Committee on Finance. - Saint Laurence O'Toole Hospital Bill, 1940—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–165 of 339. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1940 ›
In the course of the discussion either on the Second Reading or on the Committee Stage the Minister committed himself more than once to saying that he had to get this Bill through in order to enable him to acquire either compulsorily or otherwise a site. According to the Public Hospitals Act, 1933, Section 24 days down that:—
"The governing body of any hospital or nursing organisation in Saorstát Éireann or any person about to establish any such hospital or nursing organisation may at any time apply to the Minister for a grant out of the Hospitals Trust Fund...."
and so on. Section 25, sub-section (7) of the same Act says:—
"A grant made by the Minister under this section for the benefit of any existing or proposed hospital or nursing organisation may be made for all or any of the following purposes, that is to say:—
(a) the purchase of land or buildings including any superior or outstanding estate or interest in land or buildings."
According to that section the Minister is altogether wrong when he stated there was no power to acquire land. The governing body here has power to acquire land under this section. What therefore is the necessity for this Bill is not clear at all. It is quite obvious in that Section 24 and in Section 25 in the same Act that it is possible for any voluntary hospital to make applications for a grant and it is quite possible also for the Minister to make a grant. It is true that he is bound to receive a report from the Hospitals Commission on the subject. Whether it was by accident or otherwise the Minister misled the House by the statement that he had to get this Bill through in order to acquire a site. That is not necessary.
The next question is the site. It is quite clear from what the Minister has said that he is bound on going outside, away from the present site. He committed himself on more than one occasion to pointing out the unsuitability of the present site. How he stands with regard to that nobody knows—that is to say whether it is his own opinion or Departmental opinion we have not been told; whether it be the Departmental opinion itself or the opinion of the chief medical officer of his Department we are not told. But we do know, and everybody knows, that it is the desire of the patients or potential patients, that it is the desire of the staff of the hospital, both the medical and surgical staff, and that it is the wish of the persons engaged in nursing there and the staff otherwise employed to keep to the present site.
Originally it would appear as if there had been some difficulty between the governing body and another charitable organisation there, the Morning Star. There was never any such difficulty. Every accommodation has been available between those two bodies—between the governing body and the very charitable people administering the Morning Star. It is stressed through all the reports right away from 1933, from the establishment of the Hospitals Commission, that it was desirable, advisable and almost necessary to have this new or reconstructed Richmond Hospital on the same site as it is at present.
There has been introduced into this discussion by the Minister something about a town-planning body. Who is the town-planning body? Has the Dublin Corporation any interest in town planning? Is there any member of the Dublin Corporation, or any committee of the corporation, any representative body outside say an individual, or possibly two, who want to shift the site of this hospital from where it is, away to elsewhere? That hospital has been there for over two centuries and it has served the needs of thousands of people in those two centuries. Almost 100 years ago, perhaps the most celebrated medical man in this country's history went so far as to say that it would be a mischievous thing to shift this hospital from where it is. The principle in this Bill is to build a new hospital and to give it a new name. That is the principle in the Bill. The Minister altered his view. First it was to close the existing hospital and to build a new hospital. Before the Second Stage was reached he altered his view about closing this hospital. The sooner he changes his view, too, about the site of the hospital the better. He has nobody in this House in agreement with him on this matter of changing the site except Deputy McCann. Deputy McCann is so elementary in public matters as not to count in a question of this kind. The Deputy says he wants to go out where there is fresh air. Of the remarkable changes in the history of municipalities there is none more remarkable than the growth in health of the City of Dublin. The improvement in health in the City of Dublin in the last 60 or 70 years is more remarkable than in any other city in the world. Sixty or 70 years ago the mortality in Dublin was 40 per 1,000. Directly the main drainage work was undertaken the health of the city improved. The main drainage alone was responsible for a reduction of about 10 per 1,000 in the mortality in the city. This particular site is flanked with open spaces and lungs.
It is more than advisable from the point of view of the most expert and efficient medical attention that as there is in this hospital a neurological section which has gained for it a name outside of this country, it should be in close proximity to another hospital that is there. The Minister says that no decision has been taken. But there is one decision obvious from everything that the Minister has said and that is that the Minister wants to get away from the present site of this hospital. Now, in so far as Ministerial responsibility for this hospital is concerned, the Minister is considering this hospital possibly for the last seven years. A Bill is brought in here and it does not even indicate after seven years' cogitation what the site of the new hospital is to be. Surely in an Assembly like this we are entitled to know what the result of the seven years' deliberation has been. We are asked to give an absolute cheque of irresponsibility to the Minister. He can go to Raheny for this particular hospital that he wishes, or he can go to Garristown if he wishes, or he can go beyond Cabra out to Ashtown, so long as it is "in or near the City of Dublin". That is a most unhappy term "in or near". It could be on the south side so far as this section stands at present.
We are told by Deputy McCann, with his long experience of administration, that if the hospital were removed from where it is at present transport facilities could be provided. At whose expense? We are hearing day after day complaints from the Minister regarding the increasing deficits in connection with hospital administration throughout the city, and in fact throughout the country, and the solution for that is that the Minister, through his mouthpiece, Deputy McCann, says that we are to add to these deficits by incurring the expense of extra transport facilities. It was not for that purpose that these moneys were subscribed or that the Hospitals Sweepstake Act was passed. If we are really interested in the patients, who should be the prime consideration, I say that not a single argument has been advanced in favour of moving this hospital from the present site. If we are interested in the medical and surgical staff, and they ought to be considered after the long and meritorious service which they have rendered in that hospital, the present site is the place where the new hospital should be built. If we are interested in the nurses, or in the relatives who may be visiting patients in the hospital, I say that the present site is the place for it. It is foolish to say that you cannot build an hospital to accommodate 550 people on that site. Persons qualified to know can tell us whether or not that is so. It seems strange that an hospital built within the last 40 years should be scrapped and used merely as an out-patients' department for an institution which is to be built in or near the City of Dublin. Nothing that has been said justifies the removal of the hospital from the present site, and the House ought not to pass a section which gives permission to any Department of State to remove the hospital from that site against the wishes of everybody who has the interest of the hospital at heart.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary not aware that the present site of the Richmond Hospital adjoins the Grangegorman Mental Hospital and that negotiations are at present proceeding—I think a further conference will be held to-morrow—for the establishment in the Richmond Hospital of a mental out-patients' department under the direct supervision of the Resident Medical Superintendent in Grangegorman? He is also aware that a new site for the headquarters of the group of mental hospitals under the control of the Resident Medical Superintendent in Grangegorman has been sought for the last four or five years and in all probability has now been secured. The policy behind the securing of that site, which I think has largely been promoted by the Minister's Department, is that the headquarters of that group of mental hospitals should be removed outside the city. It is possible that that headquarters will be removed to Santry. The price for the Santry site has been agreed to by the Grangegorman Mental Hospital Committee, subject to the sanction of the Minister, of course. When that new mental hospital has been built, there will be a site adjoining the Richmond Hospital covering 60 acres of land. Will that not meet the whole requirements of the new hospital and enable the out-patients' department of the present Richmond Hospital to function, and also this new mental out-patients' department which is proposed to be conducted under the direct supervision of Dr. Dunne, the Resident Medical Superintendent of the Grangegorman Mental Hospital? The Parliamentary Secretary, I think, also approves fully of the new treatment for mental defectives here by the villa colony system that has been such a success in Belfast and other places.
I mention those facts to show that there is no shortage of space for the expansion of Richmond Hospital, which is on a very good site and a site which is suitable for an hospital. I am no judge of the suitability of a site for an hospital, but those who ought to be capable of judging claim that is on a good site for an hospital, being situated in the midst of a densely populated district with no other hospital close to it. One need not be an expert in medical matters to say that the hospital is conveniently situated. Then there is the other consideration mentioned by Deputy Cosgrave with regard to the medical staff. Last night in the City Hall I heard a member of the corporation say that he had succeeded in getting a bed for a patient in the Richmond Hospital after trying all the other hospitals. He said that there was no hospital more accommodating than the Richmond Hospital in taking in a patient. I have found that at on one or two occasions myself. On one occasion, when I was asked to find a bed in a hospital for a patient, I procured a bed in the Richmond Hospital, and within half an hour that patient was operated on for appendicitis. Any other hospital I am sure would have done the same thing, and perhaps that is not an argument either in support of or opposition to this Bill.
I was not present during the previous discussions on this Bill, but I have read them, and I have spoken to members of the medical staff of Richmond Hospital, some of whom have been there for 20 years. They are all against the removal of this hospital to a site outside the city. Surely there is sufficient space around the present site for the extension that is necessary. There might be some case for this if you were confined to the site of the present hospital but, as I have said, there are 60 acres available on the Grangegorman site which is at present under the control of the Grangegorman Mental Hospital Committee, which, in turn is composed of representatives of Dublin City and County, and County Wicklow, and is under the control of the Minister. When that is the case, is no use to be made of the 60 acres there except to sell them to a speculative builder? Why not speculate by extending the hospital. Whatever is required can be got there for the whole hospital. If it is removed to an outside area the out-patients' part will be lost. The air around the North Circular Road is as good as it is within 10 miles from the city. It is as good there as in the Cabra area. I can see no case for removing the hospital, and for that reason Deputy McGilligan's amendment is reasonable and should be adopted.
I am interested to know what ground the Minister has for a change, because that is what it really amounts to, taking power to move outside the city. I should like to have the Minister's views on the mental out-patients department. If any money is required for that, the Grangegorman authorities will give it freely. On the advice of the medical staff, the authorities approved of having an out-patients department. I am glad Deputy Cooney is present, because he is a member of the Grangegorman Board and was present when we got information from Dr. Dunne, the resident medical superintendent, who is very keen on this matter. My recollection of what he said was that in every country in the world they had an out-patients department where mental defectives in the first stage are treated, and that as the proximity of Richmond Hospital to Grangegorman lends itself admirably for that purpose he would take charge of it without any remuneration in order to develop the idea. If an out-patients department has been a success in other countries it should be a success here whenever the Grangegorman site passes over to the Richmond Hospital.
If you want to change the name of the hospital change it, but why change the site? After all the hospital is there for the medical treatment and accommodation of the people, and it should not be shifted to an outlying suburb. The institution should be left in the centre of the city, especially an hospital like the Richmond, which has given such useful service to the community. The reasons for changing should be very good ones. The public have got none, least of all the staff of the Richmond Hospital, which is more immediately concerned with the change than anybody else.
Comment on this
I did not intend to speak on this amendment but for a remark made by Deputy Belton. It is true to say that he and other members of the corporation, as well as myself, endeavoured to get a patient into five Dublin hospitals yesterday. I have never yet failed at the Richmond Hospital, which on more than one occasion removed patients who were nearly well into a local hotel, in order to accommodate an urgent case. I failed yesterday. The doctor who was in charge went around the wards and then regretted to have to tell members of the corporation and myself that they had no room. After considerable trouble we got the patient eventually into St. Vincent's Hospital, where a bed that was required for a surgical case was given to our medical patient. I put it to the Parliamentary Secretary that the time has come to give Dublin more beds for its patients.
Comment on this
The Deputy has wandered from the amendment. He purported to make a statement arising out of a passing remark made by Deputy Belton.
Comment on this
I obey your ruling, Sir, but I have made my point, that five hospitals in Dublin yesterday had to refuse to receive a patient.
Comment on this
Will you allow me to say that I would not say the case was too irrelevant when discussing a hospital that has the very large function of serving the poor, and that there is a kind of wangling to take that hospital outside the city? I stated on the Second Reading that the Parliamentary Secretary had established a record for this House. On a Bill that was introduced he made a case that had no reference to the Bill. Now, when we pass along in discussion we find that the Bill has no reference to what is in his mind. The Parliamentary Secretary has established a second record, he is epitomising here, in his attitude, the ineptitude and thimble-rigging proclivities to deceive which has characterised the Government.
Comment on this
The Deputy must confine himself to the amendment. General political criticism of the type indulged in is not relevant to this amendment.
Comment on this
The Chair has stated that a certain kind of discussion is not permissible on this amendment.
Comment on this
Then I leave it to the Chair to look after its duty, and I will pursue what I consider to be my duty in discussing this matter. When dealing with this amendment before, which is to secure under Section 4 that the Minister may acquire land either adjacent to the site of the new hospital or elsewhere, I asked the Minister why he was wasting Parliamentary time by asking Parliament to discuss this Bill and he said he had no power to acquire a site until he got the Bill. When asked if he had given any consideration to a site, he told Deputy Hannigan that the site could not be selected until the Minister had power. When he was asked if he looked for any site the Parliamentary Secretary said not, as the Minister had not power to acquire one.
It is proposed to replace a hospital that has a definite location, a definite function in relation to the treatment of the poor, and in relation to the teaching of medicine in the city, and the Parliamentary Secretary tells us that in proposing to replace that hospital, the authorities have not looked at a single site, that they cannot do so, and will not do so until they get this Bill. A suitable site has been suggested, but the Minister does not commit himself to that. Everything that has been said and everything that we can see shows that some kind of underhand conspiracy is on foot to transfer part of this hospital outside the city. The very fact that the Parliamentary Secretary has the neck to tell Parliament that he wants this Bill, and that the Minister cannot look at a site until he gets it, should awaken our suspicions and at any rate should be a challenge to our intelligence.
The answer to that challenge to our intelligence should be to tell the Parliamentary Secretary to take back his Bill. As Deputy Cosgrave says, this matter has been under consideration for seven years and it is still in such a position that the Parliamentary Secretary brazenly tells the House that nobody has looked at a site. We should tell him that we are not going to be treated in that way. If we want to be more reasonable, we can tell him that, if a site has not been looked at, the function of the hospital cannot have been decided. If the Parliamentary Secretary refuses to accept the proposal now submitted, that any new site acquired shall be adjacent to the present hospital, then we want to know what the function of such a hospital will be, because it will differ radically and completely from the function of the hospital which this institution is intended to supersede. It means that the function of giving convenient and immediate attention to the poor of the city is to be dropped. It means that the function of the hospital as a teaching establishment, so far as medicine is concerned, is to be dropped. It is scandalous that Parliament should be asked to deal with this measure in this way. In the light of the tone of the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and in the light of the actions of the Government in other respects, to hold up Parliament in this way and to waste its time, is going beyond the bounds of political decency. Nothing that could be said would be a sufficiently strong condemnation of the Parliamentary Secretary because of the way he is treating the House and wasting its time when, obviously, much more urgent and important things could have quiet and harmonious consideration here.
Comment on this
I have seldom listened to as much nonsense in so short a space of time as the House has been treated to by Deputy Mulcahy. I do not propose to follow him in his effort to beat the political drum this evening.
Comment on this
The Deputy may "belt" away at it. He has been "belting" it often enough without making much headway.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy was in the Department in which I am and I have not found much trace of solutions for the hospital problem, either in the City of Dublin or outside, after his stay there.
Comment on this
We cleared up part of the mess when we got you out. Deputy Cosgrave suggested—he was followed up by Deputy Mulcahy—that the House was misled inasmuch as it was told by me that new statutory powers were necessary in order to acquire a site for this hospital. Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Mulcahy may, of their own knowledge, be in a position to give an opinion on that rather involved legal question. They may come to the House furnished with the legal advice of people outside. All I can say in reply to them is that my legal advice— and I am prepared to rely on it—is that the Minister has no power to acquire a site at present for building a hospital to replace the present hospitals and that the present board of governors have no such powers. The powers of the board of governors in relation to this matter are set out in Section 5 of the Act of 1856. Their powers are confined to management. The Act of 1856, which provides for the setting up of a board of governors for Houses of Industry hospitals, does not empower that board, or does not empower the Lord Lieutenant to confer powers on the board, to acquire a site for a hospital. The position is that, until this legislation is passed, a site cannot be acquired. That may be questioned. Lawyers may argue about it. I am not concerned about that. I am concerned with the fact that that is the legal advice upon which I am going to act and upon which I must act. The lawyers can argue about it outside.
We are told by Deputies on the opposite benches that a hospital of 550 beds, with the necessary accommodation for nursing and other staffs, can be built on a seven-acre site. We are told that mysterious architects are unanimously of opinion that this architectural miracle can be accomplished. I do not believe it. I have architectural advice—expert advice— on that question, too. I believe that, if such architects exist at all, they are planning in the clouds and that they would build in the clouds if such an institution were to be provided on a seven-acre site. In the course of discussions with responsible members of the medical staff of this institution, the question of a suitable area as a site for such a hospital was raised. It was represented to this particular member of the medical staff—a very responsible member—that we thought a site of 25 acres would be necessary. He gave it as his considered opinion that 25 acres would not be a sufficient area for a hospital of the dimensions contemplated. If, in fact, a number of architects and a number of people interested in the provision of this institution have advised the members of the Opposition that the hospital can be built on the existing site and that a suitable extension of the existing site can be found adjacent, all I can say is that the members of the Opposition are more in the confidence of the board of governors, or of whomsoever is advising them, than I am or my Department is. We have recently had discussions with representatives of the board of governors and we have never been told so far—the first time I heard of it was in this House—that a group of architects were unanimously of the opinion that this institution could be built on a seven-acre site.
What is the issue before the House in this amendment? The question the House is asked to determine by the amendment is that the site will be at a particular place because the members of the Opposition say they are satisfied that it ought to be there. The Bill as it stands provides that the Minister will select a site, having duly weighed and considered all possible considerations relating to the geographical position of this important institution. But, if this amendment were to be accepted by the House, whether you could find the necessary accommodation or whether you could not, whether the site would be considered to be reasonably suitable or the most suitable or even the most unsuitable, the Minister would be bound to place the hospital there, anyhow.
The House has been asked to select the site, not on the representations of any body of experts set up to examine this question, but on the assurances of Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy McGilligan and others. I am not prepared to accept that position. Deputy Mulcahy is staggered at the thought that the hospital might, in fact, go out as far as Cabra. It might be better if the Deputy would get himself accustomed to the possibility, because if a site at Cabra is considered to be the most suitable site, having considered all the matters bearing on this question, then the hospital will be built at Cabra.
Is Cabra so terribly remote as the House is led to believe? If anybody has sufficient interest in this question as to stroll up as far as Cabra Cross, he will see a sign-post there and that sign-post indicates that it is two miles from Cabra corner to the centre of the city. That may seem a long distance, but if I were going to visit a patient in a hospital I would walk a long distance on the level rather than walk a long way in order to get to the top story of a high building. So far as distance is concerned, if one walks from the centre of the city in another direction and goes out as far as Ballsbridge, one will find a sign-post there that tells you that when you have reached Ballsbridge you are two miles from the centre of the city. Will anybody tell us to-day that Ballsbridge is too far out for the purpose of building a large general hospital? I do not think so. As a matter of fact, the authorities of St. Vincent's Hospital have acquired a site at Elm Park which is considerably further out from the centre of the city than even Ballsbridge or Cabra.
Comment on this
So far as the site is concerned, I have not heard any criticism offered either from the hospital authorities or anybody else.
Comment on this
Perhaps for different reasons. I am sure if the Minister came here and said he proposed to build a hospital at Elm Park, Deputies on the opposite benches would be outraged, and they would have an additional one-and-a-half miles from the centre of the city to back them up. But when the authorities of a voluntary hospital select a site three-and-a-half miles from the centre of the city it is all right. Anything the Minister does must be wrong. I do not think, in the light of the atmosphere introduced by Deputy Mulcahy, in the light of his contribution to the debate and his suggestions about underhand conspiracy and all that kind of nonsense, that I have any hope of persuading the Deputy that all the merits of the argument are on the side of the Government in this case. I shall ask the House to reject this amendment, which is unreasonable and which would entirely vitiate the purpose of the Bill if it were accepted.
Comment on this
Everything the Parliamentary Secretary has said emphasises the case that I make. This Bill is presented to members of the House who are not hospital experts and who are not, even if some of them do come from the city and the neighbourhood of the city, experts in the problems connected with hospitals and the services hospitals provide. We have a certain general knowledge of them, and my protest in this matter is that in the light of the things the Parliamentary Secretary can say with regard to his consultations with the hospital authorities, and in the light of other things said by other members of the House, the House is asked to discuss and pass the measure with the Parliamentary Secretary telling them that, in so far as the Department that he is connected with is concerned, not a single site has been looked at. There is a pretence made to the House that there is no purpose served by looking at a site until they get this Bill; that there is no use in looking at a site until a blank cheque with reference to powers and decisions as to where this hospital will go is put into the hands of the Minister.
We need not refer to recent history in connection with hospitals and legislation relating to hospitals in order to point out that that is a most undesirable thing. The fact that no consideration has been given to any site in the Department is, I argue, a clear implication that the functions of this new hospital have not been considered. Not only will it perform definite functions in relation to medical education and dealing with the poor but, as Deputy Belton pointed out, it is in relation to the foremost institute in the country that deals with nervous diseases and brain troubles. The development of the treatment of nervous diseases and brain troubles requires an additional amount of legislation and hospitalisation work.
Deputy Belton has indicated that certain developments are taking place in connection with the Grangegorman Hospital. He has indicated that very much more ground than has been spoken of—I am not in a position to go into seven acre and 25 acre sites—in connection with the extension of site will be available in the near future in connection with the developments in Grangegorman. Not only would an additional site be available there, but there would be a better connection between some of the work carried out in the Richmond Hospital and the type of work carried out in Grangegorman. There could be arrangements made tending towards an improvement in the manner in which nervous diseases and brain troubles would be dealt with.
Arising out of the discussions that have taken place here and elsewhere with regard to the Morning Star institution on the one side and the Grangegorman institution on the other, I know that there is no difficulty there with regard to space for a site. What does add additional grounds for suspicion as to the Parliamentary Secretary's mind is his suggestion that apparently he knows less about what the authorities of the Richmond Hospital think than members of the Opposition do. That may be, but if that is so it is entirely due to the manner in which the Parliamentary Secretary is dealing with the matter. There is nobody who should know more about the possibilities of developing the site there, there is nobody who should know more about what either the governors or the medical staff in the Richmond think of the present situation and the proposals that have been made, or what is thought about it by the Grangegorman medical authorities, than the Parliamentary Secretary or the Minister for Local Government.
If, in endeavouring to do the best for the medical services of the city, some members of the Opposition have certain opinions, and have had certain consultations: if they understand the direction and the trend of the minds of some of the most important people connected with the Richmond Hospital, and of some of the most important people in the city who are conversant with the functions and needs supplied by the hospital, I say all that is to their credit. We are being asked to discuss and speak to a Bill that has been introduced in a certain way, while at the same time the charge is made that there is something ugly and sinister in the fact that we appear to know more and appear to care more about this than the Parliamentary Secretary or his Department.
Comment on this
The Deputy can tell the Parliamentary Secretary anything, but he may not necessarily believe it.
Comment on this
I know that with regard to quite a number of things the Parliamentary Secretary is very selective in his beliefs.
Comment on this
If we are to take, as a measure of the Parliamentary Secretary's care for this subject, the fact that he has introduced a Bill that does not disclose his mind, that he makes a speech that does not deal with the Bill, and that, since he entered into exchanges of opinion on the Committee Stage of it, he has done nothing but take up the kind of attitude of a surly dog in the manger—nothing but a bark and a bite—then surely we can consider that he has very little care for this subject. Why is it possible for the Parliamentary Secretary to come into Parliament and say: "I did not look at a site because I could not look at a site until I had a Bill." In view of that, how can he persuade the House that he has considered the functions and the work of this hospital and its relation to medical education on the one hand and the poor on the other, as well as the study and the treatment of brain cases? If he comes in here and says that he wants this Bill in order that he may go and look at a site, and admits that he has not looked at a site up to the present, then the Parliamentary Secretary can have no conception of what the function of the hospital is going to be.
Comment on this
I wonder did the Parliamentary Secretary go into figures before he said that 500 beds could not be accommodated on seven acres.
Comment on this
Well, taking the figure of 550, that would give about 60 square yards per bed even with a one-storey building. That is a matter for calculation and not one to laugh at. I presume the Parliamentary Secretary knows that the site we have decided on taking for the mental hospital building would accommodate 100 beds right away. There can be that much space vacated in Grangegorman. The Parliamentary Secretary is a doctor, and I am sure is aware of the psychology of treating disease. He knows that there were hospitals around Dublin for dealing with tuberculosis, and the last stages of it. It was very hard to find patients reconciled to go to such hospitals. They felt that their doing so would be equivalent to a sentence of death. I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary, as a medical man, knows it to be true that through some little neglect in the early stages of mental weaknesses, chronic insanity sets in later on. It is the opinion of medical men now that if those cases were taken in the early stages a cure could be effected. The Parliamentary Secretary must be aware that there has been a definite increase of insanity in the country. I am not sure whether or not it is due to the worries caused by the Fianna Fáil Administration, but certainly mental tension has not been eased since Fianna Fáil came into power. I hope that, as a matter of grace, the Parliamentary Secretary will assist this experiment in the out-patient treatment of mental cases.
Comment on this
I do not know. I think the worries are nearer home, and that they are not diminishing. It will be remembered that the strongest argument put up for the site of this out-patient clinic by Dr. Dunne last Thursday was the fact that our site in Grangegorman adjoins the Richmond Hospital site, and that the actual site of the clinic will be on our grounds, and that we cut off a slice of our ground permanently from the rest of the mental hospital site so that patients attending the out-patient department of the mental hospital would not be seen by the public going in to the asylum, or mental home as it is now called. If the asylum is shifted out of there, does not that facility go with it, and if there is nothing left but the mental hospital, there can then be no camouflage about going to the mental hospital. Going into the Richmond Hospital they are able to pass into the mental wing and they get out-patient treatment, even though they do not touch the mental hospital at all nor do they feel that they are going in there. Is not that a big matter? The Parliamentary Secretary ridicules our idea of accommodating 550 beds on seven acres of land. The Minister, by his regulations, permits 98 working men's houses to be built on seven acres of land; yet he raises this point here. Does not the Department permit a density of 14 houses to the acre— that is practically 100 houses on seven acres of land? How many beds would these 100 houses have? How many people would they provide for? Yet they would be only small two-storey houses.
We all know that there is a general move out from the Grangegorman site. Is there not all that land there with new buildings on it and some of these buildings built for hospitals? I think I am right in saying that at the moment we are spending £70,000 on building. That is substantially correct. Can the ratepayers of Dublin get money so easily that we can spend £70,000 now on what may be scrapped within ten years? If the mental hospital goes out of there and this land is sold to a speculative builder, or the Dublin Corporation build houses for workingmen there, how many of these buildings will go down? It was only on last Thursday that we had tenders for furnishing those new quarters. Are all those new quarters to be scrapped? They are there for the taking over by the Richmond Hospital. It is not seven acres that the Parliamentary Secretary has to play with. He has seven acres immediately and the position is that the Richmond Hospital is standing on the seven-acre site and Grangegorman Hospital is standing on a 60-acre site. It has been definitely decided by the Local Government Department, and they are the prime movers in the matter, that the Grangegorman Mental Hospital should get a site and they have in view the ultimate fact that the Grangegorman headquarters will be on a new site. That is practically settled now at Santry. Let Deputies remember that the 60 acres are beside the seven acres.
Medical opinion in the Grangegorman Mental Hospital is that we are behind time in dealing with mental defectives. That must be camouflaged. Deadly diseases have to be camouflaged. The public want to camouflage mental diseases as much as possible. That has been done. It has gone a long way. We have given Dr. Dunne, the resident medical officer in Grangegorman, the necessary authority to put this thing over. We are meeting to-morrow. I think Deputy Cooney is on that conference that is to meet the governors of the Richmond Hospital to-morrow. I understood the Parliamentary Secretary to convey that the governors of the Richmond Hospital are most anxious to get out of North Brunswick Street. I do not think that is true. Of course it is like allocating a labourer's cottage to a tenant. If a board of health will allocate a cottage to some person that the Minister thinks should not get it, then he puts on the screw and he will give the board of health no subsidy for that cottage. Has the Minister been doing the thinking for the Board of Governors of the Richmond Hospital; has he told them what to do, or that if they do not do a certain thing they will have a very poor chance in the matter? Have they been told that they will get none of the Hospital Sweep money if they do not do what the Minister tells them?
Has the Minister considered the loss of fees to the hospital if it is moved out of the city? How many students will go out to that hospital? The Parliamentary Secretary was himself a student and I am sure he would not register in a hospital that was farthest away from the university or his medical school. Close proximity to the teaching establishment in which the student is registered popularises an hospital. The more remote the hospital is, the fewer are the students it will attract. I think it was Deputy Cosgrave who said that these doctors, physicians and surgeons who are to give their time for nothing in an hospital, perhaps hoping thereby to build up a practice, would find that a lot of their chances of succeeding will be taken from them if the hospital is moved out of its present location to the suburbs where the clientele of the out-physician department will be smaller. A surgeon in that very hospital said to me: "It means the closing down of the out-patient department if we move to Cabra." This Bill is not freedom to give freedom to the Minister to select the best site. Everybody knows that what it means in practice is that the Minister wants to shut down the Richmond Hospital where it is and to start it under another name as the St. Laurence O'Toole Hospital in Cabra —closing down the hospital in Brunswick Street and opening it in Cabra. Everybody connected with the hospital who is left freedom of choice is against the change. I suppose the present site is three-quarters of a mile from the centre of the city, the G.P.O. Is it not far enough out from the centre of the city? Is it not in a very central position if you take into account the spacing of hospitals in the city? What will accommodate the people of that locality which is densely populated if this hospital is closed down? The Minister has everything he claimed to be looking for in that site. He has seven acres to play with and 60 acres when it becomes vacant. A lot of the buildings on that site can be turned to account. They were built specially for hospitals. Why use them for other purposes, why not utilise them for hospital purposes? It may not be so easy to get money in the future, especially as a lot of the money that was left by trust funds for the maintenance of those hospitals was so badly invested that it may not yield as large a revenue now as it did in the past.
Comment on this
Deputies have complained of the unreasonableness of the Minister in coming here with this Bill to acquire certain powers without having first made up his mind fully as to the best site to be selected. It seems that the weight of expert medical opinion and of informed lay opinion is overwhelmingly on the side of the selection of the old Richmond Hospital site. The facts of the case have already been dealt with and I do not propose to reiterate them. But there is one particular point that I should like to take this opportunity of emphasising— Deputy Belton has already referred to it—and that is, that for years the question of setting up a clinic for the early treatment of mental diseases has agitated the minds of mental experts and of medical experts generally in this city. It is a long felt need and I do not think it is necessary for me to emphasise the importance of it beyond saying that it is the experience of many practitioners in Dublin that many cases of early mental trouble cannot be adequately dealt with at the moment because the machinery is not there.
The position that a practitioner finds himself in is roughly this. When he comes across a case of this kind, it is not sufficiently bad to certify for admission to a mental hospital. At the same time, it is sufficiently far from normality to indicate itself as being a potential case of admission to a mental hospital. I am informed by the doctors in Grangegorman and other mental experts that a great many of these cases would be saved the horror of having to enter a mental hospital if a clinic of the type I have indicated were set up. That project has been considered for quite a long time. The position is that if the new hospital were built on the old Richmond site the facilities would be there to put that scheme into operation forthwith, because the new hospital would not only have the necessary propinquity to the Grangegorman Hospital to facilitate the working of the scheme, but, in addition, there would be available X-ray apparatus, pathological laboratories and all the other paraphernalia necessary for its successful working.
This is not a question of Party politics. Deputy T. Kelly, by reason of his long years of service on the Dublin Corporation, must have a very profound knowledge of what is best in the line of housing and hospitalisation for the citizens of Dublin. I listened to him last week with great pleasure emphasising the desirability of the selection of the Richmond Hospital site. While the Parliamentary Secretary indicated, at any rate, last week that he still had an open mind on the matter, I think sufficient evidence has been placed before him to enable him to make up his mind definitely to select the Richmond Hospital site. I put it to him that when the matter is being gone into, if he does make up his mind in that direction, he should overhaul the lunacy laws to permit of the successful working of such a clinic, because, as he is aware, in the present state of the law a person cannot be voluntarily admitted into a public mental hospital—he must be certified. If the law were changed, mental cases could be saved the shame and ignominy of certification and, at the same time, secure the treatment necessary for their welfare.
Whatever site is selected, and I hope the Minister will do the right thing and select the site which all the indications point to as the one he should select, I hope that there will not be the usual years of delay about the selection. We have had that experience in Dublin in connection with the fever hospital, the new tuberculosis hospital, and many other hospitals. For years and years controversy has gone on with regard to the selection of a site. I hope that whatever site is selected, whether it be the old Richmond site, which appears to be the right one to select, whether it be the Cabra site, or whether it be any other site, the Minister will, with the minimum delay, acquire the necessary power and make up his mind quickly so that this project can be proceeded with. It is very important; it is more important now than in the past, because of the delay, and because of the rising costs of labour, the rising costs of materials, and all the other additional expenses which will be involved if the matter is unduly postponed.
Comment on this
I only want to intervene for a moment to comment on the extraordinary attitude of Deputy Mulcahy. If ever there was a Bill introduced into this House which one would expect would get consideration without any political partisanship being shown, this certainly is such a Bill. Yet I do not think that since 1927 I have heard a more biased political tirade, and for what reason I do not know. I can assure the Parliamentary Secretary that all the Dublin Deputies of all groups are keenly interested in this hospital being built on the site of the present Richmond Hospital.
Comment on this
I wish they would say it and explain it to the Minister and get at the Minister's mind.
Comment on this
I suggest that this amendment should be withdrawn because of the fact that this conference, which Deputy Belton referred to, is to be held and that Dr. Dunne has asked the members of the Grangegorman Committee to assist him in certain negotiations. This matter will be one of them, and I believe that we would do more good by conferring with the Department of Local Government than by abusing the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary in the House.
Comment on this
That is what we should be attending to, not making political speeches. The Parliamentary Secretary says quite rightly that, if this amendment is carried, it will vitiate the purposes of the Bill as it would compel the Minister to build on the site of the present Richmond Hospital. We all know that, in the last analysis, the responsibility rests on the experts, legal and medical, in connection with the building of this hospital. That being so, why tie the Minister's hands? He is asking for power to inspect sites and to acquire a site. I say that, in view of this conference that is pending, and in view of the fact that we can in the conference room with the Minister or his advisers put up good sound reasons why the present Richmond Hospital site should be selected, and that we will be backed up by Dr. Dunne, the R.M.S. of the Grangegorman Hospital, whose views I am sure will be given very sympathetic consideration, this amendment should not be passed. What sinister purpose can Deputy Mulcahy see behind this Bill? What sinister purpose could the Parliamentary Secretary have in rejecting this amendment or not showing reasons why he did not inspect sites? I do not see anything sinister in it. I hope that, in the interest of what practically every Deputy desires, Deputy McGilligan will withdraw this amendment.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has explained that, until this Bill is passed, giving power to acquire a site, he has not got such power, and, not having the power, he did not think it necessary to inspect sites.
Comment on this
I welcome Deputy Cooney's intervention, even though he finds fault with my attitude and approach to this matter. I am perfectly willing to start from this point in the discussion of the matter, but I suggest that if Deputy Cooney had been listening to some of the things we have been trying to get the Minister to understand, and to get a different approach to their examination, he would understand some of us talking so strangely. Deputy Cooney asked that the amendment should be withdrawn because of certain negotiations that are going on. The whole gravamen of my complaint is that this Bill is brought in, and Deputies from Cork to Donegal and from Kerry to Monaghan are asked to take part in a discussion giving the Minister certain powers, when discussions that would make way for the passage of the Bill, and that should have taken place before the Bill was presented to the House, have not taken place. Now, if under the stress of the introduction of the measure, and of the suspicions occasioned by details of it, and things said about it, discussions are now taking place that ought to have taken place before, my point is that the progress of this Bill should be arrested until these discussions have taken place, and that we could be left with this assurance, that the future of this hospital was being discussed thoroughly by those who are experts, and by people interested in municipal control in the City of Dublin, by people responsible for medical education, by responsible authorities of the hospitals and from Grangegorman, all in their proper place, and when these had taken place, and the House was assured that the question had been discussed by experts, some sort of definite conclusion could be arrived at, and the necessary power given the Minister, without wasting more time, and as Deputy Cooney suggested, without the introduction of party politics.
The gravamen of all my complaint is that from what we understand from the Parliamentary Secretary a wrong thing is intended. Our suspicions are greatly increased when we realise that necessary discussions that we thought ought to have taken place before the Bill was presented to Parliament have not taken place. In my opinion, it is because these discussions have not taken place, and because we have not been assured that the functions of the new hospital are definitely appreciated and have been approved that our tempers and our dispositions are being frayed a little by the discussion and waste of so much time. Goodness knows there are any amount of reasons why we should not waste Parliamentary time at present, why we should not allow suspicions to fray our dispositions, after the Minister for Industry and Commerce has told us how difficult it would be to keep 19 out of 20 people working after we had the Information Bureau advising the people generally, without any more information, that reserves which were demobilised a few months ago were now called up, we do not know for what or why; and after we had the Minister for Agriculture wringing his hands and saying that he was hopeless and helpless as he feared that nothing could be done to improve our relations about prices with Great Britain, upon which, according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, so much of our prosperity depends.
All these things, not to mention greater dangers, might have implications on the economic life of the country. These are all matters which might engage our attention, but because of lack of preparation we have frayed discussions, and we are driven, based on a foundation formed entirely from his own representations and attitude to the House, to form suspicions. We cannot afford to allow suspicions to be unexpressed in relation to the treatment of an institution like the Richmond Hospital, which means so much to the City of Dublin. I welcome Deputy Cooney's intervention and I would like to have some kind of understanding by which it would be possible to stop the further progress of this measure until the discussions that Deputies referred to are brought to a conclusion. Then, with some kind of knowledge arising out of the discussions that the Parliamentary Secretary or the Minister could put before us, we could attend to them in peace.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary be prepared to postpone a decision until this conference has finished its work?
Comment on this
I speak without authority, but I am sure the amendment would not be pressed now if the Minister showed a disposition to give this conference a full chance to explore every avenue, and to do what is best in the interests of both hospitals. It is a test for the Parliamentary Secretary. I am sure he wants to do the right thing and this is the opportunity. Will he take it? If necessary I am willing that the House should meet to-morrow. Will the Parliamentary Secretary agree to postpone this now or, alternatively, will he agree to the amendment coming on at a later stage?
Comment on this
I should like to hear Deputies from Cork, Donegal or Limerick telling us what they think of this business.
Comment on this
As the representative of a Dublin constituency I would like to express what is in the mind of some people regarding the background of the debate on this Bill. The Minister for Finance when closing a debate on the Financial Resolutions recently, complained of the unreality of the situation of people here discussing a Budget as if it were a normal time. If it was unreal to discuss finance then, what could be more unreal than to discuss whether the Richmond Hospital is to remain where it is or be built at Cabra. Really, the Dáil is rendering itself utterly futile and ridiculous in the eyes of the people when hours are spent discussing these proposals. Personally I do not know where the funds are to build the hospital. I have not been able to find out if they are still there and what amount. I have considerable doubt whether they will be spent on any hospital, and if they are to be spent, there is great difficulty about who is to decide. We are emulating what happened in the time of Nero in discussing this mythical hospital, and whether the Richmond Hospital is to be at Cabra or not. The proposal is that we should mark progress, wait for a calmer atmosphere and until we find out where the hospital will be built, and until the Minister will have some idea where he wants to build it. Except from Deputy McCann I have not heard any plea from any of the Dublin Deputies for the removal of the hospital to Cabra. Deputy Kelly hoped that the Minister would review the situation. Deputy Cooney asked us to postpone the amendment because there is going to be a conference to-morrow and the Minister cannot make up his mind until he hears the views at that conference.
Comment on this
The Deputy did not put it in that way because that would be insulting to the Minister but that is what the case he made comes to.
Comment on this
Deputy Cooney asked that the amendment be not pressed because it is to be considered by the Minister at a conference. Everybody here, he says, is in favour of the Richmond site; let the Minister be free to put the hospital where he pleases but we will convince him at the conference to-morrow. That is Deputy Cooney's attitude.
Comment on this
No. It is on us. We are the Parliamentary institution. We are not handing over our viewpoint to the Minister.
Comment on this
I am coming to that. I asked the Deputy what he meant by "legal experts" and the view I got was that the Minister—the Parliamentary Secretary himself put up this plea—could not look at a site and could not consider the whole thing hypothetically until he got power to acquire some place. That that should be put forward as an argument is ludicrous. That it should have bemused Deputy Cooney is surprising. Why could he not look at sites? Cannot the question of the population to be served and the whole situation with regard to internal staffs, the students who are going to attend, medical staff and so forth be considered in relation to various sites without the Minister having power to acquire a yard anywhere? Deputy Cooney is fussed up about what he is told the legal experts think must happen before a site can be considered. That is all nonsense and Deputy Cooney knows it.
What is the expert view on this question? If I have to enter into discussion of this unreal subject I hope I shall not get too far into the area of unreality. What expert said that a 550-bed hospital could not be built on this site? I have not been referred to a single expert who has said that. I know that the Hospitals Commission recommended building on the present site. They are supposed to be expert. The Parliamentary Secretary would stand over them as experts in some respects. They asked for an extension of the hospital on the present site. Under pressure, they put up a second proposal, but only under pressure. No architect has yet put his name to the statement that it is not possible to build a 550-bed hospital on the present site. That is the main contention, secondarily made. The first contention was that the population in a certain slum area are removing out to Cabra and that it would be better to get there first with the hospital. No argument as to fresh air was put up until Deputy McCann put it up. The Parliamentary Secretary knows, what Deputy McCann may not know, that the average stay of a patient in these hospitals is three weeks. You have to balance the consideration of fresh air and whether you are going to get better air at Cabra than at the Richmond with the solace which patients receive from being visited by relatives and whether you are going to get them better attended to at Cabra than on the present site.
The present site serves one-sixth of Dublin's population. Deputy Kelly tells us that the area is to be cleared. The hospital stands on a good, healthy site. It provides ample room for extension and various architects have already advised that a 550-bed hospital —which is the hospital aimed at—can be built on that site. There are certain "lungs" of Dublin in the neighbourhood, giving fresh air in abundance. Building on the present site offers a possible conjunction with Grangegorman. A suggestion to that effect has been encouraged by the medical officers both of Grangegorman and the Richmond.
You get a conjunction of these two viewpoints—no expert has yet declared that the hospital cannot be erected on the present site and the Hospitals Commission reported in favour of that site. When turned down on that, they as a secondary consideration, proposed something else and that was not Cabra. The proposal is to remove the hospital from a densely populated area, where it supplies one-sixth of the population of the city and where it is conveniently situate, on a healthy site, to the outskirts of the city. That is what we are discussing.
This removal will have certain repercussions. The nursing and other staffs will not be so conveniently circumstanced. In addition, you have the outstanding matter of the provision for teaching. If the hospital is moved out to Cabra, it will inevitably, I am told by experts in this matter, mean that as a teaching hospital which students will visit it will be no more. If that be the situation, you will, undoubtedly, get a deterioration of the medical staff attending there because the way in which the profession is built up means that those who do charitable or honorary work at these institutions depend on the students who serve under them to send them patients later because they are attracted by the work done in this honorary way. That is a thing of the past if the Cabra proposal is adopted. Cabra may make some provision in the way of advanced appliances, but they will not get a steady attendance of students there.
I am told that it is possible to provide transport. I look forward to the day when the medical students' bus will go out to Cabra, calling around to the various places where students are accommodated and trying to collect all these gentlemen at an early hour to transport them to Cabra. Then, the bus will have to bring them back and disembark them at the various places in the city to which they want to get. Such a suggestion could not be made by anybody who has a clear recollection of how "medicals" are scattered throughout the city. We are discussing a very vital matter. At first, on Second Reading, the Parliamentary Secretary gave people the impression that Cabra had never been mentioned or seriously considered. In that way a certain antagonism to this proposal was avoided. The Parliamentary Secretary came back to this question, and I want Deputy Cooney to turn to page 280 of volume 88 of the Parliamentary Debates, where he will find that the only argument made by the Parliamentary Secretary was in favour of Cabra. There is nothing in his viewpoint other than Cabra. He started off with the statement: "If I conveyed the impression"—that was on Second Reading—"that Cabra was outside consideration as a possible site, I would like to disabuse the minds of Deputies who may have come to that conclusion as a result of the discussion on Second Reading."
After that, there is half a column of argument entirely based on the removal of part of the population in a north-westerly direction. They have swarmed out to Cabra, and the argument is that it is better to get the hospital out there. The tendency was to show that, if his mind was not entirely set on Cabra, it was moving in that direction. Deputy Cooney says that it would be better to withdraw the amendment and that, when they meet the Parliamentary Secretary, they will disabuse his mind of the idea regarding Cabra. It is here he should disabuse him of that idea. It is here we should get arguments for and against Cabra. I suggest that we have had no argument from Deputies in favour of Cabra. The argument was entirely in favour of reconditioning the existing hospital and extending it on the present site. Deputy Hannigan has a view of his own regarding a municipal hospital, but his argument on the question of site is in accord with the arguments addressed to the Parliamentary Secretary by all the Deputies from Dublin with the exception of Deputy McCann, and he founds his argument on a contention which the Minister disregards.
Comment on this
I want to subscribe to the opening words employed by Deputy McGilligan. I regard it as an outrage on this country that the Oireachtas should be engaged in its Lower House discussing a Bill for the establishment of a hospital that may well never be built and discussing sites for the Richmond Hospital, while in the Upper House we are discussing the correct spelling of Irish words and whether advanced Celtic studies are desirable at this stage or not. And all this while the bottom is falling out of the world, while the country is surrounded with grave and imminent dangers, and while the people of the country look to us, their legislators, to be in common council for the defence of the essential interests of our people and of our country.
I think it is right that this House and the country should know that we asked the Government to postpone consideration of this Bill yesterday on the ground that it was no fit subject for discussion or investigation at the present time, and that the emergency was so great and the dangers so menacing that the minds of Deputies should not be distracted by discussions such as we have been listening to in this House for the last three hours. Our suggestion was categorically turned down. We were informed that it was the Government's settled decision that this Bill must be proceeded with to-day. In my opinion, when the people read to-morrow that the time of Ministers and Deputies was taken up for hours arguing over the comparatively trivial matters here raised, they will turn with disgust from our Parliamentary institutions, and they will say that public men who could display the irresponsibility of arguing whether the Richmond Hospital is to be built in North Brunswick Street or Cabra, while the whole of civilisation is in peril, and while the very territory and survival of this State is in danger, are quite unfitted for the positions they hold.
It is right that they should know that the responsibility for this grotesque proceeding is not on our shoulders, but on the shoulders of a Government who insist on proceeding with this ridiculously irrelevant business to-day. It is a shame and a disgrace to Parliament and it ought to be stopped now. If anybody but the Parliamentary Secretary was sitting where he is now, this Bill would be withdrawn and left by for further consideration, when proper attention could be given to it in the light of the situation that may exist when further proceeding with the proposal for this hospital may be possible. To continue this discussion now is ludicrous and irrelevant. No responsible Deputy can give it the calm and detached consideration that a detailed matter of this kind should have.
We are disgracing the Parliament to which we belong; we are justifying every critic of democratic institutions who described them as futile talking-shops by our conduct here to-day; we are vindicating every tyrant who seeks to overthrow such institutions and who says that you can always trust democracy to choke itself with words. This is all irrelevant and, instead of proceeding with such measures as this, Deputies should be banding themselves together to face the threats that confront us. I appeal to Deputies to have some sense of proportion of the times in which we live and put an end to this ludicrous discussion.
Comment on this
I want to know why we should be obliged to sit here to listen to a lecture on procedure and manners.
Comment on this
On the point of order, I make the submission that my remarks are addressed to the point of a proper discussion of the amendment on the paper. I suggest it is impossible in the circumstances in which we are meeting.
Comment on this
Deputy Cooney gave us certain reasons why this amendment should be withdrawn. Deputy Dillon is approaching the matter from a different standpoint.
Comment on this
The Chair suggests that the business of the House be proceeded with. The House has arranged to do certain business in a certain order and that order must be followed.
Comment on this
I have little to add. I merely think that this procedure here is irrelevant and shocking. I believe the people will be appalled when they realise what we are doing. I urge the House to chuck it.
Comment on this
The Deputy has described the procedure of this House as irrelevant and shocking. Is that in order?
Comment on this
If I am out of order, I look with confidence to the Chair to rule me out. But Deputy Allen is not in the Chair. I do not want to quarrel with Deputy Allen. Every Deputy is entitled to his views. I respectfully submit that this business should be postponed to a time when we can consider it in a different atmosphere from that in which we are obliged to meet to-day. If Deputy Allen takes the view that the proper matter to be engaging the minds of the Legislature at this time is whether a hypothetical hospital is to be put up in Cabra or in North Brunswick Street, when the very existence of this State is in peril, according to the Taoiseach himself, and when the best counsels of everybody should be gladly brought together for our common defence and protection, then I disagree with Deputy Allen and I am glad to let that matter be judged by the people. If the people take Deputy Allen's view, I do not want to represent them. I do not believe they do.
Comment on this
I do not think this is in order. At the moment we are dealing with amendment No. 3 and the Deputy should address himself to that.
Comment on this
It is virtually impossible, I suggest, to give this amendment the calm and detached consideration it ought to get in the present atmosphere, and I urge the Parliamentary Secretary to indicate to the House that he is prepared to consent, by the leave of the House, to the postponement of this business to another day when, the more urgent matter having been disposed of, it can be approached with calm and deliberation. There is no urgency about this Bill. It is unthinkable that the hospital will be built the day after to-morrow or when this Bill passes the Houses of the Oireachtas. I believe that to postpone the Bill now would create in the public mind the impression that we, whom they look upon as their trustees, have some sense of responsibility; I think a continuation of the present discussion will create the idea that we are a lot of irresponsible people who have no appreciation of the dangers that confront our country.
Comment on this
We have listened to all the dreadful things that Deputy Dillon thinks will happen. The point is that we here have every confidence in our Government.
Comment on this
It has not confidence in itself. The Taoiseach addressed the people the other night on the wireless on this very situation.
Comment on this
We are impeached by Deputy Dillon while we are sitting here calmly considering a very mundane measure. We have every confidence in our Government and in their ability to meet any dangers that may arise.
Comment on this
I think some Fianna Fáil Deputies had better read the statement broadcast by the Taoiseach. Apparently they do not know the situation.
Comment on this
There was a suggestion made to the House, if not by the mover of the amendment, at least by some others, that the amendment should be withdrawn if the Parliamentary Secretary would agree to defer further consideration until such time as the conference, which is to sit to-morrow, will come to a decision. I advocate that course to the Parliamentary Secretary not only for the reasons put forward by Deputy Dillon, but for other reasons. Deputy Cooney accused Deputy Mulcahy of making this particular Bill a Party matter, making Party capital out of the debate. Who is making Party capital out of it? The Parliamentary Secretary himself. He is trying to force it down the throats of Deputies. There are many Deputies here who are very little concerned with this measure. So far as I know, the Dublin Deputies are practically agreed on one point and the Parliamentary Secretary apparently does not agree with them, but other Deputies have no particular concern in the matter. Why should Deputies from the rural constituencies be drawn into this acrimonious dispute? In my opinion it could be settled, and probably will be settled, by a conference. Why should the Parliamentary Secretary use his majority in favour of this site for a particular hospital in Dublin, and force this section through the House. Deputy Cooney accuses us of making Party capital out of this. My suggestion is that the decision on this site should be left to the Deputies representing Dublin, and that the Parliamentary Secretary should not ask the members of his Party in Donegal or other counties, to vote on it. Apparently the Parliamentary Secretary does not want to take a fair course on this. He wants to get his Bill passed. I venture to say that members of his Party, representing country constituencies, have not read the Bill, as I have not. It is stretching the credulity of most Deputies to ask them to give a decision on this. I think the Parliamentary Secretary should agree to the course that has been suggested, namely, to postpone the Bill until such time as he will have an opportunity of making up his mind on it, having read the discussions that have already taken place. If Deputies in all parts of the House agree, I think that we, from the country, should leave the decision on this to the Dublin Deputies. They understand it. We do not. If, however, the Parliamentary Secretary insists on using the Parliamentary majority he has at his back in order to get the section through, then I will be obliged to vote on the other side.
Comment on this
I am sure that many Deputies representing rural constituencies must wonder what all this row is about. We had an extraordinary spectacle a few moments ago when Deputy Dillon wanted the proceedings of the House suspended. Three hours ago the House ordered that certain business should be taken to-day. If Deputy Dillon had any objection to make to the procedure then outlined, that was the time for him to make his objection, and not in the middle of a discussion on a simple amendment to a simple section. The Deputy wants the proceedings of the House suspended in view of things that are happening in some other parts of the world.
Comment on this
Not long ago Deputy Dillon wanted something done to stem all the armies of Europe from invading this country. There is nothing wrong in the section that the House is discussing. Deputy McGilligan, in his amendment, wants to compel the Parliamentary Secretary to remain on the present site. I do not think that either the Government or the Parliamentary Secretary can give way on this. They will have to take full responsibility for their decision. I am quite sure that, if Deputy Cosgrave was the head of a government, he would not accept an amendment of this kind. What would be said if some Deputy brought in an amendment to some Bill compelling the local authority in North Cork to build in a particular field and in a particular townland in the town of Macroom. I am sure the Cork Deputies would kick up a big row. I do not know where this hospital is going to be built in Dublin.
Comment on this
I think it is the Parliamentary Secretary who should have the ultimate responsibility for deciding whether the hospital should be built on the present site, or adjacent to it, or in Cabra or between the present site and Cabra. If he does anything wrong he will have to answer for it to the country and to the House. We all know that a very large sum of money will be required to build this hospital, wherever the site may be. Therefore, it is natural to conclude that full consideration will be given to the question of the site. I know there is a difference of opinion about the site, even amongst the present medical staff of the existing hospital. They are not in agreement as to whether the present site is the most desirable one or not, and Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Mulcahy need not try to put it across the House that they are in agreement. Deputy McGilligan mentioned that the report of the Hospitals Commission favoured the present site. What, I think, they stated in their report was that the modern tendency was to take large hospitals to the outskirts of cities.
Comment on this
I know quite well what they said about the Richmond. Anything they said about it was not objected to—to get more hospital accommodation within the shortest possible space of time. They also referred to the efforts of St. Vincent's Hospital to go outside the city, and approved of that. The Deputy, I am sure, will admit that. The proposed site for the new St. Vincent's Hospital is about three-and-a-half miles from the city, and I am sure the medical students will be able to find their way out there.
Comment on this
I know that at the present time medical students are going out to a hospital that is a greater distance from the city than either Cabra or Elm Park. Deputy McGilligan is aware of it, too.
Comment on this
Where is the hospital that the Deputy refers to situated, and is it a teaching hospital?
Comment on this
It is in the County Dublin, and is used to a certain extent as a teaching hospital. It is an orthopædic hospital. It is not a medical hospital.
Comment on this
At any rate, the students are going out there, and apparently find no difficulty in doing so. I am sure Deputies from the country must wonder what all this row is about— whether the Parliamentary Secretary should have power to decide on the site where the hospital is to be built, whether it be the present site or any other site adjacent to the city. That is what the Deputies opposite are trying to prevent by this amendment.
Comment on this
Not at all. The hospital was maintained out of State funds up to the advent of the sweepstakes.
Comment on this
It was managed very largely by a subscription of £5,000 a year, which was paid to the hospital every year except in the last year for which I was responsible for the administration of the Government of this country.
Comment on this
Approximately £5,000 was paid, and as a matter of fact, it had been maintained by the British Government ever since 1856. But after the war it was found that the management could not balance their accounts on that sum; a new board was set up, and they took in patients and balanced their accounts on that. We have not had any reason why the Minister, above all other persons in this country, should suddenly get this authority to select a site for this hospital. We have been given no reason whatever for that. The Minister is a solicitor by profession. What special dispensation of Providence is there to confer on him any special light as to where the site of the new hospital is to be fixed? If we take the Parliamentary Secretary, his practice is in another direction. He was not attached to an hospital, so far as I know. I am not making any case against him, but even if he were attached to an hospital I would prefer to have the governing body or the medical staff of the hospital select a site. Even as a medical expert, why should the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary get this power? What reason is there for it? Not one sixpenny of Government money is going into this hospital.
Comment on this
It does not. The Bill says that there will not be one penny of Government money going into it; not one penny raised by the Government of this country since they took office has gone into it. Why then should they come along and take this power now? It is a new power they are seeking. The Minister wants us to give him power to select a site. We want to know what reason is there for giving him that power? What special default has there been in the governing body that the power should not rest with them? We are told by the junior member of the House that there are two hospitals in England on the outskirts of cities. What are the facts about them? One of these hospitals was set up at a great cost, and it has not one acute case at the present moment. It is an absolute failure as an hospital.
Comment on this
Competent medical opinion does not controvert fact. What I am speaking of is fact, not argument. Perhaps the Deputy can understand it; he may learn. Unfortunately this country has had to learn much from incompetent decisions and incompetent Ministers within the last eight years. The Deputy ought to learn that now.
Comment on this
I have not learned much from those benches since I came here.
Comment on this
Oh, no. We have here a body of which Deputy Allen was a paid member in 1933 and 1934. The first general report of that body, the Hospitals Commission, says:—
"The Mater and the Richmond Hospitals, Dublin, the development of which is contemplated on their existing sites, are examples of hospitals where sectional development could be allowed to proceed without putting too great a strain on the Hospitals Trust Fund."
There is a little bit of genius behind that. I suppose they did not go any further possibly because they had only one or, perhaps, two medical men on the Commission, and they had no special dispensation from Providence to fit them for the selection of sites.
What does the Parliamentary Secretary say against that? He says as reported in column 1663 of Volume 79, No. 6:—
"The site of the existing hospitals is rather restricted, and for a large modern hospital it would be well to have considerably more space. Proposals of the Dublin town planning authorities for the replanning of the neighbourhood would have the effect of cutting off portions of the lands. This would further restrict the site and leave it inadequate for a large hospital. It would, therefore, be necessary to seek a new site."
That is pretty plain language for Deputy Cooney. The Parliamentary Secretary then goes to say:—
"At present neither the hospital authority nor the Minister has power to acquire land for the purposes of these hospitals, and it is now proposed to make the necessary legal provision."
This is a new power for the Minister, responsible to nobody, or, if you like, responsible to Parliament. But that is not much good to the patients, to the medical staff, or to the students who are going to go there if in years to come they find that the Minister has made a mistake. It is little good to tell them that he is responsible to Parliament. All they can do in Parliament is to turn him out of office, but the people may send him back again. That thing of being responsible to Parliament is of very little use to those who are injured if a wrong step is taken in the selection of a site. What does the Parliamentary Secretary say further? "The Minister is empowered by the Bill to dispose of the lands on which the existing hospitals are situated or any portion of them." What does that mean? It certainly does not mean that the Minister intends to retain the present site. When some Deputies in their innocence tell us that this matter is still the subject of consideration, we wonder whether it is a subject of consideration, or whether the decision has already been made or given. Then the Parliamentary Secretary goes on to say in the Second Reading speech: "The net proceeds of any such proposal are to be paid by the Minister into the Hospitals Trust Fund." Is that put in for sport or amusement or merely to fill up any gaps there would be in the draftsman's work? Surely that must reveal an intention to dispose of the present site. Surely whatever site the Minister has in mind is not the present site. Then he goes on to say: "It will be necessary on the Committee Stage to submit some amendments in relation to the provision regarding the closing of the existing hospitals.... I propose to submit amendments providing for the closing in whole or in part of the existing hospitals in such manner as the circumstances may require." I think it is fairly clear that whatever the Minister had in mind, he had certainly made up his mind that it was not the present site on which the hospital was to be built. He says in column 1666 that "it is not considered possible to build a new hospital on the present site, for the reason, with the information before me, that it appears there is not sufficient room available on the site. If property adjacent to the present site can be procured, it does not follow that the present site will not be used in conjunction with whatever additional property may be secured but the position appears to be, as far as I could examine it, that the existing site as it stands does not provide adequate accommodation for the proposed new hospital". If anybody can tell me that that matter is still under consideration if words mean anything, I make him a present of his judgment and of his wisdom. What is the reason for the non-success of the hospital that was referred to by Deputy McCann as having been built outside a city?
Comment on this
Yes; the Deputy knows nothing about it, except that he was told by somebody of this hospital having been built outside the city. That is the most unfortunate thing about it. Not only was the hospital in Birmingham connected with the medical school, but that school was moved with the hospital to the outskirts of the city. The result gives a very grave warning. No acute cases are being treated there, and its wards are occupied by incurable cases.
The main concern we should have in this matter is the suitability of the site for patients and its proximity to the homes of those who will require attention. The second is, and it is almost as important as the first, to maintain this hospital as a teaching hospital. That has not happened in the other case. Notwithstanding the fact that they brought out the other institution along with it, it has not been a success. Is it considered advisable to maintain this hospital as a teaching hospital? If this is a means of directing public attention to the importance of having it still maintained as a teaching hospital, we must give consideration to the question of its proximity to the teaching establishments in the city. A student attends the hospital at 9 o'clock in the morning, and he can get away to a lecture at 10.40 at present. What time will he get away from the other place? He has three possible schools to attend. This hospital differs somewhat from the case of St. Vincent's Hospital, which is to be removed to Merrion. This hospital attracts students from the three colleges; it is not bound to any one of them. I know of a doctor who is putting his son to medicine, and who had intended that he should go to the Richmond Hospital. But when he saw this Bill he said he would not send him until he saw where the hospital was to be built. There was a good reason why he should send his son to the Richmond Hospital, because he had been there himself.
We have, in the first instance, the report of the Hospitals Commission with regard to this site. We have the reasons for it, and there are more reasons even than the financial one. We have the fact of its proximity to the other institution which is there. We have its long association of over two centuries with the present site. This House is asked to give to one individual the selection of the site. The consequences will have to be borne by other people. The loss that will ensue will be the loss of the unfortunate patients, the students, the medical and surgical staff, and all those employed in the hospital. If the matter were likely to be the subject of further investigation, I would have no hesitation in recommending the withdrawal of this amendment. But, on the facts as they stand, with the Minister practically committed to a site which is not the present site, we feel bound to press the amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen and Deputy Cooney expressed astonishment at the attitude taken up by those who are supporting this amendment. I suggest to Deputy Allen that the opinion of the Dublin representatives in the Dáil, most of whom have experience of municipal and social welfare matters, is worth considering. I wonder what Deputy Allen would think if we went down to the County Wexford and expressed an opinion as to a site for an hospital there. With one exception, the Dublin Deputies of all Parties are united in suggesting to the Minister that the new hospital should be built on the present site as being the most desirable from many points of view. I do not want to repeat what has already been said in favour of the present site; but I do say that there is a decided public opinion in favour of it. My experience on public boards for many years has shown me that there is a decided objection to the building of hospitals outside towns or cities. That is one reason why I take the view that the present site should be selected for the new hospital. There is plenty of space there for expansion of the hospital in order to provide additional accommodation. I think that the Minister ought to change his mind and not insist on changing the site of this hospital. As I said, public opinion is in favour of the hospital remaining where it is.
Comment on this
I seem to have been singled out because I gave my opinion on this amendment, and because I consider that a site on the outskirts of any city is the best place for the erection of a modern hospital. I gave as my reasons that sunlight, fresh air and quietness were important factors in the cure of disease. I cited the case of Birmingham and of the new Local County Council Hospital at Tooting. Nobody informed me of these things. I can read the British Medical Journal as well as Deputy Cosgrave. I gave my opinion because I believe that that is the best place for an hospital. The argument has been advanced here that if the Richmond Hospital was transferred to Cabra or some such site it would lose a certain number of students. I think that is all nonsense. Deputy Cosgrave knows as well as I do how long it would take to get from the site of the present hospital to Cabra. It is a matter of not more than four or five minutes in a 'bus. I have no axe to grind in this matter, but I think that there are axes being ground in connection with it. I want to give my view that, so far as the voluntary system is concerned, it is long since dead and buried. I want to give my further view that the sooner the State takes control of hospitalisation in Dublin and in the country generally the better for the poor people.
Comment on this
With reference to Deputy McCann's remarks about people having axes to grind, might I point out to him that Deputy T. Kelly and Deputy Cooney, who sit on the benches with him, are with us in this matter? He ought to question them as to whether they have an axe to grind. They are guided by public opinion.
Comment on this
On this amendment, Deputy McCann, like every other Deputy, is entitled to his point of view, and his point of view ought to be weighed by the arguments on which he bases it. He talked about two hospitals being removed out of cities. The answer has been given with regard to one of these that it has been proved not to have been a success. It has been definitely stated and cannot be contradicted that that particular hospital is more or less derelict, so far as acute cases are concerned, and that it has only chronic cases in its wards. This matter was considered by the Hospitals Commission and I have here excerpts from three reports of that commission. In the first report they say very openly and without the slightest question of obscurity: "In the North City, the enlargement of the Richmond and Mater Hospitals on their existing sites is recommended."
They were considering having two large hospitals. In the second general report they say:—
"If the hospital is to be rebuilt and extended as recommended by the commission, the utilisation of the site to the fullest advantage necessitates that the roadway from North Brunswick Street to the Legion of Mary premises should be closed and an alternative approach provided to the latter."
They are still recommending in the third report in 1937. We are told that there was a difficulty as to accommodation. That difficulty no longer exists. In the third report they say:—
"The Hospitals Commission has considered the new proposals submitted by the Board of Governors of the Richmond, Whitworth and Hardwicke Hospital in connection with the future development of this hospital, which accompanied your letter of the 3rd ultimo, and has directed me to send you herewith its observations on these proposals."
That was addressed to the Minister. It concerned proposals put up by the boards of the hospital after they discovered that the Department was rather against the idea of building on the present site. They continue:—
"The new proposals envisage the provision of two hospitals, one in the city and one in the country. It is stated that the idea has proved satisfactory in London, but the commission is of opinion that the great disparity in size between London and Dublin detracts very much from consideration of the former city as a satisfactory guide to hospital development in Dublin. Furthermore, in most instances in London the development of hospitals in the country in association with city hospitals is most evident in those city hospitals which are so large as to be unwieldy if further extended on existing sites. The value of property adjacent to the principal existing London hospitals is out of all proportion to that in Dublin, and so much beyond the financial capabilities of those hospitals that some alternative has had to be found to enable extension to be undertaken."
They go into details about the disparity in costs, and counter-calculations are made. They went on:—
"The commission is, therefore, of opinion that the new proposals of the Richmond, Whitworth and Hardwicke Hospital ought not to be entertained."
Three times in three yearly reports the commission put up their viewpoint without any obscurity, one about building where they were; secondly, maintaining that point of view; and thirdly, having considered a contrary proposal and turned it down, bring in the question of London. London was brought up by Deputy McCann. The other case was that of Birmingham, with which we have dealt. We are up against this matter finally, because there has been no argument put forward to sway the mind of any rational person in favour of going away from the present site. The only plea was to leave it where it is. I propose to proceed with the amendment unless I get an undertaking from the Government that the matter will be left open for discussion again.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 4:—
In sub-section (2), page 4, line 4, after the word "hospital" to add the words "and may so acquire land either adjacent to the site of the new hospital or elsewhere for the purpose of providing substitute lands for a local authority or for any person from whom lands have been acquired under the immediately preceding sub-section of this section".
It is proposed to add certain words to sub-section (2). As the sub-section stands, it enables the Minister to acquire lands either by agreement or compulsorily where the land is adjacent to the hospital, but for a stipulated purpose—that is "for the purpose of facilitating the extension or enlargement of the new hospital." I had thought that the phrase, "for the purpose of facilitating the extension or enlargement," would have been sufficiently wide to cover the acquisition of land for the purpose of exchange with, say, a charity in the neighbourhood, or any other person or corporation upon whose property the hospital would encroach. I gathered from the statements made on Second Reading that the phrase is not interpreted in that liberal way. Therefore, I put down the amendment to enable what I have in mind to be effected. I want the Minister to have power to take lands either by agreement or compulsorily where the purposes are to provide substitute lands for a local authority, or any person from whom lands have been taken under the previous sub-section. In short, it is for the purpose of facilitating exchange.
Comment on this
It is not usual when acquiring land for the purpose of this kind to acquire additional land for the persons from whom the first land is acquired. When land is acquired for the purpose of a hospital site, or for extending a hospital, compensation is paid for the land so acquired. The persons to whom compensation is paid are free to acquire compensatory land if they require additional land at all. A local authority has already power compulsorily to acquire land for its own purposes. If the Minister compulsorily acquires land from a local authority for the purpose of extending the site, that local authority can, in turn, acquire land compulsorily.
I do not think that the amendment is necessary. If land were to be acquired for the purpose of exchange, considerably further consequential amendment of the Bill would be necessary. The law relating to compensation for land compulsorily acquired deals with compensation in the form of money. If compensation in the form of land is to be substituted for money, far-reaching further amendment would be necessary. I do not think that it is necessary to do that. I am advised that the position is fully covered by the proposal in the Bill and the existing law in relation to the compulsory acquisition of land.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary's advice runs along the lines indicated to the House, it cannot be regarded as very sound. He says that if land is taken from a local authority, that local authority will have power to acquire other land compulsorily in lieu of the land taken from it. Where do they get that power? A local authority is strictly limited in the purposes for which it may acquire land compulsorily. It may be that, having lost certain lands, they set about acquiring others, and they may not be able to make a case for that acquisition which would bring them within the terms of their ordinary powers.
In any event, the local authority is not the sole object of this amendment. This refers to the local authority or any other person. The particular people I have in mind are people connected with a charity that is in the neighbourhood. This was one of the objections indicated by the Minister for Local Government when he put forward a proposal to the Richmond Hospital. He said that they could not find alternative accommodation for the charities operated by the Legion of Mary. If the Legion of Mary are ousted from their present position, having no power which enables them compulsorily to acquire other land, what is their position? The Parliamentary Secretary's answer is that they will be paid. So they will, but I know the way in which these payments go. Nobody who has had any experience of these inquiries that are held by the inspectors for the Department of Local Government, in order to associate a price with land compulsorily acquired, has any confidence that the person ousted would get such money as would enable that person to get, on a free arrangement, adequate accommodation in the neighbourhood. The price would go up immediately.
It could be said definitely that this would be a very wide and far-reaching amendment if it were in a form tending to compulsion; but it simply enables the situation to be met in this way. Suppose an occasion arises—and it may arise in the instance I have in mind— it could be said that while it might be necessary to extend this hospital, in order to do it they would have to eject a charity in the neighbourhood, a charity that had grounded itself firmly, and it would be unfair to move it elsewhere on the chance of purchasing substitute land in the neighbourhood with the money paid by way of compensation. I merely suggest that land should be obtained for the purpose of providing substitute land for any person from whom land has been acquired. The amendment would not need to be operated more than occasionally. I had only one particular case in mind, and I thought the phrasing was wide enough to cover what I had in view, but it appears that was a wrong conclusion. I want to enable the Minister to have power to make this exchange.
Comment on this
I might inform the Deputy, in case he does not know it, that the land occupied by the particular charity he mentions, the Legion of Mary, is State land. It is vested in the State under Article 11 of the first Constitution. The land was made available for the charity by the Dublin Board of Assistance. The board has power, under the Public Assistance (Acquisition of Land) Act, 1934, to acquire land for that or any other charitable organisation. In the event of the Minister acquiring land from that particular organisation—and this is in reply to Deputy McGilligan's argument that the Legion of Mary could not acquire compensatory land— the Dublin Board of Assistance have statutory power to provide any additional land that might be necessary in compensation for the land that might be taken from them.
Comment on this
Has the Minister the statute under which the board acquires? What are the compulsory powers?
Comment on this
The Public Assistance Act, 1937. Section 2 (d) sets out:—
"... by providing premises (with all requisite furniture and fittings) for use by such society for the purpose of so affording relief to poor persons."
Comment on this
The board of assistance may do that in respect of a charity. Where is the compulsory acquisition?
Comment on this
I think the Parliamentary Secretary will realise that that does not quite meet the point. Any argument as to the site of the present charity being more or less State owned does not arise at all. I am talking about the site to which the charity will have to move if the land is taken from them, the land which they occupy at the moment. If the board of assistance have power to acquire land compulsorily, that does not quite meet the situation either. It might tend towards it. I do not know what their powers are, but they are tied very expressly.
Comment on this
Perhaps I might quote a section from the Public Assistance (Acquisition of Land) Act, 1934. Section 3 sets out:—
"A public assistance authority may, for the purpose of its powers and duties, acquire land either by agreement with the consent of the Minister or compulsorily under this Act and the Acts incorporated therewith."
Comment on this
I am told by the Parliamentary Secretary that the situation is clear because the land is more or less State owned. Supposing they do not care to exercise their powers in favour of the charity? I would be anxious to have some co-ordination and I think it ought to be the same person who carried out both operations. I agree it would be an enlargement of the existing law if this were going to be used in a general way, but I suggest that it will only be used for odd occasions and on such odd occasions it would be convenient for the Minister to do both things. As to this being a novelty, it is no such thing. It was found, in the course of the Shannon operations, that where the canal, as it was projected, divided lands, it was necessary to take powers there to acquire land not merely for the purpose of building the canal through certain people's lands, but to acquire portions of separated holdings on either side of the canal in order to consolidate the holdings on one or the other side. There was exactly the same power taken there and it was used effectively. This does not throw any obligation on the Minister and I suggest that it is power he may need.
Comment on this
I am not disposed to accept it. I foresee another complication Suppose the Minister acquires substitute land for a particular charity and the charity refuses to accept that land, would the Minister not require power to compel?
Comment on this
Surely the Minister would not acquire land until, in consultation with the charity, he had agreed with the charity that the land he proposed to purchase would be suitable for the charity?
Comment on this
In the case of this charity, they have no right or title to the land; they are only permitted to use it by the Dublin Board of Assistance.
Comment on this
They might be treated as people who had squatters' rights. In the correspondence that passed between the Richmond Governors and the Minister, one of the difficulties raised was as to whether or not alternative accommodation could be found for the charities operated by the Legion of Mary. Now it is understood that the accommodation will be got, but can the Legion of Mary be facilitated in the neighbourhood? If it is not possible to facilitate them by the compulsory acquisition of land in the neighbourhood, then I want to give the Minister this power. He says he does not want it because he has it already. That is contrary to the argument he recently made use of.
Comment on this
In their present situation they have not any more than a squatter's right. They are working in the area through the facilities given by the Dublin Board of Assistance. As a matter of Government policy the work that is being done is most important. It is absolutely essential social work. I take it that it is the policy of the present Ministry to help to develop what was the policy of the last Ministry, because here you have definite work which it is necessary to have continued and carried out.
Comment on this
Before the amendment is put, may I say that here we have a suggestion being made to the Parliamentary Secretary that a certain simple power be taken which will make it possible, without any complication or development of a dispute, to acquire land in the neighbourhood, land which may be required in order to extend the ground upon which the Legion of Mary is working at the present time, and in order that they may pass some land which they at present control to the hospital. The Parliamentary Secretary is deliberately refusing to take that power.
Comment on this
I want to say that the Parliamentary Secretary is simply adding to the difficulties. His plan seems to be to leave as many difficulties around him as he possibly can in order to prevent a situation which, as Deputy Cooney says, every Dublin Deputy with the exception of Deputy McCann wants to see carried out: to see the hospital developed so that it may fulfil all its functions on the present site. The Minister is refusing to take that power. He is afraid of the development of the present site because it might then be suitable for keeping the hospital where it is.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that is not so. The Minister has power to acquire the site either compulsorily or by agreement. He can acquire that site, or one adjacent to it, or a site anywhere else. That matter has already been determined. The issue raised in this amendment is a different issue altogether, namely, that the Minister should arm himself with powers to acquire land for the purpose of exchanging it in compensation for other land acquired. That would be a complicated and rather dangerous procedure to adopt. He can acquire any land that is necessary for the extension of the existing site. He has the power to compensate but that compensation will not take the form of land but of money.