We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Saint Laurence O'Toole Hospital Bill, 1940—Committee Stage.

Contributions 166–339 of 339. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Saint Laurence's Hospital Bill, 1940
Enacted

No. 9 of 1940 ›

The Parliamentary Secretary is putting himself in this position, that if he acquires a particular piece of land he will disable a charity that is engaged on very important work at the present moment. What we are asking him to do is to take power that when he acquires that site for the purposes of this hospital, and invades the area covered by this charity, he should also take power to acquire compulsorily lands that are adjacent to where that charity is working now. If he does that it can continue its work on ground which extends from the ground on which it is working at the present time. If it pushes its way in on top of this charitable institution, it will secure that this charitable institution will be able to push its way a little ahead on to the site that is already there.

Comment on this

If the Minister disables a charity, as the Deputy has suggested, he has the power to compensate, and compensate in money. That compensation will be adequate to the estimated loss of the charity concerned.

Comment on this

But it will not enable the charity to buy satisfactorily the additional ground necessary to extend itself and remain where it is.

Comment on this

That is too big an onus to put on the Minister.

Comment on this

The amendment does not confine this to a charitable institution.

Comment on this

No; but it does not say that in the ordinary course compensation is to be an exchange of land. Experience is surely some guidance. In connection with the Shannon scheme it was discovered that the amount of money which people, whose farms had been separated by the driving of the canal, got did not enable them to purchase lands adjacent to the bit of the holding left to them from another land owner whose holding had also been divided. The Government of the day had to take power to enable them to amalgamate the holdings on one side of the canal and on the other side. Provision of that kind had to be made by way of amendment. If this amendment was setting a fashion that compensation would be given in land instead of in moneys, it would be quite legitimate to say that it was a wide extension of the existing law for a purpose that had not been clearly disclosed. But it is only an enabling clause, and is confined to the purpose of substituting land where other lands have been acquired for the purposes of this Bill. It is certainly going to be of very limited application.

Comment on this

Deputy Cooney must be aware that there is an adequate site there when certain parts of the ground covered by Grangegorman are taken into consideration, as well as a certain part of the ground covered by the Legion of Mary institution. If and when some of the grounds of the Legion of Mary institution are taken for this hospital, it will be necessary to acquire ground to the north of the present site occupied by the Legion of Mary in order to give the latter a sufficiently large site on which to continue the work they have in hands. It will be necessary to get land there in order to substitute it for the accommodation that is between the hospital and the Legion of Mary. What is proposed here is to give the Minister power to acquire that land as if it were acquired for this hospital direct—to exchange the land that it would acquire to the north of the present Legion of Mary site in lieu of the southern portion of the Legion of Mary site which it is contemplated would be required for the hospital extension.

Comment on this

Take the case of the Grangegorman Committee. They are looking for a site for the new mental hospital. In the event of their compulsorily acquiring a particular person's holding which may be quite on the cards, if this power is given, then that person might, through various channels, attempt to bring pressure on the Department to facilitate him in respect of other lands convenient to where he is now. The result may be a general hold-up and a certain amount of chaos and delay.

Comment on this

The action that may be taken by the Grangegorman Committee to acquire land for their purposes does not arise in connection with this Bill at all.

Comment on this

This Bill is called the "Saint Laurence's Hospital Bill".

Comment on this

Would it not apply to the other hospitals?

Comment on this

We could deal with the case.

Comment on this

The Grangegorman Committee are at present proceeding under the powers they have to acquire additional lands for their own purpose. That action stops at that.

Comment on this

Why should they not be entitled to the same facilities as are proposed in the amendment?

Comment on this

If Deputy Cooney wants to raise additional difficulty in preventing doing the job in which he is interested, then he can join the Minister's class and make difficulties rather than resolve them and have the work done.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment No. 4 put.

Tá 27
·
Níl 43
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

We are in this position that, without there being any real argument put up for going elsewhere than on the present site of the Richmond Hospital, and in the teeth of three reports presented by the Hospitals Commission, the House has now decided to allow the Minister to have the Bill with a section in it which enables him to go elsewhere. By way of further protest against this, even in this atmosphere of complete unreality, I propose to divide the House on the section.

Comment on this

The situation is really worse than that. The Minister has refused to take power to extend the site, if necessary, in the direction of the Legion of Mary buildings. He has stated emphatically that he does not believe those architects who, apparently, have been advising the Opposition that on the present site a 550-bed hospital can be erected; that architects who look at the present situation and suggest that are the kind of people who would be prepared to build in the clouds; and that he does not believe in people who talk in that way. He has told us that we had better prepare our minds for this hospital going to Cabra; that it will go to Cabra if he thinks that that is the proper place for it to go. He addresses the House in that way, taking powers to do anything he likes in the matter of this hospital and, at the same time, telling the House that he has not looked at a single site. That gives us some idea of the extent to which he has reviewed the functions of this hospital and the change that will be brought about when the present hospital is done away with. I say that it is a scandalous way to treat this House in the present times and that it is an outrageous way to deal with medical interests in the City of Dublin.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 42
·
Níl 29
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 6:—

In sub-section (1) (a), page 5, line 24, to add after the word "site" the words "including any extension of the area of the site".

I understand that the word "site" may be interpreted as not including an extension of the area.

Comment on this

I do not understand the Deputy's amendment. Does it imply that it is necessary to define "site"? I understand that "site" means such area as may be necessary for the purposes of the Bill or for the purposes of establishing a hospital.

Comment on this

If that is the understanding it is odd that, while in Section 4 you have the word "site", in sub-sections (1) and (2) power is given to acquire land adjacent to the site. Apparently there is a difference between "site" and "land adjacent".

Comment on this

It is for the purpose of extending the existing hospital.

Comment on this

The word "site" does not apparently exclude extension. There is a distinction made in the Bill between site and something required to extend or to enlarge. That would seem to me to tie the person acquiring down to something which has been described as "site". I want to make it wider. It may be that at some time someone will decide that such and such an addition would be made before the hospital is built.

Comment on this

I will have the matter further looked into.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In sub-section (1), page 5, line 37, to delete the words "the Saint Laurence O'Toole" and substitute the words "Saint Laurence's".

This is a consequential amendment intended to change the name of this hospital from "Saint Laurence O'Toole's" to "Saint Laurence's".

Comment on this

There is more than one Saint Laurence. There is a celebrated saint called Saint Laurence of the Gridiron, after whom the Escorial is called. If the word "O'Toole" is eliminated, any distinctiveness in the association of the hospital with Saint Laurence O'Toole will be gone. If the intention is to have the hospital called after the patron saint of the Archdiocese of Dublin, that should be mentioned somewhere in the Bill. What the hospital will be called by the people is another question. The hospital, under this amendment, will be Saint Laurence's Hospital, but will not be Saint Laurence O'Toole's Hospital. In the ordinary interpretation, the Laurence mentioned will be Saint Laurence of the Gridiron. Great as he was, Saint Laurence O'Toole's fame is confined to this country, whereas the fame of Saint Laurence of the Gridiron is almost universal.

Comment on this

In Ireland the name Saint Laurence refers to Saint Laurence O'Toole and to nobody else. If Deputy Cosgrave would consult some of his clerical friends—perhaps he has done so—he would find that in the Ordo sanctioned by the Bishops of Ireland for the use of the Catholic clergy in reciting the Divine Office and celebrating Mass, the feast of Saint Laurence O'Toole is noted under the heading "Feast of Saint Laurence." In the Ordo no feast of Saint Laurence O'Toole is set out.

Comment on this

The Ordo is for the clergy. It is quite possible that, if you looked up the name of Saint Laurence of the Gridiron, you would not find the words "of the Gridiron" after his name either. Outside the ProCathedral, I do not think that there is a stained glass window to Saint Laurence O'Toole anywhere, but there is a stained glass window in another church to Saint Laurence of the Gridiron.

Comment on this

No other saint than St. Laurence O'Toole is known to the Catholic Church in Ireland or to the Irish people as Saint Laurence. In Ireland, Saint Laurence means Saint Laurence O'Toole.

Comment on this

Rubbish. Even in the history books, he is described as Saint Laurence O'Toole.

Comment on this

Has the learning of the Parliamentary Secretary been lately acquired? We had the word "O'Toole" plastered over this Bill up to now.

Comment on this

That was an oversight.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is flush with information now——

Comment on this

The complaint made was that the hospital would be commonly known as the O'Toole Hospital.

Comment on this

Yes, and that was a reasonable complaint. The point can be urged home by the Parliamentary Secretary. But I did not know that the phrase "St. Laurence O'Toole" was being comprehensively wiped out of the Bill.

Comment on this

The point was not urged by me. I made my point against the point which Deputy Cosgrave was trying to make.

Comment on this

There is no use in parading learning that was not there this day last week.

Comment on this

I wish the Deputy would learn some week.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary ought to try to behave himself. We are discussing a Bill. It is not the Parliamentary Secretary's Bill; it is a Bill of this House.

Comment on this

I could not learn to behave myself from you.

Comment on this

Nobody would take the Parliamentary Secretary as a tutor of anything except insolence. Nobody would take him as a tutor of manners. With an ordinary piece of behaviour, would the Parliamentary Secretary say whether this amendment is designed to wipe out the phrase "Saint Laurence O'Toole" from the whole Bill?

Comment on this

It is desired to submit this amendment.

Comment on this

We will vote against it, because this is the place where that should be stated.

Comment on this

This mixture of learning, lately acquired, sandwiched in between various items of insolence, is not manners.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not lecture the House about manners.

Comment on this

I am not lecturing the House. I am lecturing the Parliamentary Secretary—the one person who requires it badly.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot teach anybody manners.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary had been treated more roughly as a boy he would be a better man now.

Comment on this

The Deputy could not have been treated roughly because he would not have stood rough treatment. He was not physically able to take rough treatment.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary should remain silent——

Comment on this

I am inclined to regret that I saved him from rough treatment.

Comment on this

Are we to take it from the Parliamentary Secretary's lately acquired knowledge about saints——

Comment on this

Are you disturbed about it?

Comment on this

It does not disturb me. The disturbance may be due to the fact that the knowledge came late.

Comment on this

It is too bad to disturb you.

Comment on this

This matter can be discussed quietly.

Comment on this

Sure.

Comment on this

Is this the sort of thing to which we are to be treated?

Comment on this

I am helping the Deputy along.

Comment on this

It may be the Deputy's idea of "helping" but it is not mine.

Comment on this

I shall stop if it is not assisting him.

Comment on this

It will neither assist nor disturb me. I am trying to continue, and will do so as long as I am permitted by the Chair. No exhibition of vulgarity or bad manners on the part of the Parliamentary Secretary will knock me off. If I may get away from the insolence and bad temper of the Parliamentary Secretary, these both being evident to anybody looking at the Parliamentary Secretary at the moment, I want to say that, when I made the suggestion that this phrase if left in the Bill would mean that the hospital would be called by one term, and that an obnoxious term, that suggestion, apparently, found favour with the Parliamentary Secretary.

Hence we get this late idea of wiping out the phrase, "Saint Laurence O'Toole," from the whole measure. When the first amendment was produced, I heard Deputy Kelly speak in an angry state of mind against this, and I thought that the proposal was that the name was to be put down as "Saint Laurence's," but that some phrase would be left in the measure which would associate the hospital with Saint Laurence O'Toole. I think that point could be urged and should be urged without any exhibition of bad manners by the Parliamentary Secretary in dealing with it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is setting a bad example so far as manners are concerned, and that is nothing new.

Comment on this

Listen.

Comment on this

If I were not listening, I would not be able to intervene.

Comment on this

This gutter-snipe performance——

Comment on this

Never mind the gutter-snipe.

Comment on this

I am trying my best to avoid him.

Comment on this

You live in that atmosphere; you cannot get out of it.

Comment on this

I have been away from the Parliamentary Secretary for a long time.

Comment on this

Thank God. I hope you stay away.

Comment on this

I can continue this as long as the Parliamentary Secretary, but it is not edifying.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is not edifying when dealing with the patron saint of the Archdiocese of Dublin.

Comment on this

Surely we can have this matter argued in a proper way. Is it meet and proper for a Deputy to say that if this hospital is to be associated with the name of Saint Laurence O'Toole, that name should appear somewhere in the Bill. I say it should. I also have the definite objection that if the name is left there the hospital will be known by an ugly title. Therefore, I suggest that the phrase, "Saint Laurence's," should be substituted for the longer phrase in any place where it is appropriate to nomenclature, but nothing else. I think the point should be answered, but not vulgarly.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 42
·
Níl 22
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 8:—

In sub-section (1), page 5, lines 42 and 46, and in sub-sections (1) and (2), page 6, lines 5, 12 and 19, to delete the word "Minister" where it occurs in the said lines and substitute therefor the words "existing governing body".

The purpose of the amendment is to make a radical change in what is proposed in the Bill. The Bill proposes that there is to be made what is called a principal order which is to provide for the number of members of the board, their method of appointment, their term of office, the resignation and disqualification of such members, and the filling of casual vacancies. Under paragraph (b), the Minister, in this principal order, may provide for such other matters, in relation to the members of the board, as he thinks proper. In sub-section (2) the Minister is taking power that, having made the principal order, he may at any time amend it by addition, deletion or variation. I propose to have the Minister in all these matters substituted by the existing governing body which is defined as "the governors of the existing hospitals established under the Act of 1856." My proposal, therefore, is to make this radical change in the method of the appointment of the new board in relation to all the matters I have mentioned. In that way we will have continuity between the existing governing body and the body or board of the new hospital.

I have put down this amendment with deliberation. I do not see that it is the function of the Minister of any modern Government to interfere with regard to the composition of a board to run a hospital. It is not a public hospital, and I do not understand how it is going to be the function of any member of a Government to provide for the appointment of members of such a board, their method of appointment, resignation and disqualification, and the filling of casual vacancies. It seems to me that is peculiarly the function of boards of the type that at the moment are the governing authorities of all the hospitals in the City of Dublin. I presume I am going to be answered by the statement that, at the moment, the board is to some extent under the control of the Government. If it is, it is because such powers were given in the old days. Powers of the kind were more or less common in the days when the Act of 1856 was being drawn up. We have advanced considerably since then. If we were to write into an Act of the year 1940, as being proper to this year, things which were thought proper in 1856 and which have simply been continued, it could be attributed more or less to inertia, and to an incapacity to deal with this urgent matter. We would be giving a new life to these old principles.

I may also be met with the argument that neither the present Government nor the last Government has interfered to any great degree with the appointment of members of such boards. I found myself on that particular argument by showing that many of the powers written into these old Acts have, in fact, fallen into disuse. It is well known that under the change of Government in this country, and through the operation of the Ministers and Secretaries Act, a number of the powers which had been vested in the Lord Lieutenant and other functionaries in the old days, came by delegation of function into the hands of the Government of the day.

Many of these have been neglected, such, for example, as the appointment of the Provost of Trinity College. The nominations sent forward by the ruling authorities in these institutions have, I think, in all cases been accepted by the Government of the day. What I am proposing here, therefore, is that we should end the old system and mark our appreciation of the new system, and write into this Act of 1940 that there is to be no interference by the Government in these matters. It may be considered proper that there should be a new scheme drawn up by the existing boards to mark the evolution that has taken place. If the rules and regulations of the present boards are found not to be up to date, that better provision should be made to deal, for example, with members who do not ordinarily attend the meetings, I suggest all that should be done by the boards of governors which will be better qualified than the Minister to deal with the new situation as it develops.

My proposal is, in principle, directed against interference by the Government in such intimate matters as the conduct of a board of governors of a hospital, their method of appointment, resignation and so on. There is only one thing that may be objected to in so far as the amendment is concerned. Sub-section (4) provides that "every order made under this section shall have the force of law". It may be said that it is a rather extreme delegation of powers to give an outside governing body the right to make orders and then to give those orders the force of law. But the orders refer only to internal matters: the number of people to be appointed to the board, their method of election, resignation, the filling of casual vacancies, and so on. In so far as that is a limited delegation of powers, I do not think it is too wide. In the case of the universities, the scheme is that the governing bodies are given the power to make their own statutes and to carry them a certain distance in the way of making them statute law. The obligation, however, is placed on them to lay those statutes on the Table of the House of Parliament for so many days. Until that is done they have not the force of law. However, that is a matter that could be dealt with by way of amendment if the principle that the Government should not interfere in the matter were carried.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 8 to 13 propose two alternatives to the powers of the Minister to regulate the appointment of the board. Amendments Nos. 8, 11, 12 and 13 all go together and seek to place power in the hands of the governing body. The decision might be taken on amendment No. 8. Amendments Nos. 9 and 10 seek to restrict the exercise of the Minister's power. The decision might be on amendment No. 9.

Comment on this

I take it, Sir, whatever the decision—assuming that an adverse decision is taken on amendment No. 8—it will not affect the discussion on amendments Nos. 9 and 10?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No, except they are alternative proposals. One of them seeks to remove the Minister's power, and the other seeks to restrict it.

Comment on this

I wonder would I be in order on this section and amendment in asking the Parliamentary Secretary how he proposes to constitute the new board? On that matter I would like to urge on the Parliamentary Secretary the necessity for appointing representative people on that board.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think it would be better if the Deputy reserved his remarks for the section. It has first to be decided whether the Minister will appoint the board or not.

Comment on this

If I get a chance later——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, on the section.

Comment on this

On amendment No. 8, I want to say that Deputy McGilligan has himself answered his own arguments in favour of this amendment. He has adverted to the fact that the Minister, under the Act of 1856, has vested in him powers which he proposes by this amendment to take away from him. In fact, if Deputy McGilligan's series of amendments calculated to curtail the Minister's powers were all to be carried, the only function the Minister would have in regard to this hospital would be to provide a site and to provide the money to build the hospital or, at least, to certify that the hospital was required.

Under Section 5 of the Act of 1856—

"The Lord Lieutenant may, when he shall deem it expedient so to do by order direct that the management of the House of Industry Hospitals shall be vested in a board of governors to be partly nominated by the Lord Lieutenant and partly elected by the subscribers to the said hospitals, in such proportion as the Lord Lieutenant shall from time to time determine, and the Lord Lieutenant shall from time to time determine the number of members of which such board shall consist, and the qualifications of such members as are to be so elected by the said subscribers".

There were, in fact, no subscribers and under the Act of 1856 the Lord Lieutenant appointed the board of governors entirely. The powers vested in the Lord Lieutenant under Section 5 of the Act of 1856 passed to the Minister for Local Government and Public Health. During the 18 years since the Free State came into existence these powers have remained vested in the Minister for Local Government and Public Health and during the ten years when Deputy Cosgrave was head of the Government in this part of Ireland, these powers were vested in the Minister for Local Government and Public Health. Since Fianna Fáil took office as the Government these powers have been vested in the Minister for Local Government and Public Health and it is now suggested that all that should be changed; that the powers vested in the Minister in relation to this institution should in fact be vested in the existing board of governors. I am not prepared to accept the proposal. The powers that have been vested in the Minister in the past are vested in him at present and he seeks no further powers under this Bill. The powers he has are to be retained by the Minister. No reason whatever has been advanced and I cannot conceive what reason could be advanced as to why the Minister should divest himself of the powers he has in relation to this. A lot might be said and possibly a good share will be said about the voluntary principle. I have not a word of criticism to say about the voluntary principle except this—in the debate in this House recently on the Hospitals Bureau Bill suggestions were made that if that Bill was passed the voluntary hospitals would not co-operate with the Minister in the development of these hospitals to meet the needs of the sick poor of the Dublin area. Now the Bill has been passed and the people who take it upon themselves— with what authority I know not—to speak on behalf of the voluntary hospitals have stated in public that the voluntary hospitals will not co-operate with the Minister in any scheme for the full development of the voluntary hospitals to meet the needs of the poor of Dublin.

People who speak or write in that strain may not, as I say, speak for the voluntary hospitals, but they may. At any rate, so long as that possibility exists it seems to me that it would be entirely foolish and short-sighted to hand over the power of control which is vested in the Minister at the present time in the case of one hospital in Dublin at any rate. I do not know what arguments are to be advanced but I wish to say this, that it is proposed to retain the powers vested in the Minister at present under the Act of 1856in toto.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary can scarcely understand exactly the position with regard to this hospital. His entire case in respect to the holding of the powers that are in the Act of 1856 is that the powers are there, that they are statute law and that they have been exercised for 18 years. Now, I wish to say that the exercise of them during 18 years admits of very considerable qualifications. They were exercised for the first ten years, at any rate, at the request of the governing body. The suggestion of the governing body was accepted. There was certainly very much more reason for not interfering with the law during those ten years than what there is now. Now, there is not a vestige of evidence to be found that during those nine or ten years this House voted any sums of money for that hospital. Since the Minister's Party came into power not a single penny has been voted for it. Any authority that he exercises—assuming that it is an authority that is an expansion of what is in the Act—is an interference. Why should there be an interference in this present case? There is a governing body there. What is the complaint against them? They are administering the voluntary hospitals. It is in the line of succession of the appointments made since 1856 but it stands in a different position from the previous governing body. In 1919 the Hospital Committee applied for a bigger sum of money than was voted to them. The general impression was that it was a Government hospital. It was called so in the City of Dublin and it was stated in both Houses of Parliament in England that it was a Government hospital.

The Government stated they would give the £5,000 a year, or whatever the sum was, and no more. They advised the governors, if they wanted to keep the hospital open, that they had better alter their plans and take in paying patients and so on. The governing body resigned, and then the surgical and medical staff came together and decided that they would themselves make every effort to maintain and keep the hospital open. They nominated, I think, six of their number, and put up the remaining names to the Lord Lieutenant, who was then the person in authority, and stated that if that board were appointed they would do their best to keep the hospital open. Some members of that medical staff wrote cheques to meet current liabilities. They took in some paying patients and, so far as their resources permitted, they treated the sick poor. That was the situation then.

Some eight or ten years ago the hospitals found that they were unable to make their accounts balance and, through a member of the medical staff of one of the hospitals, they promoted a Bill to provide money for the hospitals. It might be said that the Government's help in connection with that was to loot what they could out of it. They took 5/- in the £ income-tax out of what was raised for the hospitals. Now they want to regulate the administration of the other 15/-. They want to regulate who is to administer this hospital and so on. What is the purpose of it? Here is a governing body that has functioned to the advantage and satisfaction of the various persons concerned—the patients, their relatives, the staff, and the employees, etc. Is there anything wrong with the body that has been in authority during these years? We are now brought to this position, that the Minister shall, before the establishment date, make an order prescribing the number of members of the board, the method of appointment of such members, the term of office, and the resignation and disqualification of members and so on. At any time he can alter and amend the orders that he has made.

It is a great thing for the City of Dublin that its hospitals are what are called voluntary hospitals. It would be a great pity to interfere with them, unless there is cause of complaint. If there is, we want to hear about it. If there is a cause of complaint we would prefer that some effort should be made before bringing it here to see if accommodation could not be found. If accommodation cannot be found, or there is a major cause of complaint, they should tell us about it and put forward their suggestions for meeting it. But, at a time such as this, when this hospital has gone through a lean and difficult time and surmounted practically every obstacle that could possibly be placed in its way, when it is one of the most up-to-date hospitals in the country, with operating theatres which are air-conditioned, mainly through the work of the governing body, why should there be an entire alteration and a provision that on a particular date there will be two boards operating, the outgoing board and the incoming board? From the way in which this Bill has been drafted, one can see the distinction drawn by the Minister between the two bodies. Wherever the new board is mentioned a capital B is used; and whenever the existing governing body is mentioned three small letters are used. They are not even given the courtesy in their expiring days of a capital letter.

I should like to know what case the Minister has to make for his interference in this case. Is he making any contribution of any sort or kind towards improving the situation? Is he bringing any money into it? Does he intend to bring in any money? What improvement is he going to make under this arrangement that the present governing body could not make? I think Deputy McGilligan's amendment is a sensible one, that it is in keeping with the spirit of the age and with the character of the institution; and that it should commend itself to any person who has had treatment in this hospital.

Comment on this

Apparently the Parliamentary Secretary is not going to reply to Deputy Cosgrave's statement. I suppose we can understand the spirit in which the Parliamentary Secretary would listen to Deputy Cosgrave and not make any attempt to reply. It has been suggested that the provision in Section 10 as it now stands is just giving life to an old thing that was heard of about 1856. I do not think anybody here would be misled by any suggestion of that kind. What we see here in this measure is absolutely brand new. It is one of those "isms" the suppression of all mention of which will provide an absorbing and full-time occupation for an additional emergency Ministerial appointment. The proposal is that, in respect of this hospital that has been run on voluntary lines, we are to have a new situation under which the Minister shall make an order determining the number of members who will be on the governing board, the method of their appointment, and the term of office of the members. He will set out all about their resignation, if resignation is required. He will set out everything dealing with their disqualification. He will set out all the arrangements for dealing with casual vacancies. He will set out such other matters as he may think proper in relation to any members on the board. He will deal with different members on the board in such different ways as he thinks proper. He can change his mind as often as he likes about anything that he has power to do. This is all proposed in relation to an hospital with the long-established record of the Richmond Hospital, and with the relations that it has with this city. If the Minister were proposing something like that for an hospital in, say, Ballydehob, we would be outraged at the thought of it. I do not think that he would seek to exercise his power in this particular way in connection with an hospital in Ballydehob.

I should like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary why Ministerial powers of this kind are being sought. I suggest that they are not sought because of anything carried over from the past working or administration of the hospital, but that they are an absolutely brand-new intrusion into public dealings with hospitals. How is it that we cannot get some kind of answer to the objections raised to this scheme by Deputy Cosgrave? What about this new "ism" which we are not allowed to mention, lest we come under Ministerial edict and suppression? How is it that while these powers are looked for by the Minister he does not appear in the House to give any reasons for asking for these extraordinary powers?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell the House what new powers the Minister seeks in the Bill that he does not hold at present?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary was told by Deputy Cosgrave that a statute was inherited in 1922, and that at the request of the governors of the hospital there was no change in the statute made in the meantime.

Comment on this

Then the Minister has powers at present that he is seeking in this Bill?

Comment on this

The Minister has.

Comment on this

He has or has not?

Comment on this

He may have, but the position is that the law is being put into a different set of words in the circumstances outlined and traversed here. The administration of the hospital has been radically different from what was implied in the words of the existing statute. Will the Parliamentary Secretary say that the hospital has been controlled in recent years in a spirit and in a way that is suggested in the section? Is it not a fact that any steps taken by the Government with regard to the hospital in recent years, except the withholding of certain grants from it, have been taken at the suggestion of the present governing body?

Comment on this

I cannot understand the view point that Deputy Mulcahy has put forward or the amendment. It seems to me, as far as the hospital and its administration are concerned, that there is much greater power vested in the House and room for criticism if the Minister is empowered to do these things. At least a Parliamentary question can be put down as to why so-and-so was done, or why a thing was not done in a particular fashion. We can have an annual discussion on the Minister's Estimate as to why he acted in a particular manner with regard to certain appointments.

From the point of view of the House and of preserving control, that seems to be a more effective way to exercise some control over the hospital than the existing board, a board which under Section 9 is "a body corporate with perpetual succession, and to make appointments." Once power is given to that kind of board, then you have to put up with what it does, and cannot ask the Minister if he heard what the board did on a particular occasion, and if he proposed to take action. Deputies might be told that there was no effective power to do so, whereas if the Minister gets the power proposed in Section 10, which, in fact, he is supposed to have, there is some power over the administration of the hospital.

I could understand two points of view, either that there should be a little State interference or voluntary hospitals. As far as State interference makes for efficiency and adequate supervision, by making people realise that their activities are under supervision and control, I am in favour of such supervision. I cannot say if other people share my views. I question if we have not reached the stage when voluntary hospitals will have to give way to municipal hospitals. I believe that many eminent members of the medical profession believe the same thing, that it is much better in the national interest to have municipal institutions. I know that voluntary hospitals provide a very substantial income for certain people who, under the guise of ministering in voluntary hospitals, can presume to lecture everyone and to imagine that they are omnipotent in the world of medicine. The income they get from these hospitals should, at least, make them civil. On inquiry, Deputy Mulcahy will find from medical men here and elsewhere that the method that is functioning of filling appointments is far from being democratic. There are some hospitals in this city where young doctors dare not look for an appointment. It is probably as easy to secure election to this House or probably to the Presidential Establishment as for some young doctors to get into some city hospitals, while it is very easy for others. Because I know these facts, which are known to medical men, I am in favour of giving the Minister these powers, if he has not got them. If he has them, this is merely a reaffirmation of his position. I am giving the powers because if he exercises them there is a method of control in the Minister and in the Administration.

Comment on this

Now we have the issue really knit as between two contrasting points of view. What passed for argument with the Parliamentary Secretary is now definitely stated. The Parliamentary Secretary told Deputy Norton that he is doing nothing except what he could do. He harped on the word "vested" and was on safe ground. If the Parliamentary Secretary asks whether in the time of the last Government equal powers were there he will get a different answer. I object to renewing in this legislation old powers which had lapsed. Deputy Norton raised a new issue. Let us consider the prospect that he contemplates. He wants to have the situation with regard to this hospital—and, no doubt, he would like to see it with regard to other hospitals—such that Deputies would be able from time to time to put down questions to the Parliamentary Secretary to know why such a patient was not admitted or how a particular appointment was made. Once the Minister gets that power, and the thin edge of the wedge is introduced, other things are looked for. I object to that. I think it is a very bad principle. There might be a case made for it where public money was being devoted to such purpose. Remember that this House took what was considered to be a big step towards socialism when the Electricity Supply Board was set up. Vast accumulations of the people's credit were given to that board and the only thing asked in return was publicity, that there would be a regular report and that the Minister would have power to ask the auditors appointed by him, but paid by the board, for information, so that the public would get information and that the House would have an opportunity of debating it. We wanted to remove the board and appointments made under the board, and everything about the board from day to day interference by Parliamentary criticism.

Comment on this

It would be no harm if there was more light thrown on that board.

Comment on this

Possibly, but let the Deputy remember that the opportunity for debate has been available to him since 1927 and never once availed of.

Comment on this

We asked several questions about the Sugar Board and did not get information.

Comment on this

I agree with regard to the Sugar Board that it is a bit of a scandal, but the scandal with regard to that board and the State has been unchanged. We did not get any information arising out of it. There is a bit of scandal even with regard to some hospital matters. We have asked where are the hospital funds and we cannot get any information. I would like to see it made incumbent on a Minister to produce details once a year, but I object to day to day interference.

Comment on this

I never contemplated that, any more than I would ask why So-and-so was not admitted to the Army.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton wants to ask the Minister why an occasional appointment was made. There will be a variety of opinions as to whether appointments were good or bad. I do not think that would be good for the hospitals. I could understand it if public money was given to the hospitals. That is not the case. There is not 1/- of the taxpayers' money here. What happened was that a scheme was established mainly for the running of sweepstakes and the accumulations were to a certain extent to be managed by certain people. They raised certain moneys and the State dipped its hands into the funds and, so far, all the State has done with regard to these funds is to lessen them and to take part of them for the relief of general taxation.

All the Minister is going to do in this connection is to pass over some of the moneys subscribed by others who got tickets in the sweepstakes to the hospital. He is giving no other grant to the hospital. The Parliamentary Secretary says that this happened in 1856. Public money was going to the hospitals in 1856, but we have a new situation now. I do not mind Deputy Norton saying he would agree with my point of view in one respect and diverge from it in other ways. As to whether the Minister or the existing governing body should have control, I do not think there can be any real contest. The people do not want the Minister to interfere. Deputy Norton has withdrawn from the attitude I understood him to take up and says that it is only when something irregular has happened the Minister should interfere. Then, why not associate with the board something in the nature of public representation? In this case, the Minister represents nobody. Where public money has been given, he has properly a place. But he has nothing to do with this matter. If you could get somebody to represent the subscribers, there would be a case for putting them on. But that cannot be done. The Minister merely gives over some of the money of subscribers which he has pilfered for this purpose. The statutes governing the old board could be examined to see if something in the nature of local representation could be attached to it. Does anybody really think that hereafter the Minister is going to interfere in connection with the board? We have the experience of two Governments to put against that. Over a long period of years, they have not interfered in regard to this matter. They have simply taken what came from the board. I suggest that we leave that as the foundation of the new scheme. Let us make changes if we wish, but let us not make a radical change, and the change here proposed is a radical change.

Comment on this

What about the alleged threat of the hospitals not to work the bed-bureau scheme?

Comment on this

That should be taken in its context.

Comment on this

Who is to deal with that?

Comment on this

How can you deal with that? In connection with the bed-bureau scheme the hospitals were asked if they would facilitate certain investigations which would take place and provide certain information. Most of them said they would. That understood, they were asked to accept something else—Ministerial interference. They say that that is not good for a hospital. I agree with them, though the Deputy may not. They have made a distinction. They are prepared to provide information but, when as an essential part of that, they were asked to join in the scheme under the last Bill, they said no, because it would involve Ministerial interference. So far as giving information is concerned, I have not found anybody to object to it. But they object to the second part—Ministerial interference.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 47
·
Níl 20
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 9:—

To delete sub-section (1) (a) (ii), page 5, and substitute the following sub-paragraphs:—

(ii) the number of members of the board to be selected from the surgical and medical staff of the hospital which shall not be less than one-third of the total membership of the board;

(iii) the method of nomination by the existing governing body or by the board after the establishment thereof of suitable persons to be appointed by the Minister as members of the board and of submitting two alternative nominations, if so requested by the Minister, in respect of each appointment to the board, other than the members selected from the surgical and medical staff.

The passage of this amendment would mean that there will be a definite proportion of the board drawn from the surgical and medical staff and, as regards the rest of the members of the board, where vacancies occur the appointments would be made on the recommendation of the board itself. In case there was any difficulty between the Minister and the board on the question of appointments, alternative nominations for each vacancy would be made.

Deputy Norton, commenting on some of my remarks on the last amendment, subscribed wholeheartedly to full ministerial control of the board—at least, his words suggested that he did. His reason for doing so was that the fact that the board was entirely controlled by the Minister gave members of the House power to question any matters in relation to the carrying on of the hospitals—power of criticism. My intervention on the last amendment, rather than on this amendment, arose from the fact that when criticism was offered and information was asked by the Leader of the Opposition on the last amendment there was none forthcoming and we had a situation where the Parliamentary Secretary was sitting dumb, completely ignoring the request for information or the criticism that was made on the proposals in the measure. I do not see that it is any great advantage to a member of the House to get power to ask for information or to offer criticism with a spirit like that and I do not think the House can be satisfied to accept the position as shown in Section 10.

Deputy Hurley asked the Parliamentary Secretary how he proposes to form the board. I think it might have been a help if, in dealing with the previous amendment, the Parliamentary Secretary had given some information as to how he proposes to form the board. My proposal here is that the board will be formed on the same lines as at the present time; that is, that there will be a statutory provision by which at least one-third of the board will be drawn from the surgical and medical staff and additions to the board, the filling of vacancies, will be carried out by the board as a whole, as they do at the present time, and as they have done ever since 1922. They usually nominate a person to fill the vacancy and then they get the Minister's consent to that.

I should like to add that there is provision under amendment No. 15 to enable the Minister to keep in complete touch with the board, and the way in which the work of the hospitals and of the officers and servants of the board is being carried out. Under amendment No. 15 the Minister may by order direct a medical officer from the Department of Local Government and Public Health to attend meetings of the board and the board shall afford to such medical officer, when so directed, reasonable facilities in obtaining necessary information. That puts the Minister into the most satisfactory possible position to supervise the work and to see what is being done, if he has any reason for considering that he should supervise the work at close quarters. It leaves him completely free from any personal responsibility for the bad carrying on of the hospital by reason of the fact that he has appointed the board.

Comment on this

The section in the Bill, as it stands, empowers the Minister, by order, to provide for the following matters: the number of members of the board and the method of appointment of such members. In the first paragraph of Deputy Mulcahy's amendment, the Minister would be under a statutory obligation to constitute the board in such a way that one-third of the membership would be drawn from the medical staff.

Comment on this

That is not less than one-third.

Comment on this

I agree that the representation of the medical staff on the board of governors is desirable, but I do not agree that the Minister should be under a statutory obligation to give the medical staff one-third of the total membership. Such a concession would be a curtailment of the statutory powers which the Minister holds at the present time in relation to the management of this institution. It is to be remembered that the functions of the first board to be appointed will be confined entirely to the provision of the new hospital, and clearly the constitution of such a board would be very different from the final constitution of a board to be charged with the duty of administering the institution. On a board whose functions and duties would be confined to the provision of the new hospital, you might well require a much higher proportion of technical advisers than of administrators. The reverse might hold on the governing body of an institution that was already there. You might, indeed, and probably it would be desirable, have other technical advice than medical advice.

The second paragraph of Deputy Mulcahy's amendment provides for the method of nomination by the existing governing body or of suitable persons that would be prescribed by order, and for the submitting of two alternative nominations in respect of each appointment. That would hand over to the board the right of nomination, so that the board would have the sole right of nomination to the Ministry. As I see things, that would not be desirable, because outside bodies, other than the board of governors, will ultimately have representation on the board of governors. Provision will have to be made when this hospital is being established, for representation from the Dublin Corporation, for example, or the Dublin Board of Assistance, when the time is reached that the new hospital will be taking charge of a big proportion of the patients that are at present provided for in St. Kevin's Hospital, and, clearly, the Minister must be free to provide for nomination by such a body as the Dublin Corporation, or possibly by other social organisations that may be deeply interested in the administration of such an institution. As I have said, it is desirable that the medical staff should be closely associated with the management of the institution, but I do not think it is desirable that a statutory obligation should be put upon the Minister to give a minimum of one-third of the entire personnel of the board to its medical staff.

Comment on this

Again, the Parliamentary Secretary's contribution marks the half-baked proposals that are being presented to the House. All of us have been led to suspect that there are definite proposals in the Parliamentary Secretary's mind, but in so far as an outline of them is given in his words in the House, they are certainly very half-baked indeed. We are told now that the board, under Section 10, is not going to be the board that will run the hospital, but is to be one that will have just one task in front of it, namely, the building of the new hospital. It will not even have the job of acquiring the site. The Parliamentary Secretary is to do that himself. If he has given any consideration at all to this, can he not tell the House now what kind of a board he thinks ought to be set up for the purpose of seeing that the new hospital is built? Will he say what difficulty he has in letting us know what kind of a board he has in mind for seeing that the new hospital should be built?

Comment on this

I do not think any Bill that has come before the House ever had so many hateful complications as this, or in respect of which so many hateful admissions have had to be made. The Parliamentary Secretary's view is that you must have one body appointed to build the hospital and a different body to administer it. Who is going to have the primary responsibility in the new hospital? Obviously, the surgical and medical staff. Why not charge them from the first with responsibility for the kind of hospital they are going to have? One would imagine from the Parliamentary Secretary's statement that it is only from Departments of State that anything in the nature of efficiency can come. What is the Parliamentary Secretary's own record in connection with the building of hospitals through the country? He has had one hospital constructed and completed without any water supply, and in another, in a different part of the country, there is no method for the disposal of sewage. There was another in which the rain was coming down and the Minister sent down an official in dry weather to inspect it. Obviously as there is no rain in dry weather, no rain was coming down when the inspector went there. Having regard to that fact the Minister, his advisers and his whole system of regimentation does not commend itself to me. Here is the case in which, as has already been pointed out, the surgical and medical staff will be ultimately responsible. Who is responsible for the construction of the Mayo clinic in America? Did the Minister find a separate board set up by the State to deal with that matter? He certainly did not. This board of governors has in its line of succession from its previous controlling bodies as fine a hospital in this State as there is in any other. But that governing body is not to be trusted to build another hospital. The body that in a time of stress was able to keep its hospital doors open—doors that would otherwise be closed—is not to be trusted now to build the new hospital.

Has the Minister made any inquiries of the surgical and medical staffs of other hospitals and of persons interested in other hospitals as to what is the ideal arrangement? If he does he will get an admission from quite a number of medical and surgical members of the staffs of other hospitals that the particular constitution of this governing body is one that appeals to the whole of them. For what reason? Obviously matters that should go before the governing body would be matters for which they had agreement with the surgical and medical staffs before these matters come to the board. Accommodation is almost settled before it goes to the governing body. At all events something comes up which has been the subject of serious consideration previously. It is recommended by the body as a whole.

What is needed in this case is harmony between those charged with the very serious responsibility of administering those hospitals. What is the position under the new dispensation? First of all there is the Minister; next there are his nominees, the Hospitals Commission, then the Minister's officials, and the existing governing body of the new body charged with the responsibility merely of building the hospital and leaving it there. There is no responsibility on them afterwards. It is to be subsequently administered by three bodies. The Minister's functions will be entirely confined to the provision of the new hospital and clearly the constitution will be very different from the final constitution which will be charged with the duty of administering the institution. It would really seem as if the Minister were considering something in the nature of a Chinese puzzle. He trusts nobody. He has no ultimate confidence in anybody. The old body will administer it, the new body will build the hospital and in a year or two there will be another body administering it. The thing is ridiculous. The Minister should re-write the Bill.

Comment on this

I ask the Parliamentary Secretary would be tell the House what kind of body he proposes to set up for the purpose of building this hospital.

Comment on this

I cannot give the constitution of the board which it is proposed to set up under the Bill until the Bill has been passed.

Comment on this

Again I ask the Parliamentary Secretary who is putting a Bill here before the House and who, under this section certainly is presenting as nice a Chinese puzzle as anyone could put into a section of a Bill, just to tell the House what the position actually is. He comes here and tells us he wants these powers, that there is an hospital to be built but that until the Bill is passed through five stages in the Dáil and is afterwards passed through five stages in the Seanad that he is not going to open his privileged mouth to tell us what kind of a board he is setting up to see that this hospital is built. I ask the Parliamentary Secretary again to tell us what kind of a board it is proposed to set up to see that this hospital is built?

Comment on this

Nobody has asked the Parliamentary Secretary to reveal the names of the members of the first or subsequent board at this stage. But it is a matter of some importance that we should know the lines upon which he is thinking what type of representation will be given? Will the representation be on the basis of the medical staff, the Dublin Corporation, or the board of public assistance? Will any effort be made to get representation for persons representative of the generality of the patients who use the hospital, or will any effort be made to get representation for certain social organs or for the workers who will form the bulk of the patients in the new hospital? That is not asking the Parliamentary Secretary to reveal any Governmental secrets, but I think we are entitled to ask him to take the House into his confidence and let us know the lines on which his mind is working.

Comment on this

The board that will be constituted for the purpose of building the new hospital will, I believe, be largely, perhaps entirely, drawn from the most active members of the present board of governors. Then the hospital will be provided, but it will be a considerable number of years before it will be ready. The question of a wider representation will then be examined. The board, I think, that is in mind will have first representation for the corporation, then for social and other organisations intimately interested in the administration of the institution.

Comment on this

The accommodation in this particular hospital is not very extensive. I am informed now that the position will be that you will have the existing governing body, and when its business is concluded you will have your new board. If that is the case, surely it ought to be possible now to get accommodation from the board; it ought to be possible for the present Minister to get suggestions from them. It ought to be possible to ask them to make suggestions and have one board there right from the start so that the body from the beginning would be responsible for the building of the new hospital and ultimately for administering it. If we take the Minister's statement the constitution would be very different from the final constitution which would be charged with the duty of administering the hospitals. Surely the Minister does not want three boards. He tells us now that is what will happen. Has any approach been made to this governing body to see whether any accommodation could be reached between the Minister and them with regard to its constitution? There might not be a single member of the medical board on the governing body. We have no guarantee that the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary will be here this time 12 months or even in six months' time. There may be changes of personnel or of Government and the new Minister does not inherit the undertakings the Minister has given to the House or his obligations——

Comment on this

Or his wisdom.

Comment on this

The new Minister can have six boards instead of three boards.

Comment on this

The present Minister will not have three boards, as Deputy Cosgrave suggests.

Comment on this

He will have two.

Comment on this

These two will be one or, possibly, they will be replaced. It will largely be a matter of merger. It is desirable, perhaps, that we should have two boards. We should have a board of the usual type which will provide a new hospital. The existing Board of Governors will carry on the administration of the existing institution during the very considerable period that will elapse until the new hospital is built and ready for use.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary give an undertaking to the House that the medical members of the present board will be appointed to the new board? He can think over that and tell us on the Report Stage if he likes.

Comment on this

I will give an undertaking that a reasonable proportion of them will be appointed, but it may be a substantially smaller board for the purpose of building the hospital than the existing board of governors. Undoubtedly, there will be a reasonable proportion of the medical staff appointed, perhaps, indeed, a larger proportion than would be on the ultimate board.

Comment on this

I am putting forward the suggestion for this reason: I do not know whether this applies to the medical profession or not, but I suppose they have some of the ordinary infirmities that beset mankind. If a particular man is on one board and not on the other he may have a suspicion that the particular surgical or medical work he is engaged in may not be satisfactorily dealt with. I am putting forward that suggestion purely in the interests of harmony. I do not know the names of the members of that board, except one. Deputy Mulcahy has put down an amendment which ought to meet any of the difficulties that may arise in connection with this matter. He introduces a new principle with regard to membership of the board.

His amendment No. 15 proposes:—

The Minister may by order direct a medical officer from the Department of Local Government and Public Health to attend meetings of the board and the board shall afford such medical officer when so directed reasonable facilities in obtaining necessary information.

My own impression is that such a medical officer would have more influence than a majority on the board. Whatever he would have to say would be listened to with respect and consideration and every effort would be made to accommodate him. He would have first-class information. The members of the board would share their confidence with him and he with them. That would have a much more harmonising influence than the Minister's proposal of inspections, etc.

Comment on this

Might I mention to the House and to Deputy Cosgrave in particular that, so far as harmonising influences are concerned complete harmony has existed between the Department and the board of governors on this question? This debate has certainly been anything but harmonious and it does not reflect the relationship that has existed and which we hope will continue to exist between the Department and the board of governors. Perhaps if there were less of that kind of interference there would be less chance of endangering the harmonious relations which have existed.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that. I would be glad to hear it also from the other side. There are always two parties to a bargain. I should like to know from the Parliamentary Secretary if his conception of a representative here is that he should accept every word that falls from the benches over there and every recommendation and say "Thank you" for whatever he is told.

Comment on this

I do not suggest that at all.

Comment on this

We are in danger of getting into that position.

Comment on this

The most inharmonious things in the discussion of this Bill from the day it was introduced were not the words spoken by any section of the House but the words left unspoken by the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

The ones spoken by some Deputies were certainly bad enough for anything.

Comment on this

They were not bad enough to fill the gaps left by the Parliamentary Secretary in his contributions to this discussion. We did manage to squeeze a few words out of him. We now know that there is going to be some representation of the medical staff on the special body to be set up to deal with the building of the hospital. I do not know that very much more was squeezed out.

Comment on this

I do not take kindly to squeezing.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary cannot offer to do his Parliamentary duty by subjecting himself to that kind of process, he ought to invent some kind of process by which he can do his Parliamentary duty and give us the information to enable an intelligent and therefore harmonious discussion of things to take place. But from the way in which we have been treated from the opening of this Committee Stage, not to speak of the Second Stage, we are left in the position that we cannot get any information on any of these sections except by pounding it out of the Parliamentary Secretary and then we only get an odd grunt of information from him. We have not got any reasonable explanation as to why there should be a special committee for the building of this hospital and why there should be another committee to administer it. We are only left to imagine, from the beautiful subtlety of Section 10, that that section provides for the doing of the one and the other. We are simply left to infer that. But, from the Parliamentary Secretary's remarks, the Minister retains the power of doing anything he likes with regard to this board and he will not accept any kind of modification of this power.

The Parliamentary Secretary says it will be necessary, some time in the far distant future when the hospital is built, to have representatives of the Dublin Corporation on the board. If this hospital will not be built until some far distant date, I cannot understand why the necessary discussions between the various bodies involved have not taken place, a definite principle established, and plans arranged before this House was asked to discuss a Bill drafted in this way, and before it was asked, as a result of unsatisfactory consideration of the matter, to go through the type of discussion we have had to-day.

Comment on this

It seems to me to be a very unsatisfactory position that we have reached at this late hour on this matter. We started off with a statement from the Parliamentary Secretary that he could not allow his mind to wander over the details of such things as the people who were to be on the board until he got the power of appointment. That, if it were true, would mark him down as a person of limited intelligence who could not speculate as to the type of people who should be appointed, or the categories from which he would select certain people for the board until he has power to establish it. His argument was so unsatisfactory and so lacking in persuasion that the Parliamentary Secretary abandoned it. We were afterwards told by him, by this odd process of extracting information that has gone on, that there was to be a board immediately set up after the establishment date whose main duty would be the building of the hospital. We were told that that board, having different functions, would have a different position from the board which would administer the hospital. Then, a little later, by a still further painful process of extraction we got these words:—

"Those who are considered the most active members of the present board."

That would be at a time when that board will be operating with the existing governing body still alive. Later, when the existing governing body is defunct, on the transfer date, there will be a new body instituted to run the hospital. That will be a larger board and will have to make provision for outsiders. It is lamentable, to my mind, in this particular year of grace, that we should be considering the appointment of local representatives on a hospital board.

I should like to have an example given me of any such board on which local representatives have been worth their appointment. I know that they have been on certain boards rather a distraction. They may bring in a point of view which may be very proper and necessary in local affairs, but the point of view they bring in in any board that I know of is that they are a complete distraction and serve no useful purpose. Yet, apparently, we are at the point when we are going to have, not merely Ministerial interference but provision for local appointments on the board. The only consolation I get is that we have reached this point of recognition of one board, that the Minister let the cat out of the bag, when he said that there will be many days before this hospital will be built. I believe that is the soundest thing that was said. I am still querying where are the funds from which this hospital will be built, where they are located, where they can be easily dislodged, and whether the dislodgment of any of such a large amount would do the fund any harm. I want to know when it is proposed that any money will be let loose for building any hospital. I think the most satisfying thing was the statement that it would be a long, long time before it would be built. I hope it will be longer even than the Parliamentary Secretary thinks.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted, stand."

Tá 44
·
Níl 23
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 10:

In sub-section (1) (a) (v) page 6, line 4, to add after the word "members" the words "by the remaining members".

This amendment provides that, when the Minister makes his principal order, the terms of the order will be such that, when casual vacancies have to be filled, they will be filled by vote of the remaining members of the board.

Comment on this

This amendment is calculated, like many of the others, to curtail the Minister's powers. Apart from that objection, by the constitution of the board certain bodies, such as Dublin Corporation, may be entitled to representation. It would be wrong that the board, as a whole, if a vacancy occurred by the death, resignation or other withdrawal of a member who had been appointed or nominated by the corporation, should appoint his successor. If the corporation nominated in the first instance, they should be the nominating body in the second instance. Whether other organisations than Dublin Corporation will have a right of nomination I cannot definitely say at the moment. I am opposed to the amendment on the general principle that it is a further effort to deprive the Minister of powers which he enjoys at present.

Comment on this

The 1856 lot.

Comment on this

I am opposed in principle to being side-tracked in putting up a proposal by talk about things that are not in the section. When I see Dublin Corporation or some such body in the section, then I will be able to harmonise my amendments with that position. I think the section should be amended to give at least that amount of power to the board—that casual vacancies be filled by the board itself.

Comment on this

It appears from what the Parliamentary Secretary says that he considers himself and his successors honest, but that he regards the board to be set up with his imprimatur as not to be trusted to do what he or they would do. Obviously, if there was a vacancy on the board amongst the representatives of Dublin Corporation or any social institution, the governing body would communicate with the corporation or the body concerned and get their nomination. Why is it to be assumed that the board will not act as impartially as the Minister? The Minister will nominate them. He will have confidence in them. Why should they not be given the autonomy which the responsibility of their office and the confidence the Minister reposes in them warrant? It is unfortunate that we should start off with such suspicion of the board. It is very unlikely that the board will depart from one of the unwritten rules in connection with representation. The filling of a casual vacancy is not a very important matter. Even where politics run riot, there is an honourable understanding between persons that an agreement arrived at will be carried out. While the Dáil had the filling of vacancies in the Seanad, before the Minister's Party came into the House, that was an unwritten rule which was generally accepted and acted upon. Why should it not be acted upon in this case?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is not amendment No. 10 governed by the decision on amendment No. 9?

Comment on this

It is an entirely different matter.

Comment on this

It is an addition. The other amendment was a subtraction and an addition.

Comment on this

I understood the Ceann Comhairle to rule that these two amendments stood together.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would like to be informed of the meaning of the phrase "remaining members."

Comment on this

If there are 12 members and one resigns, the 11 members would sit down and, in their wisdom, select the twelfth member, after communicating with the outside body concerned.

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) meets the point put by the Parliamentary Secretary. If they belonged to different classes, and one member died, the vacancy would be filled by the remaining members of that class. Every point he has mentioned is met by that.

Comment on this

The section, as it stands, with amendment No. 10, would mean that the Minister in his principal order would provide for the number of members of the board, would provide for the method of appointment of members, would provide the term of office, would provide for resignation and disqualification and for the way in which casual vacancies would be filled among such members by the remaining members of the board. He would outline the period that would elapse and the arrangement that would be made for selecting a person to fill the vacancy, and that would be done by the remaining members of the board.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Should it not read "the filling of such casual vacancies amongst such remaining members"?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

In this matter we are merely endeavouring to help the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is the Parliamentary Secretary prepared to accept that help?

Comment on this

I am not disposed to accept the help. Deputy Cosgrave complains that the new body is not to be trusted. I could suggest, on the other hand, that the Minister ought to be trusted. If a new body or, for that matter, the present body, have not the powers that Deputy Cosgrave proposes to give them, I suggest the Minister has those powers and, if there is any distrust, in what direction is it? I say it is the distrust of the Minister, when Deputies opposite refuse to leave vested in him the powers he at present possesses.

It is regrettable that we should start off, as Deputy Cosgrave says, in an atmosphere of suspicion; but the atmosphere of suspicion, I suggest, has been created by Deputies opposite. They have created suspicion around the actions of the Minister; what he may do and how he may use the powers vested in him, powers that have been possessed for a number of years and which never have been abused in the past. If we are to start off in a better atmosphere and have honourable understandings, trust and confidence ought to extend to the Minister as well as to other people.

Comment on this

This is the usual debating trick. Distrust is immediately suggested whenever an objection is taken to a point of principle. This is not a question of distrusting the Minister in the sense that he will abuse the powers given to him, but the objection is rather in the sense of showing that it is not a proper function for any Minister to have. There are certain powers vested in the Minister. Again we have a certain stress placed upon the word "vested" and there is no stress on the word "exercised". The reality of the situation has been that the casual vacancies have been filled by co-option and the Minister signs on the line. That has been the practice, and I deny contradiction on that point.

As regards vesting, the powers are there in abeyance. I thought the argument might have been advanced that it would be good to have them there because of a possible abuse of its powers by the board. That, of course, would be distrust of the board, and the Parliamentary Secretary would not have such a thought in his head. In 1856 certain powers were vested in a Lord Lieutenant and those powers now come down to the Minister. When the Lord Lieutenant had those powers vested in him there was this consideration, that the State was putting up money. The position was that he could carry on certain vested powers which have, in fact, fallen into disuse at a time when we are having such a fundamental change as now. It is really a question of the Minister getting money which was subscribed by the people who took tickets in the Hospitals Sweepstakes and he is going to divert some of that money to a particular hospital. It is not costing the State anything. He pilfers some part of the fund built up by the subscribers to the sweepstakes. He decides now that he wants the powers that were once given to the Lord Lieutenant under the Act of 1856. I suggest that the circumstances have entirely changed. Of course, this may be considered a very small point.

The other argument apparently has been dropped, the argument in regard to a vacancy on the Dublin Corporation. In case it does come about, we are told that if there was a casual vacancy on the Dublin Corporation, then the remnant of that lot ought to be allowed to reappoint in the case of that vacancy. That is all possible under Deputy Mulcahy's amendment. If we take paragraph (b) of Section 10 we find that the Minister may divide the members of the board into such and so many classes as he thinks fit and make different provisions in respect of different such classes. There is the overriding consideration that the remaining members of a class will co-opt to the casual vacancy when one of a class dies or resigns. I object to any of these powers being given to a Minister, not because there is any question of distrust, but because I think it is not a function that should be given to a Minister in these days. It is not a personal matter; it is a matter of principle.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary indicated that these powers were vested in the Lord Lieutenant. We are accepting that. He always took a nomination from the board, and so it happened for a period of ten years. Now, according to what the Parliamentary Secretary tells us, we are going to depart from that and it is no longer to be a question of nomination by the board. We ask why, and the Parliamentary Secretary says the Minister is not to be trusted. Is it any wonder he is not, because he proposes to depart from what has been the practice for 84 years, and for no good reason?

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 21
·
Níl 44
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 14, standing in the name of Deputy Norton:

Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(4) Every order made by the Minister under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as conveniently may be after it is made, and if a resolution annulling such order is passed by either House of the Oireachtas within the next subsequent 21 days on which that House has sat after such order is so laid before it such order shall be annulled accordingly but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under such order.

I do not think this amendment requires very much explanation as it is self-explanatory, and I trust the Minister will see his way to accept it. It aims at preserving the authority of the House in any action taken by the Minister. He has been vested with very wide powers and I trust that any such order which the Minister may make will have the sanction of the House. I think that would be of assistance to the Minister himself as well as preserving the control of the House. He would be sure that he was acting with the approval of the majority of the members of the House. In view of recent legislation it is necessary to have such safeguards, and I do not think there is anything objectionable in asking that the Minister should be subject to the principle of democracy and of the democratic control of the House and that orders be tabled here for consideration of the members. Then, if a majority of the House wishes to annul them it should be within their privilege to do so. I ask the Minister to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I have no rigid objection to the proposals contained in the amendment, but I have some doubts as to the desirability of opening up discussion in the House on the constitution of the board. It must be remembered that very many organisations will be seeking election to the board and will have to be disappointed. Already, many social organisations have made representations to the Department as to the desirability of giving them representation on the board of governors.

In all probability the list is not yet exhausted. I have a sufficiently open mind on it, but if we are to have discussions in this House as to the rights of various organisations to representation, and their prior claim to other organisations that have got representation, I have some doubt as to whether it would be in the interests of the institution. However, if there is a strong feeling in the House that it is desirable to have these orders laid on the table, I am open to persuasion.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary when he anticipates that he will issue his first principal order?

Comment on this

It is rather difficult to give any reliable indication of that inasmuch as the order will not be made until after the site has been acquired. I cannot indicate to the House at present how long it may take to acquire the site. Clearly, the views of many interested parties will have to be very carefully considered and the field will have to be fully surveyed before a decision on the matter can take place, but I assure the Deputy and the House that so far as the Department is concerned we are anxious to get on as rapidly as we can.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 43
·
Níl 19
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Does Section 11 refer to the two different kinds of boards?

Comment on this

It refers to the new board. The old board carries on until the new board takes over.

Comment on this

I understand that there is provision to the effect that the governing body shall give facilities to the new body and provide accommodation. Would it not be well to amend this section in some such way as that the board, after consultation with the Minister, shall do so and so? Obviously, the Minister does not want to have any clash with the existing body, which may meet on a particular day. I think it would be advisable to have some sort of understanding to prevent the two meetings taking place at the same time.

Comment on this

Yes, but surely it is not necessary to incorporate that in the statute. Before fixing a day for the meeting of the new board, the Minister can find out whether there is any question of a clash taking place. I hardly think it is necessary to put that in here.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this

Sub-section (6) of this section says that whenever at the election of chairman of the board, there is an equality for two or more persons, one of these persons shall be elected by lot. What is meant by "lot?" Does it mean just tossing a penny?

Comment on this

I could not tell the Deputy what is the legal definition of "lot," but I think it is usually done by a draw.

Comment on this

By drawing what?

Comment on this

Oh, two bits of straw, I suppose, if you happened to be short of anything else.

Comment on this

Suppose they have not any straw?

Comment on this

Then they might have bits of string to pull.

Comment on this

That would be more like it—strings to be pulled.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:—

Before Section 15 to insert a new section as follows:—

The Minister may by order direct a medical officer from the Department of Local Government and Public Health to attend meetings of the board and the board shall afford to such medical officer when so directed reasonable facilities in obtaining necessary information.

This was meant to be part of a scheme suggested in my amendments Nos. 9 and 10, but since the Parliamentary Secretary has not seen his way to accept these amendments, I do not think the necessity for amendment No. 15 arises.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16, standing in Deputy McGilligan's name:—

In sub-section (1), page 7, to delete paragraph (a).

This is one of a series of amendments dealing with matters which it was hoped would not be insisted upon. The sub-section says:

"Subject to the provisions of this section, the board shall not, without the consent of the Minister ..."

and then goes on to state the various things which the board cannot do without his consent. That is a particularly delaying kind of procedure. Suppose the board wishes to appoint certain officers. The positions concerned may be quite unimportant, and yet the board has to await the sanction of the Minister before making an appointment. I think it is putting the board in the position of a board of guardians or a board of health, and I do not know why it is intended to do so. There must be some particular reason that the Parliamentary Secretary has in mind but, as it stands, if the board required the services, presumably, of even an office boy, they would have to wait for the Minister's sanction. Surely it is not intended that in a case of that sort the sanction of the Minister should be required. If it were the case of appointing, let us say, an architect, does the Minister intend in that case that he should be informed of the name of the proposed architect in order to consider whether or not he will approve of the appointment, and delay proceedings in that manner? I think the Parliamentary Secretary should explain to us what is his own idea with regard to that.

Comment on this

If this amendment were accepted it would empower the board to appoint officers without reference to the Minister. In sub-section (2) of Section 15 the Minister is empowered to exclude, by order, officers to whose appointment Ministerial sanction would not be necessary. It is intended to retain the power and right of sanction in so far as important officers are concerned, but with regard to minor officers, after consultation with the board and, I hope, by friendly arrangement, minor officers will be excluded under sub-section (2) from the scope of Ministerial sanction.

Comment on this

But the Minister can immediately revoke any exclusion order made and thus bring every officer again under his control?

Comment on this

The Minister has complete control. There is no question about that.

Comment on this

Yes, and that is what this amendment is aimed against. I move to report progress.

Comment on this