Private Deputies' Business. - Economic Council—Motion.
Contributions 1–164 of 327. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move the motion in the names of Deputy Davin and myself:—
That in view of the dislocation of industry and consequent increase in unemployment due to the emergency situation, the Dáil requests the Government forthwith to set up an economic council to plan measures to deal with the situation.
In proposing this motion, I do not desire that it should be discussed in any acrimonious Party fashion. The object of the Labour Party in submitting this motion is to endeavour to awaken the public to a realisation of the serious economic situation confronting the country and to focus the attention of the public and, if possible, the attention of the Government on the entire futility of the methods which so far have been adopted for dealing with the situation which confronts us. I believe that those methods, effete and useless as they were in peace times, will be found to be still more useless in the days of trial and tribulation which lie ahead.
This motion is addressed to a threefold problem: (1) the dislocation of industry; (2) increasing and widening unemployment; (3) the complete absence of a plan to deal with our war-time difficulties and the apparent absence of a plan to deal with the post-war situation. I suppose it might be relevant at this stage to ask ourselves are these three problems with us. Are we face to face to-day, for instance, with dislocation in industry? Have we to face up to and are we obliged to solve an increasing and widening unemployment problem? Have we a plan for dealing with the situation which has arisen within the country and the new situation which will arise in a more intensive form in the post-war situation?
I think it is only necessary to put these questions to ourselves in order to find a ready answer. Statements have been made at meetings of Chambers of Commerce throughout the country, statements have been made at meetings of public companies in which very strong emphasis was laid on the shortage of raw materials. It has been explained that that situation has inevitably brought about the repercussion that large numbers of staff have been laid off and there have been prognostications of further considerable unemployment in industry. At a recent meeting of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce the chairman stated that there was a possibility that within eight months one-third of the population of Éire would be unemployed. In the course of his speech he indicated further that the reserve stocks of raw materials in many cases would not last longer than from three to eight months. He added that the man in the street did not appear to realise the position and that it was time that the Government took the man in the street into its confidence.
Statements of that kind which have been made ad nauseam at meetings such as I have referred to, indicate in the most unmistakable fashion that, so far as those who are charged with production are concerned, they see the red flag up. They realise that there is a shortage of, and a difficulty in obtaining raw materials. When a man, who occupies an eminent position in the commercial and industrial life of the city, with all his authority goes on record as saying that there is a possibility that within eight months one-third of the entire population of Eire would be unemployed, it is a very serious position,
But we had an even more surprising admission recently in the annual report of the Federation of Irish Manufacturers. Referring to the supply position, the federation's report stated:—
"From the beginning of the war the federation has taken a grimly realistic attitude towards the problem of supply, has assumed that the very worst would happen, and has constantly demanded the most extreme measures, being confident that finances were available and that the full powers of the State could be mobilised in the early stages of the war to lessen, as far as possible, the adverse effects of the acute shortage now becoming apparent."
The report of the federation goes on to make reference to the scarcity of raw materials and their efforts to awaken the Government to the dangers that lay ahead; it emphasises the necessity for the compulsory mobilisation of waste materials on which apparently nothing was done by the Government, the necessity of obtaining a dollar exchange to enable us to purchase raw materials in America, of the necessity of a mercantile marine and of the urgency of that problem for a long time before the report was written. The report winds up with two very interesting observations.
"The council of the federation further suggested that the Government should make a more active examination, with the aid of scientific experts, of native substitute materials, which, while possibly uneconomic in peace time, might prove invaluable in time of war."
It then adds:—
"Having stated the federation's position, it is obviously no use continuing what is in reality an inquest on deficiencies which up to now have been apparent in that part of our national economy concerned with securing deliveries for our national needs."
The signature to that report is that of the secretary to the federation— Deputy Childers. I congratulate him on the very outspoken views which he expresses in that report, and on the very valuable survey it contains of our economic position.
Comment on this
On a point of order. These views were the views expressed to me, and dictated to me, by my federation. I was simply acting there in a professional capacity.
Comment on this
I have no doubt the Deputy was so acting. I have no doubt also that the views dictated to him were very excellent views. They are views that might be adopted with profit by anybody. No one need be ashamed of having expressed them. They are views that mirror completely the chaotic industrial position that exists here to-day — a shortage of raw materials in most industries, inability to procure these raw materials from any source, apparently no foresight in dealing with the problem, and no planning for easing the situation.
One has got to realise, when considering matters of this kind, the interrelationship of one industry with another, and the tied-up character of our commercial and industrial activities. We have seen recently the effects on industry, on commerce, on agriculture and on employment generally of the shortage of petrol which caused not merely an immediate loss of employment to men in garages, to men in private employment who depend for their employment on activities in connection with motor transport, but we have seen that it results in the disemployment of men engaged in a variety of, apparently, unrelated occupations in industry and commerce. Just like the stone thrown into the centre of a pool, that shortage of petrol radiated unemployment right throughout the entire State. If men are going to lose their employment through a shortage of petrol, through a shortage of raw materials which sustain our people in employment, then a very serious situation is going to arise here from an employment point of view. Men who lose their employment cannot pay their rents or instalments due on furniture. They cannot fulfil their house purchase contracts, they cannot pay for their groceries, for boots and for clothes, and, in the end, their idleness in turn leads to the disemployment of people engaged in these other activities.
A visit to the employment exchange in Gardiner Street to-day, will be sufficient to remove doubts from the minds of the most prejudiced of the serious situation which is growing up in the country, not merely because of the number of unemployed but because of the new type of unemployment which has arisen out of the emergency situation. Men who formerly were in good and regular employment and able to enter into commitments to purchase houses and furniture, men who always paid their rents regularly and suffered no economic distress which necessitated the postponement of that obligation, are now thrown on the employment exchange, and the State, which ought to be concerned, having regard to its constitutional obligations, about safeguarding people in that position, is doing absolutely nothing. Those men are being compelled to allow their insurance policies to lapse, they are unable to pay the instalments due on their furniture, they are unable to pay their rents. Because they have fallen into arrear with their rents they are being evicted and driven down to a condition of depression never experienced by them heretofore.
The dislocation which has arisen has been due in great measure to the absence of an adequate mercantile marine such as might have served the nation efficiently and effectively in the present situation. Much of the dislocation could have been avoided if, in 1939, we had the foresight to purchase ships from the large number of neutral countries which then had ships and were ready and willing to sell them. It was not until towards the end of 1940, when the area of belligerency had been extended, and when there was practically no country which had any portion of its mercantile marine for sale, that we awoke to the necessity of having a shipping service of our own, and appeared to appreciate its indispensability in carrying to this country the goods and raw materials, needed to sustain life as well as our industrial and agricultural activity. Now, there is some concern about that. It is a belated kind of concern. One does not know even now whether, in fact, there is a genuine desire on the part of the Government in regard to it. We had a most amazing declaration made in this House recently by the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defensive Measures to the effect that, if all the ships in the world were at the bottom of the sea and if we used our brains, we could still have a good standard of life here. Surely, nobody believes that that is a sane policy for any Government to postulate for this country. Every country in the world regards shipping as indispensable and yet in this country with its negligible mercantile marine, we have a responsible Minister saying that it does not matter if all the ships in the world were at the bottom of the sea: that all we have got to do is to use our brains and that then everything will be all right.
Notwithstanding the fact that all the ships are reposing on the bed of the ocean, this Minister still thinks everything will be all right. We then had a statement from the Minister for Supplies which gives cause for doubt as to whether he, in fact, believes that the augmentation of our shipping fleet is desirable. His statement was to the effect that the purchase of ships and the utilisation of Irish ships might possibly have consequences for us which might impair our neutrality. Is that Government policy in respect to a mercantile marine? We ought to be told definitely where we stand in this matter. Do we believe, as the Minister for the Co-Ordination of Defensive Measures said, that if all shipping was at the bottom of the sea, everything would be all right, or are ships regarded as a danger to our neutrality as indicated by the Minister for Supplies in his speech? Are ships things of which we should rid ourselves in this emergency because one or two or 12 might be lost as a result of belligerent action elsewhere? Which of these viewpoints represents Government policy on this question of a mercantile marine? It seems to me that both are economically crazy, having regard to our circumstances. Consequently, we ought to have from the Government an authoritative statement on its policy in regard to the acquisition of ships and the augmenting of our present negligible mercantile marine. One does not know whether, in fact, the Government are serious in endeavouring to purchase ships. They were told in 1939 that they ought to purchase ships and at that time ships could have been bought. The Government knew that, but nothing apparently was done. Now, a half-hearted effort is being made to acquire ships. But everybody knows that the only ships that we can get to-day are unseaworthy junks and luggers which are situate at the far ends of the earth where we cannot even inspect them.
I want to say that I charge the Government with sheer inertia in failing in 1939 to survey the requirements of this country, and to examine its potentialities in the matter of supplying its own requirements. We were told at that time that a Department of Supplies had been established. We were told that the new Department was making efforts to obtain certain materials. We were told that it was to be the eyes and the ears and the brains of our economic and agricultural workshop. But we see now, in the early days of 1941, and we have seen it for many months past, that such activity as was undertaken by the Department of Supplies was of a very limited and puny character. A very short time after the war became intensified we are faced with difficulties which that Department and the Government generally had ample time to deal with if they were only serious in approaching the problem. We are short of materials now. We have been short of them for a long time, but everybody knows that for all of 1939 and for the first six months of 1940 we could have bought supplies in a large number of places without any difficulty whatever because then there was no great drain on the resources of other countries. Ships of many countries were plying the seas. Ships of many countries were available for hire, for sale, for lease, but during that period we appear to have rested on our oars, being treated to an occasional speech to the effect that things were all right. Our sense of security was rudely disturbed, however, by the declarations made in December last regarding a shortage of petrol followed by the declaration that tea was scarce and again by an intimation that we could not get coal, and that if we could get coal it was only the rubbishy quality that is coming in to-day.
If we had not sterling assets during that period, or if we could not get dollars, one might understand the difficulties that confronted us later on, but we had dollars then or could get them, or were entitled at all events to get dollars in exchange for our sterling assets, but we did not exploit that situation as we ought to have done, and did not, apparently, recognise the difficulties which were then naked before our eyes. We could then have utilised the assets which are now frozen in London for the purpose of importing a good deal of the commodities which we cannot get from any source now. Our position in respect of manufactured goods and raw materials so far as Britain is concerned is that we cannot get the materials we need and we cannot, of course, in those circumstances repatriate our foreign assets. Now, we have neither our money nor the materials to feed and clothe our people or to sustain our industries and agriculture. We could then have bought and stored, if we had only the foresight to do so, the materials that would be needed to tide us over the war period, but because we neglected that opportunity we are now paying the price in an increasing number of unemployed, in a substantially increased cost of living, and in a creeping despair and bleakness in the homes of tens of thousands of our people in this country to-day.
There is probably no better illustration of the complete absence of planning than is revealed by an examination of the food situation. It must have been obvious to the Government last harvest that there would be a shortage of wheat in this country this year. It must have been obvious, with only 300,000 acres under wheat, giving us approximately 300,000 tons of wheat while we needed approximately 650,000 tons, that we were bound to be in a serious position in respect of wheat production this year. Nothing was done in October; nothing was done in November; nothing was done in December. But, in January, the Government woke up to discover that we were not going to get any more foreign wheat, that we could not get ships to transport the wheat if we got it, that we could not get any re-exported from Britain, and that, consequently, we must rely entirely on our own resources in respect of wheat production.
Four very valuable months were allowed to pass before anything was done, and then we had panicky declarations in January and February on the necessity for growing wheat and other cereals, when with any foresight we might, towards the end of last year, have seen clearly that our wheat acreage was insufficient, and that there was necessity for a considerable increase in the acreage under wheat and other cereals if we were to feed ourselves independently of outside supplies. The campaign to grow more wheat should have been launched at the very latest in October, 1940, and even that might well be said to have been too late to put a comprehensive plan into operation, but instead of moving even in October nothing was done until January. Then there were panicky advertisements, panicky speeches, Ministers let loose all over the country, and other officials let loose to try to get county committees of agriculture to encourage local people to grow all the wheat and other cereals that it was possible for them to grow. That kind of panicky appeal never yields satisfactory results. Certainly, from the point of view of results, it is much to be deplored, when we could have put into operation a planned and systematic campaign such as is always calculated to yield satisfactory results.
Another example of the shortsightedness of the Government in respect of food supplies was revealed by the butter position. Last year, we exported tens of thousands of cwts of butter to Britain at a very low price, at a subsidised price. We had to pay a subsidy on those exports of butter to the British market. With the most unhurried leisure we proceeded to feed that butter out to another country; we are now paying, and have been paying for the past two months, and probably will be paying for another month or six weeks, for the folly of exporting butter which we urgently need for our own people. We have another example of it now in respect of potatoes. The Minister for Industry and Commerce would not disclose the figures this evening. Everybody knows perfectly well that there are substantial exports of potatoes from this country to-day. Somebody may try to defend that on the ground that they are seed potatoes. If those seed potatoes were in the country our own people would not be paying the fancy prices they are paying for potatoes to-day, and we have no indication whatever that even the supplies of seed potatoes in the country are sufficient to meet our requirements this year.
If we have seed potatoes available we ought to be putting them in Irish earth, instead of exporting them to other people while there is any possibility of utilising them for our own benefit. It will not surprise me to discover later in the year that there is a certain shortage of seed potatoes, which will show itself in difficulty in procuring them or substantially higher prices for those who require them. I think the Government has good grounds to feel concerned with the present food supply position.
Last minute and panicky efforts to augment the acreage under wheat and other cereals are not, I fear, going to give us all that we require in order to sustain our human and live stock population. Even if, by some adventitious circumstances, that does result, the Government appear to be planning from week to week and month to month; they do not appear to have any coordinated plan and apparently they do not intend to plan any distance ahead. Other countries in Europe are to-day planning for the years 1942 and 1943, and they are endeavouring to work to a programme which will ensure supplies of foodstuffs for a few years ahead. In this country, in contradistinction to that wisdom, we wake up in the month of January to an appeal to our people, notwithstanding our climatic conditions, to grow more wheat and other cereals, and there is no authoritative statement from the Government with regard to their agricultural plan.
The reply of the Minister for Supplies to-day with respect to the difficulty of obtaining ships indicates that we may have to depend entirely on our own production of food for our people. In circumstances of that kind it is surely good business to conserve for our people all the foodstuffs which they may need. We certainly ought not to have a repetition of the folly of last year when we exported butter at a time when our own people could not get butter, and we should not be exporting potatoes when there is a possibility that there will be a shortage of potatoes later in the year. The circumstances to-day are probably dissimilar in many respects to the circumstances that produced the famine of 1846 and 1847. It is true there was a potato crop failure in both of those years, but it is true also, as John Mitchel said, and as was proved by statistics, that, at the time we lost 2,000,000 of our population of 8,000,000 through starvation, we were producing sufficient food to feed a population of 18,000,000. We may well, by a shortsighted policy with regard to the conservation of food, produce a position in which, while we may grow more and harvest sufficient, our own people may not be able to get adequate supplies for which they now must rely on their own country because it is not safe to expect imports.
My main difficulty is to ascertain what is the precise policy of the Government. A short time ago the Minister for Agriculture, in Cork, said he did not know what to do with our agricultural produce if the British did not buy it. In every other country Governments are anxious to garner all the agricultural produce possible for the use and benefit of the people, but here we have the Minister for Agriculture saying that he does not know what to do with our agricultural produce if the British do not buy it. There are 300,000 Irish citizens who do not get a fraction of the Irish produce that good health and decent sustenance demand, and in those circumstances our Government might be well advised if they utilised our agricultural produce for the purpose of sustaining, in healthy life, our own population, rather than worry about exporting any of that agricultural produce to another country. It is that type of mentality, postulated in the speech of the Minister for Agriculture, that is going to commit us to a policy of sighing after a market to which to export goods that we may yet require for our own people.
Of course, everybody will understand that in our circumstances, due to our size, our geographical situation, and the fact that we are ill-equipped with regard to shipping, we may have to put up with a shortage of tea, a shortage of cocoa and coffee, and that we may not be able to get bananas and cocoanuts. These are not serious economic problems, if we have only the courage and vision to produce here the other commodities which we require for our people. We have a soil which enables us to produce fresh meat, vegetables, potatoes, pork, bacon, butter, milk, cream, jams, bread, cheese, eggs, lard and honey. If we can produce these commodities in quantities sufficient to enable our people to live, then we need not worry about the absence of such things as coffee and cocoa, and we can look with the completest indifference on a shortage of silk stockings, fur coats and tall hats. But we are not doing what we ought to be doing in the matter of utilising the fertility of our soil for the production of these commodities. Their production in abundance will mean a decent standard of life and a healthy existence for our people.
I have already indicated that this motion is directed to three problems. It deals, first of all, with the dislocation of industry and I think the quotations which I have given indicate that there is a very serious position developing in that respect. The motion is also aimed at focussing attention on the problem of unemployment. There is no Minister, no responsible Deputy and no responsible citizen who cannot but be gravely concerned with the unemployment position that faces us. The chairman of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce has indicated that, because of the shortage of raw materials, he could conceive a situation in which one-third of our population would be unemployed in eight months' time. Unfortunately, the fears which he expressed are already being borne out by the disemployment of substantial numbers of workers in various industries in Eire. The number of unemployed who registered at our employment exchanges last December is given as 96,000. That figure has since risen to over 100,000. Of course, figures taken at that time of the year are not necessarily an accurate guide to the number of persons really unemployed, because during that period the Board of Works inaugurates its rotational schemes which result in two sets of men being employed to do a job that would normally require one set in a particular week. You, therefore, get substantially reduced unemployment figures by reference to the December statistics.
The figures since December have risen rapidly and they would rise still more were it not for the order recently made by the Government cutting off tens of thousands of unemployed workers from assistance for the next six months. Let us examine the last figure relating to the unemployed— 105,000—and at the same time it would be well to remember that there has been a substantial exodus of our people to Belfast and Britain, that we have almost doubled the strength of our Army, and that the doubling of the Army has, in turn, caused a considerable increase in the number of civilian employees associated with the extended military establishments. Notwithstanding the artificial aids of migration, the absorption of large numbers of persons in the Army and the increase in civilian employment associated with the Army, we still have a hard core of unemployed represented by the figure of 105,000.
One might be inclined to say that that is a gigantic figure having regard to our circumstances and our population; but, when you add to it the dependents of those signing at the employment exchange, and when you add still further the numbers dependent on home assistance or outdoor relief and the numbers dependent on unemployed workers who are temporarily out of employment through illness and living on National Health Insurance, I think you will find that the roll-call of the unemployed in this State is approximately 300,000. That number represents approximately one-tenth of the entire population, but, obviously, substantially more than one-tenth of the industrial and agricultural population. That situation would be bad at any time. My complaint is that the difficulty is being intensified and aggravated by the complete absence of a plan to deal with that situation as we know it to-day. There appears to be no plan whatever and there appears to be no appreciation whatever of the still greater magnitude to which that problem may grow in the months that lie ahead.
We had a statement the other day from the Minister for Supplies, a statement which is in marked contrast with the speech he made in this House a few months ago, to the effect that we are facing a crisis of the first magnitude. That is the declaration now. The last authoritative declaration of the Minister concerned with the preservation of industries and with the procurement of raw materials for industries is that, in his view, we are facing a crisis of the first magnitude, but, notwithstanding that, there does not appear to be the slightest grain of evidence that the Government are facing up to the unemployment position which is going to flow, and to flow rapidly, from that crisis of the first magnitude. The ordinary unemployed man to-day may just trek off to the labour exchange to get the miserable pittance of his unemployment benefit or to try to get unemployment assistance, of which large numbers have been deprived for the past week and of which they will continue to be deprived for the next six months, but there is no evidence either in Ministers' statements or in any Governmental activity to indicate that there is a fragment of a plan for dealing with that situation.
We appear here in our relatively undeveloped circumstances to regard unemployment as something we are predestined to endure, as something which it is the destiny of the ordinary working-class man and woman to suffer, but if we could possibly make hunger as infectious as foot-and-mouth disease, I think we could rouse some people from their present state of indifference towards hunger and towards the sufferings of hungry men and women throughout the country. Under both Governments, unemployment has been looked upon as something from which we can never escape, as something about which we might talk at election times but make no effective effort to deal with between one election and another.
I took the trouble recently of calculating the cost of idleness to the country over the past 18 years in the loss of purchasing power and the capital value of emigrants who left this country since 1922 and I arrived at a figure, for that period of 18 years, in the vicinity of £800,000,000. If we had put these people into employment and had garnered for the nation productivity to that extent, we could have built 200,000 houses at £800 each and spent £200 on furnishing each of them; we could have electrified the railways at a cost of £50,000,000; we could have redeemed all the outstanding land annuities; we could have bought out every holding in the Gaeltacht under £10 valuation and afforested the whole area; we could have provided a substantial number of up-to-date hospitals, and parks for every town with a population over 7,000; and we could have rebuilt 2,000 national schools; and we could have bought and run a mercantile marine as big as those of Sweden and New Zealand together. But we are apparently quite happy to allow unemployment to remain with us and to try puny methods for dealing with it.
No reference to unemployment could be complete without a reference to the condition of poverty which is endured by a large number of persons who are registered as unemployed. At present, over the greater portion of the country, the maximum unemployment assistance paid is 14/- per week and a man with a wife and five children may have to live on that sum. If any Deputy reflects for a moment on the picture of life within a household where seven people have to live on 14/- per week, he will realise that the condition of life in such a household is a long way below the high ideals, the worthy ideals, set out in the new Constitution. For that family of seven persons, there is a sum of 14/- available, representing 2/- per day or ¾d. per meal. Can anybody imagine endeavouring to purchase a meal for ¾d., having regard to the cost of living to-day, or can anyone imagine a family of seven trying to exist for a day on 2/- for food alone, to say nothing about the necessity of paying rent, providing boots, clothes, furniture, domestic requisites, medicines, school books and all the other articles which ought to be the right of every person in a civilised community?
I want to ask the Government whether they intend that that situation should be allowed to continue, and whether they are satisfied to have a vast army of unemployed people in this country enduring a condition of life which is mirrored in the payment of that low subsistence rate by the unemployment exchange? I say to the Government in all friendliness that they are sitting on a powder barrel in respect of unemployment, and that it would be very unwise for them to carry on the present complacent policy in existing circumstances because the unemployment problem we have had in the past will be enormously intensified during the coming months, and apathy and indifference on the part of the Government at this stage will make it impossible to grapple with that problem as effectively as it ought to be grappled with, if we are to avoid the economic chaos which is going to follow from the intensification of the problem.
The other aspect of the matter to which this motion is addressed is the question of planning to deal with these wartime circumstances and planning for the post-war period. It is for the purpose of dealing with present problems and the problems which will arise following the war that we are anxious that a national economic council should be established. Everybody who has taken the trouble to read the declarations of statesmen in other countries will acknowledge that the one point upon which they all agree is that, after this war, a new order will enthrone itself on so much of civilisation as is then left. It must be clear to everybody that, having regard to the present gigantic expenditure on arms, the dislocation which has been caused to industry and agriculture and the complete uprooting of existing activities which will take place on return to peace, that the end of the war will be just the prelude to an intensified struggle for the means of livelihood. That will be particularly so in small countries such as ours where we have got neither the mechanical efficiency nor the tradition of technical skill necessary to make a speedy change to meet a new situation of that kind.
This new order, whether we like it or not, may well enthrone itself in Europe and elsewhere throughout the world and, just as in the matter of supplies, it will be quite impossible for us to imagine that we can ever escape its consequences or ensure ourselves against any of its repercussions here. We should be thinking about it; we should be keeping abreast of those countries that are thinking about it; we should be planning to-day to meet the situation which will follow on the conclusion of the war. But here, anxious to maintain a halcyon atmosphere, we have not even contemplated doing anything to face up to this world situation. We have no machinery for dealing with existing problems in an effective or comprehensive way. We do not appear to have even thought of the machinery we will need, or the thinking-box we will require, to adjust ourselves to the conditions that will supervene when peace does come. One might well be forgiven if, at this stage, one thought that the Government's policy was to leave this country as just an interesting survival of the civilisation that endured up to the outbreak of war in 1939. That civilisation in a post-war world will mean economic degradation for our people, will mean chaos in agriculture and industry, and will reduce the standard of living in this country substantially below even its present low level.
The motion which we have introduced seeks the establishment of a national economic council, because we are anxious that on its establishment it should be charged at once with the task of dealing with the worst evils which have flown from the war in Europe and that, when these problems are in hand, or concurrently with the application of a solution to these problems, the national economic council should also plan for the situation which will arise in the immediate post-war period. It may be urged on behalf of the Government that national economic councils are not practical things and that here it is quite unnecessary to establish such a council. Well, at one time, the Taoiseach used to believe that all this country needed was an economic council, a kind of economic G.H.Q., which would act as the eyes, the ears and the brains of our economic activities. If the scheme was worth advocating in 1931, it is as good to-day in 1941. There has been no vital change in our economic sluggishness in the meantime judging by the number of people who still have to register at the employment exchanges. The only thing that has happened is that the Taoiseach has changed his position in this House. What he regarded as something desirable and necessary in 1931, when he was in opposition, the Taoiseach apparently does not regard with the same urgency in 1941 when he is in office.
On the question of the practicability of the establishment of an economic council, there is abundant evidence to show that not only did such councils work and that not only can they be made to work, but that immediately prior to the present war, they were in operation in a number of countries in Europe. These were countries which are not as undeveloped as we are. These were countries the productivity of which was immensely greater than the productivity of this country. Economic councils were functioning in Belgium, Finland, France, Germany, Italy and even in China. The membership of these councils varied but they had, in all these countries, the same common function, namely, to act as a national planning authority. An examination of the reports issued by these councils from time to time and a survey of their work, by those who are interested, will show that they played an important part in the ordered planning and the ordered development of the nations over whose economic destinies they were given control. Why then is it not possible to establish a national economic council here? If it was possible for all these countries in Europe, much better developed than we are, with greater organic strength in the realms of industry and agriculture, to establish with profit these economic councils to plan ordered national development, what set of circumstances prevent the establishment of such a council here?
In August of last year when this matter was debated on the motion for the adjournment, we had from the Taoiseach the most surprising declaration he has ever made having regard to his previous utterances, that there was no need for a planning authority in this country because Ministers and their advisers are the natural planning authority. Even a cursory examination of a statement of that kind will show that it was not planning the Taoiseach had in mind but sheer bureaucracy, sheer totalitarianism, if the Minister and his immediate subordinates are to do all the planning that is necessary for this State and all our economic wisdom is to be wrapped up in their minds. We can have a Christian Constitution, a democratic Constitution. We can read fine words into the Constitution, we can fill every text-book with fine flowery phrases about it but when we come to decide upon methods of economic government, the only democracy we shall permit ourselves is the democracy of having a Minister and a few of his higher officials initiating, directing and supervising the entire economic development of the country. That is totalitarianism, not democracy; and a constitution which runs side by side with that condition of affairs is a travesty of democracy. Then, we had from the Taoiseach in August last this kind of rhythm: "If the economic council is not large, it will not be representative; and, if it is large, it will not work." Who could reason at all with a mentality of that kind? I confess that I am not able to reach to that high level of metaphysics—that an economic council which is not large will not be representative and that one which is large will not work. Then you are supposed, from the Taoiseach's declaration, to find something else which will not have these two objections —it is not to be large and it is not to be small. The Taoiseach only permits you to find something which is not large and which is not small, and which apparently must not be anything in between.
Other countries have managed to overcome their difficulties in this connection. Finland has an economic council numbering 20; Portugal has one of 20; Belgium, one of 35; France, one of 150; and Germany, one of 326.
Comment on this
Immediately prior to the recent war. I have not had any information from those countries since then, though the Minister for Industry and Commerce may have had. Apparently, all those countries can overcome their difficulties in the matter of such a council, untroubled by the personnel of the council. One country prefers a small one, another a large one, but with the Taoiseach it must not be large and it must not be small.
Comment on this
I did not say that, surely. What I said I stand over, but not the Deputy's interpretation.
Comment on this
I have read it very carefully. The example of what happened in other countries demonstrates clearly that there is no insuperable difficulty in the establishing of an economic council here. The only difficulty is that the Government, or certain Ministers of the Government, do not like to see one established, as they think it would be a rival to their activities— something that would impede them, something that would interfere with the kind of bureaucracy to which they are accustomed in the matter of their Departmental activities, something that would dispossess them of some of their power. If it is these considerations, and these only, the public should know why an economic council is not being established in this country.
We may be told, of course, by the Taoiseach, in the course of this debate, that, if you want an economic council, you must have a large one in order to make it representative; but the economic council which we envisage is not one similar in character to a Departmental advisory body which, in the nature of things, might well be concerned with intimate and routine details. The economic council which we envisage is a national planning authority, which would concern itself with the application of general solutions of problems, rather than the working out of the minute details which is the job of some other organisation to implement. In advocating the establishment of an economic council, we are anxious, therefore, that it should be a body which would plan nationally, that would think nationally, that it would seek and apply general solutions to our larger problems; that, having once given a direction, that direction would be implemented by such a staff as may be available, either in the council or in the Departments, to implement the policy decided upon. We do not desire that the council should in any way interfere with Governmental activities as such. Our desire is that it should be an advisory body, but that it should have considerable weight and standing, by the nature of its personnel. As has been shown to be practicable elsewhere, it may be either a large or a small body.
Comment on this
We would prefer that the council be a small body, but that those Ministers who are concerned with economic activities be represented.
Comment on this
I suppose the Minister wishes that the person selected be the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
Unless the Minister could be the economic council. Our desire is that the council should be a small body, with those Ministers concerned with economic activities represented on it. The report of the council, on any matter brought before it, should be treated with respect by the Government. It should not be treated as the Banking Commission's Report has been treated, nor as the Minister for Industry and Commerce treats the Transport Tribunal Report.
Comment on this
It is not our desire that the council should be a rival to the Government or a rival to the Minister. That might satisfy the vanity of some Ministers. Our desire is that it be an economic counterpart of the Governmental and legislative machine, and that it would work hand in hand with the Government, endeavouring to deal with the special tasks allocated to it, to find the best possible solutions for problems and to submit those solutions to the Government for consideration. Our desire is that the council be charged primarily with the carrying out of a national survey, and that its especial task be to plan the development of our resources and the strengthening of our economic life
In the circumstances under which we are living to-day, we would desire that no hoary traditions be allowed to stand in the way of that council's exploring every possible avenue in the fields of industry, agriculture and finance. In such a manner, they may find a solution for the problems which have left us a legacy of over 100,000 hungry men and women and a notion of starvation represented by 300,000 unemployed and at present unemployable people. Of course, we realise that a council of this kind necessarily must be charged with a particular task and that, at the outset, it should accept certain defined principles. We would charge the council with the responsibility of intensifying agricultural production of a balanced character.
Comment on this
We would charge the council also with the task of retaining in this country the foodstuffs which are necessary to feed our human and live-stock populations. It should survey the industrial possibilities of the country, with a view to their exploitation in the existing circumstances for the benefit of our own people, especially in our present blockaded position. We would charge them also with the responsibility of accepting as an economic fact that idleness is waste and that the most effective way in which that waste can be combated is by the provision of useful work to the full extent of the resources of our country. We would charge the council also with responsibility for the organisation of prices, for the regulation of prices within the sphere of industry and agriculture, so as to ensure that farmers, industrialists and workers would secure a fair return for their labour or for their investments in these particular activities. We would charge the council, too, with the responsibility of organising credit to finance our new economic activities, unfettered by traditions of the past or by present financial practices.
It is a council on these lines which the Labour Party has in mind. To-day we have a choice of doing two things. We can plan on these lines, and, if we do, we can have ordered economic life. If we fail to do so, we will just have the same confusion and bewilderment and that intensified unemployment and continuance of the industrial and agricultural chaos which we have in this country to-day. It is to avoid a continuance of the latter catastrophe, it is to plan for the present difficulties, and for the greater ones that lie ahead, that we offer this motion to the House. I think that the Government, realising the dangers that lie ahead, realising the necessity for co-operation, and realising the necessity for careful planning and ordered development, even at this stage will accept the motion which has been proposed here to-day.
Comment on this
I beg to move the amendment standing in my name and that of Deputy McGilligan:—
To delete all words after the word "Dáil", and substitute the words "is of opinion that the Government should immediately reveal to the Dáil any plans already prepared by them to maintain employment, and relieve distress during the present period of emergency."
With Deputy Norton I think that it ought to be possible to discuss this matter without breaking any of the furniture, and before proceeding further with this discussion I want to thank him for the magnificent case he made for my motion before he mentioned the economic council. I should like to point out to Deputy Norton that the fact that we have a serious situation here, that it has been going on for a long time, that the Government have not faced up to it, and have shown no signs of doing so or of even examining what the situation is, and that they have failed up to the present to face up to these matters which are affecting the whole of our economic life and the well-being of our people, is no reason why the consideration of these important matters should be referred to any back room or to any small section of Deputies in this House rather than to the House as a whole, or that it should be referred to any body of outsiders. There is the present-day situation to be faced, and there is the future to be faced, but there is an additional case to be made against Deputy Norton's motion at the present time, and that is that we are immediately facing up to the consideration of the amount we are going to spend during the current year, the way in which we are going to spend it, and the way in which we are going to search the people's pockets to find the moneys for that spending. As I say, we are going immediately to be discussing, in this very serious situation, the spending of our national money, the way in which we are going to spend it, and the way in which we are going to collect it. I say, on that point in particular, that in a crisis such as the present it is not the time to refer any economic matters to discussion inside closed doors.
I can understand the difficulty that the Government would have in discussing defence matters publicly. I can even understand, though not entirely, the difficulty they have in discussing some aspects of defence even in private. I can understand their difficulty in visualising the type of defence problem that we are preparing against, but the preparation of our defence resistance, within our resources, is a simple matter. It is a limited type of work, there are specially equipped and specially appointed persons to deal with it in the Army, and the problem of planning is segregated along definite lines and confined to a limited number of people. There is no difficulty, however, but quite the contrary, in discussing what the nature of our economic problem is, but the remedying of it and the preparation for dealing with it is much less simple than is the preparation for dealing with our defence problem, because, whereas the regulation of the defence problem rests upon a small selected few, we require the co-operation of men and women in every walk of life and scattered throughout the whole country if our economic problem is to be settled. Therefore, we require the fullest possible discussion here if we are going to be assisted by all the people in the country, who must and can assist.
It is quite true, as Deputy Norton says, that in no way have the Government shown anywhere that the appreciate the nature of the problem that exists, or in no way have they shown us anywhere how they propose to deal with it or to deal with any section of it. We have had experience of supplies. The Government have failed either to conserve or to distribute, in any kind of an equitable way, such supplies as we have got. Part of the difficulty that is created there is due to the fact that, without any very clear necessity, the supplies, as they have arrived, have not been reported in the normal way, nor have trade statistics been made available to Deputies or to the commercial community or the manufacturers. I submit to both the Taoiseach and the Minister for Supplies, as well as to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that if our petrol statistics, our tea statistics, and our coal statistics, had been published in the regular way, month after month, during the last 18 months, we would not have had, and could not have run into, the difficulties with regard to the supplies and distribution of these commodities that we have run into, and it would not have been possible for the odd periodic anxieties or excitements on the part of Ministers in respect of one or other of these particular commodities to have upset the whole distribution of them and thereby to have cut off supplies from the poorest sections of the people. The very secrecy which was intended, or which was stated to be in the national interests in regard to some of our principal supplies, has cut deep and hard against the national interests generally. It has undermined the confidence of the people generally in the Government at a time when, goodness knows, all energies ought to be directed towards keeping up their courage and when they ought to have some confidence in the Government, and, on the other hand, it has injured the poorest sections of the people and those who are least able to protect themselves.
Comment on this
I do not like to interrupt the Deputy, but perhaps I might be permitted to intervene. I have been at pains to try to see how the publication of the facts in the case of petrol would have helped, but I cannot see how it would have done so. That is, the supply position in regard to petrol, the amount that is coming in or that is not coming in.
Comment on this
I would ask the Taoiseach to look at the quantities of petrol that came in last year and the year before, and compare them with the quantities that came in in the year 1938, and I would ask him how, if there was public knowledge of these facts, the Government could panic itself into the situation which it went into on Christmas Eve. I say that it could not, and I say that the sooner the Taoiseach and the Minister for Supplies tell us definitely what the petrol situation is now, the sooner they will make the best out of their supplies of petrol and the better it will be for the economic life of the country here.
Comment on this
I challenge the Taoiseach on that point: that there could not have been in this country the panic with regard to petrol on the 24th December last if the monthly statistics with regard to petrol had been published in 1939 and 1940. I challenge him, too, on the point that the sooner there is publication of what are the facts with regard to petrol to-day, the sooner such supplies as we are getting will be put to proper economic use. I say also that many people are being injured economically, and the country is being injured economically also, because such petrol as we have is not being distributed upon sound lines. However, I make the case with regard to supplies because, as a result of hiding and secrecy with regard to supplies, there has been confusion and economic loss to the country. I make the point that, at the present stage of our problems and at the present stage of the Government's appreciation of them and their action regarding them, you cannot take from the arena of public discussion any aspect of our economic affairs. Men and women in the past have given their lives, their money, their resources, have given tithes from their very poverty, to upholster seats of representation and authority in this House. Seventeen of those seats are filled by members of the Government. There are 121 left. What was the purpose of men and women struggling in the past to put these 121 seats here if their occupants, in times of difficulty and times of crisis, were to relinquish their responsibility and to hand over, either to a small section of themselves in private, or to anybody outside, the discussion of these things that are vital to the whole interests of our people? I appeal to members of the Labour Party and I appeal particularly to the members who sit behind the Government Front Bench that they should examine themselves as to what their functions and their responsibilities here are and whether, under present circumstances, they can afford simply to sit and wait and see, and to let us pass from one week to another, increasing our problems and increasing the difficulty of remedying them, without their stating their minds here as to what they think the position is with regard to their own constituents, with regard to the facts of their lives at the present time and the tendency of those facts and as to what should be done to protect them, in so far as the Government or co-operation among individuals can protect them from the unfortunate things that are happening economically, politically and socially at the present time as a result of war emergency in Europe.
We cannot hope to deal with the problems that the emergency has brought to this country, unless we mingle our voices here for the purpose of interpreting the facts, unless we mingle our counsels here for the purpose of deciding what should be done, and advise the Government, with all the wisdom and all the experience and knowledge possessed by the grouped members of the House, as to what should be done. We cannot inspire the people throughout the country, who have to do the work, who have to cooperate, and who have to understand what is being done from the Government side for them, or get them to organise their energy and their strength, until they see that their representatives in the national institutions are shouldering their responsibilities, and speaking their minds, and doing the work which can only be done for the country here, that is, the interpretation of the situation and the planning of the broad lines upon which solution is to be found, and the proper instruction of the Government in dealing with it.
There is a grave crisis, and it would be much more in keeping with what we say of ourselves as being so much a democratic State, if the Minister for Supplies would address himself on the subject of the gravity of the situation to this House. There is no one on whom a greater responsibility rests at the present moment for addressing this House on that subject, because it is particularly in his Department, or from his Department, that some of our more urgent problems have arisen. There is a grave crisis, and what is the Government's attitude, both as expressed by Ministers and by their critics? That the greater part of the problem arises out of the fact that nobody listens to Ministers. "Long before the outbreak of this war, and almost every week since, practically every member of the Government tried to waken the people up to the gravity of the time." That is the Party Press comment on the 10th March.
So much did we realise the gravity of the economic position which the world war was going to bring to this country that, as early as September, 1939, when we saw the Government, without previous consultation with us, concentrating on mobilising the Army to deal with the defence aspect of things, we thought it wise and urgent to make representations to the Government that we thought the economic side of things was the matter of real urgency, and we asked them to show, in respect of agricultural production, drive and energy instead of in the mobilisation of the Army. It was our concern then that this country was likely to run into financial difficulties, that we were likely to have serious unemployment, that a very considerable amount of distress of one kind or another would have to be relieved, that in the development of the war, circumstances were likely to arise which, post-war, might affect our agricultural production, that there should be special attention paid to our agricultural production and to the relations between ourselves and Great Britain in respect of that, that the shortage that was likely to arise in connection with raw materials should be looked after and that waste and disorganisation in our administrative machine, were to be avoided as far as possible. We considered that all these things should be avoided, but that the economic problems that were going to arise in this country were the problems that were most serious. In comparison with the steps that were being taken to organise defence in September, 1939, there was no evidence forthcoming that agricultural production at that particular time was getting the attention it required.
There is, on the part of Deputies, a certain amount of natural hesitancy to carry criticism to such an extent that it will show up the weaknesses in the Government. In fact, it can be said, in the time that has intervened, that our criticism has been rather too temperate. Where there has been criticism of the Government, they reacted against it like spoiled or bad-tempered children who threaten to break something if they do not get their own sweet irresponsible way. Responsible members of the Opposition have tempered their criticism rather than disclose that particular tendency or type of weakness in the Government.
Comment on this
We will leave it to the Minister to figure that out, but I ask him to consider whether there is any truth in the assertion that, when criticised, Ministers, instead of welcoming criticism from the House that they were able to answer, or to show that they were in the right, or if it was of assistance to them, tried to hide out a weak situation by a kind of bad-tempered reception of any criticism. If the situation is as serious as the Minister for Supplies now thinks, does he not agree that it is the responsibility of a Deputy to speak his mind, so that the position would be understood, so that his advice could be listened to, and the country informed both with regard to what Deputies think and advise, and the Government strengthened or pushed to do what was the right thing. Then we cannot consider any aspect of our economic circumstances behind closed doors. We asked —what is the situation? The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated that there was an increase of 353,000 acres in agriculture in 1940 as compared with 1939, that about 2,800 additional paid agricultural workers were employed, and about 10,000 additional members of farmers' families, so that it took the production of 625 additional acres in 1940 to put one permanent additional agricultural labourer and four temporary labourers back to work.
Comment on this
I mentioned them. I speak now of agriculture as a possible absorbent of unemployed who have to be paid. The point I want to make is that increased agricultural production does not seem to be going to absorb many of the unemployed people that remain to be absorbed at present. The Minister for Industry and Commerce indicated in a speech that he made elsewhere that there were at present 20,000 additional unemployed persons in the country. His figures indicated to-day that the number of persons employed in the year 1940, compared with 1939, and liable to pay national health insurance stamps, was down by what was equivalent to 11,000 every week for the whole year. We have pointed out that instead of what was normal some years ago—an increase of 11,000 persons who paid into national health insurance— as a result of the economics we have been going through in recent years that increase was brought to a standstill since 1937. The Minister's figures to-day disclosed that employment for the national health insurance year has fallen to the extent of 11,000 persons who were employed full-time for the whole year, and the unemployment insurance fund had been affected by a fall of 6,000. I admit that the 6,000 are also included in the 11,000. I am talking about full-time employment of people in the whole year by which unemployment insurance was affected in 1940. With 20,000 additional people to be found employment, and with agriculture showing that it is not going to absorb many of the people that it was thought it would absorb, showing that it is easier to put men off the land than to bring them back to it, we are faced with the unemployment situation indicated by Deputy Norton. It is a situation about which, I understand, the Minister for Finance communicated with some local bodies in respect of the coming year, asking them to bear in mind, when striking rates, that there will be additional persons, running into tens of thousands, to be looked after and financed either by way of work or relief.
That is the main outline of the situation. There is also the additional question of supplies of raw materials running out, with some of our industries shutting down, and others struggling to keep open. We do not know how others may be affected. The Government must be as fully aware of these things as any Deputy. They ought to be more fully aware, but never have they outlined in any way what principles they are going to apply when dealing with the situation. We are now on the eve of a discussion of the Vote on Account and the Central Fund, and our spending for next year, but we have not been informed what is going to be done. We are within a month or two of discussing what we are going to spend, where the money is to come from or how it is to be spent. I say that certain things will have to be done. There must be an extension of unemployment assistance in the case of families. We are soon going to celebrate the 25th anniversary of 1916.
"In this supreme hour the Irish nation by its valour and discipline and the readiness of its children to sacrifice themselves in the common good proved itself worthy of the august destiny to which it is called."
That is the final sentence in the 1916 Declaration. Somehow it strikes me to-day as suggesting that we ought to ask ourselves in the first place whether this is an hour less supreme than Easter Sunday, 1916, and whether we have the same conceit of our august destiny to-day as had the men of 1916. I may return to that but, I refer to it now because Pearse, writing in From a Hermitage, in 1913, said:—
"It is further known that a pound a week is sufficient to sustain a Dublin family in honest hunger. I would ask those who know that a man can live and house, feed and clothe a large family on a pound per week to try the experiment for themselves. I am nothing so new-fangled as a socialist or syndicalist. I am old-fashioned enough to be both a Catholic and a Nationalist. If the inhabitants collect in the streets to discuss these matters to-day, the police baton them. Before God I believe the root of the matter lies in foreign domination."
The cost-of-living figure was 100 when Pearse was writing these words. The cost of living in November—the last period for which we have a figure —was 214. The cost to a family in November, 1940, was more than twice the amount it was when Pearse was writing about the inadequacy of £1 per week. Since November, 1940, the price of a bag of coal has gone up by 1/11. Other things have gone up in different ways. The Minister for Industry and Commerce protests that the tea used by the working-classes of Dublin is paid for at the rate of 2/- per lb. There must be cobwebs on his Departmental file. But there are no cobwebs on the shillings which are circulating in some of the poorer parts of the city to-day. No tea can be got in the City of Dublin at 2/- per lb., so that the allowance of £1 per week would come in for a lot more scathing criticism from Pearse to-day than it did in 1915. Some aspects of that may be explained by the Minister for Supplies or the Taoiseach as resulting from foreign domination, but it is for us to deal with all the resources we have in our own hands. If there is nothing else for some families but unemployment assistance, then I suggest that we do not celebrate the 25th anniversary of Easter week without considering to what extent a man and his wife and their six, seven or eight children, can maintain themselves in the City of Dublin on 23/- a week. That is one thing which it seems imperative we should do. I mention it in this debate because I am touching upon things which I consider of importance.
There must be an extension of unemployment assistance to women in some of the urban centres, at any rate. Women in the City of Dublin are being denied unemployment assistance and assistance of any kind. It is utterly at variance with the spirit of the House, as revealed in the Unemployment Assistance Act, that circumstances should be what they are at present. It should not be necessary in any case for a person receiving unemployment assistance to have to go to the poor law authorities to receive a small additional amount. Administrative arrangements should be made so that people in receipt of unemployment assistance should not have, because of its inadequacy, to go down to Balfe Street or the Dublin Union to persuade the authorities there to give them additional assistance. In unemployment assistance there is ground which should be surveyed. Our employment exchanges are not functioning as employment exchanges, nor is there any kind of critical review of the men and women who go there to see how their services could be used. The result is that the men, particularly, are tending to slip out of the country by the hundred and to give service, in employment or some other way, in Great Britain or the northern counties. Part of the trouble at the labour exchanges at the present time arises from rumours that large numbers of men are required for employment in Great Britain. There is no plan in giving out unemployment assistance in a general way except that of assisting immediately people who must be assisted and who cannot be assisted in any other way. We want some kind of review so as to see how the services of these people can be used. I was hauled up by the Chair when discussing the Taoiseach's Estimate, for dealing with spare material and financial subsidies. I suggested that, as a specialised body was being set up to review the materials available, another specialised body should be set up to review the human material gathering around the labour exchanges. As a start, the material going before the Court of Referees and being turned down as not looking for work might be considered. If anything is to be of use to us it ought to be our men and women, and surely the Government, with all their protestations, are not going to fall back on the theory that they can afford to get rid of men and women while the stress is upon us. To do so might only exaggerate and increase the trouble.
There will, no doubt, be public employment, which we have not yet heard about except in a casual way. We take it that a certain amount of additional employment will be provided by the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Finance but this House has yet to hear of the schemes in contemplation. The House ought to be put in a position to criticise the proposals and to make suggestions as to the best way in which a return for the money expended in giving employment might be obtained. It may be that we shall have to run into some scheme of subsidised employment. That is a separate problem entirely. In the circumstances described by the Minister for Supplies and in the circumstances obtaining at the employment exchanges, no effort should be spared to prevent boys and girls who would ordinarily leave school this year from drifting out and becoming part of the existing problem. I suggest that, for the purpose of dealing with the present situation and having the future in mind, our young people in urban districts should have their school life extended straight away. Here we are closing down training colleges and preparatory colleges while we have a certain number of teachers unemployed.
There are classes of boys and girls in the City of Dublin in which there are 70 pupils to a teacher. We expect children to go through the primary schools in that particular way, with, you might say, the lack of education, the lack of discipline and the lack of any kind of respect for institutions which must inevitably go with that kind of thing, leaving these young people to find themselves in the streets without any kind of employment, and drifting down towards the labour exchanges. Not only from the point of view of the present, but from the point of view of the future, in connection with our educational establishments and primary and technical schools there is to-day an opportunity for a plan, and an opportunity that will give, perhaps, a chance of re-opening some educational institutions which have been closed. If we are to come through the present emergency with a large number of our educational institutions closed, instead of a large number of them being kept open, even unnecessarily, in order to prepare and train men and women to deal with the education of this country, then we will never rise from the circumstances in which we will find ourselves after this emergency, because it is only by education, by filtering into our life better-educated and better-disciplined people from the schools that we will make anything of the future. Therefore, I would ask the Government, if they have any plan in connection with our youth and their education which will segregate them from the problem that exists and may definitely increase, and, at the same time, will strengthen the roots of our national mind and our national education and put us in a better position to deal with the situation that will confront us in the future.
As I say, the suggestion that we are to have a commemoration of 1916 this year brings us back at least to the last sentence of the declaration made then, that in this supreme hour something is expected of our people. This is, in my opinion, a much more supreme hour for our people than 1916 was. We look at the various countries which have got torn up and tangled up in the war and we see that in most of them, where there have been gigantic failures on the part of their statesmen during the last ten or 20 years, they are able to forget their failures and to rally themselves to face their present circumstances.
In face of very definite aggressive facts they are able to find the strength to face difficulties much greater than face us here. We are not subject to the pressure of those facts like other countries. If we are to have a certain feeling of Christian responsibility both in respect to the use of our own talents and energies, and in respect to the responsibility for being our brother's keeper, we ought to be able to exert here a pressure that would enable us to rise to the present situation in the way in which other countries are rising to theirs.
If we look at Great Britain, we find that Great Britain is spending at present £10,500,000 per day on the war, and £1,750,000 on ordinary Government services, and is likely to be spending that for many a day. It has a future to face in which its people will have to live. We do catch from the people who are spending that amount of money, I might say, a heroic outlook, not only on their present difficulties which they are facing up to, but on the future, which we might very well look into and see if we cannot catch up some of the vision and hope of people in greater difficulties than ours, and if we cannot realise that the problems they have to face after the war will have to be faced by us earlier. If we throw ourselves into facing up to that situation, using our resources and energies here, we may have a situation in which we may be path-finders to them. By our work and achievements here, we may raise the hopes and stiffen the courage of many people in Europe who are in much more difficult circumstances than we are, and who also, if they are to achieve a position in which their people will be in any kind of peaceful or happy economic circumstances, have a much longer road to travel than we have.
If I might speak of Great Britain, which is the place nearest to us and which we know most about, it is realised there that the unemployment that took place after the last war and persisted was a different kind of thing from the unemployment that took place before, that if a fraction of the money now being spent on war was spent about 1930 in dealing with the unemployment situation there, and if a fraction of the thought and the planning devoted to war was spent on employment, there would be better housing, better education, and more leisure for a very large number of people in Great Britain to-day; that they might, indeed, have avoided war, as many other countries in Europe might have avoided war, if, instead of planning and thinking on war lines, they put their effort and resources into planning and building for the people who were their responsibility. It is realised that there are two scourges which have to be got rid of—war and unemployment; that unemployment is now as definite a thing, or was even before the present war as definite a thing in the world as the scourge of war was, and that it has to be tackled with all the energy and spirit required for a war.
Every country in Europe will have to face that question. The present circumstances are entirely new for us as well as for them, but the circumstances are different. We have not yet got any serious or mortal blow from war; we may, please God, be spared it. We have certain resources, and the question for us is to realise that there is serious distress and a serious unemployment problem that is likely to continue as long as this emergency lasts. It is likely to continue after the war, and, however it will be done, the question of unemployment has to be faced, so that we will not be under the stigma of Pearse that, with full control over our own resources, we are leaving a man and his wife and six or seven children to exist on what is, when you take the cost of living into consideration, half the figure that he scorned and spat upon in 1913.
There are little ways in which the Ministry suggest, from time to time, that our troubles here are not our own. I think that a serious examination of some of the information that is being withheld, and a serious sitting down over whatever difficulties we have in regard to supplies, ought to show Ministers that it is inevitable we will be short of supplies, and that the difficulties which we labour under, and will continue to labour under, are such that we cannot get out of them except by our own labour and exertions. We should be given the chance of facing up to that situation. It does not help to say that other people are squeezing us as regards supplies. I do not think a case can be made for that. I would plead with Ministers that we should face up to present circumstances as if they were inevitable, and that we ought to bring all our brains and good will, both in this House and with people outside, to bear on the solution of our difficulties. What I particularly want to ask the Government is this: to treat the House in a different way from that in which it has been treating it so as to help it to discuss these problems. If the Government have any plans they should not be hanging back about them. They should let us know what the plans are because there is a kind of blight, wherever it comes from, of incompetency over the whole situation. In connection with the defence situation, all kinds of voluntary organisations have come into existence. I venture to say there is not a single one of them in which there is not disillusion and dissatisfaction. That, I think, will continue until there is a definite Government lead on all national matters. You cannot have a satisfactory policy in connection with either the Defence Department or any aspect of the economic situation in the country unless it is felt through the country that you have here a vigorous Parliament, controlling the Executive, informing the Executive and satisfied that the Executive is standing up to its job and doing its work.
In a short time we shall be recalling the 26th anniversary of 1916. What are we to recall about it, if not that in that supreme hour men of leadership, men of action and men of courage came forward and saw circumstances in which they could bridge the gaps that divided men in different walks of life, men of different ages and men with different upbringings: that Pearse could join hands with Connolly, that Ceannt and Plunkett could join hands with Tom Clarke, that MacDonagh could join hands with Seán MacDermott. There is to-day as supreme an hour, but are we getting the leadership in this hour that was given by the men in 1916, with less resources, less hope, and less encouragement from those around them? If we are simply to go back to 1916 and read the half misrepresented and half-faded page of history, and sentimentalise over it at a time when, perhaps, fiery pens in Europe are even writing the very history of this country, then we might as well forget 1916. If it is going to be of any use to us, it must be to tell us that in a supreme hour it is the Irish tradition that leaders will come forward, openly, generously and vigorously: that they will face the circumstances of that time and hold out a helping hand to anybody whom they can help. The last thing that leadership in the traditional spirit, as we know it, would tolerate or accept is that Irish representatives in an Irish Parliament, founded securely by their efforts and by the efforts of those who went before them, should in a time of crisis sit down and let week pass week and month pass month, each adding its own problems and making the whole situation much more difficult to be tackled.
There is no case for the setting up of an economic council at the present time. Deputy Norton may have some idea of what an economic council might do in other countries, but here an economic council could, at the present time, do nothing except hide facts from the people. The people know that it would take responsibilities from the members of this House which they must shoulder. They know, too, that there is one group in this House that ought to be foremost in shouldering those responsibilities because it, more than any other, could make a valuable contribution in the spirit in which it ought to be given at the present time. I refer to the members of the House who sit behind the Fianna Fáil Front Bench. That group has the biggest contribution of all to make in the present situation, by pooling its mind and counsel in discussion in this House. Those comprising that group are not to think that their doing so will either undermine the Government or destroy the country.
What could undermine the Government or destroy the country is that this House would shut its mouth and fade out. I suggest to those members that, in a moment like this, if they have any sense of the august destiny of this country they have a bigger contribution to make than simply to file silently into the division lobby. We cannot energise our people, cannot direct their efforts in such a way as to assist them to deal with the problems that face them either in the workshop or in the home, except we show them that we have here an Irish Parliament taking an intelligent interest both in their circumstances and in their lives, that we are prepared to help them by our advice as to the road they should travel, and the control we have over the resources of the country. We must show them that our resources are being used in such a way as to keep this nation alive, vigorous and hopeful during the present situation. If we fail to solve our problems, and if we cannot show that our people are being maintained in circumstances of fair economic well-being, with no real distress amongst them, then God help the people of Europe.
Comment on this
I should like to approach this debate in the spirit in which Deputy Mulcahy has approached it, but I feel that I should perhaps remind the House of the terms of the original motion. The motion is:
That in view of the dislocation of Industry and consequent increase in unemployment due to the emergency situation, the Dáil requests the Government forthwith to set up an Economic Council to plan measures to deal with the situation.
This motion and the amendment, which proposes to delete all reference to an economic council, raise two separate and distinct issues, which should not be confused or entangled with each other, and indeed it would be of great advantage if we were discussing them separately. I take it from Deputy Mulcahy's speech that he rejects in toto the main purpose of the motion, which is to establish an economic council, but I think it would have been of some advantage if he had stated more explicitly the reasons which compel him—as I think all thinking men must be compelled—to take up that attitude. I should like, therefore, before coming to the amendment, to address myself, first of all, to the motion.
Deputy Norton has based his case for the establishment of an economic council upon the assumption that there exists a grave and widespread dislocation of industry, and a consequent increase in unemployment due to the emergency situation. I am going to begin by questioning that assumption, but I wish to make it clear that the Government's attitude in that regard should not be misunderstood. I am sure that, in view of the grave and serious situation with which this country may be confronted in perhaps some months' time, it will not be wilfully and deliberately misrepresented. We do not contend by any means that all is well either in regard to industry or in regard to employment. How could it be well, in view of the general dislocation and universal hardship which the present war has occasioned in every country in Europe? Neither do we suggest that in some industries changes for the worse have not occurred since last year. That would be demonstrably wrong. In certain occupations, the construction and repair of motor vehicles, for instance, and in the cotton industry, the position so far as production and workers seeking employment are concerned is definitely worse than it was 12 months ago. On the other hand, in other industries, in agriculture for instance and in the general building and construction industry, the present position as regards men registered as seeking employment is very much better, and, since we are dealing with the general situation, it is to the aggregate, to the algebraical sum of the better and the worse, that we must look.
Comment on this
Does the Minister suggest that there is an increase in employment in the building industry?
Comment on this
I say that, so far as men seeking employment in the building industry and general construction work are concerned, taking them all in all, the present position is very much better.
Comment on this
I am just coming to that. I am approaching and I have approached this problem with a view to ascertaining, with the means which are at my disposal, what are the real facts. If they are unpleasant, if they are unpalatable, even if they were discreditable to this Government, I would feel it my duty to put them to the House and to the country. Now, what are the facts in relation to those prime issues of industrial dislocation and grave unemployment? Dealing with the latter issue first, so far as I can ascertain them, here they are. Deputy Norton has stated that there has been a substantial exodus of workers from this country to Great Britain and elsewhere. Deputy Mulcahy appears to be under that impression also. Well, that impression is not confirmed, but is refuted, by the statistical investigation which has been undertaken by our Department of Statistics. On the contrary, it shows that, so far from there having been a general exodus from this country, no less than 33,000 additional people net have come into it since August, 1939; in addition, there has been a natural increase in the population of 20,000 souls, and the calculation which has been put to me as a reasonable one—not the calculation which I make myself, but the calculation which has been put to me as a reasonable one —is that there were 20,000 more people available for employment in this country at the end of December last than there were in August, 1939. Now, as I say, all of us, looking at our own immediate narrow circle, reasoning from the particular to the general, hearing of one person or another person leaving this country to seek employment, may have come to the conclusion that that has been the general trend, but here, so far as the facts can be ascertained by a statistical examination, is the net truth—that, so far from people having left this country, on the balance 33,000 more people net have come into it, and that, with the natural increase in the population, with the natural increase in the age groups of the population, there were and have been up to the present about 20,000 more people available for employment in this country.
Comment on this
I am giving the net inward figure; I am giving the balance; there has been a net inward movement of 33,000.
Comment on this
It includes cross-Border figures, and it includes people coming from the other side.
Comment on this
They are not exact figures, but they are subject to reasonable check, and they are given to me as figures which do not misrepresent the position. There is nobody going to say that, in a census of this sort, you are exact to the last decimal place or to the last whole number, but it is put to me by men who look at it in a purely scientific way, with no partisan object to serve, but with a desire simply to represent the existing picture as accurately as possible, that on the balance there has been a net inward movement into this country of not less than 33,000 persons and that as a result of these and other circumstances there were 20,000 more people in this country available for employment than there were in August, 1939. Now, if there were 20,000 additional people available for employment, and if they had not got employment somewhere, in one occupation or another, whatever it might be, whether it be in the Army or in some other occupation, then that fact would be reflected in an increase in the live register of those seeking employment.
Comment on this
Not if they got the employment. If they did not get the employment, the fact that they were looking for it would be reflected in the live register. The actual position in regard to the live register is this. The actual number of men on it, registered as seeking employment at the commencement of the present month, was 13,569 less than at the corresponding date of last year and was no less than 4,652 lower than on the corresponding date in 1939. I am quite prepared to admit that to a large extent these relative favourable figures are ascribable to the considerable increase which has taken place in our Defence Forces. To some extent, also, the position has been eased by an increase of 2,400 in the numbers engaged on employment schemes and, no doubt, too, part of the decrease has been occasioned by the operation of employment schemes under the Turf Development Board at Clonsast and in the Construction Corps. But, making every allowance for these factors, the reality still remains that, even with an addition of 20,000 to our working population, there are over 13,000 fewer men claiming subsistence to-day from the State than was the case this time last year.
In general, therefore, the position in regard to male employment is not merely better, but very much better than it was in March last, or even in March, 1939. Upon that ground, therefore, I am submitting to the House that there is no case for the motion. If the case for an economic council rests on the statement that unemployment is more widespread than it was last year, or in 1939, then there is no case for the motion because, in fact, the number of men registered as seeking employment in this country is 13,569 fewer than was the case last year and is 4,652 fewer than in March of 1939.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wishes to accuse those who prepared the figures of trying to deceive me and to deceive the House, I am not going to answer that sort of foolish accusation.
Comment on this
These men cannot get assistance because they are not eligible; the 13,000 are not eligible because they have no stamps.
Comment on this
If the Deputy, who professes always to be concerned about the unemployed, had really studied this question, he would know that a man would not have to have stamps in order to receive unemployment assistance.
Comment on this
Take the men who came back to this country from England. For two years they have been walking the streets and they are not getting any assistance.
Comment on this
I would prefer to make my speech. It is impossible to deal with a situation like this under cross-examination.
Now, let me consider the other issue raised by the motion, the assumption that there exists general industrial dislocation of such a type as might be cured or obviated by an economic council. I think, on the information I have at my disposal, that at the present moment there is no real ground for that assumption. Most industrial concerns in this country are producing according to their normal routine; one or two of them may be even working to capacity. It is true that some undertakings may be seriously affected by the restriction in the supply of petrol or of other materials, such as cotton yarns; but if that be the case, I think that Deputy Norton, who has based his argument for this economic council upon an assumed general industrial dislocation, should at least have told us in what way an economic council could have prevented either the shortage of petrol or of cotton yarns. The Deputy has not shown us that, and I suggest that a council such as he has outlined in a somewhat vague and shadowy manner would be worse than useless in dealing with that fundamental problem.
We did not hear a great deal about the composition of this council from Deputy Norton and, therefore, we have to try to see for ourselves what his ideas in the matter might be. I suppose he would have on it some businessmen and perhaps some engineers. I do not know whether trade unionists would have a seat on it, but perhaps he would have an economist or, if Deputy Davin would permit it, a banker.
Comment on this
He would also have, perhaps, a doctrinaire intellectual or two. On this question of obviating general industrial dislocation due to a shortage of supplies, what more could such a body do to secure supplies of yarns for the cotton industry than has been done by the active, able and efficiently-conducted organisation of cotton manufacturers which we have in this country? If the organised cotton manufacturers could not make themselves secure in regard to supplies of cotton yarns, who could do the job for them? I think we will find most people sceptical as to the ability of the association of diverging and, perhaps, conflicting interests such as Deputy Norton has suggested, at any rate to tackle the job and do it for them. What I have said in relation to the problem of cotton yarns applies likewise to the question of petrol and coal and any one of the other things of which there is or there is likely to be a shortage.
Deputy Norton was very critical about the wheat situation. He told us that the Minister for Agriculture and the Government ought to have taken steps, not merely in December, but in October of last year, and even earlier. Has it ever occurred to Deputy Norton that the Government and the Minister for Agriculture had to take steps in regard to this wheat growing problem not merely in December of last year, not merely in October of last year, but when we took office in March, 1932, almost ten years ago? Could an economic council have done any more in regard to the wheat supply than has been done by the Minister for Agriculture, carrying out the policy of the present Government in regard to wheat? Could this economic council, even if it had been able to increase the area of land put under wheat over ten years, have prevented the grain ships from being sunk? That is the question, and that is the root of this matter at present. If there is a shortage of wheat, it is not because the Government failed to take steps to ensure that supplies of wheat would be available for all our needs during the whole of the present year, but because, due to circumstances over which they have absolutely no control, those arrangements were upset.
I have asked the Deputy whether an economic council could have done any more to ensure that this country would be self-sufficient in regard to its wheat and bread supplies than was done over the past nine years—it will soon be ten years—by this Government and the present Minister for Agriculture. If an economic council had embarked on a wheat-growing campaign in 1932, would its policy have been any less strongly opposed than was that of the Minister for Agriculture?
Comment on this
Would there have been any less temptation on the part of certain interests to make political capital out of the fact that, because of our wheat growing policy, because of our attempts to make this country self-sufficient in regard to its daily bread, the cost of living was going to rise? These are the practical questions to which the Deputy ought to have addressed himself when recommending a motion of this sort to the House.
The Deputy has spoken of coal. Could an economic council have done more, or have done any better, than our organised coal importers, men who are familiar with every aspect of the trade, have done to insure us in regard to coal? Again, in relation to petrol, could an economic council have done any more than the Minister for Supplies did——
Comment on this
——when he tried to secure the erection of an oil refinery, and among other things to provide much greater storage for petrol? If an economic council had set out to establish that oil refinery, and to make us, at any rate, somewhat independent in regard to petrol, would that proposal have received the benediction of the political and other interests which opposed the Minister's proposals? Although Deputy Norton might wish us to assume otherwise, I think we may be safe in doubting it. Is it not clear that there is nothing an economic council could try to do by securing supplies to prevent the dislocation of industry that has not already been done, and, I think, better done by existing agencies? What justification, then, can there be for further confusing an already difficult situation by creating a body which, in relation to the fundamental question of supplies, will be of no practical utility?
Let us look at this question from another aspect. Deputy Norton, as I said, has been somewhat vague about the nature and constitution of the body he proposes to set up. According to his motion, it is to be an economic council, and it is to plan measures to deal with the situation. Firstly, I should have liked to have had from Deputy Norton a more precise definition of this economic council. It is very necessary, I think, that we should have that, because, in fact, as perhaps I may be able to show later, what the Deputy proposes is an unconstitutional revolution. I suppose all revolutions must be unconstitutional——
Comment on this
——except, as the Parliamentary Secretary reminds me, when they are successful. We are told that this body is to be an economic council and that it is to plan measures to deal with the situation and I have said that I should have liked to have had a more precise definition of this economic council. All of us, I suppose, know what a Cabinet is; all of us know what a Government is, and have some idea how they work here and elsewhere, but which of us knows anything about these economic councils? Deputy Norton tells us they have worked so satisfactorily—and I think his examples were perhaps a little unhappily chosen—in Belgium, France, Germany and Italy. So far as I know, the only country in which economic councils are now a fundamental part of the Constitution is Russia, and, if one may believe what one reads, membership of such a council would seem to be a stepping-stone to an untimely grave. Is that the idea the Deputy has in mind in suggesting that we should set up an economic council, because, apparently, notwithstanding everything which the Deputy says of them, notwithstanding all the good which the Deputy anticipates would flow from the establishment of an economic council in this country, in the country in which such councils have been tried, in which they are fundamental organisms of the State, the only thing that will get them to work is the death penalty.
Comment on this
While we might be a little doubtful and somewhat ignorant as to what the economic council is, the Deputy has left us in no doubt as to what this economic council is to do. It is to plan measures to deal with the situation. What sort of plans is this economic council going to make? Will it make engineering plans, detailed working drawings for constructional works of some kind or another, such as are made by portion of the staff of the Office of Public Works? Or is this council to confine itself to social plans, plans to set up machinery for the relief of hardship and distress, such as have been evolved from time to time in the Government Departments charged with such matters and such as are being constantly reviewed and revised by these Departments in the light of the changing needs of the times? Or will the council concern itself with financial plans—plans for raising money, plans for controlling the expenditure of that money so as to ensure that it is properly utilised for the purposes for which the community provides it, plans, in fact, such as those upon which the Minister for Finance is continuously engaged from one year's end to another? Or will the economic council prepare all three sorts of plans—social plans, engineering plans, financial plans—as it must, if it is to plan measures to deal with the situation? And if it does so concern itself in this comprehensive way with practically every activity of normal everyday life, would Deputy Norton, or Deputy Davin, who is going to have a chance of speaking later, tell us what functions will be left to the constitutional Government of this country?
Again, I think we might have been told somewhat more definitely how big is this economic council to be. "It is not to be too big," said Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
Will it have ten members? I think the Deputy cited an example in which an economic council had 20 or 25 members. Then you had the other extreme, in the case of France, which had 150.
Comment on this
It was said that France had 150 and, as Deputy Davin has pointed out, Germany had 350. In this country what is the number to be—ten, 150 or 350?
Comment on this
How different is that from the Government? There happen to be ten members of the Government who are holding 12 portfolios. Is this council to consist of ten, 150 or 350 members? Surely on that question we ought to have a little more light from the Deputy who proposed the motion? Whether it is going to consist of ten, 150 or 350 members, the question will arise as to what sort of persons are going to sit on this council. Of course, I agree that if we are going to have a small council, we must be more selective in our choice but, in any event, the question will arise: what type of person are we going to have on it? Would Deputy Norton or Deputy Davin put businessmen on the council? If they would, will they tell us from what particular businesses these members of the council should be drawn? Would Deputy Norton put railwaymen on the council? Would we have brewers, woollen manufacturers or glass bottlemakers on it? Would he have farmers, and if so, will they be sheep farmers, dairy farmers or graziers?
Comment on this
Is this supposed to be a serious attempt to deal with the motion?
Comment on this
It is a serious attempt to deal with it because here we have a phrase which is very vague flung into the arena of politics and we want to see what is behind it. If you take this motion seriously as I am taking it seriously——
Comment on this
—— the moment you sit down to consider it, these are questions that are going to arise. I have asked will you have business men or farmers, members of this council? If you are going to have farmers, will membership of the Dáil debar them from sitting on the economic council? If it does, are you then to go out into the highways and byways of the country looking for a farmer who takes no part in politics and who, if you do succeed in finding him, will tell you that he has no time to engage in public affairs? Will you put such a one on the council whether he wills it or not? These are all questions of importance, even if Deputy Morrissey does not believe it, and these are the questions that will have to be solved if the House is so misguided as to accept this motion.
Then the question will arise, if you are going to be selective in regard to your economic council, which occupations are we not to have represented on it? To which trade or profession will Deputy Norton turn round and say: "Your members are not fit to have a hand in this great planning business?" Will he say that the glass bottle manufacturers will make plans for the woollen manufacturers because the woollen manufacturers are incapable of planning for themselves, or will he solemnly decide that the brewers are to do a similar service for the glass bottle manufacturers? Or shall we have the railwaymen planning for the brewers and the woollen manufacturers, or, reverse the order, and have the brewers and the woollen manufacturers planning for the railwaymen? Or, instead of having brewers or railway men, per se on this council, will it be composed of jacks-of-all-trades who are notoriously masters of none? I want to know is that what the Deputy proposes to do? I am asking the Deputy to clarify our minds in regard to these matters.
We are asked to set up an economic council and, naturally, one question that will arise is, are you going to put economists on this council? If you are, are they going to be followers of this professor or that professor? Will they be followers of Professor Keynes, Professor Robins, Professor Hayek, or Major Douglas? Perhaps in order that this economic council should be truly representative of economic thought, we ought to put upon it a follower of every professor of economics and a representative of every school of economic thought. If so, does Deputy Norton or Deputy Davin think that the cauldron of economic disputation will make confusion less confounded for the humble people of this country, for whom this authority is going to plan? Or, if we decide that we are not going to have room on the council for disputation, shall we put just one economist on it, and if so, whom, and in what manner are we going to select that infallible guide? I suppose that tradesmen and labourers would feel entitled to a place on the council, but which particular trades are to be denied representation? After all, we cannot give a seat to every trade. Even the Trade Union Congress cannot do that in relation to its own domestic governance. Surely, these are all matters which those responsible for this motion must have taken into consideration, and in respect to which they should have formulated precise proposals. Apparently, they did not, because they could not, because their demand for an economic council is, in my view, only a meaningless phrase.
The fundamental issues involved in the selection of an economic council, however it be chosen, cannot be stressed too strongly. So far as I can see, and so far as I have been able to gather from anything which Deputy Norton has said, from the tasks with which he proposed to entrust it—whether it was recognising that idleness is waste and that it should provide work for the people or develop our agricultural resources— he was simply going to make it, in its functions, a duplication of existing government. If this council is to deal with the development—I think he said —of agriculture, surely there would have to be somebody on it entrusted with that particular task. If the council is to deal with the provision of moneys to finance the proposals which the Deputy contemplates, there would have to be somebody who would discharge the present functions of the Minister for Finance. Furthermore, the problem of supplies is fundamental in a crisis like the present, and possibly will be fundamental in the post-war situation. If that were the case, I suppose we should have on this council someone to deal with this particular problem and I assume that, to deal with it successfully, he would require to be invested with the same great and far-reaching powers as the Minister for Supplies. And we might go through every aspect of this problem and find that, in regard to each of them, we should require on the council an appointment parallel to virtually every Department of State.
There are other matters inherent in this issue of an economic council which should be brought out, simply to keep people from talking aimlessly and vaguely about it. We are told that the council is required to plan measures to deal with the situation which arises from a general dislocation of industry —a dislocation, bear in mind, of such a character that those who are actively engaged in industry themselves cannot effectively deal with it. If we are to set up a council to plan in this way, naturally the first thing we must ask ourselves is whether the council will be given also the responsibility for putting these plans into effect and, if so, we have then to ask ourselves what powers it will be given to that end. Will it be given arbitrary control over the whole business, property and rights of every citizen?
I believe we ought to get, perhaps, an explicit statement in regard to that aspect of the problem from Deputy Davin, who has seconded this motion, and who, I presume, proposes to speak to it. I say that we ought to get an explicit statement in regard to that, because Deputy Norton said that one thing which this economic council should not do was to have regard to any hoary traditions. It is a hoary tradition, of course, in this country, that our citizens have control over their business and property. That is recognised by law. They also have control over their everyday lives. Does Deputy Norton propose that this economic council, disregarding all hoary traditions, should be given power, say, to possess itself of stocks and property which far-sighted and prudent concerns may have laid in for themselves? Will it, again disregarding all hoary traditions, have power to distribute those stocks and property amongst other concerns which have not exercised the same foresight?
Comment on this
Perhaps the Government, in some respects, has done that, but, if so, the Government is responsible here to the Dáil and to the people. If the economic council is to be given power to do what the Government has done already, perhaps somebody might say at once what is the use of keeping the Government established by the Constitution. I know that Deputy Norton is much more revolutionary than sometimes appears on the surface, but, leaving that issue aside, I ask this question. If this economic council is given power to take over the property of one group of individuals and distribute it to another group, disregarding all hoary traditions, to whom is that council to be responsible when it uses such powers? Is it to be responsible to the Government, to the Dáil, or to whom? Do Deputies believe that power of this kind is less likely to be abused by such a council than by the Government responsible to the Dáil? Again, in regard to this council that is to be bound by no hoary traditions, will it be empowered to decide that men are to be transferred from one occupation to another, and from one place of employment to another? Because that is a question which, elsewhere, has been found to go to the root of all this question of economic planning: that not merely have you a right to use raw materials and inanimate things in a way which appears to some people, to the select few, to be best for the nation, but in these countries where they apply this idea of an economic council it is also implicit in the whole arrangement that they have likewise the power to transfer labour, to transfer flesh and blood, men and women, from one occupation to another and from one place to another.
Comment on this
Men are being forced through hunger to transfer in hundreds and in thousands into the British Army from this country at the moment, and you can see them going in hundreds on the trains to Belfast.
Comment on this
Wherever they are going—and whether or not they are going to join the British Army I do not know, and the Deputy does not know either—but wherever they are going, and whether it is to join the British Army or not, they are not going through hunger.
Comment on this
It is not true. However, let me get back to this one question, because, after all, Deputies of the Labour Party, who are advocating an economic council, at least ought to answer it? Is the economic council to be given this power? If Deputy Norton thinks that it is in the national interest that people should be transferred about in this way, is the council to be given that power, and if such transfers do take place, who shall decide what rights the transferred workers have? Will it be the economic council, or will it be the Legislature, and, if it is the council, who is to hold it to account should it decide wrongly or unjustly? If it is not to be given this power, if it is not to be given this power over men and materials, of what use is it to be? The moment we begin to examine questions like these, in my view, we recognise at once that if this economic council is to be an effectual instrument to deal with the situation it must have powers which rival those of the duly constituted Government.
But here is another question. If the Government is to retain its constitutional responsibilities, the effectiveness of the economic council's plans will depend upon the view taken by the Government of their practicability. Supposing this view differs from the view of the economic council, will the Deputies who are advocating this institution tell us how that difficulty is to be resolved? Will the council be entitled to urge citizens to give effect to its plans, even when these have been turned down by the Government? And in that case, will the people be bound by law to obey the Government, or will they be free to follow and support the views of the economic council? In my view and in my opinion, an economic diarchy of the kind that is contemplated in this motion, if persisted in, might eventually lead to civil war.
Comment on this
There are other more practical aspects of this matter. Perhaps, we may have been dealing with it in its theoretical aspects, but there is this question that would have to be answered if this council is to be set up to do all the things that Deputy Norton has suggested. What is going to be its relation to the appropriate Government Departments? If it is going to function at all, every investigation it may undertake, and every plan it may conceive, will involve their views. Is this economic council to be entitled to butt in on the work of the Departments, to controvert or to counter the policy of the Ministers and of the Government, and to seek precedence for the information which it requires, or the examinations which it desires to have undertaken? Is this power to be exercisable by each and every member of the council at his own discretion, or may it only be exercised by the council as a corporate body after it has met in solemn conclave and decided which Department of State it is going to invade; or, if this is not to be the situation, if the economic council is not going to work through the Government Departments, is it to have a staff of its own? Are we to build up, for instance, in order to deal with all the manifold problems of, say, agriculture, another staff which, in so far as the directive heads and principal officers are concerned, would be a mere duplication of the existing departmental organisation? Is that to be done, too, in relation to financial and economic matters? Are we to have a second Department of Finance, and, in relation to trade and industrial matters, a second Department of Industry and Commerce, and so on?
Comment on this
We are told very often that we have far too many people engaged in the public service. Of course it is serious. The Deputy's interjection shows that he has not thought this out. Is the economic council to have control over Departments of State if it wants work done, and if it is not to have control, and if it still wants the work to be done, is it to set up its own Departments? Let the Deputy answer that question.
Comment on this
We have the opportunity of discussing it now. We are very often told that we have far too many people engaged in the public service and drawing public money. We are going to double that number in the vain hope, as, I believe, it will be vain, that this new-fangled government or council—call it what you will—is going to handle these problems any more efficiently than an elective Government, with Parliamentary responsibility for them all, can do?
Comment on this
Well, if it is, the Deputy and the House have the remedy in their own hands. If they think that any other Government would handle the problem better than the present Government is doing, then by all means use the remedy which you have. Turn out the Government. Turn it out, but do not try to turn it out by a side-wind and, for heaven's sake and for Ireland's sake, do not bedevil the whole situation by setting up an other and a rival instrument of government in this country which, as most people believe, has already twice as many governments as it can cope with.
Deputy Norton, in the course of his speech, when he referred to the countries which enjoyed the benefits of an economic council, seemed to think that an economic council is an instrument of democracy. Well, there is an authority equally eminent in regard to these constitutional questions — an advanced democratic thinker, a democratic thinker at least as advanced as Deputy Norton. I refer to Professor Laski, and here is what he has to say in regard to an economic council. He says, first of all:
"But the whole of this demand for an economic council is based upon an assumption which is not justifiable, the assumption that specialists have an esoteric body of truth in their possession the importance of which politicians fail to recognise. In fact (Professor Laski points out) there is no such body of esoteric truth, and the specialist who is insistent that Government needs the aid of ‘thought' usually means that the politicians do not place upon the remedies the same importance as he attaches to them."
And, mind you, that applies to other than specialists.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy goes too far. He was a member of the Labour Party to which, I think, the Deputy's own Party at one time or another has sent fraternal delegates.
Comment on this
I do not know whether Professor Laski is or is not a Communist. I think he is as nearly advanced as Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
If I am permitted, I should like to revert to Professor Laski:
"In fact" (I was saying that Professor Laski points out) "there is no such body of esoteric truth; and the specialist who is insistent that government needs the aid of ‘thought' usually means that the politicians do not place upon the remedies the same importance as he attaches to them. But at the point where he makes this judgment, he, in fact, ceases to be a specialist; for he is then establishing a scheme of priority in value for ideas—a matter in which wisdom and not specialism is the test of validity. It is the essence of our parliamentary system to make the responsibility for such priority in value one that the Cabinet must take. Any alternative would destroy that system because it would ultimately place the responsibility for action outside the areas where it can be controlled by Parliament and the electorate."——
And the Deputy will now see the force of the questions which I was putting to him as to whom this body was to be responsible——
"That road, ultimately, leads to dictatorship, however benevolent in purpose, for it rests upon the assumption that, whatever the popular will, it must accept the specialist's conclusion of what is good for it. It is a view, no doubt, capable of powerful defence; but, so far, it is contrary to the traditions upon which the governmental system of this country has been built."
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, will the Minister give the authority for his quotation, and the date?
Comment on this
The quotation is from Professor Laski's book on the English Constitution, published, I think, in the year 1938.
Comment on this
Are there any Irish quotations at all, or are there only English ones, as to why we should not have an economic council in Ireland?
Comment on this
No, I have not gone to Russia, but I have often noticed in the Deputy's speeches a strain of thought which suggests perhaps he may have made a secret visit to Russia.
Comment on this
Will the Minister hide the handkerchief he is wearing then?
Comment on this
If the Minister were to deal with the motion or the amendment, we might get somewhere.
Comment on this
I have been dealing with the motion which proposes to set up an economic council. Every statement I have made since my opening remarks has been directed to that issue and to no other. I presume that if I had been irrelevant the Chair would have called my attention to that fact. I have devoted quite a lot of time to this motion, and to the proposal to establish an economic council. I presumed that as that was going to be the foundation of the debate we would have heard a great deal more about this economic council from the proposer of the motion than in fact we have.
I would now, however, like to deal with one or two of the matters which were referred to by Deputy Norton in the course of his speech and which had, I think, very little relation, if I may say so, to the motion, perhaps rather more to the amendment. I am going, if I can, to deal with the amendment. The amendment asks the Government to "immediately reveal to the Dáil any plans already prepared by them to maintain employment". It is difficult, I think—at least it was difficult when I was considering this amendment—to say what was exactly implicit in that phrasing, because we cannot prepare plans to maintain employment in this country without giving full consideration to the circumstances which occasion unemployment, and in this country at the moment such unusual unemployment as has arisen has arisen from a wholly abnormal circumstance—the interruption of certain essential supplies. This is a circumstance which, as Deputy Mulcahy fairly said, could not, I think, have been avoided by any measures which it was possible to foresee— perhaps he did not go as far as that— but at any rate, practicable for us in our circumstances to take. If this particular difficulty were removed, so far from there being exceptional unemployment in this country, the situation, from that point of view, as the figures which I have already given indicate, would be more satisfactory than it has been for a number of years past. Now our ability to maintain employment is governed and will be determined by our ability to maintain supplies.
Deputy Norton seems to think that there would be no difficulty whatever in that regard if it were not for the absence of an adequate mercantile marine. I wonder whether, in fact, that is Deputy Norton's view, whether the phrase "the absence of a mercantile marine", which has a fine swinging ring about it—very much like that of an economic council—is just simply trotted out in order that the people may believe that it is the easiest thing in the world for us to have and to maintain such a marine service. A few days ago I pointed out that of the few Irish ships on our register eight, or perhaps nine, have been lost. I also pointed out that that was since last July. Others under charter to us, bringing in grain and raw materials here, have also been lost, and others, the main portion of whose cargo was destined for our shores, have likewise gone down. In fact, there has been sunk, virtually since the middle of last year, an equivalent to more than half of any mercantile marine, adequate or otherwise, which under any reasonable circumstances we could hope to be able to maintain. Deputy Norton states that our present difficulties are due to the Government's failure to maintain an adequate mercantile marine. Has he adverted to these facts, or is he just content to ignore them, to disregard them when putting the issue to the public, to deceive the people as to the seriousness of the situation? How happy we should be if our present difficulties could be cured by the purchase of a few ships.
In ascribing our present situation to the lack of ships, Deputy Norton fully ignores the hard realities that underlie the whole problem, not merely that we want ships, but that we should want a navy—if we wanted to make certain of our supplies—sufficiently strong to keep the sea lanes open and free for the passage of such ships to our shores. Without a force of that kind ships, even if we could get cargoes, would not be likely to afford the relief to us that Deputy Norton believes to be possible. They would be in grave danger of passing either under the control of one belligerent or being destroyed by the other, as has happened to practically every neutral ship in Europe since this war started. Deputy Norton and the members of the Labour Party are aware of that fact. Nor is that all. You cannot keep ships at sea without coal, oil and servicing facilities, and in a time of war facilities of that kind— coaling stations and servicing stations —are under the control perhaps of one belligerent, who might be anxious to reserve them for his own use.
Then there is the question of crews. That is a big question. It raises issues involving human lives. Unfortunately, vital considerations of this character are apt to be overlooked when the supply problem is discussed by serious politicians, or by serious members of this House, in terms of inanimate objects like ships.
Comment on this
I should like the Deputy to understand the situation that I sometimes am in when crews are going from these shores. I should like the Deputy to be faced with such issues.
Comment on this
They have never failed to go, but what the Deputy overlooks is that some of them have failed to return.
Comment on this
It is all very well to discuss this problem in terms of inanimate things like ships, but we are apt to overlook the vital issues involved. The Government has to keep those in mind, and if we send our sailors on voyages to dangerous waters, there is a responsibility on us to afford them the maximum possible protection. If we are unable to give them this we cannot deny them the right to avail of such protection as may offer. But when ships and crews accept the protection of one belligerent they may incur the hostility of the other, with consequences of which we are only too familiar.
The Deputy need not think that our difficulties end there. If we had the ships, and if we were able to give them adequate protection in their comings and goings from these shores, there would still remain the question of getting cargoes for them. Our problem in regard to vessels and the maintenance of normal supplies, ultimately comes to this, that in order to safeguard fully the raw materials we require, not merely do we want the ships and not merely do we want adequate protection for them, but we want an assurance that those who have at their disposal the supplies which we want, will be prepared to sell them to us in preference to another customer. The root of our difficulties in regard to such overseas supplies is that we have no such assurance.
Deputy Norton said that prior to the outbreak of war we could have converted our sterling into dollars. We have no assurance—and this is what makes this problem serious for us and for the country—that even dollars will buy materials which those who have them for disposal have destined for another purpose. The Government have been making every effort, through every channel and through every agency available to them, to secure supplies, but it cannot compel those who have supplies to give them to us if they desire to make other uses of them. Those are the hard facts, and there is no use in saying that an economic council is going to remove them. There is no use in the Deputy's saying that all our problems would be ended if we only had an adequate mercantile marine. All our troubles would be ended if we had peace instead of having war raging around us.
The Deputy and others like Deputy Hickey go on repeating this parrot cry, shutting their eyes to the fact that outside these shores there is a conflict raging whose chief battlefield is the sea, and that every ship that goes into the zone of that conflict goes into it at its peril. Outside that zone people can pick and choose their customers, according to their preference or desires. These are fundamental facts. These are the conditions which govern every plan and every policy of the Government in regard to the employment situation and the present economic position. That and nothing else. It is not going to be cured by the setting up of the body Deputy Norton refers to in the motion.
Leaving aside these difficulties, I should like the House to consider, in view of the request that we should put before the Dáil any plans prepared by us to maintain employment what, in fact, we have done to safeguard the country against the present situation.
In this country we have lived through 18 months of war, and during the whole of that period employment in general has been well maintained, so that until quite recently the normal tenor of commercial and economic life was virtually undisturbed. During these 18 months this country has reaped the benefit of the long struggle we had to make wheat, beet and peat the staple products of our agriculture, and boots, clothes and cement the staple products of our manufactures. I have pointed out the difficulties which confront us in regard to supplies of raw material which, in the case of some industries, have to be procured from overseas. If on top of that we had to import as well a very large proportion of our food supplies, and of the things that we require to clothe and shelter us, then our position would be intolerable indeed. We may be thankful that, whatever may have been the case in the past, it is no longer the case to-day.
Take our bread supplies. When we first took office, this country was producing 3,840,000 cwts. of flour. Last year the total production was 6,784,000 cwts.—almost double the 1931 production. In the fundamental matter of wheat, the position is even more striking. In 1931, we produced only 418,000 cwts. of wheat. To-day, we are producing 6,257,000 cwts.—15 times more than was produced when we took office in 1932. Undoubtedly, if we are not careful, if we do not do everything possible to ensure that neither wheat nor flour is wasted, there may be a shortage of flour and bread in the period between July and September of this year. But think what our position might have been if the Government, since 1932, had been content to allow this country to continue to rely almost to the full extent of its bread requirements on imported wheat. The same thing is true with regard to bacon and hams. The same thing is also true with regard to other articles. We produced 52,000 dozen pairs of boots and shoes in 1931. In 1939, we produced 349,000 dozen pairs. This industry, because of the policy of my predecessor, is very largely self-supporting, as the tanning industry has been developed to an extent almost commensurate with that of our boot and shoe manufacturing requirements. We produced no cement in 1931 and we produced 256,000 tons in 1939. In 1940, we produced even more than that.
The amendment asks us to reveal immediately plans for the maintenance of employment. These figures represent plans not merely in contemplation, not merely being devised now, but in steady operation at the present moment, maintaining employment in essential industries and preventing the distress that the amendment adumbrates. The people are already reaping the benefits of the advance planning undertaken by this Government. I am not going to say that the programme in operation leaves nothing to be desired. But if there are weaknesses in it, then they are weaknesses which arose out of the conditions of the time, and weaknesses for which we, at any rate, cannot accept full responsibility.
While it is true that, in regard to a number of industries, employment has been maintained up to this, I certainly do not wish anybody to understand that I believe that normal employment is going to be maintained at the same level in future. Undoubtedly, if we cannot replenish stocks from overseas supplies, then existing stocks of raw materials are going to run out, and we shall have to deal with the position of those who were engaged in industries which were dependent upon such imported materials for their continuance. That is a most difficult problem. If men and women are thrown out of employment because their employers have been unable to secure the supplies which are necessary for the continued operation of their factories, one cannot propose to continue them in the same occupation. The question arises: in what other occupation can such workers be employed? It is not possible to take a tenter straight out of a cotton mill and to employ him as a navvy on a public health works. Neither can we do that with a pastry cook, a watch and clock maker, or a saddler. That holds good for practically every skilled trade. An examination of this problem has shown that if, in the course of six or 12 months from now, 70,000 or 80,000 of those persons normally in continuous employment were to be thrown out of work by reason of shortage of raw materials, barely 10 per cent. of them would be capable of working upon constructional works. Nor would it be possible to employ a significant number of them upon alternative skilled work. All tradesmen are specialists. A carpenter cannot readily become an iron worker, nor a house painter a printer, nor a motor mechanic a tailor, nor an electrician a weaver.
Accordingly, where general unemployment arises from shortage of raw materials for the skilled trades, it is virtually impossible in most cases to provide employment for more than a small percentage of those engaged in such trades. Moreover, even where alternative employment can be provided, we must be careful to ensure that it will be of such a nature as to encroach as little as possible upon the stocks of plant and raw materials which are required for the maintenance of normal productive industry. In those circumstances, perhaps the best thing we could do would be to ration out such normal employment amongst operatives in every concern and stretch out the supplies available so that in every industry, over the period of crisis, there would be some activity which would continue to keep the skilled and semi-skilled workers actively associated with their normal occupations.
Comment on this
I was going to remark that this may mean that the output of industries operated in this way may have to be dealt with by way of a ration scheme amongst those who would normally take it. It may mean that production costs may be increased —perhaps very appreciably increased— and that the price problem may become acute. It may also mean that the earnings of workers whose employment is thus rationed may have to be supplemented from public sources. The extent to which it may be possible to give this help, whether in money or kind; the organisation which will be necessary, in that event, to administer it and the alterations required to be made in the existing law, together with other aspects of this problem to which it is not necessary to refer, are, and have been, under active consideration.
Simultaneously, programmes of public works have been planned to provide, so far as possible, alternative employment for those who may be disemployed. We must bear in mind, however, that the possibilities in this regard are limited by three conditions: (1) the proportion of the disemployed who are physically fit for employment on public works schemes such as drainage, road-work and the like, will be small indeed; (2) the works must be of a kind which will make the minimum demand possible upon plant and materials required for normal work; (3) since the greatest proportion of such unemployment, due to shortage of supplies, as we may experience will arise in urban districts—and particularly in the larger urban centres— the works must be convenient to, or within easy reach of, such centres. Due to these limitations, I have no doubt that, when plans have been completed, the amount of alternative employment available will absorb only a small fraction of the disemployed, so that the greater part of the problem will remain to be dealt with by the Department of Local Government and Public Health and the Department of Industry and Commerce in conjunction with the regional commissioners who, with this and similar objectives in view, were appointed months ago to operate under the Minister for Supplies.
We have been, and are now, approaching this problem with the outlook advocated by Deputy Mulcahy. Not one aspect of it has been left unexamined. We have not come to final conclusions in regard to a number of the matters because it is not an easy thing to arrive at conclusions until the situation has further developed. But we have had the situation under constant review and examination and, as I say, we are trying to see what good we can get out of these evils. The Deputy has made one or two suggestions to-night which, I think, warrant further consideration and investigation —particularly, the suggestion dealing with the position of the young people who are leaving school. I should like, if I may, in that connection, put him a problem which we have quite recently experienced in respect of the Construction Corps. It is a thing which we might bear in mind when dealing with the figures of those who are on the live register. Since this Corps was established, 2,818 young persons in Dublin between the ages of 18 years and 25 years were invited to join. Of these 2,148 refused to join, even though they had reason to believe that, if they refused this offer of work, they would not be eligible for unemployment assistance.
Comment on this
Does the Minister realise that they had left school at least two years previously and had been hanging around for that period?
Comment on this
That may be. I do not want to discuss that. Out of 2,818, 670 agreed to join. They were all called up and all reported for enlistment. The number who actually enlisted was 258— out of 2,818. Of those who did not enlist, 15 were over-age; 14 were under height; 113 were not enlisted because their character and previous discharge from the forces would not warrant that course; 113 had obvious physical defects; 57 had defective vision, and 100 were unsuitable on other medical grounds, so that out of these 2,818, although the Construction Corps is full at the moment, we got only 258.
Comment on this
There is a very great problem and that is why I say, in relation to the boys who are leaving school, that Deputy Mulcahy's suggestion warrants serious consideration and, perhaps, the necessary action. The Deputy can see that a great many considerations arise out of these figures. The Deputy suggested that these were persons who were two or three years away from school and who had not learned the habit of work. Another question, however, arises: are quite a number of people in a position to maintain themselves in circumstances that they consider better than those they would enjoy in the Construction Corps and are able, while maintaining themselves, to sign on at the employment exchanges for unemployment assistance? I do not want to be misunderstood. While I am prepared to concede what the Deputy has said in relation to boys who have never acquired the habit of work, I think there are others who would not join the Construction Corps and who would prefer to do without unemployment assistance simply because they were not in need and had some other job which made it more profitable for them not to join the Corps.
Comment on this
There may be. These figures certainly indicate a problem that is not going to be easily solved. You have men in jobs and men who want work, and you have men who are physically unfit for work—men who should not be drawing unemployment assistance but who should be dealt with in some other way.
Comment on this
In regard to 670 men out of the 2,818 who offered themselves for enlistment, we might consider there was a problem of poverty but, in regard to the others who did not offer, there is a problem which requires further investigation. In relation to some of them, I do not think it was a problem of poverty at all. It was, probably, a problem of psychology, of ingrained habit which, in some way or other, we shall have to cure.
Comment on this
The Minister has spoken for an hour and 35 minutes. His was a long speech, but what he contributed which would be of use to the House or the country could have been said in less than 15 minutes. One found it hard to believe during the first hour of the Minister's speech that we were dealing with a matter affecting tens of thousands of people, and a question as to whether these people should be hungry or should get something to eat. The Minister indulged in a speech, if I may use the word, that was not worthy of a fourth-rate debating society for schoolboys. The Minister does not like that. Let me say that the previous Minister could have improved upon the present Minister when he was making petty points about the economic council. I am not in favour of an economic council, but the best speech I heard in favour of it, so far, was delivered by the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister used gags for an hour and 35 minutes. He spoke as if he heard the words "economic council" for the first time. I remember the Minister a full-blooded enthusiast for an economic council. He followed in full cry behind his leader in favour of an economic council. Apparently, even at that time, when he was following his leader with enthusiasm, he had not heard this name.
We were treated to all sorts of fantastic nonsense. When the Minister gave us figures, I must confess I was rather sceptical about there being a net influx into this country since August, 1939, of 33,000 people. What the Minister had to say about unemployment figures subsequent to that made me even more doubtful. The Minister said that there were 20,000 additional persons available for employment, and he assumed that they had got employment, because, if they had not got it, the fact would have been reflected either in the unemployment insurance or unemployment assistance figures.
Comment on this
I said they had been reflected in the figures on the live register. That is what I said.
Comment on this
Might I suggest to the Minister, with all possible respect, that he ought to get himself put right in regard to that matter. His colleague, who is sitting next to him, may be able to put him right on the matter, or, if not, somebody else. I will leave it at that.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is not quite right. However, I am not going to interrupt the Deputy's speech.
Comment on this
And I will not presume to instruct the Minister on his duties. But I suggest that if he looks up the matter of the qualifications of people returning from abroad——