We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Economic Council—Motion.

Contributions 165–327 of 327. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Morrissey

Of course they are.

Comment on this

If there is room at the hatches.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Of course they are entitled to register. Is that the sort of serious approach we are to have to the matter? I know they are entitled to register, and so does everybody else. What else are they entitled to?

Comment on this

If their residence was here, they are entitled to unemployment assistance.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Where?

Comment on this

In this country.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I am talking about people who returned from outside this country.

Comment on this

We have grasped that.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Minister went on to improve on the situation. He quoted other figures, and made the statement, which I do not think he believes himself, that there are fewer unemployed in this country than there were in 1939.

Comment on this

Fewer men seeking employment.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Fewer people unemployed in this country than in 1939.

Comment on this

I said fewer men seeking employment.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I will make the Minister a present of the quibble.

Comment on this

It is not a quibble.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Minister went further. He said the unemployment situation is more satisfactory to-day than it has been for years. Does the Minister believe that? If these are the conclusions he draws from the figures put before him, I suggest that he ought to get away from the figures.

Comment on this

I do not like to interrupt the Deputy. But, in connection with that last statement, he left out the qualification which I made, that if it were not for the difficulty in obtaining supplies, the position would be much better. That is what I said.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Minister may have meant to say that.

Comment on this

I said it.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

If the Minister said that, I did not hear it, and I did not understand him to say that. As a matter of fact, if it were stated in that way, I do not know why it was stated at all, because, if that condition of things were to obtain, there would be no necessity for the motion or the amendment. When the Minister got a bit serious towards the end of his speech, he proceeded to tell us what the Government were thinking out, what they were trying to plan for the absorption of the unemployed. He did not outline it very clearly, I may say. He did not spread himself so much, as he did during the first hour of his speech, about all the plans and all the proposals and all the schemes they had.

I wonder was it since this motion and amendment were put down that they began to think of these plans and schemes, because the extraordinary thing about it is that not one of the schemes or plans of work, which the Minister says have been having the attention of the Department, is reflected in the Book of Estimates given us to-day under any of the three headings where one would expect to find them?

I want to approach this motion and this amendment from a different angle. Of course, when he said that the Government have done so and so, the Minister sailed away with the idea that everything which possibly could have been done in connection with providing more food in the country was done. Last September, when the war had been going on for 12 months, surely it was evident to everybody that it was highly problematical, to say the least of it, that it would be possible for this country to import feeding-stuffs either for human beings or live stock. It was certainly quite clear to everybody, as a matter of fact, before September that if we were fortunate to be able to import anything, it would be in quantities that would not be worth taking into account when arriving at the total figure of our requirements for the coming year.

Surely that was the time to announce that it would be necessary for this country to produce all the food that was required both for man and beast. Surely during the harvest, which was one of the best harvests we were ever blessed with, was the time to make it clear to farmers and others engaged in that industry how absolutely essential it was that we should set aside sufficient winter and spring seed wheat to enable us to produce the whole of our requirements this year. Surely, when it was estimated that, in order to be on the safe side, we required from 650,000 to 700,000 acres of land under wheat alone, and when it was quite evident that we would have to go out to what have been called the dairying and ranching counties and to break virgin soil, that was the time to warn people that we would require double the number of acres for wheat alone, apart from all the other things. Surely it was evident to somebody in the Department of Agriculture, if not to any other Department, that if you wanted to sow successfully, and if you wanted to break lea, some of which had not been broken for 60 or 70 years, break it to the fullest advantage, particularly in a year when manures were scarce, the time to do it was in October or November. Secondly, having due regard to our uncertain climate, your chances of getting a crop of winter wheat was probably anything from 30 to 50 per cent. better by having it sown before, rather than after, Christmas.

That was all the more important this year, because of the fact that we had a fairly good supply of winter seed wheat, and that our supply of spring seed wheat was very limited indeed. Surely, it did not require a great deal of foresight to make, even in October last, the very big effort which was made in the middle of January. The only difference was that, if the effort had been made in October, there would be tens of thousands of acres of wheat over the ground before Christmas. The unfortunate part of it is now that, probably due to the bad weather— which we have had since before Christmas, it was certainly not due to any reluctance on the part of the farmers to do their work—it has been found almost impossible to sow the amount of winter wheat that was available. Winter wheat is being sown this week, and sown under unfavourable conditions, and unless we are blessed with a fairly good year somewhat similar to last year, it is very doubtful whether it will ripen. We are in that unfortunate position.

I doubt if the Minister for Agriculture, or anybody else, could say now that, with all the goodwill in the world on the part of the farmers, he is going to get the amount of wheat grown this year that he says is necessary. Ministers seem to think that they can shed all their responsibility in this matter merely by saying: "Look at all that we have done since 1932." If Ministers said that, but for the shortage of supplies, the unemployment situation would be more satisfactory to-day than it had been for years, it would, I suppose, be true, to some extent. There are certain shortages for which, perhaps the Government cannot he held responsible, but there are other shortages for which they can very definitely be held responsible. I should like to hear some of the Ministers tell the House what they were doing from September, 1938, to the outbreak of war in September, 1939. The Minister for Supplies said to me in the House on a famous occasion that, if he knew the war was going to break out in September, 1939, then everything in the garden would be lovely, because he would have seen to it that we had ample supplies of everything we required. The Minister, surely, knew before the outbreak of war that it was necessary to get in additional supplies of wheat, and to make arrangements with the millers to store it. He and the Government must be aware that it was possible to import far more goods of all descriptions between September, 1939, and June, 1940, than it has been since June, 1940, to date. Imports in the earlier period could have been got in at a third of the present prices—that is, if they can be got to-day.

What I blame the Government for is that for six or nine months before the outbreak of war they would not allow fertilisers to be imported. Because of that, many of our crops this year are seriously threatened. There is no use in saying that the Government took every step that could have been taken. They did not. They did not take many steps that ordinary prudence would have suggested. They did not even take steps to get in supplies of certain raw materials and of other commodities which people in particular businesses advised should have been taken. There is undoubtedly a certain dislocation of trade at the moment. No one but a fool believes that that dislocation is not going to be far greater. There is no use in talking about what the Government are doing now or what they hope to do for the future, completely ignoring what they failed to do between September, 1938, and June, 1940. The speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, this evening, showed a complete absence of any plan on the part of the Government for dealing with some of the major problems that confront us in the present emergency. It showed that the Government are not, apparently, able to appreciate the seriousness of the position—that is if one is to judge by the way in which they meet the criticism offered in this House. The Minister's speech, this evening, and the speech of the Minister for Agriculture, last week, showed, in my opinion, a complete inability to appreciate the seriousness of the matters with which we are dealing, or a realisation of the gravity of the situation in which we are living. It appears to me that certain of the Ministers seem to be utterly irresponsible. One can only come to the conclusion that they themselves are beginning to realise what other people have long since realised: that they are either unable or unwilling to do the job given to them and are simply throwing their hat at it. That is the position as most people down the country see it. The strange thing about it, if it is strange, is that the most severe critics of the Government and of the manner in which they have dealt with matters arising out of the emergency, are some of their own strongest supporters.

The existing position with regard to fuel supplies is very serious. Only very limited supplies of coal are available. Limited as they are, the coal is of such an inferior quality that people are looking around for a substitute. May I suggest that the Government plan for dealing with this situation ought not to begin and end by saying: "We are making arrangements to have a two-, three, four, or five-years' normal supply of turf cut this year." The position goes further than that. Turf can be cut and saved. If given the labour and bog facilities, you could produce as much turf as would meet requirements for the next five years. Having turf in the bog and producing it is perhaps the easiest part of the problem. The most difficult part, I should say, is the distribution. Because of the petrol shortage, that is going to be ten times more difficult in the coming season than it has ever been. If the turf has to be distributed by means of a horse and car, then producers will be limited as to the distance they can take the turf, and in the amount they can supply.

We have in this country another class of fuel that would supply, to a large extent, a good part of our requirements, and that, at the same time, would provide a good deal of employment. I refer to the timber we have available. I do not like to see trees being cut down. When they are cut, my desire would be that there should be replanting. While I say that, I am aware that we have hundreds of thousands of old trees, particularly beech trees, that could be cut down and used for fuel. Some of these trees are so old and rotten that they are beginning to get dozed. They are of no commercial value. They have a certain scenic value undoubtedly. We have tens of thousands of old trees, beech, ash and even old oak trees. Some of the latter are gnarled, knotted and twisted and of no commercial value. Side by side with the cutting down of those old trees, replanting could proceed. The timber is there and the men are there, and I do not see why an effort should not be made to make this fuel available for the people. The question of transport does not enter in as much there as it does in the case of turf. I put that forward as one of the matters that might engage the attention of the Government, and as one of the matters that would give employment, particularly in country districts, to what is described as unskilled labour.

Comment on this

It is a very wise policy not to use up all your reserves at once.

Comment on this

It seems to me that there are empty fire-grates in the country because reserves are being held here in Dublin for some half-thoughtout emergency.

Comment on this

That is not so. It is not on that account it is there.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I sincerely hope that the Taoiseach, when he comes to speak, will approach the matter in a manner very different from that in which it was approached by his Minister for Industry and Commerce. I want to assure the Taoiseach that we have got to consider now plans such as the one I suggest which will give us fuel and give us work for our unemployed, particularly in the rural areas. There are thousands of homes in this country in which turf—if you gave it to them to-morrow morning at 5/- per ton—would hardly be economical, unless you gave them the proper means to burn it. There is no question at all about that. We all know very well that it is not an economic proposition to put turf into a range, for instance.

Coming to this question of unemployment, there is another matter to which I should like to refer. A while ago, the Minister touched in a sort of vague way on a matter which I touched on before. I should like to know from the Taoiseach—unfortunately the other Minister had to go away—whether any steps have been taken for classifying our unemployed, for grading them?

This year, we hope to put an additional million acres of land under the plough. In many counties, land which has not been broken for years will have to be broken, and many people who do not break the land will give the excuse which was given last year in certain counties—that labour was not available. That may be true in certain cases, but of course I believe that a great many people will be putting it forward simply as an excuse. Great as that problem may be now, if it is a problem at the moment, it will be far greater when it comes to gathering in and threshing the enormous harvest that we hope to have next September, and I should like to know whether any Department of the Government has classified the number of skilled agricultural labourers or men who have been born and reared on the land in this country.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Supplies (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

They are all classified according to the descriptions they give of themselves.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

That is one step. What I want to know is whether anybody in this Government or in any Department has thought of this: If farmers in the County Meath want, say, 2,000 agricultural labourers next August or September, and there are only 500 or 600 or 1,000 available in the County Meath, what plans are there to give them the additional number they require? If farmers in the County Limerick want an additional 1,000 or 1,500 or 2,000 agricultural labourers, what arrangements are there to provide them? Are we to go on with the old position that we are to be short of agricultural labourers in County Meath or in County Limerick while we have them in thousands in the West of Ireland? I want to say that I have seen no evidence of any plan. There may be a good deal going on that we do not see, but what we do see, far from reassuring anybody in the country is certainly making them very uneasy, because anybody following the activities, such as they are, of the Government and of the various Departments from day to day gets the impression that there is simply one muddle after another, one mistake after another, one blunder after another. That is the impression which is there not only in the minds of the members of this House but in the minds of people down the country, who are very definitely uneasy. Speaking for my own particular district, I have found that there has been a wave of depression over the people for the last month.

I do not want to worry the House with a long speech, but I do appeal to whoever is going to speak from the Government Benches on this matter to approach it in a different manner from that in which it was approached by the Minister for Industry and Com merce. This is neither the time nor the place for that sort of slick turning of phrase, that sort of flippancy, that sort of cheap debating point.

While Ministers may resent what we say sometimes, and probably have a right to resent it if you like, I think most of us here in this House do not say those things for the sake of wounding or hurting anybody; we are merely saying to the House and to Ministers here what is being said to us in the country when we meet our constituents. We are trying to put before you the situation in the country as we see it, and I think it is not going to help either the country or the Government or this House or the unemployed to get the sort of statement we got from the Minister that the unemployment position in this country to-day is far better than it has been for years, or that there are more people in employment in this country to-day than there were in 1939. Nobody believes that. We know it is not the fact. As I said at the beginning of my speech, if those are the conclusions which the Minister draws from whatever figures are put before him he ought to keep away from the figures and deal with the facts. It is futile also for the Minister to say that people are not going to the other side. They are, undoubtedly, and if it were not for the obstacles in their way they would go in far greater numbers. I would suggest to the Taoiseach that, even if he is against the motion, he ought to give serious attention to the amendment, and that he ought to tell this House what plans he has, as asked for in the amendment, so as to reassure the people in the country. Mind you, the country requires to be reassured.

Comment on this

Every member of every Party sent into this House after the last general election was sent here with a mandate to play his part in the selection of a Government, and in the influencing of Government policy and legislation during the lifetime of the Parliament. Since I came here to this House in 1922, now nearly 19 years ago, I certainly know of no period in the history of this House when the members of it had so little to say in influencing Government policy and legislation. That is true so far as it represents the position since the last general election, but it is particularly true regarding the powers of the average member of this House since the emergency arose in 1939. If the members of the House are to play their part here as representatives of the people, they must be given the necessary parliamentary facilities to do their work efficiently, and the members of the House and particularly the members of the Opposition have been denied those facilities for some considerable time.

Whenever I want to get information which might be helpful to a Deputy doing his duty here, I put down parliamentary questions. I consider it is my right to get information, within reason. In recent times every member of this small group here has put down parliamentary questions. I put down a number last month asking for information which, I believe, I am entitled to get if I have any right at all to be here. I asked for information early in February as to the quantity of fuel, imported and home-produced, which was used by different Government Departments during the last three years. Surely there would be nothing to injure the public interest by supplying me with information of that kind? I have not been given that information.

Comment on this

How did that prevent the Deputy from doing useful work in the House?

Comment on this

I wanted to find out from the answer to the question to what extent the Government were helping to develop the peat industry by having turf burned in the different Government Departments. I was anxious to know to what extent that was being done over a period of years. I was told it would take a certain number of clerks two weeks to supply me with that information. I have not got the information yet. I also put down a question with regard to the petrol position, asking what was the quantity imported over a period of years and the quantity consumed by different Government services, particularly the Army and the Gárda Síochána. I have not got that information. These are but a few of the many instances in which Deputies on this side of the House have been refused information which we are entitled to receive, and the excuse always has been that it would not be in the public interest to give the information.

The Government have set up, with the authority of the House, a number of commissions and tribunals at the expense of the taxpayers. In 1934 they set up the Banking Commission, the most important commission that, I think, ever was set up by the present Government or its predecessors. It sat for four years and reported in the early part of 1938, and up to the present time we cannot get any indication from the head of the Government, or any of the Ministers, as to the policy of the Government arising out of the report of that commission.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want the findings of the commission implemented?

Comment on this

Deputy Norton submitted a question to the Taoiseach asking for a statement of Government policy arising out of the Banking Commission's report, and the Minister for Finance said he was not yet in a position—although he must have read the report over several times—to make a statement on Government policy. Finance is at the bottom of every problem that has to be solved in this country, and if the Government cannot make up their minds, after four years, on the subject of financial policy, how can we talk about the solution of the unemployment problem or any other problem in which finance is involved? They set up a Transport Tribunal—the Minister for Supplies established one on the 7th December, 1938, and he told the members of that body, through his eloquent tongue here, that he expected their report, as it was a matter of urgency, inside a period of two months. They reported in August, 1939, and for some unknown reason, notwithstanding that this was a matter of urgent public importance—I am using the Minister's words—these documents have not been allowed to see the light of day.

A Drainage Commission was set up by the Minister for Finance a few years ago and it was composed of a number of experts. When questioned about the publication of the Drainage Commission report two weeks ago, the Minister for Finance said he had received the report, or reports, in August, 1940, but that he had not had time to consider the reports and was not in a position to make any pronouncement on Government policy. I must ask the head of the Government, if he is—and I believe he is—anxious to maintain this democratic institution, representing the viewpoint of the taxpayers, how can even his own Party, apart altogether from other members of the House, do their parliamentary work efficiently if they are not given the information to which they are perfectly entitled to have access?

I mention these matters because Deputy Mulcahy seems to think that this economic council would be a body that would hide from the House the facts which the House should know. We have not been given any facts, and I am sure that Deputy Mulcahy will not contradict what I have been saying up to the present.

Comment on this

I entirely agree with you.

Comment on this

I say that we are not given the information which will place us in a position to discharge our duties properly. If we are not in a position to try to influence Government policy and legislation, what is the use of this Assembly? The question has been asked: What is the use of the Dáil? One Deputy adds fuel to the fire when he says that we are being paid excessive allowances and expenses. When that statement was made, I am sure the Deputy did not want to throw cold water on the work of this Assembly. But that statement was made by a Deputy who has not often been seen in the House since the last general election. I am sure his name is not at the top of the division list of the Fianna Fáil Party and, consequently, he should be the last man to criticise his colleagues who are constantly here trying to save the Government when divisions are challenged. Deputy Mulcahy said there would be no difficulty in discussing economic problems publicly. We would have much less difficulty in doing so if we were given access to the documents and other information which Deputies are entitled to receive. I suggest we should have the reports of commissions set up by the decision of the House at the public expense. I submit to the head of the Government for serious consideration that it ought not to be the policy of the Government to continue to withhold essential information from Deputies who are here to help, not to hinder, not deliberately to obstruct. We will have to get this information. Our parliamentary questions should be fully answered, and we should have access to the reports of public commissions.

I was rather amused the other day when I read the announcement that the Minister for Supplies was to address a meeting of his political supporters, and the title of his address was—"Facing the Facts." The Minister will not allow us access to the facts here. He thinks it is a far better thing to refuse to furnish Deputies with the facts, and he prefers to go to a meeting of the select few in the Dolphin Hotel, or the Red Bank Restaurant, and to try to persuade the people there—it is much easier to persuade them than it is to persuade us here—that he is facing the facts. I ask for a reconsideration of the position, and an indication from the Government as to whether they believe that the members of the House cannot make a contribution to the good government of the country.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce did not treat the motion with the seriousness that a Minister should treat a proposal of this kind. I know, the head of the Government knows, and the Minister is well aware of the details behind this motion. The head of the Government knows that the proposal was put in writing, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and perhaps others of his Ministerial colleagues, were furnished with the framework of the proposed economic council. He asked us did we want an economic council of the type that existed in Germany before the war, and did we want 10, or 350 members. In a communication which was sent to the head of the Government a short time ago, it was indicated that the proposed economic council should consist of 10 or 12 persons, including the Ministers for Industry and Commerce, Supplies, Agriculture, Finance, or the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, together with representatives of labour, industry and agriculture, who would be appointed by the Government after consultation with the interests concerned.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce was, I believe, in possession of that information when he wasted about half an hour here putting questions to us as to the size of the suggested council, and the type of people who would be members of it. He asked us —and I am sure he was not serious in doing so, but was merely attempting to waste time—whether we were proposing the establishment of this council for the purpose of superseding the Government. No such thing. The council suggested, as a consultative body, presumably would have powers, and, in my opinion, should have powers, if the Government meant it to do work of a serious nature, to send for persons, papers and documents and to have access to every bit of information which would enable it—and it would include four or five Ministers— to put carefully prepared plans before the Government for their formal and final approval. If a body of this kind had amongst its members five Ministers, the plans prepared by it would surely go to a full meeting of the Government with considerable influence behind them, and I assume that there would be very little delay on the part of the Government in giving formal and final approval to whatever plans were sent up. There is no intention, and never was, on the part of any member associated with this proposal to set up a body which would supersede the Government elected by the people and responsible to this House and to the people. That, I hope, disposes of the silly type of questions which were thrown across at us by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

The motion asks the Government to select the most suitable persons from those available for work of this kind. The Government would be responsible to the House for their selection and for their activities afterwards. Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Morrissey, in opposing this proposal, are obviously wrong in suggesting that the work proposed to be done by this body could, under existing circumstances, be done better by this House in public discussion. We have not got the machinery, nor have we the information to enable us to do this work. This proposal, of course, was debated and rejected six or seven months ago on the motion for the adjournment of the House on, I think, 7th August last, but there was no definite proposal on that occasion and no division was taken on the proposal as such. The head of the Government, although he admitted on that occasion that he was the father of the suggestion when he sat on the Opposition Benches, does not now, and did not then, feel so enthusiastic about the setting up of a body of this kind. He indicated that the body, being a representative body, would be too large and, therefore, unwieldy and unworkable, and he also indicated—and it is perhaps a matter of importance—that the setting up of such a body would be likely to cause friction between different Government Departments.

I do not see how a body of the kind composed of the number and type of persons I have suggested could cause such friction. Roughly, five out of the ten or 12 members would be Ministers, and these five Ministers would come to the meetings of the council armed with all the information they could get from their own Departments, and as well as bringing representatives of industry and finance before them to give information, the council would be entitled to bring in the heads of the Civil Service.

I do not want to go into the details, but an economic council of this kind would have access to far more information than the members of the House would normally be entitled to have access to. Under existing circumstances, and with the practice of withholding information which has been followed for some considerable time, withholding the contents of the reports of public commissions and tribunals, the House could not be expected to do the work which a council with access to inside information could do. Nobody would seriously suggest that a body of 138 persons could do work as efficiently or as quickly as a body of ten or 12 persons, and I hope that if this body is ever set up by this or any other Government, it will be made as small as possible, while, at the same time, representative of the Government point of view and of the point of view of the big interests who control, or have a big say in controlling, the economic life of this country and its people.

The proposers of the amendment ask the Government to indicate their plans for the relief of unemployment, and so far as I can gather, the information supplied by the Minister for Industry and Commerce does not go very far towards adding to the information given by Ministers during the past 12 months. Is it seriously suggested by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who should know more about the employment and unemployment position than anybody else, that the position is not as bad as it was in March, 1939? I have here a list supplied to me during the last 24 hours from an authentic source, giving the numbers of members of trade unions at present unemployed. These numbers do not cover the whole industrial and agricultural field, but the Minister suggested that the only two industries more adversely affected to-day than in March, 1939, are the motor industry and the cotton industry. I certainly will not question the Minister in that regard, but is it not true that there is a greater number of workers who could be getting work in the building trade unemployed to-day than there were in March, 1939? I have here a list of the unemployed members of the Amalgamated Society of Wood Workers, the Irish National Union of Wood Workers and the Brick and Stonelayers Society, and I am absolutely certain that the numbers unemployed in these trades to-day are far greater than in March, 1939.

The Minister for Supplies must know it to be true—and the Minister for Industry and Commerce should have better knowledge of it—that there is a greater number of dockers out of work to-day in the different ports of the country than in March, 1939. I am sure my colleague sitting behind me can give very reliable information on that matter. I know it to be true that a number of foreign shipping services have been either totally or partially suspended and that services on long sea routes have been cut off. Dockers who used to get work in the ports where these ships called are out of work. Similarly, carters and other persons associated with transport and shipping services have lost their employment. The Minister for Industry and Commerce did not mention these sources of employment at all. It is quite evident to me, at any rate, no matter what figures he may have at his disposal, that an addition to the number of unemployed who formerly worked in these industries can be shown as compared with the number of unemployed in March, 1939. I am also aware, and I have figures before me to prove it, that part-time employment only is provided in a number of industrial concerns, due I suppose to the shortage of raw materials. I see in one union catering for boot and shoe workers, that there are about 1,000 workers who are employed only two days a week. I daresay that was not the position in March, 1939. I am quite certain, whether or not fulltime employment was provided for all workers in the boot and shoe trade in March, 1939, that there has been an increase since in the number who are only partially employed. That is not an improvement on the position in March, 1939.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce put another funny question to Deputies across the House. He wanted to know whether if this economic council were in existence since the emergency arose, it would have helped to improve the position in regard to supply of tea, petrol, coal or raw materials. I am fairly certain that if you had, as I am sure you would have, active and intelligent men on the proposed economic council, if the Government had seen their way to adopt this proposal, the members of that body would certainly keep themselves well-informed as to the supplies position in the country and would have kept awake Ministers who might be likely to go asleep on that very important matter. You would have, in the ordinary course, amongst the non-Ministerial members of the economic council, representatives of agriculture, industry, banking and people of that type. Surely, they would make it their business, if they were active-minded men, to inquire as to the position and probably they would be able to help the Ministry in matters of that kind if they were themselves fully and correctly informed. In any case if the economic council were in existence during that period the position could not be worsened in that respect.

With regard to the unemployment position in general, and the very limited information furnished to the House by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister did not indicate, for instance, in what measure we should be likely to increase the number of persons employed in this country as a result, say, of a greater expenditure in future on the production of native fuel. I have raised this matter in the House on several occasions by way of Parliamentary question. I have written to the Minister for Lands on the matter on a few occasions pointing out—mind you, this goes back over a few years—that there was a very large acreage of bogland inside and outside my constituency which should be taken over and worked by the Turf Development Board if the policy of the Government was to increase the consumption of native fuel. Recently in this House I asked two or three questions relating to bogs in my constituency with an area in one case of 2,000 acres and in another of 3,400 acres. The Taoiseach has repeatedly appealed to the people on this matter through the radio and on public platforms during the past couple of years. I was listening to him on one occasion on which he appealed to the people in areas where there was a large acreage of bog to produce three times as much turf as they had done in previous years. I suggest to the Taoiseach and his Ministers that production cannot be increased to any great extent while bogs ranging from 500 to 3,500 acres are left in the hands of private owners.

I have raised the question with the Minister for Lands and he indicated that in some cases that were under consideration, if the red tape regulations of the Land Commission were followed, it would take possibly years before these bogs could be taken over and divided amongst the people. Might I suggest to the Minister that he should survey the whole position from the point of view of the production of native fuel, and that he should consider the advisability of asking the Turf Development Board to take over every bog in this country over 500 acres, carry out the necessary drainage work, which can only be carried out by a body such as the board, and so provide employment in many of our provincial towns for large numbers of people who have no other avenue of employment open to them? I can cite places in my own constituency such as Mountmellick, Birr, and Mountrath, in which there are large numbers of unemployed at the present time, and in the immediate vicinity of which there are many large bogs. If these bogs were taken over and worked by the Turf Development Board many of these people could be usefully employed in producing more native fuel. That would go a long way towards reducing the amount of unemployment in some of the areas where, as I say, no other avenue of employment is open to those in need of work.

I do not know what suggestion to make in connection with the transport position in the country because I have no information, officially, at any rate, as to the contents of the famous document which the Minister for Industry and Commerce has kept in his private pigeon hole for the past eighteen months. If the Minister for Industry and Commerce would release that famous report and circulate it to Deputies, I might be able to make some suggestions whereby the principal transport concern of the country could be saved from bankruptcy and chaos. I am sorry that the present Minister for Supplies was removed, or, at least, transferred, from the office of Industry and Commerce to that of Supplies, because I believe that if he had remained in Industry and Commerce he would, with the knowledge that he has gained over a number of years, have made some attempt to carry out the undertaking he gave to the House when he set up the Transport Tribunal in September, 1938.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter has been the subject of an express motion recently.

Comment on this

There was a motion dealing with it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Hence, the matter may not be re-opened for six months.

Comment on this

I cannot, without referring to the motion, explain what the Minister did not explain.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has not explained yet why he endeavours to re-open the debate within a month of its having been decided in the House.

Comment on this

With great respect I say that the solution of the transport problem involves the employment of a large number of persons who are now unemployed. I can only bring that home to those concerned by repeating the suggestion made by Deputy Norton that if the main railway lines were electrified, it is obvious that employment would be found for a large number of people. When these chess-board like changes were made in 1939, if the present Minister for Supplies were left in Industry and Commerce, I believe he would have made some attempt to solve the problem in accordance with previous promises given by himself and his colleagues.

There is another serious matter affecting the plain people of this country at present, and it concerns mainly the administration of the Department of Supplies. That is the failure, the absolute failure, of the Minister for Supplies and those responsible to set up any effective machinery to control prices of essential commodities.

It is a glaring scandal that prices are being allowed to go up in this country in this way, at the same time as the Government says that there must be a standstill order—that wages must be kept down to the pre-war level, while prices are allowed to go up as they please. At the same time, they pretend that there is a price-control machinery in the Department of Supplies and a Prices Commission. If it were doing its job, it would be keeping down the prices of essential commodities.

Is there anybody in this House who will stand up and say publicly that the prices of essential commodities like vegetables, bacon and potatoes should be allowed to rise as they have done during the past six or 12 months? As far as I can see, the Minister for Supplies, or the people in the Department of Supplies responsible for price control, merely say: "O.K." to whatever recommendations come in from the bodies responsible for putting up prices. Even quite recently—within the last couple of weeks—in my constituency the price of an ass-load of turf went up from 2/- to 6/-. There is a member of the House listening to me who knows this to be a fact. The people who have to pay these increased prices are the people whose wages will not be increased under the policy of the present Government.

Comment on this

Is it not time he got a decent price for his ass-load of turf?

Comment on this

I, personally, am prepared to stand over an increase of prices within reasonable limits, so long as I am certain that the primary producer is the man getting the most out of the increase and that the man who produces the food and essential commodities is getting at least a profitable price. I wish to hear something from the Minister for Supplies, if and when he speaks in this debate, as to the functions and powers of the Prices Commission and whether the members of the Prices Commission, as constituted by this House, are asked to investigate the prices of essential commodities from time to time. If they are not being asked to do work of that kind, I suggest they should be, as there is no more useful work they could be asked to do. I am of the opinion that the standstill policy of the Government, in regard to keeping wages down and allowing prices to rise as they please, is bringing about a very dangerous position which is likely to lead to internal trouble and confusion in this country. That is one of the things which should be very carefully watched by the people responsible for the price control policy.

I referred to the Banking Commission. I suppose, as the Government cannot say anything about it, there is no use in my saying anything about it. We do not know the Government's policy in connection with this matter, and I suppose there is no use in referring to it. However, is it not a fact that the financial and economic policy here is to a far greater extent controlled by 30 or 40 people in this country outside this House than it is by the Government elected by the people of the country through this House?

There are 30 or 40 persons who have their fingers upon our whole economic life and who dominate and control every key industry, I think, except the Electricity Supply Board. Where do they come from and who are they? Look up a list of directors of the different banks and you will find that there are bank directors upon the boards of all the key industries except the Electricity Supply Board. Those are the people who dictate the financial and economic policy up to the present. That is why those who sit on these benches are anxious to hear—and I hope we will hear—from the Government before the life of this Dáil expires, as to whether they have any fixed financial policy arising out of the reports of the famous Banking Commission.

Dealing with finance and unemployment, I think it would not be out of place for me to quote some very important pronouncements recently made on this matter by members of the Hierarchy.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest to the Deputy that it is inadvisable to make such pastorals the subject of debate in the Dáil.

Comment on this

If the Minister for Industry and Commerce can come into the House, as he has done, and read a lengthy pronouncement from Professor Laski, a Communist, I think I am entitled to read from a pastoral letter which has a very definite bearing upon this whole proposal.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The proposal is to set up an economic council.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir, it has a bearing on the motion and the amendment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy thinks that it is seemly and proper to introduce episcopal pastorals into parliamentary debate the Chair will not prevent him. It is left to the Deputy's judgment and discretion.

Comment on this

If the document were a private one, I should not use it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair merely questions the wisdom of such quotations in contentious discussion.

Comment on this

I remember that on many occasions the statements of members of the Hierarchy were quoted here. I am certain that this is much more important than the opinion of Professor Laski, who knows nothing about this country. I am quoting from the pastoral letter of the Bishop of Clonfert:

A completely new world awaits us —a new world, perhaps, in its political changes, but certainly in its social, economic and financial framework. There is nothing divine or permanent in our present economic system and it needs change and modification to meet the changed conditions of the world and the modern needs of men. We in Ireland—

and this is not Professor Laski in England—

can do little or nothing to prevent or to check or to hasten this change, but now is the time to prepare ourselves so that we can meet it as Christian men when it does come. We need—at least so it appears to me—new concepts of society, of economics and of finance; it is necessary that we abandon the social, economic system founded on a pagan materialistic view of life and imposed on us from without, and that we adopt in their fulness the Christian ideals of society as enunciated in the Social Encyclicals.

It goes on further, to the question of unemployment, which has a very definite bearing on the shortage of money or lack of credit, or whatever you like to call it.

Why the demoralising dole when there is so much work for everyone? Is it that we lack constructive ability and that we are unable to survey and to plan on a big scale on national lines? Or is it that we have not the money?

Now, it is either one or the other, or both. I think that, after having read these brief extracts from that famous Lenten Pastoral, you will admit, Sir, that it has a very direct bearing on the subject matter of the motion and the amendment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair does not question the relevancy, but doubts the advisability.

Comment on this

I have read them all.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is a matter for the Deputy's sense of fitness.

Comment on this

Regarding the solution of the unemployment problem, I will read an extract from the speech of another famous Irishman—a layman—no less a person than the ex-President of the Federation of Irish Manufacturers, Mr. J.J. Walsh, who was a member of Mr. Cosgrave's first Government. Speaking to his friends in the Federation some time ago—and, presumably, in the hearing of the Minister for Industry and Commerce—he said "it would be a good policy for the Government to employ some of the thousands of unemployed in such work as afforestation and drainage, even if, in so doing, further taxation eventuated." That was from a man who does not believe in squandering money. Mr. Walsh further pointed out that money expended in this way "served the dual purpose of increasing their spending power and, at the same time, creating real wealth."

Comment on this

Will the Deputy vote for increased taxation?

Comment on this

If Mr. J.J. Walsh says he is prepared to do so, I am prepared also.

Comment on this

I doubt that. Did the Deputy ever vote for a tax in his life?

Comment on this

Indeed, I did. I was often severely censured for doing so. The Division Lists will tell the tale against me—if it is against me. It is very useful to quote—and I am glad I have had the opportunity—from the pronouncements of distinguished Irishmen, to refute the type of argument which the Minister for Industry and Commerce used when he read from the speech of two years ago of Professor Laski. I want to say, in conclusion, that I believe that this House, the Government or the proposed economic council cannot do their job efficiently in the matter of dealing with the problems that confront us in this country until the Government make up their own minds and tell the members of this House and the members of the economic council, if and when it is established, what their financial policy is. In the present state of affairs you are just carrying on from one day to another, hoping that the next day that comes will tell a better story than the day that went before it. There are other matters that might be mentioned in connection with a motion of this kind, but I realise that there are many other Deputies in the House who are very anxious to speak, and I have no desire to hold them up any longer on the matter. The proposal for the establishment of this economic council was put forward with the sincere intention of assisting the Government in this country and helping them to solve the terrible and pressing problems before them. Nobody on these benches, and, I am sure, nobody in the House, envies the men who sit on the Government Benches to-day, and I think that the head of the Government and all his Ministers may well admit that the Parties sitting on this side of the House have given them every consideration and every help, especially since the emergency arose, and that they have given every indication of their desire to help rather than to hinder. I and my colleagues believe that one of the best things that could be done in order to help the Government would be to set up a small body of the type suggested by us—not for the purpose of superseding the Government elected by the people, but for the purpose of helping them to discharge their duties more efficiently and more quickly than at present.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Supplies (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

I am very glad that the spirit moved Deputies Norton and Davin to put this motion down for discussion, and that this discussion is, in fact, taking place. No doubt, it was the intention of both Deputies to help the Government, and they will be glad to know that the Government appreciates that help. It is important, really important, that this proposal, put forward conjointly by the Labour Party and by the Irish Times, for the establishment of a national economic council, should be killed and, being killed, decently buried. So long as that idea survives so also will survive the idea that there is some organisational device, some general plan, some trick of finance by which we can get rid of all our present difficulties. That is not true. The most important thing that this Dáil can do at the present time is to get it into the heads of the people of this country— they have got to get it into their own heads first—that there is no such arrangement by which we can get rid of all our difficulties. These difficulties, arising out of the shortage of supplies, bringing with it a slowing down in industrial activity which will mean growing unemployment, cannot be ended so long as the conditions which produce them exist, and these conditions are outside our control. No economic council, no plan, no rearrangement of the bankers of the country on the lines Deputy Davin would suggest, will possibly end these difficulties until the conditions that caused them are themselves ended. We must get that fact realised and into the minds of the people of this country, because it is only when there is a widespread public realisation of the inevitability of these difficulties in our present circumstances that we will get proper attention concentrated upon our task, our real task—the task of taking such action as is open to us to minimise the consequences of these difficulties, the task of ensuring that the exceptional hardship that may be caused for individuals will be reduced by a proper sharing of the burden over the whole community.

This idea of an economic council was debated here before. It was debated in times of peace, in relation to the problems of peace. It is revived now in times of war, in relation to the problems of war. Both Deputies Norton and Davin, who spoke upon it, appeared to have the most hazy ideas as to what the constitution and functions of this economic council would be, but Deputy Norton at least made it clear that it should be given certain responsibilities. Lord Baldwin, when Prime Minister of England, said that all his experience had taught him that the acme of political wisdom was to put legal responsibility only where there was real power. All history teaches us the danger of power without responsibility, but the Labour Party want to try the experiment of responsibility without power. They are going to give to this economic council—whoever constitutes it or whatever its mode of operation may be—responsibility, the responsibility, according to Deputy Norton, of intensifying agricultural production, the responsibility of conserving our supplies of food stuffs, the responsibility of surveying our industrial position, the responsibility of regulating prices, the responsibility of ensuring that farm workers and labourers will get a fair return for their labour, the responsibility of organising national credit to finance new activities.

How is it contemplated that this council is going to discharge these responsibilities? It is going, apparently, to produce reports which, according to Deputy Norton, should be respected by the Government, and while they are at labour producing these reports the Departments of State that have the power, the legal power, to deal with these matters, are to be standing idly, presumably, twiddling their thumbs. That is no method to recommend or on which to proceed in a time of crisis like the present. If we had 50 years of peace, with no pressing economic problems and with no matters calling for urgent attention, we might try that experiment of the Labour Party, but in times like the present, with circumstances changing from day to day, and when nobody can foretell with any confidence what the conditions will be or are likely to be to-morrow or next week, there must be a complete concentration of power and responsibility, complete contact between those who are responsible for devising and formulating the plan and the organisation responsible for carrying out that plan. You cannot divorce one responsibility from the other, and it would be the height of folly to attempt it in our present circumstances.

However, the proposal has been put forward by the Labour Party and also by the Irish Times, and we have got to get rid of this idea because, I believe, that there are people in the ranks of the Labour Party who could contribute commonsense ideas and suggestions if these preconceived notions were got rid of. You can hypnotise a hen by sticking its beak to a chalk line; you can hypnotise a rabbit by making it look at a shilling; and you can hypnotise the Labour Party by a phrase. They have succeeded in hypnotising themselves by using this phrase “national economic council” without precisely knowing what it means. We want to wake them up so that they can contribute to the debates in this House in a much more important manner than they have done heretofore. They have got the responsibility, which they do not appear to fully recognise, of assisting this Dáil by giving to it its views on the problems of the class that they represent. They are not the exclusive representatives of that class, but they do claim to have made a special study of these problems. It is in relation to these particular problems that we most want advice at the present time, because, in the long run, all the troubles arising out of our condition, all the problems arising out of the war, will bear most heavily upon the shoulders of the working class, unless we can devise ways and means of shifting them, in part at least, on to the shoulders of others.

We are told by Deputy Norton that if such an economic council as he contemplates had existed in the past, all the alleged mistakes for which he holds the Government responsible would never have been made. A large part of Deputy Norton's speech was designed to ensure that the Government could not escape any blame for these mistakes which he alleged against it. He recited a long litany of things which might have been done otherwise if the Government had been wiser, or if this economic council had been in existence. Deputy Mulcahy pleaded here for the Government not to defend itself when attacked. I do not think that is precisely the way in which he expressed it——

Comment on this

I do not think it is.

Comment on this

——but that is in fact what he meant. He urged that when the Government is criticised it should not resent that criticism. I think I can say that the Government, although composed of human beings, with ordinary feelings——

Comment on this

And failings.

Comment on this

——are not more likely to resent constructive criticism than anybody else, but when Deputy Mulcahy was pleading with the Government not to resent constructive criticism, he was in fact asking it also to accept without question criticism of another kind. He might, at least, have addressed a plea to his own colleagues before he came to lecture us. Immediately following him, from the ranks of his own Party, there came Deputy Morrissey, and Deputy Morrissey's whole speech was designed to ensure that the Government would not escape any blame he could put upon it for the conditions that now exist. In fact, he used a phrase in which he said it was no use talking about what the Government is doing now, or is going to do; what he wanted to talk about is what the Government is to be blamed for. And, of course, Deputy Norton was mainly concerned, in talking about these past events, in ensuring that, so far as he could arrange it, all the responsibility for present conditions would be placed upon the shoulders of the Government. No doubt, he very conveniently offered the Government an opportunity of passing the buck to a national economic council. The Government does not want that opportunity. It is taking full responsibility for everything it has done in the past, for what it is doing now, and for what it may do in the future. It is not going to share that responsibility with anybody, much less attempt to pass it on to some organisation set up for that express purpose.

It is very interesting to know now that the Labour Party foresaw everything that was going to happen since 1938. No doubt some Deputies were surprised to hear that assertion from Deputy Norton, that they foresaw with such extraordinary accuracy the whole development from peace to war, the outbreak of the war, the precise course of the war, exactly the countries that became involved in the war. The only complaint we can make against them now is the fact that they kept that knowledge to themselves. Why did not they tell us then? It is so easy to be wise after the event that Deputies opposite should not fall into the very obvious trap of basing criticisms upon knowledge which they now have, which have no relation to the suggestions they made before the event. Unfortunately for them, all the speeches they made about these problems are on record. Every idle word they spoke was recorded and is now available in evidence against them. They did not know all about these things in advance. They did not make these suggestions concerning supplies of wheat and tea and petrol, until the circumstances of shortage had actually arisen. We know that. They cannot go back over the records of the House and say: "We knew about it then and, what is more, we warned you about it then." No doubt, Deputies opposite from time to time made various suggestions without much regard to their practicability. In fact, if we are confined to the activities of the Labour Party, one can say there is probably nothing on earth about which they did not make some suggestion at some time. But that is not good enough. There is no use telling us that, if we had a national economic council established a number of years ago, it would have foreseen precisely the need for ships that would arise in the autumn of 1941 and would have taken steps to establish a mercantile marine, even though it involved a subsidy of £2,000,000 a year, and even though we were assured the members of the Labour Party would have gone like one man into the Division Lobby to vote for the tax on tea, sugar or anything else that was necessary to provide that £2,000,000.

There was a proposition in those years about which the Labour Party had a different view. Ships, of course, are only important for what they will bring to us, and one of the commodities which are in short supply and about which difficulties have arisen and will arise is petrol. Would a national economic council of the kind suggested by the Labour Party, if they knew all about the course of impending events as accurately as Deputy Norton did, have said: "Well, it might be a good idea to establish in this country a national refinery to get the maintenance of our oil supplies into the hands of an independent Irish company, a company which would have a number of tankers on the Irish register"? And, if they had done that, would the Labour Party then have gone out on a rip-roaring campaign throughout the country to see their idea was carried out—a campaign such as they undertook to prevent that idea being operated by the Government?

Comment on this

Do not suggest such things.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Hickey suggest they did not?

Comment on this

Do not suggest such things.

Comment on this

There is no good going into that at the moment. The files of the paper which the Labour Party published in relation to that one matter are available for examination if anyone wants to examine them.

Comment on this

Is this about ships?

Comment on this

Tankers.

Comment on this

We had seven, had we not?

Comment on this

We had seven.

Comment on this

What happened to them?

Comment on this

I am concerned here at the moment with this contention on the part of the Labour Party, first, that they foresaw all these events and, secondly, that even if they did not, a national economic council, if it had existed, would have foreseen them and would have made that provision. We had not got the refinery when the war started and a large part of the responsibility for the delay in establishing it rests upon the shoulders of the Labour Party and upon the shoulders of others who participated in the campaign to delay the establishing of it.

Comment on this

Supposing we had, what would be our situation?

Comment on this

The situation would be, our oil supplies would now be provided for by an independent national organisation. At the present time they are being supplied by international organisations to which this market is such a small item in relation to their total sales that it is not to be wondered if they give it only very secondary consideration. That is inevitable, but if we had a national organisation, which would have no other concern except to see our supplies were kept up, our position might have been better. I cannot say with any certainty it would have been but, at least, it is a reasonable assumption.

Comment on this

It is a bad conclusion to that long argument.

Comment on this

I am not going to deal with Deputy McGilligan by way of cross-examination.

Comment on this

Why did you give away the tankers?

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy complained here that Ministers frequently make official pronouncements of importance outside this House. Did it ever strike the Deputy that the sole reason why Ministers resort to making announcements outside this House is because they are permitted to talk without interruption? As far as I am concerned it has been my experience that when I want to get some particularly important pronouncement across to the public it was much better to make it outside this House.

Comment on this

Hear hear.

Comment on this

In Dublin and elsewhere I know that the audiences will not be as disorderly as some Deputies opposite.

Comment on this

Then this House should not be here.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not be here. The House should be here, and there should be responsible disciplined Deputies in it.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I wonder would the Fianna Fáil clubs pay the Minister's salary for addressing them.

Comment on this

In any event the tankers are still outstanding.

Comment on this

The House is entitled to discuss any question it wishes, but if we are going to have that type of debate, which consists only of placing upon the Government's shoulders responsibility for past events, and the reactions of past events on present circumstances, then Deputy Mulcahy need not appeal to us, in resenting criticism, not to hit back as hard, because we will probably hit harder. If we are going to have that type of debate which Deputy Mulcahy visualises, in which all Deputies would contribute their best ideas for a solution of present difficulties, and that the Government would accept these ideas for what they are worth, and examine them in the spirit offered, then it is asking a bit too much to have this rehash of past events along the lines that Deputy Norton and Deputy Morrissey chose to give it.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I did not deal with past events.

Comment on this

The Deputy was solely concerned to ensure that the Government was blamed, and that it carried the blame for the difficulties that we have at the moment. I will deal with that later. Deputy Norton was on the same subject.

Comment on this

What was that?

Comment on this

Then there was the question of the Government's responsibility for the inadequacy of our present wheat supply. Deputy Mulcahy referred to that, but on more reasonable lines. He said that in 1939 the Government was so concerned with the summoning of the Army reserve of the Defence Forces, and taking other measures of protection of a defence character, that there was no evidence that agricultural production, and the problem of increasing agricultural production, was getting the attention it needed. Deputy Norton said the same thing, only he put it in this form, that if a national economic council existed in 1939, the problem of increasing our wheat production and other forms of agricultural production would have got more attention. Deputy Morrissey will admit that he said the same thing.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I did not.

Comment on this

I did not say that either.

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey dealt with it in a somewhat different way. He said that it had become obvious to him that in 1941 no more cereals could be imported, and that the Government had taken no steps to increase supplies.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Something to that effect. Let us consider what happened. In the autumn of 1939 the Government passed legislation for compulsory tillage. It undertook a widespread publicity campaign to get more wheat grown. It also increased the guaranteed price, which was then operative, for Irish-grown wheat. These three measures were designed to encourage maximum production of wheat from Irish soil. Deputies opposite who think that the Government did not do enough in these years might now examine their consciences, and ask themselves to what extent they helped the Government then or in subsequent months to secure the increased acreage. No doubt some Deputies opposite were as anxious as the Government that that result should be obtained. Were they all? Was it their official Party policy at that time to help the Government to get an increased acreage of wheat? If it was not do they think it honest now to blame the Government when, despite the measures the Government took by compulsory legislation, by a publicity campaign, and increased prices, they did not get in 1940 a much larger increase in the acreage under tillage than the 350,000 acres, which, in fact, the tillage area was increased by in that year? But that was not enough. We had got to get a bigger increase. That increase, nevertheless, was secured very largely as a result of the measures taken in 1939 and in the early months of 1940.

Comment on this

Did the Minister say that there were an additional 350,000 acres under wheat?

Comment on this

No, in tillage generally. It is quite true that the situation concerning the import of cereals from abroad deteriorated rapidly towards the end of last year. Deputy Morrissey said that it was obvious in September, 1940, that deterioration was taking place. It was not so obvious to the Government in September. Let me say that the Government was fully alive to the possibilities of the situation. In discussions which took place at the Cabinet, and Committees of the Cabinet, as to the plans necessary to provide against various possibilities, all these possible developments were taken into account and examined.

In September, 1940, we were still importing wheat and able to charter vessels to import wheat. There appeared to be no difficulty in securing sufficient ships to import the balance of the wheat required to supplement our own yield and to meet requirements here. The one announcement we made in September, 1940, was that to the extent that available tonnage was curtailed that there would be a diminution in the importation of maize, that as far as it was necessary to do so, the whole of the available tonnage would be utilised for the importation of wheat, and that maize would have to take second place to wheat when only a restricted number of ships were available. It was very much later in the year that the position arose in which Grain Importers, Ltd. reported that they were no longer able to get ships for the carriage of any kind of grain to this country in 1941.

Comment on this

That was early in November, 1940?

Comment on this

I am not going to answer Deputy McGilligan because he is too disorderly. In September, 1940, the Government again took action to secure an increase in the acreage under wheat. Again it proceeded on the same lines as in the previous year. The area fixed under the Compulsory Tillage Order, requiring farmers to till, was increased, the price guaranteed to farmers was increased, and another publicity campaign was undertaken by the Government to impress upon farmers not merely the importance but also the advantage both to the country and to themselves of an increased acreage under wheat. Towards the end of the year, when difficulties had become aggravated as a result of the disappearance of Greek ships, the Government further acted upon the same lines. Again there was an increase in the acreage required under the Compulsory Tillage Order, and a widespread publicity campaign which brought the full facts of the situation to the knowledge of every individual was undertaken. Deputies opposite, no doubt, have helped and helped considerably in that campaign. I urge them in their own interests as well as in the interests of the country, that it is wiser for them to confine their present activities to giving that help now rather than going back to the year 1939, for the purpose of blaming the Government for not having done more than the Government thought it necessary to do.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

To October and November, 1940.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy's memory is correct. I have listened to speeches from Deputy Norton and Deputy Mulcahy about September, 1939.

Comment on this

September, 1940.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton did not stop at 1939. He said that there would be no difficulty if a national economic council had been in existence.

Comment on this

Another mistake.

Comment on this

The Minister completely misrepresents my reference to agricultural production.

Comment on this

I have no intention of misrepresenting the Deputy. As I understood it, the Deputy's complaint was that the Government in September, 1939, devoted far too much attention to the completion of defence preparations, and not sufficient attention to the problem of agriculture and increased agricultural production in that year.

Comment on this

My point was that in September, 1939, we made formal representations on that point.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton, however, had a further complaint, that the Government had always been telling the public that everything was all right, which was proof of the fact that the Government were not undertaking any real planning, and that, consequently, these sudden shortages of petrol, tea, coal, and wheat caused considerable public dismay. Deputy Norton had no foundation whatever for the assertion that he made. The Government from the beginning of the war were continuously reminding the country that the war was bound to mean for us a period of economic stress; that it would mean inevitably a curtailment of overseas supplies; and that eventually that curtailment of overseas supplies would mean a diminution of industrial activity. I made a speech in Cork the week before the war started, in which I spoke to that effect. Every other member of the Government spoke to that effect. On every occasion on which this matter was discussed, Deputies and the public were warned that, even though the position at a particular time might be satisfactory in so far as stocks available in the country were concerned, there could be no certainty as to the future; that the one thing certain in war was the probability that unforeseen and unforeseeable events would upset all pre-existing plans and create a new situation which would call for new plans.

At various stages during the course of 1940 I reported to the Dáil here concerning the stock position in respect to wheat, tea, and other commodities. I was able to report all during last year every time I spoke that there was no shortage in relation to these commodities. The shortages in relation to all these commodities arose almost simultaneously towards the end of last year and the beginning of this year, and the problems which these shortages have created for us are only a foretaste of those that are to come, because the circumstances that made it less easy to import wheat also affected the other commodities. All these problems were bound to arise simultaneously. It is, of course, open to Deputies to say that we could have foreseen more accurately the course of events. The answer to that is that we did not know when precisely the war was going to start, over what area it would extend, what countries would be involved, and what its course was going to be. We had to plan against a number of possible developments. We did succeed in making plans which secured for this country during a lengthy period after the outbreak of the war that no serious effect on its economic life was felt.

When these developments towards the end of last year began to intensify all our problems a new situation was created. At the earliest possible opportunity the public were informed that a new situation had arisen, and that, in that new situation, it would depend upon ourselves alone whether we would meet the problems created by the shortages through the utilisation of our own resources and of our own supplies. This House and the country must face the fact that our future safety, the maintenance of our industrial activities, the maintenance of our essential commodities, will depend entirely on the success of our efforts to get them produced here. There can be no certainty that we are going to import any substantial quantities from outside.

Various arrangements are being attempted, various possibilities are being explored, some of which may succeed in opening the means of transport to us. If they do, well and good.

But there is no basis on which we can plan except the basis that these sources of supply are cut off from us and are going to remain cut off until the war is over. On that basis we have to organise internal production of the goods, or substitutes for the goods, that were formerly imported. That is not a matter for a national economic council, but for individuals, with the specialised knowledge which they can get from experts, going out themselves to do the work. It is not necessary to have somebody sitting in a back room writing reports for others to act upon. Those who decide the policy will themselves have to put it into operation, and that is the only sound way of getting effective results.

We have taken various measures to cope with the situation. The Taoiseach informed the House last week of the establishment of an emergency scientific research bureau charged with the responsibility of investigating the possibility of producing substitutes from our own resources for materials that were formerly imported, and which are now not available. We are carrying out a systematic examination of the position of each individual industry, the extent to which its raw materials can be done without, the extent to which they can be substituted by other materials available within the country, the extent to which existing stocks may have to be conserved in order to ensure that the forms of production which will be maintained are those most essential to our circumstances. That systematic review is proceeding. The Government are giving consideration to the problem of having to provide work on public schemes on a larger scale to offset increasing industrial employment. They recognise the fact that the organisation of such schemes of work may be more difficult in the absence of external supplies or certain mechanical equipment previously considered necessary, and they are endeavouring to prepare a programme of works of that nature which could be undertaken with the resources at present available within the country.

We recognise that it will not be possible to deal with all forms of industrial unemployment by schemes of public works. But we do know that if we can keep up the purchasing power of a substantial section of the workers it will have beneficial reactions over a much wider circle, because the circulation of that purchasing power will prevent the development of unemployment which might otherwise be inevitable in secondary occupations. By various measures of that kind, together with the adaptation of our social services to the new circumstances, whether on the lines suggested by Deputy Mulcahy, or some other lines, we can do all that we can hope to do in present circumstances, and that is to minimise the effects of those difficulties and to share the burden, so that no individual will have to carry an undue proportion of it.

Comment on this

Do you not think that the unemployed had their dependents are bearing too much of the burden at present?

Comment on this

I am prepared to discuss at any time how the position of the unemployed can be modified. Of course, it is possible to speak for a long time about the plight of the individual, to describe the circumstances of the individual, and to ask others better circumstanced, such as members of this House or businessmen outside, whether they would like to be circumstanced as that individual is. It is possible to quote from documents written by Padraig Pearse and others as to the inadequacy of £1 per week for the purpose of maintaining and educating a family. All these things get us nowhere. What does get us somewhere is this, we have got to ensure that, to the limit of our available resources, each individual in the community is protected against the possibility of destitution, with, however, a sufficient incentive to go out and help himself by whatever means are open to him.

Comment on this

What comes before the family if you say that what Patrick Pearse said does not matter?

Comment on this

I have not said that it does not matter. What I say does matter is this, that any plans that we make for dealing with these matters must be effective plans. You cannot feed the unemployed on phrases. If there is an unemployment assistance scheme which the Deputies opposite are anxious to get extended, I ask them why it was not there when they constituted the Government. I ask them, also, to remember that when these new social services were being brought into operation, and when new taxes had to be imposed in order to finance them, we did not get much support from the Deputies opposite for the imposition of the new taxes. These are all matters concerning which the Government have got a record of achievement to their credit. That record should be a guarantee to the people of this country that, in any new set of circumstances which may arise, the Government will be prepared to take effective action to deal with that situation, while others here are only prepared to make speeches.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say that in Gardiner Street?

Comment on this

If I spoke in Gardiner Street I would not be interrupted. I would get a peaceful, orderly hearing from people better able to appreciate what I say than some of the Deputies.

Comment on this

The Minister could not get into it without a police escort.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin referred to a large number of matters in support of his statement that he is not able to do his work effectively as a member of this House because certain information is denied to him. The Deputy, I suggest, could do a lot of useful work in the House with the information available to him. If he concentrated his energies on the information available to him he has scope to do a lot of useful work instead of spending his time complaining about the refusal of the Government to tell him the quantity of turf that was burned in Government grates last winter. Information of that kind can be of very little use to his constituents. When Deputy Davin wants to know what number of persons will be employed if we secure a certain increase in the production of turf in this country, the reply is that it is not possible to get him the information. If the Government are going out to try to secure a very substantial increase in the production of turf it is doing so for the purpose of getting turf—not as a relief scheme and not as a means of off-setting unemployment in other industries. The Government's primary purpose is to get the turf produced economically and efficiently, so that the fuel will be available to the public at the lowest price possible.

Various problems of that kind will arise during the coming year, problems which the Government will have to decide and, very frequently, the decisions which they will have to take will not be easy. If the raw materials for a particular industry show signs of running out, so that one can say with some degree of accuracy that in six or nine months' time production in the industry must cease, shall we, as might be suggested, endeavour to maintain the largest number of people in employment for the longest possible period, even though it means that they will not get a full week's work or a full week's wages, thus sharing over the fullest possible number the diminishing returns which the industry is able to give, but knowing that such a system will result in higher prices, or shall we concentrate the total production possible in a limited number of factories, shutting down the others and disemploying staffs, knowing that while we are increasing the number who will be without work, we will nevertheless be securing the industrial goods concerned at the lowest price, and will have them available for the public at the lowest price possible?

These are some of the questions which the Deputies opposite might consider and give thought to. These are problems about which the Government will have to take decisions, decisions which are bound to be criticised by those who are adversely affected by them. The Government know that they cannot expect to avoid adverse criticism. They know that when people suffer, as they are bound to suffer in consequence of the inability of the Government to increase supplies from abroad, or to expand some form of internal production upon which employment depends, that people are going to blame them. We are not going to try to avoid that blame, if we feel that there is anything that we could have done which would have left the position better. Where we know that the circumstances were entirely outside our control and outside the control of anybody occupying our position—then we will say so.

Deputy Norton spoke to-day about the widening pool of unemployment caused by the scarcity of petrol, and in doing so, used the old metaphor of dropping a stone in the middle of a lake. We know that a scarcity of petrol can cause unemployment, but every possible step that could be taken was taken to increase the importation of petrol. It has been possible to increase to some extent this month the total quantity in respect of which licences were issued as compared with last month. What the position is going to be next month, I cannot say. With good luck we will be able to keep up next month the same rations that were available this month. With bad luck, there may be no petrol at all available for anybody. It is, I think, commonly recognised that the war has not yet reached the stage of maximum intensity. Should it develop to a much greater intensity than anything we have known, particularly in the immediate vicinity of our country, that is bound to have adverse reactions here, which no plan that the Government or any economic council might adopt, could possibly prevent.

Deputy Davin spoke about the powers and functions of the Prices Commission. Time and again, in the course of discussions in this House, I have asked Deputy Davin to try and get his mind clear on one fact, namely, that the Prices Commission is not functioning at the present time in relation to the day-to-day control of prices. I am functioning through a section of my Department. The powers conferred upon me by the Emergency Powers Act are much wider than those conferred by the Prices Control Act under which the Prices Commission was set up.

The prices branch of my Department, acting upon my instructions, is endeavouring to ensure that the price of any commodity will not be increased except in consequence of some increased cost arising outside of this country. I do not know if I have made that clear. When one sets out to consider the prices that will be permitted to be charged for coal, one decides that there has to be allowed in the price any increase in the wholesale price of the coal and any increase in the price of the transport of coal to this country. One may decide that no allowance will be made in respect of increased costs arising here, such as an increase in wages to workers, in order to keep prices down, or by way of higher profits to distributors. In fact, the distributor is not even being allowed the same rate of profit as heretofore. His rate of profit is being reduced to ensure that the actual monetary return which he gets from his business will be the same under war conditions as it was in times of peace.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think that system is in operation all over Ireland?

Comment on this

I know quite well it is not in operation all over Ireland. Time and again I have spoken of the difficulties of ensuring an effective system of price control in relation to a number of articles. When one deals with cement, sugar, flour—with any commodity that is produced only in one quality and sold in bulk—price control is easy; but, when you come to deal with commodities that are produced in greater variety, price control becomes very difficult. When you set out to deal with commodities that are sold in an almost infinite number of varieties, then price control, at the source, becomes a matter of impossibility, and reliance must be placed entirely upon individual complaints resulting in the investigation of individual charges.

Comment on this

I put a suggestion before the Minister to-day, which would help, and it was turned down.

Comment on this

I am going to do better than that.

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this

I am going to arrange that every retailer selling a commodity in respect of which difficulty has arisen or may be anticipated will be registered, and that it will be a condition of registration that reasonable prices are charged, so that a retailer who is proved to have been guilty of a gross over-charge will be removed from the register, and by removal from the register kept from engaging in that business so long as that condition of affairs exists.

That is, I admit, a severe penalty, or may be a severe penalty in individual cases, but having regard to the difficulty of enforcing a system of control for retail prices there must be a severe penalty if that control is to be effective at all. There is no possibility of my being able to send an inspector into Arnott's to examine the prices charged for every commodity in that shop for the purpose of ensuring that no excess profit is being taken. We can only deal with commodities of that kind sold by retail on the investigation of individual complaints, and by making the penalty so severe that people will not take the risk of offending against the regulation.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that coal which was imported last August should be charged at the current price to-day?

Comment on this

Coal imported last August is not being sold at the current price to-day. The Deputy can produce any proof he likes, and if he does I will undertake to have it examined by people who are fully competent to do so. I say here that in every case where a price was fixed for coal by my Department regard was had to the stocks in existence at the time, and the price which might have been permitted in consequence of the increased price of coal abroad or the increased cost of transportation was reduced to ensure that no additional profit would be taken on existing stocks.

Comment on this

I am speaking only of coal imported last August.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister must be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

It is easy enough for Deputies opposite to come here and complain about increases in the price of coal. I say there has been no increase in the price of coal with the consent of my Department except in consequence of an increase in the wholesale price in England or an increase in the cost of transporting it from England. It is true that the price charged us for coal in England has advanced frequently and substantially since the war started. There is nothing we can do about it. When the war broke out we had an agreement with the British Mines Department under which we on our side undertook to buy all our coal from Great Britain, and they on their side undertook to supply that coal on a fixed scale of prices. That agreement had months to run after the date of the beginning of the war, but some time after that date the British members of the committee which was responsible for the fixing of the price came over here and said that that price would have to be increased.

Undoubtedly, as might have been expected, we referred to the fact that this contract had not yet expired, and that their obligation was to supply us with coal at that price for a stated period of time. They said: "That is so, and you can maintain that schedule if you like, but in the circumstances prevailing in England we cannot guarantee that you will be supplied. If you want to be supplied with coal you will have to agree to those increased prices which have already become operative in Great Britain and elsewhere." We agreed to that in order to ensure that supplies of coal would be available. Since then, that agreement has expired. There is no possibility of our getting coal elsewhere, and whatever price the Mines Department fixed for the coal to be supplied to us is the price we have to pay. That price had gone up and up as the cost of production in England has increased. Furthermore, the cost of importing that coal from England has increased considerably because transport and freight charges have risen, and risen considerably in the case of ports like Cork and others which are further away from the ports of shipment in Great Britain. All those increases have had to be reflected in the price.

Comment on this

Not since last August, surely?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister must be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

When increases in the pit-head price in Great Britain or in the cost of transporting the coal to this country took place, my Department took under consideration the extent to which retail prices here should be increased, and, in deciding on the extent to which they should be increased, they had regard to the quantity of coal in stock purchased at a lower price, and fixed a price which was fair, having regard to that increase in the pit-head price and to the quantity in stock. At least that is what they set out to do. The fixed prices published by my Department in relation to coal in particular centres were prepared on that basis. It is not true that manufacturers and importers are allowed to charge as they please, as was stated by Deputy Davin. Shortly after the outbreak of the war, we made a stand still order in respect of all prices. It is quite true that that order may have been evaded here and there. I recognise the possibility that in certain circumstances people may be prepared to pay more, and if they are prepared to pay more it is very easy to conspire with the trader to get the goods, in consideration of a higher price, in preference to somebody else, and there is no possibility that we will hear about it. But where a complaint has been received, full investigation has taken place, and in relation to those prices that were subject to the stand still order we have got, since it was made, more than 2,000 complaints, all of which have been investigated. A very high proportion of the complaints were discovered to be unfounded.

Comment on this

Mine was not.

Comment on this

But, in relation to a very considerable variety of articles, reductions in price were effected. In the case of manufacturers, the various firms are brought into my Department one by one, their accounts are examined by qualified accountants and their profits are controlled. Their prices are fixed where it is possible to deal with them on the basis of fixed prices, and their profits are regulated where it is not possible to effect the same result on the basis of fixed prices. I am prepared to agree that circumstances may arise in the course of this year which will make the problem of price regulation a much more important one than it was last year, and a much more difficult one than it was last year, and we may find it necessary to supplement our existing machinery. We may have to resort to much more drastic measures in order to prevent a shortage of commodities resulting in famine prices. We are prepared to do that. I think it is unfair to a number of men who have been doing very hard work and have been remarkably successful in preventing a rapid inflation of prices in this country, to suggest that there is no control in operation at all. In any event, whatever machinery is there can be expanded to deal with new circumstances, or can be adapted in whatever way is considered necessary from time to time.

There is nothing which this national economic council could do in relation to a matter of that kind. That is an administrative work which has been undertaken by a Department of State, and concerning which the Dáil is the only body which should be entitled to satisfy itself that all necessary steps have been taken and that the machinery of administration is working efficiently. I do not profess that I am going to be able to satisfy every member of the Dáil, but I do think I would be able to satisfy the great majority of members that the measures in operation are reasonably capable of dealing with the problem of price control as it now exists, and I can assure the House and those members that if that problem becomes worse then the machinery will be adapted in consequence. There is, of course, a very large number of problems arising every day over the whole field of industrial and commercial activity. That is inevitable. Those problems are going to continue to arise until the war is over —they may not even end with the war —but no system of advanced planning will make it easier to deal with them. No economic council or no Government or no Government Department could sit down now and think out ahead a long term plan for dealing with those problems, because they do not know what the future holds. Nobody speaking in this Dáil in March, 1940, could have foretold the events of 1940. Nobody could have foretold the collapse of France, the blockading of Europe, or the entry of Norway, Holland, Belgium or Greece into the war.

No Deputy opposite knew for a certainty that these things were going to happen. We did not know. When we were marshalling our ideas with regard to the year 1940, we had not the knowledge that we now have as to how the events in that year were likely to develop. We have as little knowledge now about the year in front of us as we had then about the year 1940, and we cannot plan against the unforeseen events of this year with any certainty that our plans will be suitable to the conditions that will arise.

Comment on this

That is fine.

Comment on this

We are taking into account various possibilities. We are preparing tentatively and provisionally to deal with various possibilities, but to have one body concentrating on advanced planning would be folly. The one thing that is essential in present circumstances is to keep the most intimate possible contact between those responsible for the planning and those responsible for the administration, so that there will be the least possible delay between the planning and the implementation of the idea. It is for that reason, as well as a number of others, that I think this motion should be rejected.

Comment on this

The Minister used to like a bit of in-fighting in this House; nobody enjoyed a debate better than he did when he felt he had merits. To-night he announced that he would prefer the quietude of a Dublin audience, four speakers in evening dress, a platform, and no rowdy allowed to interrupt, or the quietude of a Fianna Fáil cumann where he has it all his own way, where he is only one step from the refuge of the wireless, so much enjoyed by some of his colleagues, where he cannot have the remotest possibility of being answered back.

There never was a motion which allowed for so complete an answer as this. The Minister is asked merely to place the facts before the House. In one of the proposals before the House the Minister is asked to set up an economic council to plan measures to deal with the existing situation, and in the other he is asked for the revelation of whatever plans the Government have prepared, if any, with regard to the relief of distress and the maintenance of employment. The Minister could have answered these motions effectively by saying: "Here are our plans; what better can anybody else offer?" Instead of which he sighs for the quietude of a Dublin audience or a Fianna Fáil cumann, where nobody will interrupt or ask him nasty questions. In one flight of oratory he referred to the obstructions there were to Government plans with regard to the oil refinery. I thought that that project was not merely dead but entirely forgotten. The Minister was asked if the independent organisation, with its own boats, tried to get this country its crude oil supplies and he tailed off lamely with the observation: “We might have been in a better position.”

He was asked: "Had we not tankers —had not that organisation, even in its embryo state, some tankers, and where are they?" I remember a casual announcement in the early days of the war that those people thought it better to transfer registration to the other side, and the Government thought it better that that was so, and we lost the whole of the nine tankers. Two have since been sunk, but the rest are still sailing the ocean. One of the things that might possibly cause rejoicing is that tankers built in Germany are now sailing the seas under the British flag —those of them that are still afloat— but they do not belong to this country, although apparently once they did, and we let seven out of the nine, or the whole nine, go. The Minister was further asked what would be the situation with regard to these tankers if they were still afloat and bringing in crude oil. I understand that it takes three tankers of crude oil to give us the equivalent of one tanker of petrol. That would mean three tankers loaded with crude oil running the gamble of the ocean to get home here as against one cargo of petrol. If we had the oil refinery the Government would probably say: "There is the organisation; there are some boats; there is something coming in and that represents our work."

We were told that nobody could have foreseen the events of 1940, and that no one can foresee the events of the nine months ahead of us. Neither can one, but what was a department of supplies established for in the early days of 1938? What did the Minister for Supplies say he was doing in 1939 —arranging for supplies to be brought into this country, apparently feeling that there might be something in the nature of a blockade. The Minister for Supplies, we were told at the time, was interrupting his ordinary work of fostering Irish industry, taking himself and his officials three weeks off their normal tasks in order to get on to this important matter of supplies and rationing. What supplies have we got? We have not yet heard, even in respect of any single commodity, what supplies were brought in by his Department, What supplies can he say his Department was responsible for bringing in? Can he specify even one commodity?

Apparently he thought a rationing system might have to be introduced. The next time we heard of rationing was on the occasion of his address to a Fianna Fáil cumann recently, where, after the facts had been almost sufficiently strong enough to stun most men, he labels his lecture—“Facing the Facts.” How has he faced the facts, and how has he provided for the situation which is upon us? He is the person upon whom Government responsibility rests, but they have a collective responsibility, the whole of them, for his activity or lack of activity. What did he do? There is no necessity to go through the old petrol muddle and scandal again to any great extent, but, from information that has recently come to me, the position is worse now than ever I thought it was. In the last fortnight I received a letter from a constituent who put himself to me under these conditions, that he is a man who suffers from infantile paralysis and he requires an invalid's chair, which is petrol driven. If he wants to get about, to do whatever business he has to do, if he wants to get his health in the open air, or to go to Mass on a Sunday morning, he must have that chair, and it requires one gallon of petrol a month, and yet he could not get that from the Department. I wrote to him to know if it was serious, and he replied that it was. The position is that an invalid of that type cannot get even one gallon of petrol a month.

Petrol is an article in respect of which the Minister told us in a recent debate that if anyone asked him on the forenoon of Christmas Eve of 1940 what the situation was, he would have said: "As easy as ever it was." But by the afternoon of Christmas Eve the situation was changed, and it is now at the point when this sufferer from infantile paralysis cannot get 12 gallons a year. Does that represent making proper provision? Could that not have been foreseen? Could something better at least not have been done than to reduce us to that extremity? Has the Minister fully explained what happened with regard to petrol? It was not clear from his speech in the House whether the tankers were numerous or scanty in number, whether they were sunk or diverted to England. At a later stage he intervened, as if it was his all-embracing excuse: "We should have foreseen that the tankers would be sunk!" I do not know what he was Minister for Supplies for if the possibility of tankers being sunk during this war was not ever present to his mind. His excuse was that he was supposed to consider that tankers would be sunk. Not having considered that, he is able to preen himself here that he did all that any man could have done. All the invalids in the country who want to get their health or go to religious service on a Sunday cannot get the miserable ration of a gallon of petrol a month.

The Minister boasted of the Government's wheat policy, and someone asked him to keep to the present. I understand that the Minister for Industry and Commerce spent the whole night getting back to 1932. Most of his speech was about that period. What happened about wheat? Again we were told in the debate recently to which I have referred that a great organisation called Grain Importers, Limited, was set up. They were looking after imported wheat supplies, but there came a period in November of last year, and at that point Grain Importers told the Minister that for some weeks previously it had been impossible to charter a boat to carry wheat into this country.

What was the position as the Ministry knew it? Luckily, the House did not know it. The position as the Ministry knew it was that if they could get over certain critical days, they had a provision that would carry us as between certain harvests. The month of November was critical, because, if we had to jump into a campaign for increased tillage, for increased sowing of wheat, November was a very critical month, and Grain Importers, Limited, if they were doing their duty in the first week in which they found it impossible to charter a boat, and knowing also the critical portion of the year, should have told the Minister of it. Possibly they did. Possibly they told him for four weeks in succession that they had not found it possible to charter a boat, but it comes to his realisation in the beginning of November that, for some weeks back, it had not been possible to get a single boat. Did the country hear a word about that? Not until the Taoiseach went to the wireless round about Christmas night, when he appealed to America that if the blockade got any worse, would America please see that we got supplies of wheat. That was the first intimation the public got—and that was round about Christmas night—that the situation was bad, and by that time it was clear to those inside Government that no boats would sail the ocean bringing wheat to us.

There was the valuable period of November, the running-out period of December, and we had started in the very critical time of January, and it was not until something like ten days had passed that the Minister for Supplies thought fit to address members of the House asking them to indulge in a campaign for extra wheat sowings this year, as he did not believe that the provision made by the Department of Agriculture met the position. He sent around a letter which criticised the Department of Agriculture in its methods of dealing with the situation, and he had information that it was impossible to get ships to carry wheat to this country; and he had sat on that information for a valuable ten weeks. If any part of the harvest, which should have been a plentiful one and for which good preparation should have been made, turns out poor; if a very scanty period hits us as between May and the gathering of the next harvest, the people who had that information earlier, and may have had that information some time in October, if Grain Importers, Limited, were doing their duty, the people who have responsibility for Grain Importers, Limited, and who take whatever information they give them, and who sat on it for a period, will bear responsibility before the people. That is the wheat situation.

Butter is still more amazing. There was a professor long ago in a medical school in this country who used to set the young medical men, when they first began to carve the human corpse, the task of discovering what he called the great sciatic nerve, which runs like a rope through the body and which can hardly be mistaken once certain flesh is dissected, and it was his remark always when some blundering apprentice hand cut the nerve: "I asked you to find it, but you have done better. You have cut it." It took the Minister for Agriculture to go one better than the Minister for Supplies with regard to petrol and wheat. In this country we had a situation with regard to butter —the Minister for Supplies only helped a scarcity which was really brought on by events outside the country—in respect of which the Minister for Agriculture did honours work. He helped to create a scarcity. When he found it was coming, he did not close down on exports soon enough, and he left this glorious agricultural producing country in a position in which we have been rationed in regard to butter for some months past.

There came a debate here in January of this year in which the present Minister for Supplies told us that we could be quite complacent with regard to tea, that there was no reason why the people should not get their ordinary normal supplies of tea. At the moment at which he was speaking—it was on 16th January—a circular had been sent around to most of the retailers in this country, of a date of 1st January, which announced that tea supplies were irregular and that it was doubtful if they would continue. It indicated a situation in which rationing would obviously become necessary, but, on 16th January, the Minister, on his defence as he was to-night, and because tea had not then drifted into the emergency situation, preened himself about tea, and said there was no reason why the people should be anything but complacent about supplies, that they would go on. Then we had the announcement that tea was to be rationed, and the Minister at that time, beaten about the head, the impact sufficiently strong even on him of the situation with regard to petrol, wheat and tea, decides to read his lecture "Facing the Facts" to his cumann.

He has told us about the situation with regard to coal and Deputy Hickey has asked him with regard to coal brought into the country last August and the price at which it is now being sold. The Minister was asked questions about the price of coal to-day. The price of household coal imported in January, 1941, was 45/2 and in February, 1941, 46/5, and the c.i.f. value of all coal imported was 44/8 to 45/-. Let us take it at a rough and ready 45/-.

With regard to bellmen, as I understand the situation, a certain percentage of every shipload that arrives at the quay is dumped on the quay for bellmen to gather. It comes in at 45/- and 10 per cent. is dumped on the quays for the bellmen to gather. They are getting it at 63/- and that is passed on, together with their particular expenses, profits and other costs, to the poor. Why is there that gap between 45/- and 63/-? Let us talk about January and February and not about the scandalous matter of the coal imported last summer and retailed at the present price, because that is what is happening. According to the Minister's statement to-day, the price distributed over various grades comes roughly to 45/-, and the bellmen who pick it up from the quayside where it is dumped pay an extra 18/- before they start on their rounds.

Comment on this

And then we are told that the merchants are making no profits.

Comment on this

It appears now that the increase shown in all coal between January and February is 1/3, while the increase to the bellmen is 11/-, and they are the people on whom the poor depend for their supplies. Why has that happened, and if there is this method of price-fixing, and this system of price controlling, is there not a scandal here and now ready and ripe for investigation by the hordes of officials and by whomever, as controller of prices, the Minister has under his control?

Have the Government as a whole yet come to any policy on the question of ships for this country? We have sent off to America a Minister, who in this House recently electrified Deputies by saying the more ships were sunk, the happier he would be. I hope he will repeat that where he is gone. I hope he will tell these people who are interested in a particular drive and a particular war effort that his idea is that the fewer ships, American or others, which visit this country, in order to enable it to get a fair standard of life, the better pleased he will be.

Comment on this

That statement is wrong.

Comment on this

It was wrong, I agree, and it should never have been made. I am glad to see one backbencher at least rise in revolt against it.

Comment on this

I am not revolting against it. I do not like to see a man's words twisted.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell me what was said? I will accept any amendment of it that is given. We were told in the same debate by the Taoiseach that there is no good talking about ships, that even if we had ships of our own, as long as commodities had to be imported, we required a navy to protect them, and after that, the Minister for Supplies went off to his Fianna Fáil cumann and told them that, although it might be a difficult matter to determine here and now, at the height of a war, the first thing which the Minister for Industry and Commerce, or some such branch, after the war would have to attend to would be the getting of a mercantile marine and, of course, if the Taoiseach is right, unless these wars are abolished for ever from the world, with it we must have a navy to protect it. Is that our policy? Are we all out hereafter for a mercantile marine and a navy, or are we going to have a mercantile marine and some system of convoy which we will bend our proud souls to accept in order to get our ships with our goods brought safely across the ocean?

The Minister for Supplies told us in connection with this matter of prices that he had made a standstill order in September, 1939. So he had; he made two of them. They covered a very wide range of commodities. There were certainly 30 or 40 items mentioned in them. Then in the months between September and February, we had a succession of individual price orders which steadily removed commodities from the standstill order. I am sorry the Minister for Supplies has left the House, but I should like to find out from the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who has taken his place, how many commodities are still covered by the standstill order. How many commodities are subject to the standstill order at the present day? I ask him to agree with me that not more than five are governed by it. That is a serious matter in the situation which is developing at the moment.

I should not feel happy in having a Labour motion adopted here to-night stating that: "In view of dislocation of industry and consequent increase in unemployment due to the emergency situation, the Dáil requests the Government forthwith to set up an economic council to plan measures to deal with the situation." I would have thought that Deputy Norton and his colleagues would have been warned by the fate of two recent motions in this House that should be fresh in their minds. They fathered a motion here with regard to unemployment some time ago. That motion was short-circuited by an amendment put down on behalf of the Government which in effect stated that instead of discussing the matter of unemployment there and then in the House, it was meet and proper to set up a commission to deal with unemployment. That amendment was adopted some months ago, but as yet we have had no announcement as to the names of the members or the terms of reference of that commission. No action has yet been taken in regard to that amendment. Of course Deputy Norton need not be reminded of what happened here a few weeks ago in respect of a motion dealing with the report of the tribunal set up to deal with a matter of urgent national importance three years ago. That tribunal reported, but the report has as yet been kept secret. We could not even get it debated in this House after an interval of 18 months. Having regard to these facts, I believe that the acceptance of this motion would be regarded with grave suspicion. Personally I would have been unquiet about it. I would have believed that it was like the diversion of the motion about unemployment into a totally new form, and that it was only a way of getting the Government out of their difficulties.

We offer another solution, that the Government should tell us what are their plans for maintaining employment and for relieving distress during the present period of emergency. Is it conceivable that in March, 1941, in respect of a war which started in the Autumn of 1939, that the Government would not have foreseen that unemployment at least was likely as a result of the restriction of supplies of raw materials?

Is it possible to conceive that in this month of March, 1941, the Government would not have decided that distress was likely to increase in this country and more particularly in this city, and that they would not have thought of some plan to relieve it? I would have thought that acceptance of the motion, although it might be a cute way of shelving the difficulty, would have involved a confession that the Government had no plans at the moment. We think it better that the Government should have an opportunity of saying: "There are plans already completed for dealing with unemployment and relieving distress; here are the things we are going to do."

I do not know exactly how many speakers there have been on the Government side in this debate, but I believe there have been very few. I have asked some of my colleagues what plans these speakers have foreshadowed with regard to employment and the relief of distress, and I have been told that while the speakers have been few, the proposals have been fewer still. We have no record of any plan to maintain employment or any scheme to relieve distress. If there is one thing that must be present to the minds of people on the Government side at the moment, it is that owing to the increase in the prices of commodities as are purchasable at all, and owing to the fact that certain commodities can only be purchased in restricted quantities, it is quite clear that those who have the long purse are getting as much as they require while those who cannot avail of the long purse are suffering. There is one way to meet that. I do not know if one can point to any country outside this that is in the war or that is threatened with war that has not adopted a full comprehensive system of rationing and price control. We are unique in that respect; we have decided that we shall have this scatterbrained system of price control in the heart of the Department of Supplies without any visible beneficial results to the people. We have decided, for no reason that anybody can fathom, that we are not going to have a system of rationing. Is there any other way of ensuring a fair distribution of such supplies as can be got? I think it is quite clear that when there are profits to be made, as a result of restriction of supplies, those who are prepared to pay an enhanced price are not likely to suffer any privation while those who cannot afford to pay that enhanced price will undoubtedly suffer. There has been no attempt by the Government to deal with these two matters.

Apart from all that, if the Government believed that their past programme was worth anything more than a few pious platitudinous speeches in this House, they should have felt that they had machinery in their industrial organisation such as we never had before in this country which could be set at work in this emergency. Have they set it at work? Can the Minister for Supplies say in respect of any single item of raw materials that he has helped industrialists to get supplies which, but for his help, could not have been obtained? I do not think he can. Can the Minister for Supplies say that he had forewarned particular groups of industrialists, that the opportunity for getting in raw materials was likely to be lessened in the immediate future and that he exhorted them at that stage to get in increased supplies? I do not believe that there is a single group of industrialists in this country to whom that warning was given, and I know there is no group to whom aid was given, in the sense of financial aid. That again would have allowed the Minister to tell us what had been done, that although he could not forecast with any precision what was likely to happen in the future he could show that certain things had been done in the past to safeguard the position. No matter what explanations are advanced by Ministers in these matters, nobody can say that what has happened in regard to tea, petrol, coal and butter is calculated to induce any confidence in the present Government—their vigilance, their alertness, their capacity to deal with the situation, their capacity to look forward and make plans against the emergency which is looming.

They could have dissipated that feeling of lack of confidence by saying it was difficult to obtain some commodities, but that in regard to ordinary requirements for our industrial life they had built up a certain machine and they were making it work. They might have said: "We had some pride in that machine because we perfected it ourselves, and we want to test our policy of self-sufficiency by it in this emergency. Here are the plans by which we propose to make use of it." Can they tell us in regard to one single item how they have availed of that machine to improve the position or to save us from falling into a worse position? I challenge them to say that in regard to one single item. Surely if the Government have not plans already in existence they must in face of the emergency which threatens, excogitate plans, or produce some rough and ready plans to show that there is some speed, some alertness, or some vigour put into this matter?

There is one thing that brooks no delay. I could mention a variety of other matters but time is running on. You have a vast number of people signing on at labour exchanges looking for work which is not there. The Government know that the strain on the labour exchange has been eased in recent months only by the fact that good conditions are offered on the other side and that men have preferred danger and wages to labour exchange signing-on and our neutrality. They have gone in droves out of this country. If Ministers do not believe that, let them get in touch with anybody who has been on the platform of Amiens Street during the past three or four weeks. Then he will find out about the scenes there, as the overloaded trains go off with our people, facing even the night bombing, as long as they get some money to send home for food for their people, rather than have the temporary security of this country and what it means, together with the unemployed people signing on for work that is not here.

We are told that raw materials are running out. The Minister for Supplies has told us in a recent speech that we are not at the greatest intensification of the war, that we are not at the worst point, that there is worse to come. Does that mean that the Government is simply content to do nothing, while more and more people clutter up the labour exchanges to sign on for the non-existent work? Do they not intend to do anything in regard to that? Even foodstuffs in this country are getting more scarce and, therefore, dearer. Is there to be any attempt to see that the limited quantity required to keep body and soul together will be on sale to the poorer sections of the community at prices which those poorer people can pay? Is there anything undignified in putting every member of this community on the basis that he has a card and coupons and that he will get certain foodstuffs in exchange for certain coupons, and that those coupons will be given to the head of the household in accordance with family strength and not in accordance with the depth of his purse? Why should not that be done?

We are told that keeping up neutrality requires almost as great an effort as maintaining a war situation. Over against us we have England— defamed by nightly broadcasts as being the home of the plutocrats—and in May of last year they turned everything over into the hands of one man or one group of men. They conscripted not merely the bodies of their people for either field warfare or industrial warfare, but they confiscated the wealthy factories and land, and they took over all the property for the service of the nation. That was handed over for proper use along the lines of the war effort. We are told here that our position, in regard to keeping out of the war, is at least as dangerous and entails as much sacrifice and effort as if we were in it.

What is the nearest approach we have made to the socialisation of all property in England? We have this meagre business of asking the tea merchants to register as retailers, and possibly arranging, as the Minister for Supplies indicated, that that measure might be applied to other people. Then, if these people disobey, they will be dealt with severely. How the measure of their disobedience is to be taken I do not know, but apparently the Minister takes them off the register and they are no longer able to trade. Who is going to give us a standard, who will give us the prices that the people may charge when they do get on the register? Who is going to tell us where there is to be priority in distribution, whether the supplies will go to the big families or the small families, or whether it will be a position in which the supply will go to whomsoever can get first to the counter or to whomsoever has dealt longest and is best known at a particular shop, or to that person whose trade would most be missed from the particular shop.

As regards all these factors, they will eventually work out in favour of the people who ought to be able to make the greatest sacrifices and against the people who are incapable of making any. We have these ridiculous measures for which there is no necessity, as far as I can see, though it might be that, if these ridiculous measures were adopted, there would be less mental anxiety than there is at the moment, apart from the fact that the poorer people would be considered properly. There is a feeling of resentment that people who are better off are, in this crisis, getting more of the limited supplies than others are getting, and there is a feeling which, if it grows, will destroy a great many more things than one political party. That is a situation which ought to be faced. We think that that situation might have been faced here to-night by some spokesman for the Government telling us: "Yes, we have foreseen that." These people talk about facing facts. Is it not a fact staring us in the face for the past year?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest that Deputy Norton be given 20 minutes for his reply.

Comment on this

I am coming to the conclusion. I suggest that these matters are staring us in the face for at least a year back, and one big question is that of increased unemployment, and the consequent distress brought on the people. Some one spokesman of the Government might have told us: "Yes, we foresaw that, and, as far as what we have done in regard to trying to keep the wheels of industry turning is concerned, it may mean a shortage of work amongst a certain number of our people, and we may have to ration the amount of work that there is, but we will keep them going by means of relief schemes. If this fails, and we cannot cover the difficulties in that way, we will see that the limited supplies available will be distributed as equally as possible." It is on these matters that the Government have been silent. I do not believe it is worth while pressing this demand for an economic council if the Government can do that on their own. If they cannot tell us what they have done to face that emergency, I do not think the Government should be embarrassed by an economic council, which would have to look on at their inactivity from day to day. I would rather have the opportunity to use this House to bring to the people a knowledge of the position in which they are placed, and a knowledge that, in dealing with such matters, the Government has completely failed.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Norton to conclude.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I would ask leave to speak for just two minutes, to express my disappointment—and, I think, the disappointment of the whole House— with the speeches made from the Government Benches to-day. They did nothing. They only made efforts to justify the past, and none of us wished to go into the past. We wished to know what the Government holds for the future, what consolation this debate will bring to the thousands outside tomorrow morning and during the next few weeks. One of the Ministers, in his opening statement to-day, said that we have 20,000 extra people to provide for. He went on to say that we have 13,000 fewer receiving assistance at the labour exchanges or through benefits. I cannot reconcile these two points, and I wish to know what the Government will do for the 13,000 fewer registering. They are here in our midst; they came back from England, having been bombed out of their homes; they are our own countrymen. However, they are not eligible for benefits from the Government, and they are anxiously hoping that some form of relief measure will be introduced to give them something for their wives and families.

Even the 20,000 extra that the Minister mentioned that he has to provide for are earnestly hoping for some consolation, too. We have all read in the papers about warrants and decrees for possession of people's homes in various parts of Dublin. There are high rents, high costs of living, shortage of materials, scarcity of tea, scarcity of paraffin oil used in tenement houses, and slack given for coal. Deputy Mulcahy has taken a very active part in dealing with such matters. I heard of a case only to-day where small coal purchasers, who sell again in small quantities, are not even allowed to go to the coal banks but are ordered to go to the slack banks, and they sell to our poorer people at 6d. a stone. These are matters I should like Ministers to deal with. They should tell us what is to happen to our people from tomorrow onwards and not what has taken place in the past.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Norton to conclude.

Comment on this

I am sure I can speak for the people of Dublin as well as any man who spoke here to-day. I only want two minutes, as was given to the last speaker. I must say that we have the right Government at this time when this terrible disaster is overtaking the Continent. That is the feeling of the people of Dublin.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must resume his seat.

Comment on this
Deputies

Order, order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The anxiety for order is very edifying, indeed.

Comment on this

It is not fair. I submit I should get two minutes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy have a little patience? Deputy Norton gave two minutes to Deputy Byrne. The Chair decided to ascertain whether Deputy Norton would give Deputy Tom Kelly two minutes also.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton is not Speaker of the House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

eputy Norton was entitled to 20 minutes in which to conclude, but waived part of his allotted time.

Comment on this

It is only five or eight minutes past ten.

Comment on this

I am willing to give way, Sir.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Norton to conclude.

Comment on this

I have made my protest. I say that the feeling amongst the good Dublin people is that they are thanking God that they have such a Government during the present crisis, and such a leader. I submit that that is as good a speech as was made here to-night.

Comment on this

"An t-é gur leor leis beagán ó Dhia, is leor le Dia beagán dó."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Ní deas an abairt é sin uaireannta.

Comment on this

Well, I do not understand what the Deputy says, but I would answer quickly if I did.

Comment on this

This motion, dealing with the establishment of an economic council, and the amendment which was put down in the names of Deputies Mulcahy and McGilligan, were intended, so far as discussion in this House was concerned, to produce a serious debate, and it was hoped that the Government would realise the importance which not only the House but the whole country attach to a discussion on matters of such tremendous importance in existing circumstances. If we are to judge, however, by the two speeches that were made here from the Government benches this evening I think that the whole economic outlook so far as this country is concerned is bleaker than I ever imagined it to be. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, who was the first speaker here this evening, treated us to a most infantile display, a display of buffoonery which would do discredit to a third-class music hall.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The word "buffonery" should not be applied to a speech in this House. It is not consonant with the dignity of the House.

Comment on this

I shall withdraw the remark, Sir, but the speeches we listened to here this evening were not by any means in consonance with the dignity of the House, and that is why I am protesting. The Minister treated the House with absolute levity. He regaled himself for three-quarters of an hour in putting up Aunt Sallies of his own creation and then knocking them down, and that is the answer and the kind of procedure we get from a Minister of this House whose job it is—and who is paid for doing it—to deal with the economic problems in this House in our present circumstances.

He spent some time in analysing the possible work and constitution of an economic council. He did not know what it could do, or he could not be convinced that it could do anything. He forgot, apparently, to ask the Taoiseach what he had in mind when, some years ago, he advocated an economic council and an economic G.H.Q. The Minister was so concerned with reducing the whole discussion to a basis of levity that he could not see that he was engaging in a gigantic satire on the advocacy of an economic council by the Taoiseach in past days, although he was told that our intention was that the proposed body should be an advisory body, a body of weight which, by the nature of its personnel, would command respect not merely from the Government, but from the country. The Minister, with characteristic perversity, this evening endeavoured to suggest that we were urging that the economic council should supersede the Government, that it should take prime place in the economic development of the country, and that the Government should take second place. He wanted to know whether the economic council was going to take over property and, if so, how it was going to distribute that property—as if anybody made a suggestion of that kind! It only arose in his own imagination, and then only for the purpose of misrepresenting the motion.

The Minister then became grave for a few moments, and wanted to know if the economic council was to arrange for the transfer of men from one place of employment to another, or from one industry to another. Even if it had to discharge a function of that kind, I say that it is preferable to transfer hungry, starving men from one centre where there is no work to another centre where there is work in this country. As I said, it is the absence of an economic council, it is the absence of a transfer system, or of any planning system in regard to work or employment, which is causing hundreds of our men to take excursion trains to Belfast every Saturday, or every Thursday, and when these men go they do not come back to this country. Instead, they are joining another Army, and trying to get work in Belfast, or else endeavouring to get across to Britain to get work there. Would it not be better to have an economic council, transferring these people of ours from one place in this country where there is no employment to another place in the country where there is employment to be had, than to have that condition of affairs prevailing? I cannot understand the mentality of the Minister for Industry and Commerce who would not prefer to see our people transferred from places of unemployment to places of employment in this country rather than have that situation develop as it has developed and as he must know it is developing, if he took steps to inform himself of the facts.

Personally, I should prefer to see our people transferred from one place of employment to another here in this country rather than seeing them standing in the same labour exchange three times a week, having to face the same landlord without rent, week after week, having to face the same grocer without being able to pay, and so on, with all the economic ills that follow to-day in this country as a result of the endeavour of these people to subsist on low standards of State allowances.

The Minister for Supplies this evening did not at all improve on the contribution we had from the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Minister for Supplies wanted to know whether the Government were to wait while this economic council was considering problems. Well, waiting for the consideration of problems is a task with which this Government is pretty familiar. We have been waiting for the best part of two years for this Government to give the country some definite plan with regard to industry and agriculture, some definite plan which would tide the country over its present war-time difficulties, some plan indicating that the Government appreciated the danger and that it was planning ahead. Yet, after nearly two years, we have not had a shred of information or any indication from the Government as to what steps it is taking, or proposes to take, to deal with the situation which now confronts us or to provide for the still more difficult position which is yawning for us all in the days ahead.

He said that he did not know that the war was going to start, but he was silent on the fact that for nearly a year before the war started the Department of Supplies was in existence and that we were then told that it was devising all kinds of plans to shield us against all kinds of adversity if the crisis should come. A few months after the war was intensified in the vicinity of these islands, however, the Department of Supplies collapsed like a house of cards. We suddenly discovered that there was a shortage of tea, petrol, coal, butter, and that boats could not be got to bring in cargoes of wheat, and the whole Department collapsed like a house of cards so far as its grandiose plans were concerned. The Minister now tells us, by means of a kind of courteous gesture, presumably, that the people are satisfied that the Government will take effective action. If that is so, if the people are satisfied, why are not the people told now what action the Government proposes to take? The Minister said that he could not say in 1940 in what way the war would develop in 1941 and that, consequently, he could not plan for 1941. He now says that he cannot say how the war will develop next year and that, therefore, it is not possible to formulate a comprehensive plan for dealing with the situation in the following year—as if it is not possible in connection with agriculture to plan and develop our resources to the utmost limit if we have the energy and the courage and if we are prepared to devote some previous preparation to it.

In respect of our agricultural development, it has been pointed out already, in the course of this debate, that Grain Importers, Limited, told the Minister early in November that they could not get ships to transport grain to this country. Nothing was done in November or December. It was away towards the end of January that there were alarming speeches about the shortage of wheat and other cereals, and then the Minister for Agriculture was sent cantering around the country, addressing county committees of agriculture in an endeavour to persuade them to increase the area under tillage. They had been warned in November, but nothing was done between November and the end of January, and it was not until the end of January that the Minister for Agriculture went around the country, and thus a very valuable ploughing and sowing period was neglected so far as the production of wheat was concerned.

The two speeches that we have had here this evening from the Government Benches reveal that there is no plan whatever for dealing with the situation confronting us to-day, and that there are no plans whatever for dealing with the growing and widening unemployment situation. The Minister for Industry and Commerce spent his time logic-chopping this evening, juggling with figures and telling us that there were 13,000 fewer people idle this year than there were at a particular date last year. Does anybody in his sane senses believe that? If the Minister believes that, then it shows how far out of touch he is with the people and how much divorced he is from a knowledge of their real sufferings. Everybody who has eyes in his head, who mixes with the people, who goes through the country, who attends small meetings and gatherings of the ordinary people in the country, who attends meetings and gatherings of small farmers, knows perfectly well that the struggle for employment to-day is much more intense than it has been for a long time, that, in fact, there are more people idle to-day than there were last year or the year before and that the situation is daily and weekly becoming worse. When we consider that position, let us remember that we have absorbed a considerable number of people in our Army; we have exported a considerable number of people to Britain and to Belfast, and we have provided a certain new type of employment in connection with our new military activities. All these factors, including the fact that at this time of the year, for which the Minister was quoting his figures, the minor relief schemes are in operation throughout the country, have not been able to conceal the grave problem of unemployment or prevent us from seeing its stark reality.

The Minister spoke of the number of emigrants returning to this country. He sought to get some consolation out of these, to weight his case against this motion, but the Minister ought to have told the House—what he knew to be perfectly true—that all the emigrants who come back to this country do not register at the employment exchanges, firstly, because, if they have stamps on their cards, there is no reciprocal arrangement between Great Britain and this country and they get no unemployment benefit and, secondly, they get no unemployment assistance because they are not registered as resident here for 12 months immediately preceding their claim. If 13,000 came back, these 13,000 do not show themselves at the employment exchanges and they must be added to the number of people who are at present registered at the employment exchanges throughout the country.

The Minister for Supplies, this evening, was as delightfully vague as ever he was on the question of the availability of supplies for industry. The Minister could give no hope whatever that the supply position would improve. He could give no indication that we were going to face up to the difficulties, caused by a shortage of supply, in accordance with any previously arranged plan. The Minister told us about the oil refinery which it was proposed to establish in this country. It was proposed to establish an oil refinery. Some of the stories that came out in the Press reports about that refinery from London meetings did not show that the whole venture was just the creditable thing we were told it was likely to be at the outset. But at all events, even that company, such as it was, built, I think, nine tankers in Germany to liquidate the frozen assets of the British group who had money invested in Germany. The nine tankers were to come here and to sail under our flag. I think we had seven when the war started. With delightful generosity, having no petrol of our own, having no crude oil of our own, we proceeded to give away seven of the nine tankers and they are now sailing the oceans of the world, not in our service, not carrying petrol to us, but carrying these supplies to another country. That is the kind of planning the Minister for Supplies has engaged in.

We had from the Minister for Supplies, in January, during the discussion on supplies, a statement that there was nothing wrong with the tea supplies in this country; that the only thing that happened was that one particularly timid tea merchant was rather nervous about the position, and, as a result of that nervousness, had reduced supplies to his customers, but that all the other merchants were giving full supplies to their customers. There was nothing wrong whatever except the particular eccentricities of this one merchant who, on being brought into the presence of the Minister, had his fears set at rest, and undertook to toe the line and distribute tea in the same manner as his colleagues in the Tea Importers' Association. We were then assured by the Minister that the tea situation was quite all right; there was no scarcity; we could look forward with reasonable calmness to a continuance of supplies. A short time after that debate, the people in the City of Dublin cannot get one-quarter of a pound of tea or half a pound of tea, as the case might be. People's supplies of tea have been cut down to a fragment of their normal supplies, notwithstanding the assurance of the Minister, much less than two months ago, that the tea supply position was perfectly normal, and that there was no reason for anxiety about it.

In the face of statements that things are right, followed by admissions that things are wrong; in the face of statements that supplies are all right followed by statements that supplies are not all right, how can one have confidence in the present Government's policy? The public has been deluded since the war started in respect of supplies. There has been no attempt to take the public into confidence; no attempt whatever to get the public to appreciate the difficulties in the light of definite information given to the public for the purpose of enabling them to appreciate the position. One cannot even get Ministers to give information. This evening, the Minister for Industry and Commerce would not say what quantity of potatoes was exported from this country in the past two months although he knows perfectly well that tens of thousands of cwts. of potatoes have been exported from this country during the past two months. They dare not give that information to the public lest the public might rightly and properly say that these potatoes ought to be conserved in this country for the use and benefit of our own people. Last year we witnessed the criminal folly of supplying butter to the British people at a subsidised price and our own people cannot get butter now and have not been able to get it for the past few months. How can one have faith in a policy of that kind or confidence in the management of our affairs when they are in hands which are guilty of glaring inequalities and discrepancies of that kind? The other day the Minister stated that there was a crisis of the first magnitude at hand and, after making that admission the other day, he has now no policy whatever for dealing with that crisis. I interpret the Government's declaration this evening, through the speeches of the two Ministers, as an intimation to the plain, poor people of this country that they will have to suffer more hunger and want, that there is no relief at hand and no plan for dealing with the situation. If the Taoiseach can find comfort and consolation in those two speeches, the ordinary people of the country will see in them an intimation to them that their sufferings and privations are going to be continued and, possibly, intensified so long as persons of that kind manage Government policy.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That the words proposed to be deleted, stand"—put.

Tá 7
·
Níl 90
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Omitting a possible intermediate question, I shall now put this motion as amended.

Comment on this
Division

Motion, as amended, put.

Tá 36
·
Níl 60
Result _

Do you agree with this result?