We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1941-42.

Contributions 1–162 of 330. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Seán T. O'Kelly Minister for Finance (Mr. O Ceallaigh) Fianna Fáil

I move:—

That a sum not exceeding £12,350,000 be granted on account for or towards defraying the charges that will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1942, for certain public services, namely:—

£

1President's Establishment | 1,300

2House of the Oireachtas | 41,700

3Department of the Taoiseach | 4,600

4Comptroller and Auditor-General | 6,560

5Office of the Minister for Finance | 24,500

6Office of the Revenue Commissioners | 309,000

7Old Age Pensions | 1,230,000

8Compesnation Bounties | 18,000

9Office of Public Works | 48,500

10Public Works and Buildings | 380,500

11Haulbowline Dockyard | 1,300

12State Laboratory | 3,300

13Civil Service Commission | 7,400

14Property Losses Compensation | 350

15Commissions and Special Inquiries | 3,100

16Superannuation and Retired Allowances | 166,700

17Rates on Government Property | 49,000

18Secret Service | 6,700

19Expenses under the Electoral Act, and the Juries Act | Nil

20Miscellaneous Expenses | 3,300

21Stationery and Printing | 60,000

22Valuation and Boundary Survey | 11,000

23Ordnance Survey | 11,790

24Supplementary Agricultural Grants | 450,000

25Law Charges | 23,000

26Universities and Colleges | 77,700

27Widows' and Orphans' Pensions | 150,000

28Quit Rent Office | 1,100

29Management of Government Stocks | 20,700

30Agriculture | 310,000

31Fisheries | 9,000

32Office of the Minister for Justice | 14,600

33Gárda Síochána | 706,000

34Prisons | 29,000

35District Court | 13,800

36Supreme Court and High Court of Justice | 18,400

37Land Registry and Registry of Deeds | 15,700

Circuit Court | 16,900

Public Record Office | 1,744

40Charitable Donations and Bequests | 1,100

41Local Government and Public Health | 410,000

42General Register Office | 4,278

43Dundrum Asylum | 6,500

44National Health Insurance | 103,000

45Office of the Minister for Education | 63,000

46Primary Education | 1,400,000

47Secondary Education | 160,000

48Technical Instruction | 99,745

49Science and Art | 15,500

50Reformatory and Industrial Schools | 60,000

51National Gallery | 2,133

52Lands | 616,400

53Forestry | 64,420

54Gaeltacht Services | 50,000

55Industry and Commerce | 87,600

56Transport and Meteorological Services | 29,460

57Railway Tribunal | 980

58Marine Service | 14,000

59Unemployment Insurance and Unemployment Assistance | 383,000

60Industrial and Commerical Property Registration Office | 4,800

61Posts and Telegraphs | 885,800

62Wireless Broadcasting | 23,600

63Army | 2,771,000

64Army Pensions | 217,200

65External Affairs | 31,600

66League of Nations | 5

67Employment Schemes | 500,000

68Agricultural Produce Subsidies | 80,000

69Office of the Minister for Supplies | 9,535

70Irish Tourist Board | 1,500

71Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies | 5,600

72Repayment of Trade Loans Advances | Nil

73Emergency Scientific Research Bureau | 4,000

TOTAL | £12,350,000

As Deputies are aware, the purpose of the Vote on Account is to enable moneys to be made available for the carrying on of the various Supply Services during the interval which must elapse in every financial year before the Dáil has had an opportunity for discussing each Supply Service Estimate in detail. Normally the greater part of the first four months of the financial year has elapsed before all the Estimates have been considered by the Dáil and the Appropriation Act passed into law. It is, therefore, customary to provide in the Vote on Account sufficient moneys to cover the working of the various Departments and services for the period from the 1st April to the 31st July. The amount necessary in most cases approximates to one-third of the total net Estimate for the year, but in some instances a departure from that proportion is necessary.

The various items comprising the Vote on Account of £12,350,000 are set out on the Order Paper and in the White Paper which has been circulated. As Deputies will have observed from the Volume of Estimates, the total net provision for the Supply Services in respect of the year 1941-42 is £35,322,791. This represents an increase of £697,755 on the net provision of £34,625,036, including Supplementary Estimates, in respect of 1940-41. The original net provision for the current financial year was £30,511,359 and, as compared with this figure, the 1941-42 provision is up by £4,811,432.

Whichever of the two modes of comparison Deputies may choose to adopt, the increase can only be attributed to the necessity for greater provision for the Army. The Army Estimate for the coming year shows an increase of £1,404,498 as compared with the total Army provision for 1940-41 (including supplementaries), or an increase of £4,957,908 as compared with the original net Estimate for the current year. It will be apparent that, were it not for the increase in Army expenditure there would be a net decrease over the whole Supply Services, notwithstanding the rising costs of materials reflected throughout many of the existing services and the expansion of Governmental activity necessitated by the present emergency.

Deputies will probably have noticed that the usual explanatory details of the Army Estimate for the coming year have been omitted as the Government have decided that, so long as the present emergency continues, it would not be in the public interest to publish such information.

As compared with the current year's Estimates, including supplementaries, there are increases on 27 of the 1941-42 Estimates, decreases on 42, while four show no change. The total of the increases on the various Votes amounts to £1,836,632, while the total of the decreases amounts to £1,138,877.

Comment on this

I regret very much that a bill of this immensity should be presented to Parliament and to the people with such an economy of words. Without actually acting as a timekeeper, I would say that it took the Minister for Finance just three minutes to explain, or pretend to explain, exactly why this country should be asked to provide £5,000,000 more than we were asked to provide this time last year. I think, like every Government that has been in office for a great number of years, the breach between Government and people in this country at the present moment is more marked in extent than any breach that was ever before found to exist between Government and people. It has been the experience of all of us, on both sides of this House, that a Party must have been coquetting with the people very actively, very intensely and very closely for a number of years before the result is achieved of securing control of Government. That close contact continues for one, two or three years, and then, gradually, people and Government begin to drift apart. The rapidity with which that drift has taken place in the case of the present Government has been remarkable. The tone and style of Ministers, one after the other, as they stand up from that bench are ample evidence of the distance between themselves and the people.

I believe we have reached a state of affairs in this country when every £10 note counts very much. We have reached the stage when there should be as much explanation to-day about every extra £10 taken from the public purse as would be required ten or 11 years ago to explain a demand for, say, £100,000. We can all recollect the time when the present Ministers occupied this Bench: their eloquence, their vehemence and their tears about the load of taxation that oppressed the people, when the demands on the people was some £12,000,000 or £13,000,000 less than the demand made to-day by the Minister for Finance in a few brief words. He told us that most of the demand is to be accounted for by the extra demands of the Army. We have been told that every year during the past three years. We have been told that each huge Vote that was demanded for the Army was to be the last, and that it would bring the Army to the final stage of equipment. The money was voted. The money was spent, but apparently the goods were not procured. If the sum so voted had been spent for the purpose for which they were voted, there is a very real explanation required in order to justify the cost of sending a Minister to America for two, three or four months or longer. The explanation given to Parliament and the people is that he went to buy arms. The presumption is that sufficient arms have not been bought—could not be procured—but any sum asked for was never reduced by one halfpenny. If there is such an inadequacy of arms that it has been necessary to send a Minister away for months, I think it is very unwise to be proclaiming it to the world. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce told us a short time ago that the safety of the State would be threatened, that the State would be rocked to its very foundations, if we knew the amount of wheat and tea that came into the country in the last few months. Yet, in the light of that statement we proclaim to all the world that we lack arms and military equipment, and that we lack them to such a very grave extent that it is necessary to send a Minister away for months. If any of us had made a statement to that effect outside the House a fortnight or a month ago, the full weight of the emergency powers would be felt. The man who has gone to America is the very man who would ensure that newspapers would be completely put out of print should any such statement appear in an Irish newspaper. That type of blundering is characteristic of the whole team for some years past. The more serious the situation becomes the more blundering there is and the more pronounced becomes the lack of consideration shown for the people.

Repeatedly from these benches we have urged on the Taoiseach and his Ministers, with regard to supplies not only for the Army but for the people of the country, that it would be advisable there should be direct Ministerial contact between our Ministers here and the Ministers of the country from which we have always bought 70 or 80 per cent. of our goods. The reply we always got was that there was no necessity for such contact, that that country had its representative here, that approaches could be made to that representative, and that the reason why we have all this machinery of representation in the different capitals is in order to make it unnecessary for Ministers to travel from one country to the other. That was a reasonable argument. It was a reasonable answer, and if it was a truthful answer, and represented the real situation, the cost of a taxicab would do to establish contact between our Government and the Supply Department of the United States of America. There cannot be always two heads on the penny that the Taoiseach tosses. That was the answer we got not once but many times. The other head is going to turn up this time in the Taoiseach's favour.

With regard to this particular Vote on Account, the customary practice has been to give notice of the particular items that are to be discussed in detail. It is one of the few occasions in the year when the Dáil is presented with, as it were, a tabloid Vote, a Vote which requires money for each and every Department, and a Vote which permits of discussion on each and every Department. I think it is true to say that there is scarcely one Department which can be congratulated on its work in recent years. Reading the provincial Press, I notice that those who were the strongest adherents and supporters of the Government in the past are those who are becoming most vocal nowadays in their criticism of the Government. I am inclined to think that we are living in times when a full sense of responsibility may be better demonstrated by a person's capacity to keep a grip on his tongue rather than the capacity to lash any particular Department with that tongue. I speak, as others, with very great restraint, and I have no idea of going into detail with regard to the activities, the mistakes, the blunders of the various Departments. Most of those blunders, unfortunately, are only too well known and too acutely felt by the people. The people themselves, in their irritation and in their anger with the Government, have been calling to task all Deputies and all Parties for giving too free a rein to the Government, for abstaining too consistently from carrying out their functions of challenging, of opposing, of criticising the Government.

Every one of us knows that to a greater or lesser extent throughout this country of ours there is a growing anti-Parliamentary movement, and to an extent an incentive to the growth of that movement has been the amount of freedom from criticism which has been given to Government Ministers in this Assembly for the past 18 months. That was done with the best intentions in the world. The results outside were bad. The results inside were worse. We cannot control the results outside. Inside, the one result has been that Ministers, one after the other, have carried on their work casually, negligently, encouraged in the belief that the day of criticism, of controversy, of opposition, was gone. We have that stamp clearly seen on every single one of the Ministries. Perhaps the one which comes most clearly under public notice nowadays, and affects the life of the people most closely, is the Department of Supplies—a costly Department, a huge Department, and a vital Department. In so far as any of us can interpret the functions of that Department by its contacts with the people, one may summarise its activities by saying it is a huge and costly Department, there for the purpose of notifying the people when supplies have run out. The local merchant could do that. He would not cost half as much. There is no warning in advance—merely a notification that the worst has happened. When that notification reaches the other Departments of State, they all buzz into activity. If it were in the month of July that they were told of a wheat or a flour shortage, presumably they would select July as the month to tear up the land. We had no timely intervention, no timely increased tillage drive. Either the Department of Supplies did or did not know last fall that there was a shortage, or that there would probably be a shortage in 1941; yet, it was the end of January before any approach was made to farmers and people holding land that it was vital that more land should be turned up in order to safeguard the food supply of the people. When we discussed supplies here some two months ago we had the farcical exhibition of the Minister for Supplies, with his customary brazenness, standing up over there to down-face anybody here who suggested that there was a tea shortage. We were merely engaged in the malicious game of panicking and disturbing the country for political purposes. We had statements of that kind made over there on a Wednesday or a Thursday evening, and on the following Sunday night, I think it was, we had the Taoiseach going on the air, a kind of a representation of all the Apocalypse horsemen rolled into one, giving notice of tea famines, petrol famines, wheat and flour famines and butter famines. That was three days after the Minister for Ballyhoo had told us that things were never better.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy assured us that he was keeping a curb on his tongue.

Comment on this

We were told that perhaps it was true that one wholesaler had held up supplies of tea, but he had been approached and the situation was now all right. Three days later the Taoiseach broadcasts that the situation is grave, is serious, and amongst the items mentioned was tea.

At the time he was speaking the port of Dublin was glutted with tea, but there was no machinery of government, no activity of government, to connect central government with the port of Dublin. When every pump in the country was run dry of petrol, the Department of Supplies stirred itself into activity to the extent of notifying the people that petrol was gone. I suppose the Minister would claim that that is being efficient.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy claim it is the truth?

Comment on this

And I suppose he claims that the manner in which the petrol situation has been handled since bears the stamp of efficiency. I have no hesitation in saying—and I bring it home to the Minister—that the handling of that particular commodity since bears the stamp of crass stupidity. Civil servants must do their job according to rules and regulations laid down. They have not, or rarely have, full powers of discrimination, for the free mind, the active mind, the live wire is expected to be on top, the temporary head of the Department.

We have in the issue of petrol the kind of live, elastic, flexible mentality that would be represented by an old-time cannon ball. What have we got? We have certain classes picked out to whom petrol will be issued. We have the bulk of motor owners thrown on the scrap heap. They may have sunk their money in cars; they may have taxed and insured their cars. They may be living in a house miles from their work, miles from schools, miles from a marketing town or shop. The whole homestead was, to an extent, based on the car. No consideration whatsoever is given to them, but we have certain classes who will get petrol. The petrol situation may be so very bad that only certain classes can be catered for. How are they catered for? Amongst them we have clergymen and doctors. There is a flat rate of allowance of petrol to all, according to the horse-power of the car. There is one doctor whose job is in an institution, who can do his work in carpet slippers, who has not to travel a mile in the year to attend his patients and do his work. There is another doctor with a huge Connemara dispensary district. There is the same allowance of petrol to both.

Comment on this

Who told the Deputy that?

Comment on this

The Minister's representatives.

Comment on this

I stated in the Dáil last week, to the knowledge of a number of Deputies, that in the case of doctors we were able to make special allowances for those whose circumstances were exceptional.

Comment on this

I will give the Minister an idea of some of the work of his Department. The exceptions made and the allowances made were to have effect if there was a grave epidemic. The flat rate allowance to a doctor is based on the horse-power of his car, not on his duties, not on his population, and not on the area. If he is a very special case, it will take special certification, and, after a considerable length of time, he may get an extra ration. The same applies to clergymen. Whether a man is a professor teaching in an institution, or responsible for a large parish, there is no discrimination. Latterly we have been told that special cases will receive special consideration. I was immersed as late as the night before last in a mass of complaints and correspondence from doctors and in most of the letters there was written down the number of times they had communicated with the Minister's Department without receiving a reply. Is that the type of Departmental activity we are to congratulate the Minister on?

Comment on this

I do not care if the Deputy congratulates me or not, but I would like to draw his attention to the fact that we published a large scale advertisement in the papers pointing out that it was not proposed to reply individually to letters and that the rations allowed could not be increased.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

What about the special cases?

Comment on this

I regret it was necessary for the Minister to notify the public that the era of courtesy has passed in Government administration, because, if more of the public were here, you could have saved the price of the advertisement.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy should read these things before starting to make speeches about them?

Comment on this

I read them.

Comment on this

If the Deputy did, apparently he did not understand them.

Comment on this

The fact that I did read an announcement from the Department that no replies would be made is no reason why I should not complain of the matter here. The advertisement only added insult to injury. The public, when they are paying for a Department, have a right as taxpayers to receive a reply to their communications, and all the jaunty advertisements that the Minister may design will not clear him of the responsibililty of having to reply to correspondents. Is there any divine right with the Minister's Department that it is to be exempt from the ordinary procedure of courtesy that has been the practice in every Government Department in every State? Merely because the people were so stricken with the bungling of the Minister, he probably got more correspondence to deal with than did any other Minister. The advertisement does not clear the Minister from the responsibility of replying to correspondence.

Important organisations, at a time when many, at least, are paying lip service to vocationalism—such bodies within the community as have vocational organisations—were confronted with this advertisement when they tried to represent their members or put up, in a concentrated, considered way, the disabilities under which their trades or professions were suffering. We had further evidence to-day of that determination to exclude the person who is paying for all from any rights, even the right to information. We had evidence of it in the replies of the Parliamentary Secretary to a leading Deputy, an ex-Minister, representing one of the constituencies making up the city, a Deputy pressed, worried, annoyed and irritated, as every Deputy is, whether in the city or the country, by people who cannot get supplies, people who cannot get their requirements in the way of food. They asked that Deputy why is this, what is the reason, has there been a complete cutting off of supplies. That Deputy, as a democratic representative working within a democratic machine, comes here to Parliament and asks a simple, straightforward question with regard to imports of tea and flour. It is a question that demands an answer, a question to which that Deputy is entitled to get a reply.

What is the game that is played? There is a hocus-pocus reply about the world situation, the world war, the awful state of emergency, and that it would be unsafe to let the Deputy know what every tally clerk at the Port of Dublin knows—and these are the people who at the moment are the custodians of the institutions of this State, including Parliament. That kind of reply and that kind of antics are doing more damage to Parliament and more damage to democracy in this State than those whom you have behind barbed wire could do if they were at liberty. If there is sabotage going on here, if confidence is being undermined, if Leftist organisations are growing in strength, they are being pap-fed by these antics and by the insolence of that type of Parliamentary reply. As a result of all this type of activity or inactivity, we have reached a point in this country when not thousands but hundreds of thousands of people are going out of work weekly. They are going out of work weekly because either the industry out of which they lived is paralysed or working at half-cock because the raw materials of that industry are being curtailed, and these people are clamouring for consideration by Parliament. A Deputy, through the ordinary machinery of Parliament, in the ordinary manner, asks questions. He is told that he will not be answered and he meets these thousands who are being hurled out of work and tells them: "The Government refuse to give any information in Parliament as to why you are being thrown out of work." Do you not know that you are breeding revolutionaries by that style of answer like blue-bottles on a dungheap?

Comment on this

By that type of lying.

Comment on this

Are you living on a different planet? Do you not know what the world is like? Do you not know the internal workings of the country? Have you no sense of responsibility for the future? Do you think you can come here like so many little tin-pot czars, despising the people, showing your contempt for Deputies and trampling on Parliament itself? The greatest disservice that was ever done to this Parliament was when Ministers adopted the phraseology: "not in the public interest." If Parliament is not a place where questions can be put and where questions will be answered fully, freely, frankly, then discussion will take place outside and the mischief-maker will enter into the discussions. Every phrase and every phase of life will be distorted and the object inside and behind these discussions will be to tear down.

It would be well for every Minister to get back to something like where he was ten years ago, to re-establish his contacts with the people, to re-establish his lines of communication to and from the people, to have some kind of machinery to let him know what the people are thinking, what the people are doing, what the people are saying, to try to revive if there is a spark of it left, at least, the phrases of humanitarianism which bubbled so freely to their lips ten, 12 years ago, to revive the spirit, even if it was a hypocritical spirit, of deep consideration for the people. It would be well for him to realise that if the supply position has reached such a point that hundreds of thousands of people must go short, that tens of thousands must go out of work and that tens of thousands of families must face ruin, hunger and destitution, there is an obligation not only on Deputies but on Ministers and the whole of Parliament to give the appearance, at least in Parliament, that we are conscious of the afflictions that have fallen on these people, that we are sympathetic towards them in their misery and that any use that can be made of Parliament to give them all information, so as to make clear to them in an easy, simple way why it is that the industry which previously gave them full employment can carry now only half, or the industry out of which they and their fathers lived has now closed its doors, to make clear to them that this position is due to circumstances not within our control, but outside our control. Surely in that way you would at least be generating through the people a deeper sense of understanding, and the irritation, annoyance and anger of these people would be directed not towards those who have no responsibility for that state of affairs but towards those who are directly responsible for it.

If these immense votes, introduced without apology and without explanation, are to bear any fruit, that fruit can only be brought forth by the freedom of discussion which such votes must provoke in a House such as this, and nothing but harm can result from Ministerial insolence and Ministerial taciturnity. I ask Ministers to remember this, that when statements are made here by one Deputy, it is merely one voice expressing the thoughts of hundreds of thousands outside, and when a question is asked here by one Deputy, it is the request of only one Deputy, but a request made in order to convey information to hundreds of thousands of decent people outside.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It might not be amiss to state that it is usual to give the Ceann Comhairle an intimation as to the subjects selected for discussion on the Vote on Account. These should be of a general character dealing with general financial or other policy. On this occasion, the subject selected by the main Opposition is supplies.

Comment on this

Facing as I believe the most critical year that this country has faced for the last half century, not only for the defence of our country and of our national rights, but from the economic and financial standpoint, I was grievously disappointed at the paucity of the Minister's remarks on this Vote on Account as a justification for such expenditure. We were told that the huge increase of approximately £5,000,000 in the Estimates for Supply Services was covered by the increased Vote for Defence. In my opinion, a mere bald statement of that sort is not sufficient to account for that huge sum. It is treating Parliament and the taxpayers generally with contempt. The attitude adopted by the Minister, and that has been adopted in recent months by Ministers generally, is undoubtedly bringing Parliamentary institutions into disrepute. We were told that the increase was mainly accounted for by the huge amount necessary for defence. I do not think any Deputy will attempt to question the advisability of spending the huge amount of money that we are spending at present on defence. We all agree that it is necessary to provide adequate defences; that it is our moral responsibility to do so. What struck me on looking over the various items was that, while huge sums of money are being spent on uniforms, salaries and general supplies for the Army, the amount actually spent on arms and armaments is relatively small. As that is a matter we should not discuss in detail I do not propose to do so, but it would be an unfortunate position for the country if, having devoted large expenditure on defence, we found that the equipment was poor. I have no doubt that our Army will give an excellent account of itself if it has to do so, but it would be under a very grievous handicap if it was short of the necessary arms and equipment.

I understand that this debate covers mostly Supply Services, and under that heading I am principally concerned with the agricultural position. With regard to increased agricultural production and food supplies, it was on Christmas Day that we got the first intimation as to the serious position of food supplies for the coming year. As a matter of fact, I think it was on Christmas Day that the Taoiseach broadcast an appeal to America to come to our aid with certain essential food supplies, but it was some two weeks later that any campaign for increased production of food here was undertaken. Anybody who has any appreciation of the necessity of early notification to the agricultural community to prepare for increased production of food, realises that it was unfortunate there was not earlier intimation and an earlier appeal made for increased agricultural production. As a result of the adverse weather conditions during the last couple of months we find ourselves now in an unfortunate position with regard to the amount of land under wheat, and it is necessary, even at this late hour, to review the position to see what can be done about it. Appeals have been made to the Minister for Agriculture from time to time about supplies of seeds. If farmers are asked to put an increased amount of land under tillage, some effort should at least be made to protect their interests.

The House is aware that the Minister for Agriculture last year licensed certain individuals to assemble seed wheat, and fixed the price that was to be paid to the farmers at 2/6 over the guaranteed price of 35/-. Irish-produced seed wheat was bought by licensed assemblers at 37/6, and that seed has since been sold back at from 55/- to 65/- a barrel. In many cases a considerable quantity of seed reached farmers at 62/-, 63/-, and 65/-. That is a disgraceful situation at a time when farmers are expected to produce a crop of wheat for the coming year at the not very attractive price of £2 a barrel. The agricultural community generally was so chastened as not to kick up a row about that, but the Minister, at least, should have faced up to his responsibility and controlled the price of seed wheat. There was no difficulty about fixing the price. He had the basis of 37/6, allowing a reasonable margin for handling charges which, in my opinion, should be covered by 10/- a barrel. That seed should have reached farmers again at a cost of about 47/6, but they had to pay from 10/- to £1 more than that. As a result many farmers have been fleeced in the purchase of seeds.

The reply that Deputies get in this House when they put down a question is that the Minister says it is not in the national interest to give any information. I put down a question some time ago to the Minister for Supplies with regard to superphosphate manures. I asked him whether he approved of an ex-factory price of £8 per ton. He gave me that information. I asked him to give me some information as to the approximate dates of the landing of raw rock in this country. He refused to give me that and said that it was not in the public interest. I then asked him if he would give me even the date of the last landing of raw rock, and again he refused and said that it was not in the public interest. I cannot see why it is not in the public interest to know when the last landing of raw rock was made in this country. I cannot satisfy myself as to the justification or otherwise of an ex-factory price of £8 per ton. We are paying a subsidy through the Department of Agriculture of £1 per ton on superphosphate and the effect of that is nullified to a very great extent by the exorbitant price charged by the manufacturers.

I have here the official prices of fertilisers obtaining in England at present. The official price of superphosphate at Bristol is £5 4s. per ton; Hull, £4 19s. 6d.; Liverpool, £5 4s. 6d.; London, £4 19s.; Leigh, £5 0s. 6d. These are the prices at five centres all over England, giving an average ex-factory price of £5 1s. 6d. There are certain rebates on that. There is a rebate of 3/- per ton if delivery is taken in the month of January, and of 1/6 per ton in the month of February. In round figures, £5 per ton is the ex-factory price in England, and the ex-factory price here is £8. I am deliberately dealing with superphosphate, because the ex-factory price of sulphate of ammonia in England is £10 2s. per ton. Sulphate of ammonia is manufactured in England and has always been much cheaper in England than here, because it is manufactured there. I am taking a particular basic manure, and the source of the raw material for that for both countries is the same, namely, North Africa, and both countries manufacture their own manures. While it is conceivable that the transport charges in our cases are higher——

Comment on this

Very much higher.

Comment on this

——and sulphuric acid possibly may be cheaper in England, there is no justification for a higher price for superphosphate here of £3 per ton.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know the difference in the transport charges?

Comment on this

I can get no information from the responsible Minister. I was refused the information.

Comment on this

The Deputy does know that British ships are controlled, and not merely are freights controlled, but they are subsidised by the British Government. Phosphate rock into Great Britain is carried in British ships, while phosphate rock had to be brought here in neutral ships chartered in the open market at the top freight at which ships could be obtained. That factor will be sufficient to indicate the cost of transport, not from North Africa, because it has not been available from there for 12 months, but from across the Atlantic, and the freight is very much higher than in Great Britain.

Comment on this

I have referred to that.

Comment on this

The cost of phosphate rock delivered here has gone up 400 per cent.

Comment on this

When did we get the last cargo?

Comment on this

I have referred to that possibility and I concede that to the Minister. I am taking this up because I represent a very intensive tillage area where a lot of artificial manure is used and has been used for a great many years. I have tried from time to time to elicit some information from the Minister, and I want to protest against the contemptuous way I have been treated by the Minister in that regard. I have gone to some trouble to try to determine what the position is. I am not at all satisfied that there is any justification for an ex-factory price of £8. What was the position when the agricultural community were satisfied to grow essential food for the community at a price that was not by any means attractive under the conditions that operated last Christmas with regard to the price of essential artificial manures? First of all, we got a delivery of 25 per cent. of last year's supply and there was no sign of any further supplies being forthcoming. From time to time we tried to find out what the position was from the Minister for Agriculture, but he was so vague about the whole position that we could get no information. We were told by him that there was a possibility of 50 per cent. of last year's supply, and, during the tillage drive, the Secretary of the Department of Agriculture went to Cork and announced that a supply of 75 per cent. would be available. But, when a further 25 per cent. of last year's supply was eventually released at a very late period, the price had jumped 35/- per ton, although, without taking that into consideration at all, the price of wheat had been fixed and the whole position with regard to the farmer was ignored.

My attitude on the whole question of essential food for the people was and is still that, facing the very critical time in which we are living and the very serious future for this country, we cannot afford to think individually or sectionally. I do not want to stress the farmer's interest particularly; neither do I want the farmer to make excess profits any more than anyone else; but I think he is entitled to consideration and to a fair crack of the whip, and he is not getting that. Farmers are not being protected at present, as a most important section of the community ought to be protected, if you want them to do their best in this emergency. No effort has been made to protect them, either in regard to seeds or artificial manures.

What is the position in regard to compound manures? There is 100 per cent. of last year's supply of compound manures available, and any man who bought compound manure last year can get 100 per cent. of what he bought last year. What does that mean? It means that it is contrary to the whole policy of the Department of Agriculture, because farmers have always been advised by the Department to buy single manures and make their own mixture; to study artificial manures and to see what type of mixture would suit their own circumstances; and that, in any case, it was a cheaper and better proposition for them, because the manufacturers always took the advantage of charging too much for compound manures. The price of compound manures as against single manures was always relatively too high, and the low grade phosphates were always mixed in the compound manures. That was the advice of the Department to the farmers and the progressive and keen farmer took advantage of that. The man who took the advice of the Department is penalised this year, because the manufacturers have been permitted to manufacture 100 per cent. of last year's supply of compound manures. The farmer who last year ignored the advice given by the Department of Agriculture is, obviously, going to be the wise man this year, because he is to get 100 per cent. of what he got last year. I think that is not treating the people fairly. This question has aroused a good deal of indignation all over the country. First of all the supply was held up to a very late period. Secondly, there is no reliable information as to the quantity that is available. One Department appears to be contradicting the other on that. Another point is, that within the last few weeks the price has been jumped without any justification because so far as my information goes no raw rock has arrived in this country for some months past.

There is also the question of oil for tractors which we have discussed here during the last few weeks. I put down a number of questions to the Minister for Supplies with a view to focussing his attention on that problem, to try to get him and his Department to realise the important place that these tractors fill in the agricultural life of the country. We know that on the very large farms their cultivation depends to a very large extent on the employment of these tractors. A number of new tractors came into the country within the last two years. It is well, however, that it should be realised that the high compression engines in these tractors will not function without adequate supplies of vaporising oil. The supply of that vaporising oil for tractors was allowed to run out at a critical period in the year. The Minister may say that after a period he found a substitute for it in a new compound fuel—a mixture of kerosene and petrol. But why was a valuable period of time allowed to be lost, and why were a number of these tractors immobilised for want of fuel? Obviously, because the Department did not take the matter seriously and did not worry about the position. I wonder if the Minister is aware that there is one particular company not able to supply this new fuel for tractors to-day, with the result that there are some tractor-owners who at the moment are without a supply of fuel. Does the Minister appreciate what that means, and the effect that it is going to have on future production?

Again, in some areas, owing to the lateness of the season and the fact that the land is still very wet, many farmers have been unable to sow wheat. There is no doubt, I think, but that the area of land under wheat this year is not going to come up to the Minister's anticipations or to meet the nation's requirements. There will be quite a good increase under oats and barley. No attempt is being made by the Department of Agriculture to deal with the position as regards seed. In some counties seed barley is definitely scarce, even at this early period of the year. To my knowledge, the Department made no attempt to review the position and find out what quantity of barley and oats seed was available.

In my opinion no proper planning has been done with regard to the production of essential food. I come from an area of the country where there is intensive cultivation of sugar beet. I want to say now that I am very doubtful whether, at the present time, it is in the national interest to cultivate 100 per cent. of our requirements in sugar beet. I say that at the risk of offending many sugar-beet growers in my area. I believe the policy that is being pursued by our neighbours in England and Northern Ireland is the right one. It has resulted in a tremendous increase in the area of land that is being put under potatoes. It is all very well to advise farmers at the present time to grow more potatoes, but that is not enough. If we find ourselves in the position next year that our wheat production is far short of our requirements, the best substitute we can have is potatoes. I want to say to the Minister that it is not yet too late to encourage a big increase in the area of land under potatoes. We should do as our neighbours have done in that respect—give a guaranteed price for potatoes, one that will ensure a plentiful supply of them next year. That is a matter that should be taken up immediately, otherwise it will be too late.

I ask the House to bear this fact in mind, that I am not blaming the Government if the area of land under wheat falls far short of their anticipation and of their requirements. That is due to adverse weather conditions, the fact that the land could not be cultivated in its present condition. I suggest to the Government that they ought to fix a guaranteed price for potatoes. We know that in England and in Northern Ireland, as a result of fixing a handsome price for potatoes last year, the Governments there succeeded in getting their farmers to put a hugely increased area of land under potatoes. I think that if we want to make suitable provision for our people we should do the same. If our wheat supply falls short of requirements our people will not go hungry if we have a plentiful supply of potatoes and milk. While on that point, I should like to say that I do not think it is at all suitable that cottage plots should be laid down under wheat, oats or barley. These plots should be sown with potatoes and garden vegetables so that should there be an acute shortage of food next year, the occupiers will have a supply of suitable food to meet their own requirements. It is almost certain that there will be a shortage of essential food, if the shipping position does not improve. The Minister for Supplies has told us that he does not anticipate any improvement in that respect. No ships are being chartered to carry grain to this country.

While on the question of food supplies, I desire to refer briefly to a matter that we debated last week. I want to say that I think it is a real crime at the present time, when one takes into account the scarcity of food generally in those islands, to have the wholesale slaughter of herds carried out wherever an outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease occurs. We all agree that where the disease is present the infected animals ought to be destroyed and buried. That ought to be done immediately. Unfortunately, delays have taken place in digging trenches and in burying infected animals. A delay of a week or more has occurred in some cases. I discussed that privately with the Minister for Agriculture yesterday, and I do not want to go into it here. There is this point that I would like to emphasise, that where animals at one end of a large farm do not come into contact with infected animals at another end of the farm, the former, I think, should not be slaughtered. You have, however, cases like that. An outbreak occurs at one end of a large farm—this has actually happened in the County Dublin—and at the other end of it you have stock there that have not made any contact whatever with the diseased animals. Yet, all the animals on that farm have been slaughtered and destroyed. It seems ridiculous to me, when we talk about food supplies, that that valuable food should be lost simply because those animals happened to be on a farm where the disease is present and that there might be a risk of infection if they are allowed to live. Those animals are perfectly free from the disease. The food is good and absolutely fit for human consumption. It seems a shame, a crime, that that food should be buried. It ought to be used for human consumption, providing necessary food for our own people, or there is no reason why we should not export it if necessary. The British are doing it themselves. In the case of the S.S. Kilkenny, which produced an infected animal at Birkenhead, there were 15 contacts in that case, but there was only one destroyed The rest were slaughtered and used for food. I think their system of handling this disease has been very effective in the past. They consider that this food is good for human use and is free from disease. They have not destroyed it, and I think we should not destroy it. There is no reason why those animals should not be killed and dressed on the farm, packed in canvas and brought in either for consumption here or for export.

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

I should just like to ask the Deputy whether or not the British did that in pre-emergency cases of this kind, or whether they are just doing it in those emergency cases?

Comment on this

They have always done it. As a matter of fact you got a set of figures quite recently from the Minister for Agriculture on the other side giving the cost of the incidence of the disease over a period of years. I think the average cost was £100,000, and that low figure was made possible by salvaging any food that was fit for human consumption. The question of tea and petrol has been referred to by Deputy O'Higgins. On the question of tea, I think that to a great extent the Minister himself is responsible for the shortage, because he appealed to people last summer and last autumn to put in stores of essential food. Obviously the principal commodity that people could store easily was tea. I have no doubt that there are stocks of tea in the country, laid in by people who were able to afford to do so. To my mind that is very unfair to the unfortunate man who was not able to afford to lay in stocks, the wage-earner who could buy only his supply from week to week. Even the alarm that was created within recent weeks by the announcement of an acute shortage in supplies of certain commodities has had the effect of encouraging further hoarding of supplies. Up to the present the attempt at rationing tea is a pure hoax, because there is no difficulty in the way of any individual who wants to go in to two or three shops in a particular town and represent that he is going to buy from each shop his weekly supply, thereby ensuring that he will get three times the amount which is supposed to be rationed to him. In any case, so far the Minister has no control or no information concerning the quantity of tea that a retailer has. The retailers are in a position to supply their friends with any quantity of tea they like, and the whole scare about tea has had the effect of making supplies still more scarce, because hoarding has definitely gone on within recent weeks.

It is the opinion of many people in this country, and I think it is absolutely sound, that if there is a shortage of any essential commodity we should all be put on a short supply. We should all be put on the same basis, and you can only do that by compiling a national register. I think it is unfortunate that a national register was not made months ago. Our neighbours are on iron rations at the present time, and that could only be effectively done there through a national register. After Munich, the British I think spent six months on compiling that register, but we evidently did not anticipate the position which exists to-day. No attempt was made here to compile a national register, and, when rationing was necessary, the sort of rationing which was introduced was utterly futile. In fact, it was harmful, because it encouraged some people to lay in reserves, leaving other people who were unable to afford to do so in the unfortunate position that, as they could only buy from week to week, they would be the first to suffer if there were any real shortage. That is the sort of thing, which, in an emergency of this sort, gives rise to discontent, and when you have discontent in the country it may go further and give rise to civil commotion and revolution. That is what we ought to be afraid of. That is what we must guard against in this country at the present time. I think we will be lucky if we get through without civil disturbance of some sort or other. As I have said, we all realise the serious position to which we have to face up. We have all the disadvantages of war, and we have none of the advantages that war brings in the way of employment, etc. I would suggest to the Minister, therefore, that in any scheme of rationing which he brings in he should deal fairly with every individual and every section of the community.

On the question of the rationing of coal, there is just one point to which I want to direct the Minister's attention. Apparently, no provision has been made in the case of people in the country who have been in the habit of buying a quantity of coal here in the city. They were in the habit of getting a wagon of coal or a lorry of coal in the city, and they now find themselves in the position that they cannot get supplies. I want to know if the Minister will do something about that. Those people have not been in the habit of buying locally, and they have now no local source of supply. There is also another matter in relation to coal which arises in my constituency. A number of families, soldiers' families who have been evacuated from the Curragh to Newbridge and other towns in the vicinity, and who were always getting their supplies of coal on the Curragh, are unable to get supplies at the present time. I am not sure whether the Minister knows that or not. I would like him to take a note of the fact that those families are not able to secure their supplies of coal locally, because they have not been buying locally. It is only within recent weeks that they have been evacuated. There is a good deal of discontent in those towns in the neighbourhood of the Curragh as a result of that position.

On the question of petrol, I wish to emphasise the point made by Deputy O'Higgins, that it is really a disgrace to find that the petrol to the medical profession and the clergy is issued on a class basis. The Minister said that they were able to make allowances in special circumstances, but where representations were made, to my knowledge, by several Deputies, because of the special circumstances in respect of dispensary doctors in rural areas where a 'flu epidemic was raging, they met with no response. The representations made in every case of which I am aware have failed to get any allowance. It does seem extraordinary that a medical man working in an institution, a whole-time officer who has no work outside that institution, is allowed eight gallons of petrol for a small car, just as much as a dispensary doctor in the remote, mountainous districts of County Kerry, trying to look after his dispensary patients. The country doctor cannot get the petrol he requires. There is no common basis there, and you should not deal with cases of that sort on a class basis.

I think it is unfair to the men who have to do a lot of work, if they are expected to do that work in any way effectively. It is wrong to put the doctor working in a rural dispensary district on the same basis as the man who does not have to use petrol. The same applies to clergymen. A professor in a college is getting the same amount of petrol as a priest working in a rural diocese. I have been told of medical professors attached to the university, not living far from the university, and they are able to ride up in their cars every day to give lectures there. They get eight or 12 gallons, whatever the allowance is according to the horse-power of their cars. Doctors in the city are also getting a big allowance. With the volume of public conveyances which you have in the city, that seems absurd.

I made a genuine representation on behalf of certain farmers who were trying to carry out tillage operations on farms ten or 12 miles away from their homes. They wanted to supervise the work on those farms, and their applications for a reasonable petrol allowance were refused. There was no consideration given in a case of that sort. Here were men vital to the interests of this country, producing essential food, and they wanted to get petrol simply for the purpose of seeing that the food was being properly produced for the use of the nation. They were not considered at all, but the professor who wanted to ride in his car to the university, and who would not use a tram, could get his allowance of eight, ten or 12 gallons. I am not a man who would ordinarily approve of farmers attempting to strike, but under those conditions one would be sorely tempted to say to the farmers, owing to the way they have been treated, that it would be time for them to down tools if genuine representations on their behalf were going to be ignored by responsible Ministers.

It is really a disgrace the way this matter has been handled. No attempt has been made to organise it properly. The Department of Supplies has made no attempt to face the problems that are there to be solved. If the petrol supplies that are available in this country are worth rationing, the rationing ought to be done properly. It cannot be done properly from a central office in Dublin. If you work from a central office there will be an inclination to do it more or less on a class basis. I suggest that you should have an office in each county and send down a clerk or two in order to work in co-operation with the local registration officer, the Gárdaí, and other people with local knowledge. The local registration officer in each county is a store of information as to the activity of every man with a lorry or car, and he, alone, would be worth more than half a central office staff. At the present time no attempt is being made to use the knowledge of a man in that position.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy give him absolute discretion in deciding applications?

Comment on this

No. I would send down one or two officers from your Department to co-operate with him and with the Gárdaí.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want discretion to be exercised in determining the relative merits of individual cases? Does he wish to have it this way, that John Smith will get ten gallons, that Pat Browne will get none, and that someone else may get two? Is that the Deputy's suggestion?

Comment on this

I suggest there are no parallel cases in any class in this country. You cannot deal with this matter on the class basis.

Comment on this

Therefore, there must be individual discretion?

Comment on this

Because it has been dealt with on a class basis, that is the cause of all the grousing and the grumbling.

Comment on this

The Deputy would hear plenty of grousing and grumbling if you did it the other way.

Comment on this

Of course, if the Minister put in one of his own colleagues, there would be plenty of grousing.

Comment on this

What about one of the Deputy's colleagues? Then there would be twice as much grousing.

Comment on this

I suggest that some of the Minister's officers should go down and get in touch with the Gárdaí and get the information necessary. It is not such a big problem. The money spent in the Minister's Department is worse than wasted, because it is creating violent discontent all over the country. The sooner the Minister gets in touch with how the people feel about these matters, and appreciates how they feel, the better. The gap between the Government and the people has been widened. The people have been ignored. Their feelings have not been taken into account. Their interests are not catered for, and that is what is wrong at the present time. The people who are most disappointed and most bitter in their criticism of the Government at the present time are the Minister's own supporters.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

It is so, and if anything is going to happen democratic government here, and if this institution, our Parliament, is torn down, the Minister and his colleagues will be responsible for it.

Comment on this

I will say this in connection with Deputy Hughes' last remark, that if there is anything going to pull down democratic government in this country it is the moaning and the groaning and the howling that has been going on here week after week and month after month on the part of people who cannot see one week beyond another——

Comment on this

What about those who are hungry, who cannot get food? Speak the truth.

Comment on this

They are not the people who are howling.

Comment on this

I listened to Deputy O'Higgins, and all I have to say to him——

Comment on this

The people will not stick it much longer.

Comment on this

I will say this to Deputy O'Higgins, that if there were fewer of his class in the country the country would be better off. There are too many pro-British squibs hanging around this country to-day.

Comment on this

There are no pro-British squibs here.

Comment on this

Ministers and Deputies on this side foresaw that this position might occur years ago, and they started making their preparations for it years ago. They started to make those preparations in the face of a campaign of sabotage and blackguardism such as no Government ever had to put up with in this country before. When we set out to prevent the flour mills of the country being scrapped, we had howls from this and that corner of "there is profiteering here, profiteering there and profiteering elsewhere," from people whose eyes were blinded while the British millers were profiteering to ten times the extent, if there is any profiteering going on to-day. They were silent at that time, and that campaign of sabotage was conducted in the hope that when this country's hour of need would come, we should be dependent for our bread on those across the water. When we started to get the Irish farmer to grow wheat supplies here, so that there would be bread for the Irish people, what was the attitude of the know-alls on the opposite benches? What was their attitude even after the war started? We had the deputy-leader of the Party holding out the olive branch and saying: "We are prepared to assist this Government by every means in our power on condition that the beet factories are blown up and the wheat lunacy is done away with." That was the statement made by Deputy Dillon two months after the war started. That was their policy as enunciated by the only agricultural leader who put forward any policy from that side. If we had accepted his advice, I wonder how many hungry mouths there would be to-day. I wonder where the bread would come from and what would be the price of it. I do not think it would be cash. Deputy Hughes was so far-seeing in respect of the condition of affairs that, last November, he spent a full day demanding of the Minister for Agriculture that he should allow barley to be exported from this country.

Comment on this

I said no such thing.

Comment on this

I will produce the Official Report for the Deputy, if he wants it.

Comment on this

Produce it. I should like the Deputy to do so.

Comment on this

He demanded that the ports should be thrown open for the export of the surplus barley which the brewers did not want.

Comment on this

I do not think it is fair for a Deputy to misrepresent what another Deputy has said. The way I put that last year was that, when export was refused, the farmers were entitled to at least a guaranteed price on the home market, which is quite a different thing. I did not advocate the exportation of barley or oats, but said that when exportation was denied, a guaranteed home price should be fixed for them.

Comment on this

I had a couple of hours to spare the other night, and I amused myself by reading over the speech of Deputy Hughes on that subject. I have a very good memory—perhaps too long a memory for some Deputies opposite —and I very definitely took that statement from him. It was the period when the farmers were endeavouring to sell their barley and when it was being bought at a price of from 18/- to 20/- a barrel. The Deputy said that barley could be sold across the water at a price of anything from 35/- to 50/- a barrel, and he demanded to know why, since the market was not here for it, the Minister was not prepared to allow its export.

Comment on this

I protest against Deputy Corry——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is a question of fact which the Chair cannot pronounce on. Deputy Corry must cease discussing it further.

Comment on this

I want to show how farseeing the Deputy was.

Comment on this

In that case, the Deputy should read from the Official Report.

Comment on this

I shall bring it in here in a minute, and read it for the Deputy's benefit, if the Ceann Comhairle allows me to do so. But for the manner in which this Government worked from 1932 to the present day, there would be little use in talking of supplies of food, because they would not be here. The Government had to work against that type of sabotage which was carried on in this country. If you went to any farmer who had any kind of Fine Gael leanings at all, and asked him to grow an acre of wheat, he would nearly hit you. They were brought to that viewpoint by the continued——

Comment on this

I personally grew more wheat than the Deputy did.

Comment on this

I am not alluding to Deputy Hughes in this matter.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is alluding to me all the time.

Comment on this

Not in this matter of wheat. I am alluding to his leader, to the shadow Minister for Agiculture, Deputy Dillon, who told us here that he would not be seen dead in a field of wheat. He is glad to have it to eat to-day. If the farmers had not grown from 200,000 to 250,000 acres of wheat since then, there would be little use in looking for 500,000 acres or 600,000 acres to-day. Let us face the facts. Deputy Hughes is absolutely right when he speaks of the profiteering that went on. I know farmers to-day who are anxious to grow wheat, but who are completely unable to do so at the price placed on that wheat by the merchants.

Comment on this

But for the merchants you would have no seed at all. Nobody but the merchants was carrying the baby, so do not be too severe on them.

Comment on this

It is a lovely baby. I should like to be carrying that kind of baby. If they were carrying that kind of baby in any other country in Europe, they would be strung up from the nearest lamp post. They bought wheat, re-winnowed, bagged and ready for sale, at 37/6 per barrel, and sold it at 65/- to 70/- per barrel. That is a lovely baby, a beautiful baby.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry might just as easily have done it.

Comment on this

I was not as big a millionaire as Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

I did not do it any more than the Deputy.

Comment on this

More fool the Deputy.

Comment on this

Surely, but why blame the fellow who did?

Comment on this

The baby will be killed between the two Deputies.

Comment on this

That is the position and there is no burking it. God knows, we have officials enough. My attention was called to three men from the Board of Works to-day who were outside measuring with a measuring tape a 200 year old cannon. There were three of them around it with the tape measure.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not seem to relate to general policy.

Comment on this

I suggest that these civil servants would be far better employed if they were handed over to the Minister for Supplies and told to go into the merchants' stores, examine their books and so get at the profiteers, and end the profiteering. End it, but not by the policy of the Prices Commission, which found a man overcharging for a pair of boots, and ordered him to hand back the difference, and there was no more about it.

Comment on this

Did the man keep the boots?

Comment on this

The balance between the right price and the original charge was handed back. In my opinion that shopkeeper should have been sent to jail.

Comment on this

The position is that we have no spring wheat. If £10 a ton were offered for it, enough of it could not be got now.

Comment on this

Oats bought at 1/- per stone is now fetching from 3/- to 4/- a stone. Barley that was bought at from 18/- to 20/- a barrel is now selling at from £2 to £2 10s. 0d.

Comment on this

And it cannot be got for seed.

Comment on this

The Department of Supplies is responsible for prices. Surely the Minister could spare some of the officials to go round and ascertain the prices at which merchants bought and the price they are charging for seed.

Comment on this

Let the Department produce a supply of seed. That is its job, but it is not doing it. That is the kernel of the whole thing.

Comment on this

I dealt with that position six weeks ago. It has not been rectified since. In fact, it got worse when these people saw that they were able to "get away" with it. Unfortunately I find myself in the position that I have to bring matters that I referred to previously before the House again in order to get something done. I refer now to supplies of iron and steel. In August, 1939, the Minister for Industry and Commerce was present at the opening of a big steel industry in Cobh, which was to give employment to a large number of people, numbering in the seventeenth month 724 persons. I happened to be in Haulbowline then and I was delighted that the Government was going to get rid of the white elephant there, and that there was going to be plenty of employment in the mill that was working in Cobh. Any business man would know definitely from August, 1939, that imports would be scarcer every month until they ceased entirely. Still, in August, 1940, merchant iron was still being produced in this mill from billets. In February, 1941, steel rails and billets were still being used there.

There are now 300 men on the unemployed register in Cobh. The mill I refer to was to be self-contained. It was to deal with all the scrap iron that could be brought there, and turn it into merchant iron. For the past 18 months it has been producing merchant iron. I have a proposal here which would mean that 60 or 70 tons of steel ingots could be produced every 24 hours from scrap iron. Some 120 men could be employed on the erection of an extension for five months. If erected these men could have been working on raw material that for the past 13 months has unfortunately been exported. This proposal is from one of the cleverest engineers in this country, a man who knows his job. He says that in five months he would have the necessary furnace erected and working. In fact, three-quarters of it is erected and the remainder of the material is on the ground. That is bad enough, but when we look at the far-reaching effects the position is going to have on a firm in Cork that employs from 150 to 180 persons, it means that in three months it may have to close down for want of iron, and also some other small industries.

I may be told that there is no right to interfere with private property. We have been told that all citizens of this State have equal rights and privileges. I am a farmer representing the majority of the people, who are farmers. If there are to be equal rights for all citizens I have as much right to my farm as any industrialist has to his factory. For the good of this country the Minister ordered me to plough one-fifth of my farm in order to produce food. If I do not do it, the Minister has the right to take that land from me and produce the food himself. If the argument is that this place is private property, I say that there should be equal rights for all citizens, and that the Minister has the same right to take over that mill and use it to produce the iron and steel that this country needs, as he has to take over my farm and produce wheat on it. There should be equal rights for all.

Between 60,000 and 70,000 tons of scrap iron have been exported from this country since the war started. It has been exported, I understand, at £3 per ton, while billets have been imported at £16 per ton. Irishmen to the number of 115 could have been employed in that mill in the open furnace portion alone, converting that scrap iron, which is allowed to leave this country, into billets, which were imported at £16 per ton. I do not pretend to know what the difficulties are. I am only a farmer. When I went about this business first, I went about it blindly. But I went about it because there were 300 people in Cobh hungry, and this mill, in which it was guaranteed they would get employment, was not giving them the employment I considered they were entitled to. My job here, I take it, is to look after the interests of my constituents, and I intend to do it. We had this extraordinary position, that one individual in this country, who had two separate personalities, came down to my constituency and bought ten or eleven miles of rails there. He bought them as one individual, loaded them on his trucks, took them to Dublin, then sold them back to himself, and railed them back to within half a mile of the place from which they came.

Comment on this

They are very slow in Cork.

Comment on this

They are. These rails were bought in Cork, brought up to Dublin, and re-sold to the man himself. He was the managing director of two mills; he bought them as the managing director of one mill, sold them back to himself as managing director of another, and railed them back again to where they came from.

Comment on this

He was a terrible fool to bring them back again.

Comment on this

When Deputy Belton wants a pair of shoes for his horse, he will have to pay for taking these rails up here and taking them back again. When Deputy Belton wants a part for his agricultural machinery, he will have to pay for sending them up here and taking them back again, and for the profit made on them. Farmers are told to produce a crop at 40/- per barrel, and that they will get no more. But, when we look for a plough-share, or a steel bar for our plough, or a set of shoes for our horse, we find that this is allowed. This is perfectly justifiable, because the person concerned is a business man. I am not concerned how it is to be done. What I am concerned about is that there are 300 men idle in Cobh, and 100 to 150 in Passage, and unless this scandal is rectified within the next three months men will be idle in every metal industry in the Twenty-six counties. This is the root of the matter—the scrap iron going out of our ports for the benefit of the foreigner. That mill is now lying idle. The furnace there should have been converting that scrap into merchant iron. I alluded to this matter some six weeks ago and three weeks ago, and I hope that I will not have to allude to it again.

Comment on this

Who is the agent who is sending the scrap iron out of the country?

Comment on this

Unfortunately, I have got so many lessons in this House that I know we are prohibited from giving the names of individuals.

Comment on this

The export of scrap iron has been prohibited for many months past.

Comment on this

Except under licence.

Comment on this

No licences have been given for well over twelve months.

Comment on this

The Minister will have to look it up again, as my information in regard to it is fairly correct. It took me a long time to poke it out, but I think I have got my finger on it. According to the information I have got, from the 17th month this furnace was to be melting 6,250 lbs. of scrap iron every month. The average export of scrap iron since 1927 was about 30,000 tons per year, so that they would want two and a half years' supply to keep the mill going for 12 months.

Comment on this

And the man who is to keep it going is also the chief agent for exporting the scrap iron.

Comment on this

All I am worrying about is that some of my constituents are idle and that this country is going to be in a bad way because the farmers will not have iron for shoes for their horses and steel will not be available either. One of the objects set forth in connection with this mill was to build one 35 tons open hearth furnace to produce from 100 per cent. scrap, 60 to 70 tons of steel ingots per 24 hours, which could, without intermediate rolling, be worked on merchant mill into standard merchant iron — rounds, squares, horse-shoe iron, angles, car-tyre flats, etc. That has been gone into and found absolutely correct. This proposal was vetted by four or five engineers on the job at Haulbowline, as well as by engineers from the Department. That is the position, as I view it, and I want it ended. If there are any private individuals, private interests or private concerns standing in the way of having it ended, then I claim we are entitled to demand that they be treated in the same manner as the farmers are being treated. It has been found necessary, in the interests of this country, to make the farmer do certain things with his land. If he refuses to plough it the Minister for Agriculture comes in, takes the land from him and gets it ploughed. I suggest that in this case, if the people I refer to are not going to do the job themselves, the Department should come in and do it for them, take over the thing and work it as an emergency measure. At any rate, it is time to have an end to this gamble that has been going on there.

Our agricultural community have been doing their part and doing it well. We can see that as we travel in the train from Cork to Dublin. Every second field is ploughed. You see men on the land harrowing, or engaged in some other form of agricultural work. Some years ago I demanded that the leeches be taken off our backs, the jobbers, the profiteers, the wanglers of all descriptions who have stepped in between the farmer and the consumer of bread in this country. If our price for wheat is to be 40/- a barrel, let it go in to the miller at 40/-. Let the miller's costings be examined at the price at which he delivers that wheat in the form of flour to the public. Let us not have the local publican getting his shilling a barrel out of it, the thief a little bigger than he getting 2/6 a barrel, and the still bigger thief getting 5/- a barrel; all of it coming out of the farmer's pocket. All those people have been getting that money out of the farmer's price, even though they had not seen the crop grow. It is time that all that should end.

As far as I can judge, a very tough time is before us in this country for the next 12 months and, in my opinion, this war is going to carry on until about 1945.

Comment on this

It is well to know that anyhow.

Comment on this

The Deputy can take it as a tip.

Comment on this

From the Minister for pessimism.

Comment on this

People should remember that we of the agricultural community are not profiteers. We are not out to fleece anybody. We are not allowed to fleece anybody. When a Minister tells us solemnly that if we get more than 35/- a barrel for our wheat, the price of a 4 lb. loaf will have to go over 1/-, and when we find afterwards that the get-rich-quick gentlemen step in between the miller and the farmer and extract 43/2 for what was supposed to be sold for 35/-, we say there is something wrong. That also should end. If that is allowed to go on, then in the course of a few years the position will be reached here that we had in connection with the redundant creameries some years ago. We will find it necessary to set up some sort of a disposals board to buy out those gentlemen and their interests, because in a few years' time they will have created a vested interest in the farmer's crop. These are the only points I wish to deal with.

Comment on this

A few days ago the Minister for Supplies delivered a lecture to his political supporters under the heading—"Let us face the Facts." That was a very appropriate heading. It would also, I think, be an appropriate heading for this debate. It is about time that this Parliament and nation faced the facts as they are. At the present time there is in this country a growing feeling of hostility towards Parliamentary institutions. Nobody, except a person employed in a Government office, or a member of the Government, perhaps, can close his ears to the mutterings of that campaign. At the moment we are only hearing the first great murmurings of that protest. Therefore, I say that unless we face the facts, these murmurings will swell into an angry roar, demanding the abolition of democratic government and the substitution therefor of a socialistic or communistic form of dictatorship, such as has been established in some other countries in Europe.

What are the facts at the present time? Suppose the 130 odd elected representatives of the Irish people who sit in this House found themselves marooned to-morrow on some island in the middle of the ocean, what is the first thing we would do? Would we start by looking out across the waters to see if some big banker, some Government official, or some financial expert was coming to us with a roll of notes, or a fat cheque book to provide us with the means of improving our position? No; we would first of all survey the position of the island and take account of whatever food supplies were on it; to see how we could best provide ourselves with the necessary food, clothing and shelter. In other words, would we not, for the first time in our lives, put our heads together and face the facts? The first thing to do would be to make a survey of the quantity of food that we had in the nation. The second would be to try to make provision for the growing of increased supplies for the future. In addition to that, we would have to see about providing shelter. If we were to adopt the methods which we in this country adopt, we would have to wait until somebody would provide us with paper currency from some source in order to get to work, but if we were facing facts as we would be facing facts in such an isolated condition we would not wait for any paper currency, or for any financiers or bankers to come to our assistance. We would get to work at once. Those Deputies who have some knowledge of agriculture would be put to work on the land. Those who have some knowledge of building would be put to work to provide us with houses. In a word, we would all get to work as sensible people, and thus ensure at least survival. What this nation wants at the moment, and what this nation expects from the 138 elected representatives here in this House, is that we will get down to bedrock facts and give the nation some hope of survival.

At the present time we are faced with a shortage of food, although we know that this country is capable of providing more than sufficient food for a much larger population than we have at the present time. Why are we faced with that shortage? Simply because nobody thought it worth while to face facts. Nobody thought it worth while to make provision for the future. Last year, a considerable amount of land was put under tillage. The greater portion of that land under tillage was applied to the growing of potatoes, oats and barley. When those three crops were produced, there was no market for them. There was a market for a limited quantity of barley. There was no market for oats or potatoes. Was that, I ask, facing facts? Was it encouraging the agricultural producer to get the maximum amount of food out of the land? As far back as last August I asked a question here in this House: I asked the Minister for Agriculture would he be prepared to assist the farmers with credit to hold over their supplies of oats and barley until a market would be available, but the Minister said "No". He said there was already machinery there through the Agricultural Credit Corporation, which every farmer knows is machinery that is not available to the farmer who requires credit. Later, in October, it struck me as a farmer that a sufficient effort was not being made to encourage or induce farmers to get in autumn sown wheat. I asked the Minister for Agriculture if he would be prepared to take steps to offer some particular inducement to farmers to get in autumnsown wheat. I suggested in the question which I asked that a special inducement should be offered which would increase the price of wheat, particularly to those who got their crop in before Christmas. The Minister replied that they were about to engage in a campaign for increased wheat growing and that there had been an increase of 2/6 in the price, an increase which every farmer knew was altogether inadequate and was completely cancelled by the already increased costs of production. That, in my opinion, was not facing facts. The fact that I put that suggestion to the Minister for Agriculture ought to show that the Deputies at this side of the House were not out to criticise or obstruct the Government, but were simply concerned about making constructive suggestions to them, and making them in good time. However, no notice was taken of that suggestion, and we had the position allowed to drift on until after Christmas when the Government found that supplies of wheat were becoming exhausted. Anyone with any knowledge of realities, or any desire to face up to realities, would have realised that September and October were the months in which to launch a campaign for an increased acreage of wheat. They were the months in which the best results would have been obtained from that campaign.

Last week, at a meeting of the urban council in Wicklow, the chairman of that urban council stated that there were children in the town of Wicklow whose feet were bleeding from the cold through the shortage of coal. A Government facing facts would not have allowed a situation to develop in which children in this country would have to suffer from such an acute shortage of fuel. I myself know that the statement by the chairman of the Wicklow Urban Council was not exaggerated. Any Deputy who has visited the cottage of a worker, particularly a cottage situated on the seaside, in a bleak, exposed seaside town, will realise how bitterly cold the weather was, and how bitterly cold it was in those cottages during the past two months. The statement that children's feet were actually bleeding from the cold was not exaggerated. Yet, we know that in this country there are and have been quite formidable supplies of coal in the hands of merchants and individuals, but those supplies were never properly distributed. In addition to whatever other complaints may be made in regard to coal, there was no reason whatever why last year we should have supported or tried to support, or pretended to support, an army of 100,000 unemployed, while we had tens of thousands of acres of bog which simply called for employment in the production of fuel. We know that the Government asked those engaged in turf production to increase their production, and we know that those people did increase it to the utmost of their resources, but we know also—at least, those of us who try to face facts know it—that those engaged in the production of turf are people with very limited means, with very limited resources, and with no capital to employ additional labour. Surely it was the duty of the State—the State which was paying 100,000 unemployed men, or paying them at least a portion of their maintenance in various ways—to put those men to work in the production of fuel, thus saving us from the humiliation of seeing children in this country, which is teeming with supplies of fuel, actually suffering acutely from the cold. That was a primary duty which should have been realised by those occupying the position of Government, and it was a duty which was pointed out to them by Deputies in all parts of the House. There was a necessity for direct action on the part of the State in the production of fuel, because it was only the State that could have taken up that work. It was only the State, with their resources, that could have provided us with supplies of turf.

It is the duty of the State, whereever possible, to employ men on the land. In towns where there are large numbers of unemployed, it should be the duty of the State to provide these men with adequate allotments and, where that is not possible, it should be the duty of the State to acquire plots of land and engage the unemployed upon them directly. There is no doubt that an unemployed man with a spade on an allotment will be much more useful than if he is left standing at a street corner or parading to the local labour exchange. What does he do at the labour exchange? Nothing, except that he signs his name. I was speaking to an unemployed man and he told me he was getting reconciled to being unemployed, reconciled to attending the labour exchange. I asked him what he expected would happen to him in the future and he said: "I am becoming so educated through signing my name every week at the labour exchange that I may have a chance of getting into the Civil Service and then I shall not have to work for the remainder of my life." That is the rather hopeless type of mentality that is being developed through the Government's policy.

The Government have been severely criticised over the hopeless muddle they made in the matter of petrol. I do not want to add anything to that criticism, but I should like to ask how it is possible to provide a court messenger, a man who simply runs messages with, possibly, some attendants to show him the way about, with 130 gallons of petrol a month when a dispensary doctor, upon whom the lives of hundreds of people may depend, is allowed only ten gallons a month? There is something wrong there. Surely there is some gross disregard of the real interests of the people when you can supply a court messenger with 130 gallons a month, as was stated here last week, and refuse a doctor in a mountainous district an extra ration beyond the ten gallons allowed. The Government claim to be a Christian Government, to be an example to the governments of other countries, but surely that is not an example of Christianity. A court messenger could easily get around on a bicycle and the dignity of the State would not be lowered if he had to find some other mode of conveyance than a V-8 motor car.

This is a matter to which the Government should pay attention, if they wish to live up to the claim that they are a Christian Government, and it is a matter with which we Deputies should concern ourselves if we claim to be the representatives of a Christian country. I am told—it may not be true—that petrol can be bought in this city at 8/6 a gallon. I wonder what kind of supervision or rationing has brought about that situation? I am told that any person prepared to pay 8/6 or 9/- a gallon for petrol can get as much as he wants. If that kind of profiteering is allowed under the guise of rationing and control, I think we would be far better off without a Minister for Supplies.

In connection with our food supplies, why is it that the unfortunate farmers are obliged to sell potatoes at 6d. to 8d. a stone while the poor in this city have to pay as much as 1/4 a stone for them? There is something wrong there and I think that in itself is one of the most serious evils under which this country is labouring. There is too much profiteering in essential foodstuffs. The net result of that profiteering is that the working classes are turning away from wholesome, home-produced foodstuffs, such as potatoes, vegetables, milk and butter, and are depending entirely on tea and other such commodities. If consumers of farm produce in our cities and towns were able to get their food supplies at a reasonable margin over the price which farmers obtain, I believe we would have more of our home-produced food consumed and we would have a healthier and a happier people.

I am afraid our Ministers are too much inclined to be benevolent to the speculator and the gambler in every walk of life, and that is not desirable. In a time of emergency there should be rigid control over people who try to corner supplies and make exorbitant profits. We have an example in the case of oats, where in some cases 200 per cent. profit has been made. We have the same position in regard to milk and butter. We had the position in the summer months when we were providing butter to the British at a very cheap rate and subsidising that supply in order to make it still cheaper and no attempt was made to foresee our own people's needs, with the result that we now have not enough butter. There has been no organisation, no foresight, no national planning. Everything has been allowed to drift in a haphazard way.

I suggest that, even now, we should begin to plan for the future. We should see that every unemployed man—and there are more than 100,000 unemployed —is occupied usefully. There are far more unemployed than have ever been registered at the labour exchanges, and the Government know that. Every unemployed man should now be converted into food and fuel. That may create a certain amount of amusement, but it does not require anything in the nature of a miracle to bring it about. Unemployed men, if put to work in the bogs right now will ensure that we will have sufficient fuel for the coming year, and perhaps for the next two years. Unemployed men, if provided with allotments and assisted to get into work in agriculture, will see that we have sufficient supplies of food.

It may be asked how we are going to assist the unemployed man to get into work in agriculture, but there is at least one thing you can do, that is, you can ensure that the agricultural employer will get back the wages he pays to these men in a fair price for his produce. If the farmer is guaranteed a price which will cover the cost of production, not only in respect of wheat, but in respect of other products also, the Government can rest assured that there will be increased employment on the land, and that that increased employment will be converted into the food which is urgently needed by the nation. No attempt has been made to assist in the financing of tillage operations during the next few months. In regard to the beet crop, I have pointed out before that ample provisions are made to finance the farmer's tillage operations over the summer months. He is provided with seed on credit, with manures and with an advance to meet his expenses in tilling and tending the crop. Farmers engaged in other branches of production which are equally important are not given any facilities. Why? Surely wheat, potatoes, barley and oats are as important as beet?

I do not altogether agree with Deputy Hughes when he says it might not be wise to grow as much beet as we intend to grow. I think that we should maintain last year's acreage, that we should even increase it, because not only does the beet crop ensure this nation supplies of sugar, it also provides a foodstuff, beet pulp and tops, which are equal to almost any other crop which can be grown on the land. An acre of beet is equal to the grain produce of an acre of oats, which shows that beet is an important crop. The other crops, however, are equally important, and it is equally essential that the credit facilities provided in respect of beet should be provided in respect of the other crops. Yet, the Government has refused to do so. They have allowed the profiteers, the gamblers and the speculators to make excellent profits out of seed wheat, oats, barley, and every other kind of seed as well as out of other supplies which the farmer needs, such as manures and implements. As Deputy Corry has pointed out, scrap iron has been brought from one end of the State to the other, and then brought back, and the cost of it falls on the tillage farmer when buying his implements and supplies.

This is a time for planning and for foresight. We all know what happened last year when the Government made a small attempt to look into the future. They apparently looked into the future with their eyes closed, when they advised parish councils to urge people in every walk of life to lay in supplies of tea, sugar, flour and coal. Surely our Ministers were not looking into the future with their eyes open when they issued that advice, the result of which is that people who could afford it have laid in supplies, but people who could not afford it, who live from day to day and hour to hour, are starving and cold to-day, because they have neither sufficient food nor sufficient coal, and are faced with the fact that before many months have passed they will be unable to get sufficient bread. I appeal to the Government to plan for the future.

In planning for the future, they have some models upon which to rely, which are not outside this country. I direct their attention again to the sugar industry. There we have a planned industry; there we have an industry in which there are no big profits being made by capitalists; there we have an industry in which the producer of the beet, the raw material, is guaranteed a fair price for his produce before he puts the crop into the land. In that industry he is given credit facilities, and not only that, but the workers in the factory are paid a wage far in excess of anything which can be paid on the land at present. If we can plan in regard to our supplies of sugar, can we not plan in regard to other supplies? Can we not look ahead? Why should we always be compelled to rely upon the very conservative and often not impartial advice of financiers and State officials? Why have the Government not sufficient initiative to plan something big for the future, as their predecessors did when they planned the sugar industry, and as they did when they extended that industry, and as their predecessors planned a national supply of electric power and light? What is needed at present is national planning, boldly conceived and courageously carried out.

Comment on this

This Vote on Account contains a reminder of the vast expenditure which will be required by the Army this year in respect of what is termed "national defence". The papers this morning contained, under rather heavy headlines, reminders on that issue also, and that, to my mind, prompts the thought of how futile and how useless all this expenditure will be if the main essentials of defence and security are ignored, as they have been up to the present. I suggest to the Minister for Finance, as a very important Minister, and to his colleagues, that as long as the injustices which are perpetrated in this country at present on the mass of the people remain, the gravest danger to national security and the greatest enemy of national defence remains in this country.

This expenditure has prompted the thought also of how easily objections which appear insurmountable to the provision of money for any useful or reproductive purpose are overcome when the provision of money for anything else arises. This world war and the breezes of the world war which have reached our shores remind us that in a situation of this kind money is always obtainable. They remind us of how insignificant all human claims —the claims of widows and orphans, of old age pensioners, of people who are idle and sentenced to a life of semi-starvation, with similar conditions for their children—appear when the thousand obstacles and difficulties alleged to exist in providing money for these purposes are enumerated, and how rapidly all such obstacles disappear when money is required for purposes of this kind. We have heard a great deal in the last seven or eight months about national unity. I repeat what I said elsewhere, that there can be no real or lasting unity while masses of our people are living as they are to-day. I say, furthermore, that the greatest menace to our security is the rising tide of discontent that unemployment, want and poverty have created, and that will be intensified in the months to come. I say to the Government in all seriousness, that all the expenditure on the Army and such purposes is useless, if they neglect to lay the real foundations of defence and security. As Deputy Hickey reminded the House, last evening, I believe that they must begin with the family, and with the home by taking real cognisance of the neglected and miserable homes that exist in our midst. A great many people are asking, and a greater number will ask in the near future: "What are we to defend?" Is it a flag that is at present the symbol of misery, the symbol of a system that has heaped upon us, time and again in the last few months, wrongs and injustice; that has deprived the unemployed of the miserable amount of assistance that the labour exchanges afforded them from the 5th of this month until next October, in addition to other indignities?"

The Government and those who think with them are sitting on the edge of a volcano if they believe that the situation that now exists is going to be borne with the same patience and the same resignation as that to which the Irish people submitted in the past. In the past the people submitted to difficulties and privations under alien administration because they had the ideal before them that the time would come when managing their own affairs, that state of affairs would end. They have been disillusioned and disappointed in that hope, and even with the fortitude that their religion has always enabled them to maintain it is expecting too much, and is, in fact, expecting the impossible to imagine that they will continue in that attitude in future. If there could be any further revelation of how hopeless is the outlook in regard to their position, that revelation was contained in last night's debate. I think the Ministerial spokesmen in that debate cut most pathetic figures. Surely, it was patnetic to hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce say that there was an improvement in the employment position in the building industry, when, to the knowledge of any man with any shred of common sense, work has completely ceased in that industry.

The position concerning supplies is represented in my opinion by a complete absence of any real national lead. We had an inquiry from the Minister for Supplies as to what could be done. No country in the world got such notice as this country got of the difficulties that would arise. No country could have made more complete preparations about supplies, because from the very day that the war broke out, the Government should have taken the lead and given the example, if private enterprise could not do it, by providing supplies and the storage necessary to sustain this country to stand any prolonged siege. There was no great foresight or knowledge of any of the plans of the belligerents needed to do that. It was quite clear to anyone who lived through the last war that the activities of submarine warfare would be a very big factor in this war, and that if wholesalers and merchants were unable to get in supplies, the Government might have gone some distance along the road that the British Government have gone, in taking over and importing and storing supplies in anticipation of the situation that has now arisen. The dislocation that could be expected might have set the Government planning along lines to counteract the effects of such dislocation. No reasonable person wants to put all the blame on the Government for the dislocation, but at least they knew that 120,000 people were idle before the war started, and as a Government they were bound to make some national effort to reduce that number substantially. We were taunted on this side last night with failing to suggest any method by which that could be done. On the eve of the war the Labour Party put down proposals in black and white to deal with the crisis that would arise but beyond sneers in certain quarters they received no attention from the Government. Many people realise now how useful some of these proposals would have been if they had been adopted. I say in all sincerity to the Government that there are people in very responsible positions, who are neither Labour agitators nor irresponsible demagogues who are wondering how long the present situation will last, until an attitude that is favourable to revolution may arise. The Government should be aware of that. It would be no pleasure to anybody if that situation should develop. It would be a great disaster for the country, but there is certainly some limit to the patience required of people who have to submit to the situation that now exists, which is virtually an economic sentence of death for thousands who cannot get a penny until next October except by way of out-door relief. There are many people in the rural areas who have not yet lost that pride that exists even amongst the humblest of them, which repels the idea of charity either through poor law institutions or the poor law system in another form.

I know thousands of people in the rural areas who are always willing to work for a living. They have been denied the opportunity of doing so, although they were told in recent months that as they were the salvation of the country they should work harder. That was what they wanted to do all the time, but they would not be allowed to do so. They would not be allowed to work more than three days a week on rotational schemes. They would not be listened to for the last seven or eight years when they asked for work from a Government that promised them work as soon as they assumed office. They are being told now that they should work hard to produce more food and do all kinds of things to save the country. I hope the Government will realise the duty they have to such people. I hope the Government will take seriously this matter of security and defence and national unity, and do something before it is too late to show, with the assistance of some outside body, or with a belated recognition of their own responsibility, which they have shelved up to the present, that they are prepared to face up to this matter in a real way. If they do that, they can depend on the co-operation of every Party in the House, and they can feel that in the future, in so far as any danger threatens the country, such danger can be faced more bravely because of the fact that the people, no matter in what humble circumstances they are, will realise that there is a united desire to do them some justice and to remove some of the grievances under which they have suffered so grievously and bitterly in the last two or three years.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

I am wondering whether the Government have yet come to a realisation of their responsibility to the people. One would imagine that the conditions obtaining during the last few months would have made them realise the position. Only to-day I received complaints that people in the poorer quarters of this city could not procure a couple of ounces of tea for their breakfast. I join with other Deputies in entering a protest against the treatment of the people as a whole, not alone in regard to tea, but in regard to petrol, coal and paraffin oil. Paraffin oil is much used in houses, tenements and cottages where there is no gas. Sometimes paraffin oil is used both for lighting and heating at the one time. Tea is scarce and very dear. When one realises that £1 unemployment assistance and 4/- home assistance have to maintain a man and his wife and four children, with the cost of necessaries increasing every day, and that the children of these people, as one Deputy said, are cold, hungry and half clothed, one can see how bad the position is.

I heard one Deputy suggesting that some outside body should be called in to advise the Government. I know that the Minister who is at present on the front bench has a keen interest in the welfare of the Dublin working classes and he knows what the Dublin tenements are. Last Sunday week 1,700 of the finest volunteer workers in any country assembled in the Mansion House at a meeting of the St. Vincent de Paul Society, under the patronage of His Grace the Archbishop of Dublin. Any one of these workers could tell the Minister about the hardships and patience of our people. I heard a clergyman recently in a reference to saints saying: "You will find saints in every cottage and in every tenement room in the City of Dublin. The wives of the unemployed who are depriving themselves of the necessaries of life in order to see that their children do not go altogether hungry, are saints that should receive every praise." I think every Deputy will agree that the wives of the unemployed are suffering very great hardships so that their children will not go hungry. I would not like the Minister to think that this is an attack on the Government. It is not intended to be an attack on the Government. We sympathise with their efforts to do the right thing for the country, and we want to give them our help, if we are allowed to do so.

I received a complaint to-day regarding the petrol supplies for the ferry boats carrying workers at the North Wall. These boats are overloaded, because there is not sufficient petrol for them to go across the river as often as is necessary. When I made inquiries about getting extra petrol for these ferry boats, I found that not an extra gallon of petrol could be got for them. I have visited the North Wall very often during the last few weeks, and I want to assure the Minister that the conditions there, so far as the workers are concerned, are appalling. Dockers who are in the habit of earning reasonably good wages are now unemployed. There are no goods coming in, and none going out. These men have to exist on the miserable sum of 24/- per week which they receive in unemployment assistance.

One Minister said yesterday that we now have 20,000 more people to provide for as a result of people returning home from across the water. Three or four of these people came to me to-day to see if I could get them passports to go back to England. The Minister went on to say that he could not understand what was happening with regard to the labour exchanges, as there were 13,000 fewer people registered. I wonder has anybody tried to study these figures—20,000 more to provide for, and 13,000 fewer registered. The 13,000 are men who have no stamps on their cards, or men who went across the water for a few years and have only English stamps on their cards. There is no reciprocal arrangement for dealing with these people. They are signing on for employment, but they are not registered to draw either unemployment assistance or unemployment insurance benefit. These people are now depending on relatives or friends in the city to provide them with the wherewithal to keep them going.

Last week I raised the question of the price of flake meal, and pointed out that, since the Minister appealed to the public to use meal as a substitute for other foodstuffs, the price of flake meal to the small shopkeepers had gone up by 1/- per stone. The small shopkeepers complained to me, and to other members of the House, that there was no earthly reason why the millers should have put up the price of flake meal by 1/- a stone. It is used a good deal in our working-class quarters. Some farmer Deputies assured me yesterday that there was no reason for the increase, and that the producers were not getting any part of it. Potatoes were selling to-day at 1/4 a stone. I have been asked to press on the Minister the urgency for a greater drive to grow more potatoes, so that, should there be a shortage of wheat, they will be available for the people. We have been told that there will be a shortage of wheat in the month of June or July. The Government, in their campaign to grow more food, should, I suggest, encourage our farmers and others to go in more extensively for the growing of potatoes. I had a letter to-day from a small shopkeeper who uses a donkey and car to sell coal in small lots at 5½d. a stone. He says that when he went to the yard for a supply, he was not allowed to go to the coal bank, but was told to go to the slack bank. Slack at the price quoted would be of very little use to poor people who are only able to buy firing in small quantities. I would press this point on the Minister, that I think we are expecting too much from the poor people.

One hesitates to draw attention to outside matters that the Government have not direct control of. The Corporation of Dublin are most anxious to carry on their housing schemes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter that would more properly arise on the Estimates, on the Estimate for the responsible Minister's Department.

Comment on this

Except that the contractors are being threatened with a shortage of petrol which will prevent them from getting material to the sites.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy might allow Deputy Byrne to make his own speech. He is quite capable.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Deputations representing the sand hauliers have waited on Dublin Deputies to point out the difficulty they are finding in getting supplies of petrol to enable them to get sand to the sites for corporation housing schemes. One of these men told me that he had secured a contract in Northern Ireland. He had sufficient petrol to take him to the Border. The Government here would not allow him to cross the Border, and he had to come home. I understand the reason for that was that there is a prohibition against taking lorries across the Border. At any rate, he informs me that as a result of not being able to get to Northern Ireland he will have to let 10 men go to-night. He has two lorries, and if the Government here had allowed him to cross into Northern Ireland he would have been able to keep these 10 men in employment. He was prepared to give a guarantee that if he were required here he would be able to return within 12 hours. The Dublin Corporation are being asked to pay 4¾ per cent. on the money they require for their housing schemes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is again going outside the Vote.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I am prepared to get away from it. I hope the Government have taken note of the very important statement made a few days ago by a very eminent medical man in this city, and that the Minister will have enquiries made, because the statement was of such a nature that it should not be allowed to pass without notice. The statement was to the effect that, in certain areas of this city, new babies were coming into the world, and that their mothers were only half fed. The word "starvation" was used in one newspaper placard. I think the Government should take notice of a statement of that kind. It does not exaggerate the position. It is quite true that the wives of unemployed men are not getting sufficient nourishment. Being on the committee of maternity hospitals in the city, I am aware of the conditions that prevail in certain areas here. I have attended some of the feeding centres that are being run by the St. John Ambulance Brigade, under the direction of Sir John Lumsden. They are doing splendid work for expectant mothers. I hope the Minister will see to it that the conditions referred to by Dr. Collis are inquired into and an improvement brought about. I am sure his statement shocked many who were not aware of existing conditions. When I read it I said: "Unfortunately, it is too true." I hope that, even at this late hour, the Government will realise its responsibility in the matter and take steps to ease the burdens on our poorer people, on the unemployed and those casually employed. They are suffering great hardships at the moment.

Comment on this

There are just a few questions that I desire to deal with on this Vote. Before getting down to particulars, I should like to refer to some statements made to the effect that Parliamentary institutions have been brought into disrepute in this country. I do not subscribe to that belief. In my opinion it is the personnel of Parliamentary institutions that has come into disrepute, and that, I suppose, reflects on all of us. The borderline in that case is very narrow. I respectfully suggest to the Government, who have the custody and control of our Parliamentary institutions, that they should take the necessary steps to defend and protect them.

On the question of supplies, I feel that the Government have failed in their duty. Down the country at the moment there is grave dissatisfaction with the manner in which it has been handled. The Minister for Supplies, speaking recently, said that facts should be faced. I agree with that, but he should give us some facts, so that we may face up to them thoroughly. On March 8th, as reported in the Irish Independent, page 5, he gave us the following statement as a fact, and I should like to have a much clearer interpretation of it:—

"Early in 1940 we made an arrangement at the request of the British Government for the joint chartering of neutral ships for the purpose of eliminating competition and effecting a reduction in freight charges, but the arrangement worked out ultimately so much to our detriment that it was terminated."

Now, Sir, he stated prior to that that no ships were available for the carrying of supplies except neutral ships. Then he told us that jointly with the British Government we were chartering ships, and on this occasion he told the political organisation which he was addressing that that arrangement had been terminated. Surely we are entitled to know who terminated it. That is question No. 1. Secondly, in what way was the arrangement working out to our detriment? Thirdly, assuming, as I think I am entitled to assume, that, as it was working out to our detriment, it was the Government here which terminated the arrangement, we are entitled to know whether the Government has any ships left now, or whether by the terminating of that arrangement they left us without any ship at all to carry anything? If so, did they realise that position before they terminated the arrangement? Before we can discuss this question of supplies in a proper and intelligent manner, it is imperative that we should have the information upon which the Government acted, and some information as to how certain situations arose, because without that information we are groping in the dark.

If the Minister was down the country, as I am every week, he would see the farmers selling off their pigs wholesale for slaughter, the bonhams upon which the pig population will depend being slaughtered as the calves were slaughtered. He would also see the farmers' wives selling the hens. It has been said that the reason they are doing that is because there is a good price for them, but I can assure the Minister that it is because there is no meal, or pollard, or bran, or anything of that type to feed them. The farmers' wives and the poor people of the country districts feel that by feeding potatoes and oats to poultry and pigs they would be running the risk of leaving their families short of food. They feel that it is not reasonable to give to animals the food that human beings may require in the hungry months of June and July. That creates a new situation. Take the small shopkeepers, and the large ones, too, who go in for mixed trade. I know merchants who at this time of the year handled from 50 to 60 cases of eggs per week, and that really meant their financial turnover for the week. There might be a few odd shillings from old age pensioners, or some small payments from agricultural workers, but the big turnover for those shopkeepers was from the eggs brought in by the farmers' wives and labourers' wives. I am speaking now of the small shopkeepers in the County Longford. At the present time, they are getting only 15 or 16 cases of eggs, as against 50 or 60. That immediately reduces their turnover. It means that their credit is restricted, and it means that the people employed in those businesses, shop assistants and so on, are now under notice. That, in itself, is bad enough, but in other parts of the district, where important poultry farms have been established, they depended a good deal upon maize, barley and things like that, which could have been got last year and up to the beginning of February. They cannot get any at the present time, and those poultry farms are now being dispersed. Several of them had thorough-bred strains of various types, which were prizewinners at shows all over the country, but at the moment because of inability to obtain poultry feeding they are being dispersed and destroyed. The result of that will be that the people engaged there, maids, workmen and others, will become unemployed.

Added to that, there is the dislocation of the petrol trade and the motor trade. The situation is being worsened every day, and unemployment is facing people who were in well-secured employment until a short time ago. That creates an unsettlement of mind, and there is nothing at all to show that the Government or this Parliament did anything about it, except to warn the people that things might be serious. They are not satisfied with the information given to them as to how that position came about. Unless the Government of this country have faith in the people, and take them into their confidence, there is no doubt at all that parliamentary institutions will be running a grave risk, and not only parliamentary institutions but the safety of the State. I think there is no person in the House who will not agree that I have done my best in every way to defend the interests of this State against all comers, and I say that the Government, through the flippant answers of Ministers in this House, has created a situation which will be very hard to overcome, but which could be overcome if they would only tackle the matter in a proper spirit.

In the case of hackney drivers there have been complaints that there is favouritism. I do not know whether or not there is any truth in that. I did make inquiries at the Department of Supplies, and I admit that I found that some of the complaints made were not well founded; they had neglected to fill some particular form, or had not done something else that they should have done. But that is very hard to explain to John or James or Billy or Tom, whose livelihood is depending upon the use of a hackney car. When one of those men sees a well-off firm able to get a substantial amount of petrol and supplementary supplies, while he gets merely his basic allowance, he cannot see why he is not better treated. I admit, of course, that there are certain difficulties, but I think the Minister should leave no stone unturned in order to see that people whose livelihood depends upon getting a fair share of petrol will get it without delay. He should also see to it that there is not even a hint of political favouritism or favouritism of any type.

I am not going to say much about the Estimates. It is undoubtedly a huge bill, and if the Minister would apply the figures that the Taoiseach used to use some time ago—66 to 1—he will observe the colossal load that is being put upon the shoulders of the Irish people. I hope that the Government and the Minister for Defence will be fully satisfied with the return they get for the money. I trust they will make sure that transport will be very carefully handled and that it is used only where it is absolutely essential. If you have a lorry containing one or two soldiers running up and down the street of a town, and a hackney driver without a drop of petrol to run his car is looking on, it is liable to make him say: "What the devil are they doing with that? Why could I not get a gallon or two, which would enable me to bring a little food home to my wife and family?" Every care should be taken of the petrol used by the Army, the Guards, Ministers of State, and everybody in State positions who are entitled to use State transport. More care should be exercised in the use of State transport than in the case of a private individual. At the moment there is a responsibility upon every one of us to set a good example. If we ask the people to undergo hardships, we should at least make an effort to carry some ourselves.

I will have an opportunity at a later stage of dealing with the various Estimates. I want just now to impress upon the Government the absolute necessity of making sure that this money will be expended in a useful way and that they will get value for every penny of it. Perhaps I will be permitted to say a few words to civil servants. If they expect the farmers——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must address his request to the Minister responsible.

Comment on this

This is concerned with supplies. If the civil servants expect the farmers to work night and day to produce the food supplies necessary for this State, it is essential that they should be in their offices pretty early in the morning, and remain there fairly late in the evening, so that——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The civil servants are responsible through the Ministers.

Comment on this

I know they are.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may give advice through the Ministers who have responsibility to the Dáil.

Comment on this

Then I will put it to the Minister that he should be early in his office; he should be there a bit earlier and remain somewhat later than he usually does, so that he may show the farmers, who are expected to work early and late, that he is doing his share to assist them at a time when they are asked to do everything necessary to produce essential food supplies for the nation.

Comment on this

I think, as well as I remember, that it was on a Saturday we met here when the war began, and I think we sat the whole night. Most of us left this House the next morning with very definite impressions of what was going to take place. Those impressions were brought back to me to-day when I was listening to Deputy Byrne, and other Deputies, reciting the woes and miseries that are now upon us, the same woes and miseries that we thought at that particular date were about to come upon us. Fortunately they did not begin to make themselves felt until lately, but I do not think there was one of us leaving this House that morning who did not feel that within the following two or three days these misfortunes would arise. I am not going to say that it was entirely through the wisdom of the Government that they did not arrive until now, but I am certainly entitled to say that the Government had a good deal to do with staving off many of these miseries.

Many people hold that this unfortunate conflagration, this unfortunate catastrophe that is raging all over the world has not properly begun yet. So far as I can see, we have evidence in this country that a beginning is about to take place, and I believe that we all should do our best to pull this country through whatever misfortunes may come. There was not one of us that morning leaving this city in our cars, but had been calculating the nearest day when the car would be locked up. Most of us had already decided here that we were going to have a petrol war. Anybody who looks up the propaganda papers from foreign countries will see magnificent drawings of petrol wells in Iraq and other countries, and even then it was obvious that petrol would become an extremely important commodity. Being such an important commodity, ordinary individuals in this country naturally came to the conclusion that they were not going to have their full share of it. As the struggle became more intensified, the demand for petrol became more acute, and the average man here realised he was going to get less.

I do not think any good case has been made why the Minister or the Government should be blamed because there is a shortage of petrol. I wonder what the position of neutral countries—I do not know how many there are, but I do not suppose there is a great number in Europe—is. I wonder what is the position of these countries who are engaged in the war. Have they not got to make sacrifices, and have they not to face a good deal of confusion and difficulties? I appreciated very much what Deputy MacEoin said. He spoke about fowl, and said that many of the farmers' wives were selling their hens. Oats increased very much in price, and to-day it makes possibly 28/- or 29/- a barrel. That might be some answer to Deputy Byrne's complaint about the increased price of flake meal. Oats has definitely gone up in price. The farmers are glad of that increase, to which they are entitled, but someone has to pay for it.

Comment on this

They are not getting it.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The farmers did not get it.

Comment on this

They are getting 28/- or 29/- a barrel.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Not when they had a crop to sell. Very few farmers could hold it until now.

Comment on this

That is more of the nonsense and foolishness which is deliberately put forward here by people who know the truth. Deputy Morrissey knows it as well as I do.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I do, and I am stating the truth.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Reilly is stating his view at the moment.

Comment on this

Some Deputies opposite said that we should face facts, and these are some of the facts. The result of this increase in the price of oats is that people could scarcely, in reason, be expected to feed oats. which now makes 25/- or 26/- a barrel, to fowl, and get 1/3 a dozen for their eggs. There is another thing about it. There are many people who run poultry farms in a modern way, who, at this time of the year, sell off their two-year-old hens, because the price happens to be good and it is time to get them out of the way for the new brood. The real point is that the price of oats has gone up. The seed time for potatoes is coming in, and they do not want to waste their potatoes on feeding fowl when eggs are only 1/3 a dozen. I agree that it is unfortunate that people in the cities should be hungry, and that people who produce farm produce should feel at times that it is not worth producing because the price is too low. There are people here who have not got the means of buying. Some would have the means if the price was normal, but the great difficulty is how to fix that price and make up the difference which the cost of transport involves.

Comment on this

Where would you get eggs for 1/3 a dozen?

Comment on this

All over the country to-day.

Comment on this

The Deputy should bring in a load of them to-morrow.

Comment on this

They are 1/3 all over the country.

Comment on this

They are not.

Comment on this

Perhaps the hens are not laying in County Wexford.

Comment on this

They are, but more than that is being charged for them.

Comment on this

How much are they?

Comment on this

2/4 a dozen.

Comment on this

It would be worth sending them down to Wexford. We had a long speech from Deputy O'Higgins in which he told us of the change of opinion in the country, which, he said, was mainly brought about because Ministers had begun to ostracise themselves and were not in touch with the community. So far as the general opinion of the country is concerned, the bulk of the people are extremely grateful that they had a Government with such foresight and such wisdom which has, up to this, kept them from being directly interfered with by the war. I do not think anybody will refute that statement. They are also extremely thankful that preparations were made in time here to enable farmers to produce the necessaries of life and that we had the machinery here to handle them. Most countries may be reduced to a point at which, if they had enough to eat, they would be satisfied, and, so far as the Government are concerned, they did their best—in face of strong opposition —to ensure that if war did come and, whether it came or not, we would be as self-contained as possible. Every effort was made to propagate the growing of wheat, while every effort was made by many people to stop it, to condemn it, to ridicule it and to prove to those who attempted to grow wheat, to learn something about it and to bring back the wheat-growing tradition, that they were merely foolish, and were mostly politicians. I am glad to be able to say that every necessary step to make this country independent was taken by this Government.

We have heard about petrol. That turned out simply to be a political snag —they thought they were going to make much political capital out of petrol and its uses, but they did not. I know that the petrol situation created a great deal of inconvenience. I have not seen any myself since last January, and lately I have begun to come to the conclusion that I am not terribly sorry. We have other ways of getting on, and if we really intend to get about, we can do so, because I do not believe for one moment that the situation will be solved if we talk here for two weeks or two months. I do not think we are going to get that petrol as long as this war continues, because it is one of the bases upon which what is happening in the world is taking place. Whichever side runs short of that commodity, that side is going down, and, therefore, the powers that be in these countries are going to conserve all their supplies of petrol. That must be known to everybody. I could argue like other Deputies that there is difficulty in the distribution of that petrol.

If the Minister for Agriculture tomorrow—and he may do so—were to issue licences for the slaughter of cattle, he would be faced with difficulties. When any of these commodities become scarce and have to be licensed, all these difficulties arise, but they can be solved to a large extent, or minimised in their effects. There will be people with grievances, no matter how you do it, but those grievances can be lessened if those in authority consider cases put up to them and decide on rectification.

I do not see anything whatever in the complaints made by Deputy O'Higgins. So far as the Government are concerned, the definite opinion of the bulk of the people is as I have stated it. They know that up to the present they have been kept secure; they know that every effort was made to see that they would be secure in the matter of food, and that that food would come from a source as nearly certain as possible, that is, the land of the country. I do not know what more a Government can do. I agree with Deputy Murphy that the country now is ripe and suitable for many "isms", and I think it the duty of every Deputy to see that these "isms" are not allowed to develop. We live in times of hardship, and there is no use denying it. Everyone of us is involved, and it is up to us all to do what we can to lessen the difficulties of the situation. Petty criticism sometimes irritates but I am sure Ministers have the good sense not to be unduly irritated by it, because the bulk of these criticisms are not sincere and are not meant in a sincere way. It is a good thing to have opposition and to have criticism so long as it does not encourage people to try to get what cannot be got. So long as that is not done, there is not any great harm in criticism. I said before that parliamentary institutions only live by being used. Motor cars deteriorate when not used and parliamentary institutions will also deteriorate if not used. One of the best ways to use them is by advancing honest, sincere criticism.

Comment on this

Do you realise their possibilities?

Comment on this

As long as criticism does not aim at pulling the whole thing down just because one section cannot succeed, it is all right. So long as people do not say: "Since we cannot succeed, we will pull the whole thing down," criticism may be useful. Hardly a speech is made here, whether long or short, in which there are not a few ideas that are worth examining. One sometimes reads a whole book without learning anything from it, but you will find in most books a few things which are worth remembering. That is how democratic institutions should be carried out. It is a great consolation to us that we can meet here. It is a good thing that we are not thinking of the shortest way out through the place at the back. I hope we shall never be thinking of that, and I hope that the biggest problem we shall have to solve will be the feeding of the hungry.

Comment on this

Do you suggest that we have done all we could do in that respect?

Comment on this

We have not. I think that further steps could be taken to improve the situation, but my remedy may not be the same as yours. The remedies might not be akin. None of us is going to deny that there is misery and hardship and hunger in the country and that we should try to eliminate it.

Comment on this

It can be done if you make a good attempt.

Comment on this

That is a horse of another colour.

Comment on this

You are going to feed them by stopping unemployment assistance in rural areas.

Comment on this

That is one of the problems which possibly can be surmounted, and which we hope to see partially surmounted. I am not going to say that we shall succeed 100 per cent. No matter how we manage, there will be people who will get into misery and misfortune, but we should aim at securing that there will be no starvation. It is probable that we shall have sufficient food here. The season is not generally very promising but, at the same time, I believe that we shall have sufficient food. So long as there is a sufficiency of potatoes, even though wheat be not as plentiful as we would wish, I think we are safe so far as the alleviation of hunger is concerned. It will be then only a matter of arrangement regarding its distribution. Transport is short. The railway is the only method of transport for these commodities to the city. We want to see just how that is done and what it costs. I think that transport is one of the greatest difficulties we have, and that it is one of the stumbling blocks to feeding the poor who are hungry. There are plenty of potatoes in the country and no great demand for them.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

What?

Comment on this

They are not as dear as we are told they are and, if the question of transport were solved, a great part of that difficulty would disappear. The whole Dáil should come together and sincerely try to solve this problem. It is only on the internal supplies we can count. There is no use in trying to solve questions which may arise regarding supplies from other countries.

Comment on this

The speech of Deputy O'Reilly epitomises the real danger of the situation. He speaks with so much complacency that he gives the impression that everything is lovely in the garden and that the danger has not yet arrived. He gives us the impression that something may happen later, but that nothing has happened yet. He is to be congratulated on his happy immunity from any of the hardships which are weighing upon the people at this juncture. He has not felt the draught in any shape or form from the economic crisis up to now.

Things may happen in the near future but he is perfectly happy that all the necessary plans have been made and are ready for operation when these evils arise. He complains that allegations were made from this side of the House that Ministers are not sufficiently in touch with the people. I can readily believe that Ministers cannot be in touch with the people or with the situation generally if they accept from back benchers information of the type which has been given by Deputy O'Reilly. He, a prominent member of the Government Party, tells us that there is nothing wrong, that hens are not being killed off for lack of food as alleged by Deputy MacEoin. I can substantiate the statement of Deputy MacEoin from the evidence of poultry keepers in the County Limerick. They are killing their fowl because of lack of food and not because of the price they are able to obtain. Deputy O'Reilly is quite happy and content since eggs are only 1/3 a dozen, as he tells us. I think we should all take an excursion up to Meath. There, we can have eggs for breakfast and go into training. But in the City of Dublin, eggs will cost 3½d. each. I cannot get them in my city and it is not such a bad place for eggs. The price there is 2/4 and if Deputy O'Reilly can get them at 1/3 he will make a fortune. Deputy Corish tells me that the same position obtains in Wexford. This is indicative of the mentality of the back bench members of Fianna Fáil. We are to sit down and allow Ministers a clear road. Everything they do is perfectly correct and Deputy O'Reilly tells us we should not offer criticism because our criticism is not sincere. The Government is to be accorded a monopoly of business capacity, planning ability and even citizenship. We are not to advance criticism because our criticism is automatically and ipso facto insincere. We are all trying to score political points off the Government and we have no interest whatever in the affairs of the country. That is the conception of Deputy O'Reilly, and, indeed, of the front bench, too, according to the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce yesterday and, to a certain extent, the speech of the Minister for Supplies. That is indicative of the outlook of the Government. They are intolerant of any criticism or interference by anybody else. They monopolise citizenship, the patriotic virtues and administrative capacity. Anybody who makes a suggestion is immediately turned down. He is merely trying to score political points off the Government and his suggestion is not intended for the improvement of the country. We claim to have as much interest in the affairs of the country as the Government and the back benchers of Fianna Fáil have. We definitely refuse to allow the Government to run the country on the rocks. The country does not belong to the Government and we have a right to call attention to what is happening as a result of lack of planning.

I do not propose to deal with the petrol position. Last night, the discussion was definitely diverted into that channel by the Minister for Supplies and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who held that we must not go back behind the period of immediate emergency. Their arguments had to do with the difficulty of providing supplies during the emergency. I suggest that the drift on the part of the Government set in long before the war commenced. If the Back Benches or the Front Benches of Fianna Fáil were in touch with the country, they would know that our list of 120,000 idle men did not open with the start of the war. We have been carrying that as a legacy since Fianna Fáil came into office. The figure may have fluctuated, but the position before the war was that charitable institutions were doing what should be the Government's job. To-day, the St. Vincent de Paul Society is working overtime to provide such sustenance as will keep people from actual starvation. That is not a function of any charitable institution whatsoever. They are perfectly entitled to act as adjuncts to any national provision, but it is not the function, surely, of any charitable institution. Any Government ought to be ashamed to have to admit it, and I challenge a denial; and if it were not for the activities of the St. Vincent de Paul Society and kindred societies, you would have definite death from starvation in the country to-day. They are making provision now, in thousands of cases, for the sustenance of our citizens.

Arising from the absence of petrol, let us see what was done by the Government to plan an alternative. It was known that petrol would be short. I am not going to say whether it came suddenly or dramatically, but it did come about that petrol became short, and the situation was difficult to cure. One would think, as we looked up alternative means—producer gas, and so on—to drive motor vehicles, that there would have been some thought of the alternative in the way of horse-drawn vehicles. A lot of people thought that those respectable tradesmen, the saddlers, the harness-makers and coach-builders, would have got an opportunity in the building of traps and cars, and the provision of harness for horse-drawn vehicles. But the saddlers and harness-makers, all the craftsmen of Dublin, Limerick, Cork, and other cities, were at the labour exchanges for years past, and their skill had been definitely wasted by the abuse of that institution. They were sent out to concrete streets, and quarry in quarries, while their skill was allowed to become dissipated. Now, they were looking forward to getting some of their own work, but instead of that being restored to them, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in his wisdom, immediately struck off the duty against outside bodies, saddlery and harness, and allowed lots of second-hand stuff to come in, in the way of old hearses, carriages, and all kinds of chassis. These were brought in here. The Minister hurls back in the teeth of these men the expectation and hope that they had.

Comment on this

I saw an advertisement in a Dublin paper this morning for 20 harness-makers, who are wanted immediately.

Comment on this

I will tell the Minister something about that. I have a letter from a prominent harness maker in my own city who said: "Now in the name of commonsense, will you please ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce what is his idea in suspending the tariff on saddlery and harness and leaving the duty on leather. Is it his idea to wipe out the harness makers altogether by this method and prevent them from making harness and saddlery at home?" If they wish to make it, there is a tariff on the leather, and they have to get a licence, but the finished article can come in without any tariff whatsoever. The Minister may shake his head, but that is true.

Comment on this

He does not have to pay a tariff. Surely we can manufacture harness leather in this country?

Comment on this

I am suggesting that, as a result of the Emergency Order that has been made—and I do not wish to have any equivocation about it—the finished article can come in from Britain, but any person who wishes to import certain kinds of leather must pay a duty on the leather. Is that encouraging? I know this particular gentleman I am dealing with here was called up by a nobleman of this country with a big title, to meet him in the city, to place an order for six sets of farm harness from England. He said that he did not order them from England, as he could make them himself. The nobleman then said that he need not mind doing that as he could import them himself free. That is the contribution that has been made by the Government. The Minister does not seem to be fully aware of it, but he can check it up and I am sure he will find that it is perfectly correct.

He can see the protest made by the Secretary of the Bootmakers' Association in this city quite recently at a couple of meetings, when they were voicing their indignation and amazement at the complete lack of assistance from the Government, when they thought that they were going to get a chance, through the shortage of petrol, to get a bit of work. The Minister for Industry and Commerce again told us last night that the building trade was not less busy than last year, but something better because of the fact that there were less signatures at the "College of Signs"—the labour exchange—this year than last year. As long as we are being treated to that kind of thing in this country, it means treating the hunger and misery of the poor with levity. We had the Minister for Industry and Commerce last night juggling with figures in regard to building.

Comment on this

More houses were built in 1940 than in 1939.

Comment on this

He argued last night that there was a bigger influx of people, as the balance was one of 13,000. He completely ignored the fact that these people were evacuees—mainly women and children—and were not signing on at the labour exchanges. They would not be entitled to register there, and I am suggesting that they would not be allowed there, as most of them were children. But the people who went out were the heads of families and active bread-winners in one shape or form.

When the Minister tells us that there is an improvement in the building position, does he wish to suggest that we should go round with black glasses and ask where the building is going on in Ireland to-day that in any sense compares with the activities of last year or the year before? It is said that they cannot get sand or gravel to bring in for the houses, and there is a standstill except in the case of municipal authorities, but the responsible Minister told us in the House last night that the position in the building trade leaves nothing to be worried about, that it is better than last year. Deputy O'Reilly said that is so, and if we can keep lulling ourselves all the time into that sense of false security that there is nothing wrong, I think we will have a rude awakening.

We who live down the country feel that it is our duty to focus the attention of the Government upon it We believe we are entitled to do that, and we will persist in doing it, whatever reception we may get. At any rate, I am amazed at the objection shown by the Government to accepting any advice or suggestion, regarding an economic council or otherwise. We are told that the only man to plan in his own Department is the Minister and his staff, and we know that the policy of one Minister may cut across the policy of another. That definitely has taken place in some instances. There seems to be no plan or policy in the Government as a whole. Again, I want to accuse the Department controlling the labour exchanges, the Department of Industry and Commerce, as being one of the most wasteful in this country— wasting human labour and skill. They are no longer entitled to be called employment exchanges, as they have long since ceased to function in that capacity. They exist at the moment only for the paying out of unemployment assistance and unemployment insurance and, in the main, they are trying to deprive recipients of as much as possible. Then there were the period orders, which I will deal with later.

During the period that the men were signing on at the labour exchanges there was a national waste, through the lack of segregation of the different classes of people. We have linotype operators, electricians, highly technical engineers, printers of all types and kinds—all herded together in one common herd. They are definitely classified on the register by their particular calling, but the exchange refuses to give any recognition of that thing whatsoever and, as I have said, they are sent out on jobs for which they are unsuited. Some of these men would sooner take these jobs than lose their benefit and starve, and so they do work for which they are entirely unfitted. Then, as a result of doing that heavy work, in many cases they are unfitted for their own type of work. A skilled man who has had to do work of that nature, handling picks, shovels and crowbars, becomes unfitted for his own particular work. For instance, I know of the case of a linotype operator, a £6-a-week man, who was sent out making concrete, and if he were to be called back to his own work in a day or two he would not be able to do it.

I know of some cases where tailors were sent out to do work in quarries, men who had never handled a pick or shovel before. Their hands were stripped to the bone as a result of that work, but the unfortunate men were prepared to do it rather than leave the exchange and lose benefit, because they had wives and families.

I say that the Labour Exchange has other functions than that of cutting men off the dole, investigating spurious or alleged spurious claims, opening up letters, and so on. Surely, if they are not able to supply work, they should have some function which would enable them to segregate these people into different classes.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy's suggestion? I should be glad to get it.

Comment on this

Well, first of all, that the skilled men ought to be classified as such, and not sent down to work on these relief schemes, in quarries, and in streets in the city and on concrete work, or digging trenches and dykes, because that class of work unfits them for their own type of work if they are called back to do it. I have known of cases of men who were called back to their own types of jobs and they were unfit for them as a result of the work they had been doing. At the same time, I have known of cases of plenty of men of the labouring type, who were anxious and fitted to do that work, but because they were on a lesser scale, under this scheme, they would not be sent out. One man had 20/- and the other had 19/-, and it was determined according to the amount and number in family.

Comment on this

Am I right in saying that that would not arise except in the case of people who had been out of employment for a considerable period? A skilled tradesman, for instance, would have been drawing unemployment insurance benefit for a certain period, and it would be only when he comes on to the unemployment assistance scheme that he would be liable to be sent out on such work?

Comment on this

Yes, under the unemployment assistance scheme.

Comment on this

That would be only after a certain period?

Comment on this

Yes, six months.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Provided he had the required number of stamps.

Comment on this

Mostly it would be six months, and then they have to go by what their calling is, and that is regulated by the amount of the stipend.

Comment on this