We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1941-42.

Contributions 163–330 of 330. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

At one time one stamp counted for a week's benefit, but now one stamp only counts for one day's benefit.

Comment on this

The original scheme was six stamps, and that was inherited by this State.

Comment on this

The original scheme had a certain amount of humanity and citizenship in it as well as patriotism, but all that has been wiped out by the action of the Department, for which the Minister was responsible for a considerable time and for which the present Minister for Industry and Commerce is now responsible. The original intention, in my opinion, has been departed from, so far as the operation of that Act is concerned, because it is more and more being pointed out to the citizens of this country that what they are getting is charity. We contend that that assistance is as much the right of the citizens of this country as any assistance that has been given under any other Act that has been passed here. We contend that the attitude of the Department is to try to defeat the original intention in every shape and form and to give the idea to the citizens of this country that what is being given to them is not what they are legitimately entitled to. I know that there is a motion coming forward in connection with the Employment Period Order, which is worse in its effects, and this perhaps is not the proper time to discuss that matter.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy will allow me to intervene for a moment. Would not a tradesman, who had been unemployed for a long time, feel that he had a grievance if he were denied the opportunity of getting work on relief schemes? Some of them might feel that they did not want to be denied that opportunity.

Comment on this

Yes, if it was a voluntary matter, and if there were any people of that type—and there might be some who might be sufficiently strong and hefty to do such work. I know that some of them would be prepared to volunteer for such work, but there is no question of volunteering in the matter. They will be struck off from benefit if they do not go down to the job to which they are sent. That is the difficulty. The Parliamentary Secretary, when this or a similar matter was being discussed on a previous occasion, spoke of these things being only in the interests of the community. Now, this Vote on Account is to make provision for moneys that are necessary, and I have no objection whatever to voting whatever money the Government thinks is necessary for the successful running of this country if I can be satisfied that these moneys are being utilised in the best interests of the citizens.

When, however, we see, on the one hand, a huge sum of money being voted, presumably for the carrying on of services in the interests of the community, and when, on the other hand, we see such destitution, misery and poverty, with no sign of any improvement, but with definite signs of an increase in destitution and misery in the weeks and months to come, we feel that we must protest, and, in my opinion, much of that destitution and misery has been caused by the Government themselves. The money is supposed to be for the purpose of preventing destitution and to maintain the citizens in the best social standards possible, but I am accusing the Government of not acting in the best interests of the citizens.

When they are dealing with unemployed persons and sending them about their business, telling them that there is plenty of work for them and that they should go and do it, without indicating where that work is to be had, the Government are definitely producing these conditions of want and misery. I have seen letters from men with families of five, six, eight and even ten in numbers, who have not a shilling left and do not know where to look for it. Somebody here spoke about sending these people to the local authorities, and said that they do not like to go to the public authorities. Whether they like it or not, the public authorities are not able to bear the extra strain. The public authorities plan for old and invalid men and women, and it is the Government's business to deal with able-bodied persons who are fit to work. It is a terrible responsibility for the Government, at a time when they are calling for co-operation amongst all sections, to be striking off thousands of men for a certain period of the year from benefit and callously telling them to go about their business and find work that is not there.

I know of some of these chaps who went into the various Forces, such as the Local Security Force and the Local Defence Force, from the very beginning, and who have been drilling and parading around the country, making themselves fit for their duty, and these men are constantly asking: "Are we to continue in the Local Defence Force when we have not a meal or a crust of bread in the house at home? What are we going to defend?" I could read these letters for you, and I also have dozens of men coming to see me, during the past week even, pointing out the position. I say that the Government should calmly and patiently examine the position, and if you want more money, then ask for it and you will get it, but do not treat this responsible section of the citizens of this country as if they were pariahs and untouchables. These people should not be left on the verge of starvation as they are being left to-day.

Comment on this

It seems difficult to agree with this Vote on Account because of the huge amount of taxation about to be imposed. What seems most peculiar is the huge increase in the Army, I suppose because of the danger of invasion and for the purpose of defence. In the circumstances, we cannot say much about that, but it is extraordinary that there is no provision at all made for the national problems that face us to-day. There is no Minister on the other side of the House, no matter what he said yesterday, who does not know there are more people hungry and more people unemployed now than at any stage of the existence of Government here in this country. There is no Deputy on that side of the House who does not know that we are going to have thousands more unemployed. Even in the pictures they paint themselves, they admit that. While they try to evade straight answers about it, sometimes they really admit it. In this Vote there is not one provision for dealing with the people who are likely to be hungry in the future.

One thing which should concern us as much as our national defence is that peaceful social conditions will continue to exist in this country. If you have thousands of hungry men in every big town in this country, whose wives and families are hungry, you are not likely to have peaceful social conditions, and it would be better, no matter what amount of taxation is involved, to ensure peaceful social conditions. There is no use in condemning robbery or anything else which is bound to come. If I were long kept a hungry man, standing at a corner, seeing my wife and children hungry, I would find food some way. That is what every unemployed man is talking about at the moment. People on that side of the House said there was no grumbling or growling among the people of the country. Never before in this country was there so much grumbling and growling at every street corner. When the people see this Estimate for the Army, perhaps they will not understand why such a large amount should be spent on the Army. They will feel worse when they see nothing is provided for themselves, and they are saying: "I wish Hitler came, or somebody came; we would not be half as badly off as we are to-day." I am sure there is no Deputy in this House who does not know that as well as I do. Not alone is that the case, but Ministers in the Front Bench of the Government have done everything to make their position worse. First we had the butter fiasco. Who was to ration that? Who took control of it? The Minister sent word to the creameries that it was to be rationed. It was rationed to the shopkeepers and the hucksters' shops throughout the country. Let us say, I came in first; I had the price of my butter and I got it. The poor man who had children, who is badly off, perhaps in debt, was left without any butter. He was not even able to get his half pound of butter. Then come on to tea. It was forgotten that we had thousands and thousands of families from one end of this country to the other who are only living from hand to mouth, perhaps getting their tea on credit, especially while they are idle or waiting for relief schemes to start. The Minister told the people to lay in supplies, to buy up all the supplies they could. It was hoarded in the drawing-rooms of the people with money.

Comment on this

I never told people to lay in supplies of tea.

Comment on this

The Minister told the people to lay in supplies of everything, and they certainly laid in supplies of tea. Tea has been scarce throughout the country for months. I do not know how else that scarcity was created. That is really what has happened. The Minister would not tell us the amount of tea that came into the country, but presumably as much came last year as ever came in. The shortage is there, but the tea is in the drawing-rooms, back parlours and stores of those people who could afford to buy it. The position is that tea is not even selling at a fair price, and those being mulcted are the poor.

With regard to agriculture, there has been a tremendous campaign to grow wheat. Unluckily, that campaign came in too late. It was being pushed forward even at the expense of oats and barley. Even before the propaganda campaign was started, people were going around hawking their barley. Even when everybody knew feeding was getting scarce, people who wanted ready cash—the poorer people —were hawking their barley from one place to another and hawking their oats around, asking shopkeepers to buy a few barrels in order to give them an opportunity of getting food and other things.

That, I believe, was done purposely. No effort was made by the Ministry to get the millers to buy up this barley and oats at a reasonable price. People sold oats at from 12/- to 14/- a barrel up to last Christmas, and barley at 17/-, 18/- and 19/- and £1. Later on the Minister told the merchants he would take it from them at 32/-. There was no attempt to make provision a few weeks before that, when the producer would have got the benefit. It appears to me, as it should appear to everybody else, I think, that this was a deliberate thing, done in order to ensure that people who were not growing wheat previously would grow it in future. That was a dangerous side of the campaign, because it is making people put down wheat this year where it will not yield one-fourth the feeding stuffs that would come from oats and barley. They will put it in land where normally they would not dream of putting it, land which is not suitable.

Deputy Hughes raised the matter of manures in this House this evening. It is a serious thing. The best farmers in this country bought the ingredients and they mixed their manures. The position to-day is if you are going to grow beet you can get nothing but the compound manure, and the farmer who bought his own ingredients last year and mixed it has no manure to get. The letters from Goulding and Paul and Vincent to the merchants say that they are sending the same amount of beet manure as they sent last year, and they cannot give any extra this year. Therefore, people who got their own ingredients and mixed them, who have signed contracts to grow beet, cannot get manures except the phosphates they want for wheat. I think that is a matter to be dealt with immediately by the Minister for Agriculture. I know hundreds of people who have increased the acreage of beet which they have contracted to grow this year and who have signed contracts. They are not able to get manure.

Certainly no farmer is going to chance growing a crop with something other than the right manure, or with less of it than he requires. It is up to the Minister to see that Paul and Vincent or Goulding supply a percentage to every farmer, and that those people who got manures last year will not get 100 per cent. this year. Those others who are growing beet are entitled to get some, and there ought to be some distribution. The matter of manure also is left to the shopkeeper to decide. I suppose it has to be, because of the policy the Minister has adopted that it would be too big a job to take over all these things for the purpose of saving the country.

It was left to shopkeepers to decide whether poor people were to get any supplies. They had to go from shop to shop, and often could not get the share that they got in previous years. It is time that there should be a system of rationing of all essential food supplies. If it is necessary the Government might consider taking over everything produced on the farm and dispose of it at regulated prices. A state of emergency has arisen and we are not in any better position than the British. It is up to the Government to take over what is produced, to pay a fair price for it and to see that purchasers get it at a reasonable price. The position now is that there is muddling, that those who are producing food are not getting anything like its value, while the poor have to pay practically three times what would be a fair price for it. No effort has been made to control flour supplies. Up to this farmers, well-to-do tradesmen and labourers bought in as many half-sacks of white flour as they could afford when the scare came. They are holding the white flour and are also purchasing further supplies, some of which may be used for feeding bonhams or hens. Something ought to be done about that or otherwise we may find, as the Minister mentioned, that we will not have sufficient flour to last until July, or that before the harvest there may be no flour available for the poor. I am interested in this question because I am afraid that if things go on as they are going, and if the poor cannot obtain the necessaries of life, that may cause trouble.

Comment on this

The only defence I saw Government spokesmen falling back on for the muddle that has arisen is that they made preparation to provide the necessaries of life for their eight or nine years of office. They overlook the fact that years prior to taking office, there was a feeling abroad that our climate and soil were not suitable for the growing of wheat of good milling quality, and that the growing of sugar beet was an experiment which had never been tried here. The Government have no right to arrogate to themselves credit for producing sugar beet and good milling wheat. The bogey that this country could not grow good milling wheat was exploded in 1925 by the efforts of a voluntary body called the Grain Conference, which held deliberations every fortnight in the offices of the Dublin County Council. The Minister for Supplies smiles. He knows nothing about wheat, except to eat it in bread when it is milled into flour, but those of us who applied ourselves to the practical side of producing supplies of wheat, had first to surmount an obstacle which then amounted to national prejudice, and to demonstrate by experiment that it could be done, and it was done in every county in 1926. Even the Department, which was opposed to the experiment, was surprised with the result, and issued a pamphlet about it for the general information. Beet growing also came as a result of a demand from progressive farmers.

I give full credit to the Government for building on that information, and raising the acreage of wheat between 1932 and 1939 to 200,000 or 250,000 acres. They deserve full credit for that, and also for increasing the number of beet factories, thereby making it possible in times of emergency like these to produce the necessary sugar supplies. Where I find fault with the Government is, that when war broke out in September, 1939, there could be no more favourable month in which to prepare for food production, and particularly wheat production. In addition there was the warning of the Munich Conference of September, 1938. Those of us who lived through the last war, 1914—1918, and who followed the trend of international events up to 1939, knew that the world was in for a terrible conflict, and that such a war would not be one of massed armies, but a war of attrition, in the nature of an economic conflict, greater than any previous war. It was up to our Government to build on the foundations that were laid—foundations for which they deserve great credit. What inducement was offered for an extension of wheat growing? What did the Minister for Industry and Commerce do to provide supplies? Did he not know that all the new industries started under his direction depended on imports of raw materials? Did he provide the raw materials? He did not. Did those engaged in the industries appeal to him to have supplies provided?

Comment on this

In what industry?

Comment on this

I have been informed by responsible people in the industrial world that they approached the Minister and told him that this was going to be a long war, that their industries would go out of production if raw materials were not procured, and that that was the time to lay in stocks. They said to him: "We are comparatively poor people engaged in these industries. All our money is in these industries—not a terrible lot—and as we are not able to finance the importation of supplies for some years ahead, we ask you to put it up to the banks to finance the purchase of raw materials."

Comment on this

And what reply did they get?

Comment on this

I am informed that the reply was "no."

Comment on this

On the contrary, that was done. If the Deputy is raising the matter of difficulties which industries might have in financing the purchase of reserve stocks, my reply is that an arrangement was made with the Irish banks, under which they provided finance in any such cases.

Comment on this

On the eve of the outbreak of war after the matter had been under discussion for 12 months?

Comment on this

On the contrary, the arrangement was made at least nine months before the war started.

Comment on this

Does the Minister say that an arrangement was made for the purchase of timber nine months before the outbreak of war?

Comment on this

Certainly. A company called Timber Importers, Limited, was set up after the war broke out, but the financing of reserve stocks for individual traders was arranged with the Irish banks before the war started.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not aware that the arrangement was made for the banks to finance the purchase of timber only two days before the outbreak of war?

Comment on this

The proof of the pudding is in the eating of it, and in considering this very tall order of a Vote on Account for over £12,000,000, we have to consider how it is going to be raised. I first want to touch upon the abuse of censorship here. About three weeks ago, I attended the annual meeting of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce. A very important business man in this city, a man of no politics, but essentially a business man——

Comment on this

In other words, he is against the Government.

Comment on this

The description does not sound like that.

Comment on this

He is against nobody. He is not against the Government. He is a man I know of for a number of years, and I do not think he cares what Government is in so long as business is booming. Anyway he made the statement that some of our industries are going out of production within three months for want of raw material, that a considerable number would be out of production within six months, and that within eight months there would be practically none of the industries working. He said: "I am quite satisfied that one-third of the population would be out of work within eight months."

Comment on this

That was published.

Comment on this

Does that square with the Minister's statement that supplies were brought in? My information from an ex-president of the Federation of Irish Industries, perhaps one of the most active in the industrial world today—the information is not a week old —is that the supplies which the Minister was requested to harness the banks to purchase were not purchased, and now we find ourselves short of supplies. The war was not three months old when we were short of the most essential of our supplies.

Comment on this

What were they?

Comment on this

Fertilisers.

Comment on this

Three months old?

Comment on this

If the Minister surveyed the position correctly when war broke out in September, 1939, took his eyes from the ends of the earth and said: "we here in this country are going to produce food for this country," it would have been better business to have paid the people of this country to grow wheat rather than to speculate on corn exchanges in New York and Chicago for supplies which are now at the bottom of the Atlantic. No wonder the Minister would not in the public interest give the amount of wheat which was purchased and the price which was paid for it, because the wheat that went to the bottom of the Atlantic cost this country more than they are going to pay the farmers for growing wheat.

Comment on this

Sure. Will the Minister give us the amount purchased, the price at which it was purchased, how much came here and how much went to the bottom?

Comment on this

The Deputy knows the price at which wheat is being sold here.

Comment on this

What wheat?

Comment on this

Imported wheat.

Comment on this

Where is there imported wheat on sale at any price?

Comment on this

There are thousands of tons of it.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

Here in the country.

Comment on this

When did it come in?

Comment on this

Not so long ago.

Comment on this

When it was about 12/- or 15/- a barrel?

Comment on this

Nonsense. Some came in a couple of months ago.

Comment on this

If you had built granaries you could have filled these granaries with wheat at the start of the war. A lot of criticism, and I do not think it is fair criticism, has been levelled against merchants who bought our wheat last harvest at 35/- a barrel or thereabouts. If they made a few shillings on it, at any rate they provided us with seed wheat. If it were not for these merchants, we would not have the area under winter wheat that we have to-day. I defy contradiction in that and I think when they carried the baby, they are entitled to be paid for it. I say that unequivocally and I am perhaps one of the largest wheat-growers in the country. The Minister may laugh.

Comment on this

I was merely saying that it is not everybody is paid for carrying the baby.

Comment on this

We have had to slaughter calves in the past but before the year is out we will have to slaughter cattle and other live stock to provide food. The Government is beginning to learn its lesson. It was good propaganda a few weeks ago to say that a few farmers in this House wanted inflated prices for wheat when they asked for 50/- per barrel. I challenge any Deputy in this House to get up and say now what feeding-stuff is as cheap for live stock as wheat at 50/- a barrel? What feeding-stuff is as cheap for cattle, pigs or fowl as wheat at 50/- a barrel? The Government did not grasp the significance of the situation with which they were called upon to deal. They were confronted with the situation that half the quantity of feeding-stuffs required for our live stock had to be imported. I am quoting the Minister for Agriculture when I say that. We now have to do without that half of our requirements. Then we mill about 600,000 tons of wheat and formerly we took 30 per cent. offal from that. That was 180,000 tons of offal. We are now taking only 60,000 tons of offal from that wheat. I do not think we are taking even as much as that judging by the sort of loaf we have. What was that bran selling at here while it could be got? £15 and £16 per ton. Wheaten meal at £30 a ton is much better feeding. Difficulties are bound to arise at the end of next harvest seeing that 50 per cent. of our feeding-stuffs will be no longer available, and that we shall also have to do without 180,000 tons of bran and pollard if we continue to extract such a heavy percentage from wheat for human consumption. Every inroad we make on oats and barley reduces still more the amount of feeding-stuffs available. Deputy O'Reilly is not in the House now but I can tell him that they are killing poultry all over the country, in Meath as well as in Limerick— that is, in parts of Meath where they work.

It was a revelation to me, as it was a revelation to anybody who had his ears to the ground, to be told yesterday that the building trade was booming. I wonder where and how could it boom when there is a shortage of timber and no provision has been made to meet it? Where was our Ministry of Supplies which had organised and harnessed the banks to back the merchants in order to bring in materials? Is there not a shortage of timber now? Is there not a shortage of window glass in Dublin? Have we not ceased for over a year to make window glass in this country?

Comment on this

We are restarting now.

Comment on this

Why did we stop? Surely it is a joke to say that in the midst of a war we gave up making an essential commodity and that we have now restarted. Why did we stop?

Comment on this

Because the external supplies of materials were not available and we have now succeeded in replacing them with internal supplies.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear it. It seems extraordinary to me that we stopped making it. Had we not been making it?

Comment on this

Yes, from imported materials.

Comment on this

Is it the Minister's case that we are now able to substitute native materials for the materials hitherto imported?

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

And we are getting on with the making of glass?

Comment on this

What was the substitute?

Comment on this

A better article. It comes from Donegal.

Comment on this

I accept the Minister's statement, and I am glad he succeeded. The Minister is aware that there is a terrible shortage of window glass. When the war started, he knew that we had no timber for building in this country, and that a shortage of timber would stop the building trade, even if we had everything else. An explanation is required from him as to why stocks of timber were not laid in. Then, as to the petrol position, why was not a supply of petrol stored? There was a lot of cross talk, and people who knew something about the organising of the oil refinery kept warding off criticism about it. If you want to get stores of petrol here, what is the use of dragging in the oil refinery? Is it not substantially correct to say that it takes four tons of crude oil to manufacture a ton of petrol? In case of an emergency, would it not be the greatest folly to import crude oil, which requires four times the space of petrol, and neglect the importation of petrol? Why was not petrol imported and stored here? Does the Minister suggest that Great Britain is depending from day to day on the importation of petrol? Is it not true that Great Britain has about 12 years' supply of petrol? Will it be contradicted that millions of tons of petrol are stored in the bowels of the earth in Great Britain? Was there not an offer made within the last month to provide 50 per cent. of our requirements of petrol? I say that offer has been made.

Comment on this

An offer made by whom?

Comment on this

I have said that an offer was made. It does not matter by whom it was made. Was it made or was it not?

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

The Minister is trying to do a little bit of the amateur detective, but I got up a little too early for that. I am making the statement that the offer was made. Will the Minister contradict it? I am sure he will not. Why was not petrol stored here in the bowels of the earth? Is it not true that tankers came into the port of Dublin within the last year and were not able to get a place to discharge the whole of their cargo, and went away again with a considerable amount of their cargo? If that is true why did it happen?

The question of unemployment, not so much in its economic aspect, as in its dangerous and potentially revolutionary aspect, has been dealt with here. It is time that we got down to business about running this country, and ran it in the way a successful business man will run his business. What does a business man consider the most vital department in his business? Finance. The Minister for Finance is asking us to pass estimates for public services running into £35,000,000, which will have to be paid for out of the industry and agriculture of this country. But the Minister for Finance was not a bit surprised that he was not consulted when the bank rate was shoved up a couple of points. That could not happen in any other country in the world. The Minister for Industry and Commerce says he got the banks to give guarantees so that raw materials could be bought. These banks are part of a larger banking system in another country, and are not in touch with the Government of this country. If the rising tide of unemployment threatens the stability and peace of this State, then the fault will lie with the Government, which did not take control of the financial and banking system of this country.

We are told late in the day that this country must fall back on its own resources. What have we done in the months that have passed to make this country self-supporting?

I do not think the food position looks as well now as it did this time last year. Despite the campaign that is being carried on for the growing of more food, I doubt if there is as much wheat sown now as there was this day last year. Inquiries have so far failed to enable us to get information on that. We are proposing to spend £8,500,000 on the Army. What good is an Army in modern times without petrol, and at any time without food? I suppose it is as true to-day as it was in Napoleon's time, that an army marches on its stomach. If we are not making provision for the Army's stomach, is it not a pure waste of money to spend this £8,500,000?

Why are we short of seed wheat and of seed spring wheat? We took over the Department of Agriculture from the British, and 12 or 15 years ago established a faculty of agriculture, but we seem to have failed to make any provision for the propagation and raising of seeds. We should be told why we are so short of seeds now. Presumably, we intend to remain neutral in this war, and yet we depend on a foreign country for the seeds that we require for food production. Onion, carrot, parsnip and, to some extent, cabbage seeds were imported this year, but not from countries where we had been accustomed to get them. We did not get the strains of seed that we were familiar with. We are now faced with the alternative of American seed or no seed. We do not know how it will do here. I cannot understand any Government spending millions of pounds on an Army while the food basket is empty, and there appears to be no chance of filling it. We are not making any attempt to provide food for man and beast.

During the last eight or nine years, on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture, I developed my speech on that Estimate each year on the lines of producing seeds. Sometimes I advocated the breeding of new strains because it is by that means that other countries have excelled in particular branches of tillage. It was that method that enabled California to become the finest producing country in the world. It may be news to Ministers to hear that when wheat was first grown in California and Canada it was a failure, but that position was corrected when the right strain of seed was bred in subsequent years.

As regards fertilisers, we do not know what we are getting. The farmer who tills a certain amount of his land, who can more or less depend on the choice part of his farm always responding, and who has plenty of farm-yard manure to throw into the small crop that he cultivated, can take a chance, but not so the man who tills on a large scale. He must handle artificial manures intelligently. That class of farmer never bought compound manure, because it is not meant to grow crops so much as to make profits for the people who mix it. The farmer depending on artificial manures to grow crops must first ascertain what the crop requires, what his land is deficient in, and make his mixture accordingly. If he does so intelligently he will make different mixtures for different seeds. This year we are to get a percentage of what we got last year, perhaps 75 or 50 per cent. We do not know what we are getting and might as well burn a few old trees and mix the potash through them. That is the position.

If the statement made by the Dublin business man in the Chamber of Commerce, to which I have already referred, is substantially correct, and my own survey of the industrial field agrees substantially with it, then I think the difficulties confronting agriculture here, supposing we are thrown back entirely on our own resources, are, unless I am mistaken, very gloomy indeed for the future. Deputy Byrne may shed tears because flake meal is selling at the price he mentioned, but he may have to shed more bitter tears if, in the future, he has no flake meal to get, and I think that is the position we are facing. It will not be a question of price or of suitability, but rather one of having food to keep body and soul together. While giving the Government all credit for developing a tillage policy and for having the country well prepared for a good spring in 1939, and particularly in 1940, to enable us to produce all the food necessary for man and beast, it must be said that they failed at the last jump. There is not much use now in appealing to the Government to do work that can only be done in its own season. It was in last September or October that the field should have been surveyed for producing adequate supplies of food to meet the requirements of the country, but there was not a word said about it at that time. We had, of course, broadcasts and after-dinner speeches when it was too late to make good the neglect of the Government. We had these when the weather was so bad that you could not enter on the land. Now, we have not enough wheat.

It is not fair to keep us in the dark as to how much wheat has been sown. I have made inquiries, and from what I know it would be painting a rosy picture of the situation to say that we have more wheat sown than we had at this time last year. We want nearly twice as much, and if we have not got it we will lose half of our feeding stuffs for our livestock. If we have to encroach upon oats and barley, even to the extent of 120,000 or 180,000 tons of bran and pollard, in order to supplement our bread supply, it will leave us very little, if any, for feeding our livestock. If we have not livestock to sell, how will we buy our tea? How will we buy our petrol? How will we buy all those things which we cannot produce here, and which are essential to our economic life? Questions about the wheat position have been asked here in this House by responsible Deputies, but it is not in the public interest to give the information sought. If it is not in the public interest to give it, then the position must be very bad. Wheat is bought in foreign countries, paid for before it is shipped, and it goes to the bottom; we will not be told how much was bought, or at what price, but we are told that £2 per barrel for doubling our acreage under wheat is a paying price. The Government is playing with a question of life and death by concealing necessary information. All Irish writers from the famine period down refer to the famine of the forties as a British-made famine. If we are up against famine now, I wonder whether subsequent Irish writers will declare that it is an Irishmade famine? I am afraid that those responsible for supplies, and responsible for maximum production here will be gravely responsible for the stringency which I hope will not reach the famine stage.

When supplies run out, what is going to be done with the workers who will be thrown out of work? I was speaking to an industrialist during the week, who said that their normal output of a certain commodity was 40,000 units. They are now producing 25,000 units. They are keeping on their staff, just in order not to throw them on the labour market, "but," he said, "we cannot continue for very long, because our production will become less; we will be eating into our capital, and we cannot do that unless we want to court bankruptcy." That is the position in practically every trade. The building trade is even worse than that, in spite of anything which the registers may be said to show. I will take the Minister around the City of Dublin and that is the register that will speak plainly; he will see the roads which have been made, the houses which have been partly built, and no work going on. Why? Because conditions are not favourable to building, either through lack of materials or otherwise. Building is not going on, and it is an insult to this House when a responsible Minister comes in and says in effect that there is a boom in the building trade. In what industry has there been increased employment? The Minister for Industry and Commerce juggled with figures in regard to the people who have come back from England. I think that was dealt with fairly well by Deputy Alderman Byrne, when he said that the people who came back did not register, while the people who went over did register.

On the whole, the people who came back here were people whose nerves had been shattered through the air raids, and who came over here to friends. The people who went over were workers who could get no work to do here. Thousands of them left both the Ministers' constituencies, and thousands of them left County Dublin, and are still leaving. Anyone who goes down to Amiens Street will see how many of them are going up to Belfast to go over to England. Anyone who goes out to Dun Laoghaire will see how many of them are going on the mail boat every day. Yet, we are told that that is not so. There is not much use in this House assembling if that sort of stuff is given out here as official information.

I should like to hear some Minister explain to the House the survey of the position made by the Government on the date when it became evident that this country was thrown back entirely on its own resources. I should like to know what survey was made, and what planning was done to meet the future. If we are thrown back on our own resources, how does the Minister for Supplies propose to give us our supplies? What steps has he taken in that direction? Of what supplies must we go short? Has the Minister for Agriculture taken adequate steps to provide sufficient food for man and beast in the months and years ahead? We are entitled to know those things, and if the Ministers refuse to give us that information I think it will make the people even more apprehensive of the position. Anything may happen. I quite agree with, I think it was, Deputy Keyes, who said that, if that position is allowed to develop, we here in this country are sitting on a volcano which will explode any day. Then it will be too late to give the information. It will be too late in the national interests, but it will be given then, so why not give it now and let us know where we stand? Why not make an effort to produce all that is required to keep the home fires burning, and to produce the necessary food here? The people will produce the food if they get the chance. If the unemployed are sent out to produce fuel—they can go out in the ordinary old-fashioned way with the barrow and sleán—I think they will produce as much turf per £1 spent as the experiment in Clonsast is producing. Let them be sent out to produce turf so that we will have fuel, and let the Minister for Agriculture see to it that we have enough food for the human population. Let us see that we produce enough food for the bovine population and that we will not have to kill many more cattle. I think the Minister, when asking for this £35,000,000, should explain how it will be possible to pay it, considering that we have not our normal imports. We cannot have the same import duty. There is a shortage of tobacco and we cannot have the same duties from that commodity. We have not much petrol. I do not suppose there is anything like half the normal consumption, and in that connection we will lose the tax. Half the motor cars are not licensed and we will lose in that respect, too. Our outlay has increased, whereas the national income from every direction is contracted. How do the Government propose to make good the deficiency and allow the country to live?

Comment on this

I am anxious to intervene in the debate at this stage, because it is my intention this evening to make a calm speech for the information of Deputies. I feel that it might become a matter of considerable difficulty for me to make that speech if I had to listen much longer to speeches of the kind that have been delivered here this evening. I propose not to give way to the temptation to revive the Party dog-fight, as was quite evidently the intention of Deputy McGilligan last night and of Deputy O'Higgins to-day. Why these Deputies chose to adopt the line they did, it is hard to understand. I do not think they were serving any national purpose, and I doubt if they were serving even a Party purpose.

I propose to curb my tongue. Deputy O'Higgins said he was going to curb his tongue, but he followed up that announcement by a great deal of personal abuse of Ministers. I was referred to as the Minister for Ballyhoo. All the other members of the Government were described as tin-pot Czars, and the adjectives used throughout the whole of his speech were by no means complimentary. If Deputy O'Higgins wanted to put this debate on the wrong line, he did his best, but, fortunately, he did not succeed, because other Deputies who spoke subsequently adopted a much more reasonable line. No one could find the slightest fault with the speech delivered by Deputy MacEoin, nor have I any serious complaint to make about the speeches delivered by other Opposition Deputies yesterday. Some of them even went to the extent, which Deputy McGilligan never reached in his life, of putting forward constructive proposals which, whatever their merit, are at least worthy of consideration.

Deputy O'Higgins spoke of the position existing in the country and, of course, like other Deputies who spoke yesterday, he was anxious to make it clear that the Government alone were responsible for any difficulties that the country is experiencing. He said that the position in the country was giving certain persons, certain ill-disposed persons, an opportunity of provoking discontent. Deputy O'Higgins did his best to provoke all the discontent he could, and I think it is no harm that Deputies should realise that one of the most obvious dangers in a situation in which foodstuffs are scarce, unemployment is growing and the whole economic organisation of the State has become dislocated, is that people may be stampeded by false hopes into taking certain courses of action, hoping to escape from unpleasant realities, which may well result in permanent damage being done to this State, which may well result in the total destruction of the State.

It is important that that should be avoided. If there are remediable causes of discontent, they may be removed, but all leaders of opinion, not merely members of the Government or the Dáil, must co-operate in ensuring that the public will understand the causes of their troubles, the extent to which these causes arise from matters that are within our control and the extent to which they are unavoidable—and a great many of our troubles are unavoidable. It is open to Deputies to blame the Government, if they wish to do so, for not having foreseen with greater accuracy the course of the events in Europe, and made more extensive provision against the consequences of the war.

We can deal with that if it is worth while, but for those who are merely concerned with facts as they are, those whose main purpose is to endeavour to find the best means of dealing with these facts, so that the inevitable troubles which they cause will be minimised, and the inevitable hardships which flow from them will be reduced, it is important that there should be no playing upon the discontent of individuals, upon the difficulties of individuals, merely for the purpose of arousing irritation or promoting disorder.

Reference was made here to-day by a number of Deputies to an alleged growth of opinion in the country hostile to parliamentary institutions. Apart from a few fairly obvious references to Deputies' salaries and matters of that kind, in the pages of the Irish Independent which, for some motive which has never been made clear, never loses an opportunity of bringing disrepute upon this House, I am not aware that that situation is developing; but I am fully alive to the possibility that it may develop if the institutions of the State are not fully utilised, and properly utilised, to secure whatever solutions are possible of our present difficulties. What must we do if we are to make democracy work under present circumstances, and avoid a futile turning by the people to other methods of organisation which would be no more effective in dealing with difficulties arising from causes which are not within the control of this country at all, but which, nevertheless, might be resorted to if discontent should grow to the point of unreason? We must, first of all, ensure that the most effective methods of handling our problems are calmly discussed here, not for the purpose of putting blame upon one individual or another, but to get all the facts marshalled and the combined wisdom of the House brought to bear upon them.

It is natural enough for me to retaliate in kind to speeches made from the opposite benches, designed to show that I alone am to blame for all the ills of the country. If that is said, I will endeavour to ensure that other people bear what I consider is their due share of whatever blame is going, but that is not going to profit either them or Deputies on this side. What is important is that we should have a calm approach to this problem in order to find a solution, making it clear to the public that the best solution can only be a makeshift, something designed to tide us over a temporary difficulty until changing international circumstances make it possible for us to plan on a more permanent basis.

I think it is necessary that the idea that all our difficulties are due to some errors on the part of the Government should be killed. That idea exists partly through natural causes, and partly through the efforts of anti-Government propagandists. Deputies can believe it privately if they like, but if the idea gets public currency that all these evils are due to errors on the part of the Government, that all these evils could now be made to disappear if the Government were to resort to some new method of operation, some new policy, then, it will not be possible to get that calm, deliberate consideration of our position which is necessary, or to devise the policy which will be most effective in dealing with it. I ask Deputies to stop nagging. Nagging has been defined in a dictionary as the continued reiteration of unpleasant truths.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

A perfect definition.

Comment on this

The Government knows quite well, in the light of circumstances as they now exist, that many of the steps it took to deal with a possible war situation, before the war or in the early days of the war against possible adverse developments in it, were inadequate, having regard to events as they actually developed. We did not know before the war what its course was going to be, or when precisely it was going to start. Deputies now convey the suggestion that the Government should have endeavoured, in the early days of 1939, to build up Government stocks of essential goods, stocks imported by the Government and held by the Government against the possibility of a scarcity. We did not do that.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

You did.

Comment on this

We did not.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

In respect of wheat.

Comment on this

In respect of wheat, we utilised the existing wheat importing organisations.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

You got in reserves, anyway.

Comment on this

But not much.

Comment on this

Generally, we endeavoured to operate through the existing trade organisations. The wisdom of that course was obvious. We did not want to disorganise trade in that year. We were not certain that war was going to start, and we did not want to undertake a commitment which would create immense trouble for those engaged in particular businesses, if, in fact, war did not occur, and our effort was to get the various trade organisations of the country alive to the importance of bringing in additional supplies and building up reserve stocks, and in facilitating them in the doing of it. We endeavoured to facilitate them by getting over whatever financial difficulties they might have had. An arrangement was made with the Joint Standing Committee of the Irish banks to provide the finance, and we got over difficulties due to the absence of organisations necessary to provide for combined or concerted action.

When war did occur, it was necessary to go further than that, and in relation to a number of commodities, combined purchasing organisations had to be brought into existence. They were brought into existence not merely for wheat, not merely for timber, but also for animal feeding stuffs and more recently for coal; but, apart from these Government sponsored organisations, other arrangements were made for combined purchasing which were acceptable to all the people concerned, and which worked reasonably satisfactorily. Not in every case did they produce the full results that we thought were possible. Some of these organisations were more efficient than others, and some worked more energetically and more enthusiastically than others. It may be that some of them were luckier than others, but they all did succeed in handling the situation which had arisen here and which called for the existence of some centralised purchasing authority in relation to the goods concerned.

There were other goods in relation to which those who were most concerned with the problem of importing them advised us that a combined purchasing organisation was neither necessary nor desirable. They felt that their own trade associations, their contacts with particular markets, their ability to bring forward small parcels on a large number of boats, meant that we would get larger supplies than if we tried to confine purchases to bulk lots bought by one organisation. In relation to some of these commodities, we tried both methods alternately, and in each case our actions were decided by the advice given us by those who were best able to advise, those who were engaged in the particular business and had expert knowledge which they placed at our disposal.

Comment on this

What caused the breakdown in our effort to get supplies?

Comment on this

The Deputy must not misunderstand the position. Some of our efforts to get supplies have not broken down. Problems have arisen in relation to a number of individual commodities—I propose to deal with them here to-night—but there must not be any exaggeration of our difficulties, any more than is it desirable that there should be any minimising of them. I will endeavour to put the facts as accurately as possible before the House in relation to the commodities to which I wish to refer. A number of Deputies referred to-day to the speech made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce yesterday, in which he dealt with the employment and unemployment position up to date. The statistics which the Minister quoted cannot be contested. Whatever interpretation may be given to them, whatever significance is properly attachable to them, the statistics themselves are accurate; but our concern here this evening is, presumably, not with the position which has existed up to now, but the position which common sense tells us is likely to exist in the future, and even though it was true that more houses were built in 1940 than in 1939, it is extremely unlikely that more will be built in 1941. We know that various problems are going to arise which will affect the activity of a number of industries and reduce the employment these industries give, and it is in relation to these future anticipated problems that our main anxiety exists. We can debate what has happened up to the present when the war is over, because handling these problems which will arise next week, next month and during the course of this year, is going to occupy, and going to require, all our time and our attention.

Deputy Belton spoke of the possibility of various classes of farm animals having to be killed off in order to economise the supply of feeding-stuffs. He referred to that possibility as something which was so out of the question that only extraordinarily bad fortune could bring us to that position. That position has been reached in a very large number of European countries already. In Denmark, Holland, Belgium and a number of other countries in Europe, by Governmental decree, for the express purpose of conserving the existing food for the maintenance of human beings, a very high percentage of the number of cattle, pigs and other farm animals have already been destroyed, and while I recognise that our position is not made any easier by contemplating the greater misfortune of others, it is not impossible that a situation may arise for us as grave as that which has already arisen for a number of other European nations.

For the purpose of dealing with the situation, it has frequently been suggested that we should have a general rationing scheme. Sometimes, I think that those who speak of a general rationing scheme do not fully understand what they mean by it. If, by a general rationing scheme, we mean complete control of individual expenditure of all kinds, such as exists in Germany and, to some extent, in Great Britain, then, I say that our circumstances do not require it. General rationing of the kind they have adopted in Germany or of the kind they are operating in Great Britain had behind it other purposes than the equitable distribution of supplies that were short. In these countries they were concerned to release from non-essential occupations labour required for war production purposes or for their armies. They were concerned also to compel economies on the part of individuals, so that they would save a substantial proportion of their incomes which they could lend to their Governments for the financing of their war efforts. It may be that many of the rationing measures adopted in these countries had primarily the idea of economising labour, and were only in a secondary sense associated with the problem of a fair distribution of supplies that were short.

Our position is different. There is no reason why we should deliberately discourage people from buying and consuming a very large number of goods of common use concerning which we have no supply problems and do not expect to have any. Over a great range of foodstuffs we are producers, and we produce far in excess of our own requirements. Instead of trying to curtail the consumption of these goods here, it is obviously in our interest that we should, if possible, afford facilities which will permit of even greater consumption of these goods than was the normal practice in times of peace. Our aim is to try to preserve as long as possible normal civilian employment. We have no purpose to serve by restricting employment in non-essential occupations. On the contrary, to the utmost extent possible and for as long as possible, we want to maintain the maximum number of people in their normal peace-time occupations. Therefore, over a wide range of industrial goods produced either from native raw materials or from materials in respect of which difficulties of supply have not yet arisen, there is no reason why we should curtail the purchases or the consumption of the public.

I think it is common sense to say that there is no reason why we should resort to rationing, save for one purpose and one purpose only. That is, to secure fair and equitable distribution of supplies of essential goods which are either in short supply at the moment, or concerning which the danger of short supply in the future may exist.

It can be said that difficulties have arisen, so far as goods of general consumption are concerned, only in relation to a number of products—such as tea, coal, petrol, wheat and timber. It is quite true that there are a number of other goods the supply of which is running out, and may at some time cease, but they are not goods of general consumption, and their disappearance from our shops—as, undoubtedly, they will disappear before the war is over—will not cause any great hardship.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

What about soap?

Comment on this

There are a number of other commodities, like soap, concerning which the position is somewhat different. It is not that we shall not be able to keep up a supply of soap; we shall. We may not be able to produce soap of the quality to which we have been accustomed. We shall have to do without certain imported materials required for the manufacture of the high-grade soaps to which the public have become accustomed, but we can to some extent substitute for these imported materials native materials which will produce a soap of lower quality, but in sufficient quantity to supply our requirements.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

There is a scarcity at the moment.

Comment on this

I do not think that that is correct. An individual trader or an individual manufacturer may be short, but, in the industry as a whole, there is a sufficiency of supplies or stocks to meet existing requirements. That is a problem for the soap manufacturers. We have said to them: "There is the supply of raw materials you are going to get. You are going to get no more unless our supply position improves." These manufacturers of soap were told that the existing stock of vegetable oils in the country, or any future stock of vegetable oils that might come in, was going to be conserved for the manufacturer of margarine, and that none would be made available for the manufacture of soap. The manufacturers of soap were told that they would have to work on existing stocks, and that, when these became exhausted, they would have to replace them with materials produced within the country. They will be able to produce a lower grade article, but in sufficient quantities for our requirements, so that there will be no absolute scarcity.

I do not want to go over the whole range of industrial goods. I am merely referring to some of them by way of illustration. There are commodities other than those of general consumption to which I have referred which may become short, but the problem of dealing with these shortages could not be met by a general rationing scheme of the type we are applying to tea, or which we have applied to petrol, because it is not everybody who requires them, and those who do require them cannot be as easily identified as owners of motor cars can be identified.

In the case of such commodities, control must be exercised at the source or at the point of distribution. It is necessary that there should be a limitation of the quantities supplied to retailers and an obligation on retailers to distribute those goods in accordance with specific instructions. I know that retailers dislike the placing of such an obligation upon them. But in relation to certain commodities, such as paraffin oil for household consumption, no other system of control is possible. We must put that obligation on retailers, and put it in legal form, if we are to get over the difficulty of distributing a reduced quantity of paraffin oil to people who cannot get their full requirements. It would not solve the paraffin-oil problem to give ration coupons to everybody. I may not want paraffin oil. Half the members of the House may not want paraffin oil but, if we get a coupon entitling us to buy it, we shall, probably, buy it and intensify the problem of supply. Therefore, in relation to paraffin oil, our main concern must be to keep all that is required for agricultural and industrial purposes and our secondary concern must be that the balance left over, representing only a proportion of normal supplies, be distributed fairly by retailers amongst customers registered with them, giving each customer a fixed proportion of what would be his normal purchase.

There is a whole variety of problems of this kind to which I do not propose to refer. I merely mention this matter for the purpose of showing that a general rationing scheme is not required at present. I have no objection to a general rationing scheme if circumstances call for it but our present circumstances do not call for it. They do call for a number of individual schemes to control the supply of commodities concerning which scarcity has arisen or will arise in the near future. We do not need for any of these ration schemes a general national register such as has been suggested. I do not know if Deputies who speak lightly of a national register quite realise what it means in the matter of organisation both throughout the country and at headquarters. The taking of a census is a fairly substantial task which the Government undertakes every ten years. I want you to contemplate what the problem would be if a census had to be taken on a different basis. A census is taken at present for the purpose of getting information relating to everybody in the family, family and industrial conditions, and so forth. It is taken in relation to a particular date and, in the course of some years after the taking of the census, the information is collected and published in respect of that particular date. But a national register, established for a particular date and containing information only in relation to that date, would be of no use whatever for a rationing scheme.

If a national register is to be of any value for a rationing scheme or for any other system of public administration, it must be correct, not merely for the date on which it begins, but for every date. The information contained in it must be accurate for every day and every week in the year, and that involves, not merely a temporary organisation, drawing up the register once, it means a permanent organisation established throughout the country, supplying information to a headquarters as to variations in the original records that must necessarily be made to ensure that, for whatever date it is decided to bring it into use, the register for rationing or some other purpose would be accurate.

We may have to establish a national register yet. They established one in Great Britain, but not primarily for the purpose of rationing commodities. They were concerned with the conscription of their man power for armies, and the best utilisation of their labour power for war production and other purposes. It was primarily for that purpose that they set up their national register. I feel certain that, in relation to those commodities that are already in short supply here, and for which we have to introduce rationing straight away, our system of rationing will work better than the system operating in Great Britain. The system there, as I think is common knowledge, is not working satisfactorily. There are a number of people who, of course, have the impression that the mere introduction of a rationing scheme solves problems of supply and automatically guarantees to everybody that they will get supplies of the rationed commodity. That is not the case. Everybody who has been in Britain knows that there are people there holding ration cards for a number of commodities that they cannot get. Before we decided upon the introduction of a rationing scheme for tea and for other commodities here, we took the precaution of examining the methods in operation in Britain, and hearing the views of the officials of the British Government, who had the responsibility for the operation of these methods; and it was with all that information available that we decided upon the system of rationing which we are operating.

Let me say at once that our present plans are based upon our present problems and upon our present knowledge of prospective future problems. If the circumstances change so as to require the scrapping of those plans—and that may happen—then we will scrap them. Perhaps we may yet be obliged to establish a national register or to resort to a general rationing scheme on a coupon basis, or to some other device which is not considered necessary now. It is not thought possible, in circumstances such as exist in Europe at the present time, to do more than to base plans upon the immediately ascertainable facts, but it is necessary always to keep in mind that these facts are liable to the most violent fluctuation, and that circumstances may arise in a week or a month to completely upset all calculations.

Let me refer to the individual commodities concerning which difficulties have arisen, and to which references have been made by a number of Deputies here to-day. The first is tea. The information which I am about to give the House now was given by me some days ago in the Seanad. Those Deputies who take any interest in the proceedings of the Seanad, and who read the Seanad Debates, will know what I am about to say. When the war started the position in this country was this. The great bulk of our tea supplies was bought through the London market. A very high percentage of the total tea output of the world came to London, and was auctioned there by brokers, and the tea merchants—tea importers and blenders—of this country went to the London market and there bid for the various grades of tea which they required, in the quantities that they required to produce the blends that they were putting on the market. The great bulk of our tea came from London; a very much smaller quantity was purchased from a similar market which existed in Amsterdam; and a very small amount was purchased direct from the countries of origin.

The bringing in of teas direct from the country of origin was not a very practical proposition, because, as some Deputies know, tea in the raw as it comes in in chests from the countries of production could not be consumed; it has to be blended with other teas produced in different districts, or with different characteristics before producing the beverage which we take at breakfast or supper. When the war started, we made an arrangement with the British Government under which we, on our side, undertook that we would not compete with them in bidding for supplies of teas in the countries of production, or for shipping space for the transhipment of tea from the country of production, nor would we utilise dollar resources to purchase teas outside the sterling areas. They, on their side, agreed to give us 100 per cent. of our normal requirements of tea. Our normal requirements were agreed to be our imports for a twelve months' period between 1938 and 1939.

That arrangement operated almost from the beginning of the war. The necessary legal restrictions were put upon the tea importers of this country by us, and the British Tea Control on its side made periodic allocations of tea to this country, which represented our normal purchases of tea. There were various considerations which prompted that arrangement, to which I might make reference, as they have a distinct bearing upon our present problem of rationing distribution. One of these is that many of the firms engaged in the business of selling tea by wholesale in this country are British firms, or firms established in Belfast. Their headquarters and their stores are outside this country. The allocation of tea in respect of this country made by the British Tea Control is made to those firms and not to a Government Department here or retailer here. Consequently, the fact that the British Tea Control made an allocation of so many pounds of tea did not mean that that tea had arrived here. That tea, in part, was in the possession of British firms who, however, were under obligation to sell it in this country, in very much smaller quantities, to retail firms scattered throughout various counties.

The arrangement concerning tea worked, as I have said, reasonably satisfactorily. It is true that, from time to time, the allocations of tea which were due to be made to us were not made or, if made, did not arrive because of the destruction of stocks in Great Britain or transport difficulties. So, at the end of 1940, there were a number of these allocations in arrear. Nevertheless, the quantity of tea imported over the whole of the period from the beginning of the war to the end of 1940 was not less than our normal imports, as there was a period during which the British Tea Control was not completely operative and a quantity of "free teas", as they were called, came in, so that even if the Tea Control were a number of allocations in arrear, the total quantity of tea imported was, nevertheless, up to normal.

Deputies have frequently represented me as having said here in the Dáil on the 17th January that we had an abundance of tea in the country. I said nothing of the kind. I said on the 17th January that, up to that date, no shortage had arisen, that the tea wholesalers were in a position to make, and were making, to reach retailer allocations equivalent to 100 per cent. of their normal purchases. Before I made that statement, I had taken two precautionary steps. In the week in which the Dáil met and before the Dáil met, telephonic communication was established with the head of the Tea Control in Britain, and inquiry was directed to him as to whether there had been any change in the position, and we were informed there was no change in the position. The position was that we were still getting allocations of tea equivalent to 100 per cent. of our requirement under the arrangements made at the beginning of the war, even though the British had decided to ration tea to their own consumers as from the beginning of July. Not merely was that information received from the Tea Control of Great Britain, but a meeting of the tea wholesalers in this country was held in the offices of our Department, and their view was that tea supplies, while not abundant, were at any rate adequate to keep up 100 per cent. supplies to retailers, and that there was no necessity to introduce a rationing scheme. Supported by the knowledge that that was the opinion of the tea wholesalers, and with the knowledge supplied to me by the head of the Tea Control of Great Britain, I came to the Dáil on the 17th January and said that there was no shortage of tea—not that there was an abundance of tea or that there was going to be no shortage, but that up to that date any difficulties in connection with supplies either to retailers or individual consumers were due to accidental causes.

That was the position, but shortly after the Dáil adjourned we received notification from the Tea Control in Great Britain that, owing to sinkings of ships and the losses of tea due to these sinkings, and also due to the destruction of stocks of tea in Great Britain by fire, they were compelled to effect a percentage reduction in the allocation of tea to this country. They did not specify the percentage. It was when that information was received—and not because our stocks of tea had gone down or been lost, or had been misappropriated by any body of traders or consumers — it was only when we received the intimation that our future allocations of tea were going to be reduced, that we decided to introduce a rationing scheme, and forthwith we ordered the tea wholesalers to reduce their allocations to retailers by 25 per cent. We did that, knowing that a number of retailers throughout the country had stocks of tea—some of them, possibly, had considerable stocks —which they could put into consumption. Some of these retailers may have been holding these stocks against the possibility of the tax upon tea being increased in the Budget, and some of them for some other reason, but at any rate we knew that these stocks were there, and, furthermore, we felt that it was necessary to get our people to understand that the problem that we had feared might arise in relation to tea had, in fact, arisen. Accordingly, we asked these people to reduce their consumption of tea, and we proposed in the case of retailers, that that should take the form of an allowance to each adult individual of two ounces per week and, in the case of each child under 12 years of age, of one ounce. These regulations are now prescribed in a legal order which will come into force next month.

I want to say that these precautions are now justified on the basis of the situation with regard to supplies as we now know it to exist, but consumers must face the possibility that the situation with regard to our supplies of tea may become worse. It is true that the Tea Controller in Great Britain said that the reduction in allocation of tea was temporary and that it was due to the recent losses they had experienced, but I think it would be very unwise to base any hopes upon the assumption that full allocations will be restored again. On the contrary, we must be alive to the possibilities that future allocations may be reduced even by a greater percentage than 25 per cent., imposed upon the wholesalers in their trading relations with retailers. I want now to refer to the question of wheat.

Comment on this

Before the Minister leaves the question of tea, I should like to ask him whether, in view of the fact that the import price of tea from 1939 to 1940 was 1/6 in the lb., and that the increase on that was only 1¾d. in the lb., he can explain why there has been the great increase that has come about in the price charged for tea to the consumer?

Comment on this

I have made many attempts in the past few years to find a satisfactory method of regulating the price of tea by order. I do not want to say that I have found a solution. A solution has been proposed to me, and it may work, but at any rate it is not in force yet. Clearly, it is extremely difficult to regulate the price of a commodity which is sold in such a great variety of grades, and where the ordinary layman, or even the ordinary inspector is quite incapable of determining what represents the highest value or what represents the lowest value. We could have standardised the price of tea, that is to say pooled all the tea in the country and levelled it out at a controlled price, but that would have involved a considerable hardship on those who bought the lowest priced tea. It would have meant that they would have had to pay more for their tea while those who bought the higher-priced tea would pay less, and I have not so much faith in human nature as to expect that the retailer would give the same quality tea to the poor person who ordinarily got the lower-priced tea, as he would give to the person who previously paid the best price.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

But that is the position to-day.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say if the import price is only increased by 1½d. a lb.?

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

I said that the import price was only up by 1¾d., and yet, over the whole gamut, there is this enormous increase.

Comment on this

Let me proceed with my speech without all this cross-examination.

Comment on this

All I am asking for is an explanation of that fact.

Comment on this

The explanation is that I am not accepting the Deputy's fact.

Comment on this

Does the Minister accept one fact: that the import price of tea in 1940 was only 1¾d. over the previous import price?

Comment on this

The Deputy must remember that a number of factors must be taken into consideration about which he knows nothing. A very large amount of tea is sold in bulk to various large institutions, public and otherwise, in this country.

Comment on this

I am talking of the import price of tea.

Comment on this

There is what people have to pay for tea, and what that price is has to be related to the import price. I am not saying that there are no instances of overcharging. I have inspectors going around, and I have ten additional inspectors going around this week, in an endeavour to enable me to bring about the prosecution of any people who may be trying to evade the regulations.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

The wholesalers——

Comment on this

Let me speak. I am as much entitled to speak as anybody else.

Comment on this

The Minister is talking on the question of supplies, and I suggest that if there is any question of prices it can be dealt with afterwards.

Comment on this

Yes, we are dealing with the matter of supplies at the moment. The position with regard to the enforcement of control over tea prices is that there is inspection following upon individual complaints whereever a substantiated complaint is received by my Department in relation to a particular sale by a particular trader. Where that occurs, inspection follows, and at the moment, in this city, the inspectors of my Department are going through the books of certain firms for the purpose of ascertaining whether any breach of the law is taking place, and if we find that a trader has broken the law—and it is against the law to do many things at the present time—prosecution will follow, and, if the necessary evidence is available, I hope that conviction will follow in such cases. This question of prices can be discussed, perhaps, on another occasion. The matter of price control is one that is worthy of consideration in itself. At the moment we have been dealing with the question of the supply of tea, but I want to deal with the matter of the supply of wheat.

It has been stated here that we should have taken steps much earlier to secure a rapid expansion in the area under wheat in this country. When the war began we were in the position that we had substantial stocks of wheat in the country, and the native harvest came in sufficient to supply our own requirements for four or five months. Furthermore, in addition to the stocks held by the millers, we had also stocks held by the Wheat Reserve Committee.

Nevertheless, in that year we took positive action to secure an increase in the area sown in this country. Not merely was there a publicity campaign, involving advertisements in the newspapers, lectures on the radio, talks to county committees of agriculture and similar methods of propaganda, there was also a Compulsory Tillage Order which made it compulsory upon farmers to put a proportion of their land under the plough and, furthermore, there was the inducement of an increase in the guaranteed price given them to use that newly-ploughed area for the purpose of producing wheat. These measures were resorted to in 1939. Perhaps Deputies will say, in the light of the knowledge they now have as to how events have developed since, that they were not adequate, but in 1939 we were still bringing in substantial quantities of wheat from other countries, spasmodically, it is true, but nevertheless getting it in. There was a period, in July and August of last year, during which so much wheat was available that a problem had arisen at the ports. We were not able to clear the ships as fast as they could come in, and it was partly for the purpose of dealing with that problem and partly for another reason that the advice was given to the public to buy flour and store it, so that congestion in the granaries at the ports would be eased and make it possible for us to bring in more wheat as well as saving the Irish harvest when it came along.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

That is an amazing statement.

Comment on this

Towards the end of November of last year, Grain Importers, Ltd., reported to me that they had not been able to charter a ship to bring in wheat in this year for some time past. Deputy McGilligan tried yesterday to make some case based upon the fact that we did not immediately adopt the measures that subsequently were resorted to to secure a still further expansion in the Irish wheat acreage. When Grain Importers, Ltd., so reported, the first reaction of my Department and of the Government was to endeavour to secure the ships for them. We felt that the difficulties which they had experienced might possibly be removed by our intervention, and we intervened. It was only after we had explored a number of possible means of getting over their difficulty that we had to come to the conclusion that it was likely to prove impossible to get over that difficulty.

Nevertheless, in December, considerable quantities of wheat came in. Let not Deputy McGilligan or anybody else convey the impression that the import of wheat was stopped in November or some time previously. At one time in December there were so many grain ships in our port that the labour organisations came to the Government and asked that the old method of clearing ships by hand should be resorted to rather than those ships should be queuing up, waiting discharge from the automatic discharge plant. The arrival of that considerable quantity of wheat however, did not materially alter the position because we were reckoning upon it, and as I stated in the Dáil in January, several thousands of tons of wheat purchased in last year, for which ships had been arranged in last year, were still due to arrive in the country. Unfortunately, more than half of that wheat we were expecting has already been lost.

The position is, because certain quantities of imported wheat which were purchased failed to arrive, because of the fact that the quantity of native wheat prescribed in the national percentage fixed by the Minister for Agriculture, and which we expected to get from the Irish harvest last year, has not arrived—instead of 40 per cent. of our total requirements we only got 34 or 35 per cent.—and because of the fact that during the early months of this year there has been an increase in the consumption of flour as compared with the last quarter of last year, there is a problem, the problem of how best to conserve existing stocks, on the assumption that these stocks are not going to be supplemented in any way, in order to secure reasonable supplies of flour and bread to our people until the next harvest is in. For safety's sake, we cannot reckon on the next harvest being in until late in September. Various measures have been taken towards that end and we have got to recognise that these measures will not be effective unless we get a considerable degree of public co-operation in carrying them out.

One of the orders which I directed should be prepared to be made, and will be made this week, relates to the feeding of flour or bread or any wheaten product to animals. We are proposing to make that illegal. We are proposing to ask the Civic Guards to bring up for prosecution anybody who is found, subsequent to the making of that order, feeding wheaten products of any kind to animals. But we all know that the making of that order may not prevent it, that farmers who are unable to get other kinds of feeding-stuffs, and who have animals which require to be fed may selfishly utilise flour or wheat in some form as animal-feeding, and that the Civic Guard will not always be there to take down the evidence in his note-book and get the farmer charged before the appropriate court. If we are going to get that order obeyed—not merely enforced, but obeyed—by the public, everybody must co-operate in creating the public opinion which will regard the utilisation of an essential human food such as wheat, in the present circumstances, as food for animals as a crime, a crime not merely against the law, but a crime against the community, a crime which would be punished by individual members of the community even if there was no law.

There is a number of other orders which it is necessary to make. I think it will inevitably be necessary for us in the near future to increase the present extraction to 95 per cent. We are making an order taking under control the deliveries of flour from flour mills, the intention being to confine the average weekly deliveries of each mill to their average deliveries during three months of last year in which consumption of flour was somewhat lower than normal. It is difficult to know what the causes of the fluctuations in the flour consumption of the public arise from. Such fluctuations do occur. For a certain number of months last year the consumption of flour was low. In the earlier weeks of this year it began to rise. It now appears to be falling off again. We are, however, proposing, for the time being at least, to confine deliveries from the mills to the average weekly deliveries of a three-month period during last year. We are proposing to place restrictions upon the sale of bread in hotels and restaurants. As the nature of these restrictions will be published in due course, it is not necessary to reiterate them now.

One further order is being made by the Government, and that is one removing all restrictions upon the importation of flour. It is probably true we will not be able to arrange for the importation of flour from anywhere, but recently there were some indications that it might be easier to ship flour than to ship wheat, and if these indications should prove to be based upon reality, then it is desirable that the existing legal barriers to the importation of flour from abroad should be removed, and an order to that effect is now being prepared.

Comment on this

You would get an odd bag of flour across the Border.

Comment on this

If that should happen, there is no reason why we should worry. By a combination of all these measures, we believe it will be possible to eke out existing stocks over the whole of the period until the next harvest is in. It may be that some of the various plans now being explored to increase existing stocks will produce results. We cannot reckon upon that. If they do produce results it may be possible to modify some of the rationing restrictions now being imposed.

I want to refer now to matters concerning petrol. I know that it is difficult, as Deputy Belton found it difficult, to understand why it was not possible for us to accumulate stocks of petrol. It is necessary that Deputies should know that the total storage capacity in the country is limited to twelve or fifteen million gallons, and, in any event, it could not all be utilised at the same time. The effective storage capacity is only two-thirds of that representing from ten weeks to three months' supply. I know the idea exists in some quarters that if throughout the whole of 1940 we had imposed more rigorous restrictions upon the consumption of petrol than we did we could have taken out of the supplies available a larger quantity and stored it somewhere for reserve purposes, thus preventing a sudden stoppage in supplies when something unexpected or something unaccounted for might arise. That was not possible.

I have tried to explain the situation to Deputies, but perhaps it is as well to do it again, so that any misunderstandings will be removed. Deputies can believe it or not as they like. I am concerned only to tell the facts. We are supplied here by companies which are engaged in the oil business on an international scale. These companies have parcelled out the whole world between them. They supply the various markets in agreed proportions, and for these companies this country is very small fry. The total annual consumption here of petrol is less than one day's consumption in other countries supplied by them. No special arrangements were made by them to secure supplies for us. They did arrange to bring supplies across the Atlantic, or from some other sources outside, consigned to their parent organisations in Great Britain, and that stream of tankers came across the Atlantic carrying oil supplies to Great Britain. Only when it was reported that stocks here were running out, and new supplies were required, was one of these tankers diverted into our harbours and our stocks replenished in consequence. If we had six months' supply on the 1st January, 1940, we would have gone on using that six months' supply until the end of June, and then a tanker would be diverted to replenish stocks then exhausted.

It was not possible to build up reserves unless we went to purchase supplies from the oil companies to put into storage of our own. Precautions had to be taken, obviously for certain purposes. There comes a danger period recurring regularly when existing stocks are low, before a new supply has arrived, and clearly if at any time the new supply fails to arrive, there is going to be an immediate problem of distribution. That happened at Christmas. Stocks were running out, and the new supply to replenish them did not arrive, and it was not possible to replace the lost supplies. Some Deputy said to-day that we only woke up to the fact that there was a petrol shortage when the petrol pumps in garages were dry. The first intimation of the existence of a difficulty at all was the announcement from my Department that the distribution of petrol to garages was going to be temporarily suspended. Petrol pumps in garages were not dry then. In fact, the suspension of supplies was to ensure that the quantity of petrol available in tanks owned by garages would be utilised while we were keeping the position under review. As soon as we got the position under review, we were able to resume supplies. Since then we have not succeeded in getting a sufficient quantity of petrol to enable anything like the rationing allowances of last year to be restored. We have not, in fact, been able to make any distribution of petrol to private car owners.

I want the House to understand that the situation which arose in December may arise again. That danger period cannot be avoided and, at any time, a further failure of a new supply to arrive, when existing stocks are exhausted, will mean that for a period there will be no petrol available, because we had some reserves in December, and we were able to issue during January, in order to keep going, twice the quantity imported during January, but that situation does not exist now. If a new supply does not arrive periodically, then distribution has to stop forthwith, and there will be petrol for no one. That may well happen more than once during the course of the present year. There is no means by which we can avoid it. It is, if course, necessary that certain essential reserves should be acquired and kept for purposes such as Red Cross services, ambulance services, fire brigade services and other essential services. That is being done.

The balance of the petrol available is being distributed on the most equitable basis we could devise for those requiring it. Some Deputy suggested to-day that we should exercise individual discretion in determining to whom petrol should be given. I do not think it would be wise from any point of view that we should do so. At the present time petrol is distributed to people who come within certain clearly defined categories, based on the quantity of petrol available, and if a person comes within one of these categories he gets petrol. If he does not, he cannot get petrol, and no amount of influence, writing to Deputies or to the Minister, will succeed in getting petrol for him. That is the best way to do it, because if the impression gets abroad that a Minister or some official of a Minister has individual discretion, and that Pat Murphy will get petrol when John Smith is not getting it, then there is going to be chaos and widespread discontent, because everybody will believe that failure to get petrol was due to the incompetence of a Deputy or his inability to pull the wires successfully. Nobody wants that. It is much better the public should know that no discretion is exercised by anyone, and that the only point at which Ministerial determination comes into the picture is when the categories are being fixed. That is the only system I am prepared to work.

I realise that that may mean that Deputy McGilligan may have an invalid friend with a car who would want one gallon a month, and because that individual cannot get it, Deputy McGilligan may present that as an appalling case. His friend is not getting it because it is not available, because we could give 12 gallons a year without difficulty, but I get dozens of letters from motor car owners and others, who support their claims for petrol by providing doctor's certificates, and I cannot deal with Deputy McGilligan's friend without dealing with thousands of others who may, for all I know, have as good claims. It is not possible for any officials in the Department to determine the relative merits of individual claims. We are not going to deal with them. We can only distribute petrol, on the basis of the supplies available, to those coming within the categories.

Comment on this

Can we take that as definite?

Comment on this

Deputy Cogan stated to-day that some people were able to buy petrol at 8/6 a gallon. I have no doubt that there are garages throughout the country selling petrol illegally. It is illegal to sell petrol except against coupons. I am sure there are garage proprietors who are breaking the law. I am not going to be held responsible if they break the law. I am going to ask the Civic Guards and the officers of the Department to take every possible steps to detect those who are breaking the law. I am trying to ensure that those breaking the law will receive exemplary punishment in order that others will not be encouraged to do it. It is illegal to sell petrol above the fixed price. That is the law. If people break the law, then I want them to know that if such breaches are taking place, and if the necessary information is sent to the Civic Guards or to my Department the requisite procedure will be adopted.

It is, I think, of real importance to every individual in this country that there should be no connivance at breaches of these Governmental Orders which are necessary to deal with the difficulties of the present situation. There are a very large number of these Orders. It is not possible for the Government to place an officer at every cross-roads or at every shop in order to ensure that these Orders are being carried out. If we do not get public co-operation in making the Orders effective, then some of them will remain ineffective. The only people to suffer in consequence will be the public and, therefore, I ask the public to help the Government in seeing that the Orders are carried out. I should like, if I am in order in this connection, to address a similar appeal to some of the district justices and to ask them also to see that the law is carried out, because it is of real importance that there should be no connivance even at minor breaches of the law in this situation. If we are going to get through the present period of trial without collapse, there must be effective discipline amongst the public and that means that the regulations made for the benefit of the public must be strictly enforced and loyally obeyed.

Reference has been made to the question of building. It is inevitable that building activities will have to be slowed down because certain building materials, notably timber, are becoming difficult to obtain. Some timber is still coming in and there is a quantity of timber available within the country, but at a very early date it will be necessary for the Government to take control of timber and to determine a schedule of priorities for the use of it so that timber will be released for some purposes earlier than for other nonessential purposes.

Comment on this

Is the Minister speaking now of imported timber?

Comment on this

I am speaking of imported timber. The problem of effective control of native timber, considerable quantities of which are available, has also to be faced.

Comment on this

When will there be some plan for the utilisation of native timber?

Comment on this

There is a plan. I am not quite satisfied with the plan which exists at the moment. Arrangements for the utilisation of native timber and the conservation of imported timber were made some time ago. They were in fact reviewed this week in my Department, and new arrangements will be announced in due course. I want to state that the Departments of State directly concerned are also being asked to experiment with ways and means of conducting building and similar operations with a reduced use of timber. Various experiments have been, in fact, conducted with that object. It is not, of course, possible to do without timber entirely, and the problem is aggravated by the still greater difficulty of getting steel for reinforcement purposes. Nevertheless, an examination is being made of that aspect of the problem. We must face the fact that we cannot maintain building on the same scale as previous years. We may not be able to maintain it even on the scale of last year unless we can utilise the resources of our building industry for purposes other than the construction of residential buildings.

I want to speak on the question of coal, if I may, without delaying the House unduly. We have had a large number of discussions here and elsewhere concerning bellmen's coal. I think to some extent this agitation about bellmen's coal is prompted by the fact that Fuel Importers, Ltd. have in stock substantial quantities of good coal, and those who are encouraging this agitation have in mind the possibility of the Government's releasing some part of that stock for sale by bellmen. The Government is not going to do that. That is our iron ration. Our coal difficulties are likely to be much more serious next winter, and we may have no coal to fall back upon except the very limited stocks which Fuel Importers, Ltd., brought in last year. They do not represent more than an insignificant fraction of our annual consumption, and we cannot release them for use because of an agitation concerning the quality of the coal which is at present available. These complaints concerning the quality of coal available to bellmen have been revived in the course of the last few days. May I explain that an arrangement was made by my Department with the Fuel Importers' Association under which four dumps of coal were established in the City of Dublin for bellmen. Ordinarily these bellmen were supplied by individual merchants. Each merchant had a number of bellmen to whom he supplied coal.

The merchants agreed with my Department that that system of supplying bellmen would be ended, and that instead central dumps would be established from which bellmen would be supplied. A register of bellmen was established for that purpose. That arrangement to supply bellmen from these central dumps will commence to operate from Tuesday next. Up to the present the arrangement was that a bellman was supplied from his own merchant, and only when the merchant could not supply him was he supplied from the dump. The arrangement also provides that 20 per cent. of every cargo that comes in is assigned to the dumps.

The complaint which has been most frequently voiced is that bellmen are being supplied only with slack. I stated here that that complaint could not be completely justified, because of the arrangement to which I have referred. I received, however, a letter from the Women Workers' Union this morning asking me to carry out an inspection of the dumps so that I would be satisfied as to the quality of coal there. When I received that letter, I caused an inspection to be carried out of these dumps and I have since received the report of my officer. It is quite clear from the report that while the quality of coal in the dumps is inferior to the quality of the coal normally imported into Dublin, it is not of a lower grade than the quality of coal which merchants have available for sale to people other than bellmen. The position is that during the last week seven cargoes of coal came into Dublin. Five of these were of slack. That reduced the general quality of the coal available in the dumps. That position has, however, improved as from Monday last when 10 cargoes came in, only one of which was of slack.

The report which I have received relates to the position in each dump. Only two dumps are at present being worked, one for the north city and one for the south. No. 1 dump which is worked for the south, consists of a mixture of large coal and slack and the fuel is being sold to bellmen as 50 per cent. coal and slack. There is approximately 1,000 tons of briquettes, coal and slack in the dump. The other dump, No. 3, is being worked for the north side. There are there about 1,400 tons of slack and of large coal and the inspector was satisfied that the quality of the coal there was somewhat better than in the Hanover Quay dump which is being worked for the south side.

However, the report, the accuracy of which I am prepared to accept, while admitting that there was a temporary difficulty during last week, arising out of the fact, that by far the greater quantity of the coal imported last week was slack, shows that the quality of the coal available in the dumps for distribution to bellmen is not inferior to the quality available for sale to anybody else. The arrangement ensures that no matter what the scarcity of coal, the bellmen will get 100 per cent. of their requirements. That means that people who buy in small quantities from bellmen will be assured of their supplies. The price which they pay for coal is fixed by Order. That price is being subsidised. The price which merchants are being permitted to charge to ordinary consumers has been increased slightly so as to permit of a reduction below the figure that would represent an economic price for coal sold to bellmen. Of course the system of distributing coal through bellmen is an uneconomic one. It is unfortunate for the people who have to buy coal in small quantities that they should have to meet the excessive costs of that uneconomic method of distribution.

Comment on this

Will the Minister deal with the question raised last night? The Minister says that the price at which the bellmen are getting coal is subsidised. The Minister for Industry and Commerce yesterday said that the import prices for coal in January and February were 44/8 and 45/11 per ton, but the bellmen are being charged 63/-. There is also the point that the import price rose between January and February by 1/3 per ton, but between the 18th January and 11th February the increase to bellmen was 11/- per ton.

Comment on this

I am not concerned about the figures which the Deputy got from the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I am not going to explain those figures because I have not examined them. I do know that the price of coal which is being sold in Dublin to bellmen and ordinary consumers is fixed by me on the basis of information supplied by the accountants on my staff who examine the cost of importing coal and relate that cost to a reasonable retail price. I am taking the responsibility for the prices of coal in Dublin, and I am guaranteeing to this House that these prices represent no element of undue profit. That is all I am going to say at the moment. If the Deputy's allegation is that somebody is making undue profits——

Comment on this

I am making no allegation. I am saying that the Minister for Industry and Commerce told us yesterday that the import price of coal in February was 45/11.

Comment on this

The Deputy is trying to relate one set of statistics to another.

Comment on this

And the bellmen are being charged 63/-.

Comment on this

The Deputy is trying to do what I was complaining about and that is to confuse the public mind for the purpose of causing discontent. Does he believe me when I say that the price at which coal is sold to bellmen is fixed by me? Does he believe it is fixed by me and that I fixed that price for the purpose of ensuring that the bellmen got it without undue profits to anybody? If the Deputy believes that, he can do his damnedest to try to cause discontent amongst the poor of Dublin. He can go out with his red flag to cause revolution if he likes, but he will not succeed, because the Government will expose his tactics on every occasion.

Everybody knows what Deputy Mulcahy is up to. He is taking a figure supplied from the trade and shipping statistics which has no relation to the price of coal delivered to a merchant's yard, and which does not purport to be the price of coal delivered to a merchant's yard, and quoting that figure to try to convey to other people the impression that somebody is being permitted to take undue profits. Not merely is that not true, but the contrary is the case. The price of coal to bellmen is, in fact, being subsidised, so that these men are getting coal at a lower price than they would get it if that arrangement had not been entered into by my Department. I promise I will not interrupt the Deputy and he can tell what lies he likes.

Comment on this

Might I ask if that statement is in order—that the Deputy can tell what lies he likes?

Comment on this

Perhaps his conscience will prevent him.

Comment on this

My "lies" are taken from official figures.

Comment on this

There is only one other matter I want to refer to.

Comment on this

Might I ask what are the prospects of getting an adequate supply of anthracite beans?

Comment on this

I could not answer that without notice. In the ordinary course, coal is imported into this country from a wide variety of districts in Great Britain, in a wide variety of qualities. The schedule of coal prices which we agreed to with the coal committee of the British Mines Department was a very lengthy document, and each of these qualities of coal when imported here has to be priced in relation to varying transport charges, because the cost of bringing that coal into different parts of the country differs in each case. Consequently, the coal prices covered a very wide range in normal circumstances. But the present circumstances are not normal. We are not now allowed to buy coal wherever we like in Great Britain. Our purchases are confined to a limited number of areas and the price differential between the highest and the lowest grade of coal which we are allowed to purchase is very narrow. In these circumstances, it has been found possible to fix maximum prices for four grades of coal. These prices have been fixed by my Department and represent the maximum which can be charged. That development of the situation will, of course, facilitate the whole problem of price control in relation to coal in the Dublin area.

Then I was asked about shipping. Deputy Norton inquired when our difficulties began to develop. The difficulties concerning shipping gradually became more acute during the whole of 1940, but they came to a head when Greece was involved in the war, because for a long time after July the great majority of the neutral ships which we chartered for our purposes were Greek ships and after Greece became involved in the war these were commandeered by the Greek Government. Whether we will be able to make our shipping problem easier is a matter I do not wish to discuss now, because the ground has not been sufficiently explored to express an opinion. As I said, everything possible is being done to find some way by which the difficulties created by the absence of these neutral ships will be reduced. If we succeed, well and good. We must, however, base our plans on the assumption that we will not succeed.

Deputy MacEoin asked why the arrangement with the British Government for the joint chartering of neutral ships was terminated. It was terminated for the simple reason that we were not getting the ships. The arrangement was made when neutral ships were available in numbers; but, because of the competition between ourselves and the British Government, the freight rates charged for voyages from South and North America increased very rapidly. In order to effect a reduction in these rates, we made an arrangement at the request of the British Government for the joint charter of these neutral ships. That arrangement was effective for its purpose for a time, and in the months after it was made, months early in 1940, the freight rates quoted us for grain fell by 20 to 25 per cent. as a result of the elimination of competition. But in the course of the year the number of neutral ships available became less. Of those that remained, a number were time chartered by the British Government for their own purposes. The net result was that no ships were being made available to us under the arrangement, and in our own interests, we felt that we should release ourselves from the obligations of the arrangement and take steps to secure vessels on our own account, voyage, charter, or time-charter, or purchase them as the opportunity offered. That is what is being done.

Comment on this

Why did you not buy them when they were available?

Comment on this

The Deputy may ask that question, but he cannot expect to get an answer in a single sentence. We could have bought ships before the war, we could have established an Irish mercantile fleet before the war, but its operation would be most costly to this country. It could not have been maintained on the basis of our own external trade; it would involve a very substantial subsidy. No doubt the Dáil would vote that subsidy with enthusiasm in the light of pre-war circumstances. But, nevertheless, the Government felt that their efforts to promote an Irish mercantile marine in pre-war circumstances should be confined to the encouragement of private enterprise to get into that business.

To some extent private enterprise did get into that business, but not to the extent of building up a fleet of vessels capable of transatlantic voyages. After the war began the problem was a somewhat different one. It appeared to us, so long as neutral ships of other nationalities were available to supply our needs, that it was unnecessary for us to take the risk of having a number of vessels of our own nationality plying in these dangerous waters. I am sure I need not elaborate in this House what that risk was. The risk was sufficient to induce the American Government to pass a law prohibiting their ships from coming into these dangerous waters.

Comment on this

For different reasons.

Comment on this

For precisely that reason, to prevent a breach of neutrality and incidents arising in connection with those ships which would put them in the position of having to sacrifice their prestige or neutrality. There were a number of other reasons. It was only when it became clear there was no alternative that the Government decided to take the risk of acquiring ships to sail in these dangerous waters with goods for us. There are other factors which, I think, the Deputy should bear in mind. His assumption that if we had got Irish-owned ships, acquired before the outbreak of the present war, our problems would now be easier, is not necessarily based on a firm foundation. All those ships which were sunk on their way to this country—and we lost over 70,000 tons of wheat en route to this country in the course of a few months last year—were all neutral ships, sailing from neutral ports, with as much right to engage in the trade of carrying goods for use in this country as our ships would have. His assumption that, if those ships had been carrying our flag, they would have escaped the perils of the sea that brought those other ships to destruction is, I think, unfounded. We might have been luckier, but that is only a possibility.

However, the Deputy can, if he likes, make any case he thinks the facts will sustain against the Government on the ground that it had not built up a mercantile marine in pre-war years. I am prepared to discuss that question at any time, but I suggest that we postpone argument on it until after the war when its merits, or otherwise, can be debated in peaceful conditions. Our present conditions are such that there is little possibility of getting ships to engage in the business of carrying goods to this country except we own them, and that is why the necessary measures to acquire control of such ships are now being taken.

I do not know that there are any other matters concerning which it is necessary to refer. I have spoken much longer than I had intended. I have endeavoured to give the Dáil the maximum amount of information on the various matters which arose in the course of this debate. The Dáil can take the information in the spirit in which I have given it. I was anxious to give the House the opportunity of making whatever constructive suggestions Deputies may have in mind so that we can pool our wisdom and approach the consideration of these problems in a spirit of co-operation and understanding. If Deputies approach them in the "Smart Alec" spirit of Deputy McGilligan they cannot expect to get away with the idea that they are co-operating with the Government. They cannot do that while at the same time heaving bricks at the Government. We want to get their co-operation. We want the help of every one, but if we are going to get a spirit of co-operation in this House it has got to be evident on both sides of it, and not on this side only. We have had very little evidence of it from some of the Deputies opposite in the course of the past two days' debate.

Mr. D. Morrissey rose.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister a question? Arising out of what the Minister said on the petrol situation, are steps being taken to see that a sufficient quantity will be accumulated and be available for harvesting operations this year?

Comment on this

There is the problem of ensuring that the necessary fuels for the conduct of harvest operations will be available. Steps to ensure that are being taken.

Comment on this

And that includes petrol?

Comment on this

Petrol and kerosene.

Comment on this

Is it the Minister's intention to make an order making it an offence——

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is now making a speech. He has already spoken for fifty minutes. Deputy Morrissey.

Comment on this

I just want to ask a question.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy was allowed to do that. Deputy Morrissey.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Minister, at the beginning of his very long but certainly not very good effort, told us that he was going to approach this matter in a serious way. He said that we were going to have a calm approach to it. We had from the Minister who spoke for an hour and thirty-five minutes, a series of confessions of absolute failure. He finished his speech by asking, with his tongue in his cheek, for co-operation and understanding, and for a pooling of the wisdom of the House. The Minister's contribution this evening to that co-operation, unity and pooling of wisdom was to give an exhibition of his usual bad temper. Deputy Mulcahy put a question to the Minister in a perfectly orderly way, but we saw what the Minister's attitude was. That is an old stunt with the Minister for Supplies when he is put a question that he cannot answer, a question that he knows it would not suit him to answer. Let me put the question to the Taoiseach who is going to speak next. The Minister, in the course of his speech, said that the price of coal to bellmen is subsidised. Instead of answering Deputy Mulcahy's question, the Minister said the Deputy could do that and the other thing—that he could make a speech to-morrow and lie as much as he liked. It would be a good thing for this House and country, if the Minister for Supplies would give as much time, attention, intelligence and industry to discovering the position of affairs here as Deputy Mulcahy gives. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in reply to a Parliamentary Question, stated that the price of coal landed on the quays in Dublin was 45/11 per ton.

Comment on this

I said the c.i.f. price. That is not the price landed on the quays.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I accept the Minister's correction. But the price to bellmen is 63/- from the central dumps from which the bellmen have to take it, and still it has to be subsidised.

Comment on this

Of course, that is most misleading, and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Why did not the Minister answer the question when it was put to him?

Comment on this

The Deputy is relating an average price to the price of a particular commodity.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The average price? Will the Minister say if there is more than the average quality of coal being dropped into the four dumps? Are special qualities of coal being lodged in the four dumps? Is there any coal, inferior to what is being put into the dumps, being imported into the country?

Comment on this

Of course there is, and always was.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

What is it?

Comment on this

Industrial coal—steam coal.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

What is being sold in this country to-day for household purposes? However, that is a small point. The Minister amazed the House this evening by the statement he made, and if it is not censored in the newspapers to-morrow morning, it will amaze the people of the country when they read it—the statement that we have to go short of bread, not because it was difficult or impossible to get wheat into the country, but because, according to the Minister, not only in July last but in December—three months ago—we were not able to unload the wheat that was coming into the country.

Comment on this

But we did unload it.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

But you had great difficulty in doing it and it took you a long time.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The position of supplies was such that we had supplies of wheat coming into the country three months ago and we had not sufficient storage to handle it.

Comment on this

The point I made was that it was coming spasmodically.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

In July last, seven months after the outbreak of war, and a month after the fall of France, the people who were set up in this country to ensure that supplies would be available had such little foresight, or rather I should say were so blind that when wheat did arrive the storage was not capable of taking it. The Minister said it.

Comment on this

That is not what I said.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

That is exactly what the Minister said, unless it has been changed by the Minister in the Official Reports.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy allow me to correct him? Following the fall of France, because of the fall of France, there were exceptional quantities of wheat and coal available for us to purchase. Purely temporary circumstances made those exceptional quantities temporarily available, and it was necessary to avail of that temporary advantage to the greatest extent to get in the maximum quantity of wheat and coal. It was for those reasons that we had certain difficulties at the ports.

Comment on this

At the port of Dublin.

Comment on this

And Cork also.

Comment on this

Oh no.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Are we to understand that there was such an abundance of wheat and coal coming into the ports of this country in July last that we were not able to handle it, and that our storage was not sufficient?

Comment on this

We did handle it.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

If it is true that we were not able to handle it, and that our storage was not sufficient, the Minister and his whole Department should be shoved out of the way as soon as possible. I observe that the Minister is leaving the House.

Comment on this

Smart Alec is smarting.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

This is the Minister who said in the Seanad only last week: "The fact that we have gone through eighteen months of war"—that is bringing it up to the present day—"with no serious consequences developing ...." The fact that there are additional thousands of people unemployed in the country to-day is not a serious development; the fact that we are not going to have enough flour in this country to make bread for the people, even with a 95 per cent. extraction, is not a serious development; the fact that the people in this country have to go without fires, without butter, and in some cases without tea, is not a serious development in the eyes of the Minister. On the contrary, conditions are such that he feels that his Department is entitled to a vote of thanks from the House.

Let us take the bread situation. This is the man who told us three weeks ago in this House that there was sufficient flour and wheat in this country to ensure that, on a 90 per cent. extraction, we would have enough bread on our normal consumption to last us until the new harvest. He now tells us, as in the case of tea, that we will not have enough, but he does not tell us when it is going to run short. He does not tell us whether it is going to run short in May or June or July or August. He tells us about some of the orders that have been made and some of the orders that are going to be made. Let me suggest to him one order that ought to be made immediately, and should have been made long ago. If there is a definite shortage of flour, if the position is that there has to be a 95 per cent. extraction from the wheat, and that, notwithstanding that, we will have to ration bread, why in God's name are we affording ourselves the luxury of allowing the bakers in this country to make fancy loaves, pan loaves, fancy rolls and all that sort of thing, which are very highly wasteful? Why does not the Minister insist upon a plain standard loaf being turned out? Why does not the Minister insist, as he should insist, that no bread should be allowed to be offered for sale in this country unless it has been at least 24 or 36 hours baked? The things that would appeal to the ordinary man in the street, the matters that it is easiest to enforce, are the last things that appear to commend themselves to a Government Department.

The Minister talked about the wheat situation. With respect to him, he talked a whole lot of nonsense about it. The Minister talked about what was done in 1939 when we were talking about what should have been done in October, 1940. Of course, now I can see why we are in danger of not being able to produce enough wheat this year to meet our requirements next winter. There was so much of it coming in at the ports that we were not able to handle it even in December. In critical times such as these, if that is not the greatest confession of incompetence and inefficiency—I go further and say criminal negligence—that was ever made in this House, I do not know what to say.

If it was not clear to any Minister, to any member of this House, last September and certainly in October, that there was little hope of getting supplies of foodstuffs from outside for either man or beast, and that it would be necessary to double our own production of wheat, then all I have to say is that that man must be living away up in the air. What is the result? Because the campaign which was started in the middle of January was not started in the middle of October, it is highly problematical that we will get 500,000 acres of wheat, much less 700,000 acres, and as I said yesterday that is not due to any reluctance on the part of the farmers to whom the appeal is being made. It is due to the fact that there is a shortage of seed wheat, and to the fact that we have had extremely bad weather for nearly three months. I am glad to say that a great deal of winter wheat has been put in, and put in under very unfavourable conditions. Even this week people are taking the gamble, and a gamble it is in our climate, and sowing winter wheat. It is a definite gamble, notwithstanding the fact that some officials of the Department of Agriculture and some instructors of county committees of agriculture were told to go down the country and spread the gospel that it was perfectly safe to sow winter wheat up to the end of the second week in March. There is not a practical farmer in the country who does not know that sowing winter wheat in the second week in March is a gamble.

Comment on this

It has not proved so.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Now, I grant the Deputy this, that if this country is fortunate enough, and I hope it will be, to be blessed with a year like we had last year——

Comment on this

And the year before, and the year before that and for several years back.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I am granting that, but I am putting this to the Deputy, that the risk, such as it is—let us agree that it is there; it does not matter whether it is big or small— could, with a little ordinary foresight, have been avoided. I think the Deputy will agree with me that if he were sowing winter wheat he would prefer to see it peeping over the ground in the week before Christmas than to be putting it into the ground in the second week in March.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not agree with you.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Deputy is prepared even to sink his experience as a practical farmer in order to keep the political flag flying.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

All those questions and repartee must stop.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The position with regard to seeds in this country to-day is well-known. I want to put this to any member of the House, any farmer on the Government Benches: Is it not a fact that, if we are to produce our own root seeds for next year, this is the month in which the preparation must be made for it? Is any member of this House satisfied that the Department of Agriculture has taken any effective steps to see that that is done? Is it not a fact that, because the Department of Agriculture was asleep this time 12 months, six months after the war started, and made no provision for providing seeds, that there is practically no turnip seed to be had in this country to-day? It is almost impossible to obtain it at any price. Is it not a fact that, until we got the recent consignment of mangold seeds from America, it was impossible to get mangold seeds from any other quarter? Is it not apparent to everybody who takes an interest in the matter that it will be extremely difficult, if not absolutely impossible, to obtain either root seeds or vegetable seeds?

Is there any evidence that effective steps are being taken by any Department of the State to make adequate provision for such a situation? It is bad enough to be short of manures; it is difficult enough to raise crops successfully without manures; but it is utterly impossible to do it without seeds. Is it not as essential at the moment to have early seed potatoes sown as it is to have spring wheat? Is it not essential to do something of that sort if we are going to have an alternative food supply in June, July and August when the flour is likely to be short? What effort is being made to provide for that situation? There is just one line at the bottom of a large advertisement about wheat. It is false economy. It is of sufficient importance and urgency to demand at least a separate advertisement for itself, and every person in this country who has a perch of ground to spare should be encouraged to put early potatoes into it.

We talk a lot about waste. There is colossal waste, having regard to the circumstances in which we now live and will have to live in the near future. Is any Department of State making an effort to stop that waste? There has been no national effort made to collect waste material, whether paper, tin or anything else. There are a number of voluntary societies appealing in a tuppence-ha'penny sort of way to the people to avoid waste and to save old tins, paper and other things of that sort. They can appeal only in a small way compared to what the Government could do. We are told that our industries are running short of raw materials and yet there is no national appeal made by the Government to the people to avoid waste.

There is no Deputy here who is more anxious than I that every member of this Assembly should pull together in this crisis. Deputies opposite should not take the point of view that we are helpful only when we are dumb. That seems to be the idea of the Minister for Supplies—that is his idea of how we should co-operate with the Government. He started his speech by telling us that he was going to make a serious speech, that he was going to approach the matter in a calm way. What was his first sentence? He said that Deputies on this side should not be playing on the feelings of the people in order to create discontent. I find it very hard to imagine that the Minister for Supplies believes that. He criticised the speech made last night by Deputy McGilligan and he talked about "Smart Alec" and about being slick. He criticised the speech made by Deputy O'Higgins to-day. I did not hear Deputy O'Higgins speaking, but I listened with very great attention to Deputy McGilligan and I considered his speech a very searching speech and I think nobody could consider it other than being a helpful one. I think it is helpful not only to the country but to the Government that if we believe they are going on wrong lines we should point that out to them. Not only is that helping them, but it is our duty to do it.

Comment on this

Deputies over there are constantly interrupting the Minister. I have been here for years and I know that that is your practice. No Deputy sits in this House as often as I do.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I know that, and nobody keeps as quiet as the Deputy, and so long as he keeps quiet he is an asset to the House.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

I am glad to hear that.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

So far as Deputies on the Government Benches are concerned, their idea of co-operation seems to be that we should simply shut our mouths, or else simply say "ditto" to everything that is done. I suggest that when Deputies get the Official Report they should read the speech of the Minister for Supplies. There were several points in it—let us leave out what happened during the last two years and start with the facts as they face us to-day; let us, if it is necessary in the future, have a national register; let us make plans for rationing, if they are necessary in the future, and, if they do not prove suitable, we can change them; we have not coal for this reason, we have not petrol for that, we have not flour for the other, and so on. There was not one sentence in the whole hour and forty minutes' speech to show that he has any plan of his own, that there has been any constructive thinking.

The Minister asks for constructive criticism. His whole speech shows there has not been any constructive thinking in his Department since it was set up. He simply moves from one blunder to another. He says that rationing is not necessary, but if it becomes necessary we will have it. Will we have the same situation as in regard to tea? The position in relation to tea was that the people who could afford to do so bought all they wanted, when there was talk of rationing, and the poor could hardly get any at all. We know what happened with respect to coal, tea and even flour. If you take the import statistics over the years 1938, 1939 and 1940 and study the figures for tea, petrol, coal and wheat, you will see that the shortage was to some extent artificial. People were not only allowed to hoard, but they were even encouraged to do so.

We had another helpful speech from Deputy O'Reilly. He told us that our criticism was not sincere. He told us that when we talked about the petrol shortage we were merely trying to make political capital out of it. He told us we should not be reciting the miseries of the poor and we ought to be satisfied that we had not sheer starvation. I think it was Deputy Keyes who said that, having regard to the type of speech made by Deputy O'Reilly, he was not surprised to find that Ministers knew so little about the actual conditions in the country. I must agree that if Ministers gather their information from men like Deputy O'Reilly, who tells them that farmers are to-day getting 35/- a barrel for their oats—there may be a couple of farmers here and there getting it, but there are very few farmers who grew oats and could afford to keep them over until this month—they cannot be very well informed about existing conditions. I should like Deputy O'Reilly to address himself to the farmers who had to grow oats last year and to sell it at 13/- and 14/- a barrel and saw someone else getting 35/- for it later, or the farmer who had to sell his barley at 19/- and has to buy it back now, if he can get it at all, at £2.

If there is one thing clear from the speech of the Minister for Supplies it is that we would be much better off in this country if that Department had never been set up. We certainly could not be worse off. They have not given us adequate supplies of one single commodity and have not attempted, with the exception of petrol, to see that there was an equal distribution of any commodity in the country. I move to report progress.

Comment on this