We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Trade Union Bill, 1941—Committee.

Contributions 1–192 of 392. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Trade Union Bill, 1941
Enacted

No. 9 of 1941 ›

This section says that:

"This Act and the Trade Union Acts, 1871 to 1935, may be cited together as the Trade Union Acts, 1871 to 1941."

I do not think this Bill is worthy to be classed with what have been called the Trade Union Acts of the past which have been steps of progress for labour, for working organisations, and for peace, harmony and progress in industrial life. We asked, originally, that the consideration of this Bill should be postponed until we had the report of the Commission on Vocational Organisation, and of the evidence given before that commission. On the Second Reading of the Bill we indicated why the members of the Oireachtas and the ordinary people of this country should have expected that nothing in the nature of this Bill would be brought forward until the report of that commission was before them, and more particularly in view of the fact, as has been pointed out, that since the beginning of the emergency nothing has occurred to upset ordinary conditions or the social life of the country in the way of strikes. Quotations, are frequently given from the Encyclical letters of our Holy Father the Pope with regard to labour conditions and labour organisations, and the outlook in regard to them. In the Encyclical, Rerum Novarum, we find this in paragraph 42 under the head of Trade Unions:

"The most important of all are workingmen's unions; for these virtually include all the rest. History attests what excellent results were brought about by the artificers' guilds of olden times. They were the means of affording not only many advantages to the workmen, but in no small degree of promoting the advancement of art, as numerous monuments remain to bear witness. Such unions should be suited to the requirements of tills our age — an age of wider education, of different habits, and of far more numerous requirements in daily life. It is gratifying to know that there are actually in existence not a few associations of this nature, consisting either of workmen alone, or of workmen and employers together; but it were greatly to be desired that they should become more numerous and more efficient. We have spoken of them more than once; yet it will bewell to explain here how notably they are needed, to show that they exist of their own right, and what should be their organisation and their mode of action."

It is one of the distinguishing features of trade unions, as pointed out there, that they have in no small degree promoted the advancement of art, and on another side have become more numerous as well as more efficient. I say that this Bill is not worthy to be classed with the other Trade Union Acts, because Section 6 of it completely wipes out any of the smaller unions that would naturally be so close knit with regard to the organisation of their personnel that they would give a, contribution to art: that they would be craft unions in the sense that we spoke of craft unions. In paragraph 34 of the same Encyclical we find that:

"When work people have recourse to a strike it is frequently because the hours of labour are too long or the work too hard, or because they consider their wages insufficient."

Because a union is a craft union is no reason why it should be prevented from dealing with some of the things that are most important to it.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I should like to know if the Deputy's speech is in order.

Comment on this

Do I understand that a point of order is being raised?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, as to whether the Deputy's speech is in order. The principles of the Bill may not be re-discussed on this or any other section. A dissertation on Papal Encyclicals and their relationship to this or any other Bill, is not relevant on this section; neither is it relevant to quote a subsequent section, Section 6, as a reason why Section 1 should not pass. It is against all practice to discusss Section 6 before Section 1 has, gone through.

Comment on this

Do I understand that my remarks are more applicable to Section 6 than to Section 1? Is the Chair making the point that on the lines I have pursued, and intend to pursue further, I am not in order on Section 1?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is definitely of that opinion. The Deputy is discussing the principles of Bill on the Committee Stage, principles which have been approved on Second Reading.

Comment on this

I am then left with the hope that I may be able to raise the question on Section 6.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That hope may be disappointed.

Comment on this

Is the Chair ruling that I am out of order on Section 1?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Decidedly.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That Section 7, as amended, stand part of the Bill."

Tá 52
·
Níl 36
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

On this section, I find myself in difficulties. There are some amendments down here in the names as of members of the Labour Party——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These amendments were tabled to Section 3, not to Section 2.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Section 3. Is amendment No. 1 being moved?

Comment on this

Not moved.

Comment on this

Section 2 has not been put yet.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Section 2 has been passed.

Comment on this

No positive vote was recorded for Section 2.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I put the section twice; there was no demur.

Comment on this

You reminded Deputy Mulcahy that the amendment referred to Section 3, but we did not hear Section 2 being put.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Section 2 was put to the House and agreed to, but, if Deputies so desire, I shall put the question again.

Comment on this

We desire to have a vote on it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 53
·
Níl 35
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

As I say, I find myself rather in a difficulty owing to the fact that some amendments were put down in the names of members of the Labour Party that might have been put down by members of our Party if these amendments were not already in. Now these amendments are not being moved. I take it that the circumstances in which these amendments are not being moved will accentuate the position brought about by the unfortunate way in which the Bill has been conceived and the manner in which it has been presented to the House by the Minister. If the Bill were a serious Bill which was going to be implemented, and which could be expected to do anything Jor workers, or as between workers and employers, I should like to see an amendment in here governing the regulations, so that regulations dealing with important matters would not simply be passed by the Minister and then be left in a position in which they were unchallenged or unchallengeable by the House. It just indicates, however, the spirit in which the Minister prepares his Bill, that, when he takes power to make regulations dealing with the tribunal and the fees to be paid by trade unions for this, that and the other thing, he so drafts his Bill as to exclude both Houses of the Oireachtas from any say by challenge of any kind, in the regulations he proposes to make. It is characteristic of the whole spirit in which the Bill is prepared.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 52
·
Níl 35
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

May I express the very mild protest, that no matter how this conspiracy of silence may have begun, whether out of pique or anything else, in the interests of Government, of Parliament, of the country and of Irish trade unionism, it should not continue? What good, and how much harm, is being done by a Bill, of the gravity of this Bill, being passed, section by section, without the Minister thinking it worth his while to give one word of explanation of the section, without even thinking it worth his while to move the section? I do not care — I have no knowledge of — what the reactions of this Bill may be, but surely it is unfair to expect Parliament to be regarded as a serious and responsible body if it is to pass a Bill that may have very serious reactions, without getting an explanation from the author of the Bill as to the meaning of the different sections which he is moving. It is quite another matter whether amendments are moved or not, but the Dáil and the country are entitled to get a clear, brief statement from the Minister as to the meaning of each section. We have now passed three sections of this Bill, just like three votes of condolence, passed in silence. We are now up against the fourth section, the one that naturally hangs out of the three votes of condolence — the burial expenses of Irish trade unionism. We are asked in this section to vote the money out of public funds for the expenses of working this Bill. Does anybody know, if the Bill is to go through in the present atmosphere of bad feeling, what the expenses may be? Even though we may lightly talk of the burial expenses of Irish trade unionism, it may very well include the burial expenses of Irish trade unionists.

Now, this is a Bill that was introduced originally as a Bill to bring about peace in Irish industry. Let us make all allowances for the Minister and say that he believed that statement when he made it. Let us say that he was misinformed by alleged representatives or spokesmen of the trade union movement. Speaking from an entirely detached position, I have seen, and can see, every trade unionist, and every man associated with trade unionism without being one himself, violently, bitterly and angrily opposed to this Bill.

I have not, outside of that bench opposite, heard any voice raised in favq|ir of the Bill. Now, I do not expect the Minister to do a somersault at this stage, but as one Deputy, with a certain sense of responsibility and a certain respect for this House, and hoping that people outside of it will develop equal respect, I think that this silence on the part of the Minister should, and must, cease, and that some brief explanation must be ghen of sections requiring explanation. On the Money Resolution — there was a certain amount of heat in connection with it — the Minister was pressed to give a brief outline of the possible, probable, or likely expenses. We are now asked lo adopt the machinery, in this section, for issuing those expenses, and I think that some explanation should be given to the House on a section of this kind.

Comment on this

I have been asked to explain Section 4 of this Bill. I have too much respect for this House and too much respect for the intelligence of the members of the House to think that there is any one of them who requires an explanation of Section 4, the meaning of which must be plain to any person who can read. The section states that "the expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act shall, to such extent as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance, be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas." That is just the usual section which one finds in a Bill of this sort.

Comment on this

I do not know BO much as to that, but as a medical man I am anxious 10 find out if the Minister is able to speak.

Comment on this

Could the Minister inform me what it is expected the measure will cost?

Comment on this

That was dealt with on the Money Resolution.

Comment on this

But would the Minister be good enough to mention it again?

Comment on this

As the matter was dealt with on the Money Resolution, Sir, I do not propose to deal with it again.

Comment on this

It may have been dealt with on the Money Resolution but, unfortunately, I was not able to be present at the time and therefore had no opportunity of hearing the in formation, if it was given. I am asking the Minister to be good enough to give the information again.

Comment on this

I dealt with that matter on the discussion on the Money Resolution and I do not propose to reopen it.

Comment on this

I am only asking for information. How much — is it expected that this measure will cost in a year? Surely, as a Deputy, I am entitled to ask for and get that information? Surely I am entitled to get that information on this point? If the Minister will not reply, might I ask you, Sir, if you have found out the amount, to let me know what it is?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am sorry I cannot give the Deputy the information, as I was not in the Chair at the time.

Comment on this

So there are two of us in the same position. I am asking, and I think I should be told definitely, what the measure is likely to cost in a year.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The motion, I understand, is for a sum not exceeding £1,000.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 49
·
Níl 30
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

We have finished Part I. I think we might proceed better with the discussion of this Bill if we could get rid of the present atmosphere. I would like to move that the House adjourn for an hour for a meal.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot accept that. I cannot agree to it.

Comment on this

The Minister would not disagree?

Comment on this

It is now 6.10 p.m. and we are apparently faced with a night of divisions. I think even such discussion as is likely to take place on this Bill would steer itself back into more reasoned channels if we could have a cessation of work for an hour. I should like to ask if you would accept a motion to adjourn for a meal?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

So far as the Chair is concerned, there is no question for such a motion. In the absence of an arrangement with the Whips, I do not think it is practicable.

Comment on this

I do not see any reason for an adjournment. There has been no heat in the discussion on this Bill as far as I am concerned. I do not think I have impeded legitimate discussion in any way, and I do not think there is any necessity for the House to adjourn for an hour in order that other sections of the House may approach the Bill in a better frame of mind. After all, I am not responsible for the fact that members of the House have seen fit to divide on the question a& to whether this Act may be cited as the Trade Union Act, 1941, nor am I responsible for the fact that, with all the problems with which the country has to contend, members have seen fit to challenge a division on the issue that the expression "the Minister" means the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Those are the matters upon which the House has been divided, but the House has not been divided by the Government.

Comment on this

It does not matter whether you pass the Bill or not. Pass a dozen Bills like it, and nobody will take any notice of you or of them. There will be a different kind of division after this, if you are still Minister.

Comment on this

You would not accept a motion to adjourn for a meal?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think in the absence of agreement——

Comment on this

The Minister does not disagree.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The motion should be carried by agreement if it is to be effective.

Comment on this

The majority of his members are outside the House, not inside it.

Comment on this

They are standing to attention.

Comment on this

And he will not talk inside the House.

Comment on this

I move that we report progress and adjourn for an hour.

Comment on this

I hardly think I can agree to that.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister will let us drink tea?

Comment on this

If the Deputy is anxious to obstruct the Bill, he may move that motion and further obstruct the House.

Comment on this

Deputies cannot now drink tea except with the permission of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

In the absence of agreement it is only waste of time to put the motion.

Comment on this

Have you not power to take a motion, Sir? You are not obliged to get the agreement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is within my competence to take such a motion if the House wishes, but I think in the absence of any well-defined agreement in the House it would be waste of time to put it.

Comment on this

We are wasting the time of the House in any case with this Bill.

Comment on this

I will not press the motion.

SECTION 5.

Comment on this
Division

Question again put: That Section 2 stand part of the Bill.

Tá 48
·
Níl 33
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 5:—

In sub-section (3), lines 21 to 24, to delete paragraph (a) and substitute in lieu thereof the following:—

(a) a body which consists of persons who are constantly employed in a particular form of work and are constantly or continuously employed by the same employer (not being a local, authority) and which carries on negotiations for the fixing of wages or other conditions of employment with that employer only and which has been registered on application previously made to the Minister, by the Minister in a Register of excepted bodies.

I have several amendments to this section—amendments Nos. 5, 6 and 8. They are all different approaches to the same thing, in regard to the section. As I understand the section, any group of workmen who may never have met together under the same employer before may come together for the purpose of, say, a particular building scheme. Having been farm labourers before, they may come under the sway of some contractor and they, apparently, may become an excepted body right there and then. I want to put some limitation on them — the phrase I have used may not be appropriate— and the first limitation I seek is that. they shall only be an "excepted body" if they are in the habit, so to speak, of working for the same employer, and if he is in the habit of employing them; in other words, if they are workmen known to a particular employer and he is known to them.

The same idea is embodied in my second amendment, that is, more or less habitual work with the same employer, with the addition of a Parliamentary approach so that the Minister can agree that certain people will be excepted bodies. Under amendment No. 5, a group shall only be an excepted body if, having complied with certain conditions, they are registered as such. For that purpose, the Minister would have to set up a register of excepted bodies and he would have to take control and responsibility for accepting certain bodies as excepted bodies. I grant that, once that happens, the thing is brought inside the scope of the Dáil and comment can be made on it.

The other amendment I have, and I am indifferent as to which of these will be taken as long as there is some restriction put on this rather wide section, is amendment No. 8. What I want to achieve there is that no body shall be regarded as an excepted body except it deals with unorganized workers; that if there is an organised trade union catering either for the people in that locality or for workers of that type in the country generally, then it shall not be possible to have an excepted body of such workmen. The clear purpose of that is that you can only have excepted bodies where there is no real trade union organisation. As I say, I am indifferent as to which of these amendments is put in, but I should like to have some restriction put on that very easy way of being excepted entirely from the provisions.

Comment on this

I have been considering the points raised by these amendments and I am prepared to accept amendment No. 6 in principle. I think that the idea of having a register of these excepted bodies is a very good one and should be a useful safeguard As to the phraseology of amendment No. 5, I have some difficulty in accepting the words "constantly employed" or "continuously employed", but Deputy McGilligan has suggested a word which I think would meet the case. We can use the word "habitually" for both of these conditions. There might also be a question of having some registration fee, but that is a matter that could be dealt with on the Report Stage. I do not know whether it would be safe to delete the word "constantly" in the amendment as it stands and the words "constantly or continuously" and substitute the word "habitually".

Comment on this

Put in "habitually" in both places.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Does the Deputy withdraw the amendment?

Comment on this

I will put forward an amendment with the word "habitually" instead of "constantly" in the first instance and "constantly or continuously" in the second instance.

Comment on this

I will undertake to do that.

Comment on this

Then I will withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

In regard to amendment No. 7, I want to give notice that on the Report Stage I will bring in an amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

In sub-scJtion (3), page 4, to delete in line 29 the word "and", to add at the end of line 31 the word "and", and to add at the end of the sub-section a new paragraph as follows:—

(f) a body in respect of which an order under the next following sub-section of this section is for the time being in force.

This amendment is to give me power to deal with a number of bodies who do, but not as the main part of their business, occasionally have to negotiate about wages and conditions with their employers, namely, professional associations. I would propose in that regard not to grant this exemption to those bodies which do regard the strike weapon as a normal part of their armoury. In the case of bodies such as I have in mind, namely, nursing associations and professional associations, I do not see any reason why we should compel them to pay the deposit provided for in the Bill. Accordingly, I am moving the amendment to give me power to deal with bodies of that sort.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Does that not come into amendment No. 14 too?

Comment on this

Yes, amendments Nos. 10 and 14 go together.

Comment on this

I want to raise a protest as to the spirit in which the Minister is prepared to bring this in. I thought it might refer to the position of smaller unions concerned with crafts, that the Minister might be proposing to deal with them under this, but he tells us now that that is not part of the scheme, that he is simply thinking of professional bodies, such as nurses, who normally would not use the strike weapon. I thought this was a constructive amendment to the measure, but I see it is not.

Comment on this

We also have to deal with the Joint Industrial Councils.

Comment on this

I want to raise on this section a rather fundamental matter which I think properly arises on sub-section (1) of this section, that is to say, the bearing of Article 40 of the Constitution on this section and consequently on the Bill as a whole. Article 40, sub-section (6) of the Constitution provides:

"The State guarantees liberty for the exercise of the following rights subject to public order and morality."

One of those rights in sub-paragraph (3) is the right of the citizens to form associations and unions. I should like to know if the Minister and his legal advisers have considered the bearing of these particular provisions of the Constitution on the drastic proposals contained in this Bill and the implications of those proposals. In Section 6 (1) there is a definite prohibition against a body of persons, not being an excepted body, carrying on negotiations for the fixing of wages or conditions of employment unless such body is the holder of a negotiation licence. In other words, there is a very definite statutory prohibition against rhe formation of an association for purposes which have up to this been more or less the prerogative of trade unions. At all events, there is a definite prohibition against a body of citizens forming an association. I should like to hear from the Minister how he proposes to reconcile the provisions of Section 6 (1) with the definite guarantee-of what is called, in Article 40 of the Constitution, the fundamental rights of the citizens. One of the fundamental rights of citizens is to form associations subject to public order and morality.

So far as I know, this Bill is not brought in or justified by reasons referable to public order and morality. Therefore, this section, which requires certain very drastic requirements to be complied with before an association of the kind can be lawful, appears on its face to be in the teeth of the so-called guarantee in Article 40 of the Constitution. I emphasise in this connection the words "so-called guarantee", because it appears to me that this is only another instance of the cumulative effects of the policy of the proposals for legislation that have been introduced and are being introduced by the Government undermining every single fundamental right that was supposed to be guaranteed in this Constitution to the citizens of the State. The right of habeas corpus is practically gone. I say quite deliberately, and I will continue to hold the view until the Minister convinces me to the contrary, that the proposals in this Bill are in the teeth of the provisions of Article 40 of the Constitution. I suggest that the Minister or his legal advisers should have recognised that if they had adverted to the provisions of Article 40.

I am convinced that there has been no advertence to the provisions of Article 40 in reference to this Bill. If any such advertence had been made, there would have been some reference in the draft to the provisions of the Article. That attitude is again the attitude of the Government towards the provisions of the Constitution, eating into fundamental rights by ordinary legislation. I take it that an effort will be made, if this matter is considered by the Minister or his legal advisers, to justify this Bill as being a law enacted under Article 40 for the regulation or control in the public interest of the exercise of the right of the citizen to form an association or union. The only possible justification for this Bill must be found in this line —a law for the regulation and control in the public interest of the exercise of the constitutional right of citizens to form an association or union. This is not a law for the exercise of a constitutional right at all and, if this matter had been carefully considered, and an endeavour was being made to justify this Bill as a law under Article 40 regulating or controlling in the public interest the exercise of the foregoing right, some reference would surely have been made to that Article of the Constitution. No such reference has been made.

So far from this Bill and this particular sub-section being a law for the regulation and control in the public interest of the exercise of the constitutional right of citizens to form an association, this particular provision is taking away the rights of citizens. Our citizens are supposed to have rights to form associations. This is a Bill preventing them from having such rights unless two very stringent requirements are complied with. There must be a large number of people in the associations, and the associations must be sufficiently wealthy to be in a position to give the deposits mentioned in the provisions of this Bill.

You cannot have your fundamental right as a citizen — the right the Constitution so grandiloquently stated on paper — unless you are sufficiently wealthy to be able to exercise it. That is what the Bill says in so far as it can be justified at all as a law regulating or controlling in the public interest the exercise of a constitutional right.

What about the rights of the small craft unions which have been in existence for very many years, and which have been exercising a right which would appear to have been reinforced by the provisions of the Constitution? That is being taken away; it is not being regulated or controlled by this Bill. The right of such an association of craft workers, a small number of people engaged in a particular skilled employment, to look after their own interests, is not being regulated or controlled; it is being taken away. A vested right which has been in existence for many years in the case of unions dealing with skilled craftsmen is being taken away. They are being deprived of the vested right they had when the Constitution came into operation, a vested right which would appear, from the grandiloquent language of the Constitution, to have been further assured to these unions. It is now being taken away under the guise of ordinary legislation.

I think a strong case will have to be made here, and probably elsewhere, for this Bill. This particular point has not been adverted to in the discussions that have taken place, on this Bill. I am convinced there has been no advertence to Article 40 in connection with this Bill and, if any advertence is made now, it will be made on the spur of the moment by the Minister and probably by, reference to the three-line clause in Article 40. When proper consideration is given to it, the present attitude will be found to be entirely unjustified, and it will be seen that the provisions of Section 6 (1), taken in conjunction with the provisions of Section 7, are entirely unconstitutional and do not give a fair or ordinary meaning to the Constitution.

If we are to take the constitutional meaning at its face value, this Bill should never have been introduced; but we have long since learned the Government attitude towards constitutional problems and other matters when they are raised. The Constitution is then nothing but a series of coruscating words, a series of words put forward to dazzle the public at elections; but when the Government are asked to give effect to the so-called fundamental rights which are supposed to be guaranteed to the citizens, matters stop short there. Habeas corpus stops short of practical extinction; the position of the judiciary has been altered to a mere recollection of the past, and now the right of forming associations and unions is taken away to such a point that it will crumble and fall at the first shock.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

Some time ago the Minister stated that a section was so crystal-clear it was unnecessary to explain it to the House. The Minister cannot make that statement about Section 6. That section seems to me to be the strangest section which I ever read in any statute. It appears to me, under the guise of a Trade Union Bill, to slip in a provision which makes any federation of employers entirely illegal. I will read Section 6:

"It shall not be lawful for any body of persons, not being an excepted body, to carry on negotiations for the fixing of wages or other conditions of employment unless such body is the holder of a negotiation licence"

—and a negotiation licence can only be given to a trade union under Section 7. Now, to have a negotiation for wages, or any other purpose, you must nave two parties to the negotiation; you must have an employer and workmen. Trade unions may negotiate but a federation of employers cannot negotiate. In other words, a formation of employers, in a Bill calling itself a Trade Union Bill, is entirely illegal.

But it goes very much further than that. Suppose there is a limited liability company with a board of directors. They are a body of persons and they cannot carry on negotiations for the fixing of wages or other conditions of employment unless they have a negotiation licence. A board of directors of a limited liability company cannot, as I read this section, carry on negotiations with their own workmen, fixing the rate of wages or the conditions of employment.

The Minister may have some explanation or I may be very dull. There may be something standing out somewhere but, as I read the Bill, it seems to me to be hardly the product of a sane mind. I go that far. A board of directors of a limited liability company are employers of labour, but a board of directors of a railway company cannot carry on negotiations with their servants about the fixing of fair wages or hours of employment. Surely a Bill that contains a provision of that nature is hardly the product of a sane mind. Although the Minister may have some explanation, there is nothing that I can find in the Bill which takes away from the plain effect of the section, that no body can negotiate except with a negotiation licence. A negotiation licence cannot be given to a board of directors of a company or to a federation of employers except in the case of a single employer who could not be called a "body of persons". A single employer can negotiate with his workmen but a board of directors or a federation of employers cannot.

Comment on this

I question if the last contention of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney is correct, when he said that a single individual might negotiate. I do not think there is anything in Section 6 to that effect. It says that employees may negotiate but there is nothing about employers.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

The section says:

"It shall not be lawful for any body of persons...."

A single person is not a body of persons.

Comment on this

A single person does not become "an excepted body." The section makes provision for employees but does not contain any provision whereby employers could negotiate. Employers should receive the same treatment.

Comment on this

On the Second Reading I drew the Minister's attention to the position of organisations like the Federation of Irish Farmers, which is registered under the Trade Union Acts. I asked if that organisation would be affected by the Bill and the Minister stated definitely that it would not. It seems to me that that promise is not borne out by the wording of the section, Wad I would need some greater assurance than the Minister's promise that the section will not affect farmers' organisations. Any body of persons cannot carry on negotiations with regard to wages and conditions of employment. It might be necessary for organisations of farmers to discuss with labour organisations or with representatives of agricultural workers the question of wages and conditions of employment and to negotiate settlements. If this section is passed in its present form farmers' organisations would be debarred from doing so and would be heavily penalised. Conditions of employment is a wide term. Conditions of employment might mean conditions under which farmers or their dependants are employed and might cover the prices of farm produce For example, the beet growers had frequent negotiations with the Irish Sugar Company concerning the pi ice of beet. If the price were adequate that would affect the conditions of employment of persons engaged in the industry. In addition, there was in the beet industry a general strike against growing beet at an uneconomic price. Under this section the Beet Growers' Association or similar organisations would be penalised. The statement made by the Minister on the Second Reading does not safeguard farmers' organisations.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello suggested that the constitutional point had not been adverted to when the Bill was drafted. It was adverted to and we have been advised there is nothing in the Bill repugnant to the Constitution — which would be so held by the courts.

Comment on this

Why did the Minister make that change?

Comment on this

Because neither the Deputy nor I have the final determination of that matter. It does not lie with the Deputy or myself, and accordingly I am not purporting to do what the Deputy did when he spoke on behalf of a superior tribunal. As to the point made by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney concerning a group of employers negotiating, under the Bill a group of employers would not be entitled to enter into negotiations for fixing wages or settling conditions of employment unless they had a negotiation licence. That is the general intention.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

But they have not got that.

Comment on this

They can get one by applying. Of course they can register, as many of them do.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

How about the directors of a limited liability company?

Comment on this

I will look into that matter. I am advised where a company is the employer that in that case a single person who is a direct agent acting on behalf of the company would be competent to enter into negotiation. The Deputy has raised a point, however, which I will investigate. There was no substance in the point the Deputy made in relation to railway companies. They conduct their negotiations through conciliation boards, and one of the purposes of the House in accepting amendment No. 10 was to allow me to make joint industrial councils and conciliation boards excepted bodies for the purposes of the Act. I cannot understand the point made by Deputy Cogan. As a rule agricultural wages are settled between representatives of groups of persons and are fixed by the Agricultural Wages Board. The Agricultural Wages Board is definitely excepted from the provisions of Section 6 (1). I cannot understand the laborious process by which the Deputy tried to drag farmers' organisations, whose main purpose is the fixing of prices, inside the scope of this Bill. If the beet growers meet to fix prices of beet with the Sugar Company they are not going to settle the wages of workmen. Undoubtedly the price at which they sell their beet will have reactions on the wages of the workmen, and I am sure that will be taken into consideration by the Agricultural Wages Board when making its determination. I cannot see how the farmers' organisations, of which the Deputy spoke, come inside this Bill.

That was an assurance which I gave him on the Second Stage, and which still holds good. If, on the other hand, they want to constitute themselves as an employers' organisation for the purpose of negotiating wages and conditions of employment, then they will be in exactly the same position as every other association or federation of employers under this measure. They will have to register as a trade union. Some of those farmers have, in fact, registered as a trade union. Not only will they have to register as a trade union, but they will have to take the further step of making a deposit and of complying with the general provisions of the Bill in regard to the lodgment of rules, the furnishing of the names and addresses of the committee of management, etc.

Comment on this

Can a single employer get a negotiating licence?

Comment on this

I would say not, because I do not see how a single employer could register himself as a trade union.

Comment on this

Can a single employer carry on negotiations with regard to wages and conditions?

Comment on this

Yes, with his own workmen.

Comment on this

Where is that?

Comment on this

It is provided in sub-section (1) that

"It shall not be lawful for any body of persons, not being an excepted body,..."

A single employer, I suppose, could not be described as a body of persons.

Comment on this

So that an individual employer can carry on negotiations under that for the fixing of wages?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And the person so carrying on is not, then, of course, a conspirator, and could not be?

Comment on this

He could not be.

Comment on this

So that every individual employer will be completely free from trade unionism hereafter? Is not that so?

Comment on this

To the extent that every single employer under the present law is.

Comment on this

A single employer, so long as he does not associate with other employers, is completely free?

Comment on this

He is in no worse or better position than he is in at the moment.

Comment on this

He does not need a negotiating licence, and he does not need to become associated with other employers.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I do not know whether the Minister understood correctly the point I raised about a board of directors. I do not think the Minister has considered the effect of sub-section (2). If a board of directors agree to negotiate with employees and appoint, as he says, one man to do it, then according to sub-section (2), "such of the officers of such body as consent to or facilitate such act shall each be guilty of an offence under this section" and shall be liable to a fine of £10. My reading of that is, that the body, even though they act only through one particular director, is still a body acting and, consequently, the members of the board of directors would each be liable to a fine of £l0 for daring to negotiate with their own workmen as to wages and conditions of employment.

Comment on this

I do not think there is much in that point, but I shall look into it to see if we can adequately safeguard the position so as to ensure that the position the Deputy fears will not arise.

Comment on this

On the constitutional point that has been raised it is, I think, common case here, to quote the words of the Constitution, that the right of association is one that is guaranteed under the Constitution. It is also common case that that right is subject to the impact of the type of law that is passed here. As stated in the Constitution, the laws that may be passed are, more or less, for the common good as well as to regulate and control the right of association. Does not the Minister know that there is a definite exception to only one of the fundamental rights that is guarded by association, the exception being that the law to regulate and control the exercise of this right shall not be subject to any religious, political or class discrimination? We have here a measure that is definitely going to discriminate on this basis: can you put up £2,000 or not? Is that in accordance with the Constitution?

Comment on this

There are so many natural rights under the Constitution which can only be exercised when one has deposited a certain sum of money that I do not think the Deputy's point holds.

Comment on this

In regard to how many rights in the Constitution have you this prohibition — that there is to be a discrimination on the ground of class? This right of association is guaranteed by the Constitution. The Constitution forbids the passing of legislation which would have the effect of regulating or controlling it on the ground of class. Now we have this measure which regulates it on the basis of a deposit of £2,000. Is that clearly inside the spirit of the Constitution?

Comment on this

That is not class.

Comment on this

It is inside the spirit of the Constitution?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

An argument has been advanced from these benches by Deputy Costello and repeated, to some extent, by Deputy McGilligan, and the only answer the Minister gives is that he consulted somebody or other. He did not attempt to deal with the argument. I confess that, in many respects, my sympathies are with the Minister. In his words, at all events, Deputy Costello showed some respect for the Constitution. The Minister, by his words, in replying to Deputy McGilligan, did not, and I think the Minister is right, because practically all the fundamental rights which we were told by the statesman who introduced the Constitution were to be interpreted by the ordinary man in the ordinary way, and not by pettifogging lawyers, have gone. This right of combination that was guaranteed by the Constitution now goes. Our experience is that practically every other fundamental right in that Constitution has now gone. There is some slight guarantee, I think, with regard to religion, but it is very slight, and is not by any means as broad as some people think. The right with regard to class distinctions is now wiped away. The only thing guaranteed by the Constitution that is left at the present moment is the number of members that there shall be in the Seanad. One after another all the fundamental principles have been wiped away. In fact, to incorporate rights in the Constitution has become as dangerous to these rights as, say, the forming of a treaty of friendship is in international politics. The Minister has clearly expressed by his words, by his actions and by his smile his supreme contempt for that instrument. Really I have a certain amount of sympathy with the line he has taken up in this particular matter.

Comment on this

The Minister said, in reply to a suggestion I made, that when this Bill was being drafted there was no real advertence to the provisions of the Constitution. He said that the points I made were adverted to, and left the matter at that. It would appear to me to be quite obvious that, although he was suggesting to the House that there was advertence by somebody to Article 40 of the Constitution, that he himself never adverted to it. If I am to judge by the manner in which the Minister treated the point which I put up to him — I did so in all seriousness — he has not the remotest idea about the serious position that is going to be created by the provisions of this Bill in its impact on the Constitution. I think I stated that the whole tendency of legislation here since the Constitution came into force was towards the undermining of these so-called fundamental rights.

One may almost say that the rags and tatters of these rights are scarcely left. I do say that the point I put up was, at least, deserving of being treated with some degree of seriousness, because it is one which is going to affect, very seriously, the type of legislation that may follow in reference to this particular right. It was argued by counsel appearing for the present Government in certain constitutional matters that the courts had to take cognisance of the fact, when the Legislature passed a particular law, that it considered whether or not it was contrary to the Constitution — that the mere fact that the Legislature had passed that law was something of which the courts ought to take cognisance. If we pass this law without adverting to the Constitution, that principle may, possibly, be extended. There is no reason why, if this is not contrary to Article 40 of the Constitution, the right to strike might not also he taken away under the Constitution. If this section, regulating the method by which associations may be formed, is constitutional, then a law dealing with the right to strike or to picket, or any other right in connection with matters that fall within the scope of trade unions in their efforts for the betterment of wages and conditions, may also be constitutional. If this Bill is constitutional, a Bill to take away the right to picket or to strike would be equally constitutional. That is a matter of very considerable importance, and it should not be thrust lightly aside by the Minister.

Comment on this

The single net point which Deputy Costello made several times in connection with this section was that Section 6 of Article 40 of the Constitution had not been adverted to. I am now looking at a document — I hope he will take my word for it— dated 19th November, 1940, in which that matter was specifically referred for legal opinion and advice.

Comment on this

That is no answer to the argument which has been adduced. The Minister has not met the argument. He has simply stated that he got the opinion of somebody. The suggestion is that the House should not consider the matter at all.

Comment on this

I have not made that suggestion.

Comment on this

I did not say that the Minister had made the suggestion in words but he has done so by his conduct. Deputy Costello quoted the relevant Articles of the Constitution, and put forward reasons to show why this section was opposed to the Constitution. The Minister has not met a single argument put forward by Deputy Costello. He has simply stated that he has the opinion of somebody on the subject. It is not those people who are passing the law; it is the House which is supposed to be debating this Bill. We have already had a number of examples of how the House is being helped to debate the Bill, which involves many fundamental issues. I admit that the Minister is consistent in refusing to touch on the arguments raised.

Comment on this

I accept the Minister's statement that advertence was had to this point, but I want to know whether it was properly and adequately adverted to. I have said before here that there is no use in flinging the magic phrase "legal opinion" at Deputies. A legal opinion is worth only the grounds or reasons given for it. If these are not proper grounds, then the opinion is of no use. There is no substance in the phrase "legal opinion". I do not know whose opinion was obtained and I am not particularly interested to know that. I assume that the opinion was that there was nothing unconstitutional in this Bill. Assuming that that was so, I want to have the grounds for that opinion. I am not in the least interested in the statement that an opinion was given. I want to test that opinion, now that we have a chance of testing it. An opinion is not worth the paper it is written on unless the grounds on which it is given are good grounds. The House is entitled to knew these grounds.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

What is the cause of the Minister's shyness? If he has an opinion and reasons are put forward for that opinion, the Minister is capable of mastering those reasons and reproducing them in the House, either in his own words or in the words of the opinion which has been given to him. Why his shyness? The Minister is not, normally, a remarkably shy man. One would have thought that the Minister was not altogether wanting in self-confidence. Why is the Minister overwhelmed with a fit of shyness on this occasion? Why will he not give to the House the arguments advanced, if arguments were advanced and if it were not a mere negative opinion larking argumentative form?

Comment on this

Under Section 6, as drafted, could two employers become an excepted body?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

Is not that class discrimination? Two employees can become an excepted body but two employers cannot.

Comment on this

I doubt whether two employers could become an excepted body for the purpose of negotiating jointly with their employees.

Comment on this

There is something in this Bill which allows a facility to two employees which it does not allow to two employers. Is not that class discrimination?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

As regards the use of this word "employment", a person could be employed, though not working for an employer. A farmer producing beet is employed in the production of beet. If an organisation on his behalf carried on negotiations in regard to price, that organisation is carrying on negotiations in regard to the conditions of employment of people engaged in the production of beet. If there were a strike of agricultural producers, it could be held that that was a strike in connection with conditions of employment and the organisation could be penalised under this section.

Comment on this

It is quite plain that there is not much use in discussing anything with the Minister.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 47
·
Níl 33
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 16:—

In sub-section (1), to delete paragraph (b), lines 42 to 44.

The clause which the amendment aims at deleting deals with one of the conditions that must obtain before a body of persons shall be granted a negotiation licence, namely that it has deposited and, subject to the provisions of this Bill, keeps deposited, with the accountant of the courts of justice the appropriate sum, the appropriate sum being not less than £2,000. We have not been able up to the present to get any clear idea of what is intended by this Bill. We have got no idea as to how small craft unions are going to stand: we have got no idea as to the particular classes that will be regarded as separate classes for the purpose of a trade union and, generally, we have got no idea of the principles that are working in the Minister's mind. Even if this Bill were a serious Bill, intended to achieve serious piece of organisation, it does not seem at the present time, and until the preliminary movements in that organisation had taken place, that it is desirable to impose any property qualifications on any trade union.

The one point I wish to make is that it is an extraordinarily inappropriate time that the Minister selects to require a property qualification for a group of workers who want to act as a negotiating body for themselves and for their class. I think the last figures that have been published for registered unemployment in the country show that the number of persons unemployed at present is within 3,000 of the total number of persons unemployed a year ago. My recollection is that the relative figures are 60,000 and 63,000.

In spite of the thousands of men who have gone into the Army and who have gone out of the country, the unemployment position here at present is such that the number of registered unemployed is within 3,000 of what it was 12 months ago, before the big Army recruiting drive started and before the large body of men who left the country within the past 12 months had gone away. It is that very inappropriate time that the Minister selects to say that organised workers shall be required to have a property qualification, to have not less than £2,000 before the State will recognise them as people capable of looking after the interests of their class in respect of wages, conditions of employment and so on. If the Bill were a serious Bill, designed to do something for the workers, there is no necessity for this qualification. As a matter of fact, it would be most undesirable to have it because, before the ground could be reviewed, before it could be established that some of these smaller bodies were not absolutely necessary or desirable as negotiating bodies, they would be forced out of their positions as negotiating bodies since they had not this money to put up.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present: House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

The discussion of Section 6 disclosed that the proposals generally with regard to negotiating bodies and the limitations on them are somewhat unconstitutional. It also disclosed the ramshackle way in which the provisions of the Bill are put together, but I want to add, in relation to what is proposed in Section 7, that it is contrary to the great Christian aspect of the Constitution which is so often spoken of and to the spirit which is supposed to have been enshrined in it. On Section 1, I quoted an extract from Rerum Novarum, and I now want to quote from Quadragesimo Anno. In paragraphs 79 and 80 of that Encyclical we find these words:

"It is indeed true, as history clearly proves, that owing to changed circumstances much that was formerly done by small groups can nowadays only be done by large associations. None the less, just as it is wrong to withdraw from the individual and commit to a group what private enterprise and industry can accomplish, so too it is an injustice, a grave evil and a disturbance of right order, for a larger and higher association to arrogate to itself functions which can be performed efficiently by smaller and lower societies. This is a fundamental principle of social philosophy, unshaken and unchangeable. Of its very nature the true aim of all social acthity should be to help members of the social body but never to destroy or absorb them.

"The State, therefore, should leave to smaller groups the settlement of business of minor importance, which otherwise would greatly distract it; it will thus carry out with greater freedom, power and success the tasks belonging to it alone, because it alone can effectively accomplish these: directing, watching, stimulating, restraining, as circumstances suggest and necessity demands. Let those in power, therefore, be convinced that the more faithfully this principle of suhsidiary function be followed, and a graded hierarchical order exists between various associations, the greater will be both social authority and social efficiency, and the happier and more prosperous the condition of the commonwealth.

This proposal to make bodies of workers deposit £2,000 before they can enter into any negotiations in respect of wages and conditions of service of their workers cuts entirely across die principle enshrined in that paragraph, which emphasises that the principle is a fundamental principle of social philosophy, unshaken and unchangeable.

I should like to hear from the Minister what is proposed with regard to these smaller craft societies, those societies which can be regarded as being referred to in the paragraph which I quoted from Rerum Novarum, that they were the means of affording not only many advantages to the workman, but, in no small degree, of promoting the advancement of art as numerous monuments remain to bear witness. The Minister is interested in technical efficiency, industrial efficiency and craftsmanship, and if we are going to succeed in the modern world in keeping our industries in the position both of serving the country and of facing up to competition, we must have a spirit of craftsmanship in our people. Where is that to come from except from those who are associated in craft unions, and what is going to become of our craft unions, the personal sense of craftsmanship which you can find only in these unions and the development of their craft technique which can only come from inside these unions, if they sue to be denied the right to act as spokesmen for their members in respect of conditions and other matters which are of such importance to them? Anything we can read into this Bill shows that they are either going to be wiped out of existence or smothered by the larger unions. The paragraph of the Encyclical which I quoted says:—

"Just as it is wrong to withdraw from the individual and commit to group what private enterprise and industry can accomplish, so, too, it is an injustice, a grave evil and a disturbance of right order for a larger and higher association to arrogate to itself functions which can be performed efficiently by smaller and lower societies."

So far as we can find out, we have not demands by some of the larger trade unions that they should be allowed to arrogate to themselves the functions of the craft unions, but we have the State forcibly driving the craft unions out of existence or into the larger unions, where that individualism, so essential for industrial efficiency and for the keeping up of a high standard of craftsmanship, is likely to be smothered. The Minister has not given us any answer to that.

Again, in paragraph 87 of the same Encyclical, we have these words:—

"Just as the citizens of the same township are wont to form associations with very diverse aims, which each citizen is perfectly free to join or not, similarly, those who are engaged in the same trade or profession will form equally voluntary associations among themselves, for purposes connected in some way with their occupation. Our Predecessor of illustrious memory has explained clearly and lucidly the nature of these voluntary associations. We are content, therefore, to emphasise this one point: not only is man free to institute these unions which are of a private character, but he has `the further right to adopt such rules and regulations as may best conduce to the attainment of the end in view'. The same liberty must be asserted for the founding of associations which extend beyond the limits of a single trade or profession. Let those voluntary associations which already nourish and produce salutary fruits make it the goal of their endeavours, in accordance with Christian social doctrine, to prepare the way and to do their best towards the realisation of those higher corporations or vocational groups which We have mentioned above."

We have a Vocational Commission sitting at the present time. They have been sitting for a very long period, and I think that for some time past they have finished the taking of evidence. and we are waiting for their report.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy purposes to be speaking on amendment No. 16.

Comment on this

I am speaking to amendment No. 16 which, under the terms of Section 7, would put completely out of existence the smaller trade union organisations which have been built up around a particular craft and which would be wiped out of existence. I do not know by what kind of a scheme, but by some kind of a manipulation that could be brought about inside of six months after the passing of this Bill, and, apart from the desirability of seeing that there was a proper examination of the situation in order to harmonise these bodies in the best possible way with one another and to get the kind of structural organisation that is referred to here, actually an inquiry has been going on to see what kind of dovetailing of these organisations had best be brought about in order to serve the State socially, industrially and in every other way. I am making the point that by the passing of this business now, not only are we flying against the spirit of the Constitution, not only are we flying into the imbecilities of which Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney speaks, but we are flying, in a hurried way and without satisfactory examination, directly contrary to the principles that have been expounded in the Encyclicals that we hear talked about so much.

I think that, before passing this provision requiring associations to make a deposit of £2,000 before being heard and before being allowed to continue as persons with any power or responsibility to negotiate conditions of employment, we should have some idea. either from some kind of an exposition from the Minister or through getting the report or some information from the commission that has already been dealing with this matter, as to what exactly is going to be done with regard to these smaller unions. This says: "Wipe them out" because the smaller unions have not the £2,000 to be put in. So that in this section we are moving against our own Constitution and we are moving against the whole spirit of Catholic thought as enshrined in the various Encyclicals, that have been issued over a number of years by the Holy See, dealing with the organisation of working-men's societies, and I do riot think we should do that. I think, therefore, that if this Bill is to be proceeded with, that qualification should come out, so that such societies as exist here can continue to exist while the manipulation of this Bill is going ahead, and that they will not be turned down as useful societies in the country simply because they have not got £2,000.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy press the amendment?

Comment on this

Certainly, Sir. Has the Minister anything to say as to why I should not press it?

Comment on this

I said it all on the Second Reading.

Comment on this

Does the Minister say that he dealt with this matter on the Second Reading?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Will he say what is to become of these smaller societies?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be good enough to tell me the names of some of these craft unions about which he has been so eloquent?

Comment on this

In the framing of this Bill, has the Minister given any consideration to these smaller craft unions, or has he considered the terms of this amendment?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy be good enough to mention the names of some of them?

Comment on this

If the Minister now pretends not to be aware of the existence of these smaller unions, probably a little reminder will recall their existence to his memory, because lie spoke of them on the Second Reading. Speaking on the Second Reading the Minister said: "It has been said that it may affect small unions, craftunions and trades councils. Of course it will affect them. It will affect all of them in some measure." That is what the Minister said then. Does he say now that he is not aware of the existence of these craft unions?

Comment on this

No, but I want to test Deputy Mulcahy's knowledge of them.

Comment on this

The Minister at that time said that the Bill will affect all of them in some measure, and Deputy Morrissey intervened to say: "It will wipe them out." The Minister then went on to say:—

"Those which are not fit to survive as independent entities will either have to go completely out of existence or will have to unite, in some way or other, with other trade unions or with other labour organisations."

Comment on this

Yes

Comment on this

Very good. Yet, having said that, the Minister is now affecting not to know that there were craft organisations in this country.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I wanted to see if Deputy Mulcahy could name the craft organisations about which he was so eloquent.

Comment on this

Well, the Minister has not shown himself to be sufficiently acquainted with the matters affected by this Bill to set himself up as an examiner of any Deputy in that regard. It is notorious that there are and have been for a very, very long time past, craft unions in this country, and it is equally notorious that the imposition of this deposit of £2,000 will seriously affect them, if not wipe them out of existence. During his speech on the Second Reading the Minister went on to say that it was well known that there were rivalries and jealousies between these small unions and large unions and that that had been the cause of a great deal of the industrial unrest and the unnecessary industrial strife in this country. I had challenged the Minister on that earlier in the debate and had asked him if he would get the statistics, published by his Department from time to time, as to the number of working hours and the amount of money lost to trade and industry as a result of strikes over a number of years, and endeavour to make some estimate of what the rivalry of small trade unions caused in that way.

We waited for an answer to that, but we did not get an answer. All we got was to the effect that it was well known that it was the rivalry of small trade unions that had been the cause of a great deal of the industrial unrest and unnecessary industrial strife in this country. Now, I am not aware that that is the fact. I know that people, who are more intimate with trade union conditions than I can pretend to be, have denied that, and denied it very vehemently.

Comment on this

The contrary is the case.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Minister knows that if he had two points of view before him, he is going to accomplish one of them here. He had a point of view with regard to overlapping activities and a point of view about the two great strengths of trade unions, as far as their numbers were concerned. As far as overlapping is concerned, there are later sections of the Bill dealing with that, and there would be no requirements with regard to a deposit if all that was thought necessary in the interests of peace was to see that there would not be overlapping. However, the Minister achieves a lessened number of trade unions hereafter and, up to date, has not made any real argument to prove that that is necessary in the interests of peace. He has made a case which is false or which, I think, at least, he must know to be false, and that is that it is the rivalry and jealousies of the smaller and older trade unions that have caused industrial unrest and unnecessary industrial strife. That habeen denied here in the House and it has been denied outside the House by people who must be presumed to be competent to deal with the matter and to be conversant with conditions. If the Minister denies that he has made a false representation to the House, what is the purpose then? Of course some people in the country can see some good in the measure from the machinery point of view, but the modern tendency is rather to shrink back in horror from the great machine or the great organisation. At one time there was a tendency towards the conception of the great, monster corporation, the monster union, the monster State, and so on, but people are rather in retreat from that conception now and are getting back to the dissipation of the great forces and great organisations towards the smaller groups, as being more definitely and closely related to the interests of the people they serve, the general idea being that the smaller groups can be expected to have more responsibility and to cause less unrest or strife in anything that they may be governing or connected with.

I suggest that this is an unwise provision. It is the kernel of the Bill so far as the reduction in the numerical strength of trade unions in the country is concerned. I have seen no real reason advanced for it. The Minister did not refer to this point in his opening statement, and I have read what he said in his closing remarks, and, except for what I have quoted, that matter was not dealt with, and my suggestion is that the phrase the Minister used there makes the false case. This is the kernel of the Bill, and why should it be insisted upon? If the Minister has no case, that he can substantiate with figures, that the strength of these smaller unions has contributed to any extent to industrial unrest, then he has no case for insisting on this deposit. If the effect is that the small union, as a separate entity, will disappear, and if it is going to preserve its existence in some sort of hidden or secret way by joining up with a larger body, then the Minister will have to contemplate that, with the greater body, the people who were formerly members of two separate craft unions will find themselves involved. What was the larger body going to do in these circumstances? Does the Minister think he is going to get rid of unrest by simply driving back behind the scenes of the trade union movement the rivalries and the jealousies that he talks of? Does he think that a small union is going to get its interests properly served by being submerged in the bigger union? If he does not, is he not cutting at the roots of the trade union movement? Is not the principle of the trade union movement being broken when people are asked to cohere when they have strength in their movement? The Minister is going to weaken their effort. He is going to take away from the possible effect of any sort of cohesion for that purpose, and going to make the trade union system languish. Under this Bill a whole lot of people of diverse interests will be put in the control of folk who have not their association for the particular type of work and who, therefore, cannot be expected to carry out negotiations with anything like the same intelligence, the same point or the same strength as these smaller unions had themselves. Incidentally, if a bigger trade union, enclosing some of the smaller people in its ranks, is going to take up every quarrel which the smaller unions would have previously taken up, it only means that disputes that were localised are going to be conducted by the big union, and you are going to have instead of localisation, a spread of the trouble.

I suggest to the Minister the whole thing is not merely contrary to the current of modern thought, not merely contrary to the quotations Deputy Mulcahy has given from the documents that he has relied upon, but is contrary to the view of most people who have at all studied the conditions in industrial life in the big countries. The movement in other countries which have suffered even much more severely from trade union strife than we have is definitely in the other direction, trying to net away from monster unions, trying to have people grouped in such small associations that any dispute is brought home intimately to them. In addition, their resources not being so big, the likelihood of their indulging in the last resource — it is the last resource of the trade union movement— the strike weapon, will be minimised. The Minister is doing a thing which I think in his own time he will live to regret. Apart from any external causes there may be in regard to the way in which the measure is being proceeded with, he will live to regret the principle he is standing for in insisting upon this particular deposit.

Comment on this

I have been challenged consistently throughout this debate to adduce evidence of the need for the proposals which are in this Bill. It has been suggested to me that I cannot produce any evidence that the smaller unions have been the cause of a great deal of the industrial difficulties with which we have been confronted, and I have said that one of the things which I hope to do by this Bill, and perhaps particularly by the section which we are now discussing, is to compel an amalgamation of the smaller unions. I have asked Deputy Mulcahy, who has been talking about the craft unions, to mention some of those which he thinks would be compelled to amalgamate under this Bill. He has not been able to do it. I do not think the Deputy knows what he is talking about. I do not think the Deputy knows what he is talking about when he attempts to deny the fact that it is commonly held by, I think, the majority of trade unions that a great deal of trouble in the trade union movement and a great deal of the industrial strife in this country arises from the jealousies which do exist between certain labour organisations, among whom I would put as the principal offenders in that regard these smaller unions.

Comment on this

Using the Minister's own tactics, may I ask him to give an example?

Comment on this

I am not making that statement without having a great deal of support for it inside the trade union movement itself. I have here a ropy of a memorandum — and, Sir, I propose to table the whole of this document — which was presented to the Commission of Inquiry into the Irish Trade Union Movement on, I think, the 25th April, 1936. I do not propose to read the whole of the document but, as I have said, I will table the document and any member who wishes to learn more about this business of trade union organisation and trade union rivalry and to appreciate the problem which the Government is endeavouring to tackle — the trade union movement itself having signally failed to do anything about it — can read it at his leisure. In the course of the memorandum it is stated:—

"At the outset it must be realised that the complete implementation of item (1) of the Terms of Reference means largely recasting the whole trade union movement. That some recasting is desirable cannot be doubted. A more modern and more compact trade union movement is necessary all will agree. To attain that necessary and desirable end there is a large number of technical difficulties to be surmounted, which could be done with time and good will. Preliminary inquiries, however, point almost unerringly to the fact that amongst the trade unions, whose overlapping makes them ripe for amalgamation or association, there yet appears to exist a great diffidence to merging into more comprehensive industrial organisations....

Craft differences.— Craft or trade union pride and rivalries tend to keep alive animosities, which militate against comradeship and association.

"Furthermore, it must be remembered that the internecine quarrelling of the trade unions weakens them, not alone physically but it also vitiates them morally. This great evil can never be eradicated while the organic existence of the trade unions is confined to and dictated by the accidental divisions of trade, commerce or occupation. Neither can legislative interference to end those inter-union differences be ignored."

Legislation of this sort in fact was quite clearly forecast by the trade union movement itself in the year 1936 when it, having been given a chance to put its house in order, realised that public opinion in tins country was not going to stand for the continuance of the present abuses.

"The position of the organised trade union movement, as represented by the Irish Trade Union Congress, cannot be considered satisfactory, either from the point of view of the numbers organised or the manner in which the whole trade union movement is split up into some very small and often opposing unions.

This memorandum goes on to say:—

"Co-existent with the unions affiliated to Congress there is also a large number of local unions affiliated to the several trades' or workers' councils, and which, as trade union units, are unknown officially to Congress. The condition of affairs disclosed indicates a great necessity for clarification, if order is to be brought out of the existing chaos.

The commission kept strictly to their terms of reference, and considered a suggestion for amalgamating or merging the various unions within fairly clearly defined industrial demarcations.

This suggestion contemplates the re-casting of the whole trade union movement into the following ten industrial union groupings, which it is claimed can adequately accommodate and cater for the industrial workers of the country."

Then they recite those groups.

Comment on this

Will the Minister recite the groups for us?

Comment on this

Certainly. They are: (1) building and furnishing; (2) engineering. shipbuilding and vehicle building; (3) seamen and dockers; (4) rail and road transport; (5) printing; (6) bakery; (7) distributive, clerical and supervisory; (8) teachers; (9) Civil service; and (10) general workers. I am not advocating that classification. I am not interfering with the rights of the unions to make their own associations and to frame their own relations with each other inside the movement. I am merely, by means of the section which we are now discussing, compelling the trade union movement as a whole and in all its details to consider this question of amalgamation, and to consider it seriously, and to act upon it. The memorandum from which I am reading goes on to say:—

"Again, there is the question of the fairly large number of workers who are in small local unions affiliated to trades' or workers' councils. Many of such unions are entirely too small and financially weak to affiliate with Congress. Such unions cannot be left out in any reorganisation which may take place. They must be absorbed in the general reorganisation in their appropriate industrial setting.

In interpreting the terms of reference on the above lines the commission were fully cognisant...."

Perhaps this paragraph which I am now reading explains a great deal of the agitation which has been worked up in the City of Dublin in the last three or four weeks; I should like the House to hear it and consider it, and I should like the people outside this House and the workers of this city to consider it also. This paragraph goes on:—

"In interpreting the terms of reference on the above lines the commission were fully cognisant of all the great difficulties inherent in the proposals, not the least of which difficulties to be encountered will be the fitting into compatible office the various officials who will have to be moved about on the reorganisation."

The memorandum goes on to say:—

"The elimination of inter-union disputes, if nothing else were secured, will bring relief to all concerned. Such disputes do a tremendous disservice to trade unionism and militate against that progress which should now be manifesting itself in the movement."

I say that in that memorandum there is evidence, there is ample support and ample justification for the proposal contained in Section 7 of this Bill. But it is not only in that memorandum that we will find that support and justification.

Comment on this

Before the Minister leaves the memorandum, is that a report of the commission or is it a memorandum submitted to the commission?

Comment on this

This is a memorandum which, I understand, was endorsed by no less than five of the members of the commission of inquiry.

Comment on this

What were the members' names?

Comment on this

I am not giving them. The Deputy will get them in the Report.

Comment on this

It was not endorsed by a majority of the commission?

Comment on this

Not by a majority of the commission. I think the Deputy took care to see that there was not a majority. The Deputy was a member of that commission.

Comment on this

Is it a minority report of the commission or a memorandum submitted to it?

Comment on this

It is a memorandum which received the greatest body of support inside the commission.

Comment on this

And it was rejected by Congress subsequently.

Comment on this

But it had received the greatest body of support.

Comment on this

You know nothing about the thing at all.

Comment on this

I think that that memorandum supports the proposals contained in this section, and I now go on to read from another memorandum:

"The following memorandum (III) has been approved by one member of the commission:

"While I ardently support the principle of trade union amalgamation and recognise its efficacy as a weapon of protection to the organised workers, I regret I am unable to subscribe to the recommendations contained in Memorandum 1 on the subject of industrial grouping. I would welcome a reorganisation of the unions as they exist to-day. I would welcome a reorganisation of the unions with a view to avoiding the wasteful overlapping and baneful jealousy and rivalry which exists to-day.... I would prefer to see the question approached from the standpoint of examining the possibility of effecting grouping of unions in industries where, owing to the multiplicity of unions and the consequent weakness of organisation due to inter-union strife, the advantages of amalgamation are clearly demonstrable and the necessity for it more readily appreciated."

Whatever else may be said about Section 7, it does undoubtedly compel every one of those unions to whom the author of Memorandum III referred to give their most careful consideration now to the question of amalgamating inside the trade union movement.

Comment on this

This is tyrannising them, not amalgamating them.

Comment on this

I am not tyrannising them, but I am compelling them to do what the author of Memorandum III stated he would welcome.

Comment on this

I wrote that memorandum, and I know more about it than the Minister knows.

Comment on this

Of course the Deputy knows a great deal about it, but I am wondering why the Deputy — who would have welcomed a reorganisation of the trade union movement in 1936, who is on record as saying that he, would welcome a reorganisation of the unions as they exist to-day, who stated that he would welcome a reorganisation of the unions with a view to avoiding the wasteful overlapping and baneful jealousy and rivalry which exists to-day——

Comment on this

This is not reorganisation; it is strangulation — and the Minister knows it well — to be done in the interests of the "boss" class in the country.

Comment on this

——has put himself at the head of the Moscow Fifth Column in this country.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That remark should be withdrawn, as it has implications which should not be made.

Comment on this

In view of the opinion expressed by the Chair I am withdrawing the remark.

Comment on this

That is just like the contemptible Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The remark has been withdrawn.

Comment on this

What about the time you sent people to Moscow to get guns to use on Irishmen?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Words, once withdrawn, should not be commented upon.

Comment on this

I have no reason to be annoyed at the statements which are contained in Memorandum III.

Comment on this

Then do not be annoyed.

Comment on this

I am not annoyed, but apparently the author of them finds them rather distasteful to-day.

Comment on this

Owing to the damnable way you misrepresent them.

Comment on this

I am not misrepresenting them.

Comment on this

You are specialist in misrepresentation, but it is the only thing in which you are a specialist.

Comment on this

In 1936, this was the opinion Deputy Norton expressed— that he would prefer to see the question approached from the standpoint of examining the possibility of effecting grouping of unions in industries where, owing to the multiplicity of unions and the consequent weakness of organisation due to inter-union strife, the advantages of amalgamation are clearly demonstrable and the necessity for it more readily appreciated. Surely any of the unions who will be unable to make the required deposit, and who know that they are catering for the same class of workers as other unions which are in a better position than themselves, or perhaps in a position which is no better, know also that by pooling their resources they can meet the requirements of the Bill and can secure recognition as an authorised trade union. Surely the fact that this Bill would compel them to do that should meet with the approval of the person who said that he would welcome reorganisation.

Comment on this

Go out on O'Connell Street and tell them that.

Comment on this

Perhaps I shall in due course.

Comment on this

Go up to the old ladies in Rathmines and tell them that story.

Comment on this

At any rate, I am telling the Deputy——

Comment on this

Use the Moscow stuff on the old ladies in Pembroke.

Comment on this

——what responsible trade unionists have had to say on this question of amalgamation. Having regard to the present condition of the Irish trade union movement, one of the ways in which it was hoped to ensure that this condition will be considered by those responsible in the movement is in this section of the Bill. The report was demanded on a former occasion. At that time I was not aware that copies were readily available. I regarded it then as a confidential document, but I am prepared now to table it.

Comment on this

Is it still a confidential document?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this