Committee on Finance. - Trade Union Bill, 1941—Committee.
Contributions 193–392 of 392. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1941 ›
If the Minister, on the last occasion when he was handling that report, could have made that document available, he would have avoided a lot of misunderstanding. The Minister has simply made case, on the point I was putting to him, even more elaborately than I made it. If we ever heard of the blind leading the blind, here we have a case of the blind driving the blind. The Minister says that the largest group in the commission considered that the trade union movement should be organised into ten groups, but lie does not agree. He is simply taking the heavy stick to drive people whist, cut look on the matter he does not agree with, to do something. He alleges that he has thrown the responsibility on them to do it, although nobody can be convinced by that suggestion. The Minister, in handling-this Bill in the way in which he has handled it in the House, has something-more in his mind, I would say, than he discloses to the House.
Take the proposal that the Minister does not agree with. The first group would be the building industry and furniture. Has the Minister any idea that, say, painters, upholsterers, bricklayers — to go no further — can be suitably catered for inside the one union? Is he going to deny a separate existence to a painters' union if they have not £2,000, to the bricklayers' union and the upholsterers' union if they have not £2,000? Are we to understand that people of that class — different trades and different crafts — will be thrown together simply because at some time or other they do something about a house. In the second case — engineering, ship building and vehicle building — are we to understand that an electrical engineer, a motor mechanic and a ship builder are all catered for inside one union, and that a motor mechanic cannot be allowed to have a separate existence unless his union can scrape up £2,000? Will electrical engineers be treated in the same way?
Before the House gives this big stick to a Minister, who says he has no mind of his own on this particular matter, and who does not agree with the mind of the trade unions, he ought to discuss in more detail the kind of mind he thinks they ought to have, or the kind of mind he thinks he might have-if he were left to carry out the reorganisation himself in the way suggested. The Minister talks of what people in the city might think of the people who are opposing this measure, and asking for a little more information on it. Deputy Morrissey raised the question of a group of a particular and characteristic type when we were discussing this matter on the Second Reading.
We can take a particular society— there are many to choose from — say, the Tipperary Workingmen's Protective and Benefit Society, which is a group of town workers. The workers of the town are organised in this society. They developed a very well-established and well-respected union— a position in which they were treated with the greatest possible confidence. They were most useful in the development of Muintir na Tíre and of the parish council organisation and spirit. Since April, 1931, they have been acting as the representatives of the general workers of the town of Tipperary. They have been registered with the Department of Industry and Commerce as a trade union since 1932, and have sent in their annual returns every year. They have agreements with every firm in Tipperary employing workers — including the Condensed Milk Company, a Government concern. They have not only the confidence of the employers of the town — a town that was not famous for its industrial harmony in years past — but they have had stable and satisfactory agreements with the employers. In contrast to the circumstances in Tipperary some years ago, Tipperary is now a place where there is industrial peace of the most stable kind. They have a membership of 500, yet they are to be wiped out of existence as soon as this Bill is passed. What union will take them over? If we are working on the system of these ten unions, we find general workers — No. 10 — at the end.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister what kind of union the members of the Tipperary Workingmen's Protective and Benefit Society will go into, under the rough idea that I am sure the Minister has of what will happen under tins Bill. You have the same in Dundalk — the Dundalk Town Workers — and in other places. Are these general town workers' unions, from Letterkenny down to Dungarvan and Kenmare, through lack of funds, to be driven out of the position they occupy between the workers and employers of the towns, and be made form one great big union extending from one end of the country to the other? What is the idea, the necessity or the benefit which will arise through forbidding the existence of town labourers' unions or town workingmen's unions of the type I mentioned and forbidding them to carry on negotiations between employers and workers of that town?
Comment on this
I would like to comment on the way this interesting matter has emerged. The Minister has given no arguments up to now on the points at issue. The issue in this question is whether or not it is necessary to combine into a smaller group the trade unions which now run to a certain number. The Minister quoted earlier from what I suppose was part of the report of this same commission. The unions affiliated to the Trade Union Congress numbered 48. As he gave the numerical strength at the present time, 34 of these will suffer because they have not as many as 2,000 members. 14 will survive if they have the deposit necessitated by the strength of the membership; but 34 have to make other arrangements for themselves, that is, 34 out of 48. If that is being demanded by the Minister, it must be on the basis that industry has been devastated by strife and that that strife is due to the multiplication of unions. At long last the Minister decided to try to advance some proof or evidence of that, and the way he does it is this: He told us on Second Beading that a Trade Union Commission was set up, and that two and a half years afterwards it reported. The Minister tried to read extracts from that document, but was brought to order because he was not then prepared to publish the document; he had only extracts. One peculiar phrase he used was that he would make public such part of the document as was then available to him. Now he proposes to put the document in the Library.
He has confined himself in his argument to telling us that six members of the body, which reported to that Trade Union Congress, reported in memorandum form. But, apparently, the views of those six people were not accepted. He then tells us what one person advocated in a memorandum. In that biassed way, not giving us by extract what the people who apparently opposed those views said, not giving anything from them, the Minister makes his case upon a, memorandum backed by six people and a memorandum backed by one person. What the context of these is we do not know. I asked the Minister if the document was privileged and he said no. It is apparently a document circulated to members of the Trade Union Congress. The Minister faced another impediment in quoting, as I say, in a partisan way from a document and one has to consider the reaction to this upon other work that the Government may endeavour to get done. As I understand the procedure now outlined by the Minister for another problem it may be this: that the Minister will get people interested in that matter and ask them to meet as a body ,to see if they could regulate their conduct in whatever way it required regulation. These people submitted to the Minister a memorandum that went before them and on which they failed to agree and the Minister feels that it is open to him to make whatever use he likes——
Comment on this
I must protest. There is nothing that I have done to-day that would warrant the Deputy making that assumption.
Comment on this
I am making a point of order. I am making this point of order. The Deputy accused me of dishonourable conduct. He has implied that I asked a certain body to set up a commission of inquiry, that memoranda were presented to me and that I have divulged them to the House. These memoranda were not presented to me. They were presented to the Trade Union Congress and they can be read in the forty-fifth report of that body which is in general circulation.
Comment on this
The Minister should stop losing his temper and try to let us have a little bit of argument. I did not say any such thing happened.
Comment on this
I wish the Minister would count ten or whatever the number is to try to keep his temper below flash point. It is very annoying to have these constant interruptions about things that I have never stated or implied. I am outlining a course of conduct which I think is open to anybody and is likely to be followed in any negotiations which may bake place hereafter in regard to the settlement of a dispute. The Minister gets a document, and having this particular document will make a case in the Dáil by quoting in a partisan way extracts of a one-sided type from the document.
Comment on this
As I understand it, there was a commission of some 13 people established. Six people were of one viewpoint and submitted some memorandum; one person submitted another memorandum. We have not heard what the others did. We do know that the memorandum submitted by the six was not adopted by the group.
Comment on this
It is on the Minister's argument on the matter, which may not be so completely relevant. The only arguments the Minister has used to meet what Deputy Mulcahy and I have put to him are quotations from this particular memorandum. I do not care what the quotations are; I do not care how partisan or biassed they are, but they have not met the point. Will the Minister get back to the statistics his Department published with regard to loss of time and loss of money?
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell me what percentage of time or money lost was due to the rivalries of small trade unions? Is that relevant? Surely it is, because it is the small trade unions who will be killed by this requirement of a £2,000 deposit. I have asked several times if the Minister will give an estimate of the percentage of these losses to industry that have been caused by trade union rivalry. He advanced to-day so far as to say that a considerable number of the disputes in the country were due to rivalries of small trade unions. He has not attempted to be concrete in any degree in this matter. This is the pivotal point, the kernel of the whole matter, whether £2,000 should be demanded. I see no reason for it. It has nothing to do with the overlapping matter which is dealt with in another section which provides that people must go before a tribunal to find out whether a group or a number of groups are to have the right alone to cater for people of their own class. That is to do away with the overlapping. The only thing we are left with then is, how far small trade unions with their jealousies have caused trouble in industry. I have got no answer to that.
Comment on this
The Minister has now gone a little distance in disclosing home of the considered thought on this question of trade union organisation contained in documents of one kind or another in the past couple of years. He did go a little forward since the last time. I wonder will he go a little bit more forward. Will he endeavour to give us some extracts from the memoranda submitted to the Vocational Commission bearing on this particular matter? The Minister wants to get more efficient organisation, better mutual understanding, better harmony amongst workers themselves particularly, and between workers and employers. I quoted Dr. Lucey of Maynooth speaking at the Catholic Social Week as saying:—
"A spirit of mutual understanding and collaboration and a strong regard for the common good, without which vocational organisation was but a sham, could not be infused into the leaders of Capital and Labour overnight by governmental decree."
Following the performance that we have had here on this Bill, I do not think that any order of the Minister issued within six months after the passing of the Bill will bring about any mutual understanding or collaboration or strong regard for the common good amongst the people on whom he has thrown the responsibility for clearing up the kind of mess in which he thinks the trade union is at present. If there is a serious problem to be dealt with, it has to be dealt with by collaboration and by thorough understanding. It is that feeling, that desire, the intention to collaborate and avoid mistinderstanding, that is one of the first things to be secured. With that given, people then have to find what are the proper lines on which organisation can take place. The Vocational Commission has appealed to the trade union organisations throughout the country and has got a very considerable amount of evidence and has had a considerable amount of discussion. Can we have any of the suggestions that have been made by anybody before that commission, or can we have any suggestions from the commission itself, before we take this irretrievable leap in the dark of wiping out, so far as negotiations are concerned or so far as people having any power to influence wages or conditions of work in industry are concerned, every group that cannot put up £2,000?
If the Minister insists on wiping out every group that cannot put up £2,000, we ought to be told what groups are affected like that and in what direction they are likely to be absorbed, so that we can see what kind of absorption is going to take place. We can then have the Minister's opinion as to whether that absorption is desirable and we can form our own opinions as to whether it is desirable. If we cannot have that, if the Minister thinks his own mind is not sufficiently clear to tell us and if he thinks the. trade union leaders' minds are too divided or confused to get any picture through him from them, then I seriously submit that the abolition clause ought to be left out and that in whatever discussions, negotiations and examinations that are going to take place after the passage of this Bill the unions should not be put out of the arena of thought and consultation and discussion simply because they have not £2,000.
Surely the Minister cannot make a case for telling every union that has not £2,000 to stand aside out of the remodelling that is likely to take place? The last thing anyone who was anxious to put trade unions on a more harmonious basis and organise them in a more satisfactory way should think of suggesting would be that every trade union that has not £2,000 should be wiped out of existence. The Minister by insisting on this provision is going to do more damage than the bull did when it entered the china shop, particularly in view of the statistics he has given us as to the number of unions likely to have the £2,000. Could the Minister at least tell us——
Comment on this
Could the Minister tell us what is likely to happen under the scheme? Let us take town labourers' union whose whole interest is in their employers and in the town in which they live. What is likely to happen a union such as that under this Bill?
Comment on this
Not having £2,000. and being put out of existence under This Bill, what is likely to happen with regard to its members and with regard to the employers?
Comment on this
I have already answered. Am I or am I not entitled to bring the debate to a close? Deputy Mulcahy may, if he wishes, repeat ad nauseam the same sort of speech on every section. We have heard this speech for at least the tenth time. He tried to make it on Section 1 and he repeated it again and again since. I am not going to waste the time of the House by answering. The Deputy will see what will happen to the trade union if it cannot provide or raise the £2,000. If the 528 men in it, according to the Deputy, cannot raise £2,000, then I do not think that the community of Tipperary has as much confidence in them as the Deputy professes to think it has.
Comment on this
So that 528 men in an Irish town, whose whole interest is in their town and the work around them — the only people who are interested in them so far as carrying on work harmoniously is concerned are he employers of the town — are not going to be allowed, under a penalty, to discuss wages and conditions of service. They cannot do so in that town except £2,000 is collected and lodged with somebody lest, I suppose, they break the peace or do something and have to be fined. The Minister tells us they are going to be wiped out: they are not going to be allowed by law to talk to the employers with regrard to wages. Who is going to settle any question that arises on the subject of wages between the employers of that town and the workers? Can the Minister tell us that? I submit we are entitled to know.
Comment on this
Is the Minister by penalty, going to destroy the negotiating; machine in the town of Tipperary and in similar towns, machinery which has carried out satisfactory work since 1931? What is going to be put in its place under this Bill? We are going to spend public money on putting this Bill into operation and we are entitled to know what is going to replace the existing satisfactory machinery.
Comment on this
With all the talk we have had from the Minister about bringing harmony and co-operation and everything like that into the relations of workmen and their employers, lie has not yet informed us what is going to be put into the place of existing satisfactory machinery in towns like Tipperary and Dundalk.
Comment on this
If the Minister cannot tell us, is there any Deputy in the Fianna Fáil Party from Louth who will tell us what is going to happen in Dundalk, or is there any Fianna Fáil Deputy from Tipperary who will tell us what will happen there?
Comment on this
We have heard this statement repeated ad nauseam and surely the House is entitled to have the question put from the Chair?
Comment on this
If there is not any Deputy in the Fianna Fáil Party from Louth who is prepared to say what will happen in Dundalk, and if there is not a Fianna Fáil Deputy from Monaghan, Limerick, Cork, Waterford——
Comment on this
That is more than I can say about the Minister. The Minister has not said anything on this Bill which would justify the charge that he is repeating himself. He has dodged around in every possible direction for the purpose of seeing that nobody will get at what is in the back of his mind. But at least he does realise this, that if this Bill is passed, a workman's association in the town of Tipperary, comprising 528 men, an association that has carried on satisfactorily and in perfect harmony for 11 years, in a period in which he suggests there have been all kinds of industrial difficulties in the way of strikes and animosities between the people in such a labour organisation, will cease to exist if it cannot lodge £2,000. They have given satisfaction to one another, they have given satisfaction to the employers, but they are now going to be wiped out of existence because they have not £2,000.
At a time when employment conditions, as disclosed by the last figures, were nearly as bad as those of last year, in spite of the numbers of men who have gone into the Army and gone abroad, they are asked to find £2,000. I should like the Minister to relate his conception of how they ought to be able to find £2,000 with some of the debates that took place on the Budget, and on the Financial Resolutions, to the emergency that exists, and to the kind of emergency we are running into, as well as the crisis as regards prices that is likely to be here in three months. The Minister has deliberately set out to withdraw machinery in Irish towns that worked satisfactorily and that brought about harmony. What machinery is going to maintain that harmony; what machinery is going to step in when a difficulty arises?
Comment on this
The Minister has not said one word that would suggest to the House that he has any idea of the machinery that would step in. He should tell us what machinery he would like to step in assuming he was able in control it.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 17:—
In sub-section (1), page 4, to delete in line 43 and 44 the words "accountant of the courts of justice" and substitute the words "High Court".
The object of the amendment is to provide that the procedure shall be to have the deposits required under the section made with the High Court rather than with the accountant of the courts of justice. By this amendment, and the consequential amendments which I have put down — amendments Nos. 32, 34, 35 and 37 — the procedure with regard to such matters as the payment of accruing interest, and the variation of securities, can be simplified. The trade unions will be enabled to avoid the inconvenience and expense of making formal application to the court in regard to such matters.
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 5 stand part of the Bill".
Do you agree with this result?
The point which I now propose to make was hinted at in the discussion that took place on Section 6. Suppose you have a difference which, judging by previous circumstances, is likely to create a wages dispute, say, in the drapery trade in Killarney. There are, let us say, two shops in Killarney in the drapery trade. One is owned by a company and the other is owend by two brothers in partnership. As I understand, neither the company nor the two brothers can engage in negotiation separately with their own employees. Jointly, they cannot, of course, engage in negotiation with their mixed employees unless these two brothers become a trade union and put up £2,000 or unless the company becomes a trade union and puts up £2,000 or unless either or both are members of a trade union. Quite a number of employers are not members of trade unions. These people could not conduct negotiations in connection with a threatened dispute with their employees in some type of trade in which there are only a few shops engaged and, therefore, only a few employers because they had not taken the precaution to become members of a trade union and were not a trade union themselves.
As I understand, this Bill makes it illegal for these people to carry on negotiations. Take the case of a company composed of a small number of persons, all of whom are residents in, say, Killarney. I am not taking the case of a big company in Dublin with a branch in Killarney. I am taking the case of a small company with the minimum number of members requisite for a company — a private company of the family type. As I understand, it is not lawful for these people to engage in negotiations with their own employees. Two brothers in partnership, carrying on business under the names of both, cannot negotiate with their employees, and the combination of the two brothers and a small company cannot engage in negotiation. I think that that is the situation, but I should like to know if the Minister agrees that it is.
Comment on this
I do not contest what the Deputy says. I think there is something in the point which he raised, particularly regarding the partnership, and I shall see if I can cover it.
Comment on this
Take the case of a small company which is not a trade union and is not registered with a group of other employers as a trade union. Can it not conduct negotiations with its own employees?
Comment on this
That is the point which I propose to investigate. It is not intended to deter it from doing so.
Comment on this
Take the case of three drapers in a provincial town. A question regarding wages arises. They cannot negotiate with the drapers' assistants in that town unless they become a trade union.
Comment on this
I am not accepting the statement that, in a large number of towns, there would not be a sufficient number of employers to form a negotiating body.
Comment on this
I am not saying that it does not. What I have questioned is that in most Irish towns there would not be a sufficient number of employers to constitute an authorised trade union and put down the deposit.
Comment on this
In a large number of towns there might be only three or four drapers. A question might arise between these drapers and their assistants on which they would like to come to a joint decision. The question might have reference to the length of holidays to be allowed or to the amount to be allowed for board. Some small matter such as that might crop up and these drapers would not be allowed to negotiate as a body. A question might arise as to the closing of the shops on the weekly half-holiday. That would be a "condition of employment" and these three or four men could not come together and negotiate with their employees.
Comment on this
There is no reason why even drapers should not federate with other employers in the town and negotiate these things jointly.
Comment on this
Before these persons could negotiate — say three or four persons had joined together — they would have to put up £2,000, which would be lying idle afterwards.
Comment on this
Well, earn ing only 3 per cent. or so. Would it not be far better to amend this part of the Bill completely by saying that nobody can negotiate on behalf of such employers?
Comment on this
Take the average country town where a question of wages might have to be decided by negotiation. There may be a number of drapers in that town but the number who would have to employ assistants would be very few and these are the only ones that the Bill will affect. If it were a question of wages in the drapery trade; there is no use in their joining together with licensed vintners to form a union for that purpose. The Minister said they could federate with other trades.
Comment on this
I am talking of this particular trade, the drapery trade. It seems far-fetched that three or four men should have to put up £2,000 merely in order to enable them to solve a passing difficulty.
Comment on this
Questions of wages and conditions of employment are not merely passing difficulties. In most towns in Ireland they are frequently under discussion in one trade or another. I am not suggesting that three drapers should come together, form themselves into a self-contained organisation and put down £2,000. What I am suggesting is that they should federate with other employers in the town to form an employers' federation. The three drapers then, acting through that organisation, could conduct negotiations.
Comment on this
There are a number of fairly prosperous towns in the country with a population of about 5,000, but the people are not all employers. There are quite a number of people amongst the 5,000 who are not, to use the language of statistics, gainfully employed. There would be amongst these people many old persons and small children. Possibly in a town of 5,000 you would not have more than 100 people of the employing class engaged in trade. Because some drapers' assistants in one of the drapers' shops in the town have to enter into negotiations which will affect other drapers — say that there are not more than three drapers' shops in the town — all these drapers, the people who are in the licensed trade, the people who are provision merchants and people in all other sorts of business, have to get together to form a union and put up £2,000. That is a fairly big levy to ask them to put up against the possibility of drapers' assistants causing trouble amongst three drapers in the town.
Comment on this
They are asked to form it for the purpose of negotiating conditions in case of a dispute with the drapers' assistants.
Comment on this
The employers are asked to federate for the general purpose of negotiating wages and conditions with all employees in the town.
Comment on this
They have to conform to several conditions. They must have a memorandum and articles of association. They must have conditions as to the way people get in and go out of their trade unions. When a dispute arises with the drapers' assistants they have to call the trade union officials together, employ all this negotiating machinery and observe all these heterogeneous conditions.
Comment on this
That may happen, all because there is the dispute with the drapers' assistants in the one shop.
Comment on this
Normally what would happen is that inside this federation there would be groups, one consisting of drapers, others of other traders; these groups would have the services of a secretary and the organisation would help them to conduct negotiations. In fact, the members to conduct these negotiations would be chosen by the federation of employers. No doubt they would be representative of the traders concerned.
Comment on this
These 100 people would have to put up £20 per head and they would have to have a secretary, a paid official, I presume. They would have to have trade union regulations. That is the sledge-hammer that is being built up for the drapers' assistants in Killarney.
Comment on this
The aim of the Bill seems to be to organise the country into vast camps. That is the logical goal towards which the Bill seems to aim.
Comment on this
Little new light has been thrown on the situation. I was trying to find out from the Minister in the discussion on the amendment what was going to happen to a workmen's organisation in a town like Tipperary, in which there are 500 workers and where, over a period of 11 years, by peaceful negotiation, the employers and employees have maintained perfect peace and harmony in the business of the town. The Minister suggested that it was rather queer if the employers in a town like that could not put down £2,000. Then my mind woke up to the fact that not only have the workers to put down £2,000 on their side but that the employers have also to put down £2,000 on their side.
Comment on this
I did not use any such phrase, because the Minister has been much too nebulous for anybody to make out what kind of legislation he has put forward. Nobody has been able to figure out from anything he said what is going to be the result. I would again ask the Minister, if the present situation is going to continue in Tipperary, have the combined employers to put down £2,000 on their side, and the workers £2,000 on their side? Could the Minister answer that?
Comment on this
It is very hard to know what the Minister has answered, because I do not think anybody in this House has got an answer from him to-day. Am I right in figuring out from anything the Minister has said that if the present conditions are continued the workers have to put down £2,000 for their organisation, and that the employers have to put down £2,000 for theirs?
Comment on this
There is prima facie evidence that that is so, because nothing the Minister has said up to the present has been of any assistance in clarifying my mind. I take it that the only reason the Minister will not give a straight answer to my question is that the suggestion is too disgraceful, that, under present economic conditions, he should require the employers of Tipperary town and the workers of Tipperary town, if they are to continue working in the harmony in which they are working at present, to find £4,000 to put down. Deputy O'Sulhvan raised a point with regard to employers generally in a town, but I should like to direct the attention of the House to Section 20, which says:
(1) Subject to the provisions of this section, where application is made to the tribunal by a trade union which claims to have organised a majority of masters of a particular class for a determination that such trade union alone shall have the right to organise masters of that class, the tribunal, after hearing such application and having considered all the circumstances of the case, shall either...
What does "masters of a particular class" mean? Is it possible that, in the town of Tipperary, the employers would all come together and be registered as a trade union and, if so, what interpretation are we to put on the words "particular class"?
Comment on this
There are a large number of towns in the country, and if local organisations of any kind are continued and if £2,000 on one side and £2,000 on the other has to be put down, it means practically £400,000 altogether.
Comment on this
Suppose that in a parish there is a dispute between a couple of farmers and their workmen, and the parish council decides that it will intervene and arbitrate, will the parish council have to put down £2,000, and get a licence, before it can stir?
Comment on this
If such a council wishes to carry on negotiations between an employer and an employee, will the council have to put down £2,000?
Comment on this
The point raised by Deputy Mulcahy is important, and I take again that hypothetical case I gave earlier, of the small town where there are 100 of the employing class. There are some drapers, some publicans, some grocers and so on, in it. They may be able to find £100 each and other towns may be more or less inspired by their example. They are going to have a small town trade union, and at that point the drapers' organisation, that is, of masters, in Dublin realises that the ground is being cut from under their feet. They go before the tribunal to be established under another part of the Bill for a determination that they alone are entitled to organise drapers and they get a determination in their favour. From that moment, no other one of these heterogeneous groups can get a draper in. People in a town close to the first town I mentioned decide that they will get 100 of the employing class together to form a trade union. They have to cut out drapers. They cannot receive drapers, a determination having been given in favour of the main city organisation. The licensed trade people will also be in immediately and get a determination, so that these people cannot join with their colleagues in business in the small town in order to get a trade union of a heterogeneous type.
Comment on this
If there is anything in that point, I shall discuss it on Section 20. I do not think it arises on this section.
Comment on this
Having clarified very fully and satisfactorily the position with regard to urban workers and employers, and feeling that perhaps it could not possibly be clarified any more under present circumstances, we may pass to the rural position. Road workers are a group which, in various counties, are very definitely organised, and they have always been able to carry out fairly satisfactorily their negotiations with the county councils. Under the present proposal, the negotiation of wages and conditions between road workers and the local authorities will, in future, be forbidden.
Comment on this
That point should have been raised on Section 6. There was a Labour Party amendment down which was not moved.
Comment on this
Section 7 speaks of holding a negotiation licence and sets out that it is necessary to register under the Trade Union Act. The Deputy is in order.
Comment on this
On a point of order, if road workers in the employment of local authorities wanted to carry on negotiations, arrangements could have been made when we were discussing Section 6 to put them within the category of excepted bodies.
Comment on this
I am not in any way responsible for what may arise out of the way in which the Minister carries on this discussion when addressing the Labour Party. I am facing Section 7 and what it implies, if passed, in the light of what is contained in Section 6. If Section 7 is passed, the road workers in any county, unless they put down £2,000, will not be able to carry on negotiations with the county council in respect of wages, or their general conditions of employment.
Comment on this
I do not suppose it will keep the Deputy from wasting the time of the House, but I do not think he was in the House when we were discussing Section 6. If he had been, he would not be so concerned about road workers, because I indicated that I would move to strike out the words "not being a local authority" in paragraph 3 (a) of Section 6, but that will not keep the Deputy from wasting the time of the House.
Comment on this
It is a point of order. I have given notice that I propose to introduce an amendment on Report Stage to deal with the point which Deputy Mulcahy is making.
Comment on this
The Minister has interrupted four or five times, at one time, apparently, on a point of order, objecting to a certain thing being discussed on this section. I notice that he did not rise in making that point of order. Now he makes an objection of an entirely different kind. It is purely interruption.
Comment on this
I am concerned merely with my own reputation, as besmirched with the Minister, and in order to show that I have not the slightest intention of wasting the time of the House, I shall just ask the Minister to help me on this point: Do I understand that, taking into consideration the amendment already passed to Section 6 and the amendment he proposes to introduce on Report Stage, it will be possible for road workers to carry on negotiations directly with a county council as in the past?
Comment on this
Provided they apply for registration as an excepted body in the register of such bodies.
Comment on this
Yes. To the words "the expression `excepted bodies' means any of the following bodies", I can add "county councils".
Comment on this
As it was introduced, the Minister could not, and, as the amendment was introduced to as here, it was to deal with associations like nurses'.
Comment on this
And various other bodies. I mentioned industrial councils, conciliation councils and a number of other bodies.
Comment on this
At any rate, there will be machinery by which the road workers and the county councils can carry on in the future as in the past?
Comment on this
That Section 6, as amended, stand part of the Bill.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 18a:—
Before Section 8 to insert a new section as follows:—
8. (1) Where—
(a) the Emergency Powers Act, 1939 (No. 28 of 193&) is in force, and
(b) the Minister is satisfied that, as regards any particular trade union registered under the Trade Union Acts, 1871 to 1935, it would, on account of abnormal conditions referable to the war in which the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is now engaged, cause undue hardship if such trade union were compelled to make and keep with the High Court the full deposit specified by the next preceding section,
the Minister may by order declare that every sum of money mentioned in the Schedule to this Act shall, as regards such trade union, be deemed to be reduced to such extent not exceeding 75 per cent. as the Minister thinks proper.
(2) An order under sub-section (1) of this section shall have effect in accordance with its terms for the period specified in that behalf therein, save that no such cruder shall have effect after the Emergency Powers Act, 1939 (No. 28 of 1939), has ceased to be in force.
(3) The Minister may by order, made after six months' notice of the making thereof has been given to the trade union concerned, revoke any order previously made by him under sub-section, (1) of this section.
The purpose of this amendment is to enable the Minister for Industry and Commerce, so long as the Emergency Powers Act of 1939 is in force, to grant a reduction in the case of any particular trade union registered under the Trade Union Acts in this country, in circumstances where he is satisfied that because of conditions which have been created by the present war it would occasion undue hardship to that particular trade union to make the deposit called for by the Schedule. This amendment will enable the Minister to consider that particular case and, with a view to the alleviation of such hardship, to grant a reduction, to an extent not exceeding 75 per cent., in the amount which it would have to deposit with the High Court in order to secure a negotiation licence.
Comment on this
It would depend on the particular circumstances of the union, but the maximum reduction would be from £2,000 to £500 in the case of a trade union having not more than 2,000 members. In the other cases the reduction would be proportionate, that is to say, in the case of a union where the appropriate deposit would be £10,000 the Minister could, if he felt that the circumstances justified it, reduce that deposit to £2,500.
Comment on this
Do we understand that the Minister is introducing here an important amendment and that he does not know the number of trade unions that are likely to be affected by it?
Comment on this
I cannot say because I have no reason to believe that the more effective trade unions will be affected by it.
Comment on this
Supposing they were all affected by it, what would be the number of the trade unions?
Comment on this
Could the Minister give us any information as to the number of trade unions in the country likely to be affected by it or that could be affected by it, or can he give us any information as to whether there are any trade unions that are likely to be affected by it?
Comment on this
Could the Minister give us an idea as to the reasons that would operate with him in suggesting a particular trade union?
Comment on this
It has been suggested to me that a particular union which was in a nourishing position, say, at the beginning of this year may, due to increasing unemployment, experience some difficulty in making a deposit out of their existing fund.
Comment on this
And the Minister's idea is that while that may affect the type of trade union suggested here, it is not likely to affect Irish trade unions at all? Is that so?
Comment on this
Is that so? Does that mean that if the workers' union in Tipperary were able to show that employment was difficult and that a number of their members was unemployed, they would be able to come in on the reduced fee?
Comment on this
If they show me that they cannot fulfil the conditions laid down in this amendment, yes.
Comment on this
This provides that any authorised trade union may apply to the Minister for a negotiation licence.
Comment on this
Because it is usual to charge a fee when an application of this description is made.
Comment on this
So that, as well as finding £2,000 to put down they also have to find an additional £1 for fee?
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the section."
Do you agree with this result?
This section provides that, where the Minister is satisfied that an applicant for a negotiation licence is an authorised trade union, he must grant the licence.
Comment on this
Section 7 laid down certain qualifications which are necessary for a union to become an authorised trade union. Why then in Section 9 is it necessary to bring in "to the satisfaction of the Minister"? A trade union either is or is not an authorised trade union. If it complies with the necessary qualifications in Section 7 it is an authorised trade union; if it does not comply with them it is not an authorised trade union. Why then should "to the satisfaction of the Minister" come in?
Comment on this
As the Minister is responsible for granting the licence, he must at least be satisfied that the conditions provided in Section 7 are fulfilled.
Comment on this
We have indicated on several occasions already that one of the difficulties about having a satisfactory discussion on this measure is that we do not know what is at the back of the Minister's mind. In relation to not one single matter on which we have had a discussion has the Minister allowed himself to be pinned down to any definite statement of any kind. It is quite true, as Deputy Benson said, that the Minister ought to have no function in this matter, unless he wants to set himself up as an authority to pursue a policy of directing things with regard to the formation or the organisation or the classification of trade unions. The unions are supposed to deposit a certain amount with the High Court. The fact that they have made their deposit, the fact that they have registered as a trade union, and the fact that they have applied for the negotiation licence should be quite sufficient. I see no reason why the section should not read:—
Where application is duly made for a negotiation licence and the applicant is shown to be an authorised trade union, the Minister may grant such licence.
Comment on this
Where it is "shown to the satisfaction of the Minister". The Minister is personally responsible for granting the licences, and, therefore, he must be satisfied that the conditions have been fulfilled.
Comment on this
Why should the Minister's satisfaction come in when it is a question simply of facts f Under that section, although the facts may be all the facts that are required, if, for any reason, the Minister is not satisfied to have the union given a negotiation licence, the Minister has power to refuse it. Would the Minister say for what purpose he desires to have that power of refusing a licence to a trade union that has carried out all the necessary steps which would entitle it to the negotiation licence?
Comment on this
It is quite clear, when Sections 7 and 8 are read together with Section 9, that when the conditions prescribed in Section 7 are fulfilled the Minister must of necessity grant the licence. The section here is mandatory on the Minister —"the Minister shall grant such licence." Naturally, before he grants it, he must satisfy himself that the precedent conditions have been fulfilled.
Comment on this
That the applicant is a registered trade union, and has made the appropriate deposit.
Comment on this
That might be, but it seems to me that, by analogy, any decision which the Minister would take could be argued to be a judicial decision. Whether or not there would be any justification for so arguing, I do not know.
Comment on this
The only justification for arguing on it is that there are three things which require to be done— they have to be a registered trade union, they have to lodge a certain amount with the courts, and they have to make an application. When those things have been done, when an application is made by a body shown to be an authorised trade union, why a negotiation licence should not be granted, without the Minister being called in to express satisfaction or otherwise, is a matter that justifies questioning. The Minister will realise our position?
Comment on this
I realise that the Deputy, who professes to be so concerned for the public weal, is simply wasting time in repeating questions and obstructing the passage of the Bill.
Comment on this
I would be very sorry to think that within the last ten years I have been responsible for so much waste of Parliamentary time as the Minister has been responsible for in the control of this measure from the time it was introduced. The Minister has indicated that it is the trade unions which will have to settle all this. There are trade union representatives that he thinks fit to quote here, yet he does not agree with them as to what they ought to do. He tells us he has no plan in his mind, and does not think much about the plan the trade unionists have. The only people that he thinks it worth while to quote here is the particular section that he has quoted. In these circumstances he asks us to put into this section of the Bill an idea that a negotiation licence will be granted only when it is shown to the satisfaction of the Minister that a certain body is an authorised trade union. I think that the Minister is putting himself into this situation for some particular purpose he must have in mind, but which he is not disclosing to us.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the purpose of the section is clear on the face of it. It says:—
Section 2 of the Trade Union Act, 1871, Section 3 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, and the Trade Disputes Act, 1906, shall apply only in relation to authorised trade unions which for the time being are holders of negotiation licences and the members and officials of such trade unions, and not otherwise.
Comment on this
I think the House is well aware of the general purpose of the Act. It frees the officials and members of these organisations from charges of conspiracy in connection with the organisation and prosecution of trade disputes and gives them the right of peaceful picketing.
Comment on this
Are we to understand that these rights are being withdrawn from a body which consists of persons all of whom are employed by the same employer and which carries on negotiations for the fixing of wages or other conditions of employment with that employer only; that they are taken from agricultural labourers; that they are taken from people whose wages and conditions of employment are arranged by trade boards; taken from teachers, civil servants, and any other body of people, such as road workers, that may come under the excepted bodies?
Comment on this
No, the House need not understand anything of the sort. There is nothing in this Bill which would prevent persons whose minimum wages are fixed by trade boards being members of a trade union; in fact the majority of the people so situated are members of a trade union. Neither is there anything to prevent an agricultural labourer from being a member of a trade union. I presume that some people who are employed as agricultural labourers are in fact members of general workers' unions, so that the case which the Deputy is making has no substance in it. The main thing, as I pointed out when putting amendment No. 10 to the House, is that those bodies which are excepted, since they are exempt from making a deposit under the Bill, are bodies which it is anticipated need not have recourse to the strike weapon. If they do wish to have recourse to the strike weapon and to have the benefit and advantages of Section 10, then they must join an authorised trade union. It is only the members of authorised trade unions who will have the benefits and advantages and special privileges conferred by these Acts.
Comment on this
If a body of road workers in any particular county are not able to put up £2,000 in order to make themselves an authorised trade union able to deal direct, as in the past, with the county council, they will have to forfeit their rights under the Trade Disputes Act in order to be able to carry on negotiations with the county council?
Comment on this
They would have to put themselves in the position of any other person who would be subject to an action for tort, if they do anything to injure another person in his business or property, and who would not be entitled to carry on picketing.
Comment on this
Is there not this difference between the existing position and the position according to the provisions of the Bill, that they must put down £2,000?
Comment on this
Therefore, if any county road workers want to deal with their own affairs they will have to find £2,000, as otherwise they will not get the benefits to which the Minister has referred. It is no good saying that this Bill does not take away from them rights which they have at present. This amounts to a fine of £2,000, because it practically means that it must remain there the whole time and they can never touch it again. If they lose anything on it, they must pour more money into it. Unless they can find £2,000, they get none of the benefits of those Acts. As things stand at present, they could form a trade union without the loss of that £2,000. The Minister may think that that is nothing, but it is a very severe penalty. It may in practice deprive them of the benefits of these Acts.
Comment on this
Will not the section hit the smaller trade unions of craftsmen in different parts of the country which would not be in a position to apply for a negotiation licence, and deprive them of the rights they have had for something like 70 years? There are a number of these unions in Dublin, Cork, Limerick and other places. If they have not sufficient members to enable them to apply for registration as a negotiation body, they will practically pass out of the category of trade unions as they exist at present. I do not know if the Minister has considered that point of view. Take one of those now in the City of Dublin. There is an amendment down by Deputy Byrne to exclude it from the scope of this measure — the Regular Dublin Coopers' Society. The membership is not much more than 300 in the City of Dublin. If they were to be called upon to pay £2,000, it would require a levy of about £7 per man.
There are two points that arise in this connection. The first is whether the mind of the Minister is running towards allowing such bodies to exist at all as trade unions. If they are allowed, the price is almost beyond their capacity. The second point is this, that if the intention is to group these with a number of other crafts into a trade union, that trade union would have to have a long name if it were to include coopers, certain classes of men engaged in making good furniture, french polishers, printers and other people of that sort.
What case can be made for the introduction of a Bill of this sort at such a period? These trade unions have not occasioned the disturbance in employment that the Minister has spoken of, and it seems rather hard that, because there is a problem to be dealt with in respect of one section, we are, by a single swoop, to deprive these people of the advantages they have had for 50, 60 or 70 years. Surely there should be some other means of dealing with a situation of that kind?
Comment on this
People who are at the moment engaged in talking about the conflict that is being waged outside our country sometimes refer to the "last war"; people who want to get in a note of personal reminiscence of a more ancient date refer to the "Boer War," and quite a number of people occasionally give examples arising out of the Napoleonic wars. When you are there you are back a good bit, but you are not back quite as far as the Minister wants to put the trade union movement.
About the year 1800 it was discovered there were combinations growing up for the betterment of conditions in industry. Up to that time they had been regarded as conspirators and the whole weight of the old employer-made law was put against these people. Everything that could be done by legislation and by the courts, giving effect to that particular type of class legislation, was done, and it all pivoted finally on the point that where people gathered together to do anything in restraint of trade, anything of the type we have got used to arising out of trade union activity, was regarded as conspiratory activity and people were sentenced for that.
Somewhere after 1800 men began to get enlightened. They realised that these combinations for the betterment of conditions in industry ought to be allowed and, by degrees, we got a, relaxation of the old laws about illegal combinations. The trade union move ment got leave to grow and it grew to the proportions which we had in this country prior to the beginning of this war. All that is ancient history. A little bit more recently the Minister was invited to speak before a university gathering, where a student read a paper on trade unions. I do not suppose there was anybody more flowery in his compliments to the trade unions than the Minister when he was speaking before an educated audience. Today, that same Minister wants to drive the trade union movement back beyond the 1825 period, unless trade union organisations can produce £2,000.
In the ancient days it was the old, hard-crusted employer who had everything in his hands. He was determined he would relax nothing, holding on to what he had, and he got the machinery of the law sharpened against the people who got together in order to secure better conditions in industry. The old-time employer governing the old-time Parliament and the old-time courts got his way until a period of enlightenment came, and then people were allowed to enter into those associations for the betterment of conditions. Such betterment they brought about, as anybody will realise, and now, for no argument that anybody could count sound, the Minister proposes to divide trade unions, to reintroduce class discrimination. For the future, unless trade unions can put up £2,000, they are back again in the days of 1800 and 1825.
I want once more to give the Minister the example of the provincial town of 5,000 inhabitants. Perhaps I took an exaggerated figure when I said 100 might be of the employing class. Let me take it that there might be three drapers. These drapers are faced with a difficulty if they get into some sort of unauthorised associations in the sense that they are not authorised trade unions under this Bill. If those three men enter into a discussion with employees in their own premises with regard to the fixation of wages and the betterment of conditions, they are committing an illegal act unless they are in a big organisation extending through the country, or are joined with the butchers, bakers and candlestick makers to form a local union. The men are also an illegal body unless they are members of a trade union or have the privilege of becoming the members of an excepted body.
If either of them does anything that can be described as a restraint of trade or some type of tort protected by the Trade Disputes Acts then, unless they can put up the £2,000, they are in danger of being dragged before the courts on foot of the old-time charge of conspiracy. That is what is being introduced in 1941 as enlightened legislation in order to bring harmony into society under the slogan of peace in industry in our time.
Comment on this
That is the situation. I thought this clause might have been better hidden, but here is Section 2 of the Trade Union Act of 1871— another war springs to the mind—and here is Section 3 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act of 1875 and the more modern Trade Disputes Act of 1906. All these things cease to apply except in relation to authorised trade unions and, for the future, men in this country are going to be allowed to boast that they are free in regard to associations only if they are sufficiently wealthy to be able to put up £2,000.
I wonder has the Minister realised that that is the setting in which this measure must be presented to the people? I wonder if the Minister thinks that is a proper setting or, if he does not think that it is an exaggerated way in which to present a Bill like this, does he not realise that some argument ought to be produced to show why there is a necessity for this particular type of control of the unions on the industrial side? The Minister has told us there is overlapping to be avoided. Overlapping is not any part of this section. It is covered in a later part of the Bill, which deals with the determination of one or many unions — that one or many unions have a right to organise workers of a particular class. So far as overlapping goes, it is out of it.
The only thing left is this question of rivalry and dispute, and the Minister has not advanced to the point of telling us, if he can, what number of hours in any one year, taking the worst year in which we were most harried by industrial disputes, were lost through industrial disputes because of the rivalry or jealousy of small trade unions. Until he comes to the point that there is not merely a case, but a multitude of cases, to show that the whole cause of the dispute is a small trade union, it is a scandal to the Parliament, to the Government and the age we live in that anybody should attempt to get back beyond the Trade Disputes Act and the 1871 Act and throw us back to the days of the anti-combination laws.