Committee on Finance. - Trade Union Bill, 1941—Committee (Resumed—Section 10).
Contributions 1–130 of 262. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1941 ›
Has the Minister anything to say in reply to points made by Deputy McGilligan last night?
Comment on this
Is it possible to add something to nothing? The Minister says he has nothing to add.
Comment on this
This section reveals the mentality behind this whole Bill. The mentality, of course, is clearly a most vicious mentality, because we are providing in Section 6 for the exemption of certain bodies, some of them being Civil Service staff organisations, teachers, and house unions. Under Section 6, it is possible for any particular employer to make it a condition of employment in his factory that his staff must be members of that contemptible and detestable thing known as a company union, and you may not find it possible to get employment in that factory unless you are prepared to become a member of that creature of the employer. That organisation under this Bill is exempt from paying any deposit whatever as a condition for getting a negotiation licence. It may function as a trade union and carry on negotiations in respect of wages and conditions, but, so that it will not hurt the employer, so that it may be always under his thumb, always part of his creation, always just his plaything, the Minister put Section 10 into this Bill, which deprives an organisation of that kind of ever getting the strength to make it the economic equal of the boss. That organisation, by virtue of Section 10, is prevented from enjoying the benefits of Section 2 of the Trade Union Act, 1871, and Section 3 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, and the Trade Disputes Act, 1906, so that if any of the members of that organisation go on strike, and if they try to resort to peaceful picketing, a thing which has been recognised in respect of trade unions down through the ages, that organisation does not get any such protection. The boss, in such circumstances, can send for the armed forces of the State and have those peaceful pickets removed, even though their only purpose is to make the public aware of the fact that the boss is not paying a fair rate of wages or is imposing unreasonable conditions on his employees. Now, that organisation cannot tell the public by means of peaceful picketing that there is a strike on. They cannot tell the public that the boss is paying a low rate of wages. They cannot tell the public that he is enforcing bad conditions. The Civic Guards in the first instance, the military in the second instance and the jails in the third instance, all line up behind the boss and prevent the workers in such circumstances from making their grievances known to the public.
We have all this, in spite of the smooth humbug in the Constitution, which talks about freedom, of association. Freedom of association under Section 10 means the freedom that the boss will permit to the workers, or that the Minister for Industry and Commerce will permit to the workers. That is the purpose of Section 10, to squeeze the workers in the interests of the boss. Every Deputy who goes into the Division Lobby in support of this section, no matter what humbug he talked at the last election about being in favour of raising the standard of living of the masses of the people, is going into the Division Lobby to strengthen the hands of the boss, and to take away from trade unionists the rights which they have had for over 70 years, rights which it was left to this Government to try to filch away from them. I defy any person still purporting to have any fragmentary bias in favour of the working classes to justify this section. It cannot be justified. It can be justified only on one ground, that is, if you want to squeeze the workers, if you want to make them ineffective, if you want to prevent them from exercising the privileges of law which they have enjoyed for 70 years, and which were given to them by an alien Government. For 50 years those privileges were enjoyed under the British Government. They were enjoyed for 10 years under native governments, but this Government at this stage proposes to take away from the workers the rights which they have enjoyed for 70 years. I say deliberately and definitely that it is done for the purpose of weakening the workers' movement in the interests of the employing classes. As Deputy McGilligan rightly said yesterday evening, the growth of the trade union movement has gone hand in hand with the raising of the standard of living of the workers, and trade union legislation generally for the past 70 years has been based on a recognition that trade unions expressing the view points of collectively organised workers can play a useful part in the promotion of social peace and the raising of the standard of living of the masses of the workers. Every piece of trade union legislation affecting this country for the past 70 years has proceeded on a recognition of the useful part which trade unions can play in those directions. There has been a recognition, tardy at first, but accelerating afterwards, that it was desirable to give the trade unions such reasonable measure of liberty as was calculated to enable them to discharge their task of raising the standard of living of the workers. Now, for the first time in 70 years, the hands of the clock are being put back by this Government. Workers now are being prevented from exercising their rights, or may be prevented from exercising their rights if the Minister can have his way under Section 10. I protest against this section. It is an outrageous attack upon the efforts of the workers to defend themselves against low wages and bad conditions of employment. There can be no purpose for this section other than to weaken that resistance.
This Government has shown scant regard for the interests of the workers. It has done nothing to protect their standard of living; it has done nothing to raise their wage scales; and it insists on imposing hardships on them under the Emergency Powers Order No. 83. Having failed to lift the standard of living of the workers, having failed to protect them against the inroads which high prices make upon their standard of living, the Minister comes in under Section 10 to try to take from the workers even the protection they have left — the protection of combination and protection in the exercise of their rights and privileges which they enjoy under the Acts set out here. The Minister is doing this in the interests of the employing class and should be ashamed of himself, and he should never again be trusted with the confidence of a worker.
Comment on this
Is the Minister not replying at all? I think he should make some attempt at some stage in this Bill to make the rase that is made against the different sections of it. Up to the present we have seen the extraordinary course — cither complete silence or else, as he has done on other occasions, the Minister merely has quoted the result of considerations given by somebody else, namely, by legal authorities that he consulted. Surely — leaving aside the contempt that he shows for the House, which possibly is a thing to whrch we are accustomed — is it not a bad augury for the Bill that it is being passed in this way? We are supposed to be a legislative Assembly. This is a Bill that has aroused and is arousing a great deal of opposition and criticism amongst people who think they are being severely hit and that the privileges they have enjoyed for a long time are being filched away from them. These people are presented with the extraordinary spectacle of a Minister who absolutely refuses to justify a single clause of this Bill, relying altogether on the efficiency of the Whips Department of the Government.
Whatever chance there may be of this Bill being worked in the spirit that the Minister probably has in mind, what chance could there be after attitude and conduct of that kind on the part of the Minister? It is hard to believe it and yet it is equally hard to avoid the conclusion that he is deliberately provoking opposition to this Bill outside the House. I say it is extremely difficult to think that any responsible Minister would adopt an attitude of that kind. I know that the Minister——
Comment on this
When I notice the Minister addressing the Chair, it is hard to know. He may have the same contempt for the Chair as he has for the House.
Comment on this
When I notice the Minister addressing a remark to you, Sir, I am not aware whether it is a point of order or not.
Comment on this
I should like to recall that the Committee is supposed to be discussing Section 10. Twice at least yesterday protests were made against the action of the Minister. Repetition on every section of similar protests is not permissible. Nothing has yet been said by the Deputy on this section.
Comment on this
Therefore, I am not repeating myself. I am protesting against the Minister's conduct to-day. Deputy McGilligan, when finishing the debate last night from these benches, made an onslaught on this section and the purposes of this section. The leader of the Labour Party, breaking his silence — as we hoped the Minister would break his — also made an onslaught. To-day the Minister does not deign to give any answer. I suggest that if the Minister insists, and repeats his contempt for the House, on every occasion that he does that attention can be called to it.
It is quite obvious that the charges made by Deputy McGilligan last night were well founded, and that unless certain onerous conditions can be fulfilled by bodies of workers or by bodies of employers — it must be remembered that, as we have found out in the course of this debate, this Bill cuts both ways — they are liable to the penalties of conspiracy, and so on, to which they would be liable were they not protected by the Trade Union Acts. To that charge the Minister hag made no reply. The charge is a grave one. I do not think anybody who considers the Bill as a whole, as it war drafted, can be easy in his mind as to the future that this particular section is preparing for the country. I hold, that even though his intention may be to help industry, as I presume it is, this Bill is more calculated — and this section is more calculated — to cause in dustrial trouble than a multiplicity of trade unions.
The Minister has not shown that workers — especially in small bodies — have unduly caused great material damage to the country, yet the whole purport of the Bill is to make any combination of small bodies of workers practically impossible, and to deprive them of the protection which was gradually granted to them as the result of humanitarian efforts quite as much as the result of agitation during the whole of the past 100 years. Yet, as I have said, the Minister will not reply. It is hard, I admit, to justify this particular section. It seems to to me that there is nothing to be said for this and various other sections in the Bill. I admit that some amendments, very vague in character, have been put in, but the Bill as drafted would tend to make it impossible and illegal even for a county council to combine in fixing the wage of their workers. That the Bill as drafted. I hold also that it is quite obvious that every section of this Bill requires drastic amendment, or at least the principal sections do. They have an implication which must not have been apparent when the Bill was drafted in the first instance.
Comment on this
Last week, when this Bill was before the House, I described it as the nearest thing to dictatorship that was ever produced. It is a tyrannical Bill. I made reference to this clause as being the worst clause — one which cannot be justified. It takes from the workers rights which they won in days gone by, not alone from an Irish Government but from the British Government. It looks very bad tor an Irish Parliament to take from our people rights they won in the days gone by. They are to be denied the right of peaceful picketing and of exposure of their grievances if their union is not sufficiently strong to pay £2,000 to the Government; they are denied the rights to show the public how they are treated. I say that the Bill ought to be withdrawn immediately. I believe that the Bill is beyond amending, that it is impossible to amend it, because every clause of it has the tyrannical idea behind it to crush the workers and, in many cases, to crush their leaders.
I mentioned last week that I remember when the quay labourers in Dublin were being paid 18/- per week. Until a leader at that time adopted methods that appeared to be revolutionary these workers were paid that miserable wage, and it took their leader all his time to prevent the wages being paid to them in publichouses. I refer to Jim Larkin, a man with whom I differed very often, but of whose good points I have knowledge. Twenty-five years ago he stopped the stevedores paving the men their wages in publichouses. Now, as a result of organisation, the workers have reached a certain standard. This measure will prevent them from bettering that standard. I appeal to the Government to be wise, and to guide the Minister on to the right path and withdraw the Bill.
Comment on this
I think the Minister would be well-advised to reconsider his attitude in this matter. This is a penal section. There are other penal sections in the Bill, but they all recede, both in their intensity and in their powers, before this one. As matters stand, if a trade union has not a sufficient number of members to enable it to put up the sum required, and does not belong to what is described in the Bill as a negotiation body, then the members cannot withdraw their labour without endangering themselves and being open to prosecution for conspiracy. So far as the Trade Disputes Act of 1906 is concerned, it is of small moment compared with the dangers there are in connection with the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875.
A book has been published recently called An English Saga. Although that work is not correct in every repect, and is particularly incorrect in regard to its estimate of the number of soldiers from Ulster who took part in the last Great War — it put the number at 1,000,000 men when there were not 1,000,000 men in the whole of Ulster — it tells the story of the humanitarian efforts of certain people just described by Deputy O'Sullivan, and of the efforts of the workers during the last 100 years to improve their lot. It is quite clear that an enlightened public opinion was brought to bear on that situation, and that the best elements in the community responded to the call of their fellow human beings. We have evidence that the fruits of that were partaken of not only by those engaged in manual labour, but also by employers and the wealthy classes. Perhaps in no case has the improvement been so marked as in the City of Dublin, where, within the memory of people who are alive to-day, the death rate was two or three times what it is at present. That improvement in wages and in the conditions of labour is reflected in the health of the people. The benefits that those engaged in industry derived by reason of that great movement extended even to the employing classes who were able to live healthier, longer and more secure lives by reason of the humanitarian efforts of those who were engaged in improving the industrial conditions of the workers.
If it were suggested during the last 70 or 80 years ago that the Act of 1875 should be repealed, there would he a very strong revulsion of feeling. None of us is prepared to contest certain parts of the case that the Minister makes for this measure. The intention is good, but unfortunately good intentions form the macadam of the road to a certain place in the next world where a great many souls arrive. In order to achieve the purpose the Minister has in mind in connection with this measure he must get the maximum co-operation from those engaged in industrial occupations. He will not get that so long as this section remains in the Bill in its present form. Whatever changes he proposes to make in the measure, or whatever amendments he intends to bring in to make it more acceptable, this section is one which cannot stand in a measure of this sort with the very partial support, if any, that there is for the proposals in the country. No trade unionist could view such a section as this with composure. Their entire future is bound up with the chance they have of being recognised as a negotiation body. They may be placed in danger if they are not selected as a negotiation body, if any other trade union comes in and upsets them in that connection. A great many people agree with the Minister that there is room for improvement. I think the Labour Party believe that. Why then should we put anything in a measure of this sort which would make for disunion at a time when the Minister requires the maximum of co-operation from everybody? I suggest that in this situation, the section, with no provision whatever made for those societies which may not be passed as negotiators, is a very dangerous one, one which may possibly give rise to much greater industrial turmoil than the Bill proposes to remedy.
Comment on this
I do not think that anyone who can throw his mind back some 40 or 45 years and contemplate the conditions under which people had to work then and who considers the changes that have since taken place, can calmly consider the insertion of a section of this kind in the Bill. This Bill may be enacted but, so sure as it is, so surely will it be torn to bits by some succeeding Parliament. Humanity is not going to go back 100 years. People are not going to revert to the conditions under which men and women laboured when I was a boy. I would long regret if they had to do so.
A half a century ago the working classes were emerging from conditions of slavery. The conditions under which people worked and lived in the city of Belfast are not unknown to the Minister. I am sure he does not for get the earnest pleas of the late Mr. Joseph Devlin for the improvement of the conditions under which people were called upon to work. We are now asked to vote for a section of this kind. I think the appeal made last night by Deputy McGilligan is unanswerable He was dealing in a theoretical way with certain changes that took place in working conditions. I know for a fact that those changes took place, because I had experience of the conditions under which people worked years ago. I know what the unfortunate workers had to endure, and I do not want anybody here or elsewhere to go back to such conditions. So far as lies in my power, I would be prepared to resist a return to such conditions.
The case submitted by Deputy Costello and Deputy McGilligan was a very moderate and unanswerable case, in my opinion. During the last 50 years the workers have been emancipated from conditions amounting to slavery. We all realise the better conditions under which people now labour, and we are aware that because of that improvement the workers are in a position to give better service to their employers. The employer who does not observe that change does not deserve to be an employer. He is really standing in his own light. I am sure the Minister remembers when girls from seven to 14 years of age had to go to work at six in the morning on a breakfast consisting of a cup of tea and some dry bread. For dinner those children had probably the same thing, and there was no change in the evening meal. That was the position of mere children. This House cannot possibly conceive the conditions existing 40 and 50 years ago in the Belfast textile trade. I do not want the children of this country ever to endure such conditions.
Through the efforts and the wisdom of democrats, those conditions were remedied. The employers and the workers saw the wisdom of it. As a result, we have to-day healthier and more efficient workers. No child who is compelled to work from six o'clock in the morning until six in the evening is fit to give efficient service to anyone. It would be physically impossible for a child to do so. The physical and mental capacity of the workers half a century ago were so affected by the dreadful conditions under which they worked, that their output was not at all comparable with the output of the workers of to-day. If the Minister throws his mind back he will remember some of those conditions quite well. I am sure he heard about them often enough from the man who emancipated the Belfast workers, the late Mr. Joseph Devlin.
It would be a tragedy if we put this vicious section into the Bill. I thought, after the very moderate case submitted by Deputy McGilligan last night, that this section would be withdrawn for amendment. I hope that even at this hour the Minister will consider it wise to withdraw it.
Comment on this
In common with other Deputies, I should like to ask the Minister to withdraw this section. I do not know whether the Minister appreciates the effect of this section or the power contained in it. It is always in some tucked-away corner of Acts of Parliament that one finds the deadly blow and in this case, by reason of the inapplication of two sections of the Acts referred to in Section 10, my reading of the position is that unless a trade union actually receives a negotiation licence it will become an illegal body. It became necessary to insert Section 2 in the Act of 1871 for the purpose of legalising the object for which a trade union would be formed.
I take it the Minister does not contemplate, in this Bill, to render illegal any body which obtains a negotiation licence. I take it that it is the intention of the Minister to abolish a trade union unless such trade union is in possession of a negotiation licence, or unless it comes under the heading of the excepted bodies mentioned in the other section. The first point against this section is that, every trade union that is not an excepted body, or is not in receipt of a negotiation licence, is not entitled to the benefit of these two sections of the Act of Parliament which renders legal activities which would otherwise be illegal.
There was some reason, I think, in the Act of 1871 for putting in Section 2 at a very early stage. I think that as we are discussing these sections, in so far as they refer to trade unions generally, it would not be out of order to quote the Trade Union Act of 1871. It sets out:—
The purposes of any trade union shall not, by reason merely that they are in restraint of trade, be deemed to be unlawful so as to render any member of such trade union liable to criminal prosecution for conspiracy or otherwise.
Every member of every trade union, such trade union not having a negotiation licence or not being an excepted body within the meaning of the section we have already discussed, renders himself or herself liable to criminal prosecution and cannot plead the defence of Section 2. Is it the Minister's intention that all trade unions, other than those that get a negotiation licence or excepted bodies, will become illegal. Because, if it is, then he is carrying out that intention in Section 10. If it is not, then Section 10 does not carry out the Minister's intentions. I have dealt with the position in 1871. In order to make the position clearer, the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, was passed and that is more explicit still. Section 3 says:
An agreement or combination by two or more persons to do or procure to be done any act in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute between employers and workmen shall not be indictable as a conspiracy if such Act committed by one person would not be punishable as a crime.
Here again the effect will be that if any two employers or any two workmen meet together for the purpose of settleing a dispute, they would find themselves before long, if the powers were so willing, in the criminal court, facing a charge of conspiracy.
In the wisdom of their generation they started in 1871 and went on to 1875, and a whole statute was passed in 1906, but those are now sought to be done away with in connection with certain trade unions. The Trade Disputes Act, 1906 gave the right of peaceful picketing and set out the code under which bargains could be carried out between masters and men or between different trade unions. The whole effect of this section is that it will give the State power to put out of existence any particular body that conies within the definition of trade union at present, if that body does not comply, or is not allowed to comply with the section which permits it to be a negotiation body. With respect, I put that to the Minister and his advisers as the legal position.
There is a second objection to the section, and it is this, that it is 70 years ago exactly since Section 2 of the Trade Union Act, 1871, was passed, and during that period all who have grown, to man's estate, having lived in a certain atmosphere of law and appreciation of fundamental rights, know of the endeavours to ameliorate the lot of the people. But while it is very easy to do away with barriers and to increase, safeguards it is very difficult and very harsh to cut them away. We have been brought up and have lived in an atmosphere under which Section 2 of the Act of 1871 and Section 3 of the Act of 1875, and the whole Act of 1906 have become the statute law of this land and have been acted upon as part of the fundamental law. What is sought to be done will absolutely revolutionise everything now appreciated as law. I wish the Minister to realise that, while there are many intentions behind this Bill which are probably very good, I believe the most harmful section is Section 10, and I ask the Minister seriously to consider the position that will arise if it becomes the law of the land.
Comment on this
Having the right to reserve my intervention in tills debate until I had heard the rase made against the section I am now going to say that I was impressed by the speech which Deputy McGilligan made last night, particularly with reference to Section 2 of the Act of 1871 and Section 3 of the Act of 1875. I have had some doubts as to whether it was necessary to refer to these Acts at all for the purpose for which this section is introduced in the Bill. The House will remember that on the Second Reading the main focus of criticism was Section 6.(Interruptions.) I gathered that there were some members of the House who took an intelligent interest in the Bill and would like to hear my point of view.
Comment on this
I was saying that the burden of the attack on the Bill centred round Section 6 which, because it is necessary to preserve the natural right of people to discuss with each other the terms of employment, if they so desire, provided for what are known here as "an excepted body." It is alleged that this provision was introduced in order that we might encourage what is known as "shop unions," and criticism of the Bill centred entirely on that section.
Comment on this
A reference to the debates will bring that point out. I do not propose to endeavour to substantiate it here at the moment. In replying, I pointed out that Section 10 had been introduced as a deliberate discouragement to the formation of house unions, and so tar from house unions enjoying the special privileges that were alleged, Section 10 definitely places members of house unions at a disadvantage as compared with members of authorised trade unions holding a negotiation licence, in so far as it definitely reserves to the members of such authorised trade unions the privileges which are embodied in what I might describe as the Trade Union Acts. I was not at all certain that in order to ensure that there would be no encouragement for shop unions it was necessary to refer it all to Section 2 of the Trade Union Act, 1871, or Section 3 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, and I have been impressed by the speeches made by Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Cosgrave, and Deputy Esmonde. Deputy Esmonde pointed out that, perhaps, under the section as it stands any body of persons coming together, other than for the purpose of discussing and considering wages and conditions of employment might be held, in so far as "excepted" could be interpreted as constituting a restraint of trade, to be guilty of conspiracy. Accordingly, I have come to the conclusion that it is not necessary to retain Section 2 of the Trade Union Act, 1871, or Section 3 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, and on the Report Stage I will introduce an amendment to deal with the position.
Comment on this
Apart from our individual interest in the future of our unions under this section, and the Bill as a whole, if it ever becomes law, I know of no measure introduced here during my period of membership, new nearly 20 years, which has given such grounds for complaint to the community. I was one of the founders in this country of my own union, of which I have been a member continuously for 34 years. My colleagues and I know how in the early days of the organisation of trade unions, house unions were used by employers, against the efforts of those who were trying to establish legitimate trade unions. The Irish National Teachers' Organisation is being given the status if a house union under this Bill. I would be deeply interested to learn what Deputy Cormac Breathnach, and one or two other teacher-members of the Fianna Fáil Party, have to say about this proposal.
Comment on this
There are some teacher-members in the Labour Party, too.
Comment on this
If the Minister speaks again on this section, I should like to know from him whether he has been in consultation with the leaders of the Irish National Teachers' Organisation, and whether, as a democrat — I believe that at one time he was a member of the Independent Labour Party — or as one who poses as being a democrat, he has given any opportunity to the rank and file of the Irish National Teachers' Organisation to say whether they are willing to have their organisation reduced to the status of a house union inside the trade union movement.
The Minister read some extracts yesterday from a semi-confidential report which was submitted to the Irish Trade Union Congress in 1936. He appeared to build his whole case for the dragooning of the trade union movement in this country on the extracts which he read from that document and which suited his own point of view. I, like most, if not all of my colleagues, and of every other person in the country who has taken an active interest in the trade union movement, am prepared to say that there are justifiable grounds for tightening up the the trade union movement, but that can never be secured by a measure of this kind. All the power of the military and of the police, all the whispering agents which the Minister may have at his disposal, will not compel — to use the Minister's words last night — the trade unionists of this country to swallow this measure in its present form.
Comment on this
It is not in order for the Deputy to discuss the measure as a whole on this stage. He should confine himself to Section 10.
Comment on this
I am sure the Chair would realise, if it looked into the matter carefully that Section 10 hits at the heart of the existing trade union movement. It must be evident to anybody who studies the measure, and its implications that the object of Section 10, and of every section in the Bill, but of Section 10 in particular, is to weaken, if not to break, the existing trade union movement. The trade unionists of the country who lost jobs in order to make it possible to build up the existing organisation which, as I have said, may not be 100 per cent. correct are prepared to lose a little bit more in fighting the Minister and this measure, if and when it becomes law It is my considered opinion, for what it is worth, that the trade unionists of the country and trade union officials will not recognise this Bill if and when it becomes law in its present form. If the Minister is sincerely anxious, and I assume he is, to do the tightening up work which he thinks is necessary inside the trade union movement, why does he not attempt it by means of consultation, negotiation and agreement, especially in present circumstances? As I have already said the Minister read from the contents of a report which was submitted to the Trade Union Congress at its annual conference in 1936, in which particulars were given of the position at that time. But the conditions prevailing then were quite different from those of the present time. If the Minister speaks again on the section, I should like him to give the House the number of hours of labour lost by trade unionists in this country during last year, from any cause whatever, and particularly if these can be attributed to the alleged jealousies and rivalries between trade unionists and trade union officials.
Comment on this
I think that question could have been more properly raised on Sections 6, 7, 8, and 9, which have already been discussed.
Comment on this
This section proposes to reorganise the existing trade unions, to make some which are now legitimate trade unions mere house unions if and when the Bill becomes law in its present form. It goes further, as Deputy Breathnach and the few Fianna Fáil Deputies who sit in silence behind the Minister know. they know, as well as I know, that when the trade union movement is reorganised in accordance with the Minister's wishes we will have, as the brother-in-law of this Bill, to see that the trade unions as reorganised will not be allowed to function——
Comment on this
——the Emergency Powers No. 83 Order. If and when this Bill becomes law, it will be there to prevent the reorganised union from functioning on behalf of their members. The Minister knows that quite well.
Comment on this
The Deputy must come back to Section 10. He is making what is practically a Second Reading speech on the Bill.
Comment on this
I know there is a certain amount of filling in stuff in the 28 sections of this Bill but Section 10 is not to be described as such.
Comment on this
Certain trade unions which are now in existence, and which sue their members insurance rights, will be disbanded when this Bill becomes law. The members of the dahanded unions will have their insurance rights lapsed according to law, if and when this Bill becomes law.
Comment on this
They, possibly, will become horse unions. One will be the Irish National Teachers' Organisation, of which Deputy Breathnach was at one tune the honoured President. This Bill, and this section of the Bill in particular, was horn inside the secret chamber of the Chambers of Commerce and in the offices of the Federation of Irish Industry. The members sitting on these benches have known for a long time that certain leaders in the Chambers of Commerce, and in the Federation of Irish Industry, have, even in their own journals, been advocating the introduction and passage of this measure. This section has been advocated by certain employers who do not give a damn about the neutrality of this country, about who invades it or when it is invaded. They know, as well as I know, that if the trade unions of this country refuse to recognise this Bill, if and when it becomes law, it is going to endanger the peace, security and safety of this State.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce who was at one time a member of the Independent Labour Party to reconsider the whole position if he does not want trouble in the country.
Comment on this
I am sorry that Deputy Davin should so far forget himself as to bring himself into the position in which the Minister was yesterday when he suggested that Deputy Norton was setting himself up as the leader of the Moscow Fifth Columnists in this country. I think it is unfair that Irish employers should have their names associated with this Bill.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy very nearly approached the Minister's standard when he spoke of employers, as an organised body, being in any way related to this Bill. I find it impossible, I admit, to understand the Minister in connection with this Bill. It is of such a nature that, from the point of view of Christian charity alone, I should hesitate to pass on the blame for it any more than is necessary.
Comment on this
It is because we sire discussing Section 10, that I am making these remarks about the unfairness of Deputy Davin's statement.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation, docs the Deputy read Irish Industry which speaks for somebody?
Comment on this
I would advise the Deputy, if he wants to make the Federation of Irish Employers responsible for any publication, a Bill or other, that he should examine the matter a little more closely, before jumping at conclusions. I do not want to labour that further. We are all familiar with the saying of "putting the cart before the horse." If ever the cart was put before the horse, the horse being then turned backwards and having large nails stuck into it to help it to travel, we have an example of that sort of thing in tins section. We are out to introduce harmony into industrial life here. This Bill does not provide any machinery for stopping strikes. Section 10 confirms to those who hold negotiation licences all the rights that existed under legislation up to the present to carry on strikes in the good old-fashioned way. I notice that the Minister calls these "privileges." He rather emphasises that the rights won by legislation, which have proved so useful in improving the position of the working class, are to he called "privileges." I do not know how many people in the House regard them as privileges. I think that anything conferred on people by legislation might, reasonably, be described as "rights."
The Minister has indicated that he is going to drop the reference to Section 2 of the 1871 Act and to Section 3 of the 1875 Act and that he is going to withdraw from anybody who does not hold a negotiation licence the rights secured to all trade unions under the Trade Disputes Act, 1906. It would be very important to know what exactly he means. Section 2 of the Trade Union Act, provides:—
"The purposes of any trade union shall not, by reason merely that they are in restraint of trade, be deemed to be unlawful so as to render any member of such trade union liable to criminal prosecution for conspiracy or otherwise."
The Minister says he is withdrawing that, so that a trade union which is not in possession of a negotiation licence will, so far as we can read the present riddle, still have the right to interfere in a way that will restrain trade without bringing themselves outside the law. I have to read Section 3 of the Act of 1875, because the Trade Disputes Act, 1906, makes an addition to it. While Section 3 of the 1875 Act is to go by the board, the addition made to it by the Trade Disputes Act, 1906, is to be held against people who have not a negotiation licence. For the information of the House, I shall quote Section 3 of the 1875 Act:—
An agreement or combination by two or more persons to do or procure to be done any act in contemplation of furtherance of a trade dispute between employers and workmen shall not be indictable as a conspiracy if such act committed by one person would not be punishable as a crime. Nothing in this section shall exempt from punishment any persons guilty of a conspiracy for which a punishment is awarded by any Act of Parliament. Nothing in this section shall affect the law relating to riot, unlawful assembly, breach of the peace or sedition, or any offence against the State or the Sovereign. A crime for the purposes of this section means an offence punishable on summary conviction, and for the commission of which the offender is liable under the statute making the offence punishable to be imprisoned either absolutely or at the discretion of the court as an alternative for some other punishment. Where a person is convicted of any such agreement or combination as aforesaid to do or procure to be done an act which is punishable only on summary conviction, and is sentenced to imprisonment, the imprisonment shall not exceed three months or such longer time, if any, as may have been prescribed by the statute for the punishment of the said act when committed by one person.
That is to go by the board. Persons who do not hold a negotiation licence are still to have these rights retained to them but people who have not got a negotiation licence will not in future have the benefit of the Trade Disputes Act, 1906. Section 1 of the Trade Disputes Act, 1906, added a paragraph to Section 3 of the 1875 Act which I have just quoted. Section 1 of the Trade Disputes Act says:—
"The following paragraph shall be added as a new paragraph after the first paragraph of Section 3 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875:—
An act done in pursuance of an agreement or combination by two or more persons shall, if done in contemplation or furtherance of a, trade dispute, not be actionable unless the act, if done without any such agreement or combination, would be actionable."
That means that, even though an act would not in itself be actionable, if a party, consisting of two or more persons, not holding a negotiation licence, does the act in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute, it will he actionable by reason of the fact that it is so done. That is being held against people who do not hold a negotiation licence. What has the Minister in mind? What none of us is able to find out is what is the long scale of punishment that lies behind this section, even with the 1871 and 1875 provisions taken out? It strikes me that what the Minister had in mind last night in connection with Deputy McGilligan's comments was the suggestion that 1871 was a long time ago and that 1875 was a long time ago and that he does not want to appear to be taking from people rights which they got in 1871 and 1875, but it does not sound so badly when you come to 1906. If Deputies consider what is being granted by the Minister under his withdrawal and what is still being retained, they will have difficulty in ascertaining that anything is left. Section 2 of the 1900 Act says:
"It shall be lawful for one or more persons, acting on their behalf or on behalf or a trade union or of an individual employer or firm in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute, to attend at or near a house or place where a person resides or works or carries on business or happens to be, if they so attend merely for the purpose of peacefully obtaining or communicating information, or of peacefully persuading any person to work or abstain from work."
That right is to be withdrawn from people who cannot put up £2,000. I do not know what the penalties are to be on persons who may be found guilty of peaceful picketing. Section 3 of the 1900 Act says::—
"An act done by a person in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute shall not be actionable on the ground only that it induces some other person to break a contract of employment or that it is an interference with the trade, business, or employment of some other person, or with the right of some other person to dispose of his capital or his labour as he wills."
What exactly does the Minister ask us to think he is doing when be removes Section 2 of the Act of 1871 and leaves this other provision in? Section 2 of the 1871 Act says that the purposes of any trade union shall not, by reason merely that they are in restraint of trade, be deemed to be unlawful so as to render any member liable to prosecution for conspiracy or otherwise. Here we have an act which is
"an interference with the trade, business or employment of some other person, or with the right of some other person to dispose of his capital or his labour as he wills."
I am reading there again Section 3 of the 1906 Act and I am asking how does the Minister arrange that he is going to allow a person rights under Section 2 of the Act of 1871 and to deprive him of the rights given under Section 3 of the Act of 1906?
Section 4 of the 1906 Act says:
"An action against a trade union, whether of workmen or of masters or against any members or officials thereof, on behalf of themselves and all other members of the trade union in respect of any tortious act, alleged to have been committed by or on behalf of the trade union shall not be entertained by any court."
A group without a negotiation licence is going to be deprived of that protection. The Minister has not been quite as explicit or quite as frank with the House as he might have been, considering that he has stated that he was impressed with the arguments put up. We should like to have from the Minister a schedule of the punishments that lie at the back of this section. I have said that it deprives persons who are trade unionists, but who have not a negotiation licence, of the rights of protection they get under the Trade Disputes Act. We ought to know what punishments we are laying up in store for these organisations throughout the country as the Minister, by implication, confesses that he does not know what is going to be done about them — the Tipperary Workers' Organisation, the Dundalk Workers' Organisation and the road workers even. If the Minister has been persuaded by the speeches made by Deputy McGilligan last night and by Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Esmonde to-day, let us see the nature of his conviction.
To my mind, looking at the terms of the three Acts to which I have referred, the fact that the Minister is deleting the references to Section 2 of the Act of 1875 and Section 3 of the Act of 1871 is no contribution in any way to the appeasement of the situation so long as persons who do not hold a negotiation licence are being deprived of the benefits and the rights of the Trade Disputes Act of 1906. I think the Minister ought to take the House frankly into his confidence and if he still persists in his attitude, as regards the Trade Disputes Act he should tell the House what are the penalties that are involved by retaining the reference to that Act in the section.
Comment on this
The Minister told us that he was so impressed with certain arguments which he had heard in connection with this matter that he proposes to delete, at a later stage, the references to Section 2 of the Trade Union Act of 1871 and Section 3 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, but he is taking very good care to leave in the reference to the Trade Disputes Act, 1906. The effect of doing that is to deprive a union which has not a negotiation licence, that is an excepted organisation, from the enjoyment of the natural rights to withdraw its labour, to deny it the right to withhold its labour if it is not paid a decent price for that labour. Every Papal Encyclical, every tenet of Catholic thought has expressed itself on the side of the right of the worker to withdraw his labour and of not being put in the position of being forced to sell his labour at any price the employer may choose to pay. Under the section as it stands, the Minister is still preventing trade unions from enjoying the rights which are set out in the Trade Disputes Act of 1906. It is important that the House should know what, in fact, the unions will lose under Section 10. It might be no harm, therefore, to quote the terms of the Trade Disputes Act of 1906 because that particular Act is a vital charter so far as trade unions are concerned, a charter of which they are going to be deprived by Section 10 of this Bill as it now stands.
It is a long time since 1906. In 1906 there was an agitation in this country which did not give the British Government much credit for any enlightened view in respect of conceptions, or high standards, of freedom. Although it is 35 years since the British Parliament passed that measure, and although we might very rightly claim, after the lapse of the intervening period, to have leached a somewhat better standard and a better conception of freedom and liberty, particularly for the masses of the people, yet we deliberately in this section set out to go back Beyond the period of 1906. In fact, what we are really doing is going back to 1825, before the repeal of the anti-combination laws. That is what is proposed by this enlightened Fianna Fáil Government — to put the workers of the country back to the period of 1825. That is the Fianna Fáil conception of progress — back to 1825.
It is very important that the House should know what in fact the 1906 Act gave to trade unions. In that year an alien Government enacted this Act. It said:—
"Be it enacted by the King's Most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords Spiritual and Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—
"1. The following paragraph shall be added as a new paragraph after the first paragraph of Section 3 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875:—
"‘An act done in pursuance of an agreement or combination by two or more persons shall, it done in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute, not be actionable unless the act, if done without any such agreement or combination, would be actionable.'"
Section 2 provides for peaceful picketing in these terms:—
"(1) It shall be lawful for one or more persons, acting on their own behalf or on behalf of a trade union or of an individual employer or firm in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute, to attend at or near a house or place where a person resides or works or carries on business or happens to be, if they so attend merely for the purpose of peacefully obtaining or communicating information, or of peacefully persuading any person to work or abstain from working.
(2) Section seven of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, is hereby repealed from attending at or near to the end of the section."
Section 3 relates to the removal of liability for interfering with another person's business, etc. It provides:—
"An act done by a person in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute shall not he actionable on the ground only that it induces some other person to break a contract of employment or that it is an inter ference with a trade, business, or employment of some other person, or with the right of some other person to dispose of his capital or ins labour as he wills."
Section 4 prohibits actions of tort against trade unions in these terms:—
"An action against a trade union whether of workmen or of masters, or against any members or officials thereof on behalf of themselves and all other members of the trade union in respect of any tortious act alleged to have been committed by or on behalf of the trade unions, shall not he entertained by any court.
(2) Nothing in this section shall affect the liability of the trustees of a trade union to be sued in the events provided for by the Trade Union Act, 1871, section nine, except in respect of any tortious act committed by or on behalf of the union in contemplation or in furtherance of a trade dispute."
Section 5 reads:—
"(1) This Act may be cited as the Trade Disputes Act, 1906, and the Trade Union Acts, 1871 and 1876, and this Act may be cited together as the Trade Union Acts, 1871 to 1906.
(2) In this Act the expression ‘trade union' has the same meaning as in the Trade Union Acts, 1871 and 1876, and shall include any combination as therein defined, notwithstanding that such combination may be the branch of a trade union.
(3) In this Act and in the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, the expression `trade dispute' means any dispute between employers and workmen, or between workmen and workmen, which is connected with the employment or non-employment, or the terms of the employment, or with the conditions of labour, of any person, and the expression `workmen' means all perons employed in trade or industry, whether or not in the employment of the employer with whom a trade dispute arises: and, in section three of the last mentioned Act, the words between `employers and workmen' shall he repealed."
That was generally regarded as a very valuable piece of legislation from the point of view of the trade unions. It gave them a new status, a new strength, a new dignity before the law, and carried on the general process of not regarding their beneficial activities as conspiratorial activities, such as were contemplated by earlier conspiracy Acts. Nobody in the country in which this legislation was passed would dream to-day of impeding unions in the enjoyment of the rights conshrined in that Act, but in this country in a Bill which is falsely represented as a Bill to assist and encourage trade unionism a section is embodied to deprive workers who do not hold a negotiation licence of the enjoyment of the rights which were given them 35 years ago by an alien Assembly.
Let us see what can happen under this Bill. A house union may exist. An employer may insist on encouraging the establishment of a house union and may say that it is a condition of employment in his establishment that the staff must be members of that house union, which will be his own creature. The employer — and he may well be an alien employer from Whitechapel, Poland or some other place — may say to the workers: "I propose to reduce your wages by 10/- per week." The wages may be already low, but the employer may come along unscrupulously and reduce them by 10/- per week. The employees in his house union may protest against an already low wage being made still lower, but they cannot go on strike. They may stay at home, if they like, and, so far, under this Bill they cannot be compelled to work for that man. They cannot be dragooned into his employment. They can stay at home and they can be hungry. The State will deprive them of unemployment insurance and unemployment assistance, of course, on the ground that they left their employment, but they cannot picket that man's premises. They cannot say to the Irish people: " This alien employer, who enjoys a substantial tariff from this Government, has reduced our wages by 10/-per week and we are now paid much lower wages than are paid by his competitors in the same industry." They will not be allowed to say that to anybody outside, nor will they be allowed to carry a simple placard saying: "This boss has reduced our wages by 10/- per week." If they do that, they are guilty of an offence and are liable to prosecution under the ordinary common law.
What the Minister is doing under this section is protecting every unscrupulous employer who may have a house union in his pocket and preventing the employees of that employer from ever going on strike, no matter how unfairly they may be treated, or by how much the employer reduces their wages. That may he done in the interests of an unscrupulous type of employer who has come into this country in recent years, the type of employer who does not accept some of the practices which, I am glad to say, are recognised by the best-class Irish employers. Under this section, it would be an offence for the employees of such an employer to go on strike. They are prohibited from doing so and all the advantages of the 1906 Act are taken from them. I should like to find out from the Minister why he insists on jumping into the ring on behalf of the bosses. I do not think it is even his job to keep the ring. Unless the Constitution is a greater humbug than I think it is, I think the function of the Minister of Industry and Commerce, under Article 45, is to come in on behalf of the weaker sections, to stand behind them and to prevent their position and their economic needs being exploited by a stronger class. I do not think his function is merely to keep the ring, but to be in on the side of the workers, helping them in every possible way and endeavouring to raise their standard of living in every possible way. The Minister, however, does not propose to do that under this section. He does not even propose to keen the ring. He has come into the ring on this occasion on the side of the bosses, and he is preventing the employees of such an employer from going on strike, no matter in what rascally way these employees may be treated by the unscrupulous employer.
Will the Minister tell us why it is necessary for him to line up with the bosses? Will the members of the Fianna Fáil Party tell us why it is necessary for them to line up with the bosses, because every vote for Section 10 is a vote for lining up with the bosses against the workers, for depriving the workers of their weapon of the strike and peaceful picketing? Will Deputy Cormac Breathnach tell us why he will go into the Division Lobby in support of Section 10 to allow an unscrupulous alien employer to sweat Irish workers, and to prevent Irish workers from telling the Irish people that that unscrupulous alien employer will not pay decent rates of wages? The workers of Dublin are entitled to know why Deputy Breathnach wants to line up with the bosses, even if his own boss, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, wants to do so.
Comment on this
From the statement the Minister made I presume he is now agreeing that Section 2 of the Act of 1871 and Section 3 of the Act of 1875 will apply to combinations of workers, even if they are not a recognised trade union under this Act?
Comment on this
I presume, therefore, that these two sections have not been repealed by the Act of 1906, so far as strikes are concerned?
Comment on this
Good. Will not the position then be this: that a number of employees who are not members of a recognised trade union in this Act will have the right to strike?
Comment on this
In other words, to strike. But the men who have the right to strike will have no right, unless they are members of a recognised trade union, to discuss and negotiate with their employers as to what the strike is all about.
Comment on this
All right. I shall make the point again. They will have the right to strike. That is clear, both from the Act of 1871 and the Act of 1875.
Comment on this
The Deputy had better make his case or make his point and I shall deal with the matter afterwards — if necessary.
Comment on this
Now, the point is this. As the intention of the Minister now is before us, a number of workers, one or more, may withdraw their labour; in other words, may strike or agree to strike, and they are perfectly legal in doing so, but they have no right to discuss with their employer why they are striking or trying to prevent a strike. Anything more absurd than that, I cannot well imagine.
Comment on this
We are somewhat under a difficulty in dealing with this because of the Minister's silence, and I am going to look for some information, although whether I shall get it or not I do not know. The Minister, apparently, holds a different view, in so far as he has given any view in regard to anything, in the House, as to what this section will mean if it becomes law. I want to put the following case to the Minister. Some years ago, there was a strike in a certain town in my constituency It was a very bitter strike, and by " bitter" I mean as between the employers and the employees. It was a big creamery strike. It went on for eight or nine weeks, and as the strike went on, feelings became more bitter and it led to assaults on the workers by some of the farmers and to retaliation by the workers in attacking the farmers and spilling the milk and the contents of the tankards on the roads. Several efforts, I understand, were made to settle that strike. Ultimately, I was asked by some of the workers to see if I could do anything to bring about a settlement, and although I was not connected with a trade union — I was pot even a member of the Labour Party at the time — after some negotiations and some travelling to-and-fro between the creamery committee and the workers concerned. I succeeded in having a settlement that was acceptable to both sides. If that position were to arrive to-morrow, would I, or any other person in my position. approached by either one side or the other to bring about a settlement in that type of dispute, be committing an offence? It seems to me that I would.
Comment on this
No person, under this section, can attempt peacefully to persuade any worker or group of workers to work, or try to settle a dispute.
Comment on this
At any rate, the Minister has not made any attempt to explain this section to the House or to the country.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not here when this section was being discussed at the beginning. He came in here during the last half hour, and I am not going over the whole discussion again for his benefit.
Comment on this
Yes. There is nothing in Section 10 which deals with the efforts of an intermediary to settle a strike.
Comment on this
I agree to some extent with the Minister, but the application of other Acts to this Bill gives a wide scope to its discussion and to the implications and references.
Comment on this
Am I entitled, Sir, to put a point of order There should not be two Deputies on their feet. I am intervening to make a point of order.
Comment on this
I have not been ruled out of order. The House has heard, twice recited. Sections 2, 3, 4 and 5 of the Trade Disputes Act of 1908, which is the only Act now in regard to Section 10. There is nothing in any of these sections relating to the efforts of an intermediary to settle a strike. They relate entirely to the efforts of persons who are endeavouring to prevent people from working. I am putting the point of order to you. Sir, that Deputy Morrissey is not in order on this section.
Comment on this
The Minister, before he made the point of order, tried to make another point, nearly as good as the point of order. He tried to make the point that I had not been here in the House or had not heard what he said.
Comment on this
I attempted to read what the Minister thinks he said yesterday, and I read some other speeches that were made that were much more important, but I think it would have been a very good thing for the Minister himself if he himself had been absent from this House yesterday, if one can judge from the newspaper reports of what he said.
Comment on this
If the Minister refers to me in the way he has, Sir, am I not entitled to reply to him?
Comment on this
I am not the person to introduce personalities here. Sir, — most often I am the subject of them — but I say that it would be far better for the Minister and for the country generally if he had not been here yesterday. One finds it difficult to understand whether his silence or his speech was the more harmful. I am putting the point and putting the case to the Minister because he has failed to do his job. It is his duty, when introducing a Bill, or putting a Bill through this House in Committee, to introduce each section to the House and explain the effect of each section to the House. Will he tell us how many members of this House, he thinks, have gone to the trouble of reading up the Act of 1871, the Act of 1875, and the Act of 19061 We would not be troubled with Section 10 if the Minister understood what it means. I shall go so far as to credit him with this, that I do not think we would be troubled with Section 10, much less the Bill itself, if the Minister had the faintest idea of what is going to flow from it.
Deputy O'Sullivan, a moment ago, pointed out one of the absurd positions that are going to arise. There are an employer and an employee in a house union formed by the employer himself. They cannot negotiate. The Minister again s that they can strike, and the main purpose of this Bill, so far as it has a purpose at all, according to the Minister, is to reduce industrial unrest and strikes. One of the effects of this section, if carried, we are told, will be that an employer cannot discuss with his employees why their hours should ho lengthened or why their wages should be reduced.
Comment on this
Is it possible, Sir, to discuss this section without referenrcs to Section. The Minister himself, when he intervened for a few moments on this section, discussed lection 6. On this very section, he discussed Section 6. As a matter of fact, his words applied far more to Section 6 than to Section 10. The only reference he made to Section 10 was that, having been convinced by speeches made by Deputy McGilligan and others that it would not be wise to leave in the 1871 and 1875 provisions, he is taking them out, but he did not utter one word to this House as to why he is going to retain the Act of 1906. Notwithstanding the fact that Deputies Mulcahy and Norton have quoted particular sections of it, practically the Act itself, the Minister yet does not think it worth his while to make any reference to it. Then, when we endeavour to extract information from the Minister, so as to enable the House to come to an intelligent decision on-this matter, he immediately tries to stop discussion by raising frivolous points of order. The Minister is very anxious to restrict the debate to Section 10. Now, you can have a Bill introduced to this House and there might be ninety sections in it, but the whole Bill can very well be in one section. The Minister, in the course of his few words on this section, also said that the main point made against this Bill on Second Reading was on Section 6. That is not so. Important and all as Section 6 is, that was not the main point of the debate. The fact is that the whole volume of opposition in this House to this Bill was to the Bill as a whole.
The Minister, apparently, does not himself understand this Bill. He certainly does not understand the implications of the Bill. Apparently he has no idea whatever of what is going to flow from the passage of the Bill into law because, if he understood the Bill, he would not now be trying to trip me up on this section on the point that I have made certain references to what is contained in Section 6. He would not speak on this particular section himself without speaking on Section 6. I would like the Minister and the House to realise that this is a very important. Bill — I said this on Second Reading— probably the most important Bill that has come before this House for a number of years, and this is a very important section of the Bill. I only hope and pray, as I said before, that when this Bill becomes law, if it does become law, and is put into force the Minister and the Government may not find themselves faced with a far greater problem than they had to deal with before they set out to wipe out any union in this country — the road union, the town union, or the village union— any union that cannot put up £2,000 at least. That is Section 10 in a nutshell.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey was seeking guidance on a point as to what would happen to a negotiator who was trying to do something in the interests of industrial peace, individually. He was not conceded that information. He was told, practically, that he was dealing with Section 6 when he should be confining himself to Section 10. I consider Section 10 is no more and no less than the penalty clause for offences under Section 6. I referred on the Second Reading of this Bill to a very important and useful section of the community who have been doing very good work, unostentatiously, and who are going to be put out of action. I want to ask the same question in regard to these people as Deputy Morrissey has asked in regard to the individual. What will become of or what will be the penalty on a trades council who try to offer their good offices to settle a dispute between employer and employee? Under this section they have no right.
Comment on this
I have already informed Deputy Morrissey, through the Chair, that there is nothing in this section that deals with any person or affects any person who is trying to settle a dispute. It only deals with people who are trying to foment and encourage dispute.
Comment on this
I am suggesting that this section and its contemporary. Section 6, is striking at a very vital function and there is nothing being put back in its place for the maintenance of industrial harmony in the country. The Minister does not seem to give any attention to that point. I have spoken of my own experience in my own city and I know it happens in other cities and towns where these bodies of workers who are affiliated from respective unions come together. They go over to the employers and the employees to try to produce settlements of disputes that are pending or in embryo stages. In many cases they have been able to settle disputes—in fact in most cases—before the intervention of the Minister's official was called for. Where the local efforts have failed it has been the practice of the Minister for Industry and Commerce— and the present Minister's predecessor, notably — to send some of his officials through the country — which took a lot of their time — trying to bring about settlements of industrial disputes. I suggest, if it had not been for the good action and offices of the local trades councils you would have a whole-time staff of the Minister's officials doing this job. If the Minister will tell me that the trades councils can still carry on their functions, I will sit down immediately as far as this is concerned.
Comment on this
Has not the Minister already so stated? I am not conversant with the possible implications of the Acts mentioned as here amended.
Comment on this
What 1 did draw your attention to was this — by the way, I may point out that the Trade Disputes Act, 1906, has already been read twice, if not three times, in the course of the discussion of this section — that the Act in question merely restricts the activities of persons who are taking part in a trade dispute. The Deputy is now asking me what is the question of a trades council who would seek to mediate. That point does not arise under this section. That is the point of order I made.
Comment on this
The penalty is here. As has been pointed out earlier by Deputy O'Sullivan, a small section of workers can go on strike but they dare not discuss the reason of the strike with the employer, and if they go to seek the good offices of a collection of men who are associated together——
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I point out that that is fully covered by Section 6 and there is nothing in Section 6 which would justify the assertion which the Deputy has made.
Comment on this
Section 10 reads as follows:—
"(1) Section 2 of the Trade Union Act, 1871, Section 3 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, and the Trade Disputes Act, 1906, shall apply only in relation to authorised trade unions which for the time being are holders of negotiation licences and the members and officials of such trade unions, and not otherwise.
" (2) This section shall come into operation on the same date as Section 6 of this Act comes into operation."
I suggest that that particular section us it stands prohibits anybody, either individuals or collections of individuals, except those holding negotiation licences, from having anything to do with the settlement of industrial disputes. The Minister may read it any way he likes. They are withdrawing from people the right to do work they used to do in the country. I ask the Minister what is he putting in its place?
Comment on this
It is not a function of the Chair to interpret every section of this Bill. If the Deputy gives his interpretation — quite legitimately and honestly, I am sure— the Chair cannot interfere.
Comment on this
The Chair did not indicate assent or dissent to the Deputy's interpretation. Interpretation is not my function.
Comment on this
If the Minister would sive an explanation of each section there would not be half of this.