We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Trade Union Bill, 1941—Committee (Resumed—Section 10).

Contributions 131–262 of 262. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Trade Union Bill, 1941
Enacted

No. 9 of 1941 ›

I put a point, Sir. I think I am entitled to that interpretation if I can read the thing correctly or intelligently. I suggest that the Minister should attempt to deal with the question on a broad basis, having regard to the honesty with which I have put my question and the purpose I have behind it, instead of trying to evade the issue. He has put nothing in its place. He keeps getting up, looking for points of order and rulings. He has done so three or four times before you, Sir, came in and he has done so three or four times since you came in. I say that is not a serious way to deal with the matter with which he is dealing. He has come in here to introduce this Bill without giving proper study to it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must come down to this section.

Comment on this

Section 10—with Section 6 — is unquestionably one of the most serious blots in that Bill. If the Minister is honest in his protestations that he is not striking at the trade union movement, why is that objectionable section there? What is the necessity for it? What useful purpose is it intended to serve, and how does the Minister propose to cope with the disorder and chaos which it will cause in operation?

Comment on this

In this discussion there has been a certain amount of confusion because of irrelevancies introduced by the Minister, and perhaps others, and I think it would be well to endeavour to focus the attention of the House on the real position which arises under Section 10. Members of the House know that there are two distinct and separate types of unions recognised under this Bill — unions possessed of negotiation licences, and other unions not so possessed. The view has been expressed, and the Minister has not met it in any way, that unions not possessed of negotiation licences will be seriously harassed and affected, as well as any other people coming to their assistance, if they seek to indulge in negotiations, or in the action following disputes which has been hitherto the legitimate privilege of any trade union. Section 2 of the Trade Union Act, 1871, is as follows:—

"The purposes of any trade union shall not, by reason merely that they are in restraint of trade, be deemed to be unlawful so as to render any member of such trade union liable to criminal prosecution for conspiracy or otherwise."

That privilege has been withdrawn. That privilege will definitely be withdrawn from certain trade unions in this country. The Minister says that is not so. I would ask the Minister to show us in this measure any provision of kind that safeguards people in the position I have mentioned. The Minister takes refuge in the fact that there are certain excepted bodies. Will the Minister show us any portion of the measure that covers the excepted bodies? The teachers in this country some time ago found it necessary to organise a one-day strike. The teachers are an excepted body. If they resort to action of that kind in the future will they be permitted under this measure to do it or will they be subject to the penalties provided in this Bill? The Minister's policy in this whole matter has simply gone mad; even now, the Minister would do something to mitigate the feeling of hostility which this whole measure has aroused if he would endeavour to face up to the particularly dangerous parts of this measure which have provoked a great ideal of that hostility. I want the Minister to make some reasonable contribution to the discussion on this particular matter, and to point out how he thinks that certain trade unions in this position, and their agents and assistants, will not be subject to the penalties that were provided as far back as the time when the anti-combination laws were repealed, I think, in 1825.

Surely if is about time that a harking back to a situation of that kind was entirely forgotten. Surely it is time that the Minister should adopt a more progressive viewpoint and outlook in regard to this whole measure than the viewpoint which was given effect to in the situation which arose when the anti-combination laws were repealed. The Minister's whole attitude in relation to this section and other sections has been anything but helpful to the conduct of an orderly discussion on the whole matter.

Comment on this

If I understood the Deputy correctly, I think he is under a misapprehension. I have already indicated to the House that I propose to bring in an amendment which will delete the reference to Section 2 of the Act of 1871, and to Section 3 of the Act of 1875, but as far as the Act of 1906 is concerned, it must remain. It must remain for this reason, that I do not intend that anything in this Bill should encourage the formation of house unions. It has been stated that paragraph (3) (a) of Section 6 of the Bill would encourage the formation of such unions. That was never the intention. That was deliberately not the intention when the Bill was being drafted, and Section 10 is in here, not for the purpose of depriving trade unions, authorised trade unions, of the rights and privileges which they enjoy under the Act of 1906, but to confirm them in those rights and in those privileges, and to confine those rights and privileges to authorised trade unions only. I cannot see how, in the light of that, any Deputy could, with a full cognisance of what he was saying, allege, as Deputy Norton alleged, that this Bill, and this section particularly, was directed against trade unions.

The next point with which I want to deal is this: It has been suggested here that if an employer and his workmen have a difference in relation to wages or conditions of employment, that employer and his workmen cannot negotiate. As far as the Bill stands at the present moment, paragraph (3) (a) of Section 6 is definitely put in to preserve that right to an employer and his employees to negotiate with each other. Therefore, the suggestion which has been made here that if men go out on strike they and their employer cannot get together to settle the strike is without any solid foundation.

The third point, which has been made by Deputy Davin, indicates what has so often transpired during the course of this debate — that some of the people who are criticising this Bill have not read it and do not understand it. Deputy Davin made the suggestion that, under paragraph (c) — which recites that an excepted body means any organisation of teachers recognised by the Minister for Education — the Irish National Teachers' Organisation, being presumably a body which would be recognised by the Minister for Education, would be an excepted body under the Act. Of course it would be an excepted body under the Act. All that means is that, in order to discuss wage's and conditions of employment with their employers and with the Minister, it is not necessary for that National Teachers' Organisation to register itself as a trade union and pay the necessary deposit. That is, if it wishes to conduct these negotiations and if its sole object is to conduct negotiations and try to yet a peaceful settlement of differences of opinion in relation to wages and conditions of employment. If, however, the National Teachers' Organisation wishes to go further— whether it would be judicious for it to do so or not is another matter — and to secure for itself all the rights of authorised trade unions under Section 10, there is nothing in this Bill which would prevent the National Teachers' Organisation registering itself as a trade union, making the necessary deposit and securing a negotiation licence.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that it is possible for the excepted bodies under Section 6 (3) to escape being excepted bodies by making a deposit of £2,000?

Comment on this

All the section says is that it shall not be lawful for any body of persons, not being an excepted body, to carry on such negotiations. It would be lawful for an excepted body to carry on negotiations, but if excepted bodies wish to convert themselves into authorised trade unions— and their character lends itself to that conversion — there is nothing in this Bill to prevent them from securing a negotiation licence as such. In fact, the Irish National Teachers' Organisation is registered already as a trade union. As a trade union, the only thing that is necessary for that body, in order to secure a negotiation licence and secure, if it wishes, the particular privileges of Section 10, is to make the necessary deposit.

Apparently Deputy Davin—who has been so voluble here in discussing this section—had not adverted to that fact, and alleged that the National Teachers' Organisation would be affected by Section 10. A number of questions arising out of that were put to Deputy Breathnach. The only thing that was clear from the questions Deputy Davin put was that, as so many other people opposing this Bill have shown, he has not studied nor read the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not believe it is possible to do as the Minister suggested in respect of the teachers' organisation. I would like to know if the Minister has any advice on that matter from the Attorney-General. It seems to me to be quite clear from Section 6 (3) that certain bodies are automatically labelled "excepted bodies."

Comment on this

That does not matter.

Comment on this

The labelling of them as excepted bodies is not going to be alleged as an unrestricted right to be an organisation——

Comment on this

Would the Deputy, if he believes that, and if he wishes the House to believe it, read sub-section (1) of Section 6?

Comment on this

I have read it.

Comment on this

Read it to the House and the House will see the foundation on which the Deputy is basing his argument.

Comment on this

The Minister was objecting when the Act of 1906 was read. Whether they can register or not as organised trade unions is beside the point. The fact of the matter is that under Section 10 we are withdrawing from certain organisations the right to the protection which is afforded them under the Trade Disputes Act of 1906. Under that Act it is possible for a trade union organisation — which means it is possible for any seven people — to withdraw the labour of their members and to picket the premises of an employer, alien or native, who is paying low wages or enforcing bad conditions of labour. It is possible for them to picket that employer's premises in furtherance of a trade dispute which is caused by the action of that employer in reducing the rates of wages paid to such workers. Under Section 10, if that organisation in future happens to be an organisation catering for workers employed by the same employer, that organisation cannot picket the premises of that employer and it has none of the protection afforded by the Trade Disputes Act.

Let us take an example. Suppose, for instance, that all the employees of the Sugar Company decided to establish a sugar workers' union and the Sugar Company decided that it was necessary, in order to secure employment with the company, that the employees should be members of this sugar workers' union. In that case it would be a house union and would not be required to put down £2,000 deposit. They could carry on negotiations and do the things other old organisations-which have been in existence for 150 years — will not be allowed to do under this Bill unless they pay the ransom of £2,000. The sugar workers' union might negotiate with the directors of the Sugar Board, but if they quarrelled with the directors of the Sugar Company and withdrew the labour of their members, on that day they could not picket. They might stay at home, or go to the labour exchange to be refused unemployment insurance or unemployment assistance. They could not picket the premises of the Sugar Company and could not proclaim to the community what the strike was about, nor could they carry any banners indicating that a strike was in operation at any of the various sugar factories.

That protection is not now being afforded to a union of that kind under this Bill. The Minister is encouraging the formation of house unions in order to exempt them from the payment of £2,000 and, in addition, having so exempted them, he is preventing them from using against an employer the same type of weapon which a union which paid a deposit can use against an employer. This section is, I think, completely unconstitutional — apart from the fact that it is a perfectly unscrupulous section, and a dastardly section so far as organisation is concerned. The whole purpose is to give the boss a better chance to win.

Article 40 of the Constitution provides that all citizens, as human beings, are held equal before the law. The provision of Section 10 of this Bill deprives citizens who happen to be members of a trade union which does not hold a negotiation licence from enjoying the protection which they got from the law under the 1906 Act. That seems to be class legislation of the worst kind. It is not only class biassed against the workers but class biassed towards the employer. There is no reason whatever for the insertion of Section 10 unless the real purpose of the Bill is — as I believe it is — to weaken the trade union movement and to make it easier for the Minister and the Government to get over Emergency Powers Order No. 83. The mailed fist behind this Bill is in Section 10, and the whole purpose of the section is to weaken the unions. I charge the Government again, and those who will vote for Section 10, that that is being done in the interests of the employers and done in a way that will be used by employers who originally probably came from Whitechapel or Poland. It is being done against the Irish workers.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 56
·
Níl 39
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 23:—

In sub-section (1), page 5, to delete in line 40 the words "free of charge for public inspection" and to insert in line 41 before the word "and" the words "for inspection by any person having a bona fide interest therein and paying such fee not exceeding five shillings as such trade union determines”.

Section 11 imposes on a registered trade union which holds a negotiation licence the obligation to specify the conditions as to the entry into and cesser of membership of the union. There is a further obligation on the trade union to maintain at its office a register of its members which shall show for each union the name and address of each member, the date and commencement of his membership, and, where the membership has ceased, the date of the cesser and whether the membership has ceased by reason of death, resignation, suspension or expulsion, together with the date of the order directing such suspension or expulsion, and a reference to the authorising rule.

Paragraph (c) of sub-section (1) also provides that the union shall keep at its office such register of members open free of charge for public inspection during ordinary business hours under conditions set out in the original text of the Bill. It has been represented to me that there is a possibility that the very open conditions set out in the text of the Bill as introduced — that is to say, that the register should be open free of charge for public inspection during ordinary business hours — might be vexatiously used and to avoid that I propose to delete the words "free of charge for public inspection" and insert before the word "and" the words "for inspection by any person having a bona fide interest therein, and paying such fee not exceeding five shillings as such trade union determines”.

Comment on this

A rather unusual procedure has been adopted in connection with this section. It has not been thought desirable, in any of the Trade Union Acts during the last 70 years, to put in a provision to the effect that any member of the public can walk into a trade union office and inspect the register of members of the union. The legislators of the past have apparently rightly taken the view that that is not a matter that concerns the general public, and they have rightly omitted any provision whereby any mischief-maker or busybody could say: "Produce the register; I want to see who is in the organisation."

One indication of the thoughtless manner in which this Bill was prepared, or perhaps I might say the wilfully malicious manner in which it was prepared, is that the Minister, in the early text of the Bill, put in a provision that any Tom, Dick or Harry could go to a union headquarters and say: "Produce the register; I want to see who is in the organisation," and he could go into the office on the 1st January and keep going day after day until the 31st December of the same year and maul and paw the registers every day when the offices were open, and he would be entitled to remain in the office all day merely for the purpose of looking at the register. One can easily imagine the manner in which a right of that kind could be abused. It still can be abused under this section, even though the unions are entitled to charge a fee of 5/-.

It seems to me the provision made here is very indefinite. "Any person having a bona fide interest therein”— what is a bona fide interest in a register? Obviously you have to indicate what bona fide means in that context. I might have a genuine interest in ascertaining whether a particular person was a member of an organisation, whether, in fact, he was a trade unionist. Is that a bona fide interest? If I am an employer and I want to find out whether John Murphy is a member of a trade union, am I entitled to go to a union office and have a look at the register and, when I am there, can I ascertain what other people are members of the trade union? The description bona fide seems to me to give rise to all kinds of doubts in the matter.

This whole procedure seems rather strange. No provision of this kind has been made in any of our Trade Union Acts so far. No such provision has been made in respect to friendly societies or public companies. The long-standing practice has been to allow a person interested in the funds to inspect the register; in other words, a parson who is a genuine member of the organisation, who created the organisation and who helps to maintain it should be afforded all reasonable facilities. In this measure it is possible for a boss to come in and ascertain who is on the register, when a certain person went on the register and how long his name has been there. I regard it as a most inquisitive power to give to anybody other than a person who is genuinely a member of an organisation and who is interested in its welfare. Under this Bill any busybody engaged in any type of sabotaging operation can, merely by paying 5/-, do damage, so far as a union is concerned, which would not be covered by the payment of the fee.

Comment on this

I should like to hear from the Minister the nature of the representations made to him and the source from which this suggestion came. It would seem that for the payment of a fee of 5/-, some person, with qualifications approved by the Minister, can stay in a trade union office, the office of one of the biggest affiliated unions in the country, every day of the year for the purpose of inspecting the register. There are some unions affiliated with the Irish Trade Union Congress having a membership of 70,000 or 80,000. Some unions have a membership ranging from 25,000 to 70,000. One of these gentlemen that the Minister has in mind can pay a fee of 5/-, and he can come into the office on the 1st January and go day after day until the 3lst December of the same year, and inspect the register of the trade union, thus causing considerable inconvenience and irritation to those who have to work in the office.

Comment on this

They must have a bona fide interest and they have to pay a fee of 5/-.

Comment on this

Five shillings would do for the whole year.

Comment on this

Will he have to pay 5/-every day, or will it cover his trespass on the premises for the 365 days of the year? Will Deputy Kelly answer that question, if the Minister does not? I am delighted that Deputy Kelly interrupts me, but I would be much more pleased if he would say all he thinks of this silly section. He says he knows the City of Dublin for 73 years, but he does not remember what went on in 1825.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Neither the Deputy's age nor what happened in the year 1825 arises on this.

Comment on this

I am merely referring to what the Deputy said about himself when he was waiting for the last division.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When the Committee was not technically in session as it now is.

Comment on this

The Minister, in all his speeches during the period of emergency, repeats in gramophone fashion that every individual is called upon to make equal sacrifices and to suffer some inconvenience. Is he going to apply the ridiculous procedure contained in Section 11 to every society that exists? What is the idea behind this section? Did the suggestion come from a certain type of employer, who wants to have the right to send his spotters or his spies, if you like to call them that, to examine the register of unions catering for members working on his premises, or is it for the purpose of giving the police authorities access to the registers of affiliated unions? If that is going to apply to every society, with the good will of the Minister, there might be something to be considered, but this is a special regulation, and it is brought in in these days of progress, to apply only to unions that will exist under the Bill, if and when it becomes law, or if and when it is recognised as the law by the unions that will exist after it is passed. We are entitled to some information as to what is at the back of this proposal, and whether the fee of 5/- will cover the right of some person authorised by the Minister to go into the office of a trade union on the 1st January and to remain there until 3lst December of the same year.

Comment on this

The principle in this section is one that has been fiercely resisted for many years. I want to know what is the object of this system of prying into the affairs of trade unions. The Minister referred to a certain amendment. Why does he think it necessary for trade unions to keep registers of members? What purpose can that serve? What is the advantage to anybody concerned? Like Deputy Norton, I am uneasy about the reference to "bona fide”. Under the licensing laws the term “bona fide” is one that has caused endless trouble. I do not see how the Minister can gain anything very substantial by the words “bona fide”. It may be news to the Minister but, in regard to one of the biggest unions, no register of members has ever been kept at headquarters. Membership is measured in accordance with the contributions received from the various branches. That is the barometer of membership. Why will the Minister increase the hatred and hostility to the measure by having a section couched in such unfortunate terms? This section gives very good ground for the belief that, like many of the other sections, the object is provocative. I strongly protest against this section. I think it is intolerable that it should be put into any Bill. It comes very badly from a Minister who was once a revolutionary and also a poet.

Comment on this

It is a long time since he recited any poetry.

Comment on this

I suggest to the Minister that there is no definition of bona fide person, and that this section will lead to a great deal of complication. I urge the Minister to define bona fide. Suppose that a complete stranger wishes to avail of the wording of the sub-section, he has no right until he has paid 5/-, and then he has no right if he has not bona fide interest. I can see considerable disputes about that. In the first place, the payment of 5/- may be refused on the ground that the person tendering has not bona fide interest, while if the 5/- is accepted his right may be disputed on the same ground, that he has not a bona fide right. The wording will give rise to a considerable amount of litigation if the unions in question care to question it. It might lead to a question of trespass or to a breach of the peace. The position could be cleared up if a definition were inserted concerning what is meant by a person having a bona fide interest.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Esmonde has put his finger on the heart of the amendment. It is designed to ensure that only a person who really has a right, because he has a genuine interest in the affairs of a union or is genuinely affected, will, endeavour to inspect the register. Naturally the onus rests upon him, and having applied, if inspection is refused, he has to satisfy the court that he has a bona fide interest. The matter would arise perhaps in this way, that under Section 21 of the Bill the tribunal may grant a determination to the effect that a particular trade union shall alone have the right to organise workmen of that class, or it may happen under another section that such a right may be granted to two or more unions. If it happens that such unions have reason to believe that the determination of the tribunal is not being observed by a certain union, then the unions to whom determination was granted, will have the right to ask for inspection of the register of members of the trade union which is not honouring the determination of the tribunal. That is one of the principal objects the section hopes to secure, by having these registers open for inspection. I take it that the unions whose registers of members it is desired to inspect will naturally consider, when a person tenders 5/-, the basis upon which he claims to have a bona fide interest, and decide whether or not it is desirable to allow the register to be inspected. If they refuse, the person affected by refusal, if the matter is of such importance, has a right to go elsewhere to secure, if he can, a declaration that he has a bona fide interest in the union.

Comment on this

Who made this suggestion to the Minister?

Comment on this

That is my business.

Comment on this

There was a certain point raised affecting a particular individual. There is no question but bona fide interest is a matter that will have to be determined by the courts.

Comment on this

In some cases.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot answer that. There are no standards and no tests of bona fide interest, unless the unions act and then a man would have to go to the courts. That is what we contend. The second point was that on payment of 5/- a person has a bona fide right, and would be entitled to go to an office in the early hours of the day and stay until closing time.

Comment on this

He might.

Comment on this

There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

Whether he could do that twice is another matter.

Comment on this

Why not? If he has a bona fide interest he could go one day and could certainly go a second day.

Comment on this

Until he concluded the examination.

Comment on this

And not only are present members affected but people who were members at any time, or who have ceased to be members. The only people excluded are those who ceased to be members before the negotiation licence was granted. Even if a host of members swarmed into a union at one time for reasons which had concluded, and then left, their names have to be recorded year after year. There is no cleaning up of the register.

Comment on this

There might be the names of men on it who were dead for 30 years.

Comment on this

If a man was a member I understand his name must be kept on the register. The section says "including former members". It does not say people in the land of the living but those who were at any time members. That register is going to give some difficulty to keep after years have elapsed and, as far as I know, these registers are not kept in alphabetical order. A person looking for a name might have to spend hours going through thousands of names.

We had the point of view put forward that, once a man pays a fee of 5/- and has a bona fide right of entrance to the office, he can remain there until the office is closed for the day, and come back again the next day. Companies have been referred to, but it surely does not occur to anybody that anyone is going to have such an interest in the business of a company as to remain on the premises all day. With regard to the ordinary management of companies, that sort of procedure is hardly likely to obtain very often, but it might in the circumstances in which the Minister has placed the background of all this business. I learn from a speech made by another Deputy that the procedure under trade union rules up to date is that a person who has an interest in the funds of a society has the right to inspect. What other purpose does the Minister want to serve by this?

Comment on this

Take the case of a union which has seemed a determination in its favour.

Comment on this

Categories of classes could easily be arranged. For example, people with an interest in the funds who were subscribers at one time, and who think that they have not liquidated entirely the benefits that should accrue to them; also the representatives of a union in whose favour a determination has been given by the tribunal. Are there any other categories that the Minister thinks should have access.

Comment on this

I presume the officers of the Minister.

Comment on this

Exactly. But surely all these categories could be arranged for by set phrases. I think the Minister would be well advised to go some distance to allay the suspicion that continues to grow up around this Bill. A list of well defined classes could be prepared, and provision might be made for any person duly authorised by the Minister. That would mean that the Minister would have to decide, before giving his authorisation, whether in his opinion such a person could be said to have an interest in the funds.

Comment on this

That would be a very invidious duty to put on the Minister.

Comment on this

But that is what Parliamentary institutions are for: to have some one to take on those invidious duties who will be here to answer for them. That is the Parliamentary system of government. I would have my suspicions deepened if the Minister refused to take on the invidious task of deciding whether people who might apply to him for the right to inspect had or had not in his opinion a bona fide interest in doing so. What the Minister has said seems to indicate to me that he feels there will be a lot of people he would feel bound to refuse, or, alternatively, that there will be a lot of people he would like to give the right to inspect to, but would not like to have to answer for here. I suggest that there should be categories of people set out, with an overriding provision to the effect that such other persons as produce a warrant from the Minister will be duly authorised to inspect.

Comment on this

I will look into the matter from that point of view.

Comment on this

I do not know what was in the minds of the drafters of this Bill when they came to draft certain portions of this section. There are some rather unusual innovations in it. Under paragraph (b) of sub-section (1) the obligation is put on the holders of a negotiation licence to maintain at their offices registers of members, including former members other than those whose membership ceased before the grant of such negotiation licences, and these registers are to show a variety of things. What the trade unions will be required to do under this provision is to create, where they had not already done so, a central head office register. They will have to keep it and make it available for inspection from time, to time to those folk who are supposed to have a bona fide interest in examining it, even though a person may have ceased to be a member for 20, 30 or 40 years after the passing of this Act, and even though a member is dead.

Comment on this

For 40 years after his death.

Comment on this

Yes. Suppose this measure ever passes and is ever implemented; suppose anyone takes any notice of it after it is passed, and suppose some organisation does create a register: suppose all these things are, in fact, done, then the union will keep a record of its members. A member may die next month. Forty years hence the union will have to keep a record of that member, even though he is dead and even though every other relative of his may have long since followed him into eternity. What purpose is it hoped to serve by insisting on a union keeping a record of members who have mouldered into dust? I should like to hear someone tell me what is the reason for asking a union to keep a list of dead men? That would seem to be the function of the registrar of deaths. As I have said, these are most unusual innovations so far as trade union records are concerned.

Under paragraph (d) of sub-section (1) it is provided that:

"A person who ceases to be a member of such trade union shall, for the purposes of this Act, be deemed to continue to be a member thereof for one month after such cessor."

So that a member of a union who has been expelled, or a member who has resigned, is deemed to be a member one month after his expulsion or resignation. A member who has died is to be deemed to be a member one month after he has been buried. That is a provision which has all the appearance of having been drafted in Grangegorman. What is the purpose of deeming a person to be a member one month after he has ceased to be a member? Would the Minister for Industry and Commerce like to have this position: that an expelled member of his Party would be entitled to turn up to the weekly Party meeting, and be deemed to be a member of it for a month after his expulsion? Suppose a member of the Minister's Party died, would the Minister like, for the purposes of his membership of the Party and of this House, that he should still be deemed to be a member of both the Party and the House for a month after he had left this earth?

Take another case. A carpenter, say, is a member of a union. On the 1st January he decides to open business on his own account and becomes an employer. On that date he automatically ceased to be a member of his trade union and became an employer and a member of an employers' organisation. For the purposes of this section, although not eligible to be a member of a trade union according to its rules, that union must carry that gentleman on its books and accept responsibility, presumably, for his actions, even though he is now an employer and not a worker. This Bill deals with the organisatiun of workmen. It acknowledges that people must organise in classes of workmen and in classes of employers. Before I say anything more on this unusual provision I should like the Minister to tell us in what set of circumstances it is necessary to deem folk of that kind to be members of a union long after they have left the union. Why is it necessary to keep a record of members long after they have ceased to be members or even ceased to live?

Comment on this

There has been a great deal of misunderstanding about the purposes of this section, and some very fanciful visions have manifested themselves in regard to the effect of it. I take it that the register of a trade union is a continuing document in which a name once inscribed remains. If a person ceases to be a member, his name may either be struck out or entered upon some other register as having ceased his membership. The register itself would form part of the archives of the trade union, and as, from day to day, members died or otherwise ceased their membership, the register would preserve evidence that they had been members of the union. If it is felt that that interpretation might not be placed upon the provision as it stands, it is open to us to provide that the union may, after five or ten years, replace the register by a revised register of existing members, brought up to date. I cannot see what objection there can be to a union allowing the register to exist in this form as evidence of past membership of the union.

Comment on this

Some of the unions keep card indexes.

Comment on this

It is essential, in view of the special position in which authorised trade unions are being placed under this Bill, and in view of the great power which trade unions now exercise in our industrial life, determining, very often, whether a man is to be entitled to employment or not, that there should be clear evidence as to whether a person is or is not a member of a union. If, for instance, a strike takes place because it is alleged that a person is not a member of a union, we want to ensure under this Bill that that question can be settled, beyond yea or nay, by the production of documentary evidence. It is essential we should do that, because, as I have said, this Bill, so far from doing anything to injure the trade union movement, as has been alleged very often during this debate, places these authorised trade unions in a very strong position.

Comment on this

In a privileged position?

Comment on this

In a strong position. The Deputy, as a true-blue democrat, would not look for privilege even for a trade union. The unions are placed in that strong position and, therefore, it is essential that there should be a clear and continuing record of men's membership of them. Not merely that, but provision should be made that, if a person is unjustly expelled from his union and, perhaps, by that expulsion deprived of his right to earn a livelihood in certain occupations, there should be a waiting period during which he should have the right to appeal against such expulsion. That is the reason why this period of a month is being provided.

Comment on this

Before what court will the dead man appear on the question of membership?

Comment on this

Surely, it is not necessary to take the steps indicated by the Minister in his concluding remarks to afford protection to members of trade unions. That is already afforded by the ordinary law. Any member of a trade union who is unjustly dealt with, or improperly expelled, can apply to the courts for protection.

Comment on this

Has he always been in the position to incur the necessary expense?

Comment on this

What protection are you giving him, which he has not already, by keeping his name on the register a month after he has ceased to be a member?

Comment on this

We give this protection: it has been stated in the House that one of the largest unions in the country does not keep a register of its members at all; it will now have to keep such a register.

Comment on this

What has that to do with the question of the name of a dead man being kept on the register?

Comment on this

Perhaps I do not know as much about trade unions as the Deputy does but he is aware that there are trade unions who will not take as members persons who are not the sons or other near relations of members. It may be essential to show that a deceased person was, in fact, a member of a particular union.

Comment on this

If I had made that reference, I would have been ruled out on a point of order and told that my remarks were not relevant to the section. The question of apprentices does not arise. The Minister alleges that this provision will give protection to members who are unjustly or harshly treated. There is nothing in the section to add to the security which members of trade unions have at the present time, so far as unfair treatment in concerned. They can appeal to the law courts if they are not fairly treated. The keeping of a man's name on the register, while it is no additional protection to him, is a potential danger to the union. He may have resigned or been required to resign. Yet, he is to be deemed to be still a member of the union "for the purposes of this Act". How is the court to determine the scope of the words "for the purposes of this Act"? How are they to decide that he is a member for one purpose and not a member for other purposes? That man may be driving a vehicle and may knock somebody down, seriously injuring or killing him.

Will the Minister argue that the union is not bound to do all the things, in the way of his defence, that they were bound to do when he was a member? The words "for the purposes of this Act" would be of little use in enabling the judges to come to a conclusion. The provision is unnecessary and is a potential danger to the unions, while it does not give additional protection to the members. There is a sinister motive underlying every section of the Bill. It is thinly veiled, and it seems to me that there is a sinister motive underlying this provision.

Comment on this

May I put one point in connection with the dead man. Why is it necessary to insist on a union retaining, for a time, on its register the names of people who were at one time members and who have died? Not merely are unions bound to keep on the register the names of members and former members, but there is a penalty of £1 per day for every day the offence continues, whether membership ceases by death, expulsion or otherwise. When a member dies, the unions will, I presume, solemnly record that they know the man has died. The position reminds me of a play in the Abbey in which the brothers of a secret society meet to record, with lamentation, the death of one of their members, eaten alive by four Orangemen. They record that he was given decent interment inside the four Orangemen. Are we to have all that entered up under penalty? In the name of all that is wise and sensible, what is the reason for keeping the register continuously overloaded with the names of persons who were members at one time and died?

With regard to live people, what ia the reason for saying that for the purposes of the Act a person is to be deemed to be a member for a month after he ceases his membership? I can understand the point about giving protection against irregular suspension. But the ordinary law deals with that and this provision adds nothing to it. Why, for the purposes of this Act, insist on a man being a member a month after he has been expelled? Added to that we have the provision that a man is a member a month after he dies.

Comment on this

After he ceases to be a member.

Comment on this

Why do you insist on a man being deemed to be a member a month after expulsion and, further, deem a man to be a member a month after he has died? That is a point which requires answer.

Comment on this

This section deals with icgistered trade unions. Does it deal with trade unions that are registered in this country?

Comment on this

Only with trade unions registered in this country.

Comment on this

It appears that there is a distinction between the unions referred to in Sections 11 and 12. Section 12 deals with unions that are not registered.

Comment on this

Section 12 deals with bodies which are trade unions under the law of another country.

Comment on this

The matter arises in connection with the meaning of the word "office". In sub-section (3) of the section it is stated that the word "office" means the office which for the time being is the registered office of the relevant trade union for the purposes of the Trade Union Acts, 1871 to 1935. That only deals with trade unions that are registered here?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Is that quite clear at the beginning of the section?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

There is nothing to show that it is limited to unions registered in this country.

Comment on this

It deals only with trade unions registered here at the moment.

Comment on this

I put to the Minister a very definite case and we are entitled to some reasonable answer. The Minister has been asked to say why it is necessary for instance to keep in the membership of a union for the purposes of this Act a person who desires to leave the union. That person may say "I want to get out" and the union may say "Go out, we do not want to keep you any longer". The man does not want to stay and the union does not want to keep him. Why are we to insist that such a person should remain a member of the union for one month after he has actually left it?

Take the case of the other man who becomes an employer. He says: "I am not any longer eligible for membership under your rules. I am now an employer and I give you notice of my resignation from such a date; goodbye", and the union says: "All right; we accept your retirement as inevitable in the circumstances." Yet for the purposes of this section we are insisting that the man should remain in the union for a month after that date. We are entitled to some explanation for that.

Comment on this

We cannot draft an Act to cover every hypothetical facet of a situation which may never arise. All we can do is to prescribe in general terms what the position under the law is going to be. I have pointed out that there is need for making some provision to ensure that cesser of membership of a union will not have effect until a reasonable period has elapsed. The need for that condition arises from the fact that trade unions under this Bill, it is anticipated, will become very strong. They are already, in fact, so strong that they virtually control the right to secure employment in this country in a number of occupations. It is of vital importance that people who, by reason of the fact that they are members of a trade union, already enjoy this right to employment in certain occupations, should not summarily be deprived of that right by a union claiming to act in accordance with its own rules and that there should be an opportunity afforded them, if necessary, to go to the courts to vindicate their right to membership and their consequent right to employment.

It has been said in that regard that a person aggrieved by being wrongfully dismissed from a trade union has a right to go to court at present. He has, but he certainly would have a very difficult job to prove his right in the circumstances, as we know them to exist, in the case of some of the bigger trade unions in this country We have heard it admitted to-day in this House that one of the largest does not even maintain a register of its members. It is accordingly essential, from the point of view of protection of workers in this country, that every authorised trade union should maintain a register of members. It is vital to the interests of the workers themselves that no person should be wrongfully deprived of membership of such union, bearing in mind the advantages which such membership now confers. Arising from that, there is certainly need to ensure that if a person is, wrongfully deprived of his membership, nothing will arise to interfere with his right to earn a living, and that the courts, it necessary, shall have the right to review the decision——

Comment on this

That is not stated in the section at all.

Comment on this

It is not, but we hope that perhaps trade unions themselves will so reorganise the movement on the basis of this Bill that they will provide domestic machinery for dealing with that situation. I do not wish to compel any person to enter into litigation with a particular union in order to prove membership, but I do want in this section to make it easier for people who are bona fide members of a trade union and who desire a determination that they have been wrongfully suspended or wrongfully expelled from the union to obtain redress.

A point has been raised as to why we should maintain a register of dead people. We do know that in certain trades in this country there is a tendency to restrict apprenticeship and future entry into these trades and their appropriate trade unions to sons and near relatives of men already engaged in them. I think it of vital importance, if a question at some time or other should arise as to whether a person seeking apprenticeship or admission to these trade unions is a son or a near relative of a deceased member or a former member — in this case a deceased member — that that person seeking admission should be able to refer to some existing document by which his claim can be proven or disproven. That is why we are seeking to ensure that the register shall contain the names of former members.

Comment on this

I wish you knew something about the trade union movement. You would not then make such a statement.

Comment on this

This point about cesser after death is a mere technicality. I do not know that it is of any vital importance. The real question here is that a person who has been suspended or expelled would be deemed to continue to be a member for one month after the date of such suspension or expulsion. If the House thinks necessary to bring in an amendment specifically to exclude from the provisions of paragraph (d) the case of a person who dies, I am quite willing to do it.

Comment on this

If you do that would you not also have to provide for the case of the person who resigned?

Comment on this

I do not think that it is necessary to do that.

Comment on this

Take the other case, that of a person who ceases to have the qualifications for membership.

Comment on this

I do not know that I would go so far as that. I would be prepared to deal with the question of deceased members because it is obviously absurd, if the issue is raised, to deem him to be a member one month after his death, but the point is of no practical importance, because I do not think it will arise.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Minister has said that he is trying to bring into this section certain safeguards. I am prepared to agree with the Minister's point of view, but there is nothing in the section, from beginning to end, that is going to secure what he wants. The Minister talks about people in certain trades not being able to secure work unless they are members of a certain trade union, but there is nothing in the section which is going to make the position any better than it is to-day. The Minister also talked about apprentices to certain trades, but there is nothing whatever about apprentices in the section, even if it were passed as it is set out here in the green paper. The Minister, with all respect to him, talked about something which is not in the section at all. It only confirms me in the point of view I had from the very beginning, that neither the Bill nor its implications are understood by the people who brought it before the House. It is quite evident that the reactions of the Bill are not understood. The Minister's speech has proven quite clearly that the Bill was conceived in a hurry and was not given the consideration it should have been given, in view of its importance. The Minister speaks of its being impossible to legislate to cover every detail, and he talked about this month after, during which a person is to be deemed a member, as being of no importance. If not, why is it put in here? He did not tell us why it was introduced in the first instance.

Comment on this

I have said it was of no importance in the case of a deceased person.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Minister sees nothing absurd in carrying on the name of a person after death, but he has not given the House any reason for that being put in. One is forced to the conclusion that the importance of the Bill has not been realised, or its reactions appreciated. When one realises that we are facing a piece of legislation which will affect, directly, anything from 400,000 to 500,000 people, one feels that it is certainly entitled to a good deal more consideration than apparently it got before it was introduced, and certainly to much fuller consideration and debate than it is getting.

Comment on this

I should like to supplement what Deputy Morrissey has said and I invite the Minister's special attention to it. It is a common experience that, when we get down to a detail of this kind, we find that a very material element in the Bill pivots upon it. It is quite clear that the case of a deceased member simply did not occur to the Minister when the Bill was being drafted. We are all familiar with the fact that, when drafting a Bill, it is not possible to anticipate every detail that may arise. That is one of the purposes of debate in Committee. May I put it to the Minister that there is no startling urgency about this Bill? We all agree that things exist which ought to be put an end to in the trade union movement, and I think trade unionists agree with that. The issue joined between us is how best to do it. It is abundantly clear from the discussion on more than one amendment to the Bill that a variety of factors were not present to the Minister's mind.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

Let me put it this way: It has become abundantly clear from the debate that it appears to many——

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The debate on Section 11?

Comment on this

On this amendment. It has become abundantly clear that it appears to many that there is more than one item of the kind mentioned by Deputy Morrissey which had not occurred to the Minister, and I want to suggest to him whether he would not consider inviting either a Committee of the House or a commission to consider this whole problem, so that points such as that raised by Deputy Morrissey and Deputy McGilligan might get the consideration to which they are entitled, but which it may very well be almost impossible to give them in Committee Stage in a full session of Dáil Eireann. Surely that would be worth thinking of?

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Now that we have a House, could I move that the House adjourn for tea?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

Can we deem all those who are here now to be here an hour after they leave?

Comment on this

Would it not be better if Deputies behaved themselves in a more dignified fashion and did not put forward these ridiculous proposals?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I did not catch what the Minister said, but, if the official reporter heard it, we are entitled to hear it.

Comment on this

The Minister has made, or has attempted to make, one pet point in order in some way to fortify his retention of the provision leaving people to be members for a month after they ceased to be such; that is, he wants to make it easy for a person wrongfully expelled, wrongfully forced to resign or in any way wrongfully excluded from a trade union, to establish his rights. How does the section make it in the slightest degree easier for him to establish his rights? If he is put out at the moment, he has resort to the court. He goes to a court as a person who is expelled. In the new circumstances, he will go to the court as a person whom the union tried to expel but whom the Minister's Act keeps on as a member, first of all, a month is no good if the Minister is thinking about legal proceedings. He will not get legal proceedings in a month, and the period ought to be extended very much beyond, the month, but would the Minister tell me one point in which the situation is eased by deeming a man to be a member for a month after the union have attempted to get rid of him?

Comment on this

By the fact that the register is there to appeal to.

Comment on this

For what? That he was a member?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The position would be that that person would say: "I was a member and I was wrongfully put off", and the union's reply would be: "You were put off in accordance with the terms of the union".

Comment on this

The union's reply might be: "You never were a member".

Comment on this

And his answer would be that he will produce the register and that that will prove it, but why allow him to say: "I am still a member" for a month after?

Comment on this

Because if he is not deemed to be a member in law, he may lose his employment. If he does lose his employment in such circumstances, by reason of the action of the union, he may have an action against the union.

Comment on this

This is not so much a question of the legal side of the matter at all, because from the legal point of view the Minister's argument is useless. I have always found that in these Acts there is a limiting phrase, such as that "he shall for the purposes of this Act be deemed to be a member", and I have searched through all the sections here to see where this would have any effect or where it would be linked up, bat I have failed to find it. I thought that it might be linked up in some way with the matter of the deposits, but evidently it is not. Now we have two points here. One is the legal point that he is deemed to be a member for another month in order to ease his situation in getting back. That is the suggestion, but in my opinion it does not ease his situation in that regard, and I challenge the Minister to give me one point of ease in the man's favour by deeming him to be a member for a month after. The second point — I suppose this is the framework to get over this — is that a union will say that their men will not work with a man on a particular job unless he is a member of a particular union, and they wrongfully expel him, and he cannot work because, if he does, the others may leave. Does the Minister think that there is protection there or an easing of the position because the man is deemed to be a member? These are the two points.

Comment on this

It is quite clear that the Minister knows nothing whatever about the procedure taken by trade unions in connection with their head offices or their administrative machinery. Because a Deputy had said that in the case of one union's headquarters no records were kept, the Minister, in his inexperience of trade unions, proceeded to assume that, consequently, there were no records of the members of that union. What happens in a case like that is that the records are kept by the local branches and are always available for union headquarters, and that record of a person's membership is just as indelibly preserved locally as if it were at union headquarters. In very large organisations, it is a matter of administrative convenience to have the records kept locally instead of nationally, but that does not mean that the records are not available. If that is an argument, therefore, in favour of the thoughtlessness of putting in Section 11 (1) (d), it is probably the poorest argument I have heard on a section, the defence of which has been so bristling with poor arguments as that section was. The Minister says that it is necessary to protect people, by giving them a right to go to the courts if they are unfairly expelled, but when asked to show in what way. Section 11 (1) (d) will give that extra protection he cannot possibly quote a single instance in which the phraseology of this section would in any way assist such a person to plead his case before the courts. Occasionally, at present, a member who is expelled from a union may go to the courts. It has never been contended by the courts that his case is in any way weakened, because, in fact, the expulsion had taken place. The courts have considered cases of that kind without any reference to whether the aggrieved person, on the date of the action, was or was not a member of the union. Membership of the union, therefore, has played no part whatever in court judgments on applications by aggrieved persons for relief and for compensation, perhaps, against expulsion from membership of a union. The Minister is making a very poor case worse by pretending to believe that there is any relief or assistance provided for an aggrieved person in Section 11 (1) (d).

Take another case. The Minister realises now that it is a bit absurd to deem a dead man to be a member of a union a month after he is buried, and he proposes, therefore, to remove that piece of dead timber from this Bill. Let us take another example of what the Minister is doing. At present, some trade union organisations — all trade union organisations — have rules. These rules, and alterations of them, are registered with the Department of Industry and Commerce and, in respect of registered unions, there is a supervision of the rules exercised by the Registrar of Friendly Societies, now functioning in connection with the Department of Industry and Commerce. The registrar may register the rules of a union, and these rules may provide that if a person is three months in arrears in his contributions he ceases to be a member in good financial standing, and that if he is six months in arrears with his contributions he ceases to be a member entirely. The Department of Industry and Commerce will register these rules and. by that fact, consent to these rules, but under Section 11 (1) (d) of this Bill the person who is a non-financial member from the end of three months until the end of six months, is put back into actual membership of the union — not into non-financial membership of the union but back into membership in good standing — even though the person is six months in arrears with his contributions and even though the Department of Industry and Commerce have agreed that his membership ought to lapse if he does not pay contributions after six months. That is what the Minister is doing under this section.

The Minister does not know the rules of trade unions or the supervision exercised over them by his own Department, and, not having had much experience of trade unions or of his own Department, he knows nothing about these matters. He would be well advised to take some guidance from people who do know something about these matters. The only thing that was put forward to justify Section 11 (1) (d) was the possibility that a person might be unfairly expelled, but it has been shown that there is no relief for that person in this section. But take the case of a person who definitely says: "I do not want to remain any longer in the union. I want to leave it and join another union" or who says "I want to retire from all kinds of industrial toil, and I do not intend to work any more." That person wants to go, and the union says: "O.K., you may go." The Minister, however, says: "Yes, but for the purposes of this Act you are still a member of the union."

What purpose is served by keeping membership in the union in that case? Take another case. A man says: "I am getting out of tills particular industry as a worker. I am ceasing to be a journeyman or a craftsman and am going into business on my own or with a brother of mine. I am going now to become an employer of workers and, in these circumstances, I intend to leave the union because, as an employer, I am no longer eligible." Yet, for the purposes of this Act, that person is deemed to be a member of the union. I want to know why you must keep him in membership when he wants to go and the union is satisfied that he should go. Will the Minister address himself to these arguments and say why that man should be compelled to remain a member of a union for a month after he leaves or desires to leave it?

Comment on this

On this section I want to renew my representations to the House. This is a highly technical piece of legislation. Take the very section we are now dealing with. Deputy Norton discussed the inner workings of the maintenance of a trade union register and the advantages that accrue to a member by having his name on the register and the consequences of removing his name from it. It is manifest to us all that on a variety of technical questions arising out of previous sections the warmest feeling has been evinced, and I say, with regard to Section 11, that, except to some active trade unionists and, notably, officials of trade unions, the merits of the issues involved are far from clear. In that set of circumstances, is it not a reasonable thing to suggest that the whole of this problem should be referred to a, body which, as a preliminary, legislatively, would clarify the issues involved? Is it reasonable to ask Deputies to pass judgment on the merits of the Minister's proposal when secretaries of trade unions say that, from their experience of the thing, the Minister's conception is entirely wrong? Now, the Minister may be right and the secretaries may be wrong, or the Minister may be wrong and the secretaries may be right; but how can the membership of Dáil Éireann determine between them, unless an opportunity has been afforded to them to peruse the proceedings of a commission which has sent for expert witnesses to clarify this problem?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This is not relevant to the section.

Comment on this

I am talking about n section of the Bill. I am talking about my inability to understand Section 11 of the Bill.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is not discussing anything in the section of the Bill.

Comment on this

Yes, there is one thing embedded and that is my incapacity and the incapacity of 95 per cent. of the members of the Dáil to understand the section of the Bill.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not in the section of the Bill at all. It is completely out of order.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy is capable of understanding the meaning of "trade union".

Comment on this

Surely I am entitled to say there is a section in this Bill which I cannot understand and which I want further elucidated before I determine what lobby I will go into. The Minister says he will elucidate the section for us and he proceeds to do so, whereupon expert trade unionists get up and say that every word the Minister has said is untrue; his elucidation of this section is false and misleading, either because he does not know the facts or seeks to mislead the House. I get up between the two contending parties and say: "All I want is information." The Minister gives me one version of the story; the trade unionists give me another version. Is it unreasonable for a Deputy who is not a trade unionist and has no direct interest in this Bill at all to say: "Would you, between you, let this matter be sent to a commission that has power to send for persons and papers so that witnesses can be examined and the individual Deputy of Dáil Éireann can read their evidence and make up his own mind as to the merits of the provision?"

Comment on this

Whenever a Deputy does not understand a particular section of a Bill we have got to set up a commission to deal with it.

Comment on this

The Minister can be provoking if he wants to. My reputation in this House is not that of a Deputy who understands no legislation. The Minister frequently finds fault that I profess to understand every kind of legislation. On this occasion I am putting a serious point. I am putting a point which I think, if taken earlier, might have avoided a great deal of pretty violent scenes in the House which a great many people outside in the country do not understand the necessity for. I believe that a modus operandi could be found and an agreed measure arrived at to meet the evils that exist if a little patient consideration were given to it.

Is there any other Deputy in the House who will get up and say frankly that he does not understand many of the sections, and, notably, Section 11 of this Bill? I know many of them do not. Is it unreasonable for us to ask for machinery to enable us to understand the section? I think that if that machinery were made available, a great deal of acrimonious debate could be avoided. If all this violent clash of opinion were transferred to another forum, instead of having violent disagreement of the kind we have had, we might ascertain truths and I think, if we did, the passage of this Bill would be very much easier through later stages. Indeed, it might become apparent that some entirely new section would fit the machine better than Section 11. I put it to the Minister that that suggestion is worthy of consideration. It would be much better if we could get an instrument before the House which in detail we could discuss, having agreed in principle, than to get a measure before the House that pleases nobody, that is discussed in detail in an acrimonious spirit which results in no accommodation being arrived at. We ought to be able to get accommodation about this problem, and we could if all sides of the House had the exhaustive information which the Minister professes to have but which the trade unionists in the House say he has not got but which, I have no doubt, they would be very pleased to supply if some independent tribunal were set up to examine the evils this Bill is designed to abate, and to elucidate from them what their views are of the source of these evils and the most expedient method of overcoming them.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I was hoping that the Minister would have something to say before the section was put. The Minister, in his attempt to justify this section, relied on two points which, to my mind, are not affected by the section at all. There were two points on which I could find myself very largely in agreement with the Minister's point of view, strange as that may seem. The Minister said that this section was designed mainly to see that workers, tradesmen of a particular trade or craft, would not be deprived of their right to employment by being forced out of a particular trade union. The Minister also referred to the system which he alleges to be in existence regarding apprentices, that is, that you cannot be apprenticed to a particular trade, or a particular number of trades in this city or in this country, unless your father or your uncle or some member of your family was a member of that particular trade and trade union. If the object of the section is as stated by the Minister and if something in that direction was going to be secured by this section then there might be something to be said for it, but so far as I can read the section there is nothing in it from the first to the last line that has the slightest bearing whatever on either, of the two main points made by the Minister in his attempt, as I said, to justify putting this section through the House.

I would like the Minister to tell us which sub-section of Section 11 is going to secure to apprentices anything which they have not got to-day. Is there anything in this section that is going to secure to a man if, for any reason, he ceases to be a member of a trade union, that he can get work at his particular trade in defiance of that trade union? That is the only case I have heard the Minister make on this section. When I raised the point and when I asked the Minister to point out to the House where the question of a member of a union or an apprentice was covered under Section 11, I was hoping the Minister would be good enough to give that information to the House. That, apparently, is not the Minister's intention. Deputy McGilligan put two specific points to the Minister. The Minister, apparently, does not consider either of these points worth answering. Deputy Norton put a number of points to the Minister. The Minister has not thought it worth his while to reply to any of these. Deputy Dillon has just put certain points to the Minister. Again, the Minister does not think it worth his while to make any comment. I suggest, to the Minister, if I may say so, that that is not the most helpful attitude to adopt in dealing with a measure like this. It is a measure on which there are very different points of view, and I would venture to say that if he could get the free voice of this House the Minister would find that the majority of the members of this House have very great fears in regard to this particular Bill and very grave fears as to what is going to arise in this country and in this city as a result of its passage into law. This section may mean a number of things but it certainly does not mean what the Minister says it means. It makes no reference whatever, from the beginning to the end, to the Minister's point about safeguards for tradesmen who have ceased to be members of. unions, who have been expelled from unions, or apprentices. Perhaps, even now, the Minister would give some information to the House on these two matters.

Comment on this

Would the Mimiter reply to these specific points, because they are of considerable importance?

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Minister is putting his eye on the clock instead of on the section.

Comment on this

Maybe when he has the hour's reflection, while the Finance Bill is being taken, he may think better of it.

Comment on this

I move to report progress.

Comment on this

It is not 7 o'clock.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I putting the question.

Comment on this

I want to speak on the section.

Comment on this

This is deliberate obstruction, reducing the proceedings of the House to a farce.

Comment on this

Let the Minister walk out and stay out, for Heaven's sake, and not come back-any more.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is the Deputy moving to report progress?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this