Committee on Finance. - Vote 55—Industry and Commerce.
Contributions 1–108 of 215. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
Go ndeontar suim ná raghaidh thar £165,057 chun slánuithe na suime is gá chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1942, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Oifig an Aire Tionnscail agus Tráchtála agus Seirbhísí áirithe a riartar ag an Oifig sin, ar a n-áirmhítear Ildeontaisí-i-gCabhair.
That a sum, not exceeding £165,057, be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending the 31st day of March, 1942, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and of certain Services administered by that Office, including sundry Grants-in-Aid.
In introducing this Estimate last year I stated that my remarks would necessarily reflect the impact of the European war on our trade and industry, and that statement is as true for this year as for last year. Since then, time and the development of hostilities have intensified our difficulties, particularly in relation to the procurement of plant and raw materials, but we have not yet experienced that general dislocation of our normal productive activities which we all fear and which, to most, must seem to be inescapable. Indeed, so inevitable does it appear, that there is some temptation to be over-pessimistic as to the future course of quite incalculable events. It is wiser and more practical then to review the proximate past and the immediate present and, beyond saying that we must take a serious, indeed a very serious view, of the future, avoid prophecy. The real tests of the immediate economic position are production and employment. I am not yet in a position to give the House full particulars of the census of production in 1940, but I can say that the results available, covering almost half the area of industrial production, indicate that there has not been any decline in output on the average as compared with 1939.
This position is all the more striking when it is remembered that the total volume of output in 1939 of transportable goods was about 5 per cent. greater than in 1938. From this we may conclude that in the very critical year of 1940 we were in possession of or managed to obtain the requisite quantity of raw materials to enable the generality of our industries to continue in normal production, which is something to be thankful for. I dare not suggest that I shall be able to report so favourably next year upon our experience in this. On the contrary, I anticipate a marked deterioration in the position in so far as it is governed by the availability of many essentials which we have normally to bring from overseas.
So far as employment is concerned, the figures of employment in the protected industries in March, 1941, show a decline of about 5 per cent. as compared with the corresponding period last year. As a test of employment generally, outside agriculture, the income of the unemployment fund from the sale of stamps at post offices has decreased by 3 per cent. in the first quarter of 1941, as compared with the same quarter of 1940, and it is down by about 4.8 per cent. as compared with the corresponding period in 1939. On the other hand, the income of the National Health Insurance Fund from the sale of stamps likewise at post offices in the first quarter of 1941 was .25 per cent. greater than the same quarter of 1940 but was 3.4 per cent. less than in the corresponding quarter in 1939.
The figures for employment on farms for the midsummer period of this year are not yet available, but the number of males so occupied in the midsummer of 1940 was 544,000 as compared with 531,000 in 1939. It is not, I think, an unwarrantable assumption that the number so employed this year will show a marked increase over the figures for 1940.
So far as urban employment is concerned, we may take the figures on the live register of unemployment as reflecting the net position. According to the latest return, the total number of persons on the live register who were residing in the cities and urban districts on the 24th May, 1941, was 44,751, including 35,159 men, as compared with 46,793, including 38,970 men, at the nearest corresponding date in 1940. It is significant that there are 3,800 men fewer on the live register this year than there were this time last year.
Comment on this
Yes. I may perhaps anticipate questions in this connection by remarking that the operation of the employment period orders, so far as cities and urban districts are concerned, does not affect the comparability of the figures for this year with last year, so that I am justified, I think, in drawing the deduction that there has been a decline in unemployment of about 4.4 per cent. in cities and urban districts where the decrease in the case of men only is about as much as 9.8 per cent.
Comment on this
Has the Minister made any estimate of what employment these people have been absorbed into?
Comment on this
I have not been able to do that, but I am going to make a suggestion which may cover some part of the decrease.
Comment on this
There has been a decrease of 9.8 per cent. as far as the men are concerned. As I said of the volume of production in 1940, I may also say of the comparative steadiness of employment, taking the country as a whole: the worst of our earlier fears in that regard have not materialised yet, which is due in part, no doubt, to the fact that so many of our citizens have left their normal pursuits to enlist in the Defence Forces. At the same time, in this connection, and while making every allowance for the enlistments, we must not lose sight of the very significant fact that on the balance inwards and outwards of passenger traffic over our land and sea frontiers, the estimated balance inwards by rail, road, sea and air, except in regard to passenger movement on foot or in private vehicles, during the period from September, 1939, to May, 1941, was between 45,000 and 50,000.
The two largest accessions to positive employment have been in the production of food and the production of fuel. The drive for increased agricultural production inevitably led to additional new employment and to more full-time employment for those ordinarily working on farms. The turf cutting campaign has created an intense demand for labour suitable and available in the vicinity of bogs. When I spoke last year on the Estimates I referred at some length to the duty which then rested on me of increasing production of native fuel, particularly turf. In the course of the year, after full consideration it was decided to unify the control of all the various turf-producing agencies, and this control now rests in the hands of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. The Dáil has already indicated how whole-heartedly it approves of that arrangement. So far as coal is concerned, the House will be interested to know that the production of semi-bituminous coal in the year 1940 from the Arigna district was more than double what it had been on the average over several preceding years. It is hoped that the production in 1941 will be still further increased. So far as anthracite is concerned, the estimated output this year will be something over 100,000 tons, without taking into account possible additions to the output of new production from the mine opened some time ago at The Swan, and from the Slievardagh property. The House is already aware of the steps taken recently to establish a new company for immediate development of the anthracite deposits in the Slievardagh district. That company is in existence, and is proceeding as rapidly as possible with the development. The present Estimates include a sum of £21,100 for that company, as well as £18,100 for the Mineral Development and Exploration Company, which is now in process of formation.
In the course of the year I have been giving constant consideration to two problems; the first relating to the impact of the war conditions on the poorest class of the community, and the second, how best to prolong existing employment. By Emergency Powers (No. 93) Order, 1941, allowances for dependents under the Unemployment Insurance Acts were last month increased from 5/- to 7/6 per week for adult dependents, and from 1/- to 2/6 per week for child dependents. So far as recipients of unemployment assistance are concerned, plans are in active course of preparation for the distribution of vouchers entitling the recipients of unemployment assistance, as well as of old age and widows' and orphans' pensions, to weekly rations of milk, bread and butter. It is hoped that this scheme will be in operation within the next few weeks. It is intended in this case likewise to put the scheme into effect by an order under the Emergency Powers Acts, 1939 to 1940. Recently, I have had conferences with representatives of the Trade Union Congress, of Federated Employers Limited, and the Federation of Irish Manufacturers, regarding the need for formulating plans for short-time working where the supply position dictated such a course. Naturally, such plans will take time to work out in detail, and must, of course, be based upon agreements between employers and employees in each particular concern or industry. In the meantime, however, I am in the course of making such amendments in the Unemployment Insurance and Unemployment Assistance Acts as will enable unemployment benefit or assistance to be paid in the case of alternating periods of employment and unemployment much more flexibly and much more readily than can be done under the existing regulations. The changes I am considering will definitely ease the situation for the employees of such firms as may find it practicable to produce schemes for part-time or rotational employment.
Comment on this
By order. In connection with all this, there is close collaboration between my Department and the Department of Supplies in the matter of the availability of supplies for each industry, and this collaboration of the two Departments with the industries concerned, with all engaged in the industries concerned, should yield helpful results in prolonging employment. There will, no doubt, be special difficulties in certain industries, but I am hopeful that, by the cooperation of all concerned, we shall mitigate the hardships which the present conflict will impose upon large sections of our industrial workers.
An allegation was made recently in this House that men were refused unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance because they had refused to go to the United Kingdom to take work. I should like to take this opportunity of stating categorically that there is no shadow of foundation for such an allegation.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Minister alleges that a statement was made in this House not once but several times, and he has been asked to give the quotation. I definitely say that, so far as I know— and I have been in the House fairly constantly—the statement which the Minister has now put before the House was not made. I think in fairness to the House itself the Minister should give the quotation. If the statement was made in the House it is on record.
Comment on this
On the point of order, the Chair cannot ask the Minister to quote, since he has not attributed the statement to a Deputy.
Comment on this
Statements, perhaps not in those precise words, have been made in this House, which do suggest to uninformed people——
Comment on this
——that men have been deprived of unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance because they refused to go to the United Kingdom to take work. I should like, as I have said already, to state categorically that there is not a shadow of foundation for that statement or for that suggestion.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, the opposite would seem to be the case. Over and over again I have had complaints of difficulties being experienced by Irish workers who desired to take up employment in Great Britain. My own view, in that regard, is that it would be wrong to exercise any form of compulsion on workers of this country to leave this country for such work, and that it would be equally wrong to take active steps to prevent men, who are unable to obtain employment here, from obtaining work elsewhere if they desire to do so. Indeed, my wish would be to do everything to safeguard and protect the interests of those who may have been called upon to look for work outside the country.
On occasions, references are made in this House and elsewhere to the possibility of the Government providing work for all the unemployed. Accordingly, it is necessary to make the position in that regard quite plain. The policy of providing economic work by way of developing new industries and maintaining those recently established is meeting with almost insuperable difficulties and obstacles in present conditions. Except in quite exceptional cases, or under unacceptable conditions, new machinery is virtually unobtainable. There are difficulties of a like kind in relation to the necessary supplies and technical direction for operating such plants. The fundamental factors in the present situation are frequently ignored. Yet, the fact that we are being drastically rationed in regard to such common commodities and industrial essentials as coal, timber, fuel oil, kerosene and petrol, should bring home to us how difficult it is to procure specialised equipment, the production and export of which are much more rigorously restricted.
We are faced with the same difficulties in preparing programmes of public works to deal with the unemployment in many industries which will be inevitable in consequence of the cessation of normal supplies of raw materials. Once again, plant and materials, often unprocurable, are required if works are to be undertaken upon any rational basis. The exhaustive examination made some years ago into the problem of providing work for the unemployed revealed that, apart from other very serious difficulties, one of the most serious then—and it is still more serious now—was to devise public works, of any practical utility whatsoever, in which the labour content would be sufficiently high to provide an adequate alternative to relief by way of benefit or assistance. It is necessary, I think, that this fact should be grasped by those who talk as though the task of absorbing the unemployed in useful occupations was as easy as putting pen to paper. As an example of the practical difficulties which confront those who undertake the planning of major public works as a means of relieving unemployment, I may refer to the recently published report of the Drainage Commission. We all know that the execution of large-scale drainage works has very often been pressed as a remedy for unemployment. That matter was exhaustively examined by the Drainage Commission, and here is what the report of that commission has to say in regard to it—I am quoting from paragraphs 202-206 inclusive, of the published report:
"Many witnesses strongly advocated a national scheme of arterial drainage for the reasons that it would make a very considerable contribution to the solution of unemployment, that several thousands of men would be permanently employed all over the country for many years, and that the savings in unemployment assistance would in large measure meet the cost of the works.
"It is, however, necessary to point out that drainage construction works do not afford a very satisfactory solution for unemployment. Drainage areas do not always correspond with unemployment areas. Even if work is continued all through the year, the pace of operations must be reduced in winter and intensified with low river flows, good weather conditions and long hours of daylight in summer, when the problem of unemployment is less pressing in agricultural areas. Works will not be in progress simultaneously all over the country. They will tend in a particular year to be concentrated in a very few catchment areas. The work will have to be organised in gangs moving up-river with the gradual progress of the operations. Assuming an annual expenditure of £250,000, an unskilled labour content of 30 per cent. a year of 300 working days, and a weekly wage of £1 10s. 0d., whole-time employment would be afforded for only 1,000 unskilled men which would probably work out at 1,500 men for the six months summer period and 500 for the six months winter period. Assuming that 1,000 unemployed men secure regular work on drainage for a year, and that all these men are unmarried without means or dependents, to whom the lowest rates of unemployment assistance (ranging from 6s. to 10s. 6d. per week according to area) are payable, the approximate annual saving on unemployment assistance would range from £5,100 to £27,300. In view of the fact that rates of unemployment assistance are graded according to dependency until they reach a weekly rate (in the case of a man with a dependent wife and five or more other dependents) varying from 14s. to 23s. according to area, it may be assumed that the saving on unemployment assistance will be more substantial than £5,100 especially as the practice in the case of works wholly or partly financed from public funds is to give preference for work to recipients of unemployment assistance and priority to those in receipt of the highest rates of assistance. During the summer employment period, some 32,000 rural residents may be off the register. During this period they cannot register for assistance, but they can register for work when they rank on the same basis as those in receipt of unemployment assistance.
"The lower figure of £5,100 is based on the assumption that all the workers come from rural areas and consequently would not qualify for assistance during the summer employment period which during the present year covers a period of 35 weeks. The higher figure of £27,300 is based on the assumption that all labour would be recruited from the county boroughs, where the rates of unemployment assistance are highest and the Employment Period Orders do not apply. It will, however, be appreciated that it is highly unlikely that workers from the county boroughs would be employed to any substantial extent on drainage schemes. If all the labour employed were recruited from the rural areas and employment were provided for 1,000 men in winter as well as in summer, the maximum saving on unemployment assistance—assuming that those employed were entitled to the highest rural rates of assistance —would be £11,900 per annum.
"The Office of Public Works informed us that on employment schemes the equivalent of full-time employment for 15,000 to 16,000 men is provided each year. Approximately a quarter of the benefit goes to urban areas, half to congested rural areas, and the other quarter to other rural areas. It is estimated that, under the system of rotational employment by which a workman receives 16 to 18 weeks' work each year, each week consisting of three to four days' employment, the cost to the State is about £43 per man per year including all costs of work, labour, material and unemployment assistance for the balance of the year. It may be argued that each such man put into steady employment represents an offsetting saving to the State of £43 per annum. The extent of such savings on drainage works would, however, depend in substantial measure on the location of the actual works. As indicated above, only a quarter of the expenditure on employment schemes is incurred in rural areas outside the congested districts and it may be taken that the expenditure normally provided for in many of the areas where drainage schemes would be undertaken would be small."
Now, what are the salient facts which emerge from the report of the Drainage Commission with regard to the practical utility of drainage works as a means of relieving the unemployed? They are these: that for an annual expenditure of £250,000 on arterial drainage, whole-time employment would be provided for about 1,000 unskilled men at about 30/- per week. That is to say, these 1,000 men if working all the year round, would draw out of that £250,000 about £78,000. As against this, the State, which of course in this connection means the general body of taxpayers and their dependents, would save about £11,900 per annum in unemployment assistance formerly payable to the men employed on the drainage works. The net cash benefit of the drainage works to the 1,000 men employed thereon accordingly would be £66,000—no inconsiderable sum no doubt, but nevertheless only a very little in excess of one quarter of the total burden of £250,000 annually which the community would have to shoulder in order to provide this work for 1,000 men.
Now, it is true, and I wish to lay all the emphasis possible on the fact, that the execution of arterial drainage works serves many other purposes than merely to provide employment. Some of these are set out in paragraphs 153-157 of the Drainage Commission's report, where, for instance, it is stated
(1) That an efficient system of drainage is an essential condition for good tillage, healthy pasture, and the elimination of disease in farming stock.
(2) That the reclamation or development of bogs on a national scale cannot be successfully carried out unless preceded by arterial drainage.
(3) That in many areas injury to public highways and bridges and dislocation of traffic and transport will be relieved.
(4) That a good system of drainage will bring considerable improvement in public health conditions.
(5) That relief will be afforded to many urban areas by the prevention of periodical flooding, and by the provision of better sewerage outfalls.
Accordingly, a national scheme of arterial drainage might be justified upon many grounds of public utility other than as a relief measure to deal with unemployment.
But in regard to how many of the other types of relief work which are sometimes suggested could that be said? In order to demonstrate the importance of the utility factor in relation to public works as a means of relieving unemployment, let us consider the cost of a project undertaken, not because it had any public utility whatsoever, but merely because it affords an opportunity of compelling men to work. Assume now that the project is a substantial one involving an expenditure, like arterial drainage, of £250,000 per annum, and that the unskilled labour content of the works is the same as for an arterial drainage scheme, let us see what the effect of undertaking such a project would be upon community employment in general.
To start off with, the community must, somehow or other, provide £250,000. Since the unskilled labour content of the work is about 30 per cent., the maximum sum which can be spent in wages is about £75,000. If the works are carried out in a rural area, this would give employment to about 1,000 men for one year. If, on the other hand, the works are being carried out in an urban area, the amount of employment would be correspondingly reduced, since the wage rates are higher, and probably only about 600 men would get the 12 months' job. If the works were in a rural area, the State or taxpayer would be saved about £11,900 or, say, £12,000, in unemployment assistance payments, while, if they are carried out in an urban area, the saving would be about £16,000. Thus, the net additional cash gain to the men employed would be about £63,000 in a rural area, or £59,000 in, say, a county borough; while the net cost, accordingly, to the taxpayer of the works would be £238,000 in a rural area, and £234,000 in an urban area. In either case, the money would all have to come out of the taxpayers' pockets, and would only be found by imposing additional taxation.
Now, it does not matter in what form the taxation is imposed, wheather it be as a tax on tobacco, a tax on tea, a tax on sugar, or a tax on income; it means that those upon whom the tax falls have less money to spend upon their needs and according to their own desires. The poorer classes will have less money to spend on the necessaries of life; the better-off classes will have less to spend on amenities. Because the additional taxation compels people to curtail expenditure upon goods or services to which they have been accustomed, there must inevitably be a reduced demand for those workers who were formerly employed in supplying either the demands for the necessaries of life or the demands for the amenities of life.
In relation to this particular work of low utility which we have been considering, we therefore find ourselves up against the following practical difficulty if we are proposing to carry it out merely to provide work for the unemployed. Is it wise or justifiable to divert an expenditure of £250,000 from its normal and natural use in procuring necessaries or amenities to which the community as a whole, or sections of it, have become accustomed? Particularly, is it wise or justifiable, when we thereby reduce employment to a proportionate extent in those trades and industries which are meeting this demand, and when we are not in a position to ensure that anything more than one-third of the money so diverted will find its way, in the form of wages, into the pockets of other individuals in the community? Is it not clear that in the extreme cases which I have been discussing, the employment which is afforded to 1,000 individuals to earn £75,000 over the year is given to them at the expense of all those other workers amongst whom £250,000 was formerly expended? We are, therefore, I suggest, driven to the general conclusion that unless a public work is of great public utility, and has a high labour content, the net result of the undertaking will not be to increase employment in the community in general, but to diminish it, some times very seriously indeed. Accordingly, when we endeavour to frame a programme to deal with unemployment, we must be very careful not to indulge in unwise expenditure, the result of which will be merely to aggravate the very evil we are endeavouring to cure. It is necessary that I should stress this danger, because it is important in our present circumstances that we should face our problems, and particularly this problem of unemployment, in a coldly realistic frame of mind. By all means we must put as many of our people to work as is practically possible, but it must be on work which is reproductive and useful, work, indeed, which those who are employed on it will regard as such, for there is nothing so demoralising to a man as to set him to do something which he knows to be valueless. We must employ the limited resources of plant, materials, and technical skill with the greatest possible economy, so as to ensure that they will provide the utmost good for the community as a whole. Our restricted supplies of timber, metals, chemicals and fuel must be conserved for the normal needs of industry. In my view we cannot do that if we squander our stores by impracticable, ill-considered and grandiose schemes which may have nothing to recommend them, beyond the opportunities which they afford for political tub-thumping of the most blatant and unscrupulous kind.
Comment on this
As to the practical problems which arise out of that fact, it is essential that our raw materials should be put to the best possible use. I may say that the closest liaison is maintained between my Department and the Department of Supplies in relation to that matter, and not only that, but for a considerable time past officers of my Department and of the Department of Supplies have been meeting several industrial groups in the country to discuss with them the particular difficulties which they are experiencing in regard to supplies and other matters. Since the establishment of the Emergency Research Bureau these conferences have been attended by representatives of that body. I think I may say that they have been of great value, both to the particular industrialists concerned and to the Government Departments.
Comment on this
Over 100 meetings have been held in the course of 12 months, and out of that number members of the Emergency Research Bureau attended 30. The reduction in our fuel oil supplies since the beginning of the year necessitated a substantial reduction in the operation of transport road services both for passengers and merchandise. Reductions of rail services have been recently found necessary consequent on the shortage of coal supplies. These reductions have been confined to the passenger services, and being of a limited nature, affecting mainly excursion and Sunday traffic, they are occasioning the least possible inconvenience to the travelling public and the business community in general. Should, however, the position not materially improve, I should like to give notice that it may be necessary to restrict even more substantially the services, both by rail and road, but in any restrictions which may be necessary, the interests of the other users of the railways, and particularly the necessity for the provision of sufficient transport for essential commodities, will, of course, be kept carefully in mind.
Consequent on the loss of revenue experienced by the Great Southern Railways owing to the reduction of their passenger road traffic and increased cost of operation, the company considered it necessary in March last to increase substantially the fares on passenger road services. While I appreciate that there are grounds for increased fares on these services, I should say that I am not satisfied that the extent to which they were increased was fully justifiable. I have the matter still under consideration with the company, which in the meantime is introducing some attractions in the form of cheap one-day tickets on practically all services. The falling off of the trade of our ports consequent on the reduction of shipping due to the war has necessitated in many cases an increase of port charges and in some cases has seriously affected the financial position of harbour authorities, which is a problem to which I have been giving some attention.
Comment on this
It is better to promise nothing until one is satisfied that he is able to give effect to the promise. The Deputy must be aware that the matter is not fully in my hands and that we have a duty to the community in general as well as to the harbour authorities.
Comment on this
After all, the lot of citizens to whom no compensation is given comes first. We cannot say that harbour or any local authorities can be considered a first charge on all the citizens.
Comment on this
Some fears have been expressed as to the ability of our transport services to cope with the carriage of grain, beet and turf. So far as the capacity of the railway rolling stock and road vehicles is concerned we need have no apprehension in that regard. They are ample for the purpose. Of course the difficulty with regard to fuel supplies remains, and may necestion sitate further restrictions on services, both on rail and road. The Department of Supplies is, however, dealing with that aspect of the problem and, no doubt, will do everything possible to ensure that supplies of fuel will be available for the transport of essential commodities. The shipping of the country has had both gains and losses since last year.
Since the outbreak of hostilities ten Irish registered ships have been sunk, and in eight of these cases it has been established that the loss was due to belligerent action. Irish ships have also, from time to time, been the targets of attack by bombing aircraft, but the damage caused in this way has, happily, not been serious. On the other hand, the Irish mercantile marine will be substantially strengthened by the addition of a number of vessels acquired by Irish Shipping, Limited. Generally I may say that my powers under emergency legislation have been used to ensure that, so far as possible, ships on the Irish register are used to the best advantage from the point of view of our trade.
There has been steady development in our air transport. Despite drastic restrictions on travel during the summer and autumn months, and the complete suspension of flying, owing to weather conditions, for a fortnight in January and February last, some 2,500 passengers more than in the previous year were carried during 1940 on the service operating between this country and Great Britain. Transport by air has many attractions in war time, and the aircraft engaged in the cross-Channel services are operating to their fullest capacity. Building operations on the new Dublin airport slowed down somewhat owing to the difficulty of supplies, but the aerodrome has given every satisfaction in operation. Our interest in the transatlantic services is maintained through the services which are now being operated from the Shannon airport to Lisbon. I do not think there is anything further I can add to the very full review of the activities of my Department which I have just given.
Comment on this
I move:—
That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration.
I think I can say without the least exaggeration that this Vote comes up for discussion at a time of very great gravity in this country. I think I could go somewhat further and say that, in the 18 years during which I have been a member of this House, I do not remember this Vote coming up for consideration in circumstances of more exceptional gravity than those which prevail to-day. One would have thought that in such a situation, a situation of unparalleled gravity so far as our experience so far has gone, this Vote would give some indication of an appreciation of the position. I regret that the Minister's statement has shown no indication whatever of any adjustment to the new and very serious situation which has developed here. To a large extent, of course, the situation is not new, but it is freely granted to the Minister that the difficulties which have arisen since the outbreak of the war have greatly intensified the situation. My submission to the House this evening is that that situation has been made worse by the inaction and ineptitude associated with the Minister's Department during the year, and that has been amply reflected in the statement, or, rather, the apologia, given to the House by the Minister.
It seems clear to me, and I think it must be fairly apparent to the House generally, that the Minister is still definitely and firmly wedded to the old, time-worn methods of dealing with a problem of this kind, and that he at least has concluded that poverty, want, destitution and decay are matters for which he has no special responsibility, and in respect of them he has not seen fit to present any special proposals to the House. If we are to regard the situation which prevails at present as inevitable, to throw up our hands in despair and to say that things might have been worse, then our main function, and indeed the function of the Minister as the Minister responsible to the House and to the country for industry and commerce, go entirely by the board. The Minister has spoken in practically the same vein, and has offered the same opinions as can readily be found in any statement he made to meetings of the Chamber of Commerce in this city, to meetings of bankers in this city and to other gatherings of the same kind. The new and terrible facts which are forcing themselves on the minds of the people, no matter how lightly they apply themselves to a consideration of the position, had no place, and did not get even a passing mention, in the Minister's statement. We just heard a lecture of a kind which is going to be cold comfort and which will bring very little hope to the people in the terrible plight in which they are at the moment.
The Minister has referred to unemployment. Could anything be more regrettable than the Minister's inaction in that respect? I rely on one concrete instance to show how blameworthy the Minister is in this regard. In December, 1940, this House was asked to consider a motion by the Labour Party that proposals should be formulated within a period of six months to meet the unemployment position, and yesterday we learned that the terms of reference of the commission set up in pursuance of an amendment presented by the Minister to that motion, and carried by a majority of the House, have not yet been settled, and so this fiddling, this reproduction of the attitude of Mr. Micawber, continues, while our whole social fabric is in danger of being overthrown. I say that the Minister in his statement has shown that, if the outlook in his Department is not changed completely, there is very little hope in his Department for the people who are idle at present, and whose numbers are increasing daily.
We got the very significant information in the last day or two that 1,100 persons per month up to the date for which the latest figures are available, were leaving this country to seek employment in another country, and taking all the risks which are bound to attend their looking for employment in that country and continuing in any employment they get there. To that figure can be added the large number of people who are unofficially leaving this country through the Six Counties to join the British Army. The majority, if not practically every one, of the people concerned have no interest in the war. They are going for the plain and avowed reason of endeavouring to get some employment, and are joining the army for preference, in order that their dependents who remain behind will get some allowance to sustain them in the difficult times through which they are passing. Years ago, the London Times joyously announced that the Celt was going from this country, and going with a vengeance. It is certainly one of the tragedies of our present time, when this country is in the control of a Government of Irishmen, that that position can be reflected and repeated in the happenings of to-day. I consider that the attitude of the Minister and his Department, and his inaction, and the inaction of the Government generally, in this connection, is a very strong factor in the repetition of the condition of things that was so joyously reported on by a newspaper that hated this country and everything this country stood for at that particular time.
I want to urge the Minister, before this debate concludes, to give the House some indication of a change of heart from a policy that talks of unemployment, of want and of the difficulties of the present position, in some other way than the academic way that the Minister has dealt with this problem. I want to refer to one happening during the year—the establishment of what has been described as the Construction Corps. If that act was intended as a contribution towards the relief and reduction of unemployment, the conception behind it was singularly unhappy. It has done a great deal to arouse suspicion that has not been eased by happenings since then which have emanated from some official quarters. There never seemed to be any direct explanation as to whether unemployed workers who were offered recruitment in that Construction Corps would be within or outside the Army. There was the statement of the Taoiseach that they were within the framework of the Army. The whole atmosphere in which that arrangement was conceived and certain things that have happened since go very clearly to show that there was some ground at least for the suspicion that the ideal behind the scheme was one of industrial conscription, and that the people recruited behind it might be used for the purpose of lowering wages and breaking conditions of employment throughout the country.
In fact, in Cobh some time ago, a situation arose that goes to bear out that particular point of view. Members of the Construction Corps—we were informed lately on this matter— were asked to do work that civilians did formerly, and when certain members of the corps expressed the view that they should not be asked to do that work, as it was interfering in a direction and a domain they never intended when they were recruited for membership, they were put under arrest and confined or imprisoned—all because they refused to take the bread out of the mouths of civilians who always were engaged on this work formerly and paid certain rates of wages for it. The Minister should look into that whole question again.
I do not stand, and have never stood in this House, for people who would refuse to work. I have no sympathy with such people, but I think the approach to this whole question in that respect is wrong. The Minister should have no doubt about the fact that, if the approach to this question is made in the right way, he will get a 99 per cent. response from the working people, who are anxious—and have been anxious always—to work. If approached in the proper way and in the right spirit, they will give a response that will gladden the Minister's heart, if he has any doubts about this particular matter. I have had experience before me in the matter of the production of fuel in the last two or three months, of people vieing with one another to go a very considerable distance to work.
It may be said that that is a characteristic of the working man in the rural areas, that he always has been prepared to do that. It may be said that it does not apply in the cities; but let us take the experience in Cork recently, where over 2,000 unemployed men—many of whom had never seen a turf bog—offered themselves for employment in the turf bogs. Many of them were men who had been cut off unemployment assistance because they refused to join the Construction Corps. The Minister must be aware of the fact that, amongst many in this country—now or at any time—there would be for many reasons some reservations about undertaking military service. In depriving people of that kind of employment assistance without ascertaining whether they had refused any other bona-fide or genuine offer of employment, the Minister acted in a way that showed a very lamentable lack of consideration for this whole question.
For the few little rays of light that are shed by the Minister's statement we are thankful. It is well to know that, after a very long period of consideration, the Minister has realised that the amounts paid to the dependents of people in receipt of unemployment insurance have been entirely too low. The small increases which have been granted in that respect go at least to show that there is some realisation of the great injustice and continued wrong over a long period to which people in that position have been subjected hitherto. It is not, of course, true to say that extra grants in the way of vouchers of food are being given to old age pensioners, widowers, and dependents of persons in receipt of unemployment assistance. The proposals, as I understand them and as I have been informed about them, are very far short of doing anything of the kind. They are being confined to urban areas, and the people in the rural districts are entirely excluded from the benefits. Surely at the present time, if a scheme of that kind is to be worth anything it must have national application, and before it comes into force I ask the Minister earnestly to reconsider this matter and bring proposals to this House or deal with it otherwise—I think he has indicated that he proposes to deal with it otherwise—so as to enable the people in the rural areas to benefit by it.
The method of granting assistance to people of that kind by way of food vouchers is a most unfortunate one. The operation of such schemes through the agency of the boards of health and the assistance officers is a singularly unhappy method—it is a reflection on the housekeeping ability and the worth of the people concerned in managing their little affairs, to say to them that they could not be trusted with money allowances in respect of whatever little increases they will get.
Furthermore, as one having a great deal of experience of the working of a board of health, I say that the giving of assistance of this kind in the way that a board gives it between one meeting and another to the poor, as provisional assistance or by food vouchers, almost inevitably means that the persons concerned cannot get the best value out of it. It affords them no assistance in meeting the other charges that are recurring problems. I suggest, therefore, that the allowances referred to be paid in cash and I suggest that, after fully considering the view point of the Government in this particular connection—that it is the amount of food and the particular food that will matter in the future. I should like to know whether it is permissible on this Vote to refer to the unemployment insurance and unemployment assistance. I know that they are separate Votes but I seem to recollect that, in former years, all the Votes were discussed at the same time.
Comment on this
I think that would be the most convenient procedure— to discuss the subject matter of all the Votes on this Vote.
Comment on this
Before I pass on to the matters with which I am concerned, I want to say—and this is not for the purpose of attacking the Minister—that I very sincerely regret, which regret must be shared by other members of the House, that we spent two or three weeks in discussing a measure recently which could, under no circumstances, be regarded as urgent, while we have not been able to give any considerable amount of time to the urgent problems that exist and which are reflected in the figure of 60,000 persons on the live register— a figure that would be immensely increased were it not for the large number of persons taken into our Defence Forces, the number of persons who have gone to England, incurring the risk of maiming and injury, as well as the risk to their life, to get employment, and the large number of able-bodied men who are being conscripted by hunger and want into the ranks of the British Army to fight in a war in which they have no interest and in which they only engage because they have been denied a living in their own country.
One begins to despair of the future of this country when proposals for the relief of unemployment are left to enterprising and well-disposed organisations. I do not say that by way of reflecting on what has been done in that way; I think it has been well done. But if we can have no greater national approach to this question of poverty and want than that made by Judge Wylie, the Mount Street Club and various organisations in this country, then we might well say "God save Ireland," because it will be necessary for some agency other than this House, and this Government, to step in and save the country from the catastrophe which is otherwise bound to overtake us. The situation which gives us a huge number of idle people, ready to work, with opportunity for absorbing their labour, and a continuation of the policy of inaction which separates the unemployed workmen from the labour which is at hand for them to do, represents a grave indictment of the Minister and of this House as a Parliament that legislates wisely for the country, which ought to be the first function of Parliament.
Regarding the question of unemployment assistance, I want to repeat a complaint I have made in this House more than once as to the unsatisfactory method that has been adopted in dealing with assessments of means. The question is not, so far as the rural areas are concerned, an urgent one now, and an opportunity is provided to deal with the matter in a proper way. The applicant for unemployment assistance ought to be informed of the basis on which his means are calculated. The same applies in the case of assessment of means for old age pensions and widows' pensions. The applicant should be given an opportunity to rebut whatever statements are submitted officially regarding his means. I am entirely unconvinced by any explanation I have heard so far, that an entirely fictitious standard has not been set up in calculating the means of a large number of applicants for unemployment assistance. I want to repeat, too, the complaint that there has been too much delay in notifying decisions in these cases. This was the subject of discussion before, and I, as well as other members of the House, have had correspondence with the Minister on the subject. A great improvement ought to be effected in the clearing of cases of that kind and in notifying members of this House and others interested of the decisions taken. That is not outside the region of reasonable practicability, and I press that viewpoint on the Minister.
I am wondering how up-to-date is the information of the Minister's Department as regards certain matters. I asked a question some time ago about the number of registered unemployed in part of my constituency, which is off the mainland—Bere Island. Bere Island, as some members of the House know, is a well-defined area. It is entirely surrounded by water and there could be no difficulty in establishing that fact, which is a geographical fact, entirely unassailable. In the reply which I received to that question, I was referred to the number of people on Bere Island and reference was made to the possible population of all the other islands in the neighbourhood. I have tried—whether I have succeeded or not I do not know—to convince the Department that the other islands referred to were just barren rocks which had never been inhabited. They were never inhabited by anything more than birds. To mention places of that kind for the purpose of unemployment returns would seem to me to be nothing more than putting up a smokescreen, as there was never a living soul in residence on some of these islands. There is no purpose in evasion of that kind. I cannot understand why a State Department should make a laughing-stock of itself in this way, to the knowledge of everybody locally who knows the facts.
It seems to me that from whatever aspect one wants to examine this Vote, no case can be made for the Minister. He has been found wanting in this respect. If the Minister has any doubt that that is the viewpoint of the ordinary citizen, the person one meets in the rural districts and in the small towns and villages, he can easily ascertain what that viewpoint is. I think he will have no difficulty in ascertaining that the people who expected some approach, some leadership, some effort from him in facing the present menacing position have concluded that up to the present there has been no sign of that approach. The Minister's statement to-day confirms that view. I do not think the Minister is entitled to this Vote on the case he made and, therefore, I am moving that it be referred back for reconsideration.
Comment on this
Listening to the Minister's comments on the report of the Drainage Commission, I felt that I never listened to a greater piece of economic heresy. His approach to the consideration of the commission's report was typical of Fianna Fáil's approach to the whole problem of unemployment. He merely looked at it from the employment utility aspect and he condemned national drainage on the grounds that its cost of £250,000 annually——
Comment on this
The Minister condemned it on the grounds that an expenditure of that magnitude imposed on every class in the community would not be justified, viewed from the aspect of the amount of employment in the rural districts it would afford, namely, 1,000 men each year.
Comment on this
A proper approach to the unemployment problem will not be made by looking for the type of work that will absorb the greatest number of unemployed, irrespective of what type that work is. The Minister said, in relation to work of low utility—I took down what he said, word for word——
Comment on this
Dealing with unemployment, we must approach it mainly from the point of view of production. If we are going to find a permanent solution for unemployment, it can only be found through the medium of increased production. I stress that point in approaching the problem of drainage. The Minister overlooked the fact that arterial drainage might improve a considerable amount of land.
Comment on this
Not only would it give employment in the actual work of arterial drainage, but there would be a considerable volume of work on field drainage as well and, incidental to the opening up of field drainage, it might mean bringing a considerable area of land into production and cultivation. The Minister seemed to overlook that aspect. I regard the farm improvement scheme, which was in operation for the first time last year, as a very useful scheme, but that scheme cannot be made a complete success without some sort of arterial drainage. Most of the money spent under that scheme went on field drainage and that work cannot be properly done if there is not a proper fall for the field drainage. When we talk about national drainage, we have in mind mainly the construction of a suitable fall which will enable farmers to complete the drainage of their lands and bring those lands later into production. The natural corollary to good drainage work is increased production and, in turn, that brings about increased employment.
Huge sums of money have been spent during the last ten years on works which were mostly of an unproductive nature, works that gave little return to the State. Those works were a heavy drain on the financial resources of the country and they never could hope permanently to solve unemployment. In fact, those works had almost the reverse effect; the State was getting no return out of the work done and, at the same time, it was becoming poorer. We must approach this problem mainly through the medium of production. We should talk far more about production as the real solution for unemployment because, if we get the increased production, the unemployment problem will largely be solved. I was disgusted with the Minister's outlook on drainage. What he said was the height of economic heresy.
Comment on this
The Minister did not know what he was talking about. There was one important matter that I thought the Minister would refer to, and that is, how soon he will be able to get the Mineral Development Company into operation? This country is deeply concerned with food production. We were lucky enough to have a certain amount of artificial manure this year. In some cases we had not quite enough, but, on the whole, we fared pretty well. So far as one can see, we will have very little next year unless something is now done about it. We have phosphate rock deposit in County Clare, and, since the inception of the emergency, it has been mentioned on numerous occasions here. Questions were submitted in relation to it, and it has been discussed on Votes for various Departments. The Government have been asked what they are doing about it. We are within three months of next winter's sowing period, and nothing has been done about the development of our phosphate resources. I submitted a question to the Minister recently, and his reply showed that he knew very little about it, but he informed us that the phosphates there were not as rich as North African phosphates, and were not as soluble, and we would require more of the Clare phosphates than we would of the North African phosphates. I do not know what it is going to cost, but as a farmer I know that there is a lot of land in this country that will give a very poor return if it is put into cultivation without any artificial manure.
In the old tillage districts especially, we shall be facing a very serious situation next year if we have to try to produce crops without any artificial manure, particularly the basic manure, superphosphate. We have raw material here; it is a most important matter that it should be utilised to stimulate food production next year, and this is the time we ought to be on our toes about it if anything is to be done. Precious time is being lost. In another three months the season will be upon us, but the Minister, as far as I can see, is quite indifferent about it. He made no reference to the problem, good, bad or indifferent, this evening. It has certainly been agitating and worrying my mind for the last few months, and I have asked a number of questions about it. I have brought it to the Minister's notice. I have tried to get a move on as far as the Minister is concerned. Whether he fails to appreciate the gravity of the situation, or what is wrong, I do not know, but I do know that nothing has been done about it up to date.
I should like to point out that normally our supplies of sulphuric acid are derived from imported pyrites. I should like to know from the Minister whether it is possible to import pyrites and, if not, whether any consideration has been given to the manufacture of sulphuric acid from gypsum. In Subhead M (4) of this Estimate a sum of £3,000 is provided for a research laboratory. In that connection, I should like to know whether any examination has been given to the question of the manufacture of sulphuric acid from gypsum or whether it is possible to import the pyrites necessary for the manufacture of sulphuric acid, because if we are going to deal with large quantities of phosphate rock, particularly rock of a hard nature— and our rock is definitely much harder than North African rock—we should certainly require large quantities of sulphuric acid. Again, has any consideration been given by the Research Council to the production of nitrate of lime here? We have the raw materials here; we have the limestone, we have the anthracite and we have the electricity. I do not know what it would cost to provide a plant for the production of nitrate of lime, but that is certainly another problem that calls for examination. If we have no manure in the form of nitrate for poor land the result will be a very serious falling off in production.
Take again the question of potash. We were told by the Parliamentary Secretary, who deals with the Gaeltacht services, that something was being done about the manufacture of potash from seaweed. What progress has been made in that direction? We have not got any information so far. If the Minister is dealing with the matter, I should like to know what is being done and what measure of success has been achieved. Are we likely to get any great quantity of potash from seaweed? To my mind, these are matters of the very gravest importance at the present time, and they ought to engage the Minister's immediate attention. First of all he should see that we get all the basic manure, superphosphate, that we can manufacture because even if it is of poorer quality than the North African phosphate it is better than nothing at all. It is better to try to secure a profitable yield from poor land with the assistance of artificial manure than to attempt to produce crops off that land when we know that it cannot give a satisfactory yield without the addition of some form of plant food. If it is discovered that Clare phosphate is not soluble in the 2 per cent. citric solution, which is the equivalent to soil conditions, or if its solubility is much lower than North African phosphate, to counteract that slower effect the farmer will have to be asked to apply it to the soil three or four months earlier than normally. That slowness in solubility can be counteracted by an earlier application to the soil. The Minister for that reason will appreciate the necessity of getting anything we are able to get on the market as early as possible, so that it can be applied as soon as possible to the land. Here, however, we are in the month of July and nothing so far has been done about it. I should like the Minister when he is replying to give us the full facts of the case, to state when the new company is likely to start operations, what the production is likely to be and what supply we may hope for next year.
The Minister gave us some figures about coal production. I think he told us that in the Arigna district production of coal had been doubled and that the output of anthracite in other districts had been increased. A short time ago the possibility of developing the old coal deposits in the Munster coalfields and also the Leinster coalfields around Carlow was brought to the Minister's notice. While I realise that the coal in some of these fields is of rather doubtful quality, that the seams are very thin and probably faulty, it struck me, having regard to the emergency situation and the very serious shortage of fuel we are experiencing, that some of these fields or the outcrops of them might be well worth working. The outcrops in the Carlow-Kilkenny area and also in the Munster coalfields could be worked. The possibility of working these outcrops is, I suggest, well worth examination. In fact, it might prove more useful fuel than turf. To my mind, turf is going to prove expensive. When dealing with the question of coal, Deputy Morrissey expressed his anxiety as to our inability to provide transport for turf during this slack period. We are approaching the busy period. Before long we shall have the harvest with us. After it, we shall require all the transport available for the removal of grain, and later for the beet campaign. I can understand the order that has been made prohibiting the moving of turf from the turf areas to the non-turf counties. If that were to be permitted without restriction, the transportation required would eat up enormous quantities of fuel, and naturally that would add to our transport difficulties.
In peace time we imported coal. As all our large centres of population are on the coast, one might say that no transport was required for it. The coal was landed from the boats in the different cities and towns. With the limited amount of petrol that is available, it would not be possible at the present time to permit of the transport of turf from the turf areas to the non-turf counties. Before any of that turf is released under licence, it will be necessary to find out what quantity of coal we are likely to get during the coming year, or if there is any hope of making a deal with the British in the matter of securing coal supplies. In a letter to the newspapers recently, the manager of Messrs. Sutton's, a big coal-importing firm in Cork, stated that in the last two or three weeks he had been over at the other side trying to secure coal supplies for Cork. He suggested that a deputation of coal importers, accompanied by one of our Ministers, should go to England and see what could be done in the way of getting supplies of coal released.
Before he wrote that letter he naturally must have satisfied himself, from what he had seen in the South Wales coal area, that the coal is there and that it is only a question of getting it released. I think his suggestion is worthy of consideration and that the Government should do something about it. I do not think the Government can decide what quantity of turf can be released, or will be necessary in Dublin and other big centres of population during the coming winter, until they know the quantity of coal that we are likely to be able to import. If that quantity is likely to be sufficient to meet the needs of Dublin City then there may be no necessity to bring turf to Dublin, and in that way we may be able to save a good deal of fuel on transport. We need to be very careful, because only very limited supplies of petrol and fuel oil are available. There will be big demands on both after the harvest when the grain has to be shifted off farms into the stores and when, later, the beet has to be removed from the fields to the factory.
We read the announcement in the newspapers yesterday that passenger train services on the Great Southern system are being curtailed in order to conserve coal supplies. I do not approve of the way in which the curtailment is being made. Some train services are being retained that might possibly be knocked off, while some have been knocked off that I think should be kept on. In the case of districts 60 or 70 miles from Dublin, the evening train will now leave an hour or an hour and a half earlier than heretofore. That appears to me to be unreasonable. If a person travels that distance to do business in the city he likes to have a full day to enable him to do his business. For such people there should be an early and a late train. For people who come to Dublin on business an early and a late train service ought to be maintained. I would also suggest to the Minister that railway and bus services ought to be "staggered". It is ricidulous to see a train and a bus service running simultaneously. That still happens. If the train service is curtailed, then I suggest that train and bus services, as far as possible, be "staggered". If there is an early train service to a district, there ought to be a midday bus service. Generally speaking, such a service ought to be provided as will ensure that people who come to Dublin in the early morning will be able to get home that night.
In conclusion, I again desire to stress the importance of getting supplies of artificial manure for next year and of getting them as early as possible. We shall soon be approaching the winter sowing period. We have the material for superphosphates, and that more than anything else is necessary. The Minister ought to get a move on about this matter now.
Comment on this
There are just a few small points that I want to refer to. The Minister still retains on the Estimate a sum of money for expenses in connection with the Prices Commission. There is a note which says that its functions generally are under the control of the Minister for Supplies. In that connection a question was asked here about a fortnight ago with regard to the prices of boots and woollens. The statement made was that the prices were under supervision all the time, and that recent supervision had led to a lowering of prices. The effect of the statement made was that, generally speaking in regard to boots and woollen clothes, prices were lower in the last 12 months than previously—not that they had been brought back to the pre-war figure. Deputy Dillon raised this matter referring to boot prices. He gave a series of boot prices and of "numbers" of boots which have a certain significance in the trade and which definitely showed an increase. I have before me a list of materials as supplied to the tailors of this city, and I wonder how it is possible to reconcile the prices I have here with the statement made that prices on the whole are lower than what they had been. I take a particular type of cloth manufactured by Messrs. Clayton of Navan; the trade number is 221. The price per yard in September, 1939, was 12/9. In 1940 it had risen to 14/3, and by August of that year it was 17/6. It had risen during the year 1940 from 14/3 to 17/6. There is another cloth, trade number 215, manufactured by Messrs. Morrogh Brothers, Cork, and the movement of it is: September, 1939, 13/3, rising to 15/9 in March, 1940, and in June of this year, 1941, to 17/9. It has gone up as between September, 1939, and June of this year from 13/3 to 17/9 per yard.
Comment on this
There is said to be no increase in the price of the cloth, which is what I am at at the moment. Messrs. Morrogh Brothers, Cork, manufacture, a fancy worsted, trade No. 527, which stood at 14/- a yard in April, 1940, and by January, 1941, had gone up half a crown. Another material, black Vicuna, trade No. 1139, manufactured also by Messrs. Morrogh Brothers, has moved, as between January, 1940, and January, 1941, from 11/6 per yard to 15/4 per yard. A certain type of worsted manufactured by Messrs. Mahony of Cork moved from 13/6 per yard up to 16/-. The only case I can find of a reduction is the case of a certain Cork firm who were apparently brought before the Prices Commission, not for having increased the price of their cloths at all, but for having increased them too much. A certain type of blue serge which used to be sold at 7/8 rose by degrees to 8/3, to 10/6, to 11/3, to 11/10, to 12/2, and finally reached 13/-.
At that point the people were brought before the Prices Commission, and the price was compulsorily reduced from 13/- to 11/3, but the original price was 7/8. I am giving these facts, because it is not possible to put the details of these in Parliamentary question and hope to get an answer that will deal with the details. I gave these prices as they have been given to me by the merchant tailors of the city here. They were brought to me because there was a statement made by the Minister for Supplies in the House that in regard to cloths—he also mentioned with regard to boots—there had been a lowering of prices on the whole this year, and although he did take away from the statement that there was anything like an approach to pre-war prices, the impression left on the public mind was that, if tailors were charging more for suits, they could not relate any great part of the increase to an increased price they were paying for the raw materials. I give these particulars to the Minister, and I ask him to have them examined and to see whether they are true. I can give him the details in the greatest particularity —prices of cloths, types of cloths, and range. I have given him the run of the prices as I have them here, and I certainly say that they must make anybody very suspicious with regard to the statement made as to prices.
There is one other matter, a somewhat delicate matter, which impinges somewhat upon people who are not supposed to be discussed here. They are not being discussed, I think, in any of the capacities in which discussion is precluded. The Minister carries in his Vote here moneys that are to be expended under the provisions of the Minerals Exploration and Development Company Act. A case has been brought under my notice where a person got a licence under that Act, and in the course of the prospecting under the licence he trespassed upon another person's land. Of course, that having been brought to his notice—whether it was in the original licence or not I do not know—the situation was rectified so as to give him a right-of-way over the second person's land; but in the course of operating his right-of-way he used to leave gates open, and cattle began to wander around the land. Eventually, things came to a head when certain damage was done to the property. Application was made to the licensee, who holds the licence from the Government for exploration, to see if he would remedy this. He proposes now to get this man's land, the land over which he had only a right-of-way. He proposes to get a further licence to exploit that land. That might be tolerable enough in an ordinary citizen, but when the person is a judge of the Circuit Court, I think it is something that amounts to a scandal. I suggest to the Minister that if we have a Constitution which states that judges on appointment are to receive no other emoluments than those peculiar to their office, and may not hold any other office or position that brings them in any money, it is somewhat in breach of the spirit of that if under this Act his Department gives a licence to a person who is a judge, which enables that judge to get a right-of-way over another person's land, and eventually to try to seize that person's land, simply because a request is made to deal with the land in a proper way.
If it is suggested that the phrase that is in the Constitution does not cover a person getting a licence to work for minerals over another person's land, then, of course, we are opening a door very wide. If that principle be allowed to go, one of these days we may have a Circuit Court judge running a draper's shop in some town in his own circuit or, maybe, running a public house in his own circuit. I suggest that that latter would certainly be regarded as a highly undesirable development. I do not see how you can stop that if you are going to allow people in that capacity to come in before the Minister's Department or before a committee, under this Act, and get a licence to prospect over other people's property—naturally for the good of the particular gentleman who has got the licence. I think there is not more than one judge who has a licence of this type, but I think the Minister should bring this licence to an end as speedily as possible. I do not think the country would like to contemplate the position that people in that walk of life would be allowed to get licences and to operate in the way this man is doing, or to operate at all. I would ask the Minister to have the matter looked into.
Comment on this
I was listening to the Minister with interest trying to convey to the House what is being done for the unemployed and their dependents. He stressed the fact that the supplementary assistance that was to be given to unemployed men's dependents was to start in a few weeks' time, notwithstanding the fact that it was announced that they were to be paid as from the 19th June. It would be interesting to hear from the Minister what justification there is for not giving an increase in the allowance paid to unemployed men, while agreeing to give something to the unemployed men's dependents. It would be interesting to know from the Minister what is the Government's point of view and why it is that single persons who are in receipt of unemployment assistance at the moment are not to get any increase whatever under these supplementary increases. The one thing about the unemployed and the treatment of the unemployed is that they have lost their place in the family relations, so to speak. We have been told that everything that is done by the Government is being done from the viewpoint of the family. The important thing to remember in these scales of benefits is that it appears to be the settled policy of the Government in dealing with the unemployment problem to punish a man because he is committing the crime of being unemployed for a longer period than his fellow man, and if he continues to commit that crime of being unemployed the punishment is increased and is continually increased. A man who becomes unemployed will receive 35/-unemployment insurance if he has five children. At the end of six months he is cut off that insurance and put on to unemployment assistance. He will get a lesser sum under unemployment assistance than he got under the unemployment insurance. That means that the man who is the victim of unemployment is punished for being so long unemployed.
I should like to hear from the Minister on what grounds that scheme of things is arrived at. Surely a man who is unemployed has no control whatever over the means by which he might get employment. Is it not brutal, therefore, to punish him because he is unemployed over a long period? Can anyone tell me that he has any means of increasing his opportunities of employment? Should he then be punished because he has no control over those things?
On the question of the unemployed in the rural areas, it is a rather sad thing to find that a man in the rural areas is getting only 14/- a week for himself and his wife and five or more children, and the Minister decides that that amount is not to be increased. He said this evening that those supplementary payments will be made by Order rather than by any means which would give us an opportunity of discussing the figures. I should like to know how much longer we are going to treat in that way those decent, sober and industrious men who are anxious to work to maintain their families? How long more do we expect them to remain cheerful and quiet, when they see abundance all about them and are kept from enjoying that abundance? I want to say to the Minister that the position is a very serious one. It is well that the Minister should realise that there is a good deal of resentment and despair concerning the whole economic system under which we live. We heard the Minister making a long statement about the danger of embarking on schemes which would not be productive; in other words if those things cannot be done at a profit there is going to be no employment. I would remind the Minister that the wealth of a nation does not consist of the gold in our banks or the entries on the bankers' ledgers. It consists of the capacity of the people of the nation to produce goods, their capacity to consume goods, and their capacity to exchange their surplus goods for materials from other countries. I would say to the Minister and to anybody else who is thinking like him that if all the bank notes and gold were sunk to the bottom of the sea, this country would still go on, and perhaps go on better than it is going on at the present time. If all our money were done away with, production and distribution would still go on. If the farming community and the workers as a whole stood idle, those who control our wealth and currency and credit would disappear for ever. As I have said, production and distribution would go on without money, but without the workers the money would be useless.
The Minister has talked to us here to-night as if we were a lot of boys in school, telling us what were the principles of economics. He may talk to me as long as he likes about the principles of economics, but to me they crumble into dust before the abundance of goods which are kept from the people owing to what are known as economic laws. I want to say to the Minister and to the Government that there is going to be in this country a very strong revolt against this economic system. I should like to hear the Minister deal with this problem of unemployment from an entirely different angle to that from which he has approached it this evening. Speaking, I think, on a Money Resolution three or four weeks ago, he told us that there would be no yarn spun, that there would not be an ounce of food produced, nor, I think he mentioned, a ton of turf produced, unless the people were going to get a profit out of it. If that is so, there will be no production unless there is a profit. I often wonder why it is that the air we breathe and the sun we enjoy cannot be controlled. Then of course there would be no air to breathe and no sun to enjoy unless those who controlled it made a profit. I want to express my regret and disappointment at the way in which the Minister has dealt with the unemployment problem, and with the whole economic position of the country.
He mentioned the question of our harbour authorities and their financial condition. I was one of a delegation which approached the Minister some time ago looking for assistance for the harbour authorities in Cork. We pointed out that the position in regard to Cork harbour was rather difficult owing to the fact that we had no shipping. We came to the Minister and to the Government asking for a loan of £50,000 to help us to carry on some very important and necessary work, such as the building of quays and jetties to meet the situation which will arise when the war is over. After a period of three months we got a reply from the Minister stating that he was unable to give us that financial assistance, and stating that he was not able to do so because other boards might look for similar treatment. We returned, and consulted the banking institutions in Cork, but we were informed that they could not see their way to grant us the sum of money we required unless we got Government securities. We had a long lecture from the Minister to-day about the danger of embarking on certain schemes. Here we have necessary national work to do in preparation for the future. We have the materials to do it, and have men standing idle and ready to do it; the only obstacle is this thing called money. We cannot do this necessary and important work because we have not the money to do it. Yet, the Minister says that we must put the people at work which will give us a return. I agree that we do not want to put men to work on schemes which will be useless and futile, but when necessary and useful work is ready to our hand it should be carried out. I want to suggest to the Minister that the social and economic problems which are with us to-day are due to the fact that we are thinking as we are, and to the fact that we are voting as we are. I believe that this financial system is dying slowly and surely, and the sooner it dies and gives way to a more equitable system the sooner will the people not alone of this country but of other countries achieve the justice and peace of which the world is so much in need. The present financial system has got to change, because money cannot remain the dominating factor over the lives of our people. We have been told that employment would have to be provided on the basis of production. I agree, but there is no use in producing if we have not also the means of distribution. I want to tell the Minister that if he intends to deal with the unemployment problem in this country he will have to forget some of the old and outworn ideas that he has about the question of controlling credit.
Comment on this
In the course of the Minister's speech introducing this Estimate, I understood him to say that the total production of anthracite coal in this country last year—I think it was last year he referred to—was 100,000 tons.
Comment on this
Well, that is a rather interesting figure. I am speaking from recollection, but I think I am accurate when I say that the last figures we had showed that the imports of anthracite coal were 92,000 tons. Now, anthracite coal has become of increasing importance in this country, and I should be glad if the Minister could tell us, when he is replying on this Estimate, why it is that even in this year, the second year of the war, our production of anthracite coal, which is so badly needed, is limited to 100,000 tons. I understand, from figures that were given by the Minister himself in this House recently, that it is estimated that in one coal mine in this country alone there are between 4,000,000 and 5,000,000 tons of anthracite. I refer to Castlecomer. That is a mine that is working, and if there are 4,000,000 or 5,000,000 tons of anthracite coal in that mine, why is our output limited to 100,000 tons from all the mines in the country?
It is a well-known fact that the anthracite coal produced in Castlecomer is at least equal to the best anthracite imported from abroad. It is further a well-known fact that at periods of the year, often fairly long periods, there is practically no output whatever from Castlecomer. What the reasons are I do not know, but I do suggest that steps should have been taken, either by the present management themselves or, if necessary, with assistance from the State, to produce from that stock of 4,000,000 or 5,000,000 tons of anthracite, a tonnage, certainly far in excess of that mentioned by the Minister. The Minister also referred to the company that has been formed for the development of the mines at Slievardagh. I should like him, when he is replying, to be a little more definite on that matter and tell us whether he is in a position to intimate to the House when work is likely to start at Slievardagh, whether he has any information which would enable him to indicate to us that there is a prospect of coal being produced by this coal mining company during this year or, if not during this year, whether there is a prospect of its being done early next year.
The Minister's speech was, to say the least of it, a doleful one. He was not optimistic. He was not even hopeful. He was least hopeful of all when he was dealing with the employment position, and he rather suggested that he resented people in this House suggesting that the solution of the unemployment problem was easy to find. I do not know that any member of the House—certainly any member on this side of the House—ever suggested that the solution of the unemployment problem was an easy one. Any time that was ever suggested, it came from people on the far side of the House. We are, however, in what is to me, at any rate, an extraordinary situation. We have heard, for a long number of years, that we could feed half the world. We are, this year and, so far as one can see, next year, in danger of not being able to feed ourselves. That is understandable and can be appreciated by anybody who realises the difficulties of importing raw materials and of getting into this country the things which we are not in a position to produce ourselves, but it is not so readily understandable why we cannot produce in sufficient quantities the things which can be produced in our own country. The materials are there, the ground is there, and the men are there. Still, we are not able to produce enough. It is doubtful, to say the least of it, if we will have enough food produced in this country this year for human consumption. It is extremely doubtful if there will be enough food produced in this country for animal consumption, and I think it is beyond any shadow of a doubt that we will be unable to produce enough fuel.
We are told, in respect of most of the commodities to which I have referred, that the shortage is due largely to the fact that the men are not available for the work. I want to return to a matter that I have raised more than once in this House, and I raise it now because I think the Department of Industry and Commerce is primarily responsible. We have at the moment somewhere in the neighbourhood of 50,000 unemployed. Let us say that we have 40,000 men unemployed even at the present moment. Side by side with that we have county surveyors looking for men to produce more turf, and they say they cannot get them. We have farmers looking for men to save hay, and they say they cannot get them, and we know that within the next four or five weeks farmers all over the country will be looking for men to save the harvest, and they probably shall have the same story to tell then. Now, on the face of it, there must be something radically wrong, and it is inconceivable to me that if this Government were facing up to its responsibilities, active men, married men—many of them living in the urban areas and cities of this country—should be compelled to try to eke out an existence not only for themselves but for their wives and families on a maximum of 14/- a week when they could be earning at least 30/- a week and at the same time contributing their very valuable quota to the work that is so necessary if we are to produce anything approaching our requirements.
I know that I shall be told that there are difficulties. Of course there are difficulties, and I know quite well—as well as the Minister or anybody else can tell me—that it is not possible to get all of the 40,000 men and shove them either on to a bog or on to a farm. I know that. But I assert, from my knowledge of those men who are even to-day lining up at the labour exchanges in the cities and urban areas of this country—and other Deputies could assert the same from their knowledge—that a very big proportion, if not a big majority, of these 40,000 could be usefully employed, certainly for the next two or three months, with advantage both to themselves and to the nation.
This problem is not as difficult as it may appear on the surface, nor is it as difficult as the Minister may wish to make it appear, because there is a complete register available of every unemployed man and of every man who was unemployed for the last few years. There is a card index to show every man's name, whether he is married or single, what his occupation was, and the number of his dependents, etc., fully classified for the whole of the country. Yet with that available there are many men to-day who are trying to support themselves and three, four, five, six or seven children on 14/- per week, who could be earning and should be earning, both for their own sake and for the sake of the nation, at least 30/- per week.
The Minister seemed to get a good deal of consolation from the fact that there are about 3,000 fewer unemployed in the urban areas than there were at this time last year. The Minister can find very little consolation in that fact. I do not know the exact number who were unemployed in the urban and city areas and who are now working temporarily in the bogs, but I can safely assert that it would be far in excess of 3,000.
One striking aspect of the Minister's speech dealing with the question of employment and unemployment was that there seems to be no plan, no scheme, no approach even to a scheme for providing not only for the present situation, but for the appalling situation we shall find ourselves in at the end of the emergency. At the end of the emergency, even according to the Minister himself to-day, we shall find ourselves with a very big proportion unemployed of those who are to-day in very useful employment. We shall find ourselves with about 40,000 men who are now in the Army, and who will not be required in the Army at that period. Very probably we shall find ourselves with thousands of men—I will not put it any higher than thousands—at the end of the war period returning here from war work upon which they were engaged in Great Britain or from the British Army. If the Government are unable to face up to the problem as it presents itself at the moment, what hope can we have that they will be able to face up to what the problem is likely to be at the end of the emergency? I suppose we should not be very terribly surprised at the picture I have painted. I suppose it is unreasonable to expect that a Government that was unable to make any contribution whatever to this problem during normal times could possibly contribute anything to it in the abnormal circumstances under which we live to-day. It would not be unfair to say that the Minister's contribution to-day to this question of employment, production, and unemployment was a confession of absolute failure and, I might say, a gospel of despair.
I do not want to be continually raising this matter, but it is a very important matter. I think any Deputy will admit that if, on the one hand, you have, as we have, plenty of work available in the country, and if, on the other hand, you have men willing to work and able to work lining up at the labour exchanges, and you do not succeed in bringing those two together, there is something radically wrong. I would ask farmer Deputies, who know more about this business than I do, to ask themselves how easy it would be to lose a crop, particularly a crop of wheat, if you had broken weather during the harvest, and you had to cut the wheat and to try to save it, and found yourself unable to get the necessary labour. Farmer Deputies know that you could lose a whole crop of wheat in 24 hours. That is a risk that we cannot afford to take. I say that, if the Minister was doing his job, no farmer should be in a position to say that he wanted a man and could not get him as long as there is an unemployed man in this country willing and able to work.
The Minister made a lot of other points that one could deal with, and probably would deal with in a normal year. I do not want to go into them now. I just want to make the point about the position, as I see it, as clearly and as briefly as I can. It is a very important point; it is a matter that brooks of no delay. We have a tremendous amount to produce and to save, and we have only a very short time in which to do it. If the maximum production is to be got—and I think it is admitted on all sides that even our maximum this year will not be sufficient—and if it is to be saved in the way it ought to be, we certainly would not have anything like 40,000 men lining up at the labour exchanges.
Comment on this
So long as there are 10,000 people getting relief from the Dublin Board of Assistance I must continue to protest against the Government's inadequate effort to deal with unemployment in this city. About £5,000 a week is being paid to these 10,000 people by the Dublin ratepayers, and even at that the allowances are totally inadequate. All these people are desirous of getting work. That shows that the Government have not awakened to their responsibility to the unemployed in this city. Other Deputies have spoken about country districts, and mentioned the scarcity of labour on farms. I stated last week that I had read in an evening paper that 2,000 men, who were anxiously waiting for work, had left Mayo for the potato fields of Scotland. It was pointed out in the report that they were men with practical experience of turf cutting, yet we have the position that there is a scarcity of fuel not only in Dublin, but all over the country. Reference has been made by some Deputies to mineral development, and one might ask whether the Government were utilising to the full the brains of experts here who could help them in that respect if they got some encouragement. It has been announced in the newspapers that the train service is to be reduced, but that the Drumm train will continue to work. I wonder if the services of Dr. Drumm and others are being used to the full extent to develop our resources. There is a scarcity of petrol at present, and there has been talk during the week that supplies of oils will be short for threshing purposes. Is it not a fact that Dr. Drumm and others are at present engaged on investigations—and I believe with success—in an effort to find a substitute for petrol? If the Government would pay serious attention to development of that kind, and to the advice of those engaged on it, we might look forward with a little more confidence to having the necessary oils of which farmers complain there is now a shortage. I avail of this opportunity to protest against the Government's failure to allow certain parish councils to get licences to bring turf into the city. This matter was raised before.
Comment on this
I do not intend to touch on it further, except to say that it is one to which the Minister should pay attention. At a time when some of our people have fireless grates, and empty teapots, and the cost of living increasing, I see no effort being made to remedy the position. There is growing discontent, especially in the city, because this House is not paying sufficient attention to the situation, or is not finding remedies to ease the hardships which the poor are bearing. I express the hope that the Government may be able to find employment for those who have lost their work owing to the present emergency. Many people are getting only an odd day's work recently, as well known Dublin factories which always gave good employment have had to go on short-time. I earnestly appeal to the Minister to try to have that state of affairs remedied, so that these people may be able to resume full-time employment, to keep their families and be in a position to meet the rapidly increasing cost of living.
Comment on this
The unexpected overnight change in the Parliamentary programme prevented me, unfortunately, from having an opportunity of hearing the Minister's statement but I heard from my colleagues that it was a very depressing one, and that no indication whatever was given by the Minister that he had any plan for finding work for the registered unemployed, or for the greater problem, of which he must be aware, of finding suitable relief schemes to provide employment during the coming winter. The registered number of unemployed is, in my opinion, abnormally low at present, because very large numbers of our young people have joined our national Defence Forces, and also, according to the information at my disposal, an extremely large number have joined the British Army and Navy, and in addition, the Minister knows better than any Deputy, that large numbers have gone to England, particularly during the last three months, to find work there that they were unable to get at home. I do not know what the position would be, or what the number of unemployed persons on the register would be, if such large numbers of men were not required for the defence forces here during the emergency, or if those who are now in the British Army and Navy, or working in England had remained at home. The Minister ought to have some idea of the problem that will confront himself and his colleagues when the emergency ceases.
I wonder if he could venture to give any figures as to the numbers that would be thrown on the unemployment register if our young citizens were demobilised from our defence forces, as well as the others who joined the British Army and Navy or who went away within the past few months to England. I believe the Minister must have machinery at his disposal that would enable him to give some idea of the problem that he will be facing at the end of the present world war, as far as providing for the unemployed is concerned. Every Party in this House is willing and anxious to assist the Minister and the Government in facing up to this problem, but the lead must be given by the Minister, because he has the authority of the people, and the machinery of the State at his disposal to solve it.
As far as I am aware the Minister seems to think that the problem will have to be solved under the existing system. We had repeated assurances from the head of the Government, particularly in 1932, that if he could not solve unemployment under the existing system, then he would go outside that system for the purpose of doing so. I daresay the opinion then expressed by the head of the Government was shared by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, who was at that time in charge of the Department of Finance. Nobody can suggest proposals of a practical nature unless there is some indication from the Government, and particularly from the Minister for Finance, as to what the financial policy of the Government is, or is likely to be, arising out of the reports submitted by the Banking Commission. The solution of unemployment and every other problem associated with it depends on the adoption of a progressive financial policy by the Government. I was amazed yesterday, in answer to a question put to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, dealing with a proposal passed by the majority of the House on December 12th last, to set up a commission to advise the Government regarding the provision of suitable work for unemployed people, although seven months have passed, to hear the Minister stating that the terms of reference and the members of the commission have not yet been finally dealt with. If it takes seven months for the Minister to make up his mind about the terms of reference of such a commission, which the Government decided to set up, then it is hopeless to think that before the next general election the same Ministry will produce a solution of this terrible problem.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in his wisdom, and acting, I presume, on the advice of his official advisers and with the consent of the Government, several months ago called into conference the representatives of the Irish Trade Union Congress and the several organisations representing the employers of this country and suggested that, during the period of the emergency, the different employers should adopt a system of rotational employment for those who were still left working in the several industries. I should like to hear what progress has been made in that direction, and I should like the Minister to indicate the industries which he thinks, without interfering with the efficiency of their organisations, could adopt that policy and whether that policy was intended by the Minister to be adopted by employers and applied to those in permanent employment. The Minister might also tell us what leaders of industries have expressed their willingness to adopt the suggestion and what industries, if any, have so far put the scheme into operation. I do not know whether it was intended that the proposal should apply to workers under local authorities. I should like to know how far the proposal is to be put into operation, or whether it is, generally speaking, acceptable to the employer.
The number of unemployed is bound to increase as the months go by, for reasons which it is not necessary for me to explain, and I should like to hear from the Minister what plans he has in mind, what plans he has prepared or are in course of preparation for providing work during the winter months, for unemployed people, for the large number of people working on the bogs to-day, many of whom, for understandable reasons, may be unable to work at turf production, bog drainage, or bog road repairs during the winter months. We had a statement last week from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance on the turf situation, in the course of which he indicated that 30,000 people were at present employed on turf production. That number is almost certain to be considerably reduced during the winter months, and I should like to know if the Minister has any scheme in mind for the absorption of those on the register at the moment, and the additional numbers who will go on the register, into useful employment during those months. I know of schemes sanctioned some time ago— waterworks, sewerage schemes, and housing schemes—which are held up, either because the necessary money is not available, or because there is a shortage of the necessary material. Is there any hope that in a number of towns where it was intended to carry out improvements of the existing water supplies, such schemes will be put into operation during the winter months?
I have been very much interested for a long period, and I am sure every Deputy is equally interested, in the policy of the Minister or his colleagues in connection with the reports of the Transport Tribunal. I think it is six weeks since the attention of the Minister for Finance was drawn to the failure of the Government to publish and circulate to Deputies the reports of several commissions and tribunals, and, on that occasion, the Minister promised, without any qualification, that the reports referred to—the principal reports outstanding were those of the Transport Tribunal, the Drainage Commission, and the Dublin Bakery Inquiry—would be circulated in the near future. The Drainage Commission report has since been circulated, as has also the report of the Dublin Bakery Inquiry, but I cannot understand, although I am sure the Minister does, why the report of the Transport Tribunal has not been circulated as promised. I raise this question because the Minister's predecessor, when asking the House for the power to set up that tribunal, said that the matters to be referred to it were so urgent that he expected the report to be in his possession within two months. He also indicated in the same speech that it was the intention of the Government to bring in legislation to amend the Transport and Railways Act, 1933. Not alone has the amending legislation not been brought before the House, but the members of the House, irrespective of Party, have not been taken into the Minister's confidence and have not been given the contents of the tribunal's report.
Apart altogether from the policy issues involved in the necessary reorganisation of the transport industry, I think it is the duty of the Minister to see that Deputies are furnished with copies of such reports within a reasonable time. If it is the intention of the Minister and his colleagues to modernise our transport system, I think that, by doing so, whether the reorganised system is under public ownership or semi-State control, a considerable amount of employment can be given, and particularly on the railway side. I am sure the Minister will not challenge the accuracy of my statement that the rolling stock of the railways to-day is not sufficient to meet the requirements of any modern transport concern. There is plenty of work to be done in increasing the rolling stock which should be available to any modern transport concern in any part of the world. The permanent way of the railway must be known to those who travel, even on the main lines, not to be in first-class condition, and considerable employment could be provided there for some of those who are on the list of registered unemployed. I do not know whether the Minister has at any time given any consideration to the question of the electrification of our main railway lines, but if such a scheme were decided on, it would certainly give considerable employment for a very long period to a large number of our able-bodied citizens now on the list of registered unemployed.
I would like him to indicate whether he is satisfied, from the reports in his possession, that the mileage of our principal railways is in a safe condition, and that the necessary number of wagons and railway vehicles is at the disposal of the principal transport concerns, or that, generally speaking, the community is getting a satisfactory transport service, whether it be by rail, road or canal. I asked him these questions before and he did not answer. There is too much transport in this country for the quantity of traffic to be carried. I often hear people talk about the cheaper services that are given by road transport as against rail or canal transport, but I have yet to find the trader who has got the benefit of that cheaper system, and who has allowed the difference in the prices charged to consumers. Citizens of the State, and the community as a whole, have never, in my recollection, received the benefit of any cheap system of transport by way of reduced prices. I have discussed that with traders in my own constituency and asked them why that was so, when we were getting cheap rates by road, in some cases by railway companies not complying with the law.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be able to develop that point later on and I hope that he will do it. I asked them why those who got cheaper rates for tea, sugar and flour by road transport were not giving the benefit of those reduced rates to purchasers of those commodities in the shops. There was no explanation. They simply pocketed what they got by the cheaper system, instead of passing it on to the community. Therefore I think there is no reason in this argument that the cheaper system of transport is always the best. I raise this question for the purpose of finding out whether the Government have any policy in mind on the transport question, after all the time that has been given to considering it and to making up their minds.
The Transport Tribunal Report has been in the hands of the Minister for Industry and Commerce —both the present Minister and his predecessor, for nearly two years. The Banking Commission Report has been in the hands of the Ministers concerned for four and a half years, and they have not made up their minds on this question. I do not know whether it is possible for them to make up their minds on any question arising out of any report of any commission set up since this Government came into office. If they are unable to make up their minds on these matters when a Commission or a tribunal reports, let us save the taxpayers' money by refusing to set up any commissions in future. If they are set up, Deputies are entitled to the benefit of whatever information is contained in their reports and recommendations.
One other aspect of the transport problem, and one which I hope the Minister will deal with in his reply, is one which has been referred to on more than one occasion by Deputy Morrissey, and rightly so. Where transport companies have been brought into consultation with the Minister and his advisers, in connection with the transport of turf from the bogs in different counties to the cities and towns, where it will be required in the coming winter, I want to know if any scheme has been presented by the railway, canal or road transport companies which will indicate the extent to which that very serious problem can be dealt with in a satisfactory way. What percentage of the turf in the bogs will be carried by rail, canal or road? I hope the Minister will make some attempt to give us some information on that point in his reply.
Comment on this
It was referred to, but the Minister for Industry and Commerce is the responsible Minister to deal with the question of transport— both policy and administration. I am not aware that the Minister for Supplies has any responsibility whatever in connection with the distribution of turf from the bogs. He has no right to make direct representations to the railway companies on the matter unless some new transfer of functions has been made recently under the powers, presumably, of the Emergency Powers Act, but I am not aware of that. I am aware that some few orders were slipped into the Library in a very quiet way, but I am not aware of any order having been issued to relieve the Minister for Industry and Commerce of his responsibility in connection with this very serious matter.
To me it is an almost impossible problem, but in any case if there is no consultation between the responsible Minister and the representatives of the companies who will be responsible for doing this job—and doing it particularly at a time of the year when railway wagons, canal boats and motor lorries are available—I do not know that there can be any hope of getting the job done later on in the year, when all these transport services will be required for doing other and perhaps equally necessary work. Under this Vote I suppose it is not possible to deal with the question of the price of turf. I do not want to go back on any discussion concerning the production, marketing and price of turf that might have been more rightly raised under other Votes. However, the Minister should have some interest in the matter.
I think it desirable, at any rate, that he should give us some detailed information regarding any plans he may have in his locker for the solution of the great problem of unemployment, which will be worsening as the months go by. I sympathise with any Minister who has to face up to the preparation of a plan for this particular purpose. The Minister can be assured that any assistance possible will be given to him and to the Government in helping them to solve—if at all possible—this terrible problem, and to reduce the poverty and destitution that seem to be facing the community during the coming winter months.
Comment on this
I think it rather strange to hear Deputy Davin looking for the Transport Tribunal report and asking the Government to have their minds made up on any transport position up to the moment, when he knows that the question is whether we will be able to get any transport at all or not. This is not a time to decide on policies of transport for the future.
There is, however, one particular matter on which I am anxious to have the Minister's decision. We know there is a great deal of unemployment, and that there will be a greater volume of unemployment according as raw materials for certain industries disappear. I would not agree with Deputy Morrissey that these people will get employment on the land, even in the harvest time. What rural labour is there will be required for that purpose, and nobody else. From time to time in this House I have seen the Minister take up other essentials as Government problems, make them into Government works, and work them as Government industries; and I would like to know definitely whether it is the Minister's intention to deal in that way with the iron and steel industry. There are over 300 people in the town of Cóbh drawing unemployment assistance at the present time. There is no use in telling those people to go out on the land, where there is any amount of work. They would not be worth feeding on the land; they are men who are accustomed to ship building, ship repairing, iron and steel work, and who were reared at that, trained to it, and have become skilled at it. Still, we have the extraordinary position of industry after industry closing down for want of merchant iron and steel. One after another they are closing down, and, at the same time, we have had a whole factory lying idle for five months.
Comment on this
This pertains particularly to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. As far as Haulbowline is concerned, the premises are merely situated in Haulbowline. It has no more to do with it than that.
Comment on this
It does not matter where an industry is situate. Deputy Corry is speaking of the industry, as such, which is the responsibility of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The location of the industry does not count, and Deputy Corry could not raise this question on the Vote for the Board of Works, where Haulbowline came in.
Comment on this
The Chair is interested to ensure that Haulbowline, simpliciter, will not be again discussed.
Comment on this
I am discussing the industry known as "Irish steel" and I think I am entitled to do so on this Vote. For the past five months, this factory has been idle. No effort has been made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to get the industry working. I am a member of the agricultural community. I have seen the Minister for Agriculture, where a member of our fraternity failed to do his part, take over the land and have it ploughed and sown. Here, we have this eyesore which, in the end, will mean the disemployment of thousands of men all over the country and absolutely nothing is being done about it. I shall not deal with the scandalous manner in which this matter was left to be carried on by the Department of Industry and Commerce for the past six or eight months. When I raised a question here about seven months ago about the export of scrap iron, which is the raw material of this industry, I was informed by the Minister for Supplies that the export of scrap iron was prohibited. When I said "except under licence," I was told that no licences were granted. I produced in this House a fortnight ago a copy of the report of the Dublin Port and Docks Board which shows that 17,800 tons of scrap iron left the Port of Dublin last year and, lo and behold, in yesterday's Press I read a notification from the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the export of scrap iron and steel was now prohibited except under licence—what we were told was prohibited 18 months ago. That is bordering on the ridiculous. Our farmers will find themselves, when they want to start their ploughing operations, without a ploughshare or a steel bar for their ploughs while all the time this industry is lying idle. There were about 350 people employed there for a period——
Comment on this
Does the Deputy assure the House that he has not raised that precise matter on the Vote for the Office of the Minister for Supplies?
Comment on this
I raised it on the Vote for Supplies and I submit I am entitled to raise it on this Vote.
Comment on this
It is for the Deputy to show that he is not raising the same issue on two Estimates——
Comment on this
The Deputy may not raise a point of order when the Chair is addressing the House. A matter cannot be raised in the same connection and in virtually the same words on two Estimates. One or other Minister is responsible, not both.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I was listening to Deputy Corry and Deputy Hurley when they raised a certain aspect of this matter on the Vote for Supplies——
Comment on this
I shall have the report of the debate in a few minutes, and I shall be much surprised if there is a 10 per cent. difference between Deputy Corry's speech on that occasion and his speech on this Vote.
Comment on this
Is it not in order to raise a question as to the disappearance of an industry, and the disemployment of large numbers of persons, on the Vote for Industry and Commerce?
Comment on this
This is the first occasion on which I could put the matter here before the Minister who has primary responsibility—the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I had to raise it on the other Votes so as to call attention to it on account of its urgency. This is the first occasion on which I have brought the matter before the Minister who has primary responsibility. I submit that it is my duty, as representing that constituency, to raise the matter here. I do not want to go into it fully. I want to draw the Minister's attention to the position and get a definite statement from him as to his intentions. I think that the House is entitled to that. We are entitled to be told, definitely, whether this industry is to be taken over as a national industry, as it should be, and worked, or whether it is to lie there idly, an eyesore to the country.
When the farming community get an order from the Minister for Agriculture to plough their lands next season, they will find themselves without the essential implements. That is my reason for raising the matter. An additional reason is that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has primary responsibility for the prohibition of the export of scrap iron, the essential raw material for this industry, and he did not prohibit its export until two days ago. If export had been prohibited when I was told by the Minister for Supplies it was prohibited, why should we be faced with an announcement in the public Press two days ago that the export of scrap iron and scrap steel had been prohibited? I do not believe that any man living can tell us how many years this war will last. We do know that, while it lasts, our imports of ordinary merchant iron and steel will be nil. If we have the materials and the factory to produce the essentials for our industries, are we to be deprived of them on account of any pernickety ideas in the Department of Industry and Commerce?
Comment on this
The supply of agricultural implements would, surely, relate to the Vote for the Department of Supplies.
Comment on this
The industry for making these supplies is in this country and, therefore, it is not a matter of supplies. It is the industry which is responsible and the Minister for Industry and Commerce is in charge of all the industries in the country. Unfortunately, the agricultural community will be made to bear the brunt of all this.
It is bad enough to have burdens thrown on our shoulders month after month and year after year, without having wilful discrimination between two classes of the community, the agriculturist and the industrialist. If a member of the agricultural community, owning land, fails to till it, that land will be taken from him and will be tilled under the instructions of the Minister for Agriculture or the county council. Here is an industry which is producing something very vital for the agricultural community, steel for the manufacture of machinery essential in food production, and no effort has been made to put it again on a working basis. If the people connected with that industry are unable or unwilling to produce these essentials, then the Minister should take the industry over for the purpose of putting it into production. That is his duty, just as much as it is the duty of the Minister for Agriculture to take over land if it is not put under cultivation.
There is too much class discrimination carried on, too much anxiety to put burdens on the only real producers, the agriculturists. The manner in which this industry was carried on for 18 months would not be tolerated by any other Department. This is an industry that was supposed to convert scrap iron into merchant iron. Instead of doing that, the scrap iron was, under licence, exported. This might be regarded as practically the most important industry in the country to-day. Soon it will be difficult to get shoes for the horses, because the iron is not being produced. Soon it may be difficult to get agricultural machinery, because of the lack of iron and steel. I know one industry in Cork City that may have to close down within the next month and 200 men will be rendered idle, all because this factory is not producing merchant iron. The same thing may soon happen in the town of Clonmel and in other places.
If it was good policy for the Government to take over the sugar industry and work it, to take over the peat industry and work it, equally it ought to be good policy to take over the steel industry and work it. Unless we do that we will have difficulty in getting the necessary implements that will enable us to provide food for the people during the emergency. If the Minister does not do that, he will be neglecting his duty to the people.
I am not worried whether the debenture holders or the original swindlers lose their money in this undertaking. I will not worry much if the get-rich-quick gentlemen go out. I am worried about the production of iron and steel to meet our requirements. The Government should have no hesitation in taking over the industry. I called attention to this matter some five months ago. I thought it necessary to draw attention to the scandal going on and that was being winked at. I was told that there was no export of scrap iron at a time when the Dublin Port and Docks Board statistics revealed the export of thousands of tons.
Comment on this
I find that one might as well be in the wilderness as endeavouring to deal with this matter here. I do not intend to repeat myself, because I am simply fed up calling attention to the conditions in this industry. I know the position can be remedied now, but later on it cannot be. I will make one last appeal to the Minister. The longer this industry is idle the longer will be the periods of unemployment, the more industries there will be closing down and there will be a bigger problem to be tackled later on. Faced with that prospect, surely there should be no hesitation in taking over the steel industry and working it as a national concern.
Comment on this
I join with Deputy Corry in his appeal to the Minister to use his influence to get going what I consider is a national asset. Like Deputy Corry, I am not concerned with the banks or the people who are connected financially with it. I am mainly concerned because the industry is a national asset. I have evidence to prove that there are many subsidiary industries that will definitely close down in the near future if they cannot get a supply of steel. The Irish steel industry has been closed down since February. The Minister should tell the House the reason for its disappearance, and what plans he has in mind to get it going again.
Deputy Corry rightly pointed out that there are certain industries which private enterprise could not undertake to run, and I think the steel industry is one of them. It is no use delaying; if the industry is to be revived as a State enterprise there should not be a day wasted in carrying out that intention. The longer the delay, the more certain it is that other industries that depend on the steel industry will go out of existence. It is the responsibility of the Minister to keep whatever industries we have going. We have the raw materials for the steel industry in this country. We have the materials for putting up the necessary open - hearth furnaces. The only stumbling-block is finance. Surely that should not stand in the way where it is a question of the existence of a very important industry.
I wish to reiterate every word Deputy Corry has said, and I can assure the House that there is no difference of opinion in Cobh or elsewhere so far as the restarting of that industry is concerned. All Parties, all creeds and classes are anxious that that industry should get a fresh start. The only solution of the matter, in my opinion, is that the Government should take it over as a State industry. That can be done, especially in this emergency, when more drastic things have to be done, when, as was pointed out to the House already, farmers who neglect their duty in the production of food have their land taken from them.
Comment on this
I think that it does not require any great argument to convince this House of the necessity of taking over this industry. There is no doubt that the harbour area—I am sure the Minister for Industry and Commerce and his officials know it from the unemployment returns—is one of the hardest hit areas in the country. There is no possibility of connecting the unemployed men in that area with turf cutting or with any of the other schemes operated as a solution, or a partial solution, for unemployment. It is only in the industry that formerly existed there, and the ancillary industry at the docks in Rushbrooke that employment can be found for the skilled and semi-skilled men who have been unemployed in that area since the 11th February of this year. I think that the Minister should tell this House the reasons for the disappearance of this industry, and of the plans, if there are any, to restart that industry under State control. I think that much at least is due to the House from him as Minister for Industry and Commerce. If he has no intention of restarting that industry, he should tell us what alternative industry he intends to operate in that area, because, as I pointed out—and I want to emphasise the fact—the bulk of the unemployed men in that area are skilled or semi-skilled men who had, as Deputy Corry stated, a training in skilled work in connection with the dockyards and steel production. These men cannot find employment in any alternative work such as turf cutting, employment by outside firms, or otherwise. Again, many other industries are dependent upon this industry for their raw materials.
Just as in the question of Irish steel, I am convinced that this Government will never solve, or even partially solve, unemployment by the methods they are adopting. At the present time, they seem to have gone back to a defeatist policy, that there can be no solution, not even a partial solution, of unemployment. They are content to let things drift, and they carry on in the hope that we shall not reach the worst climax in this country. That is not tackling the problem. We in this Party charge the Minister with a dereliction of duty as far as that is concerned. He has made no appreciable effort to deal with the question of unemployment. As Deputy Davin pointed out, the numbers who have gone over to Britain, who have gone into our own Army and the British Army, have provided a partial solution of this problem for the Minister. These outlets have been a godsend for the Minister; otherwise the employment problem would have been one of appalling proportions. That is so because the Minister and his Government are completely wedded to the old worn-out policy of the Manchester school, the old policy of laissez faire:“Let things carry on; private enterprise will provide a solution.”
That policy has been discarded years ago even by the people who were the greatest believers in it. Still we cling on to it. The attitude is that unless things can be produced at a profit and sold at a profit, then they are not worth producing—no question of the good of the community or the good of the nation. We are the only country in the world that clings to sterling. Even England itself has gone away from that system. I could never understand why the present Government, the Fianna Fáil Party, that was born in revolution and that came in here as a semi-revolutionary Party, have not the pluck to break away from the British system of sterling and its implications. We had Deputy Childers last night telling us about the danger of inflation. We have as much control over that question as the man in the moon. That question of deflation or inflation is controlled by the Bank of England, in consultation with the British Government.