Committee on Finance. - Vote 55—Industry and Commerce.
Contributions 109–215 of 215. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Are we to be allowed to discuss sterling, because if so some of us would like to have notice of it?
Comment on this
I do not want to discuss it, but I am suggesting to the House that most of the failure of the Government to solve the unemployment problem is due to the fact that they have so steadfastly clung to that financial system. I leave it at that.
Comment on this
I think that the Deputy ought to put down a motion. We should like to hear him on it.
Comment on this
There are motions on the Paper for the last nine or ten months.
Comment on this
What I want to point out is that this country is at the mercy of the British economic policy— the policy of Jewish bankers aided by the win-the-war policy of Britain. They want unemployment in this country so that they can get cheap labour for their war effort and cannon-fodder for their armies through the operation of this policy. We have not the energy, the initiative or the pluck to break with that policy. Employment means purchasing power in the hands of the workers and purchasing power means that everybody gets his share—the grocer, the baker and everybody else. We could have in that way prosperity in the country but when we have mass unemployment, such as exists at present in this country, we have poverty, misery and destitution amongst the poorer classes. Purchasing power is restricted and goods cannot be bought that would be bought in the ordinary way if people had employment. As a substitute for employment, we have unemployment assistance. Unemployment assistance is at the same figure now as it was in 1934, the year after the Act was introduced. Take the case of an unemployed man with a wife and five children, living in a rural area, who was getting 14/- a week in unemployment assistance in 1934. That amount is now reduced by 4/-, because since then the cost of living has gone up by over 30 per cent. We hear a lot of talk about the family, that it is at the root of social life in this country. The case I have quoted shows the respect we have for family life.
Some time in March the Great Southern Company, after giving very little warning to the people, raised bus fares in Cork by 50 per cent., in some cases by 75 per cent., and in others by almost 100 per cent. I put down a question to the Minister at the time, and, as I was not satisfied with his reply, I raised the matter on the adjournment. The Minister then undertook to make an investigation as to whether the increases were justified. He has had ample time since to carry out his investigations, and I want him to tell the House now what has been the result. The people feel they are suffering from a great grievance by reason of the increases made. From parts of my constituency people travel by bus to and from the city where they work.
In some cases their fares have been increased by 50 per cent. That, taken in conjunction with the operation of Emergency Powers Order No. 83 means a serious reduction in their weekly wage. Will the Minister say if, as a result of his investigations, he is satisfied that the increase in bus fares was justified? If he is, I want him to relate that to the principle underlying Emergency Powers Order No. 83, because I think it has a definite bearing on the wages of workers. It certainly has a definite bearing on their spending power, because if they have to spend more in travelling to and from their work they will have a smaller sum to bring home at the end of the week.
I would like to hear from the Minister what the prospects are as regards keeping such industries going as Dunlops in Cork City, Fords', Sunbeam or the bacon factories. I understand the latter are in danger of closing down. Will the Minister say if he has made any efforts, or intends to make any efforts, to keep these industries going? They give a big amount of employment not only to people in Cork City but to numbers in the outlying districts. If they are closed down it will mean that great numbers will be thrown on the unemployment list. I have already dealt with Irish steel and the Rushbrooke docks. If I remember rightly the Minister answered a question dealing with the latter, and said that it was being kept in mind. I would like to know from him if there is any hope of a resumption of work in the docks. We have a number of men still living in that area who follow the trades connected with dockyards, and who are still available for work. If there is no prospect of employment for them here, I am sure they will find work across the water. In view of that I would like to know from the Minister if there is any prospect of getting the Rushbrooke docks going very soon, especially in connection with some ships that have been purchased by the Irish company.
Comment on this
The omission from the Minister's statement on this Estimate of anything in the nature of a concrete plan for the solution of unemployment or, indeed, I might say of anything in the nature of a hint towards an approach to a solution of that problem, must be regarded as a tacit admission on the part of the Minister of his complete inability to cope with the situation as it exists to-day. I am certain that there has been no year in the history of this city, since the famine period, in which poverty has been so much in evidence: so much so that in some of the newly-built areas a social organisation—I am glad to have the opportunity of saying here in this House that it has great work to its credit in this respect— found it necessary to introduce mobile food canteens to stave off the hunger and want which were evident in these areas.
If any further evidence is needed of the poverty that has existed in the city during the past year, one has only to refer to the remarkable increase in the incidence of malnutrition in hospitals where children are specially treated. In these circumstances it must cause a great deal of surprise to those people outside that the Minister, whose Department is responsible for industry and commerce in this country, has no plan, or even a suggestion of a plan, to cope with the situation.
It may give the Minister great personal satisfaction to rely on an isolated statistic that there are 3,000 people less on the unemployed register than there were at this time last year, but that statistic is of very little value unless it is related to the existing circumstances. If we take that statistic, in conjunction with the fact that thousands of people have emigrated from the country during the last year and that thousands and thousands have been recruited into the Army, we find there the conclusion to be drawn from the fact that there are 3,000 less on the unemployed register than there were at this time last year. In Dublin one of the principal employing units is Jacob's factory. Already, I understand, quite a number of hands has been laid off there and quite a number of workers are working on shorter periods than is the custom, on account of the restrictions—necessary no doubt—in regard to the manufacture of various types of bread, biscuits and so on. I mention this fact just to show how it is linked up with statements made by other Deputies in the House in respect of industries in urban districts throughout the country. Surely the Minister does not consider for a moment that the House will be satisfied with his opening statement on this Estimate? So far as I can see, taking the statement as a whole, it summarises very nicely what appears to be the policy of the Government, simply to drift from day to day, to live a day-to-day existence so far as the country is concerned, hoping for the best.
Comment on this
In connection with this Estimate, I think we ought to say a little more about the constructive work of the Department in increasing industrial production in this country over a considerable period. I thought the Minister, because of the urgent problems that confronted him, was more than modest in speaking of the work of his Department. I think that now that we are facing a prolonged war and now that we have watched the effect of an intensified industrial policy, the members of the House should be given some indication of what our progress has been.
I think it is a magnificent thing that, in the middle of a war which surges around our coast, in respect of practically every single industry of importance for which 1940 industrial production figures have been given there is an increase, not only in the value of the production but in actual volume of output; that in spite of difficulties with regard to raw materials, in spite of every circumstance of an adverse character, at least throughout the whole of 1940, the policy of this Government to establish industry in this country was more than justified. It has been more than justified because, in so far as I know, from examining the general supply position since the beginning of the war, it has been easier to obtain raw materials or even semi-manufactured materials than finished goods in the case of a great number of industries. Therefore our industrial development, both through the use of our own resources and through the use of imported raw materials, has been an advantage to us in maintaining employment and in supplying the country with goods that it needs. I think I should give the House a few figures in addition to those given by the Minister in respect of some of our more important industries. For the year 1940 I note that we produced 1,169,000 cwts. of bacon as compared with just over 1,000,000 cwts. the year before.
Comment on this
I am quoting from the Census of Industrial Production, Irish Trade Journal, June, 1941. I note in connection with boots and shoes (wholesale factories) we produced 39,000 dozen pairs of men's heavy boots, as compared with nearly 36,000 dozens in the year 1939. I note that we produced altogether goods to the value of £2,200,000, as compared with goods to the value of £2,000,000 in 1939—an increase of 10 per cent. So far as brewing is concerned, there is evidence of stability in the industry, in spite of all its difficulties in transport. If we take an industry such as hosiery, where the raw materials are in some cases imported and in some cases home-manufactured, we may note that the actual production, for example, of adults' stockings and hose, mainly of cotton, increased from 78,000 dozens in 1939 to 119,000 dozens in 1940. These are just items taken at random.
If we examine the employment in these industries we find the same progress. We find, for example, in the hosiery industry the number of people employed increased by over 800 persons in the year 1940 as compared with 1939 in spite of the fact that many of the raw materials were imported. There is no need for me to go on reading figures from this census of production. Even if we examine the figures in industries where the raw materials commenced to become scarce in the middle of 1940, the figures for production are highly satisfactory. When we take the progress over a period of years, resulting from the Government's industrial policy, the results are, of course, far more notable. The gross output of industry which was £60,000,000 in 1931 had increased, by 1938, to £90,000,000—an increase of 50 per cent.—and the net output, which represents the actual increment of money value to the country, the actual increase of circulation of money due to manufacture, which has eliminated all what may be described as neutral charges, such as the cost of raw materials, increased from £25,000,000 to £35,500,000, or by £10,500,000. £10,000,000 is a very considerable sum for a small country of 3,000,000 inhabitants, a country which was at that time passing through an economic war, a country which was facing all kinds of internal difficulties. That represents a solid achievement as does also the fact that whereas there were 102,000 persons employed in 1932, by 1938 there were 166,000 persons employed in the whole of our industries, including building services as well as the manufacture of transportable goods.
In regard to the direction of these increases — where they were most notable—the production of food in this country or, shall we say, the processing of food in factories, increased by one-third from 1931 to 1938 and that increase is of enormous importance in connection with the present crisis in our supplies. The fact that we have been able to increase in a period of ten years the actual processing of our food products is of enormous importance in enabling us to have the maximum variety and quantity of food in this country at the present time. Aside from that, other remarkable increases in our production have been no less than 106 per cent. in clothing, over 300 per cent. in footwear and nearly 300 per cent. in hosiery. I am giving these figures, comparing the year 1931 with 1938, because 1938 was the last normal year and since then there has been a slight increase in production, which has not been notable and which, of course, has been affected by many unusual factors. I think we should recognise, at the same time, the enormous value of the principal exporting industry of this country, the brewing industry. Of the total net output of the country, 10 per cent. is represented by brewing and that fact has to be borne in mind, particularly as it is an industry which uses agricultural raw materials.
In connection with the work of the Government and the work of the Department in trying to decentralise industry and to bring new factories into towns where there was dreadful deadness, towns which served purely for the purpose of distribution and minor agricultural industries, it is interesting to note that about half of the whole of the new industrial development which took place was in rural districts. In actual fact, out of about 1,000 new establishments, both small and large, the province of Munster got 700, Leinster got 170, and Connaught got 70, the balance of 60 going to the three Ulster Counties of Monaghan, Cavan and Donegal. Many people imagine that industry is concentrated in Dublin to too great an extent. In fact, very nearly half the new employment and very nearly half the new production went to places other than Dublin City. The suggestion has also been made that many of the factories are small institutions. In a small country it is inevitable that the factories would be small, but it is interesting to note that, of the new factories, no less than 14 employ over 500 persons; that 282 employ from 50 to 500, while 475 employ from 10 to 50 persons. In other words, there have been established here at least 300 large-scale factories. Those factories have very great importance in relation to our total output. It is interesting to note in that connection that in 1936 60 per cent. of the factories employed less than 15 workers, but produced less than 10 per cent. of the net output. In other words the larger factory units are very important in giving employment. In view of the criticism by certain members of the Opposition that the industries in this country which are contributing to our national income are employing juvenile female labour to a great extent, I might say that the actual facts point to the opposite. In 1926, 6.3 per cent of the workers in industry were under 18 years; in 1936, 10.4 per cent. were under 18, the corresponding figure for the United Kingdom being 13 per cent.
Comment on this
I do not think they have yet been provided by the Department. But in 1936 the actual facts show that the new industrial development had not increased to any extent the proportion of workers under 18. In regard to the employment of females as compared with males, in 1936 about one-quarter of the workers were women, as compared with 17 per cent. in 1926. In the United Kingdom the proportion was approximately the same. It is comforting to note that our new industries have neither resulted in a large increase in the employment of females as compared with males, nor have they tended to an increased employment of children or young persons.
We hear a lot about industrial disputes in this country, and it is interesting in that connection to examine the wage levels here. There is nothing to be ashamed of in that regard in so far as a considerable number of our industries are concerned. I have here a statement from the International Labour Office journal of 1939 as to the comparative wages in this country and in the United Kingdom. If wages in a number of industries in London and Dublin are compared—London being the highest wage area in the United Kingdom, and Dublin being the highest wage area in Ireland—it will be seen that in all but one of 16 classifications of employment the wages in London were about 10 to 30 per cent. less than the wages in Dublin. The figures show that, in respect of organised industries here, there can be no suggestion that the workers are paid at an excessively low level.
Of course, we have to bear in mind one fact—it has been made obvious to us during this war—that, just as in other countries, the proportion of raw materials imported for our new industries is very high. Out of about £47,000,000 worth of raw materials used in our industries in 1936, at least £23,000,000 worth were imported. If one were to eliminate from that figure the importation of wheat for flour milling, it would be correspondingly reduced. When the members of the Opposition refer to the fact that many of our raw materials are imported, it must be remembered that that proportion of about 50 per cent. is no greater than in many other countries. The proportion of national income in Denmark which arises from industry is something over 30 per cent.—a fact which is unknown to many people—and most of the raw materials for Danish industries are imported; they have very few raw materials of their own. There is nothing to be ashamed of, then, if we have established industries in this country which are using a large percentage of imported raw materials, provided we can manufacture goods at a price which the people can afford to pay. But the fact that we have imported raw materials to the value of 50 per cent. of our total raw materials for industry does suggest that, if we could develop industrial exports on a larger scale, particularly when the war has ended, it would be to the advantage of industry. We have a very small market in this country for many of our industries, and that is one of the problems which the Minister for Industry and Commerce will have to face in the future. That is revealed by the fact that a very large number of our factories enjoy what might be described as virtual monopolies. No monopoly has been conferred on them by law, or by any action of the Department of Industry and Commerce, but the market is just large enough for the products of one factory only. Although a second factory may at any time be started, provided the Control of Manufactures Act is observed, if that second factory is started, one or other of them is likely to go out of production because of the limited nature of the market. I have compiled a list of at least 40 quite important products which are made in single factories, not by reason of a legal monopoly, but simply owing to the circumstances of our economy. There is, as the House knows, a very limited number of legal monopolies. They are restricted, I think, to about five commodities altogether.
With regard to the price at which our products are sold, I think it should be stated in this House that as soon as our workers became more accustomed to the new forms of production, and partly owing to the revision of tariffs which occurred at the time of the Anglo-Irish Agreement, the price of goods produced in this country in a great number of instances has become more and more equivalent to English prices. At the beginning of this war, and before the whole price situation changed completely owing to war conditions, a very creditable number of industries here were producing goods at prices near the English prices. That is a fairly good criterion to work on— if we can approximate to the English prices we are doing very well. It must also be remembered that there was a great deal of leeway to be made up, because many of our new plants were manned by workers unaccustomed to production. I think it is also important to note that there had been what might be described as disciplinary action, in so far as industry is concerned, before this war took place. In addition to the 23 tariffs which were reduced at the time of the Anglo-Irish Agreement, there were modifications of tariffs under that Agreement in, I should say—I have not the exact figures with me—at least 20 other industries. It is a fine thing to be able to record that in most cases these industries managed to survive. Some of them had to face a reduction of tariffs, and in some cases they ceased to produce certain classes of goods and were able to manufacture other goods here at a lower cost and more efficiently. There might have been adverse effects from the Anglo-Irish Agreement, and we might not have been so successful were it not for the activities of the Department of Industry and Commerce. Great credit is due, in my opinion, to the Prices Commission, that section of which operates under the Department of Industry and Commerce, for the way in which they conducted negotiations between the parties concerned and the manner in which they allowed Irish and British groups of manufacturers, producers, and so on, to get together, and thus, perhaps, avoid the necessity for examination and delay. I think the greatest credit is due to the Department for that work.
I think that in connection with the more recent development of industry that has occurred since the war began, it is very important that the public should be aware of the fact that prices of imported raw materials have increased enormously, and a very good answer could be found to Deputy McGilligan's rejoinders regarding the prices of certain worsted and woollen goods in connection with the economic indices, 1938-41, in the June number of the Irish Trade Journal. Every single person in this State who buys an imported article, or an article manufactured from imported raw materials, should be aware of the fact that the import price index, based on the prices of various categories of imported goods, was, in September, 1939, 89.5, in September, 1940, 134.2, and that in April, 1941, that figure had risen to 147.3—an increase in price which was out of our control and for which we cannot be held responsible, but which must affect the prices of all commodities. I am not trying to argue from that, that price control is necessarily effective, or that it could not be improved, or that profiteering has not occurred, but I am arguing that there have been very large increases in the prices of imported goods which we cannot possibly control ourselves. In actual fact, to give a comparison that would be of interest to agriculture, the agricultural export price figure—that is, not the whole figure—on the 1930 basis of 100, stood, in August, 1939, at 86.6, and in April, 1941, it was 164.7, showing a very considerable increase. The figure for the whole agricultural price index, covering goods sold in this country as well as abroad, did not increase to the same extent. That figure, which was based on the 1911-13 figure of 100, was in August, 1939, 116.3, and in April, 1941, it was 166.1.
I think it is useful at this time to review our industrial production and reiterate what has been done generally, giving briefly the value of our new industries, their value to the economy of the country, and at the same time point out the dangers that may arise and the reactions that may take place as a result of any new policy, with a view to having such deally ficiencies corrected now and in the future. I should say that the first and most important reason for industrial development in this country is a factor that has not been sufficiently considered, and that is the rural exodus from the country to the towns all over the world, in every State, and in particular the States where there has been a notable increase in agricultural prosperity.
There have been certain States which were famous for efficiency in agricultural production and where, for reasons that are hard to tell, they managed to maintain a sufficient number of agricultural workers and to maintain agricultural employment, but it would seem, generally, that when a State becomes prosperous agriculturally, it may give a certain amount of employment to begin with, but after that people tend to leave the land and go into districts where they can service the agricultural community. In the smaller cities and towns, for instance, they can operate a greater amount of transport for a greater amount of agricultural produce; they secure employment in factories processing agricultural products, and at the docks and in ships helping to transport agricultural produce. There is no hope that I can see in the future, with all these precedents that we have before us, of our being able to give largely increased and permanent employment on the land of this country as a result of the development of agricultural prosperity. The employment will have to come, as I have said, through transport services, through the processing of agricultural products, and through industrial employment generally increasing as a result of there being a greater consumption.
One of the most notable facts about the rural exodus is that in all countries people move out of the country districts much more quickly when there is work available for them. I am not arguing that we have really begun even to consider proper methods for bringing about agricultural prosperity, but I am saying that even in countries where there were no disturbances such as an economic war, where there was stable government, it has been found necessary to take artificial measures and the State has had to interfere in order to produce employment for people who leave the rural areas, even though, apparently, there may be no economic necessity for their leaving them. Therefore, I suggest that the securing of employment in industry is a vital factor. It will be a limited factor, so far as this country is concerned, and will never be able to give more than a limited amount of employment. Nevertheless, it is necessary to provide employment to deal with the rural exodus that is going to continue, and it is vitally important for us to vary our economy by increasing our secondary and primary industries, and by making everything that we can for ourselves, whether of raw material imported, or home-produced, in order to provide employment for these people.
I think that a second important reason for the establishment of these industries lies in the fact that we have certainly a very large number of potentially intelligent persons who are naturally addicted, if I might put it that way, to industry—people who desire employment of a technical kind in the towns and cities, and who refuse to remain agricultural labourers, and the only way we can find employment for them is by increasing industrial production by every means possible. Going through the country, it is quite obvious —aside altogether from the depression, or the war, or anything of that kind— that there is an enormous number of people who, through having relatives or friends in England, can manage to find work there, and who would remain here, possibly, if we could provide work for them, and therefore the more work we can provide for them the better.
One thing that is obvious is that, were it not for the industries that have been established here, we would not have been able to provide ourselves with many of the commodities that are manufactured from home produce and which now, owing to the war, it would be impossible for us to have otherwise. For instance, it would have been a frightful thing if we did not have our flour mills in full operation. Notwithstanding the criticisms that have been made by Deputy Dillon as to profiteering, and so on, whether they are true or not, the fact that we have modern grain mills in this country and that, for the first time, we have grain-drying plants capable of drying grain that might be produced in a poor agricultural season, is of vital importance at the present time. The fact that we are able to produce our own cement from our own home-manufactured or produced material is of equal importance, not only in continuing employment in the industry itself but in helping to keep going whatever housing or building is possible at the moment.
I could go through a whole list of articles which we now provide and which we can maintain, if we can obtain certain quantities of processing materials. Take, for instance, the boot and shoe industry. With the leather industries included, it employs thousands of people, and if we can get certain processing materials, that industry will continue. Were it not for that fact, there would be a serious scarcity of footwear at the moment. As a matter of fact, people have been over here in this country trying to buy footwear from us, because there is a scarcity in England. I could give many cases where, as a result of bombardment or other causes, English importers have come to us for goods, some of which we have been unable to supply them with, because we needed them ourselves, although in other cases we were able to supply them. There is abundant proof that the manufacture from home-produced or foreign raw materials of goods here in this country has been of immense advantage to us in this war.
There is another reason for satisfaction in our industrial development, and that is in relation to what may occur after this war if, as a result of war action, our external income collapses. We have about £300,000,000 invested abroad, and we receive from that an income of over £13,000,000 per year. We also receive from emigrants an ever declining remittance which has gone down from about £4,000,000 to £2,500,000 in the last ten years. We also received money for the Sweepstakes, whose existence is extremely hazardous, and the loss of that external income has made an enormous difference in the standard of living to-day. It has made a difference such as that between a Balkan State and a country with a high standard of living for a large number of people. Whether we should have done something with part of that external income in advance of this war is a matter which is now post mortem. We know, at least, that as a result of the war it is unlikely that that income will remain at the same level, and the more units of production we have, by means of which we can export to other countries, the better.
I refuse to accept the position that at the end of this war it will be impossible for us to export linen and cotton goods to Brazil solely because the output of the industry is about 15 per cent. too low to enable us to compete efficiently. I believe that the Government will have to take steps at the end of the war to correct output in industries where there is a possibility of export and that industries which are receiving high protection and are capable of exporting will have to be summoned before the Department of Industry and Commerce, and they will have to discuss how far they will be able to export if we have the capacity to make an international agreement in order to compensate them. Inevitably our whole industry may have to be mobilised to export as far as possible. I know there are enormous difficulties. I am aware that in very new industries, where our workers and employers are still without experience, the possibility of export is limited. But I certainly believe that, in so far as textiles, preserved foods, and hand-woven goods are concerned, we can develop exports to a considerable degree.
I have noted cases of export in industries which were entirely new. For example, before the war we were just about to export electric lamp bulbs to Brazil, which may seem strange to those people who are too easily cynical about such exports. We were exporting bakelite goods made from casein obtained from a co-operative company in North Cork on a large scale before the war. I think it is a matter of genius, skill, organisation and initiative on the part of the people concerned aided by the Government by every means possible, and that the existence of our industries will be vital in the post-war period if we lose part of our external income.
I have described as far as I could the positive results of industrial development in this country and the fine work done by the Department in developing industry. It is essential, in order to maintain industry and to give encouragement to the Department, that we should examine some of the adverse reactions. For the last 15 years the total national income of this country has been stagnant; it has hardly changed. If it is weighted according to some price factor and the price changes examined in relation to any change in the income, it will be seen that it has remained almost exactly the same. The reasons for that are known to everybody. We had to get through the economic war and the increase in the industrial income which took place in that period was offset by an almost corresponding decrease in agricultural income. That is the one difficulty we have to face in the future. We have to preserve the tremendous advantage of our new industrial development and, at the same time, we must, shall I say, dovetail agricultural and industrial development so that one does no harm to the other but that one stimulates the other.
In actual fact the percentage of our national income represented by industry in 1926 was 17 per cent, in 1938 it had risen to 23 per cent. In actual fact industry gained £10,000,000; our national income from industry increased by £10,000,000 in ten years and our agricultural income decreased by £9,000,000. That is a serious problem to face. To my mind, the whole future of industry is inevitably linked up with agricultural production and an increase of agricultural prosperity. I think the biggest problem that faces the country is the fact that, according to the figures given in the June, 1941, Irish Trade Journal, the agricultural output of this country, in spite of every inducement given to it during the past two years, continues to show the same stagnancy.
I think that in considering anything in relation to industry and future industrial production and the reward that can be obtained by employers and workers and the effect of that reward on the costs of agriculturists, we have to consider the agricultural output in this country. The total value of agricultural output in the year 1939-1940 was £60,000,000; in 1929-1930 it was £62,000,000. If we weight that by price and obtain a figure that is independent of price and which represents the volume, we find that the volume of agricultural output in 1929-30 was 100, and in 1939-40 it was 100.2. To my mind, therefore, the principal problem facing Irish industry is to dovetail agricultural development with the development of industry. The £9,000,000 which was lost must somehow be regained before this Government or any Government can say that they have increased the total national income of the people.
Most of us agree that the present war is being fought partly because the nations of the world have discovered that the policy of economic nationalism as such neither gives employment to large numbers of people nor could be said to solve other problems and bring peace and order to the world. One of the difficulties facing the Department of Industry and Commerce is that no matter who wins this war I am absolutely convinced—although there will be a period of chaos in which we shall retreat within ourselves and perhaps export less than we do now for some peculiar reason— as I am sure most Deputies are convinced, that the era of economic nationalism will be at an end, that we shall have to face a period of far stiffer competition, whether we face it under one system of international order or another. Then will come the testing sime when both workers and employers will have to show esprit de corps and a desire to produce efficiently which has not been necessary up to now because the desperate need has not been there. I hope the Department of Industry and Commerce, in so far as it is able, even in the middle of the war with all the other problems it has, is considering that possibility. No matter how much we may wish to preserve high tariffs and the protection system, we may be compelled by negotiation to modify our tariffs, to have freer exchange of goods, and we will at the same time want to preserve the sound industrial development that has taken place. We shall have a very serious problem to face in that connection.
The principal trouble from which our industries suffered before the war was lack of output. The output was insufficient in many industries, and was gravely less in many cases than in corresponding industries elsewhere, although the position has considerably improved. The Department of Industry and Commerce throughout the whole period up to now inevitably has had to interfere more and more with production in industry. The Department decides how many commodities are to be imported, it decides the tariffs on commodities, and it has a right to modify these tariffs. It also has a right to decide conditions of work in industry. It has an enormous amount of power by which it can supervise industry in general. I want the power the Department has, and that it may have to undertake, to be such that it can stimulate output in industry for the specific reason of safeguarding the national economy as a whole. Although I dislike excessive State control, I can see our living in a world of ever-growing State control. I can see that being increased here after the war. The work of constructively increasing output in industry is a very vital one. It deserves prolonged study and I know that the Minister, by his speeches and warnings to industrialists, has obviously given thought to it. I am also aware that the immediate problems of the country have detracted from the amount of thought that should be given to the problem in present circumstances.
I have tried to give, as briefly as possible, a résumé of the problems that have arisen. In that connection I would like to say that the efforts of the Government to improve industrial relations are in the interests of the workers themselves, because we cannot afford to have waste in anything. If we lost 3,000,000 working days in industrial disputes since 1931, after the war we shall not be able to afford that type of economic waste. Although the loss of working days may have had social and beneficial results, let us hope that after the war we shall attain social and beneficial results without the same waste.
Comment on this
How many were lost last year? It would not suit the Deputy's purpose to quote the number.
Comment on this
In 1939, the number of working days lost in industrial disputes, according to the Irish Trade Journal for March, was 106,476, and in 1940, 152,076 working days. I want to refer now to statements made by several Deputies in connection with this Estimate. One Deputy suggested that this Government was a laissez faire Government. I am not going to recite all the Acts passed dealing with industrial development under the xgis of the Department of Industry and Commerce to indicate reactions quite contrary to a laissez faire attitude. I suggest that it is ridiculous to say that this Government's policy was one of laissez faire, because the Trade Loans Section of the Department and the Industrial Credit Corporation, which were established by the action of the Department of Industry and Commerce, have resulted alone in injecting at least £10,000,000 of money into industry. That does not suggest an entirely laissez faire policy.
I presume we can discuss the Irish Tourist Board contribution on this Estimate, and I should like to hear a few words from the Minister about what has been done by that board during the past year. As remittances from our emigrants slowly decrease in the coming years, the only way to replace that income quite obviously is to get the Irish people to take their holidays in Ireland, and to get foreigners to take their holidays here. One of the ways of giving employment is to schedule areas and districts suitable for tourist development and to build such amenities as concrete breakwaters and promenades, to prepare these resorts for tourist development which, I think, would be a fairly safe speculative proposition when the war is over. The chances are that people will want to travel to this country for reasons that are too obvious to mention. I should like to know from the Minister whether he thinks much employment could be given in preparing the ground for tourist development. The Government has already taken steps of the kind indicated by the Labour Party, to produce where possible commodities without profit. One of the peculiarities about this country is that everyone knows that there has been what might be described as subnormal mineral development, but the present Government has, by means of three Acts, made it possible to consider the development of minerals on a non-profit-making basis.
I am well aware that this Department and the other Departments are studying the unemployment question. I am also aware of the remarks made concerning the amount of employment given by arterial drainage, but I want to know from the Minister whether his Department has been specifically consulted by the Department of Agriculture about the amount of employment that could be given by a really large-scale scheme of land improvement work, or whether it has only come before the Department in a minor way, because it is one primarily for the Department of Agriculture.
I was inspecting a farm the other day which is run by a very great agricultural expert in this country—not a hobby farmer, but a man who has to live off his agricultural income—and I noted that he had got permission from the county council to excavate every drain along the county council roads bounding the farm. He excavated the drains and took tons and tons of earth away for manuring purposes. I noted that he had cut back his hedges and that he had removed leaf mould from under the trees. I then took occasion to review what agricultural knowledge I have, and I realised the immense importance of that work, and the comparative neglect of it in many parts of the country. The fact is that many farmers either have not got the pecuniary means to do large-scale drainage or land improvement work, such as the piling up of big heaps of compost for agricultural purposes, or they are under the impression that they have not got the means. In most cases it is the former, and I cannot help feeling that large-scale employment could be given in land improvement work, such as the removal of furze and ferns from areas of land which have gone back to rough grazing and the provision of valuable compost, humus, for farmers at a time when artificial manures are scarce. When I examined the effect of that work on this farm, I was amazed that it was possible to see the improvement in the character of the grass where this material had been spread. There are many farmers who do it, but one has only to travel through the country to realise that there are large areas where only one farmer in 100 does it. Could that not be considered as a means of giving large-scale employment on an economic basis and on a basis that would be of immense advantage to the country?
I want to ask the Minister whether the question of limekilns is a matter exclusively for the Department of Agriculture. The production of lime is a small industry in this country. It is not only a matter of agriculture, but a form of industrial output. The country desperately needs lime, because the proportion of land which is acid is appallingly high. Would it not be possible for the employment branch of the Department to consider the development of more limekilns, apart altogether from the Department of Agriculture? All the Department of Agriculture is concerned with is that, where lime is produced, it should get a certain subsidy. I should like to have considered as a matter of employment, of industrial development, the re-creation of ruined limekilns all over the country at a time when lime is urgently needed.
Finally, I want to advert to the statement made by Deputy Hickey with regard to sterling, and I have a very quick answer for it. Ninety per cent. of our trade is with Great Britain with whom we exchange a series of well-known commodities for another series of well-known commodities. No matter what you call the pound, no matter what you value it at, no matter what you do with it and no matter how many societies, institutions or boards you create in connection with the issue of it, you come back, in the long run, to the fact that the farmer wants a stable value for his exports and the industrialist wants a stable value for his imports. If you reduce the value of the pound, there will be certain economic and psychological effects which will have to be corrected in some other way, by means of duties and burdens on some other sections, or by restrictive action. If you increase the cost of the Irish pound, you get an opposite series of effects which will have to be treated in the opposite way. Until the day approaches when we can trade with a number of different countries throughout the world, so that we can choose between one form of currency arrangement and another, we shall be compelled to consider the interests of the ordinary farmer and the ordinary importer, so far as maintaining a stability in the prices we pay for our raw materials of industry and a stability in the price level for our exports is concerned. That is a very simple matter, and no amount of talk can possibly dispose of it. Where changes have been made under circumstances similar to our own, corrective action has had to be taken in every case, and I think that the introduction of that matter into a discussion of the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce is altogether apart from the issues we have to face.
Comment on this
At this rather late stage of the discussion on this very important Estimate, it is refreshing to find somebody who has no complaint to make in regard to the running of the Department, in the person of Deputy Childers. It is actually exhilarating to find how completely satisfactory everything has been done by the Department, so far as Deputy Childers is concerned. But one wonders whether or not Deputy Childers is entitled to sympathy or congratulation. I think he is entitled to both. To my mind, to a man with the analytical mind of Deputy Childers, it must be a rather difficult task to make the fine defence he has made for what he knows, in his heart of hearts, and what the majority of the people consider, has been a complete faux pas on the part of the Department he is trying to defend.
He is certainly entitled to congratulation, because he, at least, has made a decent attempt, by reference to figures of all sorts, showing that he has carried out deep research into the subject, to justify it. He has made a much more decent attempt than the Minister to answer to the House for the actions of the Department for which the Minister is responsible. Deputy Childers has tried to do the best he could as a member of the Party to which he belongs to justify what the Minister has not attempted to justify by resort to figures which, to my mind, make a very unsatisfactory meal, but which can be made to prove any sort of thing.
I do not intend to try to follow Deputy Childers into the vast morass of figures into which he has travelled, but I congratulate him on the research he has carried out in an effort to prove his case. I, however, am more or less inclined to fall back on the acid test of what we find in the country, what is the net result of what has been, and is being, done by the Department, and its reactions on the people, as we find them. The Deputy has painted for us a nice picture of what he hopes will be done in the future, arising out of the war, and that is one of the aspects which we should be examining. We should be planning ahead for development in this country after the war, and I suggest that, if that planning ahead is to be left to the people who have failed to plan for the present, the future must definitely be regarded as black. In supporting the motion to refer back the Estimate, I want to say that I know of no Department in the State which has failed more completely in a very important task than the Minister's Department, viewed from any angle.
They are vested with a very serious and important responsibility, and, as has been stressed by various speakers who have preceded me, the main point to be considered is the unemployment problem. More than anybody else, the Minister for Industry and Commerce must be held accountable and responsible for the employment or unemployment of our people, and, measuring the Department by that standard, I ask any of the most ardent supporters or admirers of the Department if he will say that they have been successful in relation to that all-important question. To my mind, they have been a complete failure. They have perpetuated and concentrated on the old tinkering methods, and have never seemed to see the necessity for grappling in a broad national way with it. They have tried to apply small poultices to serious cankers, and the result, of course, has been that the problem has grown worse and worse.
The Minister told us that there were fewer unemployed than last year by approximately 3,000, that there was a decline in unemployment of approximately 4 per cent. What does this reflect? The Minister also spoke of so many people having left their normal employment to enlist in the Defence Forces. The Minister very cautiously refrained from stating to what defence force he was referring. While we are glad to admit that a very considerable number of people went into the Defence Forces of this country, I suggest that the proportion of those from employment was relatively small. But a very considerable number has gone into the defence force of another country, to which he has not referred.
Comment on this
Certainly the Minister said in his statement that so many had left employment in order to enlist in the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
I am quoting from the Minister's statement. He did not say to what defence force. I presume that he was referring to the Defence Force of this country, and I think I am right in attributing that meaning to the Minister. I am extending that, by reference to the Minister's silence, to the fact that one of the methods by which unemployment has been reduced is by a considerable number going into the defence force of another country.
Comment on this
I am repeating that. The Minister has a better opportunity than I have, but I have many opportunities to maintain and uphold that figure from my personal knowledge of my own district, and also of this city. One of the artificial factors which have contributed to keep our employment figure lower is, in addition to migrating and deporting our people to industrial work in Britain, the very considerable number compelled to join the British Army. The Minister states the Period Order, as applied this year, does not relatively affect his computations, notwithstanding the fact that the introduction of the order this year was, I think, three months earlier than last year. If that is so, there is no use in talking of common sense figures. If the fact that you decline to give unemployment assistance to men from the month of March this year as against June last year, and struck them off your books three months earlier than last year, has no serious reflection or does not affect the computation of your figures, there is no sense in keeping books at all.
I said that the reports we have got here from year to year of unemployment figures are only taken from the records of employment exchanges, and do not mean anything. It simply means that men are struck off the records by means of the unemployment period order, as no longer entitled to benefit. They are assumed to be employed at that moment. That is all that happens here. I have asked, for several years past, if the Minister for Industry and Commerce will take the trouble to pursue these people who were struck off under period orders 1, 2 and, subsequently, 3, to know what became of them and how many actually did become employed. However, the Minister's predecessor—not the Minister himself, I think—told us he had not attempted to trace those people. The order came in on the 1st June or the 1st March for the small valuation people, but, whether it was June or March, they were simply taken off the books and told to go away and do the work waiting to be done. It was not worth the Minister's while to ascertain how many in actual fact did secure that employment.
The Minister or his predecessor never told us how many of the people immediately adjacent to cities and towns—and who had never stood in a hayfield or a garden—and who were engaged all their lives in industrial employment, were classified, because they were resident outside the borough stone, amongst the agricultural community, notwithstanding the distinct classification on the books of the employment exchange, and sent ruthlessly to do this work. How many of these got employment? Of course, none of them did. It meant a saving on the books of the employment exchange and a fictitious figure produced for this House and for the people, to delude us that unemployment was not as serious as previously. I remark no change having been made in 1941 as distinct from 1940, except that we have a Third Period Order, sweeping all types of people into its mesh, as in 1940. The Minister states that, for the purpose of his argument, the earlier Period Order does not affect his computations. We find the Department which has been eulogised by Deputy Childers as having done all they possibly can do, engaged in the things which, to my mind, should not matter. They are utterly regardless of the fact that we are passing through a serious economic crisis, which cannot be avoided and which calls for all the consummate skill of the Department and the Government as a whole, to obviate its harmful vicissitudes, but the time of the House has been wasted for the past few weeks, forcing down the necks of the citizens of the country a most unpalatable pill which they did not ask for and which even their medical officer would not consider necessary—in the form of a Trade Union Bill, accompanied by the black draught of Order 83. In the meantime, the same Department came in here some years ago to tell us, at their own request, that the transport industry was in such a parlous position that it could no longer continue to exist without having an immediate and urgent operation performed. As a substitute for the major operation of transport legislation, the Transport Tribunal was formed, which the Minister then said would report before the 8th of the following February. That is about three years ago. That Transport Tribunal report, again promised quite recently, has not yet materialised.
Someone might ask what that has got to do with the case. I suggest that the delay in issuing this Transport Tribunal report is a very serious matter to the general economic success of the country. The railways have been forced back now into a position something like that which they used to be in—because of circumstances they are going up. At the moment, they are being called upon to become the major transport facilities for the entire country, yet they are left unaware—I presume they have not been told, as the House has not been told—of the contents of the Transport Tribunal report. Not knowing their eventual determination and destination, companies in that state are not able to plan, as they should be able to plan, for the vast development which is taking place in their resources. They are called upon now to be the main haulage system for the entire country, for food, fuel and other requirements of the State, owing to the paucity of petrol coming from outside sources.
The railways have to be made now— and are being made—the main factors in the carrying on of the country's trade. I suggest that it is manifestly unfair to them—if for no other consideration whatever—that they are not to be consulted and told the plans, intentions and decisions of the Transport Tribunal which sat two and a half years ago. That would enable them to advance on a big scale and try to cope with unemployment, as the country is entitled to ask them to do. These matters are considered to be only details and are left in the pigeon holes of the Department of Industry and Commerce, while they are pursuing their merry round of introducing new legislation of a character that is inclined not to be remedial but harmful, disturbing and dislocating at a time when harmony is required.
Another one of their activities which should not escape the Minister is that they have distinguished themselves by, in my opinion, violating the Constitution, if not actually conscripting some of our people—no other word would fill the bill to state my feelings about it. Boys from 18 years of age to 25 will not be allowed to participate in the turf drive in the national emergency. They will not be allowed by the labour exchange to cut turf, but must join the Construction Corps, as the Department has decided to pay no unemployment assistance to them. Even if they wished to go to the bog, they will not be allowed to go as the men must be drawn, in the first instance, from people in receipt of benefit or assistance. I suggested on many occasions in this House impartially that that is a bad national outlook to take on a question of national importance. We want to get the maximum amount of turf cut.
I ask is it fair or reasonable to allow anybody to control such an important Department and take this twopenny-halfpenny view of the situation, that men in the prime of life from 18 to 25 must go into the Construction Corps? They must get into uniform. I have had my attention called to the case of a boy on whom his mother and two or three sisters were depending. The few shillings he got from the labour exchange were of some use to the family. That boy will not be allowed to work at the cutting of turf and he will not receive any assistance from the employment exchange. If he joins the Construction Corps, the 1/- a day which he will receive will be of no use to his dependents. That is another item that ought to be placarded as an achievement of the Department of Industry and Commerce—their contribution to the national fuel drive and their endeavour to rob the country of the services of healthy, strong young men from 18 to 25 years, in their attempt to conscript them and put them into uniform which, I believe, is contrary to the Constitution. We were told that this was to be a voluntary force. I do not think it is a voluntary force if you can tell a boy that he must either join the Construction Corps or starve. That may not be held by the Minister to be conscription but I say, definitely, that it is conscription. It is just as much conscription as if the press gang were to take him by the back of the neck and force him into uniform.
The Minister told us to-night—I was glad to hear the reference—that the control of turf development had been transferred to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. Is it any wonder that a change was made? I hope the turf drive will have a greater chance of success than it would have had under former circumstances. Deputy Childers, in his defence of the Department, said he was dealing only with the 1938 figures, which would not bring him up to the abnormal period. He made quite a good defence for the normal period, but surely the Government ought to have been capable of planning for the abnormal period since the war broke out? If we want a true picture of the position in the country since the war broke out, we should have to appeal to the St. Vincent de Paul Society. The Government have failed to tell us what the position in the country is. Only the members of a society such as the St. Vincent de Paul Society and the medical officers of the dispensary districts could enlighten us as to the true position. They could give us a more accurate picture than all the statistics which could be produced.
That position is due to the lack of planning and to lack of provision of suitable employment at reasonable rates of pay and, for this I hold that the Department of Industry and Commerce is largely responsible. The effects of their failure are going to be felt not alone to-day but in the future. They will lead to lasting deterioration in our country as a whole.
I want to refer to a document which I heartily endorse: it is a statement issued from the Annual Ard Fheis of the League of the Kingship of Christ, on the 8th December, 1940. This statement says:—
"A very large proportion of men are still without work of any kind, while others can only look forward to intermittent work or to employment at low rates of pay. Such economic insecurity constitutes an almost insurmountable barrier to marriage and it is apparent from recent official statistics that the situation is becoming more and more serious. Of women between the ages of 20 and 35, only one in three is married and at least one quarter of all the women in the country never get married. Such an overwhelming proportion of unmarried women has no parallel in any other country in the world (Census of Population, 1936, Volume V, Part 1, pages 24, 33, 35 and 217).
"The consequent steep decline in the number of children, which is especially evident in the rural areas, strikes at the very foundation of the nation and spells its ruin if an effective remedy is not quickly applied. It is obvious that a nation without sufficient children has no future, whatever its political status or the extent of its territory."
That paucity of marriages is attributable not to any inclination towards celibacy on the part of the people but to economic stress. The position provides serious cause for reflection for the Minister and his Department. The people are not marrying because of their inability to maintain a home. The race is declining. I think that we are the only white race who, apart from the war, are so declining and deteriorating. The position presents a definite challenge to the Minister and to the Government as a whole. They are not taking the steps which they have been appealed to from every platform to take. They are not giving sufficient attention to the serious effects on the future of our race—not on the labour section alone but on the whole race—of their failure to plan except in the tinkering twopence halfpenny way to which I have referred. The work is there to be done. Deputy Childers spoke of the financial aspect. That there is plenty of work to be done, cannot be denied.
We were left a legacy of neglected work by the people who controlled this country in the past. We have not attempted to cope with that work. We have not dealt adequately with afforestation, coast erosion, or any of the many schemes which suggest themselves to people's minds to-day on which men could be employed at reasonable rates of pay. Their wages would circulate amongst the shopkeeping population and the farmers, and everybody in the community would benefit. We do not set our men at work because it would upset the balance we are maintaining at Thread-needle Street. The time has come to get over this inferiority complex, and to realise that we are entitled to create the necessary credit, and to have sufficient confidence in the future to put our unemployed people into the useful employment which is waiting, so as to enable them to build up assets for the country, and also to maintain their homes and families. Otherwise, there is no future for the country. This Estimate represents a continuance of the definite failure marked by the Ministry since it came into office, and it certainly has not been improved during the régime of the present occupant of the chair in this Department.
Comment on this
Deputy Childers referred to the modesty of the Minister when introducing his Estimate. That is a great tribute to pay to the Minister— that he has preserved his humility notwithstanding the manner in which he has been serenaded by members of the Labour Party and the Opposition during the past three weeks. I do not know whether it is true or not. Deputy Childers dealt, to a great extent, with the distant past and the distant future. He did not dwell, to any great extent, on the very serious present. He did not dwell, to any extent, on the failure of the Department of Industry and Commerce to cope with the difficulties of the present emergency. This is an agricultural country, and it should be the duty of the Department of Industry and Commerce to find substitutes for the many commodities in which the agricultural industry is deficient.
I understand that in Germany they have an unpronounceable word for substitute materials. In this country we should devote a very considerable time to the production of substitutes for the very essential articles which agriculture requires. We have a native supply of phosphates, and we cannot import phosphates now. We have not heard from the Minister to what extent our deposits of raw phosphates are being developed. We have heard very little of the amount of phosphatic manures which will be available for our agricultural industry during the coming year. It should also be possible to produce other forms of manure such as potassic manure, sulphate of ammonia and nitrogenous manures, which are all essential to agricultural production. We have heard very little from the Minister for Industry and Commerce, or those who applaud his good work, as to what is being done in that direction.
Deputy Childers referred to another form of fertiliser, lime, which is home-produced, and the production of which could be greatly expanded. This is one matter to which the Minister should direct immediate attention. When it is impossible to secure artificial manures there is no doubt that land can be greatly improved, particularly when it has become sour, by the application of quantities of lime. Agriculturists are only beginning to realise the extent to which large areas are deficient in lime. Therefore wherever limestone can be obtained in sufficient quantities, kilns should be provided by the Government.
With regard to transport, it is generally believed that the Minister's Department has not availed of every opportunity to provide substitutes for petrol and other fuels which are now so scarce. We have found that producer gas plants are workable and have been generally successful. We are at a loss to know why the manufacture of such plants has not been undertaken on an increased scale. I do not think that the change over to producer gas should be confined to the period of this emergency. If we were to change over to producer gas, having regard to the fact that we have the native fuel supplies we would be able to reduce to a considerable extent, even in normal times, our importation of petrol and other motor fuels.
A good deal of concern has been expressed with regard to lighting, particularly in areas which are not linked up with our electricity supply system. I should like to know whether anything has been done in relation to the manufacture of candles from native tallow or some other commodity. These would be a desirable substitute for paraffin when it is not obtainable in sufficient quantities. So far as our native coal supplies are concerned, I am definitely of the opinion that the Minister's Department must have been asleep for the last few years in regard to extending production in our coal mines. We have certain coal mines in Leinster which have been developed fairly extensively. We have others which have been developed only on a minor scale and which are capable of wide expansion if the necessary capital were made available.
It is possible some of these mines may not be capable of being developed on a profit-making basis, but they may be capable of producing a large amount of fuel to meet our requirements, if they are developed by the State. I know a company has been formed for the purpose of developing our coal mines, but a lot of time has been lost and this company seems to be rather slow in proceeding with the work of producing coal. The result is that it is not possible to anticipate if there will be any appreciable increase in the production of coal during the next few months, and we may have to face the possibility of a serious shortage of fuel during the coming winter.
Deputy Corry referred to iron and steel and I think that, apart from whatever has happened to the factory engaged in the manufacture of iron and steel, sufficient has not been done in respect to the collection of scrap iron and waste metals generally. Farmers are to a large extent the heaviest purchasers of iron and steel and so far as I know no attempt has been made to collect scrap iron and waste metal from the farming community. I am quite certain that there are ample quantities of waste metals lying around the country which could be utilised to the advantage of the country and it is regrettable that some system of collection has not been organised.
I asked a question with regard to waste paper. I believe it is the function of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to deal with the industry engaged in the manufacture of paper and it should be his duty to see that there is no waste and that whatever waste paper is available will be collected and utilised in the paper-making industry.
In this connection very little is being done over the greater part of the country. My opinion is that in this, as in every other Department, there is too great a concentration of administration in the City of Dublin. I think it would be a good idea if the Minister were to distribute officials of his Department throughout the country. If I might make a suggestion, it would be to divide the country into, say, 200 administrative districts, with each district in charge of an official, instead of having them all concentrated in the towns. If that were done, a good deal of very useful development work could be undertaken in different areas and a good deal of the time which is now lost sending officials from the city to remote parts of the country, getting back reports and communicating backwards and forwards from the remoter districts, could be saved and, on the whole, you would have a better administrative system and undeveloped potentialities in our rural areas would be given much needed attention.
Deputy Childers referred to one point in connection with the improvement of lands. He suggested that deposits of a manurial nature, such as might be found on roadsides and so on, should be collected and utilised for the improvement of land, and our unemployment problem might be relieved to a great extent by the collection and utilisation of such deposits. In addition, the productivity of our land would be very greatly increased. In that connection, it may surprise the Minister to hear that when a farmer suggested that work of this kind might be carried out under the farm improvements scheme, he was informed by an inspector that work of that kind did not come under the scheme at all, an opinion which I think is rather extraordinary having regard to the fact that we want to get the utmost productivity out of the land. We have not got sufficient artificial manures, which is all the greater reason why the alternative that Deputy Childers suggested should be adopted, yet officials have made it known that grants made available under the farm improvement scheme should not be utilised for that purpose. That just shows how officials in the City of Dublin trying to make rules for rural areas, agricultural districts mainly, are handicapped. I repeat the suggestion which I have already made that the country be divided into small administrative districts, and that the Minister appoint one official in charge of each district instead of having all these officials concentrated in the City of Dublin. I think if that suggestion were adopted the Minister would find that, in a very short time, it would be possible to develop rural areas and to provide employment of a decentralised nature throughout the length and breadth of the country.
Deputy Childers referred also to the fact that our agricultural output has not increased to any extent. I am suggesting towards that end measures which lie within the power of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to adopt, namely to provide as far as he possibly can, an increased supply of manures for agriculture and an increased quantity of home produced lime. I ask the Minister also when he is replying to the debate—it is possible he may not reply at all; he has lately developed a tendency to regard himself as the strong, silent man of a weak talkative Government—to state whether his Department has investigated the potentialities of the mineral deposits in County Wicklow. I think Wicklow is one of the richest counties as regards mineral deposits.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not the first to talk in that way.
Comment on this
I know attempts were made to get gold in the county, but I do not think that gold at present is a very valuable mineral.
Comment on this
From the point of view of providing us with essential products that we require at the moment, there are other minerals that are more valuable or equally valuable. We have iron ore deposits, lead deposits and other deposits in Wicklow which are capable of very extensive development, and I hope that when the Minister's new mineral development company begins operations they will turn their attention to that county.
Comment on this
One of the subjects which the Industrial Research Council is investigating is seaweed products, and one of the derivatives of seaweed is called calcium alginate. It has been found that calcium alginate is a very valuable ingredient in the manufacture of starch. At the present moment there is a great shortage of starch in Great Britain, and there is a market there for all the calcium alginate that can be produced in this country. I should be glad to know when the Minister is replying what progress has been made with research into this question, if there are any possibilities of its commercial production and, if so, when it will be possible for that commercial production to commence. I have endeavoured to obtain this information from the Department, but so far without any success. Possibly when the Minister is replying, he might deal with the question and let me know if it is at all possible to produce this substance on a commercial scale. I have no idea of what the process is or how much plant is required. It may be that, having regard to the difficulties of the moment, it is impossible to obtain the necessary plant. I think the Minister might at least make clear whether it is possible, because there is a valuable market for this product and one which could be easily cultivated if it were possible to produce it.
Comment on this
Listening to the Minister one would think that the times were normal. No references were made of a constructive nature, at any rate, in his opening statement to any proposal for dealing with the unemployment situation. I think the Minister admitted that that is a growing problem, a problem which will have to be tackled in the very near future, if any headway is to be made. The Minister and other Ministers have reminded us repeatedly that, in consequence of the emergency, they expect that this winter will be a very bad one, for the poor especially. In view of that, it is very surprising that the Minister has not given any indication of what he proposes to do during the coming winter months to deal with this vastly-growing problem. He went to great pains to indicate what he was not prepared to do. He dealt at length with the proposals contained in the report of the Drainage Commission and he pointed out that the labour content of the scheme mentioned would be very small. Of course there is something in that contention. At the moment it may not be desirable that work of that kind should be undertaken, but there are various other kinds of works which have been pointed out from time to time from these benches and other benches which could be initiated.
I would term the Minister's speech an academic statement, a statement which might be all right in normal times. Deputy Childers followed in the footsteps of the Minister in delivering what might be considered a good lecture if delivered at a conference of industrialists. It is to be noted that Deputy Childers has thrown overboard his Party's policy of economic self-sufficiency. I can imagine that if Deputy Childers six or seven years ago had made statements in connection with that policy such as he made here to-night, he would be expelled from the Party. Deputy Childers dealt with the situation which he envisaged might develop immediately after the war Nobody knows how long this war is going to last, and surely we are not going to wait to do any planning until it is over. Nobody knows who is going to win the war. I am sure a lot will depend on the particular set of belligerents who will win.
There are some things that I would like to speak about in connection with the Minister's Department. There was set up in the country during the last 12 months what has come to be known as the Construction Corps. I know the Minister had nothing to do with the setting-up of it, but his Department is responsible for the payment of unemployment assistance and unemployment benefit, and I would like to know from him under what authority he has refused to pay unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance to people who have refused to join the Construction Corps. I know that he has power to refuse benefit to people who will not work. I am submitting to the Minister, and to the House, that this is not work in the accepted sense. There are some people who might be approached to join the Construction Corps, and, if they refused, the Minister would perhaps be right in stopping the payment of benefit to them, but I know of cases where apprentices have been offered work in the Corps and, because they refused it, they have been taken off the employment exchange and refused benefit. I submit to the Minister that, surely, is stretching it too far. I know of cases in my own town, of young men serving their apprenticeship as carpenters, who had been idle for a few months but were expecting to go back to work in a short time, who were asked to go away on the Construction Corps. I suggest to the Minister that is not fair. The fact of their going might seriously interfere with their apprenticeship; it might succeed in preventing them from getting a knowledge of the trade which they have set their hearts on.
In that connection, I want to ask the Minister when it is proposed to put the Apprenticeship Act into operation. I know that, to a small extent, it is in operation in the City of Dublin. So far as apprenticeship through the country is concerned, terrible abuses are occurring. That may be largely attributed to the number of unskilled men that we have in the country. I know a certain firm which takes in young boys, supposedly to serve their apprenticeship to a particular trade. They are kept at work for two or three years, but when it comes to the time that they should get a decent wage, they are thrown out on the streets, and other young men are brought in. The result of all that is that, in this country to-day, there are more young men idle between the ages of 19 and 25 than between other ages. I think the time has arrived when the Minister should seriously consider his attitude in regard to that Act, and try to have it put into operation generally.
At the recent Technical Education Congress, expression was given to certain opinions on behalf of the executive of that body. It was stated very definitely that they were very anxious and, in fact, had offered to co-operate with the Minister in any efforts that he might make to put the Act into operation. There is very little use in talking about vocational and technical education in the country so long as the Minister is content to leave that Act in a cupboard in his Department.
Comment on this
I am not talking about Dublin, either. I am stating a fact which I know, that the Dublin Trades Council controls apprenticeship.
Comment on this
Deputy Childers recited a litany of the days that were lost during the period 1939, 1940 and 1941, and prefaced his remarks by saying that he welcomed the action of the Government in introducing certain legislation. Of course he had in his mind the Trade Union Bill, and I presume Emergency Powers Order No. 83. If Deputy Childers is of opinion that the Trade Union Bill is going to cure things of that kind, he is making a terrible mistake.
Comment on this
I was just answering what Deputy Childers said. I take it that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, with the Department of Supplies, is responsible for trying to secure certain supplies of raw material for industry. I am sure he is interested in that from the point of view of the amount of employment to be given. There are two iron foundries in the town I come from, and, as the Minister knows, they employ between them from 600 to 700 men in turning out agricultural machinery. Their position is a very serious one at the moment. They are of the opinion that they will be unable to carry over next winter, because they have not been able to get sufficient supplies of steel and iron. I am not blaming the Minister that he has not got steel and iron, but I would ask him to make a special effort to try to secure supplies, especially since we have now got certain ships of our own. It would be a very serious matter if two firms employing that number of men had to go out of production during the coming winter.
During the last fortnight I had occasion to approach the Minister in connection with the payment of office cleaners at the Wexford exchange. I have the assurance of the Minister that he is investigating the matter. At the same time I would like to draw the attention of the House to the wages paid to these two office cleaners. During the summer season they are paid 6/11 per week each, and during the winter season 9/1 per week. I would ask the Minister in all seriousness is that a wage which should be paid by a Government Department— that should set a headline and be a model employer for the rest of the country? These two people have to go into the exchange morning and evening. They have to wash down the exchange completely every Saturday, and for that they get the splendid sum of 6/11 per week. I hope the Minister does not suggest that Emergency Powers Order No. 83 ought to be applied in their case.
Comment on this
I said that I hoped the Minister did not suggest that it should, but the Minister has done such funny things during the last couple of months that I would not be surprised if he did apply it to them. These are the matters in which I am specially interested. I ask the Minister to give special attention to the case of these office cleaners, and to the question of procuring supplies of steel and iron for the Wexford foundries.
Would the Minister say if any serious effort is being made to secure a greater supply of anthracite coal? What is being done to develop the Tipperary coalfields which the Minister got pretty considerable sums of money for some time ago? My information is that more coal could be got out of the Castlecomer mines than is, in fact, being got. There is a big demand for anthracite coal at the present time, but, notwithstanding that, I understand that a number of miners from the North Kilkenny area have gone to England within recent weeks with passports which, of course, were provided by the Government to enable them to go. I think that is a very serious state of affairs. It goes to show that the workers resent the application of Emergency Powers Order No. 83, and that they prefer to go over and stand their chance of being bombed and killed in England rather than remain in this country on a starvation wage.
Comment on this
I did not intend to intervene in this debate, but I do so because the last speaker has made a remark, which I am sure he is able to substantiate, which is of very serious consequence to the whole country. He mentioned it from the point of view of the danger of 600 or 700 workers being thrown out of employment in Wexford owing to a shortage of material for Wexford foundries, where agricultural machinery is manufactured. What is going to be the consequence for the whole country if these foundries are shut down for want of material? Is there any connection between that condition of affairs and the matter that Deputy Corry has been raising here for months? Has the Government allowed raw material, steel and iron, to be shipped out of the country as scrap and at scrap prices while we were rushing headlong to the condition represented by Deputy Corish? If we are moving towards such a position, the Minister responsible should be charged with criminal negligence.
There is no use in issuing emergency orders or in passing Acts requiring certain work to be done when, in the midst of doing that work, people cannot get the machinery or the motive power to do it. I have been speaking recently to people who are interested in the development of native fertilisers and they complained bitterly that they have not got from the Government the support and the encouragement they should have got and which they expected. I do not know if there is anything in that. In the development of industry here we were told, and of course we expected, that the natural development would be in the industries that were racy of the soil, something akin to agriculture. In the present national emergency and international emergencies, we are thrown back entirely on our own resources. Are we making reasonable provision; are we planning ahead? Does the Government think that merely by making an order that a certain amount of land in the country must be broken up and put under cultivation they are going to meet the food situation? They evidently did think that but it is revealed here to-night that they did not make provision to secure the implements of industry to cultivate the land and to produce food. Neither did they make provision to procure the stimulants and food necessary for the soil in the production of food. Another department has been so entirely lacking in foresight that you have not the motive power to drive machinery to cultivate the soil and to garner the crops. It is a wonder the Taoiseach should say that the country does not realise the danger it is up against? Those who are engaged in agriculture and in industry know the dangers they are up against.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is on the Estimate for Agriculture and Estimate for Supplies rather than the Estimate for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
I submit that I do not think I am. The production of iron and steel is an industrial matter and these are required for agricultural production. We are short of them.
Comment on this
To catch the right estimate here on any subject pertaining to the economic life of the country is getting increasingly difficult because what is appropriate to one Ministry or Department this week is shifted to another Ministry next week. You are chasing the hare round about and you do not know what form it is in.
Comment on this
No. So, when Ministers, on important national matters like this, adopt such elusive methods I feel inclined to give as much credence to a Deputy, particularly when he is speaking of the industrial life of his constituency, as I give to a statement of a Minister. I would like to know what the Minister is doing to make available Clare phosphates. Are there phosphates in Clare? Will we be told whether there are or not? If there are, why are they not worked in sufficient quantities to make them available for the country? If agriculture is to be the handmaid of industry, industry must be the master of agriculture, and why is not a supreme effort made to produce Clare phosphates and make them available for agriculture?
I have been told by one of the most distinguished industrial chemists of the country that 3 per cent. of sea water is potash and that it can be extracted commercially economically, that the Government had been approached on this matter and that they did not give the necessary encouragement. Phosphates, too, are extracted from the air in France. Why is not some effort made to do that here? Can we get any further than talk in an emergency of this kind? I think the policy of self-sufficiency is getting more criticism than it deserves. As has been stated by the previous speaker, none of us knows how long this war will last. The situation has every appearance of lasting for years, and even when the war ceases it will be a long time before we can get back to normality. By that I mean back to the time when we could depend for our manufactured goods on raw materials coming from the ends of the earth. When this war is over there will be no ships. Even if peace were declared to-morrow there would be no ships to carry goods to this country. It would take years to get back to normality. During the years of belligerency and during the period of repairs in the years succeeding peace, we will have to depend on our own resources. We had better get down to that.
In the county that I represent, we are not at all satisfied with what the Government has done to make provision for fuel for the coming winter. I do not intend to go into that. But it seems to me that the Government is shelving responsibility to other bodies, and overcrowding other bodies with work, bodies that have been constituted to do a different kind of work from that which the Government is imposing upon them, instead of setting up their own machinery to meet the emergency created by the shortage of fuel, food and materials. I suppose I will be told that this is appropriate to the Department of Supplies. Our industries depend on the supply of raw materials. If I ask the Minister what is the position of industries which have to depend on imported raw materials, I dare say the Chair will point out that that is appropriate to the Department of Supplies. In discussing matters of such wide national importance, if we are to be hemmed in and not allowed to discuss supplies other than on the Vote for the Department of Supplies— which is only a child aged about a year or two, a child of the Department of Industry and Commerce—it will be very difficult to discuss intelligently the matters which come before this House; it certainly will be very difficult to discuss them comprehensively. I will accept the Minister's reassurance if he tells the House that there is no danger of a shortage of iron and steel for the foundries of this country. If there is no shortage of iron and steel, why are our foundries not put to work on producing parts for all the agricultural machinery we have in this country, imported as well as native produced? I am waiting for parts for a reaper and binder from America. Why can they not be made here? Why are we not producing the necessary parts for all the imported machinery which we have here? We are asked to produce food, and those parts are necessary if we are to produce it. Why does not the Minister see that those parts are made here? When a man goes out to cut 40 or 50 acres of wheat with a reaper and binder, he may not have been working for an hour when a vital part of the machinery is broken, and he cannot get it replaced here. Does the Government appreciate the difficulties which the people who are producing food are up against? If those difficulties are appreciated, the Government should see to it that, in the next five or six weeks before the harvest comes in, our foundries here will set to work on the making of those necessary parts.
I should be glad also to have an assurance from the Minister that we have an adequate supply of horse-shoeing iron. My information is that we have not, and that there will be a serious shortage in a short time. That is a very serious matter. There is an old proverb about the shoe being lost and the rider lost because a nail had not been tightened in the shoe. If the proverbial nail is not tightened in time, it may cause the loss of our neutrality in this world conflict. If we are to retain our independence and retain our neutrality, we must be self-supporting. The policy of self-sufficiency proclaimed by the Government is now on its trial. If it succeeds, the Minister and his Government will succeed. If it fails now, when it is on its trial, the Minister and the Government will fail through not having adequately developed that policy after having had nine years in which to do it.
Comment on this
I suppose it is intended to give the Minister this Vote to-night. It will not be possible then to deal extensively with the matters which have been raised here, particularly by one of the speakers on the Government side. We are getting away a little bit from that period in our history when we had two different policies to put before the country, and the events of the last 14 or 15 years have afforded us an opportunity of examining the results of the two policies which have been pursued. Judging by the results, that is by the facts of the case, we would be very much mistaken indeed if we were to take what Deputy Childers has said here to-night as representing anything like the true situation in the country. In the first place, we must consider what percentage of the people of this country are employed. According to the 1936 Census the total number of persons employed amounted to 45 per cent. Of that 45 per cent., 22 per cent. are engaged in agriculture, 7 per cent. are engaged as other producers, makers and repairers; transport and communications account for 2 per cent., and 14 per cent. are engaged on commercial, professional and other occupations. It is not by any means with a view to belittling the secondary industries of the country that I say that, so far as the secondary industries are concerned, the numbers employed represent one-third of those who are engaged in agriculture. It is obvious, on examination, that the policy which has been pursued here since 1932 has been one of absolute indifference to agriculture, and of hastening, regardless of the consequences, any sort of industrial activity, whether or not it was to the benefit of the country, or whether or not, in giving employment in one direction, the policy was going to put people out of occupation in another direction.
That disturbance which has taken place is responsible for the results as we can see them from an examination of the number of those who have been in occupation from 1927 to date. From the year 1927 to 1931, a period of five years, let us take a certain basis of calculation for the number of those in gainful occupation. In that regard, let us not misunderstand one another, because other figures could be quoted, and one could show different results from other returns. What I am giving is a calculation based upon the sum of money contributed annually in national health insurance. Taking that calculation as representing the number of persons employed, I find that the numbers paying national health insurance contributions increased by 57,000 in those five years from 1927 to 1931. An average of 11,400 additional persons were put into occupations every year. Let us now take the other side of the account, and see what has happened since 1932. From 1932 to 1939, the numbers amounted to only 9,375, a total of 75,000 persons in eight years. I am not taking this year, because it could be alleged that, by reason of the disturbances due to the emergency which has taken place, it would not be a fair comparison. The number has diminished by 11,000 this year, and that would affect that calculation very considerably indeed. Now it is a fact that, in so far as unemployment insurance contributions are concerned, only 27,000 persons were put into occupations in those five years from 1927 to 1931, whereas, for the eight years from 1932 up to 1939, 68,000 persons were put in—an average of 8,500, or 3,000 persons more annually. If that is so, 6,000 additional persons were, each year from 1927 to 1931, in occupations other than those covered by unemployment insurance, whereas the average under the new policy was only 875. Now, there are the two policies for you, as far as the results are concerned: that one concentrated upon a particular sphere of activity in the country, and that the other was directed on a more national basis, embracing all classes of the community and leaning, as far as it was possible to lean, towards the interests and the advantage of agriculture.
Now, it may be alleged that the circumstances of the period operated in favour of the policy that was pursued from 1927 to 1931. It may be. The Minister is perfectly entitled to make that case. During the industrial blizzard, as it was called, when, perhaps, never in the history of the world was there such a shock given to employment, to industry, to finance, and to every possible sphere of occupation that one could mention, as there was during those periods from the end of 1928 down to 1931 or 1932—when even the richest, or what was regarded as one of the richest, countries in the world, Great Britain, staggered off the gold standard, and we had not long to wait until even the United States, that had over £2,000,000,000 in gold, followed suit—surely it will not be denied that in these rather difficult years, 1927 to 1931, taking again into account what we had to pay for our agricultural imports, and paying for them out of our agricultural exports, we had in each of those years an average of almost £15,000,000 of an advantage to agriculture. We had an advantage of £15,000,000 annually, even in those bad years when the world was rocking from the effects of the economic blizzard.
We then got into a new policy in this country, a policy of self-sufficiency in which, amongst others, the farmers, agriculture, and all the rest of it, were to be helped. Let us take, over eight years, the corresponding figures of what was left from our agricultural export values after we had paid for our agricultural imports. The amount left was an average of £6,400,000. Does anybody, in his senses, think that it is likely that you are going to develop, improve, expand and extend the secondary arm when you have given such a paralytic blow to agriculture? That policy was pursued in direct opposition to the type of policy that had been pursued during the first ten years of the existence of this State, when there was selective protection, when moderate tariffs were imposed, when taxation was reduced, and when the burden and the weight of costs of production were decreased, as far as it was humanly possible to decrease them, upon our main industry, as a consequence of which more money was available to spend on the secondary industries of this country. The results of that policy at the time were reflected in the resiliency and buoyancy of the increased occupations that were made available for the people of this country.
We should be very glad if we could accept the optimistic views that have been expressed by one of the speakers on the Government side. Deputy Childers, but when we want to examine what has been the effect of this industrial efficiency of which the Deputy has spoken, over these few years, with a view to seeing to what extent we have developed an export trade, we have, again, to look in the books to see what the Government themselves have to say about the problem. Let us examine the figures for the period prior to this great industrial expansion, when, as some people would say, a policy of laissez faire was being adopted by the Government, and the figures for the succeeding period. The exports of industrial goods—I am leaving out now vehicles and parts, because there was a very big extension of the manufacture of vehicles and parts in Cork, principally tractor parts during a couple of those years, and it might be regarded as unfair if they were included—the exports of industrial goods, as I say, excluding exports of vehicles and parts, are as follows for the years 1927 to 1938:— 1927, £1,477,000; 1928, £1,762,000; 1929, £1,606,000; 1930, £1,356,000; 1931, £1,139,000; 1932, £993,000; 1933, £697,000; 1934, £675,000; 1935, £636,000; 1936, £630,000; 1937, £648,000, and 1938, £592,000. Now, these figures are from the Trade and Shipping Statistics, and they show that in 1938, at the peak of the industrial expansion that had taken place here, as we were told, the figures had fallen to £592,000. We are not engaged, at the present moment, in share pushing or anything of that sort, but merely dealing with the facts of the situation. Everybody would wish that our industrial exports had gone up by leaps and bounds, but the figures are there. They are the Government figures, and we cannot contradict them; they are not my figures.
The Minister has been a Minister for Finance as well as Minister for Industry and Commerce, and he has had experience during that period of the trend of taxation in this country and how, year after year, there were piled on industrialists, business people, agriculturists, and everybody else, the costs of production. He entered into possession of office here when we were raising something like £26,000,000 for running the country. We are spending, this year, £40,000,000. We are spending it: we are not raising so much, because we are going to borrow £5,000,000 of it, and we are putting over £8,000,000 of additional taxation on the people—apart from the fact that local taxation has gone up also—and getting into debt as well. Notwithstanding the fact, that, year after year, we have added to our national debt and piled on taxation on the people in order to give employment, what is the result? What has been the result of this policy of self-sufficiency? The result is that it has not been a success.
What I regret about it is this. Most of us have been here in public life 20 years, and we have got to leave it soon, because none of us will live for ever— and perhaps it is a good job for the country that we shall not—and we ought to be able to leave some headline for the future, some hope that things will improve in the future, that the faults and mistakes that were being made during the last 12 years will be remedied, and that we shall get away from this humbug of trying to mislead the people of this country by telling them that there is industrial expansion here when, as a matter of fact, our incidence of employment is going down. The previous Government was by no means a laissez faire Government. This Government, as Deputy O'Sullivan said, was a fairly lazy Government compared with the previous Government. One has only to examine the results to see what has been the effect of their policy. What is the use to us all of increasing and expanding industry in this country if the people are getting poorer, and if, as a result of that so-call industrial expansion, the incidence of employment is going to decrease?
Now, notwithstanding the fact that there was less money raised then, there was a very considerable amount of good work done in the country. We started the sugar beet industry. Deputies have stated that I had that established in my own constituency in order to sweeten my constituents there. I had nothing whatever to do with the selection of that site; it was a matter entirely for the company. But out of the taxation which was imposed, we contributed to the cost of working that particular industry: we did not make the consumers pay. It was done in order to meet a situation which this country, in common with all others, had to face at that time, namely, a drop in the price of cereals. That is one of the reasons why these figures were so favourable. The drop in the price of livestock and livestock products did not occur until later: the price of cereals, foodstuffs and other things fell first. Notwithstanding the fact that we handled less money, our net income was better by reason of it.
I have mentioned that the previous Government raised money and paid for the experiment of manufacturing sugar in this country and I want to put another matter to the Minister. I do not know what his views are about it. I intended to ask him in respect of an item here of £250 for a consultant in connection with steel production, whether anybody has been engaged; if not, when it is expected to make the appointment; and whether the consultant will be requested to report on the plant of Irish Steel, Limited, at Haulbowline. I have no particular interest in Cobh—it is not in my constituency—but there are certain towns in this country which, by reason of the changes which have taken place in the last 20 years, have been very severely hit, and Cobh is one of them. An effort ought to be made, even at the cost of putting up some money annually, to improve conditions in Cobh. It has been hit twice. First of all, by reason of the entry and exit of people, it was a place where a fairly considerable amount of money was put in circulation. Secondly, before the setting up of this State there was a considerable number of soldiers and sailors stationed there. It has lost all that.
I want to know whether the position with regard to these steelworks at Haulbowline is under the consideration of the Minister's Department. From the information at our disposal, it was at the behest, suggestion, or recommendation of the Government that these works were established. At present the works are in the hands of the courts. All I want from the Minister is information as to whether the matter has been examined with a view to seeing whether or not it would be advisable to keep the works going and whether an effort will be made to examine it favourably.
In conclusion, I should like to say to the Minister that he has had a special opportunity, by reason of his long association with the Department of Finance, to look at this industrial situation with different spectacles from those with which the Government have viewed it during the last ten years. We must get rid of this nonsense about the new factory that was making us richer when nobody knows but that it was responsible for the big fall in the number of those registered as being in employment other than those covered by unemployment insurance.
Comment on this
I want to direct the attention of the Minister and the House to a very serious matter about which I thought I would have heard a good deal from various speakers during this debate. I refer to the large number of people who are being engaged by employment agents from Great Britain. On Friday last, in my own town, almost 1,000 men signed up for work in Great Britain. These men are being driven out of the country in many cases by the aggressive attitude displayed by the Government in Emergency Powers (No. 83) Order. The Taoiseach last night told us that the people do not seem to realise the dangers that the country may be up against. He referred to the danger of external aggression. I speak with responsibility when I say that, to my mind, there is greater danger from this internal aggression which is being practised by a native Government through the medium of that order.
The need for an increased production of fuel has been stressed here. Everybody seems to be of the opinion —and I think there is good reason for it—that there will be definitely a fuel shortage in the coming winter. In my constituency we have the only coal mines of any capacity in the country, namely, the Castlecomer Collieries. I am informed that at least 40 of the miners employed there signed on with one of those agents on Friday last for work at coal production in Great Britain, because the Government here have denied them the right to obtain a small increase in their wages which has been long overdue. I want the Minister to tell the House, and to tell me for the information of my constituents, what the Government intend to do to deal with this very serious situation. In my opinion, it is a humbug to be preparing for national defence against external aggression while we allow this kind of aggression to be carried on with such serious effects as I have indicated, not only in regard to people who are unemployed but to people who are employed and who are leaving their employment to go to work elsewhere. I avail of this opportunity to bring that matter to the attention of the Minister and I hope there will be a satisfactory reply to it.
Comment on this
I am sensible of the fact that, perhaps, Deputy Cosgrave and other Deputies have been somewhat at a disadvantage owing to the understanding that we were to get this Vote to-night. I should like the indulgence of the House if I only refer to one or two or more important matters raised in the course of the debate. First of all, Deputy Benson referred to the fact that calcium alginates were produced from seaweed in Great Britain, and he wanted to know what we were doing here in regard to that matter. As he indicated, he has, in fact, been in consultation with my Department in regard to the matter, and he has also been in consultation with myself. I think on the last occasion upon which we met I pointed out that, while it was true that calcium alginates had been produced from seaweed in Great Britain and elsewhere on a commercial scale, the production is not large. The possibility of producing alginates here from seaweed is being examined in University College, Galway, under the auspices of the Industrial Research Council, but the greatest difficulty is being experienced in obtaining plant to produce these alginates upon any very extensive scale.
Deputy Hughes wanted to know what steps were going to be taken to develop the Clare phosphates. The position in relation to the Clare phosphates is this very briefly, that we have had very great difficulty in persuading the manufacturers of phosphatic manures that these phosphates are of some value. I think I gave figures in the House the other day to show that to meet normal requirements we would have to extract about 160,000 tons of material from the better of the phosphates there. Remember, there are two deposits of phosphates in Clare one of which is definitely inferior to the other. As was pointed out in the reply, of the better material we would require 162,000 tons and I am advised that there are not 162,000 tons of that material readily in sight. There may be considerable deposits, which are not readily discernible or accessible. But the deposits are in private hands, and it will be one of the fine tasks of the company which is in process of formation to ascertain upon what terms these phosphates can be secured and developed. The difficulties in the way there are going to be very great. They are going to be great because they are likely, as in the case of Slievardagh, and all other industrial developments in this country, to require plant and mechanical equipment of one sort or another which is hard to get.
I have been criticised this evening because I did not paint a glowing picture, because I did not expatiate upon the possibility of dealing successfully with the unemployment problem. I deliberately refrained from describing, as I might have done—and as Deputy Childers has manifested I could have done—the benefits which the Fianna Fáil policy has conferred upon this country, and the benefit this country has derived from the fact that there was here an earnest attempt to establish industries on a widespread scale during the past eight or nine years. I do not wish to go into the more controversial aspects of this matter, but I would like to relate anything I have to say to the difficulties of the immediate position, because we must realise what these difficulties are if we are going to stop such vain talk as I heard this evening; telling the people that this could be done, and that could be done, that we could have nitrogenous fertilisers, that we could have coal for suction gas producers, and could have petrol substitutes; in short, if it were not for the ineptitude, the incapacity and want of drive in this Government we would be in as entirely a satisfactory position as if there was no war in Europe, and as if we were not in the very centre of the battle of the Atlantic. The fact of the matter is, as I said in my opening statement, so far as procuring plant, mechanical equipment, certain essential raw materials, technical skill and even fuel, is concerned, it is virtually impossible to get any one of these things from outside this country.
Deputy Corish put a question to me as to whether supplies of steel and iron were likely to be available for the agricultural industry. My information with regard to that matter is this—and I do not want to talk too much about it —that so far as materials for the manufacture of agricultural machinery are concerned, there is no reason to fear any immediate shortage; that there are of these materials very substantial reserves. Because Deputy Corish referred to the fact that there was a shortage of steel and iron for the manufacture of agricultural equipment, Deputy Belton had to get up to make a statement charging the Minister and the Government with criminal negligence with regard to our supplies of steel and iron. What are the facts in relation to the Haulbowline industry of which we heard such a great deal? In the year 1937 a proposition was put up to the Department of Industry and Commerce, whereby the owner undertook to establish a comprehensive steel manufacturing plant in this country provided he secured fiscal protection. A company to do that was floated with something like £450,000 capital, which was estimated to be enough to build, equip and provide working capital for a comprehensive self-contained, steel-making plant.
In November, 1939, a proposal was put up to me that I should finance and guarantee an additional £250,000 for that company to enable it, not to complete the comprehensive, self-contained plant as outlined in the prospectus but to enable the company to change its production policy, and to enable it to complete some part only of the plant, which would still have left the undertaking dependent upon overseas supplies of raw materials. On examination of that proposal I refused to give that guarantee. A further proposal was submitted to me about February, 1940, which came to me ultimately in final form some time about May, 1940. The proposal this time was to complete the undertaking as originally projected and to provide a self-contained plant upon the basis of an additional expenditure of £660,000, of which the Minister for Industry and Commerce, with the sanction of the Minister for Finance, was to guarantee £500,000.
On examination I was not satisfied that we could get a self-contained plant for this additional expenditure of £660,000, of which I was to guarantee £500,000. I was not satisfied because of this fact, that the estimates were based on the assumption that the plant would be procurable from Great Britain when, in fact, at that stage, it was already clear that there would be the greatest possible difficulty in getting plant from Great Britain, and if plant was to be secured from America it would cost very much more. In any event, we may say now, that if it were possible to secure the necessary plant from America to complete the proposition project as originally put up, and to keep this undertaking going as it existed in May of last year, in my view it would have taken roughly £1,000,000, of which of course a considerable amount would have had to be paid in advance to the manufacturers of the plant.
What now are the practical difficulties apart from the financial difficulties which exist? I emphasised in introducing my Estimate the almost insuperable difficulties we are up against in procuring plant, and particularly plant of a specialised character. Steel-making plant, I have no doubt, would be very difficult to procure in America at present, but if we did succeed in procuring it, there is next the difficulty of shipping it and the difficulty of getting it erected here. Over and above those, there is what is the key difficulty in the whole matter-the difficulty of getting the necessary technical skill and competent management to ensure that this undertaking would fulfil the needs for which, in these circumstances, the Government would have to finance it.
I have been trying for quite a long time to secure competent advice in regard to this matter, and I may say that it is very difficult. I do not think I would be justified in guaranteeing the substantial capital which would be required to finance this undertaking, if I had to depend upon the advice and administrative capacity of those who have hitherto been associated with it. The undertaking has had to close, but it has had to close because, first of all, the original plans were not carried out and, secondly, because the original management, in my view, has not shown itself capable of running and developing this concern. Until such time as we can really assess the undertaking at its worth, until such time as we can get the technical and skilled experience which is necessary to operate the undertaking and until such time as we can be certain of getting delivery of the plant and getting it erected here, even after we pay for it, I cannot see, as a person who has to look at this matter realistically and as a person who has had some experience in matters of this sort, that we shall be able to resume the manufacture of iron and steel in this country.
There is no use in Deputy Hurley, Deputy Corry, or any other person, getting up here and trying to pull the wool over my eyes, or trying to lead the country to believe that, if only the Minister for Industry and Commerce would go to the Minister for Finance, and take £500,000 or so of the Irish people's money and put it into this venture, we would have iron and steel for our farmers to-morrow. We would have nothing of the sort. I am convinced of that, and I am as anxious and as concerned about the fact that the undertaking has closed down as any other person in the country. Having to say "no" in this case was a great responsibility to have to shoulder, but I am satisfied that if the whole facts of this case were before the people, there would not be one honest man to say me nay.
Comment on this
Put down a motion and see, if you feel like it. In what way is the information incorrect?
Comment on this
It would be better to leave things as they are, because I understand that a conference is to be held on next Monday night.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Hughes asked me what was the position in relation to the Slievardagh coalfield. The position in that respect is that we have the company formed, that we have secured, I think, a very competent board, after some difficulty, and that they are now mapping out their plans and endeavouring to secure the necessary plant and equipment. They have been enjoined to commence operations at the earliest possible date.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say what are the prospects of getting steel and iron for the foundries? The Minister has that matter in mind?
Comment on this
The Deputy was not in the House when I was dealing with that specific point, but my information in regard to both these matters is that the agricultural machinery firms are very well off for raw materials.
Comment on this
No. In fact, we have been pressing very strongly to get priority for iron and steel shipments.
Comment on this
As I say, we have been pressing to get priority for iron and steel. Deputy McGilligan raised two points, one of them in relation to the price of some woollen cloths. I no longer have responsibility for the control and regulation of prices. If the Deputy looks at the Estimate, he will see that the money there is required for the special purpose of the Prices Commission (Extension of Function) Act, 1938. That is the tribunal to which applications for reductions of tariffs under the 1938 agreement are referred, and it is only in that connection that we have any functions at all in relation to the Prices Commission. With regard to the other point the Deputy raised, as to a certain judge who holds a certain mineral lease, I do not think the Deputy would expect me to endorse what he has said in regard to the propriety or otherwise of that matter. After all, the conduct of a judge is a matter which falls within the purview of the Minister for Justice, and I do not wish, accordingly, to say anything in regard to some of the mild strictures the Deputy saw fit to make. The only thing I can say in that connection is that when the question of this lease was under consideration, the point was raised as to whether the person concerned could legitimately be refused a lease in the matter, and we were advised that there was no ground for doing so. Accordingly, as a prospecting lease had previously been granted, we could only implement what is the usual understanding, that is, that where a person has operated a prospecting lease and subsequently applies for a mineral lease, it shall be granted to him unless there are good reasons to the contrary. I might say, however, that I would prefer that that sort of thing did not arise again.
Deputy Hughes asked a question about the working of the outcrops in the Carlow coalfields. We can see no reason why private interests, having the ownership or being able to acquire the ownership of these outcrops, should not proceed to work them. I would deprecate the attention of the Slievardagh company being diverted from its main task of trying to get a substantial quantity of coal to these outcrops and minor workings, because I think they are going to have a difficult enough job to get the Slievardagh field going.
Deputy Morrissey asked me about the output of anthracite during the different years and why it was that we were estimating only on 100,000 tons. That 100,000 tons is from the Castlecomer field and represents a substantial increase over the output for 1940 and for 1939 and 1938. Since 1937 the output from Castlecomer has been declining somewhat. That is due to the more difficult conditions which are met with in that field periodically. When the miners are working up to the top of the seam, up on the slope, they can get the coal out more easily: when they get on the decline and start to work downwards it becomes more difficult and the output falls off. This year we are hoping to get an increase of almost 25 per cent. on the output of last year. With regard to the practicability of securing a greater output from that field, we have been pressing that on the proprietors of the field for a considerable period and, in fact, the output has risen from about 59,000 tons in 1926 to what we hope will be 100,000 tons this year. The conditions are somewhat difficult. Deputies who know the area understand that many of the miners have small farms as well; and I am advised that the amount of absenteeism which takes place in the Castlecomer mine is larger than is customary in similar fields in Great Britain. Men often take the day off to attend to farm work.
Comment on this
It has. Unless the wool is being pulled over my eyes— and I do not think Deputy Pattison is a coal miner any more than I am—where you have absenteeism on a fairly large scale as in Castlecomer, the output of the whole mine is lower.
Comment on this
Not merely that, but I verified that information for myself, as I had occasion to examine the wage sheets and attendance sheets over a period in the Castlecomer mine. I am advised that, if there were more constant attendance of the miners and if it were possible to get additional miners, the output could be expanded somewhat, though it might be very difficult to expand it considerably. When we talk of a deposit of 4,000,000 tons, we must remember that it is scattered over a wide area, that it is in seams varying from 15 inches to 18 inches in thickness.
Comment on this
I will come to that, too. The Deputy has stated that a considerable number of miners have been leaving the area for Great Britain. I do not know the basis for those allegations which we hear, here and there. The Deputy stated that 1,000 men had been signed on in Kilkenny by an employer's agent for Great Britain on Friday last. The last returns I had in regard to exit permits, for the month of May, showed—speaking from recollection and subject to correction—1,900 issued during May.
Comment on this
During the whole month of May, of the 1,900 persons who secured permits, about 1,100, drawn from all parts of Ireland, said they were going to Great Britain for employment. Others said they were going for other purposes. In fact, we were holding up cases, as we were anxious that the situation in relation to Irish people going to Great Britain should be definitely cleared up. We were holding up in Dublin a considerable number of applications for permits, where there were notifications that there were positions waiting for these people in Great Britain. We were doing that as we wanted the position of Irishmen going to Great Britain to be clarified, to ensure that they would be definitely immune from conscription and, if they were working on jobs there, that they would be entitled to compensation just as any British national working on a job, if by any mischance they were injured. The total number held up by us was only about 500.
Comment on this
I think they are in process of being secured.
On the export of scrap iron, from the Scrap Iron (Prohibition of Export) Order, issued last week, Deputy Corry deduces that there was no prohibition on the export previously, but the fact of the matter is that these orders are made periodically, and this happens to be the latest made. Previous exports were governed by other orders. In fact, the position has been that, from December 1940 to date, no licences have been issued for the export of scrap cast iron, as it was retained for Irish foundries.
Scrap steel and wrought iron exports were being licensed up to a few months ago, when a ban was imposed on exports. From the latter date, in view of the fact that there was a considerable amount of wrought steel for which there is no use here it has been necessary to issue licences for the export of scrap iron and steel, other than plates and rails of certain thicknesses and sizes which can be used here. The ban continues on the export of scrap iron.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the mining industry must be regarded as a key industry, what does the Minister propose to do to induce miners not to leave the country?
Comment on this
It has been pointed out to those miners and everybody else that an increase in their wages definitely means an increase in the price of coal and we cannot have that.
Comment on this
Question—"That the Vote be referred back for reconsideration"—put.
Do you agree with this result?