Committee on Finance. - Vote 69—Office of the Minister for Supplies (Resumed).
Contributions 1–213 of 421. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When dealing with this matter on the last evening, I stated that, in my opinion, this was one of the most serious Estimates this House would have to consider for a long period. The Minister for Supplies is responsible for the supply of all necessities to this country during a very trying period, the period of the war. He has to face the responsibility for seeing that the people of this country will have sufficient bread during that period. I warned the Minister the last day, and I repeat that warning now, that, in my opinion, from the knowledge that I have of the country, he will not get anything like 300,000 acres of wheat grown this year at 41/- per barrel—he has no hope of getting it.
Comment on this
The Minister is making provision in his Estimate for the extra cost of wheat, and I suggest that he is not, on the one hand, making sufficient provision, and, on the other hand, that the provision he is making is being spent in the wrong manner. The Minister states he is making provision for the import of something like 80,000 tons of wheat at his present figure of roughly about £33 per ton. I suggest to the Minister that, with world conditions as they are, he has very little hope of getting 80,000 tons of wheat across the Atlantic and, if he can bring in 80,000 tons of anything across the Atlantic, I suggest to him that it should not be wheat. I suggest that wheat can be grown here in sufficient quantity for this country's needs. We have proved it. We have worked on that policy ever since 1932. Now is the time to try out that policy. The Minister's 80,000 tons will cost about £2,500,000 landed here at £33 per ton.
Comment on this
I suggest that, in the Minister's position of responsibility for seeing that this nation has sufficient bread, he should take steps to see that the full quantity of wheat is grown at home; that he should consider the agricultural community in the same manner as he is considering the industrial side of it. If he does that, the agricultural community will supply him with sufficient wheat. The Minister stated here:—
"The total amount of commodities which all those ships, working at their fullest capacity, can bring in a year is very limited. Every ton of wheat which we bring in in excess of the minimum required to maintain the quantity of flour required by our people can only be imported by stopping something else and there are many other commodities, essential commodities, which are in such short supply that we must avail of these shipping facilities to bring them in."
I suggest that we can spare him 80,000 tons, which is the quantity he is budgeting for. I suggest further that, if the Government stick to their present proposal of 41/- per barrel for wheat in the coming season, he will want to budget, not for the import of 80,000, but 200,000 tons, and more perhaps. The position is too serious. I ask the Minister to look at it in the light of the seriousness of the situation. We grew 490,000 acres of wheat last year. The Minister said he expected to get 290,000 tons of wheat from the Irish wheat crop. But even that has not materialised. Out of 490,000 acres, he was not able to get 290,000 tons. He has got 170,000 tons, and perhaps he may get up to 200,000; but I doubt it. That shows that the yield this year and the situation of the Irish farmer who grew wheat were worse even than we thought. I budgeted myself on getting between 8½ and nine barrels per statute acre. I got six to the acre, and was lucky to get it. Some of my neighbours did not get six.
Comment on this
I got 50/- for wheat for seed and they were glad to buy it at that. If we are to work on the basis that every ton of shipping belonging to Irish Shipping Limited that can be spared should bring in something else besides what wheat is required, then I say to the Minister: "Let us have an economic price fixed for wheat this season." It would pay him better. He can afford to give up to 50/- per barrel for Irish wheat and lose nothing by it. In fact he would gain by it. He would gain to the extent of the foreign securities that have to be used for the foreign wheat, as against our own currency here. I suggest that it is nothing short of criminal lunacy in the middle of a war to start out on an economic fight for our daily bread. I say that frankly as one who made up his mind away back in other years that this country would not be caught out during the period of a war for want of sufficient wheat being grown here to supply our own people. I started out with that before my mind and, despite all the codology preached here by Deputy Dillon, we stuck to that. If this country to-day finds itself in the position that the greater portion of its requirements in wheat are grown in the country, it has to thank the Minister for Supplies and other Ministers like him. I want to give him praise for that; but I ask him now not to spoil it in the midst of a trial by expecting the agricultural community to do this year what, in my opinion, they will not do, and that is grow wheat at an uneconomic price.
Comment on this
I wish it were, but unfortunately I have found, with very bitter results, that it is not.
Comment on this
The Minister whose Vote we are considering now is the Minister who is responsible for seeing that we have sufficient supplies in this country. The responsibility rests on his shoulders, and I am suggesting to that Minister, who budgeted for 290,000 tons of wheat last year, and who states he has only got 170,000 tons out of 490,000 acres, that if he is going to ensure that this country will get a sufficient supply of wheat this year he will have to change his plan. Instead of spending £2,500,000 in trying to bring wheat across the water, he should use that money for the production of home-grown wheat here and see what the result will be. It is a far safer insurance policy than investing money in the hope of bringing anything across the water in the present condition of world affairs.
Every other class in the community is catered for. The agent, who never sees our wheat, who never bothers with our wheat, who only gets the cheque and passes it along to us, gets his commission. He is provided for. The miller is provided for. He gets 6 per cent on his shares. Every other class in the community is provided for except the man on whom dependence must be in the first instance, because if the farmer does not produce neither the miller nor the agent will have anything to get. I do not wish, nor do the farmers of this country wish, anything exorbitant. The farmers in this country last year were asked to make a sacrifice and they made it. They grew 490,000 acres of wheat at an uneconomic price.
Comment on this
It is certainly not fixed by the Minister for Supplies. While a passing reference may be allowed, a discussion on the price of cereals is not in order.
Comment on this
We are discussing here a subsidy for imported wheat and home-grown wheat, the subsidy being required to reduce the price to a certain limit. In dealing with that, the Minister made certain statements. He made a statement as to the quantity of Irish wheat he expected to get; as to the quantity of foreign wheat he intended importing and as to the subsidy he would have to pay on both. I am suggesting that it is absolutely in order on that to deal with the actual amount of Irish wheat which, in our opinion, the Minister will get, the steps he would require to take to get a sufficient supply and the foolishness, to my mind, of the Minister budgeting on a supposition that he will be able to bring any wheat from abroad.
Comment on this
In his submission to the Chair the Deputy has not even mentioned the price of wheat.
Comment on this
It should be quite clear to the Deputy that for the fixing of the price of wheat the Minister for Supplies is not responsible. To suggest to the Minister for Supplies. that the required quantity of wheat is not forthcoming because the price is not sufficiently high is permissible, but not a debate on the condition of the farmers or the growing of wheat generally.
Comment on this
The price of wheat is fixed, I understand, by the Executive Council and the Minister for Supplies has certainly the right to stand up and say: "I am afraid I will not get my supplies unless the price is right." I think I am appealing to the right man to see that the price is right.
Comment on this
Oh, no. I am going to support a fair price and not robbery. The farmers of this country do not wish me to support robbery. Deputy Bennett, who voted for the motion, did not make sure his own constituency would grow any wheat, either with or without a subsidy or price.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton made his speech and ought to be quite satisfied with it. I am dealing here with the position as I see it.
Comment on this
I would like to put the Deputy right this year so that he will not make the same mistake he made last year.
Comment on this
When I want Deputy Belton to put me right I will ask him. Up to the present I am confining myself to the two points that came before us, one is, the sending abroad, under the Minister's proposal, of £2,450,000 out of foreign securities to buy wheat and import it, as against the payment of roughly about £1,500,000, as I suggest, at home in order to see that the full quantity of wheat required for this country is grown here, which would mean that we would not be gambling on anything. I suggest that that should be the policy of the Minister. I am supporting the subsidy because, in my opinion, the burden of getting bread for the poor at the present day should be placed on the shoulders of those most able to bear it; but I am suggesting to the Minister that it would be far better for him, as the Minister responsible for seeing that our people have sufficient food, to see that the money is spent in producing sufficient supplies at home. If he wants to bring in anything to this country to-day let him bring in artificial manures, which would help us to get a decent result from our wheat crops. Let him devote the 80,000 tons of space that we are giving him—or a good deal of it—to artificial manures, and he will find it will pay both of us better. The difficulty, as I see it, is that the situation is too grave to gamble on bringing wheat from abroad. Deputy Belton asked me the other night if I were prepared to support Deputy Belton's price of 60/- a barrel. I am not prepared to support it. I do not think it is necessary to offer our farmers an inducement of 60/- a barrel in order to get them to grow sufficient wheat for our people. I do not think it is necessary.
Comment on this
That depends. I do not believe, for instance, that if you gave 80/- a barrel for wheat you would get the County Limerick farmers to grow sufficient for their own needs.
Comment on this
I believe the only thing that will get Deputy Bennett's farmers to grow it is compulsion—definite compulsion, and I would resort to compulsion in County Limerick so far as to take the land from them.
Comment on this
I do not wish to press the matter further. I just wished to put forward the case, as I saw it, to the Minister who, in my opinion, is responsible. That Minister, from 1932 onwards, from the moment we started out on a wheat policy, has been the one man who has shown the way and led the way and I ask him at this point, when the whole policy is on trial, not to spoil it. If he does succeed in bringing in 80,000 tons of wheat and if, at the same time, he has made provision for the growing in this country of all the wheat necessary for the supply of our people, there is not a man in this country who will not clap him on the back for it.
Comment on this
I do not. I do not believe there is any necessity for importing into this country anything that can be produced or made in it, even if we have to do with substitutes. I should prefer to see the people living on oatmeal than to import wheat for them, but there is no necessity for them to live on oatmeal, because there is plenty of land to grow sufficient wheat for the country's needs, not only for this year but for the next ten years, if the war should last that long, and I believe it almost will. I think it is absolute lunacy to depend on the importation of 80,000 tons of wheat and to set that out as a definite policy for the next 12 months, because, with the Yankee coming into the war and the Japs also coming in, I see very little hope of bringing any of that wheat in. Whatever else we say we must do without, let us not say that we will run any risk in relation to the provision of sufficient bread for our people.
Comment on this
When an Estimate of this size, marking a departure in regard to policy and involving so many different sets of figures is introduced here, one would have expected that the Minister would have provided us with a White Paper in connection with it. It is not easy to decide to which of the various figures he gave us the Minister is pinning himself down. Let us take one example. He has said that 370,000 tons of wheat are required to supply the country with flour and bread, and then we have the Minister's statement that we must import one-fifth of that amount. Is the Minister altering his figure of 80,000 tons to be imported to 74,000 tons, or is it that it is merely an approximate 20 per cent.? We are informed that very careful steps are being taken, and that various checks are being provided, to ensure that correct accounts will be kept in this matter, and, almost in the same breath, we are told that when the Minister is in a fix in relation to dealing with the flour problem and the shipping problem, he goes outside and gets in business men to help him. The experts, I suppose, are within and the specialists are without.
We have different figures for the price of flour and for the price of wheat. In one case, there is what is called the allocation price. Presumably, that is the price at which this new body which the Minister has set up is going to issue wheat to the millers. This wheat in one case is stated by the Minister to have been purchased at 15/- per barrel, and having supplied the Dáil with an estimated price for the quarter, of 120/-, we find that the price of this wheat which is to be imported this year will be 70/- per barrel. If the sum of 15/- is paid for it and it is to cost 70/-, it is obvious that the transit charges and other expenses amount to 55/- per barrel, or £22 per ton. May we ask in all seriousness if that is a correct figure? If so, I think the experts ought to be changed, or some alteration made in the whole procedure. £22 a ton for transit charges, freight and insurance!
Comment on this
Some of them are much higher. The transit charges on a large quantity of the wheat will be much higher than that.
Comment on this
Can we get any information as to why there should be such a difference as to make it necessary to take an average?
Comment on this
Even if it did, it means the addition of only another couple of miles. Does that cause the very much higher figure?
Comment on this
The Deputy will understand that it has to be discharged, stored and reloaded in Lisbon, and that involves a substantial difference in the cost.
Comment on this
In that case, we have the most extravagant and most expensive way of getting it across that we can have. All we are concerned with is getting it across—the price does not matter. If the Minister were in business, he would have another view with regard to that. It is one of the disadvantages of this problem that there is not a single business man or man with business knowledge of any sort or kind amongest the Ministers, and their advisers are in the same position. The Civil Service is exactly the same.
Comment on this
If we had not brought it through Lisbon, there would have been weeks during which the Deputy would have had no bread.
Comment on this
Perhaps, and that notwithstanding the fact that we have a Department of External Affairs which, for years, knew exactly what the situation in the country was, and that we had a Minister for Industry and Commerce who should have been informed of that situation, in which he could buy wheat at one-third of the price of 15/- per barrel, but he did not stock it. Even when he was in Ottawa, he could have learned from Mr. Bennett, the then Canadian Prime Minister, of the drop there had been in the price of wheat over a few years at that time.
Comment on this
We stored a very large number of tons, despite the opposition of the Deputy and his Party who protested strongly against our doing so.
Comment on this
I tell the Minister that he stored, at the best or worst, not two months' supply of anything.
Comment on this
It was, several times. The Dáil was lectured by the Minister in connection with this business of a subsidy. If we wanted to select lecturers to give us lectures on morality, philosophy, economy or anything else, we would not approach the Government for them.
Comment on this
Or on dangers, either. The Minister lectured the farmers and told them of the serious steps that were going to be taken in the event of their using wheat for feeding stuffs. Let us put the farmer's side of the question. He gets 16/- per cwt. for the wheat he grows himself. What is he asked to pay for feeding stuff of a much lesser value? At least 6/-, possibly 7/- and maybe 10/- more. Is the Minister aware of that? Is he aware of the difficulty the farmer has in buying any feeding stuffs, if he has not grown them himself. In this year, whether the Minister is aware of it or not, the yield per acre is down, the price of feeding stuffs is up and the costs of threshing and all the other operations are higher than ever they were, and are increasing. The suggestion made by Deputy Corry, if he understood it, was probably a fairly sound one. The Minister informed us that we would import 80,000 tons of wheat. He gave us a price of 120/- for 480 lbs. which is 70/- a barrel. It is made up of 15/- a barrel, the cost of the wheat to the producer, and 55/- freight and other charges. The wheat would cost, on this calculation, £480,000, and the transit and other charges £1,760,000, making a total of £2,240,000.
Taking that figure with the figure which the Minister supplied us with, the price which it is expected the Irish wheat will cost, the average all-in price is about 54/- a barrel—that is on the basis of 46/9, not the 40/-. That would probably admit of an extra 5/- or 6/- a barrel for wheat in this country, if it were all to be grown here, although it is nonsense to be talking about it in the way that Deputy Corry did. There is no use in growing wheat that will only yield three or four barrels to the acre. No man will do that unless he is prepared to run a big loss as well as injure his land. When the Minister talked about stocks of wheat he obviously had in mind the possibility of a war at that time, but what did he do about manures then? What is going to be done about manures now? The better policy in this case, the one which would be more satisfactory from practically every angle, would be to save that 80,000 tons of shipping space and grow wheat here. I doubt very much if it is an attractive proposition at the price. It certainly is not a sound proposition in the absence of manures.
My final point is that the Dáil is entitled to a White Paper on this whole matter. I do not think it has been properly presented to the House at all. The House is entitled to something more than lectures from the Minister about the danger of this policy. We know all about that. He has been engaged in this matter of subsidies over the last ten years. That has not tended to improve the country in any respect. It has been responsible for a smaller number of persons being put into employment than was the case before he became Minister. His industrial push was all bosh. Whatever advantage was in it was at the expense of other forms of employment. In connection with the guaranteed 6 per cent. on the money that is invested, what exactly is meant by the money that has been invested? I have looked up the particulars of one company, and I find that there are 5/- shares quoted at 15/-. I am informed that in the prospectus the 5/- shares were sold at 15/- to the public. This particular company for a number of years paid 20 per cent. on those 15/- shares.
Comment on this
It is in relation to the Minister's speech in which he said that a guaranteed 6 per cent. is to be paid to the millers——
Comment on this
——in respect of their profits out of this transaction. I will get the relevant extract.
Comment on this
What did the Minister say? I do not wish to misquote him at all. If he wishes to intervene now he can do so. What did he say? Did the Minister say that he was providing, in connection with this business, that the flour millers would not get more than 6 per cent. on the money that was invested? The Minister said:
"In other words I am allowing nothing for any possible increase in the cost of production or for any change in the remuneration of the milling industry, which is 6 per cent. on the capital employed in the industry as a whole."
As I have said, I have not seen the balance sheets of this particular company. I was supplied with a stock exchange card which gave particulars showing that this company paid 20 per cent. from the year 1934, in which it was incorporated, up to 1939. Last year it paid 16? per cent. Now 6 per cent., on the basis of 15/- being paid for the 5/- shares, would, I presume, be 6? per cent. It would be 18 per cent. against 20.
Comment on this
I made it clear that in calculating the capital invested in the flour-milling industry no regard was had to the issued capital of the companies at all, but regard was had to the capital value of the equipment employed in flour milling.
Comment on this
I am not interested in what the Minister said or in what he is saying now. I am saying that this company, from the year 1934 when it was incorporated, two years after the Minister came into office, paid 20 per cent. per annum on 5/- shares which were being quoted at 15/-, and that in 1940 it went down to 16? per cent. That, roughly, would be 5 per cent. Were the profits to be regulated in connection with this scheme at 18 per cent?
Comment on this
There is a subsidy to be given. The Minister speaks here of 6 per cent. on the capital employed on the industry as a whole. Are there some companies to get more than that, and others less?
Comment on this
I am putting a simple question to the Minister in connection with the flotation of that particular company in which the 5/- shares were sold at 15/-. In this case, are the millers' profits for this year going to be based on 18 per cent. on the 5/- shares, or are they to be 6 per cent.?
Comment on this
Obviously, the Deputy does not understand the matter yet. I explained that we fixed the price for flour, and that in doing so we had to have regard for the capital invested in the flour-milling industry as a whole, and on the basis of allowing a remuneration of 6 per cent. on the capital invested the price was fixed. It may be that companies operating in the flour-milling industry on that basis will make no profit at all.
Comment on this
On all the money invested. One person invested his money at 5/-, and another at 15/-.
Comment on this
If the Minister does not want to give the information or if he wants to mislead the House, let him say so. If he purports to give the information, let him give it to us exactly.
Comment on this
The Deputy understands the difference between issued capital and the capital actually invested in the production of a particular commodity. It is on the capital invested in the production of flour that the fixed price is based.
Comment on this
If a premium is paid on a share, is it the premium price that is counted or the rock-bottom price? Does the Minister mean that the carry-forward and reserve funds are included? They are still in the business. Does the Minister include or exclude them?
Comment on this
It frequently happens that a company has a much smaller issued capital than invested capital. If the profits are re-invested in a company, the invested capital will be larger than the issued capital. In some cases the reverse happens. In flour milling most of the companies are engaged in other businesses than the production of flour. The price is related to the capital invested in the production of flour.
Comment on this
I want to know whether the capital on which the Minister proposes to calculate is represented by the premium price of the shares?
Comment on this
I presume the Minister refers to the cost of that portion of the buildings and that part of the machinery used in the manufacture of flour?
Comment on this
The Minister has apportioned the value of the buildings and machinery in the possession and ownership of the flour millers?
Comment on this
I did not do it personally, and I do not want to take the credit for it, but it was done.
Comment on this
The amount we are asked to vote under this sub-head— £550,000—is very substantial. It represents a contemplated annual expenditure of £1,900,000. That is an extremely large figure for any particular object. When I saw in the Press some days ago a statement by the Minister that it was intended to subsidise the price of flour to the extent of, approximately, £2,000,000 for the current year, I, in common with, I am sure, a very large part of the population of this country, expected that a full and ample explanation would be given, so as to enable the public to appreciate the necessity for the expenditure of this sum. I sat here and listened carefully to everything the Minister said in connection with this matter. I do think that, in the presentation of this Estimate to the House, there was a great lack of clarity because of the different units mentioned. Reference was made to quarters, sacks, tons and barrels. It was only by sitting down and very carefully parsing and analysing the Ministerial statement, as it appears in the Official Report, that I was able exactly to discover the case the Minister was making. It may be that I am not as intelligent as the bulk of the population, but it certainly required not only my presence here, but careful analysis of the printed statement, to discover the case made by the Minister.
The people, generally, believe that this sum is being voted for the sole purpose of subsidising the millers. It was stated by the Minister that the sum is required for the purpose of ensuring that the price to be paid for bread will be fixed. In other words, the Minister regards it as an insurance against an increase in the price of the loaf. The public believe—on a careful analysis of the Minister's statement, I do not think that anything will be found to disabuse their minds in this respect—that this sum is not so much an insurance aimed at controlling and keeping within certain limits the price of the loaf as an insurance that the pet industry will not suffer a single penny of loss as a result of the emergency through which we are passing. That is the general opinion in the country. I searched the three daily papers—including the Government organ, the Irish Press—and read what they had to say on the subject, and I could discover nothing in those papers which put any other interpretation on the Minister's statement. In a matter of this kind, where a large sum of money is involved, I think the Minister should have made the position much clearer than he did. I shall pay the Minister this tribute, if I may, that he is a splendid advocate in a bad case.
Comment on this
I am not departing from that view. I regard this sum with intense suspicion. The Minister marshalled his facts in such a way as to put a face on the case for spending this money but he did not disabuse the minds of a number of people of the idea that the money was more intended to benefit the milling industry than to benefit the people of the country in respect of the price of the loaf.
I am not acquainted with any of the directors, not even with the names, of Grain Importers, Limited, but I agree with the Minister that it is a splendid thing that people should come forward and offer their services voluntarily for the purpose of helping the general good. I quite agree that they should not be attacked for doing so, but I do not think they deserve any particular credit for the action they have taken in this matter. After all, they represent a committee of a certain trade or industry, and they are ensuring that they will get adequate supplies of their own raw material at a price which will involve them in no loss. In any industry, any profession or any occupation a group of people would gladly form an association, and give their services voluntarily in their particular occupations if, in the times we are living in, they were assured of a supply of raw materials. That is the position of these people.
My criticism is chiefly directed towards seeing that the Minister approaches this question, not from the point of view of benefiting one section of the community, but for the general good. The figures which he quoted reveal a very serious state of affairs. The importation of wheat will be reduced from 50 per cent. to 20 per cent. The importation on the Minister's figures will be 30 per cent. less for the year we are now discussing than the previous year. Yet, in spite of that, the additional cost will be £1,200,000. I accept the Minister's figures. They disclose a very serious state of affairs. The bulk of the amount, he pointed out, will represent freight and transport. The whole object, I think, underlying the Minister's activities in this direction was to look after the millers. I am not saying that in a critical sense, but that appears to be the arrangement. Speaking in this House last week the Minister, at column 598 of the Official Debates, when referring to the price the millers would have to pay for home-grown wheat said:—
"The average price paid to the farmer will be 40/6. Allowances in respect of sacks, agents' commission and drying costs will remain unchanged, but the 10 per cent. loss on drying will involve a higher figure because of the higher price. Consequently, although the guaranteed price to farmers was increased by 5/-, the actual cost of dried wheat to the millers will be increased by 6/-."
There is not a single aspect of the millers' problem, in the purchase of wheat from the grower, that has not been dealt with there, in case it was possible that through a contingency they might suffer a loss. How different is that from the way the grower, the person who in the first instance is responsible for the production of wheat, is treated. Accepting the Minister's figures, and assuming that this sum of money is to be spent for this particular purpose in order to stabilise the price of the loaf, I think the Minister and the Government would be very much better advised to divert portion of that sum towards ensuring that bigger and better crops of wheat will be grown, and in that way encourage farmers to produce more wheat at home, with the knowledge that such encouragement is necessary. I know that it is not within the province of this discussion to deal with the fixed price of wheat, and I do not intend to do so, but it is perfectly obvious that with the Department of Agriculture, and all the resources of the State, some other way should be found to increase the quantity of wheat, and to have it available at a certain price rather than to be paying this large subsidy to the millers. If the subsidy was directed in a different direction, something on the basis that exists in England and Northern Ireland of £2 to the acre or something like that, the Minister would find that there would be a very much better return, and that it would not be necessary to come to this House to ask for this extraordinarily large sum of money.
The country believes that the millers are the pets of the Government. I do not know whether that is so, but having listened to the Minister, and read his speech he had no word of sympathy whatever and no word of encouragement for the growers. Everything was for those persons who buy the wheat. The whole idea was to put the millers here in a favourable position. In an agricultural community like this it is up to the Minister to give a better explanation than he has given. It may be that the view I take is entirely wrong, and that this enormous subsidy is necessary, but I do not think that 99 per cent. of the people realise or approve of the action taken. I certainly did not realise it, and I did not appreciate it. I believe there are other ways in which the money could be spent for the purpose of producing a cheap loaf, and for that reason I intend to oppose this proposal.
Comment on this
I believe we all agree that the paramount consideration of every Deputy is to ensure that bread is available for our people, particularly for our poor people, during the present year, at a price that will not exceed the present price. Whether the method that has been adopted by the Minister to secure that object is the best method is a matter that I very seriously question. I think the method adopted to subsidise bread and flour as adumbrated by the Minister is a highly complicated method and one that leaves itself open to very grave abuse. It will require very drastic inspection and supervision that will prove very costly to the State. Notwithstanding drastic supervision, I am satisfied that many people will find loopholes in this scheme, at all events dishonest people, and I am afraid we are not free from that type in this country. They will be able to net something to which they are not entitled. It will be very difficult to arrange. The Minister suggests that he is not prepared to pay a subsidy on fancy bread made on premises where that bread is produced in conjunction with batch bread. I feel that that is a method of handling this situation that undoubtedly leaves itself open to the danger of being abused. We got numerous figures from the Minister when he was dealing with this question, and the estimated production from native sources this year was 290,000 tons.
If you take it that that is the production of 490,000 acres, and that the Minister is banking on that for seed for next year for approximately 600,000 acres of wheat, which would require about 400,000 barrels, and that a considerable quantity must be retained by farmers for their own household purposes, it appears to me that the Minister has calculated on a yield this year of at least about seven barrels to the statute acre. From my experience as a farmer, I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that the average yield this year will prove to be far less than seven barrels—I think you could not put it higher than six barrels—to the acre. The Minister told us that, so far, that expectation has not borne fruit, that up to the present date not more than 170,000 tons out of the 290,000 tons estimated has reached the millers; so that that figure alone of what has reached the millers at present, will indicate to the Minister that he cannot possibly base his calculation on a return of 290,000 tons from native sources.
It is a well-known fact that there is a very substantial drop in the yield this year, that we had a bad year and lack of sunshine, and that there was a rather serious shortage in artificial manures. On that account, many people who grew wheat this year are very disappointed with the result. In face of that situation, there is an announcement of a price of 41/- for the coming year. The Minister has been advised by many Deputies already— and notably by a Deputy from his own benches, Deputy Corry, who is a practical farmer—that the result of a price offer of 41/- for the coming year will be a serious falling off in the amount of land under wheat cultivation. I must say that I am in complete agreement with Deputy Corry on that point. Taking the price of foreign imported wheat and all the chances and risks that are involved, the cost of importing it and also paying on that a subsidy —as the Minister has told us—of £2, it appears to me that the course he is asking the House to agree to now shows that the producers in this country are being treated in a very shabby way.
The Minister has based his calculation first on the chance of importing 80,000 tons of foreign wheat in the teeth of a U-boat menace, although he has informed the House that quite recently cargoes of wheat have cost as high as 84/-. The Minister has not made it clear to the House how he can hope to reduce that figure of 84/- a barrel to 70/-. Possibly it is by means of direct shipment, and that the 84/- wheat was shipped through Lisbon and that the handling charges there have driven the price up to 84/-. The fact remains that any imported wheat we can secure at the present time—after running all the risks of war—is going to cost us £3 10s. In face of that figure, the position is that we are now offered a price which amounts to only 1/- increase over last year, notwithstanding the fact that the position with regard to the supply of artificial manure is very serious for the Irish farmer. Undoubtedly, we had a considerable reduction in the amount of artificial manure available for the production of wheat last year and that reacted very unfavourably on the yield. I ask the Minister, if that was the position last year, what will it be next year, in view of the present supply of artificial manure—or what we are told it is likely to be for the coming year?
Comment on this
Are not these questions for the Minister for Agriculture? I have a recollection of their being minutely debated on the Estimate of the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
If the Deputy were present, he would remember that Deputy Corry had to depart from that subject.
Comment on this
There is no objection to a Deputy suggesting an alternative to giving subsidies, but there is objection to a discussion on artificial manures and the fixing of a price for wheat, for which the Minister is not responsible.
Comment on this
I wish to support the alternative that a price offer should be made sufficiently attractive to induce our own people to produce our own supplies.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that it will affect it. Undoubtedly, if a better price had been paid for this year's wheat, it would have affected the subsidy this year, as it would reduce the amount required still further. The price offered this year of 40/- was not sufficiently attractive to induce enough people to put land under cultivation, to produce 100 per cent. of our requirements. Undoubtedly that would affect the subsidy this year. The Minister was informed on this point when numerous Deputies expressed the view —on more than one occasion here—that he should not allow the same position to obtain in the future, as it will be even much worse next year.
The present position is that the farmer has to sell his wheat at £16 a ton as human food. If he is feeding many animals and requires animal food, he cannot replace that at the present time at £16 a ton, or at anything like that figure, nor can he get any animal food at all at anything like £16 a ton. There is the risk that wheat may be used for animal feeding, notwithstanding the fact that the Minister has warned and threatened people that severe penalties will be inflicted on anyone making use of wheat for animal feeding. As an alternative to that, I believe it is a very good suggestion that some of whatever shipping is available should be used for the importation of artificial manures, if agriculture is to be kept going.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned a figure of £36 a ton. How is it that there is a considerable quantity of nitrogenous manure available in the "black" market at £25 a ton? Will the Minister answer that?
Comment on this
I am talking about the price of bringing manures in on ships from the United States.
Comment on this
The price of sulphate of ammonia in England is ten guineas, with a certain rebate, as much as £1 a ton early in the year. Every English farmer is stocked up; he has all his requirements of sulphate of ammonia. He was appealed to to take early deliveries. Imperial Chemicals had large stocks of sulphate of ammonia and they were anxious to unload these stocks, because the place might get bombed at any time, and the English farmers were asked to take early deliveries. There was an inducement offered to them of a rebate of £1 per ton. The price in June and July was £9 10s. a ton. There was plenty of sulphate of ammonia available. There is any amount of it coming over the Border at £25 a ton. It is available to Northern Ireland farmers at ten guineas a ton, less a rebate of £1. The Minister states that that could not be bought.
Comment on this
On the question of artificial manures, will the Minister indicate what type of artificial manure could be obtained from America?
Comment on this
Has the Minister made any attempt to get concentrated manures here, manures that would correspond to I.C.I.? Is he aware that Imperial Chemicals have made a highly-concentrated manure known as I.C.I., one cwt. of which would correspond to six cwts. of ordinary compound manure? That is the type of artificial manure he ought to try to secure, in view of the fact that shipping charges are so high. If it is possible to get a highly-concentrated manure of that sort, the freight charge of £22 per ton on it would be relatively less than on a low-grade manure.
Comment on this
You are getting ships to carry 80,000 tons of wheat. Our suggestion is that provision ought to be made for the importation of manures.
Comment on this
I feel this whole situation could have been better handled. We are paying out money that could have been kept at home to help our own people, particularly our farmers. Out of the amount that is being made available now by the House, you certainly could pay much more on the wheat that was produced this year. The home production has been very disappointing. The financial return to the producer is uneconomic and it is bound to have a very bad effect on future production, unless there is a very substantial increase in the price the Government are prepared to fix.
Comment on this
This Estimate is one of great importance to the country, inasmuch as it is intended to enable flour and bread to be provided for our people at a price which they can pay. One great worry in the minds of Deputies is that a very large percentage of the money which is being provided will give a very inadequate return. Much of this money will be spent subsidising the importation of wheat. In that way, it will be spent on freight charges that are excessive. It will be spent in connection with ships which are not value for the money paid for them, and much of the money will find its way into the pockets of speculators and profiteers who are out to take advantage of the abnormal situation that exists.
Every Deputy will agree that it is a shame and a pity that all this money could not be held in the country and eventually be put into circulation amongst our farmers and other agricultural workers in the production of wheat. Everyone admits that there was slackness in the effort to secure the 100 per cent. wheat requirements of this country last year. In the first place, there was failure to stress at the proper time the need for an increased supply of wheat. Secondly, there was failure to provide an adequate price, a price which would induce farmers to cultivate the necessary acreage of wheat. It is our duty to ask if any real effort is being made to secure our requirements for the coming year. Two of the most important months of the year, from the point of view of wheat production, have passed. The cultivation of land for wheat growing should begin in September.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister for Agriculture deal with the cultivation of land for wheat growing? I have a recollection of the Deputy and other Deputies holding him responsible in that regard.
Comment on this
I regret to say that many people have come to regard the Minister for Agriculture as being wholly incompetent for the job which he is called upon to perform, and they are looking to the Minister for Supplies to take him by the hand——
Comment on this
——and make some effort, at least, to induce him to deliver the goods in the coming year. The Minister for Supplies has a tremendous task placed on his shoulders and people would be inclined to sympathise with him if they were satisfied that he was making a reasonable effort to deliver the goods. So far as wheat is concerned, the people are not satisfied that a reasonable effort is being made. We are not satisfied that the acreage necessary for the coming year has been ploughed and is being sown.
Comment on this
Having failed to offer the inducement which is absolutely necessary if we are to secure a supply of wheat adequate for our needs, the Minister is now forced to provide a subsidy to pay for imported wheat at the rate of 84/- per barrel. Now, surely it is not good business, it is not sound business to offer to pay such a price for imported wheat when it is possible, when it is within our means, to provide the home supply. There is in this country, first of all, sufficient land to grow all the wheat we require for our needs. There is, in addition, I think, sufficient seed within the country to seed that land for the coming year. Those two things are available, and even though, having regard to the shortage of artificial manures, it is necessary to plant a greatly increased acreage in order to provide our needs for the coming year, there is still sufficient land and sufficient seed available to ensure that we will in the future, or should in the future, be independent of imported wheat. Yet we find that time is passing and no reasonable effort is being made to offer the necessary inducement to farmers and to take the necessary steps to ensure that wheat will be cultivated.
An offer of an increase of 1/- a barrel for wheat is simply insulting the potential grower, putting him off wheat altogether, and making him feel that those in charge, and having on their shoulders the responsibility for providing this country with a food supply, have absolutely no sense of responsibility and do not seem to care whether the necessary food is provided in this country or not. It makes it appear to the plain people that the Government prefer to sink the taxpayers' money in the Atlantic Ocean rather than pay the farmer and the agricultural worker for the production of wheat. Deputy Esmonde suggested that it would be a good policy for the Government to provide a subsidy per acre for wheat grown in this country. I do not think that that is sound. I think the Government should pay for the article or the commodity produced, but I think it would have been a good policy—it certainly would have been a good policy, and I think the Government will realise it—to have offered some special inducement to growers to plant autumn wheat, even by giving a small bounty on wheat sown during the autumn months. By so doing we would have ensured that a greatly increased acreage would have been put under wheat instead of having to rely on a shorter period for growing wheat in the Spring.
These considerations are of vital importance to the people of Ireland and they should be of vital importance to the Government and to the Government Party. The importance of this question does not seem to be indicated by the attendance of the Government Party in the House at the moment, but I am sure that within the private meetings of the Party the question is getting consideration and anxious thought, and I hope the Government even now, though it is somewhat late, in order to secure the maximum production of wheat that could be secured, will mend their hand in regard to the price of wheat and offer a substantial increase which will make it unnecessary in the future to provide a subsidy on imported wheat.
The most startling fact which was brought to light by the Minister in his opening statement was the fact that only 170,000 tons of wheat have been delivered so far to the millers. That seems to indicate that the yield for the present year has been abnormally low, lower perhaps than most people are aware of, because it must be certain that the bulk of the season's wheat crop has been already delivered to the millers, and if the yield is so low it is certain that a tremendous effort will have to be made to secure the production in the coming year of even the inadequate quantity which was produced during the present year, and so far as we can see no effort has yet been made to face up to this problem. Some time ago, the Minister for Agriculture informed me, in reply to a question which I asked, that he did not know what the acreage of arable land in this country is. Yet we have the Government making estimates of the necessary amount of compulsory tillage required, and so on, without any facts upon which to base these estimates. We have the position also that the Minister—and he made it clear to me, in reply to a question—does not know what is the cost of producing wheat in this country. These are two essential facts upon which the Government of an agricultural country, apparently, have no reliable information. They are in much the same position as a blind man in a black-out: they are groping about trying to find some means of solving problems as they arise but have no knowledge on which to base calculations for the future. Now, I think that the Government of an agricultural country should know exactly what it costs to produce cereal crops, that the Government of this country should base the price of such cereals upon the cost of production, leaving a decent margin of profit, and that in addition to that they should know exactly how much arable land is available in this country. If they did that, we would not be called upon now, as we are to-day, to provide this enormous subsidy upon imported wheat. I hope that even now the Minister for Supplies, who is believed to be a man of energy, will take the Minister for Agriculture to task and insist upon his providing the necessary wheat for the coming year and providing it by the simple means of offering the producer an economic price.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy get back to the Estimate? He has been dealing so far with the cost of production, the development of agriculture and the price of grain, none of which comes in under this Estimate at all.
Comment on this
I am afraid, Sir, that all these matters have been extensively debated up to the present, but I do not intend to dwell further upon them. There is also in the Estimate provision for a subsidy on bread, and I should like to ask the Minister for Supplies whether he is satisfied that the people, and particularly the people who are dependent solely upon plain or batch bread, are getting a product which is as good as could be produced out of the materials available? I am satisfied that over a very large part of the country the bread provided is not as good as that which could be provided. This may be due to the fact that the bakers have not adjusted their equipment to the production of bread from the present type of flour. At any rate, there is certainly a very great difference between the bread produced in some parts of the country and that produced in other parts, and I think it is a question to which the Minister should direct some attention. I was told of a workman's wife who, having purchased some loaves of bread and some sods of turf, both of emergency quality, unfortunately made the mistake of putting the turf on the table and putting the bread into the fire, but she hardly noticed the difference. There is certainly considerable waste of this very essential commodity, flour, due, I believe, to the fact that in many cases the bakers have not the necessary equipment or for some other reason are not producing bread which can be used economically.
I would not mention this matter except for the fact that there are other bakers who are producing quite good bread, and it is obvious that there must be something wrong somewhere. I am not putting the entire blame on the fact that the present extraction is too high. I think if the Minister were to inquire into this matter he might have it adjusted. I would appeal to the Minister for Supplies, who has this important duty of keeping the country going, to ensure that in the future the very limited shipping space which we have available will be used for the importation to this country of really essential commodities. It may be possible to secure artificial manures, and, if it is, all available shipping space should be devoted to that purpose. There is an abundance of other materials used in the manufacture of home-produced commodities for which shipping space is urgently needed, and to which it could be devoted if the Government were to adopt even now a vigorous and progressive policy in securing our 100 per cent. of home-produced wheat.
Comment on this
The last speaker described this as an enormous Estimate. Undoubtedly, it is for a very large sum, £1,900,000, but the trouble is that we are not quite sure that it is sufficient. It seems to me that the House will be faced with a further Supplementary Estimate for this very purpose. So far as I can understand, this sum is based upon 290,000 tons of Irish wheat finding its way into the mills of this country. The Minister told us last week that, so far, 170,000 tons are in the stores, and he expressed the hope that the other 120,000 tons would come in to be ground by the millers. I think that was a very optimistic hope. I think that, at the very end of the grain season, it is too much to expect that there are 120,000 tons of wheat in this country still to be purchased. I think anybody who knows anything at all about the wheat situation here will agree that that is, to say the least of it, very unlikely.
So far as I am concerned, my main interest in this matter, my primary interest, if you like, is to see the price of flour and the price of bread stabilised. If this £1,900,000 is essential for that purpose, and if it is to be used exclusively for that purpose. I do not believe anybody in this House will object to it. There are really two aspects to this question; one, the stabilisation of the price of flour and bread, and secondly, an economic price for home-grown wheat to the farmer. Deputies, I think, with reason, have said that the Government should have offered greater financial inducement to the farming community to grow more wheat. I should like to say, with all respect to the Deputies who have spoken, and most of whom have greater knowledge of this matter than I have that it is not altogether a question of financial inducement. So far as certain farms in this country are concerned, no financial inducement that could be offered would get economic wheat growing. Deputy Cogan, I think, was right when he said that one of the Minister's biggest problems in equalising the price of home-grown and imported wheat, and in arriving at an estimate, whether it is £1,900,000 or £2,500,000, is the fact that home-grown flour is not available to the millers to the extent that we expected. One of the reasons for that is unquestionably the fact that the yield of wheat this year is down anything from 20 per cent. to 25 per cent.; certain authorities in this country have put it as high as 33 per cent. Coupled with that, you have the fact that this year more farmers than ever have kept wheat for themselves, and even those who always kept a certain amount of wheat for their own use have kept a far greater amount this year.
I should like to take the opportunity of saying here and now, reinforcing, if I may, the statement made by the last speaker, that the great danger is that we are facing a cereal year when the shortage is going to be even far greater than it is this year. I have heard with regret dozens of farmers—I think I might say, without being accused of exaggeration, hundreds of farmers— saying at the end of this harvest, when their crops were gathered and threshed and ready for sale, that they would not grow wheat again next year, or that if they did, they certainly would not grow it to the same extent as they have grown it this year. I think that is to be deplored. There are two reasons for it. One is the low yield this year, and the other is that they realise that they are facing a new cereal year with probably only one-third or perhaps only one-fourth of last year's artificial manures available. Of course, every practical man in the country realises that it is almost impossible to grow wheat, or certainly to get any sort of decent return on wheat, without artificial manure, although the leader writer of the Irish Press pushed it aside a few days ago and said that artificial manures were unnecessary.
If you go and ask any farmer in any part of the country—I do not care what his political views are, or which newspaper he reads, or whether he reads any newspaper at all—whether he thinks artificial manures are unnecessary for the growing of crops here, particularly beet and wheat, he will very soon give you an answer. There are certain lands in this country that will grow wheat—perhaps a fairly decent crop of wheat, and perhaps even two crops of wheat—without the aid of artificial manures. I am talking at the moment about some of the most intensely cultivated parts of this country where they have always tilled and grown wheat, but it is impossible in places where the soil is light to grow crops of wheat without artificial manures.
Without desiring to widen the discussion in any way I say that three main points present themselves to me. Firstly, there is the question whether we have any chance of getting in the 290,000 tons of wheat we should get, according to the Minister, this year. That will depend on whether this estimate is sufficient, and I doubt it very much. Secondly, the question arises— and in passing may I say that it is a matter of tremendous importance and urgency?—whether adequate steps are now being taken to see that we shall not be called upon for a far greater subsidy in respect of the next cereal year. Thirdly, if the Minister can convince the House that this sum of money or even a larger sum is essential for the stabilisation of the price of flour or wheat, I think he will get the House behind him provided he assures us that it is used exclusively for that purpose. Fourthly, I should like to know whether the Government have satisfied themselves that 41/- is a fair price for the farmer, and is it the highest price they can afford to give. These are very important matters and now is the time, this very month, to settle them definitely as the best part of the year for the preparation of the ground for growing wheat is practically over. Every day we lose now is storing up for our people very hard times in regard to flour and bread for the next 12 months. These are the points that present themselves to my mind, and I do not want at this stage to deal with any other aspect of this Estimate.
Comment on this
The country seems to be getting by easy stages to a system of rationing for the entire population, and I just want to make a few remarks as to why rationing is necessary. I feel that one of the reasons is to be found in the policy of the Government in the past. In many cases only one manufacturer was allowed to accumulate raw materials, as against a stocking-up by the entire distributing trade. In other cases regulations were made by the Prices Commission that rendered the holding of supplies unremunerative for the distributor. I know the Minister does not agree with me in that.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the subsidisation of flour and rationing. I merely refer to it in passing as one of the problems that has aggravated the position. Nobody suggests that we could, by any process of stocking-up, have got the country over the war period, but we are now coming to the most important stage of this country's supplies. Supplies are getting scarcer in the one market where we can get any goods. I was rather disappointed that the Minister did not seize this opportunity to give us some idea of what the policy of the Government is going to be. I should like to suggest to him that the alternative facing the Government is: are they going to take the duty off some supplies which can now be got or will they wait to remove the duties until these supplies have disappeared? Again, I should like to ask the Minister if when removing these duties he can see his way to give any forecast as to the period for which the duties will be removed, whether it will be for the duration of the war, or the duration of the war plus a certain postwar period. The Minister has spoken about this subsidy that is to be given to flour.
Comment on this
Another question that arises is, what is the population that will consume that flour during the coming year? Naturally, the first thing that the people require is something to eat and I think bread is a primary commodity. I do not see how the Government, therefore, could avoid some system of subsidising bread, but at the present time it appears as if this country were faced with a total stoppage of almost all essential supplies in the very near future. I should like the Minister to give us his views on that question. Surely the Minister should be able to give some indication to the country as to the materials that are running short? As an instance of what I am referring to, petrol became very short.
Comment on this
I quite agree, but the question of rationing is involved and I am merely using the case of petrol to illustrate my argument. Petrol became very short and people turned to gas. Of course, there is no gas in this Estimate either, but I might point out that a lot of people installed gas-bags on their cars when the petrol shortage arose. Soon afterwards it transpired that they would not be given any gas for the bags. That is a procedure I should like to see reversed. I should like the Minister to have told these people that there was no use in installing gas-bags on their cars because they would not be given any gas. I think that if the Minister could give a lead to the country by way of telling the people in future what they should or should not install, his time would be well spent. I should have liked the Minister to have availed of the opportunity to give us a forecast over a wider field than the flour position because there are other people who have their problems as well as the Government.
Comment on this
One serious fact which this Estimate has elicited is that there is a very alarming wheat position in the country to-day, because, although we are now in the middle of November, the Minister has told us that there are approximately only 170,000 tons of wheat in and that we still require to get in 120,000 tons, which, with the 80,000 tons which it is intended to import, will probably carry us up to the next harvest. But I, with other Deputies, have grave fears that, in the middle of November, you are not likely to get in another 120,000 tons of wheat and I think the sooner the Minister realises that the better, rather than that the country should be treated again to the shock tactics——
Comment on this
The Minister always misses tides and then asks people to explain to him why he did not see them flowing.
Comment on this
The Minister received a deputation from this Party in September, 1939, and was then advised to buy ships. He was told then that small nations in Europe had extensive mercantile marines and ships that could be bought. The Minister did not realise then the necessity for ships, but he woke up in 1941 when he could not buy ships except at a fancy price, and when the area of belligerency had so extended as not to give the Minister any choice whatever in the type of ships available for purchase.
Comment on this
I will come to your question. The Minister asks now what should he do. We had a Department of Supplies, or were supposed to have a Department of Supplies, 18 months before the outbreak of the war. We had all kinds of declarations here——
Comment on this
We were told that there was not merely a shadow Department of Supplies but an actual Department of Supplies in operation before the war commenced, and the Minister was supposed to be a kind of one-man brains trust who was thinking and planning for the dark days of shortage which the war would probably herald. Then the war broke out and there was considerable commercial activity between nations for a considerable period, although the war was on. Then the commercial activity was interrupted suddenly by events on the Continent. We found it difficult to import commodities and discovered that the Department of Supplies, which was to do all the planning and all the storing had, at most, a few weeks' supply stored away and no more. The moment the relations between nations broke down, owing to the events of the war, then we were pretty well in the position of a beleaguered nation. We ought to have thought in 1939 of the necessity for growing a full wheat harvest, sufficient to provide our people with an all-Irish loaf and an all-white loaf. Of course, nothing was done in that matter until last November when the flour importers discovered that they could not charter ships to take grain here. Then the Minister for Agriculture was released on the country to urge farmers to grow wheat at all costs and, of course, we go the inadequate results that are visible to everybody this year.
We are told that the acreage under wheat was 490,000. Apparently, all we hope to get out of the 490,000 acres is 290,000 tons of wheat, showing, at all events, a very small yield. Of course, if the Minister went through the country he would realise from what he would hear from farmers that the yield all over the country has been uniformly low; so low, in fact, that, as Deputy Morrissey rightly pointed out, many farmers will abandon wheat growing this year and go in for growing oats and barley in preference to the growing of wheat. Before the Minister is many months older, he will be able to get returns of the acreage under wheat which will indicate a veering away from the production of wheat to the production of other cereals which are calculated to give a better yield on the soil available for growing them and less risk from the standpoint of the farmer growing the cereals. I suggest to the Minister that that position has got to be faced and that he ought not, in the middle of next year, come to the House, as he had to come so often before, to tell us of another difficulty that has arisen, because this difficulty can be overcome now if the Government will only think and plan. It can be overcome if the Government will insist, in respect of each suitable holding, on a minimum acerage of wheat, and at the same time give the farmer a price for the wheat which will ensure that he is encouraged to sow wheat and that he is kept in the production of wheat for the use and benefit of our people.
Apart from the question of the now inevitable shortage of wheat supplies for the current cereal year, I have grave doubts about the wisdom of this Estimate, and I have more doubts as to the generoús way in which this House, in present circumstances, is treating the millers of the country. According to the Minister's statement a sum of £1,900,000 is to be shovelled out to the millers, and the bakers in order that they will not get too envious, are to get £80,000 as well. When you think, in these circumstances, of millers getting a subsidy to that substantial extent and of bakers getting a subsidy of £80,000 and contrast that treatment, on the one hand, with the provisions of Emergency Powers (No. 83) Order on the other hand, one thing that strikes you immediately is that, apparently, the miller or baker is to get what he likes from the Government, but, as regards the worker, the best treatment the Government can give him is to peg down his wages to a low level while doing absolutely nothing to control prices. We were told by the Minister for Finance and by various members of the Government that the Government had decided to set its face against any class in the community getting compensation for the increased cost of living. The millers apparently walk in and present a demand to the Minister and are now being offered a cheque in the name of the House for £1,900,000.
Comment on this
They will not get 1d. of it. Deputy Norton does show signs of intelligence once in a while.
Comment on this
The Minister has not developed the symptoms of intelligence, not to speak of signs of intelligence.
Comment on this
Whether it is Joseph or James, the Minister knows very well that he can manage to ring the changes on the Government that came into office to put him out of the country.
Comment on this
There was a day when the Minister used to say it but, of course, we have seen the road back. We have seen the road back on flour milling, as we have seen it on nationalisation of transport and various other things. The point I want to make, Sir, is that we have in the country a relatively small number of millers and a small number of bakers. They can walk into the Government and get a subsidy of approximately £2,000,000 as compensation for their increased costs.
Comment on this
Will the Minister read the case he made for granting the bakers the £80,000? Will the Minister read the case?
Comment on this
A small number of people are able to come in and get a subsidy of approximately £2,000,000 while the Minister, on the other hand, refuses to allow workers to get any compensation whatever for the increase in the cost of living so far as it affects them. The Minister tried to explain to the House why these gentlemen are treated in this lavish fashion whilst he reserves for the workers, apparently, the bitterest hostility in respect of wages that he could manifest. The workers' wages are to be pegged down to a low level. They dare not get an increase. The greatest sweating employer in the country, if he wanted to wipe out sins of low wages committed in the past, would not be permitted to do it under Emergency Order No. 83. That is the treatment reserved for the workers. He virtually throws £2,000,000 at the millers in this country and the Minister imagines he is conferring a public benefit on the nation by treating that monopoly in this generous fashion.
The most striking part of the Minister's statement was his admission that he asked 1,000 provincial bakers to send him copies of their certified accounts and that out of the 1,000 people communicated with only one provincial baker sent him a certified copy of his accounts. Notwithstanding the fact that he had not got a certified copy of the accounts of these 1,000 bakers, the Minister intimates that he is nevertheless going to give them a subsidy of £80,000. What information was the Minister looking for when he asked for the certified accounts? Information, presumably, as to the financial position of the firms in question and their rate of profit or loss. What information has the Minister now about that position if he did not get a certified copy of the accounts from the firms?
Comment on this
It is all set out in column 613 of the Official Debates. The Deputy did not understand.
Comment on this
I read it all. The Minister said he got one reply from a provincial baker. The 999 simply put out their tongue at him and would not furnish him with any certified accounts. The Minister says: "Nevertheless, let me give this fraternity £80,000 as a subsidy towards their increased costs," although the Minister has not got from the firms in question the information which he felt was necessary when he asked them for these certified returns. I would like to know on what grounds the Minister attempts to justify the payment of a subsidy to bakers. There may be a case. We have not heard the case. The Minister talked about costs increasing. I have seen reports of firms in the Press and they do not appear to be doing too badly in these difficult times. But, of course, the gentleman marauder in the whole milling industry is the miller because that gentleman has plucked and salted the community with impunity for many years past and, by reason of the fact that he possesses a State milling licence, he is apparently put now in such a privileged position that not only can he legally continue to salt the public but he is now advanced even further; he is now entitled to come to the House and say: "Notwithstanding the fact that you gave me a milling licence, please also write a cheque for £1,900,000."
I heard the other day of a gentleman in the flour-milling industry who was appointed at a salary of £7,000 and he subsequently had the salary increased to £10,000. Fancy £10,000 being paid to a gentleman in the flour-milling industry out of bread and flour sold in the main to poor people in this country. That is the type of firm for which we are writing this cheque for £1,900,000.
Comment on this
The Deputy need not do it. He can vote against it. The Deputy should vote against it. By this time 12 months he will deny he ever did it.
Comment on this
That is a prophecy. It is on record, too. This time 12 months the Deputy will deny he voted against the subsidy on flour.
Comment on this
The Minister poses as a prophet. This is a subsidy on millers' profits, according to the Minister's own words.
Comment on this
The Minister poses as a prophet. There is another type of profit that Mr. Rank is interested in, that is the £1,900,000 that the Minister is going to ladle out to him now in a very generous fashion.
Comment on this
Every time I told the Deputy he was making a political mistake it came true. He is making one now.
Comment on this
Let us examine this flour milling industry in the hope that we may unmask to the public, notwithstanding Press censorship——
Comment on this
——some of the things that happen in respect of monopolies. I hope I will not annoy the Minister by reference to Mr. Rank and I do not want to conjure up any ghosts of the Minister's past speeches about the gentleman but everybody knows that Rank came into the country and bought up the interests of any mill he could get, and bought them for the purpose of closing them. He originally did that in order that he could flood this country with flour. Then the Government changed and Rank changed. Then the Government changed again to conform with Rank but Rank floated a company consisting, I think, of a group of other companies that he bought up. He released, I think, in 6 per cent. preference shares, £700,000.