Committee on Finance. - Vote 69—Office of the Minister for Supplies (Resumed).
Contributions 214–421 of 421. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
——to the Irish people but they were released at 15/- a share and Mr. Rank, whom this Government was going to drive out of this country so that he would not be the octopus in the flour milling industry, was permitted to do that by this Government while this Government was in office, after the Minister had finished his fire-eating speeches about Rank. All that was done by a firm that is now getting a very substantial slice of this £1,900,000. I regard that as racketeering. I regard that as simply swindling the public and making exorbitant profits out of the vital needs of the people.
Comment on this
Rank is able to float these shares at 15/- because our people eat bread and because our people want flour. He is, apparently, allowed to do that, which is a most dishonest form of gambling because there is no element of loss or probability of loss in it so far as Rank is concerned. It is downright racketeering, downright plundering of the people, to permit a firm to get away with that type of financial welshing on the needs of our community in respect of bread and flour. These millers have been given a monopoly by the State—a milling licence. That is their goodwill. We created their goodwill by giving them a milling licence. That is the only goodwill they have and that is the thing that entrenches them to-day. We gave them a licence to deal in the most vital need of our people, namely, flour, a commodity which has become still more vital because of the circumstances under which we live. I have very grave doubts if it is good national policy to give a subsidy of £1,900,000 to a monopoly which is in private hands.
Comment on this
And I think on an invested capital of about £7,000,000— which is not bad either. Flour in present circumstances is a vital necessity for our people and having regard to all we know about flour milling and having regard to what we know has gone on in respect of flour milling and having regard to the exorbitant profits which were made out of the milling of flour, I do not think that we should continue to allow this monopoly, in present circumstances, to rest in private hands.
It seems to me that what the State ought to do, having regard to the conditions with which we are now faced, is to take over the mills and operate them as nationally-owned institutions, administer them not for the purpose of issuing shares, or for the purpose of paying salaries of £10,000 a year, but for the purpose of producing flour at the cheapest possible price and making the provision of flour for the people the overwhelming consideration of their milling policy. At present the millers think of one thing, that is, the making of the highest possible profit, and they are sufficiently well organised and have sufficient financial resources to be able, according to this Estimate, to shake the Government any time they choose to do so; but, in present circumstances, it seems to me to be very undesirable that a private monopoly of this kind should be given this gigantic sum of money. I should very much prefer that the State itself would take over the flour mills and operate them under national ownership, basing their policy on the production of flour at the cheapest possible price. So far as we here are concerned, we are in favour of any practical policy which will keep bread prices low and which will keep flour prices low.
Comment on this
The way in which that can best be done is by the State taking over and operating the flour mills on a non-profit—making basis. Does it not seem absurd that we should pass through this House the Shannon Electricity Act, which prevents any profit being made out of the generation and sale of electric light, while we give a free field to the flour millers to make any profit they can get away with in respect of flour, a still more vital commodity?
Comment on this
It is fixed at a price which enables the millers to become the new rich of this country.
Comment on this
Does the Minister deny that when Ranks were issuing their 5/- shares at 15/-, they said as the reason for looking for 15/-, that a profit of about 30 per cent. would be earned?
Comment on this
The Deputy said that we were allowing the flour millers to charge any price they liked. That is not true.
Comment on this
I did not say any price, but any price which will pay the flour miller generously. Is that not the position to-day? The people who are getting rich are the flour millers. The mass of the people may have their standard of living depressed, but if you want to get rich you have to be a flour miller or a bacon curer, and then you have a passport to a kind of Eldorado under this Government. My quarrel with this Estimate is not in respect of the amount of it, but in respect of the purpose for which the money is being used. It is being used for the purpose of subsidising the millers, and I should prefer to see that money kept in the pockets of the State and to see the State breaking from the policy of the past, taking over these flour mills, especially in existing circumstances, and operating them for the purpose of providing cheap flour for the people, instead of huge profits for the millers.
Comment on this
So far as the debate has gone, it certainly will not ease the minds of the traders or the people who have to procure bread in the counties along the Border. I had two telephone messages this morning before I left home saying that they still had not got an adequate amount of flour. They have got most of their quota for the month, but, owing to the amount of flour which has come in illegally during the past three months, the people have not got sufficient for their requirements. There has been a good deal of discussion about this sum of almost £2,000,000 and about where it is going. Deputies say that it is going in one direction, and the Minister says that it is going in another direction.
I wonder did the Minister consider whether it would be better to give a subsidy to the millers or to give it, as Deputy Esmonde has suggested, to the farmers? If the Minister would take the trouble of finding out what it would cost to pay for these 370,000 tons of wheat required and dividing that sum into the £2,000,000 which he proposes to give to the millers, he would find that it would represent about £5 a ton. To approach it from the other angle, it is estimated that we have about 490,000 acres of land which might be developed for this purpose, and dividing that into the £2,000,000 which he proposes to give to the millers, we find that it works out about £4 an acre. If some of this money were given to the farmers, it would be an inducement to them to grow wheat because they will not grow wheat at the present prices. Even people who are not engaged in the agricultural industry realise that wheat cannot be grown year after year, or even in the space of two or three years, without a great quantity of artificial manures. This year, unfortunately, we cannot get artificial manures. We were able to get a certain amount last year by ways and means which will not be available this year, and something should be done, and done immediately, to give the farmer a subsidy or some increase in price—let it be paid by the acre or by the ton, and I think the weight system would probably be the better— because winter wheat sown later than October is not nearly as good as winter wheat sown in that month.
A terrific amount of money was spent last year on advertisements encouraging farmers to grow wheat up to January and into February. Some of the Ministers went through the country in February and said: "There is still time to grow wheat." That is not so. It is impossible to grow winter wheat at that time of the year. Some Deputy asked a question as to the cost of these advertisements and we were told the figure. It was a huge amount, but anyone in the habit of growing wheat realises that there is a difference of tons between wheat sown in October and wheat sown in January. The longer it is left unsown, the worse it is, and unless a move is made immediately, there is no hope of getting the wheat required. There is another item which you, Sir, will probably permit me to refer to, although it is not exactly relevant to the Estimate, that is, the matter of tea.
Comment on this
We are not discussing tea. The Deputy must confine himself to the subsidy in respect of flour and bread.
Comment on this
We always seem to be wrangling over sops of one kind or another here, and it is unfortunate that we can never get the Minister to view things correctly. He always seems to stick his heels in the ground and to do practically as he likes. We have now a glorious opportunity of showing the world that we can produce our own food and live by the hands of our agriculturists, but have we the manliness to do it? We find ourselves in a position in which practically £2,000,000 are to given away. And who are the people who are to get this money? The millers and some importers, while the very people who can and will produce the food, the farmers, are to get nothing. If the producer is not given a better price for the wheat that he grows than he got last year, then everyone knows we are not going to get half of last year's acreage grown for the reason that his costs of production are so heavy. The Government and all concerned should realise that. Now is the time for sowing winter wheat, but the fact is that very little of it has been sown except in a few areas of the country. I come from what might be described as a ranch county, in which there is a great deal of virgin soil. There very little winter wheat is being sown. The farmers will not be encouraged to sow it until the Government offer them a decent price for it. If that situation is allowed to go on, it may very well land this country in a desperate position. We may be faced with famine, so, therefore, I would urge on the Government to offer a decent price to the farmers and encourage them to grow all the wheat that will be needed to feed the people. What is wrong that we cannot afford to pay a decent price to the man who is ready to produce food for the people?
Comment on this
The point that I am trying to make is that, in my opinion, this subsidy is being wasted. A subsidy is going to be paid to the millers, but I think it is the producers who should get it, the men who kept this country in safety last year. They can be relied on to do the same next year if they get a fair deal. I agree that we can produce all the wheat we need. Of course, it is only in a time of emergency that such a thing will be done, because when the war is over you will have wheat being landed here from many far away parts of the world. In that case our farmers will go out of wheat production, but we do not want that to happen this year. We want them to stick their heels in the ground and to produce all the wheat possible. Growing wheat year after year on the same land means that you get a diminished return per acre. To produce wheat properly you must have adequate supplies of manures and fertilisers. We are not likely to have either this year. Therefore, the only incentive to the farmer to grow more wheat this year is to offer him a decent price.
I agree with Deputy Belton, Deputy Corry and other Deputies who have said that to offer anything less than £3 a barrel for wheat will not get the farmer to produce it. I know, of course, that in a time of emergency our farmers will do the right thing, but the Government should not be tinkering with this thing. They should go out boldly and offer a price that will encourage farmers to produce. Otherwise the country may be faced with starvation and we may have to appeal to outside powers to help us out of our difficulty. We should not be put in that position. It is now in the power of the Government to do the right thing, to take the necessary steps to stave off any fear of starvation in the coming year. If immediate steps are not taken by the Government the winter wheat, which gives a good return, will not be sown. Farmers will put off sowing it and will wait until the spring. We all know that winter wheat is desperately hard on land: that it takes years to bring back that land to a good condition. The farmers are the people who can deliver the goods and it is they who should get the subsidy. If the tillage undertaken last year had been carried out in a proper way a subsidy of perhaps £1,000,000 would be sufficient. In the county that I come from I saw tens and tens of thousands of barrels of wheat lying rotting on the land. It was not that the people could not overtake the work but rather that proper care was not exercised in the saving of the crop. In some places we had very big landholders who tilled hundreds of acres of land, not because they loved to do it——
Comment on this
What connection has that with a Supplementary Estimate for the Department of Supplies?
Comment on this
I want to show that £1,000,000 of this subsidy could be saved if the crop last year had been properly harvested, and if there had been more supervision of some of the people who tilled large areas of their land. A lot of them put in the crop and then let it take pot luck. In a number of cases I saw cattle and birds eating the crop, and there was no attempt made to save it at all, although Providence had blessed us with a bountiful crop which should have been saved to meet the needs of the people. I do not know where all the inspectors were. They seemed to be very anxious to get the land tilled, but when it came to saving the crop the inspectors were not to be seen at all.
Comment on this
I do not know which Department they belonged to. In future, when we force people to till their land I think we should take steps to see that they deliver the goods.
Comment on this
If I cannot develop that I have not much more to say. In conclusion, I ask the Government to do the manly thing now, and not leave it too late, by giving a good price to the producer. Let them forget about the flour millers and the importers, and let the subsidy go to the farmers.
Comment on this
I have listened for almost two days to the misrepresentation of the Opposition led by that stalwart of wheat growing in this country, our friend Deputy Dillon, and to other members from the opposite side who have spoken on this Estimate. What they have been really doing is this: making a case for a reduction in the price that the farmer should get at the present time. Everyone of them knows quite well that it is a good "cant" to get going in the country—probably good ammunition for propaganda purposes—to say that the Government are paying the millers £2,000,000 of a subsidy. If they go out on public platforms and say that it will go all right. It is quite a good "cant". Deputy Dillon should go down the country with it immediately. If he thinks he can get away with it, I am sure he will. But Deputy Dillon and the other Deputies know quite well that this sum of almost £2,000,000 is being paid to enable the people of this country to get bread at the price they got it at last year.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon and the other Deputies opposite who have spoken also know quite well that if this sum of almost £2,000,000 were not paid, one of two things would have to happen: either that bread would go up in price, or that the farmers would get from 5/- to 10/- a barrel less for their wheat.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not interrupt me. Last year he spent almost a day speaking on this. We have been listening to the Mad-hatter of the Fine Gael Party speaking on this matter.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon has been the leader of a campaign against any wheat growing in this country. If he had his way, and if the people minded him, they would be starving to-day because they would have no bread. That would be their position if Deputy Dillon had got away with the campaign which he has been carrying on for the last ten years. Fortunately for the country, Deputy Dillon had no influence amongst the people of the country and never will. That, at least, is certain. He knows quite well, and other Deputies know, too, that the price of the loaf of bread and of flour would have to be increased substantially as a result of paying farmers 40/- for their wheat and also because a certain amount of hard wheat had to be imported at an exorbitant price from abroad. Those are the two reasons why this £2,000,000 has to be paid this year to keep the price of bread to the poor at the level at which it has been since the war started.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton, who dare not go into the Lobby against this Vote, indulged in cheap penny-ha'-penny criticism on the level of what has come from Deputy Dillon. He spoke about millers' profits and Rank's 5/-shares selling for 15/-. I doubt if Deputy Dillon will contradict the statement that Guinness's £1 shares went up to almost £7 some years ago.
Comment on this
I got up to protest against the campaign being carried on by the Opposition. Deputies on the opposite have no less responsibility than Deputies on this side. They have a responsibility to the people to lead and guide them and tell them the truth.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen, in his cross little outburst, told us that either the price of wheat would have to be reduced or the price of bread would have to go up. I wondered at his saying that.
Comment on this
We have been told that a miller made 21 per cent. profit. Is there not plenty of room there? There is no use in comparing the profits of Guinness or the price of Guinness's shares with the millers' position. Guinness has not a monopoly, and so far as I know, were never subsidised by the Government.
Comment on this
The millers have had a monopoly for quite a number of years and they are being presented with a subsidy.
Comment on this
It is just as dishonest as Deputy Allen's suggested alternative to say, as was suggested in the Minister's speech, that 6 per cent. is the correct profit. Everybody knows that that is not correct. This is going to prevent the miller from ever getting less than 6 per cent.
Comment on this
I do not think that I interrupted Deputy Allen. From beginning to end of his introductory speech on this Estimate, the Minister was defending the millers, apart from the price or the subsidy.
Comment on this
I read it in the report. Everybody knows that since 1932 the most stalwart defenders of the millers has been Deputy Corry. He is the man who stood up for the millers from beginning to end.
Comment on this
He is the man whose greatest grievance was that somebody was going to make profit out of the millers because he cornered some wheat before them.
Comment on this
Regarding the distribution of flour, I do not agree that one point made by the Minister is correct —that 90 per cent. of complaints regarding shortages in the rural areas were attributable to the traders concerned "trying to get something out of it". The suggestion is that, in rural areas, traders were getting a reasonably level supply of flour from the millers and that they were holding this up and not giving it to the consumers. That is not so and I defy the Minister or anybody else to prove it. It is not correct that millers were delivering to traders—particularly, small traders—in the rural districts a reasonably level supply of flour. Some traders always got flour but others could not get it. In the case of one large milling industry—the Minister referred to this —one half of a county got very little flour for a period and the other half of the county got a good supply. That was simply because the commercial traveller for one half of the county was able to secure supplies for his customers.
Comment on this
My information from a baker is that it happened in County Cork. When the Minister asks parish councils and similar bodies to investigate complaints about flour shortages before sending them up to him, how does he expect them to do it? The ordinary consumer goes into a shop in a village where he has been buying his flour all his life and he is told he cannot get flour. According to the Minister, that is the fault of the trader. I say that is not so. If the Minister was satisfied that the shortage was being created artificially by the trader, is it not strange that we did not hear anything about it until he introduced this Estimate? If the Minister is allowing traders to get away with the creation of artificial shortages in flour, it is a scandalous situation. I say that the shortage is not the fault of the smaller traders. They are absolutely at the mercy of the millers and the Minister knows that.
The most serious feature of the whole situation—one which was referred to by a number of Deputies—is that regarding the 120,000 tons of wheat which have not got into the mills to be turned into flour. The subsidy in this Estimate is not going to bring in those 120,000 tons of wheat. I should like to hear from the Minister how he proposes to get in those 120,000 tons because it is obvious that, if they are not got in, there will be a 50 per cent. shortage of the wheat necessary to provide flour up to the next harvest. That is more serious than most people realise. If that be the position, drastic measures will have to be taken to deal with it. There is a suggestion in the country that certain people are using wheat for animal consumption. In present circumstances, that is a shocking crime. I doubt if that practice is widespread but, if it is happening at all, it is a shocking crime against the people. If 120,000 tons of wheat are unlikely to be turned into flour, it is the most serious revelation made since the present emergency. I find it hard to visualise what will happen if that wheat is not got in. The subsidy under this Estimate will not have the slightest effect in bringing it in. It will not offer the slightest inducement to bring it in. A number of Deputies in talking about an increased price for wheat—whether it be justified or not— may be doing a lot of damage. If the Government feel that they should offer an increased price to get that wheat in, let them offer it now, but let not an atmosphere be created in which certain people will think that they will get an increased price, and accordingly, hold up the wheat with a view to getting it.
I am afraid that is what is happening. When you have a number of Deputies on all sides expressing their views, rightly or wrongly, as to the right price, there are people with the necessary accommodation who can hold up their wheat, and if the Government do not choose to give an increased price, what will happen? Suppose these people hold up the wheat until March, and the Government do not give a better price, what possibility is there of getting it? None at all. The people who will not sell it now will not sell it in March or April.
Comment on this
I wish I had the same faith in human nature that Deputy Corry has. I am not satisfied that people who hold up the wheat until then will not use it for animal feeding.
Comment on this
That does not concern me. My concern is that there are 120,000 tons of wheat which must be got in. It would be satisfactory to have an indication from the Minister for Supplies, whose job it is, as to how he hopes to get that wheat in.
Comment on this
I probably grew more than the Deputy did. Deputy Corry will, surely, agree with me that no Deputy from Meath should ask a Deputy from Cork how much wheat he grew.
Comment on this
Deputy Victory is so busy looking after Deputy Childers that he has not time to grow wheat.
Comment on this
While the Minister denies that the flour millers are going to get anything out of this £1,900,000, he does not suggest what is going to happen it. So far as I can judge, it will not go anywhere. It will not go to the farmer, because he will get the same price as before. It will not go to the consumer because he will pay the price for his bread as before, and the Minister says it will not go to the millers. It is beyond me to guess what will happen it. According to the Minister, we are voting this sum for some purpose, but he does not tell us what will happen it. If it will not go anywhere, then he does not want it at all. But it is utter nonsense to suggest that it will not go to the miller and the baker. In fact, the Minister gave the figure on which he based the amount to go to the baker. The Minister is very foolish to be defending his attitude, as he did to-day, by suggesting that Deputy Norton and Deputy Dillon are making the same speeches as they made before, and are merely doing that with a political object. Perhaps the Minister will tell me how he is going to get in these 120,000 tons of wheat so as to turn that wheat into bread? If he is not able to do that, then we have a shocking position, and no subsidies will get over it.
Comment on this
It is up to the farmers to help to feed the nation, and it is the duty of the Government to help the farmer to sow more wheat. My experience of the county which the Minister for Agriculture and myself represent is that a great deal of barley is grown because the land suits barley. So long as the farmers are getting £2 for wheat and 30/- for barley, there will be little wheat grown in that county. The farmers cannot be blamed for not growing it. The best way to spend some of this money would be to go out and tell the farmers that you would give them a decent price for their wheat, so as to make it worth their while to grow it. Deputy Belton suggested that the farmer was entitled to 50/- a barrel for his wheat. I agree with Deputy Belton, and I voted for his motion. We all know that this is not a suitable country for wheat growing. There is considerable dampness at times, and plenty of sun is required for wheat. There is only one way to feed the people, and that is to give the farmer a good price for his wheat. He should not be told in April, May or June what he will get. He should be told now that he will get £3 a barrel——
Comment on this
The Deputy should make these representations to his Wexford colleague, the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
You know as well as I do that I have often suggested it to the Minister for Agriculture, and he turned me down. Last night he said it was economic to feed pigs on barley and potatoes. "Jack the Lantern" would not feed pigs on barley and potatoes without milk.
Comment on this
I say the farmer is entitled to his share of the subsidy and that he is not getting it. It is necessary to grow all the wheat and potatoes possible. Do you think it would be better——
Comment on this
The Chair will not allow me to talk to the Minister or to the Chair itself. If we are asked to grow more wheat, we should be encouraged and told that we will get £3 a barrel for it.
Comment on this
The Minister for Supplies is not now asking farmers to grow wheat. He asks a subsidy for bread and for flour.
Comment on this
A subsidy to give to the foreigner. If the Minister for Supplies is voted this money it is not going in the right direction. It is the farmer who is entitled to a fair price for his labour. Deputy Corry told us here about seven barrels of wheat to the acre. I am sure the same land will grow 12 barrels of barley. Seven barrels of wheat at £2 a ton would yield £14, while 12 barrels of barley would yield £18. If you were given the choice, which would you grow?
Comment on this
There is talk of "Grow more wheat". Why are the farmers not encouraged to grow it? I will get an opportunity later on to talk to the Minister for Agriculture about prices.
Comment on this
Listening to the debate this evening, it comes as an agreeable surprise to me that at least one-half of the Opposition is now preaching self-sufficiency—a word which used to be laughed at and about which there was a lot of codology. The only question now seems to be how to handle the sufficiency. Personally, I believe that the price of wheat will have to be advanced, if the farmers are to be expected to produce it. We all know that at the moment in certain districts oats and wheat are both going at 2/- a stone. Therefore, something must be done to give encouragement to grow wheat.
The whole meaning of the subsidy— as I understand it—is to give bread to the poorer part of the community at a reasonable price, and I ask those people who are opposed to the subsidy, if there are any, if they would in the same breath ask to remove the stabilisation of salaries and wages. Are we going to have this inflation—one thing chasing the other—and none of us in this House able to sum up where it will end? At the moment the Government is trying to ensure that the food produced will be sold at a price which will enable people to live within the present salaries and wages. It is argued by some that the Government should take over the mills and nationalise them. That is a very big question and I, for one, would not like to start on it in the present emergency and world outlook.
I believe we should try to give encouragement for production. Some people do not set the same value on money now that they set on it five years ago: they do not know where the present world racket will end or what its value will be. Our consideration should be to get as much industry and production going as possible and to try to make conditions for our people, as a whole, as easy as possible. We cannot expect to have it very easy, as the cost of many things from foreign countries has gone up. After listening to some of the speeches in the debate, I must say I cannot see any division on this point, and I would not have risen were it not that one side of the House has been ridiculing the Minister and nobody here to defend him.
Comment on this
We do stand up to defend him. We believe, as we believed five years ago, that the policy was right, and we are glad to find Deputies, like Deputy Keating, advocating self—sufficiency.
Comment on this
One of the items which has been very well dealt with is that in regard to the subsidy, and the Deputy who has spoken made a very good case for it; but there is another item to which I would refer— the very first item. It shows £42,168 increase in salaries, wages and allowances. That is an appreciable item and I suppose it is an indication of an increase in the number of officials. If there is an increase like that in the number of officials, one would expect that there would be efficiency in that Department, but from long experience of trying to deal with that Department I have found that, instead of having any sort of efficiency, it is behind every Department in the State. There seems to be neither head nor tail there, nor any kind of order. It is very hard to account for it. They never seem to get things into shape, or to have any method in that Department.
Comment on this
No; wheat and flour subsidies. In the Estimate there is provision for salaries, wages and allowances, but those items have been disposed of.
Comment on this
I suppose there is hardly any difference of opinion about the need for reducing the price of bread and the price of flour. As regards the method by which that money is passed out to the people it is intended to reach, the trouble is that it is paid over to the men who have a monopoly—a few millers who have been multiplying their profits for the last few years. They get a present of this subsidy, to deal with it very much as they like. The money is voted by this House, but they do not reduce the price of bread or flour. If we vote money to people who have a monopoly like this, it is but natural to expect that they have some obligation in regard to these privileges handed over to them.
There should be no reason for debate on this question. I believe that all sides of the House ought to be satisfied that it is a little difficulty which could be overcome, if there were some committee of men competent to deal with it, representing all Parties in the House, to arrange the way this money would be paid. Some Deputies say it would be better to pay it direct in increased prices for wheat. All sides of the House are inclined to agree that that would be the best way. There has been a tendency here for a considerable time to give more and more to the monopolists—to the men who are making thousands and hundreds of thousands of pounds in profits—making millionaires of them and making paupers of the bulk of the people, the real producers on whom the country has to rely for food. It is not fair, and everyone knows that it is not fair.
I do not know why the Government should be so anxious to pass it all on to the men who need it least and to throw the responsibility on them to use it as they like and they will deal with it very much as they like. They do not distribute it to the satisfaction of any section of the community, and I am sure that nobody on that side of the House would agree that they are dealing with the subsidy properly and letting the people entitled to benefit get the benefit. If they were doing that, there would not be so many complaints about the price of flour, bread and other commodities.
Deputy Cole referred to the distribution of flour in parts of County Cavan. That has been a very troublesome matter in this area between the consumers and the shopkeepers, the Deputies and the Government. I got in touch with the Department of Supplies in June last about an extreme shortage of flour there and the first time I got a reply was in September. That was to a letter I wrote in June— three months before—and it went no further than saying they were going to investigate the matter. From September until now practically nothing has been done about it. About two weeks ago, I got a notice from the Department of Supplies that they had decided to increase the quota by 5 per cent.—that was over the whole country. Any suggestion of 5 per cent. or 20 per cent. or even 50 per cent. indicated that the Minister or the Department did not know the first thing about the problem there. I explained it as far back as last June, and it has since been explained by the people concerned in the flour trade and has been clearly put before the Minister and the Department.
There is no purpose served by talking about any increase if there is not going to be a general rationing scheme in these districts where special circumstances exist, as the Minister knows. Certain conditions that existed in my area in 1940 made it inevitable that the quota was very much below what it should have been. Yesterday I was speaking to a man who, in conjunction with two others, gets flour from a miller; they are distributors in the town of Ballyconnell. This man told me that the amount of flour they got for the last month or two would work out at 1½ lbs. every week for each person in the area which they supply. From another source I heard it said that if the flour were rationed there would be 5 lbs. for each person. It is no use talking about increasing the percentage when there is such a wide difference as that. It may be asked how did the people manage to get along during the last year. There is an explanation for that, and I believe some of the traders there have brought it to the Minister's notice. They were able to carry on because they had laid in supplies, but these supplies are now exhausted and unless the Minister sees to it that something will be done, there is nothing but starvation facing those people.
I heard yesterday of another increase over and above the 5 per cent. I advise the Minister not to rest assured that that will meet the situation. The people who have the responsibility of supplying customers must be satisfied that they are getting a fair and equitable supply as compared with other districts. They do not want to be better off and neither do they want to be worse off than the people in other districts. There has been a serious scarcity in this area, and I hope that situation will not be allowed to recur. The people have correctly informed the Minister of the circumstances and they will be satisfied if they get a fair show. The supplies that the people were advised by the Government to lay in have been exhausted.
The district I am speaking of is not a place where any wheat worth while can be grown, because the land is unsuitable. The people have to depend on whatever supplies they can get. I hope the Minister will give some attention to their grievances. At the present time many people are writing to the Department and they fail to get satisfaction. It is impossible, of course, for the Department to deal with individual complaints from all over the country. If the people are given to understand that goods are being distributed in an equitable fashion they will realise there is nothing to be gained by writing, and thus the Department will be able to save a good deal of time, and a more satisfactory condition of affairs generally will exist. Would I be in order if I referred to tea?
Comment on this
There is a shortage of other commodities to which it is not permissible to advert now.
Comment on this
I must respect the ruling of the Chair. I do not think there is anything more I can say on this subject. Other speakers have dealt with it better than I could, and perhaps it is better to leave well enough alone. I appeal to the Minister not to overlook the district to which I have referred, and I trust he will arrange for a suitable flour allocation. He does not seem to realise to what extent the existing quota has been affected by the supplies brought in last year.
Comment on this
The Minister referred to complaints, and he pointed out that in nine out of every ten cases there was no proper ground for complaint. In the area I represent I am aware there was a definite shortage. I am not referring to what led up to the shortage, whether it was the fault of the traders or the system of distribution, but there was a definite shortage in some of the congested areas in South Kerry and, were it not that one or two traders in one district happened to have a substantial quantity of flour in stock, the position would have been very serious. In order to avoid that happening again the Minister should adopt some system along the lines already outlined here. He mentioned the definite quantity that would be required for the whole country. Could there not be a certain quota allocated to each county in such a way that every area would receive a fair quantity?
In my opinion there is a lack of uniformity in the matter of distribution. It is the duty of the Department to see that all Government orders are enforced and properly respected. There should be a general evening-up of the whole position. Deputy Linehan and others mentioned that farmers were withholding wheat stocks and that 100,000 tons were still being held in different parts of the country. It has been suggested that some of the subsidy could be utilised to give an enhanced price to the farmers.
Of course, everyone realises that would not be fair, because a certain price has been paid to the farmers who have already sent in their produce and their stocks, and why should anyone suggest that farmers who have still held on to their stocks should at this stage be given an enhanced price as an inducement? I do not think that that would be fair or just. There is, however, the question of the farmers holding on to these stocks for animal feeding. That is deplorable, if it is true. I have been informed of a few cases where people have held over stocks of wheat. I must admit that it is a difficult matter to check up on, because these farmers, naturally, state that they require it for home consumption and that it will be utilised eventually for home requirements.
I believe that there should be some check-up on this matter, even if the Minister has to call in the assistance of another Department of State. For instance, why should not the Minister for Supplies, on occasion, call in the assistance of the Gárda Síochána in the enforcement of some of these orders? I think it is necessary and that it will be necessary, and I would suggest that when he is replying the Minister should refer to the fact that it is understood that there will be a fixed minimum price in regard to the retail price of flour. That would be a step in the right direction, and I believe that that would be one deterrent so far as the distribution of flour is concerned.
I have been given information—I have passed it on, not to the Minister for Supplies, but to the Minister for Agriculture—with regard to the withholding of stocks of wheat. I have also been informed in regard to traders who have sold two and three sacks of flour to farmers for the feeding of animals and had none at all for the poor people and others who came from congested districts. They had none at all for these people when the shortage took place. These are the matters I was referring to when I mentioned the question of the Gárda Síochána being called in. If the Minister adjusts the system, probably it would not be necessary to have any such proceeding or any intervention at all so far as the Gárda are concerned, but I believe that in order to have proper distribution and a proper check-up on the whole thing the position must be reviewed. The Minister makes an order up here and the House gives it its approval, but it is another matter altogether to get the order enforced and respected. With regard to the subsidy, I would suggest, if I am in order, that a percentage of that subsidy should be put aside for an increased price for wheat for the coming season. I do not know if I am in order in suggesting that.
Comment on this
The question of the price of wheat would be a matter for the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
Well, could not portion of this money be left over, if necessary, so as to make sure that the price of wheat would be increased for the coming year? That would be one of the main considerations in connection with having a sufficiency, in my opinion. We are given to understand, and we agree, that the Minister is doing the right thing in asking for this money to subsidise the price of flour and to regulate the whole system, but I should like to know, since we are given to understand that portion of this money will be required for the subsidisation of imported wheat, homegrown wheat, etc., whether portion of it could not be also utilised for the other development, that is, to ensure a sufficiency for the coming season. Could not portion of that £1,900,000 be held over and not expended for the current year? I am only making that suggestion in case such an adjustment is possible and if I am in order in doing so. In conclusion, I should like the Minister, so that this shortage will not occur in future and so that there will be a proper distribution in the areas I am referring to, to consider the question of a minimum retail price for flour.
Comment on this
The House is being asked to vote a sum of £1,900,000, as stated by the Minister, to enable him to keep the price of the loaf at its present level. Now, portion of that £1,900,000 will be for the 80,000 tons of wheat that the Minister hopes to import into the country, but the price of that 80,000 tons of wheat is not included in this Estimate, I presume. The total Estimate of £1,900,000 will go to the miller and the baker to subsidise the price of the loaf to the consumer in this current year, and I believe that that will be allowing the baker something like 1d. per loaf.
I do not know how much the miller will get out of it, but £2,000,000 is an extraordinary amount for the taxpayers and the people of this country to have to pay this year to the millers and the bakers. The loaf will be at the same price as it was for the past three or four years. For the past year they have been selling the loaf to the people at the same price, while that loaf was very inferior in quality, and therefore their profits must have been greater than when they were giving us white bread at the same price. Now we are giving them another £2,000,000. The Minister said that the millers will not get any of it. I suppose the bakers will not get any of it either, and I should like very much to know where this £1,900,000 is to go. I know the farmers are not getting any of it.
Comment on this
I thought the Minister stated neither the farmer nor the miller was getting any of this?
Comment on this
Is not the farmer getting 5/- a barrel more than he got last year? Somebody must pay it.
Comment on this
The farmer is paying the whole lot; there is no doubt about that. I have been very much surprised at the figures given for this year's yield of wheat. The Minister says he has 170,000 tons from 490,000 acres. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I do not think it is correct. Surely there was a better yield than that even though the year was not a very good one. Another Deputy has stated here that he believes there are 120,000 tons of wheat in the country unaccounted for at the moment. If that is so, it is not being held by the farmer who went out to plough up his land in order that the people would have bread, and it is not being held by the working farmer who had to harvest his wheat as quickly as he possibly could and get the money for it. It is being held by the people who can afford to hold it in order to get a better price for that wheat out of the sweat of the people of this country. If that wheat is here, and I believe it is, then it is the duty of the Government immediately to see that it is procured for the people at the price that was paid to the farmers for this year's crop. I would say to the Minister, if I am in order, that now is the time to fix the price for the coming year's crop of wheat, and that a decent price should be fixed if the farmers are to be asked again this year to be the great heroes that they were last year in producing 500,000 acres of wheat. The Minister will remember that if the yield was low this year it is likely to be very much lower next year, when the farmers will be unable to get any manures, and the price will have to be greater if the wheat is to be got for the people. Now is the time to fix the price.
Comment on this
Well, I am sure this Minister is very much interested in it, and while I may criticise him I appreciate his very great and onerous job in procuring food for the people. He has a big job on hands, and he has willing workers in the farmers of this country to procure the food. I wish him success, and I hope that, whatever happens or whatever the cost, our people will not be without flour and bread.
Comment on this
I agree with some of the statements made by Deputy Flynn regarding a shortage of flour in South Kerry, particularly in the Kenmare rural district, and in the area called Castlecove. When the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was in Kenmare about two months ago I drew his attention to the matter, and he raised it with the Minister for Supplies. The situation improved slightly at that particular time, but there is still a serious shortage in that area. I should like if the Minister would endeavour to improve the supply of flour into the Kenmare rural district, particularly Castlecove. I tabled a question to-day, more or less in the form of a helpful suggestion, asking that a bounty would be given per acre for the growing of wheat in congested districts and in the areas where the land is poor. I had a particular reason for tabling that question, because I remember distinctly that, during the Great War, the congested districts and areas along the seaboard produced quite a large quantity of wheat, mainly for the use of the tenants themselves, and the falling off in the growing of wheat this year is very noticeable in those areas. As a matter of fact, the shortage of flour is particularly noticeable in the areas where no wheat is grown. I know quite a lot about that subject for the simple reason that I had something to do with the milling of wheat during the Great War, and I know that there is at least 80 per cent. shortage in the growth of wheat in those congested districts.
There must be some reason for that, and, therefore, I think it is up to the Minister to encourage the growing of wheat in those areas. Apart from that altogether there is the question of transport. The transporting of flour from the rich tillage areas into the western seaboard makes a big demand on the transport facilities of the country, and the granting of a small bounty per acre for the growing of wheat in the poorer lands would certainly relieve the transport problem. I was not satisfied with the answer I got to-day, and if the Minister has any influence in the matter I would ask him to take serious notice of the necessity for giving a bounty for the growing of wheat in the poorer lands, because I am fully satisfied that, if that bounty had been given, at least 25 per cent. of an increase in the growing of wheat would have taken place this year.
Comment on this
It is evident that the reason why the Minister had to bring in this Supplementary Estimate is that the whole wheat question has been bungled. If the farmers had received more encouragement last year, we would have more wheat. If the Minister had taken my advice six or eight months ago the price of wheat would have been increased, and the full complement of wheat grown in the country would be in the mills now. We heard during the debate that there is a certain amount of wheat still outstanding. Wheat at 2/- a stone is cheap feeding stuff, and no matter how many inspectors the Minister sends out he will not get all the wheat in the country. Another matter to which I want to refer is the way in which bread is being made at the present time. I was in a farmer's house the other day—I will not mention names no matter what the Minister says—and I saw two loaves there. I asked: "Is that all the bread you buy?" I was told: "We buy two loaves for the hens, and then we have our own wheat; we cannot eat the loaf bread." The complaint all around the country is that nobody can eat the loaf bread made at the present time. If more of the bran and pollard were taken out of the flour, there would be more use made of the bread; it is not being eaten at the present time. Anyone who goes down to the restaurant here will see that there is home-made bread and loaf bread, and the loaf bread is left on every plate. The bread is being used for animal feeding, because the people cannot eat it. It is a great hardship on the poor people to ask them to eat such bread. The people who can afford it can go and buy their bag of flour. Frequently people in the country cannot get flour. There is a workman of my own who has eight big growing sons and his family normally used a bag of flour every ten days. These eight boys cannot get sufficient bread at the present time unless they eat this stuff which is made at the baker's. That is a problem which the Minister must examine. Again this flour made into baker's bread is sheer waste. Now the Minister has to provide a subsidy in order to secure sufficient wheat to carry on until next harvest. If the Minister had given sufficient forethought to the matter he would not have to do that.
Comment on this
If he had encouraged the farmers to grow wheat, there would be no necessity for this.
Comment on this
You have to do it this year in order to get sufficient wheat to carry on until next September.
Comment on this
You want to get enough wheat to carry you on until next September. You must remember that next September there may be a position in this country in which you will be able to import nothing and if you do not make provision now, all the subsidies in the world will not get you wheat. There is, therefore, every necessity to encourage farmers to grow wheat because the fact at present is that many farmers are getting out of the growing of wheat. I prided myself this year on my crops of wheat. I thought they were as good as it was possible to produce but the wheat did not ripen or did not give the yield which I expected so that in the end the crops did not pay me. I had as I say an excellent crop. On manured ground, it bushelled over 62 but on the lea ground it did not bushel 57. That is the trouble all over the Midlands. Wheat did not come up to expectation owing to the moist weather in the month of August with the result that generally it bushelled only 54 or 55. I thought I had myself the best crop of wheat in Westmeath and many people congratulated me on it but, except on manured ground, none of it bushelled more than 59. I do not think on that basis it would pay me to go into it again. I put plenty of artificial manure on it. I bought it wherever I could but I cannot see where I am going to get it this year. Although I used such a quantity of artificial manure last year the yield of my crops was not up to expectations.
If the Minister wants the farmers to produce sufficient wheat to carry the country over the next year he must get the Cabinet together and put the problem before them. There is a general idea in the country that the Minister for Supplies is the enemy of the farmers. There is a belief that, were it not for the Minister, we would get a better price for our produce. I think the Minister should get the Cabinet together and put this problem before them, otherwise next September you may have a position in the country in which not all the subsidies in the world will get you wheat. Unless he throws out a sufficient bait to the farmers there will be no wheat and no bread. Should that position arise, the fault will lie on the shoulders of the Minister for Supplies. He is paid to see that the country has a sufficiency of all essential supplies, and if he wants to be sure of a sufficient supply of bread, he will throw out a good bait to the farmers now.
I admit that I voted against an increase in the price of wheat to the farmers last year because I did not want to raise the price of bread on the people and because I honestly thought the price that obtained at that time would pay the farmer. After my own personal experience, I can now say that it did not pay them. If the Minister wants a sufficiency of wheat he will encourage the farmers to produce it by paying an adequate price. It has to be remembered that owing to the shortage of artificial manures, the yield this year will be lower. It must also be remembered that a very large proportion of the land is wheat-sick at the present time. Wheat has been grown on it for the last three or four years and farmers will tell you that they cannot produce wheat on such land again this year. You may produce wheat for two or three years on certain land but you cannot produce it after that. That is why I say that the Minister should make every effort to encourage the farmers to grow wheat by offering them a proper price. I think the Minister should also give the people a loaf they can eat. It is all right for the rich man who can buy white flour but it is sinful to compel the poor people to eat, or to try to eat, the bread made out of the present flour. It is wasteful also because if more bran and pollard were taken out of the wheat, that bran and pollard could be utilised for animal feeding and the bread would be all eaten whereas, in many instances at present, it is simply thrown out because it is unfit for human consumption.
Comment on this
I should like to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that in certain districts along the Border there has been a shortage of flour for the past few months. It is perhaps only natural to expect that in the difficult conditions through which we are now passing there would be a shortage of certain commodities, but I hope that the Minister will see to it that the districts to which I have referred will receive a fair share of whatever supplies are available. The subsidy of £2,000,000 which it is proposed to provide for flour under this Estimate is a very large sum. I am not going to suggest that all that £2,000,000 will pass into the pockets of the millers; neither am I going to take the advice of Deputy Allen and other Deputies on the opposite benches who seem to imagine that we should swallow everything that is said on the Government Benches and vote this £2,000,000 without asking any questions. I was surprised to hear Deputy Allen talking about propaganda and suggesting that Deputy Dillon should try to go out to undermine the Fianna Fáil Party on this issue of a subsidy of £2,000,000 for flour. I think that Deputy Dillon has to go a long way to equal the tactics of Deputy Allen and others in the past as regards propaganda.
This, as I say, is a vote for a very large sum of money and I am interested to know whether we are going to get value for it. It is only right to say that portion of that money will go into the pockets of the Irish farmers. I think that, according to the Minister's statement, something like £700,000 of this money will go to the Irish farmers and that £1,200,000 is being paid to cover the extra cost of the wheat that has been imported. It strikes me as extraordinary—I do not know whether I am right or wrong; if I am wrong I hope the Minister will correct me—that a sum of only £700,000 is being paid in respect of the 80 per cent. of the wheat that is raised in this country while a sum of £1,200,000 is being paid in respect of the other 20 per cent. In other words, the 80 per cent. of our wheat requirements which is being produced in this country receives only £700,000 of the subsidy while the 20 per cent. that is imported receives £1,200,000. Am I right in that assumption?
Comment on this
Perhaps I should quote from the Minister's statement on the matter. He said:
"The increased cost of native wheat will be £700,000. We estimate that 80 per cent. of the total wheat used will be native wheat, as against something below 50 per cent. previously. The increased cost of imported wheat will be £1,200,000. We estimate that the allocation price will be £30 per ton, as against £15 per ton last year, and that only 20 per cent. of the wheat used will be imported wheat. That sum of £1,900,000, which represents the total increased price we will have to pay for wheat on the assumption that the quantity of flour to be consumed will be 2,700,000 sacks, means that, without any subsidy from any source, the price per sack of flour would be increased by 14/-."
Therefore, it does seem extraordinary. The reason I emphasise those figures is that I want to relate this question of wheat production to the Estimate, seeing that the Leas-Cheann Comhairle has more or less ruled the point out, and quite properly so. Yet, it is important, and I think the Minister, in conjunction with the Minister for Agriculture, should examine those figures and see whether it is not possible to produce more wheat in this country in the coming year, and not have a situation arising whereby, to use the Minister's own words, this country is paying £1,200,000 for 20 per cent. of the wheat we use in this country, and we have only paid £700,000 for the other 80 per cent. That is the position as I see it, from reading the statement of the Minister. Therefore, it is imperative that the Minister should take cognisance of the fact. While I know the difficult position that exists in this country, yet, on these figures, something must be done.
It seems to me, from reading the Minister's statement, that he at least is resigned to the fact that we are not in a position to grow sufficient wheat for our own requirements. I should like Deputy Allen and other Fianna Fáil Deputies, who are always preaching the policy of self-sufficiency, to recognise that fact. I think they will agree with me. My reading of the Minister's statement gives me the impression that this country is not able to produce sufficient wheat to meet our requirements fully. It seems to be the fact. So far as I can see, I am afraid we will not produce the same quantity of wheat this year as last year. As I say, it seems extraordinary to pay £1,250,000 for 80,000 tons of wheat. That represents the produce of about 80,000 acres. I am assuming a yield of about eight barrels to the acre. On that assumption, 80,000 tons means the produce of 80,000 acres. I think it would pay the Government and the people of the country if we could get an extra 80,000, 100,000 or 150,000 acres of wheat, and not be paying £1,250,000 for 80,000 tons which as I say, represents the produce of about 80,000 acres. In some parts of the country there may be only a yield of six barrels to the acre, but I think the average yield is about eight barrels to the acre; that is about one ton per acre. Therefore, 80,000 tons represents the produce of 80,000 acres. Surely it would be good policy to induce the farmers of the country to grow 80,000 more acres of wheat. On the Minister's own estimate, that would save us an expenditure of £1,250,000 for the import of 80,000 tons of foreign wheat.
I know the extra price is due to the freight charges and war risks. I recognise the fact that the price at which we get that wheat in the country where it is produced is a mere bagatelle when compared with the price when it is landed at the ports of this country. I think that the Minister, in conjunction with the Minister for Agriculture, should endeavour by whatever means is possible, let it be an increased price or not, to get that extra acreage of wheat grown here. I am not a farmer, and I have never grown wheat, but from reading the statements made here and knowing something about the matter, there is no use in talking about a policy of self-sufficiency if we are not in a position to grow 80,000, 100,000 or 150,000 extra acres of wheat this year and save the expenditure of that £1,250,000. I should like to ask if this country is able to produce sufficient wheat for our requirements, or have we been talking nonsense for some years past? It would take 600,000 or 700,000 acres to provide sufficient wheat.
Comment on this
How is it that that has not been done? I am not speaking politically. The times are too serious to be indulging in political speeches; but facts are facts. Are we in a position in this country to turn 600,000 or 700,000 acres into wheat? I believe there are between 10,000,000 and 11,000,000 acres of arable land in the country. The question, therefore, arises: are we able to turn into wheat 700,000 or 800,000 of that 10,000,000 or 11,000,000 acres? If not, then we have failed, and all this talk about self-sufficiency is just so much bunkum, especially in view of the fact that that huge sum of money has to be paid for the purchase of a very small percentage of our total requirements. The Minister may have some explanation to give in answer to my contention, but that is my reading of the statement that he made, that £700,000 goes into the pockets of the Irish farmers who produced 80 per cent. of our total wheat requirements, and that £1,200,000 is to go into the pockets of the millers, or whoever is responsible for getting this wheat into the country.
Whether we are getting full value for that £2,000,000 is what we are debating. I am not saying that the £2,000,000 is going into the pockets of the millers, but I do say that it is not fair that they should get 6 per cent. on their capital, in view of the difficulties through which the people of the country are passing at present, especially if, as the case may be, the capital is put at such a figure that it is much in excess of requirements; in other words, that it is inflated and that they are getting 6 per cent. on that inflated capital at the expense of the farmers and the rest of the community.
Comment on this
I can appreciate the motives which have induced the Minister and the Government to introduce this Estimate. It is in order to prevent the poor from having to pay an extra price for the loaf. One can appreciate that fact, but at the same time we do not want to pay one penny more than is sufficient, if we can avoid it, because we are paying sufficient at present. In regard to the suggestions made by Deputy Fagan, I think it is worthy of consideration by the Minister and by the Government, and that is whether by reducing the extract of flour we could not produce as much if not more bread, or at least bread that the people could eat. It is a well known fact that from 15 to 20 per cent. of the bread goes to waste in some parts of the country, although it is hardly fair to say that that happens all over the country. So far as the bread produced in Dundalk is concerned, I can say that I will not lose a night's sleep if I do not get any change of bread for the rest of my life. That is as far as the bread in Dundalk is concerned, and I am told that it applies to the Drogheda bread also. I am not praising the bread produced in Louth as against bread produced elsewhere, but I have heard it stated that the bread, especially in the Midlands, is very bad. It has been suggested here before by many Deputies, including Deputy Dillon, that it would be much better if the Minister would reduce the extract by from 10 to 15 per cent. He would have as much flour for the people and they would have as much bread, because there is a wastage of from 15 to 20 per cent. of the bread produced at present.
I would also ask the Minister whether, in conjunction with the Minister for Agriculture, he could not get the farmers, by some means or other, to produce sufficient wheat to give us 100 per cent. of our requirements, instead of having to import wheat from other countries. I will not go into the question of whether the wheat policy is good or bad. We are passing through an emergency, and time will tell all that when the war is over. Deputy Allen may have to change his tune when the war is over about the growing of wheat. We need not go into that question now. I have my own opinion about it. We are now faced with an emergency and we have to do the best we can with the means at our disposal, and it is up to us all to do it. In the meantime I would ask the Minister to pay attention to the question of the lack of supplies in certain parts of the country, especially those districts adjoining the Border. Of course, I know the reason why there is a shortage there to-day. There is no use going over that but, however, times are becoming normal now and I hope they will not be penalised for the good times they had in previous years. I hope that sufficient flour will be sent to those districts so that the people may have their usual allowance.
Comment on this
There is a matter that has taken my attention. In the Minister's speech, reported at column 611, Official Debates, 13th November, he says:—"It is proposed also to subsidise the price of wheaten meal produced by licensed wheaten meal millers for sale. The cost of the subsidy in respect of wheaten meal is estimated at £33,000." That is a matter which is puzzling the people in my part of the country. I happen to come from a part of the country where both commission mills and licensed wheaten millers are working, and I can give the Minister figures for both these mills. I would like to know if the Minister had any advice from people who are acquainted with both sides of this question before he came to the conclusion that he ought to subsidise wheaten meal from these mills. I wonder if he had any advice? I wonder if he has gone into the figures to find out what is the profit already being made upon wheaten meal by the millers who have licensed wheaten meal mills. Has the Minister done that? I am going to give the figures to the House and it does not appear to me or to the people in the country that there is any justification for subsidising wheaten meal as the Minister says he is going to do.
The Minister said a while ago, in reply, I think, to Deputy Daly, that one of the causes for this subsidy is the increased price of home wheat. I am going to take the Minister up on that and to see how far that is justified in regard to the production of wheaten meal. Take, for instance, the man down the country who takes a barrel of wheat to a commission mill. We will say his barrel of wheat is worth 40/-. Any of the country Deputies who are in touch with commission mills will know what I am talking about. The barrel of wheat is worth 40/-. He will pay the commission mill 3/6 per barrel for turning that into wheaten meal and he will get back 18 stone, after drying. What is 18 stone of wheaten meal worth to the licensed wheaten-meal miller? It is worth 24/- per cwt., that is 54/-. If we add the price of the wheat, that is 40/- and the 3/6, that is 43/6, it would cost the ordinary licensed wheaten meal miller to turn that into whole meal the sum of 54/- and the Minister does not think that is enough. Is that the position? He has 9/- per barrel for handling the wheat and he is not providing bags at the moment. The Minister proposes to tell the House that one of the reasons why he has to provide this subsidy is in order to give £33,000 to those millers. Is there any justification for that? Those are the figures I bring up from the country from mills that are operating at my back door. I would like the Minister to give his attention to this matter and to justify, as far as he possibly can, the subsidy to the licensed wheaten meal millers down the country who are making whole meal and are charging 24/- per cwt. for the whole meal. If that is in keeping with the Minister's other statements, it is no wonder that the House and the country would be very doubtful of what the Minister says. Deputy Allen, I am sure, knows perfectly well what I am talking about. On the price of 40/-, the value of the wheat, the miller is able to make at least 9/- a barrel profit and the Minister does not think that is enough for him. I do not want to spoil my case by saying any more or bringing in any other matters.
I would like the Minister to tell us what he thinks about it.
Comment on this
I had hoped that we would have been able to discuss this proposal to subsidise the price of flour and the price of bread in a spirit of a legislative Assembly dealing with an important matter of national policy. I think it is utterly discreditable to members of this House that they should have endeavoured to use this occasion for the purpose of misleading the people of this country as to the proposal before the House and as to the effect of that proposal. We have to face the fact that the wheat we are going to use this year will cost more. Everybody knows that. The guaranteed minimum price to Irish farmers was increased from 35/- to 40/- a barrel. Somebody must pay the extra 5/-. The wheat which we are going to bring from across the Atlantic is going to cost more. Somebody must pay the extra cost. If we do not subsidise the price of flour, that additional price for Irish wheat and additional cost for imported wheat will be paid by the consumers of flour. All the rest that has been stated here is so much humbug. The extra cost of our wheat will increase the cost of flour from 52/6 to 66/6 a sack. That is the result of the increased cost of wheat. It will mean that the 1/- loaf will go up to 1/2. If we do not provide this subsidy, that will happen to-morrow. If the Dáil votes against this Estimate, as many Deputies indicated it was their intention to do, then, as from to-morrow, the loaf will be 1/2—it will probably be slightly more because there will be certain arrears to be made good—and the price of the sack of flour will be 66/6, because our wheat is going to cost us more.
Deputy Dillon said that we are providing this subsidy for the benefit of the millers. "Is there a Deputy in the House," he said, "who will get up and maintain that this plundering monopoly should be further buttressed up with £2,000,000 of public money?" Later he said: "The sum of £1,900,000 is to be handed over to these gentlemen." Not by one penny will the millers of this country benefit by this subsidy. Except in very exceptional cases they will not even see a penny of it. The purpose of this subsidy is to ensure that there will be delivered to the millers in this year wheat wherewith to manufacture flour at the same price that they bought it last year. Getting the wheat at the same price, they will sell flour at the same price. There will be no benefit of any kind to the millers. There can be no benefit to the millers. The operation of the subsidy will be conducted through Grain Importers Ltd., a Government organisation——
Comment on this
——which will arrange the production of the flour by regulating the price at which the millers will receive the wheat. Some Deputies have tried to mislead the House— Deputy Dillon, followed in a very parrot-like fashion by Deputy Norton——
Comment on this
——and other Deputies who, apparently, are unable to understand humbug when they hear it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister is behaving in a disorderly way inasmuch as it is contrary to the rules of order of this House to state that any Minister or Deputy is trying to mislead the House.
Comment on this
May I resume? Deputy Dillon misled the House. Whether he did that intelligently or unintelligently, consciously or unconsciously, I do not know. He misled the House. That is a fact.
Comment on this
On a point of order, it is, I submit, disorderly for the Minister for Supplies to say that any Deputy of this House sought to mislead the House. Is that in order or is it not in order?
Comment on this
Would Deputy Dillon please sit down? He blathered here for two hours on the last occasion and now he wants to interrupt the few minutes allowed to me to reply by raising these frivolous points.
Comment on this
It is a most sportsmanlike attitude on Deputy Dillon's part. I was allowed twenty minutes in which to reply——
Comment on this
On the point of order, Sir, is the Minister in order when he states that a Deputy sought to mislead the House?
Comment on this
Some Deputies were not clear as to how this increased cost of wheat arose. I gave figures yesterday which were based upon one method of calculation. Some Deputies did not understand these figures, and perhaps if I give others based on another method of calculation, they will make the position clearer to them. In rough figures, we require 370,000 tons of wheat to produce our requirements of flour and bread.
Comment on this
Yes, but that does not matter. It is only the total quantity that matters in this case. Last year, we used 200,000 tons of native wheat which cost us 35/- per barrel on the farm and 40/9 per barrel delivered dried to the mills. If Deputies work that out, they will find that the total cost of native wheat last year was £3,260,000. In order to make good the inadequacy of the home supply, we imported 170,000 tons of wheat, or, at any rate, we used 170,000 tons of imported wheat which was delivered to the millers at the allocation price of £15 per ton. That cost £2,550,000 and the sum total of these two amounts was £5,810,000. That, roughly, was the total cost of the wheat we used, whether native or imported, last year. This year, the consumption of native wheat will, we think, increase from 200,000 to 290,000 tons, and that native wheat will be bought from the farmers at 40/6 per barrel, instead of 35/- last year, and delivered dried to the millers will cost 46/9 per barrel. 290,000 tons at 46/9 per barrel will involve £5,400,000. We have to supplement that 290,000 tons of native wheat by 80,000 tons of imported wheat which this year will cost £30 per ton, making £2,400,000. The total cost of both these items is £7,800,000. Last year, the wheat used to produce all our requirements of flour and bread cost us £5,810,000 roughly. This year, it will cost us £7,800,000. The difference is what we are going to make good by subsidy.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister where he got the figure of 290,000 tons? How does he arrive at it?
Comment on this
Our calculations are based on the assumption that that is the quantity of native wheat which will be used this year. I think our estimate is correct——
Comment on this
I am not going to deal with these minor factors which may affect our calculations. I am dealing with broad figures. Some quantity of that flour purchased by millers was devoted to purposes other than the manufacture of bread for sale to householders. Other minor factors operate which affect these figures in greater or lesser degree, but, roughly speaking, these calculations will show Deputies clearly where this additional sum of £2,000,000 is going. It is going to pay the extra cost of Irish wheat, plus the additional cost of imported wheat. Even that statement is somewhat misleading——
Comment on this
——because, as Deputies will have noted, the amount which will go to Irish farmers this year exceeds by more than £2,000,000 the amount which Irish farmers got last year, because not merely has the guaranteed minimum price of the wheat been increased but the total production of wheat by Irish farmers has increased, and therefore, the total amount which will go to the farmers exceeds by more than £2,000,000 the amount which they got last year; but, on the other hand, even though the price of imported wheat has risen considerably over the allocation price of last year, the quantity will be so much less that the actual outgoings for imported wheat this year will be less, we assume, than last year.
I have said that these figures are based on certain assumptions. Deputies have misunderstood the statement I made last week. I told them that, of the 290,000 tons which we calculated would be available for milling into flour, 170,000 tons, according to the latest information, had actually been delivered to millers or merchants. That delivery does not indicate that there is going to be difficulty in getting the 290,000 tons. As a matter of fact, I gave that information on Thursday last as being the latest available to me, but, when I checked up on it, I found that, by Thursday last, 200,000 tons had been delivered to millers or merchants, and the quantity delivered to date is probably larger still. Those who are familiar with these matters tell me that, making allowance for the lateness of the harvest, the deliveries of wheat to date are quite good and well up to normal, and, in fact, somewhat above normal, and there is as yet no reason to anticipate that there will be difficulty in securing the estimate of 290,000 tons of dried wheat delivered to millers and available for milling. Whether that will prove to be so or not, I cannot say, but there are at least sufficient indications of the total quantity we will get to enable us to say that, if we do not get 290,000 tons, we shall at least get so near to it that the importation of the balance required to maintain a full supply of wheat will not be beyond our resources. I therefore would not like it to be thought that there are any serious grounds for apprehension on that point yet.
I have answered the question asked by a number of Deputies as to where this money is going. In fact, it is going to pay for the wheat. In practice, it will be distributed through Grain Importers, Limited, who will adjust the price of imported wheat to the millers in such manner as will ensure that the total cost of the millers' grist in this year will be the same as last year. I want to make it doubly clear that there can be no benefit to the miller from the subsidy because that utterly misleading statement made here is likely to be accepted by some people, and in fact has already been assumed to be correct by occasionally intelligent people like Deputy Norton. The miller this year will get his wheat at the same price as that at which he got it last year. He will pay in wages to his workers the same amount as he paid last year. Whether the cost of producing flour from wheat will prove the same this year as last year will, in any event, not affect the price, because the miller is going to be allowed only the same charge in respect of that cost this year as last year——
Comment on this
Some Deputies either misunderstood, or were anxious to misrepresent, that particular calculation. I stated quite clearly that the profit allowance, in the price of flour, represents 6 per cent. upon the capital invested in the production of flour.
Comment on this
I think I am entitled to proceed without interruption from the Deputy. I have said that the calculation is based on the capital invested in the flour milling industry as a whole. It is not the practice of my Department, nor would it be practicable, to fix the price of flour at each mill according to the costs of production in that mill. We take the flour milling industry as a whole. We take the average costs of production in all the mills of the country. We determine what is the total capital invested in flour milling in all the mills in the country, and, on the basis of these average costs, a price for flour is fixed which would enable the miller to produce flour with a return of 6 per cent. upon the invested capital. Some millers, of course, are able to work to costs which are below the average, and some millers work to costs which are above the average, but the price is fixed on the basis of the average costs of the most efficient mills in the country. I should have made that clear.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy stop interrupting? I think I am entitled to proceed without this buffoon keeping up this chorus of interruption.
Comment on this
For the information of the House I should explain that there are certain mills in this country which, because of their position, can produce flour somewhat more advantageously than others. These mills are located at certain ports—Dublin, Cork, Waterford and Limerick—and our calculation of the cost of producing flour is based upon the actual cost of production in these port mills. The price that we fix for flour is based at these port mills. Over and above that price, flour is sold in other parts of the country at that port mill price plus the cost of transporting the flour from the port by the cheapest means of transportation.
There was made recently an order, which comes into force on Monday, fixing a flat retail price for flour. Heretofore that was not considered practicable because certain difficulties existed, but these difficulties have been overcome and an order is now coming into force which will fix a flat retail price for flour in these port mill towns and in the rest of the country. The price in the rest of the country will be slightly higher than in the port mill towns. It will be 3/- per stone in the port mill towns and 3/2 per stone in the rest of the country. It is, therefore, clear that we do not, as has been stated, guarantee profits to anyone. We do make it possible for the mills of the country to carry on their industry. I think it is obvious that we must do that. I know of no action by which a Government could compel any manufacturer or trader to continue in business at a loss to himself. Clearly, any practicable arrangement for the fixation of prices which will be just to all parties must provide for the earning of at least minimum profits for the manufacturer. The profit that we have fixed in the case of flour milling, of 6 per cent. upon the invested capital, is, I think, the lowest point at which we could fix it. Certainly in normal circumstances it would be held, by most people who are familiar with business conditions, that 6 per cent. upon ordinary industrial capital is an inadequate return.
Comment on this
Does the Minister think that farmers who put their money into wheat growing at 40/- a barrel are getting 6 per cent. on it?
Comment on this
Some, I am sure, are. Of course, it is obvious that if people can get only 6 per cent. on the money they invest in ordinary shares in industry they will not put their money into them if they can get 6 per cent. on preference shares and debentures where they have security added to their return.
Comment on this
I am prepared to defend a return of 6 per cent. upon the capital invested in any industry. In fact, there are some industires more precarious than flour milling, where 6 per cent., in my opinion, would be an unfair return. The actual capital in the case of some companies is substantially less than the issued capital. There are many well-known companies in Dublin—big firms of manufacturers —whose nominal capital does not represent the value of their assets. These assets have been built up out of profits. I think it is true to say of the banks and a number of other commercial concerns that the actual money invested in their businesses is substantially less than the original capital invested. There may be other cases, but for the purpose of this particular calculation the capital invested by the concerns in flour milling is substantially less than the issued capital. That, in fact, is the normal situation in this country. Most of the flour millers in this country are also maize millers and engage in other business activities as well. The total capital of the concerns includes their investment in their other businesses, maize milling or whatever other activities they carry on. The actual capital invested in flour milling is less than the issued capital of these concerns, and a return of 6 per cent. upon the invested capital, which the fixed price allows for, would not permit in some cases of the payment of 6 per cent. upon the issued capital. But if there is any basis in the charge that we, by this arrangement, are guaranteeing 6 per cent. to the millers, we are doing it not by the subsidy but by the fixed price. The subsidy does not affect the position in the least. Any intelligent person can see that. It is by the fixed price that we do secure, if, in fact, it can be said that we are securing, for the miller a return on his investment.
I want to deal further with some points that were raised here of greater importance than those that I have referred to already, but as the time available does not admit of that now, I will have to postpone my remarks until to-morrow. There is one point, however, that I want to make clear for the information of Deputies, and that is in relation to the shortage of flour which arose in some districts, and was attributed by some Deputies to the feeding of wheat, or wheaten products, to animals. It was urged that we should make more extensive efforts to enforce that order, and particularly that we should employ the Civic Guards for that purpose. It is at present the responsibility of the Civic Guards to enforce that order. We realised that it would not be possible to secure the enforcement of it through the activities of departmental inspectors. The risk of evasion was much more widespread than in the case of other orders, and, consequently, arrangements were made with the Department of Justice that the Gárda Síochána should undertake the enforcement of that order. Anyone who is aware that the order is being evaded: that this practice of feeding animals with wheat that we will require for human consumption is taking place, should make the fact known to the Guards who, I am sure, will take the necessary steps to bring the offenders to justice.
I move to report progress.