We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 6—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–94 of 206. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

When dealing with the Budget last week I stated that I was seriously troubled about the food position. If the position is examined carefully I do not believe, even with 25 per cent. of the land tilled, that we will have a sufficient supply of grain. We have complaints about the shortage of butter already. Previous to the war we imported about 350,000 tons of maize and 100,000 tons of linseed meal and oil cake for the feeding of cattle. In 1938, the last normal year, the acreage under oats amounted to 570,414, and under barley 117,842 acres. In 1941 the acreage under oats amounted to 782,201, and under barley 163,000 or a total of 945,000 acres. The 700,000 acres under oats and barley in the year preceding the war were used for feeding purposes, and very little of it was exported, leaving a difference of 227,000 acres to fill the gap caused by a shortage of some 500,000 tons of maize and cotton meal for feeding stuffs previously imported.

Comment on this

For feeding purposes.

Comment on this

I suggest that the present acreage under tillage will not be sufficient, and that is the main reason why oatenmeal cannot be got this year. I believe that 40 per cent. of the land will have to be put under tillage if there is to be a safe supply of grain, and that that will have to be done, not in a haphazard way, but definitely enforced if we are going to prevent want and misery. I do not believe all the yarns that we hear about farmers holding back oats for better prices. The farmers sold a certain quantity at tempting prices and, in my opinion, they were absolutely justified, having regard to the gap that was left between the price of oats and the fixed price of oatenmeal. Farmers are prepared to work and to produce crops at very little profit, if any, so that the consumers may get food at a low price, but when a gap was left other gentlemen on whom there were no restrictions stepped in between farmers and consumers. No attempt was made to get these gentlemen to share in equal sacrifices for all. They stuffed their pockets with the loot, while others might starve. While that condition of affairs exists I do not think farmers are to be blamed if they take advantage of the scarcity of commodities to try to extract portion of the loot. I know that I will be told: "Oh, nobody takes any notice of what Deputy Corry says." I heard that often before from county councillors and in every phase of public life, but I succeeded in showing that when I make a statement I never do so without producing the proofs. In this case the proof was a letter from a miller who admitted that on a turnover of 300 barrels of oats per week—the oats having been bought at the price fixed by the Government and the oatenmeal sold at the fixed price—he could make a net profit of £10,600 a year.

Comment on this

Is that the Galway gentleman?

Comment on this

Yes, he was an honest man. He made that statement to me personally and when I asked him to put it in writing he did so. He deserves every credit from this country.

Comment on this

Did you hear from the Minister for Supplies since?

Comment on this

He did his part. There would be less trouble if some of the cock-and-bull yarns were dealt with in the same manner. I agree with what the Minister for Supplies said the other day. The principle under which we are working is right. If the administration goes wrong it is our duty to call attention to the loopholes. In an emergency period like this we cannot afford to have loopholes. Democracy is on trial to-day, it is on trial here. I know that the people on the opposite benches can sneer at times and can talk about bringing this House into disrepute but if there is anything that would bring this House into disrepute, disgrace and shame, it is the manner in which the Ministerial and Parliamentary Offices Act has been acted upon. There is the picture drawn by Deputy Hickey, and the statement made by the Taoiseach the other day regarding the means test in the case of old I.R.A. pensions. Where was the means test here in the case of people with £1,200 in one job, £480 out of another job, and £500 a year of a pension?

I consider it my duty to my constituents, who sent me here on every occasion on which I asked them, to show, since the Opposition Front Bench are gagged by this Pensions Act, where, in my opinion, mistakes have been made by the Government. I will carry out that duty while I am here, and no sneers from anybody will prevent me from doing so. I said democracy was on trial. It is on trial in this State and very much on trial. If we cannot provide for the unemployed and poor. I do not think there will be any democratic rule here before this war is over. When you have a condition of affairs here in which the necessaries of the poor, such as sugar, are shipped across the Border while the aristocracy here—those who are rich enough to afford it—can get black-market tea and black-market white flour, that does not shed credit on this country and would not shed credit on any country. Nobody can deny that that position exists here to-day. A person need only take up the paper any day to be aware of that. Nobody will persuade me that the lorries which bring that white flour and those chests of tea across the Border to this side are going back empty. Nobody will persuade me that the butter which is so scarce here has not found its way out of the country as well as the sugar. The merchant who wants white flour does not care what he exchanges for it when he can get a profit of 500 per cent. on his gamble. That is, unfortunately, the position which has prevailed and which I am asking this House, as a whole, to stand up and end. There is only one place for the black-market man and we should put him there. If he were in any other country, he would not be black marketing so long as he has been here.

Then, we have the position in regard to iron supplies—a position which is getting more acute day by day. I saw representatives of Messrs. Pierce, of Wexford, in Cork recently looking for scrap. They found that all the scrap of Munster had been piled up by the Jews in Cork—what they had not exported —and they would not sell a lb. of it. Surely, if an emergency order can be brought in for one thing, it can be brought in for another. To-day, if you want to get a set of shoes made at the forge, you have to bring a wheel band with you to make them, because the blacksmith has no iron with which to make the shoes. I hope that, now that the Minister has done his part, as I freely admit he offered to do a year and a half ago only the crooks were too strong for him—now that they have accepted the money, I hope that the Minister will see that that factory in Cobh is set working at once, that the furnaces are built and that the scrap iron there will be melted down, so that we shall no longer have a scarcity of an article which is absolutely essential if the agricultural community are to carry on their work.

I now come to the turf position. I put the figure of 64/- on one side and, on the other side, the price at which a local authority in Cork was able to get its turf. There is no comparison between 25/- a ton for turf ricked in Cork County Home, and 64/- for turf, 400 yards away, under the control of Fuel Importers, Ltd. I heard the very lame excuse—I cannot call it anything else —given by the Parliamentary Secretary in that regard. We had the public statement here that the cost of transferring that turf from the wagons across the road and ricking it in the Marino was 9/7 a ton. The moment that statement was published I received a letter from a prominent contractor in Cork stating that he had tendered to do that job at 5/5—4/2 less than it cost. I hold a copy of his tender. The excuse given by the Parliamentary Secretary was that he realised that the poor fellow would lose a lot of money, and, therefore, he would not give the contract to him. How long has the Parliamentary Secretary set himself up as a Providence for looking after foolish contractors? My principal trouble is that that is the turf the poor will get. It is not the gentleman who goes in for a ton of turf that matters; it is the unfortunate people who have to come to our boards of assistance to have their dole supplemented by home assistance. The few shillings we give them has to go to pay the difference between 5/5 and 9/7. That is not a condition of affairs for which we should stand. I freely admit that no man in this country would have handled the turf situation as well as the Parliamentary Secretary handled it last year, with this exception—that, in my opinion, he has not paid enough attention to keeping the costings down in the right manner and in the right place.

Comment on this

He kept the quality down.

Comment on this

I do not mean that he should keep the costings down as regards the unfortunate labourer working in the bog, but that he should keep them down in the case of the fuel merchants here in Dublin who are getting more for carting the turf around than the unfortunate labourer got for cutting, footing and ricking it in the bog. It cost the board of assistance in Cork 2/9 for unloading and ricking the turf in the bog and it cost the Parliamentary Secretary 9/7 for doing the same thing 300 yards away. These are the things that count and which the unfortunate people have to watch. If we are to keep wages at a standstill or anything like a standstill, so that there will be no inflation, surely it is equally our duty to see that the poor will get their fuel and their food at the lowest price we can fix. After all, a large part of the food of the poor is oatmeal. One might say that 95 per cent. of their fuel consists of turf. In regard to those two items, in my opinion, we are sadly lacking in our duty. In my opinion they are the things we have got to look after. We recognise the principle all right, but we must have regard to the administrative side and see that the costings are kept down and that the consumer will not have to pay the wide margin that is at present allowed by the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Supplies between the cost of production and the price at which it is sold to the consumer. We must do that this year, from the moment it leaves the hands of the men who have to work and toil and sweat— the farmer and the farm labourer— and comes into the hands of the collar and tie boys. Where the farmer is allowed 8d. an hour, the merchants are allowed £5 an hour. There is too much class distinction in this country and too much cheese-paring, cheese-par ing that was evidenced here three weeks ago in the questions that I had to ask in connection with a certain county medical officer of health and the manner in which his duty was being discharged and the manner in which the unfortunate ratepayers of the county had to pay his substitute. That kind of thing is turning this House, not only into disrepute, but into contempt, the contempt of every decent man in the country, who will say, "They are all alike."

I speak as one who is anxious, and more than anxious, to see this country coming successfully through the present trouble. If we here keep our heads and do our duty towards our people, it will. Let not money stand in the way. Let there be equal sacrifice for all. If there is £125,000,000 lying idle in our banks, as Deputy Mulcahy told us some time ago, let some of that be sacrificed, to be used, not merely for providing the few million pounds that are necessary now for the relief of unemployment, that, unfortunately, in my opinion, we have not made one-fourth provision for, but for seeing that our people are put into decent employment here and for covering what I call the black period in agriculture, namely, from the 1st November to 1st March, the period in which our agricultural labourers, when they became disemployed last year, flew off to England. If England can pay them with borrowed money that is not worth the paper it is written on, in my opinion, we should be able to do the same. Let us do the same. Let us see that our people are clothed and fed and that the food which our people should receive is not sent across to build up paper credits in Britain that may be no use to us in our hour of need. I do not intend to delay the House further. I have stated what in my opinion is the actual situation in this country to-day and the means that I think should be taken to remedy it.

Comment on this

I am not going to enter into a very lengthy criticism of the Budget. I am not going to suggest that any economies that the Minister could have effected would, in any degree, have mitigated the position of the people in general. I am not even going to suggest that borrowing was not, in the present period, unavoidable. But I would say that if we had not so lavishly expended in the past and if taxation had not been allowed to reach the limits it had reached we could face with some degree of equanimity the post-war period in which it will probably be more necessary to borrow than it is now, when expenditure may become heavier than it is now, because expenditure rather than economy will be necessary. I wish to refer, in the main, to the effect of the Government's policy on the agricultural community. If one were to follow Deputy Corry, I think one would have to make the rather unfair statement that the policy of the Government was anti-agricultural. I do not think that it is quite fair to go as far as to say that it was deliberately anti-agricultural. I think it would be equally unfair to say that the Government pursued a policy of sympathetic inactivity in regard to agriculture because the whole trend of their policy during the last few years has not been of any great help to the farmer in general. Agriculture suffered very severely in the early years of the Government's administration. It was used as the rope in the tug-of-war in the fight with Britain and if it was not broken it was sadly frayed, to say the least. There was never an attempt made by this Government, or indeed by any Government since the State began to govern itself, to provide the farmer with a profit commensurate with his capital expenditure on the land and with his cost of production.

No attempt was ever made to carry out a proper investigation of the real costs of production in farming. Certainly no attempt was ever made to give the farmer a return sufficient to provide him with a reasonable profit and some slight amount for interest on his capital expenditure, on equipment, etc. Certainly no provision was made, as is made in this Budget in relation to manufacturing industries, for giving the farmer the equivalent of the post-war compensation given to manufacturing industries for moneys expended on emergency equipment and plant. There is no provision in the Budget to compensate the farmer in a similar manner for the expenditure he now makes on the increased production of food, without manures. No provision is made in the way of post-war compensation for the enforced deterioration of his property, his land, as a result of that extra production. I am not saying now that the Government has never given any money towards agriculture, but I do say that, in the distribution of the pool, agriculture has been unfairly treated. Any help that the Government has been forced to give to agriculture has come after months and years of agitation and, when it was eventually given, it was given grudgingly and hesitatingly.

Take the case of wheat. For over two years, since the emergency started, there was an agitation all over the country and in this House, to fix a price for wheat that would make it an economic proposition for the producer. The Government began by advancing the price to 30/- and then in small doles advanced it to 35/-, 40/-, 45/- and eventually to 50/-. If, in the first instance, the Government had taken the view that they have taken in regard to other industries in this State—that the producer must get a price commensurate with the cost of production— they would have fixed the price of wheat from the start at 50/- or over 50/-, if they took into consideration the deterioration in the fertility of the land and the cost of putting that land into a proper state after the emergency has passed.

What has happened in the case of wheat, possibly will also happen in regard to butter. Sufficient butter is not available at the moment for the needs of our own people. There has been a shortage for the last few months. Probably for the summer months there will be a sufficiency but then it is in the balance whether for the remainder of the year supplies will be adequate for the needs of the people. The threatened shortage could have been avoided if the Government had listened to the voice of people who knew the position, in the last three or four years. I am sure the Minister for Agriculture knows the position. I shall pay the Minister the tribute that I believe if it were in his sole power he would help in this matter and that he would provide the money necessary to give an economic price for milk, but the Minister is held up by the Minister for Finance and the Government who do not understand the agricultural problem, as I hope the Minister for Agriculture does.

There has been, as I say, a consistent demand for an increase in the price of milk. That demand was so forcibly put forward by the producers that it is now almost generally recognised by every section of the community that 7d. per gallon is not an economic price for milk and that butter is being sold, even at the moment, at a price under the cost of production. Are we to wait for the same thing to happen as happened in the case of wheat? Are we to wait for the inevitable to happen, because I foresee a further increase in the cost of production of milk, and in the price which will have to be charged to the consumer. That is as inevitable as the increase in the price of wheat from 30/- to 50/-, but Government action may come too late also in this matter. The evil effects of their inactivity may be avoided if they decide to do now what will be inevitable in mid-winter. Why should the Government not investigate the matter fully to see if 7d. per gallon is a fair price to give to the producer of milk and if they find that it is not, why should they not take such steps as will ensure that the production of this vital commodity will be sufficient to meet all the needs of the people while the emergency lasts?

Looking at the production of milk from another point of view, in the last few years the production of butter has fallen by 200,000 cwts., which is equivalent to a decrease of 150,000 in milch cows, or again equivalent to a decrease of 15,000 to 17,000 workers on dairy farms. Is it any wonder that there has been an addition to the number of unemployed in the country, or that the number of emigrants has increased? This is a matter that concerns everybody in this State. It is a subject that looms largely in the conversation of people everywhere. There is not a housewife in Dublin who is not concerned with the question of the production of butter at the moment. There is not a consumer at the moment who would not willingly pay a penny or more extra per pound for butter if he could get it, recognising as he does that it is the one article of food that he is getting under the cost of production. We are only asking the Minister for Finance and the Government to be as fair to the farmers as they are to the rest of the community. I recognise that we are practically all living on doles. From the rich to the poor, we are receiving Government assistance in one way or another. The Government gives with one hand, but they take away lavishly with the other hand in the form of taxation. Everybody is on the dole to a lesser or greater extent. That being so, we unfortunately have to demand for the agriculturist his share of the swag, as Deputy Corry would describe it.

I have noticed in the Budget that, in regard to manufacturing industry, a fairly liberal provision is made. I grant you that a sufficiency of taxation is extracted from the industrialists, as much as the Minister could afford to extract, in income-tax, supertax, excess profits tax, and in every other way. Many taxes are also extracted from the agriculturist. There was a time when the Minister's predecessor said that no farmer had to pay income-tax. That has been proved to be a mistake. There are several farmers paying income-tax, but I do not think there is any farmer who will be charged with supertax or excess profits tax. I never heard of a farmer having to pay excess profits tax, and I would like to see the official of the Minister's Department who would set out to prove that the farmer had made excess profits. In fact, I think the Minister would smile if anybody suggested that there was ever such a thing as excess profits in the case of a farmer. Provision is, however, made for extracting an excess profits tax from industry. The mere fact that that provision is there and that excess profits are productive in the way of taxation, proves that one section of the community is at least more prosperous than the other, that the manufacturing community have reached a degree of prosperity altogether beyond what the farmer can ever hope to attain.

I notice that the liberal margin of 7½ per cent. beyond which the Minister could extract an excess profits tax has been, in this Budget, increased to 9 per cent. in the case of certain industries—I do not say in the case of all industries. It has been increased to 9 per cent. So the Minister believes that 7½ per cent. profit on capital turnover is not sufficient for a new industry in this State, that an industrialist should be allowed at least 9 per cent. before he extracts excess profits from him and that after the excess profits are extracted he is going to share in the swag over and above that —the Minister will only take a share in the excess profits. Now, I am not grudging the industrialist his profit— he is entitled to make a reasonable profit—but I am urging that what is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander and that if it is possible, by Government policy, for one section of the community to make profits in this emergency, it ought also to be possible for another, and a much more vital, section of the community, a section for whose welfare the State should be more concerned than the section I have been talking about.

What I believe should be done, and what never has been done in this country, is to set up a Departmental commission, if you like, or rather some sort of a committee—a committee of Deputies of this House would satisfy me—representative of all Parties in this House, to make an investigation of the whole position of farming and agriculture and the cost of production of all the essentials that the farmers produce, as well as the provision by the Government during this emergency of a price which will provide agriculturists with a fair profit. I do not want any excess profit. I do not want to drive the farmers into the ranks of the excess profiteers—although I do not believe there is any danger of their being driven into them—but I do want some investigation to be made, as I suggested, into the whole question of agricultural production and agricultural profit. It does not suffice to give the farmer what is considered, generally, satisfactory for him, a mere nominal profit on his production.

Take the price of wheat or of oats or anything else produced by the farmer: the profit is arranged on the actual cost of production, and no attempt is made to consider the amount of capital involved in the land, or to provide for interest on that capital, nor is any attempt made to provide the amount that would be necessary in the post-war period to restore the fertility of the soil. I merely want to emphasise, in particular, the position in regard to butter, and I warn the House that what has happened in regard to wheat and our bread supply, oats and oatmeal supplies, is definitely going to happen to our butter supply if no provision is made to provide a better price than that which the Minister for Agriculture announced recently. I believe that a better price is inevitable and that it is going to be brought about within the next few months by the force of agitation and public opinion in this House and elsewhere, and it would be more desirable if it came willingly and unhesitatingly from the Government now than to have it dragged out of them later on when it might, perhaps, be too late.

I notice that the Minister anticipates that he is going to derive something over £2,500,000 in excess profits tax in the coming year. That does not represent the whole of the excess profits in regard to industry. Now, if industry is in such a position that it can probably make £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 of an excess profit, over and above what one might call the legitimate profit, in a period like this, then one cannot say that the manufacturing industries, in general, are not in a flourishing condition in this particular period. We only ask and demand that some attempt should be made to put the agriculturist, if not in exactly the same position, at least in a position where he would have some profit on his production and some interest on the capital that he has invested in agriculture.

Comment on this

I should like to make some remarks on Financial Resolution No. 2. I notice that in that Resolution, there is the following:—

"...references to a trade having been discontinued or to the discontinuance of a trade shall be construed as not referring to or including any case where such trade was carried on by a single individual and is discontinued by reason of his death..."

Apparently, the Government are altering the law in other cases, and I do not think the Minister gave us any very great detail as to what was the necessity for the alteration in other cases. Certainly, however, where there is a death the procedure is not very fair or very just. I understand that the procedure is to call for a valuation of the stock-in-trade at the retail price. Now, that quite disregards the fact that an ordinary trader would have to continue trading for a considerable period and incur considerable expenses, in order to realise his stock. I think that that position should be recognised, especially as, very often, after a death it is found that the person has been in poor health for a considerable period, during which time he was unable to give proper attention to his business, and probably the stock is, if anything, below the normal value that it would have if the person who was experienced in the management of the business had been constantly and closely supervising it. I would advise the Minister to look into that provision.

The Minister has acknowledged a deficit of £4,500,000 in balancing his Budget, but that is by taking in nearly £1,500,000 as capital expenditure. When one examines those items, I am afraid one is forced to the conclusion that the Minister has merely stuck a "capital" label on certain items that ought properly to be treated as items which should be paid for out of the normal revenue of the year. I could agree with the Minister that such items as Afforestation, £66,000; Airports, £83,000—especially if that is in connection with the commercial airports—and Fuel Subsidy, £100,000—especially if the receipts from fuel are going to show a surplus over and above expenses— should be treated as capital expenditure. I can quite understand that a large part of those might well be treated as capital expenditure. But, when we come to Defence—£493,000 — Special Employment Schemes— £188,000 — and Special Emergency Schemes—£417,000—I am afraid one is forced to the conclusion that a very great portion of all that expenditure is not going to give any return and, therefore, should not be treated as capital expenditure. I think it would have been much more frank on the Minister's part to have lumped all that in with the deficit of £4,500,000. The Minister also called attention to the wasting character of the land annuities which now amount to about £1,750,000. If we were to include these sums the deficit would certainly reach a very formidable figure. Since, I suppose, we must all shelter behind the Government, I do not see how it would have been possible to have bridged that gap by taxation.

The Minister, in the course of his speech, touched upon the depreciation of machinery installed in special cases to meet the emergency. I think he was very wise to have made provision for dealing with cases where people have provided machinery which is serving a very useful purpose at the present time. When, however, the period of the emergency is over, that machinery will be just absolute scrap. While on that I would like to bring to his notice that at the present time the ordinary replacement of machinery is practically impossible, so that the average person is being forced to make all sorts of emergency repairs. He has simply to cobble up the machinery he has so that he may be able to carry on. I think the Minister ought to make some sort of provision so that allowances may be stored up to meet replacement expenditure in the post-war period. I am not suggesting that the revenue should lose anything over the period. It certainly would be a very foolish thing to allow a number of firms to go on gaily spending the money that ought to be laid aside for the replacement of machinery, but I do suggest to the Minister that some provision ought to be made so as to enable firms to meet the enormous expenditure they will be faced with in that respect in the post-war reconstruction period.

That brings me to another point that the Minister did not touch on in his Budget speech—indeed, I do not know whether it is relevant to the present discussion—and that is how far the present duties have been taken off or merely suspended, because it is true to say that almost anything can be brought in now duty free. That, in my opinion, is not enough as far as the ordinary traders and manufacturers are concerned. Some lead ought to be given to them as to how long the Government think that will last, and as to what plans they ought to make for the future. The Government may say that the future is very obscure, and that they cannot make any pronouncement as to what their future policy is going to be. If that be their attitude, the ordinary trader or manufacturer may say that he is in the same position and cannot make any provision for the future. Countries that are a lot more occupied than we are seem to be giving very special care to the problems that will arise in the post-war period. The Government, I think, would be well advised to try to give the people some idea as to the conditions under which they think trade will be carried on in the post-war period. The Government are very anxious to develop employment. I am afraid, however, that, due to over-anxiety in a number of cases, they have sacrificed officials. For example, I would like to know the real cost of certain Government Departments.

In the case of the Department of Supplies, one notices that almost 250 people have been loaned to it from other Departments. Their salaries do not appear to be charged to that Department, nor is any information given as to the sum they might represent. The Minister, of course, may argue that their salaries have to be paid in any case, and that one may as well pay up and look cheerful. I suggest to the Government that the analogy of a business firm starting a new department ought to be followed. I cannot imagine any business firm not charging to a new department the salaries of officials transferred to it so as to show to the board of directors what savings had been effected in the older departments, and what the true cost of the new department was. Even if it be not possible to give an exact estimate, at least an approximate estimate should be given showing the cost of the salaries of the transferred officials, with a view to showing what is the real cost of this new Department set up by the Government. It is an extraordinary state of affairs that while for years officials may be working in one Department which is almost shut down, owing to the emergency, we are left in the position that we do not know what the saving in the case of that Department is on the transfer of officials, or what the cost of the Department is which now has the services of those officials. I submit these points to the Minister for his kind consideration.

Comment on this

The first thing that strikes one with regard to a Budget of this magnitude is whether or not anything approaching the services which the people would be entitled to get for this sum of money are being provided. On that, the case for this Budget would naturally stand or fall. If we examine the most prominent item that enters into the budget of every household, namely, fuel, on that basis, we find turf being sold at 64/- per ton in a place like Dublin. That is not value for the money. Some of it that I have seen and which has been bought by people whom I know, would not be used in any house in the rural districts. When we go further and examine what provision is made here in respect of turf, we find a sum in the Estimates amounting to over £820,000. In none of the appropriation returns which I have been able to examine have I seen any return in the shape of cash receipts for that expenditure of almost £1,000,000. If, then, the price of 64/- is to be added to by a subsidy of this sum, one wonders what really is the price. Looking back over the last few years and some of the statements made by industrially-minded Ministers, we find the Minister for Supplies on one occasion stating that he looked forward to such an expansion of the turf industry that it would be a rival to agriculture. Certainly at that price it is not ever likely to be a success. Judged on that basis, one would say that there will be no value given for the money provided for in the Budget if the value of the rest of the items can be in any way equated to the value received there.

Let us take another item. In this sum of £44,000,000 there is provided a sum of approximately £9,000,000 for the Army. We have heard from many platforms and from almost every political Party in the State about the independence of the people of this country, their self-reliance and so on. There is another small nation in Europe which has been independent for a great many centuries and which at one time occupied an almost dangerously dominant position on the borders of Europe. That country has been supplied with and has taken supplies from America under the lease-lend provision. It is a neutral country just as we are; it is independent just as we are. But its independence and its neutrality have not been in any way interfered with by the acceptance of munitions under the lease-lend arrangement. It has made a treaty with one of the belligerents, and that has not in any way interfered with its neutrality. We seem at all times to be getting the worst of the weather; all the disadvantages and none of the advantages—and they are very few—that arise out of a situation such as we are living through at present.

In my view, and I think in the view of the vast majority of the people, the danger point for this country, if there was a danger point, since this war started, was somewhere about May or June, 1940. At that time we set up a defence machine to deal with that situation. It does not appear that the intervening two years have increased that danger. While at that time we were satisfied to expend a sum of approximately £6,000,000 in the year to defend this State, we are now, in a less dangerous time, prepared to spend over £9,000,000, and that requires some justification. Therein would be at least a species of economy which could be justified if some of the savings that were made under that particular heading were devoted to providing some nutritious food, either free of charge or at a low price, for the people who by reason of the war are suffering from malnutrition. From the information which has been given to me, the case that was made by one of the Labour Deputies was not exaggerated. There is malnutrition, serious malnutrition, certainly in Cork City. It would be well if the Ministry would bend their energies towards dealing with that situation. It is held by quite a number of persons who have studied the matter that the casualties which resulted from the disease which made its appearance on the Continent somewhere about 1917 or 1918 far exceeded those which took place in the actual field of battle. Quite a number of professional men well versed in medicine are of opinion that the ravages of that disease were largely due to malnutrition, insufficient food, and the lower quality of the food that was consumed during the war and certainly towards the end of the war.

The Minister stated in the course of his Budget speech that it was not feasible to effect economies. We have read of the number of local authorities which have been suspended or abolished for one cause or another. I wonder if the Government were themselves submitted to an examination before any impartial body whether they would escape being abolished if they got a trial such as they have given to others. We have a Budget now of £44,000,000 and a debt, national and local, of approximately £112,000,000. The Minister's case is that it is a reproof to critics, that initiative has been shown. Certainly initiative has been shown in the matter of spending. But who, outside of the Ministry, would be satisfied with the value which has been received in respect of that huge expenditure of money? Surely any body of businessmen would have been able to do better than that? After 20 years of independence in this country we have the largest expenditure ever we had; we have the highest rate of emigration ever we had, we have definitely arrested any expansion of employment, and that at a time when taxation is higher than ever it was.

Last year the Minister imposed a very high rate of tax on tobacco amounting to 5/6 per lb. He told us solemnly that he expected to get an additional revenue of £1,870,000 from that. He actually got £600,000, not £1,870,000, or one-third of what he expected. Apparently he is not satisfied with that. Why is it that the tax which was then imposed to bring in £1,870,000 succeeded in raising only £600,000? Obviously, the answer to that question is that people were not satisfied to pay the price—that there was a reduction in consumption due to the fact that value was not received. Everybody knows that if you exceed a certain point in connection with the imposition of taxes the result is unsatisfactory, and that is one remarkable example of it. There is scarcely any craze that has so captivated the taste of humanity as tobacco. Year after year the number of persons using it has increased, but here the Minister is disappointed to the extent of £1,250,000.

Last year, the Minister brought in a tax which he expected to bring in the sum of £900,000—corporation profits tax—but it brought in only £270,000. This year, for what reason I do not know, he expects to get £2,500,000, that is £1,600,000 over what he got last year. In the course of the Budget Statement, the Minister informed us that he has been impressed by the case which has been put to him by industrialists, and in this year's Budget he is making a modification of the tax which was imposed last year. He is giving a concession to firms that have been established since 1934. In all fairness to the industrialists who began their work in this country prior to 1934, it must be said that they were far more extensive, they gave far greater employment, and they invested their money with less security and less prospect of a certain return on it than those established since 1934. I make no criticism whatever of the industrialists who began since 1934, but I should like to examine the Minister's proposal for dealing with this situation. He states that some of those firms have not yet discharged all the preliminary expenses. Mind you, it is a perfectly fair case. If they have not, the order of the concession this year should be to make provision for the proportion of their preliminary expenses which they were not able to make from 1934 up to 1939. It would not even be objected to if a slight increase in that proportion were made, provided that they were then put on a level with all other industrialists. This country still boasts democratic institutions, even though they may not now be as healthy or as wise as they always were. Let us see that we are not going to have an aristocracy in industry, or a privileged class in industry. To the industrialists who started since 1934, it ought to be quite as objectionable to be placed in a position in which they have to get the feeding-bottle as it is to those who are not getting the advantage of the feeding-bottle and are left only with the soother.

The Minister for Supplies favoured us with a long speech here the other evening, which may be divided into two parts, in one of which he practically takes up the line of the Minister for Finance and says: "There is the Budget. That is the best that human ingenuity could devise for this country at the present time. It is the duty of everybody to lend his aid towards stabilising conditions in this country, towards helping the Government in its difficult task, and towards impressing on people the wisdom of the Government, its foresight and the care that is taken to help everybody in this State," even though the helping in some cases means emptying their pockets. We are not prepared to accept that particular description of the Government or its administration. We have very serious complaints to make in regard to the manner in which they have discharged their duties to this country in their time.

The Minister stated in a later portion of his speech that he had thought we would escape the ravages of a black market in this country, but that he was now fairly well satisfied that it was a problem which had to be dealt with. It is rather a wonder that the Minister did not tell us when he first discovered that there was a black market in this country, what it was that gave rise to a black market, or whether in any respect either the Government or himself was responsible for the black market here. He went on to describe persons who purchased in the black market as criminals. The description is scarcely fair. It is not just at all, in my view. In certain cases there would not be purchasers in the black market if we had efficiency in the Minister's Department. There are cases in which no provision at all is made to enable people to get supplies at the present moment. Cases have been brought to his own notice which have had to be looked into and provision made for them, not very rapidly at that. In one case that came under my own notice the people who went into the black market had neither the money nor the desire to go into it; only necessity brought them there. I have heard of a case in which a bus driver paid 5/- for ¼ lb. of tea for a sick member of his household. That man is not, to my mind, deserving of being called a criminal. I have heard of another case, in which a man, being unable to buy bread, had to buy something else at a much more costly price. To say that those men should be branded as criminals in this country is a very grave mistake.

What gave rise to the black market? Some time ago, a secretary, I think it was, to an egg dealers' association wrote to me asking for co-operation in bringing to the notice of the Minister the desirability of issuing ration cards for tea. That was about two months ago. I informed him that it was some 15 or 18 months ago since we had first made that suggestion, but it had probably escaped his attention. In the course of the case which he made for it he said that certain traders throughout the country—he was in a position to know, because he had been calling on them—were allotted a proportion of the amount of tea they got a year or two ago; their quota was based on the supplies they got a year or two ago. I forget the exact year—it may have been 1938 or 1939 —but I think Deputy Dillon would know very much more about that than I.

He went on to say that no trader in this country had to-day the same customers as he had two or three years ago. One or other of them died, and in some cases a trader might lose three or four. Then there would be removals, departures, changes of residence. His point was that certain traders in such circumstances had a surplus. He did not include them all, and it may be only a very small proportion of traders who would have it. At any rate, they would have a surplus of tea available for sale at an enhanced price and, if the rationing were enforced, that surplus would not be there. If there were surpluses, a certain temptation arose and the temptation would not be there if we had an efficient administration capable of dealing with such a situation.

If we look back over the past few years, we will find that the Minister, in 1938, offered an explanation to a group of industrialists that he had not been able to devote the same time to industrial expansion by reason of his energies being diverted in another direction—that he had to make provision for the possible effects of a war situation. One of the lessons learned in the last war was that ration cards had to be introduced, and they were operated in a very much larger country than this. In this emergency, ration cards have been functioning there with a certain degree of satisfaction. In a small country like this it seems to be difficult or impossible for the Minister to make up his mind. In such circumstances he is not likely to get the co-operation for which he asks.

He was recommended some 18 months ago to adopt the rationing system. We find that the cards are being delivered only this morning. The recommendation was certainly made in January, 1941, but it is only at this moment are the cards being distributed. The Minister told us on one occasion that he hoped he would get suggestions as to how things might be done. He might get more suggestions if a little more attention was paid to the suggestions already submitted to him. Let us take tea as one example, and no graver dissatisfaction could exist in certain parts of the country, notably in the cities, than in the matter of bread distribution. That situation has lasted long enough to have found a solution.

Some 15 months ago I made a suggestion that smaller powered cars should be used by the State. The Government are now adopting that suggestion. From 1932 to 1938 we recommended the Government to settle the economic war. They made some lame steps in that direction, such as the Coal-Cattle Pact and taking the duty off horses, and eventually they settled the whole dispute at a cost which staggered the agricultural population. That seems to amuse the two Ministers opposite, but it is not by any means a laughing matter. The two Ministers may not have suffered by the economic war, but if they only realised the sufferings of the people, if they were aware of the numbers of people that they have driven to their graves or into lunatic asylums, they might have derived less enjoyment from my statement. In November I suggested there should be an increase in the price of wheat. The price was increased after a few days. In February I again recommended that the price should be increased and it was increased after a few days. Why is it that it is only when the Government are driven to do something of that sort that they do it? It must be with very great reluctance that they made those advances.

I should like to impress upon the Government that those recommendations were not made for the purpose of giving people a few shillings extra for what wheat they had grown. It ought to be obvious to Ministers that the wheat yield during the last 12 months was particularly low. I am speaking from recollection, but I think it was something like six and two-third barrels per acre, the lowest yield, perhaps, on record. What has the Minister for Supplies to say to that? Speaking about the provision of a subsidy of £2,000,000 for bread prices as being open to question, he said:—

"I think that if we had not offset the obvious effect of the increased guaranteed price for wheat by providing that subsidy, members of the public and members of this House would have realised more clearly the exact significance and the exact consequence of the further demand which came subsequently for another increase in the price of wheat, a demand which was met."

It appears to me that was given with very bad grace. The Minister almost implies that he was held up.

What are the facts? Any wheat we imported came in here at 80/- and probably up to 100/-. The Government asked the farmers to grow wheat so that we might have more shipping space for other things. They recommend wheat to be grown, and if we ask for 50/- it is because we know it would not pay people to grow wheat at any lower price. So long as I have any responsibility, I am not going to ask people to do things which will involve them in a loss. In order to get people to grow wheat it is necessary to offer them 50/-. As a matter of fact, it is cheaper at that price than at the price at which it could be imported, and I believe it was a perfectly justifiable attitude for us to adopt.

One of the things that are rather disconcerting at the present time is the shortage of commodities. We learn that it is very probable that unless paper pulp is imported, within the next couple of months newspaper production in this country will be obliged to cease. That would be a very serious thing for a large number of people who find employment in newspaper and printing offices. It is unlikely that the people so employed will get alternative employment in this country and they will have to go out of it. If the Minister could persuade his colleagues in the Government to make a special effort to import paper pulp, it might be possible in that way to save the State a good deal of expense and to keep alive one of our important institutions. If the printing industry is affected by reason of a shortage of paper most of the operatives in the newspaper world will probably have to go across the water to seek employment and it would be a very grave thing for this country if we were to lose their services.

In the course of the discussion of this Budget, a reference was made to the small tax that is being put upon the banks, amounting to £1 per head. As I have said before, I have no brief for the banks, good, bad or indifferent—I have no shares in them—but it will be observed from the White Paper that it is estimated that the Minister will get £20,000 more from the Currency Commission this year than he got last year. The Currency Commission does not mint money; it has no means of making it, and it has no prospect of being able to provide £20,000 except from one source, and that is from the banks. The interest I have in the banks at the present moment is confined to two separate sets of persons—one, the depositors, and, two, persons seeking accommodation. I think that people who lodge money in the bank and get 1 per cent. on it are entitled to security for their money, and that those who find it necessary to get accommodation from the banks should be able to get it at a moderate price. The more this State goes into the pool to get what it can out of it, the less there is for the depositors, on the one hand, and the people who require accommodation, on the other. We have set up financial institutions in this country, and they are not yet and never have been able to compete with the advantages supplied by our banking institutions. A good deal of the industry and commerce of this country depends upon them, and the more there is taken from them the less prospect there is of their being able to provide it for industry.

This whole Budget is too expensive and too heavy an impost on the people. There is very little doubt but that the national income has been shrinking rather than expanding since the war started. As it shrinks, the demands made upon it become more and more onerous. The Minister for Supplies stated that the Government in its wisdom divided up the people of the country into four classes. Income-tax payers are in the first class. They are taking more money from the income-tax payers, so they will have less to spend. It is an unhappy way to do it, because some income-tax payers give employment. That may be unknown to the Ministers and if the demands made upon income-tax payers are such that they can no longer give employment, then employment suffers. The second class are those who are fairly well-to-do —earning, I suppose, £5 or £6 a week. Their earnings may be sufficient for a non-war period, but the increasing costs of the last few years have placed them in a rather precarious position, and if taxation is kept at this level and prices rise, they must go short in certain respects. The third class are those whom the Government seek to safeguard by the operation of Order No. 83 and the subsequent Order No. 166. There is no such safeguard for them. Probably the persons getting the least luxurious food in this country are the prisoners in the jails, and Deputy O'Sullivan has already pointed out the increase that has taken place in the provision for the food alone of those prisoners. It has almost doubled—from £11 two or three years ago to £21 this year. The fourth class are those persons in receipt of unemployment assistance and so on. There is no class in that whole category—four different orders of the community—that is not worse off than it was two or three years ago. This Budget affords no relief whatever. The mere £100,000 down for fuel is almost a mockery. One would walk three miles of streets in the poorer class areas of Dublin last winter before one would see smoke coming from a chimney, and that is not to be wondered at if turf is sold at 64/- a ton.

On that £44,000,000 there is a possibility of economy. It should not be beyond the wit of man to find it. The Minister devoted three or four pages of his statement to a eulogy of the Civil Service. Nobody found fault with the Civil Service. It is highly appreciated in this House, but I may say this—and I think the civil servants themselves would realise it—they owe much more to the State than the State owes to them. The Minister is rendering a grave disservice by bringing in such matters. When the Minister came into office the Civil Service cost £1,500,000 less than it does at present. Have the citizens got value for the extra £1,500,000? The Minister may think so, but I do not. They could get value for it if there were the economies that ought to be effected in this huge bill of £44,000,000. If the civil servants alone were left to settle that, they would probably make a much better success of it than the Minister has made.

Comment on this

The Opposition have been trying to discuss the Minister's statement as though it were a Budget. Of course, it is not a Budget at all; it is merely a good electioneering stunt. This Budget does neither one thing nor the other: it does not try to bring expenditure within income, and it does not envisage a broad inflationary policy, designed to borrow all the available funds in this country and spend them on tangible assets, so that, at the conclusion of the present emergency, there may be something left. It does neither the one thing nor the other, but it gives expression to the fact that the old war-horse is pawing the ground and sniffing the air. He thinks there is a general election likely to become desirable next September, and that abstention from imposing any fresh taxation is calculated to placate the one section of the community that does not usually support him and bring some grist to his electoral mill. From that point of view, it is a most excellent Budget: it has intoxicated the Irish Times. Since it was published, Mr. de Valera has become their hero, and Mr. Lemass their “bonny fechter”— according to their leading article—who snatches the initiative and dominates the Dáil. In so far as I am concerned, Fianna Fáil is welcome to their new recruit. That publication has been wrong in the public life of this country for the past 82 years and it would be a shame to spoil its record now.

I must say that I could not forbear smiling when I heard Labour and Fianna Fáil wrangling with one another as to what were the reasons why we did not import wheat in sufficient quantities before the war. Did anybody in this House ever hear of "Grow more Wheat" or of national self-sufficiency? When people suggested in 1936, 1937 or 1938 that we should import wheat, they were told they were "sabotaging the national effort" and "playing England's game." Deputy Norton now wants to know from the Minister for Supplies why he did not bring in wheat when he could get it at 15/- a barrel and the Minister replies that they brought in all they could get, and as a result flour is not as dear to-day as it otherwise would be. Does anybody in this House believe that Fianna Fáil was bringing in all the wheat that could be got in September, 1939? Do they not know, as I know, that people would not be allowed to bring in flour or wheat in September, 1939, if they could stop it? What will these people think of the Minister for Supplies, acting the part of the Irish Times“bonny fechter”, getting up and telling Deputy Norton that he was bringing in all he could get, and that he could justify his present position by the knowledge that he did his duty by bringing in all the imported wheat he could buy? That at a time when he was preaching to the poor innocents of Fianna Fáil the doctrine of national self-sufficiency, and that it was a crime against the Irish agriculturist to bring in foreign wheat.

Then there is the black market. Who was the father and the mother of the black market? Seán Lemass, Minister for Supplies. I say deliberately here that the black market functions in this country, and derives its inspiration and existence, from the incompetence of the Minister for Supplies, and I will prove it. It makes me physically sick to witness the Irish Times and the Minister for Supplies patting one another on the back, and describing all those connected with the black market as criminals. Such a pair of warriors inveigh against a poor country woman because she goes to the black market to get a stone of flour for her children. What is a woman to do who walks five miles into a country town four days in succession to try to get flour from a shopkeeper who has no flour? When she is going home on the fifth day to her hungry children somebody asks her if she got the flour, after having walked nearly 40 miles. She says “No,” and she is told that there is a fellow down the town who has flour at 7/- a stone and to slip down there for it. She goes back and for 7/- she gets a stone of flour for her children. Is that woman a criminal? Or is the man who made her do that a criminal? I say that the man who has been drawing £1,700 a year for the last ten years and boasting that he was Minister for Supplies for the last four years is the criminal, if there are criminals. Was he not asked two years ago to ration flour? Was he not told last January 12 months that if he did not ration flour a time would come when nobody but the rich could get flour? Was he not warned that if he did not ration flour a time would come when the poor would have to go without it? His answer was that he knew that rationing was not necessary and that an equitable distribution could be maintained without resorting to so expensive an expedient. He told us that he had not the paper with which to provide ration books, but now they are being issued. Was that poor woman a criminal because she discharged her duty to her children?

What do you mean by the black market? There is a very common habit growing up in this House, one that the Fianna Fáil Party introduced, to create dilemmas from which no man can escape with honour intact and then indulge in a fury of denunciation of people whom they themselves have forced into evil ways. What do they mean by the black market? I know what I mean by it. A man who trades in the black market, to me, means one who gets supplies allocated by the Government for distribution amongst his customers, who denies these supplies to his customers and sells them to other people at fancy prices. That man I would put in jail. Whether they are widows with orphans or people with large families, if they get supplies at Government fixed prices to distribute amongst customers, and sell them to someone else at inflated prices, into Mountjoy they should go and in Mountjoy they would stay, whether their sons are in the Fianna Fáil cumainn or not. There is no reason to be sentimental about vampires who would suck the blood out of people in hunger or in distress. Let us define the kind of person upon whom vengeance should be visited. Let us not act like mad bulls charging around the country and striking down all and sundry without a thought of the true nature of the guilty. Do you know that if it were not for people who are charging fantastic prices for many commodities at the present time half the people might be hungry? Do you realise that a very large proportion of supplies being consumed in the west of Ireland and in our northern counties are being smuggled into this country, and that, if not so smuggled, the people would go hungry?

These fantastic creatures who masquerade as a Government get up and pretend that the supplies position is not so bad as a result of their machinations. The supplies position is indescribably bad as a result of their machinations. If the smugglers were not allowed to function, hundreds of people would now be hungry. You want to stop that. Do you want to stop the fellow who goes to Northern Ireland and who smuggles out food without which people here would go hungry? Do you want to put that man in jail? Do you regard him as a criminal? I know you do not, though many of you have not the courage to admit it. Go down the country and ask any reasonable person where he thinks the sulphate of ammonia came from. Was it out of the air? Where do you think the white flour is coming from? Where do you think the bread is coming from? Where do you think the cotton thread is coming from? Is it falling like manna from Heaven? Why do you think the Minister took the duty and the prohibition off imports of white flour? Was it that he thought it would come here through the Port of Galway? The same tulip will get up and denounce the people, whom he sent out to collect the flour, as criminals for bringing it in. Surely, there is a limit to the codology and hypocrisy that can be carried on or are we such oinseachs that we will stand for it indefinitely? I do not mind an honest blackguard but I detest the whited sepulchre. Criminals! If they are criminals, they are criminals because they were sent out to commit the crime of trading in the black market. I challenge the Minister on the Front Bench to deny that his officials paid 2/- per stone for oats in East Donegal when the fixed price was 10/8 a cwt.

Comment on this

I deny it.

Comment on this

I hope your denial will be accepted in East Donegal. I say that the Minister's officials paid 2/- per stone for oats, or 16/- per cwt., when the fixed price was 10/8. If they had not done that, they would not have got any seed oats to distribute. When that had been revealed, the Minister made the intelligent Order that those persons——

Comment on this

I cannot allow the Deputy to go on in that fashion.

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

Yes. The Deputy has stated an untruth. My Department did nothing illegal.

Comment on this

What did they do?

Comment on this

They bought oats at the price fixed for seed oats.

Comment on this

I say that the fixed price——

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

When the Minister offers a denial, the Deputy must accept it.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

No. This is not a personal matter.

Comment on this

I say that the price fixed for all oats purchased from a farmer was 10/8. The seed merchant might process that oats, bag it and resell it at 18/- a cwt. The Minister's officials went out to buy oats for processing and distribution in the congested areas and under Departmental schemes. They found it impossible to persuade anybody to part with oats at 10/8. They paid 2/- a stone, and the Minister, discovering this situation, made a new Order, amending the original Order, permitting a person going to a farmer to purchase oats with the intention of reselling them as seed oats to pay up to 18/- a cwt. for these oats.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this

Did you not make an amending Order?

Comment on this

Yes, but what the Deputy has said and is trying to get away with is——

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

I say that what you have stated is untrue.

Comment on this

You can get up and speak after me.

Comment on this

It may be very hard to catch up with what you say.

Comment on this

I say that the Minister then made an order allowing the seed merchant to pay any price he liked for oats but constraining the seed merchant to go on selling the oats at 18/-. I say that that Order was made to cover up the activities of his own inspectors who engaged in procedure which, if indulged in by an ordinary merchant, would be described as "trading in the black market" and which would earn the epithet of "criminal" from the Minister for Supplies. Let us be as clear as crystal on this matter because it is vital we should be clear upon it. The person who gets supplies at a fixed price from the Government and sells them at an inflated price to customers other than those for whom they were intended is a criminal. He should be dealt with as a criminal and should be sent to jail without the option of a fine. But do not put down everybody who is selling goods at high prices at the present time as a criminal because, if these persons were not bringing smuggled goods into this country, the supply situation would be ten times worse than it is. I say, deliberately, that the father and mother of black markets in this country is Seán Lemass, the Minister for Supplies. I say that because, through his inefficiency, through his incompetence and through his lack of foresight, he has created a situation in which it has become virtually impossible to segregate the man of goodwill from the black market profiteer, who ought to be in Mountjoy.

Nobody has a right to make that indictment of the Minister for Supplies if he is not prepared to point out where that Minister went wrong and to explain how that Minister can put things right. The Minister for Supplies went wrong: (1) because he had not the foresight to realise what was about to happen: (2) because, for at least two years, he was too lazy to do his work; he was simply not doing his job; and (3) even now he has not realised—the Labour Party have fallen into this error, too—that you cannot control the price of everything. The thing cannot be done—even under Hitler or Stalin. What you must do, if you want to avoid racketeering, is to pick out a restricted number of articles, an equitable supply of which is vital to all sections of the community, and control these articles right from the source of production up to the point of consumption. If you want to fix the price of flour and ensure that that flour will be sold at that price and equitably distributed, you should take over the flour from the wheat-field to the loaf and administer it all the way through. When you do that and, at the same time, establish a proper, centralised ration scheme, founded on ration books such as have been distributed during the past few days, then, and then only, will you get equitable distribution and adherence to the just price. The Minister for Supplies constantly shouts across the House: "Let Deputies not imagine that the issue of ration books is going to result in enough for everybody." Nobody in this House is fool enough to think it will but what we all know is that the issue of ration books will mean that everybody will get the same share as his neighbour and that you will not have one man getting too much and the next man getting nothing at all.

Many Deputies imagine that shopkeepers ought to carry out this business of rationing, and the object of the Government seems to be to try to fasten upon shopkeepers responsibility for the present chaos. How is a shopkeeper to ration flour? How is he to know how many people live in each customer's house? The best he can do is, possibly, to give a quarter-stone of flour to a family with no children, a half-stone to a family with children, and a bag of flour to people from the country who come in only every six weeks. But that is manifestly unfair when you consider it in detail. A man and his wife living in the country may be getting a bag of flour in this way, while a man, his wife and seven children may be getting only the same amount of flour. If a shopkeeper wanted to operate a proper and equitable rationing system as between his customers, he would ruin himself in endeavouring to maintain a proper system of records. Remember, the gross profit on a bag of flour is only 1/- or 1/3. You have nothing out of that wherewith to set up an elaborate rationing system as between one family and another. If you did so, you would lose heavily on your flour trade. My experience of the country shopkeepers is that in the vast majority of cases they are doing their best equitably to distribute the goods. There are a few blackguards amongst them, as there are amongst other sections of the community, who are trying to make hay while the sun shines. My advice to the Government is to go out after these individuals, put them in jail and keep them in jail.

Let me deal with another commodity before you begin throwing the word "criminal" about. The genius who is seated on the Government Bench has succeeded in producing a situation in which you cannot get a stone of oatmeal, and he is proud of it. He thinks it is wonderful. It is the first time that has happened since Brian Boru was killed at Clontarf.

I need not tell Deputies in this House who come from the country how the complete disappearance of oatmeal has aggravated the problem of the flour shortage. If I had oatmeal to distribute amongst the people living around me I would not care so much about flour. I could give them half a stone a week and, if they had unlimited oatmeal, it would not be very comfortable, but they could get along all right, but there is not a tint of oatmeal to be got in any part of the country at the present time. Is it a crime for a small shopkeeper to go into the local market and buy oats from the farmers at 25/- a cwt., have them converted into oatmeal, and distribute them at a price based on 25/- for oats, plus milling costs? Or, would it be better for that man to say to the farmer who had the oats: "Take them down and get them crushed and feed them to the pig. It is legitimate to feed them to the pig, but Seán Lemass, Minister for Industry and Commerce, says that you are a criminal if you get oatmeal made of it and feed it to the children." Do Deputies in this House agree that it is criminal to feed oats to children instead of to pigs? I do not, but I say that the people who have created a situation in which the bulk of the oats of this country is being fed to pigs instead of to the children might properly be described as criminals. Would it be any extravagant figure of speech to call them embezzlers for taking a salary for doing that? These are the people who should be arraigned, not the unfortunates down the country who are struggling to keep body and soul together. Sometimes when I come to Dublin and tell some of the gentlemen who make their living in this city the facts of what is happening down the country, they shake their heads and say: "He is always exaggerating."

Comment on this

No wonder they would.

Comment on this

Of course they do. Dispensary doctors who have not seen their dispensary districts for 35 years have forgotten all about them.

Comment on this

I never was in a dispensary.

Comment on this

You would have adorned one if you had. Here is a letter from a woman, and I want to ask Deputies of this House would they deem her to be a criminal if she went out and paid 3/6 for half a stone of flour:—

"My household consists of 11 people, including eight children under 15 years. For the past three days, Saturday, Sunday and to-day, I have received from my bread supplier five 1 lb. pan loaves, which gives each of us an average of two-and-a-half ounces of bread per day. This is not an isolated instance but, with the help of some flour and buttermilk, I have been able to supplement the bread ration. Now I am unable to get either flour or buttermilk to bake and my bread supplier tells me that there is absolutely no hope of his being able to give me any more than he is giving me. I am sorry I cannot send you written confirmation of these facts but my supplier refused to put anything in writing when I asked him. If flake oatmeal was obtainable I could substitute it for the bread but I am only able to get a negligible supply of that commodity. I wrote to the Department of Supplies a fortnight ago about this matter and have not even heard an acknowledgment. Surely one is entitled to an equal share of what is available. Any assistance you would give me in getting this share would be deeply appreciated."

Do you think that woman would be a criminal if she went to some person other than her supplier and paid 3/6 for half a stone of flour, or would you say the Minister for Supplies, who is receiving a salary annually to ensure the equitable distribution of essential supplies, was the criminal for leaving a woman with a household of eight children under 15 years of age with a bread ration of 2½ ozs. of bread per day?

I would ask the Minister for Supplies, and his patron, the Irish Times, to examine their consciences and the next time they wish to exchange bouquets on their respective capacity as bonny fechters, to ask themselves rather if they could not do their own respective jobs more efficiently than they have ever shown any tendency to do them up to now because if they did, it would probably not be necessary for them to play the rôle of J'accuse either in the Press or in Dáil Eireann. The people only ask them to do their respective jobs and, when they do not, they should not blame the unfortunates who are driven to expedients for which they have no relish in order to remedy the gross failure of the responsible Minister to do his particular task. Does the House know we are going to have a black market very shortly for pony traps?

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

We have it already.

Comment on this

They are all bought up, except what the Jews have made a corner in.

Comment on this

Might I ask Deputy Belton who enabled the Jews to make a corner in them? I will tell him. Seán MacEntee, the present Minister for Local Government and Public Health, when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce, took the duty off horse-drawn vehicles to permit supplies to come into this country. Seán Lemass replaced him as Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the day after he got into office again he put on the duty again. When the black market in horse-drawn vehicles was well under way, when further supplies were no longer available, the genius took the duty off again, the day before yesterday. Did Deputy Belton know that? Supplies of these commodities were coming in. The Minister for Supplies, the scourge of black market criminals, created a black market in that commodity of all commodities, and then, when the ghost rose up to haunt him, he suddenly took off the duty when he discovered there were no more horse-drawn vehicles to be got. How many other commodities has the tariff been taken off when no supplies were available?

Comment on this

Rubber for one—tyres.

Comment on this

Was he not asked in 1939 to take the tariffs off commodities? Would he do it? Over his dead body—he would wreck the Government before they could do it. Now they are coming off like leaves in autumn from a tree. Vallambrosa is not in it with him. When supplies were available he was quite firm; but there are no restrictions now; he has taken them all off, when there is not anything to buy.

Comment on this

There is one particular class of goods left and he is trying to keep them out. They will not be there long. When they are no longer available, he will let them in.

Comment on this

However, he fixes a price for bicycles.

Comment on this

There are no bicycles.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton interjects: "There are no bicycles." It would be quite unusual to find the Minister for Supplies fixing a price for anything of which there were supplies available. That would not be keeping up his record at all. I want to make this clear, before I depart from this extremely unsavoury topic of the Minister for Supplies and all his works and pomps: there is only one effective way to fix prices and equitably to distribute goods and that is to control them from the source to the consumer. It is physically impossible to do that in regard to every class of merchandise which moves in the market that supplies the community. A responsible Minister, therefore, should first determine a limited number of articles which it is essential effectively to control; secondly, he should take over the production and distribution of those articles from the beginning down to the consumer; thirdly, he should establish a central rationing organisation which would be rigidly applied to all the commodities determined upon; fourthly, he should fix prices wholesale and retail and any person acquiring supplies at the fixed wholesale prices, who sells them to any individual other than the rationed persons for whom they were intended at excess prices should go to jail and stay in jail until his offence is purged.

If you extend price control over the whole range of commodities in a haphazard way you can do nothing but evil, and I specially commend that fact to the Labour Party. We should concentrate on the necessities. We should endeavour to control them and we can do that, but let none of us imagine that doing that will result in 100 per cent. supplies for everybody. We know it will not. But what we are concerned to ensure is that there will not be 120 per cent. for one person and 15 per cent for his next-door neighbour. Whether the ration be 80 per cent., 60 per cent., 40 per cent., or 20 per cent., we want to see everybody treated fairly. We want to see everybody in the big house and in the small house getting his 20 per cent., so that, in respect of all these essential commodities at least, the rich man and the poor man, the big man and the little man, will all be on an equal footing, and we in this House will be able to say that, acute as the crisis has been, so far as our resources permitted, we allowed nobody to become familiar with destitution.

To pass from that unsavoury subject, I read recently a topic that was a source of very considerable satisfaction to me. I find my vindication is coming thick upon me. In an unguarded moment, the tariff racketeers of this country invited the Taoiseach to dinner. Little they knew the Taoiseach or what an awkward customer the Taoiseach can be on occasion. Were it not for the fact that we know the Taoiseach to be so abstemiously temperate, one would suspect that the observations to which he gave utterance at that dinner were of a postprandial character. I would have given a fortune to be there. After he had risen and had been received with respectful applause, the head of the State, the Taoiseach, began to muse as he so frequently does, on economic problems. In the course of his musings the Taoiseach was heard to say in that holy of holies of the tariff racketeers: "Tariffs, he supposed, were a necessary evil." I can picture the white ties and the gold watch chains sinking under the table. Just imagine, the source, the fountain head of economic self-sufficiency, the foster-father of all the tariff racketeers in this country, speaking of that holy institution of tariffs as a necessary evil.

Well, I welcome the Taoiseach halfway on his conversion. We are at least at one in regard to the evil, and I trust that a very few months instruction may bring him to realise that the evil is not necessary, and that once we can bring that lesson home to him, he will cease to be as great a menace to this country as he has been for the last 25 years. But sometimes my zeal for his education flags, and I think, in fact, the antics of Fianna Fáil mean very little in the world in which we live. The future of this country is not going to be determined by the follies of Taoiseach de Valera or any other member of the Fianna Fáil Party. The political future and freedom of our people are being determined for generations in the Coral Sea, in Libya, and in the air over Germany. On the issue of these conflicts our future depends, and in the new world that will emerge from the democratic victory that may yet take a considerable time, there will be no room for tariffs, for Fianna Fáil "codology", or for self-sufficiency— God save the mark. Therefore, to labour on at the attempt to educate this bunch is becoming a work of supererogation. Facts are going to educate them where precepts never could. Indeed, I suppose any intelligent man will realise that children seldom learn wisdom from precept. Experience is the only medium through which wisdom can be acquired, and since the children of Fianna Fáil got hold of the expensive toy of tariffs they have acquired some very salutary lessons.

I said when I first described this Budget that it was neither fish, flesh nor good red herring. One could understand the Minister for Finance saying: "We have got to raise revenue to meet current expenses; we have got to impose taxation up to the limit to prevent inflation. We have got to meet all outgoings from current revenue." One could respect him then as an honest, if a misguided man. One could have said: "That is an honest man. There is a man who is prepared to face unpopularity, even hatred, in order to do whatever he thinks will promote the common interest." One could understand Mr. Blythe introducing a Budget of that kind. He was an almost masochistic type who was prepared to do what he thought was right, no matter what the cost. He would, in fact, I think, have been wrong. But suppose the Minister for Finance had turned his back on that consideration and said deliberately to his colleagues in the Government: "There is no use in encouraging the State to save at the present time because all the money it saves will go into the banks on deposit. The banks will lend it to the British Government because they have nobody else to whom they can lend it. The British Government, which at the present moment is spending £13,000,000 per diem, will gladly take it, and when they come to repay it at the end of the war they will repay it in currency debased in value to 6d. in the £."

Therefore, one could imagine the Minister for Finance saying: "It is as well for us to borrow all the surplus money that is knocking about and spend it on some comprehensive scheme which will leave us some tangible assets at the end of this war and if there is to be any repayment of loans in a depreciated currency, we shall do the repaying in depreciated currency. We will at least have it to say that we secured for the community some tangible assets from those who are foolish enough to exchange goods for currency during the time of the war." The Minister has not got the courage to face the problem in that way. At the moment he has brought in a Central Bank Bill and he is concerned to display himself as an exponent of conservatism and prudence in high finance. A very decent man he is, for whom I always had a great personal regard, but the truth is that neither he nor the Taoiseach has the faintest understanding of high finance or central banking. These two gentlemen are now engaged in the pretence of being the arch-priests of conservative and prudent financial administration. I think this is the shrewdest and cutest Budget they could produce.

I want to make the case, and I hope I shall not unduly shock the Leader of the Opposition, that I think the Government would have been wiser, if they had the intelligence, to work out an intensive plan for utilising money at the present time. I think people are just daft to be saving money at the present time. I think money lent to our own Government at the present for the purpose of securing valuable, permanent, tangible assets is something infinitely better worth while than an accumulation of so-called savings in the form of currency, the value of which God only knows, in two or three years' time. Now, there are those who say that fixed-interest securities and Government loans are not the only things into which you could put savings, but so much savings are going to be put into these things during this period of trial that when the revaluation comes all those who have put their savings into British Government stocks, fixed-interest securities, and things of that sort, will suffer losses, and these losers will insist that all those who put their savings into real estate or tangible assets of that kind will not be allowed to go scot free, so far as their creditors in England are concerned, at any rate.

Therefore, I think that the time has come to use our resources boldly now and, mind you, I am going to call to my aid in defence of that proposition two men, one of whom, I think, commands the admiration of Deputy Mulcahy, and that is Mr. Geoffrey Crowther, and the other, Mr. Keynes, who is a director of the Bank of England, which should commend him to the conservative views of the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach. Crowther was recently speaking at one of those grotesque Brains Trust corroborees where a lot of half-wits in England sit around a table and masquerade as wisdom personified. I must say, however, that Crowther was not one of these people and was there only as a guest, but the very fact that he was there at all tended to make me suspect his intentions. However, in the course of the symposium, somebody asked Crowther:—

"Suppose you were a member of Parliament and were afforded the opportunity of introducing one Bill now, to what end would you draft that legislation?"

His reply was:—

"I would have no hesitation. I would introduce a Bill for the immediate establishment of a system of family allowances in this country, and I would consider that I had done the greatest possible service to England by the introduction of such a measure."

Now, remarkably enough, Keynes, in his famous plan, which he advanced for compulsory savings, and which has been partly adopted by the British Government, incorporated in that plan a scheme for family allowances, but the compulsory savings part of the plan got so much publicity that the family allowance part of it was completely overshadowed. Keynes' plan, how ever, followed these lines generally: that a certain proportion of everybody's income should be taken and that, in respect of that portion, the individual would be deemed to be a creditor of the national debt, post-war. In addition to this arrangement, Mr. Keynes proposed that part of the money withdrawn from circulation by his plan should be allotted to a scheme of family endowment which should pay an allowance of 5/- a week to every child in the country under the age of 15. It will be noted that under this plan saving can be made in other directions: on unemployment allowances, income-tax rebate, pensions, and a variety of other services where money is specially appropriated for the relief of indigent families. Keynes estimated that that would cost, in Great Britain, about £100,000,000 per annum, and he agreed with Crowther that immense as are the commitments of Great Britain at the present time, no greater service could be done to the State than to embark on such a plan now.

Now, Deputy Mulcahy, when he was discussing the Central Bank Bill, directed attention to the fact that many people had lost sight of what was the real fundamental cause of slumps and the disastrous unemployment and sufferings that eventuated from them. I think I quote him correctly when I say that he suggested to the House that, very often, a slump is precipitated not by any diminution in the volume of money but by a slowing down in the velocity of its circulation, resulting in the diminution of individual income.

Comment on this

Because the money is not there.

Comment on this

No, I am not prepared to accept that. It is the slowing down of the velocity of circulation.

Comment on this

Well, think it out.

Comment on this

I shall give the Deputy something to reflect upon, and I venture to quote this remark by Crowther, from his book, An Outline of Money, which may be described as a very elementary primer with regard to money, but into the small compass of which he has managed to pack an astonishingly large amount of information. On page 136 of that book, Crowther says:—

"We must go in search of that mainspring. And we shall find a clue for our search in the observation that what is lacking in a time of depression is not so much money as incomes. It is easy to establish that there is often as much money in existence at the bottom of a slump as there was at the height of the preceding boom—and if there has been some reduction in the quantity of bank deposits, the reason is not to be found in any unwillingness of the banks to create money, but in an unwillingness of the public to request the creation of money by borrowing from the banks.”

The Taoiseach might bear that in mind the next time he starts talking about money, and he might realise that that was one of the things that tended to restrict the banks from creating money: that a bank desiring to create credit money, must not only be prepared to lend, but to find somebody solvent who is prepared to borrow. I continue with the quotation:—

"What is manifestly lower at the bottom of a slump than at the top of a boom is not the quantity of money but the total of individual incomes. If people had the incomes, they would use the supply of money actually and potentially in existence; the velocity of circulation would increase and prices would rise. It is because money is not paid out in incomes that it languishes in stagnant pools.

"The value of money, in fact, is a consequence of the total of incomes rather than of the quantity of money. It is the causes of fluctuations in the total of incomes of which we must go in search."

Now, that is an illuminating passage, and I think it is perfectly correct. I re-inforce it with a further quotation from the same book, page 140. Crowther pursues that search, to which he refers in the last sentence of the paragraph I have just quoted, and then says:—

"The only conclusion, that it is reasonable to come to on the basis of the evidence is that the sudden lack of demand which causes a depression is due less to a lack of money than to a lack of income. It might be more accurate to say that it is due to a lack of spending; but we know that, in a depression, the reason why people do not spend more money is, in 99 cases out of 100, not unwillingness to spend income in hand, but sheer lack of income.”

Now that lack of income arises very largely in the homes of the comparatively poor, and it is the drying up of spending power in millions of humble homes rather than economies in a few wealthy households that creates the wave of depression which initiates a slump. It is this uncontrollable wave of depression which precipitates a slump. Now, I do not want to suggest to Dáil Eireann that a system of family allowances is going to abolish that evil development in a post-inflationary period. All that I am going to suggest is that it will do something to bring money out of the stagnant pools where it is lying into circulation, not for any unworthy or fictitious purpose but having, as its primary aim, to ensure that no child will suffer from hunger in this country. That is only one minor justification, in the purely economic sphere, for the reform which I am going to suggest to the House might well be financed now from borrowed and tax-raised money, and might properly be maintained for all time in our community out of revenues to be raised by taxes and, preferably, by taxes levied on the incomes of the well-to-do.

Democracy is a queer thing. We have acquired in democratic countries an incomparable capacity for refusing to face disagreeable facts. I do not think there is a single Deputy in this House who would desire to see the situation continue in which the children of the poor went hungry. I think I could go around the whole personnel of every Party in the certainty that every Deputy would say: "Whatever the cost, we shall abolish hunger from every house in this country." Now, I want to say most deliberately to the Deputies of this House that at this present moment there are children starving in this country. I may be answered at once that nobody in this country need go hungry: that they can go to the relieving officer. I want to submit to this House that there are two types of starvation. There is one, the starvation which gives rise to hunger and which evokes hunger pains. I admit that that type of hunger has been substantially met by the social services in this country. But there is another type of hunger which is deadly and infinitely more insidious, and that is the hunger which is characterised by malnutrition: by the filling of children's stomachs in poor homes with bulky food to still the hunger pains, but which does not provide the nutrition requisite to enable the child to grow up to be a healthy man or woman.

I want to tell this House, and I implore Deputies to wake up to the fact, that there are hundreds and thousands of children growing up in this country at the present time who will be invalids all their lives because they are hungry now, and the astonishing thing is that all the Deputies in this House, could they but realise that fact, would be prepared to do all that is in their power to make an end of that. But it seems to be impossible to shake them out of the equanimity with which they walk through the streets of Dublin, Cork, Limerick, Waterford, and other cities, and see children dying under their eyes, growing up into cripples, because their parents have not got the wherewithal to nourish their bodies, as they must be nourished, if they are to become healthy men and women. There is not a Deputy in this House who would not hand over his dinner in order to give his children enough; but what astonishes me is that they do not realise that we in this House are the trustees of the poor. I cannot emphasise too often that it is not for the want of will, but rather for the want of realising that this very limited company that sits here in this House are the trustees of the poor that we have that situation in the country: that we here are the trustees of the poor who cannot defend themselves in this matter.

We sit here quietly and let that situation continue. I say that the type of starvation that exists in this country is due to the fact that the poor parents of large families are not able to afford the food necessary to enable their children to grow up to be healthy men and women. The only person who has attempted to controvert this case so far with me has been a bucolic individual who addressed a letter personally to me and to the Irish Independent saying that there were too many damn children in this country, and he could not see why Deputy Dillon was trying to facilitate the production of any more. If that gentleman writes another letter to me I shall publish his name. I did not answer the last one because, when I wrote a reply, I felt that I might be taken up under the Blasphemy Acts if I sent it through the post. I shall reply to him in public and by name if he addresses any more of his correspondence to me or to the Irish Independent.

Can I induce the Deputies of this House to realise what is happening in the country at the present time? I take the agricultural labourer as typical of the hard-working man with an insufficient income. He gets, perhaps, at the present time 36/- a week. Now, when the first baby is born to that man's household, it is welcome. He is able to make both ends meet. When the second baby arrives, he views its arrival with some modest concern. The third baby is unquestionably a burden, and the fourth and fifth are disasters. That is the plain fact, and Deputies in this House must know of such cases. They must have seen many a young fellow marry and rejoice on the arrival of the first baby. They have seen the rejoicing becoming less and less demonstrative as the family grew, until eventually people were inclined to say: "My God, is Jimmy's wife going to have another? What will the poor fellow do?" Is that not true? Is that a desirable situation to obtain in what is described as a Christian country? It is certainly true. I have heard the comment made myself by people who had nothing but the warmest goodwill and affection for the married couple in question. What seems peculiarly shocking to me is that we in this House are, every one of us, aware of that problem, and are content to leave it there unsolved, more especially when there is a solution available to our hands—it is not the brainchild of some cracked-pot individual— which no one has ever attempted to put into practice. It is in operation in some countries which do not boast of being Christian countries at all, but rather countries which boast of being strictly materialist.

Compare the picture that I have drawn of the agricultural labourer with the man who is earning £1,500 a year. He goes to an income-tax adviser to have his income-tax return filled. The first question the income-tax adviser asks him is: "How many children have you?" When he is told that the number is seven, the income-tax adviser will say: "Glory alleluia, you will not have to pay a penny income-tax at all." How does Dáil Eireann justify leaving a man with 36/- with his 36/- a week and his seven children, and leaving the man with £1,500 a year with his £1,500 a year and his seven children?

How does Dáil Eireann justify the necessity of putting an extra tax on sugar in order to meet the revenue required to give a rebate to the man with £1,500 a year, when the family of the man with 36/- per week is paying for the sugar? That is what we are doing now. All I am asking for the 36/- a week man is exactly similar treatment to that which is afforded to the man with £1,500 a year. That is a simple proposition. That scheme of family allowances is in operation in New South Wales; that scheme of family allowances is in operation all through the Commonwealth of Australia; that scheme of family allowances is in operation all through New Zealand. A scheme of family allowances was in operation in France; a scheme of family allowances was in operation in Belgium; and, to our eternal disgrace, even the Nazis have operated a scheme of family allowances, while we, a professedly Christian country, express complete indifference to it.

Now in some countries the family allowance has been based on earnings or on the particular trade to which the parent belongs. I want to make an entirely new proposal for two reasons: (1) I want to remove all stigma of charity from the family allowances system in this country; (2) I want to eliminate all question of a means test. My idea of family allowances is to keep the bureaucrat outside the home. If you impose a means test, it means that you inject the bureaucrat into every home for the purpose of finding out what income the family has before the family allowance is assessed. I, therefore, propose that a family allowance should be made available to the mother in every family where there are children under 16 years of age, at the rate of 3/- per child after the first child, from the family of the richest man in Ireland down to the family of the poorest itinerant, thus giving to the comparatively well-to-do the income-tax concessions that they at present enjoy in another form, and to the poor, and the not-so-poor, an added amenity that they have never yet had; thus converting the unwelcome fifth, sixth and seventh child in a poor household into a temporal as well as a spiritual blessing. I cannot dwell too long upon that. The truth of it is that, at the present time in Ireland, the fifth and subsequent children in a poor man's home are a visitation from God, and that that is a reflection which should bring a curse upon the community to which we belong. It is within our power to make such children not only a gift from God, but a temporal as well as a spiritual blessing.

I do not underestimate the cost of the proposal that I make. I have tried to get some figures together, and I am bound to assure Dáil Eireann that these figures are not reliable; but they are as near as I can go to what the possible cost would be, without all the technical information that might be available to a Minister of State. But, going as near to it as I can, I believe the proposal to give to the mother of every child after the first child a family allowance, let us say, of 3/- to begin with—we might be able to make it a little more if the scheme prospered— would cost approximately £4,000,000 per annum.

I believe that that figure can be reduced by the savings that would be effected in the disappearance of the necessity for paying for children under the unemployment insurance scheme, the unemployment assistance scheme, the income-tax allowance, the free food distribution scheme, the outdoor assistance scheme, the widows' and orphans' pensions scheme, the subsidised housing schemes, and through a variety of other channels where special State expenditure is at present being made in order to provide for the children of indigent men. Therefore, although the figure of £4,000,000 may seem a very formidable impost, speaking as an income-tax payer on whom the burden would fall as heavily as it would fall on most Deputies, I say that that scheme should be initiated now out of borrowed money, and, if necessary, out of such tax money as could properly be raised, with the firm resolution that it was going to be maintained post-war out of money raised by taxation.

I said on another occasion that I could not contemplate a system of this kind unless we foresaw our way permanently to finance it out of revenue and I adhere to that view. But, in the situation in which we find ourselves at the present time, my prime concern is to turn currency into fixed tangible assets. We cannot buy the raw materials of building, we cannot buy the raw materials of roads, we cannot buy the raw materials of almost all the permanent things that would be valuable no matter what way currency went in the years that lie ahead. But we can buy one thing; we can buy health and strength for the generations of our people who are now growing and who are about to come into the world. What more tangible and enduring asset could we buy than that? For what expenditure might we more properly borrow money at present? Is there any economist, however orthodox, in this House, who challenges the proposition that a prudent man will convert cash and credits into tangible assets now? Will anybody say that it is better, wiser, more conservative to accept the I.O.U. of the British Government and the Government of the United States of America for currency now than to buy imperishable assets? I do not believe there is. Is there any man to-day who will take £1,000 in British war loan in preference to a house which was good value for £1,000 two years ago? Is there anybody who will take United States Government gold bonds to-day after the Gold Act has been passed in the United States of America in preference to 20 acres of rich land? I doubt it, because he would say: "The land will be there no matter what way the £ goes." He would say: "Bricks and mortar are the safest place to put money when currencies begin to tremble."

All I am suggesting to this House is that, instead of putting money into American gold bonds or British securities, we should put it into children, healthy children. What more enduring asset is there than that? It is an asset, the value of which will be apparent not only in this generation or the next generation but in countless generations to come, and without it the whole future of this nation may be put in jeopardy. For that reason, and that reason only, I say: "Here is an asset that we can buy now by putting purchasing power into the hands of indigent families through a scheme of family allowances of this kind, and thus avoid the dispatch of our nutritious food to Great Britain, there to acquire in exchange credits which we cannot use now and which post-war might be valueless, not through the fault of Britain, not through the fault of the United States of America, but because they are pouring out their wealth in order to keep us free."

I would give them all we had to help them in that fight, in every sense of the word, in the profound conviction that it is a fight for the survival of Ireland, as well as a fight for the survival of every free people in the world; in the profound conviction that it is a fight for the survival of the right of every man to render unto God the things that are God's and unto Cæsar the things that are Caesar's. But I cannot control foreign policy in this country. What one can do, I have done it, and failing my ability to get my country to their aid with all that I had, or to induce my fellow countrymen to do it, I face the fact that here is a great reform, here is an opportunity to purchase with our money an imperishable asset, and to establish, with a view to maintaining it for all time out of national income and as a first charge upon it, a social reform which for the first time would confer true freedom on all our people, economic freedom, the knowledge that no combination of power, however great, could grind any citizen of this country into subjection by threatening his children or his wife with hunger; an assurance to the smallest tenant farmer, the humblest working man, the striker or the worker, whoever had a wife, wherever there was a woman anxious for her children, that there would be funds to enable her to buy them food and to cover their nakedness, and that, so long as she had the right to call herself an Irishwoman, the children she had brought into the world for the Irish nation would be cherished by the community to which she belonged as prizes, treasures, and gifts from God, and not despised, as they would appear to be, as merely new nuisances and problems and afflictions visited upon an unhappy married couple.

Bring this thing down to its lowest basis of justification. If a manufacturer had bought spare parts for his machines, and laid them by in storage, would he suffer those spare parts to rot and rust away while his machines were working themselves into such a condition that the employment of those spare parts would be necessary for the maintenance of his business? I do not think any sane businessman would. I think he would spend whatever money was necessary to house and lubricate those spare parts, so that when the time came that he had to employ them they would be good and strong and effective for the work for which they were intended. Surely this nation is accumulating spare parts now in the children that are being born. Those are the spare parts which will fit into the body politic of this State and make it function in the years to come. Thousands of them are rotting and rusting away under the corrosion of malnutrition which arises from the fact that the mother of many in this country has not the wherewithal to buy them food. All I am asking this House is that we should here determine that in the future a first charge upon our national income will be a provision to ensure that whoever is born into an Irish home will be guaranteed not luxury, not an easy life, but just the bare minimum to keep body and soul together in health and strength, whether it be the house of a poor man or a rich man, and let the individual effort of the father add amenities to that provision if the opportunity presents itself to him. That seems a simple thesis. The cost of that is going to be in the order of £4,000,000 a year. No better investment could conceivably be made in this period of the declining value of currency and credit. Borrow the money now, and for the duration of this period of crisis, provided that, post-war, we here and the people we stand for are prepared to shoulder the burden of taxation necessary to maintain that scheme out of revenue down through the ages.

I am profoundly convinced that if this case is put to the income-tax payers of this country, formidable as the burden may be, they will cheerfully face it rather than that they should go on enjoying luxury while their fellow citizen's children literally starve. Instead of producing this unholy thing which is neither fish, flesh nor good red herring, but the plumes for a battle helmet for the old warrior getting ready for the hustings, if the Minister for Finance had had the courage to come in here and act the part of Ernest Blythe, with an honest austerity and something supremely admirable in the indifference to public opinion, or if, on the other hand, with imagination and vision he had come in here and said: "I have been casting about for a safe repository for the savings of our people in those troubled times. I have been rebuked that the proceeds of our foreign sales are taking the shape of idle credits which we cannot convert into enduring assets, and I have resolved to employ that surplus money now in the purchase of the most enduring asset imaginable by the mind of man," then I would be put in the horrible dilemma of voting for him. I have only done it once before in my life, and I have often wondered if I was justified. I would have had to face that deplorable duty again, but, as usual, Fianna Fáil has fallen down on the job. It could not do the big thing.

Now, let me conclude by saying that I do not want to suggest to anybody that they failed to do it because they were indifferent. I do not want to raise any political hare and declare that the Fianna Fáil Party are becoming the bankers' children or servants or anything of that kind. I do not attribute their failure to seize this magnificent opportunity to any evil in them. They have not the vision, the wisdom or the courage to do things like that. Is there any use hoping that the Minister might acquire these virtues and, before the election comes along, announce that he is going to embark upon this greatest and most urgent of social reforms? If he were to do that, unworthy as his Party's record has been in the history of this country. I think the name of O Ceallaigh would be well and favourably remembered not only in the houses of the poor in Ireland, but in the houses of the poor in every country that would follow Ireland's example when they saw the results of the experiment that I advocate to-day.

Comment on this
James Ryan Minister for Agriculture (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I want to deal first with one matter Deputy Dillon spoke of before he proceeded to speak of family allowances. He accused the officers of my Department of paying more than the legal price for seed oats in Donegal. I told him that that was not true, but he persisted in the statement, simply because he is very much more interested—and it is not to-day that I learned that—in making his case, whatever the facts underlying it may be, than he is in the truth. He did not accept what I said. I suppose it does not matter very much whether he does or not. He said later that when he told these things to his friends in Dublin they told him he was a gross exaggerator. Obviously his friends did not like to hurt his feelings by telling him what they really thought of his statement, and I expect the Chair would not allow me to say what I really think of it.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny that they paid that price in Donegal— more than 10/8?

Comment on this

That is a different thing.

Comment on this

What is the difference?

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to retrace his steps now. He would not do it when he was making his statement.

Comment on this

What did happen?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister must be given an opportunity to indicate what happened—state his view of the matter.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not accept the truth.

Comment on this

What happened?

Comment on this

The Deputy said my officers went to Donegal and paid more than the legal price for seed oats and, finding that they had to pay more, they came back and made an Order to legalise the price. That is not true, and if the Deputy persists in making that statement we know what to think.

Comment on this

I believe it is true.

Comment on this

I say it is not true.

Comment on this

I believe the Minister is deceived. It is my belief that that happened.

Comment on this

It is not belief on my side. I know that what the Deputy has said is untrue. He is sticking to it, knowing it is untrue, and therefore he is deliberately trying to mislead the House.

Comment on this

I do not know that it is untrue. I believe it is the truth. I am not questioning the Minister's good faith at all.

Comment on this

But it is not true.

Comment on this

That is your belief—I believe the other thing.

Comment on this

It is not my belief. I am sure of it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dillon has had a good innings.

Comment on this

When I was speaking the Minister interrupted me at least three times.

Comment on this

I tried to correct the Deputy, but he would not allow me, because his case was made on a false assumption and he went on with it. There was one other thing in Deputy Dillon's speech with which I wish to deal—I have no desire to reply to all the raiméis we heard from him. He accused the Minister for Supplies—and he was again saying something that was not true—of not bringing in all the wheat that could be brought in at the end of 1939. The Minister for Supplies said we brought in all the wheat for which storage could be found.

Comment on this

Why did you not build storage?

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Minister, although he interrupted me, but I argued that he and the Minister for Supplies made an Order in September, 1939, forbidding us to get supplies of flour. I was trying to persuade him to shove the flour out of the mills into the merchants' stores so that the millers could take in more wheat. The Ministers made an Order forbidding any merchant to get flour from a mill.

Comment on this

I am not in a position to deal with that matter now. I do not know if that is absolutely correct, but I do know that what the Minister for Supplies said was true; he did his best to get wheat into the country in 1939, and did actually bring in whatever there was storage to take. Our own crop was coming in at the same time and, naturally, that also took up a certain amount of room. Deputy Dillon went on to say that the reason why the Minister did not permit wheat to come in at that time was because it was regarded as a crime against Irish agriculture to bring wheat in here. That is only the greatest nonsense, and Deputy Dillon knows it. I am greatly surprised he did not go back to the fantastic argument he put forward here about it being pure "codology" to grow wheat in this country. He did attempt here to make a defence of that fantastic statement that he made some years ago.

Comment on this

There was never a truer word spoken in Dáil Eireann. That was my view about the growing of wheat in peace time.

Comment on this

The Deputy stated that those who did not grow wheat at that time could now grow more than those who did grow wheat then, and that they would get a better crop. It was an ingenious sort of defence, but there is really nothing in it, as was pointed out in the discussion on my Estimate. There is more wheat grown in what were regarded as the wheat-growing counties in 1935-36 and the yield is as good, if not better, in those counties than in the counties Deputy Dillon speaks of, where no wheat was then grown. I do not mean to deal in detail with Deputy Dillon's speech, because it would take too long to do that.

We have not got anything like an agreed criticism of this Budget either from the Opposition or the Labour Party. One criticism was that it was a cowardly Budget because the Minister did not bridge the gap between expenditure and income by taxation. That criticism would lead one to believe that the Minister should have raised a certain amount of money— the £4,500,000 necessary—to meet certain expenditure in the coming year. In addition to that, Deputy Dockrell said he thought the Minister was hardly justified in placing certain items of expenditure on the capital expenditure side. If Deputy Dockrell's opinion were to be taken on this, the deficit in the Budget would be more than £4,500,000, and would have certain items that, according to Deputy Dockrell, could not justifiably be taken from borrowed money. On the other hand, we have had Deputies here speaking about the burden of taxation. We have had some who talked about this failure on the part of the Minister to balance his Budget, and we have had some talking very often about the burden of taxation, saying it is more than people can bear. It is very hard to reconcile one view with the other. The only possible way to reconcile the two views, if held by one person, would be to say that the expenditure side was too high.

I have been reading and listening to the speeches made here, to find suggestions for a reduction in expenditure, but none has come. As a matter of fact, there was only one definite suggestion that I know of. It came from Deputy Cosgrave to-day, and it was that there might be some saving on the Vote for Defence. That is at least a suggestion, a concrete suggestion, but everyone will admit it is one that we will not all agree upon. Apart from that, there was no suggestion as to where any saving could be made. Therefore, as far as the Opposition and the Labour Party are concerned, and as far as I can find from the speeches made, we have the position that it is generally considered that the gap of £4,500,000 should not be there and that, if the Minister for Finance had done his business properly, he should have found some way to avoid showing such a deficit. In addition to that, as I have said already, some Deputies would go so far as to say that, looking at the present Budget as a balance sheet, the deficit should really be more than £4,500,000, as there are certain items that should not be put to capital expenditure.

We have no suggestion for saving but, strange to say, of the Deputies holding the views I have already given, some have pointed out the necessity for further social services. Some members of the Labour Party, in talking about this Budget, spoke of the inadequate social services—unemployment assistance, for instance, and old age pensions. In Deputy Dillon's speech to-day we had the suggestion to spend another £4,000,000 on children's allowances. It is true that Deputy Dillon pointed out that a good part, if not the greater part, of the £4,000,000 would be saved on other Votes like the children's allowances in unemployment assistance, the food vouchers for orphans treated under the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Act and in income-tax allowances. No one—not even Deputy Dillon—will deny that a substantial amount would be added to the £44,000,000 to be found by the Minister for Finance if this scheme of family allowances were brought in. It is rather a usual thing for members of the Opposition and of the Labour Party, whenever a Budget comes before the House, to find fault on both sides in that way. They say too much is being spent and not enough is being raised by way of taxation to meet what is being spent. At the same time, no indication is given as to where any saving may be made, and pressure is used at the same time to enlarge our social services.

I intended to devote myself principally to some of the speeches made on the agricultural industry. They are to the general effect that farming is in a very bad way. We hear that very often here. I suppose it is a general sort of statement that is true in some degree at some times and in a very small degree at other times. We all know that farming never has been a really prosperous career for any person and, what is more, probably never will be. On the other hand, it is a reasonably secure form of existence, particularly in war times if not so much in peace time. There is no use in taking as an example certain men at the lower end of the scale and proving, from their incomes or outgoings, that farming is in a very bad position; there is no use in taking the worst in the farming community. As in every other occupation, some farmers under the most favourable conditions will be unable to make ends meet, and others, no matter how bad conditions may be, will not only make ends meet but succeed in putting a little aside.

There is, of course, a great discrepancy between the conditions in the country and in the towns. At first sight, it does appear that the agricultural labourer who gets only 33/- a week is very badly treated compared to the tradesman in the city; but there are certain things we must keep in mind when making comparisons of that kind. Every urban worker is not an artisan in receipt of £4 or £5 a week; there are many urban workers whose wages are very much lower, and there is a great deal of unemployment—intermittent or more general— amongst the urban population. Again, one must keep in mind, in comparing the two classes, that the rural worker has certain advantages on the expenditure side: he has a very much cheaper house than the urban worker and, in the purchase of such things as fuel, milk and vegetables, he is in a position to buy more cheaply. If these things are kept in mind, it is quite possible—I am not denying it at all— that by weighing them up and comparing the rural worker with the urban worker at the present time, one may find that the rural worker is not as well off as his brother worker in the town. As far as we can, however, especially in the Dáil and in places like this, we should try to keep facts in mind when talking about farming or any other subject. It only gets a bad name for agriculturists in general when the type of speeches made here by members of the Opposition are published. It is often said by people in the towns that the farmers are always complaining. I do not think that is true at all—the farmers do not complain nearly as much as those who speak on their behalf here, and those who speak here and in public places on their behalf are giving the farmer the bad name of being a habitual growler. If the farmers themselves took much notice of what is said here, or if they read the papers, it is quite possible they may get a persecution complex.

I do not wish to go into figures very much, but I want Deputies to realise a few facts about the farming situation at the moment. If possible, what I want to find out is this: how does the farmer stand, comparing his position pre-war with that of other classes? The best thing to do I suppose is to take the Agricultural Price Index with regard to the farmer's income and to compare 1941 and the first three months of this year with 1938, the last complete year.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The last year of the economic war.

Comment on this

The economic war was over. If the Deputy wishes I will take 1939, but it does not make much difference. I am trying to give figures. The Deputy wants to make capital out of this. I want to give real figures so that we may see how farmers stand. I am quite prepared to agree with Deputy Morrissey that the farmer is not as well-off as he might be, but I do not think it will do any good to work on false premises. In 1938 the farm price index was 111.9 and in 1941 162.3, in other words, it went up 45 per cent. It is some what higher for the first three months of this year. I am not sure if farm prices might not be much higher for the first three months than for the rest of the year, and therefore it would be wrong to draw any conclusion from the first three months. For the complete year 1941 the index figure went up by 45 per cent. Against that, let us take the costs to see how they increased. It has been stated by some people who evidently had not the full facts, that in whatever way the farmer's prices increased his costs increased much more. Whatever may be the case that is not true.

Take the items of farmers' outgoings: rent and rates. Rent has not altered since 1938. The total amount of rates payable on agricultural land for the whole of this State, 1938-39 up to 1941-42 increased from £3,900,000 to £4,490,000 and, in each year, might be deducted £1,860,000 as a State contribution towards the relief of rates, an increase over the period of £590,000. That means that rates in that period increased by 15 per cent. Prices went up 45 per cent., and rates only by 15 per cent. Rent did not go up so that there was no increased expenditure there. The next big item that farmers have to contend with is wages, which increased by 6/-. I should say that these were minimum wages. It is probably true that the general wage has gone up more than that. It is possible that in 1938 practically every farmer was paying the minimum wage, while many were paying more than the minimum. The minimum wage went up by 22 per cent. Even if wages went up by half that amount, or by another 3/-, the increased cost to farmers would not have gone up by more than 33 per cent. or 35 per cent., whereas the income had gone up 45 per cent. Then there is the cost of seeds, manures and feeding-stuffs. I will not deal with feeding-stuffs because that is the farmers' business. If one farmer pays another farmer gets the benefit. If a farmer pays too much for feeding-stuffs he has his remedy by growing them for his own use. The same applies to seeds. To the extent of 90 or 95 per cent. seeds are grown in this country, and it is an inter-farm problem as to how they are produced and charged for. It is impossible to deal with manures because we only use about one-fifth of what we were using pre-war, and although the cost is higher, the farmer has not paid any more than he was paying for them. That is not his grievance. His grievance is that he is not getting as good yield as he would get if he had all the artificial manures he required.

On the other hand, apart from farming requisites, the farmer, like the urban dweller, has a household to maintain and has to buy clothes and groceries. These should be covered to some extent, I suppose, by the cost-of-living figure, which in 1938 was 173, and in 1941 226, an increase of 30 per cent. Whatever the farmer may have to buy it has not gone up to the same extent as his income, or as the price he gets for what he sells. Probably the cost of living has gone up, principally owing to the increased cost of food, but the other things have not gone up so much. That is his position as compared with pre-war.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Will the Minister mention farm machinery and implements? Are they not a big factor?

Comment on this

They are important, but comparatively of little importance if the total amount spent on farm machinery and repairs is taken into consideration. It is really only a very small percentage compared with the amount spent on rent, rates, wages and other things. What applies to machinery applies to artificial manures that are unprocurable, and therefore hardly in the picture.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Will the Minister take an ordinary farm dray that could be purchased four or five years ago for £10 and now costs nearly £30?

Comment on this

I will admit that to be true but, even so, the farmer who employs two or three men has a wages bill every year of from £100 to £130. A farmer would only have to purchase a dray every six years so that that would be a small item against him. On the other hand, I want to compare the farmer's position with other classes in the community. It was stated here over and over again that the farmer has not been treated as favourably as other classes. I will preface my remarks by saying that, perhaps, that is true, but I want to show that however badly he may have been treated as compared with other classes, he is certainly comparatively much better treated than he was treated pre-war. Take civil servants, for instance, and other people paid out of Government funds. They got no increase to cover the increased cost of living, while the farmer's income is gone up by 45 per cent. Take manufacturers and business men whose incomes have been limited to a great extent as regards salaries, and absolutely as regards dividends. As far as dividends are concerned, the owners can only draw the same amount as they did before the war.

So far as the companies are concerned, a very big amount is being taken off them by way of income-tax, corporation profits tax and so forth. There is, then, the urban labour class. The Labour Party and others have pointed out, time and again, that there has been no opportunity for urban labour to get an increase of wages since the war broke out. These three classes —the civil and public servants, the manufacturers and business men and the urban labourer—cover practically everybody outside agriculture, and they have not been permitted to expand their income since the war commenced, as the farmer has been permitted to do. I want to make very clear—I do not want to be misrepresented—that I am not saying that the farmer is in as favourable a position as he should be compared with these other classes. What I claim is that his position has improved appreciably vis-a-vis these classes since the war commenced.

Apart from the farmers' position generally, the point was made by a number of Deputies that we had, in individual items, poor prices and that, as a result, we had decreased production. Deputy Bennett, speaking of the butter position, said we had a reduction in the output of creamery butter of 200,000 cwts. during the past four or five years, that that meant a reduction of 150,000 cows and that that involved a reduction in employment of 50,000 men. Deputy Bennett is probably wrong in his figures. If he is right, he has in mind 350-gallon cows. Our cows are, I think, better than that. If he is right, then I am sure he would not have admitted in this House in 1936 that, because our creamery butter output had gone up from 1930 by 250,000 cwts., our cows went up in number by 200,000 and that rural employment had increased by 20,000. If Deputy Bennett's contention be true in one way, then it must be true the other way. I do not think that it is true either way. If employment has altered as a result of the ups and downs of the output of creamery butter——

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Probably, the trouble is attributable to the slaughter of calves.

Comment on this

Not at all. The Deputy must be living in the last generation.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Somebody is living there. The slaughter of the calves had no effect on the present situation?

Comment on this

Not the slightest.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I am glad to get that admission. It shows what the Minister knows about the matter.

Comment on this

It shows how the Deputy gets a prejudice into his mind which neither facts nor anything else will remove. It is good propaganda and, as long as it suits the Deputy, he believes it. As we are dealing with butter and the Deputy thinks that the slaughter of calves has something to do with the shortage, perhaps I should deal with the matter. In 1928 and 1929, there was no slaughter of calves under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. Why was there a reduction in butter output then? The production in 1930-1931 was 15,000 cwts lower than it was last year or the year before. There was no slaughter of calves then. To what was the reduction due?

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

To what does the Minister say it was due?

Comment on this

Let the Deputy think out some other cause than the slaughter of calves.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Does the Minister know the cause?

Comment on this

I can give an opinion regarding it. If I give an opinion, it will not be a prejudiced, political opinion such as Deputy Morrissey gives. It could not be, seeing that the same thing occurred under the two Governments. Deputy Morrissey did not think about that when he talked about the slaughter of calves. When discussing the shortage of butter, keep these facts in mind: last February— three months ago—the consumption of creamery butter approximated to almost 2,000 cwts. per day in this country. That was double what it was ten years ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Minister is speaking of creamery butter?

Comment on this

Yes, The second point is that our production in 1940-41 was 650,000 cwts.—higher than the year 1930-31 by about 50,000 cwts. We cannot afford at present to export any butter. We should not have allowed butter to be exported last year. We know that now. We allowed only 11,000 cwts. out last year while, with a lesser output in 1930-31, this country could afford to export up to about 300,000 cwts.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

What is the explanation?

Comment on this