Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 6—General (Resumed).
Contributions 95–206 of 206. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
We are consuming practically twice as much butter now as then. Evidently, the people can afford to consume more butter now than they could then.
Comment on this
It must be an inspector of the Supplies Department who brought in the Minister that story.
Comment on this
The facts are there and there is no use in Deputy Mulcahy or Deputy Morrissey trying to deny that people are consuming twice as much butter as they did under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. I am quite sure that they would eat more butter under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government if they could afford to do so.
Comment on this
Has farmer's butter any relation to this question?
Comment on this
Does the consumption of farmer's butter bear the same relation to that of creamery butter as it did ten years ago?
Comment on this
That was what I thought the Deputy's question related to and that is why I said it had not much relation to it. The figure for farmer's butter given in 1926-27 by the Statistics Department was revised eight or nine years later when they realised that they had, probably, made a very big mistake. The figure for farmer's butter was corrected to a considerable extent. It shows that, if anybody attempts to take a figure like that, they can only make a very close guess, at best. Since 1930-31, certain districts have developed into creamery districts which were previously producing farmer's butter. Again, certain creamery districts have gone back to farmer's butter. On balance, I think that there are, probably, a larger number of farmers going to the creameries now than there were in 1930-31.
Comment on this
One can only guess. I shall not attempt to do what the Statistics Department could not do accurately. One could not make a guess at the cause of this shortage without going into the matter to some extent. Now, I come to what, I think, may be part of the cause of this decline in creamery output. There was a very big increase from 1931 to 1936 because the price of creamery butter was better, comparatively, than that for dry cattle. Possibly, the price of dry cattle is better now, comparatively, than that of creamery butter.
Comment on this
That may be one cause. How are we to remedy it? We, as a Government, did our best for creamery-butter production for about ten years. We subsidised creamery butter. We gave more than the export price would warrant. We thought that, when this war came along, we were finished with that subsidy and that the British Government would give us what it was costing to produce the butter. The British Government gave us 131/-. When the cost of transport to Great Britain and the cost of manufacture in the creamery were taken out of that price, the creamery could afford to pay the farmer only 4½d. per gallon for his milk. That is too little. There is no use in talking about that being in any way a remunerative price. The farmer could not possibly afford to carry on 4½d. per gallon. So that the decline in the creamery industry, if it has taken place because prices were not as favourable as they were for other farm products, is aggravated by the fact that the export price of butter has become impossible. The remark was made in a recent debate that whenever we were in a difficulty, we blamed the British Government. I am not blaming the British Government. I am only stating the fact. If the British Government states that our butter is not worth any more than 131/-, that is their business. I do not want to go into it further, but I say our farmers could not produce butter at that price and, as a matter of fact, are going out of production and we are now down to the point where we have practically only enough butter for ourselves.
Another suggestion made by Deputies was that we should give more to the farmer for his butter here. We must keep certain facts in mind. We must remember that there is no other fat now on the market available to the consumers in this country and, however we may regard the case of the better-off families who could afford to buy butter even if it were a bit dearer, the working-man who has a very fixed wage, and perhaps nothing to spare, must buy less if the price of butter is increased to him. That would be all right if he could buy other fats in substitution. It would be all right at a time when he could purchase margarine, dripping, lard and so on, but he cannot get them now, and if the price of butter is too high he must purchase less fats in the aggregate, and that is not good for the health of himself or his family. These things must be kept in mind. I do not want to go further into that at the moment.
I want to deal with one other commodity, because it was raised here also, that is, bacon. It was alleged, I believe—I was not here at the time— that the Government had killed the bacon industry. That is a very easy statement to make, but there is no possible support for it, and the person who made the statement did not try to support it in any way. It is easy to make a statement of that kind without trying to prove it. As a matter of fact, I think probably the Deputy who makes that statement or who believes it to be true, has in mind the legislation that was passed here dealing with the bacon industry. That legislation was necessary in the first instance because the British Government had rationalised the bacon industry in Great Britain and also the import of bacon and had laid it down as a condition that there should be some authority in the exporting country to deal with the bacon that was produced there and exported to their country and that it should be done on a quota basis.
Some machinery was necessary. There was a commission set up to deal with this question. The Bill was, more or less, drafted on the recommendations of the commission, and then there was a Parliamentary Committee appointed to go into the Bill. It was generally agreed that it was the best that could be done under the circumstances, and it went through. I am not surprised—I did not expect anything better—that when that Bill turned out to be unfortunate so far as the farmers were concerned, Deputies of the opposite Party, more or less, disclaimed responsibility, although they had sat on that committee—it was a Select Committee—and had a hand in rearranging the provisions of the Bill to their own satisfaction as much as to ours. But, when certain provisions were rather resented by producers and so on, they disclaimed all responsibility. I want to show, however, that, whatever Deputies may believe and whatever anybody else may believe, the board that was set up under that Bill was successful. The worst year we had in the pig industry in this country, going back, say, 20 years, was the year 1933. If we take the balance of trade in bacon and pigs and so on, that is, deduct whatever we imported from what we exported, we only had a balance of £1,600,000. That was the lowest we ever reached—1933. It began to improve from that year. In 1935 it had slightly improved. It had not gone up to more than £2,000,000, but in 1935 this new board was set up, and from that until 1941 there was a gradual but sure improvement in the pig industry, and in 1941 we reached an aggregate figure in our trading in bacon and pigs which was the highest for about 16 years, going back to, I think, either 1926 or 1925. Therefore, it is unfair really to say that the machinery, and the personnel that were put into control as a result of that machinery, have been responsible for a great disaster in the pig industry.
Comment on this
I am quite sure the home consumption in 1925 and 1926, when pigs were very dear, was not as high as it was in 1932 or 1933, when pigs were cheap and bacon was cheap. That is only to be expected. I am talking of quantity. I suppose the Deputy means quantity?
Comment on this
I am taking the total, because there was a very big diminution in the live-pig trade, naturally, on account of the building up of the bacon industry rather than live pigs but, after all, it does not matter very much to the farmers in the aggregate whether the trade is in live pigs, bacon or pork. What I am taking is the total income, as far as the pig industry is concerned. Again, I do not want any Deputy to think that I am in any way blaming the British Government. I am only stating the facts. Remember, we had reached in 1940 the best year that we had in the pig industry for about 15 or 16 years. In 1941 we had a quota of, I think it was, 500,000 cwts. of bacon allotted to us by the British Government, at 131/- per cwt. Our pigs were on the increase at that time and we asked to have that quota increased. That was refused. As a matter of fact, we had eventually, towards the end of the year, to sell an additional quantity, over and above the 500,000 cwts., to the British Government at about 98/- a cwt. In order to meet that, a levy had to be put on all pigs, which levy was passed back to the producer.
That had a very bad effect on production here. In addition to that, there is no doubt that a big factor in reducing pigs was the want of feeding stuffs, and I believe that is the big factor now because the price is much better now than it was at the end of 1940, the time I speak of. We could not possibly send bacon to Great Britain at the price offered now, that is, 131/2d., merely taking the raw material, because if a pig is killed, the dead-weight of that pig will only produce 75 per cent. of bacon. Taking the raw material to make 1 cwt. of bacon, the factories could only give about 95/-, dead-weight, for pigs. Of course, we have gone long beyond that now, because at the moment we have a good deal of bacon in store but we are not receiving enough pigs from the factories to meet our own home demand and, were it not for the fact that we have a certain amount of cold-stored bacon, there would be a scarcity.
Comment on this
I do not know. I think at the moment it is perhaps just as well if it did not. Those who advocate an increase in the number of pigs must clearly see that they are advocating an increase in the number of animals which are in direct opposition to human beings in the consumption of food. After all, a pig consumes grain to a great extent, and we scarcely have enough grain for human food at the moment. I think, however, if we get a good harvest this year, if we get good crops of potatoes and if we can devote a certain quantity of grain to animal feeding after human needs have been met, an increase in the number of pigs will come then, and we shall get at least, I hope, the number necessary to meet the home consumption of bacon.
Before I leave agriculture, another point that was raised had reference to credit facilities. It was touched upon also by Deputy Cosgrave. While I hold no brief for any particular form of credit in this country, I do think that we should be in this instance also truthful. It is not true to say that if a person gets a loan from the Agricultural Credit Corporation he has to repay twice as much before the loan is fully wiped out. As a matter of fact, I have a handbook here which gives details of the total amounts repayable on loans. Any Deputy who writes to the Agricultural Credit Corporation can get a copy of this handbook. Taking one particular class of loan, if a person borrows £100 for ten years and pays that back in half-yearly instalments, over the ten years he repays a total of £128 6s. 8d. Therefore, it would be only in a case where a person got a loan for 35 years, which I think is the maximum period for which loans are advanced, that he would actually pay back double the amount that he might have borrowed. However, as I say, for a ten year loan, which is a very common type of loan, on a principal of £100 he would pay back a total of £128 6s. 8d.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell us to what extent the Agricultural Credit Corporation has helped the agricultural industry?
Comment on this
I think the Agricultural Credit Corporation fulfilled a very useful purpose in many ways. It was possible, for instance, for certain farmers to make settlements of certain bank debts by offering cash to the bank. They owed so much money to banks and by getting money from the Agricultural Credit Corporation, they were able to settle with these banks for a percentage of the original loans.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell us what was the financial benefit to the farmer in that connection?
Comment on this
Here is a common case. A farmer owed, say, £5,000 to a bank, a sum which it was absolutely beyond his capacity to repay. He went into the bank, told them all his circumstances and the bank manager said to him: "Give me £1,000 cash, in settlement." He then went to the Agricultural Credit Corporation, who found that his holding was good for a loan of £1,000. The corporation thereupon advanced him the £1,000 and he went and cleared off his debt to the bank. As long as he owed money to the bank, he lived in dread that he might be evicted at any time. Now he had got a loan on different terms from the Agricultural Credit Corporation repayable in ten or 15 years, and so long as he paid his instalments on that loan he was quite safe. He was in a much better position to settle down to serious farming again.
I know a number of farmers myself who settled their affairs in that way and who have now made good, farmers who never could have made good while the old debt on the bank remained. There is that advantage with the Agricultural Credit Corporation, that the loan is repayable over a number of years on an annuity basis, and as long as the farmer pays the annuity he is not pressed. On the other hand, if he owed money to a bank he was pressed by the bank, asked to take something off the loan or to renew his bill.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say how much the Agricultural Credit Corporation has advanced altogether?
Comment on this
Oh, no. Of course I should not be defending this corporation because whatever restrictions were put upon it—and I think they were too many—they were put on by the Party opposite. However, as long as it is dealing fairly with the people I shall defend it, and in fair play I say that it has given a lot of credit.
Comment on this
I do not. I am not as agile as the Deputy in these things. Deputy Norton threatened that if we exported any food not surplus to our requirements, he had a way of dealing with it. I do not know what secret weapon Deputy Norton may have, but I do not think it will be necessary to use it for, as far as we can, we mean to see that no food leaves this country if it is wanted here. I am prepared to say here and now in the Dáil that no bacon or butter will be exported during the coming year, though I shall have to qualify that statement in a moment. Neither will any potatoes be exported, except seed potatoes. There are certain farmers in this country who built up their whole economy practically around the growing of very high-class seed potatoes. It would be a terrible thing if we stopped these men from exporting seed potatoes unless it is absolutely necessary. It is not necessary, because we have more potatoes than we want.
Comment on this
That is under consideration and I hope we shall have something to say on it in the near future.
Comment on this
I quite agree. With regard to butter, this is the qualification I had in mind. First of all, I am not sure that all the factory butter will be required in this country. We shall encourage, as far as we can, manufacturers, bakers and confectioners to use farmers' butter, so as not to put an undue burden on creamery butter supplies. Even then, we may not find it possible to absorb all factory butter and, if so, some of it will have to be exported. In addition to that, in the case of butter and bacon we have a contract with the Isle of Man. I am not sure what we may yet do in that case.
Comment on this
It is a very small contract. As a matter of fact, the whole contract with the Isle of Man would not represent more than one-and-a-half days' supply for this country. I should say that they are paying the same price as we charge our own people, so that in that respect they are in a different position from the British market. I cannot say definitely yet what may happen so far as that contract is concerned. Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Dillon spoke about malnutrition.
Comment on this
Before the Minister leaves the question of agriculture, would he give some indication to the House as to the information at his disposal regarding the probable sowings of beet for this season? I think it is a very important matter and the Minister should now be in a position to say something about it.
Comment on this
I cannot tell the Deputy what the exact acreage is. The last figure I obtained was some days ago and there were still a few contracts to come in. At that time it was somewhere in the region of 53,000 or 54,000 acres, I think.
Comment on this
Does the Minister propose to attempt to get any information as to what extent the contracts which have not been returned will be fulfilled? It is quite a common opinion in the country that people who have not returned contracts will not fulfil them, and that a man who contracted to grow, say, five acres, having regard to the fact that the manure upon which he had been relying is not forthcoming, will only grow two acres instead of five.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, that was exactly where the acreage fell: a number of farmers who at first said they would grow five acres, under the new conditions, when they could not get manure, and so on, had to go back to two or three acres. However, I think that these contracts to which I have referred—the 53,000 or 54,000 acres—have been actually confirmed.
Comment on this
That is, independent of those who are not going to grow at all? It is well known that there are hundreds of farmers who are not going to grow at all.
Comment on this
I am only saying that that is what they expect to get. The only other point was one that was made by Deputies Cosgrave and Dillon with regard to malnutrition. Now, malnutrition is one of those things also that is a very wide term and is very relative in its application. I suppose there are Deputies in the House to whom we might refer as suffering from malnutrition, although you could not say that about Deputy Morrissey or myself, but it is a very relative term and it is very hard to deal with it. All we can do is to deal with it in a comparative way, if there is malnutrition, and I suppose there is always a certain amount of it, but whether or not it is of a very serious nature I would not be prepared to say, although I would not be inclined to agree that it is.
Comment on this
I know that it exists, but there are two things that I want to mention. Firstly, everybody will agree that, as far as malnutrition in children is concerned, the most important thing of all is milk, or milk products. Now, the consumption of milk, wherever we have figures for that, as we have in places where milk boards are operating, is going up steadily; in fact, it went up very much last year, on account of the big number of people who have been taken on the free list, but apart from that, there was a certain increase all the time in the consumption of milk. To that extent, I suppose, it looks as if something is being done to meet this problem of malnutrition, as far as it exists. Secondly, there is also, as I said already, an increase in the consumption of butter, and there has been an increase also in the consumption of fresh meats. I do not know about vegetables and fruits, it would be very hard to find out if there is any increase there, but there is an increase, at any rate, in the consumption of these essential foods, and to that extent we may have relieved the situation somewhat. Another point that I want to refer to is that over the years—I do not know for how many years, but going back, at any rate, for a good number of years, and every year during those years—there has been an improvement so far as infantile death rates are concerned. I think there is nothing so satisfactory as that because, after all, if the infantile death rate is improving, it shows in a general way that nutrition amongst children is improving all the time and we may be dealing with the problem, perhaps not satisfactorily, but at any rate to some extent.
Comment on this
Many opinions have been expressed on this Budget, and I think they can all be summarised into two different types of opinions: one, from those who have benefited by the Budget, and the other from those who have not. Now, we saw in the papers that this Budget was characterised by some of those people, who are called industrialists, as a damned good Budget, and that it was a step in the right direction to help industries, and so on; but we have not got that opinion expressed in the Press from the other people—the wage-earning class, the people who are unemployed, the people who are casually employed, the people who have to exist on very small incomes, or the people who have to emigrate to earn a living in a foreign land. We have tried to put the point of view of those people before the House, and in that regard we have tried to show that this Budget does not, in any way, give any relief to those people, and yet they are the big majority of the people of this country. The wage earner has had his wages pegged down by Order No. 83. He cannot get any increase in wages, no matter how the cost of living has gone up, and according to the official figures it has gone up by over 37 per cent., since the outbreak of the war. That Order has pegged his wages down. No matter how difficult his circumstances may be, he cannot get any increase in his wages. Contrast that pegging down of the workers' wages by Order No. 83 with the treatment of the people on the other side of the scale: the industrialists, the employers, and the people who have money invested. These people have got a definite relief under this Budget. Under the last Budget £750,000 was to have been got from them, but under this Budget £150,000 has been put into their pockets.
We are told from the Government Benches that Order No. 83 applies to profits as well as wages, but that Order has been definitely smashed as far as profits are concerned. We can read in the newspapers the balance sheets of certain concerns, where it is shown that they pay 10 per cent. dividends with a bonus of 2½ per cent. Surely, that is a definite breach of Order No. 83, as far as breaches of an Order can go. Yet, there is no prosecution, or anything in the nature of anybody being indicted for that breach of the Order. The object of the Order, definitely, is to peg down the wages of workers. Now, mind you, Order No. 83 was brought in ostensibly to regulate, or control, prices, but the general complaint is that prices have not been controlled in any way, and where prices have been controlled we have the issue of the black market immediately. The black market has been operated very much by people in all parts of this country, and particularly in certain commodities. I shall return to that in a few moments, but I want to show the House and the Minister, that the Minister has not acted fairly in his implementation of Order No. 83.
It is true to say that he brought in Order No. 166—the double of Order No. 83—which, as far as the ordinary layman is concerned, is impossible to understand. It is so mixed up with regulations and with semi-legal jargon that no ordinary layman can understand what his rights are at all. It would require a decision of the High Court really to interpret what is meant by Order No. 166, which is supposed to be a relaxation of Order No. 83. I want to put this to the Minister. Under this Budget, what relief is given to the old age pensioners, what relief is given to widows and orphans, what relief is given to the unemployed, except this £100,000 for turf which, at the present rate of £3 14s. a ton, would not mean more than 30,000 tons of turf? I do not know on what basis that is going to be allocated. It will be very difficult to allocate 30,000 tons of turf among 100,000 unemployed people.
With regard to malnutrition, it is no wonder that it is prevalent, considering the extent and the ravages caused by unemployment and considering the position of old age pensioners, of people living on home assistance and of widows and orphans in the rural areas who have to try to exist on the miserable amounts given to them. Would the Minister say what is the real reason for the differentiation made between old age pensioners and widows and orphans living in urban areas and those in the rural areas? I suppose the Minister will claim that the food vouchers will mean a definite increase for those classes living in the urban areas, but why have not the benefits of that scheme been extended to similar classes in the rural areas who very often have to buy the necessaries of life in the neighbouring towns and cities and at the same prices as those charged to the people in the urban areas? When speaking a moment ago the Minister for Agriculture made the point as a kind of explanation, I think, that rent and milk and a few other things were obtainable at a cheaper rate in the country. But, even in the case of these few items, that is not so. I want to put it to the Minister that food and clothing and, in many cases, rent, are as high in the rural areas as they are in the urban. In Cork City, for example, we have the position that under corporation schemes you have houses which are partly in the city and partly in the county, with the result that old age pensioners and widows and orphans living in the houses outside the city boundary are not entitled to food vouchers although they are part and parcel of the city life. I do not know why this differentiation is being made. I think it would require a stronger case to be made for it than that which the Minister for Agriculture tried to make. I am very anxious to hear the views of the Minister for Finance on it.
With that, you have the position in both rural and urban areas that there is a certain scale of unemployment assistance for a family in which there are five children. I think one can only interpret that as being definitely anti-social. As a rule, the families in receipt of unemployment assistance are large families. Very often there are six, seven, eight and nine children in them, but no provision whatever is made for the sixth, seventh, eighth or ninth child. How can we claim that we are acting on any kind of Christian or social principles while that state of affairs exists? No provision whatever is made in the Budget for these families while provision is made in it to give assistance to industrialists. We have had the position in this country for the last 20 years that unemployment, poverty, hunger and misery have become a normal feature of life here. It is about time, I think, that the outlook of the ordinary citizen towards that should be changed. In that situation, how can you expect to have any kind of stability in the State? You certainly cannot have the kind of progress that we would all wish to see. As some Deputy has said, this House is not doing its duty while such a state of affairs exists.
Side by side with that position, and as a result of it, you have a very large flow of emigration from the country. That is only to be expected since we have so many unemployed, and since pretty good wages are being offered on the other side. But, surely it ought not to be beyond the capacity of Government institutions to devise a scheme whereby the people could be kept at home and put into employment at decent rates of wages. Is there not a social principle underlying all that? If we are constrained to allow our people to emigrate to foreign countries and become part and parcel of them, even for a time, then I think irreparable damage will be done to our nation. The Government have made no provision whatever for any scheme of employment, or for any kind of an easing off of the position with regard to emigration. The emigration is going on day after day. When the Labour Party brought forward a motion, over 12 months ago, proposing to deal with the unemployment problem we were told that it was being considered by an inter-departmental committee. But we have heard nothing since from that inter-departmental committee. But seems to be a new way the Government have of dealing with very pressing problems such as unemployment—to refer them to an inter-departmental committee. If I may digress for a moment, we had another example of it to-day when questions were asked with regard to the position of 1916 men. That, also, has been referred to an inter-departmental committee. In fact, this procedure would now appear to be the fashion. The old method of referring things to commissions seems to have gone out of fashion.
Would the Minister say if he has received an interim report from the inter-departmental committee set up to deal with the question of unemployment indicating what progress, if any, has been made? I am anxious to know, because no provision whatever is being made for it in this Budget, in the same way as no additional provision is being made for those in the rural areas in receipt of unemployment assistance, or for old age pensioners or widows and orphans. As I have already said, something is being given by way of food vouchers to those classes in the urban areas.
Those familiar with conditions in rural Ireland will know that the standard of living among the people there is abnormally low, even in the case of those in employment, the reason being that you have a very low standard of values in the rural areas. Farm labourers are now receiving a minimum wage of 33/- a week, but the fact is that everybody regards that as the maximum. What I find is that it is very hard to get some employers, especially the large farmers, to pay even that minimum. From time to time I have had to get an inspector from the Agricultural Wages Board to visit some of those employers, with the invariable result that they have had to refund in wages to workers sums varying from £4 to £7. You have that position in the rural areas, and yet this Budget holds out no hope of improvement for these workers.
It is true, as the Minister claims, that there is no provision for additional taxation in the Budget. With the present high cost of living, and the position that the workers in the towns and cities and in the rural areas find themselves in, I venture to say that, if any new taxes were put on, coupled with the fact that Order No. 83 has only been relatively relaxed effectively, you would have riots. Therefore the Minister was wise enough to avoid that position for the time being at least. The cost of living has gone up over 37 per cent., but there has been no compensation for the workers. That high level of prices still exists. When this Order was brought in we were told that the principle underlying it was that prices, wages and profits were to be controlled. The Minister cannot tell the House that either prices or profits have been controlled or that any attempt has been made to control them, while there has been a definite and rigorous enforcement of Emergency Powers (No. 83) Order with regard to the workers who have to meet the high cost of living, which is not controlled.
I listened with great interest to the Minister for Agriculture when dealing with the position of the farmers. The working farmers in my constituency and in Cork County generally are a very hard-working, industrious and thrifty people. Some of them are very often in serious difficulties with regard to credit for seeds, manures, and the other necessaries for increased tillage. I say definitely that the Cork County Council have made it difficult for farmers who are not credit-worthy to get any advance for seeds or manures. I have a definite reason for saying that.
Comment on this
First of all, a non-credit-worthy farmer must get two solvent sureties. I am not questioning the wisdom or otherwise of that procedure; I am stating the facts. When these sureties are got, the secretary of the county council informs them that Mr. so-and-so owes so much for rates and asks them if they are still prepared to go security for him. I am giving concrete examples that I heard of myself. Naturally, the proposed surety will say: "That is a different proposition; that man is not credit-worthy; he is not a person who, according to the information given by the county council, should get this credit because he owes so much already." I am not suggesting that the county council should provide this credit. I am suggesting that the Minister should deal with these people by some scheme in this Budget or in some other way.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy aware that the Cork County Council last year gave £14,000 in credit to these people?
Comment on this
The people I speak of did not get it. I have gone to the secretary of the county council about cases where people could not do the required amount of tillage, although some of them had the land prepared, because they were unable to get the seeds or manures or whatever else was necessary. My argument is that the provision of seeds and manures is a national question, because it is on the return from the tillage and from the work of the farmers that the safety of the nation will depend. I want to say again that I am not blaming the county council for this. That is their scheme. The Minister should have some system of credit—facilities for farmers who cannot get facilities through the ordinary channels or even through the county council. If there were some system like that, it would make things much easier for those farmers who are not credit-worthy for some reason or other. It may have been that they were badly hit in past times or that they were always struggling along and a struggling farmer is one of the greatest objects of pity that I know of. That is the position with them to-day. They cannot make the effort that is required of them because there are no facilities to enable them to do so.
We have had a great deal of talk about family allowances both for urban and rural families. A motion was put forward in the other House that family allowances should be introduced by making provision for families in rural areas. Probably a very good case could be made for the provision of family allowances in rural areas; but the need is as great in the urban areas. As I have stressed, the standard of living in rural areas is very low and the provision of family allowances would have a very beneficial effect in rural areas. But I am suggesting that the whole question of family allowances should be considered from the point of view of the nation as a whole. Lip-service has been paid to Catholic social principles both inside and outside this House, and the basis of those principles is the family. The family is the unit on which the State is built. If we have families both in urban and rural areas, as we have, who have not sufficient food and clothing, and in some cases proper shelter, then I think that we are only paying lip-service to those principles which we talk so much about. One way in which families can be helped, especially large families, is by the provision of family allowances. That matter has been referred to an inter-departmental committee, and I ask the Minister to let us know if any interim report has been received from that committee and, if so, what its findings are.
A scheme of family allowances if adopted would, I suggest, have very big reactions on the whole social and economic life of this country. It would definitely get us away from that very obnoxious system of only making provision for five children of an unemployed man. It would benefit the nation in very many other ways. I think it would be worth the Minister's while seriously to consider the introduction of such a system, especially at the present time when the effect of the growing unemployment will be very much felt, especially by the children.
I think it is a tragedy to see a child handicapped through the unemployment of its father, handicapped in such a way that, very often, the effect of that handicap remains during its whole lifetime. I think the Minister would be doing an excellent social service to this nation if he gave attention seriously to this question of family allowances. It would certainly meet with the approval not alone of social workers, and people interested in social principles, but of the nation as a whole. It is definitely one of the topics that are now very much in the minds of people who give thought to the position of this nation, and to the dangers that beset it in the way of unemployment, emigration, and the other evils which are a very serious menace to the life of this community. Of course, I will be asked: where is the money to come from? I think an effective answer to that is that we are spending over £9,000,000 a year on the Army. I do not know whether or not that amount is justified, or whether or not we are getting value for it, but I am very sure that, if it were necessary to increase that amount or even to double it, we would not have anybody in this country very actively opposing it. We have made that provision in order to preserve this nation from invasion, and at the same time the homes of the unemployed workers and of the poor people in the country are being invaded by poverty, by starvation and misery, but we are doing nothing whatsoever about it. As I have already said, we simply take it as the normal state of affairs. How long that state of affairs is to continue will depend on the patience of the people, and on their good sense, if I may so say, but surely we cannot expect that position to remain for ever. Surely we may anticipate that the people who are ignored and forgotten in this Budget and by this House will at some time bring their grievances very forcibly before the public. I would ask the Minister then to give this House an indication of what he intends to do with regard to those very important matters. He has told us there was never a scheme—I think he qualified it in some way—which was turned down because money was not available.
Comment on this
That is what I am talking about. I should have said "no scheme of employment". A few schemes suggest themselves to my mind. I do not know whether they would be considered by an inter-departmental committee as being sound propositions, but surely schemes for afforestation and re-afforestation of the country would be very acceptable from an employment point of view, and from a national and economic point of view. Then we have in this country a large number of school buildings which have been condemned as unfit for human habitation. Many of the children of this nation have to spend a good portion of their young lives in those very unhygienic and insanitary buildings. A large amount of money would be required to build new schools and to provide decent conditions under which to educate the children of this nation.
I am sure that a scheme like that would be approved of by the nation. It would certainly benefit the health of the nation, because I can definitely say that, in those unhygienic and insanitary buildings, are sown the seeds of future diseases, which have to be treated perhaps at the expense of the nation or certainly at the expense of the parents. That is a scheme which could be undertaken very usefully by a Government that has no difficulty in getting money for good schemes of employment. Very many other schemes which come to one's mind could usefully be adopted for the provision of employment. I have yet to learn the advantage that the nation derives from exporting our people instead of using our best efforts to provide employment for them at home. I think that definitely shows a want of initiative or a want of energy on the part of the Government, because the Minister tells us that it is not due to want of money. Surely, if there is no lack of money, there are very many useful schemes which could be utilised for the provision here of the employment which our people now have to leave the country to find.
The Minister said that he has allowed £200,000 for the reopening of the steel works at Haulbowline. I put down a question last week to the Minister for Industry and Commerce as to when he expected the work to start. Could we get from the Minister for Finance, when he is replying, the conditions under which he gave that £200,000 to reopen that industry? Was there any time limit in regard to the commencement of work, or were any conditions laid down with regard to the employment they should give or to the rate of interest to be paid over a period? I should like definitely to get those particulars from the Minister. This factory has been closed now, I think, for over two years, and during that time a good deal of the material which could be used in that factory has been exported. From time to time, I have given figures here—my colleague in the constituency, Deputy Corry, has also given figures—with regard to the amount of scrap iron which has been exported. We were told that our information was not correct, because it was scrap steel that was being exported.
I am still of the opinion that the information which I was able to procure, both from the harbour authorities and otherwise, was correct, and that this material has been exported and is still being exported. The Minister will get very little return for the £200,000 if, when the factory is ready, there is no material with which to work. I would ask the Minister, in the interests of his investment, to look into the points which I have made about the export of this material. I am informed that no later than last week a good deal of it was exported from Cork Harbour. The conditions under which this money was given, the purpose of it, and the date on which we may expect the work to start, are matters that concern the Minister and this House. When I say "the work", I mean the actual production. On every hand, we have people crying out for what we may expect to be the products of this factory. The farmers think that there will be a certain amount of iron which can be used for agricultural implements, for the shoeing of horses and so on. That is very badly needed at the moment, and we would like to know when production will start.
The Minister for Agriculture referred to the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I do not know very much about that body, except that on a few occasions, when I submitted cases to them, they turned them down. I do not know whether they were very bad cases, whether they were not credit-worthy, but, at any rate, that was my experience of the corporation. I think they endeavour to strike a very hard bargain, and it is difficult to get money from them. That seems to be the experience of the farmers who want money. It may be that there is a tightening-up of loans on the part of the Agricultural Credit Corporation.
Comment on this
They are the type of people you are talking about—people who are not credit-worthy. My criticism of the Budget has been from the point of view of the people who did not receive any relief. I have tried to show the House that in the Press we see expressed the opinions of the people who got the £150,000, together with the £750,000 last year. I want to give you the opinions of people who have not got anything under the Budget. I believe that this Budget helps to rivet more firmly than ever on the people the foreign economic system that is putting thousands of our people in exile, and that threatens to destroy the whole fabric of this country. That is my summing up of the Budget.
Comment on this
On the whole, this is not an unpopular Budget. The people one meets in the country consider themselves very safe in escaping additional taxation. They know it is not quite right to have a gap of £4,500,000 between revenue and expenditure, but they content themselves by saying that the responsibility is not theirs. The average person one meets does not seem to allow his conscience to be very much troubled over the Budget. One would suggest that the Minister for Finance, who assumes a big responsibility in such things, would be very concerned about the balancing of the Budget. I do not want to give my own opinion upon this aspect, but I will give the opinion of an ex-Minister for Finance, who was speaking in 1934. He was then delivering his Budget statement. In a statement of that sort a Minister does not speak lightly. I am sure he is very careful about everything he says, and I will read to the House what he thought at that time about unbalanced Budgets. The present Minister for Finance can then draw his own conclusion as to the opinion of his predecessor. The statement from which I shall quote appears in the Parliamentary Debates, Vol. 52, col. 617. The present Minister for Local Government and Public Health, who was at that time Minister for Finance, said:
"There is scarcely anything more damaging to the credit of a State than the realisation of a Budgetary deficit, scarcely anything which so generally injures the citizen in his own private affairs, making it more difficult for the State to fulfil its obligations to him, and for him to fulfil his obligations to the State, his creditors and his fellow-citizens."
If that was true in 1934 it must be equally true in 1942. That was the last Minister's opinion about unbalanced Budgets. We have now been presented with a Budget unbalanced to the extent of £4,500,000, but the Minister for Finance does not seem to be very worried over it, and, indeed, nobody is. We are hoping for better days, but they are a long time coming.
Another rather disquieting statement that the Minister for Finance made when presenting this Budget was that the dead-weight debt, national and local, was £111,000,000. That is a rather tidy sum. I will read what the Minister for Finance, in 1934, said with regard to the dead-weight national debt:
"Now take the position at the 31st March last. Our direct liabilities then stood at £44,523,000, our offsetting assets at £27,495,649, and our net direct public debt, after allowing for these assets, at £17,027,000— a reduction of £5,460,000 in two years."
Had the Minister for Finance continued to reduce that £17,027,000 at the same rate as was done in the two years preceding 1934—that is, at the rate of £5,460,000—the debt would be completely wiped out and instead of £111,000,000 we would have nothing unless the debt from the local bodies.
It seems that we are not progressing in the best direction. If our main industry were prosperous we could say that the country had built up some assets against the dead-weight debt, but unfortunately the people are leaving the land, which is the source of our principal industry. Our new industries are idle for the want of raw material. Taking things generally, the picture is not very rosy. That is a state of affairs which calls for very serious consideration on the part of the Government, and especially on the part of the Minister for Finance, who has the chief responsibility in a matter of shortage of finance.
I do not believe we can get over difficulties of this sort by printing paper money and issuing it, as it would be of no benefit whatever. The central bank cannot cure our economic ills, whatever they may do to improve credit and reduce the price at which credit may be obtained. Certainly, the issue of cash will provide nothing, and will not improve the standard of living. Anyone of common sense knows that. Production must be increased before the standard of living can be improved, and production must begin at the principal industry of the State. Unfortunately, the position of that principal industry is anything but good at the present moment.
Speaking on the Vote for Agriculture a couple of weeks ago, I gave some comparable figures regarding conditions here and in the neighbouring portion of this country, Northern Ireland. These figures are very illuminating. They show the terrible depression that exists. When you examine them and compare the position of farmers with that in which they were during the last war, you wonder how they are existing at all. While the principal industry is in that condition; the prospect of being able to balance Budgets in future is not very rosy. Unbalanced Budgets have the tendency to go on in that direction at an increasing rate. After all, when you are adding to the burden year after year, you are adding to the services required to meet the interest upon borrowed money. That is a very serious matter, and the sooner some steps are taken to economise the better. Unfortunately, the Government, instead of trying to economise when it could have economised, went on with scheme after scheme, appointing more and more officials where they were not necessary at all. They went on from one scheme to another and the country is now unable to meet the burden.
I regret I was not present during the whole speech of the Minister for Agriculture. He referred to the position of credit and the Agricultural Credit Corporation. Speaking on the Central Bank Bill, the Minister for Finance said the reason the corporation could not give credit to so many farmers was that the farmers were not credit-worthy. He was quite right: I agree with him. There is no use in giving credit to farmers who are not credit-worthy, but whose fault is it that so many farmers are not credit-worthy? It is certainly the fault of the present Government and the policy in operation for the last ten years. It is a sad commentary upon the policy of that Government that, at the end of so many years, so many farmers are not credit-worthy that the Agricultural Credit Corporation—started for the purpose of giving loans to farmers— found it impossible to do so.
When the question was put to the Minister for Agriculture a few moments ago, as to how much money the corporation had loaned, he was not able to answer. I do not think it mattered very much, as the amount they have loaned is negligible. Whether the charges are high or not does not make so much difference, as the services are very restricted, and if farmers were dependent on them they would often be short of money. He also said that, if £100 were borrowed from the corporation it was made repayable over ten years in instalments, and £128 would clear that £100. That would be practically 3 per cent. for £100 over the whole time. We know the average amount would be nearer £50 than £100. £28 should cover the whole interest for ten years, whereas it is payable in ten instalments.
The Government has the responsibility to provide farmers with credit for the production of the nation's food, at 3 per cent., at the outside, at least for a time like that of the present emergency. We do not expect that the banks could do that, and I would not say they should be asked, or that the Agricultural Credit Corporation should be asked. The Government could go to the banks or the corporation and guarantee that this money would be repaid by the farmers or that the corporation would repay it. If the farmers generally are in that condition, it is the Government's duty to see that the nation's food supply is not held up for want of the necessary credit, at a reasonable charge which a struggling industry could bear. If agriculture were more prosperous I am sure farmers would not mind very much, if they could afford to pay 5 or 6 per cent.—all they want is to get the money. A struggling industry, however, must be and should be provided with money at a rate of interest which will not be a serious burden when added to the principal.
The Minister for Agriculture tried to justify the lowering of the price of pigs by saying that these animals were in direct opposition to human beings in the consumption of food, and yet he had no idea as to what was to be done with the surplus potatoes. Everyone knows we have a surplus of potatoes which people do not know what to do with. His remedy was, through the Pigs and Bacon Marketing Board, to fix the price of pigs over 12 stone at a reducing rate. The pig that crosses over 14 stone is to be sold at something like 80/-. Instead of doing that, he could have given the top price for all pigs up to 16 stone, and even over it. There would be a market for heavy bacon and the majority of our people would prefer a heavy bacon. There is a shortage of pigs in the State at the present moment. We cannot change that overnight or in time to consume the surplus potatoes, but by increasing the price of the heavy pig, the pig we have at present could be kept over until the surplus potatoes are consumed, and in that way the surplus would be used to the advantage of the people concerned, to the advantage of the State as a whole, and to the advantage of the Minister for Finance. Potatoes cannot be used economically after a couple of months; they simply go to loss. People have got into the habit of putting them into silos, but I do not think that is a practical proposition. A good deal of labour is involved. By making it possible for the people to keep pigs and by having prices maintained until the animals are bigger, it will be easier to maintain supplies of bacon. I hope the Minister will consider the matter and that he will find my suggestions satisfactory.
The whole trouble about agriculture is that everything produced on the land, generally speaking, is produced at a loss, and there is such a tight fit to make ends meet that nothing is left to provide for the future. Farmers cannot pay workers a living wage, simply because they and their families are not getting a living wage. Where labour is employed it is very often being paid more than would be considered prudent in other businesses, except by men, professors and others who have no interest in agriculture. The sooner the Government casts about to find out how things can be improved the better it will be for all concerned. What is wrong with this country at present is that there is over-expenditure in various directions. We are taking a headline from wealthy countries like the United States and Great Britain and trying to maintain Departments on a similar scale. I doubt if an agricultural country can afford to continue doing that.
I think we should take an example from smaller countries similarly situated to Eire. The present policy cannot be maintained, and any attempt to do so would result in the standard of living of everyone going down. The Government should change that policy drastically and try to cut expenditure at the top. I know that it is unpopular to suggest where economies might begin. I referred to this matter on other occasions. My recommendation is to begin at home. If we want a good example we should begin on the Front Benches and then go around to the other benches.
Comment on this
Once a beginning is made it would be a step in the right direction, and I suggest that the Minister should consider the other directions before next Budget day.
Comment on this
I wish to support Deputy Hurley's plea for an enlarged scheme of afforestation. Owing to fuel requirements last winter there was an abnormal felling of timber. I have no regret for that, because it was necessary, and if more timber is needed this winter let it be cut, but there should be a national policy of replacement. I submit that our forestry scheme has not been able to deal with that situation, as the amount we are spending this year is much below the normal and will not replace the heavy felling of timber that is taking place. In addition, the rule about the replacement of fuel has not been observed. The Government should consider taking immediate steps to speed up afforestation.
I want to refer to another matter, and that is the position of wholesalers in the distribution of goods. A number of wholesalers have retail shops. They also supply a number of small shops with goods, and I contend that they have collared everything for their own retail shops. They began by collaring tobacco, then tea, sugar and butter during the spring. There are reputable firms that endeavour to supply small shopkeepers with their quotas, but there are great numbers of others who look after their own shops at the expense of small shopkeepers. The Government should take steps to get after these firms. Whenever I pointed out misbehaviour on the part of certain firms to the Department of Supplies action was taken, but the procedure took months and in the intervening period these wholesalers got off with the swag, and in some places small shops were closed.
I have always advocated, in my Party, the registration of shops. It would stand to us very much in this war. I heard small shopkeepers saying that when this war was over they would never deal with certain wholesalers again, but direct with Dublin houses. What will happen when the war is over is this: small shops will spring up at the cross-roads again and be financed by local gombeen men from the nearest towns and the old position will be repeated. That is a good argument for the registration of shops. The small shopkeeper is being crushed out by the wholesaler with a chain of retail shops. He is collaring everything. In my constituency a number of public-spirited citizens have gone out of their way to make war on the black market, but the Press has not given them the publicity they deserve. Two L.D.F. men went into shops where there was a black market in cigarettes. They brought the cases to court and a fine of £25 was imposed in each case. After three weeks the Dublin Press gave that instance a small paragraph. I am not accusing the Press. I am sure the fault must lie with the reporters or somebody else, but I am sure that, if we get the help of the Press in this campaign, an inroad will be made on the black market up and down the country.
I want to come back to the point about the wholesalers. Beer, stout and other beverages are becoming scarce. These are very necessary for the community and for revenue purposes. Again, we have wholesalers with retail bars in various parts of a county. So far as I can observe, and from the information I have for April and May, these wholesalers with the chain shops are punishing the small publicans throughout the country and keeping supplies for their own retail shops. That is a matter the Government should look into. Very often, the small shopkeeper pays on the nail and does not keep books or accurate accounts. Therefore, he does not know exactly what his 1941 supplies were. Then, in the midlands this time 12 months, foot-and-mouth disease was rampant. In some parts, no fairs or markets could be held and the result was that supplies to shopkeepers in these areas were very small. They have not got supplies in this particular month and they are two or three days without any stuff on their shelves. If anything could be done to relieve that situation, we should feel very grateful.
So far as I understand, the paper industry, generally, is one of the largest industries we have. Nothing very practical has been done in the country in organising the collection of waste paper. I suggest that the county councils should take a hand and that, through the parish councils, they should establish depots on the same principle as the Legion of Mary depot in the centre of the city. People in the parish could bring their waste paper to the depot at certain fixed times. The amount contributed by each individual might be very small but the total amount for a county would be very considerable. I suggest to the Government that, through the Ministry of Local Government, an effort should be made immediately to organise the collection of waste paper through parish councils, urban councils and other bodies.
Last week, Deputy Morrissey referred to a surplus of potatoes. The same state of affairs obtains in our county. There is a surplus of potatoes which cannot be disposed of. The Government should examine that surplus in the light of the next harvest and see what can be done. These potatoes will have to be dumped in the ditches within the next five or six weeks. I do not know how far the pig industry reacts on that. I am fairly conversant with that industry but not conversant enough to enter into criticism of the Pigs Marketing Board. We have been trying to co-operate with that board for the past five or six months and, when we try co-operation for a few more months, I may be in a position to offer criticism. One thing I do know is that there is a surplus of corn in various granaries and barns up and down the midlands. There was a prosecution in Meath the other day for the stealing of oats from a farmer, and it came out in court that he had 450 barrels of oats. It was pointed out to me that another man gets 250 barrels of wheat turned once a week in the hope that he will earn an extra 10/- when the price goes up in the autumn. I am told by experts that he is going to lose by the transaction. Whether he is going to lose or win, the wheat is needed and action about this surplus should be taken immediately by the Government, now that the sowing season is over. This surplus should be released for human consumption.
Comment on this
It is a consolation to us that we are able to discuss the Budget in peace and security. It is also a consolation to most of our people that we had a Budget of the nature that we now know. It came as a big surprise to almost all the people. Deputy Hurley expressed the opinion that the Budget helped everybody except the worker. There was no increase in either direct or indirect taxa- tion. To have no increase in indirect taxation must be some consolation to the workers. They are, certainly, assured that none of the commodities they use, which are really the necessaries of life, is taxed by this Budget. That, in itself, is some advantage. Notwithstanding that Deputy Dillon pronounced it an election Budget, I think that it is quite a common-sense Budget. Under the conditions in which we have to live, it is a Budget which has satisfied the whole community. The conditions under which we have to live are not different from those we expected. In discussing this matter a couple of years ago, a Labour Deputy intervened and, I think, agreed with me, that if we got through this ordeal without actual starvation we ought to be quite satisfied. If we have starvation or hunger here or there up to the present, we, certainly, appear to have the means of preventing that starvation. At that time, we agreed that food could be produced in abundance here but that transport might be difficult. I think that we have reached that stage now. We have an abundance of potatoes. Deputy Kennedy and Deputy McGovern referred to the surplus of potatoes in the Counties of Westmeath and Cavan, respectively. We all know that there is an abundance of potatoes in many counties. I am quite sure that there are places where they are wanted, and I am not sure that they are not wanted in greater profusion in the City of Dublin. I am not sure, however, that the people, generally, in the City of Dublin are prepared to go to the trouble of cooking potatoes. I think that is part of our education that should not be neglected. As far as I know, potatoes are not wanted and, from information that I could gather in the city, even cold bread or stale bread is not wanted.
Comment on this
The Deputy would be well advised to leave remarks like that to the Ministers, because they have necks of brass.
Comment on this
A lot of this nonsense and semi-propaganda that is going on should be dropped at a time like this.
Comment on this
That is part and parcel, I suppose, of the democratic principle, and it is a good thing if we can accept it as criticism, but it may be a bad thing for the community in general. In my opinion, there is no necessity for half the grousing that goes on, provided always that an effort is made to educate the people up to procuring their needs and providing food. It is extraordinary that many Deputies have made the statement that there is plenty of potatoes throughout the country, that there is danger of their decaying and that at the same time there is hunger in any part of the country. There is something wrong in that.
Comment on this
Quite so. Whether it is the transport system or the distributive system or something else that has caused that situation, that matter should be examined. It may be because people in the city do not want potatoes and that, consequently, potato factors do not want to bring them in. I am not able to prove that. That may be the case. Certainly potatoes are not too costly. They have been sold last week in the County Cavan for 50/-. We have reached a stage where we are satisfied that there is food enough to prevent hunger but that, for one reason or another, we are not able to transport or distribute that food. The problem is one of transport and distribution.
Comment on this
Unfortunately. Money is another thing that is being talked of lightly, and how it can be made available. There may be innocent people who believe that the Government or the Dáil can turn on a machine and produce any amount of money and distribute it through the country.
Comment on this
Germany and Italy— countries that possibly one might imagine to have the newest ideas— when they were faced with a problem of unemployment, which was one of the first difficulties they had, solved the problem almost entirely by manufacturing more materials. That was one of the solutions. The Labour Party in Great Britain, when they got into power, stopped the manufacture of munitions to a large extent.
Comment on this
When they got into office. Their policy was to stop this nonsensical thing of arms and spend money on something else. They did not succeed in that and they did not remain there very long.
Comment on this
That created a great amount of unemployment. We have people going through the country now stating that there is roughly £270,000,000 lying in the banks on deposit, that that money should be taken out of the banks and handed round to labour and other people who are in need of wages to the extent of £3 or £4 a week.
Comment on this
I do not know who it was that made the statement. I heard the story and I have been convinced that some person made that statement.
Comment on this
It must have been an account of a statement from some Fianna Fáil platform in the past.
Comment on this
It took a lot to convince me that it was made, but I am convinced now, after several people have repeated it. That statement was made down the country to agricultural workers and turf workers. It was not made in the City of Dublin. There was another statement made there, a totally different one.
Comment on this
Where the statement was made in the country to any foolish individual who might be inclined to believe it, it certainly started the idea. The man in the City of Dublin who was expecting to be unemployed in a day or two, where raw materials were running short in his factory, wondered to himself what was he going to pay for the stuff that was produced in the country. There was some slick explanation given of how he was going to get over the difficulty. Statements of that sort should not be made at this stage. Some indication should be given to the workers in the City of Dublin of what would happen if the cost of production in the country increased. Every one of us would be glad to see the working community getting a full wage. I am not one who agrees that 33/- a week as a minimum for the agricultural labourer is sufficient, but the point is can any more be procured for him? We appreciate that quite well in County Meath. We made an effort through the county committee of agriculture to help the labourer to produce vital and necessary food. For 5/-, we gave him five stone of wheat to sow in his garden, and I am glad to say that some 1,200 cottiers have availed of that opportunity and the wheat is growing. It will give them three or four barrels of wheat each anyway, which corresponds to about three or four barrels, of 20 stone each, of flour. We did that because we were satisfied that it was one of the ways in which we could help. We did not think it was right or proper to tell the labourer that he could get more than could be given to him or that such a wage would be given to him as would cause inflation.
Deputy McGovern spoke about the plight of the farmers. We had a discussion on the Agricultural Credit Corporation and how it relieved many farmers in the matter of frozen debts. The bank made an offer to a farmer to settle his debt for so much cash and the Agricultural Credit Corporation, when they were satisfied that the conditions were satisfactory, advanced him the money and helped him to start again. That was all a heritage from the late war. Inflation occurred then and the people who were caught in that inflation were the farmers and their workers. No man suffered more heavily or more seriously after the last war when deflation commenced than the agricultural labourer.
Comment on this
Well, I suppose the war was run by politicians and the policy of those politicians was inflation. It is not their policy to-day. Their policy to-day is the very opposite. In fact they are making every effort to control prices, and the price of the bulk of our export commodities is controlled. That is a clear indication that in Great Britain, anyway, the politicians do not want inflation. It is a clear indication to us that we cannot have any great increase of costings in this country if we are to sell at a profit under these fixed prices. It is true that our exports are now limited. We are exporting only cattle, poultry and eggs. Neither butter nor bacon, I take it, will be exported, and these two commodities are very vital to the community, but the cost of production of these commodities is limited and consequently the bald statement that farmers could easily pay a higher wage than 33/- without interfering unduly with the prices to be charged to the community, especially the wage-earning section of the community, is highly misleading. The great danger that exists in that connection is that we might be plunged into another period of inflation.
I have some criticisms to offer to the Government, too. It is not so easy for me to understand why oatmeal is not regarded as a vital food. I think every Deputy will agree with me that if our standard of living has increased so much in recent years that oatmeal, either in the form of porridge or bread, is looked upon as something that genteel folk will not consume, that is not a proper viewpoint. I believe that oaten bread and oaten porridge could be utilised to a large extent to replace the flour which is in short supply now. For one reason or another, millers do not appear to have any oatmeal, but I trust that in the coming year some steps will be taken to ensure that oatmeal will be available. We might not then be so worried in regard to the question of the amount of wheat available because oatmeal could go a long way towards making up any deficiency in the quantity of wheat.
I agree with Deputy McGovern in his remarks in regard to pig production. I suppose in this connection also our tastes have been very highly developed or perhaps over-developed in recent years. At all events I notice in the shops in the City of Dublin that the leanest possible bacon is the type that is most in demand. Some people will not buy fat bacon. That little prejudice is invading the country too, and it is really very hard to persuade oneself that there is any actual want when one goes into a shop and sees the type of bacon that is being sold—quite dry stuff. I think that the Minister for Agriculture and the Pigs and Bacon Board should devise some scheme by which a larger number of fat pigs would be absorbed in the trade. Fat is a very necessary commodity nowadays, and it is very desirable that people generally should be educated into using more of it. If there was a bigger demand for fat pigs it would go a long way towards solving the question of disposing of our surplus potatoes and of producing pigs at a profit. In recent years there has been a tendency to concentrate on the lean type of pig, but to-day there is a shortage of fats. There is a widespread butter shortage and practically every place I go I hear complaints about that shortage. That shortage is due, to some extent at least, to the foot-and-mouth epidemic last year, but it is due also to the fact that many farmers having disposed of any good cows they had, because of the high prices prevailing, replaced them with very mediocre heifers. The result has been that on many farms at present there is no milk for butter production.
It is true also that because of weather conditions there is a marked shortage of grass. Weather conditions favourable to the growth of grass would be even a greater boon at the present moment than a good Budget. I know that matters are beginning to look rather serious in the country in that regard, but that is a thing over which we have no control. I hope the Government will seriously consider firstly, the question of providing more oatmeal for the community and, secondly, the question of bringing about a change in the type of pigs put on the market in an effort to see that more fat bacon is made available. School-going children can make great use of fat bacon as everybody knows. There is nothing vulgar in speaking in that way although I am sure there are certain classes of people who would count it vulgar. An effort should be made to popularise the use of fat bacon because there is no more suitable food for young children, specially now that there is a shortage of butter. We have no guarantee that that shortage may not be more acute next year. The shortage is in part also due to the fact that people are now consuming more butter than formerly, but every effort should be made to induce them to use fats in other forms. One thing upon which we can congratulate ourselves is that in this third year of a terrible war there is no danger of starvation provided we can keep the machinery of transport and distribution sufficiently oiled. No matter what anybody says, I think the Budget surprised everybody and satisfied the people in general.
Comment on this
While the Budget has been a matter of consolation to the masses of the people, I can see nothing in it to cause any undue elation. When we consider the fact that the Budget will not balance, that we shall have to borrow between £4,000,000 and £5,000,000, and when we think of what is likely to happen at the end of the year 1942 or 1943, every one of us must wonder where we are going eventually to land ourselves. A Budget of £45,000,000 represents a taxation of £15 per head of the population—rich and poor, the infant and the crippled old age pensioner. It seems, therefore, an extraordinary Budget. Not so many years ago we heard from the rooftops, the cross-roads, and the public houses everywhere, about the terrible burden that was placed on the country, how the country was ruined by other men before this Government came into office, and how they were going to improve the lot of the labouring man, the poor man and the farmer, but now we come along and find that the burden placed on the people is just twice the amount it was then, and at a time when hunger is threatening the people. We heard long discussions about it here to-night, but in the Budget very little provision is being made to build up the foundations upon which our people might live, and continue to live, if this war continues for a few years more. In fact, instead of these foundations being built up, they are dwindling away bit by bit and month by month.
We had a discussion here to-night about milk, oats, wheat and other necessaries, and I think it is admitted by Deputies in all parts of this House that there is a scarcity of bacon, that there is a danger of a scarcity of milk and butter, and oatmeal is not to be had at all. That is pretty well known. Nobody can understand what has become of the oats in this country. Although a price, beyond which nobody could buy oats, was fixed, oats have disappeared. The last Deputy who spoke on the opposite side talked about the benefits of oaten meal. I admit that, certainly, it is one of the staple foods of the country —something that even the poor people of Dublin might use, where they would not use potatoes—but no oats are to be had, nor is there any provision in this Budget to see that we will have oats next year, or any of the other foods to which I have referred. No provision is made to put agriculture in such a position that oats will be available to the people in the ordinary way.
Milk, which is another staple food, has been decreasing year by year, especially during the time of the present Government. The numbers of our cows are decreasing, and the yield from cows is not increasing. We had a scarcity of butter last year, and another scarcity this year. Even now, in the middle of May, there is a scarcity of butter, and the likelihood is that next year we will not have half enough butter. Yet nothing is provided in the Budget to encourage the people, who are engaged in milk production, to produce more milk and more butter. One of the essential things, especially during this period of emergency, is that the agricultural community should be placed in such a position as would enable them to produce the necessary foods for the cities and towns.
We heard a good deal here about wages. Some of the Deputies opposite talked about 33/- a week, and said that the farmer could not pay more. If the farmer were placed in the position that he could get a proper price for his produce he would be quite willing to pay more. He is paying the 33/- a week willingly at the moment, but what are the Government or the county councils, or the other bodies that are controlled by the Government, doing in that regard? They are trying to reduce wages during this time of emergency, and thus causing friction all over the country. There is hardly a county in the midlands of Ireland in which the Government has not brought about friction as the result of some kind of cutting and paring, where it would not make an iota of difference. In each and every county we have friction of one kind or another going on, especially over turf-cutting wages. The farmer pays a man to cut turf much more than he pays for the ordinary farm work. In fact, when a man is cutting turf, the farmer gives him an increase in wages. The man working on the bog gets an increase in wages from the farmer, but the Department of Local Government and Public Health seems to think that, instead of an increase in wages for work on the bog, a man ought to be cut in his wages. It should be remembered that these men have to go to the bog and to cook a meal on the bog while at the same time keeping the house at home. I think it is a shame and a disgrace, and I think that the Minister for Finance should see to it that such things do not happen in the matter of the production of fuel, because there is waste and loss of time, and, as I say, friction is created, which is no good for production and which is going to stop production. As a matter of fact, production of fuel is stopped already in my county and, I think, in many other counties, as a result of this friction over a very small sum of money. Every day, in the newspapers, we read about the scarcity of fuel in Dublin and the other cities and towns, but because of Order No. 83, or something else, these men are tied to a certain wage. I think that that, in itself, is very bad, and it certainly is not helping us out of the trouble caused by the present emergency.
Now, surely, something could have been saved in connection with this Budget, even if it were only for the purpose of devoting the money saved in one Department to the use of something else. Take the Civil Service itself. It seems to me that there ought to be some saving in some Departments, but there is not. Some Votes have already been discussed, including the Vote for Lands. We find that, in connection with the Vote for Lands, the amount for administration has been increased. It is very hard to understand that, seeing that much of the staff of the Department has been practically taken away and put somewhere else. Surely, there could have been some saving there on the Budget, and surely there might be some saving on Defence also. It is almost impossible to understand how the Department of Defence can cost £9,000,000, no matter how it is taken, and I think there certainly was room for some saving there. I wonder did the Minister for Finance go into that matter at all? Defence is costing almost £2,000,000 more than last year, and surely there was as much danger to the country last year as there is this year. In fact, in my opinion, that Department should not be costing so much as last year, because the danger signs are less in the West than they were last year. I cannot see why after 12 months we should have to pay £2,000,000 more for that Department, because it seems to me that the danger signs are going to the East and not coming this way, and unless there is something that is unknown to this House, or that nobody in this House knows about, I cannot understand why the Vote for the Department of Defence has increased at all, or why, in fact, it should not be even less than last year. I move to report progress.