We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Emergency Powers (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1942—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–161 of 329. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Emergency Powers (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1942
Enacted

No. 16 of 1942 ›

On Section 6, Sir. The words used in the section are: "For the purpose of removing doubts", and I should like to have some information as to what is the intention of this section. In the original Act—that is, the Emergency Powers Act, 1939— certain powers are given in Section 2 (1). One might almost say that they are omnibus powers, and then sub-section (2) of that section of the Act sets out a number of individual authorisations or special powers, covering some two or three pages of the Act. Now, as to what the doubts are, I do not think that was explained on the Second Reading of the Bill. I took it that so far as the enumeration of certain specific powers is concerned it meant that it was placed beyond doubt that there was power to do those things and that there was reserved, in Section 1, other powers over and above those which were so set out. Perhaps we would hear what are the precise doubts that are being dispelled by this section, as it is strange that, having had the Act in operation for the best part of three years, same question, of which the House knows nothing, should have been raised, which prompted the insertion of this particular section.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is mistaken when he says that no explanation as to the doubts was given on the Second Reading. I think I pointed out, in general terms, that the difficulty was that when you have general powers and, afterwards, specific powers —particularly if, in the enumeration of these specific powers, there are certain limitations—these specific powers would be interpreted as covering the particular thing in question, and that, to that extent, if they were in any way restricted, the restrictions that would be implied in that particular section would be implied in the general powers given. For example, in paragraph (d) of Section 2 (2), of the Emergency Powers Act, 1939, you have the phrase "otherwise than in Irish currency". It might be suggested, for instance, that because you make that limitation there in regard to the specific matter mentioned in paragraph (d)—that is, "the acquisition by or on behalf of the State of any currency other than Irish currency"—Irish currency was excluded because you excluded it in the particular enumeration. The court might hold that this matter was under consideration definitely in paragraph (d), that you exclude Irish currency and, therefore, that you are excluding it altogether from the power of the Minister or of the Government. Now, that was not the intention. Very often, you have these excluding paragraphs because you are enumerating a particular kind, and you just want to say that you are dealing with that particular kind and not with something else. It is to remove doubts of that sort that this section is introduced. That is a simple example that I have given, but in general there is that possibility, and the idea is to provide that such a possible interpretation of Section 2 (2) would not lead to a diminution of the generality of Section 2 (1).

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy McGilligan. I move amendment No. 1:—

After the word "commission" in line 18, page 3, to add the words "nor operate to add a liability or to increase a penalty for such act on a person beyond the liabilities and the penalty prescribed at the date of the commission".

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The first three amendments in the name of Deputy McGilligan seek to provide that a penalty shall not have retrospective effect. Amendments 1, 4 and 10, possibly, have some points of difference, but that is not clear. Amendment No. 3, in the name of the Taoiseach, may be considered to meet the points raised in some or all of Deputy McGilligan's amendments.

Comment on this

The purpose of amendment No. 1 is to ensure that that which was not an infringement of the law on an anterior date, should not be made so by this retrospective clause. The purpose is to ensure that the same safeguard would be inserted, in respect of a penalty, which would flow from declaring something retrospectively. For example, if it were decided to make the purchase of cigarettes subject to a certain penalty—let us say, a licence or something of that sort—and that an amendment of the law was made by means of an Emergency Powers Order, retrospectively imposing a licence fee in excess of the amount that was in force on a particular date, we are ensuring that there would be a safeguard where a thing of that sort would occur.

Under the various emergency Orders and other legislation of the State a sum of something like £20,000 has been collected out of licence fees and other things of that sort. It is a considerable sum, and in view of the tendency in this Act to add noughts either to penalties or fines, some safeguard should be inserted which would ensure that there would be no danger of an extra liability being incurred by any citizen of the State by reason of the retrospective power that is taken in this section. It is quite clear that in certain cases, if Orders are to be amended, in the interests of the public they should be amended retrospectively, as in the case mentioned on Second Reading. The supposition there was that an alteration took place in, say, the value of coupons for clothing. Suppose it were necessary to tender 40 coupons to-day for a suit, and that the Order requiring that number was amended to-morrow, reducing it to 20, it would be unfair, I think, to the person who tendered the 40 coupons yesterday not to make a return to him of 20. There is a necessity for the amendment, I think, in a case like that. There does not appear to be anything in the section as it stands to prevent an increase in any liability which may be imposed by means of this retrospective provision. It is for the purpose of dealing with such cases that the amendment was put down.

Comment on this

We propose to meet the point which the Deputy has raised in amendment No. 3, which appears in my name. Section 8 is the penalty section, and I think it would be more appropriate to bring in the matter of penalties there. If the Deputy turns to 6A he will see that, as it will appear when the proposed insertion is made, it covers his point.

Comment on this

It only covers portion of it, the portion which deals with the offence. Let us assume for the moment that on the 5th day of January this year the licence for selling wheat was £5, and that on the 5th day of February an Order was issued amending that emergency Order by laying it down that the licence to be paid for dealing in wheat was £50, that, I suggest, is not covered. What is covered is merely the offence, but the other matter, the liability which is more or less to be interpreted from the amended section, is not covered. One thing deals with something which is punishable, but the other thing— the liability—is not, I think, covered, and it is that point that I am concerned about.

Comment on this

That is possibly true. I will look into the matter. I am advised that there is the possibility that the Deputy's point is covered otherwise. I must say that my view is the same as the Deputy's at the moment.

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy McGilligan I move amendment No. 2:—

To delete lines 22 to 27, page 3, and substitute therefor the following:—

"(a) by the deletion in sub-section (6) of the words ‘and every person who not being an Irish citizen or ordinarily resident within the State commits or is deemed to have committed within the State an offence under this section';

(b) by the insertion of the following two sub-sections after sub-section (6), that is to say:—

‘(6) (a) Every person who,'".

The section in the original Act dealing with offences, punishments and so on consisted of eight sub-sections. This Section 8 seeks to amend that section in a number of ways. It proposes to increase the penalties on summary conviction. The fine is not to exceed £500, and there is provision for otherwise increasing the penalties that may be imposed. The purpose of this amendment is to divide the liabilities into two classes, keeping the penalties which are to be imposed on Irish citizens to what was laid down in the Emergency Powers Act of 1939, as originally passed, but allowing for the change that is proposed in this amending Bill to apply to persons who are not Irish citizens, persons not ordinarily domiciled in this State. The amendment marks this distinction: that a person coming in from outside to create a disturbance is regarded as being one almost outside the law. As regards persons who are Irish citizens, our desire would be to give them at least this measure of confidence, that we would hesitate to believe that, as citizens of ours, they would engage in such activities. We desire to mark that distinction between citizens and non-citizens in our legislation. When the original measure was introduced quite a number of changes were made in it before it finally emerged in the form in which it has been the law for some time. So far as the new and additional penalties are concerned, they are reserved, by this amendment, for non-citizens, while the penalties provided in the original Act, which is in operation to-day, are reserved for Irish citizens.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, the penalties originally provided do not appear to have been sufficient to deal with our own citizens. This measure has not been brought in to aim at one class of offender only. It does not propose to distinguish between those who are ordinarily resident here and non-citizens. The difficulty, apparently, has been with our own citizens. There have been a number of prosecutions and the penalties provided do not appear to have been sufficiently severe to indicate the magnitude of the offences committed. This particular measure has not been designed to deal with a particular class of offender, namely, those who are not citizens. If cases of the kind which the Deputy seems to have in mind occur, the justice has the power to distinguish between them. The penalties which are being provided are sufficiently high to enable a considerable amount of discretion to be exercised by the justices, even after this measure has been passed. We assume that if there was a situation, such as that indicated by the Deputy, the justices would duly note it.

However, the unfortunate part of it is that it is offences committed in the main by our own citizens which have given rise to the need for this. I do not think, therefore, that we would gain anything by leaving it as it was in regard to our own citizens. With regard to possible offences committed by people who are non-citizens, at the moment we shall have to leave that to the discretion of the justices in regard to the distance they will go beyond the minimum. If, of course there was an indication that there was a definite campaign by non-citizens resident here, then we might have to move in the direction of further excess penalties, in the direction the Deputy indicates, but I have no information that there is anything like that actually occurring at present.

Comment on this

It will be conceded that the penalties proposed are very heavy. The total punishment which a person might incur in this case is so heavy as almost to suggest that it is punishment for high treason. We have probably two methods of dealing with offences, one, a fairly generous and easy form of punishment, and the other, which is very heavy, one which might almost cripple a person's finances and leave him and his family in penury for the rest of their lives. That type of penalty rankles in the mind of a man and in the minds of his family. It is a very nice question as to how far persons conjure up these things in their minds before committing an offence. It is thought by quite a number of people that a man's downfall is brought about, as we learn in the catechism, by little and little and, consequently, he may find it easy to arrive at a stage in which he commits some offence which the State considers merits very severe punishment.

The real question at issue here is whether the penalty proposed is sufficient to deter people from committing an offence. If the very heavy penalty proposed is sufficient to deter people, then it is possible that there would not be so much objection on the part of Deputies to passing this section. But, human nature being what it is, we fear that it will not. There are quite a number of ways in which a person can become liable to this very heavy fine and you will then have a situation in which you are probably making a bad citizen out of an indifferent one, or perhaps even out of a good one. To that extent it struck us that the penalty proposed was too heavy; that it was almost dangerous to have a penalty of that sort; and that unless the offences are so serious as to warrant very special penalties, we ought not to pass a section so penal in its effect.

There is another aspect of this question of making the penalty as heavy as it is. Persons are inclined to take a risk that they will not be convicted owing to the enormous liability that would be incurred and owing to the operation of the law being so slow it is liable to come into contempt. However, what is at issue here is whether the offences are so serious as to warrant these very heavy fines and other penalties that are involved. I think the House is entitled to some sort of proof with regard to that. Take one particular offence which I believe has grown up since the emergency, namely, smuggling. Whatever prompted the legislature to make that a major offence, it was done, and every person responsible for altering the legislation in this country has followed suit. But it has not stopped it. In fact, if one can believe the rumours in connection with it, it has almost added zest to the activities of those engaged in it. When the penalties are enormous they say: "If we can get through on three journeys, it is possible to bear the heaviest penalty that could be imposed and to make money." Therefore, you have the speculative gambling spirit entering into the matter. If the fines were smaller, it is possible that there would be less sympathy for the persons who would be caught and what is surrounded now by a certain amount of bravado would be regarded in quite a different manner. Again we are faced with the problem: has it stopped it? Will this stop the breaking of the law? I fear it will not. Unless we were satisfied that the offences are so serious as to warrant very heavy punishment, I think the House ought not to pass so penal a clause as this one.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I am very much disturbed by the penalties outlined in this section. I have in mind particularly what the Taoiseach said on the Second Reading when he referred to offences under the tillage regulations and was endeavouring to justify, particularly, the terms of this section which sets out penalties of a very severe order indeed and also sets out minimum penalties. After all, on reflection, why should we set out minimum penalties of that kind? We, as a legislature, do not presume to be dictators. We leave the matter to the judgment of the person who hears the case and who is justice appointed for the purpose. There are circumstances which we here cannot provide for and which we ought not to try to deal with in a general way. All people are not possessed of the same amount of intelligence and in very many cases there are extenuating circumstances with regard to these tillage offences. I know persons who have been prosecuted under the tillage regulations and in some cases very small fines have been inflicted. Perhaps the Taoiseach would not think they were commensurate with the gravity of the offence owing to the existence of the emergency. But it is quite possible, if the Taoiseach knew the weak mentality of some of these people and the conditions under which they have to live, he would feel very differently about it. If we provide a minimum penalty of £100 we will probably inflict very grave and very serious injustice on some people. We are not probably the best persons to judge in the matter, although the Taoiseach and the House may feel that we are the best persons to decide that an emergency exists. We certainly are not the best persons to judge on the merits of a particular case as it is presented in court.

It is quite possible that if the House indicated that it was not satisfied that some of the penalties imposed were commensurate with the gravity of the cases, there might be an improvement, if I might use that word, in that respect with regard to the penalties imposed. But when we set down, as is now proposed, that the penalties shall not be less in some cases than £100, or not more than £500, we are doing something the reactions of which may be very serious for us all. I feel that, in the majority of cases, if we insist on enforcing a penalty of that nature, we will be doing a very grave, a very serious, injustice to people. I think it is quite sufficient for us to make it known that there is not general satisfaction at the penalties that are being imposed in some cases; but that we should fix a minimum penalty and insist on not less than a specified amount of £100 or not more than £500 or a term of imprisonment of not less than six months, without knowing the circumstances of the various cases to which those penalties are to apply, would be inflicting a very serious injustice upon some people. It is quite possible that certain individuals would be getting off lightly—I am not disputing that—but even one instance of a very grave injustice to people who did not deserve it is something we ought not to be responsible for, if we can avoid it. I am entirely with the Taoiseach that, so far as tillage prosecutions are concerned, they ought to be dealt with according to their gravity, but I am opposed to a fixed minimum penalty. That is something we ought not to do, and I ask the Taoiseach to withdraw that particular portion of the Bill.

Comment on this

I am not quite sure, from what the Deputy has said, that he has carefully read this Bill. We are not here laying down definite penalties of not less than £100. We are merely envisaging a range of offences for which £100 might, in some instances, be a relatively small penalty. We are saying that, by order, certain things may be done, and we are defining the limits of the Order, the extent to which it can go. We are saying that a minimum penalty up to £100 may be prescribed in particular cases. I do not see that we are laying down a penalty of £100. We are merely indicating a range of offences in respect of which an Order may set out penalties. There is nothing in this measure which says that there shall be a minimum penalty of £100 for any offence.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

It sets out a specified amount, not exceeding £100.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to 6A (a)?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Yes.

Comment on this

According to that "the Government may, whenever and so often as they think fit, by order under Section 2 of this Act, do one of the following things, that is to say:—(a) Declare that the punishment which may be awarded, in respect of a specified offence under this section, on summary conviction thereof shall be a fine of not less than a specified amount (not exceeding one hundred pounds)...."

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

It may reach £100.

Comment on this

It may. You must give a certain latitude to the Minister and the Government in making an Order, in view of the variety of cases to be covered. I agree with a good deal of what has been said with regard to penalties in general. It is true that people will take risks. What we have to do is to make the penalty sufficiently great that, if people are prepared to gamble, it will not be the gain side that they will have to look upon, but the other side. There may be big gains made by doing certain things, but they will have to consider the other side as well. What we have to do is to make them realise that the loss might be very much more of a certainty than the gain. If there was a certainty of punishment, it would have a deterrent effect. It is not possible to ensure that they will be caught. What you have to do is to make the risk sufficiently high.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

You are definitely endeavouring to get into the net the people inclined to gamble. I am not concerned with those people. I am concerned with people who very definitely cannot get on with their work. I know of a family who got into serious trouble over debts, and they could not get machinery or other things. They could not be described as gamblers. If there was a minimum penalty, and if those people had to bear it, it would be a very definite hardship and a great injustice. The district justice or some other judge should be the person to decide.

Comment on this

The Deputy has in mind one type of offence.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I agree.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, we have a whole variety of offences to deal with. I have already read out a list of the different types of offences. You will have those who will think of private gain rather than the emergency and the community need. They will try to make money by using their lands in a way very different from the way in which the community requires them to be used at the moment. I mentioned the last day that it is the practice of the Department of Agriculture, before they prosecute, to satisfy themselves that there were no circumstances in individual cases which really mitigated the offence of non-compliance with the Order. That is the administrative side.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I do not think it is the practice.

Comment on this

I am informed that has been their practice.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

That is not my experience.

Comment on this

I can only give the information which has reached me. I have been informed by the Minister and his officers that in regard to the enforcement of the Order there has been a practice of not prosecuting until they have satisfied themselves, prima facie anyhow, that this was a case where the tillage Order could have been applied and was not.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

My experience is that they compelled everybody, no matter what the conditions were—and I am entirely with them.

Comment on this

There is, as the Deputy probably is aware, the possibility of an appeal after the courts are finished with a case. There is the possibility of an appeal to the Minister for Justice, who is the Minister in charge of all these matters, for a mitigation of the fine.

Comment on this

How does he handle that?

Comment on this

I said to the House when I was dealing with that on the last occasion that it is quite true that the Minister has not all the material for forming a judgment that the justice would have. This form of legislation is distasteful to the Government and distasteful to everybody, if we could avoid it, but the emergency is such that we feel we cannot do without it. I have a whole list of cases where the penalties were ridiculous in view of the offence that seemed to be committed, that is, prima facie. Again, I am not the justice. But, when you get a large number of these cases, the general feeling is that the justices do not appreciate the gravity of the situation. One of the difficulties we are in is that we have followed the British system in regard to our system of law generally and in regard to our courts, and so on, but there are parts that we have not adopted.

One of the things, for instance, that we have not adopted is the practice of the British Home Office of sending around circulars, indicating certain general principles, not dealing with particular individuals, but indicating in regard to a particular type of offence and a particular piece of legislation what is the matter involved and what are the consequences from the community point of view. We do not do that. I would imagine that if we had that system, one of the first things we would have done when the Compulsory Tillage Order was made would be to issue a circular giving a general indication of the gravity of the crisis and the importance of growing sufficient food for the community.

It would be pointed out how grave an offence it was to feed wheat to animals and the danger to the community in doing that, that it was anti-social in an emergency like this to do it and that, consequently, the offence should be regarded by the justices as a very serious one. We did not do that and the result is that you have a great lack of uniformity between the attitude taken up by the various justices in different parts of the country. One man who appreciates the situation is inclined to be severe, may even go to the point of being more severe than the Minister or the Department would be if acting as judge. In another case you have people who treat it lightly. This legislation is brought in by reason of the fact that there was an accumulation of cases in which the justices seemed to regard offences in regard to this matter as if they were really trifling infringements of law, almost technical matters. Cases where people were let out under the Probation of Offenders Act, and so on, seemed to show want of appreciation on the part of the justice of the gravity of the situation.

There was no other course left. We postponed it; we hesitated about it; we put it back more than once, until finally the position was reached in which the Ministers said that they did not think that they would be able to get the regulations which they felt necessary to make the Orders effective unless we had this. We are coming to the House in the very same spirit. To meet the Deputy's point of extremely difficult cases, there is the remedy of an appeal for mitigation to the Minister and that is the only way in which we can cover these exceptional, hard cases that may occur. We agree that they may occur and, consequently, that some sort of machinery should be provided to deal with them. That is the only machinery we can see. However, the penalties here are not fixed in this Bill but there is power undoubtedly left to fix these. If you make the limits lower I am afraid you will put it out of the power of the Minister to make it sufficiently severe in a case where we probably would agree that the offence was of the type that the penalty should be as great as the Minister would make it. I am afraid, in view of the circumstances, that I cannot go any distance to meet the views for mitigation or lightening of these penalties. I am afraid if we were to make them less, we would put it out of the Minister's power, even in a case where the House would be prepared to grant that power to the Minister, to take the necessary action.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

May I put this point to the Taoiseach: he may be misjudging some of the justices and their judgments? I remember one case and I should like to put it to the Taoiseach to see what he would say to the decision in this case. A man was prosecuted for non-compliance with the tillage regulations. He is a small farmer. He was ill last year and he recovered. He had not very much money. In the ordinary way he would be subject to a fine of between £10 and £20. The district justice asked this man what he was prepared to do this year and the man said he was prepared to till his quota this year plus what he was short last year provided he was not fined anything, because if he were fined he would not be able to buy the seed.

Comment on this

That is a fair offer.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

The district justice imposed a very small nominal fine of £1 instead of a fine of £10 or £15 or £20. That man tilled three or four acres extra because of that and because he had the price of the seed. Was that judgment good or bad for the community? I put that to the Taoiseach. The judgment of that particular district justice might be taken up in this House and paraded as a most idiotic, ill-considered judgment, whereas I think it was a good judgment.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan has taken the regulation fence before we pass the preliminary fence in relation to quite a number of these. We will come to that in its own time, but for the Deputy's information, I may tell him the Civil Service would not accept that explanation and anybody who knows it realises that what I am saying is quite true. There are various offences set out in this particular piece of legislation. We propose in connection with them to increase the fine to a fine not exceeding £500. We propose later, on conviction on indictment, to make the person liable to a fine of £5,000 and at the discretion of the court to ten years penal servitude. That is a pretty stiff proposition. A man would require to be guilty of a very serious offence in that case. Let us take an example. We will suppose that an Army officer took an aeroplane out of this country to one of the belligerents. Is that a type of case that would be regarded as a major offence under this legislation? Presumably, that man would be dealt with by a courtmartial and presumably also those who were responsible for courtmartial would have in mind the gravity of the effence and would fix the penalty to meet the gravity of the offence. I wonder would they fix a penalty of £5,000 and ten years penal servitude? I have the greatest possible doubt that they would do that. In fact, I would go so far as to say they would not do it. Very good. What is the offence under this Bill which renders a person liable to a fine of £5,000 and ten years penal servitude? We are laying down the law here for the courts. I am not going to go into it now, but we are in essence taking away from the courts a discretion which they have so wisely exercised down through the ages. The judges of the courts have earned the confidence and respect of the people because of their knowledge of humanity and their general acceptance of jurisprudence and because of the fact that a person who goes before them knows he is not there to be destroyed.

What I am afraid of is that this legislation means persecution and destruction and I do not think that legislation such as that will ever earn respect or consideration from the people. Amongst the series of offences for which I presume a person would be liable to heavy penalties is that of aiding, abetting or conspiring with another person to do certain things. Anybody who knows this country knows that sometimes quite a number of innocent people are often dragged unwittingly into cases of this sort and they may become liable, under this Bill, to a heavy penalty. For that reason I say that we should mark a distinction in this legislation in the gravity of these cases. I am prepared to give the Government these powers if they want to use them against persons who are not citizens of ours. If outsiders come in here and take these risks, if they interfere with our laws during a time of emergency, any power the Government desires to deal with them I would willingly concede to them, but I hope, as regards our own citizens, we shall temper justice with mercy. I should very much prefer to see minor infringements of the law go unpunished than that even a very limited number of the people would be convicted by the courts, in circumstances which would make these convictions rankle in their minds and the minds of their families for long afterward, or that they should feel that they had been unjustly dealt with by the authorities. As I said before, one peculiarity of this State and the neighbouring State is that the authorities regard any offence against the State as a mortal sin. If a man robs me of £2—it is about as much as ever I have in my pocket—that is regarded as a venial offence. But let him take 5/- from the State and he will probably get 12 or 18 months in jail. I am very much less able to sustain a loss of £2 than the State is of 5/-. There is, however, that sort of peculiarity, that there is a tendency to deify the State by this type of legislation. I think that is unwise and it is not likely to instil in our people that respect and veneration for our laws which it should be our duty to foster in all our legislation.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach made a very strange case in support of the fixing of a minimum penalty, when he stated that it was necessary to fix such penalties because we failed to follow the example of Great Britain in circularising justices in regard to the gravity of these offences. The question naturally arises why should we have failed to circularise the justices in regard to these offences? If the Taoiseach has to choose between two courses, surely the more humane and the more sensible would be to circularise the justices in regard to the seriousness of these offences rather than to tie their hands and to deprive them of any discretion. I am only concerned with the cases in regard to compulsory tillage. There will arise cases of aged people, perhaps of uneducated people, who may commit an offence, who are definitely guilty of a violation of the law and who could not escape being prosecuted on the plea the Taoiseach has mentioned that their violation of the law was justified. At the same time, the circumstances would be such that no justice would consider it desirable to impose upon them the maximum or minimum penalties which are prescribed here. Justices are only human beings like everybody else, and if they are called upon to convict, if they feel that a conviction means putting an unfortunate person out of his home or putting his children out on the road, they will be inclined to err in the other direction and acquit the person prosecuted. That is a consideration which should weigh with the Taoiseach. I think that the plan which he has mentioned as being followed by the British is a very wise one and should be followed here. In so far as maximum penalties are concerned, if they are not sufficient they should be increased to whatever extent is necessary in view of the nature of the offences.

Comment on this

I think in these cases the Government should be very careful before providing for minimum penalties. When the Oireachtas passes laws to impress upon everybody the seriousness of the situation, that should be done by providing heavy maximum penalties but the moment you decide to prescribe minimum penalties, all sorts of questions will arise. You will have cases coming before district justices in which the minimum penalty that can be imposed will be so serious that it will mean that a poor farmer may be put out of production. A case has arisen in my county at the moment in which a farmer, who owned a fair farm but who was ill for a considerable time and who had not much money, was called upon to till about 17 acres of land. He went to his bank, or to the bank in which he thought he would get some money, but he could not get any.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Where he keeps his overdraft.

Comment on this

Yes. He could not get any money from that bank. He then applied to the Agricultural Credit Corporation for a loan but, because he owed some money to the bank he would not get a loan from the corporation. He then applied to the Minister for Agriculture to get a loan from the county council but he found that before he could get that, he would have to get two solvent securities who, of course, would be called upon to pay if he defaulted. While there may be many friendships in the country, it is very hard sometimes to get a security who must be a ratepayer of a certain valuation before he will be accepted by either the county council or the committee of agriculture. In the end the poor man himself was obliged to take his spade in his hand. He went out, himself and his family of six daughters—he had no sons—and they turned with their spades about four and a half acres.

Comment on this

And he could not get any credit from the banks!

Comment on this

That man worked from last November and he is working even yet, turning with his spade and doing the best that in him lay, but now he is summoned for failing to comply with the tillage regulations. That is an offence under this Act. Surely to goodness, when that man comes in and discloses his circumstances to the district justice, the district, justice should have discretionary power to say whether he honestly tried to comply with the law? He has about five acres tilled, but that is immaterial. The facts that can be established before the court are that the man made the best effort that within him lay to comply with the law. Of course, one might say that that farmer should have set that land, but, mind you, farmers in the country do not very much like people coming in on their farms. There are a thousand and one reasons why they do not want them. He may be able to get a lot of people to take the land if he opened the gate, but for his own reasons he felt it was better that he should hold his own fort and do the best he could. I think when the facts come before the district justice he should be able to say: "Very well; what will you do next year? Can you do so much better?" In a case like this—mind you there are many similar cases throughout the country, and I am just taking this one as a sample—the district justice should be allowed to say: "Very well; I will fine you 10/- or even 2/6 on condition that you do so much tillage next year." That poor unfortunate man does not know the first thing about petitioning the Minister. Perhaps he reads the Longford Leader or the Roscommon Herald once in the month if somebody else tells him there is something of importance in it. I think that the minimum fine should be taken out, and the maximum put there. What is the Taoiseach's point in having the minimum here? The district justices have not realised the seriousness of the situation? There is only one way for him to tell them that, and that is by putting in the maximum and impressing on them how serious it is.

Comment on this

The maximum is there.

Comment on this

Well, double it, or treble it. There is a very nice way out of it. If there is some set of facts brought before the Government which show that the district justice has so far forgotten his position and so far failed in his duty, is there not authority vested in the Government here to impugn that particular district justice? Can you not say that you propose to relieve him of so-and-so on the following grounds?

Comment on this

If you wish, I will talk about that later.

Comment on this

Yow wish to impress district justices with the seriousness of the situation, so you are going to tie their hands to such an extent that they cannot have the smallest little grain of mercy. If you put upon me the obligation that there is only one penalty for an offence, death, what are you doing to me? I cannot exercise mercy. I can only find the person not guilty. If I want to save that man's life, there is only one thing I can do, and that is find him not guilty, because I know if I find him guilty he will be shot in the morning. You are doing the same thing to the judiciary of this State. I think it is a rotten situation. I appeal to the Taoiseach not to do it. Put the maximum in there. The Minister for Justice can send for the district justices of the country——

Comment on this

He cannot. That is resented.

Comment on this

You have an Emergency Powers Act under which you can do anything. Send for them, and have a talk with them. Can you not call them into conference?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

If you cannot, then——

Comment on this

That is the position.

Comment on this

You control the Methodist Church under the same Act.

Comment on this

What Act?

Comment on this

The Emergency Powers Act.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy is driving at. I do not understand.

Comment on this

He does not remember his misdeeds.

Comment on this

It you tie the district justice so that he has to impose this penalty, I think you will create a situation in which you will bring the law into disrepute, and in which there will be several people broken. It is like the economic war, in which certain farmers were smashed to the ropes. I know the Government regretted that, but because they had put themselves into a certain situation they could not do anything better about it. I think it would be much better to give the district justice at least the power which he has in the case of revenue offences, so that if he imposes a fine he can say that he recommends a reduction.

Comment on this

He can.

Comment on this

But it is not here.

Comment on this

It is not in the other place either, I am sure.

Comment on this

Will you look up your Revenue Act? You lay down exactly what the district justice fines in revenue cases. He finds that the facts have been proved; then, according to the Act, he imposes a fine of £100, reduced to so-and-so, with a further recommendation that it be reduced to so-and-so. The records show what the district justice has found. As this Bill stands, he cannot do anything like that at all. It is only when there is an appeal to the Minister that the thing is sent back to the district justice for his recommendations.

Comment on this

The district justice can take the initiative and make a recommendation.

Comment on this

If you have it this way, I think you are making a mistake, and I would advise you as strongly as I possibly can not to take that particular step.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:—

In paragraph (a), line 34, page 3, to insert after the word a "force" the words "at the time the offence is committed".

The purpose of the amendment is that which I have already indicated.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4, standing in the name of Deputy McGilligan:

In line 1, page 4, after the word "may" to insert the words "not less than six months before a prosecution to which this sub-section relates and in any case before the commission of an offence to which this section relates.

This is the amendment which has been spoken to by Deputy MacEoin and Deputy Brennan already. By this amendment, it is hoped to effect two things; one, that the judgment of the Government may be made not in the heat and rancour of the moment, when they are filled with the importance of the case from the State's standpoint, and with resentment that the law has been broken; in other words, that they will amend the law or make changes in the law at a time when there is no heat and no feeling that the State has been outraged. The law will be laid down then in sober judgment, and will be fair to everybody. That is the second part of the amendment. The other part of the amendment is to ensure that the law will be at least six months' old prior to a prosecution under it. It is not unfair. It ought to be possible, with the experience that has been gained over the last three years, to settle those matters, so that first of all, the penalties will be there for everybody to see, and to realise what will be involved by breaking the law. In the second place, I want to ensure that, under no circumstances, will a penalty be increased after the offence has been committed. Let us assume that a man broke the law by using a motor car when he was not entitled to use it or by selling a suit for one coupon when he should have obtained 36. The offence having been committed, I want to secure that the penalty will not be increased after its commission. That is not unreasonable.

Comment on this

With regard to the six months' period, I am afraid Deputies cannot expect Departments, which have to deal with new events and new sets of circumstances arising under the emergency, to be able to anticipate six months ahead the type of Order which it may be necessary to make in the interests of the community. There is no question of deifying the State; it is a question of trying to safeguard the community. Departments cannot be expected to be able to make an Order with reference to some matter that may arise in six months and penalties cannot be arranged before the Order is made. With regard to the other point, as to the fixing of a penalty after the offence, I think that that is already covered by my own amendment.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

I am informed that it covers that point as well. It is intended that it should be covered. I shall look into the matter.

Comment on this

It is possible that one portion of it is covered by the words "at the time the offence is committed." Surely, six months is not an unreasonable period. There are people being regularly prosecuted under Acts of Edward III. Surely the penalty in respect of murder existed before even the great Queen Anne, who is looked upon as having died a very long time ago. Six months is a long time when we consider that we have three years' experience of infringements under this legislation. Directly an emergency of this sort was envisaged, those who used to be described as the "law officers of the Crown" immediately put their hands into a pigeon hole and took out an Act which, altered according to the changes that had taken place, would meet the situation. To say that you cannot anticipate six months before an offence is committed what the penalty should be is to say what is unreasonable.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not serious in that argument.

Comment on this

What is the law under which a person is charged with murder?

Comment on this

What we are talking about is the question of Orders which may have to be made, from time to time, by the Minister in relation to the present emergency. In dealing with offences of various kinds, Orders are made and penalties are prescribed. How can you anticipate six months ahead the Order you would make at a particular date?

Comment on this

Let us understand one another. "The Government may, whenever and so often as they think fit," change the penalties. The penalties are already there. What I want to secure is that the changes will not take place later than six months before the offence.

Comment on this

That is not what the amendment says.

Comment on this

"Not less than six months... and in any case before the commission of an offence." I want to secure that these changes must take place at least six months before the offence is committed. Suppose that Deputy Corry were Prime Minister and that Deputy Dillon committed an offence, I want to make sure that Deputy Corry will not be in a position to fix the penalty to meet Deputy Dillon's case. Surely, if an alteration is to be made in respect of a penalty, it should be made six months before the offence is committed. In 6a, it is stated that the Government may, whenever and so often as they think fit, declare that the punishment for an offence on summary conviction shall be fines of specified amounts.

Comment on this

Where is the word change in that section?

Comment on this

The Government may, by Order, change the penalty.

Comment on this

Six months before you make an Order, you are able to foresee all about it!

Comment on this

I do not want to have it alleged that, a person having been arrested and charged, the Government then specified the minimum, amount he could be fined.

Comment on this

That is secured already.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

By the words "at the time the offence is committed".

Comment on this

That may meet one part of it. I want to make sure that these things will be, at least, six months in the refrigerator.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have to put down a different amendment.

Comment on this

The Government amendment did not appear until mine went in.

Comment on this

The Government amendment went in because Deputy McGilligan raised that point on Second Reading. It was intended to meet the point raised. His own amendment was intended to meet that and several other things.

Comment on this

These were drafted on the evening of the day of the Second Reading of this Bill.

Comment on this

Why should the Deputy make that foolish statement? He said that the amendment was put in: that was done because of the fact that Deputy McGilligan raised a number of points, which were considered reasonable and which we wanted to meet. The Deputy wanted to meet the same thing in his own amendment.

Comment on this

What is the objection to six months?

Comment on this

Because it cannot be foreseen. It is utter and arrant nonsense to say that it could. If you are making an Order, you cannot foresee six months ahead, and arrange the penalties. It means drafting an Order six months before you issue it.

Comment on this

Let us distinguish between making an Order and fixing the minimum penalty. This clause is one which enables the Government to fix the penalty and to change the penalty—that is, to put in a minimum penalty of £100, if they like, in respect of an offence. Take one case that we have been discussing here for a long time—the case of compulsory tillage. As the law stands, there were altogether some 540 persons alleged to be defaulters under the tillage Orders. I calculate that the exact proportion of that is three persons out of every 2,000 farmers in this country. This particular legislation will be law in a month's time—that is, in the month of August. I want to make sure that, in respect of next January or February, those people will not be liable to a fine of £100, because the Minister for Agriculture comes to the Government and, in a mad moment of political exaltation, tells them that, unless there is a fine of £100, he will not be able to keep control. I want to make sure of that. It is not unreasonable, having regard to the fact that only three persons are alleged to be defaulters out of every 2,000 farmers.

Comment on this

The Deputy, so far as I can see, is trying to force a door which is already open. The section reads:—

(i) in case the offence is one in respect of which any Order, made by virtue of the next following subsection...

that is, sub-section 6A,

is in force...

We have amended that to read:—

"is in force at the time the offence is committed."

If the Order is in force, the penalties in the Order are in force.

Comment on this

No, no.

Comment on this

The section says:—

Comment on this

Look at sub-section 6A.

Comment on this

That governs 6A. Otherwise, what is the meaning of the words "next sub-section"?

Comment on this

That is as regards the offence. I want to make sure that if the law is going to be changed, at least in respect of the penalty, six months' notice will be given prior to the commission of the offence.

Comment on this

But it cannot be fixed six months prior to the commission of the offence.

Comment on this

Of course it can.

Comment on this

I take it that an Order is made at any particular time because of a particular set of circumstances which require some regulation affecting the interests of the community. In the regulation a penalty is set out. What is the sense in saying that that penalty must be set out six months beforehand? You must begin somewhere, and you can only begin when the Order is made.

Comment on this

I will give the reason. I do not want a minimum fine of £100 in respect of an evasion of the tillage Order.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

This amendment of the Taoiseach does not at all clear up the point raised by the Leader of the Opposition. I take it that the Leader of the Opposition is seeking to amend the Bill, while the Taoiseach is reading his own amendment to show that the point is already met.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Supposing the Order came into force on 1st January. Supposing there was a change made on 1st January, and that a £100 fine was specified on that date. Then, supposing there was a commission of what is called an offence, on the 2nd January; then that person would be liable to a fine of £100. Is that not so?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

What the leader of the Opposition is trying to get over is that the person who was liable to a fine of £100 on 2nd January should have six months' notification that such a fine would be imposed for such an offence.

Comment on this

In other words, that all the Orders made should not have force until six months after they were made?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

No.

Comment on this

That is what the Deputy proposes.

Comment on this

You can bring an Order into force to-day, but I want to ensure you are not going to increase the penalty—fixing a minimum, maybe, of £100—unless there is six months' notice that that will be done.

Comment on this

Surely you cannot give six months' notice if the Order is being made for a specific purpose. It is made because it is urgent and because acts in contravention of it can be offences the very moment it is made. Surely the penalty must be put into the Order and will have to be effective when the Order becomes effective. If the Deputy wants to make some exception to that, he will have to bring in an amendment on those lines. The amendment he is introducing now is covered by this proposed amendment. It is completely impracticable to see six months ahead. As far as the penalty is concerned, the amendment brought in states that the penalty must be stated at the time the offence is committed—in other words that you cannot go back, retrospectively, and change the particular penalty for an offence, after the offence has been committed.

Comment on this

Let us read the amendment, in conjunction with the sub-section:—

(i) in case the offence is one in respect of which any Order, made by virtue of the next following sub-section, is in force at the time the offence is committed, the penalties provided by such Order....

A man may not yet have committed an offence. It may be that he will be charged next February, March or April with having committed an offence. I want to make sure that an alteration will not be made in the penalty. We are giving the Government extraordinary powers in this matter. It is not usual to allow any Executive to regulate minimum penalties in respect of an offence. It is the exception rather than the rule. It is a concession that this House is giving to the Government. We are asking, in connection with that exception—and it is a remarkable exception which would not be given in circumstances other than those of an emergency——

Comment on this

It would not be asked, I take it.

Comment on this

I am not so sure, having regard to the trend in places on the Continent. We are asking that six months' notice should be given of the penalty. That is not unreasonable.

Comment on this

I think it is most unreasonable. I cannot understand it at all. As far as I can see, we are either arguing completely at cross-purposes or something else is happening. I cannot see what the Deputy is hoping to obtain by this. He is asking for six months and, to my mind, he is asking a complete impossibility. A number of Orders are made—not all of them tillage Orders—in which the offence begins to be committed at once and, therefore, the penalty must be stated in the Order, and must apply immediately. You cannot anticipate six months ahead. If you wanted a regulation in relation to a particular type of offence, it would have to be limited to that.

This reminds me of an argument we had some time ago about two things, and it was settled finally by the word "not", which happened to have been omitted from the draft. Neither of us was able to understand the other. I am afraid that there is complete want of understanding from the point of view of reading this. On the previous occasion, I was reading a document I held, and the Deputy was reading one which he held —apparently another draft. In this case I am anxious to do everything possible. I assure the House I do not want this type of legislation, if it is possible to do without it.

The Deputy has asked me why we do not circularise district justices as was done in Britain. I have been told of a case where it was done, and the justices resented it. They said it was an impertinence, so to speak, to do anything of the kind. It was an attempt to get some uniformity and proper understanding. There will be another occasion on which we shall have to go into this whole question, but as I read this amendment, one point in it is that there should not be penalties different from the penalties in existence when the act was committed. I take it that that is covered. If it is not, I promise the Deputy I shall look into it and assure myself, by my own reading of it, and by any expert advice I can get, that the position is as I have said I believe it to be. With regard to the Deputy's suggestion about six months' notice, I think he is asking something which is quite impracticable, and, with all the will in the world to endeavour to meet anything I can meet, I am not able to meet his point, because to attempt to do so would, I think, be contrary to common sense.

Comment on this

The first part of this section deals with increasing the maximum penalty which may be incurred for breaches of the Emergency Powers Act. We go on then to 6a, which says:—

"In case the offence is one in respect of which any Order, made by virtue of the next following sub-section is in force, the penalties provided by such Order..."

We can bring out an emergency Order to-morrow stating that a person who contravenes an emergency Order is liable to particular penalty, but, when we come to 6a, I say that the Government can exercise that power only six months before an offence under it— under that power and not under the other power—is committed. There is a change there in the penalty. It is a different thing from bringing in an Order and bringing in an Order with a penalty. This fixes the minimum penalty which, in essence, is £100. I am asking that in respect of that change—a very big and very important change—six months' notice of the penalty only shall be given. It is a penalty in respect of which a district justice has no discretion. A man is charged for not having tilled ten acres. He has tilled nine and a half acres and he must be fined £100. I say that that man must get six months' notice that he will be liable to a minimum fine of £100. Is that unreasonable?

I am prepared to accept everything the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Supplies say about the importance of this, but I am entitled to look at what has happened over the last 12 months. I find that three farmers out of 2,000 have been charged with breaches of the tillage Order. No discretion whatever with regard to extenuating circumstances or reasons of any sort or kind will be permitted to a district justice in dealing with a case of this type. There is a minimum penalty likely to be imposed in this case—a penalty of £100—and I am asking for six months' notice of the liability incurred by a breach of the tillage Order.

Comment on this

If the Deputy has something like that in mind, why did he not put it down in some place where it would have reference to tillage? The Deputy is evidently aiming at something like this, that in the case of tillage Orders, just as prices are announced in advance, where possible —there are a number of cases where it is quite impossible—some time in November, after estimating what the position is likely to be, a quota should be fixed and anybody who does not meet that quota will be liable to a certain penalty, and that penalty will remain unchanged. If the Deputy is aiming at that, I am quite willing to take it up with the Minister for Agriculture and to see how far it can be done.

Comment on this

That is all I wanted from the very beginning. I mentioned it often enough.

Comment on this

While the Deputy gives that as an example, his amendment is altogether wider in scope. There is a certain time for sowing and so on, aud I suppose it would be practicable to give notice in September or October and to indicate a particular quota, although I do not know whether there would be sufficient stock taken of the amount of food available to enable the Minister for Agriculture to do it as early as that. On a few occasions, we have had to change the tillage percentage. We fixed it at one time in the late autumn and had to change it in the spring because we found that the reserves were less than we expected. With regard to meeting the Deputy on the tillage point, it is a different matter, because it is of peculiar character, but I still protest that his amendment does not set that out. He is trying to get as to put into an Act of Parliament something which is quite impracticable, because, while it may be possible to anticipate in regard to tillage, it is not possible to anticipate in the case of Orders in general, and this amendment would apply to Orders in general.

I am quite prepared to ask the Minister for Agriculture if we could get some amendment to cover the point, so that he could give notice in that sense. One of the troubles is that he has to fix a date so that, if he has to enter on lands, it will still be possible to till, because the purpose of this section is not to punish anybody. All these penalties would be avoided if people tried to work in accordance with the spirit in which they are prescribed, and tried to secure the safety of the community, but in those cases in which it is not being done, the Minister must be allowed a margin of time, so that if he thinks the community's need of food is so great that he cannot allow certain lands which ought to be tilled to remain untilled, he may carry out that tilling. Deputy MacEoin spoke of hard cases, but I say that these hard cases will have to be met by the procedure I have indicated, that is, by way of appeal for mitigation to the Minister, but if everybody who finds it difficult, and in many cases it is difficult for farmers, to meet our tillage requirements takes that line, we shall not have for the community the bread required, and we ought to approach this whole matter from that point of view. It is not a deification of the State but ordinary commonsense to try to get every member of the community to realise the seriousness of the situation and the necessity for everybody to do his part, and the farmers will have to do it. In the case of other offences, other things have to be done. Certain prices are fixed, and so on, and those prices have to be kept to, so as to safeguard the community from being unfairly treated. In regard to the particular question of tillage, however, it does seem that in a case of that kind, where an Order was made, say, some time in the autumn which would cover the whole tillage requirements, you could not say that a particular farmer had not fulfilled these requirements up to some time in spring. I think there is some date fixed—February is the month fixed at present, I think—as the date on which the Minister, if he is not satisfied, may enter upon the lands. That matter, as I say, will require a little bit of careful examination, and I promise to give it.

Comment on this

I am conceding the point in regard to tillage, but why not consider this whole matter in general? The only thing I am concerned with here is the change in the penalty. All I am asking is that that would be considered, and I am only putting it forward from the point of view of ensuring respect for the law. For instance, if a person should come into court and be convicted there on a changed penalty—that penalty not having been in existence at the time of his offence—he would be entitled to say: "That has been changed only in the last six weeks."

Comment on this

My information is that so far as the question of the penalty fixed before the offence is concerned, it is covered.

Comment on this

I agree that it is covered; but why, then, should there not be at least some longer time than merely that date? I do not want to bind it down to six months. We only put down six months in order to draw attention to it. I think that in the case of tillage; six months' notice ought to be given because people must make their dispositions, arrangements, and so on, and it might be that it would take the whole of that period for a man to get what he would require in the way of seeds, manures, and so forth. I do say that the date before the offence was committed was too close. I would not bind myself to six months, but I certainly say that it should be at least three or four months.

Comment on this

The unfortunate thing is that the amendment, as far as I can see, is not phrased in such a way as would meet the points that the Deputy, clearly, has in mind. I take it that he wants that if an Order providing a penalty has been in existence for a certain time—say, that there was a certain penalty laid down in an Order for exceeding the price in selling tea— and that it is deemed desirable to change that Order—it is the word "change" there——

Comment on this

I am not considering the Order. It is the penalty that I am considering.

Comment on this

Yes, but the change of the penalty in the Order.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

But each change of penalty would mean a new Order. I take it, there are Orders in which there would be penalties which it would be possible to change without going into further detail, but there would be other cases where that would not be possible. However, I shall go into the point with a view to seeing whether we cannot get some phrasing, that if there is a change there will be a certain interval before the change takes place: that is, when a new Order changing a penalty is made, the new Order will indicate that the penalty will come into effect after a certain date. I can see, at the moment, that just as in the case of other evasions, some people might take advantage of that interval to do things which they would not do at all after the interval has passed. However, I shall have a word with the Minister. I take it that in this case it is the Minister for Supplies who will be most affected and I will take the matter up with him in order to see whether the cases we envisage would permit of that.

Comment on this

The only case I am interested in is one in which a minimum penalty is fixed. You can change the maximum any way you please.

Comment on this

That is, where there is a definite minimum?

Comment on this

Yes. That is only where I am interested—a definite minimum; in other words, where there is no discretion left in the district justice.

Comment on this

Well, we have two cases of that sort: first of all, where there is no discretion left and you want to change, and again where there is a new Order and you want to prescribe another minimum. The other is this—and I think it would be more difficult to get agreement on it, because, apparently, it is regarded as urgent to have this thing properly understood—that there would be new Orders made. It may be possible— again, it is all "maybe" because I have not examined these things in detail——

Comment on this

The two points of discretion and a minimum penalty are the only two points I am interested in.

Comment on this

I see what the Deputy is interested in, but his amendment does not cover these points in the terms in which it is phrased, as far as I can see. I shall examine it to see, when there is a change, whether an interval would have to elapse before that change becomes effective.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 5 to 9 deal with the proposal to reduce the minimum penalties. The amendments might be discussed together, but separate decisions will be given if desired. Amendments Nos. 6 and 9, obviously, run together.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy McGilligan, I move amendment No. 5:—

In line 8, page 4, to delete the words "one hundred" and substitute the words "twenty-five".

I have said practically all that I have to say in connection with these matters. I am against this proposition of immense fines. I do not know that they ever had the desired effect in this country, and by the desired effect I mean accepting the law, limiting the number of breaches of the law, getting respect for the law, and, generally, having order in the State. Where a person is liable to a very big penalty— and a penalty of £500 is big, no matter on whom it is imposed—and where the person concerned has had full advertence to the law, nobody has any great consideration for the person in that case. There is the second case, however, in which a person had no knowledge whatever of the danger that the was running and of the penalty under the law which he was incurring. Then there is the third case, in which there is indifference. The sum and substance of the whole thing amounts to this: Is the law that we are passing now likely to be generously accepted, or is it likely that there will be an attempt at general evasion? Is it likely that we will effect the purpose that we have in mind, of getting the law respected, by leaving in those impositions? Now, this is one of the cases in which the Government, "whenever and as often as they think fit, by Order declare any of the following things," and so on. That is to say, they made it clear that the punishment to be awarded may be a fine of £500, together with, in the case of a continuing offence, a further fine, not exceeding £10, for every day on which the offence is committed. I have a natural objection to this continuing fine business. It savours more of persecution than of prosecution, and I do not know that it is wise.

I said on the previous amendments practically all that I have to say. It would be highly desirable that we should get general acceptance of the law if it is passed. In a country with the history of this country, even for the last 20 years, if not for any period prior to that, there has not been, if one might say so, competition between the different political Parties in the State to show their desire to get the law respected. Now, there is general agreement upon this measure—not as regards its administration but as regards the necessity for having a code of this sort—and I think it was given a fairly generous measure of support from all parts of the House. We might conclude from that that an effort ought to be made to get the same measure of generosity extended towards any amendments of the law that may be involved. I disagree absolutely with Section 8. I dislike it because it is penal in every respect. It gives too much power to the Government. In my view a Government ought not, even in a time of emergency, seek the power to increase or vary penalties, and particularly the power to impose minimum penalties. I think that the case that has been made for this amendment of the law is not a strong one.

Take, for example, the tillage phase of the emergency Orders. The breaches that occurred have, to my mind, been negligible. Let us consider what was involved there. From 1927 to 1932 we had a period of political agitation of one sort or another in the country, one political Party in the State telling the farmers that there was no national liability on them in respect to the payment of the land annuities. We had then the economic war, during which the whole economy of the agricultural population was upset. Now, in a period of emergency, we tell the farmers that they must till 25 per cent. of their arable land. Let us see how they, responded to that demand. We find that only three out of 2,000 were liable to prosecution. Surely that represented a very generous acceptance, on the part of the farmers, of their responsibilities. Our answer to them is to bring in a law which gives power to impose penal liabilities on them: penalties of £500 and a continuing fine of £10 a day. I do not think it is advisable to hold such very heavy penalties over them, having regard to the very limited number of offenders that there have been.. On balance, I think that the amount of arable land tilled was higher than the 25 per cent. laid down in the Minister's Order. If there had been less, there might be a case for the giving of those powers. Suppose, for instance, there had been a conspiracy amongst a section of our people to defeat the law, there might be a case for some of those penalties. Generally, I dislike penalties of the size outlined here. Apart from an exceptional case in a particular county, I am of the opinion that any person engaged in agriculture who becomes liable to one of these penalties will be a broken man. If those penalties are imposed in his case he will hardly survive them. I do not think that we ought to pass a law which would create a situation of that sort for those engaged in agriculture. I think that some reconsideration ought to be given to those penalties in the light of all that has happened and of the knowledge that we have. There may be extenuating circumstances in particular cases. If these cannot be specified, we do not want to have them paraded so that certain people might say: "If we make a case we may get off." Allowing for the special circumstances to which I have referred, going back over the last 20 years, I think that the response made in regard to tillage has been very good, and that it might be well for us if we were to take a nought each off every one of those penalties.

Comment on this

The object of the amendments is to limit the enforcement of the minimum penalties set out in the Bill. Personally, I am opposed to the principle of minimum penalties. In these amendments an attempt is being made to mitigate what I would call an evil. Most of the discussion has centred round the penalties proposed to be imposed on farmers for non-compliance with tillage Orders. I am not quite sure that the object of the Bill generally is not directed against them I hope I am wrong in that, because I believe that, taking farmers generally, they are the most law-abiding section in the State. The figures quoted by Deputy Cosgrave prove that, since only three farmers out of 2,000 were prosecuted for failure to obey the regulations. I think the figure given by the Minister for Agriculture was one in 600 or 700. Either figure represents a very small percentage of the total. Could the same be said of any other section of the community: that only three out of 2,000 failed to obey some particular law? I am certain that minimum penalties are not necessary in regard to farmers. The figures quoted prove that, speaking generally, they discharged their duty under the tillage Orders very faithfully.

The number of delinquents was small. It may be that a good many of them were women who found it almost impossible to comply with the Orders. The fact that the district justices took that view proves my case, I think. Our district justices are not unreliable administrators of the law. They are an excellent body of men, and I believe are as anxious as any Minister that the law should be upheld. If, in the discharge of their duty, they find that there are extenuating circumstances in a particular case they ought be left a discretion and not forced to inflict penalties which they believe are not just. So far as the farmers are concerned, and I am speaking here principally for the members of the farming community, I resent the fact that they are being treated as Public Enemy No. 1 in the matter of the breaking of regulations. I do not believe that of them, nor does anybody else. In regard to these tillage Orders, if a farmer fails to comply with them his failure is almost certain to be detected. There is no chance of escape for him, because it will be obvious to everybody that he is not complying with the law. But, in regard to other sections of the community, they may break the law and still conceal the fact that they have done so. They can do that far more easily than the farmer can in regard to his tillage. Other classes in the community can not only break the law but can continue to break it without being detected.

To get away from the farmers for a moment, and to come to the ordinary, commercial people, the Taoiseach last week read out a list of people who had been convicted for breaches of Orders in order to justify imposing minimum penalties. I noticed that the great majority of the cases he quoted were cases where there was a very small breach of Orders; a case of a man selling tea at 3/8 per lb. instead of 3/4, or a man selling tea at 4/4 per lb. instead of 4/- when the price had been raised. Only in a very exceptional case was there a very severe breach of the regulations. Most of the cases he quoted were merely infinitesimal breaches of Orders. Out of the whole list there were not more than two or three cases of grave breaches of Orders. If we interfere with the discretion of the district justices in these cases, then we are administering the law in a harsher manner than I believe it is administered in any other country.

I have no doubt that there have been more serious breaches of the Orders than the Taoiseach read out. I am convinced that the infringements of the Order with regard to tea are not confined to charging 4d. or 6d. or even 1/- over the fixed price. But the majority of the cases which the Taoiseach quoted only referred to small breaches of Orders. The real offenders have not been caught and never will be caught, and providing for a minimum penalty will not catch them because they are too clever. The people who will be punished by these minimum penalties will be mostly those of whom I spoke, people who commit small infringements of the law and do not take any great trouble to conceal them. But you will not catch the real malefactors by this process more than by any other. They will still go on diddling the Minister and everybody else and will never come before a district justice. In cases which come before a district justice, I think the justice ought to have the discretion of deciding whether there were extenuating circumstances and of imposing a fine that will have some relation to the offence committed.

I, certainly, am opposed to the principle of minimum penalties in cases of breaches of the tillage operations. As I say, the offence is so obvious that it cannot go undetected, and the breaches of the regulations were so few that they only ranged from one in 600 to one in 2,000. There were evidently some reasons why that small number did not comply with the regulations, and if the district justices, after hearing the evidence, which the Minister will not hear, in their discretion see fit to impose a very small fine in certain cases, I do not think we ought to interfere with their discretion in the matter.

Comment on this

I think we weaken the case for this amendment by dwelling unduly on one particular class of defendant. The object of this amendment is to reduce the virulence of Section 8. Section 8 implies that every district justice and every Circuit Court judge are in a conspiracy to defeat the purpose of Oireachtas Eireann. Is that true or is it not? There never yet was an executive in any country that did not from time to time come to the conclusion that the judiciary were damn nuisances, that they were hindering and blocking the executive from giving effect to public policy and that something ought to be done to ginger them up. The plain truth is that Section 8 derives from exactly the same mentality as induced Deputy Smith, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach, to say on one occasion that it was high time we cleared some of the old "cods" off the bench that were on it on the occasion on which he was speaking, because the judges would not do what Deputy Smith thought they ought to do. At that time the desire which inflamed his manly breast was that the judges should put all of us who were not in the Fianna Fáil Party in jail, and because they would not do it, he thought some of them ought to be got rid of.

Now the Taoiseach feels that persons who infringe emergency Orders ought to be fined up to £500 as the minimum penalty fixed by Executive Order, or six months in jail at the discretion of the district justice. That is a thoroughly rotten principle, and it is a thoroughly rotten principle for this reason: no matter how carefully legislation is framed in this House, cases of exceptional hardship will appear in court. If an Act of Parliament were proposed that women who murder infant children should be made amenable to the capital penalty, few persons would demur at such legislation. If women want to go out and murder infants, it seems well to declare that they ought to pay the penalty for murder. Such was the law. But it became so manifestly outrageous to enforce that law that in Great Britain they amended the law and introduced a special category of crime known, I think, as infanticide, for which a very much wider discretion was left to judges in inflicting penalties simply because judges declared that this habitual sentencing of women to death in circumstances which technically constituted murder was insufferable, because in certain circumstances it was perfectly manifest that they should not be sentenced to death.

Now in a very much minor degree we are attempting to create the very evil that the British Legislature was concerned to abate, because we are saying to the district justices: "If a person is convicted of any offence which comes within Section 8, you must impose the minimum penalty whatever the attendant circumstances may be." It is very typical of the bureaucratic and indeed of the urban mind to take up that position, because they cannot transfer themselves into the circumstances in which we who live in rural Ireland normally live. You get a case brought before the court in which it is perfectly clear that in fact the land has not been tilled as it should have been. But it emerges that the land is the property of a widow woman, that she has one son whom she is gallantly attempting to maintain before the neighbours is a normal boy, but who, in fact, is known by all the neighbours to be a half idiot. The district justice and the State solicitor knowing the circumstances admit at once that this woman did not till the land and should have tilled it. But everybody knows the reason it was not tilled, because the woman left it to this half-competent boy to get the work done that his father used to do and, of course, he did not get it done. According to this, that widow woman is to be fined £500.

The Taoiseach says that she can appeal to the Minister and the Minister can mitigate the penalty. That is all very well. The woman sentenced to death for infanticide in England always did appeal to the Home Secretary and the penalty was always mitigated. But that does not save the unfortunate creature in court the intolerable suffering and apprehension that such a penalty hanging over her head occasions to her. Take a respectable individual operating a little shop in the country. The junior assistant, perhaps a lad of 14 or 15 years, or a little girl, sells a loaf of bread and charges 6d. for it instead of 5½d. The shopkeeper is prosecuted. He goes to court and admits at once that there was overcharging and he expresses his regret. He explains that the boy, had stepped behind the counter only ten minutes before the customer arrived and he did not know the price of the bread and merely took whatever coin was offered to him and threw it into the till. The district justice, if he is satisfied with that explanation, will impose a nominal fine in order to mark that such overcharging cannot be sanctioned and must be penalised. In the circumstances, a nominal fine will meet the case and will make clear that the district justice saw no vice or criminal tendency in the defendant. Under this section the district justice is obliged to fine the merchant £500, if that be the minimum, prescribed penalty.

If you are going to set up a legal system in this country designed to do substantial justice among the various communities where judges function, let the judges function. Let not the Executive intervene to take from the judges that measure of discretion which it was deemed expedient to give them when we established a judiciary. If the judges are of such a character that they will not enforce the law, then they ought not to be judges and the proper constitutional measures ought to be taken to clear them out. I know of nobody here who will say that the judges are corrupt or incompetent. If they are, there is a way to deal with that. The Government can get powers to remove them and put in their places men who will honestly and fearlessly do their duty. But if our judges are honest and competent they understand the circumstances better than the Executive. They know how best to secure the proper observance of the law. They know the methods which will most effectively achieve that end. Why not leave them the discretion they always have had?

I am arguing that this amendment put forward by Deputy McGilligan is a pis aller, something a little less obnoxious than what appears in the section. I want to impress one thing on the Taoiseach, and he is the kind of man who ought to understand because he is, perhaps, the least detached from the rural community of any of the Ministers. He ought to realise the insufferable hardship involved in putting a shameful and onerous stigma on somebody who the judge is satisfied is guilty of no evil purpose— he is merely being convicted of a technical offence. The Taoiseach ought to know that saying to a country person: “You can apply to the Minister for a remission of the penalty”, is very poor compensation. There is no use in talking of the collection of £500 from a small shopkeeper or farmer. They have not got it. They know the moment that sentence is imposed it can never be given effect to, because they cannot pay the fine. It is no special compensation to them to say: “You will never have to pay it.” They can tell you that themselves, because they will not be able to pay it. But that does not materially mitigate their mental suffering.

What is the measure of our problem? Against whom is this section being directed? What crime in this country is being encouraged by the district justice by reason of inadequate penalties? Will the Taoiseach tell us? Is there a plague abroad of land owners who are not tilling their land in accordance with the requirements of the statutory Orders? If there is, I have not heard of it.

Comment on this

Perhaps one in 600.

Comment on this

An overwhelming majority of land owners have not only tilled the statutory minimum, but a substantial acreage in addition. Deputy O Briain agrees that that is true.

Comment on this

Some of them set their lands on the 11 months' system at £10 an acre and tilled the poor parts.

Comment on this

There is nothing to prevent their letting land on the 11 months' system. This section does nothing to meet that. Surely we are not going to allow ludicrous misrepresentations of this section? If Deputy Victory does not know what is in the section, is it not time the Taoiseach told him? It is suggested that this section is for the purpose of encouraging the farmers to till the best land on their holdings. Deputy O Briain knows what this section is intended to carry out. He knows that it is designed to get at what he describes as the very small minority. But is it not "daft" to suspend the whole system of judicial operation in order to get after an evil which all agree is microscopic, presents no serious problem, and shows no tendency to spread?

If this House accepts in this measure the principle that minimum penalties may be prescribed for offences against emergency Orders, it is not the last we will hear of it. This precedent will be quoted and used again and again. Any practising lawyer in this country will tell you that this principle will result in cruel hardship which will afflict not the grave offender, but the defenceless individual who has come technically within the reach of the law. I am thinking of my neighbours in the country, of simple people and the kind of suffering that is occasioned to them by situations such as will arise under this section. I am asking the Taoiseach to throw his mind back to these people who do not know where they are, people to whom being brought to court is in itself a great penalty, people who, when they hear they are fined £500, will be inconsolable, because that in their ears sounds a sentence of destruction.

I strongly object to the section and I prefer the amendment. I will vote for the amendment and against the section. I warn the House that if it does not defeat the section it will be used hereafter for the purpose of introducing a similar principle into other legislation and, if that is firmly fixed in our system of law, then the independence of the judiciary has been very materially qualified, and qualified, not at the expense of the Government, but at the expense of the individual citizen whom the judges were originally appointed to protect.

Comment on this

I wish to protest strongly against this section of the Emergency Powers Bill which fixes a minimum fine for failure to till the required amount. I think the Taoiseach is making a great mistake in doing that. It is a great wrong to the farmers in view of all they are doing for the country at the present time.

Comment on this

Surely the people who do it are not the people who are going to suffer.

Comment on this

I would ask the Taoiseach to put himself in the place of some of the farmers who did not comply with the Order. There is 99½ per cent. of the tillage quota done in Westmeath, I am told by one of the inspectors, but I see an advertisement that four acres are to be set by the Government. I would ask the Taoiseach to go down to the person concerned and investigate his case personally. If he does that, he will see the hardship that would be inflicted if the minimum fine fixed in this section were to be imposed. I think this is a poor return to the farmers after all they have done in growing food for the people of the country. I must say that were it not for the action of the district justice in Westmeath last year, the full amount of tillage would not be done. If the district justice had fined everybody that came before him last year £20 or £30 there would be no tillage carried out by these people. He did a very wise thing, in my opinion. He gave all the people that were brought before him a month or six weeks, after which they were to come back and if they had done the required amount of tillage in the meantime he would reconsider their case. I am sure 40 or 50 cases went through the courts in that way last winter in Westmeath and in every case, when the person concerned came before the district justice again, the tillage had been carried out and in the majority of cases more than the quota had been carried out. If a fine had been imposed for not doing the tillage in the beginning, none of those people would have done their tillage; they would have nothing to do it with. If a farmer of 20 or 30 acres were fined £20 or £30, he would be crippled and could not possibly do the quota. The district justice in Westmeath in my opinion did much to get the tillage done and to encourage people who were not complying with the law to comply with it. I suggest that that should be continued next year. If a man is short in his tillage he should be given a month or two and if he does not carry it out in that time a fine could then be imposed.

The fixing of a minimum fine of £500 is like holding a gun to the farmer's head. I do not think the farmers deserve that sort of treatment because, as Deputy Cosgrave pointed out, the farmers by the acts of this Government for the last ten or 15 years have been brought to very low water. It reflects credit on them that in County Westmeath there is 99 per cent. of the tillage done and if the amount that has been done in addition to the quota were counted, the total would be well over 100 per cent. I think the Government should reconsider very seriously that section. No minimum fine should be fixed, but it should be left in the hands of the district justices and the judges. They will deal with it in the right way and will get the work done. I would ask the Taoiseach to consider that and to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I, like Deputy Fagan, of course, have every sympathy with the farmers in the great effort made by the great majority of them in this country, but we have exceptional cases who evade the law. I knew a man who did the ploughing and put in no crop.

Comment on this

Was that an offence?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Was he prosecuted?

Comment on this

He got away because it as possible to put in a crop within the year. Instead of sowing it in February, he could sow it in December. He got away on a technical point. Deputy MacEoin cited a case here this evening which, on the face of it, looks like cruel hardship. I would suggest that if the tillage inspector were sent for by some of those people who have difficulties about getting their tillage done, the tillage inspector could arrange for the setting of the land and give the owners some reasonable compensation. There should be some way out for that class of person. We have not many such cases, but there are some. I think everyone in the House realises the importance of growing food to-day. We are driven back on self-sufficiency whether we like it or not.

Comment on this

Supposing they got credit to do the work they were required to do?

Comment on this

There is a class of person who is trying to evade the law. I know some of them. They try every kind of game and sneer and laugh behind backs. I want to bring that person to book. The tillage inspector should be sent for and if he cannot satisfy the tillage inspector, the inspector should take over the land and have it tilled and pay the owner compensation. That would get over the difficulty. None of us, particularly those of us who are farmers, likes the idea of a compulsory minimum fine. I would be inclined to say to the Government that they should consider this. I was amazed when Deputy Dillon told us that we should take notice of what the judiciary is doing. He criticised what the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach said on one occasion and then he came along and went further himself.

I heard Deputy Bennett saying here that some of these farmers were too clever. I agree with Deputy Bennett there. It is the mean type that the whole trouble is about. I would suggest that the fine should be reduced, if that is possible, but at the same time I would only reduce it on condition that the tillage inspector was sent for, that he investigated the whole case and, where necessary, that he would try to set the land and give some compensation for the land he took over.

Comment on this

I am all in favour of the law being absolutely enforced and I am all in favour of nothing going forth from this House as said by anyone here which would in any way bring the law into disrepute. One of the reasons why I would be against the innovation contained in this section is that I think the effect of it would be to bring the law into a certain amount of disrepute. There came to my notice— not in my professional capacity—a certain prosecution. A shopkeeper in a country town had in his employment a servant girl who happened to serve an inspector, or some person making inquiries, with a box of matches at, I think, a halfpenny above the regulation price. That constituted a breach of the law and constituted an offence. It was my view, on hearing about the case that, so far as the shopkeeper was concerned, particularly having regard to the early stage in the history of these newly created offences, that it was only a technical offence, but I recognised that somebody has got to carry the burden in order to advertise to the public what the law is. A very competent district justice heard the case and he imposed a penalty of £10. The shopkeeper was entirely unaware of the sale. The sale was through the instrumentality of the servant girl who came into the shop because somebody came into the shop at that moment and there was no one in the shop to serve. Obviously, it was implied that the shopkeeper had given her authority.

I think any Deputy would agree with me that £10 was, under the circumstances, a severe penalty, but it may have been necessary in the general course of things to advertise the position of the law. But what would be the position if the penalty were limited to at minimum penalty of £100 or £500 in the same circumstances? It would break that particular shopkeeper. That is a very serious matter. I think that this section is altogether too harsh. It is introducing a novelty into the administration of justice that is entirely uncalled for and is offering a gratuitous insult to the bulk of the population of this country.

Comment on this

Why? How is the bulk of the population of the country insulted?

Comment on this

I am sure it is an insult to the bulk of the people of this country to suggest that they are not going to obey the law. I have given an instance. I have told the Taoiseach of a particular case where there was a fine of £10. I am a lawyer; there are other lawyers here; all of us here are in one way or another connected with legislation, and we find it impossible— at least I do—to follow day after day the Orders that are put out by the Government. With the best will in the world, it is very hard to keep up-to-date with the various offences that are created from day to day. The general members of the public are undoubtedly unaware of what is an offence or what is not an offence. You go to bed one night having done a particular act during that day, and you wake up in the morning and find that if you do the same act you will be guilty of an offence. There is not a sufficient explanation of what the law is. On numerous occasions there must be, and are, breaches of the law by undoubtedly innocent people. I am not suggesting for a moment that the Government are deliberately going to create offences or to frame penalties to fit these offences negligently or without due regard to all the circumstances of the case, but I do submit that the innovation introduced in this section leaves them open to do that. I do not think that the circumstances of the case or a knowledge of what has been happening in the country justifies this section.

The Taoiseach objected to my use of the phrase "a gratuitous insult". I did not use that in any harsh sense, but it is a gratuitous insult to the bulk of the population to suggest that they have not obeyed the ordinary law or the law as reinforced in the particular Act with which we are dealing. It is now found necessary to tie the hands of the justices to such an extent that they must impose in certain circumstances a certain penalty. That is the opinion we have of how laws are going to be interpreted and obeyed in the country, and I do not think it is a very good thing.

I hold no brief for those who have been dabbling in the black market, or those who have been overcharging unfortunate people. I want to see them brought to justice where possible, but I must say that I think that, if we pass this section, we shall bring the law into a certain amount of contempt because possibly there will be cases where the district justice, with a knowledge of all the facts before him, will be obliged to impose the minimum penalty and that will only lead to further evasions of the law. It will bring the law into disrepute. One can almost imagine what a justice will say with the ruined head of a family before him. He will say: "I have no discretion. That is what Parliament has decreed and I must accordingly impose this penalty."

When it was found necessary to deal with infringements of the licensing laws in this country some years ago an innovation was introduced in a sense making it mandatory that a conviction should be recorded and that forfeiture of the licence should follow, with the result that for some time licences tended to disappear altogether. At present there have to be three records of convictions before the licence is abolished. That was a concession to the licensed trade which successfully endeavoured to get the law amended in that respect. There must he three records of convictions now before the licence can disappear, but in many cases, if the minimum penalty proposition is adopted here, it is within the power of the Government to so frame the laws that any person can not only be wiped out of business as a result of the commission of a technical offence, but must, in fact, be wiped out of business. We here are the persons who will be held responsible for that. Surely to goodness, there is enough public spirit left in the country that the laws, harsh and all as they are at the present moment, difficult and complicated as they are to understand, will be obeyed by the people of the country without the necessity of resorting to such a section as this. What has happened during the past three years since September, 1939, to justify the harshness of this section? Surely we could frame this Bill in a different way? It is not beyond the wit of the advisers of the Government to frame Bills in a different way to get hold of the real blackguards and the real delinquents without leaving this extraordinary power in the hands of the Government. I do not wish the Government to assume, from that remark of mine, that I suggest, in any way, that they are going to misuse these powers.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that.

Comment on this

I do, undoubtedly.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon is capable of suggesting anything.

Comment on this

Experience has taught me.

Comment on this

I am speaking entirely for myself. I am not suggesting in any way that the Government will misuse these powers, but it is still a dangerous weapon to put in the hands of the Government and it is more or less a breach of trust in the people to give them these powers. When the original Act was passed in September, 1939, I thought that it was not such a good thing to give the Government these powers. I anticipated that they might be carelessly or improperly used. That was the breach, that was the chink in the armour, so to speak. We handed up the right of making laws to the Government. Now we are giving the Government not only the right of making laws but the right to fix minimum penalties afterwards and to limit the action of the judges in properly trying cases that come before them. I think it is a very unwise thing to do. It is neither necessary nor expedient and I do not think any case has been made for it.

Comment on this

If we could ever get to the Arcadian state of believing that the Government will not abuse powers given to it, of course we could wipe out the courts altogether. The only reason that the courts were established, that over the centuries the people have fought for the independence of the judges and have buttressed up and fortified the judges in their independence, is that there was that particular feeling that Governments would abuse their powers. If it were not for that feeling and if it were not for the experience people have with regard to the misuse of powers, a great deal of contentious history would never have been written. I have not reached the idyllic state of believing that the Government will not misuse their powers, and I want to guard against that misuse. I have listened to only one speaker trying to defend the section, Deputy Victory. He gave one case, and then he spoke of a category of cases. The one case is a case which in some way or another would escape the law altogether. It will not be met by this section. If it is a case which should have been caught and was not caught, the Government have ample power, which they avail themselves of frequently, to amend and change and repeal and put out new Orders. If it is only a case of getting wording to fit the offence, they have that power already. Deputy Victory then went on to speak of easing the fines. The whole burden of his song was to ease the situation which has been created in the country through the imposition, according to what gathered from him, of too severe penalties. That was the only speech made in defence of this section.

I want to try to find out what is the framework of all this. I have said already that, as far as the definition of offences is concerned, the Government have a free hand. They can define and re-define. They can do their usual business of testing by trial and error, and they can get there eventually. They can get a comprehensive definition which will catch anything they intend to catch, and they can do that by a series of Orders. If they are not capable of doing that, it is not our fault. They have the drafting experience, and they have considerable practice in these later days of trying to frame wording so that it will catch the particular offence they want to meet. So far as definition is concerned, they have every power that can be given to them. So far as the application of whatever definition they may get from time to time is concerned, I think they have the fullest possible power. In so far as they had not that power, they are given it now. Under an earlier section, they can make any Order retrospective. As Deputy Everett said, they have issued Orders and prosecuted under them at times when people, bona fide, were ignorant of what they were being charged with. I have personal experience of a case in which, under the Department of Agriculture, a person in the Cork and Kerry labour group was prosecuted; he was given time to do certain things, and up to the day on which that time limit expired it was not possible to get from the Stationery Office a copy of the Order under which he was prosecuted. But that did not deter the Department from going ahead, and that man had to be subservient to a particular piece of legislation of which he had no notice, and could have had no notice. I had notice, because as a Deputy I get advance copies of certain Orders. I was probably one of five or six people who had any knowledge of the matter. As far as that individual and his legal advisers were concerned, they attended at the Stationery Office day by day, until the last day of his term for complying with the law had come and gone, and day by day they were told that the Order had not been published. But that did not deter the application of the Order.

The definition is under the Government's control. The application, even with retrospective effect, is now under their control. As far as the penalty is concerned, and the sufficiency of it, there is no allegation made here that the extremity of the penalty is not sufficient to deter any of the people who may commit offences. As it used to be, it was fairly heavy; as it is going to be, under the early part of this Section 8, there is the possibility of a £500 fine, together with a fine of £10 a day for a continuing offence, and, at the discretion of the court, imprisonment for a period of 12 months, or, if the court likes, both such fine and such imprisonment. That ought to satisfy the most hardened bureaucrat as regards the weight of it. As if that were not enough, there is power that any goods or chattels in relation to or by means of which the offence was committed shall be forfeited, and those goods and chattels can be disposed of as the Department thinks fit. In the case of compulsory tillage, Orders have been made allowing entry on the land and the working of the land. As far as those land owners are concerned who may come under the harrow of the law, they can be fined up to £500, and, in case of a continuing offence, £10 a day; they can be sent to jail for 12 months, which ought to keep most of them from a repetition of the offence in the year afterwards, and in the meantime the land can be entered upon. If that is not a sufficient deterrent, the Government should have told us that it was the extent of the penalty that was not sufficient, and gone on to amend it still further.

On the lenienoy side, as far as the application is concerned, we are asked here to permit a minimum fine to be established. I asked that a case be made on that. I had hoped that some statistics would be produced—I gave an opportunity in a question put down yesterday—which would enable the House to form an opinion on one point, that is to say whether the cases in respect of which leniency is complained of are cases which are arising only in one or two parts of the country or all over the country. Very well, it is all over the country. I was wondering whether it was only in the case of one or two district justices, because the Government can prosecute anywhere they like. If one or two district justices are cranky about those things, no case need be brought before them. Those people can be prosecuted in any district court, irrespective of the place in which the person is alleged to have committed the offence. I find it is all over the country; in other words, it is the common view, the average view, and the district justices have from time to time, in respect of mitigating circumstances, worked towards leniency.

That, I think, is sufficient answer to any case that might be made. It is quite possible that you might get a district justice who was taking too lenient a view of a particular type of offence, but if the district justices on the average are, so to speak, being brought under adverse criticism here, then I think that is almost in itself a sufficient answer to the whole matter —that right over the country, when cases are brought before the District Court, the judges now and again find such mitigating circumstances as enable them to impose small fines.

I would not say, certainly in respect of one type of case, that there is any complaint about failing to find that an offence had been committed. I take a question that was asked yesterday in connection with the land offences, and I find that there are 430 occupiers prosecuted. Up to date, 341 cases have been heard in the courts, and 339 convictions were obtained; one case was adjourned and the other was dismissed without prejudice. Out of 341 cases taken into the courts, convictions have been obtained in all except two. Of those two, one was adjourned, so it is still pending, and the other was dismissed without prejudice. The district justices are certainly doing their duty in respect of finding that offences were committed. The fines ranged from the minimum of 1/- up to the maximum of £100. The question is whether the district justices were entitled to impose small fines in some of those cases, or whether it was proper for them to do so. They have the facts before them. The Taoiseach told us in this House that in certain cases the two Departments concerned, the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Supplies, did not believe that the mitigating circumstances were such that the particular fines imposed were sufficient. It depends on who reported to those two Departments. If it were the officials of the two Departments who were down in the courts, they might have felt rebuffed at the fact that a particular penalty was not imposed, and naturally their report back to the Department would be somewhat prejudiced. I think one would need to have heard not merely the Departmental side, but the opposite side before a correct judgment could be found as to whether or not the penalty imposed was a sufficient one.

On the known list of cases—this House at this stage I am sure will not go into the circumstances of mitigation and leniency—the Department simply having come to the conclusion that fines which were not proper were imposed, we are asked to change the whole law. In respect of an unspecified list of matters, we are to give the Government power, by Order, to declare that there is to be a minimum penalty. I think that that is too great a power to ask. We inquired about the question of an appeal and we were told that, if a minimum fine is imposed, so far as there is any complaint about the harshness of the fine, the only appeal is to be to the Department. Is not that getting very close to taking away the control of the judiciary and establishing a clear and open bureaucracy— giving the bureaucrats power, to be exercised on information which will be supplied to them behind closed doors, about which the public will not hear, where political considerations can weigh and where you are not going to have the same impartial outlook as that of a person who is buttressed in his position and accustomed to decide on the presentation of a case in open court? That is a bad change and a change for which no argument has been advanced. The only argument supposedly made in favour of it turned out to be an argument against it.

I ask the Government to reconsider this whole matter. If they do not think they have sufficient power in respect of any of the matters I have spoken about, they can describe the offence in anyway they like; they can hunt the offence by a series of phrases until they get the one that catches the point. They have considerable power and they have used that power to get people prosecuted in circumstances that seemed definitely unfair. There is power to impose a sufficient penalty, on conviction, to deter anybody from the commission of the offence. We find now, at the heel of the hunt, that, in so far as leniency is complained of, it is leniency on the part of the whole corps of district justices. Deputy Esmonde said that this was an insult to the public but surely we are now criticising, without any statement as to why, the whole corps of district justices. I do not think that that should be done.

Comment on this