Emergency Powers (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1942—Committee Stage.
Contributions 162–329 of 329. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 16 of 1942 ›
At the outset, I said that it was with extreme reluctance the Government took the step of bringing in this measure, that we realised that it would be very much better if we could attain the purpose we had in view—to safeguard the community—by indicating maximum penalties in the usual way, leaving the law to be administered by the district justices in the ordinary way. I pointed out that there were long lists—I read a number of them—of cases in which there had been convictions in respect of offences of serious consequence to the community. That long list indicated to our minds that the district justices generally— perhaps, there were some exceptions— did not seem to realise the seriousness of the situation through which we are passing. Somebody said that this legislation was an innovation. Unfortunately, the whole crisis is an innovation. We are asked to do things which we do not have to do in normal times. We have to get the people to realise that the provision of food for the community in present conditions is a serious matter and that it is also a serious matter for people to make use of the shortage of supplies to enrich themselves. The whole of this legislation is in the interests of the community, as a whole, and it is ridiculous for Deputy Esmonde to suggest that it is an insult to the community as a whole. The only people aimed at are those who are not doing their duty. If the majority of the people are doing their duty, then it is right that the black sheep should not get away with their misdeeds.
I should like to add my word of compliment regarding the work done by the farmers. The farmers have done marvellously well under the circumstances but it is not much of a compliment to certain farmers who have done their duty with great difficulty that somebody beside them, who could much more easily have done his duty, should snap his fingers at the law and refuse to do his part. This legislation is not aimed at the farmers. That it took the particular turn it did, is due to the fact that, as soon as this legislation was mentioned, the farmers' position was brought up. This legislation refers much more to offences for contravening Orders made by the Department of Supplies than to any other offences. The maximum penalties must be large. You have to put the maximum high because you have to cover so great a variety of cases. You do not want to prevent the penalty going up to fit the crime when the crime is of a particular type. The variety of offences to be covered is so great that you must necessarily have the maxima high. If we are to have minimum fines specified, it is equally important that there should be as much discretion as possible given to the Government when making the Order, so that, when dealing with a whole range of matters, if they have to fix a minimum fine for a particular offence, that fine will be sufficiently large to be a deterrent.
It is ridiculous to say, that this is persecution, rather than prosecution; that if you have power to go after a person for a continuing offence you are necessarily persecuting him. The whole purpose of this Bill is to prevent people from contravening for selfish motives the law made in the interests of the community as a whole. If the Ministers responsible for safeguarding the community in this matter find they cannot do so because of the trifling nature of the fines imposed, compared with the seriousness of the offences committed, they might as well not make Orders at all. The House either wants the interests of the community to be safeguarded during the emergency, or it does not. The Ministers who are responsible in this matter believe that we, here, are serious and that we do want to have these Orders obeyed and the community safeguarded in the way these Orders are intended to safeguard them. You have, for instance, petrol coupons offered for sale and you have the Probation Act applied in that case. You have a person using kerosene, contrary to the emergency order, and you have the Probation Act applied.
Comment on this
A case of kerosene being used in a motor lorry contrary to the regulations. In other words, the Minister's Orders, to ration kerosene and make it available in the best and proper way for the community, are being set aside. I read a whole host of examples the other day. I have a long list here. I am not going to read it, but I will take some cases at random from it. I will not select those which are particularly bad. I find a case here of tea, which should be sold at 3/4 a lb., being sold at 5/- a lb. A fine of 5/- was imposed for overcharging and one of 10/- for not giving a receipt. I find another case of tea being sold at the rate of 8/- per lb., a second offence of failure to mark quantities and a third of refusal to issue receipts. The decisions in that particular case, where there were three offences, were: the Probation of Offenders Act was applied in the first case, there was a fine of 10/6 in the second, and a fine of £1, with costs, in the third.
Comment on this
The Deputy can say that there are mitigating circumstances in regard to every one of these cases. I have no means of examining the details.
Comment on this
That is all I want. If we cannot get any one of the cases examined from the point of view of the mitigating circumstances, how can we examine them here?
Comment on this
There is no use in doing that, as every person can say that there are mitigating circumstances. If we are to have a deterrent, in the interests of the country, we must ask whether you are going to take every circumstance as a mitigating circumstance. The point is that it will be hard to find any mitigating circumstances, anyhow, for a person charging 8/- for a lb. of tea when he knew the price was 3/4 a lb.
Comment on this
The fact is that tea is not permitted to be sold at more than 3/4 per lb. and was sold in the present case at 8/-. The penalty in these cases was the Probation of Offenders Act in the first case and a fine of 10/6 in the second.
Comment on this
May I ask the Taoiseach this question? If the Taoiseach discovered, in the case of any person— and I am not defending the black marketeers—that there was a breach of the, Emergency Powers Order in selling tea at 8/- a lb., and that that was a person living near the Border, who had more persons on the tea card than he could get tea for, who bought 5 lbs. of smuggled tea, and produced to the court a receipt showing that he paid to the smuggler 37/6 for the 5 lbs. of tea, would the Taoiseach think that there were extenuating circumstances in that case?
Comment on this
I am not going to answer hypothetical questions of that sort, nor will I go into all the points which the Deputy's imagination could bring.
Comment on this
If we were to take all these cases, even at the end we would be no better off, because in any particular case the justice dealing with it took the points into account, summed them up in the presence of the persons involved, saw the witnesses, and had full opportunities. I do not think we would get any further.
Comment on this
I have a long list here which prima facie goes to show that the justices in different parts of the country do not appreciate the seriousness of the situation, and that there must be some method to see that the seriousness of it, as seen from the Executive side, will be brought before the community. We have not brought this in with anything like pleasure. In the case of tillage Orders, there are a number of cases here where fines have been imposed that seem to be altogether ridiculous. For instance, in a case where 63 acres were tilled out of 82. leaving 19 in default, which is a quarter of the amount, there was a fine of £2 with 2/6 costs. In another case, where 54½ acres were tilled out of 65, with 10½ in default, there was 10/- costs.
Comment on this
Because I have a list here which seems to indicate that the justices do not appreciate the seriousness of the situation through which we are passing. It is not their duty, from day to day, to take stock of the position as a whole. If there are cases like this, where 10½ acres are in default out of 65, and if other people take pattern by that, there will be a considerable shortage in the food supply. The Minister for Agriculture has seen where we will be if this is allowed to continue.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is convicting district justices. He is putting the case to us to convict them.
Comment on this
I am convicting nobody, but these results seem to suggest to me that the district justices, from the penalties they have imposed, do not appear to realise the seriousness of the situation. The people at the centre, who are responsible for the safety of the community at the present time, must have some method of making apparent the way in which they see the situation.
Comment on this
I can ask for them later. Last year there was an epidemic of foot-and-mouth disease, and a man might have his land fully stocked and not be able to afford to till an extra 10½ acres. I am not saying that that was the case, but would that not be a case which a district justice should take into account?
Comment on this
I was assured by the Department of Agriculture that, before they prosecuted in those cases, the general practice was to satisfy themselves that there were not mitigating circumstances to such an extent as would explain the failure to comply with the Order.
Comment on this
Has the district justice the responsibility for seeing that the community will be fed?
Comment on this
I am saying that these cases show prima facie that the district justices have not realised the seriousness of the situation.
Comment on this
I am putting it no farther than that. The situation is that we cannot hold the Minister for Agriculture, on the one hand, responsible for seeing that food is produced for the community, and on the other hand leave it completely and absolutely to other people to nullify his efforts, by giving altogether inadequate penalties as a deterrent. That would be an incentive to those who may have been inclined at first to obey the law.
The non-compliance with tillage Orders is not the most difficult or most serious case. The cases in the Department of Supplies are more serious. There is a shortage of certain supplies, and we must make some effort to spread the available supplies over all sections of the community. We cannot have some people in a particularly privileged position where, by money or some other means, they are able to get hold of these limited supplies and use them for their personal and private advantage. It is an attempt on the part of the Executive to see that if the rules made in the interests of the community are broken by people, they will pay a heavy penalty, and to see that they will not be tempted to gamble on the fact that they can make so much money if they contravene the law, and that, if they break the law and are caught, the penalty is going to be only a trifle. We want to balance up the account and make them feel that if they try to make money and are caught in trying to do it, at the public expense, at the expense of the poorer section of the community, they will have to pay a heavy penalty; that if they are going to gamble and speculate in that way, they will have to realise that there is a second side to it and that it is not all a question of gain for them.
I will admit, as I said before, that if we were able to be sure of catching all those who break the law, the certainty of punishment would be much better than the severity of it, but when you cannot make certain, as you cannot, that all those who do so will be caught, the neat best thing is to make sure that they will realise that they are running a big risk and, if caught, will pay a penalty. I can imagine all sorts of hard cases and all I can say about them—and I am not pretending that it is a complete and adequate safeguard —is that the district justice, if he thinks that in a particular case there are mitigating circumstances which warrant, a reduction of the penalty, can indicate to the Minister that, in his opinion, the Minister should exercise his discretion in that respect. The Minister in question would be the Minister for Justice. His Department is not the Department immediately involved in the enforcement of the Orders, so that, to that extent, there is an outside mind dealing with a particular case.
I will admit again in that connection that it is not as adequate as I should like it, because it is obvious that the Minister cannot try the case in the same way as the district justice trying it locally who has a view of the facts as a whole, and if it appeared to us that the justices realised the serious nature of the position, this provision would never have been brought in. It is because the Ministers who have the heavy responsibility of trying to ensure, firstly, that the community is fed, and, secondly, that those articles in short supply should be made available, feel that they cannot effectively do their work if penalties of the magnitude of those which have been inflicted in a number of cases continue to be inflicted.
That is the position as we find it, and I think the House will have to face it, too. We are in a serious situation. We want to get these things done and to make sure that those who are offending, and in many cases obviously offending wilfully, because it means money for them, will be severely dealt with. If there is any better way which can be suggested, I for one have an open mind, but having discussed this thing and seeing all the objections. which are being raised here—it is not the first time they occurred to us. I do not say that every particular objection did occur to us, but, in general, the principal objections raised here did suggest themselves to us—we reluctantly came to the conclusion that this power was necessary.
With regard to extending the scope of the provisions in regard to minimum fines—it is not absolutely new because there are two or three cases in which minimum fines are imposed by legislation already—we are not anxious at all to extend that scope. We can only say that we are passing through a dangerous crisis and the Executive must be armed with the necessary powers to safeguard the community, and, if justices do not realise the seriousness of the situation as we, whose business it is to see it as a whole, realise it, the only way in which we can convey it to them is by the Legislature, on the motion of the Executive, saying: "This is the case you make for it. We believe the situation is serious to the extent you mention, and we therefore convey it as a direct instruction of the Legislature to the justices that cases of this kind must be dealt with in the manner indicated by legislation."
Comment on this
The Taoiseach, so far from making a case for the minimum penalties proposed to be embodied in this section, has made a case against them. He has asked for suggestions as to some better method of achieving the purpose which he says he has in view and which I say we all have in view, and in so far as the Taoiseach in his opening remarks appeared to imply that any section of this House was in favour of any person taking advantage, or allowing any person in the community to take advantage, of the present emergency and the needs of the community, he was implying something which has no foundation whatever.
Comment on this
I do not think I said it and I did not mean to imply it. If, by any chance, anything I said could be read in that way, I want to say that I did not mean it.
Comment on this
That was the impression conveyed to my mind, but we may start with the certainty that all sections of the House are anxious and Willing to do everything possible to put an end to black marketing.
Comment on this
We object to this method of meeting the situation because we are entirely convinced that, so far from meeting the situation, it will merely aggravate, and, possibly, acerbate it. If the Taoiseach had taken the advice of some of his legal advisers, if he had had the industry to search into legal history, he would have found that one of the surest methods of bringing the law into contempt, one of the surest methods of providing means of evading the law, is the rigour of punishment. It has been the whole history of jurisprudence that over-rigorous punishment, so far from deterring criminals and so far from achieving the purpose desired, that is, the prevention of crime, had quite the opposite effect. British criminal law is built up on the manner in which severity of punishment was evaded by lawful and legal means.
What we object to is that while public opinion should be, and, to a very large extent, is, behind every effort to put an end to black marketing and to the exploitation of the needs of the community in the present crisis, over-severity of punishment, turning the district justice into a rubber stamp as this proposes to do, will cause a reaction in public opinion in favour of the black marketeers. That is what we object to. That is what over-severity of punishment always does. From the time I had anything to do with the administration of the law in this country from 1922, I fought inside against minimum penalties. I fought as Attorney-General against them, and I am fighting now as a Deputy in Opposition against them, because I believe they do not achieve their ends, and that, so far from achieving their ends, they bring about precisely the opposite of what is desired.
The Taoiseach appears to me to have adopted the theory of a writer on jurisprudence whom I remember reading. His speech recalled to me my student days when I read in some book on jurisprudence the theory that it is better for the law to be certain than just. That sentence appears to me to embody what the Taoiseach has just said: that it is better for the law to be certain than just. The Taoiseach wants to be absolutely certain that if there is an offence, however technical it may be, automatically the district justice has nothing to do but to record a conviction and impose a minimum penalty. What is going to be the result of that, apart from the effect on public opinion? The result is going to be that nothing but minimum penalties will be imposed on those who have mitigating circumstances and on those who have not mitigating circumstances. There is no objection from this side of the House to the maximum penalty, provided that it is the persons in whom the Executive have entrusted the exercise of judicial power in this State, by their own appointment, who do that sort of thing. We have no objection to a particular maximum penalty being put in to meet a particularly serious case, but to provide that every case, irrespective of the facts and circumstances, must be dealt with on the same par as a very serious case, and a case where there are no mitigating. circumstances whatever, is something that we cannot stand over.
The Taoiseach, on two occasions, in the course of his remarks, stated that there was a prima facie case against the district justices. He said that there was a prima facie case that their actions in connection with prosecutions, imposing fines and other penalties, gave the impression that the district justices did not appreciate the gravity of the crisis. A prima facie case? The only sort of case that could be made for this is a conclusive case, or, if not a conclusive case, at least a case that is not merely a prima facie case. A prima facie case, from its very terms and words, means a case that can be answered. If it is a prima facie case, an opportunity ought to be given to allow it to be answered. I heard the Taoiseach giving a few instances, which did not commend themselves to me at all, but before I refer to them I should like to ask this question. Have the Government, or the Ministers who are responsible for the prosecutions in the cases of which they now complain, made any representations, through State solicitors or State counsel, in any particular case or series of cases, that the circumstances of the time or the particular circumstances of the case, irrespective of mitigating circumstances, required that in view of the gravity of the crisis the offence should be marked by a heavy penalty? Have these representations been made by State solicitors or State counsel in court before the district justices, before these justices are condemned on what the Taoiseach has twice said is merely a prima facie case? Everybody knows what is meant by a prima facie case. It means a case that has not been really investigated, and that is the case that we are asked to pass this section on, a case that has not been thoroughly investigated.
The Taoiseach said—and, of course, it was perfectly obvious that he could not be in the position to say anything else—that he was not able to give the circumstances of each of these prosecutions which were before him. He spoke of somebody selling tea at 8/- a pound instead of 3/4. Everybody knows that 8/- a pound for tea in the black market is a ridiculous price. It is 5/- a quarter in Moore Street, and the usual price is £1 per pound in the black market. Leaving that aside, however, I can give a case, that came within my own purview in practice, and where there were mitigating circumstances, of a proprietor of a big concern who had given definite instructions to his employees not to contravene the Order, but an employee, perhaps for reasons of his own, sells the tea at 8/- instead of 3/4, and a prosecution follows. The proprietor comes in to the district justice and says: "I have done everything possible to comply with the law; the law has imposed on me liability for the acts of my employees, and I am prepared to accept that liability, but at the same time justice requires that if I have taken every step that was reasonably and humanly possible to see that the law was observed properly, I should not be punished in the same way as the person who actually did the job." I know of cases also where the actual person who sold the article at a greater price than the fixed price was fined less than his employer, who was held vicariously responsible for the act of his employee.
There must be some justice in this. Justice must be tempered with mercy, or there will be no respect either for justice or the law, and that is what we object to in this: that it will defeat its own ends. We object to it on the question of principle, in the first place, but also on the question of expediency. because we believe that if the district justices are treated fairly, they will do their duty by the people and the State as they have always done it. I want to know, and I ask again, can any Minister connected with these prosecutions tell me, or can the Taoiseach ascertain it from his Ministers and tell me, or any case where, a solicitor or counsel prosecuting in any offence having made representations in a particular case to the district justice, these representations were deliberately ignored?
The Taoiseach has spoken about a case of the sale of petrol coupons where the Probation of Offenders Act was applied. If that Act was improperly applied, the prosecution would have their remedy, as there is an appeal in a criminal matter, by certiorari, and I want to know if that was tried in this case of the application of the Probation of Offenders Act. I want to know if the Taoiseach has forgotten that in all these cases he has available to him the machinery of the Military Courts, the special tribunals, which have been largely availed of. Why not try them, as they have, in fact, been tried in certain cases—even in connection with the sale of petrol coupons? I have seen such cases come before the special tribunal, and what is the hullabaloo about, when you have that tribunal? It has not, perhaps, the judicial experience and the judicial training of the district justices, but where is the case for us condemning, by a legislative Act, on a prima facie case, an inconclusive case, a case in respect of which the Taoiseach is not able to give any details or any conclusive or coercive evidence—where is the case for us condemning the district justices for not realising the gravity of the crisis? I think it will be agreed that since 1923, when that body were established, they have given the greatest satisfaction of any branch of the judicial hierarchy and have done their duty in every crisis; and in ordinary fairness to them, a case of this kind should not have been made here, in the first place, and if there was a case to be made, at least there should have been an opportunity afforded of answering it; at least, the prosecuting counsel or solicitors, in condemning these cases, should have made their representations in open court and to each particular district justice. That is where the case should have been made, and not in this House—the case that has been made here for increases. in penalties.
We have not got any statement or any evidence whatever that these men have not realised the gravity of the situation. I would venture to say that probably the whole of them, and certainly 99 per cent. of them, are in closer touch with the people of this country than any member of this House, including the members of the Government. They are fully alive to what is going on around them. They live with the people in their districts and they know what is going on, and the gravity of the situation. They are in a judicial position. They have to act between the prosecutor and the person charged. No person can be a judge in his own cause and I say, and I emphasise it, that, particularly, no official either can be, or ought to be allowed to be, a judge in his own cause, because that is what is happening here. It is the officials who want this. It is they who want, as they always wanted, this thing of minimum penalties—that has been my experience since 1922—because they want to have their own way always, and they cannot understand a judge hearing a case impartially and then deciding against the way they want it to be decided.
I have seen—and I know as much about it as any member of the Government—that a person who is in a position to prosecute in any of these cases for the State, inevitably becomes an advocate. When he is making his report, you will not get a fair or impartial review of the circumstances of the case. You will get a grouse and a growl against any decision that is brought against the State. They always complain when there is an adverse decision. I have never known a case where any Government Department or Government official was satisfied when the case was given against them. I am quite satisfied that the judge or district. justice who decided a case against the State was not wrong, but that is what is happening here.
The last thing that I have to say is this: that so far as I know—and I am open to correction if I am wrong—in the case of the multitudinous Orders made during the last war under the Defence of the Realm Regulations, and in the case of the multitudinous. Orders that are being made at the present time in Great Britain when Great Britain is fighting for her very existence, I challenge the Taoiseach or any member of the Government or their legal advisers to produce any regulation which provided for minimum-penalties in a time of great crisis in that country.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello has said that everybody in this House wants to see black marketing suppressed. Certainly, the speeches made by members of the House in the past have given that impression. Most of those speeches were, however, directed towards demanding of the Government that effective action should be taken to that end. The Government, in order to take effective action, thinks it requires another instrument. Deputies, however, are now opposing the giving of that instrument to the Government. What was the burden of the complaints made by Deputies here in the past? First of all, that only a fraction of the number of cases of offences which are committed appear before the courts at all, and that when they do come before the courts the penalties imposed are, in a great many cases, inadequate to the offence. That has been the burden of Deputies' complaints, and they have voiced them as a criticism of the Government.
Comment on this
Do Deputies appreciate what the problem of dealing with black marketing is, or do they not?
Comment on this
The Deputy's interruption is completely irrelevant. I am sure there is no Deputy in this House who will deny that, in the past, there have been many allegations made in the House that the Government was ineffective in the action it had taken against black marketing and that, in the cases where persons were brought to trial, the punishments imposed by district justices were inadequate. Is not that correct?
Comment on this
Is that denied—that the complaint was made here time and time again that the penalties imposed by district justices were inadequate?
Comment on this
And other Deputies made the same complaint. This device of minimum penalties is not new to the law. It has been adopted in other cases where the circumstances were such that the difficulty was in producing evidence that would lead to a conviction. Revenue cases are of that kind. Offences against the revenue, of smuggling goods into the country, the evasion of the payment of tax, are not infrequent, but only in a small number of cases is it possible to get evidence that will stand in a court of law and lead to a conviction. Because that was so, even in normal times, the device of minimum penalties was adopted in order to ensure that persons who took the risk of breaking the law would realise that the penalties that would follow detection were going to be severe. The penalties were designed to deter people from taking those risks, and they may have had that effect. I do not say they necessarily had that effect, but certainly people will be less inclined to take the risk of breaking the law when they know that severe penalties will follow than if they are led to believe by newspaper reports that the penalty will be a light one.
The whole difficulty in regard to enforcing price fixing Orders is of getting cases into court at all. Every Deputy knows that offences against these Orders are committed daily without the facts ever coming to light at all, because the purchaser, as well as the seller, is engaged in a conspiracy of getting around the law. It is not only in the interest of the seller of goods that a price fixing Order should be evaded. It is frequently also in the interest of the buyer of the goods. The buyer of goods may be getting supplies in excess of what he is entitled to. He may be getting an undue proportion of the limited quantities available for the people of his particular district. He is engaged in a conspiracy, with the seller of the goods, to break the law, and each is getting an advantage from their action. In such cases it is almost impossible to secure a conviction: to get evidence which will stand in court or justify the court in imposing a penalty. In the limited number of cases where it becomes known that an offence was committed, the difficulty is to get witnesses to give evidence. Do not Deputies know that? Is it not known to everybody in this House that even where it is well known that a trader is overcharging for tea, flour, or some other commodity, nobody in the district will come forward and give sworn testimony in the court to that fact?
Comment on this
In the great majority of the cases that come to court the only evidence available is that of the officer in the Department of Supplies who detected the offence. That officer went, perhaps, into the trader's shop and succeeded in purchasing 1 lb. of tea at 10/- or 15/-. As a result of that one particular incident, the trader is brought to court. When that case appears before the court, the justice is dealing only with the facts that are sworn to before him, and what is sworn to is that on one occasion, to one person, that trader sold tea at a price in excess of that fixed by Order. But does anybody believe that in 99½ per cent. of these cases that have appeared before the courts the only offence committed by that trader was that for which he was convicted? Of course not.
Comment on this
Was not the inspector breaking the law when he asked for tea that he was not entitled to get?
Comment on this
He was not. The Deputy is raising a most irrelevant and ridiculous point. I am referring to an authorised officer of the Department of Supplies whose duty it is to detect offences of that kind. When he brings his case before the court the trader is convicted of that one offence, but everybody in the parish knows that the trader was only caught on one occasion but had, no doubt, been breaking the law on a number of occasions. It may be that in an isolated case there was only one offence, but, in the great majority of cases, everybody knows that the traders who are caught were not merely the unlucky ones, but had been continuously breaking the law before they were actually convicted of one offence.
It is for that reason that you require minimum penalties. A justice, dealing with the facts sworn before him, may be disposed to impose only a penalty related to the facts of that one case but our circumstances require that the penalties are such that a trader will understand the big risk he is taking on every occasion that he breaks the law, even when he thinks that he is not going to be detected. Deputies may give lip service to the efforts of the Department to try to suppress black marketing, but if they are in earnest about it they must realise that the penalties imposed by the courts must be a deterrent upon all those people who will never come before the courts but who are equally guilty with those who are detected and charged. Deputy Costello spoke about over-severe penalties bringing the law into disrespect. He has suggested that the penalties that will be imposed under Orders made by the Government providing for minimum penalties will be over-severe. The Deputy is talking something for granted.
Comment on this
I am not. What penalty is over-severe for some of the offences for which people have been convicted?
Comment on this
Any penalty that is a minimum penalty and that is automatically imposed irrespective of the facts of the case is an over-severe penalty.
Comment on this
That is nonsense. The circumstances may be such that the minimum penalty would be unduly lenient in view of the facts of the case.
Comment on this
If a person takes wheat required for human food and feeds it to animals, what penalty is severe enough for that? There were people doing that and at the same time there were queues standing outside bread shops unable to get supplies of bread. While that was happening people were feeding wheat to pigs. The gravity of that offence obviously depends on the circumstances at the time. It was a less grave offence when our bread supplies were reasonably adequate, when we had the prospect of being able to maintain an adequate flow of flour and bread to meet the requirements of the community. It became a much more serious offence during the time in which bread was scarce. It may become, in certain circumstances, a very serious offence indeed. A man may take a sieve in a small mill and pass the product of the mill through it in order to get white flour to sell on the black market. That is a serious offence. But when we find in one case a man who was actually operating what was tantamount to a factory for the manufacture of white flour, with a number of people employed producing white flour from a 100 per cent. product on mass-production methods, white flour which he sold in the black market as having been smuggled over the Border at an exorbitant price, a man who was probably making, judging from the scale of his operations, a profit of £200 or £300 per week, being charged before the district court and fined £3, was that penalty over-Severe? What penalty would be severe enough in these circumstances?
Comment on this
That is Deputy MacEoin's suggestion. We are not suggesting that in this Bill. When we come to deal with these Orders which are designed to secure an equitable distribution of available supplies at a reasonable price, we are up against the immense difficulties of enforcement. I ask the Dáil to try to appreciate that. These difficulties of enforcement are such that, unless we can secure that the penalties imposed by the courts are severe enough to deter people from taking the chance of not being detected in evading the regulations, our efforts to enforce them are certain to be inadequate. I do not know what brings the law into disrespect more than the impression created by newspaper reports that there is not in the minds of the justices a proper appreciation of the gravity of our position in respect of matters of supply or the disproportion of the penalties imposed by one justice and the penalties imposed by another in what appear to be similar circumstances. I have seen cases reported on the same day where, for a precisely similar offence committed apparently, in precisely similar circumstances, one justice imposed a penalty of £10, or £15, or £20 and the other justice imposed a penalty of 1/- or 2/6. Does that help to bring the law into disrespect?
Comment on this
In so far as the newspaper reports revealed the circumstances, they were the same. I am dealing now with the reactions of these newspaper reports on the minds of the public. One advantage of providing for minimum penalties is that disparity between decisions of different justices in similar circumstances is removed and a uniformity is secured in the punishments inflicted for offences of this kind. Many of these Orders made by the Government controlling supplies are of vital importance to the country. It may be that the justices do not appreciate that fact. They may not have the knowledge which will enable them to appreciate fully the gravity of the offence committed by the individual charged before them. That knowledge may be only available to the Minister who made the Order or the members of the Dáil who discussed it here and may not be fully appreciated by the members of the public, much less by the justices of the district court.
It is in such cases that the Government should have power to indicate the importance which they attach to the regulations made and the necessity for securing obedience to these regulations by putting in the Order provision for a minimum penalty. If we are to get respect for these Orders fixing prices, it must become obvious to the public that offences against these Orders are regarded as a serious matter, and that the persons committing these offences will be severely punished. It is only in that way that you can secure that traders and others will avoid the risk of detection. We can no doubt improve our methods of enforcement. We can multiply the number of our inspectors. We can adopt various devices in order to secure that these inspectors will be more effective in detecting offences. But, unless we can get behind all these methods the general idea that these offences are serious ones, that those who commit them are enemies of the people and should be punished as such, that the risk of breaking these regulations is a great one and involves serious consequences for the perpetrators of the offences, then all our efforts to suppress black marketing will be inadequate.
Deputies cannot pretend to be in earnest in their support of the efforts of the Government to suppress black marketing unless they will deal in their criticism of this proposal of the Government with the points I have mentioned, namely, the difficulties of securing convictions in cases of offences against this Order, the knowledge that there are a number of offences that will never appear before the courts, the fact that, even where it is well known to the public that, individuals are breaking the law, those who have that knowledge will not swear to it in court, and the impossibility of preventing people being encouraged into committing breaches of the law themselves by newspaper reports which indicate that those who committed these offences were lightly treated when charged before the court.
The Taoiseach said that if we could ensure that every case of a breach of these regulations was brought to trial, that in every instance in which people overcharged for tea or cigarettes or something else, they appeared eventually before a district justice to answer to that charge, then this need for a minimum penalty, this need for severe penalties, would not exist. If we knew that every offence would be brought before a court, there would be no difficulty in allowing the district justice to assess the offence committed in the individual case and to determine the penalty accordingly.
It is because we know that every case will not come before the court, that only a minority of the cases will come before the court, that the penalties must be such as to ensure that the importance which the Government attach to the offence becomes clearly recognised. It is the very inability of the State to secure a certainty of enforcement that makes this other device necessary. That was so in times of peace in relation to revenue offences and other classes of offences. It is doubly so now in present conditions when these offences are much more numerous and their consequences to the community much more serious.
Comment on this
If the sound and fury we have just listened to means anything in the way of argument, then this whole case has suddenly changed. We are now concerned with the leniency of the district justices. The Minister asks us to see to it that the gentleman who is caught is fined for the 10 or the 12 who commit an offence and who are not caught. That is his case, and he asks whether the penalties are going to be over-severe. Any penalty fixed on that basis is bound to be over-severe. One man will be caught out of 20 offenders and we are going to build up the penalty in such a way that, having convicted the man who is caught, we will penalise him for the 19 who have escaped. Of all the nonsensical arguments that have been used in this House, the limit has been reached to-night. That is the Minister's contention.
He asks us to believe that it is amazingly difficult to get offenders. Will it be more difficult or less difficult to get them if there are minimum penalties? What does the minimum penalty do with the evidence that is procurable in court? Nothing except this, that people might, on the feeling that the district justice might temper justice with mercy, go to court in order to give evidence. I suggest they will be more reluctant to do so when they realise that there is a minimum penalty of £100 to be imposed no matter how technical is the offence. The Minister, in his effort to make a case, succeeded in displaying his own weakness. He will be in a position to salt the single man that he is able to get into court for the 19 or the 20 who have escaped. There is no logic or sanity or justice in that line of argument.
Apparently, the Government are taking as their ideal the Revenue Commissioners and their penalties. We have changed the law again and again, not merely to give the Revenue Commissioners higher penalties, but to make things easier for them. What is the result? Revenue offences were never more numerous, and smuggling was never more rampant. Although the law has been eased year by year in favour of the Revenue Commissioners, we find that the number of people trying to evade the revenue laws are more numerous than ever before. And that is the example that the Minister thought fit to give us.
The Minister was exceptionally vague in his remarks about the man who was running a business and who was engaged in some black marketing in flour. Where was that case heard? Who is the district justice who tried it? I should like to have some information with reference to that case, so that I may track it in the newspapers and learn a little more about it than I could gather from the few phrases the Minister hurled at us. I do not think what the Minister has told us represents the correct picture. The statement he made merely conveyed that a man was proved to be making an income of almost £200 a week and he was fined only £3. I want the name of the person involved in that case, the area in which this particular offence occurred, the time it occurred— some definite statement, so that I can track the case in the newspapers; that is, if it was ever reported. I do not remember any such case and I wonder has that case ever occurred, as the Minister stated it?
It is conveyed to us that purchasers and sellers are in a conspiracy. There are times when the only person who can go into court to give evidence is an officer of the Department. How is that situation going to be eased by the application of minimum penalties? The Minister is critical of the House in its attitude towards the black market. He almost insinuates that Deputies here are not in favour of stopping the activities of the black market. It is suggested that people do not realise as seriously as they should that certain articles are in short supply. Who is to blame for that? I suggest that the Minister is. What has he done to get the people better enlightened as to the shortage of supplies? The fact of the matter is that his Department is a joke in the eyes of the public. It is hardly possible to get any respect for the Department. It is not easy to get credence even for the statements of the Minister.
Deputy Costello asked a cogent question. Has the Minister ever told those appearing in court for him to make, on a particular case, a representation to a district justice of the gravity of dealing with an article in short supply? If he has, will he let us know what the district justice said, how he behaved on such an occasion, and whether his penalty was tempered with too great leniency? It is at such a time that the case should be made and not here, through vague generalities, about people and their attitude to the black market and this man with the £200 a week who was fined only £3.
The Minister must know that by the populace he is regarded as the father and the mother of the black market, the man who was the main cause of it, the man who authorised the system of rationing through retailers, the man who left people in such a way that they could not demand or be entitled to get certain supplies. Once yon create the impression that articles are in short supply and you leave people in trade to parcel out what they have amongst customers, there is a golden opportunity at once for a black market. That has been the Minister's conduct up to recently. Then he went in for rationing by the coupon system, and it is not worth while at this point to speak about the result of that. The Minister is, to a great extent, to blame for two things: firstly, for giving marvellous opportunities for back market rackets and, secondly, for not sufficiently educating the public as to what the dangers were and are. I do not think he has set out on any course in order to educate the public and, if he has, whatever little result his efforts might have got ordinarily have failed, because his Department was derided by the public at the time he set out to educate them.
We have been told now by the Minister that people were feeding wheat to animals at a time when people here were queueing up for bread. The Minister used to say they were not queueing up for bread—it was for hot bread. It is a good argument at this moment to say that a district justice was lenient in the imposition of a penalty with regard to bread when it was in short supply. The Minister now refers to the time when people were queueing up. We remember how vehemently he used to deny that that was the situation so far as this city was concerned.
There are certain points that have to be answered. We want to be told the answer to the question that Deputy Costello put here. What representations have been made in court, and what are the occasions upon which these representations were not treated with the respect that should have been given to them? Will the Taoiseach do this, with the number of cases he has in front of him—will he tell me that the leniency would be a matter that would affect district justices all over the country?
I get back to my original argument with regard to people with trained minds, asked to relate circumstances to an individual case and the pleas made in court. These people all over the country have apparently failed to realise the gravity of the situation, in the phrase of the Minister for Supplies. That being the situation all over the country, would the Taoiseach go one step further and say from the cases that he even has at his disposal or has heard of, what percentage of all the offences that the district justices tried would the lenient cases be, as I certainly think this House ought not to be asked to pass legislation of a minimum penalty type on, say, 2 or 3 per cent. of cases in which even what the Department calls leniency was shown in respect of these cases. In relation to agricultural matters, the Minister was talking about evidence. There were 341 cases here and in all but two cases convictions have been recorded, and one of the two cases in which a conviction has not been recorded is a case which has been adjourned and is still pending. In one case out of 341 there was a dismissal without prejudice. That is the case as far as the Minister is concerned. If the penalties are not sufficient for the Minister, the Minister has power to enter on lands. If the Minister has not exercised that power it is for some reason known to himself which he will probably now tell the House about. If he has not exercised it effectively to make these Orders better observed all over the country, he will tell us why he has not entered a great many more times.
Deputy Costello referred to one other matter that I refer to here in conclusion. He said that it is possible, and we have seen it happen, that some of the cases that have been spoken of have been brought before the Military Tribunal. One of the cases referred to is this case about coupons. These cases have since gone before the Military Tribunal. If the Government want to make a demonstration of what they think as to the gravity of a particular situation in respect of some commodity, it is easy for them to schedule a particular, offence as an offence under the Offences Against the State Act and thereupon there is still somebody to deal with it who is not a member of the Department of Agriculture or the Department of Supplies. There are these people who are attached to the Military Tribunal and they can deal with it. It is possible, it seems to me, a situation might arise which would call for such treatment as that—it is not that I am commending it at the present moment—but the fact that the Government has not sought to treat any shortage of any material in what way indicates that the case made here at the moment is a completely artificial one and no case here can possibly commend itself to this side of the House unless in respect of, say, one or two cases where it is alleged too great leniency was shown, we are told what were the extenuating circumstances expressed to the district justice and how he responded to those.
Comment on this
I think anybody listening to this debate would, perhaps, form the impression that there were no such things as minimum fines already in existence. I happen to have had to deal with offences where minimum fines are inflicted. These were fishery offences. I take it that the reason these minimum fines were brought in in the beginning, for poaching and so on, was that, as the Minister for Supplies pointed out, it is so hard to detect these particular crimes and so hard to get evidence that they are not caught very often, but when they are caught the penalty has to be severe. I think, although Deputy McGilligan appeared to think that it was a ridiculous argument, that the legislators who drew up that legislation very many years ago, which has stood the test ever since, must have had that fact in mind: you do not catch them very often, but when you do catch them they must suffer the penalty.
Deputies talked here of the undesirability of having a Minister responsible for leniency rather than a district justice or judge. In that particular case, the district justice very often inflicts the minimum penalty and at the same time makes a recommendation for mercy. That recommendation comes to the Minister for Justice and the Minister for Justice, in practice, asks for the observations of the Gárdaí in the district and of the Board of Conservators, and if he finds that there is a volume of opinion in favour of leniency he, after consulting me, the Minister concerned, is always inclined to be lenient in these particular cases.
Deputy McGilligan talked of the number of tillage cases brought and the number of convictions. That has nothing to do with the minimum fines, for or against. The fact that of the 341 cases already heard under last year's Order, the Department got convictions in 339 cases I think only proves that they had very good evidence that the offence was committed. If they had brought cases where there was doubt we must presume that some at least would have been, thrown out but, evidently, there was no doubt in these cases.
Comment on this
The fine was not sufficient. There is not very much use in bringing a man before the court for say, having a number of acres untilled under the Order when he is fined 1/-. We feel it would be better if we had not brought him to court at all because we feel that, naturally, the farmers all around, if they are opposed to tillage and if they believe that from their own economic point of view it would be better if they did not till, will say: "We can easily take the risk of not tilling if the fine is going to be 1/-." As I said, it would be better not to bring the case at all.
Comment on this
Could the Minister tell us about any facts in relation to any case in which a shilling fine was imposed?
Comment on this
I can tell the Deputy that in all these cases that were brought there was no question of mitigation in one case very much more than another. One man would make the plea that he found it hard to get the tractor, the tractor did not come in time although he had agreed with the person who owned the tractor.
Comment on this
Yes, it might, but very often it is not. Another man will make the case that he tried to hire a man but could not get the man. Another man will make the case that he tried to buy seed and could not get it. Every person brought before the court —I think the Deputies who practise in court must have this experience—will have some mitigating circumstances to put up in his own defence but which often are not true.
Comment on this
And it would not help me or the Deputy in any way to know what the person said in court in his own defence.
Comment on this
It would help if the Minister would tell us the case that was made and how the justice treated it.
Comment on this
But the Deputy asked for one thing—he said he would like to know, for instance, with regard to the percentage of cases in which there was leniency. I could give some idea with regard to the percentage of cases where I believe the penalty was in no way adequate. I will take this point first: the Deputy also asked whether these inadequate penalties, in our opinion, were general all over the country or only in particular districts. They were, to some extent, general all over the country but, on the other hand—there is no doubt about this— some district justices were invariably very much more severe than others. I remember reading in the paper that one particular district justice said that in every tillage case that came before him he would fine £5 per acre and, as far as I could follow that district justice afterwards, he carried that out.
Comment on this
We will look into that point, too. I am taking a note of that. He is a district justice who evidently looked on the offence as being fairly serious. I do not think he was severe enough but he did look on it as fairly serious when he proposed to inflict a fine of £5 per acre on everybody who came before him. There is another district justice, and if all the cases that came before him were taken, his average fins was about half-a-crown an acre. His maximum fine did not exceed £1 an acre. Several cases came before each of these two district justices. It is not possible, surely, that there were mitigating circumstances always in the case of Justice B. and never mitigating, circumstances in the case of Justice A. So, when Deputies argue here that the district justice is there to look into mitigating circumstances, it does not hold in all cases, at least, and if this minimum penalty were inflicted, on the whole, I am quite sure you would have very much better justice than you have under the present system.
Deputy McGilligan wanted to get some idea of the percentage of inadequate fines. I do not know what Deputies would agree is inadequate in these tillage cases. I think anything under £1 per acre is inadequate but I will go very much lower. Take, for instance, under £1 an acre. Last year, out of 134 cases, there were 65 cases under £1, that is, almost half the number of cases.
I think that everybody will agree that if we are to try to have compulsory tillage at all, there is no use in a fine of anything under £1 because, if a farmer is opposed to tillage, and if he has to be forced to do it, he will certainly believe that it would pay him better to pay £1 per acre and not till at all. It is quite obvious, therefore, that a fine of under £1 an acre is inadequate in these tillage cases. The returns show that the number of cases in which fines of between £1 and £2 were inflicted was 23. Adding 65 and 23 together, we find that in a very high percentage of the total the fines imposed were under £2. That gives some indication of the answer to the question put by Deputy McGilligan as to the percentage of cases in which the fines would be regarded as inadequate.
I mentioned already that there were two district justices, one of whom made it a practice to fine £5 per acre and the other of whom made it a practice to fine in or about half-a-crown per acre. I have here a sheet of fines running from 1/- in one case—and that was not per acre—up to £100 in another case. Strange to say, I find that the very lowest fine of 1/- is for a default of 6¼ acres and the very highest fine of £100 is also for a default of 6¼ acres. Deputy McGilligan may say that perhaps there were mitigating circumstances.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy seriously contend, if he is taking the matter seriously, that there could possibly be mitigating circumstances which would warrant a fine of only 1/- in one case while there was a fine of £100 in another case?
Comment on this
I am assuming now that Deputies are taking the matter seriously. It is all right if you merely want to score debating points. I know that if Deputy Costello, Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Dillon wish to deal with the matter in that way, we could debate these points for hours and never finish on them, but if we are going to deal with the situation in a serious way, does anybody suggest that a district justice who fined one man 1/- for a default of 6¼ acres and another man £100 for a similar default was doing justice as between the two men?
Comment on this
The facts were that both persons put up the case that they could not get the work done.
Comment on this
It appeared from the decision of the district justice that the tillage did not matter in one case and in the other case it was believed that it was a very serious matter. If the Deputy will look at it and try to study the performance of the district justice in each case, he will see that mitigating circumstances did not affect the decision. We have some district justices who take these cases very seriously, and we have other district justices who seem to think that the Order should never have been made.
Comment on this
In the case of the man who was fined 1/- he should have tilled 6¼ acres and he did not till 6¼ acres. In the case of the man who was fined £100 he should have tilled 6½ acres but he tilled only a quarter acre.
Comment on this
The facts are as I told the Deputy, that in each case they said they could not get the work done.
Comment on this
The facts, as believed by my inspector, were that they could have got the work done; otherwise he would not have brought the cases. If we are going to treat this as a matter of levity we can enter into a debate and have a bit of fun over it if you like, but if we are going to take the matter seriously, let us be told how we are going to deal with these cases. I have heard farmers, and I am sure other Deputies have heard them too, say that they would prefer to pay a penalty of £3, £4 or £5 per acre rather than break up their land.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy did not, but there are, other Deputies who heard it. I have heard farmers say that, but, nevertheless, they tilled because they thought it a national duty.
Comment on this
Oh, no. I am only talking of 341 farmers out of a total of 250,000. I am not slandering the farmers generally by referring to the 341 defaulters. It is possible, Deputy McGilligan says, to bring all the cases before one district justice. I believe it is under the Act. Again I say to Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Costello and other Deputies if they want to make nice debating points, they can argue in that way. It is a nice point to make, but do those Deputies who argue with such vehemence that we are going to bring the law into contempt by this provision think that in these cases of compulsory tillage, if I direct every case to be brought to one particular place and tried by one particular justice, that that will not create any contempt for the law?
Comment on this
And the particular district justice might not be so pleased if such action were taken and he might not perhaps deal with the cases as severely as I would like.
Comment on this
The Deputy means to avoid certain justices? That might be done I suppose, but still I think the proposal put up here is better on the whole. If I bring a particular case here and I tell all the circumstances, I am quite sure that Deputy McGilligan or Deputy Dillon would get up and say that there might be mitigating circumstances under some heads. No one could argue on these lines. It is not going to help us to solve the problem we are up against in dealing with these offences, whether black market or tillage offences. I have the right of entry, it is true, and I have a very large number of inspectors. Probably Deputies will say that there are too many inspectors but, even with all the inspectors I have, they could not possibly deal with more than 1 per cent.—in fact, they could not deal with 1 per cent.—by way of entry because they must inspect those farms at a particular time in order to enter. They must go back later and deal with each case and see that the whole thing is done in a proper legal fashion. A great number of cases will only be detected after the sowing season is over. If by any chance we fail to enter on a farm and if later on we find on inspection when the sowing season is over that the particular farmer has defaulted in his tillage, then we should have some way of inflicting a penalty. The only penalty we have, or that I can even think of, is a monetary penalty. Again, the monetary penalty must be substantial; it must be adequate.
Comment on this
But why must it be a minimum? Even if it be substantial and adequate, why must it be a minimum? That is the point.
Comment on this
It must be substantial and adequate. I have already said that certain district justices did not make them substantial or adequate, and, therefore, there must be a minimum. The Taoisoach said here already that the Government reluctantly came to bring in this measure. I was certainly one of those who were reluctant to bring it in, and if Deputy Costello or Deputy McGilligan can suggest to me a way of dealing with those particular cases in which I am interested, I will not mind adopting the suggestion. Even though it comes from a member of the Opposition, I should be very glad to adopt it if I could avoid this particular way of doing it. But the Deputies have made no suggestions.
Comment on this
Here are the suggestions that were offered: make representations in court through your counsel; re-enter the lands; schedule the offence under the Offences Against the State Act; take them before the Military Tribunal. There are four suggestions.
Comment on this
No; the number of cases in which you are complaining of leniency is not more than 100.
Comment on this
The Deputy is making a very valiant effort to make me contradict myself in some way, but I cannot contradict myself because I have only spoken of what the case really is. We dealt with 341 cases before the courts, and there may be others that must come before the courts yet. I say that we cannot inspect all the cases, and we certainly could not inspect them at the particular time when you could enter. We may inspect cases when the time for entry is over. How are we going to deal with them then without an adequate penalty?
Comment on this
It is the only way, I suggest, to make the penalty adequate. The Opposition have not suggested anything else. They suggested to-day that there is nothing very serious about those things; that there might be mitigating circumstances; that a man might charge 8/- a pound for tea and might be justified in doing it; and, therefore, that there should be no minimum penalty imposed. Deputies asked whether we had tried to get the State solicitors to urge that those cases were serious. We did; through the proper quarters—Deputy Costello knows what those are—I had the State solicitor in each county instructed to go to the district justice and impress on him the gravity of the situation with regard to those tillage cases.
Comment on this
Of course; in court. Where else? It was done in every case. Those State solicitors went before the district justices and pointed out that the position was very serious as far as food supplies were concerned, and that those who were defaulters under the tillage regulations should be severely dealt with. As I have said already, some district justices were impressed by that—not to the extent that I should like to see then impressed— but some of them were impressed; others refused to be impressed, and went on with the very inadequate fines of 1/- or 2/6 per acre.
I will conclude by stating again that, if some alternative can be suggested which will give us what we want in this case, that is, that certain district justices will not continue to inflict those very inadequate fines. I certainly will be prepared to consider it.
Comment on this
Listening to this discussion, it appeared to me that each speaker was looking at a different phase of the problem. Under those conditions, it is not surprising that we have not had any sort of agreement. The Minister for Agriculture has been complaining about the inadequate penalties in cases where the tillage Order has been evaded, and in fact he has mentioned that there are certain farmers who would pay a fine of so many pounds an acre rather than till those acres. I do not know whether that is true or not, but it seems to me that, even if there are such farmers, what the country wants is the food produced from those acres and not the imposition of fines. The Minister has complained that no alternative suggestions have been made. I should like to suggest one alternative, and that is that defaulters be required to till double the number of acres in respect of which they were in default.
Comment on this
You could impose a very large suspensory fine, which would be done away with if they came forward the next year having tilled the required amount. I merely want to put that suggestion forward.
There was also another case in which I was rather interested, and that was the case mentioned by the Minister for Supplies, where a black-market mill was milling white flour, and the owner was supposed to be making a profit of a few hundred pounds per week. It was complained that in that case the district justice had merely imposed a fine of £3. I should like to ask whether there is not one trifling circumstance which the Minister has left out of account in that case, and perhaps the district justice took it into consideration as a mitigating circumstance. I take it that the mill owner had his mill taken from him as a result of being caught milling white flour? I take it that the mill was closed down, thus depriving him of his livelihood? If that was not done, there is certainly power to do it.
I think that the Government do not need dungeons if they can prevent offenders from earning their livelihood. In this case, I am assuming that the mill was closed down. Surely, it was represented to the district justice that this man had had his livelihood taken from him? I do not know how far that would have entered into the calculations, but certainly it shows that in some of those instances which have been brought before us it would have been better if we could have gone to the end of the road and seen whether there were any mitigating circumstances which might have been taken into account. I take it that, in this particular case, a very different story would have been presented on both sides. On the one side we have a miller who was making £300 a week in the black market, and who was fined £3, while on the other side it might be put forward that here was a man who had had his livelihood taken from him. Surely, that would be an adequate penalty. We have here to consider how far we ought to make the punishment fit the crime. In the old days, people were transported to the colonies for stealing a head of cabbage. That did not stop, the stealing of cabbages. It is not stopped even at the present time. But nobody would now suggest that people should be transported, even if we could transport them, for stealing cabbages.
Comment on this
They might transport themselves if they got warning that somebody in another country was looking for cabbages. Speaking as an ordinary individual, if one had to give evidence in a black-market case a certain effect would be produced if one felt that a savage penalty would be imposed. I take it that what the Taoiseach really wants is to educate the country into appreciating the gravity of the situation and realising that the punishment should fit the crime.
Comment on this
I listened with great interest to the arguments for and against this proposal. On the Second Reading of the Bill, I spoke against the proposal. I am still convinced that it is very objectionable from the point of view of every section of the community and, particularly, from the point of view of the agricultural community, I cannot see how it can be operated with equity and justice. The Taoiseach warned the House of the gravity and seriousness of the whole situation. Deputies appreciate the seriousness of the situation and are anxious to help in every possible way but, as pointed out by Deputies on this side, there is a responsibility on the House to secure that any enactment passed will ensure justice and equity to the individual. We feel that we cannot ensure that in the proposals now before us.
It appears to me that the measure is unduly interfering with the discretion of justices. If an individual is appointed to a judicial position, it must be presumed that he is fully qualified for that position and that he is fully trained as regards the imposition of penalties that will meet the gravity of offences charged before him. We cannot stand over the argument that there must be minimum penalties and that extenuating circumstances cannot be considered. I am particularly concerned with offences under the tillage Order. I fully appreciate that there must be a wide variation in the seriousness of offences. I have no sympathy with a man who deliberately refuses to comply with the Compulsory Tillage Order and who makes no effort whatever to do his quota of tillage. But a man who all but complies with the Order—say, a man who has to do 25 acres of tillage and who does 22 or 23 acres—may find this minimum penalty operated against him. It is quite on the cards that the man who deliberately refused to comply with the Order might be fined merely the same amount as the man who had gone very close to full compliance with the Order. From that point of view, the Bill is very objectionable. You are taking from the justice his right to exercise discretion and to exercise his legal training so as to fit the penalty to the offence. The case made by Deputy Costello should have impressed any Deputy. Where the minimum penalty is operated harshly, you will have the sympathy of the public, in general, with the individual who has been harshly treated. That is the danger I see. It is unjust and unfair that we should pass any such provision.
The Minister for Agriculture referred to the number of excuses put forward by farmers for non-compliance with the tillage Order—that they could not get tractors and that tractor owners promised to send them tractors to do the cultivation and failed to send them. I know a number of cases where that did occur. It occurred mainly in non-tillage districts, where equipment was scarce and difficult to procure. On several occasions here, I told the Minister for Agriculture that it was his responsibility to organise equipment in districts where equipment was difficult to procure. He has ignored that situation and it is now proposed in this Bill that he is to be the sole judge and arbiter of any mitigating circumstances. The mitigating circumstance may be that he himself has failed to make provision for equipment where provision ought to have been made by organised methods. Surely, the Taoiseach appreciates that there are many districts where little or no tillage was carried on in the past and where the amount of equipment available was not sufficient to carry out the tillage required by the Order. A number of men were harshly treated as a result of their failure to comply with the Order—men who found it impossible to obtain the necessary equipment and who received no assistance from the Department of Agriculture. I have said to the Minister for Agriculture that his inspectors should be in a position, where the farmer makes the excuse that he is unable to hire the necessary equipment to say that they will send equipment on the following Monday morning. The Minister's inspectors should be in that position. The Minister has never attempted to organise equipment behind them, so as to ensure that wherever equipment is lacking it will be sent there by the Department. The extraordinary paradox about the whole proposal is that the Minister has failed in that respect and now we are asked to make him the sole court of appeal, where an individual feels that there are mitigating circumstances which ought to be considered. He, and he alone, who has contributed to the failure, is to be the judge in such matters. That is altogether wrong and unfair; there would be no justice or equity in such a proposal.
Comment on this
I regret that Deputy Alfred Byrne is not here to-night, and also Deputy Dillon and Deputy Mulcahy, and a few others who were making all the noise here about the bread queues recently.
Comment on this
There was talk about people in Dublin starving and deprived of food. The acting and levity of some people will not improve the situation, or get us out of our difficulties. Deputies have the first responsibility to see that there is sufficient food in the country for our people. There should be no tillage offences—there should be no occasion for them. Deputy Hughes tells us about the poor fellow who could not do his tillage in time. The inspector entered on those lands in March or April and the man had until September to plough them, if he wished to do so. He was not inclined to do it; he did not want to do it.
Speaking for a county where not 25 per cent. but at least 40 per cent. of the land is under tillage to-day, providing food for the people, I would like to protest here against the manner in which the tillage Order has been treated all over the country, and the manner in which individuals and areas have evaded it. Anyone travelling up here every week, by road or rail, as do Deputies from Cork, can see the way in which the tillage Order has been treated in certain counties—it is being ignored completely in some areas. The very Deputies who were shouting about the poor having no bread are the individuals who object now to a minimum fine being put on people who will not produce that food. I speak as a farmer and as much a representative of farmers as any other Deputy. Coming from a county where the farmers really do their duty, I have no sympathy whatever with the farmers who are not prepared to till their land.
I made a suggestion to the Minister some time ago—that there should be compulsory notification by the owners of land, on or before the 1st November each year, of their inability to carry out tillage operations. If, for any reason, a farmer thinks he will be unable to till his quota, he should be compelled to go to the local Gárda barracks and notify them, say in October of each year, that he cannot carry out his obligations. If there are such areas, as suggested by Deputy Hughes, the Minister would then be able to send down tillage equipment to those areas and have the land tilled. In the case of 6,000 acres, where last year 3,000 were tilled and the crop brought in was not 25 per cent. of a normal crop, the land was not entered on until April and May when grain crops could not be grown.
Apparently, there is any amount of supporters of the black market now on the opposite benches—even Deputy Dockrell. I have no doubt it is a good investment. We had Deputy O'Donovan and Deputy Tadhg Murphy here the other day, and other Deputies from West Cork, complaining about the scarcity of flour in West Cork and the difficulties in regard to sugar and tea there. Yet we see a case where 40 tons of sugar were taken out of West Cork Creamery and sent up to Sligo to go over the Border. That was 40 tons of sugar from the poor of West Cork, to go over the Border in exchange for luxury white flour and tea for the aristocracy. They say that poor fellow should not be fined, as his business is gone from him. No doubt it was a lucrative business: I suppose it would pay 100 per cent. on capital invested— far better than any National Loan. Those who invest in a risky business like that must be prepared to pay the piper.
I agree with some Deputies over there who stated that the ordinary court is not the place for those gentlemen. Those who take 40 tons of sugar from the poor in West Cork and send it up for the Orangemen, who can afford to pay £100 a ton for it, should be tried before a military court and the penalty, as Deputy MacEoin said a few moments ago, should be the bullet. That is the only way to end that kind of game. The situation is too serious to have lawyers quibbling over the penalties to be imposed, and objecting to a minimum penalty.
The farmers are prepared to do their duty, and the majority of them are doing it. If there are farmers who think they have the legal fraternity of this House behind them in evading that duty, and that they can get cheap law and cheap defences if they go to the court, I would not blame them at all for trying to evade the Order. I do not think a fine is sufficient in a black-market case. There is only one way of stopping black-market operations and that is the imposition of a jail sentence. I would impose a jail sentence without the option of a fine, or together with a fine, in every black-market case. It is the only way to stop it. The profit which the gentleman who bought that sugar at the controlled price and was selling it over the Border at £140 a ton—that was the statement made in court—was making was such that he was not going to be stopped by a £5 or £10 fine. The position at present is that a poor workman who wants to cycle to his work and has no tyre for his bicycle has to pay 30/- or 35/- for a 4/6 tyre, in order that the capitalists of this country might have a safe home investment for their capital.
Comment on this
That is what is wrong with Deputies and evidently what has influenced the Front Bench opposite in making such an anxious defence of the black marketeer, of those who refused to produce bread for our people and to produce oatmeal for our people. Deputies are afraid they will lose their job of demanding from the Minister for Supplies the reasons for the long queue in such a street last month, of people waiting for bread which they could not get. What can be the defence of a farmer for not putting at least the minimum acreage under tillage this year? He has a choice of grain. If his land is unable to grow wheat, he can grow barley or oats and I can see no defence for him—and I speak here as a farmer—and I am not prepared to allow him any defence, either. We had Deputies shouting a month ago about bread queues in the streets of Dublin, and now coming in here to defend those who caused these bread queues in the first instance— the people who were not prepared to till their quota of land to provide food for the people. There is only one cure for it, that is, to insist that in all cases not alone will a minimum fine be imposed but a jail penalty as well.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry says he speaks as a farmer, but he is a privileged farmer. He is in such a position that he was able to boast of having so much artificial manure last year, and that he got the contract for sowing beet seed last year.
Comment on this
He might not shout about the farmers of Cork doing their bit. What can the majority of them do with their land but till it? It is fit for nothing else. He speaks about bread queues, but were it not for the British Government we would not have bread to-day. It was not the farmers of Cork who provided it; it was the British Government. There is no secret or hiding of that. The farmers of Cork would not have given it to the people. Deputy Corry knows nothing about the farmers of the midlands, who are in a different position.
Comment on this
Only for the graziers we would have very little bread to-day. You people have your land wheat-sick and unable to grow anything at present. It grows nothing but pressach and charlock, but we in the midlands are the people who will stand by you because our land is not wheat-sick, and the farmers there should not be treated as they are being treated by this proposal of a minimum fine. These people stood by the Government when they asked them and speeches like that of Deputy Corry are a shame and a disgrace to the Party to which he belongs.
Comment on this
Arising out of the observations of the Minister for Supplies and the Minister for Agriculture, it appears to me that both these Ministers have confused in their statements the difficulty of detecting black marketeers and the necessity for getting adequate fines. There is no relation whatever between the complaint made by the Government that district justices are not imposing fines adequate to meet the gravity of the situation and the difficulty of securing evidence against people who are engaged in black marketing. The Minister for Agriculture contrasted the actions of two district justices, one of whom imposes a fine of 2/6 an acre and the other of whom has announced in advance that in every case, no matter what the facts are, he will impose a fine of £5 an acre. I give my compliments to the half-crown district justice, and I say that the other district justice who has announced in advance what he is going to do, irrespective of the facts or merits of the case, is not dealing out justice.
I have ascertained who the justice is to whom the Minister referred and, when the facts are known, the compliments which I hand out to the half-crown district justice will be found to be well justified. What has happened here is that the Government have taken a list and have seen on it fines ranging from £100 to 1/- and, without knowing what the facts are, they have drawn deductions from them. If the Taoiseach and members of his Government got a list of the convictions and sentences from Green Street, they would find sentences ranging from 15 years' imprisonment to the application of the Probation of Offenders Act, and, if they draw conclusions from that, they will draw the same conclusion, that is, that the Circuit and High Court judges are not doing their duty either. The same conclusion is drawn from the same premises. With reference to the so-called half-crown district justice, he is a justice who has caused the Acts and Orders properly to be administered in his county, and the results of his operations have been that not merely has there been no necessity to impose fines, but in every respect the Orders have been carried out and more tillage has been secured as a result of his method of dealing with prosecutions than any minimum or maximum penalty the Government can devise would secure.
Comment on this
There is only half a minute left. Would the Taoiseach before to-morrow investigate whether what Deputy Costello has said is a fact, that the district justice in respect of whom allegations were made to-night has in fact secured better compliance with the tillage Order than any other justice?
Comment on this
That may be, but it would not help us very much. I was quite frank with the House when I said that it was on general evidence that I had to act.
Comment on this
Use the phrase: "prima facie case”. The Taoiseach just baulked at using the phrase for the third time.
Comment on this
I will make the Deputy a present of it. "On the surface" is what I take a prima facie case to be. I cannot investigate each one of these cases and I have not said I could. I have a list before me. It is an extensive list, and, on looking at it, I am satisfied that, in general terms, the position is as I have stated. There may be exceptional cases and mitigating circumstances, and I can see only one way to meet them if this Bill is to pass, that is, an appeal to the Minister for Justice and an examination of whether there is sufficient mitigation to warrant a reduction. Taking cases from this list at random, I find, for instance, that where a person's quota was 45 acres, 16 acres were tilled, there being default in respect of 29 acres and the fine imposed is £5. I do not think that a fine of £5 on a person who has failed to till 29 acres, when he was able to till 16 acres, will act as a deterrent.
Comment on this
I will admit all these things which can be imagined, but we have to try to deter people from breaking the law and to ensure compliance. That is the whole purpose of it. I find further on this list that, where 8 acres were to be tilled, a quarter acre was tilled, leaving 7¾ acres untilled, and the Probation of Offenders Act was applied. Other cases are: 6½ acres to be tilled: 1¼ acres tilled—5¼ acres untilled and the Probation of Offenders Act applied; 9 acres to be tilled: 5 acres tilled—4 acres untilled and a fine of 10/- with 14/- costs; 3 acres to be tilled: nil tilled—3 acres untilled and a fine of 10/-; 15 acres to be tilled: 7 acres tilled—8 acres untilled and a fine of 10/-, with 2/- costs; and so on.
I move to report progress.