Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1942—Recommittal.
Contributions 1–182 of 363. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 17 of 1942 ›
The Minister might indicate what course he proposes to take with regard to the amendments?
Comment on this
As the Bill is being recommitted in respect of all the amendments, I am prepared to allow to be moved some eight amendments that would otherwise be ruled out. Amendment No. 41 is of such a sweeping character that the Chair could not admit it at this stage or, for that matter, at any stage of the Bill. It is the only amendment that may not be moved.
Comment on this
Will it be possible to have another Report Stage? There are some amendments here that will require re-drafting.
Comment on this
It would be possible again to report the Bill with amendments and have a formal Report Stage of short duration later. The Minister might now move amendment No. 1. Possibly the Deputies over whose names amendments Nos. 2 and 3 appear will be in attendance before the discussion on amendment No. 1 has concluded. Amendments Nos. 2 and 3 must be disposed of before a decision is taken on No. 1.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:—
In page 2, line 29, Section 4, to delete all words from the word "by" to the end of the section, line 35, and substitute the following:—
(A) by the deletion of paragraphs (a), (b), and (c) of sub-section (1) and the substitution in lieu thereof of the following paragraphs, that is to say:—
(a) on any weekday, before the hour of half-past ten o'clock in the morning, or after the hour of half-past ten o'clock in the evening, or (subject to the exceptions hereinafter mentioned) between the hours of half-past two o'clock and half-past three o'clock in the afternoon, or
(b) on any Sunday—
(i) in the case of the County Borough of Dublin or the Dublin Metropolitan area, before the hour of two o'clock in the afternoon, or between the hours of three o'clock and half-past four o'clock in the afternoon, or after the hour of seven o'clock in the evening, and
(ii) in the case of any other county borough, before the hour of one o'clock in the afternoon or between the hours of three o'clock and five o'clock in the afternoon, or after the hour of seven o'clock in the evening, or,
(B) by the deletion of sub-sections (2) and (3) and the substitution in lieu thereof of the following sub-section, that is to say:—
(2) Save as is otherwise provided by this Act, it shall not be lawful for any person in any place not being a county borough to sell or expose for sale or to open or keep open any premises for the sale of intoxicating liquor or to permit any intoxicating liquor to be consumed on licensed premises—
(a) on any weekday, before the hour of half-past ten o'clock in the morning or after the hour of half-past ten o'clock in the evening, or
(b) at any time on any Sunday or on Christmas Day, Good Friday, or Saint Patrick's Day.
As the House is aware, we came to a compromise with regard to weekdays. I was anxious to leave things as they were, but, in view of the pressure from all sides of the House, I agreed to compromise. I thought that that was accepted, but I find that there is an amendment down to have a 10 o'clock closing hour in the county boroughs. According to the agreement, I put down 10.30 o'clock. I understood that there was no objection to 10.30 in the morning. I thought that was agreed to, but apparently it is not. As regards Sunday, I have arranged in the case of the county boroughs other than Dublin for an opening from 1 o'clock to 3 o'clock and 5 o'clock to 7 o'clock. I made the inquiries that I said I would make about the opening hours on Sunday in Dublin. So far as I could gather, anything earlier than 2 o'clock would not meet the objections raised. A one-hour break on Sunday was scarcely sufficient. It is suitable, I understand, on weekdays, because there is not very much business done up to the closing time on those days, but it is anticipated that for the hour on Sunday there would be rather a rush, and it would probably be a quarter of an hour after the closing hour before assistants could get out and the proprietor have the place ready to start again.
I am satisfied that one and a half hours are necessary, and that means knocking off half an hour from the time originally proposed, giving a three and a half hours' opening instead of four hours. The times now suggested are from 2 to 3, and from 4.30 to 7 o'clock. I, personally, would have preferred to have the time uniform in all the county boroughs, but as there was a special problem to be dealt with in Dublin, I have made a distinction in the case of Dublin.
Comment on this
There will be general acceptance of the Minister's amendment, and so far as I am personally concerned I do not see the slightest objection to letting the half-hour go in the morning. The Minister says he wants to have a uniform time, and that is quite reasonable. I do not think that in the rural areas, with the provision which exists in respect of exemption orders for fairs and markets, anybody bothers about whether the opening is 10 o'clock or 10.30 in the morning. So far as the county boroughs outside Dublin are concerned, the Minister has accepted the suggestion made on the first Committee Stage and has adopted the hours we suggested in respect of which we intended to put amendments down. There was a misunderstanding on that point, but the Minister has met us very fairly on it.
I want to draw the Minister's attention to one matter in order to show how things may be misinterpreted. When the Minister circulated this amendment, the first thing which struck many Deputies was paragraph (b) which refers to "any time on Sunday, Christmas Day, Good Friday or St. Patrick's Day". There was a wave of indignation through the country for the past few days because people felt that the Minister was closing public houses completely on Sundays. The paragraph gave that impression, and for the last two days most Deputies in the country have been bombarded by people who seemed to think that this amendment meant that there would not be even a bona fide traffic on Sundays. Of course it does not mean that, and I make the point merely to show that Sunday in the country is not affected by the amendment at all, as the Minister may not be aware that that construction was put on his amendment.
On the first Committee Stage, a case apparently was made in regard to a particular situation in Waterford and Limerick in relation to the split hours, and I understand that an amendment dealing with that situation was to be moved. I do not know whether the Minister proposes to do anything about it.
Comment on this
I am not accepting any amendments to do away with the split hours, but I am allowing a continuation of the status quo in which bona fide traffic can be carried on during the hour. The deputation which met me asked me to see that that was done, and I have arranged for it, but I do not propose to agree to abolish the split hours provision because I think it very necessary.
Comment on this
We are perfectly willing to accept the Minister's amendment so far as the position in this city is concerned and I think it meets very fairly all the points we made on the first Committee Stage. I am quite satisfied, even though the Minister felt that he was on a slippery slope, that he has succeeded in making a very forcible approach to what I think is a very much better licensing Bill than the original, for the reason that nothing will ever convince me that more and more restrictions will improve the situation, but when you have a reasonable job done, you can enforce what you have. The Minister, I am sure, will have the support of everybody, now that certain concessions have been granted, in seeing that the licensing laws are carried out.
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister does not propose to interfere with bona fide trade in the country on Sundays under this amendment. Many people in the country were under the impression that the amendment affected that trade. I am sorry, however, that the Minister could not see his way to allow some few hours of opening on Sundays in country districts. It would be much better and the law would be observed more fully if hours of trading on Sundays were granted to the people in the country as well as in the cities.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 1 cannot be decided until two amendments thereto have been disposed of.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:—
In paragraph (A) of amendment No. 1 to delete sub-paragraph (a) and substitute therefor the following:—
(a) in the County Borough of Dublin and in the County Borough of Cork—
(i) on any ordinary week-day, before the hour of ten o'clock in the morning, or after the hour of ten o'clock in the evening, or (subject to the exceptions hereinafter mentioned) between the hours of half-past two o'clock and half-past three o'clock in the afternoon, or
(ii) on any Saturday, before the hour of ten o'clock in the morning, or after the hour of half-past nine o'clock in the evening or (subject to the exceptions hereinafter mentioned) between the hours of half-past two o'clock and half-past three o'clock in the afternoon, or
(b) in the county Borough of Limerick and in the County Borough of Waterford—
(i) on any ordinary week-day, before the hour of ten o'clock in the morning, or after the hour of ten o'clock in the evening, or
(ii) on any Saturday, before the hour of ten o'clock in the morning, or after the hour of half-past nine o'clock in the evening, or,
Comment on this
So far as it affects the County Borough of Cork, I am in complete opposition to anybody who asks the Minister to go backwards. I thought the Minister's forward movement a very good thing and I am very much surprised, in view of the general agreement in the House on the last occasion—and I think the Minister must have been completely surprised— that anybody should now ask the Minister to go back to the position from which he so wisely went away. I have at the back of my mind the idea that the reason behind this amendment has something to do with a situation with which this House should not concern itself at all. So far as I can gather, the reason for the amendment has to do with the question of assistants and licensed traders, and I submit with all respect that if the Ministerial hours will give rise to an awkward situation as between the licensed traders and their assistants, that is a domestic matter for the licensed trade to get over, and not one for this House. So far as I am concerned and, I am sure, so far as the other members of this Party are concerned, we will oppose any attempt to force back the hours which the Minister has given.
Comment on this
The purpose of the amendment, as I have already explained to the Minister, is to exempt the southern cities from this closing hour in the middle of the day. It may serve some useful purpose in the City of Dublin—I am not going to argue whether it does or not—but it is senseless in a place like Limerick. Limerick is really an over-grown provincial town, which is dependent on the hinterland from which the people come with horses and traps to do their marketing. They park their horses and traps in the livery yard behind the public house, and particularly a public house which belongs to a friend or relation, and do their shopping, sending their goods back to the public house. When they come back to the public house, they find a queue of messenger boys waiting for the end of the split-hour period. There is no useful purpose that we can see served by it. It is an unnecessary and vexatious intrusion. I think I mentioned on the last occasion that a particular anomaly arises in this connection and the Minister agreed to look into it. I pointed out that if a man went into the public house during that particular period on a bona fide basis, he could buy drink and nothing else as a bona fide traveller, and that it would be an offence for him to buy a sack of flour or any other goods. I hope the Minister has looked into the point.
Comment on this
I understand that is not so. He could buy anything he wished.
Comment on this
I am glad to know that there would not be a prosecution for buying foodstuffs. I ask the Minister favourably to consider the proposal regarding the hours in places outside Dublin. The 1927 Act was specifically related to Dublin. The present position has created what amounts to a growing nuisance, and I ask the Minister to take advantage of the alteration to bring this Bill more into conformity with common sense, and to make it easier for the Civic Guards to discharge their duties. We do not respect the present position in Limerick. It is not thought to be any breach of the law to disrespect it. No evil is likely to arise from the change, while business will be facilitated. There cannot be any consequences in the way of intemperance.
Comment on this
The reason that members of the licensed trade have looked for a change of hours is that they have to compete with theatre bars and clubs and in that way are at a disadvantage under the present time-table. The Minister would have met the situation much better by making the hours uniform for licensed premises, clubs and theatres.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I should like to know how the Deputy's remarks relate to the amendment now under discussion.
Comment on this
There has been a misunderstanding. I understood Deputy Keyes' point was about Limerick, Waterford, and even Cork. Is the Labour Party serious about it for the County Borough of Cork and the County Borough of Dublin, in going back on the half-hour that the Minister gave? That appears to be the real point. The Minister gave until 10.30 at night, and now do Deputies want to go back to 10 o'clock?
Comment on this
The hours of closing on ordinary week nights are 10 p.m., and on Saturdays, 9.30 p.m. The point I want to make is that the only demand for the later hour, which the Minister has seen fit to incorporate, was made by the licensed trade. That demand is based on the fact that they have to compete with theatres and clubs, which are able to keep open longer, under existing circumstances, than they can, and at the best hours. That change has been made at the expense of the workers in licensed premises. I suggest to the Minister that the proper way to deal with the difficulty is by having uniform hours for clubs, theatres and licensed premises.
Comment on this
I think the last Deputy is misinformed. I have very little interest in this Bill, but I did appeal to the Minister to give a later closing hour in the summer than 10 o'clock. There was agreement that that should apply all round. It was not given because the licensed trade asked for extended hours so that they might compete, but was really a concession to the rural community.
Comment on this
That was my idea. I did not consider the licensed trade or any other interest but acted on what I found to be the general wish. I thought I was agreeing to the general wish expressed in the House.
Comment on this
There was a second reason to link up the closing time with the statutory bona fide time, so that people would not be running from one part of the country to another.
Comment on this
Under the Bill as amended it would extend the closing period to 10.30 p.m., but the Minister is meeting that by a later opening hour in the morning. The assistants have a point of view there which is of some importance. The half hour they work extra at night is not going to be compensated for by giving them half an hour in the morning. From their point of view they would much prefer if the existing opening hour would continue, even though the licensed premises might remain open until 10.30. at night, because the additional half hour they work if aggregated over a week, could be utilised to confer on the assistants a period of relief from duty to compensate them in some measure for the fact that they worked from 10 a.m. to 10.30 p.m. There is no particular advantage in keeping the houses closed until 10.30 in the morning if the assistants have to work until 10.30 at night. They would prefer to be allowed to aggregate the additional half hour over the week, and then be allowed to get some substantial advantage for working the extra half hour than by going on duty half an hour later in the morning. Did the Minister consider that question?
Comment on this
I did. My attitude when I brought in the Bill was rather to have restrictions instead of giving concessions. I was frank about that. The Dáil forced me to extend the hour. I am not going to be forced, if I can help it, by anyone to give extra time for drinking. As far as I can avoid that I will. I cut off half an hour. I know plenty of people, even healthy people, who, if they spend a few hours out at night, do not mind lying on in the morning. I have enough trouble. People come to me—not in this House —about that. I was surprised at one case. Deputy F. Lynch told me of people whose duty it was to look after our souls. Even in the House some opinions have been expressed in that respect. If I can help it I am not going to be responsible for increasing the hours permitted for drinking from 10.30 in the morning to 10.30 at night —12 hours.
Comment on this
Does the Minister realise that he is not increasing the hours but increasing the facilities, by adding a half an hour at night? The half-hour in the morning does not matter.
Comment on this
I understand when people take longer to take a drink it does not do any harm. That is what I was informed by people who take drink.
Comment on this
Deputy Keyes was not in the House when I was dealing with the position in Limerick. I considered the position there, and I am surprised that Deputy Keyes has such a pessimistic view about Limerick. I think Limerick is going to be a very big city in the near future. It may not be a university city but, as far as I can see into the future, Limerick is not going to remain like a large provincial town. At any rate, these were the four county boroughs and the split hour was introduced to do away principally with the long sitter. I am pretty certain there are plenty of them in Limerick, and in Cork too, as well as in Dublin. I did meet the point made by the deputation of traders from Limerick that people from the hinterland who were in the habit of coming in the middle of the day would be placed under a disadvantage by the proposal to close for an hour in the middle of the day. Under my proposal, anybody who comes from districts three miles beyond the city can still be treated as bona fide travellers and they can get goods, and drink if necessary, during that hour. I have met them to that extent and I think that is quite satisfactory.
Comment on this
I accept the Minister's assurance on that point. That apparently is all he is able to do. I am not worried at all about the hours of closing. I agree that the hour of 10.30 would be a desirable step forward, and since the Minister has definitely improved the situation by making the bona fide position clear, I shall not press the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3, which is an amendment to amendment No. 1:—
To delete paragraph (A) (b) (i) and substitute the following:—
(i) In the case of the County Borough of Dublin or in the Dublin Metropolitan area before the hour of two o'clock in the afternoon or after the hour of six o'clock in the evening, and,
This amendment has its roots in the Committee Stage discussion, in the course of which we endeavoured to have the hours on Sundays in the county borough from 2 o'clock until 6 o'clock. The Minister's proposal at that time was that the hours should be 1 to 2 and 4 to 7. I made the case then that there were many objections to opening for one hour during the day on the ground that it was extremely difficult to induce people to leave licensed premises within an hour of the opening of the premises. Many large licensed traders in Dublin have frankly confessed that where a public house opens at 1 o'clock and people come in, say, at 1.10 or 1.15, in groups of four or five, in order to close the premises at 2 o'clock it would be necessary to get these people moving at 1.40. It has been represented to me that it would be a physical impossibility to get such licensed premises cleared at 2 o'clock. I think if the Minister consults any of the large licensed traders in the city he will get confirmation of that view. If the Gárda are to do their duty with the alacrity recommended by Deputy Dillon, I should imagine that it will not be long before a considerable number of licensed traders in the city are before the District Justice explaining why it was not possible for them to close their premises at 2 o'clock. I think many of them would be able to put up the argument that it would be a physical impossibility to open their premises at 1 o'clock and have them cleared again by 2 o'clock. I think the Minister is opening up the possibility that there will be widespread disregard of the licensing laws in the city in this respect.
I suggested on the Committee Stage that it would be much better for the object which the Minister has in view if the hours were made from 2 to 6. That period is not too extensive. It meets the demands of anybody who wants refreshments on Sundays and, at the same time, it would make bearable the conditions of assistants who have arduous hours of work and who are compelled to work when most other folk can enjoy themselves. I thought the Minister would have seen fit to accept these hours, but instead he has put in an amendment which really worsens the position of the assistants. The Minister now proposes that the hours should be 2 to 3 and 4.30 to 7. There would be still, under this proposal, the objectionable split hour from the point of view of the assistants. The proposal still perpetuates the difficulties which, I think, will arise as a result of the short opening period from 2 to 3. It gives a total opening on Sunday of 3½ hours. Again, from the point of view of the assistants it would have been much better if the Minister had a four-hour opening on Sunday.
Comment on this
I think the Minister might have looked at this matter from the point of view of the assistants. If Deputy Cooney wants any information in regard to it, he knows where to go to for that information and he will find that what I say will not be challenged. The position is that the assistant who works four hours on Sunday——
Comment on this
Quite so. My proposal in this amendment is also for an opening of four hours, but I want the hours to be different from those originally proposed by the Minister.
Comment on this
I am not personally concerned if every club in the country is closed down. I am putting this matter from the point of view of the assistants. Frankly, the purpose of my amendment is to get a period of opening which will suit the assistants. I am not concerned with the interests of the traders; I am not putting a tooth in that at all. Deputy Cooney can look after the interests of other people if he likes. I am not concerned with the interests of the licensed trader, but with the interests of the assistants. The Minister's proposal as it stood originally was really better than the amendment he has now put in because if the hours of opening on Sunday were four, the assistant, under the Conditions of Employment Act, would be entitled to compensation if he works for four hours on Sundays. Now by making the period 3½ hours, the assistant will not get the compensatory time he would receive if the licensed premises were open for four hours. Frankly, I would prefer the original proposition in the Bill—2 to 3 and 4 to 7—than 2 to 3 and 4.30 to 7, because the Minister's new proposal reduces the opening period from four hours to 3½ hours. That small reduction of half an hour deprives the assistant of some compensation which he would get.
Comment on this
I gave my reason for bringing in that proposal when the Deputy was not here.
Comment on this
As I understand it, the Minister said that he wanted a longer meal interval for the assistants.
Comment on this
The assistants would much prefer to put up with the inconvenience of an interval of one hour for meals and have a four-hour opening than to get 1½ hours for meals and have only a 3½ hour opening. All they would be doing would be sacrificing half an hour of the meal interval, and the advantages which they would get for a four-hour opening would more than compensate them for the sacrifices they made in that connection. If the Minister's purpose in moving that the second period of opening should commence at 4.30 instead of 4, is to facilitate the assistants, I should be glad if he would look into the matter again and see if it is not possible to accept the hours 2 to 6. At least he should not introduce a 3½-hour opening which is calculated to deny the assistants the bargaining power which they will get if there is a four-hour opening on Sunday. In any case, it seems to me that you have all the disadvantages of the short opening period of one hour, the broken day, and the long spread-over for the assistants. Most reasonable people will agree that a 2-6 opening has many advantages over a 2-3 and 4-7 or a 2-3 and 4.30-7.
I understand that a meeting of the licensed trade in Dublin was held on Sunday last and that, out of approximately 155 people present, 83 voted for the new hours proposed in the Bill and 72 against them. I understand there are approximately 500 licensed traders in Dublin, of whom 300 are members of the Licensed Traders' Association. There is no terrific demand there for these proposed new opening hours. If the Minister consults the trade, on the assistants' side and the employers' side, he will find probably that he is putting into this Bill provisions for which there is no great demand by the citizens, by the assistants or by the employers. I would appeal to him to accept the amendment providing for a 2-6 opening in the City of Dublin. If he cannot accept it, he should not deprive assistants of the bargaining position they would get by a four-hour opening on Sunday instead of a 3½-hour opening.
Comment on this
I deeply deplore the fact that the Minister is interfering with the Sunday hours for the City of Dublin at all. I say that 2-5 was quite sufficient for any man who wanted a drink. Opposed to that, however, there were elements in the city who said that, on the occasion of big Gaelic and Soccer matches, when there was a crowd rushing to the stations, by the time they would leave the football field the licensed houses would be closed. If the Minister would agree with me to leave the hours 2-5 as they are, it would give the workers of the city an opportunity to leave the licensed house at 5 o'clock and go home to celebrate the Sunday cup of tea with the family. That is something we all would like to see. Under the new proposal, while the Minister breaks the hour, to let them go home to lunch—better known as "dinner" amongst people in the city—he is encouraging them to go back and remain out of their homes for the tea hour. I strongly object to that.
The split hour also means an extra cleaning up. People talk about the assistants and say they finish at certain hours, but the cleaning-up process takes at least a quarter of an hour or half an hour each time. If they close at one on a Sunday, it will take a quarter of an hour to clean-up. At least, in the old days, when I was in in the business, that was so, and I do not think there has been any change. I would not take second place to any man in the House regarding my knowledge as to how hard the assistants have to work. The official hours are not the hours he has to work— generally he has to work an hour more. The hours 2-5 are sufficient for the City of Dublin. I appeal to the Minister to accept that. If that effort fails, perhaps he would agree to do the next best thing and make the hours 2-6. That would empty the house at 6 o'clock and let the men go home to tea. The Gaelic and Soccer football crowds would have an hour, from 5-6, to get refreshments before getting their trains home.
I appeal to the Minister to have some regard for the assistants and for the conditions under which they work, and for the licensed traders and their families, too. I have been told by very many licensed traders that they do not want any alteration in the Sunday hours in Dublin. They are glad to have their early evening off, just as much as the assistants. The 7 o'clock hour would spoil the assistant's tea. He may want to go to the pictures or to a concert, or may wish to enjoy the open air. This would spoil his whole evening. Is it proper or right that we should talk always about this giving of extended hours for drinking, for a few who, as the Minister says, go out to the outskirts of the city on buses? We should not be legislating for them at all, but should tell them to act as reasonable citizens, like the other 99 per cent., and stay at home, having had reasonably sufficient. It should not be a holiday at all, to send them out on buses five or ten miles to enjoy the evening according to their lights. It is not enjoyment. In the City of Dublin and in the licensed houses on the outskirts, those people are considered a nuisance by the licensed traders. The man who takes too much is a danger to the trade— both to the trader's profit and his business. We have been talking here a lot about the man who drinks to excess. The traders do not want that type and there should not be further encouragement to him.
I again appeal to the Minister to consider the assistants and to have regard to the fact they are human beings, who, like every other type of worker, want their Sunday evening off. If he cannot see his way to accept my view that the hours 2-5 are long enough, he should consider 2-6, so as to give the assistants an opportunity to bargain for additional time off on another occasion.
Comment on this
The Minister has changed his mind two or three times already in regard to the hours of opening and closing on Sundays. On one occasion, when speaking on the Bill, he clearly indicated that he did not know anything about the trade.
Comment on this
I never said any such thing. There is a great difference between knowing nothing about the trade and not going in front of the bar. I know as much as most people.
Comment on this
In any case, the Minister meant that he does not rightly understand the position, as to what the hours should be.
Comment on this
I would strongly advise the Minister not to be taken away too much by Deputy Cooney's confidence. In the first instance, the Minister's proposal was calculated to meet the objections of some licensed traders in the city who found themselves at a great disadvantage. When the Minister realised the difficulties in that position he changed the hours, or indicated that he was prepared to accept a change in the hours, that would meet the objection of the G.A.A. We now find, in this amendment, a further change which, I think, the Minister was prompted to introduce in order to meet the difficulties of the assistants with regard to the very short interval for luncheon. Deputy Norton has explained that, instead of conferring any benefit on the assistants by the changes the Minister proposes to make now—namely, to reduce the hours from four to three and a half— he is putting them at a disadvantage as, by taking away the half hour, he is also taking a half day a week off them. I am sure that is very far from the Minister's intention.
He would be well advised to drop the idea of splitting the hours on Sundays and revert to the position of granting the hours 2-6, which would meet the views of those in the trade and be best calculated to meet the requirements of the general public. Over and over again it has been emphasised that there is no demand on the part of the general public for a change in hours. The Minister's efforts are calculated to please this person or that person, this body or that body, and he will find himself soon in a very difficult position. To get out of the difficulty, he should adopt the hours 2-6.
Comment on this
I am more than surprised at the attitude of Deputy Alfred Byrne in relation to this Bill. He must be aware of the fact that, for the last 15 years, the licensed trade have made an annual request to the Government in office, asking for legislative proposals dealing with certain matters in relation to the trade.
Comment on this
Deputy Byrne must be aware of that fact. In addition, Deputy Byrne, as we all know, was a potential candidate some years ago for the Presidency of the State.
Comment on this
Admittedly, it does not, but I want to ask Deputy Byrne: Is he in favour of closing down the houses of the licensed traders outside the city? The Minister made one specific statement when he introduced this Bill—his original proposals were revolutionary, the complete abolition of the bona fide traffic, a complete close-down from 10 p.m. Thanks to the good sense of Deputies from all benches, the Minister changed his mind and allowed the bona fide traffic to be maintained up to midnight. That is why we have the proposal to close at 10.30 on week nights, and that is why we have the split-hour proposal in respect of Sundays. That is very fair. I have been in this House for a number of years. I have been here when the Ministry of Justice was occupied by different persons, and no Minister in that Ministry ever faced up to a critical position, such as this Licensing Bill created, more honestly or more courageously than the present Minister did. It is untrue to say that there is no demand for amending legislation in respect of hours. It is in the interest of the community, as a whole, that there should be a one o'clock opening in the capital of this State.
Comment on this
What is the position we are to have now? The other three boroughs are to have precedence over the capital, with 500,000 of a population. The capital is to remain a sleepy valley until 2 o'clock on Sunday. The other three boroughs are to open at 1 o'clock. Although this is the Report Stage of the Bill, I hope that the Minister will again change his attitude and that we shall get a 1 o'clock opening. The Minister has said, time and again, that it is immaterial whether you have three or four hours, provided you establish the principle of split hours. On that he is determined to stand, and on that I am with him 100 per cent. I regret and deplore that the licensed traders and their employees did not come together and formulate proposals to enable the Minister to have this 1 o'clock opening and 7 o'clock closing, the split hours being arranged to suit their mutual interests. It could and should have been done.
It is very interesting to hear Deputy Norton tell us that his sole interest is that of the assistants. I am glad to hear that from Deputy Norton, particularly in view of the fact that it is only a few months since a very intimate colleague of his took advantage of an occasion in Bundoran to slander and ridicule the assistants' organisation. I have not heard that any member of Deputy Norton's Party stood up at that Trades Congress to repudiate the abusive methods used by that gentleman in respect of that particular organisation. Adversity makes strange bed-fellows.
Comment on this
Now, we have Deputy Norton oozing sympathy for the assistants and their organisation. The reasons are quite obvious——
Comment on this
I know not what the reasons may be, but, obviously, the same reasons inspire both Deputies in exchanges which have nothing to do with this amendment.
Comment on this
I am merely replying to remarks made by Deputy Norton when he said that his sole concern was with the assistants. I have sufficient confidence in the intelligence of the rank and file of the assistants to know that they will realise that the attitude I have taken on this Bill is in their interest and that it will lead to increased employment and increased wages. Did the Labour Party take up an attitude in opposition to that on Committee Stage? Not at all. I asked Deputy Norton or any member of his Party to say if it was contrary to trade union principles to advocate extension of hours in any trade or industry where the workers had a guaranteed working week. The workers in this trade have a guaranteed week. It is guaranteed by law—I emphasise that—and that is due to this Government. They have a 48-hour working week and, if the original proposals of the Minister had been accepted by both Parties, what would have been the position? Increased wages and increased employment would have been inevitable.
Comment on this
The Chair does not think so. The original proposals contained in the Bill are not now before the House. What is before the House is a Ministerial amendment.
Comment on this
It is very seldom I inflict myself on the House. I was accused on Committee Stage of having shrouded myself in a cloak of silence for a few years and Deputy Norton vehemently objected to my shedding that cloak of silence——
Comment on this
I have broken the silence because of the poison gas poured forth from the Labour Benches —the poison gas of political hypocrisy and sham. I urge on the Minister to stand fast for the principle of the split hours. I hope that, before this Bill becomes an Act, we shall get the 1 o'clock opening and 7 o'clock closing. It can be arranged whether the hours will be 1 to 2 and 5 to 7 or 1 to 3 and 5 to 7. I think that there is an open door there, if the Minister gets agreement. The people of this city and the people who come here are entitled to that. They should not be told that the houses in the other boroughs can open at 1 o'clock, but that the houses in the capital of the State must remain closed until 2 o'clock.
Comment on this
One of the purposes of the Sunday closing was to stop the rush, not of a few people, but of a multitude from the city to the surrounding districts. To do that, I brought in the 7 o'clock closing. I would much prefer to have left it at 5 o'clock. The licensed trade may have appealed to me, but I did not listen to them. I was concerned only with the report I had got both from the Guards and from decent people— mostly in County Dublin—who had to travel on Sunday evenings or who live in the districts concerned. These disgraceful scenes were increasing in those districts. The only way I could see of dealing with the matter, unless we were to cut the bona fide hours, was that which I proposed. If we made the hour 7 o'clock for the bona fide traffic, instead of 8, then I would be inclined to have a 6 o'clock closing in the city. But two hours would leave it as bad as ever. If you had 2 o'clock and 6 o'clock, you would have it as bad as ever.
We discussed the break on Sunday on the Committee Stage. I think it was Deputy Linehan quoted the report of the commission which sat in England. They referred to the good effect that the closing for the dinner hour had from the point of view of stopping the long-sitter. I said on the Committee Stage, and I think I was right in saying, that four hours on a Sunday, when there is nothing else to be done, would be a temptation to people to stay drinking for the whole four hours; whereas, if you have the break, they will go home and there is a chance that they may not come back; but if they do, at least they will have the break. The reason I put in 1 o'clock in the beginning was because I was given to understand and I was satisfied that it was the most suitable time. Clubs open at 1 o'clock and hotel restaurants open at 1 o'clock. Therefore, I thought that was a reasonable time to open. I admit that an hour is a short time. But when people know there is only an hour, they can be got out in time if the owners wish to get them out. I had provided for a two hours' interval, namely, from 1 o'clock to 2 o'clock and from 4 o'clock to 7 o'clock. I thought that was all right, because the Sunday would be different from a week day. When it comes to closing for the dinner hour on a week day, there are very few people in the public houses and it is easy to get them out. There is no trouble and the assistants and the owners can get a break of a full hour for their meals. I do not think it would be the same on Sunday. Deputy Byrne told us that from his experience it would take at least a quarter of an hour to clear the house.
Comment on this
But on Sunday there would be rather a big crowd and, if they were to get a meal at all, I think one and a half hours would be the minimum. Two hours was provided for before.
Comment on this
You have not the same rush at all. There will be practically nobody in the house at all on an ordinary day. I would prefer, as Deputy Cooney has said, that all the county boroughs would have the same hours, but apparently it does not suit Dublin. It was in order to deal with the Dublin problem that I brought in 2 o'clock. I think the amendment is a reasonable one. I tried to adopt a reasonable attitude in connection with this Bill. There were, however, certain things to which I would not agree, for instance, the general opening on Sunday. On the whole, I think it will be admitted that I have been reasonable in this matter. I will not agree to a longer gap than one hour on Sunday. That is my main trouble. If the closing hour were 6 o'clock in the cities and 8 o'clock in the outside places, I think the unholy rush would still continue. I want to avoid that. Then, if there were a four hours' continuous opening on Sunday when people have not got work to do, I am afraid it would lead to a continuous sitting. That is why I would not agree to make it from 2 o'clock to 6 o'clock.
Comment on this
I do not care whether they do or not, or whether the licensed trade want it. As Deputy Cooney pointed out, the assistants have a guaranteed maximum working week, and let them settle that. As Deputy Linehan said, it is a domestic question. I am concerned with the general problem. Clubs have been mentioned. If I had the same continuous complaints from the police about abuses in clubs that I have had about the public houses, I would have dealt with the clubs, too. But I have not had these complaints. That is why I have not dealt with them. There may be some foundation for them, but I do not think there is. I think there is a certain amount of propaganda in this. We all know that there is a certain amount of lobbying going on and a case being made. They have not got any evidence that the abuses in clubs are anything like what has been said here. I am sure the police would have been in possession of the facts if there had been. I am sticking to the amendment. If Deputies would agree to knock an hour off the bona fide hours, it would be a different matter. But I object to four hours' continuous opening on Sunday. I admit I have changed my mind, because I was open to reason and I wanted to get the views of Deputies.
Comment on this
It is open, except that the gap must not be widened between the closing hour in the city and the closing hour outside the city. I am sticking to that.
Comment on this
In regard to the Minister's statement about clubs, the Minister may not be aware, when he says that he has not had complaints in the same volume as he had in respect of public houses, that before the Gárda can enter a club they must procure a search warrant. That is the difficulty.
Comment on this
I want again to call the Minister's attention to the fact that he has made the Bill worse by the amendment on the Order Paper. I should like to ascertain from the Minister whether he would go back to the hours of 4 o'clock to 7 o'clock, instead of 4.30 to 7 o'clock, in order to give the assistants a bargaining position in connection with the new hours which are being forced upon them.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy think I would be justified in doing it for that purpose? I do not think I would be justified in doing it for that reason.
Comment on this
Deputy Cooney says that it does not matter to the assistants once they have the maximum working week.
Comment on this
Of course it is not so. Surely the assistants are entitled to agitate reasonably for avoiding a long spread-over? That is a legitimate demand. Is it just the same for a person to have to work 48 hours at night as 48 hours during the day? Of course it is not. Many conventions have been ratified in Geneva and here prohibiting the employment of certain people at night and prohibiting the employment of people at certain work at night, all indicating that the hours of work are an important consideration, and often a more important consideration than the actual number of hours worked. For instance, it is much better for a person to work 48 hours during the week, say, from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. each day than to work 44 hours per week from 9 o'clock at night until 5 o'clock in the morning. The hours at which people work are important. The assistants have a long spell, inasmuch as their hours are to be 10.30 a.m. until 10.30 p.m. Of course it is not just 10.30 p.m., because when a person closes at 10.30 there is washing up to be done and the stuff has to be made ready for the next day. An assistant in Dublin will probably find himself in the future getting home about 12 o'clock at night after a 10.30 o'clock opening. Anybody who cares to inquire into the matter will find that to be a fact.
Comment on this
Would not that be better than to go home with a week's wages in lieu of notice and an intimation from his employer that he regrets that business would not permit him to retain his services any longer?
Comment on this
There is no question of discussing it on that basis. In present circumstances you could probably just open public houses for one day per week because of the limited quantities of stuff which they are getting in some places.
Comment on this
I shall make my own argument. The Minister makes the case that on Sunday he wants to give the assistants——
Comment on this
——a break of one and a half hours. He forgets the fact that during the week he only gives one hour, namely, from 2.30 to 3.30 and in that period they have to have their meals. The Minister says, of course, that they have not so much to do when they come back. Take, for instance, a licensed premises in Dublin on a Saturday. I venture to say that when an assistant opens it again at 3.30 o'clock he will probably have a large number of customers to deal with, because a large number of people are in town on a Saturday afternoon. A large number of workers are off on a Saturday; crowds are coming from and going to football matches on a Saturday and, if an assistant manages to get a meal on Saturday from 2.30 to 3.30, why will not the Minister permit him to manage it between 3 o'clock and 4 o'clock on a Sunday? If it can be done on a Saturday, why cannot it be done on a Sunday? It would at least give the assistants four hours' attendance and, under the Conditions of Employment Act, they would be entitled to one day's compensatory leave. But they will not get a full day's leave for three and a half hours. They will get a half day's leave for three hours. If they have four hours on Sunday, they are entitled to one day's compensatory leave.
This Bill, so far as the assistant is concerned, is putting him in a certain disadvantageous position with regard to the present hours of duty. Why should the Minister deprive them of using whatever bargaining position they can get by a four-hour opening on Sunday instead of going back to a three and a half-hour opening? The Minister ought not to deprive them of that. Deputy Cooney indulges in some "ráiméis" about what happened in Bundoran during the year. I was not there, and I do not know what was said. I am sure Deputy Cooney was not there——
Comment on this
——and in any case he would not be qualified to go there. He knows that, too, and yet he uses an incident—I do not know whether it took place at all or not—and tries to make some capital out of it against the Labour Party.
Comment on this
At any rate, anything that would provoke Deputy Cooney into talking in this House is worth introducing. Having regard to the mantle of silence that he wrapped around himself in this House for years past, it is good to hear his voice.
Comment on this
A good listener? He must be a good listener, seeing that he can hear all that happens outside the House.
Comment on this
It requires some physical operation to produce that in Deputy Cooney. I appeal to the Minister to accept the hours of 2 to 6. As far as I am concerned, I would welcome the 2 to 6 hours, even if that meant restricting the bona fide traffic around Dublin to 7 o'clock in the evening, and if you do restrict it around Dublin to 7 o'clock in the evening. I do not think you will do very much harm. As far as I am personally concerned, whatever might be said about a black area for the purpose of this bona fide traffic, so called, on a Sunday evening, I think that any restriction is justified, but if the Minister, for various reasons, does not want to restrict it to 7 o'clock on a Sunday evening and prefers to go on to 8 o'clock, I venture to say that if the Gárdaí exercise vigilance in these places around Dublin which are the sources of trouble, so far as the Gárdaí and the Minister are concerned, I think that the Minister need not fear a continuance of that type of conduct; but even the fact that it should continue to a minor extent is not a reason for dividing up the day in the way the Minister proposes in his amendment. I still press him to agree to the 2 to 6 opening on Sunday.
Comment on this
As things stand now, I think there would be general agreement to revert, if there is to be a reversion, to the hours of 2 to 3 and 4 to 7 on Sunday. I think a case has been made on behalf of the assistants and, in my opinion, we should not go out of our way to try to facilitate one section more than another.
Comment on this
Ós rud é go bhfuil beartuighthe ag an Aire an t-am ólacháin i mBaile Átha Cliath do scoilt Dia Domhnaigh—agus aontuighim leis fé sin—molaim dó na h-uaireanta a 2-3 agus a 4-7. Tuigeann gach T.D. an fáth atá leis na tithe tabhairne do choimeád ar oscailt sa chathair agus sin é gan caoi thabhairt do dhaoine dul amach go dtí áiteanna lasmuich den chathair seo atá fé droch-cháil maidir le h-ólachán tráthnóintí Dia Domhnaigh.
Comment on this
I will agree to knock off the half-hour, although I think the other would be better. However, I will agree to have it 2 to 3 and 4 to 7.
Comment on this
I would prefer the two hours, as we had it originally.
Comment on this
Well, they would prefer the four-hour working period instead of the three-and-a-half-hour period.
Comment on this
I will accept that: from 2 to 3 and from 4 to 7.
Comment on this
I would urge the Minister to make it 1 to 2 and 4 to 7, or even 5 to 7. I think that the 2 o'clock opening is absolutely unjust and unfair to the community. As the Minister said —on an earlier stage of this Bill— Dublin, the Capital of Ireland, is the heart of the tourist traffic of this country. Into this city, in normal times, on Sundays, come thousands of people, and I would again remind the Minister of the terrible situation that existed in pre-war times when, on one occasion, something like 50,000 people came here to see an All-Ireland Final.
It was one of the wettest days that ever dawned, and these people were lined up at the railway stations and along O'Connell Street and the Quays, unable to get even sandwiches, not to mind liquid refreshments. Now, the majority of these people came in before 1 o'clock, and if—again adverting to the question of the national games— the games start, as they always do, at 3 o'clock, and if you do not open until 2 o'clock, the gates at these national games will suffer, because the people coming from the country want their stout and sandwiches before going to Croke Park. I think that no case can be made against a 1 o'clock opening, not alone on that ground but also from the point of view of the public houses and the people who have not money enough to become members of clubs. I think the ordinary consuming community should be given the same rights as those who can afford to become members of clubs, which open from 1 to 3 and from 6 to 9.
Comment on this
I wish to be recorded as dissonting from the 7 o'clock proposal. I think it is spoiling the assistants' evening off. I object to the extension to 7 o'clock from the existing 5 o'clock, because it spoils the evenings of everybody concerned in the industry.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 2 has already been withdrawn. The next question is that amendment No. 1, as amended, be agreed to.
Comment on this
With my dissent.
Deputy Byrne recorded as dissenting.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:—
In page 2 to add at the end of Section 4 the following sub-section:—
Nothing contained in Section 2 of the Act of 1927 shall operate to prohibit the holder of an on-licence (not being a six-day licence) in respect of premises situate in an urban county district or town the population of which district or town according to the last census exceeds ten thousand from selling or from keeping open for the sale of intoxicating liquor on any Sunday between the hours of one o'clock and three o'clock and between the hours of five o'clock and seven o'clock in the afternoon and the said sub-section shall have effect accordingly.
The intention of the amendment is to extend to towns of the size indicated the privilege enjoyed by the boroughs, other than Dublin. The legislation we are dealing with, I understand, has in the main been dictated by the conditions obtaining in and around Dublin, and advantage is being taken by the Minister to adjust the existing code because of requests from the Dublin area. It is the view of some people in the House that when the Bill is being put through, the people of the country generally should be given an opportunity to have a drink on Sundays in their own localities. That, seemingly, has not been possible, but this amendment aims at extending to sections of the community who live their lives under exactly the same conditions as the citizens of Cork, Limerick and Waterford. Even though they happen to be something smaller in population, it cannot be said that there is any difference between the conditions obtaining in Galway, Dundalk, Drogheda, and towns of that size and type, and the conditions obtaining in cities like Waterford, Cork and Limerick. The inhabitants of these towns cannot be said to be rural in their habits. They are really citizens in their methods of life, and they are denied the right that citizens of these big towns have of getting a drink on Sunday. There is no question of there being any fear of the extravagances that have been the subject of so much comment in the House taking place in those districts. Instead of driving them to become bona fide travellers, the Minister should give the people in these districts an opportunity to get a drink on Sunday.
They ought to be entitled to have the same hours of opening, before and after dinner, as are enjoyed by the southern cities. That would put them on a plane of equality with the population of these towns, and I think nobody can suggest any argument, from the temperance point of view, that there would be likely to be any abuses in these districts. It would facilitate them also, of course, on the occasion of big events taking place in their towns, but I am rather speaking for the life of the people from one end of the year to another, rather than for catering for an influx of visitors to these towns, when I suggest that they are as much entitled to have an opening between 1 and 3 and 5 and 7 as are the citizens of my own City of Limerick or of Waterford or Cork. I am perfectly satisfied that the House would agree and that nobody would put forward any argument that there would be abuse of that privilege if it was extended by the Minister in this Bill to the towns I am speaking of.
Comment on this
As I am personally concerned, I would support this amendment. The fact that such an amendment has to be brought in at all shows where the real problem lies. Even though I support the amendment I am beginning to be very much afraid of what the people in the rural districts are going to do now. First of all, they were in a subordinate position only to Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Waterford, the four county boroughs. If this amendment is accepted they will be in a subordinate position to every small country town. There is no doubt there is a strong case for the amendment. There is an equally strong case for the rural areas, but, for the life of me, I cannot see why the Deputies suggest this amendment. I suppose they are suggesting it now because they know they will not get the other thing and they are hoping to get this. I think there is a very strong argument for it, and I am quite satisfied that in the towns such as Deputy Keyes mentioned—Drogheda and Dundalk—which are industrial towns, there is a very strong case for a Sunday opening. I shudder to think what Deputy Corry's reaction will be if this amendment goes through. He felt small enough in his position as country representative when the Bill was being brought in originally, but when he is put in a still more inferior position to the towns, I do not know what he will feel. I think the Minister ought to accept this amendment and I think the Minister, even at this late stage, could consider going the whole hog.
I want to put one very strong point to the Minister. I am glad that I have been reminded of it by Deputy Keyes' reference to temperance. There was a snowball resolution sent to every Deputy in this House from a certain society of which branches were revived all over the country for the purpose of sending that resolution, condemning the action of the House and of the Minister and condemning everybody having anything to do with the proposed relaxation of the licensing laws in the new licensing Bill. I do not know how many Deputies thought it worth their while to reply to that circular, but I thought it worth my while to reply to it. I wrote to the secretary of one of the branches that sent me that circular. I said: "I have got your letter. I do not see anything wrong with the licensing Bill, as amended. The Minister has given us concessions that I am satisfied with. If you see anything wrong with the licensing Bill, will you tell me what you see wrong with it and what your arguments for your opposition to it are?" I did not get any reply to that letter. I am very much afraid that, behind the general opposition to the Sunday opening in the country, there is a feeling that there would be intense opposition to it from certain quarters. There was a certain amount of that opposition in the House. There was quite sincere opposition, I believe, from Deputy Allen in his speech on the Committee Stage. I appreciate his viewpoint, although I totally disagree with it. The fact that it is necessary to ask that this amendment be accepted in the case of towns of over 10,000 population indicates the necessity for doing something like that for the whole country. As far as the amendment is concerned, it is something to be desired. The towns mentioned are surely entitled to have an opening. It will do this much, but it will not improve the situation because it will make a bad anomaly worse.
Comment on this
I have been a member of a temperance organisation all my life, and I have not received the abusive letter to which Deputy Linehan referred.
Comment on this
If this amendment is accepted, it will mean there will be less bona fide traffic. You will not have men coming from Dublin to outlying districts, especially to my constituency. I am supporting this amendment on account of representations made by the Bray Urban Council on behalf of the licensed trade in Bray. In the summer time there is a floating population of 20,000 in Bray. The Bray traders are prepared to meet the Minister's wishes if he wants to restrict bona fide traffic and to have similar hours of opening to those in Dublin and not to have any bona fide traffic in Bray. They are large ratepayers. They are large employers. They have represented that people can come by bus or rail from Bray to Dublin and get in Dublin the drink that is denied them in the Bray area. I am not one who would advocate intemperance. I pointed out to a temperance organisation many years ago that, with transport facilities, a three miles' or five miles' limit will not prevent a man from travelling in order to get a drink. I am satisfied that if you had the facilities in the district that I am speaking for that exist in Dublin there would be less drink consumed. I am sorry the Minister brought up the question of clubs. I could give him instances of clubs and I could give him the reasons why he does not receive reports in connection with them. It is because high officers are appointed committee members of the clubs before they are a week in the area. What I object to is the fact that the publican who is paying for his licence and paying his employees, is restricted by Guards, watched and persecuted in many ways, while people can leave the public house and go to a club on St. Patrick's Day, St. Stephen's Day or Sunday and get drink there.
If the Minister wants to restrict drinking, he would first of all have to tackle, not the decent public houses which are under everybody's observation, but the clubs in isolated places where there is intemperance. Even in my own constituency we are often surprised at the reports we receive from the clergy and others about the drink that is consumed in certain clubs. You have the licensed trader backing up the club because he happens to be the agent for supplying the beer to the clubs in the area. I appeal to the Minister to accept the amendment on behalf of Bray—it is not for all the rural areas. It is such a short distance from Bray to the city, a matter of a quarter of an hour in the bus, that the workers of Bray can come to Dublin for bona fide trade. The Bray traders are prepared to comply with the regulations. They recognise that under the present law they would be entitled, in the tourist season, to supply when the public houses are closed in Dublin. If there were a rush in the summer season in Bray, there might be a difficulty in meeting it. We will be satisfied if the Minister grants this concession. The effect of it will be to bring about the situation that he desires. We believe that its acceptance would help to abolish a lot of the abuses that occur in connection with the bona fide traffic.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will not give way by accepting this amendment. This is the thin end of the wedge for a general opening on Sundays. There can be no doubt about that. Deputy Linehan was quite right when he said that the rest of the rural population would have a grievance if the Minister were to give way on this and allow Sunday opening in about a dozen towns in the country which have a population of over 10,000. There is one such town in the constituency that I represent. It has a population of about 12,500. I think I can speak, to a certain extent, on behalf of that town. Neither the members of the licensed trade there, nor any section of the people, want Sunday opening. It is very significant that a Deputy who resides in that town is not sitting beside Deputy Everett to support him.
Comment on this
I represent my own county, and I speak on behalf of Bray, which is pretty close to Dublin.
Comment on this
There is one thing that I am certain of, and it is that if Deputy Everett forces a division on this Deputy Corish will not support him.
Comment on this
I do not know. I did not ask him. One would not get a box of matches in Wexford on a holyday, not to speak of a Sunday.
Comment on this
It is all to the credit of the Wexford people that they keep the Sabbath. I hope the people in other parts of the country will follow their example. If, as I said on the Committee Stage, the Minister were to give way to the clamour of a few topers by allowing public houses to open on Sundays the effect would be to sap the morale of the people. If Sunday were allowed to be turned into a day for the carrying on of general trade, and for boozing, that would have the effect of sapping the whole moral foundation of the people in this State. We would soon have what they have on the Continent—no Sunday. The observance of the Sabbath has, unfortunately, been done away with in some countries. If we had a general opening of public houses in the rural areas on Sundays, then we would be on the high road to the position that, unfortunately, has been reached in many countries throughout the world. As I have said, I hope that the Minister will not give way to this clamour from a few topers for Sunday opening.
Comment on this
I appeal to the Minister to resist this amendment. I rise to speak on it for the reason that the town I represent has been mentioned in the course of the debate. I want to say that no representations whatever have been made to me by the licensed trade in that town or by anybody else in regard to the granting of facilities for the opening of public houses on Sundays. Deputy Linehan rightly pointed out that the rural community would have a grievance if towns with a population of the one that I represent were to be allowed to have a Sunday opening for public houses. There are a few public houses situate outside the borough of Drogheda. Is it suggested that the owners of them must, of necessity, keep closed on a Sunday while the publicans in Drogheda, only a few hundred yards away, are to be allowed to open? I hope that, for the reasons I have stated, the Minister will refuse to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I desire to join in the appeal to the Minister not to accept this amendment. On previous stages of the Bill we pointed out, when a general Sunday opening was advocated, that at present only a small number of "pubs" in the country engage in the bona fide trade on Sundays with the result that the owners of them and their assistants can go away and have a day's recreation. If the Minister were to agree to have a general opening on Sundays, the result would be to pin everybody down to a seven-day week. It would open the door for the carrying on of a general trade on Sundays. Deputy Davin, on the Second Reading and Committee Stages of the Bill, advocated that the carrying on of a general trade should be allowed on Sundays. This, he urged, would save the busy farmer and his wife from having to do their business on Saturday. If that state of things were permitted, it would mean a return to slave conditions both for the owners of public houses and their assistants.
I agree with Deputy Linehan that, in this amendment, we have the thin end of the wedge for a general opening on Sundays. If the Minister were to give way on the question of population, then at some future stage he, or some other Minister, would have to give way in the case of towns with a population of 5,000. Later on the figure would be brought down to 1,000, and, eventually, we would reach the position of having not only a Sunday opening for public houses but of other premises in which a general trade is carried on. I think it is a good thing for this nation and for its people to have a day of rest on Sunday.
Comment on this
I desire to support the amendment. I have not taken very much interest in this Bill, but, viewing this from a logical point of view, I cannot see why towns like Dundalk, Drogheda and Wexford and other towns with a population of over 10,000, should not enjoy the same facilities on Sundays as Waterford, Cork and Limerick. I should have greater admiration for the attitude that Deputy Allen is taking up if he, as a member of the Fianna Fáil Party, had voted against the Minister's section which gives those Sunday facilities to Waterford, Cork and Limerick.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen's attitude is this: it is all right for the people in Waterford, Cork and Limerick to be able to get drink on a Sunday, but it would be all wrong for the people in Dundalk to have a drink on a Sunday.
Comment on this
They would lose their faith and all the rest of it. I cannot speak from experience of public houses on Sundays, but I suggest to the Minister that, in the case of people who want to have a drink on a Sunday, it would be much better to have an opening of public houses during certain hours so that they could walk boldly in and take their drink, instead of, as at present, ducking around and entering public houses through back yards.
I want to dissociate myself from some remarks that were made in the course of the debates on this Bill in regard to the manner in which the Civic Guards enforce the licensing laws. The statement was made that the public houses might as well be open on Sundays, the suggestion being that the Civic Guards were not enforcing the law. I want to repudiate those statements and suggestions. In my opinion, the Guards are doing their duty as best they can to see that the law is obeyed in regard to Sunday closing. If abuses do happen to occur in connection with the licensing laws, it is not fair to put the blame on the Guards. As I have said, I cannot for the life of me see why people in towns like Dundalk and Drogheda should not enjoy the same facilities in regard to being able to get a drink on a Sunday as the people in Cork, Limerick and Waterford enjoy. Take the case of the City of Dublin. Nowhere in the country is there a better observance of the Sabbath than in this city, where the public houses are allowed to open for a few hours in the afternoon. The people in Dublin, it can be said, are most exemplary in the observance of their religious duties.
Therefore the argument put forward by Deputy Allen does not, in my opinion, hold water. If he were prepared to go the whole hog and vote against Sunday opening generally, whether in the city or anywhere else, one might appreciate his point of view, but, with all respect, he cannot differentiate as between various sections of the community. A large number of people come into the town of Dundalk on Sundays, and I think it would be much better if they could get into a public house for a drink than that they should carry on as they have been doing for the past two or three years. I think the Minister would not be making a mistake in granting those facilities. Possibly, he may not think that the hours suggested are suitable; he may want to make certain changes in the hours. If he does, I am sure Deputy Keyes and the proposer of the amendment will only be too happy to fall in with any adjustments he may wish to make. I cannot see why those towns should not have the same facilities with regard to Sunday opening as are enjoyed by people in the other places to which the Act applies All those terrible things which we are told would happen if those facilities were granted simply would not take place. There is no use in throwing up our hands in despair. We have very little confidence in the people of this country if we think they cannot be trusted to pass by a public house on a Sunday even if it is open. The public houses are open every other day, and thousands of people do pass them by; they can do the same on a Sunday. I would ask the Minister to grant those facilities.
Comment on this
I thought we had settled this question with regard to the general opening hours. As Deputy Kennedy said, if those facilities are granted to towns with a population of 10,000, we would then be asked to go down to 5,000 and 4,000, and where are we to draw the line? Deputy O'Higgins said that I should justify the differentiation: he tried to put the onus on me. I found it there; there was some reason for it, and I do not propose to interfere with a differentiation that has been there for quite a long time. This is more than the thin end of the wedge; it is something I would not be prepared to do at all. I am not prepared to do what Deputy O'Higgins said I was bound to do, that is, to justify the differentiation. I found it there, and conditions have not changed so very much. One of the reasons, I think—I may be wrong— why facilities were given in the cities and not in the country is that it was easier to control the sale of drink in the cities. That may have been at the bottom of it.
Comment on this
There may have been other reasons. There were rows that could not be controlled; the police could not be everywhere; and all the rest of it. As I say, if those facilities were granted to towns with a population of 10,000, then a case could be put forward for towns with a population of 5,000, until eventually a case could be made for the countryside. I do not propose to agree to this amendment.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Minister that the reason for that differentiation is not a reason why it should be allowed to continue at all.
Comment on this
I am not prepared to go and recast the whole licensing code.
Comment on this
The reason for the differentiation was that the bona fide trade was no good to the city public-house, because the people would not come in three miles, and there would not be three miles from one point to another in the city.
Comment on this
I can understand to an extent the Minister's reluctance to depart too extensively from the provisions of the 1927 Act, but on the other hand I do not think that the acceptance of the proposed amendment would involve any very revolutionary departure. There is no question of stepping down to 9,000 or 6,000 or 5,000, at another time, by some other Minister. Personally, I am inclined to hope that, with the passing of the years, we will reach a stage of confidence in our people which will justify that further extension. At the moment, it ought to be possible for the Minister and the House to agree to what is suggested in the amendment— that we see no huge gulf between the conduct of people in the towns with a population of 10,000 and those with a population of 20,000 or 30,000.
If I anticipated for a moment the terrible calamities portrayed by Deputy Allen as the consequence of accepting this amendment, I would shudder to think of having my name associated with it, but I have not the least fear in the world that in his own town of Wexford—I am sorry Deputy Corish is not here—where we are told that one cannot buy a box of matches on a Sunday, the conduct of the people would be so shockingly revolutionised by having the public houses open on a Sunday. I do not think any abuses would take place if the people in those industrial towns with a population of 10,000 had the privilege of having the public houses open on Sundays for a certain limited number of hours, so that they can get a drink if they want it. We do not see any of those abuses taking place in towns where the public houses are open. If such abuses were taking place, neither the House nor the Minister would agree to a continuation of those opening hours. We would have a clamour from the temperance people, demanding the prevention of those abuses. There has been no such clamour. Where have we an example of the horrors that we are given to understand will take place in Ireland if Galway, Wexford, Dundalk, and those other places are granted those facilities? They are purely a figment of the imagination; there is no evidence to support it. It is a reflection on the conduct of the people to suggest that they would not behave themselves if this privilege were ex tended to them.
I think the Minister would not be doing anything revolutionary in extending the privileges of the 1927 Act from the four county boroughs to the industrial towns of our country. As has been pointed out, modern transport has revolutionised the condition of affairs in recent years, and you cannot prevent people from getting a drink if they want to get it. I heard Deputy Norton making the point on an earlier stage of this Bill that if the Minister had a commission for bicycle tyres there might be something to be said for this restriction, because it drives people further afield to get their drink. If they could get a drink close at hand, they would take it and go home to their dinner, but when they have to go out a few miles they will not stop at one drink. I would again ask the Minister to grant those facilities to towns with a population of 10,000, and not to be intimidated by the bogeys which have been raised.
Comment on this
Now, I might as well raise another bogey. As far as I am concerned, I am totally opposed to the amendment. I have never had any representation from anybody in my constituency asking for those facilities, and I will vote against the amendment.
Comment on this
I am speaking on behalf of traders in my constituency from whom I received representations. As I stated before, I would not advocate any excessive facilities for drink, but I would ask the Minister to consider the position in regard to places in close proximity to Dublin. The position will be that when the public houses close in Dublin the people will travel by bus to the public houses in Bray. It is only a matter of a quarter of an hour. We do not want bona fide traffic on Sundays; we are prepared to have in Bray the same opening hours as in Dublin, with no bona fide traffic.
Comment on this
I have been listening to the debate on this amendment and to the debate on the last amendment and I am beginning to wonder if this country is not made up of only two classes, the owners of licensed premises and their assistants, because I hear now, as a conclusive argument put forward by Deputy Allen and Deputy Corish, that this thing must, of course, be bad, as the publicans have not asked for it.
Comment on this
I never said one word about the publicans. I said one person in my constituency had asked for it, to my knowledge.
Comment on this
If I misunderstood the Deputy, I am very sorry, but that was the impression left on my mind. Let us ask ourselves, who else could have asked for it? So far as the temperance associations are concerned, I know they passed resolutions. Even the licensed trade may pass resolutions, but I do not yet know of any association of moderate drinkers, let us say, who would come together and pass resolutions and send them on to their Deputies. I have not come across that type of body, but possibly it is in existence in Wexford.
Let us get down to this amendment. Whether the licensed trade or the assistants are or are not asking for it, let us consider it on its merits. I am not at all impressed by the Minister's argument that a certain thing is there and it must remain. That is not at all, to my mind, a conclusive argument. If amendments are brought before the House, you must deal with them according as you think they are sound or unsound, and not because a differentiation was made 60 or 70 years ago and it must remain for all time. It does seem to me that there is a particular reason why large towns should be differentiated from strictly rural areas, and it is a pretty obvious one. If you have 10,000 people collected in one area and none of them can get alcohol on Sunday inside that area, they have to wander out in order to get the alcohol. Possibly friends may come in to meet them, and may want to have a friendly talk over their alcohol. The inhabitants of the town must be teetotal, while the visitors whom they are entertaining can take the stronger stuff, one set being bona fide and the others not.
If this amendment is carried it will mean that in the larger towns that problem will not arise to the extent to which it does now. In a small village or town where there are only 500 people they may have to move out if they want a drink on Sunday. It is quite a different problem, and I take it that is the reason why the differentiation between Dublin, the other county boroughs and the rest of the country took place. The legislature did not want a colossal exodus from a city with 500,000 of a population to the country public houses around in order hat persons might become bona fide. I would be absolutely absurd and impossible to prevent Sunday opening in Dublin unless you stopped the bona fide traffic altogether. So far as the argument is concerned that you may have to enlarge if you start with 10,000, that need not be taken seriously. How this legislation will work out will only be shown by experience. I do not think there are any statistics to show that there is more drinking in Waterford than in Galway or Clonmel on Sundays. I do not think there are any statistics that could be produced by the Minister to show that there is more drunkenness on Sundays. If the public houses are opened in accordance with this amendment, they will be opened for a shorter time so far as the bona fide traffic is concerned.
Comment on this
Has the Minister any statistics to show the number of prosecutions for drunkenness on Sundays as compared to week days?
Comment on this
The Minister must have been armed with a good deal of statistics before he came here to father the Bill. He talked about the principle involved in this amendment that Deputy Everett and Deputy Keyes have moved, and for that reason he declined to accept it. I do not think that is the real position. The Minister has agreed to the continuance, and even the extension, of the Sunday opening hours in the boroughs and by so doing he has given away what he calls the principle of Sunday opening. It is now only a question of whether he will extend what he has agreed to in the case of Dublin and the other county boroughs to places like Drogheda and Dundalk.
Comment on this
The facilities in the boroughs were always there. It is something new that is being asked in this amendment.
Comment on this
I have received resolutions from various organisations—I suppose they have been sent to every Deputy—requesting that in the consideration of this Bill we should not agree to any extension of existing facilities. The people who were party to the drafting and passing of the resolutions do not seem to be aware that there is an extension of drinking facilities being given by the Minister to the residents of the four boroughs. Is that not so?
Comment on this
They are well aware of it. I have heard enough about it, anyway.
Comment on this
The only argument the Minister makes against this amendment is, in effect, that he will not agree to change what has been the practice since 1878. Is it not time that we changed everything in the shape of legislation that was passed in whatever Parliament was responsible for the legislation of 1878? I think the Minister would be well advised to review everything affecting his own Department.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not forget the Intoxicating Liquor Act passed in 1927.
Comment on this
The living conditions of the people and the outward appearance of the country as a whole have changed since 1878.
Comment on this
For that reason I think that the Minister should seriously consider the acceptance of this amendment. Deputy Brady seemed to suggest that there is no great rush to Bray, after the public houses close in Dublin, on the part of people anxious to avail of the existing drinking facilities. Does he seriously suggest that?
Comment on this
I seriously suggest that no man could possibly get from Dublin to Bray in a quarter of an hour, as was stated here.
Comment on this
If that is the point, then I agree with the Deputy; but a man could get there in 35 or 40 minutes. If he left Dublin at 5 o'clock, he would be able to arrive in Bray before 6 o'clock and be able to get another "fill-up".
Comment on this
That is what the Deputy would be voting for if he voted against the alternative suggested in Deputy Everett's amendment.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy ever try to get a bus from Dublin to Bray within the last 12 months? I did.
Comment on this
I wonder would the Deputy go down to the bus terminus at Dun Laoghaire at 5 o'clock on a summer evening and see the queue of people lined up waiting for buses to Bray in order to get another "fill up".
Comment on this
Yes, and from Dun Laoghaire as well. Anybody can see those queues there on a Sunday evening in summer time.
Comment on this
You certainly would be very lucky if you were able to go from Dublin to Bray in an hour in present conditions.
Comment on this
The conditions affecting transport from Dublin to Bray and everywhere else have considerably altered as a result of the emergency. I am telling the Deputy what I believe he ought to know regarding the people who are getting extended drinking facilities in Dublin and in Dun Laoghaire and who, under the legislation which is to be continued and for which he is voting, will be entitled to go to Bray and get further facilities there. Would the Minister consider the advisability, as against a general opening policy, of allowing people to have drinking facilities within three miles of their residence and cut out bona fide traffic everywhere?