We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1942—Recommittal.

Contributions 183–363 of 363. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1942
Enacted

No. 17 of 1942 ›

Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not in the amendment.

Comment on this

No, but I suggest it is quite possible to offer a suggestion of this kind under the terms of the amendment. I put that suggestion, not as one manufactured in my own mind, but as one put forward by a responsible officer of the Gárda, that is, that there might be general opening in the country as a whole applicable to people within a radius of three miles of their places of residence.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I suggest that the Deputy is out of order. General opening has been decided already in a very definite way.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that no principle that I know of is involved in this amendment, will the Minister give us a better reason for opposing this amendment than the fact that it has been in existence since 1878, and that there is a big principle involved?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I give the Deputy the reason I have given already—it was decided in 1927 and has since worked satisfactorily, and I do not propose to recast the 1927 Act. That Act was passed in 1927 after a very long debate. The point originated in 1878, but it was fully considered here in 1927, and I am satisfied that it has worked satisfactorily. There has been no general demand for a change. I do admit that it would be a very bad principle to say that what was good enough for our grandfathers is good enough for us. I do not stand on that principle at all. I agree we ought to move with the times, but you must draw the line somewhere and not take on too big a job. If something has worked fairly well, it is as well to leave it alone, until there is a very big demand for a change; but where something has not worked and has become simply a farce, as in the case of the bona fide traffic, it is time to interfere. That is why the Bill was brought in.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

I see the danger which the Minister sees, but he is looking a little further ahead than I. As has been said already, it will probably be 20 years before we have another licensing Bill. I hope that will be so, but the Minister is resting his whole case on four boroughs. The amendment in the name of Deputy Keyes suggests that towns or cities with a population of 10,000 or over should have the same concessions as those enjoyed by the people in the four boroughs. I do not know what the population of Waterford is, but let us take Galway which has a population of over 20,000. I think that a city with a population of 20,000 or over should have the same concessions as the boroughs, and I do not want to preach intemperance by any means.

This amendment will not affect many towns in the Province of Connaught, but I appeal to the Minister to accept the amendment, with the proviso that the figure of 10,000 population might be raised somewhat. I should be quite agreeable. I cannot see why the same concessions should not be given to a city with a population of 20,000 or 22,000 as are given to the boroughs. I do not think it will lead to a spread of intemperance, and in fact I think it will bring about a lessening of intemperance, because if people want a few drinks, they will have to run into backyards, persecuting the Guards who are trying to keep law and order, in order to get them.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

If the Minister were disposed to accept the amendment I should be rather inclined to urge him to reduce the figure rather than to raise it as Deputy Brodrick suggested, so that towns in tourist areas, such as Killarney, might be brought in. If he were to consider it at all, he should consider it on the basis of towns which have town commissioners, urban councils or bodies of the kind; but in fact I object to any of this differentiation, as I pointed out at the Committee Stage. I see absolutely no reason for any differentiation between the residents of our towns and our rural population. I agree that it is an inheritance of the Minister's and I do not throw the blame for it on him. It has existed for 70 or 80 years. It was brought forward into the 1927 Act, but that does not make it right, and the Minister cannot adopt the attitude that everything we did was right, and therefore sacrosanct.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Only when it suits me.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

When the 1927 Act was under consideration here, we were all very much younger than we are now. We were all very young men and young men are inclined to be enthusiastic in adopting particular attitudes. There was undoubtedly a great wave of temperance enthusiasm behind the 1927 Act, even though there was a fair amount of strong opposition to some of its provisions. I do not want to go into it all, but I do want to stress that the principle of differentiation between the residents of the boroughs and the residents of the rural areas is wrong, and that the Minister should have taken his courage in his hands and made the same law for every citizen.

It would be a very nice question as to whether there is not a constitutional issue involved in this differentiation between different sections of our people. It has never been raised, but it is a point which may be raised, as to whether it is constitutional at all. If the Minister gives any consideration to the proposition in the amendment, I ask him to consider it on the basis of making it much more wide than the amendment proposes, while I still maintain that it is entirely wrong to make any such differentiation.

Comment on this

I should like to ask if the Minister would inform us in regard to the question of the amendment proposed by Deputy Everett. While I hope that he will not give way and extend these hours widely on an indiscriminate basis all over the country, and while I cordially approve of the principle of discriminating in respect of closing hours in the cities and in rural Ireland, for reasons into which I do not think it is necessary for me to go —Deputy Lynch and I had our say on the merits of that question on Committee Stage—I do think that this question arises: If we are going to emphasise the development of the tourist traffic industry post-war, does not the Minister think that in areas recognised as tourist areas, the amenities provided should not be identical with those in rural Ireland? I cannot find myself in agreement with Deputy Brodrick's views. There is something to be said for a middle course. Does the Minister not think that he should reserve to some one discretion to give limited hours in tourist areas by bringing them into line with city hours rather than with those in rural areas? If we are to be in competition with the Isle of Man and Blackpool and to build up a considerable business on that assumption, it seems absurd to say to persons whose co-operation we are seeking that there will be certain hours in those areas for that type of tourist. We will have to compete with Blackpool and the Isle of Man, but we are asking people in the licensed trade to conform to hours that are intended for a rural population or for remote parts of the country.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Perhaps the Deputy is not aware that in the Isle of Man there is complete closing on Sundays.

Comment on this

I do not profess to be an expert on the tourist question. I think the Minister for Justice will agree that if the Isle of Man has total Sunday closing that arrangement must be founded on some peculiar puritanical ordinance. I wonder if there is some difficulty in repealing it? However, I do not care what they do in the Isle of Man. What I am concerned about is to do what is reasonable here. If they want to do something daft in the Isle of Man let them, but if we go to people in this country and ask them to improve their premises, and to spend money on them, because they happen to be located in an area where there is a certain development of tourist traffic, we should tell them that we give money to the Tourist Development Board in order to second their efforts to improve their premises. Does the Minister not think that consequential on the private efforts of the individual, and the exertions of the Tourist Development Board, which are financed out of public money, the rational thing would be to reserve a discretion, if adequate representations were made to him to define an area, and to say that in that area the Sunday opening hours normally available in Dublin would be available for tourist traffic, and to justify that departure from the general rural rule by scheduling it as a tourist area? It seems to me that unless we do that, sooner or later we will be confronted with a new Licensing Bill, in which special facilities will be set out to create amenities of that kind.

Under the present law, people who go to hotels to get a meal on Sundays can have a drink with it. But remember that while a considerable body of tourists are in a position to go to hotels for meals, or for whatever refreshments they want, a different class of people who go there bring sandwiches in paper bags. While the children are picnicking on the strand the men in the party may adjourn to a public house to have a bottle of beer or a bottle of stout with which to moisten their lips. If we intend to do all we can to develop the tourist trade I urge that view on the House. Everybody seems to think that we are manoeuvring for positions in this debate, and that by our stand here we are going to be known hereafter as advocates of tee-totallers or of "drunks". I do not mind what is said. The important thing is that we should do the right thing now.

I do not think that at this stage or at any stage we could finally define every tourist area. What is a tourist area to-day may not be a tourist area to-morrow. There should be discretion in the Minister or in somebody to declare tourist areas scheduled areas. I can see that the Minister might be in misery if he were called upon to administer a discretion of that kind. I know that every Minister is reluctant to undertake that task. I cannot see why any serious doubt should arise as to whether an area is a tourist area or not. I imagine there will be some rule of thumb which the Minister will apply as to what he considers a tourist area. Will the Minister consider that suggestion?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I discussed this question at length on the Committee Stage. Perhaps the Deputy was not present then.

Comment on this

I was.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

There is the difficulty of scheduling areas. I pointed out that, without doubt, Dublin is the biggest tourist area. How could Howth, which is now in Dublin, be excluded? We also discussed the extended hours. The whole problem of scheduling an area is there. I do not see how this could be done, seeing that the whole country, all round the coast, is concerned.

Comment on this

If the Minister takes discretion it need never be exercised.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

If it is necessary let someone else do it. It is queer how other tourist centres attract enormous crowds—for instance, Wales and the Isle of Man.

Comment on this

And Northern Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Wales, Scotland and the Isle of Man get any amount of visitors, so that they are not affected by what obtains there.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know that the conservative clubs in these places are open on Sundays?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The tourist organisation urged to have this done and one of the arguments put up was that if extra facilities for drinking were given, we would be able to compete more successfully with places such as the Isle of Man and Llandudno. The fact is that these places attract crowds of tourists, and the public houses are not open on Sundays. It is not people who want drink we want to attract here. There are many people who would be glad to come and enjoy the amenities that we can offer without considering the drinking facilities.

Comment on this

They can go into a conservative club in any of the places you mention.

Comment on this

Could the Minister not give a discretion to the district justice on application made by traders in a licensed area? After Dublin, Bray is the largest tourist centre, and you have the position that residents in Bray who want these facilities can take a train and come up to Dublin. I might not have been correct in suggesting that the journey could be covered in a quarter of an hour, but I suggest that if the shops are closed in Bray, it would not take more than 30 minutes in normal times to get to Dublin.

Comment on this

I do not like the Minister's last equalisation, that if you open in these tourist areas you are offering facilities to "drunks". That, I think, represents a division of mind on the part of the Minister. There is the mind that seems people who come into an area to get refreshment to which human beings are reasonably entitled, and the mind that can only see "drunks" coming in. I would agree that so far as there are more facilities given, you are likely to have a greater proportion of people who are under the influence of drink, but I think there are other people who should also be considered.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I admit that perhaps I went too far in that.

Comment on this

I think that Deputy Davin's answer to the Minister with regard to those areas where there are no drinking facilities in England, is pertinent. I understand that the number of clubs in England went up by at least 50 per cent. in a very small period of years as a result of these restrictions in England. I think, however, the distinction made between a tourist area and the rest of the country is a bad one. It is very hard to see why there should be any logical discrimination between the countryside generally and these areas. It seems to be odd that the stranger who comes in here to look at our natural scenery is apparently going to be enervated to such an extent that he cannot recover unless he gets drink while the native who is looking at that scenery all the year round has to go without drink. I take it that this concession is sought merely for the purpose of catering for people generally. That is the net point, that public houses should be allowed to cater for the reasonable demands of the community. In this country, unfortunately, we have had a reputation in the past for intoxication. We have lived that down by slow degrees—partly as a result of the increased price of drink, and partly as the result of temperance crusades. I think it is largely because of that history of ours that Ministers are not inclined to interfere with laws made so far back as 1878, but I should like the Minister to make up his mind that while old liquor may be good, old liquor legislation is not necessarily good.

Comment on this

The whole objection, I understand, to extending the hours in the whole of rural Ireland is that by doing so we would probably turn Sunday into a market day. Public houses in rural Ireland are usually engaged in mixed business. If I am a draper and a person next door has a public house and also carries on a drapery business, if he is allowed to open his premises for the purpose of supplying drink on Sunday, he will also carry on his drapery business at the same time and I must, in order to compete with him, open my drapery establishment. The moment the premises are open, they will be open not alone for the sale of drink but for the sale of any commodity which the shop stocks. If my next door neighbour opens, then I must open in competition with him. If the whole town is going to open after last Mass, the idea will be that Sunday is the best market day. That surely would be an undesirable development in the rural life of this country. I do not think it is any exaggeration to say that tourists who go to a centre for relaxation will ordinarily and legitimately consume rather more liquor refreshment than a native who has to work six or seven days of the week. If Deputy McGilligan and I are in Waterville or Portnoo on holidays, shall we not consume more frequent glasses of sherry than in our respective homes? That is the ordinary practice. Why not face the fact that any one of us on holidays will consume more alcoholic liquor than when we are engaged on our daily jobs at home? If we are catering for the accommodation of persons so minded, who want to go and relax and to pursue a less ordered or less careful regime than ordinary men going about their daily work, why not make provisions for that purpose?

If, on the other hand, we do not want tourists, if we do not want people to relax and have a good time, then we should not have a Tourist Development Board. There are many rationally-minded people who think that we should be much better off if we did not encourage such people to come amongst us but if we reject that view and invite and urge tourists to visit this country, surely it is nonsense to suggest that if that class of person wants refreshments on Sundays we should not give them to him? There is nothing sinful in taking refreshments on Sunday. If the tourist wants it and thinks it will add to his comfort by all means let him get it, but that is no reason why we should revolutionise the whole social life of rural Ireland, by throwing open all the public houses in the country. In tourist parts, however, inasmuch as there is nothing intrinsically bad in consuming liquor on Sunday, facilities can be provided whereby liquor will be available for people visiting these places.

Comment on this

When the Deputy mentions tourist areas, will places doing a mixed trade in such areas not be open for all purposes?

Comment on this

Inevitably, and that is the feature about the tourist trade which rather repels me.

Comment on this

Supposing you insisted on a structural separation between the bar and other parts of the premises, and allowed the structurally-separated bar to open for the consumption of liquor only, would that meet the Deputy's objection?

Comment on this

And make it illegal to carry on any other form of business in that house on Sunday?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If that were practicable, a great part of my objection to Sunday opening would disappear, but I do not think it would be practicable.

Comment on this

I suggest that Dublin is the biggest tourist area in the country. The district of Howth, which was formerly in the county, furnished one of the reasons for this Bill, but I think it has been forgotten that Howth is now part of Dublin City, so that any legislation that comes into force in future applying to the city, equally applies to Howth.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 28
·
Níl 52
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 5:—

In page 2, line 36, Section 5, to delete all words from the word "by" to the end of the section, line 41, and substitute the following:—

(a) by the insertion in sub-section (1) of the word "half-past" before the words "ten o'clock",

(b) by the deletion in sub-section (2) of the words "in a county borough on week days between the hours of nine o'clock and ten o'clock in the morning and" and the substitution in lieu thereof of the words "on week days between the hours of nine o'clock and half-past ten o'clock in the morning and, in a county borough, on week days",

(c) by the insertion at the end of the section of the following sub-section, that is to say.—

(4) In sub-section (2) of this section, the expression "premises to which an off-licence is attached" does not include premises to which a wine retailer's off-licence within the meaning of the Finance (1909-10) Act, 1910 (and no other off-licence) is attached.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 6:—

In page 2 to delete lines 46 to 53, Section 7, and substitute the following words:—

(a) by the deletion in sub-section (1) of the words "licensing area, be entitled to have the seven-day licence transferred at the annual licensing District Court" and the substitution in lieu thereof of the words "district or adjoining districts, be entitled, on application at any sitting of the justice of the District Court in whose district are situate the premises to which the six-day licence is attached, to have the seven-day licence transferred",

(b) by the deletion in sub-section (2) of the words "licensing area, be entitled to have the ordinary seven-day licence transferred at the annual licensing District Court" and the substitution in lieu thereof of the words "district or adjoining districts, be entitled, on application at any sitting of the justice of the District Court in whose district are situate the premises to which the early-closing licence is attached, to have the ordinary seven-day licence transferred",

(c) by the addition at the end of the section of a new sub-section as follows:—

(3) In this section, the word "district" means a district of the District Court prescribed under Section 68 of the Courts of Justice Act, 1924 (No. 10 of 1924).

This amendment is intended to meet the suggestion of Deputy McGilligan on the Committee Stage. Section 11 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1927, entitled a person who is the holder of a seven-day licence and a six-day or an early-closing licence in respect of premises situated in the same licensing area, to obtain, at the annual licensing District Court, a transfer of the seven-day licence to the premises to which the six-day or early-closing licence is attached. Section 7 of the Bill provides that such transfer may be obtained at an ordinary sitting of the District Court as well as at the annual sitting. The purpose of the amendment is to enable a seven-day licence to be transferred to premises to which a six-day or early-closing licence is attached, where the seven-day licensed premises or the six-day licensed premises are situate in the same or adjoining districts of the District Court. I think that this meets Deputy McGilligan's proposal.

Comment on this

It does.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In page 3, before Section 8, to insert a new section as follows:—

"Section 11 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the insertion in sub-section (1) after the words ‘six-day licence' where they occur in the said sub-section of the words ‘or a beer-house licence (as defined in Section 52 of the Finance (1909-10) Act, 1910, for the purposes of Part II of that Act).'".

The purpose of this amendment is to permit the transfer of a seven-day licence to a beer-house licensed premises. There are only a small number of beer-house licensed premises. The number licensed in the last licensing year was 153, while the total number of licensed premises in the State is 12,000 odd. The amendment would enable the holder of a beer-house licence to extinguish a seven-day licence and transfer it to his own premises if the courts had no objection.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The position regarding these beer-houses is that, if they have a six-day licence, they can do what is sought in this amendment, but if they have a seven-day licence they cannot. I think that that was an oversight in the 1927 Act, and I accept the principle of the amendment. The amendment will require to be redrafted.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

In page 3, before Section 8, to insert a new section as follows:—

"Section 11 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the insertion in sub-section (1) after the words ‘six-day licence' where they occur in the said sub-section of the words' or an off licence.'".

The purpose of this amendment is to enable an off-licence to be extinguished and an on-licence substituted in the same or in an adjoining area. In certain towns, owing to the building programme which has gone on for a number of years, slum areas have been cleared and the town has assumed a new aspect. The population has shifted to a particular area, and there may be one or two licences in the former areas which have become redundant, the licence-duty being paid in the hope that something will turn up. This amendment would permit the owner of an off-licence to buy out the interest of an on-licensee in the slum area and to apply to the court to transfer the on-licence to the off-licensed premises.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I cannot accept this amendment. The effect of it might be to enable a person with an off-licence to get an on-licence in an area where there were existing on-licences, which might be seriously affected by the transfer.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 9:—

In page 3, line 6, Section 8, to delete the words "annual licensing" and substitute the words "sitting of the justice of the".

This amendment is intended to enable a restaurant owner with a wine retailer's off-licence to apply for a restaurant certificate at any sitting of the District Court.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 10:—

In page 3, to delete all words from the word "by", line 23, to the end of the section, line 36, and substitute the following:—

(a) by the insertion in paragraph (a) of sub-section (1) before the words "on any week day" of the words "after the hour of six o'clock in the morning",

(b) by the insertion in sub-paragraph (i) of paragraph (b) before the words "on any week day" of the words "after the hour of six o'clock in the morning",

(c) by the deletion of sub-section (2).

This amendment is designed to give effect to the closing between midnight and 6 o'clock.

Comment on this

I think that there is something wrong with the wording. It is proposed to amend the 1927 Act by inserting before the words "on any week day" the words "after the hour of six o'clock in the morning". That means that, after 6 o'clock in the morning, the premises can be used for the purpose of the bona fide traffic. Until when?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Until the end of the day—12 o'clock.

Comment on this

I think that it would be better to put in the hour.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I thought so myself but the draftsman assured me that it was all right. If the hour had been 11 o'clock, it would have been necessary to put it in but, as it happens to be midnight, that is the end of the day and it is unnecessary to insert it.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean that on any week day bona fide traffic can be carried on from 6 o'clock in the morning until 12 midnight?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes.

Comment on this

This is a new form of drafting.

Comment on this

Assuming that I was acting for a publican who was prosecuted for a breach of the licensing laws, it would be an arguable submission that I could use my premises on any week day at any time after 6 a.m.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

So you could, but not before 6 a.m.

Comment on this

There is nothing to suggest that "day" has a recognised specific meaning. It is a period of 24 hours for the purpose of the licensing Acts.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The Interpretation Act defines it clearly.

Comment on this

It would be a simple matter to put in "midnight".

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I will examine it again, but I am told it is quite right.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 11:—

In page 3, before Section 12, to insert a new section as follows:—

Sub-section (5) of Section 15 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the deletion of the word "five" and the substitution in lieu thereof of the word "ten" and the deletion of the word "three" and the substitution in lieu thereof of the word "six".

Comment on this

Where did this come from?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

This and the following amendment were put down by Deputy. Dockrell and Deputy Kennedy. They were not my amendments. I said I had no objection to them. I thought that Deputy Dockrell was speaking for his own Party, but apparently he was not. I think, however, that it is hard to call a man a traveller if he only travels five miles. I admit that with modern transport the difference between five miles and ten miles is not a lot. I said I would put it down for the purpose of debate to see what support it would have in the House. I am not committed to it, but I should like to see it done myself. Deputy Lynch reminded us that in the country they still travel by ass and cart. He did not care, he said, what we did about the county boroughs, but in the country areas we should stick to the three miles. I do not know if there is anything more I can say with regard to it. But, if you are to call a man a traveller at all, I think a distance of five miles is ridiculous.

Comment on this

I think the Minister would be well advised to adopt the attitude he took up on another section and leave well enough alone. Whether Deputy Dockrell was speaking for himself or anybody else, so far as I am concerned, and I think other Deputies, there would be the most violent opposition to this, whether it came from Deputy Dockrell or from the Minister or anybody else. I think we would be inflicting another shocking injustice on the rural community if we compel them to travel any longer distance than they have to travel at present.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is with regard to the three miles. But what about the urban community? Suppose we leave the rural people as they are?

Comment on this

Anybody in a county borough at the moment has to travel five miles and in the rural districts three miles. The suggestion here is to double it in both cases. There may be something in the point about the county boroughs that the facilities for transport are different from those in the country districts. But in a country district there might be only two public houses within a radius of 12 miles, and there may not be any buses travelling on these roads. So far as the country is concerned, I am sure Deputy Lynch and every other rural Deputy will advise the Minister to leave well enough alone.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

So far as the rural areas are concerned, I would be strongly opposed to any suggestion to extend the present distance from three to six miles. It is all very well to talk about the improvement in travelling facilities; but actually in a great many parts of the country the travelling facilities now are the same as they were 50 years or 100 years ago. The ordinary vehicles by which small farmers in my constituency go to Mass are the same as they were when I was a child. They go on a horse and cart. Very few indeed have even risen to a pony and trap. Even bicycles are not anything like as common as you would find them in the neighbourhood of the cities and towns. Therefore, so far as rural areas are concerned, I would be very strongly opposed to the suggestion to increase the mileage from three to six miles.

I am not particularly interested in the boroughs, as it is undoubtedly a fact that the transport facilities in the neighbourhood of the boroughs are much greater than in the rural areas. You have a great service of buses plying from the boroughs, and perhaps a case could be made for extending the limit from five to ten miles.

However, I think the Minister would be well advised to leave well enough alone. After all, there are persons who presumably have invested sums of money in hotels within five, six, seven or eight miles of the boroughs on the basis that the existing mileage would stand. I am not speaking for any of these, but I can assume that there are such people. As a matter of fact, I can recall a case in the neighbourhood of Dublin where there was a hotel licence granted in recent years which I think would be cut out if the distance were extended to ten miles. I am not speaking for the hotel concerned because, as a matter of fact, when the application was before the courts I was briefed against it, but the hotel got its licence. I am referring to the new hotel at Portmarnock. It is a question of whether that would not be brought within this definition of ten miles. I think it would be hard lines on the proprietress if she found the money she had sunk in that concern very nearly gone owing to the loss of the bona fide trade from the city. However, I am not particularly concerned with the question of the distance from the boroughs. But I am very much concerned with the question of the distance in the rural areas. I am strongly opposed to the proposition that there should be an increase of the existing three miles. With regard to the boroughs, I think the Minister would be well-advised to leave the matter as it stands.

Comment on this
Andrew Fogarty Mr. P.J. Fogarty Fianna Fáil

I think the Minister would be well-advised to leave the existing mileage as it is, both in the county boroughs and the rural areas. Does the Minister realise what the position will be in the County Dublin and within ten miles of the other county boroughs? It means that the public houses cannot open as they do in the city to supply the local people and that they will not be allowed to carry on the bona fide business. The Minister might as well insert an amendment to close 200 public houses in the County of Dublin and as many more within ten miles of the other county boroughs. That is what it would amount to. I think the Minister's intention was to grapple with the bona fide business. In the summer time he has only left a difference of one hour between the city and the county, and in the winter time he has not left any difference at all. Therefore he has dealt with the abuses which were said to exist. I understood that was what was in the Minister's mind when introducing the Bill. If the distance is increased from five miles to ten miles, it will mean that all those traders who sunk money in the business cannot sell to local people and will be too near the city to do a bona fide trade.

Public houses in Clondalkin, for instance, are only seven miles from the city. They cannot let in the local people from Clondalkin and they cannot let in people from Dublin City. Therefore, they might as well shut down. The same applies to places like Portmarnock. This would apply to places nearly as far as Bray, as well as places like Tallaght, Saggart, etc. Then if the distance of three miles outside the boroughs is doubled, farmers and farm workers who go to Skerries or Malahide on a Sunday in the summer time in order to enjoy the only day they have off, will also be affected. At present if they live more than three miles from these places they can go and have a drink while their families are playing on the strand. Therefore, I think the Minister would be well-advised to leave the mileage as it is. Otherwise he would be doing a great injustice to traders in the neighbourhood of the four county boroughs. Therefore, I would appeal to him to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I am opposed to this, both with regard to the county boroughs and the rural areas. The case of the rural areas is obvious; nobody could defend this in my opinion. With regard to the urban areas, I do not think the authors of this realised the serious injury which it would inflict on people who have bought premises on the basis that the existing mileage would stand and paid a considerable amount of money for them, or, if the premises were not very good, spent an enormous amount of money on them for the purpose of that trade. You are striking at the rights of property and at the whole stability of property if you do a thing like that. I am putting it on that ground alone. It is not so much a question of whether the distance is five miles or ten miles; my serious objection is that people invested their hard-earned money, their savings or the savings of somebody else, and that by just changing a word in a sentence you are hitting at the stability of their property. It appears to me to be absolutely indefensible. You turn five into ten, and thereby you wipe out property worth tens of thousands of pounds. It is just the same as if you were to take a tin of petrol, put a match to it, and blow it up. It is from that aspect that I look upon the matter—that is, with regard to property around the county boroughs, the City of Dublin, and places like that.

With regard to the rural areas, I think that the people of rural Ireland are suffering enough at the moment without subjecting them to any more disabilities. These are the fellows who have to put hobnails on the soles of their shoes, and now you are adding another three miles on these people. Now, I hold that if a person goes that distance for a drink, he will make up his mind to make a perfect job of it and, having gone that distance, such people will simply sit there in the public house until they are sodden with drink, and if they have come on bicycles or have driven a horse and trap, they will not be fit to ride the bicycles or drive the horse when they leave. I do not hold with driving men to a point where they cannot readily get refreshments, and I say that, having had to travel such a distance for a drink, they will say to themselves: "Very well, we will get full now, and make a proper job of it." If they have to go six miles in a pony-cart or some such conveyance—there are no motor-cars now, of course—they will go into a hotel or public house, put up the pony and trap in the yard and say: "We will make an evening of it now and do this job right." We all know the dangers in the case of an intoxicated man driving a motorcar, but it is just as bad in the case of such a man driving a horse or a pony. If these people could get a drink conveniently, they would not get full of drink, and they would go back home. I think that if the distances were allowed to stand as at present, there would be no abuse.

So far as the county boroughs were concerned, I was trying to link up the closing time of the city public houses with the closing time in the county where these scenes were taking place, with a view to seeing that it would not be worth while for these people to go out there. My object was to cut that out by linking up the closing hours of the city public houses with the legal closing time for the bona fide traffic, so that it would not be worth their while to go out. This, however, is on quite a different plane, and while it is connected with the bona fide traffic, at the same time I think that this House would be doing a very serious injustice, and would be doing it unwillingly and unconsciously, if it were to agree to this. I think the Minister should not attempt to do it. I am really thinking of the value of property. I have no particular case in mind at all, but there must be plenty of such cases, and I hold that this would be committing a terrible injustice and would lead to the ruin of many people.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am prepared to drop this. Deputy Dockrell is not here, but I shall drop the amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 13:—

In page 3, before Section 12, to insert a new section as follows:—

Section 16 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended—

(a) by the insertion in sub-section (1) after the words "(not being or forming part of a county borough)" of the words "or by any holder of an on-licence (not being a six-day licence) attached to premises in such licensing area",

(b) by the deletion of the word "three" where that word occurs in the words "not exceeding in the whole three hours" and the substitution in lieu thereof of the word "four",

(c) by the addition at the end of the section of the following sub-section, that is to say:—

"(4) An area exemption order shall not be granted on the application of the holder of an on-licence unless—

(a) the applicant has, not less than 48 hours before making the application, served upon the officer in charge of the Gárda Síochána for the licensing area a notice of his intention to make the application, setting out his name and address and the area, day, and period or periods for which the order is required, and

(b) the justice of the District Court has heard such officer in relation to the application."

This is in accordance with a promise I made to arrange that a licence holder could apply for an exemption order. At present, the superintendent of the Garda Síochána must make the application, and this is to provide that a licence holder may make application. It also allows for an extension from three hours to four hours. I promised to bring this in, and I think it meets the case.

Comment on this

Yes, that is very reasonable.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 15:—

In page 3, before Section 13, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Section 25 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the insertion in sub-section (1) before the words "shall, if the person so convicted" of the words "if the court in its discretion so thinks proper."

(2) Every conviction which, immediately before the passing of this Act, stood recorded under Section 25 of the Act of 1927 on a licence then in force, shall, upon the passing of this Act, cease for all purposes to be so recorded.

This is the amendment giving full discretion to the justice in the matter of an endorsement. I think it meets the point. Of course, it will be understood that the justice's right of endorsement is still there, but he is given full discretion.

Comment on this

Yes, but I would draw the Minister's attention to one type of case. It is proposed to wipe out all endorsements existing at the passing of the Act, but there will be cases where an offence has been committed and a summons issued, but the case has not been determined at the date of the passing of the Act, and an endorsement could take place for an offence committed prior to the passing of the Act.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Well, I was asked to wipe the slate clean. I do not know how that would be interpreted. I daresay that this would apply only to existing endorsements, but perhaps the justice, in a case that was sub judice, would take the view that such a case would be on a par with an existing endorsement.

Comment on this

Even if the summons comes on afterwards, the justice will still have the discretion.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes, but I cannot go any further than that. I cannot have something wiped out that is not there.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, if the Minister were to suggest that he would wipe out summonses that had been issued prior to the passing of the Act, there might be a terrible lot of summonses before the courts within the next three months.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 16:—

In page 3, to delete lines 40 to 49 (Section 13), and substitute the following section:—

No order shall be made after the passing of this Act under Section 26 of the Act of 1927.

This is a consequential amendment.

Comment on this

I take it that this means that Section 26 is now being left in, but that no order can be made under it. As far as I understand, you are deleting your old Section 13 of this Bill which we are discussing——

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes.

Comment on this

——and instead of that, you are saying that after the passing of this Act no order shall be made under Section 26 of the 1927 Act.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 17:—

In page 3, before Section 14, to insert a new section as follows:—

Section 27 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the deletion of the words "if satisfied that by reason of extenuating circumstances (to be stated in the Order of the Court) such conviction ought not to be recorded on such licence make" and the substitution of the words "make, if in his discretion he so thinks proper".

This is also consequential. It gives discretion to the Circuit Court judges.

Comment on this

The net result is that the District Court has full discretion in the first instance and that the Circuit Court has full discretion in the case of an appeal.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dockrell to move amendment No. 18.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir. I move amendment No. 18:—

In page 5, before Section 17, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Where a person (in this section referred to as the applicant) duly gives notice of his intention to apply for a licence in respect of specified premises and, at the hearing before the Circuit Court the applicant shows to the satisfaction of the court—

(a) that he is the holder of a wine retailer's on-licence within the meaning of the Finance (1909-1910) Act, 1910, in respect of the said premises, and

(b) that the said premises are structurally adapted for use and are bona fide and mainly used as a restaurant, refreshment house, or other place for supplying substantial meals to the public, and

(c) that for a period of ten years at the least prior to the date of such application such a licence was attached to the said premises, or to premises substantially the same as the said premises, the court shall, notwithstanding anything contained in the Act of 1902, cause such certificate as is mentioned in Section 5 of the Act of 1833 to be given to the applicant declaring him to be duly entitled to receive a licence in respect of the said premises, unless the court, in consequence of an objection made under Section 4 of the Act of 1833 prohibits under that section the issuing of such licence on one or more of the following grounds, that is to say, the character, misconduct or unfitness of the applicant, or the unfitness or inconvenience of the said premises.

(2) Where in a case to which the foregoing sub-section applies the certificate referred to in that sub-section is given to the applicant, nothing contained in the Act of 1902 shall operate to prevent the grant to the applicant of the licence which the said certificate declares him to be entitled to receive.

(3) This section shall continue in force until the 31st day of December, 1944, and no longer unless the Oireachtas otherwise determines.

This amendment is designed to foster the restaurant business, and I think the Minister will agree that that is a section of the business which really ought to be encouraged. With that object in view, I put down this amendment, and perhaps the Minister would see his way to accept it.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I cannot accept this amendment. These wine retailers' licences are not got from the courts, but by application to the Revenue Commissioners. It would mean increasing the number of licences, and I am not prepared to accept it.

Comment on this

There might be objections from another point of view.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes, there would be many objections. In this case, these people were never holders of a full licence, and I am sure there would be strenuous objections from those in the district who had full licences. It would be giving a full licence to people who do not have an ordinary licence. I know that it is not easy to get light wines now, but that is only a temporary matter, whereas this measure is designed to be permanent. That would be giving a full licence to people who would have only an ordinary licence and there would be a great deal of objection on the part of people who already have a full licence.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not think that that is a section that ought to be encouraged? The supply of alcoholic refreshment with a full meal in a restaurant ought to be encouraged, and certainly the larger restaurants ought to have a full licence. I do not know how the Minister feels about it, but there is a certain number of people who go to restaurants and find they cannot get the refreshment that they could get in a fully licensed house. It is a very serious handicap to restaurants placed in that position. If the Minister sees another way of doing it, but would adopt that principle, I would be perfectly satisfied. It is not a question of wishing to do it in that way if any other way can be found, but I certainly think the Minister ought to encourage the restaurant business as far as possible.

Comment on this

Might I put this point to the Minister—it is a thing we have not stressed at all, and I am glad he mentioned what he did about restaurants? I do not quite agree with Deputy Dockrell that because you have a big restaurant it should have a complete licence, but I think the public houses that already have the licences should be put into the position—as they are in other countries—that they would cater more for the ordinary needs of the people, that is, when a man would go in for a bottle of stout he could get sandwiches or something else to eat with it.

Comment on this

Or lunch.

Comment on this

I would not go as far as that at the moment. I think that is one thing we really lack in this country. But I imagine there would be an uproar if the Minister were to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy Dockrell is a very conservative man, who is interested in property and in the rights of property, but there is this objection about the amendment, that it would enhance the value of the property of the owner of the restaurant, and to the extent that he sells drink you are depreciating the value of the property that is owned by the publican in the surrounding neighbourhood. That is the point. The publican may have invested a very considerable sum— £12,000 or £14,000—in a public house in the neighbourhood. To the extent that the full licence will increase the value of the restaurant, it will depreciate the value of the premises that were already bought on the assumption that in that particular area or district there would be nobody else allowed to sell drink. I think that consideration should appeal to Deputy Dockrell as a very conservative man, a man interested in the rights of property.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy press the amendment?

Comment on this

I do not wish to press the amendment, but I would ask the Minister does he see any hope of offering a solution in another way?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I must say I do not.

Comment on this
Mr. Flynn

I move amendment No. 19:—

In page 5, before Section 17, to insert a new section as follows:—

Notwithstanding anything contained in the Licensing (Ireland) Act, 1902, the holder of a six-day licence may apply at any annual licensing District Court, that in lieu of a certificate for the renewal of the six-day licence there be granted to him in respect of the said premises a certificate for a seven-day licence and the justice of the District Court, if he is satisfied that a certificate for the renewal of the six-day licence might have been granted, may, if he so thinks fit, grant to such applicant the certificate so applied for.

This amendment is of importance to traders in towns situated in my constituency, and I would ask the Minister seriously to consider the possibility of accepting the amendment. In several towns in my constituency—Cahirciveen, Killorglin, Kenmare and other centres in South Kerry, fairs are held and considerable trade is carried on on Sunday evening. People come in but they are debarred from access to licensed premises where a six-day licence obtains. The holder of the licence is debarred from allowing even his relatives or friends from entering the premises on that particular day. People come ten, 15 and 20 miles on the preceding evening to do business in the fair and they return on the following day. I think something should be done by way of adjustment so as to allow these people to obtain, on application to the District Court, a seven-day licence where it can be shown that the premises and business carried on justify such a licence being granted. There is another matter. The holder of a six-day licence cannot allow a lodger or person residing in the premises to bring in people to the premises on a Sunday. In my opinion, and in the opinion of people in the district generally, it is a matter that calls for adjustment. It is an injustice to these people. I cannot see why the Minister should not consider it. We have been informed that the attitude of his Department is that it is really a big matter that entails the revaluation of the premises and property, and all that, and that it is too big a question. It is a matter that, as one Deputy described it this evening, has been there from the dim past. It has existed as a result of the Act of 1902. I do not understand why there was ever such a differentiation between six-day licence holders and seven-day licence holders, or what the origin of it was. Whatever it was, I think we have reached the stage in this country when these people should at least get a chance to carry on their business on equal terms with people who were more fortunate in a bygone period in obtaining facilities. I put down this amendment not knowing very much about the law in the matter, but simply at the request of the people in my district. I know Deputy Fionan Lynch was interested in this matter. Deputy Kennedy has a similar amendment, and I think the Minister, if he can at all see his way, should meet us in the matter. I earnestly request him to do so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This amendment seeks certain concessions regarding holders of six-day licences. The next two amendments ask for somewhat similar concessions regarding holders of a six-day beer-house licence and off-licences. They might be discussed together, with separate decisions if desired.

Comment on this

I would like to support the amendment. About 11 years ago, in a midland town, a case came before the Circuit Court judge by way of application for a new licence. The gist of the application was to turn a six-day licence into a seven-day licence. The circuit judge gave the case a very patient hearing. He heard a considerable number of witnesses, and came to the conclusion, on the facts, that the holders of such licences in that town were entitled to a seven-day licence. He made two Orders to that effect. Subsequently, the two Orders made were brought, by way of certiorari, before the High Court and quashed, the High Court holding that they were made without jurisdiction. It seems to me that this is something which is out of date in our legal code. There is no reason why the holder of a six-day licence should not have it turned into a seven-day licence, if the appropriate court thinks it fit to so order. I understand that is the object of the section, and I support it.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liomsa cuidiú leis an leasú seo. Níl aon chiall leis an dlí mar atá sé. Is féidir le duine go bhfuil ceadúnas teoranta aige cur isteach ar cheadúnas seacht lá fháil ar iarratas, ach tá cosc fén dlí ar dhuine go bhfuil ceadúnas sé lá aige ceadúnas seacht lá do lorg.

Ní thuigim sin. Ní doigh liom go bhfuil brí nó ciall leis sin, agus molaim don Aire glacadh leis an leasú. Níl san leasú ach go mbeidh cead—sin a bhfuil ann — ag duine go bhfuil ceadúnas sé lá aige cur isteach ar cheadúnas seacht lá. Sin rud beag im' thuairim-se agus molaim don Aire glacadh leis. Ní dlí é—ach ceart do thabhairt do dhuine.

Comment on this

In connection with amendment No. 20, there are 153 beer-house licences in the State. The object of my amendment is to put them on the same basis as the 10,000 publicans who have full licences. A number of holders of beer-house licences, before the establishment of this State and since, have gone into one court after another and have been precluded, by the law as it stands, from getting the spirit licence which would give them a full publican's licence. The proposal is to extend the spirit licence to 153 citizens who have a good business and are prevented by law from selling spirits. If a number of individuals in this State decide to start a club, let it be a sports club or any other kind of club, and there is in regard to it no licence in existence, they can go into court and, on satisfying the judge, get a licence for the sale of beer, wine and spirits. But here are 153 individuals, born into the trade and living by it, who are carrying on their trade under this severe handicap. The Minister has already given concessions in regard to some bigger things. We want him to grant this concession to the 153 owners of beer houses who, in some places, are doing the principal trade there.

Amendment No. 21 deals with off-licences. I want to be quite frank and to say that I had only one case in mind when I introduced the amendment. A town in the Midlands with a population of 5,000 is divided by a river. Approximately half the population lives on one side of the river, the other half living on the opposite side. It has about 50 public houses on one side of the river. On the opposite side, there is a house with an off-licence. Some of those 50 public houses on one side of the river are doing practically no trade. I think that the man on the opposite side with the off-licence, in a part of the town where the population has grown up around him, should be entitled to get an on-licence. That is the meaning of amendment No. 21. As regards the owners of the 153 beer houses, I ask the Department to examine their trade in detail and to take an unbiased view of their position. The case of a man in Howth who had a beer-house licence—he is doing the best business in Howth—was fought in the courts. He failed to get a full licence. In the end, he had to build a hotel beside his licensed premises and get a hotel licence in order to get over his particular difficulty. Tributes have been paid to the Minister and bouquets have been thrown at him. I want him to do the fair thing in regard to the 153 individuals I have referred to.

Comment on this

I want to put before the Minister, and those who are putting forward the amendments before the House, a suggestion which was made to me by a publican. It was this: that anybody with suitable premises who wanted a seven-day licence should be entitled to get it provided he was prepared to pay an extra licence duty. This man held that the present holders of seven-day licences might have a grievance if newcomers were given a seven-day licence freely, since that would mean increased competition for them. He said they would have no grievance if the newcomers were obliged to pay an extra licence duty. That might get over the present difficulty. The granting of the new seven-day licences might be left to the discretion of the district justices.

Comment on this

I think Deputy McGovern's point is already met, because I think the historical reason for the six-day and seven-day licence is not all those shocking anomalies at all; it is because certain people, when originally applying for a licence, took the cheapest licence.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is right.

Comment on this

Under any circumstances, I do not think the Minister could agree to amendment No. 21. There may be a very hard case in a particular town, but has not the Minister already provided that, if a person across the river has a licence and is not doing any trade, and the bulk of the population has slipped over to the other side of the river, he can now go in there. In present circumstances, I do not think there is any case for giving on-licences to people who have off-licences. I do not know anything about beer houses. That is not a problem in the south, certainly not as far as Cork is concerned. There are one or two six-day licences there, and if those people were given seven-day licences I do not think it would hurt anybody; the Minister would not be giving away very much by giving the extra day. As I have said, I have no interest in, and no information on, the question of beer houses, but I think that, as far as the few six-day licence holders are concerned, it would not hurt anybody if they were given seven-day licences.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

There are 1,758 six-day licence holders in the country, and I think I have heard the view expressed during the progress of this Bill that there were too many on-licences in the country. As Deputy Linehan has mentioned, we have already made it easier for people to transfer; we have en larged the district in which they car get the existing licence. I think that is good enough. I would not be prepared to go any further. Deputy Flynn did not know how those licences originated. It was quite voluntary, as Deputy Linehan said. Either at the time they got the licence or subsequently, they decided to go for the six-day licence and pay the smaller fee. Once they had done that, they could not get back to the seven-day licence. Everyone knows that there are too many licence already, and, as I say, the facilities are already there to change a six-day licence into a seven-day licence by transferring a seven-day licence to the premises.

Comment on this

I am afraid that what the Minister has suggested as an alter native would not meet the case raised by Deputy Flynn, that is, the power to extinguish the existing licences and get a new seven-day licence. Like Deputy Flynn, I have got a communi cation in connection with certain of those houses, and I immediately raised the point which I think was made by Deputy McGovern. I pointed out to my correspondent that there was an other side to the question; that the existing seven-day licence holders in the town of Cahirciveen might have something to say to it; that many of those people may have purchased their premises within the last 40 years, since the 1902 Act was passed, and undoubtedly they bought them having regard to the existing conditions of competition for the Sunday trade. At the same time, the proposal in Deputy Flynn's amendment does not give the six-day licence holder a seven-day licence on payment of the seven-day licence fee. It merely empowers him to apply to the district justice. Now, I do not think there can be any great case made against that. If the existing seven-day licence holders object, they can come before the district justice when the application is being heard and oppose the granting of any further seven-day licences in the area. Personally, I think this is a small matter; it affects very few, and they are mostly small people who would not be in a position to do what the Minister has suggested about extinguishing the licence and applying for another. They are not that type of person; financially, they are not in a position to do anything of that kind. I think the Minister might consider—if not now, between this and the time the Bill reaches the Seanad—the question as to whether or not they should not be given the right to make their case before the district justice, who would then refuse or grant the licence as he saw fit.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think it is better to leave it as it is, and try if possible to reduce the number of on-licences rather than increase them. I would not reconsider the matter. In Cahirciveen, for instance, no one will say that there are not enough public houses. I do not think either Deputy Flynn or Deputy Lynch can say that.

Comment on this

There are other towns affected as well as Cahirciveen. Will not the Minister admit that there is an injustice, an inequality, as between those people and their competitors?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

They opted for it in the beginning; it was their own choice. They opted for six-day licences.

Comment on this

I do not think we can accept that as being general. There were many cases where—perhaps because of a pussyfoot element on the bench of magistrates—the seven-day licence was refused, and the applicants had no alternative but to accept a six-day licence. As Deputy Linehan has said, a great many of them may have applied for a six-day licence originally in order to pay a smaller licence fee, but there is no doubt that a great many of the existing six-day licence holders are persons who applied for seven-day licences and did not get them.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am told that the justice could not do that; he could not impose a six-day licence instead of a seven-day licence.

Comment on this

I want to point out to the Minister that those are not isolated cases; in every town in our district we have at least half-a-dozen of those people. A very reasonable suggestion has been put forward by Deputy Lynch —that those people should be allowed to make their case before the district justice, who would also hear any objections put forward by competitors in the trade. The Minister informs us that this opens up a very important matter, but I do not see why the Minister should not accede to our request, seeing that he has given way in regard to concessions as far as Dublin and other big centres are concerned. I think all sides of the House are agreed that a case has been made for those people.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom do chur in a luighe ar an Aire nach bhfuilim sásta. Iarraim go mbéadh cead do chur isteach ar cheadúnas seacht lá, agus rud beag é sin. Níl an cead sin fé láthair ag lucht cheadúnais sé lá. Táimíd ag iarradh san leasú seo go mbéadh cead ag duine le ceadúnas sé lá do chur isteach ar cheadúnas seacht lá.

Comment on this

If the Minister gave Sunday opening in rural Ireland, this would be a much more important question.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 22:—

In page 5, lines 35 and 36, Section 17 (1), to delete the words "hearing before the Circuit Court of objections" and substitute the words "proceedings in the Circuit Court in relation".

This has relation to a point raised by Deputy Costello with regard to an objection being made, and we have altered the wording to "proceedings in the Circuit Court in relation" to any such application. The amendment will cover the point that was raised.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 23:—

In page 5 to delete lines 42 to 44, Section 17 (1) (b), and substitute the following paragraph:—

(b) that, in respect of the licensing year including the 1st day of January, 1933, a renewal of a licence attached to the said premises or to premises substantially the same as the said premises was in fact issued, and".

This covers any point that might be raised about the validity of the licence that was granted.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 24:—

In page 6, lines 14 and 15, Section 18 (1), to delete the words "hearing before the Circuit Court of objections" and substitute the words "proceedings in the Circuit Court in relation".

This is purely a drafting amendment, similar to amendment No. 22.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

As regards amendments Nos. 25, 26, 27 and 28, I am not quite happy about the way in which they are drafted. I should like to have them redrafted, and they will be submitted again on the formal Report Stage.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 29:—

In page 7, lines 19 and 20, Section 19 (1), to delete the words "hearing before the Circuit Court of objections" and substitute the words "proceedings in the Circuit Court in relation".

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I move amendment No. 30:—

In page 7, Section 19 (1), to insert before paragraph (d) a new paragraph as follows:—

(d) that no certificate under Section 5 of the Act of 1833 has already been given by virtue of this section by reference to the original premises having been so burnt down or otherwise destroyed or rendered uninhabitable, and,

This is also a drafting amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I could not accept amendment No. 31, in the name of Deputy Costello. I told Deputy Costello so, and probably that is the reason why he is not moving it.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Costello, I move amendment No. 33:—

In page 8, before Section 20, but in Part III of the Bill, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Where—

(a) by reason of the discontinuance of the business carried on in any premises an off-licence attached to such premises is extinguished or surrendered, and

(b) the goodwill of the business formerly carried on in the said premises has for valuable consideration been acquired by or on behalf of any person who was in the employment of the owner of the said business prior to its discontinuance, and

(c) such person is carrying on a business similar or analogous to the same business in premises (hereinafter referred to as "the adjoining premises") adjoining or in the immediate vicinity of the premises to which the licence so extinguished or surrendered was attached,

the justice at any sitting of the District Court shall, notwithstanding anything contained in the Act of 1902 have power to grant an off-licence for the adjoining premises unless the justice refuses to issue such licence on one or more of the following grounds, namely, the character, misconduct or unfitness of the applicant or the unfitness or inconvenience of the premises.

(2) This section shall continue in force until the 31st day of December, 1944, and no longer unless the Oireachtas otherwise determines.

This amendment is meant to deal with an individual case, the case in Dame Street. Has the Minister any objection to it?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I have an objection. In the other case, the Clery case, there was a licence in existence and it was allowed to lapse. In this case, the premises were disposed of, the people actually in the business went out and people who were engaged there took over the premises next door, which never had a licence. If they sold the other premises as a going concern there would have been no objection and the incoming people could have got a renewal of the licence. This is an entirely new premises, and I see all sorts of objections to the granting of a licence.

Comment on this

It is for one case only.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

There is really no merit that I can see in this proposal. I admit I have dealt with an individual case in this Bill, but there was much more merit in that case. In this case, the whole premises have gone and they are to be devoted to a different purpose altogether, a drapery establishment as distinct from a grocery establishment.

Comment on this

I understand the situation is that there was an old-established firm there who had an off-licence. They carried on other business as well. These people suddenly decided, without giving anybody a chance to arrange to take the whole premises, to sell out, and before these other people could get a group to buy over the whole premises, the sale was accomplished. Then some of the people employed in the previous business in Dame Street took over the place next door. They are not financially strong enough to go into the old line of business, but they propose to carry on as much of it as their resources will enable them to do. They ask for a transfer of the off-licence. If they were seeking an on-licence I can imagine it would be a much more serious proposition.

I might point out that these people are going to give employment to quite a big proportion of the folk who were previously employed in the main establishment and they want a transfer of the off-licence. The Minister will observe that the circumstances are very severely limited by the terms of Deputy Costello's amendment and the same situation will hardly ever arise again in the period specified in the amendment. It will also be noted that the goodwill of the business has to be taken over by some person in the employment of the previous business prior to its discontinuance.

At the moment such a person is carrying on a business similar or analogous to the original business. It would not affect a man opening the adjoining premises and carrying on a drapery business; he has to be in a business similar or analogous to the old business. The whole thing is very limited. If the licence transfer is not granted, there will be relatively great hardship arising. These people felt that they would get the transfer and now they are going to be faced with the usual difficulties.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Of course this would mean granting a new off-licence. I see a difficulty there and I am sorry I cannot consent to what is proposed. I do not see how I could. In the other case a restaurant business was being carried on and the licence lapsed for a number of years.

Comment on this

I am not saying that there is an analogy.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am merely trying to justify myself in bringing in the other case. I would like to meet individual cases as far as I could and I have given this case sympathetic consideration, but I find it would be impossible to do what has been suggested.

Comment on this

As the Minister is no doubt aware, a new off-licence cannot be achieved. The objection based on the number of premises in the neighbourhood would prevent that.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I move amendment No. 34:—

In page 8, before Section 20, but in Part III, to insert a new section as follows:—

Section 3 of the Act of 1902 is hereby amended by the insertion after the words "for consumption on" of the words "or off".

Section 3 of the Act of 1902 says: "Where, by reason of the expiration of a lease, a licence for the sale of intoxicating liquors for consumption on the premises comprised in the lease is extinguished or surrendered, the licensing authority may, notwithstanding anything in this Act, grant a licence for a suitable premises in the immediate vicinity of the premises to which the licence so extinguished or surrendered was attached."

I do not intend to take up much time in advancing arguments in favour of the amendment. It speaks for itself. I am satisfied that had there been an organised body or association of off-licence holders in existence in 1902, no amendment would now be necessary. I should like to ask the Minister whether he intends at an early date to introduce legislation releasing certain family grocers from what many of them regard as penal clauses, and whether he will give the same concessions to off-licence holders as he has given to on-licence holders. An off-licence holder at present may find himself deprived of his licence and of his livelihood without any right of appeal and nothing has been brought into this Bill to safeguard him. It is not necessary to stress the matter. I urge the Minister to accept the amendment, but if he can suggest an alternative which would be acceptable to him, I am in his hands, provided it achieves my object, that is, full protection for the family grocer, and that if there are two convictions, they might be removed and the family grocer given a fresh start.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The Deputy is now on a different amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Sub-section (2) of Section 25 of the 1927 Act gave a life of five years to the first endorsement and——

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Would the Deputy confine himself to one amendment? We can deal with the other afterwards. It is rather difficult to deal with the two together. I have no objection to the Deputy moving his previous amendment, but I should like to deal with one at a time.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are dealing with amendment No. 34 and with no other.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

This is the first amendment which has come up for discussion in connection with off-licence holders, and I ask the Minister to consider the point I have made. I left the House for five minutes, during which time the Minister was allowed to rush seven amendments through, with the result that I was caught napping. If the Chair would give me the privilege of moving my previous amendment, which I failed to move in those circumstances, I should be very happy.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We cannot discuss that matter now.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I quite agree, but the Minister very graciously said that, with the permission of the House, he had no objection to my dealing with it. On the general question of family grocers and endorsement of their licences, I merely ask that the same concessions be given to them as have very properly been given to licensed traders.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I do not think the amendment is necessary. Under the Landlord and Tenant Act, the holder would probably be entitled to a new lease, but, to make sure, I will accept the amendment. There is no reason why an off-licence holder should not get the same facilities as an on-licence holder.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Might I ask if the Minister had anything special to say on my previous amendment?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We cannot discuss that amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

The matter could arise on this section.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

There was no discussion on it because it has been marked "not moved", and the House cannot go back on it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38:—

In page 11, before Section 26, but in Part V of the Bill, to insert a new section as follows:—

"Nothing in the Licensing (Ireland) Acts, 1833 to 1927, or in this Act, shall be deemed to prohibit any licensed person or his private friends from gaming by way of playing cards for stakes on licensed premises provided that such gaming is carried on in any part of such licensed premises other than the part in which the sale of intoxicating liquor generally takes place and the private friends of the licensed person are being bona fide entertained by him at his own expense.”

This is a matter to which I want to call attention. One of the Acts scheduled to the 1927 Act was the Licensing Act, 1872, Section 17, and the result of that section being scheduled is that if a person commits an offence against one of these enactments, there has to be an endorsement. Section 17 of the Licensing Act of 1872 simply says: "Permitting gaming on licensed premises" Gaming has been the subject of definition in quite a number of Acts, but it is not quite clear which of the definitions is strictly brought into the 1872 Act. There is a particular definition which means playing at any game where money passes, and the situation is that if a publican has friends on his premises and they are engaged in such an ordinary innocent matter as a game of bridge, so long as there are stakes on the game, the publican, if he is caught, may be prosecuted for permitting gaming on the premises. It is clearly not intended to cover any such thing as that. The amendment proposes to meet the position by tying it down very strictly and narrowly by saying that nothing in the earlier Acts shall be deemed to prevent a licensed person or his private friends from gaming by way of playing cards for stakes on licensed premises, provided that such gaming is carried on in what might be described as the private part of the establishment and that the private friends are being bona fide entertained by him at his own expense. I do not think there is anything wrong with the amendment, and I do not know whether the Minister feels that it is putting up a barrier against something which is not going to happen.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am afraid it might be used as a sort of cloak. There has been no complaint of any hardship, so far as I know. The provision has not been carried out very strictly, and I have never got any complaints about it. There is the danger, however, that if we take the provision out of the licensing code, it may help people to evade the law.

Comment on this

Look at the situation that has to be met to get an exclusion. The publican must have people who are his private friends; they must be in the private part of the establishment; and if they are not playing an inhospitable game, the phrase is that they are being entertained bona fide at the publican's expense. All these provisos will cover the ordinary game of cards which a publican ought to be allowed to have.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That has never been interfered with.

Comment on this

No, but the difficulty is that I know cases of suspicious circumstances, so to speak, of people not adverting to the gaming aspect at all whose premises were entered and to whom the police have expressed themselves to the effect that "In the end, you were gaming on licensed premises". That was the threat held out. I can realise very well what the old Acts meant. These old Acts were drafted in a frame of mind which I think is not at all the modern frame of mind, that is, that a publican was a sort of outcast who was not to be allowed to do things which the ordinary person could do, with the result that they prevented a variety of things happening on licensed premises, one of them being gaming, because it was suggested that, if it were allowed, those taking part would make merry and there would be general debauchery. Look at the amendment: A publican entertaining his friends and having a game of cards in the private part of the establishment. I do not think that will ever make much of a gap in the Act.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Take the case of a bridge drive in the Gresham Hotel. Strictly speaking, that is not legal either because it is a licensed premises, and the bridge drive is gaming. I suppose that should be regularised just as much as this. My only objection is the one I have mentioned. I do not think people ought to be penalised in that fashion, but I should not like the amendment to be used as a cloak for evasion or that people should be able to put a deck of cards on the table and say they were friends of the publican. Suppose there was a raid on a premises, and the people there went up and got out a deck of cards, and evaded the law in that way?

Comment on this

The publican need not do that. If he is entertaining friends in a private part of the premises that is not an offence against the liquor laws. Why should he make an extra camouflage with a pack of cards?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I would not agree to putting it into the Bill if it created any great gap in the licensing laws.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 39:—

In page 11, before Section 26, but in Part V of the Bill, to insert a new section as follows:—

Nothing in this Act shall operate to prohibit or render unlawful the serving of intoxicating liquor at any time in premises which are for the time being an hotel, to persons accompanying a person then lodging in such premises providing that such intoxicating liquor is ordered and paid for by the person so lodging in the hotel.

I put down this amendment having regard to the general attitude towards this question. At present if a person calls to see a friend at an hotel there is difficulty about asking him to have a drink. Of course the host may have a bottle in his room, or he may order a bottle to be brought there, but I am desperately opposed to bottles being brought into these rooms. I much prefer that they should openly have a drink where they are having dinner or lunch, whether the drink be a glass of wine or a glass of whiskey. I abhor the idea of driving people to bedrooms where they can drink out of bottles, whether it occurs in hotels or motor cars. That is a vicious practice. I do not see any reason why two respectable citizens, one of whom is staying in an hotel, cannot meet and, if necessary, transact some business and then have a drink. I do not think any abuse can arise from that. It may be said that it could by people with vicious minds who suspect everything. I am speaking of a well-conducted hotel, and I suggest that it would be better to authorise what I propose rather than have back-stairs methods and have bottles brought to bedrooms. I tried to put my proposal in such a way that nobody would be afraid of doing anything that was not within the licensing laws. As Deputy McGilligan pointed out, conditions have changed enormously in recent years.

There is a variety of other attractions besides drinking, such as picture houses, etc. Hotels are now subsidised by the State and they will have a direct interest in seeing that their character and reputation are raised. I put down the amendment to prevent abuse and the Minister would be wise to accept it.

Comment on this

The amendment is merely asking us to recognise what was generally thought to be the law for a number of years. As far as I am aware, everyone was under the impression up to the decision in the High Court by Mr. Justice Hanna, in the case of the Attorney-General v. Carroll, that a permanent resident in an hotel was entitled to invite in a friend. That was the generally accepted view up to that period. The decision in the case of the Attorney-General v. Carroll then upset the applecart and gave rise to a number of vexatious and silly prosecutions. The amendment asks us to assume what everyone recognised was the law of the land, not only in connection with hotels but ordinary public houses, into which a cattle dealer who stayed there the night before a fair could invite a friend. The amendment is a reasonable one and the Minister might accept it.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Acceptance of the amendment would do a great deal to clarify the present position. There are people who believe that as the law stands they have the right to do this. It seems sensible to believe that if a man is resident in a hotel that is his dwelling for the time being. There is no reason why during his period of residence there he should not have the same rights as if he were in his own home. If a friend called he should be entitled to ask him to have a drink. That was accepted as the law until recent years. The Minister should clarify the position by accepting the amendment or, if the drafting is not satisfactory, bringing in one of a similar nature.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think the licensing laws could not be enforced at all if the amendment were accepted in regard to hotels. There is no question about that. People could go into them and the bars would be open. Everybody in the town could be there. We know that there are parts of the country where that was done and where there was no such thing as a closing hour. I think Deputy Lynch is aware of that in one part of the country. The police would not be able to enforce the licensing laws in hotels if the amendment were agreed to. I could not accept it.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister but I want to call his attention to another matter which was mentioned to me recently. Take the position of a licensed hotel in which there is a surplus of visitors who are sent to other premises where no food is cooked. These people sleep on one premises, say, on Saturday night, but they have to return to the hotel on Sunday for meals. It appears that they are not entitled to be on the hotel premises. That is a position that the Minister might look into. Some officers of the Gárda mentioned it to me. At seaside places there will be great difficulty in administering the law on Sundays if conditions of that kind are not provided for.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

If it could be confined to genuine cases there would be no trouble about it. That is the difficulty. It could not be. We are aware of that. I admit that if this could be confined to friends genuinely living in a hotel it would be reasonable. I am well aware that it would not be confined to them.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not admit that, until the decision in the case of the Attorney-General v. Carroll, that position was accepted by the police and by everybody else as being the law of the land? Until then a number of Circuit judges on appeal held that if a person was resident on licensed premises, and wanted a drink, he could have it on paying for it.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

When Deputies speak about a hotel being a man's home, I imagine that they have in mind the part in which he is living, or the room he is occupying. If he brought drink there and had it in his room there would not be much objection. That would be the law at present.

Comment on this

He cannot. That is the difficulty now.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

In his own room?

Comment on this

Since the decision in the Carroll case he cannot do it. Would the Minister consider that point?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I would be prepared to go that far, if it is confined to the part of the house which he occupies, but that would not apply to general drinking in the bar. I shall see to that.

Comment on this

The Minister can hedge it round with as many regulations as he likes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:—

In page 11, before Section 26, but in Part V of the Bill, to insert a new section as follows:—

"Paragraph E of the First Schedule to the Finance (1909-10) Act, 1910, is hereby amended by the deletion of Provision 2 and the substitution in lieu thereof of the following provision, that is to say:—

‘2. A railway restaurant car licence, granted in respect of a car in which passengers can be supplied with meals, authorises the sale by retail to passengers of any intoxicating liquor for consumption on the car and in any compartment of a train to which a car so licensed is attached'."

This is really a very small matter. It came to the notice of certain people that while the restaurant car attached to a train is licensed, it might be an offence for the waiter to bring a drink to a person sitting in a carriage attached to the restaurant car. Apparently the licence will not cover the whole train, and if a person sent up to the restaurant car for a drink, the waiter would be committing an offence if he brought it to him.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think the Deputy should not press that amendment. If a person wants a drink on a train, it is not far to go down to the restaurant car. Passengers might object if drinking were carried on in other parts of the train.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, the reason I move the amendment at all is to meet a very obvious case. In 90 per cent. of cases a person who wants a drink will go down to the restaurant car, because it is much more comfortable, but occasionally you find people travelling who are not in good health or who are very old. I think it is unreasonable that they should be obliged to go to the restaurant car.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I can see people occupying carriages where drink would be consumed objecting to that. I do not think it would be right to allow it.

Comment on this

It would make the whole train into a public house.

Comment on this

The railway company will take care of that. The railway company would have to face this difficulty, and they could not allow drink to be consumed generally in the carriages, because there would be objections to it. There is, however, the odd case of people whom the railway company would like to serve and they do not think that it will be very difficult to meet any objections that might be made. They feel that the legal impediment is there, that the restaurant car only is licensed. The Minister himself knows that scenes that occur on a train are not caused by people who get drink on the train, but by people who bring drink with them into the train.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I know that, but I could not agree to this amendment. In any case, it would mean an amendment of the Finance Act.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 41, in the name of Deputy Cogan, has been ruled out of order. The Deputy has been so informed.

Comment on this

I have not been informed. I am sorry I was not in the House when the matter was raised.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy cannot speak to the amendment when it is out of order.

Comment on this

Have any grounds been given for ruling it out of order?

Comment on this

I do not think it is any more drastic than any of the amendments that have been accepted.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Is there any woman or girl who will admit she is over 25?

Comment on this

Will the Minister bring in an amendment to cover the point about hotels?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I shall.

Comment on this