Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account (No. 2), 1943-44 (Resumed).
Contributions 1–174 of 499. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
When speaking on this matter last night, I called the attention of the House to the fact that agricultural wages under the régime of the Fine Gael Government were somewhere between 7/- and 9/- per week, that the minimum wages at present are 36/- per week, and that the farmers are better able to pay that 36/- to-day than they were able to pay the 7/- or 9/ during Deputy Cosgrave's régime. I invite the representatives of the agricultural community here to say whether they wish to go back to the period when the value laid on their work by the then Government was from 7/- to 9/- per week, the value not alone of their employees' work, but the value of the work of the farmers themselves, for every farmer worth his salt in this country works on the land. I want to know whether they are prepared to go back to that.
We had a lot of statistics here last night. I am sorry Deputy Davin is not here now because those statistics are rather interesting. I have here the trade statistics for the years 1924, 1925, 1927, and 1932. They are rather interesting, in fact very interesting. For instance, in 1925 we exported 300,000 fewer cattle than in 1924 and we got for these cattle £5,000,000 less than in 1924. We exported 182,000 fewer sheep in 1925 than in 1924, and we got £500,000 less for them. We exported 13,000 fewer pigs and we got £550,000 less for them. We exported 220,000 less cwts. of bacon and we got £420,000 less in respect of that commodity. We exported 66,000 cwts. less butter in that year than in 1924 and we got £400,000 less than in the previous year. The total difference between what we got in 1925 and the amount we received in 1924 was £7,000,000 odd—a drop of £7,000,000 in the income in respect of agriculture for one year. The drop continued still further in 1927. In 1927, we got a further £2,000,000 less than we got in 1925.
We come on to a later period. We hear the Party opposite talk about production and still more production. That is all right; it is the finest policy in the world for the agricultural community so long as they can get a market for their products. That is what our Minister for Agriculture aimed at. He aimed at having a market here at home for wheat, beet, and every other crop that we can produce, the price fixed to have some relation to the labour the farmer expends on his land. I shall give you an instance of how those things worked out. In 1929, we exported 774,000 head of cattle and we got £13,000,000 for them. In 1931 we exported the same number of cattle and we got £8,700,000 for them. Although the farmer had the same trouble in rearing calves and in feeding cattle, he got £5,000,000 less in 1931 than in 1929. He could kick up any row he liked in the Dáil about the price, but he had to take what he got. As regards sheep, he exported 211,000 sheep in 1929 and 240,000 in 1931, and for these sheep he got £542,000 in 1929, and £284,000 in 1931. He got £2 11s. per head for his sheep in 1929, and for similar sheep he got only £1 9s. per head in 1931. These are figures I want Deputies to think over. I now turn to the fat pig. The farmer got £7 6s. per head in 1929 and for a pig of the same weight in 1932, he got £4 4s. He got £1,866,000 for fat pigs in 1929, and £804,000 for the same number of pigs in 1932. Those are the facts. They are rather stubborn. They show what happened. We shall pursue the matter a little further.
Comment on this
Take the item of butter. In 1929, the farmers received 164/10 per cwt., and in 1932, 95/- per cwt.—a drop of roughly 50 per cent., so that the farmer in 1932 would have to produce 2 lbs. butter to get the same amount of money into his exchequer as he got in 1929 for 1 lb. That was the position under the policy of those gentlemen opposite. I have gone through the whole of the items, live stock and butter. The income from eggs exported shows a decrease of similar proportions. In the four years from 1929, there was a drop every year in the income from these exports. That is why our Minister for Agriculture decided that the farmers should have something to fall back upon in their own country, that they should have some market that could be controlled here at home, and in which the price of their produce could be fixed here at home. If the farmer was not getting enough, at least he had some redress.
That is the difference between our agricultural policy and the agricultural policy of the Party opposite. Those books can be got by new Deputies in the library, and they can examine them themselves. That is actually why I am at one with the Minister for Agriculture in his present policy as regards agriculture. We do not agree, and we never would agree, that we are getting enough. Sometimes the agricultural community look for too much—I say that honestly here. Sometimes the Minister does not give enough. The year before last the Minister did not give a sufficient price for beet, with the result that the acreage needed was not grown. Last year we endeavoured to force the pace a bit by demanding 90/- a ton for our beet. We fought for that and the Minister for Agriculture and the sugar company decided on paying 80/-. Whilst the Beet Growers' Association were still fighting the sugar company on the price, the farmers of this country, wiser apparently than the Beet Growers' Association, signed contracts with the sugar company for 52,000 acres at 80/- per ton, the price the Minister decided on paying, proving, to my mind, that we had looked for too much, and that we had overstated our demands. Those are rather striking facts, but they bring the matter home to us.
Last year I dealt with one particular question of the Minister's programme because in my opinion he could afford to allow the farmers to get a fair price for malting barley. I would like to take the Minister's mind back for a few years, back to the last war, when the price of malting barley in this country was 52/- a barrel, and when the duty on the pint of stout was practically the same as it is at present, and the price of the pint of stout was practically the same also. During the bad years afterwards when a Government was in office in this country which had no respect for the working farmer, the price of farmers' barley was allowed to drop until in 1931 and 1932 farmers were getting only 13/- a barrel for barley and were fighting for the market. They delivered the barley to the brewer and they did not know what the price was going to be. They were glad to get it into the brewers' store and to wait for three months until the brewer announced his price of 13/- a barrel for Irish barley. During those years the price of stout remained it the old figure despite the fact that the brewer had the difference between 13/- and 52/- to put in his pocket. The duty on the stout was the same and the brewer got that extra profit. I ask the Minister now here in the House to give us our chance, to give the agricultural community of this country who grow barley and who had to grow it at 13/- a barrel when the brewer was still fattening his pockets with the extra sweat of the farmers, to give them a chance now and let them deal on the principle of supply and demand with the brewers of this country. Let us get our price.
The brewers of this country are brewing stout for export purposes. The price of barley in Britain is roughly 70/- a barrel. The brewers want to buy our barley at 30/- to 35/- a barrel, and they are going to have for their own pockets the difference between those prices and the 70/- which they have to pay the Englishman for his barley. In my personal opinion, and I think I may speak for 100 per cent. of the farmers who grow barley, that is a market which should be left open. Let us deal with the brewer, and let us extract some of the ill-gotten gains he shoved into his pocket during the years he had a Fine Gael Government to protect him.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton can speak in his turn. I am speaking here for the farmer, and I am pleading for him. Deputy Norton can look after his own industrialists, but I have stated a position which cannot be denied in this House or anywhere else. I will now go into another matter which, in my opinion, deserves the Minister's attention. I think the question of seeds, small seeds in particular, mangold seed, turnip seed, rape seed and kale, should be examined. Those seeds were previously imported from Britain, and I have here the figures giving the cost of seed when imported and the price the farmer had to pay for it.
In 1938 we imported 10,765 cwts. of mangold seed at a cost, landed here, of £22,685. The farmer paid £90,396 for that mangold seed—four times what it cost. We imported 6,972 cwts. of turnip seed at a cost, landed here, of £21,689, and the farmers had to pay £52,057 for that. We imported 405 cwts. of cabbage seed at a cost, landed here, of £3,938, and the farmer had to pay £15,752. We imported kale seed, rape seed, carrot seed, etc., to the extent, of 2,586 cwts., at a cost landed here of £8,147. The farmers paid £32,588 for them. The total of the seeds imported cost £56,459, landed here, and the farmers paid £190,793 for them.
Comment on this
Is it? My job here for the past five years has been to call the attention of the Government to things that the so-called Opposition in this House were too lazy to look up and too much afraid to criticise. Any Deputy over there will have just about the same trouble in getting those figures as I have had. But Deputies over there were too lazy to look for them. One of them who aspires to be the new Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, tired this House last night quoting a four-year-old speech because he was too lazy to make a new one. No wonder there are only 32 Deputies now in their combined eight Parties.
These are facts that I have been giving. My principal reason for doing so is that I want to quote a new factor. Since this war started the farmers of this country have endeavoured to be self-sufficient as regards their crops. We have endeavoured to raise our own beet seed which the Belgians supplied us with before. We have endeavoured to raise our own mangold and turnip seeds instead of having to import them from abroad. If we take last year, the farmers grew mangold seed under contract at, roughly, from 8d. to 10d. per lb. That mangold seed was afterwards resold to the farmers at the stiff price of 2/9 per lb. Pre-war, the price of mangold seed sold over the counter here was 1/6 per lb. The profit now allowed on mangold seed from the time it leaves the farmer's haggard to the time it is sold back to him over the counter is 2/1. If the farmers of this country grew the whole of our requirements in mangold seed, the quantity would be 16,145 cwts., for which they would receive £60,208 according to contract, while they would pay back for it under the fixed price £198,000. If we are going to build up new industries in this country, industries which will provide employment for our unemployed people on the land, we cannot afford to have those industries killed now by profiteers. If our farmers grew all the turnip seed that is required by the agricultural community they would need to produce 9,500 cwts. of turnip seed. According to the contract price paid by Associated Seeds, Ltd., for this turnip seed, the farmer would get £71,000 for growing the seed, while Associated Seeds, Ltd., at the present fixed price for turnip seed would get £496,000. These are the figures, and they show that the system of profiteering that is going on in this country must end. It must end if the industries that the farmers are trying to build up are to go ahead.
The sugar company gave us contracts during the past three or four years, since the war started, for the growing of beet seed. We grew on the land their beet seed at 8d. per lb. The company helped us out considerably as regards manures, supervision and some other things that we could not do ourselves or that we would find it difficult to do. That company is able to sell back the seed to the farmer at 1/6 per lb. Those new seed companies which have come along are paying exactly the same price for the growing of mangold seed as the sugar company is paying for the growing of beet seed. In view of that, how is it that they are permitted to sell back the mangold seed to the farmer at 1/3 per lb. more profit than the sugar company is getting on the beet seed which it sells back to the farmer?
Comment on this
This job is in its infancy. This is not Government profiteering. This is a ease of individuals taking advantage of the emergency to profiteer.
Comment on this
Unfortunately the agricultural community do not enjoy the same advantages as Deputy Norton's people.
Comment on this
We have. I am giving the figures, and I want to see this industry remaining in the country when the war ends. I do not want to see it killed now. Where is the farmer who to-day is paying from 6/6 to 7/6 per lb. for turnip seed going to go after the war? Is there not going to be a universal demand to go back and buy the cheap seeds that we had before? This is an industry that would be peculiarly helpful to what I may call our small farmers and uneconomic holders in the West of Ireland, in Galway, Mayo, and portions of West Cork and in Kerry. The growing of an acre of seed will bring in, roughly, from £100 to £130. The greater portion of the labour needed for that work could be done by those young men and women who at present have to go over to England to pick potatoes or to do some other class of work, and would keep them in employment at home. On the growing of an acre or two acres of seed they could earn as much as they are able to earn by going abroad, and the seeds grown here could be sold in the country at a reasonable price. If the sugar company are able to sell back the beet seed to us at 1/6 per lb., why cannot the mangold seed be sold back at the same price?
Comment on this
I am not arguing with anybody. I am directing my statements to the Ceann Comhairle and not to any particular Deputy. But those are the facts, and facts are stubborn things. In my opinion, this is an industry which should be protected and preserved. It is one that would provide an enormous amount of employment for our people at home.
I would like to say one word about the price of milk. I cannot for one moment agree with the Minister as to the cost of producing milk in Cork and the cost of producing it in Dublin. I would advise him to go very carefully into the enormous discrepancy there is between the price that is now being allowed to Cork farmers to produce milk and the price allowed to the Dublin farmers for producing the same article. With regard to milk at the creameries, the situation was very peculiar. I gave figures here half an hour ago showing that the price of creamery butter delivered in Britain fell from 164/10 to 95/- per cwt. in four years. During the first few years of the Fianna Fáil Government, the price fell still lower, and, as a matter of fact, in 1940, the price for Irish creamery butter in Britain would not allow the Government of this country to pay 4d. per gallon for milk. That is your outside market, and watch very carefully how you ever return to it. That is my advice to you. Facts are stubborn things and the facts are there. The fact is that if this country is to be forced to depend on an outside market in relation to its butter exports, it had better slaughter the cows.
Last night I gave one instance of the manner in which this Government had to step in to protect the dairy industry. They had to bring in a Stabilisation of Prices Bill, followed by an enormous subsidy on exported butter. The people opposite argued that 4d. per gallon was too much to pay to the farmer for his milk and they trotted into the Lobby to vote against the fanner getting any more. Deputy Bennett was a notable exception.
Comment on this
I wish to emphasise that particular fact in connection with the present, price of milk, which I am leading up to. I said last night also that I was not satisfied with the position of our premier industry. I am not satisfied with the position in which the people working on the land are the worst paid people in the country. I will just give one instance of what happened in order to bring it home to the House. It brought the position home very forcibly to me. Some time ago, Dr. Ryan decided——
Comment on this
The Minister decided that the profit allowed to retailers on the sale of butter would be 1d. per lb. There was war in Cork, where the traders, decided to sell no more butter. They bad deputations roaming around the streets looking for Deputies to tackle and I happened to fall in with some of them. They wanted me to head a deputation to the Minister with their case. I asked them what was their case aad one of them said to me:
"You know, Mr. Corry, we have to pay £3 10s. 0d. per week to the lad inside the counter who hands out that butter."
I looked at them and said:
"You want me to go to the Minister because you are paying £3 10s. 0d. per week to the lad who papers the butter and hands it over the counter. That lad comes into work at 9 o'clock in the morning, with a nice collar and tie and polished boots, and he gets £3 10s. 0d. per week. The poor man who has to get up at 5.45 and in the cold and frost, feed and milk the cows and possibly on a wet, rainy day has to get into his cart and take the milk to the creamery, gets 36/- per week."
That is the difference between the farm labourers and the others. I suggest that it should be the other way round, if there is to be a change. It is time tho lad who has to get up in the morning at a quarter to six, milk the cows and feed them and take the milk to the creamery should get some decent remuneration for his labour. The only way that can be done is by an increase in the price of milk.
Comment on this
There is no good in getting into a union if the price of milk does not go up, because if he does get into a union and fights for a better price for the farm labourer, while the price of the milk remains the same. there will be two crowds going to the union. The farmer and the farm labourer will go to the union together.
Comment on this
And he will get no sympathy there either, because the robber is more welcome at the present time.
Comment on this
I urge that if we are to raise the status of our rural community and if we are to keep our rural community on the land, these are the main things that must be looked after.
There is one matter which should concern the Minister for Supplies of which I want to speak. We hear a lot of talk about costings, fixed prices, and all the rest of it, but the farmer down in West Cork who, finding that he had no artificial manure, went down to the coast, got a load of sea sand, conveyed it to the railway station—because he would not be allowed to use lorries on account of the petrol shortage—and booked it to Dunmanway, last year paid 3/1 per ton freight. This company, which has the monopoly of the whole carrying trade of the country, published a new scale of charges the other day. The poor farmer down in Dunmanway who paid 3/1 per ton freight on his sea sand last year must now pay 8/- per ton. When the agricultural community look for better prices on that account, they are told that they are trying to hold the country up to ransom.
The quantity of sea sand delivered up to June of this year was: in January, 840 tons; in February, 1,100 tons; in March, 1,300 tons; in April, 1,300 tons; in May, 1,200 tons, and in June, 1,300 tons, showing that the railway company, even on the basis of a 3/- per ton rate, got a fairly good whack. Any Deputy who has to travel from Cork in the train at present knows that he may manage to get a seat in the corridor, but will not find very many inside the compartments, which shows that the railway company must be doing very well on passenger traffic. I think it is holding up the agricultural community to ransom that a body of people who have a monopoly of the carrying trade of this country should increase their charges to the farmers.
Comment on this
I did not hear Deputy Anthony or Deputy Larkin or any of the Deputies alluding to these matters. I have to allude to them because there is no Opposition there, because the Opposition do not work.
Comment on this
You are on the wrong benches. You should be down with the Sons of the Soil.
Comment on this
I have to be in opposition. I have had to call the attention of my Government to these things during the last five years, because Deputy Norton sat there, and the other Deputies sat there, and did nothing.
Comment on this
My people showed the appreciation they have for me. If any Deputy wants to have a round in my constituency, I will give him another round in the morning.
Comment on this
Maybe we will meet again, and we will miss more of you. I suggest that this is a matter that should be taken up immediately with the railway company by the Minister for Supplies. I think it grossly unfair. For instance, the fare in one case went up from 3/6 to 9/10; the fare from CourtmAcsherry from 3/6 to 10/3.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy, for Heaven's sake, try to look after Cork City? The Deputy has got a new chance. He neglected his duty here for ten years. The people of Cork kicked him out. He made so many promises to them that they have given him a new chance to look after Cork City. Let him look after Cork City and not mind the farmers. The farmers do not want him.
Comment on this
The agricultural community can be looked after without Deputy Anthony. Let him look after the matters in Cork City to which I will be alluding in a few moments. It may be a lot better for him and he may collect a few extra votes.
Comment on this
I am dealing with it and I am dealing with the matters as best I can but I cannot stand for unruly and disorderly interruptions—most disorderly.
Comment on this
Deputy Anthony may not interrupt. These are the matters in connection with agriculture with which I wish to deal. In conclusion, as far as agriculture is concerned, I would like to say that, in my opinion, at any rate, we are on the right road. We have been on the right road from 1932 onwards as regards agriculture. We have continued along that road. Our statements have been proved to be true. That is the right road, namely, to produce for the people at home the food they require. In times of stress, in times of trouble, this country was not going to be at the mercy of Deputy Dillon's friends, or dear friends of other Deputies, or of people inside and outside this House who hoped that by a campaign against the Fianna Fáil policy of food production at home they would drive this country into the position of having to beg from the foreigner the bread to feed our people and having to pay for that with the lives and the blood of our people. That is what Deputies over there tried to do.
I intend to deal with another matter, connected principally with local government. In generations past, when a person was discovered to be a malefactor or highwayman of any description, he was beaten and stoned and driven outside the walls of the city. My friends in Cork tried that policy on a body of people who were not malefactors, who were not robbers, people who had committed only one crime, the crime of being poor. They were driven outside the walls of Cork City and the red city was built there for them and they were shoved into it. Those people are deprived of the social benefits that this Government has passed legislation to provide for the community. Some thousands of families are suffering in that way. There is no use in the Minister for Local Government expressing views that he has recently expressed in connection with this matter—why do not they extend the borough boundary? Those people, poverty stricken, without unemployment assistance, without the benefit of the voucher scheme, cannot continue during a ten year dispute between Mr. Monahan, the City Manager, and the Cork County Council on the extension of the borough boundary. By that time a large number of them would have buried their children as the result of starvation. This is a matter that should be immediately taken up by the Minister for Local Government. Is there any reason on earth why a man living in No. 3 Spangle Hill should have 25/- a week unemployment assistance, so much free milk, butter and bread, and a man living in No. 5 Spangle Hill, with a larger family, in exactly the same position, should have nothing at all, merely because one happens to be inside a borough boundary stone and the other happens to be outside it?
Comment on this
It is a matter of general policy—of the policy that definitely lays down that one man is to have unemployment assistance, vouchers for free milk, free butter, free bread, free turf, and the other man, living two doors away, is to have nothing.
Comment on this
It does not. It might apply to one man in 5,000 in County Wexford. It applies in my constituency to one man in five.
Comment on this
I am dealing particularly with the position of affairs as I find it in my constituency.
Comment on this
I am dealing with people who have been driven outside the walls. This is not a question of a borough boundary. This is a question of a body of people living in Cork City, who were born and reared in Cork City, whose fathers were reared in Cork City, whom the Cork City Manager took, body and bones, and lifted out. He built huts for them and drove them outside the walls of the city.
Comment on this
Certainly. Yesterday I submitted a question here to the Minister for Local Government in connection with one injustice that this City Manager endeavoured to inflict. The unfortunate people out in that district, in addition to being driven outside the city walls, were paying outrageous rents. These people happened, on account of legislation passed here, to be entitled under the Emergency Powers Act to a bonus. They went before a tribunal and gave evidence as to the extra cost of their bread, butter, tea and sugar. That tribunal awarded them something between 5/- and 8/- per week to make up the extra cost of the bread, butter, tea and sugar. Then the City Manager came along and took 1/- off the 5/- and 1/4 off the 8/- by way of extra rent. That is one of the ways in which it was tackled without legislation. We want to curb the Czar that has arisen in Cork.
Comment on this
Comment on an official who is not here to answer is unfair. The Deputy has not yet, explained how people outside Cork City boundary could be treated as city men without legislation.
Comment on this
There is nothing to stop the Minister making an Emergency Powers Order in the morning without legislation.
Comment on this
I do not wish to discuss anything here which I am not entitled to discuss. I wished to call attention to matters that in my opinion are urgent—matters that may mean life or death to some hundreds of my constituents.
Comment on this
I regret I had to get the indulgence of the Dáil for that. As regards the main attack that has been made here, the attack on the Government's agricultural policy, I stand over every bit of the Government's agricultural policy. The Government's agricultural policy is all right. The farmers are four times better off under it than they were under the Fine Gael Government or the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, or whatever they were called when they were the Government. That is the position of the agricultural community. In my opinion they are not properly treated. The agricultural community are the only producers in this country who are not paid a decent wage for their labour.
Comment on this
There are too many "standstills" in the country at the present day standing at the corners while the others are sweating. There are a lot of "standstills" in this House.
Comment on this
They would be better off somewhere else doing a bit of work. I heard Deputy Dillon appeal to Deputies opposite. We heard a lot about pigs and bacon from Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon solemnly told us that Irish pigs could not be fattened on rotten Irish barley. Deputy Dillon also told us that nobody could eat the wheat produced on Irish soil. He can sit over there now with a smirk on his face after having had a feed of Irish wheat this morning. Apparently it has not harmed his digestion. I would be satisfied if it could affect his tongue.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon hates to have to swallow his own words. I am sure that every morning when Deputy Dillon sits down to his breakfast he gives a look at the "rotten" Irish wheat the Irish farmers grow, but still he eats it. Yet Deputy Dillon had the impertinence to get up in this House yesterday and to attack the policy of growing wheat in this country for our own people. Deputy Dillon seems to think that he can say what he likes to-day and nobody will think of it tomorrow; that he can preach one policy to-day and a different policy tomorrow. Deputy Dillon came into this House as an avowed protector of the farming community and as a completely independent Deputy. Yet he attacked other Deputies last week for doing exactly the same thing as he did previously when in that position. At that time he said he did not care for Deputy de Valera's national policy, that he did not care for his economic policy, and that he would not vote for him; neither did he vote against him. He sat down just as those other Deputies did. Then he came along and gave us a two hours' harangue last week.
Comment on this
I will have another day. These are the facts as I see them. I do not wish to delay the House further. I have given the facts as I know them, and if Deputies can contradict him, they have the whole evening to do it.
Comment on this
This House has listened very attentively to the speech of the Deputy who spoke just now, and it listened very attentively to the speeches of other Deputies yesterday, and I think most members of the House were waiting to hear some constructive suggestions. I am glad, at any rate, that the tone of the debate was a little better than what we experienced last week, that there was a little sense of responsibility such as was not shown by other Parties in the House last week.
Comment on this
The members of this Party entered the House with the intention of dealing seriously with the grave problems which face the country. We did not find much indication from other Opposition Parties of an inclination to deal seriously with these problems. We found, instead, an attitude of absolute recklessness and irresponsibility displayed in the House last week. Nevertheless, we, as a new Party, are prepared to consider the issues that confront us seriously. We are not going to allow ourselves to be intimidated by the type of "yahooism" which was demonstrated here last week.
Comment on this
I want to make it clear that it would be a reckless action to leave this country without a Government in a time of serious national emergency—and that is the proposition which was put before this Party. We consider that the largest Party in the House ought to be allowed to form a Government in view of the fact that there is no other Party at the moment in a position to form a Government. We are giving the largest Party in the House an opportunity to show whether they are prepared to deal seriously with the problems that face agriculture and, indeed, that face the nation generally. If they fail to deal with these problems as they require to be dealt with, then we will deal with them as we think fit.
The main problems that face this nation at the present time are, first of all, the problem of providing food for our people during the emergency and, secondly, the problem of planning for the future of agriculture when the emergency is over. I found very little indication of a willingness on the part of the majority of the Deputies who spoke yesterday to face up to the immediate needs of agriculture and of the nation—that is, if they are to ensure that the people of the State will have sufficient food to carry them on until next year, and that sufficient provision will be made during the coming months so that there will be an ample quantity of food produced to enable us to carry on until the following year. It is not only possible, but there is even a grave probability, that before this time 12 months we will have more serious problems to deal with in regard to the food supplies of our nation than are at present facing us, grave as they are at the moment.
I am not satisfied that everything that could be done is being done to increase food production. I am not satisfied that the food producer is being given the encouragement, the co-operation and the support which he is entitled to expect from the Department of Agriculture and the Government. First of all in degree of importance is our wheat supply. Are we sure that sufficient wheat has been sown during the past year to carry us on until this day 12 months? I have grave reason to fear that the acreage under wheat this year is not substantially higher than what we had last year. The Minister may have some figures at his disposal in regard to this matter, but so far they have not been made public. Whatever the position may be, there is a very urgent need to ensure that in the next few months a great effort will be made to increase the acreage under wheat. There are two ways in which encouragement can be given to the farmer to extend the acreage under wheat. You can encourage him by giving an increase in the price per barrel, or you can give encouragement by paying a direct subsidy per acre on every acre grown. I strongly recommend the desirability of giving a direct State grant per acre.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon has been a member of this House for the past 10 or 12 years—I do not know how long. I think he came in, very early in his Parliamentary career, as Deputy Leader of a Farmers' Party and, as Deputy Leader of that Party, he demonstrated the Party's independence by abstaining from voting, as we did last week. Notwithstanding that demonstration of independence of both the big political Parties, within a few months he had sold out his Party and he went into one of them. I do not know what induced him to act in that way. There may have been some compulsion brought to bear upon him. Deputy Dillon has always distinguished himself in this House as an advocate of free trade, and it sounds a little bit absurd to see this advocate of absolutely free and unfettered trade suggesting that the farmer should be compelled to grow a certain crop.
Comment on this
I agree there is a war on and there would be a greater war on in this country if Deputy Dillon got his way. This reckless, irresponsible man, who would bring down on the heads of our people the blind fury of total war——
Comment on this
——has the audacity to accuse members of this Party of not having the courage to face up to their responsibilities. This man who would involve the country in war has not the moral or the physical courage to take part in that conflict himself. This man dares to insult and to interrupt Deputies of the Farmers' Party when they endeavour to make a case on behalf of agriculture. If he had one drop of red blood in his veins he would go out and join the Red Army or some of the other armies that are fighting. He expects the women and the children of this city to fight for the principles he is advocating.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy is wise to interrupt in this debate. I was seriously recommending to the Minister, when this reckless, irresponsible Deputy interrupted me, that a subsidy per acre for wheat would be more advantageous and desirable than an increase in the price of wheat, for this reason, that if we want to have the acreage under wheat increased we have to get the farmers——
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the Deputy has a motion on the Order Paper in relation to this matter, is he in order in raising it at this stage?
Comment on this
The Chair has to take into account the possibility or probability of that motion not being reached for many months. If there were a fair chance of its being reached in the near future, I would rule against Deputy Cogan, but he is in order, provided he does not devote too much of his speech to the matter. The motion probably will not be reached for some months.
Comment on this
I have no intention of dealing with the matter at any great length. Of course, the wheat-growing season begins in September or October. In the meantime, I should like the Minister for Agriculture and the Government to consider ways and means of getting the acreage under wheat extended. The suggestion I put forward offers a reasonable method of getting that increase. It is desirable because the farmer whose land is inferior would not reap as great a benefit from an increased price per barrel as would the man with superior land. To give the man with inferior land some encouragement, I think that a direct subsidy is desirable.
In respect of another aspect of this wheat question, the Minister seems to have been lacking. We have never been able to ascertain exactly how much and is under wheat until the harvest season is virtually approaching. The position is completely different in regard to beet. Beet is grown under contract and the sugar factories and the Government know exactly how much land is being put under beet before the sowing season commences. I strongly suggest to the Minister for Agriculture that it would be in the best interests not only of the farmers but of the nation generally that the wheat crop should be grown under contract. It would then be possible for farmers, in the month of September or October before the wheat-growing season commences, to enter into a contract to grow whatever acreage of wheat they thought fit. The Department of Agriculture would know in the month of October exactly how many acres had been contracted for. If they found that the acreage was below that which would be required, there would be ample time to make provision for an increase. As the position is at present, the Minister can never ascertain exactly how much wheat will be grown until it is too late to remedy the situation. That is why I so strongly recommend the contract system in regard to wheat-growing. I think that the Minister should seriously consider the suggestion.
The contract system would also have advantages for the farmer. It would enable him to secure seeds, manure and, perhaps, an advance for harvesting the crop on the security of his contract. It would enable many farmers who are in difficult circumstances to go into wheat-growing. My colleague, Deputy Meighan, referred to the difficulty of getting credit for seed wheat. We all know that there is a county council scheme under which seed is provided, but a great many farmers do not avail of that scheme. It is rather humiliating to a farmer to have to appeal to a neighbour to secure him in a matter of this kind. In view of the urgent need for the greatest possible acreage of wheat, I think that a seed scheme similar to that which obtains in relation to beet should be adopted. Wheat-growing is the most urgent question that faces us at present. It is a question that will have to be tackled before this House meets again. In view of its urgency, and of the urgency of other matters relating to agriculture, I suggest that the House should meet again, if possible, in September.
Of even greater immediate importance is, perhaps, the question of harvesting this year's crop. We have been very fortunate as regards weather during the sowing season, and the early growing season this year, but we cannot be so optimistic as to hope that we shall be similarly favoured during the harvest. We hope for the best, but we have also, in the interests of the country, to make provision for the worst. Never have the people, whether they live on the land or off the land, been forced to depend so much on the harvest and on the weather as at present. Whatever can be done in the way of recruiting and making available additional labour for the harvest should be done now. Plans should be devised to rush to the relief and assistance of agriculture the largest possible number of men, particularly if the weather proves unfavourable. If it is necessary to release large numbers of men from the Army, it should be done, and if there is urgency, it should be found possible to draft men who are in the Army to the assistance of the farmers. That suggestion should command the Minister's sympathetic support. These are two urgent matters. We have got to make provision for the entire sowing of next year's crop, and we have got to ensure that the farmer is assisted and supported not only in the growing of wheat, which is so urgently needed, but in the growing and extension of the potato crop.
I think that the Minister made a rather serious slip yesterday if he is correctly reported in the Press. I was not present when he made the reference. He said that the acreage under potatoes last year showed an increase on that of the previous year.
Comment on this
The fact is that there was a slight decrease in the acreage and a very marked reduction in the yield and in the quality of the potato crop. We Want to secure that next year there will he a substantial increase in the acreage under potatoes. For that reason, I ask the Minister to consider how the British Government has dealt with this question and how they have increased the acreage under potatoes until they are able to provide sufficient potatoes for their entire population. That has been achieved by paying a direct subsidy of £10 per cent under potatoes. In addition, the Minister should consider the necessity for securing that everybody who wishes to grow potatoes in the coming year will be able to get assistance and facilities in procuring seed.
When we have dealt with the urgent need of food for our people in this emergency, we must consider the pressing need of providing an ever-increasing supply of food for live stock. We are extending our acreage under tillage. In bringing more and more land into cultivation there is a danger of deterioration of the land, and it is, therefore, desirable that the largest possible amount of winter feeding should be carried on on our farms. For that reason, it is desirable that farmers engaged in stall-feeding during the coming winter should get every encouragement. The position during the past few years has been that it paid farmers better to sell their live stock at the fall of the year and avoid the expense and labour of feeding cattle in out-houses. That must not be allowed to happen next winter. Whatever assistance could be given to farmers who engage in hand-feeding stock should be given them. That is an urgent matter because we cannot extend tillage unless we extend the hand-feeding of live stock. A little encouragement given by the Department of Agriculture to those who concentrate upon the hand-feeding of live stock would have a very beneficial effect. Even an assurance from the Minister or from whoever speaks on behalf of the Government in this debate that something in that direction will be done would be an encouragement to farmers to plan for the hand-feeding and stall-feeding of cattle.
I notice that since the Farmers' Party entered the Dáil there has been a rapid growth of land-mindedness amongest all Parties. We had the Taoiseach taking us back to the green valley of his boyhood and introducing us to young Eamon de Valera when engaged in farming operations. I believe that if this process of land-mindedness continues we will in a short time have some of the leaders coming into this House with hobnailed boots, and perhaps the hobnailed boots will have on them a little farmyard manure. This land-mindedness on the part of all Parties is very welcome. It shows that Deputies on all sides are beginning to think seriously about agriculture. I believe that the entry of the Farmers' Party to this House has achieved a very useful effect in bringing the old Parties down to earth. It will also have the effect of bringing the people down to earth, by making them realise that it is by the land the nation has to live, and that it is upon the development of the land the future of this nation depends.
That brings me to the second question to which I intended to refer, the planning of the future of agriculture when this emergency has passed. Recently I came across a book entitled Food and Farming in Post-War Europe, the authors of which are P. Lamartine Yates and D. Warriner. They deal with the conditions of agriculture generally in Europe. They refer to the emergency and then review the position of agriculture in Europe for the past 20 years. They also make recommendations for the post-war period. One of the things that impressed me in this book was the appaling condition of poverty and destitution of many people engaged in agriculture during the past 20 years. With the exception of Denmark and Holland, the majority of the European countries have carried on food production under very primitive and unremunerative conditions. It is against these countries that we have to compete.
We should realise that in Europe the standard of living of those engaged in food production has been very low. When we hear people talking about competing with other nations in the British market we have to ask ourselves this question: Are we going to sink our people down to the very low standard of living which prevails in many other countries? I do not think that is a policy to which our farmers would submit. In the post-war period I believe we must plan to maintain a standard of living in agriculture as good as the standard that has been achieved in industry, in commerce and in the professions through the operations of the trade unions and the protection of the law. People engaged in industry and in commerce have secured a standard of living much higher than those engaged in the production of food. They have achieved that through the organised efforts of the workers and by legislation passed through this House and through the British Parliament. We want to ensure that in future people engaged in agriculture will not be expected to accept a standard of living lower than that which prevails amongst other sections of the community. If we are to compete with other nations in world markets then I do not think we are at present facing up to that problem. In the book to which I referred there is a chapter dealing with marketing to which I wish to draw the attention of the House. They say:
"We sketched out certain proposals which might improve the efficiency of food production and enable the peasant to attain a bigger output of better quality produce with less expenditure of effort. But efforts at real improvement in this direction will be of little avail if the peasant is unable to secure satisfactory markets for what he produces.
"In the modern world it by no means follows that commodities which have been efficiently produced can be sold for remunerative prices, even if consumers in the same country or in other countries urgently need them. In the present chapter we shall be concerned with the home aspects of market security, and while we shall say a good deal about State planning and guarantees of stability it must be remembered throughout that more valuable even than security will be the expanding market generated by policies of full employment and adequate nutrition.
"There were two kinds of ups and downs which in pre-war days afflicted the agricultural producer. One was the whole complex of fluctuations in world prices. Those whose output had to face competition, whether at home or abroad, with the produce of all five continents, found that over a period of years the price which they received rocketed about in a manner which bore no relation at all to their own output or to the demand of the consumers for whom they catered. The price which the Rumanian peasant obtained for his wheat was determined by the rainfall in Manitoba or the psychological tone of Wall Street.
"But even those producers who enjoyed a sheltered market at home experienced annoying and, to a large extent, unnecessary fluctuations in prices. Fruit-growers, for example, found that when nature provided a bumper crop the prices obtainable hardly covered the costs of picking, whereas in years when prices were really attractive they had no produce to sell."
That indicates serious thinking in regard to agricultural problems. The paragraphs I read are, I might say, a re-hash of what I have been advocating in this House for the past five years. I have advocated, not that the farmer should be put in a position to compete in world markets, but that the farmer and the agricultural producer should be guaranteed, regardless of what price prevailed in the world markets, a reasonable price for his produce and security of market. That can be done, and until it is done we cannot look forward to any expansion in agriculture.
I remember that when Deputy Cosgrave was in power I was farming in a small way. In 1929 I started farming on my own, and I found that every line of production in which I embarked was completely destroyed and ruined by the collapse in prices which prevailed in 1929, 1930 and 1931, which collapse in prices was still further emphasised during the régime of Deputy Cosgrave's successors in office. Perhaps I might be permitted to call to Deputy Cosgrave's recollection that at a meeting that was held in the Town Hall in Carlow, in 1932, I advocated that the Cosgrave Government should do something to relieve agriculture, but his view on that occasion was that to do anything, or to attempt to do anything, to relieve the condition of agriculture would be to interfere with the ordinary economic laws of supply and demand—laws which, according to him, could not be interfered with—and that, whatever the farmers were suffering was due to causes over which he, as head of the Government, had no control. That was the attitude which was adopted by the Cosgrave Government. They adopted an attitude of complete irresponsibility in regard to agricultural prices—if prices were bad in the world markets, then the farmer had to put up with them and take the consequences.
Now, that is an attitude which I do not support, and which I never have supported. It was, however, unfortunately, an attitude which was continued by our present Government, to a very great extent. Only in connection with a small number of branches of farming was an effort made to protect the farmer or the producer against the effects of world depression. In the case of the majority of the branches of farming, the more important branches of agriculture, not only was the farmer compelled, under the present Government, to bear the full effect of world depression but, in addition, he had to bear the cost of the international dispute with Great Britain—generally referred to as the economic war.
Looking back over the mistakes of the past 20 years, it ought to be possible for the Minister for Agriculture and the Government to plan so as to ensure that in the future the entire home market will be reserved to the farmer, first of all. There is no reason why we should import into this country any agricultural commodity which can be produced here. The present war emergency has shown how we can make ourselves self-reliant to a great extent in regard to agricultural seeds. It has shown how we can supply very many of the essential foodstuffs which we formerly imported. When this emergency is over, the question will have to be considered as to what our attitude will be in regard to those-agricultural commodities which were formerly imported. We shall have to consider our attitude in regard to imported feeding stuffs, for instance. There is a simple test in regard to imported feeding stuffs—as to whether or not they should be allowed into the country—and that is to take, for example, the fact that it takes 7 cwts. of certain concentrated foodstuffs to produce 1 cwt. of meat. By comparing the price of the 7 cwts. of feeding stuffs with the price for the 1 cwt. of meat thus produced, it will be possible to arrive at a decision as to-whether the importation of those feeding stuffs is justifiable or not. That is a simple test, and it is the angle from which this problem must be approached.
Now, having assured the farmer of the home market, in so far as it is possible to assure him of it, even in regard to wheat, I think it will be necessary to have a decision, in the post-war period, in regard to wheat. I believe that the wise and prudent policy in regard to wheat is that if we do not produce 100 per cent. of our requirements, we should produce at least such a quantity as would enable us in a time of emergency to increase the amount up to 100 per cent. No matter what kind of peace may be arrived at, at the end of this war, I do not think it would be wise for us to bank on being entirely free from international complications, and under no circumstances should the acreage under wheat, in my opinion, be allowed to fall below 50 per cent. of the nation's requirements. That would leave a sufficient margin to enable us to deal with the nation's needs in a time of emergency. In addition to that, it should be possible to arrange for the storage of large quantities of home-grown grain, and even of foreign grain. It is desirable to have granaries established, under State or public control, so as to ensure that sufficient food supplies for man and beast would be provided.
Next comes the question of planning in regard to those commodities of which we have an exportable surplus. I do not agree, and I have never agreed, that the price of any commodity of which we have an exportable surplus should be allowed to be depressed to the extent to which that commodity might be depressed in the external markets. We should not, and cannot, in the future, allow our internal economy and our whole price structure to be disrupted by anything that may happen in external markets or by any depression that may be brought about in other countries. Our producers, whether they produce for the home market or for the export market, must be protected in regard to prices. Ways and means must be found to deal with such a situation. If it is necessary to export, as it will be found necessary to export, and if the price is not sufficient to cover the cost of production of the goods we are exporting, then ways and means must be found to supplement that export price. We must remember that the agricultural producer who produces for export is really producing for the home market indirectly, inasmuch as he is producing a commodity which can be exchanged for some other commodity which the home consumer requires. Therefore, he is as much entitled to protection as the man who produces directly for the home market. Of course, I know that the home market can also be very extensively increased by providing a higher standard of living for our people. If our standard of living is raised, there is no reason why our people should not be able to use a great deal of the dairy produce, bacon and other things, which in pre-war years were exported.
I think there is need for serious planning in regard to agriculture. Since agriculture is the basis upon which our whole economic system is founded, there is need for planning in regard to our whole economic structure. I hold that our planning should take the line of ensuring that, come what may, the man who produces essential goods, either for the home market or export, will be guaranteed at least as high a standard of living as the man who sweeps the streets or performs other duties of that kind, which are, of course, also essential. Even now, notwithstanding the display of irresponsibility to which we were treated in this House last week, would it not be possible, in order to get our economic problems solved, to get all Parties in this House to unite in the form of an economic council representative of all Parties here, similar to the Defence Council, which is dealing with matters of national defence? Surely the problem facing our people in regard to the provision of employment for our population, the provision of employment for our men who are in the Army, and for our workers who are now in Great Britain, and the problem of carrying this country through the difficult transition period after the emergency, are matters on which all Parties should be prepared to co-operate to the same extent as they have been prepared to co-operate in dealing with military dangers.
I think that an economic council, representative of all Parties in this House, and meeting occasionally as the National Defence Council meets today, would be of immense value. Unlike a meeting in this House, the meetings of that council would not be open to the public, and it would not be necessary for political Parties to indulge in the schoolboyish pranks which other Opposition Parties indulged in last week. We would have no Press representatives present; we would be able to sit down and talk over the difficulties which face the nation; we would be able to exchange ideas, put forward suggestions, and help in achieving security and prosperity for agriculture, thereby securing prosperity and stability for the nation.
Comment on this
I think that if the Deputy who has just sat down had examined the economic situation here, particularly in regard to agriculture, more from the point of view of the returns that are published than from the point of view of the information that is given in Government documents, he would not have committed himself to the very foolish statement he has just made. It is not a part of the business of a legislator here to bring before the House his own shortcomings with regard to any speculations in which he may indulge, either in agriculture or in business. What we have to consider here is: what is the situation for the whole of the country. One of the besetting sins of the last 15 or 16 years in this country is that a few people, very glib of tongue, very persuasive, having almost immeasurable time at their disposal, have been going around sabotaging the public mind with regard to matters upon which their knowledge was very limited indeed. There was, in the world generally, a very serious economic situation from the end of 1928 down to 1931. Not, I suppose, within the memory of living man has there been such an economic catastrophe affecting world conditions as there was in that time. The genius of statesmen, the knowledge of economists, and the co-operation of all classes in endeavouring to find some means of preventing this catastrophe to mankind, were ineffective even in the most wealthy of the countries— perhaps more ineffective in those countries which had practically measureless resources than in some of the smaller countries.
The countries which the League of Nations reported as having best met the storm of that economic collapse was this country, and, I think, Denmark. Why was that? Because the policy which had been pursued here from the time this State was established was a definite constructive policy in regard to agriculture. It was not any of the nonsense to which we have been listening here for the last few days or for the last 15 years. It was a policy designed to meet any and every circumstance that could arise. One of the reasons why the economic blizzard did not affect this country as it affected others was that our agricultural economy was based upon live stock and live stock products and not upon the growing of cereals. In those countries where there was wheat growing, maize production, and the lower forms of agricultural activity, the slump was greater and the losses were much more pronounced than they were here. I do not know whether the Deputy has been following the trend of popular thought in Germany since the war started. I imagine that, if he had, he would realise that there they have divided agricultural production into two classes. There is what they call the lower order of agricultural production, which refers to the growing of cereals, and there is the other— live stock and live-stock products. The intention, if they were successful in the war, was to persuade their neighbours to indulge in the lower forms of production, and to keep for themselves the more profitable ones.
I have gone into the figures of our agricultural sales here over a great number of years, starting with the year 1927. I will give the reasons for taking that year. Up to 1927 a very considerable proportion of the seats in this House was untenanted. Deputies opposite had not made up their minds to shed Republican principles, and in 1927, when they entered this House, we had what they call normal political conditions. Allowing for the cost of every item of agricultural production which came into this country out of the money that we received for our agricultural exports, there was in the year 1927 a balance of almost £13,250,000 to the credit of our agriculturists. In 1928 the credit balance was almost £15,750,000. In 1929—to which the Deputy referred as the year in which he lost money, the year in which he did not see any future for agriculture—the balance was £15,636,000. In 1930 it was £16,329,000. In 1931, the year of the slump, it was £13,425,000. I will not weary the House with the exact figures in those cases, but I will give some which are of interest and which present the case in tabloid form. Having paid for all agricultural imports to this country, the average income over those five years was £14,866,000 odd. What was it in the succeeding seven years? In the succeeding seven years we had put into practice the policy which the Deputy recommends. Neither during this election nor during those years have I ever heard of any attempt made by the Deputy or his Party to put forward an agricultural economic policy.
This policy of giving subsidies for this, that and the other thing is all moonshine. As an immediate expedient, it is something that has a steadying effect but as a regular policy for the country it is futile as is the policy of tariffs to, build up industry, to promote industrial production or to give industrial employment in the country. The average income for the seven years in which we had this so-called change-over policy was £6,422,000 as against the £14,866,000 to which I have referred. There is the answer to all the statements made by the Leader of that Party that they had won the economic war. If they did, they lost the peace and it cost much more to win it than even the losing of the peace. There was the greatest blunder that a country could have committed. Not only did the Government of this country pay every penny that was in dispute but they paid much more and at the end of the period we entered into an agreement —we were bound to enter into it, whether by duress or otherwise—under which our agricultural produce was put on a lower plane on the market which had been open to us than it had enjoyed prior to entering into that contract. Not only that, but one of the great achievements accomplished by Griffith and Collins, in securing fiscal autonomy and sovereignty in this country, was completely undermined. We had to barter portion of it in order to get a lower position on the British agricultural market than we had enjoyed there before. I hope that when Deputies are dealing with a matter of this sort in future they will at least pay some attention to the facts. They are there on record. They can be found easily and if anybody has any difficulty in getting them I shall give him every assistance in my power. At any rate before we get to the point at which we have got to plan an agricultural economy we should be sure of our ground. Let us know where we are starting from and then let us map out where we are going.
Listening to the Minister for Agriculture on this Vote yesterday I was inclined to feel depressed, but having 11 years' experience of the work of the Minister, the thought occurred to me that there was no use in getting depressed. We shall have to grow up even though the growing process in the case of the Minister occupies a much longer time than we had expected. The Minister compares the events of the last few years with those of the ten or 11 years prior to his coming into office. Apparently he must have been satisfied that there was something good in these 11 years or he would not have bothered about them. To take one example. During the last 12 months the Minister introduced a Creamery Re-organisation Bill. When the original measure of that character was introduced here by the late Mr. Hogan it did not meet with anything like the same reception which the Minister's Bill received. Why? Because at that time there was political capital to be made out of the measure. There was an opportunity given to the members of that Party to go around from place to place, where there were redundant creameries, and to tell the people that the policy of the Government was to make it more difficult for them to carry on their business, that the closing down of a creamery here and the opening of one a couple of miles away meant interfering with their amenities and the convenience with which they could carry on their business. We have moved away from all that now. I think we have got away from that particular phase of idiocy, and we can proceed in a more sane fashion than in those days.
The Minister compared the output of butter from the creameries with that of some years ago, but he did not take into account the butter produced by farmers at that time. If he does, he will find that the output is down by 100,000 cwts. as compared with ten or 11 years ago. Assuming that he is perfectly correct and that the output of the creameries has increased by 8,000 cwts. over some years ago, is that anything to be greatly proud of? The policy laid down by the late Mr. Hogan aimed at the extension of the creamery business. The intention was to increase the production of butter from the creameries, and if the Minister has achieved that purpose even, to the extent of 8,000 cwts. over ten or 11 years ago, has not something been done? According to the Minister's own statement down in Cork some time ago he saw no future for the dairying industry.
Comment on this
If the Minister likes I shall look up what he said on the subject. If the Minister contradicts me in regard to that, I shall endeavour to look it up for him.
Comment on this
I never said that. That is even further from the point. "Migration" was the word I used.
Comment on this
I do not care what Press report the Deputy has. I never said "emigration". I said "migration".
Comment on this
Reference was made here yesterday to the Pigs and Bacon Commission. It was stated here, I do not know from what side of the House, that the Pigs and Bacon Commission or Committee was set up by reason of new marketing conditions on the British market. I thought there was a better reason given at the time than that. I hope that Deputies are not mixing up two particular terms, the Pigs and Bacon Commission or Committee or the Pigs Marketing Board. In any case whatever body was set up, was not it stated in this House that the real reason for establishing it was that there had been over a long period extraordinary fluctuations in the price of pigs, that people went into production on a large scale when prices were high and that when the price dropped they went out? Again when there was a small production of pigs, the price went up. It was to try to equate, in some measure at any rate, these extraordinary fluctuations that it was decided to set up the Pigs and Bacon Commission. That was the reason given, as the Minister is aware.
Comment on this
Whatever it was, it arose out of the dispute with Britain in connection with these moneys.
Comment on this
The Deputy is wrong in that. Britain made the same regulation for all the countries from which she was importing.
Comment on this
But there had never been a limitation up to that time on this country.
Comment on this
But the other countries were all rising in their sales of their exports. We were fairly constant.
Comment on this
Yes, but that was the first time the matter affected us. It operated also in regard to bacon and mutton.
Comment on this
If the Minister will look up the report of the House of Commons Debates for 1935 when we were considering the Cattle Slaughter Bill—I may not be giving you the correct name, but that was the purpose of it—he will find that the British Minister in charge over there stated that they had made arrangements with the Dominions for the importation into Britain of a specified quantity of dead meat——
Comment on this
——and that a particular Dominion, either Australia or New Zealand, had been allotted—we will say for the moment—500,000 cwts. of dead meat to be sent in the first six months of the year. They had sent 600,000 cwts., and he expected before the year was out that they would send an equivalent quantity for the second six months. In that particular case, the large exports which they sent closed us out of the cattle trade over there, and limited this country to a smaller quota of both store and fat cattle on the British market at that time. That was the reason for the changes in respect of more orderly marketing, but they also arose out of those agreements in Ottawa, and it was the first time in our history in connection with the export of agricultural produce for the British market that any limitation had been put on the quantity we could sell.
Comment on this
But they were on a different basis. I would like the Deputy to realise that bacon was on one basis, and that the others were on a different basis. As a matter of fact, we were excluded from regulation as regard beef and mutton, but included as regards bacon.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not remember that the quotas of fat cattle were lowered and that we were put upon a 50 per cent. basis? In the last year of office of my Government we exported 300,000 head and they went down to 150,000 in the years afterwards. Let us exclude the British market altogether, and remember that the purpose of the commission was to regulate the prices over a period. It was done in this fashion: the commission was to consider what would be a fair price. If the market prices were below it, they would borrow or raise money and they would pay in excess of the market price to keep it on the level. Later when the prices went up, they would still give only the level price, and they would repay whatever sums they had expended in the earlier period to make up the price to what we will call an equitable level by reason of the savings they would effect under the new dispensation. Very good. What happened? For a long time, the price remained as it was, and then, after a while, some money was saved by this commission to be used when the price of bacon would go down. How was it employed subsequently? My recollection is—I put it no further than that—that the Pigs and Bacon Commission got permission from the Minister to allow them to reimburse themselves. At that time there were some bacon curers on it. My recollection is that that was how they used it. In any case, the sum and substance of the establishment of the commission was to ensure that they would avoid fluctuation in the price of pigs and that in order to keep the farmers in production, they would pay a fair price. The aim was to give the people who produced the pigs a sufficient sum of money to enable them to keep in production. After five or six or seven years how does it look? The pig figures were never lower in our lives.
Comment on this
If the figures were up, it was for a very short period and the general trend was downwards. My recollection is that it never reached the level of my time of office.
Comment on this
The total number of pigs in 1940 had reached a higher level than for 15 years with one exception.
Comment on this
Our policy has escaped. We were told a few minutes ago that our policy was not a success. I will turn for a moment to another matter. The following is an extract from a report of a speech by the Minister, in Cork:—
"During the two years of war, the Minister said, the dairy farmer has had to be subsidised and for the present that subsidy must continue. They could only mark time until the war was over and see what conditions were like then.
"Dr. Ryan said we might be compelled to discontinue some of the exports that before the war had become uneconomic. The elimination of the export of dairy products, if such a course should eventually become necessary, would not be so disastrous to farming economy as might at first sight be feared, he said. If, on the other hand, we decided after the war to continue in the export business, we could only do so by reducing the standard of living of our agriculturists or by reducing costs of production."
Comment on this
I could find fault with it. There is no hope in it for the dairying industry.
Comment on this
If that be the Minister's complaint, I am prepared to admit that I do not know the facts as he has made them. I see no great hope for the dairying industry in that. May I direct the Minister's attention towards reducing the cost of production? Increasing production would be one way of doing that.
Comment on this
The thing which strikes me about it is that we hear all those speeches and never a single suggestion as to how it could be done. I said on the day I opposed the Minister's re-election that the Minister had not been paying any attention to that. I said I could not understand how cows in New Zealand and cows in Denmark had a yield of approximately 33? per cent. more than our cows. Even in England they had a higher yield and they get their best cows from us. How is that?
Comment on this
They say we are indispensable to them in respect of dairy stock. They must get their cows from us. They have no other source from which to draw. They can get the milk from them and why cannot we? I would like to see a reference to that, and a discussion started about how these things are going to be remedied.
Comment on this
How is it going to be done? I suggest that the Minister should examine the situation and see how it has not been done.
Comment on this
I would go further and say that better winter feeding would effect some improvement.
Comment on this
From what I have learned from people in the business, they are not satisfied that we are getting the best out of the land. A man who raises pigs more extensively than any other farmer who raises pigs—not on our side of the Border—informed me that they had brought out grasses in England, and he was trying them in Ireland, where I believe there is better soil, which would put up to 3 lbs. per diem weight on animals. No other article could give the same result.
Comment on this
What are we doing to find out if anything like that is possible on our soil? I am not the Minister for Agriculture and I think it is scarcely up to form to ask me what are my suggestions. I say there is the line, start from it and go on building up our agricultural production. That is the way to do it. The Minister has experts, but I do not know if they are bothering their heads about things of this sort. To my mind, we are not getting the full value of production in this country, and if the Minister devoted attention to that problem instead of to the making of political speeches it would be much better.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I am very tired in a great many ways of them.