Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account (No. 2), 1943-44 (Resumed).
Contributions 175–329 of 499. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
It is a waste of time. I think you have to wait a little until people really learn. But, apparently, the most important speech that can be made is to tell the people they have got freedom and then to warn the people that if they do not elect a particular Party there will be destruction. That is a new type of freedom. Does the Minister understand it—tell the people they are free but that their freedom is limited by the way that they vote?
Comment on this
While those philosophies prevail in this country, I do not see what progress will be made. People were not cowed before. If they can be cowed now after they got their freedom, then they got their freedom too soon, or, maybe, too late.
Comment on this
However, we are dealing with agriculture. What has the Minister to say about agriculture? The Germans say we feed our cattle on the most expensive diet in the country, on beef.
Comment on this
Could we not improve on that by giving those farmers the best information available for them from all sources, and any source, as to how they could make their industry more profitable than it is to-day? I do not believe you can do that by a system of subsidies. If we are going to subsidise agriculture and subsidise other industries in this country, how is it going to be done? Is there not going to be something wrong in the whole business? The real point is to provide our people with gainful occupations out of which they can make a profit. If that is not done, then sooner or later you are going to have a crash. I am quite sure, whatever mistakes the Minister may make, he would not like to see that occurring.
Getting away from that aside, it must be admitted that the pigs and bacon business has gone down. A silly statement was made from the opposite side when it was said that we had criticised the feeding of pigs with maize. It was suggested that we had said that you could not have crushed oats, barley and other commodities mixed with maize. We never said anything of the sort. We said it was not the best method of feeding. The people raising pigs know themselves what is best Under the admixture scheme, it now takes three weeks longer to fatten a pig and it costs £1 more. If there is more money in that method, I would like to know where it is. It is certainly not there for the farmer.
Comment on this
Whether they do or not, the fact is that people have practically gone out of pigs. I suggest to the Minister that he should examine the matter and see if there is any money in it at all. It is an extraordinary thing that in this country, which was celebrated for the production of its pigs and bacon, we now have not got enough bacon for ourselves. At one period our exports in pigs and bacon brought £5,000,000 a year into the country. A foolish recommendation was made here some years ago to prevent the importation of bacon into the country so as to ensure the market for our own farmers. When we did stop imports how did we stand with regard to the consumption of bacon? We used to consume 800,000 cwts. a year. That figure went down to 600,000 cwts. Do not tell me that the 600,000 cwts. of our own bacon is better value for the people than the 800,000 cwts., because there are people who cannot afford to buy Irish bacon, but who could afford to buy the imported bacon. Why we should put up the cost of living on them, and prevent them from getting certain meats when they could not afford to pay for others, I do not know.
Comment on this
I know that, but the Minister for Agriculture at the time told them that it would not improve or affect in any way the bacon industry, or pig production, in this country. Of course, we had to have that proven to us. I was informed by a man who was down in the Minister's constituency that there was bacon in the shop windows, sometime about 1930 or 1931, selling at about 4d. or 5d. per lb. Of course, some of our modern economists would say that was a terrible thing, but there are people who can only afford to pay 4d. or 5d. a lb. for bacon. They cannot afford to pay 2/-. It does not follow from that that if you get 6-lbs. for 2/- the person who will pay 2/- per lb. will buy a single lb. for 2/-. By doing that you interfere with particular phases of our economy: (1) the person on a small wage, and (2) you give a better chance to the country to sell dear and buy cheap.
I do not know whether the Minister is going to bend his attention towards bringing back the pig industry. I think it would be well worth while doing that, but it is not going to be done from his office witli experts. This year's Estimate includes a sum of about £10,000 for regulating the pig industry here. The figure was £20,000 last year. It is the pig producers who will have to pay that.
You know that you could regulate traffic with perfect ease if you had Gárda officers on duty at the points where the lamps operate for the purpose of arresting any person who crossed the line before the lamp indicated to him that he should cross. It is the same in regard to regulating the pig industry. The fact is that we have too many regulators and too few pigs. If that £20,000, spent on regulating the pig industry, were spent in buying feeding stuffs for the pigs it would be far better.
The Minister made reference to the improved situation, due entirely to the war, but what does it amount to? The figures show an income of £76,000,000 in respect of the total output of agricultural products for a year. That includes, in respect of turf and timber, a sum of £4,500,000 over the figure for 1929-30. The inclusion of the latter figure under agricultural production was a pure accident. It was included because the use of turf in 1929-30 was almost exclusively employed in agricultural households. If you deduct the £4,500,000 from the total, you are left with £71,500,000. The advance in prices accounts for about one-seventh of that sum, and when you make that deduction you are down below the 1929-30 mark. Certain economists opposite thought that was not good enough for this country. It would be a great matter for them if they had been able to maintain it during all their time.
There are many ways in which it would be possible to improve agricultural production in the country. The first is that you must employ scientific methods to increase production. Secondly, you cannot expect an industry like agriculture to bear the increase in rates. The rates on agricultural land have almost doubled in the last 11 years. In addition, you require to see what extra accommodation is needed on farms so as to make the business of farming a more profitable one than it is to-day. You also require to extend electric current to our farms. It would be well if the Minister considered what capital sum would be required to do that, so that farmers might take advantage of electric current.
I agree with a good deal of the criticism that was made here yesterday by Deputy Dillon. I think it is a deplorable thing that during the bad years, 1932 to 1938—I suppose the worst years that the country has experienced since the time of Cromwell —that taxes or tariffs should have been placed on the importation of phosphates. If you require to improve or benefit the manure works in the country, give them a subsidy, but whatever you do in that respect, let the raw materials of the agricultural industry—the Cinderella of our industries—be free of tax. Let them get their chance.
Similarly with regard to machinery. If you require to benefit the firms making, agricultural machinery here, do it by subsidy, but do not put the cost on the industry of agriculture. People make the mistake sometimes of saying that we depend entirely on it. We do not, but we could not do without it, and there ought to be no head-on collision between the interests of agriculture and the interests of other industries in the State. They are all complementary, one to the other. In the best of times, on the most prosperous farms in the country there are four or five sons and a couple of daughters. They cannot all remain on the land, and employment must be found in some other direction for the larger numbers of the household. We have to bear that in mind, but, notwithstanding all that, for the last 50 or 60 years and perhaps for even a longer period, agriculture has been in a poor condition all over the world. In the case of Great Britain until the war, although they had £1,000,000,000 invested in agriculture, and made something like £100,000,000 per annum out of the industry, their primary industries, that is, manufacturing and other concerns of the sort, were of so much greater importance from the point of view of wealth and employment that they neglected their agriculture. In America some time ago a cartoon appeared in one of the principal papers circulating in New York or Chicago of a farmer on all fours, with bankers, politicians, business men, professional men, and so on on his back, and their weight was put down in dollars as compared with the amount he was making out of his business.
I think that no greater mistake could have been made by this Government than the imposition of these burdens on agriculture during the last few years. If there was available to them the information which was available to Ministries in other parts of the world to the effect that a war was impending, it was surely, their bounden duty to get in phosphates. The Minister gave us figures relating to the production of wheat. He said that it was about 18 cwts. to the acre. According to the Banking Commission Report, in the years 1932 to 1936 the yield was 20.4 cwts., so we have gone down.
Comment on this
The Banking Commission Report does not say that. The Minister's figure was 18 cwts.
Comment on this
We are down in that respect. I am not without hope that we shall learn after a while to concentrate upon endeavouring to make this industry more profitable for the people in it, notwithstanding these last 11 years, but I have not got that hope from what we have heard from the benches opposite or from any of the speeches made. I am not without hope that they will learn that an agricultural policy for this country is rather a mixed affair. We have live stock and live-stock raisers around Dublin, Kildare and Meath: we have the tillage farmers of the Midlands: we have the farmers of West Cork, who are mixed farmers and the hardest workers in the world: we have the dairying farmers of Limerick, Tipperary and Clare: and we have the mixed farming of Wexford and Louth. Not the same policy will suit all these, but whatever policy suits them, to criticise the importation of cheap feeding stuffs and manures is wrong. You ought to try to enable the farmers to farm even more land than they have. That was the policy of the late Mr. Hogan. He himself had a farm of about 250 acres, but he farmed practically 400 acres by reason of the importation of cheap feeding stuffs from the ends of the earth which he sent out as live stock and live-stock products. I am not at all satisfied that an economic council will settle this question. I do not think politicians will settle anything and I think it was a mistake ever to mix up politics and agricultural production. Until we get away from politics and get down to business, the position is not likely to improve, and I am satisfied that it must improve.
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave has given us a new index of national prosperity. The more intelligent members of the Fine Gael Party were too astonished even to gasp, while the others did not understand it. I propose to make them understand it. The new index of national prosperity given by Deputy Cosgrave——
Comment on this
Some of us forgot more than you ever learned. Do not insult Deputies on this side, please, even if you are a Minister.
Comment on this
My function in this House for years past has been an educational one. I have been trying to educate Deputies opposite in the elements of national economics. I have at times despaired of succeeding in that task, but with the persistency which is characteristic of me——
Comment on this
You might educate us in the elements of republicanism and the republic you have not got yet.
Comment on this
Deputy Coburn must allow the Minister to continue.
Comment on this
I will make it as simple as possible for the Deputy and speak in words of one syllable, if I can. We have been given a new index of national prosperity, an index by which Deputy Cosgrave proposes to judge the effectiveness of economic policy. What is that index?—the surplus in the value of agricultural exports over agricultural imports. If there is a big surplus, we are prosperous; if there is a small surplus, we are ruined. We were prosperous during his régime because there was a big excess in the value of agricultural exports over the value of agricultural imports, and we were ruined during Fianna Fáil's régime because we had a small excess. Is that not the index of national prosperity which Deputy Cosgrave has just given us?
Comment on this
What was the purpose of reading out these figures? Why read out the difference in the value of agricultural exports and agricultural imports in each of these years unless he was proposing to prove something by doing so?
Comment on this
Because the consumption of the remainder was practically level over the period.
Comment on this
If there was any purpose at all in reading out the figures, if there was any sense in the Deputy's remarks in relation to the figures, it supports my contention that the Deputy was giving us an index of prosperity, that the greater the excess in the value of agricultural exports over the value of agricultural imports, the greater was our prosperity. That is what he set out to prove. He is perhaps beginning to see the fallacy in the contention now, and I am sure that many other Deputies of the Fine Gael Party saw it before this. Some of them would never see it.
If we take Deputy Cosgrave's general contention and reduce it to particular commodies, we will see the fallacy very easily. Suppose we produce 600,000 or 700,000 cwts. of creamery butter every year and instead of consuming that creamery butter ourselves, we export it and import for our own consumption foreign margarine, then we are prosperous by that standard. The greater our exports of creamery butter and the greater our imports of margarine to make up for the creamery butter, the greater our prosperity. The cheaper the margarine we import, the more prosperous we are. It is a very simple calculation. We can produce an enormous excess in the value of agricultural exports over the value of agricultural imports if we do not confine ourselves to butter. If we send out our fat cattle and beef and import frozen Argentine beef in substitution, if we send out good bacon and import cheap bacon, if we take every agricultural product we produce—and our main strength in the export market for agricultural goods is the quality of our goods—and export them, importing for our own use cheap substitutes, we are prosperous. That is Deputy Cosgrave's idea of prosperity. That is the index he has just given us. Does it appeal to the members of the Fine Gael Party? Are they satisfied that that should be the aim of Government— to produce that statistical result?
Comment on this
What would you do if you were not exporting or even producing enough for yourself, as is the case in regard to bacon and butter?
Comment on this
So far as the Deputy is concerned, he is, of course, allergic to facts. He has proved that in the past, but he is, I think, exceedingly foolish in committing himself to statements which can be confuted by facts. I have often in this House warned Deputies opposite to avoid making statements that cannot be supported by facts. The greatest tragedy in political life is to see some fanciful theory brought face to face with facts. The theory disappears always if the fact does not agree with it. The Deputy always avoids facts. One of the most obvious facts in the statistics published by the various Government Departments is that our consumption of agricultural home-produced commodities has increased consistently year by year since Fianna Fáil came into office.
Comment on this
In the years 1929-30, agricultural produce consumed by farmers represented 32.4 per cent. of total production. Other home consumption of agricultural produce was 18.2 per cent. of total production. We exported 49.4 per cent.
Comment on this
£16,600,000 consumed by persons on farms; £13,368,000 other home consumption, £30,000,000 in all, out of £62,000,000. Where is your 32 per cent. there?
Comment on this
My argument is that we have reached the situation in which we are consuming ourselves a far higher proportion of our total production of foodstuffs than we did previously. The only market for Irish foodstuffs of which we can be certain at all times is the one at home. There can be no certainty of any foreign market.
Comment on this
I see. You are on another line now. You are mixing it up.
Comment on this
We were dealing with the value of the stuff made here.
Comment on this
I was not dealing with it. I do not know what the Deputy was dealing with. He gave us an index of national prosperity which is so fantastic that even he himself must see now the inapplicability of it. If the Deputy while President of the Executive Council of Saorstát Eireann was directing the national affairs upon the basis of such theories as he expressed here to-day, it is no wonder he produced the mess he did.
Comment on this
Facts—that is what they were. You must distinguish between the two.
Comment on this
I see. O.K. We have endeavoured to secure that a higher proportion of our total agricultural production would be consumed at home. We have endeavoured to secure that because we realised that it is only in the home market we could give security to our farmers—security of sale and economic price. In the export market we had to take any price we could get. Deputy Cogan suggested that it was undesirable for Irish farmers that the export price should determine the home price. That is a natural result where there is an exportable surplus. Where the export price was entirely uneconomic, we tried to remedy the situation by effecting arrangements designed to secure that the all-over average return for farmer would be satisfactory. We did it in relation to butter. Deputy Cosgrave referred to the situation in which we found the creamery industry. It was in a hell of a mess. Everybody knows that. I think the first legislative proposals brought to this Dáil by the Fianna Fáil Government were those designed to stabilise dairy produce prices. Does the Deputy remember that?
Comment on this
Does he remember the condition in which the creamery industry was at the time? Does he remember the attitude of his Party at that time? Some of them opposed it. The Deputies representing creamery constituencies did not. They were conveniently absent from the House when the vote was taken. It was the policy of his Party to oppose it, and that measure was designed to secure that the total return to milk producers would be as adequate as we could make it, even though we could not get more for our exportable surplus in the British market than an entirely uneconomic return. In order to try to offset that, we brought up the price in the home market, and we also provided out of national funds a subsidy to the industry. Does the Deputy remember what was said about it? Deputy Cogan remembers quite well.
Comment on this
He was here long enough to have heard time and again the contention which the Fine Gael Party repeated concerning that proposal—that it was one designed to tax our people, to give cheap food to John Bull. Does not that sound familiar?
Comment on this
The Minister says we are not going to do it now—the Minister says that now.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not recognise a fact. The fact is that we were getting for our agricultural produce in the British market the highest price we could get.
Comment on this
Excuse me. 28 per cent. was on it. Do you remember that?
Comment on this
Even after it was settled, the price which we were getting for our agricultural produce, particularly for our dairy products, in the British market was uneconomic It would not pay the cost of production here. Is not that true?
Comment on this
There is no guarantee, and there can be no guarantee, that when this war is over that situation will not be repeated.
Comment on this
The prophet Lemass is a very different person from the Minister Lemass.
Comment on this
I am not attempting to forecast what the situation after the war will be. I am making the contention that there is no guarantee that that situation will not be repeated. There can be no guarantee. The very forces and circumstances that produced that undesirable situation before the war may exist again after the war and, if they do exist, will produce the same result. That is clear. There can be no certainty if we depend for our prosperity on agricultural exports. We must endeavour to secure that we will export produce of some kind sufficient to offset the cost of the products we must import but we can have no certainty that it is going to be a profitable undertaking for us. Certainly, this index of national prosperity which the Deputy gave us would be a false guide upon which to rely. Does not the Deputy see that?
Comment on this
Certainly not, no. As I told you, I was dealing with facts. I refuse the Lemass prophecies and theories.
Comment on this
I have not made any prophecy yet. I am going to before I finish, but I have not done so yet.
Comment on this
I am only trying to put forward a perfectly reasonable case, which people of average intelligence will have no difficulty in accepting.
Comment on this
We certainly do not claim to be geniuses. We are not the best brains in the country.
Comment on this
I think the Minister ought to be allowed to make his speech.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy tell us whom he had in mind when he was talking about the best brains in the country? Let us into the secret. It is all over now. Tell us who they were.
Comment on this
If the Minister will look over here—all successes—all men of courage—every single one of them. They never terrorised anybody and when they say a thing they do it.
Comment on this
The Deputy gave us an index of prosperity which is completely inapplicable to our circumstances.
Comment on this
That index, if it operated in the manner in which the Deputy suggested, could in fact record prosperity at a time when we would be very badly off indeed. It could, on the other hand, show us to be very poorly off at a time when we would be enjoying real prosperity. It is much better for us to try to secure that the products of our farms will, if possible, be consumed at home. We can at home, at least, so arrange matters that the producers will get a fair return, will get a price for their products which will pay the cost of production and yield a fair margin for themselves. Is not that so? We cannot do that elsewhere.
If we have to export, we may have to do it at a loss, a loss which we can spread over the whole community; it need not necessarily be borne by the individual producers of the exported products. That, I think, is the fundamental difference between the Fine Gael and the Fianna Fáil Parties— that our conception of national prosperity is people better off in Ireland, a general improvement in the standard of living, not merely a statistical return which shows that there is a movement of money in and out of the banks. That does not matter in the least.
Comment on this
Let us say a falling emigration and a rising emigration.
Comment on this
I will deal with emigration, if the Deputy likes. The Deputy must see that the standards by which he has been judging our national policy in the past are completely unsound. Judged by those standards, this country was never better off than in the year of the Famine.
Comment on this
This idea of concentrating upon our internal situation, and endeavouring to consume at home our own home products, what we require for our standard of living, has been described by the Deputy as being as futile as the policy of industrialisation through tariffs and other forms of protection. What is his test of futility? I do not know what he regards as a successful industrial policy. Does he think that the industrial policy pursued by his Government prior to 1932 was successful?
Comment on this
It closed down none. The Minister, within three months, closed one in which 300 people were employed.
Comment on this
During the period of his administration a number of industries disappeared, a number of factories were closed down, and a very large number of workers lost their employment.
Comment on this
On the contrary. Take any particular industry and you will find that the record shows that what I have said is right. I am talking about industrial employment, the employment of persons in the production of goods by industrial processes. During our period of office we were not as successful as we had hoped originally. We ran into difficulties. We had not foreseen the impact of the economic war on our economic situation. The opposition offered by Fine Gael and various other circumstances which arose hampered our efforts. But we did succeed in establishing a number of industries which did not exist before. We did succeed in procuring the erection of a very large number of factories, and the putting into employment of some 50,000 or 60,000 workers in excess of the number employed previously. That is not futility.
Comment on this
If the Deputy takes the total additional number put into employment, he will find it was larger, but in the manufacturing industries the number of persons employed had at least increased by some 50,000. It is true that we could have done more if circumstances had been more favourable. When in 1938 we succeeded in bringing the economic war to a successful conclusion, we thought we were in a position in which it would be possible for us to secure that the full fruits of our economic policy would be secured. We felt then that at long last we were free of the shackles put on our efforts and that we could go forward to the full implementation of that policy in order to procure the results which we knew that policy was capable of achieving. Instead, we ran into the world war, a situation which handicapped our efforts, in fact, reversed our progress in many respects.
But this war will end sometime. When this war ends, we will have to face again this question of a national economic policy, and what policy will produce the best results. The best results are represented by a well-fed, well-clothed and well-housed people here, not by statistics. How are we to do that? Do Deputies contemplate that the new international conditions will be so fundamentally different from pre-war conditions that none of the policies that were debated in the pre-war period will apply? No one can forecast with any certainty what the post-war world will be like. It is reasonable to assume that it will not be so different that the principles and policies of the pre-war period will be inapplicable. We believe that the particular policy that we applied in the pre-war period, and which produced tangible results of real benefit to our country, will be equally applicable afterwards. It is easy to talk about the handicap placed on farmers by the effort made to establish various industries, but what sort of a mess would the country be in if they had not been established? Do you think we can still go to the ends of the earth for spades and shovels? Deputy Dillon spoke as if it were a monstrous thing to conceive the idea of Irishmen in Ireland making spades and shovels when we could buy them elsewhere. Is there any reason why we should not make spades and shovels here, or why our industrial activities should be confined to those, and why we should not have factories established and workers occupied in them making agricultural machinery? It is all very well to talk of restrictions being placed upon the importation of manufactured fertilisers in the pre-war period. It is not true to say that there was a tax on fertilisers. The very reverse was true. There was a bounty paid out of State funds to make cheap fertilisers available to Irish farmers. The existing factories are capable of manufacturing them if we could procure the raw materials and, to an increasing extent, we are getting the raw materials from our own soil.
Comment on this
Did fertilisers arrive on which money was collected?
Comment on this
A certain amount of money appears in the finance accounts as received in respect of phosphates.
Comment on this
Practically nothing was received, if the Deputy will look up the figures. Before the war we had plans for the establishment of a plant to produce nitrogenous fertilisers. I know the opposition that would have been offered by the Fine Gael Party to the establishment of such a plant. They are rather sorry now, as sorry as I am, that these plans did not materialise. In fact, they were upset by the war situation. I think the contract with the Skoda works at Prague, for the erection of the factory here, was signed only a few weeks before the German armies occupied that city, and that made the fulfilment of the contract by that firm impossible. Would it not be better for this country if our industrial policy in relation to that undertaking had been brought into operation earlier and tangible results secured—if we had in this country, not merely factories capable of producing superphosphates, but also nitrogenous fertilisers? Deputies are pressing every day of the week that we should do everything we can to secure supplies of sulphate of ammonia from Great Britain. It is not possible to get increased supplies from that country. Not merely have they not enough for themselves, but it is a munition of war and we cannot get it. But we can reach a situation in which we can produce it ourselves from raw materials in this country.
Every single proposal for an industry from 1932 onwards was opposed by the Deputies opposite. Is it not a good thing that these industries are here now, that their efforts to prevent their establishment were not successful; that these industries are there not merely to give us the goods we need. but also because they strengthen the economic organisation of the country which would be incapable of withstanding the strain of the war situation without them? We can at some stage debate here this policy of free trade, in which Deputy Dillon and Deputy Cosgrave believe, and the policy of industrialisation through protection to which this Government adheres.
Comment on this
Neither Deputy Dillon nor I spoke of free trade.
Comment on this
The Deputy can speak for himself. Deputy Dillon certainly did. Deputy Cosgrave's remarks were as indecisive as they usually are and it is hard to attach any real meaning to them, but they appeared to support the views expressed by Deputy Dillon. The war has produced difficulties. It has made it impossible to pursue the policy that we were operating before the war. It has, in fact, reversed our progress. Deputies, having left the cross-roads, coming in here must face this problem in a constructive way in relation to the facts. I was amazed to hear Deputy Davin speak as he did about the twin problems of unemployment and emigration. What solution did he offer or attempt to offer? Housing. Does any Deputy of the Labour Party think, or does Deputy Davin believe, that it is possible for us to proceed now with a housing programme upon the scale on which we carried it on before the war? Do they not realise that there are required, for the construction of houses, materials which we cannot get and which there is no chance of getting in present circumstances?
There have been references to the modernisation of our transport system. We would all like to embark upon that, but will Deputy Davin tell me how it could be done without steel, without metals of any kind, without any of the materials that would be required in the construction of transport equipment? It is not good enough merely to come in here and talk about the undesirability of emigration. The advantage of preventing emigration by giving our workers employment at home has been pointed out. That is a contention with which we all agree, but has any Deputy given an indication of how it is going to be done?
When Deputy Davin proceeded to reel off the list of works upon which he wanted to see Irish people employed, I was hoping that some new idea would, even by accident, have crept in. Not at all. We had references to afforestation, drainage, land reclamation—all the old proposals which have been debated here again and again. Deputies who were members of the last Dáil know precisely what the Government have done, and what difficulties prevent an expansion of the programmes already embarked upon. The lack of such a simole commodity as rabbit wire, which we cannot under present circumstances procure, makes it impossible for us to embark upon new forestry schemes. The areas which could be planted depend, of course, primarily on the supply of seedlings, which we cannot get in sufficient quantities, and even the mere fencing-in of the young forest trees becomes a matter of impossibility under existing conditions. I may say that there is a great deal being done in the matter of afforestation—all the work that can be done is being done in preparation for a post war development when the materials, that must be procured from abroad, will be obtainable. There is very little more we can do at the moment.
We set up a drainage commission which produced a comprehensive report, a report which has been accepted by the Government. The legislation to implement the findings of that commission is being prepared, but every Deputy knows that many of the projects contemplated for the improvement of drainage are held up by inability to get materials of one kind or another—machinery, tools, equipment —and even fuel. We are up against real difficulties, and we will not be able to surmount those difficulties merely by talking. We cannot effect much by just wishing them out of existence. There is a scarcity of fuel, fuel-oil, petrol, kerosene, and coal. Does any Deputy believe that there is some course open to the Government which would make it possible to get additional supplies of petroleum products?
If we are to have a large-scale productive programme of such dimensions that the emigration of our workers will cease, we must have not only the materials with which to work, but fuel to drive our vehicles and machinery. I read recently in British newspapers that munition factories in England were closed down because of a scarcity of coal. Does any Deputy think that in such circumstances the British are going to give us additional supplies of coal? We are getting substantial quantities of coal, but they are barely sufficient to keep our railway services, our electricity undertakings and our gas undertakings going; all the coal we are getting is required for these essential enterprises that cannot operate without coal. Every day in the week we read of the destruction of oil wells in various parts of the world and we read of the claims of belligerents that they have sunk so many tankers. Modern armies eat petrol. We have no sources of supply and, even if we had sources, we have no ships to carry the fuel to our shores. We have to depend on the goodwill of belligerent powers to get supplies to maintain essential services here.
We cannot have an industrial expansionist policy under such circumstances. If there are ways and means by which we can put large numbers of people into useful activities, there is no reason why it should not be done. There is no financial difficulty—the finances are available. There are large sums voted every year for the financing of public works. If Deputies have concrete and useful suggestions as to how the supply difficulties can be overcome, let them produce those suggestions. I ask and I urge Deputies to do so; I plead with them, in the interests of the unemployed, to get away from generalities and to pool their ideas. Let them not be afraid that their ideas will be subject to hostile criticism. Any Deputy who is in a position to produce constructive ideas will be met in a constructive way by the Government. Useful ideas capable of being put into operation will be welcomed. Of course, ideas submitted by Deputies may, on examination, prove to be impracticable, but they will be gladly received and fairly examined.
Our policy in relation to the temporary emigration that is proceeding has been explained time and again. If Deputies want to alter that policy, let them indicate the alterations they desire. Already we have restricted the emigration of persons under 22 years of age, except in special circumstances. We have also restricted the emigration of farm workers and persons skilled in turf production in the portions of the country where there is a danger of a scarcity of workers to meet the peak requirements of agriculture. In order to offset whatever hardship might be imposed on the workers in these areas, we have arranged for certain compensating factors. We have established a special register of these workers, which means that they will be entitled to receive amounts over and above what is received by those who are in receipt of unemployment assistance. They are also given a preference in the matter of employment upon State-financed schemes, as well as exemption from the Employment Period Orders which operate in the rural areas and which affect other rural workers.
We do not apply restrictions in the congested districts, the scheduled areas, scheduled because of the rather lower level of prosperity which exists in them as compared with the rest of the country. Persons other than those subject to restrictions are allowed to emigrate if they are not in employment and if there is no immediate prospect of employment being available for them. We do not believe we are entitled, in the case of an individual who we know is not employed and for whom there is no immediate prospect of employment, to prevent him getting work elsewhere in order to make suitable provision for himself and for his dependents.
If we can, by any means open to us, increase the opportunities of employment at home, we will do it. There is, in fact, a considerable additional amount of work available in rural areas. It is in the urban areas that the effects of the war on employment have been most severely felt, for obvious reasons. The building trade, for example, has been depressed; the output in that trade has decreased by 75 per cent. since the war began by reason of the dearth of materials. The skilled workers of the building trade cannot be employed; there is little we can do to provide, for the skilled workers in that trade, work at their special vocations. We can undertake schemes which will provide employment for unskilled workers, but for carpenters, bricklayers, electricians and other skilled workers of that sort it is poor compensation to be offered employment, using a spade or a shovel on relief schemes.
The same thing applies to motor mechanics. The number of motor vehicles on the road has decreased by 80 per cent. The services requiring motor mechanics have considerably decreased. You cannot provide for unemployed motor mechanics on relief schemes designed for unskilled labourers. I do not think we are entitled, as regards workers of that kind, for whom there is no prospect of employment while the emergency lasts, to hold them here against their will while there is a chance of temporary employment elsewhere. That is our view.
If Deputies have any suggestions to offer, let them express themselves clearly and indicate precisely what modifications they would be inclined to make in the existing regulations. We must, however, get away from generalities. We all agree with the principle of endeavouring to arrest emigration by increasing the opportunities of work here, but there are practical difficulties in the way. We would like to overcome these difficulties and in that connection we are prepared to consider whatever proposals Deputies may feel inclined to submit to us. If suggestions can be brought forward as to how difficulties that, at the moment, appear to be insurmountable, can be removed, we shall welcome those suggestions. The members of the Labour Party, in particular, should be able to help in this regard because they, through their trade union affiliations, will have personal knowledge of the very material problems that affect employment in many industries. If there is any way by which these problems can be minimised or overcome, they should be in a position to indicate it.
One of the results of the war has been to redress the absence of balance between the remuneration of persons engaged in agricultural pursuits and the remuneration of persons employed in urban pursuits. There has been a considerable improvement in the cash position of farmers. Deputies must not leave that fact out of account. Not merely has the net value of our agricultural output substantially increased, but the cash position of Irish farmers has substantially improved. There has been almost 100 per cent. improvement in the cash income of the Irish farmers as against an increased cost of living of 50 per cent. affecting farmers. Deputy Davin suggested that we should endeavour to offset the difficulties of butter production by giving 1/- a gallon for milk delivered to the creameries. There was behind Deputy Davin's suggestion the idea that an increase in price for milk would automatically result in increased production. I think that that remains to be proven. There is no reason to assume that increased production will automatically follow on an increase in price. It may be so, but the fact is that our records would not appear to support that contention. If Deputies will take the precaution of drawing graphs representing the trend of milk prices and milk production over any period in the past, they will get an astonishing result. They will find that, in fact, the production of milk for manufacture into butter inr creased when the price fell, and decreased when the price rose.
Comment on this
Could you not state that the other way round—that the price fell when the supply increased, and rose when it decreased?
Comment on this
I am not sure that that is the right way to state it. It may be that the individual farmer is content with the income he is getting, and that if that income can be got by lesser effort, he will make only that lesser effort. I do not say that that is so.
Comment on this
The supply of milk is down 30 per cent. in Tipperary and Limerick creameries this year.
Comment on this
The fact is that the price of milk has increased to a greater extent than that of other agricultural products, and far more than the cost of living.
Comment on this
I am merely putting the contention that the assumption that it is axiomatic that increased production will follow upon an increase in price is unsound. In other occupations, that assumption has been proved to be unsound. In our own experience, in the case of workers following dangerous or unattractive occupations, we found that an increase in wages did not result in greater production. The workers preferred to take the benefit of the increased wage in the form of greater leisure to taking it in the form of increased income. The British Government had precisely the same experience in relation to their coal mines. They found that production was being impeded by what was called absenteeism—the unwillingness of workers to work six shifts per week. To offset that absenteeism and to induce workers to work more and produce more, they increased the rate of wages. They found that they were getting a lower output afterwards than they had been getting before; that there was more absenteeism and that the workers preferred to take the benefit of the higher rate of wages in increased leisure to taking it in the form of increased wages. It may be that some similar cause will affect agricultural production here but, clearly, we cannot assume that the whole problem of production is one of price. In the case of milk and of bacon, there is the problem of the supply of feeding stuffs and there is no way by which we can adjust price to overcome the difficulty caused by the inadequate supply of feeding stuffs.
Deputy Davin approached this problem in a typical manner. He recognised that if we were to give 1/- a gallon to the milk producers for milk delivered to creameries and manufactured into butter, there would have to be a higher price for butter. A higher price for butter would not be popular with the people who support Deputy Davin. Therefore, he suggested that the effect of the increased price of milk upon the price of butter should be offset by a subsidy. That is a very glib suggestion, but it requires careful examination by this House. Other Deputies have suggested that other processes should be subsidised. We can provide out of national funds subsidies for particular purposes, but we should do so with considerable hesitation because it is a dangerous course on which to embark. I asked Deputy Davin who would pay the subsidy. He admitted that the subsidy would have to come from taxation. I asked him what tax he would vote for. He will not vote for any tax. That has been the weakness of the Labour Party, and it will remain a weak Party so long as it fails to face up to the unpopular as well as the popular consequences of its policy. It is easy to say that the milk producers should get more for their milk, that nobody should suffer, and that the consumers of butter should not be affected by the higher cost of production. It is easy to make that sort of suggestion, but our consumers and milk producers know that there must be some means found of bridging the gap between the higher price of milk and the cost of the butter manufactured from that milk.
Comment on this
The contention that we could make everybody better off by handing out bank notes at the street corners is just about as sensible as would be a suggestion that we could double supplies by giving everybody two ration books. As Deputy Flanagan knows, one individual might possibly get double supplies by having two ration books.
Comment on this
I am prepared to deal with the whole question of money. Deputy Davin suggested that this higher price which he suggests should be paid to the producers of milk should be provided by means of subsidy. We can provide subsidies by two methods—by taxation and by borrowing. If we provide a subsidy by taxation, we have got to make sure that the people we propose to benefit will be better off as a result of the subsidy. That need not happen. There are certain taxes which can be imposed. There is no use in talking about taxes on luxuries which people can do without or on commodities that are purchased only in limited quantities. The money must be got by a tax on incomes or tobacco or beer or tea or sugar or other commodities which people must buy.
Comment on this
You can easily calculate whether, in fact, the amount the individual will have to pay in tax will be more or less than——
Comment on this
The Deputy must stop interrupting. He is not entitled to a fool's licence here. The other method by which money can be found is by borrowing. I know that the Labour Party have the idea that the temporary difficulties of the war period should be overcome by recourse to borrowing. That is a very dangerous expedient and one that we should only embark upon with a full knowledge of the dangers associated with it. We can, in fact, produce here a position of uncontrollable inflation, and all the economic forces are tending at present to produce an inflationary position. That has always been the case in wartime. The Government here is trying to control that situation, and we have succeeded to an extent, but we are not sufficiently strong to prevent it entirely. Inflationary tendencies, in fact, have already been produced here. We can at least prevent these tendencies from getting out of control, but if we move with them, if we have recourse to borrowing or to the subsidising of prices to an undue extent, then we can let these forces get beyond our control, and, if they do get beyond our control, they will produce in this country precisely the same disastrous effects as they have produced in every other country. There is no reason why we in this country should expect to escape the disastrous results that have followed in other countries as a result of the lack of control of these inflationary tendencies.
I think that the Labour Party have failed the workers of this country in their inability to recognise that it is the workers who will suffer most from inflation here. It is always the workers who suffer in any period of financial instability, whether caused by happenings abroad or by the foolish financial policies adopted by Governments at home. It is always the workers who suffer by such policies. That is a historical fact, and it is easy to find out that it is so. It is not the owners of property or the owners of wealth who suffer as a result of such a policy. The only people who suffer are the workers, who depend on the buying power of their week's wages to get the necessities required for maintenance of themselves and their families. All through history, in times of financial disturbance, it has been the workers who suffered. It was in order to overcome for the time being the disastrous results that follow from inflation that the Government made re-regulations with the object of controlling these inflationary tendencies in the best interests of the workers themselves, because otherwise it is the workers, and only the workers, who would be sacrificed. Inevitably they would have to carry the full burden. They have always had to carry it, all through history, in other countries, and it would be the same here.
I suggest, therefore, that it is not fair for the Labour Party to ignore the consequences of their advice upon the people in whom they are especially interested. We are just as much concerned with the interests of these people as the Labour Party are, and it is because of that that we are exercising controls, unpopular as they may be from a Party point of view, that may arrest or at least slow down the various inflationary tendencies that are at work.
I urge that the problems—the very real problems—that this country is facing, should be approached in a constructive way here in the House. Of course, we all made speeches in the elections which were designed to appeal to the emotions rather than the intelligence of our audiences. It is not possible, in an election campaign, to approach these matters in the same way as one can approach them in the calmer atmosphere of this House. Statements are made at election meetings, at the cross-roads through the country, which cannot be critically examined or verified, but the atmosphere in this House is different, and no contention that is made here should be accepted until it is proven, or no alleged fact accepted until it is verified; nor is any policy worth following until all its implications have been worked out. That is why Deputies here should approach these problems, not in the spirit of election meetings at the cross-roads, but in that of people coming here, to a legislative Assembly, for the purpose of producing a policy in the best interests of the country. Every Deputy here has the same right. Everybody is here as a representative of the people and is entitled to respect, as such. Whatever his ideas may be, whether we agree with them or not, those ideas are entitled to be seriously considered and examined, and I ask Deputies here to approach our problems in that spirit.
The problems that we have to face are very considerable. We had very grave problems to face before the election, but it is my conviction that the problems we had to face then will fade into insignificance compared with the problems we shall have to face in the future. The longer the war lasts, the greater will our problems become, and if increased activity between the belligerents should develop around the coast of this country, following the establishment of a Second Front, then we shall be faced in a very short time, both in regard to supplies and other matters, with very severe hardships for our people, unless we can ensure that the burden will rest evenly on all section and that no section will have to bear these burdens unduly.
I think, Sir, that I have referred to all the matters that were raised in this connection. Various matters were referred to last week, but I think we shall have an opportunity of dealing with them again. Unfortunately, the Vote in connection with my Department has already been dealt with, which deprives me of the opportunity of throwing back the missiles that, I am sure, would be thrown at me. However, in connection with the Vote for which I am responsible, particular problems will be adverted to, and I want to say that I quite recognise the incapacity of any individual, or any group of individuals, to provide perfect solutions for all of them, and that it will take the combined brains of the whole Dáil to secure solutions for them. In my opinion, the only way to secure solutions is by a critical examination of these problems by all Deputies in this House, and if there is merit in any proposals put forward by Deputies of this House, no matter from what side, that merit will soon emerge, and if it is there, then I promise that such proposals will be taken into account, and that legislation will be introduced to make them effective.
Comment on this
In the course of the debate during the last two days, emphasis has fallen more on agriculture than on any other item. It is true that agriculture is our principal industry and, as such, is deserving of the most serious consideration which it has received in the debates here for the last two days. It would appear from the various speeches that have been made that the position of our country, when the war is over, will have to be considered, and that when the various armies or war workers are disbanded and sent back here we will have to see how far it is possible to make provision for them, and extra emphasis is laid on the necessity of planning now for that provision. As long as I can remember, I have listened to wise people in this country saying, from time to time: "Well, when all is said and done we will have to get our people back to the land; that is the solution of our problem." I believe that it is that attitude that creates the problem—why they "have to." Why is it necessary, in connection with the principal industry of the country, to have to apply compulsion in order to make the getting into that industry a matter of reality? You have that running underneath the whole tillage scheme. We have had a lot of criticism of that scheme and of its result. The tillage scheme has shown, in fact, that we have not got, under a compulsory tillage scheme, the results that we should really expect under ordinary tillage. Why? Because of the "have to", the compulsion. People who are compelled to do something will do it reluctantly. People who do something because they are attracted to it and because they find it advantageous will do it much better. The Minister for Agriculture, or anybody else who may be studying statistics and wondering why it is that we have not got from 500,000 acres of tilled land a yield in proportion to that which we got from 250,000 acres, must remember that the cultivation of the 500,000 acres was the result of compulsion, whereas the work of cultivating the 250,000 acres was freely undertaken by people who had a personal interest in it. The moment anything is made compulsory, the people will comply with the law, but the will to succeed is not there. The personal interest and good husbandry necessary to make tillage a success are absent. There may be other explanations for the disappointing yield. Bad harvesting seasons and the absence of labour have been responsible for substantial losses. I suggest that some scheme by which the standing Army or the labour corps would be made available to assist the farmers during the harvesting season is essential.
We have to remember that our principal industry, agriculture, must absorb the great majority of those of our people who are bound to become unemployed when the war is over. We will have to plan for the creation of that employment, that absorption of our people, so that they will not merely go back to agriculture as a last resort but will find that work as lucrative and as attractive as any other occupation. We have listened to Deputies from the Fine Gael Benches claiming that the line of action adopted by them many years ago in regard to agriculture was the proper one. Statistics have been quoted to prove that. We had Deputies from the Fianna Fáil Benches indicating that their line of action was a better one, and they had figures to prove that. We had farmers and Labour Deputies participating, over a number of years, in a definite Party programme. We have to anticipate that large numbers of our people will come back here when hostilities are over, and the only industry here which is capable of absorbing them is agriculture. We must bring the standard of living of those who are engaged on that occupation up to the level of that enjoyed by people engaged on other occupations. We have heard complaints from Deputies about the appalling tragedy that agricultural workers can receive only 30/- or 36/- a week, whereas those engaged in other occupations receive a much higher wage. Is it any wonder then that we have the problem of the flight from the land? Is it any wonder that the farmers are unable to find workers to help them with the harvest which they are compelled, and rightly compelled, to put in and save because the needs of the community require it? I suggest that we ought to tackle this problem seriously, and the only way in which we can hope to absorb our people who come back here is by bringing the standard of living of those engaged in agriculture, the industry in which we must find employment for them, up to the level enjoyed by people in other industries. Give them the same wage, give them the same conditions of employment, give them the same facilities, give them, as nearly as possible, the same atmosphere of convenience, and there will be no hesitancy. It will not be a question of having to go back to the land, they will go back willingly.
We have had, not only here, but I suppose in other countries also, legislation dealing with conditions of employment of workers, wages of workers, holidays for workers, and various other amenities of that sort. To what extent have those conditions any application to the farmers of this country? How many of them get a holiday with pay? What about their hours of employment? What about their Sunday work? Is there any extra payment for that? I suggest that no Government in this country has ever seriously tackled our fundamental problem, the improvement of conditions in our principal industry. I suggest that we ought to set up an agricultural board, representing the biggest industry in this country; an industrial board representing the industrialists of this country, and a labour board representing the workers of this country. Those three responsible boards must come together and settle the problem, which is an internal one. There is no use whatever in trying to do this sectionally. One section of the farmers will look for an increased price for dairy produce; another section will look for an increased price for tillage products, a bounty on wheat, a bounty on potatoes, and so on. If they get away with it, for the time being that section has improved its position. The same applies to the workers; the same applies to the business people. They all have great power if they are organised, but unfortunately all that they achieve is the temporary alleviation of sectional grievances. The advancement of the interests of the community as a whole has never been seriously tackled. I may be told that it would be difficult to set up a board representing the farmers of this country and their agricultural interests. I say that it is no more difficult to do that than it is to set up a board representing the electricity supply interests, or a board representing or controlling any other industry. Let those people come together, realising that, unless each section of the community gets a fair share out of the total pool, then condiditions are wrong. I believe that by setting up such an organisation we could arrive at a fine balance between the various interests and the various industries which compose the entity of our economic life here. I do not believe that our tillage programme is giving that result. I am quite satisfied that it is not. I believe that, in order to make our tillage scheme a success, it would have to be much more seriously considered and applied than it is at present. We should not be content with telling the farmers that they have to till the land. The planning of tillage should be considered by scientists in advance.
There are areas which are particularly suitable for the growing of certain types of crops. I know districts in which there is very poor land, but much better potatoes can be grown on that land than on land that is regarded of superior quality. Wheat growing areas do exist in this country but the haphazard method of compulsory increased tillage, without the smallest consideration as to the suitability of the soil for the production of wheat as against the production of oats, barley or potatoes, reveals the absence of any considered plan. The production of wheat, if it is to be continued in this country, must be conducted along lines which, while yielding an economic price to producers, will enable consumers to buy it at a price that will in turn enable them to engage in other activities the products of which have to be sold in competition with the products of other countries. The wheat areas will have to be defined, the necessary machinery for the tillage will have to be available on the spot, and the amount of labour involved will have to be reduced to the minimum. Harvesting facilities will have to be concentrated in particular areas so that the necessary number of workers will be available to ensure that, in our uncertain climate, the maximum of the crops can be saved.
In my opinion, the country could be divided into areas in which wheat, oats, barley, or other crops could be most successfully grown. A system of that kind will have to be rigidly applied unless the export markets are capable of absorbing the entire surplus of our agricultural produce. Nobody is so optimistic, I think, as to believe that that will happen, but unless it should come to pass I am afraid that we shall have to limit the production of pigs and poultry to the poorer areas so as to provide the small farmer with an outlet for the employment of the members of his family. I can visualise, if the worst comes to happen, that the 30 or 40 acre farm, which we have come to regard as the standard size economic holding, may very well disappear, and that, instead, we shall have to cater for farms of from two to five acres. In my opinion, if a planned constructive policy were put into operation, we would get much better results from farms of that kind than we are at present getting from our present farms ranging in extent from 30 acres to a couple of thousand acres. I can see the agricultural industry—and it is our main industry—surviving only after we have brought our experts to produce a plan to show us the most economic methods of utilising the land for the production of the various crops we need.
Similarly, I can see the dairying industry surviving only by the adoption of a system which will ensure a more intensive milk yield from each cow fed on the land. That can be done in two ways. One is by the encouragement of cows with a high milk-yielding strain. In that connection, I suggest that a very serious situation is developing. The price paid for young heifers for export likely to become good milch cows has risen to such an extent that there has been a considerable diminution in the number of such young cattle now left in the country. We shall have to deal with the specific problem of increasing the milk yield of our cows, if dairying is to be continued on an economic basis. That is recognised by the Department of Agriculture and steps have been taken by the Department to encourage an increase in the number of cows of the best milking strain. That is a very difficult problem, but anybody who has an elementary knowledge of the production of heifers will know the uncertainties attached to cattle-breeding. Where you are waiting and hoping to get a heifer calf, you may get a male calf and you are then thrown back along the line. While waiting for the production of a milking strain, the farmer may be compelled to sell the cow with a chance of "springing" in order to realise ready cash. His whole effort of years is frustrated in that way. I suggest that the Department of Agriculture should step in, take a census of all cattle that, in their judgment, are suitable for producing a milking strain and endeavour to retain these in the country, even if it should be necessary to pay the farmer a subsidy for the retention of these cattle. The farmers might be paid subsidies to keep suitable heifers in stock just as farmers are paid premiums for the maintenance of suitable bulls. If heifers were subsidised in that way, a satisfactory foundation stock might be retained and farmers would be encouraged to produce cattle of a milking strain and so make the most of their land from the dairying point of view.
Comment on this
In addition to the development of high-yielding milk strains amongst our cattle, farmers should be encouraged to cultivate crops suitable for winter feeding or winter dairying. That is just one point on which our dairying industry has failed to maintain its position. The Deputy asked if I had engaged in dairying. I have, and engaged in it successfully. Twenty-five years ago, and even long before that, there was a tradition on the farm on which I was reared of using grass in a very scientific way, as ensilage. Speaking from experience, I can say that the use of grass as ensilage is very beneficial for winter dairying. It is at least as good as the best hay that can be saved from the same field plus the cabbage which any dairying farmer knows is one of the best milk-yielding adjuncts that can be utilised on a farm. I know that the Department has encouraged the use of ensilage in recent years. The method which I inherited was a very old-fashioned method. The grass was built in the open and there was considerable loss as a result of air penetrating from the outside. Modern methods have adopted the use of a silo in which the grass is put and ought in the ordinary way prevent that wastage from the outside caused by the penetration of the air. But, unfortunately, I found that where many of these silos have been built under grants from the Department of Agriculture, for some reason the wastage there, too, has been excessive. I do not know whether it is due to the carelessness of those who used it, or what is the cause but the grass has sagged away from the silo concrete, and wherever that occurred, again there is wastage.
I would recommend that the Department of Agriculture should endeavour with their utmost efforts to ensure that those silos which have been subsidised should be so successful that farmers generally will adopt them, because, speaking from experience, I know they are of great value for the winter production of milk and their general adoption would to a large extent contribute to the success of the dairying industry.
As regards pigs, I heard criticism here yesterday from Deputy Dillon. He cited a case where a fair was held somewhere and there were no buyers at it. The result was that the pigs had to be sold below the fixed price, at whatever price was offered for them. Owing to the absence of the required number of buyers, the market was flat and that was the reason for the sale of the pigs below the fixed price. I have known it to occur, too, but I must say this in fairness to the Pigs Marketing Board, that on my taking up a similar case in Mohill last year, the Pigs Marketing Board immediately made provision for the arrival of a buyer in Mohill. Every pig was taken from the fair, earmarked, and sent to the factory, and full payment was sent back the following week.
If Deputies would only realise their full duties instead of making contentious points at a later date they could be of immense value to the people among whom they live. The Pigs Marketing Board is clearly not a satisfactory board, in the opinion of the great majority of pig producers. A statement was made by Deputy Dillon in this House, and I cannot believe that any Deputy would make an untrue statement here, that he invested £300 in a bacon curing factory and that two years afterwards he was presented with £900, showing 300 per cent. profit. If that be the fact, there is no question whatever about it that these bacon curing factories have been extracting extortionate profits from the pig producers, and I say that the matter is one that should be fully examined. It is a statement made by a responsible Deputy, and even if it were far less than it is—if the profits were only 100 per cent., or even 50 per cent., or even 33? per cent.—these profits are excessive and it is the duty of the Government to ensure that the farmer who produces the raw material should have a share of the profits at the manufacturing end. The bacon curing factories of this country should be under the control of the farmers who produce pigs just the same as the creameries are under the control of the farmers who produce the milk. I see no serious difficulties in the way of this at all.
Again, as regards this problem of having to go back to the land, surely it is past the stage when we have to do that. "Back to the land or die of starvation." Land does not belong to the farmers; it never did. The farmers are trustees. They hold land as owners, but in every period of time, in every country in the world, whenever the country is in stress and the land of the country is required to provide for the whole of the people, the alleged ownership of the individual farmer is set aside. He is compelled to use his land, so far as it can be used, to provide the needs of the whole of the community and not as he considers he should use it himself. If that be so, why not try to make the lives of those engaged in that essential occupation more attractive than they have been?
Look at all the trouble we have had in trying to encourage Governments to give small grants to build a bit of a road to a farmer's house, to build a bit of a road to the bog or to do a bit of drainage that would relieve the farmers from flooding. From my experience I say that the farmers I know, if they were not herculean, would not have withstood the miseries they have had to undergo. They are compelled to pay rates to build steam-rolled roads—roads which they rarely use, and which are generally a menace to them and to their vehicles. The men who are compelled to build these roads often have to plough with their pony or donkey and cart over a field sodden with rain, and I have known children going to school ploughing over that sodden track and getting their feet wet through before they reach the main road. Bringing home the turf in wet seasons is the same. That is the occupation we feel we will have to utilise if a real emergency comes. Is it any wonder that we use the expression "have to go back to the land"? Farmers go out and do a bit of tillage in an emergency period. They know the risk they run, but there is increased tillage. When they have done that, as I have seen last year, their crops are often destroyed or carried away, if not covered by water.
It is not necessary to wait for the application of a big national drainage scheme to remedy many of these grievances, but they are left unattended to and the flooding brings ruin to those families. When crops are destroyed they are a national loss and still the Department—I do not know why—are unable to act. A little redress could mend a lot of things, but there is too much rigidness in the Departments. The work does not belong to the Land Commission, although they are operating in the area; it does not belong to Local Government or the county council, although they are also operating in the area; it belongs to another section. There are all these water-tight compartments of officials operating in an area where abuse is apparent, and still it is nobody's duty, and the difficulties go on and remain, and in face of that we wonder why our people want to leave the countryside. We wonder they do not find great enjoyment in sodden feet and children travelling through the mud to school because of the absence of a road, although they have been contributing to the making of roads so magnificent that they are incapable of travelling in safety on them when they do not own motor cars.
There is the picture as I see it, and I suggest that the problem can only be faced in this way: that the conditions of those engaged in the major industry of this country will have to be brought up to a level similar to that of those engaged in any other industry—Civil Service, business or transport, let it be what it is. Conditions, with holiday facilities, will have to be improved for everybody engaged in that national industry. Their lives and home surroundings will have to be brought up to the level of the suburban dweller in the city. It can be done. We are a small, poor community. There is no use in fighting sectionally—labour demanding increased wages for one section and forgetting another; farmers demanding increases for dairying and others demanding increased bonuses or bounties for tillage farming, and industrialists demanding protection for their products. They are all engaged, each fighting the other sectionally within the one field. Let us pool our resources. Let us have an industrial board and a business board, and see that even justice is distributed to each person engaged in these industries. Until that is done, in my opinion, all the Parties we send to the Dáil will do nothing more than defeat their own ends and achieve nothing.
Comment on this
This debate has been remarkable in one way, that we have had from Deputy Corry, sitting on the Government Benches, probably the most striking indictment of the Government's agricultural policy that has yet been delivered in the House in the course of this debate. The Deputy quoted from a wealth of statistics which he assured the House he had taken great care to prepare and still greater care to analyse. He told us that, notwithstanding the fact that we have a Prices Commission in operation, and notwithstanding the other virtues which I am sure he claims for the Government, the people who are engaged in the production of small seeds for agriculture were at present getting away with swag estimated at a profit of 250 per cent. on the prices which they are paying for the seeds to the producers. Deputy Corry quoted the prices of mangold, turnip, rape and other seeds. He gave us the prices which the producers are paid for these seeds, and told us the price which the farmers have to pay for the seeds to the retailers. He finally worked out the percentage profit on all these small seeds at about 250 per cent. He then asked the question: what is going to be done about it—piously hoping that the Government might do something about it. It seems to me that even if half of what Deputy Corry has said is correct, and I am prepared to discount his statement by 50 per cent., you get at a situation in which he admits, as a member of the Government Party, that the profits on the production of small seeds are about 125 per cent. His own figure was approximately 250 per cent.
Deputy Corry also told us of the way in which his heart bleeds for the farmers who produce barley. He told us that Messrs. Guinness and Co. are compelled to pay the British farmers 70/- a barrel for barley, but that the Fianna Fáil Minister for Agriculture has such a benevolent interest in Messrs. Guinness and Co., that he would only permit them to pay 35/- a barrel for barley to the Irish farmer. Messrs. Guinness and Co. are paying 35/- a barrel for Irish barley and are sending it to Britain in the form of stout, although in Britain they are compelled to pay 70/- a barrel for barley of the same quality which they are also converting into stout in Britain. I think Deputy Corry was quite right when he asked for an answer to the question: why the Irish farmer will not be allowed to make his own price with a millionaire firm like that of Messrs. Guinness? Why is our farmer being exploited in the interests of Messrs. Guinness; why is he being tied down to a maximum price of 35/- a barrel for barley when he sells it to Messrs. Guinness, while the latter is compelled to pay 70/- a barrel for barley in the Six Counties and in Britain? We ought to have an answer to these questions in the course of this debate, because it seems to me incomprehensible that farmers, endeavouring in present circumstances to grow barley on small holdings and with heavy domestic commitments, should be compelled to sell their barley to Messrs. Guinness when that firm is apparently quite willing to pay 70/- a barrel for barley bought in Britain for the production of stout to be sold there.
Apart from these statements made by Deputy Corry, and apart from his indictment of the Government's policy in not controlling prices and of the manner in which it allows the farmers to be fleeced by everybody who regards the farmer as a good chicken to pluck, there are aspects of this discussion on agriculture which are of outstanding importance to the nation as a whole.
The one aspect of agricultural policy upon which there is general agreement is that, notwithstanding that we have very fertile land which is the envy of many other countries in Europe, we are, nevertheless, in the position that the acreage under corn and root crops in normal times has continued to drop calamitously. There was a fall in the acreage under corn and root crops between 1921 and 1929, and even if you take the period 1936 to 1939 there was another fall in the acreage under corn and root crops. It cannot be said that the fall between 1921 and 1929 or between 1926 and 1939 was explained by the absence of fertilisers. There was an abundance of fertilisers available in those years, but yet the application of two agricultural policies, by two different Governments, did not succeed in arresting the decrease in the acreage under corn and root crops. Even to-day, in the midst of war and as a beleaguered nation in this the fourth year of the war, we find, notwithstanding compulsory tillage, a relatively stagnant position in regard to agricultural production. The best evidence of that is to be found in the fact that here in this country with 12,000,000 acres of arable land available for cultivation, we are experiencing, and have experienced, a shortage of sugar, a shortage of bacon, a shortage of eggs, and, in some areas, a shortage of milk, a shortage of flake meal, and recently a fairly extensive shortage of potatoes.
I would like to hear some member of the Government Party endeavour to explain to us why, with 12,000,000 acres of arable land available and with 80,000 acres of that land capable of giving us all the sugar we require, we should be short of sugar in a country possessed of such agricultural potentialities. Why are we short of flake meal in a country with 12,000,000 acres of arable land available, 9,000,000 acres of which are not under cultivation to-day? Last year we had the Government Press organ telling us that there was a shortage of sugar because approximately 54,000 acres only were under beet.
This year the acreage under beet has jumped to approximately 80,000. Why? Because, in the meantime, the farmer was encouraged by better prices to grow beet. If the farmers had been encouraged—it is the job of the Government to encourage the farmer and not to drive him—to grow more beet we need not have had any sugar shortage last year; we need not have a sugar shortage to-day, and a sugar shortage need never recur in this country. The fact that there is a shortage of all these primary products in a country abounding in fertility and in arable land is, it seems to me, the clearest indictment of the type of agricultural policy which has been pursued here over the past 21 years.
I think anybody who has given any thought to the matter will recognise that the land of this country is our greatest source of wealth. The use we make of that land determines the standard of living for every man, woman and child living here. Agriculture to-day represents our greatest source of employment. Out of every 100 persons gainfully employed in this country no less than 57 get their livelihood in agriculture. Every farm in this country is an agricultural factory, and we would be fools if we did not realise the great wealth that resides in the land, and still greater fools if we did not exploit that wealth in absorbing a greater number of our people into employment.
Deputy Maguire who has just sat down, put his finger on some important aspects of our agricultural policy and of our national activities which, I think, deserve attention. Like myself, he apparently agrees that agriculture is capable of absorbing more of our people into employment. In the world into which we shall be precipitated after the war, unless we develop our agricultural potentialities to a much greater extent, we shall be faced with a post-war situation which from the unemployment point of view will be without parallel so far as this country is concerned. Remember that approximately 350,000 of our people have gone to Britain in the past ten years and that there are large numbers of our people in the British armed forces to-day. One of these days the guns will cease to bark, peace will reign again, armies will be demobilised in a chaotic and disordered world, and nations will seek to give first preference to their own citizens. We may be in a situation then in which we shall not have to send to America for emigrants because we shall have hundreds of thousands of them dumped back on us from Britain.
Has anybody given any thought at all to the situation which would arise here if we were suddenly notified by the British Government that they were providing transport to send back a quarter of a million of our people? Remember that these people will not have come from cloisters. These people will have been in bombed and blitzed cities in Britain where they will have been earning high wages and living under conditions which taught them that courage, strength and physical endurance, and not cheque books, were the real things that mattered in life. They will have seen wealthy people fall under the rain of bombs; they will have seen, the biggest buildings and mansions tumble down in dust; and they will have seen the most gigantic ships and the most gigantic guns made powder under the instruments of death produced there. If these people come back they will not be quiet. They cannot be led around by the hand. If a quarter of a million of these people, having experienced a new life, having a new outlook on life, and having a new determination and a new objective in life, are suddenly thrown back here, will not a nice situation confront this country?
What do we propose to do in such a situation? So far as I can discover, this Government has no plan whatever for expanding agriculture, for expanding the production of goods which will probably be in greater demand when the war is over than at any time previously. The Government appear to have no plans whatever for expanding agriculture, either because the products of agriculture will be marketable the world over, or as a means of absorbing into that constructive, reproductive craft the large numbers of our people who will inevitably be thrown back on this country when the war concludes.
The Minister for Agriculture some time ago went to Cork to deliver a lecture on agriculture. I read that lecture twice. It was a recital of the De Profundis over post-war agriculture in this country. No bleaker or more miserable picture was painted for the farmers than was painted by that Minister in the course of his lecture in Cork last year. The big problem, of course, which confronts agriculture to-day, and which has always confronted agriculture in the circumstanees of this country, is that the farmers are financially impoverished. They have not sufficient liquid capital to enable them to stock or work their lands, and that want of capital has prevented the farmer from exploiting his land sufficiently to intensify the production of wealth or to enable him to employ additional labour. Any enlightened agricultural policy must break with the tradition which keeps the farmer financially impoverished. and withholds from him the necessary capital to enable him to exploit his land to the fullest.
One of the essentials, if we are to rehabilitate and re-vitalise agriculture, is to make available to the farmer loans free of interest in order to enable him to stock his land, to purchase implements to use on his land, to fence, drain and to fertilise his land, so that he may engage in the tillage of land instead of the quarrying of land which unfortunately is the position on many farms throughout the country to-day. But, even then, you would have done nothing more than to touch the fringe of the farmer's problem. One of the biggest difficulties confronting the farmer is the price he can get for his produce. The industrialist can fix a price and be sure of getting that price because his commodity is in demand. The worker, in so far as he is organised in a protective organisation, such as a trade union, can make some effort to fix the price at which he will sell his labour. The farmer, unfortunately, is not so well organised and the State does not take in him the interest it ought to take, with the result that, except in the stress of war, the farmer has been compelled to rely upon any price he can get in the market for his produce.
There has been a welcome departure from that policy in recent years, but it has been a departure not of a very satisfactory character for the farmer, because the prices which have been fixed for agricultural produce have not been prices which have given the farmer an adequate return for his labour. An enlightened agricultural policy must take note of the necessity for giving the farmer a decent price for his produce, just as every other person in the country is entitled to get a decent return for his labour. That can best be done by giving the farmer a guaranteed price which will take note of his costs and of the standard of living which the farming community is entitled to enjoy. If the farmer is given a decent price for his produce, it must go hand in hand with ensuring for the agricultural workers a wage which will raise them above the agricultural serfdom in which many of them are wallowing to-day.
The test of prosperity in agriculture is not the number of fat cattle a rancher can sell, and not the price or the income which the wheat rancher can get. The test of prosperity in agriculture is the standard of living in the homes of the agricultural workers of the country, and if one were to go through the homes of agricultural workers in the country, one would find there an appallingly low standard of living, a standard of living which does violence to those pious expressions of economic security and prosperity which are enshrined in the new Constitution. Fancy, in 1943, an agricultural worker being expected to keep himself, his wife and six children for seven days a week on 36/-. Fancy 36/- being our conception of the standard of living we ought to give to an agricultural worker, his wife and children. Fancy taking 36/- into a clothing shop in this city or in any provincial town to-day and trying to clothe a family of eight with that sum. Fancy trying to buy boots and shoes for children, to buy bread and butter at 2/- a lb. for a family of eight with that amount. We allow 5/- per day to keep that family of eight. The detention of some of our people as miscreants in jails throughout the country probably costs more than we are paying sturdy. honest, hard-working agricultural workers to keep themselves, their wives and families. That is a situation which is blandly allowed to continue. Nobody apparently feels that there is any Governmental obligation to remedy such a condition.
Probably the most striking contrast is at political meetings in the country. or after Mass in the country. There is no hesitation whatever in picking out the agricultural worker. He is badly clad, he has bad boots, he is obviously undernourished. His children bear the hallmark of their father being an agricultural worker. They are badly clad and, in the main, they are in their bare feet. Such clothes as they have are in tatters. In the home of the agricultural worker the same blighting poverty exists.
To me at all events it seems the plight of the agricultural worker is the most appalling reflection on our assertions here that we are steering this country on the road to prosperity. Unless we can rescue the agricultural worker and the small farmer from the stagnant condition in which they are to-day, from the poverty and misery which abound in their homes, we need never claim to have made any effective contribution towards agricultural prosperity.
I am sorry Deputy Dillon is not in the House at the moment. We had yesterday from that Deputy a characteristic free-trade speech. Deputy Dillon believes that the one solution of all our problems in this country is to buy in the cheapest market and, of course, sell in Deputy Dillon's spiritual home, Britain. I do not believe in a policy of buying in the cheapest market, because if you develop that policy you will often buy goods produced under coolie conditions of labour. In any case, as a nation, our problem is to provide a living and a livelihood for our people. If we accept the philosophy of buying in the cheapest market, we ought to close down every industry in this country to-day. We ought to give up tilling in peace times. We ought even to give up ranching in peace times because every commodity that is produced here, every article of clothing that we wear, every article of household furniture, can be produced more cheaply in some other part of the world than it is produced here. If you think of buying eggs, you can buy Chinese eggs. If you think of buying poultry, you can buy Polish or Chinese poultry. If you think of buying butter, you can buy butter in countries where it is sold cheaper than it is produced and sold here.
The suggestion of buying in the cheapest market is the crystallisation of a free trade outlook. While that policy may have suited Britain, it is a policy which never suited the economic destiny of this country. Deputy Dillon, of course, I know, believes that the British market is the best market. In my view, the best market for our people is the home market, because it is in the home market, and only in the home market, that you can control prices, that you can regulate the conditions of production and marketing, and it is because you have control over these vital factors that-the home market is the valuable market for our people.
The British market is a market exposed to every economic, fiscal and agricultural wind that blows. Production for sale in the British market exposes to competition with every country in the world which has agricultural or industrial products to sell. Some of these countries may have natural advantages in respect of agricultural production; or may have advantages in respect of high capitalisation of industries, scientific machinery for the production of goods and patents which enable them to produce goods under conditions under which we could not produce them here.
It seems to me our task here is to cultivate, as far as possible, the home market for our own people. I realise, of course, that we must sell our surplus commodities in order to import other commodities which are not produced here, but in the past what we have been selling abroad has not been our surplus products. We have been selling abroad products which were not surplus to our requirements but which could not be consumed here because of low wages; large scale unemployment, and endemic poverty in many parts of the country. I hope that, in the interests of our people, whatever the complexion of future Governments may be, each and every one of them will abandon the policy of free trade in agricultural and industrial production, because free trade, as we have seen it in operation under an alien Government and to some extent under a native Government, has given us a depopulated countryside, has given us a situation in which the bullocks have increased while our men and women, pride of every nation, have been driven to the emigrant ship, forced to seek elsewhere the livelihood that was denied them here.
Deputy Dillon, in the course of his remarks yesterday, appeared to me to regard industrial development as the one and only enemy of agriculture. Deputy Dillon appeared to imagine that if you produce in this country buckets, ploughs, spades, forks, agricultural boots or any of these commodities which the farmer requires for his domestic life or his agricultural work, immediately you become an enemy of the farmer. I do not believe that. I do not see any conflict between the development of our secondary industries and the protection of our agricultural industry. One has only to go to Sweden to see land used to the fullest possible advantage and gigantic works and factories manufacturing goods for industrial use. They are not merely manufacturing them for Swedish use. At the docks in Sweden you will find freights of machinery labelled for every country in the world. One of the things that strike one about Denmark is that, while it is largely an agricultural country, it has some excellent industries. There, again, one sees the products of Denmark being sent to almost every country in the world. The Danes do not put all their eggs in one basket. They do not depend solely upon agriculture as a means of livelihood and a way of life. They developed agriculture to the fullest, it is true, but, at the same time, they did not neglect the development of their secondary industries.
What Sweden and Denmark can do in permitting industry and agriculture to develop side by side, one complementary to the other, we ought to be able to do here. The example of these small countries ought to be an object lesson for us. We ought not to take as our pattern and our guide the agricultural and industrial methods in a country which is an empire, controlling probably 20 per cent. of the world's surface. It is noteworthy that Sweden and Denmark are the two countries in Europe where the workers and the mass of the people enjoy a standard of living not approached by our workers or by industrial workers in any other country in Europe to-day. In Denmark and Sweden one does not see the insulting wealth that is visible in other countries. One does not see the poor in the slums and the hovels that one sees here and in other countries.
Denmark and Sweden have been able to balance their agricultural production with industrial production. We ought to aim at a policy of that kind here. There are some people, particularly new industrialists, who imagine that once you start a factory and employ some people, nothing else matters but to develop the factory and maintain the industry. I take a different view. In a country such as this the great bulk of our population and the great bulk of our customers are in the rural areas. If you cannot make agriculture prosperous then you can get no prosperity in the towns and cities. If the farmer and the agricultural worker are impoverished by low wages, then there is no demand for the goods produced in the factories in the towns and cities. There is no employment in the shops, there is no employment in the offices. If you can bring prosperity to agriculture by giving the farmer guaranteed prices, on the one hand, and the workers a guaranteed wage on the other hand, then you will immediately set up in the rural areas a demand for the goods produced in the city and town factories, you will create a demand for the goods shops have to sell, you will create a demand for the services available in the towns and cities, and you will provide employment in the commercial offices, in consequence of that trading activity. If you can create that prosperity in agriculture on the one hand, then the demand for the goods which agriculture requires will in turn provide a substantial amount of employment for town and city workers. When you provide employment for town and city workers, you, on the other hand, set up a demand for the goods which farmers have produced in the rural areas and are willing to sell at a fair price. In that way you create an ever-widening circle of prosperity from the rural areas into the towns and cities, radiating back into the rural areas again. But that policy requires for its success the adoption of good prices for agricultural products, good wages for workers who are employed in towns and cities and on the land, regular work, the abandonment of emigration as a solution for unemployment, and the organisation of the nation on the basis of the eradication of the stagnation which, unfortunately, is such a feature of our agricultural and industrial life.
In all this situation money, of course, plays a vital part. In the old days it, was thought to be the business only of financiers to be interested in the part which money plays and the functions of money. There is a more enlightened opinion abroad to-day. Throughout the world a new school of thought, an intelligent progressive school of thought, has come into being, a school of thought which recognises that money is an instrument of production and exchange, that with money controlled by the State and made available by the State you can induce the creation of new wealth; and with that new wealth made available that you can issue money in the form of State credits or currency anchored to the new wealth which has been created and financed by the new wealth which has been created, and that that type of guarantee for the issue of State credits is of a much more enduring kind than the type of money which is being issued to-day without any gold backing whatever.
Britain has long ceased to have any gold backing for her money; Britain has ceased to have any backing at all for her money in the form of currency; Britain is issuing millions and millions and millions of pounds every day, the backing for which is not gold or agricultural production, but the gigantic armament programme to which the British Government is committed. Britain is not an exception in that respect. Germany, Italy, the United States and Russia have all long since abandoned gold as a backing for their money. They are backing their note issues by the expectation that they will win the war and that, having won the war, they will he able to settle down to the creation of wealth that will justify the continuance in circulation of the money which was issued without any gold backing during the war situation. If Britain can, with the benediction of her former orthodox financiers issue money backed not by constructive work, but by the manufacture of implements of death, is it not much easier for us, in our circumstances here, to issue State credits which will induce the production of wealth, so long as these State credits are anchored to sound constructive work the exploiting of our land, and the creation of new wealth with a new outlook for our people?
I do not want to delay the House further on this matter, because I understand there is a kind of tacit agreement to finish the Vote on Account to-night. I do, however, want to say that unless we recognise the fundamental need for a change in our agricultural methods, for an abandonment of that hopelessly stagnant conservative outlook with which we have been afflicted for the past 21 years, then this Dáil will go out of existence, and ten other Dála will come and go, and yet the position of agriculture will be just as bad and just as stagnant as it is. I would urge on the Government and on everybody interested in the creation of a prosperous agricultural industry that we should pool our best thoughts on the matter so as to endeavour to rescue agriculture from the morass into which it has been allowed to sink during the last 21 years under native Governments. I believe the policy of this Government is not calculated to rescue agriculture from its present unsatisfactory position. However long the Government may remain in office. I urge them during whatever time is available to them to recognise that their past methods have given most unsatisfactory results. After nearly four years of war, they have given us a shortage of primary products. There must be an abandonment of methods and policies which have given such unsatisfactory results, and a reliance on methods more calculated to stimulate agriculture and to give the agricultural community a better return for their excellent services in the production of food for the nation.
Comment on this
I am interested in this debate mainly so far as it concerns agriculture, and particularly mixed farming. The most important product of mixed farming is milk, and the present price of milk is not economic. Milk cannot be sold below the cost of production. Pig feeding, which is also important in connection with mixed farming, has declined very much. If an increased price were given for pigs, the scarcity that exists would not continue. The poultry industry is also an important one, especially in the poorer districts. That industry should have received more attention from the Minister for Agriculture than it has received, and I hope that more attention will be paid to it in the future. With regard to the pig industry, I suggest that the abolition of the Pigs Marketing Board ought to be considered by the Minister, and that a minimum price should be fixed for pigs. The holding of fairs in country towns should be encouraged, because, since pig production went down, these towns and villages have deteriorated.
I would ask the Minister for Local Government to consider the position of old age pensioners. I have had experience of pension committees, and I found that very deserving cases were not given proper consideration. If a person's income is over £39 5s. a year, he is deprived of his pension. That is not fair to old people. I suggest that that should be raised at least to £50 or £55. I should also like to call the attention of the Minister for Supplies to the scarcity of many essentials at present. In my district there is a great scarcity of binder twine. Some farmers have over 100 acres of wheat, yet dealers have been refused permits to supply them with binder twine.
I am also interested in the important matter of the provision of sea sand for farming purposes. Some farmers complain that they cannot get the amount of sea sand they require, and there are also complaints with reference to a shortage of oil for the boats that are used for hauling the sand. Has the Minister any explanation to offer in that respect? He should endeavour to have adequate supplies issued to these boats, because this sand is very essential for the production of food. Every effort should be made to keep these boats going in order to have the sand conveyed to the farmers.
With reference to Deputy Corry's statement to-day about the increased railway charges for the hauling of sea sand for manurial purposes, I have some knowledge of the matter and I think the Government should take immediate action to effect some remedy. Deputy Corry's statement was quite to the point. We have had a communication from the secretary of the county committee in Cork complaining with reference to this matter. There was one thing that Deputy Corry omitted, and that is that there were a number of men thrown out of employment because the farmers cannot afford to pay what is demanded.
This sea sand is costing more to haul over a distance of 20 or 30 miles than it costs to land it on the quay where it is first delivered. The increases are very stiff, representing 100 per cent. to 200 per cent. The imposition of these charges is very unfair to the people who so urgently require the sand. The sand is particularly useful for the purposes of food production and the Minister should make every effort to see that the railway company will not be allowed to take this matter into their own hands, and that they should have some consideration for the people who require the sand in order to help them in the production of food.
I should like the Minister to consider these points. I have already sent forward complaints to the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Industry and Commerce with reference to the action of the railway company. The production of food is hindered if the sand is not made available for manurial purposes. I may say that the sand has given good results in the last three or four years, when it was utilised in substitution for the artificial manures which were not available in that period.
Comment on this
In the concluding portion of his speech Deputy Norton said what I think all the House has come to recognise, that on the success of agriculture depends the prosperity of every other form of industry in this country. Almost every aspect of agriculture has been mentioned in the course of the debate. We have had reference to the shortage of sugar beet, of butter and of other commodities. I shall endeavour to confine myself to the position of the dairying industry. The Minister has been criticised because there is not a sufficiency of butter in the country to provide a full supply for our own people, not to speak of exporting butter as we used to do at one time. The reason the Minister gives is that there has been an excessive consumption of butter in this country within the last two years.
It is probably true that the people of the cities and towns have consumed more butter during the emergency period than they used to consume in other years. But I think there are other reasons for the shortage. I believe the main reason for the shortage of butter is that the farmer has found it increasingly difficult to produce milk and, subsequently, butter at the ruling prices. At the moment the farmer is getting a little more for his milk than he received at any period within the last 10 or 15 years, but I suggest that it would pay a farmer better to engage in any other form of agricultural activity than in dairying. For instance, it would pay him better to let his land on the 11-months system. In my own county grazing land is let on the 11-months system at prices ranging from £9 to £12 an acre. When you consider that it takes two acres to keep a cow for the year, you will realise that the farmer would be better off to put £18 or £24 in his pocket and let some other person utilise the land.
The Minister says that there is an excessive consumption of butter. There is, mainly on the part of the people in the cities and towns. There has not been any marked increase in consumption among the farmers or the farm labourers, because they cannot afford that. The mere fact that there has been an excessive consumption, almost a double consumption within the last two years, is in itself a proof that butter is probably the cheapest commodity the people can get. The Minister commented yesterday on the statement that was made that the excessive butter consumption was probably due to a shortage of fats. He told us that there were lots of fats in the country. If there are lots of fats to be had, then there is definite proof, if there is an excessive use of butter, that the butter is the cheapest commodity the people can purchase. It is the only commodity that is being retailed at or under the cost of production. Deputy Norton said that agriculture is the foundation of prosperity in this country. Carrying the argument further, I might say that dairying is the foundation of all agriculture, in this country, and it follows logically that dairying is the foundation of that prosperity. The question that the Minister for Agriculture and others have to answer is this: is the dairying industry essential to our agricultural economy?
Is there any fundamental alternative in our agricultural economy? If there is an affirmative answer, that dairying-is essential in our agricultural economy —as I believe it is—then we have to find some way of maintaining and, I hope, expanding dairying, some way of making it an attractive proposition for the farmers.
There has been a lamentable decline in dairying in the districts with which I am acquainted—Limerick, Tipperary and parts of Cork. I did not observe many statistics produced by the Farmers' Party. I would not give a crack of my fingers for statistics; I do not believe in them. If one had the time and energy to go over a district, I honestly think he could confound all our statisticians. Any person who tells me that there has not been a decline in the dairying industry is telling me something that I cannot believe. Every creamery I visit tells me the same story. So far as herds of cattle are concerned, where there used to be 25 or 30 there are now only ten or 20. It was a common thing in my own county, ten, 20 or 30 years ago, and also in Tipperary and the adjoining parts of Cork, to see herds of 50, 80 and even 100 dairy cattle. You could travel 40, 50 or 100 miles to see a herd of 40 cattle now. I do not know if there is a herd of 40 in my district. There are very few herds of 30; they consist generally of 20, as many people have gone out of business. Every newspaper that one reads announces auctions of dairy herds, and those who are not selling out are reducing numbers. That is the position in regard to this vital industry. I asked this question before: Is it an essential industry or not? If it goes down what will happen?
Deputy Norton spoke for some time about tillage, and other Deputies dealt with the same subject. If we omit the war years, during which every one of us is eating bread grown from wheat that we produce here, where will we be in regard to tillage? Does anyone believe that after this war, any form of compulsion that the Government announces is going to make people here eat bread made from third-class flour when they can get better bread made from wheat grown in other countries?
That may be an unpopular thing to say here or elsewhere, but I am as certain as I am speaking in this House now, that in five or ten years, whenever the war is over, the people of this country will demand and will get bread that is made from the best flour that the world produces. I know as much about wheat as any Deputy that has prattled about that crop in this House during the last week or during the last five years. Probably I know more about it than most Deputies. I stated here ten years ago, when the Government Party first introduced their tillage policy, that it would be folly for us to grow third-class wheat when, for half the price that we are paying for it, we could get first-class wheat; that it would pay us much better to sell our produce at a fair price and to buy good wheat cheaper than the price at which we could produce inferior wheat. I uttered a challenge, which was never taken up, that if any Deputy here or elsewhere could produce one grain of wheat grown in this country that I or any other person would grade up to No. 2 Manitoba I would acknowledge my mistake. I never heard of such wheat being grown here. It cannot be produced because of our climate and our conditions. Let those who rattle and prattle about wheat think that over. The foundation of our agriculture must be dairying and, if you like, the production of cattle for export which would consume the tillage the people are asked to undertake. If there is any future for the growing of wheat and cereals it depends on the cattle that I hope will be raised here. It must be made profitable for dairy farmers to produce livestock to eat the cereals that we hope-to continue to produce.
Comment on this
If human beings will not eat the cereals we hope they will be eaten by animals, and dairy farmers are the only men who can produce these animals.
Comment on this
I was coming to that. They could not exist without dairy farmers. The present price of milk is 9d. a gallon. It is the best price that dairy farmers have been paid for some years, but it is not enough. As Deputy Norton stated that price is not sufficient to enable dairy farmers to pay labourers a sufficient wage on which to live in comfort. It is not sufficient to give the labourers an income on which to live in comfort comparable to workers in villages and towns. Of course the villages have now been practically wiped out. Deputy Norton also stated that a labourer cannot provide a living for himself, his wife and children on 36/- a week. He cannot, but there are many small dairy farmers with six or eight cows who have not 36/- a week to spend on their families. Anybody who understands the position knows that. Some of us in this Party do not like subsidies. I believe that subsidies are the last refuge in these matters, but once a policy of extreme tariffs was adopted then there has to be a policy of quid pro quo for agriculture, and the only way to give that quid pro quo is by means of subsidies. Let those who dislike subsidies get that into their heads and think about it. If we are to get away from subsidies on agricultural produce we will have to drop tariffs on manufactured goods. We cannot have it both ways.
Comment on this
Lower the cost of production by removing the taxes, and make production more profitable if you like by increased production. People talk about increased production as if it was going to be produced by a wave of a wand. The Irish farmer is not less intelligent than the farmers in any other country. We have had comparisons made between this country, New Zealand and Denmark. For God's sake let us drop such comparisons. Conditions in New Zealand and Denmark and conditions here are as different as the conditions between here and the Behring Straits or the Polar regions. New Zealand is blessed by nature for milk production as there they can out-feed their cows all the year round and they do not produce cattle for sale. It does not matter twopence to the Danish farmer whether a cow produces a rabbit or a calf, except in so far as it leaves him with a supply of heifers to renew a herd.
New Zealand is in the same position. Here, rightly or wrongly, we have adopted the principle of the dual capacity cow, founded on the production of as much milk as possible, and as a result we produce the best off-spring and the best beasts in the world. We cannot ever achieve the success in relation to gallons per cow that they can achieve in Denmark and New Zealand unless we stop producing the best cattle that can be produced. I heard this question argued outside the House. The Minister for Education said at an election meeting in my own county that low production was the fault of the farmers themselves, and that they ought to take a lesson from Denmark. He pointed out that, some years ago, production in Denmark was as low as it is here, but that the farmers there, without Government help, had raised production from under 300 gallons to 700 or 800 gallons. He said that they did that by their own exertions, by denying themselves things and by going into the banks, mortgaging their farms and borrowing money. That is what the Minister said to the electors of Limerick.
Comment on this
But he could not stagger me. I came after the Minister and I pointed out that the comparison of this country with Denmark was a false comparison. Then, I came to the titbit—that the Danes had mortgaged their farms and borrowed money to build up their herds. I asked the audience whether the Minister had not cheek to tell them to mortgage their farms. Some years ago, when farmers had a somewhat worse time than usual—and we have always had a bad time—the small farmer could face the bank manager and ask for a loan of £10 or £15 and the bigger farmer could ask for a loan of £50 or a £100 with a clear conscience. The bank manager would tell me, when I asked for a loan of £100 on those occasions, that he would give it to me. My land was security in those days, but times have changed. It is useless now for the farmer, either of five acres or 50 acres, to walk into a bank and ask for a loan on the security of his land because he will be told that the land is no security. He will have to get the assistance of somebody who has a deposit or an investment with which to secure him. Yet, the Minister had the audacity to tell us that the Danes did this and that we should do likewise.
I now come to the argument regarding increased production. I hope that some method of increasing the production of milk per cow will be arrived at. I see on the Farmers' Benches a couple of Deputies who have taken a deep interest in this matter. Some of us have been engaged for years in an attempt to bring that about—with very little result. We thought, in the first instance, of intensive feeding. But many farmers were unable to undertake that at the price available for milk. I tried it, and it did not produce the results expected. I have been 30 years at the job, and I know all about feeding. I never was reduced to the state in which I had to starve either myself or a cow. We have, then, the cow testing method— an excellent method. I advised every farmer to go in for cow testing. But all cow testing does is to tell you with certainty what you knew already but were not sure of—which was the bad cow and which was the good one. When I got rid of the bad cow, the cow which I obtained in her place was oftentimes little better. Small farmers could not afford to replace such a cow. There is no certain method of improving the milk yield so long as we have to produce a dual purpose cow—a cow to give a certain quantity of milk and the best possible calf afterwards. I know a very eminent authority, not in this House, who will argue definitely that if the people outside the dairying industry will not come to its assistance, then the people in the industry should get away from producing good stock and confine themselves to the production of a beast that will give a good supply of milk. We could go in for the Holstein or some other cow that would give a fair yield of milk. But would it be fair to the people if we, in Limerick, Clare, Cork or Tipperary, gave up producing the best cattle in the world and confined ourselves to production of cattle for milk purposes only, such as the theorists tell us the farmers in New Zealand and Denmark have done?
We cannot have it both ways. We can dispense with the dual-purpose cow, producing a certain percentage of milk and the best store cattle in the world, and go in for cattle with a high milk yield. It is for the Minister for Agriculture to lead the country on that question. I think that it is wiser to continue on our present lines. I think that we should produce as much milk and butter as we can produce and then let us all get together in a common examination of the problem to see if we can improve the position and keep the industry alive, at least, for the duration of this emergency, so that we shall have, at worst, a sufficiency of butter for our own people. The Minister for Supplies asked, in an interjection yesterday, how the money was to be found to increase the price of milk. I say that it can be done by raising the price of butter. That may be unpopular, but the Minister has told us that the consumption of butter by people outside agriculture has doubled. The Minister stated definitely yesterday that the people in the cities and towns had doubled their consumption of butter in the past four or five years. Neither the farmer nor the farm labourer has been able to do that. They live on a lower standard. Though they produce the butter, they cannot eat it, but the people of the cities and towns have been able to consume double their normal quantity. Why is that? Because butter was the cheapest form of food they could buy. It was the only food they could buy at, or under, the cost of production. If it is 3d. or 4d. more, they will buy all that we can produce in the next two or three years.
Comment on this
Yes, it would, and if butter was at 2/5 a lb. you would have illimitable quantities of it, and the Minister would have to take rationing away. If some shopkeeper could put up in his window "Butter at 2/5 a lb." he would need to get the police and the horse guards to stop the people from coming in. Let nobody tell me that butter is the one food that is costing the people too much. It is the only food that they are getting at anything approaching a reasonable price. It is so cheap that although the Minister says that there are lots of other fats available in this country, the people will not buy these fats, but will only buy butter because they consider it cheaper and better. Deputy Dillon has pointed out that there are only two ways of improving the position. One is by means of subsidies. As I have said, I do not like the idea of subsidies, but as I have pointed out already, once you resort to tariffs for the protection of industries in this country, then you have to provide a quid pro quo for the farmer, and if you deny him a subsidy, then you have to do away with your tariff system, because the farmer will not stand for it and the country will not stand for it.
On the other hand, if you do not do these things, there is only one hope for the dairy farmer, and that is to get back to the position—and does anybody want that?—where the Revenue Commissioners wanted us to pay 6/- a week for milkers, or, alternatively, where the Minister for Co-ordination of Defensive Measures advocated in this House, six or eight or ten years ago—he said it across the floor of the House, to me, above all men—that we should get our milkers to milk 15 or 20 cows. You had the Revenue Commissioners advocating 6/- a week, and you had the Minister for Co-ordination of Defensive Measures advocating getting our milkers to milk 15 or 20 cows. If we got to that position, then, possibly, we could produce cheap butter, but does anybody suggest that we should get back to that position? Deputy Norton says that 36/- a week is too low a wage. I agree. Agricultural labourers are often referred to in this country as being unskilled, whereas they are amongst the most skilled workers in the country. The agricultural worker is a Jack-of-all-trades. He has to be a bit of a doctor, a bit of a veterinary surgeon, a bit of a milker, a bit of a carpenter, a bit of a wheelwright, a bit of almost every trade. There is no end to the jobs that he has to do. Put that man in a factory for ten minutes, or at any rate for two hours, and you will find that he will be able to do his job. These men go over to England in hundreds and thousands to work in the factories there, and in about three weeks' time they are found to be as good as the most skilled labourers in the world—so good that they are put in responsible positions in the factories, and doing the hardest work that there is to be done in England. Yet, here, they are described as unskilled workers —God help us—and until we get away from that position there is very little hope for prosperity in this country.
Let us, if we can—and, with a combination of all the best brains in this country, we certainly can—lift up our agriculturists, whether by means of subsidies, or in any other way. I do not care a damn how it is done, so long as the farmer can get a fair price for the commodities which he produces: sufficient to give him and his family a fair competence and to provide him with reasonable comfort and to enable him to pay his workers—the hardest workers in this country, particularly the milkers, who have to be up at five o'clock in the morning and who finish their work long after everybody else is finished—a decent wage. Until we get to that position, whatever your hopes may be, you will not get real prosperity in this country.