We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account (No. 2), 1943-44 (Resumed).

Contributions 330–499 of 499. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Michael Cleary Mr. Ó Cléirigh Fianna Fáil

There is one encouraging thing about this debate, and that is that the vast majority of Deputies in this House have accepted all the main principles of the policy of the Minister for Agriculture, and that is the policy of maintaining in this country whatever market there is for farm produce for the Irish farmer. With the exception of a very few Deputies— a small minority, I think, of Fine Gael —all of us have accepted that principle, and that is a very hopeful and promising sign for the future of this country, and I hope that no future Dáil will depart from that policy of protection for our farmers, without having all the facts in connection with free trade, as encouraged by Deputies Dillon and Bennett and a few other Deputies, before them, and without a thorough examination of these facts. I hope that the policy advocated and encouraged by Deputies Dillon and Bennett will not be embarked upon again by Deputies in this House without having all the facts before them.

It has been suggested by Deputy Norton and, I think, by Deputy Bennett, and probably by qther Deputies. that if the farmer were guaranteed fixed prices for his products it would enable him to pay a higher wage to his labourers, and that that policy should be embarked on now. I think I should be opposed to that, and I think that the vast majority of farmers in this country would be opposed to it. In my opinion, whatever interference by the Government has occurred heretofore in regard to fixed prices, it has been opposed by the farmers, and the Government has been accused of having too many inspectors and interfering too much with the farmers' business. You cannot have regimentation in farming or in the production of commodities produced on the farm in the same way as you can have regimentation in a factory. It is absolutely impossible to have regimentation of that kind in connection with farming, and I think it would be a bad day for the farmer if you were to have that kind of regimentation, because it would mean that you would have to have hordes of officials, and I am afraid that it would take years and years to reach such a state of efficiency as would justify the tackling of the problem in that way.

Surely the farmer, as much as anybody else, requires a free market to some extent, and I think that he would be well able to hold his own. With the free market that you have at the moment, how can it be said that farming is in a bad way? If, as Deputy Bennett admits, grazing is going at £12 an acre on the 11-months' system, farming cannot be in a bad way. If you have to look for conaere in the West of Ireland, it is amazing the prices that are offered for it, and that is in a free market. Therefore, I would warn people against this plea for regimentation, so far as these things are concerned. I think that if regimentation were to be introduced, whereby farmers would be controlled in connection with everything that they did on their farms, they would rue the day. At the moment, the farmer is fairly free, and I think that there is no quarrel, as far as the vast majority of farmers in this country are concerned, except on the question of prices. That is a question that is debatable and arguable. There were arguments about wheat prices, beet prices and oats prices, but those are things that can be argued in the Minister's office or here in the Dáil. It seems to me that the question of prices is the only one on which there is any difference, but I think that farming is in a fairly healthy condition otherwise.

Deputy Cogan made an excellent suggestion about wheat growing. He said that wheat growing should be on the same basis as beet growing and that it should be by contract; but I am afraid that that would be a bad system and, again, I fear that you would have too much regimentation. If that were to be adopted, it would mean that every man who contracted. for the growing of an acre of wheat must contract for the selling of that acre of wheat at the same time. That would be the implication.

Are all the people in the country who produce wheat prepared to hand over that wheat to the mills at the fixed price in the same way as the beet growers are prepared to hand over their produce? If contracts of that kind are made, will it not be necessary to have a vast number of officials to go into the farming areas, and, within three months of embarking on that course, will not the farmers and probably the farmers' representatives complain that we are again increasing officialdom to the detriment of the farmers and other members of the community? I think we should not go too far with this question of regimentation. If a reasonable price is given for wheat—if the price offered is not a reasonable one, the case can be argued—and if the vicious circle of argument against wheat-growing, at a time when we are dependent solely on Irish wheat, is stopped at least for the period of the emergency, and if Deputies on the opposite benches who have a bad record as far as wheat-growing is concerned will forget that, as we are prepared to forget it during this emergency, and go in for the production of wheat at a reasonable price, I think we will get enough wheat for our people. Judging by the rough figures which are available I have hopes that there will be an excellent supply of wheat in the coming season.

On the question of land division it has been said by the Leader of the Farmers' Party that we would not require all the inspectors if the two Governments which were in power for the last 20 years had expedited the division of land; that, if they had given land to the emigrants and kept them here, those people would have tilled the land without any inspectors. On examination, I think the Leader of the Farmers' Party will find that that statement is not correct. To my own knowledge, one particular county in which land was given to landless men has the worst record for tillage in the whole of the Twenty-Six Counties. I refer to the County Roscommon. Land was given to the landless men there, and that is the county where extra inspectors were required and where the courts had to be resorted to in order to force those men to till a perch of the holdings that they got. That is proof that those landless men, when they got land, failed to do their work for the nation. They did not even give any indication that they were prepared to work the land which they got.

The Minister was told by a Deputy representing Roscommon — Deputy Meighan, who knows Roscommon very Well—that the majority of the farmers in that county are opposed to him and his policy. I think the Deputy was probably correct in that. Without meaning to be in any way disrespectful to him, I should like to point out to the Deputy that the majority of the farmers of Roscommon are the worst farmers in Ireland. They were the last to respond to any scheme for the production of food in this country. It was only when coercion was threatened that they helped in any way in the production of vital food for the people. It was not on the question of price they held back; they were very slow to respond to the call for tillage at all.

I know it is difficult to divide land now, but, if the Minister would consult the tillage inspectors throughout the country, I think the lessons that are to be learned now about land division, and about the men who are willing to work the land, are lessons which will enable any Government in the future to divide land expeditiously amongst the men who will work it in their own interests and in the interests of the nation. I may have misinterpreted the Leader of the Farmers' Party when I understood him to make a plea for the division of laud amongst landless men. I am strongly opposed to landless men getting land in this country, and I hope that the Minister concerned will never adopt that policy, while there are thousands of uneconomic holders, bog holders, if you like By the time their holdings are made economic there will be no more land left for division. Our uneconomic landholders should receive first consideration. They have the first claim on the land, and not the landless men, with the exception of course of men who may lose their employment because a particular estate is being divided. I hope the Farmers' Party will study that question before they demand that landless men should get land, because they will find many rude shocks awaiting them if that policy is carried out, to the detriment and exclusion of uneconomic landholders in congested districts.

Deputy Cosgrave made a great case for increasing the milk supply. I only wish he had been in the House when Deputy Bennett was speaking. Deputy Bennett very effectively answered Deputy Cosgrave, and I presume that, as a dairy farmer. Deputy Bennett knows more about that subject than I do, and certainly more than Deputy Cosgrave. He said that you cannot have it both ways; that you cannot increase the milk production and keep the herds of cattle we have in this country at the moment; that you must sacrifice the cattle trade if you go in for increasing milk production. That should do away with the silly arguments advanced here by certain Deputies that the Government are responsible for the low milk yield, and that it is disgraceful that the Minster for Agriculture does not do something about it.

There is another important matter which has not been dealt with—I think it is one of the most important branches of agriculture—and that is the egg industry. It has been shouldered out of this debate altogether, although it is a very important industry and although it is now in a very precarious condition. In the circumstances at the moment, I think there is too much interference with that industry by the Department of Agriculture. In war time they are trying to keep in operation peace time regulations and rules, in spite of the fact that many things are making egg production difficult and practically impossible in certain areas.

The amount of first grade eggs produced in this country to-day is negligible, and that is due principally to the shortage of food. Oats are not now being fed to fowl to any extent. It has come to my notice that, in the congested areas, wheat is more extensively fed to fowl than oats. That is a pity. The oats are not there, and the fowl are fed on food which will not enable first grade eggs to be produced. While that is so, inspectors of the Department are going around as actively as ever, and they find that, after a few days, eggs which had been labelled "first grade" are only second grade owing to the unsuitable quality of the food on which the fowl were fed. The Minister should look into that question immediately and take some steps to call off the rigid inspection that there is in connection with the egg industry. It is one of the most valuable sections of our agricultural industry, particularly in congested areas, because the people have a weekly egg account while they may have only a quarterly account in connection with other branches of their industry. Again, I would urge the Minister to pay more attention to this very vital branch of the agricultural programme.

Comment on this

I hope to be able to convince the House that Deputy Ó Cléingh was wrong when he objected to the giving of land to landless men. What does he say about the ploughman who is skilled in the production of food? I have before me the case of a ploughman in County Dublin who is now 73 years of age and who has applied for the old age pension. He has half an acre of ground, and I have here the report of the Government inspector who says that he is capable of getting £61 10s. 0d. worth of produce out of that half acre. But Deputy Ó Cléirigh would not give land to the ploughmen of this country.

Comment on this

He did not say that at all.

Comment on this

He said he would not give it to the landless men.

Comment on this

He qualified that.

Comment on this

I did not intend to deal with the question of land division, but I should like to say that the record of the men who have been given land by the Government is anything but good. Men have been given land because of political pull. These lands are let out in conacre, and the men who own them have failed to produce food.

Comment on this

You know that is wrong.

Comment on this

I can give the cases if necessary. Land has been divided in County Dublin and friends and relations of Ministers have been brought into County Dublin over the heads of ploughmen and the local landless men. They have been given good land, and they have let it out in conacre. I should like to draw the Minister's attention——

Comment on this

What about Mayo?

Comment on this

I expect the Deputies who are here from Mayo will answer for Mayo. As a Mayo man, I say that the people of Mayo have not the same facilities for producing food as those on the fertile lands of Meath and Dublin have. I am sure the Deputy will agree with me.

Comment on this

Has Deputy Killilea a right to cross-examine the Deputy when he is speaking?

Comment on this

Nobody cross-examines more than Deputy Davin.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I should like to say this. I did not intend to touch on the question of land division——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of land division does not arise on this Vote except, perhaps, incidentally to agricultural policy.

Comment on this

I hold that we have been listening all evening to the question of agriculture. Well, you can have no agriculture if you have not land division.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Quite, but the Vote for the Department of Lands has been passed and the money appropriated.

Comment on this

Deputy O Cléirigh has referred to land division and I am replying to what he said. I say when land is to be divided no man has a greater claim than the ploughman and the agricultural labourer because they are capable of using the land. I shall not say very much on that point. In all that has been said here this evening about land, we have heard very little about the agricultural labourer. I should like to draw the Minister's attention in particular to the sad plight of agricultural labourers, their wives and dependents, in County Dublin. For hours to-day we have listened to statements by Deputies to the effect that the farmer and the agricultural labourer belong to the most important section of the community in the nation. We are all agreed on that point, but do we agree that they should be treated as slaves? If any Minister doubts my statement, I can take him to the homes of agricultural labourers in County Dublin to-night in which the occupants have not their breakfast for to-morrow. Let us be honest and face up to the position. Everyone admits that without the agricultural labourer, we could not exist. Take the medical man. He is looked up to in this country because he cures disease. I hold that the agricultural labourer is more important because by the production of food he prevents disease; yet we treat the agricultural labourer in the same way as if he were a slave.

I hold that the agricultural labourer, and those who give their time to agricultural work, should get at least equal treatment to every other section of the community. I have worked as an agricultural labourer for 33/- a week, but when I come here I get £10 10s. a week. Yet I say I was a greater asset to the nation when I was producing food than I am here. Let us be honest about the position. I say it is a sad thing that in a Christian country like this we should praise and boost up these unfortunate men, pretending that we have an interest in them, while we are deceiving them. I have heard it suggested by, I think, Deputy Maguire that we should set up a commission to do this or that. Have we not been elected to this House to do these things ourselves? I say the first thing that should be done by this House is to ensure that the agricultural worker will have sufficient means to preserve his wife and children from hunger.

Is it not sad to think that an unfortunate man who has to work from Monday morning to Saturday night, every day in the year, without any holidays, is obliged to go out on Sunday morning to get the loan of a bike to come into Dublin because his clothes are so bad that he cannot go out amongst his neighbours? The man I describe is no wastrel. I have no place for the wastrel. The man I refer to is a Pioneer. For the whole of the week he is engaged in the most essential work of producing food for the nation; he is the father of seven children, and yet on Sunday morning in this Catholic Christian country he is forced to get the loan of a bicycle to hide himself from his neighbours. And then we say that the Fianna Fáil policy has succeeded!

I do not intend to dwell further on that point except to say that the agricultural labourer is very badly treated indeed. Quite recently in a case where the wife of an agricultural labourer was ill I had the sad experience of approaching a certain Department to see if I could get a gallon of paraffin for use in that house. I was told that that could not be allowed. I say in particular that agricultural labourers and those who derive their living from small farms, such as exist in County Mayo, are very badly treated. It is very poor compensation for the small farmer and his wife in Mayo that they are to be used for nothing better than to rear up beautiful boys and girls to build up other nations because we can do nothing for them here. I hold that the mothers of Mayo are entitled to better compensation from a national Government.

On the question of cottage purchase, when the Fianna Fáil Party went to the country and asked for an over-all majority they promised the farm labourers and cottage holders that they would bring forward a Cottage Bill that would be acceptable to the cottage tenants and farm labourers. But they failed in that promise. They gave the farmer a reduction of 50 per cent. in his annuity but they did not fulfil their promise to agricultural labourers. They would give them a reduction of only 25 per cent. I happened to be one of those who approached the Minister to make an appeal to him in connection with this matter, and he said that as long as he was Minister he would not think of giving a greater concession to the farm labourers of this country.

I should like to refer for a moment to matters concerning the Local Government Department, and in that connection to mention specially the case of old age pensioners. When the Fine Gael Government were in power they took 1/- off the old age pensioners, which I say was bad politics to say the least of it, because I do believe it had a great effect in bringing about the downfall of the Fine Gael Government. I say now that the old age pensioners are amongst the worst treated section of the community. I am sure other Deputies are aware of the position in other counties, but I know as far as County Dublin is concerned—and I speak with a knowledge extending over many years of County Dublin— it does not matter who in County Dublin reaches the age at which he or she is entitled to apply for a pension, he will not get it in full. Take the case of the ploughman I have referred to. He worked until he was 73 and he was not fit to work any longer. Then he applied for the old age pension, and his means are returned as £61 10s. 6d. out of his half-acre garden. That is only one case. I have here the case of an ex-farm labourer residing in Cappagh, Finglas. He worked until he was two years over the age, and then he applied for the pension. The pensions officer informed him that, although he has not a quarter of an acre, not a rood of a garden, it is capable of producing 7/- of an income per week, and he is allowed only 3/- pension. The Old Age Pensions Committee of which I happen to be a member—though we all differ in our stations of life—were good enough to grant him a pension of 10/- and here, to-day, there is an appeal against it.

There is an old man after a life-long struggle, without a day's comfort in this world, offered 3/- a week by a native Government when he comes to the age of 72, while the ex-Minister can get ten guineas pension. The highest wage this man ever earned in his lifetime was under £2 and he reared a very large family. Is that Justice or honesty? Old age pensioners are being treated much worse now than by the previous Government, because there is a rigid means test. We have the case of a man in receipt of 6/- a week outdoor relief. Before he receives that relief he must be destitute, because the poor relief is only for the destitute. He applies for a pension and his means are returned as 6/- a week. I would appeal to the Minister for God's sake and for Ireland's sake to change that cruel position.

Take the case of widows' pensions. We have the name of an Act in force in this country. As far as the contributory section is concerned, it is something towards a pension, although the amount is not half sufficient, but as far as the non-contributory side is concerned, it is an insult for any Government to present it to the people. I have here a letter sent by the Minister for Local Government to the widow of an agricultural labourer in County Dublin, which reads:

"With reference to the non-contributory pension payable to you under the Widows' and Orphans' Pension Act, I am directed by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health to inform you that as the result of re-investigation it has been decided that your net weekly means, as calculated in accordance with the provisions of the Act, amount to 5/4. As this sum exceeds the rate of pension of 5/- per week to which you would be entitled had you no net weekly means, you cease to be entitled to a pension as from 28th October, 1938."

It is very strange that this letter should coincide with the passage of a Bill to give pensions of £500 a year to ex-Ministers without any means test. They take the 5/- away from the widow in County Dublin and give it to the Minister.

I have gone back to 1938, but between 1938 and 1943 I have come across many similar cases. I would take the case of 1943. Here is a letter sent out on the 31st May, 1943:

"Further to my letter of the 8th April regarding the rate of pension awarded to Mrs. Julia Lawless, Grange Road Raheny, under the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Acts, I am desired by Dr. Ward to state that her net weekly means amounted to 4/4, and she is consequently entitled to a pension at the rate of 1/- per week only. I am to add that the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Acts provide that a referee's decision on any matter referred to him shall be final and conclusive. Consequently Mrs. Lawless's case cannot be reopened unless a reduction in her means occurs"

—a reduction in 4/4, to the mother of an invalid daughter.

This lady lives at Raheny and has an invalid daughter in a chair for 30 years. Her only means in the world are four hens. There is a bit of an old garden that neither herself nor her daughter is able to till. Yet we are told we have a Christian Government. This Government asks those people to live on 1/- a week. Is that justice? If that is justice, then I am the greatest fool that was ever born. I would appeal to the Minister to have this case investigated and to have this injustice remedied forthwith, otherwise those people must go to the Dublin Union.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

May I inform the Deputy that legislation may not be criticised or advocated on this Vote?

Comment on this

I hope the Chair will not blame me for bringing these cases before a Minister in the only place where I am entitled to bring them forward when those people are on the verge of death. When this House rises I am prepared to pay for a taxi so that the Minister can confirm for himself the circumstances of these two people.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will have an opportunity on the Minister's Estimate.

Comment on this

The thing is so urgent that you will pardon my raising it here to-night, Sir. This lady has raised a family and has only an invalid, crippled daughter with her in the house. The same complaints can be made in the case of blind pensions and National Health Insurance. How, in God's name can people live on 15/- a week? They are forced to go to the relieving officer and make paupers of themselves. Mind you, there was a period when the Irish people in days gone by would not do that, but we have gone a long way from that now. How can a man with five children live on 15/- a week? In the first week he does not even get the full amount. Therefore, I would appeal to the Minister in charge of the Department of Local Government to have that type of people looked after. I have a letter——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is advocating legislation.

Comment on this

I thought I was entitled to criticise Government policy, and I want to know if it is the Minister's policy that there should be people starving in this country in the midst of plenty. I am not appealing for legislation, but I am putting up concrete cases and I am prepared to pay the expenses of anyone who is willing to investigate the truth of them.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is pleading for higher grants than those prescribed by law.

Comment on this

And appealing to the Minister to change the law.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Which is not in order.

Comment on this

Is not anything that is right legitimate?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not.

Comment on this

The moral law is higher than any other law.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy cannot come within the rules of order and procedure he will have to resume his seat.

Comment on this

Is it in order to address personal abusive remarks when a Deputy is speaking?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair did not hear any such remark.

Comment on this

Deputy Killilea made one remark.

Comment on this

What did I say?

Comment on this

You said the Deputy was a fool.

Comment on this

It was the man himself who talked about fools.

Comment on this

What I heard him to say was that he was very near to it.

Comment on this

That is a deliberate lie!

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

I am not appealing for legislation. It is a case of administration and justice. I think that I am justified in raising this question of hospitals. We are supposed to be in possession of many million pounds for the provision of hospitals. Yet in spite of that fact, it is a sad thing that if a little girl in the County Dublin, residing with her family, is certified to be suffering from tuberculosis, there is no hospital to take her to. Perhaps if her treatment were undertaken in time she could be cured. I would appeal to the Minister to do something in connection with that. It is a dreadful thing that when persons are certified by the doctors to be suffering from tuberculosis they are sometimes left in their homes for 12 months, and oftentimes two years, before being removed for treatment. That is no credit to whoever is responsible. So far as the working classes in the County Dublin are concerned, the only hospital whose door is open to-them is the Dublin Union Hospital. My next point deals with the question of supplies.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This Vote contains no demand for money for the Department of Supplies.

Comment on this

There is one matter that I want to bring to the notice of the Minister for Defence, and that is the unequal treatment given to the I.R.A. We know that there are some men who never fired a shot drawing huge and lavish pensions, while there are other men who gave good and faithful service and they have been denied a pension. That is a rather serious statement to make, and I ask the Minister to look into those cases. The statement is one that I can prove. I know there are men in receipt of pensions, and I say it is robbery that they should be getting them.

Not only did they not fire a shot but the people who were in the movement were afraid of them. Deputies may laugh, but I do not care as long as I am telling the truth. I defy contradiction of any statement that I make here. In connection with I.R.A. pensions, I have here a letter which I received from a lady on the 5th July. This lady's husband served in the Irish Army in which he held the rank of sergeant in 1941. He was sent to the County Wicklow where a mine was washed ashore, and during its removal he was killed. His widow was left with three young children, and from our Irish Government she was given neither a pension nor compensation. That is the position of the dependents of a man who gave his life in the service of this country. They have received nothing. I hope that is not Government policy, and I would appeal to the Minister to take a note of the case.

I would like to have some statement from the Taoiseach as far as the national position is concerned. I think he owes a statement to this House because of statements made by his supporters in the County Dublin during the recent election. They went out and told the people——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is not responsible for statements made by candidates during the election. The sooner the House realises that the election campaign has concluded the better. Deputies should get away from the election platforms.

Comment on this

I will not mind about the statements. I will keep to the advertisements.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Policy is enunciated by Ministers.

Comment on this

And published.

Comment on this

I would like to know whether it was stated there was going to be strife and bloodshed and hunger unless Fianna Fáil got in. I think the Irish people have the right to demand from the Taoiseach, as the leader of the nation, to say who is going to create the bloodshed and the strife——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The election is over.

Comment on this

——and the hunger.

Comment on this

Who paid for the vans?

Comment on this

I do not blame the Government for certain things. I know that there are certain essential commodities that must be procured from outside, but as regards the things that we are capable of producing from the land I think the Government have failed hopelessly. We heard a lot to-day about the 12,000,000 acres of arable land which we have in the country. In view of the fact that we have that area of land, and a population of less than 3,000,000 people, it is a poor consolation to think that we are not fit to find sufficient food or work for them at the present time. If that is the position now, I dread to think what it is going to be when the war is over which, I hope, will be in the near future, when the 250,000 of our people who have had to emigrate return. Surely, if ever a Government were given the opportunity to find work and food for the people within the country it is at the present time. Our people have had to leave and take up work in another country making implements for the destruction of life. That is the position of many of our beautiful boys and girls, the finest and purest in the world, who would be capable of building up any nation. They have been forced to go to a foreign country where they are employed making instruments for the destruction of life. To-morrow, if the war were over they would only be regarded as scrap. Here in Christian Catholic Ireland we are not capable of patting them to work, producing something that would be for the betterment and happiness of humanity, and while that is so we say that the Government is a success.

If this nation is to survive, it cannot do so on emigration and doles and the starvation allowances that are being given to our poor people. Do not forget that within the Constitution of this nation there is a clause under which we are in duty bound to support the aged and the widow. I want to say, in the presence of the Taoiseach to-night, that I could take him to hundreds of homes where people are starving. They are not being supported even though there is that clause in the Constitution drafted by himself. There is a duty on the nation to see that those people should not be hungry, and I hope the Government's. duty in that respect will soon be realised.

In this little country, why should one small section have every comfort that the world can give, while a "standstill" order is made against the workers so that they can get no increase in their wages? They are getting nothing at all. I say it would be no-wonder if the Irish people had risen against the Government. They have left themselves open to it. They got into power on promises which they have made a very poor effort to fulfil.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

They got into power in this nation on deceitful and deceptive promises. There is no question about that. They promised that they would raise the standard of life for the masses of the people. They did. They raised the standard of life for certain people, the relations and friends of certain Deputies and Ministers who could get farms of land and positions. As a matter of fact, I would nearly go so far as to say that they had special Acts of Parliament to get jobs for a few of them who fell by the wayside. That is not equal treatment for all our citizens. I implore the Government to give equal treatment to all our citizens. If there is going to be poverty then let us all share it. Why should one section have luxuries? Why should the members of this House go on holidays from now until the harvest —for a period of two months—while the farm labourer never gets a holiday during his whole lifetime? Let us be fair. Is that equal treatment? It is not. Just as there is a responsibility on parents to set a good example to their families if they expect their families to be an asset to the nation, there is a responsibility on the heads of the State to set an example to the citizens. If there is to be sacrifice, let us all share it and let us all be poor together.

Comment on this

There was unanimous agreement in the House yesterday that we should conclude the Vote on Account and all stages of the Central Fand Bill to-night. I take it that that agreement is to be carried through, and, if so, there ought to be time for reply on behalf of the Government.

Comment on this

There was certainly agreement that we would conclude this business and the Emergency Powers Bill to-morrow and that there would be no necessity to sit next week.

Comment on this

It was agreed to give the Government these measures to-night. There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Central Fund Bill as well as the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

This motion and the Central Fund Bill. I asked Deputy Cosgrave and members of other Parties if they were agreeable, and they said they were.

Comment on this

I shall conclude by stating that the Fianna Fáil Government have betrayed the ideals of Sinn Féin. We all pose as being followers. of the policy of Sinn Féin and——

Comment on this

Indeed, we do not.

Comment on this

I do not mind Deputy Dillon. The majority of the Irish people——

Comment on this

Do not let that start you off again.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has a privilege in this nation which other people have not got. Yesterday evening we heard it stated that certain men, if they were at large, would involve this country in war. Deputy Dillon can go out publicly and ask the country to go into the war. That is a privilege which many people have not got. What I say is that those of us who supported the Sinn Féin policy feel that this Government has betrayed all the ideals of Sinn Féin. At that time, we led the Irish people to believe that this was a self-supporting nation. Now that we are given our opportunity, what will be the position when this war is over? Do you think the Irish people will burn turf again after the heart-scald they have been caused and after the way the matter of turf has been handled? I honestly believe, and I say it in all seriousness, that if a cart of Irish turf goes through some of the streets of Dublin when the war is over, the people will go out and upset it, such is their hatred of turf and of the way in which they have been robbed in connection with the turf business. I will give one illustration.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter comes under Industry and Commerce and Supplies, for which the Vote has been passed.

Comment on this

In that case I shall conclude.

Deputies McGilligan and Cafferky rose.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the agreement hold that this shall conclude to-night? The Chair has no power to enforce an agreement without the co-operation of the House.

Comment on this

I understand that there is such an agreement. I was going to ask how long the Taoiseach would require to reply.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It must conclude at 9.30, which does not afford much time.

Comment on this

I shall probably require that time.

Comment on this

I understand that if there is no division, the debate could go on until 10 o'clock.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

The Minster for Industry and Commerce spoke for three-quarters of an hour.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the House agrees that it be unopposed business.

Comment on this

I do not know whether there is going to be a division.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If this is unopposed business. There is a motion to reduce the Vote. I assume that it will be withdrawn.

Comment on this

That is being withdrawn.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is it agreed that there be no division, and that we continue until 10 o'clock and finish this Vote and the Central Fund Bill?

Comment on this

The Government Benches have had a fair innings, and these Benches have not, and I suggest——

Comment on this

Am I not in order in speaking before any other Deputy?

Comment on this

On a point of order. I think the debate should continue until 10 o'clock, and one statement should be allowed from these benches before the Government reply.

Comment on this

I shall be quite satisfied with half an hour.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Two Deputies, one a member of the Farmers' Party, and the other of the Fine Gael Party, desire to intervene.

Comment on this

It is not proposed to carry on beyond 10 o'clock?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No, we cannot.

Comment on this

Deputy Cafferky and I can divide the time, if we are the only ones to speak, outside the half-hour for the Taoiseach to reply.

Comment on this

We shall require a few minutes for the Central Fund Bill.

Comment on this

Since this Dáil assembled last week, the greater part of the time has been spent in discussing the problem of agriculture, and in so far as I have heard any of the debates to-day or on the previous days, I heard the policy of the Minister for Agriculture being lambasted hip and thigh, condemned root and branch, examined in all its principles and details and found wanting in respect of all these things. Notwithstanding that, Deputy Cleary can tell the House to-night that it is a rather remarkable thing, and one full of good omen for the future, that the Minister has had the approval of every Party in the House for the principles of his policy.

I read in the newspapers a statement made by the Reverend President of the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society in respect of milk prices this year. He said that if the farmers could only sell for what was offered to them, they would have conferred a benefit on mankind and would have done something never before done in the history of civilisation, that is, they would have shown it was possible to sell at under the cost of production and, apparently, to make some livelihood for themselves.

I gathered from the Minister for Agriculture in the last couple of days, when challenged with the statistics which the Department of Industry and Commerce produce with regard to milk and butter, that all he can say is that the statistics in the early part of the years were overstated and that there have been changes. But, in any event, this emerges from the statements, and even the revised statements: that there has been less milk in certain years sent for manufacture into industrial products than there was in 1929, and yet the Minister gets more butter out of less milk. That is another of the modern miracles the Minister has worked.

I take a series of selections from outside the House. The problems of agriculture and its plight have been dealt with by many eminent clergymen in the country. The Bishop of Kilmore, in addressing his flock in a pastoral this year, talked about the devastating flight from the land and asked whether there was a cure for it. He said: "The typical Irish home will disappear if the people continue to leave the land, and hence every effort to improve the prospects of agriculture, to make farming more pleasant and profitable, to make country life brighter, is a blow struck for the Irish home." He went on to show what were the defects in the policy of the present Government in regard to that. The Archbishop of Tuam had much the same comments to make, founding his comments also on the devastating flight from the land, and saying that if it went on, if the same drift were allowed to persist, we would certainly see at no distant date many country schools closed.

Dr. Lucey, lecturing on farming economics in many places in this country, urged a new land policy—I use only one phrase—"a blight has fallen both on the land and on the people who get their livelihood from the land." Dr. Doorly, of Elphin, comments very much along the same lines. The Bishop of Galway mentioned this matter speaking to an address by Dr. Lucey to some Society in Galway. He said:

"We must plan nowadays not merely for economy and efficiency but also for liberty and natural human rights. And the most important natural right is the right of a man to bring up his children in his own home and not to have them taken from him by the State."

He said later:

"The way of helping fathers is to encourage the production of houses, clothing, food at moderate prices. Production and hard work are what we want in this country, and we should beware of any scheme which will encourage idleness."

He added this, and he is not reputed. to be a very severe critic of the Government:

"It is a poor commentary on us as a people that in this fertile land so blessed, by God we have not enough butter or bacon, or grain or sugar."

He said later that he had always maintained that if Ireland were drained of its people it would be always starved and anæmic.

We know the result of the policy of the Minister for Agriculture at this moment is that the emigration which had risen to enormous heights here at the outbreak of the war and which last autumn had fallen somewhat, is now in full flight again. There is an average of 5,000 people leaving here per month—60,000 in the year—and that at a time when I understand from farmers they find it hard to get labour to help them to get in the harvest. There are 60,000 going out of this country. We see the flight from the land, the decay that has fallen upon farms and the people who live there. At the end of that we are told by Deputy Ó Cléirigh that the Minister's policy has the approval of every Party in this House. Neither here nor outside the House has the policy of the Minister for Agriculture the approval of the people.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Might I say that the debate could be continued to half-past ten. That would give the Taoiseach a little longer time.

Comment on this

Half-past ten?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

Whatever may be his policy and whatever may be its results in the future, the pessimistic outlook of that man on the future of this country is what matters. I believe the speech to which I referred on a recent occasion was questioned by the Minister for Agriculture to-day in the House. I want to emphasise the conditions under which this particular matter was raised. It was not a question of a speech made on a public platform when the Minister's tongue might have been betrayed into saying things he did not entirely mean. It was not that he was interrupted and that these things shot out by way of answer to the interruption. This was when he was invited to address a particular Students' Society in University College, Cork, when he went down with a prepared paper which he read, in the preparation of which he no doubt had the help of his Department officials. He called it "The Flight from the Land", and he started off by saying that "those who advocate a back to the land movement must have some vague idea that we can place more people on the land than are there at present."

Let me pause there. At the time the Minister was speaking he had lifted from the land 30,000 to 40,000 people who used to be on it. He had cleared such a number as that. But even with the lowered number he said that there must be some apparently vague idea in those who talk about a back-to-the-land policy that we can place more people on the land than are there at present. He said:

"If we do, it can only mean a reduction in the average size of holdings followed by a smaller income per person for those engaged in agriculture."

Yet, his leader tells the people of this country that he wants this country to be a nation of 8,000,000 people, and I suppose he is going to have a back-to-the-land policy when that 8,000,000 population arrives here. The Minister for Agriculture continued:

"If the farmer's holding is very small and if he has to maintain a family, he cannot do more than produce food for himself and his family, and he has no surplus to sell."

He criticised very severely this form of what he called "subsistence farming". Then he went on to say that this country had to buy certain necessary imports and the only way we could get the currency to pay for them was by exporting. He said there was nothing to export, except agricultural products, and he turned to that phase of his paper.

"We must, therefore," he said, "when this war is over, continue as far as we can to export agricultural produce. We shall do so, however, in the knowledge that we cannot control the price of our exports. We must, in fact, compete against the big exporting countries all over the world. We may be compelled to discontinue some of the exports that before this war had become entirely uneconomic. The first of these, and the one that will interest the present audience most, is dairy products."

Then he continued about this being a country of small farmers, with a long winter during which the cows must be housed and fed, and he said:

"We cannot compete on equal terms with the Antipodes. The question is often asked why our farmers cannot compete with New Zealand in the production of butter. Before the war we were both on the British market, and it may appear strange that New Zealand so far away could increase her exports and evidently build up a profitable business while our exports declined, even though we helped producers through an export bounty. The farms are bigger in New Zealand and can be more easily mechanised than ours. They have practically no winter to provide for. Their milk yields per cow are higher. They can, therefore, produce a much larger volume per person engaged in agriculture than our farmers, can here."

The next part of his lecture was that we had subsidised certain of these dairy products as an export because we believed it was only a temporary decline and that the subsidy would only have to continue for a few years. Having said that, he said he must confess himself wrong in that idea.

"I think," he said, "we must admit now that the difficulty was more than temporary and that the same conditions may prevail when the war is over."

Then he turned to this—

"The elimination of the export of dairy products, if such a course should eventually become necessary, would not be so disastrous to farming economy as might at first sight be feared. The question would obviously have to be examined very carefully and the object"

—the object of eliminating our dairy products as exports—

"achieved by deliberate and careful planning."

That is the future he looks forward to in this country. He said:—

"We can only reach the New Zealand output per person by undoing the work of the Land Commission over the last 20 or 30 years, that is, to clear the small holdings and to re-create the larger ranches. It is not possible to do this, and from the social point of view not desirable. We cannot improve the climate, and we dare not enlarge our farms. We should, and I hope we can, improve our milk yields."

They are the factors that make for uneconomic production in this country and the ones the Minister spoke of, and the only one, I suppose, in respect of which he can hold out any possibility of improvement was milk yield. But he did not say how, and he has no programme for it. Even if we are going to eliminate dairy products as an export, the Minister said it will not be so disastrous after all if we carefully achieve that object by deliberate planning. I would have expected that he would at least tell us what the substitute policy is, what he will replace these valued exports by, because we must export something to buy the necessary imports.

Having killed off dairy products exports in that way, he said:—

"The second line that may have to be reviewed is bacon... When the war is over, the price of exported bacon will probably be lower still, and I have no doubt the free import of maize meal will be advocated for the feeding of pigs."

Then he talks about the home consumer subsidising the export. Eventually he comes to this:—

"If such should occur, therefore, the obvious thing to do is to reduce pig stock to about our present number, which is only sufficient to supply the wants of our own consumers."

So pigs are gone, too, in the post-war the Minister looks forward to, and dairy exports may have to be regarded as permanently uneconomic, but it will not be so bad when the first jolt is over. We will probably then get some substitute policy for it, but the Minister for Agriculture does not know what it is.

That is the outlook—that is the pessimistic outlook—probably bred in that Minister by looking back on his own conduct from the year 1932 on. When he looks at the devastation he has caused in a once healthy agriculture, it is no wonder he may despair of the future as long as it is in his own hands. He got, as far as agriculture was concerned, a total output of £62,000,000, weighing agricultural exports and deducting agricultural imports. When he came into office it went down to £38,000,000, £42,500,000, £47,000,000, £53,000,000. It is only when we come to the war year, with inflated prices, we get to £60,000,000 of a surplus. In the seven years, 1925 to 1931, the total of our agricultural exports over agricultural imports gave us a balance of £113,000,000. In the seven years from 1932 to 1939 the excess of these exports over imports was almost £66,000,000. Notwithstanding that, men representing farmers behind the Minister say that he put agriculture on its feet. It is no wonder that bishops, clergymen, economists and men interested in farming are lamenting the state to which agriculture has been brought. It is no wonder that the Minister who has brought most of this devastation on us should feel pessimistic with regard to the future as long as that trend is to continue, and he gives no indication of any new policy to put these particular lines of approach of his into reverse.

Another of his colleagues decided that, while it was bad enough to have the dairy products trade wiped out and the pig industry wiped out, it was not going far enough. Deputy MacEntee decided that he would sport his figure at a function in University College, Dublin. He went there and told the audience that, so far as he could see, the price for cattle was going to go down after the war, in which case, he said, we must look forward to the virtual extermination of the cattle trade. When the two of them have done their business, when the dairy products export trade possibly is wiped out and pig production providing only for the needs of our home consumers, these two Ministers do not tell us on what we are to live. We are to have self-sufficiency. We are to have the self-sufficiency that enabled the Minister for Supplies in the month of July, 1941, to say that we were facing a severe shortage in food supplies for human consumption, in animal feeding stuffs, in artificial manures, in fuel, and in most of the raw materials of industry. That is what the attempted self-sufficiency brought us at that time.

Artificial manures were one of the things the Minister said we had not too much of. If you examine the statistics, you will find that, during the period of the giant tillage programme of Fianna Fáil, the importation of fertilisers went down by one-third from what it had been, say, in the years before they came into office, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce kept a tax on imported superphosphates until after the beginning of the war. I believe that was denied to-day. If the Minister denies it further, then let him get the Finance Accounts for the year 1939-40 and he will find that they record as a Customs duty receipt a certain amount of money gathered on superphosphates. If he goes over the five years before, he will find that an average sum of £2,200 was brought in. But the man who is bemoaning that we have not fertilisers kept a tax on them until they were unprocurable.

Comment on this

It was a tax on sulphate of ammonia.

Comment on this

Moneys were got from them and put into the Finance Accounts. If there was no tax, I do not know how there could be revenue derived from them and put into the Customs account.

Comment on this

On sulphate of ammonia.

Comment on this

On superphosphates brought in here.

Comment on this

There was a bounty on superphosphates.

Comment on this

You know you did it, but you will not admit it.

Comment on this

The Minister will find in the Finance Accounts that a Customs duty was levied and the proceeds paid to the Exchequer under the head of a Customs item for the years in question.

Comment on this

He knows it well, but he is trying to wriggle out of it. He is ashamed of it.

Comment on this

I am sure the new farmer Deputies would like to learn of two documents to which I should like to give them a brief introduction to-night. There is a certain amount of decay and corruption when vultures gather together. I want to parade two groups of them before this House. I understand that last night there was some talk about the Pigs Marketing Board, and that Deputy Dillon was speaking of its depredations in the country when the Taoiseach interrupted him to say that what Deputy Dillon was speaking of was what the board had avoided. What that particular matter was, I do not know.

But I know that the particular intrigues and achievements of the board were brought to light by a Government Commission, and Deputies, particularly those who are new to the House, may be interested in this sorry tale. Before I come to what was revealed by the Government Commission, let me explain that the board was set up with the grant idea of rectifying the position wherein, when prices were good, farmers got into production and pigs were plentiful in the markets, but when the prices went down the farmers got out. Then, when they went up again, everybody rushed in once more. The board set up a scheme to equalise prices through what was called a hypothetical fund. There was a hypothetical price and money was paid into the fund. When prices were low, the idea was that money would be paid out to raise them in order to keep the farmers in production.

The scheme worked to this extent, that the extra money was levied from the pig producers and was paid into the fund. Then, when the Government Commission was set up to examine what happened to the fund, they found that at a particular time there was about £137,000 in the fund, and then it disappeared. They examined why it disappeared and they found it had been shared out between the bacon curers on the board. The commission, after examining how the money was paid out and on what basis, say in their report:

"Unless the amount of the available fund be taken as a measure, there appears to have been no exact basis on which the amount of this payment was determined."

You have read of cases of larceny in the newspapers where men robbed a till. There may have been some squabble about how they divided what they got, but they took all that was in the till. That is what the curers did with the hypothetical fund. The commission's report, which is a sober one, says:

"Unless the amount of the available fund be taken as a measure, there appears to have been no exact basis on which the amount of this payment was determined."

They scooped the pool. They did not leave one penny of the hypothetical fund built up to increase the price of pigs when the price fell. That was reported. Was there any Government action? We raised the matter in the House and the Minister for Agriculture said he could not defend it. But he did not charge these people, he did not bring them before the court. If a man takes a stamp from another unemployment insurance book, though the stamp has not been previously used, and puts it in a new book to make up the proper number he has to have to get unemployment insurance, he is charged in the court with fraud, with getting money under false pretences. These people did away with £137,000 put in to help in the production of pigs and all the Minister can say is: "I do not stand over it."

But the commission went on to report that not merely did they do that, but it was clear, according to their calculations, that they took extortionate profits in four years amounting to £308,000. I think the £137,000, which I suggest they pilfered from the fund, is included in the £308,000. If it is not, it adds to the crime. In any event, there is a sum of £308,000 which they say, on their calculation, was taken in extortionate profits. What was the result? If you look at the statistics of bacon consumed in this country, you will find that 200,000 cwts. of bacon were taken off the breakfast and dinner tables of the people—bacon consumption declined by that amount. But, while consumption was going down, the curers were making excessive profits amounting to £308,000. When that was brought to the notice of one curer, his remark was that, even if that were true, it only meant that the curers during the four years charged about one-eighth of a penny per Ib. too much for bacon. I want to emphasise that, because there are matters we have to consider in regard to industries in this country. When one-eighth of a penny per lb. on a consumption of bacon reduced by 200,000 cwts. can mount up to £308,000 in four years, that shows where the takings are in this country. Am I right in describing the people who behaved in that way as the vultures who gather around the decay of Government administration?

One other thing that the farmers in this country are interested in is the growing of wheat. Wheat eventually makes its appearance before us as bread, but before it does so it has to be milted into flour. The firm of Rank arrived in this country and that firm at one time came under the scrutiny of a particular Government commission, and there is one marvellous paragraph in page 32 of the commission's report. This commission, I might mention was established by the Government to inquire into "the prices charged for wheaten flour by persons manufacturing such commodity in Saorstát Eireann". This is what the report contains:—

"The recent, flotation of Messrs. Ranks (Ireland) Ltd., is even more eloquent. Concerns previously capitalised at a lower aggregate figure were incorporated in a new company with a nominal capital of £700,000, and it was possible for the promoters to make a successful flotation on the basis of a market value of £1,452,500. Their success in disposing of the shares offered to the Irish public for a sum of, presumably, £533,750, despite the fact that effective control over the company was not transferred with such shares, must have been largely due to the following assurances contained in their prospectus:—

"The amount required annually to pay the dividends on the 350,000 6 per cent. Cumulative Preference Shares is £21,000; on the basis of the average profits for the last three years the dividend on the said 6 per cent. Cumulative Preference Shares is covered more than seven times, and on the same basis the amount available for dividend on the Ordinary Shares, subject to Reserves, is over 38 per cent.' "

Comment on this

Who would not be a flour miller?

Comment on this

I ask you to realise what that vulture company makes out of this community. All the taxpayers who pay the subsidy on flour will want to know how much Messrs. Ranks (Ireland) and Messrs. Ranks (England) are getting out of that subsidy. If you analyse that paragraph you will find it comes to this. Certain companies were amalgamated and they were said to have a nominal capital of £700,000. I understand that the fact is that the price paid for these concerns was about half of £700,000. In any event they were supposed to have a nominal capital value of £700,000. They were a flotation on the basis of a market value of £1,452,500 and the Irish public put up £533,750. The Irish public paid Mr. Rank of England all he had put into the purchase of the Ballantyne mills and gave him £100,000 over and above.

Comment on this
James Larkin Snr. Mr. Larkin (Senior) Labour Party

£250,000.

Comment on this

£250,000 over and above. He got £533,750 from the Irish public and retained a nominal holding of £900,000 in shares himself. He got his whole capital paid back, and a couple of hundreds of thousands in addition. He has been repaid all his capital, and whatever dividend now comes, he shares in the proportion of nine to five. That is the position, notwithstanding that he has repaid himself every penny he was out of pocket. We are subsidising that man through the subsidy on bread and flour. How much in the way of dividends has gone out of this country in over-payment for flour and bread to the man who has recouped himself for every penny he put into this business? How much is going to the Irish shareholders? We might like to see something going to the people who put money into the business, but it is a matter of opinion whether we would like to see anything going to the man who fleeced the Irish public and who now continues year by year, without the Minister ever saying "Boo" to him, to fleece the country of its dividends at a time when we are subsidising flour.

If it is the policy of the Government that they are going to continue the devastation of the Minister for Agriculture, and if we have to subsidise these commodities and allow these tributes to be pulled from us by people who have no right to them, then we have reached a shockingly bad position. The Ministers over there know these things, because these reports have been debated already in the House. What has been done to Messrs. Ranks (England), not Messrs. Ranks (Ireland), since, and to the bacon curers? Are the Government prepared to continue that policy, and do they consider it is in the interest of healthy agriculture here? Must we, the taxpayers, pay to have these foodstuffs subsidised to this extent, when we know that so much is going to a person who at the moment has not a penny of his own capital involved in that concern?

This policy has been carried through in such a way that the purchasing power of the £ has been reduced to 12/6. It is all very well being a good Republican and wanting to knock the King out of the Constitution; but when we get to the point at which we knock a crown and a half out of the £, then we are bringing politics to a really comical pass. But that is what the Government have done. That is what they have imposed, not merely on the income-tax payer, but on the man who is given a subsistence allowance, the old age pensioner upon whom Deputy Tunney picked, the person with the dole, the person in receipt of unemployment insurance or unemployment assistance, the man getting £2 or £3 a week, the middle-class families living on the proceeds of some little investments. All these people have deducted from them 7/6 in the £ before they start to spend anything. And that is the policy that some people in this country want to have continued.

Comment on this

The wealth of a nation can best be judged by the prosperity of the people of that nation. That applies to Ireland just the same as to any other nation on God's earth. I feel that no matter what amount of speech-making there is in this House, it will not alter the position that exists in the country. One gathers from the speakers on the opposite benches that there seems to be a certain amount of hatred, spite and envy in what they have to say. They do not seem to come here in order to give straight, honest-to-God criticism, to give a helping hand to whatever Government is in power. They seem to pride themselves on the fact that the Government have made mistakes and they like to expose the Government's mistakes. That can be applied to the Fine Gael Benches as well as to the Fianna Fáil Benches and perhaps it could be applied to our own benches.

Unless we get down to solid work, become more Christian-like and begin to realise that we have responsibilities, we cannot hope to progress. We should realise that we are sent here to work on behalf of the people, and not so much to work on our own behalf or to speak to the gallery. That is all wrong, and until we reflect and try to help in putting right whatever we believe is wrong, and give brotherly advice, friendly advice, and assist in every possible way in this country, I am, afraid we will not be able to make much progress.

As regards the Department of Local Government and Public Health, I observe that they require a sum of something over £500,000—£523,000, is the actual figure. I would like Deputies to consider how our people are being treated, people who wish to get hospital treatment, people who are suffering from various diseases, tuberculosis in particular. I could instance the cases of two very dear friends of mine, two women, one 25 years of age and the other, a mother, 40 years of age. The mother had to stay with her family—her husband died—for two years. She had no other place to go. She died. We have a tuberculosis hospital, I believe, near Ballinrobe, in the South Mayo constituency, but our doctor did not seem to be able to get her in there.

I consider that that is wrong. If we are asked to vote over £500,000 for public health, we should be careful how the money is spent and see that it is put to the very best use. Many millions of pounds have been spent during the past 10 or 12 years, since the Hospitals Sweepstake was established, and I can never understand where such sums are going in a country like this. I ask the responsible Minister to give the matter consideration. The disease will not be relieved, either in the cities or the rural areas, if you are to allow men and women to remain in thatched cottages in congested districts or to live in company with large families. The persons concerned should be removed. This is a very serious matter and deserves due consideration. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health should provide some remedy in the near future or things will take a very grave turn. We are asked to vote £4,500 for Fisheries.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Has not the Vote for Fisheries been disposed of?

Comment on this

Although the Estimate is not before us, I should like, with the permission of the Chair, to make a passing reference to the matter. In a neighbouring constituency to mine— I refer to North Mayo—the fishing industry is dwindling right along from Ballycroy to the Bangor Erris district. There, the people depend on the industry for a livelihood. It is rather sad to reflect that that industry has not been developed and that it has not become a national industry on a sound basis. We have only three deep-sea trawlers for that industry while, in 1939, we had nine. Whatever happened, they have diminished to three. We have a fine port at Blacksod Bay capable of accommodating an adequate fishing fleet.

I should like to remind the Minister that it is impossible to purchase material for the lining of the currachs or small fishing boats. It would be well if his attention were given to these matters and thus relieve the unemployment created by the lack of interest which the Minister for Lands or the Minister for Fisheries has taken in the fishing industry, particularly in western Ireland. We are asked to vote £1,265,000 for old age pensions. The system by which the means test is applied in the case of old age pensions is not fair. If you have an income of £15 12s. 6d., you are entitled to a pension of 10/-, but if you have an income of £39 15s., you are only entitled to 1/-. I do not think that that is very Christian-like, especially when we come in here and accept £40 a month. Somebody has interjected that I need not take the £40. After all, I think that I am as much entitled to take it as any man who sits on the benches on the other side or on this side. That does not alter the argument. Is the sum of £39 15s. plus 52/-, sufficient to maintain for a year a man or woman, whether they live in a city or in a town or in the country? I do not think that it is. Then, an inconceivable amount of red tape is involved before, the pension is obtained. A certificate has to be obtained, one has to go before the pensions committee, where he may be turned down. Then, the local pensions officer comes to visit him and, perhaps, makes a wrong report, which must be the case on many occasions. Six months elapse before the pension is obtained. I think that the work could be done much more easily and expeditiously. What would be wrong with the individual concerned writing to the local council or to the customs and excise, getting his certificate, sending it to the Department and getting his 10/-, if he comes, within the, regulations?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is reluctant to interrupt a newly elected Deputy, but it is necessary to point out that questions of administration do not arise on the Vote on Account. Questions of policy may be debated. Administration will arise on the Estimate later. The Deputy is now discussing details of administration.

Comment on this

We are asked to vote £1,250,000, and this is a very important matter. These questions have been drawn to my notice and, as a matter of fact, what I say applies to my own father.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will have a full opportunity when the Estimates are being considered. Inexperienced Deputies must be guided by the Chair.

Comment on this

Seeing that I am not abiding by the Rules and that I am promised the privilege of discussing the means test——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is more than a privilege; it is a right.

Comment on this

Then I shall pass on to something else.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has no power to closure the Deputy, but he would ask him to bear in mind the fact that it has been agreed that the Taoiseach be given an opportunity of concluding the debate to-night.

Comment on this

I shall occupy only about two minutes more. We are asked to vote a sum of £168,583 for Forestry. If it were possible, the provision for forestry should be increased in the next Budget because it is highly essential work. A country denuded of forestry is almost as bad as a country denuded of its people.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no item on the Vote on Account for forestry.

Comment on this

That is right. I am sorry. As long as we have unemployment, poverty and emigration, so long will this country find itself in its present condition. Some remedy must be found, and my suggestion is that we cannot find it if Parties come here merely to criticise whatever Government may be in power. If a voluntary commission were set up, consisting of Deputies from all Parties, which would not be any burden on the State, ways and means could be discussed to solve unemployment and to develop our natural resources. In that way we would be getting nearer to business. Until that is done I am very much afraid that people will lose the respect they should have for the National Assembly. People are losing respect for it because they feel that some Deputies come here and have a good time. It is no wonder they were told that at the general election. I hope that future discussions here will be on a more friendly basis, and that there will be a better understanding when business is discussed. It should be discussed in the national interest and not in Party interests or vote catching interests, or for a display of eloquence in this House or for the Gallery.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach to conclude.

Comment on this

I was not called.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is obvious that every Deputy could not be called upon if the unanimous decision of the House that the Taoiseach would conclude to-night is to be honoured.

Comment on this

Can I speak until 10 o'clock?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest that the Deputy should give way and allow the Taoiseach to do so.

Comment on this

Very well. I will allow the Taoiseach to reply. Some other time I will get my own back.

Comment on this

Before I deal with some of the larger questions involved I should like to settle a point that arose between Deputy Davin and myself. The Deputy gave certain statistics and made a number of statements in regard to them. I questioned his figures. The first statement of the Deputy was that since Fianna Fáil came into office, and since Dr. Ryan became Minister for Agriculture, the value of agricultural production has gone down by £15,000,000. That was a very definite statement. I had got the statistics examined and I could not find any figures to justify the Deputy's statement. I pursued the Deputy's remarks in order to have the matter debated. The Deputy stated yesterday that, according to Table 59 of the Statistical Abstract for the year 1932, the total agricultural production for 1929-30 was £64,865,000, and he gave Table 58 from the Statistical Abstract for the year 1939, in which prices are given for 1937-38, as showing the total value of agricultural production for that period as £49,662,000. He asked me to subtract the two figures and said that I would get £15,000,000. Of course, I was very innocent, and when I heard that that was the case since Fianna Fáil came into office and since Dr. Ryan became Minister for Agriculture, I naturally expected that I would find the figures related to the beginning and the end of that period. But that is not Deputy Davin's method. The Deputy picked the year 1937-38. Why? There was no reason for choosing that particular period. I can see no reason for doing so. In order to get a figure of that kind he had to go back to a period even before the getaeral election previous to the last. What was the purpose of that? Is that straight dealing? If he told us that in 1937-38 the figure was so and so and that in 1929-30 the figure was so and so, we could understand it, but to keep from us the fact that he took as a beginning the year 1929-30, before the present Minister came into power, and when prices were still higher than when he took office in 1932, and then to take a period half-way in our period of office before the previous general election is not, I think, fair to the House.

If we are to argue intelligently here and to use statistics honestly, we ought, at least, be given an opportunity of knowing what the figures relate to in order to see if the conclusions are justified. The first period was 1936-37. Why was that chosen? The Deputy told us that he took the Statistical Abstract for 1938 and suggested that it gave the latest available figures. Everybody knows that there was a Statistical Abstract published in 1939, in 1940, in 1941 and 1942. The Deputy did not choose any one of these. Not merely did he choose the one for 1929-30, which was two or three years before the Minister took office, and a time when prices and the value of produce were far higher than in 1932, but apparently he was not aware of the fact, and did not trouble to make himself aware, that there was a change in the basis of calculation as explained in 1938. Where he gave £64,000,000 and compared it with £49,000,000, in fact, the two sets of figures in that form are not comparable at all, because the basis was changed. If the Deputy wanted to compare the figures, instead of £64,000,000 he will have to use £62,000,000.

Having regard to the statement made by the last Deputy, if we are to do useful work here, we must give up the rhetoric and try to give consideration to facts. We ought to be told here what is the position and if there are any evils connected with it, let them be pointed out. If we want to look at the future, let us do so on the basis of the truth is we see it. If we proceed in that way then we will be a useful Assembly and will be doing useful work. I have another figure from Deputy Davin's statement and, if he were in the House now I would ask him to show me where he got it. I cannot find it. The Deputy stated that the value of our agricultural produce consumed in this country had gone down by £8,500,000.

I cannot find that. I have here a very extensive table going back to the year 1929-30, which Deputy Davin took. There is a gap because, apparently, the figures were not worked out for the years 1931-32, and a few subsequent years but I have the figures for 1938-39, 1940-41, 1941-42, and when I look along these figures I can see no indication whatever of any figures that would lead to the conclusion that there has been a reduction in home consumption of £8,500,000. I do not want to go through all these figures that I have. Naturally, during the depression, the figures were lowest in value, although the percentage was not necessarily the lowest. The value of home consumption was low back in 1935-36, and lower still in 1934-35. It rose steadily, however, between —I am giving the figures in million now—from £26 to £27, to £30, to £32, to £33, to £47, to £54. In other words, there was a steady increase in value, and that is the value of the agricultural produce consumed at home, to which the Deputy refers.

In the same way, I have the percentages of the value of the total output that was consumed at home, and here are the figures. The figures I have just given were the absolute figures in millions of pounds sterling, but here are the percentages. In 1935, the percentage was 66.9. It then went down to 65 per cent., then down to 62, and in the following year was again 62. Then there was a slight increase from 62 to 62.6, and then the percentage swung up to 69 and then to 71.4, at which it stands at present. Where, then, is the basis for the statement that there has been a decrease in home consumption? I cannot find it. If we are to argue to a point at all, and not be at cross purposes, we must be able to see what is the basis of figures that are quoted. It has been said that you can use figures to prove anything, and there is no doubt that figures can be wrongly used and that wrong conclusions can be drawn from them. In fact, it is not easy to draw the right conclusions from statistics. Very often, it requires experts to determine where there are charges of one kind or another to make sure that the figures used are comparable.

I think that a lot of the statements made in this debate were on a par with the statements made by Deputy Davin. They are statements made without any basis, in fact. Nothing is easier than to use phrases such as "No good,""Dismal failure,""Inefficiency," and so forth. I have heard parrots taught to say "No good," or "Dismal failure," and things of that sort. You can teach any parrot to say things like that, and those who have criticised the Minister for Agriculture have followed that line. I do not think that any person dealt seriously with what were the principles of the policy at all. If we were making it our general peacetime policy, then I would say that Deputy Dillon touched upon it, although I do not agree with his argument, because I think it is ridiculous. Deputy Dillon, in effect appreciated, what was in his right hand and depreciated what was in his left hand. He completely ignored the real basis of values. However, I take it that it was not the policy of peace time, but the policy that is being pursued at the moment that is in question.

Comment on this

And, surely, post-war policy also?

Comment on this

Yes, but it was the policy at the moment that was criticised. Deputy McGilligan referred to the flight from the land. Every evil that exists in this country is attributed to the policy of the Minister for Agriculture. My goodness, if the Minister for Agriculture were able to do all the things that it is suggested, by the attacks made on him here, it is possible for him to do, he would be one of the greatest geniuses in the world. He would be more than a man: he would be almost a god. He would be able to remedy all the evils that exist in our society. I have been in this House a very long time, and I have never heard a more unfair attack than the attack that has been made on the Minister for Agriculture. There is only one explanation of it, and that is that he is the cause of the war. I see no other. It is only if you can put at his door the responsibility for the present war that you can blame him for the evils that exist at the present time. Is he responsible for the war? I asked that question before. Were we responsible for the war, and are we to be held responsible for all the things that have followed almost inevitably from the war?

Comment on this

That is a question of the right hand and the left hand too.

Comment on this

It is not. It is a fact that the things that the Minister for Agriculture has been accused as being responsible for are things that have followed almost inevitably as a result of this war that is raging around us. It is easy for anybody going through this world of ours to be able to point to the very many evils and dangers that exist. I suppose the world is going to be a vale of tears to the end of time. I agree that it should be our duty to try to do our utmost to relieve all the miseries that we can relieve, and that, so far as it is humanly possible for us to do it, we should use all our efforts to remedy these, but it is one thing to be able to point out an evil and quite a different thing to be able to show an effective remedy. Some people try to find remedies, as I myself am inclined to, by a process of reform, trying to end each evil as we see it.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I believe in that, because there is one advantage in that method of procedure, and that is that you have the evils before you and can see them, and if you can correct one of them without introducing extra evils, then you certainly have a definite improvement. Very often, however, when you remedy one evil, the method by which you try to remedy it introduces, other evils.

Comment on this

You can tackle those then.

Comment on this

You have to try to calculate—sometimes it is a very nice calculation—whether or not the remedy you propose is a genuine remedy. But at least you have the whole of the facts; you can find the result of your change, and you are able to judge whether your remedy is effective or not. Other people will say: "The whole system is wrong. Let us end it. Let us take the whole thing away and try a new system." My objection to that as a method of dealing with those human evils is that you do not know where you are going. You get rid of a certain number of evils, but you have no idea of the number of other types of evils that you introduce, and they may be far worse in their ultimate effect than the evils you are trying to remedy. That is my philosophy. I take the reformist line in regard to those social and economic matters, not the revolutionary line. I do that for what I consider the good sound reasons I have given. Perhaps there may be something in one's own character which helps one to approach it in that particular way. I believe that I adopt it not through any want of courage to face the other line, but it is my conviction that you do make more progress by the method of reform, getting rid of the separate evils that you see, than you do by the other method. Looking out upon life generally, it seems to me that progress is made as a result of the operation of two forces. There is the progressive force, which is always putting out its tentacles, so to speak, trying to find a spot where it can survive. If circumstances are such that it can survive, then it is established and you have definite progress. If the circumstances are such that it cannot survive, that ends the effort in that direction.

Those are the progressive forces, always trying to move forward. Then there are the conservative forces, which try to maintain what has been got. I do believe that it is in the balance of those forces that most progress in human affairs is made. I only say those things because I think it is wise that we should try to approach all those questions from some fundamental point of view, and that we should have some general principles on which to work.

With regard to our general policy here, we in Fianna Fáil definitely believe that, in our particular set of circumstances, greater progress can be made in producing prosperity and happiness for our people on the basis of attempting reasonable self-sufficiency than on any other basis. If anybody wants to know what our policy is, if anybody wants to talk about the policy of the Minister for Agriculture, the policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, or any other part of our policy, he will find that there has been a definite, steady movement along those particular lines. Have we been successful or not? Time alone will be able to tell that. We know perfectly well that a good deal can be said for the free trade arguments. We only say that, in our particular set of circumstances, those arguments are not sound. You could regard us as at one side of the scale, and you could regard Deputy Dillon—as far as I have ever heard or understood him—as at the other. I believe that Deputy Dillon's policy generally would result in this country becoming a large ranch. It would mean the end of the idea of the wider distribution of ownership of property. You would have, very definitely, to enlarge your holdings if you were going to compete in the British market with relatively undeveloped countries like New Zealand and the Argentine, where there is vast, untapped wealth. The Minister for Agriculture was quoted here by Deputy McGilligan. Deputy McGilligan always makes his speeches by reading long quotations. It is an easy way to make a speech. If you get long excerpts, you can speak for half an hour, an hour, or several hours by reading out those quotations.

Comment on this

They were very instructive.

Comment on this

Was the forecast of the Minister for Agriculture true or likely to be true, or was it not? It is not a question of whether the Minister for Agriculture has courage or the opposite. It is not a question of whether the Minister for Agriculture is optimistic or not. In the long run, it does not matter a thrauneen to us whether the Minister for Agriculture is optimistic or otherwise. The whole question is: Is he right? Is the future which he envisages going to be the future, in fact, or is it not?

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

It is a pretty hopeless one.

Comment on this

Is it or is it not a fact that, in the post-war period as in the period of depression, we are going to have to compete in a market which will not give to our farmers a remunerative rate of return unless they are able so to improve their methods of production as to make that possible?

Comment on this

And to get their raw materials free of taxation.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have to think of all those things as a whole. If the Deputy wants me to argue every point with him, I can do it. It is not the first time I have thought of those things, and I say that the Deputy's policy would reduce this country to a ranch, and would certainly reduce our population in order that with larger areas, with fewer hands, and with more agricultural equipment we would be able to produce in such a way that we could compete with the people from the Argentine——

Comment on this

Is not the population steadily dwindling under your policy?

Comment on this

It may be that our policy has not shown positive results ——

Comment on this

They could not go out any faster.

Comment on this

——but I deny it, because the circumstances in which we are testing it at the moment, or the circumstances in which we were able to test it during the economic war, are not normal circumstances. We have not been able to test it yet. But suppose it had been tested, would it not be a reasonable answer if I were to say to the Deputy: "That is the result—a diminution if you like—of our policy, but in heaven's name what would it be if the opposite policy were adopted?" It has not been tested, but I think it is reasonable to suppose that, if we have to compete with the Argentine and New Zealand in an open foreign market, we will have to approximate to the conditions which enable them to do it. During the last election, I pointed out that the price of butter in the British market in 1934—the open price, not the price after the British had taken off their penal tariffs—was 7d. a Ib. the equivalent of 3d. a gallon for milk; 2? gallons of milk go to make 1 Ib. of butter. To-day, we are talking about 9d. a gallon not being enough, but 3d. a gallon was what the farmer was going to get for producing butter for the British market at that particular time. We had to subsidise it. At that time, we gave him 1/2½, or within a small fraction of it, for 1-lb. of butter. We had to give him more than double what he was getting on the British market. Was there any way out of it? Again, at the same time, I pointed out that the British Minister for Agriculture, when some people went along to try to get a better price for our produce, said to them:—

"Come down with me to the Smithfield market, and I will show you beef from the Argentine, meat which any of you gentlemen will admit that you will be glad to eat, and it has been landed at 1½d. a lb."

That is the sort of competition you would have to meet if you were relying on the foreign market alone. That is the sort of competition that agriculture would have to face and that is the sort of competition even in a worse form that you may have to face after the war.

Comment on this

I take it that the figure of 1½d. per Ib. for beef is correct?

Comment on this

It is correct.

Comment on this

What was the year?

Comment on this

1934.

Comment on this

Would the Taoiseach say that 3d. per gallon was the price paid to the farmers in New Zealand for their milk?

Comment on this

I am not talking about the price paid to the farmers in New Zealand. I am talking of the price paid for butter in the British market in October, 1934.

Comment on this

That is the competition we have been fighting for the last 50 years.

Comment on this

I did not say anything about the price in New Zealand. I am talking about the price that could be got for butter in the British market in October, 1934—7d. per Ib. It was the lowest price touched, I think.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

October of what year?

Comment on this

October, 1934. That gives you a price of 3d. per gallon for milk, assuming that 2? gallons of milk on the average, are required to make a pound of butter.

Comment on this

Would I be entitled to assume from that that 3d. per gallon was the price paid to the New Zealand farmers for their milk?

Comment on this

I do not know. There may have been a lot of other factors. There may have been subsidies for all I know. The Minister for Agriculture was criticised by Deputy McGilligan because he stated we would have to face a position of that kind.

Comment on this

We have been facing it for the last 50 years.

Comment on this

We are faced with the fact that, if we are to depend to any extent on an outside market, we shall have to be in a position to produce here at rates comparable to the rates at which farmers in the Argentine and elsewhere can produce. I say that the result of that competition, during the period of the depression, meant that the price you got for butter was 7d. per Ib. and our whole dairying industry was being destroyed. We had to come along and subsidise it. We had to build up that price so as to give the farmers at home, not 7d., which would be the equivalent only of 3d. per gallon, but 1/2½d. per Ib.—or at least a price much nearer 1/2½d. than 1/2. That is to say, we had to more than double the price which we got on the British market. Now it is said that we are going to be in a very parlous condition——

Comment on this

Does the Taoiseach certify to the House that Argentine beef, which was not frozen, was delivered at 1½d. per Ib. in London?

Comment on this

I am only repeating what I heard. I am quoting the remark that was made by the Minister for Agriculture in Britain:

"Come down with me to the Smithfield market and I will show you beef that is being landed here from the Argentine at 1½d. per Ib., meat which I am sure any of you genflemen will admit you would be glad to eat."

Comment on this

If he said that, he was a liar.

Comment on this

We are meeting that competition for the last 50 years.

Comment on this

We have not been dealing with that competition for the last 50 years.

Comment on this

We have.

Comment on this

We have not.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Sam Savino sold beef at 3d. per Ib. here.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach must be heard without interruption. He has only 35 minutes in which to reply to a two days' debate.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

We can sit until midnight or later if necessary.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is too late now to arrange that.

Comment on this

I am simply dealing with the position we have to face and I say, in view of that, it is obviously good policy for us in this country to try to give our farmers as much of the home market as we possibly can. I say that the more we use of their produce in the home market, the more we see that a high proportion is used at home, the more we should be pleased, assuming that at any particular stage production is as high as it can be. By all means, let us increase production, but the Minister for Agriculture cannot go in on every farm. He cannot go out in the morning and tell every farmer to get up or keep at his elbow all day or do things of that kind. He can only indicate general principles and pursue a definite policy. The policy I have been trying to indicate to you is the policy that has been consistently pursued. That policy has been that, at times like those of which I have spoken, when owing to this terrible competition in outside markets we got unremunerative prices, we said: "Give the farmer the home market and do not bring in from outside bacon and other commodities that can be produced here at home. If the price he gets for animal products is not remunerative let him use his land in other ways."

Comment on this

And work 70 hours a week.

Comment on this

If we import less, we shall have to export less. We have to export to buy the things we cannot produce here at home, but if there are things which we can produce at home, why compel us to import them and to export other things at unremunerative prices in order to do that? If we were in the position which Deputy Dillon suggested, that by rearing cattle and selling them as beef we could get twice as much out of an acre of land as by producing wheat on it—if that were true it would be quite a different story, but it is not true. Away back in 1928, when we sat at an economic conference it was proved from the figures officially supplied that an acre of land turned over to wheat production was giving more to the community—more food, more money value even—than an acre of land either producing beef or milk.

The time allotted to me is exhausted, but we shall come back to this subject on many occasions. All I want to say now is that we have never suggested that the Minister for Agriculture is a superman, but he is a better man to be Minister of Agriculture than any other man I see here. He is certainly better than the gentleman who came here to criticise him, and who, I presume, expected to be selected to fill his place in a coalition Government.

Comment on this