Committee on Finance. - Vote 30—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 1–188 of 379. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I desire to draw the Minister's attention to what occurred in the City of Dublin a few years ago when the cattle trade might have been destroyed. We all remember when the foot-and-mouth disease attacked this country. It was a member of my union, an ordinary semi-illiterate workman, who discovered the particular beast that was suffering from the disease. The cattle had been going up and down the quays five days, and the experts and veterinary officers never noticed that this animal was suffering from the disease. When the outbreak of the disease was notified, immediately everybody turned in to grapple with this fearful crisis that threatened the entire cattle trade. I and the members of my union practically lived in the abattoir where the cattle had to be slaughtered.
This is where I suggest the Minister failed on the administrative side. He appointed five of the biggest men in the cattle trade to handle all the cattle, but there was almost a revolution, by the people who owned the cattle, against control. Those five men brought the cattle to the abattoir. That was all they did. They had a very large sum of money at their disposal. They were given unlimited credit. The Minister knows that I and the men I represent lived in the abattoir. We were there for 24 hours of the day on seven days a week. When we approached these five men with a view to being paid a reasonable wage, as well as overtime rates for Sunday work and St. Patrick's Day, we were told by them that they had lost money and were losing money. These working-class men responded as patriots to the appeal made to them and decided to work the overtime as well as on Sundays and on St. Patrick's Day without anything extra. What did we find the other day? That the five gentlemen who held up that money handed back a surplus of £5,000 to the Minister. I suggest to the Minister that he has a duty to perform to the men who were engaged on that work, and should pay to them out of that £5,000 the money that is lawfully due to them.
We had an alleged potato shortage in the City of Dublin last year. One gentleman said that there were no queues for potatoes in this city. What are you to think of an intelligent human being wlio would come into a city and tell a deliberate lie reflecting on the honesty of the people? We know that there were queues composed of 100 persons in poor areas of the city standing there waiting to get even half a stone of potatoes. How did the Minister for Agriculture deal with that problem? He appointed a number of men to exercise control, one of them being a gentleman who had only been in the potato racket for less than 18 months. He had never been known in the potato market before. They were given power to control potatoes from the sources of supply. How did they do it? The early market gardeners in North County Dublin stripped the vines, took up the tubers and for these early potatoes they were enabled to get from £1 to 30/- a cwt.
I saw them in some shops charging 5/- a stone for potatoes. After a time, they found out that these gentlemen said there were no potatoes, while, in the City of Dublin, the 1942 crop was still lying in certain stores. Potatoes which are normally sold at 10d. to 1/- a stone were lying available, but these gentlemen could not put their hands on them. They went and got the potatoes which are generally shipped, and why they should be shipped at all when people want food I do not know.
One Deputy said that nothing less than £25 a ton would pay the growers of early potatoes. I wonder do Deputies ever work out figures for themselves? I grew potatoes in North County Dublin, in the area of Deputy P.J. Fogarty, who is now engaged in another occupation and reaping profits from the unsuspecting and susceptible, and I sold them at 5d. a stone, making a profit. I grew them from Tipperary bog seed, working a plot of 50 Irish acres myself and I made a profit. That cannot be challenged. While you have the system of dealing with food which we have in Dublin, when food is grown and brought into Dublin by low-paid labour, which works sometimes 20 hours in the 24, sold on the stall and while you are looking at it the price increases 400 per cent.—you bring in cabbages and sell them at 15/- a 1,000 and before you move away, they are being sold at £5—so long as you permit that kind of graft to be carried on all over the country there is no way for the farmer to get a fair return for his labour nor for the labourer to get payment for the hours he works. It is going on all over the country in the cattle trade, the corn trade and the potato trade.
I remember the Minister for Industry and Commerce being attacked here for buying potatoes for the alcohol factory near Dundalk at £2 per ton. It was said that he was giving a fair price and Deputies heard him saying that. Anybody who knows that area knows that it was a scheduled area at that time, but the potato grown in that area was the finest potato I ever ate, and yet it was sold at only £2 per ton. I remember these potatoes being shipped to England at £2 and £2 10s. 0d. per ton, but here we have a gentleman who gets £9 subsidy, plus £16 cash on the market, and now when we balance the books and find that he incurred a loss on shipping these early potatoes, we are going to make it good. Is there any man in the country or outside it who can get £25 a ton for potatoes who would not turn his activities solely to growing potatoes?
A Deputy made a very interesting speech here yesterday—what one could hear of it—and said that he would be satisfied in Westmeath with £10 per ton. I do not know whether he meant a subsidy of £10 plus the market price, but supposing he got £20 per ton or 2/6 per stone, would that pay him to grow potatoes? He would be a millionaire in a short time if he had sufficient acreage.
We have the same position with regard to bacon. A few weeks ago, before the Minister corrected his mistake and removed the grip which the Bacon Board had on the trade, I went to some of my colleagues and told them we could not get any bacon or any pork in Dublin. Yet the stuff was available. I asked: "Why do you not have the sense to lift this fixed price restriction? If it is to be a free market, let it be a free market for everybody and not one in which one crowd is at liberty to charge what they like, while the man who produces is limited to a particular price." The price was 125/- per cwt., while, in the same market, the black market gang were paying up to 160/-, before the inspector himself. While the Department's inspectors stood there, they were paying 160/- and 165/- and taking the pigs away from the fair, while the other gentlemen who wanted to pay were not allowed to do so. The Government removed the fixed price restriction and what did the price rise to? It rose to 180/- in one week. I wonder are pig producers making any money at 180/- per cwt?
It is said that there is no food for the pigs, but I suggest to the Minister that we could get any amount of feeding provided in and around Dublin. The Minister was astounded—and he will have to admit that he did not know that the information was available in statistics published by his own Department—when I told him the statistics regarding the swine population. I told him there were only 41,000 breeding sows in the country last year. I told him how many registered boars there were. It was information which he did not know and I have witnesses in the House who can prove it. Four years ago, we had 100,000 breeding sows and now we have 41,000. But, of course, we who have nothing to do with agriculture know nothing about these things.
Think of a country like Ireland with only 41,000 breeding sows and no feeding for them, when all around the City of Dublin you cannot find an exit because of the golf links. I will feed the pig population of the whole of Ireland on the barley I will produce in and around the City of Dublin. I understand that one of my colleagues suggested that we ought to have a municipal golf course. Some other gentleman told him how much it would cost and said that if he had the money, had paid his subscription and got his bag and clubs, he would possibly be blackballed. I would blackball everybody who has land lying idle in and about a city such as Dublin, which was held up to the point of starvation and in which little children were going without food last winter, when women had to stand with very little clothing in bitterly cold weather, to beg a half-stone of potatoes. But, of course, the Minister and his colleagues with their salaries, and I enjoying a similarly well-paid job—what do we care?
Hundreds of children died last winter, in my opinion, because of lack of proper food. It was not merely a matter of the potatoes; the same applied to milk. We could not get milk for children in the schools. One eminent amateur theologian told us that if we gave children a hot meal, we would endanger their immortal souls but his children were well-fed and he was well-fed, while the poor children in the schools developed all kinds of skin diseases—scrofula, dermatitis and scabies—because of lack of food and nutriment last winter, due to the greed and rapacity of these gentlemen who held us up charging all kinds of prices for milk, when it could be got. We were told there was a fixed price but you could get milk in the black market and not in any other. You could get all the potatoes you wanted, or at least the bourgeoisie of Ballsbridge could get all the potatoes they wanted. There was no difficulty about it. There was no difficulty. It was only in the working class districts that they had to queue for potatoes.
There was another astonishing thing in regard to the killing of pigs. I told the Minister of it and I said: "Why do not you carry out the law?" There is a number of men interned in the Curragh for thinking, never mind acting. But in the City of Dublin there was a man killing pigs in a tenement house. We gave the Minister the case of a gentleman—he has since been prosecuted—who actually killed 25 pigs in his own house in Dun Laoghaire in one week, while we have adequate slaughter houses and pork establishments. We had an abattoir lacking supplies of pigs, while these gentlemen were killing them in the cellars. There was a prosecution a year ago against one man, which failed on a technical point. That man was charging what he liked for the bacon. There is another feature of the case. Deputies who know how to make even country bacon know that there is not a more dangerous thing in the world than diseased pork It is a fearful thing. Badly cured pork that has been a day or two in hot weather would destroy a nation. I understand that the Minister admits that what we said to him is proof that even the best hotels had bacon that was not fit for human consumption.
The Minister has many sins to answer for in addition to those to which he has confessed. I believe he will get forgiveness because we realise his many difficulties but I would suggest that he should turn his attention to the things he has not done. I would suggest to him that when he gets men who know something about the subject, it would be well to take them into counsel. Deputies referred yesterday to advisory committees and consultative committees. I wonder do these Deputies know that an advisory committee is totally different from a consultative committee. There is no use consulting people if you do not take some advice from them. If their advice seems to be in the interests of the country, it should be taken no matter what their politics are and no matter what report is sent up from some little group alleged to be an organisation of Fianna Fáil or of the Labour Party or of Fine Gael. Do not mind that kind of thing. Half the letters written in the Dublin papers are either written in the office or by interested persons. When you are dealing with men who are engaged in day-to-day problems, try to appreciate them, whether they come from one Party or another. If we take that approach and try to get a common denominator, we can solve many of our difficulties. It is possible to work together, even in a stupid way, making, mistakes and correcting mistakes. Nobody ever lived who did not make mistakes. Even I do at times. Deputy Dillon does not make mistakes but, of course, he is an exceptional person. Even Deputy Dillon at times has a deep sense of responsibility, and I have heard him contributing some very useful information to this House. There are other men who have done the same.
Outside the House there are men who are deeply interested in this country. I never thought I would hear it said in this House that people do not work for patriotism in this country, that it is purely a business matter. There is a great deal of truth in that, but no people ever proved their patriotism as did the men and women of this country. Even during the past four years men have stood in the first line trenches in this country and have carried on the work against all kinds of moral suasions, financial stress, and every pressure that could be brought to bear upon them. Do you think the 160,000 men who have joined the British, armed forces did that for love of the British Empire? The men who left their homes to seek work in England did not do it for a joke, but because they were driven out by hard brutal hunger and the denial of a right to live in their own country. The 110,000 men and women who left this country to work for £4 a week in Birmingham, or Coventry, Norwich or any other town did not do that for a joke. The 60,000 merchant seamen of the Twenty-Six Counties who are going overseas and carrying the necessary foods and ammunition to keep the Empire safe and secure did not do that for a joke.
What attempt have we made to give them a chance to live at home? Examine your conscience. I would suggest that the Minister for Agriculture is the one man in the Government who could do most to prevent that loss of the vital blood of this nation. I suggest he ought to consult anybody who can give him ideas that will help to close the ports against that flow of the best blood of the nation. It is going on and it will continue to go on. I was in Norfolk a few weeks ago and men who have been working in the fields there for less than a week have now £21. I wonder how long a man would be in Carlow or the adjacent counties before he would have £21? Would he have it in a month or three months? Yet, surely they work just as hard in Carlow, Kilkenny, or any other county as they do in Norfolk. Do you think a man would be satisfied with a wage of 35/- or with a wage of 41/- in the County of Dublin? The fanners are very generous in Dublin. They are the most generous souls in the world. Paddy Belton is one of them. He gives away money. He even gives away his ideas. When we ask for sound boots for them we are told that it is not possible to get boots of the kind they require. They have to buy boots out of 35/- a week and feed a woman and five children.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce took some action in that respect. He allowed his friend, Woolfson, to import 215,000 pairs of discarded boots of the British Army. Disease is transmitted by the use of second-hand boots which have been worn by people suffering, possibly, from all sorts of disease. Any person or any Government that allows people to use second-hand boots is committing an offence against ordinary decency and humanity and is bringing disease, possibly, into this country. Remember, disease is coming into this country. There are 30,000 cases of scabies in the City of Dublin at the present time. If that is allowed to continue we, a clean-skin nation, will be destroyed. However, that is not the particular province of the Minister for Agriculture.
Is it fair that the Minister for Agriculture should allow this racket in the bacon and pork trade to continue? I can tell the House what the wages of these men are. It is a fixed wage in the bacon trade and a fixed wage in the pork trade. Does the Minister want to drive these skilled men out of the country? A man who can cure bacon is a man worthy of being retained. He is worth his wages. Do not drive them out. Within the last year 35 highly-skilled pork butchers have left Dublin alone. I would draw attention to the ineptitude of the Minister in enforcing the law. During the crisis created by the foot-and-mouth disease, we were killing 1,400 cattle a week in the abattoir. I hope that some day in Dublin, with the help of the Government, we will have a proper abattoir. The bulk of these cattle were for the canning trade. I do not want to go into the question of the canning trade now. In my time at school in England when we came out into the street there would be a sang outside who would shout: "Hit up these Irish." They would be waiting in hundreds to beat us up before we could get home. Incidentally I might mention that I saw a woman and her daughter stripped naked outside that school in Liverpool and their furniture burned in the street. There was a great deal of hatred throughout England for the Irish. Those who had to travel in England and Wales organising in connection with the trade union movement know that what they had principally to contend with was their Irish faces. They do not hate us any more in England. There is no more of that fanatical hatred of the Irish people, but there is what is even worse, contempt for them.
You could not get anybody to discuss anything in connection with these problems now. They do not bother with you any more. They look upon you as something outside the ordinary pale of humanity. That is the position we have brought ourselves into because we have not the ability to bargain. We give them the best food we can produce at their price, under their dictation. They treat you the same as they treated the plenipotentiaries who went over to meet Lloyd George and Bertie Smith and the rest of the gang who caused the fratricidal strife to start in this country. In the same way as you met them then and cowered before them you are cowering before them to-day. You have no need to be frightened of them. When you go into the ordinary market you have something to sell and to bargain with and you ought to insist on being treated with respect. The dago from the Argentine can get his price, or the individual from any other country. Surely we have men of ability in this country who know their subject who could go over and ask our friends across the water to give us a quid pro quo for what we provide them with.
To return to the abattoir business, as I say, 1,400 cattle per week were being killed for the canning trade. Do Deputies know that the bone matter in an ordinary old cow would weigh 3 or 4 or 5 cwts., and in a heavy bull it would run up to 8 or 9 cwts.? That bone matter will give the best fatty matter you could produce. That bone matter is cast aside and allowed to lie about until it rots. Then it is carted away to the manure merchant and the rats have three or four weeks' nibbling at the flesh on it before it is put into the bone mill to make bone manure. The Minister for Local Government on two occasions was approached by me on that matter and there were deputations of women interested in the poor who asked him to insist upon these bones being taken away and rendered down in order to get fatty matter from them. But the Minister did nothing. He would not allow these bones to be rendered down in order to get fatty matter which the people of Dublin wanted badly. Dripping in Dublin is 2/- a lb., when it can be got. Yet that is allowed to go on still. If any Deputy comes with me to the abattoir I can show him hundreds of lbs. of bone matter which is allowed to rot before it is taken away to the manure manufacturers.
Comment on this
The Minister is not responsible for that. The Deputy can raise the matter on the Vote for the Department of Local Government.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Department that deals with the food supplies coming from the abattoir is the Department of Agriculture. The Minister knows he has full power to deal with that matter. Although that is going on still, we are told that more butter is being used now than formerly because the people cannot get fatty matters. They are bound to use more butter if they cannot get fatty matters. The confectionery trade and the ordinary housekeeper would prefer to have dripping rather than butter for certain things. What about the hungry children in Dublin? These bones would make the best of broth for them.
Comment on this
I have already told the Deputy that the Minister for Agriculture is not responsible for that matter and that he can raise it on another occasion.
Comment on this
These matters of administration are under the direction of the responsible Minister and, if he fails in his duty, then undoubtedly everybody in the community will suffer. There are other matters I should like to call attention to, but there is an immediate problem affecting nearly one-third of the population of the Twenty-Six Counties. After all, there are nearly 500,000 people in the City and County of Dublin who are worthy of consideration. I do not think that we are giving them any attention, but that we are lacking in respect, if we do not provide the means of living. We have not done so during the past three winters and a heavy burden has fallen on the citizens of Dublin. I suggest that the Minister—or the incoming Minister, as may arise soon—should turn his attention to this matter. The present Minister has never at any time lacked courtesy, he is one of the most courteous Ministers in the Government; but courtesy does not get you anywhere—action is what we want.
I see that one of the commitments here is the advancement of money under M (1), £24,000, which it is suggested might be borrowed. I wonder if the Minister has the audacity to insult the intelligence of the people by suggesting that the farmers who are borrowing money are going to be charged 4½ per cent. for it. Is there any farmer who is fool enough to pay 4½ per cent. when Great Britain is borrowing millions every day at 2 and 2½ per cent.? They can borrow all the money they want for the purpose of the destruction of life, with collaterals that are not sound, and where the sterling value is falling down in intrinsic value every day. It is a great gesture to give the farmer that, if he applies in a certain way for advances and shows what collateral he has to offer—and there is no better than the land, the soundest one man can offer to another—he has to pay 4½ per cent. I suggest the Minister look at what happened in Limerick when the loan was oversubscribed in 20 minutes. I suggest that the £108,000,000 of idle money in the banks of Ireland, earning nothing at all, and that the £300,000,000 frozen in Great Britain should be good enough to reduce the charges on these advances to 3 per cent. I believe that, if the Government put a loan of £10,000,000 or £20,000,000 on the market to-morrow for the purpose of getting a surplus fund to lend to farmers who need it for seed or plants, that loan would be subscribed within an hour. That is my last recommendation to the House, which I thank for having listened with attention.
Comment on this
There is very little left for me to say on this question. I am sure the, Minister has learned a lot from the debate during the past few days. I would like information, firstly, on the question of machinery. I have made representations to the Minister on several occasions for machinery that is urgently required in various parts of my own constituency, and I find that the machinery has been allocated already. I would like to know how he gives out that machinery, who qualifies for the permits for the purchase of it, or where it has gone. It has not gone to Roscommon, and it has not gone to Leix-Offaly. I would like to know where the 100 tractors, the 100 reapers and binders, and the 22 threshing mills have gone, if they were here at all.
Furthermore, I would like to state that I am in full agreement with the Government's compulsory wheat-growing policy. I know very well that the small farmer does not need compulsory-orders to grow wheat, he is growing it already and in various parts of the country more than the quota is being grown. But there are the big farmers who do not want to grow. Those men should be made grow it and I am glad to see that the Minister for Agriculture is making them grow it. In parts of Offaly, in Clareen near Birr, as I understand the Minister is already aware, there are certain landowners who will not till their quota. I would like to know if proceedings will be instituted against such farmers. Is the Minister aware that ten or 12 small cottiers living quite convenient to those lands last year could not get the grazing of their cattle or land to produce potatoes for themselves and their families for the present year?
There are many large farms throughout the country which could be put into production. The people are well prepared to work the land and produce food and those in the constituency I represent have played a noble part in the past in doing so and are prepared to do it again. There are fine big farms in some parts and if the Minister for Lands would divide them—now is the real time for land division—we could grow more food while the demand is there.
Deputy Killilea raised a point this morning in connection with the farm improvements scheme. It is the best scheme this Government ever put into operation. I know thousands of acres which were not arable and which are now producing the best crops. The Minister should consider giving 75 per cent. instead of 50 per cent. of the grant for those improvements, as it is one of the best schemes the Government has sponsored. Deputies like myself from rural Ireland realise the benefit this scheme has been to the farmers there.
In regard to lime kilns, Deputy Gorry, who is a member of the Fianna Fáil Party and who is from the same parish as myself, knows that we have a fine lime kiln near the town of Mountmellick which is not in operation and is not producing any lime, although there is a large demand for lime in the district. It would be very wise of the Government to have some national scheme for the development of all lime kilns. The county committees of agriculture have not enough power, although I learn that in my own county the committee formulated a scheme for repairing kilns. The Minister should take up seriously the question of the repair of all kilns.
Deputy O'Donovan made a statement this morning in which he suggested that the women should go out on the land. Why have we let thousands of the best agricultural workers leave the country, and now that they are gone we want to get the women behind the ploughs and till the beet? The Deputy ought to be ashamed of himself, to expect women to work in the fields ploughing, when their place is at home. I know that the women have played a noble part in producing the food, and that there are women who work as hard as any man. I would not like to see this Government sponsor a system under which women would have to work the same as men. They could not be expected to do that. What is required is to put a stop to emigration immediately, even though it is too late now. Deputy Larkin made the only speech on agriculture that impressed me. We have seen the cream of Irish manhood being forced to emigrate and denied the right to live at home on their own land which was created by God for man's use and benefit. That is how they are being treated, not alone by the present Government but by the two native Governments. Deputy Dillon said yesterday that the Minister deserves all the criticism that he gets. I know the Minister deserves quite a lot of it, but we must remember that there is no use in talking about the past. The past is gone: what we want is a plan for the future. I could criticise the Minister for the next two hours, but it would not lead me anywhere. I am not concerned about what happened before I came into this House. I heard Deputy Cogan speak yesterday and also Deputy O'Donovan; and five years ago when sitting in the public gallery here, I heard the very same speeches. I hope the Minister will look on this question of agriculture very seriously as agriculture is the mother of the nation's wealth and all good comes from the land. Out of the land all our economic ills, including unemployment and emigration, can be solved.
The Agricultural Credit Corporation gives loans to farmers, but before doing so they try to find out the number of stock the farmer has and if he has any money in the bank which he could give as security. If the farmer had money in the bank and had the big stock that the Agricultural Credit Corporation requires, why should he be looking for a loan? There is no sense in asking farmers to pay such a high rate of interest when money can be produced at very low rates to be spent on the destruction of mankind and God's gifts to man.
Just before the war there was no money at all to satisfy the hunger of the thousands outside Hyde Park with labels on their breasts saying: "We want food" and "We want work". Where did the money come from in three weeks to finance the war? There is an important question which Deputies should think over: no money for peace, no finance to produce food, but plenty for war and the destruction of mankind. The farmers cannot produce unless they have money. I happened to interrupt Deputy Dillon yesterday and said that the farmers would have very little left if they paid their debts. I know that the farmer has very little from the time he puts his seed into the ground; he is watching and waiting until the crop is in the haggard to be threshed, and he is not satisfied until he gets his cheque and then it just comes in one door, passes the farmer's wife by and goes out the other door, and two or three months afterwards he is as poor as before. This happens year after year, and I think it should be completely changed. I would be very glad if the Minister would give consideration to the question of financing farmers—we all know that unless the farmers have capital they cannot produce—and the question of the high rate of interest they are paying at present.
In regard to the recent sugar strike, I have always favoured strikes and the men's demands for a just and rightful wage in accordance with the teachings of Pope Leo XIII. However, these men who went on strike in Mallow and other centres were getting £6, £7 and £8 per week, while there was nothing at all said about the poor agricultural labourer.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Deputy that that is a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce and not for the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
I am just coming to the point of the wages of the agricultural workers. They are of no great importance at all in the eyes of the Government, while these men on strike at Mallow are the men to be satisfied. They may have had grievances, but the men who handle the beet are the farmer and his agricultural labourers, and they are the men who should have received the real consideration, if any.
The Minister told us yesterday in the House that he had no control over the Agricultural Wages Board, but he appointed these people and, I presume, he can dismiss them. At least, I understood that that was what the Minister said, but is not the Minister responsible for establishing that body, and is it not true that he can put that body out of existence? Therefore, I take it that the Minister can compel them to pay an adequate rate of wages to the agricultural labourers. Why, therefore, does he not go to the board and tell them to pay adequate wages, and also tell them if they refuse to do so he will dismiss the board? The Minister should take the necessary steps to see the workers get adequate wages with the least possible delay, whether it be £3 per week or whatever may be decided upon.
I am sorry that I have delayed the House on this particular question, as I had not expected to speak on this matter, but there is one question on which I am very keen, and that is the question of the supply of machinery, and I hope that the Minister will tell us where that machinery went, and how he gave it out. Another question that was raised by Deputy Larkin was the question of credit facilities for farmers. I think that the farmers are the principal people that should be given such facilities, and I hope that the Minister will do all he can to facilitate the farmers in this respect.
Comment on this
Listening to the speeches that were delivered here during the past couple of days, I formed the opinion that this business of blaming the land and the Minister for Agriculture for the present critical position is not correct. I live in an area where tillage is fairly extensive in one part of the county and where, in other parts of the county, there is not so much tillage; but still, in a considerable part of the county—the northern part—there was very little tillage in former years, and the land there was all in pasture. I must say, however, that everywhere I go, through most parts of the country, I find that there are good farmers and bad farmers, whether it be a matter of those who have knowledge of tillage or not. You will find good farmers and bad farmers in every area, and it is my experience that, whether the weather is bad or good, the good farmer will manage to save his harvest and will have fairly good yields from his crops, and his corn will go to the mills or merchants in good condition.
It is also remarkable, in every part of the country, that where you find a bad farmer he is always late, and, no matter what spell of fine weather may occur, his corn will be in a bad condition. If you ask any of the mill-owners who travel through the country about this, they will tell you that certain farmers always send in their corn in good condition to the mills, but that there are certain other farmers who will always send in the corn in bad condition.
Now, that condition of affairs always prevailed, and I do not know what the Minister for Agriculture can do about that. Of course, I realise that, with the increased amount of tillage that is now demanded of us, it is hard on certain farmers who had no previous experience of tillage, or perhaps no wish for it, and who are only carrying out the tillage policy because they are compelled to do so, but in the case of the bad farmer I do not know what the Minister for Agriculture or what any Government Department or Government policy can do to make that man better. We have heard suggestions here about the setting up of advisory agricultural committees in different areas, to advise the farmers as to what they have to do when there are bad yields of wheat. Well, that is a very hard thing to advise about. I know of one farmer who, within the last few years, had a yield of 20 barrels of wheat to the acre, and each of these barrels bushelled about 20 stone. Such farmers as the man I have mentioned have been growing good wheat and getting good yields every year, but their neighbours suggest that their own land is not suitable for the growing of wheat. I hold that that is not the fault of the land but of the farmers themselves, because land in one part of a county or district cannot be so very much different from land in another part of the same county or district. If one yield differs from another on a farm, I hold that that is not so much the fault of the land as of the farmer concerned. You will have one good crop in one year and, perhaps, a bad crop in another year, but that is a matter for the farmer himself.
In my opinion, the greatest wastage occurs on the large farms that have been set or let to people who were not proper farmers originally, or to speculators who take large areas of land, plough it up, put in wheat, and then use tractors over a considerable amount of land, in order to take what corn or wheat they can get out of the land, without bothering about conserving the fertility of the soil.
Again, when it comes to the time of harvesting, even if the crop has been successful, that man has not sufficient labour to enable him to save it. I have known of cases where the yield was only four or five barrels of wheat to the acre, and possibly less; and then that land gets the reputation of not being suitable for wheat, but I hold that that is due, not to the land, but to the farmers themselves. Deputy Fagan said here last night that the land in Westmeath is not suitable for the growing of wheat or corn at all, and that the Government should provide a subsidy to enable them to grow potatoes on that land. I do not agree with that at all. I say that the land there is not getting the attention that it should get. It is just ploughed up, and then the corn is put in, and very probably the failure in that case is due to the fact that the seed-bed was not properly prepared. In the last few years, I have seen large areas of similar land, which were not producing good crops, and I attribute that to the want of proper ploughing and the preparing of a proper seed-bed, as well as neglecting the land after the crop was sown. Land for wheat wants to be rolled and made very firm. In that connection, we hear a lot of talk about tractors, ploughs, and so on, but there is one farm implement which is of very great importance, in addition to the binder, the tractor and the plough, and that is the roller. We should not have to import these rollers, because we can produce them here at home. We have plenty of cement in the country and I would suggest to the Minister that he should ask his Department to provide a sufficient number of heavy concrete rollers, distribute them in the areas where this fresh land is being broken up, and advise the land owners to use the roller at the proper time in April and May, when the crop requires that attention.
I agree with those speakers who suggested that the agricultural worker or the small farmer has not the standard of living to which he is entitled. I have heard it stated frequently that agriculture is our most important industry but I always maintain that the agricultural worker and the small-working farmer—they are both agricultural workers and their interests I suppose are identical— have not a sufficiently high standard of living. As a result these people are inclined to get away from the land.
I am afraid that the raising of agricultural wages will not solve the problem because I notice that, whenever the agricultural worker gets an increase of wages in this country, all other classes of workers immediately adduce that as an argument to increase their wages. No matter what increase you give the agricultural worker, if a proportionate advance is immediately given to industrial and other workers, the position of the agricultural worker is in no way improved.
Comment on this
They should be paid the same as other men but the fact of the matter is that immediately the agricultural worker receives an advance in wages, other workers demand a proportionate increase with the result that the standard of living of the agricultural worker is still much below that of other workers. As a result the agricultural worker is inclined to leave the land. I think that there should be more men permanently employed on the land. I do not know exactly how it could be done but some inducement should be held out to these workers to remain on the land because there is more work on the land than merely driving a tractor, ploughing, and waiting for the harvest to be reaped. There is plenty of other work at which greater numbers could be permanently employed. We hear a lot of talk about the necessity for artificial manures and the difficulties which confront farmers due to the shortage of artificial manures. I quite realise the advantage of artificial manures and the handicap imposed on farmers in not having an adequate supply of them, but the Minister or the Government cannot be blamed for that now. They are not there, and we have got to get on without them. Thirty years ago I remember we had no relief schemes, no doles, no unemployment assistance or unemployment benefit for anybody and, when the harvest was over, every man had to look out for himself. The working man considered himself very fortunate if he could secure employment with the land-owner at cleaning field drains during the winter months. This work was mostly carried out on a contract basis. That was the way the rural workers carried themselves through that difficult period in the past.
Through the farm improvement schemes it is impossible for the farmers to get back to that position of affairs again. If these schemes were availed of to a greater extent and if men could be induced to work on them—it is very difficult to get them now; they are not available—manure could be accumulated from these drains. The droppings of cattle have been accumulating in them for the last 50 years and if these were put into a compost heap, with a mixture of lime, there would be an accumulation of stuff which would contribute greatly to maintain the fertility of the land.
I think the farmers and the people of the country generally must be got to realise that if we are to produce enough food, to make the country safe for the people and for our animal population, they must work and that they must get down to it themselves. I think the majority of the farmers realise that. There is no man looking for an easy time and if we are to succeed, every one must work to his full capacity. I know the majority of the farmers are not as pessimistic or as depressed as the speeches here would lead one to believe. They are cheerful, hard working, resourceful people, at least in my constituency. They have come up against difficulties and surmounted them and I do not think there is any room to blame the Minister or to blame Government policy for any hardships that may have arisen. We hear a lot of talk to the effect that the Minister made mistakes in the past but if the agricultural policy in operation in this country, which it was very difficult to operate during the last ten years owing to the opposition, were not so advanced as it had been, at the outbreak of war, our position would be very much worse to-day.
Comment on this
At the outset, I feel bound to congratulate Deputy Larkin on his very excellent speech and on the manner in which he brought many important points before the House. I think he is an advocate of the nationalisation of land or collective farming but before adopting such a system in this country, I think it would be well to give the farmer as a private individual a trial, to give him the necessary financial help to enable him to produce food. Food production being a paramount necessity in time of war, it is impossible to exaggerate the importance of agriculture. Farming is the life blood of this part of Eire and surrounded by war, in war or out of war, the farmer is the backbone of this nation. That being so, it would be well, no matter what Government is in power, that the farmer should be assisted in such a way as to enable him to maintain production 100 per cent. In what way are we going to assist the farmer to increase production? That is a question which the House is entitled to put me and the answer I give is that there is only one way it can be done, the proper way. That is by encouragement, certainly not by compulsion, or red tape.
The House is entitled to know what can be suggested in the place of compulsion. There is only one alternative, and that is by offering the farmer a price for his produce commensurate with his labour. This is a very important matter and Deputy Larkin emphasised this point—the exploitation of the farm labourers. They are slaves in every sense of the word in this country. There is no other suitable word that could be applied to the farm labourers. If the Government are prepared to give the necessary finance to enable the farmers to produce food, they should take immediate steps to see that the farmers give a reasonable wage to their labourers so that those labourers will have an equal chance to purchase some of the comforts of life side by side with their brothers in the industrial sphere. How can you otherwise expect labourers to work long hours on the land, even on Sundays? Some farmers have no hesitation in demanding the employment of their workers on Sundays. I doubt if some of them would even give their workers the privilege of attending their religious duties, if they could possibly prevent them doing so. I mean the big farmers with 100, 200 and 1,000 acres of land—farmers who have no respect for the ordinary human being. Until the Government enforce such conditions as I have referred to. it is fruitless to be talking about increasing food production.
It may be argued that if the farmer is given the necessary finance and assistance, such as machinery and fertilisers and stable or bag manure or whatever is required, he will not respond without some compulsion. To prove my argument, let me compare last year's beet crop with this year's. The farmers got an increase in the price of beet and a little encouragement by being given a certain allowance of sugar. What was the result? You have an increase of 50.4 per cent. in the beet crop. Could not similar conditions be applied to wheat, potatoes, and all the other crops necessary to provide food for the people? What is the position of wheat? There is a decrease of 11.8 per cent. How are we placed with regard to potatoes? There is a decrease of 4.8 per cent., notwithstanding the fact that we had a shortage of potatoes last year. How do we stand with regard to turnips? There was a decrease of 3.8 per cent. How do we stand with regard to poultry? There is a decrease there, too.
In regard to those very important items affecting the agricultural industry there has been a decline because there was no assistance given. The whole crux of the position is the lack of finance. Take that very important industry, the pig industry. The pig population declined by 16.9 per cent., and sows by 15.8 per cent. Surely the Minister cannot pride himself on that? Is it any wonder that we have to criticise or that the farmers are dissatisfied? It is no wonder that Labour Deputies are annoyed. They represent Dublin and the great industrial towns outside Dublin and they are worried as to whether the workers will have an adequate amount of food during the winter and until the next season's crop comes in. According to the returns so far available, I think the position will be even worse than last year. Some people may argue that the bigger the farm the more food we will have, and they talk of modern machinery and modern mechanism. I hold that a farm that is too large for one man to work is not equal, from the point of view of production, to the farm that a man on his own is capable of working. Let me take as an example a holding of 30 acres of arable land. A man with his family would be quite capable of looking after that type of holding. On the other hand, the man with 500 or 1,000 acres has to employ labour and to bring in tractors and other necessary implements and the whole farm, in fact, becomes a machine.
As I travelled up from Mayo to Dublin I could see large areas of land and there were more flowers than blades of corn. I think it was Deputy Killilea who said that the big farmer does not take the same interest in land cultivation as the small farmer. That must be admitted. I think the bullock is still in the big farmer's brain and it cannot be knocked out of it. If there is one thing the Government deserve credit for it is their insistence on tillage, and that should be the position, whether in peace or in war, because it is absolutely essential in this country. Never mind what Deputy Dillon may say about its being all a cod and sheer lunacy. We must have tillage irrespective of what Deputies on that side of the House may say.
There are Deputies and others who tell us that wheat production is going to destroy the fertility of the soil. That is pure humbug. Men of that type would prefer to mount a pony in the morning after breakfast and ride around to see how many sheep and cattle they have rather than go out to see how the land is cultivated. Now they have to do that, because if they do not cultivate the land they will starve side by side with the workers.
If the Government would only give the necessary finance, I feel sure that the farmers will do their share. If the farmer fails in his duty, that farmer, no matter who he may be, should be deprived of the right of ownership no matter what his standard of life may be, he should be deprived of it if he does not carry out his duty to the State. If the Government give him the financial assistance he requires, and he is not prepared to do his duty, he should be penalised. There are Deputies on the opposite benches who think it well to laugh. They imagine they are clever, and they tell us they know all about farming. If one goes back to the speeches made here some years ago, one can readily realise what those Deputies tried to preach. The fact of the matter is that if the Government had listened to them then, we would not have much food in the country to-day; we would not have any grain to start the wheat crop when the war broke out. Deputy Dillon knows as well as I do the position of small farmers in that part of Mayo.
Comment on this
There is need for the division of a large farm in my constituency, as in that way more arable land would be available for cultivation with wheat, beet and corn. At present small farmers have to pay from £6 to £10 for suitable arable land. I ask the Minister how he could expect small farmers to increase production if they have to pay that price for suitable land. I wrote to the Minister for Lands on several occasions concerning the division of land in Mayo, and I received the usual reply, that such work could not take place during the emergency. Yet the country needs food. I think it was Deputy O'Donovan who referred to the question of getting women to work on the land. Does the Deputy want the women to undertake slave work similar to that performed by agricultural labourers? My advice to the women is to keep away from such work.
Comment on this
Thousands of women have to emigrate owing to economic necessity. No Deputy should have the audacity to suggest that women should be asked to undertake agricultural production. Anyone who makes such a suggestion should be ashamed of doing so while thousands of men are idle. Those who are emigrating should be kept at home and should be given a reasonable living wage, in accordance with the cost-of-living figures. We would then have everything we need, not only for human consumption but for animal consumption. I notice that there has been an allocation of £1,400 in the area I represent under the farm improvement scheme. As there are thousands of acres of land to be reclaimed that amount should be increased, and the Government should make blasting powder available for the removal of rocks. The day is gone when farmers are prepared to use spades on reclamation work. The Government deserve praise for introducing the farm improvement scheme, and I ask the Minister to make it permanent, so that it would continue after the emergency. I know farms of five or six acres that have been enlarged to 11 or 12 acres by being improved, and that are now producing potatoes, corn and beet. When enforcing the compulsory tillage Order I wonder if the Minister could see his way to have wheat grown in counties where the land and the climate are suitable, and where there is greater degree of sunshine than in the West. On the Atlantic seaboard there is much rain. The land there is not suitable for wheat, but is suitable for corn and potatoes.
Comment on this
No. I am not suggesting that those who have suitable land should not be forced to grow the crop. If they refuse to do so no penalty would be too severe. While we can all find fault with the Government, perhaps if we were in the Minister's position we would make greater blunders. Perhaps if Deputy Dillon were in the Minister's position he would make greater blunders. The Government and the Minister may deserve some criticism for their policy.
I remind the Minister that farmers are not satisfied with the way things have been handled. The pig industry is a very important one. Farmers feel that some assistance should be given to them to secure an increased number of sows. Many farmers had to get rid of sows owing to lack of feeding-stuffs. Now that certain restrictions have been removed, and that the price of pigs has increased, farmers would be prepared to make sacrifices if they got assistance to secure sows at say half or quarter their value. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney referred to a disease that has appeared in corn in Mayo. The Minister should take immediate steps to provide a remedy. I think there will be a shortage of seed oats because a good deal of corn was destroyed by bad weather. That was not due to failure on the part of the farmers to do their work. They are an industrious class and they depend very much on tillage, but weather conditions were against them. As the Minister is aware, small tenant farmers are poor, and he might be able to make some arrangement with the county committee of agriculture whereby seed wheat would be provided for them. Farmers who want to avail of such a scheme should be able to get suitable seed. The corn is not fit for anything but crushing up and giving to pigs or cattle. It is not fit for seeds or oatmeal. The weather kept it down to the ground for weeks. We expect that the Minister will do his best for the farmers.
Comment on this
I am not an agricultural worker, but I have been in touch with matters connected with agriculture as a flour-mill worker, coming. from the constituency the Minister represents. We have heard a lot from the farmers on all sides of the House. I should like to learn from the Minister why we, in rural areas and provincial towns, have to pay 3/10 for flour while in the cities of Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Waterford and in Dun Laoghaire the price is only 3/6 per stone.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister in the County Hall, Wexford, some months ago about stuff lying in the flour mills. We have heard a great deal about pig feeding. I told him of thousands of cwts, of offals from the flour mills which were waiting for a licence. They included meat meal. Before the general election, there were being put through a machine 2,000 cwts. of pig fattening meat belonging to the Waterford City Mill so as to send back the bags because there was a charge of 5/- a bag on them. Taking 10 per cent. of the pollard from the flour, this would mean one cwt. per hour for the 24 hours and, if that were given to the flour millers, we should not have Deputies saying that whole wheat was being fed to pigs. The Minister should consider these matters. In a certain place in County Wexford, a licence was given to a "co-op" while people in the industry for 30 years were denied a licence. I cannot understand why we, in provincial towns and rural areas, should have to pay more for our flour than is paid in the cities, while the wages are higher in the city mills. I live in one of the best agricultural counties in Ireland—Wexford. As representing the working classes, I can tell the farmers that there are many agricultural labourers at my house on Saturday night and Sunday inquiring for the address of the wages inspector. The agricultural workers are not getting the specified wages and some of them are afraid to complain lest they be victimised. It is all very well for the Minister to fix wages, but how many farm labourers are getting the wages? I should like to see machinery put into operation whereby farm workers would be assured of receiving their 36/- a week.
We have heard a good deal about tractors. Perhaps the people who talk about tractors would go to the villages and country areas and see the houses without light because of the paraffin oil which is given to tractors. Let the farmers get back to the horses and they will get better prices for their oats. The people who are growing oats are bringing in tractors to do away with labour. There are plenty of horses and ploughmen available. Agricultural workers are going to the home assistance officers and are being deprived of the dole during certain periods. I have called to the relieving officer on behalf of some people so as to get them a docket for a miserable 8/6 a week. The best of agricultural labourers cannot get a job because the farmers will not pay the minimum rate of wages.
Were it not for their trade unions, the industrial workers would not get paid the recognised rate of wages either. The agricultural wage is fixed by the Department but it is not carried out in practice. I do not say that all farmers are at fault or that they are all in a position to pay. Some small farmers are, like workmen, merely struggling, but others who could do so are not paying the appropriate rate of wages. A man who is living in his employer's house and who has five or six children is afraid to demand the proper rate of wages. His employer would, probably, tell him to get out and he would get no other job in the district because the farmers would think they would have to pay him the regulated rate of wages.
The Minister is a county man of my own and he knows as well as I do that many of the farmers are not paying the minimum rate of wages. Seeing that the farmers had a guaranteed price of 50/- for their wheat this year and will receive 55/- next year, I think the Minister should secure that the farm workers receive a harvest bonus. There will be great discontent if the farmer receives 55/- for his wheat and the labourer's wages remain unaltered. We have in Enniscorthy a factory opened by the Minister. What has happened there? The men are on a three-day week while pigs are being carried on petrol-driven vehicles past the factory to other firms. The employees of Buttle's Barley-Fed Bacon Factory are on a three-day week, while pigs are being carried 14 miles to another factory. I ask the Minister to give consideration to the position of the workers in our towns and rural areas and not leave them completely unprotected. Since I entered the House in July last I have heard Deputies speak about the price of oatmeal. We cannot afford, on our present wages, to buy oatmeal at 4/- a stone.
Comment on this
Some Deputy suggested that we should give porridge to our children, but how are we to do it when oatmeal is at that price? In my area on a Thursday or a Friday you will see some of the finest men in Ireland lined up waiting to get a miserable 14/- a week from the home assistance officer. How can they keep a family on that, and out of it pay a rent of 4/- a week to the urban council, or, if they are living in the country, a rent of 2/6. Thousands of workers have been appealing to me to get them passports to go to the other side. I have been to the offices in Merrion Square on several occasions, but, because they are agricultural workers, the passports will not be issued to them. In spite of what we hear about the seas, we have been getting into the flour mills of this country Manitoba wheat during the war.
Comment on this
On the question of milk, the people in the rural areas who are on home assistance, cannot get milk because it does not come from a registered dairy. The farmers grew the beet last year because they were given four stone of sugar. I say to the Minister, give a 10 per cent. reduction in flour and you will get more wheat. Why should the farming community be favoured with four stone of sugar because they grew beet? I think that if they were given white flour they would grow more wheat. There is a lot of talk to-day about the emergency. As a representative of the workers in the County Wexford, I can say that they are in the emergency all right as regards the difficulty they have in securing the necessaries of life. The people I represent are starving. Because there is no control, the shopkeepers and traders are reaping the benefits of prevailing prices at the expense of the working class people. I appeal to the Minister, who is a County Wexford man, to see that those living in the rural areas and in provincial towns are put in a position to get flour as cheaply as those living in the big cities where wages are higher than they are in the country. Six months ago I asked him to do that in the County Hall in Wexford. I hope he will see his way to give effect to the suggestions I have made to him.
Comment on this
I have listened with great interest to this debate. I think it may very well be described as a debate of conversions, because I think I have never heard of so many conversions to the Fianna Fáil policy since I entered the House. Even Deputy Dillon has become a partial convert. Deputy O'Donovan told us that we should have had compulsory wheat-growing for years past, while Deputy Cafferky told the Minister that if he was in his job he would probably make more mistakes himself. I welcome these overtures. I think it is a very good sign for the farming community that Deputy O'Donovan should now realise that wheat can be grown here. We remember when the Deputy and his Party sat in solemn conclave and decided to oust wheat with bell, book and candle, saying that it was impossible to grow it here. Now the Deputy has seen the light, and agrees that wheat-growing will be an essential part of modern agricultural production here.
I also welcome the increased tillage Order. The Minister might have gone a bit further, because I think the wheat acreage should be increased progressively in accordance with the size of a farm. I do not say that for the reasons given by my colleague Deputy Beegan of Galway. There is something in the point that perhaps the land in Mayo and in the west may not be able to produce as much as the land in other areas. It is absurd, however, to suggest that we are only able to produce two barrels to the acre. About seven years ago, in Mayo, various tests on demonstration plots were carried out under the auspices of the county committee of agriculture. Speaking from memory, the lowest yield we got was 14 cwts. to the acre, whereas on my own farm I got over 20 cwts. per acre. I still think, of course, that there are certain parts of the country more suitable for wheat production than our land in the west. I am of opinion that the Minister should go a bit further and make the people in the midlands and in the south, who have excellent land, produce more wheat and, if necessary, more of other crops. As far as wheat growing is concerned I would be inclined to increase progressively the production of wheat in accordance with the size of the farm. There is another matter that the Minister may not have taken into consideration, and it is the question of the rotation of crops. The small farmer has much less room to rotate his crops and plan for succeeding years than the large farmer has.
Production in agriculture has been increased progressively over the last 150 years all over Europe as well as here. When I hear people here talk about the flight from the land they seem to me to fail to take into consideration the fact that one man in agricultural production to-day can, with modern machinery and modern methods, produce as much as 20 men could 50 years ago. I think our people are inclined to lose sight of that fact. It has been proved that there has been a progressive decline in the rural population of the whole of Europe over the last 150 years.
On that basis, I think it is absurd for our people to expect that, so far as agricultural production is concerned, one man will be able to keep nine or ten children on a farm of £5 valuation and keep them in comfort. I think we should realise that a minimum standard for our people, so far as the amount of land they have is concerned, is necessary to keep themselves and their families in comfort. On that point also I urge the Minister, particularly in relation to the postwar period, to endeavour to see that we have some machinery available so that we may increase agricultural production and be in a position to compete with any other country in Europe in the European market. We all know that one of the greatest difficulties our people suffer from is lack of machinery for increasing production. The other agricultural countries we have to compete with have much more machinery, even though some of them are about on a level with us in respect of small farms.
On the question of the large farm versus the small farm, I am a believer in the small farm. I believe that by having the land broken up and by having small farmers with economic holdings, you will achieve more agricultural production than you will through the large collective farm as advocated by Deputy Larkin and some other Deputies. I think there should be some way, particularly in the post-war period, whereby our farmers will have some means of getting machinery on hire or otherwise, and if the Minister made available through county committees of agriculture a certain amount of agricultural machinery which could be hired out to the local farmers to help them to increase production and to maintain their crops, it would be a step in the right direction.
I listened to some Deputy advocating that we should give a bounty of 5/- on bonhams and another Deputy urging a subsidy of some kind or other on sows. No later than three weeks ago, I purchased a pair of bonhams in Castlebar market at £10 10s., and a fortnight ago I noticed that the prevailing price in the market in Ballyhaunis was £12 per pair. Where could you get a greater inducement to people to go into pig production and to produce bonhams than that price? I do not think the farming community in Mayo are short of cash, and I do not think it necessary to make any finance available for them.
I am convinced that if these are the prevailing prices, the farmer who is not prepared to produce young pigs does not know what he wants, because so long and so far as I know farming, it is as good a price as we ever got for young pigs, and I cannot see how any case can be made for a subsidy on bonhams and sows. The market is there. The chief difficulty is, and has been for quite a long period now, the scarcity of feeding stuffs for the pig population. The question of feeding stuffs for the pig population and for other animals clashed with that of providing foodstuffs for our people, and that is the sum total of the explanation of the reduction in the pig population. We simply had not got enough stuff, but with the prices going now, I think the pig population will increase. I do not believe, however, that it will increase to a very great extent until our people produce more.
The Pigs Marketing Board has come in for quite a lot of criticism. There are a number of things about the board with which I never agreed, but I ask the Minister to keep in existence some nucleus of an organisation on the lines of that board for our people after the war, because if we are to go into competition with other people after the war, we must have something in the nature of that board. Post-war planning is one of the most difficult tasks imaginable, and I do not think the Minister can plan post-war, except in relation to the home market, in the matter of agriculture.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it permissible for Deputies to put their feet on the benches in front of them?
Comment on this
So far as post-war planning is concerned, I would say that the home market is the only real thing we have to plan for. It is the only real thing the Minister or the House can plan for, because planning for post-war agriculture in the matter of exports will depend on what the rest of the world is going to do and on what quotas we may be able to get on any outside market, and if we have to do in the post-war period as the Danes had to do some years ago, that is, reduce their pig population by some millions inside one year, and at the same time produce a specific type of bacon popular on a certain market, we must have the machinery to do it. The only way in which we can have that machinery is by having something in the nature of the Pigs Marketing Board, so that the type of bacon for which there is a demand on any of these foreign markets will be produced.
In connection with this matter of post-war planning, the question of transport is an aspect which I urge the Minister to consider. It is one thing which we in this country can plan for, and when we look around and see the possibilities of other countries in relation to transport in the post-war period—transport which will play a vital part in agriculture and the marketing of agricultural produce—we must realise that it is a matter which should be borne well in mind. All the countries which were our competitors on the British and other markets before the war—possibly they do not like it, but the fact remains—have aerodromes all along their coasts. The air arm has been developed, from a military point of view perhaps, and these airfields will undoubtedly be used for the development of a modern air force for the transportation of fresh agricultural produce to the nearest markets after the war. The time of the air force has come, and it will possibly develop to a greater extent in the immediate post-war period than any of us can see now.
The Minister should bear in mind that if we have to compete on foreign markets with whatever exportable surplus of any article we may have, and if we want to get that produce to the market in fresh condition in a very short time, we shall have to make some arrangements here in order to be in a position to jump into that market. Unless some steps are taken now, or in the very near future, towards the acquiring of certain airports in this country, it may well be impossible to get them after the war, because throughout the country the acquisition of land is going on at the moment and the Minister should take steps to see that, where there are airports in the country, they will be preserved and will be ready for use when we go into this modern market that I think will develop. I think there should be a centre in Connacht, a centre in the south and a centre in the north from which the total production of that particular section of the country could be distributed so that, in the post-war days of rapid transport and increased efficiency, we will be able to compete with the countries that, of necessity, during this war, have ready-made airports which can be converted into stations for the transportation of agricultural produce.
Comment on this
I had the Deputy's foreign market in mind. I have no doubt the Deputy will be there to receive us when the war is over.
Comment on this
Of course, in view of the stand the Deputy has taken in this business, the Deputy will be Minister for Foreign Affairs in England and may not allow our produce in. I have noticed this season in my constituency the seeds sprouting in the stocks. I believe there is grave danger so far as seed is concerned for the coming season. I would, therefore, urge that the best means should be taken, even to make it compulsory, if necessary. to have seed wheat, particularly, tested for the coming season. Otherwise I believe there will be a big amount of seed that will not be fertile. That is due, of course, to the terrible weather we have had and the conditions under which the crops had to be taken. I believe there is great danger in that respect. It is a matter that the Minister's Department should bear in mind.
I have heard it urged here that in order to increase production the lands in the hands of the Land Commission should be taken over, and I understand that Deputy Dillon, as he usually does, attacked the policy and brought up all those points of fixity of tenure and the shame of interfering with the large farms in this country.
Comment on this
He attacked grabbers and emergency men, of whose descendants we have a plethora in this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy's attack does not go back to the confiscations. I wonder does the Deputy attack those who originally grabbed the land. At all events, it is my opinion that it would increase agricultural production if more of the arable land of the country were taken over and divided amongst the tenant farmers in this country. I have no doubt that those people who have studied the progress of the colonies that were migrated from congested districts to the midlands—studied it, not through the eyes of the Irish Times, but impartially—are surprised to see how agricultural production can be increased and how well these people who came from mountainous districts have done. I can understand Deputy Dillon's attitude in opposing the resumption of any lands for the relief of congestion. I can understand his attitude in mocking the idea of those people going in to these small farms. But I cannot understand people in the Farmers' Party making the point that is made in a document that I have before me setting out their election programme.
Comment on this
Party literature of the election campaign might well be left out of this discussion. The election should be taken as definitely ended.
Comment on this
Very good, Sir, and quite a good thing, too, but I do respectfully suggest that it has been stated here by a Deputy of the Farmers' Party that they want the land in the hands of the Land Commission and other lands taken over, and that I am entitled, with respect, to comment on that. I say that one of the points in the Farmer Party's programme is that we must have fixity of tenure.
Comment on this
Whether that point is sound or otherwise, as far as agricultural production is concerned, I do say it is absurd for the Farmers' Party, and for Deputy Cafferky in particular, coming from Mayo, to say that you must have fixity of tenure in order to increase agricultural production. I do say it is absurd for anybody to suggest on the one hand that you have to make the rancher so firm in his own ground that you are going to build a legal wall around him so that we cannot take his lands over and, on the other hand, that there must be fixity of tenure in order to increase agricultural production.
Comment on this
That is the Deputy's definition in his own printed programme. If the people of the West of Ireland are going to see an end to their being up to their eyes in the bog holes of £30 valuation, if they are ever to get out to the country from which the people that Deputy Dillon now praises banished them, if they are ever to get back to their own, the sooner the Farmers' Party or any progressive Party in this country wipes out fixity of tenure, the better.
Comment on this
There is no hope of increasing agricultural production by the migration of tenant farmers from the West unless we kill and bury fixity of tenure.
Comment on this
The question of fixity of tenure arises on the Land Commission Vote; only incidentally here.
Comment on this
As far as the division of land is concerned there was a comment made here by Deputy Cafferky. I am very glad that Deputy Cafferky has been converted to Fianna Fáil policy, and that all the things that were said about the "rotten Minister for Agriculture", and the "rotten farming policy" are now withdrawn. But, I do think that, before the Deputy mentioned the Brooklawn farm, he should have acquainted himself with the facts, because the Brooklawn farm has been actually taken over and there is actually a scheme in force for the division of that farm.
Comment on this
If the Deputy made inquiries before he referred to these things he would know what was happening.
Comment on this
As far as the question of financing farmers is concerned, I have not noticed any demand from the western farming community for finance. As a matter of fact, I would say here, as I have said elsewhere, that the farmer who, for the last few years has been producing crops and getting the current prices, does not need financing. There are very few farmers that I know in my constituency who to-day require any State assistance as far as pig production or any other agricultural production is concerned. I do not see any great suffering through lack of subsidies in these matters. The Deputy who urges subsidies should know that the first man to benefit by any subsidies is not the small farmer that he is thinking about or that we represent here, but the large farmer or rancher, and that the small farmer will pay. The Deputy should know that quite well. I say that any small farmer in my constituency who is worth his salt does not need any subsidy for the production of bonhams which, to-day, are selling from 10 guineas to £12 per pair. As representing a community of small farmers I would strongly oppose——
Comment on this
Mayo farmers who are worth their salt do not want State assistance for the production of bonhams or for sows at present prices. It may be that at a later stage we may have to consider whether we shall have to run farming as a subsidised industry or whether we should treat farmers as being in competition in ordinary business with the rest of the country. So far as farming is concerned, we all know that after the war the British will not pay £3 or £4 per acre for agricultural production. We all know that after the war other countries will not make the same sacrifice so far as payment to the farming community is concerned which they are prepared to make when they are up against it in time of war. We, in this House, will have to direct our energies to seeing that, in the post-war period, we shall have some type of planned agricultural production; that we shall endeavour to keep the maximum number of people on the land, at the same time remembering that the land will only support a certain number of people in comfort and that their standards of living will have to be reasonable standards. The Minister should have those things in view in considering the post-war agricultural policy.
I should, however, like to point out to the Minister that I am not at all satisfied that the inspectors who are dealing with the question of compulsory tillage are doing their job. I know that they have not been doing their job in my county. I know that in my county people are getting away with it and I believe that that is happening elsewhere also. I suggest that there should be somebody put in charge of these inspectors in each county who would see that these people do their job. Most of the tillage inspectors are drawn from the Land Commission and I would say: "Lord preserve us from the Congested Districts Board type of official who is out on this work at present." I say that he is still mildewed with the rust of the British Civil Service and that he is a bad type to have on the job. I would seriously suggest to the Minister that he should have some check on these people, that there should be some way by which the people of the country will see that their neighbours do the job as well as they do it themselves.
I know that that happened in Mayo, and it may be happening in other places. I know that in my constituency we are not getting that work done fairly. If you have one man getting away with it, he is a bad example to his neighbours who will say that he is getting away with it owing to lack of inspection or for other reasons. There should be somebody put over these people to whom conscientious farmers could go with a genuine complaint so that every man would be made to till in accordance with the amount of arable land he had.
Comment on this
After three days' debate I am afraid the miracle has not yet happened. I waited on Wednesday and Thursday and for the best part of to-day to hear what the Minister and the House would be told as to what the solution of our agricultural problems really was. I was hoping that we would get some solution. I listened with the greatest interest to the leader and the deputy-leader of Clann na Talmhan and to Deputy O'Mahony, Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Cafferky. With the claims that they made at the opening of their speeches and their criticisms of other speakers from both sides of the House, whom they did not regard either as being farmers or interested in farming, I expected that from them at any rate we would get some indication of a plan for agriculture, some indication of what ought to be done for agriculture or some indication at least of the lines they would suggest the Minister should work upon. What did we get from them? From one after the other of them we got nothing but the same demand. If it were not a subsidy for potatoes, it was a subsidy for something else. If it were not an increased price for beet it was an increased price for something else. It is the simplest thing in the world for anyone in this House, representing any section of the community, representing labourers or farmers or professional men or shopkeepers, to make a popular speech appealing to the mentality of the section whom he claims to represent by saying that they should be paid more for their work, that they should get more for what they are producing, or more for the professional work they do.
What particular solution did Deputy O'Donnell or anybody else offer? Deputy O'Donnell said he would not consider it worth his while growing beet unless he gets £5 per ton. There is nothing in the world to prevent the Government giving £5 or £10 per ton for beet. So far as the effect ultimately on the community is concerned, you might as well make it £20 or even £50 and get shut of it. Deputies on the opposite benches say that they sympathise with the agricultural labourers. They say that they stand side by side with them. Deputy O'Donnell said they played football and hurling together. How much would Deputy Cogan pass on, of his £10 an acre subsidy for potatoes, to his agricultural labourer? Would he give him half of it? How much would Deputy O'Donnell pass on, of the extra £1 per ton for beet? This thing has gone beyond a joke. The people on those benches know as well as I do, and as well as any other honest member in this House, that there is not a demand from the working farmers for one-tenth of the things that are asked for here.
The average farmer who is working hard is not thinking, like Deputy Cogan, in terms of £10 per acre subsidy for potatoes. He is doing his job and will do it, and the worst day's work done for him is to preach in this House the policy of despair. Anyone from any other part of the world who listened to the representations of Clann na Talmhan would say that no one but a lunatic would be a farmer in Ireland if they are being robbed, at that price for wheat and beet, and if they must get £10 an acre subsidy for potatoes and everything else. Those Deputies are preaching a policy of despair, by telling the farmers that, during the war or during the post-war periods, agriculture cannot be carried on unless everything from milk to beet, wheat and potatoes must be subsidised. That is the policy of the Party that claims solely to represent the farmers. Is it their policy that agriculture cannot carry on unless milk, bacon, potatoes, beet and wheat are subsidised? If that is their policy, the quicker the people know it the better.
Much as I dislike Dr. Ryan and his policy, I have yet to learn that, in his wildest days, he ever preached such a policy of arrant despair. Does anyone seriously believe for a moment that subsidies to agriculture, on the lines suggested by Deputy Cogan and others, would be of the slightest benefit to the people or to the farmers themselves? The Deputies on those benches are the first to grumble when there is any question of inflation or when the price of an article of wearing apparel goes up. We heard a lot about that yesterday. Do they ever imagine that, when that spiral of inflation starts—no matter whether it starts from agricultural produce or anywhere else—it will ultimately react on themselves?
Comment on this
I am not going around to say who my grandfather was, or whether he was 80 years of age. I am not interested in who played football and do not give a hoot whether the Tipperary farmers or the Cork farmers are the better, and it does not make the slightest difference here— though Deputy O'Donnell manfully admitted it—that though we may not be better farmers we are better hurlers. I listened to Deputy O'Donnell for 20 minutes. The only case he made was the case made by every other member of that Party who spoke, a case of despair, a case that food production would be increased out of all knowledge if the farmers were offered, say, £5 per ton for beet. Do they represent that as the mentality of the farmers? Do they honestly believe that the average working farmer is not doing his best to produce all he can? Do they honestly believe that there are so many farmers disloyal to their nationality and disloyal to the people? There are so many of them, apparently, that they are behind the ranks of the Farmers' Party. Are there so many that an increased price for any particular article will give an increased jump in production immediately? I doubt it very much, and I am quite satisfied that most of the members of this House doubt it as well. I doubt if there is any great number of farmers who are so lax in their duty to this State that they are not doing their best to give all the production possible and that they are looking for another sop every week on a different article in order to increase production.
The greatest slur that can be thrown on the agricultural community is that thrown from those benches by Deputy Cogan and others, that we will get more wheat and beet if the price is put up another bit. I am amazed that anyone who claims to represent any portion of the agricultural community would suggest that there are so many farmers not doing their duty that, if the price of any particular article were increased, the extra amount of production would make a big difference to our supplies at the moment. Deputy after Deputy has talked about the danger of starvation. Everyone admits that, in an emergency period such as this, there is always the danger of a tightening up that never would exist in normal times.
Deputy Donnellan, as reported in the Press, has said here that he warned the Minister that unless something was done the country was going to be short of many thousand tons of potatoes and that the situation would be worse than last year. Did he go to the trouble of listening to the figures given, as to the proportionate amount of potatoes produced here that goes for human consumption? Is it not perfectly obvious that, even if there were a greater drop than there happens to be at the particular moment, with any kind of proper arrangement for deliveries, the drop would not have the slightest effect on the supply of potatoes for human consumption? This year the exact statistical figures show that they are five times as many potatoes in tne country as are needed for human consumption. The Minister's job is to take good care that this year the potatoes will not be below in West Cork, where they are not wanted, but that they will be in Dublin, Cork, Wexford and other towns and cities where they are required. The Minister's job is, not to wait until the spring comes and potatoes are scarce, but to see that a survey is made to enable him to say, all through the season, that there are sufficient potatoes in such-and-such a district which can be sent to market in such-and-such a place.
What happened last year was due to a complete lack of planning and nothing else. There were large areas where you could give potatoes away for nothing, while people were short here in the City of Dublin. Those are horrible things to happen at any time and they are particularly bad during an emergency, as a panic may be caused, and the effect on the morale of the people is much worse then than in normal times. There is sufficient oatmeal and potatoes to supply our needs for the whole of the year and it is the Minister's duty to see that it is distributed to areas where it is needed. Deputy O'Leary mentioned that he could not get oatmeal at 4/- a stone. I do not think it has been at that price for a long time: 6/- is the price fixed for it. It is quite possible that it will be 10/-. The Minister took the ceiling off oats, and I have no doubt that the patriots who represent the farmers will, if the price of oats soars, switch next year from wheat to oats. They will come back to the Minister this time two years and say, "If you paid so much more for wheat, we would not have gone in for outs in 1944; it paid us better, and who can blame us?" Deputy O'Leary and the people he is speaking about, who are trying to live on 8/- a week home assistance, will probably be asked for 10/- for their oatmeal, rather than 6/-. It is not a question at all of the farmer getting a decent price for his produce. That is not the real kernel of the situation. No matter what Government may be in power in this country, nobody would object in the slightest to paying the farmer an adequate price for his produce, but there must be a limit to these things. In my business capacity, for instance, it would pay me if the farmers were to get £5 a ton for beet or £4 a barrel for wheat, or £4 a ton for oats, because the more the farmer would get, the more would come back to me, but there is one gap that everybody in this House, and even in this country, seems to overlook, and that is that when everybody looks for increased prices for produce and increased wages, something will have to be done to close the gap between the price given to the producer and that which is paid by the consumer.
I have heard a lot of talk here about the agricultural labourer, and I quite agree that he is a badly paid man, but may I point out this—and I am sure that quite a number of the farmer Deputies here will agree with me on this—that the agricultural labourer, possibly, is not the worst paid of the workers or labourers in this country?
Comment on this
I am only pointing out that there is another class of labourers who are in a much worse position than the agricultural labourers. Take, for instance, the case of people who are employed by local authorities, whose wages are fixed, and who are prevented by an Emergency Powers. Order from making an application for a cost-of-living bonus. Some of these people are only getting about 32/- a week. For instance, I think that I heard, in reply to a question asked by Deputy Spring yesterday, that some of the workers employed by the Kerry County Council were being paid at the rate of 5/4 a day. Now, many of these people may have to pay for a house. They may have to support a wife and a large family, but they have to exist on that wage, whereas the agricultural labourer may be housed free on the farm on which he is working, and also be in a position to get a ridge of potatoes, a quart or so of milk, or a bit of firewood, and so on, at a reasonable price.
Comment on this
I know that, of course, but I want to compare the position of the man who has a fixed wage—a wage which cannot be raised, as a result of the present Emergency Orders—and who has to pay all these increased prices for every kind of produce with that of the agricultural labourer.
Comment on this
He is not on the dole. He is an employee of the local authority, and everybody here in this House knows that. I am sure that Deputy O'Leary himself will have to admit that. In the case of county council workers, how are they to be paid?
Comment on this
Who opposed the proposition for an increase in wages for County Cork County Council labourers?
Comment on this
I shall give the Deputy an answer as to that. The Cork County Council last year passed a resolution, and, as far as I recollect, it was passed unanimously and supported by all Parties, suggesting an increase of, I think, 5/- a week for the road workers in the district, but they had no power to enforce that.
Comment on this
Yes, and, as I said, they did vote for it, and it was passed unanimously, but it was turned down with a bang by the Department of Local Government. I want the people who are making a poor mouth always, to realise the position of a man, with a wife and four or five children, who has to pay, perhaps, 6d. for a head of cabbage, 3/- a stone for potatoes, possibly, and several shillings for a couple of sods of turf, as compared with the agricultural labourer who, in addition to his wages and his housing accommodation, has also certain perquisites, in many cases, such as a ridge of potatoes, a supply of milk, vegetables, and so on.
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Leary would shut up for about five minutes, I might be able to develop my argument. Apparently, the Deputy has not yet wakened up to the fact that he was trying to make a case a short while ago and that he was not able to make it.
Comment on this
Perhaps I might be allowed to say that, so far as the Cork County Council was concerned, both the Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil members voted against an increase in wages.
Comment on this
All I want to point out is that that very mentality which, I am afraid, is the mentality into which even this Party is drifting, of opposing everything unless more money is going to be provided, will be disastrous for this country. If there is anything in this world which is going to make people opposed to applications for increases in wages or for increases in the prices of produce, it will be this business of people demanding 50/- now, and then, when they have got that 50/-, demanding £3 and, when they have got that, demanding £4 or £5. That is the sort of thing that the people concerned with local authorities have to deal with.
Mr. O'Leary rose.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary will have to cease interrupting. I have warned the Deputy twice already, and I will not do it again.
Comment on this
The point I wanted to make is that when you are relating the position of any particular person in the country at the moment to that of other sections of the community, it will have to be admitted by everybody that, outside of what one might term the upper middle classes, the general workers of this country, such as the small farmers the small shopkeepers in small country towns, and the workers in the cities, are far harder hit, as a result in the rise in the cost of living, than are the members of the agricultural community. Such people have not the same opportunity as the farm labourers of getting certain things, such as milk, potatoes, and so on, at a cheap rate, and I think that every Deputy in this House, representing every constituency in this country —whether he be a Labour Deputy or a Farmer Deputy, a Fine Gael Deputy or a Fianna Fáil Deputy—ought to look at these things from the national point of view, instead of looking for higher prices or higher wages, just because the people behind them are demanding higher prices or wages. I am quite satisfied that there are men in the Farmers' Party who, during this emergency, do not want to look for more than is absolutely necessary, and I am also quite sure that people on the Labour Benches, represented by such Deputies as Deputy O'Leary, do not want that either, but I suggest that if we are to go on with this kind of thing in this country, the result will be a war of class against class: one class looking for higher prices one day, and then demanding more on the next day, and then, when that demand is granted, asking for more. The result of all that kind of thing will be that the taxpayer will have to subsidise the production of these articles and the payment of higher prices and wages in order that such commodities can be sold to the consuming public at the prices which they can afford to pay for them. For instance, we are told that certain people want £5 a ton for beet. Now, I do not believe that there is an honest farmer in this country who is looking for £5 a ton for beet, and the first thing that these people would complain about would be the price of sugar. The people who are looking for £5 a ton for beet would complain about the corresponding increase in the price of sugar, and the next thing would be a demand for subsidising that article so that the ordinary consumers in the country would be able to pay for their sugar.
If we are to start this vicious circle of eternally asking for higher prices and higher wages, and for bonuses, bounties and so on, it means that we will be losing something that we had here before this country achieved its freedom, and that is that people in former times here were independent, were able to keep their heads high, and not beg from anybody; but if this nation is now to become a people —whether they be distributors, workers or farmers—who can only exist by being given subsidies, bounties or doles, during this emergency, then what can you expect from this country when the emergency is over?
What effort can you expect from the people who would be prepared to double production if they got a higher price, when there is no emergency? What will they do when the war is over? What help will they be to this country to get back into the markets of which we formerly had a big share? Will they be asking when the emergency is over for doles and for subsidies again? If they do, it will merely mean that the people of this country have been directed along a road which the people would never have travelled of their own accord. I am quite satisfied that 90 per cent. of the agricultural community are prepared to do their duty and that they are fairly satisfied—no one can be fully satisfied in this world—that they are not being badly treated at the moment. I do not believe that there is 1 per cent. who would look for £10 an acre subsidy for potatoes. Deputy Cogan in his speech referred to that matter and said that farmers in Great Britain and in Northern Ireland got £10 an acre subsidy and that they got a fixed price. He said a lot about agricultural labourers but he omitted one very significant fact worth mentioning. Did he tell the House what the minimum rate of agricultural wages was in Great Britain when he was looking for £10 an acre subsidy? Did be suggest that the minimum wage here should be £3, which I think is the lowest minimum regional figure in England? I asked Deputy Cogan if they got £10 an acre of a subsidy would they be prepared to pay the agricultural wage in operation in England at present?
Comment on this
I am very glad to get that admission. I hope if the Minister for Agriculture ever thinks of giving a subsidy of £10 an acre for potatoes that he will make it a condition that Deputy Cogan and the people he represents will carry out that undertaking and that what Deputy Cogan says now may be later used in evidence against him.
Comment on this
Deputy Cafferky said that the Government should take drastic action. I hold no brief for the Government, but every member of that Party, including Deputy Cafferky, said that the Government must take drastic action, that the country would starve if something were not done. His leader, Deputy Donnellan, said if something is not done we will be short of potatoes. Deputy Cafferky agreed that the farmers should be compelled to grow a certain acreage of wheat. Those Deputies remind me of the old lady who watched a squad of soldiers passing by and who remarked that every one of them was out of step except her Johnny. Every Deputy who favoured the compulsory growing of wheat said that his own constituency was not fit to grow wheat and that it should not be subjected to compulsion. Deputy Cafferky is very anxious to compel the people to grow wheat, but he thought that not alone Mayo, but the whole province of Connaught, should be exempt from that compulsion. A number of other Deputies who were very strong advocates of the compulsory growing of wheat think that the position of the country can only be safeguarded if other people are compelled to do something which their own constituents should not be compelled to do. That is typical of the mentality of Deputies opposite. "The country will be ruined if something is not done; the people will starve." What are they going to do? These are the people who came in here to tell us that we knew nothing about rural Ireland, that we had not the faintest conception of the problem of the people in rural Ireland or the faintest idea of how the people lived there. We want their leader, their deputy leader, Deputy O'Donnell, Deputy Cafferky and Deputy Mahony to tell us what they are going to do. So far they have merely said that something drastic must be done. I have been listening to this debate for three days, and I give you the answer that I would make to the points raised by these Deputies, that the less interference most of the farmers receive from people like you, who are putting silly notions into their heads, such as that they must get a subsidy of £10 an acre for potatoes, the better. Most of them do not want it and do not care a hoot about your ideas.
Deputy O'Donnell's speech was most interesting. With the exception of one other Deputy whose name I shall not mention, though most people can guess it, he was the most entertaining speaker we have had in this House for a long time. Very few Deputies commanded the attention of the House to the extent that he did. I do not want to criticise a new speaker unduly on one of his first speeches, but I say it was rather the manner of his speech than the substance that held the House. I do not make the claim that some people put forward, that I am the sole representative of the farmers. I know little or nothing at all about the subject, but I am waiting for the experts to tell me something about it. I have been here for three days and the experts have told me nothing. Listening to them an extraordinary thought flashed across my mind, that the people they criticised on the Labour Benches and on these benches, knew more about farming than I realised because whether their ideas or theories were right or wrong, the people who spoke from these benches and one or two Labour speakers said something at any rate. They did not just turn and say to the Government: "If you do not do something we shall all be destroyed." That is what the Clann is telling them. I imagined, after the bursts of oratory to which we were treated during the general election and from the attitude these people took up then, that now on the Agricultural Estimate, we would get from a body of people who claim to represent the agricultural industry, some plan, some solution for our ills. If our ills are as bad as they say they are, I imagined that they would have something to suggest to the Minister, that if they did not want to wipe out the Minister altogether, they would put him on the right road. As I say, after three days' debate we have got no suggestion from the Party as to the planning of our agricultural work during tlie emergency or in the post war period. We have got nothing from tlie Party except the suggestion of Deputy Cogan that a subsidy of £10 per acre should be paid.
Deputy Fagan in his speech mentioned that there were a number of prosecutions in Westmeath under the Noxious Weeds Act. There is one matter I want to bring to the Minister's notice in that connection. The greatest offender in that regard is the State itself and the people who should be prosecuted first of all are the county councils. They should be compelled to clean these weeds—ragwort, docks and thistles—from the sides of the road. There is very little use in a farmer cleaning his field if there is a ten-foot grass margin on each side of the road, on which weeds are allowed to flourish year after year. The county councils should be compelled, when they have men working on the roads, to clean these grass margins at the proper time. I am sure if the Minister suggested that to the county councils through the county committees of agriculture, it would be accepted as a very good idea and it could be done very simply.
Comment on this
I quite agree that these notices are sent out; they are in the post offices and are pasted on the dead walls. But the point is that you want to get people to observe them. The first thing to do is to give the people a good example, and the local authorities ought to be the first to clear away the weeds.
I wish to raise an important point with reference to prosecutions. Sooner or later the Minister for Agriculture will have to wake up to the facts. I know his Department have been and we dealing with the situation. I say that it is utterly ridiculous to prosecute the farmers who are selling their milk to the creameries because of a slight deficiency in butter fats. The farmers are being paid for what they sell to the creameries and it is ridiculous to have these people brought into the District Courts. They are prosecuted under the Food and Drugs Act for selling an article to the prejudice of the purchaser. One could suggest that the creameries were only paying for what they were getting in butter fats. Actually the position is that hundreds of farmers are being prosecuted every year for supplying a certain article to the creameries. They are charged with selling it to the prejudice of the purchaser whereas there is no prejudice to the purchaser because the creamery only pays for what it gets.
A shortage of foodstuffs has had quite an effect on milk production—I am sure that is pretty obvious—and I think the Minister ought to notify the local authorities, who are the people who appoint food and drugs inspectors, that prosecutions ought not to be instituted against farmers for deficiencies in butter fat when supplying milk to creameries as distinct from supplying it to other places unless there is a question of adulteration, adding water. It is ridiculous to bring these people to court. The justices generally dismiss the cases under the Probation of Offenders Act, but the farmers have to pay expenses, amounting perhaps to 15/- or 16/-. I think that during the emergency these prosecutions should be dropped.
Deputy Cogan is anxious to know my constructive policy. I could, answer that very easily by saying that if the man who claims that his business, his manner of livelihood is agriculture, has not produced any constructive policy, not one iota of constructive policy, surely he will not blame an innocent man like me who does not claim to know everything about agriculture or solely to represent the agricultural community and who is trying to earn his living in his own way. If Deputy Cogan were in my position, I doubt if he would be a very constructive professional man if his attitude to my business was the same as is his attitude towards farming. The Deputy's attitude would probably be that unless his fees were increased by 33? per cent. he would not work. That seems to be his policy. I do not believe that most of the workers would take up that attitude. I am quite satisfied that they would not.
The Deputy wants to know my constructive policy for farming. Is it not obvious that the farmers have their own constructive policy; that during the emergency they are doing everything they can, in spite of the attempts of Deputies on the Farmers' Benches to convince them that they are being robbed? Is it not obvious that in the post-war period the farmers, having some little reserve behind them, will be quite capable of taking into their own hands the management of agricultural affairs? All they will expect from the Government is to see that it will deal with other Governments on an equal footing so that the Irish farmers will be allowed to compete on equal terms in any market. You will not get a market by telling people that the Irish farmer is ruined and that he cannot produce anything unless he gets this, that or the other type of assistance.
Is it the policy of those people opposite to convince the Irish farmer that during the emergency, when prices are substantially higher, he is being robbed unless he gets these subsidies? What policy do they hope to offer the farmers in the post-war period when inflation has passed and when the seven seas will again be open, when the farmer will not have the same demands at the same price for his produce? How do they hope to convince the agricultural community, facing that situation, that they can carry on?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Donnell said something about pigs at 21/- a cwt. I do not want to criticise anyone unduly, but I will say that if everyone in this country, since pigs were 21/- a cwt., made the same type of speech as Deputy O'Donnell made last night, it would not add l/- to the price of the pig, but it might have wiped out the pig population altogether. The position is bad enough as it is. I do not agree with Deputy Harris that if we did not go into the wheat policy in 1932 this country would now be starving. Has anyone observed how quickly this country changed over to wheat production in the last war? It did not take 10 years to do that. People seem inclined to forget that.
The Minister has received a number of compliments. Everyone who spoke about pigs complimented him on wiping out the board and there were some interesting stories told, including one about a man who was able to buy yearling horses at a show and when he heard that the board was being abolished he declared that he would soon have to retire from racing. The Minister is possibly learning by his mistakes, and that is not a bad thing. I will give him this much credit, that he can change his mind as fast as any man I know. As regards sugar, when the first demand was made for four stones of sugar for the beet growers, the Minister said that he would not give it under any circumstances and that it would be a most unfair thing to do.
Comment on this
Then I wronged the Minister entirely. I assumed the Minister had changed his mind, but I now see it was the Government changed his mind.
Comment on this
I quite agree with Deputy Cogan about one thing and that is that he does not like the Minister's idea of having the new consultative council composed of the chairmen of the various county committees of agriculture. If the Minister had any sense he would not be bothered with a lot of them and I will tell him why. This will show how quickly some of these people can change their minds —almost as fast as the Minister has had his changed. The Minister will recollect that for ten years there was a county committee of agriculture in Cork. That committee met on Saturdays and every Sunday when one opened the Sunday Independent one could observe the headline: “Cork County Committee of Agriculture— Minister for Agriculture Attacked.” The attack might have reference to pigs, poultry, eggs or something of that sort. For ten years the members of the Cork County Committee, some of whom the Minister knows, were out for his blood and it seemed that if ever they got a hold of him they would practically lynch him. What happened? After a long time they succeeded in inducing the Minister to go down to Cork to discuss the agricultural problems of Cork County with the committee. What happened when he went there? They did not say a word to the decent man. They spent the whole day proposing votes of thanks to him. Will anyone tell me that that type of person is going to be a valuable member of a consultative council? I leave that to you.
Comment on this
I should like to impress on the Minister the importance of protecting the dairying industry when enforcing the compulsory tillage Order. The loss of one cow would be a loss not only to the owner but to the public health of the community. Apart from the effect on imports and exports there would be the loss of skim milk, which would go into the production of bacon, and farmyard manure, which is now very much needed to increase the fertility of the soil. It is the well-manured ground that produces the greatest quantity and the best quality crops. For these reasons when enforcing the new tillage Order, due consideration should be given to the importance of the dairying industry, because it is the bedrock of our agricultural economy. A question that affects farmers, and that has not been sufficiently stressed, is the importance of seed germination. From my experience as a farmer and a threshing machine owner, taking into consideration the very bad weather that prevailed during the harvest, the wheat crop generally was good. It was exceptionally good for milling purposes. I admit that during the threshing season I came across a few exceptionally bad lots, in haggards, that were not fit for milling. There was certainly a very great mixture of different varieties. As there is a danger that there may be a shortage of seed next season it would be well if the Minister took steps now to see that the different varieties are secured. Inspectors from the Department could control distribution if they went to the different merchants to see that every care was taken of the seed for next spring sowing. I suggest that the Minister and Deputies should advise farmers who are in a position to procure seeds to do so as early as possible as in that way valuable space would be available for stocks that could be held by the seedsmen and seed could be tested for its germinating qualities. The general opinion last year was that the germination was about 80 per cent. When we take into consideration that 700,000 acres of wheat are to be grown next year, the loss of, say, 100,000 barrels of wheat, owing to low germination, means that less food would be available. The Minister for Agriculture is not responsible for the weather or for the low germination of seed, and I suggest accordingly that inspectors should proceed immediately to see that proper precautions are taken by seedsmen.
I asked the Minister yesterday whether any seeds would be imported this season. If we could exchange a cargo of milling wheat with people across the Channel who have seeds with high germinating qualities, it would be an advantage. If two or three cargoes of such seeds could be secured, they should be allocated to certain areas. Land that has been growing crops for a number of years will not give as good return as manured land. If seed is imported it should be under the control of the agricultural instructor in whatever county it is own. A certain amount of damage is done to seed wheat, even under the best conditions, during the threshing season. It is a common practice for farmers to handle the crop just before it is ripe, to rush it into haggards, and to chase around the country to have it threshed. Under such conditions, when corn is rushed into haggards, the machines must be set to a certain position in order to extract the wheat from the straw, and a certain amount of damage results. It is better to hold over wheat in the straw for a period, as that increases the germination of the seed. If seed under the control of agricultural instructors is kept in haggards, an advance might be given to farmers to enable them to carry on until it is threshed. In that way seed of good germinating quality would be made available. Steps should be taken now to ensure that seed that stood a high germination test will be available for the coming season.
It was alleged by some speakers that the farm workers were slaves to the bigger farmers. I am a fairly big farmer myself, if a farm of 140 or 150 acres can be accounted big. I have always paid my labourers well, and treated them well. I sported with them when occasion arose, and I cannot see how the labourer is a slave to the big farmer. I admit that the labourer is badly paid. From all over the country there are words of praise for the farm labourer, but that is not sufficient compensation. As Deputy Norton said yesterday, the farm labourers stood in the front-line trenches. So did the farmers, and by their work, which did not exclude Sunday or holiday, they saved the food of the people. Rural workers should get some consideration. I did not hear any specific sum mentioned, but I think that their wages should be brought up to £2 5/-, plus a bonus. A bonus is, without doubt, a great encouragement to the rural worker. If the worker received decent wages, plus a bonus, there would be co-operation between farmers, workers and the Government, and I have no doubt that we, farmers, would produce the wheat necessary to save the nation, as we did before.
Comment on this
I wish to bring the House back to the days of our bread queues in the City of Dublin and, later, to our potato queues and, in a lesser degree, the queues looking for flake meal that could not be got. Those are three essentials so far as our people are concerned and, if there is a scarcity of any one of them, grave hardship is bound to be inflicted. There is a class of person in Dublin City who does not know the taste of meat from Sunday to Sunday. They live on bread and tea from week-end to week-end, unless potatoes are available very cheaply. Deputies can well imagine how well watered the allowance of tea they get must be. When that tea is taken with bread, without fats. Deputies can readily understand how there is a considerable outbreak of rickets and scabies in the city amongst the people suffering these deprivations. The medical authorities attest to that. I implore the Minister to make certain that there will be no scarcity of potatoes. It is true that there is rationing of butter. The people for whom I speak are not able to buy butter at the present price. At the sky-high price at which meat is to-day, they are not able to buy meat. I ask the Minister to recommend to his colleague that a plentiful supply of rice be made available.
Comment on this
When there was a scarcity of potatoes, it was fortunate that some business people had secured a substantial supply of rice. Rice was used for over a week at the penny-dinner service and at free dinners as a substitute for the potatoes which were not available. That is why I ask the Minister, in the event of a scarcity of potatoes, to see that his colleague will give shipping space to bring in rice.
Comment on this
The Deputy must confine his remarks to the administration of the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
I shall not deal further with that point. Flakemeal is scarce and dear. Bread is fairly plentiful but the fats necessary to the health of the people are not available. If the Minister can do anything in that direction, we shall be grateful. The reason I emphasise this point is that on the 12th March, 1941, the Minister was asked if he would have an intensive drive for the growing of potatoes. He said he would, that every possible step was being taken and would continue to be taken.
Since he made that promise and since there is a danger of scarcity now, it will do no harm to emphasise these points and ask him to see that there will be an intensive drive for the growing of potatoes, and that we shall not be in the unhappy position of seeing queues of from 100 to 300 persons for foodstuffs as we saw in Summerhill early this year. In March, we saw queues waiting for potatoes. When a sack or two arrived, the shopkeeper went down the queue and handed out three or four potatoes to each person. Then, he came back and started at the top again, until his supply was exhausted.
As I have said, there is a great scarcity of fats which has resulted in a serious outbreak of rickets in the city. We have read in the paper that barley is to find its way into our bread. I wonder if it would not be possible to ask another country to give us wheat in exchange for the barley which may go into other products and be exported. Britain gave us wheat before in exchange for the barley that went into Guinness's brewery. That helped to keep Guinness's men reasonably employed. If there was closer contact with the Food Controller in Britain and if our Minister met that gentleman more regularly—if he has met him at all—I think that some agreement would be arrived at for the exchange of certain types of foodstuffs and that that agreement might result in a better supply for ourselves. Dublin's poverty at present is very grave indeed. The price of all kinds of vegetables—cabbage, cauliflower, and potatoes—is beyond the means of a certain type of Dublin poor, living on doles, poor law relief and widows' pensions. The poor law authorities, with their eye on the larger interests, are not inclined to increase the relief which the poor receive in order to meet the rapid increase in the price of foodstuffs which they should be getting but are not getting.
There are families in Dublin City who never have meat for a meal. They have to live on bread and tea from week's end to week's end. The result is that the children are suffering from rickets, scabies and tuberculosis. I hope that unhappy condition of things will be removed, and also that we will have no more queues for potatoes and flake meal. Some Deputies made a reference to boots and the scarcity of leather for farm work. They properly made the claim that farm workers should be well clothed and shod. In the City of Dublin we have people living in conditions of extreme poverty and their children suffering from the diseases I have mentioned. In the slum areas you see children almost naked.
Comment on this
I simply want to put in the claim that, if they cannot get clothes or boots, it will be the duty of the Government to see that the children of the lowly-paid will be properly fed, and that a bigger effort will be made to secure for them their fair share of whatever is available. During the recent scarcity of potatoes we were told that transport was at fault. It was said that plenty of potatoes were available in the County of Kildare and in other parts of the country within 50 miles of Dublin. While that was so, you had people queueing up for potatoes. Many wondered why the Army lorries were not employed to a greater extent to bring potatoes to the City of Dublin so that there would be no week-end scarcity for the poor people. I am also told that there is a butter scarcity. Milk prices have gone sky-high, while meat at present prices is unpurchasable in the working class areas. Dripping is not available either. Ships are needed to bring in rice, but could not something be done to exchange barley for wheat with our neighbours across the water—it was done before—instead of putting it into the wheat? I hope earnestly that the Minister will see that the scarcities I have referred to will be averted in the future. If the parish councils were given more power than they have it might be possible for them to make more ample provision for the people in their areas, and thereby avoid any danger of a scarcity in supplies in the future.
Comment on this
Like the last speaker, I am naturally interested in the question of food supplies for this city. During the course of the debate disquieting remarks were made on the question of our wheat and potato supplies. It is known, of course, that the acreage under both crops has fallen. Added to that was the statement that harvest prospects, so far as wheat is concerned, and in a lesser degree potatoes, were not bright. Serious mention was made of what was likely to happen next year in regard to inferior wheat on the one hand and an inadequate supply of it on the other. The lot of the poor, as indicated by the last speaker, is at all times an unenviable one. I suggest that they should not be harassed further with anxiety, as a result of this debate over the past three days, which would lead them to think that bread and potato supplies are likely to fall short during the coming winter months.
I put it to the Minister that there is an urgent necessity for him to make a clear and definite statement, which will satiafy feeling outside this House, indicating that the supplies of these two foodstuffs will be adequate to meet the situation. If the potato supply is likely to fall short of requirements, I hope he will indicate the measures he proposes to take between now and April-May to see that there is a fair division of the available supply at a controlled price.
I do not like to exaggerate the position that occurred in this city in April-May this year, and that was repeated in August-September. I am sure the Minister does not want a repetition of it. It is because none of us want a repetition of it that I implore him to indicate now the steps that he is prepared to take over the coming few months. He will have to agree, I think, that the general opinion outside this House was that the Department responsible fell down on its job in April of last year. I remember that when the Dublin Corporation was discussing the question, the shortage came as a "bolt from the blue". We then had the unpleasant spectacle of potato queues over a prolonged period. I hope, with the Minister, that such a thing will not occur again. It can be avoided if he will now indicate the steps that he proposes to take.
I am not an agriculturist, nor would I presume to represent the views of that industry beyond what I know are the needs of the people so far as agriculture is concerned. It is a strange commentary that after more thah 20 years of the setting up of our own Parliament it should be necessary to carry on a debate over three days on the conditions that have been described by the various speakers. It certainly carries its own commentary. It is elementary, or it is not, that the soil of this country is capable of giving sufficient food to all our people. We are credibly informed that it is, and the extent, therefore, that it falls short of giving that necesary standard of life to our people I suggest is the measure of the failure of the national authorities for the past 20 years to avoid a position of that kind.
I suggest that the position of agriculture is closely related to the position in our cities and towns. In the ordinary way, up to about two years ago, a subject of this character would arouse merely academic interest, so far as our people in the cities are concerned; but we have had a very sharp reminder of the extent to which we are dependent on the farmer during the past two years.
We all regard agriculture as our primary industry, and I would say to our farmer friends that there would be no greater or more enthusiantic advocates of ensuring that the fanner gets a square deal than the people in this city and the large towns. We would also like to see that everybody associated with agriculture gets the fruits of his labour, and not the least of these is the farm labourer. The farm labourer has been the cinderella of the agricultural movement down the years, and, even now, when the Minister is quite rightly bringing into operation a compulsory tillage Order, the cry goes up: "What about the shortage of labour?" How can any sane man expect to have an abundant ,or sufficient supply of labour on a 36/- a week basis? He cannot have it.
Is there any Deputy who would be prepared to rear a family, even with the perquisites that are supposed to go to the farm labourer, on a basis of 36/- a week? Is it any wonder that the country has been denuded of thousands if its very best workers over the past 10 or 15 years? I have said that the two positions are closely inter-related, and when it is recognised that our workers in the cities and towns have a purchasing power placed in their hands, on the basis of production, and are in a position to buy the farmers' products, paying them a decent price for what they produce, then and not until then will agriculture be put on the footing on which we should all like to see it.
A question was put here yesterday by a member of the Government Party on what may appear to be a rather minor matter and the Minister responsible answered it in that rather cold and matter of fact way which has impressed me, since I came into the House as a new member, as indicating a complete absence in the entire Front Bench of sympathy with or understanding of the other members of the House. Although it may be outside the scope of the debate, I suggest that when members put down questions, they put them down with the real intent of getting useful information, and Ministers should not be satisfied to answer in the form which was usual in the House across the water in the old days, that the reply was in the affirmative or in the negative.
A Deputy yesterday put down a question regarding the Allotments Acquisition Act, 1934, in which he made the rather useful suggestion that there should be an extension of the facilities which were intended to be provided in that Act, an extension of the 1926 Act. There are certain restrictions in operation at the moment. The Act is confined to recipients of unemployment insurance and home assistance, and the idea was that it should be extended to people in receipt of national health insurance and old age pensions. To my mind, the extension might usefully cover people in receipt of small wages above the figure now allowed of £1 per week. The Minister in his reply indicated simply that it could not be done and that the Act was introduced in other circumstances. That was perfectly true. The Act, when introduced, was intended to create useful employment for people who were employable but who could not find employment in the ordinary employment market, to keep them fit, and, at the same time, serve the object of providing them with food.
That was the purpose of the 1926 Act, which was amended in 1934, but to-day the Minister is appealing, and quite properly appealing, for more food. I suggest that no irritating restrictions should be placed on the operation of a useful Act, an Act which has been appreciated by no fewer than 6,000 of our people in this city in the Allotment Holders' Association. This association, of which I am a member, has made a valuable contribution to the food supply of this city and I earnestly appeal to the Minister, because portion of the responsibility lies with him, as he has to give the final certificate when the application comes through from the Department of Local Government, to extend that Act, so far as it is possible to do so, to the classes I have indicated. I should like again to stress the urgent necessity of his giving a clear and definite statement on what the position of the bread and the potato supply in particular will be during the coming months in this city and in the other cities and large towns.
Comment on this
I do not intend to intrude unduly long on this debate, but there are a few matters in regard to the agricultural position to which it appears to me to be necessary to refer. Otherwise I would not intervene at this hour. Compulsory tillage has been accepted as a necessary condition, having regard to the circumstances prevailing. It has been generally approved from every side of the House. Its application is essential for the reason that, without compulsion, there is no question that we would not get the necessary amount of tillage and consequently the food supplies which the country requires. Whatever the reasons for that set of conditions may be, it is not necessary to go into them; but there is, to my mind, a danger that this rough-and-ready scheme of fixing a certain area of tillage, with the condition that a proportion of that area must contain wheat, may injure the purpose for which the Minister is putting that scheme into operation.
He has indicated in his Order that certain counties shall grow a certain area of wheat, and three different zones are set out. How the percentage was arrived at I do not know, but I do not assume that the Minister had at his disposal in making that arrangement anything like a detailed survey of the farms suitable for the growing of wheat. I had in mind my own constituency of Leitrim-Sligo, where the compulsory tillage Order affects comparatively few people. A very small percentage of the farmers in Leitrim-Sligo will till an extra acre as the result of the increased tillage regulations this year, for the reason that they always do it. Being small farmers, they always have had to till practically the amount that is made compulsory this year, which is a big increase on any year for which we have records. These people, accustomed to tillage, having of necessity to do it, have also taken a very keen interest in the possibility of including wheat in their crops within the last ten years and the general consensus of opinion there—which is borne out by the agricultural inspectors with whom I have spoken over those years—is that it is a mistake for farmers of this area to waste their land in growing wheat. Wheat is a useful crop where it succeeds but it is by no means successful as a generally grown crop in Leitrim and parts of Sligo. There are other counties to which the same thing applies—I know they have their own spokesmen—Donegal, many parts of Sligo, parts of Cavan and, I suppose, parts of Longford.
I think it is an entirely mistaken idea to include a crop which has been proved over a number of years to be an unsuitable crop to grow in the area. I would like the Minister, in consultation with his officials, particularly those resident in the constituency I am speaking for, to arrange that the increased area should be put under potatoes, which are an excellent crop in that part of the country, or rye, which is also suitable in many parts of the country. It is merely wasting good land to grow wheat where it has been found over a number of years that it cannot be grown successfully. It is wasting energy and results in the production of less food. I do not at all blame the Minister for the compulsorily increased tillage. I do not ask for the reduction by one point of the area he has defined, but I do say that in districts where it has been proved over a number of years that wheat is not a successful crop, crops that have proved successful in those areas should be substituted.
Under the farm improvement schemes very useful work has been done in these areas, but the operation of these schemes is sometimes not satisfactory, as the officials I have spoken to have borne out and as the farmers very well know, to their bitter sorrow. The reclamation scheme has been very favourably received in the country generally. The effects accruing from it are great and the keen interest taken by the small farmers generally in the scheme is, I think, abnormal. But, it is sad to find that the scheme is a failure in some cases because some other Department failed to do its duty or did not co-operate sufficiently to ensure that the best results were achieved. Drainage of fields is a very useful work but anybody, even the city man uninitiated in agriculture, will understand that, unless there is an outflow from the drain that is running through the field, the purpose of the drain is nullified. We come across many schemes where drains were made which were useless after the first year because the main drain into which the field drains flowed was not cleared. It may be a townland boundary drain or a drain operating over a number of townlands and it is not the duty of any one farmer to clear that main drain. Since these men cannot be got to do it and since the Government has given grants for the clearing or draining of particular fields, why not drain the main drain to provide an outflow? Results would then accrue.
The officials of the Department of Agriculture will say it is beyond their sphere, that it is a matter for the Board of Works. The Board of Works will examine the drain, but if there is not a certain number of unemployed registered in the area during the season it is not in their power to carry out the work. Consequently it is left undone. I would impress upon the Minister the necessity of taking the necessary powers to carry out the complete scheme of drainage, whether he is spending £1, 1s. or 1d. of public money, if he cannot co-operate with the Board of Works. The Board of Works is tied up in a watertight compartment. They can only spend money on this work if there is a certain number of unemployed registered in the area. This scheme is a great one, bringing into production comparatively great areas of land. Half a rood is a big extension to a small farmer who is industrious and prepared to work it. I appeal to the Minister to take such powers as will ensure the best results from the labour and money so expended, and not to allow the fact that Departments are in water-tight compartments to result in water-logged lands and wastage of labour and of money.
I have listened to the speeches of two Deputies from Dublin, Deputies Byrne and O'Sullivan. I heard their remarks about the scarcity of commodities in Dublin, and the price of vegetables and other things. I have been impressed by the prices marked on vegetables displayed in shop windows. If these prices were available to the farmers in my part of the country, however small their farms are, they could make a rich living, and I am sure they would devote their energies to the production of vegetables. I suppose there is many a snag between the growing of vegetables and the placing of them in the consumer's basket, but it might be worth while, in addition to the survey of the land of this country, for the Minister to consult other Ministers with a view to ensuring that in the marketing of essential food supplies less middlemen would be allowed to operate, that a more direct channel would be provided to bring goods from the producer to the consumer, which would result in cheaper goods to the consumer and larger profits to those engaged in production.
Comment on this
I wish to deal with this Estimate under various heads: land owners, wages, facilities granted to producers of food and manure. I also wish to discuss it in relation to the emergency powers. I would suggest that the best contribution to this debate was made by Deputy Dillon. Not alone was it the best contribution, but it was most encouraging to the Minister. The Deputy pointed to the Farmers' Benches and said to them that the only danger he could foresee was that the farmers were going to make too much money. He told them definitely that the farmers were doing well and that the only danger was that they were going to make too much money. These remarks of his will be recorded in the Official Report. I do not know if the Minister took particular notice of them. The Deputy may have made other statements in the Dáil, such as the one about the Galway hats, to which we may not have paid much attention. But on this occasion the statement made by Deputy Dillon from the Opposition benches as regards agriculture should be taken as a great encouragement to the Department of Agriculture. He said that the farmers were making money.
I represent the constituency of Co. Dublin, which surrounds the capital city of Ireland, with a population of half a million. The people of Dublin must be fed; food and milk must be produced for them and fuel also must be produced for them. At the moment Co. Dublin is the best tillage county in Ireland. There is a matter, however, which I want the Minister to consider very seriously and that is that a big number of farmers in Co. Dublin with very big farms running into thousands of acres have evaded the tillage regulations. When complaints were made that these people had not tilled their land to produce food for the people, the reply of the Department was that they had other land down the country which they were tilling. But this land was not as good as the rich land in Co. Dublin; in many cases it was only bog land. Yet, when they scattered seeds over that land, they were supposed to have complied with the tillage regulations. As I say, some of these people who own some of the rich land in North Co. Dublin, running into thousands of acres, are evading the tillage laws simply because they have other land in other parts of Ireland. They are tilling that land, which is not good land, so that they may not have to till the good land they have in Co. Dublin on which they are fattening cattle, because it suits them better. I ask the Minister to take particular notice of that and not to allow these people to evade the tillage regulations.
It is very essential, of course, that we should raise cattle, but why should these farmers, who have no interest in the people of the country, be allowed to evade the tillage regulations simply because they have other land in Offaly or Laoighis or some other part of the country which is not good for cattle and is very little good for tillage either? They just turn up that land and scatter seeds on it and in that way comply with the tillage regulations. The Minister when he gets a complaint about one of these people sends a reply that So-and-so has land somewhere else and that so far as he knows he has complied with the tillage regulations. That man does not want to interfere with the good land bordering on the City of Dublin on which he is fattening cattle. I appeal to the Minister to stop this evasion of the regulations by people who have land spread all over the country.
Speaking on behalf of the best tillage county in Ireland, as I have said, I would also ask the Minister to give some attention to the question of machinery. At the last election we had farmer candidates and Clann na Talmhan candidates in County Dublin, but none of them was returned. In fact, every one of them lost his deposit, because the farmers in County Dublin realised that this Government were doing their best in the interests of the farming community. This Government got the support of the farming community in County Dublin, and on the farming community and on the farm labourers in County Dublin rests the main responsibility for the feeding of the people in the City of Dublin, for providing them with vegetables, meat and milk. It is to the credit of this Government anyway that at the last election the majority of the votes of these people went to the Government. I heard one Clann na Talmhan Deputy speaking as to whom I can say that I have more land that he has, because he has none. Deputy Cafferky, who made a great case on behalf of the farmers, has not an acre of land.
We have heard criticism from the Labour Benches of the policy of the Government about tillage and the wages being paid. I know one member of the Labour Party who lives beside me, who has 50 or 60 acres and has not an acre in conacre, but all with grass and cattle, and who has not a man employed. He is living in a labourer's cottage. That is Deputy Tunney. The criticism from the Opposition, from Clann na Talmhan and the Labour Party and Independent Benches, is just made in order to have an opportunity to criticise the Government on this, that and the other.
I live in a county where there is intensive tillage and I wish to appeal to the Minister for Agriculture to cooperate with the Minister for Supplies and facilitate those farmers in County Dublin who want to carry out the tillage operations, who have 400 or 200 acres under corn and whose only worry is to get guarantees from the Department of Agriculture, in conjunction with the Department of Supplies, that they will get sufficient kerosene, not alone to put in the crops in the spring but to harvest them next year, and sufficient petrol to drive their crops of wheat, oats, barley and potatoes to the Dublin market. They will increase their tillage this year. I would ask the Minister to consider this matter in his reply and help those tillage farmers and the general farming community in County Dublin, who met this Government wholeheartedly when the emergency started and put land into tillage and complied in every way with the regulations of the Government. They have not been bargaining in connection with the price of wheat and increased wages.
The Labour Party sang dumb during the last week or ten days, because they knew the people were going to revolt and that the Party would be in a very bad state on account of the threat of the women and people of the country when the sugar cooks sat down. I have heard Deputy Liam Cosgrave referring to 36/- a week for labourers. It shows that he has very little knowledge of the agricultural wages paid to labourers in County Dublin. I would like to see the agritural labourer get more than he is getting. Does the Deputy know that the present rate of wages for threshing in Dublin is £1 or 22/6 a day? The minimum agricultural wage in County Dublin is 43/- a week.
I certainly would agree if it were possible, that the Minister should put farm labourers—whose work is very skilled—on a par with the builder's labourer. The farm labourer has a tough job, he loads at three or four in the morning, comes back in the evening and has to load up again for the market the following morning. We have heard a lot of sympathy here for the agricultural labourer, but the only Government that endeavoured to do anything for him was that of the Fianna Fáil Party. They set a minimum wage, not a maximum wage, but the Labour Party did nothing. There is nothing to prevent any farmer paying his labourer more than that wage, but he cannot pay less.
I heard Deputy O'Leary on the Labour Benches saying to-day that they had to bring the farmers to court in order to force the minimum wages prescribed by the Government. Then why all this sympathy from the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party? For years Fine Gael was in power and did nothing to help the agricultural labourer. They are trying to make political capital from the fact that a big number of people had to leave this country. There was only one alternative to that. Those workers could be kept here if Fine Gael and the Labour Party, by a majority in this House, could carry a resolution that we should declare war on some of the belligerents, and then you would have bombs dropping on the women and children.
Comment on this
It used to be "Hell or Connaught," now it is "Hell or England." The Deputy's Party and the Labour Party demonstrated that we are out for neutrality.
Comment on this
But it is no harm to stop the hypocrisy of those on the opposite benches. There has been some talk with reference to the Supplementary Estimate for the production of new potatoes. I think I heard Deputy O'Donovan state here that his area was the pioneer in that. In my constituency there is a little area called Rush, where the average land held by a farmer is not more than two acres. Some of them have a couple of roods, some an acre, some an acre and a half. They produce potatoes, and have produced them for years, for export. Deputy O'Donovan was surprised at the idea of £26 a ton being paid for early potatoes. I can tell him that £112 a ton is paid to Rush men for early potatoes. A shortage occurred in the City of Dublin last year and, as a result, it would be well that the Minister should take notice. No export of potatoes was allowed, and the Department decided to subsidise the production of early potatoes. They were put on the market at £16 a ton, subsidised to the extent of £9 a ton.
I wish some of those who are talking about agriculture would go down to Rush and see these little holdings, where they work hard to produce food for the people of the capital city. Let that be to their credit. We hear a considerable amount of talk about convoys to bring foodstuffs to Britain and other countries. Does this House realise that the first example of convoys we had in this country before the war was from Rush, when an effort was made to starve the people of Dublin? When an effort was made some years ago to get the people of the City and County of Dublin to undermine the authority of the present Government, and when we had something like a Blueshirt movement started, we had a farmers' strike, and the Rush farmers came into the City of Dublin in convoy. and when they came into the City of Dublin they were lined up. These small farmers did not come into the city singly; they came in in tens and twenties, with the only weapons they had. I do not know whether you would call them lethal weapons or not, but some of them carried pitchforks.
Comment on this
I am only making a case for the Rush farmers, but what I should like to have from the Minister is a guarantee that in the case of the sandy soil of Rush, Skerries, and that neighbourhood, some subsidy should be given to these farmers to encourage them to grow the same amount of early potatoes next year. At the moment, there appears to be a danger of a shortage of potatoes, and I think that the Department of Agriculture would be well advised to have more inspectors appointed with regard to taking a census of production.
Comment on this
Well, I was going to reply to that, but when it comes from a man who can turn out money through a machine, I suppose that that is all right. However, I think that the Government, through the Department of Agriculture, would be well advised to take account of the amount of potatoes in this country at the present time and where they are situated. There is no doubt—and Deputies of this House must realise it—that there has been a huge influx of visitors into this city since the war started, and I feel that there is going to be even a more tremendous influx of people into the city. Accordingly, I believe that some steps should be taken by the Government to safeguard the rights of the consuming public here. This city has been flooded, and particularly in holiday times, by people coming over from England, Scotland and Northern Ireland, and there is no doubt that these people come here, not alone for a holiday, but because they can get a good deal of food here which they cannot get at home. The result is that hotels, restaurants, and even fish-and-chip shops in Dublin have been laying in big supplies of potatoes, with which to supply these visitors, which means that our own people are left short. Now, what is going to happen as a result of all this? According to what I hear, what may happen is that there may be a shortage of potatoes here, and I think that the Minister should take steps at the present time to control the potato supply, so as to ensure that, next spring, there will be enough potatoes with which to supply our own people, at the very least. That, perhaps, does not affect the people in the City of Dublin so much as those in the adjoining areas, because I think there are about 150,000 people in the county who would be affected by this.
Comment on this
Well, whatever about that, I think it is necessary for the Minister or his Department to take control of the potato supply at the present time: to find out what amount of potatoes we have on hands, and to see that nobody will be without potatoes next year. I think it is necessary for the Minister and his Department to see that the whole supply of potatoes should not be allowed to be bought up by restaurants, hotels, fish-and-chip shops, and so on, before February and March of next year, with a view to making sure that there will be an equitable distribution and a regular supply of potatoes for the ordinary middle-class and working-class people of the city.
I should like to make a point with regard to this question of tillage, and particularly with regard to the County Dublin. I am speaking particularly on behalf of farmers, who have not 20 acres under tillage. There are some farmers who have 300 or 400 acres under tillage, and who are given certain facilities in the matter of oil, and so on, but I hold that these other people should have the same guarantee from the Minister that they will be supplied with sufficient Diesel oil, petrol and so on, to enable them to harvest their crops and bring the crops to the Dublin market. I realise that that is a very big question. One of the biggest questions last year, for instance, was that of providing binder twine, and it seems that the Department got over that very well, but there has been a considerable amount of feeling with regard to the supply of kerosene, Diesel oil, petrol, and so on, and also with regard to the matter of machinery. I understand that during the past 12 months a number of tractors as well as binders and reapers were imported here, and that the Minister allocated these at cost price to various farmers—to four individuals in each county. I am speaking subject to correction here, but I understand that there were something around 100 tractors available, and I should like to impress on the Minister that, no matter what negotiations may take place in that regard, the important thing to produce in this country is bread, butter and potatoes, for the feeding of the people of this country, and that, therefore, any imports of agricultural machinery should be free of duty, and that when it comes to a question of allocating that machinery to the farmers, whether they be small or big farmers, it should be allocated to farmers who will utilise that machinery to till all the land available and to reap and harvest the crops.
Comment on this
I am interested only in the farmer who is anxious in spite of all the present difficulties to do his utmost to meet the requirements of the country, and to produce food for the people. I am anxious to give him all the encouragement that is possible. I, therefore, want to appeal to the Minister that such people should be given a preference in allocating this machinery. I think that Deputy Dillon should be helpful in this matter. I give him the credit that the best speech made in the House in this debate, the best speech to encourage the Minister, was made by Deputy Dillon but I look back on other years listening to Deputy Dillon, as I had to, when he spoke about wheat being all "cod". I think it might have been in his own interest and he might have got more votes in Monaghan if he remained out of the House on these occasions. Although this is a debate on agriculture, I might also remind him of the time that he referred to the Galway hats, another bogey of his.
Comment on this
The Deputy is forgetting about the hats and the wheat. I would repeat to the Minister to make an effort to control supplies of agricultural produce as far as the City and County of Dublin are concerned. Of course, I know the Labour Party will kick up a terrible hullabaloo if queueing has to take place.
Comment on this
What about queueing up to pay a tanner for admission to the Workers' Union of Ireland? The Deputy should not make these remarks and he will not get these retorts. Deputy Larkin and myself will always be friends, but if the Deputy makes these remarks I am entitled to reply in kind. I am trying to put before the Minister the needs of my constituency as regards agricultural machinery. It is the best constituency in Ireland so far as food production is concerned. If the Minister, in conjunction with the Minister for Supplies, can guarantee petrol and kerosene for the agricultural machinery in County Dublin, we shall produce the food. The farmers in County Dublin are as loyal and as patriotic to-day as they were in the days of old and they will do everything in their power to feed the people of the city. I would appeal to the Minister to take immediate steps to control potato supplies. It is very essential that that should be done. I listened to the Leader of the Labour Party talking about famine and queues for potatoes and bread. He forgot all about the slogan he had during the last election, that everyone should receive £3 a week. That did not work and I am sure he realises now that it was only a bogey. In the course of the next few weeks we shall have a Bill dealing with family allowances and we shall be told that the allowances are not sufficient.
Comment on this
I am sure, nevertheless, it will be a very popular Bill. In conclusion, I want to make one other appeal to the Minister in connection with the provision of manures and fertilisers. In County Dublin, we have a very big coastline and there is some very valuable manure in the form of seaweed to be found all along that coastline. I would suggest to the Minister that he should consider making an emergency powers Order to enable farmers along or near the seaboard to draw seaweed for use as manure. They have been prevented from doing so. You have a gentleman in Malahide who is known as Admiral of the Seas round Malahide, Lord Talbot. You have another gentleman in Skerries called Lord Holmpatrick, who is Admiral of the Seas round Skerries.
Comment on this
I do not know their real names and I am not interested in their real names. All I am interested in is the fact that these fellows should not be allowed to prevent farmers getting seaweed to manure their land. The Deputy can have his little bit of fun later. I do not know their real names.
Comment on this
I do not know whether they are Jews. I do not think they are but even if they were Jews, are you surprised at my making this effort ?
Comment on this
I suggest to the Minister that he should make an order enabling farmers in that area to draw seaweed to be used as manure. There are certain rights of way over different shores and there are certain laws which prevent people taking seaweed or sand. I think the Minister for Agriculture should consider the matter and make an emergency powers Order which would enable these farmers along the seaboard or living within five or six miles of it to draw seaweed. Before sitting down, I should like to say that as far as I am concerned I do not agree with the speaker who suggested that there should not be fixity of tenure. I say there should be fixity of tenure for all the farmers of Ireland.
Comment on this
I think fixity of tenure is essential for every farmer. If he utilises his land properly he is entitled to fixity of tenure.
Comment on this
I cannot allow the Deputy to proceed further in that matter. It is sufficient to get bogged in the seaweed.
Comment on this
I think I have already made a sufficient impression in the matters with which I have dealt.
Comment on this
I am sure that the Labour Party intend to support the Government in granting this bonus. After all, they cannot carry on without money—that is the first essential. Listening to the debates, there is one conclusion I have arrived at. I will, as a matter of fact, congratulate the proposer of the amendment in as much as it has brought from every side of the House general agreement on one question and that is that the farm labourers of this country are practically starving. If the amendment did not bring forward anything more than that, it has done a lot of good. Every Deputy who spoke this evening has agreed that the farm labourers of this nation have not an adequate wage. There have been disagreements on other points, but on this matter there is no disagreement and the first thing the Minister should do is to see that the unanimous wish of the House is fulfilled and that the farm labourer is raised to a standard above his present standard, which is practically at starvation level.
Comment on this
I did, and every act I have done since I came to the use of reason, I stand over. I never did a thing that I could be ashamed of. I heard the previous Deputy say that I am the owner of land in County Dublin. I have not as much land in County Dublin as would make my grave. At the age of 16 years I took part in the Land War in County Mayo and I was arrested by people with whom Deputy Fogarty was closely associated. From that day I have been an advocate of the policy which holds that the land of Ireland should be for the people of Ireland.
Comment on this
I have not as many as would go into your "bookie" shop. The Deputy stated that there is no hunger among the farm labourers. I have here a letter which I received this morning. It is from an agricultural labourer, man who worked during the year in County Dublin.
Comment on this
The Minister has stated that he is not responsible for the Agricultural Wages Board.
Comment on this
It was stated by the last speaker that there are no people hungry in County Dublin, people engaged in agriculture. I can cite the case of a County Dublin family, where the breadwinner was engaged in agriculture. They can get no assistance from any source. This is a case in which the humane society is interested. The family is composed of the husband, the wife, and five children, and they live in 69 Ballinteer Cottages, Dundrum. Anyone who may be interested in this case will find those people there. The humane society is trying to do something for them. Is there not hunger in County Dublin? This letter is dated 20th October. I have another letter from a man living at Santry, and the position is practically the same. In this case the man cannot find employment, and he is trying to leave the country, but he has not enough money to take him out of it. This particular farm labourer finished his work a couple of months ago, and he has nothing to live on now. He and his family are starving. I will take Deputy Fogarty to places in County Dublin where the people are starving. I will take him to 69 Ballinteer Cottages, Dundrum, to Michael Byrne—that is the man's name.
It is generally agreed that the farm labourer should have an adequate wage. I do not make an apology to anyone for suggesting that anything less than £3 a week is not a living wage. It is a miracle how families of six and seven exist on less than £3 a week. We have been told by one of the Farmer Deputies that a pair of boots costs £3 10s. 0d. How can a farm labourer ever save that amount? The farm labourer can never have a holiday. There is no arrangement made for sickness, and the man has very little out of life. He has no opportunity of giving his children a secondary education. We should be ashamed to allow a position of that sort to exist. What about the people in sheltered positions, the people with huge salaries, who can sit down to their breakfast, dinner and supper, and who eat the food produced under slave conditions? Those people draw big salaries and are paid during periods of sickness, and they can have a month's holiday each year. They eat the food produced by people living under slave conditions.
When they go to their offices, to find a fire prepared in advance at which to warm their backs, do they ever consider the lot of the small farmer and the farm labourer, the men who have to be out at 7 o'clock trying to produce food, the men who never saw a four-course meal in their lives? There are people in the City of Dublin, we have been told, who do not eat fresh meat. What about the people who rear the live stock, who feed them morning, noon and night and who have never had fresh meat in their lives? There are such people. They used to have a little bacon, but that has gone off the market. I do not blame the Minister for Agriculture. I will go so far as to say that one thing the Fianna Fáil Party can stand over is their advocacy of more tillage. I am prepared to give credit where it is due. There is no question about it, the Fianna Fáil Party took their stand on increased tillage, and it is about the best thing they have done. The fault is that they have not gone far enough. The issue now is, do we approve of compulsory tillage? I do, and I am satisfied that my colleagues do. That is what we have been advocating, that the Government have been too weak on this point all along. They encouraged the growing of wheat on land capable of growing it; that is the first solid step the Government took, and I compliment them on it.
I am concerned to see that those engaged in agriculture have at least opportunities equal to those engaged in other occupations, who have not to toil half as hard, and where not nearly as much skill is needed. These unfortunate people are outcasts. They rear up families for the emigrant ship. That has been the tradition. I am sure that Deputies on the Farmers' Benches will agree with that. In this Christian country that is a sad state of affairs. We have the raw materials, the land, bogs and wool; yet our young people have to go to other countries to seek employment. Some of those who go away find employment in the making of implements intended to destroy life. Why cannot we give our young people employment at home, in making things that would be of some benefit to humanity? We had a question in this House yesterday about the amount of wool that is sent out of the country. Why not put our people to work here instead of having them going to Britain?
Comment on this
Thousands of our people's sons have been forced to go there for employment. I believe it was never intended that the wives of small farmers and labourers should rear families so that they would have to go away to build up other nations. The policy of Sinn Féin was that this was a self-supporting nation. Was that policy right? If that policy as preached was correct, that we are a self-supporting nation, now is the time to put it to the test. We have not the opportunity of bringing in food at present. If the policy of Sinn Féin was correct, as I believe it was, then I believe this country is capable of supporting three times its present population. The difficulties in the way of doing so are not very great. We are in a very fortunate position, as with the exception of artificial manures we have all the other essentials for producing food.
Comment on this
While we have horse transport we need not have unemployment. I would prefer to see 47 men driving loads of hay into Dublin from Meath than to have it brought in by three lorries. It would be better to have the men working than to be paying them a miserable dole and have them standing at street corners. Linked up with the question of agriculture is that of youth employment. How many youths wish to become agricultural labourers to-day? To give the Minister one illustration. I know a farm labourer in Co. Dublin who reared 11 children, seven sons and four daughters. That man has now retired and is getting the old age pension. His youngest son refused to take his job. When I spoke to him about it he told me he was not going to follow the example of his father and mother, who had lived a life of slavery and poverty. The youth of to-day are not going to take up such work unless they get a fair standard of living. They are entitled to that. That is only one illustration of hundreds of similar cases.
Comment on this
I was going to tell the Deputy what brought him to Dublin. I was going to mention the abolition of the R.I.C. I am sorry if I have to be personal. I wish the Deputy would not interrupt. If I was in his position I would not do so. I ask for a ruling from the Chair that the Deputy should not interrupt. I had at least the decency not to interrupt the Deputy, and I am surprised that any Deputy would be so ignorant as to do so. I will not say any more on that matter. We have in this country 12,000,000 acres of arable land. I have heard the slogan so often that I am wondering where the missing acres are, considering that we have only 3,000,000 of a population and that thousands of families are living on holdings of two acres. Out of the population of 3,000,000 we can exclude women and and children, old age pensioners and invalids, so that only a small percentage of able-bodied people is left. If 12,000,000 acres of arable land were divided there should be 40 acres available for every able-bodied person. I wish the Minister would deal with that position when he is replying.
Comment on this
The Minister is responsible for agriculture and I am sure he is aware of the amount of agricultural land available for division. If we have 12,000,000 acres of arable land some people must own huge ranches.