We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 30—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 189–379 of 379. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order! I will not speak to Deputy Fogarty again. If he interrupts again he will have to leatve the House.

Comment on this

I hold that the Minister need not expect any return from wheat from land in Connanght. The land there is not capable of growing wheat successfully. Is it not a crime to ask small farmers to grow wheat on land from which they will not get a return much larger than the amount of seed sown? The land there is not suitable for wheat but is suitable for oats. Wheat should be grown in County Dublin and the adjoining counties where the land is capable of bearing it. Farmers who have tilled more land than they are required to till, and who are giving good employment, should be given a special bonus. I am referring to the type of farmer who has 100 acres, who tills 92 acres, and pays high wages.

I hold that those farmers who are such an asset to the nation should get preference over the rancher who has hundreds of acres and barely tills the quantity he is required to till. Sometimes he tills it in such a way that it is no advantage to the nation. I saw a case during the last war in County Dublin in which one of those ranchers threw in an odd grain of oats amongst grass with the result that the cattle went in and it was never cut. That is not farming. A preference should be given to the man who utilises his land for the proper purpose. The compulsory tillage regulations are not being carried out in County Dublin. If you go from Finglas to Fairyhouse you will not see & single field of tillage. I have drawn the attention of inspectors to it on more than one occasion and nothing has been done about it. I am afraid that these people must have some loophole whereby they escape their obligations. I have no sympathy with black-marketeers but is it not hard to think that some shopkeepers will be sent to jail for a month—quite rightly—for charging ½d. more than they should charge, whereas those people who are denying the community food, which is a much bigger offence, escape? There should be no sympathy with those people. The labourer works all day, and at night you will see him in the Local Security or Defence Force ready to lay down his life for his country. But here is a farmer who is asked only to utilise the land for the purpose for which God created it and he will not do so. Those people should be punished severely because they are not doing their duty.

Loans should be made available for farmers at a reasonable rate of interest. The honest, industrious farmer who gets a certain amount of money will utilise it to the benefit of the nation. Therefore, he should get it at a reasonable charge. Deputy Hughes wisely said that the sending of youngs cattle out of the country was wrong. If cattle have to go out of the country we should send them over as stall-feds because if we are to continue this tillage scheme we must restore fertility to the soil or it will be exhausted. Some people say that wheat takes nothing out of the soil. Good land will produce crops for a few years but unless fertility is restored it will then become exhausted; the best way to do that is by the application of farmyard manure. As regards the improvement of land I have heard the Minister complimented about the improvement of small holdings in the West and South.

What about the hundreds of acres that are wasted under timber in County Dublin? I know of cases where people applied for permits to cut those trees and they would not get them. I know a man with 12 acres who can till only eight acres because the roots of big ash trees stretch so far. The Department should have no hesitation in giving permission to cut those trees, particularly in County Dublin. If there were no roots of trees on the holding to which I refer, it could be capable of producing 60 barrels of wheat. Some people say that that would take away the beauty of the country. Let us get food and that will be sufficient beauty. The farmers must be put in a position to pay wages. I am not one of those who will say that the farm labourer must get £3 a week if the farmer is not in a position to pay it. The first essential is to put the farmer into a position in which he will be able to pay a sufficient wage. The guaranteed prices have gone a certain way in that direction. But if the guaranteed prices are not sufficient, farmers should be subsidised so that farm labourers may get a living wage. Deputy Corry said we were growing too much oats. I never heard a more ridiculous statement. It is true that oats would grow practically on the roadsides and is it not a reflection on the Department that we have not sufficient oatmeal or flake meal? We heard about potato and milk queues but do not let us forget that there were demands for oatmeal which could not be procured. If the war were to last for ten years and we had sufficient oats, we would have sufficient feeding for our fowl and our live stock and, last but not least, for the population. Nobody will die of hunger if there is a sufficient supply of butter, eggs, and oatmeal bread. There is no excuse for the Government as regards the scarcity of oats in a country where we should be able to export oats. As a matter of fact, that is the one point on which I think the Department failed. In conclusion, I am glad that the debate has revealed that there is general agreement on this: that the farm labourer of this nation is underpaid, underfed and underclothed. I appeal to the Minister to take his courage in his hands and put our farm labourers in a position that we need not be ashamed of.

Comment on this

There is one very important branch of the agricultural industry which, so far, has not been referred to in this three days' debate, and that is, the egg industry. I would like the Minister to take notice of the position of that industry as it is at the moment. The poultry population has been considerably reduced chiefly because of the failure of the people to produce sufficient food to keep poultry stocks. The public do not appreciate the fact that, in order to keep poultry stocks they have to produce food, and that if you have not poultry stocks you cannot have the egg industry as prosperous as it should be. Now that it is at a very low ebb, I would like the Minister to do something about it with a view to the establishment of a proper type of poultry stock in the country. That might be done by some system of propaganda through the local newspapers. The attention of poultry keepers and housewives might be directed to a better system of poultry feeding and a better system of preparing their eggs for market.

Very often, hardworking people in the egg trade are prosecuted in court because of the failure of producers to have their eggs properly marketed. The way to remedy that is to give better instruction to the producer. If that were done it would help to bring about a better state of affairs in the egg industry. At the moment, I think there is too much interference by inspectors of the Department with people who are dealing in the egg industry. We are not catering for a foreign trade in eggs now. We are scarcely able to supply the home requirements. We should have an eye to the requirements of the people here, and see that they become more highly skilled in the marketing of eggs when we are in a position at a later stage to meet the requirements of the foreign market. At the moment there should be some relaxation so that something may be done to meet the demand for eggs in the home market, which we are scarcely able to supply.

The people should be encouraged to provide a better type of poultry house. The old custom was to have it in the farmyard, near the home. People should be encouraged to have the poultry houses outside the farmyard and not be keeping their stocks of eggs for market in the home, as they do at present. I think that if the Minister were to pay attention to these things it would be appreciated very much by the people who find that egg production brings a very fine income into their homes. The egg industry should be properly established and catered for. In the West of Ireland, it is even more important than the pig rearing industry. The Department should appreciate that and give every assistance.

Taking the debate in general, it was in my opinion the most barren debate that I have ever heard in this House on this important question of agriculture. In fact, I have never heard a worse debate. I deplore entirely the banshee-wail type of debate that we have had about the poor farmer and the poor agricultural labourer. I do not think that either class will at all appreciate the fact that they have been brought into this type of banshee-wail debate. They will not appreciate the crocodile tears of professional vote-catchers like Deputy Tunney and others who have been singing the praise of the party they expect to get votes from at a general election. If those Deputies appreciated the fact that there may not be a general election for a very long time they might have debated this subject in a better manner than they did. Even if they had tried to criticise the Minister, and he may have deserved criticism on some points, it might haye been helpful. I have sympathy with the Minister who has had to listen to this three days' debate during which there were not three practical suggestions made from any side of the House. There was not even severe criticism of the Minister. In conclusion, I join with Deputies from all sides of the House who have been singing the Minister's praises during the past three days, and particularly the Deputies of the Farmers' Party who at least appreciate what the Minister has done in tackling one of the most difficult jobs that could fall to any Minister—the provision of food and of other supplies during a most critical period.

Comment on this

There are a few items which particularly concern the area I come from that I desire to refer to. The first is pig production. In my county, and particularly in the part of it that I come from, which is a very big area, I am satisfied that we were able to compete with any other county in pig production and egg production. Both industries provided the chief means of existence for the people in that area. Unfortunately, the position to-day is that pig production has practically ceased, and egg production has disappeared. Who is at fault for the present position as regards the pig industry?

During the debate I heard some Deputy on the Government Benches recommend that some board such as the Pigs and Bacon Board should be put into operation to deal with it. I can say that neither producers nor consumers of bacon want another marketing board set up. The present board has killed production and everything connected with the pig industry. We have no bacon now. When the Pigs and Bacon Board was originally established, we on this side of the House did not oppose it. We decided to give it a chance. Later, when it came to be re-established, every member on this side voted solidly against the proposal.

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this

About one-and-a-half years ago.

Comment on this

Every member of your Party voted for it in the beginning.

Comment on this

I agree because, as I have said, we decided to give it a chance, but later, when it was proposed to re-establish it, we voted solidly against the proposal. Deputy Dillon's speech on that proposal is on the records, and I remember that we were all against it for this reason: we saw that the regulation of the industry was going to kill production. The board was re-established and, as well as I recollect, it got full control. We asked at that time that the control should not be given to the board but should be put in the hands of the Minister or in this House. We did not succeed in that. The Minister, through that board, has killed the pig industry. The result is that we have no pigs in the country. In my opinion, it will be very hard to get people to go into pig production again. I am afraid that will be so in my part of the country. One reason is that young pigs were making from £5 to £6 each about five weeks ago, but now they have come down to £3 and £3 10s. 0d. each. As I have said, the people there are not, I think, going to go back into pig production. What the farmers there are doing now is this: they are buying two pigs, one to keep and feed and kill for themselves and the other one to sell, and it is questionable if that one is going to be sold to the factory. It may be sold to a neighbour who will cure it for his own use, with the result that pig production is killed, and the bacon factories will be practically closed down and there will be no bacon. However, the last Order which was made may help things. All restrictions and regulations are withdrawn, which may encourage pig production. My advice to the Government is to withdraw all the restrictions on the production of pigs and all the restrictions on prices, and leave it to the producers and the bacon curers. If the producers can get their price as they did heretofore, it is possible that after a short time they will come back into pig production.

Another reason the farmers had for getting out of pig production is to be found in what happened in previous years. I remember that from September to December of 1940 and 1941, we had pigs in the fairs and markets and in the houses of the people ready for sale, but there was no buyer to buy them. The factories were on quotas and were not allowed to take these pigs, with the result that pigs had to be brought home from the fairs unsold and held over for a fortnight, three weeks or a month, by which time they exceeded the weight at which they realised the top price. They had to be put into a second grade at a lower price, which all tended to kill pig production. The people got sick of it, sold their sows and went out of production. However, all these restrictions are now withdrawn, and I advise the Minister and the Department to leave it to the producers and the bacon curers. If the producers can get the production price for their pigs and bacon, they will come back into production. Otherwise, I see very little hope of it.

Deputy Ó Clélirigh has spoken about eggs and it is true that egg production is decreasing. Up to four years ago, we had a big export of eggs during the winter months. Last winter, we had practically nothing to export and barely enough for the City of Dublin. This year, I do not believe the position will be any better and it may be a little worse. Some people will tell you that it is the shortage of feeding which is responsible for the shortage of eggs. That, I suppose, is part of the trouble, but still, with the price of feeding, the price which eggs are making to-day, for home consumption or for export, does not pay the producer. What is the price? The price to the ordinary farmer for the last three years has been around 15/- per 120 eggs in the summer months, which goes up to 25/- or 26/- in the winter months. They cannot exceed that, because the price of export eggs has been fixed, and that export price controls the home market. On the basis of the price of oats, potatoes or any other feeding stuff, eggs cannot be produced at 15/- per 120 eggs during the summer months or at 25/- during the winter months.

In addition, I feel that the test at the port is rather severe. I wish to make it clear that I do not desire to be very extreme in the matter of the test because I am perfectly satisfied that there must be a reasonable test, so as to ensure that the quality of the Irish egg, when put on the British market, will be as good as, and, if possible, better than, the quality of the eggs in competition with it, when this war is over. Now, however, we are not up against that competition, and I believe the test could be slightly relaxed and still ensure a good quality egg. Every Deputy in the House may not be aware of the regulations governing the export of eggs by a licensed shipper, and it would be well that every Deputy should know that if a licensed shipper sends 20 cases of eggs to the port for shipment to England, and if one case is found to contain breakages, that case is not allowed to be exported and is forfeited by the shipper who gets nothing for it. You may have a certain number of trade eggs for various reasons, one of which would be the lack of the real feeding which would produce a good quality egg. A licensed shipper may put first-class eggs into a case on rail at a station 150 miles from Dublin Port. When they arrive in Dublin, they are two or three days old, and it may happen that a perfectly fresh egg may become a second quality egg, and if there is a certain number of second quality eggs in that case, the case is also forfeited. Taking a case of eggs at 26/- per 120, the loss is £3 18s., and when £3 18s. is taken out of one, two or three consignments, the licensed dealer is not going to break his heart trying to make a success of the industry.

I am perfectly satisfied that the inspectors do their duty, and do it fairly, but my view is that the test should be made a little easier. There is no reason why it should not be made a little easier because the competition is not there, while the quality is there. An egg which may have deteriorated inside two or three days has reached a stage at which it will go no further for the next week, and when it arrives at its destination in a week's time, it is a perfectly fresh egg. For these reasons, I say that the test should be more or less relaxed in order to keep the industry alive.

Another matter about which I have to complain in connection with egg production is that I have never heard, in my area or in any part of Ireland, of the Department making special arrangements to give instructions to the farmers' wives or young girls on the production of eggs. No effort is made to give instructions as to the class of eggs, the quality of eggs, or the condition of eggs when they are put on the market or brought into the wholesale or retail shipper. It has been left to them to bring them in as they wish, and the responsibility is placed on the exporter. It is a very important industry, and I think it is the duty of the Government to get the inspectors to call three or four meetings in each parish every year and give the necessary instructions. If you start in the parish, there will be very little trouble as far as the quality of eggs is concerned. It is not right to place the entire responsibility on the person who handles them 160 miles from where they were purchased. If that, or something like it, were done, egg production could be brought back to the condition in which it was four or five years ago when, I suppose, the exports value of our eggs was four times what it will be this year.

Deputy Corry said that oats are getting 22/6 a cwt. in Cork. The fixed price of wheat is 50/- a barrel, that is, 20/- a cwt. If oats are making 22/6 and wheat is only making 20/-, there is danger that, oats may take the place of wheat. I agree with Deputy Dillon and other Deputies that there should be at least a 10 per cent. reduction in wheat extraction, that it should be brought down to 90 per cent. I am firmly convinced that if it were brought down to 85 per cent., the 15 per cent. offal would go far to supply the deficiencies as far as pig and egg production are concerned, and there would be a 100 pe cent. return in bread. I have a very great connection with farmers and their wives. They bake their own bread, and use very little machine-made bread. They tell me that the present flour does not absorb as much milk as did the original flour. I believe 7 stone of flour of 85 per cent. extraction would yield as much homemade bread as 8 stone of flour of 100 per cent. extraction. I do not know how it affects the bakers in the city, because bakers' bread is not made with milk, but there are other ingredients added which are not added to the home-made bread. I am perfectly satisfied that it is necessary to take out 15 per cent., or, at least, 10 per cent., and I believe that with that extraction we would get the returns we are getting to-day. There is no doubt that there is waste in every shop, in every house, in every bakery. It is not through any fault on the part of those making the bread, but it arises out of the quality of the flour.

It is rumoured, whether correctly or not, that there is danger that we are going to be short of flour and that barley will be mixed with the wheat. If it is necessary to mix barley with the wheat in order to carry us over a period of shortage, I suggest that we should not wait till next May or June to start rationing flour. Now is the time to do so whilst there is some surplus in the country.

In June, 1941, when the quota system was, I think, 80 per cent. of the purchases in a certain year, I asked a question in connection with supplies and I was told there was no shortage, that everybody had plenty of flour although at that time we were only getting 80 per cent. of our purchases two years previous to that. That is my recollection. I speak subject to correction. I think the present basis of delivery is 110 per cent. That means that we are consuming to-day 30 per cent. more flour than we consumed in May or June, 1941. The question is, is the population of the country higher than it was in 1941? If there is going to be a shortage and if it will be necessary to mix barley with the wheat later on, now is the time to ration the flour so that it will carry us over until such time as we hope to get the new wheat. I am not an expert but I do not like the idea of mixing barley with wheat. I imagine those two cereals do not agree. The question is, if you mix them, will they be capable of being made into bread satisfactorily? The millers may know that.

It is suggested that the Minister is going to appoint an advisory committee to advise him on the production of oats, wheat, barley, etc. I think a great deal of that should be left to the inspectors. There was an advisory committee set up when the control of the price of oats was introduced. I do not know whether that committee is in existence now or not. At the time it was set up, a price was fixed for oats. I remember, in a motion before this House two years ago, we asked the Minister to fix a minimum price for oats but to fix no maximum price. We told him that if he were to fix a maximum price it would kill production, that the price control would break down. He would not agree. He fixed a minimum price and a maximum price. The fixed price did not last very long. I do not think a new committee could do very much to advise the Minister. I would prefer to leave it to the inspectors. In my opinion, the majority of them know their work and they are in a position to investigate and to report.

I hope the Minister will not do this coming season what he did last spring or the previous spring in the matter of seed oats and seed wheat. He fixed a price for seed wheat and seed oats, and the prices he fixed were actually being charged by the seed cleaners in the City of Dublin, in Wexford and Donegal. The shopkeepers and agents in every county who had to buy oats for seed for the people in their areas were not able to purchase the oats except at the fixed price.

My recollection is that the controlled price was 20/- for seed oats. The seed oats had to be bought in Dublin at 20/- and then transported perhaps 150 miles by rail and then perhaps 40 miles by lorry to remote parts of the country. That would entail a cost of between 2/- and 3/- a cwt. over the controlled price. The people wanted the oats but the shopkeepers who were in the habit of supplying them could not buy them because they could not sell them at the controlled price. When the seed was wanted, it was not in the areas and the farmers had to go to the market and buy any class of seed that was available. We have the results now in the complaints about the quality of seed wheat and oats in the country. I believe that is due to the quality of the seed put down.

A similar thing happened in regard to the price of manures three years ago. We had four different prices—one in November, one in September, one in January and another in February. I complained of that on the Vote for Agriculture two years ago. I said there should be only one price, that the Minister should makeup his mind as to what was to be the general flat rate price for the whole year, not to have a price for certain periods. A flat rate price for the whole year was fixed for manures and certainly worked out satisfactorily. As far as the price of oats, barley and wheat is concerned, I would ask the Minister to fix the price on the same lines as he fixed the price of manures. If the Minister fixed a wholesale price of 14/- and gave 1/- per cwt. to the retailer, allowing him, say, 1/6 per cwt. for freight from Dublin to Ballina and an additional shilling to cover the cost of distribution in cwts., seed would be available to the people. But if the matter is dealt with in the same fashion as it was dealt with last year, when a single price was put into operation by cleaners and wholesalers, without any margin for freight or for profit, there will be no seed for the people when they come in for it. They had to go out on the market last year and pay any price for any class of seed. Those who held up their seed and brought it to the market were free to charge any price they liked—even 10/- orl5/- over the controlled price—because it was being sold from one farmer to another. The really poor farmer who could not hold over his seed had to buy at 10/- per cwt. over the controlled price. I want the Minister to attend to that because it is necessary it should receive attention.

As regards the subsidy on potatoes, which was allowed in County Dublin, this was the first I heard about a subsidy on new potatoes. If there is a subsidy for Dublin, there should be a subsidy for all classes of producers. All producers are taking a great risk in the production of new potatoes. One night can clear them of all the potatoes they have grown. Take the case of Erris, where they turned out between £6,000 and £7,000 worth of potatoes last year. They would have done the same this year but for a single night in the middle of May which destroyed the whole crop. For £5,000 worth of potatoes, they, probably, did not receive £500. Many of these people, live by producing new potatoes. They have buyers to collect them and they, probably, produce potatoes as early as the Dublin producers. If there is to be a subsidy or bounty in respect of these potatoes, I think that subsidy should extend to all areas producing a similar article. In Erris, the people have to go across to England for seasonal work and, if there is a £9 subsidy in the Dublin area, there should be a £9 subsidy in the Erris area.

Flax was grown this year and a ration of manure was given for it. If there is a shortage of potatoes and wheat and if encouragement is given to the growing of flax in this way there may be a danger of shortage of flour and potatoes. Flax is a useful crop for people to grow and they certainly may get some return out of it.

In regard to the price of cattle, I am not satisfied that the people are being properly treated. The Department may have done its best: I am not going to blame anybody. There is a price control by the British on fat cattle. If, for argument's sake, that price starts in December at 9d. a lb. and goes up to 13½d. per lb. to the end of June, that is, in roughly eight months it is going up and in four months it comes back what it went up in eight. In other words, for every ½d. it went up, it came down ld. The result is that the small farmer, one of the hardest and most industrious workers, goes out to buy his young calf in May and pays 10d. a lb. for him. He has to buy him at the highest price for beef on the British market and has to sell that calf in November—because he has no land on which to keep him— at the lowest price for beef.

There seems to be a common report this year that young cattle were bought in June which, if sold this November, would not make the price they were bought at. The people should be told to be careful in buying and not left in the dark when they were going out to sell. If the price goes up from 9d. to 14d. per lb and goes down again to 9d., I do not see why this Government could not arrange with the British Government, instead of bringing it back to 9d., to keep it between 10d. and 1/-. Then the big fall and the big rise would not take place and certain sections of the people would not be working for nothing, buying and selling without profit. Britain seems to want the meat and there is no reason why the two Governments could not fix it up to suit both sides. If they do not, that is another question.

In regard to increased tillage, I am satisfied that we are all agreed that the food must be got and that, if the present acreage is not sufficient to supply the necessary food, there is no alternative but to increase the acreage. If the land is properly handled and we get a good spring and a good harvest with the increased acreage, I believe we are certain to have more than our own supply of wheat, barley, oats, beet, eggs, potatoes and cattle. Now is the time for the Party in power to make arrangements to provide a market for any surplus we may have, and not be having a surplus there and no market for it next June or September.

I remember, inside the last ten years, when people would not take oats from you for nothing and when potatoes were lying along the ditches and sold at 1/- a cwt. and you would have to pay a man to take away a cart of potatoes. There is no reason why that should occur. There should be a market for agricultural produce, so that farmers would have an opportunity to sell. They will always produce if they have that opportunity, but if they find that they cannot sell what they produce they will get sick of it. I have a big connection with farmers and I know that, if you give the farmer a chance and an open market, he will produce the stuff.

I wish to finish by asking the Minster to go specially this year into the question of seeds and seed prices and not be doing it at the last minute. There is no reason why the Department should not be able to make known the prices, the quality and the germination of the seed for oats, barley, wheat and turnips, as well as the price they are going to pay for oats, barley, etc. If that is done, they may rest assured that the farmers will do their part of it.

Comment on this

I will not detain the House very long, as I realise that this subject has been debated from every possible angle at great length, and as I realise also that a good deal of irrelevant matter has been introduced. I have attended many meetings of committees of farmers throughout the country since the emergency began and in no instance have I come across any body of farmers who were not 100 per cent. prepared to go all out to assist in the food production campaign.

It is very strange, therefore, to the general body of farmers to hear statements made by the officials in headquarters to the effect that the farmers are not doing their best in this campaign. It is very discouraging to find that they have been, as it were, misrepresented to the urban population in that respect by the suggestion that they have been trying to exploit the dwellers in the towns and cities. That attitude is very unfair and, on behalf of the farmers, I protest against it here. Farmers have many difficulties to encounter—bad weather, failure of seeds, diseases in their cattle—and, in all the circumstances, I am sure everyone will agree that they have done remarkably well. Consequently, it is encouragement they want and not adverse criticism.

I wish to summarise, as it were, the demands made by the farmers upon these benches. In connection with the price of wheat, I went to the trouble some time ago of getting costings for the production of an acre of wheat, in cases where the yield was six, seven and eight barrels to the acre.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave Mr. W.T. Cosgrave Fine Gael

Irish?

Comment on this

Statute. This year, the average, to my mind, would be somewhere between six and seven. From the costings that have been supplied to me by practical farmers and agricultural experts, I find that nothing less than 60/- per barrel would be an economic price in the coming season. I would suggest to the Minister for Agriculture that the docket or document with which he supplements the price value at half-a-crown should be translated into cash, and that instead of giving the farmer a slip of paper, the farmer should get half-a-crown in cash. If the Minister will only add another half-crown to that, he will satisfy the farmers, and if the proper price per barrel of wheat is given to the farmers, they will be able to supply the wheat for a loaf of 65 per cent. flour extraction, which would enable the offals to be used for the feeding of our live stock.

Now, with regard to the price of milk, I am sure that many Deputies have read the report of the findings of Professor Murphy of Cork University. Professor Murphy has carried out investigations in connection with some 60 farms in West Cork, and also in connection with many farms along the West Cork and Limerick border. At the time that he carried out these investigations, he found that the cost of producing a gallon of milk on those farms was 8½d. a gallon, leaving aside any question of profit. On that basis, the present cost of producing milk on such farms would be 1/- a gallon, and I wish, on behalf of the farmers of the country, to make the demand that the farmers should be paid 1/- a gallon for milk all the year round, for supply to the creameries.

I think it will be admitted that the dairying industry is the foundation of our agricultural economy, and that that industry is in very serious danger at the present moment, for many reasons. Of course, the first of these reasons is the uneconomic price that is paid for milk; but there is another danger, and a very serious one, and that is the incidence of disease amongst our dairy cattle. Take, for instance, the disease of contagious abortion which, it will be admitted, I am sure, by all Deputies in this House, costs the dairy farmers of this country a very considerable sum every year. I have often wondered why it is that our Veterinary Research Department has not gone into that matter and suggested remedies to counteract the colossal losses that have been inflicted on our farmers, year after year, as a result of that disease. If documentary evidence can be relied upon, I understand that there is a remedy for this disease of contagious abortion in cattle. For instance, I understand that in the State of Wisconsin, in the United States of America, and, nearer home, in England and Scotland, calves have been inoculated against the disease at the age of six or eight months, and that the results of such inoculations have been most satisfactory. I have been wondering, accordingly, why our Department of Agriculture has not carried out such tests here. As a matter of fact, in my own district, I endeavoured to get serum through my veterinary doctor last March, but I was told that it could not be got, and I do not know why. Now, all these things are very important, and I cannot understand why our Department of Agriculture is not trying to deal with these matters. There is also the question of mammitis in cattle. Perhaps, such diseases are more likely to occur in the case of certain breeds of cattle than in others, but still I hold that it is a matter for investigation by the veterinary branch of our Department of Agriculture. Now, as regards pig production, the general belief in my part of the country is that it would be a good job for the pig industry if the Pigs and Bacon Board were entirely abolished.

Another matter to which I should like to refer is in connection with the restoration of the fertility of our soils. Lime, at the present time, is practically indispensable, and I should like the Minister to take steps to include in the farms improvement scheme a clause whereby old lime-kilns could be renovated and put into use again. I think that if that were done, and old lime-kilns renovated and put into use again, so that the limestone could be burned, it would serve a very useful purpose so far as our agricultural industry is concerned.

As regards cattle, as several Deputies here have pointed out, I believe that cattle are our greatest national asset and that the day is coming when we will have no other medium of exchange except our cattle. For that reason, I welcome the recent schemes put forward by the Department for the improvement of our dairy herds, and I hope that these schemes will have the desired effect. When I am on that matter, perhaps I might say that I understand that a committee has been set up to deal with the question of post-war economy. I myself, and some other Deputies here, gave evidence before that committee last March, with regard to the dairying industry and schemes for the improvement of cattle generally. Subsequently, the Minister for Agriculture told me that there had been an interim report and that the recommendations contained in that report would be carried out forthwith. Well I am still waiting for that report, and I am still hoping that the findings of that committee, for the improvement of our dairying industry and the improvement of our cattle industry, generally, will be put into effect, because that is the basic industry of this country.

There is another matter to which I should like to refer, although I know that it has been thrashed out sufficiently already, and that is the question of the price of wheat and the price of milk. Certain suggestions have been made with regard to the Pigs and Bacon Marketing Board, and if the Minister will agree to abolish that board, then I think we would all be in agreement with him; but if he does not do that, or re-constitutes the board on entirely different lines, then I am afraid that we, as representatives of the farmers, cannot see our way to approve of his policy and must vote for the proposal of Deputies on the other side of the House.

I shall not delay the House any longer—I had not intended to speak as long as I have—but I hope that the Minister will see his way to accede to our request in this matter. If he does so, as I have said already, and speaking on behalf of the farmers of this country, I think I can assure him that he will have a surplus of wheat, butter, milk, and all the other commodities that the farmer can produce in this country. Remarks have been made here to the effect that the farmers are getting rich now. Well, perhaps, they are rich as compared with the days of the economic war, but it is time that the farmers should get some encouragement after the lean period through which they have had to go. In this connection, however, I should like to point out that there is a large section of the farming community who are not able to carry on at the present time, and these are the small farmers who are living on the hillsides of the country. They cannot grow beet or wheat. They have nothing to fall back upon but the drop of milk. The pig has gone, the poultry have practically gone and these people are in a very bad way. I say that, having personal experience of it, living as I do amongst them.

In passing, I should like to say that I join with other Deputies who have spoken of the desirability of giving every encouragement to agricultural labourers. The principal way I want to encourage them is to provide for them a decent system of housing. At the present time, we have so-called agricultural labourers' cottages but they are not agricultural labourers' cottages. Every section of the community seems to be using them. There should be some scheme whereby it will be possible for every farmer as in the old days to have a labourer's house on his land. Until such time as agricultural labourers see an opportunity of settling down on the land and making for themselves a home upon it, the flight from the land will continue. I think that is the root of the trouble— the difficulty of getting suitable homes. Whatever Department is concerned with that, I hope steps will be taken to investigate that problem and to provide a solution for it.

Comment on this
Mr. Cosgrave

Perhaps the Minister in the course of his reply would give us some further information regarding the extra percentage of land which it is expected will be put under tillage this year. If I took the figures correctly, the area devoted to tillage during the present year was 2,400,000 acres and next year it is hoped that there will be another 1,200,000 acres added to that.

Comment on this

Oh, no. The Deputy will understand that the percentage is being increased from 33? per cent. to 37½ per cent. Taking into account the allowance for first-crop grass, the increase of tillage would be about a net 4 or 5 per cent., or about 500,000 extra acres. That means that the total will be about 3,000,000 acres.

Comment on this
Mr. Cosgrave

It will mean an additional acreage under the plough in any event. I expect the Minister has taken into account the difficulties which the farmers had in dealing with the harvest this year and whether the labour content of the country will be sufficient to meet the demands during the coming harvest. A case has been made here for excluding from the compulsory tillage scheme, lands devoted to dairy herds and I think that that case has a fairly sound foundation. Assume for a moment that for the 40,000 gallons of milk which come in daily to Dublin, 20,000 cows are required. Probably another 20,000 would supply the needs of other cities and towns throughout the country. Allowing 3 acres for each cow that would absorb something like 120,000 acres. Even if we were to say 200,000 acres, the concession of 10 per cent. in that case alone represents only 20,000 acres. There are strong reasons why the House should agree to that. In the first place, the purchase of feeding-stuffs for cattle devoted to milk production is very expensive. It would be unfortunate if the better cows were sold from these herds and if the average milk production per animal were to be diminished. I think enough has been said on that point to impress the Minister with the importance of the suggestion.

Stud farms, too, deserve more than usual consideration just now. Those conducting stud farms have had four very lean years. They give a great deal of employment, and the animals require a considerable quantity of tillage products. It would be unfortunate if a man who had invested very considerable sums of money and who kept a considerable number of employees, had either to get rid of the animals or reduce the number in his employment. Having regard to the trend of events recently, it is possible that in the next couple of years thare may be some return for the investments that have been made in that way. In that case, too, the acreage to be excluded from the compulsory tillage scheme would not be very considerable.

A third point to be considered is the growing of wheat on land where its cultivation would not be a success. In no circumstances should any landholder, no matter in what part of the country he lives, be asked to grow wheat on land which will not yield a comparatively good crop. I think, too, some consideration should be given to the case made here, by Deputy Dillon, I think, for an examination of the waste occasioned by the 100 per cent. extraction. From information given to me by a member of the Minister's own profession, it appears that there is considerable waste, inasmuch as the bread becomes stale much more rapidly than if the lesser extraction were made. A good case can be made, therefore, for a 90 per cent. extraction rather than 100 per cent. extraction. Apart from that, the offals, pollard and bran, would be of considerable advantage for the feeding of animals.

One case that I expected would have been made by those who have close association with the land during the last ten years is that whatever shipping space is saved by reason of the extra production of wheat should be earmarked by the Minister for the importation of manures. Reference has been made in the course of the debate to the new departure in agricultural policy in the last ten or 11 years. It was urged that if it were not for the experience we had gained during that period and the advantage derived from the extra tillage policy, we would be in a bad position now. I do not think the people who made statements of that sort are aware of the facts. During the years in which we were supposed to be engaged in this intensive tillage policy, we imported a much smaller quantity of manures than in the years when there was not so much land tilled.

Perhaps the Minister would be able to tell us in the course of his reply what reliability we can place on the statistics we get both in regard to acreage and under the various headings of cereals. Assuming that they were correct for that time, is it not a joke to say that we had such an extension of tillage in the last 10 years? What does it amount to? Why, in the best year, it represented only 1 per cent. Assuming it were ten times what it was, is there not left in the country 90 per cent. of the land on which something else must be produced and on which we must get some return? It is on that aspect of this Vote that greater attention should be concentrated. If we take the coming year and say that 3,000,000 acres will be under tillage, we have left 6,000,000 or perhaps 7,000,000 of good arable land on which live stock will be raised. Now, is the 7,000,000 as important as the 3,000,000, or, alternatively, is the 3,000,000 as important as the 7,000,000?

It is a national duty on the part of the State to restore the fertility of the soil. The soil has been practically starved of manure for something like ten or 12 years—more starved, perhaps, during the last three or four years than in the preceding eight or ten. But the Minister has an unanswerable case to make to his colleagues. Shipping space has been spared by reason of not having to import wheat and, therefore, it is possible to get in manures and distribute them through the country. The proposal, if I understand it correctly, on the part of the Ministry, is that these manures are to be distributed according to whatever wheat is grown. I think that is a mistake. The approach should be in the direction of having the land, wherever it is or whoever has it, restored in fertility and so made useful for the State. It may be that an individual will benefit here and there, but ultimately the State must come in on whatever benefits accrue to the individual. It is the bounden duty of the Government to see that those who, during difficult years, drew upon the resources of the land, should have that land restored to its original fertile condition.

Reference has been made here to the hard life of those who are employed on the land, and particularly agricultural labourers. In one case a Deputy went so far as to suggest that the Government should fix the wage they ought to be paid. We are in this difficulty. What reliance can we place upon the figures given to us regarding, in the first place, the numbers engaged on the land and, in the second place, the value of the agricultural production in a particular year? Let us take the last year. The Minister will correct me if I am wrong. I think the amount made on the land was £73,000,000. Will the Minister accept that figure?

Comment on this

I think that is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Cosgrave

There are 630,000 persons engaged in the production of commodities from the land. It is an easy thing to divide one figure into the other and I think the quotient will give something like £115. That represents the annual value per person employed. How can we get £3 a week if the average earnings are £115 per head? We must remember that the £73,000,000 was made in what one might term a prosperous year. It was a year in which, as was stated here, the farmers were wealthy. The sum and substance of the situation is that there was not £2 5s. per week for each person engaged in the agricultural industry in that good year. Out of that sum they have to pay their rates and other liabilities. Although the annuities may be static, the rates have been going up. All that leads to this point: that if they are to get a higher wage—and apparently there is universal agreement that they should—we must increase in some form or other the value to be got out of the land. That is our main consideration here.

Taking the presentation of the case made by the Minister about his Department, I would say it was almost purely from the administrative aspect. It dismissed entirely any idea that you could have any change except for the worse in the agricultural policy. There was concentration on individual items, but the general policy in relation to agricultural output and value was ignored. There was a gradual reduction over the years in the value of agricultural output. How do we propose to remedy that? I say in that connection that practically every problem in relation to agriculture must be directed towards getting more out of it than what has been got—a greater development of output, an increase in output, and in the value of that output.

Some Deputy spoke of a reference in the Press and in the Parliament of another country regarding an improvement in agricultural output. He dismissed it and said it could not be true. It is true, and there is no doubt about it that agricultural output in a neighbouring country has advanced from 50 to 70 per cent. If we take the information furnished during the last ten or 15 years, it will be seen that the output per person employed here has been generally under that of our neighbours in the North or across the water. What is the remedy? We must increase the milk yield. The Minister may ask how is that to be done. I suggest it is a matter for his Department. I can only speak as a person with some experience. In my own experience the average output from cows is about 800 gallons and I believe it is possible for anybody else to have the same. There may be cases in excess of that.

What I am leaving towards is that if we examine this Estimate from that angle, I do not know whether it would be possible—the Minister may be able to say whether it would be—to increase the amount put down in the Estimate ior a better type of bull. The whole amount in the Estimate is almost negligible. We have £2,000 in the case of the non-dairy, and £2,000 for dairy stock and £12,000 or £14,000 by way of loans. I think those amounts, ought to be increased. I cannot say whether there is a market at the moment, but I am informed by a person with some experience of agriculture in another country that on a recent, occasion an animal that got first prize in a show across the water and which was purchased at a very high price, got only 3rd prize in South America.

My view In that connection is that no country in the world should have a higher standard of cattle than this country. It is true that in common with the herds of other countries our cattle have been subject to certain diseases. I believe they are relatively less affected than in other countries, but, however small it may be, that disease ought to be eradicated entirely. I do not agree with Deputy Halliden that it is a matter for veterinary experts. I rather think it is a bacteriological matter. It may require the assistance of the veterinary profession in getting a solution, but that a solution is possible, I am convinced, however long delayed it may be. I could verify what has been said with resard to the efforts made across the water to have animals inoculated in order to get rid of the disease. My information is that within the next few years it is likely that cattle in this country will not be exported unless a certificate has been supplied that they have been so inoculated. There is enormous loss in regard to that matter, and every effort must be made in this country, the same as in other countries, to eliminate that terrible waste. Similarly with regard to T.B. in cattle. It is probably less prevalent here than in any other country, but it should be eliminated. We should go so far as to exclude animals which react to it on examination, and in that case there would be none suffering from the disease.

With regard to seeds, soils and so on, I had the advantage of getting information directly from an extensive live-stock feeder who has given that up now and who is concerned with the system of lea farming. Probably the Minister has heard more about that than I did. In such cases we should have expert advice and the most scientific methods should be employed to improve the feeding qualities of our land. These are my suggestions regarding a scheme which would afford a better wage to those engaged in farming and to agricultural labourers. I suggest to the Minister for his serious consideration either to divide his Department into two separate compartments or to get a Parliamentary Secretary who would devote his attention exclusively to planning or arranging for an extension of agricultural output.

Reference was made by one of the Deputies for Mayo to eggs. I entirely disagree with him. They asked for concessions in connection with the marketing of eggs. I say that there should be none. The only aim in this country should be to get the highest quality in all brandies of our agricultural products. The standard should be nothing but the best. It may be that, by reason of that, for a time losses will be sustained, but if we arrive at the point where Irish agricultural products reach the highest price in competitive markets, we can sell our goods. If we arrange that only the highest quality goods get there we will surely have a people satisfied to make a living by marketing only the highest quality goods. There was a time when we had that position. We should not be in the least depressed by the new orientation which other countries have had before them in connection with agricultural development. Comparing the results of some ten years ago with the results of 90 years before that, I say that there is a marked improvement in our period in the production of cereals and in the numbers of cattle, pigs and poultry. I should say that the general expansion of production from the land in cereals and roots may be put down on the average as from 20 to 25 per cent.; that the numbers of cattle went up by about 50 per cent., and that that was the peak point in our production. It may be a difficult task now but it is a worthy one.

Agriculture, in my opinion, is a noble calling and every effort should be made to stimulate production and the volume to be got from it. It may be that in connection with such improvement in value there would be employment found for a greater number of people. I suggest that those who live in cities and towns, and who say that we spend too much time talking about agriculture, should remember that we have no secondary industrial exports, and that whatever market there is for industries in towns and cities will come from the purchasing power of the agricultural community. Until that is expanded, as it can be expanded, there will not be real prosperity in our towns and cities.

It is unfortunate that in the course of a debate such as this misconceptions have arisen as to what one Deputy who represents County Dublin said, which led a Deputy for Mayo to think that there was a subsidy for growing potatoes. There is no such thing. There is no subsidy for potatoes. There is a subsidy for people in Dublin who could not afford to pay the market price of potatoes owing to mismanagement in connection with the supply of potatoes. There was a plentiful supply of potatoes to meet, all requirements during the last 12 months, but by reason of a shortage at a particular time potatoes had to be bought, and, in order to do that, certain people had to get the market price. There was no subsidy for potato growers in Dublin and it is very wrong for any Deputy to try to lead his constituents to think that such a subsidy was given.

Comment on this

I hope that some good will come as a result of this debate. There seems to be variance between the views of farmers from different counties. I consider that as the farming community all earn their living in the same way, it is time that they had a common platform. If farmers are able to stand alone now that is no credit to the Government. They have no one to thank but themselves. When the Minister is replying I think he should repudiate a statement made in Dublin, that farmers had let the nation down. I thought that was a mean statement. The farmers did not let the nation down. It was lack of organisation and nothing else that was responsible for doing so. I agree with Deputy Cosgrave that if there was a better output in agriculture, better wages could be paid. The Minister has now made wheat growing compulsory, but I think he should have done so in 1940, and should have offered £3 a barrel. He will have to give that amount later on. If farmers are given a decent price they will provide the crops.

Meath is one of the counties to which the nation looks for an increased output of wheat. It is one county that contributes more than any other towards feeding the people. In my view the Minister has not given sufficient consideration to the claims of that county. It was known as a county of large ranches. It is time that the position there received special attention. Some men in that county are tilling 300 acres of wheat, but they find that they have sometimes to wait two or three months before securing a tractor, and at harvest time they have to wait months for machines to reap their crops.

It is my belief that sufficient attention has not been paid to that. I say without fear of contradiction that there is sufficient waste wheat lying on the ground in County Meath for rats and crows and pigeons to eat as would feed this country for a fortnight. That is a terrible statement to have to make but it is a fact, I walked over belts of wheat land where the wheat was lying rotten. To some extent that may have been due to the weather, but a lot of it was lost through pure neglect. I know of belts of wheat up to 60 or 70 acres which were overripe for five weeks because there was no machinery to be got to cut the wheat. I say that it was the duty of the Minister to see that such wheat was salvaged in some way or other, even if it were necessary to get some of the Army to save it. Most of that wheat was lost. The land was capable of producing 20 barrels to the acre, but instead of that only four or five barrels to the acre were got out of it. The owners, however, were quite satisfied because they were able to clear themselves. As long as the cattle paid them well, that paid for the wheat that was lost. The owners did not care if it was never reaped.

That is where the Minister made the mistake, because he did not get his Department interested in these large tracts of land in my county. I know that many ranchers there did good work, and did it well. But there are many tracts of land in my county the owners of which live 40 miles away, and hardly see the land once in 12 months. They have a herd and a couple of men employed, and it is left to them to deal with 30 or 40 acres of wheat. It is a colossal scandal that the Minister would not step in and take over these tracts of land in the interest of the people. We will now probably be short of one or two months' supply of wheat, and perhaps hunger may be staring some people in the face. Yet I know that wheat was left there rotting on the ground. The poor of Dublin will have reason to regret that. I blame the Department for that.

What is the use of sending inspectors to Connemara where they cannot produce two barrels of wheat to the acre? They should be sent to my county, where 20 barrels to the acre can be produced. That is where the Department should concentrate not alone its inspectors, but every bit of machinery they can get from Great Britain. That machinery should be concentrated in Kildare, Meath and Westmeath, where you can produce the crops. I say that any machinery that comes in from Great Britain should be the property of the Department until the war is over. I know that some machinery came into my county during the last few months, and I know the way it was distributed. The county committee of agriculture did their best to have it given to those best entitled to it, but other men, who were not entitled to the machinery, came up to the Department and pulled wires there and got the machinery, not in the interests of the nation, but to see how much they could make out of it. That is a disgrace. I ask the Minister to see that the State will own any machinery which comes in, and send it out to the large estates to sow and reap the crops, so as not to have thousands of barrels of wheat wasted which should be turned into human food. The Minister should give special consideration to that. I live in the district where these ranches are, and, although I see the waste, I can do nothing about it. It is for the Department to try to salvage these huge areas of wheat which are being wasted.

Many of these big farmers in my county are making every attempt to provide food and make it a paying proposition, but they cannot cope with the matter. What happens then is that tillage ranchers from Louth and Cavan come to Meath and take the land, not in the interests of the people, but to see what they can get out of it. They take 40 acres here and 50 acres in another place and 100 acres somewhere else. They are running about from one place to another. There is only one way of dealing with that, and that is that the Department should take over these ranches and parcel them out amongst the small farmers who are willing to take them in lots of four or five or six acres. They will do the work well. If that is done, I guarantee that there will not be one barrel of wheat lost. A small farmer with 25 or 30 acres is well able to cope with the tillage on his own farm as well as take part of a larger farm on conacre. In the days of the British Government every little farmer in County Meath was able to do well by taking conacre.

I ask the Minister to stop this practice of men coming from God knows where to make a profit out of the land in County Meath. As long as that is happening the country will be short of wheat. I ask the Minister to see that the small farmers in County Meath who can cope with the work should get a chance of taking such land on conacre. They have not the slightest chance at present of getting it. The "combine" men will always get it. The rancher will give the land to these "combine" men. Most of the ranchers hate to see a small farmer coming on to their land. They would rather give it to somebody else. I say that that is a disgrace and that it is time it was put a stop to, and that the men who can deal with this position should be allowed to deal with it.

As to county council workers who were released to give assistance during the harvest, I know many small farmers who wanted to save their harvest and who asked for the assistance of these men. While the ordinary agricultural worker was satisfied to work for 10/- a day, a good many of these warriors—not all of them—said that they would not work for less than 15/- a day. I do not know whether they combined together or not. The small farmer could not afford to pay that wage. These men were glad to hear that, because they did not want to work for the small farmer. The farmer with plenty of money, when he is told that the small farmers can only pay 10/- a day, will say that he will give 14/-, and the labourers of the country trot after him in order to get the 14/-. But the small farmer who was not able to pay 14/- had to do his work with a scythe. It is time that something was done with regard to that.

I agree with Deputy Beegan that there should be a definite fixed harvest wage—that the bigger men who can afford to pay should not be allowed to pay more than the poor man. There should be an honest harvest wage fixed for a three-months' period. These men who come from the county council work are not always the best type. The majority of them do not want to work on the land. A man who works on the road with a shovel does not want to work on the land. But the unfortunate agricultural worker, who is working from morning to night, is glad to get 9/- or 10/- per day. These other men want to get back to work on the roads or in the bogs. That is a matter which should be looked into. I am not saying that every man who is released from county council work is a bad worker. Some of them are good workers. There should, however, be a fair deal for everybody.

Another matter I am concerned about, as are also other people in County Meath with a national outlook, is that at present there is a complete "sell-out" in County Meath of large and middle-class farms. Public auctions of land are being held every day. I would not mind that if the land was going to farmers. I raised this question yesterday in order to bring it to the attention of the Minister. Jews and publicans from Dublin and others who have thousands to spend, such as the racketeers who made money during the economic war, are buying this land and giving a good price for it. In some cases they never see the land— they buy it by telephone. Within a few days some of these farms are sold to somebody else, but we never hear the name of the buyer. All that we see are herds of cattle from Tipperary or Dublin being put on the lands. With that situation, I think it is time for the Irish nationalist people to take stock.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is not that a matter for the Minister for Lands?

Comment on this

I am raising it now because these farms are being bought by the type of people I have referred to. Some of the land is torn up for tillage by the man who owns it, but in a fortnight's time or so it is sold again and goes into the hands of somebody else. The tillage is left derelict and there is nothing but waste. It is time that an Irish Government should take stock of that position. You have the Jews and those who have fattened on the Irish people engaging in that sort of thing. If it is allowed to go on, it will again be a case of "To Hell or to Connaught" for the Irish farmer's son. That kind of thing is being done by people who have fattened on the sweat and blood of the Irish people.

I am not satisfied with the regulations the Minister has made for threshings. There was a regular racket last year in the case of these threshing mills. The charges which farmers had to pay were extortionate. The Minister should fix a definite charge per barrel. That would be fair to the farmer and to the millman, whether he was a man with a big mill or a small mill. To allow the threshing mills 12½ per cent. on what they charged last year is not the right way to do it at all, because very big prices were charged last year. If the Minister does what I suggest, of making the charge so much per hour or per barrel, there can be no quibbling about it, and the farmer will be satisfied.

I would ask the Minister to concentrate more on the County Meath. There is more waste there at present than would feed the Irish people for a fortnight. It is a public disgrace. Is it not a terrible waste to see these combines going in on 60 acres of land and 30 acres of the crop lying flat? The combine threshes out about four sacks to the acre, while three times that is left on land which has been sown with first-class seed.

We have the position, too, of men getting agricultural machinery who never stood behind a tractor or anything else, while good farmers cannot get one. These tractors and machines should be given to the men who are competent to make the best use of them. I heard of a man who was to get a reaper and binder, but another man who was at enmity with him and who probably had a pull with the Department, succeeded in getting it for himself. All these things should be looked into if we want to get honest, decent results from our tillage drive.

Comment on this

I want to touch on a few matters that concern the district I represent. West Cork is a very poor district and a big proportion of the holdings there are small. It is not a wheat-growing district. It is one in which potatoes and oats can be grown. The big problem there is the scarcity of farmyard manure. That was felt very much this year and will be felt during the coming season. The absence of it is principally due to the collapse of the pig-feeding industry, which was a very important industry in the district. Very little artificial manure is available. We have no lime kilns, but along the sea coast thousands of tons of sand are available. This is regarded as a great fertiliser in our part of the country. In fact, we prefer it to lime, but unfortunately we have no boats to deliver the sand as the farmer requires it. On at least two occasions within the last two years the Minister for Supplies refused to make oil available for two boats that were needed to land sea sand.

I would ask the Minister for Agriculture to use his influence with his colleague, the Minister for Supplies, to have oil made available for a few extra boats in our district. I want to assure him that the oil could not be put to a better use because the land is so poor that the sea sand is needed to act as a fertiliser.

There is a good deal of reclaimed moorland in the district. I am anxious to know from the Minister if his inspectors, when mapping out the area of land to be put under wheat, will include this moorland. My own opinion is that the sowing of wheat on reclaimed land is a waste of time and a waste of good seed. That land will grow potatoes all right but not wheat.

I have already brought to the notice of the Minister the anxiety of farmers in the district to get a change of seed. I hope that on that matter the position is not going to be worse this year than it was last year. I have here one letter signed by 25 farmers in a big district asking for a change of seed and requesting me to bring the matter to the notice of the responsible authority. The Minister, in his reply to me, said that the seed could be got through the usual channels. That may be so, but I would ask him to get his inspectors to visit the district where the change of seed is required. He should obtain a report from them. There may be some people in these districts who would not be able to pay for the seed, even if they were able to get it from the Minister. The people of West Cork are very industrious and at one time were very well-off. They are hard-working and industrious, but they have not recovered yet from the effects of the economic war. They are prepared to do their part. The crops failed with many of them this year, and if they are to fail again next year, owing to the lack of proper seed, it will be a very serious matter indeed for them.

The poultry industry at one time was a very important one in West Cork, but like the pig-feeding industry it has almost disappeared. The creameries as well as a number of people in the district went to great expense in putting up hatcheries and chicken houses. The price which is being paid for the dead chickens exported is not a remunerative one at all. I think the Minister should make recommendations to the British Government to pay at least a reasonable price for those chickens. It might be a small matter in the eyes of some but it is a very important industry.

A Deputy to-day made reference to the county committee of agriculture in Cork and to a visit paid to it by the Minister for Agriculture. The Minister went down to Cork at the invitation of the county committee, and the county committee were advised a week beforehand that the Minister was coming. A member of the committee was told off to put the case in respect of each branch of the agricultural industry before the Minister.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I should like to draw your attention, Sir, to the fact that there are less than 20 members in the House and that when a Clann na Talmhan Deputy is speaking, only three members of his Party are listening to him.

House counted; and 20 Deputies being present—

Comment on this

The members of the county committee received the Minister, and, whether they agreed with him or not, gave him the honour due to him as a member of our Government. I do not think that many of us agreed with him, but surely the Deputy who spoke to-day did not want us, instead of putting our case before him, to give him a crack of a blackthorn. We put our case before him, and I think the Minister's views have been improved as a result.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister if he is convinced that with the new scheme he proposes to put into operation for next year, he will get the necessary quantity of food for the people. That is a question which I have been putting to myself for the last week or two, and, listening to the debate, I have, rightly or wrongly, come to the conclusion that a great many people in this country have over-estimated the country's resources, and regard the country as one vast empire with nothing to do but will that a thing be done to have it done forthwith. In view of the policy which the Government has pursued for the last eight or nine years, can the Minister say, once and for all, whether, irrespective of the price per barrel which he proposes to pay for wheat—whether 55/-, 65/- or 105/—we can produce sufficient wheat for our needs, because every year that passes we are short, for some reason or other, and then we are told we are self-supporting?

Irrespective of the price, we do not seem to be able to produce sufficient wheat, and at the same time put into operation all the other parts of our agricultural economy. In other words, will we be able, even at this late stage and notwithstanding all the boastings we have carried on for the last eight or nine years, to produce sufficient wheat, and at the same time keep our oats, barley, root crops in the form of turnips and mangels, beet crops, and the necessary acreage of grass to feed our cattle and all the other things ancillary to the successful working of an agricultural country?

That is an important question, and one which I should like the Minister to answer. There is no use in talking about producing wheat, if at the same time the Minister is in negotiation with some foreign country for the importation of wheat. I hope he will be successful in those efforts, but one of the points I put to him is that, notwithstanding the fact that we have paid out very large sums of money during the past eight or nine years, we are not self-supporting. This debate has convinced me of one thing: the utter failure of the policy of self-sufficiency, in spite of all that has been said and done during the past ten years.

I represent the smallest county in Ireland, but, I believe, one of the best tillage counties. We grow more wheat, oats and barley per head than any other county, and one of the things which are annoying the farmers in that county in regard to threshing is the fear of using turf and sticks, owing to the danger of fire. They are very much put out by reason of the fact that, having got permits for coal, they are not in a position to get coal of a quality which will give definite results, and I suggest to the Minister that, if it is at all possible, he should negotiate with the British Government with a view to getting in a few cargoes of coal at the right time, which could be distributed to farmers all over Ireland who are the owners of threshing sets, and so free the farmers from their fear of fire, and also encourage them to go on to greater things in the future.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The importation of coal is a matter for the Minister for Supplies.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister for Agriculture would have an interest in it, seeing that it plays such an important part in an operation, threshing, which is of real concern to the agricultural community. No matter how good the crops you have, if you have not got machinery to thresh them at the proper time, there is sure to be wastage. I think my suggestion would be one means of meeting the difficulties which confront a great many of the farmers in County Louth. I hope the Minister will consult the Minister for Supplies with a view to getting a few extra cargoes of coal and, in doing that, I do not think he will be running any risk, as Deputy Fogarty seems to think he would be, of plunging this country into war. We are an independent country and why should we be afraid to go across to England and negotiate there, as the Turkish statesmen are doing?

You could scarcely carry on an agricultural policy but for the assistance of Great Britain, and there is no use trying to deny that fact. Where would we be but for the imports of kerosene and petrol of which we have heard so much even from Deputy Fogarty during this debate? Everybody would, have to go out with a hook and scythe to save the crops, were it not for the imports of kerosene and petrol which we have got. There is no useful purpose served by this hypocritical talking about the dangers of war. There is no such danger. As Deputy Larkin says, why do we not stand erect as free men, the representatives of a free nation. and demand a quid pro quo from those on the far side for what they are undoubtedly getting here in the shape of cattle and other products from the farmers of this country.

With regard to tractors, it came to my notice last week that a man had to stop threshing operations because he could not get sufficient petrol. He was the owner of two steam threshers, but, owing to the poor quality of the coal he got, he could not use them. He was an honest man who stated that his steam threshers were in excellent condition but he could not use them because the coal was no good. He applied for petrol but there was a delay in giving it to him. I believe he will get it ultimately, but why the delay?

I would ask the Minister for Agriculture, who is primarily responsible, to consult with his colleague the Minister for Industry and Commerce and have these matters attended to. Of course, I recognise that we are not the bosses here, that even the Minister for Agriculture is not the boss in this country. He has to consult with the people on the far side in these things. I know his difficulties. I am not trying to gloss over or to hide them. He must only do the best he can to see that there is equal distribution of whatever supplies are available and can be imported. I hope that we will be lucky enough to get more during the coming year.

Last week I heard that large numbers of old cows had been sold to the canning factories in this country to be killed and canned. I have it on reliable authority that large numbers of those cows were in calf. If that is a fact, it is a disgrace to this country. If that is allowed to happen, is it any wonder that we fear a shortage of cattle? It was bad enough when the Minister ordered the slaughter of the calves but to continue it by slaughtering the calves before they are born is a crime that possibly will call for vengeance in the very near future. I hope the Minister will see to it that that does not occur because, to say the least of it, I do not think it is a bit lucky.

I think it is up to everybody to assist in providing sufficient food next year for the people of this country. It may be said here that the farmers were taking advantage of the position in order to cash in. I do not think that is right. During the economic war there was very little sympathy with the farmers when they were cashing out and when they almost lost everything. It is well to issue the warning that we must all work together, that nobody is indispensable, that nobody is the boss and that we must all sink or swim together in the difficult years that lie ahead. It may be that this war may last another three or four years and we will be left absolutely on our own resources. If we are fortunate enough to be able to secure some small imports from our friends on the far side, so much the better, but I think in the main we will have to rely upon the work of our own people and on the productivity of our own soil. I repeat that it is extraordinary that in the year 1943, so far as I can see, the Minister is still not in a position to state whether this country will be able to grow sufficient wheat for next year, or not. When I say sufficient I mean a quantity of wheat that will support the people if we never import any foreign wheat. If we can get it in, it will be all the better. but, so far, that has not happened. We are told that it takes the produce of something like 750,000 acres, roughly, to produce 750,000 tons of wheat, which is the quantity we require. Between oats, barley and other cereals and root crops we have used only about 3½ million acres and we are supposed to have from 9 to 12 million acres of arable land. I cannot understand, therefore, why the Minister cannot say that we are in a position to produce sufficient wheat.

When the wheat policy started, great things were expected of it. Of course, it has to be grown now, whether we like it or not. There is no use in Deputies on the opposite benches saying that Deputy Dillon agrees with the policy because he stated in his speech that we have perforce to grow wheat. The Deputy on the far side forgot to say that Deputy Dillon said that after the war the wheat scheme would go into thin air. Any man of common sense must agree with that. When the war is over you will all get your eyes opened and it will not be a bit of harm. We have to move with the times. All things will change when the war is over. We have to try to get through these difficult years as best we can.

We have to plan now, not for postwar. We will be doing well if we get through the present years and I would advise the Minister to pay the least possible attention to this question of post-war planning. It is all moonshine and bunkum, just as town planning and everything else were found to be here. It is sufficient for us to try to get through a difficult time from day to day, week to week and year to year, letting the future fend for itself. One of the things we have to do now is to grow wheat. It does not follow that we will have to do it when the war is over.

I can assure the Minister, whatever criticism I have to offer, I do my little bit with the farmers of my county and I think he will agree that the results obtained in County Louth compare very favourably with those obtained in any other county in Éire. I would like to impress upon the Minister the two matters to which I have referred, namely the supply of coal and kerosene. If he could afford to give a little extra oil to the farmers who have to look after large numbers of stock during the winter months, it would be a great boon.

We have occupied a long time on this Estimate but it is a very important one and every member is supposed to say something. I did not wish to waste the time of the House, because most of the things I have mentioned have already been mentioned. But the time we have spent on this Estimate falls very far short of the time that used to be wasted by the members of the present Government when they were in Opposition. I remember their wasting a fortnight or three weeks on the smallest Estimate. I remember Deputies on the opposite benches wasting weeks and weeks in their eloquence telling the late Government how they could run this country and solve the unemployment problem. It never was as bad as it is to-day. The Taoiseach, in his innocence, when he was in Opposition, said that the land of this country could feed 9,000,000 people. Of course, he has learned sense since. He has solved the problem by sending the people to England and to America, if they could get to it. For the one who goes, ten would go if they had the facilities and would be glad to go.

I hope the Minister will consider the suggestions that have been made. For our part, it is our bounden duty to do what we can to assist him in seeing to it that sufficient wheat, oats, barley, potatoes and other crops will be grown during the coming year.

Comment on this

I have no desire to prolong this debate, but conscientiously I feel bound on behalf of my constituents in County Roscommon to put their views once again before the Minister, and to say that I am directed by them to protest against the bungling of the Minister for Agriculture and his Department, as well as the Cabinet who are responsible for putting up with such bungling, during the Minister's term of office. I think that every member of the Cabinet should be held accountable, and must bear his fair share of the responsibility for the bungling which has taken place. I entirely agree with the statement of Deputy Corry that we are not getting a fair return for the money spent in premiums and on special-term bulls. When I give some particulars as to what I am personally aware took place in my parish and county, I think there are few Deputies but will agree that it is little wonder that the production of milk and butter has decreased. I also feel sure that Deputies will be convinced that Deputy Corry was right in his statement.

Some four or five years ago the county committee of agriculture in Roscommon, working in conjunction with the Department and under the instructions of the Department, made an effort to increase the milk supply. They went around to bull-keepers in the area, including myself. I was asked if I would co-operate with them in this object. I thought the object a very worthy one, and I promised a very personal friend of mine on the county committee of agriculture, and a member of the Department's staff who accompanied him, that I would co-operate wholeheartedly. I put in for a premium and got it, but it was cancelled a week after I got it. I was not very worried about that, because, as I say, it was at the instance of the Department official and this particular member of the county committee that I applied at all. Later on they came and asked me to take a special-term bull, and I agreed. This special-term animal came along, and I was so anxious to do everything possible, in accordance with their wishes, to increase the supply of milk in my district and county that I got posters printed at my own expense. I also circularised people living in the area, and sent them the pedigree of the animal that I had received from the Department of Agriculture, all of which was printed at my own expense. This met with a very favourable response. Some 30 cows visited my place in a period of one month. To my amazement, one day when I was grooming the animal I looked at his earmark and found that it was not the animal I should have got at all. I reported the matter to the local inspector, who communicated with the Minister or his Department.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it permissible for a steward to report something that happened on his own farm in a debate on an Estimate? It appears that there is a dispute between this particular farmer— not the Deputy, because I am taking it that he is really speaking in the second person, though he spoke in the first person—and the Department. He has reported something that he should put down in black and white and which is not the concern of the House.

Comment on this

Has he not a perfect right to state his own case?

Comment on this

I am speaking with regard to a matter involving public funds and as a Deputy I claim——

Comment on this

The Deputy is accusing somebody in the Department who is not here to defend himself. He says that somebody brought him down an animal and that he examined its earmark, and he is now making a charge which the Minister must take notice of. But whoever sent him down that particular beast is not here to defend himself.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The bull came from the Department and the Minister is responsible.

Comment on this

Of course the Minister is responsible.

Comment on this

I can assure Deputy MacEoin that the Minister and the Department are already aware of the facts, and anything I say here or that I have said in regard to this matter I am prepared to stand over and prove. The Department's inspector visited the place and reported the matter to the Department and told me he would let me know the result in a few days. In a fortnight's time he came along and presented me with their record of the bull that was sent out to me and asked me to sign it. I pointed out to him that I had already humiliated myself by admitting to people, including no less a personage than his Lordship the Bishop of Achonry, that I had sent out a circular with regard to another animal, and that I had publicly to notify them and apologise to them. I told him that I would have nothing further to do with the animal, that I looked upon it as a trespasser, and that he should have it removed. The animal was removed and from that day to this I have never received a penny compensation for the upkeep of that animal during the period it was in my possession. There are other matters I could speak of with regard to that, but these are the mere facts. All I have to say is that it so disgusted me that it brought to an end a record of 90 years' bull-keeping on that farm, and that, irrespective of what I am to receive by way of premium, I would have nothing further to do with a premium or special-term animal, as the present Ministry or those responsible for doing that had not even the courtesy to apologise for what they had done.

But that is not all. In 1936, a neighbour of mine went to Carrick-on-Shannon show and sale which was held under the patronage of the Department of Agriculture and subsidised by the county committees of agriculture, including the Roscommon committee to the extent of £20. Two inspectors were present. The champion bull of the show and sale was awarded the championship. He was bought by my friend, but he was not awarded a premium and, when the Department was asked why, the reply was that he was suffering from genital defects. They were quite justified in rejecting him for a premium, but I say here that they had no right to pass him as a licensed bull.

We have also a case of another farmer in the district, who paid £130 for an animal which was boosted up on the papers and was sold in a very short time as baby-beef, as being unfruitful, for something like £15 or £16. I understand that the purchaser of that animal was not at a loss, due, probably, to the insurance company, but I would like to know what loss the district suffered. Under those circumstances, I think I am quite justified in my remarks, in saying and feeling as Deputy Corry has felt—that there is not a return for money spent in this direction.

Further bungling in regard to bulls has happened this year and I allege that even political bias has been in vogue in the matter. A friend of mine— not a relative—applied for a premium bull. He was granted the premium by the county committee, sanctioned by the Department and got his voucher to attend the show and sale. When he was 20 minutes or half an hour on the train, on his journey to Dublin, he got a wire from the Department that the premium was cancelled. He was allowed to spend one day travelling, the night in Dublin, and the next day going back. He got some expenses, but I think these are matters that require the very serious consideration of the Minister and that, before we vote public funds, we have a right to point out abuses, if they have taken place, and to ask the Minister that more care be exercised in future.

I do not agree with everything Deputy Dillon said yesterday, but I agree with a good deal of it. I agree with the committee that he suggests —a county food committee—provided that it is an impartial, non-political committee. I also suggest that such a committee, or even a national committee of the members of the Dáil, could be elected on such a basis. The people have voted quite recently in the general election and, if all of us who have been elected are really sincere, it should be our duty not to throw Party gibes but to accept the will of the people and work for the common welfare of the country during this emergency. I suggest that this national committee or Dáil committee be elected on proportional representation, on the basis of the strength of all the Parties in the Dáil, that nominees be extracted from each Party to co-operate and meet, if necessary, to oversee the reports of the county food committee.

The reason I do not like county committees or officials to be appointed is that, from information on those things, I am afraid that the Government would use the whip for political purposes. My reason for saying so is that, when six or seven tractors were allocated to County Roscommon recently, the chief executive officer of the Roscommon County Committee openly admitted that he was instructed to give no information, notwithstanding the fact that we were told by An Taoiseach a couple of years ago, in a public statement, that the county committees of agriculture were to discharge the administration of agricultural affairs in their counties.

We have an instance, I understand, of a merchant in Roscommon. No doubt, to be fair to the Minister for Agriculture, he has said that the Department did not interfere in any way but, however, the bald fact remains that people came from the end of the county to purchase the machines, or, at least, the tractors came through this one merchant. I am also informed that he received one himself; two ex-employees of his, I understand, got one; and I am also informed that a brother-in-law of his got one. Three of those tractors have been placed within a radius of about four miles, in a circle of at least six or seven miles——

Comment on this

They would be able to cut it all.

Comment on this

——whilst in another part of the country no tractor has been placed. All I have to say is that to my mind and to the minds of a good many people, the allocation of those tractors was disgraceful.

If I am not mistaken, I heard the Minister for Lands yesterday saying that 20,000 acres had been bought and allocated during the last 12 months. I would like to know the reason why two farms in Southpark, near Castlerea, purchased, I understand, five or six years, have not been allocated for the provision of food.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the Minister for Lands.

Comment on this

I just wanted to point out that, if they were given to the tenants around, it would help very much in the way of food production. We have also another case of a young man, anxious to co-operate in the food production scheme last year, notwithstanding the fact that a great many of the Fianna Fáil Party want to blacken our county as being bad farmers and not anxious to till or do their duty. I refer to a young man, with three acres of land, adjoining the Brooklawn farm. When he went to the Land Commission to ask for a half-acre of conacre, he was informed by the Department that a certain amount of the Brooklawn farm was set in conacre, but that if any other division was to be made, the local Fianna Fáil club would be aware of it. In other words, they told him politely, in effect, to go down and join the local Fianna Fáil club, and thus he would be able to get the letting of the conacre. I think that, in the case of Roscommon, at least, when it comes to such matters, we should draw lots, because I am sure the Government are aware that at the present time they cannot claim a majority in that county.

Comment on this

Well, they hope to get a majority there, and I suppose the end justifies the means.

Comment on this

We hear of farmers being in want of clothing and boots, and I should like to draw the attention of the House to the fact that when, three or four years ago, the Bishops of Ireland were asked to urge their people to make economies, the Bishop of Achonry endeavoured to do so, but his people failed to respond until his administrator called a public meeting in Ballaghaderreen to deal with these matters. The things that his Lordship the Bishop of Achonry asked to be put in force were: first, that a sufficient supply of milk should be provided for the poor generally, and, secondly, that second-hand clothing should be let in duty free to this country for the benefit of the poorer farmers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with this Estimate, Deputy.

Comment on this

I bow to your ruling, Sir, but as the matter of clothing for agricultural workers was raised yesterday, I am only putting the suggestion to the Minister for Agriculture so that he might convey it to the proper quarter. There is one burning question in our county, and that is the question of the making of bog roads and of drainage, and I imagine that that would have a bearing on many other parts of the country also. Of course, I suppose I shall be told again that such matters do not exactly come under the Minister's Estimate.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They do not come in at all.

Comment on this

Well, Sir, if I do not mistake, I think that when the Minister was going through the various items in his Estimate he referred to rural relief schemes and said that a certain amount of money was being made available for them.

Comment on this

Not under this Estimate.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not under this.

Comment on this

Well, may I point out to the Minister, in passing, that if these bog roads——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies must accept the ruling of the Chair when they are informed that certain matters are not in order.

Comment on this

Very good, Sir, I bow to your ruling. Again, let us come to the question of bacon. According to my information, the highest price paid to farmers has been £8 a cwt. for the best pigs, and for sows £6 a cwt., and I see where the bacon curers have asked for higher prices. I should like to point out that, with rashers at 2/6 or 3/- a lb., that would amount to about £14 or £17 a cwt., plus the value of the offals, and since the bacon curers have amassed fortunes at the expense of the farmers and of the consumers in the past few years, I think that serious consideration should be given to this matter before their demands for increased prices are granted. The price to the farmer is £8 a cwt. for the best pigs and £6 a cwt. for sows, but we find, when we go into the shops or factories, that the bacon is not marked as sow bacon or otherwise, or that sow bacon is sold at a reduced price.

In my opinion nothing would give the farmers and the general public so much satisfaction as to know that the Bacon Board had been put out of action entirely, and all that the farmers and the consuming public wish to convey to the Minister is their sincere desire that that board will be put out of action immediately.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon, I think, expressed some little sympathy with them, and suggested that they ought to get pensions. I think that it is jail they should get. I see that a fine of £500 is to be enforced in the case of illicit bacon curers who are caught. I think that it is the members of the Bacon Commission on whom that fine should he enforced, because they are the people who are responsible for the evil. Again, I disagree with Deputy Dillon when he talks about rich farmers. He may be talking about farmers in County Monaghan, for all I know, but so far as the farmers in my own county are concerned, most of them are hard-working and honest, and men who try to pay their bills to the best of their ability. I am sure that Deputy Dillon is aware that a great deal of that money comes from England. As a matter of fact, during the last fortnight or the last month, I should say that no fewer than 50 farmers have come to me asking me to recommend them for passports to enable them to emigrate to England. I am personally aware that, during the last week, two farmers from my own area, who had spent some years in America and who had come home and settled down and are now fathers of families, with children aged from five to ten, had to flee from this country because they could not make a living here, and yet we are told that we farmers are a lazy lot.

These are only a few examples of the conditions of the people around Ballaghaderreen and in the West of Ireland generally. These people have worked from dawn to dark in the springtime in order to produce food for our people. They have been the mainstay of the nation, and when they have their crops gathered, instead of being able to take a holiday at the seaside, they get their tickets to England to spend more of their sweat working over there in order to provide food for their own wives and children. I think it was a rather strange comment that the Minister made here about a year ago, to the effect that people going to work in England, and sending paper money over here to buy commodities that could not be replaced, were doing a great injury to the country. All I can say is that it is heartrending, when travelling through the West, to see fathers and mothers taking leave of their children. You can see that almost every day at Ballaghaderreen and all through County Mayo.

I do not intend to prolong the debate further than to say sincerely that if a fair and square deal is given to the farmers we shall do everything possible to produce the necessary foodstuffs. I think that everybody connected with the administration of this scheme should cease browbeating. Let the Minister for Agriculture, his officials and public servants generally, give effect to the boasted Christian Constitution that An Taoiseach is so proud of, which guarantees justice, fair play and equal treatment to every citizen. It is not too much to ask that officials and public servants should not be actuated by political bitterness in the discharge of their public duties. Let us take the advice of an impartial national food production committee and forget about coercion, because I think every Irishman will agree that coercion is very repugnant to the sons and daughters of the soil no matter whether it comes from a native or a foreign Government. I ask the Minister for Agriculture to use his influence with the Executive Council to have byroads constructed to farmers' places and to have the flooded lands drained so that they may be made capable of producing food. In short, if you give a square deal to the sons and daughters of the soil they will rise to even greater heights for the sake of God and country to feed and save the nation.

There is only just one other matter to which I wish to refer. When Deputy O'Driscoll was speaking, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney asked the Ceann Comhairle to take note of the fact that only two members of this Party were present. I would like, you, Sir, and Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney to note that in less than five minutes afterwards, when his own colleague got up to speak, only two members of the Fine Gael Party remained to listen and that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney himself left immediately afterwards.

Comment on this

There are about three points that I wish to put to the Minister, but before doing so I should like to draw your attention, Sir, to the fact that it is not customary in this House to attack a civil servant on a personal matter, and that if a Deputy has a charge to make against a civil servant of which the Attorney-General would take notice, he should make it before he comes into this House and not under the privilege of the House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair did not hear any attack on any civil servant, or would immediately have intervened.

Comment on this

Is it not perfectly in order for a Deputy of this House to draw the attention of the Minister to the general incompetence of his Department in any given particular?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Quite, but individual civil servants should not be singled out.

Comment on this

Or named. Certainly.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Or be so referred to as to be identifiable. A Deputy may refer to alleged maladministration, but must put the responsibility on the Minister.

Comment on this

When a Deputy names a case in which he is personally involved, and of which, therefore, he has first-hand knowledge, it is within his competence to give that information direct to the Minister or to inform the proper authorities at that particular time but he should not, in my opinion, make a charge in this House that he would not dare to make outside.

Comment on this

The charge was made on every platform in County Roscommon.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon will allow me to make my point and he can make any protest he wishes on a point of order, afterwards.

Comment on this

As I am repeatedly doing.

Comment on this

I shall make my case to the Chair as I think it should be made.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy MacEoin.

Comment on this

I would not have intervened in this particular manner were it not for the fact that part of my constituency is in County Roscommon and I have a certain responsibility for it. Deputy Meighan might argue that I was not discharging that responsibility as well as I should, but I think I shall be able to discharge my responsibility towards that part of the county just as well as he has done because I think he has not served a very useful purpose or served the interests of agriculture in that particular area by referring to this matter.

Speaking for the County Longford, portion of Westmeath and portion of Roscommon, I do not subscribe to the view that wheat can be grown upon all parts of every farm. I think that some discretion must be left, either to the agricultural instructor or the inspector of tillage, whoever he may be, to say exactly on what land wheat should be grown because on some land you could put in the best seed wheat available and you would not get even a return of the seed. That would represent a loss rather than a gain.

If you take County Leitrim or North Longford, for instance, there are patches of land there of which the statement made by Deputy Corry yesterday would not be true, namely, that if there was a root crop taken off it prior to its being sown with wheat you would have a chance of getting a good crop of wheat. That would not apply to every portion of land front which a root crop has been taken. The point I want to put to the Minister is that there should be some system of selectivity or some method of appeal and the matter is now one of urgency as the time is very short. There should be some discretion left to the inspector in charge of the area or to the agricultural instructor. A farmer who is in doubt may say to the instructor: "I cannot sow wheat there. I could get a good crop of oats from it but I will not get the seed wheat out of it if I put in winter wheat, and if I put in spring wheat I might have a very poor result." The inspector or the agricultural instructor will know whether that is true, or at least he should know because he is trained. I think a discretionary power should be left in their hands in dealing with what are known as the light soil areas, and I include in the light soil areas, portion of Roscommon, nearly all County Leitrim, most of North Longford and part of County Westmeath. If you attempt to sow wheat on every farm in these areas your efforts will be futile. I do not wish to put it any further than that but the Minister should take care that the objective he has in view will be attained. You could lose thousands of barrels of wheat in seed for which you would have no return, and that would be even a greater loss at this particular stage than the non-sowing of it.

The next point relates to machinery. There are people in the country, small firms—if you like, you might not call them firms—who have welding plants of one type or another and these are used for agricultural purposes. Where the Minister gives a certificate that these machines are used for the welding and the repair of machinery, he should insist that the Department of Supplies will make the necessary arrangements for transport, whether by petrol or paraffin or whatever method may be used. It is a very great hardship upon a farmer when he is ploughing if some part of the machine breaks. It may be a good day and if he has to go a distance to get the repairs carried out there is valuable time lost. The main object we all have in view is the production of more food and the safeguarding of our food supplies. Every little effort that helps in that direction must be made. The Minister and the Department of Supplies should accept whatever information can be sent to them by people upon whom they can rely.

It is a well-known fact that Fianna Fáil, at a certain point, said that the wheat acreage in this country had increased. Everybody knew there was some increase, but that it had not reached the point indicated by the Fianna Fáil propagandist. The next year the same thing was said. I think if there was a complete analysis made as to the efforts of the farmers this year, it would be found that there are not many acres of wheat loss sown and harvested this year than in other years. What has really happened is that the Fianna Fáil trick of "more wheat" has been found out. It was the simplest thing in the world lor a farmer to tell a Civic Guard he had nine acres of wheat this year, because Fianna Fáil wanted it. That report was duly sent in. It was only when the pressure came down and a report had to be made by the farmer that the exact acreage—and I do not know that it is too exact even yet—was found out. What happened was that the propagandist of Fianna Fáil was found out. The Party made a great success of it; the Fianna Fáil propaganda was the best. Deputy Dillon said that the Taoiseach was the astutest politician in Europe. He may be, but the Fianna Fáil propagandists are ten times more astute than ever he was.

I have travelled the country from Donegal to Cork and Dublin to Galway and I have seen the fields growing wheat and I believe there is more this year, but there is this danger, that although you have a slightly higher acreage and next year you are going to have a greater acreage, you may have a lower produce. That is the danger that must be guarded against. As you want wheat you must sow only wheat and sow it in the land able to produce it well. No farmer will sow wheat when he knows in his heart he is going to get only three or four barrels to the acre, or even five. He will not sow it when he knows that he can get 17, 18 or 20 barrels of oats to the acre. The man would be mad if he did that because he would be taking from this country the food he can produce.

I want to remind the House of two things. Oats has been a more staple food in this country than ever wheat was. Oats and oatmeal, and oatmeal bread have formed the staple food of the armies of 1641 and 1798. Men marched from Killala to Ballinamuck in 1798 on oatmeal and buttermilk, and in 1641 they used the same food. If there is a food crisis in this country, while wheat may be a grand food I suggest that you cannot beat the oatmeal and the drop of buttermilk. The best food in this country is to be had in good milk and good oats. If you have them you arc in a perfectly sound position, because you can fight on that diet for any distance.

I suggest to the Minister that in the Midlands and in the North and South, where danger is likely to arise, if there is a good supply of oats in these districts and a good supply of milk then when the emergency arises the people may not have, perhaps, a dainty wheaten cake, but they will have a good farley of brown bread that any man could live and fight on and, I suppose, we could die on it, too.

Comment on this

I cannot say that, in the course of this debate, I have been overburdened with suggestions. The debate has lasted for three days and, although I took notes of all the points that were made, I do not think I will have very many ideas to carry back with me to the Department. Some speakers suggested that when I was introducing my Estimate I did not refer to certain things. That may be, but that does not mean, as seemed to be inferred, that I was not interested in these matters or that I considered them of no great importance. When I was introducing this Estimate I spoke for almost 1½ hours and, if I were to cover every activity of the Department of Agriculture, the debate over the last three days will give some idea of how long it would take me. I had to omit some things and I may omit some things now, but, again, that does not mean that the things I omit are of no importance or that I am not interested in them.

There is one thing I think we may conclude from this debate and that is that every Party is united on the major policy during this emergency. Every speaker who referred to it said that he agreed with compulsory tillage. There may have been small differences of opinion as to whether it should be 25 per cent., 27½ per cent. or should remain at 33½ per cent. or go to 37½ per cent. These were only minor differences of opinion but they were raised as big objections. I was rather surprised to hear speakers from every Party agree that compulsory wheat-growing is necessary. In fact, the criticism from Fine Gael. Clann na Talmhan and from Labour was that it had come too late; that it should have been done in 1940 instead of this year. We had agreement on that. Every Party also agreed that we should have a guaranteed price on a remunerative basis for essential food. We had agreement on all big matters. There was also agreement that the Government should do everything possible to help farmers during these difficult times in the way of getting fertilisers, proper seeds, machinery, fuel oil, binder twine and so on, and as far as we could, to see that there was labour available. Although we agreed on the big principle, we took three days to talk about small things. We only differ on small details after all. There was a lot of talk about bacon and eggs and listening to some speakers from Clann na Talmhan, and from Fine Gael one would imagine that if the Pigs and Bacon Commission was not there, we would have 1,000,000 pigs now. I should have included Deputy Dillon, who has come into the House, with the others, but it was a case of out of sight out of mind.

Comment on this

The Minister should have said: "Talk of an angel and he will appear."

Comment on this

Some speakers drew attention to the fact that we could not get enough potatoes for human consumption last year. I think the figures were given by the Minister for Supplies some time ago. I take it that they were correct. I am sure he went to trouble to get them. It appears from the figures that we require 600,000 tons of potatoes for human consumption. Our production of potatoes last year was 3,000,000 tons. There was the shortage that we heard of in May. The total shortage was 4,000 tons out of 600,000 tons. There was a slight shortage of potatoes for human consumption. We also know that there was a slight shortage of oats for human consumption, yet we had speakers getting up in this House, people who are supposed to be responsible men, in the Fine Gael Party, in the Farmers' Party and on the Independent Benches, Deputy Dillon, for instance, and telling us that but for the Pigs and Bacon Commission we would have plenty of pigs. What would we feed them on? Were we to take more potatoes away from Dublin to feed them? Were we to take more oats from the oatmeal millers to feed them? What were we to feed them on? Every Deputy from these three Parties who spoke claimed to represent fanners, with the exception of Deputy Larkin. I am sure that no farmer would tell me that he had plenty of oats, barley, and potatoes at home, but that he had no pigs to give them to. Where then was the feeding for pigs to come from?

What is the use of blaming the Pigs and Bacon Commission for having no pigs when there is no foundation for doing so? The Pigs and Bacon Commission may have made mistakes, they may have done wrong things and may have made it difficult for farmers to market their pigs. I do not think they did. It may be held some day that they did, but for goodness sake, if we are to get things going, and if we are to have production on proper lines, let us try to get facts and not act on prejudices, as Deputy Dillon did when he said that the Pigs and Bacon Commission is responsible for everything that has occurred. Would members of Clann na Talmhan believe that when the framework of the Commission was going through, and when I was putting the Bill to set up the commission through the Dáil I had no greater supporter in this House than Deputy Dillon?

Deputies can read his speeches if they doubt my word. It is true that when the amending Bill came along, Deputies opposite wanted to get rid of a certain man on the board. That was all. As a matter of fact, the amendment they proposed was that I should take control instead of the commission, but that control should remain. Would these Deputies believe that the Party opposite, including Deputy Dillon, who was then in that Party, supported all that legislation for the control of pigs and bacon? One would imagine that they considered all along that that was wrong.

I often stated in this House that I never knew better prophets than Fine Gael when a thing is known. When the facts are known, post factum, they are the best prophets in this country. Deputy Dillon stated that the Government was always wrong, and that he was always right. Deputies do not know Deputy Dillon. The Deputy is sometimes amusing when he does not mean to be. When he is most emphatic, his case is weakest. Deputies will get to know that. I do not want to deal further with it now. Everybody must admit that we cannot have more pigs unless we grow more feeding. We cannot import feeding. We were importing 500,000 tons of feeding-stuffs before the war. Deputies should know what 500,000 tons of feeding-stuffs represent. To put it in round figures, it means probably 1,000,000 pigs. That 500,000 tons of feeding-stuffs are not coming in now. To some extent we have replaced that 500,000 tons by growing more oats, more barley, and more potatoes, but they are not by any means fully replaced, and pigs had to go because we had no food for them. We could have adopted a different policy at the beginning of the war if we thought bacon was essential. We could have then said to farmers: “Grow more oats and barley, but leave wheat as it is.” At the beginning of the war we made up our minds that we must get bread. We did not know the day imports might stop. We do not know now. As we did not know then, we said that the only sensible thing for the country to do was to grow more wheat as quickly as possible.

We were blamed by some speakers for always stressing wheat. Why? Because it means bread, which is the most essential food of all. We will always stress wheat until we get enough grown. But we did not stress it to the exclusion of everything else. I defy any Deputy to produce any speech I ever made before the county committees of agriculture while going around the country during the last three or four years, asking them to produce more food, in which I devoted myself exclusively to wheat. I always mentioned potatoes. I always stressed the fact that when farmers have given us the wheat we required, they should then look after the live stock by growing more oats, more barley and more potatoes, including, of course, more potatoes for human food. When we considered the matter at the beginning of the war we thought that a time might come in our history when we might have to make it illegal for pigs to be kept, if they were going to compete with human needs. The same applies to poultry. If we were to be up against the position of not being able to got wheat for the people, and not able to get bread, or if there was an inclination to feed pigs and poultry instead of human beings, what could the Government do except to cut out pigs and poultry so that the people would get enough bread ?

It is all very fine to make generalisations and for people to make attacks on the Government when it considers it necessary to get all the wheat it can for bread. It was necessary to stress the growing of wheat all the time. We had to do it. Anybody who considers the matter knows that we got a very good acreage of wheat, more perhaps than many people thought we could ever grow here. Many people thought we could never reach anything like 500,000 acres of wheat in this country.

It is very interesting to hear the people on the opposite side saying now that it is all right to grow wheat in war-time but that you should not grow it in peace-time. For amusement, I suggest the reading of their speeches away back in 1928 and 1930 when they said that wheat could not be grown because we had not the soil or the climate to grow it. They told us that the weeds would choke it and that the crows would take it. But there are no weeds now in war-time to choke it, and no crows to take it. Is the soil all right in war-time, and is the climate all right in war-time? These were the arguments they had against wheat-growing eight or ten years ago. We had to get over that prejudice and try to persuade the farmers of this country —in spite of what they were being told by Fine Gael when Fine Gael was the Government and when the farmers were looking to Fine Gael for a lead —that wheat could be grown. A lot of them did not believe us, and that is why a compulsory measure is necessary.

Let us at any rate get down to a proper basis and recognise the fact that we cannot have more pigs here unless we have feeding. We cannot have more poultry unless we have feeding. There is no further feeding, however, for them. It cannot be got unless we grow it. If we grow more oats, barley and more potatoes next year, in addition to the acreage under wheat that we expect, then we can have more pigs and more poultry.

What discouragement is there? I heard a Deputy this evening saying that the people would not produce pigs any more, and yet in the same speech he spoke of small pigs going to £5 and £6 apiece. Surely to goodness that is encouragement for any man to breed pigs. If a man can sell small pigs at £5 or £6 apiece that should be an encouragement to him to breed pigs if he can feed them. But there is the crux—can he feed them, and that is what is going to decide the number of pigs we can have in this country.

As regards the shortages that were referred to, as I told you we were short 4,000 tons of potatoes last May out of 600,000 tons in the country. There were bread queues referred to. The strange thing is this, that bread queues were there in the spring of 1942. There was no restriction in the same months of 1943. There was no restriction on the amount of flour that we released from the flour mills, and the flour mills actually released less in 1943 than they did in 1942 when the bread queues were there. That may give you some explanation of the fact why the Government—Deputy O'Sullivan put this point to me and rightly so, being Lord Mayor of Dublin—took no measures to prevent this potato shortage. If the Government had—I am quite sure of this—issued a warning two months previously, in February, that a potato shortage was likely, I am quite sure the potato shortage would have come much more quickly than it did. I have no experience of other countries, but I am quite sure that if we were to issue a warning that a shortage was likely in a certain commodity, the shortage would come very much quicker than it otherwise would, and you all know why: because the people who can afford it will begin to lay up stores, and the people who can afford to do so will, perhaps, hold on to stuff expecting a rise in price, so that a free exchange does not take place, as it will take place when people are under the impression that there is plenty of a commodity there.

There was talk about a labour shortage, and suggestions were made, I think, that the Government should do everything possible to help farmers in this emergency. But we are being asked to do too much. Deputy Hughes and Deputy Fagan made the suggestion that there should be labour available at the other end of the 'phone. These were the words that both Deputies used. How can that be done? Deputy Hughes, I am quite sure, does not need labour on his farm.

Comment on this

I found it difficult for the first time this year.

Comment on this

Perhaps a little difficult. The reason why Deputy Hughes does not need labour on his farm is because he farms properly. He does mixed farming. He is not like the farmer that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney spoke of who sowed a crop of wheat and paid labour for the sowing of it. He then closed the gate and wanted no more labour until the harvest time. We do not want that class of farmer. We want the farmer who will do proper mixed farming, and the man who does that has work for his men the whole year round.

I know that in a bad harvest like this, when there are so many wet days, any farmer would be glad to get extra labour on a fine day, but we should not have to cater to such an extent that the 360,000 farmers in this country should have a pool of labour at the other end of the telephone when the fine day comes. Is it not obvious that it could not be done? If you have a wet week and the same fine day comes all over the country, how are you going to supply labour to one-tenth of those farmers—to 36,000 farmers? How could you do it unless you have 250,000 men at the other end of the telephone, and that cannot be done. The mixed farmer might possibly like to get them, but he can get on without them.

I agree with Deputy Harris that the good farmer, who is carrying on farming on the proper lines, succeeds in saving his crops whether the year is good or bad, and he will always save them because, if you like, he knows more about it than the other man. Perhaps we cannot blame the new tillage farmer too much if he does not know the game as well as he should, but we cannot guarantee the new tillage farmer even that the Army is at his disposal. It would be a very dangerous thing to do.

I ask any Deputy to imagine himself in my place. Would he take the risk, I wonder, of making an announcement now that the Army would be at the disposal of the farmers next year? Deputies must know well that we must put the onus on the farmers themselves to provide their own labour. We did, as a matter of fact, try to make it easy, in the vicinity of camps, to see that farmers could get help from the Army, but it cannot be done all over the country, and it cannot be promised even in the vicinity of these camps. We will do our best, but every farmer must naturally look after himself and see that he solves his own labour difficulty. It is not fair either for the farmer who is doing cereal tillage and not doing any roots and not employing men the whole year round: it is hardly fair for any farmer, or anybody else, to expect that he could have labour at his disposal when he wants it for six or eight weeks, and then let somebody else look after those men for the rest of the year. After all, he should make some attempt to see that men are kept the whole year round. That was one of the reasons why the Farm Improvements Scheme was brought in—to give farmers an opportunity of improving their land and maintaining their men during the winter months, if they found it hard to maintain them in other ways.

Comment on this

Why did you restrict it to small valuations?

Comment on this

We restricted it for a commencement but that is not the case now. There was a great deal of discussion hero about farm wages. Everybody agreed here that the farm labourer is hardly paid sufficient. We would all like to see him paid more but do not ask me to do anything about it. There is a perfect system there. I do not think anybody wants to change the system. It is all very well for Deputies on every side of the House to express their sympathy with the farm labourer. It may be a nice thing for farm labourers to read in the local Press. It may help them in time to come. That is all right. But, after all, there is no use in upsetting the whole arrangement of this country for a reason of that kind.

When the Agricultural Wages Bill was brought in, in 1936, nobody voted against it. It was an agreed measure in principle. There may have been some discussion on details, I am not sure if there was, but there is one thing I am certain of, that is, that nobody voted against the Second Reading. Members of the Labour Party have practically disowned it in their speeches here. I saw posters from them in the general election claiming that they were responsible for making me bring in the Agricultural Wages Bill. Now they repudiate it because Deputies from the Fine Gael Benches and these benches talked about the wages of the farm labourer, and, of course, naturally, the members of the Labour Party had to go a bit better. We do not want to repudiate the Agricultural Wages Bill. It is a perfect system. Everybody has to admit that. You have farmers' representatives and labourers' representatives meeting and discussing, on the one side what the farmer can afford to pay; on the other side, what the labourer can live on, and they do their best to fix a fair wage.

There is usually a fair amount of agreement on that board but, naturally, there will no be if we are going to talk about farm wages as we did here for the last two or three days, putting big ideas into their heads. Somebody mentioned £3 a week. It is only natural that representatives of the labourers on that board in arguing the point will quote the Dáil members as asking for £3 a week. Deputy Cosgrave dealt with that point very effectively when he indicated that all the males in this country engaged in agriculture had an average of £2 5s. a week last year, when our output was at its highest and, as he pointed out, the farmers have to pay rent and rates first and divide whatever is left between themselves and their labourers. That gives an indication of what they can afford to pay. We have a system for fixing farm wages. Why not leave it to that system? Why do Deputies from every side of the House appeal to me to step in and do something about it?

Deputy Cafferky made a speech, for instance, which he commenced by saying that the Minister for Agriculture should not coerce the farmers, that he should encourage and induce them. But, with an eye to the point about the farm workers, he said the Minister for Agriculture should compel the farmers to pay a better wage to their labourers. I was to allow the farmer to get whatever he wanted for wheat, oats, milk and so on. There was to be no compulsion there. That pleased the farmer. But there were others to be pleased. I was to compel the farmer to pay his agricultural labourer a good wage. That is all very nice. It may read nicely. It may sound very nice to the farmer electors and the agricultural labourers of South Mayo, but here, where we are trying to get some sort of national policy, we are not likely to succeed if we are to be tempted to appeal to every section of the community by over-bidding one another. That is what it amounts to.

From every side of the House we were asked to give higher prices for agricultural produce. I cannot understand Deputies saying that they are with the Government in this drive for food. Imagine a Deputy saying that he is with us and with the Army going out to fight the enemy and at the same time telling the soldier: "Before you go, I can tell you the Government is letting your wife starve at home." That soldier is not likely to go out with great morale. Deputies here say: "We are behind you in getting the wheat grown but we say to the farmers on the other hand that they are not getting enough for their wheat." That is not very good for the morale of the farmers. That came from the first speaker, Deputy Hughes. I am quite sure Deputy Hughes makes wheat-growing pay on his own farm. He is speaking for others. I happen to represent part of the County Carlow and I know that this year the price of conacre—on not very good land either—for the growing of wheat in South Carlow went as high as £18 an acre. The man who takes conacre to grow wheat expects to make a profit. I am not sure that he did make a profit at that price. I think it is a bit too high.

Comment on this

That does not prove anything, does it?

Comment on this

It proves that there are some foolish men in Carlow.

Comment on this

It proves that the farmer who is going to grow wheat on another man's land thinks he can pay £12 or £14 per acre and still make a profit. I do not know whether or not Deputy Hughes has first-hand knowledge of what I am saying, but I know that he says we should give the farmer 60/- a barrel. That was the price mentioned. I am very much inclined to think that if I had come before this House and said we were going to have compulsory wheat growing and that the price would remain at 50/-, Deputy Hughes and others would have asked us to make it 55/-, but, because I said the price would be 55/-, they said : "Make it 60/-."

Comment on this

And next year they will say 70/-. I told you that 12 months ago.

Comment on this

There is compulsory wheat-growing this year. I do not wish to appear to be harsh towards the farmers. I think the farmers are getting a decent price and, whatever Deputy Cogan may think about the immorality, if you like, of Ministers comparing prices with prices in England. I want to tell him that we are giving a very much better price wheat here than the English farmer is getting. The conacre price shows what a farmer is prepared to pay and what he himself thinks about wheat-growing in this country. We are going to pay 55/-. We are not going to increase that. I admit that we had to increase it one year, but in that year there was no compulsory wheat-growing; we were merely depending on price inducement. We believe, honestly, that we are giving a generous price for wheat this year in 55/- and an additional 2/6 for artificial manures, that is, if you like, 57/6. There is no use in saying that we should change that.

Let Parties do one thing or the other. Let us know where we stand. If Parties are going to support us in trying to get food for the nation, let them support us on the scheme we have outlined or not support us at all. Unless you are with us, you are against us. We do not want Deputies coming in here or to county committees of agriculture or going down the country, saying: "We support the Government in their food drive but we think they should give more for the wheat." I would prefer that they should say to us: "We do not support the food drive," or "We do support the food drive," and that is an end of it. When other Parties support a Government in a national matter of this kind, those Parties must be prepared to incur a certain amount of unpopularity, but that is the price they have to pay if they join a national campaign of this kind. They cannot have it both ways. They cannot say that they support the Government in this national crisis and at the same time say to the farmers: "We think they should give you a little bit more." Either support us or do not support us.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

A good many of your own supporters say the same thing.

Comment on this

It applies to them equally. If they want to support us, let them support us on the scheme we have laid down or let them say openly that they do not agree with the Government in their efforts to grow more food.

Deputy Cosgrave raised some points of detail with regard to this tillage Order. He says there will be more land under the plough, and asks have we considered the difficulties farmers have at present. Yes, very fully. We have considered the position that in many places farmers have gone practically to the limit that their machinery can do. They have gone in many places to the limit that the available labour will do. I know all that, but, after all, even though these farmers will have to work late at night, is not that essential if it is necessary to produce food? We must get enough food. We must do everything necessary to get enough food even if it does involve people working overtime, even if it does involve working the plough for ten to twelve hours instead of nine hours a day. It must be done. Were it not for that consideration I think we would have decided on a higher percentage of tillage, probably 40 per cent. There was another point I had in mind, which I mentioned before. Some Deputy said that we were working all the time on the assumption that the war would be over next year. We are not. We have to keep in mind that this war may last for many years. That is one of the reasons why we are keeping the tillage down to the necessary amount and nothing more because, if the war goes on for seven or eight years, with the difficulty of getting fertilisers, we must try to maintain the fertility of the land as best we can. We must not put all the land under tillage. We must keep some in reserve for the years to come.

Deputy Cosgrave also asked me if I had considered the point about excluding dairy farmers. We have. Deputy Cosgrave said the number of dairy farmers supplying milk to Dublin and all the other towns—he only pleaded for these men, not the creamery farmers—was small. Perhaps so, but Deputy Cosgrave has been in office long enough to know what administrative difficulties amount to and the administrative difficulty there would be enormous. I do not know how anybody would draw the line and decide what particular men or type of men supplying liquid milk for human consumption would be exempt and what men would not be exempt.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Are not they registered?

Comment on this

They are registered, I suppose, to a great extent. That is true. But then there are a good number supplying a small amount. There are what might be termed mixed farmers supplying milk to the City of Dublin, or some other town. There are, as you know, farmers living near villages who might be only supplying two or three pints a day. It is difficult to draw the line between all these people. In any case, as far as I can learn from reports, and so on, the hardship inflicted is not as much as at first sight would appear.

Deputy Cosgrave mentioned stud farms. Some stud farmers, as a matter of fact, are doing their tillage quota. Others are claiming exemption. Some exemption is granted. The fact that many of them are doing their tillage quota even though they are entitled to exemption shows again that if they were all as good as the best we would have no trouble with stud farms.

Deputy Cosgrave asked me did I consider that there might be bad farms not suitable for wheat-growing in the middle of the other areas. We did consider that but, again, inspection of every farm would be impossible, and the only effective way of getting the wheat we want is to say that every farmer must grow it. Admittedly, as some Deputies mentioned, there will be hardship in certain cases. We cannot help that. There are always hardships in a general rule of that kind. Where you have to require everybody to do a certain thing in the national interest, there will be some people who will suffer more hardships than others, but that cannot be helped.

Comment on this

Can you not set up a county appeal?

Comment on this

I think Deputy Dillon made the point that we should do it for next year, but not this year. This year it would be impossible.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

Our statistics are reliable.

Comment on this

Could you not consider excluding those above a certain contour, say a 600 or 700 line?

Comment on this

I will consider that, but there is one thing certain: unless the farmer knows himself from the day you make the announcement, whether he is excluded or not, it is going to be ineffective, because if he does not know on the day you make the announcement, he has a defence that he was waiting to find out whether he was inside or outside the line.

Comment on this

I think it is well worth considering.

Comment on this

Yes—there may be something in that. Deputy Cosgrave went on to speak of the output of agriculture here, which is the big point. The same point was touched upon by Deputy Dillon when he spoke of rationalisation and mechanisation of agriculture. It is a very big question. Deputy Dillon did not seek to come down on one side or the other.

Comment on this

I do not think I could come down on one side or the other either. It is a question of social values —of keeping small farms as they are, with the families as they are—or economic values—making big farms co-operative farms.

Comment on this

I came down on the side of social values, definitely.

Comment on this

I would be inclined to, too. However, whether or not we are going to holdout in this country for the years to come, I do not know. To return to Deputy Cosgrave's points, that we should try to increase output, that we should try to increase the values, and in that way try to increase the earnings of every person engaged in agriculture, that is quite right. I agree with all that. There is one point I want to make. When people talk about the flight from the land, they should remember that a certain flight from the land is necessary, and, in fact, if the output of agriculture is remaining even stationary, or increasing, a flight from the land is a good sign, because if we can have the same output from agriculture with a smaller population on the land, it means that every person engaged there is getting a better income.

Comment on this

Where do the social values come in then?

Comment on this

I say that, from the point of view of economic values, that is good, and Deputies who talk of the flight from the land are talking of the economic values, if they are flying away to get better wages and so on. Deputy Hughes mentioned a point, not a big point, to which I should like to refer. He mentioned as an indication of the want of sympathy of the Government with the farmers that the Minister for Defence ordered training for the L.D.F. during the harvest. That is not altogether correct.

Comment on this

I did not say that—I said training took place. I do not know who was responsible.

Comment on this

The training stopped on the 15th August and it stopped because the Minister for Defence was advised by my Department—we cannot order him—that we would like to have these men released for fanning operations at the very latest by the middle of August. He accepted that and arranged accordingly. It is very easy to be sarcastic—I do not say Deputy Hughes was sarcastic—about these men strutting around in uniform and so on while farmers were working hard. I do not say Deputy Hughes said that.

Comment on this

That was not my intention. Two farmers complained to me and I do not know anything more about it.

Comment on this

They were released on the 15th August anyway, which shows that the Minister for Defence was alive to the importance of allowing these men out. Another point which was made, and which has been made un the debate of this Estimate for three or four years past, was about the continuous cropping of wheat. Why do Deputies talk about this continuous cropping of wheat? I cannot understand it. We have only to grow one-tenth of the arable acreage. Any farmer who does not want to have a continuous cropping of wheat need only put the same field under wheat once in ten years. If a farmer chooses to grow wheat year after year he has no cause to complain about the continuous cropping of wheat and if the inspectors of my Department find he is doing that they will probably stop him from growing wheat year after year on the same land. We hear these stories of declining yields.

The point has been made by the Fine Gael Party that the fact that we did not grow very much wheat before 1939 enables us now to have fresh land for wheat that will give good yields. There is nothing in that. I have myself grown wheat on at least 15 per cent. of my arable land every year since 1933, and I had 11 barrels to the statute acre this year. There is nothing whatever in that. As a matter of fact, when they began to grow wheat in the Midlands they did not know a thing about it. It took them some years to know when they should cut the wheat. I do not know if they know even yet in some of these places how properly to sow and cultivate wheat; they are only learning. If it were not for the small amount of knowledge that was disseminated in these districts from 1933 to 1939 we could not have had the results we have had since 1939. There is no use in Deputies opposite trying to save themselves from what they deserve for their attitude on wheat growing before this war by making a defence of that kind. The question of soil survey was referred to by Deputy Hughes. I do not know exactly what the Deputy means. Does he mean a survey of every individual field?

Comment on this

I mean a soil classification.

Comment on this

That would mean going into every field and mapping it out, because I think the Deputy must admit that there is a variation from field to field. I know you can make a geological survey with less trouble, but it would not be of very much use to the ordinary farmer. What are we to find out? I suppose whether there is a deficiency of phosphates, potash or nitrogen, or whether the land is acid and wants lime.

Comment on this

There are other minor deficiencies.

Comment on this

I think we can take it for granted, without any survey, that in regard to 99 per cent. of the land more phosphates, more potash and more nitrogen would do it good. I do not want to belittle the importance of a survey. All I say is that the fact that we have not made a survey does not prevent us from going ahead with the proper methods of farming. I think a survey should be made and will be made. But as regards making a survey, we would have to map out every farm and on that map indicate on every field whether it is first-class, second-class, third-class and so on, and what are the deficiencies. Every field will have to get an individual place on the map and it will be a big job.

Comment on this

Has the Minister interested himself in the problem that where we have heavy straw crops and a low yield there must be a deficiency? Would it not be well to find out what it is?

Comment on this

To come to the point about lime, probably a great deal of the land wants lime. On the other hand, mistakes were made in the past by over-liming. I think Deputy Hughes said there was a considerable amount of crown rot disease in sugar beet in Carlow. That was probably due to too much lime. A mistake was made by putting on too much.

Comment on this

Not at all, lack of boron.

Comment on this

It does not occur, as a rule, unless there is too much lime.

Comment on this

There is a boron deficiency.

Comment on this

The crown rot, of course, is due to a deficiency of boron, but the blackleg——

Comment on this

The blackleg is due to an alkaline deficiency. It is too highly acid.

Comment on this

We have done everything we possibly could. We have not stinted the amount of money voted for lime.

Comment on this

Has the Minister consulted his experts on that problem?

Comment on this

I have consulted my own Department. We have not been niggardly about the amount of money voted, but in a fairly large number of counties they were not able to use the amount of money given, because they could not get the lime.

Comment on this

I admit that.

Comment on this

We are trying to get over it as best we can.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any scheme in mind for the repair of kilns?

Comment on this

We are doing the best we can. A number of Deputies referred to statements made by members of the Government, but the only one specifically mentioned was a statement made by the Taoiseach at the Ard-Fheis. Are we not becoming very thin-skinned? The farmers are not so thin-skinned: they are not going to object to what the Taoiseach said. I will quote from the Irish Independent, for fear Deputies may think I am being too kind to the Taoiseach. He said: “Now, what is going to be the result of the failure of the farmers?” Would any farmer in the country resent that? The spokesmen of the farmers resent it. If I try to convince Clann na Talmhan to vote with me on this issue and if I am told to-morrow “You failed to get Clann na Talmhan to go with you,” will I be offended? I will say that that is the fact. I failed; it was not my fault—I did my best. The Taoiseach did not say that the farmers were at fault. Let anyone read what he said. He said that it was owing to the failure of the farmers to give us the wheat. It is a simple statement of fact, and I am quite sure there is not a single farmer who saw any offence in it, though their spokesmen did.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

It is the first time the Taoiseach did not say that the Independent had misrepresented him.

Comment on this

Not very much, anyhow.

Comment on this

Deputy Fagan talked about some muddling about the assembly of binders, and said some were three weeks in coming. The binders were assembled as they came, in three centres—Dublin, Athy and Cork—and no binder was held up for more than a few days.

Comment on this

How many did we get?

Comment on this

We got 100 altogether.

Comment on this

We did not do badly at all. From whom did we get them?

Comment on this

The International Harvester Company.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister would not have the courage to say "the base, bloody and brutal British Saxon".

Comment on this

We got them through the good offices of the British Government. We paid for them, of course.

Comment on this

Did you pay for them with any particular commodity?

Comment on this

We paid for them in cash and also in exchange—both ways. Deputy Fagan also mentioned—and other Deputies quoted Deputy Fagan, which shows how a bad story can spread—the case of cows going to be canned and a whole lot of them in calf. There was not a whole lot of them in calf: some of them were, but only a small percentage. Every cow is examined by inspectors of the Department, and we get a return of the number of cows in calf. There is nothing like a wholesale slaughter of in-calf cows for canning.

Regarding flour, Deputy Dillon advocated 85 per cent. extraction, and was supported in that by other Deputies. The Government is not against that on principle, but we must have enough bread, and that is the only test we must apply. If we thought we could get enough bread in this coming year by extracting 85 per cent., we would probably do it. I hope that, in the coming year, when we get this wheat under the new scheme, we may be able to extract some of the offals and have those offals available for farmers for feeding. As well as that— and I should put this first, as it is more important—we would have the semi-white flour available for feeding people, which, according to certain medical opinion, as quoted by Deputy Dillon, is more healthy than wholemeal.

Comment on this

And you could use a certain percentage of barley flour, as I advised the Taoiseach 18 months ago.

Comment on this

We might do that, too.

Comment on this

You will do it in time, when it sinks into your brain.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donnell of Tipperary spoke of a resolution which he moved at the county committee of agriculture, and which I think would be a very praiseworthy scheme, if it could be adopted. I must say, personally—I am not speaking for the Government in this, as they have not considered it—that I hope, when we do get electric light into every house, and possibly before that, we might get the water in, too.

Comment on this

Would the electric light interfere with the water, if you put the electric light in first? There are £250,000,000 invested in foreign countries, and some of it has gone to Hong-Kong.

Comment on this

We do not mind the cost at all. Deputy Corish spoke of the export of dried milk and said my justification of this was that we were getting in exchange powdered milk for feeding to babies. I did say that, and I must say that Deputy Corish did me the honour and kindness of quoting me correctly in the House, because he quoted me during the general election as saying that I had introduced a scheme to kill all the babies in the country. Deputy Corish also doubted my figures about butter. There is one thing I am certain of: I do know exactly the amount of butter stored for the winter, because the person who stored butter, at any time during the last ten years, gets a subsidy of 10/- a cwt. to cover the storage cost.

Deputies may be sure that any trader who stored a cwt. of butter at any time during the past ten years claimed that 10/-; so we have very reliable figures. As I quoted, in introducing the Estimate, in fhe winter of 1938-39 we had 98,000 cwts. and last winter we had 164,000 cwts. I do not care how Deputy Corish doubts the consumption of butter in the country: those are the figures and nobody can deny them. We had plenty of butter, with no rationing, in the winter of 1938-39, and we had not enough to go round last winter, the only obvious explanation being that the people got more butter last winter than before the war. There is no doubt about it, there is no other explanation, and there is no use in Deputy Corish or anybody else saying that people are getting less butter.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

We are getting less in the Dáil Restaurant at the moment.

Comment on this

We may be getting less.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

A lot less.

Comment on this

People who can afford to buy butter are getting less than in 1938, but the people who could not afford to buy before the war are getting more now. The Deputy can inquire for himself, from any honest trader in the towns and cities, who will tell him, that he is selling more butter now to the working people than he used to sell three or four years ago.

Comment on this

I do not think that is true. I do not think any trader would tell you that.

Comment on this

Well, there is no doubt about my figure. It is even audited. No Deputy will tell me that a trader stored butter in 1938 and did not ask for the 10/- to which he was entitled. The accounts were audited and they show that 98,000 cwts. were stored in 1938-39 and 164,000 in 1942-43. There was no butter exported at all. We had the winter production each time as well, added to that, and that is the total consumption in this country during each winter.

Comment on this

Would it not be true to say that the people who were eating 2 lb. of margarine pre-war are eating only half a pound of butter now?

Comment on this

Yes, I have said that there was no margarine or even fats; but even then, cwt. for cwt., it would not amount to such a large quantity Deputy O'Donovan asked about the Flax Development Board and the bonus of 2/6 a stone supposed to go to the growers. I told the Deputy, in reply to a Question yesterday, that 1/6 a stone was paid direct to the growers by buyers on behalf of the British Minister of Supply. The other 1/- to which the Deputy refers was sent to the Flax Development Board and the board is financed in that way, because it is doing emergency work. It looks after the building of dams, the repairing of scutch mills, and so on, which are things that never would have been done by this Government, as it would not be necessary to have this extra acreage of flax.

Comment on this

So, large grants go to Northern Ireland firms for erecting scutch mills in Cork—large free grants.

Comment on this

Half the cost of erection.

Comment on this

I would like to compare the two schemes; they are probably very similar.

Comment on this

That seems to me to be very unfair. These fellows are not erecting the scutch mills for love of us, but because they make money out of it.

Comment on this

I would like to tell Deputy Linehan that there are prosecutions sometimes for deficiency of fats and solids in milk delivered to creameries. Now, it did not strike me at the time, but the Deputy mentioned that it is obvioubly an advantage to the farmer to put more water in his milk as a result of this.

Comment on this

That is the point I made. I was speaking of two particular cases, in connection with the Cork County Council, where the certificate said that there had been no added water. That is the point that I want to establish.

Comment on this

Yes, but I think the Deputy has said that the deficiency of fats is owing to the lack of feeding stuffs. I think it has been fairly well established that feeding stuffs have no effect on the fat content of the milk. I think it was Deputy Halliden who advocated a system by which farm labourers should own their own cottages on thir own land. That may be a very useful scheme, and I am considering it. Deputy Giles mentioned the matter of speculators in land. There was a good deal of talk about that, and about the buying up of land by speculators.

Comment on this

I think the reference was to men who merely speculate in the buying up of land in order to exploit it for the moment, and not to any question of sale between farmer and farmer or even landlord and landlord.

Comment on this

Yes, but such things would interfere with the price of the farm.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think that I stopped Deputy Giles from dealing with that matter.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir. Deputy Meighan raised a number of points about bulls in Co. Roscommon. I cannot deal with these points now, because I have not the particulars at hand at the moment, but I have information with regard to a man, who was already on the train with his bull, when the premium was cancelled. If my recollection is correct, it was not made known to the Department of Agriculture that there was already a bull within three miles of the district, and when the Department found out that that was the case, they immediately wired to the man concerned that the premium was cancelled, but unfortunately the telegram only reached him when he was getting on the train.

Another point which I shall inquire into—and if Deputy Meighan is correct in this, he certainly deserves an apology—is the suggestion that in County Roscommon, tractors and so on were distributed unfairly. My Department informs me that the company concerned, Messrs. Henry Ford & Co., were to send these machines out to the various counties on the basis of the requirements of each county from the tillage point of view.

Comment on this

Might I ask by whom were the custodians of these tractors chosen?

Comment on this

We were asked how many tractors, and so on, should be allocated to each county, and we tried to machines to the new tillage counties than to counties that were used to tillage. A good deal of these machines went to counties such as Meath and Westmeath, and to Roscommon also, but the tillage counties did not do so well.

Comment on this

How many went to Wexford?

Comment on this

I think three tractors, two ploughs and three reaper and binder machines.

Comment on this

That was not bad at all.

Comment on this

No, it was not.

Comment on this

I should have liked to have them come to Leix-Offaly.

Comment on this

Having decided on that, the county inspectors were asked to give the names of those they would recommend as most suitable, and it was pointed out that they should decide on what farmers would make the most use of these machines and would also hire them out to other farmers. Of course, the result was that, when these returns came in, there were at least three times the number of names submitted than could be supplied with the tractors or binders available.

Comment on this

Were any conditions attached?

Comment on this

Yes. Of course, there had to be such conditions as that they would not sell the machines, and that they would make the best possible use of them. I know that it is very hard to enforce such regulations, of course.

Comment on this

I know it to be a fact that where a tractor was placed at the disposal of a certain farmer, that tractor was used for other purposes than those for which it was intended, as a result of which there was no work for the binders and reapers in that particular locality. Would the Minister say whether that was fair or unfair?

Comment on this

If that is so, it certainly was unfair.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is a matter that should be reported to the Department.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Has the Minister anything further to say on this question of seed wheat?

Comment on this

Yes. I am sorry that I did not deal with the matter earlier, as I had promised to deal with it. I explained here before that we subsidised a scheme for seed wheat during the last two years: that is, we encouraged certain assemblers of seed wheat, who had drying and cleaning facilities, to overshoot the mark that we thought necessary, by giving them the difference between the selling price and the milling price. In other words, if there was a difference in the prices, we guaranteed 25 per cent. of the difference. We are doing the same this year, and I think I can reassure Deputies with regard to this matter that it will work out all right.

In many parts of the country they are getting quite good samples of seed and getting the seed itself, of course. The seed assemblers this year asked that provision might be made for 390,000 barrels. Our experience up to this year has been that 60 per cent. of the farmers have their own seed and the remaining 40 per cent. purchase seed through the merchants. 390,000 barrels are obviously too much to provide for on that basis, but in case the farmers' own seed may not be so good this year and that there may be more applications for seed, we are prepared to guarantee up to 390,000 barrels.

Comment on this

Some of the seed kept by farmers will not be in very good condition.

Comment on this

We are allowing for that. Up to last Saturday the assemblers had obtained 110,000 barrels of quite good seed, and that compares very favourably with the amount they had received this time last year. We have also asked the millers, where they get in what might be regarded as a good lot of wheat, to put it aside for a few months in case we would need more wheat for seed purposes than we shall have assembled. That is being done and I think we shall have quite good seed for the coming year.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Minister mentioned that approximately the same amount of seed is in the hands of the assemblers as at this time 12 months.

Comment on this

A little more.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Minister is not overlooking the fact, I hope, that we shall require considerably more seed next spring?

Comment on this

Sixty thousand barrels went back last spring beyond what was used.

Comment on this

Is the Minister doing anything to provide a margin between the retailers' price and the assemblers' price?

Comment on this

That is a matter which I shall have to ask the assemblers to consider.

Comment on this

When I was speaking, I suggested that £5 per ton might be paid for beet and some Deputies seemed to ridicule that idea. I just want to show the Minister how that might be done.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may ask a question, but at this juncture it is not permissible to make a statement.

Comment on this

I merely want to show the Minister how a price of £5 per ton could be fixed for beet.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may only ask a question.

Comment on this

If we were to pay 6¼d. per lb. for sugar, thaL would only mean an advance of 1½d. I would respectfully suggest——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may only ask a question. There have been already over 40 speeches and the debate may not be reopened.

Comment on this

I am simply a 'prentice hand. I want to point out to the Minister that if we pay 6¼d. per lb. for sugar——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy cannot make his point in the form of a question he must resume his seat.

Comment on this

The Minister is aware that we had a good deal of smut in barley and some other diseases last year and that we were very short of mercurial dressings. What is the position likely to be this year?

Comment on this

I think it will be good.

Comment on this

Has the Minister's attention been directed to the potato situation, or would he cause an inquiry to be made as to the nature of the black rot which, rumour has it, is widespread but which on inquiry may nob prove to be so serious? I have heard reports of it from Leix-Offaly, West Cork and Mayo.

Comment on this

We get very frequent reports on the potato crop, but unfortunately we have not got reports from all areas on the main crop as yet because it is only now coming in. On the whole, according to the reports so far received, we should have at least as good a crop as last year.

Comment on this

Is it the intention of the Minister to provide, financial assistance for farmers who may require such assistance?

Comment on this

If the Deputy were here when I was introducing the Estimate he would have heard of various schemes to assist the farmers.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to be good enough to do what lie can to see that land in the hands of the Land Commission is set at a reasonable rate.

Comment on this

Will the Minister encourage the dressing of oats and barley?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration"— put.

Tá 39
·
Níl 63
Result _

Do you agree with this result?