Committee on Finance. - Vote 32—Office of the Minister for Justice (Resumed).
Contributions 1–185 of 367. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Deputy Larkin was in possession when the House rose last night and I have no desire to usurp his position.
Comment on this
Last evening, some very nice tributes to the Minister for Justice were paid. Every member of the House will agree that the Minister makes himself the most approachable and accommodating Minister of all. Certainly he is accommodating quite a big number: that description is very right. Deputy Linehan alluded to the tramps and others known as gypsies who go round in caravans touring the country. The Irish people generally, both rural and town folks, are very friendly disposed to them but they have become a bit of a nuisance. As Deputy Linehan remarked, some 30 or 40 years ago they were quite useful citizens—tinsmiths and metal workers. I myself remember their being at that work. I can tell of a particular case where five caravans came to a town and set up near it. About eight or ten people then came along begging. The Irish people are very kind to poorer people but these beggars are a nuisance. During the day when the men are in the fields the farmer's wife or daughter is at home and these beggars make a raid on the place. They ask for a grain of tea or sugar or a bit of bacon and are never satisfied. One would not mind that so much but they hold up the lady of the house in that way and, in the meantime, the hen roost and the hay loft are raided and any loose feeding round about the house is stolen.
Deputy Linehan did not make any suggestion as to how those people should be dealt with. I do not think I can make one either but I remember picking up a copy of the Wide World magazine which showed that President Roosevelt was faced with the same problem. There were 2,000,000 people on wheels at that time apart from the hoboes or train jumpers. The article was beautifully written by a university man who had been in jail and who had been later put in charge of one of the camps. He called a halt by erecting little wooden huts at each town. Inside six months he had them all held up and interviewed them—they now had at least one friend left and he had 1,500,000 placed inside six months and the whole 2,000,000 placed inside nine months and they became very useful members of society. The hoboes and train jumpers are just dying out.
There was then the problem of the old Ford cars. In Missouri there were 2,000 of them. A man selling petrol there was very anxious to get rid of them and would give a quart of oil to get them on to the next town.
Those tramps on the roads here seem to have degenerated in the same way. They do not seem to bother very much about birth control. I saw three generations of such children; they marry very young and breed like rabbits and consumption is unknown amongst them. I remember a time when I had some five acres of potatoes to be picked and there was rain impending. I asked some of those men to come in but there was nothing doing. I heard one of the lads return from town later and his father said to him, as he had not had a successful day: "I will make you go in there and pick spuds." In the town of Cahir market day on a Friday is a gala day. I was going in on the bus on a ten-mile journey one Saturday morning. Seven of them got in and paid 9d. each to get into town. The return journey cost them 10/6. Their peregrinations around the town came to my notice. I never saw a more drunken crowd leave it. They created seenes and their language was terrible. I suggest to the Minister that the Roosevelt method might do something in the way of making such people useful citizens. With regard to those people, their horses, mules and asses grazing on the road carry on their osculations with farmers' animals. Many diseases in animals may be traced to that. Farmers consider it much better to give these people supplies of milk because otherwise they will go out at night and milk the cows. The tinsmiths and the metal workers have practically ceased to exist. These young boys and girls do not go to school and there is no earthly chance of doing anything with them.
With regard to the birching system, Mr. Parnell got birching done away with in the British Army and gained great commendation for his efforts. It is a disgrace that birching should be permitted here. I appeal to the Minister to take that power off the statute book. If the youngsters cannot be chastised except by birching them then the world must be coming to an end. It is extraordinary the number of bachelor Deputies who spoke on this Estimate. We all know that married people with no families themselves are for ever giving advice to other people as to how they should rear their children. I reared three boys myself—their mother died young —and I never laid a hand on one of them. I do not agree with the saying "spare the rod and spoil the child." When I was a youngster I got plenty of floggings from my parents, and I must say that they left a bitterness in me. I think birching is a brutal thing. The correct way to rear children is by precedent and example and birching should be done away with.
There is another matter that I approach with some trepidation. It is a matter in which I am deeply interested. I do not like being too personal, but I have a boyish memory of the Minister's father and mother. I had the Minister in my arms when he was a youngster. I would not like by word, deed or action to interfere with him. Great compliments were paid to him last evening. He is certainly a gentleman—good hearted and good natured.
Comment on this
I have a suggestion to make to him. I have a friend in the glasshouse. Owing to an attack of illness I was not able to travel to see him. He is a glorious fellow. His brothers and himself refused a pension. He is above price. I do not say that pensions are a bribe, but he is a man of the highest ideals. He has unhealed wounds on his body. I know his brothers and sisters, and his aged father who is in a low state of health at the moment. I know they would like to have this boy home, but they would not lower the flag. I do not like to go too closely into the matter of the 345 who have been released or the 200 still to be released. In the case of these men, would the Minister accept the will for the deed? I suggest to him that a friendly Deputy or two from each area might interview them. I do not think they should be asked to sign any bond. I kneel down twice a day and say "Peccavi". I wonder do I mean it?
Comment on this
Of course, I will. That goes without saying. I am anxious to throw oil on troubled waters. I think that a little heart of grace and consultation in the Cabinet might do wonders. I think that these grand fellows are in the mood now, but there is no use in trying to get them to admit that they did wrong. It would be just as well to give that a miss-in baulk, as we say in billiards. We want those men out. I believe that if they are let out they will be good citizens, and that the bulk of those who have been released have been fitting themselves in with the laws of the State. I think that the balance, if released, will do the same. One of them, the son of a neighbour of mine, is out on parole at the moment in connection with the division of an estate. As I have said, all those young fellows have fine ideals. I think the Minister should approach the situation with a little boldness. If he does, he will win out.
Comment on this
As I said before, I am approaching this subject in fear and trepidation. I am making suggestions that may help the Minister out. As a matter of fact all my folk are interested in those young fellows, and I believe they will be all right in the future if an amnesty is proclaimed. I remember as a youngster when Mr. Tom Clarke, Mr. James Egan and Mr. John Daly were released from jail. It is the loss of liberty that is killing those men. No matter how well treated a man may be in jail he feels the loss of his liberty. An All-Ireland footballer, who spent a period in jail, as a result of an accidental occurrence following a football match, assured me of that, and he was one of the grandest characters I ever met. I asked him what did he feel most—he was in Clonmel jail for 18 days—and he said he felt most the loss of liberty, the thought that he was there and could not get out. These men have expiated any wrong they have done by the time they have spent in jail, and I think the time has come when the Minister should deal with them in a broad way. I do not think he will have much cause to regret it. May God guide him in arriving at a decision and I hope we will see those people out very soon.
Comment on this
After all the very nice things that have been said about the Minister, I am rather hesitant to intervene in the debate, but I think it is only right and proper that from the Independent Benches there should come some tribute to the Minister's courage and sense of justice during his period of administration. I understand a good many complimentary remarks were passed yesterday about the Minister's administration. I want to add my quota. The mamby-pamby stuff we have listened to about extending mercy to all those people who did not extend any mercy to the policemen they shot, or attempted to shoot, is the kind of stuff that has led up to the imprisonment of a lot of these young men. We have a plea for clemency for them, but there was little or no sympathy expressed publicly in this House or outside it with the victims of those people.
It is about time we began to think that, in this House, we should have some sense of responsibility. We have not heard many people condemning the attacks on the instruments of law in this country, the armed attacks, the cowardly and brutal murders and assassinations, and there was no horror at all expressed in this House at these happenings. There were no words of condemnation expressed here about the acts of these murder gangs. The Deputies on the benches over there know that as well as I do. We have all this namby-pamby stuff, coaxing the Minister to let them out and trusting again to the leniency of the Minister. It cannot be forgotten that the Minister, in his goodness and kindness, and soft-heartedness, if you like, did release a number of the prisoners. What was the result? Some of them again conspired to undermine the institutions of the State and the result was the murder of one or two policemen here in Dublin. There was not a word from people like the members of the Farmers' Party about the widows and orphans who were left behind as a result of these murders.
I do not want to encourage the use of the birch, but I hope the Minister at some future date will look into the merits and the justice of administering the birch or the cat of nine tails to the garrotters and the robbers who attack undefended women at nighttime when they are on their way home, snatching their purses and bags and robbing them of whatever they possess. I feel that in cases of robbery with violence the only thing to strike terror into the heart of that class of ruffian would be to use the cat of nine tails or the birch. That is the proper type of punishment to inflict upon those people. I suggest that encouragement is being given to them by the type of speeches to which we have just listened.
I was asked to deal with one case a few weeks ago. The case is as follows: A young lad left Cork with the alleged intention of attending an All-Ireland Final. He went across the Channel. His people did not hear a word about it until six months afterwards, when they were informed by the British authorities that this boy had been sentenced to 20 years in jail. Subsequently the parents were informed that the boy was in a mental hospital. The boy is still there and will remain in the mental hospital during His Majesty's pleasure, possibly for 18 or 20 years. I asked the sister of that boy did she know the party or parties responsible for sending him across the Channel to throw bombs into railway stations, to put bombs into suitcases, to drop bombs into pillar boxes, thus bringing disgrace and discredit on this nation. Those things were done in the name of the I.R.A. I do not know if the I.R.A. were responsible, but those things were done in their name. We have not heard a word of condemnation of these acts in the Dáil. Instead, we have had a lot of namby-pamby stuff.
Comment on this
I know the Minister's Department is doing its best and I know, because of the type of speech I have listened to, that there is a sort of terror abroad; people do not want to give the information necessary to put those persons in their proper place. The people who sent that young boy to commit those crimes against society in England have a big responsibility. That was not a national effort, although we had a paper in Dublin talking about "our forces abroad". We read about this alleged Irish army conducting the war against Britain, but we all know in our hearts and souls that that is so much tommyrot.
Now we are told that the Minister should exercise clemency and let these people out of the jails. I have very grave doubts if the authors of the outrages in England, the real people, the forces behind the throne, have been arrested in this country. The Minister's Department should endeavour by every possible means to get at those people. By "every possible means" I mean that, if necessary, they should go outside the various Acts of Parliament, habeas corpus and the rest of it, in order to put down this sort of ruffianism. It can never be done if we have public men, and more especially members of the Dáil, telling the Minister to exercise further clemency and not treat these people as criminals— people who are exercising their brains and intellects to undermine the institutions of the State.
I take off my hat to the Minister for Justice. He was in opposition at one time and, like his associates today, he then had little sense of responsibility. The Government in office then found it necessary to pass the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, otherwise known as the Public Safety Act. Later, when the present Government were first faced with responsibility, they began to realise the responsibilities of Government and they got to know the difficulty of government in this country. Having realised that difficulty, they had to introduce even more penal legislation than the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act. It takes a whole man to say: "I was wrong once, but I am not going to be wrong a second time." That is why I salute the Minister for Justice. He has shown determination and courage. It takes a 100 per cent. man to say that he was wrong at one time when he opposed the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act and to admit that he did not know the extent of the ramifications of the organisations that were then, as well as now, trying to undermine the Government.
I salute the Minister because of his method of administration. I have the feeling that he is humane to the extent of 100 per cent. In fact, his humanity in my view went too far. I believe he has erred on the side of leniency and humanity 100 per cent. in the course of his administration. I am very glad to notice that there is no question of referring this Vote back. No matter what expense it may be, if you have not this Department administered in the one and only way you will never have peace or ordered government in this country. If you want to cultivate the best sense of citizenship and to try to check that stampede from civic sense in the country, you will have, first of all, to support the Minister in his administration of justice, and it is the only way.
Comment on this
I think it is time that this House and the people generally should understand clearly the position in regard to the right of the Government to intern citizens without trial. This House has approved of the Emergency Powers Act which gives the Minister that power. But it must be clearly understood, and I think the majority of Deputies understand, that men who are interned without trial are not being subjected to punishment for any offence which they have committed. They are being kept in custody in order that the State may be safeguarded. For that reason, the Minister should not be appealed to so much on the ground of clemency. He should be appealed to, if he is appealed to at all, to review carefully and at frequent intervals the position of each interned person, to find out whether or not that man can, with safety to the community, be released. That should be the first and most important consideration influencing the Minister's decision. To allow himself to be swayed by appeals made by Deputies or by friends of internees or by anyone else on the ground that these men are suffering severely would be betraying the trust placed in him. These men are not being interned for the purpose of inflicting any punishment upon them. They are being interned to safeguard the community, and the safety of the community should be the Minister's first consideration.
Let there be no mistake about it, internment does inflict very considerable punishment upon these men, in spite of every effort which the Minister may make to prevent it, because the first objective of the Minister must be to ensure that these men will remain in custody, that they will not escape. In order to ensure that, he must restrict their liberty to a considerable extent. He must also ensure that they cannot direct the operations of any organisation outside with which they are connected from within their prison walls and there again there must be a restriction on their means of communication with the outside world. Those things do imply a very severe hardship on the men interned and, for that reason, it is the duty of the Minister—and I think the Minister as a conscientious man realises it is his duty—to see that no man is retained in custody for one day longer than the safety of the community demands.
It is very easy to make appeals to the Minister to put those men on trial. That point was raised by Deputy Connolly and other Deputies. It is an appeal which would be popular. But I think everyone who has considered this question realises fully the difficulty of securing an impartial trial in certain cases, particularly in the case of organised crime. It was the experience of the United States when dealing with organised crime on a big scale that they could not secure convictions against the leaders in that campaign and, as a result, the State was almost brought into a condition of confusion and chaos. If the Executive Government in the United States availed of the power of internment they would probably have broken the organised opposition to the law more speedily. There is no alternative to giving the Executive Government the power to intern in certain cases, but we must ensure, as far as possible, that ample safeguards are provided to see that no real injustice is inflicted.
It may be asked: what safeguards do we suggest. I think that men who are interned are at least entitled to have their cases investigated by some form of visiting committee. I do not know if the Minister has ever considered that question. But I think there should be a committee appointed which would visit the internees, consult with these men, find out what is their attitude to life and to the law, find out whether their views in regard to the observance of the law and the duties of citizenship have changed in any way during the course of their internment. The Minister might ask how you would constitute such a committee, who would be the people to form such a committee. First of all, as internment must have a certain serious effect upon the mental and physical health of such persons, such a committee should include a highly-qualified medical man. Then, as a considerable number of the persons interned may be young and inexperienced, it is desirable that there should be also on the visiting committee some person who has been in the habit of dealing with the young, such as a teacher or a professor in one of our colleges or institutions; somebody who understands the mentality of young people and who could talk to them in language which they understand. Then, in order to ensure that there will not be political victimisation in the exercise of this power of internment, it would be desirable that on the visiting committee there should be some representatives of other political Parties besides the Government Party so as to safeguard the rights of the citizens and the rights of minority political Parties. I have said that the right of internment, so far as I can ascertain, is justifiable, but I have also indicated to the Minister that he must see that that right is exercised judiciously. He must see that it is not allowed to be prostituted into a tyranny which would seriously interfere with the rights of political minorities. The Minister is a conscientious man, and I think he will take all aspects of this question into consideration. I think he should set a headline to other Ministers who will come after him by providing certain safeguards for people who are interned. One of the safeguards which I have suggested, and which appeal very strongly to me, is a visiting committee to look into the case of each individual sympathetically and thoroughly.
The Minister has under his control one of the most important forces under the authority of the State, that is our national police force. He is charged with the duty of seeing that that force discharges its duties thoroughly and efficiently. He is charged with the duty of seeing that its members are fairly treated. I think that in the pre-war period, and particularly in the early stages of the life of our present police force, there was no very grave cause for complaint in regard to the remuneration of its members. But since the emergency, since the abnormal increase in the cost of living, and since the natural increase in the expenses of members of the force with growing families, it is the duty of the Minister to re-examine the matter of their remuneration and see that it is adequate. It is essential that members of a police force should be paid sufficient to ensure that they can maintain themselves and their families on a fairly decent standard without having to sink into debt, because nothing could be more undesirable than that members of the police force should have to seek credit from people with whom they have to deal in the enforcement of the law. I am not satisfied that the present remuneration of the members of the Gárda is adequate during this emergency, and I think there is a case for reconsideration of the matter.
Another question which arises at the present time, and which will become more important in the course of a few years, is the question of the recruitment to the Gárda. Many compliments have been paid to the existing force. Having regard to the circumstances under which the force was established, having regard to the fact that the force had to be started from scratch, and that practically the entire personnel were new men with no experience, it is extraordinary how efficiently and effectively they adjusted themselves to the maintaining of order in this country. There is no doubt that the present Gárda have set a fairly high standard for those who will come after them. At the present time the number of vacancies in the force is extremely limited, and that situation will prevail for a few years to come. After that, having regard to the fact that the entire force was recruited practically within the same year, there will be a large number of retirements. I am putting it to the Minister that he should see that during the present year and the next few years the standard of qualifications for members of the force is raised to the highest degree. If the number of vacancies is limited, and if, as I understand, the number of applicants for the force is large, it is the duty of the Minister to see that the best possible men are secured.
I want to know what exactly is the position with regard to recruitment at the present time. I understand that the Commissioner of the Gárda selects the candidates who are to sit for examination. My information is that the Commissioner selects a very limited number of candidates. If there are, say, 160 vacancies and the Commissioner selects, say, 180 or 190 candidates to sit for examination, we have the position that it is the Commissioner who is really making the selection of the members of the Gárda, and that they are not really selected by competitive examination, because the examination is confined to a very small number of candidates. If that is the position, it is altogether wrong. I hold that every candidate who fulfils the statutory qualifications for membership should be allowed to sit for examination. That is his right, and it is necessary in order to secure that the highest standard of qualifications, educational and physical, is obtained. To confine the number of candidates sitting for examination to a very small percentage of those who make application is preparing the way for favouritism on a very wide scale. I am not suggesting political favouritism, but there may be favouritism of many other kinds which would be equally undesirable. I am told that the number of candidates selected for examination is very little more than the number of vacancies. Therefore, practically all who sit for examination can get through.
Comment on this
The number of candidates selected is about twice the number of vacancies.
Comment on this
I think in the beginning the number was about 2,000, but it has gone down very much lately. There were very few the last time, but the number was about 2,000 a few years ago. There would be only about 100 vacancies at the time, and 2,000 applicants.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that you might have 2,000 applicants for 100 vacancies I do not think the Commissioner would be justified in cutting down the number sitting for examination to barely twice the number of vacancies. After the examination, I think there is a medical test, which might eliminate quite a considerable number, and it is hardly fair to cut down the number of candidates so drastically. As a matter of fact, I think there should be very little restriction on the number who come forward for examination, because you have to get the best and I understand the educational test is not very stiff.
I have a number of reasons for raising this matter. First of all, there is, as I said, the danger of favouritism— the danger of the Commissioner being pulled or dragged by individuals seeking to advance the claims of particular candidates. There is also a need during the next few years for the raising of the educational standard of members of the force. It may not be possible to do so when the number of vacancies becomes great in the course of nine or ten years, but during the next five or six years I think a real effort should be made to get into the force men of the highest educational qualifications. The Minister will realise that that is very desirable.
Another matter to which the Minister should give attention is the recruitment of a certain number of women police. So far as I can gather from the Book of Estimates, there are only two or three women police in the force at present, and I think that number should be substantially increased so far as the large cities are concerned. Women police would be more effective in dealing with various types of juvenile crime and in carrying out many of the other duties which devolve on members of the Gárda. Women, from their knowledge of their own sex and of children, would be best qualified to discharge these duties and the Minister ought to state the reason for the failure to increase the number of women police.
There is no doubt whatever that the present position in regard to crime, both major and minor, is alarming. The fact that crime has not substantially increased this year as compared with last year is no reason for complacency on the part of members of the House, in view of the fact that crime was rampant in 1942 and was very substantially in excess of crime in the pre-war period. While I consider that the position is sufficiently alarming to require the very earnest attention not only of the Minister and his Department but of members of the House, I am prepared to admit that there will always be a substantial increase in crime during war-time and allowance must be made for that fact. Nevertheless, while making due allowance for that fact, we must also take into consideration that, as emergency conditions become more difficult, there is always the danger that crime may become more rampant. For that reason, it is the duty of the Minister not to allow himself to be lulled into a sense of complacency by the fact that the crime wave has been held, so to speak, during the past year, but to take ample and adequate precautions to see that, if emergency conditions become worse, the crime position will not also become much worse.
There is no doubt that the main reasons for crime lie in the fact that people seek to obtain other people's property without going through the formality of earning it. That is, and always has been, the main motive for crime, and, when supplies are short, it is inevitable that crime should increase. At the same time, adequate precautions must be taken to protect property and life, when necessary. I have frequently suggested that the ordinary uniformed police cannot adequately deal with crimes against property, particularly at night, and that it is essential that all cities and large towns should be actively patrolled by plain-clothes men. That would make the position of the would-be criminal much more difficult than it is when he has to deal only with the uniformed man on beat duty. I have also suggested that these plain-clothes men should be provided with bicycles in order to enable them to do their patrols noiselessly and speedily and thus take would-be criminals off their guard.
Another of the undesirable tendencies which are apparent to every Deputy is the growth of crime amongst juveniles, which has been dealt with by other Deputies. There is, however, one aspect which has not been adequately stressed, that is, the growth of drinking amongst the younger generation. It is a rather peculiar thing that, for a period pre-war, drinking amongst the young had very considerably declined. It has, however, recurred on a large scale, and I believe that the facilities for drinking at dances have contributed in large measure to this undesirable increase. It has often surprised me why more attention is not given to the enforcement of the law with regard to drinking by persons under the age of 18. I know how difficult it is to enforce that law and, so far as I can gather from statistics in relation to one recent year, only one case of a person under age charged with drinking was brought into court.
It is common knowledge that drinking by persons, both boys and girls, under 18 is extremely prevalent, and I want to know what steps the Minister is taking to deal with that evil. I am one of those who hold that the age of 18, in relation to this matter, is not sufficiently high, and I am one of those who tried to have the law in that respect amended, but, at least, the law as it stands should be rigidly enforced. If the Minister takes the line that it is difficult to decide the age of persons engaged in drinking, I think it is his duty to find some means of surmounting that difficulty. I have often been inclined to think that the law in regard to drinking was somewhat lopsided. It is the consumers and not the retailers of drink who should be licensed. It is unjust to place the entire onus of finding a person's age and habitation entirely on the publican. Sooner or later, regulations must be made to assist the members of the licensed trade in carrying out the law. I would like to know if the Minister consulted the Gárdaí on that matter and if they had any suggestions to make. It is certainly a criminal thing to have young boys and girls drinking excessively, particularly at dances and such amusements.
In my constituency—Wicklow—an experiment is contemplated in regard to the attendance of young people at cinemas. In Bray it is proposed to confine picture houses with the ordinary programmes to persons over a certain age. That is a very desirable experiment and one to which the Minister should give very close attention. It is a reform which must inevitably be widely introduced. Frequent attendance at cinema shows has a very deteriorating effect on the minds of young people, and it is absolutely impossible for them to attend picture houses night after night without having their entire mental outlook completely influenced. In the majority of cases, these shows have a demoralising effect on them. Certainly, they are not of a very edifying character for young people. There is no reason why shows should not be provided at certain hours specially for young people. In this respect, I would like to see steps taken to ensure that the programmes provided for young people are sufficiently attractive to leave no desire on the part of children to attend the adult shows. I would also like to see their programmes sufficiently informative, attractive and amusing for adults. Fathers, mothers, grown-up brothers and sisters often like to attend a matinee or other show in company with younger members of the family, so the programme should give a reasonable amount of entertainment to grown-up people. That reform is long overdue and is one which should appeal to the Minister.
It is absolutely necessary to ensure, in the post-war period, that the members of the Gárda Síochána will be adequately housed, under conditions which will not impose any extra cost on themselves or on the State. In the housing schemes for Gárdaí, steps should be taken to see they are located convenient to the Gárda station, so that the men may be available always for the performance of their duty. Owing to the shortage of houses at present, some Gárdaí have to reside at a great distance from the station and this seriously interferes with the efficiency of the police force.
Comment on this
Do chuala mé caint indé ó Theachta a bhí uair amháin ina Aire Dlí agus Cirt. Chuir sé i gcuimhne dhom an sean-fhocal atá againn: "Is mó cor a chuireann an saol de." Dubhairt sé agus chuir sé i dtuisgint don Dáil nach raibh sé sásta in aon chor leis an árdú páigh a fuair na Gárdaí le linn na haimsire práinne seo. Ní cuimhin leis in aon chor, is dócha, an t-am a bhí sé féin ina Aire agus a dhein sé laghdú ar an méid a bhí ar fáil aca an uair sin. Bhí sé sin níos mó ná deich mbliana no dhá bhliain déag ó shoin.
Tá cúpla pointe agam le cur os cóir an Aire. Maidir leis an nGaeltacht, do cuireadh scéim ar bun roint bhlian ó shoin i dtaobh obair na nGárdaí do dhéanamh trí Ghaedhilge ar fad agus ba mhaith liom a fháil amach ón Aire conas tá an scéal mar gheall air anois. Bhfuil sé i bhfeidhm fós? Bhfuil na Gárdaí ag glacadh leis an scéim seo? Bhfuil na Gárdaí ag leanúint de?
Comment on this
Conas tá an scéal mar gheall air? Mara bhfuilid ag leanúint de, is truagh liom go mór é. Ba mhaith liom eolas éigin fháil ón Aire faoi sin. Más fíor an rud a dubhairt mo chó-Theachta nach bhfuil siad a leanúint de, ba mhaith liom go gcuirfí an scéim sin i bhfeidhm maidir leis an nGaeltacht. Níl aon ní is mó do chuir an Béarla i bhfeidhm sa tír seo ná dlí agus cúrsaí dlí. Níl aon ní is láidre chun cabhrú le haithbheoehaint na Gaedhilge agus buanú na Gaedhilge sa Ghaeltacht ná an scéim sin gur tosnuíodh air roint bhlian ó shoin. Scéim ana-mhaith a b'eadh í.
Tá rud eile ba mhaith liom a chur os cóir an Aire agus eolas d'fháil ina thaobh. Deineadh a lán tagairt insan díospóireacht so mar gheall ar dhaoine sna príosúin i láthair na huaire, ins na campaí. Maidir le scaoileadh na bpríosúnach, nó iad do choimeád, tá mise sásta le breithiúnas an Aire agus breithiúnas an Rialtais. Ní maith liom aoinne d'fheiscint i bpríosún nó fé smacht más féidir é sheachaint. Ba mhaith liom fháil amach ón Aire an bhfuil caoi ag na príosúnaigh sin, an fhaid atá siad i bpríosún, suim do chuir i gcúrsaí oideachais. Bhfuil caoi aca ceachta fháil ar nós na gceachta a bhí le fáil fadó, ceachta Gaedhilge? Tá a fhios agam nach féidir leis an Aire a chur d'fhiachaibh ar aoinne dul ag foghluim na Gaedhilge mara mian leis féin é. Ba mhaith liom go mór go mbeadh an chaoi sin le fáil ag na daoine ins na campaí anois.
Maidir leis an meastachán i gcoiteann, níl le rá agamsa ach go mba mhaith liom go gcuirfí an dlí i bhfeidhm go cothrom ar gach aon dream sa tír. Tá an dlí céanna againn do gach aoinne. Isé dualgas an Aire, dualgas na Roinne agus dualgas na nGárdaí an dlí do chur i bhfeidhm go cothrom agus go macánta. Ná bíodh dlí fé leith d'aon dream, dlí fé leith d'aon tigh tábhairne amháin agus dlí eile do thigh tábhairne eile. Ba cheart go mbeadh cothrom na Féinne le fáil do gach aoinne. Isé an príomhchuspóir atá os cóir an Aire ná an dlí do chur i bhfeidhm go cothrom, agus táim sásta go bhfuil an méid sin á dhéanamh ag an Aire.
Comment on this
Last night and to-day Deputies have been dealing with the administration of justice under the Minister. I was very pleased to hear so many Deputies pay glowing tributes to the Minister for the manner in which he has conducted the administration of his Department since he took over office. I even heard Deputy O'Donnell pay a tribute to the Minister such as I am sure no other Minister has ever received. He said that when the Minister was a wee boy he nursed him in his arms. It was very encouraging to hear all those nice fairy tales about the Minister in his youthful days. This House, however, is not concerned with the activities of the Minister in his youthful days, but rather with his activities as Minister for Justice and with statements that he has made in this House since he was first elected a member of Dáil Eireann. I am sorry that I cannot see my way to join with other members in throwing laurels at the Minister. Nevertheless, I will express my views on the manner in which, I think, the Minister has discharged his responsible duties. As far as I am concerned, the Minister for Justice is the balance between the people and the State. The Minister is supposed to exercise an honest independent discretion in all cases. He is the balance between the people and the law. As far as I know the Minister, he just signs on the line. I am going to give the House some information that I have been anxious to give it since I was first elected a member. I want to ask the Minister to make a public denial of one serious accusation that I am going to make against him. If he does not deny it, then let him admit it. If he does, I will say that I have done a good day's work.
Since the 23rd June last, when I was first elected to this House, I have been endeavouring to put down questions asking information on this same subject, but as fast as I put them down they were ruled out. I was told that I could raise the matter on the Estimate for the Minister's Department. I hope that the Minister will have the courage of his convictions and either deny the serious allegation that I am going to make against him or admit it. While I cannot pay tribute to the Minister on certain issues, I must definitely say that he has a very good and efficient staff in his office. I have had occasion, time and again, to approach the Minister, his private secretary and others under his control, and as far as the office is concerned I have no complaints to make. I have, however, certain complaints to make as far as the administration of justice is concerned. The first complaint I have to make is in connection with the political prisoners. I cannot for the life of me see why this State should have unfortunate men behind prison bars without trial. If the Minister cannot see his way to release them will he consider establishing a board which will deal with individual cases and report to him as to whether those people should be released or otherwise? I am told that such a board has been established in Northern Ireland and in England: that those who are interned in both places have the right of appeal to have their cases dealt with by an independent board. We have no such appeal board here. We have these poor, unfortunate men simply, I suppose, because of their political outlook, locked up behind prison bars. I say that is a disgrace.
I do not want the House to get the impression that I would be inclined to defend criminals because I would not. I am quite well aware that we must have law and order. Every country must have some law and order, but those men—I refer to the police—whom the Minister has under his charge for the carrying out of this law and order have, on very many occasions, abused the authority they have been given. During the election campaign, and afterwards in this House, the Minister told us that those men have the key in their own hands: that if they want to go out they can. Some of them have been released. I do not see all those political prisoners using the key. As I have said, I can not see why they should be there without trial. Many of them, I believe, are suffering from T.B. as a result of the conditions that exist in the camps in the Curragh and elsewhere.
The Minister has even refused Deputies permission to see them. When I made representations to visit some of my own constituents that are on the Curragh I was refused. I would like to see those people, to talk to them, to see what their state of health is and the conditions under which the Minister and his Department are forcing them to exist during their period of internment. I have been told that a great number of the men released recently by the Minister are definitely carriers of T.B., which they contracted as a result of their term in prison. I believe there are men that he has interned who are definitely suffering from a serious breakdown in health and from T.B. I cannot see why the Minister will not give those individuals the right to have their cases heard in court, or the right to make an appeal to some board in order to secure justice. I know from my own experience that there is any amount of law in this country; we have piles of law, heaps of it, but there is not an ounce of justice in any of that law. There is a terrible difference between law and justice.
Within the past few days I went over the Official Reports and I find that our present Minister for Justice, on the 18th November, 1927, intervened during a discussion on the trial of Edmund O'Reilly, who was charged with the murder of a Civic Guard—the case that Deputy Anthony referred to. We have been asked are we defending the murderers of Civic Guards—the people who appealed for the release of Republican prisoners. I do not think anyone would dream of appealing for the release of any man who was proved to be a murderer, because we are for law and order, but we are appealing on behalf of men who have had no trial; we suggest that they should get a fair trial, the type of trial every citizen is entitled to. On the occasion I have referred to, the Minister said:—
"I think this treatment is intended to break this young man, who is one of the best that ever stood in this country."
That is what the Minister said about an individual who was being tried for murder in 1927. I will go a little further with the quotations. On the 14th March, 1928, the Minister asked for an independent investigation into prison conditions. The Minister has complete control over the prisons now and we merely ask him to do what he wished for in 1928—have an independent investigation into prison conditions.
Deputy Connolly last night raised a very important point when he referred to Portlaoighise Prison. There the prisoners are treated the very same as slaves are treated in darkest Africa. I am quite satisfied they are not being fairly treated and the Minister will not allow myself, Deputy Davin, Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Boland or Deputy Gorry to look into the conditions of the prisoners. We are told that there are prisoners in Portlaoighise who did not hear Mass for the last three years. Who is responsible for that? Is it the Minister's Department? Why does not the Minister, when he is in a position to do it, implement what he demanded in this House on the 14th March, 1928— an investigation into prison conditions?
On the 21st March, 1928, the Minister, dealing with a particular case, said:—
"My friend, Ned O'Reilly—I would not like to hear the Minister call him a criminal, anyhow."
That is the statement the Minister made here. I have known the Minister to refer to political prisoners as criminals. They were never tried and the crime was never proved. They were never brought into court. I will go further in giving quotations from our Minister for Justice. On the 23rd March, 1928, referring probably to the I.R.A., he said:—
"I am convinced that it is the continual hunting down of these men that has kept the organisation going and is still giving reason for carrying it on."
Comment on this
On the 23rd March, 1928. The Minister now has an opportunity to let that organisation die out. Now is the time to take the bull by the horns. If you want to keep down a man, arrest him, send Guards to his house, intern him. That is the time that the general public will support him.
Comment on this
I would not be afraid of a general election in the morning. Those are the statements the Minister made and I put those statements that he made when he was on this side of the House against the statements he makes to-day. On the 7th June, 1928, the Minister spoke about arrests, including the arrest of a lady who was in jail in 1943. He said:—
"The right man is up to answer, a Castle hack."
He was referring to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. He described Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney as a Castle hack. He is a greater Castle hack himself than Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney ever was, and Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney certainly was a Castle hack. I say the Minister is twice as big a one.
Comment on this
He was not then responsible to the House, and if the Deputy, as alleged, in those days said something about Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, that is no excuse for the Deputy now in possession to repeat it and make similar personal charges.
Comment on this
The administration of the Department for the past 12 months is the matter under investigation. The Deputy has gone back 16 years.
Comment on this
Am I not in order in referring to the administration of the Department of Justice over the country as a whole?
Comment on this
I do not suppose we will have any chance of debating it now, but I will say that we had a different idea of things at that time. Our idea was tried out in our Government's time and it proved a failure and consequently the action taken in our time had to be taken.
Comment on this
Some time ago the Minister for Justice said there were dangerous criminals in the employment of the Department of Justice. I have here in black and white what the Minister said in this House—that there were dangerous criminals in the employment of the Department of Justice. I wonder are those dangerous criminals still in the service of the Department; and, if not, will the Minister tell us when he got rid of the dangerous criminals? If they are still in the Department the Minister will not have very much to say for his police force. If there were dangerous criminals in the Department since he took over office, and if they have not been put out, then they must still be there. Probably I have refreshed the Minister's memory with regard to statements made by him long ago. I think it is only right for us to have this comparison in order that we may look back upon it. Since you, Sir, in your wisdom, have requested that we should only go back on the past 12 months, it is with great pleasure that I give my experience of the past 12 months.
Comment on this
An occasional reference back is legitimate, but the Deputy for many minutes confined himself to quotations of debates of 16 years ago.
Comment on this
Personally, I have no objection, and I am glad that he has given me an opportunity of withdrawing one statement.
Comment on this
I will not go back as far as I was going. I shall only go back as far as 1941. When going through some old papers, I discovered the report of a case in the Evening Herald of 2/10/41, in which an ex-British soldier or an ex-secretary of the British Legion in Cavan pleaded guilty to having aided and abetted soldiers to desert the Irish Defence Forces and enter another force. The sentence imposed in this case was two months in prison. Two months' imprisonment for using his influence with members of the Irish Army probably to get them sent to the British Army. Side by side with that we have the case of a person charged before the Central Criminal Court with conspiracy to obstruct the Government, receiving ammunition, possession of firearms, etc. This accused person stated in the court that at no time had he conspired against the Government. He swore that he had never conspired against the Government and that he never had firearms to endanger any man's life or property.
Comment on this
The court could draw its own conclusion as to where the stuff was going and how it was being used. This person, although it was not proved against him, got ten years' penal servitude, as reported in the Irish Independent of 22/8/40. The gentleman who succeeded in getting members of the Irish Army into a foreign army only got two months in jail and an Irishman got ten years' penal servitude because he was supposed to have firearms. I cannot see very much justice in that. Probably the court drew its own conclusions. But, from reading the papers, the general public would be under the impression, when such cases are compared, that justice did not go as justice should go. In the Irish Press of the 17th February, 1943, in a square in the front page there appeared the following: “Nearly 13,000 Indian nationalists in jail”. They would want to put 65,000 in jail before the internees would be in the same proportion to the population as our internees here.
I do not intend to make any further reference to the political prisoners except to ask the Minister to consider the establishment of a board so that these men will get an opportunity of proving their innocence, because I am convinced that every man in this country has a right to see that the State gives him a fair and honest trial. I am convinced that these individuals have not got a fair and honest trial and that they have not been sentenced in accordance with justice. I ask the Minister to establish what the British Government and the Ulster Government have established, a board for the purpose of having each internee's case investigated.
I would be very glad if the Minister would indicate the reasons why members of the Gárda Síochána are following around a well-known citizen of this State in Cork—Mr. Joseph Kearney of Youghal. This gentleman appears to be definitely victimised, because every place he goes members of the Gárda are after him. Would the Minister give some information as to why the Guards are continually after this man? What has the Minister up his sleeve, what have the Guards up their sleeve, and what are they following him for? He wrote several times to the Department asking why the Guards were following him, but he does not seem to have got a satisfactory reply and I would be glad if the Minister could give us some information about his case.
Dealing with the Gárda Síochána, I wonder has the Minister or his Department seen a statement published in The Leader, which I understand is edited by a former Minister. The Leader states:—
"It is said that there is a black sheep in every flock. There has never yet been a police force anywhere some odd members of which did not, sooner or later, appear in the dock to answer criminal charges. Therefore, it is not, in itself, alarming that an occasional member of the Civic Guard should leave the straight and narrow path and end up by being sentenced to a term of imprisonment. Nevertheless, it is widely believed that our police force has, in recent years, come to have rather more than the unavoidable minimum number of members who are not quite all that they should be."
The article goes on to say:
"We could, moreover, point to areas in which, to judge merely by appearances, practically every Guard seems to take a good deal too much drink and in which it is common knowledge that in some favoured public houses Guards sit drinking long hours after closing hours."
I wonder did the Minister see that? This paper is edited, I understand, by a former member of this House. We were satisfied many years ago that the Civic Guards would run into a very difficult period when they had been some 15 or 20 years in existence. I wonder has this paper been brought to the notice of the Minister and is he aware of the manner in which members of the Gárda Síochána abuse the authority that is vested in them. I would like the Minister, or the Commissioner, or whoever is responsible for recruiting members of the Gárda Síochána, to give first preference to temperate men. I would nearly go as far as compelling them to be sober men.
Comment on this
I know very well that incidents have taken place, and I am sorry to say that in some areas the Gárdaí are standing around street corners waiting to see who will give them a drink. I have that experience. I must admit that there are other men in the Gárda Síochána who are as satisfactory in the discharge of their duties as any man could meet anywhere. In the County of Laoighis there is a certain sergeant of the Guards who exposed one of the greatest crimes in the history of the county. He was one man who did his duty and did it well. He is a credit to the Gárda Síochána. He discovered that in the County of Laoighis the poor were being badly treated; that they were being robbed, right, left and centre. He did what any good officer of the law should do: he brought on the case, I am told, even against the wishes of the superintendent. That sergeant of the Guards was up against a tough position in his district. A certain prominent Fianna Fáil officer in County Laoighis came down to the village of Clonaslee and said—those are the exact words this gentleman used—"I am after being in Athlone, at an L.D.F. meeting, and I saw Jerry there." That is the way he described the Minister for Justice, he knew him so well. He said he had made arrangements for the transfer of that sergeant of the Civic Guards. That officer was a well-known member of Fianna Fáil in my own constituency. I want the Minister to deny that that man made representations to him about the transfer of the sergeant of the Civic Guards, or else to admit it. Political spite was used against that sergeant of the Guards because he exposed a crime against the poor of that constituency. If I had my way I would give that sergeant promotion, but my information is that the Minister was approached by a member of his own organisation to get him shifted before he would expose anything else. Will the Minister say that he met this gentleman in Athlone—the gentleman who is going around the county giving the impression that he knows "Jerry" so well that he can get the Guards shifted to any part of the country?
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to say whether he met this gentleman, so that I may be in a position to go down to my constituents and say: "That man is telling lies. The Minister stated in the House that he does not know him." I should also like to ask the Minister for Justice, through you, Sir, if the general public are likely to be inspired with confidence in the administration of justice in this State when they see the superintendent of the Gárda Síochána, the State solicitor, and the district justice, having "a confab" in the district pending a serious criminal charge? The people are apt to be very suspicious when they see the justice who is going to try the case, the State solicitor and the superintendent of the Civic Guards having a big discussion in a certain Guard's barracks quite convenient to the district. Did the Minister ever inquire as to what they were talking about? He knows about the matter, because I think I have drawn his attention to it already. I made it my business to find out what they were talking about. They were discussing the very case I raised here to-day in connection with the Laoighis County Council. That is what they were talking about. Influence was being used with the district justice by a high officer of the Gárda Síochána. I understand that, as a result of reports made to the Minister for Justice, when the trial came off it was not the judge whom the officer of the Gárda Síochána had tried to influence that was sent down; it was an independent judge. I must give the Minister credit for that.
Comment on this
I have to repudiate that suggestion. I knew nothing about that at all. I have nothing to do with what justice tries any case. I cannot allow a statement of that kind to go unchallenged. I certainly did not interfere. I know nothing about what district justices do in the course of their duties.
Comment on this
Did the Minister not hear that on 1st February, 1944, the State solicitor, the local superintendent, and the justice of the local District Court, went into the Mountmellick Guards' barracks? What could the general public think of that when a serious criminal charge was pending? It has definitely been reported——
Comment on this
The Deputy is making grave insinutions against men who might be identified, men who have no chance of refuting his statements.
Comment on this
I made them outside the House, too. If an inquiry were held, and if those men were on oath, the statements which I am making here would be borne out. Influence was used to try to cloak a criminal charge. If the people are to have confidence in the administration of justice I think the Minister will have to carry out a good deal of tightening up in his Department. I remember during the election campaign when I went into a certain town in County Laoighis, representations were made to the Minister by, I am told, a well known banker in this country. I was one of the men who signed a communication sent to this banker, accusing bankers and other gentlemen of being responsible for unemployment, poverty, and emigration, by their corrupt banking system. I am told that that banker wrote a letter to our illustrious Minister saying: "Please give me protection against those gentlemen." Immediately, the Minister took up the case with the Gárda Síochána in the district concerned and, just as I had attended the funeral of a neighbour in Mountmellick, I had the Guards down to me to make a statement. The Minister for Justice had come along to give this banker protection. What protection did the banker need in regard to hearing the truth? Did the Minister see the communication which I addressed to the banker? If he saw it, or if he read it, perhaps he will indicate to the House why he should issue instructions to the Gárda Síochána to take statements from the individuals who signed that document. The Minister and the banker knew quite well that the document was not of a very serious nature, that we only told the truth in it, but we see how quickly the Minister took up all the weapons of the Department of Justice to defend Sir John Keane.
One other matter which I want to deal with is whether the Minister's Department have received any report as to a man with eight young children having lately been thrown out of his employment with Columbia Pictures Corporation, Ltd., Dublin; whether representations have been made from any quarter about the manner in which this gentleman was forced to become one of the unemployed; and whether he is aware that the gentleman who stepped into his shoes the following morning was none other than Mr. Jay, alias Jacobs?
Comment on this
One moment, Sir. I am informed that this gentleman is a deserter from the British Army, and I am asking the Minister what steps he proposes to take to have this gentleman deported from this country.
Comment on this
He could get him out of this country, anyhow. So far as I can see, too much of this Jewish control has been allowed, when we see a Jew stepping in to take the bread——
Comment on this
I have got my point in. I want to refer now to a meeting which I addressed during the election campaign in the town of Mountrath. I went down to that part of my constituency as a candidate during the last election and the Gárda Síochána canvassed tooth and nail against me. Is the Minister aware of that? The Minister then says that there are no politics in the Gárda Síochána. I am told that a member of the Gárda sent an interrupter to break up my meeting.
Comment on this
He could not. When this disturber came to create annoyance at the meeting, I asked a member of the Gárda who was standing at the corner what steps he was going to take to remove the interrupter and to ensure freedom of speech to every candidate. That Civic Guard never took his back away from the wall—he just laughed. The sergeant of the Guards in Mountrath then came up, and as a man who knew his duty, immediately removed the interrupter, and I believe gave the Guard "the works" for not doing so.
Comment on this
I placed these facts before the Minister and gave the Minister proof of strong political influence having been used against me by members of the Gárda Síochána, but the Minister did not seem to be worried about it, and no action whatever was taken. The Minister said on one occasion in this House: "We want to see that everybody gets freedom of speech," and I think that if Dáil Éireann is the democratic institution it should be, every person, no matter what his political outlook may be, should be allowed to express his views. The Minister once referred to the I.R.A. and asked why that organisation did not come out in public, place its cards on the table and put its views before the people. I must admit that I had no connection with the I.R.A., and yet because I came out in public, and in a democratic manner put my views before the people, I was hounded around the country by the Minister's touts, the Gárda Síochána. The Minister in reply to a Parliamentary Question recently said that he was not prepared to interfere with the action taken by the Guards. Does the Minister know that the circular which was issued requesting members of the Gárda Síochána to attend my meetings was not issued by the chief superintendent, but that advantage was taken of the absence, through illness or otherwise, of the chief superintendent by a political adventurer, the superintendent——
Comment on this
The Deputy will withdraw that description. He is not entitled to abuse men in that fashion who have no chance of replying. He is abusing the privileges of the House.
Comment on this
I bow to your ruling, Sir. Is the Minister aware that the gentleman responsible for the issuing of that circular was a well-known supporter of the Government? I understand that when this individual had complete control, in the absence of a decent man, the chief superintendent, he took a mean advantage of the position and sent his circular around. The Minister has not taken any steps to withdraw that order, and, what is more, says that he will not do so. He further said that there would be no need for the order if Deputy Flanagan used language which was suitable. I want to know what language I used that was not suitable. It may have been strong, but I am convinced that the Minister, in his day, used stronger language than any I ever used. We had a member of this House who went so far as to advocate war for this country. He was allowed to go scot free. I wonder do any Guards or other members of the force attend Deputy Dillon's meetings in his constituency.
Comment on this
It does not arise, and the Deputy will not be able to say later that he got away with the point, in spite of the Chair. It does not arise and will not be pursued further.
Comment on this
With all due respect, Sir, I think that the attendance of the Gárda at my meetings does arise.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not referring to that, but to a Deputy, Deputy Dillon, who made a speech in this House quite within his rights.
Comment on this
I should say that when I go down to address my constituents I am quite within my rights. Every Deputy who goes to his constituency has a right to put his views —no matter what they may be, and whether they are in the estimation of the Minister right or wrong—before the people. How can the Minister say that Dáil Eireann is a democratic institution when he will not allow candidates to express their honest views in public? I would be pleased if the Minister would see his way to withdraw the circular. If he does not, I might as well be quite frank and say that I do not care, because my meetings will go on just the same. I cannot for the life of me, however, see why the taxpayers of the counties I represent should bear the expense involved in driving these plainclothes men in motor cars to the different places at which I hold my meetings, while I have to cycle to my meetings.
Comment on this
The Minister is trying to back out of it now, but the taxpayers of Offaly will not stand for any more of this squandermania. It is most unfair that a Deputy should be prohibited from expressing his views.
Before concluding, I wish to make reference to the censorship of letters. Deputy Davin, my colleague from Laoighis-Offaly, made reference to that last night. Certain documents are being censored at the present time and the information is being used for political purposes. I am sure Deputy Davin could prove that. I know cases of it in the city. Communications are coming to me as a responsible Deputy —whether I am responsible or irresponsible, I am representing the constituency; that is a matter for the intelligence of the electorate—and, assuming that my correspondence is opened, is it not a nice thing that the information coming from my closest supporters will be put at the disposal of those who canvassed against me in the constituency? How is that to react against me, if such is the case?
The Minister is instructing these men, and I would like information as to the procedure in regard to the censorship of internal correspondence. Who is the principal censor dealing with such correspondence? What is the procedure followed? On whose instructions is correspondence opened? Of course, the Minister gives the instructions, but we would like to hear a little more about it. These charges are of a very serious nature, and the Minister would be wise to clear the air when he is replying. I join in the statement made by Deputy Davin last night, that the information is definitely used for political purposes.
I would appeal to the Minister to see that members of the Gárda Síochána are provided with houses in the different areas. In every town where we have a Gárda barracks with five or six members of the force, the State should provide suitable accommodation. They should not have those men looking for and getting houses from county managers which were intended for labouring men. It is an appalling state of affairs to see Gárdaí living in houses erected by local authorities and see the labouring men entitled to them under the various Acts deprived of them. It is the duty of the State to see that houses are provided for the Gárdaí.
Deputies have referred to late dances and drinking at dances. I must admit that I never danced a step in my life and do not intend to do so. I never go to dances, except perhaps an odd social function to which I get an invitation. At the same time, I am satisfied that dances are ideal recreation for rural areas. I am not opposed to the late hours, but I am definitely opposed to the drinking at dances. I will be glad to see the Minister introduce legislation to prohibit the granting, at any district court, of a licence for a bar at any dance. I have seen young men neglecting their work, and even neglecting their religious duties, because of dances the night before, when they were under the influence of drink.
It is a shame that certain dance halls should be conducted in that way. It is all right to go to a dance for amusement, but no such thing as drink should be allowed—I am one hundred per cent. opposed to it. I am sure no one would object to a mineral bar, to teas or lemonade refreshments; but I strongly oppose the ordinary bars at all-night dances. In regard to the long hours, I do not care if the dances go on all night, nor do I think the Minister should worry about that. It would be much better to see the young people amuse themselves in a dance hall than that they should be out in the hedges afterwards.
In regard to film censorship, I have seen some films shown here which are one hundred per cent. anti-national and make a laugh and a skit of the Irish people. Many of these British productions to which we all flock, thinking we will hear The Lakes of Killarney or Galway Bay—which do not make a skit of the “wild Irish”—are very damaging to youth. There should be a different performance—something of an educational nature—for children, instead of showing them how to draw a gun. Some special pictures should be provided for the young folk.
I would like to know if the Minister has jurisdiction over courthouses. I understand that, through the District Court clerk, the courthouses are looked after by the Minister's Department. I would like to draw the attention of the Minister to the fact that, at a meeting of Laoighis County Council, some time ago it was proposed, seconded and adopted unanimously that, on the day of each meeting of the council, the National Flag be flown from the County Courthouse, Port Laoighise. The resolution was sent to the Department of Justice and the secretary of the county council has since made representations on the matter, but no reply has been given. We have been told that the letter was sent to the county registrar. I have also been informed that the county registrar objected to the National Flag being flown from Laoighis County Council offices on the day of the council's meetings. It is a strange state of affairs if we have our own native Irish Government prohibiting the display of the National Flag. I would be glad if the Minister would look into that matter, to see if he got the resolution and if the reply the county registrar gave was as I have stated. I must admit that I did not propose the resolution, but I have been asked by other members of the council to draw the Minister's attention to it.
I received a letter this morning from Westmeath and I must pass it over to some of the Westmeath Deputies. It says:
"I am a Civic Guard's wife, and on behalf of the womenfolk I am making a special appeal to you. I wonder would you ever raise the matter of the Guard's weekly pay at the first opportunity in the Dáil. It is impossible to believe what the effect of the present monthly pay has on the married members of the force. You see we have to wait 31 days for our pay, and then the last part of it goes into the grocer's book when we get it. On every item he enters 3d. or 4d."
I will not continue to read it further. Probably there is a lot in the contents of that letter. It comes from the wife of a Civic Guard in the County Westmeath. I do not propose to disclose the name. I wonder would it be possible for the Minister to arrange weekly pay for the members of the Gárda Síochána? Probably it would be a great inconvenience in the Department, but if it is practicable or possible, I wonder would he consider it? We know that at the present time it is very inconvenient for the housewife to get groceries and the other provisions to keep the house going, and then when the month's cheque comes in to find that the greater part of it has to go to pay the grocer's bill. I would be glad if the Minister could arrange, if not to make the payments weekly at least to make them fortnightly. During the emergency we all know that a man wants his week's pay at the end of his week's labour. Could the Minister see his way to do something not for the sake of the Civic Guards themselves but for the sake of their wives and families? On this occasion I do not propose to say anything further on the Estimate.
I have made some very grave statements here in connection with the transfer of a sergeant at Clonaslee in the County Laoighis. I hope to be in the House when the Minister is replying to see if he will deny speaking to this Fianna Fáil henchman who knows him so well that he calls him "Jerry." Why, even Deputy O'Donnell who had the Minister in his arms when he was a little boy would not go that far. I am anxious to hear what the Minister has to say about this gentleman in the Fianna Fáil organisation who was at the convention in Athlone where he said that he had met "Jerry" and would arrange for the transfer of the sergeant. That makes a bad impression on the public. I would be glad if the Minister would take the opportunity of dealing with that.
Comment on this
With all respect I was afraid that the Minister might forget it. I would also like to hear what reference the Minister has to make to the police order.
Comment on this
We had some sensible speeches on this Estimate and some very sloppy ones also. We cannot ignore the background of history in this country during the past 20 years and leave any loophole for gunmen who think they are going to have a good time here. Thanks to the courage of the Minister for Justice, we have fairly decent peaceable conditions at the moment. Some of those gentlemen have found that it is not a paying proposition to defy the law. We had some "molly coddle" speeches about the poor unfortunate men who, we were told, are locked behind prison bars. We were not, however, told about the many lonely graves that there are all over the country, of superintendents and other members of the Gárda, as well as the many honest decent citizens who were foully done to death by members of this organisation. I know very well that there are some innocent men behind prison bars. The innocent suffer with the guilty. If there is any man behind prison bars on the Curragh there is nothing to prevent him being released. It rests with himself.
I think there is great room for constitutional republicanism in this country. I have always held the opinion that things will never be right until we have a healthy constitutional republican party in the country. This country will never be at peace until the Six Counties have been restored to the motherland. In my opinion, we must have clean, healthy, constitutional republicanism. The Minister's strong and firm attitude has forced those men away from the gun and has brought them on to the platform. If they come on the platform as honest, decent men and put a proper programme before the people, I will be prepared to speak from the same platform with them myself. But, when speaking about them, I would like to see fair play all round.
I knew many grand young men who were in the Guards—superintendents and others—who were foully done to death. I know the circumstances in which their widows and children or their mothers were left. When an appeal is made to release men something ought to be said about the many lonely graves that there are all over the countryside. It is my belief that it is not the I.R.A. who are a danger in this country but the flood of money that is coming in through Nazi-ism and Communism. There is not the slightest doubt but that the kind of work that has gone on here during the last six or eight years has been fostered and fed by the flood of money that has been coming in from Russia and Germany. Our young fellows fell for that money and did the dirty work for those nations. At the present moment there is great need to find out what is the position with regard to Communism in this country. Is it a fact that there are live active cells ready and eager for the day when they can do the foul work that they have done in other countries? I have it on fairly good authority that there is in this House an active member of the Communist Party. I think that the Irish people, whatever their past, were false to the true traditions of Ireland when they elected an avowed Communist, an anti-God who was trained in Russia in all the dirty anti-God——
Comment on this
Every Deputy elected to the Dáil has the same rights and standing as his fellow Deputies.
Comment on this
That is the real danger that I see in this country. In a debate last night a good many speakers referred to the harm done by the pictures and the dance halls. I think that Deputy Linehan struck the nail on the head when he said that there are two major problems before this country: one its economic condition and the other the lack of parental control. It is perfectly true to say that you require sound economic conditions to provide houses and work for our people at constant wages. I hold with Deputy Linehan that it is not the Guards or any other institution that is going to put our people on the right track. You need parental control to do that. There is far too much laxity in many homes. You have too many young people falling by the wayside, and the cause of that in many cases is that they did not get a good whipping in their early days. If some young girls see others going around with blackened eyebrows and red on their lips and walking the streets late at night, they must follow their example. Their parents should exercise more control over them. If they got a good whipping when they did anything wrong it would help to correct many of the things that Deputies have complained of.
Think of the way the teachers of the country are handicapped. If a teacher, in the exercise of his rightful duty, spanks a schoolboy then, as Deputy Linehan said, the parents will be off to take out a summons against him and he is brought into court. The result of that is, teachers are inclined to take the line of least resistance and will not slap young fellows when they deserve it. As regards the Civic Guards, I hold that we have a magnificent force in this country. I am not going to say that it is as good a force as it was four or five years ago. It is, however, the mainstay of peace in the country. At the moment it may be a lackadaisical force. I do not blame the members of it for that. They have many grievances and feel very sore over them. At the moment the Guards have to play second fiddle to other organisations. I hold that unless the Guards are regarded as the superior and over-all force in this country, we cannot expect law and order to be enforced as it should be. I do not believe in this thing of having military or semi-military organisations taking over control from the police. At the present time the police would appear to have no duties. They are more or less like messenger boys to other organisations and that is unfair.
I know some good sergeants, men who suffered in prison camps, and they told me their grievances. They were asked to go to a lecture hall and give lectures on detective duties and how to detect crime to men who they knew were criminals and robbers. I am sorry to say that some of these men are members of the L.S.F. I regard that force as a brilliant and patriotic force. But to ask a sergeant or superintendent of the Gárda to give lectures to men who, to their knowledge, are potential criminals, is very unfair. Any men who are to be passed as super-detectives should be selected for their character and ability to go straight. It is very unfair to ask the Guards to play second fiddle to any organisation.
I hold that Gárda duties are not being carried out in the same manner as in other years. I am aware that the Guards are willing to do their duty, to patrol the country and protect the property of the people and try to put down crime, but at the present time they are merely messenger boys. I suggest that the L.S.F. be taken away from the duties of Civic Guards and allow the Guards to carry out their duties as of old. That is a great cause of trouble among the Gárda to-day.
Another important matter is the provision of suitable housing for married Gárda. This matter has been delayed unnecessarily. There is no question about it, the Gárdaí must be properly housed. Some scheme should be devised so that suitable houses will be erected convenient to the barracks. I know many Guards who are obliged to live down old lanes and boreens in thatched houses, somewhat like wigwams, because they cannot get a decent house convenient to the barracks. It is about time we gave them proper housing facilities. They should be within easy reach of the barracks in case they are needed during the night. The Minister cannot expect the police to be attentive to their duties if they are obliged to live in country lanes in houses little better than wigwams.
We have heard a good deal about drunkenness. There is a fair amount of drinking, but that has happened in every period of Irish history. When money is plentiful, drink will be taken, perhaps, to excess, but I was horrified to hear Deputy Cafferky saying that it was something appalling to observe the drinking that is going on in Mayo. He said that the people there were absolutely drunken and sodden, and that there was one case of a father, mother and youngsters of 14 and 15 years getting drunk. That is a terrible accusation and, if it is a fact, what will become of my county, where hundreds of migrants from Mayo are arriving day after day? I hold that the men who came from Mayo in the past were decent, hardworking, sober men, but if those who are left in Mayo are the drunken, sodden lot that Deputy Cafferky said, then God save us from them. I hope that other Deputies from Mayo will take part in this debate and will either support or deny that statement. It is a terrible accusation, and if Ireland is in the wretched, degrading position that a man cannot cross the road without staggering from drink, then God save us from ourselves.
I agree there is a great deal of petty larceny. There are many small thefts all over the country, and it is very hard to detect the criminals. If the Guards were allowed to carry out their duties as in the past this type of crime would cease. The Guards cannot carry out their duties because they are too much restricted. We regard the Guards as the custodians of the people, and it is upon them we depend for freedom from crime. You will always have a crime wave in every country when there is a war on and when money is plentiful. The crime wave here will ease off when money is less plentiful.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy misquoted me. What I said was that the only occasion I ever had to hang my head when outside this country was when I came in contact with a drunken Irishman. By that statement I did not suggest that all Irishmen who leave this country are drunkards. In making that statement I was asking the Minister to consider the question of allowing drink to be sold at dance halls, and I suggested that by doing so he is endangering the peace. I am surprised at Deputy Giles trying to misinterpret my statement and suggest that I said that Irishmen as a whole are drunkards. I said no such thing, and the Deputy knows that very well, but he has taken a rotten opportunity deliberately to try to misinterpret my statement, knowing that I had no intention of saying anything like that. The Deputy should look up the official report and see what I did say.
Comment on this
I may not have quoted the exact words, but anyone listening to the Deputy would think we were a drunken lot and nothing more.
Comment on this
You said that in the publichouses or in the dance halls a father, mother and children were drinking together. I do not believe the country is as bad as that. It is a shame to make such a statement.
Comment on this
I know there is a certain type of man who can get money handy, and who will act the dandy, drinking cocktails and everything he can get. He will go to the dances and he will not have the courtesy to ask a girl to dance; he will pull her out, or haul her away from another fellow. It is not the duty of the Guards to deal with that type of thing. That is a case where civic responsibility comes in. A decent, hardy Irishman would give that type of fellow a crack on the jaw. I have seen it done. That type of drunken lout will go 20 or 30 miles to a dance, and he will be there Sunday after Sunday, and as long as he is allowed to get away with it he will do the dirty on everybody, but I know of some cases where he ran up against stone walls—and he never forgot it.
There is too much crawling and cringing and too much cowardice. There are men looking at criminals stealing bicycle tyres, stealing poultry out of farmers' yards, but they are too cowardly to go to the police court or give evidence. If Irishmen and Irishwomen were prepared to give evidence all this wave of crime would come to an end. After 700 years of toil and trouble we have a free country with free administration and justice. What are we afraid of? What are we crawling and cringing for?
We have heard the cry here to-day: "Let out the poor devils who are behind bars, the fellows who have done nothing." All over the country there are hundreds of green graves containing the rotting bodies of young men who fought a good fight. Let us remember what they sacrificed their lives for. Let us do our duty in a manly fashion, even if we have to die in the attempt. Let us have clean, healthy administration. Let us stand shoulder to shoulder in an Ireland free from shore to shore. Let us do our utmost to get out of the mess we find ourselves in to-day.
Comment on this
I am more or less forced to my feet by the last speaker because of references he made to migrants from my county coming to County Meath in connection with references which were made to drunkenness in the County Mayo yesterday evening by Deputy Cafferky. I think that in debates of this kind there should be some element of truth in statements made by Deputies who hold that they have some responsibility as Deputies. I cannot see the wisdom of Deputies putting on the records of this House, which are there for all time, and which are there to be quoted in foreign newspapers against the Irish, statements that would give the impression all over the world that the man in the West of Ireland is the Playboy of the Western World, the usual typical drunkard that enemies of Ireland would like to think he is. It is a recorded fact that there is less drunkenness in Aran than ever before. It is also a recorded fact that the consumption of drink has gone down considerably in recent years. It is also a recorded fact that in our courts there are less prosecutions for drunkenness than there have been for quite a long time. I think there is a lower record of prosecutions for drunkenness than ever before. When that is the case, I regret very much that Deputy Cafferky gave the impression by his statements in this House that in Mayo, in particular, drunkenness has been the order of the day, or rather that drinking has been the order of the day.
Comment on this
That is a deliberate misrepresentation of my statement and you know it. You have spoken an untruth. You are deliberately misrepresenting the statement that I made. You are acting like a scoundrel as you have done since the first day you were elected to this House.
Comment on this
The statement that boys of 12 and 14 drink at public bars with their parents in Mayo is a disgraceful statement and is untrue.
Comment on this
I will read the words:—
"Boys from 12 to 14 years are drinking at public bars with their parents ..."
I will accept it, if you like, that Deputy Cafferky might not have actually said that boys were drinking, but he continued to say——
Comment on this
The words are these:—
"Boys from 12 to 14 years are drinking at public bars with their parents, and is it any wonder that they continue to drink when they come to the age of 16, 17 and 18 because, when they see their fathers and mothers doing it, they think it is the wise and good thing to do?"
Comment on this
My recollection is that the Deputy said that the fathers and mothers were accompanied by these young people of 12 and 14 years, but that these children were not drinking and, unless it is a copy of the Official Report, I do not want the Deputy to misinterpret the statement.
Comment on this
I put it in as an exact copy. In case I might be accused of misconstruing it, I went to the trouble, which Deputies are entitled to do, to put myself right on the matter. Even if the Deputy wanted to convey that boys only accompanied their parents while they were drinking, I say that it is not the practice in Mayo for fathers and mothers to drink at public bars. It should not go on the records of this House that that is the practice, because the records of this House will be used by a certain organisation in this country that wants to create the impression that our social order here is bad, that we are not a decent people, and that the present Government or any Government that is not the Government of that particular international organisation is not a fit Government to rule in this country. I want to protest strongly against Deputy Cafferky's being made the tool of any other Deputy or any organisation in this country to put abroad statements of that kind that are absolutely incorrect. Mothers in Mayo do not drink at public bars. Boys of 14 in Mayo do not drink at public bars. I will exclude that if you like. But why should the Deputy say that boys of 16, 17 and 18 continue that practice, and that, because they see their parents drinking, they think it the wise thing to do?
The Deputy also complained that publichouses are open on Sunday evenings and that groups of boys go from them to the dance halls. The Guards do their duty in Mayo, as far as I can find out. There have been very few prosecutions for brawls in dance halls. The Deputy also stated that outside dance halls you are in danger of being hit with stones. He said that you could not know who the culprit was. Mayo is not a place for brawls. Its record has been good. Many of the boys who attend dances there are in the Defence Forces and they know how to conduct themselves. I also want to say that when Mayo boys go abroad nobody need be ashamed to meet them. They have got into very prominent posts in England and have carried themselves well.
There are no more misfits amongst the young men and women of Mayo who go abroad and have to come back again than amongst the people of any other county or nation. It is only because I did not want that statement to go on the records of this House without contradiction that I stood up to refer to it. The Deputy in question should not make these statements, because they are untrue. He should not be urged to make them by any other body for use elsewhere. Deputy Giles was perfectly right in stating that, if that were the condition of things in Mayo, Mayo migrants should no longer be sent to the County Meath to carry on their brawls there. In a previous debate, also, statements were made that the Mayo migrants were responsible for illegitimate children in homes in England, and that these had to be paid for out of the English Exchequer. I think that this slandering of Mayo men who go abroad should not be indulged in here, because these things are not true.
Notwithstanding the statements made that crime is on the increase, I think that, taking world conditions as they are and the disturbed minds of people, of youth in particular, we are a wonderfully peaceful country at present. It has been stated here by men of experience that, because of the terrible situation throughout the world and the callousness that goes with war, crime is bound to enter into the minds of people to a greater extent than before. Any increase of crime is due to the restlessness in the world. Taking that into consideration, I think we are wonderfully free from crime, especially petty crime that people hope to get away with. The proceedings in our courts are proof of that. I do not know what the police reports are, but I take it the police are doing their duty in trying to detect and prevent crime. Therefore, I think the Minister and the Department and the people are to be congratulated. I think that any statements to the contrary should not be made here for the purpose, I may say, of having them used by a certain organisation elsewhere to try to smash the morale of the people who want law and order here, despite what was said by a Deputy a few moments ago when speaking against the Minister, the Department and the Government.
In regard to recruitment to the Guards, Deputy Cogan thought that the standard should be raised. I do not at all agree with that. I suggest that the standard of education should be lowered, that is, as far as secondary and university education is concerned. To my mind, the pupil who has done five years in a secondary school, or the man who has done a year or two in a university or even qualified for a degree there, is not the best type of man to become an ordinary member of the Gárda Síochána. Men have applied for those posts time and again because they could get no post that would suit them. They applied to become members of the Gárda Síochána and passed the test on their educational qualifications. They are fine types of men, but in accepting that post they feel it is beneath them. They never have their hearts and souls in police work. Sometimes they run into debt. In my experience, they become bad members of the Gárda Síochána, and bring lesser men from an educational point of view into disgrace. The best type of Guard in this country is the small farmer's or labourer's son who has got a good primary education.
Comment on this
And without a competent knowledge of Irish either—an Irishman without a competent knowledge of Irish. Do not forget that.
Comment on this
A man with a good primary education has a good competent knowledge of Irish, and when he becomes a member of the Gárda Síochána he does not feel that the job is beneath him. He has a pride in his work, and he is a very good limb of the law. I think the Department would make a grave mistake in going in for the highly qualified men from an educational point of view without taking into consideration that the man who is highly qualified educationally feels that the job is beneath him. He is there on sufferance, and for that reason does not give to his work the attention that he should give to it.
About the force as a whole, I believe there is more laxity now than there was heretofore. I believe there is, but it is due to the duplication of forces if you like. Duties of various kinds are divided up amongst the L.D.F. and other members of the forces. I think that is a mistake. I think the police should be the rigid enforcers of the law, and that only in a very extreme case should their duties be handed over to any other body. I also believe that economy could be effected by reducing the number of barracks in certain backward parts of the country. The Minister could very well close down a number of small barracks. There is a greater public spirit now than heretofore. There is not a backwood village in the country in which you have not members of the L.D.F. prepared to assist in seeing that the law is carried out. They have become first-class trained citizens and are ready to enforce the law. There is no need to have a Guards' barracks in those districts, and I think an economy could be effected in that direction. Therefore, if the Minister has any economies in mind, he might consider that some of those barracks might well be closed down, leaving it to the sensible people of the countryside not to give way to pressure from criminals or allow crime to be committed without giving any information in their possession to the proper authorities.
Comment on this
There are one or two points which I should like to put to the Minister in connection with his Estimates. Before going into those matters, there was one point raised by Deputy Flanagan at the end of his remarks to-day with which I would like to be associated. That is where he quoted from a letter from the wife of a member of the Gárda Síochána requesting that payments to members of the force might be made at more frequent intervals.
Comment on this
I have got a note on that matter since. I find that two payments monthly were tried out, and the Guards themselves were not satisfied and were prepared to go back to the monthly payments.
Comment on this
Certainly any number of them have complained that they are driven more and more to living on credit, and I have always understood that those associated with the Department of Justice are definitely against anything that would drive members of the force to living on credit.
Comment on this
Certain people feel that by getting the Guards to run up bills in their establishments they get a certain amount of pressure and strength which they can exercise for their own purposes. I would ask the Minister to relieve the members of the Guards, who must be very definitely feeling the pinch at the moment. The cost of living has gone up for them, as well as for everyone else, by 70 per cent. As far as the cost-of-living bonus is concerned it alleviates that 70 per cent. increase on their old wages by about 10 per cent. They are still very badly handicapped when one remembers the old purchasing power of their money.
With regard to this matter which has been discussed by many speakers, the question of political internees, I have not troubled the Minister very much on that matter, and I hope never to have very much to do with him in that connection. I did have one representation made to him in one case. That man was released, but there is one small matter which I have already mentioned—the Minister can get the details from his advisers—incidental to the release. The person in question was not I think ever suspected of being active in the sense of doing any harm to any man with a weapon. He was supposed to have been an inciter, but whatever was the strength of the case against him the Minister, on examination, apparently decided that he would be lenient with him. He was let out. But here is what I cannot understand about it: That man had no way of earning his living—he was physically disabled—except by some sort of hack journalism. His typewriter was taken from him and has not been returned. I think it is somewhat anomalous to have a man released as being fit to be let loose on the citizens of this country, but to retain from him his means of livelihood. I expect there is some reason why that has been done, and the Minister might inquire into the matter.
With regard to those people generally, I was amazed last night to hear that the Minister had released 300 of them in the last year. I would urge the Minister that, in respect of those people more particularly than in the case of any one else, it is not only required that justice should be done but that there should be a definite appearance of the fullest justice being done to them. This country has had bitter experiences, and there are very few people in the country at the moment who would back publicly those who decide that they can use physical force against the citizens of the State. Nobody is going to stand for that sort of thing at all, but there is an uneasy feeling in the minds of certain people—I have shared it myself from time to time—that the vast powers with which the Minister has been armed are very liable to abuse. I am not saying that they are being abused, but there are people who have their suspicions about that matter, and the Minister would be well advised to take every possible opportunity not merely of explaining to the people his mind on the matter but explaining how the individual cases of those people who are still interned have been dealt with. There is a lot of talk as to whether or not there are boards to look into the cases of those men. If any of those men are detained under the Offences Against the State Act of course there is a board to which he can apply. If they are detained under the Emergency Powers Act, that is a different matter. I do not know whether the whole 209 are interned——
Comment on this
They are interned under the Emergency Powers Act.
Comment on this
Then the situation is that they have not immediately at their disposal any statutory board to which they can appeal?
Comment on this
Therefore, they are entirely dependent on what may be the opinion of the Minister in view of the information given to him by his advisers as to the changed mental attitude of those people.
Comment on this
There was a board, but it was considered unsatisfactory. The matter was discussed at the Defence Conference, and it was decided to drop it.
Comment on this
I am sure there are good reasons for that, but I suggest that they might be explained. I am sure the Minister has learned from his experience in the Department that all through the run of history men's minds have been exercised in trying to find some way of preventing the natural corruption that power tends to bring in the human fabric, and the way that is generally done is by all this system of checks and balances that the law has established.
At the moment, we are in that situation in which the Minister has been given extraordinary powers. He said, last night, that he had been given them because of certain troubles in the country. I do not think that is so. He was given them under the 1937 Constitution, I suggest, on arguments which have not stood the test of practical experience since the Constitution was passed. Special courts may be set up. It was understood, when the matter was being discussed in connection with the Constitution, that if these special courts were to be set up, there would be a form of court, not a lay body, which would determine what were the circumstances in which these special courts should be established. In any event, the Minister got powers and got them for peace time—not for the emergency alone. The Minister has power under the second edition of the Offences Against the State Act to put people in jail when he likes. That, roughly, is the position.
Comment on this
Even in peace-time, but in peace-time, apart altogether from this war emergency we are in, the Minister, by getting an emergency declared by the Government, a political body, can thereafter simply sign a Schedule which is affixed to one of the Acts. There is no going wrong about it, unless the Minister fills in his own name as the person to be interned, instead of as the signatory. That is the only mistake that could be made in the warrant. All the old cases we knew of about warrants being wrong and points of detail being picked out have gone. The Minister has such a formula at the back of the Act, and all he has to do is to put his signature to it, and he can send people to jail indefinitely.
That is possibly a power which is required. History has shown that the worst people in any country are those who make use of Constitutional matters to overthrow the Constitution, who prepare their plans for an armed rising against the Constitution under the guise of the Constitution. The 1937 Constitution, undoubtedly, armed the Minister against that sort of nonsense. With regard to that, it is a pity that at this stage people can be found in this House still, even with reservations and some without reservations, to try to justify the use of armed force. On account of the circumstances in which the State emerged, there was a pretty evil tradition established with regard to the use of physical force. I have my views that that should have stopped on a certain date, and the Minister will hold that, after a particular date, no attempt at physical force could be justified. Our dates may disagree.
In any event, as a result of two political Parties having had experience of office, there is now a pretty healthy opinion in this country against the use of physical force, and it is a desperate thing that, even in this debate last night, people should be found to seek, even with some reservations, to pretend to justify force, and to justify it on the ground that, when force is used against people, they may be driven to the use of force themselves. That argument reverses the truth. The truth is that when people have attempted to use physical force, the force of the law comes down upon them, but I think a few words by the Minister would not be out of place in indicating that, even with regard to these 209 persons, opportunities are taken when they occur to have their cases reviewed, to have the files gone into and to have some association with people which will give them every chance of escaping from evil associations. If these people are banded together in a particular internment camp, they are all going to be pretty much under the supervision of the others, and it may be hard for a man who wants to leave the association—I am not speaking of an organisation, but of associates— to get a chance of disclosing his mind. I understand that the Minister gives these men every chance.
Comment on this
Very well. The Minister said with regard to these people that they will stay there until the emergency is over and probably for some time after it.
Comment on this
I take that as meaning that they represent the hard core of the physical force system in the country.
Comment on this
The Minister will get all the support he wants from this side, so long as that is the situation and so long as he can make it clear to us that he is not being obtuse in regard to any appeal made in connection with a change of mind on the part of these people.
The Minister last night—it may have been simply due to the heat of interjection of debate—objected rather vehemently to some remark as to whether he himself might not be prejudiced with regard to some of these people.
Comment on this
I did not quite hear what was said, but I thought the particular Deputy was accusing me.
Comment on this
The remark was made, and I want to make a point on it. The Minister immediately afterwards accepted with equanimity the suggestion that some of his advisers might have hostile associations or a background which might make them hostile.
Comment on this
If the Minister repudiates the idea that he is prejudiced, on the basis of having tried to clear his mind of any of the old-time associations with regard to these people, of having impartially considered their cases and now feels that he is not in any way prejudiced against them, I will accept it from him, but I did think it was rather odd of him so strongly to repudiate the suggestion that he might be prejudiced and to accept that some of his advisers, associates or someone down the line might have particular prejudices. The Minister would admit that if prejudices were anywhere they probably were with these people, but I should imagine that when the Minister says he is not prejudiced, it means that he has gone through a particular phase, that he has judged these things impartially and has taken the most objective view that he can of them.
Comment on this
I trust so, and I have no reason at all to believe the contrary. That is the situation with regard to these people, and in so far as there are 200, and only 200, under detention at the moment, I think it is a great situation. In the height of this war, when people who were inclined to be antagonistic to the best interests of the country had such open opportunities for mischief and with all the tension surrounding a recent period, to have only a couple of hundred still detained is a matter upon which we can congratulate ourselves.
It is also a matter for congratulation that 300 were released last year. I gathered from the Minister's retorts to various people that he is not at all satisfied that the whole of the 300 have kept faith with him, but I understand that, numerically, there are not very many who have broken faith, although his interjection made me feel that he was a bit doubtful of the strength of the opposition of certain of the small number who have gone back, so to speak, on the faith which they had pledged. That is all I want to say on that, except to urge that the Minister will take the opportunity of indicating to the House that cases get the fullest consideration, and that if any man shows that he has turned to a new path the Minister releases him and hopes for the best. I hope that he does not neglect a little supervision at the same time.
It is the secondary part of this matter which causes me anxiety. The courts are crammed with criminals at the moment. Deputy Ó Cléirigh said that we ought to congratulate ourselves that crime is only at the point at which we have it. I think we are in a shockingly bad condition. The best the Minister could say in his opening statement was that we had stabilised crime at a very high point, at double what it was four years ago. I think he said that the number of indictable offences had more or less doubled in four years.
Comment on this
It is lamentable that we should have that situation, and I am not sure that simply getting judges to sentence men to terms of imprisonment is the solitary means to be adopted against that particular set of circumstances. I am worried rather more by this position: We have our ordinary courts presided over by judges appointed under the Constitution, with all the fortification there is to judges of being impartially appointed and put beyond the reach of any prejudice by the manner in which they are appointed, and in addition we have these special courts presided over by people who can be changed at any moment. They are not people who must be appointed under the Constitution, or subject to the restrictions in the Constitution.
I find myself, in reading the accounts of cases in the newspapers, wondering what is the line of principle which determines whether a case goes before the special courts or the ordinary courts of the country. At one time, I thought that what were called serious black-marketing cases went before the special courts, but then I saw, within the same month, cases in connection with petrol coupons going to the special courts and some going to the ordinary courts.
Comment on this
I know, but surely there is matter for the administration of justice in connection with it. I agree that the Attorney-General has a very big say in the whole matter, but I am quite certain that the Attorney-General can have representations made to him with regard to particular cases and with regard to, say, the abuse of the special courts; but the public, or the small fraction of the public whom I meet, are a little anxious about this overworking of the special courts. There are any number of cases in which it seems to us people might have been paraded before the ordinary juries of the country and in respect of which we could have depended on the juries to give justice. I can see one excuse, but I do not know that it is one which the Minister would like to give, that is, that the ordinary courts are so crammed that the special courts are taking part of the burden of this tremendous outbreak of crime in the country. In any event, I do suggest that the use of the special courts has been overdone and there is no real line of principle in relation to the type of case which we see from time to time appearing before the special court, when the ordinary criminal courts under the Constitution are open for the trial of these people. The ordinary criminal courts set up under the Constitution are open for the trial of those cases. The Minister might help in that matter by stating what percentage of the prosecutions for indictable offences come before the special courts as opposed to the ordinary courts. Is the percentage growing in recent years? Is there a bigger percentage, so to speak? In any event, there must be a bigger number of these cases coming before the criminal courts, as the crime cases have doubled. The statistics would show whether the courts are getting the increasing number. I understood that the use of the special courts under the Act was to be confined to cases in which the ordinary administration of the law had broken down. Applying that rule, there is really no case for the special courts at all. I do not think the Minister in the last three or four years could say that the ordinary courts have broken down. He gave one instance of an attempt at shooting and wounding one witness.
Comment on this
Yes. I do not think the Minister can indicate a solitary example of a solitary district justice having been prevented from holding his court by any process of intimidation. If that is the case—and I suggest it is—the Minister has to justify the use of these special courts. It must be remembered that the courts are composed of people not appointed under the Constitution and that all the fortification the citizen is supposed to get from the background of the courts is gone.
Comment on this
The rules of evidence may have been suspended, too, but as far as the special court is concerned——
Comment on this
Without any disrespect to the personnel of those courts, I must say that cases are being taken in that way before people not accustomed to the rules of evidence, who do not know the strict application of the rules of evidence as it is known in the ordinary courts. Therefore, people who go before a special court may be subjected to a much more severe type of control than those who go before the courts appointed under the Constitution. There are certain other courts in which the rules of evidence may be set aside entirely— it depends on the court and on the special circumstances.
There is one other matter which causes anxiety. The Minister might answer by some statistics. Statistics were asked for yesterday, but the Minister said it would take too much time and effort to get them.
Comment on this
I said I was prepared to get them if the Deputy insisted.
Comment on this
The research might have been magnified beyond what is proper by the way in which the Deputy put the question. Could the Minister not answer easily enough, by giving an estimate of the number of cases in which remissions have been made by himself or by the Government of penalties imposed by the courts?
Comment on this
The Deputy wanted the percentage of reductions of fines.
Comment on this
Reductions of fines or sentences of imprisonment. I want to get the number of cases in which the Minister or his Department interfered with the decision of the court.
Comment on this
I gave the Deputy that. He wanted the details segregated.
Comment on this
I think in about 140 cases. I will get the Deputy the figure.
Comment on this
I do not want to tend towards any anti-racial feeling in the country at all, but there is a suspicion in the city that people of a certain religion or of a certain race are more favoured in respect of these remissions than other people.
Comment on this
I am very glad to hear the Minister now state clearly and precisely that there is no truth in that suggestion.
Comment on this
I feel very disturbed over this question of the outbreak of crime. Deputy Cleary has, I suggest, a completely wrong view of the situation. He said, first of all, that we are to be congratulated that, with all the turmoil in the world and with all the upsetting of standards, we have only got to the point we have reached. The point we have gone to is that the indictable offences have doubled. Here we are, in a bit of a backwater, as far as the ordinary currents of world thoughts are concerned. We pride ourselves on being a Christian country as well as an agricultural country—we use the two slogans— and we are supposed to be protected more by our religion than a great many other communities. We adhere strongly to Christian tradition, yet at this particular period crime has doubled in four years.
At the same time, there is an outbreak of a sort of kill-joy spirit, given expression to in this House. Listening to some of the speeches, one would think that all the vice in the country can be traced back to either cinemas or dances. Dances are a proper form of amusement and are, in the main, properly used. There is a commercialised type of dance hall, to cope with which various efforts have been made, without any great success, unfortunately. There can be, and frequently has been, abuse of drinking.
I have occasionally been—more often than I want to be—in a District Court, when I saw Guards solemnly sworn, in a sort of chorus, and then saw a lot of unfortunate youngsters being paraded for playing football in the streets. The district justice's time and the time of a certain number of Guards was taken up and young people and their parents were all brought in to answer to the charges and to pay small fines, because the youngsters were kicking football in the streets. I sometimes wish I may live to see the day when a decent healthy-minded district justice will adjourn his court and go out to see the places where those youngsters kick football and have a game with them. I have known people fined for playing football in streets where there was no traffic at all likely to bring them into danger and where the street was so wide and the houses so definitely set back from the street that it was almost beyond the strength of the youngsters playing with the bit of a ball to do any damage whatever to property.
The other side of that picture must be shown. I can only place this particular matter in a very small percentage of the cases I have heard talked of. I have known people brought up from areas I know of and where the people in charge of the city playgrounds have made no provision for the young people to get any amusement anywhere in the neighbourhood. These youngsters are driven to the streets, those healthy young boys have some little bit of animal spirit and, God knows, they are innocent enough if all they do is to kick a ball about the streets.