We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 32—Office of the Minister for Justice (Resumed).

Contributions 186–367 of 367. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I know of certain places where there is no traffic.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

They would follow a ball under a car.

Comment on this

I am talking of back streets and side streets—streets where the appearance of a car would be noticed. I am talking of things that have happened in the last three or four years.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I have seen children rush into the road after a ball, right under a car.

Comment on this

I know enough about the ordinary courts to know that that sort of thing occurs. There are these other cases. In any event that is one part of this problem of the juvenile delinquent. What are you going to do with these lads? Are they not going to be allowed to amuse themselves? If no playing fields are provided for them they must amuse themselves somehow. Amongst the district justices dealing with those cases there is great humanity. When boys are paraded before them in court a small fine is imposed. If the lad does not appear a heavier fine is imposed. Some of the lads that I have seen around the courts seemed rather glad to have the day from school.

Deputy Dillon, as is his habit on these occasions when dealing with this matter of the juvenile delinquent, was very eloquent and sincere. The Minister has been asked to visit various places—the prisons, Civic Guards' barracks and so on. I wonder if he has ever visited a District Court, particularly when young people are up and seen the sort of atmosphere that is there? The atmosphere is such that one feels the boy has now got into a position in which there is really no saving him. There used to be the old criminal test of subjecting people to ordeal by fire, and later the test of water. In the case of certain crimes people were pitched into a lake. If they escaped it was a sign that they had certain supernatural and magical powers, and then they were destroyed. If they sank it was a very clear proof that they were innocent. That is how one feels about some of those children who come into the courts. If they are put into prison one wonders what their associations there are going to be. Unfortunately, it is very easy for a boy to take a wrong turning at a particular point. It may be that he will be chastened by his experiences and will set himself right or that he may become a little bit of a gangster hero and will take the wrong turning.

The part of the judiciary that comes in contact with those juvenile offenders have the feeling, I think, that they are not doing much good simply by listening to a sordid story and then imposing such punishment as seems to fit the offence. I do not think they believe they are doing as much good as they do, say, with the hardened criminal. If they cannot reform him at least they will try to preserve society from him. The juvenile offender is an entirely different matter.

Most judicial people who come in contact with those juveniles are rather saddened and heartbroken by the fact that the only resources that this civilisation of ours can offer is to establish people who will rule according to certain rules on the cases that come before them. None of them feel, I think, that any great good is being done. Appeals have been made to the Minister for the appointment of more probation officers. It is considered that a little more expenditure under that heading would produce better results. I know that the Minister may be advised that the people who speak about more probation officers are really first-class cranks in the community. Some of those at any rate are people of brains and capacity as far as social conditions are concerned. They think that some other way than the brutal business of sending young people to jail might be adopted to effect reforms. I have heard some of these people say that if there is anything wrong about various matters you see the Government jumping in. The appointment of warble fly inspectors is one example. The Government can find money for warble fly inspectors, but it will not add to the six probation officers in the Dublin courts. That indicates the stingy outlook they have in the matter of reform. The Department of Finance appears to block every effort made in the way of correction or prevention especially in this matter of juvenile crime.

Deputy Connolly spoke with great feeling on this matter. Many people have been thinking over this juvenile problem and looking out for a better solution of it, one that would regard the juvenile delinquent as more a matter for psychological observation and analysis, for the attachment to him of a doctor instead of a police officer. People are thinking along the lines that if you could dig down into the mind of the juvenile delinquent you would get a response. As Deputy Dillon said, there may be something crabbed in a fellow's nature which has made him an object of scorn amongst his fellows. He reacts to that and becomes a bit of an enemy of the people around him. Many people are thinking that if you could give those lads a healthier outlook you might make something out of them. If the Minister ever had the experience—I do not wish to suggest for a moment that he ever had—of finding someone related to him who had fallen foul of the law as a juvenile and of being pushed off on a sentence, he would have a very much better appreciation of this problem than he will ever get from reading statistics with regard to crime.

I feel that I am talking to a person who is sympathetically disposed but who, for the last 10 or 12 years, must have felt the overwhelming power of the Department of Finance. He is probably tired of butting his head against the immovable people who control finance. I suggest to him that he would get the approval of this House if he made a further attack on them— in this time of great extravagance in spending—for some additional expenditure on the part of the State in an attempt to save people from going wrong or to reform them instead of going on with this brutal business of pushing them into jail.

There is one other matter that I want to refer to. It did not arise last year but I can raise it hypothetically. I asked before, in connection with the officers of judicial institutions in this country, whether any thought had been given to that provision in the Constitution which says that judges are not eligible to hold any other office or position of emolument. I raised this before when a particular judicial person had got from the State a licence which certainly gave him profit and emolument. I was told I think by the present Minister that the matter had been enquired into, and that the legal advice was that the licence given to him by the Minister's colleague could not be withheld. Some time or another somebody is going to have to make a decision on what the words "any other office or position of emolument" cover. It is, of course, open to the Minister to put up regulations of his own in respect of people who are appointed to judicial office. I stress these words because they will be repeated with regard to other people; we repeat them with regard to the President of the country and they are repeated with regard to the appointment of a new Comptroller and Auditor-General.

When this matter was before the House on a previous occasion I raised the point whether it was not highly undesirable that a judicial person should be enabled to get a licence for a premises and have a licensed premises run in his name. I gathered that it might not be desirable, but it was not prohibited by the Constitution. There is only one actual case in which that occurred. The Minister is entitled to make his and the Government's point of view clear with regard to what profits other than judicial or other salaries people of this type will get.

We made an appointment yesterday. That person is not a judicial person, but he is put on the footing of a judicial person as far as the Consituation is concerned. I do not think it is desirable that any of these highly-placed officers should have any source of emolument other than their salaries. There is a considerable difficulty in applying that rigidly. If people invest their money, they are entitled to some return. Supposing a person buys out a concern—I am not speaking of an actual case—he is entitled to draw the whole of the profits of that concern.

I think what we are aiming at in the Constitution has been entirely broken or departed from. I think what was back of that phrase when introducing the Constitution was that you wanted to put a person in a way that he would always be able to judge himself objectively and without partiality. The way you achieve that is to say that this person will have no touch with the outer world, as it were; he will have his money in one way only, so that in the event of cases coming before him nobody can say that he was prejudiced because of his association with a particular company or a particular type of emolument, or was in a special type of business whereby his judgment might be perverted.

This matter will arise from time to time. It has arisen in the case of a judge who is no longer a judge. It will arise with regard to others, and it will arise with regard to other appointments. I suggest to the Minister that it is about time somebody gave an authoritative interpretation of what is in the Constitution. The Government are entitled to put further restrictions than those set out in the Constitution on certain people and I think the Minister should make the point clear as to what his position will be with regard to people who hold any other office or position or any post from which they can get emoluments.

I have referred to the emergency bonus. It represents a 10 per cent. addition to the salaries of certain officials. The cost of living has gone up to 70 per cent. The Guards have got an alleviation to the extent of 10 per cent. and to that degree they are better off than others. I do not know if it has occurred to people, when they are considering the increase in crime, to associate that with the economic conditions under which numbers of people are expected to live in the country. There is an Article in the Constitution which deals with the family. We regard the family as a natural, primary and fundamental group of society.

It is rather noticeable that in this Constitution, having made that pious expression of our attitude, which is following out the Christian condition with regard to the antecedent rights of the family as a unit, we separate it from the Article dealing with private property. The encyclical from which that particular paragraph is copied goes on to refer to the obligation to pay a family wage. Can it be said that the majority of the Guards, even with the 10 per cent. emergency bonus, are getting a family wage? That, of course, is one of the things that is contrary to the spirit if not of the special encyclical, certainly to the tenor of encyclicals generally, because the tenor is that the parents in charge of the family should be looked to, in the matter of the family wage and its provision, and not the benefaction of the State. In any event, the Minister surely ought to face his responsibilities in connection with the people who are expected to set standards with regard to law and order. We know from the Estimates what is given to the ordinary rank and file of the Guards. The Minister ought to consider that matter seriously.

He must have given hours of thought to the outbreak of crime. I think that he associated the outbreak of crime with a number of articles that are in short supply. He said the vast increase in crime in the country, the larceny and housebreaking, might be associated with articles in short supply. Is there not another factor to be considered? The people who are getting small wages find that they have to count their pounds as worth so many 11 shillings, and yet they are expected to keep up the same standard of life. That is more likely to be the cause of people breaking out into the larceny of goods than merely that certain articles are in short supply.

If the Minister wants some radical reform in this country, he will have to move outside his own Department. He might depict for the Government the very sad situation the country is brought to through the failure of certain colleagues of his. I imagine that if the Minister will get in touch with people on the judicial bench he will find corroboration of what I say, and that is, that it is the desperate straits to which people are driven by the fact that the pound has such a small purchasing power that is the greatest cause of the increased crime. I doubt if the Minister will see any betterment of that situation, apart from the world movement of ideas outside. The Minister will see that as long as this country is compelled to live in the shockingly degraded conditions under which the vast majority are obliged to live at the moment there cannot be any improvement. I have asked and pleaded that the people with the small money should have their situation better regarded.

I move to another group now. Judges are, amongst the people in the country, a group specially singled out. They are the people who have adopted this attitude—that they should be put beyond all reach of temptation in the carrying out of their independent office by having themselves put on a particular salary scale in which they will enjoy amenities of life. Judicial salaries were fixed many years ago. They are worth about half now what they were when fixed. It was very often hard to get people who were in a good way of practice even to accept the old rate of judicial emolument. It was not so much the rate of pay was the incentive, it was more the fact that when a man was retired from the judicial bench he had a very good pension. Both salary and bonus are to be weighed in the light of the present run of prices, and not merely in the light of the present run of prices but with some idea of what prices will fix themselves at in the post-war period. I think that as a special group the judicial people should be singled out for better treatment. Amongst other things, I think a judge is entitled to say that he has attained a particular office, that he has been picked out for that, and that he ought to have certain privileges amongst them the capacity to be able to provide better for his children in the way of education and everything else than other people who have not been picked out for the same attainments that he has. Judicial people can say that they are in an exceptional position. I think it would be part of the duty of the Minister if he wants to keep the courts in the position in which he found them—nobody will accuse me of saying that the judges have lapsed from their high standards because of the impact of prices on the particular salaries they receive—to give some consideration to that matter, and that the level of judicial salaries ought to be raised higher—at least it ought to be put at the point where what judges get is able to buy more or less what it used to buy. That would mean a considerable increase in the actual monies they get.

Comment on this

There are just three or four points which I should like to stress. The first is with regard to those people of whom Deputy Dillon gave a pretty fair account yesterday. They have become a great nuisance in the West lately. The Minister for Justice I think will get co-operation from the local Gárda in dealing with them. On a recent occasion they created pandemonium in Ballaghaderreen. It took the Gárda and the Local Defence Force to rout them out of the town. It is a common practice with them to let in their horses and asses into a farmer's field. That would not be very serious at the present time, but it could be very serious in the autumn when the corn crops would be ripe. On one occasion I saw 80 asses put into one field. If you turn 80 asses into a cornfield for a night, you can imagine what the result will be. The Department should take some steps to try to check these liberties which these people seem anxious to take.

With regard to dances, about which a good deal has been said, I have not seen any abuses in my town, and we have a great many dances there. That may be due to the fact that licences for bars have not been sought for these dances. Generally, an energetic and representative committee runs these dances, and they are being carried out very creditably. There have not been any disgraceful scenes that I am aware of.

I should also like to take this opportunity of paying a compliment to the Gárda in Roscommon and in every other county that I happened to go through during the recent election. I came across a great number of them in the various districts in Roscommon and in some of the adjoining counties, and I must say that they carried out their duties very impartially. With regard to recruiting for the Gárda, I agree with a good deal of what Deputy Ó Cléirigh said. Deputy Ó Cléirigh, however, seemed to think that Deputy Cogan had a different point of view. I discussed the matter with Deputy Cogan, and his point of view and Deputy Ó Cléirigh's are somewhat similar. Deputy Cogan suggested that the standard of education for recruits would want to be higher, but he informs me that what he meant by that was that in a couple of years there will be a large number of Guards retiring from the Force and that for a pretty large number of Guards to be eligible for the position of officer it will be necessary that a large percentage of them should have a pretty high standard of education. Outside of that, I think it must be recognised that both the R.I.C. and the Gárda were recruited from the middle-class farming and labouring community, and that both forces proved to be satisfactory. As they are reared in the country and lead an open-air life they are the people who are the most suitable for recruits. They are of a hardy nature and are generally of strong physique, and I think they are really the most suitable people for the position. As I say, these two forces were recruited largely from that class of people and, as that has been so successful, I think it should be continued. I know there has been a growing feeling in the country for some time that the ordinary farmer's son who has only received an ordinary national school education has no chance of getting into the Gárda. A great many of them have not applied, because they felt they would have no chance against those who had a secondary education and who, as Deputy Ó Cléirigh said, applied to become members of the Gárda because they cannot get some other position. I should like the Minister to give us his point of view on that matter, so that young boys in the country could know whether they were eligible or not. If the ordinary national school education is not considered a sufficiently high standard, there is no use putting them to the expense and trouble of applying.

There is just one other point with regard to the prisoners. I never believed in physical force and I do not believe in it at present. We should congratulate ourselves on the fact that comparative peace has been restored to us. I think it was last June that there was prolonged discussion on those matters. I was one of those who suggested at that time that it would be useful if a committee representative of every Party in the House were appointed to visit those prisoners. At the time, if I remember rightly, various complaints were made by the prisoners that they were being treated badly. The Minister for Justice told us that they were not, and Deputies were not in a position to get first-hand information. If they had that first-hand information they could go down to their constituencies and point out that they had definite information that things were as good as could reasonably be expected.

With great respect, I suggest to the Minister that he should consider that matter again. He has told us something like 300 have been released, and no grave happenings have resulted. If this committee were appointed, it would be able to assure the House, and Deputies in turn could assure their constituents, that everything possible was being done, and that those people, as the Minister said, have the key in their own pockets if they wish to avail of it. Those are the only points I wish to raise. The larger questions have been dealt with more efficiently than I could have hoped to do.

Comment on this

I agree with other speakers that we have every reason to congratulate ourselves on the efficiency of the Civic Guards. People are sometimes inclined to think that the Civic Guards are not sufficiently efficient; they forget that a certain amount of responsibility rests upon the ordinary citizen as far as giving assistance to the Guards is concerned. I think it will be admitted by every decent-minded man in the country that our Civic Guard force is a credit to everybody concerned. The Government and the country have reason to be proud of it.

I would suggest to the Minister that something should be done about providing proper housing accommodation for members of the Force. In many cases they find it very difficult to procure suitable accommodation. That applies particularly to members with large families. I think that the Department should ensure that suitable accommodation, adjacent to the barrack, will be made available for them. I would also suggest that, particularly in the case of married members of the Guards, it would be a good thing if the Minister could see his way to pay their salaries every two weeks. It is difficult, especially in view of the great increases in prices, to budget over a four weeks' period, and it would be a very definite convenience to the household if payment of salary were made every two weeks.

I would also suggest that, particularly in country areas, the Sunday closing regulations should not be strictly enforced. After a very hard week's work, I think a man is entitled to a few pints on a Sunday, and the Civic Guards should be instructed by the Minister for Justice not to be too hard on those country men who like to get a drink after Mass on Sundays. They should get at least an hour or so to get a well earned refreshment after the week. I would ask the Minister to instruct the Guards to close their eyes to small things that might happen during that period.

I do not think licences should be allowed for bars in dance halls. I do not object to dances, not even to all night dances, but I do object to having a bar on the premises. Parents throughout the country have a real objection to allowing their sons and daughters—particularly their daughters—to attend dance halls which have a bar attached. Only too often we hear of deplorable incidents in such halls, and I think it is demoralising to the youth of the country that such state of affairs should exist. As I said, I have no objection to dances. They are a great source of entertainment to boys and girls. They cannot be expected to spend all their time at home. They have a right to their legitimate amusements. We are living in a modern world, and I think nobody will deny them that right. I would ask the Minister to see to it that licences for bars in dance halls are not allowed in any circumstances.

Comment on this

I have listened to Deputies attacking dance halls, picture houses and travelling people on the roads. Those travelling people buy donkeys from small farmers in the district, and in the course of their journeys at the present time they do very useful work making galvanised buckets, when buckets are not to be had in the hardware shops. They are not as dangerous as certain speakers made them out to be. They are human beings and they have to live. They have their own way of living and I do not see why attacks should be made upon them from all sides. They are living in their own way and they never interfere with others. They may brawl amongst themselves, but they never interfere with anyone outside their own circles. Every one of us must make a living—we are not all lucky—and I think it is very unfair that all Parties should be attacking these people. They are horse dealers and many farmers buy horses from them. They are very useful for the farmers. They go down to Cork and buy donkeys which they sell to people around County Wexford, to cottage people and others who want donkeys. It is very hard to get them, and, but for these people, they would not be available. They go to Connemara and buy ponies. They are not all beggars —some of them are wealthy men.

There is one matter which no Deputy dwelt on sufficiently, that is, the position of poor people who go out gathering firing in the form of a few bits of sticks. These people are brought to the District Court and fined 40/-. Some of them are unemployed men, and that is an outrageous fine to impose on an unemployed man or a poor woman for gathering sticks to light a fire during the bad times through which we are passing. The Minister should instruct district justices not to be too hard on these poor people.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is asking the Minister to interfere with the administration of the courts of justice.

Comment on this

The Minister could use his good offices all the same. With regard to what has been said about dances, all parties run dances. The Labour Party, the L.D.F. and various other people run dances, and I suggest that the hours of 10 p.m. to 4 a.m. are not suitable, because it often happens that people are put out at 4 o'clock in the morning and cannot get into the places where they work. It is a bad hour to turn out boys and girls when they cannot get into the places where they are employed. It would be better if the dances went on until 7 a.m. and I say that as one who often goes to dances.

We have had references to the prisoners, and I should like to see all the prisoners released. I have here the name of a man arrested on 5th December, 1942, and released on 4th June, 1943—Séamus Ó Ceallaigh, 23 Laoighis Road, Cabra. This poor young man has the use of only one hand and his typewriter, his only means of making a living, was taken from him and is at present held by the authorities. I ask the Minister to restore it to this young man, who told me that it is his only means of livelihood.

With regard to district justices and black-marketing cases, I remember the case of a woman in Wexford who was fined £5 in connection with the sale of a box of matches. That was a very heavy penalty to impose in such a case because black-marketing is going on all over the country. Deputies have spoken about pictures, but fewer people will go to the pictures now, owing to the electricity restrictions, and I do not think it is right for Deputies to condemn amusements, because these amusements provide revenue for the Government. In attending picture-houses, dog-tracks and so on, we are paying a certain amount in taxation to the Government, and if we do away with the little sport going on in the country at present we will have very little amusement.

There has also been reference to drinking in dance halls, but I never saw a bar in a dance hall in my own town of Enniscorthy. I have been out at dances in the country and I saw no bars there either. I do not know where these bars are used, but dancing is going on all over the City of Dublin, and, when one leaves this House, one meets ladies and gentlemen going to dance halls in the city and it is probably to these dance halls that Deputies were referring. I see none of this wholesale drinking in County Wexford, and I was surprised to hear some of the West of Ireland Deputies giving their own constituencies such a bad name. I would not like to do it for my constituency, because if they see that going on, they must take part in it themselves. I have been at as many dances as Deputy Cafferky or other Deputies, and I see none of this drinking going on, in County Wexford, anyhow.

Finally, I ask the Minister to restore to Seamus O Ceallaigh, of Cabra, the typewriter which is his only means of livelihood. I do not think the Government need be afraid of a disabled man. I know some of the young men from my own town who were released. What happened to them? There was no work for them. They could not get to England to work, and they had to join the Air Force. That is where some of these poor young fellows who were put into internment camps without trial have ended up—in the British Army.

Comment on this

The first matter I want to raise is the matter of prison reform. We have operated as a separate political entity for the past 20 years, and, in the main, we simply administered a system of prison regulations which we inherited on the change of Government. It is perfectly true that certain minor administrative and executive reforms have been carried out in the meantime, but no really serious attempt has been made to study our methods of detention, our prison regulations, or the conditions under which prisoners are detained, or to endeavour to effect any kind of reformation from the standpoint of the prisoner, whether he be a veteran prisoner or just an occasional miscreant. One of the most objectionable features of our present prison code is that we commit young persons—mere youths and adolescents —to mix in prison with incorrigible offenders who know every artifice of the prison, know every trick in the criminal code and who, in idle moments in prison, are quite capable of imparting to youthful and accidental offenders many of the tricks which they have learned in a long life of crime.

I understand there are no regulations at present for segregating youthful offenders from the more hardened type of criminal. I do not think it is calculated to induce reformation, so far as the young person is concerned, by permitting any association whatever between the relatively youthful prisoner and the person who, apparently, has decided to embark on a course of crime and in respect of whom no methods of reformation are likely to be effective. I think it is the experience of persons responsible for dealing with prisons that any association whatever between the youthful offender and the incorrigible criminal is likely to result in the youthful offender being taught new and very vicious methods.

There should be an examination of the whole prison regulations, to ensure that youthful offenders—I do not mean mere boys of 17 and 18, but those up to 22 and 23 years of age—should not be permitted to have any intercourse with the more hardened type of criminal whose methods, habits and knowledge present one of the greatest possible problems to those charged with prison administration. If prison is to act as a deterrent on youthful prisoners, or even on the adult prisoner who has fallen for the first time, it is essential that in our prison administration we should recognise by a different method of treatment and by a different code of regulations that the first offender or the youthful prisoner is viewed differently by the State to the manner in which the inveterate offender is viewed.

In that connection, one of the blanks in our whole prison code is the fact, that at present it merely exists for the purpose of detaining persons who have broken the law, and no effort whatever is made to use the prison service or prison code to impart education or vocational training to those who, unfortunately, have lapsed and are compelled on that account to spend a long period of incarceration. Many of the prisoners sentenced to long terms of imprisonment spend their time in the kitchen, or on the farm—if there is a farm attached—or in the laundry or garden, or doing the thousand and one routine things to be done in prison. No attempt, however, is made to plumb the depths of mind of the prisoner, no real endeavour is made to point out to the prisoner the evil effects which inevitably follow any embarkation on a course of wrong-doing. No serious attempt is made to woo a prisoner away from the criminal path. The whole purpose of our prison regulations seems to be merely to detain people, to treat them there with all the rigour inseparably associated with prison life, and no effort whatever is made, so far as I can see, to wean them away from the path of crime and induce them to take a new, a healthier and a more idealistic view of citizenship.

To be effective at all, our prison code must endeavour to make psychological examination of prisoners. Many of the persons who break the law are persons who up to then have been excellent citizens and against whom no charge of want of rectitude could be levelled. Many of them have been guilty of isolated lapses, due often to environment, to personal association with other persons, to want of proper appreciation at the time the offence was committed, or to want of an accurate sense of wrong-doing. It is important, if there is to be respect for the law, that efforts be made to effect some psychological reform in such persons.

We have now had 22 years' experience of our present prison code. From statistics, nobody would pretend to believe that the existence of our prisons or of our criminal code is such as to induce people to avoid prisons. Statistics show that, apart from political crime, the state of ordinary crime is alarming and something with which those interested in the welfare of the State cannot be in any way pleased. For the past 22 years, prison has been, in the main, just a place of detention, with all that kind of brutalising and blighting influence which goes with rigorous prison life. I recognise, of course, that prison life cannot be a kind of garden tea-party. There must be restrictions and the wrongdoer must be punished. I prefer to believe, however, that there is a much better dividend for the State, in the long run, if prisoners can be weaned away from the criminal path.

The time has now arrived when the Minister or the Government might usefully set up a commission of inquiry into our prison service, methods and procedure and into our criminal code so far as detention is concerned. The commission might consist of persons who, while wanting to mark disapproval of wrongdoing, will also recognise that the main purpose of prison life should be to woo the evildoer back to the path of virtue. Unless our prison service results in humanising people and teaches those incarcerated the benefits of being physically, morally and educationally elevated, the whole purpose of prisons will be defeated. Instead of being merely a place of detention, the prison should be a place of correction. There is nothing in our present service to indicate that that matter is receiving the attention and consideration it should receive at the hands of those responsible.

If prison is to be just a memory of rigorous treatment so far as the prisoner is concerned, and merely leaves an influence on the prisoner that his period in prison was accompanied by very rigorous hardship and often brutalising treatment, our detention of persons fails completely to achieve its real purpose, namely, to effect reform in the prisoner and induce him to go back to the path of virtue.

I suggest, therefore, to the Minister that, having had experience of our prison administration during the past 22 years, some steps should now be taken to set up a commission of inquiry to investigate the operation of the whole prison service with a view to effecting such reforms as are likely to have a much better effect on prisoners than the present service has. As I have said, crime statistics do not show that prison is a deterrent so far as prisoners are concerned. It is a noticeable feature of our prison administration that no real effort whatever is made to inculcate any love of high virtue on the part of prisoners or to look after a prisoner once he has been discharged from prison custody. I hope, therefore, that the present Minister who, I think, is sympathetically disposed in a matter of this kind, will be able to see his way to set up a commission of inquiry so that we may evolve a prison code something different from the code which we have inherited. The prison code which we are administering to-day is simply the code which we inherited with this difference, that the code which we inherited in 1921 or 1922 has undergone many useful reforms so far as Britain is concerned. We, however, cling to the worst aspects of that code. In Britain a new type of prison is being erected. It is a considerable advance on anything that we have got here. They have new and better methods for dealing with prisoners in Britain, and a much more serious effort is made to educate prisoners in Britain than there is here. Our whole prison methods are confined to a mere detention of the prisoner. No effort whatever is made to impart any education to the prisoner such as might be calculated to bring him back to the path of rectitude.

On this Estimate I want to raise the question of the administration of the Gárda Compensation Act of 1941. When passed, its purpose in the main was to deal with a situation which had arisen out of the murder of Gárdaí throughout the country in 1940 and in earlier years. When the 1941 Act was going through the House, I think the Minister gave an assurance that the claims of the next-of-kin of Gárdaí who had lost their lives prior to the 1st January, 1940, and who were not covered by the retrospective provisions of the 1941 Act, would be sympathetically reviewed. I understand that efforts have since been made to secure a review of the cases of the next-of-kin of Gárdaí who lost their lives prior to the 1st January, 1940. But although every possible effort has been made to induce the Minister to review these cases in accordance with what, I think, was an implied assurance in 1941, so far not a single one of them has been reviewed with any beneficial effects, so far as the next-of-kin of deceased Gárdaí are concerned. The position prior to the 1st January, 1940—that is prior to the effective date of the 1941 Act—in the case of a Gárda who was murdered or lost his life because of the malicious intent of other persons, was that an action on the part of the next-of-kin could not succeed unless the next-of-kin were in a position to prove that there was personal malice against the Gárda who was murdered or against the Gárda who was maimed and seriously injured. A number of cases were brought before the courts prior to the 1st January, 1940. In these cases efforts were made to establish that the circumstances of the Gárda's death were such as to justify the substantiation of a claim for the payment of a certain scale of compensation, but, because of the difficulty of proving personal malice against the deceased Gárda, practically all these cases failed. Certainly, large numbers of them were lost, and the next-of-kin were placed in the unfortunate position that not only did they get no compensation but they were privileged to pay the costs of an unsuccessful legal action.

As I see it, the obvious purpose of the 1941 Act—I think the Minister indicated that it was so at the time—was to remedy a flaw in the legislation which was operative prior to the introduction of that measure, and to give the next-of-kin of members of the Gárda Síochána who lost their lives through malice or physical violence in the course of the execution of their duty the opportunity of going before the courts and claiming such compensation as the courts believed that they were entitled to. The Gárdaí at that time believed that the Act would be generously interpreted by the courts and that in its interpretation what are described as Lord Campbell's scales of benefit would be made operative so far as scales of compensation were concerned. Since the 1941 Act became law a number of claims for compensation have been brought before the courts, but the result of them has only served to disillusion the members of the Gárda force because they now see that the presentation of claims under the 1941 Act, which was intended, I think, to remedy the flaws in the pre-1941 legislation, has only served to place Guards in as bad, if not in a worse position, than they were in prior to 1941.

Since the 1941 Act was passed, a number of claims for compensation have been brought by the next-of-kin of Gárdaí who were murdered or of those who were seriously injured in the course of their duties. The maximum award in death cases has been the sum of £650. I suggest to the Minister that an award of that sort is completely at variance with the spirit in which the 1941 Act was conceived and completely contrary to the spirit in which it was passed by the Dáil. My recollection of the discussions on the 1941 Act convinces me that, so far as the House is concerned, it was genuinely anxious that the dependents of any Guard who lost his life in the execution of his duty on behalf of the whole community should be generously treated by the legislature and generously treated by the courts. The results of the cases which have so far come before the courts do not in any way indicate that there has been a generous interpretation of the legislation passed by this House. Although the 1941 Act was introduced for the purpose of remedying flaws in the pre-1941 legislation and of providing fair compensation for the dependents of the Gárda Síochána who lost their lives in the execution of their duty, the Gárdaí are now in the position in which if they have the choice of being shot to pieces in the execution of their duty or of being knocked down by a motor car, it is much better for them to be knocked down by a motor car than to be shot to death in the execution of their duty. Suppose a criminal sets out to raid a bank, holds up a Guard and says to him: "I will shoot you to death or, if you like, you can fall under the motor car that is coming along and let me into the bank; if you do I will not shoot you." If the Guard were to enter into negotiations with the criminal and say: "All right; you get into the bank and I will fall under the motor car," the Guard's family would be better off by his falling under the motor car than by attempting to disarm the person who was about to rob the bank. I do not think our legislation ever contemplated a situation of that kind, but that is the fact and that is the result of the legislation which we have passed.

The fixation of compensation in the vicinity of a sum of £650 by the High Courts in recent cases, and upheld by the Supreme Court, means that if a Guard feels he is going out on a very dangerous job which is likely to result in his death, it is better for him to be knocked down by a motor car than to attempt to defend the property of the State or the lives of the citizens. I suggest that is a situation which was never envisaged when the 1941 Act was introduced. It is completely contrary to the spirit in which the Act was passed and it calls for immediate remedy if we are not to continue to inflict serious injury on those who are the custodians of law and order in this country.

Bad and all as that situation is, it is really worse when you follow the interpretation of the law by the courts in a recent case. It has been decided in a case in which a detective-sergeant lost his life that the awards made by the court are subject to this condition, that they must be governed by the value of the assets held by the deceased Guard. A case occurred some time ago where a detective-sergeant was shot in the execution of his duty. His widow brought a claim for compensation and, after hearing the evidence, the High Court awarded compensation. The case was appealed and the judgment of the Supreme Court was that the next of kin should get £650 as compensation, less the assets of the deceased sergeant. The sergeant who was shot dead in the execution of his duty had a house, valued approximately at £350, which he had willed to his wife. Out of the £650 compensation awarded to the widow and dependents the value of the house was deducted. The widow received the £650 compensation, less the value of the house, just as if the State had given the widow the house and not her husband, who had managed to gather together the cost of the house by prudence and thrift in the course of his service as a member of the Gárda Síochána.

I think that is an outrageous conception of the law. It is an outrageous situation that a member of the Gárda Síochána who loses his life in the execution of his duty and who leaves a widow and children, should be treated in that fashion. The interpretation of the Act results in the next-of-kin getting a low scale of compensation, but the most vicious and incomprehensible aspect of the matter is that whatever assets a Guard had through his thrift and prudence are deducted from the compensation which the widow gets.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is aware that in discussing an Estimate it is not permissible to criticise legislation or propose remedial legislation. The law was passed and the courts are bound to administer it, such as it is.

Comment on this

Before you took the Chair I was calling attention to the fact that, when the Bill was going through the House, the Minister indicated the purpose behind it, the spirit of it, and I was adverting to the atmosphere in which the Bill passed through the House. I am now endeavouring to direct the attention of the Minister to the fact that it was believed the Bill would remedy flaws in previous legislation. In its interpretation now it is doing anything but that. I want to call the attention of the Minister to the manner in which what I then believed was his assurance is now being implemented. I do not intend to delay much further on that point and perhaps the Chair will allow me to finish.

I suggest to the Minister, although this is a matter in which he ought to take the initiative, that where a member of the Gárda Síochána loses his life in the course of his duty we ought to provide a generous scale of compensation for his dependents. A generous scale is not being provided and if the Minister wants to get the Guards at the highest possible pitch of efficiency he will say to every member of that body: "If you serve the State and if, in the course of doing so, you lose your life and thereby deprive your wife and children of your company, assistance and the protection which you can give them, then the State will stand behind your widow and children and make sure they will not suffer hardship because of the loss of your income." I was saying that under a recent judgment the courts decided, in the case of a member of the Guards who lost his life, to award £650 to his dependents, less the amount of his assets. The value of the Guard's house was subtracted from the compensation awarded. If you pursue that further and if the Guard had a house valued at £700 and not £350, then the widow who had lost her husband would get no compensation at all because under the recent court ruling the assets exceeded the compensation and, therefore, no compensation would be paid.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will realise that the construction of the law is a matter for the courts. It is for us to make the law and the courts to construe it.

Comment on this

The Minister for Justice, when he was introducing the Bill, led us to believe that it was to remedy flaws and give the Guards a fair break. I suggest that far from getting a fair break they got a raw deal.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The Deputy is aware that it was an amendment to that Bill, at the request of the Opposition, including the Deputy, that was responsible for that position.

Comment on this

Of course I know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

If that Bill was passed as introduced, it would have been all right.

Comment on this

The Bill would have been all right, the Minister says, so now it is all wrong.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

It is going to be amended—the Deputy knows that as well as I do.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that. That will give me an opportunity of shortening my speech.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That was my object.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister has assured the House that the Act will be amended and that in the new legislation steps will be taken to ensure that reasonable compensation will be provided for the dependents of Gárdaí who die in the execution of their duty.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is right.

Comment on this

If the Minister gives that assurance, I have nothing more to say.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is quite right.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

I did not intend to intervene in this debate, but there have been a number of Deputies who talked about juvenile delinquency and who made a very strong case in relation to the bad effect that the cinema has on children's minds. I am prepared to admit that probably certain films are in no way suitable for children. But I do not believe that the increase in juvenile crime has been in any way caused by films. I can remember in my young days, when there were not quite as many picture houses as there are at present, when the Sexton Blake and Buffalo Bill books were supposed to be responsible. So far as I can remember, there was an exceedingly high moral tone in these little books. Virtue was always triumphant and wrong was always found out in the end. Anybody who took up these books would see that they could not have done any boy any harm. It was often said to me that it was very bad to read these, that it would affect my knowledge of English and that I might get very bad ideas. I do not know whether my knowledge of the English language was corrupted, but certainly my morals were not corrupted in any way by them.

The question of juvenile crime is a very big one to enter into exhaustively. It arises from a number of things; but I believe that social conditions are at the root of most crimes, whether adult or juvenile. If we improve our social conditions to the extent to which we would like to see them improved, juvenile crime will decrease and, of course, adult crime with it. Crime, of course, comes from many things, but it is the bad child of social conditions.

Another question I should like to touch upon is the health of the Civic Guards. Speaking from memory, I think that within the last year or two it was stated that the incidence of tuberculosis was pretty high among the Civic Guards. I do not know what information the Minister has on that matter, but I would be very glad to get the explanations that his experts advance for that situation. In a country such as ours it does seem wrong that amongst our Guards we should have a high tuberculosis rate, or at any rate a rate higher than the general rate of tuberculosis amongst police forces.

I should like to compliment the Minister on the way in which he handles juvenile crime. But I should like to say to him that, while a good measure of praise is due to him for the way in which he is beginning to tackle that problem, the country generally has not any reason to feel satisfied that we are really dealing with this matter in the very best possible fashion. We are beginning to realise that children are not necessarily criminals. While we are realising that, we do not seem to have the physical facilities for dealing with this matter— the proper remand homes and the properly segregated institutions, or at least enough of them. Our minds are awake to the problem, but we have not yet put our hands in our pockets and spent the necessary money. I am sure the Minister would be whole-heartedly in favour of such a policy and I would urge on him the necessity for that. Educated public opinion in this country will applaud any increased efforts that are made for dealing with this problem. We are one of the small countries of the world, and if the small countries have any contribution to make—and I believe they have— their contribution must lie largely in the things of the mind and in social order and justice. I personally will not feel satisfied until I see Ireland leading in this matter of dealing with juvenile and other crimes. I would put that point of view to the Minister, and I am certain that he will get the enthusiastic support of the people in dealing with that matter.

Comment on this

There are only a few points which I wish to put to the Minister. The first is the question of the attendance at dance halls. If I am not mistaken, the law as it stands provides that young people under 18 years of age should not be allowed into dance halls. There is great abuse in connection with that matter which I think could be easily dealt with. I understand that the onus is on the Civic Guards and the owners of dance halls to check the ages of those attending such dances. I think the Civic Guards or the dance hall owners should not have any liability in regard to that matter further than to get the names of the young people concerned and that the parents should be made responsible. Young people do not carry their birth certificates with them to dances, and when a Guard goes into a dance hall it is not easy for him to say whether young people are under 18 years of age. I think it should be made punishable for parents to allow their children under that age to go to dance halls, where it can be proved that they have given their consent, even tacit consent.

A good deal has been said about the power of films for good or evil on young people. Several Deputies suggested that special films should be provided for young people and I thoroughly agree with that. I think there should be special films for young people, as I believe that the films usually provided for grown-ups are not suitable for those under 16 years, or perhaps a year or two older. I think it would be a great step forward if something could be done along that line. It should be easy to provide suitable films for young people which would be good for them.

A good deal has been said on the matter of drink, and I think there should be some tightening up in that regard. There is no doubt that there are abuses, particularly by young people. Fortunately, it is only on a very small scale, but there is not a shadow of doubt that young people are indulging in drink. There is a danger that that might spread and become a great evil. There is no doubt too that young girls take drink, particularly at dances, and it is causing grave concern at the moment both to the parents and to the clergy. It does not happen very often, but from my own experience I know that that habit is creeping into the country districts. I suppose it is being copied from the so-called upper classes. It is only in its infancy at the moment, as most young girls have a natural abhorrence of drink, but the practice is definitely creeping in, and is causing great concern.

Yesterday evening, we had the strangest occurrence in this House. I think we must be the only Legislative Assembly in Europe that can claim to have a prophet amongst its members. Yesterday evening Deputy Dillon foretold that Deputy O Cléirigh would twist Deputy Cafferky's remarks on the subject of drink in County Mayo. He said that Deputy O Cléirigh had just left the House to lubricate his throat— I think those were the words he used— before returning to the fray. Strange to relate, that prophecy was fulfilled this evening. I do not want to defend Deputy Cafferky; there is no need to do that. But Deputy Cafferky is young; he may not be as cautious in the use of words as he will be when he has had more experience here in the House. Every Deputy is free to put whatever construction he likes on another Deputy's statements, but I was listening to Deputy Cafferky and I think he conveyed quite clearly that what he was referring to were the rare cases of abuse in connection with drink. I took it from Deputy O Cléirigh's speech here this evening that he was actually condoning drink. He said that the people of County Mayo were not by any means addicted to drink. Of course, the vast majority are not, the same as in any other county in Ireland, but we must take the rare cases into account. We would not condemn a whole flock of sheep because there is one black sheep amongst them, and neither do we condemn the whole countryside as drunkards simply because there are a few drunkards. What Deputy Cafferky clearly condemned is the fact that parents on some occasions allow their children in to public houses while they themselves are taking drink. Deputy Cafferky told nothing but the truth in that case, and I think it was a very unfair misrepresentation on Deputy O Cléirigh's part to construe his speech in that way.

A few Deputies, both on the Fine Gael and the Fianna Fáil Benches, think they have done their duty to their country and made a great contribution to the debate if they open their speeches with a broadside attack on Clann na Talmhan. We do not by any means apologise for our attendance here, and the Deputies who make those attacks seem to convey that they would like us to do so. I do not think there were four speakers on any side of the House during the debate on the Agriculture Estimate who did not open their speeches by an attack on us. I do not see what that contributes to the debate. My idea of a contribution to the debates here is that every speaker, whether he is a solicitor or anything else, should put his own views before the Minister. If he thinks the Minister and his Department have not done their duty, let them have it. That is my idea of a contribution to the debate—perhaps I am all wrong. I cannot see how far it gets this House or where it gets any Deputy to make an attack on any other Deputy. Deputy Ó Cléirigh on two occasions has devoted practically his whole speech to painting Deputy Cafferky as being this, that or the other thing. I cannot see how the House is interested in that kind of speech. Deputy Cafferky, to my mind, made a very good case in pointing out certain abuses that exist in South Mayo, his own constituency, and he was perfectly right in doing so. I take all this misrepresentation as a direct attempt at intimidation to prevent Deputy Cafferky and other members on the Clann na Talmhan Benches from speaking at all. I am sorry to have to take up the time of the House in referring to these matters, because I do not believe in personal abuse, but it has occurred so often that it has become disgusting.

I should like particularly to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that young girls are drinking. I do not know whether it is possible for him to take action in that regard. There is no doubt that, especially in the case of dances in towns, girls under 20 years of age, particularly around holiday time and Christmas, can be seen drunk, as a direct result, I believe, of being in company with male companions who are no better than sharks in human form. I think there should be more rigid supervision of the sale of drink on those occasions. The practice is only in its infancy yet, and now is the time to nip it in the bud. If the Minister or his officials can devise any means of checking it I think it is their duty to do so.

Comment on this
Gerald Boland Minister for Justice (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

I think the debate here was very good and very informative. It took longer than usual, but my opinion is that it was time well spent. There were some very useful contributions. I think the best line I can take is to go through the speeches of the different Deputies, and when I come to some point that I can raise generally I will spend some time on that. I will deal with most of the minor points raised, and I hope with all the major ones. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, who was the first speaker, seemed to suggest that I very lightly brushed aside the crime position. I do not think I did any such thing. I said it was an undoubted fact that crime had not increased since last year, but that still it was double what it was in normal times, and I deplored that. I gave what I thought was one of the reasons for that—the shortage of supplies. It is not confined to one section of the community. I think it was suggested last year that the unemployed and the poorer sections of the community were responsible. That is not so. We are aware that in times like these, when money will not buy everything, even those who have plenty of money will steal things. They might have money to buy them, but they cannot get them for money. We had cases of men with enormous salaries being put in the dock for stealing things which they would buy if they could get them. I think it is very largely the scarcity of commodities which people are not prepared to do without that is responsible for a lot of the increase in crime. I hope that will not be taken as an excuse for it, but that is the fact.

One of the best speeches I heard during this debate was made by Deputy Linehan. He really put the blame on the right shoulders. Some people are inclined to say that the schools are to blame; others will say that the Church has not done its work properly; but very few got as near the mark as Deputy Linehan, who put the major responsibility—some of the Clann na Talmhan Deputies also did so—on the parents. I think that is where the major blame belongs. There certainly is a lessening of parental control, and when children get to a certain age, when they reach their teens, it is rather late to begin to exercise control. I believe that is one of the most menacing situations we have to meet to-day with regard to juvenile crime—that parents do not exercise proper control over their children and that whatever efforts are made by clergy or teachers in schools are not backed up to the extent to which they should be by the parents.

Deputy Linehan also drew attention to another big failing from which the whole of the Irish people—it may be, and probably is, due to our history—suffer, that is, the reluctance on the part of practically any of us to help those in authority, to help the Guards. He instanced a case—I do not know whether it was an actual case or an example of what might happen —of 20 people watching a man stripping a bicycle, not one of whom would be prepared to give evidence. I think that is largely true, and so long as we have that spirit, so long as people do not recognise that the Guards are there to protect them, and until the people are prepared to co-operate with them, I do not think we shall get very far in arresting crime. We could talk about the causes of juvenile delinquency for ages, and I would very much like to have an exhaustive inquiry into its causes, to see what remedies could be suggested. I do not know whether I would be able to get any such commission going, but I shall look into it and see what can be done. My belief is that one of the major causes of the whole problem is this lack of parental control.

With regard to what is happening in relation to these offenders and the social position, so to to speak, of the children who have been dealt with, I got the police to compile certain information, which, I think, will be useful, relating to juveniles charged in 1942, which, I think, would be fairly representative of what happens in any year and setting out what these crimes are attributable to. In that year there were 3,350 cases. Of these the police held lack of parental control to be responsible for 1,348 cases; youthful gang influence, 354; criminal association, 109; ordinary mischief, 521; desire to get money for amusement, 832; and necessity, about 186. The occupations of the parents were: industrial workers, 266; agricultural workers, 299; casual labourers, 936; other occupations, 1,220; and no occupation, 629.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

What does "no occupation" mean?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I suppose people of no employment, but I really cannot say whether it means people who are unemployed or people who never worked at all. With regard to the types of houses these offenders came from, in the case of 498, they were from tenement houses; 1,064 were from houses of three rooms or less; and 1,788 from houses of more than three rooms. I think we can deduce from these figures that it is not the very poor who are responsible for most of these offences. The total number of boys between the ages of 12 and 18 in the Twenty-Six Counties in 1942 was in the neighbourhood of 200,000, and, of these, 2,340, or 15 per cent., were prosecuted during that year for indictable offences. As to how they were dealt with in the courts, of the 3,350 charged in that year, in 284 cases the charges were not proved, were withdrawn, were dismissed or otherwise disposed of, leaving 3,066 cases. The number of cases dismissed under the Probation of Offenders Act was 1,395; discharged on recognisances, 600; discharged under the supervision of a probation officer, 348; committed to care of relative or other fit person, 12; fined, 239; whipped, four; committed to industrial schools, 121; committed to reformatory schools, 130; sentenced to detention in a place of detention—like Summerhill, or the present place of detention, Marlboro House, for a very short time—19; sentenced to imprisonment, 119; and otherwise disposed of, 79. I do not know what the effect of these sentences on these children is likely to be.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Do the figures include school attendance?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

No, indictable offences. A question which has been raised several times and particularly by Deputy Connolly—and Deputy McGilligan referred to it to-night—is this question of the necessity for appointing more probation officers. Deputy McGilligan suggested that we had allowed Finance to stop us in this matter. I can assure him that that is not the case at all. I am not satisfied that extra probation officers will do the job, and I told Deputy Connolly, in answer to a question, that, after full consideration, my opinion was that societies of the type of the St. Vincent de Paul Society and others in different parts of the country can, on what is called application, become registered societies and grants may be made to help them in their work. I recommended Deputy Connolly to try to get that done in Dundalk and I now strongly recommend him to do so.

I know that the probation officers perform a useful function, but they simply cannot do this job. I believe the whole community will have to lend a hand, and societies of this kind, composed of public-spirited people—and there are, thank God, numbers of them in this country—should be encouraged in every way to help in this work. We have made a very good start in the city, as I have said several times. His Grace the Archbishop got in touch a couple of years ago with the Legion of Mary, and in each area they got volunteers to co-operate with the whole-time probation officers in helping to look after these children. Special classes have been held for probationers in different parts of the city. They have not been quite as successful as we would wish, but I think a good beginning has been made, and on these lines far more will be done, I think, than by employing another 16 or 18 probation officers. I have no objection to approaching Finance and would have no difficulty in getting the Minister for Finance to agree to give me any extra assistance of that kind which I want. I do think the money would be much better spent in making grants to organisations of the kind I have mentioned, who will look upon it as a social duty and privilege to help those young people who require it and try to get them into useful ways of life and away from crime.

I am well aware that a lot of this is due to the social conditions. I appreciate what Deputy McGilligan has said. I have not had the experience he has had in attending the court. I have never been in the Circuit Court. I realise the position and the difficulty. The Guards are told that football must not be allowed on the streets. As a general rule, if the Guards see that it is not likely to lead to any accident, I think they turn a blind eye to it. There may be cases where young Guards may be over-officious and haul a lot of these young boys in. I do not know to what extent that occurs. Deputy McGilligan seemed to think a lot of that is done.

The Deputy also pointed out the need for more playgrounds. I fully realise that, too. Until we are able to improve social conditions generally, especially in the large towns, it will be very difficult to rectify this situation. There is no use in blaming the Guards or the Government. It is a job in which we must all lend a hand. A start—a modest start—has been made, and certainly it is on the right lines. I do not think that lack of funds will be responsible if there is any failure. I appeal to Deputies to help as much as they can, by getting societies of that kind into the different districts. The Department will give all the cooperation possible.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

And make a grant for playgrounds?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am afraid that is not a matter for me. Certainly, I will do everything I can, as a member of the Government, in that matter. There was one question about whipping. I am going to take a chance of being put down as a brutal sort of person by my remarks. Some Deputy did say that, for the recent type of crime of snatching women's handbags and striking people on the head and robbing them, we will have to resort to that punishment. That may not appeal to Deputy Connolly, but I certainly stand for that. In the case of the district justice in Dundalk who sentenced boys to be birched, if it had not been for the flaw in the sentence, I would not have intervened. A lot of the evil is due to the parents not doing what they should do, that is, give them a good hiding and knock a bit of obedience into them. In the case of those particular boys, they had apparently got completely out of hand, and the parents had repudiated their responsibility. We cannot put them all into schools. If I were to make a suggestion to district justices, I would say that they should get more after the parents and fine the parents heavily. That may bring home to them the duty they have to the children they brought into the world, and make them realise they should not throw the whole burden on the State. So far, the number of sentences to birchings has been very small, but I am certainly not going to remove that from the Statute Book. It may be necessary, and if justices see fit to impose such sentences, I certainly am not going to interfere with their discretion. I do not care what name I get for that.

Comment on this

Will the Minister not agree that there is a great difference between a good hiding and a birching?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

There is. As far as I understand it, birching is not the good hiding it ought to be. There is that difference. The Guards who have the job of administering these punishments are big, hefty men with soft hearts. It may read ferocious and fierce, but if Deputy Connolly were present, he would have a different impression.

Comment on this

In other words, the Guards connive regarding the sentence.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I would like to see such young lads get a really good hiding from someone, if the justice thinks fit. If justices read my remarks, I suggest they consider punishing the parents, in order to bring home to them that it is their job. In saying all that, I know there is a fundamental cause for all this delinquency, both adult and juvenile. It is not to-day it arose: it is there, I suppose, from the beginning of time. The growth of modern civilisation, this top-heavy city idea, has contributed very largely to it. If there were some way we could devise, in our organisation of civilisation, to have smaller units rather than big cities, with their inevitable slums, there would be a better chance. I hope that the planners of the future will make some effort to bear that in mind, in designing towns from now on.

There is one healthy sign in the way that everyone is thinking of these things. We seem to be at a crisis of history, where big changes are being made, which may last for quite a long time. It is very hopeful and helpful to find in this House a concern for the way things are shaping, the way children are becoming delinquents and, particularly, the causes of that delinquency. When human beings set their minds to searching for causes, I believe they will succeed in finding the remedies.

Deputy Dillon has been very keen on the Borstal system. I do not know why it was given that name: I think it was from some house in England. It is a system of not treating boys altogether as children, but of trying to educate them to better ways. They are not prisoners with short sentences, they are a type of boys who show signs of becoming hardened young criminals. They have been before the courts and sentenced more than once. Generally, the judge feels: "If I send this boy to Mountjoy, in three or six months he will only be worse; I will send him to Borstal for three years and get the Department of Justice to try to make a good job of him."

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

From the frying pan into the fire.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I visited the Borstal Institute and, first of all, changed it from Clonmel to Cork Jail. I must say that Cork Jail is a very poor institution for a work of that kind. The trouble was that I had not Aladdin's lamp, and, in a time like the present, I could not produce a building, nor could the Office of Public Works produce one.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Ask Davy Frame.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Neither Davy Frame nor anyone else. We searched for houses. People glibly talk about that and say that houses can be obtained, but I found they would need such adaptation and reconstruction as would make the idea impossible. I have visited several of them and have come to the conclusion that we must get a virgin site and build a proper institution, with plenty of ground. That is my view. I was speaking to Deputy Dillon to-day about it, but he does not seem to agree. I have despaired of getting a building at the present time.

In the meantime, I claim that we have done something towards making this system more like what it was intended to be. The boys are not locked in cells as they used to be, but are left out until about 10 p.m. The Cork Jail is not suitable. We could not get a proper playground there. After some time we got in touch with those in charge of Cork University and they were kind enough to put one of their playing fields at the disposal of those boys. There is also a very useful institution in Cork City composed of public spirited citizens which is doing marvellous work of the Borstal kind. It is looking after those boys. They are given lectures, they are brought out for walks and cycle runs and to play football. They are taught shoe-making and carpentry. Generally speaking, an attempt is being made to make them what normal boys ought to be. I can say that from my own personal experience. Recently, when returning from playing football three of those boys bolted and so far they have not been caught. It was put up to me officially that, in consequence, I ought to stop this privilege which they have been enjoying. I said that I was not going to victimise the boys who did not run away for those who did. When the Guards catch those who ran away we will have to deal with them.

Comment on this

Send them back to Clonmel where they were taught all classes of trades.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Clonmel was not suitable either. When they were in Clonmel we could not get any sort of a playing ground for them.

Comment on this

They have hundreds of soldiers in the Borstal institution in Clonmel now.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I want the House to know that we are taking a practical interest in this question. I do not hope to solve it, but I hope before I leave office that steps will have been taken in that direction. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney spoke about crimes of violence. He said they were very much on the increase. Statistics, as we know, will prove almost anything. I have here some figures with regard to crimes of that sort—robbery with violence and assault with intent to rob. The figures relate to the period between 1927 and 1943. There was undoubtedly a big increase last year, but over the whole period there was not a big increase in that type of crime. In 1927 the number was 66, in 1928, 62. In 1929 the number went down to 42. In 1937 the number was 15. The figure started to rise again in 1940 and 1941. In 1942 it went down to 42. This year there has been a big increase as compared with last year. The number is 77. I know it is bad and I am not trying to make little of it or treating it complacently. At the same time, there is no use in saying that there has been an enormous increase. There has been an increase, I admit, in this very dangerous type of crime. I think that the robbery with violence that is now taking place is largely made possible by the partial black-out that we have.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

The Minister, I think, will admit that 1927 was a fallacious year to take for the reason that the crime at that time might be described as political. The present ones are more of a social kind.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I agree.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Is the Minister able to tell us the ages of the criminals?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

No. This is simply a return dealing with robbery with violence. It is a bad form of crime and has broken out recently. I admit that it is alarming. An army officer, a friend of mine——

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Close the public-houses at 10 o'clock and you will have less crime.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I do not think it is drunken people who are committing these crimes at all. This friend of mine, an Army officer, on his way home, was struck on the back of the head and robbed. Then there is a case which is sub judice at the moment where a man's body was found in the river. It looks as if it were one of these cases: that they did not mean to kill him but actually did and then threw the body into the water. The Guards are doing very good work in unearthing this class of crime. I think it will be found that there is some sort of a gang operating. One gang has been laid by the heels, and I believe the Guards will get to the bottom of that particular crime.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

The case that the Minister has referred to is the one that I had in mind where the man's body was found in the Liffey.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Attacks on women and young girls are also very serious.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think that is all I have to say about crime. Deputy Fitgzerald-Kenney spoke about dance halls. Deputy Blowick said that we could not expect the Guards to be at every dance hall, or the dance hall people to get the birth certificates of all the young people coming to the dances. Deputy Linehan and Deputy Blowick put the responsibility for these matters on parents and said that they should exercise more care. It would be hard to expect the Guards to follow young people to find out whether they were 18 years of age or not and whether they were going to dances.

On the question of drink, since the Intoxicating Liquor Act of last year was passed the Guards are now in a position to deal with anybody who attempts to get drink after 12 o'clock at night. I think they are trying to do that. As country Deputies are aware, the position prior to the passing of that Act was that once 12 o'clock came on a Sunday night people who lived three miles away from a public-house were entitled to go in and get drink. In fact, they could remain there until closing hour the next night. That is not possible now. I think that the Guards are enforcing this Act. They will have no excuse, if they are not doing so, by saying that they did not know whether the people found on the premises were bona fide travellers or not. Nobody is allowed to drink on licensed premises now after 12 o'clock at night except in cases where a special permit has been obtained from the district justice. Before the 1943 Act was passed, if there was a dance hall in a village, and a public-house near it, there was nothing, as I have said, to prevent people going into the public-house after 12 o'clock at night and getting drink. The Guards could not interfere with them. They often had a great difficulty in knowing whether the young people who went in for drink lived over the prescribed distance or not. That is no longer the case and, unless the courts give a special permission, the Guards will have no difficulty in bringing it home to the publican and to those on the premises.

Deputy Linehan made a very useful speech and I think it was he who said that perhaps the district justice would consider fining the people who go in after hours more heavily than the owner of the public-house. I think there is a lot of commonsense in that. It is rather hard to expect the person who owns the premises and who earns his living by it to turn out customers if they are there after hours. If the district justices will take notice of that and consider it, it might lead to an improvement. I think the position ought to be better as regards drinking at dances than it was last year. If it is not, then the Guards must be slack in the areas where it is done, because they have not the excuse they had before.

Comment on this

They drink until 12 o'clock and the dance goes on; they go back to the dance later and they kick up a row under the influence of the drink.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I know that they used to drink from 12 o'clock into the small hours of the morning.

Comment on this

Quite so.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

It is very hard to deal with some of these things. We cannot have the State interfering at every step. The whole community will have to take notice of this thing and the people will have to do their best to help. If we do not arouse public support it will be no good. It is not altogether a police job. The police cannot attend to everything.

As regards internment, when we were first interned in 1916 there is no question that that internment was one of the most foolish things the British Government ever did. We certainly did organise the whole of Ireland. But, after the Civil War, I was interned for a little over two years and it was quite a different situation. We had time to cool our heels, to weigh up the situation and to study the pros and cons. A prisoner is not going to humiliate himself to anybody. I would not do it, and we do not expect other men to do it. Nevertheless, they had their minds made up that it was futile, seeing they had been beaten in the fight that took place over the Treaty, to continue. The vast majority of the men interned felt like that. That was my own opinion from the day I was captured, but nobody knew it, because I would not let anybody know it. I was not prepared to eat my words. All the same, that was my opinion and it was the opinion held by others that it was absolutely futile to continue. Therefore, the internment in that case had quite a different effect.

I felt satisfied from a close examination of the people interned that I would be able to release so many. They were able to weigh up the situation and they asked themselves whether they would go on and what would it lead to and, except for the hard core that we were likely to have for a good while, the internment had a very good effect, a salutary effect, and it made these people far more reasonable than when they were interned.

I would like to draw attention to the changed situation that we are in to-day as compared with the time when the internment was first undertaken. We have a different House. In the last Dáil, from the very beginning of the internment, every Party in the House knew about it. We had our Defence Conference, and I could get the views of the main Opposition and the Labour Party, and any Independents I wished to consult, with the result that for the whole period of the internment there was not one question raised in the last Dáil. That shows that the position was fairly satisfactory, and people must have been satisfied. We had no fully organised L.D.F. then. In every area in the country there was an element which was likely to be a very serious menace. When the matter was raised last July, I drew attention to the circumstances in which we found ourselves when a certain document was captured, a document which planned, as far as we could see, for a projected invasion of this country, when that same organisation had actually carried out the operation that Deputy Anthony referred to to-day, the so-called war, and taken on themselves the right that only this House has.

That organisation, not very numerous, was still rather widespread in that there was scarcely a parish in which it was not represented. Consequently, to make sure of our position, it was felt by the whole House— otherwise the Government would not have got the powers—that it was absolutely necessary to take these people and prevent them doing what we were satisfied they were prepared to do if the opportunity arose. All Parties in the State combined; we got our local defence forces together and now we are in the happy position that there is not a corner of the country in which they are not strong. The result was that a lot of these people were released. I have been asked how many of these people went back on their word. I have not asked the majority of these people to give any undertaking whatever. I would not give very much for any undertaking.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

You said here that the keys were in their own pockets.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes, if they wished to avail of them. I think I know the case of every individual who is interned. It is not a question of examining a case to-day and again in six months. Almost every day I have gone into this matter, because I feel a personal responsibility, and I know how serious it is to take the liberty of a man even for one minute, not to mention a year. There are some men in there for four years. Others have been let out. I would not give tuppence for the word of most of them. Talking of undertakings, some are offering to give any undertaking, and I would not, from the information at my disposal, be prepared to risk letting them out. There are others with whom the Guards could easily deal if they got out of hand. That was why I referred to the keys being in their own pockets. As regards those who, up to this, claim that they have the right to involve us in war or, worse still, to take the life of any citizen here, as long as I have a say in the matter I certainly will not agree to let them out amongst the public. I have no right to do it.

Deputy McGilligan asked me how this matter would be dealt with. When the internment first started, there was a tribunal set up to review the cases of people interned. We put a High Court judge there, and only one or two cases went before him. I saw right away that it was going to be no good. I explained the whole matter to the Defence Conference at the time. I said that people who, I was perfectly certain, were aiding and abetting and very actively doing valuable work for this organisation, had been recommended for release by the tribunal, and things would not be easy if that system were to continue. It would mean that I would have to get evidence to convince the tribunal that it was not advisable to have those releases. If I had that evidence I would put it before the court. The organisation was of such a type that they worked in secret and conspired together and decided to take people's lives. They were able to cover up those who committed those crimes, and we had to intern them without trial for the reason that we simply could not get proof.

We know what the position of the last Government was. I was told about my attitude here to the Constitutional Amendment. I think I made my attitude clear in the speech that I made on that occasion. I undoubtedly did not support it. I may have been wrong, but I did think that, if a break were given at one particular time, things might be better. We gave that break. We did it more than once, but it was proved conclusively that the more leniency or softness we showed towards these people the worse they got. We are certainly in this position, that we tried the other method but it did not succeed. I am not saying that the other Government did not try it. I admit that probably it would have the same result. I thought genuinely at the time that if we did try that method we would have good results. I am perfectly satisfied now that if a new Government had been elected last June, and if they did what we did in 1932 there would have been disastrous results if they let out all these people. One of the reasons why we have so little of this violence now is because we have the most dangerous of these people under lock and key. There are some of them we have not got.

When one of the bravest men belonging to one of the best families of this country was murdered in Rathfarnham as a result of a cowardly ambush with machine-guns, we issued advertisements and published photographs of the people we wanted to interview, but we could not get any help. We could not get them. It is a fact that immediately after that gallant man was murdered these people actually cycled through a crowd who were standing at the gate over the dead body of that murdered man, and yet we could get no help from anybody. That is what we are up against. Three of these people, as I said last July, gave a solemn undertaking that they were through with all this thing. That is what we are up against. When Deputy Connolly in his innocence, if it is innocence—I do not see how it could be; in view of what I said last July I am afraid it is a little more than that—suggested that we should bring the remainder of these people up for trial, he was simply trying to fool himself. He certainly is not going to fool me or the country. The fact is that we cannot get the evidence. We have knowledge that the most dangerous elements in that body are interned. There are some others whom we should like to get and hold, too. So far as I can see, we will get no good of this organisation by any more soft work. Even if the war were over, until we can make sure that these people are not going to take on themselves the right to take human life, it would be very dangerous to set them at liberty.

Deputy McGilligan asked what happens in these cases. In every case, I do not wait until I am asked. I have a periodical look through all the names. If anybody asks me to review any case, any Deputy or any relation of any interned person, I immediately do it. I have refused in one case; I have refused Deputy Connolly and will continue to do so. The man concerned is prepared to sign any undertaking, but I would not give a snap of the fingers for it. That is not because of what the Gárdaí tell me. I am perfectly satisfied myself. Deputy O'Donnell mentioned another man. He may have high ideals and all that, but the man he is referring to, in my opinion, is a dangerous gunman who cannot be let out. I am sorry to say that he is not in good health, but in my opinion he is a dangerous man and I would not take the responsibility at a time like this of ordering his release. There are people of that type there. I cannot prove these things. I have the information which enables me to take that decision and the last Dáil anyway unanimously gave me that power. I think that is as satisfactory as it can be. There is not a case that is not inquired into. If I had not given satisfaction, I think I would be told so. I am open to hear of any change of mind on the part of these people, but it must be genuine. I must have regard to the fact that I believe anyway that three of these people had a hand in that murder. One of them, whom we suspected of two other murders of Guards, gave a most solemn undertaking that he was through with all this thing, and persuaded the Guards to that effect; so much so, that I myself questioned the Guards and they stated they were perfectly satisfied and that is the result.

As to the pay of the Guards, which was raised by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, and other Deputies, of course any Minister in charge of the Department would like to pay the Guards as much as he could. I know that they are not in the same position as they were at the start of the emergency, but nobody else is either. The value of everybody's money is gone down by the same amount. We have all had to do without things we could have got before the war.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Surely £2 a week is not sufficient?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is another matter which I shall deal with in a moment. I would certainly like to have the Guards in as strong a financial position as possible. When I put that matter before the Minister for Finance, I tried to get better treatment for the Guards and I nearly got away with it. I thought I had got it, but I was caught out, because immediately I tried to get a bigger increase for the Guards every member of the Civil Service naturally expected the same and everybody had to be treated on the same basis. The teachers and others had to get an increase; the Minister for Finance could not discriminate. The Gárdaí are undoubtedly going through a hard time, but is there anybody in the country who is not? Everybody has to do without something that he could get before; even people who have plenty of money. They cannot get the things they were able to get before. There is only a limited amount of goods available and any increase in pay will not produce the goods. We have to ration them and make them go round as far as we can.

As to the £2 for recruits, Deputy Larkin was not a member of the House when that was discussed. I was pressed very strongly as to why I agreed to that. The position was that we had the usual fight with Finance. We were pressing every year for an increased rent allowance for Guards and it was taken off one section and given to another. I had to accept that. I insisted that, if we had to accept that, we should lower the age for recruits. I would not stand for an initial pay of £2 per week for a man of 27 years. We reduced the age for entrance to 22 at first and then it was raised to 23. The position is that that £2 per week is paid to very young men when they are in training. The training takes about six moths. When they go out on beat duty they get an increment of 10/- and, in addition to that, they get a bonus of 10/-. I admit that that is not a princely salary. I understand that they are in the Depot for six months while training and they get £2 while they are there. For young men it is tolerable enough. I was prepared to accept it anyhow at the time, and I think the House accepted the compromise that we made on that occasion. But, when they start out on duty, they get £3 per week. We also got a steeper increase for them in the rate of increment than was at first suggested.

As to the Rule-making Committee, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney does not seem to realise that there has been a change in the matter. During the discussion of the Courts of Justice Act of 1936 two leading Deputies on the other side, Mr. Lavery and Mr. Costello, insisted that a representative of the Minister for Justice should not be on that Rule making Committee and the Minister gave way, with the result that there is no representative of the Minister on the Rule-making Committee. It is a matter entirely for the legal profession. Some are nominated. If the Deputy will look up the Courts of Justice Act, 1936, he will find that it is a matter entirely for the legal profession and the judges. The Incorporated Law Society and the Bar Council appoint their representatives and the judges are also represented. They have not been able to arrange matters. There is, probably, some force in the point made by the Deputy that we should reconsider the whole position and try to get away from that system. I cannot imagine any satisfactory amendment of the court rules being effected without the active help of some of the judges. Deputy Davin raised a question regarding the film censor's increase of salary.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

What about the cleaning of the barracks?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That has been in agitation for a long time but it appears that, during the days of the R.I.C., that was part of their duty.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Can you not get away from the R.I.C.?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

During our own time, that was also the position. I have taken this matter up with the Minister for Finance. I do not know how far I shall succeed, but he will, probably, make some allowance towards barrack-cleaning. I told Deputy Norton that we are not satisfied with the Act governing compensation for Guards injured in the course of their duty and the dependents of Guards who are killed in the course of their duty. We had to wait to get the exact judgment of the Supreme Court. In due course, we shall introduce an amending Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Will it be retrospective?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes. Deputy Davin wanted to know why we increased the salary of the film censor by 50 per cent. Everybody knows how efficient the outgoing film censor, Mr. Montgomery, was. He was not entitled to a pension and his salary was £900. I was asked by the Chairman of the Film Appeals Board to get some provision made for Mr. Montgomery on retirement. His successor, Dr. Hayes, very generously offered to forgo one-third of the salary for the post in order to make provision for Mr. Montgomery— a thing which we could not do under the law as it stood. Mr. Montgomery was 70 years of age and had to retire. When he left, he had £300 a year and, when he died, Dr. Hayes got the salary which had been enjoyed by his predecessor. That is the explanation of the increase in the figure.

A very important and very damaging statement was made by Deputy Davin. He was quite definite in his suggestion that letters which the police got authority to open had been handed to political supporters of the Government and used for political ends. He asked me to explain what happens about these letters and how it comes that letters are opened at all. In certain cases, the police and, in other cases, the Intelligence Department of the Army ask the Minister for Justice to authorise the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs to hand over correspondence addressed to certain people or to certain places. That application comes to me. I sign the warrant, which is sent to the Army authorities or to high police authorities. That is done on the requisition of the police or the Army and the warrant is sent to the police or the military, as the case may be, to enable them to obtain and read this correspondence. I was asked by Deputy Davin if those concerned were under an oath of secrecy. They are bound by the Official Secrets Act, and if any member of the Gárda or Army were known to disclose any information obtained that way to any unauthorised person, not only would they be dismissed but they would be prosecuted.

Deputy Davin mentioned this particular case some time ago. He asked me the same question then that he asked me openly last night. I told him what I have said now—that these things do happen. I am not prepared to tell him either the number of such warrants current or the names of the people on that list; but there is such a list. I told him that if he could give me any instance in which a public official had betrayed his trust in that way, I would investigate the matter to the very end and have him dealt with. There were other persons present when he raised this matter, and I felt fairly sure that he would give me the particulars. That is about six weeks ago, and I have not got the particulars yet. I flatly deny his allegation. I think I am entitled to do that in the absence of the detailed information which I expected to receive from him and which would enable me to prosecute my inquiries. The suggestion was made on the occasion on which the matter was raised that the information could have come from another quarter. That is a possibility that cannot be ruled out—that the letter was handed out from the end to which it was addressed. Since the Deputy did not give me the minimum details necessary to have the allegation inquired into, I think I am entitled to say that there is no foundation for it. I assure Deputies that correspondence dealt with in that way does not relate to politics, but to the detection of crime and the defence of the State. This course is only taken under warrant by the Minister for Justice authorising the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs to hand over the correspondence.

Comment on this

Is it the usual procedure for the Gárda Síochána to present the Minister's warrant at the post office to which the letters go?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is the way it is done. There is a special section of the Guards to operate the system; it is not done by an ordinary Guard.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Deputy Flanagan must be getting ready to go into the Government.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Any reasonable Deputy will appreciate the difficulty of carrying on a modern State if such an arrangement were not possible. I think I have completely refuted Deputy Davin's charge. Deputy MacEoin put some question about the Land Registry. I had dealt with that matter before he came in and I have dealt with it three or four times since. Deputy O'Sullivan spoke about juvenile delinquency and the necessity for additional police. He was probably not present when I was dealing with the matter. I was surprised at his speech. I had thought that the first citizen of Dublin would have made himself sure of his facts before making sweeping statements about conditions at Mountjoy Prison. I do not think that I misrepresent him when I say that he alleged that prisoners were locked up for 18 hours at a stretch. There is no truth whatever in that allegation. As a matter of fact, before I became Minister for Justice they were undoubtedly locked up for quite a long time, but never for as long as that. At 4.30 in the evening they were locked up until about 7 o'clock in the morning. Having been an old "lag" myself, I always thought that was too long. Personally, I did not mind it, because my own company was generally good enough for me, and I could keep my mind occupied by reading, but I know there are other people who are not like that, and it has a very bad effect on them. One of the first things I did was to change the hour from 4.30 to 7.30, so they are locked up now from 7.30 in the evening until about 7 o'clock in the morning. In addition to that, they get an extra meal. The last meal they got used to be about 4 o'clock; they get an extra meal now. I do not pretend that Mountjoy is a heaven on earth, and it was never intended to be. Surely to goodness, not alone must we try to reform those people but there must be some element of punishment. Surely we are not going to be so namby-pamby as to make Mountjoy and Portlaoighise so attractive that there would be a rush for accommodation there. Mountjoy is not nearly as bad as Deputies have made it out to be.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

From what the Minister has said I think it must be heaven now compared with when I was in it.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think it can compare with any prison anywhere. Deputy Connolly asked me to visit the female prison in Mountjoy. He almost made us all weep by his description of the female prisoners. It is not so long since I visited Mountjoy, and I made inquiries this morning as to when Deputy Connolly did so. The Governor has no record of his ever having been there. I was there not later than last Christmas, and when I was passing through the place where the women prisoners were I thought for a moment that they were nurses they were so neatly dressed. If any one doubts that, I have one of the costumes conveniently available, and perhaps Mrs. Reynolds or some other Deputy would like to have a look at it. It is a very neat, bright piece of clothing. As I say, when I saw those women there my first impression was that they were a group of nurses. If Deputy Connolly or Deputy Larkin or any other Deputy in the House wishes to visit the female prison in Mountjoy he has only to let me know, and I will get him a permit to do so—the Governor will be only too delighted—and if he can find anything wrong from the point of view of the cleanliness or dress of the women prisoners there I certainly will be astonished. I admit that the type of clothing of the male prisoners is very bad. It is warm, but it is a drab kind of uniform; it makes me sick to look at it. I did ask the Department to see if they could get some better style of dress.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

It is nearly as bad as that of the postmen.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

It is not what I would like. I certainly do agree that dress has an effect. It can have a very depressing effect or the contrary effect on anybody. I think we can all admit that. I do admit that the clothing of the male prisoners is not what I would like it to be, but there would have to be some sort of uniform.

I now come to another aspect of the prisons raised by, I think, Deputy Connolly, that is the conduct of certain people in Portlaoighise and the alleged inhuman way in which they are treated. Undoubtedly there is a group down there who will not conform to prison rules. They say that they are better than the other prisoners. They have murdered Guards and other people. Some of them were sentenced to death and reprieved, but still they think they are better than other people and must not be treated as ordinary prisoners at all. I cannot agree with that at all. I think if people go out and shoot a Guard, and if the Government, after taking all the circumstances into consideration, sees fit to reprieve them, I do not think they are entitled to any better treatment than any other reprieved murderer, and I do not propose to give it to them while I am Minister. There are other people there who committed crimes of violence. They robbed with guns; they terrorised the people; they held up banks and post-offices. But they will not conform to the prison rules. Am I expected to let them rule the prison? They are certainly not going to do it. If they do not see their way to-do what men who are every bit as good as they are—that is the ordinary prisoners—have to do, that is their own look-out. I am certainly not going to be persuaded by them or anybody in this House to change my attitude on that matter.

Comment on this

You have the whole country behind you in that.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I frankly admit that it may have a detrimental effect on the health of those men. I admit that I am disturbed about it. It is not a thing I would brush aside lightly; I feel it very much because I have the same softness in me as most Irish people. I feel it very much but I have to swallow my personal feelings, and until they change their attitude they will not get away with this attempt to wreck the system we have in Portlaoighise. I said that the conditions in Portlaoighise are better than in Mountjoy because it is the prison to which people with long sentences go. There is a big farm there and those people could go out on the farm if they wished, or do other useful work of some kind. But they want to be treated as political prisoners. They claim even still that they were right; that they had the right to take the lives of servants of this State, and to hold up post-offices and banks and rob them. I am not conceding that, and there is no use in any Deputy trying to appeal to me on any grounds of humanity. Let them appeal to those who are guilty of those crimes, and who have to take their punishment like every other offender. I think the net result of raising those matters here is to get those people to persevere in their efforts to break down our system. I said last July that raising the matter of the hunger strikers had jeopardised the lives of some of those men, because I know myself—having been on hunger-strike for 40 days—that the slightest thing, even a letter to the newspapers, will give a man in that condition hope that the Government may give in. When we had this unfortunate hunger-strike here which resulted in the loss of two young lives, I warned some of those visitors when they persisted in going in that they would have a very grave responsibility indeed—that every visit was an encouragement to those unfortunate men to persevere in trying to beat the Government, which we could not allow to happen. Unfortunately, my warning went unheeded, and two young men lost their lives. It is the same in this case. If Deputies can be got to raise the cases of people who have been guilty of those crimes, and to try to force the Government to give way, they are only encouraging those people to persevere in an attitude which will eventually, I believe, lead to their permanent loss of health, or may be their reason. It is their own doing; it is not my doing; although I do admit that I worry about it, not on an occasional time but all the time. I never forget it, but I cannot see that I would be doing my duty as Minister for Justice if I were in any way to encourage those people to hope that they are going to get their conditions improved by flouting the rules we have found necessary to enforce in our prisons.

I was asked about technical education in Mountjoy. The Lord Mayor mentioned that too. Mountjoy is a short sentence prison—perhaps he does not know that—and there is not very much opportunity of giving technical training there. There is a sort of a school there. It is not what it might be, I admit, but as I have already explained, where these juveniles are likely to be in for a lengthy period, such as in Borstal, we do endeavour to create a proper atmosphere and to give them as much education as possible.

Comment on this

I should like to point out to the Minister that the point I made in regard to Mountjoy was that the arrangements there were of such a character as to permit continuous intermingling of juveniles with what might be referred to as the old "lags"—that there was no segregation.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am informed that there is a definite segregation as between juvenile offenders and the others.

Comment on this

I think that the Minister will find that, in that respect, my information is based on facts.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Well, I can assure the Deputy that, as soon as he made that statement, I had inquiries instituted in my Department. I myself have always been very anxious about the matter of seeing that there would be segregation of the first offenders, and I am informed by my staff that there is that segregation and that the old, habitual "lags", as they have been called, are not allowed to associate with the first offenders. I shall have the matter looked into again, but I have no reason to doubt the information with which I have been supplied.

The question was raised of the awards for bravery. In that connection, the idea was to get the Red Cross to take up the matter. That is really what we want, but I do not know whether it will be feasible or not. Deputy Donnellan seemed to want less strict supervision of public-houses. As a matter of fact, I have asked the Commissioner to tighten up that matter as much as possible, and so the Deputy and I do not appear to agree upon that at all. I know that it is a very difficult thing. The whole matter was threshed out here on the Intoxicating Liquor Bill, and I have asked the Commissioner to tighten up this matter of the supervision of public-houses, and I know that he has taken special steps in that regard. We had a long discussion on the Intoxicating Liquor Bill, and I know that we met most of the requests that were put forward by various Deputies. Having gone so far, I think it is only reasonable to appeal to the Gárdaí to see that the regulations are strictly enforced and that the district justices should impose adequate sentences. I do not think, in view of all the circumstances, that the Deputy should ask the Commissioner to slacken his efforts in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Might I suggest a change in the bona fide hours, which are at present between 10.30 and 12?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Well, my hopes were fully justified in regard to the stopping of the bona fide traffic at 12 o'clock at night. Deputy Larkin has suggested a change in the present hours, as between 10.30 and 12 o'clock at night. I was not so much inclined to object to the extra half hour in the city—it was 10 o'clock formerly for closing time—for the reason that I was most anxious to lessen the gap between the closing hour in the city and the closing hour outside, so that there would be no inducement for people to go out from the city. As a matter of fact, some traders came to me asking to be compensated for the loss of trade. They pointed out that a lot of their trade had been done during these hours, that that trade was now completely gone, and that they wanted me to compensate them.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

I suggest that the Minister should make me the arbitrator in these cases.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think that the big effect which I hoped for has been achieved, particularly with regard to the Sunday evening trade. We all know that formerly it was impossible for decent people to travel on a bus in the outskirts of the city on a Sunday evening, because of the behaviour of people who used to drink in the public-houses outside the city in the then bona fide hours. That also has been stopped. The question also has been raised of the licensing of bars at dance halls. I did express the hope, at the time, that that evil would also disappear. Perhaps, however, that is not so, but I have nothing to do with that. It is a matter for the courts, and not for me. If the court gives a permit for a bar at a dance hall, I cannot interfere; and, of course, the Gárdaí are represented in the court and will object if there is any reason why the licence should not be given. I think that any ordinary citizen can also object if he feels that the privilege is being abused.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Can the Minister tell us whether we are to get any more Gárdaí in Dublin?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I do hope that we may be able to do something in that direction soon. A number of young Guards are being trained rapidly, and I shall try to get the Commissioner to allocate a greater number of Gárdaí to the city. We are doing all that we can in that direction.

Comment on this

What about the matter of the disposal of their uniforms at the end of the year? Is there not some question of the payment of about 15/-?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Well, if the Deputy does not mind my saying it, I think that that is rather a small point, and I have not the information at my disposal now with regard to that matter, but I shall let him know later on. I cannot give him the information now, because I have not got it. The question of the L.S.F. was also raised. There, again, it is not so much a question of money as of supplies. The Minister for Finance was prepared to give the money, but it was really a question of supplies. I hope that there will be an improvement in the coming year but, so far, we have not been able to get all that we wanted. The question of the housing of the Gárdaí was also raised. It appeared to me that every Deputy who was not present in the House when I was speaking mentioned the same thing. My Department has put before the Department of Industry and Commerce, which is dealing with the whole question of post-war planning, the matter of providing houses for the Gárdaí.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

If we cannot provide them with houses, why not provide them with some extra money?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The whole question is being gone into with a view to seeing what can be done when the present emergency is over, but the fact is that we have not got the materials, and it would appear that nothing can be done until after the emergency.

Comment on this

The matter of the provision of new Gárda barracks at Carracastle was also mentioned.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The fact is that in many parts of the country the Gárda barracks are under-staffed and we cannot consider the establishment of new barracks when so many of those barracks are undermanned. With regard to New Ross, I told Deputy Corish that we were trying to deal with that matter.

Comment on this

Do the Gárdaí get a rent allowance?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes, and I think that the rent allowance will probably go to pay for the houses that will be built.

Comment on this

Would the Minister restore the typewriter to Séamus Ó Ceallaigh, of which mention has been made?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Deputy McGilligan raised that point also. Now, that young man was certainly an inciter. He is a very delicate man, indeed, but as a result of his incitements he did very grave damage in this State. He is a cripple, but I remember reading different accounts of revolutions that took place 100 years ago, in France, let us say, and there was one particular cripple in those days who did desperate damage as a result of his incitements. This young man was of that type. He incited a number of young boys and girls to carry arms and use them, and some of these young boys and girls are now suffering long terms of imprisonment as a result of heeding his incitements. He used a typewriter for that purpose and, under the Forfeiture Act, I declared the typewriter forfeited. He, or somebody on his behalf, appealed against that, but the court refused his application and the typewriter was disposed of. I can assure the House that I have not got the typewriter.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Surely, the man concerned is paralysed?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

As far as the typewriter is concerned, I, personally, would be prepared to get him one myself if that would keep him quiet, but the fact is that he used that typewriter to publish the most inciting and inflammatory statements imaginable, as a result of which many young people were involved in serious difficulties; some of them carried and used guns and are now in jail, serving long terms of imprisonment, as a result of this man's actions.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Mr. L. Cosgrave Fine Gael

Might he not be able to get another typewriter himself?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Well, if he does, and even though we have to have him attended by nurses and doctors, we will have to take it away from him again.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Mr. L. Cosgrave Fine Gael

In the absence of a typewriter, can he not use a pen?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes, he can use a pen. He has to be lifted up on a platform, but he can use a pen. He is a most extraordinary man.

Comment on this

This man has said that his typewriter is the only means of livelihood he has.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I know all about that, but so far as that particular typewriter is concerned, the procedure laid down was followed.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

It has been auctioned, I suppose?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

It has probably been sold for a few shillings—I do not know —but it has gone out of my possession.

Comment on this

Deputy Flanagan made a very remarkable accusation regarding certain citizens.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Deputy Flanagan says a lot more than his prayers, and if he thinks I am going to follow him in all he said, he is making a great mistake. I have dealt with his references to what I said in 1928 and I deliberately say that, apart from the unfortunate remark I made about Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, I stand by everything I said on that occasion. I was glad to get the opportunity of withdrawing what I said about Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, but I stand over everything else I said, although I admit that I was not as old then as I am now. Nevertheless, I thought the experiment we made was perfectly justified. Having tried every other method, we were justified, and we have no qualms of conscience whatever, in relentlessly pursuing these people until we wipe out all this attempt at organised crime.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Mr. L. Cosgrave Fine Gael

Deputy Flanagan is one of your products.

Comment on this

I would not accuse even the Minister of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The Deputy asked me about somebody in Athlone. I was in Athlone on the occasion of a convention of L.S.F. district officers and I met several people from Leix. I think I have an idea as to who the person the Deputy referred to is. He says he called me "Gerry"—he is a man I happened to know in the past. I did meet him that day, but he made no mention whatever——

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

We all call you "Gerry".

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

He did, anyway, and I do not mind that, but he made no request whatever of the nature suggested by Deputy Flanagan. With regard to the sergeant to whom the Deputy referred, I have had representations made about him. The position is that that sergeant has one child who has now left the home and gone into some business. The sergeant occupies a house which is suitable for a Guard with a rather large family, and the Commissioner, being unable to provide a proper house for the Guard with a large family, decided to move this sergeant, whose family has left him, to a small house and to put the Guard into this house. That is the extent of the political interference with that sergeant. I had nothing whatever to do with it, and no member of our organisation, so far as I know, had anything to do with it, If he had, it was certainly without my knowledge. Nobody approached me in Athlone or anywhere else about the matter and whoever told the Deputy that certainly did not tell him the truth.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister denies it.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Oh, you are there.

Comment on this

I am a little closer to you.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think the Deputy has come to the wrong side. I would prefer to see him on the opposite benches.

Comment on this

He has gone back to Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

It took us a good while to get rid of him and we do not want him back. The Deputy referred to some letter which he wrote and suggested that I had jumped to the defence of a banker. I did get a complaint that he was, I think, one of four people who signed a letter addressed to the Bank of Ireland. As he has raised the matter, I might as well deal with it. Senator Sir John Keane came to me with this letter. I smiled when I read it and Senator Sir John Keane said: "You do not seem to take it very seriously." I replied: "To tell you the truth, I do not and if you take my advice, you will agree that we should not do what we ordinarily would do, that is, to arrest this man. I happen to know Mr. Flanagan. He is a very pushful young man and I think he is anxious to get into the Dáil. He would love to be arrested arising out of this matter and I think we ought not to do it." Senator Sir John Keane agreed with me, but a fortnight later he came to me with another letter which referred him to the previous letter, told him that the people who had signed that letter meant what they said, that they were holding them responsible for everything that had happened since 1847 and that they had better look out for themselves, if they did not remedy things. I thought it was then time, not to prosecute the Deputy—he was not a Deputy then—but to tell the Guards that they ought to go around and advise the people who were sending these rather menacing letters that they would need to be very careful as they were pursuing a very dangerous line.

Comment on this

We did it in a strictly constitutional manner.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That was the extent of my action in that matter. With regard to pursuing the Deputy, I did not know that the police were bothering their heads about him, but on account of the sort of speeches he was making—I quoted some of them here already— most Deputies will agree that if Deputies were to make that type of speech, we would not get very far ahead in this country.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

He was an organiser for Fianna Fáil at the time.

Comment on this

God forgive me, I was.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

We had got rid of him long before that. It was my job, not as Minister for Justice, but as secretary of the organisation, and I took good care that we shed him long before that. That is the history of that matter. As to recruitment for the Guards, I agree with Deputy Meighan and Deputy Ó Cléirigh that a farmer's son generally makes the best type of Guard. There is a lot in what Deputy Ó Cléirigh said that, when a man gets a university or very high education, he does not feel quite content. He thinks he should be a superintendent or some such officer, but it is necessary to put oneself in the Commissioner's position. He gets applications and finds that some people have done the leaving certificate and that they are fine athletic men. Naturally, he will take the best he can get. The standard was lowered recently because the Civil Service examination was of such a high standard that the required number did not qualify. It is a qualifying and not a competitive examination— the competitive part has to do more with physical than educational qualities. The standard was lowered considerably recently, and I think it is now reasonably low. It may be a little above the standard of the national school, though I am not sure. I think, however, that it is reasonably low and the ordinary fairly well educated young man ought to be able to pass it. That was done in the realisation that the people who went up could not pass the examination set.

People have spoken about favouritism by the Commissioner, but the fact is that it is only lately that there has been any examination of this kind at all. The Commissioner is the person who recruited for the Guards. It was in his hands. The way he manages is that he has a board of senior officers who examine all the applications. He generally looks for people at least 5ft. 10ins. in height, and if he can get enough men 5ft 10ins. in height, or over, he will take nobody under that height. He will not take a 5ft. 9ins. man. In the case of drivers, some men under the standard height were accepted, but 5ft. 9ins. is the limit. If he can get enough 5ft. 10ins. men with the necessary educational qualifications and who are physically fit, he will take them first. If he has a greater number than he has vacancies for, he tries to allocate them on the basis of a quota for each county. He generally takes about twice the number he requires, which gets him about the number he is looking for, and I think it is a fair enough system.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

How does the Minister explain the incidence of tuberculosis amongst physically fit men?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I inquired from the Commissioner, as I mentioned in my opening statement, and I am told there is no foundation for the statement. Tuberculosis is not prevalent to any great extent. I understand that the health of the Guards is as good as that of any force anywhere for which we have figures. I do not know where Deputy Dockrell got that idea. There certainly seems to be no foundation for it.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

It was stated in other speeches as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I have asked the Commissioner and that is the information.

Comment on this

Does the Minister feel that the seventh standard of national school education should be sufficient?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I cannot say any more about that.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that at the moment men who have gone to the seventh standard pass the present examination?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think a lot of them do. They reach the seventh standard and when they intend to enter the Guards' exam they do a bit of brushing up.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I can assure the Minister that I know Guards who have passed only through the national school and who have succeeded in the Gárda exam.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think the situation is as good as could reasonably be expected at present. Deputy Cogan raised the question of women police. I have no use for them. I do not think women police are needed at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

There was a point raised by Deputy Linehan about District Court officers having a higher status.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I cannot deal with everything. About the cinemas, I do not know whether they are a cause of crime or not. There are different opinions. Deputy Linehan dealt with that as well as I could. The principal responsibility for this juvenile crime is really on the parents. There may be something to be said for preventing young children from going to certain types of cinema, but I am not going to say whether that is a remedy or not. I have an open mind on the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Will there be any additional women police?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am not inclined to that at all. I do not think they are necessary. About paying the Guards weekly, as I told Deputy McGilligan, we did for a while pay them fortnightly and their representative body, which generally speaks for all ranks, asked for a reversal to the old system. If they want to go back to the twice-monthly system, I can have that considered.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Is there any reason why the Minister will not appoint any more women police?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I do not think they are very effective.

Comment on this

There are plenty of young men.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

In regard to the question of embezzlement, that is a big matter into which I am not prepared to go. I am not quite sure what the position is and it is something I would not like to deal with now. I would like to go into it before making a statement.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

The Minister is not forgetting my point?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Regarding the special courts, as to whether a particular case would go to the special courts or the ordinary courts and whether there is congestion in the ordinary courts, the Attorney-General decides the point. The special courts are confined to dealing with black-marketing and cases of that kind and he decides whether the case is serious enough to go there or whether it can be dealt with by the ordinary courts.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Mr. L. Cosgrave Fine Gael

I think the Minister is missing the point of Deputy McGilligan's question. He mentioned that some cases go before the special court and others of a similar kind go to the ordinary courts.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The judge of that is the Attorney-General. He looks into all the circumstances. If he decides that one case is proper to go before the special court and another can be dealt with adequately in the District Court, he makes that decision after going into all the circumstances.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Mr. L. Cosgrave Fine Gael

It looks like an abuse of the Emergency Powers Act.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I do not think so, as this deals entirely with the emergency. The whole life of the State may be involved. One may come across a black-marketing case with very wide ramifications—and there have been several such—where we might have been deprived of vital articles wanted for the life of the community. That is a very serious offence, indeed, only taking second place to some of these armed attacks.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Mr. L. Cosgrave Fine Gael

But the ordinary officers who are dealing with these cases are not trained in the same way as lawyers.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

They are good, hardheaded men who have done the job for a number of years. They were selected by the last Government and have justified themselves. They are practical men and have dealt with most of the cases coming before them in a very satisfactory way. I do not think I have any further remarks to make. I may have left some things out, but I have tried to cover every point made.

Comment on this

Would the Minister deal with the question I raised about having the prisoner in the dock?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is a question I never considered at all. The question never occurred to me, but I will have it looked into, to see what the position is.

Comment on this

I went to the trouble of looking it up.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I will inquire into it and see what can be done.

Comment on this

Cad mar gheall ar na Gárdaí sa Ghaeltacht?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Tá Scéim choiteanta i bhfeidhm fós.

Comment on this

Agus cad mar gheall ar na príosúnaigh?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Tá cead acu aon bhuidhean is maith leo do chur ar bun.

Comment on this

An bhfuil a fhios agat an bhfuil a leithéid ar siubhal?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Níl a fhios agam. Rud dóibh féin an rud sin.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

My contribution was so short—it occupied only two minutes —that I do not blame the Minister for forgetting it. I raised the case of the inadequate compensation to dependents of men who were shot in the exercise of their duty.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I dealt with that.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

I also raised the case of Joseph Gains, of 5 St. Michael's Lane, who was incapacitated by a Government weapon and lost his wages, by order of the court, by having to remain over from his work in England to give evidence. He lost £139 1s. out-of-pocket expenses. He was incapacitated through being shot and has become a T.B. case. There is no compensation whatever, although the man was shot and incapacitated by a Government weapon.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I dealt with that case. I made inquiries about it and I do not think the State can take responsibility. This was a brawl in the small hours of the morning and people who go into those places take on a certain amount of responsibility. The Guard who did it was punished and people who have suffered loss can take action against those who committed the injury.

Comment on this

He is not any mark for a case.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I cannot add any more.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

At 11 o'clock at night, a detective shot a visitor from England.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is the third time the Deputy has made that statement. The Minister has replied.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

It is very unsatisfactory.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I cannot help it if the Deputy is not satisfied.

Comment on this

Could the Minister indicate why the members of the Gárda Síochána——

Comment on this

Did the Deputy not speak before?

Comment on this

I never opened my mouth.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has spoken for an hour. Does he wish to ask a question?

Comment on this

Will the Minister indicate, on the point I raised, why the Gárdaí shadow Mr. Joseph ——? I have his name here.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I do not know anything about that. I would want notice of that question. I presume that the Guards must have very good reason to suspect that he was doing something that he should not be doing.

Comment on this

Will the Minister look into the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am not going to ask them about this man. I do not know who Mr. Joseph Kearney is.

Comment on this