Transport Bill, 1944—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–134 of 282. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1944 ›
When I moved the adjournment of the debate on this Bill on Wednesday evening, I was dealing with certain features of it which, with your permission, I want to recapitulate.
Comment on this
There are just a few points that I would like to deal with briefly for the benefit of members who were not present the last day.
Comment on this
I am not going to repeat myself, but I want to bring out certain points. The first is to suggest that the Bill is mistitled; the second is that, in another place an investigation is taking place which may change the whole outlook of the House and opinion throughout the country on this Bill, and that may compel a readjustment of the situation; thirdly, that this railway company has, on the submission of the Minister himself, proved its incapacity to carry on such an undertaking; fourthly, that the House is being asked to vote the considerable sum of £13,500,000 to be handed over to people for property for which, according to the Minister himself, there is no collateral; fifthly, that the company itself is in such a state of disquietude as well as being in a condition of bankruptcy almost that it would be unfair if not, to use a stronger word, dishonest, to tender £13,500,000 for a property that in certain quarters was valued at from £4,500,000 to £7,000,000. I am very generous in saying £7,000,000, because it has been stated that the property is not worth £4,500,000 as a going concern. This railway company has no goodwill to sell except the needs of the community. Furthermore, I suggest that these statements made publicly, as well as the atmosphere outside of this House, should convey to the Minister— he seemed to have a feeling of uncertainty within himself in the halting submission which he made to the House—and should convince the back-benchers in his Party, that this is a serious matter which requires further consideration.
I put some questions to the Minister when speaking on Wednesday which he failed to answer. I know that, with his usual courtesy, he will answer them when closing the debate. I put it to him, again, that this is a Bill born out of time; it is an abortion, born of mismanagement and fathered by cupidity. To that extent it is a measure that is going to affect the back-benchers opposite, in their relations with their constituents, in a very serious way. Their constituents are being denied the services to which they are entitled. The back-benchers in the Minister's Party ought to consider their position. If the Minister takes off the Whip, I feel sure that 90 per cent. of the membership of the House will vote for delaying this measure. If the Whip is not taken off, then, naturally, the back-benchers will respond to it.
I submit to the members of the Government Party, who represent the citizens of Dublin, that they cannot be a party to this merger because if so they will either have to lie here or lie in another place where they are carrying on in an administrative capacity. It is quite clear, in connection with this merger which takes in the Dublin Transport Company, that there is something to be explained. My submission to the House is that the Dublin Transport Company has nothing to sell. The Corporation of Dublin and its citizens, represented by the Lord Mayor, Aldermen and elected councillors have. The corporation would not hesitate, if it were in the interests of the country even to forego their financial rights, founded on the security of the rates, and accommodate themselves to the needs of a national service of transportation, but what is clear from this Bill is that the Dublin United Transport Company is confiscating and presuming to sell something that it has no legal right to sell. It has no legal right to negotiate with any body outside the Corporation of Dublin. It has a life extension, under agreement, in this property up to 1966, but the company has violated every term and condition in that agreement. They never kept one of the conditions of the agreement. They did temporarily open up the Lucan line and they did temporarily supply electrical energy in the immediate area of the power station controlled by them: but they closed those two activities down, denying the public of Dublin the rights set down in the agreement. I hold that those two rights alone, having been evaded by the company, made that agreement null and void in law. It was the duty of the citizens of Dublin, through their elected representatives, to take into their own charge the use of the streets of the city.
This merger goes further than that. It provides that whatever way-leave rents were payable are to be matters of treatment before an arbitrator. The Minister specifically repeated that this question of arbitration as to the rights of the citizens of Dublin applies only to trams, yet in the 1925 Act the Corporation of Dublin is entitled to carry on omnibus services. That seems to have been forgotten.
There are two pertinent issues which I wish to bring before the House, without taking more than my share of the time. These two fundamental issues affect the workers in this country. In this Bill, officers and servants are segregated. The high officials, officers, who may be found redundant are compensated and there is no question of any difficulty about that. When it comes to the workers, the servants, however, if they go out of the service within six months after the merger, they will be entitled to consideration only if they are found redundant for certain reasons.
An amendment to the 1924 Act was drafted for the purpose of evading responsibilities to the servants of the railway companies. After many hundreds of men—close on 2,000—had got compensation, the balance of the men suing before the courts failed, through no fault of their own, because the law was subject to delays, there not being sufficent judges available to carry on every day and deal with those cases as they should have been dealt with—immediately on the discharge of the men. In that particular Act, there was a clause, which is inserted in this Bill. Deputies might turn to Section 41, where they will find it, as follows:—
"Every person who was, on the 1st day of January, 1944,
—so the Minister was sure this Bill would come into law by the 1st January, 1944, though this is a legislative Chamber, where every matter has to be discussed and where, after certain points of view have been talked over and considered, that matter may be made law, under certain procedure—
"...an officer or servant of any dissolved company
—and in this case there are two dissolved companies, the Great Southern Railways Company and the Dublin United Transport Company—
"shall, if his office or situation is abolished before the 1st day of January, 1945, directly and solely as the result of the amalgamation effected by this Part of that dissolved company and the other dissolved company and not
—mark this, he or she is entitled to compensation if in the service at that date and found redundant—
not—
"caused by decrease of traffic,
—I submit there will be a decrease of traffic as a certain number of branch lines have already been abolished by the dictator, with the approval of the Minister—
"reduction of renewal or maintenance work,
—in other words, the promise that these lines will be restored appears to be doubtful and, if the maintenance work is not of the same volume as previous to that particular date, he or she is disqualified from compensation—
"alteration in methods of working —the Minister himself suggested, and the House has considered, that there may be different methods of working, and that has always been visualised—
"closing of railway lines or other economic cause..."
What happened when the men were making application on the latter stage of the 1924 Act? The economy committee, which consisted of non-nationals, came in on oath and stated that, in the opinion of that committee and the company, it was to the economic interests of the company that these men should be dismissed. Ergo, they lost their rights to compensation. I would like to tell the aftermath of that in four different cases—suicide in one case, sudden death outside Trinity College in another——
Comment on this
Under this Section 41 of the Bill, the men and women who may be found redundant may be dismissed without compensation. I think I would get strong legal support in making that submission. There is another matter which seems to have been overlooked. Though the Grand Canal Company is not being taken over, what do we find here? The Minister does not take over the canal services, but he takes power to decide—on the advice or without the advice of an advisory committee— that the rates charged by the Grand Canal Company may have a certain effect on the earning power of the new combine and, if he is of opinion, even without any expert advice, that the Grand Canal Company is not charging rates commensurate with the services rendered or is otherwise competing unfairly with the combine, he has power to compel the Grand Canal Company to reduce or increase the rates. I am not a defender of private enterprise, but I suggest to those interested in that particular form of activity that this is nothing but confiscation. It is perfectly right and proper for a State-controlled organisation to arrange terms of service and the rates they are to charge for them, but are they to be allowed to enter the premises and management of another concern and decide they will make those people—whether they like it or not—carry goods in such a way as not to be in competition with the State-financed concern? I do not know whether the Grand Canal Company has been informed of that or not. Even yet, if the ordinary laws operate in this country, they may have power to ask a question about that, since it means taking away certain rights and properties which they possess as a statutory company.
If the Minister had gone a step further and said: "We are going to take over the transportation system of this country," I for one would be with him. I am quite sure that the majority of this House is of opinion as Deputies have stated on all sides of the House that this problem can only be settled by public control and public ownership of the service. I believe the Minister would get a majority for that but he would only get it when it was carefully surveyed and certain well-considered plans had been prepared, after a certain price was paid for the properties now existing and after the investigation has come to a close and a considered verdict been rendered.
Even if the Minister gets the Second Reading of this Bill, all these Schedules and clauses will be debated and considered. I am quite sure the Minister, where there is unfair treatment of individuals, or even private companies, or contradictions in the measure, will correct them. A sop has been thrown out to private owners of lorries and road vehicles throughout the country who have been stopped by the fiat of the Minister and denied the right to carry on their business, for various reasons, including that of competing unfairly with the Great Southern Railways. Even if the Minister has approached this question by recognising in a limited way the right of these private owners to operate, after this merger he will qualify his permission by only allowing them to operate in limited areas with the limitation of the present permission of 15 miles outside certain areas. In the case of Dundalk he goes further, because there our authority does not extend beyond the three-mile limit near the Border. In conclusion, I am going to make a request—and I submit it to my three colleagues here—I ask them to live up to the declarations which they have voiced, that the property of the citizens of Dublin is being filched from them, is being confiscated. That means that we have got to increase the rates on the city, that every man and woman in the city will have to pay more for houses, and that business men will carry further responsibility. I do not think any of us in the city council would consider it fair that the way-leaves should be met by the corporation, because we have repeated again and again our claim that the streets of the City of Dublin are owned by the citizens. Of course, there is overriding authority of the national Government, but no national Government would take from a municipal, urban or rural council the rights which are inherent in its jurisdiction. These three representatives have always done their duty, and I suggest that they should do their duty in this crisis. There is another court of appeal, and I would ask the men of the West to consider the position, no matter what their political affiliations. In 1934, the service on the Midland Great Western Railway was cut by 50 per cent., and lines torn up, and the railway from Dublin to Galway singled. The Minister comes in here and admits that that was wrong, and that it may have to be corrected. What are you going to say to your constituents in regard to this matter? It was stated in this morning's papers that fish have had to be thrown into the sea, either because they had gone bad by bad handling, or because there was no service to bring them to where they could be sold. Then, with regard to the extreme south, everybody knows that the counties of Kerry and south-west Cork are not getting service. They are getting less now than they were getting. When you have done the long, painful passage to Waterford, you would think that Waterford was outside the State altogether. It is a long, wearisome drag that should have been cut by an hour or an hour and a half years ago. All these things, I suggest, are matters which you have to answer for to your constituents.
I will conclude by saying that although I do not know the mind of this House, I suggest to the Minister that the introduction of this Bill is ill-timed. There is no feeling of antagonism on the part of the critics. The only criticism we have offered is that it is a bad bargain and financially unsound as presented to the House, and there might have been delay. There is no reason why there should not have been delay in introducing the Bill because there is no urgency in regard to it. The urgency is just to mend this old crock and keep her going for a time until we get a clear, well-planned, well-considered scheme. Then bring in your scheme and I feel sure, as we have undertaken to do throughout this session, your submissions to the House will be considered fairly. In every submission you have made to the House on the Estimates, you have got comfort and support from the House. In this case I ask you to consider the claims of the people of the country and not to submit to the dictation of the Stock Exchange and the speculators. Before I finish I want to mention one or two things that happened to other workers. A gentleman who was some years ago in a transport company was asked to give up his position. Four years before they could have compelled him to resign. For that he got adequate compensation. He got a bonus in addition, to shut his mouth. In regard to the schemes for the betterment of the workers, I want to point out that in the case of this scheme for a particular form of insurance over 200 insurance collectors will lose their positions. I am quite sure these men are going to become articulate. But the money that used to go to them is now going into one particular office in which one of the heads of this alleged company is now a partner. The most offensive thing in the Bill that I can see is the section which gives power to this company to subscribe to charitable objects. I do not know whether that means the advisory board and that these gentlemen are going to get charity or whether the dictator-chairman is going to consider what he gets to be charity or the gentleman who is supposed to be the managerial expert and who is not known to the outside public. Why a public utility concern should take upon itself to become a charitable organisation I fail to understand. One of the most peculiar and amazing things in the Bill is that a person entering a clerical capacity must know Irish, oral and written but, strange to relate, what applies to the office-boy or other clerical officer is not enforced against the gentlemen with salaries, the advisory committee and the manager nor the imported gentleman, the two non-nationals. They are not compelled to know Irish. That only applies to the boy who pays attention to his studies and tries to get in by a close examination. I think it is fine that it is essential that he know Irish, but I would carry the thing a stage further. I say that every officer in the service, after a certain number of years, ought to know Irish.
The stations will be named in Irish. What a lot of foolish people we are! If your salary is over £500 a year you do not need to know Irish; if you do, it is only for the purpose of passing into the job. If it is a case of a man getting £2,500 a year, he can learn Sanskrit or any other language; he must know English. I was surprised that this Scottish gentleman did not know more than——
Comment on this
With all due respect, if you bring a non-national in here to run the railways to suit his own purposes—a man with no railway experience whatever—it is a very strange proceeding. However, I shall have an opportunity later on of referring to that matter.
Comment on this
The Minister, in moving the Second Reading of this Bill, paid a tribute to the members of the tribunal who sat to inquire into public transport in this country and reported in 1939. I agree that it is a very useful and informative report, and that it contains, for the most part, very sound recommendations for dealing with the problem. But while the Minister paid a tribute to the members of the tribunal, the Bill, as introduced, pays them very small compliment, because, as a matter of fact, the Bill entirely spurns their recommendations.
The main principle of this Bill, the backbone of the Bill, is the merger between the Great Southern Railways Company and the Dublin United Transport Company. All the rest is, to a certain extent, padding, though necessary padding. There is not the slightest hint in the report or in the recommendations of the tribunal with regard to that merger. They have not made any such recommendation what ever. The recommendations of the tribunal are under various headings with regard to the different types of public transport. The report deals with the Great Southern Railways under one heading, and with the Dublin United Transport Company under another.
With regard to the Great Southern Railways Company, Deputies will see the recommendations starting in paragraph 170 of the report, page 82. Paragraph 170 starts off by setting out what the company has said about its difficulty in getting capital in order to carry on its business and it makes certain suggestions with regard to being allowed to borrow a further £2,000,000, setting out that that should be under a Government guarantee. There is some suggestion of that kind —that the Government should give a guarantee. The recommendation of the tribunal is at the end of page 82. This is what it says:—
"We have examined the question of direct investment by the Government in either debenture stock, preference stock, or ordinary stock and we are of opinion that direct investment is not the most desirable method of providing the company with the assistance it requires. Instead, we recommend that the borrowing powers of the company should be increased and that the Government should fully guarantee the repayment of the principal and the payment of the interest in connection with an issue, in such manner as the company considers most advisable, of a further £1,250,000 debenture stock..."
Comment on this
The paragraph proceeds:—
"...bearing interest at a rate not exceeding 4 per cent. Per annum and ranking pari passu with the existing debenture stock of the company.”
That is the recommendation of the tribunal, committing the country and the Government—the taxpayer—to £1,250,000 annually. And they did it with considerable hesitation. They refused to accept what the company said they would require—a little over £2,000,000—and they thought they were going quite far and were being very generous in putting forward a recommendation that the Government should guarantee £1,250,000. In paragraph 171 they say:—
"The adoption of the recommendations which we have made so far would impose upon the Government not only heavy financial obligations, but the responsibility for the imposition of additional duties on forms of transport other than those made available by statutory transport organisations."
They thought £1,250,000 was a heavy financial obligation. I wonder what they think of the suggestion to provide £16,000,000? They go on to say:—
"We consider we would not be justified in making such recommendations without reasonable assurance that the methods of administration of the company during the next five years would result in maximum advantage being obtained therefrom, and that an opportunity would thereby be afforded of measuring the commercial possibilities of the company and at the same time of formulating a more enduring policy in regard to public transport as a whole than is now possible."
Then they go on to make a recommendation to deal with the government of the company over a period of five years. They say:—
"We recommend that for a period of five years, instead of the business of the company being carried on by seven part-time directors, operating through a general manager, the board should consist of three directors, two of whom would act in a part-time capacity and would be elected by the shareholders, while the remaining director, who would be chairman, would act in a whole-time capacity and would be nominated by the Government."
Not one word of dictatorship; not one word that the chairman nominated by the Government should be the complete controller. They suggest two directors nominated or elected by the shareholders and presumably, because there is nothing said to the contrary, these two shareholders would have an equal voice with the chairman in the policy of running the railway. There is a further suggestion about controllers who are not members of the board, and the qualifications they should have are set out.
In paragraph 172 they speak of a national transport council. It is only when you come to paragraph 175 that they actually make a recommendation. They say:—
"To exercise such wide functions we recommend the establishment of a national transport council consisting of a small number of persons with special qualifications to deal with the complex economic, statistical, financial and general matters to be entrusted to their care."
The Bill does not provide any such council, but a council is given some duties. The last sentence in paragraph 172 is one the House should take to heart.
"In particular it is of great importance that a clear and dispassionate appreciation of the factors affecting the success or failure of the Great Southern Railways Company under the new conditions should be available before any final conclusions are reached as to its future commercial possibilities."
The suggestion there is that the transport council should be supervising the working of the railways under the new system of a chairman nominated by the Government, with two directors and two controllers watching it over a period of five years, and that a full report arising out of the inquiries they had made and the working which took place during that period should be available before any final conclusions were reached; in other words, before a Bill would be brought into this House and enacted. That is almost entirely the recommendation with regard to the Great Southern Railways.
Paragraph 173 goes on to deal with hauliers' licences. Paragraph 174 emphasises the supervision that there should be over this £1,250,000 that the State was to put up. It says:—
"The Government guarantee in respect of a sum not exceeding £1,250,000 for capital purposes should be utilised only after every precaution had been taken to ensure its productivity, and the council would advise the Minister as to the extent to which it was desirable that the guarantee should be made available. It would also fall within the scope of the activities of the council to have regard to the wider aspects of transport and to give consideration to such matters as the cost and condition of the roads carrying the bulk of the motor transport of the country and the incidence of taxation imposed for the building and upkeep of such roads."
That is a matter of very great importance to every local authority. That is the recommendation of the Transport Tribunal for dealing with the position of the Great Southern Railways.
They make recommendations also with regard to the Dublin Transport Company which start at paragraph 254. The Dublin Transport Company had suggested that they required to borrow a further £800,000 which should be repaid with the existing debenture stock of £300,000 over a period of ten years. This did not commend itself to the tribunal, because they felt, and I think very rightly and sensibly, that in order to repay that sum of £1,100,000 over a period of ten years, such fares would have to be charged by the Transport Company as would be unfair to the public. They saw no reason why that £1,100,000 should be repaid over such a short period. Instead, in the last sentence in paragraph 254, they say:
"We consider that the necessary capital should be raised by means of an issue of long-dated debenture stock, the company being empowered at any time after the expiration of, say, 15 years from the date of issue, to take advantage of the possibility of redeeming the stock by an issue of further stock at a cheaper rate."
That is the principal recommendation made by the tribunal with regard to the Dublin Transport Company. Paragraph 255 is of minor importance. Paragraph 256 refers to complaints made by the Dublin Transport Company with regard to competition by the railway companies in transport within the city, that is with regard to the running of buses for mystery tours, etc., and the recommendation in that respect was this:
"We recommend that the competitive passenger traffic between the Tramway Company and the railway companies should be the subject of a `pooling' arrangement. Such a pool would prevent wasteful and uneconomic competition, and would, therefore, be in the interests both of the general public and the companies concerned."
That is the nearest thing to anything in the nature of a merger. As to the suggestion for pooling, I suggest that if there was that competition still going on—probably there is not during the war years—there would be an excellent opportunity for arranging that pooling as between the Great Southern Railways and the Transport Company, at any rate. Since the managing director of the Dublin Transport Company has become chairman and practically dictator of the Great Southern Railways no difficulty can arise there now. These are recommendations which commit the State to nothing more than a guarantee of £1,250,000 to the Great Southern Railways. The tribunal made no suggestion that the debenture stock issued by the Dublin Transport Company should be under a Government guarantee and the total commitment the State would incur under the report of the tribunal was a contingent one of £1,250,000.
The proposal in the Bill is that the State should undertake the enormous liability of perhaps putting up the debenture dividends on a sum of £16,000,000. That that is a very serious matter we can gather from the statement by the Minister for Finance when introducing the Budget the other day, at the end of page 38 of his typed statement, he says with regard to this guarantee:
"The giving of this guarantee, which has become necessary for the protection and development of an essential undertaking, is one of the most important single financial transactions that has taken place in the history of the State. No Minister for Finance can assume without misgiving such a heavy liability—however contingent it may be and however hopeful he is of the prospects of rail and road transport in this country. In the present circumstances, when the impact of emergency conditions on transport is more severe than ever, and may, indeed, grow worse, no Minister in my place can be free from anxiety that the Exchequer may be in the shadow of coming obligations arising from this guarantee ... That is a possibility which must not be forgotten in any preview of public expenditure during the financial years that lie immediately ahead."
These are very serious words in connection with this guarantee of £16,000,000. I suggest to the House that they also should show anxiety with regard to committing the country to this contingent expenditure. Towards the end of that page the Minister says:
"If the full amount of guaranteed debenture stock authorised by the new Bill, viz., £16,000,000, is issued by the company, it will represent an increase of 44 per cent. in the total contingent liabilities of the State. Both absolutely and relatively this transaction is obviously one of outstanding importance."
In view of the fact that there is no such recommendation made by this tribunal who investigated the question of public transport, I think this House should not agree to the State undertaking that liability without further inquiry. The Transport Tribunal only recommended that the State should commit itself to a liability of £1,250,000. The Minister admitted that they had investigated the matter fully and he praised their report and paid tribute to them for the thoroughness with which they went into their work. The most they recommended that the country should be committed to was a sum of £1,250,000. Here, out of the blue, comes a proposal that the State should commit itself to a sum of £16,000,000 which, as the Minister for Finance points out, would mean an increase of 44 per cent. in the contingent liabilities of the State, and I assume that that means, in simple words, in the public debt of the State.
Deputy Larkin and other Deputies referred, very rightly, to the provision in the Bill dealing with officers and servants. For that provision alone, I think the Bill should be rejected unless there is some assurance from the Minister that it will be amended in Committee. The proposal is that if any officer of the company loses his employment after a period of six months has elapsed he may go without compensation, because that is, in essence, what it means. Deputy McGilligan referred to the Railways (Existing Officers and Servants) Act, 1926, which provided that the railway company, to avoid paying compensation, had to show that an officer or servant had not been dismissed as a result of the amalgamation of the railway companies during a period of seven years. I think that was the effect of it. Deputy McGilligan pointed out that he had discovered that the seven-years period was too short and that in fact there should be no period in relation to a matter of the kind. In other words, if a man loses his employment as a result of any piece of legislation we pass, no limit should be put to the period during which he would be entitled to compensation for dismissal.
It stands to reason. Why should there be a limit? If, when ten years have gone by, it is found that, entirely as a result of this Act—not because of any economies and not because of any alteration in the services—a man is dismissed, why should he, because that period of years has passed, be deprived of the right to compensation? We ought to cut out the period altogether but, at any rate, we should not be less generous than the 1926 Act which Deputy McGilligan, who introduced it, has since found was not fair to the officers and servants, or at least to one of them whose case came to his notice. We have a new departure here also, in that for the first time we find chapters appearing in a Bill. I do not think we have seen it in any of the enactments which have gone through this House.
The next section in the chapter, Chapter 42, deals with the inauguration of a superannuation scheme. It is a scheme which is to apply apparently to the new company. Section 43 refers to the existing superannuation funds of dissolved companies. I am given to understand that this is causing very considerable anxiety amongst railway officers who are members of the fund referred to in Section 43 (4), that is, the Railway Clearing System Superannuation Fund. The governing body of that fund, I understand, is called the Railway Clearing System Superannuation Fund Corporation, and I do not know how the Minister is to work Section 43, if he carries out the proposal in Section 42. I am entirely a child in these matters, but the officers concerned are very anxious about it, because they believe that, in the light of Section 42, it is not possible to carry out the assurances purported to be given in Section 43.
They say that the corporation dealing with this clearing system superannuation fund is a body of the general managers of all the railways, both in Great Britain and Ireland, which are parties to the scheme, and of the representatives of the staffs. It is established and conducted under statutory conditions laid down by the United Kingdom Parliament. They say that the funds are entirely controlled in England and that, in the case of the death of any member here, probate has to be taken out in England in so far as what that member is entitled to from the fund is concerned. They also say that no railway is admitted to this fund, unless the whole staff of the railway become members. If what they say as to the cardinal principle in respect of the admission of a company—that all its salaried staff must be entered— is correct, it is not possible to have Section 42, unless it is in addition to continuation as a member of the fund, and I think the Minister should see that it is very carefully looked into before Committee Stage.
On whatever date this Bill becomes law, the Great Southern Railways will cease to exist. The company will become a dissolved company and the members going over to the new company will possibly find themselves in the position that their rights are gone. The Minister shakes his head, but——
Comment on this
If they are right in saying that the cardinal principle for admission of a company is that all its salaried staff must be entered, then it is not fully provided for, because obviously Section 42 intends to institute here a superannuation fund for the members of Coras Iompair Eireann.
Comment on this
For the employees of a company who have no superannuation rights at all at the moment.
Comment on this
The members of the salaried staffs now and in the future will continue to be members of the railway clearing system superannuation fund. Is that the position?
Comment on this
The position will be continued so far as this new company is concerned, when established. What the future will be is another question altogether, but that is a matter for discussion and arrangement.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Minister appreciates that the railway company, when established, is a new company.
Comment on this
It is a mixture of a railway and a transport company, but I think we can get over that point. At any rate, it would have to apply for admission.
Comment on this
Yes. The railway employees who are members of the fund would know more about it than I and I am sorry that Deputy M. O'Sullivan is not here.
Comment on this
The railway company will have to apply for membership and, if they apply, they will have to say that all their salaried staffs are becoming members. I do not say that, in ten years' time, they may not decide otherwise, that they may not decide to resign from membership and operate their own superannuation fund. But if they apply for membership, I under stand that they must give the assurance that all their salaried staff will be entered.
Comment on this
That is not correct either, nor are all the salaried staff of the Great Southern Railways members of the fund at the moment.
Comment on this
I shall leave it at that because I am not sufficiently well informed in the matter. Deputy Doyle asked me to raise it because some of his constituents are very anxious about it.
To come back to the Bill as a whole, I think that the Dáil should be slow to allow the country to commit itself to a very big undertaking like this and such a big commitment of the country's finances. The main principle of the Bill is to merge the Great Southern Railways Company with the Dublin Transport Company. That is not a recommendation of the tribunal which sat on public transport. We have not been told where the proposals came from and we have not been told the reasons for their introduction now.
We have been given no reason why the recommendations of the tribunal that a period of five years in normal times of peace should not have been considered, in order to make a complete study of the problem, before committing ourselves to any final limitation in this matter. If we adopt that suggestion, the country would not be involved in anything more than £1,250,000 gross debt, even if it were necessary over a period of five or six, or seven, or even eight, or nine years, while the problem was being studied, to subsidise the railways. It would be far better and cheaper for the country to undertake that subsidy than to commit ourselves to proposals which deal with such a huge involvement of public funds.
Comment on this
Deputy Lynch has made reference to the Report of the Transport Tribunal. I read it very carefully, and I must say that I thought it rather a dreary document. The best friend of that tribunal could not describe its report as a very inspired production. I invite the Dáil to turn its attention for a moment from a report, which emanates from that body, that Government guaranteed loans in this country should bear interest at 4 per cent., to the Minority Report of Dr. Henry Kennedy which, in my judgement, is a more valuable document.
I hope, Sir, before departing from the Majority Report, that we have passed for ever from the day when Government guaranteed loans in this country will be issued at 4 per cent. With the report of Dr. Henry Kennedy, the Minority Report, I want to say that I agree, and I want to suggest to this House that this Bill, stripped of its verbiage is really a speculators' Bill. It is a Bill designed to ensure that the speculators will get what they hoped to get. Here is Paragraph 2 of Dr. Henry Kennedy's report written in 1939:
"The full gravity of the financial position of the Great Southern Railways Company is not shown clearly in the accounts. Representatives of the company in evidence before the Tribunal have stated that, in order to maintain satisfactory standards, an average annual expenditure of £600,000 would be essential for maintenance and renewals of the permanent way and works, and an equal sum for maintenance and renewals of the rolling stock. These amounts are relatively lower than the figures for maintenance and renewals submitted by the Great Northern Railway Company for its undertaking. The officers of the Great Southern Railways Company have frankly admitted the very unsatisfactory condition of the rolling stock, and especially of the passenger coaches, explaining that that condition is due to financial stringency, and consequent inability to provide adequate renewals.
"3. The chief Engineer has in recent years given only a modified certificate with regard to the condition of the permanent way and works. The company has stated that expenditure has been reduced to the irreducible minimum consistent with safety. There seems to be no reason to doubt the accuracy of the estimate submitted by the company. One result of the reduced expenditure is shown in the evidence that in order to maintain services on the branch lines, which it is proposed to close, an expenditure of £1,238,070 would be essential over the next five years. The deficiency in maintenance, rather than evidence of the operating economy, seems to have been the major consideration in the proposal to terminate services on the branch lines."
This report, based on the evidence of the company's own officers, reveals that the rolling stock and permanent way of the company were not only inadequate, but almost dangerous, because the engineer was prepared to give them only a qualified certificate. This report shows that the company itself believed that immense sums would be necessary to put the company's property in a safe condition. Nevertheless, with that before them, the evidence on which it was based, and the summing up of a member of the Commission, speculators entered the market and drove the price of the stocks up by 100 per cent. on the Stock Exchange, and in some cases, substantially more. That having taken place, we are presented with a Bill which, in effect, proposes that the Great Southern Railways Company is to be bolstered up on the one side by the acquisition of the Dublin United Transport Company, a traditionally prosperous and well-managed enterprise, and on the other side by a £16,000,000 Government guarantee.
After you have read the chapters and paragraphs and sections of the Transport Bill, is not that what it amounts to, that every fellow who bought stock from poor people and held it until it doubled and trebled in value on the Stock Exchange, is going to get his plunder in the shape of the Dublin United Transport Company and £16,000,000 of public money? I exhort Dáil Eireann to vote against a Bill, the only substantial effect of which, so far as we can see at this stage, is to provide the speculators of the Dublin Stock Exchange with comfortable profits, and, mind you, not only the speculators resident in Éire but other cute international crooks who got wind of the word through the usual channels and have been operating on the London Stock Exchange as well.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister does not want us to close our eyes to the fact that the Stock Exchange speculators have benefited by 100 per cent.?
Comment on this
The Deputy has suggested that individuals got wind of the word. That is a matter on which a judicial tribunal is sitting and I think it is improper that it should be discussed until the tribunal has reported.
Comment on this
Is it seriously suggested by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that some honest and public-spirited men on the Stock Exchange bought these shares of a prima facie bankrupt concern in order to relieve the widow and the orphan of their undesirable holdings? Or is it more reasonable to suggest that the “cute boys” went in and bought the shares in that undertaking to hold them in anticipation, in well-founded anticipation, that they were going to rise to double and treble their value because the Dublin United Transport Company would be absorbed by the new undertaking?
Comment on this
That is not quite the statement the Deputy made first. In reply to the submission made by the Minister: a tribunal has been appointed by this House to investigate the allegations of improper disclosure. The investigation should be left to the tribunal.
Comment on this
A judicial commission has been established to find out whether there has been improper disclosure of information. All I say is that these "boys" got the wind of the word.
Comment on this
Neither Dáil Eireann nor anyone here is going to limit my right to tell the public about these irregularities——
Comment on this
The Deputy got an opportunity of telling the tribunal about it. Why did he not do it?
Comment on this
I answered every question I was asked at the tribunal. If the Minister wants to draw me into a discussion of rumours which should properly be investigated by the tribunal, the only thing I want to add is that the Milltown Golf Club was the principal centre of these rumours——
Comment on this
All I want to do now is to record the fact that the Stock Exchange quotations for Great Southern Railways stocks have appreciated two or three times. That proves that those who held the stocks during the period were right. That is the only substantial and concrete factor of significance in this Bill. I am asking Dáil Eireann to say to the speculators, foreign and domestic, that they have slipped up, and that they are not going to get the swag they expected, and let them sell their shares as best they may. I would be glad if the House took the decision, so that these sharks would be left with their shares, and would not be given time to unload them on unwary people who would otherwise be left holding the baby.
I listened with some dismay to my friend Deputy Fionán Lynch. His speech was trenchant and clear, but I gathered from it as I listened that his proposal is that we should set up another transport tribunal. We have had several transport tribunals, and surely it is not proposed that we should set up another? If we are going to establish a transport tribunal every five years, the history of transport in this country will be a history of transport tribunals, because every time we try to make some progress, it can be argued that the report on which we are proceeding is out of date. In the meantime, the grass will grow on the railway lines and the transport system will collapse.
Comment on this
I want to make a proposal to the Government which I think is reasonable and right. The railway company is "bust"—"bust" wide open—and everybody knows it. The only thing that has maintained the company is the monstrous increase in railway freight rates which has taken place, with the Minister's approval, over the last two years. I think very few Deputies realise the reckless and unscrupulous way in which railway rates have been increased in the past two years. I direct the attention of the House to the Quarterly Statistical Bulletin of the Central Bank, which gives a return of railway receipts. That return, No. 15, shows that the goods train receipts have risen from £3,500,000 in 1941 to £4,242,000 in 1943. Let me make a comparison. In 1939, they were £2,635,000. In 1943, they were £4,242,000, and in 1944, they are still rising steeply. Will anyone argue that there is a larger volume of goods carried over the railways to-day than in 1939?
Comment on this
If there were, the increase might be in the order of not more than 50 per cent. That would give Deputy Davin a full and ample margin. The increases, however, amount nearly to 100 per cent., and certainly to 75 per cent. I could have brought here freight bills to show the specific additions to the charges, but, perhaps, at this stage it is scarcely appropriate to go into such great detail. It is known to anybody interested in transport that railway rates have shot up and that it is only the increased revenue derived from that increase which has kept the railway company in existence.
I propose to the Government that instead of pursuing the utterly disreputable and fantastic Bill now before the House, they should make up their minds to adopt the minority report of the Railway Tribunal and set up a transport board analogous in constitution to the Electricity Supply Board, which would take over the railway company, the Transport Company and, if necessary, the Grand Canal Company. I suggest now the names of two persons who might act as directors, Mr. Reynolds and Dr. Henry Kennedy. Dr. Kennedy is the kind of man, I believe, who would effectively represent rural interests on the board. I think these two men should be accompanied by three others so that you would have a board——
Comment on this
I think we should have a board constituted almost identical with the Electricity Supply Board, and I say that my experience of the Electricity Supply Board is that after it had got over its teething troubles— it was inclined to be somewhat dictatorial in the earlier stages—it matured. I can only speak of what I know in saying that in dealing with the Electricity Supply Board, as it is now, you are dealing with an efficient, a reasonable and expeditious body. You have the feeling that that organisation has developed what is so difficult to secure in monopolies such as this is: a desire not only to serve the community as a whole but also a desire to ensure that every customer it has will be satisfied with the service it offers. I suggest that, the transport board having been established, we should, by legislation, authorise it to take over the railway company, the Dublin Transport Company and, if thought desirable, the Canal Company, at the average Stock Exchange quotation for the year 1938. I do not think it would be fair to fix the year 1939, because the incidence of the war caused a downward tendency in share values on the Stock Exchange in 1939, but if we take the valuation placed on the concerns in 1938, then I feel that although we are not being over-generous, at least we are not being unreasonable and we are giving the shareholders in those two companies a reasonable price for their enterprise. Nobody would argue that the condition of the railway company improved since 1938, and I do not suppose that the Dublin Transport Company would argue that the condition of their enterprise had materially improved since that date.
That having been done, I do not think I want to say at this stage that it is possible for Dáil Eireann to set itself up as a board of directors to run a transport company. There is no use in my pretending that I can sit down here and discuss transport with the same authority as men who have been in the transport business all their lives. I think it is a great mistake for the Legislature, even when it decides to nationalise a public service, thereupon to resolve that Dáil Eireann must be consulted about every detail of the administration of the service it has been decided to take over. No body of shareholders claims the right to check up on the day-to-day policy of the board of directors of a company, nor are they competent to do so.
Shareholders, ordinarily, invest their money in an enterprise, which appears to them to hold prospects of success, on condition that the board of directors of that company is a body of men in whose judgment and capacity they have confidence. I suggest, therefore, to Dáil Eireann that if we take over the business of transport in this country, and are resolving to operate it, not as a speculative undertaking but as an essential public service, we have an opportunity, having taken over that enterprise, of choosing the best men that we ourselves want and appointing them as directors of the company. That done, and despite my devotion to the principles of democracy, I think we should leave the management of the transport industry to that board of directors, and then, if we find it unsatisfactory, if we find that adequate facilities have not been provided, if we find that charges are unreasonably high or that labour conditions are not consistent with what we think right and proper, we have an opportunity in this House of dealing with that board of directors when their annual report is presented here. When the transport board reports to this House annually, in the same way as the Electricity Supply Board does, we can call the whole conduct of the board into question and we can call on the Government of the day to carry into effect any changes that we think requisite in the constitution or administration of that board to secure the broad objectives which we consider are not being adequately served by the board as then constituted.
Now, no matter how good a board we establish, I suggest that it is a desirable thing to preserve the element of competition in order to spur that board on to its best endeavour. The longer I live in this world the more I am convinced that competition is the greatest blessing that any businessman can secure. The old view was that if you had a shop, you wanted no rival set up against you in your immediate neighbourhood. My experience, after 20 years of running a shop, is that the more Woolworths, the more Liptons, the more Home and Colonials that are set up near me, the better I do my job and the more money I make, and I also found that the less Woolworths, the less Liptons, and the less Home and Colonials are set up near me-the less competition, in other words, which used to be called unfair competition— the more I am inclined to stick my foot in the ground and grow like a cabbage.
For that reason, having created such a monopoly as I have envisaged, I think we should ensure for the consuming public, the users of transport, that competition should be preserved, and the way to secure proper competition here is to guarantee the right of every individual citizen to use his own vehicles for the transport of his own goods and for the transport of his own person, thus ensuring that if the Transport Board does not give adequate service, larger and larger numbers of citizens will purchase their own lorries and their own cars and travel on the roads in preference to using the railways or the vehicles made available by the board. I do not think that we should, on establishing this new board, close down the railway company or the railway system. That would be a mistake, but I think we should make up our minds to the fact that the railways are dying and that in a comparatively short time they will be as archaic and out of date as the Bianconi coaches of former days.
It may take 20 years or it may take 30 years, but certainly the younger Deputies of this House will live to see the entire goods and passenger transport of this country on the roads, and I think that one of the essential steps necessary to take—and I observe with interest that it is also contained in both the majority and minority reports of the Transport Tribunal—is to plan and put in hand without delay a system of roads in this country adequate to carry, not the volume of traffic at present available, but the volume of traffic that those who are most competent to judge forecast as being available 30 years from now. There, is a project upon which labour could be employed. There, is a project for which 85 per cent. of the raw materials are available here in our own country. There, is a project which would make possible a suggestion which I intend to make in connection with the Budget debate, and that is that the payment of the dole to unmarried men in this country should for ever cease and let every unmarried man who is looking for the dole get out and help the nation to build that system of roads that the nation will require, if and when the forecast that I now make comes to pass.
Now, some people will say that, strategically, it would be suicide ever to close down the railways and thus leave ourselves dependent on the rubber and petrol requisite to operate road transport. That is a shortsighted view, and an ignorant view, to boot. Firstly, I do not think that petrol will be the principal fuel of future transport. I think that the principal fuel is much more likely to be fuel oil, and that the Diesel engine will supplant the petrol-driven engine in a comparatively short space of time. A certain amount of imports from abroad would be required in that case, but the fact is that any system of railways in this country depends almost entirely on the import of raw materials. Many people think that if you can fuel the locomotive engines with turf, the trains could run for ever. That, of course, is nonsense. You could run small trains on branch lines for short runs with reasonable efficiency by using turf as fuel, but when it comes to the high-powered engines on the main lines, they could not be operated on turf; they could not generate enough steam on turf to make a long run with a heavy train. Furthermore, no train can be run for more than a day without lubricants. Even if we had all the fuel that we required, the lack of grease would bring the transport of this country to a stand-still. There is also the question of spare parts which are not available in this country. Steel and iron are not available in this country unless we import them, and these are constantly requisite to keep a railway in running order. The rails for the railway trains to run on have to be provided. All these things represent imports with just as much force as do Diesel oil, petroleum and rubber. Even the Taoiseach and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Department of Local Government and Public Health have come to the conclusion that self-sufficiency is all "cod" and they are beating a strategic and dignified retreat from that position. Sooner or later the more obscurantist and childish of their followers will realise that the Chief has turned tail though he is still looking in the same direction, and proceed to back gracefully out of the self-sufficiency position. That they have all to get out of it is manifest, from the point of view of maintaining essential services. Whether these services depend on rail or road transport, certain supplies from outside are necessary and, in effect, no more for road transport than they are for rail.
I hear it frequently alleged that people who get up here to discuss legislation confine themselves to criticism and that they refuse to make alternative proposals. I have made four proposals here to-day. Each one of them, I think, is first-class. One I made was to disappoint the speculators. Let us leave them holding the baby. That would be a great day's work for this House. If we made it clear to-day that we were not going to give the speculators the swag they calculated on, just imagine the effect on the Dublin Stock Exchange. Imagine the "boys" who had £75,000 worth of debentures waking up to discover that these were worth only £30,000 and that they had to make good the £40,000 or £45,000 which they had borrowed from the bank to speculate in these stocks. Imagine the dismay of the worriors who had bought some £60,000 or £70,000 worth of preference shares from poor widows and their neighbours who had held these shares for years without getting any dividend. The swag taken from these widows has trebled and quadrupled, but imagine the speculators waking up to find that what they thought would be worth £20,000 was worth only £3,000. Would that not be a public service? I invite Dáil Eireann to join with me in that pious public service of taking from the burglar his swag, taking from the brigand his spoils.
My second proposal is that instead of paying out £16,000,000 of public money to line the pockets of the Stock Exchange speculator, we ought to take over the transport enterprise of this country at a fair price and give to the owners a fair price, that we ought to provide an element of competition by the preservation of the right of the private individual to run his own lorry and car, that we ought to build an adequate system of roads forthwith to carry any traffic that may accrue over the next 40 years, and that we ought to make up our minds hereafter that, if there is to be any profit made in the transport of goods in this country it will accrue to the community, and that if this great investment is essential in order to preserve adequate transport for the commerce and trade of the country, the profit on that investment will accrue to those who make it, the community as a whole.
Lastly, I want to make this suggestion. Everybody says that post-war one of our most valuable invisible exports will be our tourist traffic. Large sums are being made available to the Tourist Development Board in order to improve the amenities and beauty spots of this country for the tourist trade. An absolute sine qua non to the full user of those facilities is an adequate road system because 95 per cent. of the post-war tourists are going to be in their own cars. They are not going to travel to any remote part of the country without carrying with them the assurance that they can move freely about to any particular beauty spot they have chosen to visit. Good roads then will be an immense additional inducement to foreign visitors to come to this country, roads prudently and discreetly constructed, adequate for the real needs of the country but not constructed in such a way as to destroy the amenities of the remoter and more secluded parts of the country which must ever remain less commercialised than those areas where the system of transport must be designed to meet commercial needs.
I want to make one more suggestion. If my proposals were put before the House to-morrow morning they would be carried unanimously. Is there any single Deputy who would object to taking over control of the present transport system of the country and using it for the good of the country through a transport board which we could establish for that purpose? Is there any single Deputy on the Fianna Fáil Benches who objects to the principle which I adumbrate? The Government's proposals are to ram down our throats a proposal to vindicate every unscrupulous speculator who has been operating on the Stock Exchange, at a cost described by the Minister for Finance as one of the most formidable liabilities this State has ever undertaken. That is the proposal which it is sought to thrust upon us by holding the whip over the reluctant heads of members of the Fianna Fáil Party who do not believe in this Bill. I am making a proposal which I believe will be acceptable to every member of the Government Party, which will be accepted, I am sure, by the majority of the Fine Gael Party, which certainly goes very much nearer to what the Labour Party stands for than the present proposal and which, I think, will meet with the approval of Clann na Talmhan.
If this is a democratic Assembly, and if our purpose is to do that which the majority of the House think best, why not withdraw the Bill and accept my proposal? It is really a proposal that does not reflect on anybody; it will achieve justice for all, and it will be launched with the best of good-will from all sides of this House. The Minister's mangy proposal is to be thrust down the throats of the Opposition and forced upon the reluctant members of the Government Party. Which is better? Surely mine. I understand the proposal I put forward now bears some likeness to proposals that were once adumbrated by the Minister himself. Why has he changed his mind?
Comment on this
Why has he changed his mind? Why has he run away from what he used to advocate at one time? I always believed that if these things could be operated by private enterprise it would be better to maintain that system but I am forced to the conclusion by the course of events that the maintenance of a satisfactory transport system in this country open to competition is no longer possible. Whether that is the fault of the directors of the old railway company or is due to the trend of world events I am not in a position to say and I do not think it is profitable to discuss the matter. The facts confront us. Let us think the whole thing over and do the best we can. If we do half as well with the Transport Board which has been adumbrated as Deputy McGilligan did with the Electricity Supply Board, we shall have every reason to be proud of it. There is, probably, as much ability available to manage the affairs of this Transport Board as Deputy McGilligan had at his disposal when he established the Electricity Supply Board and, given in the early stages, the goodwill which the Electricity Supply Board received from the majority of our people, I think we should be able to make a success of it. The Electricity Supply Board was adversely criticised at one time by influential members of the present Government. I can remember the Minister for Local Government and Public Health screaming about the horrible white elephant which had been left to the incoming Fianna Fáil Government by their predecessors in office. I often wonder if the Minister now scratched his head and asks himself where we would be but for that white elephant of Cumann na nGaedheal. The Electricity Supply Board was misrepresented in its early stages and vigorous efforts were made to destroy it by the Party which now constitutes the Government of this country. If the Minister sets up a transport board on the lines I suggest, no efforts will be made to destroy it and no lying campaign will be preached against it. No slanderous suggestion that it is a slave camp will be made. On the contrary, all Parties will do what they can by way of advice and recommendation to make it a success.
I look forward with hope to the emergence of something enduring which will reflect as much credit on the State that established it as the Electricity Supply Board. I make a suggestion which will be acceptable to all sides of the House against the Minister's suggestion which, in truth, is acceptable to none. There is time for the Minister to mend his hand and arrive at agreement with the Dáil on his proposals. If he does not, I think that the future of transport is extremely gloomy. If he does, I think we may reasonably anticipate success.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins moved a motion which is being discussed with the Second-Reading Motion in connection with this Bill. That motion provided for the suspension of further discussion of the Bill until the report of the tribunal at present sitting is available. I should like to support Deputy Dr. O'Higgins's motion as strongly as I can. Deputies on non-Government Benches have facilitated the Government with any legislation required. They were always ready to give the Government, in exceptional circumstances, the measures they desired with the least possible discussion. There has been no instance in which that help has been refused. The Opposition do not believe that there was any necessity for hurrying this measure in the manner in which it has been hurried. When the transport difficulty arose lately, the matter was referred to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. They recommended that certain privileges be given to the Government in connection with the Estimates. They also suggested that the House sit all day on Tuesday and Wednesday of each week. That arrangement placed at the disposal of the Government more time per week than has ever been available to any Government here. The Government has at its disposal a greater number of parliamentary hours per week than was available at any time since this country became self-governing. Notwithstanding that, the Government asked us to rush the consideration of this measure. It was considered so important that it could not wait for a week or two so that Deputies would have a chance of discussing it properly. Most Deputies live far from Dublin. I live 150 miles away. We come up here on Monday to facilitate the Government owing to the rush. We travel all day on Monday and work all day on Tuesday and Wednesday, without a moment to attend to the other business which Deputies have to discharge. If Deputies desire to transact other business for their constituents, they must either stay here over the week-end or do their business by correspondence from their homes. That takes a great deal of time and effort. Between the time the Bill was presented and Deputies were called upon to discuss it, reasonable attention could not be given to it. I venture to say that only a few Deputies on the front benches of the different Parties had knowledge of the details of this Bill on the first day on which this debate opened.
If other Deputies have a better knowledge of the Bill now, that is mainly due to the speeches delivered by Deputies who had more time than country Deputies to read and understand the measure. I frankly say that at the time this Bill came before the House, I knew nothing about it. I had not the time at my disposal to read it or to try to understand its contents. I have somewhat more knowledge of it now but that is mainly due to listening to men who knew more about the subject than I did and who had more time to consider the provisions of the Bill. I think that the House ought to support the motion that the discussion be postponed until the findings of the tribunal, which has been set up to inquire into certain matters which have been mentioned here, are available.
As to the Bill, Deputy Dillon said that the Great Southern Railways Company, as it exists, is down and out. I do not know that those were his exact words, but that was their effect. I am in agreement with that opinion. Everybody knew during the past seven to ten years that the Great Southern Railways Company could not profitably carry on. Its existence as a profit-making undertaking had ceased. It was only by various remedies, if they can be so described, that it was kept in operation at all. A number of things were done to help the company. There were amalgamations. Following the amalgamations, a number of competing transport concerns were put out of operation. Then, there was a watering down of capital, so that overhead charges, in the way of interest on capital, would be less if there was any chance of a profit being made. The remission of the rates in connection with their agricultural lands was a great boon to the railway company. Yet, with all these facilities in the way of reduction in capital charges, remission of overhead expenses, the company was insolvent and most people envisaged a situation, in the not far distant future, when the operations of the Great Southern Railways Company must collapse. That was a position that the Government would have to meet, but I am quite sure nobody expected that they would meet it by asking the House, without any particular discussion, to pass £16,000,000, and probably £20,000,000, to bolster up a concern which everybody knows is in a decaying and dying condition. It would be different if the House were sure that this £16,000,000 or £20,000,000—I frankly admit that I am not quite certain of the sum involved—would mean that the company would be put in such a position that they could guarantee efficient transport service for ten, 15 or 20 years, and that it would be able to repay the principal and interest.
I should like to know of anyone who sees any probability that, even with the extra facilities which the Minister proposes to give them in this Bill, the company will be able to provide interest on its stocks in the years to come. If, in the past, with monopolies and other facilities, the company was not able to pay a dividend on most of their stocks, is there any probability that in the years to come, when conditions will be changing and when there will be greater competition with other forms of transport, the company will be in any better position in regard to earning power? I know the Minister is attempting to place them in a better position by wiping out all possible competition but even with that, as far as anybody can foresee, there is little probability of their being able to repay the interest on the money which it is proposed to grant them.
The Minister stated that he disliked subsidies and that he hesitated to give subsidies that might be considered necessary in other circumstances. But what is this but a subsidy? What are the proposals the Minister present to the House but subsidies? Is not the guarantee of capital and interest, under present circumstances, a subsidy? As far as one can see, it is a direct subsidy because nobody foresees that the capital or interest will ever be repaid. Is not the compulsory acquisition and handing over to this company of another successful and solvent company a direct subsidy? If it is not, I do not know what subsidy means.
There will be strong objection to the proposal in the Bill to set up the new company under the authority of one man. I do not care who the man is that it is proposed to select, the House generally considers that no one man should be entrusted with the powers that it is proposed to give him under this Bill. I do not know if there is in this country any man with such comprehensive knowledge and experience of railway working, who has earned such a record for railway traffic management in this or any other country, that he could be entrusted safely with the powers proposed in this Bill. When the Minister thought fit to entrust the management of the Great Southern Railways Company practically to one official, he did not select a railway man; he brought in a man who had no knowledge of railway working. We do not know whether or not under the new Bill somebody with very little knowledge of railway working may be placed at the head of this concern, who, for a number of years, may learn his business at the taxpayer's expense and, through lack of knowledge and experience of the particular work, may create all kinds of difficulties.
I should rather favour the proposal of Deputy Dillon that, if we must have a national transport concern, it should be something on the lines of the Electricity Supply Board, consisting of a board of four or five or six of the most competent men the country could select, some of whom would have the best possible experience in the management of railways. The transport of this country should be entrusted to such a body. Experience has proved that it worked well in the case of the Electricity Supply Board although, when the Electricity Bill was first introduced, there were hardly any men in the country who had extensive knowledge of that particular problem.
The difficulty that most Deputies will find in voting for this measure is that the entire management is entrusted to one individual who may or may not have, and probably will not have, any extensive knowledge of railway traffic.
I have one other great objection to the Bill, that is, the reappearance of the compulsory acquisition clause. It is proposed compulsorily to acquire the assets and business of the Dublin United Transport Company. Compulsory acquisition is not altogether a new thing in this country. It has been applied in two or three other cases, but I think the further extension of the principle is not desirable. Many of us in the agricultural community are familiar with the principle of compulsory acquisition of land, and know how it ended, in many cases amounting practically to confiscation. When discussing this measure we cannot forget that we did not then get the sympathy we expected from other interests in this House. Very little sympathy of that kind was expressed by the representatives of industry until quite recently. When it comes now to the acquisition of a big concern like the Dublin United Transport Company perhaps the shoe begins to pinch. There is one satisfaction in this case, the Dublin United Transport Company shareholders are going to be better provided for than the people from whom land was acquired. If I were a Dublin Deputy, I think I would have pretty strong views in opposition to the acquisition of the Dublin United Transport Company. Do these Deputies realise that they are about to hand over an efficient, and a profit-bearing concern, which provides internal as well as external transport for areas up to 20 miles from the city at very reasonable rates? They are going to hand that concern over to people who provided to be inefficient, who failed to run the railways in the manner in which they should be run with the result that the company became bankrupt.
Can Deputies visualise what prospects there are of cheap transport in future? I happened to travel in a bus recently that goes to a place 20 miles from the city. I produced a few shillings change for my fare, but not thinking that would be sufficient, I tendered a ten shilling note, but the conductor said that the silver was sufficient. When I handed him 2/- he gave me back 6d. change. The return fare was also 1/6. In contrast to that I find when I travel by bus from the village where I reside, to the City of Limerick, the distance being three miles shorter than the Dublin one, I am charged exactly double the fare by the Great Southern Railways, so that Dublin citizens get for 3/- what I pay 6/- for. That is because the Great Southern Railways are not able to run their bus service as efficiently as the Dublin Transport Company. That is a benefit that the Minister may be the means of depriving Dublin citizens of in future, as it is obvious that if these services are handed over to the Great Southern Railways, as well as a capital of £2,000,000 and a good business in order to bolster up the Great Southern Railways Company, this Bill will not result in a wiping out of the difference in fares that I indicated. Is it not more likely that the fares may be raised?
I wish also to refer to the position of private owners. The Minister says that they are not affected by the Bill. Perhaps that is so. I should like to have a definition of "private owner". I assume that these words include commercial firms and limited companies that own lorries on which they carry their goods. I want to know definitely if "private owner" includes concerns like co-operative creameries with lorries in which they carry their products. Is the transport business of co-operative creameries to be handed over to the new railway company or do these concerns remain in the category of "private owner" ? It seems to me that there is a danger there. There is a fear in the minds of many people that that is one of the objects of this Bill, because in recent months there has been in my constituency a gradual disposition on the part of the Minister's Department to put lorries owned by co-operative creameries out of operation. I have many applications from managers of creameries asking me to intercede with the Department so that supplies of petrol would be provided for these lorries. The Minister will probably argue that that has nothing to do with this Bill; that the issue of permits for petrol was suspended because it was not available, and that there will be a re-issue when it is available. I am not at all sure that that is the reason why some of these lorries were not allowed to operate. I know of one very large co-operative creamery whose lorries had to go out of operation because the Minister's Department would not issue permits, and the transport part of the business had to be transferred to the Great Southern Railways. Experience has shown that they are not getting as efficient service from the Great Southern Railways as they could provide with their own lorries, and the business has not been running on the lines on which it was run previously. In fact in many ways that creamery is hampered. They also find that their expenses will be from £600 to £700 per year more than they were. Their computation is that the amount of petrol consumed by the Great Southern Railways services on their work, as against the quantity they required, would be greater by from 150 to 200 gallons per month. The case cannot be made there that it was necessary to save petrol and that that is the reason why the lorries of this co-operative creamery were not allowed to operate. Suspicion may arise in the minds of those concerned that that portion of the business was put out of operation so that when this Bill becomes an Act they will not be able to resume that side of the work.
Comment on this
I knew the Minister would tell me that there was nothing like that in the Bill. I say that the fear that such will happen is in the minds of these people. If there is no intention of putting these co-operative creamery lorries out of operation why are they not allowed to operate now? It is not because the petrol is not there. They can prove that the railway company is using more petrol than they were using. It must be for some ulterior motive, so that these lorries would not be operating when this Bill becomes an Act and that they would not then be allowed on the road.
Comment on this
If the Deputy intended any such accusation I would have to insist on its withdrawal.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Under the Seventh Schedule to the Bill, the Minister has the power to make Orders. Therefore, I think Deputy Bennett is entitled to ask a question.
Comment on this
Under the Seventh Schedule the Minister has the right to make Orders governing private transport or anything of that sort.
Comment on this
Not under the Seventh Schedule to this Bill. The Deputy must have a different Bill before him.
Comment on this
I am obliged to Deputy MacEoin, but whether the power is under this Bill, or some other Bill, it does not matter. If I have made a blunder in discussing this Bill it all goes to prove what I said at the opening of my speech, and what the mover of the amendment said in his speech, that the House should not have been asked to discuss this Bill in such haste. Deputies should have been given sufficient time to enable them to grasp the full contents of it. I am simply endeavouring to extract some idea of what is in the Bill and of what is not in it. I am afraid that most of us here have a very vague idea of what the Bill contains. Even Deputies who have read the Bill carefully and have pondered over it, have not been able to give it the consideration that they feel themselves would enable them to describe in clear language to the House what the Bill means or does not mean. I have listened to this debate for the last three days. With the exception of the Minister, I have not heard any Deputy say that he clearly understood what are the implications of this measure and what its general effect will be. In such circumstances, is it any wonder that I should look to the Minister for an explanation as to what he intends to do with private lorries owned by co-operative creameries: whether there is any danger of their being put out of operation in the future? The Minister would relieve our minds if he were to tell us that these lorries will be put back into operation again in cases where it can be proved to him that their going back on the roads would mean no loss of petrol.
This Bill will also have very grave effects on the unfortunate employees of the railway company. The question of redundancy has been argued pretty generally. We would like to know what men will be put out of work because of redundancy. Deputy Larkin described some of the things which he would not consider redundancy. At any rate, whatever be the meaning of redundancy, every Deputy must have sympathy for the possible conditions which will obtain in the case of those railway workers when the Bill is put into operation. I do not profess to be able to define clearly what redundancy means. My reading of the Bill is that, if a worker is lucky enough, for some reason or another, to be put out of work before a certain number of months elapse, he will be considered to be redundant and will get some compensation. If, however, he is not lucky in that respect and is discharged under some other head, then he is going to be unprovided for. Surely that is a state of affairs that no Deputy should subscribe to. The debate on this measure has been unreal. The Taoiseach nods his head. I agree that a number of us who have spoken on it have done so without sufficient knowledge. The fault for that lies with the Minister. The Bill was in the hands of Deputies for only two days when it was taken in the House.
Comment on this
We spent two days attending the sittings of the House. Deputies have other duties to discharge besides reading Bills. The fourth day was spent in going home.
Comment on this
The Minister supposes that we had nothing to do for two days except read the papers. That is a nice compliment. I hope that is not the view of other Ministers. We are working four days a week for the State. If the Minister thinks that the representatives of the farmers and of agriculture have so little stake in the country that they are not to have any day to work for themselves, and that facilities are not to be provided for them to do their own work, then the future of agriculture in this country is in a very bad condition and agriculture is very badly represented in this House. I do not believe, however, that it is so badly represented. I believe that we have farmers and farmer-representatives on the Government Benches, on the Clann na Talmhan Benches and on the Fine Gael Benches with sufficient work of their own to do, and with a sufficient interest in that work to occupy them for at least two days in the week. If they give four days a week to the service of the country, then I think they are doing their bit and should not be asked to do what is happening in the case of this Bill, to discuss a measure for which sufficient time has not been given. Sufficient time was not given to Deputies to prepare for a discussion on this Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy has referred to this question of insufficient time at least four times in a short period.
Comment on this
If I have done so I am sorry, but the matter is one that concerns everybody in this House, and what I have said will, I think, bear repetition. Other things that were not quite as important have been repeated. There is no necessity whatever for hurry in connection with this Bill. Not a tittle of evidence has been given to show why there should be all this haste. The discussion on the Bill could have been held over for another two or three weeks so that Deputies would have had an opportunity of preparing for a discussion on it. I believe that, in common decency, the discussion on this Bill should have been postponed until the tribunal, which is investigating the doings of certain people in this country, has presented its report.
Comment on this
The last speaker said that there was an air of unreality about this debate. I think that anybody really interested in this matter will say there is a good deal of truth in what he said. The debate has been very unreal, very far away from the real subject before the House. It would be helpful, I think, if we could get back to the position as it is, and not to what people imagine it to be. This Bill is a fairly bulky document, but I think we have had very much longer Bills before us. Everybody with experience of the House knows perfectly well that it is in Committee the details of a measure such as this are fully discussed, and that the object of a Second Reading debate is to get at the general principles underlying a particular measure. On any occasion when I have been in the House during the discussion on this Bill, except when the Minister was explaining the measure, the speeches seemed to me to be very far away from the general principles of the Bill. It is suggested that we are rushing this legislation. We are doing nothing of the sort. Everybody must admit that, for very many years, our transport services have been in an altogether unsatisfactory position and that the sooner we improve that position the better. We have been told we are not looking sufficiently far ahead and planning for the post-war period. There are some things which we cannot plan ahead satisfactorily, as the details are not sufficiently well know to us. Surely anything we can do now in the way of work which would have to be done after the war, will help to prepare us for the difficult situation which may arise then. If we postponed action in this matter, the Government might be justly accused of not taking time by the forelock, of not doing now the things we could do. Everybody will admit that our transport services will have an important part to play in the future development of our country. If we can improve them now, why should we postpone doing so?
It has been suggested that sufficient time has not been given to Deputies to understand the principle of the Bill, which is the question on the Second Reading. Is that right? Is that true? In March, 1943, the Minister indicated that he had been in touch with the management of the company and that proposals were being considered for reorganisation. Some months later, he told the Dáil that we had to go further and indicated that legislation would ultimately be necessary. Then, during the general election, the Minisster pointed out that legislation would be necessary to deal with the transport situation. The definite proposals which form the basis of this Bill and the main point of principle in it were published in October last, as far as the Great Southern Railways was concerned, and were indicated in December, as far as the Dublin United Transport Company was concerned. I think that there was a discussion on the matter in the Seanad in January last. Therefore, over that whole period since October and December, everybody knew the main basis of the proposals.
The Bill was circulated eleven days before the Second Reading began. That is a reasonable time to give to people, particularly when there was circulated with the Bill a White Paper, summarising in four pages the principal points in the Bill. In my opinion, the suggestion that Deputies did not get reasonable time to prepare for a Second Reading speech on this Bill has not a leg to stand on.
Deputy Bennett seemed to think that Deputies were here for the convenience of the Government. Deputies are here to do the business for which they were elected and not to convenience the Government. If they come here, they come to do public business and it is part of that public business that they should give time to these matters, to prepare so that they may be able to deal with them properly in this House. When they become Deputies they engage to do that. Surely, if a period of 11 days is given in which to read four pages containing the main principles of the Bill and if for several months those proposals have been discussed in public, that should be sufficient to enable anybody to take part in the discussion. There is no desire on the part of the Government to rush anybody and, in asking that the Second Reading now take place, there is no indication of any desire to try to rush its discussion in this House.
It is unfortunate that certain accidental things have taken place which have enabled Deputies to confuse the issue if they want to do so. It is possible that Deputies whose minds are easily confused may find themselves confused by these accidental circumstances. It is true that there is a shortage of coal now and that our transport services have to be curtailed. That brings about a serious situation for the whole country, and especially for those whose livelihood depends on their employment in that service; but it has nothing to do, directly and immediately, with this Bill, which was prepared before the shortage occurred. This Bill is for the control of transport services in a general period and not for a time of emergency. As it is a permanent measure, why should we bring in the present situation, which has nothing to do with the principles underlying the Bill?
Another unfortunate circumstance is that there is a tribunal investigating certain transactions which took place in a certain period, mentioned in the terms of reference. That tribunal was set up—
"To investigate and report on the dealings in Great Southern Railways stocks between the 1st day of January, 1943, and the 18th day of November, 1943; and the extent, if any, to which any of such dealings were attributable to the improper use or disclosure of information concerning proposals for the capital reorganisation of the Great Southern Railways."
That is what the tribunal is examining and that is apart and aside altogether from this Bill. If it should be found that there were dealings which were attributable to improper disclosures of information, or if there were other improper things done, I take it that these things can be dealt with by this House when the report comes to hand. I have no idea as to when the report may be ready. Why should we postpone consideration of this Bill until we have that report? This Bill would not prevent us from dealing with any individuals, no matter who they may be, who may have acted improperly, nor will it prevent the House from taking any steps that may be necessary to deal with the tribunal's report.
I was here when Deputy Dillon suggested that, to spite speculators, we should do something quite different. That was an extraordinary sort of purpose to put in front of members of this House. This Bill is for the better arrangement of our transport services. That is the fundamental thing that we have to consider —what is the best manner in which we can rearrange the organisation of our transport services, the control, management and so on so as to give the best service to the community. If speculators have to be dealt with we ought to deal with them in some other way. Certainly we ought not to use this Bill to try to attain an object of that sort. I do not know what speculation there has been. I remember being on the opposite benches when Deputy McGilligan was talking about the Drumm battery and the prospect he held out was so bright that I heard one Deputy say: "We will all rush out and get shares in the railway company."
Comment on this
I do not know. Perhaps it was because wise people thought that there was not much in the Deputy's statement.
Comment on this
Those who spend all their time dealing in stocks and shares and whose business is planning to see how they can improve their financial position by buying and selling are always on the look out for a good price.
Comment on this
There is a difference between speculation after the Dáil has been told and 12 months before.
Comment on this
That is a matter the tribunal will investigate. I am only saying that it would be quite wrong procedure for Dáil Eireann to try to use a measure like this to deal with speculation. If speculation has to be dealt with let it be dealt with as a separate thing.
This measure has no relation to speculation in railway shares but if you want to deal with speculation it seems to me that you will have a very wide subject indeed to deal with. I am not going to try to defend speculators who try to deceive the public. I have never speculated and I know nothing about the business but I do say that it seems to me that most private business is carried on one way or another by speculating on the chances of making a profit. I am sure Deputy Dillon in his business tries to buy the things he thinks will increase in value.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is unaware of his own Emergency Powers Orders which require the sale price to be based on the basis of cost and not of enhanced value. Speak up, Minister for Supplies, and instruct him.
Comment on this
I am not talking about the emergency. I am speaking of ordinary times. I think myself that where business is carried on for profit and where there is buying and selling you buy at the lowest price you can get and buy those things you think will appreciate in price. That is speculation if you like. It runs through a lot of our economic activities. Perhaps I should not say the whole of our economic activities. I think if you try to deal with that you will have your work cut out for you. If there are people improperly buying and selling and if people such as the widows and orphans mentioned by Deputy Dillon were induced to sell shares to people who were buying to make a profit by all means let us inquire into it, but it seems absurd that we should make use of a measure like this to deal with it. The purpose of this Bill is to improve the transport service and nothing else. The arguments ought to be addressed to it from that point of view. With regard to the point that the measure is being rushed, I can only say there is no basis whatever for that. You have made long speeches on it and you have plenty of time to deal with it. There has been no attempt to rush you and you have got ample notice of the measure; I think four days is the period in Standing Orders and you have got eleven days. You had a White Paper presented to you to make things easy so that you could grasp the principles of the Bill. You knew the principles of the measure some months ago so you can have no basis for the complaint that the Bill is being rushed.
With regard to the fact that the tribunal is sitting, I think it would be absurd to put aside doing something that ought to be done until we receive the report of the tribunal. If the tribunal reports, action can be taken on that basis if the Dáil wants to take action and this measure will in no way tie the hands of the Dáil. I have heard the complaint that we are offering to throw away £20,000,000 in this Bill. It is quite clear that people who talk like that have not attempted to understand the Bill. The £20,000,000 that have been mentioned is the authorised capital of the new company. In other words, they can have capital up to that amount. That is the only way you can have the figure of the £20,000,000. How is that figure arrived at, supposing they reach the figure of £20,000,000? There is £13,500,000 which comes from the purchasing of the stock of the existing companies, of the railway company and the Dublin United Transport Company, on the basis indicated in the White Paper. The shares of each of these companies are going to be transferred over to the new company on the basis that was announced here a few months ago. That means £13,500,000 roughly of the authorised capital will already be accounted for and the remainder of that is to enable the company to borrow such sums, from £13,500,000 up to £20,000,000, as may be necessary to improve the earning power of the company on the one hand and the facilities it can afford the public on the other. It is to enable the company to borrow money which will enable it to get improved equipment. We all know that the position of the company was such that it could not borrow up to the present. The Great Southern Railways was not in a position to raise new capital in order to do anything. It was to put the railways in a position in which they could get equipment necessary to enable them to do their work in the best interests of the community that you had to enable them to borrow money.
That is the reason why the authorised capital has been raised to £20,000,000. There is in this matter no question of the State subsidising them or handing over any money whatever to them. What the State has done, or rather what the State will do after the Bill becomes law, is this—it is going to put a State guarantee behind the debentures and other guaranteed stock. That is being done on the basis of the reduction of these stocks as is set out here in the White Paper on the Bill. The 4 per cent. debentures of the Great Southern Railways are reduced to 3 per cent., pound for pound. The 4 per cent. guaranteed preference stock is divided into two parts. If you hold £100 of that stock, you get £50 of the 3 per cent. debenture stock and you get £50 of the common stock. On the £50 at 3 per cent. you will get £1 10s od. Afterwards, if the company thrives, they can get on the £50 ordinary stock half of what would go on £100. It depends on the dividend that they may earn. It is purely a matter of estimation in the future whether they will earn or not. We hope they will. At any rate, the terms given to the 4 per cent. guaranteed preference shareholders is that they get £50, on which they are guaranteed £1 10s od, and they will get £50 stock on which they will have to take their chance, as it is ordinary stock. On the 4 per cent. preference stock they are simply given £100 common stock, and the ordinary stock also will be pound for pound common stock. Is it suggested that these terms are unnecessarily generous to the stockholders? I have not heard anybody making a detailed case that they are.
Comment on this
If the State were to take them over, as has been suggested —if they were to be acquired and nationalised——
Comment on this
If we were to take them over I doubt if the majority of the people would feel they were being dealt with fairly by a proposal of that sort. I only know that there was twice a reduction of stock. On the amalgamation in 1924 it went from £27,500,000 to £26,000,000, and by the 1933 Act it was brought down to £12,500,000.
Comment on this
Well, about £11,500,000. I remember that there was very strong dissent from a number of people here when that Bill was going through; they were saying that the debenture holders were very improperly treated when, for £100, they got £85; that it was altogether unfair to take the 4 per cent. guaranteed preference stock and write it down to £50; that it was still more unfair to write down the 4 per cent. preference stock to £35 and, taking off 90 per cent. of the ordinary stock and writing it down to one-tenth of its value, they said, was robbery. What is being done in this case is that the dividends and interest are being considerably reduced. The burdens which the company will have to carry are being considerably reduced by this Bill and, in view of the reduction, there has been a State guarantee given instead. I can understand people going into details and arguing on this basis but, looking at it, it seems to me not an unfair proposition. It is very hard to get anything that could be said to be definitely fair; there are different points of view. One thing, at any rate, is that there have been negotiations and the companies have agreed on this. You may say that if the companies have agreed it must be good for them. Our position is that it is also good for the State if we get agreement without arbitration. Very often the State does not do so very well in arbitration. The State does not always do well in arbitration.
Comment on this
What significance does the Taoiseach attach to the fact that the shares went up by 100 per cent. at least when these proposals became known?
Comment on this
All I know is that if somebody holds on now to a share of £100 of common stock, originally he must have bought that at £1,000. If you go on with the buying and selling, that is one of the troubles. People talk about extravagant bank profits. They forget that shares may have changed hands time after time and there are very few of the original stockholders left. If you own at the present time a £100 share of common stock, originally you would have to have ten shares or, in other words, £1,000.
Comment on this
If my shop goes bankrupt, will you buy it out on those terms? Why should you pay the railway company any more than you would be prepared to pay for a person's shop or any other enterprise? People put their money into the railway company to earn dividends and they have lost it. Why should we pull the chestnuts out of the fire?
Comment on this
Set up a board and take over the railway company at the average Stock Exchange quotations for the shares in 1938, the year before the war.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows perfectly well, with regard to the buying of shares, that you may buy property and it may not be quoted because there may not be sales.
Comment on this
The Government are putting this forward as representing a fair deal in the existing situation. It represents fair dealing with the transport problem. There is a reorganisation on the basis of a State guarantee and reduced dividends to those who had the stock. That is what is being done.
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach realise that he is guaranteeing stock to people who for years never got a dividend?
Comment on this
Withdraw the guarantee and then see what the stock will be worth.
Comment on this
This is being put forward by the Government as a fair proposition. Nobody can get any exact basis for doing this. The procedure of trying to get the company's consent and agreement was the method adopted rather than compulsory acquisition, because, apart from anything that might be unfair about it, if we came here with a compulsory acquisition Bill all those who are now talking in favour of it would probably be against it, just as on the occasion when we were proposing to write down the debentures from £100 to £85, we had objections from the benches opposite on the ground that we were robbing the people of their property.
Comment on this
With regard to this question of what will happen when the tribunal reports and so on, that is a matter we can leave over because we are not in any way tying the hands of the Dáil in dealing with that matter when it arises.
Comment on this
It is not in the Bill. If this tribunal had not been in existence at all, this Bill would have been brought in. Does anyone doubt that?