We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Transport Bill, 1944—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 135–282 of 282. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Transport Bill 1944
Lapsed

No. 10 of 1944 ›

If there is a suggestion of changes as far as details are concerned, they will be matters for consideration on the Committee Stage —each detail can be dealt with.

Comment on this

Will the Committee Stage be postponed?

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is the Taoiseach to be allowed to speak without interruption or is he not? He is making a speech and he has as much right to make it as any other Deputy. It is the duty of the Chair to see that he is allowed.

Comment on this

We got little or no information from the Minister. We are getting some from the Taoiseach. He said it can be amended in Committee as a result of the findings of the tribunal.

Comment on this

No, I did not say that.

Comment on this

Does that mean that the Committee Stage will be postponed?

Comment on this

I said nothing that the Deputy could reasonably understand as that.

Comment on this

What I say is this——

Comment on this

The Deputy was allowed to speak without interruption and he should, at least, concede the same right to others.

Comment on this

I wonder why the Minister is so bad-tempered at the word "speculators".

Comment on this

I am so bad-tempered because of the disgusting manners displayed by the Opposition.

Comment on this

There are disgusting matters which we want to have disclosed.

Comment on this

We ought to get back to a little bit of order. What I am saying is that, on the Second Stage of the Bill, what we are considering are the main principles of the Bill. These are designed to try to improve the transport services of the country and put them in a proper position. We are anxious to have that done, and to have that permanent position. reached as soon as possible. There will be uncertainty with regard to these proposals in the railways and in the tramways. That uncertainty is not good. We want to try to end that uncertainty with all possible speed. I suggest to the Labour Party that they ought to be particularly interested in ending any uncertainty in the position, because the stronger the position of railways is financially, the better will they be in a position to carry on, for instance, over a longer period, if necessary, with their employees, etc. At present they cannot do that. I suggest to the House that it is very bad national business to leave this in an uncertain position. We should get out of our heads, so far as this Bill is concerned, two things which are purely accidental. One is the emergency which is causing the curtailment of services and the hardships which that possibly would bring on the community and, possibly, would bring on others, a thing which everyone must regret. The other is the question of the sitting of the tribunal to examine whether there were disclosures and, therefore, improper dealings as a result. I suggest that by passing this Bill we are not tying our hands in any way from dealing with the other matter. The difference between the Second Stage and the other stages is that there may be amendments in the other stages. Deputies can put down their amendments and, if these amendments are ones which, in the general interest, should be accepted, I am perfectly certain that the Government will consider them from that point of view.

Comment on this

Indicate the clauses

Comment on this

I am indicating no clauses. I am talking of the general principles which ought to hold for any Bill. This Bill is based on certain general principles and the Second Stage is for dealing with them. In the case of a long Bill like this, the Committee Stage is the proper stage to deal with details and, if Deputies have suggestions to put forward for the improvement of any of these, they will be considered on their merits. I can say that with regard to any Bill.

Comment on this

Will the dictatorship be changed?

Comment on this

The position with regard to the control of the company is that there is to be a chairman who is to be appointed by the Government and there will be six other directors chosen by the ordinary shareholders.

Comment on this

"Yes-men."

Comment on this

Why should they be "yes-men"? Are they not there to look after the interests of the people who put them there?

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

The Bill says so.

Comment on this

It does not. The Deputy ought to be very pleased to have what is in the Bill. I know that for a long time nationalisation has been the policy of the Labour Party. I understand that is their policy. But there are a number of other people supporting them at present who do not believe in nationalisation.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

Why not test them and withdraw the Bill?

Comment on this

We are not here to test people. That is like what the Deputy said the other day. We are here to get things done. The position is that, where there is a public utility, such as the transport services, there are various grades of opinion. There are those who think that you ought to leave it absolutely free and not interfere with it; let the whole thing go as wild as the transport service in Dublin at one particular period before it was dealt with, when we had competition amongst buses. You can have that state of affairs completely and absolutely uncontrolled. I do not think that, at any time, people were prepared to allow a public service of that sort to be absolutely uncontrolled. Then you could bring in measures of control. These measures of control range from the sort of control which existed in pre-war days up to the position in which the State owns, controls, and operates the railways. I take it that the position of the Labour Party is that they want the State to own, control and operate them. I must say that I am not a believer in that at all.

Comment on this

The Minister promised that in 1931.

Comment on this

He did not.

Comment on this

I quoted his speech.

Comment on this

I do not mind what you quoted. I know the position well enough to know that the Minister said at one period that it might be necessary to go on to that.

Comment on this

The position of the Government—and it is my personal position, too—is that the extent to which the State enters into economic affairs and the whole guiding principles are set out in the Constitution.

Comment on this

Will the Taoiseach read the Minister's speech of the 9th December, 1931?

Comment on this

I have not the time to read the speech now.

Comment on this

There are only four lines.

Comment on this

I know well what the Minister is likely to have said.

Comment on this

"We are strongly in favour of public ownership of the transport service".

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach is in possession and must get a hearing.

Comment on this

There is the question whether there should be public ownership, public control and public operation. I say with regard to the Labour Party—I take it they wish to go the whole hog——

Comment on this

——that I do not believe in that. It would be interesting to find where you draw the line.

Comment on this

The Minister has a copy of our proposals. He admitted it.

Comment on this

We are putting forward our proposals now, and our proposals are not those. I do not believe in the running of the railways by the State, through a State Department, to start with. I do not believe it would be efficient, and I believe it would be a bad thing for the country from a variety of points of view. I do not want that to start with. The next thing is that you could have control in a variety of ways. The sort of control I would stand for would be that control which would make sure that the public interest, and not merely the private interests of the shareholders, would be kept to the fore. I am in favour of that, and there is provided in the Bill a method by which the public interest in the transport services can be safeguarded. We do that without becoming directly the owners. It is done by means of contact between the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the railway management. It is provided by having a chairman, who is appointed by the Minister and removable, whose business on the board will be to see that the public interest, and not merely the interests of the private shareholders, will be safeguarded. That is the purpose of the chairman, who, however, does not act alone. He will be there as a public trustee, so to speak, but there will be with him six others who are interested in the efficient management of the railways from the point of view of making them pay.

Comment on this

Without any power.

Comment on this

If the Deputy thinks that six people representing a certain interest will not make themselves effective so long as they are there, he does not know human nature.

Comment on this

Read the Bill.

Comment on this

I know the Bill, and I know that the position is that these six people are there to see that the transport services are efficiently run, because it is only by having the railways efficiently run that they will have any chance of getting any dividends for their, shareholders.

Comment on this
Mr. Larkin

On a point of order, Sir. Is it in order for a Parliamentary Secretary to read a book while the Leader of the House is speaking?

Comment on this

It is the Life of de Valera he is reading.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It depends on what the book is. It might be relevant to the debate.

Comment on this

There is a general permit to read the Life of De Valera.

Comment on this

It is a good book to read.

Comment on this

Tá an ceart agat, a chara.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach is entitled to at least as good a hearing as the Deputies who have already participated in this debate, and will get it.

Comment on this

My purpose in speaking was to try to get this matter fully considered on its merits and to get an understanding by Deputies as to what we are doing on this Second Reading. There is the method by which the public interest is safeguarded, so that the public interest will not be lost sight of in any desire to secure efficiency and the other directors are there to see that there is efficiency, for which the spur will be the ordinary spur in the case of business men trying to make their business pay. I think it is a fair combination. Many years ago —about 1908, I think—I read a paper which had been read at a meeting of the British Association in Dublin, in which the whole question of railway control was considered. The questions of public ownership, private ownership, private management, and so on, were discussed and the conclusion reached in that paper was that it was necessary to make sure that the public interest was safeguarded and that one of the ways was the appointment of directors as a whole. That had the fault that the interests of efficiency might not be so well safeguarded. I believe that this proposal here is a sound one. It is somewhat of a variation of what has been done in relation to other matters, but it is a sound proposal. It provides a method of getting maximum efficiency, of getting it away from being the subject of public discussion every day here, which has been the case in countries where there has been direct State management and which has been a fruitful source of damage.

Comment on this

Would the Taoiseach consider the Electricity Supply Board technique for railway management?

Comment on this

We have more than once had some discussion of that, and we are not altogether satisfied that it is the best by any means. We do not think it is the ideal method.

Comment on this

Is this considered better than the Electricity Supply Board arrangement?

Comment on this

These enterprises are not quite on all fours and, for this particular purpose, this method, which is a slight variation of the method of control, is one which we believe will be successful. That is only our belief; we may find that we are mistaken in the long run; but we believe in it sufficiently to desire that it should be given a trial. I repeat that all I wanted to say was that there are two accidental matters which are confusing, or which are brought in deliberately to confuse, the issue; the existence of the emergency and the tribunal which is at present sitting. The issues can very well be raised on the method of control on our method of organisation—that is a fair matter; it is what the Dáil is here to discuss —but we put forward our proposals which we believe to be the best. The reorganisation of the capital of the company is designed to reduce expenses and there is a saving of about £70,000 per year, I think, in respect of debenture interest and so on.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is not too clear about the £70,000.

Comment on this

The saving in respect of debenture interest of the Great Southern Railways is £70,000, but the total saving is much more.

Comment on this

A saving of £70,000 in respect of an immediate reduction of interest charges. What the State is doing is giving a guarantee. That guarantee, I think, is not likely ever to be required.

Comment on this

Not?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance does not agree with the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance is naturally anxious and properly anxious about every contingent guarantee. He very rightly and properly looks askance at any extension of State guarantees. This is a matter in regard to which, I think, Deputy McGilligan and those who apparently have his philosophy with regard to money cannot complain very much. It is a matter of opinion whether it is likely to materialise or not. I think the position is such that, under the new arrangement, the company ought to be on a fairly sound basis and able at least to make ends meet.

Another matter to which I feel I should refer in passing is the amalgamation of the Dublin United Transport Company with the railways. It has been suggested that that is an unfair proceeding so far as the transport company is concerned. Now, with regard to the citizens of Dublin, the position is that we hope that they will have just as satisfactory a service under the new arrangement as they had under the old one. If it is suggested that, where there is a special density of population, there should be special transport services separate from the rest of the State, that is something which would not be in the national interest as a whole.

We believe, in the national interest as a whole, that Dublin, which is the national capital and whose prosperity and position depend ultimately on the country, is really best served by the amalgamation. If you do not take national interests into account your position will be that each separate area will take over the cream of the services and neglect the rest. Then the State would have to step in to deal with the problem. We think these services ought to be self-supporting. There is no question of any subsidy in this Bill. The whole idea is to try to make these services self-supporting, and we believe that the proposals put forward by the Minister are such that any person who makes up his mind that he is not going to allow himself to be confused by considerations of the moment will support them. It is in that spirit that the Government is proposing the Bill.

Comment on this

When I saw that the Taoiseach was about to intervene, I felt that he intended to act in the same manner as that in which oil is poured on troubled waters. I did not expect his intervention would have the contrary effect. He created some disturbance in this House, and I think the uneasiness and perturbation manifested here should have convinced the Taoiseach himself, apart altogether from the context or content of what was said, that there is something definitely wrong in the whole situation about this Bill. In my very short experience here never, I think, has there been such agitation about any matter as on this occasion. It certainly has caused a greater stir than any other measure which has come here for consideration. The Taoiseach gave us such a wide variety of angles on the subject that it is very difficult to know where to begin, but it became evident, as I listened to the Taoiseach, that he was in much the same plight as ourselves. I sympathise with him sincerely that his grasp of the Bill was not much better than that of the younger Deputies of this House, in matters of detail.

I am sure, however, that in the matter of principle he is well posted. I think that when we discuss principles we may have the best intentions. We may not be doctrinaires in economics any more than in politics—but in the actual working out of a principle, we may discover that there is no good in it, that it has been negatived. We may agree that a principle is enshrined in this Bill but may hold that the manner in which it is proposed to carry it out is ineffective. The Taoiseach evidently wants us to discuss the Bill in vacuo. Apparently, he thinks there is no relation between it and speculation and, to a certain extent I agree, that it must be considered apart from the question of speculation. Speculation is a very desperate thing when it overrides itself in any State.

I am sure that everyone is familiar with the case of modern France when the Stavisky scandal rocked that State to its foundations. I submit that we have come perilously near to the same position in this country over this business. Whether we have been able to take it in hand or not remains to be seen. The Bill as such should, of course, be discussed apart from the aspect of speculation, but its impact is on it and it is strong enough to vitiate the whole issue of the Bill.

Even supporting the principle of this Bill, we would be very loath to operate it in these circumstances, and under these conditions. I quite agree that it is a long-term policy, a case of getting ready for the post-war period — perhaps I would more properly put it, the inter-war period before the next conflict—but that does not mean that we have any good reason for optimism about it. I am unconvinced by the statement of the Taoiseach about the time that has been allotted to us. I still think that the White Paper was not as ample a document as he imagined it, or that it gave us a summary or résumé of the principles of the Bill. It is merely a condensation and, even as a condensation it is more difficult to read than the Bill itself. Certainly, it is a very difficult document to grasp. If, in this paper, there had been a proper discussion of the new principles about which the Taoiseach talks, then it might have been very helpful to new Deputies and to those who have not long experience of legislation such as the Transport Bill.

I suggest that even the Taoiseach found considerable difficulty in wading through the White Paper, difficulty even on the front page. It consists of many sections and many pages, and because of the importance of the whole of it, I submit that it is a Bill to which even more than 11 days should be given. We may have ideas about transport, we may have our own principles with regard to transport, but we must discuss the problem as a legislative assembly and not as a debating society, relate the provisions of the Bill to our principles, and see how far they coincide or diverge, and what accommodation is possible between the Bill and our principles. I submit that it is not possible to do that in the short time at our disposal. We are asked to dispose of this Bill in less than a month, but no statistician could make the investigation that it is necessary to satisfy himself that justice has been done either to the workers or to the public, and in the time allowed, no statistician could dig up the facts and assess their value over a period of years.

The Taoiseach seems to suggest that matters which have been under consideration for several years should be disposed of in a survey over a period of three weeks. That is the real difficulty about the Bill—the Taoiseach and Ministers who have been intimately connected with the details have had this Bill under consideration for months past, yet they ask the House to dispose of it in a few weeks. This legislation is of particular importance as transport is the lifeblood of the country. It concerns the workers employed in the industry and it affects the whole economic future of the State. Under those circumstances, I think the Minister would be well advised not to press for the rushing through of this Bill before the 1st July like a Hurricane or a Flying Fortress. Plenty of time could be given, unless the Minister has inside knowledge about the opening of the Second Front or the collapse of the European situation. If he thinks the war is going to end in a much shorter time than I do, then there may be some justification for his desire to rush the Bill.

Everyone in this House who has been democratically elected for the purpose of discussing the nation's business is concerned to see that we will be prepared as a nation to withstand any shocks that come in the period after the war, but a good case must be made out for it. So far a case has not been made. I think that any Deputy who has considered the matter will see that there are so many different ways of approaching even a question of principle that the short time at our disposal is not sufficient for the discussion of the matter. Most of the members of the House whom I have heard speak have approached this question from the point of view of what they consider to be their own principles. They have ideas of their own in relation to transport.

Personally, I have great sympathy with the Minister presenting such a Bill when he has to traverse the diverse workings of many minds on the matter. I am sure he could reply when many of the past ideas of his own, his theoretical principles, are quoted against him that consistency is the refuge of a small mind. We have had many somersaults here. I was quite amazed to notice the change in the economic outlook of some of the members of Fine Gael and particularly of Deputy Dillon. I should say that the age of miracles is not yet past and if the Minister for Industry and Commerce has done nothing else, even if this Bill were to go into the limbo of forgotten things, he has done a very good day's work in converting a number of leading figures to the policy of nationalisation or an approach to that policy. He has brought them nearer to understanding something about the control of transport.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy restoring Deputy Dillon to this Party? Is that part of the function of a leader of labour?

Comment on this

Does the prospect of restoring Deputy Dillon appal you?

Comment on this

I noticed that Deputy Connolly was very nice about it, but he seems to be determined to shove him back here.

Comment on this

If you recall my words, I made a definite distinction. I said "leading members of the Fine Gael Party". I was more amazed to find that Deputy Dillon had come nearer to the Labour Party's conception of a proper system of transport.

Comment on this

That was your second version.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I do not think that the Labour Party is claiming Deputy Dillon any more than Fine Gael is claiming him. I was just saying that I think it is good to have a more realistic approach to these economic questions than we have had for some time past. I was going to add, and I might as well do it now, that whether the statements of the people in opposition when they are in opposition are of any great value is another matter. Had I the time, which I regret I have not, to search in the past, I am sure I would find that the policy of Fine Gael on the question of transport is no more consistent than the policy of Fianna Fáil.

Whether again that is any grave matter for politicians is a question that is somewhat apart from the main one. To my mind, the whole Bill is a Bill that even in its title is quite uncertain as to where it will lead us. A great deal of this uncertainty runs through it. The title itself would lead one to believe that it has a narrow basis, that it deals particularly with two big concerns and their amalgamation. But, in fact, if you examine the Bill you see that it is of much wider scope, that it proposes to operate a transport service and to take over and acquire the whole or any part of any transport undertaking. Transport service, in this Bill, means not the rail and road and canal services which we have at the present time but, in fact, it means as well, sea, air and road services. In other words, in discussing this Bill we are discussing the future transport of the country—transport as a whole in all its forms.

We are dealing not only with the railways and the Dublin Transport Company and the canals but with the company or the concern which will have prior rights, and probably exclusive rights, in regard to any development of transport, whether that development is by way of the Drumm Battery or by electrification or by jet propulsion or helicopters or other forms of transport. We do not know what they may be. It will all be under this company. This company will have everything to say in regard to anything that has to do with transport in this country, and it is for that reason that I think the Dáil should be particularly concerned with the control of the company and with what method is observed over its control by the nation: how its acts shall be regulated, how its employees shall be treated, and how it shall attain efficiency for the different sections of the country.

It appears from the Bill itself, that we have a new form of control, a control that is not the same, we have been assured, as the method of control obtaining under the Electricity Supply Board. It is not a method of nationalisation. It is not a method, I think, that is known by any precedents. It is a new venture, and what the exact working of that venture will be, it is difficult to forecast. Whether the present situation of the railways justifies this new method is a very moot point. It has been termed a method of control by dictatorship, and on this point I think the Taoiseach himself has not, as has been alleged by members on these benches, sufficiently studied the Bill. It is quite true that he may have read Section 35, which deals with the board of directors. The Taoiseach informed us, correctly, that there would be six of these directors and a chairman. In sub-section (3) of that section it says that the chairman alone shall constitute a quorum at a meeting of the board. Sub-section (4) says that no meeting of the board shall be held unless the chairman is present thereat, and, as if that were not watertight enough, we finally have sub-section (5) which says that no decision shall be arrived at by the board at any meeting without the concurrence of the chairman.

Those are certainly very drastic powers. There is something in what the Taoiseach says: that if you have six men, six businessmen with railway experience, and men of responsibility, they, despite the regulation in the Act and despite the curtailment of their powers, will, as normal human beings are apt to do, make their presence felt. Now, there is no doubt about that, but here is the point: if they are in agreement with the chairman, then their presence or their submissions or their representations will have the same effect on the transport company and will be carried into effect, but if they disagree with the chairman, if they do not walk the same path as he does, if they do not follow along the same line, then the chairman is the determining factor. It is, undoubtedly, a fact that the whole motive of existence of these directors on the board would be to spur on the railway company to improve the efficiency of the railways. As the Taoiseach has said, that will be their duty, but what is the criterion of efficiency? It is not something that is abstract or ideal or that can be found in a White Paper. Efficiency has certain connotations, particularly with regard to transport. Everyone knows, everyone can see, that here you have an amalgamation of two concerns, one with very large interest in the railways and the other with very large interest in the road services.

Now, I am not adverting in the slightest to the character of the present chairman or the presumed chairman, or the chairman who has been in the position and who may be promoted to this other position. Apart altogether from his personal qualifications and character, any chairman coming into such an amalgamation of two diverse interests such as is proposed here must be either one or the other. He must, to use the common parlance, be either road minded or rail-minded. Now, which is he to be in this case? If he comes from the Dublin Transport Company, if he comes with that background, he will be bound to have certain views with regard to the railways and will be bound to be road-minded.

Those six directors, on the other hand, who probably will be picked as representatives of the interests of various industrial concerns through the shareholders, will undoubtedly, so far as one can see, be mainly rail-minded. There you have an obvious conflict of interest. If they were all to be road-minded then one could make a case that their representations would have an effect upon the all-powerful chairman, but if they are opposed to the chairman, or if he is opposed to them, you do not get a deadlock, but you get the chairman, with his overriding authority, being able to determine the whole policy of the Government. Now, that is a principle. That is not a detail of the Bill. That is not something that you can amend on the Committee Stage. That is the question around which the whole Bill revolves—this question of control—and that point undoubtedly must be met. These men will either be "yes-men" or "no-men", but whether they are yes-men or no-men, what the chairman says goes.

Comment on this

He is the "go-man".

Comment on this

The "go-ahead" man.

Comment on this

He is the head man of all. It is a very important thing then to discuss, in the creation of such a board as that, what is the outlook of the chairman. I submit that in a transport concern he cannot be both. I suppose that Deputy Davin or anybody who has been brought up on the railways, who has known their working, in and out, all the time, could not conceivably, in any circumstances, take the same view of a transport matter as would be taken by another person who regards the whole question of transport as devolving on a road service. It is undoubtedly true that many of those who have been brought up with the road tradition believe that the railways are obsolete. They believe that there is no future for the railways. I think—I am not quite certain and am not giving this as a quotation—that a Minister, even the Minister for Industry and Commerce himself, was accused, at least at one time, of making some remarks of that character. Whether that is so or not, there is undoubtedly a tendency manifest in this country and every other country to believe that the railways are obsolete.

It becomes a question then of considering whether the State is wise in putting in capital, in putting in some resources, and even in giving guarantees, to bolster up what has been described as an obsolete service. There will be a conflict there on the board. There will be railway-minded directors who believe that there is a future for the railways, whether through electrification or through rationalisation of the whole concern, or by connecting it with various forms of road transport. They will believe that there is a future for the railways but the chairman, if he be road-minded, might look upon these things from an entirely different point of view. He may come from a sphere of industry where things are naturally at a higher state of efficiency because in the evolution of human society and in the evolution of industry, road transport has undoubtedly been at a higher level than rail transport. It is a later movement, it has learned the lessons of the past and undoubtedly it has been enabled to achieve a different type of organisation, in some ways a much more efficient type of organisation, judged from commercial standards. Now the man who comes with that training to control the transport company may consider that his duty on lines that are best for the State, best for his own colleagues, best for the shareholders and best for everybody concerned, is to carry through some rationalisation of the railways, according to methods to which he has been accustomed in his control of road transport. That may be calamitous in its effects.

For instance, in the past we had different crises. We had the closing down of the Broadstone at one period and I am sure as a result of that closing down or amalgamation, we had the transfer of many workers hither to employed there to other services and other workshops. Their transfer would naturally increase very much the overhead charges in such workshops. Railway people who are accustomed to such things would try to ease that situation or improve it within narrow limits but a person coming from outside, with his idea of hustling and the organisation that obtains in the road service, might reasonably consider that these workers constituted a very heavy overcharge for which no value had been obtained for the company. He would undoubtedly make out from the economic point of view a very good case for the redundancy of many of these workers. But there are bigger issues in this question than the mere, narrow, commercial idea of efficiency. We have to consider transport, as the Taoiseach said himself, on the basis of a national service. We have to consider it as giving value to the community in every shape and form and we must consider such mere commercial views of efficiency as would be held by this hypothetical chairman to be dangerous to the country as a whole, dangerous to the community in its repercussions on the people employed in the concern itself and on people outside.

I think this Bill has created such a feeling among many of those who are at present working on the railways. We know that by the idea of Mondism, the idea of rationalisation which was so common in Great Britain and America in days gone by, different sections of different industries were put out of commission in order to conserve profits for the profit-makers and provide better guarantees for the speculators. We in this country escaped a great deal, if not all, of that policy of Mondism and rationalisation but many of those now working on the railways are wondering whether, under this transport concern, we are to have a very much delayed spate of rationalisation. There are provisions in this Bill in regard to redundancy which would indicate to their minds that that long-delayed rationalisation of the railways is about to take place, that quite large sections of these men will find themselves without an occupation when the Bill becomes an Act and is implemented. That is a very serious question of principle, a question that concerns us particularly on these benches. That is why we should like the question of compensation for railway servants to be dealt with in a much more generous spirit than is indicated in the Bill.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think that there will be fewer people employed in the new transport service than in the past?

Comment on this

There may be economies.

Comment on this

I am not referring to economies. Does the Deputy think that our transport services are going to be of such a kind that fewer people will be employed?

Comment on this

That is what the Minister indicated.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister said, but I should like to know the Deputy's views.

Comment on this

If the Taoiseach wants me to speak frankly about that matter I should say that what I have stated indicates the current that is running through the minds of very many workers at present employed on the railways. They fear that when you are bringing, as I have termed him, a road-minded man into control of the whole concern, inevitably there will be rationalisation. They fear that there will be a cutting down of various forms of employment, that, from the point of view of road-transport efficiency, he may consider many of the smaller stations, for instance, as unnecessary. He may consider that the workshops repairing these vehicles could be brought up to a higher level of efficiency. As I have indicated, and as the Taoiseach knows very well, in Great Britain and in America there was a spate of what was known as rationalisation, under which firms used to get out a stop watch and time every different action of the worker. They developed the endless chain system, so well known in connection with Fordism. They ran everything so efficiently that they were able to close down sometimes one-third or one-fourth of the plant and yet were able to get the same output from the remaining workers. They were able to increase the economic efficiency, the efficiency which would pay dividends to shareholders, efficiency from the point of view of commercial standards, but an efficiency that, from human standards, I am sure the Taoiseach will admit, was entirely wrong and would not suit this country.

Comment on this

I wonder did that diminish the number of people employed?

Comment on this

I believe that the industry developed and that as a result very many more people were engaged. I only want to know if that is not so.

Comment on this

No, particularly in the steel industries. They had an amalgamation. I remember going over some of the factories in Sheffield. They had an amalgamation under one of the big steel concerns there. They transferred wholesale the machinery in what they called uneconomic shops to better situated shops and closed down the uneconomic works completely. To such an extent did this go that in many places in England and Wales the steel industry was wiped out and the workers were left without occupation in that line. As a result of this short-sighted rationalisation. When this war came upon them, they were in a very sad state and there was a long delay in getting these mills restarted.

The question of the short time allowed in which a decision is to be come to regarding redundancy—from July to December—has been dealt with by other speakers. I am sure that the Taoiseach, with his humanitarian outlook, will see that that period of six months will be extended. There is no reason why this question should not be left open to decision over a period of years. There is, in fact, no reason why any definite period should be inserted in the Bill at all. If a man is proved to be redundant as a result of the rationalisation, following upon this amalgamation, he should, in justice, be entitled to compensation. The question of the period should not affect the matter at all.

The question of nationalisation has, naturally, been debated upon this Bill. The Taoiseach said that the Labour Party went out whole-hog for nationalisation. Our alternative proposals are not—as an individual, I am sorry to say it—whole-hog nationalisation proposals. They are proposals which were enshrined in a document presented to the Minister and with which he is familiar. We indicated in that document that our idea of the organisation of the transport industry was of the nature of a public utility company, with certain control by the Oireachtas, not in regard to every-day policy but rather as a check. An annual report would be submitted to this House, as is done in other cases, and if there were a desire for discussion upon the policy of the principle of the transport concern, then such report could be availed of. We do not at all regard as desirable nationalisation in a form in which every little movement and action by the transport company would come under fire in this House. Our proposals did not proceed upon that line.

The question of nationalisation is one that cannot, unfortunately, be considered without relation to the particular subject under discussion. If it could, a very good case could be made for nationalisation, particularly in the present economic situation of the country and of the world. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has assured us that he has read the funeral service over capitalism and that we are entering another period of economic life. What exactly it will be called it is hard to say but so far as indications by the Minister, Fine Gael, Deputy Dillon and, more particularly, Deputy McGilligan are concerned, they suggest some form or other of nationalisation.

The exact working-out of what constitutes nationalisation is a problem which would have to be left to each industry. Whether it would be practicable or desirable to have nationalisation per se in one major industry, while the remainder of the industries of the State were privately owned and conducted on the principles of the system which the Minister assured us is dead, is a very difficult point to decide. Nationalisation, if it is to be really effective, should extend over all the major and heavy industries of the country, all the industries that are susceptible to amalgamation and that are capable of being brought up to a moderate state of efficiency. It would not, of course, include one-man industries or craft industries. These could not, under any conceivable scheme, come under a scheme of nationalisation or socialisation. But transport is the lifeblood of the whole economic system and it is susceptible to some form of nationalisation. It is a great pity that the Minister lost his chance of trying out some form of nationalisation in this case instead of adopting the method of a chairman-controlled concern to implement the ideas of the State and control the general tendency of the undertaking.

The financial provisions of this Bill would require three months' discussion by statisticians. I suppose it would be possible to discuss them apart from the situation in which the new company is to be born. The Minister, however, has indicated his desire to launch the new company so soon after this period of speculation that it would be astonishing if there were no relation between the speculation that has taken place and the launching of this concern, despite the wishes of the Minister or the Government. When the Taoiseach was asked could he state the cause of the phenomenal rise in the Great Southern Railways Company shares, he had to answer that he did not know. He did not know why the ordinary stock had risen from £9, on March 26th, 1943, to £52 on March 24th, 1944. He had no answer. Surely there must be some reason for this phenomenal rise. It is not confined to ordinary stock. Preference stock jumped from £14 on March 26th, 1943, to £52 on March 24th, 1944. Guaranteed stock jumped from £28 to £72 on January 28th, 1944. Debenture stock jumped from £56 on March 26th, 1943, to £90 on March 24th, 1944. Surely these are phenomenal rises. They must have some explanation. If it is stated that the provisions of this Bill bear no relation whatsoever to this movement on the Dublin Stock Exchange of a character never previously experienced in dealings in these shares, then the age of miracles has returned.

Speculation may have unduly boosted these shares; there may have been leakage of information proper or improper, which may have further boosted the shares but the commonsense view is that apart altogether from this unusual, abnormal state of affairs, if a Transport Bill were to be brought forward in a normal state of affairs the provisions of the Bill or what were understood to be the provisions of the Bill would affect railway shares, either favourably or adversely. The shares would go up or down according to what the experts considered to be the implications of the Bill. Therefore, if we subtract from these phenomenal rises in railway stock what might be due to abnormal causes, and then try to relate them to the normal operation of the Stock Exchange, we must admit that there is every indication that persons interested in these shares considered that the provisions of this Bill would be unduly favourable or extravagantly favourable as far as they were concerned. That, in my submission, is the real reason for this speculation and that is the answer to the question which the Taoiseach was unable to answer.

Finally, I wish to refer to cross-Border traffic by road vehicles and the method that should be adopted for the control of this traffic. It may not be a question of principle, but it has had important reactions on the country and should be considered. Many people concerned in this business know that for a number of years there has been an invasion of the south by vehicular traffic from the north. There has been a muscling-in of services and traffic which would normally have gone to the Port of Dublin and probably the Port of Drogheda and perhaps Dundalk. It is being diverted to the north by road haulage. There has been a consequential diminution in the volume of employment among dockers in the south along the southeast coast while no great economic advantage has accrued to the country to offset that loss. We have advocated in that connection that there should be a licensing system limiting the field of operation of these cross-Border road vehicles, having due regard for the national interest. We do not suggest that they should be completely prohibited, because some case may be made for a certain volume of this traffic, but to allow them absolute freedom to operate without some proper form of control would be to abandon all that traffic to these higher powered and, in some ways, more highly efficient services. We are particularly concerned with this diversion of traffic. I am sure that is a minor point that can be settled.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to private cars?

Comment on this

Yes, for public hire.

Comment on this

Nobody can ply for public hire for the carriage of goods here except they are licensed under our Act.

Comment on this

We understand that there is some form of licensing in operation, but we consider that, if there is to be a transport system, particularly in the cases I referred to, where a national transport concern will not operate directly on the rail service, there should be some restrictions, in the interests of the State and of employment, on the activities of those cross-Border vehicles which operate into territory which should naturally be drawn off by rail services from the south. Navan is such a case. We consider that there should be greater control of licensed road hauliers from the north, but not a complete drying up, because that would not suit people generally, their convenience or economic interest. A case could be made for restrictions in order to help a return of traffic to what I hope will be a more efficient railway service under the new concern.

Comment on this

I rise in protest against the introduction of this Bill, particularly in view of the fact that an inquiry is taking place at present, and that we are prevented from making any reference to the outcome. Deputies in this Party will oppose this Bill, because we are of opinion that it is to a great extent dictatorial by placing the control of transport in the hands of one individual. Accordingly we believe it to be the duty of this House to prevent such a measure becoming law. In introducing the Bill the Minister laid strong emphasis on the necessity for a reorganisation of transport. It is generally accepted that he failed to outline the extent of the Bill's operations, if it becomes law. He gave no indication of future plans for dealing with transport. Motor-tax revenue goes into the General Exchequer. I am of opinion that a large increase of heavy traffic over the roads by lorries and buses is inevitable under the new proposals, and consequently the Minister for Finance will welcome such additional revenue.

Comment on this

Motor taxation does not go into the Exchequer. It goes into the Road Fund, which is under the supervision of the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

Not the whole of it.

Comment on this

Some of it is taken out again.

Comment on this

Some of it is taken out to finance relief works on roads.

Comment on this

I understood that the whole of the licence duty does not go into the Road Fund.

Comment on this

The whole of it does.

Comment on this

This Bill will result in a large increase in the number of vehicles on the roads. At the present time the roads are not in a condition to deal with any substantial increase of heavy traffic, and any extra burden placed on them will mean rapid deterioration. That will undoubtedly entail the expenditure of a large amount of public money. The Minister is aware that the maintenance and repair of roads is the concern of local authorities and that they have to defray the charges from local rates. Accordingly, we may visualise much higher local rates for the upkeep of roads, particularly in the rural communities. It may be assumed that the railways will remain the major traffic arteries between towns, but the roads will be used for the transfer of merchandise from the railways. The revenue collected from increased road traffic will be distributed, I suppose, according to the Government's wishes, but there is no guarantee that local ratepayers will not have to bear the burden of increased construction and maintenance for the accommodation of fleets of heavy buses as well as for haulage work.

Comment on this

The money is distributed on a mileage basis.

Comment on this

That may be so now. The Minister will realise that the trend is towards road transport. Deputies have pointed out that the manager of the new concern may be road-minded. Is the Government prepared to remove the burden of road maintenance from local rates? Will local authorities have to maintain roads for the increased burden which will be imposed upon them if the manager is road-minded?

The concentration of all transport under one body may be detrimental to national economy, inasmuch as the opportunity of providing cheaper methods of conveyance is considerably reduced if there are vested interests affected. Should some new motive power prove cheaper and more efficient than the existing system there is every reason to assume that the chance of trying it in competition with the other methods is eliminated. Does the Minister see that point? The monopolists will not be ready to scrap plants in which considerable funds have been invested and to substitute services which would cost the community less. The obvious outcome would be that the community would be penalised by a monopoly which would not scrap its plant for one that would provide cheaper, more efficient services. The effect on cost of production is of particular importance in an agricultural country where transport represents a large part of total costs. That might mean that the world price of our goods would stand higher than those of countries in which newer and more efficient transport methods were operating, thus reducing cost of production as well as cost to consumers.

Should this occur, it would mean penalising our export trade and adversely affecting our home standards of living. The Bill makes no provision for the replacement of obsolescent transport with newer developments. In fact, by setting up a body which is not State-owned, and yet not open to private competition, practically ensures this adverse result. The Minister will admit that the company which he intends to set up is not a State-owned company, and yet that it will not be open to private competition. The Minister will also understand that this company is to be sheltered like an infant industry. No provision is made as to when it is to come of age. It is to be continually sheltered. One could understand if it were to be sheltered for two, three or four years, but according to the Bill and to the Minister's statement it is to be continually protected from any competition, private or otherwise. Cheapness and efficiency are the results of human and private initiative, the pitting of one man's skill against that of another, the incorporation of new ideas and technique such as may be attained within the framework of a totalitarian economy where, of course, specialists are trained for that purpose. The Minister is aware that he has not got specialists here for that particular type of totalitarianism.

This Bill relieves Córas Iompair Éireann of all the distinguishing marks of an ordinary company. In fact, it sets up a department where the members, directors and stockholders are to receive a definite remuneration stipulated by the State. That remuneration will not depend on the initiative of the persons concerned. They are relegated to the position of the wage-earner whose wage is guaranteed by the Government, and will have, in their newfound positions, all the irresponsibility of such wage-earners. They will have nothing to worry about. Their wage is there, and they are going to be paid irrespective of what they do or how they do it. The normal incentive towards a reduction of costs—the profit motive—is completely wiped out because, in no instance, can the stockholders receive more than 3 per cent. on the debentures, and 6 per cent. on the common stock. There is, therefore, no inducement towards providing cheaper services. The company, on the one hand, will have to face no competition, and hence need not look for trade. In other words, it can just look on the public as it likes. It will not need to facilitate the public or give the public the service that it would have to give if it were a private company open to competition. It will not need to give the public the service that it would have to give if it were a State company nationalised, and had to give an account of itself in a yearly report to this House. This new company is to be protected in every possible way, with a guarantee from the Government that it can earn a certain dividend or certain wage. The normal functions of a company are being taken away. The company is a collection of fixed income earners. There is no inducement to the company to provide cheaper transport. It is not even being burdened with the effect of making a loss, should earnings be insufficient to cover commitments.

Comment on this

What about the ordinary shareholders?

Comment on this

The ordinary shareholders have a guarantee from the Government.

Comment on this

The ordinary shareholders? On a point of order, may I ask, has the Deputy been reading his speech?

Comment on this

No, not necessarily. As I was saying, the company is not even burdened with the effect of making a loss should earnings be insufficient to cover the commitments to pay 3 per cent. on the debentures. That will still hold good because the necessary moneys to meet that are to be provided by the Oireachtas. Subsections (1), (2) and (3) of Section 17 give the company that guarantee. The company is not even required to pay back these moneys. Again, in Section 7, it allows the Minister to make any regulations that he thinks fit. If in anything I have said, I have hurt the feelings of, I think, the Deputy from Cork—I do not know his name—by exposing something that he does not agree with he will get sufficient time to read his speech if he wants to read it.

Comment on this

The Deputy admits then that he is reading his speech?

Comment on this

No. I said that you will get sufficient time to read your speech if you want to. The company, therefore, when it is set up will be deprived of all incentive to provide cheap transport. To relieve the company of the consequences of earning a loss is to deprive it of the incentive to give cheap transport. The initiative to do so will not be there due to the fact that guarantees are being given by the Government that its losses will be made up by the State coming to its aid.

Comment on this

Is not the 3 per cent. on the debentures being guaranteed?

Comment on this

The debentures are guaranteed.

Comment on this

Is not that a guarantee that if the commitments they engage in——

Comment on this

The debenture holders are not the company. The company consists of the ordinary stockholders.

Comment on this

Yes, but does not the Government also guarantee them?

Comment on this

The Government does not guarantee this £16,000,000 after the end of 1960?

Comment on this

The Government guarantees the principal and interest on the debentures. There is no guarantee whatever to the common stockholders.

Comment on this

Cheaper transport is promised, but the volume of transportable merchandise carried by the railway company in normal times resulted in a loss of money. The road services managed to pay. I would like to have an explanation from the Minister, if he can give it to me, as to how he is going to get the railway company to function, to pay dividends and fulfil its commitments when, at the present moment, it is not in a position to do so. If it is not able to do that now, will the Minister say how he expects this new company that he is setting up is going to be able to do it?

What action will the Government take to force the company to do that? Cheaper transport is promised, but the total volume of normal transportable merchandise is fixed and in normal times the railway company is losing money and trade. The road transport system was beating it by giving more efficient and cheaper services. If individual competition outwits the new combine, will the Minister intervene to prevent that and give a complete monopoly to the railway company?

Comment on this

We are not proposing to do that.

Comment on this

Then what is to happen to the money that is guaranteed? If individuals find it easier and cheaper to run their own lorries to bring their own merchandise wherever they want it, instead of using the railway, has not the Minister got power under this Bill to prevent those individuals using their own lorries?

Comment on this

No, there is no power of that kind.

Comment on this

How can more economical transport be promised, in conditions in which there are major reductions in services and a new company is formed which must pay a 3 per cent. dividend on the debenture stocks? I want that answered. If there must be a 3 per cent. dividend and if the new company continues to lose money, what guarantee is there that the Minister will not have to come to the company's aid?

Comment on this

The old company had to pay 4 per cent. and that is changed to 3 per cent., which represents a saving and a reduction in the cost of operating transport.

Comment on this

Will there be a reduction in cost?

Comment on this

There will be at least the reduction from 4 per cent. to 3 per cent. on the debentures.

Comment on this

The total volume of transport business is unchanged, so economies resulting from a unit operating on a larger scale are automatically excluded. To operating costs running expenses, maintenance and replacement, is now added a charge approaching £500,000 interest on debenture stock. That is the commitment of the Government. If the railway company fails to pay the interest, the Government is charged with £500,000 interest annually.

Comment on this

Only if the whole of the debentures are issued.

Comment on this

In the same breath, the Minister promises cheaper services all round. How can that materialise? Has the Minister any guarantee beforehand, in setting up this new company, that it will give better services than the one functioning at the moment? There is no guarantee.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must not cross-examine the Minister. He should make his speech and address the Chair.

Comment on this

The Minister is making a very vague promise, in the hope that this new company will be able to cover its commitments and pay the £500,000 interest. The economies of large-scale operation are promised; there is no inducement to economic management, and the consequences of loss are dismissed. An initial millstone of £500,000 is placed around the neck of the company. If charges are reduced, it can only mean that the Oireachtas is paying part of the cost, and that means that the consumer must really pay a higher price for the services rendered, though in a disguised form. The Government will have to pay to the company this 3 per cent. on the debentures, and £500,000 must come from the taxpayers in taxation disguised in one form or another.

The private hauliers ran their lorries on a mileage basis. Have we any guarantee from the Minister that the new company will take the farmers' merchandise from the farmyard to the fair or market and remain there for the day; and, if so, will the company charge for that on a time basis or on a mileage basis?

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I told the Deputy he must not cross-examine the Minister. The Minister cannot guarantee anything but what is provided in the Bill and the Deputy has the Bill before him.

Comment on this

That is a detail of management, which is not provided for in the Bill at all.

Comment on this

In introducing the Bill, the Minister did not define the details, so we have to ask him now. We wish to know exactly the conditions under which he expects us to support or oppose this Bill. We must know how the farming community is to be treated.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that, when a Bill leaves this House and becomes law, it is for the courts to interpret it and the Minister disappears then entirely.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Mr. L. Cosgrave Fine Gael

The Minister does not disappear in this case.

Comment on this

As Deputy Cosgrave says, the Minister does not disappear. He is the hidden dictator and has the power to remove the chairman at any moment. The interpretation that will be given to this Bill will be the interpretation the Minister desires. The Minister, in introducing the Bill, failed to give the meanings which he wished to apply to the Bill and that is why I put these questions to him, through the Chair. I hold that, if the future trend of transport is towards the road, it will mean a heavier draw on the ratepayers. Those of us who represent the farming community will have to oppose that. It would also mean that the lorries which are used to take pigs and cattle to the local railway terminus or bacon factory may have to be retained for five, six or seven hours, which would mean heavy costs to the farmer and a reduction of his profits. It would mean the reduction of whatever profits he would have.

Judging the Bill as a whole, although there is necessity for reorganisation of transport and for a new system, I do not think this Bill will bring that about. I do not deny that the Minister may be under the impression that it will bring about the object which he has in mind and lead to the more efficient development of transport. But we here are honestly of the opinion that it will fall short of that. It will not have the desired effect in making the transport of this country, both rail and road, as efficient as the people would like and in particular it will not give a cheaper system of transport. The transport system, especially the railway system, is costly and I do not think the Bill will alter that. For that reason, I and others on these benches, will oppose it and I appeal to members of the other Parties, even those of the Fianna Fáil Party who are not afraid of the Whip, to oppose it also.

Comment on this

That means Deputy Ó Cleirigh.

Comment on this

It is not addressed to Deputy Ó Cleirigh any more than to any other Deputy. I am not trying to forecast what Deputy Ó Cleirigh is going to do. That, of course, is his business. My appeal is to every Deputy to oppose the Bill. We are not doing this for spite or from any reactionary motive but rather from a progressive motive because we wish to see a more progressive and acceptable Bill before the House.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach in speaking here to-day expressed the great truth that the details of a Bill can be amended upon the Committee Stage but that the Second Stage is concerned with the principles of the Bill. I submit to you, Sir, that the principles enshrined in this particular Bill are concerned mainly with the directorship. There is the directorship with a chairman who has full overriding powers over everything. There is the question of the £16,000,000 guaranteed and £20,000,000 ordinary capital. Thirdly, there is the management and general working of the Bill or of the transport of the country or the amalgamation of the Great Southern Railways and the Dublin United Transport Company. If the Second Reading were taken, you could not change any one of these three things in Committee because then you would alter the whole principles of the Bill. I submit that every attack and every opposition made to the Bill has been made on these three points. There may have been minor points raised like lack of time to examine the Bill and so forth, but these are the three outstanding principles and they cannot be changed.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Mr. L. Cosgrave Fine Gael

If the amendments are accepted, cannot these things be changed in Committee?

Comment on this

I would not agree that either the powers of the chairman or the composition of the board is a matter of principle.

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

You would accept that the capital is a matter of principle?

Comment on this
Daniel McMenamin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That could also be changed.

Comment on this

I would regard as a matter of principle the decision to guarantee the interest on the debenture stock, and to guarantee the debentures. The manner in which the new capital might be dealt with is a matter of detail.

Comment on this

And the amalgamation?

Comment on this

The amalgamation is a central part of the Bill. The Bill was introduced primarily to set up a new company consisting of these two companies amalgamated.

Comment on this

Then you take it the way control is exercised is not a matter of principle.

Comment on this

The method of exercising control is a matter of detail.

Comment on this

I will accept that, but from the manner in which the Bill was introduced one would take it that the control of the company was enshrined in it as a matter of principle. The Minister says that that is not so but he was quite clear that that control was necessary to make the proposal a success and he went further and said that it was only just short of nationalisation. I submit that the difference between what he is doing and nationalisation is the difference between two figures one on the same sheet and that is nothing. In the Bill the proposal is to abolish two existing companies and to establish a new company, transferring the powers of the two companies to one company, the management of which will be held by a managing director who is to carry out the instructions of the Minister and the policy of the Government of the day. The difference between that and nationalisation is nothing. I want to be quite clear as to where we stand on this question of railway transport of the country on these benches. We believe in the establishment of a public utility company run on the same lines as the Electricity Supply Board. We think that that is an excellent manner in which to deal with such a great public service as transport. It is alleged that that is nationalisation of a type, but it is not. It does mean that it is the property of the State and that it is managed in the interests of the people as a whole.

It is very hard for Deputies who have no experience of the Stock Exchange to value the £16,000,000 or £20,000,000 that it is proposed to guarantee to this new company. The £16,000,000, it is argued, is not a subsidy. It is the nearest thing again to a subsidy that you can possibly have because once you give security to a person for a certain amount of money it is nearly the same thing as if you wrote him a cheque and he did not cash it until he wanted it. If the House passes this Bill—I sincerely hope it will not—it will be giving £16,000,000 to the director without saying to what purpose it is to be devoted and in that way nobody, except the Minister and that director, will have control of that money.

The Taoiseach to-day very properly gave expression to some great truths. There was one thing to which he gave expression that I do not exactly accept. He said he was not a speculator. I take it that that is correct, that he is not a speculator on the Stock Exchange. But as a political speculator there is no one in the world to equal him. He also said he did not know how people judged the rising and falling of stocks. Nobody knows better than he how his political stock went up and down. Let us hope that it is again on the descent. He knows that very well; there is no person better able than he to appreciate that.

Comment on this

If he is as good a speculator as the Deputy says, he might be right.

Comment on this

He speculated well from 1922 to 1932, but, then, the greatest speculator, the greatest operator on the exchange, can meet his Waterloo, and this Bill could just be the Waterloo for the Taoiseach. In this particular speculation he should be very careful. We are guaranteeing £16,000,000. The people who are going to benefit by that guarantee are those who have, no matter for what reason, purchased shares in the Great Southern Railways during the past 12 months or two years. While I am quite agreeable to the guarantee being given, I insist that it should be a guarantee for the valuation of the stock at a certain time. I believe that what Deputy Dillon suggested would be quite reasonable, and that is that we should select the year 1938. When you are taking over the company you should take over the shares as valued in a year such as 1938, when everything was normal. But you are taking them over now at a figure which has established itself more or less on the market and you will enrich people to whom we are under no obligation.

So far as the citizen of this State is concerned I do not begrudge him anything he gets, but what annoys me more than anything else is that we are guaranteeing the interest and capital of people who have money in the railway company, but who are living outside the State and who purchased their shares within the past 12 months. I think that is a very unfair position for a Minister to take up. He has no mandate from the people to guarantee those things. I would like to know how many persons in Stormont will have their capital and their dividends guaranteed under this Bill if it passes —people who have purchased stocks within the past two years. I suggest it is almost impossible to discuss this Bill in the manner in which it should be discussed when we have not the report of the tribunal now sitting. I suggest that because of the circumstances of the time we are tongue-tied upon very essential matters, and we are not at liberty to deal as adequately as we should, and as we could, with certain proposals.

The amalgamation of the Great Southern Railways Company and the Dublin United Transport Company may be all to the good, and may be essential for the useful employment of transport in this company. But it is a strange thing that the Transport Tribunal did not make any such recommendation. It is also strange that the Government would adopt a plan almost contrary to the recommendations of the Transport Tribunal. That tribunal recommended, as Deputy Lynch pointed out, that there would be a period of five years in which the whole transport question would be examined while being worked under fairly favourable conditions. Nothing like that has been done. The tribunal reported in 1939, but the Government did nothing since then and they do not show any anxiety to operate the proposed five years plan. They have multiplied the capital, and have asked us to guarantee £16,000,000 without giving us the information which we consider essential before we arrive at any decision.

The Government knew very well in 1939 that the Great Southern Railways had not an adequate coal supply. This bringing in of £16,000,000 to bolster up the railway company now is like locking a stable door after the horse has been stolen. If in 1939 the railway company had sufficient capital they could have left in ample coal stocks to carry them for a considerable time. The Government, for some reason or other, did not advise the railway company to lay in sufficient coal or did not express any desire to guarantee the purchase of such fuel. I submit that in that sense the Government are too late with their present proposals. Before we agree to this heavy expenditure we should have more information placed at our disposal.

I am one of those who believe that we cannot do without the railways, although in the United States and elsewhere road transport has taken away to a very great extent the activities of the railway companies. Road transport has advantages inasmuch as it can go to the producer's premises, load up the stuff and thus have only two handlings instead of four or five. In that way it is true to say that road transport has a great advantage over railway transport. But in this Bill the Minister has not given us any indication how the £16,000,000 will be utilised, whether for complete road transport, complete rail transport, or both. He tells us blandly that this is an enabling Bill to allow this board, with a dictator on top, to do what they please.

Comment on this