Committee on Finance. - Arterial Drainage Bill, 1944—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–235 of 470. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 16 of 1944 ›
The group of amendments with which we are now dealing refer to the power to take compulsorily trust funds that have been provided for the maintenance of embankments. We are opposed to that, on the grounds that those trust funds have been specially provided for maintenance purposes, and the intention behind this piece of legislation is that improvements, drainage works and embankment works generally were to be a national charge. The country got that impression and promise, and Dáil Eireann has agreed that that is the proper procedure, if we are to carry out national drainage effectively in the future. We think it is unfair to local authorities that substantial trust funds created for some counties should be swept into the Exchequer by the Minister for Finance. We are here empowering him to do that, and the maintenance charge will be thrown back on the ratepayers in that particular county, and it will be a substantial charge in some areas.
Where you have capital provision of that nature made over a period of years, and a regular yearly income accruing for maintenance purposes, it is bad financial policy, taking the long view, to destroy capital sums of that sort, and it is an injustice to the ratepayers in the counties concerned. The problem is concentrated in a few counties, where the maintenance charges are substantial. If we destroy the capital sums, we will let the Land Commission out of a very awkward situation. The Parliamentary Secretary should appreciate that it has been a problem in the Land Commission for a number of years. Not merely are we letting them out, but we are going to sweep away all the funds which were accumulating from one source or another over a period of years. When estates were acquired under the different Land Acts in the past, and where maintenance of certain works was the responsibility of the landlords in the past, that responsibility was carried on through trust funds, which were the responsibility of the Land Commission. Now, it is proposed under this Bill that the drainage authority will take over the responsibility for maintenance and pass on the financial responsibility to the local authority. That is a most unjust provision, so far as the general ratepayer in a particular county is concerned. If it were general throughout the whole country, it would be a different matter, as it may be argued that they would get substantial benefit.
It is true that certain counties will benefit substantially, but certain other counties — Waterford, Limerick, and Wexford, counties on the seaboard, where water from inland counties is being discharged, are really corridors from counties situated further inland, which get rid of surplus water by discharging it through those counties near the sea, where the problem arises. I represent some inland counties and it is not my problem at all, but I would point out to the Parliamentary Secretary, firstly, that it is going to put a substantial charge on the few particular counties concerned. If the present maintenance capital sums were preserved for maintenance purposes, it would be fairer to the ratepayers situated in those counties. Secondly, it is bad financial policy to rake in substantial capital sums that are very useful and which have been provided very conveniently, by the vision and foresight of people who went before us, to ensure that an annual income would accrue for work of this sort. I would like also that the Parliamentary Secretary should inform the House as to the aggregate capital sum that is involved, so far as the Land Commission is concerned, and the yearly income that accrues from the capital sums.
Comment on this
In very many cases, the money in these trust funds has been retained out of the purchase price of estates, so it could be argued that it really belongs to the original owners of those estates. In any event, this money was set aside for the maintenance of these embankments. If my recollection serves me aright, the income from those funds was not nearly adequate to maintain the majority of those embankments in any reasonable state of efficiency. It is now proposed to hand that money over to the Treasury and deflect it from the purpose for which it was originally intended.
I cannot understand this discrimination in respect of embankments. In the preceding sections of this Bill, it is provided that the funds belonging to trustees and drainage boards are to be handed over to the county councils, to enable them to carry on the maintenance work; but, in this case of embankments, a different procedure altogether is to be followed. It is proposed that the money that was set aside specifically for the maintenance of these embankments is to be handed over to the Treasury. The Parliamentary Secretary is to collect whatever the expenses of carrying out the maintenance work will be from the county councils. Why has the Parliamentary Secretary chosen to adopt this procedure in regard to embankments and quite a different procedure in regard to drainage boards and drainage trustees? Morally, in my opinion at all events, this money should be handed over to the county councils, and should not be diverted from the purpose for which it was originally intended. The money, as I have said, is really the property of the original owners of the estates. I hold that the Parliamentary Secretary is acting wrongly and setting a bad precedent by making provision for the handing over of this trust money to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
This is one of the most extraordinary provisions that we find in this Bill. Deputy Roddy has referred to the moral property in this money. He could have gone further and said that it is the legal property of the owners of the estates. This House will be committing a breach of trust by diverting this money from the purpose for which it was intended. It was specifically vested in trust for maintenance work. If this section is passed in its present form will not this House be acting ultra vires? I hope that some county council will have the courage to test the matter, assuming that the Bill goes through in its present form. Undoubtedly, this money belongs to the original owner. It was his property. He left it in trust for the specific purpose of maintaining the embankments that were erected to drain the estate of which he was the owner. Neither this House nor anybody else has the right to interfere with that trust. This money was deducted from the purchase money at the time of the sale of the estate for the maintenance of these works in order to relieve local ratepayers of the burden which that maintenance work would put on them.
Last night the Parliamentary Secretary told us that the Government were taking all responsibility for the construction of these works. Of course a Government can do whatever it likes. It can take over whatever responsibility it likes, but there is one thing it cannot do, and that is interfere with trusts. That is wrong in law. The Government has neither a legal nor a moral right to this money. It belonged to the original owners, and was set aside for the purpose of maintenance. The creation of these trusts was a just and natural one. The Land Commission have retained huge sums of money from landlords when buying out their estates. Is that money going to be paid back to the landlords? During the time of the land agitation it used to be said that to shoot a landlord was a popular thing, but, of course, murder is always murder. We are putting up £7,000,000 in connection with this Bill, but while we are doing that we should not rob anybody. The amount of money held by the Land Commission for the purpose of maintaining these embankments was deducted from the price paid to the landlords for their land. I must say that the proposal in the Bill is a startling one. My opinion is that to enact anything of this kind would be ultra vires, and a breach of trust even though done by this House. This House has no prerogative to do wrong any more than a private individual has. I know that in recent years it has been quite a development to do these things. I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to reconsider the matter. If this House has the right to commit a breach of trust it certainly has not the right to confiscate money that belongs to other people — money which was specifically set aside for the maintenance of these embankments, and in order to relieve the local ratepayers.
Comment on this
I also hold in connection with the money held by these trustee bodies that at the time of the passing of the Land Acts the money was set aside by the landlord for the maintenance of embankments. Deputy McMenamin says it should be handed back to the landlord. I hold that if anybody should get the money held by these trustee bodies it is the county councils since they will have the responsibility for this maintenance work. The money should be transferred to their credit. Recently, I raised a question about a sum of £1,700 or £1,800 which was held by a trustee body on the estate of the Duke of Devonshire. I have not yet been told by the Parliamentary Secretary whether the local county council will be responsible for the maintenance of embankments hitherto maintained by the Land Commission. Will they come automatically within the scope of this Bill?
Comment on this
In my opinion the money held by these trustee bodies should be handed over to the county councils who will have to bear the cost of maintenance.
Comment on this
I desire to support the series of amendments dealing with these funds which were set aside for a specific purpose. The Government did not originally provide them. Therefore, I hold that they should not be diverted from the purpose for which they were originally created, namely, the maintenance of embankments. I think eventually it ought to be used for that purpose. The Parliamentary Secretary argued yesterday that the State will take over the function of maintaining particular embankments in future, at a large cost, but as far as I can see in the Bill the county councils will eventually have to provide for the maintenance of the rivers and the embankments as well. It will eventually fall on the local rates, and any provision that was made for the maintenance of these embankments should go to the bodies that will be responsible for them. I am not a lawyer and I do not know what the legal right would be, but I think that is the moral right.
It may be that in some cases where trust funds had been provided for embankments, as a result of the operation of this Bill expenditure of such funds will no longer be required for the particular embankments. Take, for instance, a tidal river where it has been very essential that embankments should be maintained and where, in years to come, as a result of the drainage of a particular river, maintenance of the embankments is no longer essential. I can envisage certain rivers where that would happen as a result of a big drainage scheme. It might happen, however, that as a result of the drainage of that particular river, an increased burden of maintenance would be incurred in connection with a lower river. That would happen in particular areas, such as Wexford, as a result of the drainage of the Upper Barrow. It might happen in the Lee area or as a result of the drainage of the Shannon or the Blackwater. A tremendous flow of water might be let down on to the lower reaches as a result of the drainage of certain levels. The cost of maintaining embankments on the lower reaches would be increased.
I see no reason why the amendments should not be accepted by the Parliamentary Secretary or why there should be this mean attitude of encroaching on these small sums. I do not know how much they amount to, but the smaller they are, the less reason there is to encroach on them. The Parliamentary Secretary suggested that we made a fuss about very small sums. The smaller they are the less reason there is for encroaching on them. The smaller they are the less use they would be to the Exchequer. The Parliamentary Secretary also referred yesterday to the fact that the State was providing drainage for the country. We are all grateful for it. Every Deputy appreciates the attempt that is being made to drain the country properly, once and for all, and everybody here is desirous of helping the Parliamentary Secretary in that laudable work. The Government are providing these millions of money and probably, eventually, will have to provide more millions. It will be money well spent. It will be expenditure that will redound to the credit of the country and pay one hundred fold in improving the country generally. It will be money that probably will save the State in respect of certain relief schemes because no work will provide more work per unit of money spent than drainage. It is idle to cavil about such small sums as are referred to in the amendments.
Amendment No. 100 deals with the setting up of an embankments maintenance fund. There is no reason why such a fund should not be set up so that it would help in extraordinary cases to meet difficulty. Deputy Broderick referred yesterday to the possibility of serious happenings in Youghal owing to the condition of embankments there, and he could see no way, and the Parliamentary Secretary did not see any way, of providing for these contingencies. Deputy Allen referred to the case of New Ross where the drainage of the upper reaches of the Barrow had created such a situation that the local bodies could not see their way to cope with it. The amendments suggest a way — the setting up of a fund that might be used to meet cases like this. I do not think that it needs further elaboration. I think the amendments are reasonable. I think it is a very mean action on the part of the Government to encroach on these small funds. They will not count in meeting the huge cost of this drainage scheme but they would make a great difference in providing for contingencies that none of us can foresee.
Comment on this
With the main principle of the Bill everybody agrees. The Parliamentary Secretary appears to be forgetting what he said last night, namely, that his desire was to safeguard the ratepayers as far as possible. As far as I can see, the confiscation of the trustee funds is not a matter of importance but it is the principle underlying the thing that matters — the principle that all the liabilities are to be transferred to the ratepayers. I prefer to leave the phrase "local authority" out of it altogether. I think the words "taxpayer" and "ratepayer" convey more to the public. The Treasury means the taxpayer. The local authority means the ratepayer. In this case the liabilities are to be transferred to the ratepayer and the assets are going to the assistance of the taxpayer. These sums are of little account when one considers the huge sum of £7,000,000. These moneys were provided for a certain definite course, namely, to keep embankments in repair. That liability is being transferred to the ratepayer. Are not they the natural inheritors of any trust funds that exist? They are now by law being made responsible for the work that the trustee funds were created for. Surely the trustee funds should go to the relief of the ratepayers.
As I pointed out yesterday, the County Council of Cork advanced a sum to the Awbeg drainage scheme, which is repayable in 35 years. Now the occupiers are being relieved of that at the expense of the County Cork ratepayers. Under this Act of Parliament, they are completely relieved of that liability but any trust funds that are there for the purpose of maintaining other embankments are being taken over by the State. I do not think that is fair. I think the principle is so wrong, the concession so small, that the Parliamentary Secretary might very easily give way on this particular point.
Comment on this
I was hoping that, as a result of what I said last night, we would have a clearer understanding of what is involved here, but I find now that either I failed to explain the position or Deputies failed to grasp the explanation. We are not automatically interfering with these trust funds about which all this fuss is being created. I want Deputies to ask themselves the number of these embankments which are in existence. They will find them in the report of the Drainage Commission, and, according to that document, the number is 381. There are trust funds in respect of some of these; there are some in respect of which there are no funds whatever; and there are others that for maintenance purposes are the responsibility of the people whose land they protect. We do not propose to confiscate these trust funds on the passage of this Bill into law or on the fixation of the appointed day.
Comment on this
What we propose to do is, if and when we come to a particular embankment which we propose to take over and reconstruct, only then do we propose to take into the Exchequer whatever funds are in existence. Surely if those funds were adequate, we would not have to reconstruct them at the State expense. Deputies speak of the taxpayer's expense, and I am not trying to deny that. I want to give the taxpayer all the credit due to him and I want to make him fully conscious at all times of the fact that it is he, and nobody such as the Treasury or the Ministry of Finance, who has to meet it. We are merely providing ourselves here with power, when we reach a point at which we are ready to take over a particular embankment, to take it over, because we feel that, whether there is a trust fund in respect of it or not, it has been neglected, that it is in a bad condition and that it requires repair and is capable of being repaired and put into a proper condition.
Comment on this
That is my point. Section 4 empowers the commissioners, when they are of opinion that the execution of arterial drainage works is expedient in any catchment area for preventing or substantially reducing the periodical flooding of lands in that area, to prepare a scheme. I am speaking in relation to an area where the responsibility rests on somebody— whether the land owner, the Land Commission, a trustee body or somebody else. In that area, where there are up to 60 miles of embankments, flooding occurs, and if the commissioners are satisfied that there is flooding, even though the responsibility rests with the Land Commission or with a trustee body, they are empowered to go into that area, whether the county council likes it or not, and carry out a scheme. That is what the section says.
Comment on this
And what about the Land Commission, where it is their responsibility and where they have neglected their duty and allowed embankments to fall into a state of disrepair? Why should the county council be asked to shoulder such a responsibility, particularly in County Waterford, where we have up to 60 miles of embankments?
Comment on this
I do not mind Deputies having a shot at me. I want to give them every chance of asking questions and of understanding this matter. If I thought the opposition were reasonable, I would try to be sympathetic. When we reach an embankment in respect of which there are trust funds in existence and decide to reconstruct it, is the fact that we have to undertake that reconstruction not proof that the trust fund was not sufficient to keep that embankment in a condition in which, from the national point of view and in the interests of the landholders concerned, it should have been kept?
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary must remember that it has to be maintained after the reconstruction.
Comment on this
I refer the Deputy to Deputy Broderick who wants us to emphasise the part being played by the taxpayer.
Comment on this
And the ratepayer. What Deputies are arguing now, however, is that not only should this taxpayer who must on all occasions be named, according to Deputy Broderick, take on himself responsibility for the constructional charge but he must, according to Deputy Hughes, shoulder also the burden of maintenance.
Comment on this
I do not think a Committee Stage should be carried on on the basis of all Deputies speaking together.
Comment on this
When the time comes for reconstruction, my point is that while the council is held responsible for maintenance, it inherits the liability of the trustee.
Comment on this
The Deputy has a different problem altogether. The problem about which he has been pressing us both here and outside the House is an entirely different problem. So far as I can see, it is the only one in which a local authority has some justifiable grounds for fear, but so far as the 381 embankments are concerned——
Comment on this
Is it not true to say that Deputy Broderick's problem will be subject to this legislation?
Comment on this
It is not the problem about which the Deputy is talking at all, or the problem which any of the Deputies have put forward.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary says that it is in the public interest that embankments should be repaired in a satisfactory manner. The provision is that the commissioners shall maintain such drainage works or existing drainage works, as the case may be, in proper repair and effective condition, but in the case of any such existing drainage works it shall not be obligatory on them to maintain such works in better condition or state of repair than they were in on the date of the maintenance transfer order. I hold that if you take over the embankments in the condition they are in, the county council is still shouldering the responsibility.
Comment on this
I have no objection, as I have said, to these interruptions, but they have the effect of breaking my line of thought, and they are not fair to me, in the sense that when I get up to speak I have a certain line of thought to follow and these interruptions break it. I do not want to deprive Deputies of the right to interrogate me, but their interruptions do knock me about a little. I only want to make clear what I thought was in doubt and what I thought should not be in doubt; that is, that we are not, on the passage of this Bill, proposing to interfere with these funds. We do not propose to interfere with the funds, to the extent that there were funds in existence for the maintenance of these embankments; nor do we propose to interfere with the embankments in respect of which there are no funds at all. We are merely providing here, that, as we reach an embankment and decide that it is one that can be reconstructed and afterwards be maintained, we will proceed to take over that embankment and reconstruct it at State expense and that whatever sum of money is there in the shape of trust funds will go to the Exchequer. As I say, I can see no injustice in that, inasmuch as the reconstruction cost of the embankment will in all cases be greater than the amount of the trust funds; because, if that was not the case, then the embankment would not need any reconstruction. I think there can hardly be any doubt as to whether the State is trying to commit some mean, unpardonable sort of act in so far as this is concerned.
Comment on this
I am only talking about what is fair between the important individual, the taxpayer, and the important individual whose lands are to be protected at the taxpayer's expense. I am only an ordinary man and I do not know anything about legal matters, but I have as good a conception as most people as to what is fair as between man and man and class and class——
Comment on this
The ex-Leas Cheann Comhairle should understand that when a Deputy is speaking he is entitled to speak without interruption. I am only making it clear that what we are doing here is entirely defensible and fair, and that whatever trust funds are in existence are only a very small matter in relation to the total cost of the reconstruction of these works, when we come to the point that we will be able to undertake that work. I think that if there was a clearer understanding of what is aimed at there would not be this opposition to the course we are pursuing which has been displayed in the course of the discussion.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary this question. Where there are no trust funds in existence and where an embankment is not the responsibility of any local authority, at some stage or other it is the intention of the commissioners to take over control of the embankment and reconstruct it and maintain it. You eventually mean to deal with all the embankments.
Comment on this
We agree with that. In the case where there are no trust funds for maintenance, the State is prepared to take over and reconstruct the embankment, maintain it afterwards, and present their bill to the local authority for maintenance. Where there are no trust funds in existence, we are quite prepared, under the proposals here, to reconstruct at State expense. But, where trust funds are available, we are going to confiscate them. That is where the injustice lies. To my mind, you are applying one measure of justice in one case and another in another.
Comment on this
It is similar to the point you raised here with regard to county councils who undertook schemes under the 1925 Act and entered into a financial obligation in relation to these works, that they will have to continue to pay, while counties that refused to take advantage of the 1925 Act will get off. The cases are similar. As I say, we must approach this with an eye to the taxpayers' rights and interests. If you ask me to undertake a job for you that would cost £20 and there is only a sum of £5 to meet it, I do not think it is reasonable that you should ask me to do the job without at least having the assistance of whatever fund is there, however small it may be.
Comment on this
The point is that the fund there is in perpetuity for maintenance, and you are taking it for reconstruction.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary argued in reply to what we said that the State will proceed to reconstruct the embankments. None of us mentioned a word about reconstruction — I did not anyhow. I did not even refer to the legal aspect, because, like the Parliamentary Secretary, I have not a legal mind. What I am trying to discuss as clearly as I can is the question of maintenance. I never mentioned reconstruction. The Parliamentary Secretary jumped on me and others because he said we did not understand what reconstruction meant. We know perfectly well what it means. In fact, I made reference to the efficiency of the present embankments when I spoke before. I said that, in the event of these rivers being taken over and drained and cleaned, some of the existing embankments need not be even as strong as they are. I can take the Minister to a river that has perfect embankments at present which do not want any reconstruction. They will not want to be maintained even at the present cost. Everybody knows that when a sluggish river flows into a tidal river it needs very strong embankments to hold the strength of water if the river is not properly cleaned and drained. When the tidal river and the river flowing into it are attended to, the embankments do not require the same attention, if they are in good repair at present. The cost of maintenance in future will not be as great as if the river were never attended to. In some cases, landlords built very good embankments, and a sum is provided for their maintenance. I know some that will last for a very long time. The purpose of Deputy Hughes's amendment is to save this money for the purpose for which it was originally intended. There may be a legal way of getting out of it. It may be possible, by a quibble of the law, to evade the original intention in the setting up of these funds. The Parliamentary Secretary may know nothing about the law, but some of those concerned with the drafting of this Bill know something about it, because they took a way of changing the ultimate destination of the funds. I know nothing about law, but I know that, if things are left as they are and this money is devoted to the purpose for which it was originally provided, everybody will be better served.
Comment on this
The point that Deputy Bennett raised has given me a new idea. Suppose you have a situation where you were taking over at some date an embankment in a good state of repair. This legislation envisages a situation in which the commissioners will take over all embankments. Suppose that at a future date they take over the embankments that the Deputy described, which were built by landlords, which are in a perfect state of repair, and merely require a certain amount of maintenance, and there is a fund provided for that maintenance. The commissioners in that case take over that bank, confiscate the funds and do the maintenance work. There is no reconstruction now. They take over responsibility for maintenance and do it and present the bill to the local authority. Is that justice?
Comment on this
In a national scheme you cannot pick out a few hundred perches of a sound embankment; you have to look at 381 embankments and ask yourselves what condition are they in, and what fund is there to maintain them. You ask yourselves has the fund been adequate to do the job. It may be that a couple of hundred perches of a bank are perfectly sound and the fund provided may have been intended only to be spent on them. But this is not a small matter; this is a bigger matter. You have this number of embankments in the whole country, and a certain number of them, as we come to them, will be included in the comprehensive drainage district. A certain number of them will have to be approached as a separate matter, as embankments pure and simple.
What I want the House to realise is that, to the extent that there are funds there, we are not confiscating them until we proceed to reconstruct and recondition, and in undertaking that work I can assure the House the taxpayer is entering into a very substantial liability indeed as compared with the trivial amount available in the way of a trust fund.
Deputy McMenamin talked about these funds in perpetuity. There is no such thing. In many cases where these trust funds are in existence, the capital has been spent in an effort to keep the works in proper condition, and he who professes to give the House the benefit of his legal mind apparently does not seem to understand that what he is saying is entirely inaccurate.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary ought to remember that it may look a very small matter to him, looking down from the office that is going to spend £7,000,000; but from the point of view of people in a small way down the country it might appear to be a very big matter.
Comment on this
The people in the country are getting the best of the transaction. They are going to benefit.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 98:—
To add at the end of sub-section (4) the words "and conclusive".
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I am inclined to oppose sub-section (5). If a man loses portion of his lands on account of flooding or through some other cause, his income is reduced because of the loss incurred. Is it not a bit of hardship to apportion it and make him redeem the annuity?
Comment on this
That is no reason why we should do it now. Why should we slavishly follow what was done in the past, when injustice was done?
Comment on this
I am not concerned with what was done in the past. I want a reason why we should do it now.
Comment on this
I will give the reason. The man has contracted to pay this money, this advance, by way of annuity. He is getting compensation for a portion of his land and is it not only right that he would recoup to those who advanced the money the portion advanced, in the ordinary way?
Comment on this
He has to redeem the portion of the advance on the land in respect of which he is getting compensation. Surely, he should not be allowed to pocket that, where he would not be allowed to pocket it in any other case where land was being taken from him?
Comment on this
Sub-section (5) provides:
"Compensation payable under this section in respect of the flooding of land (in this sub-section referred to as flooded land) which is subject, either alone or in conjunction with other land, to a land purchase annuity or other annual payment (not being merely rent under a contract of tenancy) payable to the Irish Land Commission or to the commissioners shall be applied by the commissioners in or towards the redemption of so much (whether the whole or a part) of such annuity or annual payment as is charged on or apportioned to the flooded land exclusively, and only the surplus (if any) of such compensation remaining after such redemption shall be paid to the owner or occupier of the flooded land."
Does that mean that he has to redeem the whole amount?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 101:—
At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—
"All trustees affected by the preceding sub-section shall be entitled to give evidence relating to such trust fund before the Judicial Commissioner."
The object of the amendment is to ensure that when the fund is being apportioned the trustees, whoever they may be, will be entitled to give evidence before the judicial commissioner.
Comment on this
That would follow. There is no objection to the amendment, but we think that it is already covered. If it is not clear we will make it clear.
Comment on this
On this section, I would like the Parliamentary Secretary to clear úp a few points. It is not clear whether every type of trust fund is to be acquired regardless of whether there is any responsibility on trustees to maintain work or not. There are funds in respect of which there is no responsibility, but the interest on the funds can be applied. There is no legal obligation on the trustees to carry out any work. Is it the intention to confiscate all funds regardless of whether there is any obligation on the trustees or not?
Comment on this
As I understand it, we are taking power to take over any embankment if and when we decide to do so. It does not matter whether there is any trust fund at all or not.
Comment on this
My point is, are you going to clear all trust funds regardless of whether they are bound to maintain or not?
Comment on this
I have a particular trust fund in mind under which there is no obligation to maintain, but the interest can be applied for maintenance.
Comment on this
I cannot see a case in which we will take over an embankment and reconstruct it and leave a fund there of whatever kind or nature it may be.
Comment on this
I do not see that any useful purpose would be served by moving amendment No. 102. We have discussed the question already.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary does not say that the benefit to the Exchequer is emphasised in every paragraph of the Bill.
Comment on this
If I had heard Deputy Broderick earlier I would have asked the draftsman to say for the benefit of the taxpayer rather than the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 105:—
In sub-section (1), before paragraph (b), to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
"The Irish Land Commission shall be responsible for the cost of maintaining all embankments which may be under its control at the date of the passing of this Act."
I would like to know from the Parliamentary Secretary if, in a case where responsibility rests with the Land Commission, they are being relieved of that responsibility?
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy's conception of the responsibility of the Land Commission is.
Comment on this
Where the Land Commission have responsibility for maintaining embankments, are you taking over that responsibility under this Bill?
Comment on this
There are some people who would hold, even though there were no trust funds in existence, that the Land Commission were responsible for the maintenance of embankments. Is that the kind of case that you are trying to make? I will put this kind of case to you, although the Ceann Comhairle may remind me——
Comment on this
The Chair is anxious to secure compliance with the Standing Order which says that Deputies — and Parliamentary Secretaries are Deputies — must address the Chair. Were Deputies to develop the habit of addressing each other in the second person discussion could more easily become acrimonious.
Comment on this
I ask the Deputy to take the case of 20 farmers in a district whose lands are vested in them and portion of which are protected by an embankment.
Comment on this
What Deputy Heskin has in mind is this: when a transfer order operates, is the Parliamentary Secretary going to relieve completely the Land Commission of any obligations under a trust?
Comment on this
I was in doubt about it. In County Waterford there is a number of embankments in connection with which the Land Commission have failed to carry out their obligation to keep them in repair. I do not understand the position very clearly and I am merely trying to protect the interests of the ratepayers. I want to see that the embankments are in a proper state of repair when they are handed over to the county council. That is the point I want to make clear. I mentioned, yesterday, a case occurring in the Nier Valley, where, in 1933, the Land Commission built a sod embankment. The following is an extract from a letter I have received in connection with it:—
"In 1933 the Land Commission built a sod embankment on my side of the river and a good limestone embankment on the other side. In 1937/1938 my side began to go and I informed the Land Commission. They took no notice, and at that time very little would do. So, in 1940, the whole thing was swept away, which has rendered about 10 acres useless. I am continually writing to the Land Commission. I may get a reply that they are looking into the matter, but, so far, nothing has been done."
In cases like that, where the Land Commission have refused to carry out their obligations——
Comment on this
They could do that without having obligations. They might do it under a minor employment scheme. It would not follow that they had obligations. They might spend money without having any obligation to do so.
Comment on this
Even if it was not their responsibility in that case, there are other cases, in the Tar area and the Lismore area, where the Land Commission is responsible. The point is that in connection with the section in the Bill under which compensation would arise, if the embankments were in a bad state of repair and, as in the case I have mentioned, ten acres of land were rendered useless, that particular individual could look for compensation from the responsible authority, namely, the county council. All I ask in the amendment is that where the responsibility rested with the Land Commission, the Parliamentary Secretary, when he takes over under this Drainage Bill, will place the embankments in a solid state of repair before the county council will be asked to accept the responsibility.
Comment on this
This is what the Drainage Commission had to say on this matter of embankments:
"In all these cases, however, the tenant purchasers continue to look to the Land Commission for assistance. They persist in regarding the Land Commission as the legal successor of the former landlords, with all the obligations of the latter. They fail to realise that a tenant purchaser whose holding is vested in him has become an owner in feesimple and has acquired the interest of the former landlord with all its obligations as well as its rights."
The tenant, although his lands are now vested in him and although, with that vesting, has gone the responsibility to him that was formerly discharged by the Land Commission, still regards the Land Commission as the legal successor of the landlord and he will look to the Land Commission as an institution that should carry out this work for him, while, in fact, the Land Commission has no legal responsibility whatever. That is why I put the question to the Deputy. I was not trying, as Deputy Hughes suggested, to evade a straight question. I was trying merely to get the trend of thought of the Deputy. There can be nothing more clear than this. It is quite simple and quite easy to follow. I told the Deputy the number of embankments that were in existence. I told him that there were funds in existence in respect of some of them. There are some embankments in respect of which there is no fund and I told him that these embankments would remain as they are until such time as we decide to take them over as we reach them. Whether they are embankments in connection with which funds exist or not, if the drainage authority felt that it was in the public interest to take over any portion of these embankments, then we would take them over, reconstruct them and maintain them afterwards — of course, at the expense of the local authority. That is simple, I think, and easily followed.
Comment on this
Provided, of course, that they would be well constructed before the maintenance charge would fall on the county council.
Comment on this
I do not suppose you can get any assurance other than this, that our obligation will be to reconstruct them to the best of our knowledge and ability, and, without regard to expense, to ensure that they will be in a proper condition.
Comment on this
If you reconstruct the banks and put them in a proper state of repair before the local council would be charged with their maintenance, I am satisfied.
Comment on this
It is about the abandonment order. Why should it have been necessary to abandon an embankment or even to make provision for the event of any damage arising out of the abandonment of an embankment? There is no liability.
Comment on this
I see, and you are going to allow the shocking condition that might exist to continue.
Comment on this
We might have to. If it should transpire that we could not maintain it, we would have no alternative. It would not arise, perhaps, in one case in a million.
Comment on this
This is only a necessary safeguard. It is not anticipated that you would operate it?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 106:—
In sub-section (1), before paragraph (b), to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
The owners of lands benefited by a drainage scheme shall pay an apportioned amount of the cost of the maintenance of such scheme.
I understood that the increase in the valuations would place a further liability upon the owners but I understand now that the valuation will not be increased on the individual but on the county generally. Is that so?
Comment on this
We will estimate, of course, the improvement that will be effected on the lands that will be situated in the particular county.
Comment on this
Anyway, it is very evident that there will be no such thing as an increase in the individual's valuation?
Comment on this
I hold that where land will benefit by a drainage scheme some charge should be put on the land so benefited. This is a very big scheme and if land is going to benefit by the scheme it should bear a part of the cost and the ordinary county ratepayer should not be asked to bear part of the burden. In a particular area where lands are drained, provided they are brought up to a good state for cultivation, or even for grazing, surely they are worth more money to the owner than before they were drained. If not, why drain them at all? I have in mind areas in which this scheme might be operated. It is good land, and I see no reason why the man on the mountainside should be asked to pay a penny, twopence, threepence or sixpence in the pound for the drainage of that land. I hold that land which will benefit should bear a share of the cost of maintenance, apart from the county-at-large rate.
Comment on this
The old principle was that a man should pay portion of the improvement value—not the full value, because if he were charged the full value, it would be no benefit to him at all — and it is on that basis that Deputy Heskin is arguing. There is something to be said for it. Nevertheless, we think that, taking the broad view, the principle of making it a county-at-large charge is sound. It so happens that some people are in the rather unfortunate geographical position of living in wet, low-lying districts while others live along a trunk road. The latter gets all the advantages of a trunk road service and the man on the hillside has to pay for those services, although he gets very little advantage from them. We do not attempt to strike a special charge for the man with the advantages of trunk road service, and, in respect of all these social services, I think there is a lot to be said for spreading the charge generally. However, if we agree here that some portion of the charge should be paid and that the charge should be apportioned as between the riparian owners and the county-at-large — I do not know if this aspect has been examined, but it struck me as being rather useful —we might decide that where you increase a man's valuation because of the improved value resulting from drainage, he is indirectly contributing to the local authority because his rates will be slightly increased. What I mean is not to have a separate charge for drainage works, but to permit the increase in the valuation to operate which would help the local authority, to a small extent at any rate.
Comment on this
I must say that I agree with Deputy Heskin. I think the owners of benefited lands should be asked to shoulder some additional charge. I am not quite clear as to how this will operate. The final award will show the increased value of the benefited land. It may be confined to a townland or a number of townlands, but I take it that subsequently it will be a matter for the Valuation Office to step in and increase the valuation in proportion to the increased value of the land.
Comment on this
If the valuation is to be increased, the general valuation of the whole county is increased.
Comment on this
In that case, the bulk improvement will be made known in the final award to the county concerned, but it will have no importance, except as a record of information showing the improvement effected in the lands drained. But where there is more than one county concerned, an apportionment as between counties will be made for the purpose of enabling an apportionment of the drainage maintenance charges afterwards, but it will have no further significance. It cannot be added on in the manner suggested by Deputy Heskin, or divided amongst the valuations, because that could not be done without new legislation. That being so, it has no purpose except the purpose I have described.
I can only say that I agree with the argument that there is nothing unsound in asking a man to pay for benefits which he receives, and the Drainage Commission held that he should be made responsible for the payment of 70 per cent. of the estimated improvement to his land. We departed from that, not because we disagreed with the principle or with the recommendation, and not because we felt there was anything wrong or unjust about it, but because we found from our experience that it was a source of delay and a source of trouble not only in the preparation of a scheme and the segregation of the estimated improvements amongst the different holdings affected, but of continued trouble in respect of these holdings afterwards. Taking it all in all, while we agree with the principle of asking a man to pay, we thought that, because of the smallness of the amount involved in many cases, and the delay which would be occasioned by the process, it was better to ask the State to bear the whole initial cost, and to ask the local ratepayer, who is the nearest approach to the individual, to meet the cost of maintenance. That is the line of reasoning which was applied to our deciding on this proposal.
Comment on this
I asked the Parliamentary Secretary whether a particular aspect had been examined, that is, of permitting the increased valuation to operate so that it would yield a higher income to the local authority. It may not be possible in the case of legislation like this.
Comment on this
Not in legislation like this, but was it considered at all — the increasing of a man's valuation pro rata to the improved value of his holding which would yield a higher local income?
Comment on this
I move amendment No.109:—
In sub-section (1) (b) to delete all words after the words "drainage works" in line 22 to the end of the paragraph and substitute the following:—
"the judge before whom such proceedings are being heard may, after hearing the evidence of the plaintiff and defendants appoint a member of the panel of arbitrators who is a qualified engineer to make an inspection of the said existing drainage works and to furnish a report of his inspection to the court."
I think this a shocking paragraph. There was a similar paragraph in an earlier part of the Bill where it stated that the commissioner's certificate was final and binding so far as the maintenance by a local authority was concerned. That was not so bad. This paragraph states:
"(b) in any proceedings against the commissioners for damages or for relief in the nature of mandamus on account of the alleged inadequate maintenance by the commissioners of any such existing drainage works, a certificate sealed with the seal of the commissioners and stating that the commissioners have caused the said existing drainage works to be inspected and are satisfied that the said existing drainage works are, at the date of such certificate, in a condition and state of repair at least as good as on the date of the relevant maintenance transfer order shall be conclusive and irrebuttable evidence that the said existing drainage works are in a condition and state of repair at the date of such certificate at least as good as on the date of the said order."
Surely that is an extraordinary principle, that if there is litigation, one party to the legal proceedings can certify that their own work has been properly and efficiently carried out, and that cannot be questioned. A fundamental principle of justice in this country, so far as protecting the liberty and the freedom of the individual is concerned, is that, if the individual feels he has a grievance against a fellow-citizen or against the State, he can bring his case into court and get a strictly impartial decision. How can justice be administered if we legislate in this manner to protect an authority that, I hope, will be very active? It may be that the drainage authority requires exceptional powers to carry out national drainage work. I agree that it wants exceptional powers. But the moment you give an authority like this exceptional power in dealing with any individual, I suggest that you should ensure, if you are to legislate properly, that you give that individual all the essential safeguards so that the authority will not abuse the extraordinary powers you are giving to them. We are providing the essential powers which I admit are necessary to carry out drainage work. They can go in on land and take sods and everything necessary to build embankments. They can compulsorily acquire land for the purpose of carrying out a drainage scheme. All these powers are being conceded. Nobody has questioned the wisdom of doing that. But, once we provide these exceptional powers, surely it is only reasonable that we should provide the necessary safeguards on the other side, and see that the liberty and freedom of the individual are not infringed in any way, and that if he has a grievance he has the right to take that into court and get an independent decision.
The proposals put up to this House in that respect are shocking, if you approach them in a strictly impartial way. I think the Parliamentary Secretary should reconsider the whole matter. I do not think that we should leave ourselves open to being charged with contempt of court. We are very nearly doing it in more than one instance. If we expect that citizens will have respect for the law, surely we should set a good example ourselves by having respect for the law. You are accepting the fact that a matter can be made the subject of legal proceedings, but you throw in a provision of this sort, that there is to be a certificate from the people involved in the legal proceedings, that they are to be the judges of their own conduct, and that no one dare question their work. That is a preposterous suggestion to which we could not possibly agree. I think the Parliamentary Secretary should reconsider the matter, and at all events have respect for the individual's rights, the right to question a decision even of the State, take it into court and get an impartial decision on it within the laws made by this Parliament. You are infringing his rights and liberties if you do anything else.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy was amongst those who admitted our right to protect county councils to whom we are transferring districts on the appointed day. Most of the Deputies, I think, recognised the necessity for inserting a provision, as we did, in Section 23 for the protection of these bodies. If the House recognises the importance of the insertion of that protection for local authorities, I do not think that they can reasonably deny to the drainage authority a similar protection. I must confess that, when you look at this at first, it seems a bit high-handed that when you have a drainage authority charged with the maintenance of a district and somebody decides to take an action against that authority, it is the certificate of that authority which will be called upon to determine whether or not there is anything in the complaint. But what other way can you have it? I cannot see our having very many of these districts on our hands. The only occasion on which we are likely to have a district of this type on our hands for maintenance purposes will be when we take over an old district for reconstruction, and will not be ready to start on it for some time, and will have to maintain it in the interval; or where we will construct a drainage district, and because of our having to set up one maintenance organisation, we might take in some districts lying close by for maintenance purposes. But I cannot see the drainage authority handling very many of these, because we will naturally wait until they are being taken over for the purpose of reconstruction, and after reconstruction they will pass into our maintenance organisation for maintenance purposes. After that, the individual will have all the freedom that Deputy Hughes wants him to have in the way of taking whatever proceedings he may think fit.
This only refers to the old existing districts. It does not cover any wider ground than that. It only refers to those if and when we take over any of them for the purpose of reconstruction and may not be able to proceed with the reconstruction right off; or because we have in a catchment area carried out some new works in respect of which we would be responsible for maintenance, and, because of being responsible for maintenance, we would take in a number of those other old districts and say that we would maintain them as a unit with this organisation we have set up. It is scarcely likely that any difficulty of the kind that Deputy Hughes anticipates will arise; but, anyhow, if there is anything in the argument that he has advanced, we are the people who now are charged with the inspection of these districts for the purpose of putting on record their condition prior to the fixation of the appointed day. Who, then, will be in a position to give a certificate except ourselves? There will be no other authority that will have any record of the condition of the district.
Comment on this
The only thing I am worried about is that they will not be mixed up in some other minds than mine.
Comment on this
We will have to put on record the condition which exists in every one of these districts. They will automatically be transferred to the county council on the appointed day. If, in a year or two years, we decide to take one of them over for any of the reasons I have given, and if the situation visualised by Deputy Hughes were to arise, my point is that if even a private person wanted to get into court, and if the court wanted to get a certificate, as it would, with reference to the condition of the district on the appointed day, there would be no authority in a position to give that information to the court unless ourselves, and, that being so, and while it may seem to the Deputy somewhat extravagant, I do not think there is any reason for anxiety about it, because we will have committed ourselves to recording the condition in which it was, and that is the important thing. We are the only people having that record, the only people who will be able to say what the condition was then and is now.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary is trying to draw an analogy between what occurs after the transfer order and what occurs on the appointed day. To get the whole thing properly focussed and clear in the Parliamentary Secretary's mind, let us follow the trend of events. I agree that you want to protect the local authority, because it is not envisaged in this legislation that the local authority should reconstruct; they merely should do the necessary maintenance until our people would finally step in and do any reconstruction necessary. It is only envisaged that the local authority should maintain at a standard not greater than the standard on the appointed day. For that reason it is necessary to have people like the commissioners stepping in and examining the degree of maintenance that is there, so that they will be able to certify that the local authority is doing its duty and is maintaining it at a standard equal to the standard prior to the transfer order.
The people who certify are certifying the work of another body. At a later stage the transfer order operates and it comes to the commissioners. In the event of litigation, not merely by an individual, but possibly by a local authority having some ground for questioning the commissioners after the transfer order operates and when it becomes the responsibility of the local authority, the certificate by the commissioners will be final and binding. The commissioners are to be the judges of their own work and no one dare question them.
Are we to agree to legislation of that sort? Are we to build up a fortification around the commissioners and put them in such an impregnable position, so far as their work is concerned? No one would dare to question the efficiency of their work, and the judge's hand would be tied. The evidence of a technician or an engineer on the matter, no matter how strong regarding inefficiency, would not be enough. The commissioners could not be assailed or questioned in any way because of the provisions we are asked to subscribe to in this Bill.
The Parliamentary Secretary has not convinced me, and I do not think he could possibly convince the House, as to the desirability or wisdom of putting such a provision in here. There is no analogy whatever in this instance. You are brought in as an impartial body in the one case to certify the work of the local authority in the carrying out of maintenance. Here it is a totally different matter. You are claiming the privilege of certifying your own work. That sort of provision cannot be defended and I could not possibly agree to it.
Comment on this
The provision does not seem to be altogether clear to me. I understand from what the Parliamentary Secretary has said that the amount of work affected by clause (b) of Section 37 is not very great. If it is not very great I think the Parliamentary Secretary might consider the desirability of taking the risk of having a case decided against him in the court. What I also fail to understand is this: suppose the drainage work is undertaken by the commissioners and completed, the maintenance of such work will then be the function of the commissioners. Why is it a clause is not inserted to protect the commissioners, in reference to such work, a clause such as we have here in the case of work already existing? Why is a distinction drawn between existing work taken over and new work completed by the commissioners? If there is no need for the protection of the commissioners in the case of new work which they are liable to maintain, why should they need this special protection in the case of existing works taken over?
Comment on this
It is important that I should answer that right off. Surely the Deputy is aware that the districts that are being transferred on the appointed day are districts that have been neglected, in some cases for 30 years? Some of these districts are districts in which no work has been done in the memory of man, and surely it is unreasonable to suggest that we alone are not entitled to protection and that the county council, who are being asked to take them on the appointed day, are to have protection against people taking action against them for insufficient maintenance?
Comment on this
You do not expect them to carry out improvement work, but you are expected to do so.
Comment on this
We are not expected to improve them until we reconstruct them. When we reconstruct them the normal law will apply to them. We will have a chance then of designing a proper scheme and carrying out proper works. We do not seek any special protection. If you give us a district on which no work has been done for 30 or 40 years and you say to the county council: "We are merely asking you to maintain this up to the standard in which you find it"——
Comment on this
You start off the section by saying: "Where a certificate of completion has been issued." Your argument does not apply here.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary himself applied the words "extravagant" and "high-handed" to this particular clause. I think a more appropriate word would be "outrageous". I do not believe there was such a clause in any legislation ever passed by this House or in any other legislation taken over from the British authorities.
Comment on this
The drainage authority concerns itself with all sorts of safeguards, but there is no safeguard for the individual or the unfortunate local authority affected by these drainage schemes. A clause of this kind is calculated to cause inefficiency amongst the officials of the commissioners themselves, as they know perfectly well that, no matter how indifferently or carelessly they may carry out the work, they are safeguarded against any action taken against them. They issue a sealed certificate, which will be irrefutable evidence that the work was done in the fashion specified, and no one has the right to question it. I wonder what would happen if someone should take action and what the comment of one of our present High Court judges would be in regard to this type of legislation, if someone presented a certificate of that kind. It is indeed an amazing clause.
The Parliamentary Secretary did say that this clause was only intended to apply to old existing drainage districts. From my opinion of the country, I would say it is because of the fact that it does apply to those old existing drainage districts that trouble is likely to arise and that certain people may be inclined to take proceedings against the commissioners on account of the negligent manner in which the work was being carried out. No matter what grievances these people may have, no matter what damage they may suffer, no matter how their livelihood may be affected, they are to have no rights whatever. The drainage officials are at liberty to carry out the scheme in any manner they wish, as indifferently as they wish and without any regard for the people. The officials know perfectly well they are secure under this particular clause and the commissioners also are secure against any claim these unfortunate people may be inclined to make. I would almost say that this clause is unconstitutional; at any rate, it is utterly unjust and I do not think such a clause was ever included in previous legislation.
Comment on this
I want to be strictly fair to the Parliamentary Secretary. The section starts off by saying:
"Whenever a certificate of completion has been issued and also whenever a maintenance transfer order has been made, the following provisions shall apply...."
If the Parliamentary Secretary's contention is right that this paragraph (b) of sub-section (1) applies only in the case of existing drainage works that have been transferred before a certificate of completion has been issued and is intended to safeguard the commissioners from litigation pending the completion of the reconstruction works, I think that it is very badly drafted to cover that point. If he would read it again, he might not be so satisfied that that is properly covered, as the two things are coupled.
Comment on this
That is the one I am talking about. In (a) he is really trying to cover the commissioners, "who shall maintain the said drainage works or existing drainage works in proper repair and effective condition but, in the case of any such existing drainage works...." What he means there is "prior to reconstruction." If the Parliamentary Secretary wants to get that in, it is very necessary to clarify it by saying "prior to reconstruction," as he starts off the section by coupling the two and operating it under both completion and transfer order. In any case, I feel that the paragraph is highly objectionable.
Comment on this
This sub-section (b) would only operate in the case of an existing drainage works prior to reconstruction. In the drafting, I think that is not made clear.
Comment on this
We could not dream of taking over these districts without that protection. One may call it unconstitutional or anything else, but we certainly will not expose ourselves by taking over districts of that type and making ourselves the cockshot that I referred to in the case of the county councils last night. If they are entitled to protection—and they are—so, too, are we.
Comment on this
It is highly objectionable. It is not so bad if you want to protect the commissioners in the interregnum. The principle of a man certifying his own work is wrong. Is it not possible to get out of it in any other way?
Comment on this
They would not inspect these works for us now. We want to fix the appointed day fairly quickly, as we are already engaged on the inspection work that will be necessary in order to fix the appointed day.
Comment on this
I wonder if the Parliamentary Secretary is satisfied that this section is properly drafted?
Comment on this
I will divide the House on this point, unless the Parliamentary Secretary undertakes to make it perfectly clear on the Report Stage, by the introduction of some further phrase. If necessary, I myself will put down an amendment for the Report Stage, saying that this applies only in the period of transfer before reconstruction takes place. Certainly, after reconstruction this paragraph should not be effective.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary gives that undertaking, I will not challenge a division.
Comment on this
There is no such thing as discerning between one district and another, because that district is gone.
Comment on this
The section starts off by saying:—
"Whenever a certificate of completion has been issued and also whenever a maintenance transfer order has been made, the following provisions shall apply..."
One of them is paragraph (b). I am inclined to meet the Parliamentary Secretary on the point that he is putting to the House, but I feel that the section is badly drafted. If the Parliamentary Secretary is prepared to make the matter clear between now and Report Stage, I will not challenge a division.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 111:—
In sub-section (1) (c), page 25, to delete in line 34 the words "in the month" and substitute the words "on or before the 15th day" and to delete in line 37 the word "in" and substitute the words "on or before the 15th day of".
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 112:—
In sub-section (1) (c) to delete all words after the word "year" in line 41 to the end of the paragraph, and substitute the following words:—
"and apportion the said estimated probable cost between all counties in proportion to the poor law valuation of the said counties."
The main purpose of the section, as I understand it, is to provide that the burden of the cost of maintenance of all drainage works shall rest on the local authority. I was hoping that I might be able to draft some kind of amendment that would place that burden on the national Exchequer instead, but I am afraid I could not devise any such amendment. Since the burden is to be borne by the county councils and it might occur that one or two county councils might be victimised inasmuch as the burden would be excessively heavy on one particular county or two, I consider it would be better if the cost were distributed equally over all counties. That may seem to be going too far, but when we consider that one of the principles of this Bill is to take the burden of maintenance off the individual landowners affected and to make it a county-at-large charge so that the ratepayers in even the largest counties must bear the cost of maintenance of perhaps a comparatively small work in a particular county, I do not see anything wrong in distributing the burden equally over all counties. There can be nothing objectionable in it. It would avoid friction and dissatisfaction between one county and another.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy would be well advised to withdraw his amendment. Suppose you had two counties involved in 100 miles of drainage work and that one county had 99 miles—to take an extreme case —and the other county one mile of drainage. I think that if I were living in the latter county I would kick up a big row if I had to pay 50 per cent. of the cost of the maintenance of that work.
Comment on this
The Deputy wants a fiat rate for the whole country. Deputy Hughes's argument would apply all the same.
Comment on this
It would apply in this way: if you had a particularly dry county where they were short of water, and you asked them to pay for the drainage of another part of the country that had too much water. In that case the former would not be getting any benefit.
Comment on this
The same argument could be used against the present system by which you have a flat rate for an entire county. Take the case of a very large county half or three-quarters of which may be exceptionally dry and may not require drainage of any kind. Yet, under the Bill, all the people there will have to bear their share of the drainage rate.
Comment on this
This matter was very carefully considered by us and we decided against the course suggested in these amendments. There is general agreement that the principle of paying in proportion to the benefit received is not an unsound one. It was only departed from in the case of riparian owners for convenience purposes.
Comment on this
It has, but there was nothing wrong with it in principle. It was dropped, and the county-at-large charge was substituted for the reason that the county is a unit. It is the nearest that you can get to the individual in this particular case. The county is responsible for many of its own services. If the principle in the Deputy's amendment were to be accepted, we would have a great deal of agitation and not the harmony which he suggests. I believe it would have the very opposite effect in counties in which there are not very serious drainage problems if the people there were to be called upon to pay into a pool on a flat rate from which they would get very little benefit. You would have a great deal of agitation conducted by local authorities as to the injustice of that state of affairs. For these and for other reasons that it is not necessary to go into, it was found, on giving these amendments consideration, that the course suggested in them would not be a wise one to take.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary not agree that it could be a greater cause of friction in a case say where a river is flowing through two counties? A great deal of work is carried out on the outfall works in one county but very little benefit is derived by the county from that work. Would not that county feel a very big grievance if a very substantial burden were placed upon it as against the other county which derived all the benefit? Is not that much more likely to be a cause of friction than if there was a flat rate?
Comment on this
That is an important point, but surely that is taken into account in the final award?
Comment on this
They would only have to pay in proportion to the benefit conferred. The cost of the outfall works would not have any determining effect on the cost of the maintenance. I think that the Deputy could withdraw this amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 114:—
In sub-section (1), (f), page 26, to delete in lines 28 and 29 the words "in the year next after the year in which such demand for payment is made" and substitute the words "next following such 30th day of September".
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I formally move amendment No. 116:—
In sub-section (3) (a), page 27, before the word "employed" in line 14 to insert the word "wholly".
What does the Parliamentary Secretary say about it?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 118:—
Before Section 38, in page 27, to insert the following new section:—
"The moneys payable by a county council in pursuance of the next preceding section shall become due only to the extent that the commissioners certify that the maintenance work included in the estimate prepared in accordance with that section has been carried out."
What is the Parliamentary Secretary's view on this?