Committee on Finance. - Arterial Drainage Bill, 1944—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 236–470 of 470. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 16 of 1944 ›
Sub-section (1) is shocking. It gives power to enter on land and to do all such things as shall be necessary or incidental to maintenance. You cannot more clearly define the duties of the commissioners in regard to work than "Do all the things that shall be necessary for the incidental carrying out of the work."
Comment on this
If an ordinary contractor were doing a job and if you drew up the terms of his contract in that way, it would be a rather poor contract. That is a shocking piece of legislation. It may have been taken from other Drainage Acts; I do not know. It gives power to "take from any land all sods and other material required for the purposes of such maintenance". You could go ten miles away and take sods and other material. We talk about the value of soil in this country. We are going to dig up the surface of the earth and make embankments out of it. Paragraph (d) empowers the commissioners "to utilise for the purpose of such maintenance all or any soil, gravel, stone, rock or other material removed in the course of such maintenance". Then in sub-section (2) we give power to "execute such improvements to such drainage works or existing drainage works as appear to them to be minor matters". The drafting is so wide it simply means that the commissioners can do what they like. That right is preserved through the whole Bill and they have very wide powers when they enter on a piece of land.
Comment on this
I suppose, when we proceed to carry out the work, we will find that we have not powers enough.
Comment on this
The only thing I take exception to is that when you have taken the wide powers you are not prepared to put in the safeguards. The Parliamentary Secretary is absolutely stubborn about that. I am afraid that in a very short time he has developed the Departmental mind. The Civil Service has had an overpowering effect on him. He should preserve the mentality of the ordinary citizen, of a democrat, who believes in making the Department do its job and imposing the necessary check on it, and if it does not do its job then the citizen has a right to bring the Department to court and test the matter there. I think that between this and Report Stage the Parliamentary Secretary would be well advised to reconsider the whole matter of putting in safeguards. It changes the mentality of an official if he feels that the individual has certain safeguards and can test him in court. The moment he walks in with full arbitrary powers, he is quite a different individual to deal with. Are we going to legislate in this House to give powers of that sort to individual engineers? They may be very decent men if they know that you can take them to court and test their right and authority to do certain things. If the citizen has not that power, some of them may still behave as decent men, but all of them will not behave as decent men. That section attacks the fundamental liberty of the individual. It is shocking legislation and, as I pointed out to the Parliamentary Secretary, it has been vigorously condemned in the Report of the Vocational Organisation published a few days ago. Why do we set up such commissions if we do not take cognisance of their recommendations?
The Parliamentary Secretary suggested that I wanted to prevent national drainage in this country. I am as anxious as the Parliamentary Secretary is that there should be national drainage, but I say that giving a drainage authority exceptional powers which are necessary requires the necessary safeguards so far as the individual and the local authority are concerned. We have given all the exceptional powers that are necessary to the drainage authority that we are setting up and the Parliamentary Secretary and the Government Department generally are refusing to put in any of the essential safeguards.
Comment on this
I only want to say that the only fears I have are as to the danger of our not having sufficient powers. I feel that when we proceed to do this work we will find in all probability that we have not sufficient powers in certain cases. Instead of my mind running on the same lines as Deputy Hughes, having doubts and fears as to the powers we are taking here, I look in the opposite direction and my only fears are that we might not have powers enough.
Comment on this
Is that a fair answer to our criticism? We have said that we are prepared to give you any exceptional powers you want—because you want very wide powers to carry out a national drain age scheme like this — but we have pressed you time and again to put in the very necessary safeguards. That is our line of argument. We are not denying you the powers, but we are pressing for the safeguards which the Parliamentary Secretary has adamantly refused.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 120:—
In sub-section (1), page 28, to delete in line 11 the words "water-rights" and substitute the words "fisheries, water-rights, navigation rights"—Aire Airgeadais.
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I cannot understand the necessity for taking power to amend an award. Where is it likely to arise?
Comment on this
If it is found, on completion of a scheme, that it requires amendment. The award then has to be amended in accordance with the amended scheme.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton is ill, and I do not know what he had in mind with regard to this amendment.
Comment on this
We would be inclined to meet him on this. He suggests that the time should be extended. We will try to meet him.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 122:—
In sub-section (2) (d), page 29, line 9, to insert before the words "in his own" the words "by the reference committee."
This matter has been considered already.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 123:—
In sub-section (2) to delete paragraphs (f) and (g), lines 15-23.
This aims at making the appointment permanent. Under the original legislation, the Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act, 1919, the decision was that the officials appointed held permanent office. I think there was some good reason for making that decision. In the first place, they would be more independent. The Parliamentary Secretary has given way on the proposals here by which the reference committee would pick a panel of arbitrators, and whenever the Minister wanted an arbitrator, he would simply take one from the panel. I was inclined to argue that the Minister would pick a man who would suit him, as he would. If he did not like him, he would get another. The same thing would apply where a man holds a temporary office. If his awards are too generous, from the commissioners' point of view, they may get some other man, but if a man held a permanent office, he would be independent and not afraid of losing his job.
There is another aspect, that is, that a man might be a member of a firm or associated with a firm which might be interested. It might be a milling interest in a stream in relation to a water right which might be in question and temporary appointments for that reason are undesirable, especially in the case of an arbitrator. When the British, who passed this Act originally, insisted on a permanent appointment, there was a very good and valid reason for putting men in strictly impartial and independent positions and above any influence by the State or anyone else. They got reasonable remuneration for their work, and were completely independent. If you want to get the strictly impartial decisions which are necessary, if the arbitrator is to do his work properly, it would be more desirable to have a man in a permanent position than in a temporary position. If a man holding a temporary appointment for three years makes awards which are too favourable to the individual, from the commissioners' point of view, or from the point of view of the Minister for Finance, who has to pay the compensation, he will get the "sack."
Comment on this
It happens that there is no ulterior motive in this. The Drainage Commission had something to say about this matter, and we are following closely the lines they recommended to us. They visualised a large number of cases arising in which the services of arbitrators with varied qualifications would be necessary. It is not the same as the acquisition of land for housing. The question of mill rights, fisheries, land, and so on, will arise, and they apparently came to the conclusion that it would be better if the reference committee had power to select a man, even though he might be engaged in private practice. We saw that the recommendation was sensible, and we made this alteration. There is no danger or harm in it, and I think it very necessary.
Comment on this
I think it was made clear in the original Act that a man held a permanent office for a definite reason, to ensure that there would be no danger of abuse. A man might be called on to arbitrate on a matter on which commercial interests, in which he himself might be indirectly involved, arose.
Comment on this
I am following exactly the recommendation of the Drainage Commission, and I think the Deputy can let it go.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 124, on behalf of Deputy Norton:—
At the end of paragraph (f), line 20, to insert the following proviso:—"provided, that the Minister shall fix in respect of all members of the panel a uniform scale of remuneration and fees, travelling and subsistence allowance so far as may be practicable".
Comment on this
Deputy Norton wants a uniform scale. I do not think it would be fair or right to fix a uniform scale because the qualifications of the men employed will not be uniform.
Comment on this
The scales appropriate to the individual, in accordance with his qualifications and standing, will be paid.
Comment on this
What guarantee have we in any part of the section that a man with technical experience will be chosen as an arbitrator? The Parliamentary Secretary suggests that he favours the temporary appointment because there might be a variety of interests involved. Have we any safeguard that, in the event of the milling industry being involved, an engineer with technical knowledge will be selected?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 126:—
To add at the end a new sub-section as follows:—
(3) Whenever under this section the commissioners in lieu of executing any specified work themselves contract with some other person for the execution of the whole or any part of such works it shall be mandatory on the commissioners to insert in the contract made with such other person a provision requiring such other person to pay rates of wages and observe conditions of employment not less favourable to the persons employed under the contract than the wages paid and conditions of employment prescribed under trade union agreements applicable to work of a similar kind or in the absence of such trade union agreements the wages paid and the conditions of employment observed by good employers in the district in which the work is carried out.
We propose that where the commissioners give out any works for which they are responsible for execution by contract, a clause shall be inserted requiring the contractor to observe trade union conditions, or, where there is no trade union agreement, to observe the wages and conditions observed by employers in the district.
This is in conformity with Government policy and the generally recognised policy of local authorities throughout the country that contractors should not be permitted to carry out a contract under wages and conditions less favourable than the local authority or the Government Department itself would observe. In so far as we include the alternatives, that either the trade union clause, which is the clause included in many tenders of local authorities, or the terms of the fair wages clause, which the Board of Works itself observes, I think the Parliamentary Secretary should meet us in the matter.
Comment on this
In making contracts, we always stipulate for a fair wages clause. That has been our policy, and will continue to be our policy. The amendment, of course, is not altogether in that form. But we are committed by practice and otherwise to a policy of stipulating in every contract that we make with an outsider that he will observe the fair wages provision.
Comment on this
In so far as there is no issue as between the Parliamentary Secretary and the principle of the amendment, would he not accept the amendment to make it quite clear that such a practice would be definitely binding?
Comment on this
The amendment could not be accepted in the form in which it is. There is no necessity to cover the point which the Deputy raises.
Comment on this
The conditions will pass on to the sub-contractor?
Comment on this
In this section, power is asked for, in the event of the local authority not paying up when the bill is presented, to secure that any moneys coming from any Department of State may be withheld for the purpose of discharging the liabilities to the commissioners. Supposing there is a dispute between the local authority and the commissioners regarding the amount involved or the efficiency of the work or anything else; surely that sort of procedure is wrong, that we should authorise any Department or any Minister to deduct money for the purpose of discharging the liability of the commissioners. In the event of any dispute between a local authority and the commissioners regarding the efficiency of the work, the magnitude of the bill, or any point that might be the subject of litigation in such circumstances, we should not agree to this provision that money should be deducted from other sources. Such money might be for the purpose of dealing with tuberculosis or some other purpose altogether. I am certainly opposed to this section.
Comment on this
I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will see his way to delete this section on the Report Stage. Local authorities under this Bill, when it becomes an Act, will be called upon to act in a very responsible manner, and I think this penal section is all wrong. This is the only Bill, other than Land Bills, which came before the House in which this section is included. At present, local authorities remit to certain Government Departments huge sums of money each year, for instance, in repayment of loans out of the Local Loans Fund, and not a single one of them has ever defaulted to the extent of 1/-. They raise the rates faithfully each year, and remit every 1/- they owe to the Local Loans Fund without any penal clause compelling them to do so. I cannot understand why this section was lifted bodily out of the Land Act and put into this Bill. Several Bills have been passed providing that local authorities should raise certain funds and remit them to the central authority. In no case was a penal clause such as this inserted. To my mind, it is degrading to the local authorities to say that responsible bodies will not pay their just debts to the State, that they will not raise sufficient funds to pay what is a statutory obligation. It is made a statutory obligation in this Bill for a local authority to raise a certain county-at-large rate to the extent of the certificate of the drainage commissioners, and the suggestion here is that local authorities will hang on to this money and will not remit it to the drainage authority. The drainage commissioners have plenty of powers, other than this section, to get the money. They can go into court at any time and mandamus the local authority or sue them, if any local authority were so foolish as to withhold the money. They are bound each year to raise the money. The county manager will have no option but to raise the money. The members of the council will not have the right to decide not to raise the money. It is mandatory on them to raise the money each year. To say that a county council will have power to withhold the money is all nonsense. It is an executive function. The council will have no control over any of the funds other than to provide them. This would seem to contemplate that the county manager would withhold these moneys from the commissioners. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will see his way to have the section deleted on the Report Stage. It is a penal clause which is bringing the county councils into absolute contempt. The people who put in that section had nothing but contempt for local authorities. That is my opinion.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Allen that this section appears to be unnecessary. I was not quite sure whether this was an executive function or a reserved function. Deputy Allen says it is an executive function. If it is, it is a function of the county manager, who is the direct servant of the Government, and he is not likely to default in the payment of the money due. If Deputy Allen is wrong and it is a reserved function, we all know that county councils are subject to very rigid control by the Local Government Department. County councils have been abolished for smaller offences than not providing moneys such as these which are statutorily due. Therefore, there seems to be absolutely no justification for putting in this penal section. It is not desirable that the commissioners should have power to collect this money from some other funds due to the county councils.
By making that deduction from some other fund that is payable to the county council they may upset the finances of the county council unduly. I cannot conceive any delay occurring in the payment of these amounts unless where there is a very serious difference of opinion as to whether the amount is actually due. In a case like that I do not think it would be desirable that the commissioners should have such drastic powers. I think the fact that local authorities are under such rigid control should be sufficient guarantee that the money will be paid.
Comment on this
Whatever case there might be for the inclusion of such a section in other legislation, I certainly do not think there is any need for it in this Bill. It is true, as Deputy Allen pointed out, that a similar section was included in some of the Land Acts. I do not know whether the section in the Land Acts was as drastic as this particular section. It is most unlikely that any county council would default in regard to whatever payments may be due to the Board of Works. I think sub-sections (2) and (3) could safely be deleted.
If Section 44 is read in conjunction with Section 45, it would appear that the Drainage Commissioners will be performing another function as well; that is, a sort of debt-collecting agency, because in Section 45 it would seem as if they are going to collect all the money due to other Departments of State as well as what is due to the Board of Works. I think Section 45 is an insult to local authorities.
I agree with Deputy Allen that it is most unlikely that a county manager will refuse to make payments. I do not know whether it has happened in the past, but we are all aware that county managers are appointees of the Minister for Local Government and I cannot understand how they would refuse to meet claims made upon them by the Drainage Commissioners in respect of any moneys due. I consider this section entirely unnecessary.
Comment on this
If the county manager does not refuse to pay, the section will not operate against him.
Comment on this
I agree with the point of view expressed by Deputy Allen. I do not see any reason why this section should be included in the Bill. I have a good deal of experience of local authorities and I have never known one of them to withhold a payment of this kind. It is a penal clause against local authorities and there is no necessity for it. I do not know what right the Parliamentary Secretary has to assume that any local authority will withhold such payments. Local authorities all over the country have been appealing for proper drainage laws so that drainage may be carried out in their districts and they will be only too happy to pay whatever is due under this measure. I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to withdraw the section. It shows a complete distrust of local authorities. There has been enough interference with local authorities in recent years without a section of this kind being brought in. To my mind this is extraneous matter altogether. I will definitely call for a division on this section.
Comment on this
I can only say this, that if a council pays the moneys that are due to the commissioners, neither the county council nor the county manager will ever know there is such a section in the Arterial Drainage Act. If they do not pay, the section merely gives the commissioners power to make a deduction from any moneys due to the council. I do not think there is any harm in having that safeguard there.
Comment on this
I think this is belittling a council. I see no reason why you should assume that a council will not pay its debts. I do not know of any other Act of Parliament which has a similar section.
Comment on this
This section has its origin in the first Land Act that was passed by the British Parliament. It was also embodied in Land Acts passed by this House, but to my knowledge it was embodied in no other legislation. Under the 1925 Drainage Act moneys had to be remitted to the central authority and under other Drainage Acts moneys had to be remitted. To my knowledge, no local authority has ever defaulted to the extent of 1/-. The Parliamentary Secretary has not answered that.
The insertion of this section in the Bill is no injury to local authorities, but it shows an utter contempt for them and it indicates that here are some kind of wild men, halfsavages, who will not pay these debts. That is how it appears to me and for that reason I object to the section. Local authorities have a pride in their business, just the same as this Parliament has a pride in doing its duty and paying its debts. The Drainage Commissioners and the Board of Works have statutory powers to collect any money that is due. They have the same authority to collect as other Departments of State. If the Minister for Agriculture is owed money by a county committee he has power to go to court to collect it. So, too, the Office of Public Works has power to collect debts, and I do not think it can claim that any local authority withheld money that was due. If the Parliamentary Secretary can give me one instance of where they withheld money, I shall withdraw my opposition.
Comment on this
With other Deputies, I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to withdraw this section. I think he might reasonably give way to us on this occasion. As Deputy Allen so well argued, it does not matter very much whether it is in or not, but it does cast a slur on very respectable bodies. We have been arguing about the commissioners, and when we suggested they should be compelled to do certain things the Parliamentary Secretary would not give us any hearing—it was almost calumny to suggest the commissioners would act as we suggested. How, he asked, could any reasonable man assume that the commissioners would do what was suggested? It was unthought of. Here it is a case of a county council doing something which a county council was never known to do and yet the Parliamentary Secretary thinks it necessary to put in this section. I think he is unreasonable in not meeting Deputies on this matter.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary consider this matter between now and the Report Stage?
Comment on this
It is not one of these matters where you can see on its face what it is aimed at. It is a question of whether the thing is right or wrong. I do not understand those Deputies who are so sensitive about local authorities.
Comment on this
The sensitiveness is so highly developed that it is beyond me to understand it. This is a section which merely says that, if money is due, power will be given to those to whom it is due to take the amount from money which they might have to pay. There could be a case in which we would take over a district and be responsible for maintaining it, while the local authority would be responsible for paying for that maintenance. If they refused to pay us promptly, or were squabbling about it, we want to be able to take the amount from those sums due to them. I know what local authorities are, I have some experience of them and I cannot see that there is anything in this section in any way offensive, if they do their job.
Comment on this
It is not at all a question of sensitiveness: it is a question of pride in the local authorities and resentment that the Parliamentary Secretary has not faith in them. He has not been able to cite one instance where a local authority broke its word, in so far as payment for lawful debts is concerned. I cannot see why it is necessary to have such a section. There has been enough interference with the local authorities in recent years: do not let us wipe them out of existence altogether by having no respect for them at all.
Comment on this
The principle enshrined in this section is a most objectionable one. It was established in the first Land Acts, when the moneys due to this country at that time from the Imperial Exchequer were impounded and made liable for any defalcation under the Land Acts. That is a principle we strongly resented even then, through our representatives, and that resentment still remains. It is repugnant to us now that the very same principle should be adopted by our own Department of State, and that moneys due to the county council could, if there were any neglect or dispute, be held liable for that payment. It is an unnecessarily provocative section, continuing a principle that everyone in this State repudiated when it was first introduced against us. It is very bad policy that we should now adopt the ways and means formerly adopted against us when we had legitimate claims to fight. The principle is now being brought against the local authorities, a section of our own people. I regret to have to speak in that way and to impeach it on those lines, but when has a local authority refused to face its liabilities? I am not aware of it and I have had very close and intimate association with local authorities for a very considerable time.
It is entirely unnecessary that we should take over this method, which was repudiated by us previously, with emphasis, when it was first introduced, as a dictatorial and arbitrary method of recovering annuities in this country. It is a particularly bad principle and, on those grounds alone, I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to withdraw the section. It is not in the least effective and is entirely unnecessary, as it has never been known that a local authority refused to face its liabilities. Why should this section be introduced, in a Bill which is unquestionably of great advantage to the country? Why put the House to the pain of dividing on this point and compel members of the Government Party to vote for it, although they see the effectiveness of this section against local authorities and see in this a very close adherence to the procedure adopted against our people by the people of another country.
Comment on this
I find this section in the Local Loans Fund Act, as well as in the other Acts mentioned.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Norton I move amendment No. 127:—
In line 20, after the word "person" to insert the words "on foot of a decree".
I think it is reasonable that the Parliamentary Secretary should accept an amendment of this kind. After all, it is only right that someone, other than a Minister of State, should determine whether a debt is due or not.
Comment on this
It is scarcely likely that a State Department would demand money that is not due from an individual. I do not think it would be fair to ask them to go to court to get a decree.
Comment on this
Surely the Parliamentary Secretary does not consider it necessary to take such power, in view of the fact that other departments over which Ministers are the heads, for example, the Revenue Commissioners and the Land Commission, have machinery of their own for collecting debts? Why should the Parliamentary Secretary and the Drainage Commissioners assume the responsibility of a debt-collecting agency for these different State departments? Even assuming that such a section is in one of the earlier Acts, that is no justification for introducing it into this Bill at this stage of our history.
Comment on this
But, surely, all these State Departments have machinery of their own for collecting their debts. It seems to me very unfair that a person to whom compensation is payable should be treated in this fashion, and that the Drainage Commissioners should act as a sort of vigilance committee on behalf of other Departments of the Government.
Comment on this
I think that the Parliamentary Secretary has not the slightest doubt that the Revenue Commissioners will collect any money that may be due to them.
Comment on this
I think the section is very objectionable. We should not be prepared to grant privileges of that sort. The Revenue Commissioners invariably decide that the money is owed. In this case, once they decide that the money is due, there is an end to it. There is some justification for the amendment suggested by Deputy Norton on foot of a decree, but in any case I think the section is highly objectionable. Opportunity should not be taken in this Bill to take one year's income-tax or an annuity that he owes from a person because for once in his life he is entitled to compensation since you have taken some rights from him, acquired land or something like that.
Comment on this
I think it would be a very useful power. Would the Deputy realise that sums of money might be due by an individual to a State Department? He might be an individual from whom it would be impossible to recover. Is it suggested that in the event of another State Department having to pay money to that individual we should not take the right here to deduct the sums that were due to him—that we should in fact pay money to him although when, we had paid, the other Department would not be able to recover the amount that was due to it?
Comment on this
The Revenue Commissioners is the deciding factor, according to the section, as to whether it is due or not.
Comment on this
According to the section, it appears to me to be obligatory on the commissioners to make inquiries from all other Departments as to whether this man to whom compensation is payable owes any money to any of these Departments. That is a responsibility the Drainage Commissioners are assuming.
Comment on this
I think this is a worse section than the other. With all the work the commissioners are going to have under this Bill—and goodness knows they will have a whole-time job if they are to do the draining of the country in any reasonable time—we are giving them the job of debt collector. I think it is monstrous. I cannot find any other word for it. The Parliamentary Secretary says he cannot conceive of any Department asking money that is not due to it. He cannot conceive of any Department asking money that is not due to it. He cannot conceive even the Revenue Commissioners demanding money that is not due to them. I can conceive it. In fact, I have had painful experience of even the Revenue Commissioners demanding money from me that I did not owe. I remember taking the Revenue Commissioners to court and beating them. The Parliamentary Secretary tells me, with a face of clay, that he cannot imagine a Department of State, particularly the Revenue Commissioners, demanding money that was not due. If I had the same case to-morrow as I had some years ago against the Revenue Commissioners, all they need do would be to refer to the Drainage Act and say: "Collect the money; he owes it to us." I would have no redress. The Drainage Commissioners are not only to be debt collectors for the Revenue Commissioners but for the Land Commission and any other Department of State. They are going to have a fine job. I cannot argue the section without losing my temper. I am going to vote against it if nobody else challenges a division.
Comment on this
It appears to me that the object of this Bill is being lost sight of altogether. Why should a Bill of this kind be used as a medium to set up the Drainage Commissioners as a collector for other Ministries? This might prevent urgent drainage work from being carried out, if it is carried to its logical conclusion. It is a very objectionable section. We will have to amend it as best we can but I do suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that it should not be in the Bill at all. Again I say it is extraneous so far as the real objects of the Bill are concerned.
Comment on this
Surely the arguments are not seriously contended? Surely they are not being advanced in a serious manner?
Comment on this
Let us take the case of an occupier of land who, for one reason or another, whether through inability or otherwise, has failed to pay his annuities?
Comment on this
Never mind that case. Take the case of a man who has failed to pay his annuities to the Land Commission, and suppose that same individual was awarded compensation as the result of the activities of this drainage authority. Assuming that as a result of arbitration it was decided that this man should get compensation to the extent of £50, £100 or £200, is it seriously suggested that the State Department should hand that money to that man without having regard to whether or not his annuities had been paid? If that is put forward as a serious argument or if it is contended that that is imposing an injustice, there is no use in talking.
Comment on this
That is only dealing with one transaction. In this section the drainage authority is empowered to act on behalf of any Ministry. As far as I am concerned, I would agree to it in so far as arrears of annuities in respect of land are concerned, but I would not agree to give power to collect in behalf of other Ministries in connection with transactions that have nothing, good, bad or indifferent, to do with the particular thing you aim to do here.
Comment on this
Is the section so unusual? I remember a case that came to my notice some years ago where an applicant was awarded compensation under the Damage to Property Act, 1934. That person owed money to the National Health Insurance for stamps that he had failed to put on his employee's card. The amount was deducted from the compensation he was awarded by the Department of Local Government. Evidently this procedure has been followed in other legislation.
Comment on this
No, it was not. It was under the Damage to Property Act, 1934, which was passed by this House to enable applicants to apply for compensation in respect of damages incurred during the Black-and-Tan and civil wars.
Comment on this
Supposing it is due to the Land Commission, we are not objecting to that, even if the Parliamentary Secretary accepts the amendment, but in the case of money due to the Revenue Commissioners, the Revenue Commissioners are going to decide whether the debt is due or not, and no one else. That is the position. The individual might be disputing the amount but, whether he disputes it or not, the Revenue Commissioners can inform the Drainage Commissioners that the amount is due, and the Drainage Commissioners deduct it.
Comment on this
What safeguard has the individual? If the Parliamentary Secretary accepts the amendment, then we will not divide the House on the section but, if he is not prepared to accept it, we will have to divide the House. We are anxious to ensure that the individual's rights are safeguarded and they are not safeguarded under this section. It is not an unreasonable attitude. In the case of money due to the Land Commission it is not unreasonable to deduct the debt from any compensation that is payable because the amount could scarcely be disputed, but, obviously, it could be disputed in the case of money due to the Revenue Commissioners and if the matter had been lying there it is more than likely it is in dispute. In this section, the Revenue Commissioners can simply inform the Drainage Commissioners that the amount should be deducted.
Comment on this
I am in entire agreement with the Parliamentary Secretary in the case he put where work might be done on a particular land in respect of which land annuities were due, which ought to be collected or deducted from any compensation grant. I think Deputy Hughes is of the same opinion. That is definitely just one transaction, but we all know that from time to time there are disputes between the Revenue Commissioners and various individuals, or groups of individuals, and such a dispute might be in course of negotiation. Is it suggested that if compensation were payable to such an individual, the Board of Works should become the collector for the Revenue Commissioners? The Parliamentary Secretary would be well advised to accept the amendment. It gives him ample powers and the ultimate result would be that he would get his money.
Comment on this
This section appeared in every Bill that came before this House recently and no objection was raised in any shape or form to it. This section merely gives us the right to deduct. It does not prevent the individual who thinks the deduction is unfair or unreasonable from taking us to court and disputing the deduction, but I am going to resist any amendment which would impose on us the necessity for getting a decree before we can make a deduction.
Comment on this
The poor individual has to go to court, but the Government, with plenty of money behind it, will not go to court.
Comment on this
This section is not unreasonable. I challenged the Parliamentary Secretary on the last section to tell me one Act, apart from the Land Act, in which that section appeared, but in this case I know that every Act of the Dáil—Agricultural Acts, Compensation for Criminal Injury Acts and so on—had this section in it. In every case where the State pays compensation, there is a similar provision and this section is lifted exactly out of every Act under which the State pays any compensation for the acquisition of land, damage to property or in any other respect. All the agricultural Acts contain this section and I think the Opposition are unreasonable in suggesting that it should not be embodied here. It is only 12 months since Deputy Hughes allowed a similar section in an agricultural Act to go through.
Comment on this
I will agree to the section if the Parliamentary Secretary will agree to the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 130:—
In sub-section (3), page 32, line 3, to delete the figures "1939" and substitute the figures "1944".
That is consequential.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 131:—
In sub-section (1), line 15, to delete the words "one month" and substitute the words "three months".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 133:—
In sub-section (1), line 17, to delete all from the word "watercourses" to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "watercourse or watercourses on the said lands as is or are specified in such notice and is or are not included in any existing drainage works or any drainage works constructed under this Act, but which discharges or discharge into an existing drainage district or a drainage district constituted under this Act and is or are, in the opinion of the commissioners, incapable, by reason of neglect or of inadequate maintenance, of efficiently discharging the water passing into or through it or them from adjoining land."
This is a fairly formidable type of amendment.
Comment on this
I was not satisfied with the section inasmuch as there was a possibility that injustice could be done to a landholder and, as a result of discussions that took place, these amendments were designed to meet that case. The House may feel that the effort has not been successful, but I think these amendments will give us the power that we want and, at the same time, give it to us in such a way as to ensure that substantial injustice could not be done to any individual.
Comment on this
I must say that it was my intention before the Parliamentary Secretary put down this group of amendments to oppose Section 48. At the same time, I realised the necessity of getting after people who might be obstructing drainage being carried out. You might have some people who were anxious to carry out drainage works and an individual, who was not prepared to do anything about it, might intervene between that group of individuals and the outfall. Therefore, it was necessary to take power to do something about it. I agree that the amendments provide a pretty fair safeguard. This is the first time in two or three days that the Parliamentary Secretary has mentioned the word "safeguard" in its application to the individual. He mentioned it now for the first time. It is rather belated, but it is better late than never. The only thing is that in amendment No. 135, paragraph (d), you leave it to the commissioners to decide the time, if an objection is disallowed. The paragraph states:
"Whenever the commissioners disallow an objection, they shall amend the notice to which such objection relates by extending, for such period as they think proper, the period specified in such notice for compliance therewith."
Comment on this
In paragraph (c) you appeal to the commissioners; you lodge an objection and the commissioners consider it. You have the position that the commissioners have decided that the man should carry out the work. It is very unlikely that they will change their minds.
Comment on this
Yes, to an arbitrator — I understand that. What I am worried about is that you may possibly compel an individual to carry out work that should properly be carried out by the commissioners. That is the only danger I see in the operation of the section. I am all for compelling an individual to carry out work that should be carried out by him, but there is the danger that this section may be operated against an individual in relation to work that should be carried out by the commissioners. That is what I do not like about it. However, the amendment otherwise fairly meets the objection and it goes some way to protect the individual.
Comment on this
Sometimes you may find a situation where, perhaps, an individual is not interested in a drain; it does not affect him; it may be passing along the lower fringe of his farm, and so far as the drainage of his land is concerned it is not affected to any extent by the drain, which is merely a waterway conveying the water from land higher up. In that case it should not be the responsibility of the individual.
Comment on this
Freedom to enter on the land to do the work is provided for. That will be the position if the commissioners think it necessary to have certain work done.
Comment on this
You have provided for someone else to do the work, but you have not stated that it is not his responsibility.
Comment on this
It is cut across by amendment No. 133. If Deputy Blowick thinks it has not been covered by the Ministerial amendment, he can resubmit it on Report.
Comment on this
He may resubmit it in whatever form he thinks necessary—the same amendment in substance.
Comment on this
When I saw the original section, it rather confused me and I was inclined to move its rejection. I am still more or less of the same opinion. I felt the section was unnecessary and it might have made it incumbent on a small farmer to do work which would be difficult for him to do, work which should be included in the drainage scheme. The Parliamentary Secretary has made some attempt to meet that; he has put it in a less objectionable way.
There is another reason why I objected to the section. I thought that the powers it contained were unnecessary and that there was already machinery available for one landholder to make another do certain things. The Parliamentary Secretary and I were throwing bouquets at each other about our lack of knowledge of the law. I confess I lack a knowledge of the law, but it is within my memory where a tenant farmer proceeded under the ordinary law against another tenant farmer for neglecting to clean his drain, thereby impeding the water supply. He won in ordinary law and compelled the man to clean his drain. For that reason I thought the section was unnecessary. I felt that if it was a big thing it should be included in the drainage scheme, and if it was a small thing the existing law was there to give a landowner power to compel others to clean the drains.
I would have let it pass except for sub-section (2), paragraph (c), which says that if the objector is willing to give a written undertaking that he will allow at all reasonable times any occupier to come and clean his drains, he will be let off. That might somewhat endanger a man's right under the ordinary law. If the ordinary law is as I think it is, and as was ruled in the case I mentioned, I have the power of compelling a man who impedes the flow of water on my land by not draining his to remedy the position. The Parliamentary Secretary puts in a sub-section which gives that man the right, if he gives an undertaking in writing to the commissioners that he will give me permission to do it myself, to be absolved. If I have the right to compel him to do it, why should he get the right, by giving a written guarantee to the commissioners to permit me to do it, to be absolved? You may be taking away a right one person has against another by that particular sub-section. I would like the Parliamentary Secretary to look into the matter before the Report Stage. I should not like to see any landholder debarred from the right he has under the existing law.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Parliamentary Secretary's amendment has watered down the section too much. I fear that under the section as it will read now, as Deputy Bennett pointed out, in the case of a man who will not clean up his watercourse there is power given here to let the man upstream come along and clean it. It is unfair to allow that to happen. It would be better to leave the section as it was. I saw no danger in the section as it was. You have individuals in the country who will not do their part in cleaning up the watercourses, and, as a result, lands are damaged. We all know of such cases. Every one of us has a dozen such cases in mind. We have similar individuals under the rural improvement scheme. They will not allow the scheme to be carried out on a certain boreen or lane. We will have similar people under this drainage legislation. They are in existence already. I am afraid that the section has been watered down to such an extent that it will not be effective. It will not have the effect desired. As regards the individual's rights, no individual will be affected, except the crank who will not do his duty by his neighbour.
Comment on this
The section as it was originally was quite all right, but under it now the crank will get away with it again.
Comment on this
A man does not want to bring his neighbour into court every day and Deputy Bennett knows that. I am not afraid of the individual's rights being affected: it will only affect the crank who is not doing his duty by his neighbour.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is wrong there. Paragraph (e) of this new sub-section contained in amendment No. 135, deals with a particular type of case—that of a man who has land on a hillside where there happens to be a stream at the foot of his land, along the lower end of his farm. He may not be affected by that drain at all, as it is merely conveying the water from farms higher up. It would be unreasonable to expect that man to pay a lot of attention to that particular stream. This amendment is to permit farmers higher up to go in on that man's land and clean up the stream which is merely passing along the lower end of his farm.
Comment on this
Yes, that is why we must be careful with legislation of this kind. The Parliamentary Secretary has said, for the first time in the last two or three days, that he is anxious to protect the individual's rights. I am glad to see that he is alive to that necessity, and I am rather pleased that he saw fit to amend the section. I think it fairly covers the point. I hope he will accept the amendment further on, to the effect that the individual will not be held responsible for a drain that is an arterial drain.
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to look into that case, as I am not satisfied with it. If a tenant has a right already to compel another tenant to do a certain thing, I do not think we should take that right away from him. Deputy Allen and Deputy Hughes know what I mean. In the case of the stream running through three or four farms, if one farmer fails to drain, the work of the others will be destroyed. I am familiar with a case which went to court under the common law. A man refused to clean his drain and the farmer further up, whose land was waterlogged and whose work was useless because the other man would not drain, took him into court and made him do it. I am not a lawyer and cannot say whether the justice who decided the case was right or wrong in law; but, apparently, he had the right to compel the other man to do what he should have done willingly. Sub-section (2) gives that unreasonable man the right to say that, if he writes to the commissioners and gives an undertaking in writing to let the objector do it himself, they will absolve him.
Comment on this
Perhaps I could ease the Deputy's mind by saying that, to the extent the law gives the power he desires, those powers will still remain when this Bill becomes an Act. He is right in saying that, in certain cases, the power existed for one farmer to compel another to do certain things; but the unfortunate point is, was, and will be in the future, I suppose, that many farmers do not want to incur displeasure by taking their neighbours into court to establish these rights. That fact is borne out by the Report of the Commission when, in dealing with this problem, it recommended that action should be taken. We are following that recommendation and those of us who know the problem in our own way see the necessity for it.
I disagree with Deputy Allen. It is all right to go just far enough and, when you go far enough to meet a certain difficulty, there is no use in going further. A cranky man has to live, too, and I would not like to go to the extent of heaping injustice upon him, just because he is a cranky man. All we are trying to provide is that his crankiness will not prevent his neighbours getting the relief to which they are entitled. I can see, under the section as it existed—and I did see it, in fact, on the Second Reading—that there was a possibility that he could be called upon, in certain circumstances, to do a job of work which would be altogether unreasonable and which would confer no benefits at all upon himself, while it would bring substantial benefits to his neighbours. I do not want to go that far, but I want to ensure that the neighbours will not be obstructed by him in going in upon his land, or, in the case of the county council or Special Employment Schemes Office, that they will not be prohibited from going in on his land, in order to relieve the obstruction that was causing hardship to the neighbours upstream.
Deputy Bennett may rest assured that, even after we have done this, the law as it stood and to which he referred will be unchanged and the case cited will still be possible, if the necessity arises; and if any farmer is courageous enough to take his neighbour into court, he can still do so without let or hindrance.
Comment on this
That is all I want. I agree with the Parliamentary Secretary that advantage is not taken of the common law and that farmers are reluctant to proceed against one another in the courts. However, if the Parliamentary Secretary assures me that the right is still there, I am satisfied.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 135:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) Whenever a notice under the foregoing sub-section of this section has been served on a person, the following provisions shall apply and have effect, that is to say:—
(a) such person (in this sub-section referred to as the objector) may, within one month after the service of such notice on him, send to the commissioners an objection in writing to such notice;
(b) every such objection shall contain a full statement of the grounds on which the objection is based;
(c) the commissioners shall consider every such objection duly sent to them in accordance with the foregoing paragraphs of this sub-section and shall do, in respect of each such objection, whichever of the following things shall appear to them to be proper having regard to all the circumstances of the case and in particular whether compliance with the notice to which such objection relates would or would not cause undue hardship or expense to the objector, that is to say:—
(i) withdraw the said notice unconditionally, or
(ii) if the objector is willing to give to the commissioners a written undertaking (in a form approved of by the commissioners) that he will at all reasonable times permit any occupier from whose land water passes into the watercourse or any of the watercourses specified in the said notice to enter upon the objector's land and there do, at such occupier's own expense, all such things as may be necessary for compliance with the said notice, withdraw the said notice upon such undertaking being duly given by the objector, or
(iii) disallow such objection;
(d) whenever the commissioners disallow an objection, they shall amend the notice to which such objection relates by extending, for such period as they think proper, the period specified in such notice for compliance therewith;
(e) the commissioners shall as soon as may be inform the objector of their decision on his objection;
(f) whenever the commissioners disallow an objection, the objector may, within 14 days after being informed by the commissioners of their decision on such objection, require in writing the commissioners to refer his objection to an arbitrator appointed by the Reference Committee from the Panel of Drainage Arbitrators, and thereupon the commissioners shall so refer such objection;
(g) the arbitrator to whom an objection is referred under the next preceding paragraph of this sub-section shall have the like powers in regard to such objection as are conferred by this sub-section on the commissioners, and the decision of such arbitrator shall be final and conclusive.
Comment on this
The time will be the same as it was in regard to the original notice. We will allow for the time that will be taken up in the consideration of an appeal.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 136:—
In sub-section (2), to delete all from the word "the" in line 23 to the word "notice" in line 25, and substitute the words "this section on an occupier of land and has not been withdrawn by the commissioners or by the arbitrator and such occupier has failed to comply with such notice".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 137:—
In sub-section (3), line 33, to delete the words "sub-section (1) of".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 138:—
In sub-section (3), to insert in line 37 before the word "watercourses" the words "watercourse or" and to insert in line 38 before the word "them" the words "it or".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 139:—
In sub-section (4), lines 40 and 41, to delete the words "sub-section (1) of".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 142 should precede amendment No. 141, as it refers to the preceding section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 142:—
Before Section 49 to insert a new section as follows:—
Notwithstanding anything contained in the next preceding section of this Act it shall not be the responsibility of an occupier of land to restore, open up or generally put into effective condition or maintain an arterial drain and nothing contained in the said section shall relieve the commissioners or the county council, as the case may be, of such responsibility where a drainage scheme is in course of construction or maintenance under this Act.
This amendment relates to Section 48. I merely put in this safeguard to protect the individual again, so that the commissioners cannot compel him to do work which properly is a responsibility and duty of either the local authority or the commissioners themselves. You can envisage a situation of an individual or group of individuals, where an injustice might be done by the commissioners through the operation of Section 48. Section 48 is a rather dangerous section, but we all agree that it is necessary. I am all for putting in the necessary safeguards. I think that a safeguard of this kind is necessary, and, consequently, I am moving the amendment.
Comment on this
I am not defining an arterial drain, but I do not want to give the commissioners power to compel a man to do arterial drainage.
Comment on this
The amendment says: "Notwithstanding anything contained in the next preceding section of this Act it shall not be the responsibility of an occupier of land to restore, open up or generally put into effective condition or maintain an arterial drain".
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary will go back to the discussion on Section 4, or some of the earlier sections, he will find that it is provided that the commissioners can carry out a scheme of arterial drainage. That puts the responsibility on the commissioners to do that. I am merely saying in this amendment that it is not the responsibility of an individual to do arterial drainage. I am not concerned as to who defines this. Why was not a definition given in the Bill?
Comment on this
Because it cannot be done. There is no need to have any argument about it now. This question was debated very fully earlier on the Committee Stage. I then referred the House to the paragraph in the report of the Drainage Commission which dealt with this matter. The Drainage Commission pointed out that much thought had been given to the matter by engineers and others who were interested, in an effort to define what an arterial drain was. All of them threw up their hands and said that a definition of it was impossible. In their report, the Drainage Commission recommended that the determination of drainage to be included in any scheme would have to be left to the engineers who were charged with the responsibility of designing a scheme. I cannot improve on what was their best effort, nor can I improve on the best efforts of those who, even prior to the setting up of that commission, made similar efforts to solve the same problem.
Comment on this
We are setting up a special drainage authority to carry out arterial drainage. In Section 48 we are giving special powers to that drainage authority to compel an individual, in certain circumstances, to clean up drains. I feel that the individual must be safeguarded, especially when you are giving the use of the instrument that we find developed in Section 48. I want to ensure that the individual will not be compelled to do work that belongs either to the local authority or to the commissioners. I do not think it is necessary to define what an arterial drain is. If the matter is disputed at any time the court will decide it, whether the particular drain in question is the responsibility of the local authority, the commissioners, or the individual, as the case may be. The commissioners will have the duty and the responsibility of carrying out arterial drainage.
Comment on this
Is the position this: that we are discussing a subject and do not know the meaning of the actual words we are using? We know what an artery is. What is an arterial drain? Could we have it in Irish? I say that with all respect to the Irish language.
Comment on this
On the Second Reading of the Bill I argued, in the case of a drainage scheme which was being carried out, that it could conceivably happen that a drain or a watercourse which needed repairs had been omitted from the scheme, and that it would be almost impossible for a small farmer to carry out that work if the responsibility were placed on him. The object of the amendment is to prevent such a thing happening. On the other hand, we do not want to go too far and say that if a little drain is left out of the scheme that the farmer concerned should not complete it. But where a watercourse or a drain had been left out, the completion of which would involve heavy expense, it would be unreasonable to ask a farmer to do it.
Comment on this
If the amendment were passed, would it not nullify completely the previous and several other sections already passed? Deputy Hughes cannot define what an arterial drain is. One can imagine all the controversy that would be aroused through the country if this amendment were inserted in the Bill. There would be a controversy going on all the time as to what was an arterial drain, what was a watercourse, and so on. You would find farmers calling every drop of water passing through their land an arterial drain. I do not think this is a serious amendment.
Comment on this
If the difficulty with Deputy Allen is the definition of an arterial drain, and if the Parliamentary Secretary is prepared to meet me, I am prepared to meet him by proposing to substitute for arterial drain "any drain properly the responsibility of the commissioners under this Act".
Comment on this
The court. That is what it is there for. The commissioners cannot be the final arbiters between an individual and themselves.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been fighting for arbitration for the last week, and now when we are giving it to him he wants something else. Deputies have been raising Cain about the fact that we refused arbitration and refused a court of appeal. We provide an arbitrator now and Deputies want something else.
Comment on this
An artery is, so to speak, a drain; a watercourse on the surface of the earth is, I suppose, an artery. It is rather confusing discussing arterial drainage when we do not know the meaning of the word "arterial".
Comment on this
There is nothing to prevent him operating that section in his capacity as arbitrator.
Comment on this
There is nothing to prevent the court from doing the same. Is not it the same thing? You want an appeal to a court and there you have an arbitrator.
Comment on this
You can leave it to the arbitrator as it is. All the security one could reasonably want is provided in the section. It is not for the sake of opposing you that I take up this attitude, but Deputies should be reasonable.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 141:—
Before Section 49, page 32, to insert a new section as follows:—
49.—(1) Any Minister of State or any council of a county may at any time make to the commissioners a representation (in this section referred to as an originating representation) in writing claiming—
(a) that it is essential for the improvement by drainage of specified land, situate, in the case of a representation by a Minister of State, anywhere in the State or, in the case of a representation by the council of a county, anywhere in that county, either that a specified existing watercourse delineated on a map attached to the representation and not included in any existing drainage works or any drainage works executed or proposed to be executed under this Act be restored, opened up, or generally put into proper repair and effective condition or that a new watercourse be constructed in a position delineated on a map attached to the representation, and
(b) that the money required to meet the cost of the work of restoring, opening up, or generally putting into proper repair and effective condition the existing watercourse mentioned in the representation or of constructing the new watercourse similarly mentioned (as the case may be) has been provided, and
(c) that the execution of the said work is being impeded or prevented solely by reason of the unreasonable withholding by any owner or occupier of land traversed by the existing watercourse or the proposed new watercourse (as the case may be) mentioned in the representation of his consent to the execution of the said work.
(2) Every originating representation shall set out fully the names and postal addresses of all owners or occupiers of land (in this section referred to as the objecting parties) who are stated therein to be unreasonably withholding their consent to the work mentioned in such representation.
(3) As soon as may be after the receipt by the commissioners of an originating representation, the commissioners shall serve personally or by post on every objecting party named in such representation a notice in writing setting out the claims made in such representation and stating that such objecting party may, within one month after the service of such notice on him, send to the commissioners all (if any) such observations as he may think proper to make in regard to the said claims.
(4) The commissioners shall consider every observation sent to them by an objecting party within the time limited in that behalf by the next preceding sub-section of this section and may, if they so think proper in respect of any particular observation, cause an inspection to be made by one of their officers of the land owned or occupied by the objecting party who sent such observation and of the land specified in the originating representation to which such observation relates and of the existing watercourse or the site of the proposed new watercourse (as the case may be) mentioned in such representation.
(5) If none of the objecting parties named in an originating representation sends to the commissioners, within the time limited in that behalf by such representation, any observation in regard to the claims made by such representation or if the commissioners, after considering all such observations sent to them within the said time and considering the report of their officer making such (if any) inspection as aforesaid in respect of such observations or any of them are satisfied that the work mentioned in such representation (with such additions, omissions, and variations (if any) as the commissioners may deem necessary or expedient) are essential for the improvement by drainage of the land specified in such representation, and that the money required to meet the cost of such work (with such additions, omissions, and variations as aforesaid) has been provided, and that no substantial injury or damage will be caused to any objecting party by the execution of such work (with such additions, omissions, and variations as aforesaid), it shall be lawful for the commissioners to make an order (in this section referred to as a compulsory drainage order) authorising the execution of the work mentioned in such representation by or on behalf of the Minister or the council (as the case may be) by whom such representation was made.
(6) As soon as may be after making a compulsory drainage order the commissioners shall—
(a) notify the Minister or the council (as the case may be) who made the originating representation pursuant to which such order was made of the making of such order, and
(b) serve personally or by post on every objecting party named in such originating representation a copy of such order sealed with the seal of the commissioners.
(7) A compulsory drainage order shall operate to empower the Minister or the council (as the case may be) who made the originating representation pursuant to which such order was made to enter by himself or themselves or his or their officers, servants, or agents upon the land specified in such representation (including land owned or occupied by objecting parties named in such representation) and there do by himself or themselves or his or their officers, servants, or agents all such things as may be necessary for the execution of the work mentioned in such order.
(8) No action or other proceeding for damages, compensation, or otherwise shall lie against a Minister of State or the council of a county or any of his or their officers, servants, or agents for or in respect of anything done by him or them or any of them in the execution of work authorised by or the exercise of a power conferred by a compulsory drainage order save only if and so far as it may be shown that such work was not executed or such power was not exercised in a reasonable and workmanlike manner.
(9) Every person who—
(a) wilfully obstructs a Minister of State or the council of a county or any of his or their officers, servants, or agents in the execution of work authorised by or the exercise of a power conferred by a compulsory drainage order, or
(b) pulls down, removes, or injures any work or any part of any work executed or in course of execution under a compulsory drainage order, or
(c) obstructs in any way the flow of water to, through, or from any work executed under a compulsory drainage order,
shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding £50 or, at the discretion of the court, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months, or to both such fine and such imprisonment, and shall also be liable, in the case of a continuing offence, to a fine not exceeding £5 for every day during which the offence is continued.
Section 48 is somewhat limiting inasmuch as it only refers to drains and streams within a drainage district or entering a drainage district. One can conceive many cases in which the obstruction might exist in a drain that was not in a district or immediately emptying into a district, and it is for the purpose of giving a local authority or a Department of State power to deal with an obstructor in that particular type of case that we propose this new section.
Comment on this
I have not grasped the significance of the new section. I must say the Parliamentary Secretary has not made himself clear on it.
Comment on this
I thought I did. In Section 48 we are limited inasmuch as we can only take action against an individual in relation to a stream that is within a drainage district or immediately emptying into a drainage district. The Deputy will realise that there could be small streams that would not contact a drainage district at all and Section 48 would not give us the power in such a case. Therefore, this new Section 49 is necessary and it gives us more or less the same power to proceed against an individual or individuals who would be obstructing any work that might be found necessary.
Comment on this
Take, for instance, a rural improvement scheme or minor employment scheme, where a group of farmers would come together and be prepared to pay a contribution of 25 per cent. in order to have a small drainage scheme carried out and where they would be obstructed. In that case the Department responsible for giving the assistance could make an originating application and proceed to deal with the obstructor as set out.
Comment on this
It is to cover almost exclusively farm improvement or rural improvement schemes—that is what you mean by "moneys already provided from some other source"?
Comment on this
It is a rather serious penalty for an offence that would not be a serious offence. A man might feel he had legitimate cause for the obstruction.
Comment on this
You must have a penalty and that penalty does not seem unreasonable in most cases that I know.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 144:—
In sub-section (5) to delete paragraph (a), lines 42-44.
I did not move amendment No. 143 although there is an objectionable feature in the section in regard to local authorities, but I consider it not unreasonable that they should have consultation with the commissioners and have plans approved. I move amendment No. 144 because we find in the section—paragraph (a) of sub-section (5)—"if such person is a local authority, such claim shall be referred to the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, whose decision thereon shall be final." Why on earth should the commissioners refuse to public authorities the right to arbitration? Why should the public authority expect to have a dispute between themselves and the commissioners referred to the Minister for Local Government from whom there shall be no appeal?
I think the local authorities are having so much responsibility passed on to them that they should not be deprived of some of the functions of responsibility. If they feel it necessary to construct any such bridge, having done so in consultation with the commissioners and having accepted plans approved by the commissioners, and if eventually there is any alleged default, the claim can only be referred to the Minister for Local Government. Why should local authorities be pilloried in this measure? If that is a criterion of what will happen in future, I think it is a very poor look-out. I see no justification for that clause, and I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to delete paragraph (a) of sub-section (5) as being perfectly unjustifiable. I do not see any sound grounds for having it in the Bill at all. I move to report progress.