In Committee on Finance. - Local Government Bill, 1945—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–126 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 32 of 1945 ›
My opposition to this amendment comes entirely from the point of view that it reinforces what I regard as the rather dictatorial attitude and atmosphere of the County Management Act. The Department of Local Government is intimately associated with the lives of the people. It is concerned with their security and welfare, if you like, more intimately than any other Department and in these circumstances I think it ought to be altogether removed from anything in the nature of political atmosphere. Matters ought to be dealt with entirely on their merits. It is from that point of view that I approach this subject. I regard local government and public health as commencing in the Custom House and reacting right down through the State, and local authorities, their officials and the Department ought to act in the closest possible co-operation and ought to deal with every question sympathetically and on its merits. Due regard must be paid to the attitude of the people and their capacity to pay.
Bringing into that anything in the nature of a dictatorial attitude, as was referred to last night by other Deputies —an attitude typifying Hitlerism, a name I do not like mentioning—is, in my opinion, entirely out of place. The Minister last night allowed his imagination free rein on the terrible things that would happen the local authorities and the people depending on them, the afflicted and the destitute, if local authorities did not do their duty. I have had many years' association with local authorities and I have never known any of them to deal with public affairs in any but a sympathetic and generous way. The biggest item in connection with local government is road maintenance. Here, I think, there is plenty of room for difference of opinion, and plenty of room for misunderstanding. I suppose I would not be strictly in order——
Comment on this
I think I am reinforced in my attitude in view of the Minister's statement last night, which was not entirely confined to the merits of the amendment but rather covered all the activities of local authorities. There is one bone of contention which gives plenty of room for the opposition of local authorities and plenty of room for compromise and co-operation. I regard road maintenance as one of the most difficult things to handle, from the point of view of both the Department and the local authorities. If you cast your minds back you will see how well sustained was the opposition of many local authorities to the huge expenditure involved. You can visualise the position in this country before the advent of mechanical transport.
Comment on this
That is going too far back. The Deputy must not discuss road maintenance and the upkeep of the roads.
Comment on this
If you allow me to develop it a little, I will get away from it immediately. These roads were built by local authorities entirely for local use. They have gradually developed into national highways for mechanical transport, and, by reason of that mechanical transport, these roads have been entirely destroyed. An enormous revenue, however, has been derived from this mechanical transport and one would think that these roads would be entitled to these revenues, or at least to a substantial portion of them.
Comment on this
The Deputy is on a very broad road now when he is proposing to deal with trunk roads.
Comment on this
I imagine that the Minister did not deal with the financing of the upkeep of these roads.
Comment on this
He dealt with activities in relation to the roads and I am dealing with the reasons for my opposition to this amendment. I am trying to deal with this matter not on the basis of making any reflection on the Ministry, or of gaining any political kudos, but from the point of view of getting straight at what the difficulty is and of ascertaining if ways and means can be found to get over it. I am pointing out that the great difficulty we have at present is the financing of these roads and suggesting that there ought to be a compromise by the State. In our opinion, if the State had subscribed its just and equitable amount towards these roads, the conflict of opinion between the Ministry and the local authorities would never have arisen. The difficulty has not arisen in relation to the orthodox duty of local authorities to look after the afflicted and destitute. It has arisen, and the necessity for all these dictatorial powers has arisen, in relation to the financing of these services.
Comment on this
The Deputy is straying too far in trying to introduce a debate on whether they should be financed from the Central Fund or not. That is outside this amendment.
Comment on this
It could be interpreted in that way, but that is not the intention of the Deputy. The intention of the Deputy is to see that if this cause of irritation can be allayed or modified, it will be allayed or modified. I am pointing out what the opinion of local authorities is. If, however, you, Sir, debar me from dealing with the financial aspect, let me deal with the administrative aspect. By this amendment, the Minister is taking power to compel local authorities to face any expenditure, not on what they think, but on what he thinks. The council of which I have the honour to be a member received a letter on 15th December last from the Minister's Department practically demanding, although not in so many words, that it should raise a sum of £308,000 for bitumen and tar. Add that amount to an estimate well over £1,000,000 for county administration and you can clearly visualise that there is plenty of room for compromise between the Ministry and the local authority. On the finance side, the Minister has revenue of well over £1,000,000 and possibly five times that amount in motor taxation. I know that the Minister's answer to the statement by us that he has taken practically £1,000,000 out of the Road Fund in the last nine years, leaving it altogether to the local authorities to finance it, will be that he gives it back in other ways. Again, I come in conflict with the Minister.
Comment on this
I am afraid that I am in conflict with the Deputy. If the Deputy is permitted to deal with these matters, 50 Deputies may follow him on the administration and financing of road maintenance and the debate would go very far beyond the measure and particularly beyond what is before us, amendment 31a, which contains nothing about roads.
Comment on this
The point is that if a local authority sees its way to reduce the amount of money which it is required to provide, the Minister takes power under this amendment to suppress that body if it does not mend its hand, completely ignoring public representatives and the opinions they were elected to express on behalf of the people. Quite recently the Minister, in his advocacy of the Managerial Act, stated that control of finance was entirely reserved to the local authority, but now we find that if, in the opinion of the county surveyor, sufficient money is not provided, his only duty is to inform the county manager that it is insufficient. The local authority's action thereupon becomes non-effective and it then becomes a matter entirely between the county surveyor and the Minister to fix whatever they think ought to be the expenditure on roads, irrespective of the opinion of those most in touch with the matter of the capacity of the people to bear it.
I am not allowed to develop my argument on the lines on which I should like to develop it, but I put it to the Minister whether, if we refuse to act on his letter of 15th December in which he requires us to raise £308,000 for one commodity alone, added to our ordinary expenditure of well over £1,000,000, if we compromise on it and try to provide the money in other ways, the Minister can invoke this amendment and say to the council: "You do as I tell you, or I will dissolve you". Surely we should not have to submit to powers of that kind and surely we are entitled to oppose this amendment which accentuates the power which the Minister already has.
I have been for a long number of years connected with local authorities and I do not deny that I have taken a very deep interest in their financing. I am pretty conversant with everything done in the last 20 years. Up to the passing of the Managerial Act, attention was always paid to local opinion and local opinion was effective in matters of local government. I must say that, in my long association with public bodies, I never got anything but sympathetic and reasonable treatment, the merits of every question being reasonably dealt with, but under the Managerial Act, reinforced by this amendment, the power is entirely taken out of their hands and it now becomes a mechanical device. Local authorities are to be told: "Our technical experts say that so and so is necessary and I make this Order. If you do not comply with it, there is nothing for me to do but to dissolve you and to compel the county surveyor and manager to carry out my will." That is a very drastic power to have.
I opposed the Managerial Act on the ground that, as time went on, it would dissociate public opinion from its own interests, and we are gradually reaching a position in which we will have government from the Custom House and government from this House, with no public representatives in between.
Every action of the Minister and every amendment of this kind is, in my opinion, calculated to lead to the suppression of the local body's opinion. I would remind the Minister that one of the most valuable things in this country is the interest which the local people take in their own affairs. That ought to be encouraged, because without it local administration cannot be carried out efficiently. I submit that the less the Minister interferes apart, of course, from seeing that things are properly done, the better it will be for all concerned. I started my speech by urging that there should be the closest co-operation between the Department of Local Government and local authorities. There should be between them a pooling of their very best efforts in the interests of the people they serve. The Department, on its part, should make every endeavour to lessen the liabilities of local authorities by demanding from the Minister for Finance, or the Government, as much of the moneys derived from road taxation as justice would demand. That would be one way of helping our local authorities. At the moment, I am not at liberty, under the ruling given by the Chair, to develop that point further, but I do submit that there is that obligation on the Department of Local Government: to see that the sums which are justly due to local authorities, and which are derived from the revenues that I have referred to, are paid over to them. In that way, the Minister would be doing his part in trying to lessen the liabilities that fall on local authorities, and ultimately on the ratepayers.
The Minister may think it wise to link up the various public services under the arbitrary powers that he is proposing to take in this amendment, to bring them to the highest point of perfection, while ignoring altogether the opinions of the local authorities. I would remind him that there is a limit to human endurance, and to the people's capacity to pay. It may be that, under what one may describe as this method of mechanical dictation, we will arrive at the time when we will have the most perfect services and the most perfect roads, but will we have the people there to enjoy them? You can squeeze the public, and, under duress, the rates may reach such a point that it will be impossible for the people to pay them. The Minister should take care that, under the Managerial Act, as amended by this amendment, the people who will have to pay the money necessary for the carrying on of those services are not forgotten. There may be in the Department a disposition to bring those services up to the very highest point. That may also be the disposition of the officials—county surveyors and managers—but it must never be forgotten that it is the people who will have to pay. Their primary interest is to get an opportunity to live and to earn the moneys that are necessary for the financing of all those services. There is the old saying that it is the last straw that breaks the camel's back. I would advise the Minister to consider this matter seriously before he invokes the powers that he is taking in this amendment.
As I have already said, I have been in public life for a long time. During all the period that I have been a member of public boards, I have never allowed anything to influence my decision on matters that came before me except the merits of the question at issue. I have always regarded a close association between the Department of Local Government and the local representatives of the people as an essential to the efficient working of our local government administration. At the same time, I want to say that I shall always oppose any arbitrary or dictatorial proposal which would take power out of the people's hands and place it in that of an individual. I believe that in all public matters public opinion is entitled to be consulted. Therefore, I am very strongly opposed to the efforts of the Minister to try centralise power in himself, irrespective of the wishes of the people and their representatives.
Comment on this
I suppose I feel myself rather at a disadvantage in venturing to follow, in this debate, a Deputy of the experience of Deputy Broderick. It would be a good thing indeed for this House if all Deputies, and particularly those on the Opposition Benches, would follow the example set by Deputy Broderick—the calm and dignified manner in which, from his point of view, he has put his case. I want to say that, having listened to the debate here last evening, I was rather disappointed this morning that we had not flash headlines in the daily papers, proclaiming a split, from top to bottom, in the Fianna Fáil Party. Various speakers on the Opposition Benches commented on the fact that members of the Fianna Fáil Party had the courage of their convictions by standing up in this House to express views different from those held by the Minister. I would remind the Deputies of all Parties, my own included, that that is the kernel of democracy.
Comment on this
It would be a good thing for the Deputies on the Opposition Benches if they had had as much democracy in their organisation, from its inception, as we have in ours. We have the right to have our opinions. We make decisions in our organisation, and these decisions being made, majority rule counts and all abide by them. I want to assure the members of the Opposition Party that last evening they discovered a mare's nest. Fianna Fáil is the premier Party in this country to-day, and will be for many years to come, judging from the form which Deputies on the Opposition have shown in this debate, in particular.
I want to say that, so far as amendment No. 31a and its subsidiary sections are concerned, I have no fears at all about them, and will have no qualms of conscience in supporting them when it comes to the time for giving support. I am old enough to remember, having taken part in the establishment of Fianna Fáil, that away back in 1932— this, a Chinn Comhairle has a direct bearing upon my reference—if we had this piece of legislation in operation in 1932 many of the delays which took place and prevented the people of this country from enjoying the benefits that the then new Government provided for them, would not, in fact, have occurred.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy ought to know that. He had responsibility for many years, and we know what we got from him. If it pleases Deputy Mulcahy, I can take these out of their chronological order. I will take as No. 1, the housing of the people. I ask the leader of the Opposition to contrast his services to the people of this country, in the matter of housing them, with the housing achievements of Fianna Fáil from 1932 to 1938.
Comment on this
I am basing my reasons for supporting this amendment on these grounds and I have no other good grounds than these and I think it is very relevant.
Comment on this
Very revealing for the Deputy and rather disappointing for him, I am quite sure. We had water schemes, sewerage schemes, road schemes, improved hospitalisation, free meals schemes and free milk.
Comment on this
Free beef, when necessary. It did not go to loss.
Comment on this
In addition to that, we had tuberculosis services. Later, we had turf schemes.
Comment on this
Yesterday Deputy Morrissey drew the attention of this House to the fact that there was an increase of 45 per cent. in rateable taxation on the local authorities since Fianna Fáil came into office. I suggest that Deputy Morrissey, when he goes down to Tipperary for the week-end, should tell the people of Tipperary that he was opposed and is still opposed to the provision of all these social services for the people of this country. That is what Deputy Morrissey's objection and protest here yesterday amounted to. He was protesting against the increased social services which were provided for the plain people of this country from 1932 to date.
Comment on this
No. That will be my business. When I have finished I will pass on.
Comment on this
There is one important thing the Deputy is omitting. Fianna Fáil gave the people more room because they got 38,000 men who were working on the land off the land.
Comment on this
And the 136,000 that you paid to leave this country, who did not leave voluntarily. The Fianna Fáil Government never paid gratuities, as you did, for your henchmen, to get them out of this country.
Comment on this
I would be glad if Opposition Deputies would address the Chair. Then I would conform to it.
Comment on this
To return to 1932 again. I am quite satisfied the Opposition do not want to hear anything of these things.
Comment on this
They used three pieces of machinery in this country in order to block the progress of Fianna Fáil's democratic government. To begin with, the law courts, to bring our Government into contempt.
Comment on this
The only thing that was brought into contempt was the draftsmanship of the Deputy's Attorney-General.
Comment on this
I have no hesitation whatever in supporting the amendment. My only regret is that the Minister for Local Government did not have this power many years ago. During the emergency there was an Emergency Powers Order issued empowering local authorities to strike an additional rate if they found it necessary. We heard no protest against that. There came a circular letter intimating to us that we had to provide for A.R.P. services and such other national emergency services and that if we found it necessary we had only to make provision for an additional rate which could have been collected. I want to know what is the great objection to giving the Minister this power now, seeing that he already has power to suspend local public bodies if he so wishes. That is, of course, another stick in the hands of the Opposition, as they think, wherewith to wallop Fianna Fáil, but the more of that we get the more these people expose themselves and, so far as I am concerned, the more welcome it will be.
I hope that when Deputy Morrissey returns to Tipperary he will tell the people there that he is not now in favour of the provision of those social services or other schemes such as I hope the Government will attempt in the near future, the provision of roads, housing accommodation for the people, and other such schemes. I, for one, will have no hesitation in supporting this amendment when it comes to a division.
Comment on this
Deputy Walsh gave a good deal of advice to Deputy Morrissey as to what he was to do and say when he got back to Tipperary in the week-end. I wonder will the people of Drogheda realise that when Deputy Walsh spoke to an important amendment he hardly said a word concerning the amendment. There was a great deal about what was done in 1932 and before that. I should like to say, not necessarily to the Deputy who last spoke, but to many other Deputies who keep harping back to what was done and what was not done in the past, that there is a generation in Ireland more interested in 1946 and onwards than they are in what was not done 15, 16 or 12 or 13 years ago. What we are concerned with, strange as it may appear, is amendment No. 31 (a). I want to say a few words about that. These particular points may have been mentioned by other Deputies but it seems to me that the kernel of the amendment is that if it appears to the Minister that a rate is likely to be insufficient to maintain the public services at a reasonable standard, after the Minister has held a local inquiry into the sufficiency of such a rate, various things may happen which I do not think any democratic people can view with any great pleasure as happening to them or to their lawfully elected representatives, that is, the local authority are to be dissolved if they refuse to carry out the behests of the Minister as made manifest by the local inquiry.
The Minister made a speech last night. Judged from a debating point of view, it was an excellent speech. He made an excellent case for himself, but he did not make an excellent case for amendment No. 31 (a). The gist of his remarks was that a local authority was to be given power to mend its hand if it had taken an ill-judged or misguided action. This amendment does not say that power is to be given to the local authority to mend its hand. This amendment proposes that power is to be given to the Minister to force the authority to carry out something which they, in possession of local knowledge, do not wish to carry out. That is the kernel of the amendment. The Minister tries to say that the local body will be given that power, but the amendment says that the Minister is to be given that power. Then the Minister says: "Oh, I have always had that power. There is nothing new in this." If he has always had that power, what on earth has he put in this amendment for? He cannot have it both ways. If he has the power why is he putting in amendment No. 31 (a)? The Minister has already very great powers for dealing with local bodies. He can dissolve them and hold local inquiries of various sorts. I do not wish to go into the ramifications of some of the local inquiries held recently, but the Minister, at least, will admit that they have caused a good deal of trouble, even if he is not prepared to admit the justice of the claims made by the people concerned. We are now asked to pass an amendment which gives the Minister power to hold a local inquiry after it appears to him that a rate is likely to be "insufficient". To understand fully the meaning of that sub-section one would want to be a mind reader. Even the Minister cannot tell a year hence what is likely to be insufficient to meet the situation, and then a local inquiry is to be held on the narrow issue of the sufficiency of the rate. There is not a word about the advisability of such a charge. Certain local authorities have recently had a good deal of bother with the Custom House authorities on the question of hospital charges.
I wonder if this amendment is being put in at this stage to deal with something that might be likely to arise in future in connection with hospitalisation. The phrase "any other body" is a very wide one and might mean many things. I do not think it is defined in the definition section.
Comment on this
There are many bodies and numbers of them are outside the jurisdiction of what I might call the county area. Under that a local authority might be asked to provide for any body outside their area. I do not wish to labour that point too much. This amendment has been very widely discussed, but I do not think it possible to discuss it too often, because an enormous number of points arise out of it. Before closing I should like to mention that the amendment has been brought in on the Committee Stage of the Bill. I am not attempting to criticise the wisdom of that. That is a matter for other people, but it is certainly a rather extraordinary amendment to bring in at this stage. I wonder it was not there when the Bill was on the stocks, because it is very far-reaching and claims considerably more than is contained in present local government practice. I wonder why such a brilliant idea did not occur until now, and for that reason I think the Minister ought to give us an explanation of the grounds for it. In conjunction with other members of my Party, and with a considerable number of the Fianna Fáil Party, I view this amendment with the very greatest alarm. I trust the Minister will withdraw it.
Comment on this
I join with other Deputies who are opposed to this amendment in appealing to the Minister to withdraw it. I was surprised at Deputy Walsh advocating the necessity of having it in a Local Government Bill, considering that the Government Party has at present control of all local bodies in Éire. Am I to take it that since the last election those who have been elected think it necessary to have this new section in the Bill put into operation to compel them to carry out the Minister's orders? When Deputies ask why this amendment is brought in, I am rather suspicious that a county not very far away is responsible. Even Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches will agree that if other counties were in a similar position they would act in the same way. County Wicklow is a tourist county with a very energetic county engineer. The majority of the county council are Labour men. The raising of a rate of £93,000 was suggested for main roads on a three years' plan. The council adjourned the matter in order to inquire from the Government what their intentions were, and what grants they were going to give for post-war schemes. The raising of that amount of money required in County Wicklow would mean an extra rate of 5/- in the £, apart from increased demands for the maintenance of the mental hospital, the board of public assistance, vocational education, as well as other expenditure. Notwithstanding the fact that for the last six years they have been allocating practically the same amount of money for the roads, expenditure in County Wicklow last year was reduced by 3d. in the £. It was suggested later that £10,000 should be provided for the purchase of tar and the money was raised. I want to know from the Minister what his Department proposes to do in that connection.
The County Council of Wicklow started to build a coast road to the Silver Strand and, with the approval of the Government, spent money out of the rates on that project, but they found afterwards that a public body cannot incur expenditure of that kind unless there is a grant from the Government. For the past few years the Government left that road to be dealt with as a post-war measure. I should like to know when the council will be allowed to complete the reconstruction of the road. It was for that reason that the county council deferred consideration of the engineer's estimate. Am I to take it that the Minister wants power in this Bill to deal with a county council who, by a majority, refused to strike a rate which they thought would be an exorbitant demand in view of the increased cost of social services? If, instead of having a three-year plan, it was recommended that it should be a six-year plan and that the rate in the £ should be reduced correspondingly, would the Minister then send down an inspector of his Department who would be one of the Department's engineers? The Department's engineers have very powerful influence. This inspector and engineer would be in favour of having the roads perfect and he would maintain that we had not struck a rate sufficient to keep the roads in a reasonable state of repair. There would be no appeal from that. The engineer would support his county colleague in the view that the council has failed in its duty in striking an inadequate rate. That is why I say that public bodies are not getting a chance. They can appeal to nobody but the inspector holding the inquiry. Where a county council recognises that the estimated rate would be exorbitant, surely that council, representing all parties, and elected by the people, should be allowed to enjoy the power they possess on one day in the 52 weeks of the year. The county manager submits his estimates, and if the council give him the rate he seeks, they have no more power over officials or anybody else.
I have never been in favour of the Managerial Act. If this amendment be persisted in and if an engineer be sent down to hold an inquiry, it will not be possible to get in the rates. While the people are prepared to increase the rate for home assistance, mental hospitals and social services, they are not prepared to strike an exorbitant rate for the maintenance of roads until the Government reveals their plan for dealing with this question. The Government are not in a position on account of the condition of the Road Fund to notify the county councils of the amounts they are likely to receive in connection with road improvements. Our council asked the Minister to let them know what wages they were to pay road workers. They were prepared to increase the road estimate. There is a majority of Labour men on that county council. We object to the treatment of the road workers and we cannot understand why the county manager has recommended an increase of 11/- a week to men in receipt of £500 a year while the road workers' claims cannot be conceded. Notwithstanding the arguments of the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary, a public body must consider the welfare of the ratepayers. Councils are asked to strike a rate to meet increased bonus for officials, while the road workers cannot be given an increase of a few shillings a week. If Deputy Walsh was in a similar position, I do not think he would agree. I think that he would take up the same position that I am taking up. The case I have mentioned may be far-fetched, but the implications are there.
Without this amendment the Minister had power to hold an inquiry and remove a council which failed to provide funds for the county manager to enable him to carry on the social services. But a council may decide that the rate recommended by the county manager is exorbitant and that it would be better to spread the expenditure over a number of years. The council are best fitted to decide such a question. In our rate, £93,000 was provided for trunk roads and £31,000 for improvements. That was a huge bill for trunk roads and the council adjourned it and will continue to adjourn it until they get satisfaction. We recognise that the roads must be maintained in proper repair but we pointed out that our county was a tourist county and should get different treatment from that accorded other counties because buses are used on our roads and tourists from Dublin and elsewhere are travelling over them without leaving a lot of money in that area. In view of the increase in the yield of taxation by reason of the increase in the number of motorists, the Government should be able to strengthen the Road Fund and give money to public bodies to enable them to carry on road work. I do not sympathise with a public body which holds up social services. But before sanctioning an increased rate, a public body must satisfy itself that it will receive service for its money and must consider the ability of the people to meet the increase. In the case I brought up, has not the Minister power to abolish the council? I am sure that every public representative would support the views I put forward. If it is not the intention of the Minister to interfere with a public body, why is it necessary to bring in this amendment? The Minister has already the necessary powers. To make the Bill a workable Bill, the public representatives should be given responsibility. There should be some body to which they could appeal, which would decide, in such a case as I mentioned, what would be a reasonable rate. For the reasons I have mentioned, I oppose the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not think that Deputy Walsh was quite fair to himself. I am satisfied that the Deputy has a far greater knowledge of local government administration and local government law than one would gather from the speech he delivered here to-day. My colleague, Deputy Dockrell, pointed out that Deputy Walsh had not said anything about the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not think that Deputy Walsh believes in this amendment. We had a similar type of speech last night from Deputy M. O'Reilly. I am satisfied that Deputy Walsh and Deputy O'Reilly can see as far into this amendment as any other members of the House and I must come to the conclusion that, like the Minister, they are endeavouring to deceive not only themselves but the House. Does Deputy Walsh subscribe to the kernel of this amendment? What is the kernel of the amendment? If this amendment passes, the making of the rate will lie not with the local authority but with the Minister.
Comment on this
Deputy Walsh mentioned, as if it had a bearing on the subject, that, during the emergency, local authorities were given the right to impose additional rates. He added: "Why object to this amendment when you agreed to that?" Of course, the essential difference is that it was the local authority which had the right to impose the additional rate and not the Minister. Deputy Walsh spoke of many things that had nothing whatever to do with this amendment. He challenged me to go back to Tipperary and talk about social services. I do not want to issue a challenge, but I should like to see Deputy Walsh, ex-Mayor of Drogheda, going back to his colleagues in the Drogheda Corporation and attempting to justify his viewpoint that the Drogheda Corporation should not have the right to fix their own rate without the Minister's interference
Comment on this
They have not. It is bad enough when the Deputy tries to "cod" himself, but let him not try to "cod" the House as well. The fact is that, if this amendment becomes law, the local authority can only strike a rate if it satisfies the Minister, not if it satisfies the local authority.
Comment on this
If it is, why is it necessary to pass this amendment? Let me put this question to Deputy Walsh: if that is the present position why do we want this amendment?
Comment on this
To compel people to do their duty. They had to be compelled already, for instance, in the case of County Dublin and County Cork.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy make up his mind one way or another? The Deputy said that the Minister had power already to do anything that he may do under this amendment; now he says the Minister requires power to compel them to do it.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation, Deputy Walsh did not say anything of the kind. Deputy Walsh referred to the powers which the Minister had already.
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy has now made himself perfectly clear to everybody in the House. I can understand the Deputy's difficulty. It is very hard to speak against one's own knowledge or one's own conviction and I fully appreciate the delicate position in which the Deputy finds himself. The Deputy is acting against his knowledge of local affairs and of the conduct of local affairs. The Deputy spoke about people losing their sense of dignity but if any Government, other than the present one, dared to introduce an amendment such as this and Deputy Walsh was in opposition to that Government, mind you I have a fairly powerful voice, but it would not hold a candle to the resounding tones which the Deputy would roll off in condemning that amendment and he can be fairly effective when he likes in that way.
I want to put this view to members of this House, even to Deputy Everett, Deputy Broderick and some other members on this side. This amendment has nothing to do with the position of local authorities up to the present. It is not intended to meet anything that is there at the moment. It is to meet a situation which the Minister has in mind for the future. The only reason I mentioned 46 per cent. of an increase was to show, as I said, that local authorities were satisfied to strike a rate, even a rate which showed 46 per cent. of an increase, to meet their normal obligations but the Minister intends to impose obligations on local authorities that were never imposed on them before, to give them fresh duties and to put other expenses upon them. The local authorities are going to be compelled to pay for, and to raise rates to meet, services which they have no say themselves in establishing, which will be established, not by the local authority, but by the Minister. The Minister will not only establish services or institutions; he will assign, when he knows how much these services will cost, what is to be paid by the local authority. It is not the local authority that will decide that. One of the remarkable things about the Public Health Bill at present before the House is that we have got no indication from the Minister or anybody else as to what it is going to cost.
Comment on this
I beg your pardon, Sir. I am keeping far closer to the amendment than any Deputy who has spoken so far.
Comment on this
I agree that I should not waste any time in replying to the Minister but I did not get as far away as the Minister in his flights of fancy. He accused us last night of advocating that local authorities should refuse to obey the law, of trying to bring about chaos, and he said that nobody could do it better. Talk about being fantastic ! Deputy MacEntee holds——
Comment on this
——the record in that respect in his description of the opposition to his amendment. "Members on the opposite benches are going to bring us to the verge of civil war." If there was anything more fantastic ever said by any member on my side of the House, I should like to hear it. Of course it only goes to show, when the Minister talks in that way, that like Deputy Walsh, he can say nothing in support of the amendment. Does any member of the House who has been a member of a local authority conscientiously trying to do his best in all the circumstances to provide for services, to cut out waste and extravagance— does any member of this House who has any knowledge of local government, as Deputy Corish said last night, want to see the last remaining bit of power left in the hands of local authorities removed? Remember when you pass this you cannot say that you have a right to strike a rate. You have a right to strike only a rate that will satisfy the Minister.
Let me put this point to Deputies, particularly those who are members of local councils. If and when this Bill becomes law county managers, in order to safeguard themselves against the Department and the Minister, will of necessity bring in inflated estimates so that there will not be the remotest possibility of a shortage in the amount provided for public services, not even the remotest possibility of resorting to anything in the nature of a supplementary estimate or a loan to cover up a gap. If the manager brings in an inflated estimate which, in the light of their experience, appears to the local authority—and mind you there can be complete unanimity on a local authority—as an unduly inflated estimate, the members of the local authority have no power to reduce it. If they do the Minister will hold an inquiry and immediately direct them to increase the figure to at least the amount asked for by the county manager.
The Minister has said that he can only act after a local inquiry. I want to say quite frankly that the local inquiry is all "bosh". What is the machine that operates? The inspector at the local inquiry has the thought in his mind that naturally the Minister has reason to believe that the estimate struck is not sufficient. The Minister directs the local inquiry to be held. The Minister himself selects the inspector to hold that inquiry. The inspector knows that he is going down to that particular county or town because the Minister is not satisfied that a sufficient rate has been struck. The inquiry is held and the inspector, on the evidence tendered, drafts his report, but there is this difference between the procedure and what happens in any ordinary tribunal or court. Nobody but the Minister himself can see the recommendation made by the inspector or will be allowed to see it. On the undisclosed report of the inspector the Minister can there and then remove the local authority from office. If there is anybody who has knowledge at all of local administration and who wants to defend this amendment, I should like him to try to meet some of those points. I am totally opposed to this amendment for many reasons, not the least of which is that I cannot see anybody, who is genuinely interested in local government, allowing his name to go forward for election to a local body if and when this becomes law. I cannot conceive of anybody with a sense of his responsibility and his duty to the people going forward for election, knowing that he has no power, and knowing that once you strike a rate you are finished. Whatever happens after that is in the hands of the county manager.
The Minister, on numerous occasions in the past, gave as a justification for the County Management Act the reason that, in the ultimate, the local authority had the power to strike the rate, and that nobody else had that power; but that power is now being destroyed by this amendment. Let me say this to Deputy Walsh, in connection with his remarks about social services: I do not know of any public authority in this country that has refused to make adequate provision for whatever social services were passed by this House—I do not know of even one. I do, however, know this: that local authorities in this country were prepared to increase the rate—not to reduce it, but to increase it—in order to do some slight measure of justice to their employees, by increasing the wages of road workers and similar employees by, say, 5/- a week, but the Minister put his foot down and would not allow that. That does not show that there is a desire on the part of the local authorities to increase the rates except for the purpose of doing justice.
Let me say, in conclusion, that this amendment is brought in, not because the Minister thinks that the local authorities will refuse to strike a rate in order to face their ordinary obligations or any obligations that may be placed on them up to the moment, but because, as is well known, the Minister's Department, as well as other Departments, have in mind schemes for the development of which the Minister proposes to make local authorities pay a substantial part of the cost. Let me mention one other matter. The Minister has prepared a very ambitious road scheme for this country. I shall not go into the merits or otherwise of that scheme, but it is a very ambitious scheme. We understand that some of these roads will be almost as wide as the Phoenix Park; that there will be roads running this way and that, one portion of them for cyclists, the other for motorists, and so on. Indeed, the scheme is so ambitious that it might appear that half the arable land of the country will be taken over for that purpose. However, I should like to know what proportion of the costs of these roads will be placed on the local authorities. Let me remind Deputies, in that connection, that for a number of years the Government raided the Road Fund; even in prewar years something like £100,000 was "lifted" by the Government out of that fund every year.
Now, we are not opposing this amendment merely for the sake of opposing it. We are opposing it because it is introducing a tremendously dangerous principle, and I am perfectly satisfied that if the members of this House cannot induce the Minister to change his mind on this matter, they will regret it, and regret it very bitterly. Once this is passed, the position will be that it is the Minister who strikes the rate, and not the local authority, unless the local authority strikes a rate which the Minister wants, and then the county manager operates it. If that is what Deputies want, then I think it is only fair for them to say that this whole thing should be administered from the Custom House through the county managers, and not have this camouflage—because that is all it is— of bringing men a distance of ten, 20 and even 40 miles to attend meetings of county councils, and a somewhat shorter distance for urban councils, merely to have typewritten documents put before them by the county manager, not one word of which they have power to alter. I think that any right-thinking, honest man would object to such a sham, and that is the reason that I say we should not pass this amendment, and I hope that the Minister will be persuaded to change his mind.
Comment on this
As a member of the Wexford County Council, I should like to join with other Deputies who have spoken on this matter. I have been in public life in that county since 1934. We had elections in 1942, and a county manager was put in, costing the ratepayers for salary and expenses a large amount of money per year. At our meeting last Monday, Deputy Allen, who is chairman of the Wexford County Council, reduced the estimate for the county manager, and, as far as I can see, under this section, the Minister can come along and dissolve the Wexford County Council. Deputy Allen, as well as other members of the Fianna Fáil Party, spoke here against this amendment, and if we go to a division I hope they will be in the House to vote against it, because they know that it is wrong. Under the county managerial system, the rates were passed in County Wexford without any talk about how the manager was going to spend the money. He spent £500 over a number of years sowing apple trees on the public roads instead of putting out materials on those roads, and we could say nothing. On several occasions, members of that county council—a big majority of them—agreed to increase the road workers' wages from 39/-, and one member of that county council—a Fianna Fáil member—proposed that they be given an extra 1/-, to bring the wage up to the agricultural wages standard. That proposal was sent up to the Department—at least we were told so—but the Minister refused to sanction those 12 extra coppers. We had elections last June, costing the county council £2,000, and costing the urban council £100. The people there elected 21 people. When we go down to Wexford and ask that certain things should be done we are told that this is an executive function, that we have no say in the matter, and that it is a matter for the county manager. They spent the whole day last Monday, from 1 o'clock until 4——
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is discussing the County Management Act, generally, instead of the specific matters contained in this amendment.
Comment on this
We did not come to the discussion of the section yet. This is an amendment to the section.
Comment on this
Well, I submit that that is what the amendment does. It gives power to the Minister to abolish the county council.
Comment on this
I submit that if the county council made an estimate, and even cut it down, still, under this section, the Minister can abolish the council. I hold that if the Minister wants any more power, then the best thing for him to do is to scrap every county council in the whole country— probably, by doing so, he would be saving the rates in the matter of travelling expenses and so on—as this is only a sham. That is all the Wexford County Council or any council is. The Minister wants more powers. He has too much power already; he has all the powers. The local representatives have no powers under this system. I do not know why the Minister comes to the House now asking for more power. What he should do, as I say, is dissolve the council and leave the management of local affairs to the county manager and the Custom House officials, as they think they know more about local affairs than the public representatives elected by the people. Deputies on the other side talk about the roads and say that they must be maintained. The Party on the other side of the House did more destruction to roads and bridges in this country than all the traffic that will pass over them between this and the end of the world will do. We all know that they blew up bridges and tore up roads.
Comment on this
The roads and the bridges were blown up by the very people who are now talking about them.
Comment on this
The county manager in my county and some of the Fianna Fáil members on the council a month ago passed a sum of £4,800 to buy new machinery, while diesel engines, steam engines, and all the necessary equipment have been lying in the county council yard at Enniscorthy for the past five years. Now they are going to buy a whole lot of more machinery that is not needed. I certainly will oppose this amendment, and I believe that I will be doing my duty to the people by opposing it. I am a member of all the committees under the county council in Wexford and, so far as the power we have is concerned, we are only stool pigeons. If a member of the committee goes to the mental hospital he is allowed to talk to the inmates there as long as he likes. But if an attendant comes along and asks the member to do something for him and that becomes known, the man is dismissed. I was not a member of this House when the County Management Act was passed, but I was interested in it at the time. If the Fine Gael Party had fought that Act as they are fighting this section, it would not have been passed, because the Fianna Fáil Party had not a majority in the Dáil at the time.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33a:—
In sub-section (3), page 11, line 39, to delete the words "and collecting" and substitute the words ", levying, collecting and recovering".
This is merely a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
This is now a very remarkable bit of legislation, which will have a very big effect, unless the country is very wide awake, not only on the political side—on the way in which the people, through their institutions, are allowed to carry on public business—but on our social and economic position. We have heard many references to history while this amendment has been under discussion, but the really important phase of history of which we have heard nothing is that since October, 1945, when this Bill was introduced and had its Second Reading in this House, which induced the Minister to introduce the amendment which has just been discussed. It is perfectly clear to anyone who has been listening to the discussion, whether to the speakers on the Fianna Fáil Benches or to those on any other benches, that we are now in the position where, when a technical officer of any local body—a county medical officer of health, or a county engineer or any other technical officer—presents an estimate for the carrying out of any work for which he is responsible under that local body, it is not the local body which ultimately will fix the rate. That rate can and will, in the last resort, as Deputy Walsh puts it, be fixed by the Minister.
Through the whole of the local government system, the State manager which the Minister for Agriculture spoke about in November last, has very definitely appeared on the scene. What, then, are local representatives to be? They are to be people who will act—if they lack the courage necessary to stand up to the situation and to their local responsibilities—as the smoke-screen behind which the Minister's will will be carried out, in certain places, as simply the public will. Deputy Dillon has drawn attention to the fact that, under sub-section (2) of the section, as amended, the Minister, if he disagrees with the rate that has been struck, can order that a new rate be made, and the local authority shall have to make a new rate. If they do not, there are two courses open to the Minister, namely, to mandamus them into doing his bidding or to wipe them out. The Minister indicates that his measure is designed to help the innocent, weak, misguided local authorities, but I think he has very definitely planned to endeavour, by threat of mandamus, to get the members of local authorities weakly to agree to his instructions. That would be even a more degrading and a weaker result, and have a worse effect on the country as a whole, than if a local authority, standing over its local responsibility regarding local problems, should decline to carry out the Minister's Order. That would expose the Minister, who has now taken up the position that, in the last resort, he will strike the rate in any county where the local authority disagrees that it is the right thing in the interests of the people to do so.
The position to which the ratepayers have been brought up to the present time, as the result of Fianna Fáil policy, has been mentioned here and, arising out of certain figures given by the Minister to a Parliamentary question within the last day or so, comparing the net expenditure of local authorities in 1932 and 1942, and the amount of money received by the State to meet that expenditure, a figure has been quoted here that would suggest that the increase in rates between 1932 and 1942 has been 46 per cent. It has been more than that. It has been 60 per cent. The net expenditure of local authorities in the year ended March, 1932, was £9,446,000 and, of that, State sources contributed £3,522,000 and the local authorities contributed £5,924,000, of which £4,677,000 was raised by rates; the other smaller amounts of £1,000,000 odd came in from other sources that the local authorities had.
In the year ended March, 1942, the last year for which we have the information, the net expenditure had risen by £4,024,000 to £13,471,000, or about 46 per cent. But of that increase of £4,024,000, State sources contributed only £1,009,000 and the local authorities had to contribute an additional £2,852,000. In March, 1932, the total amount collected in rates was £4,677,000. In the year ended March, 1942, the rates had to contribute £7,529,000, an addition of £2,852,000, or an increase of 60 per cent. The only figure we have available up to the present is the increase shown in the warrants issued for county councils and I think you will find these are up by something like £400,000.
That is the position in which the Minister finds the country, on the one hand, and in which the local authorities find themselves, on the other. The total amount taken from the rates has gone up by 60 or 61 per cent. between 1932 and 1942 and, with the additional expenditure that has come on during the last four war years, they are now facing the plan that the Government have for loading on the local ratepayers the work of one kind or another that the taxpayers find themselves unable to bear because of the extraordinary increase in taxation. Taxation went up since 1932 from £21,000,000 in that year to £39,000,000 in the year ended March, 1945.
We have had a rather formative period in our national history, politically, socially and economically. The only thing that will maintain this country will be the efforts of the ordinary people in agriculture and in industry, and the only political stability that we can have will come if the people in every part of the country address themselves to the organisation and the management of those matters which require to be managed politically in order to have a society here and to maintain our institutions.
This legislation is machinery for taking more and more money out of the people's pockets, spending it through Government channels and leaving the people to have less to spend on their own initiative and on their own planning. That leads to more poverty. Why do we hear about social services? We hear about social services here because road workers throughout the country cannot get the increase in their wages, inadequate though they might be, that local authorities consider they ought to have. I asked the Minister the other day whether any examination had been made which would suggest that 40/- a week was sufficient to maintain a family whose breadwinner was working in one of the vital services of the country. I refer to road workers. You might apply the same to agriculture although, as Deputy Morrissey pointed out, the minimum for agricultural workers is the maximum that is apparently being paid to road workers.
A country whose economy is such that persons working at necessary vital occupations in rural districts have to be kept at wages like that must, if you like, provide social services to help them to eke out a living on their wages, but it cannot and will not continue to do so. The Minister may, in order to hold up his prestige and the prestige of his Government and the dignity of doing things through an emergency period, take his powers, but it should be realised that there are no powers and resources in this country outside of those that the people handle and there is no real intelligence that can make any use of them to build up the country economically or politically except that of the people themselves.
This is a measure to cow, restrict and restrain the intelligence of the people and the intelligence of the local representatives standing over their local problems. These are, if you like, symptoms of the absolute bankruptcy of mind of the Government in approaching the political, social and economic problems that exist.
Comment on this
The Minister attempted to dissipate the warning I gave the House last night. I submit that, in his attempt, he has hopelessly deceived himself. This section, as now amended, gives to the Minister for Local Government and Public Health in this country a power which no Local Government Act has ever given to any Minister in any civilised country heretofore. We all know that in the past there were certain mandatory services imposed upon the local authority. They were imposed by the statutes of this House and, if the local authority refused to carry out these mandatory services, anybody could institute mandamus proceedings against that authority, force it to do so, and the members who had refused to do their statutory duty would be mulcted by the local government auditor for the costs of the mandamus proceedings which they had properly defended and in which the verdict had gone against the council of which they were members. But this section, as amended, is the first attempt to incorporate in the law of this country the doctrine that the Minister, examining the same facts as were examined by the local authority and coming to a different conclusion on the same facts from that reached by the local authority, can order the members of the local authority to act not on their judgment, but on his.
If the members of a local authority should conscientiously believe that they are bound in duty to those who voted for them and those for whom they stand trustee to adhere to their decision, the Minister now, instead of dissolving the body, instead of dismissing them and sending them home, can start mandamus proceedings against them, not to carry out a statutory duty of which this House had prior knowledge, but to do what he thinks they ought to do, although he knows it is something which they conscientiously believe they are not bound to do. If the members, honestly doing what they believe to be right, strike a rate of 15/- in the £, honestly believing that the people of the county in which they live are not able to afford an additional burden, the Minister can say: "In my opinion, you should have struck a rate of 18/- in the £." The council stands by its decision and the Minister then, under sub-section (1) of this section, can make an Order directing them to strike a rate of 18/-.
Observe what happens then. In the existing state of the law, if the local authority adheres to its refusal, the Minister can dissolve the local authority, put in a commissioner and depend on the commissioner to strike the rate he thinks is right. The only consequence of that is that the members of the local authority are now private citizens and have no further responsibility as local representatives. That is the law as it stands now. If we pass this Bill in its present form, when the Minister issues his Order directing a council, in violation of their conscience, to strike the 18/- rate and the council rejoin that they have a conscientious scruple about doing it and will not do it, the Minister can then institute mandamus proceedings in which he is bound to succeed, because sub-section (2) now says that,
"within 14 days after the date of the receipt by the secretary or clerk of a rating authority of notification that a requirement has been made under sub-section (1) of this section the rating authority shall comply with such requirement."
If then the members who acted conscientiously at their next meeting declare that it would be contrary to their conscience to comply with the requirement made under sub-section (1), mandamus proceedings can be instituted.
Every Deputy who has any knowledge of local government procedure realises how immensely expensive such proceedings may be, and, inasmuch as the attitude of the council would be in direct conflict with sub-section (2) of this section, when those expenses came to be reviewed by the local government auditor, he would unquestionably surcharge those members of the council who were in the majority voting to reduce the Minister's requirement. Bear in mind that the surcharge will not be made on all the members of the council. It will be made on the members who voted to refuse to comply with the Minister's requirement, and that means that the individual small farmer in Roscommon or Mayo may find himself confronted with a bill of £50 to £100 for doing what he wanted to do, for doing what he believed it was his duty to do.
If that is the case, do Deputies want to impose on members of local authorities a liability not only to have their term of service arbitrarily ended but to be heavily mulcted in a fine for doing what they believed it was their duty to do? If you intend to put that burden on prospective members of a local authority, who do you think will go on to local authorities? What has always happened in rural Ireland is that if, in the popular cause of a particular district, you require a man to face an oppressive authority, you put up a man of straw because you did not want to give the oppressive authority the power effectively to injure decent, conscientious men who were only doing their duty and who were vulnerable in that they had property which might be taken from them and sold to John Brown, or somebody of that kind. Do we want all the local authorities to be manned by men of straw who will act at the council meetings merely at the instance of an extern corpus which will tell them what to do when they go in and which will send them in to do it, because no independent man will become a member of a local authority lest he find his person and property made liable under sub-section (2)?
The Minister has now gone off to his tea—I hope he enjoys it—but I direct the Parliamentary Secretary's attention to this because it is a very grave matter. We have a lot of friendly neighbours coming over from Great Britain reading the Riot Act to Sir Basil Brooke in Northern Ireland for that he has denied to the people of Northern Ireland the universal suffrage to which they are clearly entitled in their local affairs. I endorse that remonstrance by public-spirited British politicians in regard to the Sir Basil Brooke administration, but observe what we are doing in this country. We gave universal suffrage ten years ago and what have we been doing ever since? We have been taking back from the persons elected by universal suffrage on our local authorities all effective powers. Having given universal suffrage and having made a great to-do about it——
Comment on this
On the contrary. I think the Deputy will remember that General O'Duffy—Lord have merey on him—the then Leader of the Party, to which I had the honour to belong, was strongly in favour of universal suffrage. He was much more profoundly convinced of it than I, but it certainly was the policy of our Party at that time to give universal suffrage in local elections. For the last ten years, the effect of the legislation submitted to this House by the Fianna Fáil Government has been piecemeal to take away from the local bodies elected by universal suffrage all their authority and to convert them merely into tools to give effect to the various decisions of the Minister sitting in the Custom House. In fact, what we are working to in this country is a centralised, authoritarian régime in local government, with the disguise of democratically elected councils throughout the country, who heretofore were under notice that, unless they were prepared to do precisely what the Minister told them, they would be dissolyed, but who now are to get notice that, unless they are prepared to do promptly what the Minister tells them, even in respect of the last reserved service left to them under the County Management Act, they are liable not only to be dissolved but to be heavily fined as well.
What, in the name of Providence, is the use of giving universal suffrage in local government if no man of property dares to become a candidate for a local authority, lest his property be taken from him as a result of conflict with the Minister for Local Government? What is the point of giving universal suffrage to electors in local affairs when all the legislation of this Parliament is designed, and has been designed for the past ten years, to take from the representatives elected by universal suffrage every shred of power which local authorities might ordinarily expect to exercise? Surely this House should not abandon itself to an orgy of hypocrisy. Is it not much more honest for the Prime Minister of Northern Ireland to say: "I will not let anybody vote in an election in any part of my jurisdiction unless I am satisfied that, on the result, the local authorities will be dominated by people of my political view," than to say as we do here, "everybody will be allowed to vote, and, having allowed everybody to vote, we are quite resolved that none of them shall function unless they are prepared to act in the way we tell them to act under the sanction that should any of them dare to dissent to our instructions we will first fine them and then dismiss them"? Why do we not wake up to and face the facts? I invite the Parliamentary Secretary, at an early stage, to answer me this question: Is it not true that under sub-section (2) he can mandamus the members of a local authority to do not a mandatory duty imposed by statute of this Oireachtas but an act dictated by the Minister and in conflict with the conscientious convictions of those members? Taken with all the other powers that he has taken under the Local Government Acts since 1935, is it not true that, while in theory we have universal suffrage under local government in this country, in fact the only person who can freely function on a local authority in this State is someone who is prepared to act the part of the stooge on orders handed to him by a Fianna Fáil Minister sitting in the Custom House? If that be true, would he not agree with me that the position taken up—open, barefaced and above-board—by Sir Basil Brooke, Prime Minister of Northern Ireland, is a great deal more honest and straightforward than the pseudo-democracy of the Minister to whom he is Parliamentary Secretary, and of the Taoiseach who is responsible for all the legislation which the Government brings in?
Comment on this
The danger that I see in this section, if it is passed, is that the first victims under it are going to be the ratepayers of the City of Dublin. The Minister for Local Government has made a demand on the Dublin Corporation for a sum of £186,000 to subsidise the maintenance of patients in voluntary hospitals. That sum is equivalent to a rate of 1/9 in the £, so that it will mean an increase in the rates of close on 2/-. The Minister has informed the corporation that he must get that money, and that it is not his intention to allow the interest on Hospital Trust Investments, which amount to £8,000,000, to be drawn on for the purpose of meeting the deficits arising on the working of our voluntary hospitals. The Minister said that Dublin is a rich city, and that it could well afford to pay this amount. His demand has been presented to the corporation at the point of the pistol. No opportunity has been given to say "yea" or "nay" to his demand. With the other demands made on the Dublin Corporation by outside authorities, and over which the corporation has no control, this demand by the Minister will mean an increase in the Dublin rates this year of 2/6 in the £. That means that the rents of working-class cottages, and the rents of the rooms in the working-class flats built by the corporation and occupied by people with very moderate wages, are going to go up by 3d. or 6d. a week, probably per room. The finance committee of the corporation, which met to consider the Minister's demand, decided that it had obligations to those people who are not able to pay for their maintenance in the voluntary hospitals, and made an offer of 9d. in the £ to the Minister instead of 1/9, the payment to be in three 3d. instalments. The object of that was that the increase would not fall too heavily or too quickly on the people. I have no knowledge that the Minister has given any reply to the offer made by the corporation.
I have seen for a long time that this section was put in not for the purpose of dealing with roadways or of making county councils bring their roadways up to a proper standard, but for the deliberate purpose of forcing the hand of the Dublin municipality to pay this demand that I speak of, and of seeing that other public bodies will do likewise if similar demands were made on them. Under the section the Minister gives the public body the chance of meeting the demand. If it does not do so, then he will direct an inquiry to be held by one of his own officials. He will make a report to the Minister. The official may see some justification on the part of the local authority in refusing to meet the demand, for example, the hardship that it would cause to people whose rents would have to be increased in order to meet the increased rate demand. If the official reports on any points in favour of the municipality, the Minister will take jolly good care that his report will be pigeon-holed, as happened in the case of the report concerning the Cork Street Fever Hospital.
I am opposing this section because I believe that all local government authority is now in the hands of a dictator in the Custom House under the Managerial Act. One of the few powers that was left to a local authority under that Act was the power of striking the rate. Now, that power is being taken from us by the Minister. He is putting himself up as a dictator. This is just a beginning of a greater dictatorship in other affairs in this country. I warn all representatives in this House, Fianna Fáil and others, who are members of local authorities, that the day is rapidly approaching when they may find their local bodies dissolved, and when they will have no powers. You will have one man a dictator in the Custom House. He will give orders to his manager or commissioners, so that local government in the country will be carried on by one man in the Custom House. If you think well of it you can do that, and, mind you, there are some people who think well of it. We know there are critics of the local authorities. We have seen some of their published letters criticising local authorities, so that there are some people who think that this power may do no harm. Dictatorship leads to trouble. Some Deputies to-day instanced the case where a county manager recommended a small increase in the wages of a few workmen in the county council to help them to meet the high cost of living and it was refused. The day is coming when the local authority will not be able to move without the sanction of the Minister.
I put it to him that the intention of this section is to force the authorities to put up the rates to meet demands of local government that should be met by national taxation. Why should there be an attempt to put on to the ratepayers of any county the cost of the maintenance of the hospitals and of the patients? That charge should be distributed over the whole country and I maintain that the proper fund from which to draw for the upkeep of those who have to utilise the public services is the national fund and not the local rates. The Minister has no right to introduce these services and then to force the cost of them on the local authority. There are many measures required for the benefit of our people and they should be introduced, but the national taxpayer should pay his share of the cost. It should not be borne by the local rates all the time. I, therefore, oppose the section.
Comment on this
We must all admit that a rather contentious amendment has been inserted in the section, an amendment on which various views have been expressed. That matter has been decided, and the House must apply itself to a consideration of the effect of the amended section in the light of experience which is definite and in anticipation, which is largely speculative. In the light of experience, the first question that occurs to us is, have these powers ever before come within the authority of a Minister in this or any previous Government? We find that in principle the power has been exercised and that various public councils, for the time being, have been abolished, whether to the advantage of the ratepayers or not, in individual cases, is a matter which must be considered in a general light. We know that in some cases, as, for example, the recent case of the Kerry County Council, the abolition was to the advantage of the local ratepayers to the extent of something like 1/6 in the £ in their rates. I am not in possession of the details, but in other cases both the past Government and the present Government considered it necessary to apply the provisions now embodied in this section to the administration of the public services. We have had much talk from Deputy Dillon about what is to be done by a dictator in the Custom House, but this House by now, I regret to say, is pretty well aware, and to some extent sick, of the exaggerated statements of the Deputy. At very critical times he made very damaging statements.
How is the Minister to adjudicate on the question whether a rate is adequate or not? Surely it is on a report from the county manager appointed under the Managerial Act which is part of the legislation adopted by this House. The county manager is guided by the advice of his technical advisers, engineers, surveyors public representatives on the various sub-committees for public assistance, mental hospitals, and various other services. After discussion with the public representatives, and after such adjustments have been made as the public representatives in their wisdom advise and the manager and his advisers are prepared to accept, then it comes to the Minister, and if the Minister sees that the difference between what the technicians and the county manager advise and what the local authority are prepared to strike is so serious as to affect the public services or the maintenance of the roads in the county, then the Minister will step in and, if he thinks fit, will order an inquiry to see who is right in the matter. The result of the inquiry goes before the Minister and he judges the case in accordance with the circumstances put before him.
Roads will be the principal item of contention. At any rate, that has been suggested to the House. Deputies on all sides of the House said that they are in favour of social services. The provision of social services is a statutory obligation and the local authorities are bound to carry it out. Therefore, the provision of roads will be the bone of contention. Roads are the arteries of the country and there is no use at this stage in trying to decide between main roads and county roads because we all use the main roads as much as the county roads. Since the new policy of tillage was put into operation, since there has been beet-growing and wheat-growing, farmers are not willing to bring their produce over the county roads in their own carts. They want the lorries to come in over these roads, which they never travelled before in any great numbers, and to bring the produce direct from the farmyards to the mills and to the factories. Consequently, the movement of lorries over the county roads to a greater extent than before has caused deterioration and, therefore, the charges in respect of roads, both county and main roads, will perhaps be a more serious item for the community than before. But the community request the services and use the services. Let us recognise the fact that, for the 20 years, 1922 to 1942, motor taxation contributed £16,500,000 or, approximately, on an average, £825,000 a year, to the Road Fund. It was stated to be about £1,125,000 before the emergency, but it diminished last year to something like half that figure.
Comment on this
Because of its application to the contentious matters raised about rates and the powers of the Minister.
Comment on this
Surely every purpose to which a rate was devoted is not to be discussed. Why single out the roads?
Comment on this
Because of their nature the other items are statutory, but the roads are a variable item. Deputy Mulcahy and other Deputies stated that the Minister had failed to sanction advances in the case of road workers, and the condition of these workers was commented upon. I think no Deputy adverted to the fact that because of the inadequate allocation of rates for certain roads last year, the workers not only did not get an increase, but they have not been working since the middle of January, and will not be working until next April. Are these men not worse off than others who got regular wages because the county allocated sufficient rates for that purpose? I agree that this is a serious matter.
It was stated in the debate yesterday that the Minister was unreasonable, and did not give sufficient facilities, in certain cases, to public representatives who wanted to examine the affairs of institutions on which public money was being spent. Let me say at once that I disagree with that view. I disagree in the particular instance that was mentioned. I believe that the Minister gives all reasonable facilities in that respect. Doneraile Sanatorium was mentioned. There are 20 members on the committee, which usually meets on the same day as the county council meets in Cork in order not to put the expense of going an extra 28 miles to the institution on the rates. The Minister gave permission to members of the visiting committee to go to the institution twice a year to look into its affairs. When a claim was made to increase the number of visits to four a year, it was granted. That meant that by taking one car every member of the committee would visit the institution within the year.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Deputy that he might settle that matter with his fellow Deputies from County Cork.
Comment on this
I did not want a false impression to be created as against the Minister by the remarks of any Deputy. I hold these views just as strongly as my colleagues, and I hope I will have the same privilege of speaking my mind. In this particular matter I am prepared, in the light of my experience, to support the section. I would be very sorry to think that any responsible Minister, either in a former Government or in the present Government, would use his power in order to curb the rights of elected representatives. I do not believe there is any such intention. The control that the county manager has now got over officials may give him more overriding authority in the councils, and to some extent take from the elected representatives the power of exercising the criticisms that they formally exercised. While these criticisms could be effective, considering all aspects, no other alternative is open to us but to give the Minister power, where local authorities fail in their duties, to order an inquiry, and to take all necessary steps to see that the social and national services within a county would be effectively carried out.
Comment on this
I wonder could we hear the Minister on the important point put to him with regard to mandamus.
Comment on this
In intervening in this prolonged debate I hope I will make certain matters, which have been the subject of most ridiculous speeches by the Opposition, clear to Deputies. The suggestion has been made that we are abandoning democratic principles through the application of this amendment. The suggestion has been made that there is no real liaison between electors in their capacity as electors for local authorities, and electors in their capacity as electors for the Dáil. The suggestion has been made that it is possible to impose, through this section, such a burden of expenditure on a local authority that the rate struck will be intolerable to the community. No one in opposition seems to have adverted to the fact that a general election and an election for a local authority take place regularly, and, by the ordinary process of political controversy, if under any circumstances—apart from the circumstances attending this amendment —the people consider the burden placed on the rates is excessive, they can elect a national Government, and can elect a Dáil which can either reduce the whole level of expenditure, as far as a Government grant is concerned, or can decide to award a greater proportion of expenditure in respect of local services, which are the subject of State grants. A great many of the observations of members of the Opposition fall completely to the ground when that is borne in mind. One would imagine that the whole expenditure of the State was entirely rigid and unchangeable. One would imagine that no Government was capable of altering their opinion as regards the total expenditure of the State, or as regards the contribution of local authorities. The fact is that, under this so-called Fascist system of government, the local authorities have elections every three years, in which the county councillors and urban councillors can express their view in regard to the burden of expenditure. The Dáil, in the ordinary course, has an election every five years, if not more often, in which the people can express their view in regard to the burden of expenditure as between the local and central authorities. The smooth, continuous working of those two processes should eliminate any such danger as has been foreseen by members of the Opposition in connection with this amendment.
Going further into the question, members of the Opposition have entirely failed to appreciate the intention underlying this amendment. It is not designed to enable the Minister to say to each county council: "You must strike a rate of so much in the £; you may not strike a rate of 15/-, the rate must be 19/-; it must not be 20/-, on the contrary, it must be 24/-." The purpose of this amendment, as defined by the Minister, is that of making local authorities balance their budget, making them strike a sufficient rate to defray the expenditure they are to incur. There is no other intention behind this amendment. In connection with certain services, there has been an obligatory striking of a rate over a number of years. In the Vocational Education Act, 1930, and the Agriculture Act, 1931, there are provisions for a prescribed rate in the £ which local authorities are bound to raise. In the Local Government Act, 1898, there is provision whereby the contribution to the upkeep of asylums is dependent upon certain conditions being observed and a certain rate being struck. The Local Government Act, 1925, clearly indicates that there must be some minimum expenditure upon the maintenance of main roads.
Aside from those particular items of expenditure, I am not aware that there has been in the past five or six years any such controversy as between the Department of Local Government and the local authorities in respect of the numerous and comprehensive services which they administer as would suggest that, when this amendment is passed, the Minister will say, not only in connection with vocational education, not only in connection with agriculture, not only in connection with the maintenance of main roads—controversy in connection with which on a serious basis has taken place in only two counties—but in connection with other services: "You must not strike only so many shillings for this; you must increase the rate; we demand that you do so." There is no precedent for that. During my period of office, which, I grant, is short, there has been no ground for suggesting that we are going to start to use the whip to compel local authorities to increase their expenditure in respect of multifarious services. The sole purpose of this section is to secure that local authorities pay their way.
I want to advert once more to the difference between the Minister's powers before the passing of this amendment and after its passing, because a number of Deputies, frightened with the thought of an oncoming Nazi or Fascist movement, seem not to have properly examined the position. Before the advent of amendment No. 31a, the Minister, if he observed a rate deficiency, could order an inquiry and, satisfied that there was a rate deficiency and lack of responsibility on the part of members of the local authority, could proceed to dissolve the local authority. That was, and is still, the precise position. Under amendment No. 31a, the procedure is more elaborate and provides opportunities whereby procedure so drastic may not, in fact, be necessary. It provides an orderly method by which the members of the local authority are given an opportunity to reconsider their position— not an opportunity by the mere will of the Minister, or because of his desire to avoid disagreement between himself and the local authority, but by statutory requirement. The statutory requirement—I must repeat it—is that the Minister, having observed that there would appear to be an insufficient rate struck, is bound to hold an inquiry.
If he satisfies himself that the proposed rate is insufficient, he then indicates to the local authority that they should strike a sufficient rate. If the local authority, having been reminded by him of their responsibilities, do not strike a sufficient rate, then the Minister may proceed to remove the local authority.
When Deputies make accusations to the effect that Fianna Fáil is either Fascist or Nazi in its tendency, they should think the matter out quietly and, in an impartial spirit, review their opinion upon this amendment. I want to repeat that, prior to the passing of this amendment—at present—the Minister could order an inquiry as a result of the striking of an insufficient rate. What he did during the course of the inquiry or as a result of the report of the inquiry depended to a considerable extent upon his will and not upon statutory requirement. Whether he gave the local authority a chance to strike a sufficient rate was a matter for his will and not an Order of this House. He could proceed to dissolve the local authority the moment he was satisfied that they had not fulfilled their responsibilities. Now, he must hold an inquiry, he must satisfy himself that the rate is insufficient and he must give an opportunity to the local authority to review their position. Only when they have reviewed their position and are still unwilling to balance their budget, so to speak, can the Minister remove the members.
Comment on this
Some people who have suffered under various forms of tyranny during the past century would laugh at the Opposition if it was suggested that this was something in the nature of a move towards a Fascist State or any other kind of dictatorship.
Comment on this
I grant that the application of 31a depends, as in the case of all legislation of this kind, on the Minister having a sense of his responsibilities but I should like to remind the House that this Dáil exists by will of the people and that the Minister is responsible to the Dáil in respect of his every Ministerial act. If, at any time, any Minister for Local Government was foolish enough to use this section in order suddenly to increase the burden of expenditure in respect of rates, as apart from central taxation, he would deserve all he would get from the electors at the next general election. What Minister in his senses in a Government of our time, and with the publicity afforded in all matters of finance, would use such a section in order suddenly to alter the proportions or the weight of the burden placed upon the taxpayer in respect of rates and general taxation? Any Minister for Local Government elected by this Party, and I would say any Minister for Local Government elected by Opposition Parties, if they were good politicians, apart from having the interest of the country at heart, would refrain from using this section in the manner I have indicated.
I have been asked by Deputy Dillon about the use by the Minister of mandamus proceedings. I have not had an opportunity of making a detailed study of this matter but I should say that procedure by mandamus is not the procedure contemplated under the section, nor would it be appropriate. If the courts were asked to intervene, I think that they would say that the procedure which the Minister should use was clearly indicated in the amendment. There is nothing that I, as a person of common sense and not as an expert lawyer, can see in the amendment which would suggest that it could be interpreted by the Minister in such a way that he could use mandamus proceedings. I see no danger of members of local authorities being mulcted as special defendants should they lose an action in mandamus proceedings. I am not an expert lawyer; I am merely relying on the advice I have received. Reading this section, I cannot see why the Minister should need to do any other thing than that clearly indicated to him in the words of the section. It is the most normal thing to do; it is the wisest thing to do, and it will cause least friction between him and the local authority. It will result in difficulties that have been experienced being cleared up in the simplest way, and it will give everyone a chance of examining the position that has arisen. I should like to say, in conclusion, that the section empowers the Minister to do in an orderly way certain things which before he could only do, if he so willed it, in a way which prevented proper consideration being given to the whole problem.
Comment on this
I was awaiting the reply of the Parliamentary Secretary to the question put to him by Deputy Dillon. It is perhaps unfair, in the absence of the Minister, that he should be called upon to give a reply to something that is essentially a technical matter. I find myself in complete agreement with Deputy Dillon, and I find the answer of the Parliamentary Secretary completely unsatisfactory. The speaker who spoke before the Parliamentary Secretary made, so far as I was able to ascertain from his observations, only one clear contribution to the debate—that he was in favour of the powers contained in the section being conferred on the Minister. He stood up immediately after Deputy Dillon, presumably as one qualified to answer Deputy Dillon. The only way he was able to answer Deputy Dillon was to indulge in some cheap sneers at Deputy Dillon, because of what he alleged were over-exaggerated statements in the past. Deputy Dillon at least had the courage to make these statements, and to give his reasons for his statements. The Deputy who presumed to reply to him cannot answer the reasoned statement made by Deputy Dillon by merely sneering at his past utterances. I say categorically that I am entirely in agreement with practically everything—indeed I may say everything—which Deputy Dillon stated this evening.
The Minister stated in the course of one of his speeches on the section that he had already the power of dissolution, and that the section in its present form made it more difficult for the Minister to get a mandamus. Then he went on to make the fatuous observation that it was intended to protect the innocent, the weak and the misguided. Implicit in the Minister's statement, if I have correctly given expression to what he uttered, is the admission that Deputy Dillon is correct in the assertion that he made before, and that he repeated to-day, that under this section, if it is passed into law, the remedy of mandamus will be open to the Minister. The Parliamentary Secretary stated that it was not the appropriate remedy, nor was it the remedy contemplated. We may start with the fact, admitted by the Minister, that the remedy is available under the section. Therefore, there can be no controversy about Deputy Dillon's statement that this power is put into the hands of a Minister of this State for the first time.
The Parliamentary Secretary stated, in extenuation of the matters put to him by Deputy Dillon as emerging from the section, that the power of dissolution was there before, but certain additional machinery had to be put in which was not there before this section was introduced. I fail to see how that is an answer to the allegation made by Deputy Dillon. There was no power of mandamus in circumstances such as are contemplated in this section. There was a power of dissolution. There is now the power of dissolution and the power of seeking the assistance of the courts by way of mandamus. In other words, the Minister before could eliminate the local authority. Now he can both scourge and eliminate members of a local authority, because, as Deputy Dillon has—correctly in my view—pointed out, this section imposes upon a local authority a duty and every statutory duty imposed upon a local authority is one that must be carried out.
Failure to carry out that duty can be made the subject of mandamus proceedings, naming the persons who have refused or who, it is alleged, have refused, to carry out the duty, as special defendants in the mandamus proceedings with the consequence to them personally in the first instance of being made subject to the heavy costs of these proceedings, and secondly of becoming the victims of the machinery of the court, if the court proceeds to put its order into operation by proceedings for contempt or adopting the other means by which an order of mandamus is enforced. So, in addition to the powers of dissolution, there is the power of fastening the costs of mandamus proceedings on the members of a county council with the possibility of their being put into jail for failure to carry out the orders of the courts under mandamus. It is idle, therefore, to suggest that these extensive powers are not in the section. It is idle to suggest that they are not contemplated or intended. The point is not whether they are contemplated; the point is whether they are there.
The Minister, having probably been told by one of his legal advisers that the issue of a writ of mandamus is discretionary, has sought to show that because the issue of the court order is discretionary, it will not be granted because of the fact that there is the power of dissolution. He says that because of the existence of that power of dissolution, the courts will exercise a discretion and refuse to grant the mandamus. I say that there is no substance in that contention, if it is made by the Minister, and it is only implicit in what he has said. It is suggested that that power will not be exercised, merely because there is the power of dissolution. It will be noticed that the power of dissolution is not in itself mandatory, and where there are in these two sub-sections, (2) and (3), duties cast upon the local authority, irrespective of whether or not there is another remedy open to the Minister in his discretion, that remedy can be availed of.
Of course, it is perfectly obvious that this procedure by way of local inquiry has in recent times fallen into disrepute. The public have become alive to the fact that local inquiries were merely the pretence by which the Minister endeavoured to cover up his actions, having already in nine cases out of ten decided upon a certain course of action before the local inquiry started its proceedings. It was merely to delude the public into thinking that something would emerge from the public inquiry that the proceedings were started. Even before the Cork Street Inquiry had awakened certain sections to the injustice of some Ministerial actions, many people were aware of the fact that local inquiries were a farce and that in many instances it had been decided to punish the local authority long prior to the beginning of the sittings of the local inquiry. So public money and much private money of individuals, whose livelihoods were jeopardised by the holding of such inquiries, were spent, all to no purpose and to no avail. Now, the position is that the Minister, having got frightened, has a different opinion on these local inquiries and does not like the task, if he can avoid it, of dissolving local authorities, and a new instrument is devised—the powerful instrument of the writ of mandamus. That can be sought first and an endeavour can be made through the machinery of the courts, while still maintaining the facade and the pretence of democratic institutions, to force particular members of local authorities to comply with the Minister's wish. Having done so, and the Minister having fastened the costs of these proceedings on individuals, and perhaps having brought down on them the wrath of the court for contempt in not carrying out the orders of the court— all that having been done, then these local authorities can still be dissolved under this section. So that, instead of there being the same power—as was rather suggested by the Parliamentary Secretary—in this Bill as there was formerly, and instead of having additional safeguards provided, the position is, actually, that an additional instrument, of a very virulent and forceful character, has been put into the hands of the Minister, in order that he may keep up the pretence of democratic institutions by keeping the local authorities in existence and not dissolving them, while using the machinery of the courts to hold up individual members of these authorities as persons who will not obey the orders of the court.
Comment on this
Sir, last night I described Deputy Dillon's argument as a cobwebby fantasy, intended merely to blind the eyes or the intelligence of those who realise that this is a practical matter: that if we have to dissolve a local authority because it refuses to do its duty, and if we have an expeditious weapon at our hands to deal with such a situation, then we would do so in a way that would involve us in the least amount of expense. Before Deputy Costello leaves, I should like to put a question to him. Deputy Costello referred to the Cork Street Hospital Inquiry, and the findings connected with it. Now, I understand that Deputy Costello appeared at that inquiry.
Comment on this
In my professional capacity. Any reference I made to the Cork Street Hospital Inquiry had nothing to do with my attendance there as a professional man. I made no reference to that inquiry except from the political point of view, and I ask the protection of the Chair against any reflection on me professionally.
Comment on this
If anything was said against the Deputy professionally, yes. The Deputy referred to the Cork Street Inquiry, and if any reflection is made on the Deputy as a professional man, he shall certainly have the protection of the Chair, but the Minister did not do so.
Comment on this
I did not refer to that inquiry except to say that even before it was held certain things had taken place. I did not refer to it in any way from the point of view of my professional capacity.
Comment on this
The Deputy suggested that it was shown that the findings in the inquiry were not justified by the evidence.
Comment on this
In this case, I must have misunderstood what the Deputy said, and, if so, I make the fullest retraction. I am glad to know that the findings in that matter were not contrary to the weight of evidence. However, in regard to this matter of mandamus, that is a practical matter which does not arise, as the Minister has already this remedy at his hands in any case in which a local authority refuses to discharge its statutory duties and statutory obligations. It has been said that a mandamus is a remedy for every default on the part of a local authority. Naturally, the Oireachtas, by law, imposes obligations on local authorities, and in the case of an additional obligation, the conditions in which mandamus may be imposed on local authorities are enlarged. It is true that every fresh statutory provision relating to a local authority, which is embodied in an Act of the Oireachtas, is also the ground upon which a mandamus can be sought, but prior to this it has never been put forward here as a substantial argument against the enactment of legislation that if the Oireachtas makes a law, the parties affected by that law are entitled to go to the courts to enforce it. That is the basis of Deputy Dillon's criticism: that in making a law we are giving, to a party affected by the law, the right to go to the courts of this land and ask the courts to enforce the law. I think that that was a fantastic argument to produce against this section. As I have said, it was a cobwebby argument, because it was meant to draw a veil over the intelligence of Deputies as to the merits of the section.
There is nothing more than that in the argument used by Deputy Dillon in regard to this section, and, accordingly, I ask the House to accept this.
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 23, as amended, stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 35:—
Before Section 24, page 11, and in Part II, to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) The Minister may from time to time by Order vary the existing division of a rated area into collection districts or, in the case of a rated area forming one collection district, divide such area into two or more collection districts and, in the former case, may, in particular, by the Order increase or reduce the number of collection districts in the rated area.
(2) The Minister may by an Order under this section make provision for such (if any) transfers of rate collectors of the rating authority concerned as in his opinion is rendered necessary or expedient in consequence of the Order.
(3) In this section—
the expression "rated area" means the area in which a rating authority is empowered to levy rates, the expression "collection district" means the area for which a rate collector of a rating authority is appointed.
This amendment is to clear up a certain amount of confusion and to make it clear what the Minister's position is in regard to the variation of divisions of rated areas into collection districts. Article 65 of the Public Bodies Order provides that a rating authority may, with the consent of the Minister and in such manner as the Minister shall approve from time to time, divide a rated area into separate districts for the purpose of the collection of rates. Now it happens that the division of an area into districts is not a function that has been expressly reserved to the elected body. For that reason, it has been assumed that it is a matter for the manager, although the making of the rate and, in the case of a county council, the appointment of a rate collector is a reserved function. There has been a tendency in some counties in the past to create more election districts than are warranted or would be necessary. On the other hand, when it is desired to undo this process and to amalgamate the areas and make them more reasonable units, a conflict of opinion sometimes arises as to who is entitled to do this. I propose to resolve such conflicts as may arise, by giving to the Minister final authority in the matter, to give him power from time to time to vary an existing division of a rated area into collection districts or, in the case of a rated area forming one collection district, to divide it. In some cases, the collection districts are unwieldy and cannot be conveniently worked. Others are so small as to make it impracticable to appoint a rate collector who would be able to do the job efficiently for the remuneration which may be available to him. So, on occasion, questions have arisen as to the amalgamation of a district or as to the division of a district and there has been a conflict of opinion as to what authority is the rightful authority for the purpose of amalgamating the districts or subdividing them. I think the only way in which we can resolve that now is to give the Minister the final authority and, no doubt, he will take into consideration the views in that connection of the local authority.
Comment on this
This amendment is in accordance with the policy of the Minister under his amendment No. 31a. He wants to reserve full and absolute control in his own person. He wants to filch whatever power the local authority has to determine whatever areas are most suitable in their administrative districts for collection purposes. He wants to say whether districts should be amalgamated or subdivided. I wonder would he tell us what the function of the local authority is when this Bill becomes an Act? Is it to be a mere pretence that it is a body with certain powers? Even in this particular matter, the Minister is not prepared to let the situation stand, where the local authority had the right to do certain things with the sanction of the Minister. He now proposes to take away that right and says he is to determine from the Custom House the most suitable district in any administrative area in the country. So far as we are concerned, we are not prepared to give the Minister that power and we do not subscribe to the policy of ignoring the elected representatives and vesting absolute control in the Minister. If the Minister is going to press this amendment, we will be forced to divide the House on it.
Comment on this
Before the Deputy finally makes up his mind in that regard, let me repeat what I said. This, in fact, is apparently not the function of the elected representatives. It is not a power expressly reserved to them by the Act and, therefore, it has been held—or, at least, it has been contended—that it is a power which rests in the manager. Therefore, if the Deputy is going to oppose this on the grounds that I am going to deprive the elected body of some power which it has, I think he is acting erroneously. The position seems to be that, in so far as there is any power to do what is proposed here—either to amalgamate collection districts or to divide them—it would appear that the person in a position to operate it is the manager. I want to clear up that and see that, if proposals come up to me and if they have the consent of the local body, I will be able to confirm them.
Comment on this
The Minister seems to have some doubt and, even on his own admission, it appears to be the function of the manager.
Comment on this
Well, as the law stands, if it is the function of the manager, probably the manager would consult the local authority, if he is going to operate the County Management Act in the spirit in which the Minister suggested it should be operated—that there should be co-operation between the manager and the local authority. In that case, the manager will consult the local authority; but we are now putting in this provision to ensure that he will not consult the local authority but will ask the Minister to intervene and make an Order deciding what subdivision should be made in a district or, in fact, ask the Minister to determine the rating district.
Comment on this
The Minister has said in his speech that he may amalgamate two or more areas into one, if he thinks fit. The section goes on to say that the Minister, by Order, can increase or reduce the number of collection districts in an area. If he should do so and redundancy follows and if there is a rate-collector with certain rights, due to his appointment and his having been 20 or 25 years in the rated area, and if that rate collector is about to lose his appointment, is the Minister providing any compensation or giving him any benefit, such as in Article 10 of the Treaty, if he does not wish to continue the employment? Does he propose to give such collectors an opportunity to retire voluntarily and will they get the benefit of a provision similar to Article 10 of the Treaty, which gave men the opportunity of getting out if they felt it was impossible for them to continue under such a régime?
Comment on this
With all due respect to the Deputy, I think that point is covered by Section 25, which deals with amalgamated offices. Perhaps it is not, but in any event I will look into what the Deputy has said and will see if I can safeguard the position. It certainly is not the intention to force a rate-collector out of his post and refuse to compensate him.
Comment on this
But if he loses his appointment as a rate-collector, will he be adequately compensated?
Comment on this
Well, so far as my mind goes in the matter, there would be no proposal to amalgamate or divide a district unless the post happened to be vacant. I will look into the matter between now and the Report Stage and see what I can do.
Comment on this
I would not have any objection to what the Minister proposes to do, but if the tendency is to increase the areas of collection, I do not think that is a very good policy. If the county is divided into pretty equal areas, it would be a good thing. There are undoubtedly some unwieldy areas at the present time and it is very awkward to collect. Strange to say, the collector in many cases does not live near the centre of the collecting area and he has to travel perhaps quite a number of miles before he enters his collection district. He might have a small portion of the collecting area near where he lives, but the bulk of the area would be far away. It would not be a bad thing if the Minister had power to reorganise these areas but, on the other hand, I would feel opposed if the tendency were to make the areas too large, thereby doing a number of people out of employment.
I know there is such a thing as the Department and the councils and the managers wanting to get people of substance, people of substantial means, to carry out the collections. I quite agree with that, but at the same time you can have a fairly poor man just as honest as people of substantial means. If the idea is that the areas will not be made too large, I have no objection. Naturally, I have a lot of experience of this matter and I agree with the Minister. There are many areas unwieldy at the moment and they require adjustment.
Comment on this
I want to make clear what our attitude is in regard to this.
Whatever doubt there may be about the function of the local authority or the manager in this matter, the Minister wants to clear that up, but the Minister, in doing so, definitely wants to cut out any control or authority that the local body would have. If he was going the other way, ensuring that the local authority would have some control and authority in the matter, he would get full support from this side of the House, but because his whole attitude is to withdraw any control or authority from the local body, we are opposing the amendment.