We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Local Government Bill, 1945—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 127–257 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill, 1945
Enacted

No. 32 of 1945 ›

I may say that I have known, within the last few years, since the Managerial Act started to operate, rate collectors to die and the county manager divided their areas, amalgamating them with certain other areas, and he did not consult the council. In practice it has not been done.

Comment on this

Now is the time to clear that up and make sure about it. The Minister could put in an amendment to the effect that the manager should consult the council but, instead of that, he puts down an amendment in order to give himself full authority.

Comment on this

I know of a case where a rate collector received up to £700 a year. The collector died, a vacancy occurred and the county council recommended the manager to divide the district and give a decent living wage to a man in one area and £350 a year in a smaller district. The county council recommended the manager to make the division and to ask for the Minister's sanction. I do not see why there should be any opposition to this particular section because the manager, unless he is a particular dictator altogether, will only consult the county council. I can speak for our county manager who is very reasonable and reports everything to the county council. In this particular case the county council recommended him to ask the Minister for sanction and we are awaiting that sanction. If the proposal is sanctioned there will be two districts instead of one. I take it that it will be only on a recommendation from the council or the manager. How will the Minister know otherwise?

Comment on this

The Minister is seeking very peculiar powers under the Bill.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 52
·
Níl 31
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

What has happened to all the democratic zeal of the Opposition?

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 36 has not been moved.

Comment on this

Perhaps discretion has operated in this matter.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 37:—

Before sub-section (5) to insert the following new sub-section:—

The powers conferred on the Minister by the next preceding sub-section of this section may be exercised only in circumstances analogous to those mentioned in sub-section (2) of this section.

In sub-section (2) of Section 25, certain offices which will be affected by the section are set out and the amendment is designed to ensure that should the Minister revoke or amend —the question of revocation does not arise for us—an Order, the amendment of the Order will be circumscribed within the limits of the offices set out in sub-section (2).

Comment on this

Even if I were prepared to accept the principle of this amendment, I think it would have to be redrafted. I am not going to commit myself with regard to it, because there are very strong objections to it. I do not think it at all probable that a Minister who made an Order amalgamating offices would revoke or amend that Order unless the amalgamated offices were vacant. It seems to me to be extremely unlikely. If he did, I assume that he would have to have very strong grounds indeed for doing so. He might even be made do it at the instance of an officer who found that the duties of the amalgamated office were too onerous, or he might have to do it, because despite anything that the holder of the amalgamated office would say, experience might have shown that the amalgamated office could not be efficiently filled by one person. While I say I am not at all inclined to accept the amendment, I would have liked to have heard a stronger case made for it than has been made, and if it would be more convenient to the Deputy perhaps he would withdraw the amendment and discuss it again on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I am prepared to withdraw the amendment on the assurance given by the Minister. As I have said, the amendment has substance in it, in view of the fact that the Minister, in sub-section (4), actually takes power to issue an Order either to revoke or to amend. The amendment is designed to ensure that any amendment made will not go outside the terms of sub-section (2). I think that is reasonable, and would meet any Order made by the Minister which might very well do that. However, on the assurance given by the Minister I am prepared to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I am not giving the Deputy any assurance. I want to be quite clear about that. If there is a case for this I do not think it has been adequately made. It certainly has not carried conviction to me. What I am suggesting is that if it is not convenient for the Deputy to press the amendment to a division, to which it would ultimately go in my present frame of mind, he can, if he wishes, withdraw it and discuss it on the Report Stage. I want to make this clear, that I am opposing the amendment unless I hear a stronger case made for it.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It can be moved again on Report Stage.

Comment on this

On that understanding, I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 39:—

In sub-section (1), line 10, to delete the words "appropriate Minister" and substitute therefor the words "local authority".

I think that all the amendments to this section might be discussed together.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 39, 40, 41 and 42 can be discussed together.

Comment on this

The object of the section is to facilitate the holder of an office who wants to be absent from duty for an indefinite period. If the appropriate Minister is of opinion that he should get that leave of absence, the Minister can make an order authorising someone to perform his duties by deputy. Sub-section (2) of the section empowers the officer concerned to appoint the deputy. Our objection to the section is that it completely ignores the local authority which is the body that is paying the official's salary. We feel that if an official has to be absent from his office for an indefinite period, he should at least have the approval and sanction of the body that is paying him. The Minister is proceeding on the same old policy here. He wants to ignore the local authority completely and to deal with the matter himself by order, giving approval to the official being absent from his office. In the Bill the officer concerned is given power to appoint a substitute. The Minister, in amendment No. 44, is proposing to delete the word "appoint" and to substitute the word "nominate". As I have said, the Minister in doing that is completely ignoring the local authority. I would like to hear him defend that policy. It is analogous to the policy running through the whole measure. The Minister wants to arrogate to himself complete control and authority, while the poor fools who will have to find the money to pay the officer are to be completely ignored.

Comment on this

On the narrow point of all these amendments, I would like to indicate to the House that if the amendment were carried the effect of it would be to leave the power of authorisation in the hands of the manager. It would not put it in the hands of the elected body but would leave it in the power of the manager. The choice, therefore, would be between the manager and the Minister. I think that the section as drafted has manifest advantages. If the Minister is responsible for the authorisation, as he would be under the section as it stands, his conduct can be challenged in this House and can be debated here. On the other hand, if it is going to be left to the manager the local authority will not have power to discuss it, and it could not even be discussed in this House. Therefore, if the desire is to ensure that this authority will only be given in circumstances where it is clearly warranted, I think that the section as it stands meets the case much better.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I must confess that I cannot follow the Minister's reasoning. I take it that for the purpose of this section, the local authority includes the manager. The position at the moment is that the manager has certain powers and certain authority, and that the local body has certain reserved functions. I think it is correct to say that the local authority has nothing whatever to do with the appointment or removal of any official at present operating under the manager. That is a managerial function. It seems to me that what the Minister is doing is this: he is not satisfied merely with taking power altogether from the local authority, but wants to take to himself even the functions of the manager, and to remove this matter completely from any contact with the locality. The point here is whether we are going to give to an official of a local authority the right to nominate his own deputy. If we do, then neither the local authority nor the county manager will have any say whatever in this matter except, as Deputy Hughes has said, to provide the official's salary. May I say to some of the Deputies on the opposite side, and particularly to Deputy Walsh, that this is taking us a step further as far as the powers proposed to be taken in this Bill are concerned.

There is this in it, that, generally speaking and following, if you like, upon the Minister's circulars and advice to county managers, there is fairly close co-operation between managers and local authorities and although the county manager has the power to do things without the permission, or in spite of the views, of the local authority, county managers who have any common sense try to get as much common agreement as possible. If we are completely to take away, not only from the local authority but from the county manager, power in this matter, I think it is a step in the wrong direction.

Comment on this

The viewpoint we take is that a nomination of this character should only apply to a pensionable, whole-time officer and in such case I could well imagine circumstances arising from time to time where it would be necessary for such officer to have temporary leave, say, for a period of three months. Obviously, cases of that kind can be cited. The Minister made the point, which was an interesting one, that there is not very much in so far as the claim for the local authority is concerned seeing that, if he conceded the point, in the last analysis, it would rest merely with the county manager as distinct from the local authority and, therefore, he asks the House to decide as between the county manager and the Minister. I think the point made by Deputy Morrissey is an exceedingly good one and those of us who are in close touch with some of the managers will agree and will very gladly testify to the fact that there is an element of co-operation as between the council and the manager. The point made is quite correct, that is, that a manager who is trying to do his job right will naturally try to keep the atmosphere sweet in so far as the council is concerned. In this respect I would point out to the Minister that, even on the distinction he makes, if it were left to the county manager, as such, in any event the manager would have to make an order for such an appointment and it would be open to the council to discuss his order under the Standing Orders of the council and in that way the local authority would be associated. I would ask the Minister, in view of that, to agree with us that his action in arbitrarily confining a nomination of this kind to himself is detracting from the power and influence of local authorities and will be viewed in that way.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Morrissey and Deputy O'Sullivan. If the local authority means the manager, as the Minister has pointed out, and as it does, because it is an executive function of the manager, the manager must make the order and the local body has a right to question that order at the next meeting, if they desire to question it. In any case, the manager will desire to have harmony with his local body and will do the right thing. But there is no opportunity for the local authority to question the Minister in the matter. So far as that is concerned, it is preferable to have the function rest with the manager. He will have the co-operation of the local authority and the local authority will have the opportunity of making their observations on his order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 44:—

In page 13, to delete the word "appointed" in lines 19 and 33 and substitute in each case the word "nominated" and to delete the word "appointment" in lines 22 and 27 and substitute in each case the word "nomination".

It is not desired to allow an officer to appoint his own deputy. The amendment proposes to substitute the word "nominated" for the word "appointed". There was an amendment, I think, put in by Deputy Hughes, and we are prepared to accept that amendment.

Comment on this

I had another amendment, the Minister may observe. I wanted the local authority's consent to it as well as the Minister's.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 48:—

In page 13, to insert in lines 20, 22 and 26, before the word "Minister", the word "appropriate".

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister why he has not thought it wise to fix some limit to the period that an officer may be off duty. According to the section as it stands, a man may be permitted to absent himself for ten years. Surely that is not desirable. There ought to be some limit set to the period of time that he can be absent from duty and can perform his duties by deputy. In what circumstances does the Minister contempiate that this section is necessary?

Comment on this

In view of Section 28, which requires the holder of an office to devote the whole of his time to the duties of that office, does it not seem rather inconsistent that, for no apparent reason, an officer can absent himself for an indefinite period? In the normal course, if a holder of a particular office under a county council is incapacitated through some form of illness or disease, he or she may be allowed a period in which to recuperate. But, apparently, for reasons which are not stated in the Bill, and for an indefinite length of time, officials of local authorities are to be allowed to vacate their offices and to have the rather unusual privilege of nominating a deputy to fill those offices, with the approval of the Minister. I think this is a very unusual provision in a Bill and it requires some justification, not only in respect to the reason for vacating the office but also in respect of the length of time that these people may be absent. As Deputy Hughes has said, they may be absent for ten years. As I read the section, if the Minister were prepared to approve, a person might leave such an appointment for life and nominate a deputy.

Comment on this

I think the position is not quite so unsatisfactory as it has been described. It is impossible, in certain circumstances, to say how long a person holding an office, not necessarily a whole-time office, in fact an office in respect of which the remuneration would be by fee, might be absent whether through illness, on public duties, or otherwise, and I think the realistic way to approach this matter is to have regard to sub-section (4) of the section, which gives the Minister power to withdraw approval given under sub-section (2) and to terminate the appointment of the officer.

That might be the best way to approach the problem where, as I have said, the circumstances may be obscure, and where a period of time would be difficult to prescribe, because, if the appointment of a deputy were to be unduly prolonged, the Minister's action in allowing his original Order to stand could be challenged. In fact, the opportunity would occur, I suppose once a year, to challenge the Minister's action in this House, and he would be, naturally, called upon to justify the Order which he had made. If he could not justify it, because the Order had been in operation for an unreasonable time, then, I think, acting on sub-section (4), he would revoke the Order. Quite frankly, it is not possible for me to prescribe, in advance of circumstances as they arise, a definite time. If the circumstances are such that the Minister for the time being feels justified in making an Order of this kind then, I think, we may assume that as long as these circumstances remain unchanged the Order should stand. If the circumstances change then, naturally, I suppose the Minister's attitude in regard to this power to nominate a deputy could be challenged, and presumably would have to be modified.

The position we are dealing with is rather a peculiar one. In most cases, unless a personal certificate is required, it would not be necessary to take this power at all, because, in fact, the holders of some public appointments, particularly holders of part-time legal appointments, who work through subordinates or who supervise work which employees do, or work as partners. In their case no question of a personal certificate arises, and there is no difficulty. There are other appointments where a personal certificate is required. For instance, apart from the case mentioned in the House before the recess, it occurs to me that certain medical officers might be required to give a personal certificate in certain circumstances. Normally, perhaps, they would function through a deputy, not a deputy officially appointed under the section, but through a deputy selected by them unofficially. That, I believe, is quite customary. Yet, as we look into this, it is possible, by reason of the fact that they had not secured power from the Minister for the appointment of a deputy, some of the proceedings might be invalid in a court of law.

There is also the case of people who have to give a certificate in respect of bacteriological tests. There again a personal certificate is essential. If it should happen, for one reason or another, that a person was allowed to prosecute a course of study, and was not personally available, he could not act unless a deputy were appointed under the section. That is the position we are trying to deal with. I suggest that the section provides the fairest and the best safeguard that the powers given the Minister will not be abused. The Minister having power under sub-section (4) to revoke a certificate, if it is allowed to last over a long period of time it can be challenged.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

All that the Minister has said might have some weight if we had no local authority and no local government. He seemed to forget the fact that for close on 50 years we have been operating under local authorities in accordance with the Local Government Act, 1898. I cannot understand why the necessity of taking these extraordinary powers has arisen, so to speak, overnight. The Minister spoke about certain people who perform their duties through a deputy, but he overlooked the fact that, even though that may be essential in regard to certain classes of workers, there might be physical impossibility on the part of people holding these appointments to carry out everything that they were supposed to do. But they are still responsible for seeing that the work is properly carried out. If I may say so, that is a point the Minister overlooked. The official has the right, even in the amended form of the section, to nominate a substitute, and neither the local authority, the county manager nor the city manager, as the case may be, can in any way question that. They will have no say as to whether the person nominated is the most suitable person. It is only the Minister will have a say there. This section takes away the power not only of the local authority but of county managers to have any say. I think the Minister will find it almost impossible to make a convincing case for doing so either in this House or anywhere else.

I want to put this question to the Minister: what has arisen, after 47 or 48 years' experience of local government, to make it appear to him to be desirable to make those terribly drastic changes from the ordinary routine? While I know that it has been the practice of certain officials of local authorities, notably dispensary doctors, or doctors attached to hospitals, to be given the privilege of nominating their own substitutes, the local authorities always had the right to refuse to accept the person so nominated and to appoint anybody they liked. At least, they were in this position, that with their knowledge of the duties to be performed, and of the substitute named, they could either accept or reject. They will have no such decision when this section becomes law, because the matter will be one that will be in the hands of the Minister alone. As was pointed out, a deputy might be allowed to act for a month, for six months, for 12 months or any period. Not only is the holder of the office relieved of the work when he nominates his deputy, but he is relieved of the responsibility.

Comment on this

The Minister has not convinced me that it is wise to leave the period completely indefinite. He would be well advised to put a limit to the period in which an official can be absent from duty even by order of the Minister. If there be no limit, an official will be able to plan for a long absence. If there was a limit, officials would appreciate that, in planning to take up a post-graduate course or any other type of course, a limit had been set by law to their absence and that they could not exceed that limit. I do not suggest that the period should be unduly narrowed but it is not desirable that we should provide in law facilities for an official to be absent from duty and to have his duty discharged by a deputy over a long period. I am completely against the cutting out of the local authority and leaving the decision to the Minister absolutely. Take the case of a medical officer who may have private duties to perform. If a local authority is concerned with the approval of his substitute, they may feel that the arrangements made are not sufficient to cover the services that are essential in a remote district.

It might be difficult to find a suitable substitute over a long period in an unattractive district. The Minister would be concerned with ensuring that provision was made for local government services but he would not be concerned with the private service which the doctor would be called upon to perform. The local authority would realise that private individuals would require the services of that particular doctor and, if arrangements were made for a neighbouring dispensary officer to discharge the duty, it might not be satisfactory to the local authority. The local authority would know the local circumstances and have a better appreciation than the Minister of the services which would be required from the substitute in a case of that kind. The Minister has made no attempt to convince the House that the local authority should be cut out in this matter. Surely, commonsense dictates that, in a case like this, in which the local authority pays the whole of the bill, they are the people who should be consulted. The man who pays the piper is entitled to call the tune. In this case, the man who pays the piper is to be ignored and the Minister is to call the tune. The Minister should sleep on this matter. He should realise that the people will not stand for this type of dictation. He may get away with it at present but, some day, somebody will call a halt to this form of legislation. The local authority are the best judges of what alternative provision should be made during the absence of an individual but they are completely ignored and the Minister, who is not conversant with local affairs, is to make the decision.

Comment on this

I put it to the House again that, if this principle is to be accepted at all, it is much better the Minister should carry the whole of the responsibility. The Minister has certain responsibilities under this section as it stands. He must satisfy himself that the person to be nominated shall possess the necessary qualifications. If he is to discharge that obligation, I do not think that much is to be gained by dividing responsibility. In that event, while the Minister would be the person responsible for the qualifications, you would have an officer of the local authority responsible for the actual appointment. The Minister has to come to this House once a year with his Estimate. If his action is challenged, he will have to show the House that the person acting as deputy for a particular person is fully qualified. If the continuance of the deputyship appears to be unduly prolonged, he will have to justify his continuance of the Order. That will have to be done in this House, where it will attract an amount of attention which it might not otherwise receive. That circumstance will, no doubt, make the Minister concerned to ensure that reasonable criticism cannot be levelled at him. For that reason, I suggest to the Deputy that the section in the form in which it has been drafted meets the case of those who are concerned to ensure that nothing improper will be done under it. I am reluctant to prescribe any period for the deputyship because I can envisage circumstances in which future officers of local authorities, and even officers of State, with whom we are not concerned here, might be sent abroad to pursue post-graduate courses of study.

Comment on this

For how long?

Comment on this

Perhaps two years. I am reluctant to prescribe the term, but if the Deputy feels strongly about that aspect of the matter—the other aspects have been disposed of by amendment—I shall look into it between now and Report Stage and see if we can prescribe a term.

Comment on this

I congratulate the Minister on the remarkable reticence with which he has dealt with this section, particularly in view of his undoubted knowledge of the unusual circumstances which surround it. To me, as to Deputy Hughes and to Deputy Morrissey, this is a remarkable departure from the usual provisions in the local government code. If the Minister is of opinion that special circumstances surround a particular office, he can allow the holder of that office to vacate it and to nominate a deputy for an unspecified period even while he, the holder, may have another appointment. If the holder wished to vacate the office entirely, the Minister might even have sufficient power to appoint a person permanently to it.

Comment on this

No, not if the office is vacated.

Comment on this

Possibly not, but there is nothing to prevent the holder from being absent for an indefinite period and the Minister allowing the deputy to hold the position whilst the officer is occupying another position. I think that is a very serious encroachment on the rights of the local authority, particularly when the local authority is paying for the services rendered. The local authority has no say whatever at the moment because most of these appointments are made by the Local Appointments Commission, but the local authority has the responsibility and the duty of providing the funds. In this case the Minister takes power to appoint for an indefinite period. While the Minister states that the matter can be reviewed in the House there is not the usual provision at the end of the section that, on a motion being put down within 21 days, the Minister's decision can be annulled. I think this section is designed for a specific purpose and for a specific person and I think in these circumstances it should not be passed.

Comment on this

Let us be clear as to what our attitude is. Our attitude is that the Minister should be required to sanction the provisions made by a local authority to fill an office temporarily and I think that is perfectly reasonable. The Minister then gets an opportunity of seeing whether the deputy is qualified in every way to fill the office. If he feels he is not qualified, he does not sanction him. There the local authority is consulted and the local authority has an opportunity of saying whether the members feel that the nominated deputy is suitable for the office. The Minister has not attempted to answer my suggestion that there may be considerations, so far as a particular office is concerned, outside mere service under the local authority. I gave as an instance the case of a medical officer who may have a private practice. If he is going on a course of studies abroad for a protracted period, the members of a local authority are surely the best people fitted to decide whether the nominated deputy is best suited to fill the office, not merely under the local authority, but to discharge whatever private duties may have to be performed for people who are not entitled to get them under the local services. The Minister is not concerned with that aspect of the case and he is anxious to cut out whatever control the local authority should have. The Minister has evaded that by trying to entice me into agreeing with him on a minor matter because I suggested that a limited period should be set. The issue is not the limited period; that is a minor matter. The issue is the policy of filching power from the local authority and vesting it in the Minister himself.

Comment on this

I wonder would the Minister instead of having a person nominated to fill the office temporarily have the vacancy filled by the Local Appointments Commission? It could happen that a person could be nominated for 20 years under the section as it stands. This is looked upon as a very important matter by local authorities and county managers. They are not deemed capable apparently of even filling a minor post but the man getting extended leave can fill the post himself. In fact he is a sort of a new Appointments Commission. That is what it amounts to. I heard members of local authorities discussing this point before now and it is one that could lead to a good deal of abuse. There is something in it that the Minister does not realise but members of local authorities who have given thought to the matter can visualise what it might lead to. It can lead to endless trouble; you can give the privilege to one and refuse it to another. I suggest if there is a reason for it—and I do not believe there is a very sound one—if the appointment is for longer than six months or three months or for some specified period, it should be made by the Local Appointments Commission. That would remove some of the odium from the section. The Minister knows that it can lead to all kinds of abuses and the only way to prevent these abuses is to provide that the appointment, if absence is longer than a specified period of, say, six months, should be made by the Appointments Commissioners. I understand that the Appointments Commissioners cannot make appointments for a limited period but I have known cases where such appointments were made by the Appointments Commissioners. Take the case of house surgeons for instance. There is no reason why appointments such as are referred to in this section should not be made by the Appointments Commission instead of the person leaving the office being given power to nominate a person to act for him.

All kinds of questions may arise under this section. You may have medical men or clerical workers all of whom are pensionable making arrangements to nominate people to act for them for a long period. It may come to the time even when road workers may be pensionable and they would equally be entitled to nominate somebody to act for them. As I say, it could lead to all kinds of abuses. I have discussed this matter with members of local authorities over a long number of years and they can see probably better than the Minister what the reactions of this power will be because the Minister or some other Minister following him will be forced into a position that he will not at all like. I would suggest that the Minister would consider the section before Report and see if he could amend it in any way.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I am glad that Deputy Allen has made this contribution to the debate. His suggestion, if accepted by the Minister would, as he said, remove some of the odium from the section but I do not think it would go far enough. There is a big principle involved. My old friend over there is laughing at me again but I should like Deputy Walsh to appreciate that what we are asked to do here is to give to an officer a function hitherto exercised by the local authority, that is to make an appointment subject to the Minister's consent. Remember that is exactly what this section means. It means that an officer or an official can appoint his own substitute subject to the sanction of the Minister. I put it to any Deputy that that is something we ought not to accept unless, as I said earlier to-day, we have made up our minds completely to wipe out local authorities, as we understand them. I do not think the Minister has been able to make a convincing case for the section. I do not think any man could make a convincing case for it. I am not concerned with any particular circumstances, any particular position or any particular person. The thing is absolutely wrong in principle. As Deputy Allen has said, it could lead to a great deal of abuse. Then there is the other point that we cannot get away from, that is that we are not only moving away from the powers of the county council, but even from the powers of the county manager in this matter, and that is something that, I suggest, we cannot stand over here and still talk about democracy. I do not think that the Minister, or anybody else here, could make a convincing case for the section as it stands.

Comment on this

I think that in some of the suggestions that Deputies have made to meet the difficulties of the situation they have not taken full cognisance of the facts. First of all, the section does not deprive any local authority of power of appointment, because local authorities, in fact, have not anything more than nominal power of appointment to an office, since, as Deputies know, practically all these appointments are made by the Local Appointments Commission; and, certainly, the manager has not the power of appointment to an office. The next thing is—I am not going to be so precise and definite about this—that, in general, the Local Appointments Commission can only make appointments to offices which are vacant. Now, the essence of this section is that the office is not vacated; that there is no vacancy to which the Local Appointments Commission may make a recommendation. So that it would require, I think, an amendment of the law—I am not speaking now cx cathedra, and I do not want this to be taken as a wholly accurate view, as I may be wrong—to enable the Local Appointments Commission to fill a vacancy in such circumstances. Now, there is another aspect of this matter. In general, holders of offices to which this section may apply will not be whole-time officers of the local authority. They will be mainly carrying on a private professional practice, as in the case of a doctor or a chemist, and the local authority concerned will only be one of their clients. Now, even in the case of dispensary doctors, the right is given, or at least it is acknowledged, to practise as ordinary practising professional men, in addition to acting as the medical officers of health in a dispensary district. It is acknowledged that they are not only in appointment as the medical officers of health in that dispensary district, but that they also have a practice as ordinary, practising professional men—a practice embracing a number of private patients and, in some cases, if you like, a number of private clients. In such a case, naturally, the person who has to vacate his office temporarily, and who has to ask for authority to appoint a deputy, must be concerned to see that the deputy appointed is one in whom he will have confidence and who will retain, unimpaired, the private practice which, probably, will form the main part of his livelihood. Consequently, I do not think that such a person would leave the appointment of a deputy to some outsider. There may be cases in which the title to an appointment of this sort is not valuable so far as the remuneration immediately to be derived from it is concerned, but it is valuable from the point of view of the prestige and professional standing which it gives. In many cases, the holder of an office of the type to which this section would apply may have been engaged for a considerable number of years in a public, professional practice, and, in the course of these years, may have acquired a professional standing and professional goodwill which might easily be destroyed if an unsuitable person were appointed as a deputy. Therefore, it seems to me, that in a matter of this sort the person who holds the appointment will be as concerned as the local authority to ensure that a proper deputy is appointed.

Now, the local authority, on the one hand, and the Minister, on the other hand, have also responsibilities; but the Minister, under the Local Government Act, as it stands, is given power to prescribe qualifications for these professional posts. He must prescribe them after consultation with the Local Appointments Commission, but the Minister has the power of prescription, and therefor it seems to me that in these circumstances it is in accordance with the spirit and, perhaps, the letter of the existing law, that the Minister is the person to be satisfied that the proposed deputy has, in fact, the qualifications which are necessary to enable him to fulfil the duties of the post.

Comment on this

We are not questioning that.

Comment on this

No, but I want to make the position clear. I am not suggesting that the Deputy is questioning that, but I could envisage this position: I think it would be quite possible to write into the section an amendment which would limit the range of selection. I might prescribe that the deputy to be nominated by the holder of the office would be a person who holds a comparable post, if you like, under another local authority. That would mean that, beyond yea or nay, the deputy would be a person who had been selected by the Local Appointments Commission as being fully qualified for the office. I think that that would meet the point of view which Deputy Allen has expressed. At any rate, at one remove, we would have, as the person selected by the Local Appointments Commission to fill the position, a person who had held a similar office to that in which the holder was temporarily prevented from acting. That, as I have said, would ensure that the person would be fully qualified. It would leave to the holder of the office who, as I have indicated, has other interests and other rights in the matter, the power to nominate the deputy who has to act for him. Now, if the House will accept that, I am prepared on the Report Stage to bring in an amendment to ensure that the deputy will be a person who holds a comparable post under another local authority, and I am prepared to consider bringing in on the Report Stage an amendment which would prescribe the period during which the deputyship would run.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

So far as he has gone the Minister has dealt with one side of the matter only. With regard to the amendment which he is prepared to consider introducing, that the person to be appointed as deputy would be a person who had been selected by the Appointments Commissioners for a similar position, holding similar qualifications, it is conceivable that there would be a position to which a deputy or a substitute would have to be appointed for which there was not a corresponding number, so to speak. In other words, it is conceivable that, under this section, you may have a person seeking, for any reason you like, to be relieved of his duties for any period you like and wanting to exercise the right to nominate a substitute, and that there may not be available a person having all the qualifications which the Minister said he was prepared to consider putting into his amendment. That is so far as that goes. With all respect to the Minister, I do not think the proposed amendment would be of any value.

With regard to what was said about a dispensary doctor, that is not at issue at all so far as this is concerned, because the practice has been, as Deputies who are members of local authorities know, that if a dispensary doctor wants to pursue a post-graduate course or to take his holidays, he nominates, or suggests if you like, a doctor to be appointed as locum tenens. The Minister said that he had rights. He has not that as a right. But the members of the local authority, being sensible people, are quite conscious of the fact that the doctor has a private practice which, in most cases probably, is far more valuable than his position as a dispensary doctor. I suggest to the Minister that there is another side to this, that the local authority have the right to say yea or nay to the person nominated by the doctor. I have practical knowledge of this, because I have known a case where a dispensary doctor going on holidays asked to have appointed as his locum tenens another dispensary doctor living a considerable distance away from the dispensary of the doctor who was going on holidays. We refused to accept that person as a locum tenens, because it was obvious that he could not attend to two sets of private patients, his own and the private patients of the doctor who nominated him to do locum tenens, and the two dispensaries. That is where local knowledge is valuable.

I honestly think that it is beyond the wit of the Minister so to amend the section as to remove the really objectionable part of it, namely, that you are giving an officer or an official a right to nominate his substitute or deputy and the local council, the county manager, or the city manager, as the case may be, has no say in the matter. An official who is vacating a post for any period from a month to 20 years would have the right to nominate a person and the Minister merely would have to sanction that or not to sanction it. I do not think it is within the competence of the Minister or the draftsman or his officials to draft an amendment that will remove that objection. With the best intentions in the world, I do not think the type of amendment which the Minister has promised to consider between now and the Report Stage will cover the positions which may arise from time to time. The case of dispensary doctors is the simplest one, because in recent years they have been appointed through the Local Appointments Commission, except those who were put into vacant dispensaries by way of promotion by the local authority. That is simple enough. But, if you take the case of a chief executive officer in any branch of the local services, you may not be able to get a person so easily. I do not think you will be able to cover that by an amendment. If you do put in an amendment, I think it will be of a type which will not work out in practice. I do not believe that this section can be so amended as to remove the objectionable part. The whole trouble is that the mind of the Custom House is running all the time in one direction, and that is to have whatever little authority remains in local government centralised and exercised through the Minister. You cannot have that and have local government. You have to make up your mind which you are going to have.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Morrissey was not correct in saying that local government was being more centralised because the local authorities have not dealt with the appointments at any time.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

They can appoint a substitute.

Comment on this

No. The manager appoints the substitute. I suggest that when the Minister is considering amendments to this section he should make the person nominated or appointed subject to the local authority. At present under the section the person nominated will not be subject to the local authority in the way the person who makes the nomination is. He is the person who is subject to the local authority, not the person doing duty for him. That is an important fact to keep in mind.

Comment on this

On that point, it seems to me that a local authority have this safeguard, that, naturally, the office-holder would be responsible for the conduct of his nominee, and if the nominee were unsatisfactory, the local authority always would have power to terminate the appointment by suspending the officer.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That Section 27, as amended, stand part of the Bill."

Tá 49
·
Níl 29
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

What does the section mean?

Comment on this

Section 19 of the Act of 1941 provides that the appropriate Minister may make regulations for a number of purposes specified in the section. It has been found necessary that he should have power to make it a condition of appointment that the person appointed to an office under a local authority must devote the whole of his time to the duties of the office. Now, I want to emphasise that this does not mean that the Minister will convert existing part-time officers into whole-time officers. The purpose of the section is to enable the question of whole-time or part-time services to be determined specifically in the same manner as the other conditions, such as those relating to remuneration and hours of duty, are settled. Ordinarily those matters will be settled in the general officers' scheme for each public authority.

I also want to point out that despite what was said on the Second Reading of the Bill, the condition that whole-time officers shall devote the whole of their time to the duties of their office does not mean that every hour of an officer's life must be given to official work. It means broadly that an officer who is supposed to be giving whole-time services to a local authority cannot give that time which belongs to the local authority to any other gainful occupation which requires his attention during official hours. If his hours of duty are nine to five or ten to five then, during that period, he cannot pursue any other avocation. He may, if he likes, late in the evening, lecture in the university or in the local technical school or, if some relatives have a shop, he may assist him or her in that business after official hours. We want to ensure that where officers have been appointed to whole-time posts they will give the whole of their time to those posts during the prescribed hours.

It is not proposed by this amendment to interfere in any way with membership of the Oireachtas. If there were to be any limitation or any bar upon membership of the Oireachtas, that would have to be dealt with in an Act specifically regulating and relating to that matter.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not feel that the terms of this section go a bit wider than his expressed intention? Will he consider making it read "requiring holders of the office to devote the whole of their official time to the duties of their office"? The "whole of their time" is a phrase that I am sure there would be all kinds of judgment on.

Comment on this

Yes. If Deputies would be good enough now to give me their views in regard to that particular matter, I certainly will consider them between now and the Report Stage. I do not want to do anything which would interfere with existing rights. I do want, in relation to future appointments, to be in a position to say that the officer appointed to the post will give it the time that the post is presumed to require by the regulations; but if it is felt that there is any danger in regard to this, I am prepared to consider an amendment on the Report Stage. If Deputies feel any uneasiness about the section as it stands, I would like if they would discuss it now.

Comment on this

I want to know if this section covers all officials who are at present whole time. That is number one. Next, is every official who holds a pensionable office supposed to be holding it as a whole-time office or not? We have some very peculiar things happening from time to time, and I think it is time that the Minister clarified the position. I have in mind the unfortunate position of the Cork ratepayers. They are paying a pension of £750 a year to a man about whom very eminent lawyers sent down an opinion to the county council setting out that he was only a part-time official. Still, he got a pension of £750 a year as a whole-time officer.

We have running right through the whole of this legislation what you might call grades. I do not think they are recognised in the Constitution or anywhere else. If you are an ordinary, whole-time worker you cannot accept any other services. If, on the other hand, you are in any one of the professional classes, then of course the word "whole-time" is merely an anomaly; it is not meant to cover you. I would like the Minister to give us a clear definition of what he intends to do now. Is this another sample of class distinction, another class grade? To whom is it intended to apply? Is it intended to apply to an officer who has a pensionable post? Is he to be a whole-time officer? Is he not supposed to do any other work during general office hours? Is he supposed to devote all his time to his own duties? Does that apply to an engineer? Does he come into that category? I would like a clear statement on that point.

Does it apply to all pensionable officers? I understand that in order to be pensionable you have to be a whole-time official. Does this apply to such persons, or has the Local Government Department graded them, each for special classes, special distinctions? The ordinary home assistance officer is supposed to be a whole-time officer because he is pensionable. He is supposed to work full-time in his office. On the other hand, the engineer, though he is a whole-time officer and is paid a salary for whole-time work, has various other jobs besides, as is generally found. In his spare time he carries out other work. That applies to county surveyors and engineers to boards of health. I hold that in these offices, in connection with which the Department has taken very good care that the salary paid will be sufficient to enable a man to devote his whole time to the work, the public are entitled to the whole-time services of these men.

We want no back-door methods in this connection. Let the Minister tell us plainly and simply what particular branches this is intended to cover. Is the engineer appointed to the board of health position at £600 or £700 a year a whole-time officer and is he covered by this? Is he supposed to devote his whole services to the board or can he be an architect in the building of a new church in some other county or the building of a new school under the Board of Works in another county and 15 or 16 other jobs of that description, all in the time that he is supposed to be, not alone paid a salary, but earning a pension, the bill for which will have to be paid afterwards by the ratepayers? I want an explanation of that particular point from the Minister before we let this section through.

Comment on this

Would I be correct in assuming, from the statement the Minister has made, that an employee of a local authority, who can make suitable arrangements for periodic absences from a locality, will not be precluded from membership of the Oireachtas? Am I correct in taking that inference from his statement?

Comment on this

I should not like to put it precisely in those words. No existing right which any existing member of the Oireachtas has in regard to that matter will be interfered with by this Bill.

Comment on this

Existing members?

Comment on this

Existing members, and I suppose, until the conditions regulating membership of the Oireachtas are changed, future members, too. There are at present members of the Oireachtas who are whole-time officers of local authorities. The practice has been for them to apply for leave of absence to attend to their Parliamentary duties. That leave has invariably been given, and, so far as I am concerned, will be given in future, but I am not in a position to say that at some time some other Minister, without reference to this section at all, may not say that attendance here is incompatible with the discharge of his duty to the local authority. I cannot bind my successor, but, so far as I am concerned, if an officer of a local authority is elected to this House and all that is required to enable him to attend is that he should be given leave of absence, I should feel myself bound, as the precedent has been created, to treat him as any other citizen has been treated.

I should like to make it clear that this is to enable the Minister to prescribe qualifications on conditions of employment under Section 19. Section 19 of the 1941 Act states that the appropriate Minister may make regulations applying to all the officers in relation to which he is the appropriate Minister and to their holders and to such of these offices as belong to a specified class, that is to say, determining remuneration, regulating the payment and amount of travelling expenses, determining hours of duty, providing for records of attendance, regulating the granting of sick and other leave and the payment of remuneration during leave, requiring holders to give security for the due and proper performance of their duties and regulating the nature and amount of such security; prescribing the procedure to be followed by local authorities in making appointments otherwise than on the recommendation of the Local Appointments Commissioners, etc. We propose to add to those a provision requiring holders to devote the whole of their time to the duties of their offices. A person can be required to devote the whole of his time to the duties of his office, and, at the same time, could be given leave of absence by the Minister to attend to duties here, but unless he gets that leave from the appropriate authority, if he is a whole-time officer, he must devote the whole of his time to the duties of his office.

With respect to what Deputy Corry has said, if an engineer is appointed as a whole-time engineer, it seems to me then that, during official hours, he must devote the whole of his time to the work of the board. It is not true to say, as the Deputy has suggested, that all pensionable offices are necessarily wholetime offices. The Deputy is well aware that dispensary doctors are only part-time officers but have pension rights, so that it is possible to be the holder of a part-time post which carries pension rights.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:—

Before Section 29, page 13, to insert a new section as follows:—

Sub-section (1) of Section 26 of the Act of 1941 is hereby amended by the insertion of the word "appropriate" before the word "Minister" where the latter word occurs secondly.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

With regard to amendment No. 53, in the names of Deputies Keyes and Murphy, I have to point out that the amendment is out of order because it is equivalent to a complete negativing of the section.

Comment on this

I can put forward the argument for the amendment on the section.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 54:—

In sub-section (2) to delete the word "October" in line 48, page 13 and line 1, page 14, and substitute in each case the word "August" and to insert the word "appropriate" before the word "Minister" in line 53, page 13 and lines 6, 15 and 20, page 14.

This again is a drafting amendment. There might be more than one Minister involved in the section.

Comment on this

In what way can changing October to August be a drafting amendment? What is the significance of the change?

Comment on this

"October" was a drafting error. August 26th was the date on which the Local Government Act, 1941, came into operation. It was also the appointed day of Emergency Powers Order, No. 216, which this section will replace.

Comment on this

If changing "October" to "August" implies that we are embodying Emergency Powers Order No. 216 in this measure, I object to the amendment.

Comment on this

It does not mean that we are taking that Order and embodying it in this measure, but perhaps it would be better to agree to the amendment and to discuss the point on the section. It is a question of a misstatement of date.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Will the Minister say what is the relation of the change to Emergency Powers Order No. 216?

Comment on this

If we are on the section——

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

We are not; we are still on the amendment.

Comment on this

Then all I can say is that August is the appropriate month, and not October.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Minister wants us to accept the amendment before he is prepared to tell us anything about it, and——

Comment on this

I have already told the Deputy that 26th August, 1941, was the date upon which the Principal Act of 1941 came into operation. In the Emergency Powers Order No. 216, the expression "local authority" has the same meaning as it has in Part II of that Act. The Emergency Powers Order became effective as from 26th August, 1941.

Comment on this

What is Emergency Powers Order No. 216?

Comment on this

It is the Order which gives to the Minister for Local Government the right to give or to withhold sanction in respect of proposals of local authorities relating to the remuneration of their employees.

Comment on this

Does that include road workers?

Comment on this

It includes road workers.

Comment on this

Does it include county managers?

Comment on this

County managers are already covered by the Act.

Comment on this

They have already got their increase?

Comment on this

No, their remuneration is already controlled by the Minister.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Plus the bonus.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment agreed to?

Comment on this

As a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:—

In sub-section (3), page 14, line 21, to insert the word "appropriate" before the word "Minister".

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) sets the ceiling as at 26th October, 1942, for salaries and wages. I am at a loss to know why that particular date has been fixed, or whether the Minister has taken cognisance of the fact that salaries and wages which operated in 1942 might bear no relation whatever to the conditions operating five years hence. It is still more interesting to point out that the Minister already has power to control salaries and wages which cannot be conceded without his consent. Why, therefore, in this sub-section try to superimpose the authority that he is now seeking? The amendment was put down to ascertain from the Minister the purpose of this particular sub-section.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Has the Minister anything to say about the section? It is customary for a Minister to do so.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that the Minister is a stickler for order, and, generally, waits until the Chair calls on him. In this case Deputy O'Sullivan forestalled me. Prior to the emergency, the Minister's powers over remuneration were exercised in relation only to officers except where Government grants were granted for the relief of unemployment. In 1941 an Order was made bringing the pay of every employee of a local authority within the Minister's control on the coming into operation of the Local Government Act. The Act, under which the Order of 1941 was made, was repealed, and a new Emergency Powers Order became necessary to preserve that power of control. That Order was made, as I have said, in 1942, and the purpose of this section is to preserve the powers of control given to the Minister by that Emergency Powers Order. That does not mean that a ceiling has been definitely fixed for the remuneration of officers and employees of local authorities. It only means this: that, where a proposal is made to increase the existing remuneration of employees of a local authority, that proposal will not become effective until it has been sanctioned by the Minister. That is the purpose of the section.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Indeed it is not, with all respect to the Minister. The effect of this section will be to make permanent in our legislation the notorious emergency standstill Order. The purpose of the section is to put Emergency Powers Order No. 216 into an Act of Parliament, so that as far as the lowest paid workers in this country are concerned, the emergency is going to last for ever if the Minister can see to that. Let us see what we are condemning those workers to. The cost of living in this country has increased since 1939 by approximately 72 per cent.

That is the official figure, though I do not agree that it covers the real increase in the cost of living. By the Minister's exercise of Emergency Powers Order No. 216, which he is now seeking to put into our permanent legislation, thousands of working men in this country—I think I can safely say the majority of them with families to maintain—have been pegged down, in most cases, to an increase of 4/- per week in their wages, from 35/- to 39/- to meet an increase in the cost of living of at least 72 per cent. I would like Deputies to realise that it is for the purpose of continuing that state of affairs and that gross injustice that this section is before the House. The dishonest argument has been used from the Front Bench opposite that the sole reason why they will not agree to an increase in wages to, let us say, bog workers or road workers, is because agricultural workers might be induced to go off the land and on to the roads. I need not tell anybody with any practical experience how dishonest that argument is, mainly for the reason that, owing to the restrictions that were in operation during the war, there has been less work on the roads during the last five or six years than in any period during the last 22 or 23 years. It is dishonest also, in this sense, that we are taking a class composed of the lowest paid workers in this State—and more shame it was for us to do it—the agricultural workers, and deliberately pegging down thousands of working men to their standard. Let me put this to the Minister and to those who use that argument about the agricultural workers. The rate of wages fixed for agricultural workers is the minimum rate.

I am very glad to be able to say this, that there are great numbers of decent farmers in this country who are paying a wage to their workers that is substantially in advance of the minimum of £2 per week. Let me put the other point, and in doing so do not take me for one moment as suggesting that even now the agricultural worker is being paid anything like what he should be paid. If the industry could afford a better wage he certainly should get it. But the fact is that the agricultural workers wages have been at least doubled. They have been increased by 100 per cent. to meet the increased cost of living, whereas the road workers' wages have not been increased by 10 per cent. I want to put to the Minister and to his Parliamentary Secretary who is sitting beside him, that, as ordinary men, we know what the cost is of the ordinary necessities of life to-day: the cost of clothes, of boots and of food. In the case of road workers and quarry workers, there is more wear and tear on their clothes and boots than there is in the case of men in normal occupations. In that situation, what is the use in saying that these men can support themselves and those depending on them on a wage of 39/- or £2 a week? It cannot be done. Is it not absurd, therefore, to be talking here about hospitals, about the millions of pounds spent on tuberculosis, to be talking about malnutrition and about bringing up a healthy race? How can a healthy race be brought up on such wages with the cost of living what it is to-day, especially when we think of the cost of boots and the cost of clothes? I defy contradiction of this: that a pair of boots or shoes bought to-day, particularly children's boots, will not last a quarter of the time that a pair of boots or shoes bought seven years ago would have lasted. That statement cannot be contested.

What case can the Minister make to the House for this section? I challenge any Deputy who has a conscience to go into the Lobby and vote for putting Emergency Powers Order No. 216 into our permanent legislation. If there is one scandal greater than another of which we have been guilty, it is the way in which that standstill Order has been operated, remembering the circumstances and the atmosphere in which it was introduced. The Government said at the beginning of the emergency that, if we were not to have chaos and inflation, profits and wages would have to be controlled.

Will any man on any side of the House say that the Government have been able to maintain the balance between profits and wages? Would the Minister dare to suggest that? Will he try to reconcile a 72 per cent. increase in the cost of living with a 10 per cent. pegged-down increase in wages? And that 4/- a week goes only to the lowest-paid section of workers. Small as is that figure of 39/- a week—and it is small enough—the workers are not sure even of that, when broken time is deducted from their wages. With weather such as we have had recently, some of those men would be fortunate to get three days' work a week. Are we to remain for ever in the days of the past? What do we mean by saying that we have our freedom if we are not able to give a better standard of living to the man and his family than can be extracted from 39/- a week? All that talk about freedom is, in such circumstances, so much froth.

I believe that this country can afford a better standard than that. I believe that the Minister has sufficient power to control any move by any public authority to give more than a just wage. The members of local authorities, particularly the members of county councils, constituted as such councils are, are just men. I do not think that they could be described as extravagant or wasteful when dealing with the ratepayers' money. You will not get an increase from the average county council unless the members are fully satisfied that the increase is merited. Nobody with any experience of county councils will dispute that. Thousands of families will be affected by this provision, and it brings us back to Section 27, which we discussed a short time ago. The local authority, when striking a rate to be paid by local people, with a knowledge of local conditions and of the men they employ, decide, after due consideration, to give a moderate increase. In no case has it been suggested that an extravagant increase has been given by a local authority. That having been done, a letter is received from the Custom House stating that the Minister refuses to sanction the increase. You may be talking about your hospitals, Public Health Bills, tuberculosis, and schemes that are to cost millions. Until such time as you feed and clothe the children as they should be fed and clothed, you will have disease, and you will require Public Health Bills and so forth. You will not have a healthy nation.

Comment on this

It is important that every member of this House should realise that, during the next year, we shall be marking the character of the society we propose to have in this country. If we do not realise that, we shall make a terrible mess of our national affairs. We are at a colour point in the social and even in the political life of the country and the manner in which we mould our institutions will have a very radical effect upon us. It is made clear in this Bill more than anywhere else that we are doing that. If we are not going to say that the society we are to have will be one that will maintain itself by wages earned in employment, then we are entering a very disastrous social situation. With the lips of Ministers dripping so much regarding social services, it is a shocking thing that in a measure which gives the Minister for Local Government so much power over administrative machinery and the lives of our people there should be a clause showing that we are pinning the salaries and income of a large section of our people to a level which cannot maintain those who are doing vital work in carrying out social services. We hear a lot about the ideals which we had in the past. We hear a lot about Pearse. What was Pearse doing in 1913? He was writing a pamphlet to put courage and energy into our people and he was declaring that it was a crying shame that employers in the City of Dublin should think they were properly employing a man when they paid him £1 per week. He looked for revolution and revolutionary feelings in Dublin because men and women in the city were being asked to support their families on a wage of £1 a week.

What are we paying the road workers of South Tipperary? Forty shillings a week, at a time when the cost-of-living figure is 298—three times greater than it was in 1938. The Minister is preventing the local authority from paying wages higher than the equivalent of 13/- a week when Pearse was challenging the whole social idea of expecting men to work in the City of Dublin for 20/- per week. The Minister brings in the ghastly figure of Emergency Order No. 216 and pins back the wages of local employees to what they were in October, 1942, except for the change of terms. The cost of living in August, 1942, was 250. It is now 298. It has risen one-fifth since the date of the figure the Minister seeks to insert in permanent legislation as the level above which wages or salaries of local employees cannot be raised without his express sanction— the express sanction of a man who declined to receive six members of a county council, who were anxious to come up here, putting themselves to the inconvenience and expense to plead with the Minister that they could not look upon men in their employment endeavouring to rear families on 40/- a week. They asked if they could come at their own expense, and in their own time, to plead with the Minister to lift his ban and to enable them to raise wages by a few shillings.

The Minister was not here the other night when I was putting certain aspects of this matter before the House. We are anxious to keep our people at home. We proclaim loudly that we are anxious to see our people staying at home under conditions in which they will be able to raise educated families in comfort and decency, in circumstances under which they can live in a Christian way, get most out of their resources, more out of their abilities and out of their capacity to do good for themselves and their country. We boast of these things to people who ought to live and stay here, but a man who was condemned by the Minister's edict to remain at work here at 40/- a week, when the cost of living has risen 300 per cent., can go to Great Britain and become an ordinary British soldier and after a few months' training, by the 1st July of this year, if he is married, he can get 42/- a week for himself and 25/- for his wife or a total of 67/- a week, as well as food and clothing.

Comment on this

And his wife would get one dried egg a month.

Comment on this

His wife can stay in her Irish home, and she will get more to keep herself and her family here than the man would be paid under the regulation made by the Minister. Does the Minister seriously argue that this is a section that should be in any permanent legislation? How does the Minister think that men and women are going to live in this country and rear families, if the State machine, employing permanent and necessary servants on essential services, is going to pay them such wages and salaries as would not maintain their families? How does the Minister think that a society like that can build expensive hotels, can build expensive roads, or build expensive luxury hotels for luxury-minded visitors who come here? Surely the Minister must realise that his whole outlook on the world is upset. Surely he cannot realise that he is talking to an Irish Parliament that wants to concern itself with every aspect of our national affairs, and that wants to build on solid ground. Surely the Minister realises that Irishmen never had any strength in either economic or political life except the strength of the mind and the strength of heart of its men and women. To what condition will the men and women of this country be reduced if our public services are to be reduced to the state the Minister wants to reduce them? I asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister recently whether any examination had been made into the cost of things required to keep a man and his family, which would warrant him suggesting that 40/- a week at the present cost of living in Ireland would keep such a family. I ask that question again now. I do not think the Minister should ask us to pass this section, without giving us some particulars as to the wages and salaries that are being paid to the lower-paid classes in the service of local government.

Comment on this

There is an aspect of this question which is worthy of the attention of the House, and one which, I should say, has a practical application as far as the section is concerned. The Minister defended it on the grounds that wages and salaries may be increased with his consent. I suggest that a matter the House should consider is whether that consent shall be withheld unreasonably in the light of events as we see them. The Order Paper for a number of weeks past contained a series of questions relating to bonus Orders for staffs of public authorities. I know for a positive fact that a number of public authorities suggested that bonuses, which operated in other public services from the 1st January, should be extended to the employees of these bodies. In his reply the Parliamentary Secretary admitted that there were at least eight such authorities. But the actual position is —and I want the Minister to face up to this—that a state of shall I call it unsettlement and indecision has arisen in local affairs recently, as between the Custom House, county managers and local authorities, which is not making for good local administration.

I think it will not be denied by anybody with experience, much as we may abuse the system of county management—which we may leave aside now— that there are aspects of the actual position, as far as county managers in their administration are concerned, with which from our experience we may very well sympathise. We must know from experience that, in fact, there are occasions when they are between the hammer and the anvil, and a situation has arisen now when some managers feel that if they make certain approaches to the Custom House they will be unfavourably received, and in consequence they are immediately up against local councils. I suggest to the Minister, anxious as he is for the success of the County Management Act, that he might pay attention immediately to that indecision and unsettlement on the part of county managers. No better start, as far as public authorities are concerned, could be made than on the question of salaries and wages. Managers are undecided, shall I say, whether they can afford to make an approach or not, lest they encourage the displeasure of the Miniter. I think that will not be denied. The result is that a number of managers have actually sent in recommendations in connection with bonuses, but so far there has been no indication that the Minister is prepared to give consent, or what is still more important, to give any direction to local authorities, to wit county managers, that they may certify in connection with bonus Orders.

I suggest the time has arrived when this foggy atmosphere should be cleared so far as the managers and the Minister are concerned and that a smoother and more harmonious arrangement, resulting in good administration of local councils, might very well be influenced by closer collaboration between the local authority and the Minister on the lines I have indicated.

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey has alarmed some of us by stating that this section is an effort to enshrine in an Act of Parliament the most unpopular Emergency Powers Order ever brought into this House, that is, the Order clamping down wages of workers while the cost of living continues to rise. If that is the position, it is up to every member of this House who is here to-night to keep the debate going. Each Deputy should state the case as he knows it in his constituency and the debate should be kept going until we have a fuller House to listen to us. Only half the members have been in the House to-day for the discussion of this most important Bill. The absence of members is deplorable. If this is an effort to bring in as part of permanent legislation an Emergency Powers Order that will keep down wages while the cost of living is increasing—every Deputy knows that the cost of living will further increase in the next month or two—we ought to show our strength and the Deputies of the Minister's Party should be the first to stand up and appeal to the Minister not to put them in the false position, the unenviable position, of having to support the section that he is asking the House to accept.

Deputy Mulcahy, very properly, drew attention to conditions and wages operating on the other side. The Minister's contribution was that the soldier's wife who went to England would get "one egg a month". Now that he knows that there is only one egg a month for the gallant people on the other side who are giving employment to thousands of our countrymen, what is he going to do about improving the position for the people who are bearing such hardships and for our people who are sharing the hardships with them? The fact that they have only one egg a month is no reason why he should taunt Deputy Mulcahy or use that as a lever to induce our workers not to seek high wages or to look for better conditions. There are many women in this country who would be very happy if they could get passports and cross the water, join their husbands, put up with the conditions there and have the one egg a month rather than endure the conditions here and be without their husbands and see their children, as Deputy Morrissey said, half naked and cold. They would take that risk. I think it is up to the Government to see that the conditions of our loyal body of workers, as outlined by Deputies Mulcahy, Morrissey and O'Sullivan, are improved. We see children who are cold and shivering for the want of clothing while the shares of drapery houses and clothing manufacturers who are manufacturing shoddy clothing are increasing, in some cases tenfold, because the Minister did not clamp down profits. We have only to look at the Stock Exchange returns to see that the shares of various concerns engaged in the clothing business jumped from 3/- and 4/- to 23/- and 24/-, within five years, because the Minister who is now so determined to enshrine in permanent legislation the standstill wages Order was not able to keep down the cost of living as represented in the high prices for clothing.

In many cases working-class people are not able to buy clothing because of the high prices. In at least one house in this city the shares increased tenfold without any effort on the part of the people associated with the concern but simply because they saw and availed of the opportunity. Clothing was wanted. Boots were wanted. The Minister could not keep down the cost of living. To-night he is trying to embody in permanent legislation the clamping down of wages. It is up to every member of the House to resist the Minister in his efforts.

Comment on this

I join with Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Byrne in protesting in very strong terms against any proposal to enshrine in permanent legislation any measure such as the Emergency Powers Order which controlled wages. If any Order made by the present Government got the vast majority of the citizens up against them, it was the standstill wages Order. To-day I raise the question as to how any unfortunate working man could be expected to exist at the present rate of county council wages, 39/- a week. I am the member of the Laoighis County Council who proposed a resolution to grant an increased bonus of 4/- per week to the county council workers of Laoighis. Deputy Gorry, representing the Fianna Fáil Party on the council, saw fit to fall in line with the resolution and it was passed unanimously. The resolution instructed the county manager to forward for the sanction of the Local Government Department a proposal for an increase of 4/- per week in the wages of our employees. At a meeting of the county council four weeks later, the county manager stated that he had not sent the resolution to the Local Government Department and that he would not sent it to the Department because, as he pointed out, it was Government policy to keep wages of local authorities' employees under the agricultural wage rates. A sewerage scheme caretaker and a nurse in an in stitution are employees of the local authority. I cannot see what relation the wages of a nurse in a hospital or of a sewerage scheme caretaker has to the wages of an agricultural labourer. I do not understand how the Minister or the Government has arrived at the miserable sum of £2 per week as the wage basis for agricultural workers, nor do I understand why it should be taken as a basis for local authority employees, whose wages must be 1/- or 1/6 less than that figure.

Deputy Byrne pointed out a few moments ago the conditions in England. Does the Minister realise that the 175,000 able-bodied Irishmen who are employed in Great Britain to-day did not leave this country for the love of England or the love of the British Empire? It was not their intention to go over to slave in the malt-houses and munition factories in England in order to help England's war effort. It was simply because this Government failed to give them even an existence in their own country. The Government saw fit to bring in an Order which, as Deputy Morrissey has pointed out, they are now trying to embody in permanent legislation, to keep the working-class people of this country in misery, semi-starvation, and poverty, as we have seen for many years past. I say that is the sole reason why the vast majority of our young men went across the Irish Sea to the land of our traditional enemy to slave in coalmines, munition factories and malt-houses during the past six or seven years simply because they were denied the right to a fair wage and a decent standard of living here in their own country.

Does the Minister realise that the legislation he is trying to put over on this House at the moment is absolutely contrary to Christian teachings? Does he recall the statement of the great Pope Leo XIII that every worker was entitled to a living wage in order to enable him to bring up his family in Christian decency? Wages, he said, should be sufficient to enable any worker to rear his family in Christian decency. Surely, the Government is not acting in accordance with Christian principles when they wish to have legislation passed here giving the Minister authority if he so desires to increase or decrease wages? I think this House should protest in the strongest possible terms against any attempt to make a permanent fixture of the wages standstill Order. If there is one thing to which the workers of this country are awake to-day it is to the prevalence of low wages. I warn any Fianna Fáil Deputy from my constituency that if he votes for this legislation I shall make it very hot for him in my constituency and I should be very glad if other Opposition Deputies would throw out the same challenge to Government Deputies in their constituencies.

We are going to make that fact known throughout the length and breadth of the various constituencies. I challenge any Deputy representing my constituency on the Government benches to get up and say that he will stand over the Minister's action in trying to make the wages standstill Order a permanent fixture. There are people, county council workers, in that constituency who are toiling from sunrise to nightfall, from week-end to week-end, and these workers, as Deputy Mulcahy pointed out in this House a fortnight ago, are trying to exist on 39/- a week and to rear large families. Some of them are living in county council houses in towns where the cost of living has increased by leaps and bounds.

I may say that I am put to the pin of my collar to try to exist on £10 a week and I fail to see how any unfortunate citizen can exist on the wages paid by local authorities on turf production, drainage or other schemes carried out by local authorities. No steps have been taken by the Government to improve the lot of these poor working people. If anything put the writing on the wall for the Fianna Fáil Party, it was the wages standstill Order and the one piece of legislation that will complete the writing on the wall for them is the introduction of this section to a Local Government Bill. I hope Deputies generally will act in accordance with the dictates of their consciences and I believe there is no Deputy whose conscience is so bad as to leave him under the impression that any employee of a local authority can exist on his present wages. How can a man be expected to feed and clothe his family on these miserable wages? The vast majority of the children are going around the country half naked. I see them in my own constituency going bare-footed and half naked through hail and frost, wading through floods in their bare feet to school and no steps have been taken to give any consideration to the conditions under which the parents of these children have to exist owing to the standstill Order. I submit that wages ought to be sufficient to enable every person to live in decency.

I trust that the Minister's attention will be drawn to the seriousness of the present situation. I believe the situation has become so serious that workers throughout the country are prepared to rise up in arms to protest against this standstill Order. The day is coming when no decent citizen will sit on a local authority because when local authorities do grant an increase of wages to their workers, they are told that it is a matter for the Minister and that they have no voice in it. When in Leix we increased workers' wages by 4/- a week we saw that we were up against it and that all our talk at the county council was just so much hot air. The decision was not implemented and will not be implemented. Here we are now faced with a proposal to put into permanent legislation a provision that all future wage increases will be controlled in a similar manner. Is it any wonder that tuberculosis has got such a great grip on the country seeing that the vast majority of workers of the country and their children are half starved? The only cure for tuberculosis is good food, sufficient woollens and clothing, and proper housing accommodation, and a man cannot provide these things unless he has proper wages. Until such time as wages are fixed at such a rate that workers will be able to purchase the necessities of life, to keep themselves and their children well nourished and well clothed, there seems to be little hope of success for the attempts of the Government to combat the awful scourge of tuberculosis. Low wages are responsible for present conditions. Surely to goodness half-starved parents cannot be expected to nourish properly their children; because, if the parents are half-starved, it follows that the children must be starved entirely.

That is really a very gloomy picture to paint in this House, but it is a picture of the position as I see it in my constituency. I trust that some steps will be taken to remedy that awful state of affairs. I believe, with Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy Morrissey and others, that we could offer our people a much better standard of living. Did it ever occur to the Minister that shortly before the war broke out there were thousands of people unemployed in England? Does the Minister remember reading of a black coffin being carried up to 10 Downing Street by the unemployed as a protest against the awful conditions which the working people had to endure at that time? Does he recall that hundreds of people died outside the railings of Hyde Park from hunger? Does the Minister remember when thousands of people were lying on the streets of Manchester, Liverpool, Hull and other cities in England with cards tied on their breasts proclaiming that they were dying of poverty and hunger?

Does the Minister remember that within two months after the war broke out wages in England were increased by at least six times as compared with the period to which I refer? It was found possible to pay £10 per week in cases where only 10/- per week was paid formerly and every available man was put into productive employment. Even the women were put into full employment. Those who were not capable of work, such as cripples, were given the job of sitting and looking at others working and were paid wages as timekeepers and overseers. They were given a decent wage, not a miserable 39/- or £2 a week. I know the case of a cripple in Hull who had not worked since the war which ended in 1918, and during the last war he was in receipt of £9 per week simply for sitting and looking on at others working. We cannot give our able-bodied men any more than £2 a week to carry out the Taoiseach's appeal to produce more food in order to provide our people with the necessities of life. Does the Minister remember all those incidents in England? I am sure that his memory is not so failing that he cannot go back over the past five or six years, when any amount of money could be provided for war and for the destruction of mankind and civilisation, but not a penny piece could be found for the thousands who died from hunger and exposure before the war. I want to throw out a challenge in this House to any Deputy from my constituency to support the Minister in this, and if any Deputy from my constituency does support the Minister, I am prepared to go from north to south of my constituency and expose the thing in much stronger language than I have used here to-night.

Comment on this

The section which we are discussing seems to have a very much wider signification than a section merely conferring on the Minister the power to remunerate the employees of local authorities. It appears to me that the section gives an indication that what was war-time Government policy of low wages and salaries, justified by emergency conditions, is now becoming their policy for peace and their policy for a long term because, as has been pointed out, this section embodies in it the principles of the Emergency Powers Standstill Order (No. 216). The Minister stated that the only object of the section was to enable the Minister to have power to prevent local authorities increasing the remuneration of their employees without his consent. I have always understood that that was the existing legal position. Now, I hesitate to state, as a matter of law, anything in connection with local government law. It was stated in a recent case, or cases, by an eminent judge, that he had once taken a plunge into the jungle of local government law—a very good description of local government law. In the course of his remarks, speaking about the denizens of the jungle, he said that the difference between the denizens of the jungle and the denizens of the jungle of local government law was that the denizens in the jungle knew their way about the jungle, whereas the denizens of the jungle of local government did not know their way through the jungle of local government. I hesitate, therefore, to express an opinion on any matter concerned with local government, but I do think that it was always the law that the Minister had power to see that remuneration was not increased without his sanction. I am not sure whether that is so or not. If it be so, then what is the necessity for this section? If it be not so, and the Minister is seeking such powers, why is this section based entirely on the emergency legislation? There can be only one conclusion from that: that what was the war-time policy of the Government is now becoming their long-term, peace-time policy.

I want to affirm and reaffirm my political faith, that was so well and ably stated by Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Mulcahy, and that is that we believe that it is not merely possible but essential to bring about an increase in the purchasing power of the people of this country, and that can be brought about by increasing wages and thereby increasing purchasing power. The policy of the Government has been the opposite to that—to depreciate wages and, accordingly, to depreciate purchasing power. They pegged down the wages of the worker during the emergency, but they failed miserably to peg down the prices of essential commodities. Here we have an Act of Parliament purporting to be part of a code and part of local government law, and which would codify all the statutes dealing with that particular branch of the law, and yet into that must be put a section which bears all the marks of the Emergency Powers Standstill Order (No. 216). There can be only one conclusion from that: that this is an indication that since this section is being put into a permanent Act, then, by virtue of that fact, so long as this Government is there, that will be the standard policy so far as the workers, in particular, are concerned: a policy of keeping down wages and depreciating purchasing power, while at the same time not taking power to keep down prices of essential commodities.

We stand for a different policy from that, a policy of increasing wages and, thereby, increasing purchasing power. We hear a lot of talk about the social services, but the less social services you have to provide your people with, the more it is an indication that your people are happy and contented, and the more social services you have to provide it is an indication that the people are unable to keep their wives and children in a decent standard of comfort. It is the boast of the present Government that they have set up a great many social services, such as free milk, free school books, and so on, but the more of these social services there are, the more it is an indication that there is disease in the body politic, and the more employment there is, the less social services you require. If you increase the standard of living, increase wages, and so increase purchasing power, you can then decrease the necessity for the multiplicity of social services which we are creating in this country and, thereby, increasing taxation. You can decrease taxation by decreasing the social services, and you can decrease the necessity for all these social services by pursuing a reverse policy to that which is being pursued here, a policy of low wages, which means a decrease in purchasing power. If you increase wages, you increase purchasing power and, as a consequence, there will be less taxation necessary to provide for these social services.

Comment on this

When the devil was sick, the devil a saint would be;——

Comment on this

That is an old one.

Comment on this

——when the devil was well, the devil a saint was he.

Comment on this

Can you not think of anything better than that? That is a very old cry.

Comment on this

It is. It is like the old Fine Gael cry about the poor workers, and Fine Gael are very sick now. It was amusing to hear Deputy Mulcahy on wages and it was also amusing to hear Deputy Flanagan. Deputy Flanagan, some time ago, was very eloquent in this House on the salaries that were being paid to Deputies, and he now tells us that he cannot live on the £10 a week he is getting. He proposed an increase, which, I take it, Deputy Flanagan thought was sufficient, for the road workers of Laoighis from 39/- a week to 43/-. Apparently he thought that 43/- a week would be sufficient for the workers in Laoighis to enable them to rear a wife and family, although he himself cannot live on £10 a week.

Comment on this

He has gone out now.

Comment on this

Yes, he has gone out, and I should like him to hear this.

When I endeavoured on the last section to raise another matter, I noticed there was general silence in the House, that nobody was interested in it only myself. In this matter we have to face a rather difficult situation. If I am to judge by the general position of the agricultural community and the wages paid to agricultural workers, I am sure there is nobody in this House who will not admit that the agricultural worker is the hardest worked individual in this State to-day. At least 75 per cent. of the farmers can be put on the same basis, because they too have to work the same hours and, in a great number of cases, far longer hours than their employees. Deputy Morrissey said the maximum wage of agricultural workers was 40/- and that employers are willing to pay more. A lot of employers are paying more and when the work is done, they have not 40/- for themselves.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

They were often worse off and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this

They were worse off for a very long time and, if we went back to the policy of Fine Gael again, they would be a damn sight worse off.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Let us hear about the emergency.

Comment on this

I do not want interruptions from Deputy Morrissey. I did not interrupt him.

Comment on this

There are no grounds for interruption.

Comment on this

No. We must remember that the agricultural workers, with their 40/- per week, were not given an opportunity of appearing before a tribunal for a bonus. They were not allowed to put up their case. The farmers were not allowed to show what they were getting for the produce they were producing for this nation during the emergency. I should like to see some of the classes that come under Section 28, which was galloped through here, pegged down on the basis of the agricultural workers' wages. I am not in favour of low wages; I never was and I never will be. I never paid any man in my employment the bare minimum wage. I always paid more. If they were not worth more than the minimum wage to me, I would not keep them. I would vote for an increase in the wages of these workers, and always did when some of the people who are shouting here were trying to pull them down. I voted for an increase when some of the people who are talking very loudly now about the miserable wages paid were endeavouring to cut them down. But I do not say that we are getting value for our money. That is not the fault of the road workers. It is the fault of those who come under Section 28, the supervisors, who are to be whole-time officials in future. When I endeavoured to find out what they were going to be, no Deputy stood up to help me. You cannot get more than a pint out of a pint jug.

Comment on this

That is an insult to the Minister.

Comment on this

If you go over the line in regard to one section of the community, the supervisors, you will not have anything left to give to the men who have to use the shovel and spread the stones. You have to face that condition of affairs. You have to consider the position of 70 per cent. of the population of this country who are living on less than £2 per week.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

If that is so, we ought to be ashamed of it.

Comment on this

When Deputy Morrissey was supporting the previous Government the wages of these men were less than 29/- a week. Deputy Morrissey knows that very well.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I do not.

Comment on this

He should know.

Comment on this

When we took office, the Government was paying them 22/6 a week.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I shall deal with that. It was worth far more then than £2 is now.

Comment on this

I suppose it was.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Deputy is trying to keep going until the tick of 10.30 o'clock.

Comment on this

I will keep going as long as I like.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is not discussing the matter before the House.

Comment on this

I am. If Deputy Morrissey was able to ramble, I have no intention of rambling. I want to keep as close as I can to this matter. Let us find out where we are in connection with this. Is Deputy Morrissey in favour of an increase in the price of agricultural produce?

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I am.

Comment on this

Is he in favour of an increase in the wages of agricultural workers?

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Surely.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy was the person who went around and said the farmers should not get any more than 3d. a gallon for milk.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not well.

Comment on this

They were shouting: "Give us back our markets."

Comment on this

Why did you not do it?

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil are shouting that now.

Comment on this

I wonder will Deputy Mulcahy induce any of the unfortunate farmers he is trying to dope at present to send butter to Great Britain at the present price of butter there?

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

We have not got it for ourselves.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Section 29 is the question before the House.

Comment on this

This has to do with Section 29.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy move to report progress?

Comment on this

I move to report progress.

Comment on this