We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Local Government Bill, 1945—Recommittal.

Contributions 1–174 of 533. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill, 1945
Enacted

No. 32 of 1945 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

In page 6, to delete Section 10 (4), lines 48 to 55, and substitute the following sub-section:—

(4) Expenses of the council of a county which are incurred in meeting a demand made by the commissioners of a town under sub-section (1) of Section 24 of this Act shall consist of—

(a) the amount of the said demand, and

(b) a sum (which shall not, without the consent of the Minister, exceed 7½ per cent. of the amount of the said demand) equal to the estimated amount of rates to be written off as irrecoverable and the costs of collection,

and such expenses shall be charged on the area of the town and shall be known as town charges.

This amendment, I hope, does not outrage the sensibilities of Deputy Mulcahy——

Comment on this

No, because it is Deputy Hughes' amendment.

Comment on this

Call it Deputy Hughes' amendment if that makes it more palatable.

Comment on this

And it was properly discussed in Committee.

Comment on this

The purpose of the amendment, as Deputy Mulcahy has reminded me, is to meet a point raised by Deputy Hughes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:—

In page 6, before Section 10 (5), line 56, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(5) If at the time when the estimate of expenses of a county council for a local financial year is considered in pursuance of Section 24 of the County Management Act, 1940 (No. 12 of 1940) the area on which a portion of such expenses is properly chargeable cannot yet be determined, the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say:—

(a) such portion shall be included in such estimate in the prescribed manner as a county-at-large charge and raised accordingly by means of of the county rate for the said year;

(b) provision shall be made in the prescribed manner in the accounts of the council for determining how much (if any) of such portion should have been charged on any area other than the whole of the county;

(c) if, in accordance with paragraph (b) of this sub-section, it is determined that any amount should have been charged on an area other than the whole of the county an appropriate adjustment shall be made in the prescribed manner in the county rate for a subsequent year by means of an increase in the sum charged on such area and a reduction in the county-at-large charges.

Under the Public Bodies Order, a method has been in force for allocating provisionally the areas to be charged with certain expenses, where the expenses themselves or the areas have not yet been definitely determined. The validity of this provision has not been challenged, and I am advised that there is no doubt with regard to it, but the amendment, in fact, gives statutory authority to a particular provision in the Public Bodies Order of the year 1925.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:—

In page 8, before Section 14, line 26, to insert the following new section:—

14.—(1) Where a hereditament which is situated in a county but not in an urban area and which is not a small dwelling within the meaning of the Local Government (Rates on Small Dwellings) Act, 1928 (No. 4 of 1928), is unoccupied at the making of the county rate, such rate shall be made upon the person (in this section referred to as the owner) who is for the time being entitled to occupy the hereditament and, upon such rate being paid by the owner, he shall be entitled to claim and receive from the council of the county a refund of one-twelfth of such rate in respect of every completed month (reckoned from any day of one month to the corresponding day of the next month) during which the hereditament is unoccupied either for the purpose of the execution of additions, alterations or repairs thereto or because the owner isbona fide unable to obtain a suitable tenant therefor, in the case of a hereditament to which the Rent Restrictions Act, 1946 (No. 4 of 1946), for the time being applies, at the maximum rent for the time being permitted under that Act or, in the case of any other hereditament, at a reasonable rent.

(2) Where—

(a) a rate is made by virtue of this section on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament, and

(b) the hereditament is subsesequently let by or on behalf of the owner, and

(c) the rate or any part thereof is in arrear and unpaid,

the rate collector by whom the rate is collectible may, in addition to and without prejudice to any other remedy for the recovery of the amount of the rate so in arrear and unpaid, serve either personally or by post on the occupier of the hereditament a notice stating the said amount so in arrear and unpaid and requiring the occupier to pay to the rate collector or his successor in office all rent then due or thereafter to become due by him in respect of the hereditament until the said amount is by such payment or otherwise discharged, and thereupon the rate collector or his successor in office shall have the exclusive right to recover, receive and give a good discharge for all rent required by the notice to be paid to him.

(3) A rate made by virtue of this section on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament shall not be invalidated by any error or defect in the statement of the name of the owner or by the use of the description "the owner" without any name or addition, and the rate shall be recoverable from the owner notwithstanding any such error or defect or the use of any such description. The House will perhaps remember that, when the Bill was in Committee Stage, I refrained from moving what was originally Section 22, on the ground that, in the Rent Restrictions Bill, there was a provision relating to rates on unoccupied controlled premises, and it was proposed to take the opportunity, during the later progress of that Bill, to delete that provision, and, when that was done, to move on Report to reinsert the original section as it appeared in the Local Government Bill, as originally circulated. Accordingly, this amendment appears with amendment No. 6 on the paper, but we have decided to extend perhaps the provisions a little and to have a separate section dealing with rates on vacant premises in county areas as well as with rates on vacant premises in urban areas.

This amendment, which I suggest should be taken with amendment No. 6, deals with the rates on vacant premises in the county, and, as will be seen, the rates, where premises are unoccupied, will be charged on the owner, but the owner will be entitled to be recouped for the rates in respect of these premises, if he shows that the premises have been unoccupied for repairs, or alterations, or because he cannot get a tenant at the controlled rent, or, if the premises should happen not to be controlled, at a reasonable rent. The refund will be made to him at the rate of one-twelfth for every month during which the premises were so unoccupied, but I should like to make it quite clear that the onus of showing that the premises are unoccupied by reason of the fact that they are the subject of repairs or alterations, or because the owner cannot get a tenant at the controlled or at a reasonable rent, will rest on the owner of the premises.

I should like to say that the section —particularly Section 6—does not limit the amount to a refund of six months' rates as in the case of the Cities of Dublin and Limerick. The circum stances, I suggest, in the rural areas and smaller towns, are such that a limit to the refunds might occur in some cases where premises could not possibly be let for any purpose.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

This is a most cumbersome and difficult section to understand. I submit it introduces a completely new principle into the Bill. The Minister goes much further than he even said he would. There is a proposal here that the rate collector shall recover rates by taking possession of the rent of a house. I would like to hear the Minister on that aspect. The Minister talked about allowance being made if a house were unoccupied, provided that the owner established that he was unable to get a tenant at the regulated rent. That does not appear in the section at all. What the section says is very wide—namely, a suitable tenant. We are all aware as to what house owners nowadays classify as suitable tenants. Nowadays a man with one or two children is looked upon as a very unsuitable tenant indeed. I would like to hear the Minister elaborate on that a little more. This is one of the sections (if I may say so again, with respect), that I am extremely doubtful should be discussed on the Report Stage of the Bill. It is something which has not been before us in this Bill up to now. I think the Minister should give the House a fuller explanation (1) of the necessity for this, and (2) of the way in which it is expected to work.

Comment on this

Due notice was given on the Committee Stage of the Bill when this or a similar section was not moved that provisions or proposals of this sort would be reintroduced on the Report Stage of this Bill.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I beg to differ from the Minister. We had not this before us at any time. This bears no, or very little, resemblance to the section which the Minister speaks about as not having been moved. I submit that this section is, like another famous section to which Deputy Mulcahy referred on the Committee Stage, an after-thought. It should not be before the House at all.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say what particular amendment he is speaking about when he says the amendment was before the House but was not actually moved and was reserved for discussion in this form now?

Comment on this

I have explained that in the Bill, as originally approved on Second Reading, there appeared Section 20 dealing with rates on vacant premises in urban areas. I have said that for convenience it would be quite simple—and I do not think it would be unprecedented or contrary to rules or order—if a verbal amendment were made to introduce here after the word "urban" the words "and county". I do not think an amendment of that sort, if moved, could possibly be objected to because we want to make it quite clear exactly what we propose to do. In order, if you like, that it will be easier to discuss, we have introduced two separate sections— one dealing with premises in urban areas and one dealing with premises in county areas. The section originally in the Bill was Section 20.

Comment on this

I have it here.

Comment on this

I think if anybody studies the original text that he will find a close resemblance between Section 20 and amendment No. 6. As I have already explained, due notice was given that it was not proposed to move that particular section at the time because of a certain duplication in the Rent Restrictions Bill. It was understood that when the corresponding provisions had been removed from the Rent Restrictions Bill this section would be reintroduced into this Bill.

Comment on this

So that we are now practically discussing for the first time Section 20 in the form of the two amendments that are now before us.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

And something more.

Comment on this

They were referred to in the debate on the Second Reading.

Comment on this

On the Second Reading; but we are now discussing the effect of these proposals and we are discussing it in Committee. We may welcome, particularly in respect of rural areas, a provision by which premises which are vacant for adequate reasons will not have rates levied upon them. By that particular kind of relief we will get rid of this appalling anomaly which was so widespread where houses were reduced to a dilapidated condition by the removal of roofs, or in other ways, in order to escape being classified as habitable houses or houses capable of occupation. But I think there are aspects of the proposal here that require attention.

The amendments contemplate the possibility of a dispute arising between a local authority and the owner of a premises whereby, in the case of ownership passing from one to another, the local authority will regard the outgoing owner—if I may so describe him —as liable for the payment of rates which, in fact, he escaped; that is, the local authority considers the possibility that they will disagree that a house before it was occupied by, say, owner B was not vacant by reason of the fact that there were additions, or alterations, or repairs being made thereto or by reason of the fact that a suitable tenant at a reasonable cost could not be obtained. The new section, as it stands, means that the local authority will have the power of deciding whether or not a suitable tenant could have been got and that a reasonable rent would have been paid by such suitable tenant. Coming to that conclusion they can themselves issue an instruction to the rent collector and the rent collector will immediately, by virtue of the terms of this section, take possession of the rent payable by occupier B in respect of a debt that had occurred in the opinion of the local authority before his time. I submit that here you have a question of fact and a question of judgement which should not be left to either the local authority on the one hand, if it is the local authority the Minister has in mind as being the body that should come to the decision, or to the rate collector, if the rate collector is the person who is being given a judicial function in this matter by this section.

I submit that it is utterly unreasonable, if it is not actually unconstitutional, for the Minister to seek by this section to confer a judicial function on a local authority or on a rate collector that would empower them to adjudicate on the question of whether a particular tenant was a suitable one and one offering a reasonable rent. That is a matter that should not be left to either the local authority or to the rate collector and at least the District Court should be brought in to decide these matters before it would be possible to consider reasonable that occupier B should be called upon to hand over rent in respect of a debt that was owed to the local authority by a previous person.

Comment on this

Why should you do that in any case? I take it that the former occupier was liable for the rate. If he gets away without discharging his liabilities to the local authority and if the local authority are not quick enough to collect the rate that has accrued under the occupancy of the former occupier, why should you turn around then and saddle someone else with the responsibility of paying his debts?

Comment on this

Why does not the Deputy read the section? Why does not he read what is proposed? There is not a word about a former occupier in the section.

Comment on this

What is the rent going to be seized for—for what type of debt?

Comment on this

There is not a word about a former occupier in the section.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say what is the difference between this section and the law as it is at present? At the present time the county council are not entitled to collect rents on vacant premises. Is not that so?

Comment on this

No; this relates to rates on unoccupied premises.

Comment on this

A great deal of fraud is perpetrated under the existing law and will be under this section. County councils have come across cases before now, where men would not let premises for any rent, however reasonable. There have been cranks and faddists who would not let their premises under any provision. Instead of setting out to safeguard persons who have unoccupied premises, the Minister should see that the local authority would be safeguarded to a greater extent and that all dwellings that are fit for occupation should be rateable. That is the opinion of local authorities, that all dwellings that are in good order should be rateable and that rates should be collected in respect of them. At the present time and at any time when there is great shortage of dwellinghouses there is no reason why there should be a refund of rates in respect of any house that is unoccupied if the house is occupiable and is in proper sanitary condition. There is no reason for such a provision and local authorities should be allowed to collect rates on any dwellinghouse that is occupiable.

Comment on this

There is another point. So far as a hereditament in the country is concerned, supposing it is vacant but that the farmyard is being used and supposing there is a house in the yard for a workman, which is occupied, what is the position? The Minister has not given us a definition of an unoccupied hereditament. I would like to have a definition of an unoccupied hereditament in the country because it might serve a man's purpose very well not to have a dwellinghouse occupied but to use the out-offices attached to the dwellinghouse and to use a workman's house in the yard.

Comment on this

And pay no rates.

Comment on this

And allow the dwellinghouse to fall into disuse.

Comment on this

I do not know where all this confusion arises. It is a well-known fact that, as Deputy Mulcahy himself admitted, in order to evade the payment of rates upon houses or buildings which might have been used at some time or other, the houses are virtually dismantled. I do not know whether or not the Leader of the Opposition thinks that that is a good thing. I gather that he does not. I think he welcomed this provision, because at least it would remove that inducement from people wilfully to put their property into a condition in which it could not be occupied or used for any useful purpose. That is what we are trying to do here. At the same time, we do not want to benefit a man who wilfully refuses to allow his premises to be occupied. The purpose of the section is made quite clear. First of all, he has to pay the rates. He is bound to pay the rates. The rates are levied and charged on him, in the first place, but he is entitled to claim and to receive a refund from the council if he can show that the hereditament is unoccupied either for the purpose of the execution of additions, alterations or repairs—I think that no person can regard that as being unreasonable.

Comment on this

When is it decided that a hereditament is unoccupied?

Comment on this

The Deputy had better go and read the common law reports in relation to that matter and he will find that there is a long series of decisions dealing with that. I could not possibly undertake to give the Deputy the benefit of all the legal learning that has gone to determine that point. Most county councils would appreciate when a hereditament is unoccupied for the purpose of this section because, remember, they are the people who have to make the refund; they are, as the section goes, the proximate judges as to when a refund should be given. If the Deputy will permit me, I was saying that the owner of the premises was entitled to a refund and could claim a refund when he could show that these premises were unoccupied either for the purpose of the execution of additions, alterations or repairs, that is to say, that they were not in his own occupation and that they were not in the occupation of a tenant and that additions, alterations or repairs were being carried out to the premises or because the owner isbona fide unable to obtain a suitable tenant therefor. Deputy Morrissey suggested that the owner might regard a tenant who had children as being an unsuitable tenant. It does not matter what the owner's opinion is. The opinion that counts in the first instance in the matter is the opinion, I assume, of the county council.

Comment on this

That is the manager.

Comment on this

Of the manager, certainly, the properly constituted authority. We are not going to have the council meet to determine whether a person with or without children is a suitable tenant for premises which are not occupied. So that, so far as Deputy Morrissey's suggestion is concerned, that this amendment would in fact be of advantage to the man who would not let premises to a tenant who had children, I think it is clear that there is no substance in it. We are not going to assume that a county manager would take up that anti-social attitude because, if he did, I think he would be speedily dealt with. Deputy Mulcahy, who has got very fond of litigation and law, suggests that before any claim can be allowed under this section we should initiate court proceedings; that the district justice should be called in to settle what is not a question of law, but a question of fact that could quite easily be settled, to the satisfaction of the rate-making authority, at any rate, by any ordinary person of common sense. I think it would be a preposterous procedure that a man having premises to which alterations or repairs are being carried out and who is entitled to a refund under this section in regard to rates charged on him in respect of these premises should, before he can get that refund, have to take proceedings in the District Court. That is what Deputy Mulcahy suggests.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

The Deputy asked who is going to adjudicate in the matter. It is not a question of a judicial decision; it has nothing to do with the law. It is a decision and an opinion formed in regard to facts. The Deputy asked who is to adjudicate in this matter, who is to exercise this judicial function. He said first that it ought to be a judge. He then mended his hand a little and said that, instead of a judge of the High Court or the Supreme Court, he would be satisfied with a justice of the District Court. I think that would be altogether too cumbersome a method for dealing with an ordinary matter of business and with an issue which could be determined by an ordinary man of common sense.

Comment on this

The Minister is insulting the intelligence of the House.

Comment on this

Then we have the next hare started by Deputy Mulcahy again. The Deputy wants to know what is all this about in sub-section (2) of the section. The sub-section reads:—

"Where (a) a rate is made by virtue of this section on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament...."

He said that these might be rates payable by a previous occupier. That is where Deputy Hughes got his idea about a previous occupier—from his Leader, Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

What about paragraph (c)?

Comment on this

I am coming to (c). Where the rate or any part thereof is in arrear and unpaid, the rate collector would be entitled to require the person who subsequently entered into occupation of these premises to pay over to him towards the discharge of the unpaid rates which were due by the owner the rent otherwise payable to the owner. That has nothing to do with the question of the previous occupier, unless the previous occupier happened to be the owner. So long as the premises are otherwise unoccupied the rates are chargeable on the owner. But a case might quite conceivably arise where an owner, knowing very well that he would not be entitled to a refund in respect of unoccupied premises, because he could not show that these premises were unoccupied by reason of the fact that additions, alterations or repairs were being carried out to them, or because he could not find a suitable tenant for them, might not pay any rates at all, even though the rates were charged upon him. Then, having got tired of keeping the premises unoccupied, he might quite easily let them to a tenant who would pay him the rent which he demanded.

In that event, this is the remedy which the county council has. The owner has not paid the rates. The premises become occupied. The rate collector is entitled to collect the rent towards the discharge of the rates properly payable by the owner of these premises. He is entitled to do that without prejudice to any other steps he might choose to take for the collection of the rates which are due. I do not see what all the pother has been about. There is nothing new in that principle. Surely, if the rates are due by the owner, then any income arising out of the premises can be quite easily, in accordance with the law, diverted to the discharge of the owner's rightful debts to the local authority.

Comment on this

The section contemplates two persons. One is the owner of the unoccupied premises. The Minister forgot to say that this was an Act of mine. I knew he forgot something.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy has reminded me of that fact.

Comment on this

As I say, there are two persons contemplated, the person who owns the property, which happens to be an unoccupied house, and the person who enters into occupation of that house. If the rate collector or the local authority wakes up to the fact that before the second person entered into occupation, the owner owed certain rates, the rate collector can demand from the second person, the occupier, that he should pay to the local authority the rent due to the owner until such time as the debt owed by the owner to the local authority is paid off. Suppose the occupier says: "I will not; I am going to pay the rent to the man who rented me the house." The position then, before the law as it would stand, would be that the local authority has a case against the owner in the first instance for not having paid the rates and against the occupier in the second instance for not having paid over the rent demanded by the local authority under the Act as it would appear if this section is inserted. The intention is not to proceed against the owner of the property, who is the real breaker of the law in the matter, but against the newly-manufactured criminal under this section, the person who becomes the occupier and who will not pay over the rent demanded under this section as a payment in lieu of rates.

Can the Minister say why, in the name of common sense, the action that would lie at law on the part of the local authority against the person who is withholding the rates should not be taken, and why, in an inequitable way, they have to bring some person in between and say: "It will be easier to get it off this poor fellow; the man of property is a fellow who might stand up against us, but the unfortunate person, who is not a man of property, and who has to rent a house from somebody else, will be an easier mark; he will be cowed and overawed"? It is a fantastic proposal.

Comment on this

I should like if the Minister would try to make clear the meaning of this rather obscure amendment. He has told us it is not for the purpose of collecting any arrears that may have accrued through the occupancy of a former tenant. While the house is unoccupied no rates could accrue, so that that house would not be rateable until the new tenant would come into occupation. So far as I can see, the meaning of the section is that once you assess the owner you assess him for the 12 months and when the new tenant comes in, and the rates are not collected off the owner, then you are given power to collect them off the occupier for the end of that particular year before you assess the occupier for the new year.

I think the Minister has not given us any satisfactory explanation as to the purpose of this amendment. He has not told us if it is for the purpose of collecting arrears. How do the arrears accrue? He said they are not arrears from any old tenant, and he must admit that while the house is unoccupied no arrears could accrue. Where do they come from?

Comment on this

I have not admitted anything of the sort. I made it quite clear that the premises could be rated even if they were unoccupied.

Comment on this

Are unoccupied premises liable for rates?

Comment on this

Certainly, except in the circumstances set out in this Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is No. 3 agreed?

Comment on this

No. In view of the Minister's remarks, will he take the word "and" in paragraph (a) and then in paragraph (b) and will he tell us if there is any meaning in that combination of words, or if there is supposed to be any meaning in the last remarks he has addressed to Deputy Hughes?

Comment on this

A rate is made by virtue of this section on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament. Deputy Hughes asked me could a rate be made on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament and I said "certainly".

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell the House why, in a case where a local authority has a legal claim against the owner of a house, he now proposes, instead of allowing proceedings to be taken in the ordinary way by the local authority against the owner for the recovery of rates said to be owed, to invent a new person as a defendant against whom the local authority can take action instead of against the person properly regarded as the defendant?

Comment on this

Whatever merit there may be in this proposal, I am too modest and too conscientious to claim to have invented it, because I find, in the Local Government (Dublin) Act, 1930, this provision appears, as Section 71 (2):—

"When the rate is made by virtue of this section on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament or tenement and such hereditament or tenement is subsequently let by or on behalf of such owner and such rate or any part thereof is in arrear and unpaid, the rate collector by whom such rate is collectible may, in addition and without prejudice to any other remedy for the recovery of the amount of such rate so in arrear and unpaid, serve either personally or by post on the occupier of such hereditament or tenement a notice stating the said amount so in arrear and unpaid and requiring such occupier to pay to such rate collector or his successor in office all rent then due or thereafter to become due by him in respect of the said hereditament or tenement until the said amount is by such payment or otherwise discharged, and, upon such notice being so served, such rate collector or his successor in office shall have the exclusive right to recover, receive, and give a good discharge for all rent required by such notice to be paid to him."

I think that is a very good provision. I admired it so much and thought such a lot of it that I have incorporated it in this Bill. I am too modest to claim that I am the inventor of it. I concede that to Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

Did it ever happen, even in the restricted area of Dublin, that where a case was brought against a person under the section the Minister has quoted, it was not fired out of the courts? Will the Minister say what case can be made in 1946, by way of afterthought and on the Report Stage of this Bill and in circumstances that, from the point of view of order, Deputy Morrissey objects to, for bringing forward a proposal on these lines and referring it to the whole of the country? Can the Minister give the House any reason for that?

Comment on this

I happen to be acquainted with a particular case bearing on this section. I can assure Deputy Mulcahy that we in Drogheda did take powers to go in and collect the rents until the rates which were due were paid off. It is quite true to say that an unoccupied house can legitimately claim a refund for six months only. After that it becomes liable for the full rate. The case I have in mind actually took place during Deputy Mulcahy's term as Minister for Local Government. We had the right to go in and collect the arrears through the rent and when the amount due was cleared off we handed it back to the rent collector for the landlord.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us how the authority in Drogheda was able to operate a section from a Local Government Act which refers only to the City of Dublin?

Comment on this

I am telling Deputy Mulcahy what we actually did in the town of Drogheda.

Comment on this

Under a Dublin Act?

Comment on this

I am not concerned with the City of Dublin; I am concerned only with the administration in the town of Drogheda. We adopted that procedure there.

Comment on this

Surely the suggestion in the Bill is much more reasonable than what exists under the Act, whereby a rate collector is entitled to seize the goods of a tenant and sell them in order to recover the amount due and the tenant's only remedy is to proceed against the landlord for the recovery of the amount. I consider that the suggestion in the Bill is far more reasonable than that.

Comment on this

Not being able to get any kind of reasonable case made for the amendment from that point of view, may I go back to what the Minister started with? He started by suggesting that it was argued here that before the owner of a premises which he considered should be regarded as unoccupied could get relief, or a refund of rates, he should go to the court. On the contrary, what was suggested here was that the owner of a premises could not be denied the relief that this section proposes to give him, in respect of an unoccupied house, by the local authority, without a reference to the District Court for decision by a body with judicial functions, on the question of any claim so made by the local authority, that a suitable tenant was available for the house and that a reasonable rent was obtainable.

Comment on this

My recollection is that vacancy meant the absence of furniture and that premises were empty. Now we have a position in which the onus is on the owner to show that the premises are vacant. What would be the position of an owner of an empty warehouse in Deputy Allen's constituency in New Ross or Wexford which cannot, by reason say of the decay of a port, be of any value to the owner? If Deputy Allen's suggestion is to be followed then the owner would be liable for rates. Is that the intention?

Comment on this

No. If premises cannot be let to a suitable tenant at a reasonable rent the owner will not be liable.

Comment on this

Local authorities believe that there is too much concern shown people who own property, whether houses or warehouses, and that for some reason no rates are paid on them. This section is going to complicate the matter. County council and other bodies are operating the existing law in regard to such property for a considerable time. I do not see any reference to the existing law or to an amendment of it in this section. In a large number of cases local authorities come across cases where fraud is attempted. I could point out a half-dozen residences that could be let at substantial rents, but the owners refuse to let them. I know warehouses in New Ross that the owners refused to let to a shipping company or to give berthage to develop the port. Warehouses have been closed there for 20 years.

Comment on this

Why would the owner not let in people who wanted berthage?

Comment on this

To tighten the ring —to keep out competition.

Comment on this

It would create competition. I know of persons who wanted a berthage on the quay at New Ross but who would not be given it by the owner.

Comment on this

Why would the owner not give it?

Comment on this

Because he did not want competition against himself, and his own warehouses were closed.

Comment on this

That is not the only town in which that happened.

Comment on this

There should not be consideration in law for people who own property, and will not let it. Everybody knows that vacant residences and warehouses are scarce at the present time. There is no such thing as a big number of vacant houses or warehouses because tenants cannot be got for them. It is the other way about. That has been the experience of local authorities in the past dozen years. Whatever may have been the position 20 or 30 years ago, it is different now. Building materials cannot be got now for the erection of anything. I, as a member of a local authority, cannot understand why the Minister is so considerate for the owners of such property.

Comment on this

We are given to understand that rates struck on property at present have to be paid, and unless the local authority is satisfied, without the intervention of any kind of judicial authority, they can hold on to the rates and then give a refund. If that is so, I cannot understand Deputy Allen's statement. Why do they refund the rates?

Comment on this

When a dwellinghouse is unoccupied. Although the rate is struck it is not collected. On March 31st the rate collector returns the premises as unoccupied.

Comment on this

The Deputy should read the amendment.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy should read it.

Comment on this

We are trying to get information as to the law on the subject.

Comment on this

The rates are going to be collected under any circumstances and then refunded.

Comment on this

This is not the first time Deputy Allen has criticised an amendment without reading it. The position, as I understand it, is that rates levied on unoccupied premises are not collectible when the premises are unoccupied. In this case the collector, as a matter of fact, collects the rates, and I think that is a substantial improvement on the existing position. It gives the owner the right to claim a refund under certain circumstances.

Comment on this

It complicates the matter.

Comment on this

It does not complicate it; it simplifies it, unless a person is going to be so perverse that he is going to close premises or not allow repairs to be made. If you like take up this attitude that whether a man is to maintain his premises or not or cannot make any use of them, then he must pay rates. Otherwise what is going to happen to the demands we heard in this House from time to time to induce farmers to improve their premises and to give them concessions in respect of rates on improvements? Is the only person who is to receive no consideration to be the man who, having built houses or business premises, tries to maintain them in a habitable condition and as an economic unit? The other condition in which a person is entitled to a refund is when he cannot find suitable. premises or premises at a reasonable rent. Are we to come to this situation that if a man cannot get a suitable tenant he is going to be mulcted in rates? What inducement will there be to any private person to go ahead with building for the purpose of letting to other individuals if property is to carry these disadvantages?

The purpose of this section is to simplify, from the point of view of the local authority, the position in regard to rates or unoccupied premises. It makes the rates chargeable, in the first instance, on the owner and the owner is entitled, provided he satisfies certain conditions, to claim and to get a refund, but only for so long as the premises are genuinely unoccupied,bona fide unoccupied in accordance with the provisions of the section. The moment they cease to fulfil these conditions, the rates are properly chargeable upon him and we have sub-section (2) to deal with that situation and with kindred situations. So far from being too concerned about the rights of property owners, we have in this section done something to ease the position of county councils, to meet equitably the position of owners of property which is unoccupied for bona fide reasons—not because the owner happens to be an anti-social person but because he is trying to maintain his property or because he cannot get a suitable tenant for it. In these circumstances, I think that, instead of being criticised by Deputies who have not read the section, we ought to be congratulated by them when they appreciate what we are trying to do.

Comment on this

How do the arrears arise under the second sub-section?

Comment on this

The arrears might arise by reason of the fact that the owner——

Comment on this

But he would have to pay under the first sub-section.

Comment on this

He might not necessarily pay. He is charged with the rates but the rates might not be paid.

Comment on this

The arrears arise for the purpose of making a refund. That is what it means. The Minister is not fair to Deputy Allen and I think there is a good deal to be said for Deputy Allen's point of view. Let me put this example to the Minister. Suppose a big farmer, occupying a substantial unit of land, buys a neighbouring farm—he might buy two or three neighbouring farms, which would not be desirable—on which there are a good dwellinghouse and out-offices. He wants to use the land as an out-farm and it is unlikely that he will get what is described as a suitable tenant for the house, because a man does not want to take over such a house without getting the unit of land with it. The man who has bought the farm, however, wants the land, but does not want the house, so that we are going to turn an entire district into a ranch by encouraging the buying of farms of that sort and preventing other men from occupying them and rearing families on them. I do not think that sort of thing should be encouraged.

Comment on this

Get the Minister for Lands to stop that.

Comment on this

The Minister for Lands cannot stop it.

Comment on this

It is up to him to sponsor legislation to stop it.

Comment on this

The arrears will be arrears as against the owner?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

But they are to be collected from the occupier?

Comment on this

To the extent to which the rate collector will be entitled to recover through the rent payable to the owner.

Comment on this

He serves notice, either personally or by post, on the occupier——

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Although there is power to make the owner pay and to make a refund to him in relation to the months for which the place is unoccupied, you are going to make the occupier bear the arrears.

Comment on this

The arrears due by the owner.

Comment on this

You are going to make the occupier pay these arrears.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Although you have a right against the owner.

Comment on this

We presume that the occupier pays the rent to the owner, we collect such rent until the arrears of rates are discharged.

Comment on this

Under the first sub-section, you have control of the owner and you make him pay, but, notwithstanding that, you are going to ask the occupier to pay the arrears.

Comment on this

To pay the arrears in lieu of rent.

Comment on this

That is not set out here.

Comment on this

Indeed, it is.

Comment on this

He has to pay the amount in arrear and unpaid.

Comment on this

No—

"to pay to the rate collector or his successor in office all rent then due or thereafter to become due to the owner."

Comment on this

Having gone to the trouble of collecting from the occupier, you then make a refund to the owner.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

He is entitled to a refund.

Comment on this

The rate is in arrear and unpaid.

Comment on this

Then, it is only to be paid in order to be given back?

Comment on this

No. It may be one or the other.

Comment on this

Let us take a case of a premises unoccupied for six months and then let. If the owner had paid under sub-section (1), he could have recovered for each of the six months the rates which he paid.

Comment on this

He could.

Comment on this

But he does not do that, and an occupier comes in. You are then going to make the occupier pay the arrears of rate, that is, for the six months, for which the owner could claim a refund.

Comment on this

That is a subsequent procedure.

Comment on this

You are going to collect for the months for which the premises were unoccupied in order to repay.

Comment on this

No, it does not necessarily or essentially follow.

Comment on this

I am taking the clear case——

Comment on this

It is not a clear case the Deputy is taking.

Comment on this

May I take a clear case, a case in which the owner has failed to get a suitable tenant at a reasonable rent for a period of six months? If he had paid up the whole of the rates, he would have been entitled, month by month, for each of the six months, to a refund.

Comment on this

Yes, if he had satisfied the conditions of the section.

Comment on this

I am taking a case in which he has. An occupier comes in and he apparently is going to be served with notice regarding the six months' arrears. That is to be taken from the occupier and is to be deducted from the rent, orvice versa, he is going to pay an equivalent of rent so as to pay the six months' arrears, whereupon the owner says: “I am entitled to have six months' rates paid back to me”, and you pay him. Why go through all that nonsense?

Comment on this

That is an extreme case and I am prepared to concede that it might arise, but who will be damnified by that?

Comment on this

First, the local authority or the rating authority. This applies only to hereditaments which are not in urban areas. Let us take the case of an area where there is no trouble about the situation. The rating authority has power to make the owner pay for the whole year in one payment and thereafter to refund it to him month by month.

Comment on this

As the law stands at present, the occupier—

Comment on this

I am dealing with it on the basis of this amendment. When this amendment is passed, the rating authority can make the owner of premises which are unoccupied pay. Let us assume that, for some reason, they do not do so.

Comment on this

For some reason, he does not do so, anyway.

Comment on this

There are then six months' rates in arrears. For these six months, he has not been able to get a suitable tenant at a reasonable rent, and then he does get a tenant. The first thing the rating authority does is to serve on the new occupier a demand for the six months' arrears, and, when he pays the arrears, can the owner not step in and get a refund?

Comment on this

Perhaps he might.

Comment on this

Then what is the purpose of all this?

Comment on this

It is an extreme case, but the purpose is to ensure that the local authority will get its money eventually.

Comment on this

Is that not the only case in which it can occur? Where can arrears arise otherwise?

Comment on this

I have told the Deputy that they could quite easily arise in respect of premises which the owner kept unoccupied under conditions which were not in accordance with those in the section and in consequence of which he became liable for the rates.

Comment on this

And thereby become liable to the rating authority for the whole sum.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

If they do not pay it then you charge the occupier.

Comment on this

If the occupier gets a receipt, and that receipt is declared a valid discharge against the debt of the owner and the occupier is in a position to clear his account with the owner, in what way then does hardship lie so far as the occupier is concerned? I can quite well conceive circumstances where the local authority would regard the occupier as a better mark for the debt rather than the original owner.

Comment on this

Rather than the owner of the property?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Surely Deputy O'Sullivan realises that persons who seek to become occupiers of houses have difficulties enough without necessarily being thrown into a situation where they can be caught by the throat by the local authority and put into the position that they are withholding.

Comment on this

But eventually they will not suffer.

Comment on this

They will suffer in their relations between themselves and their landlords.

Comment on this

Because they pay the money over to the rate collector.

Comment on this

Yes, certainly; and we have not yet had any explanation as to why an owner should be put into a position where he may refuse and say: "I am not going to pay this debt for which I am not responsible to the local authority." He then becomes a criminal under this Act; but instead of proceeding against the real criminal we here are providing for the local authority to proceed against the lesser criminal—that is a person who to-day is not a defendant in these matters or even a possible defendant until this Act becomes law. I think the Minister and Deputy Walsh fell too easily into the temptation to accept my invitation to say that this idea was a child of my brain. I do not recognise the child after the recent discussions we have had in this matter, and I want to suggest that if the Minister gets any more ideas like this we will need a kind of cinematograph apparatus here in order to give the House some chance of understanding what is involved in this, because the processes through which the Minister's brain has gone in dealing with this particular matter could only be adequately portrayed by some rather up-to-date type of photographic apparatus.

Comment on this

Would the Minister enlighten me on one point? I am not sure of the position outside the city here. Under the law as it stood before this Act was passed was it possible to recover 12 months' rates in respect of premises unoccupied or was there a limit of six months' refund?

Comment on this

As things stand at the moment the rates are leviable on the occupier. If the premises are vacant and a new occupier goes into them such new occupier becomes liable for the accrued rates.

Comment on this

Does he become liable for the whole rate?

Comment on this

Not for the whole year.

Comment on this

I am talking of the whole year.

Comment on this

For all arrears.

Comment on this

If the premises are unoccupied for a full 12 months is it not the position that the owner is entitled to a refund for six months?

Comment on this

In respect of Dublin —yes.

Comment on this

In respect of that year. Is not that the position?

Comment on this

That only applied to Dublin, Cork and Limerick.

Comment on this

Did the limitation to six months apply only to the city?

Comment on this

You are not giving him 12 months now.

Comment on this

In the county and urban areas.

Comment on this

You mean in County Dublin and in the urban areas.

Comment on this

In the County of Dublin, yes.

Comment on this

And in the other counties?

Comment on this

In the county council administrative areas and in the urban districts.

Comment on this

The limitation was six months?

Comment on this

No. In the City of Dublin a person was entitled to one-twenty-fourth; in the City of Waterford to one-twelfth; in the Cities of Limerick and Cork one-twenty-fourth. That is the refund in respect of vacant premises. Elsewhere I do not think owners were chargeable at all.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

That was under the Rates and Small Dwellings Act?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

We cannot leave that out, because this proposed new section is an amendment not merely of this Bill but of the Rates on Small Dwellings Act. That is the crux of the whole matter.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Of course it is. It is for the purpose of bringing this into line. It is to enable the Minister to do in the county what he is now entitled to do under the Rates on Small Dwellings Act.

Comment on this

That is so. In fact, under the Rates on Small Dwellings Act the owner was liable for rates whether the premises were occupied or unoccupied.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Quite.

Comment on this

We are dealing now with unoccupied premises.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Yes, and we are also dealing now with an amendment.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

It is a completely new principle.

Comment on this

Before we pass from that, I understand a point is being raised that this is completely new matter brought in in the Report Stage. I understand you have ruled on that?

Comment on this