We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Local Government Bill, 1945—Recommittal.

Contributions 175–352 of 533. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill, 1945
Enacted

No. 32 of 1945 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

I want to understand whether the ruling is comprehensive and, whether the matter is new or not, that all amendments are open to amended introduction at this later stage.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair did not so rule.

Comment on this

I was trying to get the principle. I understood it was agreed that this was not a matter which had been under discussion before and was, therefore, entirely new.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is Section 20 modified.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

It was not discussed before.

Comment on this

I understood the question was whether the matter had been discussed in the earlier stages. I understood this matter had not been discussed on the Committee Stage.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It was said in the Committee Stage that something else would be introduced in respect of Section 20 and it was said that these amendments might be recommitted. That has been done and the amendments are being considered in Committee.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

With all respect that does not necessarily bring them into order. This is a completely new section.

Comment on this

This is onlyad hoc.

Comment on this

I think we can take amendments Nos.4 and 5 together, Sir. They are quite simple. Their purpose is to preserve to the urban district rate collectors who, under the Act, become municipal rate collectors whatever rights they enjoy in regard to conditions of service, remuneration and pensionable status. I move the amendments:—

4. In page 10, Section 18 (3), line 6, to insert before the word "and" the words "upon the same terms of office (including terms relating to pension and superannuation rights) as he held office immediately before such commencement".

5. In page 10, Section 18 (4), line 14, to insert before the word "and" the words "upon the same terms of office (including terms relating to pension and superannuation rights) as he held office immediately before such commencement".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6. This has already been discussed.

Comment on this

Is this in order?

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think they have all been declared in order.

Comment on this

I want to record a protest against any such ruling. It is entirely contrary to the rules of procedure governing this House.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think that was discussed.

Comment on this

It may have been discussed but I am speaking now for the purpose of having the words taken down. I want to record a protest that this, in my opinion, is completely contrary to the rulings given heretofore and contrary to the whole scheme of legislation in this House. I hope it will not be taken as a principle hereafter.

Comment on this

The Minister did not seem to think he had a fair start in having said what amendment No. 3 was about. Now I take it we can all, including the Minister, sit down. Would the Minister explain to us in simple words and in a series of points what exactly amendment No. 6 is about?

Comment on this

I have already dealt with that on amendment No. 3.

Comment on this

And the same law applies.

Comment on this

The Minister in dealing with amendment No.3 was like a boy who goes into a clear pool and starts to stir the mud in the bottom. By the time he has finished stirring he has no earthly idea as to what is in the pool.

Comment on this

I understood that we were taking amendments Nos. 3 and 6 together.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Nobody spoke about it but the Minister himself.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think they were discussed.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

They were not.

Comment on this

Inadvertently, Deputy Allen raised some matters with regard to the urban district of New Ross.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Well, they were discussed.

Comment on this

And he was reproved by the Minister, Sir.

Comment on this

No, he was not. I think Deputy McGilligan joined in that discussion too.

Comment on this

May I point out to the Minister that the old law in relation to this matter was entirely different from the old law which was the background to the previous amendment? We are now coming to urban areas, which includes county boroughs.

Comment on this

It does not include county boroughs.

Comment on this

Urban area includes county borough.

Comment on this

No, it does not.

Comment on this

The Minister apparently has not read the Bill—"The expression ‘urban area' means (a) a borough other than a county borough or (b) an urban district".

Comment on this

"Other than a county borough" but the Deputy has just been saying it includes county boroughs. I am awfully sorry, but really!

Comment on this

In any event, it relates to urban and borough areas as distinct from county areas.

Comment on this

That is different, now.

Comment on this

I want to hear the Minister explain what is the old law in the urban and borough areas which it is proposed to change now by this amendment and I think we are entitled to hear that from the Minister.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Surely.

Comment on this

There are two terms in the amendment in respect of the interpretation of which I think we might have useful discussion, especially from our legal friend, Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Let us hear the Minister on it first.

Comment on this

The House might also have the benefit of the Deputy's contribution on that particular subject. I refer to the interpretation of "suitable tenant" and also "reasonable rent". I understand more trouble has arisen around these two terms in relation to a section of this character than any other cause of action in the courts, and I am at a loss to know what way we include the old section in so far as these two sections are concerned.

Comment on this

We appreciate the Deputy's desire to have the Minister's point explained from this side of the House and we will do our best.

Comment on this

I have already indicated that in the first instance the local authority is to be the deciding voice as to what is a suitable tenant.

Comment on this

The local authority is?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Minister has not moved or explained this section.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment, Deputy.

Comment on this

I have, on amendment No. 3. I have nothing to add to it.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Minister cannot move this when moving amendment No. 3.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It was discussed with amendment No. 3.

Comment on this

It was not, Sir. There was no intention.

Comment on this

It was.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I am submitting, Sir, that it is not even yet before the House.

Comment on this

I move it, Sir, and it is then before the House:—

In page 11, before Section 22, line 30, to insert the following new section:—

22.—(1) Where a hereditament which is situated in an urban area and which is not a small dwelling within the meaning of the Local Government (Rates on Small Dwellings) Act, 1928 (No. 4 of 1928), is unoccupied at the making of the municipal rate, such rate shall be made upon the person (in this section referred to as the owner) who is for the time being entitled to occupy the hereditament and, upon such rate being paid by the owner, he shall be entitled to claim and receive from the urban authority of the urban area a refund of one-twelfth of such rate in respect of every completed month (reckoned from any day of one month to the corresponding day of the next month) during which the hereditament is unoccupied either for the purpose of the execution of additions, alterations or repairs thereto or because the owner isbona fide unable to obtain a suitable tenant therefor, in the case of a hereditament to which the Rent Restrictions Act, 1946 (No. 4 of 1946) for the time being applies, at the maximum rent for the time being permitted under that Act, or, in the case of any other hereditament, at a reasonable rent.

(2) Where—

(a) a rate is made by virtue of this section on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament, and

(b) the hereditament is subsequently let by or on behalf of the owner, and

(c) the rate or any part therof is in arrear and unpaid.

the rate collector by whom the rate is collectable may, in addition to and without prejudice to any other remedy for the recovery of the amount of the rate so in arrear and unpaid, serve either personally or by post on the occupier of the hereditament a notice stating the said amount so in arrear and unpaid and requiring the occupier to pay to the rate collector or his successor in office all rent then due or thereafter to become due by him in respect of the hereditament until the said amount is by such payment or otherwise discharged, and thereupon the rate collector or his successor in office shall have the exclusive right to recover, receive and give a good discharge for all rent required by the notice to be paid to him.

(3) A rate made by virtue of this section on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament shall not be invalidated by any error or defect in the statement of the name of the owner or by the use of the description "the owner" without any name or addition, and the rate shall be recoverable from the owner notwithstanding any such error or defect or the use of any such discription.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain?

Comment on this

I have already explained.

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this

On amendment No. 3.

Comment on this

The Minister did no such thing.

Comment on this

I did. Not only New Ross, but even Dublin, was discussed.

Comment on this

I respectfully suggest that the Minister has given no explanation of the effect of this amendment.

Comment on this

The effect of the amendment is quite clear.

Comment on this

It is quite clear, to my mind, that the law relating to urban and borough areas may in certain instances be different entirely from that in the county areas and the introduction of this amendment should at least be explained to the House before we can discuss it. I would respectfully, through you, Sir, ask the Minister to state for us the old law obtaining in urban and borough areas and then the effect of this amendment.

Comment on this

I do not propose to follow the Deputy at that length at all. The purpose of this amendment is quite clear.

Comment on this

Then we will have to elicit the information by a process of cross-examination.

Comment on this

No. The Minister is not going to submit to that.

Comment on this

What was the position in, say, the borough area of Kilkenny?

Comment on this

I think the Deputy had better consult the local authority.

Comment on this

The Minister has his advisers with him and surely we are entitled to information as to how this amendment will affect the rating law in the urban area of Kilkenny.

Comment on this

The only thing this does is to make the owner of unoccupied premises which are wilfully kept unoccupied by him in contravention of the provisions of this section liable for the rates.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I suggest that this is treating the House with absolute contempt. The Minister has succeeded in convincing the Chair that the introduction of a completely new principle and a new section on Report Stage is in order. So far for that. Surely if there is any point in Committee discussion and in discussion on Report Stage in this House it is that the House should understand what it is discussing. Surely, if a Minister brings in a Bill here, a new Bill, and if, on Committee and on Report, he brings in amendments of his own, it is the duty of the Minister to explain to the House why it is necessary that the Bill should be amended in this way. The Minister referred to amendment No. 3. Amendment No. 3 was dealing with buildings situate in the county as distinct from the urban area. We are dealing exclusively, in this amendment, with buildings in an urban or borough area. I submit that if we are to have useful discussion, if we are to know what we are doing in relation to a Bill of this importance, it is not unreasonable to ask the Minister to give as full an explanation as he is capable of giving dealing with an important new principle such as this. Surely that is the purpose of any discussion in this House on this or any other Bill. Or, does the Minister want the House to pass a Bill or a new section of a Bill on which he is not prepared to inform? The Minister knows quite well that he has sources of information at his disposal that ordinary members of the House have not got. The Minister I take it brought in this particular amendment for one reason. Surely we are entitled to know what that reason is. That is what we are asking. We are not asking for anything to which we are not entitled and I suggest that the Minister, in courtesy, apart from any question of duty, should give the House that information.

Comment on this

I have already given that in respect of a precisely similar amendment, amendment No. 3.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I want again to protest on that. This is all the more regrettable in view of the fact that the Minister has been allowed to do on this Bill what was never allowed to be done in this House since it was set up, to do something which is not only in flat contradiction of the whole practice and procedure of this House, but in flat contradiction of the Standing Orders.

Comment on this

I submit that we are proceeding on a line on which this House never proceeded before. We have here an absolutely new section to the Bill, moved by the Minister. The Minister refuses to give the House any explanation of it, except to say that he has explained it previously. That is not a practice that has been adopted in this House as long as I have been in it, over a period of 20 years. The Minister, following that practice, might tell us, when we came to the last amendment, if any Deputy asked for an explanation, that he had already given it at some other time. I suggest the time to give an explanation of this amendment is when the Minister is moving it.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

And no other time.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say whether in an urban or borough area the owner of an unoccupied premises was entitled to a refund and, if so, to what extent? Was it in respect of six months in any particular financial year or in respect of the whole year?

Comment on this

I have indicated previously that the occupier of premises was liable to pay the rates charged on the premises. This now makes the owner definitely liable for rates on unoccupied premises except in circumstances as set out in the Bill. There is nothing more to be said about the matter than that.

Comment on this

Is not a new position being created now? Previously a refund in respect of six months in any year might have been obtained whereas you can now go month by month and obtain the maximum refund of 12 months' rates on any empty premises.

Comment on this

You can, if the premises fall within the section.

Comment on this

Then you are introducing two new principles.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

You are transferring the liability from the occupier to the owner and introducing a new test of non-occupation. Previously, as I understand the position, the test was that the premises were empty and untenanted. Now we are introducing four new conditions: that the premises are unoccupied by reason of the fact that they are vacant for the purpose of additions, alterations or repairs, or that the owner has been unable to make abona fide letting of the premises. We are introducing four entirely new conditions as a test of non-occupation. On this side of the House at least we should like to hear from the Minister what are the reasons for this new departure, and I submit that we are entitled to that information. Furthermore, as has already been indicated, these amendments introduce on the Report Stage an entirely new principle into this Bill which, in the opinion of this side of the House, is entirely out of order.

Comment on this

I do not want to be difficult with the members of the Opposition, but I have a shrewd suspicion that a matter which was fully discussed on one amendment is being rediscussed again on another which is of almost identical purport. I cannot see what their difficulty is.

Comment on this

I want to explain this from my own personal point of view. On the previous amendment I tried to elicit from the Minister the legal position, and the only concrete fact I got was that, so far as premises under the control of a county council were concerned, there was no liability for rates whatever there. That was his answer to me—that there was no liability.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I want to get, however, what was the previous liability in urban and borough areas and how that is being altered by the present amendment.

Comment on this

The Deputy may remember a recent Act passed through this House. I was not in charge of it. I think he took a great deal of interest in the discussion of the Mortgage and Rent Restrictions Act. I think he has overlooked the fact that the previous provisions making the owner chargeable for six months' rates have been repealed in the recent Act. This amendment is adverting to the new position and therefore bringing the position as it now exists into line with Waterford.

Comment on this

Why is the Minister quarrelling with us for asking for that information?

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that the Minister has only recently got that information?

Comment on this

The old test is further complicated by reason of the fact that the owner has to show that he isbona fide unable to let the premises to a suitable tenant at a reasonable rent. Deputy O'Sullivan quite properly asked the Minister to give some information to the House as to who is to be the arbiter as to the suitability of the tenant; and, secondly, as to the reasonableness of the rent. I respectfully submit that we are entitled to that information.

Comment on this

I think I dealt with that point on amendment No. 3. I said that, in the first instance at any rate, it has got to be the local authority. If any person feels aggrieved by the refusal of the local authority to make a refund to him, I presume he has the ordinary remedy under the law.

Comment on this

Is that in relation to suitability and reasonableness?

Comment on this

I should say in respect of both.

Comment on this

So that if a landlord objects to a tenant because, shall we say, of some social objection, the local authority can come along and say: "That is not abona fide reason for your keeping the premises vacant. You have had an offer from X”. If the landlord says: “He is socially objectionable to me”, then he is not bona fide making an effort to let the premises.

Comment on this

I think there is aprima facie case that he is not. It is up to him to go further if he wants to get a refund.

Comment on this

A moment ago the courts were ruled out.

Comment on this

They were ruled out in the way in which Deputy Mulcahy wished to bring them in.

Comment on this

I think the answer to Deputy O'Sullivan was that the local authority decided these points.

Comment on this

In the first instance.

Comment on this

Would it not be desirable, if power is to be given to the local authority, that it should be incorporated in the section so that at least it cannot be repudiated in the courts afterwards?

Comment on this

The local authority have the power because they can refuse the refund on the ground that he has not complied with the conditions.

Comment on this

Are we getting to this position: that the Minister proposes to confer on the local authority power to encroach on the landlord's freedom of contract? He has a perfect right to let the premises to whomsoever he wishes. He has a perfect right to object to X, Y, or Z as tenants, either on the ground of their credibility or on the ground of social objection or any other reasonable ground. If, in these circumstances, he objects to taking X, Y, or Z are we to reach the position that the urban council can come along and say: "You will have to take X, Y or Z or else you will be liable for the rates"?

Comment on this

They do not have to say you will have to take X, Y or Z. All they need say is: "We are not satisfied that a suitable tenant is not forthcoming." Then the owner has his remedy. He can go to court and claim a refund.

Comment on this

Then you have the other position that if X, Y or Z offers a rent which the landlord considers is not a fair market rent for the premises and he will not take them at that and X, Y or Z is able to work the oracle on the urban council in the particular area, then the question of reasonableness will again be decided by the urban council.

Comment on this

In the first instance.

Comment on this

They can say: "You could have got X, Y or Z and you refused them. You are not making abona fide effort to let the premises.”

Comment on this

The owner then has his remedy in the courts.

Comment on this

I respectfully submit that these are all matters that can only be decided by the courts.

Comment on this

I would say, if agreement is not reached, then perhaps by the courts——

Comment on this

Then, I take it, the Minister does not propose to instruct the House as to the old law in relation to urban and borough areas and the effect of this amendment upon it?

Comment on this

I have already instructed the House.

Comment on this

You have explained the law in relation to county areas and the effect of amendment No. 3 upon that law. I respectfully submit that we have not yet got any indication from the Minister as to the effect of this amendment on the law relating to urban and borough areas and that we are entitled to it.

Comment on this

This discussion has done some good, because we have now got some statement from the Minister trying to discriminate between amendment No. 6 and amendment No. 3 which does not go very far. I think a fair test of the information given to the House is this: would anybody who does not know anything about the law relating to rates in respect to either urban areas or non-urban areas say that his mind has been clarified by what has been said in this House? I do not think he would. I think a person who came in here with some sort of standing as an expert on rating would find himself considerably confused. It must be understood that these are amendments put up for the first time. It is not as if this matter was discussed thoroughly and this was merely bringing into form the result of a fruitful discussion at an earlier stage. They are brought in now for the first time. I think the test as to the information given by the Minister to the House is, how far the House is enlightened on the different rating systems, particularly as these rating systems bear upon unoccupied dwellings in urban and non-urban areas. The Minister has had information suddenly given to him by his informers and he told us there is a certain reference in this to the Rent Restrictions Act just passed. That was a late thought to him, I must say.

Comment on this

It was not.

Comment on this

We are at least thankful to the Minister that he gave us the information almost as soon as he got it himself.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not here when the amendment was being moved.

Comment on this

There was very little time between the period when it was breathed to him and when he vocalised it in an audible way to the House. I am glad I was not here, if the debate was anything so confusing as it is now. Deputy Martin O'Sullivan asked a question which surely could have been replied to. He asked what was a suitable tenant and what was a reasonable rent. These are matters on which court decisions have been given arising out of other Acts over the years, but the Minister's comment was that the decision as to a suitable tenant would be made by the local authority.

Comment on this

In the first instance.

Comment on this

That was not said.

Comment on this

It was said before the Deputy came into the House. The Deputy should remember that he came in only quite recently.

Comment on this

If it was said, then it was quite an easy addition to make in the reply to Deputy Martin O'Sullivan. That addition was not made.

Comment on this

I was dealing at the time with Deputy Mulcahy's preposterous suggestion.

Comment on this

The suggestion was made that the courts would decide what was a suitable tenant and what was a reasonable rent, and the Minister recently made the addition that it will be the local authority in the first instance. I presume the same thing applies in the other case, namely, that the local authority will say whether it thinks that there is lack of occupation for the purpose of enabling alterations, additions or repairs to be made. I suppose, again, it will be the local authority which will decide whether the owner isbona fide unable to obtain a suitable tenant. There may be a suitable tenant in the offing and there may be a tenant offering reasonable rent and there may be a case where the owner would be bona fide unable to get such a person. He may not know of such a person being in the vicinity. I understand now from the Minister that the local authority will decide that in the first instance. What I am anxious to discover is whether the courts will decide that in the end.

The courts have from time to time laid down who would not be regarded as a suitable tenant, who would be unsuitable by reason of previous history in regard to occupied premises, habits he had shown and had already proved to the satisfaction of the courts. A man might not be suitable also on financial grounds, even though he might offer what was regarded as a reasonable rent for a period. Men often make efforts which they are not in a position to carry out.

The reasonable rent is the matter about which I am anxious. Has that been changed by the framework in which the phrase is now enclosed? A reasonable rent in the past, when free disposal of property obtained, meant a rent which the owner of the property considered reasonable. I should imagine that is no longer the case. There have been tests applied. The courts have made a comparison with neighbouring premises of a similar type and by that system they arrive, in respect of a certain premises, at what is a reasonable rent. But all this has now been put into a peculiar setting which more or less says that it is the duty of people to let property so that the local authority can get the benefit of the rates paid on it.

I wonder is there any intention to make any change in the old-time court attitude towards a reasonable rent because of the peculiar framework in which this matter is encompassed? There is definitely a new slant on this subject. Anybody reading the new sections will see the idea lurking in the background that property ought to be in occupation and there is the onus on a person who has not let property to show why he leaves it unoccupied. The idea of the two sections is that property ought to be in occupation. I should like to know from the Minister if the courts are to be asked to put a new interpretation on reasonable rents, having against that an acceptance of the idea that rates ought to be derived on property and, therefore, property ought to be let.

Comment on this

I think the courts will have regard to existing statutes dealing with the question of rent.

Comment on this

There is a simple test. Will the Minister say it is not intended to change the old idea and standards made applicable to the determination of what will be considered a reasonable rent?

Comment on this

There is nothing in this section which does.

Comment on this

The Minister apparently is not anxious to say that there is no intention to change the standards?

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy know that anything I might say in that regard would have no binding effect on the courts?

Comment on this

There is no intention to change the interpretation of reasonable rent?

Comment on this

There is nothing in this section which changes that interpretation.

Comment on this

For the third time, is there any intention to have a change worked in the old-time standards?

Comment on this

I do not see what purpose would be served by my saying "yes" or "no".

Comment on this

Thanks very much for the reply. One goes out of this House fully informed.

Comment on this

The amendment proposes that where a hereditament is unoccupied by reason of additions, alterations and repairs, the rates shall be paid, but that application can be made and, where it is considered by the local authority that the hereditament was actually unoccupied for the additions, alterations or repairs, then the rates can be refunded. That is the proposal. I would like the Minister to say, in respect of the Borough of Clonmel and the Urban District Council of Tipperary, what are the circumstances there at the moment in respect of unoccupied premises which the proposal in this section will change?

Comment on this

I cannot answer that in detail.

Comment on this

Can the Minister not tell me whether, at the present moment, if premises in Clonmel are unoccupied by reason of additions, alterations and repairs, rates are not collected or are not payable?

Comment on this

I cannot answer in respect of a particular town because these Acts are already complicated and I cannot at the moment say what the position would be.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give me that information in respect of the Urban District Council of Tipperary?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say, in regard to a normal urban district council, whether, at the present moment, a hereditament that is unoccupied, by reason of alterations, additions or repairs, is liable for rates?

Comment on this

The difficulty of answering cases like that is the extent to which the premises will be regarded as unoccupied.

Comment on this

Assuming that premises are unoccupied for the purpose of additions, alterations and repairs, and that the local authority agrees that they are unoccupied, what is the position in regard to rates in urban districts?

Comment on this

Last year I think the owner would be entitled to get nothing back.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot assist the House in the matter.

Comment on this

Last year the premises were uncontrolled, but this year the owner will be entitled to recover half the rates.

Comment on this

When the Minister says that the owner will be entitled to recover half rates if a house was unoccupied for six months, do I understand that he would be entitled to recover only for three months?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Under the Rent Restrictions Act, he would not be entitled to recover anything.

Comment on this

This amendment is to create a uniform position in all urban districts.

Comment on this

If the premises were not controlled, what would be the position?

Comment on this

If unoccupied, the owner was not rated. The premises were rated, but not the owner. If there were arrears when a person entered into occupation, he would be liable for a certain proportion.

Comment on this

For what proportion of the arrears would he be liable?

Comment on this

Whatever happened to be the amount of the arrears.

Comment on this

In the case of controlled premises unoccupied for eight months, there would be only an allowance in respect of four months?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If controlled premises were unoccupied for eight months, according to the Minister, the allowance would only be in respect of half that period.

Comment on this

To the owner. On the other hand, if the premises were not controlled and he went into occupation, he would be liable for a period.

Comment on this

I am glad to get that statement on record.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In page 11, before Section 23 (2), line 39, to insert the following new sub-section:—

(2) Any part of the agricultural grant which becomes payable after the commencement of this section to an urban authority under sub-section (1) of Section 5 of the Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Act, 1939 (No. 23 of 1939), shall be paid into the municipal fund.

This is intended to cover the position in an urban area which, after the passing of the Act, includes agricultural land. It merely provides that the appropriate part of the grant will be included in the municipal fund and that the occupier of the land will get the relief set out in the Second Schedule.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

In page 12 to add at the end of Section 24 the following new sub-section:

(4) A person who immediately before the commencement of this section—

(a) held the office of collector of rates under the commissioners of a town, and

(b) also held another office or offices under the said commissioners or any other local authority, and

(c) devoted the whole of his time to the duties of all the said offices, and

(d) was a pensionable officer for the purposes of Part IV of the Local Government Act, 1925 (No. 5 of 1925),

shall be deemed for the purposes of the said Part IV, for so long as he shall continue to hold such other office or other offices, to devote the whole of his time to the duties of such other office or other offices (as the case may be).

This is to ensure that a rate collector under town commissioners who holds other official posts will not lose his pension by reason of the abolition of the position of rate collector to town commissioners.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:—

In page 12, to delete Section 25 (2), lines 21 to 27, and substitute the following sub-section:—

(2) If a sum, which consists either of portion of a loan advanced pursuant to this section by the council of a county to the commissioners of a town or of interest on any such loan, is not included by the commissioners in the appropriate demand under sub-section (1) of Section 24 of this Act, such sum shall be deemed to have been included in the demand and sub-section (4) of Section 10 of this Act shall have effect accordingly.

This is merely a re-draft of the sub-section. A county council was allowed to make an automatic addition of 7½ per cent. to cover the cost of collection. That power, which was given in Section 65, was dropped, and it should have been dropped out of this sub-section also.

Comment on this

Would it not be necessary to add the words "in accordance with".

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

It is deemed that the interest on the loan is included, but it does not say that it shall be included.

Comment on this

That is the form in which the draftsman gave the sub-section. That precise point was not put to him.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

In page 12, before Section 26, line 35, to insert a new section as follows:—

26.—(1) Where a hereditament situated in a town which is not an urban district is, on the date of the commencement of this section, held (whether together with or without other premises) under a lease which binds the lessor to pay or allow a deduction or set off against or otherwise to relieve the lessee from any rates made by the commissioners of the town payable in respect of the hereditament, all rent payable under the lease in respect of a period commencing on or after the date of the commencement of this section shall be reduced—

(a) in the case of an annual rent, by an amount equal to the amount of the rates made by the commissioners of the town in respect of the hereditament for the local financial year expiring at the commencement of this section to which the relief afforded to the lessee by the lease lawfully extended, and

(b) in the case of any rent other than an annual rent, by an amount which bears to the rates made by the commissioners of the town in respect of the hereditament for the said local financial year to which the relief afforded to the lessee by the lease lawfully extended the same proportion as the period by reference to which such rent is calculated bears to one year.

(2) In this section, the word "lease" includes any contract of tenancy, whether in writing or verbal, whereby the relation of landlord and tenant is created, and the words "lessor" and "lessee" respectively include the landlord of and the tenant under such tenancy.

This section provides for the adjustment of rent under town commissioners and corresponds to Section 19. When town charges are raised, the rated occupier becomes liable. Under an existing lease, the lessor has to pay the rates in urban areas.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:—

In page 13, before Section 28, line 45, to insert the following new section:—

28.—A rate made by the commissioners of a town under the Towns Improvement (Ireland) Act, 1854, for the local financial year beginning on the 1st day of April, 1946, shall not be invalidated by reason of a failure to comply with Section 172 of the Towns Improvement Clauses Act, 1847, which is repealed by this Act.

The rating authority makes a rate by passing a resolution and making it accessible in the rate book. In the case of a county council, the chairman and two other members present at the meeting make a statement under seal that the rate has been made by the county council. In the case, however, of town commissioners, where the total number of commissioners is nine, no less than six commissioners must sign the rate book. Under the Bill, the provision in the Act of 1847 to this effect will be repealed, but the repeal will not come into effect until the Bill generally is put into operation. The purpose of the amendment is to dispense with the necessity in the current year for six members to sign the rate book.

Comment on this

Is there any regulation other than Section 172 as to how many must sign?

Comment on this

Five members must adopt it, but there is no such provision as the Deputy refers to.

Comment on this

Previously, Section 172 governed this matter. That is being repealed. What comes instead of it?

Comment on this

So far as a definite number is concerned, nothing, but five members must adopt the rate under the Public Bodies Order.

Comment on this

What was the purpose of having six in the old days?

Comment on this

Heaven knows. We have reduced the quorum to three.

Comment on this

I can understand a reduction of the number, but why abolish all provision in respect of the numbers who must sign?

Comment on this

When the Bill is passed, town commissioners will not make a rate, but will make a demand on the county council which will make the rate. I do not think it is necessary to put in any specific provision because the whole machinery is being changed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:—

In page 13, before Section 28, line 45, to insert the following new section:—

28.—The poor rate made by the council of a county for the local financial year beginning on the 1st day of April, 1946, shall not be invalidated by reason of the fact that, subsequent to the estimates meeting, held under Section 24 of the County Management Act, 1940 (No. 12 of 1940), at which the said council determined a rate in the £ to be levied for the purposes of the construction and maintenance of roads, the said council, in anticipation of an increase in the receipts by way of grant from the Road Fund, reduced the said rate in the £ and made the poor rate for the said year accordingly.

This amendment is designed to meet the situation which arose in the case of a few counties this year. When the increased allocation from the Road Fund was announced this year, some county councils had already made their rates and had made them upon a much higher scale than would have been necessary, if they had been aware of the increased allocation from the Road Fund. Under the existing law, they could not alter the rate in the £ which they had determined and this amendment will validate any change they have made.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say what counties are involved?

Comment on this