Local Government Bill, 1945—Recommittal.
Contributions 353–533 of 533. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 32 of 1945 ›
How were some counties in a position to anticipate the grant, while others had no informamation?
Comment on this
The Deputy has Misunderstood me. Some councils had already made the rate at a higher figure than would have been necessary, if they had been aware of the allocation, while others put back their meetings.
Comment on this
Surely there was some leakage somewhere. I am a member of a county council and I know that we had no information whatever about it and we struck a high rate, while other counties held their hand and did not strike a rate, in anticipation of the increased grant. What was the source of the information and how was it possible for some counties to anticipate an increase in the grant while others had no information?
Comment on this
The Deputy is not right. The position is that county councils do not all hold their rate meetings on the same day, and what happened was that some of them held their meetings before the circular went out, and struck a rate.
Comment on this
It refers to those counties where the rate had already been made and where, when the allocation from the Road Fund became known, it was realised that they had struck too high a rate. They have now amended the rate, reduced it, but, in order to make that proceeding valid, this section is necessary.
Comment on this
As I read the amendment, it is that something shall not be invalid by reason of the fact that a council, in anticipation of an increase in the receipts, etc., reduced the said rate in the £.
Comment on this
This is an amendment for the purpose of permitting local authorities, at a considerable amount of inconvenience, to rectify the position created by the futility and incompetency of the Minister's Department, in not making the allocations from the Road Fund at such a date as would enable local authorities, sitting down to discuss what moneys they would have to raise by rates for the coming year, to know what contribution they were to get from the Road Fund for the maintenance and upkeep of roads.
Comment on this
The Minister is trying to validate here an illegal action taken by local authorities. I have in mind a specific county council which considered this matter and which was advised that, as the law stood, it could not mend its hand, when they had the information that an increased grant was forthcoming.
Comment on this
That council was rightly advised, but the position was that some other councils took a chance and decided to strike a lower rate. On the point which Deputy Mulcahy has raised, I am quite prepared to admit that the allocations from the Road Fund were made known at a very late date, but I can say in regard to that that it would have been unfair to the county councils to have made the allocations at an earlier date, because we would not have been in a position to estimate what was going to be the effect on the Road Fund of the increase in the petrol ration and, consequently, in the motor vehicle duties payable. We could not possibly have anticipated that so many more vehicles would have been put on the road, that the reaction to the restoration of the petrol ration would have been so favourable, and, therefore, we, quite rightly, I think, waited until we saw what was the maximum amount we could give, and we gave that accordingly.
The Deputy may say that was blameworthy, but the only alternative was to have taken a rather conservative view of the position some weeks earlier and to have released much smaller grants than we were in fact able to release. I thought it was better, since we had the money and since it was essential that the work of restoring the roads should be begun as early as possible, even though it did mean that, in one or two cases, county councils had already made their rate, to release the larger sum. I thought it was much better to proceed and release the large sum. With regard to what Deputy Hughes has said, he is quite right. The county councils who have already struck their rates and which, subsequently to the release of the notification of an increased grant in the road fund, adopted a lower and I might say a fictitious rate, acted illegally. Their second rate could be quashed in court. It is to deal with that situation and to validate the reduction in the rates which they made that we are here to-day.
Comment on this
The Minister now tells us that when considering the responsibility of the Department in relation to the maintenance and upkeep of the roads instead of approaching the problem from the point of view of a realisation of the fact that we are now 12 months after the end of the war the Minister made, or was preparing to make, his allocation, not in respect of the urgent and necessary work essential on the roads, but in respect of the amount of money which he calculated would come to the Road Fund. Surely the Minister realises that the Exchequer stands behind the Road Fund and that on many occasions there have been borrowings from the Exchequer for the purpose of the Road Fund. The present debacle illustrates very clearly the way in which the Department is breaking down, not only in the manner in which it is dealing with its legislative work but in the manner in which it is dealing with its ordinary administration when it can make an announcement so late as to completely upset the machinery for striking a proper and adequate rate on the part of a number of local authorities. In relation to the work carried out on the roads it is quite obvious that the Minister was waiting to see how the barometer was rising in order to calculate how much money he would make available for the Road Fund in the present year.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Minister's difficulty in that respect, but I do say very emphatically that he has not been fair in the treatment he has meted out to the various county councils. I protest strongly that there were sources of information available to some county councils that were not available to others. The responsibility is on the Minister to ensure that whatever information is available should be available to all. Possibly they were sources of political information. I think that is not good enough and I want to emphatically protest against an administration in a Department which permits that to happen.
Comment on this
I disagree with the statement that there were political sources of information in this matter. I was one of the people engaged in the striking of the rate in County Louth and those who refused to strike the rate were those who were diametrically opposed to us politically. They were successful in their opposition and, therefore, it cannot be said that there were political motives.
Comment on this
So it was mere Ministerial incompetence then that was responsible for that position.
Comment on this
I would like to support Deputy Walsh in what he has said. Ours was one of the counties that struck a rate. We had no information, and the rate was struck on the proper date.
Comment on this
And you would have had the information if it was going politically—is that the inference?
Comment on this
Which used to be the case when Deputy Mulcahy was Minister.
Comment on this
Whatever happens they should not have to change their rates. Have you changed the rate?
Comment on this
What happened was that some counties did not strike the rate. In those counties the position is that the date of their meetings was probably a fortnight or three weeks later than in the case of other counties. The result was that in those counties where the later date prevailed they had the information before the rate was struck. That is what happened.
Comment on this
That is all right. You are not concerned in this amendment. This is only for the purpose of legalising an illegality.
Comment on this
Whether it is legalising an illegality or not the grant was welcomed by the county councils. It was a good thing that was done; and if it is necessary to legalise it now then that is a good act.
Comment on this
Is fearr déanach ná ró-dhéanach, béidir.
Comment on this
The introduction of an amendment would not be necessary were it not for the utter incompetency of the Minister in administering the allocations from the Road Fund this year. He did not make that allocation in sufficient time to let the local authorities know where exactly they stood in regard to such allocations when they met to strike the rate for the purposes of road upkeep and maintenance.
Comment on this
Oh, no. We could not condone an illegality. I did not understand the discussion was over.
Comment on this
Is not this validating an illegality? That is clearly the purpose of this amendment.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that illegality happened because certain people anticipated something that subsequently did happen?
Comment on this
The amendment is introduced because county councils in anticipation reduced the rate. Is not that the only reason why it is being amended? Is there anything else in the amendment except the validation of something that is illegal?
Comment on this
May I read it again:—
"The said council in anticipation of an increase in the rate reduced the rate."
Comment on this
Knowing in anticipation what moneys they were going to receive from the Road Fund—a grant which had already been notified to them but which they had not yet received.
Comment on this
And, in anticipation of it, whether they ever do receive it or not, they reduced the rate and they thereby acted illegally.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows as well as I do that they strike the rate in anticipation of money which they will receive from the Road Fund.
Comment on this
But that is in anticipation, according to the amendment, of an increase in the receipts.
Comment on this
Very good. Then somebody passed on the tip that there were going to be increased receipts.
Comment on this
No tip was passed on. An official circular was issued to all local authorities, some of them, unlike Carlow, acted rather intelligently and as soon as they saw that they were going to get increased moneys decided to reduce the rates.
Comment on this
The circular was sent out apparently—and perhaps unfortunately—after Carlow had met and struck its rate but prior to the striking of the rate by many other county councils.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister ought to give us the complete history. Was there not a previous circular appealing to county councils generally to bring the roads into good condition because of the deterioration that had taken place; and the suggested period was a two years' programme?
Comment on this
I am not in a position to say that they did, but they all endeavoured to give effect to the circular.
Comment on this
Does the Minister envisage the possibility of county councils calling a further meeting to mend their hands?
Comment on this
The Minister is very fortunate in having the Report Stage of this Bill on which to bring it in. If he had to bring in a special Bill to validate what was being done, we might have got the whole story.
Comment on this
I want to be precise about this. Is not it the purpose of this amendment to validate a poor rate which might be invalidated?
Comment on this
The poor rate made by a council of a county for a particular period shall not be invalidated. Does not that mean that but for this amendment it would be invalidated?
Comment on this
Therefore, something did happen which would invalidate this poor rate and that was, as I read it, that the council reduced the rate in the £ and that they did that in anticipation of an increase in the receipts. Is not that the whole purpose of the amendment?
Comment on this
Because they were given clear and open indication in a circular that there was going to be an increase in the grants from the Road Fund.
Comment on this
The Minister is getting down below the legal standards, even in regard to intelligence.
Comment on this
I do not agree with the Minister. Quite a number of them decided that they would not have a two year programme, that they would do it in three years and, if they were tied to striking the original rate, they could with the increased grant carry out the programme that they had decided they would carry out in three years, in two years.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:—
In page 14, before Section 29, line 3, but in Part II, to insert the following new section:—
29.—(1) A hereditament which but for this section would, as regards any local financial year, be a small dwelling within the meaning of the Act of 1928 shall not, as regards that local financial year, be a small dwelling within the meaning of the Act of 1928 if on the 1st day of April in that local financial year the owner of such hereditament within the meaning of the said Act is a State authority.
(2) Where a gale of rent paid, before the passing of this Act, to a State authority by the occupier of a hereditament was, in purported compliance with Section 6 of the Act of 1928, increased by a sum (in this sub-section referred to as the increase) purporting to represent part of a rate purporting to have been made in respect of the said hereditament under Section 4 of the Act of 1928, for the service of a particular local financial year, then, unless the increase was returned by that State authority to such occupier before the passing of this Act, the following provisions shall have effect—
(a) That State authority shall pay the increase to the rating authority by whom the said rate was made,
(b) the increase when so paid to that rating authority shall be deemed to have been paid by that State authority at the request of such occupier in respect of a rate lawfully made on such occupier in respect of the said hereditament for the service of the said local financial year.
(3) In this section—
the expression "the Act of 1928" means the Local Government (Rates on Small Dwellings) Act, 1928 (No. 4 of 1928);
the expression "State authority" means any authority being—
(a) a Minister of State, or
(b) the Revenue Commissioners, or
(c) the Irish Land Commission, or
(d) the Commissioners of Public Works in Ireland.
This is to place the occupiers of small dwellings owned by State authorities in the same position as occupiers of dwellings that are not small dwellings, that is to say, it will make the occupiers of dwellings owned by State authorities liable for rates in future. This will mean that the rates will not be collected by the owner, that is, by the State. It will not make any difference to the rates payable by the occupiers but it will mean that these rates will have to be collected by the rating authority.
Comment on this
What small dwellings or what hereditaments that might be small dwellings are owned by the Revenue Commissioners?
Comment on this
There may be a number. I am not so certain whether there is or not at the moment, but I know that it was contemplated at one time that dwellinghouses might have to be provided for preventive officers and others in remote areas.
Comment on this
No. They belong to the Revenue Commissioners. I think the Revenue Commissioners probably own those.
Comment on this
Would a customs hut on our side of the Border belong to the Revenue Commissioners? Would it be in their ownership?
Comment on this
First of all, the hut is not, except in very exceptional circumstances, a dwelling. I do not know if anybody ever lives in these huts, but I assume they are the property of the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
We will have to go on then to say, "a dwelling, that is, a place where people ordinarily reside".
Comment on this
What premises are there that are capable of being a dwelling owned by the Revenue Commissioners?
Comment on this
I do not know. I am told that the Revenue Commissioners do have dwellings under their control. I do not know how they come to have them, but they have them, apparently.
Comment on this
I presume a dwelling would be a house let for rent. It must be a dwelling within the meaning of the Act of 1928.
Comment on this
Under this section, it must be a small dwelling within the meaning of the Act of 1928.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:—
In page 17, before Section 38, line 21, to insert the following new section:—
38.—(1) Any two or more road authorities may, by resolution under this section passed by each of such authorities, establish a joint committee of their members to consider proposals for an application for a bridge Order to be made by any one of such road authorities and to facilitate the obtaining of the consent of every such road authority to the terms of such an application.
(2) A resolution passed under this section by each of several road authorities shall state—
(a) the general character and purpose of the work,
(b) the number of members from each such road authority who are to be members of the joint committee established by the resolution, and
(c) the manner in which the expenses incurred by such joint committee are to be defrayed by the several road authorities.
(3) A joint committee of two or more road authorities established by a resolution under this section shall consider proposals for the application in respect of which they are so established and shall furnish to each such road authority a report setting out the terms in which, in their opinion, such application should be made and, for the purposes of such consideration and report, Section 46 of this Act shall apply as if the committee were a road authority.
(4) The expenses incurred by a joint committee established under this section by two or more road authorities shall be defrayed by such authorities in the manner specified in the resolution establishing such committee.
This new section is intended to meet the case made by Deputy Broderick for provision by which road authorities might meet and reach agreement regarding an application for a bridge Order. It will be recalled that on Committee Stage Deputy Broderick said that if two county authorities come together and reach agreement on an application for a bridge Order it was undesirable that the whole processes involved in Part IV of this Bill should be put into operation and this section is included so that a joint committee may be formed of the members of two or more local authorities and that by that means the preliminary inquiry may be dispensed with.
Comment on this
As the Parliamentary Secretary says, this is an amendment to meet the point made by Deputy Broderick but sub-section (2) provides for a resolution to be passed by each of the several road authorities. Surely there is some necessity for referring the decisions taken by the committee before those resolutions are passed.
Comment on this
I should think the section is fairly clear. Two road authorities may desire to come together and dispense with the preliminary report and the inquiry and establish a joint committee of their members to consider proposals. In doing so they have to indicate the general character and purpose of the work and also to provide for their expenses. I do not follow what the Deputy means.
Comment on this
They may set up a joint committee but supposing they do not, they may pass completely different resolutions under sub-section (2).
Comment on this
If they should pass conflicting resolutions, the general provisions in Part IV of the Bill dealing with bridge Orders take place. The Minister would have to refuse the application for the bridge Order if there is anything that is not desirable or anything which shows conflict of opinion. Then the preliminary report has to be prepared and inquiry held. It is only if all goes well that this section becomes operative and the Minister must be the person who finally decides whether all does go well between the two authorities.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary say what is covered by the expression "expenses" in (c) of sub-section (2)?
Comment on this
That covers the expenses for the administration of the joint committee. The joint committee will obviously have to have some clerical staff for the purpose of keeping minutes, for the purpose of examining reports.
Comment on this
It seems that some preliminary preparation is left unattended to there. We will have to see how it gets on.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:—
In page 18, Section 40, to delete sub-section (1), lines 5-7 and substitute the following three sub-sections:
(1) Subject to sub-sections (2) and (4) of this section, the Minister may make the bridge Order in such terms as he thinks proper.
(2) The Minister shall not make the bridge Order unless, either—
(a) every road authority to which the bridge Order applies has consented to such application, or
(b) the following things have been done—
(i) a preliminary report has been prepared and furnished under Section 38 of this Act, and
(ii) a local inquiry has been held under Section 39 of this Act, and
(iii) every road authority to which the Order applies was given notice of the inquiry, and
(iv) the Minister has considered the report of the inquiry.
(3) The giving by a road authority of consent to the application to such road authority of a bridge Order shall be a reserved function.
This amendment follows on from the previous amendment and enables the Minister to dispense with the making of a preliminary report and the holding of a local inquiry when the terms of a bridge Order have been agreed upon by all the road authorities concerned. It will be noted that the Minister now makes a bridge Order subject to two or three main considerations:— (1) that he must have a preliminary report and a local inquiry and he must ensure that every road authority has been given notice of the inquiry before he makes the bridge Order, unless the road authorities concerned have already consented to the application by means of having formed a joint committee. It will be noted in this case that the giving by a road authority of consent to the application of such road authority to the Order is a reserved function; in other words it is for the county councils concerned to make a decision as to the action of the joint committee and in approval of their submission to the Minister.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary say in respect of Section 40 and this amendment what is to happen in the case of the bridge at Wexford? Have they to go through all the preliminaries again? Work has been done in respect of that bridge. Plans were prepared and borings made over four years ago. What is to happen in respect of the work done? Have the county council there to go through all these preliminaries here?
Comment on this
So far as I can understand, this Part of the Bill is principally designed to resolve conflicts between authorities as to their responsibility with regard to the construction or reconstruction of bridges. Since all these matters have been gone through in connection with the Wexford bridge, there will be no need for them to conform with this Part of the Bill. On the other hand, if at any time any of the authorities concerned disagree as to the cost of the bridge in its final form, then they will take advantage of Part IV.
Comment on this
The new sub-section says:—
"Subject to sub-sections (2) and (4) of this section."
What is going to be sub-section (4)?
Comment on this
It is the sub-section to the original section in the Bill. Sub-section (2) becomes sub-section (4). Perhaps the Deputy would look at Section 40 as amended in Committee.
Comment on this
Yes; the sub-section with regard to consulting the Minister for Industry and Commerce becomes sub-section (4).
Comment on this
Why is not the numbering of this changed? It will make a difference as to which are the governing ones.
Comment on this
There will be three new sub-sections. The present sub-section (2) will become sub-section (4).
Comment on this
It is quite clear that what now stands as sub-section (2) on page 18 will become sub-section (4)?
Comment on this
The two sub-sections hereafter to govern the Minister are in the amendment at the top of page 6 and what is in Section 40 as sub-section (2) will become sub-section (4)?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:—
In page 18, Section 42, to delete sub-section (1), lines 28-33, and substitute the following sub-section:—
(1) The bridge Order shall contain a direction to a road authority to execute the work in accordance with the bridge Order and this Part of this Act.
This amendment is consequential on the amendment of Section 40, which provides either that agreement has been reached by all the road authorities concerned or a preliminary report has been obtained and a local inquiry held of which notice was given to each road authority concerned before a bridge Order is made.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:—
In page 19, Section 45 (1), line 32, to delete the words "who were given notice of the inquiry".
The same observations apply to this. It is making the Bill conform with the new arrangement for the joint committee.
Comment on this
The amendment provides that the Order cannot be made unless they got notice of the inquiry.
Comment on this
Because it conflicts with the arrangement for the formation of a joint committee. It is purely consequential. If an Order is made by agreement, the words become meaningless. If any Order is not made by agreement, the section still holds good.
Comment on this
If an agreement was made, the agreement would incorporate such a thing as the allocation of expenses.
Comment on this
The allocation would have been already provided for in the agreement of the joint committee.
Comment on this
If the Deputy reads No. 15 he will find that the necessary phrases have been inserted there which makes this unnecessary.
Comment on this
That the Minister shall not make the bridge Order unless the following things have been done.
Comment on this
"Every road authority to which the Order applies was given notice of the inquiry." Why are the words objectionable?
Comment on this
Every road authority to which the bridge Order applies has consented to such application, otherwise has agreed in advance. It is only a matter of wording. The Deputy is unduly disturbed about it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:—
In page 10, Section 46 (3), line 58, to insert after the word "consent" the following: "(in the case of occupied land) of the occupier or".
This is simply a drafting amendment. We did not use the words "of the occupier" in indicating the person upon whom the notice is to be served for the purpose of making a survey and investigation. It corrects an omission in the original draft. Obviously we must be able to make surveys and in so doing to obtain the consent not only of the owner of the land but of the occupier of the land if the owner is absent.