Vote 32—Office of the Minister for Justice.
Contributions 1–134 of 269. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That a sum not exceeding £43,480 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending the 31st day of March, 1948, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Justice.
Shall we adopt the practice of other years and debate all the Votes relating to the Department of Justice on this Vote? The Committee can divide, if necessary, on the different Votes.
Comment on this
The main debate generally takes place on the Vote for the Office of the Minister for Justice. I propose to start with the financial aspects of the Votes and to deal later with other aspects. A part from normal increments of salary, the increases in all these Votes are almost entirely due to the new salary scales in the Civil Service which came into operation on the consolidation of the basic pay and bonus last November and, on Vote 33, to the corresponding increases in the pay and allowances of the Garda Síochána which have been published in the Press during the past week. The cost of the increased pay and allowances of the Garda amounts, approximately, to £350,000 per annum. However, I shall very briefly go through the Votes in the order in which they are numbered, pointing out any variations in the figures which, I think, may be of interest. There is nothing of particular interest, I think, in Vote 32.
On Vote 33, the estimated strength of the officers and men of the Garda Síochána is given as 7,494 as against 7,476 last year. Apart from the substantial increases under sub-heads A and B for pay and allowances, I would draw the attention of Deputies to sub-head H, which provides for an increase of £7,600 for the maintenance and running expenses of motor transport, and to sub-head M which provides for increased compensation to members of the Garda injured in the course of their duty, etc. The figures under sub-head M are, however, purely conjectural. Naturally, we cannot be sure what the amount will be.
On Vote 34, there is an increase of £16,182 for pay and allowances. There is a decrease under sub-head B of £2,130 for victualling, as the cost is based on an estimated daily average of 675 prisoners as compared with 780 in the previous year. These figures, I may remind Deputies, are conjectural as various factors may arise throughout the year which will upset the advance calculations as to the daily average number of prisoners. Last year, for instance, a daily average of 780 prisoners was budgeted for, but the actual number in custody was 687. The number of officers to be employed in the prisons service this year is estimated at 326, as against 289 in 1946-47.
The increased staff is consequent on the reopening of the Borstal institution at Clonmel and the extension of the periods of recreation granted to all prisoners on Sundays, which have been increased from, roughly, two to eight hours. I might also direct attention to sub-head H, under which a sum of £8,050 is provided for the maintenance of buildings and equipment. This sum is more than double the sum provided for last year: the extra £4,500 is to be spent mainly on the erection of a new boiler-house, the building of ball-alleys and the concreting of exercise yards at Mountjoy Prison and the erection of ball-alleys and a good deal of reconstruction and renovation work at the Borstal institution in Clonmel.
On the District Court Vote, there is a saving of £3,170 in the provision for temporary additional justices. This saving is more apparent than real. There has been an increase in the number of permanent justices and four will be paid out of the Central Fund and will not be provided for in this Estimate. It was hoped to dispense altogether with temporary justices and that may come about eventually when things become more normal. That was the idea of increasing the number to 40. There were four movable justices, to relieve those who were ill or on holidays, but I find that, in spite of having made these four permanent, we still have to provide extra help. There were three justices ill recently and we had to have three extra temporaries; and I do not see any hope in the coming year of being able to do with less than three temporary justices.
Comment on this
Ever since I was Minister for Justice and even before that, the practice has been to have some temporary justices. The law allowed us only 36 permanent justices and I brought in a Bill during the year to increase that to 40, so that we were doing away with the undesirable practice of having temporary justices at all. However, that did not happen to be sufficient. We hope that it may prove unnecessary to have temporary justices in a year or so when things become normal.
I do not think that the financial side of the Votes for the Circuit, Supreme and High Court, the Land Registry and Registry of Deeds, the Public Record Office and the Office of Charitable Donations and Bequests calls for any comment.
Turning to the statistics for crime— the important part of the debate and one in which everyone is interested— I am sorry to have to say that the figures are still very high. I need scarcely remind Deputies that the Report of the Commissioner of the Garda Síochána on Crime for the year 1945 was laid on the Table of the House last December, and the statistics in the various crime groups—indictable, summary and juvenile offences—are set out in detailed tables and are summarised in the foreword, and compared with the statistics for similar crime groups in earlier years. The report is a valuable document and I hope to have it printed and circulated in each year in future about the month of August. It may not be possible to have it printed this year, as I understand there is considerable congestion in the printing trade, but, when conditions permit, it will be done.
I have recently received from the Commissioner an interim report on crime for the year 1946. The figures in it are provisional, of course, and will be re-checked before being published in final form next August, but I do not expect any great divergence as a result of that re-check.
The total number of indictable crimes reported to the police in 1946 was 15,139, as against 16,786 in 1945. It is the lowest figure recorded since 1941 but it is still almost 100 per cent over the 1939 figure.
In the group classified as "offences against the person", that is the group comprising crimes such as murder, manslaughter, woundings, sexual crimes, etc., there are 550 cases recorded in 1946, as against 639 in 1945.
In the group headed "offences against property with violence", that is, burglaries, housebreaking, robbery, malicious damage to property, etc., the corresponding figures are 2,571 and 2,732; the decrease in this group in 1946 is almost entirely in the Dublin metropolitan area.
In the group headed "offences against property without violence" which includes larceny, receiving, fraud, embezzlement, etc., the figures are for 1946—11,832; for 1945—13,227. There was a decrease of 1,159 in the number of larcenies reported and a decrease of 183 in the number of cases of receiving stolen property.
Other indictable offences (such as forgery, unlawful possession of firearms, etc.) totalled 184 in 1946, as against 188 in 1945.
With regard to non-indictable offences, the total number of prosecutions in 1946 was 152,210 (the corresponding figure for 1945 being 150,862). This figure (the 1946 figure) was made up, in the main, of 85,735 breaches of the Road Traffic Act (of which 53,151 were in respect of offences by pedal cyclists against the lighting regulations); of 17,241 breaches of the intoxicating liquor laws, of 11,701 offences in relation to the licensing of dogs and 8,100 breaches of the School Attendance Acts.
As regards juvenile crime, the number of persons under 18 years of age who were charged with indictable offences in 1946 was 2,409, a decrease of 424 on the figure for the year 1945.
In the Dublin Metropolitan area the number of indictable offences reported to the police in 1946 was 9,070 as against 9,543 in 1945. The number of crimes of burglary, housebreaking, etc., last year was 1,094 which is over half the total of such crimes committed throughout the whole country. The total number of larcenies in 1946 was 7,262 as against 7,506 in 1945. Larcenies of goods not exceeding £5 in value totalled 3,051, a decrease of almost 800 on the figure for the previous year, but under the heading "Larceny from Unattended Vehicles" the figure 946 shows an increase of 474 on the previous year.
In the Report on Crime for 1945, tabled in the House last December, the Commissioner gave it as his opinion that over 40 per cent. of the larcenies in the Dublin Metropolitan area could have been prevented if the owners took reasonable precautions to ensure the safety of property such as bicycles, rugs left in unattended motor-cars, clothes left on lines at night, overcoats in hotels, etc. The prevention of these larcenies and their detection is an extremely difficult task for the police, who have their hands full as it is. People should take care at least of their own property and not expect the police to do everything. I might refer here to Appendix B of the 1945 Report to show the high value of police work in the detection of indictable crime. There is in that report a very valuable index. The table of figures shows for each Garda division the number of indictable crimes committed under various heads, the number of detections and the percentage of detections. I think most Deputies will be interested in that report if they study it.
When speaking earlier on the financial aspect of Vote 34, I mentioned the increased staffing in the prison service owing to the reopening of the Borstal institution at Clonmel. As Deputies are aware, the premises at Clonmel were taken over by the military during the war years and we moved the boys to Cork Prison, at the same time transferring the prisoners there to Limerick Prison. When the emergency ceased my Department resumed possession of the Clonmel premises. For a long time past I was satisfied, both from personal inspection and the reports of my officers who supervise the prisons service, that Cork Prison was unsuitable for the housing of boys over long periods. The Borstal institution at Clonmel was reopened in January, 1947, and the 26 boys in Cork were transferred there. There is no intention of making the premises at Clonmel the permanent institution for the care of these boys. I am satisfied that the best solution is to build an entirely new institution with ample grounds somewhere in the vicinity of Dublin. Various sites have already been inspected and a provisional selection has been made, but so far we have not been able to make any headway with the building of such an institution.
I do not propose to make any further observations now, but if any Deputy has observations to make on the working of my Department during the past year, I hope to be able to deal satisfactorily with them in my reply at the close of the debate.
Comment on this
I note that provision has been made for a new assistant secretary and a new principal in the Minister's office. We did not get any explanation of the necessity for such increased staff there. I am sure that the work of the Department is growing with the years and there is probably a good case for these appointments, but at the same time I think the House is entitled to some explanation for the appointments just now, when expenditure of all kinds is soaring upwards and upwards.
I am glad that the Minister has been able to meet the demands of the Gardaí to a very considerable extent and, whilst appreciating that the increases now being granted involve a sum of something like £350,000 a year, nevertheless I would like to direct attention to the fact that under the new dispensation of pay and allowances the Taca Síochána has not been fairly treated. This force was recruited in 1939 as a temporary police force and it was absorbed in the Garda Síochána in 1942. Because of the fact that it was regarded as a temporary police force from 1939 to 1942 it has been treated, for pay and allowances purposes, on a different basis from the rest of the force. The net effect of the improvement in pay and allowances for the Taca Síochána is that no member of that body can earn an increment for seven years. It seems an extraordinary anomaly that men serving in the same barracks and wearing the same uniform should be placed in such a position of disparity. Anomalies of that kind, particularly inside the four walls of a small police station, are likely to lead to a lot of internal jealousies and it is desirable that any grievances that might arise in that direction should be rectified.
The number of the Taca Síochána is somewhere about 300. Another point is that none of these men can earn an increment in pay until he reaches 27 years. Again, that is an unfair discrimination as between the Garda proper and the Taca; in other words, they have to serve seven years before they can enter on the basic pay of the Garda Síochána proper. Whilst the original intention was to treat them as a temporary force, circumstances rendered it impossible to disband that force. In fact, not only had they to be absorbed in the Garda Síochána proper, but the Garda Síochána has since had to be increased by recruitment. Any anomalies or grievances that arise there should be rectified.
I know one particular member of the force who will have eight years' service completed in April. He will then qualify for his first increment. Most of these men have the secondary standard of education and some of them are university men. The vast majority are undoubtedly men of the very highest standard of secondary education. They are the cream of the country's physique and the cream of the country's talent and education. I think these young men not only have rendered a good account of themselves to date, but we shall have to look to that force for many of our future non-commissioned officers and officers. I ask the Minister to review their case and to see if the anomalies to which I have briefly directed attention could not be rectified.
As regards the increases in pay, they are a considerable improvement on the old position. We are setting up, however, an economic and social boundary between the police force in Northern Ireland and the police force in Éire. The disparity in salaries and benefits of all kinds between here and Northern Ireland is becoming so marked that it will be to the economic advantage of anybody seeking employment in the future to cross the Border. I understood it was the policy of this State, whatever Government might be in office, to endeavour to attract the citizens on the other side of the Border to this part of the country rather than that the Six Counties should become an attraction for our citizens. It is noteworthy that many of our citizens are crossing the Border to take up employment there because of the better attractions in pay and emoluments.
In Northern Ireland a policeman starts with £5 5s. a week and rises to £7 a week. Here a Garda starts off with £3 10s. a week and rises to £6 7s. 6d. A sergeant in Northern Ireland starts with £7 10s., rising to £8 5s. The equivalent position here has a salary of £6 12s. rising to £7 10s. The head constable in Northern Ireland, who is the equivalent of an inspector here, starts with £475 and rises to £550. Our inspector has £420, rising to £475. The Northern Ireland district inspector, the equivalent of our superintendent, starts with £525 rising to £875. A superintendent here has £490, rising to £770.
The county inspector in Northern Ireland, who is the equivalent of our chief superintendent, starts at £925 and rises to £1,150. The pay here starts at £850 and rises to £1,015.
The figures I have given represent the new scale obtaining here. There is a definite lag between the two forces and, having regard to the degree of cooperation which exists between the two forces and to the necessity for trying, as far as possible, to make conditions here equivalent to what they are across the Border, there is still an anomaly which in time is bound to have an adverse effect.
I mention that matter to show that our people here have not yet reached the level of the people in the Six Counties but I think the most distressing position obtaining to-day under the new Order is the case of the widows and orphans. I do not think they have been treated in any way fairly—in fact they have not been treated at all under the new scale. A Garda's widow gets £30 a year as a widow's pension and, in respect of her children, she gets £10 for every child not exceeding three. The maximum amount she can get in respect of children is, therefore, £30. If she has a family of 12 there is a limitation which deprives her of any allowance in respect of every child beyond the third.
That is a limitation which certainly cannot be defended on moral grounds, a limitation which should go irrespective of any increase in the allowance per child. The Garda's widow, who is expected to carry on in late life with a pension of £70 a year for herself and her family, is placed in a most unenviable position. It is a physical impossibility for her, perhaps at 50 or 60 years of age, to get a position of any kind in any walk of civil life. Unless she turns out to take a job as charwoman or something like that, she has virtually no other source of employment or income. She is very often faced with the problem of having to rear and educate her family on that very attenuated income. I think that when pay and allowances were being revised, the case of the widow and orphans should have received first consideration. Instead of that they have been ignored. I am sure it is not the Minister's fault that that position obtains to-day. I feel that that position is due to the Department of Finance rather than to the Department of Justice. I would again ask the Minister to consider this matter because there are several cases in the City of Dublin to-day of widows who are living under the most appalling hardship while endeavouring to maintain some degree of respectability in circumstances which certainly are not creditable to the State.
An officer's widow receives the old-time pension of £50 with an allowance of £20 for each child, the allowance, again, being limited to a maximum of three children. Again I feel that it is a limitation which is indefensible on moral grounds. I suggest that the cases of these widows and children should again be raised and that no matter what the attitude of the Minister for Finance may be, the Minister should continue to fight the matter until a satisfactory solution is arrived at. I understand that the number of widows would not be more than 400 and the amount of money involved would not be very considerable. I know that the Minister is sympathetic. I know also that there is a great deal of dissatisfaction and discontent prevailing in the force because of the manner in which widows and orphans have been treated. I would ask the support of Deputies here in urging on the Minister to consider the case of these widows and orphans.
As regards the crime figures, it is rather startling that the situation has not improved as much as one would expect. The figures are still very high when compared with the pre-war statistics. I understood the Minister to say that they are the lowest since 1941 but that indictable offences still show an increase of 100 per cent. over 1939. That is a very serious matter. Many serious offences are definitely on the decline but there are still some very unsavoury features connected with the crime situation. The number of larcenies, petty pilfering, embezzlements and forgeries remains practically constant and gives food for thought to sociologists and others who are worried about our social and economic condition. I am glad to see that juvenile crime is on the decline. I agree with the Minister and with the Commissioner of the Garda when they say that a great deal of the petty larcenies, particularly in urban and metropolitan areas, are entirely due to the carelessness of property owners, particularly motor-car owners. There is downright carelessness in that regard. Much of the crime which prevails, larcenies from cars and even from houses, and larceny of bicycles, would be prevented if owners would only take reasonable care.
I should like to mention, as I have on previous occasions, the case of District Court clerks and to put the case of these clerks before the Minister in the hope that it may awaken some sense of justice amongst the hard-headed men of the Civil Service and particularly of the Department of Finance who are dealing with this problem and who are not showing the appreciation of the service of these gentlemen that they might show. The problem of finding a suitable scale of salaries and pensions for District Court clerks has now been under consideration for five years and, as far as I can ascertain from questions in the House, we are now no nearer to a scale of salaries and pensions than we were five years ago. I have already mentioned this case to the Minister but I want to stress the position again as I see it.
The Minister in 1942 introduced a Retiral Order and gave notice to the District Court clerks that they would be retired at the age of 65, in the case of established clerks, and that in the case of unestablished clerks, they could not hope for service beyond the age of 70. Now this Order came as a bolt from the blue to these men who were led to believe in 1923 and 1924 that they would be established on a pensionable basis. According to the terms of their appointments in 1923, they were to have a probationary period of six months and, if confirmed in their appointments, they were given to understand that they would be entitled to a gratuity or pension in due course. They were certainly told that they could rely on having their positions established and on having pensions provided for them at the end of their period of service.
Yet, in 1942 at the height of a grave economic emergency, these gentlemen were notified that they would be retired. That retiral meant in many cases that they would be retired without any provision whatever. I think that was very harsh treatment for men, many of whom had rendered great national service in the Sinn Féin and Irish volunteer movements, many of whom had been active not only in the old Dáil courts but in the old Vounteers, men who not only took a prominent part in the Sinn Féin movement but some of whom spent long terms of imprisonment and endured great hardships in jail.
Two of these men come from my own constituency. One of them was retired under that retiral Order and is to-day in Thomastown County Home without any provision whatever. That gentleman was not only a clerk of the old Dáil courts, but was secretary to the Sinn Féin executive in Kilkenny. He took the present Taoiseach on a canvassing tour of Kilkenny away back in 1917, on the occasion of the first Sinn Féin election there, and he was active down through the years as a member of the Volunteers and particularly as a member of the Dáil courts' staff there. Yet, we who claim to be a national Parliament and to have regard to the sacrifices made by men in the national movement allow such a gentleman to retire to the county home, without any provision being made for him. That is due entirely to the fact that the Departments dealing with this problem of salaries and pensions for District Court clerks have failed to find a scheme. It is high time a scheme was found for these gentlemen. Many others of them will be placed in the same position in the very near future.
The other gentleman in whom I am interested has, due to the Minister's good offices, been kept on, because, if he were not kept on, he would have to go the same way, to the county home. That gentleman spent three years in prison at one time. He sacrificed all his property in the national cause. He was at one time a man of considerable means and he is now an old man, and if provision is not soon made for him and he has to retire because of incapacity, he must also seek the solace of the county home. I hope the Minister will energise whatever Department deals with this matter sufficiently to ensure that a gentleman with a splendid national record of that type will not have to retreat to the county home or depend on charity in his old age.
As to the rest of these men affected, many of them have national records. I have a long list of them here and I can give particulars of their records. Each one has a very good national record, both in the Volunteers and in the Dáil courts. I do not want to weary the House with the detailed list, but I give as a sample: Gaelic League and G.A.A.; I.R.B., 1905; National Council of Sinn Féin; organised branches of Sinn Féin throughout his native area; shareholders in Griffith's original paper Sinn Féin; battalion adjutant, Irish Volunteers, 1914; organiser Dáil courts in his native county, 1920; registrar of District Court; organising parish courts; collector, Dáil Éireann Loan in 1918-19. As a result of these activities, this man's business collapsed when he had to go on the run. He subsequently became a District Court clerk, and, according to the conditions of the appointment, was led to believe that he could look forward to a sheltered old age when he could retire on some decent pension.
The pension terms offered are not very generous. The pension terms originally offered to these gentlemen were so appallingly ungenerous that they, all but one, refused them. They were asked to sacrifice years of service and were asked, in consideration of a pension, to take a reduced salary and to go on an established basis which virtually meant that, on their retirement at the maximum age, they would have to fall back on one quarter of their pay. None of them was paid liberally and a £300 a year man would have to fall back on something like £80 a year to survive in his old age. There are several cases similar to that of the gentleman I have mentioned, such as: I.R.B., 1907; secretary, local Sinn Féin clubs; member of the Volunteers from 1914; secretary, Belfast Boycott Committee; Gaelic League and G.A.A.; I.O. during the Black and Tan régime; assisted in running Irish Freedom; engaged in all forms of national and Republican activities at that time. These are the types of gentlemen who are being left to the mercies of, I am afraid, a cold-blooded Civil Service who have no regard for the sacrifices made by these men in these days. I appeal to the Minister not to leave these men in the hands of that cold-blooded Civil Service machine. I doubt if these gentlemen have an appreciation of the sufferings and hardship these men underwent in those days and I am afraid that some of them may be tinged with prejudice. Some of them may not have any sympathy with the men who took these risks in those dark days.
I want to put this point of view also, that these men, by virtue of the terms of their appointment, are virtually whole-time officers. They are debarred by law, by the Petty Sessions Act, Section 35, which, so far as I can find out, has not been repealed, from engaging in other activities and they may therefore, be regarded, for all practical purposes, as whole-time officers. Many business and other activities are denied to them by law and they were definitely given an undertaking in 1923 and 1924 that their position would be improved and that they would be established on a proper scale of pay and allowances and would receive pensions.
Comment on this
I think it is a matter for the Minister for Justice. They are controlled by the Minister for Justice and the Examiner of District Court clerks is in his Department. It is he who must take the initiative in improving their lot. They are the servants of the Minister's Department. I urge that the scheme should be expedited as much as possible and I also urge that, where these men have capacity for their work, they should not be kicked out at 65, but should be retained, so long as they have the capacity to work. In Great Britain, this problem of court clerks arose and the British kept them on until the age of 72. There is no reason why, if a man is active in brain and body, he should not be kept on here until the age of 72. If they have to go at 65, the terms of their establishment should be such as to enable them to retire on something more than a mere pittance.
If we take the case of a petty sessions clerk in Derry and in a comparable area like Limerick, it will be found that the petty sessions clerk in Northern Ireland has a salary of about £750, with an assistant at £350. I do not know the Limerick man's salary, but I venture to suggest that it is not half the Derry man's salary and he has no assistant. There is no comparison between the work of a clerk in Northern Ireland and the clerks down here. Many new jurisdictions have been conferred on the District Court here which do not obtain in Northern Ireland. The job of the District Court clerk here has become so loaded with work that it has become a skilled occupation. The District Court clerk here is responsible for showing jurisdiction on every summons issued from the District Court office. Any document issued by him may be challenged by a solicitor in court and every time he deals with a summons or court document, he does something for which a solicitor in the ordinary way would receive a fee.
I put it to the Minister that having regard to the increased work of the courts, and particularly the increased work which will be thrown on the courts under the Rent Restrictions Act, there is certainly a case not only for expediting this scheme but for giving these men generous terms for the work they are doing. I have laboured the point sufficiently to indicate that there is a case for these gentlemen receiving decent treatment.
The Circuit Court clerks are in a somewhat different category, but their case, I understand, is also dragging along. Many of these men have spent 50 years in the public service. I know that, when originally appointed, these men were probably appointed as assistants to the clerk of the peace and were not established civil servants, and, in the ordinary sense, were not paid directly from public funds; but nevertheless the clerk of the peace, the predecessor of our court registrar, had to get the money from public funds to pay his assistants, and to that extent they were public officers in the employment of the State, even though they were not established. Certain offers were made to these gentlemen, many of whom, as I say, have upwards of 50 years' service.
But the net effect of the offer was that they would not have received as a start more than seven years' established service and, in order to get that seven years' established service, they would have had to agree to a considerable reduction in their existing salaries. I think their case is one which should receive treatment also. Some of them definitely have rights to compensation under Article 10 of the Treaty. Others of them, to my own personal knowledge, rendered sterling service, and dangerous service, in the national movement and are deserving of special consideration for these services. When we consider the present cost of living and realise that for 30 years a number of these gentlemen have got no increment whatever by way of increased pay or allowances, we see that their case is all the more deserving of urgent treatment. I would appeal, therefore, to the Minister to urge the Minister for Finance to bring the problem of the pay and pensions of these people to an early conclusion.
There is only one other matter that I wish to raise—it is a problem to which I have referred on previous occasions—that is, the tendency of all Government Departments to throw new duties on to the Garda, duties, which cannot by any stretch of the imagination be regarded as police duties. The Minister has given us a serious picture of our crime situation. We are 100 per cent. over the 1939 figures in crime. That is a serious situation and I have no doubt that a good deal of it may be due to the fact that ordinary beats and patrols have had to be stripped, ordinary police supervision has had to be reduced, in order that the Gardaí might provide service for other Government Departments. The Guards are expected to engage in all sorts of activities for other Government Departments. The Minister should resist any further encroachment upon the Garda's time for work of that kind. I know that it is an easy way out to get the Guards to make the necessary investigations or inquiries and the necessary reports but when that can be done only to the neglect of the performance of ordinary police duty, we are bound to have an increase in crime. If you strip the streets of Dublin, or of any large city of police, and the juveniles are aware of that fact, you are bound to have an increase in petty crime of all kinds and petty crime eventually leads to more serious indictable crime. For that reason alone, I think the Minister should resist any further encroachment upon the time of the Garda for miscellaneous duties, which cannot be regarded as police work.
The police problem should be to get our crime situation back to normal, back to the 1939 situation. They cannot hope to achieve that objective if they are to be the messenger boys for every Government Department which has a new brain wave. That is the position we have had in the Garda for years, that the Garda is being over-loaded with non-police work, to the detriment of the prevention and detection of crime. I know that the Minister and the officials appreciate that situation but I do feel that, in the interests of our people, it is essential that the Garda should be divorced from all non-police activity and concentrated entirely on their main objective, the prevention and detection of crime. That is what they exist for and we will never get back to the pre-war crime situation if half, or perhaps more, of our police in any given station are to be absorbed in non-police work. Every time a Board of Works inquiry or an agricultural credit inquiry or an inquiry from any Government Department has to be investigated it means the loss of a Guard for perhaps the best part of a day, depending upon where the investigations have to be made. I know that in practice it very often means stripping the small police station of its effective personnel for police work. These men find their energies dissipated in all sorts of administrative detail. Not only have they to go out to investigate on the spot the particular matter under investigation but they have to come back and make their report on the investigation. In that way much of their time is absorbed in duties which should properly belong to the officials of the Departments concerned. It perhaps may be argued that it is a cheap way for the State to get their inquiries or investigations carried out but I do say, with all seriousness, that many of these investigations should not be given to the Garda Síochána at all. Many of them are of such a confidential nature that they should be carried out by other agencies. They are not appropriate to the police machine at all and it is unreasonable and unfair to the citizen that certain investigations which are transferred to the Garda by Government Departments should be conducted by members of the Garda. Incidentally, that type of investigation of a confidential nature very often has an adverse effect upon the police in the locality and may have an adverse effect upon the police in their main job—the investigation of crime. I cannot overstress that aspect of police work because I feel that as the years roll on the tendency will be to increase that type of work upon the Garda machine and I am putting it to the Minister that he should resist all further encroachments and, if at all possible, get rid of the miscellaneous duties that are there, a heavy burden, on the crime machine. If you overburden the crime machine with this type of work, it cannot be expected to give the results in crime that one would expect.
On that matter of crime, while the Minister did give us figures, he did not give us any figures for the cases detected and the percentage of detections as against cases reported and the percentage of convictions in relation to cases reported and to cases detected. The efficiency of the Garda can only be tested, to my mind, on that basis.
Comment on this
Perhaps it is but I think we should have it here once a year so that we could see whether our police force is improving in crime detection and, above all, in getting the real results, the conviction of the criminal. We should have that information because it is only on that basis we can really appreciate the police difficulty. I know that a good excuse can be made for, perhaps, failure to detect certain classes of crime because men are simply not available for the investigation of crime and if I had these figures I would have been able to make a better case for resisting further encroachment upon police work proper.
Comment on this
The Estimate for the Department of Justice is divided into a number of sub-heads but taking the Estimate as a whole, it represents a considerable sum. In my opinion, so far as the District Courts, Circuit Courts, High Court and Supreme Court are concerned, the system is very complicated and it is that complexity which is the cause of so much expenditure. While we cannot discuss legislation, I would like to say that I think the time has come when something should be done to alter our legal system. I am glad that the Minister has given an increase of pay to the Garda Síochána. It was long overdue, especially to the recruits. They were badly neglected. Many arguments will be put forward as to the reasons for the increase in crime. The largest share of this crime is committed in the large cities and towns, particularly here in Dublin. When one thinks of the conditions in this city it is surprising that there is not more crime. You see young boys of from eight to 12 years of age on the streets up to all hours at night with a few newspapers under their arms. The selling of the newspapers is just an excuse for them to defy the law by begging coppers. It is a pity to see them starting out on the wrong road at so early an age. Neither their parents nor the State appears to take any interest in them. Such a thing should not be allowed in our country. If the parents are not capable of maintaining them, except by sending them out on the streets at so early an age to sell newspapers, the State should intervene and have those youngsters sent to an industrial school where they would get a useful training.
I have also noticed that the number of young women on the streets of Dublin up to 12 o'clock at night is on the increase. I am sure that some of the more senior members of the House have noticed this, but they have failed to make any reference to it. I think it is a matter that should be mentioned because there does not seem to be any interest taken in it. The Guards do not seem to interest themselves in it, but the fact is that a considerable amount of importuning is carried on on the main streets of this city at night. That is not very creditable to a Catholic city. From what I have observed during the last four years, that sort of thing appears to be on the increase. I think some method could be adopted to prevent it happening. I imagine that a policeman would be quite capable of coming to a conclusion as to what these women are doing on the streets after 12 o'clock at night.
You also have in the City of Dublin one or two cafés, the purpose of which is certainly not to supply people with meals, such as tea and sandwiches, at a late hour at night. In my estimation they are run for some other purpose. We do not hear of anything being done to bring them under the notice of the authorities. There is one at the top of Parnell Street and there is another in a street off the South Circular Road. In my opinion these places are a disgrace to any Catholic country.
They are not being run for the benefit of young men and women, but are places in which crime is bred, and sexual crime and immorality, in particular. Young men and women are led astray in them.
As regards dances, I am totally opposed to the idea of permitting the sale of liquor in dancehalls. Nothing could be worse than that, I think. If boys and girls go to dances and want a drink, then let them leave the dancehalls and go to the publichouses in the neighbourhood and satisfy themselves. They should not be able to get intoxicating drink in a dancehall. The hard point about that is this, that the dancehalls which are anxious to have these bars cater more for the middle and upper-classes than for the working-classes. It is regrettable that the middle and upper-classes should in this matter set such a damn bad example to the working-classes of the country, such a bad example that they feel it is necessary to have liquor on sale in a dancehall so that they—both men and women—can go on the booze and discredit themselves and the country. The sooner the Minister cuts that out the better for everybody and for themselves. We find dances run for various purposes, and that those promoting them are able to make a very good case before the district justice to have a licence attached to the premises in which the dances are held. In some instances the conduct carried on in these dancehalls is a disgrace. If the Minister were to instruct the district justices to refuse point blank the granting of licences to sell drink in these dancehalls he would, I think, be acting in accordance with the wishes of 95 per cent. of our people.
The system of moving Guards from one station to another is one that, I suggest, should be carefully looked into, especially in the case of married men with families. In some of these cases, the children may have reached the age of 14 or 15 and may be about to leave the national school. The income of a Guard or of a sergeant is not sufficient to enable him to send his children to a boarding-school for secondary pupils. I think that in the case of men with families and especially children of the age that I have referred to, they should be stationed in towns where it would be possible for them to send their children to a day secondary school.
In Kilkelly, the village from which I come, steps should be taken to erect a suitable barracks for the Guards. In some of those country barracks there is no sleeping accommodation for single men or married men. In many towns in the County Mayo it is almost impossible for them to get suitable places in which to stay. A sergeant who came to Kilkelly three months ago had to ask for a transfer because of the lack of suitable housing accommodation. I think he had a family of five or six children and they had to do the best they could in a couple of rooms. There is really no barrack in Kilkelly. It is really a dilapidated house. It has been used temporarily as a barracks for the last 25 years. The sooner the Government make up their minds to erect a suitable barracks there the better. As the Minister is aware, I have done a month in prison and it helped to give me a little insight into the way things are run there.
Comment on this
The position is this. When a young man is sent to jail for a crime such as stealing a bicycle, hitting a policeman, being drunk and disorderly, using obscene language or the various other reasons for which young men are sent for one, two, three and up as high as nine months I think— judging by what I myself saw—that he comes out far worse than he was when he went in. That is my conviction. I am not saying it on prejudice.
There are no means of recreation whatsoever in Sligo prison. There are three rings, something about the size of this floor, which you walk round and round until you become dizzy. It is 47 yards round about. I stepped it one day to find out the size of it. That is the only recreation they have. They have no recreation rooms, no wireless, no pack of cards, no dartboard, no billiards. They have nothing to utilise their minds except to think of crime or to bear within their minds a hatred for the policeman who caught them napping, for the justice who sentenced them to jail and, as some of them I think told me, for Mr. Boland the present Minister himself, and for everybody who is outside the jail. They are convinced that everybody is determined to knock the last breath out of them and to treat them as uncivilised human beings. It is just the mercy of God that we do not fall into one crime or another and it is unfair to penalise the young man who slips and may never slip again. I think that district justices should be most careful about sentencing a young man to jail. The man who is working in an office for a very small wage and is tempted to take £10, £15 or £20 of his employer's money, is sentenced and sent to jail for a term of six months. He is ruined for the rest of his life. When he comes out he cannot get any employment; he has no reference; his employer will not give him a reference and the governor of the jail will not give him a reference without stating that he was in his custody, and he cannot go away and hide under a false name—particularly in this country. Owing to its size everybody is known in it. It does not matter whether you live in Dublin or Mayo or Cork, you will be known and if you take up employment under a false name somebody will come along some day and expose the whole thing and your employer will fire you, even though you have served him honestly and faithfully. I think that that type of young man should get a chance to pay back what he took over a period of time and should be given a chance to go straight. Consideration should be given to the fact that he was working for a very small wage. Therefore, I would like the Minister to look into the conditions of Sligo Prison. In fairness to the Minister, I must say that I have been told that it was not the intention of the present or the past Government to leave that building there or to use it if the whole country were united but seeing that the unity of the country is as far away to-day as ever it was, with no hope or no plan or no desire, as far as I know, to bring about the unity of this country, I think it would be well to do something to provide some of the amenities that are necessary for the prisoners in Sligo Prison. The food is not sufficient, not only in quantity, but in quality and it is badly cooked. The only substantial meal there is the stirabout at 4.30 in the afternoon. That is the only meal that would in any way take away the hunger. In the morning prisoners are awakened at 6 o'clock; they remain in their cells, doing nothing, until 8.15 or 8.30 when they get their breakfast which consists of an eighth of a loaf and two cups of tea. There is one pint of milk for every 18 pints of tea. I ask the Minister how would he like to drink tea with one pint of milk for every 18 pints of tea.
Comment on this
I dare say you did, but in fairness if we are trying to reform prison conditions or the prisoners themselves, is that the way to reform them? A pint of milk to 18 pints of tea! It does not even colour the tea but it makes it look ugly and sickly. I would rather drink it black. I admit there was sufficient butter but an eighth of a loaf is not sufficient for some men. It is not sufficient for big-bodied men with big appetites, farmers' sons and men who have been working on the soil. They told me that they were hungry the whole day long and even during the night.
Comment on this
In the evening at 7.30 they get a sixteenth of a loaf of bread and two cups of black tea which has been described by a district justice as a meal. It was in the papers. I have the cutting. He has not to live on it from 7.30 until 8.15 in the morning, already hungry before he got it, in many instances the tea cold, having to travel along icy corridors with the snow blowing in the air holes. The cooking utensils in Sligo Prison are in no way modern; they are completely out of date. The heating system is numb. There are two furnaces but neither is suitable for the prison, never was and never could be to my mind and if you sat on the top of them or went into them they would not burn you. For fun's sake I spat upon it one night and the spit was still wet the next morning. What amount of heat have the prisoners been getting in that prison for years past? They have, I believe, 20 tons of coal since the emergency and they never used a shovelful although you could squeeze the turf without putting very little pressure on it. That is what they are using for fuel although the coal is breaking up into dust. What greater emergency during the month of the blizzard than that emergency with no fuel, no turf and yet no fire to heat the prison. The governor of the prison, a very nice gentleman, told us when we were going in that there were 60 degrees of heat. I did not feel warm until I came out.
We were not concerned about ourselves. We were only a month in, but God help the poor devil who has to spend nine months or a year there. I ask the Minister to afford more recreation to those prisoners, more amenities, such as cards, wireless, a dart board, a billiard table and, particularly, to arrange for communal feeding in a place such as a refectory, instead of carrying the tea along corridors and passages as long as from here to the Department of Industry and Commerce across the way. There is a cold breeze blowing through those corridors and passages, and by the time you get the tea, it is ice cold. I cannot see why prisoners are not fed in a refectory with two or three warders watching over them. The canisters in which the tea is carried are supposed to be of aluminium but they are not finished and are partly black on the inside. They serve for the purpose of tea, porridge, soup, meat, vegetables and bread. One utensil is used in all cases and, in nine cases out of ten, when you get your tea, you find grease floating on it. You would want to have the stomach of a dog to drink that tea. The prisoners wash the utensils but oftentimes the water is only lukewarm and does not take away the grease. I should not object to tea being served in a vessel in which other food had been provided if it were clean. But one knows that it is not clean. Many times I could not drink my tea because of the grease floating on the top.
In the year 1947, there should be no objection to the use of cutlery. Shortly before we went in, the prisoners were supplied with a fork and a big soupspoon, sufficient to shovel gravel into a cart. Before that, they used their fingers and they had to put their hands down deeply into the canister because it was very high. I believe that cups and saucers should be used. I do not suggest that they should be of the fancy type; half-pint delf mugs would serve the purpose. The governor said to me that canisters were better because they kept the food warm. He is right in that. It would get cooler in the mug but, if you had a refectory near the kitchen into which the boys would march, that objection would not hold. I was told that, if that were done, some ruffians would pinch the food of the others. But you could have the refectory divided into cubicles and have two or three warders supervising them. The ruffians could be put back into their cells until they made up their minds that they would behave and be content with their own rations. It would be very easy to discipline those fellows. In Sligo Jail, there were only two prisoners who could be described as criminals or ruffians. There were 26 prisoners when I went in and only about 15 or 16 when I was leaving.
The greatest prisoner of the lot is the warder. He is the real prisoner. On Sunday, when prisoners are walking around the ring, he stands like a statue. Even though the weather be freezing, he has to keep his hands out of his pockets. He has no means of warming himself and he must stand there from 9.30 to 12.30 and from 2.30 to 4.30. I saw the soldiers on duty outside Buckingham Palace and they were provided with a little hut with an electric fire. At intervals, they left the hut and paraded up and down. In Sligo, the warders have to stand in the rain or snow watching the prisoners. Whether there are only two prisoners or 22 makes no difference. Then, they have the same uniform when they are on duty and off duty. If they get wet, they cannot change into another uniform; they have to keep on the same damp uniform all day. Their shoes are too light for winter, though they are all right for summer. They are too light for men who have to go to the farm or go out with young men who are carrying turf. I understand that two or three of those warders have gone to a sanatorium. They went in as healthy young men, which proves that the conditions under which they carry out their duties are not good. I understand that the warders' hostel, or place where they are accommodated, is out of date and unsuitable. Their furniture is completely out of date. They are very badly situated so far as furniture is concerned. It is unfair that they should be asked to sleep in the same type of bed, with the same type of mattresses and blankets, as the prisoners use. The men who are supervising the criminals in jail are treated in some instances worse than the criminals. In many cases, the criminal has more liberty than the warder. Even when off duty and walking through the grounds, the warder dare not smoke. That system is too Hitlerite. I ask the Minister to consider supplying those warders with a second uniform or, at least, a second pair of trousers. They have to go around the cells and corridors and have them clean before the governor comes round.
I heard many times of the authority of the sergeant-major but a governor is next to the Almighty when he comes around on inspection. The cells and corridors must be spotless and the warders have very often to clean them themselves. They do not like to be rough on the prisoners. If they were, perhaps they would not do anything for them and would have to be locked up. The warders, therefore, have to soil their uniforms in cleaning up. Yet, when they parade in the morning for inspection, they must be spick and span. They must use the same uniform when cleaning up and when on parade before the governor. If it is not spick and span, they are told off and penalised.
The allowance given to wardens when they go to the Circuit Court is not sufficient. Does the Minister really think that 9/- allowance is sufficient for a warden who leaves home and spends a night in Castlebar, having to pay for bed and breakfast, tea, dinner and lunch and come home again? Does he think that 1/6 is sufficient for tea for an untried prisoner who is landed in jail and has to go to court to be tried? Does he realise that, partly through shame and partly through charity, the warden has to put his hand in his pocket and pay for the untried prisoner? I can understand that, as no man could in decency walk into a restaurant and leave the poor prisoner hungry outside, even if he had committed a crime. That is something which should be seen to immediately.
There is great dissatisfaction amongst the staffs of all prisons as regards having to wear their uniforms out to the Circuit Court and back. Everybody knows who they are and they are not liked by anybody. People know the warden is taking a prisoner to or from jail and, Irish sympathy being what it is, a warden is not liked. It also embarrasses the young man who may be innocent of any crime and who is being taken to the Circuit Court to be tried. When he has to sit beside the warden, everyone assumes that he is a criminal, or at least a suspected one. It is worse still when the uniform itself—which is the only one they have —is soiled and stained and it is no credit to the prison staff when they go to the Circuit Court 40 or 50 miles away but within the district of the prison.
I am not saying these things with any venom or desire to vex the Minister or score a point on him. These are a few of the things I found out while in Sligo Prison. Otherwise, I would know nothing at all about them. I am merely asking the Minister, whenever an opportunity presents itself, to consider some of the points I have made and remedy them if he can. Better conditions should be brought about in our prison life. You will not reform a prisoner by treating him as he is treated at present in Sligo. If the other prisons are like Sligo, I cannot imagine him being reformed, but can imagine him getting worse and coming out determined to revenge the serving of his nine months on society in one way or another, no matter what the consequences may be. Even if he is told he will be kidnapped again and made serve three years in another prison, he will be determined to do it, because of the time he has already spent in prison.
The quantity and quality of food are not sufficient. There should be a refectory where all prisoners could have their meals together. If there were any blackguarding or abuse of that, there is a recognised way of dealing with it and a prisoner can be sent back to his cell for a certain number of days, as decided by the governor or the chief warden. These concessions should be used to reform the prisoners and bring them back to the straight path. There should be a ball alley and football field attached to every prison, so that the prisoners can spend Sunday in a more fitting manner than walking about with an idle mind. There should be a large recreation room for use in winter. There is none in Sligo. Imagine the conditions there, where four or five men are sent into each cell and all they have is a stool each to sit on, while there is a warden standing at the door looking through the glass, which is just about the size of an eye. That is deplorable and I cannot imagine the Minister having been all these years in office—or his predecessors, either—and allowing such a system to continue.
I am pleased that the Minister has given concessions in pay to the Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
Might I interrupt for a moment? What is the total bill for the increases to the Garda Síochána?
Comment on this
I mean the Minister, though I daresay that, if you got the chance, you would do so. I would like the Minister to take into consideration the points I have made in relation to the changing of Gardaí from one station to another and in particular the placing of married men, with children of 14 years and upwards, as near to secondary schools as possible. One or two houses should be let out specially for Guards in towns where there are not suitable barracks and, whether there are barracks or not, there should be houses for the married men.
This whole legal code is a very heavy expense to the taxpayer and I would like to see the whole face of it changed and the unnecessary red tape taken out.
When the Minister was replying to two questions this afternoon, I think he had not all the information at his disposal. Perhaps he is unaware that there is a case listed in the courts in Mayo in relation to the burning of this particular house, McEllins of Balla, and the Mayo County Council is going to oppose it. There is evidence in existence that it was a short circuit which caused the fire.
Comment on this
I do not think either the Minister or the Deputy should discuss it further, as it is sub judice.
Comment on this
That was why Deputy Cafferky was allowed to raise it now to that extent. He came to me and saw me about it.
Comment on this
The Minister may not be aware that this house was burned before there was any agitation in Balla or Ballyhaunis. I would like him to correct that when he is concluding the debate.
Comment on this
Deputy Cafferky's remarks about the rather inane and purposeless form of recreation, that is, marching round in circles, which seems to be a feature of prison life, prompts me to advert to what we observed when we went down, with the consent of the Minister, to visit Portlaoighise last year. That was one of the things that did strike us as being in need of urgent reform. I gathered, though I cannot check up on it at the moment, that so far as Portlaoighise is concerned the practice was discontinued there, or at least an effort was to be made to discontinue it. I am speaking from memory now, but I have an idea that that was to be one of the adjustments that would be made in that prison. If it is continued in Sligo Prison and other prisons, there is no reason why, if it has been altered in Portlaoighise, it should not likewise be altered there.
Since reference has been made to that particular form of prison routine, I would like to know from the Minister how far it will be possible for him to adopt the reforms that that particular deputation urged upon him as necessary, in so far as Portlaoighise prison is concerned. There were a number of matters, some minor and some major. To what extent they have been remedied I do not know, and I am sure it would be of interest to the House if the Minister would give us details.
There is one matter which has been raised every year on this Vote, since I came into the House, by other Deputies and by myself and I feel it is necessary to refer to it again to-day. It is the housing problem that confronts the Garda. I can speak with some experience of their position in the City of Dublin, where they are regarded as not being eligible for the Dublin Corporation houses. There can be no doubt that the Gardaí are faced, in the matter of housing, with an almost impossible position. I am not unmindful of the fact that an equally difficult position has arisen in our country towns and villages, where there is probably no choice at all, no available accommodation for members of the Garda Síochána. It is a serious position from the point of view of the administration of justice if those upon whom the responsibility of administration rests are not in a position to house themselves and their families.
I mention this matter again because last year the Minister indicated that serious notice was being taken of the position and plans were well in hand, or advanced, in relation to proper housing facilities. I would like to know what exactly is the position and what the Minister proposes to do in relation to housing. I realise that there are big difficulties to be surmounted, but it would be reassuring if we could have some idea as to how far the plans have been advanced and what eventually will they comprise.
Deputy Coogan, together with other Deputies and myself, last year referred to the position of District Court clerks. I desire to support the plea that has been made here in connection with those officials. I feel that it is necessary to do so on this occasion because last year, when we were discussing this matter, we were under the impression that the Minister was entirely sympathetic and that his sympathy would be demonstrated by immediate representations to the Minister for Finance. Deputies were left under the impression that the point we had in mind— pensions for the District Court clerks —would follow in a short time.
We had occasion recently in the House, when the matter was raised, though not quite in the definite way that it is being raised on this Vote, to note that it was evident the Minister was not quite so keen or enthusiastic as he was here last year. It may be that he did make strong representations to the Minister for Finance and it is possible he may not have been very warmly received, but I do not think that would be any justification for dropping a matter which seriously affects, not a large number of individuals—indeed, that number may now be regarded as a diminishing factor— but individuals who have given good service to the State and who are not being rewarded in the way in which people who serve the State well should be rewarded—that is, in the form of superannuation of a suitable type.
I wish to renew the appeal I made last year and early this year. Whatever qualms the Minister may have about his approaches to the Minister for Finance, I urge him to go again and point out the merits of this case and the feeling that there is in this House behind the appeal for justice for these men.
I am anxious to ascertain from the Minister what precisely have been the reactions to the Rent Restrictions Act of 1946, in which special provision was made for the fixing of fair rents for dwellings under a valuation of £10. It was envisaged at that time that district justices would be specially appointed for the purpose. I gathered from the Minister some time ago, when he was dealing with another question related to this, that not very many cases were accruing from the operation of that Act. My view is that if the legislation has not given the result which some of us felt it should give, that is entirely due to the fact that the masses of the people, particularly in the City of Dublin, are unaware of its provisions.
The Minister may say: "What can I do? I have passed legislation which was intended to be a measure of justice for those people. It is there and I set up all the necessary machinery and what more can I do?" But it is not very easy for the public precisely to understand every detail of an Act passed here. I venture to say that there are few members of the House, apart from those associated with the discussions on the Bill, who know the essential provisions of it. It might be possible by some method of publicity to bring home to the minds of the people in Dublin and elsewhere throughout the country the clauses in that Act that are available for them if they are worried about increased rents or feel they have a grievance.
The Minister has responded in a disappointing manner to the pleas that were made in connection with the need to set up courts to deal with furnished flats—again I have the City of Dublin in mind.
Comment on this
With your permission, I shall satisfy myself by intimating to the Minister that the replies he has given on this subject are not entirely satisfactory. May I hope that the justice of the case which has been made—that is, the case relating to the necessity for changing the law, and it is quite true that now I am on very dangerous ground—will be duly appreciated by the Minister and that he will move away from the replies he has been giving recently on this subject?
Comment on this
I want to deal with another matter and it will be the last suggestion that I shall make to the Minister to-night. It is a question in which members of all Parties are interested, namely, the question of legal aid for the poor. Here again is a reform which is urgently needed. Under present conditions we have one law for the rich and another for the poor. Any Deputy will readily understand that where an individual is not prepared to bear the expense of going into court or cannot bear the expense, the dice is loaded against him. He has not the necessary funds to employ a solicitor or counsel and thereby suffers a grievous hardship. This reform is already in operation elsewhere, and I think it is overdue here. I am sure our legal friends would be in a position to make a stronger case on that point than I can, but I should like to put it from the angle of the man in the street. I think that an unfortunate poor person who is not conversant with the various intricacies of the law should be safeguarded against himself, if you like, and that facilities should be made available whereby he can obtain such legal assistance as will enable him to obtain justice.
Comment on this
I have very few points to make on the Estimate—two being on matters of principle, and the rest on matters of detail. I am impelled to mention, firstly, a matter of principle by the sort of plea that Deputy Cafferky made to the Minister for justice in which he appeared to ask the Minister to instruct district justices to take a certain action in reference to a matter about which he felt very strongly. I am sure Deputy Cafferky did not realise the implications of his plea to the Minister. I want it to be made clear by the Minister in his reply that neither he nor his Department issue instructions of any kind, class or description to district justices. I have frequently taken the occasion here of Bills dealing with district justices, whether Courts of Justice Bills or Bills imposing additional jurisdiction on district justices, to make the strongest possible plea for the independence of these courts in the administration of justice. I have pointed out that there is a disposition in the proposals that have been introduced from time to time, and in the remarks of Ministers, to suggest that district justices are in some way subject to instructions from the Government or any Department of State. I think that this House should make it clear that a district justice should not, under any circumstances, be liable to receive instructions from any Department of State as to the manner in which he is to dispense justice. I regard that as a vitally fundamental matter and I ask the Minister to state categorically and specifically, whether he or his Department have had the habit or routine of issuing instructions or circulars dealing with the matters in which district justices exercise judicial functions. It would be deplorable if such a practice existed. There is a particular method by which the view of the Department or of the Attorney-General can be brought to the attention of the district justice and that is through the medium of the State Solicitor speaking in court and acting for the Department. I would regard it as a matter affecting fundamentally the administration of justice if it were to be the practice of the Department to send out circulars in any way directing justices as to how they are to administer the law. I would ask the Minister to state when replying, categorically and specifically, whether any such practice exists.
The second fundamental matter to which I wish to advert is one which is allied to some extent to the first matter. The Minister for Justice in his opening statement referred to the number of temporary justices. For years, I have been advocating here the abolition of the system of appointing temporary district justices. I believe the Minister has stated, as he stated on previous occasions, that he looks with disfavour on the system of appointing temporary district justices and he hopes that conditions will soon arise under which that system will no longer obtain. I have watched the course of events for the last 12 months and I am glad to see that a number of these temporary justices have been given permanent appointments. I hope the same will apply to the temporary justices at present in existence.
The matter of principle to which I wished to advert is that, in reference to the appointment of temporary district justices, and even to permanent district justices, it appears to be the continued practice of the Department of Justice to appoint these temporary justices and even permanent justices for political reasons and through political pressure. I have watched that system for some time in operation. It is a bad system; it is entirely wrong in my view when it obtains in reference to temporary district justices. During the period that a temporary district justice is administering justice, he is liable at any time to be recalled from his position. In that way he is indirectly, if not directly, subject to pressure which may be of a political nature in the exercise of his functions. It is undignified, improper and contrary to the public weal that when a vacancy arises pressure should immediately be brought to bear on the Minister to appoint A, B, C, or D, not because of his standing at the Bar or in the solicitor's profession but by reason of his political affiliations or because of the service which he has rendered at a general election to a political party.
The method by which judicial appointments, from the highest to the lowest, should be made, is, of course, a very wide matter upon which to embark but I think everybody will agree as to the desirability of some system which would prevent the appointment of temporary justices or indeed the filling of any other judicial appointments on political grounds. I agree that there is a great difficulty in devising such a system but I do think that the system which has obtained in years past in reference to temporary district justices has been deplorable, obviously resting on the principle of political affiliations. That is one of the reasons why I have so consistently in this House asked the Minister for Justice to put an end to the appointment of temporary district justices. These are the two matters of principle to which I intended to refer on this Vote.
There are some matters of detail, not of very great importance but one is a matter to which I have in vain referred year after year on this Estimate. I have referred to the practice of the Garda authorities in refusing to give to solicitors who are acting in running down cases, accident cases, in the civil courts, statements which had been made to Guards by witnesses when the Guards are investigating the circumstances of the accident. That request has been consistently refused by the Minister year after year. Yet, year after year and term after term, I have seen these very statements which have been refused to certain solicitors in the hands of their opponents. It is time that all sides should be equally treated. I agree that until any criminal proceedings have come to an end none of the statements should be at the disposal of any person who intends to be a party to a civil action; but, once any criminal proceedings have been brought to an end, statements collected by the Guards should be put at the disposal of all parties to the civil action and so put an end to what is nothing less than a scandal—one party to a civil action being in the position to get these statements from the Guards and to have them in court, while his opponent in the matter is refused and cannot get the statements.
There has been a change of practice in connection with the investigation of claims for criminal injuries. I understand that instructions have been given to the Guards to put at the disposal of county councils and other local authorities the statements and information collected by the Guards in their investigation of matters giving rise to the suspicion that a criminal injury has been committed. In addition to these statements being put at the disposal of local authorities, these statements should equally be put at the disposal of the applicants. In other words, all parties should be treated equally. That is all I am asking for. I am asking for no concession; I am asking that statements collected by the Guards in the course of their investigation of an accident or an alleged criminal injury should be put at the disposal, after all possibility of criminal proceedings being brought has ceased to exist, or after the determination of criminal proceedings, of all parties, and that all parties should be fairly treated.
The next matter to which I want to refer is the question of the employment of probation officers in the Dublin courts. I assume that there are no probation officers employed in any other part of the country. So far as I can see from the Book of Estimates, there are very few of these probation officers employed even in Dublin and they are employed at what appears to be a wretched stipend. The probation officers who, over a long period of years, have been the subject of eulogies from the Bench for the work they have done appear, so far as one can gather from the Estimates—whether they will partake of any increase following the general increase intended to be given to State servants, I do not know—to be paid a wretchedly low salary and they appear to occupy the unenviable position of being unestablished. Why should they be unestablished? Why should people who have proved themselves occupy the position of unestablished officers in such an important category in relation to the reform of individuals brought under their care or coming under observation?
The chief probation officer gets an inclusive salary of £350. The men probation officers get a salary of £250, increasing by £10 to £300 and women probation officers £200 by £10 to £250. It appears to me that there is a strong case for an increase in the number of such officers throughout the country and it also appears to me that there is an unanswerable case for an improvement in the wretched salaries set out in the Estimate. I notice with some interest that the amount allocated in this year's Estimates for policewomen amounts to a sum of £437. Perhaps the Minister would vouchsafe some information to the House as to (a) the number of policewomen employed, (b) the necessity for the employment of those who are employed, (c) whether they perform any useful functions, and (d) whether, if the existing policewomen perform useful functions, sufficient of these officials are in fact employed for the purpose they are intended to serve.
As to the matter of legal aid for the poor, raised by Deputy O'Sullivan, all sides of the House would be prepared to approve of a scheme designed to achieve the ends to which he referred. I stated on one occasion that I never heard of any person who was prevented from coming to the court by lack of funds, and in fact the less funds you have, very often, the better chance you have, because you can carry your case right up to the last court in the land and it does not matter what costs are given against you, if you have no means to pay them. But there may be some cases in which hardship is caused by lack of the necessary funds to conduct a case. Considerable work is done by a section of the Society of St. Vincent de Paul in connection with that matter.
The last point I propose to deal with is one on which the Ceann Comhairle perhaps will grant me some slight indulgence, in view of the indulgence he gave to Deputy O'Sullivan, because if I do not cross the threshold of the limits of what is allowable in debate on the Estimate, I will go perilously close to it. I will put my foot on the threshold, but, I hope, no more, because while I do not intend to advocate legislation, I am going to make a complaint against the Minister. I introduced into the House some years ago a Bill dealing with the reform of the law of torts. That Bill was given a First Reading and was then referred to a select committee. The Minister, after the committee had been set up, agreed with me that he would put into shape the proposals contained in the Bill I had introduced and introduce them into the House. I know that that Bill has been drafted and I put down a question here some short time ago asking when it would be brought in. To my utter astonishment, I discovered for the first time that the Bill was connected with a nebulous law reform committee. The position is that we neither have a law reform committee nor is my Bill to be brought in after the lapse of four or five years. I have waited patiently, and I have had some correspondence about the Bill. I was given what I thought was a promise by the Minister that the Bill would be introduced. It is a Bill which is required urgently. It deals with the matter of the reform of the law of torts, and I think I have a complaint against the Minister. I do not say that he broke any undertaking to me, but I was under the impression that he promised that the Bill would be introduced, and there was certainly no reference whatever to any question of the provisions of the Bill being in any way the subject matter of consideration by a law reform committee. That was never mentioned until I got this fobbing-off reply the other day from the Minister.
Comment on this
I want to raise the matter of the existing Garda regulation under which members of the Garda Síochána are not permitted to be stationed at any place within 30 miles of their home or 30 miles of where their relatives reside. Frankly, I have never been able to understand the inspiration behind that regulation, unless it was the suspicion—I think, a thoroughly unreasonable suspicion—that a Garda could not be trusted to discharge his duties fairly if he were within 30 miles of his home or within 30 miles of his family home. For the past 25 years, the Garda authorities have assumed that if a Garda was stationed at a particular station, he would have to be transferred from that station if, by any chance, it was within 30 miles of his home. That regulation is "daft." I think it is perfectly archaic, but apparently some people can find an even greater realm of "daftness" than that which is accepted as the standard pattern.
Recently I came across a case of a Guard who was stationed in a small village. He had a large family and, being anxious to provide for them, he secured employment for one of his daughters in a local shop. There was nothing very sensational or world-shaking about that. The Garda authority proceeded to look up the regulation and informed him that he would have to go. The poor man, who had been trying to supplement the family income by placing his daughter in employment, discovered that his reward for his zeal on behalf of his family was a notification that he was to take his family out of that particular place. He could leave his daughter there but the daughter was a girl of 18 years of age, employed outdoor in the particular shop, and what she was to do when the family went away was not indicated. If the daughter got a job in any place where the father and the family were, the father and the family would have to go and, presumably, the daughter would have to go with them or remain there on her own, at an age when, obviously, it was desirable that she should be under paternal control. I hope the Minister for Education, who is now deputising for the Minister for Justice, will ask that sympathetic gentleman to examine this matter sympathetically.
Comment on this
The facts do not matter. It is the regulation that matters. As a matter of fact, I made inquiries in connection with this case and was told it was the regulation. I think the Minister for Education, being a rather skilful politician, has discovered cases of that kind himself. I suggest that this whole thing should be considered in the light of the fact that we have had a Garda force for the past 25 years and that whatever need there was for these extraordinary precautions in 1922 and 1923 does not exist to-day. We ought to get rid of an out-moded, archaic regulation of that kind. The Guards are not foreigners. They have not been discovered in a jungle and brought in here to police the Irish. They are our own flesh and blood, our kith and kin. They have as good a conception of citizenship and of private and public rectitude as any member of this House. It ought to be assumed that if a Guard does happen to desire to be stationed at a place near his own home town, that it is a natural desire on his part and unless there is clear evidence, by his action or inaction or by any misdemeanour on his part, that his being stationed near his home is likely to impair the efficient discharge of his duties, he ought to be allowed to remain there. The onus of proving that it is undesirable that he should remain there should be on the Garda authorities. They should proceed on the basis of assuming that a particular Guard is a conscientious member of the force, that he can be trusted and that, if he discharges his duties, he will be allowed to remain at the station but that if he does not discharge his duties satisfactorily at a particular station, he may have to accept the consequence of transfer elsewhere.
I think it is a reasonable request to make, in 1947. I think the original regulation was the product of suspicion, an unreasonable suspicion, so far as the members of the Garda are concerned, and I am satisfied that if the Minister looks into the matter, and will realise the amount of hardship caused to the individual and the negligible benefit conferred on the Garda as a force, the sheer logic of the situation will convince him of the undesirability of perpetuating the present out-moded regulation.
Comment on this
A few weeks ago, dissatisfaction was expressed in the news-papers that the Taca were not being credited with their full service— whether for pensionable purposes or for permanent status, I do not know If men who have served an apprenticeship in the Guards are being moved up, having been found satisfactory, they should be given full credit for the full time from the first day they entered the service. I do not fully understand the complaint but dissatisfaction was expressed.
Some time ago the Minister was asked whether it was his intention to have mounted police helping to regulate traffic in the City of Dublin. In the days of the Dublin Metropolitan Police we had mounted police. It would be a tribute to the horse-breeding industry if the Minister carried out the suggestion. Owing to slowness in putting up traffic lights in the City of Dublin and its outskirts many hold-ups in traffic occur. At the junction of George's Street and Dame Street, traffic hold-ups occur simply because there is a hold-ups at Trinity Street or O'Connell Street. If we had mounted police they could adjust matters.
In Dublin City there is a shortage of uniformed Guards. There may be plenty of Guards in the detective force, engaged on political and other types of work. While they do very useful work, it would be well to augment their numbers so that Dublin City could have more uniformed Gardaí. Guards in uniform act as a deterent to criminal activities. In the old days of the Dublin Metropolitan Police in Dublin I often saw six or eight and sometimes 12 members of the force in uniform pacing up and down on opposite sides from Trinity College to the Parnell Monument. From what I see now I feel certain that we have not enough Guards on duty in the City of Dublin. I hope, too, that the Minister will see his way to provide a mounted force to regulate traffic in the city. That would also be the means of showing people the magnificent type of horses we have, and would be a help to the horse-breeding industry.
Comment on this
I think that in future some effort should be made by the Department to facilitate Guards who desire to get a change from a particular district. They are sometimes denied that. It may be that a man wants a change because, if he is a married man, he finds he cannot afford the house rent he is paying or it may be that he wants more suitable provision for the education of his children. If a Guard is willing to undertake the expense of his transfer he should not be denied it. I know, of course, that his superior officers may think that he is a suitable man in a particular district or that he is suited for special work and therefore they will not sanction the transfer. I do not think it is a good thing to keep a man in a district against his will. If he is annoyed by reason of the fact that his application is refused he is not likely to make a good member of the force.
There is also what is known within the force as the 30 mile limit. I think that, in some cases, the regulation dealing with that is carried too far. I do not think any Guard could be said to have friends within 30 miles of his station by whom he would be likely to be influenced. I think that regulation might be relaxed, and that some discretion should be given to superior officers in carrying it out.
Deputy Cafferky gave the House an outline of what prison conditions are like. I cannot speak from personal knowledge of prison conditions, but in prisons you have two categories. You have in the first what are called first offenders, and in the second category the hardened old lag. The first offender may be in prison for some minor offence committed perhaps when he had too much drink taken. I think the Minister should inquire into the possibility of keeping these two classes of prisoners apart. The conditions should be made easier for the first offender and every effort should be made to turn him out a decent respectable citizen. Otherwise, he may become what Deputy Cafferky described as an enemy of society, one who is determined to revenge himself on somebody or other because he feels he has been too severely dealt with. There must, of course, be pretty severe conditions for the hardened criminal— for the person who is constantly breaking the law. I understand that some of them actually acquire a liking for prison life, tough and hard as it is. There can be no easing of the conditions for them.
I now come to the point where, under the jurisdiction of the Minister, two members of this House were committed to prison. I think I am correct in saying that the Minister himself suffered a term of imprisonment when this country was under foreign rule. I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that it was a harsh and savage act to send two members of this House to prison. It will be absolutely necessary for me to go into the causes that led up to this.
Comment on this
I did not send them to prison. The Deputy cannot put the blame for that on me. I do not put people in prison, and I had nothing whatever to do with that.
Comment on this
On you and your Department. The courts, the law and the prisons are all administered by the Minister for Justice and his Department. I definitely lay the blame on your Department, and I will give my reasons.
Comment on this
The decisions of the courts and the judgments of the courts cannot be raised and debated in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I am not raising the decisions of the courts, but I am going into the causes that led up to this alleged breach of the law.
Comment on this
I do not think so. We are discussing on this Vote the prisons. The Minister himself has dealt with delinquency and with crime. I think I am justified, within the rules of order, in going into the causes that led up to a particular decision of the courts. I respectfully submit that I am not out of order in dealing with that.
Comment on this
This is a peculiar one. I think I am entitled to have on the records of the House the causes that led up to this alleged breach of the peace.
Comment on this
With all respect, that does not say that the matter cannot be redealt with here. Surely if a court makes a decision on a certain case that comes before it, it is open to a Deputy who wants to speak on it here to do so. In this place, where we have freedom of speech, it is open to every Deputy to speak on that decision.
Comment on this
I will give a short account of the causes that led up to this alleged breach of the peace.
Comment on this
On a point of order, while I do not want to stop any Deputy from speaking, I do want to say that this is going to be a new situation if the Minister for Justice is to be held responsible for what a district justice or a Circuit Court judge does. That would simply be an impossible situation. I have no right or authority to interfere with a district justice or a Circuit Court judge, and I am not going to be held responsible for what a district justice or a Circuit Court judge does. It would be setting a very dangerous precedent if there was to be any interference with the decisions of the courts. I may say that Deputy Cafferky to-day was under a misapprehension when he suggested that I made suggestions to the District Court. I cannot do any such thing, and I have never attempted to do it.
Comment on this
I never had the slightest intention of reviewing judicial decisions but the Minister has told us that he is not responsible for certain officials in this Department, yet he asks this House for a Vote for their salaries. He is particularly stupid this afternoon.
Comment on this
A certain alleged breach of the law occurred on a certain day in Ballyhaunis, and I was going to go into the causes that led up to that. In my opinion, any breach of the law does not occur without a cause, much less responsible Deputies who have the backing of 7,000 or 8,000 supporters each surely did not commit a breach of the law without some serious cause. They are both good-living men: both of them are teetotalers, and I wish to put on the records of this House the causes that led up to it. This particular matter that I am dealing with has absolutely no relation at all to the matter that was raised at Question Time to-day. I only want to clear the air a little bit. I will deal with that later. These are the causes that led——
Comment on this
I beg to differ with you, Sir. These are the causes. I am not asking the Minister to shoulder responsibility but I claim that I am within the rules of order to deal with this matter.
Comment on this
The Deputy must confine his remarks to the administration of the Minister's Department and things he is responsible for on the Estimates for his Department. He is not responsible for the matters that the Deputy is going into now.
Comment on this
With all due respect to the ruling of the Chair, the Chair may be prophetic but the Chair does not know what I am going to say.
Comment on this
I will give a very short survey of the whole case—that was that a set of conditions which were absolutely unbearable existed in three townlands.
Comment on this
What has that to do with the Minister's Estimate? Show me the connection between the conditions in three townlands and the responsibility——
Comment on this
The conditions in the townlands led up to breaches of the law and they come under the administration of the Minister. Suppose there is a burst of crime in a particular place, of stealing bicycles, motor cars, bags, overcoats or anything like that, would not Deputies be allowed to come into the House and inquire into the causes and not alone that but suggest remedies?
Comment on this
If a decision of a district justice is given without having due cognisance of what led up to the act in finding a person guilty, is not a Deputy entitled to question the Minister as regards that decision if in his opinion due cognisance was not taken?
Comment on this
If the debate is going to continue like this, it is a very bad precedent. I have no responsibility for the courts and as I pointed out the salaries are not voted; they are on the Central Fund.
Comment on this
I did not intend to go into a court decision. The Minister is trying to draw a red herring across the track.
Comment on this
The fact remains that owing to unbearable conditions 41 people were asked to continue living in a state of semi-starvation on miserable holdings of land of about £3 valuation.
Comment on this
But it led up to a certain matter that comes under the jurisdiction of the Minister's Department and I am raising that now, Sir, and I claim the right to discuss it. I always like to agree to obey the rules of the Chair but I hold that I am perfectly within the rules of order of the House——
Comment on this
I do not want to rule in a way that will not conform with the Deputy's own judgment but he knows that on an Estimate he can only deal with the administration of the Minister's Department for the year under review.
Comment on this
If every court decision comes up here the situation will become impossible. I have no authority or right to interfere with any court decision. I think it would be a very bad thing if the Deputy were allowed to interfere with a court decision. I am asking for a firm ruling.
Comment on this
These court decisions cannot be raised by the Deputy nor any of the circumstances that led up to the case that came before the court.
Comment on this
There will be another place where that decision will be questioned and that is at a meeting of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges because, while obeying the ruling now, I hold that the decision of the Chair is wrong, with all due respect.
Comment on this
The Deputy can put down a motion of censure on the Chair if its decision does not appeal to him.
Comment on this
Very good. This will not be out of order. That if Deputies Commons and Cafferky were entitled to a month in jail for what they considered to be a particularly grievous case and a case in which two successive Governments for 25 years have deliberately asked 41 tenants to starve——
Comment on this
I have ruled that out of order. The Deputy must obey the Chair or sit down. It has come to that.
Comment on this
Very well, but I will conclude with this remark that, if these two Deputies were worthy of a month in jail for their offences, the Minister for Lands, Deputy Seán Moylan, should be in jail for the rest of his days for his criminal negligence in his management of the affair.
Comment on this
The Deputy must withdraw the allegation that the Minister is guilty of a possible criminal offence.
Comment on this
Very good, I will withdraw it here but I will certainly say it where I will not have to withdraw it. I want to clear up a certain matter. The Minister to-day, in reply to Questions Nos. 18 and 19, made use of certain words. He said:—
"In connection with an agrarian dispute in the course of which a house was burned."
The Minister must have fully realised the importance and the significance of that statement. In other words, I take it that the Minister is using his position as Minister to make sure that a certain malicious injury claim will be paid in full to the claimant. He states that it was during an agrarian dispute. Where did the Minister get his information on that subject? I might as well tell the Minister, and I have an intimate knowledge of the place and the conditions there, that there was no agrarian dispute in that particular instance, nor is there yet, nor will there be an agrarian dispute about it. Where did the Minister get his information that there was an agrarian dispute there? What incidents or what facts have come to the Minister's notice that led him to believe that there was an agrarian dispute? He states: "in the course of which a house was burned", clearly indicating that, as a result of the agrarian dispute, the house was burned. Would the Minister say what exactly was his information on that? Did he get his information from the Civic Guards in Castlebar? Strange to say, I do not think that he did or could. He is strangely silent on the subject now.
Comment on this
I merely rose to a point of order. My practice is to take a note of Deputies' questions and not to answer them by interrupting. I rose on the last occasion because I thought the Deputy was out of order. I am taking notes of his questions.
Comment on this
The Minister answered a definite question. The position of a Minister of State is a fairly responsible one and we must take it that statements made by Ministers here and on platforms outside are as near the truth as is reasonably possible. In his reply, the Minister said that the presence of the Garda force was "intended to prevent breaches of the peace in connection with an agrarian dispute in the course of which a house was burned". I ask him for an explanation of that. I will not wait for his speech. I shall give way to him if he has an explanation to offer. I am leaving the door open if he has given an answer on a matter of which he was not properly informed. That is a very serious statement in view of certain happenings. There is a claim for £5,000 for malicious injury in connection with this house which is alleged to have been maliciously damaged. Only one house in Balla was burned and local opinion is that it was purely accidental and was due to the short-circuiting of an electric wire. There is no agrarian agitation in the place, good, bad or indifferent. Has the Minister anything to say on the subject before I proceed?
Comment on this
I shall deal with the matter when I am concluding. That is my practice.
Comment on this
Would it be the Minister's intention to accuse Deputy Commons and myself of the crime of arson?
Comment on this
That is what he is trying to imply. That is what I want to get out of the Minister because this matter will not end here. The Minister may be called upon to prove or disprove his words later. Here is the time and here is the place. It is not a question of some days hence when he may be asked to do it. If he has been misinformed or if he has given an answer without due consideration to a very important question, he should say so.
Otherwise, it appears that he is favouring a member of his own Party in a very underhand way. That is the way it appears to me. This is a very serious matter. The Minister is still silent. We shall hear him later.
Comment on this
I congratulate the Minister on one aspect of the activities of his Department—that is, the absence of political crime. I think that political crime is practically finished here and that is largely due to the firmness with which the Minister approached his task. If we had had a molly-coddle in that position, we might have the same old crime to which we were accustomed during the past 15 years. There are many matters which require attention in the case of the Garda. Deputy Martin O'Sullivan referred to one—the separation of Gardaí from their wives and families. I know of Gardaí who are 35 and 40 miles removed from their families. These men have been 21 or 22 years in the Garda and it is a crime against them and their families that they should be so situated. They are men with splendid records, and I do not see why they should be so separated from their families. Some allowance should be made for these Gardaí, especially in the case of men with good records.
One of the most notable achievements of the Irish Government was the setting up of the Garda force. I am satisfied, however, that, for the past ten or 12 years, that force has not been up to scratch. They are getting a bit sloppy and the force is falling off. Members of the force will assent to what I have said. When General O'Duffy and Assistant Commissioner Cullen were in charge, they had the force spick and span and it was really efficient. I shall not say that it was a militant force but it was a disciplined force. At present, it is a sloppy force and from the sergeants down, they admit that. They say that something is wrong. I hate to say that because I am a great admirer of the Gardaí but some tightening up is needed. I know that a number of the Gardaí are getting old and will soon be retiring. Perhaps then the force will be put on a proper basis and the Gardaí will be a greater protection to the people. A vast amount of petty larceny in the country is going undetected. Of course, during a war there is always a certain amount of crime but too much petty larceny is being left undetected. The reason for that is, I think, that our Gardaí are more civil servants than protectors of the people. They cannot attend to their normal duties because of all the other work they have to do. They are doing this work when they should be walking the highways and byways protecting the people's property and homes. The Civil Service mentality in the Garda may be effecting a saving but it is a bad thing. I should rather see the force carrying out its proper duty—that of protecting the people's property and detecting crime. I think that it will do no harm to sound this note of warning. It will be good even for the Gardaí themselves. I think that they are satisfied that the force is getting a bit sloppy.
As regards the Garda barracks in the country, I am not satisfied that an earnest effort is being made to build proper barracks. Some of these barracks are badly needed. In some cases, the Gardaí are living in condemned houses. An earnest effort should be made to provide proper barracks, with four or five decent dwellings around them, for the accommodation of Gardaí. At present, they are living down bog roads, and byways, a long way from the barracks. That is not right. I know of Gardaí with four or five children who were brought to court and given four or five months to get out of their houses. The unfortunate men did not know what to do. They were running about from Billy to Jack trying to get houses, irrespective of whether they were condemned or not. That is extremely unsatisfactory. A Garda should be immune from that sort of thing. It causes him a great deal of trouble and Gardaí cannot do their work efficiently because they have too many private worries. Over a long number of years, our Gardaí were not paid sufficiently. To the ordinary man, their pay seems good enough but a large number of our Gardaí have to supplement their pay by going into land or selling cattle or cutting turf and selling it. I am not saying these things for the purpose of creating a scare but because they are a fact. It is unfortunate that a Garda has to cut a cart of turf and sell it. I do not think that that is a good thing. If they require more pay, they should get it.
Comment on this
I am not speaking of time off. The whole day long they do it. The Deputy need not tell me about it. I know what I am talking about.
Comment on this
A lot of them are cutting turf for sale. If they were cutting it for themselves, well and good——