We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Vote 32—Office of the Minister for Justice.

Contributions 135–269 of 269. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

If a Garda is off duty, it is his own time and he can do what he likes with it.

Comment on this

I am not saying that he is off duty. What we want is a tiptop efficient force. We had it in the past and we could have it again. Our Guards should be satisfactorily housed and paid and let do the work of Gardaí and nothing else. Private business should not enter into it. As far as the Royal Ulster Constabulary were concerned, they had to keep to their beat and do their job. I am not going to say they were better than the present force, but I think they were more kept away from private enterprise.

I would like the Minister to see that the juror gets his travelling and hotel expenses. I know a man who came 25 and 30 miles and had to spend a few days coming and going as he could not afford a car. He was out of pocket and had to go round the town, begging hotel accommodation. When there is a big case on, hotel accommodation should be arranged for those jurors and they should not have to go knocking from door to door at third- and fifth-rate houses, to try to get accommodation in the capital towns. I do not say they should be paid for doing the job, but they should not be out of pocket.

I listened very earnestly to Deputy Cafferky's remarks about the prison system and I am satisfied that reasonable reforms are needed, but I am satisfied also that prison is for punishment—and I do not say that in regard to Deputy Cafferky, who was a recruit at the time. I went from Arbour Hill to Mountjoy and the Union and to several prisons in England and Scotland. I went there often and I got as good a gruelling as anyone else. It gave me plenty of time to meditate on the things worth meditating on. I am satisfied that things are not bad now. I served in the first and second division in Mountjoy under the British system and it was not too bad at all. I know the Governor in Mountjoy, Seán Kavanagh, one of the finest humanitarian and Christian people in the land, a grand type of man, who would not like to see any man suffering unduly if it could be avoided.

I say it is a fair system. Anyone who looks for trouble should get it. We hear talk of the prisons which are full of hoboes who looked for trouble, but there is nothing about the people who had property stolen, or their necks nearly broken by thugs and thieves. We are told we must reform the prison system and have ball alleys and football fields for the prisoners. We should do no such thing. Let them sit there and reform and, if they have a conscience, they will have plenty of time to reform. I am not saying that for the juvenile criminal who is just starting off, but for the general run of prisoners our prison system is not so bad at all. I have no use at all for all this humanitarian nonsense talked about by these women with Pekes on a chain, whom we find writing about the prison system. They are the very people who would be quick to go for the Garda if their own dog were stolen. I do not want any of this mollycoddling. I have great regard for the present Minister. He had a tough job and we all know he has a good human heart at the same time.

In regard to the stirabout, I want to tell Deputy Cafferky that I ate the porridge in prison and I suppose I spent ten minutes taking ten cockroaches out of every tin. Along with that, I was damn glad to scrape the cockroach, in case there might be any porridge left on him. I had a dirty plank bed in Mountjoy for three months and the same in a Scottish prison for another three months, making six months entirely, and I say it did not do me any harm. Our prisons are the cleanest, perhaps, in Europe. I remember the time in the North Dublin Union when I spent a fortnight there, when six comrades were executed in Mountjoy, and if I put my hand up to my neck I could take down 20 lice without touching my head at all. I slept with some of the dirtiest thugs from the slums, that the Black and Tans had been rounding up and putting in. I slept in a place for a fortnight with 350 men, where there was no lavatory, and the smell and the stench were colossal. Along with that, every second night the Black and Tans were machine-gunning us through the windows, to make us keep our heads down.

It is time that the like of Deputy Cafferky realised what we went through in those days. Along with 16 colleagues, I was put to do one of the most inhuman things ever known in any prison in Europe. There were 40 acres attached to Perth Prison and ten of us were yoked as horses to the plough and had to plough the 40 acres —I could bring anyone to the place and show them—and make drills, and grub and till them. We pulled the plough with collars round our necks and we were glad to do it instead of being locked up in prison picking oakum. If you know what it is like to pick oakum in a crowded prison, you know you would not stick it long. We were glad to be out in the open fields, although it was inhuman and unnatural work. When you compare those times and that type of prison with our Mountjoy, you find that the one is a hotel and the other is hell—and that is saying very little.

I never got a pick of meat any time during 12 months while I was in prison and never saw a newspaper and did not know the Truce was on or that the Treaty had been signed, until I was told we were going home. These are some of the things we can look back on with pride now, as we were doing it for a cause and not as thugs and criminals. So I ask the Minister not to mind this humanitarian nonsense. If men commit crimes deliberately, with their eyes open, and our fellow citizens are the sufferers, let them get their merits. I do not want to give them what I went through, but give them the ordinary punishment in an ordinary manly way. If, as Deputy Cafferky said, we are making some of them come out and do worse things, let us put them in again for a longer time and if, when they come out again, they still do it, let us put them in again. There is too much of this mollycoddling and slop. I met some of those who were in and I remember a man who was in for a month and out for a month for drinking and he said to me: "It's not a very bad place at all; I am chopping wood all day and, honestly, I would rather be in than out—and I often did a good drunk to get in." That is from a man who was in half his life. The prison system may seem too hard for the soft mollycoddle type of people, but for a tough man who does not give a damn for God or man it is not half hard enough.

I am glad that the political crime is easing off and I think we have reached the stage when there is a lot of commonsense now and the political platform is able to absorb all, whether it is an extreme group outside the House or inside it. That is a big achievement in our history and I am glad the Minister stuck firm, dug his heels in the ground and did the job well. We must give him every thanks for what he did. He has weeded out political crime, he has put on the yoke and put them on the platforms, and what more could he do?

Comment on this

In the course of the debate, Deputies Coogan and O'Sullivan strongly appealed on behalf of District Court clerks for an improvement in their conditions and I heartily concur in their appeal. I wish to supplement it by including Circuit Court clerks in the same category and I think their case is long overdue for attention. As far back as 1939, an establishment scheme was promised for unestablished clerks in District Courts. A few months ago, the Minister said here that the matter was under consideration. Perhaps the intervention of the war was responsible for its being put off, but it is a long time from 1939 to 1947 and there is still no improvement in the position of the gentlemen and ladies who carry out their work under conditions which are not a credit to the Department of Justice. Men who have given service to the country in the I.R.A. or in the Army or in the Volunteer Force during the emergency and are now in service as District Court clerks are getting £3 15s. 0d. while ladies are getting £2 12s. 0d. If you compare that with the present increases which have been rendered necessary by the increased cost of living, and where the Labour Court has had to operate and has functioned successfully, we find they have given increases which are justified for one reason alone, that is, the altered value of money. When you find builders' labourers getting 2/- an hour, or £4 14s. 0d. a week for a 47-hour week, and District Court clerks working for £2 12s. 0d. a week, what can you think of such a position?

Comment on this

The Deputy must mean a 44-hour week.

Comment on this

I am speaking of conditions in my own city, Limerick. It is a 47-hour week where I am. If it were a 44-hour week my case would be better still. The rates for a builder's labourer in Limerick entitle him to a weekly sum of £4 14s. 0d. That was decided by the Labour Court as being a reasonable and equitable wage in the present circumstances. It ought to be enough to urge the Minister to get busy on the preparation of whatever scheme he has in mind to improve and uplift the standard of the clerks in the District Courts. I suggest we ought to have some regard for the importance of the work performed by these officials; you cannot but have the greatest sympathy for a man who is not adequately paid for the important work he does.

It must be remembered that those people have had to carry on during the emergency, when the cost of living increased far beyond their ability to cope with it. They must have suffered many hardships and they had no redress. There was no amelioration of their conditions in a very trying period. I make a strong appeal to the Minister to get on with this scheme that he has on hands. I trust he will, in conjunction with the Department of Finance, do all he can properly to remunerate those court clerks. Up to the present there has not been much justice in their treatment, notwithstanding that they are officials of the Department of Justice.

We have heard so much to-day about jails and prisoners, I do not propose now to go into that subject. Deputy Caffery has given us a résumé of his experiences in Sligo Jail. When it comes to my turn for a short stretch, I trust the Minister will send me to Limerick Prison. I do not think the conditions there could be quite so bad as the conditions that were depicted by Deputy Cafferky. I suggest that the Minister should not take the remarks of Deputy Giles too seriously; his descriptions went to extraordinary limits.

I will not deal now with prisoners, but I should like to know do Deputies ever consider those fellows who have been inside the prison for the best part of their lives—the warders and the other prison officials, who have given such long and faithful service to the State? Those are the people who have a very onerous and undesirable type of job to carry out. In the circumstances in which they live, they are more or less prisoners themselves. Looking at any of the Estimates that are before the House, I think I am quite safe in saying they are amongst the worst paid sections of our public servants. From the lower grades in the prison service, from the warders to the chief warder, I believe it cannot be claimed that they are even reasonably paid. It would be desirable, and it would be no more than just, if the Minister were seriously to consider treating those servants in a better way, giving them something to meet the increased cost of living. I submit there is a reasonable and a just case for increasing the remuneration of warders and wardresses and prison staffs generally.

And now for a subject that has been referred to by nearly every speaker— that is, housing accommodation for the Garda. I still think that this is a matter that should have been attended to long before now. The present scarcity of building materials is not sufficient justification for any further delay in attending to it. If the Department of Justice wants to build houses for the Garda they would be well able, with the co-operation and assistance of the Board of Works, to mobilise materials just as readily as any of the private builders. The Garda urgently require accommodation, not alone in the cities and towns, but in the country districts. They are placed in a very unfortunate position when they are transferred from one area to another, because there is no provision whatever made for them in the important matter of housing.

They may go to the local authority looking for a house. Naturally, there is a great deal of jealousy on the part of citizens, who have their names on the list for God knows how long, and they resent the Garda coming from outside areas trying to get possession of any houses that may become vacant. We who are members of county councils or corporations are quickly told-off if we help a Garda to get a house. I am aware of a case that came up recently in Limerick where a Garda was prosecuted for over-holding. The unfortunate man had no other place to go. The landlady succeeded in getting the house. What became of the Garda, I do not know.

What Deputy Giles stated is quite true. The Gardaí are obliged to live in all sorts of unsuitable places. In the cities their position, though difficult enough, may not be quite so bad. Some of them may get the ear of the public authorities, but that is an unfair position in which to place them. There is a manifest duty on the Department to provide sufficient houses in the cities and in the country for the members of the Garda Síochána, so that they will be in a position of independence and, if they are transferred from one district to another, the transfer will not hold half the terrors that it now holds, when a man has to enter a new area without any prospect of a house. I have known cases where men were transferred and they had to leave their families in the district from which they were removed. I have known a husband to be separated from his wife for years because he could not get a house in the area to which he was transferred.

The Minister should regard this as a matter of urgency. The difficulty of obtaining materials should not be put forward as a justification. They have as good an opportunity of obtaining those materials as the private builders. I hope we will not be told that this matter cannot be attended to because of the scarcity of materials. A proper housing scheme for the Garda Síochána is too long due and it should be attended to at once.

Comment on this

There is one subject which has been debated considerably to-day, and it was debated also during the past 12 months, and that is prison reform. It is undoubtedly a delicate question to deal with. It is a question which must be approached with care because there is and there always will be in this country a tendency to exploit this subject for political motives. During the long period when the people of this country were engaged in what is now known as a resistance movement, prison conditions and the evils and faults of the prison system were thoroughly exploited for national reasons.

Since this country became independent, there has been a tendency to continue to exploit prison conditions for the same reasons, and in dealing with this matter there is a danger that some people may be led to exaggerate the evils of the prison system; they may be led by some people who are agitating and using this subject for political motives to take up the case for prison reform without fully investigating the facts and without dealing with the matter in a detached way. There is also the danger that the Minister, and perhaps members of the House, realising that prison conditions are the subject of political agitation, may be tempted to resist all demands for any kind of inquiry into prison conditions, and any kind of reform. There is definitely a middle course, a course which I think ought to appeal to the Minister, and that is to find out as far as he can what faults, if any, exist in the system, and he should remove these faults as far as he can.

I have not the honour or the privilege to be able to speak of prison conditions with inside knowledge. I did, however, take the trouble to wade through a volume written by a man who did penal servitude. I must say that that book appeared to give an honest account of the prison conditions as they exist. It would appear to me to be a fair and reasonable account of prison conditions.

I must say that, reading it in a fair and detached way, there was not in that book many very serious charges brought against the prison authorities. There were statements that prison buildings are out of date. I think most people will agree on that subject but you cannot tear down and rebuild prisons every second year. There was also one matter which appeared to call for reform. It is a rather small matter—the conveyance of prisoners in public vehicles and in the eyes of the general public. Some privacy should be afforded, as a matter of ordinary justice and fair play, to prisoners and, particularly, to first offenders. There was also another matter mentioned which certainly did appear to be wrong and that is the lengthy period for which prisoners are confined to their cells during week-ends. It may be that confinement is considered necessary in order to give warders some time off, but I think it is a matter which should be inquired into. I think a reasonable amount of recreation should be afforded to prisoners at week-ends and on Sundays particularly. Viewed from an objective and detached standpoint, I think it will be admitted that there is a case for some reform in our present system, but it is not a matter which can be effected in one day or in one year. It is a matter of a long-term policy which should be carefully planned and carried out in easy stages.

I would not refer to this matter at all if it were not for the fact that, in common with probably every other Deputy, I received a communication from some organisation in America which claims to be very deeply interested in our prison system. The organisation, I might mention, calls itself the Connolly Memorial Committee and the communication is signed by a person named Gerald O'Reilly. The writer states:—

"People are particularly sensitive to-day about the treatment afforded to prisoners especially where political ideas and methods may be at the heart of the offence."

Comment on this

Send that to Joe Stalin.

Comment on this

"Americans," they say, "have been deeply aroused over European concentration camps." People may be particularly sensitive about the treatment afforded to prisoners but my first reaction on reading that document was a feeling of deep resentment that an organisation outside this country should set itself up to condemn our prison system. I should like to have been in the position to question this organisation as to whether the prison system in America is so perfect that an organisation in that country can afford to throw stones at us. I have never been a political supporter of the present Government and never intend to be.

Comment on this

That is hard luck.

Comment on this

But in common with every citizen of this country my reaction to any attack on this country by outside people, is to defend our institutions and I question the right of any outsider to condemn our prison system. We may have an inefficient Government at the moment but, as a nation, we can deal with and solve all our problems including the problem of the treatment of those who violate the law. I want to make it clear that as far as I am concerned—and I think it is the view of most Deputies—I feel that there should be no privileges for any section of the community. There should be no particular privileges for those who break the law for political reasons as against those who break the law for ordinary reasons. Neither should there be any privilege for any members of this House who commit offences against the law. There should be one law for every citizen irrespective of class, creed or occupation. That is the only basis upon which justice can be administered. Our justices should be absolutely independent to give their decisions without fear or favour, regardless of who may be brought before them for trial.

There is one matter which often puzzles me and I have some experience of cases in this connection. While I believe the justices and the courts are absolutely impartial and independent, I am often inclined to wonder if impartiality exists in connection with the prosecution of offenders. Are we absolutely certain that any man who violates the law will be prosecuted? I have known cases of people in connection with whom definite investigations were made by the Guards and the Guards definitely decided that prosecutions were necessary. The prosecutions were not instituted. In one particular case I know of, a case of a very serious offence, a prosecution was not instituted because the person against whom the investigations were made was alleged to be in infirm health. I do not know whether that excuse would hold for every citizen but I should like to have an assurance from the Minister that there is absolute impartiality in regard to whether prosecutions are instituted or not.

Before I leave the question of prison reform I should like to deal with a reference made to the fact of prisoners being divided into two classes, first offenders and hardened criminals. It was suggested that there should be special treatment for first offenders as against hardened criminals. It is perhaps desirable, if possible, that the two classes should be segregated and kept apart; but it must be remembered— and I think it was made clear by the book to which I have referred, I Did Penal Servitude—that many of the most serious offenders, even murderers, were first offenders, and it is therefore rather difficult to bring about a segregation, whereas many of the alleged hardened criminals were only in for minor offences which they continued to repeat, probably, as Deputy Giles said, because they enjoyed prison life. There ought to be a fair and just system for all prisoners. The hardened criminal has his rights as well as the first offender. The first offender, even though his crime may be very grave, is usually a man who can be reformed, a man who was a good citizen until he committed the offence, however serious, and a man who, with fair and reasonable treatment, is likely to become a good citizen again in the future. When I speak of fair and reasonable treatment, I do not mean any form of mollycoddling or anything like that; I mean justice and fair treatment, with opportunities to develop his character, to improve his mind and to improve himself physically. All these are urgently desirable in our prison system.

With regard to the Garda, we are approaching the time when a very large number of members of that force will be retiring on pension and now is the time to consider the kind of reform which Deputy Giles suggests, that is, a raising of the standard of efficiency and of the conditions of entry into the force. It is also the time at which we should consider carefully all questions relating to justice and fair treatment for those who are going out of the force. As we know, the regulations provide that, in order to obtain the maximum pension, a Guard must be 25 years in the force. The regulations also provide that a man must retire on reaching the age of 57. That means that any man under 32 years of age when he joined the force is in a position to serve the 25 years and get the maximum pension, but, at the time the force was established, a number of men, a very small number, who were over 32 were taken in and it is impossible for such men to serve for 25 years. In such cases, a certain relaxation of the regulations should be granted. It would not apply to a very large number, because, as we all know, very few men over 30 were recruited into the force.

Another matter which calls for comment—I was not here for the earlier part of the debate and do not know whether it has been referred to already —is the remarkable heroism of two members of the Garda in dealing with a criminal who had broken into a house in Dublin. Those men acted very promptly and vigorously, and both of them, as a result, suffered very grave physical injury. It is right that Deputies and citizens generally should pay a tribute to our public servants when, in the public interest, they risk their lives, and, as a result, lose their lives or suffer grave physical injuries. We have a long tradition in this country of condemning the police. That was necessary at the time this nation was occupied by a foreign Power, but we have to change over from that and we must always be ready not only to assist officers of the law when doing their duty in difficult circumstances but to applaud them when they make an outstanding sacrifice in the public interest. Those two members of the Garda are entitled to public applause.

Comment on this

And to compensation.

Comment on this

I am quite sure the Minister's sense of justice will be strong enough to see that no rule or regulation will stand in the way of these men getting their rights. The question of the provision of housing accommodation for members of the Garda has been raised here every year since the Minister took office and it has already been dealt with by several Deputies. The matter has become particularly urgent now for two reasons: first, that during the emergency very little housing accommodation was provided for anybody and there is consequently a great dearth of housing accommodation in every district, and, secondly, that there is now some opportunity of obtaining materials for the provision of the necessary accommodation.

What I am afraid of is that the Minister may not be fully aware of the gravity of the injustice under which Guards suffer, particularly in remote country districts and small villages. In big urban areas, there is a wide variety of houses for different types of people, but in a rural area there is only one type of building, that is, for workers, for people who come under the Housing Acts providing for subsidised houses. Guards in general are not eligible for such houses, and in any case the demands of workers for housing accommodation are so great that there would be resentment in any district, if a Guard were to obtain a worker's house.

In small villages there is very little private building for letting purposes. Nobody undertakes that work. It is done in the big cities and towns, but not in remote villages and Guards are in an entirely different position from any other type of persons seeking housing accommodation. Business people in these villages usually have housing accommodation attached to their shops and the local authorities provide houses for workers, but there is nobody to provide for the Guards, and, even if they had the capital, they cannot undertake the purchase of a house, or the reconstruction or the improvement of a house, because no Guard knows from day to day or week to week when he may be transferred to some other part of the country. They are, therefore, a class apart. Their need is urgent and there is no reason why the State should not undertake to provide the necessary housing accommodation without delay.

Comment on this

The first matter I want to refer to is the increase in the pay of the members of the Garda. The House generally, while reluctant to face higher expenditure, realises that the increase in pay recently granted to members of the Garda is entirely justified. We can never expect the proper highly efficient services which the House and country expect from the force if the members of that force are inadequately paid and any suggestion that the pay given to these men is insufficient to meet their requirements and that consequently they are obliged to engage in any form of commercial activity outside their Garda duties in order to supplement their income is one which the House should treat seriously.

It is undesirable that members of the Garda should not have sufficient to meet their essential needs or that their pay should be inadequate to provide for their requirements. For that reason I deplore any suggestion that the members of the Garda should have to depend on any source of income outside their salaries and wages to supplement their pay to defray the cost of maintaining themselves and their families. If the Minister finds that the increases recently granted are insufficient to defray the ordinary needs of the members of the force or that they fail to meet the present high cost of living or to provide the Gardaí and their families with a sufficiently high standard of living that would allow them to maintain an independent position as members of the force, he should not hesitate to call on the House to meet further expenditure in order that the members of the force may be satisfied, contented and sufficiently provided, so far as financial status is concerned; with the ordinary needs and with that independence which the members of the force should have.

I should like to pay a tribute to the two Guards, Flynn and Tighe, who displayed such fine courage and devotion to duty in an attempt to apprehend two armed criminals who carried out a robbery in a publichouse in Rathfarnham. Their display of courage was not merely a fine example of their own devotion to duty but represented clearly the spirit and general conduct displayed on many occasions by the Garda force and reflected the general standard of devotion to duty which the public know they can expect from that force.

I shall now deal with the rather high figures, in fact alarmingly high figures, for crime. It is a matter for some congratulation that there has been a reduction of 1,600 cases in the number of indictable offences in 1946 as compared with 1945 but when one examines the report of the Commissioner of the Garda it is obvious that the figures for both indictable and non-indictable offences in 1945 and 1946 are still far higher than pre-war, certainly far higher than the earlier years. While it is customary to attribute the increase in crime to the effects of the war, we should not allow ourselves to be blinded to the fact that a determined and sustained effort must be made by the Garda Force and by all responsible for the detection and punishment of crime to reduce the present incidence and that every effort must be made to maintain indictable and non-indictable offences at as low a figure as possible. While the people of this country, for historical reasons, have on many occasions been reluctant to deal with criminals or to support the Garda and the civil authorities in maintaining proper respect for the law, nevertheless, no matter how active, industrious, determined or devoted to their duties the members of the Garda may be, ultimately, the sanction of public opinion is the greatest authority and the greatest weapon for the detection and punishment of crime. Unless we can get the sanction of public opinion firmly behind the detection and punishment of crime and firmly behind all measures that may be necessary in order to reduce the number of criminals and the effects of leniency in dealing with these matters, we cannot expect a reduction either in the number or in the seriousness of the crimes committed.

We have dealt with almost every matter in the course of this discussion but there are two points that I wish again to draw the Minister's attention to. With other Deputies, I think the time has come for an inquiry into the prison system. While one view or another may be expressed as to the actual conditions under which prisoners are obliged to remain while in prison, nevertheless, considering the prison system here and examining the various reports in other countries on prison reform, it would seem that while we, taking one country with another, bear favourable comparison with these countries, we should now establish a committee to inquire into prison reform and prison conditions. We should do that, not merely from pressure of particular cases. It would be wholly undesirable that this House should be influenced by pressure of an individual case or of particular cases when brought to the notice of the House. We should investigate impartially with a commission established, having on it representatives of many interests, including the Church, and people interested in juveniles, in child welfare, and all people who take an interest in the administration of justice. That commission would consider the effects which prison life has on people sentenced to terms of imprisonment, in many cases for comparatively minor offences, but who, nevertheless, are obliged for a period to remain in contact with more hardened criminals.

While I realise that, in so far as it is possible, there is at the present time a great degree of segregation and that more hardened criminals or habituals are separated from those who are unfortunate enough to find themselves in prison for a particular offence, it would be desirable, and it would reassure public opinion, if an impartial inquiry were held into the desirable reforms which might be made in the present prison system and how far it might be possible, by a change in prison regulations, or in practice and procedure as adopted in prisons, to reform certain offenders. Not merely should it be the aim in passing sentence to provide a punishment, it should also, particularly so far as less serious offences are concerned, be the aim to reform the individuals and to make them useful and better members of society.

I need not reiterate the various arguments in favour of prison reform and the various arguments which might be advanced to influence the Government to set up such a commission. The arguments are generally well known. There are various authorities of one kind or another—certain publications by individuals who have had experience not merely here but in other countries—on prison conditions. These indicate that it would be desirable that such an inquiry should be undertaken.

With regard to prison conditions, representations have been made to me on behalf of the staff. It is well known that no matter how carefully or efficiently a prison may be conducted, the responsibility for the care of the prisoners and the running of the prison devolves on the governor and the various members of his staff, particularly the warders, who deal directly with the prisoners. The representations that have been made to me show that the warders in general are not satisfied with their present conditions. Some of them consider that the pay is inadequate. I suppose that everybody, no matter what position he is in, has that view. They also consider that the rates of increase, after so many years' service, are not sufficiently high. They think that the rate is too low and the number of years too long, and that the rates should be raised and the number of years reduced, or else reduce the number of years for the existing rates. I think the Minister should ascertain the views of the warders on this matter.

I am informed that at the end of 1945 an application was made to the Army for suitable personnel who were prepared to enlist as warders, and that as a result a number of men about to retire from the Army, or who had served during the emergency, accepted the terms offered and enlisted as warders in a temporary capacity. I understand they were informed that, if after 12 months their service was found to be satisfactory, they would be likely to be retained in a permanent position. After 12 months some of them were informed that their service was satisfactory, and that, subject to passing an examination, they would be retained. When their services were enlisted originally, although it was to be on a temporary basis, no mention was made that at the end of the period they would have to undergo an examination.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

As far as I can gather, the Deputy is not correct in that.

Comment on this

I am giving the information that I have got.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is what I am doing, too.

Comment on this

I have a copy of the circular. The information, if not conveyed to them individually, was published in the form of a notice. The information that I have is that there was no mention made of an examination. They may not have been informed of the particular tests that they have to pass before they could be made permanent in their positions. However, a test was laid down. Certain subjects were made obligatory and certain marks were allotted for each subject. In the particular cases brought to my notice, these men were found to be deficient in their knowledge of Irish. During their period of Army service they had not kept up their knowledge of it to the minimum requirements. In some cases they had no contact with Irish since they left school. Consequently, their knowledge of it was not as proficient as it should be. Unfortunately, while they were suitable in every other respect, this obligatory subject prevented them from being appointed permanently. I suggest to the Minister that in a case like this, if it is considered necessary to make a particular subject obligatory, a period of education re-education should be afforded to enable these men to improve their knowledge of Irish and to acquaint themselves with the terminology used in the course of prison duties. That would give them an opportunity of making themselves proficient. According to my information, they did not know that this subject would be obligatory when they enlisted and, consequently, took no steps to improve their knowledge of Irish. I also suggest that, by and large, ex-Army men are most suitable for the position of warders. They are men who have had a strict discipline and training and would be eminently suitable from the physical point of view. These men, so far as my information goes, feel a sense of grievance by reason of the fact that a test was laid down at the end of their 12 months' probationary period.

I also have a complaint as regards the hours of duty in the prison service. In the Civil Service the time allowed for meals is taken into consideration in the working day. Of course, in the case of the Civil Service there is only the one meal—the hour for lunch or dinner. The complaint in the prison service is that the hour or one and a quarter hours for lunch is not included as part of the working day. That means the staff have to work nine and a half or nine hours instead of eight hours. I think that is a matter the Minister might have examined, and ascertain the views of the warders in the various prisons on it.

Finally, I want to refer to a matter which has been raised here on many previous occasions. I refer to the position of court clerks. I do not propose to go over the various reasons there are for increasing their salaries and providing pensions for them. Even those unacquainted with the functions performed by the District Court clerks —the same applies to some extent to the Circuit Court clerks—must realise that they are responsible to a considerable extent for the efficient functioning of the courts. They enable both litigants and professional people who have business in the courts to carry out their duties. At times they have to carry out their duties over protracted periods. For these and the many other reasons that might be advanced, I suggest to the Minister that their present rates of pay are entirely inadequate. Most of them have only received a bonus on their existing salaries. They have received no increase in salary which was fixed many years ago. They have no certainty of a pension at the end of their service, and, consequently, many of them are obliged to look elsewhere for employment if they can find suitable positions. They are competent and experienced people, and it would be undesirable if the courts were to lose their services. If a person qualifies as a court clerk and is rendering efficient service, it is in the interests of the courts and of the public that his services should be available for as long a period as he is able to serve. Any increase given to these officials would be well merited. It would compensate them for the losses they have sustained and for the difficulties under which they are labouring at present. In view of the responsible duties they perform, I am sure the House will agree that the Minister should make every effort to satisfy their demands by giving them an increase in their salaries. He might also consider the position of the Circuit Court clerks. They also perform their duties efficiently. Unless they are paid suitable rates of wages it will, I suggest, be difficult in the future to secure suitable personnel for these positions.

Comment on this

I want to make an appeal to the Minister on behalf of a body of people who may be called the Legion of the Lost — the Circuit and District Court clerks. For the past eight years, on the Estimate for the Minister's Department, I have been asking that something should be done for these people. Some of them are now getting old. At least one of them in my own county has retired within the last three months. There are other men who have given over 40 years' service, and are still on a temporary basis in the Circuit Court offices. Perhaps it is not the Minister's responsibility, that there are other Departments involved, but, after all these years and as this matter has been raised in this House time and time again, it is, I think, more or less generally agreed by the different Deputies in this House that something should be done to bring these people to the same standard and put them on the same conditions as their colleagues are in other parts of the public services. I would like to know when the Minister is replying whether men who are now over 50 years of age and who are in the service of the Circuit Court and Circuit Court offices are going to be passed over. There is a rumour abroad that men over 50, notwithstanding their service over all these years, are not going to be included in the proposed measure that the Minister is going to bring in and it has caused a considerable amount of unrest and I might say consternation amongst these staffs throughout the country. These people comprise, of themselves, a very small body and there is a danger of their being overlooked. In view of the loyal and efficient service they have given over a great number of years and as this matter has been omitted here for a number of years—probably due to one type or other of Departmental delay and possibly other priorities before them— they did not get an opportunity of being dealt with. I think they should now be brought into whatever scheme the Minister has in mind. It certainly would be the height of foolishness if these men, without pensions and without due provision for their old age, after loyal service since our own courts have been established in this country, were not included. The very same goes for District Court clerks although I realise that it is possibly a much more difficult problem for the Minister because their areas differ and their responsibilities differ. But the Minister should realise that in these modern times the law is becoming very complex and the District Court clerk's job is increasing daily. He has many new duties to perform. There are new laws and regulations being made and he is supposed to be there as a chief factotum for all Gardaí and all the rest of them who come in to him. He now finds himself working every day and many nights too, where formerly he could possibly perform his duties on a couple of days a week and many of the District Court clerks who were formerly recruited as temporary now find that their jobs are very much whole-time and at least there should be a possibility of drawing up a scale whereby provision would be made for the men whose work keeps them occupied whole-time. A number of these men have been working for years in a temporary capacity. Some of their areas have been changed but the tendency has been to increase their areas and responsibility and, undoubtedly, their responsibilities are increasing daily. They are responsible for sums of money and their responsibilities generally have increased throughout the years.

I would like the Minister to bear that in mind when dealing with these men and when dealing with Circuit Court staffs and I hope the Minister will tell us that he is going to deal with them very shortly. We have been pleading for them for a great number of years and we are getting rather tired of appealing again and again in connection with this very urgent problem. I hope, when he is dealing with Circuit Court staffs, that he will give clerks who are on the point of retiring —many of them with over 20 years' service will be retiring this very year —some indication as to whether any provision is going to be made for them. These are two very urgent pressing problems that I would ask the Minister to devote his mind to. Possibly, like all these matters, it is a matter of finance and of coming to some agreement with the Department of Finance. These people's grievances are of such long standing and these people, in the main, have been so patient hoping and expecting that the Minister will, year after year, meet the case that they justly put up that I think it is now time that the Minister should take definite steps to indicate to them what their position will be. It is very difficult for them and a number of them are coming to the stage when they will have to retire and a number of them whom I know and with whom I have been in touch in the West of Ireland feel very disturbed and very worried about it and I would like the Minister to give an indication as to when it will be possible to deal finally with the matter.

The question of the land registry in this country is another matter to which I should like to refer. I think it comes under the Minister's Department. I do not know how far the Minister shares direct responsibility in the matter but there is no doubt about it that the recent increases in the land registry charges have come as a great shock particularly to the small farmers throughout the country because they are the people who are suffering. They have found that under the new scales and under the land registry practice the stamp duty has been increased by hundreds per cent. and the poor people who are entitled to put their title in order find that they are faced with the charges. I do not know what would justify these charges. Possibly the Minister for Finance found it was an easy way of getting more revenue, but to my mind the question of allowing a countryman to put his title in order should not be dealt with from that point of view at all. On a man's transfer of his title to his son, when the son marries, he finds that instead of paying approximately 15/- his bill for that transaction outside professional charges is going to cost £3 10s. 0d. or £4. The Minister will find that when these poor people discover that it would take so much money —which they erroneously think is taken by the solicitor—to put their titles in order they will refuse to put them in order. If that is going to start, and already it has started because they find it too expensive, the Minister or his Department or some Department will certainly be faced with a very serious situation.

There is no provision in the law as it stands at present to compel anybody to become a registered owner of his own lands and if an owner dies and if his son refuses to take the necessary steps to put his title in order there is no provision made for that, and the successor in title can settle on the holding without putting the title in order. If he finds it so expensive as a result of the increased stamp duty or the increased fees of the land registry, he sits back and does nothing about it. The Minister or his Department will be ultimately forced to do something about the position because they will find that nine-tenths of the small registered holders will simply leave their titles as they were in their grandfathers' time. When they do some wrong on their neighbours or some question arises which results in the bringing of an action, the judge may find that the plaintiff has a proper title and is the registered owner of his land while the defendant's folio bears his grandfather's name and he refuses to do anything about it. The judge will not be in a position to rectify those folios as regards area, or anything else. That position has already commenced to develop in the country as a result of these charges and it will continue unless the Minister does something about it. I want to inform the Minister that there has been widespread dissatisfaction about these increases in land registry charges. The sooner something is done about them the better. In the case of large valuations, these charges might not matter so much. The people concerned would have other assets and, when they died, somebody would have to take out administration or probate, as the case might be, for other reasons. But, in the case of a man with a registered holding the valuation of which is £5, there is no particular reason why he should do anything except for the purpose of putting his title in order. When faced with the increased land registry fees, he would think twice about that. He may refuse to do it, as a number have refused recently.

The Minister indicated a considerable time ago that the jurisdiction of the District Court was to be changed. We have heard nothing about that recently. We are anxiously waiting to learn whether it is proposed to increase the jurisdiction of the District Court and the Circuit Court. If that is to be done, there is a feeling in the country that, if possible, High Court actions from the country should be heard by the High Court on circuit. The complaints throughout the country of the increased costs in the courts are mainly due to witnesses' expenses. I should like if the Minister would endeavour to have affixed in all courts proper lists, so that cases would be taken on the day for which they are listed. That was the practice adopted by many judges. But the practice is not universal and, sometimes, you find that cases listed for Tuesday may not be reached until Wednesday or, in extreme cases, until Thursday. Professional witnesses have to be summoned for the first day and their expenses are accumulating day by day, with the result that costs to the litigants are much increased. It is far more satisfactory to have a reasonable number of cases, allowing for settlements, fixed for each day and thus have only one day's expenses of professional witnesses to be met.

I must say that the High Court on circuit has given universal satisfaction. Its operations have been welcomed by both practitioners and litigants in all the counties, so far as I know, and it is doing a very satisfactory job at the minimum of expense. We also feel that if a Bill is being introduced by the Minister, he should provide for the High Court on circuit dealing with High Court actions which would be outside the jurisdiction of the Circuit Court, since we have the machinery to bring these cases. Cases involving more than £300 must go to the High Court. Running-down cases may have to be commenced in the city. Nobody may know exactly when they will be taken. They may be listed for a particular day and may not get a hearing on that day. That may go on for a few days. When you have to bring doctors and professional witnesses up from the country, it means a great deal of expense to the unfortunate litigants. The plaintiffs in these running-down actions may be poor people who have not the wherewithal to pay professional witnesses. Many professional witnesses demand their expenses before they will leave their homes. The way to get over that difficulty would be for the High Court on circuit to deal with High Court actions arising in the area.

An increase in the jurisdiction of the District Court is long overdue. Nobody in his senses can understand why a district justice should not be able to deal with a £2 trespass case in which a question of title is raised. If it is a question of a right-of-way to a bog or a field or a question of a fence in which a question of title is raised, the action must go to the Circuit Court and engineers, mappers, and counsel have to be engaged. That involves enormous expense to both sides. If the district justice is capable of deciding a simple question of trespass, he is equally capable of deciding a simple question of title, which is mainly a question of fact. If a district justice is capable of trying an assault action up to £10, why should he not be capable of trying an assault action up to £50?

Comment on this

Or £1,000.

Comment on this

After a number of years' experience, it is admitted by everybody that the District Court system has been very popular, serviceable and inexpensive. There is room for all the courts to perform their own functions but, if the Minister has in mind the reduction of the cost of litigation, he would be well advised reasonably to increase jurisdiction of the District and the Circuit Courts. In that way, he would be meeting a great demand throughout the country. I understand that changes of this type were considered by the Minister a considerable time ago. Possibly, the Minister could give us an indication as to when that job can be done because such information is anxiously awaited in the country.

I understand that some references were made in this debate to the cost of certain Garda reinforcements down in Mayo in connection with agrarian trouble there. I want simply to give my view of the matter. Many people in Mayo want to see the law enforced and many people in Mayo are delighted that the law has been enforced. Many people in Mayo, when they discovered that property was being wantonly burned and that they were to be faced with tremendous costs and expenses through malicious injury claims coming before the courts——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair understands that the case to which the Deputy refers is sub judice.

Comment on this

I understand that the case I have referred to was already mentioned in this debate.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They were prevented from pursuing it. There was one sentence used in reference to it by a Deputy. The case is sub judice and the claim is already lodged for compensation.

Comment on this

The people of Mayo I represent do not want to have to pay any more of this type of compensation and do not want to be blistered by any further malicious injury claims. I want the Minister to see that the law-abiding, respectable people of Mayo are adequately protected against this business and will not be called upon, in addition to paying high rates, to pay further malicious injury claims, due to any lack of adequate protection. I know the Minister and his officers are doing a good job and a difficult one, when some of the people might, in the heat of the moment, be misled and advised to break the law made by this House. The people of Mayo will have common sense enough, when that is clearly pointed out to them and particularly when they are forced to pay for the depredations of other people who have been badly advised and who set out to burn and drive and knock down fences and so forth throughout the county. I want to make my position clear. I want the Minister, in so far as is possible, to protect the lawabiding citizens of Mayo from these malicious burnings of the type mentioned.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy was told that was out of order and he has reverted to it.

Comment on this

The question of legal reform and codification has been mentioned here many times and it is being done elsewhere, as the Minister is well aware. I know it may be a very expensive problem to deal with, but the longer it goes on the more expensive and more difficult it will be to tackle. If something could be done in the way of starting in a small way, with a small committee, I think a start should be made, as there is ample material available at the Irish Bar to deal with this matter. If the Minister would take his courage in his hands and set up a small committee to make a start on this enormous problem, he would probably find as the years went by that a good deal of progress would be made. It is a great tragedy—and if the Minister were in another line of country he would find that out—to find you have some laws still extant here that have been completely wiped out by our neighbours who started them and that they are completely obsolete.

In the case of pure realty, where the owner of the realty dies intestate, we find the blackguard of the family can turn up and claim it, irrespective of the other members of the family and of the position at home. It is in cases where claims have been made in respect of pure realty and where an heir-at-law has inherited to the exclusion of the other next-of-kin, that you realise the pity and shame it is that some parts of our law are left in such a backward state. I know the Minister's answer may be that it is a very technical job and one requiring very high skill and that it may be expensive, too. However, I do not think it is a job that would be beyond the Minister, if he put his mind to it. I would ask that a small committee be set up forthwith to deal with law reform and the urgent problems I have mentioned. As time went on, possibly we could get down to the tremendous job of codification that all the people connected with law have been calling for, for a great number of years.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

There is not a very great increase in the amount of money demanded in this Vote and we can safely say that whatever increase is asked for is going into a very worthy cause, namely, the salaries of the Gardaí, who deserve a higher rate than they have been getting for many years. Nevertheless, we must always bear in mind that there are very many people who have even worse salaries than the average Civic Guard and I must say that to the shame of the Government and of the system under which we work at the moment.

I believe there can be quite a lot of reforms in the different branches of the Department of Justice, from the courts down to the humble court clerks. It has been pointed out that reforms can be brought about. I am not a lawyer and do not like to meddle with a problem I do not know something about, but I believe we could simplify the court procedure. I remember reading some few months ago where a crowd of able lawyers and senior counsel decided amongst themselves that the time was well overdue when this revision should be brought about and something new should take the place of the cumbersome legal system we had and the Acts which may be yet brought into force, though passed 300 or 400 years ago.

In regard to those who enforce the law, the Civic Guards, the increase in pay is definitely welcome, especially in the case of new recruits, and will not be begrudged to them by anyone. During the past year, there has been a large recruitment for the Gardaí and, let me say in favour of the Minister for Justice, the men have been picked on their merits. I can vouch for the fact that there has been very little, if any, political influence of any kind as far as my locality is concerned. Young men have been brought into the Gardaí and everything has been taken into consideration. If a young fellow has a good athletic record, he gets a certain number of marks and average education will do. That gives the poor man's son a chance of getting in at the bottom of the ladder and trying to climb to the top in the years before him. Whatever other criticism I may have of the Minister and the Department, I can definitely have none as far as that is concerned.

In regard to transfers of Gardaí from one station to another, it is claimed by the Department and the Government that that is a wise thing to do, as to leave a Garda or a sergeant in some place for a number of years may make him too intimate with certain people and hostile to others, so it has been thought that an occasional shift around is for the good of the locality and the policeman concerned.

Here we meet with the trouble which the Civic Guards, the sergeants and everybody else meet with, just as well as the Government—that is, the trouble of housing. The housing problem is so acute, houses are so scarce, that a Civic Guard, on his moderate salary, can ill-afford to get a house when he moves from one place to another. It is true that in places a Guard may be leaving a house and the incoming policeman may get first preference, but then there is the matter of taste to be considered, and occasionally the incoming Guard may not be anxious to take over the vacant house.

I remember last year, in my first contribution to the debate on the Vote for the Department of Justice, I suggested that the Minister, at the earliest opportunity, should build blocks of houses in every town and keep some of those places exclusively for members of the Garda who are shifted backwards and forwards from district to district. This system of having Government-controlled houses was adopted years ago by prisons authorities. We find that in the prisons all over this country there are a few houses which are handed over first to the governor of the jail, then to the chief warder and then there are two or three or nine or ten houses as the case may be according to the size of the jail, and they are used by the warders. When a warder retires the house automatically becomes the property of the Government and it is turned over to some other warder who may be living in an outside house.

That would be an easy way out of the difficulty of housing the Guards. If that simple system could be put into operation, it would ease the minds of policemen when they are shifted from one station to another. I appreciate that for the past few years it was practically impossible to attempt any venture like this and I am offering it only as a suggestion for the future. If the Minister were to adopt that system, it would serve a very useful purpose and satisfy quite a lot of people.

The next thing we come to is crime. Some people say that crime is in the blood; a father may be a criminal, his son may be a criminal and even the grandson may be a criminal. We do not know whether that is right or not. I come from an area where we have a very small amount of crime. It is a rural locality. I got the facts within the last few weeks and I find that we have an average of 23 persons in that large section along the western seaboard — Mayo, Galway, Roscommon, Sligo, Leitrim, Donegal and parts of Monaghan—who may be regarded as prisoners. That is a very small number to hold in jail from such a vast area. We find crime more in the cities, especially juvenile crime.

In the cities juveniles have more chances of becoming criminals. I think juvenile crime can be blamed on two things. The first is the absolute necessity which prevails in many poor, humble homes. I will not say I am perfectly right in that, but I saw, no later than yesterday when I was coming into the city, one example which may be worth relating. Apparently out of pure necessity a young lad made the first move in a criminal life. I saw that young lad climbing on the back of a slowly moving lorry and he chucked down sods of turf on the roadway, then he collected them and ran with them into a house, where his father and mother probably had no money to buy the turf and probably were not able to have a fire. That may or may not be the case.

That young fellow, seeing his first step in petty theft so successful, will probably be encouraged to do other things of a similar nature. He will be encouraged to steal bigger things and then, when he reaches 15 years or 17 years, he will follow a life of adventure and he will begin to steal in his own interests. I am glad to say that 95 per cent. and even 97 per cent. of the people who are in poor circumstances would definitely flog a youngster who was caught doing a thing like that. Those people deserve every credit. Most of the fathers and mothers, even though they may be hungry and have no fire, would not tolerate their youngsters stealing. If the parents knew that the turf the youngster brought into the house had been stolen, they would flog him almost to death. There is no doubt, however, that such small beginnings help to make the juvenile criminal and, once started on that career, it is very hard to stop him.

Then we have the type of criminal who comes from a bad strain, bad blood. He will go definitely out for a life of crime and to alter that criminal and make him reform is a very hard job. It is debatable if it ever could be done.

We are told that crime has increased. It has been proved that in the cities it has increased much more than among the rural population, but that is quite natural, because in the cities large masses of people are gathered together and it is only to be expected that petty theft, pocket picking, jewellery snatching, house and shop breaking, will be carried on in the larger centres of population. These things happen in the everyday lives of the younger and the older generations in the towns and cities. To bring about some system of reform of those criminals is the task of men who have dealt with criminals, who have been over criminals for years. It will take men of that type to carry through any system of reform in the case of first offenders and severe punishment for those who insist on committing crime.

As regards our jails, I do not intend, like my colleague, Deputy Cafferky, to say much about them beyond what I have seen of our prisons, and I will put that as briefly as possible. I think the prisons in Eire are definitely 100 years behind the times. They are old, dilapidated and cold. There is no comfort for the staff of the prison or for the prisoners. I can safely say, and perhaps others who have seen the inside of a prison will agree with me, that every man inside the walls of a prison can be regarded as a prisoner, from the governor down. As regards the staffs, the off-time hours they have, even if they go abroad, are of little use to them. The close association of the prisoners and the warders tends to bring about the feeling that they are all under the same roof and one should not look down upon the other, as they are all practically carrying one brand.

As regards the prison staffs in Eire, nobody can complain in any way about the manner in which they carry out their duties, and that must be definitely said. So far as my association goes with governors and warders, I have found them all right, but the regulations under which they work are definitely all wrong. These regulations must be altered and prison reform must be brought about if we are to make any effort at the reformation of first offenders and the proper punishment of those who insist that they will be criminals and will go to jail simply and solely for the sake of being there and being able to boast about it when they come out. There are men who boast that they have spent so many years of their life behind prison bars. Old jailbirds have been known to fly into a rage because another prisoner boasted that he could prove he spent some months or some years longer in jails than they did. If one man spent 14 years of his life in jail, it would anger him to hear that some other crook had spent 15½ years of his life there.

Prisoners of that type cannot be put in the same class as the youth who, in a moment of weakness perhaps, will steal a bicycle or a little money. My belief is that first offenders who have been found guilty of petty crimes, which nevertheless are crimes, should get a suspensory sentence and a chance should be given to them to see if they will reform within a period of say 12 months and make restitution for the value of the property which they have stolen. It would be much better to deal with first offenders in that way than to compel them to associate with the hardened type of criminal in jail, as such an association can only have the result of breaking down their morale. I have heard it said that when a man is convicted of an offence for the first time and is sent to jail his thoughts there are devoted to one or other of two things. He either gets repentant and decides to turn over a new leaf, or else he starts plotting and decides that when he comes out, he will commit another criminal offence but by entirely different methods from those which he employed in committing his first offence so that he will be able to lead the authorities up the garden path. Whether that is right or wrong I do not know but I think there must be something in it when we remember the number of prisoners who are in and out of jail continually. To keep more or less innocent first offenders in close contact for six or perhaps 12 months with hardened criminals will definitely bring these first offenders to the same level. I believe, therefore, that there should be some system in each prison under which first offenders would be kept in one section where every effort would be made to reform them and the hardened criminals kept in another section.

I will say that the quantity of food allowed to each prisoner, no matter what his offence may be, at present is not sufficient. It is not a very nice thing to keep men from the time they get up in the morning at 6.30 until they go to bed at 7.30 or 8 o'clock continually with empty stomachs. It merely means that they are carrying forward a good healthy appetite from one meal to another. They never get sufficient food and there is continual "grouse" as to the amount and the quality of the food which they get. Deputy Cafferky suggested that a different type of utensils might be utilised and I fully agree with him. Even though it may cost a little extra, I think if there was an arrangement under which the prisoners could eat in one hall or room and if a better type of utensil were provided, it would make those of them who can be reformed realise that they are not enemies of society, that society will not oust them for all time, that they can take up their place again in the world and, perhaps with a little effort, carry on as good model citizens.

Another matter to which I wish to call the attention of the Minister is the degrading type of clothing which these men have to wear. There may have been an excuse for that during the emergency when the quality of cloth generally was of an inferior type but there cannot be the same excuse in normal times. It is absolutely amazing to observe the change which takes place in the appearance of a man after he has changed from his own clothes, which he was wearing on entering the prison, into the prison suit. I think some effort should be made to provide prisoners with better-fitting clothes and clothes which might be a little warmer. The same remarks apply to prison shoes. The shoes are definitely not of a good standard. What is the object of compelling a prisoner to wear a bad suit of clothes or a bad pair of shoes and compelling him to work under such conditions. I will admit that they do not do much work. To those who say that prisoners have to work hard in jail, I would reply that the average man does as much work in a day, or a day and a half outside, as the average prisoner will do in a week. I have personal experience of that and I shall not allow anybody to contradict me. The fact that a prisoner is compelled to wear bad shoes or bad clothes leaves him liable to disease. He may contract turberculosis, pneumonia or influenza and in the long run the cost of treating these diseases will be much more than the cost of supplying him with proper boots and clothing in the first instance.

Turning from the prisoners to the officials who have to supervise the prisoners, I think that much could be done to improve their conditions also. They have their "grouse" and I think that when you find men or women in this country grumbling, there is generally some grievance which gives rise to that grumbling. For the past five or six years, we have had complaints from many people, but I think the warders in our jails have every reason to complain as to their conditions. One regulation in existence at the moment prescribes the hour at which these men have to be inside the prison walls each night. I think the hour is 11 p.m. I think it is unfair, especially to the younger warders, who may like once or twice a week to go to a dance or to visit a cinema, to compel them to be back at 11 o'clock. If an extension could be given of an hour or an hour and a half even for two Sunday nights every month or for two or three week nights every month, it would be welcomed very much by these warders.

The next suggestion which warders make is that when moving prisoners from one jail to another, a warder should be entitled to wear his ordinary clothes and should be supplied with some identification badge, which he can use to prove his authority—a badge like that used by the secret service or the United States Federal Agents, as the case may be. He should not be compelled to wear his uniform so as to attract the notice of everybody who is passing because it is true of our people, and will be for years to come, I suppose, that the sight of a prison warder fills them with wrath. They say immediately: "He is a prison warder and no good. His job is to keep Irishmen in jail," even though the warder may be far better than those who criticise him. If these two concessions could be granted: first, an hour longer to remain out during their off-hours, and, secondly, permission to wear ordinary clothing when going to courts to collect prisoners or removing prisoners from one jail to another, the Minister would go very far towards satisfying the wants of some of these prison warders. I heard no complaints as to warders' pay.

They seem to think they were fairly well paid. Of course, more money would probably be asked for, but these concessions would be sought much more eagerly than any concessions in relation to cash.

The matter of the facilities for recreation in prisons is one which will have to be improved. The continuous walk in a circle for three hours at one time and for two and a half hours at another will get on the nerves of anybody. It serves no useful purpose and I suggest that in each jail a handball alley should be erected or a small football field should be provided. I personally would prefer a handball alley, or two, so that where 20, 30 or 40 men are in prison—or 200 or 300, as in Mountjoy—they could have handball tournaments and would have an interest in something other than this continuous walking round in circles, which merely serves to make them cranky and tends to develop in them a hatred of society. I understand that a handball alley has recently been erected in Portlaoighise and I hope the Minister will continue on that line and provide similar facilities in other prisons, even in Sligo, the humblest and smallest prison in Éire. If his inspector goes into Sligo Jail he will find that, for £50, he could erect a beautiful handball alley, because the side-walls are there already. Such a facility would do much to brighten the life of the poor individual who has to spend a year, 18 months or two years, or even two weeks, inside prison bars. Further, an inside recreation hall should be provided, because it is wrong that men, if they have a handball alley, should have to play handball on a wet day. If a game like basket-ball, as played in the Army, were introduced, it would be very useful. Little competitions could be organised in the jail and the warders would be only too willing to supervise them. Games of cards, with whist drives and darts competitions and concerts—it is all these little things which in jails are the great things.

Finally, if the Minister would grant permission to smoke, he would be doing much to ease the lot of prisoners.

I understand that in England this reform has been brought about. I do not know whether that it true, but in the book I Did Penal Servitude it is stated that prisoners have been allowed cigarettes—three, four and five a day. The first thing the Minister will ask is: “Why we should give cigarettes to criminals? We could give them to eight out of ten prisoners, but there will always be two to whom we cannot give them, because, if they get matches, they will set fire to mattresses and so on.” It is, however, worth the chance because there is no doubt that any prisoner who is anxious for a smoke will provide himself in some way with a smoke. The Minister spent a longer period in prison than I and he must admit that smokes will be produced. A cigarette butt may be thrown unthinkingly on the ground by a warder who should not be smoking on duty and who fears that the Governor is coming upon him. That butt will be picked up and smoked by a prisoner. To those of us who are habitual smokers, it is understandable that to a man in jail a cigarette is something which does him an amount of good, and I have heard prisoners say that they would go without their break-fast or their dinner for a smoke. I believe that to be true, and why, then, should we deprive them of this little luxury?

It was said by Deputy Giles that we are coddling these prisoners and that if we keep on at it, we should be running hotels instead of jails and queues of criminals would be lined up outside waiting to get in. I do not believe that. There are types who will always be in and out of jail and who frequently will have to go to a jail through very little fault on their part, but, instead of grinding them down and keeping them cut away in such and awful manner from what they have been used to, an effort should be made to go at least halfway towards easing their lot. I understand that in Portlaoighise, although it may have its faults and although things have happened within the last year there that I shall hate while I live, definite improvements have been made. We have been told that a radio has been installed and several types of games are being allowed, with the result that life generally there has been fairly well improved, but there is still a lot of room for further improvement.

I listened with interest to Deputy Moran on the subject of land registry. He is perfectly right. The number of people who have allowed their titles to land to lie there simply because the charge for registering is too high is amazing. The solicitors of Ireland have a very bad name at present because everybody thinks it is the lawyer who takes all the money and walks away with a man's £5, £6 or £10, when, in reality, it is the stamp duty which the Government demands which is responsible. It is unduly high and could easily be reduced to suit the poorer type of person dealing with a small holding or a small house.

Comment on this

Why not go to the revenue officer and get it done more cheaply?

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

I understand that the will not do it, unless a very small valuation is involved.

Comment on this

Under £500.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

I know of an instance in which it was refused in respect of a valuation of £150. The next matter is the matter of jurymen. I regard it as very unfair that jurymen who sometimes have to stay away from their homes for two, three or four days should be made to do so without compensation. Everybody else in the court is paid, and I think they should get at least their travelling and out-of-pocket expenses. No Deputy would begrudge them their out-of-pocket and travelling expenses when they are brought in to decide cases. If the Minister introduced a Vote for the purpose of paying jurymen, nobody in the House would object to the money being granted.

Deputy Cafferky overlooked one matter with regard to the Circuit Courts. I understand that the number of Circuit Courts will be increased and that the number of places where they hold their sittings will be increased. Several complaints have come from Swinford, County Mayo, that Circuit Court cases in that locality are heard in Castlebar or Ballina, a distance of 20 miles on each side of the town. It would be of great advantage to the people of the locality if a Circuit Court sitting could be held in Swinford town. That does not mean that there is an immensity of litigation in that town but, when there is a Circuit Court case, it should be heard in a central place. The distance of almost 20 miles to Castlebar or to Ballina is too great. A progressive town like Swinford should have a Circuit Court sitting of its own. I hope the Minister will take that into consideration.

Comment on this

Charlestown is 21 miles away.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

A sitting of the court in Swinford would suit Charlestown very well also.

Comment on this

It was always there up to the troubled times.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

There is another thing that I mentioned last year and which has been forgotten by everybody else and it is only right that somebody should mention it, that is, political crime and political prisoners. Last year, on this Estimate, some of us, in our simple, quiet way, appealed to the Minister, now that times are normal again, when, perhaps, hot tempers have cooled down, and when men whose foolish ideals got the upper hand of them so that they decided, maybe foolishly, that they would try to use force of arms and had to be, as the Minister thought, punished, to have these men treated as political prisoners and, if possible, to have them released. I am sorry to say our appeal fell on deaf ears. I am sorry to say that an incident happened last summer which definitely stinks in the nostrils of the majority of the people of this country. I refer to the death of the man on hunger strike in Portlaoighise Prison. Two wrongs will not make a right and I do not intend to scold the Minister or to say anything about that case. But there are other men, and I think the Minister would not be sorry but would be proud later on, when so many political prisoners have been released in the past year or two, if he released the few that are remaining. It would be an encouragement to our neighbour across the water, where a number of Irishmen are held as political prisoners, to release their prisoners and to forget the whole thing. If men had ideals, they are not criminals. Political crime and ordinary crime are two different things and should not be treated on the same basis. If a man must be kept in custody until his blood cools, then he should be treated differently from the man who has to be punished for embezzling thousands of pounds or for manslaughter or murder.

I wish now to refer to the matter which I raised by way of Parliamentary Question to-day with regard to happenings in Mayo at the present moment. I put down the question because I was forced to do so because of intense police activity in my locality, activity which I do not like and activity which has but one meaning, that is, an effort to point out that the Clann na Talmhan organisation in and around the locality must each and every one of them be regarded as a criminal or as a law breaker. We have agrarian and land troubles in Mayo. The Minister may not know that. I do not think he had ever charge of the Land Commission.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Indeed I had.

Comment on this

He had. He was Minister for Lands for years.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I know all about it.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

Then the Minister must know definitely that the people of Mayo are in a bad fix.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I know that Mayo got better treatment from the Land Commission when I was there than any other county.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

Why should not it get it? Is it not in the worst position?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is so, but it got it all the same.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

There are more in need of treatment there.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is right.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

But, definitely, the mind of the average Mayo man at the moment is opposed to allowing any wealthy outsider, be he foreigner or Irishman, in to buy up land.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is a matter for the Land Commission.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

I am just coming to the reason why I had to put down the Parliamentary Question. The fact that a large farm in the locality had been purchased by a foreigner caused intense dissatisfaction amongst the people and, for that reason, an immensity of Gardaí have been brought to the town where I come from. Their time is devoted simply and solely to going about—not terrorising—I will say that for these men. I have had them raiding my own house; they have raided the houses of our supporters in our locality; they have taken men and interrogated them and one of the questions they ask is, "Are you a supporter of Clann na Talmhan? Did you vote for So-and-So at the last election?" I regard that as going a bit too far.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

So would I, indeed.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

And I put down this question. The Minister in answering it, said: "It is intended to prevent breaches of the peace in connection with an agrarian dispute in the course of which a house was burned". I wonder where did the Minister get his information. I am living within a mile of the locality and I can assure the Minister that if I knew who burned the house I would have brought him to justice and I would have told the Guards or told the authorities because, while I and my colleagues stand for the division of land and for agitation, in an effort to get land divided, we definitely do not stand for anarchy and it is anarchy to raze a valuable house to the ground. But what proof is there, I ask the Minister, that this house has been maliciously burned or destroyed? There is no agitation for this land in question. There was none at the time that this house took fire. That house took fire last September and about six weeks ago somebody painted notices on the road warning grabbers, etcetera, to keep out but we have here a definite statement from the Minister—"an agrarian dispute in the course of which a house was burned". I want the Minister to understand that there are two claims, each of £5,000, lodged in regard to this. I do not want to pursue it as the matter is sub judice, but I wonder was it the Minister's intention, when he made that statement, to help out his former colleague and former great supporter, Senator McEllin, to get his claim and to fleece the people of the constituency of South Mayo for the £10,000?

Deputy Moran, speaking from behind the back of the Minister, got into a frenzy with regard to what he thought about law breakers, of what the people thought about them and of how the people of Mayo decided that law breakers should be treated. I believe that anybody who is caught burning a house, even though he does it in the name of carrying on an agitation for land, should definitely be brought to justice. I would like to remind Deputy Moran of this—I am sorry he is not in the House—that he is the last person in the world who should say that people should be penalised for causing an agitation or for knocking houses down because we had to tell him in the course of the last by-election—we had to tell him to keep him quiet—that his predecessors had knocked down and burned quite a lot of houses.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must not make any charge like that.

Comment on this

Is it not manifest knowledge?

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

I did not want to do it, but Deputy Moran made the accusation that I and Deputy Cafferky should be in jail, and that it was perfectly right to put us there because we agitated for land for the common people. I should much rather agitate for land for the common people than have it said of me that I had 40 or 50 houses knocked down by the crow-bar brigade, and have that handed down to me as my family history. I think it is much more respectable to agitate for the land for the common people.

Comment on this

Deputy Moran himself should be in jail.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

I never talk about a person behind his back. What I have to say I say it to his face, so that I hope Deputy Moran will not open his mouth again about houses burned down.

Comment on this

Can you not do that down in Mayo and not here?

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

He opened it here.

Comment on this

The Deputy is seeking fairly to answer much of what Deputy Moran said.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Ceann Comhairle definitely ruled out Deputy Moran and stopped him.

Comment on this

He did not, he let him go on.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think the Deputy might leave that.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

I have finished with that.

Comment on this

The people in Mayo have long memories.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

With regard to the Minister's statement, I notice that it is hard to ruffle him. I will not say whether I like him or not. That is immaterial to him. He does not worry about it. I certainly do not like the administration that he has carried on during the past year. With regard to political murder crimes and other types of crime, I cannot say that he is doing his best, but I can assure him of this that by his statement here, that this house was burned down, he has made a present of £5,000 to his former colleague Senator McEllin, and a present of another £5,000 to Mr. Denis E. Browne whose address we do not know.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is not that matter about the house the subject of proceedings in the courts at the moment?

Comment on this

But that is the very matter to which Deputy Moran referred. He referred to it as the blister that was going to be put on the County Mayo.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

But there are proceedings?

Comment on this

The Deputy said that this was going to put a blister on the County Mayo.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

All that I have to say is that the Party opposite were solely and simply the cause of it, and I take this opportunity of telling that to Deputy Moran and to everybody else concerned.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think the Deputy might leave that now.

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

That is a matter for the Land Commission. I do not intend to say any more. You have allowed me to get in a lot. My chief interest is in the prisoners—the political ones—and again I would ask the Minister to do something for them in the way of prison reform. If he does, he will satisfy everybody who has ever had any association with prisons in this country.

Comment on this

Deputy Commons has no reason to apologise for irrelevancies because in a long experience I can say that I have seldom heard a more prudent or a more moderately expressed speech on matters on which many feel very strongly. I found myself in great sympathy with much that he had to say on the question of prison reform. Lest this point should escape my memory, I want to say that I support most cordially the representations which have been made by Deputy Commons on behalf of prison warders who are required to be back at the prison gates at 11 o'clock at night. Such an arrangement is fantastic. In the 19th century it was the practice in certain old-fashioned shops in rural Ireland— the staffs then lived in—to require them to be in at night at 11 o'clock. There might be some excuse for it in those days, but that has long ceased to be the custom.

It astonishes me to hear that the Minister could consider approving of a regulation which requires mature men, under pain of dismissal, to be in at 11 o'clock at night. I think that the demand made by Deputy Commons was very inadequate—namely, that the hours at which the warders would be required to be in would be extended on a couple of nights a week. I think it is fantastic that they should not have the right to be out until midnight, or after midnight, without let or hindrance, provided they send a notification to the appropriate official. There should be no question of allowing them to remain out so long as they are on duty at the appointed hour in the morning.

In my opinion there ought to be no restriction whatever on the free movement of mature men. Of course, if some fellow stays out night after night and renders himself unfit to take up duty in the morning, the thing to do with him is to sack him. It would be an absurd position for any employer to take up, that after his day's work the employer should have the right to regulate the private life of his employee and determine whether he might go to a dance or walk the hills. I hope the Minister will be in a position to say, when replying, that this archaic arrangement had escaped his notice, and that he will now have the matter put right.

There are two questions which I would like to ask Deputy Commons, because, as I say, I was much struck by the moderation and prudence of much of what he said. He made a very moderate and carefully-phrased appeal for the political prisoners. May I ask him what does he mean by political prisoners? Are we still at the stage in this country that if a man draws a gun and murders a Civic Guard in the public street and says that he did it for a political reason, that he is to be given preferential treatment? Does the Deputy think that?

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

If those are his ideals.

Comment on this

Any man then can go and murder his neighbour and stand up in court and say: "I was induced to do this deed by my ideals."

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

No.

Comment on this

Why not? I accept your good faith as an Irishman, but I regard such a doctrine as absolutely indefensible and intolerable in any civilised society. If the Garda Síochána of this country, who are public servants —who are the children of our neighbours—are to stand in perpetual peril of being shot down in the public street and murdered, and if the person who murders one of them is to be transmuted by this Parliament into a national hero as a person with such lofty ideals that he has raised above the law—that he is a man in a class by himself—how can you expect any respectable man to serve in the uniform of this State?

Comment on this
Bernard Commons Mr. Commons

The Deputy must realise that guns are not that plentiful in the State.

Comment on this

What I mean is that the man who draws a gun and deliberately murders a Civic Guard should, in my opinion, be hanged by the neck until he is dead.

Comment on this

—— and should always have been so.

Comment on this

I want to say that without qualification of any sort or any description and unless this Parliament is prepared to go on record as taking the view that if a person in cold blood and with deliberation murders a servant of the State in the course of his duty that that murderer should receive the punishment appropriate to a murderer, the maintenance of civilised Government in this country is impossible. Therefore, I find myself at profound variance with Deputy Commons. What astonishes me and what, in some degree, causes me alarm is that I believe he is perfectly sincere and it shocks me to find that somebody capable of thinking as he thinks about other matters could conceivably display that confusion of mind—justify murder on the ground that some individual citizen chooses to describe it as being done in pursuit of his ideals.

Deputy Commons very readily says: "Can you blame a man for his ideals?" When he says that he is thinking of the ideals of extreme nationalism of this country. Suppose he finds other ideals which are held just as fervently and violently as they were. Suppose he finds a person blinded by religious bigotry—convinced that Catholics are enemies of the State, enemies of liberty. Does he say that in such a community any person who draws a gun and murders a man because he is a Catholic should be excused and that he does it for his ideals? If every man is to be a judge of his own justification the conduct of us all will become in all probability very strange. There is a moral law which says: "Thou shalt not kill"—and to that moral law there are well-recognised qualifications where the State acts of itself or by its agents. I know of no law that entitles a man in cold blood to go out and murder his neighbour who is the servant of the State in the course of his duty and then claim the title of an idealist and claim exemption from the law.

Comment on this

I hope that sinks into the Minister's conscience.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order, Deputy, please.

Comment on this

Deputy Commons spoke of land hunger and he and Deputy Cafferky feel strongly about that particular topic in connection with the particular part of Mayo from which they come. Have Deputies in this House yet begun to realise the source of land hunger at the present time? One of the most abundant sources of land hunger in this country at the present time is the universal knowledge that if the State can be induced to acquire my holding for distribution——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not a matter for the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

I do not think the Leas-Cheann Comhairle has the faintest notion of what I am going to say.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is referring to matters for which the Minister is not responsible.

Comment on this

Nonsense! I am referring to land agitation and the consequent crime that may derive therefrom in the County Mayo. C-r-i-m-e, and the Minister for Justice is responsible for crime. What is the cause of crime? That is what I am arguing. If we hold out to any body of people the inducement that if they resort to measures sufficiently violent they can secure for themselves the right to purchase their neighbours' land at one-half the price of that land, how can we ever put an end to land hunger in this country? If I covet my neighbour's farm in Ireland now and can induce the Land Commission to acquire it, divide it into two holdings, and sell it to me, for every acre of that land the value of which is £40 I am only asked to pay £20.

If we had a system in this country of buying publichouses and selling them to the purchaser for one-half of what they cost would not we have a publichouse hunger and would not we have urgent demonstrations started, and crime committed to prevent anyone buying a publichouse lest thereby the Government might be deterred from buying it and selling it to the fortunate allottee for one-half of what it cost?

I remember saying in this House 15 years ago, when the Land Act of 1931 was introduced: "You are going to create a situation in this country in which you will have a perennial and recurrent land hunger in pursuit of which crime will be committed, agrarian outrage will be promoted and a rotten pantomime of the land war upon which we look back with pride enacted, not in defence of the right of honourable people to live on their holdings, but enacted to give effect to the jealous, covetous nature of those who want their neighbour's land and want it at half price." So long as the law of this State provides that the Land Commission can acquire land, pay £40 an acre for it, and sell it to the allottee for £20 an acre we will have land hunger of a fraudulent and specious type, we will have agrarian crime and outrage and— if it goes on long enough—we will have every barony in this country reft with feud and hatred, created by that appeal to the natural covetousness of some people who would go to the end of the world in the hope of getting something for nothing.

Comment on this

What did the ranchers pay for the land?

Comment on this

Never mind the land——

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Deputy to make an assault on land agitation, for which the Minister for Justice is not responsible, and on lines which have been forbidden to Deputy Blowick?

Comment on this

I despair of battering into the heads of some Deputies in this House——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is trying to explain the risk of crime in connection with land agitation.

Comment on this

I do not believe that Deputy Keyes understands——

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon told the Chair that it was talking nonsense.

Comment on this

You were stopped from saying half what Deputy Dillon has said. Every Deputy in the House should be given the same latitude. Deputy Dillon is a man apart here——

Comment on this

I do not give way to that man. I do not believe that, even at the present time, Deputy Keyes understands me.

Comment on this

Nobody understands you except yourself.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Keyes understand——

Comment on this

I understand that you are definitely out of order.

Comment on this

Any other Deputy but Deputy Dillon would be ruled out.

Comment on this
An Leas-Cheann-Comhairle

The Chair makes no distinction between Deputies.

Comment on this

It makes very great distinctions, sometimes.

Comment on this

Is that permissible?

Comment on this

I stand over what I said.

Comment on this

The Land Commission buys land for £40 and sells it to the allottee——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Has Deputy Corry made a charge against the Chair of discriminating?

Comment on this

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle was present when the leader of Clann na Talmhan was ruled out of order for not half the stuff that has now been given out by Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Not at all.

Comment on this

I am not a fool.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must withdraw his charge against the Chair.

Comment on this

I will withdraw nothing. There is a special privilege for one Deputy and that is unfair.

Comment on this

Do not cry.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must withdraw.

Comment on this

I was here before some of you people and I will be here again.

Deputy Corry left the Chamber.

Comment on this

There is an improvement in the House now.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

May I appeal to Deputy Dillon to get away from the genesis of agrarian crime and to come to some matter for which the Minister is responsible?

Comment on this

This matter is extremely important and to-day the Minister himself made reference to it in the reply he gave to a question in this House. Why is it that, when you approach the root of an evil in this country, everybody thrusts his head in the sand and says: "Talk about anything but do not talk about that." There is the root of the evil. Deputy Keyes goes into hysterics when you mention it.

Comment on this

You are trying to keep the ranchers where they were.

Comment on this

One cannot get it into that man's head that, while generations of us stood for land purchase, no sane man ever said that the whole land of Ireland should be bought in parcels for £40 by the community and sold to individual allottees for £20.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is now going into the whole land question.

Comment on this

I am trying to drive home to people that the source and root of agrarian crime in this country is the perpetuation of a land war and that nothing the Minister or the Gardaí or anybody else can do will stop that until you go to the root of the matter and end the evil. Seventy years ago the representatives of the people pointed that out. "Buckshot" Forster sent in the soldiers but you cannot end agrarian crime until you put an end to the source of the evil. That was demonstrated by our representatives to the British House of Commons. The British tried the military, the police, "Buckshot" Forster and everything else——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

In connection with this Estimate, the Deputy may postulate agrarian crime but he should go on to something for which the Minister is responsible.

Comment on this

I am pointing out——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I know very well what you are pointing out. I am not deaf.

Comment on this

I have not the least intention of passing from that until I shall have dealt with it as exhaustively as I think fit.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair will not permit you to do so.

Comment on this

The Chair will not permit me to deal with crime on the Estimate for the Minister for Justice?

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

With the genesis of crime.

Comment on this

Are we not to discuss the cause of crime on the Estimate for the Department of Justice? That would be a foolish ruling if it were given.

Comment on this

When discussing crime, we must remember that there are two methods of dealing with it. One is to abolish the evil which is the cause of it and the other is to suppress it——

Comment on this

To stuff people into jail.

Comment on this

I am trying to persuade the more wooden-headed Deputies that we had agrarian crime many years ago and that a mighty empire threw all its forces into an attempt to suppress it. Our fathers and grandfathers told them from the beginning that they could double their forces and that the thing would go on until the cause of it was abolished. After years of agitation, they abolished the cause and there was no more agrarian crime. I am reminding the House—I was reared in the atmosphere of this business—that certain steps were taken in this House which I said, the moment I saw them, were going to lead to a recrudescence of crime. That recrudescence has taken place. Many Deputies want to turn their backs on the cause of the crime. They want to turn out the soldiers. The Minister is trebling and quadrupling the Gardaí in the area. All the silly remedies to which "Buckshot" Forster, who was an extremely respectable old man——

Comment on this

A kindly old fellow.

Comment on this

A kindly old fellow, most anxious to do what was right and moved by exactly the same sentiments as those expressed by Deputy Moran to-day. Listening to Deputy Moran talking about the enforcement of the law, the protection of law-abiding citizens and the assertion of the rights of private property, I could hear echoing down the years the accents of that mild, respectable old man, "Buck-shot" Forster. Both fell into the same error. Poor old Forster was anxious to be popular in Ireland. He was sure that the people would grow to love him when they got to know him and he was a bitterly disappointed man when things did not turn out as he had thought they would. He often told my father that he had been estranged from the Irish because they never understood him. All he wanted was to restore peace and quietness, the same as Deputy Moran. But they both went about it in the wrong way.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Perhaps the Deputy would come to the Estimate now.

Comment on this

I suggest to the Minister that he should learn from the experience of those who went before. He can maintain law and order provided his colleagues in the Government will collaborate with him and not be punching holes in the walls against crime which he so skillfully erects, which holes he has to fill. There are several matters on this Estimate to which I want to draw attention. Again, Deputy Commons gave me the cue. He referred to the publication, I Did Penal Servitude, a dirty, lying, slanderous, fraudulent publication by a mean hound who slanders prison officers and libels them in the knowledge, acquired by his experience during well-deserved punishment, that the prison officers are prevented by prison regulations from having recourse to the civil courts for their remedy. A decent, respectable man—a warder who is easily identified —is grossly and vilely libelled in that book. I think I am right in saying that the moment the paragraph was drawn to this man's attention, he applied for permission to issue a writ for libel but was informed that, in the general interest of the prison service, that course was not permissible. I move to report progress.

Comment on this