Sinn Féin Funds Bill, 1947—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–141 of 288. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 5 of 1947 ›
The House discussed the section at great length on Friday and pleaded with the Taoiseach to answer some of the question that were then raised. The Taoiseach seemed to indicate that he would do that in his own time. I would like him, when replying to the questions that were raised on Friday, to answer this question: sub-section (1) of this section says that on the passing of this Act, all further proceedings in the pending action shall, by virtue of this section, be stayed and he makes his general case for section 10 that to take any action other than to pass this section and to take this matter entirely out of the courts, would squander money. In column 1754 of the Dáil Debates of the 11th March, dealing with the introduction of this measure, the Taoiseach says:—
"...the present Sinn Féin organisation proceeded to take action in the courts. They issued a plenary summons in which both the Attorney-General and Judge Power were cited as defendants."
Then I intervened and I said: "When was that?" and the Taoiseach said:—
"About the end of 1941. In December and January at that time there were some communications and I would say it was in January, 1942, that the plenary summons was issued. Considerable expense was incurred by the defendants in preparing the material necessary in order to deal with the case."
So that this case was taken up either at the end of 1941 or in January, 1942, and it was not until March, 1947, more than five years later, that the Taoiseach, whose point now is that this Bill is intended to prevent the wasting of money, brought in this Bill. I would ask him if he can justify the grounds which he now puts before the House for this section and for taking out of the courts a case which has been in the courts for the last five years?
Comment on this
Since the House last discussed this matter, the Government's specialist in misrepresentation, otherwise known as the Minister for Local Government, has apparently been unleashed for the purpose of trying to explain to a bewildered public what all this Bill is about. The Minister, on Saturday night, at a Fianna Fáil cumann made a speech on what he thought to be the merits of this Bill.
Comment on this
I want to know what the purpose of this Bill is, and the House and the country are entitled to know what the purpose of this Bill is.
Comment on this
We are entitled to know what is the purpose of the machinery set up in Section 10. The machinery set up in Section 10 is to prevent this case from going into the courts, the Taoiseach says, in order to avoid money being frittered away. Now, the specialist in misrepresentation throws a new light on the matter. He says that is not the purpose at all. He says the purpose of this Bill is to provide a fund out of which the victims of Black-and-Tan tyranny in this country may get some assistance. If the Minister is right in the matter, the Taoiseach has been deluding us and fooling us all the time.
Now the abusive mouth-organ of the Party is being let out to tell the country an entirely different story. He tells us that the purpose of the Bill is to provide some sum of money to relieve cases of distress among people who were victims of Black-and-Tan tyranny. Is that the purpose of the Bill? I do not believe for one minute that it is the purpose of the Bill. I think that is a subtle little subterfuge on the part of the Government in order to get themselves out of the legal difficulties involved in this matter. They probably said to themselves: "In order to kill this Bill we will pretend that the real purpose of the money is to relieve distress among people who have suffered and for whom every citizen in this country has very considerable sympathy." I suggest that the real purpose of this Bill is not to make these funds available for the victims of Black-and-Tan tyranny but to keep the Taoiseach and members of the Government out of the law courts, having regard to all the ghostly stories that may be told of the past and all the compromising political utterances that might be adduced there in all their old-time nakedness and of the embarrassment that might flow. If the Minister for Local Government is right in his assertion, I want to ask the Taoiseach if he contends with any process of reason that this country and this Legislature could not make available to-morrow, if it so desired, £1,000,000 of money for the purpose of relieving distress among victims of Black-and-Tan tyranny. Is there any difficulty in doing so if we want to do it? Have not we got an abundance of paper money to do it? Had not we a declaration here a few years ago from the present Uachtaran when he was Minister for Finance that there was an abundance of money in this country for every worth-while object. If we have an abundance of money for every worth-while object in this country, if we have sterling assets worth £400,000,000, cannot we quite easily introduce a simple Bill in this House setting aside £1,000,000 to be administered by an impartial committee among victims of Black-and-Tan tyranny or among those who suffered loss in the fight for freedom and who might not be covered by the strict interpretation of our pension code? There is no difficulty in doing that. The only difficulty I see is that the Government will not do it. It is dishonest for the Minister for Local Government—deliberately and patently dishonest—to seek to give to the country the impression that the purpose of this legislation is to make these moneys available to relieve distress among people who were victims of Black-and-Tan tyranny. That is not the purpose of the Bill at all. It is a subtle, dirty little trick. The Minister for Local Government knows perfectly well that by the time this Bill is through, and all the consequences flowing from this Bill have to be paid, there will be very little money available for those who might otherwise present a claim on this fund. Even though the sum available will probably be in the vicinity of £10,000 or less, is that the best we can give them? Does that represent the measure of our gratitude or the measure of our desire to help those who suffered? If we are going to have an honest debate on this Bill we ought to know definitely who is correct in his statement. Is the Taoiseach correct when he says it is to prevent moneys being frittered away or is it the Minister for Local Government who, apparently thinking that the Taoiseach was not making a sufficiently good job of this Bill, thought that his talents were necessary in order to clarify the position? He went on the rampage last Saturday night and delivered the type of speech which, in any well conducted country, would result in his being sent out of the Cabinet on Sunday morning. I want to try to get the basic truth as to what is the purpose behind the Bill. Is the Minister for Local Government right or is the Taoiseach right?
Comment on this
As between the two, I still want to find out who approximates more to the truth. Is it the Taoiseach or is it this self-appointed and rather embarrassing assistant, the Minister for Local Government?
Comment on this
Before the Taoiseach intervenes, as he has undertaken to do, may I remind the House again that out of the root of this section designed to stop an action in courts many evils are already beginning to grow before our eyes? I put it to the Taoiseach that inasmuch as this Bill, from the Government's point of view, is a matter of expediency and in that it represents for us on this side of the House, belonging to all Parties, a matter of fundamental principle, in any well-ordered democracy the Government of the day, commanding an absolute majority——
Comment on this
I am only asking the Taoiseach to reply and without further argument as to the merits involved yield to the point and let there be an end of this matter. I invite him to end it now in the certain knowledge that all sides of the House will combine with him to make equal provision from the Exchequer as might have been made from the remnants of this fund for whatever body of persons the survivors of the old Sinn Féin movement rightly wish to assist. Nobody in this House feels more strongly about these matters than I do. Doubtless many feel as strongly. Feeling as deeply as I do about it, I would be glad to see it disposed of on those terms. That is not because I have any reluctance to fight this matter out to the bitter end. I am ready and willing to do that. I would sooner see an end made of it now before more damage than has already been done is done.
Comment on this
This particular section appears to contain the real kernel of the Bill. I think it should be clear to everyone by this time that the Bill itself is what seafaring men would call "an unlucky Bill", a Bill that was conceived, I would say, in political prejudice and born with a curse on its face. Nothing but misfortune and regrettable events have followed in the wake of this particular Bill. Not the least is to have the Taoiseach, the Leader of the House, so far forgetting his position in the House and the high position he occupies as to refer to the Opposition members of the Dáil as so many "cubs".
Comment on this
I am not aware of having used that expression. I ask the Chair or anybody in the House if I used that expression.
Comment on this
I quote from column 1342 of the Official Report of the 24th of April, 1947:—
"Mr. Dillon: And we will talk after him and he will not enjoy it.
The Taoiseach: Will I not! I always enjoy the bellowing and the violence of the cubs on the opposite benches."
Comment on this
I do not care what is in the Official Report. I appeal to anybody who was present here in the House, to the Chair, to say if I used that word.
Comment on this
I do not mind what is in the Official Report. I deny absolutely that I used the words. They are not the words I used. I used a Greek phrase which was misunderstood. I used a couple of words of Homer, "Poluphloisboio Thalasses", which means of the loud-resounding sea. It was misunderstood by the reporter.
Comment on this
In the course of his political manoeuvres, the Taoiseach has repudiated many things, many of his own statements, and many of his colleagues. It now remains for him to repudiate the official records of this House.
Comment on this
The Deputy is quoting from a speech made and recorded in connection with this Bill and the Deputy is within his rights——
Comment on this
The Deputy is pointing out what followed in the wake of this Bill and the Deputy introduced his remarks by saying that the kernel of the whole Bill was in this particular section.
Comment on this
He referred to a particular phrase, which he is trying to say that I used and which I know perfectly well I did not use.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach's word or a Deputy's word must be accepted. That is not an official document.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Must the Taoiseach's word or the word of any other Deputy be accepted in all matters against even the official Report of the House?
Comment on this
That is a general question. I was in the House when the Taoiseach was speaking. I did not hear that word, I might say. I was here at the time and I heard the Greek quotation. That is an uncorrected copy of the Official Report. If a Minister or a Deputy says that he has not been correctly reported, I take his word.
Comment on this
One of the misfortunes that followed this unlucky Bill is a report circulated to the effect that the Taoiseach referred to members of the Opposition as cubs.
Comment on this
Another misfortune which followed on this particular Bill is that for the first time in the history of this House and this State we had, through the instrumentality of this Bill, the high office of the Chief Justice of Ireland dragged in——
Comment on this
The Deputy might come to Section 10 which deals with taking the case out of the courts.
Comment on this
Section 10 proposes by the weight of a political majority that broke away and repudiated Sinn Féin to high-jack the Sinn Féin funds from under the very noses of the Chief Justice and other members of the Supreme Court and the instrument selected to participate in that bit of high-jacking is the Chief Justice.
Comment on this
The Chief Justice is not in this section. There has been a five hours' debate on the section which, I think, is enough, if not too much.
Comment on this
What is in this section is that on the passing of this Bill all further proceedings pending, whether before the Chief Justice or any other judge of this State, shall be quashed and that the funds which are at the moment sub judice before the courts of this country shall be taken from under the noses of the judges and passed over to a committee nominated by the Taoiseach, of which the Chief Justice is one of the instruments. That is the proposal in this section. I think it is certainly another misfortune that that should be the position we have reached. The third misfortune which followed this unlucky Bill is to have a Minister of State so far forgetting——
Comment on this
The Deputy must not anticipate a motion which is to come before the House to-morrow.
Comment on this
At the present moment we are anticipating a matter that is sub judice, a thing that was always considered entirely improper. It was never allowed by the Chair in this Assembly even to pass a remark about a case which was sub judice. All previous precedents have gone by the board and all previous rulings are completely inoperative in face of the upset that has come to a well-established precedent as to proper procedure and the propriety of Dáil action, in face of this particular section. Not anticipating any motion which comes before the House to-morrow, but merely to make a point to indicate the reason and the justification for my opening remarks, another misfortune is the fact that a Minister of State so far forgot himself when discussing this Bill outside of this House that he used a political platform, a public hall, a Fianna Fáil ceilidhe——
Comment on this
——to make an attack on the Chair and the impartial administration of the Chair. What are we proposing to do? We are proposing to take from out of the custody of the Irish courts a sum of money that is there awaiting the decision of these courts, and that proposal is made by one of the parties to, not one, but two of the three splits that reduced that organisation to what the Taoiseach now describes as a position of insignificance. It would not be so bad, it would not be so improper, and it would not be so distasteful and nationally degrading if we had a Taoiseach and a Government supported by a Party over there that did not happen to be the principal in the discreditable dog-fight or dog-fights that took place between parties and peoples 25 years ago. But imagine the quite natural resentment of any one of those parties who had been in conflict with other persons and other parties, and whose treasurers and trustees, with a sense of decency as to the proper thing to do, had consistently refused to break up the swag amongst any of the warring elements, no matter whether they were mighty or insignificant. When funds had been placed in the custody of the courts for anybody who could establish a claim to get the funds or to get their portion of the funds, was that the time for one of the principals in all those splits and dog-fights to come in by weight of a political majority and say: "I am taking over the funds to be disposed of in accordance with my decision"?
The impropriety and indecency of such a course should be apparent to the Taoiseach, seeing that he was one of the principals in all those disputes and divisions and controversies and splits. To use a democratic institution, to use a Parliamentary majority for such a purpose is steamrolling completely any of the commonly accepted principles of democracy and is certainly trampling in the dirt any ordinary standards of fair play. Is it the Taoiseach's contention that a Parliamentary majority, no matter how dumb, how disciplined or how regimented, can justify anything that is done by virtue of that majority? There was a time when it was contended that a majority had no right to do wrong. Is it now the contention that the majority has a right to do anything, has a right to trample on the courts, has a right to snatch from the courts something that is entrusted to their custody for distribution or for safeguarding? I think we have reached a point where it is not the amount of money that matters—if it was a ha'penny or a million; it is the principle of the thing.
There is neither conscience nor decency nor principle associated with the particular proposal that is made here. I do not claim by any manner of means to be a constitutional authority, but I claim as an ordinary citizen and as a plain Deputy the right to say that the Constitution of this country is a sham, a worthless sham, if it makes it possible and admissible for one rump of a political split, when it gets a majority, to wade, like a gang of gansters, even into the courts of Ireland and take from the custody of those courts the funds of that organisation, merely because others have not got a Parliamentary majority, merely because they are insignificant, merely because as a result of a split and splitters they are, comparatively speaking, powerless.
What is our constitutional remedy? To appeal to the President to submit it to the Council of State. And what is the procedure before the Council of State? To refer it to the Chief Justice to see whether it is proper or improper, constitutional or otherwise.
Comment on this
——sitting alongside justices who are invited by that particular measure to repudiate the Chief Justice. Does not even Deputy O'Connor see the impossible tangle that has been created by this particular Bill, impossible for the courts, impossible for the President, impossible for the Council of State, impossible for the insignificant persons or body that had the audacity to look to the courts of Ireland for justice, to look to the courts of Ireland for impartiality, merely to find a political body wading in to take the money and to distribute it amongst camp followers? That is the point we have reached. No wonder the Taoiseach lost his head, no wonder the Ministers lost their heads. Their heads were lost before that Bill was drafted. There is every evidence of that on the face of the Bill. I hope that even at this stage wiser counsels will prevail.
Deputy Mulcahy was accused by the Taoiseach and by his Ministers, inside and outside this House, of having been bullied by his legal colleagues into opposition to this Bill. Does the Taoiseach suggest that the legal colleagues of Deputy Mulcahy bullied other individuals and every other Party in this House? Does the Taoiseach think that the influence of those legal colleagues of the Deputy is not only able to throttle and humiliate a man of the standing and courage and character of Deputy Mulcahy, but that it is so great that they can make potboys out of an Independent Deputy like Deputy Dillon, the Leader of the Labour Party, the Leader of the Farmers' Party, the Leader of the Clann na Talmhan Party?
Will the Taoiseach get away from his jaundiced, political bias, and will he not see that here, with the exception of a regimented pack, a Party where there is no will but the will of one man, every free Deputy and every free Party in this House is disgusted and nauseated by the intentions in this particular Bill, concentrated in this particular section, and will he show himself sufficiently democratic to bow to the free will and the independent thought of the overwhelming majority of free Deputies in this Dáil?
Comment on this
Are we to take it that the Taoiseach has no intention of replying to anything said on this section since Thursday night last?
Comment on this
There seems to be very little use in making any reply. Everything that was needed to answer the points that have been raised was stated already in connection with the various sections and on the Second Reading. On the Committee Stage one can continue to repeat and repeat the arguments that have been used and, no matter how clearly the position has been stated, to go back and act as if no answer had been given.
The suggestion is that there is something extraordinary proposed in this Bill. That is not true. In several cases already the Legislature has come in to deal with matters which have been before the courts, even when they were decided by the courts, and to say even that the law was not as it was interpreted by the courts, but was deemed to have been different. One would imagine that this was the first place in which there was a question of retroactive or retrospective legislation. That is not so.
Comment on this
I will give you the names of several other Bills. I have a list of the whole lot here.
Comment on this
I shall give them one by one, if the Deputy waits. To start with there was the Land Act of 1926, the Deputy Registrar in Bankruptcy (Cork) Act, 1926, the Copyright Preservation Act, 1929, the Finance Act of 1929, the Courts of Justice Act, 1931, the Land Act of 1936 (in two sections) and the Accidental Fires Act of 1934.
Comment on this
There have been several cases in the courts in which such matters were dealt with—first of all, in which judgements were set aside and nullified, and others overruling the decision of the Supreme Court—the Stokes case of 1931, the Performing Rights Society case of 1928——
Comment on this
Of course no one Act will be the same as another, but the fundamental principle is that the Legislature comes in and declares the law, acts as the Legislature, the body which makes the law. The courts are only interpreting the law. The courts will interpret the law as it is at the moment—at whatever moment they are taking their decision —but it is for the Legislature, having the common good and the general interest in mind, to make the law as the common good suggests it should be made.
Comment on this
At any time. This Parliament has sovereign authority to make the law except in so far as its power is limited by the Constitution. As I said, in the earlier stages, if there is anything in this Bill which is contrary to the Constitution that matter can be settled in the usual way. I am confident that there is nothing in this Bill which is in any way contrary to the Constitution. It is not unusual for the State to introduce Bills of this kind. There have been, in every book dealing with matters of this sort, instances of this kind. It is the right of the Legislature to pass retroactive legislation. The one thing which it is forbidden to do in that particular way, under the Constitution, is to declare acts to be criminal, to be crimes, to be illegal, when they were not so at the date of their commission. That is the one single obstacle that is put to retroactive legislation by this Parliament. In other Parliaments where they have no written Constitution, certain conventions have come to be regarded as governing their actions but legally they are sovereign and their acts cannot be legally questioned, as Acts of this House can be under the Constitution. There is nothing unusual then in that sense in legislation of this sort.
It is right of course that in any appropriate case a question should be raised as to whether a Bill is repugnant to the Constitution. It is desirable that on a matter on which representatives of the people in Parliament will naturally have different views such questions should be raised but, as for suggesting that there is some extraordinary question of principle involved here, that is simply not true. That objection is not based on anything sound. It has been urged that it is the highest function of democracy that we should give way to the views expressed on the Opposition side. I do think that in a deliberative Assembly if some of the people present put forward views from their side, even though these people may be split up into different Parties, consideration should be given to them but when due consideration is given to all the points raised, are we to say that if the Opposition plead principle the Party in power must necessarily to give way to them? It is very easy to plead principle but am I to be regarded as such an innocent that I must believe that every one of the arguments to which I have listened here was made in good faith? I have lived a certain length of time in this world. I have listened to arguments under a variety of circumstances and there has been more make-believe, in my opinion, in the arguments that have been put forward from the other side during the debates on this Bill than in any other matter I have had anything to do with.
Comment on this
It does say a great deal. Democracy, as I understand it, means that the people of the country elect their representatives in representative assemblies. The idea in this Assembly is that every individual who is elected by the people stands on the same level here and that a vote on one side of the House is as good as a vote on the other side of the House, but the working of democracy is that when there is a difference of opinion and that difference comes to be resolved by a vote the majority vote should prevail. Of course, Deputies on the opposite side say that because they are split up into several Parties, their vote should count for more. I deny that. Each one counts for what he is. That is democracy. The suggestion is that because a large section of the people or a large organisation elect a majority belonging to a particular Party, the votes of the members of that Party should not be regarded as equal to the votes on the opposite side. We know that if the people on the opposite benches are split up into several Parties, it is because they have not a policy on which they could agree. If they had a common policy on which they could agree, they would be one Party. Would they suggest that if they were one Party their votes should not count as much as if they were separate? I think the whole thing is nonsense.
We know what democracy means here. We have a law-making institution, which is this House. The duty of the Oireachtas is to make the law. The duty of the courts is to interpret the laws as they are there at any particular time. They have never suggested that they should be allowed to make the laws. If at any particular time the law is not what it should be, in the common interest, then it is the duty of the Legislature to make the situation accord with what the common interest demands. You have, as I have said, the Legislature to make the laws. You have the courts—to do what? To interpret the laws as they are there at any particular time. It has never been denied by the courts, or never been held as any derogation of their position by the courts, that the Legislature should come in and exercise its proper function at any particular time. There is no interference with the courts or with the independence of the courts in that. The courts have their own proper function and they are allowed to carry out that proper function.
We have, in addition, the Executive. The Executive here is subject to the day-by-day control of Parliament. It can only exist as an Executive, if it has the support of the majority.
I have no qualms whatever about this Bill. As I said at an earlier stage, these funds were subscribed by the nation in a national struggle and the greater part of the nation subscribed to them. When the divisions came, they were put into the courts and they have remained in the courts for the past 23 years. A situation arose, as I have already informed the Dáil, in which the treasurers had died and in which the representative of the last treasurer came with a proposition that these funds should no longer be allowed to remain there. I indicated willingness to deal with them by legislation, as was suggested, and it was only when the Legislature, so far as the Executive part of it is concerned, was seized of this particular matter, that an attempt was made to block it through the courts. Are we to have the position in the future that, when the Legislature is about to deal with any matter which may affect the rights— and nearly all legislation does affect rights of one kind or another—of individuals or sections of the community, the Legislature can be brought to a standstill by the simple process of somebody affected running to the courts and trying to put in an action there? When it became known that the Executive was about to bring this matter before Parliament, the courts were used in this particular way.
The question then was: should we go ahead? I thought that perhaps the matter would be tried quickly and that, if the expenses were not going to be very great, that was perhaps the best way to deal with it, but the years began to pass and then the defendants, the Attorney-General and Judge Wyse Power, pressed for a hearing of the case and took legal steps to bring it about and then we had other actions taking place. It was suggested here that we should have intervened. We could not very well have intervened to get a date set down for hearing, so long as this other side issue was being tried, and the trouble with all these cases is that motion after motion can be brought in to delay and cause extra expense. It is not merely the plaintiffs who undergo expense in this case. Those who are defending the funds have to incur expense also, and, if they really mean to defend the funds, they have to take every possible care to make sure that the people who, in their opinion, are not entitled to them should not get them, and, consequently, you have expense after expense piled up.
I must say that when I asked what expenses had been incurred, I was shocked, as members of the House have been shocked, by the figures given to me. I did not ask that anybody should exaggerate or give me an exorbitant account as to the sums spent, but I saw that a position would be reached in which we were going to have the old situation, in which the amount which those who succeeded in a litigation for those funds would get would be trifling, because the moneys would, in the meantime, have been lost in legal costs, no matter which side judgment was given for. On the previous day I said that if this case went for hearing it was a case which was likely to last for three or four weeks, inasmuch as the proving of continuity or whatever else might be in it would have involved going through the history, in a sense, of the past 20 or 25 years, and that the expenses up to the present would be doubled by the time the hearing was over; that there was then almost certain to be an appeal and that the appeal would cost about an equal sum, with the result that, by the time that process of law had been completed, about £20,000 out of the £24,000 would have been spent.
I felt that it would be a shame that moneys subscribed originally in the way in which these moneys were subscribed should be dissipated in that manner and it was for that reason that I said: "Very well; we have waited long enough". If we are to have cases like these which were being brought forward, where a solicitor held on to the papers which the other side wanted and there were then to be motions, if we were to have that sort of thing continuing with the variety of side issues and motions that could be raised, it was better to cut our losses at that stage and take action. That is what is done here. We have decided that the losses should be cut at the particular stage at which we have arrived, that no further expense should be allowed and that in order to see that that would be made effective, the case should be decided here by the Legislature.
I believe, as I said at the start, in view of the way in which these public funds were subscribed, by subscribers all over the country in very large numbers, many of whom have died, that the original subscribers cannot be appealed to in the ordinary way. If we had a long list of the subscribers of the particular sums, what would naturally be said is: "All right; the people who subscribed this money may not, in present circumstances, desire the moneys they subscribed to be used in a way quite different from that for which they were subscribed originally" and a decision could be taken to give the money back to them. It is quite obvious that the money could not be given back and therefore this body, as representing, in the main, the majority of the Irish people, should say what should be done with the funds.
It was suggested by one speaker that we were capturing these moneys and using them for our own purpose. There is no truth whatever in that. There is no truth in any suggestion that our political Party is capturing the money. The money, which was subscribed for national purposes, is being used for a national purpose, and can be so used, only if this law is passed. It will be suggested that because we happen to be the majority in the House, we are doing so and so. I cannot help misrepresentations. If most of us, in the course of our lives, were deterred from doing something we thought right because it was going to be misrepresented, many a proper thing would be left undone. There has been misrepresentation both of our purpose and of what it is proposed to do. To my mind, any shame in that is on those who make these misrepresentations. If the courts have been brought in here in any way which is derogatory to them, then that is not the fault of the Bill. It is the fault of those who used an occasion like this for such a purpose. That could happen in the case of any Bill in which it was proposed that a member of the judiciary should act in any capacity in accordance with the provisions of the measure. Henceforth, it will be very difficult to ask a member of the judiciary to accept any position except such as he is compelled to accept by law or by his office. Up to the present, it was of great value to this Assembly to be able to ask an individual who might, by common consent, be regarded as impartial to act on any board which was being set up in any capacity in which impartiality was obviously valuable. We have had judges brought into Bills in one way or another in the past. We had that accepted in the sense in which it was proposed. It will be extremely difficult in future to ask a judge to do anything of that sort, because he will naturally ask himself whether, under one pretext or another, his office or his views will be brought up in this House and discussed.
As I have said, democracy is working and will work here so long as we regard each person in this Assembly, elected by the Irish people, as having the same weight when it comes to a vote. There is no other way of dealing with the matter. I am not going to admit that, if somebody on the other side claims that this is a matter of principle for him, we should give way. As the matter has arisen here, the right of the Legislature to act in a matter of this kind is, in the opposite direction, as much a matter of principle —more important, in my opinion. I have been asked the details of a number of cases. I have read them, but it would take a considerable time to deal with each case. I have the summaries here, but I have not memorised them. I have satisfied myself, in going through them, that they were examples of cases in which the Legislature did not hesitate to come in and declare the law to be different from that which the courts had declared it to be and to provide that it should be deemed to have been different. The Legislature also provided that the aid which was sought by litigants should not be given to them and that the rights which they were deemed to have possessed should be declared not to exist or to have existed. That is all that is contained in this measure. Therefore, it is not novel. Where you have retroactive or retrospective legislation, you have, of course, a different set of circumstances in each case. We are not likely to have a case exactly the same as the case we have here but, fundamentally, the principle would be the same—that the law can be declared by the Legislature whether a matter is to come before the courts, is in the courts or has been decided by the courts.
An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.
Comment on this
I said the Taoiseach purported to give them. No analogy, precedent or example can be given. The Taoiseach did not deal with Section 10. Section 10 proposes to do what no Act proposed to do up to the present—take a case out of the courts, refuse to allow the courts to come to a decision and transfer the case from the courts to this House for decision.
Comment on this
The Deputy's own county was deeply interested in a case which was taken from the courts. What about the Erasmus Smith case? Was that taken from the court?
Comment on this
I should like to hear a lawyer of the standing of Deputy O'Connor try to justify the action being taken in this case. I should be interested to hear Deputy O'Connor speak as a lawyer on this matter, as he is very competent to do.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach will have plenty of time to read it. I want the Taoiseach to read a note of a Bill which transferred a case from the courts on the ground that this House should be the deciding body and which provided that the decision of this House should be given effect by a committee handpicked by the Taoiseach. There is no precedent for that. I need not go back over the records or go down to the Library to look that matter up. I defy Deputy O'Connor, Deputy Walsh and the Taoiseach to produce here any Act passed by this House since it was established which took a case out of the courts to be decided, as the Taoiseach said, on the merits, by the Legislature, effect to be given to that decision by a committee handpicked by the Taoiseach. There is no precedent for that.
Comment on this
I hope that the Deputy will tell us all about it. There is the fundamental difference that every Party in this House had a common viewpoint on that case. It is completely different.
Comment on this
It is a precedent for the Government taking out of the courts a case which was before them.
Comment on this
I shall not say any more about that. The Taoiseach told us, for the first time, that, when the Legislature contemplated bringing in legislation, action was taken in the courts to block the proposed legislation——
Comment on this
I hope we are not going to have any more Greek phrases. The Taoiseach said that this action was brought in the courts to block the Legislature. How many years ago? In 1941. It has been allowed to stew for six years. What we have not been told is why the courts cannot be allowed to determine this. Why cannot it be left to the courts? What is extraordinary about this case that the courts cannot decide it? Are the courts not deciding every day in the week more important cases?
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach seriously suggest that this House will deal with it in a more impartial way than the courts? Does the Taoiseach suggest that the committee which will be handpicked by the Government will disburse the funds having regard only to the degree of destitution and misery of those to whom these funds are proposed to be disbursed?
Comment on this
Like the Taoiseach, some of us have lived a long time and, like the Taoiseach, we are not as innocent as to accept all that. We have had too many evidences to the contrary, in relation to matters of far greater importance, even than this or what is at stake. The Taoiseach, through the course of his speech, in a much more subtle way, of course, than his Minister performing on Saturday night, tried to allege that it was the Opposition who were bringing the courts into disrepute. The Taoiseach said that it was not the first time judges have been brought into Bills. No judge has ever been brought into a Bill before in a capacity similar to the one in which the Chief Justice is brought in now. Judges—and the Chief Justice, perhaps, on occasion, and though personally I cannot remember a case, that does not mean it has not happened— have been brought in on more than one occasion to preside over committees. We have had very recent examples of that, but not in relation to anything such as we now have before us.
I tried to look on this as an ordinary layman. As any plain man, I want to know why the case cannot be determined by the courts, why the courts cannot be allowed to hear the facts stated by both sides and determine to whom the money belongs or what is to be done with it. This House is to decide. Every argument which the Taoiseach used in the course of the statement he has made just now, in relation to this particular matter, can be used to take any case out of the courts. He asserted here the principle that the Legislature has the right from day to day to take any case out.
Comment on this
Yes. I am not suggesting that they have not the best right; but the public good is to be determined, not by the impartial courts but by the Party which for the moment has a majority of one or 51.
Comment on this
Or, as it is in actual practice, by one person. I am not saying for a moment that you can have any machinery other than that it must be determined by a majority of the Dáil. I am not suggesting there should be, or that there is, but I am suggesting that it is a very dangerous thing to lay down and assert that the Legislature can interfere with the courts of justice of this country from day to day, at any time it pleases and on any matter it pleases and upon any case it pleases. That is what is preached by the Taoiseach to-day.
Comment on this
I wonder if there is any lawyer on this or on the other side who will subscribe to that.
Comment on this
That is the whole trouble. I suppose we would not be discussing this matter at all, if the Taoiseach were not the sort of person who, when he convinces himself that a thing is right, assumes that everybody else is of the same opinion and must be so. That is the whole trouble. That is the reason why we have this thing before us. We have it now stated here, in plain, blunt language and laid down flatly, that the courts are no longer independent and free.
Comment on this
The courts are to be there so long as the majority of the day in this Parliament will leave them there. Judges can function in the courts on the existing law so long as they are allowed to function by the Government of the day. That is what the Taoiseach laid down, whether or not he appreciated—I am sure he did—the full meaning of what he was laying down. Who can say that the courts are free, who can rely on the law of the land, if it is laid down here that whatever Government—whether it is Fianna Fáil, Farmers, Labour or Fine Gael—happens to be sitting over there with a majority of one or 51——
Comment on this
Of course, they can make the law. That is what we are here for. The point is that they can stop the law——
Comment on this
——that is the point and the Taoiseach knows it and he is butting in now, trying to put me off the point, but I am not going to be put off. The Taoiseach is laying down here that the courts will do what he tells them to do, or what his successor tells them to do.
Comment on this
And why? Because the Taoiseach says: "I believe that, in particular, I have a personal duty".
Comment on this
Apart from that, on the first sub-section of this section, the object of this Bill is to deny to the courts the right to administer the law of the land as it is to-day, to take this case away from the courts. I am not concerned with the merits of this case and I do not care whether it is 8d. or £8,000,000 that is at stake. I am not concerned very much as to who receives the money but I am concerned that this principle which is now being applied to the Sinn Féin organisation or what is left of it can be applied to-morrow morning to any individual citizen or to any group of citizens, whether they are a trade union, a trade association, a farmers' association or any other association of citizens which may feel obliged to go to the courts to have their rights asserted. That is now laid down by the Taoiseach as fundamental truth. If the constitutional position is as the Taoiseach now tells us it is, then his Constitution, so far as the citizens' rights are concerned, is not worth the paper it is written upon. Is not the only protection the ordinary plain citizen or group of citizens has, in this or in any other country, against the Executive of the day, the courts of the land?
Comment on this
I am putting it that the only protection the ordinary citizen or group of citizens has against the Executive of the day is the courts.
Comment on this
The point is that Parliament, under the Constitution, is supreme, and it can at any time pass a law. Every Deputy should try to get that into his head.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach wants to get the Parliament, the Executive and the judiciary—the trinity—into his own hands. There is a Parliament there, there is an Executive and there is the judiciary. What is the judiciary for, primarily, except to see that justice is done as between citizen and citizen, to protect a citizen or group of citizens, if necessary, from either the Executive or the Parliament? I am no lawyer, constitutional or otherwise. I am an ordinary citizen.
Comment on this
You cannot protect the citizen except in so far as Parliament protects him, and the Parliament is supreme.
Comment on this
If the Constitution for which the Taoiseach was primarily responsible is not able to guarantee the fundamental rights of the citizen, then it is not worth the paper it is written on. If, in spite of that Constitution, any Executive that happens to have a bare majority in this House can, at any time, come in and take any case out of the courts and prevent judges in any court in this State from administering the law as they find it, where is the protection?
Comment on this
The point is that when a judge pronounces judgement, he declares the law to be what it is at the moment, not what it was before or may be after.
Comment on this
Decide what? It is not the courts but this House that makes the law, and this Legislature has full competence to do that.
Comment on this
You are making a law that is going to allow a judge to determine, under another law, the justice of a particular case. The Taoiseach is trying to turn this Chamber not merely into a Legislature but into a court. It is a Legislature, but it is not a court nor is it intended to be. I am making the point that this is a matter that affects every citizen and every group of citizens. What is being done to-day in relation to Mrs. Buckley, "Sceilg" and others can be done to-morrow in relation to any citizen or group of citizens, by a majority of the House. That is a sad state of affairs.
The Taoiseach went on to another point which he very often resorts to when he is not too sure of his ground or too comfortable. He gave us a little lecture on democracy. He stated that we all stand equal in this House and that democracy will survive as long as we have equal rights in the House—each and every member of it. Did he hear his first lieutenant on Friday last tell one of the oldest members of the House, a man who has been elected and re-elected over and over again for one of the principal constituencies in the country, that he had cheek even to mention one word about these funds or the organisation that is claiming them? This is not a matter of the Sinn Féin funds. It goes far beyond that. The principle that is at stake is far greater. I do not know what the Taoiseach's reasons are, and I am not concerned with them—whether it is that he does not want to go into court or stay out of it. That has nothing to do with it or should have nothing to do with it. The net point for this House is whether or not we are not embarking on a most dangerous principle, and that is interfering with the courts in administering the law of the land.
Comment on this
Where is Deputy O'Connor? He quoted the Erasmus Smith case. I sent out for the Eramus Smith Act, and when he saw it come in he shot out. Why? Because he knew what was in it. This Bill says to Mrs. Buckley: "Get out of the court". Mrs. Buckley says: "I do not want to go, I want my judgement". This Bill says to Mrs. Buckley: "Well, you shall not have it". This Bill says to the Supreme Court and to the High Court of this country that when the Attorney-General shall apply ex parte to the court it shall make an order dismissing the pending action without costs. What does the Erasmus Smith Act say? It says:—
"And whereas with a view to setting such doubts at rest the said governors instituted an action against the Attorney-General of Saorstát Éireann by summons dated the 12th day of November, 1929;
And whereas the said governors appealed from the judgement and order of the High Court of Justice in the said action;
And whereas at the date of the consent hereinafter mentioned"——
Where is Mrs. Buckley's consent?
——"the said appeal from the judgment and order of the High Court in the said action was pending in the Supreme Court;
And whereas on the 12th day of June, 1937, a consent in the said action was entered into between the said governors and the Attorney-General of Saorstát Éireann setting forth the agreement arrived at between the said governors and the Attorney-General of Saorstát Éireann with a view to ending the said litigation, saving further expenditure, and providing for the application and future administration of the said endowments;
And whereas by an order of the Supreme Court made in the said action dated the 23rd day of June, 1937, the court on reading the said consent ordered that the hearing of the said appeal and all further proceedings be stayed"——
not on the ex parte application of the Attorney-General supported by an Act of this House and nothing else, but on reading the consent. Is it any wonder that Deputy O'Connor shot out of the House as the Erasmus Smith Act came in? Deputy O'Connor is an officer of the High Court of this country. By virtue of his membership of the solicitors' profession he is himself, in a sense, an officer of this very court which, for the purposes of his own political Party, he chooses to traduce by saying that the procedure in the Erasmus Smith Act is identical with the monstrous, shameful and outrageous proposal contained in the Sinn Féin Funds Bill. Every evil that is in this disgusting Bill was anticipated and provided against in the procedure adopted in the Erasmus Smith Act.
"Whereas by an order of the Supreme Court made in the said action dated the 23rd day of June, 1937, the court on reading the said consent ordered that the hearing of the said appeal and all further proceedings be stayed;
And whereas it is expedient to empower the said Governors to carry into effect the agreement contained in the said consent, and to set at rest all doubts with regard to the administration of the said endowments, and to provide for the future administration thereof;
And whereas the purposes afore-said cannot be effected without the authority of the Oireachtas;
Be it therefore enacted by the Oireachtas."
What hateful thing is there in Fianna Fáil, that once a man joins that Party, all the standards common to the profession to which he belongs, or to the job he ordinarily does, seem to go by the board and if he is summoned to the fray, everything must be jettisoned and cast overboard in order to back up whatever the machine proposes to do? Deputy O'Connor is back now. I trust he will read the Erasmus Smith Act which I read out for him. He was deeply involved in the Erasmus Smith litigation on behalf of one of the parties that believed itself to be a beneficiary under the trust. Here is Deputy Walsh, a Sinn Féiner of 40 years' standing, certifying to the House that the executive of Sinn Féin is still in existence, to his knowledge.
Comment on this
But both of them will trot into the Lobby when the whip cracks to vote for the exact opposite to what on their testimony they have established in this House. Why is that?
I should like the Taoiseach to give us a list of the cases on which he relies. He relies upon Leatham and Quinn. What is the fact in that case? Is not Leatham and Quinn the case where Oireachtas Éireann stopped the proceedings when the appellants sought to go to the Privy Council?
Comment on this
I know there was one case. If he will give us the list of them we will check them. By the mercy of God's Providence I was in the House when the Erasmus Smith case was going through and I can nail Deputy O'Connor's ear to the post by memory.