Vote 45—Office of the Minister for Education (Resumed).
Contributions 1–112 of 225. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Nuair a tugadh tuairisc ar ar dineadh Dé Céadaoin seo thart, bhíos ag insint don Dáil nach fíor a rá mar adeirtear go minic, nach bhfuil ach 10% de pháistí na tire ag fáil oideachais níos aoirde ná gnáth-oideachas na mbun scol. Thaisbeain mé go raibh 40% díobh ag fáil oideachais níos aoirde na an t-oideachas san. Rud eile de, is beag nach iontach an méadú do tháinig, le roinnt blian, ar áiseanna i gcóir oideachais iar-bhunscoile. I scoil-bhliain a 1928-29, bhí 290 Meán-scoileanna sa tír, agus 26,792 daltaí á bhfreastal. Ach, i gceann chúig mblian déag ón am sin (.i. i scoil-bhliain a 1943-44) bhí 377 Meán-scoileanna ann, agus 40,040 daltaí á bhfreastal. Agus, i dteannta a raibh de dhaltaí ar na gnáth-Mheán-scoileanna i 1943-44, bhí 4,250 daltaí sinsearacha na mBun-scol i "Meán-Bharraí" .i. árd-ranga speisialta leanas do Chlár na Meán-scol.
Ar feadh na tréimhse céanna, tháinig fairsingiú an-mhór ar na háiseanna i gcóir Gairm-Oideachais agus Ceárd-oideachais. Do réir na dtuarascáil atá ar fáil, bhí 65 cinn de Cheárd-scoileanna ann i mbliain a 1924-25, agus bhí 22 díobh sin á stiúradh ag Coistí Contaebhuirg agus mór-bhailte, agus an chuid eile (43) á stiúradh ag Coistí Contae. Ach, de thoradh Acht Gairm-oideachais 1930, tháinig leathnú mór ar an gcóras, agus, i mbliain a 1943-44, bhí 186 ann scoileanna seasamhacha, agus tuairim's 13,000 dalta ag freastal cúrsaí lán-aimsire lae iontu.
Bhí sé ina pholasaí i gcónaí ag mo Roinn-se oiread agus b'fhéidir d'fhairsingiú a dhéanamh ar áiseanna i gcóir oideachais iar-Bhunscoile. Maidir lena leithéidí d'áiseanna do chur ar fáil in áiteanna iargúlta tuaithe, is beag tír Eorpach a ndearnadh oiread soláthair inti. Is fíor nár freagraíodh fé mar a bheifí ag súil go ndéanfaí an soláthar Gairm-scol sa tsaghas úd áiteanna atá luaite agam, ach tá na daoine ag tuiscint a dtábhacht do réir a chéile; tá an freastal ag feabhsú, agus meastar go mairfidh sé ag dul i bhfeabhas.
B'fhéidir nár mhisde gearr-bhreathnú ar an gcás a bheadh ann, i gCathair Átha Cliath, tar éis a chinneadh go n-ardófaí an aois scolfhála go dtí 16 bliana. Níl na figiúirí don MhórÁireamh a rinneadh sa bhliain 1946 le fáil fós, ach do réir an mheastacháin is deireannaí dá bhfuil le fáil tá tuairim's 17,000 daoine óga idir 14 agus 16 sa gcathair sin. Tá tuairim's 2,000 díobh sin ag freastal Bun-scol; tá tuairim's 4,400 ar Mheán-Scoileanna agus tá tuairim's 1,100 ar Ghairm-scoileanna— rud is ionann agus tuairim's 7,500 a bheith ar scoil. Den 9,500, nó mar sin, ná fuil ag freastal scoile, tá tuairim's 6,000 i saghsanna éagsúla fostuithe, agus fágann sin tuairim's 3,500 ná fuil fostaithe ná ar scoil. Mar sin de, is dócha go mbeadh tuairim's 10,000 daltaí nua ann a gcaithfí áiseanna oideachais a sholáthar dóibh, dá n-árdaófaí an aois scolfhágála go dtí 16. Tá sé beartaithe ag Coiste Gairm-oideachais Chathair Bhaile Átha Cliath go ndéanfar seacht gcinn de réigiún-scoileanna nua agus bheadh slí iontu sin do thuairim's 2,500 daltaí eile—rud d'fhágfadh áiseanna oideachais ag teastáil, fós, ó thuairim's 7,500 daoine óga idir 14 agus 16 bliana d'aois. Sé an chaoi ina mbeadh an scéal i mBaile Átha Cliath, an uair sin, go mba riachtanach scoil-slí do b'ionann agus slí 25 ceann, nó mar sin, de nua-scoileanna sa mbreis ar chlár foirgníochta an Choiste Gairm-oideachais, agus go mba riachtanach ina theannta sin, an méid múinteoir cáilithe—300 díobh, nó mar sin—a theastóodh ón oiread sin scol nua.
Is léir, mar sin, nár chóir an aois scol-fhágála d'ardú nó go ndéanfaí dian-mhachtnamh eolach ar an gceist agus ar a deacrachta go léir, agus go ndéanfaí plean dea-eagraithe chun a réiteach.
Cé's móite den tsos fhada do tharla i bhformhór scoileanna Chathair Bhaile Átha Cliath, leanadh go sásúil d'obair na mBun-scol ar fud na tíre, an bhliain seo thart. Do réir dealraimh, bíonn a lán daoine ag súil le tuilleadh agus an chóir d'obair ó na Bun-scoileanna; i dteannta a ndualgas féin, bítear ag súil uathu le hobair den tsaghas a bhaineas go speisialta leis na Meán-scoileanna agus na Gairm-scoileanna. Is léir nach féidir do dhaltaí na mBun-scol an tréineáil d'fháil a theastódh uathu i gcóir ceard-fhostuithe; agus ní féidir doibh a sáth oideachais d'fháil chun iad a cháiliú le haghaidh na Stát-sheirbhíse ná na nOllscol. Sé príomh-dhualgás na Bunscoile comh-chúnamh a thabhairt don Eaglais agus do na tuismitheoirí chun bunús daingean creideamh-eolais a thabhairt do na daltaí maidir le mórálacha agus iompar sóisealta. Tar a éis sin, is dualgas don Bhun-scoil oiread bun-oideachais choitianta a thabhairt do na daltaí agus chuirfeadh ina gcumas tuilleadh d'fhoghlaim ar a gconnlán féin, nó feidhm a bhaint as cibé caoithe oideachais a casfaí ina slí. Más cóir obair ár mBun-scol a bhreithniú do réir na gcaighdeán sin, sé mo mheas-sa go gcomhlíonann siad a ndualgais lán chomh maith leis na Bun-scoileanna i dtír ar bith de na tíortha a bhfuil aon eolas maith againn orthu.
Tá fhios agam go bhfuil sé d'fhaisiún ann, faoi láthair, dísbeagadh a dhéanamh ar obair ar mBun-scol féin; ach is eagal liom go dtagann an mhór-chuid den dí-mheasadh ón gclaonadh atá ionainn go léir bheith ag maíomh as an "am fadó"—as an saol sárbhreá a bhí ann, tráth bhíomar féin óg. Tá fhios agam gurb uireasa eolais agus mí-eolas is bun do mhórán den gcáineadh úd. An té ar mhian leis breithiúnas cóir a thabhairt ar an obair ghníthear in aon tsaghas scoile, ba riachtanach, ar dtús, dó an t-eolas agus an tréineáil a bheith aige a chuirfeadh ar a chumas an obair a mheádh mar ba cheart; agus, tar a éis sin, níor mhór dó na scoileanna féin a bhreathnú go maith. Níor mhór dó a bhfeiscint i mbun oibre, ionas go mbeadh a thuairim féin aige ina dtaobh, agus ná beadh sé i dtuillamaí ráflaí ná an bhreithiúnais a bhí déanta ag daoine eile. Ní habhar imní ar bith do Bhunscoileanna na tíre seo daoine a bheith ag déanamh fiosruithe den tseoirt sin. Ach is dí-céillí an mhaise do dhaoine, ná fuil breithniú déanta acu ar obair na scol lena súile cinn féin, bheith ag súil go ngéillfidh an pobal dá dtuairimí faoi fiúntas na hoibre sin.
Méan-Oideachas.—Faoi láthair, tá faoi thuairim 3,550 oide ag teagasc sna Meán-scoileanna agus tá tuairim's 2,500 díobh sin i bhfostú lán-aimsire. Tuairim's 1,955 de na hoidí lán-aimsire, tá siad cláraithe go buan nó go sealadach, agus tá tuairim's 1,900 díobh sin ag fáil tuarastail páigh-bhreise. An t-iarmhar ná fuil cláraithe, tá cuid acu taobh amuigh den cuóta atá dlite do na scoileanna ina bhfuil siad, agus tá cuid eile ná fuil tuarastal páigh-bhreise iníoctha leo faoi láthair.
Comment on this
Tá, sílim. Tá an méid a bhaineas le meán-oideachas ann. Maidir leis na 1,900 oide a bhfuil páigh-bhreis dlite dóibh, íocann an scoil páirt dá dtuarastail agus íocann an Stát an pháirt eile. Íocann an scoil an bun-thuarastal—£200 ar a laghad le fear-oide agus £180 ar a laghad le banoide. Sé an Stát íocas an tuarastal páigh-bhreise. Do réir an tsean-scála do thuarastail fear-oidí, bhíodh 16 páigh-bhreiseanna ann, agus shroiseadh siad sin £210 de maximum; ach, anois, tá scálaí faoi leith ann d'fhir phósta agus scálaí faoi leith d'fhir gan phósadh. £410 an maximum d'fhear pósta agus £290 an maximum d'fhear singil. £120 an sean-maximum do mhnaoi, agus tá sé sin ardaithe go £260.
I dteannta na scálaí sin, íoctar £40 de pháigh-bhreis speisialta le hoidí a bhfuil céim ónórach Ollscoile acu. Tosnaíonn an pháigh-bhreis sin ag bun an scála anois; ach, roimhe seo ní híoctaí ach a leath nó go sroiseadh an t-oide an maximum. Táthar tar éis athruithe a dhéanamh ar bhása na páigh-bhreise speisialta ar son teagaise trí Ghaeilge agus, de thoradh na n-athrú sin, tá maximum na páigh-bhreise ardaithe ó £30 go £36. Roimhe seo, ní bhíodh páigh-bhreis iníoctha le hoidí nó go mbíodh siad cáilithe i gcóir deimhin-chláruithe tar éis trí bliana de sheirbhís teagaise a chríochnú. Anois ligtear dóibh dul ar scála na bpáigh-bhreis ar bheith cáilithe i gcóir cláruithe sealadaigh tar éis aon bhliain amháin seirbhíse.
In éineacht leis na scálaí nua sin, cinneadh go dtabharfaí liúntais chíosa d'fhear-oidí pósta agus do bhaintreacha a bhfuil clann ag brath orthu. Ach ní bhaineann na liúntais sin ach le hoidí ná fuil áit chónaithe curtha ar fáil dóibh ag na scoileanna. £10 an liúntas i gceantair tuaithe agus i sráidbhaile beaga; ach is aoirde ná sin é sna mór-bhailte, agus tá sé chómh hard le £40 i gCathair Bhaile Átha Cliath.
De thoradh na scálaí nua tuarastal d'Oidí Meán-scol, méadófar síntiúis na nOidí do Chiste na bPinsean, agus ba cheart go mbeadh suim na bhfáltas i gcothraime, beagnach, leis an gcaiteachas ar feadh roinnt bheag bhlian. Mar sin de, tá an Stát-deontas bliantúil á laghdú go dtí suim ná fuil inti ach comhartha.
Má tá líon dalta na mBun-scol dulta i laghad, tá síor-mhéadú, ós a chóir sin, ag teacht ar líon dalta na Meán-scol. I 1932, ní raibh ach 30,966 dalta ag freastal Meán-scol; ach, i mbliain a 1945, bhí 41,800 á bhfreastal—níos mó ná 800 de bhreis gach aith-bhliain. Maidir le 1946-47, tá 42,927 dalta ann—1,100 níos mó ná mar bhí anuraidh. Rud eile, ní raibh ach 306 Meán-scoileanna ann i mbliain a 1932, agus tá 393 ann anois.
Rinne mé trácht anuraidh ar an uireasa slí do bhí ar a lán Meán-scol. Ba bheag nárbh éigean stad ar fad d'obair foirgníochta in aimsir an chogaidh, agus níor bh'féidir na scoileanna d'fhairsingniú i gcóir an bhreislíon dalta do bhí ag teacht chucu. Mar sin de, tá an mhór-chuid díobh lán, agus tá roinnt díobh i bhfad ró-lán—sna cathracha agus sna mór-bhailte go háirithe. Ach, d'ainneoin ganntanas abhair foirgníochta, rinneadh réasúntacht fairsingithe ar roinnt scol thall agus i bhfus. In áiteanna áirithe, fuarthas foirgnimh bhreise dóibh agus in áiteanna eile, rinneadh na seanfhoirgnimh féin d'fhairsingiú.
Táthar ag leanúint go maith don obair shásúil a bhítheas a dhéanamh maidir le teagasc trí Ghaeilge. I nGaeilge is ea ghníthear an teagasc go léir i 102 scol, agus sí an Ghaeilge úsáidtear i gcóir páirt den teagasc i 116 scoileanna eile. An dá shaghas scol sin le chéile, is ar a gcuid rolla atá 59 per cent. d'iomlán na ndalta Méan-scol. Is eagal liom, áfach, ná fuil a chomhmhaith sin de dhul-ar-aghaidh á dhéanamh maidir le húsáid na Gaeilge mar ghnáth-theanga chomhrá taobh amuigh de na scoileanna; agus is léir go bhféadfaí a thuille a dhéanamh, le linn an Chúrsa Meán-Oideachais, chun a chur in áirithe go mbeadh na daltaí i ndon an Ghaeilge a labhairt go cruinn, líofa, réidh tar éis dóibh an scoil d'fhágaint. Mar shúil go bhfeabhsófaí an scéal táthar tar éis tosnú ar scéim nua faoina gcuirfear deontaisí speisialta ar fáil do scoileanna go sroisfidh na daltaí iontu ard-chaighdeán feabhais i labhairt na Gaeilge. Féadann na scoileanna go léir bheith páirteach sa scéim seo, óir tá a gcion féin de dheontaisí leagtha amach do gach saghas díobh. Táthar tar éis tosnú ar scrúdú na ndalta, agus áireofar na deontaisí do bheith in éifeacht ó Lá Lúnasa, 1946. Maidir le híocaíocht na ndeontas, tá £4,600 de sholáthar speisialta á dhéanamh di i bhfo-mhírcheann nua (A.4) den Mheastachán.
An bhliain seo thart, chuaidh 12,540 dalta faoin scrúdú i gcóir Teastas— 3,717 i gcóir an Ard-Teastais agus 8,823 i gcóir an Mheán-Teastais. Bhíteas sásta le caighdeán na bhfreagraí agus d'éirigh le breis agus 81 per cent. de na hiarrthóirí pas d'fháil. Ní eile, bhí a n-aghaidh ag tuairim's 550 iarrthóirí bhreise ar dheimhinchuspóirí .i. iontráil i gColáistí Oiliúna, nó Scoláireachta Ollscoile a ghnóthachtáil.
I scoil-bhliain a 1946-47, bhí scoláireachta i Meán-scoileanna aitheanta ag 1,693 dalta—uimhir is ionann agus 3.9 per cent. den iomlán i Meán-scoileanna, agus is beagnach ionann agus scoláireacht a bheith ag dalta as gach 25. Ina dteannta sin, féadtar trácht anseo ar 241 de lucht scoláireacht atá in áiteanna eile—cuid i Scoileanna Gairm-oideachais, cuid i gColáistí Oiliúna agus cuid i MeánBharraí sna Bun-scoileanna. Arna gcur sin leis an méid lucht scoláireacht atá sna Meán-scoileanna (agus gan baint do lucht na n-Ollscol ar chor ar bith) chífear go bhfuil 1,934 daltaí iar-bhunscoile ann ag a bhfuil scoláireachta in institiúidí aitheanta oideachais.
Ceárd-Oideachas.—Maidir leis na Cúrsaí Gairm-oideachais agus Ceárd-oideachais atá faoi stiúradh na gCoistí, is áthas liom a bheith le rá agam go raibh ní ba mhó daltaí ar na rollaí i 1945-46 ná mar bhí ariamh roimhe. I 1944-45 bhí 75,282 díobh ann (uimhir mhór) ach bhí 76,838 ann i 1945-46. Gidh ná fuil deireadh fós féin, leis na deacrachtaí taistil, agus mar sin, do tharla ann le linn na hÉigeandála, thainig méadú (ó 13,958 go 14,274) ar líon daltaí na gcúrsaí lán-aimsire lae, agus tháinig méadú (ó 4,701 go 4,889) ar líon daltaí na rang páirt-aimsire lae. Agus is mó ná sin féin an méadú do tháinig ar líon daltaí na gcúrsaí oíche —ó 35,025 go 36,917.
Scéal an-shuimiúil is ea an t-éileamh sa mbreis a bhí ar iontráil sna ranga sóisearacha Ceárd-oideachais de na cúrsaí lán-aimsire lae—go háirithe sna Contae-bhuirgí agus sna mór-bhailte. Ina lán de na háiteanna sin, b'éigean roinnt mhaith daoine do chur ar "liostaí feithimh". Ní hé amháin go bhfuil fiúdas tréineála gcúrsaí sin á thuiscint níos fearr do réir a chéile, ach is léir go bhfuil an tuairim ag éirí coiteann i mease fostaitheoirí gur riachtanach a leithéid de thréineáil a bheith fachta ag daoine óga roimh a bhfostú. I mBaile Átha Cliath, faoi Cháisc, bhí formhór mór na ndaltaí glactha isteach mar phrintísígh ag Córas Iompair Éireann agus ag comhluchta céimiúla eile.
I gcoitinne, tháinig breis daltaí chun na nGairm-scol tuaithe; ach níor mhéadaigh a líon mar mhéadaigh líon na ndaltaí i nGairm-scoileanna na mór-bhailte, óir bhí éileamh mór fós ar ógraí le haghaidh obair na talún. Laghdaigh an freastal go mór ins an Earrach nuair do bhí géar-ghá le hobair ar na feirmeacha agus ar na portaigh.
Sna contae-bhuirgí agus sna mór-bhailte, tá an t-éileamh ar Chúrsaí Tís chomh mór agus bhí sé ariamh. I gCathair Luimnighe (an áit is fearr ina n-éiríonn leis na cúrsaí seo) bhí 240 cailín ag freastal go buan. Rud do na chéillí dóibh, chinn a lán monarcha éadaí agus gnó-chómhluchta go dtabharfadh siad tosach fostuithe do chailíní a raibh freastal déanta acu ar an gcúrsa, agus níor bheag an cúnamh é sin chun líon na ndaltaí do mhéadú. Tá saghas drogaill roimh a leithéidí seo de chúrsaí i gceantair tuaithe go fóill, ach, mar sin féin, táthar ag tuiscint a dtábhacht i gcuid de na ceantair sin. I gContae na Gaillimhe, d'iontráil 276 cailín i Lá-chúrsaí Tís i Siosón 1945-46.
Táthar tar éis obair na scol-gharrdha d'eagrú go maith sna ceantair tuaithe. Tá soláthar maith glasraí agus tortha á bhfáil ó na garraithe sin ar feadh an tséasúir, agus fágann sé sin lón maith chun úsáide sna Ranga Tís. Sa mhór-chuid de na háiteanna seo, baintear triaileacha as modhanna éagsúla curadóireachta, agus cuireann feirmeoirí na gcomharsanacht suim sna triaileacha sin.
I mórán contae, táthar tar éis grúpaí díospóireachta do chur ar bun leis na feirmeoirí a mhealladh chun suim a chur in obair na nGairm-scol, agus tá ag éirí go maith leo sin—go mór-mhór i gCo. an Chláir, igCo. Chorcaighe, i gCo. Chill Dara, i gCo. Liathdroma, i gCo. Luimnighe, i gCo. Lughbhaidh agus i gCo. Shligigh. Cloiseann na grúpaí seo léachtaí luachmhara agus ina theannta sin, cuireann siad féin ar bun comórtais treafa, taispeántais talmhaíochta, agus mar sin.
Do réir mar d'iarr an tAire Talmhaíochta, leanadh do thástáil síolta sna Gairm-scoileanna tuaithe. Tástáileadh 7,963 somplaí sa tSiosón roimh ré, ach, ó tharla gur ceannaíodh breis síolta ó dhíoltóirí iontaofa i 1945/46, níor tástáileadh ach 5,026 samplaí sa tsiosón sin. Mar sin féin, ba léir go raibh gá leis an tástáil, óir níor shrois cuid de na samplaí an caighdeán is ísle ar bith de ghiniúin. Dá thoradh sin, sábháileadh na feirmeoirí ar chur síolta nár bh'féidir dóibh bheith réasúnta torthúil féin.
Tá foráis tábhachtacha tar éis teacht ar Cheárd-oideachas sna Contaebhuirgí. In Ard-scoil na Tráchtála, Rath Maonas, Baile Átha Cliath, tosnaíodh ar chúrsaí speisialta teagaisc i dtaobh deisiúchán siopaí bialóin agus siopaí éadaí agus a gcuid fuinneog, agus tháinig chun na gcúrsaí sin suas le 200 daltaí do bhí fostaithe sna saghsanna úd siopaí roimh ré. Sa scoil chéanna tugadh seacht léachtaí i dtaobh stiúradh foirne agus, ag gach léacht díobh sin, bhí tuairim's 150 daoine fásta, idir stiúrthóirí, bainisteoirí, cinn foirne agus cúntóirí. I gCorcaigh, de thoradh comhair idir na húdaráis ollscoile agus an Coiste Gairm-oideachais, tosnaíodh, sa Scoil Tráchtála, ar chúrsa teagaisc i gcóir Ard-teastas Ollscoile i dTráchtáil. I bPort Láirge, bunaíodh rang speisialta in ard-chúntasaíocht do dhaltaí atá ag ullmhú chun cáilíochta sa gcúntasaíocht a ghnóthachtáil.
Bunaíodh trí chúrsa chun comhoibriú le Cumann Cuardaigh na hÉireann chun foirne tréineáilte tithe ósta a chur ar fáil. I gColáiste Tís Mhuire, Baile Átha Cliath bhí cúrsa do chócairí tithe ósta agus, dá thoradh sin, ghnóthaigh 17 ndaltaí na teastais atá riachtanach. Roimh dheireadh an tsiosóin féin, bhí 14 díobh fostaithe. Coiste Gairm-oideachais Chontae Loch gCarman do chuir an dara cúrsa ar bun—cúrsa tréineála do chailíní cistineach agus do bhan-fhreastalaithe, agus mar sin. Fuarthas úsáid Courtown House ón gCumann Cuardaigh mar áras don chúrsa, agus tháinig 39 gcailíní chuige. Den mhéid do chríochnaigh an cúrsa, ní raibh aon chailín ná fuair tairiscint d'fhostú i dteachósta faoi'n mBórd Cuardaigh. Coiste Gairm-oideachais Chontae Shligigh do bhunaigh an tríú cúrsa—ceann den tsaghas chéanna do bhí i gCourtown House. Fuarthas fostú do gach cailín den 12 do rinne é sin d'fhreastal.
I rith an tseisiúin, bhí forás maith ag teacht ar Scéimeanna Printíseachta. I mBaile Átha Cliath, bunaíodh cúrsaí do phrintísigh i gclódóireacht, i mbáicéireacht, i ngruaig-dheisiúchán, i ndéantóireacht bróg, i ndéantóireacht troscáin, i ndéantóireacht uaireadóir, i dtáilliúireacht, i bhfoirgníocht agus i gcócaireacht tithe Ósta. I nGaillimh, leanadh don chúrsa tréineála i gcóir daltaí sa loingeas tráchtála, agus leanadh, mar an gcéanna, don chúrsa innealtóireachta i gCorcaigh.
Ag an tríú scrúdú chun printísigh a chlárú faoi Chumann Éireannach na dTrádádaí Gluaisteán, Teoranta, do cáilíodh 270. Tá socruithe déanta ina lán áiteanna chun teagasc páirt-aimsire lae, sna Gairm-scoileanna áitiúla, a chur ar fáil do na printísigh seo, agus tá na fostaitheoirí ag tabhairt saoirse ón obair do na printísigh chun go bhfreastalóidh siad na ranga—dhá uair an chluig in áiteanna, agus oiread le sé huaire in áiteanna eile. Chun cabhrú leis na scoileanna, chuir an Roinn amach meamran speisialta ina raibh cnámh-chlár den chúrsa d'oirfeadh do na printísigh agus, ina theannta sin, mion-ealos i dtaobh an mhinimum de threallamh ba riachtanach.
I limisteár Bhaile Átha Cliath, faoi láthair, tá printísigh Chórais Iompair Éireann ag fáil teagaisc pháirt-aimsire i gCeárd-Scoileanna Shráid Bholton, aon lá amháin gach seachtain. Tá cúrsaí faoi leith á gcur ar fáil i gcóir (a) printísigh innealtóireachta meiceannaí, (b) printísigh i gceardaíocht gluaisteán, (c) printísigh i ndéantóireacht cóistí agus (d) printísigh i bpéinteoireacht agus i luaidheadóireacht. Tá cúrsaí de na saghsanna céanna sin ar bun i gCorcaigh agus i Luimhnigh, freisin.
Ar achaint Chomhlucht Siúicre Éireann, tugadh dian-chúrsaí gearra do phrintísigh siúicre-bhiatais sna Gairm-scoileanna i gCeatharlach agus i nDúrlas, le linn samhradh 1946.
An Siosón seo thart, rinneadh aithbheochaint mhaith ar Scéim na Scoláireacht Ceirde tar éis í bheith ligthe ar lár in aimsir na hÉigeandála. Tairgeadh scoláireachta i gcúrsa speisialta tréineála i gcóir fir óga a raibh trí bliana, ar a laghad, críochnaithe acu i mbun Gabhnachta. Cuireadh isteach 83 iarratas ar na scoláireachta, gidh ná raibh ar fáil ach 16 díobh. Bhí an comórtas an-ghéar; bhí scrúdú oibre ann ag deireadh an chúrsa agus chruthaigh an scrúdú sin go raibh saothar luachmhar déanta.
Rinneadh dea-obair arís sa chúrsa oblagáideach i gCoreaigh mar a raibh 952 dalta ag freastal na gcúrsaí speisialta, agus i Luimnigh, mar a raibh 588 á bhfreastal. Tá cúrsaí oblagáideacha i bhfeidhm i bPort Láirge, freisin, ó bhí Mí Eanáir ann, agus tá 185 daltaí ar na rollaí faoi láthair. Is maith bheith i ndon a innsint go bhfuil na fostaitheoirí agus na ceárd-chumainn ag comh-chabrú leis na cúrsaí seo sa gcaoi chéanna inar chomh-chabhraigh siad i gCorcaigh agus i Luimnigh.
Do réir tuairiscí na gcigirí, tá teagasc na Gaeilge ag dul ar aghaidh go fónta sna scoileanna lán-aimsire lae. Tá teagasc trí Ghaeilge ag leathnú go mall taobh amuigh den Ghaeltacht. I gCorcaigh, i Luimnigh, i Mhuigheo agus i gcontaethe eile, tá a lan scoileanna ina ndéantar roinnt mhór den obair trí Ghaeilge. In áiteanna eile, ghníthear ranga faoi leith do dhaltaí a bhfuil eolas maith ar an nGaeilge acu, agus sí an Ghaeilge úsáidtear chun abhar amháin, ar a ladghad, do theagasc dóibh sin. Fuarthas tuairiscí ó mhórán ceantar gur mhéadaigh líon daltaí na rang oíche go mhaith. Ar a dtosach sin tá ceantar Chorcaighe, mar a raibh 2,700 ar na rollaí. Ach bhí níos mó ná 1,000 ar na rollaí i nGaillimh, agus bhí tuairim's an uimhir chéanna orthu i gCill Chainnigh agus i Luimnigh, freisin. An freastal is buaine dá ndéantar ar na ranga, séard a ghníthear é sna scoileanna ina mbíonn comh-cheangal idir obair na rang agus comh-chaidrímh Ghaeilge. Tá obair fhónta á dheanamh sa gcaoi sin, sna scoileanna ina bhfuil Cumainn Ghaelacha. I gCo. Chorcaighe agus i gCo. Dhún na nGall, tháinig uimhir mhaith daltaí chun cúrsaí samhraidh den tsaghas a bhí i nGaillimh le roinnt bhlian—cúrsaí i nGaelige maraon le hobair phraiticiúil.
I siosón 1945-46, bhí éileamh thar barr ag fostaitheoirí ar dhaltaí na gcúrsa lán-aimsire lae. Ina lán áiteanna bhí oiread de na daltaí fostaithe faoi Cháisc agus gurb éigean scor, an uair sin, de ranga na dara bliana agus de ranga na tríú bliana sna cúrsaí sóisearacha. Fostaíodh tuairim's 600 de na daltaí bhí ar scoileanna Bhaile Átha Cliath: fostaíodh 260 i gCorcaigh; fostaíodh breis agus 160 i Luimnigh; fostaíodh breis agus 80 i bPort Láirge; fostaiodh breis agus 50 i nGaillimh; fostaíodh 60 i mBrí Cualann agus 45 i dTráigh Lí.
Mar an gcéanna sin, bhí éileamh mór ag fostaitheoirí ar dhaltaí na gContae-scéim, go háirithe i gContae an Chláir, i gContae Chiarraighe, i gContae Liathdroma, i gContae Mhuineacháin, i gContae na Gaillimhe, i gContae na hlar-Mhidhe agus i gContae Shligigh. Fostaíodh 137 i gContae na hIar-Mhidhe agus, gidh gurb é Contae Liathdroma is ísle ar an liosta sin, fostaíodh 45 de na daltaí ann.
Thríd agus thríd, is léir, dar liom, go bhféadfar bheith sásta leis an obair a rinneadh sna Gairm-scoileanna anuraidh. Bhí méadú réasúnta ar an bhfreastal; cuireadh breis cúrsaí úsáideacha ar fáil, agus bhí sé de thoradh ar na cúrsaí go bhfuarthas fostaíocht fiúntach d'uimhir sa bhreis de na daltaí.
Eolaíocht agus Ealaín.—Tá £6,955 de mhór-ítaim breis-chaiteachais sa Mheastachán seo agus tá sé sin ann mar gheall ar athchóirú liúntaisí tuarastail na Stát-sheirbhíseach i gcoitinne agus mar gheall ar líonadh folúntais sna foirne. Tá £2,490 de mhéadú sa tsoláthar chun scannáin a tháirgeadh i leith Roinne Rialtais; sé sin an costas atá measta do tháirgeadh scannáin i dtaobh prátaí a bhfuiltear lena dhéanamh i leith na Roinne Talmhaíochta.
An deontas-i-gcabhair don Leabharlainn Náisiúnta chun leabhra do cheannach, tá méadú eile á dhéanamh air i mbliana. Measadh é do bheith indéanta, toisc leabhra agus tréimhseacháin do bheith roinnt mhaith níos costasaí ná mar bhíodh siad, agus toisc tuilleadh mór díobh a bheith ar fáil ó stad an cogadh. Ina theannta sin, tá a lán cnuasach láimhscríbhní bhaineas leis an tír seo á gcur ar an margadh le gairid, agus níor mhór don náisiún seilbh d'fháil ar a leithéidí.
Tá £2,000 de sholáthar á dhéanamh i mbliana arís i gcóir chostas na hoibre bhaineas le suirbhéireacht agus le macsamhlú na stair-scríbhne Éireannach atá i dtíortha thar lear. Rinneadh cuardach sa British Museum, sa Bodleian Library agus i Simancas. Tá an tsuirbhéireacht agus an micróscannánú ag dul ar aghaidh i Simancas faoi láthair.
Laghdaíodh an Meastachán i gcóir foilseacháin i nGaeilge, agus níl de chúis leis sin ach an chaoi ina bhfuil cúrsaí clódóireachta. Tá moill agus bac á gcur ar obair an Ghúim, toisc an neafhonn atá ar chlódóirí dul i mbun nuaoibre nó críoch a chur ar obair atá glactha ar láimh acu.
Tá roinnt mhaith oibre déanta maidir le Stair na Mór-ghorta. Tugadh £500 de pháirt-íocaíocht do Choiste na Staireolaíochtai mbliain airgeadais a 1946-47, agus tá an £1,000 d'iarrmhar á hath-bhótáil sna Meastacháin seo.
In aimsir na hÉigeandála, baineadh £600 sa mbliain den deontas-i-gcabhair do bhíodh á fháil ag an gCoimisiún Béal-oidis; ach tá deireadh leis an "ngearradh" sin agus tá an £4,250 de lán-deontas i bhfeidhm ó bhí an lú Aibreán, 1946 ann. Ar achainí d'fháil ón gCoimisiún, soláthríodh £2,000 eile, trí Bhreis-Mheastachán, i mbliain airgeadais a 1946-47, chun a chur i gcumas an Choimisiúin dul in mbun cnuasachta béal-oidis in Albain, chun a thuilleadh cnuasairí páirt-aimsire chur ag obair sa tír seo, agus chun méadú a dhéanamh ar liúntaisí na foirne. Tá cúigear cnuasaire lán-aimsire ag obair sa tír seo agus duine amháin in Albain. Tá tuairim's 35 per cent. d'ardú déanta ar thuarastail na foirme in gach cás. £6,250 an lán-deontas a fuair an Coimisiún do bhliain a 1946-47, agus tá an tsuim chéanna á sholáthar sna Meastacháin seo.
£8,000 de dheontas-i-gcabhair a tugadh do Chomh-dháil Náisiúnta na Gaeilge anuraidh, agus tá an tsuim chéanna á soláthar i mbliana. Séard do bunaíodh an Chomh-dháil chun eagrú agus aonú a dhéanamh ar shaothar na gcumann éagsúil ar cúram dóibh an Ghaeilge d'aith-bheochaint. Tá timirí faoi pháigh ag an gComhdháil, agus tá a limistéar féin leagtha amach do gach timire. Féachann na timirí le spiorad agus dúthracht a mhúscailt i ngach ceantar faoi seach, agus féachann siad le lán-chomhar d'eagrú idir na cumainn atá ag obair ar son na Gaeilge.
D'éirigh go geal leis an gCeol-scoil samhraidh do tionscnadh i mBaile Átha Cliath, i Mí Lúnasa seo thart. Na daoine do chuaidh chuici, b'é a mbarúil i gcoitinne go mba mhaith do b'fhiú leanúint do na cúrsaí mar gheall ar a socharacht do cheol na tíre agus don chaighdeán a mbeadh a lucht éisteachta ag súil leis. Maidir le toghadh na n-Ollún agus le gnáthriarachán na Scoile, beidh treoir le fáil agam ó Choiste Comhairle ar a bhfuil ceoltóirí Éireannacha atá faoi ard-cháil.
Ó bhliain a 1934, bhíodh na Deontaisí Taighdeacháin do Mhic Léinn á riaradh ag an gComhairle Thaighde Thionscail, faoi'n Aire Tionnscail agus Tráchtála; agus, le linn sin do bheith amhlaidh, ba sa Bhóta do Thionnscal agus Tráchtáil go ghníthí soláthar i gcóir na ndeontaisí sin. Má tá, cuireadh deireadh leis an gComhairle i 1946, agus tionscnadh an Institiúid Taighde agus Caidgheán Tionscail, agus níor tugadh aon fheidhmiú don Institiúid maidir le deontaisí ar son taighdeacháin glan - eolaíochta. Meastar, áfach, go mba chóir a leithéidí de dheontaisí a bheith ar fáil, agus tá cúram a riartha á ghlacadh ar láimh ag an Aire Oideachais.
Scoileanna Ceartúcháin agus Scoileanna Saothair.—Sna Scoileanna Ceartúcháin, an bhliain seo thart, bhí 217 daoine óga faoi choimeád—182 buachaillí agus 35 cailíní. Tá dhá thaobhfhoirgneamh á gcur le Scoil an Daingin faoi láthair. Maidir leis na Scoileanna Ceartúcháin do Chailíní, táthar ag smaoineadh ar an dlí-thiúntacht d'fheabhsú ionas go mbeidh aithint le fáil ag saghas nua scoile, agus táthar ag súil, dá bharr sin, go mbeidh Scoil Chill Mochuda i ndon a cuid oibre do leathnú.
Tá fuighleach slí sna Scoileanna Saothair do chailíní—slí do 1,000 nó mar sin níos mó ná an uimhir atá iontu faoi láthair. Maidir leis an méid slí atá sna scoileanna saothair do bhuachaillí, níl an scéal chómh dona agus bhí sé, arbhú anuraidh, cé's moite de cheantar Bhaile Átha Cliath. Ach, le tamall thart, b'éigean a lán buachaillí as an gceantar sin a chur chun scoileanna i bhfad ó bhaile. Tá Bráithre Críostúla na hÉireann tar éis toiliú le scoil do bhuachaillí sinsearacha do bhunú i gcomharsanacht Bhaile Atha Cliath, agus beidh slí do thuairim's 250 buachaill inti sin. Tá talamh agus foirgnimh fachta lena haghaidh, agus tá an t-oiriúnú agus an t-athchóiriú á ndéanamh faoi láthair. Ach beidh a thuilleadh foirgneamh ag teastáil leis an scoil sin a dhéanamh sáthach mór, agus tá an Stát tar éis £40,000 .i. leath an chostais mheasta, do chur ar fáil. Bhótáileadh £9,774 den méid sin i Meastachán Breise do 1946-47, agus tá an £30,226 d'iarmhar á sholáthar sna Meastacháin seo.
I mbliain a 1946, tugadh seal saoirse sa mbaile do 40 per cent. (2,400 nó mar sin) de na adoine óga do bhí faoi choimeád i scoileanna saothair. Is eol don Roinn go bhfuil comh-chúnamh san obair sin á thabhairt uathu ag bainisteoirí na scol, agus is léir go ndeontar an tsaoirse i ngach cás dá n-oireann sí.
Ón lú Deireadh Fómhair, 1946, cuireadh deontaisí ceann-tsraithe, do réir 1/- sa tseachtain, i gcóir foirgníochta agus trealaimh ar fáil do gach scoil a dhéanfadh an t-iarratas atá riachtanach. Séard atá na deontaisí sin á soláthar mar shíntiúis i gcóir costas foirgníochta agus scoil-fheabhsuithe agus chun trealamh d'fháil le haghaidh gairm-thréineála. Gach bliain, bíonn a n-íocaíocht do réir uimhir na bpáistí agus na nóg-choirtheach bhíos faoi choimeád, an 31ú de Mhí na Nollag. Ní hamhlaidh ghníthear iad chun a leithéidí siúd de chostais d'íoc go hiomlán; de ghnáth, tiocfaidh ar bhainisteoirí na scol an tríú cuid, ar a laghad, den chostas d'íoc. I Mí an Mhárta, 1947, is ea rinneadh an chéad deonadh den tsaghas sin, agus ní raibh ach ceithre scoileanna nár iarr bheith páirteach ann.
Sa ghearr-ráiteas seo atá déanta agam, d'fhéach mé le cuntas réasúnta leathan a thabhairt uaim i dtaobh na hoibre do rinneadh, an bhliain seo thart, sna brainsí éagsúla atá faoi riarachán ag an Roinn Oideachais. Níl aon rud sár-iontach sa chuntas, agus tá fhios agam go gcloisfidh mé roinnt achasán, toisc ná dúirt mé go bhfuiltear ag brath dul i mbun mór-athruithe agus mór fheabhsuithe den tsaghas atá ar cois i dtíortha atá sa chomharsanacht againn. Ach ní cóir a dhearmad nach ionann cás dúinne agus do na tíortha a dtráchtfar liom ar a n-éisiompláir. Ní hé amháin nár leig an léirchogadh do na tíortha sin dul ar aghaidh mar ba cheart i gcúrsaí oideachais, ach chuir sé cuid mhaith dá gcóras oideachais as alt a chéile. Sa tréimhse sin, gannaíodh na foirne teagaise; chuir scéimeanna imirce isteach ar chúrsaí oideachais na ndaltaí scoile, agus bhí anró an chogaidh ina chúis le dochar intinne agus dochar coirp a bhfuil na húdaráis ag iarraidh bheith ag fáil leigheasraí dóibh anois. Ach, de dheonú Dé, níor fhuiling an tír seo aon dí-eagrú den tsaghas sin. Ar feadh aimsir an chogaidh, óna thús go dtí n-a dheireadh, bhíomar saor ó aon ní do chuirfeadh bac ar ár scéimeanna oideachais. Níor gannaíodh ár bhfoirne teagaise, agus bhí ár n-ógraí i ndon fanúint sa bhaile agus leanúint dá n-oideachas in aice an bhaile. Mura bhfuil nua-scéimeanna móra oideachais againn, tá fáth le sin, agus is é an fáth é ná fuil siad de dhíth orainn; thug Dia dhúinn teacht saor ón gcur-tríchéile do rinneadh ar na tíortha eile úd.
Ina theannta sin go léir, ba cheart dúinn smaoineadh ar na fíor-shochair atá inár gcóras oideachais féin. Tá an córas sin bunaithe ar dhúshraith nach dóigh liom a leithéid a bheith faoi chóras ar bith eile oideachais dá bhfuil sa domhan faoi láthair. Tá sé bunaithe go daingean ar an bprionsabal gur creideamh do Dhia an bhonnchloch nach foláir bheith faoi gach dea-chóras oideachais. I gcúrsaí scolaíochta sa tír seo, tá comhar agus comhardadh idir na húdaráis Stáit agus na húdaráis Eaglaise—rud nár bhféidir d'aon chóras oideachais a phríomhdhualgas a chomhlíonadh ina éagmais. Agus, maidir leis an scéal a bheith ar a mhalairt de chaoi, tá mé cinnte ná taithneódh sé sin leis an té is mó spéis i gcórais nua.
Cé's moite den bhun-chuspóir cheart a bheith ag an gcóras oideachais níl aoinní chomh riachtanach le hoidí oiriúnacha. Féadfaí a dhearbhú de ghnáth go mbeidh an scoil mar atá an t-oide; agus, ar an abhar sin, ní féidir obair na scol a cháineadh gan roinnt mhaith den cháineadh do theacht ar an oide. An modh ina n-ullmhaítear agus an modh ina dtréineáiltear múinteoirí na tire seo, measaim féin iad a bheith iomlán, oiriúnach. Ní glactar, i gcóir tréineála, le habhair múinteoirí gan lán-chúrsa na Meán-scol a bheith curtha díobh acu go sásúil. Agus, tar a éis sin, is éigean dóibh bheith, ar feadh dhá bhlian, i gColáiste Oiliúna, mar a ndéanann siad a thuilleadh de staidéar acadúil maraon le leathanchúrsa i dteoiricí oideachais agus i gcleachtadh na múinteoireachta. Maidir leis na múinteoirí Meán-scol, ní féidir dóibh aithint oifigiúil go n-a sochair d'fháil nó go gnóthaí siad Céim Oll-scoile agus an tÁrd - teastas Oideachais, nó a comh-mhaith sin de cháilíocht. Agus tá an caighdeán i gcóir aithinte chomh hard céana i gcás na múinteoirí gairm-scol.
Sa méid bhaineas le cigireacht agus le breithniú obair na scol, níl aoinne ina mbun ach daoine a bhí seal ina múinteoirí. Go fiú riarachán an chórais, tá an mhór-chuid de idir lámha ag ardfheadhmannaigh do fuair roinnt mhaith taithí ar mhúinteoireacht agus ar chigireacht. An córas atá faoi'n bhreathnú agus faoi'n riaradh atá luaite agam, agus atá bunaithe go daingean ar an tréineáil creidimh agus móráltachta is gá bheith mar chroí ag fíor-oideachas, ní féidir gurb airidh air an cáineadh atá ina fhaisiún, faoi láthair, ag daoine labhras go mí-chruinn agus go mí-chúramach.
Comment on this
Ní dóigh liom go bhfuil mórán eolais fachta againn tar éis an ráitis a thug an tAire dúinn i dtaobh cursaí oideachais sa tír seo. Tá a lán figúirí agus a lán tuairimí beaga againn, ach maidir leis na rudaí atá ag déanamh buaidhrimh do na daoine go léir, sé sin, córas oideachais na tíre agus gach rud a bhaineann leis, níl níos mó eolais againn tar éis an ráitis ná mar bhí againn nuair a thosnaigh an tAire.
Comment on this
Níor mhaith liom cur isteach ar an dTeachta ach ar feadh nóiméid. I presume we are taking all these Votes together, as usual.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon had some question to raise about the gaps in the Minister's statement, with regard to the number of Estimates in front of us.
Comment on this
We have the Vote for the Office of the Minister, the Votes for Primary Education, Secondary Education, Technical Instruction, Science and Art, Reformatory Schools and the National Gallery. It might be well to leave the Estimate for the Institute for Advanced Studies as a Vote to be discussed separately.
Comment on this
I disagree. It has been the practice to take the whole group of Votes together. I do not know why we should depart from that and have a second debate. Surely the Deputies who want to speak on a particular Vote can do so in the general discussion?
Comment on this
Níl morán eolais fachta againn ar an t-árd cheist ar fad. Something did happen at Question Time which shows that, by pounding away at a particular situation, a little more knowledge and understanding can be brought to bear on certain questions. It also disclosed how much there was to be watched and attended to by Deputies and by those in charge of schools and by the parents whose children are going to school if the teachers, whose importance the Minister says is so great, are to get any chance at all. We were told at Question Time that, after certain consideration, the Minister has now put the school in Baile Chiaragáin back into the number of schools in the Fíor-Ghaeltacht. The history of the fight that had to be made to find out exactly what the Department knew about the district of Baile Chiaragáin and the conditions of Irish in that district and the condition of things in the school and on what principle the Department is working, indicates a very extraordinary state of affairs. It is interesting and welcome that Baile Chiaragáin is to go back on the list of Fíor-Ghaeltacht schools, but it is twice as interesting and twice as necessary that we should examine what happened there and what happened in other districts and generally what the approach of the Department is to the position of the Irish language in the Irish-speaking districts on the one hand and the work of the schools on the other hand. When the Minister was speaking last year—I quote from column 176 of the 13th May, 1947 where it is requoted—he said:—
"Ní féidir linn an Ghaedhilg do shlánú gan sár-iarracht do dhéanamh i gcinnibh Béarla agus uaireanta i gcoinnibh na náduire dhaonna féin, i dtreó go mairfeadh an teanga. Ní féidir cogadh mí-chuíbheasach teangan den tsórt san do choimeád ar suíl gan íbirt, agus gan iarrachtaí diana, buan-tseasmhachta—agus níl a mhalairt sin de rogha againn muna mian linn leigint don Ghaedhilg bás d'fháil mar theangain labhartha."
The official translation presented to us states:—
"We cannot save Irish without waging a most intense war against English and against human nature itself for the life of the language. Such a desperate linguistic war cannot be carried on without sacrifice and persistent effort and struggle, but we have no choice unless we intend to let Irish die as a living language."
As part of the work, and part of the sacrifices that people are prepared to make in helping to keep Irish a living language, certain provisions are made to give extra grants to teachers teaching in the Fíor-Ghaeltacht schools, and certain facilities are given to the pupils who attend the Fíor-Ghaeltacht schools and come from Irish-speaking homes, to enter the training colleges. Other facilities are also available for them, and certain monetary grants are given to the parents. The regulation that governs that is regulation 121 (1), which reads:—
"Where the Minister is satisfied that a school is situate in a district where Irish is generally spoken as the language of the homes, and where a considerable proportion of the children going to school for the first time know Irish only or know Irish better than English, a special grant on the basis indicated below may be made for the school year to members of the teaching staff of schools specially approved for the purpose of this grant, in which the teachers are competent to give instruction entirely through the medium of Irish and where instruction in the various subjects of the school programme (other than English) is so given."
For a number of years since a definition was given for the purposes of the Department of Education, of districts as Fíor-Ghaeltacht districts, Baile Chiaragáin was a Fíor-Ghaeltacht school until certain action was taken last year. Now, Baile Chiaragáin is one of those districts that you slip into as you pass along the road from Ballybofey to Glenties. When you turn the corner at Alt-na-Péiste on the lefthand side you find yourself in one of those glens which lose themselves among the mountains, the kind of place that, here and there throughout the country, has been responsible for keeping Irish in the position in which it is even in the political arena, because it was not learning Irish in school that made people go out and save the Irish language; it was the fact that they knew the Irish-speaking people and the Irish-speaking districts where the language was a need for human communication between one person to another since the time, and long before the time, of St. Patrick.
It was in one of these spots that you found yourself when you turned the corner. You found yourself in a place where you realised you had the peace of God, and you nearly went down on your knees to thank God for the kind of civilisation that you found there, and for the glorious language in which the people there could communicate to others their characters, their feelings and their thoughts. In such a district as that there is a small school with two teachers in it. It serves a district in which there are 64 houses but only from 21 of those houses in that district are there children coming to school. You have there, as I say, a small two-teacher school. What kind of work are they doing? In 1942, the report on the principal teacher said:—
"Oide an-dílis Gaedhealach 'seadh í. Do-bheir sí togha oiliúnta dá cuid daltaí agus tá a rian san go láidir ortha. Táid an-aibidh béasach Gaedhealach."
Comment on this
The number of houses from which there are children going to school is 21. The number of these in which Irish is the home language is 16. These facts are vouched for by the manager of the school, by the curate there and by the teachers. It is clear from the figures and from the history of the place that we have in that cul-de-sac in the mountains one of these Irish-speaking districts where Irish is maintained as the home language and where Irish can be maintained if there is any sincerity at all in our attempt to do it. It is on a district such as Baile Chiaragáin that we have the kind of outrage that was committed there, when in June of last year the Minister simply said: "This school goes off the Fíor-Ghaeltacht list." Because of the fight that was made in the Baile Chiaragáin district the situation has been exposed, but over a number of years the same thing has happened elsewhere. It has happened in Bun a' Choire School in Achill, County Mayo. It has happened in respect of An Gleann, Ballinskelligs, County Kerry; in respect of Lóthar An Cuirreán, County Kerry; in respect of the Naomh Eoin School (Caisleach), near Killarney, County Kerry, and in respect of Duibhinn in the Glenties. When it transpired, as a result of happenings at Baile Chiaragáin, that this was happening elsewhere, naturally those interested in the language want to know what exactly is happening.
I put down questions to every single Department to ask what districts were regarded for the purposes of each of these Departments as the Irish-speaking districts and the answers which were given me in November last showed that the Departments to-day are working on the reports of the Gaeltacht Commission of 1926, and that beyond what advantages had been made to the Irish-speaking areas as delineated in that report, what additions had been added in Meath where transferences had taken place, there had been no review of the Irish-speaking districts since 1926. I then asked the various Departments whether they had received any report from the Department of Education that there were districts in the country where Irish was fading away and none of them had received any reports. The Minister had not made any reports. In so far as any action that we have seen at all arising out of the fact that schools have been taken off the Fíor-Ghaeltacht list, no Department in the State has in any way the vernacular position of the language under review. The Department of Education has not, because that Department has struck six or eight schools off the list of Fíor-Ghaeltacht schools within the last four or five years without asking a single question as to what is happening in these areas or without investigating whether the conditions laid down for defining a district as Irish-speaking exist at all.
I am rather inclined to the view that as so many districts have taken this decision of the Department of Education lying down there may be something in the Minister's argument that these are not Irish-speaking districts. But we have had a case in Donegal where, when the fight was made against the injustice, and when the irregular action of the Department in wiping a school off the Fíor-Ghaeltacht list although it complied with the regulations was exposed, the Minister had to admit that he was wrong or at any rate the Minister had to change the decision. What has happened in regard to these schools must certainly destroy any confidence that those who are interested in the language and who are depending upon the Department of Education to watch the situation, to foster the situation and to help the situation may have had. I do not think anything more brutal could have taken place than the action that was taken by the Department of Education in relation to the Baile Chiaragáin School because what did it do? Without investigating the situation but merely looking at the figures in its headquarters office here in Dublin as to the number of children attending the school and the number of children who are receiving the £2 grant, it struck the school off the list. What was the result? It has deprived a teacher, doing glorious work under very poor conditions and in a very out-of-the-way part of the world where there was nothing to sustain her interest except the glorious work she must feel she is doing in keeping the light of education alive through the medium of Irish in that valley in Donegal, of 10 per cent. of her salary. The children who go to that school are deprived of the special advantages that are given to children in the Fior-Ghaeltacht area. Father Mullen in his case which he submitted generally and which he sent to a certain number of Deputies said that to-day its pupils are to be found in the Civil Service, in the Defence Forces, in preparatory colleges, in training colleges, in All Hallows, in Maynooth College, in convents and in monasteries. This small Irish-speaking school was able to provide men and women of the calibre of whom that can be said and the present pupils have been injured in their chance of an economic outlet of a particular kind from these districts by the Minister's action. It emphasises very much the hopelessness of expecting the Department of Education to look at the Irish-speaking districts in the way they should be looked at. It does even more than that. It shows that there is a shocking weakness on the administrative side. However, Baile Chiaragáin has struck a blow for realities in these matters and if the Minister, as he answered me to-day, says that he may have to change the nature of the regulations that will define what a purely Irish-speaking district is then, when he is doing that, it behoves him and the Government generally to look realistically at the Irish-speaking districts to see exactly where they are and what they are and what is being done for them, educationally and otherwise.
When the Minister speaks of the fight against human nature that he and they expect other people to make in order to save the language we may expect that Government Departments will exert themselves a little bit to look frankly at the facts to see if there are weaknesses in the situation and, if so, how they should be remedied. It is nothing but the gravest possible scandal that a Department that holds itself out and that is looked to as the Department which is to preserve the Irish language would, in the case of a school like Baile Chiaragáin, strike it off the list and then leave it there without any investigation of the circumstances or the conditions until somebody outside has to come along and fight in the way in which some of the local people have carried on their fight. There may be weaknesses in regard to the language in Baile Chiaragáin. That is all the more reason why the Department should be more energetic in seeing what the situation is and in seeing what help can be given rather than rely on threats or the withdrawal of assistance. The Minister comes here again this year and what kind of year is it?
We had the President of the Association of Secondary Teachers, at Easter, giving his presidential address to his colleagues and some of his remarks run like this:—
"I think that a grave defect in the syllabus for secondary schools issued by the Department of Education is the absence of any instructions to teachers or managers, or of any other official attempt, to ensure that pupils are made aware of the high purpose and value of education, are given a bird's eye view of the general scope and aim of their courses, and an understanding of the way in which various subjects dovetail into or supplement one another so as to build up a complete pattern in their minds. A student is not required to be made aware of any purpose in his educational course other than the one usually assumed by him—that he has to get through it, to put in his time till he reaches a certain age or passes a particular examination."
The President of the Association of Secondary School Teachers, as part of his presidential address, opens with the question:—
"What is secondary education for? Why will not somebody in the Department of Education tell us what it is?"
That is one of the things that mark the kind of a year we are in.
The primary school teachers issue a plan for education and, on page 15 of the plan which they have just published, we read this:—
"There must be a reform of our educational system if we are to survive as a nation with a distinctive culture."
They give five or six reasons leading up to that to show why, with the defects there are in our present system, there must be a reform. The third reason they give is:—
"Our education system lacks continuity and co-ordination and is really a collection of systems— primary, secondary, vocational, university — differently administered and financed, and with different aims and outlooks. The lack of unity and integration results in loss of efficiency, and the divergence of aim and outlook breeds unhealthy class distinctions. Furthermore, the administration and direction of educational policy is largely in the hands of people without practical contact with education or with the social and economic problems of the community."
Whatever comments the Minister or anybody else might like to make on the statements of the President of the Association of Secondary Teachers, on the one hand, or on the report of the primary school teachers, these statements represent an attitude of mind on their part which we cannot afford to ignore; at any rate, the parents whose children are being educated and those who look at the social and economic life of the country and who realise what education means for the improvement and betterment of them cannot ignore the fact that teachers are speaking like that. The Minister for Education does. Beyond a few remarks to show that it is wrong to say that education is bad here and that there are difficulties about increasing the school age from 15 to 16, he completely ignores the things that are moving in the minds of teachers and that he must know are moving very much in the minds of parents. As we have said for several years now, there is nothing disturbing the minds of parents throughout the country or the minds of people in business or in industry more than the feeling that there is something seriously wrong with our education.
It is imperative that these matters should be faced up to. We have pressed that an advisory council on education should be set up, so that there would be gathered around the Minister in an advisory way a group of people who are in close touch with education and the various matters in education that are problems and who would help to guide public opinion or inform the public as to what was being done and persuade them that what was being done was right or, if there were defects to be remedied, as everybody knows there are, would take a part in helping the Minister to remedy them. But we only have to look outside to get from other people a guide and a help as to how we might proceed. Apart altogether from the feeling of frustration which teachers are expressing here and the feeling of exasperation that parents have, we have seen people in Great Britain and the North of Ireland and Scotland looking frankly at their educational problems, writing frankly about them, and planning extensively about them.
The Taoiseach discussed primary education in the Dáil a couple of years ago and insisted that the fundamental matters in primary education were that the pupils should, when they leave school, be able to read well, be able to write well, and be able to do arithmetic well. He emphasised that reading and writing meant that they should be able to read and write in both the English and Irish languages. In Scotland, where there is an advisory council on education, we find that in the beginning of this year that council presented the people of Scotland and the Government Department responsible for education there with a report on primary education and a report on secondary education. Both of these reports emphasise how radical must be the approach to laying proper foundations for education in future, particularly in the dangerous circumstances of the modern world. In the report on primary education, in paragraphs 112 and 113 they say:—
"As we have already hinted, we discard with little regret the narrow and obsolete view that reading, writing and arithmetic are the three fundamentals of education. A half-truth of this kind does more harm than good if it leads to the notion that every effort must first be concentrated on these subjects, that on them alone can any sound superstructure be built, and that all other subjects are more or less ‘frills'.
If it is necessary, having regard to what we have already said above, to talk about any subject at all being more fundamental than another, we would suggest tentatively, and as a basis for clearer thinking on the subject, that the three fundamental subjects are physical education, hand-work, and speech."
Putting physical education first, they go very exhaustively into what health means to the child and what healthy and sanitary surroundings mean to the development of the child, and, both in the case of secondary and primary education, they make elaborate proposals for seeing that the school buildings are adequate and well-lighted, that there are proper recreation grounds, and that bodily health is fully developed and safeguarded as a fundamental part of the human personality. Then, as to hand-work, there is the development of it in a very systematic way. We realise how necessary it is to develop manual skill. Regarding speech, language is the foundation of all communication and the vehicle of thought and memory. They bring a radically new mind to bear on speech as one of the things that must be developed if the human personality is to be developed.
We have very many things to learn from the Scotch Report. The report that the primary school teachers have now made is, in its own way, an epochmaking report, not that it says the last word in what are our difficulties from the point of view of education, or that it claims to be the last word as to how our problems should be tackled, but in it we have now given to us by one body of our teachers a studied review, however incomplete, of one branch of our education. It shows how necessary it is to have a whole new approach to what we are educating our people for and the technique that should be adopted in connection with it.
We have reached the stage, both in the history of the Department of Education and in the history of our people, when we cannot rely on the Department, as it exists, to steer us any longer through the problems that require to be tackled in order to put our education on a sound basis and we again press for the establishment of a council of education that will make a beginning in helping to do for us what bodies like the Scotch Council is doing for the people in Scotland: that is, a beginning in discussing in an open and broad way the things we require to have done for us here if our schools are to be made real educational establishments. When we consider the problem we have in connection with a second language here, we should be much more alert and active than other people are. Instead of that, we are lagging very much behind, and for that reason I move that this Vote be referred back for reconsideration.
Comment on this
Last year, when the Department of Education Vote was before the House, very naturally, because of the particular circumstances obtaining at the time, the discussion was dominated by a set of circumstances which were rather unique so far as Dublin City was concerned. In the nature of things, a certain amount of time in this debate will have to be devoted to the events that occurred over that particular period. I feel certain that anybody who will advert to that particular occurrence will do so with a view to ensuring that any opportunity there is of conciliation as between the teachers and the Department will be availed of.
There were rumours—I have no special information on the subject— following the return of the teachers, that things were not going too well so far as the Irish National Teachers' Organisation and the Department were concerned, notwithstanding that all the indications, prior to the close of the strike, suggested that conciliation when the teachers would return would be the order of the day. There is one aspect of that position which may have been —undoubtedly it has been—overlooked and I think it desires underlining. Twelve months ago, when we were discussing the irreparable harm that would be done by a continuance of the strike, every speaker from these benches referred to the position that would ensue when the trouble would have ceased. I am glad to say that a really wonderful piece of work has been done by the teachers in making up a very considerable proportion of the leeway which occurred during the period of the strike. I would like to pay tribute to the teachers, despite their disappointment, for the zeal they undoubtedly have displayed on their return and I wish to express to them the thanks of the community, and particularly of the parents, for bringing the children back to their normal standards in such a short space of time.
There was a general feeling that conciliation would be the order of the day. I submit that practical effect to that desire might be given by the Minister, even at this stage, in respect of two very serious aspects of the problem. I understand the position is that the teachers have lost their increments over that period of seven and a half months and that it will play against them so far as their pensions are concerned. I suggest, having in mind the very considerable sum that was saved— approximately £250,000 — that what would be involved in a satisfactory adjustment of these two items—relatively small perhaps, but of tremendous importance to the people concerned—would not be very appreciable and the Minister should take advantage of the in-between period to ensure that there should be such an adjustment. It would be a practical gesture along the lines of conciliation.
There is also the vexed question of rating. It was the most important item, the outstanding bone of contention, in the dispute. There seems to be an idea abroad that the Minister is favourably considering an easement of that position. I venture to say that if he does so he will bring untold satisfaction to the teaching profession. I am trying to get a picture of the time when the teachers returned and the attitude adopted by the Department. I am bound to say there was one particular occurrence, which, in the very nature of things, can only be described as a most regrettable blunder. That was the payment of a bonus to the teachers who remained in. It could only have one effect and that was to inflame passions at a time when the very reverse should have occurred. The Minister and his advisers should be well aware that action of that kind was bound to do violence to opinions, traditions and principles that have been very highly prized in trade union ranks of all hues, and particularly in this country because of the bitter struggle there has been in years gone by to ensure that the fundamental rights of trade unions would be preserved. As I say, it was a regrettable blunder.
I want to refer briefly to the question of salaries. In this respect I do say, with some little knowledge of the position, that if there was one mistake more than another made, even by the teachers themselves, it was the decision to submit a new scale of salaries at the particular time at which it was submitted. That submission was made, if you like, prior to the lifting of the standstill Order on the 23rd September last. It was made apparently with the intention of ensuring that a new scale of salaries would be paid prior to that date. Indeed, there was some ground for believing that it would but, as subsequent events proved, the Minister was not prepared to make this scale operative prior to that particular date. Since that time there has been a complete and absolute change of opinion so far as salaries and wages generally are concerned, and I am bound to say that if the teachers' claim were made subsequent to the 23rd September, the actual settlement in money terms would have been considerably more beneficial so far as they were concerned. I feel that the Minister would have had to take into consideration the reduced value of money and the changes that were taking place in other occupations which might be said to be comparable or which even merited less consideration, particularly in the City of Dublin.
I have one case in my mind, the case of a public board of a semi-commercial character. The members of the clerical staff of that board, so far as the lower grade is concerned, can reach in their ordinary salaries a figure of £520. There is no deduction for a superannuation fund, and if you add the usual 4 per cent. which is usually deducted for superannuation, that would make their salaries higher by another £20. The chief clerks in the various departments in that concern can reach a salary of £750. The case I quote is not an isolated one. There are other cases of public concerns where the salaries may be said to be of an equally good standard. I say, therefore, that the teachers have suffered in more ways than one, so far as the ultimate settlement of their salary scale was concerned. I do hope that the Minister may see his way to accede to the wish expressed from more than one side of the House when this trouble was in existence, that the Minister would, at the earliest possible date, return to this question of salaries and bring them more into line with modern conditions than was achieved by the settlement.
The position of the pensioned teachers was discussed at length not very long ago in this House. I do not wish to repeat at any great length the arguments which were then put forward but I do want to advert to one particular aspect. A deputation from this particular section called comparatively recently on the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Education. While as I said on the Budget proposals here, it is true to say that no great hope was held out to them on that particular occasion, it was felt that the matter would be reported—in fact it was said that it would be reported—to the Government as a whole. The Minister for Finance, in his Budget statement, indicated that as a result of pressure from the Minister for Education, in connection with one section of national school teachers, he was providing an extra £30,000. The Minister for Education has, himself, on more than one occasion expressed sympathy with the claims of the pensioned teachers and I should like to know whether he took advantage of the recent Budget to extract from the Minister for Finance —if I might use the term—some promise of amelioration or compensation for the pensioned teachers. It is unnecessary for me to say that a number of these men and women are in a very deplorable position at present because of the decreased purchasing power of money.
There are roughly 3,000 of these pensioners, 686 of whom are in receipt of about £1 a week each. Obviously it does not require any effort of mine to indicate to the House what that means. It is bad for the Government, it is bad for the Minister and particularly bad for the pensioned teachers themselves that such a position should be allowed to continue. It is especially bad because of the fact that these teachers can point to the treatment which their confréres in the North of Ireland have received. For some considerable time past the pensioned teachers in Northern Ireland have been enjoying a substantial advance in their pensions. So far as we know no effort has been made to bring about a like happy position here.
There is a wider aspect of this question. That is, as I have repeatedly stated, that until the Government gives a lead in such instances as that of the pensioned teachers and other servants such as those of local authorities, the position in this part of the country will be entirely unsatisfactory. Even this very afternoon the Taoiseach admitted in reply to a question that the salaries of Ministers, Deputies and others would have to be revised because of the reduction in the purchasing value of money. That is quite right of course but very naturally, sections of the community like the ex-teachers and servants of local authorities will look upon what is being done in these particular cases as indicating a one-sided treatment.
The Taoiseach has clearly indicated even by way of answer to a question what he has in mind and his justification is the reduced purchasing power of money but that is a consideration that obviously affects all sections and more particularly those in the lower income grades. I need not give any harrowing details here of how the position is felt by this comparatively small number of pensioned teachers. I suggest that it would be a gracious act on the part of the Minister if the pensioned teachers were first put into a special category because of the circumstances appertaining to them. They had to exist on low salaries for a long period of years. They contributed to a pension fund and it is no fault of theirs that they are in the plight in which they now find themselves. I think I am expressing the opinion of the House as a whole when I say that it serves no purpose in referring to a matter of this kind unless some positive action is taken by the Minister or the Government as a whole to bring about a speedy solution of it.
Members of the Labour Party have consistently year in, year out, because it is part of their programme, supported the proposal to establish a council of education. Now that we have had more than 25 years of home government I think it is time that we, so to speak, did some stocktaking. Any well-regulated business, from time to time, takes stock to see what the position is, what it is likely to lead to, and, as it were, to strike a profit and loss account. I think the time has now arrived, particularly as the people of the country as a whole are so interested in education, that that stocktaking should take place. I know of no better means to achieve what has been proposed than a council of education seeing that it would comprise personnel from the Department, from the managers, from the teachers and the parents. Such a council need not in any way be taken as impinging on the authority of the Minister. I do not see why it should, and obviously the terms of reference can be of such a character as to ensure that it will not in any case. I think everybody, educationists or otherwise, will agree that the whole system of education in this country is not on a sound basis at present and it is time that something was done about it.
Let me refer to one or two comparatively small matters but matters which are still of tremendous importance as indicating that practically no advance has been made in the 25 years of our own government. Teachers in this House will agree with me when I make a plea for two sections of pupils— firstly, the mentally retarded child, and secondly, the mentally deficient. You have the type of child who, at 15 years, has the mind only of a child of ten. That child passes from class to class. The teacher cannot hold the child down to second class until he be 12 or 13 or 14 years of age. The teacher, being an ordinary, humane individual, will, for the sake of the child's feelings, pass the child upwards in class and, at 14, he is sent out knowing little or nothing. There is no special training for a child of that type. Why should that be so? Other countries provide such training without attaching a stigma to that type of child in any way. I think that it is time we had reform in that direction. The same applies to the mentally defective child. I do not know whether or not the Department have specially examined these two problems in recent years. They may be two small matters but they are of exceedingly great importance to the children concerned and might be the subject of consideration by members of a council of education.
Reference has been made from time to time to the overcrowded state of the classes in the city schools. The same thing might, perhaps, be said in a different form regarding the rural schools. In those schools, a teacher may have to instruct 20 or 30 children in different standards. Obviously, such a teacher has not the time or the facilities to give individual attention or tuition to his pupils. That is notoriously the case in the city schools, when classes number 60 or 70 pupils. The most the teacher can do in such circumstances is to maintain discipline. Connected immediately with that question is the question of school accommodation. The Department has done a considerable amount in recent years in that respect. They can, perhaps, claim that, because of difficulties in the building industry during the past few years, improvements are not as advanced as they would like. I do not know whether or not the Minister in his speech indicated what the future programme will be or whether it will be possible to secure priority for buildings of that character in connection with the supply of building materials, which are limited in amount. The position cannot remain as it is. I have before me in the form of notes a series of extracts from the reports of county medical officers of health. By the way, I do not know what significance attaches to the fact that, whereas we used to get those reports broadly diffused and publicised some years ago, for the past four or five years we are not getting the reports in the same detailed or forcible form. Whether that is due to an improvement in the general conditions or not, I do not know, but I doubt that it is. Some years ago, the county medical officers of health virtually called upon the county authorities in their reports to condemn particular schools and a number of them stated in very vigorous language that some of the defects of the school-going children were due to their surroundings and to want of suitable amenities.
On the question of technical instruction, on each occasion on which I have spoken on this Vote for the past three or four years, I have indicated to the House that, so far as the City of Dublin is concerned, the position is entirely satisfactory. Indeed, our main trouble in the City of Dublin is to secure accommodation for the number of students seeking the services of the schools. We have magnificent schools, finely equipped, excellently staffed and doing exceedingly useful work. I am bound to say that, in the operation of those schools, we are getting the utmost co-operation from the Minister and the officers in his Department— with a few exceptions. It is not a complete picture; perhaps it would be too much to expect that. However, on the whole, I am glad to say that the relations between the school authorities and the technical instruction section of the Department are satisfactory.
Comment on this
No service under the control of the Government is more important than education. On no subject does more uneasiness exist at present than exists in regard to education. When we consider that the overwhelming majority of our people can receive only a primary education, when we consider that the sum total of formal education for the great majority of our people consists of the education received in the national school, it is only right that, in this debate, primary attention should be devoted to that branch of our educational system. I can, perhaps, speak on this subject with some authority because I left school at the unlucky age of 13, forgot everything I learned within six months and have felt better ever since. Padraic Pearse left on record that education is properly the fostering of the right growth of personality. He further stated:—
"It is a preparation of the soul to live its life here and hereafter and to live it nobly and fully."
These are high ideals but there is a general feeling, after 25 years of native government, that these ideals are not being achieved. Parents are dissatisfied with the education which their children are receiving in the primary schools. Teachers are certainly dissatisfied with the existing system. Last but not least, though they are seldom considered, the children themselves are dissatisfied. It is generally admitted—I do not think that anybody will dare to deny it—that the standard of education of children leaving the primary schools is lower than it was 25 years ago. I do not think it could be otherwise seeing that the major portion of the school day is taken up with the study of a second language. I am not familiar with the programme of the national school but I have it on good authority that 75 per cent. of the time is taken up with Irish in some form or another. When we remember that we had good, hard-working teachers 30 or 40 years ago who devoted themselves to their task earnestly and when we realise that they had not to bear this burden, it is only natural, having regard to the additional burden placed on teachers to-day, that the standard of education should, of necessity, be low.
Every principle of education is broken by the early introduction into the primary schools of a second language. If children are to learn they ought to be given an interest in the subjects which are being introduced to them. The natural way to teach a child is to encourage the child's instinct to inquire, to ask questions, and the child who is introduced to a new language cannot ask questions. He is simply exposed to a long, gruelling strain, from which there is no relief until the school door is closed. Not only is it a tremendous strain on a child to acquire a second language, but it is an even greater strain if other subjects are taught through the medium of a new language which the child does not understand and of which the teacher may not have a full grasp. Can anyone estimate the loss to education, the loss which this country is suffering, by reason of this burden which is being imposed on primary education? There is not only a loss in the matter of the ordinary subjects, reading, writing and arithmetic, but there is an even greater loss in the fact that the teacher has now no time whatever to devote to the more important aspect of education, the formation of the character of the children under his control. The teacher has to struggle to keep up with a programme which is altogether too heavy for the children and for him, and he has no time to instruct the children in the important virtues of honesty, honour, truth, obedience and self-respect. All these must go by the board; all these subjects are sacrificed in an attempt to impose a new language upon our people and to impose it as hurriedly as possible.
The Minister may say that if we cannot have this forcing of the pace in the primary schools, if we cannot have this burden placed on our teachers and on our children, there is no future for the revival of Irish as a spoken language. There are, I think, two answers to that. Does anyone seriously believe that, after 25 years of trial, any real progress has been made towards reviving Irish as a spoken language? I have known young teachers who, after this State was established, set out, full of enthusiasm, to instruct the children under their control in Irish and to make Irish a spoken language, but, as the years have gone by, these teachers have lost all their enthusiasm. They have come to the conclusion that the game is absolutely hopeless.
It has frequently been said that, by an intensive course of Irish in the schools, we are creating a situation in which, in the course of a few years, those who do that course will have a fairly good knowledge of Irish and will be able to instruct their children in the home. I do not think that hope has been justified. Teachers have told me that they have investigated the matter with former pupils of national schools who had left the schools with a fairly good knowledge of Irish and have found, without exception, that these former pupils have completely lost whatever knowledge of Irish they had. I think that is to be expected.
A new language in the ordinary course of events is a rather difficult thing to acquire, particularly for the average pupil. There are, of course, people with a special gift for languages, but for the ordinary pupil, it is a difficult task and something which, once a boy or girl leaves the primary school, he or she quickly forgets, because the grasp obtained, even in the best national school, is always inaccurate. So far as I know, there is only one really effective way by which a person can learn a second language, that is, by being completely surrounded by people who speak nothing but that language. We know that people who go to the Continent acquire a very good working knowledge of the various Continental languages after-six months or so. That is to be expected, and, if it were possible for each citizen of this State, as a child or as an adult, to spend at least six months in a purely Irish-speaking district, completely isolated from all contact with English speakers, he would probably be able to acquire a working knowledge of Irish, but that is something which is physically impossible.
The question we have to consider is, first, what sacrifice are we making as a nation in order to impose this language upon our people and, secondly, is that sacrifice worth while? I have tried to give some idea of what that sacrifice is. I would say that children are much less adequately educated in the ordinary school subjects than they were before this intensive policy in regard to Irish was introduced. They get much less opportunities for acquiring a knowledge of citizenship and for the formation of character, which is the more important function of education. I would go further and say that compulsory Irish in our primary schools is by far the most denationalising influence that has operated in this country during the past 25 years. If our young people are to grow up with a sense of nationality, with a feeling of respect for our nation, for the people who went before us, for the great men who sacrificed so much for our country's welfare, that feeling must be instilled into them in the primary schools. No attempt can be made to achieve that; instead we have a cruel attempt to impose on children a new language which they do not understand and which they have no hope of acquiring.
It is a tragedy that so much national effort should be wasted—and wasted in vain, in this way. It is a grand thing, of course, for adult people to pose as super-patriots, as being enthusiastic for the language from patriotic motives; but the entire burden of the sacrifices which that policy demands is imposed by us upon the weakest and most helpless section of the people, the school children. Children have no votes, they cannot protest, or their protest will not be heard; they can only pay the penalty, and they may pay it in after life. We, in order to show how patriotic, how national we are, go on imposing this sacrifice upon the children of our race, depriving them at the same time of the opportunities which they ought to have to equip themselves for the battle of life and to build up and strengthen their character and mental equipment.
It is time there should be a little plain speaking and clear thinking on this question. There is no use in eternally burying our heads in the sand and pretending that, because it sounds very national to be enthusiastic about the language, we should go on with this policy of coercing our children and depriving them of a real education. We are spending £7,000,000 on education at the present time and we are getting nothing for it. Parents feel that they are being robbed of what they are entitled to expect, having regard to the taxes which they pay—that is, free education for their children. Their children are being sent out into the world uneducated and illiterate to a very great extent. It is no wonder that the teachers say, in their "Plan for Education," that there must be a review of the educational system if we are to survive as a nation with a distinctive culture. The task is not an easy one; its solution will require hard thinking and careful planning,
" but the solutions are there and it is because we fail in clearness of vision or in boldness of heart or in singleness of purpose that we cannot find them".
These are the words of P. H. Pearse, quoted in "A Plan for Education".
There are a tremendous number of important subjects which could be imparted to our children, if we were to confine education in each primary school mainly to the language of the home. The first essential is that every child should be able to write clearly and well, should be able to read and should have a really good knowledge of the home language. It is equally important that a child leaving the primary schools should have a good knowledge of arithmetic. These are fundamental subjects which we have a right to expect from our primary schools. We cannot help feeling bitterly disappointed that children leaving the primary schools, who have to depend for livelihood upon whatever standard of education they have reached there, go out into the world so badly equipped. We also know that children who go to the secondary schools find themselves with a great deal of arrears to make up when they leave the primary schools.
I hold that, in addition to these fundamental subjects—reading, writing and arithmetic—it is a matter of urgent importance that children should leave the primary school with a desire for learning. What they have learned should be just a foundation. They should have a desire to read and study. to acquire knowledge. In the second place, every pupil in the primary school should be taught to take an intelligent and enthusiastic interest in life and in his environment. Children should be taught the history of their townland, parish, county and country, to know it thoroughly and to appreciate what it means to them.
A nation that cannot look back with pride and self-respect cannot look forward to anything. It is a matter of fundamental importance that a really good national outlook should be inculcated into the minds of children at an early age. It is most important that character should be formed, as far as possible, in the national schools. Children very often in their own homes get very little opportunity to learn all they should. In the homes of the poor people who have to go out and work they get very little chance of acquiring much knowledge of right and wrong and of all the things they ought to know to equip themselves for life, spiritually, mentally and physically. That very important function devolves on the teacher to supply what the parent cannot supply in the matter of character formation. All this good work is being frustrated, because we have made up our minds that children must be coerced into speaking a new language within a very short time. This is not a matter for consideration at the moment but it certainly does arise. I hold that no useful purpose can be served in the world in which we live by changing the spoken language of this country. The circumstances were different 100, or even 30, years ago. When this nation was struggling for its independence, the language was one of the weapons in the armoury which the nation had to defend itself from attack, but a new situation has arisen. We now enjoy political independence and will continue to do so unless and until we misuse or prove ourselves unworthy of it. We will continue to enjoy political independence as long as we treasure, and as long as our children are taught to treasure, respect and reverence our past history, and to have confidence in our future as a nation.
Therefore, a change in the spoken language is not essential in any way to the preservation of this country's independence. We are sometimes told that if an Irishman, travelling on the Continent, speaks English, he is mistaken for an Englishman. If he is travelling on the Continent and can speak English he is likely to meet people who understand the English language and can explain to them that he is an Irishman, but, if he can speak nothing but Irish, he will find nobody who can understand what he is saying, and therefore, will have no opportunity of explaining that he is an Irishman. The people he meets will not know from what nation he comes. Viewed from every possible angle, there is no case for changing the spoken language of this country. I am sure it will be appreciated that there is a case for the preservation of Irish as a cultural language, as the language of the educated classes. I think that the policy of persisting, as we are persisting, in hammering Irish down the throats of our children, imposing on them untold suffering and sacrifices, imposing upon the teachers enormous sacrifices and depriving our children at the same time of real education, is an unsound one. I think it is wrong even to the extent of being criminally wrong.
I know, of course, that there is a number of people in the country who acquired a knowledge of the Irish language by their own zeal, energy and toil, and that they have a deep love for it. I have the greatest respect for all such people, but that in itself does not justify us in imposing the language upon the children in this attempt to change the spoken language of the country. Some real case should be made for changing the spoken language of the country. I have never heard an adequate case made for it. I have pointed out what we are losing as a nation by this attempt at imposing Irish on our young people. We are losing real education in the formation of character; we are losing the opportunity of inculcating any sense of nationality or of our country's history in the minds of the children. At the present time we are turning out of our national schools children who have very little sense of nationality, and it is no wonder that national feeling is at a low ebb in this country at the present time.
When I was a small boy very little history was taught in schools, and I think that very little of it is taught at the present day. A copy of A. M. Sullivan's Story of Ireland came into my possession before I was 11 years of age. I am sure I read it half a dozen times, and that I memorised considerable portions of it which appealed to my enthusiasm at that time. I was certainly able to recite most of the patriotic ballads which it contains. While I am not recommending A. M. Sullivan's Story of Ireland, I certainly believe that instruction in our country's history, as well as in the important achievements of our race in the past, is more important than anything else at the present time. We have seen other nations which were surrounded and threatened on all sides by aggression standing up and defending themselves, simply because the people of those countries had instilled into them in their childhood a belief in their own nation as well as a deep reverence for its past and of unshaken confidence in its future. If we can inspire our people's minds with these feelings, we shall have nothing to fear for the future.
I do not think that the world needs any more spoken languages at the present time. I have the feeling that in 50 years' time the language of the world will be either English or Russian. I hope it will not be Russian because, I suppose, we might have it rammed down our necks if certain people got control over world affairs. I do not believe in this policy of ramming anything down people's necks, and particularly the necks of innocent children. I think that the small boy or girl, when he or she goes to school, should be led, not driven. The teacher should use the Pied Piper's pipe and not the drover's ash plant. I think that, if given a lead by the Department and by the Minister for Education, the teachers are in the frame of mind to adopt a rational and sensible scheme of education. They are anxious to co-operate with one another and with the Minister. In this connection, I refer to the Minister not in a personal way, but to the Minister for Education. I do not think the present Minister for Education will ever get that co-operation which ought to exist between a Minister and the whole teaching profession. I think it would be a good thing for education if the Minister for Education was promoted to some more exalted position, but I believe that with co-operation between the Minister of the future and the teachers we can have a far-reaching reform in education, and that we can have the right ideals governing that policy of education.
The teachers have recommended that a council of education should be set up to advise the Department and the Minister. That would have been supported by practically every Party in the House with the exception of the Government Party. Last year many people were appealing for the establishment of a medical council to advise on health matters. That demand was roughly turned down. Since then a consultative council has been established. I think wiser councils will prevail in regard to education and that a council of education will be established of people with progressive ideas and having a real interest in education who will be able to advise the Minister and to co-operate with him in evolving a better system of education.
Some time ago I was inclined to the opinion that there is only one way to test the efficiency of teachers in primary schools, namely, by examination of the pupils by an inspector. I am not so sure, however, that the present system of examination gives the results that it was intended to give. A teacher must teach many things in addition to imposing memory tests. The teacher must inculcate a desire for learning and a healthy interest in the environment in which the children are reared, particularly if they are being reared in a rural district. He must take part in the building of the children's character. An inspector, merely by question and answer, cannot see the extent to which the teacher is performing his duty in that respect.
One of the results of the inspection system is that there is a certain amount of window-dressing and cramming of children in the particular subject in which the inspector is presumed by the teacher to be interested. We know that every national school inspector has particular ideas and fads. The teacher very soon gets to know the particular subjects that the inspector is interested in and believes that if he grinds the children in those subjects he will get very good marks. On the other hand, the teacher who endeavours to improve the character of the children, to make them self-confident, better citizens, to cultivate their mentality may not do so well at the inspection. There should be a close and sympathetic co-operation and supervision by the inspector. The inspector should be able to form a good idea as to the progress that has been made in the various aspects of education by watching the teacher at work and reviewing the copybooks and should not confine himself merely to memory training.
Memory training is not the be-all and end-all of education. The aim should be to educate the child so that when leaving school he will have a great desire for learning and a keen interest in his environment and will have his character properly formed and will have a sound knowledge of what constitutes a good citizen and a good Christian. That would be much better than to educate them merely to be machines for recording dates and figures and facts.
If there is co-operation between the Department and the teachers and between the inspectorate and the teachers and a determination to abandon the system of window-dressing, we can have a better system of education. We are not a bit more patriotic because we cram dates down the throats of our children. We are not more self-sacrificing because we impose this sacrifice on the weakest of our community. Let us give our children a sound education which will enable them to fight the battle of life and to be good citizens and good Christians. That is fundamental. It is a need which is being neglected. There is no doubt whatever that our people are not getting the chance in life to which they are entitled. Anyone who has experience of post-primary school training knows that we have not made any progress in the matter of real education during the past 25 years.
Comment on this
I have indicated that to introduce a second language, into the lower standards at any rate, except in the most modest form, is wrong. It imposes too great a burden. I would not be against teaching Irish, in moderate doses, at any rate. There is no possibility that you can send children out of the primary schools with anything like a mastery of the language or with even sufficient knowledge of the language to enable them, when they become parents, to assist their children to master the language.
I am satisfied that that is not possible. I know rural Ireland and I know young people who have left the national school five or six years ago and they have completely forgotten everything they learned of Irish. I do not believe that when those people become parents they will be able to give any worth-while assistance in the language to their children. There is no real hope of making Irish the spoken language of this country. I do not think we are losing anything by that. I believe that in 20 years hence we will all decide that it is an impossible task but what I fear at present is that in our attempt to force the language upon the children, we are destroying the prospect of giving our children a real education or, in fact, any education. The position is extremely serious. I know many people who are fundamentally opposed to the Irish language. Some of them with whom I have spoken in regard to this matter think that nothing should be said or done in connection with Irish enterprise. They hold that the present Government is killing the language as quickly as it can.
I think that is true, to a very great extent. But they are killing more than the language. They are killing education. They are killing nationality. Those things are very important. I have already said that compulsory Irish in our primary schools is the most denationalising force which exists in this country at the present time, simply because it has crowded out the other subjects. Time which should be devoted to other subjects which would make our children better Irishmen and better citizens is devoted to the Irish language. I think the Minister, if he has not already done so, should sit down and study carefully the plan for education which has been produced by the National Teachers' Organisation. It is a very sound document. It contains very many useful suggestions in regard to modern teaching methods and to adult education. I believe that provision for adult education is a matter of vital and immediate importance and that sooner or later the State will have to consider the provision of opportunities in order to enable young men and women to improve their education. After all, there is no use in confining education to children, particularly having regard to the history of education in this country in the past 25 years.
Classes, night schools or even winter schools of some sort should be provided. Denmark is an outstanding example in that connection. Special winter schools and residential schools are provided there, mainly for the rural or agricultural population. Their outlook and programme is not confined exclusively to agricultural education. They are determined to give their pupils a good national and moral outlook and to improve their general knowledge. The outstanding feature of that scheme which has, perhaps, never been referred to in this country is that that education is given to adults only. There is no question in Denmark of continuing the education of manual workers, farmers, and agricultural workers above the primary school-leaving age. Children are allowed to leave the primary schools, to go out and work in their various avocations and when they reach the age of 18 or 19 years they can come in and receive a few months' adult education in those residential schools. The principle behind that system is very sound. There is no doubt that if, for example, you take a boy whose future is in agriculture away from agriculture, that is in actual practice, and keep him in some sort of a school, even an agricultural school, until he is 17 or 18 years of age there is always the possibility, even the probability, that he will not go back to agriculture. He is too long at school. There are the old sayings— If you do not dirty your hands early in life you will be disinclined to dirty them after a time—and—You cannot fall without getting dirty and getting your clothes soiled. I think it is bad to keep young people too long, at any rate, away from the actual practice of agriculture. The Danish experts in education recognised that and therefore they permitted young people to leave the formal education, to spend a few years actually roughing it in the ordinary work of the land and then, having become inured to farm work and having got to know it in actual practice, they were given an opportunity of going back to a certain type of school in order to improve their general knowledge. The principles governing that system are, I think, sound. Anyone who has experience of young people knows how desperately hard it is for a boy who has been at school, even an agricultural school, until he is 17 or 18 years of age, to settle down in a lonely remote part of the country and to live there for the rest of his life. We see young people who have been to the Albert College and to other agricultural schools coming home with the one desire of getting some kind of a job as inspector that would take them away from the loneliness and drudgery of the farm. That is unfortunate but it is the truth. I have mentioned this to show how many involved and complex questions there are in regard to education. I have mentioned it to show how much need there is for a close study of all matters in connection with all branches of the subject. I have mentioned it to show how necessary it is to have a Minister who is sympathetic and broadminded; who has not narrow, preconceived ideas in regard to all matters of education. That is what I am appealing for and I think it is what the nation, which spends £7,000,000 on education, is entitled to expect.
Comment on this
When the Minister introduced his Estimate to-day he spoke at very great length. I was greatly struck by the fact that despite the immense length of his statement we were left at the end of it in doubt as to whether he was going to deal with Estimate 28 at all. So far as I know he never uttered a word about the governing body of the Institute for Advanced Studies for which there is a substantial charge on the Estimates. That was all the more remarkable——
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
The failure of the Miniister to make any reference whatever in his opening statement to the Institute for Advanced Studies is all the more remarkable if the House recalls that the director of the institute published a letter in the Press some time ago announcing his resignation from the position of director. Subsequent to that announcement, I put down a Parliamentary Question addressed to the Minister for Education asking him if he had any information to impart to the House, and he replied that he had no official information of the reasons which moved the director to resign from that position. That was in itself a fairly striking admission. Shortly after that reply was vouchsafed by the Minister, the ex-director of the institute addressed a further note to the Press in which he announced that he proposed to resign from his position as professor in the institute as soon as was feasible and that he proposed to do so because the interference in the day-to-day administration of the institute had reached such proportions as to make his retention of that position impossible.
Comment on this
May I submit one or two points to the Deputy on that matter? The Deputy referred to the fact that a very considerable sum of money is being voted for the institute and, therefore, the Minister should have devoted some time to it. This Dáil also votes a considerable amount of money to the university. Should, for instance, differences or resignations arise there, which Heaven forbid, would the Deputy consider himself justified in raising the matter here? I understand that this is a body corporate with autonomy in certain matters; that the governing body is the appointing body and accepts resignations. If the Deputy maintains, and thinks he can prove, that the Minister for Education interfered and had anything to do with that resignation, perhaps there would be something in it. But the body primarily responsible is the governing body, not the Minister for Education.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to agree that the body primarily responsible for the day-to-day administration is the governing body.
Comment on this
The substance of the director's allegation is that his position in the institute was made untenable by political interference with the day-to-day administration of the institute.
Comment on this
No. The Minister for Education has not interfered with the institute in any way. Moreover, the Deputy——
Comment on this
The Deputy is not in the chair.
Comment on this
On an Estimate, you can discuss anything for which the Minister is responsible. I want to know what point the Deputy is raising for which the Minister for Education has responsibility.
Comment on this
I submit that he would have responsibility if there were political interferences in the day-to-day administration of that body.
Comment on this
I take it that he should deter his colleagues from interfering in an institute for the independence and autonomy of which he stands trustee.
Comment on this
I want to be sure of the Minister's responsibility for anything to which the Deputy intends to refer.
Comment on this
You pointed out, Sir, that the institute is, of its nature, an autonomous and independent body. I take it that the Minister stands trustee to this House; that that is true.
Comment on this
Inasmuch as the Minister makes himself responsible for the voting of money, on that assumption he says to us that he is satisfied that from day-to-day that autonomy and independence are preserved.
Comment on this
I put it to the Deputy before that there is an autonomous body called the National University. It is possible, but not probable, that there would be political differences in that body and that there would be resignations. Would the Minister be held responsible for them, or would it be interference with the autonomy of the university and with the autonomy of the body which accepted the resignations?
Comment on this
So far as the case is made here that the autonomy of that institute is being interfered with and Deputies ask for an assurance from the Minister that that autonomy is not being interfered with, surely we are entitled to seek that guarantee?
Comment on this
The Minister answered a question on that and said definitely that he had no function in the matter and that he did not interfere.
Comment on this
In reply to a question previously put, which I have in front of me and which the Deputy asked.
Comment on this
But, to-day, I am asking the Minister for Education, in the light of his failure to make any reference to the institute in his introductory remarks, for an assurance that the autonomy and independence of that institute are maintained, the repeated allegations of the director notwithstanding. I respectfully submit that I am entitled to ask for that guarantee and to inform the House of the reasons why I ask for it. They are grave and serious.
Comment on this
——of the privileges of the House to make an ex parle statement here and a statement that it will be impossible for me to reply to. It has been frequently explained in the House, and during the passage of the Bill to set up this Institute for Advanced Studies, that there was no intention whatever——
Comment on this
——of the Government interfering, and no one pressed that view more strongly than the Deputy. I pointed out, as you have reminded the Deputy, Sir——
Comment on this
In my reply to the Deputy on the 16th April, I referred to Article 14 of the Institute for Advanced Studies (School of Celtic Studies) Establishment Order, 1940, from which it is clear that I have no functions of authority in connection with that matter. It is entirely one for the governing board of the school. The Deputy is now trying to drag in this matter, which he knows cannot be dealt with. He knows this is not the place to deal with it and he knows that no good whatever can result from the methods he is undertaking in raising this question.
Comment on this
The Minister and myself find we are in complete agreement that the clear understanding is that this body should be autonomous and independent and free from interference by any person except those who are members of its council or officers of the institute. I am entitled, surely, before voting for the appropriation of £53,810, for reassurance from the responsible Minister that that independence and autonomy are maintained. It is to that end that my observations are directed.
Comment on this
It is to be hoped the Deputy does not want to introduce a dispute which happened in an autonomous body, who acted within their rights, giving one side of it. To raise the matter here would certainly not be leaving to that body the autonomy which it enjoys by statute. If the Deputy thinks any Minister has offended, there will be other opportunities when he can raise the matter.
Comment on this
The object of my observations is to call upon the Minister for Education to provide the requisite assurance to this House that the independence and autonomy of this institute are maintained before this House is called upon to vote £53,810 to enable it to continue its operations during the coming 12 months, and in my respectful submission I am entitled to extract that from him.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Deputy's hypothesis is unsound; there is no foundation for it and I do not accept his hypothesis.
Comment on this
I am in possession, and if the Minister is not making a point of order he must sit down. All the shrieks of his supporters will not deter me in the least. To-day I received a letter from the director, the contents of which were so grave that I conceived it to be my duty to place that letter in the hands of the head of the Government for the reason that I did not choose to read that letter on the floor of this House nor did I wish to refer to it without having placed the head of the Government in full possession of its contents, so that my reference to it would place neither him nor his colleagues in the embarrassing position of hearing a document referred to without knowing its contents. I have no desire to intervene in or offer an opinion upon the merits of any dispute which may arise in the internal administration of the Dublin Institute of Higher Studies.
Comment on this
I have not mentioned a word in that connection. The case I want to make is this: There is no use pretending that two letters have not been published in the papers. There is no use sticking our heads in the sand pretending that ex parte statements have not been made. The only submission I want to make is that by sticking your head in the sand in that way far from achieving the purpose of preventing injustice or misrepresentation gaining ground you create the very atmosphere in which that kind of thing can grow. Once a matter of this character becomes common knowledge, my submission is that it is the duty of the responsible Minister, either himself to take such steps as may be necessary to bring the matter to an end, or to instruct whoever is the appropriate authority to take whatever steps may be necessary to bring the matter to a conclusion.
I go so far as to say that prima facie the right principle seems to me to be that a professor is the protector of his students and that whatever the circumstances may be, in ordinary circumstances a student, whatever his or her competence or prudence or discretion may be or may have been, he or she is entitled to look for a paternal solicitude to the professor under whom he or she works. I want to make no further comment upon it except this, that the matter must be disposed of. Whether the rules of order of this House require Deputies to vote £53,810 for an institute which they may not discuss, is a matter for the Chair to decide.
Comment on this
It is a matter for the law to decide. When a body is given autonomy it should be left to that body to deal with its own affairs and we should not have ex parte statements made here with no opportunity of a reply from the institute.
Comment on this
You are. You have been told three or four times by the Chair that this is an autonomous body.
Comment on this
What is to stop Deputy Walsh from getting up and making a case for the other side if he wants to?
Comment on this
There you are, if you know nothing about it, keep quiet. I suggest to the Chair that it is the business of this House to ensure that the affairs of this institute will be administered in accordance with the law.
Comment on this
Cuirim os do chomhair, A Chinn Comhairle, gur thugais rialú ar an gceist seo. Nach bhfuil an Teachta ag éalú an rialú sin?
Comment on this
When allegations are made in public, by persons who claim to know the facts, that the law is not being observed, surely this House is entitled to call on the Minister not only for an assurance but for proof that the law as enacted by the Oireachtas is being observed or are we to sit silent for ever, allowing such statements to pass unnoticed and pretend that we have never heard of them?
Comment on this
I have made the position clear. The autonomy of that body is not being interfered with. If a statement on one side were permitted in this House, the council would have no opportunity of replying.
Comment on this
Surely I am entitled to deliverance from that charge? I do not propose to accept anyone's statement. All I say is that the statements are made and I neither accept nor reject them.
Comment on this
In my respectful submission I have done nothing of the kind. I have taken the scrupulous precaution to avoid the necessity of doing it but, mind you, that does not mean that I would not in different circumstances argue my right to do so, but to-day I have not done so. I have taken scrupulous precautions to avoid that. I cannot believe, however, that the Chair will ultimately rule that when we are voting £58,000 for this school no reference may be made to it. What may we say in regard to it?
Comment on this
Exactly. It seems to be an astonishing position that under the Rules of Order, we may not refer to the Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies.
Comment on this
The Chair has not stated that the Deputy may not refer to the Institute for Advanced Studies, but it has said that this House shall not discuss the internal administration of an autonomous body.
Comment on this
I do not want to discuss it but I want to direct the attention of the House to the fact that an allegation has been made in public and so long as that goes uncontradicted, and this House is voting money for the upkeep of that institution, the only statement on the record of the House is in direct conflict with our intentions and purpose. I do not accept these statements and I do not reject them, but I say it is puerile and childish of the Government simply to say that they have no official knowledge that any such statement has been made. I as one Deputy of the House reject that.
Comment on this
He has responsibility to see that the law is enforced in respect to a Vote for which he is answerable to the House. Has he not responsibility to the House to see that the law is enforced in regard to one of his own Estimates?
Comment on this
Neither have I, but I say that it is puerile and childish for the Minister and the Government to say that the Government have no official knowledge of what we have all read in the papers. Surely it is childish for that Minister to say that he has no official knowledge of the document, when I personally waited upon the Taoiseach officially this morning and put it into his hand?
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is the head of the Government and his duty was to communicate with the Minister for Education if he wished to do so. My duty was to put that document in his hands to do with it what he pleased. The point I wish to put on record—the Taoiseach may correct me if I misrepresent the terms of my official communication—is that I put it in his hands to give him notice that I meant to refer to it without reading its details on the floor of the House. I say it is puerile and childish for the Government to say that they have no official knowledge of this fact. They have official knowledge. They may say they have not in order to avoid having to do anything about it. No one is more jealous than I for the academic autonomy of our learned institutions, but that academic autonomy cannot best be maintained by denying the possibility that there could be any conspiracy to undermine it.