We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Health Bill, 1947—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–169 of 325. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Health Bill, 1947
Enacted

No. 11 of 1947 ›

James Ryan Minister for Health (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 22:—

To delete sub-section (5) and substitute the following sub-section:—

(5) Regulations under this section may provide for and authorise the making of charges for the purposes of the regulations or for services performed thereunder and may provide for the recovery of such charges.

This might be regarded as a drafting amendment. We were rather confined in the charges that might be made but, as well, the sub-section which it is proposed to delete was rather badly worded. It was not clear whether the cleansing and disinfection might not be held to be cleansing and disinfection of rats. The wording of the proposed amendment is clearer and wider and I think it also covers the idea embodied in the next amendment by Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

The amendment reads:—

"Regulations under this section may provide for and authorise the making of charges for the purpose of the regulations or for services performed thereunder and may provide for the recovery of such charges."

I think it was pointed out yesterday that in a subsequent part of the Bill provision is made for the compulsory treatment or isolation of persons in connection with infectious diseases and, if the element of compulsion is brought into play, the full cost of treating them will be borne by the State. I think it was Deputy Dr. O'Higgins who pointed out that if it is intended to make any charges in connection with the treatment of infectious diseases, and if the fact of raising an objection to being treated, will mean that the State or the local authority will have to provide for the whole cost of treatment, that will induce people to resist complying with regulations or the procedure that might ordinarily apply, in order to escape the known costs or even the unknown costs in which they might otherwise be involved. I submit, therefore, that either a little more explanation or a little more safeguarding of the position is required in connection with this amendment. Under this amendment it would be possible for the Minister to make regulations which would provide for the making of charges for any kind of work done or any kind of service performed in connection with the treatment of infectious disease.

Comment on this

I should mention that it is not intended that charges in connection with the treatment of infectious diseases will be made except in such cases as the destruction of rats in vessels or in connection with the disinfection of premises or aircraft. It is not intended to make any charges where a person is treated.

Comment on this

For the destruction of rats?

Comment on this

Yes, or the cleansing of premises, the disinfection of aircraft or services of that kind.

Comment on this

Will the Minister undertake to amplify his amendment on the Report Stage by the inclusion of a specification of that kind?

Comment on this

I should say that in Section 34, which deals with the compulsory detention of a person, sub-section (7) definitely lays it down that the local authority will pay the costs.

Comment on this

That is why I suggest that this amendment is too wide to warrant its inclusion in the section as it stands. If it is intended to restrict it to the destruction of rats or the cleansing of premises or vessels, it is desirable that the amendment should be so worded as to restrict the possibility of making charges in other cases.

Comment on this

There is rather a difficulty in laying down specifically where charges may be made. While I say it is not intended to make any charges for personal treatment, if we have a person, on the other hand, who comes into a county hospital and wishes to get a bed in a private ward attached to that hospital, naturally there should be a charge. It is difficult to define the cases in which a charge would be made. That is why I think it might be better not to try to enumerate these cases.

Comment on this

There are a few questions which arise on this section to which I should like to get an answer. Firstly, if regulations are made under this sub-section, will these regulations come before the House and can they be annulled by the House?

Comment on this

Oh, yes.

Comment on this

Is it the intention that any charge so made will be made by the local authority or is the Minister clear that he may not have to pass a financial resolution to enable such charges to be made? I do not know whether the financial resolutions, a number of which have been passed in relation to the measure, were so widely drawn as to safeguard him and enable him to do that.

Comment on this

I have been assured they were. Perhaps I shall look into it again. I have been assured that the financial resolutions covered all these charges and would include provisions giving power to the Minister to enable local authorities to make charges.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 24 was discussed in connection with amendment No. 21.

Comment on this

When we were on amendment No. 21, we were on the question of the medical treatment of children but I should like to ask the Minister, now that we have passed over to the question of infectious diseases, whether he does not see a case for saying that regulations made to deal with infectious diseases should be approved by the national health council. I, therefore, move amendment No. 24:—

To add a new sub-section as follows:—

() Regulations made under this section shall be subject to the approval of the national health council.

It is quite true that the service in connection with which we have discussed this matter already has very wide ramifications, perhaps as wide as those of infectious diseases, but I should like to hear from the Minister what relation he expects the national health council to have with the direction or the advising of the work of himself and his Department in connection with the very wide ramifications of the matter covered by infectious diseases.

Comment on this

I am afraid I can only briefly reiterate what I said last night on a similar amendment. I do intend to set up a health council and the principal purpose of that health council will be to advise me on the regulations that are made. Generally speaking, the regulations would be sent to them and they would be given time to study them. Then we would get their advice on the regulations and, if they make a case, they could be changed accordingly. But, as I said last night, sometimes you have to make an amendment to a regulation which might be a very short matter and perhaps rather urgently required and we could not expect the health council to come along and deal with it because it will be composed of men who are very busy in their own spheres and could hardly be expected to come along more than once every two months or maybe, in the beginning, once a month. That is as far as they are concerned.

On the other side, I said that in principle I think the Minister should be responsible for whatever is done. He is responsible to the Dáil. The regulations are laid before the Dáil and the Dáil can reject them. But I think the Minister should take full responsibility and he should be in a position to disagree with the health council if he wants to take the responsibility of doing that. I stated last night that in a long experience of consultative councils I never had to disagree with them and it is very unlikely that I ever should have to disagree but, if it comes to a contest between what I think, and their advice, I should be able to reject that advice. I also made a point which, if you like, is not perhaps a very good point, that I would like in selecting a health council to select people who would be likely to be critical of anything I am doing but, if I am going to be bound by their decision, I might be inclined to select people who would be more amenable in their advice.

Comment on this

With your permission, I will leave further discussion of this matter until we reach No. 92.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned, in reference to charges for people who are treated for infectious disease, that an individual who might ask for a special room in an institution, should be charged. I feel that if a man is asked to go into an institution for treatment, in the interest of public health, because he is suffering from an infectious disease, he ought to be entitled to ask for conditions analogous to the conditions in his own home. I wonder whether the Minister has considered that aspect of the case or not because, in the ordinary way, he might desire to be treated at home but in the public interest he is asked to go to the institution. He enjoys conditions in his own home that are somewhat above the average, possibly, and I think he is entitled to look for conditions analogous to those conditions and, in these circumstances, does the Minister suggest that he should be asked to pay?

Comment on this

I think if Deputy Hughes were the medical officer in charge of the institution he would find it very difficult if we were to lay down that as a principle because most people will think that they are entitled to the best treatment the institution can give and that means most people would be looking for private rooms. The only easy way, if you like, and perhaps the fairest was is that the head of the institution can say: "You are entitled to free treatment if you take the same treatment as everybody else"—which I hope will be very good treatment—"but if you want special rooms, you will have to pay the extra cost." Take the big fever hospitals in this city at the moment. That is the rule, really, and it appears to work very well on the whole. I should say, perhaps, that I think the person Deputy Hughes has in mind, who has a very good home, in certain cases may not have to go to hospital where the poor person would have to go.

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) says:—

"Regulations under this section shall not require a person to submit to surgical treatment."

Comment on this

We will discuss surgical treatment later on.

Comment on this

At what stage?

Comment on this

On amendment No. 31, I think it is.

Comment on this

That refers to sub-section (2) of Section 34.

Comment on this

I am moving to delete this section and, if the Dáil will agree, this will have to be taken out on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Regulations shall not require persons to submit to surgical treatment. Has the Minister considered why medical treatment has been left out of this? As this stands, the Minister makes provision that no person, contrary to his own consent, will be made submit compulsorily to surgical treatment. It implies that a person, contrary to his own consent, may have to submit to medical treatment. Does the Minister deliberately intend to leave the Section like that and is he looking for powers compulsorily to treat persons medically, who may object to that treatment?

Comment on this

I think that when we come to discuss amendment No. 31, we can cover that point of medical treatment as well as surgical treatment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:—

To add a new sub-section as follows:—

() Where an adult person or the parent of the child is required under this section to take any action he shall at the time of being so informed be provided with a copy of the prescribed terms in which he may, if he so desires, submit his objection.

This section makes certain provisions for exemption from the requirements to submit to measures for protection and immunisation against infectious disease and it is intended by the amendment that where an adult person or the parent of a child is required to take any action under this section he shall at the same time as he is being so informed be provided with a copy of the prescribed terms in which, if he so desires, he may submit his objection. The section definitely makes provision by which there will be machinery for objecting and it is desirable that when a person is being told by the State or somebody acting for the State that he has to submit compulsorily to a particular type of treatment that if there is a way of objecting that he will be told quite clearly and simply the form which the objection has to take so that if he desires to object he will be able to do so in the proper way, without confusion.

Comment on this

I think there is a case for something being inserted here to let the person know but I think it should more appropriately be put in, perhaps, in Section 28 and if the Deputy would agree, I will try to draft an amendment for Report Stage.

Comment on this

This is Section 28. Is the Minister suggesting that a more appropriate amendment may be put into Section 28?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this

This is a very important section. We ought to be told something about it.

Comment on this

This is one of the sections that are readopted from a previous enactment—Section 144 of the Public Health (Ireland) Act, 1878. There is no change made as far as the present law is concerned, as far as I know. It is merely a redraft, as some of these sections are. It is thought necessary that we should have control over a person selling or letting a dwelling after infection. I do not think there is any more arising out of it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say if there has ever been any case before the courts in this matter?

Comment on this

I do not know of any.

Comment on this

Since 1878?

Comment on this

I do not know of any.

Comment on this

All right. There is to be no change in policy?

Comment on this

We do not intend to apply some of these sections to all diseases. For instance, you would not apply this section, let us say, to a case of influenza. Tuberculosis or typhus would be examples where you would apply the section.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister does the insertion of the section in this Bill imply any change of policy?

Comment on this

No, none. It is just in order to rescind one of the old Acts it is brought in again.

Comment on this

Where there has been a very serious case of tuberculosis, say, a whole family being infected with tuberculosis, and where it is inevitable that the disease will remain in the home notwithstanding the disinfection that may be carried out, what is the policy of the Department with regard to that particular dwelling? The safest way to get rid of the disease is to blow the house up.

Comment on this

In a case like that I would have to take the advice of the medical officer. If he says it can be disinfected, very well, but if he says that nothing short of destruction will suffice then it must be destroyed.

Comment on this

The same principle applies to Section 30 as applies to Section 29?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:—

To delete sub-section (2) and substitute the following sub-section:—

(2) In this section, the word "premises" includes a temporary dwelling.

The deletion of sub-section (2) is consequential on amendment No. 3, because the definition was put into the definition section of what the dwelling should be, and in addition to that amendment here includes a temporary dwelling.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 27:—

In sub-section (2), page 18, line 38, to add at the end of paragraph (e) the words "for which he acts and to the health authority of the area in which the patient is detained and to the appropriate person."

If his first amendment is merely a drafting amendment—

"where the committing officer amends the order, he shall forthwith send a copy of the order as amended to the Minister and to the health authority for which he acts and to the health authority of the area in which the patient is detained and to the appropriate person."

The case of a person outside his own area being dealt with was overlooked in that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No 28 standing in the name of Deputy Cosgrave:—

In sub-section (2), paragraph (g) (iii), line 55, to delete all words after the word "patient" down to and including the word "test" in line 57.

Comment on this

Could we leave that amendment over until we discuss the surgical question?

Comment on this

The Minister wants amendments Nos. 28, 29 and 30 postponed until we discuss amendment No 31.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 31 is to delete the sub-section relating to surgical treatment.

Comment on this

Is the Minister accepting, say, amendments Nos. 29 and 30?

Comment on this

As regards amendments Nos. 29 and 30——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What about amendment No. 28 first, in order to preserve the continuity.

Comment on this

We withdraw the amendment for the moment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:—

In sub-section (2), paragraph (g) (iii), line 57, after the word "test" to add the words "the consent of the patient having been obtained".

Sub-section (3), paragraph (g) (iii), as it reads at the moment, says that where an order is made it will be possible to carry out the medical examination of the patient and the taking from him of blood or other specimens for examination or test. My proposal is that there will be added after that "the consent of the patient having been obtained". If amendment No. 29 is passed, the patient will have to give his consent before the medical examination is carried out or before the taking from him of blood or other specimens for examination or test. I submit that that is quite a reasonable amendment to insert and I would find it very difficult to understand the circumstances in which the Minister would insist that a patient would be medically treated contrary to his own willingness or that blood or other specimens would be taken from him contrary to his own consent.

Comment on this

I can understand the Deputy's argument when he says that this power is hardly required. That is medical examination, the taking of blood or other specimens for examination or test without the consent of the person concerned. What we had in mind in putting in this was the clearing up of diseases. We had some hopes that when this Bill was passed we might be able to deal with some of those people who are spreading venereal disease. Such people are rather intractable and rather uncooperative when they are taken into hospital. The only possibility of dealing with them in an effective and expeditious manner is to get blood tests. Blood tests are absolutely essential in such cases where there is a suspicion of syphilis or other venereal disease. I cannot see that a doctor will have to rely on that particular subparagraph in any particular case apart from that but I do think that it might be necessary in such a case. A blood test is required also for some other diseases but it is very unlikely that resistance would be offered. For instance in a case of suspected tuberculosis a blood test might be required. That also applies to typhus. One of the tests for typhus is the Weil Felix test for which blood is required. Of course, with regard to typhoid, blood culture is necessary. For diphtheria swabs from the nose and throat are required. Blood is necessary for testing purposes in three or four of those diseases. I do not anticipate any trouble whatever, except in regard to venereal disease. If we want to get the person's consent it is hardly necessary to put it in the Bill at all.

Comment on this

I thought that the Minister might have had the question of typhus or smallpox in mind. Outside of these I could not see why the Minister might want to press any other aspect of it. The Minister's remarks in regard to venereal disease give a new aspect to this case and I think, Sir, I would like to consider it further. I would like the Minister to reconsider the whole question and have some further consultations on the matter. In view of that, I do not want to press amendment No. 29.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:—

In sub-section (2), paragraph (g), (iv), line 58, to add after the word "patient" the words "the consent of the patient having been obtained".

I am moving this to hear what the Minister has to say on it. I am thinking here of the consent of the patient in a case of inoculation or immunisation.

Comment on this

As Deputies are aware, getting consent means getting the consent of the parent. If amendment No. 29 or amendment No. 30 were accepted by the Dáil it would mean that the medical officer in charge of the institution would have to get the consent before taking a blood test or a specimen, or before immunising or inoculating. I do not think there would be much of a case against amendment No. 30 if it were dealing with adults. Let us suppose, however, that there was a very bad outbreak of diphtheria and that children were being brought into the hospital hourly. In that situation the doctor knows that it is not a matter of hours but of minutes to give the necessary inoculation in order to try and cure the patient. If he has to go through the formality of getting the parent's consent it may possibly mean the death of the child. I mention these as some of the difficulties that we are up against. Perhaps we could get an amendment that, in the case of a child, the parent's consent should be got if practicable. Deputies, I am sure, will realise that it would be a terrible thing if a doctor were faced with the position that he had to let a child die because the parent's consent was not available.

Comment on this

Would the Minister be prepared to accept the amendment if it ran in this way: "the consent of the patient having been obtained, or, in the case of a child, the consent of the parent or other appropriate person, if practicable".

Comment on this

I would like to say that there may be various other contingencies that may not occur to me at the moment, but I will consider that before Report Stage.

Comment on this

I am trying to get the Minister's mind on the matter, and I do not want to press him at this stage. I would be content if an amendment on the lines I have indicated were accepted by the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:—

In sub-section (2), to delete paragraph (h).

On the Second Reading I drew attention to paragraph (h) which says:—

"no surgical treatment of the patient shall be carried out during his detention except with the consent of the appropriate person."

I said then that I would like Deputies to consider that paragraph and to help me, if possible, to get over certain difficulties that I foresaw. First of all we must consider what we mean by consent. In the case of an adult we mean the consent of that person himself. As far as this Bill is concerned, an adult person is any person over 16. Consent, in the case of a child, would mean the consent of the parent or guardian, and in the case of a person of unsound mind, the consent of the parent or guardian. There cannot be much objection to a section like this where you are dealing with adult people, but there would be a very strong objection where you are dealing with a person of unsound mind or a child. I should have said, perhaps, that there would not be any strong objection if the adult person were conscious himself, but if he were unconscious another difficulty would arise. In a bad diphtheria case, for example, it is sometimes necessary to do a tracheotomy to save a child from smothering, and that tracheotomy has to be done suddenly and rapidly when the time comes. If the patient is an adult person over 16 and is practically unconscious at the time, you cannot properly get his consent. You may assume his consent by indicating to him in some way that you are going to do a tracheotomy. If he does not make any answer, you may go ahead. If, however, the patient is a person of unsound mind, or a child, you must under the Bill get the consent of the parent or guardian. That may place the doctor in a difficult position because there is not time to get the consent. In that connection, I would like Deputies to bear in mind that during the severe storms of last winter several parts of the country were isolated. It would have been impossible to get in touch with the parents of children in hospitals from some counties for ten or 12 days, even though an operation for, say, appendicitis might have been urgently necessary. You could not wait for the parent's consent.

Deputies will see that there are great difficulties in leaving the section in the Bill at all. What I would urge on them is to rely on the law as it stands because I think it is all right. I would like to tell Deputies what the law is at the moment. First of all, a surgeon who performs an operation against a person's will commits an assault and is liable to an action for damages. Therefore, if you allow the law to stand as it is an adult person is quite well protected because if he refuses to allow the surgeon to operate he is as well protected by the law as it is as he would be by the law we are passing now. In the case of a child, or of a person of unsound mind, if a surgeon were to attempt to operate without getting the consent of the guardian or parent it would be equivalent to an assault. In any case where an adult person is in a position to decide for himself, or in any case where the surgeon might reasonably look for the parent's or guardian's consent, he has no right to do the operation. If he does an operation on a child in a case where he could have looked for the parent's consent, the parent can accuse him of an assault for doing the operation.

The next point is that if a patient is incapable of exercising a discretion— that is where the patient is unconscious —and if he is an adult and an immediate operation is necessary to save his life, then the surgeon does not commit an assault if he performs the operation. The surgeon is guilty, or may be guilty, of malpractice in such a case if he operates where it is not necessary or essential. Under the present law, therefore, where he is up against a proposition of that kind, he usually gets the opinion of another medical man so that if anything should go wrong with the operation he can be protected by having at least another medical man to corroborate his view that the operation was essential. The same thing applies to the guardian of a young person as it does to an adult person in his own case.

The law is as I have given it, but we have very few recorded cases of actions.

There was one case where a surgeon proposed to do an operation for goitre on a young person and he told the parents that he thought the operaction was necessary and said it could be done with a local anæsthetic. The parents agreed to that, but while he was operating the child lost his nerve and got uncontrollable and they had to order a general anæsthetic before they could finish the operation and the child died. The parents in that case did not allege any negligence, but took an action against the surgeon on the ground that they had consented only to an operation by a local anæsthetic and he had, as it were, broken his contract. In that particular case, the parents lost the action.

I just wanted to state the law on the point and I would urge very strongly that we should leave the law as it is. I think that Deputies will agree that a person is very well protected. As I have said, in the case of an adult person, no surgeon can operate upon him as the law stands, unless he wants to commit an assault, and no person can operate on a young person or on a person of unsound mind without the consent of the parent or guardian. The present law has the advantage that, in a case of urgent necessity, the surgeon, after getting the opinion of another doctor if the other doctor is available, will perform the operation, if he thinks it is absolutely necessary, and only if he thinks it is absolutely necessary.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept the Minister's argument as fairly sound. This section deals with the treatment of people who have been declared to be a possible source of infection and ordered to subject themselves to detention and isolation. We are dealing with things that may happen after this Bill has been put into operation. I do not think we need introduce any additional regulations or safeguards in the ordinary way to protect the ordinary people against the medical profession. The outline of the law position as it stands at the moment is, I take it, an outline of a state of affairs which has worked satisfactorily in regard to people who have their freedom.

There is always a feeling that people who have been detained and isolated in a compulsory way may tend to be brought under a more rigorous system of treatment than people who are free. If the Minister's intention is to leave the position between the patient and the doctor or surgeon, even though the patient may be under detention or isolation, exactly as it is where there is no compulsory detention or isolation, then from the point of view of safeguarding the person and the will of the person concerned that should be regarded as satisfactory.

The manner in which this point was originally presented has, perhaps, coloured people's minds with regard to things which might or might not happen, but I accept the Minister's statement now, that the intention is that the relationship in law between patient and doctor will stand under Section 34 as it would stand if they were ordinary patients of the doctor.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Does it mean that the previous Act still stands? It is not repealed?

Comment on this

No. It is the common law and practice. In fact, it would be very hard to change it, if one tried.

Comment on this

I move amendment No 32:—

In paragraph (o) of sub-section (2), page 19, line 34, to insert before the word "the," the words "where an appeal is made under paragraph (j) of this sub-section".

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 33 and 34 are consequential.

Comment on this

I do not know if this section will be very much used. It may be used at a particular time or in a particular district. If people are nominally forced into hospital, probably by the time they arrive there they have got over the compulsion part and are fairly contented to settle down and get well. They have the regulation handed to them and know they can appeal to the Minister. I think it should be sufficient if the Minister sends his officer down where there is an appeal, but he should not have to go automatically to visit a case.

Comment on this

I move amendment 33:—

In subparagraph (i) of paragraph (o) of sub-section (2), page 19, line 37, to delete the words "patient is detained," and substitute therefor the words "appeal is received by the Minister."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 34:—

In subparagraph (ii) of paragraph (o) of sub-section (2), page 19, line 39, to insert before the word "not", the word "thereafter".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 35:—

In sub-section (2), paragraph (o) (ii), line 39, to delete the words "three months" and substitute the words "one month".

If a person is detained, he should be entitled to an examination at least once every month. As it stands, he may be detained for a period of three months. If he recovers at the end of the first month, he may still have two months more in an institution or of incarceration in some form. So as to avoid any possibility of a person being detained longer than is actually necessary on account of the illness or infection, the examination should be at least once a month. That would prevent any possibility of excessive delay.

Comment on this

First of all, the Deputy may take it for granted that the medical people or the charitable institution will be only too glad to get rid of any person as quickly as they can. However, I think that three months is a long time and maybe we could compromise on six weeks.

Comment on this

Very well.

Amendment altered to:—

In sub-section (2), paragraph (o) (ii), line 39, to delete the words "three months" and substitute the words "six weeks".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 36:—

In sub-section (3), page 19, line 46, to delete the words and figures "paragraphs (c) and (h) of sub-section (2) of".

This is a purely drafting amendment. There is no necessity to confine it to paragraphs (c) and (h).

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 37:—

In sub-section (3), page 19, to insert before paragraph (c) the following new paragraph:—

(c) where the patient, being 16 years of age or over, is for any reason unable to act for himself—the person for the time being in charge of the patient.

This is the point to which I have already referred—the adult over 16 years who is not capable of speaking for himself, such as a person of unsound mind and so on.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38:—

In paragraph (c) of sub-section (4), page 20, line 7, to insert before the word "from" the words "or attempts to escape".

It is felt that this phrase should be included.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 39:—

In paragraph (b) of sub-section (5), page 20, line 16, to delete the words "the escape" and substitute therefor the words "an escape or an attempted escape".

This is the same point.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:—

In sub-section (7), page 20, line 30, to delete the words "of this section".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

In sub-section (2) (j), provision is made for the making of an appeal for release to the Minister by a person detained and, in the subsequent paragraphs, there are arrangements for deciding such an appeal. I want to appeal to the Minister to reconsider this, with a view to ensuring that such an appeal will come before the national health council for review. I am not suggesting that each appeal should be decided by the council, but rather that the Minister should decide each appeal in consultation with the national health council. That would mean only a minor alteration of sub-section (2) (m) to provide that the Minister should consult the council before taking a decision.

The important thing to remember in connection with this section is that you will be dealing with people in a somewhat different class from those who have been detained because of infectious disease in the past. You will be dealing with people suffering from tuberculosis who might be detained for, perhaps, years and there are many important issues to be considered. For example, a person might claim that he would be in a position to safeguard his health and that of the community in his own home and there might be room for a wide divergence of opinion. For that reason, it is desirable that a more independent body than the Minister should have an opportunity of considering such a claim.

Comment on this

The objection I put forward some time ago to being compelled to put things to the health council applies all the more to the case now raised by the Deputy. We can only expect the council to meet at regular intervals and we could hardly justify calling the council together to consider an appeal of this kind; but, in any case, I am afraid that, even if we did as the Deputy suggests, the council would be entirely guided by whatever report I submitted to it. If I submitted a report that it was extremely dangerous to allow such and such a person out, what could the council do but say: "Keep him in"? If I submitted a report stating that he should be let out, all they could say would be: "Let him out." Deputies need have no great fear in this matter, because, as they know, all our institutions are overcrowded at the moment and there is a desire on the part of medical men to get people out of these institutions as soon as they can. There is no desire to keep them longer than is necessary. There is the further safeguard, in case there is any suggestion that the medical officer of health in a particular area might be over-cautious, that the medical inspector of the Minister would go down and try to keep things uniform in the various institutions. I think it should be left at that. I should like to refer again to what I said on Second Reading, that this section has been operating since 1940 in the form of an Emergency Powers Order. There were 38 cases dealt with and we never had the slightest complaint from any of the people involved. They all thought they were fairly well treated and that they had got out as they should have got out.

Comment on this

Were they all tinkers?

Comment on this

I do not think so. They were mainly typhoid carriers.

Comment on this

I should like to stress again our concern in this matter, because, while we appreciate some of the difficulties which exist in the practical application of the law, we are concerned with a fundamental principle, the violation of the fundamental right of the individual, his absolute power over his own body and the danger of permitting the State to violate that right. The Minister has pointed out certain difficulties in the case of persons unable to give their consent with regard to surgical treatment and certain difficulties under sub-section (2), paragraph (g) (iii), but, no matter what the difficulties are, I think the Minister ought to have amendments in connection with them very fully examined before Report Stage, because it is a very grave matter for an assembly of this sort to put into legislation sections which may violate these fundamental principles. While practical difficulties must be met and solved, every effort should be made by the Minister and his Department to preserve these fundamental rights. With regard to sub-section (7), I should like to inquire what financial provision will be made. The sub-section requires a local authority to finance the cost of the maintenance and treatment of persons under the section. Does that mean that the local authority is to be called on to finance this treatment fully?

Comment on this

All the expenditure under this section will be on a half-and-half basis.

Comment on this

The Minister indicated, on the Financial Resolution, that the cost of the provisions in relation to infectious diseases under the Act would be about £150,000. Is that a conservative estimate?

Comment on this

It is very hard to say whether it is or not, but we have to make a guess.

Comment on this

That is the estimate the Minister gave the House today?

Comment on this

Yes, of the State half.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think that, in view of these very elaborate provisions and the inevitable high cost of carrying them out, it is fair to throw 50 per cent. of the cost on the rate-paying community?

Comment on this

I should like to impress on Deputies that I do not think there will be very much cost under this section. There are two diseases as to which I think Deputies will probably agree that very drastic action must be taken. One of these is typhus, which is a very infectious disease. You have to clean up a whole district. You may have to remove people and sometimes burn their houses in order to get rid of the disease. The same thing applies to small-pox. You have other diseases where it may be necessary, such as tuberculosis and diphtheria and, possibly, infantile paralysis. Then there is the other case, that of venereal disease, where it will be absolutely necessary if we want to clean up the disease. There is no chance, I am afraid, of cleaning up that disease except we get the prostitutes into some institution where they can be treated and that can only be dealt with under this section.

Comment on this

I should like to remind the Minister, on the question of cost, that it is not in the interest of a particular county you are doing it, but in the national interest. Whatever expenditure is incurred is in the national interest so as to prevent the spread of infection outside the bounds of a county. On that basis, I think the contribution ought to be greater than 50 per cent. from central funds. When the Minister is throwing it back on a county, he is throwing it back mainly on a particular section of the community.

Comment on this

The contribution varies. In the case of tuberculosis, 50 per cent. is contributed by the State. In the case of venereal disease, the State contributes 75 per cent. As Deputies know, a White Paper has been promised, and I hope it will be possible to have it circulated in three or four weeks' time. When that White Paper comes along, we will be able to get down to this question of the proper rational financing between local authorities and the State in connection with all these things.

Comment on this

What will the White Paper deal with?

Comment on this

One of the things the White Paper will deal with is the financing of the services.

Comment on this

Will we see the White Paper before the Estimate?

Comment on this

I am afraid not.

Comment on this

When the Minister speaks of typhus and small-pox as the principal diseases we may have to tackle, the question arises as to whether, when dealing with a particularly heavy piece of work in a rather localised area, 50 per cent. of the cost should fall on the local authorities. From the financial point of view, it is not a local problem related to the local position. If the expense in connection with a serious epidemic of typhus was very great, it would be unfair to ask the local authorities to bear 50 per cent. of the cost. Small-pox would be a matter of a crisis and it would be unfair to impose the cost of a crisis like that on the local authority. Venereal disease has a social stigma attaching to it. When the Minister talks about facing up to the problem drastically, I doubt if it can be dealt with entirely on the basis of the local authority knowing 50 per cent. about the matter and the State knowing the other 50 per cent. and bearing the cost in that relation. If there is any kind of a serious problem with regard to venereal disease to be dealt with, I do not think it can be dealt with out of the local rates. If it has to be brought out in the open, there will be simply concealment and avoidance and the Minister will fail to deal with any problem that may arise out of that diesease.

Comment on this

I should like to say that our proposals are not quite ready yet for publication, but I think they will show anyway that the increased cost for health services will be divided between the State and the local authority. The result will be that there will be very little increase on the local authorities for all these new services; that the greater part of the expenditure will fall on the State as time goes on.

Comment on this

That means that there will be a further favourable adjustment?

Comment on this

There will be a much better percentage anyway.

Comment on this

We will wait and see.

Comment on this

So far as I can gather, there seems to be no provision for any choice on the part of a person who is to be detained in the institution in which he may be detained. If possible, I think that some choice should be given. We all know that it is desirable, wherever possible, to give the citizen the choice of a doctor.

Comment on this

There might be only one institution.

Comment on this

In many cases it is possible that there may be only one institution for the particular disease, but in the case of certain diseases there may be two or three, and it would be desirable to give a patient some voice in the selection of the institution.

Comment on this

I think it would be extremely difficult to give a choice in a case like this.

Comment on this

There is very little choice anyway.

Comment on this

This section provides for the disposal of the remains of a person who dies in an institution. There does not appear to be anything in this section with regard to the disposal of the clothing of persons who die from an infectious disease. I am not sure if there is any provision in any other part of the Bill. I think that in this section at least there should be some definite provision to ensure that the clothing of persons who die from an infectious disease is not allowed to fall into the hands of other people. It is only two or three days ago that a case was brought to my notice of a perfectly healthy man who purchased a suit of clothing at a stand in a public fair and within three days he was down with infantile paralysis and subsequently died. I did not get an opportunity to inquire into the full facts of the case and I do not know whether infantile paralysis can be conveyed by clothing or not. I think it is important that we should ensure that the clothing of persons who die from an infectious disease is not put on the market and sold.

Comment on this

That is dealt with in the Second Schedule.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 41:—

In sub-section (2), page 20, line 54, to delete the word "shelter" and substitute therefor the word "accommodation".

The word "shelter" crept in from some old Act. "Accommodation" I think is the proper word.

Comment on this

Could the Minister tell us whether he proposes to compensate people for any destruction of their equipment?

Comment on this

We will come to that on Section 100.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 42:—

Before Section 37 to insert the following new section:—

(1) A health authority may make provision for the training and education of persons suffering or recovering from an infectious disease for employment suitable to their condition of health and for that purpose may provide and maintain such premises, workshops, farms, gardens, materials, equipment and similar facilities as are necessary.

(2) The Minister may by order direct a health authority as to the manner in which and the extent to which they are to exercise their powers under sub-section (1) of this section and such health authority shall comply with such direction.

This is the section which, I mentioned, had been inadvertently left out of the Bill. It deals with the rehabilitation of persons suffering or recovering from infectious disease. The section is fairly obvious to anybody who reads it. The idea of rehabilitation was referred to by Deputies on every side of the House and there was a desire that this section should be inserted.

Comment on this

Does this apply particularly to the training and education of persons suffering from tuberculosis?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Or any other diseases?

Comment on this

And infantile paralysis.

Comment on this

Who bears the cost in these cases?

Comment on this

That will be dealt with in the White Paper with regard to cost. At the moment it would be the local authority.

Comment on this

Half and half?

Comment on this

In the case of tuberculosis it would be half and half.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 43:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:——

(3) A charge under sub-section (2) of this section for the attendance of a nurse on any person may be recovered as a simple contract debt in any court of competent jurisdiction from—

(a) such person or, in case such person has died, his legal personal representative, or

(b) any other person liable to maintain such person for the purposes of the Public Assistance Act, 1939 (No. 27 of 1939), by virtue of Section 27 of that Act or, in case such other person has died, his legal personal representative.

This is a necessary corollary to (2) (b). I think it was referred to by some Deputies on Second Reading and they suggested that it should be put in to safeguard the position.

Comment on this

Is it the local authority decides the rate of charge for the individual?

Comment on this

Yes, the local authority.

Comment on this

I take it this is intended to apply in cases where the local authority provides nurses for attendance on persons suffering from infectious diseases other than in institutions; that is, where the local authority would provide a nurse at a person's home or elsewhere?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It might, in its present wide terms, be read that where nurses were provided to deal with cases compulsorily detained under Section 34 a charge might be made.

Comment on this

There is no charge there.

Comment on this

The section reads:

"A health authority may provide nurses for attendance on persons suffering from infectious disease."

Then it says that they may make a charge for that. Does the Minister think that will require amendment?

Comment on this

No, I do not think so.

Comment on this

I should like to inquire, on Section 37, if the Minister will elaborate on the policy with reference to charging and the discretion given to the local authority. The discretion will be given to the county manager, and my experience is that some county managers are pressing rather unduly on people who find it difficult to pay for treatment in an institution. The council have little or no discretion in the matter, and I think the Minister ought to have some definite policy. It may look all right from one point of view that the county manager is pressing for contributions, but if you carry that to extremes it may become a hardship.

Comment on this

The section covers cases where a local authority, for some reason, must treat a person in his own home and provide a nurse; that is, when the person cannot be removed, being either too ill to be removed or for lack of accommodation in the hospital. Having provided the nurse, they can make a charge. The Deputy's point is that the county manager will have too much discretion with regard to the charge. I may say this whole matter will be fixed up in the White Paper. It will deal with what will be the county organisation with regard to health and the proposals for that will be published.

What the Deputy feels is that somebody must have discretion to make a charge. I do not know whether we should leave the discretion to the local authority or whether it should be covered by legislation, but there must be some discretion. You cannot just say to the local authority: "You must charge something" or "You need not charge anything". There must be discretion.

Question agreed to.

SECTION 38.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 44:—

In line 24, after the word "satisfied" to delete the brackets and words down to and including the word "defendant" in line 25.

I think the provisions in this section are extremely undesirable. It is a generally accepted maxim in criminal law that if a person is prosecuted the State must prove the charge before that person can be found guilty. In civil proceedings if one individual takes an action against another he must prove whatever he alleges before he is entitled to sustain his action. Under this section if one person becomes infected as a result of contact with another and subsequently the infected person takes an action for damages against the other person for not taking adequate precautions to prevent people becoming infected, the responsibility of satisfying the court lies on the defendant. I cannot think of any Act in which the onus is placed on the defendant, with the exception of certain stringent provisions in the Offences Against the State Act which, I think, is now being repealed. In a criminal prosecution the onus always rests on the State and in a civil prosecution on the plaintiff. In this case the onus is transferred to the defendant.

I quite agree it would be undesirable that a person who infects another should be enabled, by reason of the phraseology of legislation, to get away without any penalty. When a person has been infected as a result of another person's neglect, by reason of the fact that the other person omitted to take precautions, there should be some remedy for a grievance of that sort. The onus should be allowed to remain as it has always remained in normal circumstances, on the plaintiff. If a person is taking adequate precautions and is in a position to say that he has not exposed himself to any risk of infection, then the onus of proving that the infection was due to the neglect of the defendant should lie on the plaintiff. I think the Minister should accept this amendment and I would like to hear strong reasons given before we can allow this section to remain as it is.

Comment on this

I recognise, of course, that the Deputy makes a very strong case from the point of view of ordinary legal practice but I should like the Deputy to consider the person who has a grievance in these cases. For instance, let us say that a landlord has a room to let in which there has been a case of typhus or small-pox—I am putting an extreme case. He was informed that he should take every precaution to disinfect it but he took no precautions and let the room that night. I do not think that that particular landlord deserves very much sympathy and we should not enable him to get off with some technical defence in court. In other words, we should put the onus on him to prove that there is no neglect on his part. I am told that there are other examples or provisions of this kind in the Transport Act but I do not want to argue the case on precedent. I want to put it on its own merits. I think that a person who is likely to give infection to another person should take every precaution to prevent that and if he does not take that precaution, well we should not have too much sympathy with him. After all he may be endangering the life of another person by not taking precautions. The trouble is that I am told that people have got off in the past on some such technical point, that after all the onus was on the prosecution to show whether they were responsible or not. I do not think we would be going too far if we put the onus on the person who has been responsible for the particular infection.

Comment on this

The Minister is taking an extreme case.

Comment on this

The Deputy will admit that if it is not an extreme case the court will not be too hard on the person charged.

Comment on this

The only point about the extreme case is that once the case is brought to court the court will have no option even in cases where there is considerable doubt, but to decide it in accordance with the provisions of the Act. It is perfectly true that if a person has a room which has been occupied by a person infected with typhoid or typhus, and if he subsequently lets that room without taking proper precautions, to another person who may become infected, the owner should not be allowed to escape responsibility for his neglect, but there is an alternative means of checking neglect and that is to have a penalty imposed on the person responsible. Again the person who became infected would have a good cause of action against the landlord in that particular case. At the same time the Minister or the local authority could prosecute the landlord. Certainly it would not alter the opportunity which an infected person would have of taking action and recovering damages against a landlord who is responsible for any lack of the necessary precautions.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

I have every sympathy with the section with which this amendment deals when it tries, I take it, to prevent infected people from infecting others. I think in the past the law did not go into that matter very closely because I do not suppose that medical science, until quite recently, knew how people were infected with very many diseases. Medical scientists just knew people got diseases but they did not know how they got them. Although I should like to see every effort made to prevent people from infecting others, I think the section would be strong enough without putting this onus on the person charged. It seems to me that you might leave a citizen open to what the Americans call a frame-up. This provision might make it rather easy for certain persons to pretend that they were infected in the hope that they might get some notoriety or damages out of it. I sympathise very much with the efforts made to prevent people from infecting others but I think Deputy Cosgrave's amendment would leave the strong part of the section still there.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister whether the section applies to infected persons only. Must a person who becomes liable to these penalties have been infected himself? Otherwise, the section would open a very wide door. Take the case of a milk purveyor. He might possibly be charged with not taking the necessary precautions to prevent milk from becoming infected and spreading typhoid.

Comment on this

It only refers to a person who has been asked to take precautions.

Comment on this

A cow keeper is compelled to take precautions to prevent his milk from becoming infected and becoming a possible source of typhoid. If it can be proved afterwards that he did not take the necessary precautions, if it is found that his milk is infected, and that typhoid may be spread as a result, under this section he is left open without any prior knowledge on his part to action by persons who may become infected with typhoid. I want to put that aspect of the case. Is it only a person who has been infected with disease who must take precautions or can any member of the community who fails to take precautions in that respect, become liable under this section?

Comment on this

The point Deputy Allen has made is a good one. In cases where vendors of milk are prosecuted, very often the vendor, a retailer or a wholesaler, may have got the milk from another supplier. If you follow the passage of the milk from the byre to the ultimate seller, it may happen that the infection began a considerable distance from the person who is actually prosecuted. In fact the usual case is that a person purchases milk which is found to be deficient in fats while that person may have treated it properly or may not have interfered with it in any way. The milk was originally deficient. In cases of this kind, it may well happen that action will be taken against a person who had himself taken adequate precautions but the milk might have been infected before it reached him. I think the point Deputy Allen made is worthy of examination. I cannot say that the same thing is likely to happen in the case of letting a room, but in the case of food it is quite likely that the particular commodity was affected by contact at a far earlier period than that at which it reached the individual against whom the action is taken or against whom proceedings might be taken subsequently.

Comment on this

It must be remembered that this refers only to offences under this part of the Act—that is, against infectious diseases regulations. Where a person is asked to take precautions and where he fails to take such precautions and another person suffers damages as a result, all these conditions must be fulfilled.

With regard to the case Deputy Cosgrave raised, I would like to put it this way: If you like, it is a rather serious case I am taking. I am taking the case of a man who has let a room having failed to take the precaution to disinfect after a case of typhus, or as might be more likely, after a case of tuberculosis, and the incoming tenant gets the disease. The difference between us is this: under the present law that incoming tenant can take action against the landlord and can sue him for damages, but he must prove that he has suffered as a result of the neglect of the landlord. He never succeds under the present law because, when the question is put to him: "Could you not have got it elsewhere?" he cannot say no; he must admit it is possible that he could have got it elsewhere. He may say he is almost certain that he got it in that house. That is not enough. The court must dismiss the case because it is not conclusive. I must say the landlord, in such a case, was very negligent in exposing people to great damage and I do not think it is too hard on him to say that the landlord must prove that he did not get it there. In other words, instead of putting the question to the complainant, the court must put the question to the landlord: "Can you show that he was likely to get it elsewhere?" There is not much difference, but at least we are putting the onus on the landlord to argue that he may have got it elsewhere instead of making the complainant prove that he could not have got it elsewhere. There is not a lot of difference in fact, but there is a great deal of difference in a technical way as far as proving the case in court is concerned.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not consider making that section applicable to offences under Sections 29, 30, 31 and 32?

Comment on this

It is only to this part of the Act.

Comment on this

They are the sections of the Bill that apply to public dwellings.

Comment on this

The Minister says he must take the precaution. Is the precaution prescribed by the local authority? Supposing he takes the precaution and disinfects a house that has been inhabited by a family in which there were cases of tuberculosis and, notwithstanding his disinfecting the premises, the incoming tenant develops tuberculosis, is he responsible in that case?

Comment on this

If he proves to the court that he took the precaution, I think the case fails, as far as I can see.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

If he let him in under three months he may run the risk of such action.

Comment on this

If three months is prescribed, then he would be wrong.

Comment on this

Take the case of two persons suffering from an infectious disease travelling in a bus. A third person is in the bus and he is in contact with both. He becomes infected. He subsequently takes action against one of them because possibly he discovers that that individual is suffering from the infectious disease. He could have contracted it from either or, possibly, from both. In that particular case it might be impossible for the defendant to prove that he did not infect the person and, at the same time, it might well happen that the person had been infected as a result of the neglect of the other individual.

Comment on this

I suggest that it could be argued that the first section there applies to local authorities if the court held they did not do their job as they should.

Comment on this

Yes. The person might have an action against the local authority. That is true. In answer to what Deputy Cosgrave says, the last few lines would appear to be a good defence for the person he has in mind where he says the defendant could plead that it was unlikely that such failure caused such infection. I think he could argue that very strongly if there was a second equally potent source of infection.

Comment on this

It strikes me that this section is going to be better for the lawyers than for the doctors.

Comment on this

The doctor will be all right, too. He will be there as an expert witness.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 45:—

In paragraph (b) of sub-section (1), page 21, lines 30 and 31, to delete the words "under the supervision of a registered medical practitioner" and to substitute therefor the words "to the satisfaction of the chief medical officer of the health authority in which such person ordinarily resides".

This section deals with the maintenance of the relatives of a person who is ill with an infectious disease. I think Deputy Allen was one Deputy who pointed out on Second Reading that it was rather loosely worded and there seemed to be no proper person to control the expenditure under this section. We are putting the onus on the medical officer of health to certify that this maintenance should be allowed.

Comment on this

Might I ask who is meant there by "chief medical officer of health"?

Comment on this

The county medical officer of health.

Comment on this

Then should not it be, in conformity with this Bill, "chief medical officer" or "county medical officer," because in this Bill you are changing the title?

Comment on this

It is in the definition, I think.

Comment on this

But in your amendment you are keeping the old title whereas in your Bill you are changing it. "Of health" should be dropped.

Comment on this

The chief medical officer is either a county or State medical officer of health. We will look into it. It means a county medical officer or a county medical officer for a county borough. That is right.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 46:—

In sub-section (3), page 21, line 49, before the words "make provision" to insert the words "on application being made to them".

It would appear that the section as drafted would make it obligatory on the local authority to send this maintenance allowance to a person even if he never applied for it. I think it would be better that he should apply.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 47:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

() Every person who in connection with an application for provision for maintenance under this section makes any statement which is to his knowledge false or misleading in any material respect shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding £50 or at the discretion of the court to imprisonment for any term not exceeding six months or to both such fine and such imprisonment.

This is the usual amendment dealing with fraudulent claims through false information.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 48:—

In sub-section (1), page 22, line 25, to insert before the word "the", the words "either absolutely or subject to specified conditions".

This section, which deals with the treatment of infectious diseases in particular institutions, gives the Minister power to prohibit the treatment of infectious diseases in a particular institution. It was thought on reconsideration that where, say, an institution is rather isolated, it might be better to allow the Minister to make an exception. The amendment would enable us to make a regulation that would permit an infectious disease to be admitted in certain circumstances, say, in the case of great urgency or perhaps if there was an outbreak in the area. At any rate, it is better, I think, to have this power of qualifying the Order.

Comment on this

You may have to use the institution for another purpose.

Comment on this