We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Health Bill, 1947—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 170–325 of 325. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Health Bill, 1947
Enacted

No. 11 of 1947 ›

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:—

To insert before sub-section (2), a new sub-section as follows:—

() An Order under this section shall not be made where the Minister is satisfied that adequate precautions are taken in any institution to prevent persons suffering from an infectious disease infecting other persons.

On Second Reading I mentioned that a number of hospitals—I think it is almost confined to teaching hospitals; certainly the point at issue affects teaching hospitals only—have different categories of patients in different wings or words. If a person or persons are suffering from a particular type of infectious disease, invariably, I think, adequate precautions are taken to ensure that these patients do not infect or come in contact with other patients. The advantage of that segregation is that medical students are in a position to view patients in the hospital and to diagnose the various types and stages of diseases. That experience helps them to diagnose rapidly particular diseases and to recognise the different stages of diseases and the various types of infection.

It has been put to me that if, under the regulations which the Minister has power to make under Section 40, a person suffering, say, from tuberculosis is prohibited from admittance to one of these hospitals, while it might be possible for the student to see such patients in other hospitals and to gain considerable experience from the point of view of diagnosis and from comparison with other patients which ordinarily enables a student to diagnose a particular stage in a disease or a particular type of a disease, that experience may be lost if restrictions are enforced and regulations are made whereby only patients suffering from some ordinary illness, or at any rate not an infectious disease, are entitled to be admitted to particular hospitals. I put this amendment forward so that hospital authorities—I think it is reasonable to assume that the medical profession would be anxious to take all necessary precautions—will take these precautions to ensure that no other patients become infected, thus making it possible for permission to be received or granted by the Department whereby these hospitals may have as patients in the hospital people suffering from infectious diseases.

Comment on this

It will be seen from the next amendment, amendment No. 50, that, possibly, Deputy Cosgrave and I had the same point in mind, although we may not have arrived at the same conclusion. In amendment No. 50 the word "institution" includes a department of an institution. I was rather anxious to meet the case made by Deputy Cosgrave, that is, that infectious diseases could be treated if no great danger existed in the institution and also the case made to me on behalf of some of the teaching hospitals. I thought the best way out of the difficulty would be to say that the word "institution" includes a department of an institution. In other words, that we do not think infectious diseases should be included in a particular department, but that they might be included in some other deparment. My objection to Deputy Cosgrave's amendment is one of administration more than anything else. It implies a good deal of inspection from time to time to see that there is no danger from infectious diseases being admitted. From the administrative point of view, my own amendment, which follows next, would be easier to work. We will say that there would be no objection in certain wards while there would be in other wards.

Comment on this

Does "department" in that context include "ward"?

Comment on this

Yes. I think we are both really aiming at the same thing.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(4) In this section, the word "institution" includes a department of an institution.

I have already explained this amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:—

Before sub-section (3) to insert the following sub-section:—

() A person shall be deemed conclusively to have reason to believe that he or any other person is verminous if he is notified accordingly by a medical officer of health or a health inspector.

The meaning of this amendment is fairly obvious. It simply means that if a person is notified that he is verminous, that is conclusive proof that he is, in case of any action.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:—

In sub-section (3), page 23, line 16, to delete the words "a person or" and substitute therefor the word "an".

A person is dealt with in Section 41. Cross out "a person or" and substitute "an", thus referring to the article only.

Comment on this

There is a provision in this section that where a district medical officer of health becomes aware that a child residing in his district is verminous, he may serve in the prescribed manner notice on the parent of the child prohibiting the attendance of the child at any school until such district medical officer gives a certificate (for which no charge shall be made) that the child is fit to attend school. I would ask the Minister to look into that sub-section and see that, in the issue of such a certificate no stigma is cast on the parent of that child. If a doctor issues a certificate which, I suppose, would have to be presented to the teacher of the school in order to explain the absence of the child definitely stating that the child is verminous, the matter will be more or less public property. In this connection I think a doctor would be unwilling to hurt the feelings of the person concerned. If, under this Act, a doctor will be compelled to notify the teacher or all concerned that the child is verminous, I think that it should be sufficient to declare in the certificate that the child is a probable source of infection or infectious disease and thus avoid, in some way or other, the issue of a certificate stating that the child is verminous. In my opinion that would be more agreeable even to the medical profession.

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy in the point he has made. As a matter of fact, we repealed an Act dealing with this subject—the Childern Act of 1908—largely for that very reason. In that case the authority could notify a manager that a child was verminous or was in a foul or filthy condition. We though those words were rather strong and we put them in a milder form. Although the Act is there, I am sure no doctor ever issued a certificate in those words.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied so long as there will be no compulsion to use the words.

Comment on this

I do not think so. I feel sure that a doctor would say that the child was not fit to attend school. Such conditions are very quickly cleaned up nowadays as a result of new treatment, D.D.T., etc.

Comment on this

I wonder, with regard to sub-section (1) if that sub-section has been very very carefully considered not only within the Department of Health but between the Department of Health and the Department of Education. I know and agree with the Minister that we have remedies to our hand at the moment which clean up the particular condition referred to very very rapidly. We are a long way from that knowledge being within the reach of everybody and of that material reaching everybody.

According to the definition of "verminous" in this Bill, a very slight condition constitutes a case of vermin. In certain areas at periods of the year we have a tremendous percentage of such cases in every school. If the section were to be applied in its fullness all over the country on Monday next, I do not think you would have a 5 per cent. attendance in most rural schools, certainly not until such time as the cleansing machinery had got going, with the medical authorities being made aware of the situation and with the necessary certificates of freedom being given to individuals. The section may be well intentioned, but it is much too far-reaching. There is ample information in the Minister's Department as to the percentage of school children affected with this particular condition and as to how slowly D.D.T. is getting into the homes of the people. It will take a good two years of intensive propaganda before it becomes an article of ordinary use in the home like soap and water. When we reach that point, then the number of verminous cases that we will have to deal with will be just 1 or 2 per cent. It would be reasonable to prohibit 1 or 2 per cent. from getting the benefits of education as long as they were suffering from that particular disability. It is not right, however, to prohibit 70 or 80 per cent. from getting such benefits. We do not feel too comfortable when discussing a thing like this in public, but the percentage of it is terribly high. If the section were to be implemented in a great number of areas at the present moment it would mean closing nearly all the schools. I am not opposed to it, but I am asking that full consideration be given not only to what is desired but to the immediate results.

Comment on this

What is the position with regard to a child who is suffering from ringworm and attends school? That can be very troublesome for other children.

Comment on this

There is power in the Bill to deal with that. With regard to what Deputy O'Higgins has said, I am inclined to agree with him that this section might do a great deal of harm. I do not think it is going to do a lot of good. I will consider whether I shall strike it out or not.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:—

In paragraph (b) of sub-section (1), page 24, line 4, to insert before the word "his" the words "or with the consent of".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56:—

In sub-section (1), page 24, line 10, to add at the end of paragraph (d) the words "or on the application of his agent".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 57:—

In sub-section (1), page 24, line 19, before the words "A health authority" to insert the words "For the purpose of the execution of their powers and duties under this Part of this Act" and to delete all the words from the word "for" in line 20 to the end of the sub-section and to substitute therefor the words "or may make arrangements with any person for the provision of such facilities".

This amendment will enable a local authority to employ an agent. The local authority may not have an expert rat catcher in its employment. This will enable it to employ one.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 58:—

In paragraph (a) of sub-section (6), page 26, line 35, to delete the word "which".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 59:—

In sub-section (1), page 28, line 12, after the word "Act" to insert the word "may" and in lines 13 and 18 to delete the word "may".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 60:—

In paragraph (b), page 28, line 56, to delete the word and figures "section 88" and substitute therefor the word and figures "Part IX".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 61:—

In paragraph (b), page 29, to delete lines 5 to 9 inclusive and substitute therefor the following:—

(iii) materials or articles used or intended for use in the preparation or manufacture of such food, which are diseased, contaminated or otherwise unfit for human consumption or which do not comply with the regulations.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 62:—

In paragraph (a) of sub-section (1), page 29, line 41, before the word "or" to insert the words "or bartered" and after the word "sale" to insert the words "or barter".

An article might be sold or bought, but may also be bartered and we want to cover that possibility.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 63:—

To add at the end of the section, a new sub-section as follows:—

() Where it appears to the authority or officer enforcing any provision of this Part of this Act or the regulations made thereunder that an offence has been committed in respect of which proceedings might be taken against some person but that such person could establish a defence under paragraph (d) of sub-section (1) of this section by proving that the offence complained of was due to an act or default of some other person, such authority or officer may take proceedings against that other person without taking proceedings against the first-mentioned person.

Where a person selling food has a warranty, this will make it possible to take action against the original seller of the food, the wholesaler or the manufacturer as the case may be, instead of taking the action against the seller of the food, that is, the retailer. It does not prevent the possibility of going back to the retailer if we find he has put us on a false errand.

Comment on this

There has been great need for the introduction of this amendment, but I think it is unwise for the Minister to take power to deal with retailers at all in such cases. We have had these cases up and down the country, particularly in connection with the infestation of certain foods by accri or mealmites and invariably the traders who got these containers were prosecuted. While it is true that a notice could be served under the food and drugs code whereby the manufacturers could be prosecuted, there were many legal difficulties. When this matter can be traced to the manufacturers and when it is solely their fault, and when these packets go in sealed containers to the retailers, there should be no liability on the retailers, as they have no way of finding out whether the packets are up to the warranty or not.

Comment on this

That is what this amendment is intended to cover.

Comment on this

May I make this observation on the matter to which Deputy Moran so properly referred? I do not know whether public health authorities all over the country have yet awakened to the dilemma in connection with the preparations to which Deputy Moran referred. They are all preparations of the nature of custard powder or cornflour. The retailer and manufacturer is in this dilemma: you bring in corn starch from the Argentine, and there is no means known to science whereby any person, no matter how vigilant he may be, can discover infestation of that corn starch without the assistance of a microscope. The mites are not of the character which ordinarily occur in other cereal products. You may find mites in pig-meal and wheaten offals, which are tiny black objects easily perceivable, but the infestation of corn starch is by a creature which is truly microscopic.

What is a manufacturer or shopkeeper to do? The package of corn starch may on Monday be perfect and, without having broken the seal, without having interfered with the contents, a change takes place between Monday and Tuesday and if that sample is submitted to a public analyst and examined under a microscope it is found to be infested. It is a very serious hardship on perfectly conscientious distributors to hold them up to the public odium of making them criminally responsible for offering to the public a commodity of that character, when there is no precaution they can take, short of sending a sample every day to a public analyst—and even if that extravagant plan were adopted, they would not get the report back for at least 48 hours and so it would not be in time to stop the sale. Therefore, I suggest to the Minister that that problem is one deserving of very special consideration.

I would be interested if he would indicate whether he knows of any means whereby that problem can be met by manufacturers and distributors; and, if he does, whether he would consider addressing a circular to public health authorities throughout the country describing the method whereby the particular evil to which Deputy Moran refers can be reasonably overcome.

Comment on this

The section deals with all types of food and the amendment is put in to cover cases such as Deputies Moran and Dillon have in mind. Under the section as it stands, it would appear that public health authorities have to take action against whoever is selling the article. Now they will not have to do that—if there is a warranty they can go beyond him to the wholesaler, agent or manufacturer and take action at that level.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not think it is a hardship to make something an offence which is not within the control of the person to be prosecuted? If he consults the chemical experts and the biological experts of the Department, they will tell him that a package of corn starch may be, from the laboratory point of view, perfect on Monday and, with the seal unbroken, on Tuesday may present all the characteristics of infestation. Is it justice in these circumstances to hold that person criminally liable, when there is no possible precaution he can take which will avert that occasional occurrence? I do not for a moment suggest that the public health authority should not be vested with power to require him to dispose of the article once infestation is established and not to offer it for sale, but to prosecute him for having offered it for sale when there was no conceivable possibility of his having a guilty knowledge, seems to be a very extreme hardship and one of which the Minister should take special cognisance. Has the Minister had that particular problem brought to his attention before, in relation to corn starch?

Comment on this

Not that particular item. It would appear to be a question to be dealt with when we are fixing standards.

Comment on this

I take this opportunity to draw the Minister's attention to the peculiar problem of corn starch, as distinct from other cereals.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 64:—

In paragraph (c) of sub-section (3), page (30), line 54, before the word "club" to insert the word "restaurant".

This is to insert the word "restaurant" as well as "club", and the next amendment is to change the word "institution" to "establishment", which is the more appropriate word.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 65:—

In paragraph (c) of sub-section (3), page 30, line 55, to delete the word "institution" and substitute therefor the word "establishment".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 67:—

In sub-section (1), page 31, line 13, to delete the words "for use" and substitute therefor the words "which may be used".

This is to deal with the defence sometimes put up that a proprietary article was designed for use by animals.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 68:—

In sub-section (1), page 31, lines 16 to 18, to delete the words and brackets "(not being a therapeutic substance within the meaning of the Therapeutic Substances Act, 1932 (No. 25 of 1932),) which is sold for use" and substitute therefor the words "which may be used".

The Therapeutic Substances Act, 1932, deals with the manufacture and import of certain scheduled substances. It does not deal with the retailing of these preparations, and, if we were to leave the section as drafted, it would not be possible to cover, for instance, the sale of penicillin which is a commodity we may find it very necessary to deal with. The difficulty about some of these substances like penicillin is that, if used too widely, they may have the effect of developing bacteria resistant to penicillin which would create a very serious situation. Deputies will agree that penicillin is one of the things which may have to be regulated and we think it wise to cut out these words as set out in the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 69:—

In paragraph (a) of sub-section (3), page 31, line 30, to insert before the word "sale" where it first occurs the words "manufacture, preparation, importation, distribution".

Comment on this

What is the significance of this amendment and amendment No. 70?

Comment on this

We have been dealing so far only with manufacture and importation and we find that it would be very difficult to deal with these matters properly, unless we also deal with preparation and distribution.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 70:—

In paragraph (a) of sub-section (3), page 31, line 33, before the word "sale" to insert the words "manufacture, preparation, importation, distribution or".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 71:—

Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

() Save in so far as is provided for in sub-section (3) of this section no restriction shall be placed on the sale of medical preparations or of substances with proprietary designations by way of confining their distribution to members of specified trades to the exclusion of other wholesale and retail distributors.

This is an amendment of very great importance to a large body of deserving persons in the country. I refer to the retail merchants in rural Ireland. To begin with, I want to make it perfectly clear that, so far as the average country shopkeeper is concerned, he has no desire to limit the discretion of the Minister in the making of any regulation designed to prevent the reckless distribution of dangerous therapeutic substances, such as poisons or rare substances which ought to be used with due economy and consideration, such as penicillin, and this amendment is not designed in any sense to place restrictions of that character upon the Minister. On the contrary, it specifically provides that if a regulation is made by the Minister or with his approval, the retail shopkeeper is prepared to assume that it is done in the interests of the community at large and to accept it as such.

The problem to be cured by this amendment has a history. When the pharmaceutical chemists came to be recognised as a skilled body, a series of Acts of Parliament were passed from time to time giving to the person holding a diploma from the controlling body of the pharmaceutical chemists the right to dispense certain medicines and to deal in certain preparations, notably poisons, to the exclusion of the ordinary shopkeeper. This arrangement was justified on the ground that people should not be afforded an opportunity generally of purchasing poisons which might be used for felonious purposes, without at least leaving after them a record of their purchase, which should include a reasonable account of what they intended to use the poison for, and so, in every chemist's shop, there is a poison register and if a person goes in to buy strychnine to poison rats or arsenic to poison something els—if a farmer wants to lay poison on his land for the protection of sheep or a householder to lay poison for the destruction of vermin—he must declare his purpose to the chemist who will record the quantity of the poisonous substances supplied and the person purchasing must sign that he received it.

To these arrangements, no reasonable shopkeeper takes the slightest exception, but the original purpose of these arrangements was to ensure that people would not buy poisons for a felonious purpose, that is, to poison their neighbours. Then the pharmaceutical chemists' association proceeded to introduce a new finesse, that there was a different reason behind this—not only the purpose of deterring criminals who wanted to poison their neighbours but to deter desperate people from buying it to poison themselves. The moment you could establish that reason for these precautions, a glorious vista opened up, because, if we were prepared to control the sale of certain things in order to deter desperate people from destroying themselves, it was only a short step to saying that many people, without destroying themselves, can do themselves considerable injury and therefore we ought to confine to pharmaceutical chemists every comestible which, if improperly used, might do the purchaser an injury, and from that position it was a very short step to the position of saying that every therapeutic substance being consumed to excess is capable of doing the person who consumes it an injury and therefore every therapeutic substance ought to be confined to the chemist shop.

The chemists would defend it on the ground that aspirin, if you swallowed a bottle of it, would do you an injury. That is perfectly true, but when you come to examine the thing more closely, you discover that it was not primarily solicitude for the perils of the purchaser which was moving the pharmaceutical chemists, because the suggestion began to be made that things like cod liver oil should be confined to pharmaceutical chemists. The pharmaceutical chemist charged 4/6 for a 20-oz. bottle of cod liver oil and the poor, old, despised country shopkeeper only asked 2/6 for it. If you went in with a prescription to a chemist, when he compounded the prescription he put on the back of it a rubber stamp setting out the date and three or four little hieroglyphics, two of which gave him a reference in his prescription ledger, and two of which belonged to a code employed by every pharmaceutical chemist in the country which told any other chemist to whom that prescription might be brought how much the first fellow charged when he made it up. So that if you brought in a prescription to a chemist and he charged 3/6, he put a rubber stamp on the back and he managed to put a little cipher on it which would tell the next chemist: "Whatever else you do, do not charge this fellow less than 3/6 for the next bottle or you will scandalise me."

Comment on this

All the professions do the same.

Comment on this

There is nothing very criminal in that. They wanted to make their living. All I am asking is that commodities such as aspirin, cod liver oil, tooth paste and a variety of other diagnostic, prophylactic, and therapeutic substances, such as Parish's Food, Angier's Emulsion, Scott's Emulsion and castor oil should continue to be available as the stock-in-trade of the general merchant throughout rural Ireland so that he can make an honest profit out of trading in these things— I am not pretending that the general merchant is a disinterested benefactor of the community—and so that the people who live in his neighbourhood, if they find the chemist is charging too much for a 4-ounce bottle of castor oil can go down to the grocer and compare the grocer's price for a 4-ounce bottle of castor oil with that demanded by the chemist, as well as aloes and a variety of other salubrious therapeutic substances of that kind, at which I have no doubt Deputy Dr. Brennan would sometimes be tempted to look down his nose as being somewhat crude. But there are those in rural Ireland who find their constitution better provided for by a pennyworth of rhubarb and a halfpenny worth of aloes than they do by a bottle of Aliphan. They can get one remedy for 1½d.; a bottle of Aliphan will cost about 5/6, and the results are virtually identical. Glauber Salts and Epsom Salts are the stock-in-trade of thousands of shops throughout rural Ireland. I want to ensure that no Orders will be made restricting their sale which are designed to serve the profit-interest of the pharmaceutical chemist and not the protection of ordinary people. Therefore I move this amendment so as to ensure that no restrictions will be put upon the sale of these things with the Minister's approval.

The Minister may ask: "How can they put a restriction on the sale of these things? What power have they to make an order under the existing law?" None whatever. Like many a vested interest they have worked out a most subtle procedure in order to arrogate to themselves the power to make laws with no legal authority to do so. The subtle procedure is this: they go to the wholesale chemist and they say: "There are three therapeutic substances which are virtually interchangeable, the preparation, say, of Eli Lilly and Company, the preparation of Burroughs, Wellcome and Company, the preparation of Parke Davis and Company and the preparation of the United Drug Company. Now you will either undertake to sell only to the pharmaceutical chemist or the pharmaceutical chemist will not take your preparation at all." Suppose they go with that challenge to a toothpaste manufacturer and they say: "There are Colloidal, Euthymol and Gibbs' Dentifrice. Unless you agree to sell your dentifrice only to a pharmaceutical chemist, we will not touch it at all. Therefore, if a person comes into us for toothpaste, we shall sell him Euthymol. If he asks for Gibbs', we will win him away from Gibbs' and persuade him to take one of the two we stock."

Céad fáilte roimh an Teacht annseo, Deputy. I am sure the Deputy from Clonmel who has just come in will confirm the tale I am telling now. The pharmaceutical chemist will then succeed in establishing a monopoly in the sale of these particular commodities and ensure that no, what he would call, unreasonable competition will be set up against him by unskilled shopkeepers who surround him. The justification advanced by the pharmaceutical chemists is this: that the poor ignoramuses, the common shopkeepers, have not undergone the long period of training the pharmaceutical chemist has undergone; that they are ignorant creatures fit to sell flour, meal and domestic commodities of that character, but when it comes to selling tooth paste, on which there is a 50 per cent. profit, when it comes to selling aspirin, on which there is a very comfortable profit; when it comes to selling anything that is to be found in the pharmaceutical chemist's shop, on which there is never less than 30 and, usually, up to 50 and 70 per cent. profit, it requires a highly skilled and trained operative to ensure the safety of the public in its distribution. Where the profit is tuppence in 5/-, or a penny in the £, the common shopkeepers can handle that. Well now, common shopkeepers, of whom I glory to be one, make no claim to act as the custodians of poison goods or other therapeutic substances, which manifestly should be distributed under the direction and control of the Minister for Health. But they do expect their ready recognition of the necessity for that control will entitle them to protection from restrictive practices masquerading as control, but really designed to reserve to the aristocrats of the Pharmaceutical Society the most profitable lines which the general grocer in rural Ireland is in a position to sell. I think that is a reasonable request and it is for that reason I put this amendment down.

Comment on this

I do not think the Pharmaceutical Society ever suggested that the ordinary shopkeeper is an ignoramus. I never heard a pharmaceutical chemist suggest such a thing. The pharmaceutical chemist is merely asking that the sale of certain articles should be reserved to chemists who, undoubtedly, have to go through a long period of training, who have to attend courses of lectures and who have to pass examinations and obtain a certificate before they are entitled to keep open shop for the sale of these goods. If the ordinary shopkeeper wishes to embark on the sale of the goods which Deputy Dillon speaks of, he can form a limited company. The only condition is that he should have as managing director a pharmaceutical chemist. There is no reason in the world why an ordinary shopkeeper cannot enter into the sale of these things, with that particular provision.

The Pharmaceutical Society was founded many years ago. It is a statutory body and it has certain rights and it is in the exercise of these rights that there is, perhaps, something in the nature of a monopoly. But in order to have that, they have to go through a pretty rigorous course of training. I do not think there is anything unreasonable in any craft asking that things pertaining to that craft should be reserved. That is all the pharmaceutical chemists have asked. Up to the present, there is no restriction on the sale of things like Aspirin or Aspro —these are two of the things I heard the Deputy mention. Any shopkeeper in the country can sell them in competition with the chemist.

I am hoping that at some future date a Bill will be introduced which will restrict the sale of medicinal preparations to the people who have been trained to sell them. I must confess I have not studied the amendment the Deputy has been talking to. The only reason I rose is because Deputy Dillon said that the members of the Pharmaceutical Society who are, I think, in general, fairly decent people, are suggesting that ordinary shopkeepers are just the type of people who might be called ignoramuses.

Comment on this

Does it take three years' pharmaceutical training to sell Petrolagar to a constipated citizen—liquid paraffin and agar? I do not think it does, but there is 50 per cent. profit on Petrolagar. Does it take three years' training to permit a man to sell Kepler's Malt Extract to anyone who wants to eat it?

Comment on this

You can sell strychnine for that matter.

Comment on this

Is there any analogy between strychnine and Kepler's Malt Extract? If there is, I would like to hear it. I do not think Deputy Loughman's stomach or mine is large enough to hold that quantity of Kepler's Malt Extract which would put his life or mine in peril. We might feel sick, just as if we ate too many cakes or too much bread, but Kepler's Malt Extract is in no sense a dangerous therapeutic substance. Does it require three years' pharmaceutical training to permit a person to purchase a bottle of Cascara Evacuant? It is the 50 per cent. profit that is worrying the Pharmaceutical Society. Does it take three years' pharmaceutical training to qualify a man to sell a tin of Sister Laura's Food —baby food? If it does, why is he free to sell Neave's Food, Benger's Food, Cow and Gate, and all the other baby foods? Because the Pharmaceutical Society said to Sister Laura: "If you confine it to us, we will push Sister Laura; if you scratch our back, we will scratch yours". Does it take three years' pharmaceutical training to qualify a man to sell Ostermalt?

Comment on this

You can sell real malt without any training.

Comment on this

Does it take three years' pharmaceutical training to qualify a man to sell Antiphlogistin to make a poultice? God be with the days when we sold a quarter stone of linseed and made as good a poultice. But when you put it in a tin and charge four prices for it, no one but a pharmaceutical chemist can sell it and any poor old woman who puts a linseed poultice on her husband is an out-of-date old faggot because she did not get a tin of Antiphlogistin. Does it take three years' pharmaceutical training to qualify a man to sell Peroxide of Hydrogen, prepared by Parke Davis? Does it take three years' pharmaceutical training to qualify a man to sell Harrison's Pomade?

Comment on this

I am surprised to hear a shopkeeper cannot sell that.

Comment on this

You are a mighty good pharmaceutical chemist, but have another think about that. You know what it is for?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

And D.D.T. probably enters into its composition. Does it require three years' pharmaceutical training to sell a pennyworth of rhubarb or a ha'porth of jalap or aloes?

Comment on this

There is no restriction on the sale of those things.

Comment on this

Does it take three years' pharmaceutical training to qualify a man to sell Euthymol Toothpaste?

Comment on this

I could explain that, too.

Comment on this

Does it take three years' pharmaceutical training to justify a shopkeeper offering Iodex ointment for sale? I could go on with that list indefinitely. During the emergency the pharmaceutical chemists, apprehensive lest essential supplies might be recklessly distributed without due regard for the interests of the community, succeeded in adding to the list of their monopoly vaseline, Cuticura Soap, Liquid Paraffin, Angier's Emulsion, Scott's Emulsion and Johnson's Baby Powder, not, of course, to secure the profits that accrued from the monopolistic control of these commodities! Such a thought never entered their heads! They are only interested because if the common shopkeepers were permitted to handle these goods they would not be distributed with the solicitous discretion which we may expect the pharmaceutical chemists to exercise, inspired solely by the anxiety to ensure that those who must get a dose of liquid paraffin would get it!

Comment on this

These are not controlled.

Comment on this

Not now, but throughout the emergency they were.

Comment on this

They were always on sale in the shops.

Comment on this

Not during the emergency.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is not a dialogue.

Comment on this

It is a discussion. I am making the case that the sale of these commodities was controlled, and the Deputy intervened to say that certain things were not——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not intervene.

Comment on this

He rose and said that certain things were not controlled. I am reading a list of things that were controlled that manifestly should not have been controlled. They were controlled under regulations and by agreements which were made not for the benefit of the community as a whole, but were made to facilitate the earning of excessive profits by a privileged coterie of persons who, in my submission, were using powers conferred on their executive for the purpose of preventing the promiscuous distribution of poisons and dangerous substances, to draw as grist to their own mill a wide variety of profitable articles of commerce, so that, on the one hand, they would have a monopoly of the sale of them and, on the other, as a result of an elaborate system of agreements between their registered members, there would be no undue competition between them which might be calculated to bring down the price which the consumer was required to pay for the particular commodities which the chemist sought to control.

I find no particular fault with them. They are just another vested interest, subject to the same temptations and yielding to the same temptations as other vested interests. I am happy to think that my representations are made on behalf of a body of persons in this country, too large, too miscellaneous, too varied, ever to become a vested interest—independent, competitive citizens who want no protection, no regulation other than regulations designed to protect the community at large, no subsidy, no privilege, nothing but the opportunity to earn their own living within the law, by legitimate trade procured from their neighbour, as a result of superior service and better value, offered on the hustings in competition with all-comers, on the clear understanding that the more competition there is the better pleased they are. All they want is a fair field. That is why I put down the amendment.

Comment on this

In the first place I should like to correct the statement of Deputy Dillon that the Pharmaceutical Society regulates in any way the profits of members of the society. The Pharmaceutical Society enters in no way into the business transactions of chemists as a whole. There is an association called the Irish Drug Association which operates much in the same way as the Licensed Vintners' Association and which seeks to secure certain advantages for members and representations in regard to business matters are made through that society. I know that quite a number of trade associations arrange that goods can only be supplied to members of that association just as, in the same way, we shall say, as the bicycle people arrange that they will only sell bicycles to members of the Irish Cycle Retailers' Association.

If the pharmaceutical manufacturing firms decide that they will sell goods only through pharmaceutical chemists, I do not think that there is anything unlawful or unjust about that arrangement. Quite a number of the articles which Deputy Dillon read out here this evening are manufactured by firms who have decided in the interests of these firms, perhaps in the interest of the public also, to sell goods which they manufacture through pharmaceutical chemists.

Comment on this

At the suggestion of whom?

Comment on this

Of course that is a very old idea. I have been in business ever since 1910 and I knew of this arrangement when I first started as an apprentice in 1910. It is nothing new, or as Deputy Dillon suggests, something which started during the last war.

Comment on this

No; I agree it is an old story.

Comment on this

The Deputy mentioned some articles including vaseline of which we secured a monopoly during the war. Actually, so far as I can remember, I could not get any vaseline during the war. We did get soft paraffin but for five or six years I did not see any vaseline until the war was over. It is on the market now again. I admit that some of the commodities that he mentioned like Cascara Evacuant, Euthymol, and Hydrogen Peroxide solution are sold through chemists but again it is the firms who manufacture these commodities who decide that they will sell only through chemists. So far as our prices are concerned, the prices are arranged in conjunction with the prices section of the Department of Industry and Commerce. If we get pretty substantial profits, taking into consideration the small turnover of the average chemist's shop, if the shop is to be there at all, it is necessary that these profits should be made. I do not believe that a chemist's shop would be able to exist if it were confined to selling articles within a certain limited range and if it were compelled to sell them at a profit less than chemists are actually trying to secure at present. It is news to me at any rate that the general public, for whom Deputy Dillon thinks he speaks, looks upon chemists as a class of people who are trying to secure an unfair monopoly. I think they look upon chemists much in the same way as they look upon a carpenter who is carrying out his duties in such a manner as to ensure that he will get work that a carpenter should get. In the same way, the chemist seeks to get the type of work which the chemist should get. When I see stuffs that should properly be sold by chemists on sale in shops all over the country, I do not make an objection but I think we are perfectly entitled to fight to see that the sale of these goods should be confined to chemists.

Comment on this

One is constrained to admire the moderation and reasonableness of Deputy Loughman's approach, no matter how deeply I find myself at variance with him. I put it to him, if we restrict to the pharmaceutical chemists the duty of compounding prescriptions, the distribution of poisons, dangerous and scarce therapeutic substances, surely these are that part of his work which is analogous to the craft of the carpenter. I submit that these are to a pharmaceutical chemist what sugar, tea and jam are to a grocer and that there is then a wide variety of cosmetics, soap, and other articles which may with equal propriety be found in the shop of a pharmaceutical chemist, a general merchant, a cosmetician, a hairdresser. The more people who are engaged in the distribution of these innocuous substances, the better it will be for the purchasing community in that the competition which will take place between this wide variety of merchants for the custom of their neighbours, will be calculated to bring down prices, to improve service and to increase the amenities to which the average consumer will have access. That is all.

I am 100 per cent. with Deputy Loughman—I do not think it would be right to allow the grocer to encroach on the specialist trade of the pharmaceutical chemist. The difference that arises between Deputy Loughman and me is where should the line of delimitation be drawn. I want to draw it as narrowly as possible so that, outside that line on the pharmaceutical chemist's side on the one hand and the grocer's on the other hand, there should be free competition for the innocuous substances which either or both of them may offer for sale. It is because I feel that the Drug Association or the Pharmaceutical Society or whatever you may call it——

Comment on this

There is a great distinction.

Comment on this

The Deputy will agree with me that there are distinctions in this troubled world without a difference.

Comment on this

Not in that case.

Comment on this

The membership of both associations is strictly confined to chemists. In any case, my sole concern is to ensure that this body, call it what we may, shall not engage in a conspiracy for the restraint of trade in order to enhance the profits earned by its members at the expense of the community under the guise of making regulations analogous to those which would be approved by the Minister for Health primarily designed to protect the community from the irresponsible handling of dangerous poisons or other therapeutic substances.

I believe that is a reasonable request. The Minister has gone out to his tea, as all of us must do, from time to time, and so I am in a dilemma because I cannot expect the Minister for Lands to couch alliance in this highly controversial territory where we are at present moving and, for that reason, Sir, I must ask your leave to withdraw this amendment so that it may be raised again on Report Stage in proper form.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has withdrawn his amendment.

Comment on this

I withdrew the amendment, by leave, to raise it again on Report Stage so that the Minister might have time to consider the merits.

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this

The House has just listened to Deputy Dillon and a Deputy on this side discussing the question as to what sections of the trade should sell particular commodities. If Deputy Dillon had examined his own conscience, as a grocer, having probably an agency for machinery and several other agencies, he will find there are particular lines of business in respect of which nobody else in his town will be given an agency. Is not that true?

Comment on this

There is agricultural machinery, for instance, which occurs to me at the moment. There are certain towns in which there is only one agent for agricultural machinery and no other hardware merchant in the town will get an agency.

Comment on this

I think it is a very bad arrangement.

Comment on this

I think that is true and Deputy Dillon would be the first to defend it.

Comment on this

No. I condemn it absolutely. I believe in competition and free trade.

Comment on this

That is all right so long as it is not too near you.

Comment on this

All I can say is that I believe in free trade. I want it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Let us hear Deputy Allen.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with the chemists or the hardware merchants or the grocers. I am concerned with the ordinary public and I would suggest to the Minister in the regulations he will make under this section, not to prevent some of the substances that are in everyday use, simple substances, being offered for sale otherwise than through registered chemists because there are many areas that are nine or ten miles from a town where the chemist has his store and it would be to the disadvantage of the public if certain simple remedies that are in everyday use were not allowed to be sold otherwise than through chemists. It would be a bad thing generally and I am sure the Minister will be sensible enough to prevent that and not to give any particular section of trade a monopoly in these simple things that are in everyday use.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 72:—

In sub-section (1), page 32, to delete paragraph (c).

I am moving to delete paragraph (c) because it is sufficiently covered by the acceptance of certain amendments— Nos. 67 to 70.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 73:—

Before sub-section (6), page 34, to insert the following new sub-section:—

() A statement by the manufacturer, importer or seller of flock as to its standard of cleanliness, in an invoice or on a label attached to the flock or on the container in which the flock is sold shall be deemed for the purposes of paragraph (a) of sub-section (5) of this section to be a warranty.

This is similar to an amendment already moved with regard to warranty. We are not bound to sue the person selling the article if there is a warranty which would indicate that the offence is higher up.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 75, 77, 79 and 81 might be debated together.

Comment on this

As amendments Nos. 75, 77, 79 and 81 all deal with the same principle and as they are all the same types of amendment, let them stand or fall by the decision given with regard to the first. Therefore, I move amendment No. 75 standing in the name of Deputy Mulcahy:—

In sub-section (5) (a), line 6, after the word "shall" to insert the words "on his signifying his willingness in writing to the health authority."

The position created by these sections of this Bill is rather peculiar and, in my opinion, rather unique. The result of these sections is that a considerable number of officers in the public health service will have their present appointments terminated by a sub-section of this Act and will find themselves, the day after this Bill becomes an active law, in very different appointments carrying much greater responsibility, far more headaches and greatly increased duties. I do not think the matter was fully considered by the Department, at least before they adopted the particular procedure they did adopt, that is, to insert this in a Bill, to bring it before Parliament, to pass it to the newspapers, and then let the officers affected learn about it through that machinery. I think that aspect of the matter was never considered. I do not believe that with any form of agent or servant an employer would decide "We are going to alter that person's title. We are going to alter that person's duties. We are going to give that person much greater responsibility, but we will not even discuss the matter with him and we will not even give him an opportunity of saying ‘yes' or ‘no"'. I do not want to show any pique or anything of that kind but, to begin with, it was a thoroughly discourteous way in which to treat a large number of officers who deserve better.

I do not believe, however, that the Department was fully aware of the gigantic change it was making in the responsibilities of the people we are discussing. I do not believe that they adverted to the fact that without even discussion, without consent, they were changing the whole basis of contract between these particular officers and the various counties to which they had contracted their services. I do not believe, even, that consideration or full consideration was given to the fact that the new officers we are creating here would, in very many cases, require a quite different type of official to carry out efficiently and successfully the new responsibilities which are being forced by law on these particular officers. Let me explain the magnitude of the change made—the change made without consultation, notification, discussion or consent. Each one of these officers referred to in this part of the Bill is a qualified medical practitioner. They specialised in public health—preventive medicine. They went before the Appointments Commission and they received appointments through the Appointments Commission in the various administrative areas whether as county medical officers of health or assistant county medical officers of health. The medical work in every administrative area was, in the past, inside two fields with a high fence between the two fields. The smaller field was the field of public health— preventive medicine. The functions of these men, up to the time this Bill becomes law, and their responsibilities, have been strictly confined within the field of public health. Outside and beyond that there was the other far larger field—poor law institutions. All the work of a multiplicity of dispensary districts and all of the medical institutions in the country was on the poor law side.

In the field of public health the duties and responsibilities were, in the main, confined to preventive medicine, infectious diseases, cleanliness of food, Milk and Dairies Act, slaughterhouses, tuberculosis, the clinical diagnosis and clinical treatment of tuberculosis, plus certain supervisory duties with regard to the notification of births and marriages. Housing also came within the field of public health. I would say that from about 20 to 25 per cent. of the medical work in the county fell into the public health zone. Seventy-five to 80 per cent. fell in the poor law medical zone. By a line in one sub-section of an Act you make all the officers who were responsible purely for the limited field of public health take on responsibility for the whole field of medical work inside their administrative area. Every bit of trouble, every bit of friction, every irregularity, every lack of attention, every complaint made inside any of the poor law medical institutions in a county will become the headache of the county medical officer of the future who used to be the county medical officer of health. You make him by sub-section (1) of Section 64 responsible for advising the health authority generally in relation to health, etc., as well as for all duties assigned and functions of the health authority. Under sub-section (3) you make him the chief medical officer for the county for the purposes of this Bill.

This is not a matter, I think, about which there should be any controversy or disagreement. To a certain extent, we can both appreciate the facts as we are up against them. There should not be any dispute as to whether you are, or are not, altering to an immense extent the position of these officers as well as increasing their responsibilities to an immense extent. The county medical officer of health is an officer on the staff of the county manager, and the latter has responsibility for all work in the county. Let us take it that there is trouble or that there is work to be done, advice to be given or something to be investigated within the field of public health. Up to the date that this Bill becomes law, the county manager's staff officer is the county medical officer of health and his assistant, but if there is any trouble in a medical institution, any adverse report, any complaints from patients, any suggestion of lack of proper supervision or of prompt attention, and if the county manager refers that to the county medical officer of health, he is, and always has been, within his rights in saying: "That is the field of poor law medicine and I cannot encroach on that field". Since the introduction of the managerial system, medical inspectors from the Minister's Department have visited the various districts. They have called the county manager, the secretary for the county and the medical officers together and, in the presence of the county medical officers, they have warned the administrative side that they cannot, and must not, use the services of the county medical officers of health in relation to anything on the poor law side.

That was the position up to the date of the introduction of this Bill. By its introduction, and by knocking out the words "of health" the county medical officer is to be made responsible for all the medical work under this Bill as well as for all the institutions within his administrative area. I think it is beyond argument that you are changing his appointment, that you are vastly increasing his responsibilities. His fitness for the new position is quite another matter. It is purely one of opinion, but I think his right to be consulted before he is pitch-forked into this new office, should be unquestionable. The position that has arisen, and that will arise, is that all those people who are affected are going to find themselves faced with very much greater responsibilities than they ever had to carry before, with very many more headaches and more worries, doing a type of work that will, and must, if it is to be conscientiously carried out, lead to conflict between themselves and their medical colleagues within their administrative area. The suggestion in the amendment is that that should only be done after they have signified their willingness, in writing, to take on these new duties. The amendment, as it were, merely raises the whole question. I do not think that, if the amendment were carried it would be the wisest course, because if nine or ten officers did not signify their willingness to take on the new duties imposed on them I do not know what the position would be. It would mean that this Health Bill and the new services would break down completely, in their particular areas. I do not think that, if such an amendment were inserted and if a person did not signify his willingness to take on the new duties, there would be any justification for dismissing him. What would happen is that he would be paralysing the machine in his particular administrative area. That would be an entirely unthinkable attitude and, as far as I know, would not be adopted by any of them.

The alternative is to discuss with the officers in question their new responsibilities, their new functions and their greatly increased duties in order to induce them to face those new responsibilities with the same enthusiasm and willingness with which they faced their old duties. I have heard it argued that no change is being made in the position of these men, and that we are not increasing their responsibilities or their duties. That is one leg of the argument, but anybody who knows anything about medicine in the various administrative areas under the Department of Local Government knows that there is no foundation whatever for that particular argument. The other leg of the argument is that it is a bad principle, one that could not be accepted, to increase the remuneration of a whole-time officer because of increased duties and responsibilities. That argument is equally untenable. It is an argument that would blast sky-high the Civil Service, the Army and all State services if you were to apply it to them. The civil servant when he joins as a junior is a whole-time civil servant. When the efficient man gets promotion, he gets increased responsibilities and against that he gets increased remuneration, but he is a whole-time State officer all the time. Where does the principle apply? The principle of increased remuneration, with promotion, with increased responsibilities, with added duties and with added worries, is the soundest principle in the world and is one that makes for bringing out the best, one that makes for keenness, one that gives a person an ambition to succeed and the determination to get on. But for the first time, as far as I know, in the legislation of this or any other country, the Minister and Parliament by law abolish the office held by a number of people, by law put them into a new office, without even informing them, without even consulting them, pile on immense new responsibilities and make no provision whatever for any compensation for the vastly increased duties.

That is the principle contained in all these sections that I read out. It is the same principle applied to different officers. The amendment which is down here for the first is similar in form in all the other cases. I would like to hear from the Minister some statements to the effect (1) that there was no intentional discourtesy, and (2) that it would not be the policy of his Department when dealing with the medical man, the civil servant, the engineer or the wage earner, to change his job, increase his responsibilities and increase his work without consulting him and, further, without any suggestion as to how it is proposed to remunerate or compensate him.

Comment on this

First of all, I am afraid I will have to disagree with Deputy Dr. O'Higgins in his interpretation of the section. Sub-section (1) is very little different—in fact, there may be some difference in words, but I think there is no difference in meaning—from Section 21 (6) of the Local Government Act, 1925. In that Act it was laid down that a county medical officer of health will advise the council on any matter where expert advice is required on matters affecting the health of his county or district.

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

There was not any difference in the meaning and it was not intended that there should be. This section was brought in to codify what had gone before. Changing the name does not make any material difference, as I am sure the Deputy will admit. In regard to county medical officers of health, there is, first of all, a change of title. As far as the other provisions in this section are concerned, they are merely consolidating and do not go further than that. I do not think it can be contended that in this Bill the duties or responsibilities are increased. It is a matter to be decided whether they will get extra duties or not.

I certainly meant no discourtesy to the medical officers of health. When this section was put before me—as it stands now; I do not think I suggested any amendment—the note I got with it was that it was merely a consolidatory section and made no change in the present law except in regard to change in title. I can assure the Deputy that there was no intention of any discourtesy. What is more, I do not think I ever subscribed to the principle that, in the case of a medical officer, increased duties or responsibilities should not be accompanied in any circumstances by increased remuneration.

Comment on this

I did not even mean to suggest that the Minister did.

Comment on this

That is a matter which should be considered. I would make this appeal to the Deputy—this is not, perhaps, the place or the time to discuss this matter fully and we might only do harm if we were to argue the matter out in every detail here. The intention in this Bill is that the county medical officer of health would take over the health services of the county. He will be responsible for these, as he was in the past.

Comment on this

No, he was not in the past.

Comment on this

Public health services. As I pointed out on the Second Reading, whereas he had to do a good deal of the work in regard to inspection in the past, that will be done by district medical officers in the future and he will have the supervision. It is a matter to be decided whether the duties and responsibilites are increased or not. As regards institutions and so on, that is again a matter to be discussed and decided, whether the medical officer of health would be responsible for those institutions or not. These matters will come up for discussion when we get down to working out in detail the regulations under the Bill.

To go back to the White Paper, when it comes to be put into its final form, some of these matters may come up for discussion with regard to the exact part the county medical officer of health will take in the county and what part will be played by the other medical men of the various grades and classes. I do not think the Deputy is right in assuming that we have so far made any change. If I am convinced by the medical officers of health that they are in fact getting more work to do, more duties to perform, more responsibility and so on, I would be quite willing to listen to the case for remuneration to suit the new duties and new responsibilities. But we will have to wait until we see what those duties and responsibilities are going to be. I do not think we can discuss that very minutely at this stage.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister in that. I feel acutely uncomfortable in discussing this here and think it would be much better discussed elsewhere. It is rather unfortunate that these discussions, and many of them, did not take place before the people concerned were faced with the sections we have before us. I have been for practically 20 years a medical officer of health and have been watching the poor law administration alongside me and I can read, although not always understand, an Act of Parliament; and I know the meaning of simple English words. Taking those things together, I see sub-section (3) here:—

The county medical officer for a county shall be the chief medical officer for the county for the purposes of this Act.

Managers are not medical men and are not specialists, and the people we are talking about are staff officers of the manager. Medical worries are coming before them every day; institutional worries are coming before them every day, and complaints are coming before them, although not every day. There are matters to be investigated in many institutions and many dispensary districts. The very minute this section goes through, what will any manager who knows his job do? He will utilise his staff officer—I think that ought to be obvious to everybody—and the mere utilisation of his staff officer for the purposes of the Act means very increased worries and increased responsibilities on that staff officer or those staff officers—the kind of worry and responsibility that may lead to strained relations between himself and his professional colleagues under circumstances which may arise in any district at any time. We can leave it at that.

Comment on this

I should like to make clear to the Deputy that there is nothing in the Bill to say that the county medical officer of health will be responsible for the institutions.

Comment on this

The county medical officer for health is responsible for the medical work under this Bill.

Comment on this

Under this Bill, certainly.

Comment on this

And treatment is under this Bill.

Comment on this

That does not say he must do the treatment, or even be responsible.

Comment on this

He is responsible for the supervision.

Comment on this

That remains to be decided.

Comment on this

I take it the Minister would reply on similar lines with regard to the position of dispensary doctors?

Comment on this

Yes. If duties and responsibilities are increased, we must necessarily consider the question of remuneration.

Comment on this

I am very interested in the appointment of bacteriologists to county hospitals. The Minister will agree that county surgeons and physicians are working under great disadvantages by reason of the fact that they have not got bacteriologists. I quite appreciate that it would be too expensive to have a bacteriologist for each county, but I was wondering if it would be possible to have one appointed for three counties combined such as Sligo, Leitrim and Roscommon. As I say, physicians and surgeons are working under great disadvantages and I should like the Minister to indicate what he proposes to do in this connection.

Comment on this

One matter we are considering is a regional organisation for certain services, one of which will be bacteriology and I think it will be practically in line with what the Deputy suggests. Three, four or five counties, according to their size and the work to be expected in them, would be made into a region for certain services, including bacteriology.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 83:—

Before Section 71, but in Part VII, to insert the following section:—

(1) Where an enactment repealed by this Act (in this section called "the repealed enactment") conferred powers and duties on a sanitary authority and corresponding powers and duties are conferred by this Act on a health authority, the following provisions shall have effect:—

(a) every person who, immediately before the repeal of the repealed enactment, is the holder in a permanent capacity of an office under a sanitary authority the duties of which relate solely to the powers and duties conferred on such sanitary authority by such repealed enactment, shall become and be the holder of the same office under the health authority in whose functional area the district of such sanitary authority is situated,

(b) the said office under a sanitary authority shall, for the purposes of any enactment relating to superannuation, be deemed not to have been abolished.

(c) if any question arises as to whether the duties of a particular office under a sanitary authority relate solely to powers and duties conferred on such sanitary authority by the repealed enactment, such question shall be referred to the Minister whose decision shall be final.

(2) The following provisions shall apply in relation to every person who, immediately before the commencement of this section, held, in a permanent capacity, an office under the title of sanitary sub-officer under a sanitary authority:—

(a) such person shall become and be the holder of an office under the same title under the health authority whose functional area includes the functional area of the sanitary authority,

(b) the said office under the sanitary authority shall, for the purposes of any enactment relating to superannuation, be deemed not to have been abolished,

(c) the holder of the office of sanitary sub-officer under a health authority shall (in addition to performing duties in relation to the functions of the health authority) perform such duties as may be assigned to him in relation to the functions of any sanitary authority in the functional area of such health authority and for that purpose the provisions of paragraph (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 10, and of Section 20 of the Act of 1941 relating to the duties of officers and of sub-section (2) of the said Section 10 relating to appeals by officers shall apply in relation to the said office as if it were also an office under the sanitary authority of every sanitary district in the functional area of such health authority.

Holders of certain offices, including that of sanitary sub-officer, under sanitary authorities, will be transferred to similar offices under the health authorities. Sanitary sub-officers are concerned and nurses engaged on maternity and child welfare work, which is at present run by the sanitary authority. So far as their status, duties and so on are concerned, they will come over with exactly the same status and duties.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 84:—

In page 39, line 44, before the word "acquire" to insert the words "under this Act".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 85:—

To insert at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(4) Section 83 of the Local Government Act, 1946 (No. 24 of 1946) (which relates to the disposal of land not required by a local authority) shall apply to the disposal (not being by demise for a term not exceeding one year) of land under this section and for this purpose references to the Minister for Local Government in the said Section 83 shall be construed as references to the Minister.

This amendment is to apply and adopt Section 83 of the Local Government Act, 1946, relating to the disposal of land. It is the section which governs the procedure to be followed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 86:—

To delete sub-section (6) and substitute the following sub-section:—

(6) In this section, the word "premises" includes temporary dwellings and aircraft.

This amendment follows the third amendment moved to the definition section.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 87:—

In paragraph (b) of sub-section (2), page 46, lines 40 and 41, to delete the words "when in uniform".

Sub-section (4) prohibits a member of the Garda from exercising his powers, unless he is in uniform or produces on request his official identification card. The words "when in uniform" in sub-section (2) (b) are, therefore unnecessary.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 88:—

In paragraph (c) of sub-section (2), lines 43 and 44, page 46, to delete the words "Commissioner of the Garda Síochána" and substitute therefor the words "Minister for Justice".

It is the Minister for Justice who should be referred to, instead of the Commissioner of the Garda Síochána, because all fines accrue to the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 89:

In sub-section (1), to delete the word "may" in line 17, and substitute therefor the word "shall".

The sub-section reads at present:—

"The Minister may by Order establish a council to be called ‘The National Health Council' to give to the Minister when so required by him advice on matters affecting or incidental to the health of the people."

The provision is mixed up with a general kind of suggestion that the Minister may, at any time he requires special advice, establish a special consultative council to give him advice or assistance on any particular matter. In the first place, I think these two ideas should be separated entirely in the Bill. I think that the idea of a National Health Council, whether set up with statutory powers or merely for the purpose of being an advisory council to the Minister, should be completely separated from the general power that the Minister may wish to have to set up special consultative councils for some ad hoc purpose or some special idea. I think that it degrades and minimises the idea of a National Health Council, even as an advisory council, to simply make it part of a section that gives additional and other powers.

There are two amendments in my name. The one which I am moving now is to make it obligatory on the Minister to have a National Health Council to advise him on certain matters. The second amendment goes further. It provides that the National Health Council will have constitutional powers, functions and duties established by law. The Minister indicated that his view of a National Health Council is that they would be just an advisory body. He would call them together and, from time to time, there would be matters that he would refer to them for their consideration and opinion; and from time to time perhaps they might assemble themselves and make representations to the Minister with regard to certain matters that they considered advisable to do or to consider. The Minister has not given any indication as to what his final idea is with regard to either the constitution of the National Health Council or their powers, functions and duties. He simply says that, as far as the powers, functions and duties are concerned, he will only regard them as an advisory body. He has not indicated that they will be a body that can assemble on their own initiative and consider matters and, even though having no power of any kind, will still be in a position to advise the Minister or to make representations to him on any matter that they might decide on.

I want the Bill amended in such a way that it shall be obligatory on the Minister to have a National Health Council. The Minister may say that, except the council is to have some power, making it obligatory on the Minister to have a council would serve no particular purpose, because, if he did not want to be bothered with a genuine council he could assemble a bogus one, the members of which would give him a guarantee that they would not worry him in any way or say anything to him on any subject he did not ask them to consider. I do not think that would be a sound argument to put up. I think that if we laid down in our legislation that the Minister should have a National Health Council, no Minister could appoint a National Health Council that would not be truly and equitably representative of the profession in its various branches. Therefore, I press on the House that, even if the Minister is only to regard the National Health Council as an advisory body, the section ought to make it obligatory that such a council will be set up. I should like a decision on that point by itself. We can then discuss the matter further on amendment No. 90.

Comment on this

I do not object to that at all. As I have no other intention than to set up this National Health Council, I do not see why I should not bind myself here and now to do it by using the word "shall". I agree with the first amendment. On the second amendment——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We will come to that on the next amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 90:—

To delete all words after the word "council" in line 18 and substitute therefor a new sub-section as follows:—

() The constitution, powers, functions and duties of the National Health Council shall be as by law established.

Comment on this

I am afraid I will have to insist that the council will be advisory, and therefore bringing in a Bill and so on would do very little more than what is stated here in the first sub-section. As well as that, I am sure Deputies are aware of the congestion in connection with legislation in general and it might be a few years before we would arrive at such a Bill. I think we ought to carry on for the present anyway.

Comment on this

I appreciate that it might not be very easy to decide straightaway what powers, functions and duties we should give the National Health Council and to define them so precisely that we would be prepared to put them into a piece of legislation. I appreciate that we are advancing in the matter when the Minister agrees to make it a statutory requirement on him to have a National Health Council. Having gone so far, I think it is desirable that we should discuss the matter a little more and try to see what exactly the Minister's outlook is on the matter and get as clear an idea from him as we can how it will be constituted and the kind of duties that he expects to give it.

I think it is desirable in discussing the matter that we should refer to the recommendation made by the Commission on Vocational Organisation which was invited by the Government to review the whole of the social and economic organisations in the country and to suggest in what way the various vocations and the various sections of the community with specialist functions could give of their best to the work of the country as a whole. It approached the examination in that particular way and it made certain recommendations as to how the professions could, in an organic way, develop their organisation so as to make them, in so far as their own sphere was concerned, self-governing to such an extent that they could give the best from their own experience to the nation.

The commission approached this matter on the lines that that could and would be done, without reference to any particular kind of political organisation or society here. In relation to the Council of Health, they gave general ideas as to how that council ought to be set up from the point of view of representation and from the point of view of function. In paragraph 543, the commission recommended unanimously that a Council of Health be established and constituted more or less as follows:—

"I. Representatives of central and local authorities:

One from Department of Local Government and Public Health.

One from Department of Industry and Commerce.

One from the General Council of County Councils.

One from the Association of Municipal Authorities of Ireland.

II. Representatives of medical profession, to be appointed by the Medical Professional Board:

One from the Medical Research Council.

One from the teaching bodies.

One from the voluntary hospitals.

One county medical officer of health.

One dispensary doctor.

One general medical practitioner in private practice.

III. Representatives of other professions, to be appointed by their respective professional boards:

One dentist.

One veterinary surgeon.

One nurse.

One engineer or architect.

One chemist.

One pharmacist.

IV. Representatives of other organisations:

One from the National Health Insurance Society.

One from the voluntary bodies, e.g., the Red Cross Society.

One from the Council of Education.

One from the National Conference of Agriculture."

That gives an idea of the scope of the representation that the commission considered was necessary on a Council of Health. They then went on to discuss what the function of the council ought to be, and the report says:—

"The function of the council should be to advise, to co-ordinate and to plan.

It should serve first of all as a consultative body, possessed of specialised knowledge, information and experience, to which the Minister could look for technical advice on public health problems. It should examine and report to the Oireachtas on proposed public health legislation. It should ensure that in housing schemes the requirements of public health in regard to drainage, sewerage, sanitation and hygiene are met.

Its second function should be to co-ordinate the work of the many isolated and independent agencies interested in public health, to eliminate overlapping and to secure unified effort for agreed objectives. It should be the organ to stimulate public interest and co-operation in health services and should be a sensitive interpreter of the needs and complaints of the public. Thirdly, it should act as a planning body to draw up a long-term programme for the development of health services, stressing preventive rather than remedial measures. It should encourage research in public health with a view towards constant improvement and progress along the latest scientific lines. A positive constructive policy is most desirable in regard to dietetics and pure food, domestic and public hygiene, physical training and fitness. Obviously, its plans must be practical in relation to the taxable capacity of the country, and our available resources.

Among its more immediate tasks the council might make a survey of the present state of public health, the causes of death and the incidence of diseases; it might review the present ‘red ticket' service and dispensary system and consider how far adequate medical, dental, hospital and maternity services are provided at reasonable cost for persons of small or moderate means.

Such a council would need a standing executive committee and a permanent secretariat and should have power to appoint its own full-time director who should not be a civil servant. The amount and importance of its work would involve a number of meetings in each year and the appointment of sub-committees for special problems. It should issue an annual report to be sent to the Oireachtas. The expenses of the council should be borne by the State by means of a grant-in-aid."

I think it well at this stage to call attention to the nature and scope of the recommendations made by the Commission on Vocational Organisation. The Minister, I admit, is taking a step which will, I am sure, have its effect in helping on the organic growth of a council of this kind, representative of the various bodies that are mentioned here. But I would like to ask him whether he has considered the implications of the recommendations that are made here with regard to the unique position of the professional organisations connected with medicine and the fact that they have a unique and a specialised type of advice to give and I suggest that they ought not to be coerced into particular lines of policy that would not evolve naturally from their own lines of thought and that they ought not to be subjected to mere Departmental control either in dealing with matters that they consider should be dealt with, or restricting their views or their consideration of the problems that require to be considered.

I think it is particularly important, while the Minister is taking the step that he is taking, that he would make it clear that the council of health that he is appointing will have power of initiative, will have initiative of its own in considering matters that affect either the public health or the general education and outlook of the people on their own health problems. Perhaps the Minister could tell us what his attitude is to that type of initiative.

Comment on this

The approach of the Vocational Organisation Commission is very interesting and exhaustive. We can follow it to a great extent, and will naturally do so. I suppose any persons thinking over these problems would be inclined to think in the same direction in looking for advice. First of all, regarding the constitution of the organisation, I think many of the bodies suggested there would be asked to give us help. Maybe I might be inclined to weight some of them more than others. On the other hand, I do not think I would approve of having a representative from what is referred to there as the Department of Local Government and Public Health—I would not agree with that. I think the council should be composed of people outside the Department entirely.

As regards their work, when the Vocational Organisation Commission were considering this view they had in mind the building up of a vocational body from the bottom upwards, and they must have had in mind people who would be practically whole-time. I have in mind men who are very busy —good men are usually very busy—in their own professions. I do not think I could expect that they would give more than ten or 12 days in the year. That would mean a meeting every month. In fact, they may think it hard to give that much time and, therefore, it will be largely a matter of advice.

It says here that the consultative body shall be composed of people with specialised knowledge, information and experience. I agree with that, but unless we take them over completely, in what way can we avail of their services? We must remember that these people with knowledge and experience will have to make a living and, therefore, they can give only part of their time. I do not think they would have very much more time than to examine the proposals and regulations that we put before them for an expression of their views.

If you go on to the second function, to eliminate overlapping and secure unified effort for agreed objectives, we could not possibly ask that council to take the initiative in that respect. I think it would be only fair that they would say: "Well, let the Department provide a plan, put it before us and we will tell them what we think of it." Again, the commission say: "It should act as a planning body to draw up a long-term programme for the development of health services." You could not expect these people to do that. The Department will have to do that but that is the type of thing that would be put before the consultative council for their views when it is drawn up. Again, they say: "The council might make a survey of the present state of public health." Let the Department make the survey and let them see the result of that. I think that what will happen naturally will be, that the Department will do the investigation and the reporting and put its reports before the Health Council and get the Health Council's mind on it.

It is true, of course, that the Vocational Organisation Commission suggests that they should have their own staff. I would not agree with that. I think that would only lead to confusion—that they should have a staff to make these investigations and reports which would be going at the same time into the Department of Health. I think that on the whole if they are appointed as an advisory body—and I am quite sure they will give good advice—that we shall be going as far as we can at the moment. I do not know how things may turn out in a few years' time; perhaps then we may look at it in a different way and be inclined to look further in the direction suggested by the Commission on Vocational Organisation.

An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.

Comment on this

The Minister has not quite met the point I put. That is, will the National Health Council be so constituted that the members of it can be brought together on their own initiative to discuss problems?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The second question is: will they be provided with some element of a secretariat? There is financial provision for travelling expenses and for subsistence allowances of the members but there is no provision for a secretary to the chairman or to the council as a whole. There is no provision to give the council as a whole a small nucleus, at any rate, of a secretariat.

Comment on this

I certainly would encourage members of the council to put down matters for discussion if they wish to do so. Any member may send in a matter for the agenda and that will come up for discussion after the usual notice. Some arrangement will also be made that if two or three members want to have a meeting, that meeting will be called. As regards a secretariat, there will be an officer of the Department who will carry out the secretarial work at the meetings and he will be available, naturally, to send out any reports or any documents they may need. If the chairman wants to send a special letter to the members, suggesting that a special meeting might be called for instance, of course that officer will be available for that purpose. I do not see what further secretariat would be required. A secretary would be only required in connection with the meetings.

Comment on this

I should like to know if the Minister has any policy conceived in regard to this matter at all.

Comment on this

Yes. I think that we shall have to try to convey to the public what it is necessary to do in the way of precautions against certain diseases. Let us take, say, influenza, which comes along occasionally. We should try to convey information to the public, giving them certain advice as to how they can avoid it, or any other epidemic that may arise. I hope to get moving in that line as soon as we have time to settle down.

Comment on this

I take it that in these matters the National Health Council will have power to give advice?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

I move Amendment No. 91:—

Before Section 96 to insert the following section:—

A health authority may, with the consent of the Minister, make arrangements for the provision of a nurse or nurses to give to any person requiring the same, advice and assistance on matters relating to health and to assist sick persons.

This section would enable the health authority to employ nurses to attend people in their own houses and to disseminate information with regard to health matters. It will be possible under the section to use the voluntary associations that are there at the moment.

Comment on this

Are we to understand that it is the intention of the Minister to encourage the continuance of the voluntary nursing organisations?

Comment on this

I should not like to answer that question at the moment. I think we shall certainly require their services for some time, but what the future policy will be in regard to voluntary organisations I could not say at the moment.

Comment on this

The financial part of the White Paper might throw some light on that.

Comment on this

The financial part is attractive enough.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 92:—

Before Section 97, to insert the following section:—

(1) A health authority may make arrangements for providing ambulances or other means of transport for the conveyance of patients from places in their functional area to places in or outside such area or from places outside their functional area to places in such area.

(2) Where a person makes use of an ambulance provided under this section, a health authority may, at their discretion but subject to any relevant regulations under Section 27 of this Act:—

(a) make a charge for such use in accordance with regulations made by them, or

(b) make no charge therefor.

(3) A charge under sub-section (2) of this section for the use of an ambulance by any person may be recovered as a simple contract debt in any court of competent jurisdiction from:—

(a) such person, or, in case such person has died, his legal personal representative, or

(b) any other person liable to maintain such person for the purposes of the Public Assistance Act, 1939 (No. 27 of 1939), by virtue of Section 27 of that Act or, in case such other person has died, his legal personal representative.

I was afraid on reconsideration that the section as it stood was hardly wide enough. We suggest the new section instead because it is possible that it might be held that ambulances could only be used for the work of the health authority in connection with its own institutions. It might be necessary for the health authority to send an ambulance to a voluntary hospital in some cases. We are providing for a contingency of that kind in the amendment.

Comment on this

I want to suggest that the Minister might make a provision to enable local authorities to hire an ambulance. It might be that there were ambulances for hire in a district and the local authority might not have a sufficient number of ambulances of its own, available on every occasion.

Comment on this

It reads—"a health authority may make arrangements for providing an ambulance". "Providing" means having or hiring. It includes hiring.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 93:—

In sub-section (1), line 18, page 49, before the word "may" to insert the words "after consultation with the Minister for Local Government".

This was inadvertently left out in the drafting of the Bill. The Minister for Local Government is responsible for the constitution and removal from office of all local authorities and it would be necessary, therefore, for the Minister for Health to consult him before anything like this could be done.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 94:—

In sub-section (1), page 49, line 44, to delete the words "this Act" and to substitute therefor the words "any of the provisions of this Act except Part VIII".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 95:—

To delete the entry relating to the Public Health (Ireland) Act, 1878, and to insert the following:—

41 & 42 Vic., c. 52 | Public Health (Ireland) Act, 1878. | Section 11, paragraph (3) of section 91, section 95, paragraph (3) of section 97, paragraph (6) of section 100, sections 132 to 156 and sections 158 and 258.

We are adding to the list of repeals here. Paragraph (3) of Section 97 is being added. That imposes a penalty on a keeper of a common lodging house who fails to notify a case of infectious disease. Section 158 is also being added which provides that a justice may order the removal to a mortuary of the body of a person who dies from an infectious disease. That is already provided in the Act. Section 258 is also being repealed. It provides that every officer of a sanitary authority shall attend and assist in any prosecution instituted by such authority on receipt of an order from such authority so to attend, provided always that if a medical officer of the sanitary authority shall so attend and assist, he shall be entitled to remuneration from the sanitary authority.... These are being added to that Schedule.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 96:—

In the entry relating to the Local Government Act, 1925, to insert the word "and" between the figures "19" and "21" in the third column.

This is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

When discussing the striking case Deputy Dr. O'Higgins was making with regard to vaccination, I understood the Minister to say that with regard to vaccination he was prepared to be advised by medical opinion here and that if in consultation with organised medical opinion here he could be persuaded that it was necessary to retain the Vaccination Acts or any part if them, he was prepared to do it. I would like to ask the Minister whether it is his intention to have such consultations before the final passing of this Act with organised medical opinion in this country and whether he is on the other hand proposing to repeal the four Vaccination (Amendment) Acts here and whether he is going to wait for some time to consult medical opinion on the matter.

Comment on this

My idea is to proceed with the abolition of the Vaccination Acts and then, if medical opinion—which I believe it is—is in favour of the continuation of vaccination against smallpox, to include it in this Act, to make it the law under this Act.

Comment on this

That is, that the Minister can then, by reason of its being made an infectious disease under this Act, make the necessary regulations under this Act that will in fact do the work of the Vaccination Acts in the past or whatever part of them he considers necessary.

Comment on this

Yes. The Acts will not be repealed until the new regulations are made. The regulations will be made by the time we are repealing these other Acts. Under the immunisation section it can come in as an infectious disease.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 97:—

In paragraph 7 to delete the words "by district medical officers" in the first line.

It was too restrictive as it stood. It may be necessary, for instance, to give powers under this paragraph to the medical officers of health and their assistants. So by leaving out these words we can give the power to whoever may require it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 98:—

To delete paragraph (8).

Paragraph (8) is really not necessary. Paragraph (1) provides for notification of diseases by medical practitioners and other persons.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 99:—

In paragraph (9) to delete the words "on the requisition of district medical officers" in the first line.

This is consequential.

Comment on this

In paragraph (5) provision may be made for the requiring of adult persons to remain away from specified places or the parents of children to keep the children away from specified places. I assume the intention of that paragraph is to empower the Minister to make regulations prohibiting children who are suffering from infectious disease from going to school or church and to prohibit adults from going to any specified place to which the public have access. I agree that in certain cases of very grave infectious disease it is right that this power should be in the Bill but it is necessary that in making the regulations steps should be taken to ensure that they are so framed that they will not prevent an adult person or child from attending Divine Service in case of infectious disease which is not very grave. There are various forms of infectious disease, some grave and others not so grave. Steps should be taken to ensure that this prohibition on persons attending Divine Service does not apply to minor forms of infectious disease.

There is another provision in the Schedule. Paragraph (14) mentions the safe disposal or destruction of infected or dirty articles. I raised that matter on another section and was told that it was covered by the Schedule. I am anxious to know if this particular paragraph gives power to ensure that all second-hand clothing offered for sale to the public is subjected to inspection or disinfection or disinfestation. It is appalling to see second-hand clothing being hawked from one town to another and offered for sale when, as far as I know, there is no guarantee or assurance that any steps have been taken to disinfect or disinfest it. That is a serious matter which would require to be dealt with under this or some similar regulation.

Comment on this

The first question the Deputy raised was in connection with paragraph (5) of the Schedule with regard to people suffering from infectious disease being prohibited from going into any public place. That, of course, again, is a rehash of a power already there under the Public Health Act, 1878. I could not give any undertaking, of course, how that will be worked in any particular instance. It may be necessary in certain cases to prohibit persons even going to church but I do not think medical officers of health will be restrictive unless they find it absolutely necessary. We have power, as regards second-hand clothes, to disinfect and inspect, etc. Generally speaking the regulations can be enlarged. If anything is left out we can come along and make it right. The Schedule only gives an indication.

Second Schedule, as amended, agreed to.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to let us have his amendments a week before the actual date of discussion. When could the Minister have his amendments circulated?

Comment on this

We will try to have them as soon as we can. I promise that we will give Deputies on the other side of the House a few days to come along with other amendments if they wish.

Comment on this

We would like to facilitate the Minister in having the Report Stage at the earliest possible moment but we would like three or four days.

Comment on this

Yes, that will be all right.

Comment on this