We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Motion for Select Committee. - Proposed Sale of Distillery.

Contributions 1–242 of 482. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I move:—

That a select committee consisting of 11 Deputies to be appointed by the Committee of Selection and with power to send for persons, papers and documents be established publicly to investigate and to report to the Dáil on all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding any proposal made or attempted to be made at any time since the 1st January, 1946, either to buy or to sell Locke's Distillery, Kilbeggan, or any part of the property or business thereof.

During my absence in the country on political work, a discussion took place on Wednesday last, on the motion for the Adjournment of the Dáil following Questions that day, which raised, to my mind, a matter of serious public importance. I consider, in putting down this motion, I am discharging a public duty which I feel the Government ought to have regarded as their duty and in moving this motion I simply do so as a matter of formal public duty. I do not wish to make accusations against any person or to repeat any accusations made, nor do I want to defend anybody either against accusations made or to defend anybody who made accusations that they ought not to make. For that reason I asked the Government to-day whether they were going to accept this motion. They said they could not say whether they would or not until they had heard the case made. The reason I put down this motion is that I feel that a case has been made for it.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

By the very fact that it was possible for the Dáil on Wednesday night last to have had the discussion which took place.

Comment on this

By whom was the case made?

Comment on this

I would ask the Deputy to listen to me and, if he has other tactics to pursue, let us know whether he is pursuing them. I stated that I am performing a formal public duty which I regard as my responsibility, when the Government have not shown that they realise that they have a responsibility in the matter. I am making the plea simply now that if the Government recognise that, as I believe they might, that they would say so after having heard me. If they are of opinion that it is desirable that a public inquiry should take place and that a select committee should be set up to inquire into the matter in the way I suggest the committee should be set up forthwith and further discussion of the matters, that I understand have been raised here, might be left over until the select committee have inquired, ascertained the facts and reported to the Dáil on these facts.

In my approach to this particular matter, the Ceann Comhairle suggested that the motion might be restricted in some way or another, that it was too wide. I feel that the very nature of the statements made on the one hand, and the facts given by the Minister for Justice on the other, are of such a kind that the inquiry into this particular matter should be as open as members of the select committee set up by the Dáil would consider it should be. I do not think it would be possible or desirable to restrict in any way the scope of the inquiry in view, as I say, of the type of statements made here and the admissions made in regard to certain of these matters by the Minister for Justice.

Now while there may be a case to be made here such as the Ceann Comhairle mentioned, that this would open up an inquiry into every commercial transaction carried out by Locke's during that particular period, I think that is a rather exaggerated statement. This inquiry arises out of definite incidents and only so far as the incidents relate to the matter of public importance connected with them would any Select Committee of the Dáil inquire. Therefore I press for the acceptance of the motion in the form in which it is there.

On Wednesday last, in his reply to the debate on the Adjournment, the Minister for Justice accepted certain facts—that a Swiss national of the name Eindiguer arrived in Ireland some time at the beginning of September, that he was accompanied by others, or at any rate by one person, who was posing under the name of Horace Henry Smith, but that probably his real name was Alexander Maximoe; that by the end of September the Department of Justice was aware that Eindiguer had entered into a contract to purchase Locke's distillery, that at the same time his Department had discovered that both Eindiguer and Maximoe were associating with an alien who was under orders to leave the country; that, following the publication of the news that members of this group had been received by the President, he had received a telephone message from a friend which resulted in the Minister for Justice signing a deportation order for the man who posed under the name of Smith. Then subsequently we had newspaper information that while he was in process of deportation this man threw himself overboard.

These very colourful circumstances on the surface would warrant some kind of investigation but when, in circumstances such as those admitted by the Minister for Justice, a Deputy in this House makes the allegation that this Swiss gentleman was able to approach the Department of Industry and Commerce and get from the Department——

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

This is implied in the report.

Comment on this

Who said it?

Comment on this

I am giving the clear implications of what is here.

Comment on this

Make a case for the motion if you can.

Comment on this

Why do you not make a case?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that somebody said that this Swiss gentleman approached the Minister for Industry and Commerce for any purpose?

Comment on this

I shall read the statement made here—or rather I will not. I shall let this report stand by itself.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy refer to the column in the report in which that allegation was made?

Comment on this

I shall refer to column 836, where the Minister for Justice is reported as having stated:—

"I never heard that there was a charge made against the Minister for Industry and Commerce until I heard Deputy Flanagan say so to-night. It is the first I heard of it or of a charge against Senator Quirke."

Now the Minister for Justice accepts that, in whatever was said here on Wednesday night, there was an allegation in relation to the Minister or his Department on the one hand and in relation to a member of the Oireachtas on the other.

Comment on this

Concerning an approach by a Swiss gentleman to the Department of Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

Concerning the whole case in which Deputy Flanagan indicated, as reported in column 831, that as compared with the treatment of a group of Irish citizens here, the Government having refused to receive a deputation to discuss the matter, "another group of foreigners, the international chancers I have referred to, have come over here and have found a spot in the hearts of Fianna Fáil henchmen". It may be that the Department of Industry and Commerce was not specifically mentioned, but at any rate the general trend of the discussion and the statements made by Deputy Flanagan was such that the Minister for Justice picked it up that a charge was being made against the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

It was specifically stated in the House that they were able to get concessions from the Department of Industry and Commerce within 24 hours.

Comment on this

Who said so?

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

It was stated specifically in the House.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

I consider that it is my duty to ask the Government to take cognisance of the debate, even if they take cognisance only of the reactions of that debate on the Minister for Justice. It seems to me, from reading the whole of the debate, that there are allegations that the Department for Industry and Commerce gave concessions to this particular group that they were not prepared to give to others; there are allegations that a member of the Oireachtas used his influence as such to get concessions from the Government or some Government Department; there are allegations that a member of the Bar outside made use of his position to approach the President— to get some kind of influence or patronage through the Presidential office to get concessions that would not be available to other people.

I ask the Government to realise the effect these allegations have on the public mind, on the prestige of this House and on the confidence of the people in the impartial administration of the Government. If there are allegations made here that are unwarranted, if allegations are made inside the privileges of the House, then the House ought to be anxious to safeguard these privileges and ought to see that these privileges are not abused.

One of the effects of setting up a tribunal would be to ascertain the facts and, as a necessary corollary to ascertaining the facts, to disclose whether an abuse was being made by any Deputy of the privileges of the House.

Comment on this

What difference would that make to Deputy Flanagan?

Comment on this

If Deputy Flanagan makes charges against Ministers or other persons inside the privileges of the House, it is the duty of the House to find out whether these charges are warranted or not.

Comment on this

And then?

Comment on this

And then, if they are not warranted, in defence of our rights and prerogatives here, where we consider we have, under the Constitutions, rights guaranteed to us to speak here and be responsible to nobody unless to the House, then we must guard those rights and privileges.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! I hope someone will bring in a motion to try to get that done.

Comment on this

I am giving the Taoiseach an opportunity, in the face of an actual happening, to set up a committee which will, if necessary, move somewhat along that road. If we are to preserve our privileges here we will not do it by sitting down and, in an academic way, discussing hypothetical instances of how our privileges may be abused. The type of inquiry I ask for is the type that is warranted by the circumstances and, if the Taoiseach has anything in his mind with regard to proceeding towards the proposals he had in his general resolution, he can only proceed in a satisfactory way by dealing with ad hoc matters as they arise here.

I do not want to make any allegations here or support any allegations. I am not saying that what Deputy Flanagan stated here is not correct; I am merely saying that these things were stated here and, once they were stated, apart from the reaction of the Minister for Justice to them, it should have been the Government's duty at once to proceed and have them investigated in the most formal way.

Two of the persons whose conduct has been reflected upon here, Senator Quirke and Mr. Sweeney, have both sent communications to the Press, Senator Quirke saying: "I shall lend any properly constituted judicial tribunal all the assistance in my power," and Mr. F. W. Gilligan, solicitor, writing on behalf of Mr. Seamus Sweeney, saying he would welcome the fullest possible inquiry into the transaction and his connection with it. These are people who have been aspersed in one way or another and they welcome an inquiry.

Comment on this

What other redress have they?

Comment on this

Will the Government give them the redress they seek?

Comment on this

Particularly when the Leader of the Opposition adopts the suggestion as if there was some substance in it.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

If the Minister cannot conduct himself outside the House, he should endeavour to do so inside the House, for once in his life.

Comment on this

I am sorry that the front or the back benchers in the Government Party will not face this matter in a serious and simple way. The debates in the Dáil on Wednesday, 22nd October, 1947, contain certain allegations and certain statements were made by the Minister for Justice as a comment on these allegations. What is printed in the Official Report for that day warrants the setting-up of a select committee of Deputies publicly to investigate and report to the Dáil on the circumstances connected with any attempt to sell or buy Locke's Distillery during the period mentioned in the report. I mention a date there, not because I want all the transactions going back to that date investigated, but merely because I think it necessary to inquire into any attempt by Locke's to sell their property or business in the recent past and it is necessary to inquire into all the facts in relation to any attempt made to buy the property or the business associated with Locke's Distillery.

The allegation here is that in the dealings with Government Departments there was certain discrimination as between various bodies trying to buy the place. There was particularly favourable discrimination in relation to the group that was referred to here by the Minister for Justice in his reply on the 22nd October. It is stated that a member of the Oireachtas endeavoured to misuse his privileges in his contact with the Department to get concessions for his friends that other people might not get and that a member of the Bar attempted to make use of his connection with the President and make use of the Presidential office to have his interests assisted in some way or another.

I think these are matters that, when the dignity and the prestige of the Oireachtas have to be maintained, Deputies on every side of the House should realise should be inquired into systematically and orderly, straight away. I, therefore, move the motion that stands here and I seriously ask the Government to accept it that, in doing so, I am simply carrying out in a formal way a duty that I feel is my public responsibility. They should be as wide awake to the fact that an inquiry of this kind is wanted and wanted immediately.

Comment on this

I formally second the motion and reserve the right to speak later.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

A motion of this kind, moved by the Leader of the principal Opposition Party, has to be taken seriously. We do not have to take it seriously, however, that Deputy Mulcahy's pose on the altar of rectitude, is inspired by the highest motives. He put down this motion in order to place the support of his party behind the allegations made last week by Deputy Flanagan. The purpose of the motion is political blackmail. Deputy Mulcahy and every one of his colleagues know that, once a motion of this kind is submitted, the Government has either to accept it or take the risk that its refusal will be interpreted by foolish people as implying that it has something to conceal, that there is some substance in the allegations.

Is it seriously suggested by Deputy Mulcahy that when any Deputy, with or without responsibility, makes an allegation concerning any member of the Government or any member of the Oireachtas, there must be an immediate public inquiry into it? I submit that that is a most preposterous suggestion. Surely, before we establish a public inquiry and bring a whole lot of private citizens into the glare of publicity that attends a public inquiry, we should be satisfied, every one of us, that the allegations were made by a responsible person and with substance? Are we satisfied that that is so in this case? Deputy Mulcahy washes his hands of responsibility for the allegations. He tells us he is not supporting the allegations or criticising the person who made them. I submit that that is not good enough. I submit that this Dáil should not, in any circumstances, pass a motion for the establishment of a public inquiry until it is sure that there is somebody with a serious charge to make, who is prepared to substantiate that charge before the inquiry.

In this particular case, allegations have been made against a member of the Oireachtas and a member of the Government, unnamed, concerning transactions associated with the sale of Locke's Distillery, Kilbeggan. They have been made by a Deputy who I think nobody will contend has been otherwise than notoriously reckless in matters of that kind.

Comment on this

You knew that when you came down to Leix-Offaly.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not make those charges in Leix-Offaly. He made them here, under cover of the privilege which he enjoys as a member of the House.

Comment on this

And I have evidence to substantiate them.

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear it. The Deputy will have every opportunity to produce his evidence.

Comment on this

And I have witnesses to prove it.

Comment on this

These charges were made under the privilege of the House. Deputy Mulcahy referred to the fact that two individuals, not members of this House, have welcomed this public inquiry. Of course they welcome it. Their honour has been impugned, their reputations besmirched and, because these charges were made under privilege of this House, they have no other redress except a public inquiry. If these charges were made elsewhere, they would have recourse to the ordinary process of the law to vindicate their characters. They were made here, and made here in circumstances which ensured that, if the Deputy who made them is shown in an inquiry to have made them recklessly, he is still immune from all consequences to himself. He is immune from all consequences, even if it is shown that these charges were made maliciously, or worse.

Deputy Mulcahy is very concerned about the dignity of the Dáil and the honour of our public life. That issue does arise here, but does not arise out of the charges made by Deputy Flanagan. It arises in relation to Deputy Flanagan's conduct. However, we have a motion here which requests the Dáil to agree to set up a committee of the Dáil to investigate and report on all the facts and all the circumstances connected with and surrounding any proposal made or attempted to be made at any time either to buy or to sell Locke's Distillery, Kilbeggan. I submit that this Dáil is entitled to consider a proposal by a Deputy to establish an inquiry only if there are serious grounds for believing that a member of the Oireachtas, a member of the Government, an officer of the public service or other public official has in any way misused his position, or if it can be shown that there is a major matter of public issue involved.

I submit that it is not within the competence of this Dáil to inquire into the private affairs of private citizens who themselves have committed no irregularity or broken no law. If, therefore, there is to be an inquiry arising out of these allegations, that inquiry must be confined, I submit, to allegations that public men of any kind have abused their position. I do not think we are entitled to inquire why the owners of Locke's Distillery have decided to sell it. I do not think we should establish a precedent of that kind, because such a precedent would be very undesirable.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

We are not asking that.

Comment on this

The Deputy is certainly asking that.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Why they decided.

Comment on this

The Deputy is asking for an inquiry into all the facts and circumstances——

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Not as to why they decided.

Comment on this

——connected with and concerning any proposal made or attempted to be made at any time either to buy or to sell Locke's Distillery.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

But not why they decided to sell or not to sell.

Comment on this

I do not believe that Deputy Mulcahy is a Socialist, but I am quite certain that a motion of this kind, to inquire into private business transactions of private citizens who have broken no law, if it were persisted in and became a practice, would easily destroy all private business enterprise in this country. Nobody denies the right of the Dáil to inquire into the conduct of public officials; nobody denies the right of the Dáil to establish an inquiry into allegations against Ministers or against members of the Dáil; but I do say that a motion which contemplates that, over and above the conduct of public men, there is to be an inquiry into the private business affairs of private citizens should not be entertained.

Now whether the Government is going to agree to hold an inquiry or not will depend on this discussion. I do not think that anything has been said to-night or last week which would justify the decision to establish an inquiry. I do not think we should agree to establish an inquiry, until it is made clear by statements here that a member of the Dáil or someone known to a member of the Dáil is in a position to produce evidence of any kind to support allegations which have been made against public men. If there is going to be an inquiry—and I want Deputy Flanagan to listen to this—the inquiry will be by a judicial tribunal and all the witnesses will have to give evidence on oath.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

And I would suggest that there should be cross-examination.

Comment on this

Yes, and imprisonment for any witness who perjures himself.

Comment on this

Cross-examination is what I am interested in.

Comment on this

Will the Minister meet the proposal?

Comment on this

When it has been established that there is something to be inquired into.

Comment on this

That would not be difficult.

Comment on this

I hope that Deputy Dillon has some information that would be of value to the Dáil or of assistance to an inquiry.

Comment on this

It is all in the hands of the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

I will set out the facts of the case as I know them. As far as the Department for Industry and Commerce is concerned the history of the case is as follows: The first reference on the Department's records to the possibility of the Kilbeggan Distillery changing hands was made at a conference which was attended by representatives of all the distilleries in the country and which was held on the 16th April, 1947. At that conference Mr. Joseph Cooney, Manager of J. Locke and Co., Ltd., stated that the distillery was likely to change hands in the near future. When the report of that conference reached me I decided that the firm of solicitors representing the owners of the distillery should be invited to the Department to discuss the position, and particularly for the purpose of conveying to them my concern at the possibility of the firm passing into the hands of persons who might have no interest in maintaining it or who might in any way pursue a policy which would be detrimental to the interests of the whole Irish whiskey trade. An invitation to the solicitors representing J. Locke, Ltd., to come to the Department was issued on May 18th, and on May 21st the firm's solicitor was interviewed by a deputy secretary of the Department. The solicitor confirmed the report that the business was for sale and stated that it had been advertised in British newspapers. He said that inquiries had been already received. The deputy secretary informed him that I was interested in developing exports, particularly to hard currency countries, that I considered that the distillery industry had good potentialities in that regard, and that I therefore considered it essential that nothing should happen which might prejudice the Irish whiskey trade. He said that I was opposed to the sale if it seemed likely that the distillery was being bought for a short-term policy of exploiting the present shortage of whiskey or for a long-term policy of putting on the market the products of the distillery as a blend with other whiskey. The solicitor mentioned that I had no power to interfere with the sale—as the Deputies are aware.

The Deputy secretary pointed out that while I had no power to prevent or to interfere with a sale to any person, I exercised a control over whiskey exports and the sale of whiskey in bond, and if the business were sold under circumstances which I thought detrimental to the national interests, then I might consider withholding facilities for export or for sale in bond. The solicitor undertook to inform any likely purchaser of these circumstances and to inform the Department of any developments in regard to the sale.

The next record on the Departmental file is that on May 30th representatives of certain British interests inquired at the Department and were informed of my attitude in the same terms as the company's solicitor. Other tentative inquiries were received from Irish interests.

On July 23rd Mr. Joseph Cooney, the manager of the firm, accompanied by Mr. P.L. MacEvoy were interviewed by the Assistant Secretary of the Department. Mr. Cooney intimated that he, Mr. MacEvoy and other friends were interested in the purchase of the distillery, but expressed the opinion that persons interested in the distillery in order to exploit the present shortage and others interested in restricting its development might bid more than a fair price and prevent him from acquiring it. He urged that there should be further amplification of the conditions on which I would approve of the sale, the conditions which were communicated to the firm's solicitor on the occasion of his interview, in order to eliminate other purchasers who might have undesirable motives. The secretary who interviewed Mr. Cooney and Mr. MacEvoy informed them of my general attitude as it was explained to the company's solicitor.

On September 9th Mr. Cooney again visited the Department accompanied by Senator Quirke of the firm of Stokes and Quirke. They stated that an Irish group in association with a Swiss group intended to purchase the distillery and that a company would be formed with a majority of Irish capital and of Irish directors. Mr. Thomas Morris, Clonmel, was stated to be interested.

Comment on this

Quirke had good fishing for a directorship.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making allegations which, if an inquiry is held, he will have to prove. Every idle word spoken by him is being taken down and put on record and the records will be before the tribunal, if there is one, and the Deputy will have to justify what he says and I would advise him to keep his mouth shut.

Comment on this

I imagine that is what the Minister wants.

Comment on this

On the contrary. I am giving that advice but I do not expect that he will take it. I am going to ask him some questions later which I hope he will answer.

It was stated that the new company was interested in whiskey exports to Switzerland and an increase in the company's small quota for export was requested. The officer of the Department referred them on that point to an assistant secretary to whom they explained that the new company was prepared to extend operations and to produce for the Swiss market and that it would need an increase in the annual quota for the export of mature whiskey. That application, together with another application from another distillery, was referred to me at a conference that afternoon. As both applications involved exports to hard currency areas I decided to grant them.

Comment on this

Was it a written application?

Comment on this

No, it was a verbal application.

Comment on this

Which of them made it?

Comment on this

I could not say.

Comment on this

But was it Cooney or Quirke that spoke?

Comment on this

I did not hear them speak. Both of them were there together.

The final record is that on September 30th the Minister for Justice informed the Department for Industry and Commerce that it was making inquiries in regard to Swiss nationals who were involved in the transaction, who were under suspicion because they were associated with another alien who was considered undesirable.

That is the Departmental record. The allegations made by Deputy Flanagan and supported indirectly by General Mulcahy will have to be considered in relation to that record.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say who were the Swiss nationals at that stage? They have not been mentioned yet.

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

The Department of Justice were after Swiss nationals who were interested in the sale. Who were they?

Comment on this

Eindiguer. The note on the file concerning the conversation refers only to Eindiguer. They were inquiring about him because of his association with Mr. Sachael. Taking Deputy Flanagan's allegations in the order in which they were made——

Comment on this

Where does Sachael come in?

Comment on this

Taking Deputy Flanagan's allegations in the order in which they were made here last Wednesday, they were, firstly:

"He (the Minister) is also aware of the fact that a group of Irish citizens made an attempt to take over and develop and to improve the conditions in this distillery and that the Government refused to receive a deputation to discuss the matter and refused to entertain the claims of Irish nationalists for this distillery."

Does Deputy Flanagan know that to be a fact?

Comment on this

Had the Minister received a letter from Mr. Cooney prior to 9th September, setting out the consequences that might arise if those undesirable aliens got control of the industry.

Comment on this

I did, and it was as a result of that letter he was interviewed on the first occasion.

Comment on this

Will the Minister read Mr. Cooney's letter?

Comment on this

I shall deal with Mr. Cooney in a minute. "... a group of Irish citizens made an attempt to take over and develop and to improve the conditions in this distillery, and that the Government refused to receive a deputation to discuss the matter and refused to entertain the claims of Irish nationalists...." Does the Deputy stand over that statement?

Comment on this

I shall make my speech in a few minutes.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy name the person or the group whom the Government refused to receive or whose proposal to develop the distillery the Government refused to entertain?

Comment on this

Probably these people will come up at the inquiry.

Comment on this

The Deputy is gaining nothing by his silence.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Minister told him a few minutes ago to keep his mouth shut.

Comment on this

I also told him that I proposed to put him a few questions. Deputies opposite are not living up to Deputy Mulcahy's non-committal attitude. Is there a matter to be inquired into? Is there anybody in this Dáil who will say here now that they know that statement to be true or that they know anybody who will assert it to be true and give testimony to that effect before the tribunal? Silence.

Comment on this

That is what the tribunal is to find out.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy testify before the tribunal that that statement is true?

Comment on this

Is this kind of thing in order—this cross-examination? The Minister is entitled to put questions to the Deputy. The Deputy is entitled to answer those questions——

Comment on this

He is not answering them.

Comment on this

When he speaks.

Comment on this

I invite Deputy Flanagan to take a note of my questions. That is the statement he made. Is it true or not true?

Comment on this

I rose on a point of order. Let me further remind the Leas-Cheann Comhairle that, ten minutes ago, the Minister was threatening the same Deputy if he opened his mouth.

Comment on this

I invite Deputy Flanagan, when he comes to speak, to say whether that statement is true or not. Does he know, in fact, that it is true? Does he know anybody who will go before the tribunal and swear that it is true? Will he name the people——

Comment on this

Mr. Cooney.

Comment on this

The person most frequently in contact with the Department about this distillery was Mr. Cooney. You say that Mr. Cooney was refused access to the Department?

Comment on this

You asked a question and he has given you the answer.

Comment on this

My Department was approached on four occasions concerning the sale of this distillery: on the first occasion, by the solicitor of Locke and Company, a gentleman named Mooney; on the second occasion, by certain British interests who, so far as I know, disappeared from the picture, and, on the third occasion and on the fourth occasion by Mr. Cooney. We were approached by nobody else.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

On the fourth occasion, he brought the proper escort.

Comment on this

Is that Deputy Morrissey's allegation? I am stating the fact; the Deputy, presumably, believes what he states to be true and will testify to it. Let me put something on the record: no individual or group approached my Department for information concerning the Government's attitude in connection with the sale of the distillery in any way which was not received and which did not receive precisely the same information as any other party obtained. That is on the record and I shall testify to it.

Comment on this

Did Eindiguer and Sachael get the same——

Comment on this

We shall deal with them. Deputy O'Higgins's testimony in that regard will come into the picture. Deputy Flanagan's second allegation was:—

"The Minister has very good reasons for withholding the information in order to safeguard the names of his colleagues and in order to safeguard a certain Minister of State that has a keen personal interest in the question of the sale of Locke's Distillery."

Who is the Minister? Is this Dáil being asked to set up a committee of inquiry into charges against a Minister who will not be named? Note the silence. Is Deputy Mulcahy standing over his motion now?

Comment on this

The Minister is helping me more and more to stand over it.

Comment on this

There is an allegation against some Minister but so indefinite is that allegation that the name of that Minister will not be given. I cannot ask Deputy Flanagan to answer now. Even if I did, it would be quite useless. When he comes to speak, I ask him to say what Minister he had in mind when saying that or what knowledge he has to support that allegation or, if he has not that knowledge, who has and what he means precisely by "keen personal interest in the question of the sale of Locke's Distillery"? The Deputy's third allegation was:—

"Mr. George Eindiguer stated in the presence of a number of citizens in a certain hotel in this city that it was suggested by Senator Quirke that it might be a nice friendly gesture if Mr. Eindiguer would bring over a gold watch and give it to the Taoiseach's son as a present in order to soften things."

Silence is of no importance here because Deputy Flanagan went on:

"That is a statement I can stand over; that is a statement that was made by Senator Quirke to Mr. Eindiguer."

It is with some reluctance that I deal with this matter of the watch. Nasty things come into the political life of this country and, as Deputy Mulcahy has associated himself with this nasty thing, he is going to feel the full brunt of this. Senator Quirke has a sister to whom he is very deeply attached. That sister was seriously ill. She was in a sanatorium on the Continent and so ill that hopes of her recovery ended. Senator Quirke arranged to bring her back to Ireland. He brought her back and he placed her under the care of Dr. de Valera. Under his care, she recovered—a rather remarkable recovery. So deeply grateful was Senator Quirke to Dr. de Valera for the care, attention and skill which he devoted to his sister and for the remarkable recovery which he effected that he was anxious to make to Dr. de Valera a presentation of some kind. He saw Mr. Eindiguer wearing a watch and he said that that was the type of watch he would like to buy to present to Dr. de Valera. That was the end of the matter. So far as Senator Quirke was concerned, the watch was never purchased and never presented.

Comment on this

Where is the full brunt of that, so far as I am concerned?

Comment on this

If the Deputy does not feel any sense of shame, he is beyond redemption. What is the allegation? What is the purpose of Deputy Flanagan's mean insinuation? Is it seriously believed by any Deputy opposite that Mr. Eindiguer was going to get some concession from the Department of Industry and Commerce because of a watch presented to Dr. de Valera? Let me say here that, so far as I know, Dr. de Valera does not yet know that such a presentation was intended. He was probably the only one who did not know that Senator Quirke had the idea in mind.

Comment on this

Maximoe has his watch.

Comment on this

That is on the record, too, and the Deputy will, no doubt, of his own knowledge be able to testify to it. Is it seriously believed by any Deputy here that by a process of bringing a watch to Dr. de Valera, a watch which he did not know he was going to get and has not yet got, Eindiguer or his friends got some concession in the Department of Industry and Commerce? What concession did they get? What is the allegation? In what way is it suggested that as a result of that particular measure that they got any advantage? What advantages is it alleged they got? Is it seriously believed by anyone that I, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, dealing with that application for an increase in Locke's quota made by Mr. Cooney, the manager of Locke's, and who never heard of Eindiguer, who never before then knew of his existence or heard his name mentioned or knew of the watch, was nevertheless influenced in my judgment by this intention of Senator Quirke? Is that a proper matter on which to set up a commission of inquiry to investigate? I hope Deputy Mulcahy is beginning to feel some sense of shame.

Comment on this

Tell us how they got into Árus an Uachtaráin.

Comment on this

"Sixty-one thousand gallons of whiskey from this distillery were to be sold by those irresponsible Swiss citizens at £11 per gallon in the black market to a Mr. Jameson, representing Messrs. James Stewart and Co., Distillers, Park Lane, London, and for this transaction in the black market they were to get £660,000"—no less. Does Deputy Flanagan know that to be a fact?

Comment on this

Mr. Cooney, the Managing Director, knows it to be a fact and can stand over it and prove it.

Comment on this

I am delighted the Deputy said that. I am delighted to have that on the record because Mr. Cooney, the Managing Director of the Kilbeggan Distillery, wrote a letter on the 14th October, which is on the Departmental file, in which he stated that he had received a report that this whiskey was being offered and that it was stated on the document: "Export licence available," and continued: "I knew this was not so and that it would take a long number of years to deliver the quantity from our licence." I am glad Mr. Cooney is being brought out into the open because I, personally, had no doubt as to who was inspiring Deputy Flanagan to raise this question here. Did Mr. Cooney tell Deputy Flanagan that there were 61,000 gallons of mature whiskey in Kilbeggan? Does Deputy Flanagan know that there are? At the conference which was held on the 16th April, at which all the distilleries were represented, and which was concerned with the possibility of increasing whiskey sales, Mr. Cooney, having mentioned the fact that the distillery was for sale, added that a change of ownership would not have any significant effect on the total quantity of whiskey to be released from bond as the Kilbeggan Distillery held only a very small stock of mature whiskey. Is it beginning to dawn on Deputy Flanagan that he was led up the garden by Mr. Cooney? If it is not, it will dawn on him yet.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Cooney state the number of gallons then available?

Comment on this

I know the number of gallons which were then available but I do not want to give information concerning this firm until it has to be done. I can understand Deputy Blowick's interest in Mr. Cooney. He was a candidate, I believe, for his Party at the last election.

Comment on this

The Minister has no information as to whether Deputy Blowick is interested or not.

Comment on this

You have a paternal interest in Mr. Cooney's welfare. Dr. O'Higgins, too, knows something— something that is on the record. "Within 24 hours of their arrival they were able to enter a Minister's office and get documents and evidence of trade facilities...." Does Dr. O'Higgins know that to be true?

Comment on this

Dr. O'Higgins has information which he conscientiously believes to be reliable to justify that statement.

Comment on this

I am delighted the Deputy has said that. I am putting this on the record. These people were never in the Department of Industry and Commerce at any time during their whole stay in this country—not on a single occasion.

Comment on this

The Minister is an expert at debate and evasiveness. When I speak of "these people" I speak of them or their representatives.

Comment on this

"Their representatives" being Mr. Joseph Cooney. The only representative of these people who came to the Department of Industry and Commerce was Mr. Joseph Cooney, accompanied by Senator William Quirke.

Comment on this

I have a statement on record and I am——

Comment on this

You are already beginning to qualify it.

Comment on this

No. I am anxious to get an opportunity to produce and show the information I have behind it.

Comment on this

I believe the Deputy will have plenty of opportunity for doing so.

Comment on this

I do not want to be caught out on a point.

Comment on this

"Within 24 hours of their arrival they were able to enter a Minister's office and get documents and evidence of trade facilities." That is the statement Deputy Dr. O'Higgins says he can prove to be true.

Comment on this

I did not catch the Minister on that.

Comment on this

I will repeat it for your benefit. "Within 24 hours of their arrival they were able to enter a Minister's office and get documents and evidence of trade facilities." Do you now say you can prove that statement to be true?

Comment on this

I have stated very clearly——

Comment on this

——that the statement is not true.

Comment on this

There are more reputations than the Minister's at stake.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

What I stated was that Dr. O'Higgins made that statement on information which he conscientiously believed to be reliable and which he would produce at the proper time.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have a chance. I am on the record. I say that that is untrue in substance and in fact. That is the whole of the case. These are all the allegations that were made in the Dáil. People were going round the country whispering other allegations. Unfortunately we cannot deal with these. That is the sum total of the charges made here.

Comment on this

Tell us what happened in Árus an Uachtaráin.

Comment on this

Just a minute. There were certain non-nationals involved in this business. Mr. Eindiguer. I never heard of him until his name was mentioned by Mr. Cooney on the occasion of his visit to the Department on the 9th September. I certainly hold no brief for him. He was a visitor to this country and until we know otherwise we should at least moderate our language in relation to him. The information available to us does not justify an assumption that he is other than what he represented himself to be. Enquiry was made from the police in Switzerland and from Scotland Yard and both reported that they know nothing against him. A commercial enquiry agency states that he has displayed fairly wide commercial activity inside and outside Switzerland, and that he has been a director of various companies. So far as we are concerned, we have nothing against him except that he was found here in bad company.

Comment on this

With the President.

Comment on this

It may be that he was a victim. He came here accompanied by this man Smith, alias Maximoe, who was described as his interpreter.

Comment on this

Would the Minister clear one point?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Is Cooney supposed to be in with the Eindiguer group?

Comment on this

He came as a representative of the group. Mr. Eindiguer came here because, I understand, he had established contacts in Switzerland with Mr. Morris of Clonmel. Mr. Morris had visited Switzerland in connection with some dog-racing development. He is, as everybody knows, the head of the dog-racing business in this country. He met Mr. Eindiguer there and Mr. Eindiguer came here under the auspices of Mr. Morris. He acted in a reputable way. He employed the firm of Arthur Cox & Co. as his solicitors and the firm of Stokes & Quirke as his auctioneers to carry through the deal. After a period a report appeared in the newspapers that Mr. Eindiguer, Maximoe and another alien named Sachael had been received at Árus an Uachtaráin. How that came about I have no knowledge. But immediately that report appeared in the newspapers, one man who knew something of this Mr. Sachael and who had previously been in contact with these other non-nationals and had entertained no doubts about their bona fides, became suspicious. That man was Senator Quirke. The Minister for Justice referred here last week to a friend who rang him up and urged that inquiry should be made. That friend was Senator Quirke. There was associated with this business Mr. Morris of Clonmel who, I understand, is a strong supporter of the Fine Gael Party, and Mr. Cooney, an adherent of Clann na Talmhan. If they had any suspicion about the bona fides of these non-nationals they did not communicate them to the police.

Comment on this

Are you going to follow that line? If you are, we will deal with it.

Comment on this

But immediately Senator Quirke saw this report in the newspaper, saw that these people were associated with Sachael—and that is the first time such association had come to his notice——

Comment on this

Who was trying to take Senator Quirke's commission from him.

Comment on this

——he got on the telephone to the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

And got Sachael deported.

Comment on this

I hope that is on the record. Would the Deputy repeat it, please?

Comment on this

Who was engaged at the time in trying to take away from the firm of Stokes & Quirke the patronage of Eindinguer, who was believed to be a wealthy man and about to transact a large purchase upon which the commission was £22,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy has evidence to support that allegation, no doubt. He will certainly be given an opportunity of producing it. However, the fact of the matter is that when this report appeared in the newspaper, Senator Quirke became suspicious because, as I said, he knew something of Sachael, knew that he was an alien under orders for deportation, immediately telephoned the Minister for Justice, who immediately contacted the police and instructed them to make all requisite inquiries.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister how did the Senator know that he was under orders for deportation and at what point?

Comment on this

I do not think there was any secret about it.

Comment on this

At what point did he know it? How long had he the knowledge before he rang up?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

May I ask was there a falling out between Senator Quirke and the gentleman referred to and subsequent to that falling out he rang up the Minister for Justice?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Local Government (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

Does Deputy O'Higgins know?

Comment on this

I will deal with the facts as they appear. Deputy O'Higgins is forgetting Deputy Mulcahy's attitude. Deputy Mulcahy's attitude is that you are making no accusations; you only think that as accusations have been made it is in the public interest that an inquiry should be held. They are doing their best to try by insinuation after insinuation to blacken the character of a man who is not here.

Comment on this

I am asking this question: Senator Quirke at a point rang up the Minister for Justice——

Comment on this

And he said——

Comment on this

That man—there is a deportation order against him?

Comment on this

No. He said: "I see that these people are in association with Sachael. That means the police should inquire about them."

Comment on this

How long had he that knowledge?

Comment on this

Could the Minister say——

Comment on this

By all means. I am glad you have broken your vow of silence.

Comment on this

Is there only one Deputy who can ask questions?

Comment on this

Is this Sachael the same Sachael as was in communication with the Minister's Department about starting a factory in this country to assemble Czechoslovakian motor cars in conjunction with Deputy Briscoe?

Comment on this

That is untrue. I do not know the man. I never heard of him.

Comment on this

This is what you want to inquire into. Do you want another inquiry into that allegation?

Comment on this

I only asked the question.

Comment on this

You are only trying to blacken another man's character, a man whose boots you are not fit to lick.

Comment on this

What I asked for was an orderly inquiry, Sir, where questions would be put in an orderly way before a body entitled and competent to listen to them in an orderly way.

Comment on this

An orderly inquiry in relation to allegations made by Deputy Flanagan and with no other support for them except his word!

Comment on this

Who started the disorder?

Comment on this

I know that Deputies opposite have had the bottom knocked out of their case by the fact that the first and only man to get suspicious about these foreigners and to draw the attention of the proper authorities to them was Senator Quirke.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Nonsense.

Comment on this

You have been besmirching his character, insinuating lies against him all over the country, but that is the fact that destroys your case.

Comment on this

Who has been besmirching him? Who is making the wild charges now?

Comment on this

Deputy Flanagan has made a statement here that this man Sachael was about to engage in the assembly of motor cars in association with me.

Comment on this

I am only asking the question.

Comment on this

Do you make that allegation?

Comment on this

I just want to know is it a fact.

Comment on this

I ask you to withdraw it now because it is untrue. I never heard of the man.

Comment on this

That is all I want to know.

Comment on this

Withdraw it then.

Comment on this

I did not make a statement. I asked to know was it a fact. I did not make a statement.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Flanagan withdraw the insinuation?

Comment on this

I made no statement.

Comment on this

I ask him to withdraw.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy insinuated and I think he should withdraw that on the disclaimer of Deputy Briscoe.

Comment on this

If I insinuated, I withdraw.

Comment on this

That is typical of Deputy Flanagan's honesty. In any case, the police made inquiries concerning this man, Smith, identified him with Maximoe who was wanted by Scotland Yard, found that he had entered the country on a false passport and he was deported. According to the Press reports, he will not be available to give evidence at the tribunal. Now, Deputy Flanagan says that Maximoe was arrested in the house of a friend of the Minister for Justice—this Mr. Sachael —such a friend of the Minister for Justice that the Minister for Justice ordered him to leave the country. Sachael was an alien who came here in circumstances described to-day by the Minister for Justice, and who at one time was interested in a project for the assembly of Czechoslovakian cars here. The police became suspicious of him and the period in which he was allowed to remain in the country was curtailed. If there is going to be any inquiry about that——

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that was his business.

Comment on this

He had other business also. In any case, as soon as the Guards began to make inquiries about him they decided that he was a man we were better off without and he was instructed to wind up his affairs and to get out. He has gone. Deputy Flanagan said he is an alien who sold £25,000 worth of Irish tweed to get dollars for "you", the "you" being in this case the Minister for Justice or the Government. Does Deputy Flanagan know that to be true? Who told Deputy Flanagan that yarn? Let me say, for the purpose of the record, that you cannot export any tweed or other cloth from this country without a permit and that no permit to export as much as one yard of cloth was issued to Mr. Sachael or anybody associated with him. These are the allegations. Do you still want an inquiry?

Comment on this

Yes. We certainly do.

Comment on this

If there is going to be an inquiry, we will give the tribunal something to inquire about. I will make allegations. Deputies opposite have not the monopoly of that. At least, I will ask a few questions which this tribunal may well be asked to answer. We know that there were other people interested in buying this distillery besides this particular group that are under discussion here. We know that one gentleman, in the course of an interview with the Department, expressed concern that other bidders might offer a higher price for the distillery than he was prepared to bid. Every Deputy here knows that somebody briefed Deputy Flanagan. Somebody induced him to come into this House and raise this question. Will Deputy Flanagan say who it was? The Deputy's silence will not protect him. That question will be asked in another place where he will have to answer and that is why I, for one, would be glad to see an inquiry. Could it be that that person asked Deputy Flanagan to raise this question here in the way in which it was raised with the idea that if Deputy Flanagan raised enough stink other prospective purchasers would be warned off and he could buy the property cheaper? I am not accusing Deputy Flanagan of being anything else but a tool. I think he was just handed a stick which he thought he could use to beat the Government and had not the sense to inquire into the motives of the man who handed him the stick. Or, was Deputy Flanagan a tool? Did he know the motives of the person who asked him to raise the matter here? Did he know that the raising of this matter here might be of cash benefit to that individual? I put this question on the record—to ask the tribunal to answer that also.

Comment on this

I cannot imagine that the cause of decency in the public life of this country has been materially served by the contribution made by the Tánaiste. I frequently find myself finding fault with the Leader of the Opposition for that he leans backwards in moderation expecting to elicit from the Government Front Bench a similar solicitude for decency in public life and the dignity of this Parliament. He never gets it, and instead of meeting with the moderate and judicial tone which he chose to adopt here to-day, the Tánaiste proceeded to put on a riotous and disedifying act. In the course of a long defence of himself, of his Department and of his colleagues, for which this was not the occasion, I understood him to say that four separate parties, one after the other, were at his Department to inquire about the permissibility of purchasing this distillery, and the Minister added "all four were told the same story". Is that true? He seems to have forgotten that ten minutes before he had informed us that the first three parties were given all the warning that the fourth party, of which Senator Quirke was a member, got, the warning and also the information that the export quota of this distillery would be raised from 4,000 gallons to 8,000 gallons in order to test the Swiss market. Now, there is an awful lot of money to be made out of an additional export of 4,000 gallons per annum, and if on my first request I could get a concession of 100 per cent. from the Department might not a modestly hopeful heart prophesy that at the next interview some further progress might be made in increasing the export quota which had already, at the first time of asking, gone up by 100 per cent.? Surely, there is a difference between the story told to this fourth party and to the other three, and a vital difference.

I confess that when I heard Deputy Flanagan recite the story about Mr. Eindiguer being asked to bring a gold watch to this country to present it to the Taoiseach's son I regarded it as just fantastic nonsense—that Deputy Flanagan had been sold a dud. I confess to being utterly stunned by the story told here by the Tánaiste to-day. Surely, if any of us wanted to make a handsome present to a person, to someone in whose debt we were deeply committed in the circumstances recited by the Tánaiste, it was reasonable, natural and to be expected that Senator Quirke would feel himself under a debt that no fee could pay to Dr. de Valera for the medical services he had done—but in that atmosphere is there not something strangely incongruous that when you are choosing your gift that you should choose to smuggle it?

Comment on this

Whose suggestion is that?

Comment on this

Your suggestion.

Comment on this

I have said that the thing is fantastic, but the Minister tells me that Senator Quirke said to Eindiguer "that is the kind of watch I want; will you bring it over the next time you are coming?"

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Yes. Maybe the man meant that Endiguer would go around to the Department to get a licence from the Minister, import the watch, present it to the customs, pay duty on it and bring it in, and that he would recoup him, but it seems so odd to me, because if I felt my heart overflowing with the desire to offer something over and above a generous fee I would go down to West's or Weir's or Hopkins' and get a really choice watch to give to my benefactor. However, it is quite conceivable that we here, hearing this story, are being wise after the event. Let me go on record in saying that I am as certain as that we are standing in this room that there was nothing present to the mind of the Taoiseach or Dr. de Valera which would for a moment justify——

Comment on this

I did not hear it until it was mentioned here.

Comment on this

——the suggestion that they knew or heard anything or discussed anything. I prefer to think, and I am prepared to concede in the context of the story told by the Tánaiste that in this matter Senator Quirke was guilty of an indiscretion. Instead of going down town and buying a watch the thought occurred to his mind when he saw this time-piece in Eindiguer's hand. Why he should draw Dr. de Valera's name into the matter and not realise that that name had associations in this country, that it was not a prudent thing to canvass about with a well-known financier, surpasses me to understand, but to pretend that the person to whom that story was told is moved by nothing but malice when he comments adversely upon it is fantastic. The best thing we can say is that a fantastic indiscretion took place on that occasion. To mention the name of the Taoiseach's son in such a context was really beyond the limits of wild indiscretion.

The Tánaiste referred to a report made by Senator Quirke to the Minister for Justice that his suspicious were aroused by the appearance of Mr. Sachael in the company of Mr. Maximoe and Mr. Eindiguer.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

He was not known as Maximoe at that time.

Comment on this

No, but as Mr. Smith. I can well imagine Senator Quirke acting in that way. The Minister went on to say that Senator Quirke, Mr. Morris and Mr. Cooney were all apprised of this, but that only the public-spirited Senator Quirke rushed to the Minister for Justice and warned him. That is one explanation, but if you want to make those kind of reflections remember that that story can be given another meaning. I will tell the House in a moment that the way Sachael appeared in this whole transaction was that he was trying to muscle in on Senator Quirke's deal: that he had, in fact, taken away Senator Quirke's customer from him.

Comment on this

Do you know this?

Comment on this

How do you know that Mr. Morris and Mr. Cooney failed in their duty?

Comment on this

I did not say so.

Comment on this

You implied it—that Senator Quirke rushed to the Minister, whereas the other two men did nothing. I am saying there are two interpretations could be put on that. I know that Sachael was muscling in. I know that Sachael had got hold of Eindiguer.

Comment on this

You know it.

Comment on this

I know it and a lot more that I propose to tell you before I sit down. I know that Senator Quirke went to the Minister for Justice, because I was told so by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to-day, and directed the Minister's attention to the fact that Eindiguer was no longer in the company of Senator Quirke, but was drinking tea with Sachael in Árus an Uachtaráin. The next performance was that the Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us that when he sent that message to the Minister he knew that Sachael was a man liable to deportation. The Tánaiste went on to say that Sachael was gone. There is nobody muscling in on the bargain now.

Comment on this

That is an insinuation. I take it?

Comment on this

It is a fact. Sachael is gone and you glory in it, and Sachael is gone at the instance of Senator Quirke. I think he is a very good riddance. It would have been a great deal better for all of us if he never came here and a great deal better still if he and Maximoe and Mr. Sweeney did not drink tea in the Presidential drawing-room and send the social secretary down to the telephone. Those blushing souls whom we are not to drag into the light of publicity were not so coy when they asked the social secretary in Árus an Uachtaráin to telephone to several newspapers in Dublin to announce that they had been drinking tea with the President. When some of the newspapers rang back to inquire were they to print it "Messieurs Sachael, Maximoe and Eindiguer and Mr. and Mrs. Sweeney"——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy making a charge against Mr. Sweeney?

Comment on this

I am making no charges. In any case, with great respect, I propose to make my speech. Perhaps the Ceann Comhairle was not here when the Tánaiste chose to put this debate on this level. It is not the Opposition's seeking; it is the Minister desired to put these matters in issue.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Including Mr. Sweeney?

Comment on this

Yes. There was no coyness then. They wanted the world to know that the names were "Messieurs Eindiguer, Maximoe and Sachael and Mr. and Mrs. Sweeney". Before that it was Messieurs Eindiguer and Maximoe and Mr. Sachael. That was the correction that was made. Mr. Sachael was hoping that Herr Von Sachael or Monsieur Sachael might be a thing of yesteryear and that in two years' time he would come to be known as Patrick O'Sachael from Connemara.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Local Government (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy knows that?

Comment on this

That he was trying to plant himself here?

Comment on this

That he would become Mr. O'Sachael in a couple of years.

Comment on this

I have seen so many of the Minister's supporters travel that road that I am intelligently deducing the future from what has occurred in the past. As to the last point made by the Tánaiste. "I deny," says the Tánaiste, "that any inquiry lies in regard to the conduct of private individuals." That is a general doctrine to which, ordinarily, we could all subscribe. I remember making that submission when Dr. Ward was the victim and it was rebutted very energetically from the opposite benches.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a friend and protector of his reputation.

Comment on this

I am not his friend, protector or admirer, but I should like to see justice for the meanest creature in this country as for the most exalted. I agree with the general principle that the private affairs of Deputies or of citizens of this State are no concern of Parliament. But since when was the President of Ireland a private individual? Since when are the social columns registering the comings and goings of guests to that house of election a matter of private individuals? Since when did private individuals desiring to have their activities retained within the sphere of private activity go down and telephone to the public Press asking them to record that they had been drinking tea in Arus an Uachtaráin? We could understand foolish women with social aspirations seeking that distinction for no other purpose than to triumph over their neighbours. But can you picture the hard Sachael, the experienced Maximoe seeking to include their names in the social register of Árus an Uachtaráin in order to say to their neighbours in Connemara: "We got up to see the President and you did not"? Was it social ambition that inspired them to appear in that milieu before their neighbours?

That is in answer to the whirling language which the Tánaiste chose to employ. But I will state with as great detachment as I can the reasons why I support the Leader of the Opposition in the motion he makes to-night. He asks this House to inquire into the circumstances surrounding the transactions which have taken place in respect to Locke's Distillery. Here is the way the transactions look to one citizen of this State—myself.

From the information that came my way, every particle of which I thrust upon the Minister for Justice, not at his request but because I desire him to know it, I know that Mr. Eindiguer turns up in Ireland attended by Mr. Maximoe, alias Maxwell, alias Smith. But that is not all. That was the party whose names were published in the social intelligence column. But they were also attended, proximately or remotely, by Mrs. Chappell and Miss Donnico. Now perhaps the learned Tánaiste, who knows so much about this business, can tell us what Mrs. Chappell's interest in it was or what she claimed it to be. What was Miss Donnico's interest in this transaction?

Comment on this

To the best of my knowledge I never heard the names before.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy maintain they were present?

Comment on this

Do you know that?

Comment on this

The moment these facts came to my knowledge I communicated them at once to the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

You did not.

Comment on this

Why does the Minister for Local Government say I did not?

Comment on this

You communicated them, I presume, to-day, when you knew this inquiry was coming off and you got cold feet.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister for Justice will correct him. Is it not true that I waited on the Minister immediately after the debate and told him all I knew?

Comment on this
Gerald Boland Minister for Justice (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

Last week; that is so. I want one thing to be clearly understood. These people mentioned by Deputy Dillon are not people who would require any permit. They were British people with passports and were not foreigners whom we would be entitled to question. We had no responsibility for their being here. That is the point I want to make.

Comment on this

Perhaps at this juncture the Minister for Local Government would intervene to say that he is sorry for his insolence.

Comment on this

I am not going to say I am sorry because it has elicited some information which has at least cleared my mind with regard to Deputy Dillon's part in this transaction. All the time he was making the balls for Deputy Flanagan to fire.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know that? Might that be put on record? We will have it on oath.

Comment on this

In the course of my observations, I stated that I informed the Minister for Justice in accordance with the undertaking I had given the House. The Minister for Local Government says I did not. I invite the Minister for Justice to correct him, which he does.

Comment on this

Naturally, I accept the word of the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

Was it not an ignorant and insolent thing not to accept mine?

Comment on this

So many of the Deputy's words are irresponsible that I must sometimes try to appraise them for myself.

Comment on this

I assume he desires to be known as ignorant and insolent. The presence of these persons circulating in the atmosphere of this transaction causes me to wonder; but, let us not pretend that, in the course of trade and commerce, every casual person you meet in transacting business is a person for whose character and antecedents you can answer without reservation. I have no doubt that I have, I have no doubt that Senator Quirke has, and I have no doubt that every man in business has, from time to time, casually come in contact with persons in the course of business of whom he knows nothing.

But, then two new figures appear on the scene. It is then that Mr. Sachael under the escort of Mr. Sweeney appeared and this peculiar picture unfolds—Senator Quirke, Mr. Eindiguer, Mr. Maximoe and their retinue—all that retinue, all those principals make contact with Mr. Sweeney and Mr. Sachael, except Senator Quirke. The impression I draw from that is that Senator Quirke's position is: "I am not going to have anything to do with Sachael and Sweeney. I am prepared to transact this business for Mr. Eindiguer if he chooses to leave it in the hands of our firm, but Sachael and Sweeney have nothing to do with me and I want to have nothing to do with them." I am confirmed in that view because I suggest that Eindiguer, having been Senator Quirke's client and the full resources of Messrs. Stokes and Quirke being at his disposal, being approached to transfer his business from Senator Quirke's hands to Mr. Sweeney's, prudently replies: "I am in the hands of a very good man, a very influential man, a man who knows the ropes and I want no better agent than Quirke."

Mr. Eindiguer is a man who spoke only French and German—he spoke no English at all. He brought Maximoe here, or Maximoe alleged that he did, as his interpreter. Sachael spoke German, and when Sachael is informed by Mr. Eindiguer that he wants no change, that he is well content with his advisers, who are influential men, what surmise can we make except that somebody said: "Eindiguer believes that Quirke is the only man with pull in this country and he does not think Sweeney is worth a row of beans"? Then, on the following day, there is a paragraph in the Fashionable Intelligence: "Mr. Eindiguer, Mr. Maximoe and Mr. Sachael, with Mr. and Mrs. Sweeney, were entertained at Árus an Uachtaráin yesterday evening, where they drank tea with the President and his lady." Am I prudish if I say it ought to be a matter of inquiry when the facts, the known facts, establish at least a prima facie case that the office of the President was being used to lubricate the wheels of a somewhat unsavoury real estate deal?

Comment on this