Motion for Select Committee. - Proposed Sale of Distillery.
Contributions 243–482 of 482. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
If my words bore that interpretation, I gladly add that, in so far as I am personally concerned, I am convinced that neither the President nor Mrs. O'Kelly was remotely conscious of this business, though I do not exonerate their secretarial staff who should be vigilant to protect the President and Mrs. O'Kelly from any form of exploitation of this kind, who should have been there at once to ask the President if he had satisfied himself as to the credentials of foreigners from abroad, and, on being told that a young man married to Mrs. O'Kelly's niece had introduced them, to have sounded a note of warning and to have said: "Young people may often be imposed upon. Will you not permit me to get in touch with Justice and the Aliens Department to satisfy ourselves that these are people proper to receive?" It was not done, and the result was that so loathsome a situation was created in the morning's paper that Senator Quirke could not waste a moment until he got in touch with the Minister for Justice to say: "Not only is this man Sachael unfit for presentation in the drawing-room of the President's wife, but he is a man I would not touch in the crudest business transaction, and not only that, but any person in his company at once becomes suspect in my eyes." He knew all about Sachael's record, albeit he never met the man, never had dealings with him, but so notorious was Sachael that Senator Quirke felt entitled to go at once and warn the Minister for Justice: "To be in that man's company is to be suspect. You had better start inquiries at once."
Senator Quirke was perfectly right, because the Minister directed appropriate steps to be taken, and they were. Two officers of the Aliens Department went out to the hotel where Eindiguer and Maximoe were staying, and, while they were looking at Eindiguer's passport, Maximoe slipped out the back door. Sachael was present in Dún Laoghaire when Maximoe went out the back door. and the police redoubled their exertions searching for Maximoe. Where did they find him after 24 hours' search? In the lavatory of Sachael's house, the door of which they had to break down with an axe before they could get him out.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste is amazed that anyone should expect an inquiry to be held into the circumstances "of a little private matter between private citizens". The guest of yesterday of Árus an Uachtaráin is locked by his fellow-guests into the lavatory and the police break down the door to get in at him. It could happen anywhere! Nothing unusual, nothing to get excited about, nothing to be making all this fuss about! I think it is disgusting. The person of the President and the residence of An Uachtarán are things which should not be lightly exposed to a public affront of that kind and those who made such an affront possible have something to answer for, more particularly if it emerges that these people were brought to Árus an Uachtaráin at the instance of Mr. Sweeney. This House is entitled to set up appropriate machinery to address the question to Mr. Sweeney: "Why did you bring these people there? Why did you think it right and for what purpose did you choose to introduce Sachael, Maximoe and Eindiguer to that House to which, by virtue of your relationship, you have the entrée"?
As the issue of this harmless exchange in Sachael's residence, Mr. Maximoe was put aboard a boat. Now Mr. Maximoe had arranged to go out from Collinstown Airport in an aeroplane with Mr. Eindiguer. Mr. Eindiguer caught the plane. He left the Royal Marine Hotel at 4 o'clock in the morning, on the morning after he had been interviewed by the two aliens officers. In calm dignity he emerged at 4 o'clock in the morning and shot away from the door of the hotel, having first thrown Mr. Cooney and then Miss Donnico out of his taxicab, hotly pursued to Collinstown. He got on the aeroplane; Maximoe did not, but Maximoe's luggage was at the airport. I asked the Minister for Justice what was found in Maximoe's luggage after this unhappy man had destroyed himself. The Minister replied to me that on his person, not his luggage, there was found a sum of £55 19s. 7½d. in Irish and British currency, a dollarnote and 1,000 franc note—I forget the exact amount. Did that inventory include what was found in his luggage at Collinstown or has the Minister yet inquired what was found in his luggage at Collinstown? Maximoe was located at Sachael's house, he was put on board and he jumped overboard, it is believed, to his death.
The case of Sachael was then inquired into. Such was his reputation, he was not deported; he was invited to go. There might have been difficulty in deporting him. He is one of the gentlemen who by design would have taken the midwives' drive. He would come expeditiously; he had no home to go to. Having come without credentials, Sachael became a landed proprietor in this country. I think Deputy Beegan had the honour of representing him in this House. Mr. Sachael who had arrived here from nowhere without a passport to transact import and export business——
Comment on this
On a point of order, Deputy Dillon has referred to me as representing Mr. Sachael in this House. I know nothing whatever about this man. I do not represent him or any other foreigner.
Comment on this
Deputy Beegan has not been as diligent as Senator Quirke. Senator Quirke knew all about him and apparently that was very little. Sachael had become a landed proprietor. He was no longer a musty clerk behind a desk. He had tied a sugan below his knee and was slowly being merged into the Irish landscape as a tenant farmer. I doubt not he was looking for a picture of Parnell to hang up in his kitchen.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy say that this is relevant to an inquiry in regard to Locke's distillery?
Comment on this
It is, Sir. The fact is, I think, that these scabrous facts are generally scattered around the central fact of the proposed sale of Locke's Distillery and people are entitled to know how these miscellaneous collections of rag bags found fools ready to introduce them to the Ministry of Industry and Commerce as a worth while body of industrialists or how they could impose themselves upon Senator Quirke as a responsible body of persons——
Comment on this
Not only was this rag bag presented there but he was presented at Árus an Uachtaráin. I could understand everything until we come to the threshold of that door. The least amongst us is careful as to whom we may introduce into our own homes. The least amongst us should be circumspect not only in respect to his own home but the home of the President of Ireland.
Comment on this
Yes, when interrupted by the Minister, who suggests that there is any conceivable analogy between a solicitor who would take instructions from a Dr. Crippen or a Mrs. Seddon, because of his duty to do so, taking instructions from this rag-bag, and the President of Ireland receiving them as guests in his wife's drawing-room. Sachael is gone, Maximoe is gone, Eindiguer is gone. But is there any power of attorney for Mr. Eindiguer in existence? Is there a power of attorney in this city at this moment authorising an individual to buy Locke's Distillery for Mr. Eindiguer?
Comment on this
This, that the man who holds it is the man who brought that rag-bag into Árus an Uachtaráin.
Comment on this
Eindiguer began in this country as the client of one firm which was lawfully and legitimately entitled to collect a handsome commission on a perfectly ordinary transaction. If my information is correct, after all this strange story has been told, Eindiguer is the client of another man who holds the power of attorney, a man he had never seen in his life or heard of till he came to Ireland, and the only nexus between them is the tea-party in Árus an Uachtaráin.
Am I unduly solicitous? Is it suggested that I am unreasonably fastidious in finding that transaction unsavoury and deserving of inquiry, or have we sunk to the level in this country that we take it as the norm that the office and prestige of the President of Ireland should be used for the purpose of lubricating unsavoury transactions?
What I have here recited is all I know, every syllable and particle of which I communicated to the Minister for Justice before I entered this House and as soon as it came to my knowledge. On the facts as set out by me here, I believe there is a crying need for inquiry. It is necessary to assure the public, first, that conduct of this character meets with approbation in no responsible quarter and, secondly, to warn future parties that any attempt to turn this country into a banana republic with that kind of chicanery will not for one moment be tolerated and is fore-doomed to failure because there will be found Deputies in Dáil Eireann, if nowhere else, prepared to face the misrepresentation, the insolence, the threats and the blackmail of impudent members of the Government Party rather than recoil from the duty which they owe those who voted for them, to defend truth, to stand for decency, to condemn dirty chicanery of this kind, no matter what its source and whence it comes.
I challenge the Government to accept this motion. I assert that they should originally have set it down. I hope that when they do establish a suitable tribunal, which shall be fearless and impartial, that the air of this country will be cleansed of a very dirty smell and that a standard of conduct will be established, not exalted, not exotic, but just the ordinary standard of honour and decency that up to now has been well known to the vast masses of our people, with instructions from nobody.
Comment on this
I should like to make a little explanation. I do not want to intervene unless to clear up one point. It is about Senator Quirke. I did not mention his name last week because I did not know whether the Chair would be prepared to let me do so, and his firm did not think I should. The evening that Senator Quirke rang me up was the evening of the day the announcement appeared in the paper that this group had been received at Árus an Uachtaráin. On that occasion he told me that he only knew of this man Sachael by name and he had no suspicion whatever that Sachael was connected with either Eindiguer or the man who up to that moment was known as Smith. He was not aware, and neither were we until later, that Smith and Maximoe were the same person.
It was because of his horror at seeing a man he believed to be a shady man in that company, that he got suspicious of the others. I want to make that point quite clear. It was not personal information. I think someone asked how long did Senator Quirke know him. He did not know him at all, only in the way business people get to know others, by reputation—it was only that way. Senator Quirke had not read the paper until tea-time that evening because he was busy otherwise. When he was having tea at home he read it in the paper and he immediately got alarmed and rang me.
Comment on this
I think it will be generally agreed that any and every sense of public decency and national pride must have been outraged by the frenzied antics of the Tánaiste here this evening. Strangers not so familiar with the ease with which the same Minister can indulge in play-acting, must have wondered why, in the motion before the House, moved in the very serious and moderate tone in which it was moved, a Minister should immediately rush into a fanatical passion at white heat and attempt to bulldoze Deputies. There is no doubt that the Minister's antics were an attempt to bulldoze and intimidate a Deputy who, I believe, is the youngest member of this House. Why the heat? Why the intimidation? And why the attempted bulldozing? It was all because that Deputy, arising out of questions put to Ministers, had been answered in such an unsatisfactory manner that the Ceann Comhairle thought it right that permission should be given to have the matter raised on the adjournment last Wednesday evening.
Comment on this
The Deputy said the Ceann Comhairle allowed certain matters to be raised on the adjournment because of the unsatisfactory answers given by a Minister. That is not the case. The Chair does not question whether the answer is unsatisfactory or not if the Deputy requires more information.
Comment on this
The Deputy found it necessary to raise that matter on the adjournment last Wednesevening because of the unsatisfactory manner in which Ministers answered his questions. He acted on information which I am certain he believed to be reliable and information the sources of which I believe he will give at the proper time.
Comment on this
Let the Minister stay quiet until I have finished. He has done his antics, he has roared and jumped around this House, he has attempted to slide over the fact that men wanted from Scotland Yard, judged worthy of deportation from this State of ours, were just ordinary private citizens and that it would be an outrage to inquire into their activities.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, that is a misrepresentation. I referred as private citizens to the people who owned the distillery and those who may have had business transactions with them that had nothing whatever to do with public men.
Comment on this
That is a correction by the master of misrepresentation in this House. The questions were put down last Wednesday morning and as a result of the unsatisfactory answers given, allegations were made by a Deputy in Dáil Éireann on last Wednesday. What were the allegations? As far as I listened in to that debate, they were (1) that valuable concessions were given by the Minister's Department to financial speculators who were introduced to the Department by a man of immense political importance in the Minister's Party; (2) that in the course of conversations or discussions or meetings between that particular member of the Minister's Party and a wealthy alien who was interested in a purchase, a suggestion had been made that a watch would be brought into the country——
Comment on this
The Deputy is trying to add now to Deputy Flanagan's insinuations—and is he an adept at it? Let Deputy Flanagan tell his own lies and do not be trying to embellish them for him.
Comment on this
For the Taoiseach's son. Then (3) that information was conveyed to the Minister for Justice with regard to the character and past record of one of the people concerned in this particular deal, and (4) that these undesirable characters, unwanted by this country, wanted by Scotland Yard, had been entertained at Árus an Uachtaráin. As far as I recollect, and as far as I digested the Deputy's statement on Wednesday evening last, the substance of his statement fell within those four lines.
Having listened to that statement by the Deputy and having heard rumours about this city, I, in the absence of Deputy Mulcahy, as acting-leader of this Party, felt to be unwise the line the Minister opposite was taking of interrupting and more or less suppressing discussion. I felt that it was in the interests of the good name of this country, and of this Parliament and its Government—and my words are there on record—to warn the Government that it was unwise to suppress discussion or withhold full information with regard to this particular transaction. In the course of that brief statement— five minutes in all—I stated that the allegations made might be unwarrantable, but that they were being bandied around from mouth to mouth and, because of that, any appearance of suppressing discussion or witholding information would not be in the best interests of the country. Because of that attitude of mine, I pulled down on my head the frenzied anger and vituperation of the Tánaiste of the present Government. Is that zeal, is it dignified, does it create a good or a bad impression on anybody, either an Irish national or a foreigner, interested in this particular question, which is an international question?
Was there anything wrong in the motion there, that the whole thing in the public interest should be inquired into by 11 Deputies of this House, and moved in that moderate tone? Was there anything in the tone that was provocative or suggestive? Was there anything unjust in the speech we listened to from the supporters of this motion? Was there anything that should produce heat nearly to the point of lunatic behaviour? If there was anything in the statement or speech of the Leader of the Opposition that produced all that heat and ferocity, then it must have been the motion itself.
Why should we not have a motion to the effect that 11 members of the Dáil should inquire into allegations and, if they were untrue, demonstrate and prove they were untrue and, if they were irresponsible and were not based on reliable information or information believed to be reliable, make them recoil on the Deputy or Deputies who uttered them? Is there anything in that to produce all that heat, all that ferocity, that attempt to badger, intimidate and bulldoze a young Deputy of this House? I regard the conduct of the Tánaiste as being next door to scandalous. I do not believe there was ever a democratic Parliament where there was such a naked attempt to gag discussion on a question. The Taoiseach grunts, but the Taoiseach does not display a very pleasant smile. It is rather a nasty grin and we had enough of that from his kettle drummer.
Comment on this
What I am putting to the Taoiseach and to the interrupter up there is: "Why all the heat, why all the rage?" There was nothing in the speech to produce it. Is it because 11 members of this House have been asked to inquire into the truth of allegations made? If the allegations have so little foundation as the Minister would have us believe, is there any harm done? Is there anything to get angry about, anything to get heated about, because an inquiry was asked for? I object, as a senior member of this Assembly, to any Deputy being treated in the truculent manner in which the Tánaiste attempts to treat a young Deputy who happens to be an Independent, to have no Party and no colleagues. It would be inexcusable if that particular line of intimidation and bulldozing were taken against one of the most senior members of this House with a large Party around him. It is quite clear that the Minister does not want a full inquiry and I suggest, as the Leader of this Party suggested earlier to-night, that a tribunal should have been appointed rather than have this discussion to-night. The type of debate in which the Tánaiste engaged could not produce anything but a debate nationally harmful and nationally discreditable. It would certainly tempt and provoke any normal Deputy to reply in kind-this business of taking down every word a man spoke—"put that on record"—"you will be called on to swear to that"—"you will get the opportunity of repeating that on oath." Was there ever such scandalous behaviour on the part of a man occupying a high position and does the Taoiseach approve of his Tánaiste? Anybody with any sense of pride of Parliament, with respect for the years of sacrifice and the countless lives lost to establish an Irish Parliament, with any sense of decency, must have been shocked by such scandalous conduct from any Deputy, but particularly from the man holding the second highest and the second most responsible position in the Parliament.
The Minister challenged me in regard to a reference which was or was not made to bringing in a watch to the country.
Comment on this
I emphatically deny that. I heard the word used earlier in the debate. Does the Minister accept my denial? He does not? I would not have expected him to.
Comment on this
He said that Senator Quirke invited a certain person to smuggle a gold watch into the country.
Comment on this
I said nothing of the kind. The word was used and I understand withdrawn earlier to-night.
Comment on this
Not one. This kind of delusion of the mentality of hearing words spoken which were never uttered is responsible for the crazy direction of the country at present.
I refer to a point in the Deputy's allegations and I know how grave it would be for the country if there was any scintilla of truth in the allegations and I know how misunderstood they would be by Ministers who are trying to suppress the discussion and withhold information. I press that the Government should give the fullest information available.
Comment on this
When you see me running away from any remark I made you will see queer things. I stand absolutely on every word I put on record and I hope to see the day when the Minister a week afterwards will be able to stand over his statements.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not to be intimidated by a cheap bluffer, and I stand over every word, but I do not stand on the words which the Tánaiste or the Minister sitting beside him care to put into my mouth in their efforts to misquote me.
Comment on this
The following are what emanate from the Tánaiste's discussions here this evening: first, a permit for double the export of whiskey which the firm previously had was given to one group of financiers who were accompanied by Senator Quirke.
Comment on this
And Quirke was a party to it. Senator Quirke is not so small that he is not to be seen in a room. The Minister is holding a Punch and Judy show. Punch is to be produced while Judy is around the corner. Cooney is produced and Quirke is hidden. At least this much comes out. There had been three or four approaches to the Department between April and September, and on each occasion discouragement was given to them with regard to their prospects of increasing their quota of whiskey for export. In fact, a whole lot of difficulties were put before them. Even according to the statement now, difficulties were put in the way of the purchase of the distillery. There was no enthusiastic encouragement. But then the financial syndicate associated with Senator Quirke blows across the carpet into the Department.
Comment on this
I am standing over the Minister's statement to-night. I want to be corrected if I am inaccurate. Cooney, plus Quirke, come along and then assurance is given that the export quota will be lifted from 4,000 to 8,000 gallons per annum. That is admitted by the Minister and it is on record. Prior to the appearance of Senator Quirke there was nothing but toughness and discouragement, rather than enthusiasm. That is the first point.
The second point: it is admitted by the Minister's colleagues that these particular deportees were wanted men and that they were entertained at Árus an Uachtaráin. That is one of the charges made by the Deputy and that is admitted now.
The third charge made by the Deputy was that this particular gentleman was only deported and another individual was apparently collected by Scotland Yard after a friend of the Government had given information. There had been a falling out in the group prior to the giving of that information.
Comment on this
The Deputy has not answered the Minister at all. I have too much contempt for the Minister's whole behaviour this evening. It is the behaviour of a cheap little bellicose bluffer.
The third allegation made by Deputy Flanagan has been found to be correct. Are we to take it as a perfectly normal thing that people of that character and reputation, with the police of two countries after them, should sail up to Árus an Uachtaráin and be entertained and have their names in the paper?
The fourth charge is in regard to a watch. The Minister told a story about a watch. I have no information beyond what I heard from the two sides of this House. Even on the Minister's statement, or statements, impartial Deputies will agree that there is something which should be inquired into. One of the extra things that should be inquired into is why a member of the Government—the leader's kettle-drummer on the left—showed such heat at the suggestion that 11 Deputies and Senators should inquire into the allegations made, deal with them, if proved, and repudiate them so that they would hurl back like a boomerang if found to be untrue——
Comment on this
Will the Minister keep quiet? These little, jack-in-the-box antics are always typical of the Minister when he has a bad case. When he has a bad case, he trys to bluff, to be offensive, to be brazen and even rude.
Comment on this
I do not congratulate the Government on the individual they selected to make their case this evening. In spite of the provocation given by the impudent manner in which the Minister has addressed himself to this House to-night, I ask the Head of the Government to ignore the antics of the Tánaiste and to face up to his responsibilities. Amongst those responsibilities is that of keeping the name of this Parliament and country clean. If he faces up to that responsibility, he will establish this or some other type of tribunal to inquire in full into all details associated with that particular transaction.
Comment on this
I should like to congratulate Deputy Mulcahy on the motion which he has placed before the House to-night asking that a committee of this House be appointed publicly to investigate and report to the Dáil on the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding any proposal made, or attempted to be made, at any time since 1st January, 1946, either to buy or sell Locke's Distillery, Kilbeggan, or any part of the property or business thereof. I am amazed and astonished at the antics and behaviour of the Tánaiste in this House to-night. He is a long way out if he believes that by shouting loudly across those benches or using threats that I shall have to go before a tribunal and that I will be on my oath he will seal my mouth or "cow" me so as to prevent me from making statements which I believe to be true. It is not the first time that his colleagues in the Cabinet, his Leader, the Taoiseach, or other responsible men from the far benches have endeavoured to seal my lips. Whether I am in this House for long or short, I will devote all my energy to trying to expose Government rackets, many of which are in existence to-day.
Comment on this
Many of them are well known to the general public. One of the most glaring, in my opinion, is the manner in which the sale of Locke's Distillery, Kilbeggan, was undertaken. I believe it was my duty as a Deputy of Dáil Eireann and my duty as a citizen, if I had reliable information at my disposal from sound, responsible people, to place it before this House and before the Government. If that information is true and correct, well and good—that is a matter to be decided by the committee or tribunal.
Comment on this
If the information I have at my disposal is wrong, well and good—that is a matter to be decided by the committee to be appointed to investigate the matter. That is a matter for which I take responsibility and I challenge the Tánaiste and Government to-night to appoint this committee asked for by Deputy Mulcahy. I can guarantee two witnesses—not one—who will contribute evidence which will take the smile off the Tánaiste's face.
Comment on this
And Mr. Joseph Cooney, senior, managing director of Locke's Distillery, Kilbeggan. There are two names. Perhaps the Tánaiste would like to get further names. Perhaps he will get further names if and when this committee is appointed to investigate the matter. I believe that the charges I made in the House on Wednesday night were received by every Deputy with amazement and horror. It was looked upon as if I were making statements of a fantastic nature to which there was neither beginning nor end.
In my opening remarks on last Wednesday night, and, previous to that, at Question Time, when I raised the question of the racket concerning the distillery at Kilbeggan, I made a few very important points which were reported both in the daily papers and in the Official Report. Even on this side of the House, members were inclined to doubt the accuracy of my statements. When I mentioned about these crooks of international fame, these racketeers and gangsters, dining with the President of the State and introduced in his dining-room to the President's wife, I was laughed and jeered at even by members of the Opposition. They believed that it would not be possible for the President of this State to stoop to the lowest depths of indecency—
Comment on this
Neither the Deputy nor any other Deputy may attack the President in this House. The Deputy must withdraw the statement that the President stooped to anything disgraceful.
Comment on this
By all means. I believe that the President and Mrs. Kelly were quite unconscious of the fact——
Comment on this
It must be the secretarial staff of Árus an Uachtaráin which was to blame—those people who were responsible for allowing those international crooks to dine in Árus an Uachtaráin. Surely the secretarial staff at Árus an Uachtaráin——
Comment on this
I am only endeavouring to point out the need for the inquiry and how true and accurate my statements made on Wednesday night were when I said these people were entertained at Árus an Uachtaráin. Even members on this side of the House were inclined to doubt it until the admission came from the Minister for Justice. He said that unfortunately those people did get into Árus an Uachtaráin. It was unfortunate that they got in but unfortunately they did make their way in there. Why not have as one of the terms of the reference of the committee to be appointed that they shall inquire as to who was responsible for the introduction, who was responsible for making the necessary arrangements to have those people entertained to tea at Árus an Uachtaráin? Surely, if citizens of an undesirable character, wanted by the police in a number of countries, can walk into this country and first and foremost select no less exalted person with whom to have tea than the President of the State and his wife I believe that a very good and useful purpose would be served by the establishment of the committee of inquiry asked for here to-night by the Leader of the Fine Gael Party. That was one of the accusations I made in this House which was admitted by the Government.
A second accusation, admitted by the Government, which even the members on this side of the House were inclined to doubt, was that representations were made to the Department of Industry and Commerce by a member of the Oireachtas who was a member of the Fianna Fáil Party. I refer to none other than Senator Quirke, who was acting in his official capacity as a representative of the firm of Stokes and Quirke. I accused the Senator of endeavouring to secure certain concessions for certain people, and to-night the Minister tells us that there were four callers to the Department of Industry and Commerce in connection with the sale of Locke's Distillery. However, none of the callers who came in connection with Locke's Distillery were welcomed with anything like the welcome which was accorded Senator Quirke on his arrival. The export licence for whiskey was increased from 4,000 to 8,000 gallons immediately on the mysterious appearance of Senator Quirke on the floor of the Department of Industry and Commerce in Kildare Street. An increase of 4,000 gallons of whiskey to be exported was granted because of the appearance of Senator Quirke, who was using his high office as a Senator to advance his interests as an auctioneer. Is that not the position with which we have been presented? Is that not the reason, A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, why the Government should not back out of an inquiry when such information has been placed at the disposal of this House and at the disposal of the people? That accounts for two accusations. I made a further accusation which was laughed at not alone by the Government but by some of my colleagues on this side of the House. I refer to the question of a presentation of a gold watch for the Taoiseach's son. That was hardly credited by members of this House. To-night we heard the Tánaiste giving us a cock-and-bull story about the manner in which the Taoiseach's son was to get that watch. He said Senator Quirke's sister was dangerously ill in a hospital——
Comment on this
A friend of Senator Quirke was dangerously ill in a hospital and this patient was placed under the very expert and good care of Dr. de Valera. Through the doctor's good offices and through the proper application of his medical advice this patient was restored to her normal good health.
Comment on this
As a mark of appreciation we have been told that Senator Quirke decided to make a present of a gold watch to the Taoiseach's son. I am putting it to this House, because certainly it will not go up this cuff, that if the Senator wanted to make a presentation had he not many other items with which to present the doctor? If he wanted a gold watch could he not have gone down to Benson's? Could he not have toured some of the very best high-standard jewellery establishments in this city? Could the Senator not have made inquiries as to whether he might secure a good up-to-date timepiece for the Taoiseach's son in return for the good service he had rendered in restoring his patient to her normal good health? Was it not a strange coincidence that in Mr. Eindiguer's presence he should spot a watch on his arm and say: "I would love a watch like that for the Taoiseach's son?" Would one not expect that Senator Quirke would go out and buy a watch instead of going into the details of the illness of his relative as he did with Mr. Eindiguer? If the Tánaiste's story goes down with certain members of this House it will not go down with me. There is a man in this building to-night who actually saw the watch, who actually had the watch in his hands and said: "That is too good a watch for the Taoiseach's son." That man is going to come forward to give evidence if the inquiry takes place.
Comment on this
At the opening session of the inquiry, if it is to be undertaken, this question of the watch for the Taoiseach's son will very carefully be gone into. But no person of proper or sane mind would believe for one moment the story surrounding the circumstances of the Senator getting this watch from Mr. Eindiguer to give to the Taoiseach's son. The words that were used, according to my informant, who will give his evidence on oath at the opening session of the tribunal——
Comment on this
No, and you will be there, my boy. According to my informant, the reason the watch was being given was for the purpose of a softening influence. I want that recorded in the Official Debates of this House. Therefore, is it not quite clear to the House, is it not quite clear to the country, is it not quite clear to every broadminded and honest citizen, the allegations I made in this House on last Wednesday night have been admitted by the Government not in one, two or three forms but in all forms. I hope that my colleagues on this side of the House are even now satisfied and convinced that if the Government succeeds in pulling wool over the eyes of members of the Opposition they will pull no wool over my eyes.
Comment on this
I have been accused in the daily papers and by members of this House of abusing my privilege as a Deputy by naming certain citizens. I should be long sorry, A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, to abuse my privilege as a Deputy of this House. I think, however, I have a duty to perform on behalf of the people who sent me here and on behalf of every broadminded and honest citizen in the country by lending a hand towards cleaning up. That is the very reason I have been compelled to name certain people here. That was the position when I rose on last Wednesday night to give the names of those people who were associated with the question of the sale of Locke's Distillery at Kilbeggan. We have even seen that in the very cagey corners in connection with this sale, even the solicitor, even the legal adviser, had political connections and political affiliations. We even saw that the auctioneer was a Fianna Fáil Senator. We can read between the lines there. We have heard the story about the presentation of a gold watch to the Taoiseach's son. We can, also, see the influence used at the Department of Industry and Commerce because when as I asked the Minister at Question Time to-day if a written application had been made to increase the export licence, he replied and said: "No". No written application was made to increase the export licence held by Locke's Distillery from 4,000 gallons to 8,000 gallons. If I were to go into the Minister's office and to say that there is a man in my constituency in serious difficulties because of lack of kerosene for his tractors and machines which are held up in the tillage field the first thing I would be asked by the Minister would be if the man had made written application and I would be told that if he had not done so he must do so before an allowance of kerosene could be granted to him. In this case, however, there was no question of "You must make written application". The Departmental red tape was completely cut.
The appearance of Senator Quirke turned red tape into action and immediately the export licence, without written application being made, was increased from 4,000 to 8,000 gallons. In every other case the Minister's Department insists on written application being made. I could name numerous cases for even the tiniest items that constituents would require— every Deputy in the House is aware of this as well as I am—in connection with which the first question asked by the civil servant is: "Has written application been made? Then it will be considered." There was no consideration necessary in this case. The mighty ghost of Fianna Fáil appeared in Kildare Street and an export licence for 4,000 extra gallons of whiskey was given. Surely when we see a member of the Oireachtas using his position as Senator to advance his interests as an auctioneer, it is something which stands for investigation and which should be investigated.
I believe that I have been of national service in raising this matter. I believe that the national service that I perform will not be completed until the results of an inquiry are made known. Senator Quirke has asked for the inquiry and would not we love to see that inquiry coming off to find out how this Mr. Sweeney got those people into Árus an Uachtaráin? He used his relationship with the President. He happens to be a nephew of the President.
Comment on this
Do I understand that the Fianna Fáil Government is going to dictate how people will marry and where they will marry?
Comment on this
I am only pointing out to the Taoiseach, to the Tánaiste— the Minister for Local Government has no brains so it is no use pointing out anything to him—to the Chair, the manner in which a reception was arranged for those international crooks at Árus an Uachtaráin. That is something which should come before the inquiry for consideration. Deputy Dillon and other Deputies have made enquiries and have given information to the House concerning the activities of those aliens who came over here for the purpose of purchasing this distillery. One man's name was Sachael. I understand that since I raised this matter first in the House, on Wednesday night last, Sachael has gone from the country. There was no question of making an order to deport Sachael, but Sachael was just politely asked to leave.
Comment on this
Sachael was asked to leave. Representations were made to the Department of the Minister for Justice some time ago to extend the time limit for an order which the Minister was about to make at that time to deport him. I understand that the representations were made by Mr. Sachael's solicitor and I would be interested to know if that is Mr. Sweeney again, anxious to see that this undesirable alien, Sachael, was kept around the place.
Comment on this
If he could not, it would have been because you let him in without having any place to send him. It was no virtue in Sachael.
Comment on this
I say that the Minister for Justice had the question of his deportation under review some time ago. It was cancelled simply because it was understood that Sachael was about to sell his farm in Gort, in Deputy Beegan's constituency, and the moment the question of Locke's Distillery arose Mr. Sachael said: "I cancel the sale of my farm in Gort now because I want a nice country residence in Galway. I am going to be a director of the new distillery company". It did not materialise but it was very, very near it.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce was very much alarmed and annoyed by the way I got under his skin. The motion was presented by Deputy Mulcahy in a cool, calm, businesslike manner. I presented my case on last Wednesday night in a similar manner, and I am explaining the circumstances to-night in a spirit of good friendship and in the hope that it shall lead the Government to the speedy establishment of the inquiry and the adoption of General Mulcahy's motion. I am prepared to lend a hand and to co-operate with the Government in every way to expose rackets of this nature and to see that a speedy end is put to the racketeering that is going on and which probably will go on if somebody does not make an attempt to clear it up. Here is a statement the Minister for Industry and Commerce challenged me on. He asked me was I aware that there were 60,000 gallons of whiskey in Locke's Distillery.
Comment on this
Much the black marketeers would care whether it was mature or not. Old or young, they would sell it.
Comment on this
This is why I join with Deputy Mulcahy in demanding this inquiry. I believe that the Taoiseach will see fit to have this inquiry. I honestly, conscientiously and sincerely believe that on this occasion the Taoiseach is man enough to have the inquiry. I believe that the information that I got and have at my disposal is from sound, responsible people who are prepared to stand over it. One of those responsible citizens who is prepared to stand over his information has presented me with a memorandum of items which need investigation.
Comment on this
Information has been placed at my disposal by one who is prepared to come forward and give evidence on oath.
Comment on this
Everything is above board. I want to clear up this thing. That is what I want, and the smile will be off his face by the time I am done with him. I will give him all the names he wants. Let him be cool and calm and let him not shout or shiver in his seat. I will give him all the information he needs. I have a hell of a lot more than he thinks. That is something for the Taoiseach to whistle about. I have received evidence from one who is prepared to give evidence at the inquiry. This person writes:—
"Evidence has come to light that behind the scenes the game was to sell whiskey in the black market in England or elsewhere and actually 60,000 had been offered to a firm in London at £11 per gallon who would have netted £660,000, out of which the purchase, lock, stock and barrel of Ireland's oldest distillery would be simply a matter of £305,000."
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach or does the Minister believe that if we have a public-spirited citizen prepared to come forward on oath and prove evidence of this nature that the Government should refuse to hold an inquiry to investigate it? If the Government refuses to hold an inquiry to investigate a matter of this nature I believe the country will go completely into ruin, and that you will have nothing in this country but rackets and racketeers and that Eire will be turned into a gangsters' paradise.
I call on the Government and on the Taoiseach with all the force, eloquence and might that I can put into my speech to consider every word that has come from the lips of Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy Dillon and myself and of those who have endeavoured to co-operate in having this racket exposed. I ask that the Government in their wisdom may see fit to accept the motion that has been so ably presented to the House by Deputy Mulcahy. The motion merely asks for an investigation and that the facts be made known. I sincerely hope and trust that the Government will do that on a careful consideration of the accusations that have been made and on the Government's own admission of the allegation I made here last Wednesday night. I am very pleased that the Minister for Justice, the responsible head in charge, has admitted that there was truth in the allegations that I have made in this House, because it certainly vindicates me. It clears me in the eyes of the people. I was not talking this time— as the Minister for Industry and Commerce always says I am—trash. There was no trash this time. They were solid facts. I was well briefed and properly briefed. This case of Locke's Distillery is only one of many to come. I want the Taoiseach and the Ministers of the Government responsible listening to me, to be expecting more and further, because it was brought out in the Ward inquiry—it was said here in this House and I am the Deputy who said it—that there was no difference between Dr. Ward and any of the front benchers on the Government. The only difference was that Dr. Ward was caught out and they are not caught out yet. That was the only difference.
Comment on this
As one of my colleagues remarked as I stood up, this is evidently going to be a slander factory. There was an enquiry into the case of Dr. Ward. The result of that enquiry was to prove that he was not guilty of corruption in his public office. He was found guilty of not making a full disclosure of sales as a business man. Now we are told that there was corruption. It was implied that there was corruption. Every time that an election is in the offing we have this charge against the Government. We have a Deputy in this House pointing to the members of the Government and saying that every one of them is guilty of corruption. It is a lie.
Comment on this
The word "lie" is not permitted to be used in the House.
Comment on this
If the Deputies who say that they are interested in the honour of our country and of this Parliament had presented this case in a reasonable manner as people would who are interested in that, and solely interested in it, I think there would have been no trouble. But there were by-elections on, and it was not sufficient to suggest that there was public anxiety about certain strangers who came into this country: it was necessary to suggest that they were brought in by the Government, and that the Government was responsible for everything they did.
Now, let us try, as calmly as we can, to unravel this thing and see exactly what is in it. In so far as there is any charge against the Government, it is right and proper that it should be inquired into. The moment charges of that sort are raised, the Government has to give an inquiry, inevitably. I say that every member of the House has a responsibility to see that these inquiries are held into the things that it is right for this House to inquire into. Is it suggested that if there is some individual, some shady individual engaged in some deal or other in the country, that the Government is responsible for that, that the Government is responsible for the character and conduct of every person who comes into the country? Of course, no Government could be responsible for that. The Tánaiste has pointed out that a certain man from Switzerland came in here, that he was introduced by Irish citizens and apparently they accepted him as a colleague in some business enterprise. It transpired from what appeared in the newspapers—this was the beginning as far as Government knowledge was concerned—that with this man who came in there was associated another man who was in some way suspect. The moment it became known that this man was in the company of a suspected person enquiries were set on foot.
The first thing, in fact, that was done was that the Minister for Justice rang me up and told me that it had appeared in the papers that certain gentlemen had been received by the President and that one of the persons in question was one about whose conduct the Department of Justice was not at all satisfied. I immediately made it my duty to go to the President and tell him so. It is suggested here by a Deputy that because certain people of that type did happen to visit the President that the President stooped down to do this. Is there no possibility that people can be mistaken? Is there no possibility that people of a shady character can be introduced? Is there no question of the President receiving these people in good faith? I myself receive hundreds of people in the course of the year. I have to ask myself: "Will I see them or will I not see them"? I generally try to get some information if I can. If a friend that I happen to know brings them along and I have no reason to be unduly suspicious, I see them, and very often the result of seeing them is valuable from the point of view of our country. Are we to take up the attitude that we are not going to be disturbed and that we are going to take the telephone off the rest for some particular period? I think that if we were to adopt that attitude it would generally be found that the very time during which you had made up your mind not to attend to a call was the time that somebody who should have been seen would have to go away. You could not possibly do business on that basis, and Deputy Dillon knows it quite well.
Comment on this
Although the President's secretary is a civil servant, I say that, in a case like that, no member of the staff could have provided for it, and the Deputy knows that as well as I do. If somebody that the President knew introduced some people, do you think that a member of the staff could come along and tell the President that he was not to receive these people? The President is not in a position publicly to defend himself. It is my business to see that he is defended when his name is introduced, and it is my business to see that his staff, who are civil servants, are also defended. The only thing that can be said so far as the President is concerned is that these people did happen to find access to him. Of course, instead of taking the ordinary commonsense view of that, it is suggested that it was to make the deal easy. In other words, the suggestion is that the President was going to use his position to ask for special facilities for the people he had received.
Comment on this
I have as much experience of secretaries as the Deputy, and no secretary could have said to the President in these circumstances: "You are not to receive these people." If a person who is related to the President makes a mistake, does not know the people he is dealing with and introduces them, I say that no member of the staff could have told the President: "You must not do that."
Comment on this
I know nothing about the papers. We have all sorts of details thrown across the House in order to cloud the real issue. The real issue, so far as the President is concerned, and I am more interested in that aspect of it than any other, is that when the President received these people I am perfectly certain, although I did not put such a question to him, that he knew nothing about the character of the people, good, bad or indifferent. They were introduced to him. I can only guess, because I did not ask the President the question, that these people were introduced by a person whom he knew. Under these circumstances, it is most unfair to suggest that the staff had any responsibility, unless the staff knew these people were wrong. If they did, then they would have a responsibility. Underlying it all is the suggestion that the President knew and that the staff knew things that were not known to them, things that were not even known to the Government, and which only became known to the Government by the attention of the Minister for Justice being called to one name.
Comment on this
Do you want to suggest that the secretariat is to be informed of everything that the Minister for Justice does? How could any member of the secretariat be aware in advance that one of the people who were going to see the President was of a shady character?
Comment on this
There is first an attempt to attack the President and then, when the President is being attacked, there is an attempt to attack the staff. Neither the President nor the staff could have been aware of the character of the individual whom the Minister for Justice went after.
Comment on this
Are we to have an inquiry into that? So far as the allegations against the President are concerned, what is it precisely we are to inquire into? The suggestion is that the President stooped to this, that he was going to use his influence with the Minister for Industry and Commerce to get some concession or other. Is there a single Deputy who believes that that is true? I do not think there is. But we are to have an inquiry into it. Well and good, we shall.
Comment on this
I am pointing out what is the clear implication. Deputy Mulcahy can rise in a very calm and judicial way and make the case for this and then the people who come after him can make the suggestions.
Comment on this
Clearly, the suggestions have been that the President's office was going to be used with the President's knowledge for the purpose, as was suggested in another connection, of "softening the deal". I say we shall have an inquiry into that. But I want the members of the House and the people of the country to know that these are the suggestions that have been made and that there is not a single word of truth in the suggestion that the President was going to use his office or permit his office to be used for any improper purpose. The only thing that emerges from it is that certain people did find access to him, some of whom were of a shady character. The only thing that can be said in that whole connection is that the safeguards were not sufficient to prevent that, and I say that no safeguards can be devised which will completely and absolutely prevent that sort of thing.
Now let me come to the next point. It has been suggested that a proposed present to my son was to "soften the deal"; in other words, that I and my son were of such a character that we could, by the present of a watch to him, be induced to do what the President in the other connection was supposed to do, namely, use our influence to get the Minister for Industry and Commerce or somebody else to abuse his position and give certain concessions. Is there a single member of the House who believes that? Yet, that is the clear implication of the suggestion that has been made, and we are ourselves to set up an inquiry to inquire into just that sort of thing. The only reason we have to inquire into it is to make clear to the public the way that they are being abused.
The honour of this country is something which everyone of us ought to be jealous of. To seek to make it appear that the President of the State and Head of the Government are of such a type that they can be used to get concessions for strangers if they get some reward or other I think is damnable. I think the whole thing is such as to make it very hard for any decent person to remain in public life in this country, and that is what some of the people making these suggestions are aiming at—that we will not have any honourable or honest man going up to represent the people, because he can be attacked.
Then they say: "You can be cleared by an inquiry", but when you are cleared by an inquiry, then the result of the inquiry is forgotten. Dr. Ward was cleared, and the charges against him were found, by a tribunal, so far as his public office was concerned, to have been recklessly made. Is that part remembered? When people talk of Dr. Ward in public, do they remember that? No, they do not.
Comment on this
The point is that Dr. Ward did not make full records, that he did not, in regard to his private business transactions, make full records, and therefore did not have— in our view—a sufficiently high standard to continue in his public office.
Comment on this
He was fired, but not for corruption. He was fired because the standard some business people will boast about was not high enough for us. We know perfectly well that the evasion of income-tax is not a thing a number of people hang their heads about, and, in the long run, when you examine the case against Dr. Ward, the most that can be suggested against him is that he was trying to evade some income-tax. That is the most.
Comment on this
On a point of order, we have the right to reply to this debate. I took merely a quarter of an hour in opening the discussion and the seconder of the motion has not spoken yet. I suggest that at least 20 minutes is the period we would expect to reply.
Comment on this
We expect to reply to this debate. We have a motion before the House and we reply to this debate.
Comment on this
Before the Taoiseach resumes, if he is to resume, I should like to say a few words. I was not here last week when this matter arose and I must admit that I was completely at sea about the whole thing, but I have heard the two sides of the case to-night and would like to get time to say a few words. At the same time, I should like to hear the Taoiseach out to the end.
Comment on this
I suggest that there ought to be enough time for such an important debate—if not to-night, to-morrow.
Comment on this
I endeavoured to have this debate carried on in a formal way, with adequate time for the discussion. The Government insisted that the debate would not begin earlier than 7 o'clock and that it would be finished to-night. We ask for permission to conclude on this motion and not be talked out.
Comment on this
I do not know what the rules of the House are—whether they would permit of an extension of the debate—but I am quite ready——
Comment on this
I do not know them. I have not particularly studied the rules of the House. What I was going to say was that if the House could remain on, if it could be moved to extend the sitting for an hour or so, I am quite willing.
Comment on this
You cannot extend the debate on a motion which is a contested motion after 10.30 p.m. If the Taoiseach will agree that this motion is not opposed and will be passed, the discussion can continue until 11 o'clock; but if the Government take up the attitude that they are going to oppose the motion, as is implied by the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to-day, the debate must conclude at 10.30 p.m., and I submit that the seconder and I have the right to conclude the debate.
Comment on this
I think we could have it to-morrow, if that will do. I have no desire to burk this matter in any way.
Comment on this
I entirely agree that the debate can be carried over until to-morrow, but it is an awful pity that, when representations to the effect that a longer time for the discussion is necessary are made, the Government should deal with the matter in the way in which they have dealt with it.
Comment on this
The Deputy was quite satisfied with the debate starting at 8 o'clock, and we started at 7 o'clock.
Comment on this
The point as to the length of the debate was not raised by Deputy Mulcahy, but let that pass. If it is agreed, we can have it to-morrow. The attitude of the Government with regard to this motion——
Comment on this
Do I understand that it has been decided that the motion is to be carried on for an hour to-morrow?
Comment on this
I am not prepared to agree to this motion being carried over until to-morrow if there is to be any restriction on people who want to speak.
Comment on this
I want to state the Government's attitude towards this motion. On a previous occasion, when there were suggestions in the House with regard to inquiries, I pointed out that I did not believe at all that in matters of this sort a political committee was a proper committee. The only way in which anybody in the House who wants to be satisfied will be satisfied, or in which the country can be satisfied, is by setting up a judicial inquiry. We cannot have this matter settled on the basis of five or six people from one side and five or six people from the other. The only type of inquiry which will satisfy our people in any matter of this sort is a judicial inquiry.
Comment on this
With proper terms of reference. That is the inquiry we propose—we oppose this motion because it seeks to have an inquiry by a different type of tribunal—and, as on a previous occasion, we will bring in a motion proposing the setting up of a judicial tribunal.
Comment on this
Who will be charged with responsibility for eliciting facts? The trouble about a judicial inquiry is that unless the Government charge somebody—not themselves but somebody—to elicit information, as in other inquiries of the kind, the judges find themselves with nobody to elicit facts.
Comment on this
I take it that the whole question raised here by the Tánaiste this evening was: What are the charges and who is going to stand behind them? He was trying to get an answer to that question the whole time. I take it that the Deputies here who made the charges will be prepared to be the accusers and that the tribunal, when set up, will, as on a previous occasion, arrange for the rest. We are anxious that the Deputies who made the insinuations will come forward and be the accusers and will bring forward the people who, they say, have the information.
It is suggested that these inquiries can be lightly undertaken. The fact is that, as the Opposition knows, the making of charges of this sort leaves no course open to the Government but to have an inquiry, and even if the Government thinks the charges are completely unfounded, is convinced that they are unfounded, we nevertheless have to set up these inquiries and have to go to all the expense involved, dragging in people from outside who may have no desire whatever to be involved and who may have no connection with it. All this thing must be done, unless there is some sense of responsibility.
Taking the two cases made up to the present, the President, first, is charged. I ask any Deputy if he thinks for one moment that the charge is true. Next, I am charged, because there is a charge against me. What would be the sense of speaking about the giving of a watch to my son, unless it was suggested that my son, getting the watch, was going to influence me, or that he or I was going to influence the Minister for Industry and Commerce, because I take it it was he who was to be influenced in this matter? I knew nothing whatever about it and my son knew nothing about it. I was just in the same position as I would be in if Deputy Flanagan came in here and said that somebody was going to give a diamond ring or a pearl necklace to my wife. Is there to be any decency whatever in public life?
The next suggestion made was that the Minister for Justice somehow connived at all this, that he was aware of these people and what they were doing, as if the Minister could know everything happening in the country, know every deal and transaction that was taking place. Deputy Flanagan says that Sachael was a friend of his and that this man Maximoe was sheltered in the house of a friend of the Minister. Is there any Deputy in the House who believes that for a moment? Yet, we are going to have a judicial inquiry to find out if that is true.
Then we have the charges against the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He has indicated to-night what the position was as far as he was concerned. Is it suggested by the Deputy who pointed his finger at every one of us and who said that the only trouble was that we were all crooks, but that we had not been found out, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce was influenced by these people, or that he knew that one or other of them was a crook, or that the people who were dealing with the matter in any way were crooks? So far as I understand, the people who were dealing with them in the first place were the secretary of the company which has the distillery for sale, and the company's solicitors, and the only thing about which the Minister was concerned was that the distillery should be carried on as an Irish business concern and that if there was to be an export business in connection with it, it would be of a limited amount. It is suggested that the amount was increased. Let that be inquired into.
Comment on this
I say it was suggested that the amount was increased for some improper reason. Is that not the suggestion, that it was increased for an improper reason? I do not believe it, and I do not believe there is an honest Deputy in this House who believes it in his heart. Yet, because it suited certain people to make these allegations in public, whilst the by-elections were on, with the object of throwing all the mud they could, in the belief that some of it would stick, we are going to have a judicial inquiry. We are going to have judges spending their time. We are going to have a big expenditure of public money because it suited certain people to make these suggestions.
The suggestion is, as everybody knows, that there were two of these people in here who were apparently shady characters. They were pursued by the Minister for Justice and put out of the country. So far as the other one is concerned, nobody has been able so far to find anything against him except that he happened to be with these people. I do not know whether he was deceived by these people or not. I do not know enough about that, but it has been stated that Maximoe, or Smith as he was called when he came in here, came as an interpreter. One of them suggested that that was the capacity in which he came and, as far as I know, that is correct. Is it not possible that a businessman looking for an interpreter could come across a person of that sort and be deceived by him? Is that not the whole technique of crooks, to deceive honest men? As a rule, they are not able to deceive other people, but they sometimes deceive honest people. I, at any rate, until it is proved to the contrary—I may be completely wrong, as I know nothing about him—think it a more rational explanation that Maximoe deceived Eindiguer than that they were colleagues in an enterprise either to buy or sell in the black market a distillery or anything else. First of all, we were told quite definitely that 66,000 gallons was the amount concerned, but the Minister for Industry and Commerce said that that could not be the case because they had not that much mature whiskey and, secondly, they could not get permission to send it out.
Comment on this
If Deputy Dillon thinks that there is some point about mature whiskey for black marketing, and that there was a good sale for immature spirits, I can tell him that they could not get out mature or immature spirits.
Comment on this
It is wonderful what the imagination of anybody who wants to think wrongly of another person can think of. It is wonderful what the imagination of certain people can do if they want to attribute wrong motives to other people.
Finally, there is an accusation against the Government of corruption, because that is the word that has been most used throughout the country by Deputies who want to blacken members of the Government, because they have not themselves a decent policy to put before the country. The only thing they can do in the country is to try to blacken the fame and the reputation of decent people.
Comment on this
Deputies now want me to specify names, but anybody who is interested can look up the suggestions that have been made during the election campaign and discover who made them. I put my reputation against theirs, that there was this suggestion of corruption, and it was the fundamental suggestion the whole time —the suggestion made by Deputy Flanagan when he pointed his finger across at us and said that the only trouble was that most of us were crooks, but that we were not yet found out.
Comment on this
Do you remember the story about Lord Hailsham?
Comment on this
I know that the people of Ireland, despite all you may say, do not believe all this. The only thing you are doing by that campaign is lowering the whole standard of public life.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy running away? The people know the Deputies yonder. Do these Deputies now say that there has been no suggestion that there was corruption?
Comment on this
When the Taoiseach asks me am I running away——
Comment on this
I will not sit down. When the Taoiseach accuses me personally——
Comment on this
This is a point that requires explanation. The Taoiseach has accused me of running away from the charges.
Comment on this
I say it is a matter of public knowledge that during this by-election campaign speakers on the opposite benches when they were speaking in public did suggest corruption against the Government.
Comment on this
I take it, then, that this charge of corruption, which I say was made, was not at all in the minds of the people who were speaking.