We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1947—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–117 of 224. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1947
Enacted

No. 33 of 1947 ›

When progress was reported last night I had made some effort to deal with the question of the valution for reconstruction and for the extension of the time for making these grants retrospective. I had very nearly concluded but there are some two or three points which I still wish to say a few words on. Throughout the country, and in the cities, there are public utility societies who make application for people who propose to build houses and a larger sum is payable to them than to private individuals. For the last five or six years it has been brought to my notice that some of these societies are not all they should be.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

It has been brought to my notice that some societies have failed to pay over the sums received from the Department to the persons who build the houses in a reasonable time. I believe there are reasons in some cases why that has happened. I am aware that there is a large number of societies who have done excellent work but I want the Minister to take official notice of the societies who are not discharging their duties properly. I have in mind one society and I am sure the Minister can find in his Department that there are some others. In the particular case of which I am aware the grant is outstanding for two years. The house is finished almost two years and the money has not yet been paid. Apparently the applicant himself can make a fresh application but if he does so he immediately loses a sum of £10. Where a case such as that arises the Minister should regard the personal applicant in the same light as he would regard the public utility society and the full grant should be paid to that person. I do not wish to refer to the matter any further. I only want to make it clear that when I am referring to public utility societies I am not referring to the public utility society nearest to me, namely, the one in the County of Longford. I want to say positively that when I am speaking of public utility societies I am not referring to that particular one and the Minister is, therefore, in a position to make his own investigations in connection with my assertion. The point I want to stress is that the applicant should not suffer because of the failure of the society to attend to his rights.

In Section 30 I notice that where a cottage has been built under the Labourers Acts and is let to a tenant who is an agricultural labourer within the meaning of the said Acts because

(a) he is normally engaged in doing agricultural work on the land of a relative and

(b) he resided with that relative when he applied for, or became tenant of, such cottage,

such council shall not prepare a purchase scheme under the Labourers Act, 1936 (No. 24 of 1936), in relation to such cottage. I do not see any reason why that should be done. There is no reason in the world why that person for whom the cottage is built should not get the benefit of that Act and become the owner of his cottage the same as anybody else. The fact that he is a farmer's son is no reason why he should be debarred. First of all, it is given to him because he is a farmer's son but, because he is a farmer's son, he cannot become the owner of the cottage as laid down in the Labourers Act of 1936. The Minister is cutting the buttons off the gift when he does that sort of thing. He should encourage that type of housing as much as any other type. I would ask him to reconsider that matter. Of course, Sir, it is more properly a matter for the Committee Stage rather than for a speech on the Second Reading, but as a principle is involved I am raising the point now.

I do not know why the public utility society should get a grant of £10 more for the building of a house than the private individual, the farmer or the agricultural labourer, who builds it himself. I presume that the expectation of the Minister is that when this public utility society applies for the grant the intention is that they build the house themselves or that they give a loan or by some method assist the person in the building of the house. Generally speaking, in the rural districts the only assistance they give is to fill up the forms and lift a £1 off the fellow. As I understand it, if the Friendly Societies Act applies it simply means that every person who paid £1 to that society automatically becomes liable for the liabilities of that society. The Minister should urge his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to have these various public utility societies who are failing in their duty struck off the register. In that way we will get rid of that dud timber, as it were, that is hanging upon the housing scheme.

I want to compliment and congratulate the Minister upon the improvement he has made under this Bill. I have only one regret and that is that the Bill does not go far enough. I urge him to impress upon all and sundry the necessity for and the advantages of proper sanitary arrangements and amenities to their new homes, and that every new house built in the future should have the same amenities as are available in those built in the city. It should be compulsory that every house built in rural areas provide the amenities that are obligatory in the city. If anybody proposes to build a house in the city he will not be allowed to do so unless it comes up to a certain standard. As I have already said, the Land Commission, the local authorities and so forth, still persist in building houses which are obsolete in design.

Comment on this

Tá fáilte agus fior-caoin fáilte roimh an mBille seo ní hamháin 'sa Dáil seo ach ar fud na tíre uile. D'á fheabhas a bhí Act, 1932, in a ré féin, tá an Bille seo seacht n-uaire níos fearr ó gach aon gbné de agus tá moladh agus buidheachas na Dála agus an phobail tuilte ag an Aire i dtaobh í a thabhairt isteach agus na tairgsintí breaghtha atá innti do chur ós ár gcomhair. Tá suil agam nach fada go mbeidh an Bille i bhfeidhm agus go mbeidh tairgsintí an Bille le fagháil ag an bpobal i gcoitchinn. Tá suim fé leith agam ins an méid de'n Bhille a bhaineann le tighthe níos fearr do chur ar fagháil do mhuinntir na tuaithe. D'á fheabhas é an Bille tá phoinntí airighthe innti go mba mhaith liomsa tagairt daobhtha féachaint an féidir socrú níos fearr a dhéanamh ná mar atá innti cheana féin.

Some reference has already been made by other speakers to the principal points to which I wish to refer. But, before I refer to that, I would like to say how intrigued I was by the attitude of Deputy Mulcahy, who spoke after the Minister had made his introductory statement. It reminded me of the sinner who left his repentance too late. If we had been depending on Deputy Mulcahy during his period of office as Minister for Local Government to handle the housing situation or to cope with the dearth of houses that then existed, I am afraid the people would never have had an opportunity of doing anything to improve the housing situation for themselves.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

You have had 15 years since.

Comment on this

The attitude adopted by Deputy Mulcahy here yesterday—I did not hear very much of him—struck me as being very funny. At any rate, the less Deputy Mulcahy says about housing, in view of his own record, the better for the country and the wiser for himself.

As regards the proposals in this Bill, there are a few that I would like to see changed in the interests of the people whom it is intended to benefit. There is a number of people who have had the hard luck not to wait for the introduction of this Bill to improve their housing conditions. In rural areas, particularly, a number of new houses for farmers and agricultural labourers are already in course of construction and the grants that will be available in these cases are the grants that operated since the passing of the 1932 Act. I would like—and I think there is a very good case for the suggestion— that in the case of houses that were in course of construction when this Bill was introduced the Minister should consider making the financial provisions of this Bill available. There is a very good and reasonable case for that.

It would be very unfortunate that people who set out within the past year or so to improve their housing conditions and to provide better houses for their families, who have encountered all the difficulties and shortages and scarcities that existed in regard to housing materials, and whose building operations were held up, should have to be satisfied with a grant at the old rate whereas people who start after the 1st November of this year can have a grant at the new rate. I would ask the Minister very specially to consider these cases.

The same would apply in regard to reconstruction grants in the case of houses that were in course of reconstruction before this Bill was introduced. The same case can be made for that type of house as can be made for the new houses that were in course of erection. The reconstruction grant has always been available for agricultural labourers and the definition of an agricultural labourer, as I understand it, is pretty wide but I do not think it is wide enough yet to cover all the cases in rural areas that should be allowed to benefit by these provisions. I have come across cases in dealing with applications for housing grants of people who could not qualify because they could not be classed as either small farmers or agricultural labourers but who lived in rural areas. I have known a couple of cases of teachers with large families living in small houses, who wished to reconstruct and who could not get a grant. I have known cases of small country and village shops which, for various reasons, could not qualify for a grant and I have seen the occupants of establishments like post offices, in recent years, which could not qualify for a grant because it was suggested that the sub-postmaster or subpostmistress, as the case might be, was not working for hire in a rural area, simply because he or she was getting a small annual remuneration from the State.

As far as rural applications are concerned, I think the provisions with regard to reconstruction grants should be made available in all those types of cases. They need the grants and facilities that will be available under this Bill just as badly as those who are provided for. Of course, I know quite well that, no matter how well we scrutinise a measure like this here, even with all the care in the world and with all the efforts that can be made to bring every section and class that one can think of within its ambit, after the Bill becomes law there will be a hard case here and there which is not provided for. I do not know how that can be surmounted. It is my experience with regard to nearly all the legislation we pass here from time to time.

There is another aspect of the Bill in which, from a rural point of view, I am very interested also, that is, the provision for special grants for the installation of running water and sanitary accommodation in rural houses. As I understand the Bill, and I think it is the correct interpretation, that grant will be available only in the case of new houses which are built under the ambit of this Bill. I do not see why such a provision would not also apply to houses in rural areas—farm houses and other houses—which do not need reconstruction, but which would qualify for a reconstruction grant. That could be a house of a person whose valuation was over the £35 limit or a house of a good type that did not need reconstruction. I do not see why the special grant for the installation of running water and a sanitary system would not be made available in these cases. There is an outstanding case for that.

We propose, under the auspices of the Electricity Supply Board, to have rural electrification of the entire country and electric light and other amenities provided by electricity will be available for all rural houses. I do not see why the section of the Bill which provides for a grant for the installation of water and sanitary arrangements in the case of houses built under the Bill should not also apply to houses of the type I have mentioned. Of course, I know the Minister will have to go to the Department of Finance and that he will have a difficult job there but I think the Minister should consult the Minister for Finance and have that aspect of this Housing Bill carefully and sympathetically examined.

People have varying views with regard to the operations of public utility societies but I think the encouragement of public utility societies is a good thing. I think that they are good and that the work they are doing for their members is valuable work and should be continued and extended. The Bill, on the whole, is a comprehensive measure and the Minister deserves the thanks and congratulations of the country for having introduced it. I hope he will see his way to consider the points I have brought to his attention in regard to houses in course of erection or reconstruction and in regard to grants for running water and sanitary arrangements in country houses.

Comment on this

From the title of this Bill, Housing (Amendment) Bill, I suppose there is no measure that could come before us which would command a greater amount of support from all quarters. I do not know of any Deputy who is opposed to housing or to the utmost being done to solve the housing problem. It is a big problem with many sides. There are some extraordinary provisions in this Bill, some of which are more calculated to retard housing than to assist it. I am wondering what the Government's contribution is, when you consider that this Bill has been brought in and, of course, there is the ordinary financial provision for new grants to replace those which have more or less expired.

The Minister says the housing problem is composed of shortages of labour and shortages of materials. That is a very good definition and one begins to wonder what his contribution is to solve either of those problems. Take the shortage of labour. I think there is probably not very much shortage of unskilled labour for housing. The skilled trades have been an attraction across the water and in the North during the emergency period, by the reason of the dearth of materials here and the high wages there. One wonders what the Government intend to do or if they contemplate any effort to increase the supply of labour. Most people who are in touch with labour find that skilled labourers in other centres are highly critical before they come back here. They want to know if they can get housing accommodation and what the income-tax is and they have various other problems like that which are vexing the mind of the person who has to balance his family budget. That is in regard to bringing back labour.

I do not think the Government have done anything towards increasing the rate of recruitment to the skilled trades, a rate which has been built up slowly and gradually over a number of years by arrangements between employers. The rate of recruitment was governed by much more normal times than we are living in now. One wonders whether the Government has given any thought to increasing the supply of labour that goes to the skilled trades in two or three years. They would be very valuable certainly towards building these houses, where there is not the same amount of skill necessary as there was in former times when a house was much more ornate than it is at present. I do not think the Minister has mentioned that question of the supply of labour.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not say that it has not some relevance here now, but would not the supply of labour be a question for the Minister for Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned that the problem was made up of labour and supplies.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

But who would look after the supply of labour? Would it be this Minister or the Minister for Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

I hope the Government is looking after it, that it is not left to the individual efforts of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I would be glad to hear from the Minister if there is any appreciation of the fact that, if we want to get increased labour, there will have to be an increased supply going in.

The Minister seemed to hint that everything had been prepared up and down the country for housing. He read out figures of the number of sites which had been prepared, and so on. I cannot check up on that, but I am a Dublin Deputy and I think I am correct in saying that the whole North County of Dublin is short of a water supply. I live in the Borough of Dún Laoghaire, which is very badly in need of a sewage system, as the sewage disposal is inadequate. The question has been under review for a number of years, but I do not know why it could not have been settled during the war period and made ready. I am mentioning it merely to show that the Government appear to be waking up to the position that a number of these details should have been prepared long ago and are really in arrears.

As regards the supply of houses, the problem is made up of a number of items. The Minister said we were short of timber. Of course, timber takes a long time to get in here, but I do not think it is in short supply. If you spoke to any timber merchant in Dublin or Cork he would say: "Well, there is a lot of timber on the quays and in my yard and I would like to see it going out faster. Of course, I have not got the stock I had in pre-war days, but certainly there is a lot of timber."

I merely mention that to show that, possibly, if there was a spurt to-morrow the position might be entirely reversed, and we might hear that it was a shortage of timber that was really holding up the supply of houses. Of course, each item in a building has its importance and has to be supplied at the right time. The Minister, I think, said that he had advised all the local authorities to get in supplies of any materials they could for their housing schemes. That led to this position across the water, that they found that while one district had labour and no materials another district had materials and no labour.

There is another point I would like to stress though, really, it is a thing that I do not understand. I am speaking as one who has his eyes on Dublin and on Dublin County. The Minister seems to consider certain people as people who are providing houses for the working classes. He also mentioned houses for the black-coated workers. I take it that the local authorities are providing houses for the very poorest section in the community and that they have first call on all materials, etc. I think that is a very proper provision.

We come then to the utility societies, and these, I take it, are building houses for a class that might accurately be described as the one composed of black-coated workers. There is a third class of persons in this Bill and those in it seem to be treated like outlaws— the speculative builders who build houses on the chance of being able to sell them. The Minister seems to think that there is an enormous number of people who are going to build houses themselves and for themselves. As I have said, I disclaim any special knowledge of the country generally, but I would say that what I have just mentioned is a very rare thing either in Dublin or in Dublin County. The black-coated workers and, possibly, a class somewhat above them, have been content in the past with going around and looking at what the speculative builder is providing. He may be selling houses of a certain size for a certain price. If he finds that a particular type of house is selling like hot cakes he proceeds to build as many of them as he can. If they are not selling well he tries to find out what the difficulty is. He interviews prospective buyers. One person may say that he would like another room in the house. The builder tells him that would be so much extra, but adds that when he is building the next block of houses he will include one for him and so they agree on a price.

The Minister seems to think that houses are far too dear. Probably they are, but the only thing that will bring down prices is the provision of more houses and not strangling regulations or treating some people as if they did not exist. I wonder what would have happened in this country if the speculative and other builders had not continued to build at a slow rate during the difficult times through which we have passed, or if they had neglected to acquire supplies of building materials whenever they could get them: in other words, if they had not tried to keep together the skeleton organisation which could be enlarged when times got more easy and labour and materials were available? I think the Minister seems to enter on housing in fits and starts and that everybody who was engaged in it when the Minister had not an eye on building seems to be treated as if they did not exist.

I would like to make a plea for a realistic approach to this housing problem. It is not going to be solved by private individuals putting up their own houses. That might have been possible in the past, but in my opinion the private individual in the City or County of Dublin who, at the present time, endeavours to put up a house in which he intends to live himself might very easily have a very unfortunate experience. I would appeal to the Minister to put everybody on an equal footing: to see how far everybody can be mobilised on house production instead of making regulations which may interrupt the ordinary ebb and flow so far as the provision of houses is concerned. Between the two big wars I think the only things that were not in free supply were houses. At the end of the first world war, if a person wanted an overcoat and could not get it he had not to wait very long until he could procure one, if he had the price of it. The policy of trying to keep the classes of the community in various camps in relation to price, rent, controlled houses and various other regulations all tends to slow down the production and distribution of houses.

The Minister says he is anxious to bring back the class of people who built houses for renting. I suppose certain utility societies can do that, but they will require an extraordinary command of capital to be able to finance the letting of houses. Hitherto, the black-coated worker has seemed to favour purchasing his own house, and I want to suggest to the Minister that there is an enormous field which has been untouched in leaving people to select the type of house they desire, within certain limits—neither a dog kennel nor a palace—and assisting them to purchase these houses. It has been shown that what most people who set out to purchase a house lack is a margin. If a house is available at £2,000, they can probably raise £1,200 or £1,300, and if they could get the rest easily, they would be able to finance their own purchase of houses.

The State loses money on every house put up, every house with which it has anything to do, and I should like to bring the Minister's mind back to the Acquisition of Small Dwellings Act between the two wars. There never was enough money allocated to finance the grants for these small dwellings. The door remained open for about six months, during which time people could get grants for this purpose, and then the money was exhausted and the door was closed. If sufficient money had been allocated in that period, we would have gone a long way towards solving the housing problem. I hold, rightly or wrongly, that anybody who builds a house in an area in which houses are required is helping to solve the housing problem. There are houses which are obsolescent. There are a number of people, like the very poor, who have no other houses to go to, and I agree that the Government should go ahead on behalf of these people as fast as they can, but there are other types of tenant living in houses of which they do not approve, tenants who are looking for houses which would suit them better. They have the money and all they want is the opportunity to move into the new house.

I suppose the Minister will ask me: "What will that do for the very poor?" I will tell him what, in my opinion, it will do. It will hasten the obsolescence of a number of houses which have outlived their usefulness for the better class sections of the community. Those could be let, and have been let in the past. They have served their purpose for ten, 20 or 30 years and are then pulled down. I hold that the Government's approach to the housing problem in this city and in the country has been too narrow. They do not seem to want the assistance of everybody connected with the industry and I hold that in this Bill they are shutting out a certain section of the community who probably have organised machinery for dealing with the provision of houses. It would be a nice commentary on the Government's desire for increased housing if a number of the people with administrative ability and skeleton organisation migrated across the water after the skilled labour. Remember that it is not that these people could not do well across the water. At present there is an insatiable demand—and it is having its effect here—for building of all sorts in the countries around us.

The Government and some Deputies here are concerned as to how certain types of building are getting on so fast, in spite of the fact that they are handicapped in the matter of priority of materials. Building is not a static idea. The best type of house for all ages, all countries and all climes requires ingenuity and never so much ingenuity as to-day. There are substitute materials and methods which are considered dear and which in many cases are cheaper. If it were not for a number of these people, of whom the Government and the Minister think so little, having blazed the trail in the adoption of new methods, we would have been standing still altogether. I conclude by appealing to the Minister to open the door with regard to this housing question and get in everybody who can lend a hand.

Comment on this

There are just a few matters connected with this Bill to which I would like to draw attention. The introduction of a housing Bill in the Dáil is bound to give rise to a good deal of discussion and to excite a good deal of controversy. Practically everybody has a common interest in this matter and I was somewhat disappointed yesterday at the way in which the Leader of the Opposition treated the introduction of this Housing Bill. However, I suppose he has big problems on his mind at the moment and he feels worried. For that reason, we must forgive him for his attitude on this Housing Bill.

The Bill to my mind will give a much needed fillip to the construction of houses in the country. A great number of new houses are required. Yesterday the Minister mentioned some thousands of houses. For the last 20 years this country has been endeavouring to make up the leeway of a century in the matter of housing. Prior to 20 years ago the Government of this country showed little interest in the housing of its people with the result that a very big burden has been thrown upon the present generation. In the seven or eight years prior to the war great progress had been made. Since 1939 little or nothing has been done owing to circumstances outside our own control. We had not supplies. We had no materials. We had a certain amount of skilled labour, but not enough.

There are certain provisions in this Bill which call for some comment. Section 7 of the Bill makes provision for the control of certain premises. I think the principle involved there is a good one, but I would like to suggest to the Minister that it should be a reserved function. I think it is important that the provisions of both Section 7 and Section 8 should be reserved functions and I can see no reason why they should not be

These sections, when they pass into legislation, are bound to give rise to a good deal of controversy and it is for that reason that I suggest to the Minister now that these should be reserved functions. There are other functions which I think equally well could also be reserved. If the local authorities had more liberty they would be in a position to put more drive into housing. I would ask the Minister to consider that aspect before this Bill finally goes through the House. All that is really needed in order to provide houses is a plentiful supply of materials and skilled labour together with sufficient finances to utilise that equipment and organise that labour. I understand that an increasing amount of materials is becoming available, but it is still not sufficient to meet our needs. Within the last few weeks I have seen building held up for lack of cement. That is one item which is in short supply but I suppose that before very long it will be in full supply again.

The amount of skilled labour is not nearly sufficient. I would suggest to the Minister that something more will have to be done to provide skilled labour in the country. I would suggest that in order to attract such labour grants should be made available to apprentices and tradesmen. Something like that will have to be done to ensure a sufficient supply of skilled labour to carry out our big housing programme. Nothing worth while can be done in a very short time so far as housing is concerned. It takes five to ten years to measure output. It takes a year, or two, to acquire land. It is inevitable that there must be some delay in acquiring sites, getting contracts and going through all the necessary preliminaries. The country was just getting into its stride when war broke out. It had taken the country some years to get into its stride and it will take it some years again now. But I do suggest that some encouragement should be given to young men in the country to become skilled tradesmen. I am sure if the Government could guarantee full employment to those young men for a certain number of years in the building trade that would go a long way towards solving our present difficulty.

I notice that the Minister made no alteration in the provisions of the 1932 Act in regard to the subsidy payable to local authorities. I take it that he intends to use the Transition Fund to balance things up but I would suggest that some alteration should have been made in the 1932 Act in regard to finance. The local authorities who provide labourers cottages are paid on an estimated value of £300 per house. That £300 has become well over £600 at the moment. The Transition Fund is all right in its own way but it does slow up housing production. I would suggest to the Minister that he should increase that £300 to £500, or £600 or £700 and pay a subsidy on the actual average cost of rural housing at the present time. That would expedite the production of such houses because every added obstacle and every new regulation are responsible for a certain amount of delay.

The grants given to private persons and public utility societies are a definite improvement. They have been increased from £40 to £80 and the valuation has been increased from £25 to £35. I would suggest to the Minister that therein lies a greater impetus towards providing more habitable houses than under the large grants provided under the Second Schedule. Year by year thousands of medium-sized houses are getting into disrepair. There are far more dwellings falling into disrepair and becoming uninhabitable each year than can possibly be replaced by the building of new houses.

I put it to the Minister that we should give greater financial encouragement in the case of the reconstruction grants. I think that would go further to solve the problem than anything else, because if you provide 20,000 extra houses in the year and 20,000 others have become uninhabitable you have notadded anything to the pool of houses available. That was apparent during the boom building period between 1932 and 1939. For every house that was built, another had to be taken down or had fallen into disrepair and nothing was added to the pool of houses available at that time. That was apparent all over the country, but it was much more apparent in the city. Unless the existing houses are maintained 20 years' intensive building will not add anything to the pool of houses available. I suggest to the Minister that he should seriously consider whether the £80 grant should not be increased and also the valuation. In some areas in the West a valuation of £35 would be very high, but in Leinster a valuation of £35 would only mean a small holding. I think the same thing applies to Munster. I suggest that the grant should be increased and that the valuation should also be increased at least to £50.

Sections 16 and 17 provide for a new principle in housing so far as I know. The sections make it compulsory on local authorities to provide annual grants for persons undertaking to build houses for letting. I take it that that applies to a greater extent to urban authorities than to rural authorities. Personally, I do not think it is fair to local authorities to ask them to subsidise housing. They are subsidising housing to a very great extent at present as regards the houses they have already provided. The burden on local authorities for the provision of houses is already very heavy. I can see no reason why the State should not undertake the full cost of subsidising these houses that may be provided under Sections 16 and 17. It is a new burden on the local authorities, and I am afraid you will not get very many houses erected under these two sections.

Section 25 provides for the making of regulations for letting of these houses and Section 31 also makes provision for the making of regulations. I am wondering if these sections do not cut across one another to a certain extent. Rather different types of people will be housed under them, but I suggest to the Minister that there may be some difficulty in separating these two sections, because the same local authority may be operating both sections. The provision in Section 31, under which cottages erected in rural areas are to be confined to agricultural workers, is long overdue, because what was happening in rural areas was very bad. Originally labourers cottages were erected to house agricultural workers. The term "agricultural worker" has been so widened that in recent years it has been found, by the operation of the regulations under the 1932 Act, that almost anybody living in a rural area, even people moving into these areas from towns, became qualified for these cottages. The principle laid down in paragraph (a) of sub-section (2) is absolutely necessary and I hope it will be operated as laid down there, because you will find that people occupying cottages on land given by farmers are not working for farmers at all. When this section comes into operation, I am sure it will be a great improvement.

There is one other matter to which I wish to call attention, namely, that the increased grants will only be provided for houses built by individuals after November, 1947. I suggest to the Minister that that is grossly unfair. I have in mind two or three people who have been trying to erect houses for themselves for the last two years, but financial difficulties have prevented them from completing these houses. I think the Minister should make that provision retrospective to cover at least one year. If he does that, he will be helping a fairly numerous class of people who were compelled to undertake the erection of houses for themselves because they had no means of getting a house otherwise.

You have numbers of people trying to build houses at present who are unable to complete them. That aspect of the case should be taken into consideration by the Minister, because it is important that houses should be well-built so that the grants given will not be wasted. If, for some reason, people are unable to complete a house properly, they will be inclined to scamp the work and the result will be that in a few years they will be looking for a reconstruction grant. I believe this is a good Bill and that it will help towards a solution of the problem if the matter is tackled by local authorities and private individuals in the spirit in which the Bill has been introduced. It is a big step in the right direction and should go far to improve conditions.

Comment on this
John Ormonde Mr. Ormonde

Listening to some speakers in this debate last evening, one would get the impression that no thought was given to this problem which affects the country districts and which has led to such shocking living conditions in most of our towns and cities. No serious attempt was made to deal with this problem until the Housing Act of 1932 was passed. Under the Act, 120,000 houses were built or reconstructed. The work was going on apace until the war intervened and cut off our requirements in building materials and equipment and brought the campaign practically to a standstill. Now that conditions are coming back to normal and that the Government, as evidenced by this new Bill, are showing their concern for the housing needs of the people and their determination to solve the problem as expeditiously as possible, one would expect, not destructive criticism but something helpful and constructive. The most serious aspect of the housing problem is presented by the necessity for the clearance of slum areas. The work of slum clearance has fallen very much into arrears and if we are even to come to grips with that problem building must be greatly accelerated. From that point of view alone, this Bill should be warmly welcomed and every help should be forthcoming to expedite the carrying out of the programme in every possible way.

I do not intervene in the debate merely to criticism the attitude of the Opposition. On going through the Bill, I noticed a few points which I thought might be worthy of the Minister's reconsideration with a view to their readjustment. The first point is one to which reference has already been made by three or four other Deputies and I think I might be excused if I add my voice to theirs in appealing to the Minister for reconsideration of this matter. The grants, with one exception, will be payable only in respect of houses begun after the 1st November, 1947, and completed by the 1st April, 1950, the exception being in the case of houses built for letting purposes, the commencing date for which is the 1st November, 1945. I do not know why people building houses for letting should receive special consideration and I consider the existing provision rather unfortunate and rather hard luck on those people who have built houses in the last 12 months because undoubtedly such people would have deferred the building of their houses had they anticipated the introduction of this Bill with its improved scheme of grants. They would have deferred building in order that they might benefit by the new scheme of grants. If this section were made retrospective to include people who started to build subsequent to the 1st January, 1947, of whom I am sure there are not very many—I differ from Deputy Allen there—the extra demand on the Treasury would not be so very great.

Deputy Allen took the Chair.

Comment on this
John Ormonde Mr. Ormonde

There are two kinds of grants, a higher and a lower, in respect of each type of house, the higher grant being for a house where a piped water supply and sewerage are available and the lower grant being in respect of the house where such facilities are not available. Let us take the house in the country where there is no piped water supply, where the water is supplied by means of a pump or a well and where the sewerage would be taken into a septic tank, fully complying with the public health requirements. It is not clear from the Bill whether such houses would be entitled to the higher grant and in my opinion an announcement from the Minister to clarify the situation would be welcome.

With regard to the construction of the house, it must conform to certain definite standards. I believe the conditions laid down are satisfactory enough in the case of the three-roomed or four-roomed house but in regard to the house with five rooms or over, I have heard several complaints from the classes of people for whom such houses would be built or who would be building these houses themselves for their own occupation. I refer to people such as bank clerks, local government officials, teachers, civil servants, shop assistants, etc. I have heard complaints with regard to the upper limit of the floor space of these houses which must not exceed 1,250 square feet. It is the general opinion that no decent house with a bathroom and lavatory can be built to conform to such limited floor space. A slight alteration by increasing the limit of the floor space, say to 2,000 square feet, would not add greatly to the cost of the house and would satisfy the requirements of the classes of persons to whom I have referred.

With regard to the three-roomed or four-roomed house built mainly for the working classes, even if fuel were available in abundance, these people could not afford to heat their houses properly. The provision of cavity walls which would eliminate dampness would be a great asset and would make for the greater comfort and the better health of the occupants. I think also that it would be a great advantage to the occupants of these houses if something more substantial in the way of out-houses were provided to accommodate all the articles which require to be housed in such cases, such as garden implements, garden produce, turf, timber, coal, bicycles and numerous other articles. The present position is that you have many unsightly adjuncts of every conceivable size, shape and colour, built of all sorts of materials from a flattened-out tar barrel to the crudest piece of timber or galvanised iron, presenting an appearance that is certainly neither artistic nor picturesque. Some provision in the way of suitable out-houses would certainly be a great improvement.

I do not in the least subscribe to the view of some of the Opposition Deputies that to permit aliens to come in here to build houses and to settle down would lead to a re-conquest of Ireland. Such a suggestion is a very poor tribute to the intelligence and the national spirit of the Irish people. It is inconceivable that 99 per cent. of the people could be absorbed, dominated and brought into subjection by the one per cent. who would come in, all of whom are not aliens either. However, I would not make it too easy for these people to come in and settle down here. Recently, a property purchase tax of 25 per cent. was imposed upon them. If they desire to come in here, I would not allow them to circumvent the payment of that tax by acquiring sites for building. They should not be granted facilities to do so. Steps might be taken to withhold permits from them to build or not to release materials to them which will be in short supply for some time to come and which should be retained entirely for the needs of our own people.

The last point which I wish to make, housing being such a vital matter, is that nothing should be left undone to ensure the smooth and expeditious carrying out of this programme. There are at present 11 temporary housing inspectors. They were considered by the Civil Service Commissioners to be the best available experts some 12 or 13 years ago. With the experience they have gained since, it would be hard now to get better experts or advisers, particularly as engineering and architectural graduates have had, during the past five or six years, little or no experience of housing. It is obvious that the present housing programme cannot be completed in the lifetime of the existing housing inspectors and, therefore, there is a definite need for their establishment and for the recruitment of additional temporary men under these established officers. It is a great advantage to the housing section of the Department to have a tried and efficient staff of housing inspectors who will see that the work in the future will be carried out in an efficient manner, and who will insist that the progress and improvement in design and construction which has been apparent since 1932 up to the present time be maintained.

Comment on this

The first thing that strikes one about this Bill is that it was drafted fairly hastily. I am referring to the fact that there are so many amendments of previous Housing Acts included in it.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think that can be done hastily?

Comment on this

I think the Bill was drafted hastily and that the Minister did not think it worth while to go to the trouble——

Comment on this

The Deputy ought at least to be honest with himself if he is not honest with anybody else.

Comment on this

Perhaps it might suit the Minister to talk about honesty. My point is that the Minister might have followed up the line taken by the Government within the past couple of years by consolidating all previous legislation into one suitable measure. That was done in the case of the Public Health Act and several other Acts. Legislation by reference is very handy, but it is not so easy when people find they have to go back on Housing Acts from 1892 onwards. In a fairly comprehensive measure of this kind—and it is a comprehensive and a good measure—I think the Minister ought to have repealed all the old Acts and embodied the whole lot in one readable measure for the benefit of the House, the country in general and those whose business it will be to refer to these Acts. We have sections 18 to 27 and several other sections referring us back to Acts passed 30 or 40 years ago.

The Bill is a good one; there is practically nothing to be said against it, but a few improvements could be suggested. One thing that strikes me as peculiar is the difference in the amount of grants set out in the Second Schedule. There is a difference of £50 between houses where there is a piped water supply available and houses where there is no water supply. I cannot understand that and the Minister did not explain it. A higher grant will be paid for houses erected in towns and other areas where there is a piped water supply. I would like to point out to the Minister, as I did to the Minister for Lands on another occasion, that the country house needs running water just as much as any town house. Think of the drudgery and slavery, particularly for the womenfolk in a country house. I believe that has contributed more than anything else towards making people discontented in rural Ireland.

In country districts where houses are being erected and where a grant is made under the provisions of this Bill, the specification should include a sizeable water tank to catch the water from the roof. Every country house should have a hot water supply. That would mean a vast saving in fuel and a saving in labour, particularly for the womenfolk. The present method consists of carrying water by hand from wells that in many cases are situated a considerable distance away. The practice in the country is to hang pots over the open fire. The people have to put down big blazing fires in order to get the water boiling. That happens many times during the day in every country house. It is quite a common thing to see the women, or the girls or boys, weighted down carrying water from the wells.

Roof water could be diverted to a concrete tank, which could be erected at a small additional cost. A boiler could be installed at the back of the kitchen fire and that would supply hot water to a sink, thus avoiding the present type of slavery, and also saving fuel. It is astonishing the amount of turf and timber used in a country house to boil water. With a boiler in the fireplace the burden of kitchen work would be lightened considerably and this could be done with very little expense. The heating systems available nowadays are trouble-free for at last 20 or 30 years.

I ask the Minister seriously to consider removing the difference in the grant. For a three-roomed house in an area where there is a water supply the grant is £175, as against £125 where there is no water supply. In a five-roomed house the grant is £275 as against £225. The £50 would make a tremendous difference. In rural districts no housing plan should be sanctioned that does not include an outside tank, hot water at least in the kitchen and a bathroom and lavatory.

Comment on this

You will have few new houses for farmers if you keep to that idea.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick is not sincere—he is only play-acting.

Comment on this

These things could be installed in any country house if the Minister would only equalise those grants.

Comment on this

What would you do on a ten-or 15-acre farm?

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick has three farms.

Comment on this

What does the size matter? I would like to ask the Deputy one question, through the Chair.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

If the Deputy addressed the Chair it would be better.

Comment on this

Through the Chair, what difference does the size of the farm make or whether it is five acres or 50 acres if we are living in a civilised age? This is 1947, and what is wrong with having a bathroom and a lavatory in every house?

Comment on this

Has not the farmer to pay for it?

Comment on this

And he is willing to pay for it.

Comment on this

Is he willing?

Comment on this

This Bill seeks to give £50 more for houses where there is a piped water supply available. Why not leave it at the same figure and where a piped water supply is not available tank the roof water? A concrete tank holding a couple of thousand of gallons does not cost more than £10 or £12. I know what I am speaking about because I built the like. Farmers have built tanks like this without any grant except a few pounds from the Farm Improvements Scheme. You could have a pipe from the tank to the fireplace and a pipe from the fireplace at least to the kitchen sink if not all over the house.

Comment on this

The country man wants his open fire.

Comment on this

You will not interfere with the open fire. You would only be making use of the fire which is there in any case. I do not see what is wrong with specifying that every country house should have a bathroom and a lavatory. People in the country want a wash and look forward to it as much as any other kind of people.

Comment on this

What is to prevent them having it under this Bill?

Comment on this

In my opinion——

Comment on this

Your opinion does not count.

Comment on this

The Minister is aware that the cost of labour and the cost of building materials have both gone up. The grant of £250 is fairly good but the small farmer will have to supplement it pretty well in order to have any kind of a decent house. The £50 lopped off the country areas should be used as I propose. People in the country want proper sanitary accommodation. It is absolutely essential, and if we are ever going to make a start now is the time when the Bill is going through the House. I asked the Minister for Lands two years ago that the Land Commission should specify that they should be included in houses which they would build. He gave an answer at the time from which it would appear that there are two different classes of people, one class living in the towns who are entitled to certain things, and the other living in the country who are a lower class and who do not need these things. That was the attitude the Minister for Lands took on this situation.

Assuming that this Bill is passed into law, grants will be given to increase the number of houses in towns. We hear a good deal about the City of Dublin and Deputies have put up a case for it. We know what is happening here, that young people wishing to get married are held up, and if they do get married they are charged rents for a two or three-roomed flat of about £2 a week. As a result the wages of the husband are not sufficient to pay rent and to live, and very often we hear of young couples being separated because of the exorbitant rent. The one way to meet that situation is to make houses so plentiful that the rents will not be so high. It is the very same thing in the provincial towns. There is serious overcrowding and I am afraid that tuberculosis is the result of the overcrowding in many cases.

Many people have houses in the course of erection or which are about to be completed under grants from the Local Government Department under the previous Act. I think that this Bill should be made retrospective to cover those houses, at least, which are not yet completed. If an increased grant is necessary to-day it was just as necessary last March or April or last January because the cost of building materials has not increased at all since last spring. A good many of the people who tried to build a house with the £80 grant have gone into debt and the Bill should be made retrospective where the houses are not completed or where the families have not yet taken up occupation. The grant available up to the time when this Bill comes into effect was fair enough until wages and the cost of building materials increased so much. For the past two years the grant has become absolutely inadequate and plenty of people have actually gone into debt to complete a house. Many of the old thatched houses in the country were most unhealthy and it is a delight and a pleasure to see people getting away from those houses and building in a good healthy position and scrapping the old houses or converting them into much-needed out-offices.

In the country towns particularly the housing question is a very acute one. We have families, particularly young married couples, crowded together into the same house. We have a scheme at the present moment whereby when cottages become vacant the local authority or the county manager, as the case may be, gives preference to families who are declared to be suffering from tuberculosis. But let us not forget that while many of the families who are living in very bad houses are not suffering from tuberculosis, you will, I am very much afraid, ensure that they will be tuberculosis families in the future. I get a number of heart-rending complaints from people who are living in huts which are not fit to house stock.

While I absolutely welcome the Bill there are a few amendments or improvements which I would ask the Minister seriously to consider. They are very important. No. 1 is in regard to the £50 grant difference existing between the classes of people living in the two areas, and he should specify that that £50 should be spent on a boiler at the back of the kitchen fire. That will not disturb the kitchen fire as Deputy Giles is afraid. There could be hot and cold water laid on to the kitchen sink and a bathroom and a lavatory and proper sanitary provisions. Many people who built houses over the past ten or 15 years are now making arrangements to install a bathroom and a lavatory at their own expense. In the case of these houses erected by a grant from the Land Commission or the Housing Section of the Department of Local Government, a small additional grant could be given to people with good solid houses in order to install a bathroom and lavatory and the necessary fittings needed with these.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

I welcome the Bill. I believe it is an honest attempt to assist both public bodies and private individuals to provide housing accommodation for those who are in greatest need of it. I would, however, make some suggestions to the Minister. Any Deputy who has had experience on public bodies will realise that now is the time to submit any constructive criticism which in his view would make an improvement in the Bill. I welcome the Bill also because it will enable public bodies to provide houses for the small farmers who are not able to provide them for themselves. We have often had the experience, when selecting sites for houses for agricultural labourers, of going on land owned by a small farmer and of finding that his house was in a pitiable condition. One portion might be galvanised and another portion held together with props, yet we were unable, as a public body, to provide him with a house. I am glad that now the small farmer will be provided with a house by a public body whose bounden duty it will be to give him reasonable accommodation when he himself is not in a position to do so.

As other Deputies have pointed out, the Bill limits the grants from the 1st November, 1947. I am aware of some labouring men and tradesmen who have erected houses within the last 12 months, and I would appeal to the Minister, in Sections 15 and 16, to put this period back by at least a year, so as to enable these men to qualify for the grant. We all knew that the housing scheme would be introduced but these men did not delay their building by waiting for it and they should not be penalised.

Under the 1932 Act the space for a five-roomed house was limited to 1,250 feet. My experience on a public body is that it would be difficult to erect a house bigger than a four-roomed house within that measurement. The rooms are very small. Three of them can hold little more than a single bed. If the public bodies were given authority to go beyond that measurement of 1,250 feet they would be able to cater for the man with a large family. He would then have more space in his rooms and he could have double beds in them instead of the single bed which is all he can fit in the small rooms. I believe we are going against the interests of the people when we limit tradesmen and others who are prepared to build for themselves to that measurement. With the permission of the Minister, the local authority should be allowed to extend the measurement to at least 1,600 or 1,700 feet.

Prior to the war houses were condemned wholesale. It might happen that ten or 20 houses in a particular area would be condemned. They would then become derelict and reconstruction would not be allowed because the medical officer would not sanction it. At the present time we are building streets of 40 or 50 houses and in 40 or 50 years' time they, too, may be condemned. I have a particular district in mind where reconstruction will not be allowed although a case of infectious disease has never been known there because it is beside the sea. Some authority should try to reconstruct these houses—even a room and a kitchen—and they would then be suitable and comfortable for some of our old age pensioners and other old people. Our difficulty was that we were taking single men and old men and women out of such houses and putting them into houses at 7/- or 9/- a week. The position then was that we had to find extra home assistance to enable these poor old men and women to pay the increased rent for the new houses whereas if we were given permission to reconstruct these good slate houses they would be more comfortable and happy in the cheaper houses. Although we might have to spend £50 or £60 in doing so, I consider that it would solve our housing problem to a considerable extent.

We hear of families taking lodgings in labourers' cottages in order to try and qualify for any house which becomes vacant. That is happening very frequently at the present time and, on the other hand, a large number of people are living by themselves in single houses. They will not take in lodgers and they do not wish to be interrupted or interfered with. If discretion were given to local councils some such scheme for reasonable accommodation could be devised instead of giving a four-roomed house to the tenant of any house which may be condemned. People who have been living for years and years in old houses should not be moved but, instead, the houses should be reconstructed. That would mean that the houses which we would otherwise have to give to people from condemned houses would be available for men who have large families. That scheme would solve to a considerable extent our housing problem.

I am aware of a number of houses in rural areas which are suitable for recontruction and which could be let to people who are anxious to live in them. If we are going to insist on the operation of the Act a large number of these houses will become derelict because the owner has already got a house for himself. If he were given a grant he might, possibly, have the second house reconstructed and made available for a tenant.

I wish to point out to the Minister that I would like to see the grant under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts brought up to £2,000. The Minister has gone a certain distance in the matter but the practical experience of the public body with which I have been connected has made us appeal by resolution for authority to grant a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts up to the value of £2,000. We find that, because of the increase in wages and for various other causes, houses which formerly cost £700 or £800 in my area are now costing £3,000. I notice that under Section 35, a fine now on the repayment of a Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts loan is not being charged against the public body. I hope it will not be charged against the individual repaying it. The position in this connection is rather vague.

I welcome the Bill. It is an effort to try to meet the housing requirements at the present time. Naturally, if we all make our suggestions, on the Committee Stage we shall probably have a Bill which will satisfy the majority of the people, which will be an improvement, and which will give encouragement to us to proceed with the schemes we already have in view. I believe this Bill will go a long way towards removing discontent and that it will bring hope to the men in the rural areas who are without houses. I feel sure that every representative on a public body will give his wholehearted support to make it a success and to provide the houses for the people directly in need of them.

Comment on this

I think almost every member of the House is glad and relieved that this Bill has been introduced. I am sure that the whole country is satisfied with it also. Deputy Mulcahy was the only Deputy I heard who disagreed. I do not know that he disagreed with the Bill but rather with the time of its introduction. No matter what the time is, the Bill is extremely necessary. All I hope is that we will have the necessary amount of labour to carry it out.

To my mind, the most important houses are the board of health cottages, or labourers' cottages. In Meath there is an extraordinary demand for housing and many young people who propose to get married are anxiously awaiting houses. Quite a number of families are living together in some of the cottages and this Bill will be a great relief to them.

The next most important item of this Bill is the provision of a reconstruction grant. I am not so sure that it will be available for everybody. The poor law valuation is limited. That is rather a pity, I think, because on many large farms in County Meath there are labourers' cottages with good stone walls and reasonably good roofs but which are completely out of repair. The owner is not at all likely to repair them. If some method could be devised by which he could get a grant or the houses could be taken over from him, it would help to relieve congestion. I do not believe that the building of cottages will end all our troubles. As long as people leave condemned or old houses and those houses are demolished, congestion is bound to continue. Reconstruction, therefore, is very important.

There are five or six very nice villages in County Meath that were built many years ago by landlords. They were nicely laid out and in cases where a few new labourers' cottages were built in those villages the cottages are of the latest design. I have nothing against the design. It is neat and extremely attractive, but the unfortunate thing is that there are many gaps. Some houses have been burnt; some are in ruins and the impression is created of complete desolation. I hope that under this measure, if it is at all possible, the Minister will try to have ruins of old houses removed and gaps eliminated, not alone in villages, but in other parts of the country. They suggest a depression which does not in fact exist and present a very bad appearance.

I hope the Minister will be able to increase the poor law valuation limit for the purpose of this reconstruction grant and allow more of these houses to be reconstructed. At present the poor law valuation limit is £35. In County Meath that represents 35 statute acres which, according to the measurement generally used by the people of County Meath and most other counties, represents only 22 Irish acres. That would be a very small farm. I have a very strong idea that that figure will have to be increased or else there will be a number of farmers, living on larger holdings, whose houses are very dilapidated, who will have no means of reconstructing. It is a pity to allow these houses to disappear in time. Many of them are capable of being reconstructed. I hope the Minister will consider that point. I know he has a difficulty because that valuation in other counties would indicate a very large acreage of land but in County Meath it indicates about 20 or 22 Irish acres.

The design of cottages in County Meath is reasonably good but, unfortunately, nothing more than a house and small out-office were built. It was not realised that the tenant would require accommodation for cows and whatever other stock he might have. There was no stabling provided. The result is that, although most of the cottages are very nicely kept, many of the tenants were forced to erect some sort of device which they try to screen, and which very often consists of old tar barrels, which are most unsightly. The expense of building an extra shed or two would not be too heavy.

The next point I want to emphasise, and in connection with which I am sure the Minister has control, is that the sites of many of these cottages are unsuitable. Recently I was in a cottage that was extremely well kept and nicely decorated inside. Every effort was made to keep it properly on the outside but the cottage had been built in a hole and when it rains the garden and cottage are flooded. Our engineers ought to be capable of selecting better sites. Even some of the new cottages were built on very bad sites. Whoever selects the site, and I take it it must be the engineer, should use his intelligence and see that the cottages are not built in holes. The cottages belong to the nation. They are erected at very considerable expense to farmers, and it is a great mistake to put them on bad sites. The cottage to which I have referred has an acre plot, which was a triangle. The result of that is that the tenant is not able to get horses in to plough it. A man working all day cannot be expected to dig a whole acre in the evening. There would not have been any trouble involved in making that plot square so as to allow a pair of horses in to plough. As the plot is laid out, he could not attempt to do that. That is a pity. Instructions should be issued to engineers and others to lay out plots in a common-sense way and to put them in a position in which they can be drained.

I come now to the question of the dates fixed in the Bill for grants for building houses. It has been stated that there was a number of houses commenced before the date laid down in the Bill. I do not think there were many but there were some. The Minister should put back the date by at least a year and thereby give the people concerned the advantage of the very generous grant provided in the Bill. I am talking about the rural areas and I expect that quite a number of farmers will be building houses and a few have already started to build. They should get every encouragement. If we are to succeed in getting some of the houses reconstructed, and sufficient labourers' cottages built, some effort must be made to collect labour, as it will be one of the biggest difficulties. Deputy Allen suggested a bounty or premium on apprenticeships. That would do a lot of good, but it is too far distant and we should do something sooner.

I understand there is some bureau for getting many of the men back from Britain, but I do not know if it is properly organised, how many men it has got back or if it is a success. The Minister and the Government should make an effort to improve on that question and get many of the men back from Britain. No matter what facilities we have, if we have not the workmen we cannot build. With contractors one of the big difficulties is labour. Notwithstanding that we are told there is a great number of unemployed, many contractors complain that they are unable to obtain men and cannot enter contracts as they are afraid they will not be able to get the labour. It is one of the most important things to be considered. If we cannot get sufficient workmen, masons and carpenters to carry on the business, there will be a great deal of disappointment. The measure is a very attractive one and I have seen a number of letters asking for information about it, showing there is considerable interest. If by any chance we are not able to get sufficient workers to erect the houses, it will be a great disappointment to the people concerned. I hope the Minister will consider that point, not so much as a long-distance policy but as something to be done immediately.

Comment on this

I welcome the Bill and think it is very necessary, knowing from experience that there is a terrible shortage of houses, especially in country districts. In some houses there are three or four families living and boys and girls of a marriageable age have no chance. The most important suggestion I have is to make the grants retrospective for houses finished in 1946-47. Any person who started to build within the last two years should be clapped on the back and encouraged, as it was next to impossible to get material and that has put them in debt. I know of two brothers who built homes — one finished a house last year and the other started on the 13th August last year. They are hard-working small farmers who have other brothers in the house, who have gone out and spent their earnings and gone into debt for this purpose. Their case is deserving of consideration, so I ask the Minister to make the Bill retrospective to 1946.

I also suggest the raising of the poor law valuation of the reconstruction part. In Westmeath, as in Meath, a very small holding has £35 valuation, as the land in those counties was highly valued long ago. If the Bill was raised to cover £50 valuation, it would take in a certain type of farmer living at present in appalling houses. They are not in a position to build houses, but the reconstruction grant would help if they could get it. I know of cases where they have been cut out— one in 1941 and the other in 1939. I ask the Minister to reconsider the matter and increase the valuation at least in the highly valued counties.

I am very glad to see an effort will be made to keep cottages for agricultural labourers. At present the shortage of accommodation is the real cause of the shortage of labour for farmers. There are cottages in the rural districts, but the tenant is often a baker or tradesman in the local town and that is of no use to the farmer. These cottages should be for the agricultural labourers alone.

The building of houses in towns should be better planned. In Trim and Mullingar, in the last ten or 12 years, houses have been built, and if you stand at the end you can see that they have no breadth: each house is only a big gazebo and the whole width is not that of a good room. If they were all built two or three feet wider, practically the one roof would cover it at about the same cost and it would make all the difference. As Deputy Everett mentioned, the people at present have not room for a good single bed.

I believe there is a £50 less grant for houses in country districts where there is no water supply. The Minister should give that £50 extra grant to houses where the builder puts in the water supply. Deputy Blowick mentioned tanks. If the builder got the £50, he could put in a suitable underground tank and erect a lavatory and bathroom. We have the rural electricity scheme coming on in our district and numbers of people who have houses and who can afford it are building underground tanks to catch all the water off the house. They can buy a pump cheaply and pump automatically at a very small cost for electricity. The Minister should look into that, as the electricity scheme will be spreading all over the country.

In regard to loans for small dwellings, we are at present restricted to £1,000. Everyone knows that, if you want to build a decent type of house, that is not sufficient. The small dwellings loan should be increased to £2,000 or £3,000, in view of the increased cost of material. It would help small farmers who may take advantage of such a loan along with the grant and be able to build a house and improve it for further members of the family. At present the loan is tied down too much.

I understand that if you build a house so many cubic feet beyond the specification you will not get a grant. That is stupid. A man gets only £200 or £250, yet he is tied down to building these little houses with small rooms where you cannot turn about. There should be no maximum measurements. If a man gets a small grant, there should be a minimum size certainly, but no maximum. If he can build a bigger house, let him do so, as the present position will only create new slums.

I also suggest that a concrete tank should be built at the back of every labourer's cottage in which the rain water from the roof could be collected, thereby making it available for use in the house. The tank would not cost any more than £2, and would be a great convenience for the woman of the house. I also suggest that decent outhouses should be provided. At present there is only a little house at the back. One has to stoop down to get into it. There is a little ladder in it for the fowl and it is not of much use. If a decent outhouse were provided it would enable a labouring man to keep a donkey, pony or a pig in it.

I welcome the Bill and urge on the Minister to see that it is put into operation as soon as possible. There is a great scarcity of houses in the country. One sees two or three families living in the one house. The Westmeath County Council, over the last three years, has passed schemes for the building of labourers' cottages. We are doing our best to get cottages built for people in condemned houses. We were told two years ago that these would be completed in six months, but the contractors are only leaving them now. We have young married people living in rooms. That means you have two or three families in some houses. If the Minister pushes forward the operation of this Bill it will help to keep people from leaving the country.

An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

I most cordially recommend to the Minister the three suggestions which have been made by Deputy Fagan. He suggested the addition of a turf shed at the back of labourer's cottages, particularly where the cottages are built in rows near towns. The putting into operation of that suggestion would be an immense boon both for keeping the turf dry and avoiding the feuds that arise between neighbours about the loss of turf and small implements when there is no shed in which each tenant can lock up his property. I think Deputy Fagan's proposal that the £50 which is to be withheld from the waterless house should be given to the tenant purchaser provided he is prepared to supply his own water, is a most brilliant one. If one goes to the middle west of America — this is quite apart from the proposal to supply electric pumps — one sees all over the landscape on the western prairies wind-mill pumps. They are as typical of the prairie as the windmill is of the Dutch skyline. I imagine that, with one's experience of the windcharger in supplying electric current, it ought to be quite possible, in cases where electric power is not available to operate small electric pumps, to have a windmill pump erected. If a tank, such as Deputy Fagan has suggested, were built with the £50 to which he has referred, then running water could be made available in many houses, whereas, under the Bill as it stands, that would be impossible.

I take this occasion to direct the attention of the Minister to what has become a very serious problem in rural Ireland, and that is the extent to which the rules, prohibiting the taking of lodgers in labourers' cottages are being ignored.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is administration.

Comment on this

Very well. May I refer to the sub-letting of cottages? The taking of lodgers is bad enough, but when you discover that a lady resident in England who has thereby become the absentee landlord of a labourer's cottage, is collecting a slightly larger rent from the person presently in occupation than she herself is paying, then things have come to pretty pass.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is administration.

Comment on this

I am in your hands. I want to protest most emphatically against the continued treatment of some so-called utility societies in rural Ireland as genuine. We all know that there are in this country some well established, well run and well administered utility societies which are genuinely entitled to that description. We also all know that in 1932 a dirty racket was started in this country whereby the Fianna Fáil clubs throughout the country were to be called utility societies, the members of which were given larger grants than those given under the earlier Acts. That was a disgusting racket. It was dishonest to give larger grants to the members of Fianna Fáil clubs than were available to the ordinary citizens of the State. A few of them survive — broken, disreputable, fraudulent conglomerations of the usual type of the worthless down-at-heel pest who wants to live on his neighbour in rural Ireland.

Comment on this

I know them well, and the time has surely come when these relics of a disreputable past might properly be buried so that the genuine utility societies in this country that are doing honest work, and making some contribution to facilitate the erection of houses, might continue with their honest work without being discredited by being lumped together with these fraudulent, dishonest wrecks which constitute the broken down monuments of the earlier days of Fianna Fáil corruption and of the public generally by the bestowal of alms on their supporters.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Deputy had an opportunity in another place to deal with this question of corruption, and I suggest that he should not be allowed to ascribe or impute corruption to any Party or to any person unless he is prepared to produce proofs here in the Dáil. I am putting that point of order to the Chair: Is the Deputy entitled, under the protection of the privileges of this House, to suggest——

Comment on this

Privileges of the House? I will go out into Kildare Street and tell you very blunt and plain.

Comment on this

I am putting a point of order, and the Deputy is standing.

Comment on this

It is a point of order?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is for the Chair to judge.

Comment on this

I am going to put the point of order when the Deputy sits down. I am putting it to the Chair that no Deputy is entitled to avail of the privileges which attach to this House by reason of his position here as a Deputy, and under an Article of the Constitution, to ascribe corruption to any person, named or unnamed, unless he is prepared to produce documentary evidence that, in fact, such corruption exists. I am putting that point of order, and I suggest that you should advert to the evidence which the Deputy has already given in another place and the flimsy foundation on which he has based these charges.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot discuss what is happening in another place. I agree with the Minister that the word "corruption" might very well be dropped in this House.

Comment on this

I am sure the Fianna Fáil Party would like me to drop that word, but I will not drop it. I charge them—and for this purpose I waive— now, let the Minister note these words——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not concerned with the Fianna Fáil Party. He is concerned with the Bill before the House and might deal with it.

Comment on this

For this purpose, I waive my Parliamentary privilege.

Comment on this

But the Deputy cannot waive it. It does not attach to him personally. It attaches to the House and not to him.

Comment on this

I say that the Fianna Fáil Party——

Comment on this

Did you rule, Sir, that the word "corruption" was not to be used?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have definitely so ruled.

Comment on this

I said that the Fianna Fáil Party, for the purpose of corrupting the electorate of this country, provided in a Housing Act when they came into office that you could convert a Fianna Fáil club, in effect, into a public utility society.

Comment on this

And that any person who was a member of that so-called public utility society would get an £80 grant, whereas his neighbour who was not prepared to sell out to the local Fianna Fáil club would get only £70.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is accusing the Government of malversation of public funds.

Comment on this

No, I am not.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy, in my opinion, is so doing, and I will not allow the word "corruption" in the House from the Deputy or any other Deputy. There is another place, which is a model to the Deputy sometimes, where it was distinctly stated that the word should not be used in any connection in the House.

Comment on this

I accept that ruling. I am quite content, without any description, just to recite the story. Those who read it will judge what is the appropriate description.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is running counter to the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this

No; I accept your ruling.

Comment on this

May I again put a point of order? The present Government is not responsible for the fact that people can constitute themselves a public utility society and that to that society certain facilities to enable them to build houses can be given. I want to put this further point——

Comment on this

This is not a point of order any more than is Christmas Day. It is a lame kind of argument.

Comment on this

I want to put this point of order to you, Sir, when the Deputy has sat down.

Comment on this

This is not a point of order. Is it a point of order, Sir?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have not heard the Minister out yet.

Comment on this

You have heard half of it.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is going to refer to the administration of previous Housing Acts, because he can only refer to that administration if he is going to raise the question as to how public utility societies——

Comment on this

Did you ever hear such a point of order —"if"?

Comment on this

——have been managed or administered up to this, I suggest to you, Sir, that he would be out of order, because it is a matter that should be raised, if at all, on the Estimate for the Department, and you must already be aware that Deputy Dillon has raised that on previous occasions on the Estimate for the Department——

Comment on this

Annually.

Comment on this

——and on every occasion his allegations were shown to be without foundation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think it is a point of order.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that on a Bill——

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

Yes, it is.

Comment on this

I ask the Chair if it is a point of order.

Comment on this

I suggest that on a Bill the question of the administration of a Department cannot be raised.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

This Bill proposes to confer advantages on public utility societies. There are decent, respectable, well-administered public utility societies in this country, and, as a result of the housing legislation passed by the Fianna Fáil Government——

Comment on this

May I again——

Comment on this

Another point of order?

Comment on this

Yes. I am putting it to you, Sir, that the Government does not pass legislation, that legislation is passed by the Oireachtas, and that the Deputy ought at least to be exact in statements he makes here in regard to that fundamental matter.

Comment on this

As a result of legislation passed by the Fianna Fáil Government——

Comment on this

By the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

——there were created a series of disreputable, dishonest, fraudulent cabals——

Comment on this

Again, on a point of order——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Minister will allow the Chair to rule — I want to hear the Deputy. The Deputy is discussing the administration of an Act.

Comment on this

I am discussing the existence of——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Of an Act.

Comment on this

I am saying that there are in existence a number of bodies which would benefit under this Bill as at present drafted. That is my theme and I am saying that these particular bodies should be excluded from benefit under it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy was not precluded from saying that twice already.

Comment on this

I put it to you, Sir, on a point of order — and I think I am entitled to do so——

Comment on this

If it is like the last few, you certainly are not. Bhfuil cead agam bheith im' shuidhe, A Chinn Comhairle?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Ba cheart don Teachta suidh síos mar tá poinnt orduithe ag an Aire.

Comment on this

The Deputy has alleged — I am trying to quote his exact words — that, as a result of disreputable, corrupt and dishonest administration on the part of the Government, certain things have happened. Is the Deputy, without a scintilla of proof, entitled to make that charge in this House against the Government?

Comment on this

You are rambling.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not entitled to discuss administration.

Comment on this

He is making the charge here on this Bill and not on the Estimate for the Department. I put it to you, Sir: Is he entitled to make that charge of, again, disreputable, corrupt and dishonest conduct— and fradulent, too——

Comment on this

Yes; fraudulent, I said.

Comment on this

I put it to you, Sir, as a point of order: Is he entitled to make that charge against the Government on a legislative measure?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making it arise.

Comment on this

You are surprised at language like that?

Comment on this

I am, but not from Deputy Donnellan or Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

You are the boy who can use it at the cross-roads.

Comment on this