We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1947—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 118–224 of 224. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1947
Enacted

No. 33 of 1947 ›

The Deputy is now under the protection of the privileges of the House. I am putting it to the Chair that the Deputy is making that charge under the protection of those privileges and under the protection of the Chair. I put it to the Chair that the Chair is bound to protect the members of the Government and members of the Government Party from the charges the Deputy is making, unless the Deputy is prepared to adduce evidence and not his mere——

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

——obiter dicta in this House with regard to these charges. We have had experience of the Deputy in another place and I am putting it to you——

Comment on this

Is it a point of order?

Comment on this

The net point is this——

Comment on this

Is it a point of order? Sit down, if it is not.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

Is the Minister raising a point of order?

Comment on this

The net point is this: Is the Deputy entitled to impute disreputable, dishonest, corrupt or fraudulent practices to the Government on this Bill and in this debate?

Comment on this

I have no desire to do so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair already ruled that he is not.

Comment on this

The Deputy, I submit to you, is proceeding in complete disregard of the ruling of the Chair to make precisely those charges.

Comment on this

As result of housing legislation passed by the Fianna Fáil Government a series of fraudulent, dishonest, disreputable cabals——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is the third time that the Deputy has said that.

Comment on this

——constituted themselves first into Fianna Fáil clubs and then into public utility societies, usually calling themselves "St. Philomena's Public Utility Society" or the "Greyhound and Roundtower Public Utility Society".

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might now come to the Bill.

Comment on this

Most of them having brought themselves fully within the letter of the law collected for their members the £10 supplementary grant and then went out of existence.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not in this Bill.

Comment on this

Some of them have survived.

Comment on this

Nor is it true, Sir.

Comment on this

Some of them survive. How many public utility societies went out of existence in the last ten years?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with this Bill.

Comment on this

It has, Sir, because their survivors are still with us.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

But they are not in this Bill.

Comment on this

They are, Sir. Are not the public utility societies in this Bill?

Comment on this

All that are left.

Comment on this

Does anyone deny that? A few of them remain. Nobody knows better than the Minister that many of these public utility societies of the type to which I refer are public utility societies only in name. They do none of the ordinary services for their members that the old would-be respectable utility societies do in Dublin and Cork and elsewhere.

Comment on this

What is untrue?

Comment on this

What you have said about public utility societies — the whole lot of it.

Comment on this

I do not suppose that the Deputy knows what I said.

Comment on this

I know about the operations of public utility societies in my constituency.

Comment on this

Fire away, so. I know about the operations of public utility societies all over the country. Thanks be to God, most of them are dead and buried.

Comment on this

What Deputy Dillon has said is completely false in regard to public utility societies in County Limerick.

Comment on this

Contain yourself.

Comment on this

Is he an honest, reputable man? That is nothing new to him.

Comment on this

No? The Deputy, I take it, accepts the implication that these public utility societies were Fianna Fáil——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy please come to the Bill?

Comment on this

In the last 20 minutes I have not got out six sentences. The Minister for Local Government and Deputy Ó Briain have been jumping up and down. I was told to sit down and I sat down, because you, Sir, said I was to sit down.

Comment on this

I have not the least notion of sitting down. The Deputy has been trying to put me down for the last ten years and he has not succeeded. If he tries for the next forty years his efforts will be equally unsuccessful. Neither he nor his gang——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

"Gang" is not a right term to apply to any section of the House.

Comment on this

Sir, I am talking of the Deputy and his gang.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must come to the Bill.

Comment on this

I am dealing with public utility societies.

Comment on this

If a man belongs to a gang then he must be a gangster. Is it, Sir, orderly to apply that expression to any person in the House?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not Parliamentary to use the word "gang" in reference to any section of the House.

Comment on this

Or any member of the House, Sir, or any associate of any member of the House. Is the Deputy going to be asked to withdraw that?

Comment on this

I did not apply it to any section in this House.

Comment on this

You definitely did. "The Fianna Fáil gang" you said.

Comment on this

Is it right to apply it to a member of the House, Sir?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A member could not be a gang.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon said Deputy Donnchadh Ó Briain and his gang. Is that a parliamentary expression?

Comment on this

Did the Minister ever refer to people as a "gang"?

Comment on this

I will use the expression "Deputy Ó Briain and his gang." If you say that is unparliamentary I immediately withdraw it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Including any Deputy in a gang.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I said "the Deputy and his gang."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A very nice distinction.

Comment on this

And if you wish me to withdraw it I will withdraw it. I urge on the Minister that before these decrepit and disreputable relics are allowed to benefit under the provisions of the Bill at present before the House steps should be taken——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

By administration?

Comment on this

No, Sir. Steps should be taken to week out the bad ones and steps should be taken under this Bill to ensure that the powers conferred on public utility societies should be made available only to genuine societies. I will ask the Minister now to survey that whole position and put in a Schedule at the end of the Bill naming the existing public utility societies which, for the purpose of this Bill and the housing code generally, he will recognise as public utility societies, with proviso that hereafter to have a public utility society for the purpose of the housing code, its constitution must be submitted to the Minister, be approved by him and that an annual inspection will be made so as to ensure that they are being carried on as genuine public utility societies — as that term is ordinarily understood. If that proviso is put in I shall be quite content, Sir.

There is another proposal I want to make. I think it was Deputy Everett who pointed out that a good many houses which ought to be available for the accommodation of married couples, or families, have in fact with the passage of time become the residences of elderly single people who are ill-equipped to look after themselves, living alone as they do, but who have nowhere else to go. They hang on to these houses which would comfortably accommodate families if they were available to them. Probably the Minister has noticed that in Great Britain they have embarked upon the task of housing the old people in comfortable hostels where the old people are within reach of their friends and neighbours and do not have to go away into an old barrack of a county home. I believe that if in every parish, or barony, or group of parishes we had a comfortable hostel where the old people would have their own rooms, decent meals and a friendly atmosphere, quite an appreciable number of small houses at present occupied by such old people and which have fallen into disrepair would be vacated and would make a not insubstantial contribution towards a solution of the housing shortage.

I direct the attention of the Minister to the problem of supplies for building houses at the present time. I am told that temporarily there is enough flooring available, enough slates and even enough roofing timber. There may be a shortage of metal goods. But, strangely enough, cement seems to be more difficult to get than it ever was. The Minister for Industry and Commerce made a great flourish about six weeks ago and announced it was no longer necessary to control supplies of cement and took off all the controls, whereupon Cement Limited clapped them on again.

If a Housing Bill of this kind is the success that one may hope it would be, the question is whether the cement situation will not become utterly unmanageable. If that is to be avoided. I suggest to the Minister that a survey ought to be made to ascertain where the supplies of cement are going and, if there is an undue consumption of cement in building cinemas, dance halls and the like, we ought seriously to consider prohibiting the erection of such structures until the requirements of the housing schemes contemplated have been provided for.

I want cordially to recommend to the Minister consideration of the observations of Deputy Fagan in regard to bathrooms and sanitary accommodation in small houses in rural Ireland. A detestable practice has grown up in this country of building small houses in rural Ireland without bathrooms and internal sanitation. To my mind, that is a very great abuse and I would go so far as to suggest to the Minister that in any future housing scheme no grant should be made available unless the houses are provided with baths, internal sanitation and some practicable method of heating water for the occupants. That does not of necessity demand the installation of a range in the kitchen, because many country people cannot work a range and find turf an inconvenient fuel for a range. There are types of fireplaces in which quite an efficient boiler can be installed for the service of hot water to the house on what is equivalent to an open hearth. I have one in my own drawing-room and it works admirably.

May I make a very special appeal on behalf of a class of the community that seems always to be forgotten and whose trials are becoming well-nigh unendurable? I refer to individuals who are earning between £5 and £7 a week in small towns — the bank clerk, the senior shop assistant, the Electricity Supply Board employee, the assistant surveyor and that kind of person. They are finding it virtually impossible to get a place to house their families. I know some of them to be acquiring half a house three or four miles from their place of work, some of them paying fantastic rents. In the last few years the supply of houses suitable for them seems to have shrunk steadily. For that reason, I suggest to the Minister that one measure that might be taken to alleviate that difficulty is that this extraordinary provision that grants are not to be made available where the cubic footage or the square footage of a house exceeds a certain figure should be done away with. Why on earth did you make that provison? That is the most obscurantist Department of Finance mentality.

I would give any man who builds a house a grant if he asks for it because, if he builds a new house, he moves into that house from another house. He does not move into it from the top of a tree and the fact that he moves from the house in which he was into a new house vacates a house. That may mean that another neighbour will move into his house; but when all the moving is done, there is one house empty at some stage for a newcomer, and all we want is houses. I have known this regulation completely to distort an admirable plan made by an architect, because it was discovered at the crucial moment that the plan involved 15 or 20 extra feet, whereupon the person who was concerned to get the grant disrupted the plan and spoiled his house. The people who are going to build a house like Cartron in Maynooth and ask for a housing grant from the Kildare County Council are not legion and from the number of people who build medium-sized houses the community will get very good value for the grant they give.

Of course it is not popular to say that the real root of all our trouble is the Rent Restriction Acts. So long as that infernal system of rent restriction continues, we will suffer from chronic shortage of houses, because people whose business it is to build houses are deterred from prosecuting their business vigorously by the Sword of Damocles which hangs over their head that when they build their houses they will not be able to get a rent which will give them a reasonable return on their outlay. We have got into a vicious circle because that rent restriction code has created a chronic scarcity of houses and, so long as that continues, every Government is afraid to take off the rent restriction. Until we break that vicious circle, we will be in a perennial condition of introducing Housing Bills here.

Surely this House can afford to be realistic about something. I put this to Deputies. Of our own friends who acquired a new house since each one of us reached our majority, how many bought a house from a builder and how many built their own house? Certainly, in my own experience, as regards 90 per cent. of my friends who want to build a house, it would never cross their minds to hire Sir Edward Lutyens to lay out a panorama and design the house and call in a builder and a clerk of works. They scan the newspapers or read the advertisement of a speculative builder who is developing an estate in Stillorgan, Dundrum, or somewhere like that and they go out and look at the houses and, if they are nice and appear to be good value, they buy one and move in.

So far as I can see the speculative builder is completely excluded from the operation of this Bill. He has all the building labour organised; he has the capital or the credit to acquire an estate for development and it is worth his while to take an area where he can put up 40 houses and develop it and arrange it so that the houses can be built upon it. He is the very man who at one bite would contribute 40 or 50 houses, but he will not benefit under this Bill. We expect a poor individual, a creature who wants to get a house for himself and his family, to go out on to a plot of land to build a house, dig the drains, level the neighbourhood and do all the development work which ordinarily is associated with building a house. Certain persons will be able to do that in rural Ireland. Around Ballaghaderreen and Charlestown it may be the ordinary natural thing to do; but around places like Wexford, Limerick, Cork, Dublin or Sligo the thing is fantastic. Why are we excluding the speculative builder? If it is houses we want, he is our best bet. Why should we try to harass him or handicap him at the very moment when he can be of most assistance? I suppose it is due to some kind of idea that that would be represented as bestowing largesse on a rich man. The rich man has only one vote and you might vex 40 fellows who had 40 votes. If that is the spirit in which we are going to approach the housing problem, we shall be short of houses for ever and aye.

I must try and think of a nice, kind, gentle amendment that I can put down for the Committee Stage to impose an obligation on the Minister to survey the pure, public-spirited, noble, disinterested, inspiring associations of public-spirited citizens who constitute the public utility societies of rural Ireland — perhaps a section empowering the Minister for Local Government to give a leather medal to each of those societies, beginning with Deputy Ó Briain's clutch in Limerick.

Comment on this

Leave Deputy Ó Briain's Limerick society alone.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not approve of the award of a leather medal to testify to the purity and efficiency of these societies——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might say something about the Bill.

Comment on this

I shall try to design an amendment providing that as a reward for their disinterestedness, efficiency and public service——

Comment on this

That is what they gave.

Comment on this

I am going to propose an amendment and I do not think it will make a charge on the public funds. That is my anxiety, lest it should.

Comment on this

Who will provide the leather medal?

Comment on this

I shall provide the leather medal and all the Bill will require the Minister to do is to bestow it. I assume that out of his own largesse he will provide the pin.

Comment on this

I would be glad to welcome legislation which would tend to provide our people with more and better houses than we have at the moment, but I am sorry to say that this Bill comes at a very inopportune time. It comes at a time when there is talk of an election in the air and the people look upon it as an electioneering stunt. I am not saying that it is but I do say that it is a pity that it was not introduced three or four years ago, because at that time we were not able to build owing to the shortage of materials. That was the time to frame legislation which we could have ready to put into operation when building materials again became available.

I am satisfied, on the other hand, that we have had far too much legislation in connection with housing in the last ten or 12 years; it has been all legislation and no housing. I am further satisfied that a vast building programme, in fact a revolutionary programme, is necessary if we are going to get that balance in the country that I should like to see. The people for whom I speak are the small farmers down the country who are not in a position to build their own houses. The small farmer of that type is the most important person in the whole community but to that type of person this Bill is of very little use. There has been a certain increase in the grants provided but the Bill does not go far enough. There should be a better approach to the problem of providing houses for farmers and I am quite satisfied that a scheme of that kind could be put into operation without all this legislation. It could be done through the Land Commission. The Land Commission are a very important body who up to some time ago were mainly occupied with the division of land but that work has slowed down considerably in recent years and, in fact, has been almost terminated. It is a body of immense importance so far as the development of rural Ireland is concerned. Nearly all small farmers pay land annuities spread over a long period of years and I am satisfied that, in connection with the collection of these annuities, the Land Commission could take over the function of building new houses for the people living on the land. I am convinced that not alone would the farmers pay back some of the money expended on a scheme of that kind, but they would pay back every penny of the money lent by the Government because the farmers want nothing from anybody.

If a scheme were devised to provide new houses with suitable out-offices instead of the derelict houses and ramshackle sheds in existance on many farmsteads at present, I am satisfied that every penny of the expenditure on such a scheme would be repaid by the farmer if the instalments were spread over a number of years and added to the ordinary land annuities. I think it is only right that we should utilise a body such as the Land Commission for the purpose of providing proper dwellings in that way for our rural population. I think that such a scheme would obviate the necessity for a vast amount of legislation because I know that a large number of our farmers have not as yet taken out a proper title to their lands. When it comes to the matter of looking for grants or facilities, they cannot show a proper title to the land because over scores, or in some cases hundreds, of years no administration was taken out. Farmers looking for grants or loans under legislation of this type find the problem of taking out administration to establish their title a very difficult one. I think that in cases such as those the Land Commission should take over responsibility for rehousing our small and middle-class farmers on an annuity basis. The loans could be paid back with their ordinary annuities every year. It would be, no doubt, something revolutionary, but it is something worth considering.

There is one other thing we shall have to do if we are going to preserve a proper balance in the country. We shall have to put some limit to the extension of the big City of Dublin. I think far too much is being given to the City of Dublin. Like a big octopus, it is eating up the rest of the country. I would try to put a curb to that tendency and to pay some attention to the development of the rest of the country.

At the present moment many of our villages and small towns are nothing more than eye-sores. It is in such places I would spend money to try to bring back the people to the heart of the country where they should be, and not in the big business cities. I think the Minister should try to devise some scheme of developing villages. Villages usually spring up round a church and the local schools. In many of these villages at present there is no proper Garda barracks. In most parishes ramshackle structures serve as Garda barracks, and there is no proper attempt at housing the Guards. In the same way, we find maternity nurses living down boreens and little lanes, while the doctors in many cases reside miles away from the centre of the district. There is no proper provision either for the housing of national teachers, bank clerks or business people. In that way a vast amount of work of immense importance for the development of the country remains to be done. A start could be made by the Government in the reconstruction of these villages by providing decent buildings for national institutions, such as the Gardaí, medical and nursing services, etc. Around these buildings we could build our rural dwellings and then we could gradually proceed with the provision of facilities such as piped water supplies, sewerage, sanitation, light and heating in a big way. There is no use in talking of piped water supplies in the country under present conditions; that is fantastic nonsense.

We should make every effort to spend vast sums on the development of our towns and villages so as to make them happy centres for the people living there. In each village you could have a hall for various types of amusement, so that the people would be quite happy and contented. I am satisfied that the people are happy and contented, in any town or village where these amenities are provided. The majority of our villages have not these amenities and we should concentrate our efforts in providing them if we want to make this country a place worth living in.

As regards rural cottages, we should have a review of the whole position before we go much further in the direction of building cottages. Every cottage erected within the last 20 or 30 years should come under that review. There are many cottages not serving the functions they were originally intended to serve. In my own county there are many cottages serving no useful purpose. They are locked from Monday morning till Saturday night. Often you will see big cottages that cost £400 or £500 locked all the week. Sometimes you will find an old bachelor living in these cottages. He may be working in Dublin or in England and the key is turned in the door all the week and even longer. There should be some scheme whereby the cottages will be occupied by responsible people prepared to give a return to the community. We have numbers of old spinsters and bachelors living in houses miles away from churches, chapels and shops.

I think the position should be reviewed and perhaps we might consider building more in the vicinity of small towns and villages, constructing two-roomed houses near the shops and the chapels. The old people would be only too willing to live in these places. I know lots of people who have to hobble along the roads three or four miles on Sunday, and they frequently have to ask others to bring them goods from the shops. If these old people could get a two-roomed or three-roomed cottage cheaply near a village or town they would be only too glad to occupy it. In that way you will be releasing throughout the country scores of fine, hefty cottages built during the last 50 or 60 years and in perfect repair. At the moment those old people are living in them. We could release these houses for married men with families and thereby save ourselves from building scores of houses in the coming years.

In Meath, we always went in for big housing schemes. I do not say that the schemes were all well carried out, because there is a lot of jerry-building that never should have been passed. Of course, you could build hundreds of cottages and then when the slump comes you will have many people in dire straits. I would like to see a wellbalanced scheme with a fair number of cottages to suit workers on the land. I would like to see around the towns and villages houses erected for the old people who cannot drag themselves along the roads to the churches and the shops. These poor old people would be very glad to end their lives in a quiet easy way near the churches and the shops.

We should first cater for those people and then we could talk about sewerage, sanitation and piped water. It is a terrible thing after 25 years of native government to find our villages and small towns in such a pitiable condition. I know villages in my area and they are absolutely isolated. We have more town planning schemes and officers than we need. The trouble is that the plans are not being made operative. If we had the older people gathering around our towns and villages there would be little need for others to go to the cities and larger towns.

I am satisfied the Minister for Local Government has a fair amount of knowledge as to the scientific development of rural areas; at least, he can talk well enough on that subject. I think he is anxious enough to do the right thing. I believe we are some 20 years behind time in putting a halt to the growth of the City of Dublin. That has brought about much decay all over rural Ireland. None of the wealthy houses that we can see built around the City of Dublin should have been permitted. The people who occupy them should have been forced to go down the country and build near towns and villages. I believe that any man engaged in business in the city could get to his work by car or bus from a radius of 40 or 50 miles. If those people were forced to build down the country it would be a good day's work.

With regard to the grants and the increase in valuation, I believe we have not gone far enough. We should have gone up to £50 valuation. I know that the holding with a £50 valuation in Meath is a very small one and I feel we should raise the valuation from £35 to £50. However, we are always thankful for small mercies. If we are intent on having a proper housing programme, it would be better to be generous on the right side. Let us do something for the people who from the corner-stone of the whole edifice, and that is the rural farmers.

At the moment the biggest problem we have to face is the finding of enough land for labourers' cottages. We must have at least 400 cottages in County Meath. Every man with a cottage will take all the land he can get. We could build a good many cottages with less land attached to them. Many men with an acre around their cottages are making good use of the land but many others consider the land an eyesore and they have not made any effort to bring it into proper use. When a man works from eight in the morning till six at night with a farmer he has not very much time to devote to his own land. A good many men working with farmers get vegetables and milk, with the result that they require very little land for their own use. We should think twice before we give a full acre to every cottage.

I certainly would like to see a few acres, perhaps five acres given, if they were put to a proper use, but I am satisfied that about 1,000 acres of land are not put to any use in the county to which I refer. They are full of dock and weeds and thistles, but it is the ratepayers' money, it is the national money, which is buying this land. We have a huge drive for food to feed the people —and it is a hard job to get the food— while at the same time acres and acres of the best land are lying idle without even a goat tethered in the centre or a pair of hens walking across them. I am not against anyone getting an acre of ground, but let them make use of it. There may be some excuse for old bachelors and spinsters but there is no excuse for a healthy young fellow.

This will certainly do good; it is a step in the right direction and I welcome it, but more is needed if we are to make the country a place worth living in. The Bill could be more satisfactory in making the villages more attractive with sewerage and sanitation and piped water supply, but the Bill should have been drafted years ago. If we plan now and get Guards' homes, nurses' homes and teachers' residences built and build villages around them and arrest the tendency of the people to go across the water, we are doing good work, national work and work that we can be proud of. I am glad that the Minister and his Parliamentary Secretary is as keen for this as I am.

If we are to stop the dry rot and do good work, we must do everything in our power to curb the extension of the City of Dublin. There is a vast amount of wealth and power there but while it is growing larger and larger in pomp and power the country is decaying and dry rot is setting in. We must arrest that and get a thrifty, comfortable set of people living on the land.

Mr. M. O'Reilly took the Chair.

Comment on this
Donal J. O'Donoghue Domhnall Ua Donnchadha Independent

The amount of grant available for each house depends on two things — the number of rooms in the proposed building, and the availability of piped water supply and sewerage. If the maximum amount of grant is available only to five-roomed houses, is it not evident that the qualifying amount of floor space is an all-important matter if the rooms are to be worth living in? If we are to keep in mind the importance of the piped water supply and the fact that you always associate a bathroom with a piped water supply, is it not evident that we must recognise that the idea of having a bathroom in each house was at the back of the mind of the drafters of this Bill? I would prefer that the bathroom should not count as one of the five rooms; that there should be five rooms independent of the bathroom. Consider 1,250 square feet of floor space and then take a bathroom out of that. If you have in mind houses, not only in the towns, but in the country, a house with five rooms and that amount of floor space is not a house where a family with sons and daughters can have separate apartments. I believe that the rules governing the floor space were drafted 20 years ago and the change in ideas in regard to housing has been so rapid within the past 20 years that that particular rule should be revised. I think —and I have discussed the matter with builders and engineers — that the minimum space to allow for five rooms and a bathroom is 1,500 square feet. I seriously suggest to the Minister that one of the first matters which he should undertake is to have the Bill amended so as to cater for 1,500 square feet of floor space.

When I read the Bill for the first time I, too, was worried about the £50 allowed for piped water and sewerage.

I had in mind to ask the Minister to allow the £50 where a private water supply was supplied, but I think that, according to the wording of the Bill, any man who pipes water into his house qualifies for a bigger grant. It might be well, however, if the Minister in his reply would tell us whether or not that is the manner in which the Act when passed would operate.

There is another matter also that he should make clear, a matter which will help to build a good few houses in rural districts. Anybody associated with utility societies knows that where a man works on a farm where the profits go to his father or mother, where he is not paid a weekly wage and where he has not insurance cards stamped in keeping with the National Health Act, he does not qualify under the existing Act for a housing grant. At a time when we deplore the flight from the land and are doing our level best to encourage people to remain on the land, is it not common sense to take into consideration the manner of life which we are trying to preserve, that is, the manner of life on the farms? Where a man has two sons, one of whom is to get the farm, the other works on that farm without wages but when he is of age to marry he gets a plot of land from his father on which a house is erected and into which he must bring his wife, but under existing legislation he will not qualify for a grant for that house unless and until he stamps insurance cards. We might as well be honest about this thing. There is nothing to prevent that man from providing insurance cards and from having them stamped by his father, but that is simply in order to comply with the rules governing the giving of those grants as interpreted by a Government Department. I suggest to the Minister that that is one particular aspect of this Bill which should be given his fullest consideration, especially when it is a matter that helps to erect more houses and keeps more of our people on the land.

I suggest also that as far as the grant for repairs goes, the raising of it to £80 from £40 is not sufficient. It should bear some relation to the amount available for a new house because an old house is very often, as far as the walls go, as substantial as any new house that will be erected. If an old house is substantially as good as a new house, in the opinion of the Department engineer who passes it, I think that a grant, having at least the same relationship to the new grants as the former reconstruction grants had to the older house construction grants, should be given. I consider that at least £120 should be the minimum to be given for the reconstruction of an old house.

In my constituency we had a great number of thatched houses up to practically recent times. Quite a number of people, with considerable effort, reconstructed those houses by raising half the buildings and slating them, the second half remaining thatched. They got £40 for the reconstruction and, remember, that after that reconstruction they had half a new house. However, when they applied for a second reconstruction grant which would given them a new house they were refused for the simple reason that there is no facility under any Act whereby they can get a second reconstruction grant. I suggest that the present Bill be so amended as to allow those people at least an extra £40, thereby bringing the amount expended for reconstruction on each house to the £80 level which is allowed under the new Bill and which I consider is inadequate by at least £40. I suggest that as the amount to be expended on reconstruction will be limited, the valuation of farmers be not considered. The number of people with the very big valuations who will want to reconstruct their houses will be comparatively small. As has been said here by quite a number of Deputies, the farm of a man with a valuation of £40 to £50 in some counties is not a large farm. The wisest course, as far as reconstruction goes, is to wipe the thing out altogether. Quite a number of people have been named here as being in a rather difficult position as far as house reconstruction goes. They are neither rich enough to erect houses on their own account nor, on the other hand, are they in a position to avail of the Acts which provide for labourers and tradesmen and people generally who work amongst the rural community. I think that the more widespread operation of the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts will be the proper approach towards coming to the rescue of those people. Unfortunately those Acts are not availed of by quite a number of the local authorities.

The Minister would be well advised to revise the whole position in the light of present circumstances. A man now earning £300, £400 or £500 a year, if he has a wife and family, is not in a position to build a house in the way a man with even a smaller salary might have been able to do so ten or 15 years ago. The house in itself will be a guarantee and the man will have security of tenure. It will be something that, eventually, he or his children will own, or that he will be able to dispose of because, if he is an official, he might be transferred from the particular area in which he builds his house. The individuals whom this Act is meant to help are those who require help and have initiative in them. We all know that the number of people who can put their hands on the balance of the money apart from the grant is limited. There is an appreciable delay in the payment of those grants because of the small number of inspectors and the formalities which have to be complied with in order that the Act is administered properly. Under the old Acts the Department paid, and rightly so, part of the grant when the house was partially constructed. The balance of the grant was paid when the house was occupied. The most difficult period for the builder to get over is the period when he gets the slate and the timber from the merchant. I suggest, therefore, that the new grants be paid in four quarters so as to assist the man erecting his house to meet current expenses and so that he will always be in a position to acquire more and more of the material which will be required for the completion of his house. Only a limited amount of money is available and it strikes me that, with all the talk about the cities and the necessity for houses in them, most of that money is going to be eaten up by the cities.

I would ask the Minister to consider seriously the setting aside of a part of it for the erection of houses in the small towns and in the rural areas. Down the country we have at the back of our minds the idea that a good part of legislation caters for the cities. It has even been mentioned here by a number of speakers in connection with this £50 for the water that the Minister, in presenting the Bill as it is at the moment, is catering for the cities and the towns. With the idea prevailing in the country that only cities and towns are being catered for, is it any wonder that there is a growing desire on the part of people living in the country to go to the cities and to the towns? I ask the Minister to keep that suggestion in mind and to co-operate with the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the matter of the giving of building licences so that material may be available for the people in the country who set seriously about catering for those who want more housing facilities. I know of one particular parish in my constituency in which there are 30 houses with two families in each. I know also of quite a few where a young married man is living with his parents and his young wife is living with her parents. There are, also, cases in Kerry where there are as many as from six to 11 people living in two-roomed houses. I have taken note of a number of these cases and I think that the Minister would be well advised to look into the matter.

Comment on this

Two-roomed houses in Kerry?

Comment on this
Donal J. O'Donoghue Domhnall Ua Donnchadha Independent

Yes.

Comment on this
Donal J. O'Donoghue Domhnall Ua Donnchadha Independent

I will give the Deputy the names and addresses.

Comment on this

I do not want the names and addresses.

Comment on this
Donal J. O'Donoghue Domhnall Ua Donnchadha Independent

I know where there is one house with a family living in one room.

Comment on this

I do not know any two-room houses in Kerry and I know it pretty well.

Comment on this
Donal J. O'Donoghue Domhnall Ua Donnchadha Independent

It is a good while since the Deputy left Kerry.

Comment on this

It is a good while.

Comment on this
Donal J. O'Donoghue Domhnall Ua Donnchadha Independent

When he returns to Kerry he does not travel through the country, as I do. I have collected my information going from parish to parish in South Kerry. I do not know as well as the Deputy may know that part of South Kerry where the Deputy was born but I am saying that in East Kerry what I say is absolutely correct and, if the Deputy consults the county medical officer of health and asks him how many applicants there are for each labourer's cottage which becomes vacant, it will bring home to him that there is a greater scarcity of houses in Kerry at the moment than probably there is in any other county in Ireland, including Dublin, and I will let Dublin City go in with the county.

I want to impress on the Minister that he should make a survey of the counties, keeping in mind the number of cottages which have been built for the past 15 years, and that he should encourage those councils that have been most lax in living up to their duty of providing labourers cottages to start now and to avail of the new grants when this Bill becomes law to provide houses, of which there is an extraordinary scarcity in parts of rural Ireland. I have in mind the county and the constituency that I represent. Judging by the number of people who have called on me and have written to me in connection with this new Bill, I am quite satisfied that the Bill will give the greatest fillip possible to the building of new houses. I wish the Minister 100 per cent. success in his efforts to solve the housing problem.

Comment on this

I think it is true to say that in no aspect of our life do the changed conditions since 1939 appear so strikingly as they do in relation to housing. Whether we examine the question from the point of view of the large number of applicants for houses, which has increased considerably since 1939, or whether we consider the problem from the point of view of the cost of houses, does not really matter. The fact is that conditions have changed out of all recogaition. The cost of material and labour for house construction of any kind, coupled with the scarcity of many commodities, has aggravated the housing problem. In addition, of course, the almost complete cessation of building during the emergency period has resulted in an accumulation of applicants for houses far greater than any experienced before.

The problem in Dublin and district is. I think, more acute than it ever was and merits consideration from a number of angles. No matter how rapidly houses of any type are provided, whether they are constructed by private builders or by private individuals, or by local authorities, the demand for them exceeds supply and, apparently, will continue to exceed any prospect of supply in future. So acute is the problem that it should be tackled from an entirely different angle. Efforts should be made to reduce the aggregation of individuals living in Dublin and district and drastic steps should be taken to decentralise in so far as possible industrial development.

Many Deputies have commented on the fact that the enormous growth of Dublin and district is a serious problem and operates to the detriment of the country. Any Deputy who represents Dublin City or County subscribes entirely to that view. Not merely is it operating to the detriment of the country, but it is affecting considerably the whole organisation and the whole problem, not merely of housing but of ancillary services in Dublin City and County.

The problem which the local authorities have to face has been considerably increased as a result of the increased influx of population to the Dublin area. The population figures published last year of the census in 1946 show that there is one-fifth of the entire populaof the country in Dublin district. That is not confined to Dublin City. It extends outside the city but, nevertheless, it shows how serious the problem is and how difficult it must be to attempt a solution of that problem. There is, of course, at the present time a serious shortage of houses of all types. The effect of the war has accentuated that in many ways and it is possible that for certain categories of houses the operation of the Rent Restrictions Act has also contributed, in forcing certain builders who would normally let these houses to sell them, as they find that with increased costs and increased burdens of all kinds, it is more profitable when they construct houses to put them on the market rather than make them available for letting.

To suggest, however, that because the Rent Restrictions Act operates in this way it should be repealed, ignores entirely the other aspect of the problem, namely, that a very large number of people in cities and towns would find themselves completely without any prospect of housing accommodation, and the immediate effect of decontrol would be to place those people on the public highway. It is, of course, recognised that the operations of the rent restrictions code should be accompanied by a control on the selling price of houses. I think that two commissions sat in England on this problem and considered it very fully and, so far as I am aware, little effort has been made so far to operate any such restrictions there. The operation of any restrictions on the selling price of houses inevitably leads to other problems, but taking the whole matter and weighing one drawback against another, I think public opinion generally is definitely in favour of the continuation of the rent restriction code, despite its disabilities.

I would like to refer to a couple of matters to which I think little attention has been paid in the past. A certain minimum standard requirement should be enforced. Since the end of the war, the Minister for Industry and Commerce has had a number of committees considering this problem and last year, under the Industrial Research and Standards Act, a certain consultative council was established to consider different aspects of the whole question. So far as one can gather, any general operation of any system of control or inspection whereby minimum standards would be made obligatory is to a considerable extent very slight and any inspection carried out is of a cursory nature and no definite minimum standards are demanded.

Having seen and examined a considerable number of houses erected both by private builders and by contractors for local authorities, I have been struck by the lack of proper workmanship and the generally bad standard of a number of these houses. I recently examined houses erected by the Dublin County Council in 1938. They are not yet ten years up and they are now in need of radical repairs. In fact, it is no exaggeration to say that unless radical repairs are carried out, they will never last another ten years. When public money is voted and public grants are made available for any purpose, but in particular on a matter of this kind, it is our responsibility and the responsibility of the Department of Local Government to see that the workmanship and the materials used are the best available and that they comply with certain minimum specifications. Unless we insist on that and unless the local authorities are obliged to enforce these minimum standards, it is largely a waste of public money and the added cost to the Exchequer or the local authority, as the case may be, or possibly to the occupant, will increase considerably and add to a burden which at the present time is big enough, without these additions, which could be avoided.

I believe the Department of Local Government must enforce certain minimum standards or specifications and that these should apply both to private builders and to houses constructed for local authorities under contract. In many parts of County Dublin, houses at the present time are being erected without adequate water or sewerage service. It is, of course, a nice question to decide whether houses should be erected and these services added afterwards if they are not already available. It is a source of worry to a number of people who already live in districts where the services are barely adequate, to find that because permission is granted to builders or private individuals to build houses, the water or sewerage service available there is not adequate to carry the added burden of a number of new houses. In certain cases, the Dublin County Council refused permission to these applicants, but on appeal to the Department of Local Government they were granted permission. Where the engineers or the town planning authority refuses permission, only for the gravest reason should the Department of Local Government overrule that, particularly when it is based on technical knowledge and the advice of technical experts.

Other Deputies have referred to the question of the 1,250 square feet floor space. A great case can be made now for raising that limitation. When that 1,250 was decided on, our approach to many problems was very different from what it is to-day. In many houses bathrooms were then a novelty, but they are now commonly accepted in almost every house. Local authorities throughout the country are now inviting tenders from builders for cottages with bathrooms and if that is the case for houses erected by local authorities, surely it is reasonable that private builders or those seeking grants under this Bill should have a higher floor space than 1,250 square feet? Deputy Ua Donnchadha suggested that the floor space should be raised to 1,500 square feet. I think it should, and even higher. When we are dealing with the problem at all, and in particular when we are approaching it from the long-term point of view, we might as well plan for better houses and for houses with the most modern facilities. For that reason, I believe that the limitation of 1,250 square feet is entirely out of date and in no way complies with present conditions or requirements.

It is questionable whether, with all the added cost of materials and other incidentals, the grants proposed in this Bill are adequate. It is never popular to suggest increased expenditure, but if there is one thing which people in this country would welcome or support to the very limit, it is increased expenditure on housing. While I do not want at this stage to become controversial, there are many items under which public moneys are at the present time being spent where savings could be made without any serious drawback to the interests of the people or of the country generally. Those savings could be made available in order to increase the housing grants, whether it be by raising the actual amount of the grant or the grant in respect of floor space.

The only other point is the operative date on which grants will become payable. I cannot understand why this Bill was not introduced two years ago. The war is over now for about two and a half years. If one considers the number of houses that have been constructed since then it must be admitted, I think, that the number of houses built privately has been relatively larger than the number erected by local authorities. If we are to overcome the acute shortage of houses, the grants should be payable at least from the 1st January, 1947, and preferably from the 1st January, 1946. This Housing Bill was due at the end of the war. For some unknown reason it has not made its appearance until now, and I suppose if a general election were not in the offing, we would not have seen it even now. In view of the conditions which prevail, and the fact that a measure of this kind is already overdue, the operative date I suggest should be put back to the beginning of this year, and more properly I would say to the beginning of 1946.

Comment on this

Did I understand the Deputy to say that the number of private houses built in the last couple of years has exceeded the number built by local authorities?

Comment on this

Yes, relatively.

Comment on this

I welcome the Bill, and I do so on behalf of a considerable number of citizens, particularly those who availed of the facilities provided under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. I am glad the Minister has acceded to the request that was made to him by numerous Deputies when the Estimate for his Department was going through the House last May by increasing the ceiling for advances under this measure. I still think that he would have been well advised if he had given 100 per cent increase. There is the new disease that is spreading throughout the length and breadth of the land which is known as "more". There are demands for more and more money for everything, but there is no question of where it is to come from. We have to make up our minds that the all-important problem of housing our people is going to cost money, and that that money can only come out of the pool in which there is a definite amount.

I think the Minister would be well advised to give a No. 1 priority to house-building — I mean over all other sections of the building trade — because I feel there is a very considerable amount of luxury building taking place that could well afford to wait for the next few years. If that were done, it would give those of us who are members of local public bodies an opportunity of grappling with the all-important problem of providing houses for the people. As a matter of fact, I am a member of two local authorities and both have to deal with this housing question. We meet the claimants for houses day after day, and we know how acute this problem is. I cannot see for the life of me how we are going to house the people of the country unless there is some determined effort made to deal with the problem.

I would suggest that the Minister for Local Government, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance should come together and try to solve the problem of housing costs. Since this debate started I have been listening to the speeches made by other members of the House, and I was surprised to find that no Deputy dealt with the cost of house building. I have here before me some figures which bring out in striking contrast the cost of house building. In 1937 we were able to build a house for £290. The same type of house to-day is costing us £1,200. Every member of the House is well aware that, in the intervening period, there has not been a 300 per cent. increase in the cost of labour or in the cost of any material which goes into the construction of a house with the possible exception of timber.

Comment on this

The figures given by the Deputy do not represent a 300 per cent. increase. What is the value of money?

Comment on this

We are not now discussing the value of money. We are discussing the price of materials that go to construct a house. I am talking of the actual cost. Apart from being a public representative, I have done some house building myself. I wonder if this problem could be faced by making a national appeal to all the interests concerned? I would start with the labourer and the artisan, the builders' supplier, the contractor and the Department itself. If something is not done in that direction I am afraid that we simply cannot house the people.

I have here some figures which, I think will convince the Minister that this is a problem which no local authority can continue to deal with, not even the Dublin Corporation with all its wealth. We in Drogheda at the present time have a scheme of 30 houses. The all-in cost is £1,100 each. We are getting a grant of £300 from the Transition Development Fund. That brings the figure down to £805 to which is to be added a sum of £234 from other sources, which brings the net cost to £571. The basic rent of that house will be 12/- per week. Rates will represent 2/7 per week, so that the total will be 14/7 per week. Where is the working man who would be able to pay a rent of 14/7 a week? I know the Minister will ask me, what contribution is the local authority making to this problem. My answer is that in this particular case our contribution is approximately 2/- per week per house. That is the position in a provincial town with a population of 16,000 people. It also has to be considered that we have in hands the preparation of a scheme for the building of some 250 houses. When all these figures are totted up, they will give the Minister, I am sure, some insight into the financial burdens which are facing local bodies so far as housing is concerned. For the reasons that I have put forward, I suggest that something should be done to investigate the cost of materials, and the cost of labour, making, of course, a fair allowance for the contractor's profits. Nobody could expect a man to work for nothing. I would not expect any man to do that, and certainly not a building contractor. I feel from experience that the poorest amongst us are the people who must bear this burden in the long run. It is the people on the small incomes who must meet these rents, in the vast majority of cases, at all events.

Section 26 sets out:

A housing authority (being the council of a county borough or the council of the borough of Dún Laoghaire) may and, if required by the Minister, shall provide reserved houses for occupation by persons of a particular class.

I presume the particular class referred to are newly-married couples and I seriously suggest to the Minister that that section should be amended so as to make it apply to all towns having a population of 12,000 or over. In towns like Drogheda and Dundalk, there are very large number of young people employed in the new industries set up by the much-despised Fianna Fáil Government who simply cannot get housing accommodation. It is not their fault. When a scheme of houses is completed, naturally the people with the larger families living in the worst conditions get preference. There may be a shift around when some of the old houses become vacant, but up to the present the landlord was not permitted to relet. Under this Bill, there is a hope that we will be able to repair some of these older houses which may then possibly accommodate some of the younger people. I suggest that towns of 12,000 population and over should have the same facilities in this respect as the county boroughs or borough of Dún Laoghaire. It is a problem which cannot be easily got over, but I know its seriousness because I am very often approached by young married people who want to know what they are to do, and it is deplorable that, when young people marry, they must stay with their respective parents. Unless we get the same privileges under this section as county boroughs and the borough of Dún Laoghaire, I can see no hope of solving that problem.

I hope the public bodies throughout the country will give this new measure a fair trial and will get all the benefits they possibly can from it for the people whom they represent. I am very glad that, generally speaking, the Bill has received a warm welcome from all sides of the House, with the exception of the Leader of the Opposition, who tabled an amendment designed to postpone the Bill for six months. He said that, in six months' time, there would be a Government in office which would do something else with it. I have no hesitation in saying that, if Deputy Mulcahy is to be at the head of that Government, it is not for six months it will be delayed but rather six years, and his plea then will be, as it was in the past: "We must wait until prices come down." I hope that is not going to happen.

With regard to Deputy Dillon's sarcasm and his criticism of the Fianna Fáil utility societies, as he described them, the fact is that our housing programme over the last 15 years is nothing short of a red rag to a bull in Deputy Dillon's case. That is his trouble. We have made such a success of our housing policy that it gives rise to envy and jealousy rather than honest criticism on Deputy Dillon's part.

Comment on this

I give a very hearty welcome to this measure and I do not even suggest that it is overdue. It may be overdue in relation to the number of persons awaiting houses but, in the other sense, the purely economic sense, it is timely enough, when one has regard to the financial resources of the country. The Minister will, I think, readily agree with me when I say that the facilities provided by the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act, which, according to the First Schedule of this Bill, is to be repealed, were very welcome at the time. It was a very welcome sign of the times that people banded themselves together, people who, because of the lack of a proper or comprehensive definition of the word "working-class", were precluded from occupying the houses built by local authorities and which were let at fairly reasonable rents. Under that Act, public utility societies built a number of houses and I think it will be conceded that not alone did these societies satisfy a want in the matter of houses but, in addition, their action was of a character-building type.

The Minister will agree with me again when I say that the ambition of many of these people, sometimes called the white-collar fraternity or white-collar workers, was to own a house of their own. That is a very laudable ambition and these people showed a very good public spirit and, in my view, are amongst the best in our community. They have some little stake in the country because of their interests and efforts. People with fixed incomes are to-day the least able to bear many of the financial burdens placed upon them.

The last Deputy who spoke mentioned the increased cost of building, with particular reference to building materials. I do not propose to deal with the prices of these materials, because I am not too well versed in the building trade, but I have had contracts with people in the trade, honest people, who tell me that the cost, even to-day, of building a house, due almost entirely to the high cost of materials, is prohibitive. Anybody who takes up the papers will see reports of the meetings of various public bodies who, in many cases have not even got tenders for works advertised, all going to show that builders and builders' providers are not the racketeers or the profiteers that people seem to think.

I should like the Minister to tell us what is meant by Section 17 (1) which speaks of grants in respect of the erection of houses "for occupation by a person of the working classes or an agricultural labourer." The type of person I refer to is the person who engaged in building through the medium of a public utility society, and I should like to see that kind of effort encouraged rather than discouraged, as it may be to some extent under this Bill. I think the Minister had some doubt in his mind as to the building of these houses by private enterprise.

Now I am an individualist. I do not believe for a moment that the local authorities could build at a cheaper rate. Reference has been made to some houses in County Dublin which were built about ten years ago and which are now almost about to collapse if they are not immediately attended to. These houses will be the subject of very expensive repairs. Somebody must have blundered there. They either had an inefficient clerk of works, or there was some swindle somewhere, when houses built for a public authority such a short time ago are now tumbling down. We have that on the authority of the Dublin representatives. I feel that if these houses were constructed by one of the builders here in Dublin there would be a public outcry. We know, of course, that in the building trade, as in every other trade, there are unscrupulous people. I am sure that the Minister and the local authorities will see to it that any houses erected under the present scheme will be supervised by a competent clerk of works or an engineer who will see to it that the materials provided for in the Estimate will be put into the buildings.

We have heard a good deal here about the flight from the land. We have been told that the people in the rural areas have not received adequate treatment in the matter of housing comparable to that of the cities and towns. Deputy Ua Donnchadha must know as well as I do that one reason for that is because of the drift from the rural areas into the towns. Cork City suffers in the same way as does Dublin. If these people were properly housed it might help to stop the drift from the land but I feel myself that some Deputies fail to realise the amount of money devoted by way of subsidy to agriculture, and so on, which flows into the rural areas. One need only examine the Estimates to discover that. The rural areas are very heavily subsidised indeed.

My main concern is to learn the approximate date upon which it is proposed to start the building of these houses, or the approximate date upon which it is proposed to advertise for tenders. I do not suppose that the Minister can give us exact information on that point but he can give us some approximate date as to the time when we may hope to see building commence.

In introducing this Bill, the Minister informed us that it was his intention to bring in differental rents in these housing schemes. That system has been in operation in Cork City for a number of years. I think Cork was the pioneer in that respect. At the time it was initiated I felt it was a very courageous experiment but I also felt that it might create a lot of nosey parkers spying on one another. However, I discovered that my suspicions in that respect were completely unfounded. When I made inquiry in the proper quarter I was told that the scheme had been remarkably successful. The amount of arrears outstanding is very low. Taken all round it has worked out very satisfactorily. I trust the same experiment will be equally successful in Dublin and elsewhere.

As the Minister is aware, a number of persons built houses under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. At the end of a certain period they discovered that they would not be able to buy out their ground rents. I would like the Minister to give us some indication of his views on this matter. Is it possible that the local authorities who purchased the land would be enabled to sell the ground rents at the end of a specified period? Many tenants feel that they would like to call not only the house their own but also the land on which it is built.

An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

There is just one point I would like to make. I think it is a great hardship that people in the rural areas who started building operations three or six months prior to the 1st November are eligible only for the smaller grant. The fact they only commenced operations six months prior to the 1st November was due to scarcity of building materials. I think the Minister should make it retrospective for six or 12 months before that date, particularly in regard to the rural areas.

Comment on this

I merely want to mention the case of the purchased cottages vested in the tenants, particularly under the older scheme. I think that these should qualify for reconstruction grants. Many of the tenants of labourers' cottages are reluctant to purchase because of the fact that after the first letting responsibility devolves upon them for the repair of these houses. I think it would be an advantage to the local authorities as well as to the tenants to become the owners of their own houses in the first instance by stimulating the operation of the Cottage Purchase Acts while making them responsible for their own homes. Generally, it takes the full rent value of the cottages to execute the repairs plus the added difficulty of getting skilled operatives to do the work owing to the quantity of building construction on hands. I welcome the Bill because it will facilitate those of our citizens who wish to become owners of their own houses. I think those who have shown initiative by carrying on building in the last two difficult years should have their efforts recognised by being given grants in the same way as those who have had houses built for letting.

Another provision that I welcome in this measure is the facility given for the employment of direct labour by local authorities. I think there should be a special building section under every local authority. The speculative builders to-day are getting such high prices for their houses that they are able to pay their operatives even more than the trade union allows, thereby attracting skilled tradesmen to their schemes. Again, every effort must be made to attract our own skilled operatives back again from across the water. Many of them are coming home at the present time because they have found that in most cases the rates are as advantageous as those beyond the Irish Sea.

I think also that the building of houses should stand on its own financial foundations and that the subsidising of housing schemes from rating sources ought to be again examined. While I would not take the control of building or anything like that from the local authorities and put it into the hands of a semi-Government Department, I think it would be a wise thing to examine the scheme to see that such financial backing as is necessary would be put at the disposal of these authorities by the Government. The Minister has promised a White Paper dealing with the whole matter in the near future and then the Dáil will have a better chance of examining these particular aspects of this most important problem.

Comment on this

This Bill will possibly increase the number of houses that will be built in the future and I think everyone will wecome the terms contained in it. Personally, I think it should act as a fillip to the building of houses. I should, however, like to issue this warning to the House, that, just as Rome was not built in a day, we should not expect as a result of this Bill that thousands of houses will be built overnight. That will take time and money. I say that because of various suggestions made, owing to the scarcity or alleged scarcity of skilled labour, that people who are outside the industry should be brought into it in order to be in a position to proceed much more quickly with the erection of houses. I should like to sound a warning note on that. We will be very lucky if we can formulate a continuous programme for the next five or six years. If we can build a certain number of houses each year, I think we will be doing very well.

On the other hand, if we take advantage of the boom in the building industry and take thousands into that industry who have not been in it before and never were connected with it, what will happen when this boom comes to an end, as it must come to an end? I do not think that it would be good policy to bring a lot of people into the building industry who have not been in it previously. I think this scarcity of labour has been magnified to a large extent. We all recognise that builders are not philanthropists and that when they take a contract it is up to them to get the work finished as soon as possible. Each builder will be out to get the largest number of men possible on a particular contract. At times, owing to the amount of work in hands, it may be difficult to find men. At the same time, there may be several men who are looking for employment. It is very hard to reconcile the two things. I put that down to the fact that everybody wants to get the work done at the same time. We will have to have patience and, no matter what money is advanced by this Government or any other Government, the provision of houses for the working classes will take time.

There are one or two matters I should like to refer to. One is the proposal for the differentiation of rents. I think that is a very good provision to have inserted in the Bill — that we should give the various councils the option of a sliding scale, so to speak, so far as the rent of houses is concerned. Undoubtedly, this experiment has worked fairly successfully in Cork and in many cities in England. There is no use in denying that we come across certain people who were previously housed in what one would call a slum house whose weekly earnings are as great if not greater than the earnings of people who lived in a tolerably good house and who do not come under the 66? per cent. provision. It would be a good thing if this question of the differentiation of rents was looked at from the Christian point of view. If a man has a weekly income which enables him to pay a few shillings extra in rent, he should not have any grudge if, by doing so, he is helping some other man who is not in such a favourable position. I think that is a very good power to give to the local authorities, if they desire to put such a scheme into operation. My idea as to the ability to pay rent is this. A bun even at a 1d. is dear if a man has not got the 1d. and it is cheap at a 1/- if the man has the 1/-. The same thing applies to rents.

Large numbers of people at present are prepared to pay a fairly decent rent if they can get a house. I do not see any reason why these people should not be allowed to rent a house. We are too fond of talking about people who cannot afford to pay rent, or who have not the will to pay any rent at all, and thus keeping back the provision of houses for men who are prepared to pay. We cannot have our loaf and eat it. We cannot have very high wages and expect to get cheap houses. Some Deputies are creating an awkward situation by saying that things can be done which they know cannot be done. A house which could be built ten or 12 years ago for £350 now costs £1,100 or £1,200. There is no use in talking about the rents that obtained at that time and having the same rents to-day. I should not like to see any man paying a farthing more than he is in a position to pay. But we must face the position as it stands and bear in mind the resources of the country; that we have to distribute justice all over and be fair to every section of the people.

One or two Deputies referred to the question of labourers cottages. That is a very ticklish question. Deputies would be surprised to know that tenants who have purchased their cottages are not so soft when they come to sell them. They require the highest amount they can get. They make sure that they will get all they can. That is one of the things I do not want to dwell upon. I welcome this Bill but I should like to say that it will take time to put all its provisions into operation. In the course of a few years, when materials are available, I hope that there will be a sufficient number of houses to meet all the needs of the people. That, of course, will depend to a large extent on the supply of materials. At the moment it is not a question of money but a question of supplies. So far as cement is concerned, if you were willing to pay £5 for a bag of cement you would hardly get it unless you had a priority claim. That should convince Deputies that everything in the garden is not lovely.

In fact in the Dundalk area, in the Drogheda area and all over the country, there are roads up for the last three or six months ready for concreting but a bag of cement cannot be procured to finish these roads. That should bring home to all concerned that the progress that will be made in regard to the provision of housing in the immediate future depends to a very large extent on the supply of materials at hand. It is fortunate that during the last year we have been in a position to import large quantities of timber suitable for the building of houses. That was one of the great difficulties in the past and I am glad to know, judging by a circular sent out by the Minister, that supplies of timber will be sufficient to meet most, if not all, of the needs.

Comment on this

Put it this way — supplies of timber at the moment are plentiful and, therefore, local authorities should lay in a stock.

Comment on this

As I say, I welcome this Bill but I say again that the future will depend on the co-operation given by the people concerned. If I might make a plea, without singling out any particular section, I would say to those people engaged in the building industry — I am not going to mention anyone in particular — that they should bear in mind that it is not all millionaires who will occupy these houses, that some of the people who will occupy them are in poor circumstances. A recognition of that fact alone should impress on those people that at least during the next 12 months public bodies and those who intend to build houses should be assured at least that the cost will not go any higher than it is at present. I make that suggestion in the hope that the costs so far as building houses are concerned will be kept stationary, at least during the next 12 months, so that this old country of ours, which has suffered very much during the last 20 years through various causes, will get a chance to recuperate so that we may be in a position again to provide for all the needs of our people in regard to housing.

Comment on this

Apart altogether from the observations which were made as to the merits or demerits of this measure, which I am glad to say the House as a whole, irrespective of Party, welcomes, there were one or two Deputies whose speeches suggested that a vast quantity of materials, which should be used for the construction of houses, was being diverted to less desirable and unessential purposes. I should like to say at the outset that there is no foundation whatsoever for that suggestion. It is true that we are building other things as well as houses in the State, but, in erecting these buildings, we are not using any of the materials which are in short supply and which are essential for the construction of houses.

First of all, there are no new luxury cinemas being constructed or no new luxury entertainment centres, and there never have been what have been described grandiloquently as luxury hotels per se built in this country. What have been described as luxury hotels by those who have been critics of the Government are old, unused, uninhabited mansions which otherwise might have crumbled to decay, which were unsuitable for any other purpose —largely because of their situation and their design — and which have been taken over to house people after the manner and in accordance with the purpose for which these houses were first constructed. It was considered by the Minister responsible, and by the organisation which has been set up under an Act of the Oireachtas, that it was better to take these over and to utilise them profitably for the benefit of the people of this country, particularly for the benefit of the primary producers of this country, than to allow them to continue vacant, closed, disused and, as I have said, crumbling to decay.

These hotels are, in fact, among our best shop windows, our best and most profitable selling agencies for these primary products of our land, which we have in surplus supply. I remember—and I am an old Sinn Féiner, unlike a great many of our critics— when Arthur Griffith used to condemn the cattle trade of this country because it was the least profitable way in which we might turn to our advantage the natural increase of our flocks and herds. He pointed out how unprofitable it was that we should sell our beef, as he used to say, on the hoof, exporting all the by-products and all the offals and giving to other people the labour and the employment that arose when live stock was converted into an edible commodity. Here in these old mansions, which have been described for propaganda purposes as luxury hotels, we are selling our beef, not in that least profitable way which Arthur Griffith criticised and condemned — on the hoof — but we are selling it and serving it on the table. In doing so, we are reserving and retaining in this country all the by-products that are associated with the live-stock industry — the hides, the bones and everything that comes from the cow except its low and everything that comes from the sheep except its bleat. In addition to that, we are giving to our own people all the employment that arises from killing the beast, from cooking and from serving the meat. We are doing all this, let me repeat, without encroaching in any way upon the supply of materials that are so essential and are so urgently needed to supply our own people with houses. What I have said in regard to these so-called luxury hotels applies likewise to the cinemas and other places of public entertainment, some of which may have been reconstructed or remodelled, but none of which upon any considerable scale, have been built as new projects since the emergency arose.

Comment on this

Are you sure of that?

Comment on this

Certainly. The only one I know of belongs to an organisation with which the Deputy has, shall we say, a fraternal association; the only luxury ballroom I know of in this city that has been built during the period of the emergency is what is known as the Four Provinces Ballroom. It is a ballroom belonging to a trade union, the Irish Union of Bakers, and it is managed by a trade union as a profitable commercial concern.

Comment on this

It is not a new building; it was an old church.

Comment on this

An old church with a very new front. It amuses me, as the Minister responsible for the housing of the working classes, to read, week after week in the Irish People, articles condemning me because I am alleged to have permitted luxury building in the City of Dublin, and to see there side by side with the editorials of the Irish People a quarter page, sometimes two columns, of advertisements for the Four Provinces Ballroom, owned and managed by a trade union, by the Irish Bakers' trade union.

Comment on this

It is a damn shame, is it not?

Comment on this

No, I do not think so because, after all, I am not as puritanical as Deputy Davin is. I think that from a social point of view it is a very good thing that we should have properly constructed and properly managed places of public resort to which people can go for amusement, recreation and relaxation. I think— and I am not a pussyfoot — that it is very desirable that the young people of to-day, unlike the young people of a generation or two ago, should have some alternative to the public house and, therefore, I do not think the country loses very much if we do provide them with decent and comfortable places of resort to which they may go in the evenings.

I am not one of those who have criticised the people who go to these places of amusement and public resort, provided they are properly conducted and properly laid out and managed, so that no abuse will arise. That has been my attitude, but that is not the attitude of the new puritans who go around either in red coats or pink ties and who have suddenly developed the Cromwellian idea that there is something immoral and improper in dancing and amusement and general public conviviality.

I was proceeding to point out this, that so far as these places of public entertainment and resort are concerned, they do not use in any great measure, in any significant measure, any of the essential materials which are required for the building of houses. Picture houses and dance halls in the City of Dublin are built of concrete and steel. Public by-laws will not permit timber to be used for ordinary constructional purposes in the building or the erection of cinemas or of dance halls and we do not use steel in any considerable way in the erection of houses. In fact, unless in certain exceptional cases, we do not use it at all. We do not use cast iron seats and we do not use any of the other appliances or accessories which you find in places of public amusement, so that so far as this so-called luxury building is concerned, it does not in any way encroach upon the supplies of materials which are available for the erection of ordinary dwelling-houses.

That is the first point I want to get home. The next point is this, that in so far as there has been any reconstruction of places of entertainment in the City of Dublin or elsewhere, this reconstruction in most cases has been carried out in order that these places may be made safer and more secure and free from risk for the ordinary people, the patrons who frequent them. The third point I want to make is that the amount of reconstruction which has been carried out on these places of public entertainment has been comparatively little; that they, in fact, so far as all classes of building materials are concerned, have used very little. The building licences which have been issued for recreation buildings, including dance halls and cinemas and so on, are only 1.9 per cent. of licences to a total value of £12,330,000 which have been issued for the last 11 or 12 months, while the number of licences issued for house-building amounted to 50.2 per cent. of the total building and construction licences issued over the period. To this we might add the 14.8 per cent. issued in respect of new factories, so that there is no substance in the sort of criticism which we heard here from some Deputies in the debate on this Bill, and certainly no substance in the criticisms we hear so commonly outside, that essential materials required for house-building are being diverted to other less essential and less desirable purposes.

The fact of the matter is that the requirements of public authorities and the house-building industry generally are given first priority over every other type of constructional activity and, of course, in that regard we have to remember this, that when we come to consider the control of any activity and when we come to try to make any sort of plan in relation to any industry, any undertaking, or any section of the community, the plan must be a balanced one and we must have due advertence to the fact that every element in the community, including the people who find their livelihood in the service of their fellow citizens whether as hotel workers, as amusement workers or as builders or manufacturers catering for those trades, has a right to live in this country the same as everybody else. We cannot, by closing down on their legitimate activities, deprive them of their livelihood, cause them to be disemployed, and drive them, perhaps, out of the country to another country where they will find a ready demand for their services. It would be indeed a short-sighted policy if, to cater for one section of the community we were to beggar other people and cast out of employment good citizens, law-abiding citizens, industrious citizens, who are making their livelihood in a perfectly legitimate way catering for the pleasures as well as the needs of their fellow citizens.

These, Sir, are some aspects of the problem which I would like those who have been making such a catch-cry of this rather tendentious phrase "luxury buildings" to turn over in their own minds, because when they talk of that, I hope that those who hear them will consider what they are going to say to the waiters, chambermaids, waitresses, boots and all the other people who find employment in Irish hotels, what they are going to say to the electricians, usherettes, operators and all the other people engaged in the cinema industry who find their livelihood in catering for the amusements and pleasures of the people in a perfectly legitimate way. Let those people who are talking in this way and who are creating public prejudice remember that these are all enterprising people who want to make their wares more attractive to the public and that the critics of the Government are saying to them: "Shut down and turn your employees out of a job". I know very well that a number of trade unions in the City of Dublin have no sympathy with the gentlemen who are making slick political propaganda out of that catch-cry.

Sir, in the course of the debate I was very considerably intrigued to find that the sober critics of the Opposition Benches who have criticised this Government because they have been spending too much money and who have cried out that we have imposed too heavy burdens on the people were almost unanimous, indeed were unanimous, with the exception of Deputy Coburn, in demanding that we should give greater grants for everything to everybody in this Bill. The generous grants which have been given are not considered sufficient by the members of the Opposition. Deputies Hughes, Blowick, Byrne and the rest tell us that we are not giving enough. They will tell us that now when we are conferring real and substantial benefits on the people, but when the bill is presented at the end of March and people are called upon to raise the funds by the next Budget to pay for it, then, of course, the cry will go up from the Opposition Benches about these squandermaniacs who are in control of the Government. The very gentlemen who have been pressing us to spend more money yesterday evening and to-night will be the first to condemn us because more money will have been spent and more funds will have to be found, because of the generous assistance given in this Bill to private individuals to build houses for themselves. Then we will not hear any demands to raise the grants. The gentlemen who are Phillip drunk to-night will be Phillip sober then.

Comment on this

You will not be over there then; you will be over here on this side.

Comment on this

You will not be here at all then. I do not know where I will be and neither does the Deputy. I am certain when the people are given the choice between us and those people who blow hot and cold, who say one thing to-day and another to-morrow, who get up in the House and slander all round them and then run away from it outside, the people will realise that they now have a Government composed of men of character and reputation and they are not going to select any alternative that will be offered to them at the next general election.

Comment on this

What does "slander" mean to you? Look up Chamber's dictionary.

Comment on this

The meaning of slander to me is very much more pregnant and very much clearer than it ever has been to the Deputy. I do not want, Sir, to go back and remind the Deputy of what he said about other people including myself under the shadow and shelter of this House. I was merely pointing out that the very people who have been complaining about the alleged inadequacy of these grants are the people who are going to condemn us when we have to raise the money to provide those grants.

In the course of the debate, the suggestion was made that, because in our system of grants we were differentiating between houses with a piped water supply and sewerage and houses which lacked these facilities, we were in some way discouraging the installation of piped water and sewerage facilities, by giving larger grants to houses equipped with these very facilities. Now, Sir, that only indicates the sort of warped mentality which characterises most of the members of the Opposition. I should have thought that the plain significance of the fact that we were giving £50 more to people who propose to equip their house with piped water and sewerage facilities is that we were at least encouraging the installation of those amenities which are now regarded as ordinary facilities.

Comment on this

The phraseology of the measure states, where piped water supply and sewerage facilities are available, and not where a person proposes to put them in.

Comment on this

But a person can make them available. Is there anything in the Schedule or in this Bill or in any administrative decision which a Minister has given here in respect of any housing Act which would prevent a person from putting in a septic tank, providing himself with piped water supply from a well and equipping himself with a storage tank? Deputy Sheldon perhaps, probably like some other Deputy may be misled. If there is any doubt in the mind of any Deputy as to what our intention is in that regard we shall clear it up on the Committee Stage with a suitable amendment. The purpose, in fact, of this differentiation is to encourage people to provide themselves so far as they can with the proper sewerage facilities. Not only that. We know that in many places such provision as they may make in present circumstances is likely to be a temporary expedient. They must have a source of water supply close to hand. They must utilise it in the best way possible and they must adopt the expedient of a septic tank as a substitute for a water-borne sewerage system. Deputies should not forget that we people work to a plan and work to a design. We do not go along improvising from one day to another, just trying to think out some sort of cheap stunt that will appeal to the popular imagination at a particular time: We have already set up a technical committee consisting of persons who are technically qualified, in association with persons who have experience of administration, to investigate the practical problems involved in the provision of a piped water supply for the rural areas in this country. As a corollary to that and in association with it we have also set up another committee which is investigating the feasibility of disposing of our local sewage in a particular way.

In anticipation that something fruitful will emerge as a result of these committees we are, naturally, endeavouring to direct the attention of those who are going to build houses in rural areas to the necessity for equipping them with a piped water supply and proper sanitary arrangements. I hope that those Deputies who have spoken critically about this differentiation will recast their opinions in that matter and will realise that, contrary to their contention that we are discouraging the rural community from providing their houses with these essential arrangements, we are going very largely out of our way to encourage them to do so.

We now come to the question of the size of the grants. There have been many complaints that the proposed reconstruction grants are not adequate. There have been other complaints that we have not met the need of every person who feels that he wants a modern, up-to-date house. I suggest that, after all, we ought to look at this problem in a rational way, as rational people. The origin of the Housing Acts was for the purpose of providing houses for the homeless. It is just as much the personal obligation of an individual to provide himself with a house as it is in the case of food and clothing. He should not expect his neighbours to build a better house for him than they can afford to live in themselves. Therefore, in relation to these matters, some curb must be put upon those who would demand extravagant expenditure in regard to the provision of houses. We cannot all afford to live in mansions. We have got to suit our housing accommodation to our own purses and, when the community is providing housing accommodation for some sections of the population, then the cost of the accommodation has to be conditioned by the general resources of the community. There is not a bottomless purse out of which we can draw. We have to have regard to the conditions under which the vast mass of people in this country have to live and have to provide themselves with houses.

When I was introducing this Bill I pointed out that we had something over 600,000 houses in this country and that since 1932 we have built or reconstructed 140,000 of them. That is to say, about 23 per cent. of the total number of houses in this country at the present day have been built or reconstructed under the régime of this Government and they have been built or reconstructed very largely at the expense of the taxpayers of this country. But there is a limit to what the taxpayers can, in justice, be asked to pay. We cannot go on heaping amenity after amenity upon that one section of the population for whom these Housing Acts were intended. We have got to remember the people who have to buy houses for themselves at the ordinary economic prices, or to rent houses for themselves at the ordinary economic rents. We have also to remember that, while we are taxing men in order to reduce the rents for others, they have to provide out of their own resources for their own needs. Therefore we must, as I have said, look at this not from the point of view of trying to secure a little public favour, not from the point of view of catering for the demands of only one section of the people, but as men who have to hold the balance fairly and evenly between all sections of the community—between those people who pay and get no benefit as well as those who are going to secure advantages under this Act. I think that having due regard to all the demands that are being made on the taxpayers of this country at the present moment, upon the producers of this country at the present moment, the scale of grants envisaged in this Bill is as generous as it would be reasonable to ask for.

That leads me to the question of the retrospective grants. I will concede at once that there may be very hard cases, arising from the fact that the limiting date in this Bill in regard to the occupation of houses is the 1st of November. But, push that date back, and you are not going to get rid of hard cases. Make it the 1st July and you will have some person who began to build his house in the middle of June. Make it the 1st April and there will be somebody who began to build in the middle of March. Make it the first day of this year and you will have some person who began to build last year. Go back to last year, and you will have some person who began in 1945. Where are you to stop once you depart from this simple principle that when people began to build their houses under the existing code they did not expect any more than the existing code would allow them to get and you did not induce them to start building by promising them larger grants? They were content to build. I am not going to deny that many of them have been driven to build by hard necessity but, whether they were coerced to build by hard necessity or whether they built under much less compulsion, at any rate, when they started to build they knew what they were going to get under the existing housing code and, therefore, we have been guilty of no breach of faith in regard to them. Before we come to consider this question of making the Bill apply retrospectively to houses that were built before the actual acceptance of the principle of the Bill by this Dáil, we should have to consider at what logical point we should draw a line once we depart from the date that has been fixed in this Bill.

That is something that I have not heard any Deputy who has asked that the limiting date should be pushed back address himself to. We cannot deal with this question arbitrarily. If I am going to have some other date than the 1st November of this year, then I must find some reason why I should take that date rather than some earlier date and some reason which will justify me standing upon that date prior to the 1st November rather than upon a date still earlier. I confess that, though, as I have said, I have a great deal of sympathy for the man who began to build his house, if you like, a little bit prematurely from the point of view of this Bill, but not at all prematurely from the point of view of his own personal need, I find it very difficult to see how I am going to depart from the date which has been put into this Bill. However, that, perhaps, is a matter which may require some further consideration.

Then, again, we had critics of this Bill who condemned it because we were said to be imposing too narrow a restriction upon the floor area. As I pointed out in introducing the Bill, our housing ambitions are being thwarted by reason of the fact that there is an acute shortage of materials and of labour. We are launching a programme which will embrace no less than 100,000 houses and, if we are returned to complete that programme, then the Fianna Fáil Government will have built or reconstructed over 250,000 houses during the periods that it has been in office. We are at the moment envisaging the construction of 100,000 houses and we cannot get materials and we cannot get labour at the present time which will enable us to build, or to have built, under these Acts more than between 3,000 and 4,000 houses per annum. If we are going to enlarge the size of the houses which we are building by increasing the floor space, what are we going to do? We are going to have larger houses and more comfortable houses, certainly, for the people who are going to be lucky enough to get them, but we are going to build very much fewer houses and we are going to condemn people who are already in grevious need of a house to continue to live in their present uncomfortable, undesirable and unsocial conditions. I think we would not be justified, for the sake of benefiting the 10,000 or 20,000 people who might be lucky enough to get in early and to get houses, under this Bill, in reducing the number of houses which will be available to the other 80,000 who are clamouring for them at the present moment. Therefore, I cannot see how in equity or how on any ground of social justice we would be justified in expanding or increasing the floor area which we are insisting will be the maximum floor area within which a house must be built if it is going to qualify for this grant. At least I say this: I cannot see that we would be justified in expanding it in any significant way.

Personally, I have a great deal of sympathy for those people who say we should not restrict the floor area to its present value, that we should allow people to build houses of perhaps 1,500 or 1,600 square feet and still qualify for the grant. I have a great deal of sympathy with that view — a great deal —but, on the other hand, I have to have regard to the fact that the larger the standard house we build the fewer houses we will be able to provide for the people in this period of scarcity and of shortage and, therefore, notwithstanding the sympathy which I have for those who will want a larger house, I must say that, in present circumstances, I think the limit which we have fixed on the floor area of the house is a generous one and one which ought to be received with general satisfaction.

The proposal contained in the Bill that the corporations of the county boroughs and the borough of Dun Laoghaire should be required to provide a certain number of houses for reserved classes of applicants has been generally welcomed in principle by Deputies but, of course, there have been one or two Deputies who, rather than give a welcome to any innovation or any new development upon the part of the Fianna Fáil Government, have been concerned to try to distort and to misrepresent to the people what the intention is. As I pointed out in my opening statement, newly-married couples have found in the City of Dublin, in present housing conditions, great difficulty in finding separate houses and separate housing accommodation for themselves. That is nothing new. I remember when I was married that we had precisely that problem to contend with. I am sure I was not unique in that respect and I am sure it has been the universal experience of people who got married since 1918 and had to live here in the city.

The problem has become more acute by reason of the fact that, in latter years, the marriage rate has gone up and, despite all the lamentations which we hear about the depressed condition of the people of this country, about unemployment, the difficulty of living here and the high cost of living, more marriages have taken place in Dublin over recent years per thousand of the population than there have been, I think, for over fifty years. So far as the marriage rate is concerned, it certainly contradicts and controverts all the sort of propaganda we have had to listen to over the past twelve months or so. Because of this fact that the marriage rate has increased, naturally, newly married people are finding it even more difficult than before to secure houses.

This has been giving me a great deal of concern for a very long period and ultimately I came to the conclusion that, after all, it was primarily the duty of the local community at least to facilitate its own renewal and its own maintenance, and that the local authorities in these large cities where the problem is most acute and most extensive should be required to provide housing accommodation for those who are newly married and who are likely to find difficulty in securing it for themselves. In doing that, I had to consider the resources of the local authorities on the one hand and the availability of building supplies on the other hand, and as a background to all this the acute housing shortage in our large communities. I had to realise that, if we were going to build houses and reserve them for newly married couples, the building materials would only be made available for those houses at the expense of those who had large families, who had been longer married, who were already ill-housed and living under unsanitary and undesirable conditions.

As well as that, I took into account the fact that we were going to cater for young people who were going to establish a home for themselves. I wanted the homes to be as up-to-date and as modern as they possibly could, so that the young housewife would start off under the most favourable conditions, that she would be presented with a modern up-to-date house, easy to run and easy to live in, comfortable for her husband and her children. It was not intended that they should continue to live there for the remainder of their days. The houses would have to be economical in size, so as to reduce as far as possible the demand upon the limited supplies of materials available. They had to be limited in size because they were going to be built, some of them entirely at the expense of the local authority, which would have to charge an economic rent for them, and some of them subsidised by the Government but which, nevertheless, would carry rents higher than those which we might expect the heads of large and growing families or adolescent families to pay.

Therefore, we decided that the houses, while being modern and up-to-date and in every way desirable, should be limited as to their bedroom accommodation — that, in fact, only two bedrooms would be provided. Now, two bedrooms are quite sufficient for a young married couple starting off in life, as they do not have to segregate their children according to sex and they can continue to live in them very comfortably and very happily for a limited number of years. Therefore, because other people would be getting married as the years pass and would be wanting houses, and since we can provide only a limited number of houses in any one year, we had to decide that the initial tenancy would be for a limited period, but not for a short period, and the limit which we have notionally fixed — and it may be extended or it may have to be curtailed slightly — is five years. Now, if we provide newly married couples with good modern houses and give them, if they are satisfactory tenants, a five-year tenancy, surely in that five years they can look out for a larger house as their children are growing up and their families becoming larger?

I do not think there is anything in the point which has been made here by some Deputies who insinuated that we were going to take those people in at the beginning of one year and turn them out at the beginning of the next. Such a proposal, of course, was far from our minds. We have to remember that while there will be from 2,000 to 2,500 people getting married and looking for these houses, in any one year, in every year fresh people will come along looking for them. In the City of Dublin, so far as our present building capacity goes, we cannot build any more than 300 of them. We had to have regard to that factor and, therefore, we will have to say to the prospective tenants: "We will give you your chance and a fair start in married life, by providing you with a good house and we will give you five years within which you can get another and larger one." We are also imposing on the corporation the obligation of providing in their normal housing programme a sufficiency of houses at the end of five years, into which these young married people can be transferred and where they can settle down to make a permanent home if they so desire.

As I have said at the beginning, this is entirely an experimental approach to what is a very serious problem. I hope that the experiment will justify itself. I hope that the corporation of the City of Dublin — which has passed many resolutions demanding that special accommodation be provided for newly married people — will take up this proposal with enthusiasm and sincerity and will help, at any rate, to solve this very pressing and acute problem. If the experiment justifies itself in the larger boroughs, we shall have no hesitation whatever in applying it to other urban areas. Remember, in that connection, that this proposal is very different from the other proposals in this Bill, because this proposal requires the local authority to provide the houses. The other Housing Acts and this Housing Bill give grants to provide houses, but the local authorities will get grants here only in respect of houses which I may describe as class B houses, houses intended for industrious people, who notwithstanding their industry and constant employment, nevertheless could not afford to pay the economic rent which a house of the type I have envisaged and have in mind would carry.

The only other matter that I want to deal with is one that was raised by Deputy Byrne and Deputy de Valera. They referred to the possibility that regulations made under sub-section (1), paragraph (e) of Section 25 might be used to set aside the effect of the judgment in the case of Boland v. the Dublin Corporation. The Deputies have suggested an intention which never occurred to me. I do not propose to interfere with the decision of the court in that matter. The decision, as the Deputy must know, was based on the failure of the corporation to stipulate in the least that the house should be sold only to a person belonging to what are commonly described as the working classes which, in fact, all of us might be said to belong to. I have no intention of using the power which I have to make regulations to effect a legal decision on any question.

Deputy Anthony seemed to criticise me because I proposed to facilitate local authorities who endeavour, in existing circumstances, to carry out housing schemes by direct labour, and seemed to suggest that, in some way, I was reflecting on the efficiency of private enterprise. Well, I am not. I am a believer in private enterprise, but I must face facts, and I have been compelled to conclude that, in present circumstances, the private house-building industry is not able, and has not the capacity, to meet the demands which have been and will be made upon it. Therefore, because we cannot have the local authorities calling for tenders, and calling in vain, in order to get ahead with housing projects which are absolutely essential, I have decided that the only thing to do is to cut the Gordian knot and allow local authorities to go ahead and, where they decide to do it, carry out their schemes by direct labour. I will certainly look on their progress with a very critical eye. I will look on it with a critical eye and a searching eye but at the same time without bias, and if the experiment in that regard justifies itself we may go even further than I contemplate at present. But it is as well for those who are engaged as private undertakers in the building industry to realise that henceforward so far as local authority schemes are concerned they are not going to have the field entirely to themselves: that they will have to go in now and compete with local authorities in certain cases.

Comment on this