We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1947—Report Stage (Recommittal) and Final Stages.

Contributions 1–141 of 276. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1947
Enacted

No. 33 of 1947 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

In page 4, paragraph (a), line 3, to delete "and any urban district" and in paragraph (d), to delete "the commissioners of such town" in lines 10 and 11, and to substitute "except as respects Sections 14, 19, 20, 21 and 41 of this Act, the commissioners of such town, and, as respects the said sections, the council of the county in which such town is situate".

This amendment is in part a drafting amendment designed to clarify the relative positions of the county councils and the town commissioners as housing authorities for the purpose of the Bill. The town commissioners will in effect exercise control over demolitions and so forth of habitable houses, and will if the necessary powers are extended to them by Order, regulate tenements or "multiple buildings". They will also exercise all other powers vested in "housing authorities" by the Bill, except those reserved to county councils by this amendment.

Comment on this

In as far as Section 14 is removed from the jurisdiction of the town commissioners I presume that that they will not in any case let houses which are affected by Section 14.

Comment on this

Section 14 here is for the purpose of securing information from tenants of local authority cottages and houses. They do not.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:—

In page 5, line 51, and in page 6, line 4, to delete "tenement house" and substitute "multiple dwelling" and to insert immediately after "situate" in line 55 "and such permission shall not be unreasonably withheld."

Comment on this

This is interesting. But, Sir, it is not an amendment at all.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What happened in the amendment was that, when they were drafting it, there was only a copy of the Bill as it had gone through here available. It has been reprinted since and that has upset things. I am correcting it now. There are, I think, a few of them in which the numbers are wrong. This is one of them. At any rate, when the Minister refers to this substitution of "multiple dwelling" for tenement house it will be quite clear. It was discussed.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Do I understand this amendment to mean that the Minister is just starting into Section 11 introducing "multiple dwelling" instead of tenement house?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is so.

Comment on this

If I were allowed to explain, I could clear the matter up.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Minister rose that would be the simplest thing.

Comment on this

There are a number of Deputies here who seem to want to conduct the business of this House, despite the Minister or anybody else.

Comment on this

Now, who are you talking about? Is it Deputy de Valera—or who is affected?

Comment on this

Are you keeping order in this House, Sir, or is it Deputy Dillon?

Comment on this

I am trying to curb your rudeness.

Comment on this

I do not propose to speak or to try to conduct the business of this House if Deputies are not kept in order.

Comment on this

I do not care a hair whether you speak or whether you do not.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I certainly did not see the Minister rise. The Minister should be in first.

Comment on this

I am not referring to the conduct of Deputy de Valera. I am referring to the continuously disgraceful conduct of Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

On a point of order, we have in front of us an amendment which is perfectly unintelligible. You have attempted to clarify it, but it is still not clear. Certainly I have not grasped the import of the amendment.

Comment on this

On a point of order, if I might attempt an explanation, it merely means that in Section 11 instead of the words "tenement house" read "multiple dwelling". I think that is all.

Comment on this

I am preparing to inform the House as to this amendment as soon as I am certain that I shall have an opportunity of being heard without interruption.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister has that opportunity now.

Comment on this

Oh, paeans of praise for his kindness.

Comment on this

This amendment, Sir, is in two parts. The first part deals with a question raised by Deputy Dockrell on the Committee Stage of this Bill in which he raised the point that objection might be taken by some people in possession of a certain type of property to have that property described as a tenement house. The purpose of this amendment is to substitute for the phrase "tenement house" the phrase "multiple dwelling". I should have thought that would have been intelligible, even to some of the Deputies who have spoken here.

Comment on this

It would be more so——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

Particularly in view of the fact, Sir, that it was at their instance the amendment was made. The next amendment is designed to meet the point made by Deputy de Valera on the Committee Stage and to convey to local authorities a statutory admonition that their permission is not to be unreasonably withheld.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

On that point again, purely as a matter of draftsmanship, a "multiple dwelling" in Section 11 is being substituted for "tenement house". That is to meet an objection made by Deputy Dockrell. Now, a tenement house is already defined in sub-section (3). Do I understand that multiple dwelling will also be substituted instead of tenement in subsection (3)? It would be a consequential amendment, but is it provided for?

Comment on this

It is provided for, as you will discover if you look at amendment No. 2.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Now, which amendment is it? I am still in a difficulty in trying to co-relate these amendments. If "multiple dwelling" is substituted in Section 11 a consequential amendment is necessary in sub-section (3). I have not examined the Act to see whether any other consequential amendment is necessary.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

In other words, what is the definition of "multiple dwelling"?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I presume it is the same as "tenement house" in the original.

Comment on this

This, as I have already said, on the Committee Stage, is a perfect "Marie Antoinette" approach to housing. First of all, it is laid down specifically that people must not set their houses in tenements and that the local authorities, in certain circumstances, may tell them that they are not to do so, quite oblivious of the fact that the only reason the house is a tenement house is because the unfortunate people who are living in the sordid rooms available have nowhere else to live. This point having been taken by our modern "Marie Antoinette", his contribution is: "Very well"—if they have to live in a loathsome tenement at the foot of Dominick Street let us mitigate their suffering by calling it not a tenement but a "multiple dwelling". That will greatly relieve the stress of their circumstances. So long as we do not mention tenements, we do not have to worry about them. Are we not travelling in this House along a most extraordinary road? These two sections are designed to prevent the spread of tenement conditions into new parts of the city.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not dealing with sections, Deputy. We are dealing with an amendment to substitute "multiple dwelling" for "tenement house".

Comment on this

Certainly, Sir. But we must at least know the necessity for this legislative euphemism. Picture Marie Antoinette——

Comment on this

Must we listen to so much "blah-blah"? Can we not get on with the business.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

"Marie Antoinette" rhymes with "Marionette" which has a close affinity with something else!

Comment on this

Picture these champions of the poor. They are so distressed at the thought of people having to live in tenements that, like their prototype, they lift their skirts so as to avoid the contaminating mud of "tenement" and reassure the public that the poor in this city are not living in tenements; they are living in "multiple dwellings". Hypocrisy is a disgusting vice.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is not an election platform.

Comment on this

Oh, Sir. "Multiple dwelling" is hypocrisy, if ever there was such a thing.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I suggest the Deputy talks to Deputy Dockrell about it, then.

Comment on this

Let us call a spade a spade. "Multiple dwelling"—let us all commit those words to memory. Let us go down to the foot of Dominick Street and stand in front of the tenements there——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is quite out of order in discoursing upon Dominick Street.

Comment on this

I am objecting, Sir, to the insertion of the words "multiple dwelling" in this Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

One does not require to go down to Dominick Street in order to do that.

Comment on this

In my respectful submission, I know what a tenement is. Most people in the City of Dublin know what a tenement is. How many people know what a "multiple dwelling" is? The Fianna Fáil Party seem to consider that, if you go to a stinking tenement and change its name, you change its nature. I am suggesting that they should go down to some of these tenements, stand in front of them and tell them they are not tenement houses any longer, that they are "multiple dwellings", and see would it make any difference to the smell or the dirt or the dereliction. I am tired of listening in this House to supporters of the present Government——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is irrelevant.

Comment on this

I am talking about "multiple dwellings".

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not.

Comment on this

If the Deputy can make any sort of speech he likes at any time, the Ceann Comhairle had better leave the Chair.

Comment on this

He offended the dwellers in these houses by calling them stinking, smelling people.

Comment on this

I say that the tenement houses of this city are stinking, loathsome abominations.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with this amendment.

Comment on this

We propose to relieve that condition by changing their name.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is a complete misrepresentation. The name was in this Bill initially. The Minister had "tenement house" in the Bill first. Deputy Dockrell pointed out a certain objection he had. The Minister tries to meet him and you try crookedly to capitalise on that. It is positively dishonest. Let us get down to this Bill as a Bill and not play the histrionic politics you are playing. You did not come in here to address yourself seriously to the business of this House in Committee.

Comment on this

Is this in order? This silly man, intoxicated by the fact that he bears his father's name, imagines that he can shout down the members of this House. Dismiss that idea from your mind. No one is going to shout me down. No one is going to prevent me——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must deal with this amendment.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the question of the substitution of the words "multiple dwelling" for "tenement house"—amendment No. 2. The sole and only purpose of that amendment is to substitute "multiple dwelling" for "tenement house". Surely I can dwell on that procedure. That is the amendment. There is nothing more in it. I have a right to speak in this House, at my discretion, on that particular problem.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Within the rules of order.

Comment on this

Within the rules of order. I am bound to assume that the Minister put this down mainly for the purpose of literal clarification. I am entitled to submit that it is put down in a Marie Antoinette way——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not repeat himself. We have had that four times.

Comment on this

——which characterises almost everything the Minister does. To still the conscience of people who would be perenially solicitous so long as tenements survive——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is again repeating himself.

Comment on this

——but who may be made agreeable to their survival if we strip them of their familiar, detestable description we begin to describe them, for the first time in my lifetime at any rate, as "multiple dwellings". What merit does the Minister allege attaches to the adoption of a legislative euphemism of this kind? If people intend to allow their house property to be employed for the purposes that we have always associated with tenement ownership in this city, why should we, by law, give them the right to free themselves from the title of tenement owners and adopt, by statute, a description of proprietors of multiple dwellings? Let those who want to live out of the rents of rotten tenements——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is rambling again.

Comment on this

I submit——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not submit. I am stating what I believe to be a fact.

Comment on this

Does this create a new description for a tenement owner?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not here to answer questions or to be crossexamined.

Comment on this

I submit that this amendment will create a new title for tenement owners. Heretofore, there has existed a class of people whom we have known as tenement owners and, with very few exceptions, such persons have not had a very favourable reputation amongst their neighbours. This is a proposal to give them a new and unrecognisable title. What merit does the Minister allege for that?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is again repeating himself.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister if he has any argument for this amendment beyond saying that it gives effect to a proposal made by Deputy Dockrell. Surely the Minister must defend it on its own merits. I want to hear what the Minister has to say, not what his tempestuous echo on the back benches thinks he ought to say.

Comment on this

I should like, first of all, to raise a point of order. Here is an amendment on the Report Stage which, as it stands, is meaningless. Of course, we can all understand what is intended. I think the Minister will have to bring in an amendment to this amendment. I leave that in your hands, Sir. I want to get down to the meat of the amendment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order. I am not responsible for the wording of amendments.

Comment on this

I am pointing out to you, Sir, that this amendment is meaningless as it is here and when read in connection with the Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I gave the House the correct figures and lines, because there were mistakes made in four amendments, as nothing but the unrevised Bill was before the officials when they were putting in the amendments. I gave the correct lines here in the House and I shall give them again if the Deputy desires to have them.

Comment on this

Perhaps that is a small point. I shall proceed to the substance of the remarks I wish to make. I am obliged to the Minister for having, in response to my remarks, substituted the words "multiple dwelling" for "tenement house". But that really was not the substance of my objection, which was that, under the description "tenement houses", two utterly and distinct classes of dwellings come in and can be classified as similar. We all know what a tenement house is and what a flat is.

Comment on this

On a point of order, surely the Deputy is proposing now to discuss the general purpose of the section?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The section does not arise. The question is whether such a building is to be called a multiple house or a tenement house.

Comment on this

I am trying to point out to the Minister that while I appreciate the apparent gesture he has made in response to my remarks in Committee, he has missed the obvious distinction which I made.

Comment on this

Again on a point of order, it was made quite clear—I am putting a point of order and I should be obliged if the Deputy would allow me to submit it—in the debate on the section, that this section was intended not merely to apply to what are known as tenement dwellings but also to houses let as unfurnished flats. That was made quite clear and I submit it has been already decided on the section. Therefore, if Deputy Dockrell intends to proceed on the lines he is now following and to argue that flats as such should be excluded from the amendment, he is out of order.

Comment on this

If the Minister would have patience to listen to what I am going to say, he would be better able to appreciate the point I am endeavouring to make.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If relevant to this amendment.

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is what I want to hear but the section is not open to discussion.

Comment on this

I have said that whether the description be "tenement house" or "multiple dwelling", whichever you like to call them, the two classes of dwellings were included under the one heading and the ordinary person has no difficulty in differentiating between these two classes of houses, namely, tenement houses and houses let in flats. That is the sum and substance of what I am getting at. The Minister is going to a great deal of trouble and is putting local authorities to a great deal of trouble and annoyance in differentiating between certain flats that are no more tenement houses than this House is. The Minister invited the other evening some definition which would distinguish the two classes but I should like to remind the Minister that a tenement house occurs like a disease. It seems just to become a tenement house. Nobody christened it, changed the name, altered the structure or did anything like that; it just became a tenement house. As I have said, no one in this House would have the slightest difficulty in differentiating between a tenement house and a flat. I should like to suggest to the Minister that a flat is a place that has a closed hall door.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. That is the classic difference.

Comment on this

Wait a bit until I proceed a little further. The next question is: would the occupants possess a lock and key?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The point is that the amendment before us is whether you are going to have the words "tenement house" or "multiple dwelling". I have not heard the Deputy argue that matter.

Comment on this

I am trying to point out to the Minister that he has made a distinction without a difference.

Comment on this

It is not intended to make any difference. The House has already decided that this section will apply equally to flats and tenement houses.

Comment on this

I do not know if the House did decide that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, the House decided that yesterday and there is no amendment to it.

Comment on this

Perhaps they were right. I suppose the Oireachtas has no right to do wrong, but it does seem as if local authorities all over the country will be burdened with the task of differentiating between certain classes of dwellings. In my opinion if the definition here were more precise and better clarified, it would enable them to reduce their work and possibly obviate a certain amount of annoyance to people who are not tenement dwellers and who do not live in tenement houses. That is the substance of my objection to the Minister's amendment as introduced. He says: "I do not care whether they are flats or tenement houses; they will have to be registered and I shall call them `multiple dwellings'. You have got to trot down to the City Hall every year and register your house."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on this amendment.

Comment on this

It would be quite possible for me to withdraw this amendment.

Comment on this

In view of the wrong construction of Deputy Dillon——

Comment on this

And of Deputy Dockrell.

Comment on this

——and the hypocrisy of Deputy Dillon's suggestion——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister should withdraw it.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the hypocrisy of Deputy Dillon is to be visited on Deputy Dockrell——

Comment on this

Why not repudiate it?

Comment on this

It is like visiting the sins of the father on the children. I have made my point. Apparently I am quite wrong in thinking that the Minister was endeavouring to put the owners of flats outside the scope of this Bill. That is the point I intended really to make. If there is no substance in that, let the Minister state that openly and clearly, namely that dwellers' flats will have to be registered just the same as tenement houses and the local authority will have the trouble of going through whole streets composed of houses let in flats. That is the substance of my objection.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Deputy Dockrell is probably aware of what led to the introduction of this term but it does not arise and he cannot reopen it. We are strictly confined to the question of tenement houses. The important point in regard to the insertion of the phrase arises really in the definition sub-section, sub-section (3) in the light of which the amendment in sub-section (1) must be read. Clearly whatever type of house or dwelling the provisions of sub-section (1) are to apply to, it is a premises let in parts to form two or more dwellings. After that it is a question of the name you call it. The Minister in the original draft inserted the words "tenement house" which in my submission and in my view would most nearly accord with the ordinary legal phraseology and from the purely legal draftsmanship point of view, was probably the best way. It was pointed out to the Minister in Committee—I think Deputy Dillon was not here at the time.

Comment on this

Troth, I was.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It was pointed out that there was some difference, that Deputy Dockrell wished to draw a distinction between flats and tenement houses. In that way attention was drawn to the fact that "tenement house" has a more localised popular meaning. It is obviously intended that both types—in other words, any type of premises let in parts like that—have to be captured by the provisions of this section. Therefore, if you are to keep the words "tenement house", used in the popular sense, and if you want to differentiate them from flats, a term will have to be sought to include both. I think it was better drafted as it stood but, if you want to embrace both, some phrase will have to be thought out. I believe "multiple dwelling" is as good as any other.

The essential point to be noted, the point of substance is that the section captures both the tenement house, as colloquially so-called, and the type of house with which we associate a tenement house together with flats; in other words, any house sub-divided between separate tenants and subtenants. Perhaps the amendment is preferable, but I do not see very much difference between them.

Mr. Dillon rose.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has spoken at length on this matter and I think it rests with the Chair to determine when a matter has been sufficiently discussed. In deference to the Chair, I moved that the Bill be recommitted for the purpose of reconsidering certain amendments. It was not necessary to recommit the Bill to consider this particular amendment. I submit, therefore, that the Chair should exercise its powers to ensure that the Bill, having been recommitted, advantage will not be taken of the situation to abuse the privileges of this House.

Comment on this

Imagine the little bumpkin!

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That expression is not quite parliamentary.

Comment on this

Has the Chair heard the observation?

Comment on this

Everybody heard you.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon is running true to form.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The House heard Deputy Dillon calling the Minister "a little bumpkin".

Comment on this

Do you deny you said it?

Comment on this

At the request of the Chair I withdraw the remark. I desire to draw attention to the fact that in choosing a word for the purpose of this statute which will identify the most fashionable flats in Pembroke Road with a tenement house in Dominick Street, Lower Gardiner Street or Meath Street, we have lighted upon the delicious euphemism of "multiple dwellings". It has been suggested by the Minister that he might now withdraw this amendment and revert to the words "tenement house". I am all for the Minister withdrawing his amendment. I understood Deputy Dockrell to suggest the use of these words "multiple dwellings" under the impression that a distinction was being made between the luxury flat and the Dominick Street tenement room. The Minister is now emphatic that he does not want to make any distinction, that he never did want to make any distinction but that he thought the words "multiple dwelling" sounded more euphonious in the ear of Deputy Dockrell than "tenement house". Deputy Dockrell and I were both born in Dublin and we are familiar with tenements.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Deputy is repeating remarks he has already made.

Comment on this

Deputy Dockrell and I have both been born in the City of Dublin and are familiar with the appearance, the aroma and the disgusting inadequacy of tenement houses as housing for the poor.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not think the Deputy is contributing anything new to the discussion. I do not think he is saying anything that he has not said before in the very same form.

Comment on this

I assure you I am. The word "tenement" to us and to anyone who understands the city has always connoted something. The words "multiple dwelling" connote nothing. You do not change bread into cake by calling bread "cake"; you do not change tenement houses into flats by calling them "multiple dwellings". I exhort the Minister to eschew the role of Marie Antoinette, to be a realist for a little while and to withdraw this amendment and restore to its rightful place those words of evil omen, "tenement house", until such time as they cease to exist, not as a result of an obliterating statute but as a result of the provision of adequate houses for those who are festering in the tenement houses. When that is done, there will be no need for euphemisms like multiple dwellings; tenements will be no more than a memory and the flats will be something to which no one can take exception, for which no one ought to be compelled to register at the City Hall, and which the local authority ought not to have power to prohibit. Then the necessity for these sections will disappear and any diminution of the powers of the bureaucrat to regulate them is welcome. I want to see the day speeded when that diminution will take place. I do not want to see the day dawn when we can still our conscience in this House by changing the name to something the existence of which we are ashamed to admit.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:—

In page 6, line 8, to delete "in their absolute discretion".

This amendment is consequent on the preceding amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:—

In page 6, line 26, to delete "twelve months after that date" and substitute "such period (not exceeding three years) as the housing authority may determine".

This amendment meets the point raised in Committee by Deputy O'Connor that the annual revision of premises used as a multiple dwelling could be made a triennial revision and this empowers local authorities to give permission to the owners of such a house for three years.

Comment on this

Does this provide that anyone who owns a tenement is excused from an annual examination of the premises which would ensure that it was kept in a reasonable state of repair? At the first flush, the Minister said that it was desirable, at least as far as tenement houses as we commonly understood them were concerned, to have an examination by public officials at annual intervals so as to ensure that the inhabitants would not be unduly exploited.

Comment on this

It provides nothing of the sort. As the Deputy claimed to be here during the discussion on this particular section he can refer to the report.

Comment on this

If we are going to have impudence, we must resort to the classic method of imposing good behaviour on those who wish to be impudent.

Comment on this

Is this in order? Several times to-day, while we were discussing this amendment and previous amendments, Deputy Dillon seemed to suggest that any remark made by the Minister with which he did not agree was impudence and I would like to know is it in order for him to say that the Minister is giving impudence when in fact the position is reversed?

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Dillon asked the Minister whether certain things applied and the Minister replied that they did not.

Comment on this

I am discussing this question and I intend to discuss it for a considerable time. I have watched carefully the attempts which have been made by means of a series of points of order to get the Chair to prevent me from speaking. It is a perfectly Parliamentary expression to describe the rejoinders of the Minister as impudent.

This amendment is designed to abolish an annual process and to substitute a triennial process. I think that any Deputy of this House on the occasion of such a proposal is entitled to ask the Minister for reassurance that the triennial operation will prove adequate. Prima facie, the fact that the Minister proposed that it should be an annual operation would suggest that when he and his experts examined this matter they made up their minds that an annual operation was necessary. We are entitled to assume that they did not do that for fun, that they did not do it for the pure joy of poking their noses into other people's business, but that they did it because they thought that some public benefit would be gained by making it an annual operation.

Now the Minister says that in deference to Deputy O'Connor's proposal he is bringing in an amendment to make it triennial. Why? Is the triennial proposal sufficient? If it is, why did he propose an annual examination? Surely the Minister has a duty upon him to justify himself if he wants to amend his own proposal. Surely it is not a justification to say that Deputy O'Connor suggested this and that, therefore, this is what we are going to do. Justification is what I am now asking and refusal to give it is impudent.

Comment on this

I do not know how far we are conducting this discussion with any sense of reality. In regard to the second amendment——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That has gone now.

Comment on this

I know it has gone. I know it is, but the point is that it is boshed. Let us be frank. You have to read it in the light of previous Bills. Amendments Nos. 2 and 3 have been passed. "In page 6, line 3"——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Line 8.

Comment on this

We come down to amendment No. 4 now.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Has the Deputy got it correctly now?

Comment on this

Line 26.

Comment on this

The paper says line 21.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is what was already corrected.

Comment on this

With great respect, I submit that the Chair did not tell us that the rest was all wrong.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair did correct amendments Nos. 3 and 4.

Comment on this

The Chair only corrected amendment No. 2 as far as my theory——

Comment on this

The Chair is not responsible for the Deputy's theory.

Comment on this