We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1947—Report Stage (Recommittal) and Final Stages.

Contributions 142–276 of 276. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1947
Enacted

No. 33 of 1947 ›

Leave it to the Minister. Let him hang himself.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know now that it is line 26?

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Line 26, page 6 is in the amendment we are now discussing.

Comment on this

Are there any further alterations?

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are dealing with amendment No. 4 at the moment.

Comment on this

The Minister has brought in a proposal here——

Comment on this

The Deputy has spoken already. I was waiting for Deputy Dockrell to finish to rise.

Comment on this

Rise away.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon thinks that there is no one in the House but himself. He is so used to listening to his own blah-blah.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

No personalities.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has been getting away with personalities. He has raised a row because on the Committee Stage the Minister for Local Government was considerate enough to listen to arguments against having an annual inspection and for having a triennial inspection. Because he takes notice of reasonable arguments put to him in the House and puts down an amendment, Deputy Dillon finds fault with him. He wants this House to be conducted as a dictatorship. Deputy Cogan asked had we heard of such a person as Hitler. This is a democracy and this is a democratic institution. A previous amendment was made to meet representations made in the House by Deputy Dockrell and this amendment was made to meet representations made by another Deputy, but now Deputy Dillon finds fault and says that he must have an answer. He argued that because an annual inspection was laid down in the Bill as it was originally drafted it should not be altered. I disagree entirely with this point of view and I hope that Ministers will continue to follow suit as the present Minister is doing in being prepared to make reasonable amendments to a Bill as a result of reasoned arguments made to support them.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I think, perhaps, that I might be able to shed some light on this as I was actively involved in the discussion. The facts are very fully set out in the reports for such Deputies as were not present on the discussion on the amendment in Committee. I, among others, urged the Minister to have the licence in force sine die.

The Minister had his arguments for the section as it stood. Another Deputy suggested a compromise solution. The Minister, having listened very fully to arguments from both sides of the house — and both sides of the House took part in the discussion —said he would consider the matter. He now gives a very middle-way solution. I would still like to have pushed the matter as far as I was pushing it on the first Committee Stage but the Minister had his answers to my argument. He has now tried to meet the situation. From that point of view this amendment seems the most reasonable he could bring in to suit the case. For instance, my objection in connection with the annual licensing is largely answered by this amendment. It also preserves some of the points the Minister himself made in support of his own draft. No further explanation is necessary.

Comment on this

As the person responsible for handing in the original amendment perhaps I may be allowed to say a word. Deputy Dillon seems to have got hold of the wrong end of the stick.

Comment on this

He always does.

Comment on this

I feel it would be unduly harsh on the owners of flats or multiple dwellings to have to go for an annual revision. I suggest that a provision should be inserted to provide for discrimination where a dwelling would obviously not necessitate revision. I am satisfied the Minister has gone a considerable way to meet my point by inserting "such period not exceeding three years", which, of course, is a very different thing to "twelve months after that date". I presume that, in respect of what are strictly tenement houses, a regulation will be made demanding annual revision.

Comment on this

Why do you presume so?

Comment on this

If Deputy Dillon will now wait until I develop my argument perhaps he will know what I am getting at. My only objection is that there is no provision in this section to enable the Minister to make regulations. I would suggest that the Minister should strengthen the operation of this sub-section, as it would be amended by this amendment, by inserting a new sub-section giving himself power to make regulations. I do not like the idea that it should be left entirely to the housing authority to decide which types of multiple dwellings shall be inspected annually and which trienially.

Comment on this

Am I concluding, Sir?

Comment on this

No, it was recommitted.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is so.

Comment on this

I am afraid, Sir, I shall have to ask you to consider the matter. At the request of the Chair and in order to facilitate the work of the House, I pointed out that there was a considerable number of these amendments which it would not be necessary to commit. The Chair suggested that it would be more convenient if we recommitted the Bill in respect of all the amendments so that we should not be moving in and out of Committee. I am sure the Chair will recognise that it might be necessary to go into Committee for the purpose of discussing certain amendments. In view of the fact that the Bill has been recommitted, at the wish of the Chair, and that the Chair has full discretion to bring the debate on any one of these amendments to a close, I am asking you, Sir, to exercise your discretion in that regard and not to permit the debate on these amendments to be unnecessarily prolonged by permitting Deputies to repeat themselves or speak more than once on any amendment.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair, having made a decision to commit all the amendments, cannot at this moment change the procedure. As far as the discussion is concerned, Deputy Dillon has put a question to the Minister that needs to be answered to finish the discussion on this particular amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon was not, I suppose, present during the debate on the Committee Stage of this section. He is definitely well aware, as he has indicated himself, of the circumstances which led to this amendment. I propose to address myself to the point which has been made by Deputy Sheldon.

I do not think it is necessary for me to take power to make regulations under this section. The section was introduced at the urgent request of the housing authorities in the larger boroughs, particularly in the City of Dublin. They wanted to have power to make the annual inspection and to give a yearly permission to allow the house to be let to more than one family, for use in parts as two or more dwellings—a yearly permission. I can meet the case which was made for the better-class flats where such an inspection would be considered by the housing authority to be unnecessary.

Comment on this

We have now all become inflamed with a great solicitude for the flat provider. Poor darling, he is not to be upset by the necessity for an annual registration. You would imagine that these warriors were down-trodden struggling citizens — a gang we know to have bought up a multitude of houses in this city, very largely at scrap prices. They converted these houses into what they called flats and are now squeezing out of the unfortunate families that inhabit the flats immense wealth. That is one class of owner we are considering. The other class is our old friend the tenement owners. A difficulty has been created by the lumping together of these two classes of dwellings. The prior interest is unquestionably the most vulnerable people, and the tenement dwellers are desperately vulnerable. If it is the Minister's policy to lump the flats and the tenements together that is his business, but if they are to be lumped together, then on his head be the inconvenience caused to flat owners. I think the flat owner is getting quite enough out of his flats as it is without showing him any further special consideration.

What I am thinking of is the tenement dweller who is paying 5/- or 6/- per week for the two-pair back because he has no where else to go. The local authority comes in and licenses the tenement house on condition, under sub-section (2) paragraph (a), that the owner carries out repairs and reconditioning. Now, under the Bill as introduced by the Minister, the local authority had a right to go back at the end of the year and, when that tenement owner came for his re-registration, to say: "Show me that you carried out the repairs and the reconditioning that you undertook to carry out when we gave you the registration last January" and, if he has not carried them out, the local authority can proceed to withhold the permission to use the house as a tenement house for the profitable——

Comment on this

They can still do that.

Comment on this

It is done by inspection, Deputy.

Comment on this

For the profitable purpose it is intended. What is the object of the triennial inspection? Are not the flat owners, God knows, well enough off as it is? Will it not be an added safeguard to the poor living in tenement houses to have an annual inspection and to have on the 1st January that threat hanging over every tenement owner?

Comment on this

There is nothing to prevent that.

Comment on this

There is nothing to prevent that, but I want to make it mandatory. If you had lived long enough in this city you would know that the tenement owners of this city pull no little weight. It has been a struggle for the past 50 years—oh, for much longer than that. I remember hearing them talked about when I was a boy. I was born and reared in the city. The Deputy was not. I have heard the problem of how to grapple with the tenement owners discussed long ago. When you tracked the tenement owners down how often did you discover to your amazement who they were? They were quite influential people. If there were an option given to the local authority to examine them only once every three years, or once every year, considering some of the boys I know who own tenement property in this city, it would be a "bould" city manager who would refuse to exercise his discretion and give them a triennial examination instead of an annual one.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Is this a fair attack on the city manager?

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy does not know what he is talking about. He does not know anything about the tenement situation in Dublin.

Comment on this

It makes me laugh, Sir, to look at some of the "tulips" who are lecturing me about tenements in this city. I have forgotten more about the tenement problem in this city than the Deputy ever knew.

Comment on this

We are attending to it every day of our lives trying to get rid of the slumdom we inherited from the friends of other people.

Comment on this

And one of our methods is to call tenements "multiple dwellings". Over-night the whole problem has disappeared. They are now multiple dwellings.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That has already been accepted, Deputy.

Comment on this

I prefer the proposal made by the Minister when he introduced the Bill; that is, that there should be a mandatory annual inspection as a condition of the renewal of the licence. The Minister alleges that he has given way on that to accommodate the flat proprietors. The flat proprietors—what section of this community has grown richer more rapidly than the flat proprietors? Is it not notorious that they have doubled and trebled and quadrupled their incomes in the last few years? Why are we all so solicitous for fear the flat proprietors would be inconvenienced, upset or disturbed? If, in defence of the tenement dweller, we made it mandatory on the licensing of property to have an annual examination I would have been very well prepared to have a distinction made in regard to what is commonly known as flats in one category, on the ground that the tenants of flats are usually fairly prosperous people well able to look after themselves, whereas the tenants of tenement rooms are usually poor people, habitually exploited and peculiarly defenceless.

If that had been practicable I would have been prepared to consent to a triennial examination of flats provided there is an annual examination of the tenement rooms. But, if I am to choose between equating the tenement room to the flat and stipulating for the tenement rooms a mandatory annual inspection because of its aristocratic association in this Bill, and inconveniencing the poor, harassed, distressed flatowner in this city, then I elect for inconveniencing the poor, distressful flat-owner, in order to ensure that the tenement owner will be harassed, disciplined, inspected and compelled to carry out the conditions provided for in his licence; and that we shall continue to harass, control and compel him until such time as we can take appropriate measures to banish his kind for ever from our midst. I exhort the Minister to revert to his own proposal. The House ought to know that the Minister came in here fortified with the advice of people who have been studying the housing problem in this city from the point of view of the exploited tenements. Their preference, born of their experience, was for mandatory annual inspection.

Comment on this

There is nothing to prevent it at all, and they have it.

Comment on this

There is no power under this Bill to provide for a mandatory annual inspection. There is a permission to have an annual inspection but there is no compulsion to have it. As the Bill first came before us it was a mandatory provision that there should be an annual inspection. Do any Deputies in this House stop to ask themselves why the Minister's advisers stipulated for that? Was it for fun? Was it because their experience of the tenement problem lead them to believe it was necessary? Of course it was because their experience of the tenement problem lead them to believe it was necessary. I do not give a fiddle-de-dee for the flats. Let the people who live in flats look after their own interests. What concern is it of ours? Why should we interfere in their business? I do not give a fiddle-de-dee for flat owners. What business is it of ours? They are well able to look after themselves. My concern is for the tenement dweller and it is the only category of persons provided for in this euphemistic multiple dwelling which ought to concern this House. We have no right to go round as busy-bodies poking our noses into the business of flat holders and flat renters. Let them look after their own business.

Comment on this

Do you want it every year instead of every three years?

Comment on this

No, I do not. My sole concern is for the tenement room dweller. I do not care a hoot what happens in the flat.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think you are going outside the amendment. It is a very simple one.

Comment on this

The amendment is to substitute a triennial examination for an annual one. I want an annual examination of tenement rooms.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is not that a very simple issue?

Comment on this

God knows, it is; but it throws the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party into hysterics and shrieking rage in order to prevent me saying it. I do not care what device you invent to achieve this end, but you ought to put back the proviso that was in this Bill. I believe that if Deputy O'Connor was responsible for moving the Minister to this change he ought to search his conscience. A change of this kind may be justified in regard to flats, but does Deputy O'Connor honestly say to me that he believes a change of this kind is desirable or good in respect of tenement houses, as he and I understand that term? Does he not agree with me that it would be an immense boon and blessing that every tenement owner in this city should be fixed with notice that, if he wanted to go into that business, he would be faced with the knowledge that he would remain in it only so long as he retained his licence to operate the house as a tenement house, which would be renewable annually and only after inspection? I challenge Deputy O'Connor to say that he does not think that would be a good arrangement. If he does, will he join with me in telling the Minister so?

Deputy O'Connor rose.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The amendment has been discussed sufficiently.

Comment on this

With regard to the personal insinuations of Deputy Dillon——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not think there was anything personal in them.

Comment on this

I assure Deputy O'Connor that I insinuated nothing.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:—

In page 6, Section 12, after sub-section (5), to insert the following new sub-section:—

(6) A person aggrieved by the refusal of a housing authority to grant permission under sub-section (1) of this section or by a condition attached to the permission may appeal to the Circuit Court, within one month after he has received notice from the housing authority of such refusal or of such condition (as the case may be), or such further time as the court may allow, and the court may—

(a) in the case of an appeal from a refusal to grant permission— dismiss the appeal or order the housing authority to grant permission;

(b) in the case of an appeal relating to a condition attached to the permission—dismiss the appeal or order the housing authority to modify or annul the condition.

This gives the right of appeal to the Circuit Court by a person who feels aggrieved by the refusal of the housing authority to grant permission under sub-section (1) of this section.

Comment on this

On amendment No. 3 I thought the Minister said it was consequential on something that went before. Do not amendments Nos. 3 and 5 hang together? Is it not rather that No. 5 is consequential on No. 3?

Comment on this

No. No. 5 is an entirely new provision giving the right of appeal. No. 3 was to delete the words "in their absolute discretion."

Comment on this

I thought it had some connection with the right of appeal.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

I think this amendment was brought in to meet a point raised by Deputy de Valera. The Minister, I think, in his defence of the existing conditions, that the appeal would be to him, mentioned that a person could appeal to him with very little cost. I think that appealing to the court in this case is liable to cost a good deal.

I do not wish in any way to say anything about the Circuit Courts. I am sure they would deal with the matter very fairly, but they would not have the knowledge that the Local Government Department have in dealing with these matters. I would prefer it as it was originally.

Comment on this

It is rather a pity that Deputy Dockrell and those who take objection to this amendment did not make their objections on the Committee Stage, because, as reported in column 494 of the Official Report, I said the position might be met if we inserted a proviso "that the permission should not be unreasonably refused, and if we were to give to a person who felt that the permission had been unreasonably refused a right of appeal to either the District Court or the Circuit Court. In present circumstances that is as far as we could go to meet the objections raised by Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy de Valera."

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I think the Minister has very fairly met us on that point.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:—

In page 6, line 42, to delete "tenement house" and substitute "multiple dwelling".

This is consequential on the amendment which Deputy de Valera thought it might be necessary to make in view of the amendment we were making to Section 11.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In page 7, line 10, immediately after "whatsoever" to add, "excluding temporary allowances from any charitable organisation".

This is to meet Deputy Sheldon's point.

Comment on this

On amendment No. 7——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 7 has been agreed to unanimously. There was no objection to it.

Comment on this

I assure you I object.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 8.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

In page 7, Part II, after Section 14, line 27, to insert the following new section:

15.—A housing authority shall have the like powers of making and enforcing by-laws respecting houses containing not more than two rooms and intended or used for occupation by members of the working classes which are occupied by not more than one family as are conferred, under Section 20 of the Housing (Ireland) Act, 1919, on the local authority of an urban district or town in the case of houses intended or used for occupation by members of the working classes which are let in lodgings or occupied by members of more than one family and the provisions of the said Section 20 shall have effect as if such by-laws were made under that section.

The object of the amendment is to enable the housing authority to make by-laws with respect to one-roomed or two-roomed houses occupied by single families.

Comment on this

Will the Minister inform us why he deemed it desirable to introduce this provision by way of a new section on the Report Stage rather than on the original Bill? Has something transpired since the original Bill was drafted which made this desirable?

Comment on this

There was an amendment down for the Committee Stage in the name of Deputy Doyle which this amendment is proposed to meet.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:—

In page 7, after Section 15, to insert the following new section:—

16.—(1) The Minister may, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, and subject to regulations made under this section make, out of moneys to be provided by the Oireachtas, to any person or public utility society erecting one or more than one house, a grant not exceeding the appropriate sum specified in the Third Schedule to this Act if—

(a) erection commenced on or after the 1st day of November, 1945, and is completed on or before the 1st day of April, 1950;

(b) such house or houses complies or comply with the rules set out in the First Schedule to the Act of 1932;

(c) such house or houses was or were not occupied on or before the 1st day of November, 1947;

(d) such house or houses is or are occupied when completed by

(i) in case such house or houses is or are erected by a public utility society—a member of that society,

(ii) in any other case—the person who erected such house.

(2) A grant under this section together with a grant under Section 5 of the Act of 1932 as amended by any subsequent enactment (including this Act) shall not exceed the appropriate sum specified in the Third Schedule to this Act.

(3) The Minister shall not make a grant under this section in respect of a house in respect of which he is prohibited from making a grant under sub-section (3) of Section 5 of the Act of 1932 as amended by Section 4 of the Act of 1937.

(4) The Minister may make regulations for the purposes of this section.

On the Second Reading of the Bill and on the Committee Stage a strong appeal was made from all quarters of the House for making the new housing grant retrospective. This amendment provides that the grants payable to persons and public utility societies for owner occupation will apply to houses commenced on or after 1st November, 1945, but not occupied on 1st November, 1947. I indicated that I would bring in an amendment more or less on these lines but that, in view of the great variety of cases which might have to be covered, I would not propose to give the full amount of the grants originally provided for in the Bill. This amendment accordingly proposes to give grants equivalent to 70 per cent. of the grants originally proposed.

Comment on this

I was one of those who appealed to the Minister to make this grant retrospective. I do not know what the Official Report will convey, but I am not aware that the Minister said that he would give a lesser grant than was provided in the original Bill. There is one point to which I would like to draw the Minister's attention. There appears to be no provision for any improvement of the reconstruction grant.

Comment on this

I am afraid that the Deputy has not read the list of amendments.

Comment on this

This is a provision for the payment of moneys for houses built before this Bill is passed. I know it is a very popular position for all sides of the House, but nevertheless I am bound to say that I consider retrospective provisos of that kind to introduce an extremely dangerous principle. If you are going to authorise the whole community to anticipate legislation of this House and to build houses without inspection, authorisation or anything else and then, when a Housing Act is brought in, clamour sufficiently loudly to get the provisions of the Housing Act although they have not manifestly complied with the conditions, you are introducing a principle the end of which I think is extremely hard to foresee. Has it ever happened before? Has this House ever passed a Housing Act which imposed certain preliminary duties on grantees before qualifying for a grant and then inserted a paragraph providing that those who anticipated the Bill and complied with none of the conditions shall get their grant retrospectively in part?

Subject to that note of warning I want to renew to the Minister for Local Government a representation which I made on the Second Stage of the Bill. If we are going to hand out public money to public utility societies, as you are going to do under this amendment, you should be certain that the public utility societies are genuine and that they will honestly serve the individuals whom they purport to serve. I therefore suggest that the Minister should at some stage for the purposes of his Bill and of the housing code generally, declare that the words "public utility societies" will mean societies to be scheduled by him annually as public utility societies in good standing. I know at the present time the surveillance of public societies is the responsibility of another Minister altogether, the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I venture to suggest that the approach of that Department to the public utility society problem is entirely remote from what the approach of the Minister for Local Government would be. So far as public utility societies under the sphere of interest of the Minister for Local Government are concerned, they would be mainly of the building society character, which would exist primarily to assist people who require assistance.

The well-established public utility societies of this country, I believe, would regard themselves as trustees with all the liabilities of trustees, morally at least, for their members. But there are societies down the country which to my knowledge have acted with grave impropriety and from which to this day grantees find an interminable difficulty in getting money. I do not want to abolish good work. There may be some good societies in rural Ireland. What I want is that the Minister would conduct an annual survey of the different utility societies and strike out of the annual schedules only such ones as he believes are not performing their duties faithfully. I think that is a reasonable request. I do not believe that there is a Deputy in this House who does not know that is a necessary precaution that should be taken for the protection of the grantees of housing grants down the country. I suggest to the Minister that if he does that, he will do someing really useful to restore confidence in the minds of many people who have at present legitimate grounds for serious apprehension.

Comment on this

I have nothing further to say except to correct one or two misapprehensions under which Deputy Dillon seems to labour. First of all this is not creating a new precedent so far as housing finance is concerned. It does, in fact, follow the example of the 1924 Act in giving retrospective effect to certain of its provisions in relation to grants. It is giving retrospective recognition to the fact that a great number of people who began to build houses after the 1st November, 1945, met with unexpected difficulties in trying to complete their undertakings. I shall accept Deputy Cogan's statement that I did not precisely state how I was going to deal with the situation but I think if the Deputy reads the statement I made on the matter, as reported in column 570, he will certainly see there that I mentioned a number of considerations, including the fact that building costs in 1945 and 1946 did not show any very great increase over building costs in earlier years. It was only, in fact, in the spring of 1947 that a sharp upward trend in building costs began to manifest itself. No doubt my amendment was meant to be a comprehensive one to deal with the situation but it had to be designed to deal with the general average situation and not with particular cases of extreme hardship. That was quite clear when I said that I would bring in an amendment which I thought would go far to meet that particular situation. I added "at least it will go as far as I am able to go." It seems to me that that was a clear indication of the fact that I was not prepared to go the whole hog and to give everybody who began to build a house after the year 1945, whether he began to build in the beginning of 1945 or in the beginning of 1946, the same consideration as was given in the Bill to those who began to build in November of this year when, in fact, the rise in building costs was substantial and undeniable.

I do not want to follow Deputy Dillon into the question of public utility societies. There is no reason to believe that public utility societies in general are dishonest——

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this

——or are maladministered.

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this

——nor were they brought into existence by the Housing Act, 1932, nor was recognition first given to them as house-building agencies in the Act of 1932. There were specific grants for public utility societies in the Act of 1925, and there was no closer supervision exercised over public societies in the year 1925 or in the year 1931 than in the year 1932. There is perhaps closer supervision over them now than ever there was under the régime of our predecessors. In any event, what we have to recognise is that they have performed a very useful function in providing houses for the people. Under the Act of 1932 public utility societies, between them, have built about 16,000 dwellings, and the great majority of them have given satisfaction. Of course, there may have been a few societies which were inefficiently managed, a few societies which were poorly administered, but I have not yet had brought to my notice, by Deputy Dillon or anybody else, a public utility society the officers of which have been guilty of fraud or any criminal misconduct.

Comment on this

I can tell you of one or two in County Louth.

Comment on this

If the Deputy has that information, he certainly has withheld it from the responsible Minister.

Comment on this

Nonsense, it was dealt with ten years ago.

Comment on this

The Deputy has withheld the information from the responsible Minister.

Comment on this

It was dealt with.

Comment on this

If the Deputy knows of public utility societies, during the period of my tenure of office as Minister for Local Government, which have been badly administered or dishonestly administered, or the officers of which have been guilty of dishonest conduct, all I can say is that he has withheld that information from me.

Comment on this

It was none of your business; it was the business of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

If it was none of my business, the Deputy has made it my business, because there has not been a debate on a Housing Bill over the period during which I have been Minister that the Deputy has not risen to attack the Government by implying that political supporters of the Government have formed themselves into public utility societies, have been facilitated by the Government in doing so, and that in administering these societies they have been guilty of malversation or the criminal conversion of public funds. That has been the common statement of the Deputy upon every Housing Bill that I have handled. Now the Deputy has to admit that he has never brought to my notice any information which he may have in his possession which would enable me to investigate his statement and prove for myself and the House whether it was founded or unfounded.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that public utility societies, by law, have every year to submit an audited account to the Registrar of Friendly Societies, an account audited by a chartered accountant, and is not that a sufficient check on any irregularities that may arise? So far as I know, public utility societies have performed a very useful function in districts that I know in County Limerick and I resent very strongly any reflections being cast on decent, honourable, upright men by Deputy Dillon, as far as Limerick is concerned. I do not know anything about any other county.

Comment on this

The Minister knows perfectly well that it is no part of the functions of his Department at the present time to supervise or control public utility societies. They come under the control of the Department of Industry and Commerce. My suggestion is a perfectly simple one and it is not made in a vindictive spirit. I do not withdraw one scintilla of what I said about Fianna Fáil clubs being turned into public utility societies.

Comment on this

It is widely done, but this is a matter which I am not interested to pursue at the present moment.

Comment on this

Why not name them?

Comment on this

He has not the pluck to do that.

Comment on this

The Deputy has the shelter of the House if he wishes to do it.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the precautions necessary to ensure that the funds distributed under this Bill will reach the intended beneficiaries.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am afraid the Chair has been lax in allowing public utility societies to be discussed.

Comment on this

I am not discussing them.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The object of this amendment is to define the conditions under which these associations or persons get certain advances.

Comment on this

Surely I am entitled to ask the Minister to take the necessary precautions to ensure that this new section, which deals with grants to persons and public utility societies, will be operated in such a way that the grants will reach the intended beneficiaries? There is no need for Deputies to get hot under their collars. My proposal is that the Minister should schedule the public utility societies.

Comment on this

Why did you not put down an amendment?

Comment on this

I could not tell you, but it was not passed.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The amendment was not discussed.

Comment on this

It was not, and the Deputy knows that quite well. I want the Minister to put the accolade of his approval on it by saying that these societies are well run and are trustworthy bodies. That is all I want him to do and there is no need for Deputies to get vexed. There are a few survivors that are not being properly run and the people who get their grants through them are suffering. I want to see nothing functioning but a well run society and I want the Minister to arrogate to himself this, saying: "The Minister for Industry and Commerce has his own machinery and I do not want to interfere there at all. I want to see that the funds for which I am responsible will be distributed only to public utility societies that I am satisfied are functioning the way I want them to function; that is, for the benefit of their members." Is there anything provocative or criminal in that proposal?

Comment on this

You have changed your tune.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no amendment to the effect that the Minister should supervise these societies or take power to do so; they are under the jurisdiction of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

That is the trouble. I am putting it to the Minister for Local Government that, answering to this House for these moneys, he should take some power to enable him to certify that any money he passes out reaches the people meant to get it. There is no Deputy on the Government Benches who does not know it is necessary, yet for some obscure reason they will not admit that.

Comment on this

I think the Minister has gone a long way to meet the House in this amendment. When the matter was discussed before it was supported from all parts of the House. I do not think Deputy Dillon was present at the time.

Comment on this

Troth I was, and I never thought you would get it.

Comment on this

I am satisfied with this amendment, with the exception of one point, and that is paragraph (c), which sets out—"such house or houses was or were not occupied on or before the 1st day of November, 1947." As I mentioned on another occasion, many people, through dire necessity, were compelled to build and even to occupy houses before they were completed. If it is at all possible, and as the Minister has gone so far, I would like him to consider paragraph (c) and see if he could do anything better, though I must admit that he has done very well in regard to houses occupied before they are completed. That is the one point which I would like him to consider.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to give consideration and add to Section 16:—

"The Minister may with the consent of the Minister for Finance and subject to regulations made under this section, make, out of moneys to be provided by the Oireachtas, to any person."

I would ask to stop at the word "person". I have an inquiry from a young man which I cannot answer. A young man put down £500 a couple of months ago and entered into a contract with a builder to build a house at a fixed price. This young man, according to his inquiry, is worried whether, under the Minister's powers, the person to get the grant is the young man who ordered the house, but who did not erect it. It says here "erect" and I would like to insert the words "or ordered" after the word "erect". This young man is not a builder, so he will not erect, but he puts his money down and ordered a house through a builder. He is worried whether the builder erecting the house will get the grant rather than himself. I would like to have the matter cleared up. Judging the paragraph as it reads might lead to a legal decision, if the Minister did not say which he means to get the grant.

Comment on this

He is erecting it, for the purpose of the section.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

In page 7, after Section 15 to insert the following new section:—

"A grant payable, under paragraph (h) of subsection (1) of Section 5 of the Act of 1932, to a person reconstructing a house may be increased to £60 where—

(a) the person applied for the grant before the 1st day of November, 1947, and

(b) the reconstruction of the house was commenced but not completed before the 1st day of November, 1947."

This deals with reconstructions and gives an increased grant for houses where reconstruction was begun subsequent to the 1st of November and not yet completed.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is Deputy Sheldon moving his amendment?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:—

In page 8, lines 14 to 17, to delete paragraph (c) and substitute the following:—

(c) the person erecting the house undertakes with the housing authority that, subject to such conditions as may be prescribed by regulations made under this section, he will not sell the house and that he will let the house subject to such conditions as may be so prescribed.

This is to meet the case of a person who owns a house which is let and to let him dispose of his interests without converting the house into an owneroccupied house.

Comment on this

Would the Minister reassure me that in covering that he is covering the point which I was attempting to make by inserting "without the permission of the Minister and the housing authority"? I put that down on Committee and I was not here to move it. I think that it would more or less cover any cases of hardship which might arise. The difficulty would be that where there is an absolute prohibition to sell, cases of hardship might arise and even the Minister, with the best will in the world, could do nothing about it. I think that the hardship that might arise if there was absolute prohibition to sell could be got round.

Comment on this

I think that we could frame a regulation under this section as now amended to cover cases of hardship, but I wish to make this quite clear: we desire to exclude any possibility of a house which was let to a tenant being converted into an owner-occupied house.

I am quite prepared to allow a landlord to sell his interest in a house provided that the house remains a tenanted house and the main object of the regulations is to enable that to be done. I do not say that we could not frame a regulation to deal with cases of hardship; I would like to hear further argument on the question out I am not prepared to do it on this Bill. I think that there is something to be said for the point of view that Deputy Sheldon has put and it might encourage people to build houses if they felt that they could get rid of them if the necessity arose. On the other hand, we are not anxious to do anything which might reduce the pool of houses for letting.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister and that is why I suggest that the permission of both the Minister and the housing authority would have to be obtained. I thought that would be a pretty sufficient safeguard and I could not imagine anyone codding both the housing authority and the Minister. I think that when the Minister looks into it he could frame a regulation to cover cases of severe hardship.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to say that I could not.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

In page 9, after Section 17, to insert the following new section:

(1) The Minister may, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, and subject to regulations made under this section make, out of moneys to be provided by the Oireachas, to any public utility society erecting one or more than one house for occupation by a person of the working classes or an agricultural labourer, a grant not exceeding the appropriate sum specified in the Sixth Schedule to this Act, if—

(a) erection commenced on or after the 1st day of November, 1945, and is completed on or before the 1st day of April, 1950; and,

(b) such house or houses complies or comply with the rules set forth in the First Schedule to the Act of 1932; and

(c) such house or houses was or were not occupied before the 1st day of November, 1947; and

(d) such public utility society undertakes with the Minister that such society will not sell such house or houses and will let such house or houses only at such rent and subject to such conditions as may be approved by the Minister.

(2) A housing authority shall, subject to regulations made under this section, make, to any public utility society erecting one or more than one house in respect of which a grant is made by the Minister under sub-section (1) of this section a grant in money not exceeding the appropriate sum specified in the Sixth Schedule to this Act.

(3) For the purpose of making a grant under sub-section (2) of this section a housing authority shall have the like powers of borrowing money as if the houses in respect of which the grants are made were erected by them under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts or the Labourers Acts.

(4) The Minister may make regulations for the purposes of this section.

Comment on this

While I agree with the spirit of this, I would like a little matter cleared up for the benefit of public utility societies. Would not the Minister think it advisable to put in a period of years, 21 years if he likes? Suppose that the finances of a public utility society went a little wrong, as they have done on one or two occasions, and they wanted to raise a mortgage on the houses in order to continue their activities. I would ask the Minister to consider how this amendment will affect the finances of public utility societies if they want to enlarge on their operations or want to raise money through a bank with the house as a security.

Then you have a subscriber living in a house for a number of years who wishes to pay off what is due. Will the Minister consider allowing him to do this if he improves his position and wishes to have his house a little cheaper for his growing family?

Comment on this

I do not propose to relax the terms of this section in any way. If a public utility society wants to raise additional sums I suppose that they could get the bank to lend to them on the security of the houses even if the houses were let. If a public utility society wants to build houses for sale they can do so and get a grant under another section but not under this section.

Comment on this

Would it debar them from raising money on property in hand?

Comment on this

There is nothing to debar them if they can get anybody to give it to them.

Comment on this

They could raise it on the rent.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13A:—

In page 10, line 13, to delete "four" and to substitute therefor "five".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:—

In page 10, to delete lines 14 to 19, and substitute the following:—

(1) The Minister may, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, make out of moneys to be provided by the Oireachtas grants to a housing authority providing houses for occupation by persons of a class specified in regulations made under paragraph (b) of sub-section (1) of section 25 of this Act, but no such grant shall exceed £250 in respect of each separate dwelling (whether a house or part of a house) so provided.

The object of this amendment is to meet a point raised by Deputy Doyle that local authorities should have power to provide reserved flats, as well as reserved houses, for recently married couples or persons about to marry.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14A:—

In page 10, lines 21 and 22, to delete "two hundred and seventy-five" and to substitute therefor "three hundred and forty-five".

This amendment is consequential on the amendment in Section 26 which was passed in Committee.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:—

In page 14, to delete Section 35, lines 15 to 19, and substitute the following:—

(1) Sub-section (4) of Section 9 of the Act of 1899, is hereby amended by the substitution for the words "and not reimbursed by the receipts under this Act" of the following—"because of the default of persons, to whom advances have been made, to repay instalments of principal or interest on such advances."

(2) Sub-section (1) of this section shall have and be deemed to have had effect as on and from the 1st day of January, 1942.

This amendment modifies the meaning of the term "expenses" in sub-section (4) of Section 9 of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act, 1899. The term will now mean in effect, arrears of principal and interest due by borrowers from local authorities under the Acts. The amendment is essential in order to make the Acts operative again.

Comment on this

Have we passed Section 19?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We do not deal with sections, Deputy. They are passed.

Comment on this

The amendment—are we on Section 19 now?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are on amendment No. 16, but we are not on any section.

Comment on this

It is on Section 19?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No section. It is not committee therefore we do not deal with sections.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:—

In page 18, First Schedule, third column, at the reference to "The Labourers Act, 1906", to insert "12" immediately after "10".

This amendment is necessary in view of the proposed removal of the rating limits for rural housing purposes imposed by the Labourers Act of 1883 as amended by the Housing Act of 1931.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:—

In page 19, after the Second Schedule, to insert the following new Schedule:—

THIRD SCHEDULE.

GRANTS TO BE MADE BY THE MINISTER IN CERTAIN CASES——

Person to whom grants will be made by the Minister | Where sewerage and piped water supply are not available | Where sewerage and piped water supply are available

Number of rooms in house | Number of rooms in house

3 | 4 | 5 | 3 | 4 | 5

or more | or more

£ | £ | £ | £ | £ | £

Person erecting house for own occupation | 87.10 | 122.10 | 157.10 | 122.10 | 157.10 | 192.10

Public utility society building house for occupation by member | 94.10 | 129.10 | 164.10 | 129.10 | 164.10 | 199.10

This sets out the maximum grants payable under the new Section 16.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:—

In page 19 to add at the end the following new Schedule:—

SIXTH SCHEDULE.

GRANTS TO BE MADE BY THE MINISTER AND BY HOUSING AUTHORITIES IN CERTAIN CASES——

Type of House | Maximum grant by Minister | Maximum grant by Housing Authority

£ | £

House with three rooms | 105 | 52.10

House with four rooms | 149 | 70

House with five or more rooms | 175 | 87.10

This sets out the maximum grants payable under the new Section 17, which provides for retrospective operation of the grants to public utility societies building houses for letting.

Comment on this