Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 6—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–158 of 487. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
It has been the normal practice to move the General Resolution following the Resolutions which implement the proposals in the annual Budget statement for the purpose of permitting a review of the proposals on the following day, when Deputies have had an opportunity to consider them. This is the General Resolution which is before the Dáil now and on it I want to amplify some of the remarks which I made yesterday on the Budget statement of the Minister for Finance and the specific proposals which he made to the House. As I understand it, the main charge, if I may so describe it, which the Coalition Parties make against the Fianna Fáil Government is that it was extravagant—extravagant in the sense that it embarked upon projects which, in their opinion, the country could not afford, or projects which, in their view, were undesirable, apart altogether from the adequacy of the country's resources to sustain them. That is a view which has been expressed on more than one occasion since the change of Government by the Minister for Finance. He told us in his first speech as Minister, and again yesterday, that in expressing that view he speaks not only for his Fine Gael colleagues but for all the Parties comprised in the Coalition. It is true that members of the other Coalition Parties, even those who are actually Ministers and consequently in direct contact with the Minister for Finance, do not appear themselves to have stated that view with any emphasis, but we must assume at least from their silence that they are in general agreement with what the Minister for Finance has stated on their behalf.
In view of these declarations by the Minister on behalf of all the Coalition Parties, it was of course assumed by Deputies of these Parties in the House, by their followers in the country and particularly by the newspapers that give them such staunch support, that the Budget would spotlight the extravagance of Fianna Fáil, indicate the particular projects which the Coalition Parties consider to be extravagant and undesirable, and which the Coalition was formed to prevent, and that the proposals of the Minister for Finance following his Budget statement would be designed to eliminate these extravagant or undesirable expenditures. We must assume that has been done. Certainly the Minister for Finance represented himself as having that task and apparently considers that he performed it. If I am wrong in that, perhaps I will be corrected. Until I am corrected, however, I shall assume that the economies outlined by the Minister in his Budget statement are those which, in the view of the Government and the Coalition Parties supporting the Government, were necessary to correct extravagance or to eliminate expenditures which, in their view, were undesirable.
What are these economies? The total of the economies outlined by the Minister was £5,500,000. That sum is made up as to £3,250,000 by the reduction of food subsidies, as to £1,000,000 by reduced expenditure on social services, as to £750,000 by economies on the Army Vote and as to £500,000 by a number of other savings, minor in importance so far as their cost is concerned, to which I shall refer later. In so far, therefore, as there was a view in the Coalition Government that the Fianna Fáil Government was extravagant, that its extravagance had to be corrected, that it was spending money upon undesirable services and that they had to cure the extravagance and save the money being spent, in their view, in an undesirable way, the Budget indicates that that extravagant and undesirable expenditure came under three main headings: food subsidies, social services and defence expenditure.
We are told that, in addition to these so-called economies which were announced by the Minister yesterday, there are to be further savings, further reductions of expenditure, amounting, it is hoped, to about £1,250,000 and which, until we are told otherwise, we must assume will be of the same character as those announced yesterday. If we are to have any useful discussion upon this policy of the Coalition Government, we must try to speak in language which each of us can understand. That means that we should try as a preliminary to get agreement on definitions. What do we mean by economy? Economy must be something more than the avoidance of expenditure. The ordinary meaning of that word is the elimination of waste and nobody would ordinarily use the term to describe the mere cutting down of expenditure, regardless of the value of the purpose for which the expenditure was effected. If a person came to the conclusion that he was living beyond his means, he would not be congratulated on his policy of economy and retrenchment if he solves his immediate difficulty by postponing the butcher's bill until next month and meets the grocer's bill by an advance on next month's salary. That, however, is the type of economy the Minister has decided to recommend to the House.
I said yesterday that some of the savings outlined in the Budget were fakes. Having examined the Budget statement, I have come to the conclusion that they are all fakes. There is not one genuine economy amongst them. There is not a single instance in which the Minister was able to say to the Dáil that the country will get the same service for less cost. That is what I mean by economy and that is what the ordinary person understands by economy. It is true that there has been an avoidance of expenditure, but in no case could that avoidance of expenditure be described as an economy. What expenditures have been avoided? The main saving is upon food subsidies. Of the £5,500,000 the Minister claims to save, £3,250,000 comes under the heading of food subsidies. Of the saving upon food subsidies, the most important part is the reduction in the Vote for the subsidy on flour. The possibility of that saving has been partly attributed by the Minister to the anticipated implementation of the International Wheat Agreement which was provisionally signed in Washington last February, but he is not claiming to have had any part in the making of that agreement. That agreement was under discussion during the whole of last year, beginning at a conference held in London in March, 1947, which was unsuccessful, and continued at the Washington Conference which assembled in January. I do not want to repeat what I said yesterday in that connection. It may be that that International Wheat Agreement will be implemented. If so, we will be glad. There will be a genuine saving to the country in so far as we will get the quantity of wheat allocated under the agreement at a lower cost than we had to contemplate on the basis of last year's prices.
There are, however, real dangers that the agreement will not be implemented. Apparently, the American taxpayer, having noted the proposals in the agreement and the general trend of world wheat prices, has come to the conclusion that the agreement could not be implemented without involving America in what would, in effect, be the subsidisation of wheat exports, and there is a disinclination in America to meet that charge. If that wheat agreement is not implemented, the savings on food subsidies which the Minister took into account in balancing his Budget will not be achieved. The rest of the saving—in fact some sum in excess of £2,000,000—is a mere postponement of the expenditure. Instead of meeting the cost of the subsidy in the present year, the Minister proposes to spread it over a period of five years.
He may have grounds for assuming that the cost of maintaining the present price of flour and bread through subsidy will be less next year or the following year than it is now. If not, he is merely, by this device, increasing the problem which he or his successor will have to face this time 12 months. Nobody, however, could describe the proposals of the Minister in relation to the flour subsidy as a saving. The possible reduction in the price of imported wheat is not due to any act of his. The postponing of a part of the cost of the subsidies to next year is a spendthrift device of which few people could approve.
The balance of the expected saving upon food subsidies is secured by increasing the price to consumers of tea, sugar, margarine and butter. Not all consumers of tea, sugar and butter will have to pay the increased prices, but some consumers will, and, by this device of increasing the prices, the Minister is reducing the cost of the subsidies hitherto paid upon these commodities to the Exchequer. In the case of butter, there is, in addition to the increase in the price to be charged to restaurants and caterers, a proposal to divert to the production of chocolate crumb for export some part of the milk supplies which might have gone into butter production. By that device, the amount of creamery butter available for consumption here will be less and consequently there will be a saving on the subsidy. I should like to deal with that particular project a little more fully later on.
In the case of social services, the Minister has the gall to present to this House, as an economy, a device for transferring the cost of the additional cash supplements paid to beneficiaries under the national health insurance scheme, the unemployment insurance scheme and the widows' and orphans' pensions scheme from the Exchequer to the insured contributors. Does any Deputy opposite believe that that is an economy? It is true that the cost to the Exchequer is reduced but it is reduced by transferring the burden from the shoulders of the taxpayers in general to the particular class of persons who are insured under these various social service schemes. I am not going to contend that at some stage the whole of our social service arrangements would not have to be tidied up. We contemplated tidying them up this year with the introduction of a comprehensive insurance scheme against all forms of undeserved want. That would, no doubt, have involved the disappearance of this cash supplement even though it was not intended by us that the total cost of the social service arrangements to the Exchequer would be reduced. We anticipated it might be increased. But we certainly would never have the audacity to present to the Dáil, as an economy, a proposal to transfer that particular charge from the Exchequer to the insured contributors to these funds.
The Minister also proposes to raid the widows' and orphans' pensions investment account. That fund was being built up by a series of annual contributions with the intention of ensuring that there would in the course of time be an investment income which would permit of the expansion of widows' and orphans' pensions without increased contributions from those insured under the scheme. By this device of making no contribution this year the date upon which the fund would be capable of meeting these larger pensions has, of course, been postponed. Again, that has been presented as an economy. No sensible person would attempt to describe it as such.
The third main item of reduced expenditure is the curtailment of expenditure on the Army. I referred to that yesterday. If Deputies opposite believe that this is a period in the world's history when it is sensible to save £750,000 on our defence services there is little I can say to convince them to the contrary. But it is folly. We all hope that a stage will be reached when small countries like ourselves can dispense with defence organisations. No one can contend that that stage has been reached now, and that this is a time when, for the sake of a comparatively small sum in relation to the total Budget, we can set out to destroy the efficiency of our defence organisation.
These are the Budget proposals. I said yesterday, and I repeat here now, that we are not interested in the Budget as a mere mathematical adjustment of State revenue to State expenditure. We are interested in the Budget as an instrument for achieving certain social and economic objectives. We examine this Budget for the purpose of endeavouring to ascertain what social and economic policy inspired it, what social and economic aims it is designed to achieve. I should have thought—and I still think—that in this House there would be general agreement upon the aims of social policy. There may not be agreement upon the methods adopted to achieve those aims. With regard to the aims we should set for ourselves and the purpose of any particular projects that might be discussed here we would, I am sure, find agreement as to what we desire. The aim of social policy must be to protect and, if possible, to raise the standard of living of our people and to provide out of the general resources of the community adequate protection against undeserved want.
Consider then the Budget in relation to those aims. The Budget raises the cost of certain essential foodstuffs. It expresses the Government's stand against any attempt on the part of the workers to compensate themselves for these higher prices through wage increases. There is, in fact, a threat, or a suggestion of a threat, that if there is a continuation of the present upward movement of wages the Government will consider reimposing the standstill Order. It makes no provision for the introduction this year of a comprehensive social services insurance scheme. The House is aware that the Fianna Fáil Government had intended to legislate for such a scheme this year and we had been led to assume by statements made by the Minister for Social Welfare that the Coalition Government would do likewise. The most we have been promised now is a White Paper before the summer. It is quite clear that the White Paper is merely a device to keep the public hoping. There is, in fact, in the Budget no provision for any such scheme before April, 1949. We must assume, therefore, that there is no intention to operate such a scheme before that date. I should have thought that not merely would we have had agreement upon the general aims of social policy but that equally there would be agreement upon the general aims of economic policy. It is true that there has always been and always will be far greater differences of opinion as to ways and means of achieving economic objectives than in the case of social objectives. I am sure, however, that most of us will accept the contention that the aim of economic policy is to make possible the achievement of our social aims by increasing the national wealth through expanded output from agriculture and from industry.
Again, examining the Budget in relation to that particular aspect of public policy, we find nothing in this Budget which is in any way designed to ensure an expansion of production of any sort except a general exhortation such as we have had on many occasions recently from members of the Government speaking in public. There is no positive stimulus offered to any class of producers. In so far as there is anything in the Budget at all, which appears to have a bearing upon the volume of industrial production, it is only a deterrent. The tax upon motor fuel must to some extent operate to increase the cost, and, therefore, reduce the volume of industrial output. If that is a fair comment on the Budget, then it is obvious that we can get from it no clear indication that it has been designed to serve any intelligible social or economic aims at all.
If we are to attempt to deduce from this Budget what is the economic and social policy of the Government we must take note of the following facts. Firstly, in the future, because of the Budget, the public will pay more for jams, margarine and oatmeal. They must reconcile themselves to enduring bread rationing for a period of five years. That, I assume, is the logical implication of the remarks of the Minister for Finance concerning the flour subsidy. We must reconcile ourselves to enduring sugar rationing for an indefinite period although we know that there are stocks of sugar in the country capable of maintaining an unrationed supply of sugar for eight months and that the world position in regard to sugar has changed radically, so that there is now no difficulty in obtaining whatever supplies may be required to supplement our own production on the basis of unrationed consumption. The only reason why we have to continue to ration sugar is because de-rationing it would either mean increased expenditure upon a price subsidy or an increase in price, and the Minister for Finance was not prepared to face either. I assume that we must also be prepared to do with less butter. The diversion of milk from creamery butter production to the manufacture of chocolate crumb for export must mean a lower output of creamery butter. The Government of which I was a member had an interest in the long-term development scheme for the production of chocolate crumb. We were responsible for the initiation of that development here, and we were anxious not to discourage it. We had to recognise, however, that in present circumstances, with creamery butter rationed and an insufficient milk production to maintain the output of creamery butter on an adequate scale, we could not permit of the unrestricted export of milk products and that the allocation of milk for chocolate crumb production had to be limited. The former Minister for Agriculture and myself came to an agreement as to the quantity of milk that could be made available for that purpose. The decision of our successors has been to increase that quantity of milk. That will earn certain sterling resources, but it means that we will have to be content with less creamery butter for home consumption.
In addition, the contributors to the social services must pay more in contributions for the benefits they will get. I think it is true to say that the contributors to these social insurance schemes would not object to moderate increases in their contributions for the purpose of getting additional benefits, but the device adopted by the Minister for Finance puts them in this position, that they will have to face a substantial increase in contributions merely to draw the benefits that they have heretofore been receiving. As I have already mentioned, the raising of the widows' and orphans' pensions through the operation of the investment account must be postponed.
The other indicator of Government outlook upon policy is the decision to reduce the Army. In return for all these burdens, and the risks which the Government are asking the people to take, we have got lower prices for wine, beer, tobacco and cinemas. I want someone to tell me what sort of social policy that scheme is designed to implement. If there is a social policy someone should be able to explain it; to me it is unintelligible.
Comment on this
I do not know if Deputy O'Leary is aware that the Minister is making a profit by his manipulation of the social services.
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, the Fianna Fáil Government contemplated, under their scheme of social services, an increase in old age pensions. Deputy O'Leary is under the impression that this Budget provides more money for social services. Actually, it provides less.
Comment on this
Who will pay it? First of all, the contributors under the national health scheme, the unemployment insurance scheme and the widows' and orphans' pension scheme.
Comment on this
On the contrary, the Minister is taking £500,000 from the contributors to these social insurance schemes, £450,000 from the widows' and orphans' investment account, and he is giving back £600,000 in the form of increased allowances to old age pensioners and promises a revision of the means test.
Comment on this
Let us examine not so much what the Budget contains as what it does not contain. It does not cover the social insurance scheme about which the members of the Labour Party spoke so often during the election and since. The Minister for Social Welfare spoke about it within the past week. There is no provision in the Budget for any such scheme during this financial year. There is another striking omission. The little group of politicians who control the teachers' organisation and its funds spent as much money in the campaign to oust Fianna Fáil from office as did the publicans. Why should the publicans get all the benefit? Since the change of Government the publicans got everything they asked for. They were given a reduction in the duty on beer. Not satisfied with that, they kept on advertising in the papers to get a reduction in the duty on wines. They got it.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I submit it is not in order for a Deputy to make an attack on individuals who are not in this House. When he refers to a small group of politicians controlling funds there is the implication, from the manner in which he spoke, that these funds are not being properly used. He should name the people to whom he is referring.
Comment on this
I am saying that the funds were used. We all know that during the election campaign the newspapers day after day carried advertisements directed against the Fianna Fáil Government and paid for out of the funds of the teachers' organisation. Are they going to get no dividend? The publicans are being well compensated for the money they spent on advertisements. Are the teachers going to get nothing?
Comment on this
I am only drawing attention to the fact that in this financial year no provision has been made for them. The Budget statement contains no hint or suggestion, much less does it make provision, for an increase in the teachers' scale of remuneration.
Comment on this
The scales fixed in 1946 are due for revision in 1949. That was the arrangement made at that time. There is no question that next year, under the undertaking given by the Fianna Fáil Government, a revision of the teachers' scales is due, but apparently the expenditure of the teachers' organisation, which must have been designed to get an earlier revision, has been completely wasted money.
Comment on this
The same applies to the Civil Service. In the case of the Civil Service there was a definite contract entered into with them. When their remuneration, which was on a sliding scale, was stabilised on the basis of the cost-of-living index figure of 175, it was understood then, and was part of the arrangement which induced them to accept that proposal, that the consolidated scales would be revised if and when the cost of living rose by 30 points on the basis of the old cost-of-living index number, which has now been replaced by a new number. It is true to say that the rise in the cost of living since the scales were consolidated has brought matters to the point where a revision is due, but apparently the Minister for Finance intends to avoid honouring that obligation as well.
There is no indication in the Budget statement that it is intended to enter into any discussion with the Civil Service organisations with a view to a revision of the scales. On the contrary, the final portion of the Minister's statement made it clear that he is completely opposed to the idea of any such revision as affecting either civil servants or any other classes of workers.
Behind this Budget there is a Fine Gael mentality. On two occasions since the Dáil assembled I tried to explain to the new friends of Fine Gael what that mentality is as I have seen it developing over the 20 odd years during which I have been a member of the Dáil. They did not quite understand the help I was trying to give them, but the task has been made very easy for me now by yesterday's Budget statement.
In 1932, when the Fine Gael Government were expelled from office, the position in which the Fianna Fáil Government found the country could be very largely described as being not much better than that of a British shire. We had no, or practically no, international contacts except through Great Britain. I have told the House before that at that time circumstances were such that nobody from abroad could even visit this country unless they came through Great Britain; they physically had to pass through a British port in order to come here. Nobody could trade with us, except in a limited way, unless they used British shipping and British transport organisations and, in respect of many classes of goods, unless they employed the services of British middlemen. Over a large area of the world it was not possible for other peoples to have diplomatic or consular contacts with this country except through British diplomatic or consular agencies. There is an idea, which may not have been the original idea of the Fine Gael Party, but which has certainly since become a fixed plan with them, that anything designed to achieve the development of our industrial potentialities, the exploration of our mineral resources, the development of our air and shipping services, the exploitation of our turf resources, the establishment of radio contacts outside our own territory, the expansion of our diplomatic and consular representation abroad, our participation in international activities, anything, in fact, other than the mere growing of grass to raise bullocks for the British market, is nothing but evidence of megalomania, to be prevented at all costs.
When I said all that before Deputies scoffed at me. I do not know whether the fact that they scoffed at me was due to their conviction that the Fine Gael Party, in the course of their term in opposition, had been converted from their original errors and that they could be relied upon not to pursue that line in future or to continue to have that outlook in the future, or whether it was because they held the hope—and I believe the faint hope—that they could cause the leopard to change his spots, that they could make them act in accordance with their wishes and not in accord with the Fine Gael mentality. I want those Deputies who scoffed at me to examine this Budget in the light of what I said. Our air development is to be hamstrung; our diplomatic representation aboard is to be reduced—I take it that that is the meaning of the satement in the Budget that the Minister for Finance expects to effect a saving on the Vote for the Department of External Affairs——
Comment on this
The Minister will perhaps tell us later then what it does mean and what this saving is to be.
The short wave broadcasting station is not to be proceeded with; mineral exploration has been dropped; even the little Vote for Athletics is to be one of the Fine Gael economies. I spoke before about air development and I do not want to deal now with that question at any length. I believe—and most thinking people will agree with me— that the air will be the highway of the future. In the air great developments in international transport facilities are taking place and for the first time in our history we have got the chance of getting into that kind of development on equal terms with other countries. But we will lose that chance. If we have a Government inspired by the Fine Gael mentality for long in office we will certainly lose that chance and lose it perhaps permanently.
With regard to the short-wave broadcasting station, the Deputies should know that during the war we had no means of contact with the outside world. We could not even send a telegram except over a British cable; we could not send a letter except one which passed through British censorship; we had no broadcasting facilities to deal abroad with the many misrepresentations of our position. We decided that as soon as it could possibly be done we should have to establish a short-wave broadcasting station which could be heard outside our own territory. We received—and there is hardly a Deputy in the Dáil who has not received—hundreds of letters from our Irish exiles abroad asking for the establishment of a short-wave station which would enable them from time to time to listen to Irish news. We made arrangements for the establishment of that short-wave station and is that evidence of megalomania? That station has been partly erected; three-quarters of the cost of it has already been spent; three of the four masts have been built. Are they going to be left there to rust? Is that economy?
I was surprised at the announcement of the decision that the mineral exploration programme was to be abandoned. I think that I am correct in saying that each of the minor Parties in the Coalition Government expressed in their election programmes their intention of fostering the mineral exploration of the country. When I brought in a Bill to finance a programme of mineral exploration there was no objection to it and every Deputy supported the idea, but now we have the Fine Gael idea that anything which involves breaking the surface of the land and destroying the grass on it is megalomania and something which is contrary to their whole conception of keeping this country in the inferior position in which they left it in 1932 and from which we have been trying to lift it for the past 16 years——
Comment on this
We did not fail.
Is there any Deputy who believes that the abandonment of the provision of facilities for athletic development is to effect a saving of £25,000 in a Budget of £70,000,000? It was adopted as an economy, they say. Do they not know as well as I do that it was not as an economy that that project was dropped, but as further evidence of that Fine Gael mentality against which I have been warning their new friends? I think that it is about time that the new Parties associated with Fine Gael stopped running after their Fine Gael leaders and found out where they are going. It is time that they stopped rushing headlong down the road which Fine Gael has pointed out and looked to see where the signposts are pointing. I am trying to give them a few indicators now which may induce their momentary consideration of the point at which they now are and the point at which they will find themselves if they continue to travel the road which they are taking.
I should like to ask a few specific questions arising out of the Budget which I think should be answered and I hope that the information which I desire will be given before the conclusion of the debate. Since it was stated that the increase in the contribution paid by persons insured under the national health insurance, unemployment insurance and widows' and orphans' insurance is estimated to bring in £900,000 in a full year and somewhat less this year, I should like to know what the increase in the contribution will be. How much will the individual worker have to pay in consequence of this transfer of the cost from the State to the individual?
Comment on this
Why this obscurity on the Minister's part? Why does he not state definitely what the increase will be?
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell us what building projects are to be dropped? One of the Coalition Deputies told me that the statue of Queen Victoria outside Leinster House was to be reprieved as an economy.
Comment on this
There is to be a difference in the price of food, tea, sugar and butter for persons engaged in the restaurant and catering trades as against persons requiring these commodities for their own consumption. How is that going to work? What will be the position in the case of a trader who is both a retail purveyor of tea, sugar and butter and a proprietor of a restaurant or catering establishment? There are hundreds such. One of the main complications which I experienced in the operation of the rationing scheme during the war arose out of the many hundreds of retail purveyors of these goods who are also engaged in catering either as a permanent feature of their trade or casual catering on the occasion of fairs and similar functions. How is it intended to provide that the persons requiring tea, sugar and butter for catering purposes will pay more than the persons requiring them for retail sale? I would like to get some information as to what administrative arrangements will be made to get the results the Minister outlined? Does it involve another extension in the number of Government inspectors?
Comment on this
In fact we were told that the inspectors were going to stay outside the farmers' gates and a few weeks later we had the Minister for Agriculture going to the Supreme Court trying to get the Supreme Court to give him the right to enter a farmer's land.
Comment on this
I had nothing to do with such things. As the Deputy knows, it is not a Ministerial responsibility.
Comment on this
The decision to take the case to the Supreme Court was the decision of the present Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
I am anxious to get some information as to the administrative arrangements by which the differentiated prices are going to be effected. What quantity of milk is going into the manufacture of chocolate crumb? Is the allocation to be doubled, trebled or quadrupled, and to what extent is it likely to affect the supply of creamery butter available for consumption here?
Deputy O'Leary was very pleased about the decision to increase the old age pension but I am sure he will have noted the rather meagre provision in the Budget for the payment of increased old age pensions this year. If the Deputy will make a simple calculation of the cost of giving 172,000 people an extra half-crown per week he will find that that very considerably exceeds the total amount which the Minister is providing for the increase of old age pensions, for some unnamed increase in widows' and orphans' pensions and for a revision of the means test under all these schemes. The obvious deduction, therefore, to be drawn from the amount is that this scheme will come into operation very late in the financial year. Why must it be so? The Minister for Finance says it is necessary to review every case amongst the 150,000 old age pensioners. Why is it necessary to review them? The only possible reason why it is necessary to have a review of each case is the intended change in the arrangement for the assessment of means. Why is it necessary, however, to wait for the implementation of the new arrangement in relation to means assessment before giving the increase of from halfa-crown to 5/- a week which has been promised? That could be done without any review of the circumstances of individual pensioners.
It is, I think, well known that of the existing old age pensioners more than 90 per cent. draw the pension at the full rate and there is no reason whatever why these people should be deprived of the increase which has been promised them while some other scheme is being worked out and administratively executed. I remember when we decided to increase the old age pensions last year we took the decision at the end of February and the higher old age pensions were paid on the 1st April. I know, therefore, that it is practicable to carry through that decision to increase old age pensions within a period of a month or five weeks at the most. The explanation for the delay in doing it which is contained in the Budget statement is in a sense misleading. A review of individual cases would be necessary if there were an alteration in the method of calculating means but it is certainly not necessary for the purpose of increasing the amount of old age pensions.
There is one more general observation I want to make. The Minister justifies the general appearance of his Budget on the ground that dangerous inflationary influences are still active here. He said that in his first official speech to the Dáil in connection with the launching of the recent loan and he repeated it in his Budget statement yesterday. If that is so, if there are dangerous inflationary forces at work here, then this Budget is an evasion of the Minister's responsibility. If there is a situation here in which inflation is at work capable of producing all the hardships and risks which uncontrollable inflation has produced elsewhere, then there is on the Minister for Finance the obligation to budget here for a surplus, to use the instrument of the Budget for the purpose of absorbing into the Exchequer the excess purchasing power the existence of which could produce the serious consequences to which he referred. That is the modern view as to how the State Budget should be used for the correction of economic trends.
In the past, Governments spent money when money was plentiful and saved money when money was scarce and thereby accentuated the economic swings but during the inter-war period every Government learned the wisdom of economising in times of boom so that it would be possible to increase expenditure in times of slump. If we have now a boom situation, a dangerous inflationary situation, the wise policy is to absorb purchasing power by taxation in excess of current needs to create a budgetary surplus to build up reserves which could be given back, in a form which would make for the expansion of the purchasing power of the people, when the inevitable deflationary trend develops. If the Minister does in fact believe that there is a dangerous inflationary situation, then this Budget is a confession of his own inability to take the course which prudence suggests.
The Minister in his Budget statement offered, or attempted to offer, some evidence of the existence of what he described as an inflationary situation, and all the evidence he offered related to the year 1947. He did, in fact, show by these figures that there existed in 1947 an inflationary situation. There was in office in 1947 a Government that was not afraid to face its responsibilities, which did in fact budget for a surplus, a surplus which the present Minister for Finance is now enjoying, which took a course of action that was clearly unpopular. We, as politicians, are just as alive to public reactions as any Deputies on the opposite side of the House, but we did our duty and took that course of action despite the unpopularity we knew it would earn for us. Because we did our duty we are now on this side of the House. All the evidence produced by the Minister for Finance related to 1947. It is not true that the note circulation has increased since. The evidence published recently in the Irish Trade Journal appears to suggest that for the past six months the tendency has been downward so far as note circulation is concerned. The bank debits, to which the Minister also referred in his statement, have tended downward during the last quarter of 1947. I do not know what has happened since. That information may be available to the Minister. It is not available to me.
These two indicators are, of course, important, because currency notes and bank debits are the most liquid form of wealth, and if, in fact, as I believe, the gap between the supply of incomes and the supply of goods has closed, that the inflationary movement is over and that the deflationary movement is now beginning, it is in these two indicators that the first sign would appear.
But need we rely upon these figures only? If there existed here now a serious inflationary situation, such as was described by the Minister for Finance, what would we expect to find in the ordinary day-to-day commercial life of the country? We would expect to find, first of all, an excessive demand for goods, a supply of purchasing power in excess of the supply of goods, tending to force prices upward, tending to produce scarcities. Does that exist? Does not every Deputy know that traders everywhere throughout the country are at present reporting trade stagnation, something almost akin to a trade slump? No price has advanced this year through causes which are not quite clearly nonmonetary causes. It cannot be shown that there has been any upward movement of prices in this year because of monetary causes.
Secondly, we would expect to find that the demand for goods was in excess of the productive capacity of the country. The plans which have been outlined from time to time by various economists for achieving full employment have all been designed to create a general situation in which the purchasing power available in the hands of the people would be sufficient to set up a demand for goods and services which would not be satisfied without utilising the entire productive resources of the country. Does that situation exist here? Will Deputies of the Labour Parties agree that there exists in our boot factories, our woollen factories, or any other classes of industry producing consumer goods, evidence of such an excessive demand that the full productive capacity of these industries is being fully utilised? Instead of having full employment, or anything approaching it, we have seen from week to week the unemployment figures—the number of persons registered at the employment exchanges— running from eight to 10 per cent. higher than in the corresponding week of last year.
Comment on this
I do not understand the Deputy. Is he stating that there is no excessive demand in the way of money for the goods that are in the country, or that there is not enough money?
Comment on this
All the indicators appear to suggest that we have passed the stage in which inflationary forces could be said to be at work and are coming into the stage in which there is danger of deflation, that in fact the purchasing power in the hands of the public is not sufficient to absorb the supply of goods waiting to be purchased.
Comment on this
May I suggest that that was not your thesis last night? I thought then the Deputy said that there was inflation and agreed with the view.
Comment on this
No. I took the Minister's thesis and criticised him on the basis of his own belief. I am saying that if, in fact, he does believe there is an inflationary situation, the Budget is an evasion of his responsibility.
Comment on this
I think it is far more serious if the Government has misread the signs and is going to proceed upon the basis of an inflationary situation, one which interprets as placing on it the responsibility of absorbing purchasing powers or preventing an increase in purchasing power. The Government can precipitate a deflationary situation, which will probably come at some stage, but which we do not want to come here before it comes elsewhere.
Comment on this
No. My own view is that there is no indicator at present which appears to point to an inflationary situation here and that, consequently, we have reached the stage where a policy of economy and retrenchment, such as that to which the Government is now committed, is undesirable.
Comment on this
If there is inflation, the Budget is an evasion of responsibility. It does not go half far enough to deal with it.
Comment on this
What the policy of the Budget is, or what the ideas on which it is based are, I do not know. No one could know.
Comment on this
I want seriously to argue that the indicators suggest that there is not, that the rising number of unemployed, the trade slump which traders report, the reduced production in a number of factories and various other indicators of the kind, all suggest that we have passed from the inflationary situation—which did threaten last year and which we tried to correct by the Supplementary Budget last year —and that we are now reaching another situation in which this policy of economy and retrenchment is a wrong policy.
Comment on this
Would not one great sign of the passing of inflation be that prices would drop—and are they dropping?
Comment on this
I think it is true to say that no rise in prices occurred in the past three or four months which could be traced to inflationary causes. Any increases there were were consequences of some non-monetary factor or of a decision of the Government.
Comment on this
I am trying to get this matter discussed in a serious way. If the Minister can produce any facts which would appear to support the view that there is a dangerously inflationary situation here, then I am prepared to support him in adequate measures to cope with it; but I must conclude, from the information available to me—the limited information published in the Trade Journal and the facts of day to day economic activities in the country as I know them—that there is not an inflationary situation and that, on the contrary, we appear to be moving to a deflationary situation. Therefore, I urge that this policy of retrenchment is a wrong policy. We are not now talking about economies.
If there are economies which mean the elimination of waste, getting the same service for less money, we will all be in favour of them; but the mere avoidance of expenditure, even on useful projects, because of the threat of inflation is a wrong policy. There is a danger that the Government has misread the facts and is applying a policy —here and there, at any rate—which will tend to accentuate the dangers which I see in the present situation. I think this is a situation which requires us to spend money on useful projects and not to be seeking opportunities for retrenchment. I see no reason whatever why we should not provide the £85,000 per year for mineral exploration.
Comment on this
Why save it? Is there any justification for saving it except that there is an inflationary situation?
Comment on this
If there is deflation, it is not £85,000 we would need to expend, but a couple of millions.
Comment on this
No. I am querying the basic idea upon which the Minister framed his Budget. I take it that his justification for stopping the expenditure of money upon mineral exploration, the erection of the short-wave power station, upon athletics and all these things, is because there is some reason why we should curtail expenditure; and the reason he gave was that he saw an inflationary situation. I am not now going to infer—only a fool would do so—that mineral exploration will reveal workable deposits of commercial ores.
Comment on this
There are experts' reports which indicate the possibility that they are there and I think we should not rest satisfied until we have found out whether those reports are justified in their general conclusions or not. In any event is it not useful work? Why deprive ourselves of a short-wave broadcasting station that is three-quarters erected? Is that economy? Is it not waste? Why save the £25,000 voted for the development of athletics—unless there is some misconceived idea that it is megalomania for the Irish people to hope to develop athletics here or even to participate in international athletic tests. My belief is that the expenditure of money upon useful projects—upon necessary State building, upon transport development whether on the land, on the sea or in the air, and upon other projects of a similar kind—is desirable in present circumstances and will, in fact, be urgently necessary, if I read the general economic indicators right, as a corrective to deflationary tendencies.
I do not want to occupy the Dáil any longer in expressing my views because I am sure there are other Deputies who will have other views to express. I think this Budget was framed in political expediency and that there is nothing behind it except political expediency. In so far as it bears any hallmark of inspiration at all it bears the hallmark of the old Fine Gael mentality—that mentality which has already produced such disastrous results in this country and which, we hoped, had been permanently eradicated from the councils of this country's Government. Having regard to the views we hold and to the indications that that old mentality is being revived and is going to inspire Government activity in the future, it is inevitable that we will oppose this Budget, and we will oppose it vigorously. That it should be supported, and with applause, by the Labour Deputies is the most incomprehensible thing about it.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liomsa cur síos a dhéanamh i nGaeilge ar dtúis ar an gCáinfhaisnéis seo. Fé mar adúirt an Teachta a labhair rómham, nílimid sásta leis in aon chor. Tríd is tríd, níl ann ach cur i gcéil. Nuair a bhí muintir na taoibhe eile ag gabháil timpeall na tíre le linn an Toghcháin bhíodar ag cur in a luí ar na daoine gur theastaigh uathu an costas maireachtála d'ísliú; go raibh so ró ard ar fad do mhuintir na tíre seo agus, freisin, gur theastaigh uathu na cánacha d'ísliú. Dá bhféachadh éinne ar an gCáinfhaisnéis seo chífeadh sé láithreach bonn baill nár comhlíonadh ceachtar den dá chuspóir sin. Fuaireamar cur síos bréa uathu ar cad a bhí beartaithe acu le haghaidh na ndaoine atá ag fáil an phinsin sean aoise, pinsin na ndall agus pinsin na mbaintreach agus na ndílleachtaí, ach, tar éis an méid sin cainte go léir, conas mar atá an scéal? Níl le fáil ag formhór na ndaoine seo atá ag fáil an phinsin sean aoise ach leath-choróin sa mbreis. Ní mór an tairbhe an méid sin dos na daoine aosta. Ina theannta sin, tá sé curtha siar ag an Rialtas mar ní theastaíonn ón Aire an bhreis a cur ar fáil go dtí dáta éigin san am atá le teacht.
Níl sa Cháinfhaisnéis seo atá ós comhair na Dála acht saghas trochléireacht—ag tógaint airgid ó dhreamanna áirithe agus a thabhairt do dhreamanna eile. Fiú amháin anois na daoine sin atá ar árachas náisiúnta agus na daoine a dhíolann isteach ins an gciste atá ann do, na baintreacha agus na dílleachtaithe, beidh orthu níos mó a dhíol feasta. Is mar sin a gheibhtear airgead don Stáit agus sin é an t-airgead a tabharfar do na daoine atá chun an leath-choróin sa mbreis d'fháil lá éigin san am atá le teacht ach níor luadh an dáta go fóill.
Nuair a bhí an tAire féin, agus na daoine a chlaíonn leis, ag suí ar an dtaobh seo den Teach bhí mórán le rá acu mar gheall ar chomh híseal is a bhí páigh an lucht oibre. Agus freisin, nuair a bhí an Cháinfhaisnéis Bhreise ós comhair na Dála ag an Aire Airgeadais deireannach dúirt an fear atá anois ina Aire Airgeadais—agus an fear atá anois ina Aire Leasa Shóisialaigh chomh maith—go raibh éagóir á dhéanamh ag an Aire agus ag an Rialtas a bhí ann an tráth sin nuair ná rabhdar sásta páigh an lucht oibre d'ardú. Acht sa Cháinfhaisnéis seo do b'éigean don Aire Airgeadais teacht isteach agus a rá leis an lucht oibre nach bhfuil ardú páighe le fáil acu mar, dá bhfaighdís é, d'ardódh se an costas maireachtála ró mhór. Ní fheadar an mbeidh an lucht oibre sásta leis an ráiteacht sin.
Is cuimhin liom, freisin, nuair a bhí na Tairiscintí sin ós comhair na Dála anuiridh ag an Aire Airgeadais deireannach chun cáin bhreise a chur ar ghluaisteáin, go raibh an oiread sin cur ina choinne ag na daoine atá anois ar thaobh an Rialtais gur chuireadar bhótáil an bun air. Anois, ní hamháin go bhfuil an tAire agus an Rialtais sásta leanúint den cháin sin a ghearradh ach tá siad ag teacht isteach anois agus ag cur cánach eile anuas ar an gcáin sin mar, as seo amach, beidh costas níos airde ar phetrol agus íle le díol ag lucht tiomána gluaisteán.
Ach siad an pobal á íocfaidh as sa deireadh thiar thall mar ní bheidh lucht na ngluaisteán sásta an cháin nua seo d'iompar, is iad sin, na daoine a mbíonn gluaisteáin le híreáil acu. Agus geallaimse dhuit, a Leas-Chinn Chomhairle, go bhfuil mórán daoine eile ann agus gluaisteáin acu a bhfuil géarghá acu díobh chun a gcuid gnótha a dhéanamh.
Is mór an difríocht a bhíonn idir dhaoine nuair a bhíonn siad ar na binsí ar thaobh an Rialtais agus na daoine céanna nuair a bhíonn siad ar na binsí i gcoinne an Rialtais. Tá an difríocht sin le feiscint go soiléir i láthair na huaire. Mar adúrt, níl sa Cháinfhaisnéis seo atá ós comhair na Dála anois le dhá lá acht lag-iarracht chun an costas maireachtála agus na cánacha d'ísliú. Fé mar adúrathas cheana, níl ag éirí leis an Rialtas ceachtar den dá Chuspóir a bhaint amach.
I would describe this as a juggler's Budget. It is as fine a piece of financial juggling as we have seen for a long time. We were told by the Deputies opposite, who now form the Coalition Government, both during the election campaign and afterwards that they were out to reduce taxation by £10,000,000; not merely that, but that they were going to bring down the cost of living. I submit that they have done neither one nor the other. In fact, it seems to me that the opposite is the case, because as regards taxation, apart from the removal of the taxes imposed by the Supplementary Budget last October, it appears to me that taxation will go up as a result of this Budget.
Comment on this
I am proceeding now with my speech. I am making my speech in my own way. If the Minister has not been listening to my opening statement, I cannot help it.
Comment on this
For the Minister's information, I was saying that, instead of reducing taxation, we are going to raise it by this Budget and I shall proceed to explain to the House how this is going to happen. Last year when the Supplementary Budget was introduced by the Fianna Fáil Minister for Finance, there was an increased tax put on motor vehicles. The colleagues of the present Minister fulminated against that tax. They stated it was unjust and, so keenly did they feel about it, that they called for a Division, and that tax on motor vehicles was opposed on a Division by the Fine Gael Party, backed up, I think, by the Clann na Talmhan Party.
We are now facing another tax, an indirect tax, on motorists by way of an increase in the price of petrol. That is what we are getting now instead of a reduction in taxation. Let nobody tell me that the people who use motor vehicles are all rich, well-off people. They certainly are not. Many people have to use motor cars for the conduct of their ordinary business. In any case, it appears to me that when there is an imposition of that kind put upon people who have to purchase petrol and oil, such as taxi and hackney drivers, rather than suffer the loss, those people will naturally pass it on to the travelling public, who will have to bear their portion of the increased taxation on petrol. I do not see what justification there was for the increase in the price of petrol. I imagine that the price is high enough at the present time. But, of course people who own motor cars, people who use motor cars, are looked upon as a small section of the community and a section who do not count for very much. But, as I said, the impact of this taxation is not likely to rest on those who drive motor cars, such as hackney and taxi drivers. They will pass it on to the travelling public.
Then take the question of the proposed and much-vaunted reduction in the cost of living. There is to be no reduction in the cost of living, so far as I can see. If anybody can point out to me where there is any provision in this Budget for a reduction in the cost of living I would be very thankful if he would do so. On the contrary, there is to be indirectly an increase in the cost of living. Tea and sugar will be dearer now for those people who conduct hotels and catering establishments. As in the case of those who drive motor cars for hire and who will not be satisfied, I think, to bear the impact of the increased cost of petrol, so also those who own catering establishments, if they have to pay an increased price for tea and sugar, will naturally pass it on to the consumers. There are many people, even comparatively poor people, who have to have their meals away from home, and these people will have to bear some of the burden that is being put on those who conduct hotels and catering establishments. Also, oatmeal and margarine will be dearer.
During the recent election Deputies opposite made the welkin ring about increased production from farm and factory. Is there anything in this Budget to indicate that there is any provision whatsoever being made for an increase of production from the land? I have searched the Minister's statement in vain to get any evidence that it is the intention of the Government to take steps to increase production on the land. No doubt, an increase of agricultural production was a grand slogan for an election campaign. Now that the people who made use of that slogan have the reins of Government in their hands, one would imagine that one of the first steps taken would be to make the necessary provision for increased production from the land.
In the recent debate here on the Vote on Account I referred to the prices the farmers were getting for their produce, especially the dairy farmers. I pointed out that since the price for milk was fixed last year certain changes have taken place which would justify the farmers in looking for an increase in the price of milk and butter. Agricultural wages have gone up since then. Rates and charges have gone up since then. One would expect, therefore, that the Minister, in presenting this Budget to the House, would make some reference to the prices the farmers are getting for their milk and produce, especially the dairy farmers, because I regard dairying as the backbone of our Irish agriculture. The farmers are getting no relief under this Budget so far as I can see. There is no evidence to be adduced from the Budget that the Government intend to stimulate production from the land by the only natural method there is for doing so, namely, by price inducement.
Now, I remember the Minister himself referring in this House to our sterling balances. I gathered from some of his remarks on the occasions that he spoke about these that he was sceptical about the advantages of our possessing those sterling balances abroad. I wonder is he of the same opinion still? I do not think he is, because, having changed from this side of the House to the Government side, he is a much wiser man. I think that our sterling balances abroad will be of great benefit to us.
Comment on this
He wondered if it was worth having paper claims. I will get the quotation for you if you like.
Comment on this
The Minister himself said it several times. I think there is evidence to that effect, but, of course, having control of the national purse now the Minister is a different man from what he was when he was sitting on the Opposition Benches. In any case, I think it is advantageous to have those sterling balances at the present time, having regard to our adverse trade balance, and seeing that our imports exceed our exports considerably.
On the occasion of the debate on the Supplementary Budget the present Minister deplored the fact that it was thought necessary to peg down wages for the working man. He deplored the fact that the Government thought it wise to do so in order to restrain inflationary tendencies in this country, and as for the present Minister for Social Welfare he nearly made us all shed tears on that occasion lamenting the case of the down-trodden working man whose wages, he said, were miserably low and were kept low by Government action.
Comment on this
Yet, judging by the Minister's Budget statement this year the Minister or his Government is not inclined to increase the wages of the working man. In fact, the Minister has stated now in clear, unequivocal language that he will not allow wages to rise.
Comment on this
Nothing worth speaking about. I am not going into the question of wages in detail. I am merely referring to the attitude that the Minister himself took up on that occasion and to the attitude of the Minister for Social Welfare, the erstwhile champion of the workers, in connection with a workman's wages. Now, the workman is told that on no account whatever is he to look for increased wages.
Comment on this
That is not my responsibility. I am in opposition now, and that is your responsibility over there. You sought for the reins of Government and you have got them. You have the authority to do what you think is necessary for all sections of the Irish people, and it is not my responsibility to advise you as to what you should do.
Comment on this
I come now to the question of old age pensions, pensions for the blind and widows' and orphans' pensions. We saw in the papers recently statements made by the Minister for Social Welfare and by other members on the opposite side as to what they were going to do for the recipients of old age pensions, of blind pensions and of widows and orphans, but after all the talk and all the promises that have been given by Deputies opposite, we find that in most cases the increase in old age pensions will be 2/6, and in some cases 5/-. That would not be too bad if it were the Minister's intention to put these increases into effect right away. The Minister, however, has announced that they are to come into operation at some future date. What is the cause of the procrastination in this case? Why will not the Minister take his courage in his hands and make the increases operative from to-day?
Comment on this
Old age pensions? The Deputy sat behind the old rate for 15 years and now he is complaining about a two months' delay.
Comment on this
I am talking about the statements which were made by the Minister and his colleagues during the election campaign. The Minister also said that he proposes to increase the widows' and orphans' pensions, but he has not specified any amount. That question, also, has been relegated to the future. But let us see where the Minister is going to get the money for these things? As far as I can make out, the sum involved is the modest one of £600,000, a very small sum when one takes into account the amount of money that is being spent on these social services at the present time. The Minister proposes to increase the contributions for national health insurance, of unemployment insurance and so on. In other words, those people will be compelled to pay for the increase that the Minister proposes to effect in the case of old age pensions and widows' and orphans' pensions. As far as I can see, he is taking money from one section of the people and giving it to others. I do not propose to hold the House very much longer, except to say that I am very disappointed with this Budget.
Comment on this
Indeed, I could gather from the faint-hearted applause that came from certain benches on the opposite side of the House yesterday that some of them over there were just as disappointed as I with the provisions of the present Budget, especially those people who went down the country during the last election campaign, who went as far as my constituency and told the workers there that if they got into power they would ensure a minimum wage of £4 10s. 0d. a week for them.
Comment on this
The Deputy had a question down to-day about that and did not get very much satisfaction from the Minister for Finance, but that is a matter between the Minister and the Deputy.
Comment on this
The workers in my constituency were told that they would be guaranteed a minimum wage of £4 10s. 0d. a week.
Comment on this
It depends on the type of worker you refer to. In any event these speakers in my constituency told the workers that they would be guaranteed a minimum wage of £4 10s. Od. a week.
Comment on this
He said nothing of the kind, and you know it. I know very well that if there is any man more than another in this country who did his utmost to uplift the working man it is Deputy de Valera. Now instead of paying this minimum wage of £4 10s. 0d. a week, the workers are advised by the Minister in his Budget statement not to look for any increase at all, as any increase that might be granted might have an inflationary effect on the country's economy. I think the workers know where they stand now.
Tá mo chuid beagnach ráite agam ar an gCáinfhaisnéis. Dúirt mé i dtosach nach rabhas sásta leis in aon chor, agus dá n-innseodh cuid de na daoine ar an dtaobh thall an fhírinne agus an rud atá ina n-aigne, déarfaidís an rud céanna—ná fuilid sásta leis an gCáinfhaisnéis seo atá curtha ós comhair na Dála ag an Aire. Na rudaí adúradar i rith an toghcháin, agus na geallúintí a thugadar uathu, níl siad á gcomhlíonadh. Níl, ná aon ní dá shórt. Do chuireadar an dubh 'na gheal ar na daoine bochta ar fud an tíre, i dtaobh na maitheasaí a bhí i ndán dóibh dá ndéanaidís an Rialtas d'thrú. Go bfóire Dia orthu.
Fiú amháin, na daoine atá ag cur isteach ar phinsin sean-aoise, agus ar phinsin baintreacha agus dílleachtaithe dúradar go rabhdar chun seo agus siúd a dhéanamh dóibh. Ní bhéidh le fáil ag formhór na bpinsinéirí sean-aoise ach leath-choróinn sa bhreis agus níl fhios agam fós cad é an méid breise a tabharfar dos na baintrigh agus na dílleachtaithe agus cathain a tabharfar dóibh é. Níor chuir an tAire é sin in iúl dúinn. Nuair bhí na daoine atá ar an dtaobh thall anois ar an dtaobh seo den Tigh bhíodar ag rá gur cheart níos mó airgid a sholáthar do na seirbhísí seo ach anois nuair atá sé de chúram orthu cúrsaí an Stáit a stiúrú tá a mhalairt de phort acu ar fad.
Fé mar adúrt, níl aon fhaoiseamh gur fiú tracht air le fáil ins an gCáinfhaisnéis seo maidir leis an costas beatha agus le eánacha a laghdú. Tá an costas beatha chomh hard anois agus a bhí sé aon uair le 6 nó 7 mbliana agus ní fheicim cad tá á dhéanamh ag an Aire ná ag an Rialtas chun é do laghdú. Sin é an rud is mó a theastaíonn ó na daoine faoi láthair, agus an tAire nó an Rialtas d'fhéadfadh é sin a dhéanamh, bheadh rud mór déanta acu ar son gnáth-mhuintir na tíre seo. Tá na cánacha ag tuitim go trom ar mhuintir na tíre, anathrom ar fad, agus go mórmhór ar na daoine atá ag díol rátaí leis na comhairlí contae. Tá na srathanna áitiúla ag dul in áirde in aghaidh an lae agus tá costaisí i bhfad níos mó anois ar na feirmeoirí agus ar dhaoine eile den tsórt sin ná mar bhí le roinnt blian anuas. Is dóigh liomsa go bhfuil an t-am ag teacht nuair ba cheart rud éigin a dhéanamh chun na costaisí atá ar mhuintir na tuaithe—a ghearradh anuas. Maidir le lucht na gcathrach agus na mbailte móra, tá daoine eile ann i ndon ceist na ndaoine sin a phlé ach is iad muintir na tuaithe a bhfuil mise ag plé ar a son anois. Tá costaisí áirithe ar lucht díolta na srathanna n-áitiúil nár cheart a áireamh ar na srathanna in aon chor. Ba cheart iad a chur ar an Roinn Airgeadais agus tá súil agam go bhfuil an lá ag teacht nuair a déanfar é sin.
Maidir lem chontae féin, tá na srathanna i gCiarraidhe níos airde ná na srathanna in aon chontae eile sa tír faoi láthair. Tháinig Roinnt feirmeoirí le chéile le déana mar gheall air sin agus shocraíodar ar iarratas a chur go dtí an Rialtas á iarraidh ar an Rialtas deontas a chur ar fáil chun an Ráta i gCiarraidhe d'ísliú. Níl a fhios agam an mbéidh an Rialtas toilteannach an deontas sin a thabhairt. Bhféidir go bhfaighmís é sin amach tar éis tamaill.
Níl na daoine ar an dtaobh seo den Tigh sásta leis an ráiteas a chur an Aire ós comhair na Dála. Bhíomar ag súil go mbeadh i bhfad níos mó faoisimh le fáil. Tuigim go maith ná fuil an tAire i bhfad ag plé leis an scéal seo. Níl sé féin agus a Rialtas ach cúpla mí i réim. Pé'r domhan é ba mhaith linn fhios a bheith againn i dtaobh an treo ina bhfuil siad ag dul. Nil aon laghdú cánach ná aon laghdú ar an gchostas beatha ins an gCáinfhaisnéis seo, agus dá bhrí sin ba cheart don Dáil gan glacadh leis.
Comment on this
I understand from a remark which you, Sir, made to-day, that I am not permitted to apply the term "buffoonery" to the speeches of any member of this Assembly. That being so, I can only characterise the performance we have witnessed here from Deputy Lemass and Deputy Kissane as rank hypocrisy. I should prefer to use, if I could, a somewhat milder term. We witnessed yesterday evening and also this afternoon the spectacle of Deputy Lemass whipping himself up into a frenzy of froth in fulminating against this Budget, when every one of us knows that there is not one Deputy opposite who would not give his right arm to be able to claim that a Budget such as this was introduced in any year in which Fianna Fáil were in office. Every Deputy sitting opposite knows that, and knows that we know that, and that is where the hypocrisy comes in.
We hear these people complaining about the Budget. Do any of them, if they are sincere at all, consider what this Budget would have been, had there not been a change of Government? I have not been long here and I am not as experienced in reading the Estimates as Deputy Kissane, who, in another effort some time ago, dealt with the £ being worth only 8/-.
Comment on this
On the basis of the Estimates presented to this House and prepared before this Government took office, the taxpayers had nothing to look forward to but substantially increased taxation, if they had permitted the formation of a Fianna Fáil Government. We hear Deputy Lemass, in his own sardonic way, jeering at the Minister for Finance and saying: "You promised a reduction of £10,000,000 in taxation." I want to make this claim, that the presentation of this Budget effects a reduction of £6,500,000, at any rate, on what a Budget presented by Fianna Fáil would have been.
There is a comparatively small increase in the price of petrol. My own view for what it is worth is that petrol could have stood an increase of 3d. or 4d. more than has been imposed under this Budget. That is, however, the only increase. As against that you have valuable concessions made to the old age pensioners. I remember listening from the public gallery here to a debate on a motion tabled by either the Labour Party or the Fine Gael Party for an increase in old age pensions only last year or the year before. I remember well the reply given by Deputy Aiken, the then Minister for Finance. He said that there was then no money and that he could not raise more money to do it. He said that he could not possibly grant any increase. We came along a little bit nearer to the election and, of course, some concession had to be made. Already the Minister for Finance, who has only been a couple of months in office, has been able to do more for the old age pensioners than anything done by Fianna Fáil in their 16 years of office.
Deputy Lemass talked about the saving effected under the Defence Vote. He had the audacity to say, despite the facts put before him when that Vote was under discussion here, that for the sake of economising on the Army we were destroying the efficiency of our whole defence organisation. I believe that Deputy Lemass knows, as every Deputy in this House knows, that that statement is sheer nonsense. Every Deputy on the Opposition Benches is well aware that the actual decrease in manpower is something under 800 men. I do not know what type of defence organisation Deputy Lemass visualises if he is under the impression that the efficiency of the whole defence organisation will be destroyed by a reduction of 800 men.
Deputy Kissane describes this Budget as a juggler's Budget. I would like to say to Deputy Kissane that, if this is a juggler's Budget, the people outside this House will say and are saying now: "More power to the arm of the juggler who is able to present a Budget like this."
I think it was Deputy Lemass who, in the process of indulging in a taunt at the expense of the national teachers, criticised the decision of the Minister for Finance in relation to the tax on wines. I wonder has Deputy Lemass bothered to read the Minister's statement at all? It is perfectly obvious from the statement made by the Minister that the continuance of the tax on wine not alone would not have produced more revenue but would probably have decreased revenue still further. The Minister has shown to my satisfaction, at any rate, and I think to the satisfaction of every Deputy who has either listened to his statement or taken the trouble to read it, that the only course open to him was to reduce that particular tax. At page 12 of the statement made by the Minister he refers first of all to the reduced customs duty on wines and to the fact that they were doubled in 1946 and doubled again in the Supplementary Budget. He points out that at the time of the last increase it was anticipated that revenue for the balance of the financial year would be augmented by £220,000, giving a yield for a full year of £840,000; in fact, the yield was something about £200,000 less than that. I believe that the Minister in removing the tax has taken a step which is both sensible and logical.
Deputy Kissane spent some time endeavouring to convince the House that the people of this country were expecting a reduction in the cost of living under this Government and that this Government had undertaken to reduce the cost of living. I am firmly convinced that this Government will reduce the cost of living and that it will do so within the next 12 months. I state further that in every year of the 16 years that Fianna Fáil were in office the cost of living increased. It did not merely increase in the war years. It increased every year since 1932 and there is now a 16 years' accumulative effect to be dealt with by the present Minister for Finance.
I have every confidence that he will deal with it, and deal with it successfully before he presents his Budget here next year. So far as the ordinary working man is concerned the real cost of living has been reduced for him already. I am not quite clear as to what statistics are used in computing the cost-of-living index figure but I do know that by the removal of the taxes imposed on beer, tobacco and cinema seats under the Supplementary Budget there has been a real decrease in the cost of living for those who indulge in a pint of beer, in a packet of cigarettes or a visit to the cinema once a week. I know from the views expressed to me during the course of the general election that the average person in Dublin would have preferred to see food subsidies reduced in order that those taxes could be removed. I have no doubt that that is the view of the great majority of the people in the country. They would have preferred to see food subsidies reduced and the price of some articles of foodstuffs raised rather than suffer these taxes. In hard cash these taxes meant to them a loss at the end of every week. They lost rather than gained by the imposition of these taxes in the jugglery which was indulged in by the late Minister for Finance. I would like Deputies to consider very briefly some of the other matters in which economies were effected or will be effected.
First, it might be as well to look upon some of the big-prestige operations of the previous Government. It may possibly be that the general failing of politicians is that they talk too much. Whether that is a general failing or not, there is no doubt that Deputy Lemass talks too much. I am very surprised at the effrontery of Deputy Lemass in addressing himself to this Budget at all when one considers that the really big wastages which occurred over the past few years, at enormous cost to the taxpayers, were in the Department over which Deputy Lemass then presided. We have already seen the loss incurred by the Deputy Lemass sponsored Córas Iompair Éireann of approximately £1,000,000. We saw the loss incurred by the Deputy Lemass sponsored air lines, none of which, I think, has paid. There was one discontinued by the present Government with the full approval of the people. We saw the position which Deputy Lemass allowed to occur with regard to turf and fuel generally.
We saw the previous Government going from one extreme to another. One year there was an extreme shortage of fuel and the people of this city shivered for a considerable length of time. In the short space of 12 months Deputy Lemass, who was then in charge of the Department of Industry and Commerce, had gone completely to the other side of the scale. On the first evening when this Government took office we heard Deputy Lemass saying from his seat over there that the new Government need not now have any fears with regard to fuel. On the calculations he gave he showed that, between wood and turf, there was approximately a seven years' supply in the Phoenix Park to meet the needs of the people of Dublin. That meant wood and turf alone, leaving out of consideration entirely the coal that has since come in. With that position existing, there was fuel being put into the Phoenix Park at a cost of £40,000 per week to the Irish taxpayer. That was allowed to continue by Deputy Lemass. It was stopped later.
Only the other day we heard a statement from the Minister for Industry and Commerce about luxury hotels and other luxury erections of one kind or another. There again we had another Deputy Lemass sponsored programme which was costing the taxpayers an enormous amount of money. Let us reflect on these things. If we are to give any consideration to what the ordinary person says with reference to the cost of living and to taxation, surely this would be the very worst time either to indulge in that type of expenditure or allow it to be continued. I think it would, at any rate, and that is one of the reasons I am pleased with this Budget. I think the Budget will be welcomed by all sections of the people, and that it will be welcomed very heartily by numbers of those who formerly supported Fianna Fáil.
The Budget imposes no undue hardships on any section. I am quite sure Deputies opposite will do whatever they can to criticise this Budget. I will say this for Deputy Lemass, that he is a good man to stand over a bad case and make the best out of it. He set a headline here this afternoon. He did his best, but his best was very poor. There was nothing into which he could get his teeth. The only thing anyone can criticise is the increased taxation on petrol. At the moment petrol is a rationed commodity. The average car driver in this country drives a ten horse-power car. The allowance he receives each month is something like ten gallons. At the worst all the Budget can mean to him will be that he will pay an additional 50 pence a month. That is the sum total of the new taxation so far as the average driver in this country is concerned. As against that he gets the concessions which are outlined in the Budget.
Another feature of the Budget which makes the task of Deputies opposite extremely difficult is the fact that the tea ration is going to be increased. I would like to congratulate the Minister on that step. From my knowledge that step is receiving a widespread welcome outside.
Comment on this
Budgets have become very serious events in the lives of the people and in the life of the Government. I remember when Fine Gael was called, I think, Cumann na nGaedheal, they introduced a Budget here and took a shilling off the old age pensions. It was not very long after that that they ceased to be a Government. Therefore, I take it that there is a good deal of natural sentiment in the country for the old age pensioners, and that is a very redeeming feature. As well as I can remember—and if I am making an incorrect statement I hope that I will be corrected—I understood from what I could read and hear from all the Parties, except the Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil Parties, that the promise was £1 a week or more for the old age pensioners. Now they are going to get, roughly, 2/6.
Comment on this
That is a general statement, but when it is brought down to brass tacks I take it that it would be 2/6.
Comment on this
If the county councils refuse to put up the other 2/6—and they are pretty well overburdened— there would not appear to be very much increase at all. I hope that at some future date this country will be in a position to give a really beneficial allowance to the aged people. In fact I hope that the day will come when every person over 70 years of age will be entitled to some reward from the whole community, but I do not think that we are facing that way because we seem to misunderstand a number of things.
I just heard one of the Deputies opposite tell us that this Budget was going to be a great benefit to the community. I think that this Budget is a disaster and that is my candid opinion. We have started by taxing petrol. It is only a week ago since it went up a penny. Now 5d. has been put on, making an increase of 6d. In County Meath, the county I come from, we supply quite a lot of milk to Dublin and it is supplied in lorries. I wonder who is going to pay the tax there.
Comment on this
One thing I am certain about is that I hope that farmer producers will not have to pay it.
Comment on this
Who is going to pay it? Is it not the poor of Dublin who must pay it, the householders of Dublin? Can that be denied? I hope that the farmer producer will not have to pay it and I think that he should not be asked to pay it even if we could compel him to do so.
Farmers were asked here by every one of us on all sides of the House to become as modern as possible. A number of farmers—I do not know how many exactly, though I can give the number in the Twenty-six Counties —purchased a modern machine known as the Ferguson tractor. It is an extremely suitable machine for small farmers and for cottage gardens. It has an elevator, it is light and very handy. There are 1,500 of these machines in use in the Twenty-six Counties, and I understand from their manufacturers that 500 more are going out. Therefore 2,000 farmers cultivate their land and use this machine and we are going to tax them. I know that the Minister did not know all that, but this is a development and it is a modern method of doing things. It is suitable for any patch of land and I have seen one working. I have not got one and I do not know anything about that kind of tractor, but I know a number of farmers who do. I hope that the Minister will recognise his mistake and that when the Financial Bill comes in, he will rectify it.
Comment on this
I do not know that, but no matter how many it uses they are taxed now to the tune of 5d. and that is not good policy.
I heard Deputy O'Higgins talking about the users of ten horse-power motor cars. The car I use is a ten horse-power car and I can always manage to cut down the use of petrol in one way or another and escape the tax, but what about the lorries which use any amount of petrol? I suppose that within a radius of 50 miles of Dublin all goods are carried in lorries and I wonder who is going to pay the tax there. It seems that some very urgent reason compelled the Minister to do that foolish thing and the reason was that in an absent-minded moment it was thought that it might be good politics during the election to tell the people that it was an awful calamity on them to have a bottle of stout taxed 1d., the pint taxed something else and cigarettes something else. Having done that, they could not go back on it and they are in a mess. I do not know what figure is going to be collected on this tax. I do not know whether it is £600,000 or £900,000.
Comment on this
That is a very good lump for the community of Dublin and of the country to put up. I think that that system is not a good system.
I do not use the buses very much. People who live in the country only come now and again to Dublin and it does not matter very much, but it is the bread-winners of Dublin who have to use the buses who are going to pay the tax on crude oil. Is it not the workers? I was sorry that Deputy Larkin had to sit down last night. He seems to have been persuaded that he belongs to some combination and that he could not speak.