We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 6—General (Resumed).

Contributions 159–315 of 487. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I will be here again and the reason is that I always did my best, particularly for the people you are now victimising.

Comment on this

It is a wonder that they are in such bad condition then.

Comment on this

They are not in a bad condition, or rather, they may be since you and your Party formed a Coalition Government. As far as I know the position is that they were well looked after. The agricultural community and the workers were as well looked after as possible but if we did not come into power I wonder what the position would be. I remember in the Cumann na nGaedheal days that at the county council meetings in Navan there used to be at least 300 workers at every meeting looking for work. The wages then were only 7/- a week; only occasional farmers employed them; they were actually in misery and there was nobody there to defend them. A member of some Labour organisation did come there immediately after the war and made some little effort.

Comment on this

What war is the Deputy talking about?

Comment on this

There was no organiser and Fianna Fáil had to come to their assistance to give them some status, and a legal status at that. I think that this tax on petrol in a modern country is a great misfortune. I know perfectly well that the cause is that the Minister for Finance had no other way out of it. No one would think that we were such fools when the Budget was introduced that we were going to do something that would do us an injury.

Comment on this

The people thought so.

Comment on this

Since we were turned out and the Coalition Government came into power they are completely puzzled as to what to do and they make this attempt to get £900,000 out of petrol and to make the community, the poorer section of the community, pay it. It is a misfortune. It is a short-sighted policy to impede farmers who desire to adopt the most modern methods. I do not intend further to emphasise that point because I am sure the Minister for Finance will make some provisions in the Finance Bill to protect them.

Quite a number of cattle come into County Meath during spring. In recent years the cattle have been conveyed by lorry. There was no coal and trains had ceased to run. Many farmers consider that transport by lorry is the best and most modern system. A lorry cannot be operated now at the same price at which it was operated formerly. Again, I want to know who will pay. I hope Deputy Dillon will appeal to the British Government for some little increase in the price of cattle to compensate for the increased cost of transport.

Deputy O'Higgins referred to the turf that was brought into the Phoenix Park. I wonder how much turf was brought into the Phoenix Park. If anything happened now and there was a sudden outbreak of war how long would that turf last?

Comment on this

How long does it last in any case? Does the Deputy know that?

Comment on this

Dry turf lasts a considerable time.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy like to go out to the Park?

Comment on this

I saw it and I have just as much experience as the Deputy.

Comment on this

I am sure you have.

Comment on this

There were years, of course, when the turf was not what you would call——

Comment on this

Turf.

Comment on this

——excellent. It was not in perfect condition. There were other years——

Comment on this

There were years when it was nothing but raw field.

Comment on this

The day may come when we will be glad to have it.

Comment on this

Turf, yes, but not the turf you gave us. We are talking about turf, not raw field.

Comment on this

Were not we doing our best to modernise the production of turf and have not you turned round and reduced the funds that helped towards that development? No principle should be accepted more than the principle of making use of whatever we have in this country.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The most dreary sight is to be seen on the bogs in County Meath. In the last week or ten days there has not been a soul working on them. On one bog I have seen well over 1,000 people working. I am not referring to workmen but to families and young people who got a living there.

Comment on this

Why cannot they work still?

Comment on this

There is no hope for them because there is no encouragement. If there is no encouragement, how can they work?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean that they worked only during the emergency?

Comment on this

They were encouraged to work when they knew there was a market for their turf. The Minister wants to put them back to the position they were in when they simply went from house to house and from town to town trying to sell a bit of turf. What I want to know is, bad and all as that stuff was, suppose we had not had it during the war, what would have happened? Some of it was bad, but if we had not had it what would have happened? Was not every effort made to modernise the methods of saving turf?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say why coal was taken off the ration?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is in possession and young Deputies here must realise that a Deputy or Minister is entitled to make his speech.

Comment on this

He is very provocative.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies get impatient. After a while they will get into the procedure.

Comment on this

It is my opinion that, instead of withdrawing financial assistance, every encouragement should be given to the development of modern methods of saving turf.

Comment on this

There never were 1,000 people on turf schemes in Meath.

Comment on this

Did not I explain fairly clearly that I do not mean the people that worked for the county council? I mean the families and the people who came out of towns. I am telling you the truth. Whether it was economic or not, it was most edifying to see them working on the bogs.

Comment on this

If they were not helped by being on turf schemes, they did the work that naturally was there for them. Why is not it there now?

Comment on this

Because there is such competition with coal there now.

Comment on this

There was always competition with coal in Meath.

Comment on this

Indeed there was not. There was not a bit of coal to be got during the war.

Comment on this

I am talking about pre-war.

Comment on this

Pre-war, yes. There was a certain amount of turf even pre-war.

Comment on this

Why should not they——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister will have the last word in this debate.

Comment on this

I would like to get the figures. The Deputy is not objecting.

Comment on this

I want the Minister to be clear that I am not talking about the unemployed men and there are quite a few of them unemployed. I am talking about the families that went out to cut turf. That gave some sign of industry. It was always very elevating to see them at work and it is a pity that they could not be encouraged in some way or other.

Comment on this

I agree and I do not see any discouragement.

Comment on this

We will see the results. As I have said, Budgets are most important in the lives of the people. We see a very peculiar situation arising in connection with this Budget. We see the community penalised; we see the farmers penalised to some extent; we see the workers in the towns penalised and we see, on behalf of wine importers, the duty on wine removed. It may be that the import of wine was a declining industry or it may not be but the facts stand out quite clearly that the wine importers succeeded in getting a great relief.

Comment on this

They are giving me £250,000.

Comment on this

Whereas the rest of the community did not. There was the greatest propaganda in regard to the teachers. I do not see a word about them or any provision for them in this Budget. It may happen that something will be done later. There was very vigorous propaganda about them and they played a very active part but evidently they did not play as active a part as the publicans.

Comment on this

We of the Clann na Poblachta Party feel that we must accord to this Budget a welcome, even though it may be accompanied by certain reservations. This Government, despite Deputy Lemass's attempts to suggest that it is a Fine Gael Government, is not a Clann na Poblachta Government any more than it is a Fine Gael Government. It is an inter-Party Government, composed of members of all Parties in the House with the exception of one Party and the Budget that is presented cannot be described as a Clann na Poblachta Budget.

Comment on this

It certainly cannot.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

The Budget is in accord with the ten-point programme openly arrived at by the members of every Party with the exception of the Fianna Fáil Party. We welcome this Budget because it implements in part the promises that we of Clann na Poblachta made to the people during the recent general election campaign. We welcome it particularly because of the provision made for increased allowances to old age pensioners, to widows, to blind persons and to orphans. An attempt has been made to belittle the provision made for the old age pensioners. I am not to be taken, nor are we on these benches to be taken, as suggesting that the provision is as full and as adequate as we would like to make it; but we say this to the Minister for Finance—that he has done more for the old age pensioners in three months than the Party opposite did in 16 years in office.

If we were in a position to operate our own policy, to implement it as fully as we wish, this possibly is not the Budget that we would expect a Clann na Poblachta Minister for Finance to bring in. Deputy Lemass, yesterday in particular and again to-day, attempted to make great capital out of the fact that the reduction in taxation which, he suggested, had been promised by all the Parties had not arrived. We welcome this Budget—and these are the realities of the case and they can be stated in a few very simple words—because it imposes no increased burdens on that section of the community least able to bear them; we welcome it because provision is made for sections of the community unable properly to provide for themselves. Our welcome is tinged with reservations, but it is only to that extent that there are any reservations about the welcome that we give it.

Deputy Lemass suggested yesterday that we should throw up our hands in horror that no reduction had been made in taxation. We on these benches never made a fetish of the reduction of taxation.

Comment on this

You did to the electors.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

We on these benches never made a fetish of the reduction of taxation for reduction's sake. On many occasions during the recent general election campaign it was pointed out by the Clann na Poblachta speakers to the electors that we considered the test to be the incidence of taxation and the capacity of the section of the community upon which it fell, rather than the actual amount of taxation raised.

Comment on this

Where has the incidence been changed?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will have an opportunity of intervening if he desires to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

The incidence of taxation does not now bear upon those sections of the community least able to bear it. We welcome this Budget for another reason; despite the attempts made from the benches opposite to prove otherwise, this Budget provides for no reduction in social services but rather for their increase. Were it to provide for any real reduction in social services, we in Clann na Poblachta would not welcome it but would oppose it.

There are other matters mentioned by the Minister for Finance during the course of his statement which, perhaps, we regretted. We regret—I am sure the Minister himself regrets it— the necessity for closing down the short-wave station. I, personally, make the Deputies opposite a present of that. I regret that it was necessary to close it down. I would urge upon the Minister that, if there is valuable equipment in the country, if three of the four masts have been already erected, such steps should be taken as would make it possible to keep that equipment in order and repair, so that next year or the year after we may be in a position to go ahead with the plans for the erection of a short-wave station. As I understand it at the moment, were there a short-wave station erected, no arrangements were made by the Ministers opposite when they were in office for any wave-length to be accorded to it.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

We could be in this position at the moment, that we would have a short-wave station which would not have a wave length.

Comment on this

That is not a correct statement of the case.

Comment on this

It is absolutely the fact.

Comment on this

It is not a correct statement. Several months were spent in preparing with a view to getting a short wave length.

Comment on this

But it was not got.

Comment on this

No other country has come to any agreement.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

As I understand it, the conference which will allocate the short waves to the different broadcasting systems in different countries will not be held until next September.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

And we have no guarantee that the wave length will be available for us.

Comment on this

There are preliminary agreements between certain parties.

Comment on this

I would like to see them.

Comment on this

If the Minister would make inquiries——

Comment on this

I have made inquiries.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

Naturally, I am not in a position to controvert the statements of the former Minister for Posts and Telegraphs; but it is significant that he is not in a position to deny that at the moment we have not been allotted any short wave length. Despite that fact, plans were proceeded with for the erection of this costly short-wave station.

Comment on this

If you had not the plans, you would not get a wave length, ever.

Comment on this

The former Minister started the plans in 1945, to look for a wave length in 1948.

Comment on this

And you got the plant. The agreement was attempted.

Comment on this

And it failed.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand there is one Deputy speaking, not three. I shall hear Deputy Lehane and no one else on this.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

I must say that I found Deputy Little's interruptions very helpful, because they have at least made this much manifest, that what I merely had as third-hand information, namely, that we had not been yet allocated a short wave, was apparently perfectly accurate, and I am grateful to Deputy Little for the assistance he has given to us.

Comment on this

It distorts the whole thing.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

In the course of his statement, the Minister mentioned his desire to arrest what he described as an inflationary trend. I should like to urge on the Minister as a general principle the proposition that inflation can best be countered by increasing productivity, and I would urge upon him also that no capital expenditure calculated to increase the national productivity should be vetoed by him by reason of what I hope he will forgive me for describing as his apparent predilection for retrenchment. We of the Clann na Poblachta Party believe that only by a policy of equating currency and credit to the national needs of full employment and full production can we ever put our economy on a sound basis.

If this Budget were the responsibility of the ten Clann na Poblachta Deputies who are on these benches we would probably approach this matter in a different way. There are possible economies that we would seek to make which the Minister has not made. I would have liked to suggest to the Minister that his axe could have fallen perhaps with some effect and with some benefit to the community on the amount of expenditure on the Presidential establishment, on the salaries of Ministers and the allowances of Deputies and Senators. Perhaps from the point of view of an increased revenue yield, we would have considered the reimposition of certain taxes which the Minister apparently decided not to reimpose. The Minister admitted that, while excessive profits are still being taken in a number of industries, at the same time he had decided against the reimposition of the excess corporation profits tax and the excess surtax. The Minister, of course, is in a better position than I am to weigh and consider the possibility of estimating the yield that he would get from the reimposition of these taxes. I would urge upon him, unless in the industries to which he refers there is manifested a speedy reduction in prices to the consumer, that he should seriously consider reimposing these taxes.

Comment on this

He should do it right away.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

I hope very sincerely, and I urge this very strongly upon the Minister, that he will not pay the slightest heed to the suggestion made to him by Deputy Lemass that the transport company should be allowed to increase bus fares as a result of this Budget because, in my estimation, there is not the slightest necessity for the transport company to do that and I think there are people sitting on the Front Bench opposite who are very well aware of that fact.

Out of the criticism, out of the plethora of talk that we had, I listened to hear from Deputies opposite one concrete suggestion as to what they would have done if they were in the position of the Minister. I know very well what they would have done. They evaded the issue however; they refrained from telling the people that the pint, the package of cigarettes and the entertainment, the only entertainment open to the ordinary working people of this city and country, would have been subjected once more to the taxes which they imposed when they introduced the Supplementary Budget. That is something Deputy Lemass did not refer to. That is something which we are entitled to know. Would the solution of Deputy Lemass and the Fianna Fáil Minister for Finance have been to reimpose the taxes on beer, on tobacco and on cinemas?

Wine has flown in hogsheads from the Deputies on the benches opposite. We have heard an awful lot about wine. As I understand the Minister's statement, the reason for the reduction of the duty on wine was because the duty previously imposed when the Party opposite was in power had resulted in decreasing the revenue yield from the duty on imported wines. I do not know whether I understood the Minister correctly, but I can see no other construction that can be placed on the words he spoke in the House.

There are many things that we would like to have seen included in this Budget. We do realise that we have to cut our cloth according to our measure. I want to repeat for the benefit of Deputies opposite that this Budget is not a Clann na Poblachta Budget; that this is not a Clann na Poblachta Government, any more than it is a Fine Gael Government; it is an inter-Party Government. There was some curiosity evinced by some Deputies opposite as to whether the Parties comprising this coalition had retained their separate identity. Let there be no mystery about it.

Comment on this

Have you joint responsibility?

Comment on this

You have to answer to the crack of the whip.

Comment on this
Mr. Lehane

We have to answer to the crack of no whip. They have retained their separate identity, and the fact that they have retained their identity and can work together is what needles Deputies opposite so much. In all the circumstances, we feel that we must congratulate the Minister for Finance on the Budget he introduced yesterday. I do not know what the experience of Deputies opposite has been; but from my experience in meeting working people around the city in the few short hours that have elapsed I know the reception this Budget will get in the country. Let there be no mistake about it, it is going to be a very favourable reception. I would like to conclude on this note that, while congratulating the Minister on having confounded the prophets of doom on the opposite side of the House and having proved that the jeremiads were unfounded, at the same time I would like to sympathise with the Deputies opposite who relied so very much on the ammunition that they thought they were going to get from this Budget. Well done, Mr. Minister. As far as the Budget is concerned, Clann na Poblachta will support it.

Comment on this

It appears to me that the Minister, in selecting petrol for extra taxation, decided to do so because the number of private motor vehicles registered in this country since 1946 has been trebled. I think the Minister will agree with me that these figures are not comparable because, in 1946, motoring in this country was only beginning to revive after seven years of restrictions. In my opinion, the Minister's increase in the tax on petrol makes it one of the most heavily taxed commodities in the country at the moment. Its imposition is a shock to people who expected and hoped for a reduction in the cost of living, for this new tax must, of necessity, result in such an increase in the cost of living. Deputy O'Higgins alleges that it will have no such effect in so much as that the average driver in this country drives a ten horse-power car, and that the result in cost to him will amount to approximately about 4/- a month. Deputy O'Higgins's idea of how this increase in the taxation of petrol is going to affect the economy of the country is, to my mind, very puerile.

It is absolutely certain, in my opinion, despite what Deputy Lehane has said, that bus fares must be increased to meet this extra taxation If bus fares are not increased to meet this extra taxation, then I should like to know what the profit and loss account of Córas Iompair Éireann is going to be like at the end of the year. Taxi fares must go up and the cost of hiring cars generally must go up, but more important still, the cost of the collection of raw materials for industry, the cost of production and of the delivery of the finished product all will be affected, and not only these but the cost of the delivery of even bread and other essential foodstuffs will be affected. I should not be at all surprised if, very soon, housewives found themselves presented with a small charge for the delivery of these commodities to their houses.

I am not here to air the hardships of anybody in particular in connection with this Budget, but it is only natural that I should remind the Minister of the additional burden which he is imposing on the members of the profession to which I belong. The burden is going to be very severe on dispensary medical officers who find themselves, and have always found themselves, in the unenviable position of being the only public officials in the country who receive nothing in the way of travelling expenses. Doctors and others will find that this increase in the taxation of petrol will fall very heavily on them. They will be badly hit. Some individuals may not absorb this heavy increase themselves, but unfortunately, my profession is rather shackled by tradition in matters of this kind. We never find ourselves in the happy position of taxi drivers, bus companies or industrial concerns who are able to pass along an extra cost of this kind.

I heard Deputies arguing as to whether the pound is worth 8/- or 10/-. I am not interested in either figure, but I do know that, as a result of this Budget, the doctor's pound is going to be worth a lot less. I would like to advocate strongly the claim of the dispensary doctor who finds himself in a remote area, such as the Gaeltacht where I work and where on very many occasions one has to travel up to 30 miles on calls to which one may be summoned. Even at this stage I would appeal to the Minister to wipe out the increased taxes imposed in last year's Supplementary Budget which I, and I am sure a number of people, were led to believe at the time were purely temporary. It is hardly fair to impose on the motoring public this new petrol tax while the abnormal horse-power tax and restrictions on use, caused by petrol rationing, remain.

Deputy O'Higgins commented adversely on Deputy Lemass's criticism of defence policy, so far as man power is concerned. Admittedly, the reduction in man power amounts, approximately, only to about 800, but I think that the son of the Minister for Defence will agree with me that it is not a question of so infinitesimal a reduction in man power, it is a matter of principle. If we are not going to show that we are prepared, to the limit of our resources, adequately to defend our country, somebody else will, and at a price. Not only do I disapprove of the dropping of recruiting and of the calling up of the reserves, but I would go so far as to advocate the implementing of recruiting and even go so far as to suggest that a modified form of compulsory military service would be introduced, so that the rich man's son, as well as the poor man's son, would be given the opportunity of contributing his quota to the defence of the country to which he belongs. Apart altogether from national duty in a matter of that kind, I would advocate this compulsory military service for reasons of health, physical development and discipline.

Comment on this

Having listened patiently during the last few hours, and yesterday, to the criticisms from the Fianna Fáil Benches on the Budget, I have come to the conclusion that if a stranger were to walk into this House and were to listen to the Deputies opposite he could not but be convinced that here you had a set of men who did not believe in taxation of any kind, a set of high-spirited men who really should have control of the Government of this country—that is, of course, if he did not know their record.

Deputy Lemass was at pains to attack the Labour Party yesterday for its participation in the inter-Party Government. He shed crocodile tears over the condition of the workers in this country, but Deputy Lemass is the one individual whose name to the workers of this country spells low wages, inadequate wages and Wages Standstill Orders. This Budget does not represent to me, nor to the Labour Party, the very ultimate of our aims nor the actual real addition of our policy but it must be realised that the inter-Party Government took control at a time when the country was in a very difficult financial position and, taking the Budget by and large, weighing one thing with another, it cannot be denied but that the present Minister has done fairly well.

The old age pensioners at any rate are very glad to see how their position is to be improved, not as it should be improved or as much as it must be improved eventually, but at any rate improved to a very much greater degree than ever it was under the administration of Fianna Fáil. Deputies who will go into the Lobby to vote against this Budget will simply be following the example which they set last year when they voted against an increase for old age pensioners. They will be doing the same thing on this occasion. I would say that the remarks of the Minister in relation to the Standstill Orders, and the context in which they appear in his statement, are somewhat vague but I take it that they refer to excess profits rather than to wages because, speaking for the trade union movement, I say that we have had enough of Wages Standstill Orders and we shall not accept any further. I am not suggesting and, in fact, I do not think, in case there is any misapprehension on the Fianna Fáil benches, that that was in the mind of the present Minister but I do wish to express disappointment that the excess profits tax was not reimposed. Deputy Lemass in his many criticisms, and the other Fianna Fáil Deputies, did not refer to that particular tax but I wish to refer to it. I consider that it should be reimposed with as little delay as possible and that the collection of that tax should be rigorously pursued.

Beyond question, it is a matter of general agreement that the basic solution to the economic ills of this country is similar to that in every other country—increased production. Increased production is the key to our eventual economic betterment but we shall never achieve increased production in this country unless we realise that the producers, the workers, the men who make the country operate, must be given a proper incentive by way of adequate wages. In agriculture it is sad to think that they do not get that incentive, but rather the contrary.

Deputy O'Reilly in the course of his remarks which I think were not very much in order, and to which I wish to reply, made some sneering references to the work of labour organisations in his own county in bygone years. I do not recall the period about which he spoke; in fact I have a very vague recollection of the era of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government but I do wish to underline the fact that the contribution of Labour organisations to the development of this nation has been immeasurable. It can well be said that, irrespective of the efforts of any Government we have hitherto seen, the working people of this country owe a debt of gratitude to the Labour organisations generally and, I would say, to two men in particular, two men who are not in this House, one of them whose bones lie in Arbour Hill and the other whose remains rest in Glasnevin, and whom we buried only last year. I simply want to underline that for the benefit of Deputy O'Reilly whose sneering remarks I consider to have been very much out of place in this House.

As I have stated, the Budget leaves some things to be desired as far as Labour is concerned but, again, in fairness to the Minister, acknowledging the tremendous task he had to try to reduce the amount that faced him, he must undoubtedly be complimented. I would ask that every possible effort be made to speed up the introduction of the increases for old age pensioners. I would finally make this appeal to the Fianna Fáil Deputies: "If you vote against this Budget you are voting against an increase for old age pensioners. You have professed your love for them and if you want to give effect to that go into the Lobby and vote for the Budget."

Comment on this

Much has been said by the Party opposite concerning this Budget. I think many Deputies, who were present yesterday and who heard Deputy Lemass make his statement to the House, realised that they were listening to a very angry man, to a Deputy who realised that through this Budget something he thought impossible was being done, an angry man because he realised that the introduction of this Budget meant that neither he nor his Party, for many years at any rate, would sit on the benches from which I am now speaking. Following his statement, other Deputies opposite have spoken. They have shed crocodile tears about the tax on petrol and we heard from them the tremendous consequences that are going to follow the additional tax on petrol. We never heard, however, from any single Deputy opposite what provision they would have made to meet the bill which the present Minister had to meet in this Budget. We can assume that if they were in power the tax on beer and stout and the entertainment tax would have remained and that, in addition to these taxes, a Fianna Fáil Minister would have had to find another sum running to £10,000,000. How would that have been found, or would their Budget have been accompanied by the measure of social justice for old age pensioners which they had denied them for 16 years? I am sure that right throughout this country this morning, when the people read the provisions of this Budget, they thanked God it was not a Fianna Fáil Budget introduced by a Fianna Fáil Minister.

Speaking as a member of Fine Gael, I would like to say that I agree with what Deputy Lehane, Deputy Dunne and other Deputies said, that the Budget does not represent everything all and each of us would desire, but we must remember that it is a Budget introduced after 16 years of Fianna Fáil administration, a Budget introduced particularly after a period of seven years in which Fianna Fáil and the administration of this country went mad; it is a Budget introduced in an effort to recoup the losses of recent years and give the people some social justice.

Some references have been made by Deputies opposite to the savings upon which this Budget is based. The short-wave station and the transatlantic air line have been mentioned. I interpret this Budget as meaning that the Minister for Finance, by cutting out what he considered, under present circumstances, to be wasteful expenditure—such as was envisaged on the transatlantic air service and the short-wave station—was able to give some justice to old age and other pensioners. That is what his economy in that direction has meant for the people. I only hope that those measures are merely a beginning and that from this Budget we can advance to better things. We can at least ensure that money collected in taxes will be put to a purpose from which the people will derive a real benefit.

I regret very much that the provisions of the Budget do not include the restoration of the corporation excess profits tax. I trust that the generosity extended by the Minister to people engaged in industry, who made what most people in this country consider an illegal profit, will bring a return to him. I remember reading in the Dáil debates that when that tax was first removed it was expected by the then Minister that the result would be a fall in prices; that the incentive of greater profit to be retained by the manufacturers and industrialists would mean that they would turn that profit into equipping in a better way their industries, bettering the conditions of their employees and producing a better article at a lower price. That was two years ago. That expectation has not been fulfilled. Excessive profits are still being made. The conditions offered to employees are still far short of what we all would desire and prices have continued to rise.

I realise that this tax was a difficult one, particularly in a country which requires greater production immediately. It may be that the Minister for Finance, having considered the problem, has come to the conclusion that the incentive of large profits must still remain. I was glad to hear him say that while he has appealed to industrialists and manufacturers voluntarily to assist in the task of reducing prices, he has accompanied that appeal by a threat of what will happen if that co-operation is not forthcoming. The warning he uttered indicated to them that, should it be necessary to restore this tax, he will take not merely a part but the entire of such profits.

Deputy O'Reilly mentioned turf and, apparently, he shed some silent tears because of this Government's policy towards turf. If any Deputy deals with a matter like that, he should be honest with himself and with the country. The reason there are fewer employed in the production of turf to-day is due to this fact, that the market for turf is not there because there is a commodity which the ordinary people will buy in preference to turf and that commodity is coal. Coal is on the market; it was put there by Deputy Lemass last October and, if there is to be any criticism about the change in the turf policy, let that criticism be placed before Deputy Lemass. He removed coal off the ration in early October but he was not prepared to be honest or sincere with the people engaged in turf production by warning them of the consequences of that step.

I represent a constituency which, perhaps more than any other, has contributed to the production of turf during the emergency. In my constituency a certain amount of turf has always been produced and always will be produced for local markets, for domestic purposes. During the past four or five years, encouraged by the last Administration, and in particular by Deputy Lemass, hundreds of young men went into turf production. Many ex-Army men during the past two years put their savings into the purchase of lorries. Those men are seriously affected now. I know the hardship they suffer will be eased considerably by the policy of the new Administration, but it must be remembered that that hardship from which they are suffering is due entirely to the callous attitude of the former Administration and, in particular, Deputy Lemass, to the national production of turf. I think that matters like that ought to be mentioned. Deputy O'Reilly raised the matter here. There are other matters arising out of the Budget to which I would like to refer. I do not propose to go into them in any great detail.

Perhaps I am being a little severe on Deputy O'Reilly, but Deputy O'Reilly, in talking about the increased tax on petrol, referred to the Ferguson tractor and talked about the hardship that this tax would place upon the farmers who purchased Ferguson tractors. He admitted quite frankly that he had not got a tractor himself and, apparently, he does know sufficient about it. If he had taken the trouble to inquire into the matter before he discussed it he would have found that arrangements are now being made to adapt the Ferguson tractor for the consumption of kerosene. Fords have actually on the market at the present time a tractor so adapted.

In my opinion this is a sound Budget. It is a Budget which is the outcome not only of the ability of the present Minister for Finance but also of the policy of the Parties supporting this Government. It is a Budget drawn up and designed to meet the serious economic situation with which this country is faced—a country suffering from under-production and over-taxation. It is a country in which there are too many people too lowly paid and too many people existing on the borderline of starvation. It is a Budget which is a step, but only a step, in the right direction. I hope that from this Budget we will advance to better things. The policy initiated under it of cutting out wasteful expenditure and endeavouring to raise the standard of living of the people generally must be and will be brought to a successful conclusion. I sincerely hope that the Opposition Deputies will be honest, if not with themselves at least with their constituents. I think it was last November 12 months they voted against a motion tabled in this House asking for increases for those people who, by reason of infirmity or old age, are unable to earn. Now that they no longer have the responsibility of Government and that they have a Government prepared to lead them along the right path I hope that they will come in and wholeheartedly support this Budget. If they do not do that I can guarantee that very few of them will dare to face their constituents in the coming months.

Comment on this

We will see about that.

Comment on this

Very few of them will. The people of this country cannot forget that there are Deputies opposite now who not so very long ago voted for increases in their own allowances and who voted against a small and trifling increase to old age pensioners.

Comment on this

What about the Cumann na nGaedheal Government? They cut the pensions pre-1932 by a 1/-.

Comment on this

What about Brian Boru?

Comment on this

We restored them in 1932 by a 1/- and we subsequently gave an additional 2/6.

Comment on this

According to Deputy Kissane's argument 10/- then is worth £1 now.

Comment on this

I am very grateful to Deputy Breathnach for raising that particular matter

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What was done in 1932 or pre-1932 is not relevant to the debate now.

Comment on this

I am very glad that Deputy Breathnach has at last been goaded into making some contribution to this debate.

Comment on this

You are not so long here.

Comment on this

He has said more since he came into the House than you have said in the last 15 years.

Comment on this

I would like to remind him that there was a cut of 1/- in the old age pensions prior to 1932.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not relevant on this debate.

Comment on this

I am glad that whatever wrong was done in the past is now being rectified.

Comment on this

I am glad that even this small measure has been taken to restore the balance in favour of those entitled to some benefit from national expenditure. I trust that those Deputies here who are so concerned about increases affecting themselves will remember their duty to their constituents and to those people who are less well off. If they vote against this increase in the old age pensions they will, as I have said, find it very hard to meet their constituents. Let them have no doubt upon that. Their conduct in this vote will be watched with interest by the people. If the conduct of the Deputies opposite can be judged it would seem to indicate that because the Deputies are now on the Opposition side of the House they think they can afford to be irresponsible. Let them remember that this Dáil is now a deliberative Assembly and that every member of this Dáil has a certain obligation which he must fulfil. Refraining from voting for purely petty political motives will no longer deceive the people. There is an issue involved up to which the Opposition Deputies must face. Each one of them is asked individually as to whether he agrees with this increase under this Budget. A decision will have to be made and they cannot excuse themselves by saying that they were told to vote in a particular way. When the time comes to vote I hope they will remember that and I hope that at least some of them will remember their duties to their constituents.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin Cormac Ua Breisleáin Fianna Fáil

Bhí an tír go leir ag fanacht go cruaidh leis an Cháinfhaisnéis seo, an chéad cheann on Rialtas úr, ach, leis an fhírinne a rá, níl comhgháirdeachas ar bith tuillte ag an Aire Airgeadais mar gheall ar a chuid oibre anseo sa Dáil inné.

Níl an Rialtas úr againn ach le cupla mí, ach, más gairid an t-ám, ta a lán daoine curtha as obair acu, go mór mhór i nGaeltacht Thír Chonaill mar gheall ar ár bpríomh-thionscal— baint na móna—a stopadh. Cuireadh na mílte buachaillí as obair ins na ceantair Gaelacha. Bhí muid uilig ag feitheamh leis an Aire chun rud éicint a rá faoi scéim nó polasaí nua le cuidiú, nó le uchtach a thabhairt do na ceantair íargcúlta, scéim a choinneodh na buachaillí agus na cailíní sa mbaile i n-áit a bheith ag dul anonn go hAlbain agus go Sasain. Ach fairíor, níor dhúirt sé focal amháin faoin nGaeltacht agus níor cuireadh airgead ar bith ar leath-taoibh cun obair a thabhairt dóibh agus ní mór do na buachaillí óga agus do na cailíní dul go hAlbain mar atá siad ag dhul ann le cupla céad bliain anuas.

I rith an Toghcháin, cúpla mí ó shoin, bhí muid ag éisteacht le Clann na Poblachta agus le Fine Gael agus iad á iarraidh ar na daoine iad a chur isteach mar Rialtas mar go raibh polasaí acu a bhéarfadh saol úr do mhuintir na Gaeltachta, polasaí a chuirfeadh foraoiseacht ar bun i dtreo is go mbeadh crainn ag fás ar gach ard, polasaí a chuirfeadh scéimeanna dréinéala ar bun ionas nach mbeadh sé d'fhiachaibh ar na daoine imeacht as an tír chun obair d'fháil. Anois ba mhaith liom fháil amach céard tá siad ag dhul a dhéanamh do na daoine sa nGaeltacht, tuige nach bhfuil siad ag labhairt faoi anois agus tuige nach bhfuil aon rud le rá acu faoi na mílte atá anois gan obair sa mbaile. Tá siad chun cúpla scilling a thabhairt do na sean-phinsinéirí, ach níl siad ag tabhairt uchtach ar bith do na mílte daoine a chuir siad as obair le cupla mí anuas. Ar chaoi ar bith, ní fiú mórán an cúpla scilling atá siad a thabhairt do na seanphinsinéiró. Ní dóigh liom gur ionraic an Cháinfhaisneis é seo don nGaeltacht mar ní thugann sé uchtach nó cuidiú ar bith do na daoine ansin agus níl an Rialtas ag comhlíonadh na ngeallúint a thugadar do na daoine. Siad an Ríaltas anois iad agus nil leithscéal ar bith acu le dul siar ar a ngeallúintí agus gan rud ar bith a thabhairt do na céadta daoine a cuireadh as obair de dheasca polasaí an Rialtais nua.

Comment on this

Of the many things which were introduced in last year's Budget, the thing to which I attached paramount importance was the abolition of the excess profits tax. A promise was made by the responsible Minister that as a result of the abolition of this tax the cost of living would come down, and that the money saved could be flung back into industry, which would give a more appreciable article to the public at a smaller price. It was proved subsequently that those promises were not to be realised, inasmuch as the cost of living did not come down and the money saved by the abolition of the tax was not put into industry in order to give it a fillip or to enable the production of cheaper articles. I am not going to go into ecstasies over particular items which were included in this Budget, but I have a feeling—an independent feeling —that those taxes should have been put on again. However, as a new member here, who has not had time properly to investigate the matter, I can only say that perhaps something will be visualised later with a sincerity not very apparent on the benches opposite in 1947. This year we may realise the advantages which we were told we would get in 1947. I would strongly recommend if in the future the people who accumulated wealth—and I have no hesitation in saying ill-gotten wealth—continue to accumulate it in the same proportion as they have been doing for a number of years past, then that the tax should go on to the extent of 100 per cent., and also that some other measures should be taken to bring those people down to terra firma, and show them that the Government is inclined to give the plain people the right to live, and to live under conditions which would be appreciated by everybody.

I was astonished to-day—or at least last night—at the attitude of Deputy Lemass. He turned all his wrath on members of the Labour Party for applauding a Budget which gave 5/- to the old age pensioners and which gave a very substantial increase to the widows and orphans. Just because what was stated off election platforms in December, January and early February, was not fulfilled, Deputy Lemass seemed to think that this side of the House, and particularly the Labour Party, were directly responsible for the whole thing. I would like to call the attention of Deputy Lemass and of the Party opposite to a plan that was posted up on every hoarding and in every public place in 1931. The heading of it went something like: "We have a plan." That plan outlined the reductions that could be made, and made easily, and how the country could be run for a sum less than it was being run prior to that time. That plan was not an improvised plan. It was a deliberate plan decided on after long consideration by the shadow Cabinet of the Fianna Fáil Party at that time, when they were in opposition. Did that plan materialise? I wonder.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is 17 years ago anyhow.

Comment on this

Has it materialised in 1948 or in 1947, the last year that Fianna Fáil were in office?

Comment on this

They increased the social services by £15,000,000.

Comment on this

They did when they were helped by the Labour Party and were made to do it, when we held the balance of power. If the Deputy examines the improvements in social services he will find that that was the only time it was done.

Comment on this

I do not think that is correct.

Comment on this

I have no doubt in the world that it is correct.

Comment on this

It is a dream the man had.

Comment on this

Dreams often come true and I am sure the people on the opposite side are dreaming at the moment, but the dream is more or less a nightmare.

Comment on this

It is a nightmare opposite.

Comment on this

Let me continue. Deputy Hilliard will get time to talk. We made promises before the last general election. We promised to remit the tax on the workingman's drink, the pint of beer, on the workingman's smoke and on the workingman's entertainment. We were not very long in power—we were not 16 years, at any rate—when we did that. We promised to increase old age pensions. We promised to increase widows' and orphans' pensions. Not alone have we increased them but we have duplicated the increase. For the purposes of the means test we increased the limit of income from £39 to something that at the moment I do not know but which I am sure will be very appreciable. The people on the opposite side of the House could not see their way to increase old age pensions. For years they pleaded that the finances of the country could not stand it, that the nation would be beggared if there was any small increase in old age pensions and widows' and orphans' pensions. This inter-Party Government were not very long in office when they introduced increases in old age pensions and widows' and orphans' pensions, and I am sure that future generations will appreciate the actions of the Government in granting these increases to those who need them most.

We have heard a great deal about the increased cost of petrol. We have heard Deputy M. O'Reilly speaking about the produce of County Meath being brought by lorry to feed the people of Dublin. I am not certain that my figures are accurate but I would say that the farthest point of Meath from Dublin is approximately 60 miles. Assuming a rate of ten miles to the gallon it would mean that 12 gallons of petrol would be used in bringing two to five tons of produce to Dublin. The increased cost resulting from the increased taxation on petrol would be 5/- a load. I wonder how the people of Meath will distribute the increased cost to the poor of Dublin whom Deputy O'Reilly stated they were feeding. It seems to me that it will take some calculating machine or proximator that I do not know anything about to discover exactly what the increased cost should be.

Several Deputies on the other side are very puzzled as to why we did not do a lot of things. They maintain that what we have done is being done at the expense of the poor. There is one thing we have not done and that I hope we have no notion of doing and that is becoming airminded or monopolyminded. Certain monopolies and industries have been safeguarded in every way and the taxpayers of this country for years past have been paying through the gills to keep them going and to give them more than a fair profit. One concern which was subsidised produced a balance sheet last year showing a depreciation or loss of £1,500,000. One and a half million pounds in a concern that had a national monopoly—Córas Iompair Eireann. People begin to wonder how is that. I have no hesitation in stating in this House the reason: the people who were running Córas Iompair Eireann were the cause of it, the people who were in positions that they should not have.

Comment on this

These men are not in this House to defend themselves. I do not think it is very nice.

Comment on this

There were several charges made in this House against people who were not here to defend themselves

Comment on this
Joseph Blowick Minister for Lands (Mr. Blowick) Clann na Talmhan

The House had to provide the cash for them.

Comment on this

If the Leas-Cheann Comhairle says that I have said anything wrong, I will accept his ruling.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am trying to indicate to the Deputy that I do not see how the management of Córas Iompair Eireann has anything to do with this Budget. This Budget has to do with taxation.

Comment on this

The House is responsible for anything up to £500,000 working loss by Córas Iompair Eireann.

Comment on this

I bow to the Chair's ruling but, for the benefit of the people on the opposite side of the House, I should like to say that charges were made several times in this House against people who were not present.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No personal charges have been made against anybody. The Chair has been particularly careful about that.

Comment on this

I hope that for the future those industries will be left hanging by their own tail and that the taxpayers of this country will not be responsible for their upkeep and maintenance. In conclusion, I say that we in the Labour Party have gone a long way in keeping the promises that we made. I have enumerated things we have done in the short three months that this Government have been in office. I hope that when we meet next year we will have gone further in improving the position of the people who most require our help. I assure those on the opposite side of the House that none of us has any intention of letting 16 years pass before we fulfil our promises. We have reduced taxation. We have given the widows and orphans and the old age pensioners a part, and a good part, of what we promised them, and I trust that when next year's Budget is being introduced we will be able to go the whole hog and fulfil our promises 100 per cent.

Comment on this

We have heard various opinions all over the House on this Budget and I would like to assure Deputy O'Higgins that, whatever I do about the Budget, I will speak to my constituents wherever and whenever I like and I can assure him that the combined forces of all in this House would not prevent me from doing so. We have heard Deputy O'Higgins say something about raising the standard of living for the lowly paid. I am rather deeply concerned about that, as I consider myself one of the lowest paid men in Europe and as representing that particular class in the rural community who are the worst paid of any people in this country to-day.

We have heard a lot of talk about more production. I have examined this Budget to see in what way it will help the farmer towards increased production. If the farmer does not produce, that is the end for the rest of the people. I am anxious to see that the condition of the paid farm labourer and of the unpaid farm labourer, namely, the farmer's son, is improved. What do we find? The first move made here is where the Minister states that he counts on £500,000 this year by taking the State contribution for national health insurance, unemployment insurance and contributory widows' and orphans' pensions and shoving it over on the badly paid farm labourer and on his employer, the farmer. As an excuse for that, and for fear anybody would think that conditions for the ordinary labourer were going to improve, there is the opinion of the Minister for Finance:

"In view of the substantial increases in wages over the past 18 months and the benefits afforded by the increase in food subsidies last October, now no longer offset by higher beer, tobacco and entertainments duties, some addition to the weekly contribution of employees is not unreasonable."

Between the employees and the employer, the deficiency of £500,000 in this Budget is to be made up. As we farmers all know, we generally pay the whole of the national health contribution for our employees. I have not seen it stopped in my part of the country, anyway.

Comment on this

I wonder.

Comment on this

I will bring Deputy Keane down and he can have a look around. The extra mulct is going to fall on the employer. At the moment, I cannot divide this £500,000 out to see how much will be borne by the agricultural community and how much by the industrial community, but the fact remains that £500,000 is the answer.

Next we find £910,000 to be got from petrol and oil. How much of that will be borne by the agricultural community? I have no means of differentiating between petrol used for motor cars and petrol used for ordinary commercial business, but I know that we beet growers found ourselves last year faced with a 20 per cent. increase in the cost of transport of our beet. We also know there is at present a demand by Córas Iompair Éireann for another 12½ per cent. increase on top of that. Now you have a further 5d. per gallon on petrol to go on to that. We are a class of the community who have no possible means of passing it on. We are the underdog. This is going to tend to more production! I have been for a number of years, since the beet factories were established, negotiating each year with the sugar company and I can assure the House that they are very tight boys to deal with. I remember an occasion when the general manager of the sugar company offered to split 3d. in a ton of beet. We are going to be kept there at the back end of the stick—and we are going to produce more! If we do not produce more, that finishes the job.

The next assistance we are to get it this. We gave this year anything from £32 to £35 a ton for seed oats. The Minister has now removed the subsidy on oatmeal and we can go to the market next year with our oats, after paying £35 a ton for it, and see how we get on—especially in view of the assurance from the Minister for Agriculture that he will bring in cheap Indian meal to help us out in getting a price.

The next assistance we get towards further production is the removal of the subsidy on home-made butter. That is wiped out, in order to induce increased production on the land. It is a grand way to go about the job. We had Deputy Cogan to-day asking the Minister about the cost of production of pigs and the Minister apparently knew all about it. He said there would be plenty of pigs and he would advise Deputy Cogan not to say a word, for fear there would be an inquiry and that Deputy Keane's excess profits tax would be coming down on the fellow with the pig.

Another little assistance towards extra production, in addition to the 4/- in the £ in the rates this year, is that we are to relieve the unfortunate Budget to the extent, according to the Minister for Social Welfare, of £75,000 odd this year and £150,000 odd next year, by shifting the cost of the food vouchers that the Fianna Fáil terribly capitalist Government gave to the poor out of State funds—by shifting that over on to the ratepayer's back. The sum of £150,000 does not matter in a big job like this where you are throwing millions around. All this is to increase production. I read in the paper last week a statement fixing the price of liquid milk in the towns and cities of this country. I can honestly admit that I expected nothing better from this Government—and those who expected nothing will not be disappointed. However, when you know that a Minister has in his possession costs of production that cannot be questioned and when you see that Minister come along and do the idiotic thing the Minister for Agriculture has done in regard to the supply of liquid milk to Cork City and Dublin one questions whether we can carry on or not. The main scheme on which this country can exist and carry on is that of increased production. There must be increased production and this is a means by which it can be done.

Deputy O'Higgins referred a short time ago to a Ferguson tractor which is going to be converted so as to be able to use some other fuel besides petrol. I do not know where the Deputy got his information. Henry Ford is producing new tractors which are capable of being worked on kerosene, which is also taxed under this Budget—no doubt in order to help the farmers to produce more. There is an increase of 2d., I think, on the kerosene side of it—we will be able to plough the land cheaper as a result of that. I know several of my neighbours who were induced, an account of this appeal for increased production, to buy Ferguson tractors. These tractors use, roughly, ten gallons of petrol per day and that represents 4/2 a day extra for their costs. These people are asked to produce more yet their costs of production are increased and they are faced with a stone wall in any appeal they make for an increase in prices.

In the case of liquid milk, the actual position is this. On the cost of production, as vouched for by no less an authority than the University of Cork, the price of liquid milk fixed by the Minister leaves the farmer with a loss of 4d. per gallon for the months of October, November and December; a loss of 2d. per gallon for the months of January, February and March, and a loss of 5d. per gallon for the month of April. If anybody in this House who talks about increased production expects any farmer, knowing those definite costings, to be idiotic enough to produce milk under those conditions he will soon find out that he is expecting too much.

Added to all that is our share of the £500,000 that was previously paid by the State, as far as national health insurance is concerned, and we are going to have extra costs on petrol and kerosene. We should remember that 95 per cent. of the manures and everything else that reaches the farmer at the present day, and 95 per cent. of what leaves the farmer, is drawn by petrol. Those people can pass the burden on but we here representing the agricultural community, have no one to pass it on to. Our backs are to the wall. If anybody thinks that we are going to get increased production under these conditions he must, in the words of the Minister for Agriculture when he was a small boy here, be "daft". I ask what is all this for? It is in order that the new team may get gin and wine in the Fianna Fáil luxury hotels. I hope that they will enjoy it and I hope that, should they be short of a gallon of milk around Christmas they will, when they go to the door of the farmer with a jug, be able to say: "Well, we will have cheaper wine——"

Comment on this

And more bacon.

Comment on this

And more bacon, I understand, as a result of a question put by Deputy Cogan to-day and answered by the "daft" Minister. We are faced with that state of affairs and, as a result, I am wondering where the increased production is going to come from. In order to obtain increased production there must be an incentive. What we want to know is where the incentive is going to be found—and that after all is the kernel of the situation.

Comment on this

What do you suggest?

Comment on this

It is your own foundation stone.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will proceed without minding the chorus.

Comment on this

Last night I had not the advantage of hearing the tale-end of the Minister's speech, in which he told us that wages had now gone high enough and that it had now become a question of drawing back. As far as certain sections of the community are concerned, the wages have gone high enough. However, my men and my sons are working for a wage of less than 60/- a week but, as a result of the prices allowed by the present Government, I am not able to pay them even that wage.

Comment on this

That is only the minimum price.

Comment on this

You are worse than he is. God help the representative of the farmers who does not understand what he is talking about.

Comment on this

The labourers understood the statement about £2 5s. 0d. per week.

Comment on this

The labourers and the farmers will be asking the Parliamentary Secretary and the rest of his Party how long they are going to stand for the farmer getting less than the cost of production. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will be able to answer.

Comment on this

What about the 62/6 a barrel for wheat?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What about the Deputy being allowed to speak without interruption?

Comment on this

I am glad the Parliamentary Secretary reminded me of that. The 62/6 per barrel for wheat was fixed last November. Since then the farmer has had an increase of 5/a week in his agricultural labourers' wages; an increase of 4/- in the £ on his rates and, in addition to that, the little loads that have been thrown on to him by the Minister for Social Welfare, which will mean a couple of pence in the £ more. Of course that does not matter. My complaint is that the price still stands at 62/6. We have nobody to pass these burdens on to. It is not to-day or yesterday that I have placed the position before the House. I told those boys over there that I would give them the same crack of the whip that I gave my own, and I am doing it.

Comment on this

But you would not vote against them.

Comment on this

You are too thick to vote against anything. If you were cut in two halves there would be nothing but sawdust found. We have to consider here the statement by the Minister which practically means a standstill Order. If I have a man who is too lazy to work and he walks away from me he can go to Cork City and join a trade union and get one-and-a-half times as much wages as he got from me. On Saturday after 2 o'clock he can come and sit on my ditch and look at my idiots producing and have a laugh at them. He can say: "You poor devils can stop there. I have got a nicer job and I will get cheap milk at your expense." I claim to speak for the producers of wealth in this country, for the ordinary worker and the ordinary working farmer, and I do not want to see agricultural workers' wages prevented from increasing until they have from £4 to £4 7s. 0d. per week. The agricultural worker earns his wages harder than some of the people over there. He earns his wages far harder than Deputy Cowan, who complained to-day that he had nothing to do, that he was earning his money too softly. If there are Deputies who do no work for their money, I suggest that they should shove it in. I am working night and day and I cannot get any peace or ease. Whilst you have a condition of affairs that the people who produce the wealth in this country, namely, the farmer, the farmer's son and the agricultural labourer are in the position that their earnings are only 40 per cent. of the wages of a labourer in any other capacity in this country, so long will you have no production in this country. So long as you have a Minister kept there by the votes of those who claim to be direct representatives of agriculture in this House, so long as they condone what that Minister does in fixing a price for agricultural produce which does not pay the cost of production, then you will have no production.

I want to hear from the Clann na Talmhan Deputies, who claim to be representatives of the agricultural community, their attitude in regard to what the farmer has to produce, the price he should be paid for it, and whether they are going to get for him at least the cost of production, plus a profit. That conglomeration over there hold what I used to be happy to call long ago the balance of power. I want to know what those people who claim to be the direct representatives of the agricultural community are going to do with that balance of power in order to see that the farmer gets his rightful place in this country and the agricultural labourer a decent wage. They are the people who are responsible.

There are other aspects of this Budget which I shall have other opportunities of dealing with. I certainly think it is a wrong thing to throw any further burdens on those who are the producers of food. The burdens which are being thrown on them are unfair and unjust. They have not any loophole through which they can pass these burdens on. Some four months ago the price of beet for the coming year was fixed and contracts were entered into between the sugar company and something like 70,000 farmers. After the contracts were entered into last year we had a 20 per cent. increase in our transport costs which turned a very slight profit into a dead loss. This year, after these contracts were signed, we are faced with another 12½ per cent. increase and on top of that we have now an increase of 5d. a gallon on petrol to give transport monopolies good ground for demanding a further increase from us. I want to know from those people over there whether they consider that justice or not. Unfortunately for those who are advocating the six-day week, a 50-hour week and all the rest, the old cow does not follow that programme at all. The old cow walks in on a Sunday morning as well as on a Saturday morning, and someone must be there to milk her. I wonder if we could induce the Minister for Agriculture, who is so smart about other things, to produce a six-day cow. If he could do that he would get another medal. Since he cannot do that, does he consider it just, seeing that the farmer and the farm labourer have to milk the cows on Sunday as well as on Monday and deliver it on Sunday as well as on Monday, to fix the price of milk at 4d. a gallon under the cost of production?

I am not looking for anything extraordinary, but when I saw the Minister for Agriculture coming out with a new hat with the "new look" I said: "Blessed are those who expect nothing". I did expect, however, that he would have had common sense enough—year after year he used to comment here on the enormous profits that industrialists were getting and used to weep salt tears when he sat over here about the position of the down-trodden farmer—when he went into his office and saw there the costs of production ascertained from actual working by University College, Cork, and particularly when he had no costings to put against them, that at least he would have said: "Well, I will give those farmers at least the costs of production plus some profit." The farmer might have expected that. He has to be out at 5 o'clock in the morning in the months of October, November, December, January and February producing milk so that the "gent" who is drawing three times his salary and four times his wages might remain in bed and when it suited him call out: "Mary, bring me up a hot cup of tea as soon as the milk-man comes." With that aspect of affairs before us what hope can we have in this country of increased production? Here you are denying justice and fair play to the farmer. Do you think that there is any farmer lunatic enough to produce milk during the winter months at 4d. per gallon less than the cost of production? The farmers will not do it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be confining himself to agriculture.

Comment on this

If the farmer went out of production in the morning that would finish every Party and member of this House. Therefore, I think I am right in confining myself to agriculture and how this Budget is going to affect it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's references to the Budget are very incidental and rare. He refers to production and then goes on to make a speech on agriculture. This Budget deals with taxation, expenditure and general policy.

Comment on this

We are spending a very large amount of money every year on instructresses and in organising special classes for the training of girls in butter making. Now we come along and remove the subsidy on farmer's butter and leave it on creamery butter. Is it not a lunatic thing to train a group of girls to manufacture butter when you completely kill that production by removing the subsidy from it and leave it on the creamery butter? I have devoted my whole time to-night to agriculture.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I quite agree.

Comment on this

And to the manner in which this Budget will affect the agricultural community, the members of which are the only producers of wealth in this country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have heard the Deputy repeat that six or seven times.

Comment on this

Having done that, my job is finished, and now the industrialists can talk.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

This year's Budget will produce the usual amount of criticism. There will be the viewpoint of those who are responsible for it, while criticism will be offered by the Opposition Party. In reality, the Budget is nothing revolutionary. The Government are to be complimented as far as some points in it are concerned, but in reality they have produced nothing that is very extraordinary. What I see arising mainly from this Budget is that I think the Government to a degree exaggerated their power to control finance to the extent of making known to the public very big changes in regard to expenditure which they said it was in their power to reduce.

Meeting with the realities of the situation, they find that a reduction in the expenditure of the State is not so easily arranged. Accordingly we are confronted with a Budget running into a very substantial sum of money. It is true that the Government have readjusted expenditure and directed it towards the relief of certain sections of the community. I think the moral of all this is that members of the Government Party, the Opposition Party and all other Parties who have accustomed themselves to going before the electorate whenever the occasion demands and saying to the people: "I am going to reduce the cost of living and also increase social services, improve the condition of the workers and the poorer sections of the community," should realise that these powers are not vouchsafed to any Party. We cannot control finance magically. We cannot produce from the hat, as a conjurer would, the various essential things that he may require in the course of the exercise of his profession.

Revenue is the product of hard work and comes from the workers, and from that source alone. If we confine ourselves in a rigid way to recognising that fact, if we are honest with the public, educate the people and tell them the actual position—that Governments do not control money ad lib, that they cannot provide increased social services simply by lifting the hat —if we tell the public that the resources from which improved social services and greater prosperity for our people can be provided are hard work and increased production, then we shall create a healthier public opinion. Let us tell the people honestly that we have a certain revenue to draw from, that while out of that revenue we may be able to relieve pressure in one direction, we shall have to transfer it to another and that only by increased production can there be a general levelling up in the standard of living. Let us prepare a graph and by propaganda endeavour to educate the people in a proper manner and not treat them as so many nincompoops.

If some of the propaganda carried on at election periods were utilised at other times to establish a sound public opinion on these matters, the people would be saved a good deal of disillusionment. Let us inform them of the facts consistently and all the time. Let us teach our people through the schools and in every other possible way that the extent of our resources comprises the limit to which prosperity and social services can be maintained. If we do that, I think we shall proceed towards a more realistic, a more honest and a more practical line of advancement than we can possibly attain by present methods.

I do not blame the Government. The members of the various Parties who have combined to form the Government, made promises during the last election that were no more inconsistent than those made by other Parties. I do not blame them, as I say, but we have had a wrong outlook on these matters. We have taken a wrong step and I am afraid some of the speeches on the Budget to which we have listened are indicative of very little change in that respect in future. The things that are good in this Budget are minimised by Opposition Deputies and the things that imply a wrong outlook are represented as if they were for the general good. I think this game of Party politics is going to be the ruin of democracy. I think an approach to the people by telling them plainly what is possible from a commonsense point of view is the safest way to guarantee the continued existence of democracy.

I will say this much in favour of the Budget. As I have already stated, it indicates no radical change whatever. The Government are dealing with practically the same amount of money as that with which the previous Government had to deal. They are expending the same amount and collecting the same amount from the taxpayer but they are adjusting their expenditure very much in favour of a section of the community which I think all Parties will agree are deserving of every consideration—the old age pensioners and the widows and orphans. To the extent that they have made economies here and there, or even to the extent to which they found it necessary to increase taxation to provide increased allowances in that respect—I hope it was not due to political motives or for the sake of gaining some political advantage and I do not suggest it was —they are Christian and humanitarian in their outlook.

However, the increase in the standard of income below which pensions may be granted is so long overdue that one even does not think of thanking the present Government for doing what they have done. Any person in receipt of an income exceeding £39 was deemed to be ineligible for an old age pension. That standard was fixed away back as far as 1909. To-day a comparable income would be well over £100. There was never a greater injustice perpetrated in the name of Christian democracy than to apply a limit fixed in 1908 or 1909 to presentday circumstances or, for that matter, to the circumstances of any time within the last 25 or 30 years. The ordinary workers got their increases during that time. They had the means by which they could command and demand such increases. Governments which claimed to be Christian and democratic allowed that unreasonable and unjustifiable condition to prevail. Because old people were not in a position to demand a review of the old-time standards they were refused pensions. I think if there is a case to be made against any Party or any Government, it would be in relation to the retention of these ancient standards to the detriment of old age pensioners. The same applies to widows' and orphans' pensions but, of course, they were introduced at a much later period. They were brought in by the previous Government. All credit to them for that; but, again, nobody will say one harsh word against any Government that will introduce better conditions so as to bring the amounts payable in these very deserving cases up to modern requirements.

One suggestion which I would make to the responsible Minister is that there is one section in the community for whom no Party has made provision. I refer to invalids, those who have been invalided either from birth or who have been invalided through accident and who are left derelict. No provision is made for them unless they apply for home help and even that, as we know, is often given very grudgingly and only as the last resort is it applied for. I would recommend the Minister responsible, who seems to be very energetic in dealing with health conditions—he deserves the admiration of every person in the State for his attempt to deal in a serious way with the ravages of disease—that he would consider making some provision for that section of our community analogous to the provision made for old age pensioners and widows and orphans. The leaving out of one section is sufficient justification for accusing those responsible of failure to discharge their duty as they should in respect of social services where such services are required.

With regard to the general scheme of the Budget, while there is undoubtedly an increase in the price of petrol, I, as a user of petrol, do not propose to complain about it. It is unfortunate that we have to increase the cost of living on any section of the community, but I am sure that those who will pay this additional price—and I suppose the entire community will, directly or indirectly, contribute—will feel that it is for a justifiable purpose and will not seriously object. Many of us will merely have to use less petrol.

I feel strongly about the neglect of other matters for which no provision is made in the Budget and I refer particularly to the Government arrangements in respect of those who were employed on turf production last year. It is true that the Government have provided grants for the re-employment of the same people, but the scheme is deficient in that no provision is made for those men who normally would have applied this year and would have been employed on turf production, either on Bord na Móna or county council schemes. Neither is any provision made for the employment of those who were engaged in private turf production. To that extent, the scheme is very deficient.

The policy of the previous Government—and obviously the tendency of this Government is on similar lines— was mass employment of men, the gathering of these men into big units and the gathering of small business into big sections. It was felt then that you were doing well. That is as wrong as can be. Why make provision for those disemployed this year, because turf production is not economic, and leave out of consideration the small producer, the small farmer who, with the assistance of his children, before they went to school or having come from school, or during holidays, was able to produce turf in quantities equal to those produced by the best able-bodied man employed on Bord na Móna or county council schemes?

Look at the value of their production. Look at the additional money their efforts brought into the homes in the poorest part of the country. These people cannot be employed under any of these schemes, but their labours brought money and goods into these poor homes. Do not think you have met the situation merely because you have provided a pound for pound expenditure on alternative schemes, on better and more important schemes. Do not assume that you have discharged your duty when you have left out the most deserving section, the people who were healthily employed and who improved conditions in their homes by private turf production. What provision is made in this Budget for that section? None. These, like the old age pensioners who have been penalised for years, are the silent section. They cannot raise any great storm, and so they are neglected.

The same applies to coal production. About 800 people were employed in coal production in the Arigna area for the past 10 years. To-day much less than half that number are employed, and, from the way things look now, probably half that number again will be disemployed in the next few months. These men, the turf producers and the coal mine workers, kept the wheels of industry going here for the past eight years. It was not the most perfect job, I suppose, or the most perfect product, but it kept industry going. Will some member of either Government—this Government or the Government which has gone out of office and which is partly responsible—tell me why is not a portion of the coal which kept our industries and our railways going here for the past seven or eight years, although not as well as was the case when the best English, Welsh and Scottish coals were imported here in pre-war days, still used in our transport and industries generally?

We have industries which have been subsidised by the public and subsidised, in their initial stages, at a very high cost. We found it good business to subsidise these industries and to give employment. Our coal owners and workers never asked for a subsidy and they do not ask for a subsidy now. They can produce the analysis given them by the City of Dublin analyst of the coal they produce, and can show the Minister responsible that the quality of the coal they produce is equal to that of imported coal, if it is not better, and they will also tell him that they can produce and sell it cheaper than the imported coal. Other industries have been subsidised at the expense of these poor mine workers who have had to pay higher prices for the things they bought. Why, in the name of justice, will these men not be allowed to provide a quota for essential industries which are protected here, whether transport or otherwise, if they can show that they can sell a better article at a cheaper price?

It is surely not beyond the bounds of the Government's powers to provide that a certain quantity of Irish coal, equal in quality and in price to imported coal, if it is not better, shall be used by industries here which are subsidised by the State and contributed to by the very workers whose existence depends on the continuation of work in the Arigna area.

I listened to Deputy O'Higgins. I admired the speech he made. He referrd to coal imports and he said that the falling off in our production of coal and turf here was due to Deputy Lemass. That may be true. I am not exonerating Deputy Lemass at all. I know the imports of coal that came into this country before the present Government took office. That import adversely affected the production of coal in Leitrim, Roscommon and Sligo. Deputy O'Higgins said that the onus for that rested on Deputy Lemass. A new Government is in office now. Does that Government intend to allow the present situation to continue?

Successive Governments have taken office in this country and each successive Government has treated the old age pensioners and the less better off members of the community in the same ungenerous fashion. The people living in the congested areas have been completely forgotten. Not a single thing has been done for them by successive national Governments to remedy the outrageous conditions under which they live. No national Government should permit the present disgrace to continue. These people are compelled to live in the barren wastes of Connaught, Kerry and Donegal. They were given the choice of hell or Connaught. Connaught being their choice, they are still living there under the most appalling conditions of poverty and hardship. They are the victims of invasion. No Government has made any effort to remedy their position. At this juncture I lay no blame upon the present Government. It is a new Government and I sincerely hope that it will do something for these forgotten victims of the past. But I see no provision in the Budget for them.

Is it the Minister's intention to resume migration from the west? When does he hope to put his plans into operation? Will he undertake to examine into the economic conditions of life in these areas and see how far migration can wipe out this national outrage? Will he do something in order to make conditions there in some degree humane? Doles and grants have been given in the past. The people in these districts are a proud people. They are the descendants of those who persistently and consistently refused to bow tho knee to the invader and who refused to accept the authority of a conqueror. The people there to-day are as proud as their ancestors were. They do not want doles. They only ask for the means of earning a decent livelihood. If something is not done now they will solve their problem in their own proud way by turning their backs upon their homeland and no national Government will ever again be afforded the opportunity of helping them to take their place as citizens in their own country. Were it not for the restrictions arbitrarily imposed by the Government in the last eight years the numbers with which we have to deal to-day would be very few indeed. If we lose these people we shall have lost an asset which this nation can never replace. We must do something for them if only for the sake of our own national honour. If this Government tackles the problem seriously the country will benefit. The problem is not a new one. It was in existence many years ago. Mr. Balfour, the then Prime Minister of a British Government, established a board to examine into the conditions in these areas and that board was given £40,000 per annum to spend—a considerable sum in those days. An Irish Government annexed that sum.

While I await with a certain anxiety the Government's plan for dealing with these essential and fundamental needs, I approve of the Budget. The Government has shown some indication that it is prepared to do something tangible in relation to social services and to give some redress to those less fortunate members of our community. Might I ask the Government to remember, too, some of our other pensioners such as ex-teachers? Some of them find it exceedingly difficult to live on the small pittances of which they are now in receipt. It is only just and equitable that something should be done for them. If at any time in the future the Government comes before the House asking for increases for these people they will I am sure receive the support of the entire House. Nobody can refuse help to the aged and the defenceless.

Comment on this

It was refreshing to hear the last speaker. I sat here listening to speakers on the Opposition Benches and I did not hear one constructive suggestion coming from that quarter. The whole desire appeared to be to discredit those who form this interParty Government. I may say right away that if it was a National Labour Government that was in power, and if this was a Labour Budget, we would probably deal with the matter in our own way. I will say to Deputy Lemass that I do not look upon the people who brought in this Budget as purely Fine Gael.

Comment on this

It is your Budget.

Comment on this

I am accepting that. It is not the Budget of any particular Party. I will make one suggestion to the Minister. He talked about those who are making excess profits, even after examination, and I say he should not have hesitated to take those excess profits from the people who made them. I think it was criminal for any group to take excess profits during the emergency period from the thousands of our people who were suffering dire privations. Deputies on the opposite benches, when they were in power in 1946 and 1947, gave a present to those people who made the excess profits and that present amounted to £3,600,000. I am quoting the words of the Minister for Finance at the time. Those who were responsible for making a present of that kind to people who exploited the majority in this country would have been better advised to have dealt with the unemployed, the old age pensioners and the widows and orphans.

I heard Deputy Kissane ask: "Where does Labour stand now?" That, apparently, was because of some remarks made by the Minister for Finance. Deputy Kissane was in this House last October when the then Taoiseach stated that if the workers were to look for more increases he would bring in legislation. I did not hear Deputy Kissane or Deputy Corry or any other Deputy over there saying he would object to that procedure. Since last October the majority of the workers have received from 11/- to 15/- of an increase. While there may be some justification for giving some kind of warning of the danger of increased wages in the absence of increased production, there was very little cause for it on that occasion. So far as Labour is concerned, we know where we stand.

As regards taxation, we have not much information as to the taxable capacity of this country. So far as I can ascertain, our national income and our production did not increase between 1926 and 1938. I did not hear much from Deputy Corry or other members of the Fianna Fáil Party on the subject of the decline in production during those years.

We had many promises during the election. Like Deputy Maguire, during the election campaign I made no promise about things that were not possible. I challenge Deputies who were with me in the campaign to contradict that. I told the people that we could never maintain or increase the standard of living until we increased production. What I advocated then—and I advocate it now—is that we want a fair share of the national income. Our cake can only be a certain size, and by our cake I mean our national income. Those in the country who are rendering service to it should get an equal share of that cake.

Comment on this

Do you now say they have got it?

Comment on this

The last Government allowed certain people to exploit the majority in this country. They allowed certain people to draw from the majority during the war years £40,000,000 in excess profits. Then in 1946 and 1947 they made those people a present of over £3,600,000. One of the things our present Minister should do is plump down on all excess profits and take the whole lot off them.

The Minister should have no fear in expending money in order to develop agriculture. I am afraid most of us are too anxious to balance the Budget. We would like to hear more about the country's taxable capacity and what it is capable of producing. It is a terrible thing that for some years we have had up to 70,000 of our people compelled to sign at the labour exchanges, compelled to remain unemployed and not given an opportunity of producing goods.

Like Deputy Maguire, I do not see anything revolutionary in this Budget. If we are to proceed on right lines I think the Minister will have to do much more revolutionary things than he has indicated in the Budget. He can rest assured that, so far as Labour is concerned, we are with him in seeing that justice will be done to the people who matter in this country—those who produce goods for the nation.

Comment on this

Higher taxes on the workers.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

This Budget can, perhaps, best be approached from the point of view of reducing taxation and from the point of view of reducing the cost of living because, apparently, it was from that standpoint that the Budget problem for this year was approached by the Minister. It is, therefore, relevant to ask how far, in fact, there has been a reduction in taxation. A reduction in taxation affecting the community as a whole is what really should concern us rather than the question of benefits to particular sections in the matter of taxation. When one examines it in that way what does one find? One finds that the Minister is unable to do better than his predecessor in the matter of income-tax; that he adopts the proposal to increase income-tax——

Comment on this

What did you say I did?

Comment on this